This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Ericsson This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access Services Ericsson Access Services for Ericsson Access Services for the Ericsson Access Services for the Office Ericsson Access Services for the Office of Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, humbly Almighty God, humbly acknowledging Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need for humbly acknowledging our need for your humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all things, your guidance in all things, and your guidance in all things, and laying your guidance in all things, and laying aside your guidance in all things, and laying aside all your guidance in all things, and laying aside all private and laying aside all private and and laying aside all private and personal and laying aside all private and personal interests, and personal interests, we and personal interests, we ask and personal interests, we ask that and personal interests, we ask that you and personal interests, we ask that you grant we ask that you grant that we ask that you grant that we we ask that you grant that we may we ask that you grant that we may conduct we ask that you grant that we may conduct the we ask that you grant that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House that we may conduct the affairs of this House and that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our country of this House and of our country to of this House and of our country to the of this House and of our country to the glory of this House and of our country to the glory of of this House and of our country to the glory of your of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy name, to the glory of your holy name, the to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true religion the maintenance of true religion and the maintenance of true religion and justice, and justice, the and justice, the honour and justice, the honour of and justice, the honour of the and justice, the honour of the Queen, the honour of the Queen, and the honour of the Queen, and the the honour of the Queen, and the public the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, peace, and the public welfare, peace, and and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New Zealand, and tranquillity of New Zealand, through and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our Lord. through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen. A A petition A petition has A petition has been A petition has been delivered A petition has been delivered to A petition has been delivered to the A petition has been delivered to the clefshg A petition has been delivered to the clefshg for A petition has been delivered to the clefshg for presentation. A petition has been delivered to the clefshg for presentation. -- A petition has been delivered to the clefshg for presentation. -- Clerk clefshg for presentation. -- Clerk for clefshg for presentation. -- Clerk for presentation. Petition Petition of Petition of David Petition of David Shen Petition of David Shen on Petition of David Shen on behalf Petition of David Shen on behalf of Petition of David Shen on behalf of the Petition of David Shen on behalf of the Asian Petition of David Shen on behalf of the Asian Pacific Petition of David Shen on behalf of the Asian Pacific Charity Petition of David Shen on behalf of the Asian Pacific Charity Trust the Asian Pacific Charity Trust requesting the Asian Pacific Charity Trust requesting that the Asian Pacific Charity Trust requesting that the the Asian Pacific Charity Trust requesting that the House the Asian Pacific Charity Trust requesting that the House of requesting that the House of Representatives requesting that the House of Representatives enact requesting that the House of Representatives enact legislation requesting that the House of Representatives enact legislation to Representatives enact legislation to require Representatives enact legislation to require councils Representatives enact legislation to require councils to Representatives enact legislation to require councils to stop Representatives enact legislation to require councils to stop using Representatives enact legislation to require councils to stop using crumb require councils to stop using crumb rubber. That That petition That petition stands That petition stands referred That petition stands referred to That petition stands referred to a That petition stands referred to a select That petition stands referred to a select committee That petition stands referred to a select committee allocated That petition stands referred to a select committee allocated by That petition stands referred to a select committee allocated by the select committee allocated by the Clerk. select committee allocated by the Clerk. Ministers select committee allocated by the Clerk. Ministers have select committee allocated by the Clerk. Ministers have delivered Clerk. Ministers have delivered papers. Annual Annual reports Annual reports 2016: Annual reports 2016: Government Annual reports 2016: Government Communications Annual reports 2016: Government Communications Security Annual reports 2016: Government Communications Security Bureau, Communications Security Bureau, New Communications Security Bureau, New Zealand Communications Security Bureau, New Zealand Security Communications Security Bureau, New Zealand Security and New Zealand Security and Intelligence New Zealand Security and Intelligence Service. The The Capital The Capital & The Capital & Coast The Capital & Coast DHB, The Capital & Coast DHB, Marlborough The Capital & Coast DHB, Marlborough DHB. Statement Statement of Statement of intent: Statement of intent: Capital Statement of intent: Capital & Statement of intent: Capital & Coast Statement of intent: Capital & Coast District Statement of intent: Capital & Coast District Health Capital & Coast District Health Agreement Agreement between Agreement between the Agreement between the Government Agreement between the Government of Agreement between the Government of New between the Government of New Zealand between the Government of New Zealand and between the Government of New Zealand and the between the Government of New Zealand and the Government between the Government of New Zealand and the Government of between the Government of New Zealand and the Government of the Zealand and the Government of the Republic Zealand and the Government of the Republic of Zealand and the Government of the Republic of San Zealand and the Government of the Republic of San Marino Zealand and the Government of the Republic of San Marino on Zealand and the Government of the Republic of San Marino on the Republic of San Marino on the exchange Republic of San Marino on the exchange of Republic of San Marino on the exchange of Information Republic of San Marino on the exchange of Information with Republic of San Marino on the exchange of Information with Respect exchange of Information with Respect to exchange of Information with Respect to Taxes, exchange of Information with Respect to Taxes, together exchange of Information with Respect to Taxes, together with exchange of Information with Respect to Taxes, together with a exchange of Information with Respect to Taxes, together with a National to Taxes, together with a National Interest to Taxes, together with a National Interest Analysis. Interest Analysis. Third Interest Analysis. Third protocol Interest Analysis. Third protocol to Third protocol to the Third protocol to the Convention Third protocol to the Convention between Third protocol to the Convention between the the Convention between the Government the Convention between the Government of the Convention between the Government of the the Convention between the Government of the Republic the Convention between the Government of the Republic of the Convention between the Government of the Republic of India Government of the Republic of India and Government of the Republic of India and the Government of the Republic of India and the Government Government of the Republic of India and the Government of Government of the Republic of India and the Government of New Government of the Republic of India and the Government of New Zealand and the Government of New Zealand for and the Government of New Zealand for the and the Government of New Zealand for the Avoidance and the Government of New Zealand for the Avoidance of and the Government of New Zealand for the Avoidance of Double and the Government of New Zealand for the Avoidance of Double Taxation for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal for the Avoidance of Double Taxation and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes on and the Prevention of Fiscal Evasion with Respect to Taxes on Incomes, with Respect to Taxes on Incomes, together with Respect to Taxes on Incomes, together with with Respect to Taxes on Incomes, together with a with Respect to Taxes on Incomes, together with a National with Respect to Taxes on Incomes, together with a National Interest together with a National Interest Analysis. Those Those papers Those papers are Those papers are published Those papers are published under Those papers are published under the Those papers are published under the authority Those papers are published under the authority of Those papers are published under the authority of the Those papers are published under the authority of the House. Those papers are published under the authority of the House. A Those papers are published under the authority of the House. A select authority of the House. A select committee authority of the House. A select committee report authority of the House. A select committee report has authority of the House. A select committee report has been authority of the House. A select committee report has been delivered committee report has been delivered for committee report has been delivered for presentation. Report Report of Report of the Report of the Social Report of the Social Services Report of the Social Services Committee Report of the Social Services Committee on Report of the Social Services Committee on the Report of the Social Services Committee on the Inquiry Committee on the Inquiry into Committee on the Inquiry into the Committee on the Inquiry into the operation Committee on the Inquiry into the operation of Committee on the Inquiry into the operation of the Committee on the Inquiry into the operation of the Social into the operation of the Social Workers into the operation of the Social Workers Registration into the operation of the Social Workers Registration Act into the operation of the Social Workers Registration Act 2003. Workers Registration Act 2003. The Workers Registration Act 2003. The report Workers Registration Act 2003. The report on Workers Registration Act 2003. The report on the Workers Registration Act 2003. The report on the inquiry Workers Registration Act 2003. The report on the inquiry is Workers Registration Act 2003. The report on the inquiry is set The report on the inquiry is set down The report on the inquiry is set down for The report on the inquiry is set down for consideration. No No bills No bills have No bills have been No bills have been introduced. No bills have been introduced. The No bills have been introduced. The House No bills have been introduced. The House comes No bills have been introduced. The House comes to No bills have been introduced. The House comes to Oral No bills have been introduced. The House comes to Oral Questions. House comes to Oral Questions. Question House comes to Oral Questions. Question No. House comes to Oral Questions. Question No. 1. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: What My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has he Finance: What reports has he received Finance: What reports has he received confirming Finance: What reports has he received confirming New Finance: What reports has he received confirming New Zealand's received confirming New Zealand's sovereign received confirming New Zealand's sovereign credit received confirming New Zealand's sovereign credit rating? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! Late Late yesterday, Late yesterday, following Late yesterday, following the Late yesterday, following the PM's Late yesterday, following the PM's announcements, Late yesterday, following the PM's announcements, ratings Late yesterday, following the PM's announcements, ratings agencies announcements, ratings agencies Moody's announcements, ratings agencies Moody's confirmed announcements, ratings agencies Moody's confirmed New announcements, ratings agencies Moody's confirmed New Zealand's announcements, ratings agencies Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA stable Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA stable sovereign Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA stable sovereign credit Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA stable sovereign credit rating Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA stable sovereign credit rating and Moody's confirmed New Zealand's AAA stable sovereign credit rating and I stable sovereign credit rating and I think stable sovereign credit rating and I think the stable sovereign credit rating and I think the PM stable sovereign credit rating and I think the PM was stable sovereign credit rating and I think the PM was slightly think the PM was slightly disappointed think the PM was slightly disappointed about think the PM was slightly disappointed about that! think the PM was slightly disappointed about that! Moody's disappointed about that! Moody's said disappointed about that! Moody's said that disappointed about that! Moody's said that New disappointed about that! Moody's said that New Zealand's disappointed about that! Moody's said that New Zealand's strong said that New Zealand's strong institutions said that New Zealand's strong institutions support said that New Zealand's strong institutions support a said that New Zealand's strong institutions support a smooth institutions support a smooth transition institutions support a smooth transition and institutions support a smooth transition and policy institutions support a smooth transition and policy continuity. transition and policy continuity. That transition and policy continuity. That the transition and policy continuity. That the New transition and policy continuity. That the New Zealand transition and policy continuity. That the New Zealand Government transition and policy continuity. That the New Zealand Government has That the New Zealand Government has effectively That the New Zealand Government has effectively pursued That the New Zealand Government has effectively pursued a That the New Zealand Government has effectively pursued a policy That the New Zealand Government has effectively pursued a policy of effectively pursued a policy of fiscal effectively pursued a policy of fiscal consolidation effectively pursued a policy of fiscal consolidation and effectively pursued a policy of fiscal consolidation and federal fiscal consolidation and federal debt fiscal consolidation and federal debt is fiscal consolidation and federal debt is likely fiscal consolidation and federal debt is likely to fiscal consolidation and federal debt is likely to remain fiscal consolidation and federal debt is likely to remain low fiscal consolidation and federal debt is likely to remain low and debt is likely to remain low and that debt is likely to remain low and that GDP debt is likely to remain low and that GDP growth debt is likely to remain low and that GDP growth has debt is likely to remain low and that GDP growth has been debt is likely to remain low and that GDP growth has been strong debt is likely to remain low and that GDP growth has been strong and that GDP growth has been strong and broad-based. that GDP growth has been strong and broad-based. Order! that GDP growth has been strong and broad-based. Order! What that GDP growth has been strong and broad-based. Order! What reports that GDP growth has been strong and broad-based. Order! What reports has broad-based. Order! What reports has he broad-based. Order! What reports has he received broad-based. Order! What reports has he received on broad-based. Order! What reports has he received on the broad-based. Order! What reports has he received on the Government's he received on the Government's accounts he received on the Government's accounts showing he received on the Government's accounts showing tax he received on the Government's accounts showing tax revenues he received on the Government's accounts showing tax revenues higher accounts showing tax revenues higher than accounts showing tax revenues higher than forecast? accounts showing tax revenues higher than forecast? Well, accounts showing tax revenues higher than forecast? Well, earlier accounts showing tax revenues higher than forecast? Well, earlier today, than forecast? Well, earlier today, Government than forecast? Well, earlier today, Government released than forecast? Well, earlier today, Government released its than forecast? Well, earlier today, Government released its financial Government released its financial statements Government released its financial statements for Government released its financial statements for the Government released its financial statements for the four Government released its financial statements for the four months Government released its financial statements for the four months to statements for the four months to October, statements for the four months to October, which statements for the four months to October, which show statements for the four months to October, which show that statements for the four months to October, which show that the October, which show that the operating October, which show that the operating balance October, which show that the operating balance is October, which show that the operating balance is around October, which show that the operating balance is around 0.9 operating balance is around 0.9 billion operating balance is around 0.9 billion better operating balance is around 0.9 billion better than operating balance is around 0.9 billion better than forecast operating balance is around 0.9 billion better than forecast in billion better than forecast in budget billion better than forecast in budget 29. billion better than forecast in budget 29. Budget billion better than forecast in budget 29. Budget 2016 billion better than forecast in budget 29. Budget 2016 is billion better than forecast in budget 29. Budget 2016 is at billion better than forecast in budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a deficit. budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a deficit. Core budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a deficit. Core tax budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a deficit. Core tax revenue budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a deficit. Core tax revenue is budget 29. Budget 2016 is at a deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, largely deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, largely due deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, largely due to deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, largely due to higher deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, largely due to higher corporate deficit. Core tax revenue is higher, largely due to higher corporate tax largely due to higher corporate tax revenues largely due to higher corporate tax revenues and largely due to higher corporate tax revenues and GST. largely due to higher corporate tax revenues and GST. However, largely due to higher corporate tax revenues and GST. However, these revenues and GST. However, these numbers revenues and GST. However, these numbers do revenues and GST. However, these numbers do not revenues and GST. However, these numbers do not include revenues and GST. However, these numbers do not include the numbers do not include the anticipated numbers do not include the anticipated costs numbers do not include the anticipated costs of numbers do not include the anticipated costs of the numbers do not include the anticipated costs of the Kaikoura anticipated costs of the Kaikoura earthquake, anticipated costs of the Kaikoura earthquake, but anticipated costs of the Kaikoura earthquake, but indicate anticipated costs of the Kaikoura earthquake, but indicate that anticipated costs of the Kaikoura earthquake, but indicate that the earthquake, but indicate that the economy earthquake, but indicate that the economy is earthquake, but indicate that the economy is growing earthquake, but indicate that the economy is growing strongly earthquake, but indicate that the economy is growing strongly enough economy is growing strongly enough that economy is growing strongly enough that those economy is growing strongly enough that those costs economy is growing strongly enough that those costs can economy is growing strongly enough that those costs can be economy is growing strongly enough that those costs can be met economy is growing strongly enough that those costs can be met without that those costs can be met without a that those costs can be met without a significant that those costs can be met without a significant impact that those costs can be met without a significant impact on that those costs can be met without a significant impact on the a significant impact on the Government a significant impact on the Government books. a significant impact on the Government books. When a significant impact on the Government books. When might a significant impact on the Government books. When might the Government books. When might the people Government books. When might the people who Government books. When might the people who overpaid Government books. When might the people who overpaid that Government books. When might the people who overpaid that extra Government books. When might the people who overpaid that extra tax people who overpaid that extra tax get people who overpaid that extra tax get it people who overpaid that extra tax get it back? people who overpaid that extra tax get it back? Well, people who overpaid that extra tax get it back? Well, they people who overpaid that extra tax get it back? Well, they won't people who overpaid that extra tax get it back? Well, they won't be get it back? Well, they won't be overpaying get it back? Well, they won't be overpaying - get it back? Well, they won't be overpaying - they'll get it back? Well, they won't be overpaying - they'll just get it back? Well, they won't be overpaying - they'll just be get it back? Well, they won't be overpaying - they'll just be paying overpaying - they'll just be paying what overpaying - they'll just be paying what is overpaying - they'll just be paying what is legally overpaying - they'll just be paying what is legally due. overpaying - they'll just be paying what is legally due. Although, overpaying - they'll just be paying what is legally due. Although, as overpaying - they'll just be paying what is legally due. Although, as I what is legally due. Although, as I sometimes what is legally due. Although, as I sometimes point what is legally due. Although, as I sometimes point out, what is legally due. Although, as I sometimes point out, there's what is legally due. Although, as I sometimes point out, there's no sometimes point out, there's no legal sometimes point out, there's no legal maximum sometimes point out, there's no legal maximum to sometimes point out, there's no legal maximum to how sometimes point out, there's no legal maximum to how much sometimes point out, there's no legal maximum to how much tax sometimes point out, there's no legal maximum to how much tax you legal maximum to how much tax you can legal maximum to how much tax you can pay legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - you legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - you are legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - you are free legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - you are free to legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - you are free to pay legal maximum to how much tax you can pay - you are free to pay more can pay - you are free to pay more if can pay - you are free to pay more if you can pay - you are free to pay more if you want can pay - you are free to pay more if you want to can pay - you are free to pay more if you want to and can pay - you are free to pay more if you want to and it can pay - you are free to pay more if you want to and it will can pay - you are free to pay more if you want to and it will be if you want to and it will be gratefully if you want to and it will be gratefully accepted. if you want to and it will be gratefully accepted. But if you want to and it will be gratefully accepted. But what if you want to and it will be gratefully accepted. But what the gratefully accepted. But what the numbers gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do show gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do show is gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do show is the gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do show is the economy gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do show is the economy is gratefully accepted. But what the numbers do show is the economy is a numbers do show is the economy is a bit numbers do show is the economy is a bit stronger numbers do show is the economy is a bit stronger than numbers do show is the economy is a bit stronger than expected numbers do show is the economy is a bit stronger than expected back numbers do show is the economy is a bit stronger than expected back in bit stronger than expected back in Budget bit stronger than expected back in Budget 2016. bit stronger than expected back in Budget 2016. So bit stronger than expected back in Budget 2016. So when bit stronger than expected back in Budget 2016. So when will bit stronger than expected back in Budget 2016. So when will the Budget 2016. So when will the Government Budget 2016. So when will the Government change Budget 2016. So when will the Government change those Budget 2016. So when will the Government change those laws Budget 2016. So when will the Government change those laws so Budget 2016. So when will the Government change those laws so it Government change those laws so it does Government change those laws so it does not Government change those laws so it does not tax Government change those laws so it does not tax people Government change those laws so it does not tax people by Government change those laws so it does not tax people by more Government change those laws so it does not tax people by more than Government change those laws so it does not tax people by more than it does not tax people by more than it requires does not tax people by more than it requires for does not tax people by more than it requires for its does not tax people by more than it requires for its expenditure? does not tax people by more than it requires for its expenditure? Well, requires for its expenditure? Well, the requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing of requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing of - requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing of - the requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing of - the nature requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing of - the nature or requires for its expenditure? Well, the timing of - the nature or timing the timing of - the nature or timing of the timing of - the nature or timing of such the timing of - the nature or timing of such decisions the timing of - the nature or timing of such decisions are the timing of - the nature or timing of such decisions are part the timing of - the nature or timing of such decisions are part of the timing of - the nature or timing of such decisions are part of the of such decisions are part of the ongoing of such decisions are part of the ongoing discussion of such decisions are part of the ongoing discussion between of such decisions are part of the ongoing discussion between the ongoing discussion between the National ongoing discussion between the National Party ongoing discussion between the National Party and ongoing discussion between the National Party and the ongoing discussion between the National Party and the ACT ongoing discussion between the National Party and the ACT Party. ongoing discussion between the National Party and the ACT Party. We National Party and the ACT Party. We understand National Party and the ACT Party. We understand the National Party and the ACT Party. We understand the ACT National Party and the ACT Party. We understand the ACT view National Party and the ACT Party. We understand the ACT view very understand the ACT view very clearly. understand the ACT view very clearly. However, understand the ACT view very clearly. However, the understand the ACT view very clearly. However, the National understand the ACT view very clearly. However, the National Party clearly. However, the National Party believes clearly. However, the National Party believes that clearly. However, the National Party believes that there clearly. However, the National Party believes that there are clearly. However, the National Party believes that there are more believes that there are more opportunities believes that there are more opportunities to believes that there are more opportunities to carefully believes that there are more opportunities to carefully spend opportunities to carefully spend more opportunities to carefully spend more public opportunities to carefully spend more public money. opportunities to carefully spend more public money. Where opportunities to carefully spend more public money. Where we opportunities to carefully spend more public money. Where we are more public money. Where we are collecting more public money. Where we are collecting more more public money. Where we are collecting more than more public money. Where we are collecting more than we more public money. Where we are collecting more than we need, more public money. Where we are collecting more than we need, then collecting more than we need, then there collecting more than we need, then there is collecting more than we need, then there is the collecting more than we need, then there is the possibility collecting more than we need, then there is the possibility of collecting more than we need, then there is the possibility of reducing there is the possibility of reducing taxes. there is the possibility of reducing taxes. How there is the possibility of reducing taxes. How is there is the possibility of reducing taxes. How is debt there is the possibility of reducing taxes. How is debt tracking there is the possibility of reducing taxes. How is debt tracking against taxes. How is debt tracking against forecasts, taxes. How is debt tracking against forecasts, as taxes. How is debt tracking against forecasts, as reported taxes. How is debt tracking against forecasts, as reported in taxes. How is debt tracking against forecasts, as reported in today's forecasts, as reported in today's Crown forecasts, as reported in today's Crown financial forecasts, as reported in today's Crown financial statements? forecasts, as reported in today's Crown financial statements? Debt forecasts, as reported in today's Crown financial statements? Debt is Crown financial statements? Debt is tracking Crown financial statements? Debt is tracking a Crown financial statements? Debt is tracking a little Crown financial statements? Debt is tracking a little bit Crown financial statements? Debt is tracking a little bit better Crown financial statements? Debt is tracking a little bit better than tracking a little bit better than forecast. tracking a little bit better than forecast. We tracking a little bit better than forecast. We have tracking a little bit better than forecast. We have low tracking a little bit better than forecast. We have low Government forecast. We have low Government debt forecast. We have low Government debt by forecast. We have low Government debt by international forecast. We have low Government debt by international comparisons. debt by international comparisons. It debt by international comparisons. It peaked debt by international comparisons. It peaked at debt by international comparisons. It peaked at about debt by international comparisons. It peaked at about 25-26% debt by international comparisons. It peaked at about 25-26% of debt by international comparisons. It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP debt by international comparisons. It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP and It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP and is It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP and is gradually It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP and is gradually dropping It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP and is gradually dropping and It peaked at about 25-26% of GDP and is gradually dropping and these is gradually dropping and these accounts is gradually dropping and these accounts indicate is gradually dropping and these accounts indicate dropping is gradually dropping and these accounts indicate dropping a is gradually dropping and these accounts indicate dropping a bit accounts indicate dropping a bit faster accounts indicate dropping a bit faster than accounts indicate dropping a bit faster than we accounts indicate dropping a bit faster than we expected. accounts indicate dropping a bit faster than we expected. With faster than we expected. With respect faster than we expected. With respect to faster than we expected. With respect to the faster than we expected. With respect to the Finance faster than we expected. With respect to the Finance Minister's respect to the Finance Minister's discussions respect to the Finance Minister's discussions and respect to the Finance Minister's discussions and negotiations respect to the Finance Minister's discussions and negotiations with discussions and negotiations with the discussions and negotiations with the ACT discussions and negotiations with the ACT Party, discussions and negotiations with the ACT Party, on discussions and negotiations with the ACT Party, on what discussions and negotiations with the ACT Party, on what day, discussions and negotiations with the ACT Party, on what day, on discussions and negotiations with the ACT Party, on what day, on what the ACT Party, on what day, on what address, the ACT Party, on what day, on what address, and the ACT Party, on what day, on what address, and which the ACT Party, on what day, on what address, and which telephone the ACT Party, on what day, on what address, and which telephone booth, address, and which telephone booth, did address, and which telephone booth, did those address, and which telephone booth, did those negotiations address, and which telephone booth, did those negotiations take address, and which telephone booth, did those negotiations take place? did those negotiations take place? I'll did those negotiations take place? I'll leave did those negotiations take place? I'll leave it did those negotiations take place? I'll leave it for did those negotiations take place? I'll leave it for the did those negotiations take place? I'll leave it for the minister did those negotiations take place? I'll leave it for the minister if did those negotiations take place? I'll leave it for the minister if he I'll leave it for the minister if he wants I'll leave it for the minister if he wants to I'll leave it for the minister if he wants to answer I'll leave it for the minister if he wants to answer it. I'll leave it for the minister if he wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> That's wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> That's alright, wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> That's alright, I wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> That's alright, I know wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> That's alright, I know I've wants to answer it. <INTERRUPTION> That's alright, I know I've heard That's alright, I know I've heard for That's alright, I know I've heard for many That's alright, I know I've heard for many years That's alright, I know I've heard for many years the That's alright, I know I've heard for many years the member's for many years the member's reference for many years the member's reference to for many years the member's reference to the for many years the member's reference to the meetings for many years the member's reference to the meetings that for many years the member's reference to the meetings that he reference to the meetings that he does reference to the meetings that he does conduct reference to the meetings that he does conduct in reference to the meetings that he does conduct in telephone reference to the meetings that he does conduct in telephone booths, does conduct in telephone booths, but does conduct in telephone booths, but these does conduct in telephone booths, but these ones does conduct in telephone booths, but these ones are does conduct in telephone booths, but these ones are conducted does conduct in telephone booths, but these ones are conducted in does conduct in telephone booths, but these ones are conducted in the but these ones are conducted in the PM's but these ones are conducted in the PM's office, but these ones are conducted in the PM's office, because but these ones are conducted in the PM's office, because ACT but these ones are conducted in the PM's office, because ACT is but these ones are conducted in the PM's office, because ACT is part but these ones are conducted in the PM's office, because ACT is part of PM's office, because ACT is part of the PM's office, because ACT is part of the governing PM's office, because ACT is part of the governing coalition PM's office, because ACT is part of the governing coalition of PM's office, because ACT is part of the governing coalition of New the governing coalition of New Zealand, the governing coalition of New Zealand, and the governing coalition of New Zealand, and New the governing coalition of New Zealand, and New Zealand the governing coalition of New Zealand, and New Zealand First Zealand, and New Zealand First isn't. Zealand, and New Zealand First isn't. Order! Zealand, and New Zealand First isn't. Order! Is Zealand, and New Zealand First isn't. Order! Is the Zealand, and New Zealand First isn't. Order! Is the minister Zealand, and New Zealand First isn't. Order! Is the minister aware isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that history isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that history has isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that history has moved isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that history has moved on isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that history has moved on and isn't. Order! Is the minister aware that history has moved on and most that history has moved on and most people that history has moved on and most people actually that history has moved on and most people actually have that history has moved on and most people actually have cellphones that history has moved on and most people actually have cellphones now? people actually have cellphones now? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Mr <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker... <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker... Order!. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does lower Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does lower debt Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does lower debt and Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does lower debt and ongoing Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does lower debt and ongoing discipline Mr Speaker... Order!. Yes! How does lower debt and ongoing discipline in lower debt and ongoing discipline in spending lower debt and ongoing discipline in spending support lower debt and ongoing discipline in spending support resilience lower debt and ongoing discipline in spending support resilience in lower debt and ongoing discipline in spending support resilience in the spending support resilience in the New spending support resilience in the New Zealand spending support resilience in the New Zealand economy? spending support resilience in the New Zealand economy? Well, spending support resilience in the New Zealand economy? Well, the New Zealand economy? Well, the lessons New Zealand economy? Well, the lessons of New Zealand economy? Well, the lessons of the New Zealand economy? Well, the lessons of the Kaikoura New Zealand economy? Well, the lessons of the Kaikoura earthquake, lessons of the Kaikoura earthquake, I lessons of the Kaikoura earthquake, I think, lessons of the Kaikoura earthquake, I think, demonstrate lessons of the Kaikoura earthquake, I think, demonstrate exactly lessons of the Kaikoura earthquake, I think, demonstrate exactly why I think, demonstrate exactly why reducing I think, demonstrate exactly why reducing - I think, demonstrate exactly why reducing - reducing I think, demonstrate exactly why reducing - reducing Government I think, demonstrate exactly why reducing - reducing Government debt reducing - reducing Government debt maintains reducing - reducing Government debt maintains our reducing - reducing Government debt maintains our resilience. reducing - reducing Government debt maintains our resilience. This reducing - reducing Government debt maintains our resilience. This is reducing - reducing Government debt maintains our resilience. This is an maintains our resilience. This is an earthquake maintains our resilience. This is an earthquake that maintains our resilience. This is an earthquake that could maintains our resilience. This is an earthquake that could cost maintains our resilience. This is an earthquake that could cost 2-3 earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. If earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. If the earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. If the books earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. If the books were earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. If the books were in earthquake that could cost 2-3 billion. If the books were in worse billion. If the books were in worse shape, billion. If the books were in worse shape, that billion. If the books were in worse shape, that would billion. If the books were in worse shape, that would prevent billion. If the books were in worse shape, that would prevent us billion. If the books were in worse shape, that would prevent us making shape, that would prevent us making other shape, that would prevent us making other positive shape, that would prevent us making other positive choices shape, that would prevent us making other positive choices we shape, that would prevent us making other positive choices we could shape, that would prevent us making other positive choices we could make other positive choices we could make to other positive choices we could make to invest other positive choices we could make to invest in other positive choices we could make to invest in transport other positive choices we could make to invest in transport and to invest in transport and infrastructure, to invest in transport and infrastructure, but to invest in transport and infrastructure, but because to invest in transport and infrastructure, but because the infrastructure, but because the books infrastructure, but because the books are infrastructure, but because the books are in infrastructure, but because the books are in good infrastructure, but because the books are in good shape, infrastructure, but because the books are in good shape, we infrastructure, but because the books are in good shape, we should books are in good shape, we should be books are in good shape, we should be able books are in good shape, we should be able to books are in good shape, we should be able to absorb books are in good shape, we should be able to absorb the books are in good shape, we should be able to absorb the cost books are in good shape, we should be able to absorb the cost of books are in good shape, we should be able to absorb the cost of the be able to absorb the cost of the earthquake be able to absorb the cost of the earthquake and be able to absorb the cost of the earthquake and continue be able to absorb the cost of the earthquake and continue to be able to absorb the cost of the earthquake and continue to invest be able to absorb the cost of the earthquake and continue to invest in earthquake and continue to invest in infrastructure. earthquake and continue to invest in infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Question infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 2. infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 2. Tena infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 2. Tena koe, infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 2. Tena koe, Mr Question No. 2. Tena koe, Mr Speaker. Speaker. <SPEAKS Speaker. <SPEAKS TE Speaker. <SPEAKS TE REO Speaker. <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> "I "I honestly "I honestly wish "I honestly wish I "I honestly wish I could "I honestly wish I could have "I honestly wish I could have changed "I honestly wish I could have changed the "I honestly wish I could have changed the flag", changed the flag", <SPEAKS changed the flag", <SPEAKS TE changed the flag", <SPEAKS TE REO changed the flag", <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI>? Yes, Yes, but Yes, but the Yes, but the member Yes, but the member should Yes, but the member should know Yes, but the member should know that Yes, but the member should know that I Yes, but the member should know that I also Yes, but the member should know that I also stated Yes, but the member should know that I also stated that Yes, but the member should know that I also stated that my Yes, but the member should know that I also stated that my other Yes, but the member should know that I also stated that my other regrets I also stated that my other regrets were I also stated that my other regrets were that I also stated that my other regrets were that we I also stated that my other regrets were that we were I also stated that my other regrets were that we were unable I also stated that my other regrets were that we were unable to were that we were unable to establish were that we were unable to establish the were that we were unable to establish the Kermadec were that we were unable to establish the Kermadec Oceans establish the Kermadec Oceans sanctuary establish the Kermadec Oceans sanctuary and establish the Kermadec Oceans sanctuary and the establish the Kermadec Oceans sanctuary and the partnership establish the Kermadec Oceans sanctuary and the partnership had sanctuary and the partnership had not sanctuary and the partnership had not been sanctuary and the partnership had not been fully sanctuary and the partnership had not been fully ratified. sanctuary and the partnership had not been fully ratified. There sanctuary and the partnership had not been fully ratified. There are not been fully ratified. There are many not been fully ratified. There are many other not been fully ratified. There are many other things not been fully ratified. There are many other things I not been fully ratified. There are many other things I would not been fully ratified. There are many other things I would love not been fully ratified. There are many other things I would love to many other things I would love to continue many other things I would love to continue working many other things I would love to continue working on many other things I would love to continue working on but many other things I would love to continue working on but I many other things I would love to continue working on but I will many other things I would love to continue working on but I will be continue working on but I will be leading continue working on but I will be leading those continue working on but I will be leading those for continue working on but I will be leading those for the continue working on but I will be leading those for the future leading those for the future leadership leading those for the future leadership team. leading those for the future leadership team. Does leading those for the future leadership team. Does the leading those for the future leadership team. Does the PM leading those for the future leadership team. Does the PM regret leadership team. Does the PM regret leaving leadership team. Does the PM regret leaving 85,000 leadership team. Does the PM regret leaving 85,000 New leadership team. Does the PM regret leaving 85,000 New Zealand leadership team. Does the PM regret leaving 85,000 New Zealand children leaving 85,000 New Zealand children living leaving 85,000 New Zealand children living in leaving 85,000 New Zealand children living in severe leaving 85,000 New Zealand children living in severe hardship? leaving 85,000 New Zealand children living in severe hardship? I'm leaving 85,000 New Zealand children living in severe hardship? I'm very living in severe hardship? I'm very proud living in severe hardship? I'm very proud of living in severe hardship? I'm very proud of the living in severe hardship? I'm very proud of the record living in severe hardship? I'm very proud of the record that living in severe hardship? I'm very proud of the record that this proud of the record that this Government proud of the record that this Government has proud of the record that this Government has established proud of the record that this Government has established and Government has established and maintained Government has established and maintained for Government has established and maintained for the Government has established and maintained for the most Government has established and maintained for the most vulnerable maintained for the most vulnerable young maintained for the most vulnerable young New maintained for the most vulnerable young New Zealanders maintained for the most vulnerable young New Zealanders and maintained for the most vulnerable young New Zealanders and that maintained for the most vulnerable young New Zealanders and that has young New Zealanders and that has included young New Zealanders and that has included the young New Zealanders and that has included the installation young New Zealanders and that has included the installation of young New Zealanders and that has included the installation of over included the installation of over 300,000 included the installation of over 300,000 homes included the installation of over 300,000 homes - included the installation of over 300,000 homes - the included the installation of over 300,000 homes - the first included the installation of over 300,000 homes - the first government 300,000 homes - the first government in 300,000 homes - the first government in 43 300,000 homes - the first government in 43 years 300,000 homes - the first government in 43 years to 300,000 homes - the first government in 43 years to raise 300,000 homes - the first government in 43 years to raise benefits. 300,000 homes - the first government in 43 years to raise benefits. Free in 43 years to raise benefits. Free doctors' in 43 years to raise benefits. Free doctors' visits in 43 years to raise benefits. Free doctors' visits for in 43 years to raise benefits. Free doctors' visits for children in 43 years to raise benefits. Free doctors' visits for children under doctors' visits for children under 13, doctors' visits for children under 13, greater doctors' visits for children under 13, greater participation doctors' visits for children under 13, greater participation rates doctors' visits for children under 13, greater participation rates in 13, greater participation rates in early 13, greater participation rates in early education, 13, greater participation rates in early education, and 13, greater participation rates in early education, and the 13, greater participation rates in early education, and the like. 13, greater participation rates in early education, and the like. I early education, and the like. I think early education, and the like. I think all early education, and the like. I think all governments early education, and the like. I think all governments have early education, and the like. I think all governments have work early education, and the like. I think all governments have work to think all governments have work to do think all governments have work to do for think all governments have work to do for the think all governments have work to do for the most think all governments have work to do for the most vulnerable think all governments have work to do for the most vulnerable in think all governments have work to do for the most vulnerable in their do for the most vulnerable in their society, do for the most vulnerable in their society, but do for the most vulnerable in their society, but this do for the most vulnerable in their society, but this Government do for the most vulnerable in their society, but this Government can society, but this Government can hold society, but this Government can hold its society, but this Government can hold its head society, but this Government can hold its head up society, but this Government can hold its head up high society, but this Government can hold its head up high that society, but this Government can hold its head up high that it society, but this Government can hold its head up high that it has hold its head up high that it has worked hold its head up high that it has worked in hold its head up high that it has worked in the hold its head up high that it has worked in the best hold its head up high that it has worked in the best interests hold its head up high that it has worked in the best interests of worked in the best interests of those worked in the best interests of those young worked in the best interests of those young New worked in the best interests of those young New Zealanders worked in the best interests of those young New Zealanders and worked in the best interests of those young New Zealanders and I those young New Zealanders and I think those young New Zealanders and I think the those young New Zealanders and I think the work those young New Zealanders and I think the work that those young New Zealanders and I think the work that will those young New Zealanders and I think the work that will continue those young New Zealanders and I think the work that will continue in think the work that will continue in the think the work that will continue in the new think the work that will continue in the new ministry think the work that will continue in the new ministry for think the work that will continue in the new ministry for vulnerable the new ministry for vulnerable children the new ministry for vulnerable children will the new ministry for vulnerable children will be the new ministry for vulnerable children will be an the new ministry for vulnerable children will be an extremely children will be an extremely important children will be an extremely important part children will be an extremely important part of children will be an extremely important part of this children will be an extremely important part of this Government's important part of this Government's future important part of this Government's future agenda. important part of this Government's future agenda. So important part of this Government's future agenda. So when important part of this Government's future agenda. So when he important part of this Government's future agenda. So when he said important part of this Government's future agenda. So when he said this future agenda. So when he said this morning future agenda. So when he said this morning that future agenda. So when he said this morning that he future agenda. So when he said this morning that he would future agenda. So when he said this morning that he would have future agenda. So when he said this morning that he would have liked future agenda. So when he said this morning that he would have liked to morning that he would have liked to have morning that he would have liked to have done morning that he would have liked to have done more morning that he would have liked to have done more to morning that he would have liked to have done more to help morning that he would have liked to have done more to help the morning that he would have liked to have done more to help the country's have done more to help the country's most have done more to help the country's most vulnerable have done more to help the country's most vulnerable children, have done more to help the country's most vulnerable children, does have done more to help the country's most vulnerable children, does he most vulnerable children, does he now most vulnerable children, does he now regret most vulnerable children, does he now regret voting most vulnerable children, does he now regret voting against now regret voting against legislation now regret voting against legislation that now regret voting against legislation that would now regret voting against legislation that would feed now regret voting against legislation that would feed every legislation that would feed every poor legislation that would feed every poor child legislation that would feed every poor child in legislation that would feed every poor child in this legislation that would feed every poor child in this country legislation that would feed every poor child in this country in poor child in this country in school, poor child in this country in school, and poor child in this country in school, and help poor child in this country in school, and help them poor child in this country in school, and help them in poor child in this country in school, and help them in their poor child in this country in school, and help them in their homes school, and help them in their homes to school, and help them in their homes to stop school, and help them in their homes to stop them school, and help them in their homes to stop them getting school, and help them in their homes to stop them getting sick school, and help them in their homes to stop them getting sick and to stop them getting sick and hospitalised? to stop them getting sick and hospitalised? Far to stop them getting sick and hospitalised? Far from to stop them getting sick and hospitalised? Far from that, to stop them getting sick and hospitalised? Far from that, I'm hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very proud hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very proud of hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very proud of the hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very proud of the work hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very proud of the work that hospitalised? Far from that, I'm very proud of the work that the very proud of the work that the Government very proud of the work that the Government has very proud of the work that the Government has done very proud of the work that the Government has done in very proud of the work that the Government has done in relation very proud of the work that the Government has done in relation to Government has done in relation to both Government has done in relation to both installation Government has done in relation to both installation of Government has done in relation to both installation of homes, both installation of homes, rheumatic both installation of homes, rheumatic fever, both installation of homes, rheumatic fever, where both installation of homes, rheumatic fever, where there both installation of homes, rheumatic fever, where there has rheumatic fever, where there has been rheumatic fever, where there has been tremendous rheumatic fever, where there has been tremendous progress rheumatic fever, where there has been tremendous progress made, rheumatic fever, where there has been tremendous progress made, and been tremendous progress made, and we've been tremendous progress made, and we've also been tremendous progress made, and we've also championed been tremendous progress made, and we've also championed a been tremendous progress made, and we've also championed a very been tremendous progress made, and we've also championed a very logical we've also championed a very logical programme we've also championed a very logical programme of we've also championed a very logical programme of breakfasts we've also championed a very logical programme of breakfasts in we've also championed a very logical programme of breakfasts in schools programme of breakfasts in schools where programme of breakfasts in schools where we've programme of breakfasts in schools where we've partnered programme of breakfasts in schools where we've partnered with where we've partnered with Sanitarium where we've partnered with Sanitarium and where we've partnered with Sanitarium and Fonterra, where we've partnered with Sanitarium and Fonterra, and where we've partnered with Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I where we've partnered with Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I think Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I think 77 Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I think 77 million Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I think 77 million breakfasts Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I think 77 million breakfasts have Sanitarium and Fonterra, and I think 77 million breakfasts have been 77 million breakfasts have been delivered 77 million breakfasts have been delivered so 77 million breakfasts have been delivered so I 77 million breakfasts have been delivered so I think 77 million breakfasts have been delivered so I think the 77 million breakfasts have been delivered so I think the Government delivered so I think the Government has delivered so I think the Government has a delivered so I think the Government has a very delivered so I think the Government has a very strong delivered so I think the Government has a very strong and delivered so I think the Government has a very strong and proud delivered so I think the Government has a very strong and proud record has a very strong and proud record in has a very strong and proud record in that has a very strong and proud record in that regard. has a very strong and proud record in that regard. Why has a very strong and proud record in that regard. Why doesn't has a very strong and proud record in that regard. Why doesn't he in that regard. Why doesn't he regret in that regard. Why doesn't he regret leaving in that regard. Why doesn't he regret leaving 41,000 in that regard. Why doesn't he regret leaving 41,000 New in that regard. Why doesn't he regret leaving 41,000 New Zealanders regret leaving 41,000 New Zealanders homeless? regret leaving 41,000 New Zealanders homeless? What's regret leaving 41,000 New Zealanders homeless? What's certainly regret leaving 41,000 New Zealanders homeless? What's certainly true regret leaving 41,000 New Zealanders homeless? What's certainly true is homeless? What's certainly true is that homeless? What's certainly true is that as homeless? What's certainly true is that as rent homeless? What's certainly true is that as rent prices homeless? What's certainly true is that as rent prices have homeless? What's certainly true is that as rent prices have increased, that as rent prices have increased, there that as rent prices have increased, there have that as rent prices have increased, there have been that as rent prices have increased, there have been a that as rent prices have increased, there have been a few that as rent prices have increased, there have been a few more that as rent prices have increased, there have been a few more homeless there have been a few more homeless New there have been a few more homeless New Zealanders. there have been a few more homeless New Zealanders. But there have been a few more homeless New Zealanders. But what there have been a few more homeless New Zealanders. But what the New Zealanders. But what the Government New Zealanders. But what the Government has New Zealanders. But what the Government has done New Zealanders. But what the Government has done is New Zealanders. But what the Government has done is respond New Zealanders. But what the Government has done is respond to Government has done is respond to that Government has done is respond to that and Government has done is respond to that and part Government has done is respond to that and part of Government has done is respond to that and part of that Government has done is respond to that and part of that was Government has done is respond to that and part of that was reflected that and part of that was reflected in that and part of that was reflected in Budget that and part of that was reflected in Budget 2016, that and part of that was reflected in Budget 2016, with that and part of that was reflected in Budget 2016, with additional in Budget 2016, with additional money in Budget 2016, with additional money for in Budget 2016, with additional money for emergency in Budget 2016, with additional money for emergency support. in Budget 2016, with additional money for emergency support. The money for emergency support. The most money for emergency support. The most recent money for emergency support. The most recent package money for emergency support. The most recent package announced money for emergency support. The most recent package announced by money for emergency support. The most recent package announced by the most recent package announced by the minister, most recent package announced by the minister, the most recent package announced by the minister, the $300 most recent package announced by the minister, the $300 million most recent package announced by the minister, the $300 million worth most recent package announced by the minister, the $300 million worth of minister, the $300 million worth of support minister, the $300 million worth of support for minister, the $300 million worth of support for emergency minister, the $300 million worth of support for emergency housing. support for emergency housing. Again, support for emergency housing. Again, I'm support for emergency housing. Again, I'm very support for emergency housing. Again, I'm very proud support for emergency housing. Again, I'm very proud of support for emergency housing. Again, I'm very proud of the support for emergency housing. Again, I'm very proud of the record Again, I'm very proud of the record that Again, I'm very proud of the record that the Again, I'm very proud of the record that the Government Again, I'm very proud of the record that the Government has Again, I'm very proud of the record that the Government has in Again, I'm very proud of the record that the Government has in that that the Government has in that regard. that the Government has in that regard. Does that the Government has in that regard. Does he that the Government has in that regard. Does he regret that the Government has in that regard. Does he regret not regard. Does he regret not addressing regard. Does he regret not addressing the regard. Does he regret not addressing the housing regard. Does he regret not addressing the housing crisis regard. Does he regret not addressing the housing crisis in addressing the housing crisis in 2009, addressing the housing crisis in 2009, when addressing the housing crisis in 2009, when he addressing the housing crisis in 2009, when he recognised addressing the housing crisis in 2009, when he recognised the addressing the housing crisis in 2009, when he recognised the early 2009, when he recognised the early signs 2009, when he recognised the early signs of 2009, when he recognised the early signs of it, 2009, when he recognised the early signs of it, has 2009, when he recognised the early signs of it, has left 2009, when he recognised the early signs of it, has left thousands 2009, when he recognised the early signs of it, has left thousands of signs of it, has left thousands of New signs of it, has left thousands of New Zealanders signs of it, has left thousands of New Zealanders homeless signs of it, has left thousands of New Zealanders homeless and signs of it, has left thousands of New Zealanders homeless and many New Zealanders homeless and many more New Zealanders homeless and many more first New Zealanders homeless and many more first homebuyers New Zealanders homeless and many more first homebuyers now New Zealanders homeless and many more first homebuyers now priced New Zealanders homeless and many more first homebuyers now priced out more first homebuyers now priced out of more first homebuyers now priced out of the more first homebuyers now priced out of the Auckland more first homebuyers now priced out of the Auckland market? more first homebuyers now priced out of the Auckland market? Well, more first homebuyers now priced out of the Auckland market? Well, if more first homebuyers now priced out of the Auckland market? Well, if I of the Auckland market? Well, if I was of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to take of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to take the of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to take the member of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to take the member back of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to take the member back to of the Auckland market? Well, if I was to take the member back to 2009, was to take the member back to 2009, for was to take the member back to 2009, for a was to take the member back to 2009, for a start-off, was to take the member back to 2009, for a start-off, interest was to take the member back to 2009, for a start-off, interest rates was to take the member back to 2009, for a start-off, interest rates were for a start-off, interest rates were much for a start-off, interest rates were much higher for a start-off, interest rates were much higher than for a start-off, interest rates were much higher than they for a start-off, interest rates were much higher than they now for a start-off, interest rates were much higher than they now are for a start-off, interest rates were much higher than they now are under much higher than they now are under this much higher than they now are under this Government's much higher than they now are under this Government's watch. much higher than they now are under this Government's watch. There this Government's watch. There wasn't, this Government's watch. There wasn't, from this Government's watch. There wasn't, from memory, this Government's watch. There wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver this Government's watch. There wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver home wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver home start wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver home start for wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver home start for first wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver home start for first homebuyers, wasn't, from memory, KiwiSaver home start for first homebuyers, which start for first homebuyers, which was start for first homebuyers, which was introduced start for first homebuyers, which was introduced later start for first homebuyers, which was introduced later on. start for first homebuyers, which was introduced later on. The start for first homebuyers, which was introduced later on. The work was introduced later on. The work that was introduced later on. The work that we was introduced later on. The work that we did was introduced later on. The work that we did to was introduced later on. The work that we did to ensure was introduced later on. The work that we did to ensure that was introduced later on. The work that we did to ensure that there was introduced later on. The work that we did to ensure that there was that we did to ensure that there was 200 that we did to ensure that there was 200 Special that we did to ensure that there was 200 Special Housing that we did to ensure that there was 200 Special Housing Areas, that we did to ensure that there was 200 Special Housing Areas, if that we did to ensure that there was 200 Special Housing Areas, if not 200 Special Housing Areas, if not more, 200 Special Housing Areas, if not more, that 200 Special Housing Areas, if not more, that was 200 Special Housing Areas, if not more, that was being 200 Special Housing Areas, if not more, that was being undertaken. 200 Special Housing Areas, if not more, that was being undertaken. We more, that was being undertaken. We received more, that was being undertaken. We received no more, that was being undertaken. We received no support more, that was being undertaken. We received no support from more, that was being undertaken. We received no support from the more, that was being undertaken. We received no support from the Green received no support from the Green Party received no support from the Green Party in received no support from the Green Party in terms received no support from the Green Party in terms of received no support from the Green Party in terms of the received no support from the Green Party in terms of the desire received no support from the Green Party in terms of the desire to Party in terms of the desire to reform Party in terms of the desire to reform the Party in terms of the desire to reform the RMA. Party in terms of the desire to reform the RMA. But Party in terms of the desire to reform the RMA. But quite Party in terms of the desire to reform the RMA. But quite the reform the RMA. But quite the opposite, reform the RMA. But quite the opposite, in reform the RMA. But quite the opposite, in 2009, reform the RMA. But quite the opposite, in 2009, if reform the RMA. But quite the opposite, in 2009, if the reform the RMA. But quite the opposite, in 2009, if the member opposite, in 2009, if the member goes opposite, in 2009, if the member goes back opposite, in 2009, if the member goes back and opposite, in 2009, if the member goes back and checks opposite, in 2009, if the member goes back and checks her opposite, in 2009, if the member goes back and checks her records, goes back and checks her records, she goes back and checks her records, she will goes back and checks her records, she will find goes back and checks her records, she will find that goes back and checks her records, she will find that property she will find that property developers she will find that property developers in she will find that property developers in Auckland she will find that property developers in Auckland were she will find that property developers in Auckland were going developers in Auckland were going broke, developers in Auckland were going broke, they developers in Auckland were going broke, they were developers in Auckland were going broke, they were going developers in Auckland were going broke, they were going out developers in Auckland were going broke, they were going out of broke, they were going out of business, broke, they were going out of business, and broke, they were going out of business, and the broke, they were going out of business, and the demand broke, they were going out of business, and the demand for broke, they were going out of business, and the demand for first broke, they were going out of business, and the demand for first - business, and the demand for first - by business, and the demand for first - by first business, and the demand for first - by first homebuyers business, and the demand for first - by first homebuyers and, business, and the demand for first - by first homebuyers and, indeed, business, and the demand for first - by first homebuyers and, indeed, any by first homebuyers and, indeed, any buyers by first homebuyers and, indeed, any buyers in by first homebuyers and, indeed, any buyers in the by first homebuyers and, indeed, any buyers in the Auckland by first homebuyers and, indeed, any buyers in the Auckland property buyers in the Auckland property market buyers in the Auckland property market and buyers in the Auckland property market and around buyers in the Auckland property market and around the buyers in the Auckland property market and around the country buyers in the Auckland property market and around the country were market and around the country were very market and around the country were very limited market and around the country were very limited because market and around the country were very limited because of market and around the country were very limited because of the market and around the country were very limited because of the global very limited because of the global financial very limited because of the global financial crisis. very limited because of the global financial crisis. Does very limited because of the global financial crisis. Does he very limited because of the global financial crisis. Does he grelt very limited because of the global financial crisis. Does he grelt -- financial crisis. Does he grelt -- regret financial crisis. Does he grelt -- regret that financial crisis. Does he grelt -- regret that climate financial crisis. Does he grelt -- regret that climate pollution financial crisis. Does he grelt -- regret that climate pollution rose regret that climate pollution rose 19% regret that climate pollution rose 19% under regret that climate pollution rose 19% under his regret that climate pollution rose 19% under his prime regret that climate pollution rose 19% under his prime ministership? 19% under his prime ministership? I'm 19% under his prime ministership? I'm proud 19% under his prime ministership? I'm proud of 19% under his prime ministership? I'm proud of the 19% under his prime ministership? I'm proud of the fact 19% under his prime ministership? I'm proud of the fact that 19% under his prime ministership? I'm proud of the fact that the I'm proud of the fact that the Government I'm proud of the fact that the Government has I'm proud of the fact that the Government has introduced I'm proud of the fact that the Government has introduced overtime, Government has introduced overtime, tougher Government has introduced overtime, tougher standards Government has introduced overtime, tougher standards and Government has introduced overtime, tougher standards and a Government has introduced overtime, tougher standards and a range Government has introduced overtime, tougher standards and a range of tougher standards and a range of areas tougher standards and a range of areas -- tougher standards and a range of areas -- in tougher standards and a range of areas -- in a tougher standards and a range of areas -- in a range tougher standards and a range of areas -- in a range of tougher standards and a range of areas -- in a range of areas. tougher standards and a range of areas -- in a range of areas. I'm areas -- in a range of areas. I'm proud areas -- in a range of areas. I'm proud of areas -- in a range of areas. I'm proud of the areas -- in a range of areas. I'm proud of the fact areas -- in a range of areas. I'm proud of the fact that areas -- in a range of areas. I'm proud of the fact that we've proud of the fact that we've increased proud of the fact that we've increased the proud of the fact that we've increased the amount proud of the fact that we've increased the amount of proud of the fact that we've increased the amount of renewable increased the amount of renewable energy increased the amount of renewable energy that increased the amount of renewable energy that New increased the amount of renewable energy that New Zealand increased the amount of renewable energy that New Zealand now increased the amount of renewable energy that New Zealand now uses. energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm proud energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm proud of energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm proud of the energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm proud of the work energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm proud of the work we're energy that New Zealand now uses. I'm proud of the work we're starting I'm proud of the work we're starting to I'm proud of the work we're starting to progress I'm proud of the work we're starting to progress around I'm proud of the work we're starting to progress around electric I'm proud of the work we're starting to progress around electric vehicles to progress around electric vehicles and to progress around electric vehicles and the to progress around electric vehicles and the likes. to progress around electric vehicles and the likes. But to progress around electric vehicles and the likes. But the to progress around electric vehicles and the likes. But the reality to progress around electric vehicles and the likes. But the reality when and the likes. But the reality when it and the likes. But the reality when it comes and the likes. But the reality when it comes to and the likes. But the reality when it comes to climate and the likes. But the reality when it comes to climate change and the likes. But the reality when it comes to climate change is and the likes. But the reality when it comes to climate change is that it comes to climate change is that this it comes to climate change is that this Government it comes to climate change is that this Government - it comes to climate change is that this Government - this it comes to climate change is that this Government - this Government this Government - this Government has this Government - this Government has followed this Government - this Government has followed a this Government - this Government has followed a steady this Government - this Government has followed a steady and this Government - this Government has followed a steady and actually has followed a steady and actually medium has followed a steady and actually medium course has followed a steady and actually medium course when has followed a steady and actually medium course when it has followed a steady and actually medium course when it comes has followed a steady and actually medium course when it comes to medium course when it comes to climate medium course when it comes to climate change, medium course when it comes to climate change, and medium course when it comes to climate change, and that medium course when it comes to climate change, and that is medium course when it comes to climate change, and that is quite medium course when it comes to climate change, and that is quite in climate change, and that is quite in contrast climate change, and that is quite in contrast to climate change, and that is quite in contrast to a climate change, and that is quite in contrast to a lot climate change, and that is quite in contrast to a lot of climate change, and that is quite in contrast to a lot of countries contrast to a lot of countries around contrast to a lot of countries around the contrast to a lot of countries around the world, contrast to a lot of countries around the world, and contrast to a lot of countries around the world, and I contrast to a lot of countries around the world, and I think contrast to a lot of countries around the world, and I think that contrast to a lot of countries around the world, and I think that, around the world, and I think that, you around the world, and I think that, you know, around the world, and I think that, you know, what around the world, and I think that, you know, what we around the world, and I think that, you know, what we should around the world, and I think that, you know, what we should be you know, what we should be concerned you know, what we should be concerned about you know, what we should be concerned about is you know, what we should be concerned about is potentially you know, what we should be concerned about is potentially if concerned about is potentially if the concerned about is potentially if the United concerned about is potentially if the United States concerned about is potentially if the United States, concerned about is potentially if the United States, under the United States, under President-elect the United States, under President-elect Donald the United States, under President-elect Donald Trump, the United States, under President-elect Donald Trump, pull President-elect Donald Trump, pull out President-elect Donald Trump, pull out from President-elect Donald Trump, pull out from their President-elect Donald Trump, pull out from their commitments President-elect Donald Trump, pull out from their commitments that President-elect Donald Trump, pull out from their commitments that they out from their commitments that they have out from their commitments that they have made out from their commitments that they have made under out from their commitments that they have made under President out from their commitments that they have made under President Obama out from their commitments that they have made under President Obama from have made under President Obama from the have made under President Obama from the Paris have made under President Obama from the Paris Accord have made under President Obama from the Paris Accord and have made under President Obama from the Paris Accord and I have made under President Obama from the Paris Accord and I think have made under President Obama from the Paris Accord and I think that's the Paris Accord and I think that's far the Paris Accord and I think that's far more the Paris Accord and I think that's far more worrying the Paris Accord and I think that's far more worrying than the Paris Accord and I think that's far more worrying than anything the Paris Accord and I think that's far more worrying than anything New far more worrying than anything New Zealand far more worrying than anything New Zealand is far more worrying than anything New Zealand is doing. far more worrying than anything New Zealand is doing. We far more worrying than anything New Zealand is doing. We have far more worrying than anything New Zealand is doing. We have been Zealand is doing. We have been progressing Zealand is doing. We have been progressing both Zealand is doing. We have been progressing both an Zealand is doing. We have been progressing both an emissions progressing both an emissions trading progressing both an emissions trading scheme progressing both an emissions trading scheme and progressing both an emissions trading scheme and a progressing both an emissions trading scheme and a sensible progressing both an emissions trading scheme and a sensible policy trading scheme and a sensible policy approach trading scheme and a sensible policy approach to trading scheme and a sensible policy approach to climate trading scheme and a sensible policy approach to climate change. trading scheme and a sensible policy approach to climate change. Does trading scheme and a sensible policy approach to climate change. Does he approach to climate change. Does he think approach to climate change. Does he think that approach to climate change. Does he think that he approach to climate change. Does he think that he will approach to climate change. Does he think that he will look approach to climate change. Does he think that he will look back approach to climate change. Does he think that he will look back on approach to climate change. Does he think that he will look back on this think that he will look back on this time think that he will look back on this time and think that he will look back on this time and regret think that he will look back on this time and regret that think that he will look back on this time and regret that he think that he will look back on this time and regret that he spent think that he will look back on this time and regret that he spent more time and regret that he spent more time time and regret that he spent more time worrying time and regret that he spent more time worrying about time and regret that he spent more time worrying about the time and regret that he spent more time worrying about the SkyCity time worrying about the SkyCity Casino time worrying about the SkyCity Casino profits time worrying about the SkyCity Casino profits and time worrying about the SkyCity Casino profits and selling time worrying about the SkyCity Casino profits and selling off time worrying about the SkyCity Casino profits and selling off state Casino profits and selling off state assets Casino profits and selling off state assets than Casino profits and selling off state assets than he Casino profits and selling off state assets than he did Casino profits and selling off state assets than he did about Casino profits and selling off state assets than he did about the assets than he did about the families assets than he did about the families and assets than he did about the families and the assets than he did about the families and the children assets than he did about the families and the children who assets than he did about the families and the children who needed families and the children who needed him families and the children who needed him most families and the children who needed him most as families and the children who needed him most as PM? families and the children who needed him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. I him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. I do him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. I do believe, him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. I do believe, when him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. I do believe, when the him most as PM? <INTERRUPTION> No. I do believe, when the SkyCity No. I do believe, when the SkyCity Convention No. I do believe, when the SkyCity Convention Centre No. I do believe, when the SkyCity Convention Centre is No. I do believe, when the SkyCity Convention Centre is completed, No. I do believe, when the SkyCity Convention Centre is completed, at Convention Centre is completed, at zero Convention Centre is completed, at zero cost Convention Centre is completed, at zero cost to Convention Centre is completed, at zero cost to the Convention Centre is completed, at zero cost to the New Convention Centre is completed, at zero cost to the New Zealand zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer and zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer and ratepayer, zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer and ratepayer, it zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer and ratepayer, it will zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be zero cost to the New Zealand taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a very taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a very fine taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a very fine asset taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a very fine asset for taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a very fine asset for New taxpayer and ratepayer, it will be a very fine asset for New Zealand. very fine asset for New Zealand. Over very fine asset for New Zealand. Over the very fine asset for New Zealand. Over the course very fine asset for New Zealand. Over the course of very fine asset for New Zealand. Over the course of the very fine asset for New Zealand. Over the course of the last very fine asset for New Zealand. Over the course of the last eight Over the course of the last eight years Over the course of the last eight years as Over the course of the last eight years as PM, Over the course of the last eight years as PM, an Over the course of the last eight years as PM, an enormous Over the course of the last eight years as PM, an enormous amount Over the course of the last eight years as PM, an enormous amount of years as PM, an enormous amount of focus years as PM, an enormous amount of focus has years as PM, an enormous amount of focus has gone years as PM, an enormous amount of focus has gone into years as PM, an enormous amount of focus has gone into the years as PM, an enormous amount of focus has gone into the welfare years as PM, an enormous amount of focus has gone into the welfare of focus has gone into the welfare of all focus has gone into the welfare of all New focus has gone into the welfare of all New Zealanders, focus has gone into the welfare of all New Zealanders, and focus has gone into the welfare of all New Zealanders, and to focus has gone into the welfare of all New Zealanders, and to their all New Zealanders, and to their rights, all New Zealanders, and to their rights, their all New Zealanders, and to their rights, their interests, all New Zealanders, and to their rights, their interests, and all New Zealanders, and to their rights, their interests, and their rights, their interests, and their prosperity. rights, their interests, and their prosperity. I rights, their interests, and their prosperity. I think rights, their interests, and their prosperity. I think New rights, their interests, and their prosperity. I think New Zealand rights, their interests, and their prosperity. I think New Zealand as rights, their interests, and their prosperity. I think New Zealand as a prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country can prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country can now prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country can now rightfully prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country can now rightfully say prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country can now rightfully say it prosperity. I think New Zealand as a country can now rightfully say it is country can now rightfully say it is far country can now rightfully say it is far more country can now rightfully say it is far more confident country can now rightfully say it is far more confident about country can now rightfully say it is far more confident about its country can now rightfully say it is far more confident about its place far more confident about its place in far more confident about its place in the far more confident about its place in the world far more confident about its place in the world and far more confident about its place in the world and more far more confident about its place in the world and more prosperous far more confident about its place in the world and more prosperous and in the world and more prosperous and that's in the world and more prosperous and that's why in the world and more prosperous and that's why economic in the world and more prosperous and that's why economic results in the world and more prosperous and that's why economic results are that's why economic results are great. that's why economic results are great. I that's why economic results are great. I will that's why economic results are great. I will leave that's why economic results are great. I will leave this that's why economic results are great. I will leave this parliament, great. I will leave this parliament, when great. I will leave this parliament, when I great. I will leave this parliament, when I eventually great. I will leave this parliament, when I eventually give great. I will leave this parliament, when I eventually give my great. I will leave this parliament, when I eventually give my final when I eventually give my final speech, when I eventually give my final speech, with when I eventually give my final speech, with a when I eventually give my final speech, with a slightly when I eventually give my final speech, with a slightly warmer when I eventually give my final speech, with a slightly warmer view speech, with a slightly warmer view towards speech, with a slightly warmer view towards this speech, with a slightly warmer view towards this place speech, with a slightly warmer view towards this place and speech, with a slightly warmer view towards this place and my speech, with a slightly warmer view towards this place and my role speech, with a slightly warmer view towards this place and my role in towards this place and my role in it, towards this place and my role in it, than towards this place and my role in it, than clearly towards this place and my role in it, than clearly the towards this place and my role in it, than clearly the member towards this place and my role in it, than clearly the member will. it, than clearly the member will. Question it, than clearly the member will. Question No. it, than clearly the member will. Question No. 3. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: Finance: Does Finance: Does he Finance: Does he stand Finance: Does he stand by Finance: Does he stand by his Finance: Does he stand by his statement Finance: Does he stand by his statement that Does he stand by his statement that "the Does he stand by his statement that "the prices Does he stand by his statement that "the prices you Does he stand by his statement that "the prices you pay Does he stand by his statement that "the prices you pay for Does he stand by his statement that "the prices you pay for a Does he stand by his statement that "the prices you pay for a house Does he stand by his statement that "the prices you pay for a house are "the prices you pay for a house are ridiculous", "the prices you pay for a house are ridiculous", given "the prices you pay for a house are ridiculous", given New "the prices you pay for a house are ridiculous", given New Zealand "the prices you pay for a house are ridiculous", given New Zealand house ridiculous", given New Zealand house prices ridiculous", given New Zealand house prices have ridiculous", given New Zealand house prices have risen ridiculous", given New Zealand house prices have risen by ridiculous", given New Zealand house prices have risen by over ridiculous", given New Zealand house prices have risen by over 50% prices have risen by over 50% since prices have risen by over 50% since he prices have risen by over 50% since he made prices have risen by over 50% since he made that since he made that statement? Yes. Yes. And Yes. And the Yes. And the main Yes. And the main change Yes. And the main change that Yes. And the main change that has Yes. And the main change that has occurred Yes. And the main change that has occurred since Yes. And the main change that has occurred since that Yes. And the main change that has occurred since that statement Yes. And the main change that has occurred since that statement was occurred since that statement was made occurred since that statement was made is occurred since that statement was made is the occurred since that statement was made is the Auckland occurred since that statement was made is the Auckland Unitary occurred since that statement was made is the Auckland Unitary Plan, made is the Auckland Unitary Plan, which, made is the Auckland Unitary Plan, which, because made is the Auckland Unitary Plan, which, because of made is the Auckland Unitary Plan, which, because of this made is the Auckland Unitary Plan, which, because of this Government's which, because of this Government's legislation, which, because of this Government's legislation, was which, because of this Government's legislation, was passed which, because of this Government's legislation, was passed in which, because of this Government's legislation, was passed in three legislation, was passed in three years legislation, was passed in three years instead legislation, was passed in three years instead of legislation, was passed in three years instead of ten. legislation, was passed in three years instead of ten. It legislation, was passed in three years instead of ten. It now legislation, was passed in three years instead of ten. It now legally years instead of ten. It now legally allows years instead of ten. It now legally allows sufficient years instead of ten. It now legally allows sufficient new years instead of ten. It now legally allows sufficient new supply years instead of ten. It now legally allows sufficient new supply of allows sufficient new supply of housing allows sufficient new supply of housing and allows sufficient new supply of housing and over allows sufficient new supply of housing and over the allows sufficient new supply of housing and over the next allows sufficient new supply of housing and over the next ten allows sufficient new supply of housing and over the next ten years, housing and over the next ten years, along housing and over the next ten years, along with housing and over the next ten years, along with the housing and over the next ten years, along with the major housing and over the next ten years, along with the major government along with the major government building along with the major government building programme, along with the major government building programme, will along with the major government building programme, will have along with the major government building programme, will have an building programme, will have an influence building programme, will have an influence on building programme, will have an influence on house building programme, will have an influence on house prices. building programme, will have an influence on house prices. Is building programme, will have an influence on house prices. Is there influence on house prices. Is there a influence on house prices. Is there a housing influence on house prices. Is there a housing crisis influence on house prices. Is there a housing crisis - influence on house prices. Is there a housing crisis - yes influence on house prices. Is there a housing crisis - yes or influence on house prices. Is there a housing crisis - yes or no? influence on house prices. Is there a housing crisis - yes or no? No. a housing crisis - yes or no? No. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> New <INTERRUPTION> New Zealand <INTERRUPTION> New Zealand is <INTERRUPTION> New Zealand is building <INTERRUPTION> New Zealand is building tens <INTERRUPTION> New Zealand is building tens of New Zealand is building tens of thousands New Zealand is building tens of thousands of New Zealand is building tens of thousands of houses New Zealand is building tens of thousands of houses over New Zealand is building tens of thousands of houses over the New Zealand is building tens of thousands of houses over the next thousands of houses over the next few thousands of houses over the next few years, thousands of houses over the next few years, because thousands of houses over the next few years, because of thousands of houses over the next few years, because of the thousands of houses over the next few years, because of the changes few years, because of the changes the few years, because of the changes the Government few years, because of the changes the Government has few years, because of the changes the Government has made, few years, because of the changes the Government has made, and few years, because of the changes the Government has made, and will the Government has made, and will make, the Government has made, and will make, to the Government has made, and will make, to the the Government has made, and will make, to the regulation the Government has made, and will make, to the regulation of the Government has made, and will make, to the regulation of housing make, to the regulation of housing markets make, to the regulation of housing markets and make, to the regulation of housing markets and planning, make, to the regulation of housing markets and planning, and make, to the regulation of housing markets and planning, and the markets and planning, and the Government's markets and planning, and the Government's own markets and planning, and the Government's own building markets and planning, and the Government's own building programme. Government's own building programme. We Government's own building programme. We will Government's own building programme. We will see Government's own building programme. We will see considerable Government's own building programme. We will see considerable further We will see considerable further growth We will see considerable further growth in We will see considerable further growth in the We will see considerable further growth in the supply We will see considerable further growth in the supply of We will see considerable further growth in the supply of houses We will see considerable further growth in the supply of houses and We will see considerable further growth in the supply of houses and a growth in the supply of houses and a moderation growth in the supply of houses and a moderation of growth in the supply of houses and a moderation of the growth in the supply of houses and a moderation of the housing growth in the supply of houses and a moderation of the housing cycle. moderation of the housing cycle. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Does <INTERRUPTION> Does he <INTERRUPTION> Does he stand <INTERRUPTION> Does he stand by <INTERRUPTION> Does he stand by his <INTERRUPTION> Does he stand by his statement <INTERRUPTION> Does he stand by his statement that, Does he stand by his statement that, "The Does he stand by his statement that, "The most Does he stand by his statement that, "The most unfair Does he stand by his statement that, "The most unfair aspect Does he stand by his statement that, "The most unfair aspect of Does he stand by his statement that, "The most unfair aspect of it Does he stand by his statement that, "The most unfair aspect of it is "The most unfair aspect of it is that "The most unfair aspect of it is that there's "The most unfair aspect of it is that there's no "The most unfair aspect of it is that there's no housing "The most unfair aspect of it is that there's no housing being "The most unfair aspect of it is that there's no housing being built that there's no housing being built for that there's no housing being built for people that there's no housing being built for people in that there's no housing being built for people in the that there's no housing being built for people in the lowest that there's no housing being built for people in the lowest quartile that there's no housing being built for people in the lowest quartile of for people in the lowest quartile of income for people in the lowest quartile of income - for people in the lowest quartile of income - like, for people in the lowest quartile of income - like, none for people in the lowest quartile of income - like, none - for people in the lowest quartile of income - like, none - that for people in the lowest quartile of income - like, none - that is income - like, none - that is clearly income - like, none - that is clearly unsustainable"? income - like, none - that is clearly unsustainable"? Yes, income - like, none - that is clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and income - like, none - that is clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and at clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and at the clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and at the time clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and at the time that clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and at the time that was clearly unsustainable"? Yes, and at the time that was absolutely the time that was absolutely correct, the time that was absolutely correct, because the time that was absolutely correct, because the the time that was absolutely correct, because the old the time that was absolutely correct, because the old Auckland correct, because the old Auckland plan correct, because the old Auckland plan and correct, because the old Auckland plan and city correct, because the old Auckland plan and city plans, correct, because the old Auckland plan and city plans, which correct, because the old Auckland plan and city plans, which used correct, because the old Auckland plan and city plans, which used to plan and city plans, which used to be plan and city plans, which used to be all plan and city plans, which used to be all supported plan and city plans, which used to be all supported by plan and city plans, which used to be all supported by the plan and city plans, which used to be all supported by the Labour be all supported by the Labour Party, be all supported by the Labour Party, had be all supported by the Labour Party, had the be all supported by the Labour Party, had the result be all supported by the Labour Party, had the result that be all supported by the Labour Party, had the result that no be all supported by the Labour Party, had the result that no lower Party, had the result that no lower cost Party, had the result that no lower cost housing Party, had the result that no lower cost housing was Party, had the result that no lower cost housing was being Party, had the result that no lower cost housing was being built Party, had the result that no lower cost housing was being built in cost housing was being built in areas cost housing was being built in areas like cost housing was being built in areas like the cost housing was being built in areas like the North cost housing was being built in areas like the North Shore. cost housing was being built in areas like the North Shore. That cost housing was being built in areas like the North Shore. That is areas like the North Shore. That is now areas like the North Shore. That is now changing, areas like the North Shore. That is now changing, for areas like the North Shore. That is now changing, for instance, areas like the North Shore. That is now changing, for instance, through now changing, for instance, through the now changing, for instance, through the 1,000-house now changing, for instance, through the 1,000-house development now changing, for instance, through the 1,000-house development that now changing, for instance, through the 1,000-house development that has the 1,000-house development that has been the 1,000-house development that has been begun the 1,000-house development that has been begun by the 1,000-house development that has been begun by Housing the 1,000-house development that has been begun by Housing New the 1,000-house development that has been begun by Housing New Zealand the 1,000-house development that has been begun by Housing New Zealand in been begun by Housing New Zealand in Northcote been begun by Housing New Zealand in Northcote where been begun by Housing New Zealand in Northcote where 1,000 been begun by Housing New Zealand in Northcote where 1,000 medium Northcote where 1,000 medium density, Northcote where 1,000 medium density, medium-value Northcote where 1,000 medium density, medium-value houses Northcote where 1,000 medium density, medium-value houses will Northcote where 1,000 medium density, medium-value houses will be density, medium-value houses will be produced. density, medium-value houses will be produced. <INTERRUPTION> produced. <INTERRUPTION> Order! produced. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What produced. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What steps produced. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What steps is produced. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What steps is the produced. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What steps is the Government Order! What steps is the Government taking... Order! What steps is the Government taking... Order! Order! What steps is the Government taking... Order! Can Order! What steps is the Government taking... Order! Can I Order! What steps is the Government taking... Order! Can I just... Order! What steps is the Government taking... Order! Can I just... I taking... Order! Can I just... I detect taking... Order! Can I just... I detect an taking... Order! Can I just... I detect an air taking... Order! Can I just... I detect an air of taking... Order! Can I just... I detect an air of anticipation taking... Order! Can I just... I detect an air of anticipation and detect an air of anticipation and excitement, detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but I detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but I still detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but I still need detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but I still need to detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but I still need to - detect an air of anticipation and excitement, but I still need to - I excitement, but I still need to - I still excitement, but I still need to - I still need excitement, but I still need to - I still need to excitement, but I still need to - I still need to get excitement, but I still need to - I still need to get through excitement, but I still need to - I still need to get through Oral still need to get through Oral Questions still need to get through Oral Questions with still need to get through Oral Questions with me still need to get through Oral Questions with me being still need to get through Oral Questions with me being able still need to get through Oral Questions with me being able to still need to get through Oral Questions with me being able to hear Questions with me being able to hear the Questions with me being able to hear the questions Questions with me being able to hear the questions asked. Questions with me being able to hear the questions asked. What Questions with me being able to hear the questions asked. What steps Questions with me being able to hear the questions asked. What steps is the questions asked. What steps is the the questions asked. What steps is the Government the questions asked. What steps is the Government taking the questions asked. What steps is the Government taking as the questions asked. What steps is the Government taking as part the questions asked. What steps is the Government taking as part of the questions asked. What steps is the Government taking as part of its the Government taking as part of its comprehensive the Government taking as part of its comprehensive plan the Government taking as part of its comprehensive plan to the Government taking as part of its comprehensive plan to deliver the Government taking as part of its comprehensive plan to deliver more comprehensive plan to deliver more houses comprehensive plan to deliver more houses and comprehensive plan to deliver more houses and more comprehensive plan to deliver more houses and more affordable comprehensive plan to deliver more houses and more affordable housing? houses and more affordable housing? Because houses and more affordable housing? Because the houses and more affordable housing? Because the phenomena houses and more affordable housing? Because the phenomena of houses and more affordable housing? Because the phenomena of housing houses and more affordable housing? Because the phenomena of housing is Because the phenomena of housing is so Because the phenomena of housing is so complex Because the phenomena of housing is so complex it Because the phenomena of housing is so complex it takes Because the phenomena of housing is so complex it takes a Because the phenomena of housing is so complex it takes a large Because the phenomena of housing is so complex it takes a large amount so complex it takes a large amount of so complex it takes a large amount of initiatives so complex it takes a large amount of initiatives to so complex it takes a large amount of initiatives to push so complex it takes a large amount of initiatives to push the so complex it takes a large amount of initiatives to push the housing of initiatives to push the housing market of initiatives to push the housing market in of initiatives to push the housing market in the of initiatives to push the housing market in the right of initiatives to push the housing market in the right direction. market in the right direction. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Ranging <INTERRUPTION> Ranging from <INTERRUPTION> Ranging from the <INTERRUPTION> Ranging from the $1 <INTERRUPTION> Ranging from the $1 billion <INTERRUPTION> Ranging from the $1 billion housing Ranging from the $1 billion housing infrastructure Ranging from the $1 billion housing infrastructure fund, Ranging from the $1 billion housing infrastructure fund, the Ranging from the $1 billion housing infrastructure fund, the expand infrastructure fund, the expand HomeStart infrastructure fund, the expand HomeStart scheme infrastructure fund, the expand HomeStart scheme for infrastructure fund, the expand HomeStart scheme for first HomeStart scheme for first homebuyers, HomeStart scheme for first homebuyers, the HomeStart scheme for first homebuyers, the National HomeStart scheme for first homebuyers, the National Policy homebuyers, the National Policy Statement homebuyers, the National Policy Statement on homebuyers, the National Policy Statement on Urban homebuyers, the National Policy Statement on Urban Development, homebuyers, the National Policy Statement on Urban Development, the Statement on Urban Development, the macro Statement on Urban Development, the macro prudential Statement on Urban Development, the macro prudential tools Statement on Urban Development, the macro prudential tools for Statement on Urban Development, the macro prudential tools for the macro prudential tools for the Reserve macro prudential tools for the Reserve Bank, macro prudential tools for the Reserve Bank, the macro prudential tools for the Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking macro prudential tools for the Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of the Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of the Auckland Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of the Auckland Unitary Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of the Auckland Unitary Plan Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of the Auckland Unitary Plan and Reserve Bank, the fast-tracking of the Auckland Unitary Plan and the the Auckland Unitary Plan and the large-scale the Auckland Unitary Plan and the large-scale building the Auckland Unitary Plan and the large-scale building programme the Auckland Unitary Plan and the large-scale building programme that large-scale building programme that the large-scale building programme that the Government large-scale building programme that the Government is large-scale building programme that the Government is setting large-scale building programme that the Government is setting out large-scale building programme that the Government is setting out on. the Government is setting out on. Does the Government is setting out on. Does he the Government is setting out on. Does he accept the Government is setting out on. Does he accept it the Government is setting out on. Does he accept it was the Government is setting out on. Does he accept it was a the Government is setting out on. Does he accept it was a mistake the Government is setting out on. Does he accept it was a mistake for Does he accept it was a mistake for him Does he accept it was a mistake for him to Does he accept it was a mistake for him to rip Does he accept it was a mistake for him to rip over Does he accept it was a mistake for him to rip over half Does he accept it was a mistake for him to rip over half a Does he accept it was a mistake for him to rip over half a billion him to rip over half a billion dollars him to rip over half a billion dollars in him to rip over half a billion dollars in profits him to rip over half a billion dollars in profits out him to rip over half a billion dollars in profits out of him to rip over half a billion dollars in profits out of Housing dollars in profits out of Housing New dollars in profits out of Housing New Zealand dollars in profits out of Housing New Zealand while dollars in profits out of Housing New Zealand while kids dollars in profits out of Housing New Zealand while kids were dollars in profits out of Housing New Zealand while kids were getting New Zealand while kids were getting sick New Zealand while kids were getting sick and New Zealand while kids were getting sick and dying New Zealand while kids were getting sick and dying in New Zealand while kids were getting sick and dying in cold, New Zealand while kids were getting sick and dying in cold, mouldy New Zealand while kids were getting sick and dying in cold, mouldy state sick and dying in cold, mouldy state houses? sick and dying in cold, mouldy state houses? No, sick and dying in cold, mouldy state houses? No, and sick and dying in cold, mouldy state houses? No, and the sick and dying in cold, mouldy state houses? No, and the action sick and dying in cold, mouldy state houses? No, and the action the houses? No, and the action the Government houses? No, and the action the Government has houses? No, and the action the Government has taken houses? No, and the action the Government has taken - houses? No, and the action the Government has taken - the Government has taken - the Government Government has taken - the Government has Government has taken - the Government has taken Government has taken - the Government has taken intensive Government has taken - the Government has taken intensive and Government has taken intensive and expensive Government has taken intensive and expensive action Government has taken intensive and expensive action to Government has taken intensive and expensive action to reduce Government has taken intensive and expensive action to reduce exactly expensive action to reduce exactly the expensive action to reduce exactly the situation expensive action to reduce exactly the situation the expensive action to reduce exactly the situation the member expensive action to reduce exactly the situation the member describes. the situation the member describes. The the situation the member describes. The project the situation the member describes. The project for the situation the member describes. The project for the the situation the member describes. The project for the reduction the situation the member describes. The project for the reduction of The project for the reduction of rheumatoid The project for the reduction of rheumatoid arthritis The project for the reduction of rheumatoid arthritis has The project for the reduction of rheumatoid arthritis has been The project for the reduction of rheumatoid arthritis has been all rheumatoid arthritis has been all about rheumatoid arthritis has been all about finding rheumatoid arthritis has been all about finding the rheumatoid arthritis has been all about finding the kids rheumatoid arthritis has been all about finding the kids who rheumatoid arthritis has been all about finding the kids who come rheumatoid arthritis has been all about finding the kids who come from about finding the kids who come from those about finding the kids who come from those houses, about finding the kids who come from those houses, changing about finding the kids who come from those houses, changing - about finding the kids who come from those houses, changing - either those houses, changing - either changing those houses, changing - either changing the those houses, changing - either changing the houses those houses, changing - either changing the houses or those houses, changing - either changing the houses or shifting those houses, changing - either changing the houses or shifting them changing the houses or shifting them to changing the houses or shifting them to a changing the houses or shifting them to a - changing the houses or shifting them to a - shifting changing the houses or shifting them to a - shifting them changing the houses or shifting them to a - shifting them to changing the houses or shifting them to a - shifting them to a changing the houses or shifting them to a - shifting them to a warm, changing the houses or shifting them to a - shifting them to a warm, dry to a - shifting them to a warm, dry house. to a - shifting them to a warm, dry house. <INTERRUPTION> house. <INTERRUPTION> Order! house. <INTERRUPTION> Order! The house. <INTERRUPTION> Order! The Government house. <INTERRUPTION> Order! The Government committed Order! The Government committed 60-80 Order! The Government committed 60-80 million Order! The Government committed 60-80 million to Order! The Government committed 60-80 million to that Order! The Government committed 60-80 million to that and Order! The Government committed 60-80 million to that and the 60-80 million to that and the programme 60-80 million to that and the programme has 60-80 million to that and the programme has been 60-80 million to that and the programme has been quite 60-80 million to that and the programme has been quite successful, programme has been quite successful, but programme has been quite successful, but has programme has been quite successful, but has some programme has been quite successful, but has some way programme has been quite successful, but has some way to programme has been quite successful, but has some way to go. but has some way to go. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order!. <INTERRUPTION> Order!. Minister, <INTERRUPTION> Order!. Minister, if <INTERRUPTION> Order!. Minister, if it <INTERRUPTION> Order!. Minister, if it can <INTERRUPTION> Order!. Minister, if it can be Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as it Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as it can Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as it can be, Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as it can be, that Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as it can be, that none Order!. Minister, if it can be proven, as it can be, that none of proven, as it can be, that none of his proven, as it can be, that none of his commitments proven, as it can be, that none of his commitments and proven, as it can be, that none of his commitments and promises proven, as it can be, that none of his commitments and promises on his commitments and promises on housing his commitments and promises on housing have his commitments and promises on housing have been his commitments and promises on housing have been kept, his commitments and promises on housing have been kept, will his commitments and promises on housing have been kept, will he housing have been kept, will he promise housing have been kept, will he promise not housing have been kept, will he promise not to housing have been kept, will he promise not to stand housing have been kept, will he promise not to stand for housing have been kept, will he promise not to stand for the promise not to stand for the leadership promise not to stand for the leadership come promise not to stand for the leadership come Monday? leadership come Monday? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> As <INTERRUPTION> As I've <INTERRUPTION> As I've laid <INTERRUPTION> As I've laid out <INTERRUPTION> As I've laid out - <INTERRUPTION> As I've laid out - well, <INTERRUPTION> As I've laid out - well, the <INTERRUPTION> As I've laid out - well, the member As I've laid out - well, the member may As I've laid out - well, the member may not As I've laid out - well, the member may not have As I've laid out - well, the member may not have paid As I've laid out - well, the member may not have paid much As I've laid out - well, the member may not have paid much attention As I've laid out - well, the member may not have paid much attention - may not have paid much attention - there may not have paid much attention - there has may not have paid much attention - there has been may not have paid much attention - there has been a may not have paid much attention - there has been a raft may not have paid much attention - there has been a raft of may not have paid much attention - there has been a raft of measures there has been a raft of measures taken there has been a raft of measures taken on there has been a raft of measures taken on changing there has been a raft of measures taken on changing the there has been a raft of measures taken on changing the housing taken on changing the housing market. taken on changing the housing market. <INTERRUPTION> market. <INTERRUPTION> We're market. <INTERRUPTION> We're dealing market. <INTERRUPTION> We're dealing with market. <INTERRUPTION> We're dealing with the market. <INTERRUPTION> We're dealing with the legacy market. <INTERRUPTION> We're dealing with the legacy of market. <INTERRUPTION> We're dealing with the legacy of 30 We're dealing with the legacy of 30 years We're dealing with the legacy of 30 years of We're dealing with the legacy of 30 years of wrong-headed We're dealing with the legacy of 30 years of wrong-headed planning, years of wrong-headed planning, which years of wrong-headed planning, which was years of wrong-headed planning, which was designed years of wrong-headed planning, which was designed to years of wrong-headed planning, which was designed to stop years of wrong-headed planning, which was designed to stop Auckland which was designed to stop Auckland growing. which was designed to stop Auckland growing. Under which was designed to stop Auckland growing. Under this which was designed to stop Auckland growing. Under this Government, which was designed to stop Auckland growing. Under this Government, the growing. Under this Government, the economy growing. Under this Government, the economy is growing. Under this Government, the economy is growing, growing. Under this Government, the economy is growing, Auckland growing. Under this Government, the economy is growing, Auckland is economy is growing, Auckland is growing, economy is growing, Auckland is growing, and economy is growing, Auckland is growing, and we economy is growing, Auckland is growing, and we need economy is growing, Auckland is growing, and we need to economy is growing, Auckland is growing, and we need to change economy is growing, Auckland is growing, and we need to change all growing, and we need to change all the growing, and we need to change all the housing growing, and we need to change all the housing rules growing, and we need to change all the housing rules to growing, and we need to change all the housing rules to accommodate growing, and we need to change all the housing rules to accommodate all the housing rules to accommodate all the the housing rules to accommodate all the people the housing rules to accommodate all the people who the housing rules to accommodate all the people who want the housing rules to accommodate all the people who want to the housing rules to accommodate all the people who want to live the housing rules to accommodate all the people who want to live here. the people who want to live here. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Does <INTERRUPTION> Does his <INTERRUPTION> Does his management <INTERRUPTION> Does his management of <INTERRUPTION> Does his management of the <INTERRUPTION> Does his management of the housing Does his management of the housing crisis Does his management of the housing crisis had Does his management of the housing crisis had the Does his management of the housing crisis had the confidence Does his management of the housing crisis had the confidence of Does his management of the housing crisis had the confidence of his crisis had the confidence of his fellow crisis had the confidence of his fellow minister, crisis had the confidence of his fellow minister, Judith crisis had the confidence of his fellow minister, Judith Collins, crisis had the confidence of his fellow minister, Judith Collins, who fellow minister, Judith Collins, who doesn't fellow minister, Judith Collins, who doesn't he fellow minister, Judith Collins, who doesn't he want fellow minister, Judith Collins, who doesn't he want her fellow minister, Judith Collins, who doesn't he want her support, fellow minister, Judith Collins, who doesn't he want her support, given doesn't he want her support, given he doesn't he want her support, given he thinks doesn't he want her support, given he thinks she doesn't he want her support, given he thinks she has, doesn't he want her support, given he thinks she has, "An doesn't he want her support, given he thinks she has, "An unfortunately he thinks she has, "An unfortunately high he thinks she has, "An unfortunately high estimation he thinks she has, "An unfortunately high estimation of he thinks she has, "An unfortunately high estimation of her he thinks she has, "An unfortunately high estimation of her own high estimation of her own competence"? high estimation of her own competence"? <INTERRUPTION> competence"? <INTERRUPTION> Yes. competence"? <INTERRUPTION> Yes. <INTERRUPTION> Yes. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> If <INTERRUPTION> If we've <INTERRUPTION> If we've had, <INTERRUPTION> If we've had, as <INTERRUPTION> If we've had, as the <INTERRUPTION> If we've had, as the minister <INTERRUPTION> If we've had, as the minister says, If we've had, as the minister says, 30 If we've had, as the minister says, 30 years If we've had, as the minister says, 30 years of If we've had, as the minister says, 30 years of planning If we've had, as the minister says, 30 years of planning failure, If we've had, as the minister says, 30 years of planning failure, which 30 years of planning failure, which Government 30 years of planning failure, which Government was 30 years of planning failure, which Government was it 30 years of planning failure, which Government was it that 30 years of planning failure, which Government was it that brought 30 years of planning failure, which Government was it that brought in Government was it that brought in the Government was it that brought in the present Government was it that brought in the present legislation Government was it that brought in the present legislation on Government was it that brought in the present legislation on the the present legislation on the Resource the present legislation on the Resource Management the present legislation on the Resource Management Act? Resource Management Act? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, the <INTERRUPTION> Well, the member <INTERRUPTION> Well, the member would <INTERRUPTION> Well, the member would know <INTERRUPTION> Well, the member would know the Well, the member would know the answer Well, the member would know the answer to Well, the member would know the answer to that Well, the member would know the answer to that question, Well, the member would know the answer to that question, because Well, the member would know the answer to that question, because he answer to that question, because he was answer to that question, because he was here answer to that question, because he was here right answer to that question, because he was here right from answer to that question, because he was here right from the answer to that question, because he was here right from the genesis answer to that question, because he was here right from the genesis of was here right from the genesis of the was here right from the genesis of the RMA, was here right from the genesis of the RMA, under was here right from the genesis of the RMA, under Sir was here right from the genesis of the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey was here right from the genesis of the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I think, the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I think, and the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I think, and has the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I think, and has certainly the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I think, and has certainly voted the RMA, under Sir Geoffrey Palmer, I think, and has certainly voted for I think, and has certainly voted for more I think, and has certainly voted for more RMA I think, and has certainly voted for more RMA amendments I think, and has certainly voted for more RMA amendments than I think, and has certainly voted for more RMA amendments than anyone I think, and has certainly voted for more RMA amendments than anyone else more RMA amendments than anyone else in more RMA amendments than anyone else in the more RMA amendments than anyone else in the House! more RMA amendments than anyone else in the House! <INTERRUPTION> in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I just in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I just need in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I just need a in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I just need a little in the House! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I just need a little less Order! I just need a little less interjection Order! I just need a little less interjection from Order! I just need a little less interjection from both Order! I just need a little less interjection from both sides. Order! I just need a little less interjection from both sides. Does interjection from both sides. Does he interjection from both sides. Does he have interjection from both sides. Does he have confidence interjection from both sides. Does he have confidence in interjection from both sides. Does he have confidence in Paula interjection from both sides. Does he have confidence in Paula Bennett he have confidence in Paula Bennett as he have confidence in Paula Bennett as a he have confidence in Paula Bennett as a minister, he have confidence in Paula Bennett as a minister, given he have confidence in Paula Bennett as a minister, given she he have confidence in Paula Bennett as a minister, given she misled he have confidence in Paula Bennett as a minister, given she misled the as a minister, given she misled the minister as a minister, given she misled the minister about as a minister, given she misled the minister about flying as a minister, given she misled the minister about flying squads as a minister, given she misled the minister about flying squads and minister about flying squads and moved minister about flying squads and moved for minister about flying squads and moved for a minister about flying squads and moved for a policy minister about flying squads and moved for a policy to minister about flying squads and moved for a policy to move minister about flying squads and moved for a policy to move people moved for a policy to move people out moved for a policy to move people out of moved for a policy to move people out of Auckland... moved for a policy to move people out of Auckland... Order! moved for a policy to move people out of Auckland... Order! . moved for a policy to move people out of Auckland... Order! . There moved for a policy to move people out of Auckland... Order! . There is out of Auckland... Order! . There is no out of Auckland... Order! . There is no ministerial out of Auckland... Order! . There is no ministerial responsibility out of Auckland... Order! . There is no ministerial responsibility for no ministerial responsibility for that no ministerial responsibility for that as no ministerial responsibility for that as the no ministerial responsibility for that as the Minister no ministerial responsibility for that as the Minister for no ministerial responsibility for that as the Minister for Finance. that as the Minister for Finance. Does that as the Minister for Finance. Does he that as the Minister for Finance. Does he stand that as the Minister for Finance. Does he stand by that as the Minister for Finance. Does he stand by his that as the Minister for Finance. Does he stand by his statement that as the Minister for Finance. Does he stand by his statement that, Does he stand by his statement that, "I Does he stand by his statement that, "I want Does he stand by his statement that, "I want to Does he stand by his statement that, "I want to go Does he stand by his statement that, "I want to go for Does he stand by his statement that, "I want to go for the Does he stand by his statement that, "I want to go for the leadership Does he stand by his statement that, "I want to go for the leadership of "I want to go for the leadership of the "I want to go for the leadership of the National "I want to go for the leadership of the National Party "I want to go for the leadership of the National Party again"? the National Party again"? Questionable the National Party again"? Questionable whether the National Party again"? Questionable whether that the National Party again"? Questionable whether that is Questionable whether that is ministerial Questionable whether that is ministerial responsibility. Questionable whether that is ministerial responsibility. I Questionable whether that is ministerial responsibility. I will ministerial responsibility. I will allow ministerial responsibility. I will allow it. ministerial responsibility. I will allow it. Sorry? ministerial responsibility. I will allow it. Sorry? I ministerial responsibility. I will allow it. Sorry? I it ministerial responsibility. I will allow it. Sorry? I it was allow it. Sorry? I it was questionable allow it. Sorry? I it was questionable whether allow it. Sorry? I it was questionable whether there allow it. Sorry? I it was questionable whether there is questionable whether there is ministerial questionable whether there is ministerial responsibility... ministerial responsibility... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Speaker, <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Speaker, yes, <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I now Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I now find Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I now find myself Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I now find myself in Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I now find myself in the Order! Mr Speaker, yes, of course, but I now find myself in the rather but I now find myself in the rather unexpected but I now find myself in the rather unexpected position but I now find myself in the rather unexpected position where but I now find myself in the rather unexpected position where the but I now find myself in the rather unexpected position where the most unexpected position where the most successful unexpected position where the most successful PM unexpected position where the most successful PM in unexpected position where the most successful PM in my unexpected position where the most successful PM in my lifetime unexpected position where the most successful PM in my lifetime has successful PM in my lifetime has decided successful PM in my lifetime has decided to successful PM in my lifetime has decided to leave successful PM in my lifetime has decided to leave at successful PM in my lifetime has decided to leave at the successful PM in my lifetime has decided to leave at the top. decided to leave at the top. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Question <INTERRUPTION> Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 4. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Tertiary My question is to the Minister for Tertiary Education, My question is to the Minister for Tertiary Education, Skills My question is to the Minister for Tertiary Education, Skills and Tertiary Education, Skills and Employment: Employment: How Employment: How is Employment: How is the Employment: How is the Government Employment: How is the Government ensuring Employment: How is the Government ensuring New How is the Government ensuring New Zealanders How is the Government ensuring New Zealanders gain How is the Government ensuring New Zealanders gain the How is the Government ensuring New Zealanders gain the skills How is the Government ensuring New Zealanders gain the skills needed How is the Government ensuring New Zealanders gain the skills needed in Zealanders gain the skills needed in a Zealanders gain the skills needed in a growing Zealanders gain the skills needed in a growing economy? Today, Today, I Today, I released Today, I released a Today, I released a report Today, I released a report from Today, I released a report from the Today, I released a report from the Minister Today, I released a report from the Minister of Today, I released a report from the Minister of Education, Today, I released a report from the Minister of Education, which Today, I released a report from the Minister of Education, which shows Today, I released a report from the Minister of Education, which shows a Minister of Education, which shows a number Minister of Education, which shows a number of Minister of Education, which shows a number of people Minister of Education, which shows a number of people starting Minister of Education, which shows a number of people starting industry number of people starting industry training number of people starting industry training and number of people starting industry training and apprenticeships number of people starting industry training and apprenticeships grew number of people starting industry training and apprenticeships grew by training and apprenticeships grew by 11% training and apprenticeships grew by 11% last training and apprenticeships grew by 11% last year. training and apprenticeships grew by 11% last year. The training and apprenticeships grew by 11% last year. The credit training and apprenticeships grew by 11% last year. The credit completion 11% last year. The credit completion rate 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose from 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose from 69% 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose from 69% to 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose from 69% to 74% 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose from 69% to 74% and 11% last year. The credit completion rate rose from 69% to 74% and the rate rose from 69% to 74% and the qualification rate rose from 69% to 74% and the qualification completion rate rose from 69% to 74% and the qualification completion rates rate rose from 69% to 74% and the qualification completion rates are qualification completion rates are higher qualification completion rates are higher than qualification completion rates are higher than they've qualification completion rates are higher than they've ever qualification completion rates are higher than they've ever been qualification completion rates are higher than they've ever been at higher than they've ever been at 53%. higher than they've ever been at 53%. Industry higher than they've ever been at 53%. Industry training higher than they've ever been at 53%. Industry training helps higher than they've ever been at 53%. Industry training helps workers 53%. Industry training helps workers to 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep their 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep their skills 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep their skills up 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep their skills up to 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep their skills up to date 53%. Industry training helps workers to keep their skills up to date and to keep their skills up to date and provides to keep their skills up to date and provides employers to keep their skills up to date and provides employers with to keep their skills up to date and provides employers with the to keep their skills up to date and provides employers with the skilled provides employers with the skilled staff provides employers with the skilled staff they provides employers with the skilled staff they need provides employers with the skilled staff they need to provides employers with the skilled staff they need to grow provides employers with the skilled staff they need to grow their staff they need to grow their businesses. staff they need to grow their businesses. The staff they need to grow their businesses. The report, staff they need to grow their businesses. The report, which staff they need to grow their businesses. The report, which is staff they need to grow their businesses. The report, which is New businesses. The report, which is New Zealand's businesses. The report, which is New Zealand's workplace-based businesses. The report, which is New Zealand's workplace-based learners, Zealand's workplace-based learners, also Zealand's workplace-based learners, also shows Zealand's workplace-based learners, also shows that Zealand's workplace-based learners, also shows that trainees Zealand's workplace-based learners, also shows that trainees are Zealand's workplace-based learners, also shows that trainees are making also shows that trainees are making progress also shows that trainees are making progress through also shows that trainees are making progress through their also shows that trainees are making progress through their training also shows that trainees are making progress through their training much progress through their training much more progress through their training much more quickly progress through their training much more quickly than progress through their training much more quickly than in progress through their training much more quickly than in previous progress through their training much more quickly than in previous years. more quickly than in previous years. This more quickly than in previous years. This is more quickly than in previous years. This is a more quickly than in previous years. This is a big more quickly than in previous years. This is a big change, more quickly than in previous years. This is a big change, for more quickly than in previous years. This is a big change, for example, This is a big change, for example, from This is a big change, for example, from 2009, This is a big change, for example, from 2009, where This is a big change, for example, from 2009, where 59% This is a big change, for example, from 2009, where 59% of This is a big change, for example, from 2009, where 59% of trainees from 2009, where 59% of trainees gained from 2009, where 59% of trainees gained no from 2009, where 59% of trainees gained no credits from 2009, where 59% of trainees gained no credits at from 2009, where 59% of trainees gained no credits at all. gained no credits at all. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! To <INTERRUPTION> Order! To the <INTERRUPTION> Order! To the minister: <INTERRUPTION> Order! To the minister: What <INTERRUPTION> Order! To the minister: What other Order! To the minister: What other steps Order! To the minister: What other steps is Order! To the minister: What other steps is the Order! To the minister: What other steps is the Government Order! To the minister: What other steps is the Government taking Order! To the minister: What other steps is the Government taking to steps is the Government taking to increase steps is the Government taking to increase the steps is the Government taking to increase the number steps is the Government taking to increase the number of steps is the Government taking to increase the number of people steps is the Government taking to increase the number of people in increase the number of people in apprenticeships? increase the number of people in apprenticeships? Last increase the number of people in apprenticeships? Last month, increase the number of people in apprenticeships? Last month, I apprenticeships? Last month, I announced apprenticeships? Last month, I announced a apprenticeships? Last month, I announced a new apprenticeships? Last month, I announced a new target apprenticeships? Last month, I announced a new target of apprenticeships? Last month, I announced a new target of 50,000 announced a new target of 50,000 people announced a new target of 50,000 people in announced a new target of 50,000 people in training announced a new target of 50,000 people in training and people in training and apprenticeships people in training and apprenticeships by people in training and apprenticeships by 2020, people in training and apprenticeships by 2020, up people in training and apprenticeships by 2020, up from apprenticeships by 2020, up from 42,000 apprenticeships by 2020, up from 42,000 people. apprenticeships by 2020, up from 42,000 people. The apprenticeships by 2020, up from 42,000 people. The report apprenticeships by 2020, up from 42,000 people. The report released 42,000 people. The report released today 42,000 people. The report released today highlights 42,000 people. The report released today highlights the 42,000 people. The report released today highlights the number 42,000 people. The report released today highlights the number of today highlights the number of people today highlights the number of people in today highlights the number of people in apprenticeships today highlights the number of people in apprenticeships grew today highlights the number of people in apprenticeships grew by people in apprenticeships grew by 12% people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over the people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over the last people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over the last two people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over the last two years. people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over the last two years. In people in apprenticeships grew by 12% over the last two years. In a 12% over the last two years. In a strong 12% over the last two years. In a strong economy, 12% over the last two years. In a strong economy, more 12% over the last two years. In a strong economy, more employers 12% over the last two years. In a strong economy, more employers have strong economy, more employers have the strong economy, more employers have the confidence strong economy, more employers have the confidence to strong economy, more employers have the confidence to hire strong economy, more employers have the confidence to hire and strong economy, more employers have the confidence to hire and train the confidence to hire and train apprentices the confidence to hire and train apprentices to the confidence to hire and train apprentices to meet the confidence to hire and train apprentices to meet their the confidence to hire and train apprentices to meet their future apprentices to meet their future skill apprentices to meet their future skill needs. apprentices to meet their future skill needs. This apprentices to meet their future skill needs. This target apprentices to meet their future skill needs. This target signals skill needs. This target signals that skill needs. This target signals that we'll skill needs. This target signals that we'll back skill needs. This target signals that we'll back employers skill needs. This target signals that we'll back employers and that we'll back employers and industry that we'll back employers and industry training that we'll back employers and industry training organisations that we'll back employers and industry training organisations as industry training organisations as they industry training organisations as they grow industry training organisations as they grow their industry training organisations as they grow their apprenticeship they grow their apprenticeship numbers they grow their apprenticeship numbers further they grow their apprenticeship numbers further and they grow their apprenticeship numbers further and we're they grow their apprenticeship numbers further and we're backing numbers further and we're backing that numbers further and we're backing that with numbers further and we're backing that with a numbers further and we're backing that with a further numbers further and we're backing that with a further investment numbers further and we're backing that with a further investment $10 that with a further investment $10 million that with a further investment $10 million and that with a further investment $10 million and have that with a further investment $10 million and have capacity that with a further investment $10 million and have capacity to that with a further investment $10 million and have capacity to add million and have capacity to add further million and have capacity to add further places million and have capacity to add further places during million and have capacity to add further places during the million and have capacity to add further places during the next million and have capacity to add further places during the next year, further places during the next year, if further places during the next year, if demand further places during the next year, if demand requires. further places during the next year, if demand requires. How further places during the next year, if demand requires. How is further places during the next year, if demand requires. How is the if demand requires. How is the Government if demand requires. How is the Government linking if demand requires. How is the Government linking skills if demand requires. How is the Government linking skills training Government linking skills training to Government linking skills training to employment? Government linking skills training to employment? Well, Government linking skills training to employment? Well, last Government linking skills training to employment? Well, last month, Government linking skills training to employment? Well, last month, Hon to employment? Well, last month, Hon Anne to employment? Well, last month, Hon Anne Tolley to employment? Well, last month, Hon Anne Tolley and to employment? Well, last month, Hon Anne Tolley and I to employment? Well, last month, Hon Anne Tolley and I announced to employment? Well, last month, Hon Anne Tolley and I announced two Anne Tolley and I announced two further Anne Tolley and I announced two further jobs Anne Tolley and I announced two further jobs and Anne Tolley and I announced two further jobs and skills Anne Tolley and I announced two further jobs and skills hubs Anne Tolley and I announced two further jobs and skills hubs in further jobs and skills hubs in Auckland, further jobs and skills hubs in Auckland, based further jobs and skills hubs in Auckland, based on further jobs and skills hubs in Auckland, based on the further jobs and skills hubs in Auckland, based on the successful Auckland, based on the successful ARA Auckland, based on the successful ARA skills Auckland, based on the successful ARA skills exchange Auckland, based on the successful ARA skills exchange at Auckland, based on the successful ARA skills exchange at Auckland ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. This ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. This is ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. This is being ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. This is being run ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. This is being run as ARA skills exchange at Auckland Airport. This is being run as a Airport. This is being run as a partnership Airport. This is being run as a partnership between Airport. This is being run as a partnership between central Airport. This is being run as a partnership between central and partnership between central and local partnership between central and local government, partnership between central and local government, business partnership between central and local government, business and local government, business and tertiary local government, business and tertiary providers, local government, business and tertiary providers, and local government, business and tertiary providers, and ATOs. local government, business and tertiary providers, and ATOs. The tertiary providers, and ATOs. The hub tertiary providers, and ATOs. The hub set tertiary providers, and ATOs. The hub set up tertiary providers, and ATOs. The hub set up training tertiary providers, and ATOs. The hub set up training and tertiary providers, and ATOs. The hub set up training and services hub set up training and services facilities hub set up training and services facilities at hub set up training and services facilities at the hub set up training and services facilities at the centres hub set up training and services facilities at the centres of hub set up training and services facilities at the centres of big facilities at the centres of big areas facilities at the centres of big areas of facilities at the centres of big areas of work facilities at the centres of big areas of work and facilities at the centres of big areas of work and construction, areas of work and construction, where areas of work and construction, where there areas of work and construction, where there are areas of work and construction, where there are sizeable areas of work and construction, where there are sizeable projects where there are sizeable projects with where there are sizeable projects with jobs where there are sizeable projects with jobs and where there are sizeable projects with jobs and opportunities. where there are sizeable projects with jobs and opportunities. These with jobs and opportunities. These two with jobs and opportunities. These two will with jobs and opportunities. These two will be with jobs and opportunities. These two will be based with jobs and opportunities. These two will be based at with jobs and opportunities. These two will be based at the with jobs and opportunities. These two will be based at the win with jobs and opportunities. These two will be based at the win yard two will be based at the win yard Quarter two will be based at the win yard Quarter and two will be based at the win yard Quarter and Tamaki two will be based at the win yard Quarter and Tamaki and two will be based at the win yard Quarter and Tamaki and they two will be based at the win yard Quarter and Tamaki and they will Quarter and Tamaki and they will give Quarter and Tamaki and they will give young Quarter and Tamaki and they will give young people Quarter and Tamaki and they will give young people a Quarter and Tamaki and they will give young people a pathway Quarter and Tamaki and they will give young people a pathway to give young people a pathway to employment give young people a pathway to employment in give young people a pathway to employment in the give young people a pathway to employment in the construction employment in the construction sector, employment in the construction sector, as employment in the construction sector, as well employment in the construction sector, as well as employment in the construction sector, as well as onlight employment in the construction sector, as well as onlight numeracy, sector, as well as onlight numeracy, literacy sector, as well as onlight numeracy, literacy and sector, as well as onlight numeracy, literacy and practical sector, as well as onlight numeracy, literacy and practical skills literacy and practical skills training. literacy and practical skills training. With literacy and practical skills training. With the literacy and practical skills training. With the economy literacy and practical skills training. With the economy growing training. With the economy growing strongly training. With the economy growing strongly and training. With the economy growing strongly and unemployment training. With the economy growing strongly and unemployment down, training. With the economy growing strongly and unemployment down, we strongly and unemployment down, we have strongly and unemployment down, we have the strongly and unemployment down, we have the opportunity strongly and unemployment down, we have the opportunity to strongly and unemployment down, we have the opportunity to bring strongly and unemployment down, we have the opportunity to bring more have the opportunity to bring more young have the opportunity to bring more young people have the opportunity to bring more young people who have the opportunity to bring more young people who have have the opportunity to bring more young people who have been have the opportunity to bring more young people who have been long-term young people who have been long-term unemployed young people who have been long-term unemployed into young people who have been long-term unemployed into work young people who have been long-term unemployed into work - young people who have been long-term unemployed into work - and young people who have been long-term unemployed into work - and that's unemployed into work - and that's what unemployed into work - and that's what these unemployed into work - and that's what these hubs unemployed into work - and that's what these hubs will unemployed into work - and that's what these hubs will do. unemployed into work - and that's what these hubs will do. Question what these hubs will do. Question No. what these hubs will do. Question No. 5. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: I I like I like his I like his new I like his new suit, I like his new suit, too, I like his new suit, too, Mr I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, and I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, and his I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, and his new I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, and his new tie! I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, and his new tie! And I like his new suit, too, Mr Speaker, and his new tie! And well Speaker, and his new tie! And well you Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, but Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, but that Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, but that is Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, but that is not Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, but that is not part Speaker, and his new tie! And well you might, but that is not part of you might, but that is not part of Oral you might, but that is not part of Oral Questions! My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: Health: Does Health: Does he Health: Does he expect Health: Does he expect an Health: Does he expect an estimated Does he expect an estimated 533,000 Does he expect an estimated 533,000 New Does he expect an estimated 533,000 New Zealanders Does he expect an estimated 533,000 New Zealanders who Does he expect an estimated 533,000 New Zealanders who did Does he expect an estimated 533,000 New Zealanders who did not 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP due 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP due to 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP due to cost 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP due to cost in 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP due to cost in the 533,000 New Zealanders who did not visit a GP due to cost in the last visit a GP due to cost in the last year visit a GP due to cost in the last year to visit a GP due to cost in the last year to continue visit a GP due to cost in the last year to continue to visit a GP due to cost in the last year to continue to wait visit a GP due to cost in the last year to continue to wait for visit a GP due to cost in the last year to continue to wait for primary year to continue to wait for primary care year to continue to wait for primary care reform year to continue to wait for primary care reform which year to continue to wait for primary care reform which might year to continue to wait for primary care reform which might "form year to continue to wait for primary care reform which might "form part care reform which might "form part of care reform which might "form part of a care reform which might "form part of a future care reform which might "form part of a future Budget", care reform which might "form part of a future Budget", possibly care reform which might "form part of a future Budget", possibly under of a future Budget", possibly under a of a future Budget", possibly under a different of a future Budget", possibly under a different health of a future Budget", possibly under a different health Minister of a future Budget", possibly under a different health Minister as a different health Minister as stated a different health Minister as stated by a different health Minister as stated by him? No. No. GPs No. GPs charge No. GPs charge different No. GPs charge different rates No. GPs charge different rates and No. GPs charge different rates and people No. GPs charge different rates and people have No. GPs charge different rates and people have the No. GPs charge different rates and people have the right No. GPs charge different rates and people have the right to No. GPs charge different rates and people have the right to seek No. GPs charge different rates and people have the right to seek out No. GPs charge different rates and people have the right to seek out a people have the right to seek out a doctor people have the right to seek out a doctor whose people have the right to seek out a doctor whose combination people have the right to seek out a doctor whose combination of people have the right to seek out a doctor whose combination of service, doctor whose combination of service, approach doctor whose combination of service, approach and doctor whose combination of service, approach and pricing doctor whose combination of service, approach and pricing are doctor whose combination of service, approach and pricing are right doctor whose combination of service, approach and pricing are right for approach and pricing are right for them. approach and pricing are right for them. Furthermore, approach and pricing are right for them. Furthermore, very approach and pricing are right for them. Furthermore, very good approach and pricing are right for them. Furthermore, very good work approach and pricing are right for them. Furthermore, very good work is them. Furthermore, very good work is underway them. Furthermore, very good work is underway to them. Furthermore, very good work is underway to continue them. Furthermore, very good work is underway to continue to them. Furthermore, very good work is underway to continue to ensure them. Furthermore, very good work is underway to continue to ensure that underway to continue to ensure that subsidies underway to continue to ensure that subsidies reach underway to continue to ensure that subsidies reach those underway to continue to ensure that subsidies reach those most underway to continue to ensure that subsidies reach those most in underway to continue to ensure that subsidies reach those most in need. subsidies reach those most in need. In subsidies reach those most in need. In the subsidies reach those most in need. In the meantime, subsidies reach those most in need. In the meantime, here's subsidies reach those most in need. In the meantime, here's some subsidies reach those most in need. In the meantime, here's some good In the meantime, here's some good news In the meantime, here's some good news to In the meantime, here's some good news to cheer In the meantime, here's some good news to cheer the In the meantime, here's some good news to cheer the member In the meantime, here's some good news to cheer the member up In the meantime, here's some good news to cheer the member up - news to cheer the member up - affordability news to cheer the member up - affordability of news to cheer the member up - affordability of prescriptions news to cheer the member up - affordability of prescriptions and affordability of prescriptions and after-hours affordability of prescriptions and after-hours care affordability of prescriptions and after-hours care for affordability of prescriptions and after-hours care for kids affordability of prescriptions and after-hours care for kids has affordability of prescriptions and after-hours care for kids has been after-hours care for kids has been removed after-hours care for kids has been removed as after-hours care for kids has been removed as an after-hours care for kids has been removed as an issue after-hours care for kids has been removed as an issue because after-hours care for kids has been removed as an issue because of after-hours care for kids has been removed as an issue because of the removed as an issue because of the fantastic removed as an issue because of the fantastic free removed as an issue because of the fantastic free under-13s removed as an issue because of the fantastic free under-13s policy fantastic free under-13s policy which fantastic free under-13s policy which started fantastic free under-13s policy which started on fantastic free under-13s policy which started on 1 fantastic free under-13s policy which started on 1 July fantastic free under-13s policy which started on 1 July last fantastic free under-13s policy which started on 1 July last year. fantastic free under-13s policy which started on 1 July last year. I which started on 1 July last year. I thank which started on 1 July last year. I thank the which started on 1 July last year. I thank the member which started on 1 July last year. I thank the member for which started on 1 July last year. I thank the member for her which started on 1 July last year. I thank the member for her continued thank the member for her continued support thank the member for her continued support and thank the member for her continued support and advocacy thank the member for her continued support and advocacy for thank the member for her continued support and advocacy for this support and advocacy for this policy. support and advocacy for this policy. <INTERRUPTION> policy. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! Why Order! Why should Order! Why should New Order! Why should New Zealanders Order! Why should New Zealanders have Order! Why should New Zealanders have to Why should New Zealanders have to bear Why should New Zealanders have to bear the Why should New Zealanders have to bear the burden Why should New Zealanders have to bear the burden of Why should New Zealanders have to bear the burden of the Why should New Zealanders have to bear the burden of the $250 Why should New Zealanders have to bear the burden of the $250 million bear the burden of the $250 million accumulated bear the burden of the $250 million accumulated shortfall bear the burden of the $250 million accumulated shortfall in bear the burden of the $250 million accumulated shortfall in primary accumulated shortfall in primary healthcare accumulated shortfall in primary healthcare funding, accumulated shortfall in primary healthcare funding, leading accumulated shortfall in primary healthcare funding, leading to healthcare funding, leading to hundreds healthcare funding, leading to hundreds and healthcare funding, leading to hundreds and thousands healthcare funding, leading to hundreds and thousands of healthcare funding, leading to hundreds and thousands of sick hundreds and thousands of sick people hundreds and thousands of sick people unable hundreds and thousands of sick people unable to hundreds and thousands of sick people unable to afford hundreds and thousands of sick people unable to afford a hundreds and thousands of sick people unable to afford a doctor's people unable to afford a doctor's visit, people unable to afford a doctor's visit, because people unable to afford a doctor's visit, because he people unable to afford a doctor's visit, because he is people unable to afford a doctor's visit, because he is not people unable to afford a doctor's visit, because he is not an visit, because he is not an effectual visit, because he is not an effectual Minister visit, because he is not an effectual Minister of visit, because he is not an effectual Minister of Health, visit, because he is not an effectual Minister of Health, let effectual Minister of Health, let alone effectual Minister of Health, let alone any effectual Minister of Health, let alone any other effectual Minister of Health, let alone any other role effectual Minister of Health, let alone any other role he effectual Minister of Health, let alone any other role he might effectual Minister of Health, let alone any other role he might fancy? alone any other role he might fancy? Well, alone any other role he might fancy? Well, I alone any other role he might fancy? Well, I will alone any other role he might fancy? Well, I will leave alone any other role he might fancy? Well, I will leave that alone any other role he might fancy? Well, I will leave that for alone any other role he might fancy? Well, I will leave that for the Well, I will leave that for the member Well, I will leave that for the member to Well, I will leave that for the member to comment Well, I will leave that for the member to comment on. Well, I will leave that for the member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> Frankly, member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> Frankly, primary member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> Frankly, primary care member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> Frankly, primary care funding member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> Frankly, primary care funding is member to comment on. <INTERRUPTION> Frankly, primary care funding is up Frankly, primary care funding is up $230 Frankly, primary care funding is up $230 million Frankly, primary care funding is up $230 million under Frankly, primary care funding is up $230 million under this Frankly, primary care funding is up $230 million under this Government, $230 million under this Government, to $230 million under this Government, to nearly $230 million under this Government, to nearly $900 $230 million under this Government, to nearly $900 million. $230 million under this Government, to nearly $900 million. And $230 million under this Government, to nearly $900 million. And there to nearly $900 million. And there was to nearly $900 million. And there was a to nearly $900 million. And there was a further to nearly $900 million. And there was a further $25 to nearly $900 million. And there was a further $25 million to nearly $900 million. And there was a further $25 million in to nearly $900 million. And there was a further $25 million in this was a further $25 million in this budget, was a further $25 million in this budget, so was a further $25 million in this budget, so to was a further $25 million in this budget, so to make was a further $25 million in this budget, so to make those was a further $25 million in this budget, so to make those claims was a further $25 million in this budget, so to make those claims of budget, so to make those claims of some budget, so to make those claims of some missing budget, so to make those claims of some missing amount, budget, so to make those claims of some missing amount, that's budget, so to make those claims of some missing amount, that's pierl some missing amount, that's pierl fiction. some missing amount, that's pierl fiction. -- some missing amount, that's pierl fiction. -- purely some missing amount, that's pierl fiction. -- purely fiction some missing amount, that's pierl fiction. -- purely fiction Order! fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've asked fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've asked for fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've asked for a fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've asked for a bit fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've asked for a bit of fiction. -- purely fiction Order! I've asked for a bit of cooperation I've asked for a bit of cooperation on I've asked for a bit of cooperation on this I've asked for a bit of cooperation on this side. I've asked for a bit of cooperation on this side. If I've asked for a bit of cooperation on this side. If Mr I've asked for a bit of cooperation on this side. If Mr Faafoi I've asked for a bit of cooperation on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, I on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, I will on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, I will have on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, I will have to on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, I will have to ask on this side. If Mr Faafoi continues to interject, I will have to ask him to interject, I will have to ask him to to interject, I will have to ask him to leave. to interject, I will have to ask him to leave. Point to interject, I will have to ask him to leave. Point of to interject, I will have to ask him to leave. Point of order, to interject, I will have to ask him to leave. Point of order, the to interject, I will have to ask him to leave. Point of order, the Hon to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette King. to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette King. I to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette King. I seek to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette King. I seek leave to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette King. I seek leave to to leave. Point of order, the Hon Annette King. I seek leave to table Annette King. I seek leave to table a Annette King. I seek leave to table a document Annette King. I seek leave to table a document provided Annette King. I seek leave to table a document provided to Annette King. I seek leave to table a document provided to me Annette King. I seek leave to table a document provided to me today Annette King. I seek leave to table a document provided to me today by a document provided to me today by the a document provided to me today by the NZMA a document provided to me today by the NZMA GP a document provided to me today by the NZMA GP Council a document provided to me today by the NZMA GP Council showing a document provided to me today by the NZMA GP Council showing the a document provided to me today by the NZMA GP Council showing the $250 the NZMA GP Council showing the $250 million the NZMA GP Council showing the $250 million accumulated the NZMA GP Council showing the $250 million accumulated shortfall the NZMA GP Council showing the $250 million accumulated shortfall in million accumulated shortfall in primary million accumulated shortfall in primary care million accumulated shortfall in primary care Leave million accumulated shortfall in primary care Leave is million accumulated shortfall in primary care Leave is sought million accumulated shortfall in primary care Leave is sought to primary care Leave is sought to table primary care Leave is sought to table that primary care Leave is sought to table that particular primary care Leave is sought to table that particular information table that particular information from table that particular information from NZMA table that particular information from NZMA - table that particular information from NZMA - is table that particular information from NZMA - is there table that particular information from NZMA - is there any table that particular information from NZMA - is there any objection from NZMA - is there any objection to from NZMA - is there any objection to it from NZMA - is there any objection to it being from NZMA - is there any objection to it being tabled? from NZMA - is there any objection to it being tabled? There from NZMA - is there any objection to it being tabled? There is from NZMA - is there any objection to it being tabled? There is none, to it being tabled? There is none, it to it being tabled? There is none, it can to it being tabled? There is none, it can be to it being tabled? There is none, it can be tabled. to it being tabled? There is none, it can be tabled. If to it being tabled? There is none, it can be tabled. If he to it being tabled? There is none, it can be tabled. If he is to it being tabled? There is none, it can be tabled. If he is capable it can be tabled. If he is capable of it can be tabled. If he is capable of showing it can be tabled. If he is capable of showing leadership, it can be tabled. If he is capable of showing leadership, why it can be tabled. If he is capable of showing leadership, why doesn't of showing leadership, why doesn't he of showing leadership, why doesn't he take of showing leadership, why doesn't he take responsibility of showing leadership, why doesn't he take responsibility for of showing leadership, why doesn't he take responsibility for the he take responsibility for the growing he take responsibility for the growing number he take responsibility for the growing number of he take responsibility for the growing number of failures he take responsibility for the growing number of failures in growing number of failures in health, growing number of failures in health, leading growing number of failures in health, leading to growing number of failures in health, leading to headlines growing number of failures in health, leading to headlines such growing number of failures in health, leading to headlines such as health, leading to headlines such as staff health, leading to headlines such as staff shortages, health, leading to headlines such as staff shortages, forced health, leading to headlines such as staff shortages, forced closure health, leading to headlines such as staff shortages, forced closure of staff shortages, forced closure of beds, staff shortages, forced closure of beds, overworked staff shortages, forced closure of beds, overworked doctors staff shortages, forced closure of beds, overworked doctors make beds, overworked doctors make mistakes, beds, overworked doctors make mistakes, surgeons beds, overworked doctors make mistakes, surgeons fear beds, overworked doctors make mistakes, surgeons fear for beds, overworked doctors make mistakes, surgeons fear for patient mistakes, surgeons fear for patient safety, mistakes, surgeons fear for patient safety, budget mistakes, surgeons fear for patient safety, budget pressures safety, budget pressures unmanageable safety, budget pressures unmanageable - safety, budget pressures unmanageable - things safety, budget pressures unmanageable - things that safety, budget pressures unmanageable - things that would unmanageable - things that would never unmanageable - things that would never have unmanageable - things that would never have happened unmanageable - things that would never have happened under unmanageable - things that would never have happened under Tony unmanageable - things that would never have happened under Tony Rile? We We had We had a We had a long We had a long discussion We had a long discussion on We had a long discussion on failures We had a long discussion on failures in We had a long discussion on failures in health We had a long discussion on failures in health last We had a long discussion on failures in health last Thursday We had a long discussion on failures in health last Thursday and We had a long discussion on failures in health last Thursday and I'm We had a long discussion on failures in health last Thursday and I'm sure in health last Thursday and I'm sure the in health last Thursday and I'm sure the member in health last Thursday and I'm sure the member wouldn't in health last Thursday and I'm sure the member wouldn't want in health last Thursday and I'm sure the member wouldn't want to in health last Thursday and I'm sure the member wouldn't want to go in health last Thursday and I'm sure the member wouldn't want to go there the member wouldn't want to go there again. the member wouldn't want to go there again. But the member wouldn't want to go there again. But the the member wouldn't want to go there again. But the fact the member wouldn't want to go there again. But the fact is, the member wouldn't want to go there again. But the fact is, an the member wouldn't want to go there again. But the fact is, an extra again. But the fact is, an extra $2.2 again. But the fact is, an extra $2.2 billion again. But the fact is, an extra $2.2 billion put again. But the fact is, an extra $2.2 billion put into again. But the fact is, an extra $2.2 billion put into the again. But the fact is, an extra $2.2 billion put into the health $2.2 billion put into the health budget $2.2 billion put into the health budget at $2.2 billion put into the health budget at the $2.2 billion put into the health budget at the last $2.2 billion put into the health budget at the last budget $2.2 billion put into the health budget at the last budget and budget at the last budget and there's budget at the last budget and there's a budget at the last budget and there's a clear budget at the last budget and there's a clear record budget at the last budget and there's a clear record of budget at the last budget and there's a clear record of continued there's a clear record of continued rises there's a clear record of continued rises in there's a clear record of continued rises in appointments, there's a clear record of continued rises in appointments, more rises in appointments, more operations, rises in appointments, more operations, 6,000 rises in appointments, more operations, 6,000 more rises in appointments, more operations, 6,000 more doctors rises in appointments, more operations, 6,000 more doctors and operations, 6,000 more doctors and nurses operations, 6,000 more doctors and nurses and operations, 6,000 more doctors and nurses and the operations, 6,000 more doctors and nurses and the member operations, 6,000 more doctors and nurses and the member struggles operations, 6,000 more doctors and nurses and the member struggles to nurses and the member struggles to name nurses and the member struggles to name one nurses and the member struggles to name one single nurses and the member struggles to name one single service nurses and the member struggles to name one single service that nurses and the member struggles to name one single service that hasn't name one single service that hasn't improved name one single service that hasn't improved over name one single service that hasn't improved over the name one single service that hasn't improved over the last name one single service that hasn't improved over the last eight name one single service that hasn't improved over the last eight years, improved over the last eight years, and improved over the last eight years, and that's improved over the last eight years, and that's the improved over the last eight years, and that's the fact improved over the last eight years, and that's the fact of improved over the last eight years, and that's the fact of it. and that's the fact of it. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Is <INTERRUPTION> Is the <INTERRUPTION> Is the reason <INTERRUPTION> Is the reason the <INTERRUPTION> Is the reason the New <INTERRUPTION> Is the reason the New Zealand <INTERRUPTION> Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor magazine Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor magazine called Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor magazine called him Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor magazine called him Dr Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor magazine called him Dr Who? Is the reason the New Zealand Doctor magazine called him Dr Who? Missing magazine called him Dr Who? Missing in magazine called him Dr Who? Missing in Action. magazine called him Dr Who? Missing in Action. To magazine called him Dr Who? Missing in Action. To the magazine called him Dr Who? Missing in Action. To the Bedside magazine called him Dr Who? Missing in Action. To the Bedside Manor in Action. To the Bedside Manor Born! in Action. To the Bedside Manor Born! And in Action. To the Bedside Manor Born! And AKADoc in Action. To the Bedside Manor Born! And AKADoc Martin! in Action. To the Bedside Manor Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because in Action. To the Bedside Manor Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is too Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is too focused Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is too focused on Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is too focused on his Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is too focused on his own Born! And AKADoc Martin! Because he is too focused on his own career is too focused on his own career prospects is too focused on his own career prospects rather is too focused on his own career prospects rather than is too focused on his own career prospects rather than fixing is too focused on his own career prospects rather than fixing up is too focused on his own career prospects rather than fixing up the prospects rather than fixing up the stuff-up prospects rather than fixing up the stuff-up in prospects rather than fixing up the stuff-up in health prospects rather than fixing up the stuff-up in health which prospects rather than fixing up the stuff-up in health which is prospects rather than fixing up the stuff-up in health which is leading stuff-up in health which is leading to stuff-up in health which is leading to people stuff-up in health which is leading to people missing stuff-up in health which is leading to people missing out stuff-up in health which is leading to people missing out on stuff-up in health which is leading to people missing out on the stuff-up in health which is leading to people missing out on the care to people missing out on the care they to people missing out on the care they need? to people missing out on the care they need? Maybe to people missing out on the care they need? Maybe they to people missing out on the care they need? Maybe they call to people missing out on the care they need? Maybe they call me to people missing out on the care they need? Maybe they call me that they need? Maybe they call me that because they need? Maybe they call me that because I they need? Maybe they call me that because I actual they need? Maybe they call me that because I actual Liam they need? Maybe they call me that because I actual Liam a they need? Maybe they call me that because I actual Liam a doctor! they need? Maybe they call me that because I actual Liam a doctor! But because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, the because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, the fact because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, the fact is because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, the fact is that... because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, the fact is that... It because I actual Liam a doctor! But look, the fact is that... It says look, the fact is that... It says all look, the fact is that... It says all sorts look, the fact is that... It says all sorts of look, the fact is that... It says all sorts of things look, the fact is that... It says all sorts of things about look, the fact is that... It says all sorts of things about all look, the fact is that... It says all sorts of things about all sorts all sorts of things about all sorts of all sorts of things about all sorts of people all sorts of things about all sorts of people and all sorts of things about all sorts of people and I all sorts of things about all sorts of people and I want all sorts of things about all sorts of people and I want to all sorts of things about all sorts of people and I want to tell all sorts of things about all sorts of people and I want to tell you, of people and I want to tell you, they of people and I want to tell you, they say of people and I want to tell you, they say some of people and I want to tell you, they say some pretty of people and I want to tell you, they say some pretty interesting they say some pretty interesting things they say some pretty interesting things about they say some pretty interesting things about that they say some pretty interesting things about that member they say some pretty interesting things about that member there they say some pretty interesting things about that member there as things about that member there as well! things about that member there as well! They things about that member there as well! They certainly things about that member there as well! They certainly do, things about that member there as well! They certainly do, Mr things about that member there as well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most of well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most of them well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most of them nice! well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most of them nice! Point well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most of them nice! Point of well! They certainly do, Mr Speaker! Most of them nice! Point of order, Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Speaker. Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Speaker. Order! Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Speaker. Order! I Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Speaker. Order! I seek Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave Most of them nice! Point of order, Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave to Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave to table Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave to table the Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave to table the New Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave to table the New Zealand Mr Speaker. Order! I seek leave to table the New Zealand Doctor table the New Zealand Doctor Magazine, table the New Zealand Doctor Magazine, 22 table the New Zealand Doctor Magazine, 22 June table the New Zealand Doctor Magazine, 22 June this table the New Zealand Doctor Magazine, 22 June this year, table the New Zealand Doctor Magazine, 22 June this year, headed Magazine, 22 June this year, headed to Magazine, 22 June this year, headed to the Magazine, 22 June this year, headed to the Bedside Magazine, 22 June this year, headed to the Bedside Manor Magazine, 22 June this year, headed to the Bedside Manor Bar, Magazine, 22 June this year, headed to the Bedside Manor Bar, quoting to the Bedside Manor Bar, quoting Doc to the Bedside Manor Bar, quoting Doc Martin. to the Bedside Manor Bar, quoting Doc Martin. Order! to the Bedside Manor Bar, quoting Doc Martin. Order! It's to the Bedside Manor Bar, quoting Doc Martin. Order! It's been Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. I'll Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. I'll put Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. I'll put the Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. I'll put the leave Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. I'll put the leave on Doc Martin. Order! It's been described. I'll put the leave on the described. I'll put the leave on the basis described. I'll put the leave on the basis that described. I'll put the leave on the basis that it described. I'll put the leave on the basis that it may described. I'll put the leave on the basis that it may not described. I'll put the leave on the basis that it may not be described. I'll put the leave on the basis that it may not be readily basis that it may not be readily available basis that it may not be readily available to basis that it may not be readily available to members. basis that it may not be readily available to members. Leave basis that it may not be readily available to members. Leave a basis that it may not be readily available to members. Leave a sort available to members. Leave a sort to available to members. Leave a sort to table available to members. Leave a sort to table that available to members. Leave a sort to table that particular available to members. Leave a sort to table that particular article. available to members. Leave a sort to table that particular article. Is to table that particular article. Is there to table that particular article. Is there any to table that particular article. Is there any objection? there any objection? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> No, <INTERRUPTION> No, I <INTERRUPTION> No, I health <INTERRUPTION> No, I health it <INTERRUPTION> No, I health it up <INTERRUPTION> No, I health it up for <INTERRUPTION> No, I health it up for you. <INTERRUPTION> No, I health it up for you. Order! No, I health it up for you. Order! I've No, I health it up for you. Order! I've got No, I health it up for you. Order! I've got another No, I health it up for you. Order! I've got another supplementary, No, I health it up for you. Order! I've got another supplementary, Mr I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has he I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has he got I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has he got what I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has he got what it I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has he got what it takes I've got another supplementary, Mr Speaker. Has he got what it takes to Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a leader Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a leader when Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a leader when he Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a leader when he ignores Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a leader when he ignores one Speaker. Has he got what it takes to be a leader when he ignores one of be a leader when he ignores one of the be a leader when he ignores one of the biggest be a leader when he ignores one of the biggest GP be a leader when he ignores one of the biggest GP organisations be a leader when he ignores one of the biggest GP organisations which the biggest GP organisations which says the biggest GP organisations which says that the biggest GP organisations which says that they the biggest GP organisations which says that they have the biggest GP organisations which says that they have brought the biggest GP organisations which says that they have brought the the biggest GP organisations which says that they have brought the lack says that they have brought the lack of says that they have brought the lack of access says that they have brought the lack of access for says that they have brought the lack of access for New says that they have brought the lack of access for New Zealanders says that they have brought the lack of access for New Zealanders to of access for New Zealanders to visit of access for New Zealanders to visit their of access for New Zealanders to visit their GP of access for New Zealanders to visit their GP to of access for New Zealanders to visit their GP to his of access for New Zealanders to visit their GP to his attention, of access for New Zealanders to visit their GP to his attention, but visit their GP to his attention, but his visit their GP to his attention, but his response visit their GP to his attention, but his response to visit their GP to his attention, but his response to them visit their GP to his attention, but his response to them was, visit their GP to his attention, but his response to them was, "That's his response to them was, "That's just his response to them was, "That's just rhetoric". his response to them was, "That's just rhetoric". Well, his response to them was, "That's just rhetoric". Well, of his response to them was, "That's just rhetoric". Well, of course, just rhetoric". Well, of course, very just rhetoric". Well, of course, very low just rhetoric". Well, of course, very low cost just rhetoric". Well, of course, very low cost access just rhetoric". Well, of course, very low cost access funding just rhetoric". Well, of course, very low cost access funding is just rhetoric". Well, of course, very low cost access funding is a very low cost access funding is a Rob very low cost access funding is a Rob we very low cost access funding is a Rob we inherited very low cost access funding is a Rob we inherited from very low cost access funding is a Rob we inherited from Mrs very low cost access funding is a Rob we inherited from Mrs King, very low cost access funding is a Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if she's Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if she's so Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if she's so popular Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if she's so popular with Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if she's so popular with GP Rob we inherited from Mrs King, but if she's so popular with GP leader, if she's so popular with GP leader, I if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder why if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder why they if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder why they didn't if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder why they didn't send if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder why they didn't send her if she's so popular with GP leader, I wonder why they didn't send her an I wonder why they didn't send her an invitation I wonder why they didn't send her an invitation to I wonder why they didn't send her an invitation to the I wonder why they didn't send her an invitation to the College I wonder why they didn't send her an invitation to the College of I wonder why they didn't send her an invitation to the College of GP's invitation to the College of GP's big invitation to the College of GP's big launch invitation to the College of GP's big launch on invitation to the College of GP's big launch on Thursday, invitation to the College of GP's big launch on Thursday, but invitation to the College of GP's big launch on Thursday, but maybe big launch on Thursday, but maybe she big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just too big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just too busy big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just too busy to big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just too busy to deal big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just too busy to deal with big launch on Thursday, but maybe she just too busy to deal with them she just too busy to deal with them and she just too busy to deal with them and turn she just too busy to deal with them and turn up. and turn up. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order. Order. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order. Order. Question <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order. Order. Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order. Order. Question No. 6. My My question My question to My question to the My question to the Minister My question to the Minister of My question to the Minister of Transport: Transport: What Transport: What progress Transport: What progress has Transport: What progress has the What progress has the Government What progress has the Government made What progress has the Government made on What progress has the Government made on repairing What progress has the Government made on repairing damage Government made on repairing damage to Government made on repairing damage to transport Government made on repairing damage to transport infrastructure to transport infrastructure following to transport infrastructure following the to transport infrastructure following the Kaikoura to transport infrastructure following the Kaikoura earthquake? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, the Mr Speaker, the Government Mr Speaker, the Government is Mr Speaker, the Government is making Mr Speaker, the Government is making very Mr Speaker, the Government is making very strong Mr Speaker, the Government is making very strong progress. Mr Speaker, the Government is making very strong progress. Work Mr Speaker, the Government is making very strong progress. Work is very strong progress. Work is continuing very strong progress. Work is continuing at very strong progress. Work is continuing at pace very strong progress. Work is continuing at pace to very strong progress. Work is continuing at pace to clear very strong progress. Work is continuing at pace to clear slips very strong progress. Work is continuing at pace to clear slips on continuing at pace to clear slips on State continuing at pace to clear slips on State Highway continuing at pace to clear slips on State Highway 1 continuing at pace to clear slips on State Highway 1 south continuing at pace to clear slips on State Highway 1 south of continuing at pace to clear slips on State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura with State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura with crews State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura with crews working State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura with crews working hard State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura with crews working hard to State Highway 1 south of Kaikoura with crews working hard to clear with crews working hard to clear several with crews working hard to clear several large with crews working hard to clear several large slips with crews working hard to clear several large slips and with crews working hard to clear several large slips and rock with crews working hard to clear several large slips and rock falls. several large slips and rock falls. We several large slips and rock falls. We are several large slips and rock falls. We are making several large slips and rock falls. We are making much several large slips and rock falls. We are making much better several large slips and rock falls. We are making much better progress We are making much better progress than We are making much better progress than expected We are making much better progress than expected with We are making much better progress than expected with the We are making much better progress than expected with the transport than expected with the transport agency than expected with the transport agency hoping than expected with the transport agency hoping to than expected with the transport agency hoping to restore than expected with the transport agency hoping to restore controlled agency hoping to restore controlled single agency hoping to restore controlled single lane agency hoping to restore controlled single lane access agency hoping to restore controlled single lane access for agency hoping to restore controlled single lane access for residents agency hoping to restore controlled single lane access for residents and single lane access for residents and essential single lane access for residents and essential services single lane access for residents and essential services by single lane access for residents and essential services by mid-December. essential services by mid-December. But essential services by mid-December. But this essential services by mid-December. But this will essential services by mid-December. But this will be essential services by mid-December. But this will be dependant essential services by mid-December. But this will be dependant on But this will be dependant on weather But this will be dependant on weather and But this will be dependant on weather and any But this will be dependant on weather and any further But this will be dependant on weather and any further earthquakes. weather and any further earthquakes. Restoring weather and any further earthquakes. Restoring full weather and any further earthquakes. Restoring full access weather and any further earthquakes. Restoring full access on weather and any further earthquakes. Restoring full access on State Restoring full access on State Highway Restoring full access on State Highway 1 Restoring full access on State Highway 1 north Restoring full access on State Highway 1 north of Restoring full access on State Highway 1 north of Kaikoura Restoring full access on State Highway 1 north of Kaikoura will Highway 1 north of Kaikoura will take Highway 1 north of Kaikoura will take considerably Highway 1 north of Kaikoura will take considerably more Highway 1 north of Kaikoura will take considerably more time Highway 1 north of Kaikoura will take considerably more time to take considerably more time to complete take considerably more time to complete because take considerably more time to complete because the take considerably more time to complete because the scale take considerably more time to complete because the scale and complete because the scale and complexity complete because the scale and complexity of complete because the scale and complexity of the complete because the scale and complexity of the slips complete because the scale and complexity of the slips are complexity of the slips are unprecedented complexity of the slips are unprecedented in complexity of the slips are unprecedented in New complexity of the slips are unprecedented in New Zealand complexity of the slips are unprecedented in New Zealand and complexity of the slips are unprecedented in New Zealand and the unprecedented in New Zealand and the task unprecedented in New Zealand and the task ahead unprecedented in New Zealand and the task ahead of unprecedented in New Zealand and the task ahead of us unprecedented in New Zealand and the task ahead of us is unprecedented in New Zealand and the task ahead of us is huge. unprecedented in New Zealand and the task ahead of us is huge. What task ahead of us is huge. What progress task ahead of us is huge. What progress has task ahead of us is huge. What progress has been task ahead of us is huge. What progress has been made task ahead of us is huge. What progress has been made on task ahead of us is huge. What progress has been made on repairing progress has been made on repairing and progress has been made on repairing and reinstating progress has been made on repairing and reinstating the progress has been made on repairing and reinstating the inland progress has been made on repairing and reinstating the inland road progress has been made on repairing and reinstating the inland road link and reinstating the inland road link to and reinstating the inland road link to Kaikoura? and reinstating the inland road link to Kaikoura? Again, and reinstating the inland road link to Kaikoura? Again, the and reinstating the inland road link to Kaikoura? Again, the Government to Kaikoura? Again, the Government is to Kaikoura? Again, the Government is making to Kaikoura? Again, the Government is making strong to Kaikoura? Again, the Government is making strong progress to Kaikoura? Again, the Government is making strong progress here. is making strong progress here. Crews is making strong progress here. Crews have is making strong progress here. Crews have been is making strong progress here. Crews have been working is making strong progress here. Crews have been working since is making strong progress here. Crews have been working since the Crews have been working since the day Crews have been working since the day of Crews have been working since the day of the Crews have been working since the day of the earthquake Crews have been working since the day of the earthquake from Crews have been working since the day of the earthquake from both Crews have been working since the day of the earthquake from both ends day of the earthquake from both ends of day of the earthquake from both ends of the day of the earthquake from both ends of the inland day of the earthquake from both ends of the inland route day of the earthquake from both ends of the inland route to day of the earthquake from both ends of the inland route to clear day of the earthquake from both ends of the inland route to clear the day of the earthquake from both ends of the inland route to clear the 50 of the inland route to clear the 50 large of the inland route to clear the 50 large slips of the inland route to clear the 50 large slips and of the inland route to clear the 50 large slips and bridges of the inland route to clear the 50 large slips and bridges and of the inland route to clear the 50 large slips and bridges and get of the inland route to clear the 50 large slips and bridges and get the large slips and bridges and get the road large slips and bridges and get the road to large slips and bridges and get the road to a large slips and bridges and get the road to a state large slips and bridges and get the road to a state where large slips and bridges and get the road to a state where it large slips and bridges and get the road to a state where it can large slips and bridges and get the road to a state where it can be large slips and bridges and get the road to a state where it can be used road to a state where it can be used safely. road to a state where it can be used safely. While road to a state where it can be used safely. While the road to a state where it can be used safely. While the inland road to a state where it can be used safely. While the inland road road to a state where it can be used safely. While the inland road is safely. While the inland road is still safely. While the inland road is still fragile, safely. While the inland road is still fragile, good safely. While the inland road is still fragile, good progress safely. While the inland road is still fragile, good progress is still fragile, good progress is being still fragile, good progress is being made still fragile, good progress is being made in still fragile, good progress is being made in controlled still fragile, good progress is being made in controlled access still fragile, good progress is being made in controlled access in being made in controlled access in and being made in controlled access in and out being made in controlled access in and out of being made in controlled access in and out of Kaikoura being made in controlled access in and out of Kaikoura has being made in controlled access in and out of Kaikoura has now being made in controlled access in and out of Kaikoura has now been and out of Kaikoura has now been established. and out of Kaikoura has now been established. The and out of Kaikoura has now been established. The Transport and out of Kaikoura has now been established. The Transport Agency and out of Kaikoura has now been established. The Transport Agency is established. The Transport Agency is working established. The Transport Agency is working hard established. The Transport Agency is working hard to established. The Transport Agency is working hard to have established. The Transport Agency is working hard to have the established. The Transport Agency is working hard to have the inland established. The Transport Agency is working hard to have the inland road working hard to have the inland road opened working hard to have the inland road opened on working hard to have the inland road opened on a working hard to have the inland road opened on a restricted working hard to have the inland road opened on a restricted basis working hard to have the inland road opened on a restricted basis to working hard to have the inland road opened on a restricted basis to all opened on a restricted basis to all vehicles opened on a restricted basis to all vehicles in opened on a restricted basis to all vehicles in time opened on a restricted basis to all vehicles in time for opened on a restricted basis to all vehicles in time for Christmas. opened on a restricted basis to all vehicles in time for Christmas. But vehicles in time for Christmas. But again, vehicles in time for Christmas. But again, this vehicles in time for Christmas. But again, this will vehicles in time for Christmas. But again, this will be vehicles in time for Christmas. But again, this will be dependant vehicles in time for Christmas. But again, this will be dependant on again, this will be dependant on weather again, this will be dependant on weather or again, this will be dependant on weather or any again, this will be dependant on weather or any further again, this will be dependant on weather or any further earthquakes weather or any further earthquakes which weather or any further earthquakes which could weather or any further earthquakes which could affect weather or any further earthquakes which could affect progress. weather or any further earthquakes which could affect progress. My which could affect progress. My heartfelt which could affect progress. My heartfelt thanks which could affect progress. My heartfelt thanks to which could affect progress. My heartfelt thanks to all which could affect progress. My heartfelt thanks to all the which could affect progress. My heartfelt thanks to all the men which could affect progress. My heartfelt thanks to all the men and heartfelt thanks to all the men and women heartfelt thanks to all the men and women involved heartfelt thanks to all the men and women involved in heartfelt thanks to all the men and women involved in their heartfelt thanks to all the men and women involved in their work heartfelt thanks to all the men and women involved in their work on heartfelt thanks to all the men and women involved in their work on this women involved in their work on this piece women involved in their work on this piece of women involved in their work on this piece of road. women involved in their work on this piece of road. Question women involved in their work on this piece of road. Question No. women involved in their work on this piece of road. Question No. 7. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Social My question is to the Minister for Social Housing: for Social Housing: Does for Social Housing: Does she for Social Housing: Does she stand for Social Housing: Does she stand by Does she stand by her Does she stand by her statement, Does she stand by her statement, "Look Does she stand by her statement, "Look I Does she stand by her statement, "Look I can't her statement, "Look I can't guarantee her statement, "Look I can't guarantee that", her statement, "Look I can't guarantee that", when her statement, "Look I can't guarantee that", when asked her statement, "Look I can't guarantee that", when asked if guarantee that", when asked if anyone guarantee that", when asked if anyone living guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in a guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in a car guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in a car can guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in a car can go guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in a car can go to guarantee that", when asked if anyone living in a car can go to a anyone living in a car can go to a Government anyone living in a car can go to a Government agency anyone living in a car can go to a Government agency today anyone living in a car can go to a Government agency today and anyone living in a car can go to a Government agency today and get anyone living in a car can go to a Government agency today and get a Government agency today and get a roof Government agency today and get a roof over Government agency today and get a roof over their Government agency today and get a roof over their head Government agency today and get a roof over their head tonight? Yes. Yes. However, Yes. However, I Yes. However, I work Yes. However, I work hard Yes. However, I work hard very Yes. However, I work hard very every Yes. However, I work hard very every day Yes. However, I work hard very every day and Yes. However, I work hard very every day and I Yes. However, I work hard very every day and I know Yes. However, I work hard very every day and I know that Yes. However, I work hard very every day and I know that frontline Yes. However, I work hard very every day and I know that frontline staff day and I know that frontline staff do day and I know that frontline staff do as day and I know that frontline staff do as well day and I know that frontline staff do as well to day and I know that frontline staff do as well to help day and I know that frontline staff do as well to help people day and I know that frontline staff do as well to help people who, day and I know that frontline staff do as well to help people who, for day and I know that frontline staff do as well to help people who, for a do as well to help people who, for a variety do as well to help people who, for a variety of do as well to help people who, for a variety of reasons, do as well to help people who, for a variety of reasons, find do as well to help people who, for a variety of reasons, find themselves variety of reasons, find themselves in variety of reasons, find themselves in the variety of reasons, find themselves in the unexpected variety of reasons, find themselves in the unexpected circumstance variety of reasons, find themselves in the unexpected circumstance of in the unexpected circumstance of needing in the unexpected circumstance of needing an in the unexpected circumstance of needing an urgent in the unexpected circumstance of needing an urgent roof in the unexpected circumstance of needing an urgent roof over in the unexpected circumstance of needing an urgent roof over their needing an urgent roof over their head needing an urgent roof over their head that needing an urgent roof over their head that day. needing an urgent roof over their head that day. Isn't needing an urgent roof over their head that day. Isn't it needing an urgent roof over their head that day. Isn't it true needing an urgent roof over their head that day. Isn't it true that needing an urgent roof over their head that day. Isn't it true that if head that day. Isn't it true that if Bill head that day. Isn't it true that if Bill English head that day. Isn't it true that if Bill English hadn't head that day. Isn't it true that if Bill English hadn't taken head that day. Isn't it true that if Bill English hadn't taken $500 Bill English hadn't taken $500 million Bill English hadn't taken $500 million in Bill English hadn't taken $500 million in dividends Bill English hadn't taken $500 million in dividends out Bill English hadn't taken $500 million in dividends out of Bill English hadn't taken $500 million in dividends out of Housing million in dividends out of Housing New million in dividends out of Housing New Zealand million in dividends out of Housing New Zealand and million in dividends out of Housing New Zealand and aren't million in dividends out of Housing New Zealand and aren't reduced million in dividends out of Housing New Zealand and aren't reduced the New Zealand and aren't reduced the number New Zealand and aren't reduced the number of New Zealand and aren't reduced the number of state New Zealand and aren't reduced the number of state houses New Zealand and aren't reduced the number of state houses by New Zealand and aren't reduced the number of state houses by 2,500, number of state houses by 2,500, there number of state houses by 2,500, there would number of state houses by 2,500, there would be number of state houses by 2,500, there would be a number of state houses by 2,500, there would be a lot number of state houses by 2,500, there would be a lot fewer number of state houses by 2,500, there would be a lot fewer families there would be a lot fewer families living there would be a lot fewer families living in there would be a lot fewer families living in garages there would be a lot fewer families living in garages right there would be a lot fewer families living in garages right now? there would be a lot fewer families living in garages right now? No, living in garages right now? No, because living in garages right now? No, because we living in garages right now? No, because we put living in garages right now? No, because we put more living in garages right now? No, because we put more money living in garages right now? No, because we put more money into because we put more money into social because we put more money into social housing because we put more money into social housing than because we put more money into social housing than certainly because we put more money into social housing than certainly has social housing than certainly has ever social housing than certainly has ever been social housing than certainly has ever been taken social housing than certainly has ever been taken out social housing than certainly has ever been taken out in social housing than certainly has ever been taken out in a social housing than certainly has ever been taken out in a dividend. ever been taken out in a dividend. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Why <INTERRUPTION> Why are <INTERRUPTION> Why are she <INTERRUPTION> Why are she and <INTERRUPTION> Why are she and Bill <INTERRUPTION> Why are she and Bill English <INTERRUPTION> Why are she and Bill English focused Why are she and Bill English focused on Why are she and Bill English focused on selling Why are she and Bill English focused on selling off Why are she and Bill English focused on selling off more Why are she and Bill English focused on selling off more houses Why are she and Bill English focused on selling off more houses in Why are she and Bill English focused on selling off more houses in the on selling off more houses in the middle on selling off more houses in the middle of on selling off more houses in the middle of a on selling off more houses in the middle of a housing on selling off more houses in the middle of a housing crisis on selling off more houses in the middle of a housing crisis when on selling off more houses in the middle of a housing crisis when some middle of a housing crisis when some have middle of a housing crisis when some have fallen middle of a housing crisis when some have fallen through middle of a housing crisis when some have fallen through and middle of a housing crisis when some have fallen through and respected have fallen through and respected companies have fallen through and respected companies like have fallen through and respected companies like the have fallen through and respected companies like the Salvation have fallen through and respected companies like the Salvation Army companies like the Salvation Army refuse companies like the Salvation Army refuse to companies like the Salvation Army refuse to participate, companies like the Salvation Army refuse to participate, and companies like the Salvation Army refuse to participate, and there's companies like the Salvation Army refuse to participate, and there's a refuse to participate, and there's a homelessness refuse to participate, and there's a homelessness crisis? refuse to participate, and there's a homelessness crisis? Just refuse to participate, and there's a homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the High homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the High Court homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the High Court ruled homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the High Court ruled that homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the High Court ruled that the homelessness crisis? Just yesterday, the High Court ruled that the sales the High Court ruled that the sales can the High Court ruled that the sales can go the High Court ruled that the sales can go ahead the High Court ruled that the sales can go ahead in the High Court ruled that the sales can go ahead in Taoronga. the High Court ruled that the sales can go ahead in Taoronga. Actually, can go ahead in Taoronga. Actually, we're can go ahead in Taoronga. Actually, we're really can go ahead in Taoronga. Actually, we're really interested can go ahead in Taoronga. Actually, we're really interested in can go ahead in Taoronga. Actually, we're really interested in community we're really interested in community housing we're really interested in community housing providers we're really interested in community housing providers building we're really interested in community housing providers building their housing providers building their asset housing providers building their asset base housing providers building their asset base and housing providers building their asset base and playing housing providers building their asset base and playing an housing providers building their asset base and playing an important asset base and playing an important role asset base and playing an important role in asset base and playing an important role in social asset base and playing an important role in social housing asset base and playing an important role in social housing as asset base and playing an important role in social housing as the asset base and playing an important role in social housing as the member role in social housing as the member himself role in social housing as the member himself said role in social housing as the member himself said in role in social housing as the member himself said in the role in social housing as the member himself said in the speech role in social housing as the member himself said in the speech a role in social housing as the member himself said in the speech a few himself said in the speech a few years himself said in the speech a few years ago. himself said in the speech a few years ago. This himself said in the speech a few years ago. This is himself said in the speech a few years ago. This is what himself said in the speech a few years ago. This is what action himself said in the speech a few years ago. This is what action looks years ago. This is what action looks like years ago. This is what action looks like instead years ago. This is what action looks like instead of years ago. This is what action looks like instead of the years ago. This is what action looks like instead of the rhetoric years ago. This is what action looks like instead of the rhetoric of years ago. This is what action looks like instead of the rhetoric of a like instead of the rhetoric of a speech like instead of the rhetoric of a speech that like instead of the rhetoric of a speech that you like instead of the rhetoric of a speech that you can like instead of the rhetoric of a speech that you can give. like instead of the rhetoric of a speech that you can give. Why like instead of the rhetoric of a speech that you can give. Why does speech that you can give. Why does she speech that you can give. Why does she continue speech that you can give. Why does she continue to speech that you can give. Why does she continue to support speech that you can give. Why does she continue to support selling speech that you can give. Why does she continue to support selling off she continue to support selling off the she continue to support selling off the State she continue to support selling off the State house she continue to support selling off the State house that she continue to support selling off the State house that gave she continue to support selling off the State house that gave John she continue to support selling off the State house that gave John Key the State house that gave John Key the the State house that gave John Key the start the State house that gave John Key the start in the State house that gave John Key the start in life the State house that gave John Key the start in life to the State house that gave John Key the start in life to be the State house that gave John Key the start in life to be PM, the State house that gave John Key the start in life to be PM, when the State house that gave John Key the start in life to be PM, when all the start in life to be PM, when all the the start in life to be PM, when all the evidence the start in life to be PM, when all the evidence show the start in life to be PM, when all the evidence show that the start in life to be PM, when all the evidence show that is the start in life to be PM, when all the evidence show that is providing the evidence show that is providing reliable the evidence show that is providing reliable state the evidence show that is providing reliable state support the evidence show that is providing reliable state support is the evidence show that is providing reliable state support is important reliable state support is important to reliable state support is important to giving reliable state support is important to giving people reliable state support is important to giving people the reliable state support is important to giving people the opportunity reliable state support is important to giving people the opportunity to to giving people the opportunity to 1-day to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be PM, to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be PM, or, to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run to giving people the opportunity to 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run for 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run for Deputy 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run for Deputy PM? 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run for Deputy PM? Well, 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run for Deputy PM? Well, because 1-day be PM, or, 1-day to run for Deputy PM? Well, because those Deputy PM? Well, because those houses Deputy PM? Well, because those houses will Deputy PM? Well, because those houses will stay Deputy PM? Well, because those houses will stay in Deputy PM? Well, because those houses will stay in social Deputy PM? Well, because those houses will stay in social housing houses will stay in social housing and houses will stay in social housing and actually, houses will stay in social housing and actually, the houses will stay in social housing and actually, the Government houses will stay in social housing and actually, the Government will and actually, the Government will still and actually, the Government will still provide and actually, the Government will still provide the and actually, the Government will still provide the subsidy and actually, the Government will still provide the subsidy to still provide the subsidy to ensure... still provide the subsidy to ensure... Actually, still provide the subsidy to ensure... Actually, it's still provide the subsidy to ensure... Actually, it's as still provide the subsidy to ensure... Actually, it's as part still provide the subsidy to ensure... Actually, it's as part of ensure... Actually, it's as part of the ensure... Actually, it's as part of the contract, ensure... Actually, it's as part of the contract, that ensure... Actually, it's as part of the contract, that they ensure... Actually, it's as part of the contract, that they retain ensure... Actually, it's as part of the contract, that they retain in the contract, that they retain in social the contract, that they retain in social housing. the contract, that they retain in social housing. The the contract, that they retain in social housing. The Government the contract, that they retain in social housing. The Government will social housing. The Government will continue social housing. The Government will continue to social housing. The Government will continue to pay social housing. The Government will continue to pay a social housing. The Government will continue to pay a high social housing. The Government will continue to pay a high proportion social housing. The Government will continue to pay a high proportion of continue to pay a high proportion of the continue to pay a high proportion of the rent, continue to pay a high proportion of the rent, as continue to pay a high proportion of the rent, as they continue to pay a high proportion of the rent, as they do continue to pay a high proportion of the rent, as they do now continue to pay a high proportion of the rent, as they do now through the rent, as they do now through subsidies the rent, as they do now through subsidies and the rent, as they do now through subsidies and actually, the rent, as they do now through subsidies and actually, increasing subsidies and actually, increasing the subsidies and actually, increasing the number subsidies and actually, increasing the number of subsidies and actually, increasing the number of people subsidies and actually, increasing the number of people who subsidies and actually, increasing the number of people who own subsidies and actually, increasing the number of people who own them the number of people who own them through the number of people who own them through community the number of people who own them through community housing the number of people who own them through community housing providers through community housing providers is through community housing providers is a through community housing providers is a good through community housing providers is a good thing through community housing providers is a good thing for through community housing providers is a good thing for the through community housing providers is a good thing for the tenants. through community housing providers is a good thing for the tenants. Who is a good thing for the tenants. Who is is a good thing for the tenants. Who is responsible? is a good thing for the tenants. Who is responsible? Her is a good thing for the tenants. Who is responsible? Her or is a good thing for the tenants. Who is responsible? Her or Bill is a good thing for the tenants. Who is responsible? Her or Bill English? is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or the is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or the fact is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or the fact that is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or the fact that Housing is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or the fact that Housing New is responsible? Her or Bill English? Or the fact that Housing New Zealand Or the fact that Housing New Zealand doctor Or the fact that Housing New Zealand doctor magazine Or the fact that Housing New Zealand doctor magazine has Or the fact that Housing New Zealand doctor magazine has wasted Or the fact that Housing New Zealand doctor magazine has wasted more Or the fact that Housing New Zealand doctor magazine has wasted more than doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 million doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 million and doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 million and has doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 million and has more doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 million and has more than doctor magazine has wasted more than $21 million and has more than 500 $21 million and has more than 500 houses $21 million and has more than 500 houses lying $21 million and has more than 500 houses lying empty $21 million and has more than 500 houses lying empty because $21 million and has more than 500 houses lying empty because of houses lying empty because of incompetents houses lying empty because of incompetents in houses lying empty because of incompetents in the houses lying empty because of incompetents in the testing houses lying empty because of incompetents in the testing for incompetents in the testing for methamphetamine incompetents in the testing for methamphetamine contamination? incompetents in the testing for methamphetamine contamination? There methamphetamine contamination? There have methamphetamine contamination? There have been methamphetamine contamination? There have been health methamphetamine contamination? There have been health and methamphetamine contamination? There have been health and safety methamphetamine contamination? There have been health and safety issues have been health and safety issues around have been health and safety issues around meth have been health and safety issues around meth contaminated have been health and safety issues around meth contaminated houses have been health and safety issues around meth contaminated houses and around meth contaminated houses and up around meth contaminated houses and up until around meth contaminated houses and up until recently, around meth contaminated houses and up until recently, the around meth contaminated houses and up until recently, the only around meth contaminated houses and up until recently, the only measure up until recently, the only measure that up until recently, the only measure that they up until recently, the only measure that they have up until recently, the only measure that they have had up until recently, the only measure that they have had has up until recently, the only measure that they have had has been up until recently, the only measure that they have had has been one that they have had has been one that's that they have had has been one that's been that they have had has been one that's been at that they have had has been one that's been at the that they have had has been one that's been at the 0.5 that they have had has been one that's been at the 0.5 in that they have had has been one that's been at the 0.5 in a that they have had has been one that's been at the 0.5 in a health that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And we that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And we would that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And we would like that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And we would like to that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And we would like to see that's been at the 0.5 in a health one. And we would like to see more one. And we would like to see more houses one. And we would like to see more houses available one. And we would like to see more houses available for one. And we would like to see more houses available for those one. And we would like to see more houses available for those tenants houses available for those tenants quicker, houses available for those tenants quicker, but houses available for those tenants quicker, but at houses available for those tenants quicker, but at the houses available for those tenants quicker, but at the end houses available for those tenants quicker, but at the end of houses available for those tenants quicker, but at the end of the houses available for those tenants quicker, but at the end of the day, quicker, but at the end of the day, there's quicker, but at the end of the day, there's also quicker, but at the end of the day, there's also contractors quicker, but at the end of the day, there's also contractors who quicker, but at the end of the day, there's also contractors who need quicker, but at the end of the day, there's also contractors who need to there's also contractors who need to clean there's also contractors who need to clean them there's also contractors who need to clean them out there's also contractors who need to clean them out and there's also contractors who need to clean them out and feel there's also contractors who need to clean them out and feel that there's also contractors who need to clean them out and feel that they clean them out and feel that they are clean them out and feel that they are safe. clean them out and feel that they are safe. Staff clean them out and feel that they are safe. Staff that clean them out and feel that they are safe. Staff that are clean them out and feel that they are safe. Staff that are in clean them out and feel that they are safe. Staff that are in them, are safe. Staff that are in them, and are safe. Staff that are in them, and in are safe. Staff that are in them, and in fact, are safe. Staff that are in them, and in fact, we are safe. Staff that are in them, and in fact, we have are safe. Staff that are in them, and in fact, we have people are safe. Staff that are in them, and in fact, we have people saying and in fact, we have people saying that and in fact, we have people saying that they and in fact, we have people saying that they want and in fact, we have people saying that they want to and in fact, we have people saying that they want to move and in fact, we have people saying that they want to move out and in fact, we have people saying that they want to move out of and in fact, we have people saying that they want to move out of those that they want to move out of those houses that they want to move out of those houses because that they want to move out of those houses because they're that they want to move out of those houses because they're concerned houses because they're concerned about houses because they're concerned about the houses because they're concerned about the contamination. houses because they're concerned about the contamination. Does houses because they're concerned about the contamination. Does she about the contamination. Does she think about the contamination. Does she think that about the contamination. Does she think that her about the contamination. Does she think that her stuff-ups about the contamination. Does she think that her stuff-ups around think that her stuff-ups around flying think that her stuff-ups around flying squads think that her stuff-ups around flying squads that think that her stuff-ups around flying squads that never think that her stuff-ups around flying squads that never existed, flying squads that never existed, paying flying squads that never existed, paying people flying squads that never existed, paying people to flying squads that never existed, paying people to get flying squads that never existed, paying people to get out flying squads that never existed, paying people to get out of flying squads that never existed, paying people to get out of town, paying people to get out of town, leaking paying people to get out of town, leaking personal paying people to get out of town, leaking personal information paying people to get out of town, leaking personal information about paying people to get out of town, leaking personal information about a leaking personal information about a chairman, leaking personal information about a chairman, are leaking personal information about a chairman, are the leaking personal information about a chairman, are the reason leaking personal information about a chairman, are the reason that leaking personal information about a chairman, are the reason that the leaking personal information about a chairman, are the reason that the PM chairman, are the reason that the PM doesn't chairman, are the reason that the PM doesn't have chairman, are the reason that the PM doesn't have the chairman, are the reason that the PM doesn't have the confidence chairman, are the reason that the PM doesn't have the confidence to chairman, are the reason that the PM doesn't have the confidence to name doesn't have the confidence to name her doesn't have the confidence to name her as doesn't have the confidence to name her as his doesn't have the confidence to name her as his successor? doesn't have the confidence to name her as his successor? I doesn't have the confidence to name her as his successor? I think doesn't have the confidence to name her as his successor? I think the her as his successor? I think the fact her as his successor? I think the fact that her as his successor? I think the fact that more her as his successor? I think the fact that more than her as his successor? I think the fact that more than $350 her as his successor? I think the fact that more than $350 million her as his successor? I think the fact that more than $350 million has fact that more than $350 million has gone fact that more than $350 million has gone into fact that more than $350 million has gone into emergency fact that more than $350 million has gone into emergency housing fact that more than $350 million has gone into emergency housing in fact that more than $350 million has gone into emergency housing in the gone into emergency housing in the last gone into emergency housing in the last 18 gone into emergency housing in the last 18 months, gone into emergency housing in the last 18 months, the gone into emergency housing in the last 18 months, the fact gone into emergency housing in the last 18 months, the fact that gone into emergency housing in the last 18 months, the fact that we've last 18 months, the fact that we've got last 18 months, the fact that we've got more last 18 months, the fact that we've got more than last 18 months, the fact that we've got more than 3,000 last 18 months, the fact that we've got more than 3,000 new last 18 months, the fact that we've got more than 3,000 new social got more than 3,000 new social houses got more than 3,000 new social houses in got more than 3,000 new social houses in the got more than 3,000 new social houses in the pipeline got more than 3,000 new social houses in the pipeline and got more than 3,000 new social houses in the pipeline and ones houses in the pipeline and ones being houses in the pipeline and ones being opened houses in the pipeline and ones being opened every houses in the pipeline and ones being opened every single houses in the pipeline and ones being opened every single week, houses in the pipeline and ones being opened every single week, that being opened every single week, that we being opened every single week, that we house being opened every single week, that we house more being opened every single week, that we house more than being opened every single week, that we house more than 150 being opened every single week, that we house more than 150 people being opened every single week, that we house more than 150 people each we house more than 150 people each week we house more than 150 people each week off we house more than 150 people each week off our we house more than 150 people each week off our wait we house more than 150 people each week off our wait list, we house more than 150 people each week off our wait list, and we house more than 150 people each week off our wait list, and that we house more than 150 people each week off our wait list, and that New week off our wait list, and that New Zealanders week off our wait list, and that New Zealanders now week off our wait list, and that New Zealanders now have week off our wait list, and that New Zealanders now have hope, week off our wait list, and that New Zealanders now have hope, which week off our wait list, and that New Zealanders now have hope, which they Zealanders now have hope, which they didn't Zealanders now have hope, which they didn't have Zealanders now have hope, which they didn't have under Zealanders now have hope, which they didn't have under a Zealanders now have hope, which they didn't have under a previous Zealanders now have hope, which they didn't have under a previous Labour didn't have under a previous Labour Government, didn't have under a previous Labour Government, that didn't have under a previous Labour Government, that actually didn't have under a previous Labour Government, that actually they didn't have under a previous Labour Government, that actually they will Government, that actually they will have Government, that actually they will have a Government, that actually they will have a roof Government, that actually they will have a roof over Government, that actually they will have a roof over their Government, that actually they will have a roof over their head Government, that actually they will have a roof over their head and Government, that actually they will have a roof over their head and a have a roof over their head and a Government have a roof over their head and a Government that have a roof over their head and a Government that cares, have a roof over their head and a Government that cares, speaks have a roof over their head and a Government that cares, speaks for Government that cares, speaks for itself. Government that cares, speaks for itself. Question Government that cares, speaks for itself. Question No. Government that cares, speaks for itself. Question No. 8. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: Finance: Does Finance: Does he Finance: Does he stand Finance: Does he stand by Finance: Does he stand by all Finance: Does he stand by all his Finance: Does he stand by all his statements? Yes, Yes, in Yes, in the Yes, in the context Yes, in the context which Yes, in the context which I'll Yes, in the context which I'll make. Yes, in the context which I'll make. To Yes, in the context which I'll make. To the Yes, in the context which I'll make. To the Minister, Yes, in the context which I'll make. To the Minister, does Yes, in the context which I'll make. To the Minister, does he Yes, in the context which I'll make. To the Minister, does he stand Yes, in the context which I'll make. To the Minister, does he stand by To the Minister, does he stand by his To the Minister, does he stand by his statement To the Minister, does he stand by his statement in To the Minister, does he stand by his statement in 2010 To the Minister, does he stand by his statement in 2010 that To the Minister, does he stand by his statement in 2010 that his his statement in 2010 that his Government, his statement in 2010 that his Government, "Welcomes his statement in 2010 that his Government, "Welcomes beneficial Government, "Welcomes beneficial foreign Government, "Welcomes beneficial foreign investment Government, "Welcomes beneficial foreign investment and Government, "Welcomes beneficial foreign investment and recognise Government, "Welcomes beneficial foreign investment and recognise the foreign investment and recognise the positive foreign investment and recognise the positive contribution foreign investment and recognise the positive contribution it foreign investment and recognise the positive contribution it makes foreign investment and recognise the positive contribution it makes to positive contribution it makes to New positive contribution it makes to New Zealand". positive contribution it makes to New Zealand". And positive contribution it makes to New Zealand". And if positive contribution it makes to New Zealand". And if so, positive contribution it makes to New Zealand". And if so, how positive contribution it makes to New Zealand". And if so, how does New Zealand". And if so, how does that New Zealand". And if so, how does that foreign New Zealand". And if so, how does that foreign investment New Zealand". And if so, how does that foreign investment in New Zealand". And if so, how does that foreign investment in the that foreign investment in the housing that foreign investment in the housing market that foreign investment in the housing market now that foreign investment in the housing market now look that foreign investment in the housing market now look after that foreign investment in the housing market now look after the housing market now look after the last housing market now look after the last two housing market now look after the last two months housing market now look after the last two months of housing market now look after the last two months of correction housing market now look after the last two months of correction in housing market now look after the last two months of correction in the last two months of correction in the market last two months of correction in the market trend? last two months of correction in the market trend? I last two months of correction in the market trend? I certainly last two months of correction in the market trend? I certainly stand last two months of correction in the market trend? I certainly stand by market trend? I certainly stand by the market trend? I certainly stand by the statement. market trend? I certainly stand by the statement. I'm market trend? I certainly stand by the statement. I'm not market trend? I certainly stand by the statement. I'm not quite market trend? I certainly stand by the statement. I'm not quite sure the statement. I'm not quite sure what the statement. I'm not quite sure what the the statement. I'm not quite sure what the member the statement. I'm not quite sure what the member means the statement. I'm not quite sure what the member means about the statement. I'm not quite sure what the member means about the what the member means about the question what the member means about the question in what the member means about the question in relation what the member means about the question in relation to what the member means about the question in relation to the what the member means about the question in relation to the housing question in relation to the housing market. question in relation to the housing market. The question in relation to the housing market. The housing question in relation to the housing market. The housing market question in relation to the housing market. The housing market in market. The housing market in Auckland market. The housing market in Auckland rose market. The housing market in Auckland rose rapidly. market. The housing market in Auckland rose rapidly. It market. The housing market in Auckland rose rapidly. It was market. The housing market in Auckland rose rapidly. It was always Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely that Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely that at Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely that at some Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely that at some point Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely that at some point it Auckland rose rapidly. It was always likely that at some point it would likely that at some point it would have likely that at some point it would have to likely that at some point it would have to slow likely that at some point it would have to slow down, likely that at some point it would have to slow down, just likely that at some point it would have to slow down, just because have to slow down, just because people have to slow down, just because people couldn't have to slow down, just because people couldn't afford have to slow down, just because people couldn't afford to have to slow down, just because people couldn't afford to pay have to slow down, just because people couldn't afford to pay the people couldn't afford to pay the kind people couldn't afford to pay the kind of people couldn't afford to pay the kind of price people couldn't afford to pay the kind of price multiples people couldn't afford to pay the kind of price multiples that people couldn't afford to pay the kind of price multiples that they've kind of price multiples that they've been kind of price multiples that they've been paying, kind of price multiples that they've been paying, and kind of price multiples that they've been paying, and I kind of price multiples that they've been paying, and I doubt kind of price multiples that they've been paying, and I doubt that kind of price multiples that they've been paying, and I doubt that the been paying, and I doubt that the relatively been paying, and I doubt that the relatively small been paying, and I doubt that the relatively small flows been paying, and I doubt that the relatively small flows of been paying, and I doubt that the relatively small flows of foreign relatively small flows of foreign investment relatively small flows of foreign investment make relatively small flows of foreign investment make much relatively small flows of foreign investment make much difference relatively small flows of foreign investment make much difference to investment make much difference to that. investment make much difference to that. From investment make much difference to that. From his investment make much difference to that. From his statements, investment make much difference to that. From his statements, "You've that. From his statements, "You've got that. From his statements, "You've got very that. From his statements, "You've got very high that. From his statements, "You've got very high levels that. From his statements, "You've got very high levels of that. From his statements, "You've got very high levels of debt that. From his statements, "You've got very high levels of debt and that. From his statements, "You've got very high levels of debt and if got very high levels of debt and if interest got very high levels of debt and if interest rates got very high levels of debt and if interest rates rise got very high levels of debt and if interest rates rise sooner got very high levels of debt and if interest rates rise sooner than interest rates rise sooner than expected, interest rates rise sooner than expected, you're interest rates rise sooner than expected, you're going interest rates rise sooner than expected, you're going to interest rates rise sooner than expected, you're going to be interest rates rise sooner than expected, you're going to be under expected, you're going to be under pressure". expected, you're going to be under pressure". Can expected, you're going to be under pressure". Can he expected, you're going to be under pressure". Can he enlighten expected, you're going to be under pressure". Can he enlighten the pressure". Can he enlighten the house pressure". Can he enlighten the house as pressure". Can he enlighten the house as to pressure". Can he enlighten the house as to the pressure". Can he enlighten the house as to the implications pressure". Can he enlighten the house as to the implications of pressure". Can he enlighten the house as to the implications of an house as to the implications of an Auckland house as to the implications of an Auckland housing house as to the implications of an Auckland housing market house as to the implications of an Auckland housing market that house as to the implications of an Auckland housing market that peaked Auckland housing market that peaked in Auckland housing market that peaked in September Auckland housing market that peaked in September and Auckland housing market that peaked in September and is Auckland housing market that peaked in September and is now Auckland housing market that peaked in September and is now falling? in September and is now falling? Well, in September and is now falling? Well, Mr in September and is now falling? Well, Mr Speaker, in September and is now falling? Well, Mr Speaker, I in September and is now falling? Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't in September and is now falling? Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give advice Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give advice on Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give advice on that Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give advice on that particular Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give advice on that particular matter. Well, Mr Speaker, I wouldn't give advice on that particular matter. We advice on that particular matter. We don't advice on that particular matter. We don't quite advice on that particular matter. We don't quite know advice on that particular matter. We don't quite know what's advice on that particular matter. We don't quite know what's going advice on that particular matter. We don't quite know what's going to don't quite know what's going to happen don't quite know what's going to happen with don't quite know what's going to happen with the don't quite know what's going to happen with the auk don't quite know what's going to happen with the auk land don't quite know what's going to happen with the auk land housing happen with the auk land housing market. happen with the auk land housing market. This happen with the auk land housing market. This time happen with the auk land housing market. This time last happen with the auk land housing market. This time last year, happen with the auk land housing market. This time last year, it market. This time last year, it slowed, market. This time last year, it slowed, in market. This time last year, it slowed, in a market. This time last year, it slowed, in a way, market. This time last year, it slowed, in a way, a market. This time last year, it slowed, in a way, a bit market. This time last year, it slowed, in a way, a bit similar market. This time last year, it slowed, in a way, a bit similar and slowed, in a way, a bit similar and then slowed, in a way, a bit similar and then it slowed, in a way, a bit similar and then it picked slowed, in a way, a bit similar and then it picked up slowed, in a way, a bit similar and then it picked up the slowed, in a way, a bit similar and then it picked up the following then it picked up the following March then it picked up the following March and then it picked up the following March and April. then it picked up the following March and April. So then it picked up the following March and April. So we then it picked up the following March and April. So we don't then it picked up the following March and April. So we don't quite March and April. So we don't quite know March and April. So we don't quite know how March and April. So we don't quite know how to March and April. So we don't quite know how to work March and April. So we don't quite know how to work it March and April. So we don't quite know how to work it out March and April. So we don't quite know how to work it out but March and April. So we don't quite know how to work it out but I March and April. So we don't quite know how to work it out but I do know how to work it out but I do stand know how to work it out but I do stand by know how to work it out but I do stand by the know how to work it out but I do stand by the statement know how to work it out but I do stand by the statement that know how to work it out but I do stand by the statement that those stand by the statement that those who stand by the statement that those who have stand by the statement that those who have borrowed stand by the statement that those who have borrowed very stand by the statement that those who have borrowed very large stand by the statement that those who have borrowed very large amounts who have borrowed very large amounts of who have borrowed very large amounts of money who have borrowed very large amounts of money relative who have borrowed very large amounts of money relative to who have borrowed very large amounts of money relative to their who have borrowed very large amounts of money relative to their income who have borrowed very large amounts of money relative to their income do of money relative to their income do need of money relative to their income do need to of money relative to their income do need to keep of money relative to their income do need to keep in of money relative to their income do need to keep in mind of money relative to their income do need to keep in mind that of money relative to their income do need to keep in mind that interest need to keep in mind that interest rates need to keep in mind that interest rates can need to keep in mind that interest rates can rise. rates can rise. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> To <INTERRUPTION> To the <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what is <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what is his <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what is his view <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what is his view of To the Minister, what is his view of falling To the Minister, what is his view of falling essential To the Minister, what is his view of falling essential pre-sales falling essential pre-sales commitments falling essential pre-sales commitments in falling essential pre-sales commitments in apartment falling essential pre-sales commitments in apartment complexes commitments in apartment complexes taking commitments in apartment complexes taking up commitments in apartment complexes taking up to commitments in apartment complexes taking up to two commitments in apartment complexes taking up to two years commitments in apartment complexes taking up to two years to commitments in apartment complexes taking up to two years to build, taking up to two years to build, with taking up to two years to build, with increasing taking up to two years to build, with increasing interest taking up to two years to build, with increasing interest rates taking up to two years to build, with increasing interest rates and with increasing interest rates and the with increasing interest rates and the prospect with increasing interest rates and the prospect of with increasing interest rates and the prospect of projects with increasing interest rates and the prospect of projects like with increasing interest rates and the prospect of projects like this the prospect of projects like this floundering the prospect of projects like this floundering and the prospect of projects like this floundering and being the prospect of projects like this floundering and being abandoned? floundering and being abandoned? From floundering and being abandoned? From the floundering and being abandoned? From the Government's floundering and being abandoned? From the Government's point floundering and being abandoned? From the Government's point of floundering and being abandoned? From the Government's point of view, From the Government's point of view, that's From the Government's point of view, that's the From the Government's point of view, that's the operation From the Government's point of view, that's the operation of From the Government's point of view, that's the operation of the From the Government's point of view, that's the operation of the market. that's the operation of the market. People that's the operation of the market. People who that's the operation of the market. People who are that's the operation of the market. People who are building that's the operation of the market. People who are building apartments People who are building apartments have People who are building apartments have taken People who are building apartments have taken risks. People who are building apartments have taken risks. They People who are building apartments have taken risks. They have People who are building apartments have taken risks. They have to People who are building apartments have taken risks. They have to get have taken risks. They have to get the have taken risks. They have to get the support have taken risks. They have to get the support of have taken risks. They have to get the support of their have taken risks. They have to get the support of their banks have taken risks. They have to get the support of their banks to have taken risks. They have to get the support of their banks to able the support of their banks to able to the support of their banks to able to execute the support of their banks to able to execute the the support of their banks to able to execute the building the support of their banks to able to execute the building of the support of their banks to able to execute the building of those to execute the building of those apartments to execute the building of those apartments and to execute the building of those apartments and if to execute the building of those apartments and if they to execute the building of those apartments and if they can't, to execute the building of those apartments and if they can't, then apartments and if they can't, then someone apartments and if they can't, then someone else apartments and if they can't, then someone else will apartments and if they can't, then someone else will get apartments and if they can't, then someone else will get them apartments and if they can't, then someone else will get them a apartments and if they can't, then someone else will get them a bit someone else will get them a bit cheaper someone else will get them a bit cheaper and someone else will get them a bit cheaper and probably someone else will get them a bit cheaper and probably finish someone else will get them a bit cheaper and probably finish them. cheaper and probably finish them. That's cheaper and probably finish them. That's the cheaper and probably finish them. That's the kind cheaper and probably finish them. That's the kind of cheaper and probably finish them. That's the kind of adjustment cheaper and probably finish them. That's the kind of adjustment you That's the kind of adjustment you would That's the kind of adjustment you would expect That's the kind of adjustment you would expect to That's the kind of adjustment you would expect to be That's the kind of adjustment you would expect to be happening That's the kind of adjustment you would expect to be happening in That's the kind of adjustment you would expect to be happening in a would expect to be happening in a market would expect to be happening in a market that would expect to be happening in a market that has would expect to be happening in a market that has been would expect to be happening in a market that has been running would expect to be happening in a market that has been running pretty market that has been running pretty hot. market that has been running pretty hot. To market that has been running pretty hot. To the market that has been running pretty hot. To the Minister, market that has been running pretty hot. To the Minister, does market that has been running pretty hot. To the Minister, does he market that has been running pretty hot. To the Minister, does he stand hot. To the Minister, does he stand by hot. To the Minister, does he stand by his hot. To the Minister, does he stand by his statement hot. To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on hot. To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on 28 hot. To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on 28 May, hot. To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on 28 May, 2009, by his statement on 28 May, 2009, that, by his statement on 28 May, 2009, that, "The by his statement on 28 May, 2009, that, "The Government by his statement on 28 May, 2009, that, "The Government is by his statement on 28 May, 2009, that, "The Government is committed that, "The Government is committed to that, "The Government is committed to maintaining that, "The Government is committed to maintaining national that, "The Government is committed to maintaining national Super to maintaining national Super entitlements to maintaining national Super entitlements at to maintaining national Super entitlements at 26% to maintaining national Super entitlements at 26% of to maintaining national Super entitlements at 26% of the to maintaining national Super entitlements at 26% of the average entitlements at 26% of the average wage entitlements at 26% of the average wage to entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be paid entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be paid from entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be paid from the entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be paid from the age entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be paid from the age of entitlements at 26% of the average wage to be paid from the age of 65?" wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll just wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll just have wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll just have to wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll just have to check wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll just have to check exactly wage to be paid from the age of 65?" I'll just have to check exactly the I'll just have to check exactly the 26%, I'll just have to check exactly the 26%, but I'll just have to check exactly the 26%, but that's I'll just have to check exactly the 26%, but that's what I'll just have to check exactly the 26%, but that's what the I'll just have to check exactly the 26%, but that's what the Government 26%, but that's what the Government has 26%, but that's what the Government has done. has done. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . To <INTERRUPTION> . To the <INTERRUPTION> . To the Minister, <INTERRUPTION> . To the Minister, does <INTERRUPTION> . To the Minister, does he <INTERRUPTION> . To the Minister, does he stand <INTERRUPTION> . To the Minister, does he stand by . To the Minister, does he stand by his . To the Minister, does he stand by his statement . To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on . To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on 4 . To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on 4 October, . To the Minister, does he stand by his statement on 4 October, 2005, his statement on 4 October, 2005, when his statement on 4 October, 2005, when he his statement on 4 October, 2005, when he said, his statement on 4 October, 2005, when he said, "An his statement on 4 October, 2005, when he said, "An implication his statement on 4 October, 2005, when he said, "An implication of when he said, "An implication of Treatiology when he said, "An implication of Treatiology is when he said, "An implication of Treatiology is that when he said, "An implication of Treatiology is that citizenship when he said, "An implication of Treatiology is that citizenship can, Treatiology is that citizenship can, and Treatiology is that citizenship can, and should Treatiology is that citizenship can, and should be Treatiology is that citizenship can, and should be divided Treatiology is that citizenship can, and should be divided to Treatiology is that citizenship can, and should be divided to express Treatiology is that citizenship can, and should be divided to express a and should be divided to express a special and should be divided to express a special status and should be divided to express a special status for and should be divided to express a special status for Maori. and should be divided to express a special status for Maori. This special status for Maori. This notion special status for Maori. This notion runs special status for Maori. This notion runs sharply special status for Maori. This notion runs sharply counter special status for Maori. This notion runs sharply counter to special status for Maori. This notion runs sharply counter to broad notion runs sharply counter to broad public notion runs sharply counter to broad public support notion runs sharply counter to broad public support for notion runs sharply counter to broad public support for the notion runs sharply counter to broad public support for the idea notion runs sharply counter to broad public support for the idea of notion runs sharply counter to broad public support for the idea of one public support for the idea of one law public support for the idea of one law for public support for the idea of one law for all." public support for the idea of one law for all." And public support for the idea of one law for all." And does public support for the idea of one law for all." And does he public support for the idea of one law for all." And does he believe public support for the idea of one law for all." And does he believe he law for all." And does he believe he has law for all." And does he believe he public law for all." And does he believe he has been true law for all." And does he believe he has been true to law for all." And does he believe he has been true to that law for all." And does he believe he has been true to that statement, law for all." And does he believe he has been true to that statement, or has been true to that statement, or has has been true to that statement, or has he has been true to that statement, or has he reneged? has been true to that statement, or has he reneged? Yes. has he reneged? Yes. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Question <INTERRUPTION> Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 9. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he stand of Finance: Does he stand by of Finance: Does he stand by his of Finance: Does he stand by his statement of Finance: Does he stand by his statement to of Finance: Does he stand by his statement to this of Finance: Does he stand by his statement to this House of Finance: Does he stand by his statement to this House that by his statement to this House that "having by his statement to this House that "having surpluses by his statement to this House that "having surpluses does by his statement to this House that "having surpluses does not by his statement to this House that "having surpluses does not mean "having surpluses does not mean that "having surpluses does not mean that the "having surpluses does not mean that the Government "having surpluses does not mean that the Government can "having surpluses does not mean that the Government can go "having surpluses does not mean that the Government can go spending that the Government can go spending more that the Government can go spending more money that the Government can go spending more money on that the Government can go spending more money on ineffective that the Government can go spending more money on ineffective public more money on ineffective public services more money on ineffective public services or more money on ineffective public services or infrastructure services or infrastructure that services or infrastructure that may services or infrastructure that may not services or infrastructure that may not be services or infrastructure that may not be needed"? Yes, Yes, and Yes, and I Yes, and I think Yes, and I think it's Yes, and I think it's what Yes, and I think it's what any Yes, and I think it's what any reasonable Yes, and I think it's what any reasonable person Yes, and I think it's what any reasonable person would Yes, and I think it's what any reasonable person would say. Yes, and I think it's what any reasonable person would say. The reasonable person would say. The idea reasonable person would say. The idea that reasonable person would say. The idea that because reasonable person would say. The idea that because of reasonable person would say. The idea that because of the reasonable person would say. The idea that because of the surpluses, idea that because of the surpluses, we idea that because of the surpluses, we should idea that because of the surpluses, we should somehow idea that because of the surpluses, we should somehow go idea that because of the surpluses, we should somehow go on idea that because of the surpluses, we should somehow go on a idea that because of the surpluses, we should somehow go on a spend idea that because of the surpluses, we should somehow go on a spend up we should somehow go on a spend up on we should somehow go on a spend up on social we should somehow go on a spend up on social services we should somehow go on a spend up on social services is we should somehow go on a spend up on social services is the we should somehow go on a spend up on social services is the wrong on social services is the wrong idea. on social services is the wrong idea. The on social services is the wrong idea. The Government on social services is the wrong idea. The Government has on social services is the wrong idea. The Government has focused idea. The Government has focused very idea. The Government has focused very much idea. The Government has focused very much on idea. The Government has focused very much on the idea. The Government has focused very much on the effectiveness idea. The Government has focused very much on the effectiveness of very much on the effectiveness of existing very much on the effectiveness of existing spending very much on the effectiveness of existing spending as very much on the effectiveness of existing spending as well very much on the effectiveness of existing spending as well as very much on the effectiveness of existing spending as well as closely existing spending as well as closely targeting existing spending as well as closely targeting any existing spending as well as closely targeting any new existing spending as well as closely targeting any new spending. existing spending as well as closely targeting any new spending. We existing spending as well as closely targeting any new spending. We can targeting any new spending. We can make targeting any new spending. We can make gains targeting any new spending. We can make gains in targeting any new spending. We can make gains in our targeting any new spending. We can make gains in our support targeting any new spending. We can make gains in our support for targeting any new spending. We can make gains in our support for the make gains in our support for the most make gains in our support for the most vulnerable make gains in our support for the most vulnerable in make gains in our support for the most vulnerable in our make gains in our support for the most vulnerable in our community make gains in our support for the most vulnerable in our community by most vulnerable in our community by being most vulnerable in our community by being a most vulnerable in our community by being a great most vulnerable in our community by being a great deal most vulnerable in our community by being a great deal more most vulnerable in our community by being a great deal more thoughtful being a great deal more thoughtful and being a great deal more thoughtful and focusing being a great deal more thoughtful and focusing on being a great deal more thoughtful and focusing on results, being a great deal more thoughtful and focusing on results, not being a great deal more thoughtful and focusing on results, not just being a great deal more thoughtful and focusing on results, not just on and focusing on results, not just on shovelling and focusing on results, not just on shovelling more and focusing on results, not just on shovelling more money and focusing on results, not just on shovelling more money out, and focusing on results, not just on shovelling more money out, as and focusing on results, not just on shovelling more money out, as the shovelling more money out, as the Greens shovelling more money out, as the Greens seem shovelling more money out, as the Greens seem to shovelling more money out, as the Greens seem to advocate. shovelling more money out, as the Greens seem to advocate. How, shovelling more money out, as the Greens seem to advocate. How, then, Greens seem to advocate. How, then, does Greens seem to advocate. How, then, does the Greens seem to advocate. How, then, does the Minister Greens seem to advocate. How, then, does the Minister justify Greens seem to advocate. How, then, does the Minister justify support does the Minister justify support for does the Minister justify support for the does the Minister justify support for the Government's does the Minister justify support for the Government's commitment does the Minister justify support for the Government's commitment to for the Government's commitment to spending for the Government's commitment to spending $1 for the Government's commitment to spending $1 billion for the Government's commitment to spending $1 billion on for the Government's commitment to spending $1 billion on a for the Government's commitment to spending $1 billion on a new for the Government's commitment to spending $1 billion on a new prison? spending $1 billion on a new prison? Something spending $1 billion on a new prison? Something he spending $1 billion on a new prison? Something he previously spending $1 billion on a new prison? Something he previously called Something he previously called "immoral" Something he previously called "immoral" and Something he previously called "immoral" and "fiscal Something he previously called "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? Something he previously called "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? It's "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? It's unfortunate, "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? It's unfortunate, but "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? It's unfortunate, but there's "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? It's unfortunate, but there's no "immoral" and "fiscal failure"? It's unfortunate, but there's no choice unfortunate, but there's no choice in unfortunate, but there's no choice in this unfortunate, but there's no choice in this case. unfortunate, but there's no choice in this case. The unfortunate, but there's no choice in this case. The people unfortunate, but there's no choice in this case. The people who unfortunate, but there's no choice in this case. The people who are in this case. The people who are going in this case. The people who are going to in this case. The people who are going to be in this case. The people who are going to be occupying in this case. The people who are going to be occupying those in this case. The people who are going to be occupying those billion going to be occupying those billion dollars going to be occupying those billion dollars worth going to be occupying those billion dollars worth of going to be occupying those billion dollars worth of new going to be occupying those billion dollars worth of new prison going to be occupying those billion dollars worth of new prison beds going to be occupying those billion dollars worth of new prison beds are dollars worth of new prison beds are coming dollars worth of new prison beds are coming through dollars worth of new prison beds are coming through the dollars worth of new prison beds are coming through the courts. dollars worth of new prison beds are coming through the courts. They've coming through the courts. They've been coming through the courts. They've been convicted coming through the courts. They've been convicted and coming through the courts. They've been convicted and sentenced been convicted and sentenced according been convicted and sentenced according to been convicted and sentenced according to the been convicted and sentenced according to the law been convicted and sentenced according to the law of been convicted and sentenced according to the law of the been convicted and sentenced according to the law of the land been convicted and sentenced according to the law of the land and according to the law of the land and if according to the law of the land and if we according to the law of the land and if we don't according to the law of the land and if we don't get according to the law of the land and if we don't get on according to the law of the land and if we don't get on and according to the law of the land and if we don't get on and build according to the law of the land and if we don't get on and build the if we don't get on and build the prisons, if we don't get on and build the prisons, there if we don't get on and build the prisons, there will if we don't get on and build the prisons, there will simply if we don't get on and build the prisons, there will simply be prisons, there will simply be nowhere prisons, there will simply be nowhere to prisons, there will simply be nowhere to put prisons, there will simply be nowhere to put them. prisons, there will simply be nowhere to put them. But prisons, there will simply be nowhere to put them. But at prisons, there will simply be nowhere to put them. But at the prisons, there will simply be nowhere to put them. But at the same nowhere to put them. But at the same time, nowhere to put them. But at the same time, we're nowhere to put them. But at the same time, we're developing nowhere to put them. But at the same time, we're developing an nowhere to put them. But at the same time, we're developing an in-depth time, we're developing an in-depth understanding time, we're developing an in-depth understanding of time, we're developing an in-depth understanding of the time, we're developing an in-depth understanding of the drivers time, we're developing an in-depth understanding of the drivers of time, we're developing an in-depth understanding of the drivers of the understanding of the drivers of the longer understanding of the drivers of the longer sentences, understanding of the drivers of the longer sentences, the understanding of the drivers of the longer sentences, the kind understanding of the drivers of the longer sentences, the kind of understanding of the drivers of the longer sentences, the kind of crimes longer sentences, the kind of crimes that longer sentences, the kind of crimes that are longer sentences, the kind of crimes that are being longer sentences, the kind of crimes that are being committed longer sentences, the kind of crimes that are being committed and longer sentences, the kind of crimes that are being committed and the that are being committed and the likelihood that are being committed and the likelihood that that are being committed and the likelihood that people that are being committed and the likelihood that people we that are being committed and the likelihood that people we could that are being committed and the likelihood that people we could help likelihood that people we could help better likelihood that people we could help better may likelihood that people we could help better may end likelihood that people we could help better may end up likelihood that people we could help better may end up on likelihood that people we could help better may end up on the likelihood that people we could help better may end up on the path likelihood that people we could help better may end up on the path to better may end up on the path to crime. better may end up on the path to crime. I'd better may end up on the path to crime. I'd have better may end up on the path to crime. I'd have to better may end up on the path to crime. I'd have to say better may end up on the path to crime. I'd have to say if better may end up on the path to crime. I'd have to say if it better may end up on the path to crime. I'd have to say if it was crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, then crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, then we crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, then we would crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, then we would have crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, then we would have fixed crime. I'd have to say if it was simple, then we would have fixed it simple, then we would have fixed it all simple, then we would have fixed it all already, simple, then we would have fixed it all already, but simple, then we would have fixed it all already, but it's simple, then we would have fixed it all already, but it's a simple, then we would have fixed it all already, but it's a bit all already, but it's a bit complicated. complicated. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> How <INTERRUPTION> How can <INTERRUPTION> How can spending <INTERRUPTION> How can spending a <INTERRUPTION> How can spending a billion <INTERRUPTION> How can spending a billion dollars How can spending a billion dollars on How can spending a billion dollars on a How can spending a billion dollars on a new How can spending a billion dollars on a new prison How can spending a billion dollars on a new prison be How can spending a billion dollars on a new prison be an How can spending a billion dollars on a new prison be an effective How can spending a billion dollars on a new prison be an effective use on a new prison be an effective use of on a new prison be an effective use of public on a new prison be an effective use of public money? on a new prison be an effective use of public money? In on a new prison be an effective use of public money? In line on a new prison be an effective use of public money? In line with on a new prison be an effective use of public money? In line with his of public money? In line with his own of public money? In line with his own goal of public money? In line with his own goal of of public money? In line with his own goal of evidence-based of public money? In line with his own goal of evidence-based practice, own goal of evidence-based practice, given own goal of evidence-based practice, given the own goal of evidence-based practice, given the existing, own goal of evidence-based practice, given the existing, overwhelming given the existing, overwhelming evidence, given the existing, overwhelming evidence, that given the existing, overwhelming evidence, that sending given the existing, overwhelming evidence, that sending more given the existing, overwhelming evidence, that sending more people evidence, that sending more people to evidence, that sending more people to prison evidence, that sending more people to prison increases evidence, that sending more people to prison increases reoffending, to prison increases reoffending, rather to prison increases reoffending, rather than to prison increases reoffending, rather than reducing to prison increases reoffending, rather than reducing it? to prison increases reoffending, rather than reducing it? I to prison increases reoffending, rather than reducing it? I mean, to prison increases reoffending, rather than reducing it? I mean, if rather than reducing it? I mean, if it rather than reducing it? I mean, if it was rather than reducing it? I mean, if it was just rather than reducing it? I mean, if it was just a rather than reducing it? I mean, if it was just a simple rather than reducing it? I mean, if it was just a simple choice rather than reducing it? I mean, if it was just a simple choice like it was just a simple choice like that, it was just a simple choice like that, then it was just a simple choice like that, then you it was just a simple choice like that, then you would it was just a simple choice like that, then you would choose it was just a simple choice like that, then you would choose not it was just a simple choice like that, then you would choose not to that, then you would choose not to spend that, then you would choose not to spend a that, then you would choose not to spend a billion that, then you would choose not to spend a billion on that, then you would choose not to spend a billion on prisons. that, then you would choose not to spend a billion on prisons. But that, then you would choose not to spend a billion on prisons. But the spend a billion on prisons. But the fact spend a billion on prisons. But the fact is spend a billion on prisons. But the fact is that spend a billion on prisons. But the fact is that the spend a billion on prisons. But the fact is that the people spend a billion on prisons. But the fact is that the people going spend a billion on prisons. But the fact is that the people going into fact is that the people going into the fact is that the people going into the beds fact is that the people going into the beds are fact is that the people going into the beds are people fact is that the people going into the beds are people who fact is that the people going into the beds are people who have the beds are people who have committed the beds are people who have committed serious, the beds are people who have committed serious, violent, the beds are people who have committed serious, violent, or committed serious, violent, or sexual committed serious, violent, or sexual or committed serious, violent, or sexual or drug-related committed serious, violent, or sexual or drug-related crimes committed serious, violent, or sexual or drug-related crimes and sexual or drug-related crimes and they sexual or drug-related crimes and they are sexual or drug-related crimes and they are being sexual or drug-related crimes and they are being sentenced sexual or drug-related crimes and they are being sentenced according they are being sentenced according to they are being sentenced according to the they are being sentenced according to the laws they are being sentenced according to the laws passed they are being sentenced according to the laws passed by they are being sentenced according to the laws passed by this to the laws passed by this Parliament. Parliament. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> We <INTERRUPTION> We simply <INTERRUPTION> We simply have <INTERRUPTION> We simply have to <INTERRUPTION> We simply have to build <INTERRUPTION> We simply have to build the <INTERRUPTION> We simply have to build the beds <INTERRUPTION> We simply have to build the beds or We simply have to build the beds or there We simply have to build the beds or there will We simply have to build the beds or there will be We simply have to build the beds or there will be nowhere We simply have to build the beds or there will be nowhere to We simply have to build the beds or there will be nowhere to put We simply have to build the beds or there will be nowhere to put people there will be nowhere to put people who there will be nowhere to put people who are there will be nowhere to put people who are potentially there will be nowhere to put people who are potentially quite there will be nowhere to put people who are potentially quite dangerous who are potentially quite dangerous to who are potentially quite dangerous to our who are potentially quite dangerous to our community. who are potentially quite dangerous to our community. At who are potentially quite dangerous to our community. At the who are potentially quite dangerous to our community. At the same who are potentially quite dangerous to our community. At the same time, to our community. At the same time, the to our community. At the same time, the Government to our community. At the same time, the Government is to our community. At the same time, the Government is focusing to our community. At the same time, the Government is focusing on the Government is focusing on improving the Government is focusing on improving rehabilitation the Government is focusing on improving rehabilitation and improving rehabilitation and continuing improving rehabilitation and continuing to improving rehabilitation and continuing to reduce improving rehabilitation and continuing to reduce the improving rehabilitation and continuing to reduce the flow, continuing to reduce the flow, particularly continuing to reduce the flow, particularly of continuing to reduce the flow, particularly of younger continuing to reduce the flow, particularly of younger people, continuing to reduce the flow, particularly of younger people, into particularly of younger people, into our particularly of younger people, into our court particularly of younger people, into our court system. our court system. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> How <INTERRUPTION> How does <INTERRUPTION> How does the <INTERRUPTION> How does the Minister <INTERRUPTION> How does the Minister plan <INTERRUPTION> How does the Minister plan to <INTERRUPTION> How does the Minister plan to fund How does the Minister plan to fund the How does the Minister plan to fund the inevitable How does the Minister plan to fund the inevitable future How does the Minister plan to fund the inevitable future growth How does the Minister plan to fund the inevitable future growth in the inevitable future growth in prison the inevitable future growth in prison population the inevitable future growth in prison population that the inevitable future growth in prison population that his prison population that his Government's prison population that his Government's current prison population that his Government's current policies prison population that his Government's current policies are Government's current policies are creating? Government's current policies are creating? In Government's current policies are creating? In the Government's current policies are creating? In the first Government's current policies are creating? In the first place, Government's current policies are creating? In the first place, we creating? In the first place, we want creating? In the first place, we want to creating? In the first place, we want to use creating? In the first place, we want to use the creating? In the first place, we want to use the social creating? In the first place, we want to use the social investment want to use the social investment tools want to use the social investment tools that want to use the social investment tools that have want to use the social investment tools that have now want to use the social investment tools that have now been want to use the social investment tools that have now been developed tools that have now been developed to tools that have now been developed to reduce tools that have now been developed to reduce the tools that have now been developed to reduce the future tools that have now been developed to reduce the future growth. tools that have now been developed to reduce the future growth. But tools that have now been developed to reduce the future growth. But the to reduce the future growth. But the fact to reduce the future growth. But the fact is to reduce the future growth. But the fact is that to reduce the future growth. But the fact is that if to reduce the future growth. But the fact is that if according to reduce the future growth. But the fact is that if according to to reduce the future growth. But the fact is that if according to the to reduce the future growth. But the fact is that if according to the law fact is that if according to the law of fact is that if according to the law of the fact is that if according to the law of the land, fact is that if according to the law of the land, the fact is that if according to the law of the land, the courts fact is that if according to the law of the land, the courts sentence of the land, the courts sentence dangerous of the land, the courts sentence dangerous people of the land, the courts sentence dangerous people to of the land, the courts sentence dangerous people to be of the land, the courts sentence dangerous people to be locked of the land, the courts sentence dangerous people to be locked up, dangerous people to be locked up, then dangerous people to be locked up, then we dangerous people to be locked up, then we will dangerous people to be locked up, then we will be dangerous people to be locked up, then we will be locking dangerous people to be locked up, then we will be locking them dangerous people to be locked up, then we will be locking them up. then we will be locking them up. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Question <INTERRUPTION> Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 10. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 10. Thank <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 10. Thank you <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 10. Thank you very Question No. 10. Thank you very much, Question No. 10. Thank you very much, Mr Question No. 10. Thank you very much, Mr Speaker! My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Education: My question is to the Minister of Education: How My question is to the Minister of Education: How is My question is to the Minister of Education: How is the My question is to the Minister of Education: How is the Government of Education: How is the Government helping of Education: How is the Government helping students of Education: How is the Government helping students use helping students use the helping students use the internet helping students use the internet for helping students use the internet for learning? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Tena <INTERRUPTION> Tena koe. <INTERRUPTION> Tena koe. By <INTERRUPTION> Tena koe. By making <INTERRUPTION> Tena koe. By making it <INTERRUPTION> Tena koe. By making it available <INTERRUPTION> Tena koe. By making it available to Tena koe. By making it available to them. Tena koe. By making it available to them. Yesterday, Tena koe. By making it available to them. Yesterday, I Tena koe. By making it available to them. Yesterday, I was Tena koe. By making it available to them. Yesterday, I was pleased Tena koe. By making it available to them. Yesterday, I was pleased to them. Yesterday, I was pleased to announce them. Yesterday, I was pleased to announce that them. Yesterday, I was pleased to announce that we them. Yesterday, I was pleased to announce that we have them. Yesterday, I was pleased to announce that we have completed announce that we have completed connections announce that we have completed connections to announce that we have completed connections to the announce that we have completed connections to the $211 announce that we have completed connections to the $211 million announce that we have completed connections to the $211 million N connections to the $211 million N for connections to the $211 million N for L connections to the $211 million N for L managed connections to the $211 million N for L managed network connections to the $211 million N for L managed network project. connections to the $211 million N for L managed network project. This for L managed network project. This network for L managed network project. This network provides for L managed network project. This network provides schools for L managed network project. This network provides schools with for L managed network project. This network provides schools with ultra network provides schools with ultra fast, network provides schools with ultra fast, uncapped, network provides schools with ultra fast, uncapped, high network provides schools with ultra fast, uncapped, high quality network provides schools with ultra fast, uncapped, high quality data network provides schools with ultra fast, uncapped, high quality data at fast, uncapped, high quality data at no fast, uncapped, high quality data at no cost fast, uncapped, high quality data at no cost to fast, uncapped, high quality data at no cost to schools fast, uncapped, high quality data at no cost to schools through fast, uncapped, high quality data at no cost to schools through the no cost to schools through the Government-funded no cost to schools through the Government-funded internet. no cost to schools through the Government-funded internet. An no cost to schools through the Government-funded internet. An event Government-funded internet. An event marking Government-funded internet. An event marking this Government-funded internet. An event marking this milestone Government-funded internet. An event marking this milestone was Government-funded internet. An event marking this milestone was held marking this milestone was held yesterday marking this milestone was held yesterday and marking this milestone was held yesterday and while marking this milestone was held yesterday and while I marking this milestone was held yesterday and while I was marking this milestone was held yesterday and while I was unable marking this milestone was held yesterday and while I was unable to yesterday and while I was unable to attend, yesterday and while I was unable to attend, the yesterday and while I was unable to attend, the energetic, yesterday and while I was unable to attend, the energetic, fresh, attend, the energetic, fresh, future-focused attend, the energetic, fresh, future-focused Mr attend, the energetic, fresh, future-focused Mr Bishop attend, the energetic, fresh, future-focused Mr Bishop was future-focused Mr Bishop was representing future-focused Mr Bishop was representing us future-focused Mr Bishop was representing us there. representing us there. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Giving <INTERRUPTION> Giving substance, <INTERRUPTION> Giving substance, giving <INTERRUPTION> Giving substance, giving practicalle Giving substance, giving practicalle support Giving substance, giving practicalle support to Giving substance, giving practicalle support to the Giving substance, giving practicalle support to the self-described support to the self-described technology support to the self-described technology valley. technology valley. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> By <INTERRUPTION> By using <INTERRUPTION> By using it, <INTERRUPTION> By using it, scores <INTERRUPTION> By using it, scores of <INTERRUPTION> By using it, scores of students By using it, scores of students across By using it, scores of students across New By using it, scores of students across New Zealand By using it, scores of students across New Zealand doctor By using it, scores of students across New Zealand doctor magazine across New Zealand doctor magazine can across New Zealand doctor magazine can access across New Zealand doctor magazine can access the across New Zealand doctor magazine can access the vast across New Zealand doctor magazine can access the vast world across New Zealand doctor magazine can access the vast world of can access the vast world of learning can access the vast world of learning available can access the vast world of learning available online can access the vast world of learning available online to can access the vast world of learning available online to better learning available online to better prepare learning available online to better prepare them learning available online to better prepare them to learning available online to better prepare them to meet learning available online to better prepare them to meet the learning available online to better prepare them to meet the demands learning available online to better prepare them to meet the demands of prepare them to meet the demands of a prepare them to meet the demands of a rapidly prepare them to meet the demands of a rapidly evolving prepare them to meet the demands of a rapidly evolving digital prepare them to meet the demands of a rapidly evolving digital world. a rapidly evolving digital world. The a rapidly evolving digital world. The rollout a rapidly evolving digital world. The rollout of a rapidly evolving digital world. The rollout of the a rapidly evolving digital world. The rollout of the core The rollout of the core infrastructure The rollout of the core infrastructure provides The rollout of the core infrastructure provides the infrastructure provides the foundation infrastructure provides the foundation for infrastructure provides the foundation for our infrastructure provides the foundation for our work infrastructure provides the foundation for our work such infrastructure provides the foundation for our work such as foundation for our work such as incorporating foundation for our work such as incorporating digital foundation for our work such as incorporating digital technology incorporating digital technology into incorporating digital technology into the incorporating digital technology into the curriculum incorporating digital technology into the curriculum from incorporating digital technology into the curriculum from 2018, incorporating digital technology into the curriculum from 2018, and into the curriculum from 2018, and reflects into the curriculum from 2018, and reflects our into the curriculum from 2018, and reflects our Government's into the curriculum from 2018, and reflects our Government's absolute reflects our Government's absolute commitment reflects our Government's absolute commitment to reflects our Government's absolute commitment to enabling reflects our Government's absolute commitment to enabling 21st reflects our Government's absolute commitment to enabling 21st century commitment to enabling 21st century learning commitment to enabling 21st century learning to flourish. commitment to enabling 21st century learning to flourish. Unlike commitment to enabling 21st century learning to flourish. Unlike the learning to flourish. Unlike the 19th learning to flourish. Unlike the 19th century learning to flourish. Unlike the 19th century person learning to flourish. Unlike the 19th century person over learning to flourish. Unlike the 19th century person over there. 19th century person over there. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . Order! <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Thank <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Thank you <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Thank you very <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Thank you very much, <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Thank you very much, Mr . Order! Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. . Order! Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. To . Order! Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. To the . Order! Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. To the Minister . Order! Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. To the Minister - . Order! Thank you very much, Mr Speaker. To the Minister - what Speaker. To the Minister - what other Speaker. To the Minister - what other information Speaker. To the Minister - what other information can Speaker. To the Minister - what other information can the Speaker. To the Minister - what other information can the Minister other information can the Minister provide other information can the Minister provide on other information can the Minister provide on the other information can the Minister provide on the completion other information can the Minister provide on the completion of other information can the Minister provide on the completion of the other information can the Minister provide on the completion of the NN provide on the completion of the NN for provide on the completion of the NN for L provide on the completion of the NN for L managed provide on the completion of the NN for L managed network? provide on the completion of the NN for L managed network? To provide on the completion of the NN for L managed network? To answer provide on the completion of the NN for L managed network? To answer the for L managed network? To answer the member's for L managed network? To answer the member's thirst for L managed network? To answer the member's thirst for for L managed network? To answer the member's thirst for knowledge, for L managed network? To answer the member's thirst for knowledge, N for L managed network? To answer the member's thirst for knowledge, N for member's thirst for knowledge, N for L member's thirst for knowledge, N for L stands member's thirst for knowledge, N for L stands for member's thirst for knowledge, N for L stands for Network member's thirst for knowledge, N for L stands for Network for member's thirst for knowledge, N for L stands for Network for Learning. L stands for Network for Learning. The L stands for Network for Learning. The schools L stands for Network for Learning. The schools are L stands for Network for Learning. The schools are now L stands for Network for Learning. The schools are now able L stands for Network for Learning. The schools are now able to L stands for Network for Learning. The schools are now able to connect The schools are now able to connect and The schools are now able to connect and 97%, The schools are now able to connect and 97%, or The schools are now able to connect and 97%, or 2,431 The schools are now able to connect and 97%, or 2,431 schools The schools are now able to connect and 97%, or 2,431 schools are and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already connected and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already connected to and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already connected to the and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already connected to the N and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already connected to the N 4 and 97%, or 2,431 schools are already connected to the N 4 L already connected to the N 4 L network. already connected to the N 4 L network. More already connected to the N 4 L network. More than already connected to the N 4 L network. More than 479,000 already connected to the N 4 L network. More than 479,000 students network. More than 479,000 students are network. More than 479,000 students are using network. More than 479,000 students are using it. network. More than 479,000 students are using it. This network. More than 479,000 students are using it. This involved network. More than 479,000 students are using it. This involved a network. More than 479,000 students are using it. This involved a large are using it. This involved a large scale are using it. This involved a large scale rollout are using it. This involved a large scale rollout and are using it. This involved a large scale rollout and was are using it. This involved a large scale rollout and was completed scale rollout and was completed ahead scale rollout and was completed ahead of scale rollout and was completed ahead of schedule scale rollout and was completed ahead of schedule and scale rollout and was completed ahead of schedule and within scale rollout and was completed ahead of schedule and within budget. ahead of schedule and within budget. The ahead of schedule and within budget. The network's ahead of schedule and within budget. The network's creation ahead of schedule and within budget. The network's creation has ahead of schedule and within budget. The network's creation has been ahead of schedule and within budget. The network's creation has been part The network's creation has been part of The network's creation has been part of this The network's creation has been part of this Government's The network's creation has been part of this Government's $700 The network's creation has been part of this Government's $700 million of this Government's $700 million investment of this Government's $700 million investment in of this Government's $700 million investment in infrastructure of this Government's $700 million investment in infrastructure and investment in infrastructure and connectivity, investment in infrastructure and connectivity, N investment in infrastructure and connectivity, N 4 investment in infrastructure and connectivity, N 4 L's investment in infrastructure and connectivity, N 4 L's focus investment in infrastructure and connectivity, N 4 L's focus will connectivity, N 4 L's focus will turn connectivity, N 4 L's focus will turn to connectivity, N 4 L's focus will turn to enhancing connectivity, N 4 L's focus will turn to enhancing focuses, turn to enhancing focuses, developing turn to enhancing focuses, developing new turn to enhancing focuses, developing new platforms turn to enhancing focuses, developing new platforms to turn to enhancing focuses, developing new platforms to help developing new platforms to help schools developing new platforms to help schools make developing new platforms to help schools make the developing new platforms to help schools make the most developing new platforms to help schools make the most of developing new platforms to help schools make the most of their schools make the most of their digital schools make the most of their digital connections. schools make the most of their digital connections. And schools make the most of their digital connections. And the schools make the most of their digital connections. And the house digital connections. And the house erupted digital connections. And the house erupted with digital connections. And the house erupted with applause! digital connections. And the house erupted with applause! No, digital connections. And the house erupted with applause! No, sorry, digital connections. And the house erupted with applause! No, sorry, Mr erupted with applause! No, sorry, Mr Speaker! Speaker! <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Question <INTERRUPTION> Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 11. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Police: My question is to the Minister of Police: Does My question is to the Minister of Police: Does she My question is to the Minister of Police: Does she think of Police: Does she think there of Police: Does she think there is of Police: Does she think there is any of Police: Does she think there is any correlation there is any correlation between there is any correlation between the there is any correlation between the closure there is any correlation between the closure of there is any correlation between the closure of over there is any correlation between the closure of over 20 between the closure of over 20 Community between the closure of over 20 Community Policing between the closure of over 20 Community Policing Centres Community Policing Centres and Community Policing Centres and the Community Policing Centres and the 13,000 Community Policing Centres and the 13,000 increase and the 13,000 increase in and the 13,000 increase in victimisations and the 13,000 increase in victimisations in and the 13,000 increase in victimisations in the and the 13,000 increase in victimisations in the last and the 13,000 increase in victimisations in the last 12 in victimisations in the last 12 months; in victimisations in the last 12 months; if in victimisations in the last 12 months; if not, in victimisations in the last 12 months; if not, why in victimisations in the last 12 months; if not, why not? The The member The member is The member is wrong. The member is wrong. Community The member is wrong. Community policing The member is wrong. Community policing centres The member is wrong. Community policing centres are The member is wrong. Community policing centres are not The member is wrong. Community policing centres are not closing. policing centres are not closing. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Police <INTERRUPTION> Police announced <INTERRUPTION> Police announced a... Police announced a... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . Police <INTERRUPTION> . Police announced <INTERRUPTION> . Police announced a <INTERRUPTION> . Police announced a front <INTERRUPTION> . Police announced a front counter . Police announced a front counter safety . Police announced a front counter safety review . Police announced a front counter safety review last . Police announced a front counter safety review last year . Police announced a front counter safety review last year in . Police announced a front counter safety review last year in response safety review last year in response to safety review last year in response to concerns safety review last year in response to concerns raised safety review last year in response to concerns raised by safety review last year in response to concerns raised by their safety review last year in response to concerns raised by their own to concerns raised by their own staff, to concerns raised by their own staff, and to concerns raised by their own staff, and I'm to concerns raised by their own staff, and I'm sorry to concerns raised by their own staff, and I'm sorry that to concerns raised by their own staff, and I'm sorry that that staff, and I'm sorry that that member staff, and I'm sorry that that member doesn't staff, and I'm sorry that that member doesn't take staff, and I'm sorry that that member doesn't take that staff, and I'm sorry that that member doesn't take that seriously. member doesn't take that seriously. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> This <INTERRUPTION> This work <INTERRUPTION> This work was <INTERRUPTION> This work was instigated <INTERRUPTION> This work was instigated following This work was instigated following a... This work was instigated following a... Very This work was instigated following a... Very serious This work was instigated following a... Very serious assault This work was instigated following a... Very serious assault on This work was instigated following a... Very serious assault on a This work was instigated following a... Very serious assault on a staff a... Very serious assault on a staff member... member... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> I'm <INTERRUPTION> I'm advised <INTERRUPTION> I'm advised that <INTERRUPTION> I'm advised that 90% <INTERRUPTION> I'm advised that 90% of <INTERRUPTION> I'm advised that 90% of the <INTERRUPTION> I'm advised that 90% of the sites I'm advised that 90% of the sites have I'm advised that 90% of the sites have been I'm advised that 90% of the sites have been safety I'm advised that 90% of the sites have been safety assessed I'm advised that 90% of the sites have been safety assessed and I'm advised that 90% of the sites have been safety assessed and the have been safety assessed and the remaining have been safety assessed and the remaining will have been safety assessed and the remaining will be have been safety assessed and the remaining will be completed have been safety assessed and the remaining will be completed by remaining will be completed by Christmas. Christmas. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> To <INTERRUPTION> To the <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what is <INTERRUPTION> To the Minister, what is her To the Minister, what is her response To the Minister, what is her response to To the Minister, what is her response to the To the Minister, what is her response to the official To the Minister, what is her response to the official police response to the official police statistics response to the official police statistics that response to the official police statistics that show response to the official police statistics that show burglaries response to the official police statistics that show burglaries are statistics that show burglaries are up statistics that show burglaries are up by statistics that show burglaries are up by 18% statistics that show burglaries are up by 18% in statistics that show burglaries are up by 18% in the statistics that show burglaries are up by 18% in the last statistics that show burglaries are up by 18% in the last year, statistics that show burglaries are up by 18% in the last year, or up by 18% in the last year, or almost up by 18% in the last year, or almost 11,000 up by 18% in the last year, or almost 11,000 more up by 18% in the last year, or almost 11,000 more victims? up by 18% in the last year, or almost 11,000 more victims? And up by 18% in the last year, or almost 11,000 more victims? And the almost 11,000 more victims? And the Police almost 11,000 more victims? And the Police Assiociation almost 11,000 more victims? And the Police Assiociation is almost 11,000 more victims? And the Police Assiociation is describing Police Assiociation is describing the Police Assiociation is describing the frontline Police Assiociation is describing the frontline as Police Assiociation is describing the frontline as being Police Assiociation is describing the frontline as being at, Police Assiociation is describing the frontline as being at, "crisis the frontline as being at, "crisis point". the frontline as being at, "crisis point". The the frontline as being at, "crisis point". The member the frontline as being at, "crisis point". The member has the frontline as being at, "crisis point". The member has referred the frontline as being at, "crisis point". The member has referred to point". The member has referred to the point". The member has referred to the Police point". The member has referred to the Police Assiociation. point". The member has referred to the Police Assiociation. I point". The member has referred to the Police Assiociation. I don't the Police Assiociation. I don't agree the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with some the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with some of the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with some of the the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with some of the views the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with some of the views of the Police Assiociation. I don't agree with some of the views of some agree with some of the views of some of agree with some of the views of some of the agree with some of the views of some of the former agree with some of the views of some of the former leaders agree with some of the views of some of the former leaders of agree with some of the views of some of the former leaders of the of the former leaders of the Association of the former leaders of the Association that of the former leaders of the Association that burglaries of the former leaders of the Association that burglaries are of the former leaders of the Association that burglaries are not Association that burglaries are not important. Association that burglaries are not important. I Association that burglaries are not important. I think Association that burglaries are not important. I think they're Association that burglaries are not important. I think they're very important. I think they're very important. important. I think they're very important. And important. I think they're very important. And I important. I think they're very important. And I think important. I think they're very important. And I think that important. I think they're very important. And I think that the important. And I think that the police important. And I think that the police commissioner important. And I think that the police commissioner making police commissioner making burglaries police commissioner making burglaries a police commissioner making burglaries a priority police commissioner making burglaries a priority offence, police commissioner making burglaries a priority offence, as burglaries a priority offence, as they burglaries a priority offence, as they should burglaries a priority offence, as they should always burglaries a priority offence, as they should always have burglaries a priority offence, as they should always have been, burglaries a priority offence, as they should always have been, has they should always have been, has made they should always have been, has made exactly they should always have been, has made exactly the they should always have been, has made exactly the right they should always have been, has made exactly the right decision they should always have been, has made exactly the right decision and made exactly the right decision and I made exactly the right decision and I utterly made exactly the right decision and I utterly support made exactly the right decision and I utterly support him made exactly the right decision and I utterly support him in made exactly the right decision and I utterly support him in it, made exactly the right decision and I utterly support him in it, which I utterly support him in it, which is I utterly support him in it, which is why I utterly support him in it, which is why police I utterly support him in it, which is why police have I utterly support him in it, which is why police have committed I utterly support him in it, which is why police have committed to is why police have committed to attend is why police have committed to attend as is why police have committed to attend as many is why police have committed to attend as many as is why police have committed to attend as many as they is why police have committed to attend as many as they can is why police have committed to attend as many as they can as is why police have committed to attend as many as they can as in is why police have committed to attend as many as they can as in up attend as many as they can as in up to attend as many as they can as in up to 100% attend as many as they can as in up to 100% of attend as many as they can as in up to 100% of all attend as many as they can as in up to 100% of all domestic attend as many as they can as in up to 100% of all domestic burglaries. to 100% of all domestic burglaries. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! What <INTERRUPTION> Order! What is <INTERRUPTION> Order! What is her <INTERRUPTION> Order! What is her message <INTERRUPTION> Order! What is her message to <INTERRUPTION> Order! What is her message to the Order! What is her message to the people Order! What is her message to the people of Order! What is her message to the people of Canterbury Order! What is her message to the people of Canterbury who Order! What is her message to the people of Canterbury who have Order! What is her message to the people of Canterbury who have seen Order! What is her message to the people of Canterbury who have seen a people of Canterbury who have seen a 41% people of Canterbury who have seen a 41% increase people of Canterbury who have seen a 41% increase in people of Canterbury who have seen a 41% increase in burglaries people of Canterbury who have seen a 41% increase in burglaries and people of Canterbury who have seen a 41% increase in burglaries and where 41% increase in burglaries and where some 41% increase in burglaries and where some dairy 41% increase in burglaries and where some dairy owners 41% increase in burglaries and where some dairy owners are 41% increase in burglaries and where some dairy owners are saying 41% increase in burglaries and where some dairy owners are saying that some dairy owners are saying that they're some dairy owners are saying that they're closing some dairy owners are saying that they're closing up some dairy owners are saying that they're closing up early some dairy owners are saying that they're closing up early just some dairy owners are saying that they're closing up early just to they're closing up early just to avoid they're closing up early just to avoid being they're closing up early just to avoid being robbed? they're closing up early just to avoid being robbed? Well, they're closing up early just to avoid being robbed? Well, I'm they're closing up early just to avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say help avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say help is avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say help is on avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say help is on its avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say help is on its way. avoid being robbed? Well, I'm here to say help is on its way. Thank to say help is on its way. Thank goodness to say help is on its way. Thank goodness it's to say help is on its way. Thank goodness it's a to say help is on its way. Thank goodness it's a National-led goodness it's a National-led Government goodness it's a National-led Government and goodness it's a National-led Government and not goodness it's a National-led Government and not a goodness it's a National-led Government and not a Labour goodness it's a National-led Government and not a Labour one. Government and not a Labour one. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Does <INTERRUPTION> Does she <INTERRUPTION> Does she believe <INTERRUPTION> Does she believe the <INTERRUPTION> Does she believe the Minister <INTERRUPTION> Does she believe the Minister of Does she believe the Minister of Finance Does she believe the Minister of Finance has Does she believe the Minister of Finance has given Does she believe the Minister of Finance has given her Does she believe the Minister of Finance has given her all Does she believe the Minister of Finance has given her all the Finance has given her all the funding Finance has given her all the funding she Finance has given her all the funding she needs Finance has given her all the funding she needs for Finance has given her all the funding she needs for police Finance has given her all the funding she needs for police to funding she needs for police to address funding she needs for police to address the funding she needs for police to address the issues funding she needs for police to address the issues around funding she needs for police to address the issues around increasing address the issues around increasing crime address the issues around increasing crime rates, address the issues around increasing crime rates, falling address the issues around increasing crime rates, falling resolution crime rates, falling resolution rates crime rates, falling resolution rates and crime rates, falling resolution rates and the crime rates, falling resolution rates and the state crime rates, falling resolution rates and the state of crime rates, falling resolution rates and the state of the crime rates, falling resolution rates and the state of the policing rates and the state of the policing centres? centres? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! We'll <INTERRUPTION> Order! We'll soon <INTERRUPTION> Order! We'll soon see, <INTERRUPTION> Order! We'll soon see, won't <INTERRUPTION> Order! We'll soon see, won't we. Order! We'll soon see, won't we. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order, <INTERRUPTION> Order, I <INTERRUPTION> Order, I haven't <INTERRUPTION> Order, I haven't called <INTERRUPTION> Order, I haven't called the <INTERRUPTION> Order, I haven't called the member Order, I haven't called the member yet. Order, I haven't called the member yet. Now. Order, I haven't called the member yet. Now. Does Order, I haven't called the member yet. Now. Does she Order, I haven't called the member yet. Now. Does she agree Order, I haven't called the member yet. Now. Does she agree with Order, I haven't called the member yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly when yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly when she yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly when she said yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly when she said in yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly when she said in question yet. Now. Does she agree with Ann Tolly when she said in question time Tolly when she said in question time last Tolly when she said in question time last week, Tolly when she said in question time last week, "That Tolly when she said in question time last week, "That I Tolly when she said in question time last week, "That I judge Tolly when she said in question time last week, "That I judge a Tolly when she said in question time last week, "That I judge a person Tolly when she said in question time last week, "That I judge a person on last week, "That I judge a person on their last week, "That I judge a person on their actions, last week, "That I judge a person on their actions, not last week, "That I judge a person on their actions, not their last week, "That I judge a person on their actions, not their words". last week, "That I judge a person on their actions, not their words". And their actions, not their words". And if their actions, not their words". And if so, their actions, not their words". And if so, after their actions, not their words". And if so, after six their actions, not their words". And if so, after six months their actions, not their words". And if so, after six months of their actions, not their words". And if so, after six months of promises, if so, after six months of promises, when if so, after six months of promises, when is if so, after six months of promises, when is she if so, after six months of promises, when is she going if so, after six months of promises, when is she going to if so, after six months of promises, when is she going to deliver if so, after six months of promises, when is she going to deliver more when is she going to deliver more police? when is she going to deliver more police? There when is she going to deliver more police? There will when is she going to deliver more police? There will be when is she going to deliver more police? There will be an police? There will be an announcement police? There will be an announcement in police? There will be an announcement in due police? There will be an announcement in due course police? There will be an announcement in due course and police? There will be an announcement in due course and the announcement in due course and the member announcement in due course and the member should announcement in due course and the member should just announcement in due course and the member should just wait. member should just wait. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> When <INTERRUPTION> When she <INTERRUPTION> When she said <INTERRUPTION> When she said recently <INTERRUPTION> When she said recently that <INTERRUPTION> When she said recently that any When she said recently that any announcement When she said recently that any announcement about When she said recently that any announcement about increased When she said recently that any announcement about increased police announcement about increased police numbers announcement about increased police numbers would announcement about increased police numbers would be announcement about increased police numbers would be made announcement about increased police numbers would be made by announcement about increased police numbers would be made by the announcement about increased police numbers would be made by the PM, announcement about increased police numbers would be made by the PM, was numbers would be made by the PM, was she numbers would be made by the PM, was she referring numbers would be made by the PM, was she referring to numbers would be made by the PM, was she referring to herself? numbers would be made by the PM, was she referring to herself? Ha, numbers would be made by the PM, was she referring to herself? Ha, ha! she referring to herself? Ha, ha! <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . I <INTERRUPTION> . I believe <INTERRUPTION> . I believe that <INTERRUPTION> . I believe that any <INTERRUPTION> . I believe that any announcement . I believe that any announcement will . I believe that any announcement will be . I believe that any announcement will be made . I believe that any announcement will be made from . I believe that any announcement will be made from whoever . I believe that any announcement will be made from whoever is . I believe that any announcement will be made from whoever is the . I believe that any announcement will be made from whoever is the PM, will be made from whoever is the PM, but will be made from whoever is the PM, but I will be made from whoever is the PM, but I know will be made from whoever is the PM, but I know this, will be made from whoever is the PM, but I know this, it will be made from whoever is the PM, but I know this, it won't will be made from whoever is the PM, but I know this, it won't be will be made from whoever is the PM, but I know this, it won't be anyone but I know this, it won't be anyone from but I know this, it won't be anyone from that but I know this, it won't be anyone from that side but I know this, it won't be anyone from that side of but I know this, it won't be anyone from that side of the but I know this, it won't be anyone from that side of the house. but I know this, it won't be anyone from that side of the house. Ha, but I know this, it won't be anyone from that side of the house. Ha, ha! from that side of the house. Ha, ha! <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Question <INTERRUPTION> Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Question No. 12. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Women: My question is to the Minister for Women: How My question is to the Minister for Women: How is My question is to the Minister for Women: How is the My question is to the Minister for Women: How is the Government for Women: How is the Government encouraging for Women: How is the Government encouraging more for Women: How is the Government encouraging more young for Women: How is the Government encouraging more young girls encouraging more young girls and encouraging more young girls and women encouraging more young girls and women to encouraging more young girls and women to pursue encouraging more young girls and women to pursue career and women to pursue career opportunities and women to pursue career opportunities in and women to pursue career opportunities in science, opportunities in science, technology, opportunities in science, technology, engineering, opportunities in science, technology, engineering, and opportunities in science, technology, engineering, and maths? The The Government The Government is The Government is making The Government is making good The Government is making good progress, The Government is making good progress, enkur The Government is making good progress, enkur dgeing The Government is making good progress, enkur dgeing more progress, enkur dgeing more qualifications progress, enkur dgeing more qualifications in progress, enkur dgeing more qualifications in science, qualifications in science, technology, qualifications in science, technology, engineering qualifications in science, technology, engineering and qualifications in science, technology, engineering and maths, technology, engineering and maths, or technology, engineering and maths, or STEM. technology, engineering and maths, or STEM. However, technology, engineering and maths, or STEM. However, women technology, engineering and maths, or STEM. However, women are or STEM. However, women are particularly or STEM. However, women are particularly under or STEM. However, women are particularly under remented or STEM. However, women are particularly under remented in or STEM. However, women are particularly under remented in the particularly under remented in the highest particularly under remented in the highest growth particularly under remented in the highest growth areas particularly under remented in the highest growth areas like particularly under remented in the highest growth areas like digital highest growth areas like digital technology, highest growth areas like digital technology, so highest growth areas like digital technology, so I've highest growth areas like digital technology, so I've made highest growth areas like digital technology, so I've made it highest growth areas like digital technology, so I've made it a technology, so I've made it a priority technology, so I've made it a priority to technology, so I've made it a priority to find technology, so I've made it a priority to find new technology, so I've made it a priority to find new ways technology, so I've made it a priority to find new ways of priority to find new ways of sparking priority to find new ways of sparking their priority to find new ways of sparking their interest. priority to find new ways of sparking their interest. Today, priority to find new ways of sparking their interest. Today, I've sparking their interest. Today, I've announced sparking their interest. Today, I've announced the sparking their interest. Today, I've announced the launch sparking their interest. Today, I've announced the launch of sparking their interest. Today, I've announced the launch of the sparking their interest. Today, I've announced the launch of the STEM announced the launch of the STEM Directory, announced the launch of the STEM Directory, which announced the launch of the STEM Directory, which is announced the launch of the STEM Directory, which is an announced the launch of the STEM Directory, which is an online announced the launch of the STEM Directory, which is an online tool Directory, which is an online tool developed Directory, which is an online tool developed by Directory, which is an online tool developed by the Directory, which is an online tool developed by the Ministry Directory, which is an online tool developed by the Ministry of Directory, which is an online tool developed by the Ministry of Women developed by the Ministry of Women which developed by the Ministry of Women which makes developed by the Ministry of Women which makes it developed by the Ministry of Women which makes it easier developed by the Ministry of Women which makes it easier for developed by the Ministry of Women which makes it easier for young which makes it easier for young girls which makes it easier for young girls and which makes it easier for young girls and women which makes it easier for young girls and women to which makes it easier for young girls and women to connect, which makes it easier for young girls and women to connect, discover girls and women to connect, discover and girls and women to connect, discover and learn girls and women to connect, discover and learn about girls and women to connect, discover and learn about the girls and women to connect, discover and learn about the opportunities and learn about the opportunities and and learn about the opportunities and ensure and learn about the opportunities and ensure that and learn about the opportunities and ensure that women and learn about the opportunities and ensure that women aren't and learn about the opportunities and ensure that women aren't left and ensure that women aren't left behind and ensure that women aren't left behind in and ensure that women aren't left behind in a and ensure that women aren't left behind in a constant and ensure that women aren't left behind in a constant lip and ensure that women aren't left behind in a constant lip changing behind in a constant lip changing workforce. behind in a constant lip changing workforce. What behind in a constant lip changing workforce. What other behind in a constant lip changing workforce. What other work behind in a constant lip changing workforce. What other work is behind in a constant lip changing workforce. What other work is under workforce. What other work is under way workforce. What other work is under way to workforce. What other work is under way to further workforce. What other work is under way to further support workforce. What other work is under way to further support women workforce. What other work is under way to further support women and way to further support women and girls way to further support women and girls in way to further support women and girls in education way to further support women and girls in education and way to further support women and girls in education and girls? way to further support women and girls in education and girls? The girls in education and girls? The ministry girls in education and girls? The ministry for girls in education and girls? The ministry for Women girls in education and girls? The ministry for Women is girls in education and girls? The ministry for Women is working girls in education and girls? The ministry for Women is working across ministry for Women is working across Government ministry for Women is working across Government to ministry for Women is working across Government to ensure ministry for Women is working across Government to ensure that ministry for Women is working across Government to ensure that women ministry for Women is working across Government to ensure that women and Government to ensure that women and girls Government to ensure that women and girls have Government to ensure that women and girls have greater Government to ensure that women and girls have greater opportunities Government to ensure that women and girls have greater opportunities in girls have greater opportunities in high girls have greater opportunities in high demand girls have greater opportunities in high demand areas. girls have greater opportunities in high demand areas. Ministry high demand areas. Ministry officials high demand areas. Ministry officials are high demand areas. Ministry officials are working high demand areas. Ministry officials are working with high demand areas. Ministry officials are working with MMPI high demand areas. Ministry officials are working with MMPI to officials are working with MMPI to better officials are working with MMPI to better understand officials are working with MMPI to better understand the officials are working with MMPI to better understand the barriers officials are working with MMPI to better understand the barriers to officials are working with MMPI to better understand the barriers to -- better understand the barriers to -- MPI better understand the barriers to -- MPI to better understand the barriers to -- MPI to better better understand the barriers to -- MPI to better understand better understand the barriers to -- MPI to better understand the MPI to better understand the barriers. MPI to better understand the barriers. Earlier, MPI to better understand the barriers. Earlier, the MPI to better understand the barriers. Earlier, the Minister barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced the barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced the opening barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced the opening of barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced the opening of a barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced the opening of a new barriers. Earlier, the Minister announced the opening of a new round announced the opening of a new round of announced the opening of a new round of scholarships announced the opening of a new round of scholarships to announced the opening of a new round of scholarships to encourage of scholarships to encourage graduates of scholarships to encourage graduates wanting of scholarships to encourage graduates wanting to of scholarships to encourage graduates wanting to become graduates wanting to become secondary graduates wanting to become secondary teachers graduates wanting to become secondary teachers in graduates wanting to become secondary teachers in STEM graduates wanting to become secondary teachers in STEM fields secondary teachers in STEM fields and secondary teachers in STEM fields and we're secondary teachers in STEM fields and we're advancing secondary teachers in STEM fields and we're advancing work secondary teachers in STEM fields and we're advancing work under secondary teachers in STEM fields and we're advancing work under the and we're advancing work under the national and we're advancing work under the national science and we're advancing work under the national science strategy, and we're advancing work under the national science strategy, a and we're advancing work under the national science strategy, a nation national science strategy, a nation of national science strategy, a nation of curious national science strategy, a nation of curious minds national science strategy, a nation of curious minds and national science strategy, a nation of curious minds and through national science strategy, a nation of curious minds and through the of curious minds and through the Make of curious minds and through the Make the of curious minds and through the Make the World of curious minds and through the Make the World Curious of curious minds and through the Make the World Curious awareness Make the World Curious awareness campaign Make the World Curious awareness campaign to Make the World Curious awareness campaign to increase Make the World Curious awareness campaign to increase STEM Make the World Curious awareness campaign to increase STEM graduates. campaign to increase STEM graduates. Ultimately, campaign to increase STEM graduates. Ultimately, it's campaign to increase STEM graduates. Ultimately, it's about campaign to increase STEM graduates. Ultimately, it's about recognising Ultimately, it's about recognising and Ultimately, it's about recognising and backing Ultimately, it's about recognising and backing fantastic Ultimately, it's about recognising and backing fantastic role Ultimately, it's about recognising and backing fantastic role models and backing fantastic role models like and backing fantastic role models like 25-year-old and backing fantastic role models like 25-year-old Kelly and backing fantastic role models like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, and backing fantastic role models like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, an like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, an offshore like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, an offshore well like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, an offshore well engineer like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, an offshore well engineer featured like 25-year-old Kelly Hobbs, an offshore well engineer featured in offshore well engineer featured in today's offshore well engineer featured in today's Taranaki offshore well engineer featured in today's Taranaki News. offshore well engineer featured in today's Taranaki News. She's offshore well engineer featured in today's Taranaki News. She's working today's Taranaki News. She's working with today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls as today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls as young today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls as young as today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls as young as 11 today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls as young as 11 in today's Taranaki News. She's working with girls as young as 11 in work with girls as young as 11 in work shops with girls as young as 11 in work shops funded with girls as young as 11 in work shops funded by with girls as young as 11 in work shops funded by the with girls as young as 11 in work shops funded by the Curious with girls as young as 11 in work shops funded by the Curious Minds shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund to shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund to show shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund to show the shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund to show the next shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund to show the next generation shops funded by the Curious Minds Fund to show the next generation of Fund to show the next generation of women Fund to show the next generation of women that Fund to show the next generation of women that they Fund to show the next generation of women that they absolutely Fund to show the next generation of women that they absolutely can Fund to show the next generation of women that they absolutely can and women that they absolutely can and must women that they absolutely can and must succeed? women that they absolutely can and must succeed? STEM. women that they absolutely can and must succeed? STEM. And women that they absolutely can and must succeed? STEM. And that must succeed? STEM. And that concludes must succeed? STEM. And that concludes questions must succeed? STEM. And that concludes questions for must succeed? STEM. And that concludes questions for oracle concludes questions for oracle answer. answer. On answer. On 1 answer. On 1 December, answer. On 1 December, Ron answer. On 1 December, Ron Mark answer. On 1 December, Ron Mark sought answer. On 1 December, Ron Mark sought a On 1 December, Ron Mark sought a considered On 1 December, Ron Mark sought a considered ruling On 1 December, Ron Mark sought a considered ruling on On 1 December, Ron Mark sought a considered ruling on whether On 1 December, Ron Mark sought a considered ruling on whether the considered ruling on whether the speaker considered ruling on whether the speaker is considered ruling on whether the speaker is a considered ruling on whether the speaker is a member considered ruling on whether the speaker is a member of considered ruling on whether the speaker is a member of the speaker is a member of the Government speaker is a member of the Government for speaker is a member of the Government for the speaker is a member of the Government for the purpose speaker is a member of the Government for the purpose of Government for the purpose of appropriations Government for the purpose of appropriations to Government for the purpose of appropriations to the Government for the purpose of appropriations to the Parliamentary appropriations to the Parliamentary Service. appropriations to the Parliamentary Service. The appropriations to the Parliamentary Service. The request appropriations to the Parliamentary Service. The request arose appropriations to the Parliamentary Service. The request arose from appropriations to the Parliamentary Service. The request arose from my Service. The request arose from my ruling Service. The request arose from my ruling on Service. The request arose from my ruling on 29 Service. The request arose from my ruling on 29 November Service. The request arose from my ruling on 29 November where Service. The request arose from my ruling on 29 November where I Service. The request arose from my ruling on 29 November where I did ruling on 29 November where I did not ruling on 29 November where I did not permit ruling on 29 November where I did not permit an ruling on 29 November where I did not permit an urge ruling on 29 November where I did not permit an urge end ruling on 29 November where I did not permit an urge end debate ruling on 29 November where I did not permit an urge end debate on ruling on 29 November where I did not permit an urge end debate on the not permit an urge end debate on the plan not permit an urge end debate on the plan for not permit an urge end debate on the plan for a not permit an urge end debate on the plan for a new not permit an urge end debate on the plan for a new parliamentary plan for a new parliamentary buildings plan for a new parliamentary buildings on plan for a new parliamentary buildings on the plan for a new parliamentary buildings on the basis plan for a new parliamentary buildings on the basis that plan for a new parliamentary buildings on the basis that an buildings on the basis that an urgent buildings on the basis that an urgent debate buildings on the basis that an urgent debate is buildings on the basis that an urgent debate is a buildings on the basis that an urgent debate is a way buildings on the basis that an urgent debate is a way of buildings on the basis that an urgent debate is a way of holding urgent debate is a way of holding the urgent debate is a way of holding the Government urgent debate is a way of holding the Government accountable urgent debate is a way of holding the Government accountable for urgent debate is a way of holding the Government accountable for an the Government accountable for an action the Government accountable for an action for the Government accountable for an action for which the Government accountable for an action for which it the Government accountable for an action for which it is the Government accountable for an action for which it is responsible action for which it is responsible and action for which it is responsible and the action for which it is responsible and the Speaker action for which it is responsible and the Speaker is action for which it is responsible and the Speaker is not action for which it is responsible and the Speaker is not part action for which it is responsible and the Speaker is not part of action for which it is responsible and the Speaker is not part of the and the Speaker is not part of the Government. and the Speaker is not part of the Government. Subsequently, and the Speaker is not part of the Government. Subsequently, I've Government. Subsequently, I've received Government. Subsequently, I've received a Government. Subsequently, I've received a letter Government. Subsequently, I've received a letter from Government. Subsequently, I've received a letter from the Government. Subsequently, I've received a letter from the Rt received a letter from the Rt Honerable received a letter from the Rt Honerable Winston received a letter from the Rt Honerable Winston peters received a letter from the Rt Honerable Winston peters on received a letter from the Rt Honerable Winston peters on the Honerable Winston peters on the matter Honerable Winston peters on the matter the Honerable Winston peters on the matter the speaker Honerable Winston peters on the matter the speaker is Honerable Winston peters on the matter the speaker is deemed Honerable Winston peters on the matter the speaker is deemed to Honerable Winston peters on the matter the speaker is deemed to be matter the speaker is deemed to be the matter the speaker is deemed to be the responsible matter the speaker is deemed to be the responsible Minister matter the speaker is deemed to be the responsible Minister for matter the speaker is deemed to be the responsible Minister for a the responsible Minister for a number the responsible Minister for a number of the responsible Minister for a number of agencies, the responsible Minister for a number of agencies, including the responsible Minister for a number of agencies, including the number of agencies, including the Office number of agencies, including the Office of number of agencies, including the Office of the number of agencies, including the Office of the Clerk, number of agencies, including the Office of the Clerk, the Office of the Clerk, the Parliamentary Office of the Clerk, the Parliamentary Service Office of the Clerk, the Parliamentary Service and Office of the Clerk, the Parliamentary Service and the Office of the Clerk, the Parliamentary Service and the three Parliamentary Service and the three offices Parliamentary Service and the three offices of Parliamentary Service and the three offices of the Parliamentary Service and the three offices of the Parliament Parliamentary Service and the three offices of the Parliament for Parliamentary Service and the three offices of the Parliament for the offices of the Parliament for the purposes offices of the Parliament for the purposes of offices of the Parliament for the purposes of the offices of the Parliament for the purposes of the public offices of the Parliament for the purposes of the public act, offices of the Parliament for the purposes of the public act, 1989. purposes of the public act, 1989. That purposes of the public act, 1989. That does purposes of the public act, 1989. That does not purposes of the public act, 1989. That does not make purposes of the public act, 1989. That does not make the purposes of the public act, 1989. That does not make the speaker purposes of the public act, 1989. That does not make the speaker a That does not make the speaker a member That does not make the speaker a member of That does not make the speaker a member of the That does not make the speaker a member of the Government, That does not make the speaker a member of the Government, however. member of the Government, however. Instead, member of the Government, however. Instead, it member of the Government, however. Instead, it is member of the Government, however. Instead, it is to member of the Government, however. Instead, it is to provide member of the Government, however. Instead, it is to provide some Instead, it is to provide some oversight Instead, it is to provide some oversight of, Instead, it is to provide some oversight of, and Instead, it is to provide some oversight of, and accountability oversight of, and accountability for, oversight of, and accountability for, the oversight of, and accountability for, the activities oversight of, and accountability for, the activities of oversight of, and accountability for, the activities of agencies oversight of, and accountability for, the activities of agencies that for, the activities of agencies that form for, the activities of agencies that form part for, the activities of agencies that form part of for, the activities of agencies that form part of the for, the activities of agencies that form part of the legislative for, the activities of agencies that form part of the legislative rather form part of the legislative rather than form part of the legislative rather than the form part of the legislative rather than the executive form part of the legislative rather than the executive branch. form part of the legislative rather than the executive branch. The form part of the legislative rather than the executive branch. The only than the executive branch. The only way than the executive branch. The only way to than the executive branch. The only way to become than the executive branch. The only way to become a than the executive branch. The only way to become a Minister than the executive branch. The only way to become a Minister is than the executive branch. The only way to become a Minister is to way to become a Minister is to appointed way to become a Minister is to appointed by way to become a Minister is to appointed by the way to become a Minister is to appointed by the Governor-General way to become a Minister is to appointed by the Governor-General on appointed by the Governor-General on the appointed by the Governor-General on the recommendation appointed by the Governor-General on the recommendation of appointed by the Governor-General on the recommendation of the appointed by the Governor-General on the recommendation of the PM. appointed by the Governor-General on the recommendation of the PM. I the recommendation of the PM. I refer the recommendation of the PM. I refer members the recommendation of the PM. I refer members to the recommendation of the PM. I refer members to chapter the recommendation of the PM. I refer members to chapter 2 the recommendation of the PM. I refer members to chapter 2 of the recommendation of the PM. I refer members to chapter 2 of the refer members to chapter 2 of the Cabinet refer members to chapter 2 of the Cabinet Manual. refer members to chapter 2 of the Cabinet Manual. The refer members to chapter 2 of the Cabinet Manual. The speaker refer members to chapter 2 of the Cabinet Manual. The speaker on refer members to chapter 2 of the Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the other Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the other hand Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the other hand is Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the other hand is elected Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the other hand is elected directly Cabinet Manual. The speaker on the other hand is elected directly by other hand is elected directly by the other hand is elected directly by the House other hand is elected directly by the House as other hand is elected directly by the House as a other hand is elected directly by the House as a spokesperson other hand is elected directly by the House as a spokesperson and the House as a spokesperson and presiding the House as a spokesperson and presiding officer. the House as a spokesperson and presiding officer. The the House as a spokesperson and presiding officer. The purpose the House as a spokesperson and presiding officer. The purpose of the House as a spokesperson and presiding officer. The purpose of an presiding officer. The purpose of an urgent presiding officer. The purpose of an urgent debate presiding officer. The purpose of an urgent debate is presiding officer. The purpose of an urgent debate is to presiding officer. The purpose of an urgent debate is to hold presiding officer. The purpose of an urgent debate is to hold the urgent debate is to hold the Government urgent debate is to hold the Government accountable urgent debate is to hold the Government accountable for urgent debate is to hold the Government accountable for an urgent debate is to hold the Government accountable for an action Government accountable for an action for Government accountable for an action for which Government accountable for an action for which it Government accountable for an action for which it is Government accountable for an action for which it is responsible for which it is responsible according for which it is responsible according to for which it is responsible according to Speaker's for which it is responsible according to Speaker's ruling for which it is responsible according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The Speaker according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The Speaker is according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The Speaker is not according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The Speaker is not part according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The Speaker is not part of according to Speaker's ruling 207.2. The Speaker is not part of the The Speaker is not part of the Government The Speaker is not part of the Government and The Speaker is not part of the Government and in The Speaker is not part of the Government and in recognition The Speaker is not part of the Government and in recognition of The Speaker is not part of the Government and in recognition of the Government and in recognition of the special Government and in recognition of the special position Government and in recognition of the special position of Government and in recognition of the special position of the Government and in recognition of the special position of the speaker Government and in recognition of the special position of the speaker as Government and in recognition of the special position of the speaker as a special position of the speaker as a presiding special position of the speaker as a presiding officer, special position of the speaker as a presiding officer, cannot special position of the speaker as a presiding officer, cannot take special position of the speaker as a presiding officer, cannot take part presiding officer, cannot take part in presiding officer, cannot take part in debate presiding officer, cannot take part in debate or presiding officer, cannot take part in debate or answer presiding officer, cannot take part in debate or answer Oral presiding officer, cannot take part in debate or answer Oral Questions in debate or answer Oral Questions in in debate or answer Oral Questions in the in debate or answer Oral Questions in the house. in debate or answer Oral Questions in the house. I in debate or answer Oral Questions in the house. I draw in debate or answer Oral Questions in the house. I draw members' in the house. I draw members' attentions in the house. I draw members' attentions to in the house. I draw members' attentions to Speaker's in the house. I draw members' attentions to Speaker's ruling in the house. I draw members' attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which states attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which states that attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which states that a attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which states that a second attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which states that a second call attentions to Speaker's ruling 2157, which states that a second call on which states that a second call on an which states that a second call on an urgent which states that a second call on an urgent debate which states that a second call on an urgent debate always which states that a second call on an urgent debate always goes which states that a second call on an urgent debate always goes to which states that a second call on an urgent debate always goes to a an urgent debate always goes to a Minister an urgent debate always goes to a Minister so an urgent debate always goes to a Minister so that an urgent debate always goes to a Minister so that the an urgent debate always goes to a Minister so that the Minister Minister so that the Minister speaking Minister so that the Minister speaking for Minister so that the Minister speaking for the Minister so that the Minister speaking for the Government Minister so that the Minister speaking for the Government has Minister so that the Minister speaking for the Government has an speaking for the Government has an extra speaking for the Government has an extra period speaking for the Government has an extra period to speaking for the Government has an extra period to respond. speaking for the Government has an extra period to respond. There speaking for the Government has an extra period to respond. There can extra period to respond. There can be extra period to respond. There can be no extra period to respond. There can be no question extra period to respond. There can be no question of extra period to respond. There can be no question of the extra period to respond. There can be no question of the speaker be no question of the speaker elected be no question of the speaker elected by be no question of the speaker elected by the be no question of the speaker elected by the house be no question of the speaker elected by the house to be no question of the speaker elected by the house to speak be no question of the speaker elected by the house to speak for be no question of the speaker elected by the house to speak for it elected by the house to speak for it ever elected by the house to speak for it ever speaking elected by the house to speak for it ever speaking for elected by the house to speak for it ever speaking for Government. elected by the house to speak for it ever speaking for Government. The ever speaking for Government. The proposal ever speaking for Government. The proposal of ever speaking for Government. The proposal of a ever speaking for Government. The proposal of a new ever speaking for Government. The proposal of a new parliamentary proposal of a new parliamentary building proposal of a new parliamentary building has proposal of a new parliamentary building has not proposal of a new parliamentary building has not yet proposal of a new parliamentary building has not yet been proposal of a new parliamentary building has not yet been finalised building has not yet been finalised and building has not yet been finalised and there building has not yet been finalised and there is building has not yet been finalised and there is no building has not yet been finalised and there is no appropriation building has not yet been finalised and there is no appropriation to and there is no appropriation to fund and there is no appropriation to fund it. and there is no appropriation to fund it. There and there is no appropriation to fund it. There will and there is no appropriation to fund it. There will be and there is no appropriation to fund it. There will be ways and there is no appropriation to fund it. There will be ways to fund it. There will be ways to scrutinise fund it. There will be ways to scrutinise the fund it. There will be ways to scrutinise the proposal fund it. There will be ways to scrutinise the proposal if fund it. There will be ways to scrutinise the proposal if it scrutinise the proposal if it receives scrutinise the proposal if it receives Cabinet scrutinise the proposal if it receives Cabinet approval. scrutinise the proposal if it receives Cabinet approval. The receives Cabinet approval. The funding receives Cabinet approval. The funding of receives Cabinet approval. The funding of the receives Cabinet approval. The funding of the building receives Cabinet approval. The funding of the building project funding of the building project would funding of the building project would be funding of the building project would be contained funding of the building project would be contained in funding of the building project would be contained in the funding of the building project would be contained in the estimates would be contained in the estimates for would be contained in the estimates for both would be contained in the estimates for both Parliamentary would be contained in the estimates for both Parliamentary Service would be contained in the estimates for both Parliamentary Service and for both Parliamentary Service and could for both Parliamentary Service and could be for both Parliamentary Service and could be examined for both Parliamentary Service and could be examined in for both Parliamentary Service and could be examined in the for both Parliamentary Service and could be examined in the house for both Parliamentary Service and could be examined in the house and could be examined in the house and select could be examined in the house and select committee could be examined in the house and select committee during could be examined in the house and select committee during the select committee during the Estimates select committee during the Estimates processes. select committee during the Estimates processes. The select committee during the Estimates processes. The proposed Estimates processes. The proposed building Estimates processes. The proposed building will Estimates processes. The proposed building will also Estimates processes. The proposed building will also continue Estimates processes. The proposed building will also continue to Estimates processes. The proposed building will also continue to be building will also continue to be discussed building will also continue to be discussed at building will also continue to be discussed at the building will also continue to be discussed at the Parliament building will also continue to be discussed at the Parliament service discussed at the Parliament service commission discussed at the Parliament service commission of discussed at the Parliament service commission of which discussed at the Parliament service commission of which New discussed at the Parliament service commission of which New Zealand commission of which New Zealand first commission of which New Zealand first is commission of which New Zealand first is a commission of which New Zealand first is a member. commission of which New Zealand first is a member. However, commission of which New Zealand first is a member. However, the first is a member. However, the urgent first is a member. However, the urgent debate first is a member. However, the urgent debate procedure first is a member. However, the urgent debate procedure is first is a member. However, the urgent debate procedure is not urgent debate procedure is not available urgent debate procedure is not available to urgent debate procedure is not available to debate urgent debate procedure is not available to debate matters urgent debate procedure is not available to debate matters for available to debate matters for which available to debate matters for which the available to debate matters for which the Speaker available to debate matters for which the Speaker is available to debate matters for which the Speaker is responsible. available to debate matters for which the Speaker is responsible. I which the Speaker is responsible. I have which the Speaker is responsible. I have received which the Speaker is responsible. I have received letters which the Speaker is responsible. I have received letters from which the Speaker is responsible. I have received letters from the which the Speaker is responsible. I have received letters from the Rt have received letters from the Rt Honerable have received letters from the Rt Honerable Winston have received letters from the Rt Honerable Winston peters have received letters from the Rt Honerable Winston peters and have received letters from the Rt Honerable Winston peters and Andrew Honerable Winston peters and Andrew Little Honerable Winston peters and Andrew Little seeking Honerable Winston peters and Andrew Little seeking to Honerable Winston peters and Andrew Little seeking to debate Honerable Winston peters and Andrew Little seeking to debate under Little seeking to debate under Standing Little seeking to debate under Standing Order Little seeking to debate under Standing Order 39 Little seeking to debate under Standing Order 39 the Little seeking to debate under Standing Order 39 the announcement Standing Order 39 the announcement by Standing Order 39 the announcement by the Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM that Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM that he Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM that he would Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM that he would resign Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM that he would resign as Standing Order 39 the announcement by the PM that he would resign as PM by the PM that he would resign as PM on by the PM that he would resign as PM on 12 by the PM that he would resign as PM on 12 December. by the PM that he would resign as PM on 12 December. This by the PM that he would resign as PM on 12 December. This is by the PM that he would resign as PM on 12 December. This is a by the PM that he would resign as PM on 12 December. This is a particular on 12 December. This is a particular case on 12 December. This is a particular case of on 12 December. This is a particular case of recent on 12 December. This is a particular case of recent occurrence, on 12 December. This is a particular case of recent occurrence, for on 12 December. This is a particular case of recent occurrence, for which case of recent occurrence, for which there case of recent occurrence, for which there is case of recent occurrence, for which there is ministerial case of recent occurrence, for which there is ministerial responsibility. there is ministerial responsibility. Application there is ministerial responsibility. Application for there is ministerial responsibility. Application for urgent there is ministerial responsibility. Application for urgent debate there is ministerial responsibility. Application for urgent debate are Application for urgent debate are required Application for urgent debate are required to Application for urgent debate are required to be Application for urgent debate are required to be accompanied Application for urgent debate are required to be accompanied by required to be accompanied by authentication required to be accompanied by authentication and required to be accompanied by authentication and have required to be accompanied by authentication and have been authentication and have been declined authentication and have been declined in authentication and have been declined in the authentication and have been declined in the past authentication and have been declined in the past because authentication and have been declined in the past because of authentication and have been declined in the past because of a declined in the past because of a lack declined in the past because of a lack of declined in the past because of a lack of authentication. lack of authentication. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . Order! <INTERRUPTION> . Order! I <INTERRUPTION> . Order! I draw <INTERRUPTION> . Order! I draw member's <INTERRUPTION> . Order! I draw member's attention . Order! I draw member's attention to . Order! I draw member's attention to Speaker's . Order! I draw member's attention to Speaker's ruling . Order! I draw member's attention to Speaker's ruling 205.5 . Order! I draw member's attention to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and . Order! I draw member's attention to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. The to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. The application to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. The application for to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. The application for Mr to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. The application for Mr Peters to Speaker's ruling 205.5 and 205.6. The application for Mr Peters was The application for Mr Peters was not The application for Mr Peters was not accompanied The application for Mr Peters was not accompanied by The application for Mr Peters was not accompanied by any not accompanied by any authenticating... authenticating... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! However, <INTERRUPTION> Order! However, the <INTERRUPTION> Order! However, the purpose <INTERRUPTION> Order! However, the purpose of Order! However, the purpose of authentication Order! However, the purpose of authentication is Order! However, the purpose of authentication is to Order! However, the purpose of authentication is to verify Order! However, the purpose of authentication is to verify the authentication is to verify the facts authentication is to verify the facts on authentication is to verify the facts on an authentication is to verify the facts on an application authentication is to verify the facts on an application for authentication is to verify the facts on an application for an facts on an application for an urgent facts on an application for an urgent debate facts on an application for an urgent debate and facts on an application for an urgent debate and to facts on an application for an urgent debate and to make facts on an application for an urgent debate and to make out facts on an application for an urgent debate and to make out the urgent debate and to make out the indicates urgent debate and to make out the indicates in urgent debate and to make out the indicates in support urgent debate and to make out the indicates in support of urgent debate and to make out the indicates in support of it. urgent debate and to make out the indicates in support of it. In urgent debate and to make out the indicates in support of it. In this indicates in support of it. In this instance, indicates in support of it. In this instance, the indicates in support of it. In this instance, the facts indicates in support of it. In this instance, the facts of indicates in support of it. In this instance, the facts of the indicates in support of it. In this instance, the facts of the matter instance, the facts of the matter are instance, the facts of the matter are well instance, the facts of the matter are well flown instance, the facts of the matter are well flown and instance, the facts of the matter are well flown and hardly instance, the facts of the matter are well flown and hardly require are well flown and hardly require authentication. are well flown and hardly require authentication. I are well flown and hardly require authentication. I am are well flown and hardly require authentication. I am prepared are well flown and hardly require authentication. I am prepared on authentication. I am prepared on this authentication. I am prepared on this occasion authentication. I am prepared on this occasion to authentication. I am prepared on this occasion to accept authentication. I am prepared on this occasion to accept the this occasion to accept the application this occasion to accept the application without this occasion to accept the application without authentication. application without authentication. The application without authentication. The resignation application without authentication. The resignation of application without authentication. The resignation of a application without authentication. The resignation of a PM application without authentication. The resignation of a PM is application without authentication. The resignation of a PM is a application without authentication. The resignation of a PM is a very The resignation of a PM is a very rare The resignation of a PM is a very rare occurrence The resignation of a PM is a very rare occurrence and The resignation of a PM is a very rare occurrence and is The resignation of a PM is a very rare occurrence and is deserving The resignation of a PM is a very rare occurrence and is deserving of rare occurrence and is deserving of the rare occurrence and is deserving of the urgent rare occurrence and is deserving of the urgent attention rare occurrence and is deserving of the urgent attention of rare occurrence and is deserving of the urgent attention of the rare occurrence and is deserving of the urgent attention of the house. the urgent attention of the house. Mr the urgent attention of the house. Mr Peters' the urgent attention of the house. Mr Peters' application the urgent attention of the house. Mr Peters' application for the urgent attention of the house. Mr Peters' application for the Mr Peters' application for the debate Mr Peters' application for the debate on Mr Peters' application for the debate on the Mr Peters' application for the debate on the matter Mr Peters' application for the debate on the matter was Mr Peters' application for the debate on the matter was the Mr Peters' application for the debate on the matter was the first debate on the matter was the first one debate on the matter was the first one received. debate on the matter was the first one received. I debate on the matter was the first one received. I therefore debate on the matter was the first one received. I therefore call debate on the matter was the first one received. I therefore call on one received. I therefore call on the one received. I therefore call on the Rt one received. I therefore call on the Rt Honerable one received. I therefore call on the Rt Honerable Winston one received. I therefore call on the Rt Honerable Winston Peters one received. I therefore call on the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the House the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the House take the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the House take note the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the House take note of the Rt Honerable Winston Peters to move that the House take note of a move that the House take note of a matter move that the House take note of a matter of move that the House take note of a matter of urgent move that the House take note of a matter of urgent public move that the House take note of a matter of urgent public importance. Thank Thank you. Thank you. Order! Thank you. Order! Point Thank you. Order! Point of Thank you. Order! Point of order, Thank you. Order! Point of order, the Thank you. Order! Point of order, the Hon Thank you. Order! Point of order, the Hon Gerry Thank you. Order! Point of order, the Hon Gerry Brownlee. Thank you. Order! Point of order, the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This Thank you. Order! Point of order, the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be an the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be an urgent the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be an urgent debate the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be an urgent debate after the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be an urgent debate after the the Hon Gerry Brownlee. This would be an urgent debate after the event be an urgent debate after the event has be an urgent debate after the event has taken be an urgent debate after the event has taken place. be an urgent debate after the event has taken place. The be an urgent debate after the event has taken place. The event be an urgent debate after the event has taken place. The event has be an urgent debate after the event has taken place. The event has not has taken place. The event has not taken has taken place. The event has not taken place. has taken place. The event has not taken place. The has taken place. The event has not taken place. The PM has taken place. The event has not taken place. The PM has has taken place. The event has not taken place. The PM has indicated has taken place. The event has not taken place. The PM has indicated an taken place. The PM has indicated an intention, taken place. The PM has indicated an intention, but taken place. The PM has indicated an intention, but has taken place. The PM has indicated an intention, but has not taken place. The PM has indicated an intention, but has not resigned. taken place. The PM has indicated an intention, but has not resigned. The intention, but has not resigned. The announcement intention, but has not resigned. The announcement has intention, but has not resigned. The announcement has taken intention, but has not resigned. The announcement has taken place, intention, but has not resigned. The announcement has taken place, and announcement has taken place, and that's announcement has taken place, and that's the announcement has taken place, and that's the matter announcement has taken place, and that's the matter that's announcement has taken place, and that's the matter that's important that's the matter that's important here. that's the matter that's important here. The that's the matter that's important here. The right that's the matter that's important here. The right Hon that's the matter that's important here. The right Hon Winston that's the matter that's important here. The right Hon Winston Peters. here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. Being here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. Being the here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. Being the PM here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. Being the PM of here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. Being the PM of a here. The right Hon Winston Peters. Thank you. Being the PM of a country Thank you. Being the PM of a country is Thank you. Being the PM of a country is an Thank you. Being the PM of a country is an achievement Thank you. Being the PM of a country is an achievement and Thank you. Being the PM of a country is an achievement and holding Thank you. Being the PM of a country is an achievement and holding that is an achievement and holding that position is an achievement and holding that position for is an achievement and holding that position for eight is an achievement and holding that position for eight years is an achievement and holding that position for eight years is is an achievement and holding that position for eight years is a position for eight years is a significant position for eight years is a significant feat. position for eight years is a significant feat. So position for eight years is a significant feat. So let's position for eight years is a significant feat. So let's begin significant feat. So let's begin this significant feat. So let's begin this debate significant feat. So let's begin this debate by significant feat. So let's begin this debate by remembering significant feat. So let's begin this debate by remembering that, significant feat. So let's begin this debate by remembering that, and this debate by remembering that, and by this debate by remembering that, and by thanking this debate by remembering that, and by thanking the this debate by remembering that, and by thanking the PM this debate by remembering that, and by thanking the PM for this debate by remembering that, and by thanking the PM for his this debate by remembering that, and by thanking the PM for his service by thanking the PM for his service to by thanking the PM for his service to the by thanking the PM for his service to the country. by thanking the PM for his service to the country. We by thanking the PM for his service to the country. We wish by thanking the PM for his service to the country. We wish him by thanking the PM for his service to the country. We wish him and by thanking the PM for his service to the country. We wish him and his to the country. We wish him and his family to the country. We wish him and his family well. to the country. We wish him and his family well. Now, to the country. We wish him and his family well. Now, whenever to the country. We wish him and his family well. Now, whenever a to the country. We wish him and his family well. Now, whenever a PM family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves the family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves the stage, family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves the stage, we family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves the stage, we glance family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves the stage, we glance back family well. Now, whenever a PM leaves the stage, we glance back to leaves the stage, we glance back to consider leaves the stage, we glance back to consider what leaves the stage, we glance back to consider what has leaves the stage, we glance back to consider what has been leaves the stage, we glance back to consider what has been achieved. consider what has been achieved. Now, consider what has been achieved. Now, he consider what has been achieved. Now, he has consider what has been achieved. Now, he has been consider what has been achieved. Now, he has been rated consider what has been achieved. Now, he has been rated by consider what has been achieved. Now, he has been rated by the consider what has been achieved. Now, he has been rated by the media Now, he has been rated by the media as Now, he has been rated by the media as one Now, he has been rated by the media as one of Now, he has been rated by the media as one of our Now, he has been rated by the media as one of our most Now, he has been rated by the media as one of our most popular Now, he has been rated by the media as one of our most popular prime as one of our most popular prime ministers. as one of our most popular prime ministers. There's as one of our most popular prime ministers. There's no as one of our most popular prime ministers. There's no doubt as one of our most popular prime ministers. There's no doubt that as one of our most popular prime ministers. There's no doubt that he ministers. There's no doubt that he had ministers. There's no doubt that he had that ministers. There's no doubt that he had that teflon ministers. There's no doubt that he had that teflon factor, ministers. There's no doubt that he had that teflon factor, which ministers. There's no doubt that he had that teflon factor, which many had that teflon factor, which many of had that teflon factor, which many of his had that teflon factor, which many of his peers had that teflon factor, which many of his peers very had that teflon factor, which many of his peers very soon had that teflon factor, which many of his peers very soon will had that teflon factor, which many of his peers very soon will be of his peers very soon will be coming of his peers very soon will be coming to of his peers very soon will be coming to envy! of his peers very soon will be coming to envy! No of his peers very soon will be coming to envy! No matter of his peers very soon will be coming to envy! No matter what of his peers very soon will be coming to envy! No matter what side coming to envy! No matter what side of coming to envy! No matter what side of the coming to envy! No matter what side of the political coming to envy! No matter what side of the political spectrum coming to envy! No matter what side of the political spectrum one coming to envy! No matter what side of the political spectrum one comes of the political spectrum one comes from, of the political spectrum one comes from, many of the political spectrum one comes from, many ordinary of the political spectrum one comes from, many ordinary New of the political spectrum one comes from, many ordinary New Zealanders from, many ordinary New Zealanders have from, many ordinary New Zealanders have been from, many ordinary New Zealanders have been able from, many ordinary New Zealanders have been able to from, many ordinary New Zealanders have been able to relate from, many ordinary New Zealanders have been able to relate to from, many ordinary New Zealanders have been able to relate to him, have been able to relate to him, from have been able to relate to him, from the have been able to relate to him, from the state have been able to relate to him, from the state house have been able to relate to him, from the state house in have been able to relate to him, from the state house in Bindua have been able to relate to him, from the state house in Bindua to from the state house in Bindua to the from the state house in Bindua to the ninth from the state house in Bindua to the ninth floor from the state house in Bindua to the ninth floor of from the state house in Bindua to the ninth floor of the from the state house in Bindua to the ninth floor of the Bee from the state house in Bindua to the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, from the state house in Bindua to the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is something the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is something John the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is something John Key the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is something John Key aspired the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is something John Key aspired to the ninth floor of the Bee Hive, is something John Key aspired to from something John Key aspired to from the something John Key aspired to from the day something John Key aspired to from the day he something John Key aspired to from the day he was something John Key aspired to from the day he was a something John Key aspired to from the day he was a young something John Key aspired to from the day he was a young boy something John Key aspired to from the day he was a young boy and something John Key aspired to from the day he was a young boy and he the day he was a young boy and he can the day he was a young boy and he can be the day he was a young boy and he can be proud the day he was a young boy and he can be proud of the day he was a young boy and he can be proud of that. the day he was a young boy and he can be proud of that. As the day he was a young boy and he can be proud of that. As a can be proud of that. As a politician can be proud of that. As a politician he can be proud of that. As a politician he became can be proud of that. As a politician he became an can be proud of that. As a politician he became an astute politician he became an astute pragmaticist. politician he became an astute pragmaticist. Plotting politician he became an astute pragmaticist. Plotting his politician he became an astute pragmaticist. Plotting his moves pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with his pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with his eyes pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with his eyes fixed pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with his eyes fixed firmly pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with his eyes fixed firmly on pragmaticist. Plotting his moves with his eyes fixed firmly on the with his eyes fixed firmly on the polls, with his eyes fixed firmly on the polls, which with his eyes fixed firmly on the polls, which the with his eyes fixed firmly on the polls, which the National with his eyes fixed firmly on the polls, which the National Party with his eyes fixed firmly on the polls, which the National Party take polls, which the National Party take every polls, which the National Party take every three polls, which the National Party take every three days. polls, which the National Party take every three days. The polls, which the National Party take every three days. The question every three days. The question which, every three days. The question which, as every three days. The question which, as time every three days. The question which, as time passes, every three days. The question which, as time passes, people every three days. The question which, as time passes, people will which, as time passes, people will ponder which, as time passes, people will ponder is, which, as time passes, people will ponder is, so which, as time passes, people will ponder is, so what which, as time passes, people will ponder is, so what really which, as time passes, people will ponder is, so what really is which, as time passes, people will ponder is, so what really is his ponder is, so what really is his legacy? ponder is, so what really is his legacy? Is ponder is, so what really is his legacy? Is New ponder is, so what really is his legacy? Is New Zealand ponder is, so what really is his legacy? Is New Zealand in ponder is, so what really is his legacy? Is New Zealand in as ponder is, so what really is his legacy? Is New Zealand in as good legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as he legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as he told legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as he told us legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as he told us yesterday, legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as he told us yesterday, or legacy? Is New Zealand in as good shape as he told us yesterday, or is shape as he told us yesterday, or is the shape as he told us yesterday, or is the reality shape as he told us yesterday, or is the reality something shape as he told us yesterday, or is the reality something very the reality something very different? the reality something very different? Well, the reality something very different? Well, take the reality something very different? Well, take housing. the reality something very different? Well, take housing. What different? Well, take housing. What has different? Well, take housing. What has been different? Well, take housing. What has been the different? Well, take housing. What has been the legacy different? Well, take housing. What has been the legacy on different? Well, take housing. What has been the legacy on housing? has been the legacy on housing? Eight has been the legacy on housing? Eight years has been the legacy on housing? Eight years ago, has been the legacy on housing? Eight years ago, he has been the legacy on housing? Eight years ago, he campaigned has been the legacy on housing? Eight years ago, he campaigned on has been the legacy on housing? Eight years ago, he campaigned on a Eight years ago, he campaigned on a four-point Eight years ago, he campaigned on a four-point plan Eight years ago, he campaigned on a four-point plan to Eight years ago, he campaigned on a four-point plan to solve Eight years ago, he campaigned on a four-point plan to solve what Eight years ago, he campaigned on a four-point plan to solve what he four-point plan to solve what he called four-point plan to solve what he called the four-point plan to solve what he called the "Housing four-point plan to solve what he called the "Housing affordability called the "Housing affordability crisis". called the "Housing affordability crisis". He called the "Housing affordability crisis". He talked called the "Housing affordability crisis". He talked of, called the "Housing affordability crisis". He talked of, "The called the "Housing affordability crisis". He talked of, "The enormity crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of the crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of the problem" crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of the problem" and crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of the problem" and the crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of the problem" and the second crisis". He talked of, "The enormity of the problem" and the second worst of the problem" and the second worst housing of the problem" and the second worst housing affordability of the problem" and the second worst housing affordability a of the problem" and the second worst housing affordability a problem of the problem" and the second worst housing affordability a problem in housing affordability a problem in the housing affordability a problem in the whole housing affordability a problem in the whole wide housing affordability a problem in the whole wide world. housing affordability a problem in the whole wide world. He housing affordability a problem in the whole wide world. He said housing affordability a problem in the whole wide world. He said in the whole wide world. He said in 2007 the whole wide world. He said in 2007 the the whole wide world. He said in 2007 the housing the whole wide world. He said in 2007 the housing crisis the whole wide world. He said in 2007 the housing crisis had the whole wide world. He said in 2007 the housing crisis had got 2007 the housing crisis had got worse 2007 the housing crisis had got worse and 2007 the housing crisis had got worse and that 2007 the housing crisis had got worse and that the 2007 the housing crisis had got worse and that the crisis 2007 the housing crisis had got worse and that the crisis would 2007 the housing crisis had got worse and that the crisis would only worse and that the crisis would only deepen. worse and that the crisis would only deepen. And worse and that the crisis would only deepen. And in worse and that the crisis would only deepen. And in 2007, worse and that the crisis would only deepen. And in 2007, he worse and that the crisis would only deepen. And in 2007, he promised worse and that the crisis would only deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deliver, deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deliver, as deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deliver, as PM, deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deliver, as PM, and deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deliver, as PM, and build deepen. And in 2007, he promised to deliver, as PM, and build more deliver, as PM, and build more houses. deliver, as PM, and build more houses. He deliver, as PM, and build more houses. He got deliver, as PM, and build more houses. He got his deliver, as PM, and build more houses. He got his chance, deliver, as PM, and build more houses. He got his chance, became houses. He got his chance, became PM, houses. He got his chance, became PM, and houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had eight houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had eight years houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had eight years to houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had eight years to fix houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had eight years to fix it houses. He got his chance, became PM, and had eight years to fix it - PM, and had eight years to fix it - so PM, and had eight years to fix it - so what PM, and had eight years to fix it - so what is PM, and had eight years to fix it - so what is the PM, and had eight years to fix it - so what is the record? PM, and had eight years to fix it - so what is the record? Eight PM, and had eight years to fix it - so what is the record? Eight years so what is the record? Eight years later, so what is the record? Eight years later, the so what is the record? Eight years later, the housing so what is the record? Eight years later, the housing crisis so what is the record? Eight years later, the housing crisis has later, the housing crisis has seriously later, the housing crisis has seriously worsened. later, the housing crisis has seriously worsened. A later, the housing crisis has seriously worsened. A recent later, the housing crisis has seriously worsened. A recent report seriously worsened. A recent report said seriously worsened. A recent report said that seriously worsened. A recent report said that one seriously worsened. A recent report said that one in seriously worsened. A recent report said that one in seven seriously worsened. A recent report said that one in seven houses seriously worsened. A recent report said that one in seven houses in said that one in seven houses in Auckland said that one in seven houses in Auckland are said that one in seven houses in Auckland are being said that one in seven houses in Auckland are being bought said that one in seven houses in Auckland are being bought by Auckland are being bought by speculators Auckland are being bought by speculators who Auckland are being bought by speculators who already Auckland are being bought by speculators who already own Auckland are being bought by speculators who already own five Auckland are being bought by speculators who already own five or speculators who already own five or more speculators who already own five or more properties. speculators who already own five or more properties. In speculators who already own five or more properties. In most speculators who already own five or more properties. In most cases, speculators who already own five or more properties. In most cases, they more properties. In most cases, they have more properties. In most cases, they have taken more properties. In most cases, they have taken these more properties. In most cases, they have taken these homes more properties. In most cases, they have taken these homes at more properties. In most cases, they have taken these homes at the have taken these homes at the expense have taken these homes at the expense of have taken these homes at the expense of Kiwis have taken these homes at the expense of Kiwis looking have taken these homes at the expense of Kiwis looking for have taken these homes at the expense of Kiwis looking for their expense of Kiwis looking for their first expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. In expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. In spite expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. In spite of expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. In spite of all expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. In spite of all of expense of Kiwis looking for their first home. In spite of all of the first home. In spite of all of the denials first home. In spite of all of the denials from first home. In spite of all of the denials from the first home. In spite of all of the denials from the National first home. In spite of all of the denials from the National Party, first home. In spite of all of the denials from the National Party, the denials from the National Party, the massive denials from the National Party, the massive flood denials from the National Party, the massive flood of denials from the National Party, the massive flood of immigration denials from the National Party, the massive flood of immigration into massive flood of immigration into Auckland massive flood of immigration into Auckland and massive flood of immigration into Auckland and offshore massive flood of immigration into Auckland and offshore buying massive flood of immigration into Auckland and offshore buying have Auckland and offshore buying have shut Auckland and offshore buying have shut out Auckland and offshore buying have shut out New Auckland and offshore buying have shut out New Zealanders Auckland and offshore buying have shut out New Zealanders and Auckland and offshore buying have shut out New Zealanders and sent Auckland and offshore buying have shut out New Zealanders and sent the shut out New Zealanders and sent the price shut out New Zealanders and sent the price of shut out New Zealanders and sent the price of housing shut out New Zealanders and sent the price of housing straight shut out New Zealanders and sent the price of housing straight into price of housing straight into orbit. price of housing straight into orbit. The price of housing straight into orbit. The average price of housing straight into orbit. The average price price of housing straight into orbit. The average price for price of housing straight into orbit. The average price for a price of housing straight into orbit. The average price for a house orbit. The average price for a house in orbit. The average price for a house in Auckland orbit. The average price for a house in Auckland went orbit. The average price for a house in Auckland went beyond orbit. The average price for a house in Auckland went beyond $1 orbit. The average price for a house in Auckland went beyond $1 million. in Auckland went beyond $1 million. Now, in Auckland went beyond $1 million. Now, there in Auckland went beyond $1 million. Now, there have in Auckland went beyond $1 million. Now, there have been in Auckland went beyond $1 million. Now, there have been some Now, there have been some corrections Now, there have been some corrections later, Now, there have been some corrections later, but Now, there have been some corrections later, but the Now, there have been some corrections later, but the reality corrections later, but the reality has corrections later, but the reality has not corrections later, but the reality has not changed. corrections later, but the reality has not changed. A corrections later, but the reality has not changed. A generation corrections later, but the reality has not changed. A generation of corrections later, but the reality has not changed. A generation of New has not changed. A generation of New Zealanders has not changed. A generation of New Zealanders is has not changed. A generation of New Zealanders is growing has not changed. A generation of New Zealanders is growing up, has not changed. A generation of New Zealanders is growing up, who has not changed. A generation of New Zealanders is growing up, who will Zealanders is growing up, who will never, Zealanders is growing up, who will never, ever Zealanders is growing up, who will never, ever own Zealanders is growing up, who will never, ever own their Zealanders is growing up, who will never, ever own their own Zealanders is growing up, who will never, ever own their own home. Zealanders is growing up, who will never, ever own their own home. For never, ever own their own home. For them, never, ever own their own home. For them, the never, ever own their own home. For them, the Kiwi never, ever own their own home. For them, the Kiwi dream never, ever own their own home. For them, the Kiwi dream of never, ever own their own home. For them, the Kiwi dream of home them, the Kiwi dream of home ownership them, the Kiwi dream of home ownership has them, the Kiwi dream of home ownership has been them, the Kiwi dream of home ownership has been shattered. them, the Kiwi dream of home ownership has been shattered. They ownership has been shattered. They face ownership has been shattered. They face the ownership has been shattered. They face the dreary ownership has been shattered. They face the dreary prospect ownership has been shattered. They face the dreary prospect of ownership has been shattered. They face the dreary prospect of being face the dreary prospect of being renters face the dreary prospect of being renters for face the dreary prospect of being renters for life. face the dreary prospect of being renters for life. Now, face the dreary prospect of being renters for life. Now, that face the dreary prospect of being renters for life. Now, that is face the dreary prospect of being renters for life. Now, that is the renters for life. Now, that is the housing renters for life. Now, that is the housing legacy renters for life. Now, that is the housing legacy and renters for life. Now, that is the housing legacy and on renters for life. Now, that is the housing legacy and on state renters for life. Now, that is the housing legacy and on state houses renters for life. Now, that is the housing legacy and on state houses - housing legacy and on state houses - well, housing legacy and on state houses - well, with housing legacy and on state houses - well, with 40,000 housing legacy and on state houses - well, with 40,000 homeless, housing legacy and on state houses - well, with 40,000 homeless, families well, with 40,000 homeless, families living well, with 40,000 homeless, families living in well, with 40,000 homeless, families living in cars well, with 40,000 homeless, families living in cars and well, with 40,000 homeless, families living in cars and pensioners living in cars and pensioners scraping living in cars and pensioners scraping by living in cars and pensioners scraping by in living in cars and pensioners scraping by in campgrounds, living in cars and pensioners scraping by in campgrounds, the scraping by in campgrounds, the Government scraping by in campgrounds, the Government started scraping by in campgrounds, the Government started selling scraping by in campgrounds, the Government started selling off Government started selling off thousands Government started selling off thousands of Government started selling off thousands of state Government started selling off thousands of state houses. Government started selling off thousands of state houses. The thousands of state houses. The latest thousands of state houses. The latest sell-off thousands of state houses. The latest sell-off will thousands of state houses. The latest sell-off will be thousands of state houses. The latest sell-off will be 2,500 thousands of state houses. The latest sell-off will be 2,500 state latest sell-off will be 2,500 state houses latest sell-off will be 2,500 state houses in latest sell-off will be 2,500 state houses in Christchurch. latest sell-off will be 2,500 state houses in Christchurch. Right latest sell-off will be 2,500 state houses in Christchurch. Right now, houses in Christchurch. Right now, going houses in Christchurch. Right now, going on, houses in Christchurch. Right now, going on, while houses in Christchurch. Right now, going on, while we've houses in Christchurch. Right now, going on, while we've got houses in Christchurch. Right now, going on, while we've got massive going on, while we've got massive homelessness going on, while we've got massive homelessness in going on, while we've got massive homelessness in this going on, while we've got massive homelessness in this country. going on, while we've got massive homelessness in this country. Now, homelessness in this country. Now, the homelessness in this country. Now, the same homelessness in this country. Now, the same city homelessness in this country. Now, the same city where homelessness in this country. Now, the same city where the homelessness in this country. Now, the same city where the PM homelessness in this country. Now, the same city where the PM grew homelessness in this country. Now, the same city where the PM grew up homelessness in this country. Now, the same city where the PM grew up - the same city where the PM grew up - in the same city where the PM grew up - in a the same city where the PM grew up - in a state the same city where the PM grew up - in a state house the same city where the PM grew up - in a state house - the same city where the PM grew up - in a state house - has the same city where the PM grew up - in a state house - has got the same city where the PM grew up - in a state house - has got 2,500 in a state house - has got 2,500 being in a state house - has got 2,500 being sold. in a state house - has got 2,500 being sold. Rather in a state house - has got 2,500 being sold. Rather than in a state house - has got 2,500 being sold. Rather than selling, in a state house - has got 2,500 being sold. Rather than selling, the being sold. Rather than selling, the Government being sold. Rather than selling, the Government should being sold. Rather than selling, the Government should be being sold. Rather than selling, the Government should be keeping being sold. Rather than selling, the Government should be keeping state Government should be keeping state houses, Government should be keeping state houses, upgrading Government should be keeping state houses, upgrading them Government should be keeping state houses, upgrading them and Government should be keeping state houses, upgrading them and building houses, upgrading them and building more. houses, upgrading them and building more. But houses, upgrading them and building more. But they're houses, upgrading them and building more. But they're not houses, upgrading them and building more. But they're not - houses, upgrading them and building more. But they're not - again, more. But they're not - again, that's more. But they're not - again, that's their more. But they're not - again, that's their state more. But they're not - again, that's their state housing more. But they're not - again, that's their state housing legacy. that's their state housing legacy. And that's their state housing legacy. And on that's their state housing legacy. And on poverty, that's their state housing legacy. And on poverty, over that's their state housing legacy. And on poverty, over the that's their state housing legacy. And on poverty, over the last that's their state housing legacy. And on poverty, over the last eight And on poverty, over the last eight years, And on poverty, over the last eight years, poverty And on poverty, over the last eight years, poverty has And on poverty, over the last eight years, poverty has become And on poverty, over the last eight years, poverty has become more years, poverty has become more entrenched. years, poverty has become more entrenched. More years, poverty has become more entrenched. More apparent. years, poverty has become more entrenched. More apparent. With entrenched. More apparent. With family entrenched. More apparent. With family poverty entrenched. More apparent. With family poverty frequently entrenched. More apparent. With family poverty frequently wrongly family poverty frequently wrongly described family poverty frequently wrongly described as family poverty frequently wrongly described as child family poverty frequently wrongly described as child poverty family poverty frequently wrongly described as child poverty as family poverty frequently wrongly described as child poverty as some described as child poverty as some sort described as child poverty as some sort of described as child poverty as some sort of diversion described as child poverty as some sort of diversion - described as child poverty as some sort of diversion - it's described as child poverty as some sort of diversion - it's families sort of diversion - it's families that sort of diversion - it's families that are sort of diversion - it's families that are poor sort of diversion - it's families that are poor in sort of diversion - it's families that are poor in this sort of diversion - it's families that are poor in this country, sort of diversion - it's families that are poor in this country, not that are poor in this country, not children that are poor in this country, not children - that are poor in this country, not children - it's that are poor in this country, not children - it's families. that are poor in this country, not children - it's families. And that are poor in this country, not children - it's families. And under children - it's families. And under Mr children - it's families. And under Mr Key's children - it's families. And under Mr Key's leadership, children - it's families. And under Mr Key's leadership, poverty children - it's families. And under Mr Key's leadership, poverty has Mr Key's leadership, poverty has become Mr Key's leadership, poverty has become more Mr Key's leadership, poverty has become more entrenched Mr Key's leadership, poverty has become more entrenched and Mr Key's leadership, poverty has become more entrenched and when become more entrenched and when those become more entrenched and when those people become more entrenched and when those people say, become more entrenched and when those people say, "Be become more entrenched and when those people say, "Be generous, become more entrenched and when those people say, "Be generous, he those people say, "Be generous, he is those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", I those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", I want those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", I want them those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", I want them to those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", I want them to look those people say, "Be generous, he is retiring", I want them to look at is retiring", I want them to look at that is retiring", I want them to look at that homelessness, is retiring", I want them to look at that homelessness, those is retiring", I want them to look at that homelessness, those people is retiring", I want them to look at that homelessness, those people out that homelessness, those people out of that homelessness, those people out of work, that homelessness, those people out of work, in that homelessness, those people out of work, in despair, that homelessness, those people out of work, in despair, no that homelessness, those people out of work, in despair, no chance that homelessness, those people out of work, in despair, no chance in of work, in despair, no chance in this of work, in despair, no chance in this country's of work, in despair, no chance in this country's future, of work, in despair, no chance in this country's future, and of work, in despair, no chance in this country's future, and poor this country's future, and poor families this country's future, and poor families and this country's future, and poor families and ask, this country's future, and poor families and ask, what this country's future, and poor families and ask, what would this country's future, and poor families and ask, what would they families and ask, what would they think? families and ask, what would they think? We families and ask, what would they think? We now families and ask, what would they think? We now have families and ask, what would they think? We now have 220,000 families and ask, what would they think? We now have 220,000 New think? We now have 220,000 New Zealand think? We now have 220,000 New Zealand children, think? We now have 220,000 New Zealand children, or think? We now have 220,000 New Zealand children, or 21% think? We now have 220,000 New Zealand children, or 21% of think? We now have 220,000 New Zealand children, or 21% of those Zealand children, or 21% of those under Zealand children, or 21% of those under the Zealand children, or 21% of those under the age Zealand children, or 21% of those under the age of Zealand children, or 21% of those under the age of 17, Zealand children, or 21% of those under the age of 17, living Zealand children, or 21% of those under the age of 17, living in under the age of 17, living in poverty. under the age of 17, living in poverty. At under the age of 17, living in poverty. At a under the age of 17, living in poverty. At a primary under the age of 17, living in poverty. At a primary school under the age of 17, living in poverty. At a primary school in poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura the poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura the number poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura the number being poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura the number being fed poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura the number being fed by poverty. At a primary school in Kaikoura the number being fed by the Kaikoura the number being fed by the school Kaikoura the number being fed by the school has Kaikoura the number being fed by the school has doubled Kaikoura the number being fed by the school has doubled in Kaikoura the number being fed by the school has doubled in the Kaikoura the number being fed by the school has doubled in the last Kaikoura the number being fed by the school has doubled in the last four school has doubled in the last four years school has doubled in the last four years from school has doubled in the last four years from 15 school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to 20 school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to 20 to school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to 20 to now school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to 20 to now up school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to 20 to now up to school has doubled in the last four years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out of years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out of a years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out of a total years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out of a total of years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out of a total of 75 years from 15 to 20 to now up to 45 pupils out of a total of 75 and pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau School pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau School is pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau School is not pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau School is not unique pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau School is not unique in pupils out of a total of 75 and Toterau School is not unique in this Toterau School is not unique in this country. Toterau School is not unique in this country. Again, Toterau School is not unique in this country. Again, that's Toterau School is not unique in this country. Again, that's another Toterau School is not unique in this country. Again, that's another part country. Again, that's another part of country. Again, that's another part of the country. Again, that's another part of the legacy country. Again, that's another part of the legacy for country. Again, that's another part of the legacy for those country. Again, that's another part of the legacy for those who country. Again, that's another part of the legacy for those who care of the legacy for those who care about of the legacy for those who care about a of the legacy for those who care about a balanced, of the legacy for those who care about a balanced, fair of the legacy for those who care about a balanced, fair assessment. about a balanced, fair assessment. On about a balanced, fair assessment. On youth about a balanced, fair assessment. On youth unemployment, about a balanced, fair assessment. On youth unemployment, there about a balanced, fair assessment. On youth unemployment, there are On youth unemployment, there are 75,000 On youth unemployment, there are 75,000 young On youth unemployment, there are 75,000 young New On youth unemployment, there are 75,000 young New Zealanders On youth unemployment, there are 75,000 young New Zealanders who On youth unemployment, there are 75,000 young New Zealanders who are 75,000 young New Zealanders who are not 75,000 young New Zealanders who are not in 75,000 young New Zealanders who are not in employment, 75,000 young New Zealanders who are not in employment, education 75,000 young New Zealanders who are not in employment, education or not in employment, education or training. not in employment, education or training. 75,000. not in employment, education or training. 75,000. You not in employment, education or training. 75,000. You want not in employment, education or training. 75,000. You want to not in employment, education or training. 75,000. You want to take training. 75,000. You want to take about training. 75,000. You want to take about a training. 75,000. You want to take about a legacy training. 75,000. You want to take about a legacy - training. 75,000. You want to take about a legacy - this training. 75,000. You want to take about a legacy - this is training. 75,000. You want to take about a legacy - this is what training. 75,000. You want to take about a legacy - this is what the about a legacy - this is what the next about a legacy - this is what the next election about a legacy - this is what the next election is about a legacy - this is what the next election is going about a legacy - this is what the next election is going to about a legacy - this is what the next election is going to be about a legacy - this is what the next election is going to be about, next election is going to be about, and next election is going to be about, and if next election is going to be about, and if you next election is going to be about, and if you want next election is going to be about, and if you want to next election is going to be about, and if you want to believe next election is going to be about, and if you want to believe shonky and if you want to believe shonky polls, and if you want to believe shonky polls, you and if you want to believe shonky polls, you go and if you want to believe shonky polls, you go and and if you want to believe shonky polls, you go and believe and if you want to believe shonky polls, you go and believe in and if you want to believe shonky polls, you go and believe in them, polls, you go and believe in them, but polls, you go and believe in them, but that's polls, you go and believe in them, but that's what polls, you go and believe in them, but that's what the polls, you go and believe in them, but that's what the next polls, you go and believe in them, but that's what the next election polls, you go and believe in them, but that's what the next election is but that's what the next election is going but that's what the next election is going to but that's what the next election is going to be but that's what the next election is going to be about. but that's what the next election is going to be about. 75,000 but that's what the next election is going to be about. 75,000 - but that's what the next election is going to be about. 75,000 - a going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking time going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking time bomb going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking time bomb which, going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking time bomb which, in going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking time bomb which, in the going to be about. 75,000 - a ticking time bomb which, in the last ticking time bomb which, in the last eight ticking time bomb which, in the last eight years, ticking time bomb which, in the last eight years, has ticking time bomb which, in the last eight years, has never ticking time bomb which, in the last eight years, has never been eight years, has never been addressed. eight years, has never been addressed. To eight years, has never been addressed. To make eight years, has never been addressed. To make matters eight years, has never been addressed. To make matters worse, addressed. To make matters worse, hundreds addressed. To make matters worse, hundreds of addressed. To make matters worse, hundreds of thousands addressed. To make matters worse, hundreds of thousands of addressed. To make matters worse, hundreds of thousands of immigrants hundreds of thousands of immigrants have hundreds of thousands of immigrants have been hundreds of thousands of immigrants have been allowed hundreds of thousands of immigrants have been allowed into hundreds of thousands of immigrants have been allowed into this hundreds of thousands of immigrants have been allowed into this country, have been allowed into this country, many have been allowed into this country, many of have been allowed into this country, many of them have been allowed into this country, many of them on have been allowed into this country, many of them on student have been allowed into this country, many of them on student visas have been allowed into this country, many of them on student visas who many of them on student visas who are many of them on student visas who are entitled many of them on student visas who are entitled to many of them on student visas who are entitled to work. many of them on student visas who are entitled to work. It many of them on student visas who are entitled to work. It has many of them on student visas who are entitled to work. It has driven are entitled to work. It has driven down are entitled to work. It has driven down wages, are entitled to work. It has driven down wages, seen are entitled to work. It has driven down wages, seen some are entitled to work. It has driven down wages, seen some appalling down wages, seen some appalling abuse down wages, seen some appalling abuse of down wages, seen some appalling abuse of work down wages, seen some appalling abuse of work conditions, down wages, seen some appalling abuse of work conditions, illegal abuse of work conditions, illegal hours, abuse of work conditions, illegal hours, under abuse of work conditions, illegal hours, under minimum abuse of work conditions, illegal hours, under minimum wage abuse of work conditions, illegal hours, under minimum wage payments, hours, under minimum wage payments, wide hours, under minimum wage payments, wide scale hours, under minimum wage payments, wide scale corruption hours, under minimum wage payments, wide scale corruption of hours, under minimum wage payments, wide scale corruption of export wide scale corruption of export education wide scale corruption of export education and wide scale corruption of export education and 20-hour wide scale corruption of export education and 20-hour work wide scale corruption of export education and 20-hour work visas wide scale corruption of export education and 20-hour work visas are education and 20-hour work visas are permitted education and 20-hour work visas are permitted all education and 20-hour work visas are permitted all the education and 20-hour work visas are permitted all the time. education and 20-hour work visas are permitted all the time. All education and 20-hour work visas are permitted all the time. All this education and 20-hour work visas are permitted all the time. All this has permitted all the time. All this has made permitted all the time. All this has made it permitted all the time. All this has made it difficult permitted all the time. All this has made it difficult for permitted all the time. All this has made it difficult for young permitted all the time. All this has made it difficult for young New made it difficult for young New Zealanders made it difficult for young New Zealanders to made it difficult for young New Zealanders to find made it difficult for young New Zealanders to find a made it difficult for young New Zealanders to find a job. Zealanders to find a job. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, I'm <INTERRUPTION> Well, I'm telling <INTERRUPTION> Well, I'm telling what <INTERRUPTION> Well, I'm telling what I <INTERRUPTION> Well, I'm telling what I really Well, I'm telling what I really think, Well, I'm telling what I really think, Mr Well, I'm telling what I really think, Mr Brownlee. Well, I'm telling what I really think, Mr Brownlee. Because, Well, I'm telling what I really think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, some think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, some of think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, some of us think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, some of us people think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, some of us people in think, Mr Brownlee. Because, unlike you, some of us people in this you, some of us people in this country you, some of us people in this country are you, some of us people in this country are concerned... you, some of us people in this country are concerned... Are country are concerned... Are concerned country are concerned... Are concerned to country are concerned... Are concerned to do country are concerned... Are concerned to do something country are concerned... Are concerned to do something about country are concerned... Are concerned to do something about it. concerned to do something about it. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Not <INTERRUPTION> Not - <INTERRUPTION> Not - not <INTERRUPTION> Not - not get <INTERRUPTION> Not - not get our <INTERRUPTION> Not - not get our snout <INTERRUPTION> Not - not get our snout in <INTERRUPTION> Not - not get our snout in the Not - not get our snout in the trough, Not - not get our snout in the trough, our Not - not get our snout in the trough, our forefeet Not - not get our snout in the trough, our forefeet and Not - not get our snout in the trough, our forefeet and snout Not - not get our snout in the trough, our forefeet and snout in trough, our forefeet and snout in the trough, our forefeet and snout in the trough trough, our forefeet and snout in the trough and trough, our forefeet and snout in the trough and think trough, our forefeet and snout in the trough and think that's trough, our forefeet and snout in the trough and think that's where the trough and think that's where life the trough and think that's where life stops. the trough and think that's where life stops. Oh the trough and think that's where life stops. Oh no, the trough and think that's where life stops. Oh no, and the trough and think that's where life stops. Oh no, and what the trough and think that's where life stops. Oh no, and what I'm life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to do life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to do about life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to do about it life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to do about it - life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to do about it - what life stops. Oh no, and what I'm going to do about it - what we're going to do about it - what we're going going to do about it - what we're going to going to do about it - what we're going to do going to do about it - what we're going to do about going to do about it - what we're going to do about it going to do about it - what we're going to do about it is going to do about it - what we're going to do about it is get going to do about it - what we're going to do about it is get rid going to do about it - what we're going to do about it is get rid of going to do about it is get rid of you! going to do about it is get rid of you! That's going to do about it is get rid of you! That's the going to do about it is get rid of you! That's the first going to do about it is get rid of you! That's the first thing going to do about it is get rid of you! That's the first thing we're you! That's the first thing we're going you! That's the first thing we're going to you! That's the first thing we're going to do you! That's the first thing we're going to do - you! That's the first thing we're going to do - get you! That's the first thing we're going to do - get rid you! That's the first thing we're going to do - get rid of you! That's the first thing we're going to do - get rid of him. you! That's the first thing we're going to do - get rid of him. Now, going to do - get rid of him. Now, that going to do - get rid of him. Now, that degradation going to do - get rid of him. Now, that degradation in going to do - get rid of him. Now, that degradation in the going to do - get rid of him. Now, that degradation in the workforce that degradation in the workforce and that degradation in the workforce and the that degradation in the workforce and the absolute that degradation in the workforce and the absolute abandonment that degradation in the workforce and the absolute abandonment of that degradation in the workforce and the absolute abandonment of fair and the absolute abandonment of fair play and the absolute abandonment of fair play amongst and the absolute abandonment of fair play amongst the and the absolute abandonment of fair play amongst the young and the absolute abandonment of fair play amongst the young coming and the absolute abandonment of fair play amongst the young coming into play amongst the young coming into this play amongst the young coming into this country play amongst the young coming into this country in play amongst the young coming into this country in the play amongst the young coming into this country in the workforce play amongst the young coming into this country in the workforce is play amongst the young coming into this country in the workforce is a this country in the workforce is a disgrace, this country in the workforce is a disgrace, it's this country in the workforce is a disgrace, it's a this country in the workforce is a disgrace, it's a legacy. this country in the workforce is a disgrace, it's a legacy. And this country in the workforce is a disgrace, it's a legacy. And on this country in the workforce is a disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, claimed disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, claimed to disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, claimed to be disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, claimed to be a disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, claimed to be a rock disgrace, it's a legacy. And on the economy, claimed to be a rock star economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle - economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle - well, economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle - well, lately, economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle - well, lately, a economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle - well, lately, a number economy, claimed to be a rock star miracle - well, lately, a number of miracle - well, lately, a number of economists miracle - well, lately, a number of economists have miracle - well, lately, a number of economists have described miracle - well, lately, a number of economists have described it miracle - well, lately, a number of economists have described it as economists have described it as nothing economists have described it as nothing like economists have described it as nothing like that, economists have described it as nothing like that, but economists have described it as nothing like that, but a economists have described it as nothing like that, but a mirage. economists have described it as nothing like that, but a mirage. For nothing like that, but a mirage. For the nothing like that, but a mirage. For the year nothing like that, but a mirage. For the year ended nothing like that, but a mirage. For the year ended - nothing like that, but a mirage. For the year ended - a nothing like that, but a mirage. For the year ended - a mirage... the year ended - a mirage... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> ..a <INTERRUPTION> ..a mirage <INTERRUPTION> ..a mirage that's <INTERRUPTION> ..a mirage that's mainly <INTERRUPTION> ..a mirage that's mainly about <INTERRUPTION> ..a mirage that's mainly about your ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. For ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. For the ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. For the end ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. For the end of ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. For the end of June ..a mirage that's mainly about your lifestyle. For the end of June 2016, lifestyle. For the end of June 2016, New lifestyle. For the end of June 2016, New Zealand's lifestyle. For the end of June 2016, New Zealand's current lifestyle. For the end of June 2016, New Zealand's current account New Zealand's current account deficit New Zealand's current account deficit ran New Zealand's current account deficit ran at New Zealand's current account deficit ran at six New Zealand's current account deficit ran at six - New Zealand's current account deficit ran at six - sorry, New Zealand's current account deficit ran at six - sorry, $7.4 deficit ran at six - sorry, $7.4 billion. deficit ran at six - sorry, $7.4 billion. Net deficit ran at six - sorry, $7.4 billion. Net international billion. Net international investment billion. Net international investment position billion. Net international investment position - billion. Net international investment position - we billion. Net international investment position - we owe billion. Net international investment position - we owe the investment position - we owe the rest investment position - we owe the rest of investment position - we owe the rest of the investment position - we owe the rest of the world investment position - we owe the rest of the world a investment position - we owe the rest of the world a negative investment position - we owe the rest of the world a negative 163 rest of the world a negative 163 billion. rest of the world a negative 163 billion. Now, rest of the world a negative 163 billion. Now, they rest of the world a negative 163 billion. Now, they claim rest of the world a negative 163 billion. Now, they claim our rest of the world a negative 163 billion. Now, they claim our GDP billion. Now, they claim our GDP growth billion. Now, they claim our GDP growth rate billion. Now, they claim our GDP growth rate is billion. Now, they claim our GDP growth rate is 3.5%. billion. Now, they claim our GDP growth rate is 3.5%. That's billion. Now, they claim our GDP growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull dust. growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull dust. Because growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull dust. Because you've growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull dust. Because you've got growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull dust. Because you've got a growth rate is 3.5%. That's bull dust. Because you've got a 2% dust. Because you've got a 2% population dust. Because you've got a 2% population growth dust. Because you've got a 2% population growth and dust. Because you've got a 2% population growth and before dust. Because you've got a 2% population growth and before you population growth and before you start, population growth and before you start, you population growth and before you start, you have population growth and before you start, you have to population growth and before you start, you have to extract population growth and before you start, you have to extract that population growth and before you start, you have to extract that from start, you have to extract that from your start, you have to extract that from your so-called start, you have to extract that from your so-called projections. start, you have to extract that from your so-called projections. So start, you have to extract that from your so-called projections. So what your so-called projections. So what is your so-called projections. So what is your your so-called projections. So what is your growth your so-called projections. So what is your growth rate? your so-called projections. So what is your growth rate? 1.6, your so-called projections. So what is your growth rate? 1.6, which your so-called projections. So what is your growth rate? 1.6, which is is your growth rate? 1.6, which is the is your growth rate? 1.6, which is the OECD is your growth rate? 1.6, which is the OECD average. is your growth rate? 1.6, which is the OECD average. Stop is your growth rate? 1.6, which is the OECD average. Stop misleading the OECD average. Stop misleading people the OECD average. Stop misleading people with the OECD average. Stop misleading people with rubbish the OECD average. Stop misleading people with rubbish and the OECD average. Stop misleading people with rubbish and I the OECD average. Stop misleading people with rubbish and I wish the OECD average. Stop misleading people with rubbish and I wish some people with rubbish and I wish some journalists people with rubbish and I wish some journalists got people with rubbish and I wish some journalists got themselves people with rubbish and I wish some journalists got themselves a people with rubbish and I wish some journalists got themselves a basic journalists got themselves a basic understanding journalists got themselves a basic understanding of journalists got themselves a basic understanding of fundamental understanding of fundamental economics understanding of fundamental economics because understanding of fundamental economics because if understanding of fundamental economics because if you understanding of fundamental economics because if you talk understanding of fundamental economics because if you talk about economics because if you talk about the economics because if you talk about the GDP, economics because if you talk about the GDP, you economics because if you talk about the GDP, you have economics because if you talk about the GDP, you have to economics because if you talk about the GDP, you have to factor economics because if you talk about the GDP, you have to factor in economics because if you talk about the GDP, you have to factor in your the GDP, you have to factor in your population the GDP, you have to factor in your population growth. the GDP, you have to factor in your population growth. Every the GDP, you have to factor in your population growth. Every idiot the GDP, you have to factor in your population growth. Every idiot knows population growth. Every idiot knows that, population growth. Every idiot knows that, except population growth. Every idiot knows that, except some population growth. Every idiot knows that, except some I population growth. Every idiot knows that, except some I can't population growth. Every idiot knows that, except some I can't name, that, except some I can't name, because that, except some I can't name, because I'm that, except some I can't name, because I'm too that, except some I can't name, because I'm too nice that, except some I can't name, because I'm too nice a that, except some I can't name, because I'm too nice a person that, except some I can't name, because I'm too nice a person to that, except some I can't name, because I'm too nice a person to do because I'm too nice a person to do so. because I'm too nice a person to do so. <INTERRUPTION> so. <INTERRUPTION> Without so. <INTERRUPTION> Without this so. <INTERRUPTION> Without this adjustment, so. <INTERRUPTION> Without this adjustment, for so. <INTERRUPTION> Without this adjustment, for the Without this adjustment, for the population Without this adjustment, for the population growth, Without this adjustment, for the population growth, the Without this adjustment, for the population growth, the numbers Without this adjustment, for the population growth, the numbers are population growth, the numbers are totally population growth, the numbers are totally deceptive. population growth, the numbers are totally deceptive. Again, population growth, the numbers are totally deceptive. Again, that population growth, the numbers are totally deceptive. Again, that is totally deceptive. Again, that is the totally deceptive. Again, that is the real totally deceptive. Again, that is the real legacy. totally deceptive. Again, that is the real legacy. And totally deceptive. Again, that is the real legacy. And on totally deceptive. Again, that is the real legacy. And on the totally deceptive. Again, that is the real legacy. And on the other the real legacy. And on the other things the real legacy. And on the other things - the real legacy. And on the other things - the the real legacy. And on the other things - the flag the real legacy. And on the other things - the flag referendum, the real legacy. And on the other things - the flag referendum, $26 things - the flag referendum, $26 million things - the flag referendum, $26 million needlessly things - the flag referendum, $26 million needlessly frittered things - the flag referendum, $26 million needlessly frittered away things - the flag referendum, $26 million needlessly frittered away on million needlessly frittered away on a million needlessly frittered away on a referendum. million needlessly frittered away on a referendum. A million needlessly frittered away on a referendum. A great million needlessly frittered away on a referendum. A great splash million needlessly frittered away on a referendum. A great splash of a referendum. A great splash of advertisements a referendum. A great splash of advertisements and a referendum. A great splash of advertisements and by a referendum. A great splash of advertisements and by the a referendum. A great splash of advertisements and by the flag advertisements and by the flag consideration advertisements and by the flag consideration panel advertisements and by the flag consideration panel going advertisements and by the flag consideration panel going to consideration panel going to ridiculous consideration panel going to ridiculous meetings consideration panel going to ridiculous meetings at consideration panel going to ridiculous meetings at empty consideration panel going to ridiculous meetings at empty halls ridiculous meetings at empty halls up ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and down ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and down the ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and down the country ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and down the country - ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and down the country - and ridiculous meetings at empty halls up and down the country - and even up and down the country - and even today, up and down the country - and even today, the up and down the country - and even today, the retiring up and down the country - and even today, the retiring PM up and down the country - and even today, the retiring PM said up and down the country - and even today, the retiring PM said he up and down the country - and even today, the retiring PM said he had up and down the country - and even today, the retiring PM said he had a today, the retiring PM said he had a hope today, the retiring PM said he had a hope that today, the retiring PM said he had a hope that that today, the retiring PM said he had a hope that that would today, the retiring PM said he had a hope that that would be today, the retiring PM said he had a hope that that would be his today, the retiring PM said he had a hope that that would be his legacy. hope that that would be his legacy. In hope that that would be his legacy. In this hope that that would be his legacy. In this case, hope that that would be his legacy. In this case, there hope that that would be his legacy. In this case, there is hope that that would be his legacy. In this case, there is a hope that that would be his legacy. In this case, there is a flag hope that that would be his legacy. In this case, there is a flag legacy In this case, there is a flag legacy - In this case, there is a flag legacy - belonging In this case, there is a flag legacy - belonging to In this case, there is a flag legacy - belonging to someone In this case, there is a flag legacy - belonging to someone else, In this case, there is a flag legacy - belonging to someone else, in In this case, there is a flag legacy - belonging to someone else, in a - belonging to someone else, in a different - belonging to someone else, in a different age. - belonging to someone else, in a different age. Then - belonging to someone else, in a different age. Then the - belonging to someone else, in a different age. Then the Government different age. Then the Government hitched different age. Then the Government hitched their different age. Then the Government hitched their wagon different age. Then the Government hitched their wagon to different age. Then the Government hitched their wagon to the different age. Then the Government hitched their wagon to the TPPA. hitched their wagon to the TPPA. Railroaded hitched their wagon to the TPPA. Railroaded the hitched their wagon to the TPPA. Railroaded the law hitched their wagon to the TPPA. Railroaded the law through hitched their wagon to the TPPA. Railroaded the law through this Railroaded the law through this parliament Railroaded the law through this parliament to Railroaded the law through this parliament to welcome Railroaded the law through this parliament to welcome its Railroaded the law through this parliament to welcome its arrival Railroaded the law through this parliament to welcome its arrival - parliament to welcome its arrival - and parliament to welcome its arrival - and it's parliament to welcome its arrival - and it's all parliament to welcome its arrival - and it's all crashed parliament to welcome its arrival - and it's all crashed as parliament to welcome its arrival - and it's all crashed as New parliament to welcome its arrival - and it's all crashed as New Zealand and it's all crashed as New Zealand First and it's all crashed as New Zealand First said and it's all crashed as New Zealand First said it and it's all crashed as New Zealand First said it would and it's all crashed as New Zealand First said it would in and it's all crashed as New Zealand First said it would in February and it's all crashed as New Zealand First said it would in February of First said it would in February of the First said it would in February of the year. First said it would in February of the year. We First said it would in February of the year. We said First said it would in February of the year. We said it First said it would in February of the year. We said it in First said it would in February of the year. We said it in February First said it would in February of the year. We said it in February of the year. We said it in February of this the year. We said it in February of this year. the year. We said it in February of this year. We the year. We said it in February of this year. We also the year. We said it in February of this year. We also said the year. We said it in February of this year. We also said that the year. We said it in February of this year. We also said that Donald this year. We also said that Donald Trump this year. We also said that Donald Trump was this year. We also said that Donald Trump was going this year. We also said that Donald Trump was going to this year. We also said that Donald Trump was going to win, this year. We also said that Donald Trump was going to win, so this year. We also said that Donald Trump was going to win, so stop Trump was going to win, so stop wasting Trump was going to win, so stop wasting people's Trump was going to win, so stop wasting people's money Trump was going to win, so stop wasting people's money and Trump was going to win, so stop wasting people's money and time. Trump was going to win, so stop wasting people's money and time. Oh wasting people's money and time. Oh no, wasting people's money and time. Oh no, they wasting people's money and time. Oh no, they can't wasting people's money and time. Oh no, they can't listen wasting people's money and time. Oh no, they can't listen - wasting people's money and time. Oh no, they can't listen - got wasting people's money and time. Oh no, they can't listen - got all no, they can't listen - got all no, they can't listen - got all no, they can't listen - got all these experts no, they can't listen - got all these experts who no, they can't listen - got all these experts who knows no, they can't listen - got all these experts who knows a no, they can't listen - got all these experts who knows a lot no, they can't listen - got all these experts who knows a lot about these experts who knows a lot about everything these experts who knows a lot about everything -- these experts who knows a lot about everything -- who these experts who knows a lot about everything -- who know these experts who knows a lot about everything -- who know a these experts who knows a lot about everything -- who know a lot these experts who knows a lot about everything -- who know a lot about everything -- who know a lot about everything, everything -- who know a lot about everything, until everything -- who know a lot about everything, until it everything -- who know a lot about everything, until it comes everything -- who know a lot about everything, until it comes to everything -- who know a lot about everything, until it comes to saying everything, until it comes to saying when everything, until it comes to saying when did everything, until it comes to saying when did they everything, until it comes to saying when did they get everything, until it comes to saying when did they get their everything, until it comes to saying when did they get their forecast when did they get their forecast right. when did they get their forecast right. The when did they get their forecast right. The TPPA when did they get their forecast right. The TPPA means when did they get their forecast right. The TPPA means nothing. when did they get their forecast right. The TPPA means nothing. Put right. The TPPA means nothing. Put aside right. The TPPA means nothing. Put aside other right. The TPPA means nothing. Put aside other deals, right. The TPPA means nothing. Put aside other deals, with right. The TPPA means nothing. Put aside other deals, with tariffs right. The TPPA means nothing. Put aside other deals, with tariffs of aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this is aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this is not aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this is not a aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this is not a legacy. aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this is not a legacy. On aside other deals, with tariffs of 1.6% - this is not a legacy. On the 1.6% - this is not a legacy. On the resource 1.6% - this is not a legacy. On the resource management 1.6% - this is not a legacy. On the resource management legislation 1.6% - this is not a legacy. On the resource management legislation they resource management legislation they did resource management legislation they did a resource management legislation they did a deal resource management legislation they did a deal between resource management legislation they did a deal between the resource management legislation they did a deal between the Government did a deal between the Government and did a deal between the Government and the did a deal between the Government and the Maori did a deal between the Government and the Maori Party did a deal between the Government and the Maori Party to did a deal between the Government and the Maori Party to push did a deal between the Government and the Maori Party to push the did a deal between the Government and the Maori Party to push the RMA and the Maori Party to push the RMA changes and the Maori Party to push the RMA changes and and the Maori Party to push the RMA changes and that and the Maori Party to push the RMA changes and that has and the Maori Party to push the RMA changes and that has been and the Maori Party to push the RMA changes and that has been an changes and that has been an absolute changes and that has been an absolute disaster. absolute disaster. <BELL absolute disaster. <BELL RUNG> <BELL RUNG> National <BELL RUNG> National chose <BELL RUNG> National chose iwi <BELL RUNG> National chose iwi over <BELL RUNG> National chose iwi over Kiwi. <BELL RUNG> National chose iwi over Kiwi. His National chose iwi over Kiwi. His Government National chose iwi over Kiwi. His Government has National chose iwi over Kiwi. His Government has forced National chose iwi over Kiwi. His Government has forced parallel, Government has forced parallel, unelected, Government has forced parallel, unelected, race-based Government has forced parallel, unelected, race-based control Government has forced parallel, unelected, race-based control on unelected, race-based control on this unelected, race-based control on this country unelected, race-based control on this country and unelected, race-based control on this country and is unelected, race-based control on this country and is putting unelected, race-based control on this country and is putting consent this country and is putting consent laws this country and is putting consent laws and this country and is putting consent laws and whether this country and is putting consent laws and whether Maori this country and is putting consent laws and whether Maori or this country and is putting consent laws and whether Maori or European, laws and whether Maori or European, they've laws and whether Maori or European, they've come laws and whether Maori or European, they've come to laws and whether Maori or European, they've come to bitterly laws and whether Maori or European, they've come to bitterly resent laws and whether Maori or European, they've come to bitterly resent this they've come to bitterly resent this legacy, they've come to bitterly resent this legacy, which they've come to bitterly resent this legacy, which some they've come to bitterly resent this legacy, which some other they've come to bitterly resent this legacy, which some other Government legacy, which some other Government is legacy, which some other Government is going legacy, which some other Government is going to legacy, which some other Government is going to have legacy, which some other Government is going to have to legacy, which some other Government is going to have to fix legacy, which some other Government is going to have to fix up. legacy, which some other Government is going to have to fix up. So is going to have to fix up. So what's is going to have to fix up. So what's his is going to have to fix up. So what's his place is going to have to fix up. So what's his place in is going to have to fix up. So what's his place in history? is going to have to fix up. So what's his place in history? Well, what's his place in history? Well, let's what's his place in history? Well, let's be what's his place in history? Well, let's be fair what's his place in history? Well, let's be fair here, what's his place in history? Well, let's be fair here, he what's his place in history? Well, let's be fair here, he has what's his place in history? Well, let's be fair here, he has done let's be fair here, he has done better let's be fair here, he has done better than let's be fair here, he has done better than many. let's be fair here, he has done better than many. But let's be fair here, he has done better than many. But this let's be fair here, he has done better than many. But this is let's be fair here, he has done better than many. But this is not better than many. But this is not Sid better than many. But this is not Sid and better than many. But this is not Sid and Savage better than many. But this is not Sid and Savage and better than many. But this is not Sid and Savage and it better than many. But this is not Sid and Savage and it ain't Sid and Savage and it ain't Hollyoak. Sid and Savage and it ain't Hollyoak. Look Sid and Savage and it ain't Hollyoak. Look at Sid and Savage and it ain't Hollyoak. Look at the Sid and Savage and it ain't Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals Sid and Savage and it ain't Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals - Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals - there Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals - there are Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals - there are serious Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals - there are serious storm Hollyoak. Look at the fundamentals - there are serious storm clouds there are serious storm clouds gathering. there are serious storm clouds gathering. The there are serious storm clouds gathering. The decline there are serious storm clouds gathering. The decline in gathering. The decline in manufacturing, gathering. The decline in manufacturing, the gathering. The decline in manufacturing, the decline gathering. The decline in manufacturing, the decline in manufacturing, the decline in exports manufacturing, the decline in exports against manufacturing, the decline in exports against GDP. manufacturing, the decline in exports against GDP. There manufacturing, the decline in exports against GDP. There are exports against GDP. There are millions exports against GDP. There are millions of exports against GDP. There are millions of people exports against GDP. There are millions of people in exports against GDP. There are millions of people in this exports against GDP. There are millions of people in this country millions of people in this country that millions of people in this country that are millions of people in this country that are disillusioned millions of people in this country that are disillusioned and millions of people in this country that are disillusioned and even that are disillusioned and even Nationals that are disillusioned and even Nationals supporters that are disillusioned and even Nationals supporters are that are disillusioned and even Nationals supporters are beginning Nationals supporters are beginning to Nationals supporters are beginning to think Nationals supporters are beginning to think twice. Nationals supporters are beginning to think twice. At Nationals supporters are beginning to think twice. At Tohae Nationals supporters are beginning to think twice. At Tohae Hall Nationals supporters are beginning to think twice. At Tohae Hall we Nationals supporters are beginning to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands of to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands of people to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands of people out to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands of people out in to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands of people out in a to think twice. At Tohae Hall we got thousands of people out in a country thousands of people out in a country place thousands of people out in a country place with thousands of people out in a country place with no thousands of people out in a country place with no shop, thousands of people out in a country place with no shop, just thousands of people out in a country place with no shop, just a thousands of people out in a country place with no shop, just a school thousands of people out in a country place with no shop, just a school - place with no shop, just a school - 220. place with no shop, just a school - 220. I place with no shop, just a school - 220. I know place with no shop, just a school - 220. I know there's place with no shop, just a school - 220. I know there's a place with no shop, just a school - 220. I know there's a sea place with no shop, just a school - 220. I know there's a sea change, 220. I know there's a sea change, whether 220. I know there's a sea change, whether they 220. I know there's a sea change, whether they know 220. I know there's a sea change, whether they know it 220. I know there's a sea change, whether they know it or 220. I know there's a sea change, whether they know it or not, 220. I know there's a sea change, whether they know it or not, and whether they know it or not, and this whether they know it or not, and this sea whether they know it or not, and this sea change whether they know it or not, and this sea change which whether they know it or not, and this sea change which you whether they know it or not, and this sea change which you saw whether they know it or not, and this sea change which you saw in whether they know it or not, and this sea change which you saw in the this sea change which you saw in the UK, this sea change which you saw in the UK, you this sea change which you saw in the UK, you saw this sea change which you saw in the UK, you saw it this sea change which you saw in the UK, you saw it in this sea change which you saw in the UK, you saw it in the this sea change which you saw in the UK, you saw it in the Australian UK, you saw it in the Australian early UK, you saw it in the Australian early elections UK, you saw it in the Australian early elections there UK, you saw it in the Australian early elections there and UK, you saw it in the Australian early elections there and which UK, you saw it in the Australian early elections there and which you early elections there and which you saw early elections there and which you saw in early elections there and which you saw in the early elections there and which you saw in the United early elections there and which you saw in the United States... saw in the United States... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Oh <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, I <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, I did! <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, I did! I <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, I did! I looked <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, I did! I looked around <INTERRUPTION> Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, and Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, and I Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, and I saw Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, and I saw it. Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, and I saw it. And Oh yes, I did! I looked around you, not as you do, and I saw it. And I not as you do, and I saw it. And I said not as you do, and I saw it. And I said so, not as you do, and I saw it. And I said so, not not as you do, and I saw it. And I said so, not after not as you do, and I saw it. And I said so, not after the not as you do, and I saw it. And I said so, not after the event, not as you do, and I saw it. And I said so, not after the event, Mr said so, not after the event, Mr Brownlee, said so, not after the event, Mr Brownlee, but said so, not after the event, Mr Brownlee, but beforehand. said so, not after the event, Mr Brownlee, but beforehand. I said so, not after the event, Mr Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, real Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, real science, Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, real science, not Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, real science, not shonky Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, real science, not shonky polls Brownlee, but beforehand. I mean, real science, not shonky polls so real science, not shonky polls so badly real science, not shonky polls so badly exposed real science, not shonky polls so badly exposed by real science, not shonky polls so badly exposed by Brexit. real science, not shonky polls so badly exposed by Brexit. But real science, not shonky polls so badly exposed by Brexit. But you've badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it to badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it to Mr badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it to Mr Key badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it to Mr Key - badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it to Mr Key - a badly exposed by Brexit. But you've got to give it to Mr Key - a bit got to give it to Mr Key - a bit like got to give it to Mr Key - a bit like Kenny got to give it to Mr Key - a bit like Kenny Rogers, got to give it to Mr Key - a bit like Kenny Rogers, you've got to give it to Mr Key - a bit like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta got to give it to Mr Key - a bit like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you hold like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you hold him, like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you hold him, know like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you hold him, know when like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you hold him, know when to like Kenny Rogers, you've gotta know when you hold him, know when to fold when you hold him, know when to fold them, when you hold him, know when to fold them, know when you hold him, know when to fold them, know when when you hold him, know when to fold them, know when to when you hold him, know when to fold them, know when to walk when you hold him, know when to fold them, know when to walk away when you hold him, know when to fold them, know when to walk away and them, know when to walk away and know them, know when to walk away and know when them, know when to walk away and know when to them, know when to walk away and know when to run. them, know when to walk away and know when to run. He them, know when to walk away and know when to run. He saw them, know when to walk away and know when to run. He saw the them, know when to walk away and know when to run. He saw the bells know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, he know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, he saw know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, he saw those know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, he saw those polls, know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, he saw those polls, as know when to run. He saw the bells tolling, he saw those polls, as we tolling, he saw those polls, as we have tolling, he saw those polls, as we have saw tolling, he saw those polls, as we have saw them, tolling, he saw those polls, as we have saw them, and tolling, he saw those polls, as we have saw them, and he tolling, he saw those polls, as we have saw them, and he decided, have saw them, and he decided, "We'll have saw them, and he decided, "We'll leave have saw them, and he decided, "We'll leave it have saw them, and he decided, "We'll leave it to have saw them, and he decided, "We'll leave it to people have saw them, and he decided, "We'll leave it to people like "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". I "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". I don't "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". I don't want "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". I don't want to "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". I don't want to be "We'll leave it to people like Gerry". I don't want to be around, Gerry". I don't want to be around, he Gerry". I don't want to be around, he said, Gerry". I don't want to be around, he said, when Gerry". I don't want to be around, he said, when it Gerry". I don't want to be around, he said, when it all Gerry". I don't want to be around, he said, when it all falls Gerry". I don't want to be around, he said, when it all falls apart he said, when it all falls apart next he said, when it all falls apart next year. he said, when it all falls apart next year. That's he said, when it all falls apart next year. That's it he said, when it all falls apart next year. That's it -- he said, when it all falls apart next year. That's it -- that he said, when it all falls apart next year. That's it -- that said, he said, when it all falls apart next year. That's it -- that said, I next year. That's it -- that said, I wish next year. That's it -- that said, I wish Mr next year. That's it -- that said, I wish Mr Key next year. That's it -- that said, I wish Mr Key and next year. That's it -- that said, I wish Mr Key and his next year. That's it -- that said, I wish Mr Key and his colleagues next year. That's it -- that said, I wish Mr Key and his colleagues well wish Mr Key and his colleagues well in wish Mr Key and his colleagues well in the wish Mr Key and his colleagues well in the future, wish Mr Key and his colleagues well in the future, knowing wish Mr Key and his colleagues well in the future, knowing with wish Mr Key and his colleagues well in the future, knowing with total in the future, knowing with total confidence in the future, knowing with total confidence that in the future, knowing with total confidence that his in the future, knowing with total confidence that his successor in the future, knowing with total confidence that his successor will confidence that his successor will be confidence that his successor will be as confidence that his successor will be as worried confidence that his successor will be as worried about confidence that his successor will be as worried about his confidence that his successor will be as worried about his legacy confidence that his successor will be as worried about his legacy as be as worried about his legacy as New be as worried about his legacy as New Zealand be as worried about his legacy as New Zealand First be as worried about his legacy as New Zealand First is. be as worried about his legacy as New Zealand First is. The be as worried about his legacy as New Zealand First is. The Hon be as worried about his legacy as New Zealand First is. The Hon Bill New Zealand First is. The Hon Bill English. New Zealand First is. The Hon Bill English. Well, New Zealand First is. The Hon Bill English. Well, the... New Zealand First is. The Hon Bill English. Well, the... <INTERRUPTION> English. Well, the... <INTERRUPTION> Well, English. Well, the... <INTERRUPTION> Well, actually, English. Well, the... <INTERRUPTION> Well, actually, that English. Well, the... <INTERRUPTION> Well, actually, that contribution Well, actually, that contribution was Well, actually, that contribution was untypically Well, actually, that contribution was untypically graceless Well, actually, that contribution was untypically graceless from Well, actually, that contribution was untypically graceless from that was untypically graceless from that member. was untypically graceless from that member. Well, was untypically graceless from that member. Well, he was untypically graceless from that member. Well, he is was untypically graceless from that member. Well, he is a was untypically graceless from that member. Well, he is a member was untypically graceless from that member. Well, he is a member who member. Well, he is a member who understands member. Well, he is a member who understands the member. Well, he is a member who understands the traditions member. Well, he is a member who understands the traditions and understands the traditions and actually, understands the traditions and actually, often understands the traditions and actually, often at understands the traditions and actually, often at times, understands the traditions and actually, often at times, he understands the traditions and actually, often at times, he has actually, often at times, he has been actually, often at times, he has been one actually, often at times, he has been one of actually, often at times, he has been one of the actually, often at times, he has been one of the more actually, often at times, he has been one of the more polite actually, often at times, he has been one of the more polite and been one of the more polite and understanding been one of the more polite and understanding members been one of the more polite and understanding members of been one of the more polite and understanding members of this been one of the more polite and understanding members of this House understanding members of this House when understanding members of this House when it understanding members of this House when it has understanding members of this House when it has really understanding members of this House when it has really mattered, understanding members of this House when it has really mattered, and understanding members of this House when it has really mattered, and I when it has really mattered, and I would when it has really mattered, and I would have when it has really mattered, and I would have thought when it has really mattered, and I would have thought that when it has really mattered, and I would have thought that on when it has really mattered, and I would have thought that on this would have thought that on this occasion, would have thought that on this occasion, the would have thought that on this occasion, the first would have thought that on this occasion, the first time would have thought that on this occasion, the first time in, would have thought that on this occasion, the first time in, what, occasion, the first time in, what, 100 occasion, the first time in, what, 100 years, occasion, the first time in, what, 100 years, that occasion, the first time in, what, 100 years, that a occasion, the first time in, what, 100 years, that a PM occasion, the first time in, what, 100 years, that a PM has occasion, the first time in, what, 100 years, that a PM has voluntary 100 years, that a PM has voluntary decided 100 years, that a PM has voluntary decided to 100 years, that a PM has voluntary decided to resign 100 years, that a PM has voluntary decided to resign the 100 years, that a PM has voluntary decided to resign the job... decided to resign the job... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, Hollyoak <INTERRUPTION> Well, Hollyoak was <INTERRUPTION> Well, Hollyoak was under <INTERRUPTION> Well, Hollyoak was under a <INTERRUPTION> Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Key Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Key has Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Key has never Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Key has never been Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Key has never been under Well, Hollyoak was under a pressure that John Key has never been under - that John Key has never been under - never that John Key has never been under - never been that John Key has never been under - never been under. that John Key has never been under - never been under. I that John Key has never been under - never been under. I would that John Key has never been under - never been under. I would have never been under. I would have thought never been under. I would have thought the never been under. I would have thought the member never been under. I would have thought the member might never been under. I would have thought the member might have never been under. I would have thought the member might have been thought the member might have been slightly thought the member might have been slightly more thought the member might have been slightly more generous. thought the member might have been slightly more generous. But thought the member might have been slightly more generous. But he slightly more generous. But he wasn't. slightly more generous. But he wasn't. And slightly more generous. But he wasn't. And actually slightly more generous. But he wasn't. And actually that's slightly more generous. But he wasn't. And actually that's the wasn't. And actually that's the difference wasn't. And actually that's the difference between wasn't. And actually that's the difference between him wasn't. And actually that's the difference between him and wasn't. And actually that's the difference between him and John wasn't. And actually that's the difference between him and John Key. difference between him and John Key. John difference between him and John Key. John Key difference between him and John Key. John Key would difference between him and John Key. John Key would rather difference between him and John Key. John Key would rather work difference between him and John Key. John Key would rather work hard difference between him and John Key. John Key would rather work hard and John Key would rather work hard and strive John Key would rather work hard and strive for John Key would rather work hard and strive for a John Key would rather work hard and strive for a better John Key would rather work hard and strive for a better country... strive for a better country... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> ..that <INTERRUPTION> ..that member <INTERRUPTION> ..that member works <INTERRUPTION> ..that member works hard <INTERRUPTION> ..that member works hard and <INTERRUPTION> ..that member works hard and strives ..that member works hard and strives for ..that member works hard and strives for a ..that member works hard and strives for a bitter ..that member works hard and strives for a bitter country. ..that member works hard and strives for a bitter country. A ..that member works hard and strives for a bitter country. A better for a bitter country. A better country for a bitter country. A better country or for a bitter country. A better country or a for a bitter country. A better country or a bitter for a bitter country. A better country or a bitter country. for a bitter country. A better country or a bitter country. And country or a bitter country. And that country or a bitter country. And that wasn't country or a bitter country. And that wasn't - country or a bitter country. And that wasn't - couldn't country or a bitter country. And that wasn't - couldn't be country or a bitter country. And that wasn't - couldn't be more that wasn't - couldn't be more exemplified that wasn't - couldn't be more exemplified than that wasn't - couldn't be more exemplified than by that wasn't - couldn't be more exemplified than by that exemplified than by that contribution. exemplified than by that contribution. I exemplified than by that contribution. I mean, exemplified than by that contribution. I mean, the exemplified than by that contribution. I mean, the other contribution. I mean, the other difference contribution. I mean, the other difference is contribution. I mean, the other difference is this contribution. I mean, the other difference is this - contribution. I mean, the other difference is this - the contribution. I mean, the other difference is this - the PM, contribution. I mean, the other difference is this - the PM, who contribution. I mean, the other difference is this - the PM, who has difference is this - the PM, who has announced difference is this - the PM, who has announced his difference is this - the PM, who has announced his resignation, difference is this - the PM, who has announced his resignation, but difference is this - the PM, who has announced his resignation, but not announced his resignation, but not yet announced his resignation, but not yet resigned, announced his resignation, but not yet resigned, has announced his resignation, but not yet resigned, has always announced his resignation, but not yet resigned, has always believed yet resigned, has always believed you yet resigned, has always believed you get yet resigned, has always believed you get the yet resigned, has always believed you get the best yet resigned, has always believed you get the best from yet resigned, has always believed you get the best from people yet resigned, has always believed you get the best from people with you get the best from people with confidence, you get the best from people with confidence, not you get the best from people with confidence, not with you get the best from people with confidence, not with divisiveness. confidence, not with divisiveness. With confidence, not with divisiveness. With confidence, confidence, not with divisiveness. With confidence, not confidence, not with divisiveness. With confidence, not with confidence, not with divisiveness. With confidence, not with division. With confidence, not with division. And With confidence, not with division. And that With confidence, not with division. And that member With confidence, not with division. And that member should With confidence, not with division. And that member should acknowledge And that member should acknowledge today And that member should acknowledge today that And that member should acknowledge today that he And that member should acknowledge today that he could And that member should acknowledge today that he could have And that member should acknowledge today that he could have learned And that member should acknowledge today that he could have learned a today that he could have learned a few today that he could have learned a few political today that he could have learned a few political lessons. today that he could have learned a few political lessons. There today that he could have learned a few political lessons. There was today that he could have learned a few political lessons. There was a few political lessons. There was a time few political lessons. There was a time when few political lessons. There was a time when he few political lessons. There was a time when he could few political lessons. There was a time when he could fill few political lessons. There was a time when he could fill a few political lessons. There was a time when he could fill a stadium few political lessons. There was a time when he could fill a stadium in time when he could fill a stadium in the time when he could fill a stadium in the Trump time when he could fill a stadium in the Trump manner, time when he could fill a stadium in the Trump manner, it's time when he could fill a stadium in the Trump manner, it's just time when he could fill a stadium in the Trump manner, it's just that the Trump manner, it's just that that the Trump manner, it's just that that was the Trump manner, it's just that that was a the Trump manner, it's just that that was a long the Trump manner, it's just that that was a long time the Trump manner, it's just that that was a long time ago. that was a long time ago. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> There <INTERRUPTION> There was <INTERRUPTION> There was the <INTERRUPTION> There was the Tauranga <INTERRUPTION> There was the Tauranga Racecourse <INTERRUPTION> There was the Tauranga Racecourse to There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, and There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, and then There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, and then there There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, and then there was There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, and then there was a There was the Tauranga Racecourse to be fair, and then there was a big be fair, and then there was a big crowd be fair, and then there was a big crowd and be fair, and then there was a big crowd and then be fair, and then there was a big crowd and then they be fair, and then there was a big crowd and then they were be fair, and then there was a big crowd and then they were ready be fair, and then there was a big crowd and then they were ready for crowd and then they were ready for it. crowd and then they were ready for it. John crowd and then they were ready for it. John Key crowd and then they were ready for it. John Key has crowd and then they were ready for it. John Key has had crowd and then they were ready for it. John Key has had the crowd and then they were ready for it. John Key has had the impact crowd and then they were ready for it. John Key has had the impact of it. John Key has had the impact of changing it. John Key has had the impact of changing the it. John Key has had the impact of changing the way it. John Key has had the impact of changing the way New it. John Key has had the impact of changing the way New Zealand changing the way New Zealand politics changing the way New Zealand politics works changing the way New Zealand politics works and changing the way New Zealand politics works and his changing the way New Zealand politics works and his legacy changing the way New Zealand politics works and his legacy is changing the way New Zealand politics works and his legacy is not politics works and his legacy is not the politics works and his legacy is not the tirade politics works and his legacy is not the tirade of politics works and his legacy is not the tirade of bitterness politics works and his legacy is not the tirade of bitterness that politics works and his legacy is not the tirade of bitterness that the the tirade of bitterness that the member the tirade of bitterness that the member thought the tirade of bitterness that the member thought was the tirade of bitterness that the member thought was appropriate the tirade of bitterness that the member thought was appropriate for member thought was appropriate for this member thought was appropriate for this occasion, member thought was appropriate for this occasion, which member thought was appropriate for this occasion, which I member thought was appropriate for this occasion, which I actually this occasion, which I actually don't this occasion, which I actually don't think this occasion, which I actually don't think he this occasion, which I actually don't think he believed this occasion, which I actually don't think he believed most this occasion, which I actually don't think he believed most of this occasion, which I actually don't think he believed most of it, don't think he believed most of it, his don't think he believed most of it, his legacy don't think he believed most of it, his legacy is don't think he believed most of it, his legacy is actually don't think he believed most of it, his legacy is actually the his legacy is actually the opportunity his legacy is actually the opportunity he his legacy is actually the opportunity he has his legacy is actually the opportunity he has left his legacy is actually the opportunity he has left for his legacy is actually the opportunity he has left for this opportunity he has left for this country opportunity he has left for this country to opportunity he has left for this country to achieve opportunity he has left for this country to achieve so opportunity he has left for this country to achieve so much opportunity he has left for this country to achieve so much in opportunity he has left for this country to achieve so much in the country to achieve so much in the next country to achieve so much in the next five country to achieve so much in the next five to country to achieve so much in the next five to ten country to achieve so much in the next five to ten years. next five to ten years. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, what <INTERRUPTION> Well, what state <INTERRUPTION> Well, what state is <INTERRUPTION> Well, what state is it <INTERRUPTION> Well, what state is it in? <INTERRUPTION> Well, what state is it in? Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, what state is it in? Well, of Well, what state is it in? Well, of course Well, what state is it in? Well, of course there Well, what state is it in? Well, of course there are Well, what state is it in? Well, of course there are intractable Well, what state is it in? Well, of course there are intractable social course there are intractable social problems. course there are intractable social problems. <INTERRUPTION> problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they have problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they have proven problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they have proven to problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they have proven to be problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they have proven to be so problems. <INTERRUPTION> Well, they have proven to be so in Well, they have proven to be so in the Well, they have proven to be so in the past, Well, they have proven to be so in the past, as Well, they have proven to be so in the past, as the Well, they have proven to be so in the past, as the members Well, they have proven to be so in the past, as the members opposite the past, as the members opposite were the past, as the members opposite were in the past, as the members opposite were in given the past, as the members opposite were in given and the past, as the members opposite were in given and spent the past, as the members opposite were in given and spent billions the past, as the members opposite were in given and spent billions of were in given and spent billions of dollars were in given and spent billions of dollars of were in given and spent billions of dollars of taxpayers' were in given and spent billions of dollars of taxpayers' money were in given and spent billions of dollars of taxpayers' money trying dollars of taxpayers' money trying to dollars of taxpayers' money trying to deal dollars of taxpayers' money trying to deal with dollars of taxpayers' money trying to deal with those dollars of taxpayers' money trying to deal with those difficult dollars of taxpayers' money trying to deal with those difficult social to deal with those difficult social problems to deal with those difficult social problems such to deal with those difficult social problems such as to deal with those difficult social problems such as youth to deal with those difficult social problems such as youth unemployment. problems such as youth unemployment. But problems such as youth unemployment. But under problems such as youth unemployment. But under John problems such as youth unemployment. But under John Key's problems such as youth unemployment. But under John Key's leadership, But under John Key's leadership, with But under John Key's leadership, with the But under John Key's leadership, with the fresh But under John Key's leadership, with the fresh thinking, But under John Key's leadership, with the fresh thinking, with But under John Key's leadership, with the fresh thinking, with the with the fresh thinking, with the almost with the fresh thinking, with the almost unpolitical with the fresh thinking, with the almost unpolitical way with the fresh thinking, with the almost unpolitical way he with the fresh thinking, with the almost unpolitical way he has almost unpolitical way he has approached almost unpolitical way he has approached those almost unpolitical way he has approached those problems, almost unpolitical way he has approached those problems, this approached those problems, this Government approached those problems, this Government has approached those problems, this Government has developed approached those problems, this Government has developed a approached those problems, this Government has developed a toolkit Government has developed a toolkit that Government has developed a toolkit that will Government has developed a toolkit that will allow, Government has developed a toolkit that will allow, over Government has developed a toolkit that will allow, over the Government has developed a toolkit that will allow, over the next Government has developed a toolkit that will allow, over the next five that will allow, over the next five or that will allow, over the next five or ten that will allow, over the next five or ten years, that will allow, over the next five or ten years, us that will allow, over the next five or ten years, us to that will allow, over the next five or ten years, us to finally that will allow, over the next five or ten years, us to finally get that will allow, over the next five or ten years, us to finally get a or ten years, us to finally get a grip or ten years, us to finally get a grip at or ten years, us to finally get a grip at an or ten years, us to finally get a grip at an individual or ten years, us to finally get a grip at an individual and or ten years, us to finally get a grip at an individual and personal grip at an individual and personal level grip at an individual and personal level on grip at an individual and personal level on the grip at an individual and personal level on the kind grip at an individual and personal level on the kind of grip at an individual and personal level on the kind of social grip at an individual and personal level on the kind of social changes level on the kind of social changes that level on the kind of social changes that the level on the kind of social changes that the member level on the kind of social changes that the member outlined. level on the kind of social changes that the member outlined. In level on the kind of social changes that the member outlined. In that that the member outlined. In that sense that the member outlined. In that sense we that the member outlined. In that sense we agree that the member outlined. In that sense we agree - that the member outlined. In that sense we agree - of that the member outlined. In that sense we agree - of course that the member outlined. In that sense we agree - of course there's sense we agree - of course there's social sense we agree - of course there's social challenges. sense we agree - of course there's social challenges. The sense we agree - of course there's social challenges. The question sense we agree - of course there's social challenges. The question is, social challenges. The question is, who social challenges. The question is, who has social challenges. The question is, who has got social challenges. The question is, who has got a social challenges. The question is, who has got a fresh social challenges. The question is, who has got a fresh view social challenges. The question is, who has got a fresh view on social challenges. The question is, who has got a fresh view on those who has got a fresh view on those old who has got a fresh view on those old social who has got a fresh view on those old social challenges who has got a fresh view on those old social challenges and who has got a fresh view on those old social challenges and John who has got a fresh view on those old social challenges and John Key old social challenges and John Key did. old social challenges and John Key did. And old social challenges and John Key did. And still old social challenges and John Key did. And still does, old social challenges and John Key did. And still does, remarkably, did. And still does, remarkably, after did. And still does, remarkably, after ten did. And still does, remarkably, after ten years did. And still does, remarkably, after ten years as did. And still does, remarkably, after ten years as a did. And still does, remarkably, after ten years as a party did. And still does, remarkably, after ten years as a party leader after ten years as a party leader and after ten years as a party leader and eight after ten years as a party leader and eight years after ten years as a party leader and eight years as after ten years as a party leader and eight years as a after ten years as a party leader and eight years as a PM. after ten years as a party leader and eight years as a PM. So, after ten years as a party leader and eight years as a PM. So, the and eight years as a PM. So, the member and eight years as a PM. So, the member also and eight years as a PM. So, the member also referred and eight years as a PM. So, the member also referred to and eight years as a PM. So, the member also referred to this and eight years as a PM. So, the member also referred to this odd member also referred to this odd argument member also referred to this odd argument that member also referred to this odd argument that economic member also referred to this odd argument that economic growth argument that economic growth shouldn't argument that economic growth shouldn't count argument that economic growth shouldn't count people. argument that economic growth shouldn't count people. That argument that economic growth shouldn't count people. That if argument that economic growth shouldn't count people. That if more shouldn't count people. That if more people shouldn't count people. That if more people want shouldn't count people. That if more people want to shouldn't count people. That if more people want to live shouldn't count people. That if more people want to live in shouldn't count people. That if more people want to live in your shouldn't count people. That if more people want to live in your country, people want to live in your country, that's people want to live in your country, that's a people want to live in your country, that's a problem people want to live in your country, that's a problem for people want to live in your country, that's a problem for economic that's a problem for economic growth. that's a problem for economic growth. Well, that's a problem for economic growth. Well, it that's a problem for economic growth. Well, it isn't. growth. Well, it isn't. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Of <INTERRUPTION> Of course <INTERRUPTION> Of course if <INTERRUPTION> Of course if you <INTERRUPTION> Of course if you say, <INTERRUPTION> Of course if you say, if <INTERRUPTION> Of course if you say, if we <INTERRUPTION> Of course if you say, if we take Of course if you say, if we take away Of course if you say, if we take away all Of course if you say, if we take away all the Of course if you say, if we take away all the things Of course if you say, if we take away all the things that Of course if you say, if we take away all the things that make Of course if you say, if we take away all the things that make the away all the things that make the economy away all the things that make the economy grow, away all the things that make the economy grow, it's away all the things that make the economy grow, it's not away all the things that make the economy grow, it's not growing away all the things that make the economy grow, it's not growing - economy grow, it's not growing - well, economy grow, it's not growing - well, that's economy grow, it's not growing - well, that's true. economy grow, it's not growing - well, that's true. But economy grow, it's not growing - well, that's true. But actually, economy grow, it's not growing - well, that's true. But actually, the well, that's true. But actually, the member well, that's true. But actually, the member may well, that's true. But actually, the member may recall well, that's true. But actually, the member may recall himself well, that's true. But actually, the member may recall himself - well, that's true. But actually, the member may recall himself - and member may recall himself - and certainly member may recall himself - and certainly his member may recall himself - and certainly his colleagues member may recall himself - and certainly his colleagues in certainly his colleagues in Opposition certainly his colleagues in Opposition - certainly his colleagues in Opposition - campaigning certainly his colleagues in Opposition - campaigning for certainly his colleagues in Opposition - campaigning for quite Opposition - campaigning for quite some Opposition - campaigning for quite some time Opposition - campaigning for quite some time that Opposition - campaigning for quite some time that not Opposition - campaigning for quite some time that not enough Opposition - campaigning for quite some time that not enough people some time that not enough people wanted some time that not enough people wanted to some time that not enough people wanted to live some time that not enough people wanted to live in some time that not enough people wanted to live in New some time that not enough people wanted to live in New Zealand. some time that not enough people wanted to live in New Zealand. So wanted to live in New Zealand. So they wanted to live in New Zealand. So they have wanted to live in New Zealand. So they have to wanted to live in New Zealand. So they have to answer wanted to live in New Zealand. So they have to answer this wanted to live in New Zealand. So they have to answer this question wanted to live in New Zealand. So they have to answer this question - they have to answer this question - do they have to answer this question - do they they have to answer this question - do they believe they have to answer this question - do they believe that they have to answer this question - do they believe that it they have to answer this question - do they believe that it is they have to answer this question - do they believe that it is better they have to answer this question - do they believe that it is better to do they believe that it is better to have do they believe that it is better to have people do they believe that it is better to have people leaving do they believe that it is better to have people leaving the do they believe that it is better to have people leaving the country, have people leaving the country, because have people leaving the country, because that have people leaving the country, because that drives have people leaving the country, because that drives up have people leaving the country, because that drives up per have people leaving the country, because that drives up per capita because that drives up per capita GDP, because that drives up per capita GDP, or because that drives up per capita GDP, or do because that drives up per capita GDP, or do they because that drives up per capita GDP, or do they believe because that drives up per capita GDP, or do they believe it's because that drives up per capita GDP, or do they believe it's better GDP, or do they believe it's better that GDP, or do they believe it's better that our GDP, or do they believe it's better that our children GDP, or do they believe it's better that our children prefer GDP, or do they believe it's better that our children prefer to GDP, or do they believe it's better that our children prefer to live that our children prefer to live here, that our children prefer to live here, as that our children prefer to live here, as they that our children prefer to live here, as they have that our children prefer to live here, as they have amply here, as they have amply demonstrated here, as they have amply demonstrated under here, as they have amply demonstrated under the here, as they have amply demonstrated under the stewardship demonstrated under the stewardship of demonstrated under the stewardship of PM demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John Key? demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John Key? Just demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John Key? Just a demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John Key? Just a sense demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John Key? Just a sense of demonstrated under the stewardship of PM John Key? Just a sense of the of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of that of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of that - of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of that - in of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of that - in 2012, of PM John Key? Just a sense of the magnitude of that - in 2012, there magnitude of that - in 2012, there was magnitude of that - in 2012, there was a magnitude of that - in 2012, there was a net magnitude of that - in 2012, there was a net outflow magnitude of that - in 2012, there was a net outflow of magnitude of that - in 2012, there was a net outflow of 39,000 magnitude of that - in 2012, there was a net outflow of 39,000 people was a net outflow of 39,000 people to was a net outflow of 39,000 people to Australia. was a net outflow of 39,000 people to Australia. Actually was a net outflow of 39,000 people to Australia. Actually bigger was a net outflow of 39,000 people to Australia. Actually bigger than to Australia. Actually bigger than the to Australia. Actually bigger than the number to Australia. Actually bigger than the number of to Australia. Actually bigger than the number of seats to Australia. Actually bigger than the number of seats in to Australia. Actually bigger than the number of seats in the to Australia. Actually bigger than the number of seats in the stadium the number of seats in the stadium where the number of seats in the stadium where the the number of seats in the stadium where the PM the number of seats in the stadium where the PM did the number of seats in the stadium where the PM did the the number of seats in the stadium where the PM did the election the number of seats in the stadium where the PM did the election ad. where the PM did the election ad. And where the PM did the election ad. And last where the PM did the election ad. And last year, where the PM did the election ad. And last year, there where the PM did the election ad. And last year, there was where the PM did the election ad. And last year, there was an where the PM did the election ad. And last year, there was an inflow And last year, there was an inflow of And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And that And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And that is And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And that is one, And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And that is one, from And last year, there was an inflow of 2,000. And that is one, from my of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of view, of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of view, one of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of view, one of of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of view, one of the of 2,000. And that is one, from my point of view, one of the lasting point of view, one of the lasting legacies point of view, one of the lasting legacies of point of view, one of the lasting legacies of John point of view, one of the lasting legacies of John Key. point of view, one of the lasting legacies of John Key. He point of view, one of the lasting legacies of John Key. He persuaded legacies of John Key. He persuaded New legacies of John Key. He persuaded New Zealanders, legacies of John Key. He persuaded New Zealanders, with legacies of John Key. He persuaded New Zealanders, with his legacies of John Key. He persuaded New Zealanders, with his confidence New Zealanders, with his confidence and New Zealanders, with his confidence and his New Zealanders, with his confidence and his leadership, New Zealanders, with his confidence and his leadership, that New Zealanders, with his confidence and his leadership, that this New Zealanders, with his confidence and his leadership, that this could and his leadership, that this could be and his leadership, that this could be a and his leadership, that this could be a country and his leadership, that this could be a country where and his leadership, that this could be a country where their and his leadership, that this could be a country where their children be a country where their children would be a country where their children would want be a country where their children would want to be a country where their children would want to stay be a country where their children would want to stay and be a country where their children would want to stay and make be a country where their children would want to stay and make a be a country where their children would want to stay and make a living would want to stay and make a living and would want to stay and make a living and raise would want to stay and make a living and raise a would want to stay and make a living and raise a family. would want to stay and make a living and raise a family. In would want to stay and make a living and raise a family. In fact, would want to stay and make a living and raise a family. In fact, we would want to stay and make a living and raise a family. In fact, we keep and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking that and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking that the and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking that the tide and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking that the tide must and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking that the tide must turn and raise a family. In fact, we keep thinking that the tide must turn - thinking that the tide must turn - but thinking that the tide must turn - but it thinking that the tide must turn - but it hasn't. thinking that the tide must turn - but it hasn't. But thinking that the tide must turn - but it hasn't. But it thinking that the tide must turn - but it hasn't. But it hasn't. thinking that the tide must turn - but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So thinking that the tide must turn - but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I can but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I can quote but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I can quote all but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I can quote all sorts but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I can quote all sorts of but it hasn't. But it hasn't. So I can quote all sorts of economic can quote all sorts of economic figures can quote all sorts of economic figures about can quote all sorts of economic figures about where can quote all sorts of economic figures about where the can quote all sorts of economic figures about where the economy can quote all sorts of economic figures about where the economy has figures about where the economy has got figures about where the economy has got up figures about where the economy has got up to, figures about where the economy has got up to, but figures about where the economy has got up to, but the figures about where the economy has got up to, but the measure figures about where the economy has got up to, but the measure of figures about where the economy has got up to, but the measure of his got up to, but the measure of his legacy got up to, but the measure of his legacy is got up to, but the measure of his legacy is that got up to, but the measure of his legacy is that our got up to, but the measure of his legacy is that our children, got up to, but the measure of his legacy is that our children, our legacy is that our children, our families, legacy is that our children, our families, now legacy is that our children, our families, now think, legacy is that our children, our families, now think, when legacy is that our children, our families, now think, when they legacy is that our children, our families, now think, when they look families, now think, when they look at families, now think, when they look at the families, now think, when they look at the rest families, now think, when they look at the rest of families, now think, when they look at the rest of the families, now think, when they look at the rest of the world, families, now think, when they look at the rest of the world, this families, now think, when they look at the rest of the world, this is families, now think, when they look at the rest of the world, this is a at the rest of the world, this is a place at the rest of the world, this is a place where at the rest of the world, this is a place where they at the rest of the world, this is a place where they have at the rest of the world, this is a place where they have more place where they have more confidence place where they have more confidence that place where they have more confidence that they place where they have more confidence that they can place where they have more confidence that they can realise confidence that they can realise more confidence that they can realise more of confidence that they can realise more of their confidence that they can realise more of their aspirations. more of their aspirations. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, you <INTERRUPTION> Well, you know, <INTERRUPTION> Well, you know, that's <INTERRUPTION> Well, you know, that's the Well, you know, that's the difference Well, you know, that's the difference in Well, you know, that's the difference in this Well, you know, that's the difference in this House Well, you know, that's the difference in this House - Well, you know, that's the difference in this House - we're Well, you know, that's the difference in this House - we're in difference in this House - we're in favour difference in this House - we're in favour of difference in this House - we're in favour of growth difference in this House - we're in favour of growth and difference in this House - we're in favour of growth and everyone difference in this House - we're in favour of growth and everyone else favour of growth and everyone else is favour of growth and everyone else is against favour of growth and everyone else is against it. favour of growth and everyone else is against it. That's favour of growth and everyone else is against it. That's pretty favour of growth and everyone else is against it. That's pretty much is against it. That's pretty much our is against it. That's pretty much our ... is against it. That's pretty much our ... <INTERRUPTION> our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. So our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. So I our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. So I want our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. So I want to our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. So I want to take our ... <INTERRUPTION> Its unwinding. So I want to take the Its unwinding. So I want to take the opportunity Its unwinding. So I want to take the opportunity to Its unwinding. So I want to take the opportunity to make Its unwinding. So I want to take the opportunity to make a Its unwinding. So I want to take the opportunity to make a few Its unwinding. So I want to take the opportunity to make a few comments opportunity to make a few comments not opportunity to make a few comments not just opportunity to make a few comments not just on opportunity to make a few comments not just on the opportunity to make a few comments not just on the PM's opportunity to make a few comments not just on the PM's legacy, opportunity to make a few comments not just on the PM's legacy, but opportunity to make a few comments not just on the PM's legacy, but on not just on the PM's legacy, but on his not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of - not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of - his not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of - his way not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of - his way of not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of - his way of being not just on the PM's legacy, but on his way of - his way of being a his way of - his way of being a politician, his way of - his way of being a politician, his his way of - his way of being a politician, his way his way of - his way of being a politician, his way of his way of - his way of being a politician, his way of working his way of - his way of being a politician, his way of working with politician, his way of working with other politician, his way of working with other people. politician, his way of working with other people. I politician, his way of working with other people. I must politician, his way of working with other people. I must say... other people. I must say... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> I <INTERRUPTION> I must <INTERRUPTION> I must say <INTERRUPTION> I must say that <INTERRUPTION> I must say that the <INTERRUPTION> I must say that the way <INTERRUPTION> I must say that the way he <INTERRUPTION> I must say that the way he has I must say that the way he has conducted I must say that the way he has conducted his I must say that the way he has conducted his exit I must say that the way he has conducted his exit from I must say that the way he has conducted his exit from his I must say that the way he has conducted his exit from his position conducted his exit from his position illustrates conducted his exit from his position illustrates the conducted his exit from his position illustrates the graciousness conducted his exit from his position illustrates the graciousness and conducted his exit from his position illustrates the graciousness and the illustrates the graciousness and the consideration illustrates the graciousness and the consideration that illustrates the graciousness and the consideration that he illustrates the graciousness and the consideration that he has illustrates the graciousness and the consideration that he has shown consideration that he has shown every consideration that he has shown every single consideration that he has shown every single day consideration that he has shown every single day that consideration that he has shown every single day that I consideration that he has shown every single day that I have consideration that he has shown every single day that I have worked every single day that I have worked with every single day that I have worked with him every single day that I have worked with him as every single day that I have worked with him as a every single day that I have worked with him as a deputy every single day that I have worked with him as a deputy leader every single day that I have worked with him as a deputy leader and every single day that I have worked with him as a deputy leader and a with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. This with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. This is with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. This is a with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. This is a PM with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. This is a PM who, with him as a deputy leader and a Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite the Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite the enormous Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite the enormous pressures Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite the enormous pressures of Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite the enormous pressures of the Deputy PM. This is a PM who, despite the enormous pressures of the job... the enormous pressures of the job... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> always <INTERRUPTION> always ..is <INTERRUPTION> always ..is able <INTERRUPTION> always ..is able to <INTERRUPTION> always ..is able to turn <INTERRUPTION> always ..is able to turn up <INTERRUPTION> always ..is able to turn up to <INTERRUPTION> always ..is able to turn up to work always ..is able to turn up to work and always ..is able to turn up to work and deal always ..is able to turn up to work and deal with always ..is able to turn up to work and deal with people always ..is able to turn up to work and deal with people in always ..is able to turn up to work and deal with people in a always ..is able to turn up to work and deal with people in a confident and deal with people in a confident and and deal with people in a confident and cheerful and deal with people in a confident and cheerful manner, and deal with people in a confident and cheerful manner, always and deal with people in a confident and cheerful manner, always in and deal with people in a confident and cheerful manner, always in a and cheerful manner, always in a positive and cheerful manner, always in a positive manner, and cheerful manner, always in a positive manner, always and cheerful manner, always in a positive manner, always in and cheerful manner, always in a positive manner, always in a positive manner, always in a considerate positive manner, always in a considerate manner, positive manner, always in a considerate manner, and positive manner, always in a considerate manner, and always considerate manner, and always polite. considerate manner, and always polite. The considerate manner, and always polite. The way considerate manner, and always polite. The way he considerate manner, and always polite. The way he dealt considerate manner, and always polite. The way he dealt with considerate manner, and always polite. The way he dealt with people polite. The way he dealt with people he polite. The way he dealt with people he met polite. The way he dealt with people he met on polite. The way he dealt with people he met on the polite. The way he dealt with people he met on the campaign polite. The way he dealt with people he met on the campaign trail polite. The way he dealt with people he met on the campaign trail was polite. The way he dealt with people he met on the campaign trail was the he met on the campaign trail was the way he met on the campaign trail was the way he he met on the campaign trail was the way he dealt he met on the campaign trail was the way he dealt with he met on the campaign trail was the way he dealt with his he met on the campaign trail was the way he dealt with his colleagues way he dealt with his colleagues every way he dealt with his colleagues every single way he dealt with his colleagues every single day way he dealt with his colleagues every single day that way he dealt with his colleagues every single day that he way he dealt with his colleagues every single day that he has way he dealt with his colleagues every single day that he has held every single day that he has held office, every single day that he has held office, with every single day that he has held office, with just every single day that he has held office, with just a every single day that he has held office, with just a few every single day that he has held office, with just a few days every single day that he has held office, with just a few days left every single day that he has held office, with just a few days left to office, with just a few days left to go. office, with just a few days left to go. And office, with just a few days left to go. And that office, with just a few days left to go. And that has office, with just a few days left to go. And that has been office, with just a few days left to go. And that has been at office, with just a few days left to go. And that has been at the office, with just a few days left to go. And that has been at the core office, with just a few days left to go. And that has been at the core of go. And that has been at the core of his go. And that has been at the core of his other go. And that has been at the core of his other major go. And that has been at the core of his other major achievement, go. And that has been at the core of his other major achievement, and his other major achievement, and that his other major achievement, and that is his other major achievement, and that is stable his other major achievement, and that is stable and his other major achievement, and that is stable and trusted that is stable and trusted Government. that is stable and trusted Government. The that is stable and trusted Government. The Opposition that is stable and trusted Government. The Opposition might Government. The Opposition might laugh Government. The Opposition might laugh at Government. The Opposition might laugh at that, Government. The Opposition might laugh at that, but Government. The Opposition might laugh at that, but in Government. The Opposition might laugh at that, but in the Government. The Opposition might laugh at that, but in the world Government. The Opposition might laugh at that, but in the world as laugh at that, but in the world as we laugh at that, but in the world as we know laugh at that, but in the world as we know it, laugh at that, but in the world as we know it, stable laugh at that, but in the world as we know it, stable and laugh at that, but in the world as we know it, stable and trusted we know it, stable and trusted government we know it, stable and trusted government is we know it, stable and trusted government is becoming we know it, stable and trusted government is becoming increasingly government is becoming increasingly rare. government is becoming increasingly rare. We're government is becoming increasingly rare. We're one government is becoming increasingly rare. We're one of government is becoming increasingly rare. We're one of the government is becoming increasingly rare. We're one of the few government is becoming increasingly rare. We're one of the few countries rare. We're one of the few countries where rare. We're one of the few countries where that rare. We're one of the few countries where that is rare. We're one of the few countries where that is now rare. We're one of the few countries where that is now the rare. We're one of the few countries where that is now the case. rare. We're one of the few countries where that is now the case. And rare. We're one of the few countries where that is now the case. And an where that is now the case. And an important where that is now the case. And an important part where that is now the case. And an important part of where that is now the case. And an important part of that where that is now the case. And an important part of that achievement important part of that achievement of important part of that achievement of stable important part of that achievement of stable and important part of that achievement of stable and trusted important part of that achievement of stable and trusted government important part of that achievement of stable and trusted government has of stable and trusted government has been of stable and trusted government has been the of stable and trusted government has been the integrity of stable and trusted government has been the integrity of of stable and trusted government has been the integrity of the of stable and trusted government has been the integrity of the PM of stable and trusted government has been the integrity of the PM and of stable and trusted government has been the integrity of the PM and his been the integrity of the PM and his ability been the integrity of the PM and his ability to been the integrity of the PM and his ability to ensure been the integrity of the PM and his ability to ensure that been the integrity of the PM and his ability to ensure that - been the integrity of the PM and his ability to ensure that - his been the integrity of the PM and his ability to ensure that - his ability ability to ensure that - his ability to ability to ensure that - his ability to ensure ability to ensure that - his ability to ensure that ability to ensure that - his ability to ensure that the ability to ensure that - his ability to ensure that the Government to ensure that the Government remained to ensure that the Government remained cohesive, to ensure that the Government remained cohesive, that to ensure that the Government remained cohesive, that the remained cohesive, that the relationships remained cohesive, that the relationships in remained cohesive, that the relationships in it remained cohesive, that the relationships in it were remained cohesive, that the relationships in it were positive relationships in it were positive and relationships in it were positive and that relationships in it were positive and that it relationships in it were positive and that it could relationships in it were positive and that it could continue relationships in it were positive and that it could continue to relationships in it were positive and that it could continue to make and that it could continue to make the and that it could continue to make the decisions and that it could continue to make the decisions that and that it could continue to make the decisions that are and that it could continue to make the decisions that are necessary and that it could continue to make the decisions that are necessary to the decisions that are necessary to take the decisions that are necessary to take the the decisions that are necessary to take the country the decisions that are necessary to take the country forward. take the country forward. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> So <INTERRUPTION> So the <INTERRUPTION> So the PM <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - the <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - the PM <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - the PM will <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - the PM will not, <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - the PM will not, in <INTERRUPTION> So the PM - the PM will not, in any So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, be So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, be belittled So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, be belittled by So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, be belittled by the So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, be belittled by the comments So the PM - the PM will not, in any way, be belittled by the comments of way, be belittled by the comments of the way, be belittled by the comments of the Opposition. way, be belittled by the comments of the Opposition. He way, be belittled by the comments of the Opposition. He never way, be belittled by the comments of the Opposition. He never let way, be belittled by the comments of the Opposition. He never let that the Opposition. He never let that bother the Opposition. He never let that bother him, the Opposition. He never let that bother him, and the Opposition. He never let that bother him, and actually the Opposition. He never let that bother him, and actually it the Opposition. He never let that bother him, and actually it doesn't bother him, and actually it doesn't matter bother him, and actually it doesn't matter what bother him, and actually it doesn't matter what Winston bother him, and actually it doesn't matter what Winston Peters bother him, and actually it doesn't matter what Winston Peters or bother him, and actually it doesn't matter what Winston Peters or Andrew matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little say matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little say today, matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little say today, it matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little say today, it will matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little say today, it will be matter what Winston Peters or Andrew Little say today, it will be as Little say today, it will be as irrelevant Little say today, it will be as irrelevant as Little say today, it will be as irrelevant as the Little say today, it will be as irrelevant as the things Little say today, it will be as irrelevant as the things they Little say today, it will be as irrelevant as the things they said irrelevant as the things they said for irrelevant as the things they said for the irrelevant as the things they said for the whole irrelevant as the things they said for the whole eight irrelevant as the things they said for the whole eight years irrelevant as the things they said for the whole eight years he irrelevant as the things they said for the whole eight years he was irrelevant as the things they said for the whole eight years he was PM. for the whole eight years he was PM. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> It <INTERRUPTION> It made <INTERRUPTION> It made no <INTERRUPTION> It made no difference, <INTERRUPTION> It made no difference, despite It made no difference, despite political It made no difference, despite political obsession It made no difference, despite political obsession with It made no difference, despite political obsession with John It made no difference, despite political obsession with John Key, political obsession with John Key, known political obsession with John Key, known as political obsession with John Key, known as 'Key political obsession with John Key, known as 'Key Derangement political obsession with John Key, known as 'Key Derangement Syndrome', known as 'Key Derangement Syndrome', these known as 'Key Derangement Syndrome', these political known as 'Key Derangement Syndrome', these political machines known as 'Key Derangement Syndrome', these political machines never known as 'Key Derangement Syndrome', these political machines never laid these political machines never laid a these political machines never laid a finger these political machines never laid a finger on these political machines never laid a finger on him, these political machines never laid a finger on him, never these political machines never laid a finger on him, never knocked these political machines never laid a finger on him, never knocked him a finger on him, never knocked him off a finger on him, never knocked him off track, a finger on him, never knocked him off track, never a finger on him, never knocked him off track, never brought a finger on him, never knocked him off track, never brought him a finger on him, never knocked him off track, never brought him down, off track, never brought him down, never off track, never brought him down, never distracted off track, never brought him down, never distracted him off track, never brought him down, never distracted him from off track, never brought him down, never distracted him from the off track, never brought him down, never distracted him from the task never distracted him from the task of never distracted him from the task of achieving never distracted him from the task of achieving what never distracted him from the task of achieving what was never distracted him from the task of achieving what was best never distracted him from the task of achieving what was best and never distracted him from the task of achieving what was best and right of achieving what was best and right for of achieving what was best and right for New of achieving what was best and right for New Zealanders. of achieving what was best and right for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And in for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And in that for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And in that context, for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And in that context, that for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And in that context, that is for New Zealanders. <INTERRUPTION> And in that context, that is the And in that context, that is the PM's And in that context, that is the PM's performance And in that context, that is the PM's performance in And in that context, that is the PM's performance in the And in that context, that is the PM's performance in the bear And in that context, that is the PM's performance in the bear pit And in that context, that is the PM's performance in the bear pit of PM's performance in the bear pit of politics PM's performance in the bear pit of politics - PM's performance in the bear pit of politics - he PM's performance in the bear pit of politics - he had PM's performance in the bear pit of politics - he had no PM's performance in the bear pit of politics - he had no equal. politics - he had no equal. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> No <INTERRUPTION> No - <INTERRUPTION> No - well, <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he had <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he had no <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he had no equal. <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he had no equal. I <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he had no equal. I know <INTERRUPTION> No - well, he had no equal. I know - No - well, he had no equal. I know - well, No - well, he had no equal. I know - well, OK, No - well, he had no equal. I know - well, OK, the No - well, he had no equal. I know - well, OK, the Labour No - well, he had no equal. I know - well, OK, the Labour Party No - well, he had no equal. I know - well, OK, the Labour Party talk well, OK, the Labour Party talk about well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan Clark well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan Clark - well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan Clark - John well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan Clark - John Key well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan Clark - John Key beat well, OK, the Labour Party talk about Alan Clark - John Key beat him about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a long about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a long way about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a long way in about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a long way in an about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a long way in an election about Alan Clark - John Key beat him by a long way in an election and by a long way in an election and actually by a long way in an election and actually the by a long way in an election and actually the Labour by a long way in an election and actually the Labour Party by a long way in an election and actually the Labour Party have by a long way in an election and actually the Labour Party have never actually the Labour Party have never recovered actually the Labour Party have never recovered from actually the Labour Party have never recovered from it. actually the Labour Party have never recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in the recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in the bear recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in the bear pit recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in the bear pit of recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in the bear pit of politics, recovered from it. <INTERRUPTION> So in the bear pit of politics, the So in the bear pit of politics, the PM So in the bear pit of politics, the PM showed So in the bear pit of politics, the PM showed that So in the bear pit of politics, the PM showed that he So in the bear pit of politics, the PM showed that he had So in the bear pit of politics, the PM showed that he had the So in the bear pit of politics, the PM showed that he had the strength PM showed that he had the strength and PM showed that he had the strength and the PM showed that he had the strength and the direction PM showed that he had the strength and the direction to PM showed that he had the strength and the direction to maintain PM showed that he had the strength and the direction to maintain the and the direction to maintain the position and the direction to maintain the position of and the direction to maintain the position of government, and the direction to maintain the position of government, maintain and the direction to maintain the position of government, maintain the position of government, maintain the trust position of government, maintain the trust of position of government, maintain the trust of the position of government, maintain the trust of the people position of government, maintain the trust of the people and position of government, maintain the trust of the people and ultimately trust of the people and ultimately to trust of the people and ultimately to leave trust of the people and ultimately to leave the trust of the people and ultimately to leave the country trust of the people and ultimately to leave the country in trust of the people and ultimately to leave the country in a trust of the people and ultimately to leave the country in a much, trust of the people and ultimately to leave the country in a much, much to leave the country in a much, much better to leave the country in a much, much better state to leave the country in a much, much better state than to leave the country in a much, much better state than he to leave the country in a much, much better state than he found to leave the country in a much, much better state than he found it, better state than he found it, despite better state than he found it, despite the better state than he found it, despite the challenges better state than he found it, despite the challenges that better state than he found it, despite the challenges that he better state than he found it, despite the challenges that he had despite the challenges that he had to despite the challenges that he had to deal despite the challenges that he had to deal with. despite the challenges that he had to deal with. <INTERRUPTION> to deal with. <INTERRUPTION> Finally to deal with. <INTERRUPTION> Finally - to deal with. <INTERRUPTION> Finally - finally... to deal with. <INTERRUPTION> Finally - finally... Order! to deal with. <INTERRUPTION> Finally - finally... Order! ..The Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of the Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of the PM Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of the PM and Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of the PM and his Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of the PM and his legacy Finally - finally... Order! ..The measure of the PM and his legacy is measure of the PM and his legacy is that measure of the PM and his legacy is that he measure of the PM and his legacy is that he has measure of the PM and his legacy is that he has left measure of the PM and his legacy is that he has left a measure of the PM and his legacy is that he has left a team measure of the PM and his legacy is that he has left a team in measure of the PM and his legacy is that he has left a team in great that he has left a team in great shape. that he has left a team in great shape. <INTERRUPTION> shape. <INTERRUPTION> We've shape. <INTERRUPTION> We've seen shape. <INTERRUPTION> We've seen what's shape. <INTERRUPTION> We've seen what's happened shape. <INTERRUPTION> We've seen what's happened to We've seen what's happened to political We've seen what's happened to political parties We've seen what's happened to political parties when We've seen what's happened to political parties when leaders We've seen what's happened to political parties when leaders say political parties when leaders say too political parties when leaders say too long. political parties when leaders say too long. The political parties when leaders say too long. The PM political parties when leaders say too long. The PM has political parties when leaders say too long. The PM has left political parties when leaders say too long. The PM has left this too long. The PM has left this talented, too long. The PM has left this talented, energised too long. The PM has left this talented, energised team too long. The PM has left this talented, energised team with too long. The PM has left this talented, energised team with a talented, energised team with a clear talented, energised team with a clear sense talented, energised team with a clear sense of talented, energised team with a clear sense of direction talented, energised team with a clear sense of direction and talented, energised team with a clear sense of direction and the clear sense of direction and the best clear sense of direction and the best way clear sense of direction and the best way to clear sense of direction and the best way to fulfil clear sense of direction and the best way to fulfil his clear sense of direction and the best way to fulfil his legacy clear sense of direction and the best way to fulfil his legacy is clear sense of direction and the best way to fulfil his legacy is to best way to fulfil his legacy is to build best way to fulfil his legacy is to build on best way to fulfil his legacy is to build on those best way to fulfil his legacy is to build on those achievements. build on those achievements. <BELL build on those achievements. <BELL RUNG> <BELL RUNG> <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Thank <INTERRUPTION> Thank you, <INTERRUPTION> Thank you, Mr <INTERRUPTION> Thank you, Mr Speaker. <INTERRUPTION> Thank you, Mr Speaker. I <INTERRUPTION> Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree <INTERRUPTION> Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy PM Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy PM and Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy PM and the Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy PM and the PM Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy PM and the PM with Thank you, Mr Speaker. I agree with the Deputy PM and the PM with one the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at least the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at least and the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at least and that the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at least and that is the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at least and that is on the Deputy PM and the PM with one thing at least and that is on the thing at least and that is on the occasion thing at least and that is on the occasion of thing at least and that is on the occasion of the thing at least and that is on the occasion of the resignation thing at least and that is on the occasion of the resignation of thing at least and that is on the occasion of the resignation of the occasion of the resignation of the PM, occasion of the resignation of the PM, it occasion of the resignation of the PM, it is occasion of the resignation of the PM, it is appropriate occasion of the resignation of the PM, it is appropriate to occasion of the resignation of the PM, it is appropriate to be occasion of the resignation of the PM, it is appropriate to be generous PM, it is appropriate to be generous in PM, it is appropriate to be generous in one's PM, it is appropriate to be generous in one's offerings PM, it is appropriate to be generous in one's offerings about PM, it is appropriate to be generous in one's offerings about not PM, it is appropriate to be generous in one's offerings about not only in one's offerings about not only the in one's offerings about not only the departing in one's offerings about not only the departing PM in one's offerings about not only the departing PM but in one's offerings about not only the departing PM but one's the departing PM but one's colleagues the departing PM but one's colleagues in the departing PM but one's colleagues in PM. the departing PM but one's colleagues in PM. But the departing PM but one's colleagues in PM. But the the departing PM but one's colleagues in PM. But the aspiring colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM couldn't colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM couldn't even colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM couldn't even do colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM couldn't even do that. colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM couldn't even do that. It colleagues in PM. But the aspiring PM couldn't even do that. It didn't PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take long PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take long for PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take long for Mr PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take long for Mr English PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take long for Mr English to PM couldn't even do that. It didn't take long for Mr English to descend take long for Mr English to descend into take long for Mr English to descend into the take long for Mr English to descend into the usual take long for Mr English to descend into the usual bitter, take long for Mr English to descend into the usual bitter, angry, take long for Mr English to descend into the usual bitter, angry, nasty into the usual bitter, angry, nasty tirade into the usual bitter, angry, nasty tirade that into the usual bitter, angry, nasty tirade that he into the usual bitter, angry, nasty tirade that he is into the usual bitter, angry, nasty tirade that he is reputed into the usual bitter, angry, nasty tirade that he is reputed for. tirade that he is reputed for. Harold tirade that he is reputed for. Harold McMilan tirade that he is reputed for. Harold McMilan said, tirade that he is reputed for. Harold McMilan said, in tirade that he is reputed for. Harold McMilan said, in answer tirade that he is reputed for. Harold McMilan said, in answer to Harold McMilan said, in answer to the Harold McMilan said, in answer to the question, Harold McMilan said, in answer to the question, "What Harold McMilan said, in answer to the question, "What do Harold McMilan said, in answer to the question, "What do governments the question, "What do governments most the question, "What do governments most fear", the question, "What do governments most fear", he the question, "What do governments most fear", he said, the question, "What do governments most fear", he said, "Events, the question, "What do governments most fear", he said, "Events, dear most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, events" most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, events" and most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, events" and yesterday most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, events" and yesterday we most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, events" and yesterday we had most fear", he said, "Events, dear boy, events" and yesterday we had an boy, events" and yesterday we had an event boy, events" and yesterday we had an event and boy, events" and yesterday we had an event and today boy, events" and yesterday we had an event and today we boy, events" and yesterday we had an event and today we have boy, events" and yesterday we had an event and today we have seen boy, events" and yesterday we had an event and today we have seen the event and today we have seen the faces event and today we have seen the faces of event and today we have seen the faces of the event and today we have seen the faces of the Government event and today we have seen the faces of the Government and event and today we have seen the faces of the Government and they event and today we have seen the faces of the Government and they are faces of the Government and they are in faces of the Government and they are in fear faces of the Government and they are in fear - faces of the Government and they are in fear - they faces of the Government and they are in fear - they are faces of the Government and they are in fear - they are in faces of the Government and they are in fear - they are in fear. faces of the Government and they are in fear - they are in fear. They in fear - they are in fear. They don't in fear - they are in fear. They don't know in fear - they are in fear. They don't know what's in fear - they are in fear. They don't know what's going in fear - they are in fear. They don't know what's going to in fear - they are in fear. They don't know what's going to happen. don't know what's going to happen. They don't know what's going to happen. They don't don't know what's going to happen. They don't know don't know what's going to happen. They don't know who's don't know what's going to happen. They don't know who's going don't know what's going to happen. They don't know who's going to don't know what's going to happen. They don't know who's going to win They don't know who's going to win and They don't know who's going to win and they They don't know who's going to win and they don't They don't know who's going to win and they don't know They don't know who's going to win and they don't know what They don't know who's going to win and they don't know what the and they don't know what the outcome's and they don't know what the outcome's going and they don't know what the outcome's going to and they don't know what the outcome's going to be. and they don't know what the outcome's going to be. So, and they don't know what the outcome's going to be. So, on and they don't know what the outcome's going to be. So, on the outcome's going to be. So, on the occasion outcome's going to be. So, on the occasion of outcome's going to be. So, on the occasion of the outcome's going to be. So, on the occasion of the resignation outcome's going to be. So, on the occasion of the resignation of outcome's going to be. So, on the occasion of the resignation of the occasion of the resignation of the PM, occasion of the resignation of the PM, who occasion of the resignation of the PM, who has occasion of the resignation of the PM, who has served occasion of the resignation of the PM, who has served for occasion of the resignation of the PM, who has served for eight occasion of the resignation of the PM, who has served for eight years, PM, who has served for eight years, let PM, who has served for eight years, let us PM, who has served for eight years, let us acknowledge PM, who has served for eight years, let us acknowledge that PM, who has served for eight years, let us acknowledge that that PM, who has served for eight years, let us acknowledge that that is PM, who has served for eight years, let us acknowledge that that is a let us acknowledge that that is a significant let us acknowledge that that is a significant event let us acknowledge that that is a significant event constitutionally, significant event constitutionally, politically, significant event constitutionally, politically, and significant event constitutionally, politically, and in significant event constitutionally, politically, and in a significant event constitutionally, politically, and in a variety significant event constitutionally, politically, and in a variety of politically, and in a variety of other politically, and in a variety of other ways. politically, and in a variety of other ways. Let's politically, and in a variety of other ways. Let's accept politically, and in a variety of other ways. Let's accept that other ways. Let's accept that serving other ways. Let's accept that serving in other ways. Let's accept that serving in a other ways. Let's accept that serving in a high other ways. Let's accept that serving in a high public other ways. Let's accept that serving in a high public office other ways. Let's accept that serving in a high public office is serving in a high public office is tough. serving in a high public office is tough. Let's serving in a high public office is tough. Let's also serving in a high public office is tough. Let's also recall serving in a high public office is tough. Let's also recall that serving in a high public office is tough. Let's also recall that having tough. Let's also recall that having tough. Let's also recall that having tough. Let's also recall that having checks and tough. Let's also recall that having checks and balances tough. Let's also recall that having checks and balances in tough. Let's also recall that having checks and balances in our checks and balances in our constitutional checks and balances in our constitutional system checks and balances in our constitutional system is checks and balances in our constitutional system is meant checks and balances in our constitutional system is meant to constitutional system is meant to constrain, constitutional system is meant to constrain, and constitutional system is meant to constrain, and being constitutional system is meant to constrain, and being under constitutional system is meant to constrain, and being under daily constitutional system is meant to constrain, and being under daily, constitutional system is meant to constrain, and being under daily, if constrain, and being under daily, if not constrain, and being under daily, if not hourly, constrain, and being under daily, if not hourly, scrutiny constrain, and being under daily, if not hourly, scrutiny is constrain, and being under daily, if not hourly, scrutiny is meant constrain, and being under daily, if not hourly, scrutiny is meant to not hourly, scrutiny is meant to enlighten not hourly, scrutiny is meant to enlighten and not hourly, scrutiny is meant to enlighten and call not hourly, scrutiny is meant to enlighten and call to not hourly, scrutiny is meant to enlighten and call to account. not hourly, scrutiny is meant to enlighten and call to account. And enlighten and call to account. And that enlighten and call to account. And that is enlighten and call to account. And that is our enlighten and call to account. And that is our system. enlighten and call to account. And that is our system. That's enlighten and call to account. And that is our system. That's what that is our system. That's what makes that is our system. That's what makes it that is our system. That's what makes it tough, that is our system. That's what makes it tough, but that is our system. That's what makes it tough, but it that is our system. That's what makes it tough, but it is that is our system. That's what makes it tough, but it is tough. that is our system. That's what makes it tough, but it is tough. It makes it tough, but it is tough. It is makes it tough, but it is tough. It is right makes it tough, but it is tough. It is right sometimes makes it tough, but it is tough. It is right sometimes to makes it tough, but it is tough. It is right sometimes to put makes it tough, but it is tough. It is right sometimes to put political is right sometimes to put political differences is right sometimes to put political differences aside is right sometimes to put political differences aside and is right sometimes to put political differences aside and say is right sometimes to put political differences aside and say to is right sometimes to put political differences aside and say to a differences aside and say to a political differences aside and say to a political opponent, differences aside and say to a political opponent, "Thank differences aside and say to a political opponent, "Thank you differences aside and say to a political opponent, "Thank you for political opponent, "Thank you for the political opponent, "Thank you for the service political opponent, "Thank you for the service that political opponent, "Thank you for the service that you political opponent, "Thank you for the service that you have political opponent, "Thank you for the service that you have given political opponent, "Thank you for the service that you have given to the service that you have given to our the service that you have given to our country". the service that you have given to our country". It's the service that you have given to our country". It's not the service that you have given to our country". It's not for the service that you have given to our country". It's not for me the service that you have given to our country". It's not for me to our country". It's not for me to conduct our country". It's not for me to conduct some our country". It's not for me to conduct some sort our country". It's not for me to conduct some sort of our country". It's not for me to conduct some sort of panagaric, our country". It's not for me to conduct some sort of panagaric, that conduct some sort of panagaric, that is conduct some sort of panagaric, that is for conduct some sort of panagaric, that is for the conduct some sort of panagaric, that is for the historians, conduct some sort of panagaric, that is for the historians, the conduct some sort of panagaric, that is for the historians, the real is for the historians, the real historians is for the historians, the real historians who is for the historians, the real historians who will is for the historians, the real historians who will have is for the historians, the real historians who will have the is for the historians, the real historians who will have the benefit historians who will have the benefit of historians who will have the benefit of the historians who will have the benefit of the distance historians who will have the benefit of the distance of historians who will have the benefit of the distance of time historians who will have the benefit of the distance of time at historians who will have the benefit of the distance of time at some of the distance of time at some point of the distance of time at some point in of the distance of time at some point in the of the distance of time at some point in the future of the distance of time at some point in the future to of the distance of time at some point in the future to decide of the distance of time at some point in the future to decide what point in the future to decide what John point in the future to decide what John Key's point in the future to decide what John Key's legacy point in the future to decide what John Key's legacy is point in the future to decide what John Key's legacy is and point in the future to decide what John Key's legacy is and how point in the future to decide what John Key's legacy is and how it point in the future to decide what John Key's legacy is and how it has John Key's legacy is and how it has served John Key's legacy is and how it has served New John Key's legacy is and how it has served New Zealand. John Key's legacy is and how it has served New Zealand. But John Key's legacy is and how it has served New Zealand. But I John Key's legacy is and how it has served New Zealand. But I just John Key's legacy is and how it has served New Zealand. But I just say served New Zealand. But I just say it's served New Zealand. But I just say it's right served New Zealand. But I just say it's right for served New Zealand. But I just say it's right for the served New Zealand. But I just say it's right for the House served New Zealand. But I just say it's right for the House to it's right for the House to acknowledge it's right for the House to acknowledge the it's right for the House to acknowledge the leadership it's right for the House to acknowledge the leadership that it's right for the House to acknowledge the leadership that John acknowledge the leadership that John Key acknowledge the leadership that John Key has acknowledge the leadership that John Key has given acknowledge the leadership that John Key has given over acknowledge the leadership that John Key has given over the acknowledge the leadership that John Key has given over the last acknowledge the leadership that John Key has given over the last eight Key has given over the last eight years. Key has given over the last eight years. But Key has given over the last eight years. But right Key has given over the last eight years. But right now, Key has given over the last eight years. But right now, in Key has given over the last eight years. But right now, in present years. But right now, in present circumstances, years. But right now, in present circumstances, who years. But right now, in present circumstances, who replaces years. But right now, in present circumstances, who replaces John years. But right now, in present circumstances, who replaces John Key circumstances, who replaces John Key is circumstances, who replaces John Key is a circumstances, who replaces John Key is a question circumstances, who replaces John Key is a question only circumstances, who replaces John Key is a question only for circumstances, who replaces John Key is a question only for the circumstances, who replaces John Key is a question only for the National is a question only for the National Party. is a question only for the National Party. They is a question only for the National Party. They sit is a question only for the National Party. They sit over is a question only for the National Party. They sit over there is a question only for the National Party. They sit over there - is a question only for the National Party. They sit over there - it's Party. They sit over there - it's chair Party. They sit over there - it's chair choice. Party. They sit over there - it's chair choice. It's Party. They sit over there - it's chair choice. It's not Party. They sit over there - it's chair choice. It's not necessarily chair choice. It's not necessarily what chair choice. It's not necessarily what New chair choice. It's not necessarily what New Zealanders chair choice. It's not necessarily what New Zealanders expected chair choice. It's not necessarily what New Zealanders expected - chair choice. It's not necessarily what New Zealanders expected - they what New Zealanders expected - they expected, what New Zealanders expected - they expected, having what New Zealanders expected - they expected, having elected what New Zealanders expected - they expected, having elected someone, what New Zealanders expected - they expected, having elected someone, or expected, having elected someone, or a expected, having elected someone, or a party expected, having elected someone, or a party to expected, having elected someone, or a party to government expected, having elected someone, or a party to government with expected, having elected someone, or a party to government with a expected, having elected someone, or a party to government with a PM, a party to government with a PM, they a party to government with a PM, they would a party to government with a PM, they would serve a party to government with a PM, they would serve out a party to government with a PM, they would serve out the a party to government with a PM, they would serve out the full a party to government with a PM, they would serve out the full term, they would serve out the full term, but they would serve out the full term, but now they would serve out the full term, but now that they would serve out the full term, but now that is they would serve out the full term, but now that is a they would serve out the full term, but now that is a matter they would serve out the full term, but now that is a matter entirely they would serve out the full term, but now that is a matter entirely in but now that is a matter entirely in the but now that is a matter entirely in the hands but now that is a matter entirely in the hands of but now that is a matter entirely in the hands of the but now that is a matter entirely in the hands of the National but now that is a matter entirely in the hands of the National caucus. the hands of the National caucus. One the hands of the National caucus. One thing the hands of the National caucus. One thing remains the hands of the National caucus. One thing remains unchanged One thing remains unchanged throughout One thing remains unchanged throughout all One thing remains unchanged throughout all of One thing remains unchanged throughout all of this One thing remains unchanged throughout all of this - One thing remains unchanged throughout all of this - and One thing remains unchanged throughout all of this - and that One thing remains unchanged throughout all of this - and that is throughout all of this - and that is that throughout all of this - and that is that too throughout all of this - and that is that too many throughout all of this - and that is that too many New throughout all of this - and that is that too many New Zealanders throughout all of this - and that is that too many New Zealanders are that too many New Zealanders are still that too many New Zealanders are still missing that too many New Zealanders are still missing out. that too many New Zealanders are still missing out. John that too many New Zealanders are still missing out. John Key, that too many New Zealanders are still missing out. John Key, who that too many New Zealanders are still missing out. John Key, who was still missing out. John Key, who was quoted still missing out. John Key, who was quoted in still missing out. John Key, who was quoted in a still missing out. John Key, who was quoted in a Listener still missing out. John Key, who was quoted in a Listener article still missing out. John Key, who was quoted in a Listener article in still missing out. John Key, who was quoted in a Listener article in June quoted in a Listener article in June this quoted in a Listener article in June this year quoted in a Listener article in June this year and quoted in a Listener article in June this year and he quoted in a Listener article in June this year and he said quoted in a Listener article in June this year and he said this, quoted in a Listener article in June this year and he said this, "Voters this year and he said this, "Voters only this year and he said this, "Voters only really this year and he said this, "Voters only really care this year and he said this, "Voters only really care about this year and he said this, "Voters only really care about four this year and he said this, "Voters only really care about four things this year and he said this, "Voters only really care about four things - only really care about four things - health, only really care about four things - health, education, only really care about four things - health, education, law only really care about four things - health, education, law and only really care about four things - health, education, law and order only really care about four things - health, education, law and order and health, education, law and order and the health, education, law and order and the economy". health, education, law and order and the economy". So health, education, law and order and the economy". So let's health, education, law and order and the economy". So let's have health, education, law and order and the economy". So let's have a health, education, law and order and the economy". So let's have a look the economy". So let's have a look at the economy". So let's have a look at health, the economy". So let's have a look at health, education, the economy". So let's have a look at health, education, law the economy". So let's have a look at health, education, law and the economy". So let's have a look at health, education, law and order at health, education, law and order and at health, education, law and order and the at health, education, law and order and the economy. at health, education, law and order and the economy. Because at health, education, law and order and the economy. Because the at health, education, law and order and the economy. Because the track and the economy. Because the track record and the economy. Because the track record ain't and the economy. Because the track record ain't that and the economy. Because the track record ain't that flattering. and the economy. Because the track record ain't that flattering. So record ain't that flattering. So when record ain't that flattering. So when we record ain't that flattering. So when we have record ain't that flattering. So when we have a record ain't that flattering. So when we have a look record ain't that flattering. So when we have a look at record ain't that flattering. So when we have a look at health, record ain't that flattering. So when we have a look at health, $1.7 when we have a look at health, $1.7 billion when we have a look at health, $1.7 billion cut when we have a look at health, $1.7 billion cut effectively when we have a look at health, $1.7 billion cut effectively from when we have a look at health, $1.7 billion cut effectively from the billion cut effectively from the health billion cut effectively from the health budget billion cut effectively from the health budget - billion cut effectively from the health budget - the billion cut effectively from the health budget - the health billion cut effectively from the health budget - the health budget health budget - the health budget that health budget - the health budget that has health budget - the health budget that has failed health budget - the health budget that has failed to health budget - the health budget that has failed to keep health budget - the health budget that has failed to keep up health budget - the health budget that has failed to keep up with that has failed to keep up with population that has failed to keep up with population growth that has failed to keep up with population growth and that has failed to keep up with population growth and a that has failed to keep up with population growth and a change that has failed to keep up with population growth and a change in population growth and a change in population population growth and a change in population profile. population growth and a change in population profile. 45,000 population growth and a change in population profile. 45,000 New population profile. 45,000 New Zealanders, population profile. 45,000 New Zealanders, mainly population profile. 45,000 New Zealanders, mainly elderly population profile. 45,000 New Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, last Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, last year Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, last year alone Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, last year alone who Zealanders, mainly elderly New Zealanders, last year alone who were Zealanders, last year alone who were told Zealanders, last year alone who were told by Zealanders, last year alone who were told by their Zealanders, last year alone who were told by their GPs, Zealanders, last year alone who were told by their GPs, "You Zealanders, last year alone who were told by their GPs, "You need told by their GPs, "You need hospital told by their GPs, "You need hospital treatment, told by their GPs, "You need hospital treatment, ske told by their GPs, "You need hospital treatment, ske dadle told by their GPs, "You need hospital treatment, ske dadle up hospital treatment, ske dadle up there hospital treatment, ske dadle up there quickly, hospital treatment, ske dadle up there quickly, get hospital treatment, ske dadle up there quickly, get up hospital treatment, ske dadle up there quickly, get up to hospital treatment, ske dadle up there quickly, get up to your there quickly, get up to your hospital, there quickly, get up to your hospital, get there quickly, get up to your hospital, get your there quickly, get up to your hospital, get your treatment there quickly, get up to your hospital, get your treatment done" hospital, get your treatment done" and hospital, get your treatment done" and they hospital, get your treatment done" and they turned hospital, get your treatment done" and they turned up hospital, get your treatment done" and they turned up to hospital, get your treatment done" and they turned up to the hospital, get your treatment done" and they turned up to the hospital and they turned up to the hospital and and they turned up to the hospital and the and they turned up to the hospital and the hospital and they turned up to the hospital and the hospital said, and they turned up to the hospital and the hospital said, "We and they turned up to the hospital and the hospital said, "We can't and the hospital said, "We can't afford and the hospital said, "We can't afford to and the hospital said, "We can't afford to treat and the hospital said, "We can't afford to treat you". and the hospital said, "We can't afford to treat you". That's and the hospital said, "We can't afford to treat you". That's what afford to treat you". That's what they afford to treat you". That's what they were afford to treat you". That's what they were told afford to treat you". That's what they were told - afford to treat you". That's what they were told - 45,000 afford to treat you". That's what they were told - 45,000 NZ afford to treat you". That's what they were told - 45,000 NZ inners they were told - 45,000 NZ inners who they were told - 45,000 NZ inners who needed they were told - 45,000 NZ inners who needed hips they were told - 45,000 NZ inners who needed hips replaced they were told - 45,000 NZ inners who needed hips replaced -- they were told - 45,000 NZ inners who needed hips replaced -- New who needed hips replaced -- New Zealanders who needed hips replaced -- New Zealanders who who needed hips replaced -- New Zealanders who needed who needed hips replaced -- New Zealanders who needed hips who needed hips replaced -- New Zealanders who needed hips replaced, Zealanders who needed hips replaced, knees Zealanders who needed hips replaced, knees done, Zealanders who needed hips replaced, knees done, other Zealanders who needed hips replaced, knees done, other minor Zealanders who needed hips replaced, knees done, other minor surgeries. knees done, other minor surgeries. We knees done, other minor surgeries. We have knees done, other minor surgeries. We have a knees done, other minor surgeries. We have a health knees done, other minor surgeries. We have a health system knees done, other minor surgeries. We have a health system that knees done, other minor surgeries. We have a health system that can knees done, other minor surgeries. We have a health system that can no We have a health system that can no longer We have a health system that can no longer afford We have a health system that can no longer afford to We have a health system that can no longer afford to treat We have a health system that can no longer afford to treat NZ We have a health system that can no longer afford to treat NZ nszers longer afford to treat NZ nszers when longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they need longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they need it. longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they need it. We longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they need it. We have longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they need it. We have -- longer afford to treat NZ nszers when they need it. We have -- New when they need it. We have -- New Zealanders when they need it. We have -- New Zealanders when when they need it. We have -- New Zealanders when they when they need it. We have -- New Zealanders when they need when they need it. We have -- New Zealanders when they need it. when they need it. We have -- New Zealanders when they need it. We Zealanders when they need it. We have Zealanders when they need it. We have surgeons Zealanders when they need it. We have surgeons being Zealanders when they need it. We have surgeons being told Zealanders when they need it. We have surgeons being told don't Zealanders when they need it. We have surgeons being told don't do have surgeons being told don't do follow-up have surgeons being told don't do follow-up appointments. have surgeons being told don't do follow-up appointments. What's have surgeons being told don't do follow-up appointments. What's that follow-up appointments. What's that about? follow-up appointments. What's that about? How follow-up appointments. What's that about? How can follow-up appointments. What's that about? How can you follow-up appointments. What's that about? How can you have follow-up appointments. What's that about? How can you have surgery follow-up appointments. What's that about? How can you have surgery and about? How can you have surgery and not about? How can you have surgery and not have about? How can you have surgery and not have a about? How can you have surgery and not have a follow-up about? How can you have surgery and not have a follow-up appointment about? How can you have surgery and not have a follow-up appointment to not have a follow-up appointment to see not have a follow-up appointment to see how not have a follow-up appointment to see how it's not have a follow-up appointment to see how it's going, not have a follow-up appointment to see how it's going, to not have a follow-up appointment to see how it's going, to see not have a follow-up appointment to see how it's going, to see if not have a follow-up appointment to see how it's going, to see if there see how it's going, to see if there is see how it's going, to see if there is an see how it's going, to see if there is an infection, see how it's going, to see if there is an infection, to see how it's going, to see if there is an infection, to see see how it's going, to see if there is an infection, to see if see how it's going, to see if there is an infection, to see if you see how it's going, to see if there is an infection, to see if you need is an infection, to see if you need other is an infection, to see if you need other treatment? is an infection, to see if you need other treatment? That's is an infection, to see if you need other treatment? That's the is an infection, to see if you need other treatment? That's the state is an infection, to see if you need other treatment? That's the state of other treatment? That's the state of health other treatment? That's the state of health in other treatment? That's the state of health in New other treatment? That's the state of health in New Zealand other treatment? That's the state of health in New Zealand today, other treatment? That's the state of health in New Zealand today, and other treatment? That's the state of health in New Zealand today, and it health in New Zealand today, and it ain't health in New Zealand today, and it ain't good health in New Zealand today, and it ain't good enough. health in New Zealand today, and it ain't good enough. That health in New Zealand today, and it ain't good enough. That was health in New Zealand today, and it ain't good enough. That was health. ain't good enough. That was health. What ain't good enough. That was health. What about ain't good enough. That was health. What about education? ain't good enough. That was health. What about education? Well, ain't good enough. That was health. What about education? Well, what What about education? Well, what we've What about education? Well, what we've seen What about education? Well, what we've seen now What about education? Well, what we've seen now is What about education? Well, what we've seen now is a What about education? Well, what we've seen now is a freeze What about education? Well, what we've seen now is a freeze of What about education? Well, what we've seen now is a freeze of -- What about education? Well, what we've seen now is a freeze of -- on we've seen now is a freeze of -- on education we've seen now is a freeze of -- on education funding. we've seen now is a freeze of -- on education funding. Schools education funding. Schools struggling education funding. Schools struggling to education funding. Schools struggling to do education funding. Schools struggling to do the education funding. Schools struggling to do the job education funding. Schools struggling to do the job we education funding. Schools struggling to do the job we expect struggling to do the job we expect of struggling to do the job we expect of them. struggling to do the job we expect of them. Struggling struggling to do the job we expect of them. Struggling to struggling to do the job we expect of them. Struggling to give struggling to do the job we expect of them. Struggling to give our struggling to do the job we expect of them. Struggling to give our kids of them. Struggling to give our kids the of them. Struggling to give our kids the chance of them. Struggling to give our kids the chance to of them. Struggling to give our kids the chance to succeed of them. Struggling to give our kids the chance to succeed in of them. Struggling to give our kids the chance to succeed in a of them. Struggling to give our kids the chance to succeed in a rapidly the chance to succeed in a rapidly changing the chance to succeed in a rapidly changing world. the chance to succeed in a rapidly changing world. And the chance to succeed in a rapidly changing world. And we the chance to succeed in a rapidly changing world. And we saw the chance to succeed in a rapidly changing world. And we saw the changing world. And we saw the report changing world. And we saw the report last changing world. And we saw the report last week changing world. And we saw the report last week that changing world. And we saw the report last week that sees changing world. And we saw the report last week that sees New report last week that sees New Zealand report last week that sees New Zealand going report last week that sees New Zealand going backwards, report last week that sees New Zealand going backwards, larger Zealand going backwards, larger class Zealand going backwards, larger class sizes, Zealand going backwards, larger class sizes, more Zealand going backwards, larger class sizes, more pressure Zealand going backwards, larger class sizes, more pressure on class sizes, more pressure on teachers class sizes, more pressure on teachers and, class sizes, more pressure on teachers and, would class sizes, more pressure on teachers and, would you class sizes, more pressure on teachers and, would you believe, class sizes, more pressure on teachers and, would you believe, a teachers and, would you believe, a freeze teachers and, would you believe, a freeze in teachers and, would you believe, a freeze in funding? teachers and, would you believe, a freeze in funding? How teachers and, would you believe, a freeze in funding? How does teachers and, would you believe, a freeze in funding? How does that freeze in funding? How does that happen freeze in funding? How does that happen with freeze in funding? How does that happen with a freeze in funding? How does that happen with a Government freeze in funding? How does that happen with a Government who freeze in funding? How does that happen with a Government who says freeze in funding? How does that happen with a Government who says to happen with a Government who says to New happen with a Government who says to New Zealanders happen with a Government who says to New Zealanders it happen with a Government who says to New Zealanders it is happen with a Government who says to New Zealanders it is committed happen with a Government who says to New Zealanders it is committed to happen with a Government who says to New Zealanders it is committed to a New Zealanders it is committed to a brave New Zealanders it is committed to a brave new New Zealanders it is committed to a brave new world New Zealanders it is committed to a brave new world of New Zealanders it is committed to a brave new world of the New Zealanders it is committed to a brave new world of the future, New Zealanders it is committed to a brave new world of the future, but brave new world of the future, but won't brave new world of the future, but won't give brave new world of the future, but won't give a brave new world of the future, but won't give a chance, brave new world of the future, but won't give a chance, won't brave new world of the future, but won't give a chance, won't give won't give a chance, won't give opportunity won't give a chance, won't give opportunity to won't give a chance, won't give opportunity to New won't give a chance, won't give opportunity to New Zealanders, won't give a chance, won't give opportunity to New Zealanders, young opportunity to New Zealanders, young New opportunity to New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, opportunity to New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, when opportunity to New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, when they opportunity to New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, when they need opportunity to New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, when they need it. New Zealanders, when they need it. So New Zealanders, when they need it. So what New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about law New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about law and New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about law and order? New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about law and order? So New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about law and order? So at New Zealanders, when they need it. So what about law and order? So at a So what about law and order? So at a time So what about law and order? So at a time of So what about law and order? So at a time of the So what about law and order? So at a time of the most So what about law and order? So at a time of the most rapidly So what about law and order? So at a time of the most rapidly growing time of the most rapidly growing population time of the most rapidly growing population in time of the most rapidly growing population in New time of the most rapidly growing population in New Zealand, time of the most rapidly growing population in New Zealand, and time of the most rapidly growing population in New Zealand, and at time of the most rapidly growing population in New Zealand, and at a population in New Zealand, and at a time population in New Zealand, and at a time when population in New Zealand, and at a time when crime population in New Zealand, and at a time when crime is population in New Zealand, and at a time when crime is rising population in New Zealand, and at a time when crime is rising - population in New Zealand, and at a time when crime is rising - now, population in New Zealand, and at a time when crime is rising - now, two time when crime is rising - now, two years time when crime is rising - now, two years in time when crime is rising - now, two years in a time when crime is rising - now, two years in a row time when crime is rising - now, two years in a row burglaries, time when crime is rising - now, two years in a row burglaries, assaults, years in a row burglaries, assaults, robberies, years in a row burglaries, assaults, robberies, serious years in a row burglaries, assaults, robberies, serious crime, years in a row burglaries, assaults, robberies, serious crime, we years in a row burglaries, assaults, robberies, serious crime, we have years in a row burglaries, assaults, robberies, serious crime, we have a robberies, serious crime, we have a freeze robberies, serious crime, we have a freeze on robberies, serious crime, we have a freeze on police robberies, serious crime, we have a freeze on police numbers. robberies, serious crime, we have a freeze on police numbers. We robberies, serious crime, we have a freeze on police numbers. We have freeze on police numbers. We have declining freeze on police numbers. We have declining police freeze on police numbers. We have declining police morale. freeze on police numbers. We have declining police morale. How freeze on police numbers. We have declining police morale. How does declining police morale. How does that declining police morale. How does that work declining police morale. How does that work in declining police morale. How does that work in a declining police morale. How does that work in a country declining police morale. How does that work in a country on declining police morale. How does that work in a country on the declining police morale. How does that work in a country on the cusp that work in a country on the cusp of that work in a country on the cusp of something that work in a country on the cusp of something special? that work in a country on the cusp of something special? And that work in a country on the cusp of something special? And there that work in a country on the cusp of something special? And there is of something special? And there is the of something special? And there is the economy of something special? And there is the economy - of something special? And there is the economy - there of something special? And there is the economy - there is of something special? And there is the economy - there is the of something special? And there is the economy - there is the economy. the economy - there is the economy. How the economy - there is the economy. How is the economy - there is the economy. How is it the economy - there is the economy. How is it that the economy - there is the economy. How is it that in the economy - there is the economy. How is it that in this the economy - there is the economy. How is it that in this great the economy - there is the economy. How is it that in this great economy How is it that in this great economy of How is it that in this great economy of ours How is it that in this great economy of ours that How is it that in this great economy of ours that the How is it that in this great economy of ours that the Minister How is it that in this great economy of ours that the Minister of How is it that in this great economy of ours that the Minister of Finance of ours that the Minister of Finance and of ours that the Minister of Finance and Deputy of ours that the Minister of Finance and Deputy PM of ours that the Minister of Finance and Deputy PM says, of ours that the Minister of Finance and Deputy PM says, there's of ours that the Minister of Finance and Deputy PM says, there's now of ours that the Minister of Finance and Deputy PM says, there's now - and Deputy PM says, there's now - you and Deputy PM says, there's now - you know, and Deputy PM says, there's now - you know, burgeoning, and Deputy PM says, there's now - you know, burgeoning, doing and Deputy PM says, there's now - you know, burgeoning, doing well and Deputy PM says, there's now - you know, burgeoning, doing well - you know, burgeoning, doing well - one you know, burgeoning, doing well - one out you know, burgeoning, doing well - one out of you know, burgeoning, doing well - one out of every you know, burgeoning, doing well - one out of every five you know, burgeoning, doing well - one out of every five wage you know, burgeoning, doing well - one out of every five wage earners one out of every five wage earners do one out of every five wage earners do not one out of every five wage earners do not earn one out of every five wage earners do not earn enough one out of every five wage earners do not earn enough - one out of every five wage earners do not earn enough - or one out of every five wage earners do not earn enough - or at one out of every five wage earners do not earn enough - or at least do not earn enough - or at least only do not earn enough - or at least only earn do not earn enough - or at least only earn enough do not earn enough - or at least only earn enough that do not earn enough - or at least only earn enough that means do not earn enough - or at least only earn enough that means that only earn enough that means that more only earn enough that means that more than only earn enough that means that more than 50% only earn enough that means that more than 50% of only earn enough that means that more than 50% of their only earn enough that means that more than 50% of their income only earn enough that means that more than 50% of their income goes more than 50% of their income goes on more than 50% of their income goes on paying more than 50% of their income goes on paying either more than 50% of their income goes on paying either the more than 50% of their income goes on paying either the rent more than 50% of their income goes on paying either the rent or more than 50% of their income goes on paying either the rent or the on paying either the rent or the mortgage. on paying either the rent or the mortgage. That's on paying either the rent or the mortgage. That's how on paying either the rent or the mortgage. That's how expensive on paying either the rent or the mortgage. That's how expensive the mortgage. That's how expensive the cost mortgage. That's how expensive the cost of mortgage. That's how expensive the cost of living mortgage. That's how expensive the cost of living has mortgage. That's how expensive the cost of living has become. mortgage. That's how expensive the cost of living has become. That's cost of living has become. That's why cost of living has become. That's why so cost of living has become. That's why so many cost of living has become. That's why so many families cost of living has become. That's why so many families are cost of living has become. That's why so many families are struggling. why so many families are struggling. Working why so many families are struggling. Working families why so many families are struggling. Working families - why so many families are struggling. Working families - people why so many families are struggling. Working families - people out why so many families are struggling. Working families - people out there Working families - people out there toiling Working families - people out there toiling away, Working families - people out there toiling away, trying Working families - people out there toiling away, trying to Working families - people out there toiling away, trying to get Working families - people out there toiling away, trying to get every toiling away, trying to get every hour toiling away, trying to get every hour of toiling away, trying to get every hour of work toiling away, trying to get every hour of work they toiling away, trying to get every hour of work they can, toiling away, trying to get every hour of work they can, terrified hour of work they can, terrified when hour of work they can, terrified when they hour of work they can, terrified when they have hour of work they can, terrified when they have to hour of work they can, terrified when they have to renew hour of work they can, terrified when they have to renew the hour of work they can, terrified when they have to renew the warrant when they have to renew the warrant of when they have to renew the warrant of fitness when they have to renew the warrant of fitness because when they have to renew the warrant of fitness because they're when they have to renew the warrant of fitness because they're terrified of fitness because they're terrified they of fitness because they're terrified they might of fitness because they're terrified they might have of fitness because they're terrified they might have to of fitness because they're terrified they might have to replace of fitness because they're terrified they might have to replace the of fitness because they're terrified they might have to replace the tyres they might have to replace the tyres or they might have to replace the tyres or the they might have to replace the tyres or the brake they might have to replace the tyres or the brake lines. they might have to replace the tyres or the brake lines. Terrified they might have to replace the tyres or the brake lines. Terrified when or the brake lines. Terrified when the or the brake lines. Terrified when the next or the brake lines. Terrified when the next winter or the brake lines. Terrified when the next winter power or the brake lines. Terrified when the next winter power bill or the brake lines. Terrified when the next winter power bill comes the next winter power bill comes because the next winter power bill comes because they the next winter power bill comes because they don't the next winter power bill comes because they don't know the next winter power bill comes because they don't know how the next winter power bill comes because they don't know how many because they don't know how many hundreds because they don't know how many hundreds of because they don't know how many hundreds of dollars because they don't know how many hundreds of dollars bigger because they don't know how many hundreds of dollars bigger than because they don't know how many hundreds of dollars bigger than than hundreds of dollars bigger than than the hundreds of dollars bigger than than the summer hundreds of dollars bigger than than the summer ones. hundreds of dollars bigger than than the summer ones. That's hundreds of dollars bigger than than the summer ones. That's the hundreds of dollars bigger than than the summer ones. That's the lived the summer ones. That's the lived existence the summer ones. That's the lived existence of the summer ones. That's the lived existence of families the summer ones. That's the lived existence of families these the summer ones. That's the lived existence of families these days. existence of families these days. That's existence of families these days. That's not existence of families these days. That's not a existence of families these days. That's not a successful existence of families these days. That's not a successful economy, That's not a successful economy, that's That's not a successful economy, that's not That's not a successful economy, that's not a That's not a successful economy, that's not a success for that's not a success for New that's not a success for that's not a success for New Zealand. Labour that's not a success for New Zealand. Labour has that's not a success for New Zealand. Labour has a that's not a success for New Zealand. Labour has a plan that's not a success for New Zealand. Labour has a plan and Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour is Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour is ready. Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour is ready. Labour Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour is ready. Labour has Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour is ready. Labour has a Zealand. Labour has a plan and Labour is ready. Labour has a plan Labour is ready. Labour has a plan for Labour is ready. Labour has a plan for New Labour is ready. Labour has a plan for New Zealand. Labour is ready. Labour has a plan for New Zealand. We're Labour is ready. Labour has a plan for New Zealand. We're gonna Labour is ready. Labour has a plan for New Zealand. We're gonna build for New Zealand. We're gonna build houses for New Zealand. We're gonna build houses - for New Zealand. We're gonna build houses - for for New Zealand. We're gonna build houses - for all for New Zealand. We're gonna build houses - for all those for New Zealand. We're gonna build houses - for all those New houses - for all those New Zealanders houses - for all those New Zealanders who houses - for all those New Zealanders who don't houses - for all those New Zealanders who don't have houses - for all those New Zealanders who don't have their houses - for all those New Zealanders who don't have their own Zealanders who don't have their own roof Zealanders who don't have their own roof over Zealanders who don't have their own roof over their Zealanders who don't have their own roof over their heads, Zealanders who don't have their own roof over their heads, the Zealanders who don't have their own roof over their heads, the 41,000 roof over their heads, the 41,000 homeless, roof over their heads, the 41,000 homeless, Labour roof over their heads, the 41,000 homeless, Labour has roof over their heads, the 41,000 homeless, Labour has a roof over their heads, the 41,000 homeless, Labour has a plan. For For the For the thousands For the thousands of For the thousands of young For the thousands of young couples For the thousands of young couples who For the thousands of young couples who can't For the thousands of young couples who can't afford For the thousands of young couples who can't afford to For the thousands of young couples who can't afford to buy For the thousands of young couples who can't afford to buy their For the thousands of young couples who can't afford to buy their own who can't afford to buy their own home, who can't afford to buy their own home, Labour who can't afford to buy their own home, Labour has who can't afford to buy their own home, Labour has a who can't afford to buy their own home, Labour has a plan. who can't afford to buy their own home, Labour has a plan. We're who can't afford to buy their own home, Labour has a plan. We're going home, Labour has a plan. We're going to home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put you home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put you in home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put you in a home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put you in a home. home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put you in a home. You're home, Labour has a plan. We're going to put you in a home. You're going to put you in a home. You're going to to put you in a home. You're going to be to put you in a home. You're going to be able to put you in a home. You're going to be able to to put you in a home. You're going to be able to afford to put you in a home. You're going to be able to afford your to put you in a home. You're going to be able to afford your own to put you in a home. You're going to be able to afford your own home. to be able to afford your own home. For to be able to afford your own home. For the to be able to afford your own home. For the parents to be able to afford your own home. For the parents wondering to be able to afford your own home. For the parents wondering how to be able to afford your own home. For the parents wondering how much For the parents wondering how much more For the parents wondering how much more they're For the parents wondering how much more they're going For the parents wondering how much more they're going to For the parents wondering how much more they're going to have For the parents wondering how much more they're going to have to For the parents wondering how much more they're going to have to work more they're going to have to work out more they're going to have to work out for more they're going to have to work out for their more they're going to have to work out for their kids more they're going to have to work out for their kids at more they're going to have to work out for their kids at school, more they're going to have to work out for their kids at school, we out for their kids at school, we have out for their kids at school, we have a out for their kids at school, we have a plan. out for their kids at school, we have a plan. We're out for their kids at school, we have a plan. We're going out for their kids at school, we have a plan. We're going to out for their kids at school, we have a plan. We're going to restore have a plan. We're going to restore that have a plan. We're going to restore that funding have a plan. We're going to restore that funding for have a plan. We're going to restore that funding for education have a plan. We're going to restore that funding for education and have a plan. We're going to restore that funding for education and we're that funding for education and we're going that funding for education and we're going to that funding for education and we're going to have that funding for education and we're going to have an that funding for education and we're going to have an education that funding for education and we're going to have an education system going to have an education system which going to have an education system which is going to have an education system which is modern going to have an education system which is modern and going to have an education system which is modern and fit going to have an education system which is modern and fit and going to have an education system which is modern and fit and equipped which is modern and fit and equipped for which is modern and fit and equipped for the which is modern and fit and equipped for the modern which is modern and fit and equipped for the modern world. which is modern and fit and equipped for the modern world. Labour which is modern and fit and equipped for the modern world. Labour has which is modern and fit and equipped for the modern world. Labour has a for the modern world. Labour has a plan for the modern world. Labour has a plan for for the modern world. Labour has a plan for health for the modern world. Labour has a plan for health and for the modern world. Labour has a plan for health and it for the modern world. Labour has a plan for health and it is for the modern world. Labour has a plan for health and it is about plan for health and it is about restoring plan for health and it is about restoring that plan for health and it is about restoring that funding. plan for health and it is about restoring that funding. We plan for health and it is about restoring that funding. We won't plan for health and it is about restoring that funding. We won't be restoring that funding. We won't be able restoring that funding. We won't be able to restoring that funding. We won't be able to do restoring that funding. We won't be able to do it restoring that funding. We won't be able to do it straight restoring that funding. We won't be able to do it straight away restoring that funding. We won't be able to do it straight away but restoring that funding. We won't be able to do it straight away but we able to do it straight away but we will, able to do it straight away but we will, over able to do it straight away but we will, over time, able to do it straight away but we will, over time, put able to do it straight away but we will, over time, put back able to do it straight away but we will, over time, put back the will, over time, put back the funding will, over time, put back the funding so will, over time, put back the funding so if will, over time, put back the funding so if you're will, over time, put back the funding so if you're elderly will, over time, put back the funding so if you're elderly and funding so if you're elderly and your funding so if you're elderly and your hints funding so if you're elderly and your hints are funding so if you're elderly and your hints are giving funding so if you're elderly and your hints are giving out funding so if you're elderly and your hints are giving out and funding so if you're elderly and your hints are giving out and you your hints are giving out and you can't your hints are giving out and you can't walk your hints are giving out and you can't walk and your hints are giving out and you can't walk and you your hints are giving out and you can't walk and you can't your hints are giving out and you can't walk and you can't do your hints are giving out and you can't walk and you can't do the can't walk and you can't do the shopping, can't walk and you can't do the shopping, we'll can't walk and you can't do the shopping, we'll give can't walk and you can't do the shopping, we'll give you can't walk and you can't do the shopping, we'll give you a can't walk and you can't do the shopping, we'll give you a chance. shopping, we'll give you a chance. You'll shopping, we'll give you a chance. You'll get shopping, we'll give you a chance. You'll get the shopping, we'll give you a chance. You'll get the hip shopping, we'll give you a chance. You'll get the hip operation. shopping, we'll give you a chance. You'll get the hip operation. You You'll get the hip operation. You will You'll get the hip operation. You will live You'll get the hip operation. You will live a You'll get the hip operation. You will live a decent You'll get the hip operation. You will live a decent life. You'll get the hip operation. You will live a decent life. A You'll get the hip operation. You will live a decent life. A dignified will live a decent life. A dignified life, will live a decent life. A dignified life, because will live a decent life. A dignified life, because that's will live a decent life. A dignified life, because that's what will live a decent life. A dignified life, because that's what New life, because that's what New Zealand life, because that's what New Zealand stands life, because that's what New Zealand stands for. life, because that's what New Zealand stands for. Mr life, because that's what New Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has a Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has a plan. Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has a plan. We Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has a plan. We have Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has a plan. We have a Zealand stands for. Mr Speaker, Labour has a plan. We have a plan Labour has a plan. We have a plan for Labour has a plan. We have a plan for law Labour has a plan. We have a plan for law and Labour has a plan. We have a plan for law and order. Labour has a plan. We have a plan for law and order. We'll Labour has a plan. We have a plan for law and order. We'll put Labour has a plan. We have a plan for law and order. We'll put more for law and order. We'll put more police for law and order. We'll put more police on for law and order. We'll put more police on the for law and order. We'll put more police on the beat. for law and order. We'll put more police on the beat. We're for law and order. We'll put more police on the beat. We're going for law and order. We'll put more police on the beat. We're going to police on the beat. We're going to put police on the beat. We're going to put an police on the beat. We're going to put an extra police on the beat. We're going to put an extra 1,000 police on the beat. We're going to put an extra 1,000 cops police on the beat. We're going to put an extra 1,000 cops over police on the beat. We're going to put an extra 1,000 cops over three put an extra 1,000 cops over three years put an extra 1,000 cops over three years and put an extra 1,000 cops over three years and New put an extra 1,000 cops over three years and New Zealanders put an extra 1,000 cops over three years and New Zealanders will put an extra 1,000 cops over three years and New Zealanders will feel years and New Zealanders will feel safe years and New Zealanders will feel safe in years and New Zealanders will feel safe in their years and New Zealanders will feel safe in their communities years and New Zealanders will feel safe in their communities again. safe in their communities again. That's safe in their communities again. That's our safe in their communities again. That's our pledge. safe in their communities again. That's our pledge. We've safe in their communities again. That's our pledge. We've costed safe in their communities again. That's our pledge. We've costed it That's our pledge. We've costed it out. That's our pledge. We've costed it out. We That's our pledge. We've costed it out. We can That's our pledge. We've costed it out. We can do That's our pledge. We've costed it out. We can do it. That's our pledge. We've costed it out. We can do it. The That's our pledge. We've costed it out. We can do it. The Government out. We can do it. The Government could out. We can do it. The Government could do out. We can do it. The Government could do it out. We can do it. The Government could do it now. out. We can do it. The Government could do it now. I'm out. We can do it. The Government could do it now. I'm prepared out. We can do it. The Government could do it now. I'm prepared to out. We can do it. The Government could do it now. I'm prepared to put could do it now. I'm prepared to put money could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on it could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on it that could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on it that between could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on it that between now could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on it that between now and could do it now. I'm prepared to put money on it that between now and the money on it that between now and the next money on it that between now and the next election, money on it that between now and the next election, the money on it that between now and the next election, the next money on it that between now and the next election, the next PM, money on it that between now and the next election, the next PM, whoever next election, the next PM, whoever that next election, the next PM, whoever that may next election, the next PM, whoever that may be, next election, the next PM, whoever that may be, will next election, the next PM, whoever that may be, will announce next election, the next PM, whoever that may be, will announce they'll that may be, will announce they'll put that may be, will announce they'll put more that may be, will announce they'll put more cops that may be, will announce they'll put more cops on that may be, will announce they'll put more cops on the that may be, will announce they'll put more cops on the beat that may be, will announce they'll put more cops on the beat because put more cops on the beat because they put more cops on the beat because they know put more cops on the beat because they know they've put more cops on the beat because they know they've got put more cops on the beat because they know they've got it put more cops on the beat because they know they've got it wrong, they know they've got it wrong, because they know they've got it wrong, because the they know they've got it wrong, because the truth they know they've got it wrong, because the truth is they know they've got it wrong, because the truth is this they know they've got it wrong, because the truth is this is they know they've got it wrong, because the truth is this is a because the truth is this is a Government because the truth is this is a Government that because the truth is this is a Government that is because the truth is this is a Government that is out because the truth is this is a Government that is out of because the truth is this is a Government that is out of touch, Government that is out of touch, arrogant, Government that is out of touch, arrogant, tired, Government that is out of touch, arrogant, tired, they've Government that is out of touch, arrogant, tired, they've lost Government that is out of touch, arrogant, tired, they've lost touch arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they don't arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they don't know arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they don't know what arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they don't know what to arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they don't know what to do arrogant, tired, they've lost touch and they don't know what to do any and they don't know what to do any more: more: Mr more: Mr Speaker, more: Mr Speaker, here's more: Mr Speaker, here's the more: Mr Speaker, here's the thing. more: Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We more: Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are a Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are a country Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are a country that Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are a country that has Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are a country that has always Mr Speaker, here's the thing. We are a country that has always celebrated a country that has always celebrated the a country that has always celebrated the chance a country that has always celebrated the chance for a country that has always celebrated the chance for its a country that has always celebrated the chance for its people a country that has always celebrated the chance for its people to a country that has always celebrated the chance for its people to get the chance for its people to get ahead. the chance for its people to get ahead. When the chance for its people to get ahead. When you the chance for its people to get ahead. When you do the chance for its people to get ahead. When you do the the chance for its people to get ahead. When you do the right the chance for its people to get ahead. When you do the right thing, ahead. When you do the right thing, when ahead. When you do the right thing, when you ahead. When you do the right thing, when you work ahead. When you do the right thing, when you work hard ahead. When you do the right thing, when you work hard and ahead. When you do the right thing, when you work hard and you ahead. When you do the right thing, when you work hard and you pay ahead. When you do the right thing, when you work hard and you pay your when you work hard and you pay your taxes, when you work hard and you pay your taxes, the when you work hard and you pay your taxes, the least when you work hard and you pay your taxes, the least you when you work hard and you pay your taxes, the least you expect when you work hard and you pay your taxes, the least you expect is when you work hard and you pay your taxes, the least you expect is the taxes, the least you expect is the Government taxes, the least you expect is the Government to taxes, the least you expect is the Government to be taxes, the least you expect is the Government to be there taxes, the least you expect is the Government to be there to taxes, the least you expect is the Government to be there to back taxes, the least you expect is the Government to be there to back you, Government to be there to back you, to Government to be there to back you, to make Government to be there to back you, to make sure Government to be there to back you, to make sure that Government to be there to back you, to make sure that you Government to be there to back you, to make sure that you can Government to be there to back you, to make sure that you can have Government to be there to back you, to make sure that you can have a to make sure that you can have a roof to make sure that you can have a roof over to make sure that you can have a roof over your to make sure that you can have a roof over your head, to make sure that you can have a roof over your head, that to make sure that you can have a roof over your head, that if to make sure that you can have a roof over your head, that if you roof over your head, that if you can't roof over your head, that if you can't afford roof over your head, that if you can't afford to roof over your head, that if you can't afford to buy roof over your head, that if you can't afford to buy one, roof over your head, that if you can't afford to buy one, that roof over your head, that if you can't afford to buy one, that if roof over your head, that if you can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford to buy one, that if you can't can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford to can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford to rent can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford to rent one, can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford to rent one, there's can't afford to buy one, that if you can't afford to rent one, there's a can't afford to rent one, there's a housing can't afford to rent one, there's a housing New can't afford to rent one, there's a housing New Zealand can't afford to rent one, there's a housing New Zealand house can't afford to rent one, there's a housing New Zealand house there can't afford to rent one, there's a housing New Zealand house there for housing New Zealand house there for you, housing New Zealand house there for you, not housing New Zealand house there for you, not being housing New Zealand house there for you, not being sold housing New Zealand house there for you, not being sold down housing New Zealand house there for you, not being sold down the housing New Zealand house there for you, not being sold down the river you, not being sold down the river by you, not being sold down the river by the you, not being sold down the river by the current you, not being sold down the river by the current Minister you, not being sold down the river by the current Minister in you, not being sold down the river by the current Minister in charge you, not being sold down the river by the current Minister in charge of by the current Minister in charge of housing by the current Minister in charge of housing New by the current Minister in charge of housing New Zealand. by the current Minister in charge of housing New Zealand. We're by the current Minister in charge of housing New Zealand. We're a by the current Minister in charge of housing New Zealand. We're a country housing New Zealand. We're a country that housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes that housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes that if housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes that if you housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes that if you do housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes that if you do all housing New Zealand. We're a country that believes that if you do all the that believes that if you do all the right that believes that if you do all the right things, that believes that if you do all the right things, we that believes that if you do all the right things, we have that believes that if you do all the right things, we have an that believes that if you do all the right things, we have an education right things, we have an education system right things, we have an education system there right things, we have an education system there that right things, we have an education system there that will right things, we have an education system there that will make right things, we have an education system there that will make sure system there that will make sure that system there that will make sure that your system there that will make sure that your kids system there that will make sure that your kids are system there that will make sure that your kids are prepared system there that will make sure that your kids are prepared for that your kids are prepared for success. that your kids are prepared for success. We're that your kids are prepared for success. We're a that your kids are prepared for success. We're a country that your kids are prepared for success. We're a country that success. We're a country that believes success. We're a country that believes if success. We're a country that believes if you success. We're a country that believes if you want success. We're a country that believes if you want a success. We're a country that believes if you want a chance success. We're a country that believes if you want a chance to success. We're a country that believes if you want a chance to get believes if you want a chance to get ahead, believes if you want a chance to get ahead, to believes if you want a chance to get ahead, to do believes if you want a chance to get ahead, to do well, believes if you want a chance to get ahead, to do well, to believes if you want a chance to get ahead, to do well, to work believes if you want a chance to get ahead, to do well, to work well, ahead, to do well, to work well, we'll ahead, to do well, to work well, we'll have ahead, to do well, to work well, we'll have a ahead, to do well, to work well, we'll have a health ahead, to do well, to work well, we'll have a health system ahead, to do well, to work well, we'll have a health system there we'll have a health system there that's we'll have a health system there that's there we'll have a health system there that's there to we'll have a health system there that's there to make we'll have a health system there that's there to make you we'll have a health system there that's there to make you get we'll have a health system there that's there to make you get better that's there to make you get better when that's there to make you get better when you that's there to make you get better when you fall that's there to make you get better when you fall sick that's there to make you get better when you fall sick that. that's there to make you get better when you fall sick that. 'S that's there to make you get better when you fall sick that. 'S what that's there to make you get better when you fall sick that. 'S what we when you fall sick that. 'S what we stand when you fall sick that. 'S what we stand for. when you fall sick that. 'S what we stand for. That's when you fall sick that. 'S what we stand for. That's what when you fall sick that. 'S what we stand for. That's what New when you fall sick that. 'S what we stand for. That's what New Zealand stand for. That's what New Zealand is stand for. That's what New Zealand is about. stand for. That's what New Zealand is about. We stand for. That's what New Zealand is about. We are stand for. That's what New Zealand is about. We are a stand for. That's what New Zealand is about. We are a land stand for. That's what New Zealand is about. We are a land of is about. We are a land of opportunity. is about. We are a land of opportunity. We've is about. We are a land of opportunity. We've always is about. We are a land of opportunity. We've always celebrated opportunity. We've always celebrated that. opportunity. We've always celebrated that. But opportunity. We've always celebrated that. But for opportunity. We've always celebrated that. But for fa opportunity. We've always celebrated that. But for fa too opportunity. We've always celebrated that. But for fa too many opportunity. We've always celebrated that. But for fa too many New that. But for fa too many New Zealanders, that. But for fa too many New Zealanders, that that. But for fa too many New Zealanders, that opportunity that. But for fa too many New Zealanders, that opportunity is Zealanders, that opportunity is going Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- but Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- but for Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- but for far Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- but for far too Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- but for far too many Zealanders, that opportunity is going -- but for far too many New going -- but for far too many New Zealanders, going -- but for far too many New Zealanders, that going -- but for far too many New Zealanders, that opportunity going -- but for far too many New Zealanders, that opportunity is Zealanders, that opportunity is going. Zealanders, that opportunity is going. And Zealanders, that opportunity is going. And Labour Zealanders, that opportunity is going. And Labour is Zealanders, that opportunity is going. And Labour is about Zealanders, that opportunity is going. And Labour is about a Zealanders, that opportunity is going. And Labour is about a better going. And Labour is about a better New going. And Labour is about a better New Zealand. going. And Labour is about a better New Zealand. It going. And Labour is about a better New Zealand. It is going. And Labour is about a better New Zealand. It is about going. And Labour is about a better New Zealand. It is about harnessing New Zealand. It is about harnessing the New Zealand. It is about harnessing the resources New Zealand. It is about harnessing the resources of New Zealand. It is about harnessing the resources of Government, New Zealand. It is about harnessing the resources of Government, of the resources of Government, of backing the resources of Government, of backing our the resources of Government, of backing our people the resources of Government, of backing our people of the resources of Government, of backing our people of backing the resources of Government, of backing our people of backing them backing our people of backing them in backing our people of backing them in their backing our people of backing them in their dreams backing our people of backing them in their dreams and backing our people of backing them in their dreams and their backing our people of backing them in their dreams and their ambitions in their dreams and their ambitions for in their dreams and their ambitions for themselves, in their dreams and their ambitions for themselves, their in their dreams and their ambitions for themselves, their children, for themselves, their children, their for themselves, their children, their families for themselves, their children, their families and for themselves, their children, their families and for for themselves, their children, their families and for their their families and for their communities. their families and for their communities. Labour their families and for their communities. Labour is their families and for their communities. Labour is about communities. Labour is about stronger communities. Labour is about stronger families communities. Labour is about stronger families and communities. Labour is about stronger families and better stronger families and better communities. stronger families and better communities. That's stronger families and better communities. That's what stronger families and better communities. That's what we're stronger families and better communities. That's what we're going communities. That's what we're going to communities. That's what we're going to go communities. That's what we're going to go to communities. That's what we're going to go to the communities. That's what we're going to go to the country communities. That's what we're going to go to the country on communities. That's what we're going to go to the country on next communities. That's what we're going to go to the country on next year. to go to the country on next year. Labour to go to the country on next year. Labour has to go to the country on next year. Labour has plan to go to the country on next year. Labour has plan and to go to the country on next year. Labour has plan and Labour to go to the country on next year. Labour has plan and Labour is to go to the country on next year. Labour has plan and Labour is ready. Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've known Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've known this Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've known this was Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've known this was going Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've known this was going to Labour has plan and Labour is ready. We've known this was going to come. We've known this was going to come. We've We've known this was going to come. We've been We've known this was going to come. We've been prepared We've known this was going to come. We've been prepared for We've known this was going to come. We've been prepared for this. We've been prepared for this. Doesn't We've been prepared for this. Doesn't matter We've been prepared for this. Doesn't matter when We've been prepared for this. Doesn't matter when the We've been prepared for this. Doesn't matter when the election We've been prepared for this. Doesn't matter when the election is. Doesn't matter when the election is. We Doesn't matter when the election is. We have Doesn't matter when the election is. We have a Doesn't matter when the election is. We have a plan Doesn't matter when the election is. We have a plan for Doesn't matter when the election is. We have a plan for New Doesn't matter when the election is. We have a plan for New Zealand. Doesn't matter when the election is. We have a plan for New Zealand. New We have a plan for New Zealand. New Zealand We have a plan for New Zealand. New Zealand deserves We have a plan for New Zealand. New Zealand deserves better. We have a plan for New Zealand. New Zealand deserves better. They're Zealand deserves better. They're going Zealand deserves better. They're going to Zealand deserves better. They're going to get Zealand deserves better. They're going to get better Zealand deserves better. They're going to get better and Zealand deserves better. They're going to get better and New Zealand deserves better. They're going to get better and New Zealand going to get better and New Zealand is going to get better and New Zealand is going going to get better and New Zealand is going to going to get better and New Zealand is going to be going to get better and New Zealand is going to be a going to get better and New Zealand is going to be a great going to get better and New Zealand is going to be a great country going to get better and New Zealand is going to be a great country with is going to be a great country with Labour is going to be a great country with Labour backing is going to be a great country with Labour backing hardworking is going to be a great country with Labour backing hardworking Kiwis Labour backing hardworking Kiwis every Labour backing hardworking Kiwis every step Labour backing hardworking Kiwis every step of Labour backing hardworking Kiwis every step of the Labour backing hardworking Kiwis every step of the way. every step of the way. <APPLAUSE> Thank Thank you. Thank you. John Thank you. John Key, Thank you. John Key, retiring Thank you. John Key, retiring PM, Thank you. John Key, retiring PM, never Thank you. John Key, retiring PM, never put Thank you. John Key, retiring PM, never put children Thank you. John Key, retiring PM, never put children and Thank you. John Key, retiring PM, never put children and families never put children and families first. never put children and families first. At never put children and families first. At every never put children and families first. At every opportunity, never put children and families first. At every opportunity, John first. At every opportunity, John Key first. At every opportunity, John Key refused first. At every opportunity, John Key refused to first. At every opportunity, John Key refused to put first. At every opportunity, John Key refused to put the first. At every opportunity, John Key refused to put the needs first. At every opportunity, John Key refused to put the needs of Key refused to put the needs of families Key refused to put the needs of families and Key refused to put the needs of families and children Key refused to put the needs of families and children ahead Key refused to put the needs of families and children ahead of Key refused to put the needs of families and children ahead of the families and children ahead of the interests families and children ahead of the interests of families and children ahead of the interests of the families and children ahead of the interests of the wealthy families and children ahead of the interests of the wealthy few. families and children ahead of the interests of the wealthy few. And interests of the wealthy few. And so, interests of the wealthy few. And so, this interests of the wealthy few. And so, this has interests of the wealthy few. And so, this has been, interests of the wealthy few. And so, this has been, this interests of the wealthy few. And so, this has been, this is interests of the wealthy few. And so, this has been, this is actually so, this has been, this is actually the so, this has been, this is actually the legacy so, this has been, this is actually the legacy of so, this has been, this is actually the legacy of John so, this has been, this is actually the legacy of John key. so, this has been, this is actually the legacy of John key. I'm the legacy of John key. I'm surprised the legacy of John key. I'm surprised by the legacy of John key. I'm surprised by Bill the legacy of John key. I'm surprised by Bill English's the legacy of John key. I'm surprised by Bill English's response surprised by Bill English's response tonight surprised by Bill English's response tonight on surprised by Bill English's response tonight on this surprised by Bill English's response tonight on this debate. surprised by Bill English's response tonight on this debate. Because tonight on this debate. Because there tonight on this debate. Because there are tonight on this debate. Because there are thousands tonight on this debate. Because there are thousands and tonight on this debate. Because there are thousands and thousands tonight on this debate. Because there are thousands and thousands of there are thousands and thousands of New there are thousands and thousands of New Zealand there are thousands and thousands of New Zealand families there are thousands and thousands of New Zealand families who there are thousands and thousands of New Zealand families who know there are thousands and thousands of New Zealand families who know that New Zealand families who know that they New Zealand families who know that they are New Zealand families who know that they are now New Zealand families who know that they are now doing New Zealand families who know that they are now doing worse New Zealand families who know that they are now doing worse than New Zealand families who know that they are now doing worse than ever they are now doing worse than ever under they are now doing worse than ever under the they are now doing worse than ever under the leadership they are now doing worse than ever under the leadership of they are now doing worse than ever under the leadership of John they are now doing worse than ever under the leadership of John key they are now doing worse than ever under the leadership of John key and under the leadership of John key and the under the leadership of John key and the National under the leadership of John key and the National Party. under the leadership of John key and the National Party. Eight under the leadership of John key and the National Party. Eight years under the leadership of John key and the National Party. Eight years John the National Party. Eight years John key the National Party. Eight years John key has the National Party. Eight years John key has had the National Party. Eight years John key has had an the National Party. Eight years John key has had an opportunity the National Party. Eight years John key has had an opportunity to the National Party. Eight years John key has had an opportunity to turn key has had an opportunity to turn life key has had an opportunity to turn life around key has had an opportunity to turn life around for key has had an opportunity to turn life around for the key has had an opportunity to turn life around for the familiaries key has had an opportunity to turn life around for the familiaries who life around for the familiaries who need life around for the familiaries who need him life around for the familiaries who need him the life around for the familiaries who need him the most, life around for the familiaries who need him the most, and life around for the familiaries who need him the most, and at life around for the familiaries who need him the most, and at every need him the most, and at every point, need him the most, and at every point, he need him the most, and at every point, he has need him the most, and at every point, he has refused need him the most, and at every point, he has refused to need him the most, and at every point, he has refused to help need him the most, and at every point, he has refused to help them. point, he has refused to help them. Let's point, he has refused to help them. Let's not point, he has refused to help them. Let's not forget point, he has refused to help them. Let's not forget - point, he has refused to help them. Let's not forget - the point, he has refused to help them. Let's not forget - the first point, he has refused to help them. Let's not forget - the first thing Let's not forget - the first thing he Let's not forget - the first thing he did Let's not forget - the first thing he did when Let's not forget - the first thing he did when he Let's not forget - the first thing he did when he became Let's not forget - the first thing he did when he became PM Let's not forget - the first thing he did when he became PM was Let's not forget - the first thing he did when he became PM was to Let's not forget - the first thing he did when he became PM was to give he did when he became PM was to give tax he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts to he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts to the he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts to the rich. he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts to the rich. That he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts to the rich. That was he did when he became PM was to give tax cuts to the rich. That was his tax cuts to the rich. That was his first tax cuts to the rich. That was his first decision tax cuts to the rich. That was his first decision was tax cuts to the rich. That was his first decision was to tax cuts to the rich. That was his first decision was to give tax cuts to the rich. That was his first decision was to give tax tax cuts to the rich. That was his first decision was to give tax cuts first decision was to give tax cuts to first decision was to give tax cuts to the first decision was to give tax cuts to the very first decision was to give tax cuts to the very richest first decision was to give tax cuts to the very richest families first decision was to give tax cuts to the very richest families in first decision was to give tax cuts to the very richest families in this to the very richest families in this country to the very richest families in this country leaving to the very richest families in this country leaving working to the very richest families in this country leaving working families to the very richest families in this country leaving working families who country leaving working families who were country leaving working families who were subject country leaving working families who were subject to country leaving working families who were subject to the country leaving working families who were subject to the harms country leaving working families who were subject to the harms caused country leaving working families who were subject to the harms caused by were subject to the harms caused by the were subject to the harms caused by the global were subject to the harms caused by the global financial were subject to the harms caused by the global financial crisis, were subject to the harms caused by the global financial crisis, just the global financial crisis, just left the global financial crisis, just left him the global financial crisis, just left him right the global financial crisis, just left him right out the global financial crisis, just left him right out of the global financial crisis, just left him right out of the the global financial crisis, just left him right out of the picture. left him right out of the picture. It left him right out of the picture. It was left him right out of the picture. It was the left him right out of the picture. It was the rich left him right out of the picture. It was the rich who left him right out of the picture. It was the rich who did left him right out of the picture. It was the rich who did the left him right out of the picture. It was the rich who did the best left him right out of the picture. It was the rich who did the best out It was the rich who did the best out of It was the rich who did the best out of John It was the rich who did the best out of John key It was the rich who did the best out of John key when It was the rich who did the best out of John key when he It was the rich who did the best out of John key when he first It was the rich who did the best out of John key when he first took It was the rich who did the best out of John key when he first took the of John key when he first took the prime of John key when he first took the prime Ministership of John key when he first took the prime Ministership and of John key when he first took the prime Ministership and it of John key when he first took the prime Ministership and it is of John key when he first took the prime Ministership and it is still prime Ministership and it is still the prime Ministership and it is still the rich prime Ministership and it is still the rich who prime Ministership and it is still the rich who are prime Ministership and it is still the rich who are doing prime Ministership and it is still the rich who are doing the prime Ministership and it is still the rich who are doing the best prime Ministership and it is still the rich who are doing the best from the rich who are doing the best from John the rich who are doing the best from John Key the rich who are doing the best from John Key eight the rich who are doing the best from John Key eight years the rich who are doing the best from John Key eight years later. the rich who are doing the best from John Key eight years later. The John Key eight years later. The families John Key eight years later. The families and John Key eight years later. The families and children John Key eight years later. The families and children of John Key eight years later. The families and children of hardworking families and children of hardworking New families and children of hardworking New Zealanders families and children of hardworking New Zealanders were families and children of hardworking New Zealanders were left families and children of hardworking New Zealanders were left out families and children of hardworking New Zealanders were left out by families and children of hardworking New Zealanders were left out by John New Zealanders were left out by John Key New Zealanders were left out by John Key and New Zealanders were left out by John Key and left New Zealanders were left out by John Key and left out New Zealanders were left out by John Key and left out by New Zealanders were left out by John Key and left out by the New Zealanders were left out by John Key and left out by the National Key and left out by the National Government. Key and left out by the National Government. The Key and left out by the National Government. The only Key and left out by the National Government. The only way Key and left out by the National Government. The only way to Key and left out by the National Government. The only way to put Government. The only way to put families Government. The only way to put families and Government. The only way to put families and Government Government. The only way to put families and Government at Government. The only way to put families and Government at the Government. The only way to put families and Government at the heart families and Government at the heart of families and Government at the heart of Government families and Government at the heart of Government changes families and Government at the heart of Government changes is families and Government at the heart of Government changes is to families and Government at the heart of Government changes is to change of Government changes is to change the of Government changes is to change the Government of Government changes is to change the Government in of Government changes is to change the Government in 2017. of Government changes is to change the Government in 2017. Because of Government changes is to change the Government in 2017. Because even the Government in 2017. Because even though the Government in 2017. Because even though John the Government in 2017. Because even though John Key the Government in 2017. Because even though John Key is the Government in 2017. Because even though John Key is gone the Government in 2017. Because even though John Key is gone and the Government in 2017. Because even though John Key is gone and his though John Key is gone and his leadership though John Key is gone and his leadership is though John Key is gone and his leadership is now though John Key is gone and his leadership is now over, though John Key is gone and his leadership is now over, the though John Key is gone and his leadership is now over, the National leadership is now over, the National Government, leadership is now over, the National Government, the leadership is now over, the National Government, the National leadership is now over, the National Government, the National Party, Government, the National Party, continues Government, the National Party, continues with Government, the National Party, continues with that Government, the National Party, continues with that evil Government, the National Party, continues with that evil programme continues with that evil programme that continues with that evil programme that denies continues with that evil programme that denies the continues with that evil programme that denies the rights continues with that evil programme that denies the rights of continues with that evil programme that denies the rights of families that denies the rights of families and that denies the rights of families and children that denies the rights of families and children to that denies the rights of families and children to a that denies the rights of families and children to a decent that denies the rights of families and children to a decent life that denies the rights of families and children to a decent life in and children to a decent life in this and children to a decent life in this country. and children to a decent life in this country. It and children to a decent life in this country. It has and children to a decent life in this country. It has been and children to a decent life in this country. It has been shameful this country. It has been shameful watching this country. It has been shameful watching John this country. It has been shameful watching John Key this country. It has been shameful watching John Key make this country. It has been shameful watching John Key make decisions watching John Key make decisions that watching John Key make decisions that leaves watching John Key make decisions that leaves families watching John Key make decisions that leaves families and watching John Key make decisions that leaves families and kids watching John Key make decisions that leaves families and kids out watching John Key make decisions that leaves families and kids out in that leaves families and kids out in the that leaves families and kids out in the cold. that leaves families and kids out in the cold. John that leaves families and kids out in the cold. John Key that leaves families and kids out in the cold. John Key was that leaves families and kids out in the cold. John Key was heard that leaves families and kids out in the cold. John Key was heard saying the cold. John Key was heard saying this the cold. John Key was heard saying this morning the cold. John Key was heard saying this morning that the cold. John Key was heard saying this morning that New the cold. John Key was heard saying this morning that New Zealand the cold. John Key was heard saying this morning that New Zealand is this morning that New Zealand is largely this morning that New Zealand is largely the this morning that New Zealand is largely the envy this morning that New Zealand is largely the envy of this morning that New Zealand is largely the envy of the this morning that New Zealand is largely the envy of the world, this morning that New Zealand is largely the envy of the world, he largely the envy of the world, he said. largely the envy of the world, he said. "The largely the envy of the world, he said. "The envy largely the envy of the world, he said. "The envy of largely the envy of the world, he said. "The envy of the largely the envy of the world, he said. "The envy of the developed said. "The envy of the developed world" said. "The envy of the developed world" in said. "The envy of the developed world" in terms said. "The envy of the developed world" in terms of said. "The envy of the developed world" in terms of job said. "The envy of the developed world" in terms of job creation said. "The envy of the developed world" in terms of job creation and world" in terms of job creation and wage world" in terms of job creation and wage growth. world" in terms of job creation and wage growth. No world" in terms of job creation and wage growth. No it's world" in terms of job creation and wage growth. No it's not. world" in terms of job creation and wage growth. No it's not. No, world" in terms of job creation and wage growth. No it's not. No, it's wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not for wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not for the wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not for the New wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not for the New Zealanders wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not for the New Zealanders who wage growth. No it's not. No, it's not for the New Zealanders who live not for the New Zealanders who live here not for the New Zealanders who live here and not for the New Zealanders who live here and who not for the New Zealanders who live here and who are not for the New Zealanders who live here and who are struggling not for the New Zealanders who live here and who are struggling to not for the New Zealanders who live here and who are struggling to pay here and who are struggling to pay their here and who are struggling to pay their rent here and who are struggling to pay their rent and here and who are struggling to pay their rent and put here and who are struggling to pay their rent and put food here and who are struggling to pay their rent and put food on here and who are struggling to pay their rent and put food on the here and who are struggling to pay their rent and put food on the table their rent and put food on the table and their rent and put food on the table and pay their rent and put food on the table and pay their their rent and put food on the table and pay their power their rent and put food on the table and pay their power business. their rent and put food on the table and pay their power business. This and pay their power business. This is and pay their power business. This is the and pay their power business. This is the reality and pay their power business. This is the reality for and pay their power business. This is the reality for thousands and pay their power business. This is the reality for thousands of and pay their power business. This is the reality for thousands of New is the reality for thousands of New Zealand is the reality for thousands of New Zealand children. is the reality for thousands of New Zealand children. It is the reality for thousands of New Zealand children. It is is the reality for thousands of New Zealand children. It is not... is the reality for thousands of New Zealand children. It is not... They Zealand children. It is not... They are Zealand children. It is not... They are not Zealand children. It is not... They are not envious. Zealand children. It is not... They are not envious. This Zealand children. It is not... They are not envious. This is Zealand children. It is not... They are not envious. This is a Zealand children. It is not... They are not envious. This is a shameful are not envious. This is a shameful legacy are not envious. This is a shameful legacy that are not envious. This is a shameful legacy that John are not envious. This is a shameful legacy that John Key are not envious. This is a shameful legacy that John Key leaves are not envious. This is a shameful legacy that John Key leaves us. legacy that John Key leaves us. There legacy that John Key leaves us. There are legacy that John Key leaves us. There are so legacy that John Key leaves us. There are so many legacy that John Key leaves us. There are so many good legacy that John Key leaves us. There are so many good things legacy that John Key leaves us. There are so many good things that There are so many good things that could There are so many good things that could have There are so many good things that could have happened There are so many good things that could have happened under There are so many good things that could have happened under John There are so many good things that could have happened under John Key's could have happened under John Key's leadership could have happened under John Key's leadership that could have happened under John Key's leadership that he could have happened under John Key's leadership that he ignored could have happened under John Key's leadership that he ignored because leadership that he ignored because New leadership that he ignored because New Zealand leadership that he ignored because New Zealand families leadership that he ignored because New Zealand families and leadership that he ignored because New Zealand families and their New Zealand families and their children New Zealand families and their children were New Zealand families and their children were never New Zealand families and their children were never at New Zealand families and their children were never at the New Zealand families and their children were never at the core New Zealand families and their children were never at the core of children were never at the core of his children were never at the core of his decision children were never at the core of his decision making. children were never at the core of his decision making. So children were never at the core of his decision making. So I children were never at the core of his decision making. So I would children were never at the core of his decision making. So I would like his decision making. So I would like to his decision making. So I would like to deal his decision making. So I would like to deal with his decision making. So I would like to deal with the his decision making. So I would like to deal with the issue his decision making. So I would like to deal with the issue of his decision making. So I would like to deal with the issue of children to deal with the issue of children going to deal with the issue of children going hungry to deal with the issue of children going hungry at to deal with the issue of children going hungry at school. to deal with the issue of children going hungry at school. It to deal with the issue of children going hungry at school. It was going hungry at school. It was scandalous, going hungry at school. It was scandalous, and going hungry at school. It was scandalous, and is going hungry at school. It was scandalous, and is still going hungry at school. It was scandalous, and is still scandalous, scandalous, and is still scandalous, that scandalous, and is still scandalous, that thousands scandalous, and is still scandalous, that thousands of scandalous, and is still scandalous, that thousands of New scandalous, and is still scandalous, that thousands of New Zealand that thousands of New Zealand children that thousands of New Zealand children are that thousands of New Zealand children are still that thousands of New Zealand children are still going that thousands of New Zealand children are still going to that thousands of New Zealand children are still going to school children are still going to school hungry children are still going to school hungry and children are still going to school hungry and are children are still going to school hungry and are at children are still going to school hungry and are at school children are still going to school hungry and are at school hungry, hungry and are at school hungry, because hungry and are at school hungry, because we hungry and are at school hungry, because we do hungry and are at school hungry, because we do not hungry and are at school hungry, because we do not have hungry and are at school hungry, because we do not have a because we do not have a comprehensive because we do not have a comprehensive school because we do not have a comprehensive school food because we do not have a comprehensive school food programme comprehensive school food programme in comprehensive school food programme in our comprehensive school food programme in our schools. comprehensive school food programme in our schools. And comprehensive school food programme in our schools. And when comprehensive school food programme in our schools. And when I comprehensive school food programme in our schools. And when I asked in our schools. And when I asked John in our schools. And when I asked John Key in our schools. And when I asked John Key about in our schools. And when I asked John Key about that in our schools. And when I asked John Key about that today in our schools. And when I asked John Key about that today in John Key about that today in question John Key about that today in question time, John Key about that today in question time, his John Key about that today in question time, his excuse John Key about that today in question time, his excuse is John Key about that today in question time, his excuse is that question time, his excuse is that there's question time, his excuse is that there's a question time, his excuse is that there's a programme question time, his excuse is that there's a programme and question time, his excuse is that there's a programme and there's question time, his excuse is that there's a programme and there's been there's a programme and there's been a there's a programme and there's been a bit there's a programme and there's been a bit of there's a programme and there's been a bit of Government there's a programme and there's been a bit of Government support there's a programme and there's been a bit of Government support for there's a programme and there's been a bit of Government support for it. a bit of Government support for it. There a bit of Government support for it. There are a bit of Government support for it. There are still a bit of Government support for it. There are still hungry a bit of Government support for it. There are still hungry children a bit of Government support for it. There are still hungry children at There are still hungry children at school. There are still hungry children at school. So There are still hungry children at school. So what There are still hungry children at school. So what about There are still hungry children at school. So what about them? There are still hungry children at school. So what about them? So There are still hungry children at school. So what about them? So some school. So what about them? So some are school. So what about them? So some are getting school. So what about them? So some are getting fed? school. So what about them? So some are getting fed? And school. So what about them? So some are getting fed? And what school. So what about them? So some are getting fed? And what about school. So what about them? So some are getting fed? And what about the are getting fed? And what about the ones are getting fed? And what about the ones who are getting fed? And what about the ones who are are getting fed? And what about the ones who are not? are getting fed? And what about the ones who are not? What are getting fed? And what about the ones who are not? What about are getting fed? And what about the ones who are not? What about the ones who are not? What about the ones ones who are not? What about the ones who ones who are not? What about the ones who are ones who are not? What about the ones who are not ones who are not? What about the ones who are not getting ones who are not? What about the ones who are not getting fed ones who are not? What about the ones who are not getting fed and ones who are not? What about the ones who are not getting fed and are ones who are not getting fed and are still ones who are not getting fed and are still hungry? still hungry? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Do <INTERRUPTION> Do they <INTERRUPTION> Do they count <INTERRUPTION> Do they count for <INTERRUPTION> Do they count for John <INTERRUPTION> Do they count for John Key? <INTERRUPTION> Do they count for John Key? Do <INTERRUPTION> Do they count for John Key? Do they Do they count for John Key? Do they matter Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to John Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to John Key? Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to John Key? Or Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to John Key? Or is Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to John Key? Or is he Do they count for John Key? Do they matter to John Key? Or is he happy matter to John Key? Or is he happy that matter to John Key? Or is he happy that only matter to John Key? Or is he happy that only some matter to John Key? Or is he happy that only some kids matter to John Key? Or is he happy that only some kids are matter to John Key? Or is he happy that only some kids are getting matter to John Key? Or is he happy that only some kids are getting fed that only some kids are getting fed in that only some kids are getting fed in this that only some kids are getting fed in this country that only some kids are getting fed in this country and that only some kids are getting fed in this country and some that only some kids are getting fed in this country and some are that only some kids are getting fed in this country and some are still in this country and some are still hungry, in this country and some are still hungry, because in this country and some are still hungry, because that in this country and some are still hungry, because that is in this country and some are still hungry, because that is what in this country and some are still hungry, because that is what is hungry, because that is what is happening hungry, because that is what is happening for hungry, because that is what is happening for thousands hungry, because that is what is happening for thousands of hungry, because that is what is happening for thousands of New happening for thousands of New Zealand happening for thousands of New Zealand children. happening for thousands of New Zealand children. They happening for thousands of New Zealand children. They are happening for thousands of New Zealand children. They are still Zealand children. They are still hungry Zealand children. They are still hungry at Zealand children. They are still hungry at school Zealand children. They are still hungry at school because Zealand children. They are still hungry at school because John Zealand children. They are still hungry at school because John Key hungry at school because John Key and hungry at school because John Key and Nationals hungry at school because John Key and Nationals would hungry at school because John Key and Nationals would not hungry at school because John Key and Nationals would not support hungry at school because John Key and Nationals would not support a and Nationals would not support a comprehensive and Nationals would not support a comprehensive Food and Nationals would not support a comprehensive Food and and Nationals would not support a comprehensive Food and Schools comprehensive Food and Schools Programme. comprehensive Food and Schools Programme. They comprehensive Food and Schools Programme. They had comprehensive Food and Schools Programme. They had the comprehensive Food and Schools Programme. They had the choice. comprehensive Food and Schools Programme. They had the choice. They Programme. They had the choice. They had Programme. They had the choice. They had the Programme. They had the choice. They had the money Programme. They had the choice. They had the money to Programme. They had the choice. They had the money to commit Programme. They had the choice. They had the money to commit to Programme. They had the choice. They had the money to commit to that, Programme. They had the choice. They had the money to commit to that, but had the money to commit to that, but there had the money to commit to that, but there are had the money to commit to that, but there are still had the money to commit to that, but there are still thousands had the money to commit to that, but there are still thousands of there are still thousands of children there are still thousands of children who there are still thousands of children who are there are still thousands of children who are left there are still thousands of children who are left out. there are still thousands of children who are left out. These there are still thousands of children who are left out. These are children who are left out. These are the children who are left out. These are the choices children who are left out. These are the choices of children who are left out. These are the choices of this children who are left out. These are the choices of this PM. children who are left out. These are the choices of this PM. That children who are left out. These are the choices of this PM. That is children who are left out. These are the choices of this PM. That is his the choices of this PM. That is his legacy. the choices of this PM. That is his legacy. What the choices of this PM. That is his legacy. What about the choices of this PM. That is his legacy. What about the the choices of this PM. That is his legacy. What about the children the choices of this PM. That is his legacy. What about the children who legacy. What about the children who are legacy. What about the children who are still legacy. What about the children who are still being legacy. What about the children who are still being admitted legacy. What about the children who are still being admitted to legacy. What about the children who are still being admitted to New are still being admitted to New Zealand are still being admitted to New Zealand hospitals are still being admitted to New Zealand hospitals because are still being admitted to New Zealand hospitals because of are still being admitted to New Zealand hospitals because of the Zealand hospitals because of the illnesses Zealand hospitals because of the illnesses that Zealand hospitals because of the illnesses that they Zealand hospitals because of the illnesses that they suffer Zealand hospitals because of the illnesses that they suffer from illnesses that they suffer from cold, illnesses that they suffer from cold, damp, illnesses that they suffer from cold, damp, mouldy illnesses that they suffer from cold, damp, mouldy houses? illnesses that they suffer from cold, damp, mouldy houses? The cold, damp, mouldy houses? The 40,000 cold, damp, mouldy houses? The 40,000 hospitalisations cold, damp, mouldy houses? The 40,000 hospitalisations of cold, damp, mouldy houses? The 40,000 hospitalisations of New 40,000 hospitalisations of New Zealand 40,000 hospitalisations of New Zealand children 40,000 hospitalisations of New Zealand children because 40,000 hospitalisations of New Zealand children because John 40,000 hospitalisations of New Zealand children because John Key Zealand children because John Key and Zealand children because John Key and the Zealand children because John Key and the National Zealand children because John Key and the National Government Zealand children because John Key and the National Government refused and the National Government refused to and the National Government refused to put and the National Government refused to put in and the National Government refused to put in place and the National Government refused to put in place a and the National Government refused to put in place a warrant and the National Government refused to put in place a warrant of and the National Government refused to put in place a warrant of fitness to put in place a warrant of fitness to to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to dry to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to dry out to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to dry out the to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to dry out the homes to put in place a warrant of fitness to warm up, to dry out the homes for to warm up, to dry out the homes for the to warm up, to dry out the homes for the kids. to warm up, to dry out the homes for the kids. What to warm up, to dry out the homes for the kids. What about to warm up, to dry out the homes for the kids. What about the to warm up, to dry out the homes for the kids. What about the 15 to warm up, to dry out the homes for the kids. What about the 15 children the kids. What about the 15 children who the kids. What about the 15 children who die the kids. What about the 15 children who die every the kids. What about the 15 children who die every year the kids. What about the 15 children who die every year under the kids. What about the 15 children who die every year under John the kids. What about the 15 children who die every year under John Key's who die every year under John Key's leadership who die every year under John Key's leadership because who die every year under John Key's leadership because they who die every year under John Key's leadership because they live who die every year under John Key's leadership because they live in leadership because they live in cold, leadership because they live in cold, damp, leadership because they live in cold, damp, mouldy leadership because they live in cold, damp, mouldy houses? leadership because they live in cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses that cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses that John cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses that John Key cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses that John Key and cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses that John Key and his cold, damp, mouldy houses? Houses that John Key and his Government that John Key and his Government could that John Key and his Government could have that John Key and his Government could have fixed. that John Key and his Government could have fixed. Houses that John Key and his Government could have fixed. Houses that that John Key and his Government could have fixed. Houses that could could have fixed. Houses that could be could have fixed. Houses that could be safe could have fixed. Houses that could be safe for could have fixed. Houses that could be safe for those could have fixed. Houses that could be safe for those kids could have fixed. Houses that could be safe for those kids and could have fixed. Houses that could be safe for those kids and their be safe for those kids and their families be safe for those kids and their families to be safe for those kids and their families to live be safe for those kids and their families to live in. be safe for those kids and their families to live in. Do be safe for those kids and their families to live in. Do those be safe for those kids and their families to live in. Do those kids families to live in. Do those kids matter families to live in. Do those kids matter to families to live in. Do those kids matter to John families to live in. Do those kids matter to John Key families to live in. Do those kids matter to John Key and families to live in. Do those kids matter to John Key and to families to live in. Do those kids matter to John Key and to the matter to John Key and to the National matter to John Key and to the National Government? matter to John Key and to the National Government? No, matter to John Key and to the National Government? No, they matter to John Key and to the National Government? No, they did National Government? No, they did not. National Government? No, they did not. Nothing National Government? No, they did not. Nothing has National Government? No, they did not. Nothing has changed National Government? No, they did not. Nothing has changed that National Government? No, they did not. Nothing has changed that will not. Nothing has changed that will protect not. Nothing has changed that will protect those not. Nothing has changed that will protect those families not. Nothing has changed that will protect those families and not. Nothing has changed that will protect those families and those not. Nothing has changed that will protect those families and those 15 protect those families and those 15 children. protect those families and those 15 children. This protect those families and those 15 children. This is protect those families and those 15 children. This is the protect those families and those 15 children. This is the legacy protect those families and those 15 children. This is the legacy of protect those families and those 15 children. This is the legacy of John children. This is the legacy of John Key, children. This is the legacy of John Key, retiring children. This is the legacy of John Key, retiring PM. children. This is the legacy of John Key, retiring PM. Despite children. This is the legacy of John Key, retiring PM. Despite all children. This is the legacy of John Key, retiring PM. Despite all of children. This is the legacy of John Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the rhetoric Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the rhetoric and Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the rhetoric and all Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the rhetoric and all of Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the rhetoric and all of the Key, retiring PM. Despite all of the rhetoric and all of the lovely rhetoric and all of the lovely stories rhetoric and all of the lovely stories we're rhetoric and all of the lovely stories we're going rhetoric and all of the lovely stories we're going to rhetoric and all of the lovely stories we're going to hear rhetoric and all of the lovely stories we're going to hear about stories we're going to hear about John stories we're going to hear about John Key stories we're going to hear about John Key from stories we're going to hear about John Key from lots stories we're going to hear about John Key from lots of stories we're going to hear about John Key from lots of different John Key from lots of different places, John Key from lots of different places, this John Key from lots of different places, this is John Key from lots of different places, this is the John Key from lots of different places, this is the actual John Key from lots of different places, this is the actual impact John Key from lots of different places, this is the actual impact of places, this is the actual impact of John places, this is the actual impact of John Key places, this is the actual impact of John Key being places, this is the actual impact of John Key being PM places, this is the actual impact of John Key being PM for places, this is the actual impact of John Key being PM for eight places, this is the actual impact of John Key being PM for eight years John Key being PM for eight years and John Key being PM for eight years and the John Key being PM for eight years and the National John Key being PM for eight years and the National Government John Key being PM for eight years and the National Government being and the National Government being Government and the National Government being Government for and the National Government being Government for these and the National Government being Government for these eight and the National Government being Government for these eight years. Government for these eight years. This Government for these eight years. This is Government for these eight years. This is why Government for these eight years. This is why we Government for these eight years. This is why we have Government for these eight years. This is why we have to Government for these eight years. This is why we have to change Government for these eight years. This is why we have to change the This is why we have to change the Government. This is why we have to change the Government. We This is why we have to change the Government. We cannot This is why we have to change the Government. We cannot allow This is why we have to change the Government. We cannot allow National Government. We cannot allow National to Government. We cannot allow National to continue Government. We cannot allow National to continue with Government. We cannot allow National to continue with the Government. We cannot allow National to continue with the reins Government. We cannot allow National to continue with the reins of Government. We cannot allow National to continue with the reins of power to continue with the reins of power and to continue with the reins of power and with to continue with the reins of power and with the to continue with the reins of power and with the financial to continue with the reins of power and with the financial resources to continue with the reins of power and with the financial resources and and with the financial resources and have and with the financial resources and have them and with the financial resources and have them divert and with the financial resources and have them divert those and with the financial resources and have them divert those resources and with the financial resources and have them divert those resources and have them divert those resources and to have them divert those resources and to use have them divert those resources and to use that have them divert those resources and to use that power have them divert those resources and to use that power for have them divert those resources and to use that power for the have them divert those resources and to use that power for the wealthy to use that power for the wealthy few to use that power for the wealthy few when to use that power for the wealthy few when our to use that power for the wealthy few when our families to use that power for the wealthy few when our families and to use that power for the wealthy few when our families and our to use that power for the wealthy few when our families and our kids few when our families and our kids are few when our families and our kids are suffering few when our families and our kids are suffering every few when our families and our kids are suffering every day. few when our families and our kids are suffering every day. What few when our families and our kids are suffering every day. What about are suffering every day. What about the are suffering every day. What about the 40,000 are suffering every day. What about the 40,000 New are suffering every day. What about the 40,000 New Zealanders are suffering every day. What about the 40,000 New Zealanders who are suffering every day. What about the 40,000 New Zealanders who are the 40,000 New Zealanders who are homeless? the 40,000 New Zealanders who are homeless? What the 40,000 New Zealanders who are homeless? What about the 40,000 New Zealanders who are homeless? What about them the 40,000 New Zealanders who are homeless? What about them today? homeless? What about them today? What homeless? What about them today? What about homeless? What about them today? What about the homeless? What about them today? What about the families homeless? What about them today? What about the families and homeless? What about them today? What about the families and the What about the families and the children What about the families and the children who What about the families and the children who tonight What about the families and the children who tonight will What about the families and the children who tonight will be children who tonight will be sleeping children who tonight will be sleeping in children who tonight will be sleeping in their children who tonight will be sleeping in their car? children who tonight will be sleeping in their car? Where children who tonight will be sleeping in their car? Where do children who tonight will be sleeping in their car? Where do they sleeping in their car? Where do they fit sleeping in their car? Where do they fit in sleeping in their car? Where do they fit in the sleeping in their car? Where do they fit in the legacy? sleeping in their car? Where do they fit in the legacy? Because sleeping in their car? Where do they fit in the legacy? Because that's fit in the legacy? Because that's who fit in the legacy? Because that's who he's fit in the legacy? Because that's who he's leaving fit in the legacy? Because that's who he's leaving behind fit in the legacy? Because that's who he's leaving behind when fit in the legacy? Because that's who he's leaving behind when he who he's leaving behind when he finishes. who he's leaving behind when he finishes. Those who he's leaving behind when he finishes. Those families who he's leaving behind when he finishes. Those families are who he's leaving behind when he finishes. Those families are being finishes. Those families are being left finishes. Those families are being left behind finishes. Those families are being left behind by finishes. Those families are being left behind by John finishes. Those families are being left behind by John Key. finishes. Those families are being left behind by John Key. He finishes. Those families are being left behind by John Key. He talked finishes. Those families are being left behind by John Key. He talked a left behind by John Key. He talked a lot left behind by John Key. He talked a lot earlier left behind by John Key. He talked a lot earlier today left behind by John Key. He talked a lot earlier today about left behind by John Key. He talked a lot earlier today about housing lot earlier today about housing policy. lot earlier today about housing policy. There lot earlier today about housing policy. There are lot earlier today about housing policy. There are still lot earlier today about housing policy. There are still thousands lot earlier today about housing policy. There are still thousands of policy. There are still thousands of New policy. There are still thousands of New Zealand policy. There are still thousands of New Zealand families policy. There are still thousands of New Zealand families who policy. There are still thousands of New Zealand families who are policy. There are still thousands of New Zealand families who are home New Zealand families who are home less New Zealand families who are home less of New Zealand families who are home less of people New Zealand families who are home less of people who New Zealand families who are home less of people who sleeping New Zealand families who are home less of people who sleeping in New Zealand families who are home less of people who sleeping in their less of people who sleeping in their cars, less of people who sleeping in their cars, who less of people who sleeping in their cars, who are less of people who sleeping in their cars, who are sleeping less of people who sleeping in their cars, who are sleeping in less of people who sleeping in their cars, who are sleeping in motor cars, who are sleeping in motor camps cars, who are sleeping in motor camps and cars, who are sleeping in motor camps and caravans cars, who are sleeping in motor camps and caravans which cars, who are sleeping in motor camps and caravans which are cars, who are sleeping in motor camps and caravans which are an camps and caravans which are an appalling camps and caravans which are an appalling condition. camps and caravans which are an appalling condition. Cockroaches, appalling condition. Cockroaches, damp appalling condition. Cockroaches, damp and appalling condition. Cockroaches, damp and mould. appalling condition. Cockroaches, damp and mould. Those appalling condition. Cockroaches, damp and mould. Those familiaries damp and mould. Those familiaries matter. damp and mould. Those familiaries matter. Those damp and mould. Those familiaries matter. Those kids damp and mould. Those familiaries matter. Those kids and damp and mould. Those familiaries matter. Those kids and those matter. Those kids and those families matter. Those kids and those families matter. matter. Those kids and those families matter. They matter. Those kids and those families matter. They are matter. Those kids and those families matter. They are important families matter. They are important citizens families matter. They are important citizens of families matter. They are important citizens of this families matter. They are important citizens of this country families matter. They are important citizens of this country too families matter. They are important citizens of this country too and citizens of this country too and they citizens of this country too and they deserved citizens of this country too and they deserved better citizens of this country too and they deserved better from citizens of this country too and they deserved better from John citizens of this country too and they deserved better from John Key they deserved better from John Key because they deserved better from John Key because what they deserved better from John Key because what did they deserved better from John Key because what did he they deserved better from John Key because what did he spend they deserved better from John Key because what did he spend his they deserved better from John Key because what did he spend his time because what did he spend his time on? because what did he spend his time on? Giving because what did he spend his time on? Giving Sky because what did he spend his time on? Giving Sky City because what did he spend his time on? Giving Sky City Casino because what did he spend his time on? Giving Sky City Casino the on? Giving Sky City Casino the opportunity on? Giving Sky City Casino the opportunity to on? Giving Sky City Casino the opportunity to put on? Giving Sky City Casino the opportunity to put in on? Giving Sky City Casino the opportunity to put in place on? Giving Sky City Casino the opportunity to put in place more opportunity to put in place more gambling opportunity to put in place more gambling machines opportunity to put in place more gambling machines to opportunity to put in place more gambling machines to make opportunity to put in place more gambling machines to make more gambling machines to make more money. gambling machines to make more money. That's gambling machines to make more money. That's what gambling machines to make more money. That's what John gambling machines to make more money. That's what John Key gambling machines to make more money. That's what John Key spent money. That's what John Key spent his money. That's what John Key spent his time money. That's what John Key spent his time on. money. That's what John Key spent his time on. Defending money. That's what John Key spent his time on. Defending the money. That's what John Key spent his time on. Defending the dirty his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi sheep his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi sheep deal. his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi sheep deal. That his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi sheep deal. That is his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi sheep deal. That is what his time on. Defending the dirty Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent his Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent his time Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent his time on. Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent his time on. The Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent his time on. The tax Saudi sheep deal. That is what John Key spent his time on. The tax cuts Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for the Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for the very Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for the very wealthy Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for the very wealthy is Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for the very wealthy is what Key spent his time on. The tax cuts for the very wealthy is what he for the very wealthy is what he spent for the very wealthy is what he spent his for the very wealthy is what he spent his time for the very wealthy is what he spent his time on. for the very wealthy is what he spent his time on. Keeping for the very wealthy is what he spent his time on. Keeping foreign spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts going spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts going in spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts going in New spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts going in New Zealand spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts going in New Zealand is spent his time on. Keeping foreign trusts going in New Zealand is what trusts going in New Zealand is what he trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent his trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent his time trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent his time on trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent his time on to trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent his time on to enable trusts going in New Zealand is what he spent his time on to enable the he spent his time on to enable the very he spent his time on to enable the very wealthy he spent his time on to enable the very wealthy to he spent his time on to enable the very wealthy to hide he spent his time on to enable the very wealthy to hide their he spent his time on to enable the very wealthy to hide their money. very wealthy to hide their money. Those very wealthy to hide their money. Those things very wealthy to hide their money. Those things were very wealthy to hide their money. Those things were his very wealthy to hide their money. Those things were his priority. very wealthy to hide their money. Those things were his priority. When Those things were his priority. When he Those things were his priority. When he only Those things were his priority. When he only needs Those things were his priority. When he only needs to Those things were his priority. When he only needs to look Those things were his priority. When he only needs to look back Those things were his priority. When he only needs to look back over Those things were his priority. When he only needs to look back over the he only needs to look back over the last he only needs to look back over the last eight he only needs to look back over the last eight years he only needs to look back over the last eight years and he only needs to look back over the last eight years and see he only needs to look back over the last eight years and see for last eight years and see for ourselves last eight years and see for ourselves the last eight years and see for ourselves the legacy last eight years and see for ourselves the legacy that last eight years and see for ourselves the legacy that John last eight years and see for ourselves the legacy that John Key ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. So ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. So it ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. So it is ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. So it is time ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. So it is time now, ourselves the legacy that John Key leaves. So it is time now, New leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, that leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, that we leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, that we take leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, that we take back leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, that we take back the leaves. So it is time now, New Zealand, that we take back the reins Zealand, that we take back the reins of Zealand, that we take back the reins of Government Zealand, that we take back the reins of Government and Zealand, that we take back the reins of Government and put Zealand, that we take back the reins of Government and put in Zealand, that we take back the reins of Government and put in place Zealand, that we take back the reins of Government and put in place a of Government and put in place a Government of Government and put in place a Government that of Government and put in place a Government that will of Government and put in place a Government that will put of Government and put in place a Government that will put families Government that will put families and Government that will put families and children Government that will put families and children at Government that will put families and children at the Government that will put families and children at the heart Government that will put families and children at the heart of Government that will put families and children at the heart of the and children at the heart of the decisions and children at the heart of the decisions that and children at the heart of the decisions that we and children at the heart of the decisions that we make. and children at the heart of the decisions that we make. Because and children at the heart of the decisions that we make. Because if decisions that we make. Because if we're decisions that we make. Because if we're not decisions that we make. Because if we're not here decisions that we make. Because if we're not here to decisions that we make. Because if we're not here to fight decisions that we make. Because if we're not here to fight for decisions that we make. Because if we're not here to fight for and decisions that we make. Because if we're not here to fight for and work we're not here to fight for and work for we're not here to fight for and work for them, we're not here to fight for and work for them, what we're not here to fight for and work for them, what is we're not here to fight for and work for them, what is the we're not here to fight for and work for them, what is the point we're not here to fight for and work for them, what is the point of we're not here to fight for and work for them, what is the point of you? for them, what is the point of you? I'm for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad John for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad John Key for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad John Key is for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad John Key is going. for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad John Key is going. Good, for them, what is the point of you? I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. He I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. He has I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. He has not I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. He has not been I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. He has not been a I'm glad John Key is going. Good, he should go. He has not been a good should go. He has not been a good PM. should go. He has not been a good PM. He should go. He has not been a good PM. He has should go. He has not been a good PM. He has left should go. He has not been a good PM. He has left the should go. He has not been a good PM. He has left the families should go. He has not been a good PM. He has left the families to should go. He has not been a good PM. He has left the families to fend PM. He has left the families to fend for PM. He has left the families to fend for themselves PM. He has left the families to fend for themselves and PM. He has left the families to fend for themselves and had PM. He has left the families to fend for themselves and had the for themselves and had the opportunity for themselves and had the opportunity to for themselves and had the opportunity to help for themselves and had the opportunity to help them for themselves and had the opportunity to help them and for themselves and had the opportunity to help them and he opportunity to help them and he chose opportunity to help them and he chose not opportunity to help them and he chose not to. opportunity to help them and he chose not to. Good, opportunity to help them and he chose not to. Good, go. opportunity to help them and he chose not to. Good, go. And opportunity to help them and he chose not to. Good, go. And take opportunity to help them and he chose not to. Good, go. And take the chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest of chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest of them chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest of them with chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest of them with you. chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest of them with you. Because chose not to. Good, go. And take the rest of them with you. Because this rest of them with you. Because this is rest of them with you. Because this is not rest of them with you. Because this is not a rest of them with you. Because this is not a Government rest of them with you. Because this is not a Government that rest of them with you. Because this is not a Government that puts rest of them with you. Because this is not a Government that puts New is not a Government that puts New Zealanders is not a Government that puts New Zealanders at is not a Government that puts New Zealanders at the is not a Government that puts New Zealanders at the heart is not a Government that puts New Zealanders at the heart of is not a Government that puts New Zealanders at the heart of their Zealanders at the heart of their decisions. Zealanders at the heart of their decisions. In Zealanders at the heart of their decisions. In 2017, Zealanders at the heart of their decisions. In 2017, the Zealanders at the heart of their decisions. In 2017, the Greens Zealanders at the heart of their decisions. In 2017, the Greens will decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part of decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part of a decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part of a new decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part of a new Government decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part of a new Government who decisions. In 2017, the Greens will be part of a new Government who will be part of a new Government who will put be part of a new Government who will put children be part of a new Government who will put children and be part of a new Government who will put children and their be part of a new Government who will put children and their families be part of a new Government who will put children and their families at put children and their families at the put children and their families at the heart put children and their families at the heart of put children and their families at the heart of every put children and their families at the heart of every decision put children and their families at the heart of every decision we put children and their families at the heart of every decision we make. the heart of every decision we make. (BELL the heart of every decision we make. (BELL rings) the heart of every decision we make. (BELL rings) that the heart of every decision we make. (BELL rings) that is the heart of every decision we make. (BELL rings) that is what the heart of every decision we make. (BELL rings) that is what we the heart of every decision we make. (BELL rings) that is what we do. (BELL rings) that is what we do. That (BELL rings) that is what we do. That is (BELL rings) that is what we do. That is why (BELL rings) that is what we do. That is why we're (BELL rings) that is what we do. That is why we're saying (BELL rings) that is what we do. That is why we're saying as (BELL rings) that is what we do. That is why we're saying as New That is why we're saying as New Zealanders, That is why we're saying as New Zealanders, we That is why we're saying as New Zealanders, we have That is why we're saying as New Zealanders, we have to That is why we're saying as New Zealanders, we have to change That is why we're saying as New Zealanders, we have to change the Zealanders, we have to change the Government. Zealanders, we have to change the Government. Losing Zealanders, we have to change the Government. Losing John Zealanders, we have to change the Government. Losing John Key Zealanders, we have to change the Government. Losing John Key is Zealanders, we have to change the Government. Losing John Key is not Government. Losing John Key is not enough. Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They all Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They all have Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They all have to Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They all have to go. Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They all have to go. We Government. Losing John Key is not enough. They all have to go. We have enough. They all have to go. We have six enough. They all have to go. We have six months, enough. They all have to go. We have six months, eight enough. They all have to go. We have six months, eight months enough. They all have to go. We have six months, eight months - enough. They all have to go. We have six months, eight months - let's six months, eight months - let's make six months, eight months - let's make it six months, eight months - let's make it happen. six months, eight months - let's make it happen. Because six months, eight months - let's make it happen. Because those six months, eight months - let's make it happen. Because those kids make it happen. Because those kids need make it happen. Because those kids need us. make it happen. Because those kids need us. They make it happen. Because those kids need us. They certainly make it happen. Because those kids need us. They certainly don't make it happen. Because those kids need us. They certainly don't need need us. They certainly don't need National. This This is This is a This is a special This is a special debate This is a special debate called This is a special debate called for This is a special debate called for by This is a special debate called for by the This is a special debate called for by the Opposition This is a special debate called for by the Opposition parties This is a special debate called for by the Opposition parties so This is a special debate called for by the Opposition parties so that by the Opposition parties so that they by the Opposition parties so that they might by the Opposition parties so that they might debate by the Opposition parties so that they might debate the by the Opposition parties so that they might debate the occasion by the Opposition parties so that they might debate the occasion and they might debate the occasion and the they might debate the occasion and the circumstances they might debate the occasion and the circumstances of they might debate the occasion and the circumstances of the they might debate the occasion and the circumstances of the decision they might debate the occasion and the circumstances of the decision by the circumstances of the decision by John the circumstances of the decision by John Key. the circumstances of the decision by John Key. The the circumstances of the decision by John Key. The Rt the circumstances of the decision by John Key. The Rt Honerable the circumstances of the decision by John Key. The Rt Honerable John the circumstances of the decision by John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key to John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key to resign John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key to resign as John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key to resign as PM John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key to resign as PM effectively John Key. The Rt Honerable John Key to resign as PM effectively next to resign as PM effectively next Monday to resign as PM effectively next Monday and to resign as PM effectively next Monday and for to resign as PM effectively next Monday and for there to resign as PM effectively next Monday and for there to to resign as PM effectively next Monday and for there to be to resign as PM effectively next Monday and for there to be new Monday and for there to be new leadership Monday and for there to be new leadership in Monday and for there to be new leadership in the Monday and for there to be new leadership in the National Monday and for there to be new leadership in the National Party Monday and for there to be new leadership in the National Party and leadership in the National Party and therefore leadership in the National Party and therefore as leadership in the National Party and therefore as PM leadership in the National Party and therefore as PM as leadership in the National Party and therefore as PM as well. leadership in the National Party and therefore as PM as well. So leadership in the National Party and therefore as PM as well. So it leadership in the National Party and therefore as PM as well. So it seems therefore as PM as well. So it seems a therefore as PM as well. So it seems a little therefore as PM as well. So it seems a little bit therefore as PM as well. So it seems a little bit odd, therefore as PM as well. So it seems a little bit odd, having therefore as PM as well. So it seems a little bit odd, having decided a little bit odd, having decided that a little bit odd, having decided that they a little bit odd, having decided that they would a little bit odd, having decided that they would request a little bit odd, having decided that they would request the a little bit odd, having decided that they would request the time a little bit odd, having decided that they would request the time of that they would request the time of the that they would request the time of the house, that they would request the time of the house, that that they would request the time of the house, that the that they would request the time of the house, that the parties that they would request the time of the house, that the parties then the house, that the parties then spend the house, that the parties then spend it the house, that the parties then spend it trying the house, that the parties then spend it trying to the house, that the parties then spend it trying to push the house, that the parties then spend it trying to push policies spend it trying to push policies that spend it trying to push policies that have spend it trying to push policies that have been spend it trying to push policies that have been roundly spend it trying to push policies that have been roundly rejected spend it trying to push policies that have been roundly rejected in that have been roundly rejected in the that have been roundly rejected in the last that have been roundly rejected in the last eight that have been roundly rejected in the last eight years that have been roundly rejected in the last eight years through that have been roundly rejected in the last eight years through two the last eight years through two elections, the last eight years through two elections, three the last eight years through two elections, three elections, the last eight years through two elections, three elections, in the last eight years through two elections, three elections, in fact, elections, three elections, in fact, by elections, three elections, in fact, by voters elections, three elections, in fact, by voters of elections, three elections, in fact, by voters of New elections, three elections, in fact, by voters of New Zealand. elections, three elections, in fact, by voters of New Zealand. Why elections, three elections, in fact, by voters of New Zealand. Why would by voters of New Zealand. Why would we by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever imagine by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever imagine that by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever imagine that it by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever imagine that it would by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever imagine that it would be by voters of New Zealand. Why would we ever imagine that it would be a we ever imagine that it would be a good we ever imagine that it would be a good use we ever imagine that it would be a good use of we ever imagine that it would be a good use of the we ever imagine that it would be a good use of the house's we ever imagine that it would be a good use of the house's time we ever imagine that it would be a good use of the house's time to good use of the house's time to debate good use of the house's time to debate the good use of the house's time to debate the policies good use of the house's time to debate the policies of good use of the house's time to debate the policies of the good use of the house's time to debate the policies of the 2008, debate the policies of the 2008, 2011 debate the policies of the 2008, 2011 and debate the policies of the 2008, 2011 and 2014 debate the policies of the 2008, 2011 and 2014 elections debate the policies of the 2008, 2011 and 2014 elections all debate the policies of the 2008, 2011 and 2014 elections all over 2011 and 2014 elections all over again? 2011 and 2014 elections all over again? That's 2011 and 2014 elections all over again? That's the 2011 and 2014 elections all over again? That's the problem 2011 and 2014 elections all over again? That's the problem with 2011 and 2014 elections all over again? That's the problem with the again? That's the problem with the Opposition again? That's the problem with the Opposition in again? That's the problem with the Opposition in this again? That's the problem with the Opposition in this country. again? That's the problem with the Opposition in this country. They Opposition in this country. They have Opposition in this country. They have no Opposition in this country. They have no moment Opposition in this country. They have no moment when Opposition in this country. They have no moment when they're Opposition in this country. They have no moment when they're in Opposition in this country. They have no moment when they're in the have no moment when they're in the present. have no moment when they're in the present. That have no moment when they're in the present. That speech have no moment when they're in the present. That speech was have no moment when they're in the present. That speech was nothing have no moment when they're in the present. That speech was nothing but present. That speech was nothing but nasty present. That speech was nothing but nasty garbage present. That speech was nothing but nasty garbage which present. That speech was nothing but nasty garbage which is present. That speech was nothing but nasty garbage which is not present. That speech was nothing but nasty garbage which is not even nasty garbage which is not even slightly nasty garbage which is not even slightly reflective nasty garbage which is not even slightly reflective of nasty garbage which is not even slightly reflective of how nasty garbage which is not even slightly reflective of how New slightly reflective of how New Zealanders slightly reflective of how New Zealanders see slightly reflective of how New Zealanders see the slightly reflective of how New Zealanders see the performance slightly reflective of how New Zealanders see the performance of Zealanders see the performance of the Zealanders see the performance of the current Zealanders see the performance of the current Government, Zealanders see the performance of the current Government, let Zealanders see the performance of the current Government, let aLondon the current Government, let aLondon the the current Government, let aLondon the status the current Government, let aLondon the status that the current Government, let aLondon the status that they the current Government, let aLondon the status that they hold the current Government, let aLondon the status that they hold John the current Government, let aLondon the status that they hold John Key the status that they hold John Key in the status that they hold John Key in and the status that they hold John Key in and the the status that they hold John Key in and the way the status that they hold John Key in and the way in the status that they hold John Key in and the way in which the status that they hold John Key in and the way in which they in and the way in which they consider in and the way in which they consider him in and the way in which they consider him to in and the way in which they consider him to be in and the way in which they consider him to be a in and the way in which they consider him to be a great in and the way in which they consider him to be a great leader consider him to be a great leader for consider him to be a great leader for this consider him to be a great leader for this country. consider him to be a great leader for this country. They consider him to be a great leader for this country. They went consider him to be a great leader for this country. They went on consider him to be a great leader for this country. They went on about for this country. They went on about so for this country. They went on about so many for this country. They went on about so many different for this country. They went on about so many different things for this country. They went on about so many different things that for this country. They went on about so many different things that it's so many different things that it's hard so many different things that it's hard to so many different things that it's hard to cover so many different things that it's hard to cover them so many different things that it's hard to cover them all. so many different things that it's hard to cover them all. I'll so many different things that it's hard to cover them all. I'll try so many different things that it's hard to cover them all. I'll try to hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover some. hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover some. But hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover some. But I hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover some. But I make hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover some. But I make the hard to cover them all. I'll try to cover some. But I make the point cover some. But I make the point that cover some. But I make the point that if cover some. But I make the point that if an cover some. But I make the point that if an Opposition cover some. But I make the point that if an Opposition is cover some. But I make the point that if an Opposition is going cover some. But I make the point that if an Opposition is going to cover some. But I make the point that if an Opposition is going to go that if an Opposition is going to go from that if an Opposition is going to go from being that if an Opposition is going to go from being in that if an Opposition is going to go from being in Opposition that if an Opposition is going to go from being in Opposition into from being in Opposition into Government, from being in Opposition into Government, then from being in Opposition into Government, then they from being in Opposition into Government, then they should from being in Opposition into Government, then they should stop Government, then they should stop insulting Government, then they should stop insulting 50% Government, then they should stop insulting 50% of Government, then they should stop insulting 50% of the Government, then they should stop insulting 50% of the voters Government, then they should stop insulting 50% of the voters who insulting 50% of the voters who don't insulting 50% of the voters who don't think insulting 50% of the voters who don't think they're insulting 50% of the voters who don't think they're up insulting 50% of the voters who don't think they're up to insulting 50% of the voters who don't think they're up to it insulting 50% of the voters who don't think they're up to it and don't think they're up to it and start don't think they're up to it and start trying don't think they're up to it and start trying to don't think they're up to it and start trying to persuade don't think they're up to it and start trying to persuade 50% don't think they're up to it and start trying to persuade 50% of don't think they're up to it and start trying to persuade 50% of the start trying to persuade 50% of the voters start trying to persuade 50% of the voters that start trying to persuade 50% of the voters that they start trying to persuade 50% of the voters that they can start trying to persuade 50% of the voters that they can offer start trying to persuade 50% of the voters that they can offer something voters that they can offer something a voters that they can offer something a little voters that they can offer something a little more voters that they can offer something a little more hopeful voters that they can offer something a little more hopeful than voters that they can offer something a little more hopeful than the a little more hopeful than the dismal a little more hopeful than the dismal rubbish a little more hopeful than the dismal rubbish we've a little more hopeful than the dismal rubbish we've had a little more hopeful than the dismal rubbish we've had pouring a little more hopeful than the dismal rubbish we've had pouring out dismal rubbish we've had pouring out of dismal rubbish we've had pouring out of Winston dismal rubbish we've had pouring out of Winston Peters, dismal rubbish we've had pouring out of Winston Peters, and dismal rubbish we've had pouring out of Winston Peters, and Metiria dismal rubbish we've had pouring out of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei this of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei this afternoon. of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei this afternoon. Let's of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei this afternoon. Let's look of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei this afternoon. Let's look at of Winston Peters, and Metiria Turei this afternoon. Let's look at some this afternoon. Let's look at some things. this afternoon. Let's look at some things. Firstly, this afternoon. Let's look at some things. Firstly, the this afternoon. Let's look at some things. Firstly, the rambling this afternoon. Let's look at some things. Firstly, the rambling speech things. Firstly, the rambling speech by things. Firstly, the rambling speech by Winston things. Firstly, the rambling speech by Winston Peters. things. Firstly, the rambling speech by Winston Peters. If things. Firstly, the rambling speech by Winston Peters. If that things. Firstly, the rambling speech by Winston Peters. If that wasn't things. Firstly, the rambling speech by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request for by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request for an by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request for an urgent by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request for an urgent transfer by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request for an urgent transfer to by Winston Peters. If that wasn't an request for an urgent transfer to a request for an urgent transfer to a retirement request for an urgent transfer to a retirement home, request for an urgent transfer to a retirement home, I request for an urgent transfer to a retirement home, I don't request for an urgent transfer to a retirement home, I don't know request for an urgent transfer to a retirement home, I don't know what retirement home, I don't know what that. retirement home, I don't know what that. That retirement home, I don't know what that. That was retirement home, I don't know what that. That was the retirement home, I don't know what that. That was the sort retirement home, I don't know what that. That was the sort of that. That was the sort of rose-coloured that. That was the sort of rose-coloured nostalgia that. That was the sort of rose-coloured nostalgia that that. That was the sort of rose-coloured nostalgia that worked rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr Peters rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr Peters 20 rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr Peters 20 years rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr Peters 20 years ago. rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It rose-coloured nostalgia that worked for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does not for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does not reflect for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does not reflect mopped for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does not reflect mopped earn for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does not reflect mopped earn New for Mr Peters 20 years ago. It does not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And that's not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And that's one not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And that's one of not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And that's one of the not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And that's one of the things not reflect mopped earn New Zealand. And that's one of the things that And that's one of the things that New And that's one of the things that New Zealand And that's one of the things that New Zealand First And that's one of the things that New Zealand First are And that's one of the things that New Zealand First are going And that's one of the things that New Zealand First are going to And that's one of the things that New Zealand First are going to have New Zealand First are going to have to New Zealand First are going to have to come New Zealand First are going to have to come to New Zealand First are going to have to come to terms New Zealand First are going to have to come to terms with New Zealand First are going to have to come to terms with in New Zealand First are going to have to come to terms with in the New Zealand First are going to have to come to terms with in the next to come to terms with in the next several to come to terms with in the next several months to come to terms with in the next several months if to come to terms with in the next several months if they're to come to terms with in the next several months if they're going to come to terms with in the next several months if they're going to several months if they're going to be several months if they're going to be anywhere several months if they're going to be anywhere near several months if they're going to be anywhere near competitive several months if they're going to be anywhere near competitive in several months if they're going to be anywhere near competitive in the be anywhere near competitive in the next be anywhere near competitive in the next election. be anywhere near competitive in the next election. Because be anywhere near competitive in the next election. Because it be anywhere near competitive in the next election. Because it is be anywhere near competitive in the next election. Because it is that next election. Because it is that moving next election. Because it is that moving on, next election. Because it is that moving on, that next election. Because it is that moving on, that recognising next election. Because it is that moving on, that recognising the moving on, that recognising the situation moving on, that recognising the situation of moving on, that recognising the situation of today moving on, that recognising the situation of today and moving on, that recognising the situation of today and finding situation of today and finding solutions situation of today and finding solutions for situation of today and finding solutions for today situation of today and finding solutions for today and situation of today and finding solutions for today and for situation of today and finding solutions for today and for tomorrow solutions for today and for tomorrow that solutions for today and for tomorrow that John solutions for today and for tomorrow that John Key solutions for today and for tomorrow that John Key has solutions for today and for tomorrow that John Key has been solutions for today and for tomorrow that John Key has been so solutions for today and for tomorrow that John Key has been so very solutions for today and for tomorrow that John Key has been so very good that John Key has been so very good at. that John Key has been so very good at. When that John Key has been so very good at. When Mr that John Key has been so very good at. When Mr English that John Key has been so very good at. When Mr English spoke, that John Key has been so very good at. When Mr English spoke, he that John Key has been so very good at. When Mr English spoke, he talked at. When Mr English spoke, he talked about at. When Mr English spoke, he talked about the at. When Mr English spoke, he talked about the PM's at. When Mr English spoke, he talked about the PM's relentless at. When Mr English spoke, he talked about the PM's relentless optimism. about the PM's relentless optimism. I've about the PM's relentless optimism. I've never about the PM's relentless optimism. I've never seen about the PM's relentless optimism. I've never seen him about the PM's relentless optimism. I've never seen him anything about the PM's relentless optimism. I've never seen him anything other I've never seen him anything other than I've never seen him anything other than optimistic I've never seen him anything other than optimistic about I've never seen him anything other than optimistic about the I've never seen him anything other than optimistic about the future I've never seen him anything other than optimistic about the future of than optimistic about the future of this than optimistic about the future of this country. than optimistic about the future of this country. I've than optimistic about the future of this country. I've never than optimistic about the future of this country. I've never seen than optimistic about the future of this country. I've never seen him this country. I've never seen him daunted this country. I've never seen him daunted by this country. I've never seen him daunted by a this country. I've never seen him daunted by a problem this country. I've never seen him daunted by a problem that this country. I've never seen him daunted by a problem that this daunted by a problem that this country daunted by a problem that this country has. daunted by a problem that this country has. But daunted by a problem that this country has. But I daunted by a problem that this country has. But I have daunted by a problem that this country has. But I have seen daunted by a problem that this country has. But I have seen him country has. But I have seen him apply country has. But I have seen him apply himself country has. But I have seen him apply himself and country has. But I have seen him apply himself and demand country has. But I have seen him apply himself and demand the country has. But I have seen him apply himself and demand the same apply himself and demand the same rigour apply himself and demand the same rigour of apply himself and demand the same rigour of others apply himself and demand the same rigour of others in apply himself and demand the same rigour of others in his apply himself and demand the same rigour of others in his ministry apply himself and demand the same rigour of others in his ministry to rigour of others in his ministry to solving rigour of others in his ministry to solving some rigour of others in his ministry to solving some of rigour of others in his ministry to solving some of those rigour of others in his ministry to solving some of those problems. rigour of others in his ministry to solving some of those problems. So solving some of those problems. So if solving some of those problems. So if Metiria solving some of those problems. So if Metiria Turei solving some of those problems. So if Metiria Turei talks solving some of those problems. So if Metiria Turei talks about solving some of those problems. So if Metiria Turei talks about poverty if Metiria Turei talks about poverty in if Metiria Turei talks about poverty in this if Metiria Turei talks about poverty in this country, if Metiria Turei talks about poverty in this country, where if Metiria Turei talks about poverty in this country, where were if Metiria Turei talks about poverty in this country, where were the in this country, where were the Greens in this country, where were the Greens for in this country, where were the Greens for nine in this country, where were the Greens for nine years in this country, where were the Greens for nine years when in this country, where were the Greens for nine years when the Greens for nine years when the Labour Greens for nine years when the Labour Party Greens for nine years when the Labour Party did Greens for nine years when the Labour Party did not Greens for nine years when the Labour Party did not lift Greens for nine years when the Labour Party did not lift benefit Labour Party did not lift benefit income Labour Party did not lift benefit income for Labour Party did not lift benefit income for any Labour Party did not lift benefit income for any poor Labour Party did not lift benefit income for any poor New Labour Party did not lift benefit income for any poor New Zealander? income for any poor New Zealander? That income for any poor New Zealander? That took income for any poor New Zealander? That took a income for any poor New Zealander? That took a John income for any poor New Zealander? That took a John Key income for any poor New Zealander? That took a John Key government income for any poor New Zealander? That took a John Key government to That took a John Key government to do That took a John Key government to do that. That took a John Key government to do that. Where That took a John Key government to do that. Where were That took a John Key government to do that. Where were they That took a John Key government to do that. Where were they around do that. Where were they around things do that. Where were they around things like do that. Where were they around things like the do that. Where were they around things like the Family do that. Where were they around things like the Family Tax do that. Where were they around things like the Family Tax Credit? things like the Family Tax Credit? No, things like the Family Tax Credit? No, opposed things like the Family Tax Credit? No, opposed to things like the Family Tax Credit? No, opposed to it. things like the Family Tax Credit? No, opposed to it. Where things like the Family Tax Credit? No, opposed to it. Where were things like the Family Tax Credit? No, opposed to it. Where were they No, opposed to it. Where were they around No, opposed to it. Where were they around all No, opposed to it. Where were they around all of No, opposed to it. Where were they around all of the No, opposed to it. Where were they around all of the various No, opposed to it. Where were they around all of the various types No, opposed to it. Where were they around all of the various types of around all of the various types of job around all of the various types of job creation around all of the various types of job creation that around all of the various types of job creation that comes around all of the various types of job creation that comes from job creation that comes from expanding job creation that comes from expanding trade, job creation that comes from expanding trade, that job creation that comes from expanding trade, that comes job creation that comes from expanding trade, that comes from expanding trade, that comes from freeing expanding trade, that comes from freeing up expanding trade, that comes from freeing up the expanding trade, that comes from freeing up the way expanding trade, that comes from freeing up the way in expanding trade, that comes from freeing up the way in which expanding trade, that comes from freeing up the way in which people freeing up the way in which people can freeing up the way in which people can do freeing up the way in which people can do business? freeing up the way in which people can do business? Nothing. freeing up the way in which people can do business? Nothing. We freeing up the way in which people can do business? Nothing. We had can do business? Nothing. We had high can do business? Nothing. We had high unemployment can do business? Nothing. We had high unemployment in can do business? Nothing. We had high unemployment in 2008, can do business? Nothing. We had high unemployment in 2008, we can do business? Nothing. We had high unemployment in 2008, we had can do business? Nothing. We had high unemployment in 2008, we had an high unemployment in 2008, we had an economy high unemployment in 2008, we had an economy that high unemployment in 2008, we had an economy that was high unemployment in 2008, we had an economy that was in high unemployment in 2008, we had an economy that was in severe high unemployment in 2008, we had an economy that was in severe trouble economy that was in severe trouble in economy that was in severe trouble in 2008. economy that was in severe trouble in 2008. And economy that was in severe trouble in 2008. And we economy that was in severe trouble in 2008. And we had economy that was in severe trouble in 2008. And we had interest economy that was in severe trouble in 2008. And we had interest rates in 2008. And we had interest rates with in 2008. And we had interest rates with people in 2008. And we had interest rates with people who in 2008. And we had interest rates with people who were in 2008. And we had interest rates with people who were in in 2008. And we had interest rates with people who were in housing in 2008. And we had interest rates with people who were in housing in with people who were in housing in 2008 with people who were in housing in 2008 topping with people who were in housing in 2008 topping 10.5%. with people who were in housing in 2008 topping 10.5%. And with people who were in housing in 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was good 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was good for 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was good for poor 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was good for poor people. 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was good for poor people. Well, 2008 topping 10.5%. And apparently was good for poor people. Well, Mr was good for poor people. Well, Mr Speaker, was good for poor people. Well, Mr Speaker, that was good for poor people. Well, Mr Speaker, that is was good for poor people. Well, Mr Speaker, that is a was good for poor people. Well, Mr Speaker, that is a disgrace was good for poor people. Well, Mr Speaker, that is a disgrace that Speaker, that is a disgrace that that Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can be Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can be offered Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can be offered as Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can be offered as any Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can be offered as any kind Speaker, that is a disgrace that that can be offered as any kind of that can be offered as any kind of recipe that can be offered as any kind of recipe going that can be offered as any kind of recipe going forward that can be offered as any kind of recipe going forward for that can be offered as any kind of recipe going forward for the that can be offered as any kind of recipe going forward for the coming recipe going forward for the coming election. recipe going forward for the coming election. And recipe going forward for the coming election. And then, recipe going forward for the coming election. And then, it recipe going forward for the coming election. And then, it brings recipe going forward for the coming election. And then, it brings me election. And then, it brings me also election. And then, it brings me also to election. And then, it brings me also to the election. And then, it brings me also to the question election. And then, it brings me also to the question that... election. And then, it brings me also to the question that... The also to the question that... The prop also to the question that... The prop significance also to the question that... The prop significance that also to the question that... The prop significance that Andrew also to the question that... The prop significance that Andrew Little prop significance that Andrew Little had prop significance that Andrew Little had there prop significance that Andrew Little had there that prop significance that Andrew Little had there that John prop significance that Andrew Little had there that John Key prop significance that Andrew Little had there that John Key has prop significance that Andrew Little had there that John Key has failed had there that John Key has failed to had there that John Key has failed to house had there that John Key has failed to house New had there that John Key has failed to house New Zealanders. had there that John Key has failed to house New Zealanders. We've had there that John Key has failed to house New Zealanders. We've never to house New Zealanders. We've never seen to house New Zealanders. We've never seen the to house New Zealanders. We've never seen the house to house New Zealanders. We've never seen the house building to house New Zealanders. We've never seen the house building in to house New Zealanders. We've never seen the house building in New seen the house building in New Zealand seen the house building in New Zealand compared to seen the house building in New Zealand compared to any seen the house building in New Zealand compared to any time seen the house building in New Zealand compared to any time than Zealand compared to any time than what Zealand compared to any time than what we've Zealand compared to any time than what we've got Zealand compared to any time than what we've got now, Zealand compared to any time than what we've got now, and Zealand compared to any time than what we've got now, and that's Zealand compared to any time than what we've got now, and that's a what we've got now, and that's a programme what we've got now, and that's a programme that's what we've got now, and that's a programme that's not what we've got now, and that's a programme that's not propped what we've got now, and that's a programme that's not propped up what we've got now, and that's a programme that's not propped up by programme that's not propped up by some programme that's not propped up by some sort programme that's not propped up by some sort of programme that's not propped up by some sort of mad programme that's not propped up by some sort of mad Government programme that's not propped up by some sort of mad Government scheme some sort of mad Government scheme that some sort of mad Government scheme that says some sort of mad Government scheme that says subsidise, some sort of mad Government scheme that says subsidise, sup some sort of mad Government scheme that says subsidise, sup sidise, that says subsidise, sup sidise, subsidise. that says subsidise, sup sidise, subsidise. It's that says subsidise, sup sidise, subsidise. It's a that says subsidise, sup sidise, subsidise. It's a -- that says subsidise, sup sidise, subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. that says subsidise, sup sidise, subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows companies subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows companies to subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows companies to go subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows companies to go ahead subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows companies to go ahead and subsidise. It's a -- subsidise. It allows companies to go ahead and do allows companies to go ahead and do the allows companies to go ahead and do the subdivisions allows companies to go ahead and do the subdivisions and allows companies to go ahead and do the subdivisions and has allows companies to go ahead and do the subdivisions and has finance the subdivisions and has finance packages the subdivisions and has finance packages that the subdivisions and has finance packages that people the subdivisions and has finance packages that people can the subdivisions and has finance packages that people can avail packages that people can avail themselves packages that people can avail themselves of. packages that people can avail themselves of. In packages that people can avail themselves of. In the packages that people can avail themselves of. In the end, packages that people can avail themselves of. In the end, it's packages that people can avail themselves of. In the end, it's all themselves of. In the end, it's all about themselves of. In the end, it's all about supply. themselves of. In the end, it's all about supply. No-one themselves of. In the end, it's all about supply. No-one disagrees themselves of. In the end, it's all about supply. No-one disagrees with about supply. No-one disagrees with that. about supply. No-one disagrees with that. But about supply. No-one disagrees with that. But how about supply. No-one disagrees with that. But how the about supply. No-one disagrees with that. But how the supply about supply. No-one disagrees with that. But how the supply is about supply. No-one disagrees with that. But how the supply is created that. But how the supply is created is that. But how the supply is created is crucially that. But how the supply is created is crucially important. that. But how the supply is created is crucially important. Mr that. But how the supply is created is crucially important. Mr Speaker, is crucially important. Mr Speaker, the is crucially important. Mr Speaker, the once-proud is crucially important. Mr Speaker, the once-proud Labour is crucially important. Mr Speaker, the once-proud Labour Party is crucially important. Mr Speaker, the once-proud Labour Party claimed, the once-proud Labour Party claimed, through the once-proud Labour Party claimed, through Michael the once-proud Labour Party claimed, through Michael Joseph the once-proud Labour Party claimed, through Michael Joseph that through Michael Joseph that homeownership through Michael Joseph that homeownership was through Michael Joseph that homeownership was the through Michael Joseph that homeownership was the big through Michael Joseph that homeownership was the big deal, through Michael Joseph that homeownership was the big deal, and homeownership was the big deal, and having homeownership was the big deal, and having a homeownership was the big deal, and having a home homeownership was the big deal, and having a home was homeownership was the big deal, and having a home was a homeownership was the big deal, and having a home was a big homeownership was the big deal, and having a home was a big deal. having a home was a big deal. Nowadays, having a home was a big deal. Nowadays, that's having a home was a big deal. Nowadays, that's only having a home was a big deal. Nowadays, that's only if having a home was a big deal. Nowadays, that's only if the Nowadays, that's only if the Government, Nowadays, that's only if the Government, according Nowadays, that's only if the Government, according to Nowadays, that's only if the Government, according to them, Nowadays, that's only if the Government, according to them, let's Government, according to them, let's you Government, according to them, let's you have Government, according to them, let's you have it. Government, according to them, let's you have it. That Government, according to them, let's you have it. That will Government, according to them, let's you have it. That will not Government, according to them, let's you have it. That will not be Government, according to them, let's you have it. That will not be a you have it. That will not be a recipe you have it. That will not be a recipe that you have it. That will not be a recipe that New you have it. That will not be a recipe that New Zealanders you have it. That will not be a recipe that New Zealanders will you have it. That will not be a recipe that New Zealanders will be recipe that New Zealanders will be impressed recipe that New Zealanders will be impressed with recipe that New Zealanders will be impressed with in recipe that New Zealanders will be impressed with in the recipe that New Zealanders will be impressed with in the coming recipe that New Zealanders will be impressed with in the coming months. impressed with in the coming months. I impressed with in the coming months. I also impressed with in the coming months. I also want impressed with in the coming months. I also want to impressed with in the coming months. I also want to make impressed with in the coming months. I also want to make reference impressed with in the coming months. I also want to make reference to impressed with in the coming months. I also want to make reference to the I also want to make reference to the idea I also want to make reference to the idea that I also want to make reference to the idea that incomes I also want to make reference to the idea that incomes are I also want to make reference to the idea that incomes are going I also want to make reference to the idea that incomes are going to I also want to make reference to the idea that incomes are going to rise idea that incomes are going to rise should idea that incomes are going to rise should there idea that incomes are going to rise should there be idea that incomes are going to rise should there be a idea that incomes are going to rise should there be a Labour idea that incomes are going to rise should there be a Labour Government. should there be a Labour Government. One should there be a Labour Government. One thing should there be a Labour Government. One thing John should there be a Labour Government. One thing John Key should there be a Labour Government. One thing John Key has should there be a Labour Government. One thing John Key has done One thing John Key has done throughout One thing John Key has done throughout his One thing John Key has done throughout his tenure One thing John Key has done throughout his tenure as One thing John Key has done throughout his tenure as PM One thing John Key has done throughout his tenure as PM is One thing John Key has done throughout his tenure as PM is said throughout his tenure as PM is said that throughout his tenure as PM is said that if throughout his tenure as PM is said that if we throughout his tenure as PM is said that if we want throughout his tenure as PM is said that if we want basic throughout his tenure as PM is said that if we want basic incomes throughout his tenure as PM is said that if we want basic incomes in that if we want basic incomes in this that if we want basic incomes in this country that if we want basic incomes in this country to that if we want basic incomes in this country to rise, that if we want basic incomes in this country to rise, then that if we want basic incomes in this country to rise, then there that if we want basic incomes in this country to rise, then there has this country to rise, then there has to this country to rise, then there has to be this country to rise, then there has to be the this country to rise, then there has to be the economic this country to rise, then there has to be the economic incentive this country to rise, then there has to be the economic incentive for to be the economic incentive for jobs to be the economic incentive for jobs to to be the economic incentive for jobs to be to be the economic incentive for jobs to be created to be the economic incentive for jobs to be created and to be the economic incentive for jobs to be created and for to be the economic incentive for jobs to be created and for good jobs to be created and for good wages jobs to be created and for good wages to jobs to be created and for good wages to be jobs to be created and for good wages to be paid. jobs to be created and for good wages to be paid. That jobs to be created and for good wages to be paid. That has jobs to be created and for good wages to be paid. That has meant jobs to be created and for good wages to be paid. That has meant the wages to be paid. That has meant the relentless wages to be paid. That has meant the relentless pursuit wages to be paid. That has meant the relentless pursuit of wages to be paid. That has meant the relentless pursuit of trade wages to be paid. That has meant the relentless pursuit of trade deals wages to be paid. That has meant the relentless pursuit of trade deals T relentless pursuit of trade deals T has relentless pursuit of trade deals T has meant relentless pursuit of trade deals T has meant taking relentless pursuit of trade deals T has meant taking regulation relentless pursuit of trade deals T has meant taking regulation out relentless pursuit of trade deals T has meant taking regulation out of has meant taking regulation out of the has meant taking regulation out of the business has meant taking regulation out of the business activity. has meant taking regulation out of the business activity. It has meant taking regulation out of the business activity. It has has meant taking regulation out of the business activity. It has meant the business activity. It has meant finding the business activity. It has meant finding new the business activity. It has meant finding new markets the business activity. It has meant finding new markets and the business activity. It has meant finding new markets and encouraging finding new markets and encouraging people finding new markets and encouraging people to finding new markets and encouraging people to diversify finding new markets and encouraging people to diversify the finding new markets and encouraging people to diversify the economy. finding new markets and encouraging people to diversify the economy. And people to diversify the economy. And when people to diversify the economy. And when we people to diversify the economy. And when we had people to diversify the economy. And when we had just people to diversify the economy. And when we had just this people to diversify the economy. And when we had just this year, people to diversify the economy. And when we had just this year, the people to diversify the economy. And when we had just this year, the last when we had just this year, the last couple when we had just this year, the last couple of when we had just this year, the last couple of years, when we had just this year, the last couple of years, the when we had just this year, the last couple of years, the dairy when we had just this year, the last couple of years, the dairy price couple of years, the dairy price falling couple of years, the dairy price falling away, couple of years, the dairy price falling away, what couple of years, the dairy price falling away, what of couple of years, the dairy price falling away, what of the couple of years, the dairy price falling away, what of the impact couple of years, the dairy price falling away, what of the impact on falling away, what of the impact on the falling away, what of the impact on the New falling away, what of the impact on the New Zealand falling away, what of the impact on the New Zealand economy? falling away, what of the impact on the New Zealand economy? Dreadful falling away, what of the impact on the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it was the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it was for the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it was for some the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it was for some farmers, the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it was for some farmers, it the New Zealand economy? Dreadful as it was for some farmers, it didn't it was for some farmers, it didn't tip it was for some farmers, it didn't tip our it was for some farmers, it didn't tip our economy it was for some farmers, it didn't tip our economy up it was for some farmers, it didn't tip our economy up because it was for some farmers, it didn't tip our economy up because of it was for some farmers, it didn't tip our economy up because of the tip our economy up because of the diversification, tip our economy up because of the diversification, because tip our economy up because of the diversification, because of tip our economy up because of the diversification, because of the diversification, because of the relentless diversification, because of the relentless focus diversification, because of the relentless focus on diversification, because of the relentless focus on trying diversification, because of the relentless focus on trying to diversification, because of the relentless focus on trying to raise relentless focus on trying to raise incomes relentless focus on trying to raise incomes for relentless focus on trying to raise incomes for New relentless focus on trying to raise incomes for New Zealanders. relentless focus on trying to raise incomes for New Zealanders. At relentless focus on trying to raise incomes for New Zealanders. At a incomes for New Zealanders. At a basic incomes for New Zealanders. At a basic level, incomes for New Zealanders. At a basic level, every incomes for New Zealanders. At a basic level, every year, incomes for New Zealanders. At a basic level, every year, the incomes for New Zealanders. At a basic level, every year, the minimum basic level, every year, the minimum wage basic level, every year, the minimum wage raised basic level, every year, the minimum wage raised under basic level, every year, the minimum wage raised under a basic level, every year, the minimum wage raised under a John basic level, every year, the minimum wage raised under a John Key wage raised under a John Key Government. wage raised under a John Key Government. Never wage raised under a John Key Government. Never happened wage raised under a John Key Government. Never happened for wage raised under a John Key Government. Never happened for nine Government. Never happened for nine years Government. Never happened for nine years under Government. Never happened for nine years under Labour. Government. Never happened for nine years under Labour. Where Government. Never happened for nine years under Labour. Where was Government. Never happened for nine years under Labour. Where was New years under Labour. Where was New Zealand years under Labour. Where was New Zealand First? years under Labour. Where was New Zealand First? Were years under Labour. Where was New Zealand First? Were where years under Labour. Where was New Zealand First? Were where the years under Labour. Where was New Zealand First? Were where the Greens Zealand First? Were where the Greens and Zealand First? Were where the Greens and where Zealand First? Were where the Greens and where were Zealand First? Were where the Greens and where were the Zealand First? Were where the Greens and where were the Labour Zealand First? Were where the Greens and where were the Labour back Zealand First? Were where the Greens and where were the Labour back bench and where were the Labour back bench while and where were the Labour back bench while the and where were the Labour back bench while the Ministers and where were the Labour back bench while the Ministers were and where were the Labour back bench while the Ministers were refusing and where were the Labour back bench while the Ministers were refusing to while the Ministers were refusing to raise while the Ministers were refusing to raise incomes while the Ministers were refusing to raise incomes for while the Ministers were refusing to raise incomes for the while the Ministers were refusing to raise incomes for the poorest while the Ministers were refusing to raise incomes for the poorest of while the Ministers were refusing to raise incomes for the poorest of New raise incomes for the poorest of New Zealanders. raise incomes for the poorest of New Zealanders. This, raise incomes for the poorest of New Zealanders. This, Sir, raise incomes for the poorest of New Zealanders. This, Sir, is raise incomes for the poorest of New Zealanders. This, Sir, is the raise incomes for the poorest of New Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of John Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of John Key. Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of John Key. He Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of John Key. He is Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of John Key. He is a Zealanders. This, Sir, is the record of John Key. He is a very of John Key. He is a very compassionate of John Key. He is a very compassionate man, of John Key. He is a very compassionate man, a of John Key. He is a very compassionate man, a very of John Key. He is a very compassionate man, a very pragmatic compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He knows compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He knows what compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He knows what it's compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He knows what it's like compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He knows what it's like to compassionate man, a very pragmatic man. He knows what it's like to grow man. He knows what it's like to grow up man. He knows what it's like to grow up in man. He knows what it's like to grow up in a man. He knows what it's like to grow up in a household man. He knows what it's like to grow up in a household which man. He knows what it's like to grow up in a household which is man. He knows what it's like to grow up in a household which is not up in a household which is not advantaged. up in a household which is not advantaged. He up in a household which is not advantaged. He knows up in a household which is not advantaged. He knows what up in a household which is not advantaged. He knows what it's up in a household which is not advantaged. He knows what it's like advantaged. He knows what it's like to advantaged. He knows what it's like to see advantaged. He knows what it's like to see others advantaged. He knows what it's like to see others with advantaged. He knows what it's like to see others with more, advantaged. He knows what it's like to see others with more, but advantaged. He knows what it's like to see others with more, but he's to see others with more, but he's never to see others with more, but he's never let to see others with more, but he's never let that to see others with more, but he's never let that get to see others with more, but he's never let that get in to see others with more, but he's never let that get in the to see others with more, but he's never let that get in the way to see others with more, but he's never let that get in the way of to see others with more, but he's never let that get in the way of his never let that get in the way of his drive never let that get in the way of his drive to never let that get in the way of his drive to either never let that get in the way of his drive to either improve never let that get in the way of his drive to either improve himself, never let that get in the way of his drive to either improve himself, his drive to either improve himself, his family drive to either improve himself, his family and drive to either improve himself, his family and his drive to either improve himself, his family and his desire drive to either improve himself, his family and his desire to drive to either improve himself, his family and his desire to have drive to either improve himself, his family and his desire to have that family and his desire to have that for family and his desire to have that for all family and his desire to have that for all New family and his desire to have that for all New Zealanders family and his desire to have that for all New Zealanders as family and his desire to have that for all New Zealanders as well. family and his desire to have that for all New Zealanders as well. Mr for all New Zealanders as well. Mr Speaker, for all New Zealanders as well. Mr Speaker, we for all New Zealanders as well. Mr Speaker, we heard for all New Zealanders as well. Mr Speaker, we heard them for all New Zealanders as well. Mr Speaker, we heard them say for all New Zealanders as well. Mr Speaker, we heard them say that Speaker, we heard them say that under Speaker, we heard them say that under Labour, Speaker, we heard them say that under Labour, education Speaker, we heard them say that under Labour, education will Speaker, we heard them say that under Labour, education will be under Labour, education will be completely under Labour, education will be completely free. under Labour, education will be completely free. Completely under Labour, education will be completely free. Completely free. completely free. Completely free. Well, completely free. Completely free. Well, Sir, completely free. Completely free. Well, Sir, I completely free. Completely free. Well, Sir, I think completely free. Completely free. Well, Sir, I think we completely free. Completely free. Well, Sir, I think we heard completely free. Completely free. Well, Sir, I think we heard that Well, Sir, I think we heard that from Well, Sir, I think we heard that from Labour Well, Sir, I think we heard that from Labour during Well, Sir, I think we heard that from Labour during the Well, Sir, I think we heard that from Labour during the 1980s Well, Sir, I think we heard that from Labour during the 1980s when from Labour during the 1980s when they from Labour during the 1980s when they introduced from Labour during the 1980s when they introduced the from Labour during the 1980s when they introduced the fees from Labour during the 1980s when they introduced the fees for they introduced the fees for students they introduced the fees for students in they introduced the fees for students in tertiary they introduced the fees for students in tertiary education. they introduced the fees for students in tertiary education. I students in tertiary education. I think students in tertiary education. I think we've students in tertiary education. I think we've heard students in tertiary education. I think we've heard it students in tertiary education. I think we've heard it from students in tertiary education. I think we've heard it from Labour think we've heard it from Labour when think we've heard it from Labour when they think we've heard it from Labour when they said, think we've heard it from Labour when they said, tomorrow's think we've heard it from Labour when they said, tomorrow's schools when they said, tomorrow's schools will when they said, tomorrow's schools will be when they said, tomorrow's schools will be some when they said, tomorrow's schools will be some kind when they said, tomorrow's schools will be some kind of when they said, tomorrow's schools will be some kind of Nirvana. when they said, tomorrow's schools will be some kind of Nirvana. You will be some kind of Nirvana. You just will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk in will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk in the will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk in the gate will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk in the gate and will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk in the gate and you will be some kind of Nirvana. You just walk in the gate and you get just walk in the gate and you get conferred just walk in the gate and you get conferred with just walk in the gate and you get conferred with qualifications just walk in the gate and you get conferred with qualifications and conferred with qualifications and you conferred with qualifications and you walk conferred with qualifications and you walk out conferred with qualifications and you walk out with conferred with qualifications and you walk out with a conferred with qualifications and you walk out with a a conferred with qualifications and you walk out with a a wonderful you walk out with a a wonderful life. you walk out with a a wonderful life. Sir, you walk out with a a wonderful life. Sir, this you walk out with a a wonderful life. Sir, this is you walk out with a a wonderful life. Sir, this is a you walk out with a a wonderful life. Sir, this is a Government you walk out with a a wonderful life. Sir, this is a Government that life. Sir, this is a Government that has life. Sir, this is a Government that has focused life. Sir, this is a Government that has focused on life. Sir, this is a Government that has focused on educational has focused on educational achievement. has focused on educational achievement. John has focused on educational achievement. John Key has focused on educational achievement. John Key said has focused on educational achievement. John Key said to has focused on educational achievement. John Key said to his achievement. John Key said to his Cabinet achievement. John Key said to his Cabinet - achievement. John Key said to his Cabinet - we achievement. John Key said to his Cabinet - we cannot achievement. John Key said to his Cabinet - we cannot have achievement. John Key said to his Cabinet - we cannot have young Cabinet - we cannot have young people Cabinet - we cannot have young people who Cabinet - we cannot have young people who cannot Cabinet - we cannot have young people who cannot read Cabinet - we cannot have young people who cannot read and Cabinet - we cannot have young people who cannot read and write. Cabinet - we cannot have young people who cannot read and write. We people who cannot read and write. We cannot people who cannot read and write. We cannot have people who cannot read and write. We cannot have young people who cannot read and write. We cannot have young people people who cannot read and write. We cannot have young people who people who cannot read and write. We cannot have young people who have cannot have young people who have problems cannot have young people who have problems with cannot have young people who have problems with numeracy. cannot have young people who have problems with numeracy. We cannot have young people who have problems with numeracy. We have cannot have young people who have problems with numeracy. We have to problems with numeracy. We have to have problems with numeracy. We have to have a problems with numeracy. We have to have a better problems with numeracy. We have to have a better focus. problems with numeracy. We have to have a better focus. So problems with numeracy. We have to have a better focus. So through have a better focus. So through successive have a better focus. So through successive education have a better focus. So through successive education ministries have a better focus. So through successive education ministries and successive education ministries and his successive education ministries and his Ministers successive education ministries and his Ministers and successive education ministries and his Ministers and his successive education ministries and his Ministers and his particular his Ministers and his particular commitment his Ministers and his particular commitment to his Ministers and his particular commitment to that his Ministers and his particular commitment to that portfolio, his Ministers and his particular commitment to that portfolio, we his Ministers and his particular commitment to that portfolio, we see commitment to that portfolio, we see the commitment to that portfolio, we see the results commitment to that portfolio, we see the results coming commitment to that portfolio, we see the results coming out, commitment to that portfolio, we see the results coming out, the the results coming out, the international the results coming out, the international comparisons the results coming out, the international comparisons for international comparisons for literacy international comparisons for literacy and international comparisons for literacy and numeracy, international comparisons for literacy and numeracy, etc, international comparisons for literacy and numeracy, etc, and international comparisons for literacy and numeracy, etc, and New literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand once literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand once again literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand once again on literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand once again on the literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand once again on the rise. literacy and numeracy, etc, and New Zealand once again on the rise. A Zealand once again on the rise. A bit Zealand once again on the rise. A bit of Zealand once again on the rise. A bit of a Zealand once again on the rise. A bit of a turn Zealand once again on the rise. A bit of a turn around, Zealand once again on the rise. A bit of a turn around, a Zealand once again on the rise. A bit of a turn around, a significant bit of a turn around, a significant turn bit of a turn around, a significant turn around, bit of a turn around, a significant turn around, in bit of a turn around, a significant turn around, in fact, bit of a turn around, a significant turn around, in fact, from bit of a turn around, a significant turn around, in fact, from where bit of a turn around, a significant turn around, in fact, from where we turn around, in fact, from where we were turn around, in fact, from where we were just turn around, in fact, from where we were just a turn around, in fact, from where we were just a few turn around, in fact, from where we were just a few years turn around, in fact, from where we were just a few years ago. turn around, in fact, from where we were just a few years ago. And were just a few years ago. And largely were just a few years ago. And largely due were just a few years ago. And largely due to were just a few years ago. And largely due to the were just a few years ago. And largely due to the fact were just a few years ago. And largely due to the fact that were just a few years ago. And largely due to the fact that a largely due to the fact that a Government largely due to the fact that a Government has largely due to the fact that a Government has a largely due to the fact that a Government has a right largely due to the fact that a Government has a right to largely due to the fact that a Government has a right to demand Government has a right to demand standards Government has a right to demand standards in Government has a right to demand standards in education. Government has a right to demand standards in education. That's standards in education. That's what's standards in education. That's what's happened standards in education. That's what's happened and standards in education. That's what's happened and the what's happened and the beneficiaries what's happened and the beneficiaries are what's happened and the beneficiaries are young what's happened and the beneficiaries are young children. beneficiaries are young children. What beneficiaries are young children. What we've beneficiaries are young children. What we've got beneficiaries are young children. What we've got over beneficiaries are young children. What we've got over there beneficiaries are young children. What we've got over there is beneficiaries are young children. What we've got over there is all What we've got over there is all sorts What we've got over there is all sorts of What we've got over there is all sorts of games What we've got over there is all sorts of games about What we've got over there is all sorts of games about - What we've got over there is all sorts of games about - oh, What we've got over there is all sorts of games about - oh, it's What we've got over there is all sorts of games about - oh, it's not sorts of games about - oh, it's not good, sorts of games about - oh, it's not good, don't sorts of games about - oh, it's not good, don't listen sorts of games about - oh, it's not good, don't listen to sorts of games about - oh, it's not good, don't listen to the sorts of games about - oh, it's not good, don't listen to the stats, good, don't listen to the stats, blah, good, don't listen to the stats, blah, blah, good, don't listen to the stats, blah, blah, blah. good, don't listen to the stats, blah, blah, blah. But good, don't listen to the stats, blah, blah, blah. But if good, don't listen to the stats, blah, blah, blah. But if it good, don't listen to the stats, blah, blah, blah. But if it suits blah, blah, blah. But if it suits them, blah, blah, blah. But if it suits them, they'll blah, blah, blah. But if it suits them, they'll use blah, blah, blah. But if it suits them, they'll use them blah, blah, blah. But if it suits them, they'll use them against blah, blah, blah. But if it suits them, they'll use them against you them, they'll use them against you any them, they'll use them against you any time, them, they'll use them against you any time, or them, they'll use them against you any time, or us. them, they'll use them against you any time, or us. And them, they'll use them against you any time, or us. And I them, they'll use them against you any time, or us. And I think them, they'll use them against you any time, or us. And I think that any time, or us. And I think that they any time, or us. And I think that they need any time, or us. And I think that they need to any time, or us. And I think that they need to have any time, or us. And I think that they need to have a any time, or us. And I think that they need to have a bit any time, or us. And I think that they need to have a bit of any time, or us. And I think that they need to have a bit of a any time, or us. And I think that they need to have a bit of a look any time, or us. And I think that they need to have a bit of a look at they need to have a bit of a look at that they need to have a bit of a look at that particular they need to have a bit of a look at that particular portfolio they need to have a bit of a look at that particular portfolio because that particular portfolio because their that particular portfolio because their record that particular portfolio because their record is that particular portfolio because their record is not that particular portfolio because their record is not tidy. their record is not tidy. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . Finally, <INTERRUPTION> . Finally, let <INTERRUPTION> . Finally, let me <INTERRUPTION> . Finally, let me deal <INTERRUPTION> . Finally, let me deal with <INTERRUPTION> . Finally, let me deal with health. . Finally, let me deal with health. Mr'S . Finally, let me deal with health. Mr'S never . Finally, let me deal with health. Mr'S never been . Finally, let me deal with health. Mr'S never been more . Finally, let me deal with health. Mr'S never been more people . Finally, let me deal with health. Mr'S never been more people getting Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare when Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare when they Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare when they need Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare when they need it Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare when they need it in Mr'S never been more people getting healthcare when they need it in this healthcare when they need it in this country healthcare when they need it in this country as healthcare when they need it in this country as there healthcare when they need it in this country as there are healthcare when they need it in this country as there are now. healthcare when they need it in this country as there are now. And country as there are now. And there's country as there are now. And there's never country as there are now. And there's never been country as there are now. And there's never been a country as there are now. And there's never been a time country as there are now. And there's never been a time when country as there are now. And there's never been a time when the there's never been a time when the commitment there's never been a time when the commitment to there's never been a time when the commitment to health there's never been a time when the commitment to health dollars there's never been a time when the commitment to health dollars has commitment to health dollars has been commitment to health dollars has been as commitment to health dollars has been as strong commitment to health dollars has been as strong as commitment to health dollars has been as strong as it commitment to health dollars has been as strong as it is commitment to health dollars has been as strong as it is at commitment to health dollars has been as strong as it is at the been as strong as it is at the moment. been as strong as it is at the moment. Mr been as strong as it is at the moment. Mr Key, been as strong as it is at the moment. Mr Key, once been as strong as it is at the moment. Mr Key, once again, been as strong as it is at the moment. Mr Key, once again, making moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure that moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure that while moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure that while there moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure that while there was moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure that while there was this moment. Mr Key, once again, making sure that while there was this focus sure that while there was this focus on sure that while there was this focus on having sure that while there was this focus on having a sure that while there was this focus on having a sound sure that while there was this focus on having a sound economy sure that while there was this focus on having a sound economy that sure that while there was this focus on having a sound economy that can on having a sound economy that can provide on having a sound economy that can provide jobs, on having a sound economy that can provide jobs, that on having a sound economy that can provide jobs, that will on having a sound economy that can provide jobs, that will provide provide jobs, that will provide provide provide jobs, that will provide bigger incomes for provide jobs, that will provide bigger incomes for people, provide jobs, that will provide bigger incomes for people, still bigger incomes for people, still insisting bigger incomes for people, still insisting that bigger incomes for people, still insisting that this bigger incomes for people, still insisting that this government bigger incomes for people, still insisting that this government spent insisting that this government spent in insisting that this government spent in core insisting that this government spent in core social insisting that this government spent in core social services. insisting that this government spent in core social services. His insisting that this government spent in core social services. His legacy in core social services. His legacy is in core social services. His legacy is a in core social services. His legacy is a remarkable in core social services. His legacy is a remarkable one. in core social services. His legacy is a remarkable one. He in core social services. His legacy is a remarkable one. He will in core social services. His legacy is a remarkable one. He will be in core social services. His legacy is a remarkable one. He will be in is a remarkable one. He will be in history, is a remarkable one. He will be in history, I'm is a remarkable one. He will be in history, I'm sure, is a remarkable one. He will be in history, I'm sure, recorded is a remarkable one. He will be in history, I'm sure, recorded as is a remarkable one. He will be in history, I'm sure, recorded as one history, I'm sure, recorded as one of history, I'm sure, recorded as one of the history, I'm sure, recorded as one of the great history, I'm sure, recorded as one of the great prime history, I'm sure, recorded as one of the great prime Ministers history, I'm sure, recorded as one of the great prime Ministers of history, I'm sure, recorded as one of the great prime Ministers of this of the great prime Ministers of this country. of the great prime Ministers of this country. He of the great prime Ministers of this country. He is of the great prime Ministers of this country. He is most of the great prime Ministers of this country. He is most definitely of the great prime Ministers of this country. He is most definitely one country. He is most definitely one of country. He is most definitely one of the country. He is most definitely one of the greatest country. He is most definitely one of the greatest leaders country. He is most definitely one of the greatest leaders of country. He is most definitely one of the greatest leaders of the of the greatest leaders of the National of the greatest leaders of the National Party. of the greatest leaders of the National Party. And of the greatest leaders of the National Party. And while of the greatest leaders of the National Party. And while he of the greatest leaders of the National Party. And while he has of the greatest leaders of the National Party. And while he has now National Party. And while he has now decided National Party. And while he has now decided to National Party. And while he has now decided to exit National Party. And while he has now decided to exit the National Party. And while he has now decided to exit the stage, National Party. And while he has now decided to exit the stage, the National Party. And while he has now decided to exit the stage, the scene decided to exit the stage, the scene that decided to exit the stage, the scene that he decided to exit the stage, the scene that he has decided to exit the stage, the scene that he has set, decided to exit the stage, the scene that he has set, the decided to exit the stage, the scene that he has set, the culture decided to exit the stage, the scene that he has set, the culture that decided to exit the stage, the scene that he has set, the culture that he that he has set, the culture that he has that he has set, the culture that he has put that he has set, the culture that he has put in that he has set, the culture that he has put in place that he has set, the culture that he has put in place will that he has set, the culture that he has put in place will endure that he has set, the culture that he has put in place will endure and that he has set, the culture that he has put in place will endure and the has put in place will endure and the fundamentals has put in place will endure and the fundamentals of has put in place will endure and the fundamentals of what's has put in place will endure and the fundamentals of what's been has put in place will endure and the fundamentals of what's been achieved fundamentals of what's been achieved under fundamentals of what's been achieved under his fundamentals of what's been achieved under his ministry, fundamentals of what's been achieved under his ministry, his fundamentals of what's been achieved under his ministry, his prime under his ministry, his prime Ministership, under his ministry, his prime Ministership, will under his ministry, his prime Ministership, will continue under his ministry, his prime Ministership, will continue and under his ministry, his prime Ministership, will continue and be Ministership, will continue and be well Ministership, will continue and be well regarded Ministership, will continue and be well regarded and Ministership, will continue and be well regarded and well Ministership, will continue and be well regarded and well received Ministership, will continue and be well regarded and well received by well regarded and well received by New well regarded and well received by New Zealanders well regarded and well received by New Zealanders in well regarded and well received by New Zealanders in the well regarded and well received by New Zealanders in the coming well regarded and well received by New Zealanders in the coming year. There's There's been There's been a There's been a lot There's been a lot said There's been a lot said in There's been a lot said in this There's been a lot said in this debate There's been a lot said in this debate about There's been a lot said in this debate about John There's been a lot said in this debate about John Key's There's been a lot said in this debate about John Key's legacy There's been a lot said in this debate about John Key's legacy and debate about John Key's legacy and what debate about John Key's legacy and what it debate about John Key's legacy and what it will debate about John Key's legacy and what it will be. debate about John Key's legacy and what it will be. And debate about John Key's legacy and what it will be. And I debate about John Key's legacy and what it will be. And I think debate about John Key's legacy and what it will be. And I think that what it will be. And I think that that what it will be. And I think that that in what it will be. And I think that that in itself what it will be. And I think that that in itself is what it will be. And I think that that in itself is quite what it will be. And I think that that in itself is quite telling. that in itself is quite telling. That that in itself is quite telling. That people that in itself is quite telling. That people have that in itself is quite telling. That people have to that in itself is quite telling. That people have to discuss that in itself is quite telling. That people have to discuss and That people have to discuss and debate That people have to discuss and debate and That people have to discuss and debate and decide That people have to discuss and debate and decide what That people have to discuss and debate and decide what John That people have to discuss and debate and decide what John Key's debate and decide what John Key's legacy debate and decide what John Key's legacy as debate and decide what John Key's legacy as PM debate and decide what John Key's legacy as PM of debate and decide what John Key's legacy as PM of this debate and decide what John Key's legacy as PM of this country debate and decide what John Key's legacy as PM of this country for legacy as PM of this country for eight legacy as PM of this country for eight years legacy as PM of this country for eight years will legacy as PM of this country for eight years will be. legacy as PM of this country for eight years will be. And legacy as PM of this country for eight years will be. And it legacy as PM of this country for eight years will be. And it is eight years will be. And it is strange eight years will be. And it is strange because eight years will be. And it is strange because there eight years will be. And it is strange because there will eight years will be. And it is strange because there will be eight years will be. And it is strange because there will be a strange because there will be a legacy strange because there will be a legacy for strange because there will be a legacy for John strange because there will be a legacy for John Key. strange because there will be a legacy for John Key. Great strange because there will be a legacy for John Key. Great Prime legacy for John Key. Great Prime Ministers legacy for John Key. Great Prime Ministers are legacy for John Key. Great Prime Ministers are remembered legacy for John Key. Great Prime Ministers are remembered in legacy for John Key. Great Prime Ministers are remembered in history. Ministers are remembered in history. John Ministers are remembered in history. John Key Ministers are remembered in history. John Key will Ministers are remembered in history. John Key will not Ministers are remembered in history. John Key will not be Ministers are remembered in history. John Key will not be remembered Ministers are remembered in history. John Key will not be remembered in John Key will not be remembered in history. John Key will not be remembered in history. He John Key will not be remembered in history. He does John Key will not be remembered in history. He does not John Key will not be remembered in history. He does not have John Key will not be remembered in history. He does not have a John Key will not be remembered in history. He does not have a legacy. history. He does not have a legacy. He history. He does not have a legacy. He does history. He does not have a legacy. He does not history. He does not have a legacy. He does not have history. He does not have a legacy. He does not have any history. He does not have a legacy. He does not have any great history. He does not have a legacy. He does not have any great thing He does not have any great thing that He does not have any great thing that he He does not have any great thing that he has He does not have any great thing that he has done He does not have any great thing that he has done and He does not have any great thing that he has done and I He does not have any great thing that he has done and I challenge He does not have any great thing that he has done and I challenge any that he has done and I challenge any member that he has done and I challenge any member on that he has done and I challenge any member on that that he has done and I challenge any member on that side that he has done and I challenge any member on that side of that he has done and I challenge any member on that side of the that he has done and I challenge any member on that side of the house, that he has done and I challenge any member on that side of the house, or member on that side of the house, or this, member on that side of the house, or this, come member on that side of the house, or this, come to member on that side of the house, or this, come to that, member on that side of the house, or this, come to that, to member on that side of the house, or this, come to that, to name member on that side of the house, or this, come to that, to name two this, come to that, to name two great this, come to that, to name two great things this, come to that, to name two great things that this, come to that, to name two great things that John this, come to that, to name two great things that John Key this, come to that, to name two great things that John Key has this, come to that, to name two great things that John Key has done great things that John Key has done in great things that John Key has done in his great things that John Key has done in his eight great things that John Key has done in his eight years great things that John Key has done in his eight years as great things that John Key has done in his eight years as PM great things that John Key has done in his eight years as PM that great things that John Key has done in his eight years as PM that will in his eight years as PM that will go in his eight years as PM that will go down in his eight years as PM that will go down in in his eight years as PM that will go down in history, in his eight years as PM that will go down in history, that in his eight years as PM that will go down in history, that will in his eight years as PM that will go down in history, that will leave go down in history, that will leave him go down in history, that will leave him as go down in history, that will leave him as a go down in history, that will leave him as a household go down in history, that will leave him as a household name? go down in history, that will leave him as a household name? The go down in history, that will leave him as a household name? The likes him as a household name? The likes of him as a household name? The likes of Savage, him as a household name? The likes of Savage, the him as a household name? The likes of Savage, the likes him as a household name? The likes of Savage, the likes of him as a household name? The likes of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. him as a household name? The likes of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a man of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a man of of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a man of that of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a man of that ilk. of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a man of that ilk. We of Savage, the likes of Holyoake. He is now a man of that ilk. We have is now a man of that ilk. We have been is now a man of that ilk. We have been criticised is now a man of that ilk. We have been criticised in is now a man of that ilk. We have been criticised in this is now a man of that ilk. We have been criticised in this corner is now a man of that ilk. We have been criticised in this corner of been criticised in this corner of the been criticised in this corner of the house been criticised in this corner of the house for been criticised in this corner of the house for being, been criticised in this corner of the house for being, perhaps, been criticised in this corner of the house for being, perhaps, less the house for being, perhaps, less gracious the house for being, perhaps, less gracious than the house for being, perhaps, less gracious than some the house for being, perhaps, less gracious than some other the house for being, perhaps, less gracious than some other speakers the house for being, perhaps, less gracious than some other speakers in gracious than some other speakers in noting gracious than some other speakers in noting the gracious than some other speakers in noting the departure gracious than some other speakers in noting the departure of gracious than some other speakers in noting the departure of a gracious than some other speakers in noting the departure of a man gracious than some other speakers in noting the departure of a man who noting the departure of a man who has noting the departure of a man who has spent noting the departure of a man who has spent eight noting the departure of a man who has spent eight years noting the departure of a man who has spent eight years in noting the departure of a man who has spent eight years in the noting the departure of a man who has spent eight years in the top has spent eight years in the top job. has spent eight years in the top job. I has spent eight years in the top job. I think has spent eight years in the top job. I think the has spent eight years in the top job. I think the response has spent eight years in the top job. I think the response has has spent eight years in the top job. I think the response has been job. I think the response has been appropriate. job. I think the response has been appropriate. In job. I think the response has been appropriate. In 2008, job. I think the response has been appropriate. In 2008, when job. I think the response has been appropriate. In 2008, when John job. I think the response has been appropriate. In 2008, when John Key appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into power, appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into power, I appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into power, I voted appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into power, I voted for appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into power, I voted for him. appropriate. In 2008, when John Key came into power, I voted for him. I came into power, I voted for him. I was came into power, I voted for him. I was not came into power, I voted for him. I was not a came into power, I voted for him. I was not a member came into power, I voted for him. I was not a member of came into power, I voted for him. I was not a member of New came into power, I voted for him. I was not a member of New Zealand was not a member of New Zealand First was not a member of New Zealand First in was not a member of New Zealand First in those was not a member of New Zealand First in those days. was not a member of New Zealand First in those days. I was not a member of New Zealand First in those days. I had was not a member of New Zealand First in those days. I had sat First in those days. I had sat through First in those days. I had sat through the First in those days. I had sat through the Helen First in those days. I had sat through the Helen Clark First in those days. I had sat through the Helen Clark years First in those days. I had sat through the Helen Clark years and through the Helen Clark years and been through the Helen Clark years and been so through the Helen Clark years and been so tragically through the Helen Clark years and been so tragically disappointed through the Helen Clark years and been so tragically disappointed that been so tragically disappointed that having been so tragically disappointed that having grown been so tragically disappointed that having grown up been so tragically disappointed that having grown up as been so tragically disappointed that having grown up as a been so tragically disappointed that having grown up as a social having grown up as a social predator, having grown up as a social predator, I having grown up as a social predator, I changed having grown up as a social predator, I changed by having grown up as a social predator, I changed by allegiance having grown up as a social predator, I changed by allegiance to predator, I changed by allegiance to National predator, I changed by allegiance to National because predator, I changed by allegiance to National because I predator, I changed by allegiance to National because I felt predator, I changed by allegiance to National because I felt they predator, I changed by allegiance to National because I felt they offered National because I felt they offered hope, National because I felt they offered hope, and National because I felt they offered hope, and I National because I felt they offered hope, and I listened National because I felt they offered hope, and I listened to National because I felt they offered hope, and I listened to John National because I felt they offered hope, and I listened to John Key National because I felt they offered hope, and I listened to John Key on hope, and I listened to John Key on it hope, and I listened to John Key on it and hope, and I listened to John Key on it and I hope, and I listened to John Key on it and I listened hope, and I listened to John Key on it and I listened to hope, and I listened to John Key on it and I listened to what hope, and I listened to John Key on it and I listened to what Nationals it and I listened to what Nationals were it and I listened to what Nationals were saying it and I listened to what Nationals were saying and it and I listened to what Nationals were saying and I it and I listened to what Nationals were saying and I thought it and I listened to what Nationals were saying and I thought that it and I listened to what Nationals were saying and I thought that they were saying and I thought that they offered were saying and I thought that they offered a were saying and I thought that they offered a great were saying and I thought that they offered a great change were saying and I thought that they offered a great change and were saying and I thought that they offered a great change and a were saying and I thought that they offered a great change and a great offered a great change and a great hope offered a great change and a great hope for offered a great change and a great hope for New offered a great change and a great hope for New Zealand offered a great change and a great hope for New Zealand for offered a great change and a great hope for New Zealand for the offered a great change and a great hope for New Zealand for the future, hope for New Zealand for the future, for hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for my hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for my kids. hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for my kids. And hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for my kids. And I hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for my kids. And I was hope for New Zealand for the future, for me, for my kids. And I was so for me, for my kids. And I was so sorely for me, for my kids. And I was so sorely disappointed for me, for my kids. And I was so sorely disappointed with for me, for my kids. And I was so sorely disappointed with what for me, for my kids. And I was so sorely disappointed with what was sorely disappointed with what was delivered sorely disappointed with what was delivered that sorely disappointed with what was delivered that I sorely disappointed with what was delivered that I joined sorely disappointed with what was delivered that I joined New sorely disappointed with what was delivered that I joined New Zealand delivered that I joined New Zealand First delivered that I joined New Zealand First and delivered that I joined New Zealand First and here delivered that I joined New Zealand First and here I delivered that I joined New Zealand First and here I am. delivered that I joined New Zealand First and here I am. Because delivered that I joined New Zealand First and here I am. Because there First and here I am. Because there is First and here I am. Because there is a First and here I am. Because there is a party First and here I am. Because there is a party in First and here I am. Because there is a party in this First and here I am. Because there is a party in this house First and here I am. Because there is a party in this house that First and here I am. Because there is a party in this house that says is a party in this house that says the is a party in this house that says the things is a party in this house that says the things that is a party in this house that says the things that the is a party in this house that says the things that the National is a party in this house that says the things that the National Party the things that the National Party of the things that the National Party of old the things that the National Party of old used the things that the National Party of old used to the things that the National Party of old used to say. the things that the National Party of old used to say. And the things that the National Party of old used to say. And it's the things that the National Party of old used to say. And it's New of old used to say. And it's New Zealand of old used to say. And it's New Zealand First. of old used to say. And it's New Zealand First. And of old used to say. And it's New Zealand First. And there of old used to say. And it's New Zealand First. And there is of old used to say. And it's New Zealand First. And there is a of old used to say. And it's New Zealand First. And there is a great Zealand First. And there is a great leader Zealand First. And there is a great leader in Zealand First. And there is a great leader in this Zealand First. And there is a great leader in this house Zealand First. And there is a great leader in this house who Zealand First. And there is a great leader in this house who will Zealand First. And there is a great leader in this house who will be leader in this house who will be remembered leader in this house who will be remembered through leader in this house who will be remembered through history, leader in this house who will be remembered through history, and remembered through history, and that's remembered through history, and that's Winston remembered through history, and that's Winston Peters. that's Winston Peters. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . And <INTERRUPTION> . And you <INTERRUPTION> . And you may <INTERRUPTION> . And you may laugh <INTERRUPTION> . And you may laugh now, <INTERRUPTION> . And you may laugh now, but <INTERRUPTION> . And you may laugh now, but change . And you may laugh now, but change is . And you may laugh now, but change is sweeping . And you may laugh now, but change is sweeping the . And you may laugh now, but change is sweeping the world. . And you may laugh now, but change is sweeping the world. We . And you may laugh now, but change is sweeping the world. We have . And you may laugh now, but change is sweeping the world. We have seen is sweeping the world. We have seen great is sweeping the world. We have seen great upsets. is sweeping the world. We have seen great upsets. In is sweeping the world. We have seen great upsets. In Canada, is sweeping the world. We have seen great upsets. In Canada, the is sweeping the world. We have seen great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party went great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party went from great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party went from being great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party went from being a great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party went from being a third great upsets. In Canada, the Liberal Party went from being a third party Party went from being a third party to Party went from being a third party to being Party went from being a third party to being a Party went from being a third party to being a majority Party went from being a third party to being a majority government. Party went from being a third party to being a majority government. In to being a majority government. In the to being a majority government. In the UK, to being a majority government. In the UK, Brexit to being a majority government. In the UK, Brexit triumphed. to being a majority government. In the UK, Brexit triumphed. In to being a majority government. In the UK, Brexit triumphed. In the the UK, Brexit triumphed. In the United the UK, Brexit triumphed. In the United States, the UK, Brexit triumphed. In the United States, Trump the UK, Brexit triumphed. In the United States, Trump has the UK, Brexit triumphed. In the United States, Trump has triumphed. United States, Trump has triumphed. And United States, Trump has triumphed. And at United States, Trump has triumphed. And at every United States, Trump has triumphed. And at every turn, United States, Trump has triumphed. And at every turn, at United States, Trump has triumphed. And at every turn, at every United States, Trump has triumphed. And at every turn, at every turn, And at every turn, at every turn, And at every turn, at every turn, And at every turn, at every turn, they have And at every turn, at every turn, they have confounded And at every turn, at every turn, they have confounded the And at every turn, at every turn, they have confounded the pundits And at every turn, at every turn, they have confounded the pundits and they have confounded the pundits and they they have confounded the pundits and they have they have confounded the pundits and they have confounded they have confounded the pundits and they have confounded the they have confounded the pundits and they have confounded the pollsters they have confounded the pollsters and they have confounded the pollsters and it they have confounded the pollsters and it has they have confounded the pollsters and it has been they have confounded the pollsters and it has been the they have confounded the pollsters and it has been the real they have confounded the pollsters and it has been the real people they have confounded the pollsters and it has been the real people who and it has been the real people who have and it has been the real people who have spoken and it has been the real people who have spoken up and it has been the real people who have spoken up and and it has been the real people who have spoken up and spoken and it has been the real people who have spoken up and spoken out, and it has been the real people who have spoken up and spoken out, and have spoken up and spoken out, and in have spoken up and spoken out, and in the have spoken up and spoken out, and in the election have spoken up and spoken out, and in the election coming have spoken up and spoken out, and in the election coming next have spoken up and spoken out, and in the election coming next year, in the election coming next year, that in the election coming next year, that is in the election coming next year, that is what in the election coming next year, that is what will in the election coming next year, that is what will happen in the election coming next year, that is what will happen in in the election coming next year, that is what will happen in New that is what will happen in New Zealand that is what will happen in New Zealand and that is what will happen in New Zealand and John that is what will happen in New Zealand and John Key that is what will happen in New Zealand and John Key knows that is what will happen in New Zealand and John Key knows it. that is what will happen in New Zealand and John Key knows it. He Zealand and John Key knows it. He has Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen the Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen the writing Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen the writing on Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen the writing on the Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen the writing on the wall. Zealand and John Key knows it. He has seen the writing on the wall. He has seen the writing on the wall. He has has seen the writing on the wall. He has seen has seen the writing on the wall. He has seen the has seen the writing on the wall. He has seen the juggernaut has seen the writing on the wall. He has seen the juggernaut approaching. has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the size has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the size of has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the size of the has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the size of the dead has seen the juggernaut approaching. He has seen the size of the dead rat He has seen the size of the dead rat that He has seen the size of the dead rat that he's He has seen the size of the dead rat that he's going He has seen the size of the dead rat that he's going to He has seen the size of the dead rat that he's going to have He has seen the size of the dead rat that he's going to have to He has seen the size of the dead rat that he's going to have to swallow that he's going to have to swallow and that he's going to have to swallow and he that he's going to have to swallow and he can't that he's going to have to swallow and he can't stand that he's going to have to swallow and he can't stand that that he's going to have to swallow and he can't stand that size. that he's going to have to swallow and he can't stand that size. And and he can't stand that size. And he's and he can't stand that size. And he's not and he can't stand that size. And he's not going and he can't stand that size. And he's not going to and he can't stand that size. And he's not going to do and he can't stand that size. And he's not going to do it. and he can't stand that size. And he's not going to do it. And and he can't stand that size. And he's not going to do it. And he's and he can't stand that size. And he's not going to do it. And he's a he's not going to do it. And he's a trader. he's not going to do it. And he's a trader. First he's not going to do it. And he's a trader. First and he's not going to do it. And he's a trader. First and foremost. he's not going to do it. And he's a trader. First and foremost. The he's not going to do it. And he's a trader. First and foremost. The man trader. First and foremost. The man is trader. First and foremost. The man is a trader. First and foremost. The man is a trait trader. First and foremost. The man is a trait trader. trader. First and foremost. The man is a trait trader. He trader. First and foremost. The man is a trait trader. He know trader. First and foremost. The man is a trait trader. He know -- trader. First and foremost. The man is a trait trader. He know -- a is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. He is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. He knows is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. He knows when is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. He knows when to is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. He knows when to buy is a trait trader. He know -- a trader. He knows when to buy and trader. He knows when to buy and when trader. He knows when to buy and when to trader. He knows when to buy and when to sell. trader. He knows when to buy and when to sell. He trader. He knows when to buy and when to sell. He knows trader. He knows when to buy and when to sell. He knows that trader. He knows when to buy and when to sell. He knows that this trader. He knows when to buy and when to sell. He knows that this is when to sell. He knows that this is the when to sell. He knows that this is the time when to sell. He knows that this is the time to when to sell. He knows that this is the time to sell, when to sell. He knows that this is the time to sell, this when to sell. He knows that this is the time to sell, this is when to sell. He knows that this is the time to sell, this is the when to sell. He knows that this is the time to sell, this is the time the time to sell, this is the time to the time to sell, this is the time to get the time to sell, this is the time to get out. the time to sell, this is the time to get out. He's the time to sell, this is the time to get out. He's cutting the time to sell, this is the time to get out. He's cutting and the time to sell, this is the time to get out. He's cutting and running to get out. He's cutting and running while to get out. He's cutting and running while it's to get out. He's cutting and running while it's a to get out. He's cutting and running while it's a good to get out. He's cutting and running while it's a good time to get out. He's cutting and running while it's a good time for to get out. He's cutting and running while it's a good time for him. to get out. He's cutting and running while it's a good time for him. And while it's a good time for him. And you while it's a good time for him. And you can while it's a good time for him. And you can say while it's a good time for him. And you can say anything while it's a good time for him. And you can say anything you while it's a good time for him. And you can say anything you like. while it's a good time for him. And you can say anything you like. The you can say anything you like. The other you can say anything you like. The other side you can say anything you like. The other side can you can say anything you like. The other side can say you can say anything you like. The other side can say anything you can say anything you like. The other side can say anything they other side can say anything they like other side can say anything they like about other side can say anything they like about it other side can say anything they like about it being other side can say anything they like about it being a other side can say anything they like about it being a strategic like about it being a strategic decision. like about it being a strategic decision. They like about it being a strategic decision. They can like about it being a strategic decision. They can say like about it being a strategic decision. They can say that like about it being a strategic decision. They can say that he's decision. They can say that he's leaving decision. They can say that he's leaving a decision. They can say that he's leaving a party decision. They can say that he's leaving a party in decision. They can say that he's leaving a party in good decision. They can say that he's leaving a party in good shape. decision. They can say that he's leaving a party in good shape. At leaving a party in good shape. At the leaving a party in good shape. At the end leaving a party in good shape. At the end of leaving a party in good shape. At the end of the leaving a party in good shape. At the end of the day, leaving a party in good shape. At the end of the day, he's leaving a party in good shape. At the end of the day, he's leaving leaving a party in good shape. At the end of the day, he's leaving the the end of the day, he's leaving the party. the end of the day, he's leaving the party. And the end of the day, he's leaving the party. And he's the end of the day, he's leaving the party. And he's leaving the end of the day, he's leaving the party. And he's leaving them the end of the day, he's leaving the party. And he's leaving them two party. And he's leaving them two weeks party. And he's leaving them two weeks out party. And he's leaving them two weeks out from party. And he's leaving them two weeks out from the party. And he's leaving them two weeks out from the Christmas party. And he's leaving them two weeks out from the Christmas break. weeks out from the Christmas break. And weeks out from the Christmas break. And he's weeks out from the Christmas break. And he's leaving weeks out from the Christmas break. And he's leaving them, weeks out from the Christmas break. And he's leaving them, effectively, And he's leaving them, effectively, six And he's leaving them, effectively, six months And he's leaving them, effectively, six months of And he's leaving them, effectively, six months of campaigning And he's leaving them, effectively, six months of campaigning with And he's leaving them, effectively, six months of campaigning with a And he's leaving them, effectively, six months of campaigning with a new six months of campaigning with a new leader six months of campaigning with a new leader coming six months of campaigning with a new leader coming into six months of campaigning with a new leader coming into an six months of campaigning with a new leader coming into an election six months of campaigning with a new leader coming into an election when leader coming into an election when their leader coming into an election when their popularity leader coming into an election when their popularity has leader coming into an election when their popularity has peaked, leader coming into an election when their popularity has peaked, when their popularity has peaked, when they're their popularity has peaked, when they're on their popularity has peaked, when they're on the their popularity has peaked, when they're on the slide their popularity has peaked, when they're on the slide and their popularity has peaked, when they're on the slide and when their popularity has peaked, when they're on the slide and when the they're on the slide and when the chickens they're on the slide and when the chickens are they're on the slide and when the chickens are going they're on the slide and when the chickens are going going they're on the slide and when the chickens are going going to they're on the slide and when the chickens are going going to come chickens are going going to come home chickens are going going to come home to chickens are going going to come home to roostment chickens are going going to come home to roostment and chickens are going going to come home to roostment and we chickens are going going to come home to roostment and we know chickens are going going to come home to roostment and we know this home to roostment and we know this in home to roostment and we know this in New home to roostment and we know this in New Zealand home to roostment and we know this in New Zealand First home to roostment and we know this in New Zealand First because home to roostment and we know this in New Zealand First because we home to roostment and we know this in New Zealand First because we talk in New Zealand First because we talk to in New Zealand First because we talk to the in New Zealand First because we talk to the people. in New Zealand First because we talk to the people. The in New Zealand First because we talk to the people. The Rt in New Zealand First because we talk to the people. The Rt Honerable to the people. The Rt Honerable Winston to the people. The Rt Honerable Winston Peters to the people. The Rt Honerable Winston Peters fills to the people. The Rt Honerable Winston Peters fills halls to the people. The Rt Honerable Winston Peters fills halls up to the people. The Rt Honerable Winston Peters fills halls up and Winston Peters fills halls up and down Winston Peters fills halls up and down this Winston Peters fills halls up and down this country. Winston Peters fills halls up and down this country. 220 Winston Peters fills halls up and down this country. 220 last Winston Peters fills halls up and down this country. 220 last night. down this country. 220 last night. We down this country. 220 last night. We had down this country. 220 last night. We had 300 down this country. 220 last night. We had 300 in down this country. 220 last night. We had 300 in Rangiara. down this country. 220 last night. We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 down this country. 220 last night. We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in down this country. 220 last night. We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You never We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You never hear We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You never hear about We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You never hear about that We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You never hear about that in We had 300 in Rangiara. 220 in Gore. You never hear about that in the You never hear about that in the media, You never hear about that in the media, in You never hear about that in the media, in the You never hear about that in the media, in the mainstream You never hear about that in the media, in the mainstream media. You never hear about that in the media, in the mainstream media. But media, in the mainstream media. But you media, in the mainstream media. But you know media, in the mainstream media. But you know when media, in the mainstream media. But you know when you're media, in the mainstream media. But you know when you're there media, in the mainstream media. But you know when you're there and media, in the mainstream media. But you know when you're there and you you know when you're there and you hear you know when you're there and you hear about you know when you're there and you hear about it you know when you're there and you hear about it from you know when you're there and you hear about it from people you know when you're there and you hear about it from people who you know when you're there and you hear about it from people who were hear about it from people who were there hear about it from people who were there and hear about it from people who were there and you hear about it from people who were there and you read hear about it from people who were there and you read about hear about it from people who were there and you read about it hear about it from people who were there and you read about it on there and you read about it on social there and you read about it on social media there and you read about it on social media and there and you read about it on social media and that there and you read about it on social media and that is there and you read about it on social media and that is what there and you read about it on social media and that is what people social media and that is what people are social media and that is what people are saying social media and that is what people are saying around social media and that is what people are saying around the social media and that is what people are saying around the country social media and that is what people are saying around the country right are saying around the country right now. are saying around the country right now. That are saying around the country right now. That is are saying around the country right now. That is the are saying around the country right now. That is the undercurrent are saying around the country right now. That is the undercurrent that now. That is the undercurrent that is now. That is the undercurrent that is flowing now. That is the undercurrent that is flowing through. now. That is the undercurrent that is flowing through. It now. That is the undercurrent that is flowing through. It is now. That is the undercurrent that is flowing through. It is what is flowing through. It is what happened is flowing through. It is what happened in is flowing through. It is what happened in the is flowing through. It is what happened in the UK, is flowing through. It is what happened in the UK, it's is flowing through. It is what happened in the UK, it's what happened in the UK, it's what happened happened in the UK, it's what happened in happened in the UK, it's what happened in the happened in the UK, it's what happened in the US, happened in the UK, it's what happened in the US, it's happened in the UK, it's what happened in the US, it's what happened in the US, it's what happened happened in the US, it's what happened in happened in the US, it's what happened in Canada, happened in the US, it's what happened in Canada, it's happened in the US, it's what happened in Canada, it's what happened in Canada, it's what happened happened in Canada, it's what happened in happened in Canada, it's what happened in the happened in Canada, it's what happened in the election happened in Canada, it's what happened in the election in happened in the election in Australia happened in the election in Australia and happened in the election in Australia and it happened in the election in Australia and it is happened in the election in Australia and it is going happened in the election in Australia and it is going to happened in the election in Australia and it is going to happen Australia and it is going to happen here. Australia and it is going to happen here. And Australia and it is going to happen here. And John Australia and it is going to happen here. And John Key, Australia and it is going to happen here. And John Key, credit Australia and it is going to happen here. And John Key, credit where here. And John Key, credit where it's here. And John Key, credit where it's due, here. And John Key, credit where it's due, is here. And John Key, credit where it's due, is no here. And John Key, credit where it's due, is no fool. here. And John Key, credit where it's due, is no fool. He here. And John Key, credit where it's due, is no fool. He can here. And John Key, credit where it's due, is no fool. He can see it's due, is no fool. He can see what it's due, is no fool. He can see what is it's due, is no fool. He can see what is going it's due, is no fool. He can see what is going to it's due, is no fool. He can see what is going to happen it's due, is no fool. He can see what is going to happen and it's due, is no fool. He can see what is going to happen and he's what is going to happen and he's getting what is going to happen and he's getting out what is going to happen and he's getting out while what is going to happen and he's getting out while the what is going to happen and he's getting out while the going what is going to happen and he's getting out while the going is what is going to happen and he's getting out while the going is good. getting out while the going is good. Every getting out while the going is good. Every political getting out while the going is good. Every political career getting out while the going is good. Every political career comes getting out while the going is good. Every political career comes to getting out while the going is good. Every political career comes to an Every political career comes to an end Every political career comes to an end one Every political career comes to an end one way Every political career comes to an end one way or Every political career comes to an end one way or another. Every political career comes to an end one way or another. Most Every political career comes to an end one way or another. Most of Every political career comes to an end one way or another. Most of them end one way or another. Most of them end end one way or another. Most of them end in end one way or another. Most of them end in igmony. end one way or another. Most of them end in igmony. So end one way or another. Most of them end in igmony. So to end one way or another. Most of them end in igmony. So to be end one way or another. Most of them end in igmony. So to be able end one way or another. Most of them end in igmony. So to be able to end in igmony. So to be able to choose end in igmony. So to be able to choose the end in igmony. So to be able to choose the time end in igmony. So to be able to choose the time that end in igmony. So to be able to choose the time that you end in igmony. So to be able to choose the time that you go end in igmony. So to be able to choose the time that you go is, choose the time that you go is, perhaps, choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a credit choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a credit to choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a credit to the choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a credit to the man. choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a credit to the man. But choose the time that you go is, perhaps, a credit to the man. But it perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be said perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be said that perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be said that he perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be said that he is perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be said that he is leaving perhaps, a credit to the man. But it not be said that he is leaving his not be said that he is leaving his party not be said that he is leaving his party in not be said that he is leaving his party in the not be said that he is leaving his party in the best not be said that he is leaving his party in the best of not be said that he is leaving his party in the best of states. not be said that he is leaving his party in the best of states. He party in the best of states. He should party in the best of states. He should have party in the best of states. He should have announced party in the best of states. He should have announced a party in the best of states. He should have announced a year party in the best of states. He should have announced a year ago should have announced a year ago that should have announced a year ago that he should have announced a year ago that he was should have announced a year ago that he was not should have announced a year ago that he was not going should have announced a year ago that he was not going to should have announced a year ago that he was not going to complete should have announced a year ago that he was not going to complete a that he was not going to complete a fourth that he was not going to complete a fourth term. that he was not going to complete a fourth term. He that he was not going to complete a fourth term. He could that he was not going to complete a fourth term. He could have that he was not going to complete a fourth term. He could have led that he was not going to complete a fourth term. He could have led his fourth term. He could have led his party fourth term. He could have led his party into fourth term. He could have led his party into an fourth term. He could have led his party into an election fourth term. He could have led his party into an election and fourth term. He could have led his party into an election and told fourth term. He could have led his party into an election and told the party into an election and told the people party into an election and told the people and party into an election and told the people and told party into an election and told the people and told his party into an election and told the people and told his party party into an election and told the people and told his party that party into an election and told the people and told his party that he people and told his party that he was people and told his party that he was going people and told his party that he was going to people and told his party that he was going to pull people and told his party that he was going to pull out people and told his party that he was going to pull out a people and told his party that he was going to pull out a year people and told his party that he was going to pull out a year or people and told his party that he was going to pull out a year or a was going to pull out a year or a year was going to pull out a year or a year and was going to pull out a year or a year and a was going to pull out a year or a year and a half was going to pull out a year or a year and a half or was going to pull out a year or a year and a half or two was going to pull out a year or a year and a half or two years was going to pull out a year or a year and a half or two years into year and a half or two years into another year and a half or two years into another term year and a half or two years into another term if year and a half or two years into another term if he'd year and a half or two years into another term if he'd won. year and a half or two years into another term if he'd won. That year and a half or two years into another term if he'd won. That would another term if he'd won. That would have another term if he'd won. That would have been another term if he'd won. That would have been a another term if he'd won. That would have been a more another term if he'd won. That would have been a more honest another term if he'd won. That would have been a more honest thing another term if he'd won. That would have been a more honest thing to another term if he'd won. That would have been a more honest thing to do. have been a more honest thing to do. But have been a more honest thing to do. But no, have been a more honest thing to do. But no, instead, have been a more honest thing to do. But no, instead, after have been a more honest thing to do. But no, instead, after eight have been a more honest thing to do. But no, instead, after eight years But no, instead, after eight years of But no, instead, after eight years of lots But no, instead, after eight years of lots of But no, instead, after eight years of lots of horse But no, instead, after eight years of lots of horse trading But no, instead, after eight years of lots of horse trading and But no, instead, after eight years of lots of horse trading and very of lots of horse trading and very little of lots of horse trading and very little else of lots of horse trading and very little else and of lots of horse trading and very little else and lots of lots of horse trading and very little else and lots of of lots of horse trading and very little else and lots of noise of lots of horse trading and very little else and lots of noise and little else and lots of noise and nothing little else and lots of noise and nothing to little else and lots of noise and nothing to show little else and lots of noise and nothing to show in little else and lots of noise and nothing to show in the little else and lots of noise and nothing to show in the way little else and lots of noise and nothing to show in the way of little else and lots of noise and nothing to show in the way of a nothing to show in the way of a tangible nothing to show in the way of a tangible achievement, nothing to show in the way of a tangible achievement, he's nothing to show in the way of a tangible achievement, he's decided tangible achievement, he's decided this tangible achievement, he's decided this is tangible achievement, he's decided this is the tangible achievement, he's decided this is the time tangible achievement, he's decided this is the time to tangible achievement, he's decided this is the time to cut tangible achievement, he's decided this is the time to cut and tangible achievement, he's decided this is the time to cut and run, this is the time to cut and run, this this is the time to cut and run, this is this is the time to cut and run, this is the this is the time to cut and run, this is the time this is the time to cut and run, this is the time to this is the time to cut and run, this is the time to hit this is the time to cut and run, this is the time to hit the this is the time to cut and run, this is the time to hit the salt this is the time to cut and run, this is the time to hit the salt and this is the time to hit the salt and he's this is the time to hit the salt and he's bailing this is the time to hit the salt and he's bailing and this is the time to hit the salt and he's bailing and he's this is the time to hit the salt and he's bailing and he's getting this is the time to hit the salt and he's bailing and he's getting out he's bailing and he's getting out and he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll is he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll is go he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll is go off he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll is go off to he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll is go off to Hawaii he's bailing and he's getting out and he'll is go off to Hawaii and and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play golf and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play golf with and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play golf with Obama and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play golf with Obama and and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play golf with Obama and talk and he'll is go off to Hawaii and play golf with Obama and talk about play golf with Obama and talk about the play golf with Obama and talk about the old play golf with Obama and talk about the old days play golf with Obama and talk about the old days weapon play golf with Obama and talk about the old days weapon they play golf with Obama and talk about the old days weapon they used play golf with Obama and talk about the old days weapon they used to play golf with Obama and talk about the old days weapon they used to be the old days weapon they used to be in the old days weapon they used to be in power. the old days weapon they used to be in power. And the old days weapon they used to be in power. And in the old days weapon they used to be in power. And in a the old days weapon they used to be in power. And in a year the old days weapon they used to be in power. And in a year or the old days weapon they used to be in power. And in a year or so, the old days weapon they used to be in power. And in a year or so, he'll in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick up in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick up a in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick up a knighthood in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick up a knighthood and in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick up a knighthood and that in power. And in a year or so, he'll pick up a knighthood and that will pick up a knighthood and that will be pick up a knighthood and that will be the pick up a knighthood and that will be the end pick up a knighthood and that will be the end of pick up a knighthood and that will be the end of it. pick up a knighthood and that will be the end of it. But pick up a knighthood and that will be the end of it. But I'll pick up a knighthood and that will be the end of it. But I'll say pick up a knighthood and that will be the end of it. But I'll say this be the end of it. But I'll say this again, be the end of it. But I'll say this again, Mr be the end of it. But I'll say this again, Mr Speaker. be the end of it. But I'll say this again, Mr Speaker. Great be the end of it. But I'll say this again, Mr Speaker. Great prime again, Mr Speaker. Great prime Ministers again, Mr Speaker. Great prime Ministers are again, Mr Speaker. Great prime Ministers are recorded again, Mr Speaker. Great prime Ministers are recorded in again, Mr Speaker. Great prime Ministers are recorded in the again, Mr Speaker. Great prime Ministers are recorded in the anals Ministers are recorded in the anals of Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Love Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Love it Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Love it or Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Love it or hate Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Love it or hate it, Ministers are recorded in the anals of history. Love it or hate it, in of history. Love it or hate it, in ten of history. Love it or hate it, in ten years of history. Love it or hate it, in ten years time, of history. Love it or hate it, in ten years time, or of history. Love it or hate it, in ten years time, or 20 of history. Love it or hate it, in ten years time, or 20 years of history. Love it or hate it, in ten years time, or 20 years time, ten years time, or 20 years time, people ten years time, or 20 years time, people will ten years time, or 20 years time, people will still ten years time, or 20 years time, people will still be ten years time, or 20 years time, people will still be talking ten years time, or 20 years time, people will still be talking about people will still be talking about Helen people will still be talking about Helen Clark. people will still be talking about Helen Clark. In people will still be talking about Helen Clark. In 50 people will still be talking about Helen Clark. In 50 years people will still be talking about Helen Clark. In 50 years time, people will still be talking about Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they will Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they will still Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they will still be Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they will still be talking Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they will still be talking about Helen Clark. In 50 years time, they will still be talking about Rob will still be talking about Rob Muldoon. will still be talking about Rob Muldoon. 100 will still be talking about Rob Muldoon. 100 years will still be talking about Rob Muldoon. 100 years from will still be talking about Rob Muldoon. 100 years from now, will still be talking about Rob Muldoon. 100 years from now, people Muldoon. 100 years from now, people studying Muldoon. 100 years from now, people studying history Muldoon. 100 years from now, people studying history will Muldoon. 100 years from now, people studying history will learn Muldoon. 100 years from now, people studying history will learn about studying history will learn about Winston studying history will learn about Winston Peters. studying history will learn about Winston Peters. But studying history will learn about Winston Peters. But five studying history will learn about Winston Peters. But five right studying history will learn about Winston Peters. But five right from Winston Peters. But five right from now, Winston Peters. But five right from now, people Winston Peters. But five right from now, people will Winston Peters. But five right from now, people will be Winston Peters. But five right from now, people will be saying, Winston Peters. But five right from now, people will be saying, John now, people will be saying, John who? now, people will be saying, John who? Because now, people will be saying, John who? Because he's now, people will be saying, John who? Because he's a now, people will be saying, John who? Because he's a grey now, people will be saying, John who? Because he's a grey man. who? Because he's a grey man. Because who? Because he's a grey man. Because he's who? Because he's a grey man. Because he's a who? Because he's a grey man. Because he's a lightweight. who? Because he's a grey man. Because he's a lightweight. Because Because he's a lightweight. Because he's Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had a Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had a nice Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had a nice long Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had a nice long hold Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had a nice long hold while Because he's a lightweight. Because he's had a nice long hold while the he's had a nice long hold while the sea he's had a nice long hold while the sea has he's had a nice long hold while the sea has been he's had a nice long hold while the sea has been calm, he's had a nice long hold while the sea has been calm, and he's had a nice long hold while the sea has been calm, and don't he's had a nice long hold while the sea has been calm, and don't great sea has been calm, and don't great the sea has been calm, and don't great the GFC. sea has been calm, and don't great the GFC. It sea has been calm, and don't great the GFC. It didn't sea has been calm, and don't great the GFC. It didn't affect sea has been calm, and don't great the GFC. It didn't affect New the GFC. It didn't affect New Zealand the GFC. It didn't affect New Zealand or the GFC. It didn't affect New Zealand or Australia. the GFC. It didn't affect New Zealand or Australia. Our the GFC. It didn't affect New Zealand or Australia. Our backs the GFC. It didn't affect New Zealand or Australia. Our backs were Zealand or Australia. Our backs were to Zealand or Australia. Our backs were to it. Zealand or Australia. Our backs were to it. He's Zealand or Australia. Our backs were to it. He's achieved Zealand or Australia. Our backs were to it. He's achieved nothing. Zealand or Australia. Our backs were to it. He's achieved nothing. His to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy will to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy will be to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy will be that to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy will be that he to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy will be that he will to it. He's achieved nothing. His legacy will be that he will be legacy will be that he will be forgotten. legacy will be that he will be forgotten. He legacy will be that he will be forgotten. He doesn't legacy will be that he will be forgotten. He doesn't even legacy will be that he will be forgotten. He doesn't even have legacy will be that he will be forgotten. He doesn't even have the forgotten. He doesn't even have the flag forgotten. He doesn't even have the flag change forgotten. He doesn't even have the flag change because forgotten. He doesn't even have the flag change because nobody forgotten. He doesn't even have the flag change because nobody wanted flag change because nobody wanted that flag change because nobody wanted that and flag change because nobody wanted that and he flag change because nobody wanted that and he couldn't flag change because nobody wanted that and he couldn't see flag change because nobody wanted that and he couldn't see through flag change because nobody wanted that and he couldn't see through the that and he couldn't see through the campaign that and he couldn't see through the campaign at that and he couldn't see through the campaign at the that and he couldn't see through the campaign at the beginning that and he couldn't see through the campaign at the beginning to that and he couldn't see through the campaign at the beginning to see campaign at the beginning to see that campaign at the beginning to see that that campaign at the beginning to see that that was campaign at the beginning to see that that was going campaign at the beginning to see that that was going to campaign at the beginning to see that that was going to be campaign at the beginning to see that that was going to be the that that was going to be the result. that that was going to be the result. The that that was going to be the result. The clever that that was going to be the result. The clever thing that that was going to be the result. The clever thing for that that was going to be the result. The clever thing for a that that was going to be the result. The clever thing for a good result. The clever thing for a good operator, result. The clever thing for a good operator, for result. The clever thing for a good operator, for a result. The clever thing for a good operator, for a good result. The clever thing for a good operator, for a good political operator, for a good political operator operator, for a good political operator with operator, for a good political operator with a operator, for a good political operator with a good operator, for a good political operator with a good brain, operator, for a good political operator with a good brain, a operator, for a good political operator with a good brain, a good operator with a good brain, a good political operator with a good brain, a good political sense operator with a good brain, a good political sense to operator with a good brain, a good political sense to have operator with a good brain, a good political sense to have done operator with a good brain, a good political sense to have done would political sense to have done would be political sense to have done would be to political sense to have done would be to recognise political sense to have done would be to recognise that political sense to have done would be to recognise that that political sense to have done would be to recognise that that campaign be to recognise that that campaign was be to recognise that that campaign was doomed be to recognise that that campaign was doomed to be to recognise that that campaign was doomed to failure be to recognise that that campaign was doomed to failure early be to recognise that that campaign was doomed to failure early on be to recognise that that campaign was doomed to failure early on in was doomed to failure early on in the was doomed to failure early on in the piece was doomed to failure early on in the piece and was doomed to failure early on in the piece and pulled was doomed to failure early on in the piece and pulled the was doomed to failure early on in the piece and pulled the pin. was doomed to failure early on in the piece and pulled the pin. That the piece and pulled the pin. That would the piece and pulled the pin. That would have the piece and pulled the pin. That would have shown the piece and pulled the pin. That would have shown some the piece and pulled the pin. That would have shown some grace, the piece and pulled the pin. That would have shown some grace, that would have shown some grace, that would would have shown some grace, that would have would have shown some grace, that would have shown would have shown some grace, that would have shown the would have shown some grace, that would have shown the people would have shown some grace, that would have shown the people that would have shown some grace, that would have shown the people that he would have shown the people that he was would have shown the people that he was listening. would have shown the people that he was listening. But would have shown the people that he was listening. But no, would have shown the people that he was listening. But no, he would have shown the people that he was listening. But no, he pushed would have shown the people that he was listening. But no, he pushed on was listening. But no, he pushed on with was listening. But no, he pushed on with it, was listening. But no, he pushed on with it, pushed was listening. But no, he pushed on with it, pushed on was listening. But no, he pushed on with it, pushed on with was listening. But no, he pushed on with it, pushed on with it with it, pushed on with it regardless with it, pushed on with it regardless of with it, pushed on with it regardless of the with it, pushed on with it regardless of the fact with it, pushed on with it regardless of the fact that with it, pushed on with it regardless of the fact that it with it, pushed on with it regardless of the fact that it was regardless of the fact that it was never regardless of the fact that it was never going regardless of the fact that it was never going to regardless of the fact that it was never going to succeed, regardless of the fact that it was never going to succeed, spent regardless of the fact that it was never going to succeed, spent $26 never going to succeed, spent $26 million never going to succeed, spent $26 million of never going to succeed, spent $26 million of taxpayer never going to succeed, spent $26 million of taxpayer money never going to succeed, spent $26 million of taxpayer money that never going to succeed, spent $26 million of taxpayer money that could million of taxpayer money that could have million of taxpayer money that could have been million of taxpayer money that could have been much million of taxpayer money that could have been much spent million of taxpayer money that could have been much spent -- million of taxpayer money that could have been much spent -- better million of taxpayer money that could have been much spent -- better spent have been much spent -- better spent on have been much spent -- better spent on hip have been much spent -- better spent on hip operations have been much spent -- better spent on hip operations or have been much spent -- better spent on hip operations or schools have been much spent -- better spent on hip operations or schools or have been much spent -- better spent on hip operations or schools or any on hip operations or schools or any number on hip operations or schools or any number of on hip operations or schools or any number of other on hip operations or schools or any number of other things. on hip operations or schools or any number of other things. But on hip operations or schools or any number of other things. But $26 number of other things. But $26 million number of other things. But $26 million to number of other things. But $26 million to a number of other things. But $26 million to a multimillionaire number of other things. But $26 million to a multimillionaire share million to a multimillionaire share trader, million to a multimillionaire share trader, money million to a multimillionaire share trader, money trader, million to a multimillionaire share trader, money trader, is million to a multimillionaire share trader, money trader, is chicken trader, money trader, is chicken feed, trader, money trader, is chicken feed, particularly trader, money trader, is chicken feed, particularly when trader, money trader, is chicken feed, particularly when it trader, money trader, is chicken feed, particularly when it is feed, particularly when it is somebody feed, particularly when it is somebody else's. feed, particularly when it is somebody else's. And feed, particularly when it is somebody else's. And when feed, particularly when it is somebody else's. And when you feed, particularly when it is somebody else's. And when you have feed, particularly when it is somebody else's. And when you have a somebody else's. And when you have a vanity somebody else's. And when you have a vanity project somebody else's. And when you have a vanity project that somebody else's. And when you have a vanity project that you somebody else's. And when you have a vanity project that you want somebody else's. And when you have a vanity project that you want for vanity project that you want for your vanity project that you want for your legacy vanity project that you want for your legacy - vanity project that you want for your legacy - well, vanity project that you want for your legacy - well, that vanity project that you want for your legacy - well, that will vanity project that you want for your legacy - well, that will be vanity project that you want for your legacy - well, that will be his your legacy - well, that will be his legacy, your legacy - well, that will be his legacy, Mr your legacy - well, that will be his legacy, Mr Speaker, your legacy - well, that will be his legacy, Mr Speaker, the your legacy - well, that will be his legacy, Mr Speaker, the fact your legacy - well, that will be his legacy, Mr Speaker, the fact that legacy, Mr Speaker, the fact that nothing legacy, Mr Speaker, the fact that nothing happened legacy, Mr Speaker, the fact that nothing happened and legacy, Mr Speaker, the fact that nothing happened and nothing nothing happened and nothing changed. nothing happened and nothing changed. Mr nothing happened and nothing changed. Mr Speaker, nothing happened and nothing changed. Mr Speaker, next nothing happened and nothing changed. Mr Speaker, next year, changed. Mr Speaker, next year, things changed. Mr Speaker, next year, things are changed. Mr Speaker, next year, things are going changed. Mr Speaker, next year, things are going to changed. Mr Speaker, next year, things are going to change, changed. Mr Speaker, next year, things are going to change, because things are going to change, because the things are going to change, because the tide things are going to change, because the tide of things are going to change, because the tide of change things are going to change, because the tide of change that's things are going to change, because the tide of change that's sweeping the tide of change that's sweeping the the tide of change that's sweeping the world the tide of change that's sweeping the world will the tide of change that's sweeping the world will sweep the tide of change that's sweeping the world will sweep through the tide of change that's sweeping the world will sweep through New the world will sweep through New Zealandment the world will sweep through New Zealandment and the world will sweep through New Zealandment and they the world will sweep through New Zealandment and they can the world will sweep through New Zealandment and they can scoff the world will sweep through New Zealandment and they can scoff on Zealandment and they can scoff on that Zealandment and they can scoff on that side Zealandment and they can scoff on that side of Zealandment and they can scoff on that side of the Zealandment and they can scoff on that side of the house. Zealandment and they can scoff on that side of the house. They Zealandment and they can scoff on that side of the house. They can that side of the house. They can scoff that side of the house. They can scoff and that side of the house. They can scoff and they that side of the house. They can scoff and they do that side of the house. They can scoff and they do scoff that side of the house. They can scoff and they do scoff because scoff and they do scoff because they're scoff and they do scoff because they're not scoff and they do scoff because they're not in scoff and they do scoff because they're not in touch scoff and they do scoff because they're not in touch with scoff and they do scoff because they're not in touch with the scoff and they do scoff because they're not in touch with the real they're not in touch with the real people. they're not in touch with the real people. They're they're not in touch with the real people. They're not they're not in touch with the real people. They're not in they're not in touch with the real people. They're not in touch they're not in touch with the real people. They're not in touch with people. They're not in touch with heartland people. They're not in touch with heartland New people. They're not in touch with heartland New Zealand. people. They're not in touch with heartland New Zealand. We people. They're not in touch with heartland New Zealand. We are. people. They're not in touch with heartland New Zealand. We are. New heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First is. heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First is. And heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First is. And we heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First is. And we will heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First is. And we will be heartland New Zealand. We are. New Zealand First is. And we will be the Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. And Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. And we Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. And we will Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. And we will go Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. And we will go into Zealand First is. And we will be the alternative. And we will go into the alternative. And we will go into the 2017 alternative. And we will go into the 2017 campaign, alternative. And we will go into the 2017 campaign, New alternative. And we will go into the 2017 campaign, New Zealand alternative. And we will go into the 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of a 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of a 3-way 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of a 3-way race 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of a 3-way race standing 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of a 3-way race standing on 2017 campaign, New Zealand First, part of a 3-way race standing on our part of a 3-way race standing on our own, part of a 3-way race standing on our own, behind part of a 3-way race standing on our own, behind the part of a 3-way race standing on our own, behind the Rt part of a 3-way race standing on our own, behind the Rt Honerable part of a 3-way race standing on our own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and I own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and I think own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and I think that own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and I think that a own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and I think that a lot own, behind the Rt Honerable Winston Peters and I think that a lot of Peters and I think that a lot of people Peters and I think that a lot of people all Peters and I think that a lot of people all around, Peters and I think that a lot of people all around, the Peters and I think that a lot of people all around, the pundits Peters and I think that a lot of people all around, the pundits and people all around, the pundits and the people all around, the pundits and the pollsters people all around, the pundits and the pollsters and people all around, the pundits and the pollsters and people people all around, the pundits and the pollsters and people on people all around, the pundits and the pollsters and people on that the pollsters and people on that side the pollsters and people on that side of the pollsters and people on that side of the the pollsters and people on that side of the house, the pollsters and people on that side of the house, and the pollsters and people on that side of the house, and even the pollsters and people on that side of the house, and even people side of the house, and even people around side of the house, and even people around us, side of the house, and even people around us, are side of the house, and even people around us, are in side of the house, and even people around us, are in for side of the house, and even people around us, are in for a side of the house, and even people around us, are in for a great around us, are in for a great surprise. around us, are in for a great surprise. They around us, are in for a great surprise. They could around us, are in for a great surprise. They could take around us, are in for a great surprise. They could take the surprise. They could take the message surprise. They could take the message now. surprise. They could take the message now. They surprise. They could take the message now. They could surprise. They could take the message now. They could heed surprise. They could take the message now. They could heed the message now. They could heed the warning. message now. They could heed the warning. But message now. They could heed the warning. But the message now. They could heed the warning. But the indication message now. They could heed the warning. But the indication is message now. They could heed the warning. But the indication is that warning. But the indication is that they're warning. But the indication is that they're not warning. But the indication is that they're not going warning. But the indication is that they're not going to. warning. But the indication is that they're not going to. The warning. But the indication is that they're not going to. The indication they're not going to. The indication is they're not going to. The indication is that they're not going to. The indication is that things they're not going to. The indication is that things are they're not going to. The indication is that things are going they're not going to. The indication is that things are going to they're not going to. The indication is that things are going to unfold is that things are going to unfold here is that things are going to unfold here exactly is that things are going to unfold here exactly the is that things are going to unfold here exactly the same is that things are going to unfold here exactly the same as is that things are going to unfold here exactly the same as they here exactly the same as they unfolded here exactly the same as they unfolded around here exactly the same as they unfolded around the here exactly the same as they unfolded around the rest here exactly the same as they unfolded around the rest of here exactly the same as they unfolded around the rest of the unfolded around the rest of the world unfolded around the rest of the world because unfolded around the rest of the world because the unfolded around the rest of the world because the people unfolded around the rest of the world because the people who unfolded around the rest of the world because the people who are world because the people who are currently world because the people who are currently in world because the people who are currently in charge world because the people who are currently in charge are world because the people who are currently in charge are every world because the people who are currently in charge are every bit world because the people who are currently in charge are every bit as currently in charge are every bit as much currently in charge are every bit as much out currently in charge are every bit as much out of currently in charge are every bit as much out of touch currently in charge are every bit as much out of touch here currently in charge are every bit as much out of touch here as currently in charge are every bit as much out of touch here as they currently in charge are every bit as much out of touch here as they were much out of touch here as they were over much out of touch here as they were over there. much out of touch here as they were over there. And much out of touch here as they were over there. And we much out of touch here as they were over there. And we will much out of touch here as they were over there. And we will see much out of touch here as they were over there. And we will see change over there. And we will see change come over there. And we will see change come and over there. And we will see change come and I'm over there. And we will see change come and I'm afraid over there. And we will see change come and I'm afraid to over there. And we will see change come and I'm afraid to say over there. And we will see change come and I'm afraid to say that over there. And we will see change come and I'm afraid to say that John come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's legacy come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's legacy will come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's legacy will be come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's legacy will be that come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's legacy will be that he come and I'm afraid to say that John Key's legacy will be that he is Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as a Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as a man Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as a man who, Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as a man who, as Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as a man who, as PM Key's legacy will be that he is forgotten as a man who, as PM for forgotten as a man who, as PM for eight forgotten as a man who, as PM for eight years, forgotten as a man who, as PM for eight years, achieved forgotten as a man who, as PM for eight years, achieved nothing, eight years, achieved nothing, changed eight years, achieved nothing, changed nothing eight years, achieved nothing, changed nothing and eight years, achieved nothing, changed nothing and will eight years, achieved nothing, changed nothing and will not eight years, achieved nothing, changed nothing and will not be changed nothing and will not be remembered changed nothing and will not be remembered for changed nothing and will not be remembered for anything. Well, Well, that Well, that was Well, that was a Well, that was a speech Well, that was a speech from Well, that was a speech from a Well, that was a speech from a member Well, that was a speech from a member who Well, that was a speech from a member who lacks Well, that was a speech from a member who lacks so Well, that was a speech from a member who lacks so many Well, that was a speech from a member who lacks so many things Well, that was a speech from a member who lacks so many things and member who lacks so many things and now member who lacks so many things and now we member who lacks so many things and now we know member who lacks so many things and now we know that member who lacks so many things and now we know that he member who lacks so many things and now we know that he has member who lacks so many things and now we know that he has a member who lacks so many things and now we know that he has a profound now we know that he has a profound lack now we know that he has a profound lack of now we know that he has a profound lack of graciousness, now we know that he has a profound lack of graciousness, from now we know that he has a profound lack of graciousness, from a now we know that he has a profound lack of graciousness, from a list now we know that he has a profound lack of graciousness, from a list MP lack of graciousness, from a list MP who lack of graciousness, from a list MP who would lack of graciousness, from a list MP who would never lack of graciousness, from a list MP who would never be lack of graciousness, from a list MP who would never be in lack of graciousness, from a list MP who would never be in parliament lack of graciousness, from a list MP who would never be in parliament had who would never be in parliament had he who would never be in parliament had he not who would never be in parliament had he not been who would never be in parliament had he not been put who would never be in parliament had he not been put on who would never be in parliament had he not been put on a who would never be in parliament had he not been put on a party who would never be in parliament had he not been put on a party list who would never be in parliament had he not been put on a party list and he not been put on a party list and nobody he not been put on a party list and nobody knew he not been put on a party list and nobody knew who he not been put on a party list and nobody knew who he he not been put on a party list and nobody knew who he was... nobody knew who he was... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! ..Running <INTERRUPTION> Order! ..Running down <INTERRUPTION> Order! ..Running down one <INTERRUPTION> Order! ..Running down one of <INTERRUPTION> Order! ..Running down one of the Order! ..Running down one of the great Order! ..Running down one of the great prime Order! ..Running down one of the great prime ministers Order! ..Running down one of the great prime ministers of Order! ..Running down one of the great prime ministers of New great prime ministers of New Zealand. great prime ministers of New Zealand. I great prime ministers of New Zealand. I have great prime ministers of New Zealand. I have had great prime ministers of New Zealand. I have had a great prime ministers of New Zealand. I have had a great great prime ministers of New Zealand. I have had a great pleasure Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over the Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over the past Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over the past two Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over the past two years Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over the past two years of Zealand. I have had a great pleasure over the past two years of working over the past two years of working with over the past two years of working with John over the past two years of working with John Key over the past two years of working with John Key up over the past two years of working with John Key up close over the past two years of working with John Key up close and over the past two years of working with John Key up close and I over the past two years of working with John Key up close and I would with John Key up close and I would characterise with John Key up close and I would characterise him with John Key up close and I would characterise him as with John Key up close and I would characterise him as being with John Key up close and I would characterise him as being one with John Key up close and I would characterise him as being one of with John Key up close and I would characterise him as being one of the characterise him as being one of the most characterise him as being one of the most affable, characterise him as being one of the most affable, unflappable characterise him as being one of the most affable, unflappable people most affable, unflappable people that most affable, unflappable people that I've most affable, unflappable people that I've ever most affable, unflappable people that I've ever known, most affable, unflappable people that I've ever known, and most affable, unflappable people that I've ever known, and at most affable, unflappable people that I've ever known, and at certain that I've ever known, and at certain times that I've ever known, and at certain times in that I've ever known, and at certain times in meetings that I've ever known, and at certain times in meetings and that I've ever known, and at certain times in meetings and at that I've ever known, and at certain times in meetings and at Cabinet times in meetings and at Cabinet committees, times in meetings and at Cabinet committees, I've times in meetings and at Cabinet committees, I've said times in meetings and at Cabinet committees, I've said to times in meetings and at Cabinet committees, I've said to myself, committees, I've said to myself, "That committees, I've said to myself, "That guy committees, I've said to myself, "That guy is committees, I've said to myself, "That guy is the committees, I've said to myself, "That guy is the PM committees, I've said to myself, "That guy is the PM of committees, I've said to myself, "That guy is the PM of New committees, I've said to myself, "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, dealing "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, dealing with "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, dealing with very "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, dealing with very serious "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, dealing with very serious issue "That guy is the PM of New Zealand, dealing with very serious issue X, dealing with very serious issue X, and dealing with very serious issue X, and doing dealing with very serious issue X, and doing it dealing with very serious issue X, and doing it in dealing with very serious issue X, and doing it in a dealing with very serious issue X, and doing it in a way dealing with very serious issue X, and doing it in a way that dealing with very serious issue X, and doing it in a way that doesn't and doing it in a way that doesn't show and doing it in a way that doesn't show a and doing it in a way that doesn't show a hint and doing it in a way that doesn't show a hint of and doing it in a way that doesn't show a hint of being and doing it in a way that doesn't show a hint of being flapped, and doing it in a way that doesn't show a hint of being flapped, under show a hint of being flapped, under pressure show a hint of being flapped, under pressure or show a hint of being flapped, under pressure or panic", show a hint of being flapped, under pressure or panic", and show a hint of being flapped, under pressure or panic", and that show a hint of being flapped, under pressure or panic", and that is show a hint of being flapped, under pressure or panic", and that is why pressure or panic", and that is why so pressure or panic", and that is why so many pressure or panic", and that is why so many people pressure or panic", and that is why so many people that pressure or panic", and that is why so many people that have pressure or panic", and that is why so many people that have worked pressure or panic", and that is why so many people that have worked with so many people that have worked with John so many people that have worked with John Key so many people that have worked with John Key have so many people that have worked with John Key have found so many people that have worked with John Key have found him so many people that have worked with John Key have found him such so many people that have worked with John Key have found him such a John Key have found him such a pleasure John Key have found him such a pleasure to John Key have found him such a pleasure to deal John Key have found him such a pleasure to deal with. John Key have found him such a pleasure to deal with. On John Key have found him such a pleasure to deal with. On behalf John Key have found him such a pleasure to deal with. On behalf of pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT Party, pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT Party, I pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT Party, I would pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT Party, I would like pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT Party, I would like to pleasure to deal with. On behalf of the ACT Party, I would like to thank the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, not the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, not only the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, not only for the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, not only for myself, the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, not only for myself, but the ACT Party, I would like to thank him, not only for myself, but also him, not only for myself, but also for him, not only for myself, but also for other him, not only for myself, but also for other ACT him, not only for myself, but also for other ACT leaders, him, not only for myself, but also for other ACT leaders, who him, not only for myself, but also for other ACT leaders, who have him, not only for myself, but also for other ACT leaders, who have had for other ACT leaders, who have had that for other ACT leaders, who have had that relationship for other ACT leaders, who have had that relationship with for other ACT leaders, who have had that relationship with John for other ACT leaders, who have had that relationship with John Key for other ACT leaders, who have had that relationship with John Key over that relationship with John Key over the that relationship with John Key over the past that relationship with John Key over the past eight that relationship with John Key over the past eight years. that relationship with John Key over the past eight years. In that relationship with John Key over the past eight years. In light that relationship with John Key over the past eight years. In light of the past eight years. In light of saying the past eight years. In light of saying that, the past eight years. In light of saying that, there the past eight years. In light of saying that, there is the past eight years. In light of saying that, there is no the past eight years. In light of saying that, there is no question saying that, there is no question that, saying that, there is no question that, while saying that, there is no question that, while John saying that, there is no question that, while John Key saying that, there is no question that, while John Key is saying that, there is no question that, while John Key is one saying that, there is no question that, while John Key is one of saying that, there is no question that, while John Key is one of the that, while John Key is one of the best, that, while John Key is one of the best, most that, while John Key is one of the best, most affable that, while John Key is one of the best, most affable and that, while John Key is one of the best, most affable and most that, while John Key is one of the best, most affable and most popular best, most affable and most popular day-to-day best, most affable and most popular day-to-day managers best, most affable and most popular day-to-day managers that best, most affable and most popular day-to-day managers that a best, most affable and most popular day-to-day managers that a country day-to-day managers that a country could day-to-day managers that a country could hope day-to-day managers that a country could hope to day-to-day managers that a country could hope to have, day-to-day managers that a country could hope to have, just day-to-day managers that a country could hope to have, just like day-to-day managers that a country could hope to have, just like any could hope to have, just like any period could hope to have, just like any period of could hope to have, just like any period of conservative could hope to have, just like any period of conservative government, period of conservative government, whether period of conservative government, whether it period of conservative government, whether it was period of conservative government, whether it was 1960 period of conservative government, whether it was 1960 to period of conservative government, whether it was 1960 to 1972, period of conservative government, whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether it whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether it was whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether it was 1975 whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether it was 1975 to whether it was 1960 to 1972, or whether it was 1975 to 1984, whether it was 1975 to 1984, long-term whether it was 1975 to 1984, long-term problems whether it was 1975 to 1984, long-term problems have whether it was 1975 to 1984, long-term problems have a whether it was 1975 to 1984, long-term problems have a tendency long-term problems have a tendency to long-term problems have a tendency to accumulate long-term problems have a tendency to accumulate in long-term problems have a tendency to accumulate in such long-term problems have a tendency to accumulate in such a long-term problems have a tendency to accumulate in such a way long-term problems have a tendency to accumulate in such a way that to accumulate in such a way that change to accumulate in such a way that change must to accumulate in such a way that change must eventually to accumulate in such a way that change must eventually come. to accumulate in such a way that change must eventually come. But to accumulate in such a way that change must eventually come. But it change must eventually come. But it won't change must eventually come. But it won't come, change must eventually come. But it won't come, as change must eventually come. But it won't come, as the change must eventually come. But it won't come, as the member change must eventually come. But it won't come, as the member who change must eventually come. But it won't come, as the member who just won't come, as the member who just resumed won't come, as the member who just resumed his won't come, as the member who just resumed his seat, won't come, as the member who just resumed his seat, from won't come, as the member who just resumed his seat, from Winston resumed his seat, from Winston Peters resumed his seat, from Winston Peters or resumed his seat, from Winston Peters or from resumed his seat, from Winston Peters or from New resumed his seat, from Winston Peters or from New Zealand resumed his seat, from Winston Peters or from New Zealand First, Peters or from New Zealand First, because Peters or from New Zealand First, because to Peters or from New Zealand First, because to solve Peters or from New Zealand First, because to solve serious Peters or from New Zealand First, because to solve serious problems, because to solve serious problems, you because to solve serious problems, you actually because to solve serious problems, you actually need because to solve serious problems, you actually need serious because to solve serious problems, you actually need serious thinking you actually need serious thinking and you actually need serious thinking and serious you actually need serious thinking and serious bravery you actually need serious thinking and serious bravery to you actually need serious thinking and serious bravery to confront and serious bravery to confront those and serious bravery to confront those challenges and serious bravery to confront those challenges and and serious bravery to confront those challenges and when and serious bravery to confront those challenges and when you and serious bravery to confront those challenges and when you turn those challenges and when you turn to those challenges and when you turn to New those challenges and when you turn to New Zealand those challenges and when you turn to New Zealand First, those challenges and when you turn to New Zealand First, and those challenges and when you turn to New Zealand First, and when those challenges and when you turn to New Zealand First, and when you to New Zealand First, and when you turn to New Zealand First, and when you turn to to New Zealand First, and when you turn to Winston to New Zealand First, and when you turn to Winston Peters, to New Zealand First, and when you turn to Winston Peters, you to New Zealand First, and when you turn to Winston Peters, you get to New Zealand First, and when you turn to Winston Peters, you get an turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot of turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot of sizzle turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot of sizzle but, turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot of sizzle but, at turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot of sizzle but, at the turn to Winston Peters, you get an awful lot of sizzle but, at the end awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of the awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of the day, awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of the day, a awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of the day, a very awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of the day, a very small awful lot of sizzle but, at the end of the day, a very small sausage. of the day, a very small sausage. You of the day, a very small sausage. You get of the day, a very small sausage. You get an of the day, a very small sausage. You get an awful of the day, a very small sausage. You get an awful lot of the day, a very small sausage. You get an awful lot of of the day, a very small sausage. You get an awful lot of piffle, of the day, a very small sausage. You get an awful lot of piffle, but You get an awful lot of piffle, but a You get an awful lot of piffle, but a real You get an awful lot of piffle, but a real bit You get an awful lot of piffle, but a real bit shortage You get an awful lot of piffle, but a real bit shortage of You get an awful lot of piffle, but a real bit shortage of porridge. a real bit shortage of porridge. They a real bit shortage of porridge. They do a real bit shortage of porridge. They do not a real bit shortage of porridge. They do not have a real bit shortage of porridge. They do not have what a real bit shortage of porridge. They do not have what it a real bit shortage of porridge. They do not have what it takes a real bit shortage of porridge. They do not have what it takes and They do not have what it takes and that's They do not have what it takes and that's why They do not have what it takes and that's why their They do not have what it takes and that's why their only They do not have what it takes and that's why their only selling They do not have what it takes and that's why their only selling point that's why their only selling point is that's why their only selling point is that that's why their only selling point is that they that's why their only selling point is that they will that's why their only selling point is that they will surf that's why their only selling point is that they will surf a that's why their only selling point is that they will surf a wave that's why their only selling point is that they will surf a wave of is that they will surf a wave of changes is that they will surf a wave of changes in is that they will surf a wave of changes in other is that they will surf a wave of changes in other countries, is that they will surf a wave of changes in other countries, rather changes in other countries, rather than changes in other countries, rather than looking changes in other countries, rather than looking at changes in other countries, rather than looking at what's changes in other countries, rather than looking at what's happening changes in other countries, rather than looking at what's happening in than looking at what's happening in New than looking at what's happening in New Zealand, than looking at what's happening in New Zealand, whereas than looking at what's happening in New Zealand, whereas actually than looking at what's happening in New Zealand, whereas actually in than looking at what's happening in New Zealand, whereas actually in New New Zealand, whereas actually in New Zealand, New Zealand, whereas actually in New Zealand, it's New Zealand, whereas actually in New Zealand, it's doing New Zealand, whereas actually in New Zealand, it's doing pretty New Zealand, whereas actually in New Zealand, it's doing pretty good. New Zealand, whereas actually in New Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of the Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of the most Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of the most acute Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of the most acute things Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of the most acute things we Zealand, it's doing pretty good. But one of the most acute things we need one of the most acute things we need to one of the most acute things we need to tackle one of the most acute things we need to tackle when one of the most acute things we need to tackle when it one of the most acute things we need to tackle when it comes one of the most acute things we need to tackle when it comes to one of the most acute things we need to tackle when it comes to the to tackle when it comes to the question to tackle when it comes to the question of to tackle when it comes to the question of retiring to tackle when it comes to the question of retiring PM to tackle when it comes to the question of retiring PM John to tackle when it comes to the question of retiring PM John Key to tackle when it comes to the question of retiring PM John Key is question of retiring PM John Key is superannuation. question of retiring PM John Key is superannuation. Every question of retiring PM John Key is superannuation. Every four question of retiring PM John Key is superannuation. Every four years, superannuation. Every four years, the superannuation. Every four years, the fiscal superannuation. Every four years, the fiscal outlook superannuation. Every four years, the fiscal outlook is superannuation. Every four years, the fiscal outlook is published superannuation. Every four years, the fiscal outlook is published and the fiscal outlook is published and it the fiscal outlook is published and it says the fiscal outlook is published and it says - the fiscal outlook is published and it says - well, the fiscal outlook is published and it says - well, the the fiscal outlook is published and it says - well, the wording the fiscal outlook is published and it says - well, the wording doesn't it says - well, the wording doesn't change it says - well, the wording doesn't change much, it says - well, the wording doesn't change much, and it says - well, the wording doesn't change much, and it it says - well, the wording doesn't change much, and it predicts it says - well, the wording doesn't change much, and it predicts by it says - well, the wording doesn't change much, and it predicts by the change much, and it predicts by the time change much, and it predicts by the time that change much, and it predicts by the time that current change much, and it predicts by the time that current university time that current university students time that current university students retire time that current university students retire they time that current university students retire they are time that current university students retire they are going time that current university students retire they are going to students retire they are going to find students retire they are going to find themselves students retire they are going to find themselves living students retire they are going to find themselves living in students retire they are going to find themselves living in a students retire they are going to find themselves living in a country find themselves living in a country with find themselves living in a country with 200 find themselves living in a country with 200 odd find themselves living in a country with 200 odd per find themselves living in a country with 200 odd per cent find themselves living in a country with 200 odd per cent public find themselves living in a country with 200 odd per cent public debt, with 200 odd per cent public debt, worse with 200 odd per cent public debt, worse than with 200 odd per cent public debt, worse than Greece, with 200 odd per cent public debt, worse than Greece, Italy, with 200 odd per cent public debt, worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain or worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain or any worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain or any of worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain or any of those worse than Greece, Italy, Portugal, Spain or any of those PEGs Spain or any of those PEGs countries. Spain or any of those PEGs countries. That's Spain or any of those PEGs countries. That's an Spain or any of those PEGs countries. That's an issue Spain or any of those PEGs countries. That's an issue where countries. That's an issue where things countries. That's an issue where things are countries. That's an issue where things are moving. countries. That's an issue where things are moving. John countries. That's an issue where things are moving. John Key countries. That's an issue where things are moving. John Key said countries. That's an issue where things are moving. John Key said he things are moving. John Key said he wouldn't things are moving. John Key said he wouldn't change things are moving. John Key said he wouldn't change the things are moving. John Key said he wouldn't change the eligibility things are moving. John Key said he wouldn't change the eligibility for wouldn't change the eligibility for super. wouldn't change the eligibility for super. It wouldn't change the eligibility for super. It is wouldn't change the eligibility for super. It is an wouldn't change the eligibility for super. It is an issue wouldn't change the eligibility for super. It is an issue that wouldn't change the eligibility for super. It is an issue that young super. It is an issue that young people super. It is an issue that young people are super. It is an issue that young people are saying, super. It is an issue that young people are saying, we super. It is an issue that young people are saying, we know super. It is an issue that young people are saying, we know we super. It is an issue that young people are saying, we know we are people are saying, we know we are not people are saying, we know we are not getting people are saying, we know we are not getting it people are saying, we know we are not getting it ourselves people are saying, we know we are not getting it ourselves at people are saying, we know we are not getting it ourselves at 65, people are saying, we know we are not getting it ourselves at 65, why not getting it ourselves at 65, why can't not getting it ourselves at 65, why can't we not getting it ourselves at 65, why can't we have not getting it ourselves at 65, why can't we have the not getting it ourselves at 65, why can't we have the conversation? not getting it ourselves at 65, why can't we have the conversation? And can't we have the conversation? And now can't we have the conversation? And now we can't we have the conversation? And now we can. can't we have the conversation? And now we can. There can't we have the conversation? And now we can. There are can't we have the conversation? And now we can. There are so can't we have the conversation? And now we can. There are so many can't we have the conversation? And now we can. There are so many people now we can. There are so many people out now we can. There are so many people out there now we can. There are so many people out there in now we can. There are so many people out there in my now we can. There are so many people out there in my generation now we can. There are so many people out there in my generation of now we can. There are so many people out there in my generation of New out there in my generation of New Zealand out there in my generation of New Zealand who out there in my generation of New Zealand who are out there in my generation of New Zealand who are finding out there in my generation of New Zealand who are finding it out there in my generation of New Zealand who are finding it damn Zealand who are finding it damn tough Zealand who are finding it damn tough in Zealand who are finding it damn tough in the Zealand who are finding it damn tough in the housing Zealand who are finding it damn tough in the housing market, Zealand who are finding it damn tough in the housing market, but tough in the housing market, but they're tough in the housing market, but they're now tough in the housing market, but they're now being tough in the housing market, but they're now being joined tough in the housing market, but they're now being joined by tough in the housing market, but they're now being joined by their they're now being joined by their parents they're now being joined by their parents who they're now being joined by their parents who are they're now being joined by their parents who are saying, they're now being joined by their parents who are saying, "I'm they're now being joined by their parents who are saying, "I'm quite parents who are saying, "I'm quite please parents who are saying, "I'm quite please that parents who are saying, "I'm quite please that had parents who are saying, "I'm quite please that had in parents who are saying, "I'm quite please that had in some parents who are saying, "I'm quite please that had in some parts parents who are saying, "I'm quite please that had in some parts of please that had in some parts of Auckland please that had in some parts of Auckland my please that had in some parts of Auckland my house please that had in some parts of Auckland my house is please that had in some parts of Auckland my house is worth please that had in some parts of Auckland my house is worth $2 Auckland my house is worth $2 million Auckland my house is worth $2 million or Auckland my house is worth $2 million or $3 Auckland my house is worth $2 million or $3 million, Auckland my house is worth $2 million or $3 million, however Auckland my house is worth $2 million or $3 million, however I've million or $3 million, however I've helped million or $3 million, however I've helped three million or $3 million, however I've helped three kids million or $3 million, however I've helped three kids and million or $3 million, however I've helped three kids and I million or $3 million, however I've helped three kids and I don't million or $3 million, however I've helped three kids and I don't want helped three kids and I don't want to helped three kids and I don't want to give helped three kids and I don't want to give them helped three kids and I don't want to give them $6 helped three kids and I don't want to give them $6 million helped three kids and I don't want to give them $6 million or helped three kids and I don't want to give them $6 million or $9 to give them $6 million or $9 million to give them $6 million or $9 million to to give them $6 million or $9 million to get to give them $6 million or $9 million to get themselves to give them $6 million or $9 million to get themselves into to give them $6 million or $9 million to get themselves into the million to get themselves into the market million to get themselves into the market as million to get themselves into the market as well". million to get themselves into the market as well". So million to get themselves into the market as well". So we million to get themselves into the market as well". So we find market as well". So we find ourselves market as well". So we find ourselves with market as well". So we find ourselves with two market as well". So we find ourselves with two large market as well". So we find ourselves with two large issues ourselves with two large issues there ourselves with two large issues there that ourselves with two large issues there that are ourselves with two large issues there that are intergenerational there that are intergenerational that there that are intergenerational that a there that are intergenerational that a future there that are intergenerational that a future PM there that are intergenerational that a future PM and there that are intergenerational that a future PM and a there that are intergenerational that a future PM and a future that a future PM and a future government that a future PM and a future government will that a future PM and a future government will have that a future PM and a future government will have to that a future PM and a future government will have to take that a future PM and a future government will have to take account government will have to take account of. government will have to take account of. I'm government will have to take account of. I'm very government will have to take account of. I'm very proud government will have to take account of. I'm very proud to government will have to take account of. I'm very proud to lead government will have to take account of. I'm very proud to lead an government will have to take account of. I'm very proud to lead an ACT of. I'm very proud to lead an ACT Party of. I'm very proud to lead an ACT Party has of. I'm very proud to lead an ACT Party has been of. I'm very proud to lead an ACT Party has been playing of. I'm very proud to lead an ACT Party has been playing a Party has been playing a constructive Party has been playing a constructive role Party has been playing a constructive role in Party has been playing a constructive role in government Party has been playing a constructive role in government over constructive role in government over the constructive role in government over the last constructive role in government over the last eight constructive role in government over the last eight years. constructive role in government over the last eight years. Much constructive role in government over the last eight years. Much of constructive role in government over the last eight years. Much of the the last eight years. Much of the debate the last eight years. Much of the debate and the last eight years. Much of the debate and change the last eight years. Much of the debate and change that the last eight years. Much of the debate and change that has the last eight years. Much of the debate and change that has come debate and change that has come around debate and change that has come around in debate and change that has come around in the debate and change that has come around in the housing debate and change that has come around in the housing market, debate and change that has come around in the housing market, in around in the housing market, in particular, around in the housing market, in particular, has around in the housing market, in particular, has come around in the housing market, in particular, has come from around in the housing market, in particular, has come from the particular, has come from the Productivity particular, has come from the Productivity Commission, particular, has come from the Productivity Commission, an particular, has come from the Productivity Commission, an ACT Productivity Commission, an ACT Party Productivity Commission, an ACT Party initiative. Productivity Commission, an ACT Party initiative. We Productivity Commission, an ACT Party initiative. We have Productivity Commission, an ACT Party initiative. We have recently Party initiative. We have recently seen, Party initiative. We have recently seen, after Party initiative. We have recently seen, after evidence Party initiative. We have recently seen, after evidence that Party initiative. We have recently seen, after evidence that it Party initiative. We have recently seen, after evidence that it deters seen, after evidence that it deters criminals, seen, after evidence that it deters criminals, the seen, after evidence that it deters criminals, the first seen, after evidence that it deters criminals, the first third-striker criminals, the first third-striker under criminals, the first third-striker under the criminals, the first third-striker under the three criminals, the first third-striker under the three strikes criminals, the first third-striker under the three strikes law criminals, the first third-striker under the three strikes law - under the three strikes law - something under the three strikes law - something that under the three strikes law - something that New under the three strikes law - something that New Zealanders under the three strikes law - something that New Zealanders want. something that New Zealanders want. But something that New Zealanders want. But we're something that New Zealanders want. But we're also something that New Zealanders want. But we're also going something that New Zealanders want. But we're also going into something that New Zealanders want. But we're also going into a something that New Zealanders want. But we're also going into a round something that New Zealanders want. But we're also going into a round of But we're also going into a round of prize-givings But we're also going into a round of prize-givings and But we're also going into a round of prize-givings and commemorations But we're also going into a round of prize-givings and commemorations for prize-givings and commemorations for partnership prize-givings and commemorations for partnership schools prize-givings and commemorations for partnership schools or prize-givings and commemorations for partnership schools or charter partnership schools or charter schools partnership schools or charter schools that partnership schools or charter schools that are partnership schools or charter schools that are changing partnership schools or charter schools that are changing kids' schools that are changing kids' lives schools that are changing kids' lives for schools that are changing kids' lives for the schools that are changing kids' lives for the better. schools that are changing kids' lives for the better. The schools that are changing kids' lives for the better. The ACT schools that are changing kids' lives for the better. The ACT Party lives for the better. The ACT Party salutes lives for the better. The ACT Party salutes John lives for the better. The ACT Party salutes John Key, lives for the better. The ACT Party salutes John Key, we're lives for the better. The ACT Party salutes John Key, we're proud lives for the better. The ACT Party salutes John Key, we're proud of salutes John Key, we're proud of what salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've done salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've done with salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've done with him salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've done with him and salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've done with him and when salutes John Key, we're proud of what we've done with him and when it what we've done with him and when it comes what we've done with him and when it comes on what we've done with him and when it comes on New what we've done with him and when it comes on New Zealand's what we've done with him and when it comes on New Zealand's long-term comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, we comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, we believe comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, we believe we comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, we believe we have comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, we believe we have a comes on New Zealand's long-term challenges, we believe we have a lot challenges, we believe we have a lot more challenges, we believe we have a lot more to challenges, we believe we have a lot more to contribute. challenges, we believe we have a lot more to contribute. Thank challenges, we believe we have a lot more to contribute. Thank you. On On a On a day On a day like On a day like this, On a day like this, I On a day like this, I too On a day like this, I too want On a day like this, I too want to On a day like this, I too want to join On a day like this, I too want to join those On a day like this, I too want to join those who On a day like this, I too want to join those who have On a day like this, I too want to join those who have - On a day like this, I too want to join those who have - who On a day like this, I too want to join those who have - who wish On a day like this, I too want to join those who have - who wish John join those who have - who wish John Key join those who have - who wish John Key well join those who have - who wish John Key well in join those who have - who wish John Key well in his join those who have - who wish John Key well in his retirement. join those who have - who wish John Key well in his retirement. It join those who have - who wish John Key well in his retirement. It is join those who have - who wish John Key well in his retirement. It is a Key well in his retirement. It is a time Key well in his retirement. It is a time to Key well in his retirement. It is a time to thank Key well in his retirement. It is a time to thank him Key well in his retirement. It is a time to thank him for Key well in his retirement. It is a time to thank him for his Key well in his retirement. It is a time to thank him for his eight time to thank him for his eight years time to thank him for his eight years as time to thank him for his eight years as PM time to thank him for his eight years as PM of time to thank him for his eight years as PM of New time to thank him for his eight years as PM of New Zealand time to thank him for his eight years as PM of New Zealand and years as PM of New Zealand and anyone years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that has years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that has ever years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that has ever been years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that has ever been close years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that has ever been close to years as PM of New Zealand and anyone that has ever been close to a anyone that has ever been close to a PM anyone that has ever been close to a PM will anyone that has ever been close to a PM will know anyone that has ever been close to a PM will know that anyone that has ever been close to a PM will know that they anyone that has ever been close to a PM will know that they work PM will know that they work incredibly PM will know that they work incredibly hard, PM will know that they work incredibly hard, they PM will know that they work incredibly hard, they make PM will know that they work incredibly hard, they make a PM will know that they work incredibly hard, they make a huge incredibly hard, they make a huge commitment incredibly hard, they make a huge commitment to incredibly hard, they make a huge commitment to the incredibly hard, they make a huge commitment to the country, incredibly hard, they make a huge commitment to the country, and incredibly hard, they make a huge commitment to the country, and it commitment to the country, and it takes commitment to the country, and it takes a commitment to the country, and it takes a great commitment to the country, and it takes a great toll commitment to the country, and it takes a great toll on commitment to the country, and it takes a great toll on them commitment to the country, and it takes a great toll on them and commitment to the country, and it takes a great toll on them and their takes a great toll on them and their families. takes a great toll on them and their families. So takes a great toll on them and their families. So I takes a great toll on them and their families. So I wish takes a great toll on them and their families. So I wish him takes a great toll on them and their families. So I wish him well takes a great toll on them and their families. So I wish him well in takes a great toll on them and their families. So I wish him well in his families. So I wish him well in his years families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. But families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. But I families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. But I need families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. But I need to families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. But I need to tell families. So I wish him well in his years ahead. But I need to tell this years ahead. But I need to tell this House years ahead. But I need to tell this House that years ahead. But I need to tell this House that Labour years ahead. But I need to tell this House that Labour is years ahead. But I need to tell this House that Labour is ready, years ahead. But I need to tell this House that Labour is ready, we years ahead. But I need to tell this House that Labour is ready, we are House that Labour is ready, we are organised, House that Labour is ready, we are organised, and House that Labour is ready, we are organised, and we House that Labour is ready, we are organised, and we are House that Labour is ready, we are organised, and we are hungry House that Labour is ready, we are organised, and we are hungry for House that Labour is ready, we are organised, and we are hungry for the organised, and we are hungry for the election organised, and we are hungry for the election whenever organised, and we are hungry for the election whenever it organised, and we are hungry for the election whenever it will organised, and we are hungry for the election whenever it will be. organised, and we are hungry for the election whenever it will be. We organised, and we are hungry for the election whenever it will be. We are election whenever it will be. We are committed election whenever it will be. We are committed to election whenever it will be. We are committed to addressing election whenever it will be. We are committed to addressing the committed to addressing the challenges committed to addressing the challenges that committed to addressing the challenges that face committed to addressing the challenges that face this committed to addressing the challenges that face this country, challenges that face this country, because challenges that face this country, because we challenges that face this country, because we know challenges that face this country, because we know that challenges that face this country, because we know that there challenges that face this country, because we know that there is challenges that face this country, because we know that there is work because we know that there is work to because we know that there is work to be because we know that there is work to be done. because we know that there is work to be done. We because we know that there is work to be done. We can't because we know that there is work to be done. We can't cover because we know that there is work to be done. We can't cover up because we know that there is work to be done. We can't cover up the to be done. We can't cover up the fact to be done. We can't cover up the fact that to be done. We can't cover up the fact that there to be done. We can't cover up the fact that there are to be done. We can't cover up the fact that there are many to be done. We can't cover up the fact that there are many New fact that there are many New Zealanders fact that there are many New Zealanders out fact that there are many New Zealanders out there fact that there are many New Zealanders out there who fact that there are many New Zealanders out there who are Zealanders out there who are suffering Zealanders out there who are suffering at Zealanders out there who are suffering at the Zealanders out there who are suffering at the moment. Zealanders out there who are suffering at the moment. They Zealanders out there who are suffering at the moment. They might suffering at the moment. They might not suffering at the moment. They might not be suffering at the moment. They might not be obvious suffering at the moment. They might not be obvious to suffering at the moment. They might not be obvious to some suffering at the moment. They might not be obvious to some opposite, not be obvious to some opposite, because not be obvious to some opposite, because for not be obvious to some opposite, because for many not be obvious to some opposite, because for many of not be obvious to some opposite, because for many of them, not be obvious to some opposite, because for many of them, they're because for many of them, they're out because for many of them, they're out of because for many of them, they're out of touch because for many of them, they're out of touch with because for many of them, they're out of touch with what's because for many of them, they're out of touch with what's happening out of touch with what's happening around out of touch with what's happening around our out of touch with what's happening around our country. out of touch with what's happening around our country. But out of touch with what's happening around our country. But for out of touch with what's happening around our country. But for us, out of touch with what's happening around our country. But for us, we around our country. But for us, we are around our country. But for us, we are ready around our country. But for us, we are ready - around our country. But for us, we are ready - and around our country. But for us, we are ready - and may around our country. But for us, we are ready - and may be around our country. But for us, we are ready - and may be now around our country. But for us, we are ready - and may be now the around our country. But for us, we are ready - and may be now the air are ready - and may be now the air will are ready - and may be now the air will be are ready - and may be now the air will be clear, are ready - and may be now the air will be clear, so are ready - and may be now the air will be clear, so that are ready - and may be now the air will be clear, so that people are ready - and may be now the air will be clear, so that people will will be clear, so that people will be will be clear, so that people will be able will be clear, so that people will be able to will be clear, so that people will be able to hear will be clear, so that people will be able to hear our will be clear, so that people will be able to hear our plans will be clear, so that people will be able to hear our plans as will be clear, so that people will be able to hear our plans as to will be clear, so that people will be able to hear our plans as to what be able to hear our plans as to what we be able to hear our plans as to what we want be able to hear our plans as to what we want to be able to hear our plans as to what we want to do be able to hear our plans as to what we want to do for be able to hear our plans as to what we want to do for a be able to hear our plans as to what we want to do for a better be able to hear our plans as to what we want to do for a better New we want to do for a better New Zealand. we want to do for a better New Zealand. And we want to do for a better New Zealand. And we're we want to do for a better New Zealand. And we're going we want to do for a better New Zealand. And we're going to we want to do for a better New Zealand. And we're going to go we want to do for a better New Zealand. And we're going to go out Zealand. And we're going to go out and Zealand. And we're going to go out and we're Zealand. And we're going to go out and we're going Zealand. And we're going to go out and we're going to Zealand. And we're going to go out and we're going to ask Zealand. And we're going to go out and we're going to ask the Zealand. And we're going to go out and we're going to ask the questions and we're going to ask the questions of and we're going to ask the questions of New and we're going to ask the questions of New Zealanders, and we're going to ask the questions of New Zealanders, we're and we're going to ask the questions of New Zealanders, we're going and we're going to ask the questions of New Zealanders, we're going to of New Zealanders, we're going to say, of New Zealanders, we're going to say, "Should of New Zealanders, we're going to say, "Should New of New Zealanders, we're going to say, "Should New Zealanders, of New Zealanders, we're going to say, "Should New Zealanders, young say, "Should New Zealanders, young New say, "Should New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, say, "Should New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, miss say, "Should New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, miss out say, "Should New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, miss out on say, "Should New Zealanders, young New Zealanders, miss out on owning New Zealanders, miss out on owning their New Zealanders, miss out on owning their own New Zealanders, miss out on owning their own home? New Zealanders, miss out on owning their own home? Should New Zealanders, miss out on owning their own home? Should older New Zealanders, miss out on owning their own home? Should older New their own home? Should older New Zealanders their own home? Should older New Zealanders miss their own home? Should older New Zealanders miss out their own home? Should older New Zealanders miss out in their own home? Should older New Zealanders miss out in getting their own home? Should older New Zealanders miss out in getting the Zealanders miss out in getting the healthcare Zealanders miss out in getting the healthcare that Zealanders miss out in getting the healthcare that they Zealanders miss out in getting the healthcare that they need? Zealanders miss out in getting the healthcare that they need? People healthcare that they need? People like healthcare that they need? People like Trixie healthcare that they need? People like Trixie Cottingham, healthcare that they need? People like Trixie Cottingham, who healthcare that they need? People like Trixie Cottingham, who had like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours taken like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours taken off like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours taken off here, like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours taken off here, time like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours taken off here, time taken like Trixie Cottingham, who had hours taken off here, time taken off hours taken off here, time taken off here, hours taken off here, time taken off here, for hours taken off here, time taken off here, for her hours taken off here, time taken off here, for her home hours taken off here, time taken off here, for her home help. hours taken off here, time taken off here, for her home help. Why hours taken off here, time taken off here, for her home help. Why would here, for her home help. Why would we here, for her home help. Why would we do here, for her home help. Why would we do that here, for her home help. Why would we do that to here, for her home help. Why would we do that to a here, for her home help. Why would we do that to a 96-year-old here, for her home help. Why would we do that to a 96-year-old in here, for her home help. Why would we do that to a 96-year-old in a we do that to a 96-year-old in a land we do that to a 96-year-old in a land of we do that to a 96-year-old in a land of plenty? we do that to a 96-year-old in a land of plenty? We're we do that to a 96-year-old in a land of plenty? We're going we do that to a 96-year-old in a land of plenty? We're going to we do that to a 96-year-old in a land of plenty? We're going to go land of plenty? We're going to go out land of plenty? We're going to go out there land of plenty? We're going to go out there and land of plenty? We're going to go out there and ask land of plenty? We're going to go out there and ask people, land of plenty? We're going to go out there and ask people, if land of plenty? We're going to go out there and ask people, if they're out there and ask people, if they're going out there and ask people, if they're going to out there and ask people, if they're going to work, out there and ask people, if they're going to work, shouldn't out there and ask people, if they're going to work, shouldn't they out there and ask people, if they're going to work, shouldn't they get out there and ask people, if they're going to work, shouldn't they get a going to work, shouldn't they get a decent going to work, shouldn't they get a decent wage going to work, shouldn't they get a decent wage and going to work, shouldn't they get a decent wage and decent going to work, shouldn't they get a decent wage and decent working decent wage and decent working conditions? decent wage and decent working conditions? We're decent wage and decent working conditions? We're going decent wage and decent working conditions? We're going to decent wage and decent working conditions? We're going to go decent wage and decent working conditions? We're going to go out conditions? We're going to go out there conditions? We're going to go out there and conditions? We're going to go out there and say conditions? We're going to go out there and say to conditions? We're going to go out there and say to parents, conditions? We're going to go out there and say to parents, should there and say to parents, should they there and say to parents, should they be there and say to parents, should they be paying there and say to parents, should they be paying for there and say to parents, should they be paying for their there and say to parents, should they be paying for their education they be paying for their education for they be paying for their education for their they be paying for their education for their children, they be paying for their education for their children, when they be paying for their education for their children, when they they be paying for their education for their children, when they are for their children, when they are dipping for their children, when they are dipping in for their children, when they are dipping in their for their children, when they are dipping in their pocket for their children, when they are dipping in their pocket every for their children, when they are dipping in their pocket every day for their children, when they are dipping in their pocket every day to dipping in their pocket every day to meet dipping in their pocket every day to meet their dipping in their pocket every day to meet their expenses? dipping in their pocket every day to meet their expenses? So dipping in their pocket every day to meet their expenses? So we dipping in their pocket every day to meet their expenses? So we will dipping in their pocket every day to meet their expenses? So we will be meet their expenses? So we will be putting meet their expenses? So we will be putting forward meet their expenses? So we will be putting forward those meet their expenses? So we will be putting forward those questions meet their expenses? So we will be putting forward those questions but, putting forward those questions but, more putting forward those questions but, more importantly, putting forward those questions but, more importantly, we putting forward those questions but, more importantly, we will putting forward those questions but, more importantly, we will be more importantly, we will be providing more importantly, we will be providing the more importantly, we will be providing the plan more importantly, we will be providing the plan to more importantly, we will be providing the plan to address more importantly, we will be providing the plan to address them. providing the plan to address them. But providing the plan to address them. But this providing the plan to address them. But this resignation, providing the plan to address them. But this resignation, in providing the plan to address them. But this resignation, in my providing the plan to address them. But this resignation, in my view, But this resignation, in my view, has But this resignation, in my view, has exposed But this resignation, in my view, has exposed a But this resignation, in my view, has exposed a National But this resignation, in my view, has exposed a National caucus But this resignation, in my view, has exposed a National caucus for has exposed a National caucus for what has exposed a National caucus for what it has exposed a National caucus for what it is has exposed a National caucus for what it is - has exposed a National caucus for what it is - a has exposed a National caucus for what it is - a bunch has exposed a National caucus for what it is - a bunch of has exposed a National caucus for what it is - a bunch of independent what it is - a bunch of independent more what it is - a bunch of independent sole traders, interested what it is - a bunch of independent sole traders, interested in sole traders, interested in themselves. sole traders, interested in themselves. So sole traders, interested in themselves. So we sole traders, interested in themselves. So we see sole traders, interested in themselves. So we see the themselves. So we see the discontent. themselves. So we see the discontent. We themselves. So we see the discontent. We now themselves. So we see the discontent. We now see themselves. So we see the discontent. We now see the themselves. So we see the discontent. We now see the disbelief discontent. We now see the disbelief at discontent. We now see the disbelief at losing discontent. We now see the disbelief at losing their discontent. We now see the disbelief at losing their leader. discontent. We now see the disbelief at losing their leader. We discontent. We now see the disbelief at losing their leader. We see discontent. We now see the disbelief at losing their leader. We see the at losing their leader. We see the disaffection at losing their leader. We see the disaffection growing at losing their leader. We see the disaffection growing and at losing their leader. We see the disaffection growing and the at losing their leader. We see the disaffection growing and the envy disaffection growing and the envy and disaffection growing and the envy and the disaffection growing and the envy and the resentiment disaffection growing and the envy and the resentiment and disaffection growing and the envy and the resentiment and the and the resentiment and the resentiment and the resentiment and the resentiment will and the resentiment and the resentiment will growing and the resentiment and the resentiment will growing about and the resentiment and the resentiment will growing about John resentiment will growing about John Key resentiment will growing about John Key leaving, resentiment will growing about John Key leaving, because resentiment will growing about John Key leaving, because he resentiment will growing about John Key leaving, because he was resentiment will growing about John Key leaving, because he was their Key leaving, because he was their get Key leaving, because he was their get out Key leaving, because he was their get out of Key leaving, because he was their get out of jail Key leaving, because he was their get out of jail card, Key leaving, because he was their get out of jail card, he Key leaving, because he was their get out of jail card, he was Key leaving, because he was their get out of jail card, he was the get out of jail card, he was the person get out of jail card, he was the person who get out of jail card, he was the person who was get out of jail card, he was the person who was going get out of jail card, he was the person who was going to get out of jail card, he was the person who was going to ensure get out of jail card, he was the person who was going to ensure the person who was going to ensure the fourth person who was going to ensure the fourth term, person who was going to ensure the fourth term, and person who was going to ensure the fourth term, and now person who was going to ensure the fourth term, and now he person who was going to ensure the fourth term, and now he is person who was going to ensure the fourth term, and now he is gone. person who was going to ensure the fourth term, and now he is gone. So fourth term, and now he is gone. So I fourth term, and now he is gone. So I believe fourth term, and now he is gone. So I believe that fourth term, and now he is gone. So I believe that we're fourth term, and now he is gone. So I believe that we're now fourth term, and now he is gone. So I believe that we're now seeing fourth term, and now he is gone. So I believe that we're now seeing the I believe that we're now seeing the knives I believe that we're now seeing the knives out. I believe that we're now seeing the knives out. The I believe that we're now seeing the knives out. The new I believe that we're now seeing the knives out. The new suits I believe that we're now seeing the knives out. The new suits are I believe that we're now seeing the knives out. The new suits are being knives out. The new suits are being bought, knives out. The new suits are being bought, the knives out. The new suits are being bought, the flash knives out. The new suits are being bought, the flash ties knives out. The new suits are being bought, the flash ties are knives out. The new suits are being bought, the flash ties are being knives out. The new suits are being bought, the flash ties are being put bought, the flash ties are being put on, bought, the flash ties are being put on, and bought, the flash ties are being put on, and they bought, the flash ties are being put on, and they are bought, the flash ties are being put on, and they are going bought, the flash ties are being put on, and they are going around bought, the flash ties are being put on, and they are going around our on, and they are going around our people on, and they are going around our people who on, and they are going around our people who would on, and they are going around our people who would like on, and they are going around our people who would like to on, and they are going around our people who would like to be on, and they are going around our people who would like to be the on, and they are going around our people who would like to be the next people who would like to be the next PM people who would like to be the next PM are people who would like to be the next PM are going people who would like to be the next PM are going around people who would like to be the next PM are going around sitting people who would like to be the next PM are going around sitting next people who would like to be the next PM are going around sitting next to PM are going around sitting next to colleagues PM are going around sitting next to colleagues - PM are going around sitting next to colleagues - in PM are going around sitting next to colleagues - in fact, PM are going around sitting next to colleagues - in fact, colleagues PM are going around sitting next to colleagues - in fact, colleagues on colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the other colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the other side colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the other side have colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the other side have told colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the other side have told me colleagues - in fact, colleagues on the other side have told me they've the other side have told me they've never the other side have told me they've never had the other side have told me they've never had so the other side have told me they've never had so many the other side have told me they've never had so many phone the other side have told me they've never had so many phone calls the other side have told me they've never had so many phone calls from never had so many phone calls from their never had so many phone calls from their caucus never had so many phone calls from their caucus in never had so many phone calls from their caucus in their never had so many phone calls from their caucus in their life! never had so many phone calls from their caucus in their life! The their caucus in their life! The knives their caucus in their life! The knives are their caucus in their life! The knives are out, their caucus in their life! The knives are out, and their caucus in their life! The knives are out, and what's their caucus in their life! The knives are out, and what's going their caucus in their life! The knives are out, and what's going to knives are out, and what's going to be knives are out, and what's going to be interesting knives are out, and what's going to be interesting is knives are out, and what's going to be interesting is which knives are out, and what's going to be interesting is which knife knives are out, and what's going to be interesting is which knife will be interesting is which knife will be be interesting is which knife will be the be interesting is which knife will be the sharpest be interesting is which knife will be the sharpest one? be interesting is which knife will be the sharpest one? Will be interesting is which knife will be the sharpest one? Will it be interesting is which knife will be the sharpest one? Will it be be the sharpest one? Will it be Judith be the sharpest one? Will it be Judith Collins' be the sharpest one? Will it be Judith Collins' stiletto? be the sharpest one? Will it be Judith Collins' stiletto? The be the sharpest one? Will it be Judith Collins' stiletto? The one Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that slips Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that slips in Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that slips in very, Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that slips in very, very Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that slips in very, very easily, Judith Collins' stiletto? The one that slips in very, very easily, it that slips in very, very easily, it slips that slips in very, very easily, it slips in that slips in very, very easily, it slips in when that slips in very, very easily, it slips in when you that slips in very, very easily, it slips in when you are that slips in very, very easily, it slips in when you are not that slips in very, very easily, it slips in when you are not watching. slips in when you are not watching. It's slips in when you are not watching. It's called slips in when you are not watching. It's called the slips in when you are not watching. It's called the silent slips in when you are not watching. It's called the silent killer slips in when you are not watching. It's called the silent killer of It's called the silent killer of ambition. It's called the silent killer of ambition. Then It's called the silent killer of ambition. Then we It's called the silent killer of ambition. Then we have It's called the silent killer of ambition. Then we have Jonathan ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman - ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman - well, ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman - well, he ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman - well, he will ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman - well, he will have ambition. Then we have Jonathan Coleman - well, he will have the Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel and Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel and he Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel and he will Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel and he will be Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel and he will be wielding Coleman - well, he will have the scalpel and he will be wielding it scalpel and he will be wielding it with scalpel and he will be wielding it with total scalpel and he will be wielding it with total lack scalpel and he will be wielding it with total lack of scalpel and he will be wielding it with total lack of precision, with total lack of precision, because with total lack of precision, because he with total lack of precision, because he knows with total lack of precision, because he knows how with total lack of precision, because he knows how good with total lack of precision, because he knows how good he with total lack of precision, because he knows how good he is, because he knows how good he is, even because he knows how good he is, even if because he knows how good he is, even if everybody because he knows how good he is, even if everybody else because he knows how good he is, even if everybody else doesn't. because he knows how good he is, even if everybody else doesn't. So even if everybody else doesn't. So we're even if everybody else doesn't. So we're going even if everybody else doesn't. So we're going to even if everybody else doesn't. So we're going to see even if everybody else doesn't. So we're going to see between even if everybody else doesn't. So we're going to see between him even if everybody else doesn't. So we're going to see between him and we're going to see between him and Bill we're going to see between him and Bill English, we're going to see between him and Bill English, what we're going to see between him and Bill English, what has we're going to see between him and Bill English, what has been we're going to see between him and Bill English, what has been called Bill English, what has been called the Bill English, what has been called the battle Bill English, what has been called the battle of Bill English, what has been called the battle of the Bill English, what has been called the battle of the mustards Bill English, what has been called the battle of the mustards - Bill English, what has been called the battle of the mustards - the the battle of the mustards - the Colemans the battle of the mustards - the Colemans and the battle of the mustards - the Colemans and the the battle of the mustards - the Colemans and the English the battle of the mustards - the Colemans and the English mustards Colemans and the English mustards are Colemans and the English mustards are going Colemans and the English mustards are going to Colemans and the English mustards are going to be Colemans and the English mustards are going to be battle Colemans and the English mustards are going to be battle for Colemans and the English mustards are going to be battle for the are going to be battle for the leadership. are going to be battle for the leadership. Then are going to be battle for the leadership. Then we are going to be battle for the leadership. Then we have are going to be battle for the leadership. Then we have Bill leadership. Then we have Bill English leadership. Then we have Bill English - leadership. Then we have Bill English - well, leadership. Then we have Bill English - well, the leadership. Then we have Bill English - well, the knife leadership. Then we have Bill English - well, the knife he leadership. Then we have Bill English - well, the knife he is English - well, the knife he is going English - well, the knife he is going to English - well, the knife he is going to have English - well, the knife he is going to have is English - well, the knife he is going to have is an English - well, the knife he is going to have is an old English - well, the knife he is going to have is an old rusty going to have is an old rusty carving going to have is an old rusty carving knife. going to have is an old rusty carving knife. It going to have is an old rusty carving knife. It has going to have is an old rusty carving knife. It has been going to have is an old rusty carving knife. It has been in going to have is an old rusty carving knife. It has been in the carving knife. It has been in the back carving knife. It has been in the back drawer carving knife. It has been in the back drawer for carving knife. It has been in the back drawer for 13 carving knife. It has been in the back drawer for 13 years carving knife. It has been in the back drawer for 13 years and carving knife. It has been in the back drawer for 13 years and I carving knife. It has been in the back drawer for 13 years and I have back drawer for 13 years and I have to back drawer for 13 years and I have to tell back drawer for 13 years and I have to tell Bill back drawer for 13 years and I have to tell Bill English, back drawer for 13 years and I have to tell Bill English, it back drawer for 13 years and I have to tell Bill English, it is back drawer for 13 years and I have to tell Bill English, it is actually to tell Bill English, it is actually beyond to tell Bill English, it is actually beyond sharpening. to tell Bill English, it is actually beyond sharpening. Then to tell Bill English, it is actually beyond sharpening. Then we to tell Bill English, it is actually beyond sharpening. Then we have beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula Bennett beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula Bennett - beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula Bennett - she beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula Bennett - she hasn't beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula Bennett - she hasn't put beyond sharpening. Then we have Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in but Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in but she Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in but she is Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in but she is looking Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in but she is looking for Paula Bennett - she hasn't put her name in but she is looking for a name in but she is looking for a position name in but she is looking for a position and name in but she is looking for a position and she name in but she is looking for a position and she has name in but she is looking for a position and she has got name in but she is looking for a position and she has got a name in but she is looking for a position and she has got a boning position and she has got a boning knife, position and she has got a boning knife, she position and she has got a boning knife, she is position and she has got a boning knife, she is expert position and she has got a boning knife, she is expert at position and she has got a boning knife, she is expert at removing knife, she is expert at removing meat knife, she is expert at removing meat from knife, she is expert at removing meat from the knife, she is expert at removing meat from the bone knife, she is expert at removing meat from the bone and knife, she is expert at removing meat from the bone and she knife, she is expert at removing meat from the bone and she practiced meat from the bone and she practiced first meat from the bone and she practiced first on meat from the bone and she practiced first on beneficiaries, meat from the bone and she practiced first on beneficiaries, so meat from the bone and she practiced first on beneficiaries, so she meat from the bone and she practiced first on beneficiaries, so she will first on beneficiaries, so she will certainly first on beneficiaries, so she will certainly very first on beneficiaries, so she will certainly very skilled first on beneficiaries, so she will certainly very skilled with first on beneficiaries, so she will certainly very skilled with the certainly very skilled with the boning certainly very skilled with the boning knife. certainly very skilled with the boning knife. And certainly very skilled with the boning knife. And then certainly very skilled with the boning knife. And then of certainly very skilled with the boning knife. And then of course boning knife. And then of course Steven boning knife. And then of course Steven Joyce boning knife. And then of course Steven Joyce has boning knife. And then of course Steven Joyce has the boning knife. And then of course Steven Joyce has the utility boning knife. And then of course Steven Joyce has the utility knife boning knife. And then of course Steven Joyce has the utility knife - Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he has Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he has got Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he has got the Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he has got the knife Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he has got the knife that Steven Joyce has the utility knife - he has got the knife that goes he has got the knife that goes across he has got the knife that goes across all he has got the knife that goes across all portfolios, he has got the knife that goes across all portfolios, and across all portfolios, and especially across all portfolios, and especially portfolios across all portfolios, and especially portfolios where across all portfolios, and especially portfolios where there's especially portfolios where there's lots especially portfolios where there's lots of especially portfolios where there's lots of stuff-ups. especially portfolios where there's lots of stuff-ups. So especially portfolios where there's lots of stuff-ups. So when especially portfolios where there's lots of stuff-ups. So when -- especially portfolios where there's lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what we lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what we know lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what we know is, lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what we know is, across lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what we know is, across there, lots of stuff-ups. So when -- so what we know is, across there, the what we know is, across there, the fight what we know is, across there, the fight has what we know is, across there, the fight has begun. what we know is, across there, the fight has begun. Do what we know is, across there, the fight has begun. Do you what we know is, across there, the fight has begun. Do you know, fight has begun. Do you know, they've fight has begun. Do you know, they've got fight has begun. Do you know, they've got two fight has begun. Do you know, they've got two ABCs fight has begun. Do you know, they've got two ABCs already fight has begun. Do you know, they've got two ABCs already - they've got two ABCs already - they've they've got two ABCs already - they've got they've got two ABCs already - they've got "Anyone they've got two ABCs already - they've got "Anyone but they've got two ABCs already - they've got "Anyone but Coleman" they've got two ABCs already - they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone by they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone by Collins". they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone by Collins". And they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone by Collins". And three they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone by Collins". And three AB they've got "Anyone but Coleman" and "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs - "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs - anyone "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs - anyone but "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs - anyone but Bill, "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs - anyone but Bill, anyone "Anyone by Collins". And three AB Bs - anyone but Bill, anyone but - anyone but Bill, anyone but Bennett - anyone but Bill, anyone but Bennett and - anyone but Bill, anyone but Bennett and anyone - anyone but Bill, anyone but Bennett and anyone but - anyone but Bill, anyone but Bennett and anyone but Bridges. - anyone but Bill, anyone but Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the battle Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the battle is Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the battle is on. Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the battle is on. The Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the battle is on. The phones Bennett and anyone but Bridges. So the battle is on. The phones are the battle is on. The phones are running the battle is on. The phones are running hot, the battle is on. The phones are running hot, as the battle is on. The phones are running hot, as I the battle is on. The phones are running hot, as I said. the battle is on. The phones are running hot, as I said. We're the battle is on. The phones are running hot, as I said. We're here running hot, as I said. We're here watching. running hot, as I said. We're here watching. But running hot, as I said. We're here watching. But what running hot, as I said. We're here watching. But what we're running hot, as I said. We're here watching. But what we're telling running hot, as I said. We're here watching. But what we're telling New watching. But what we're telling New Zealanders watching. But what we're telling New Zealanders is watching. But what we're telling New Zealanders is while watching. But what we're telling New Zealanders is while they watching. But what we're telling New Zealanders is while they fight Zealanders is while they fight amongst Zealanders is while they fight amongst themselves Zealanders is while they fight amongst themselves we Zealanders is while they fight amongst themselves we have Zealanders is while they fight amongst themselves we have a Zealanders is while they fight amongst themselves we have a plan Zealanders is while they fight amongst themselves we have a plan to amongst themselves we have a plan to take amongst themselves we have a plan to take New amongst themselves we have a plan to take New Zealand amongst themselves we have a plan to take New Zealand forward amongst themselves we have a plan to take New Zealand forward and amongst themselves we have a plan to take New Zealand forward and make take New Zealand forward and make this take New Zealand forward and make this a take New Zealand forward and make this a much take New Zealand forward and make this a much better take New Zealand forward and make this a much better place take New Zealand forward and make this a much better place than take New Zealand forward and make this a much better place than it take New Zealand forward and make this a much better place than it is this a much better place than it is now. Tena Tena koe, Tena koe, Mr Tena koe, Mr Speaker. Tena koe, Mr Speaker. <SPEAKS Tena koe, Mr Speaker. <SPEAKS TE Tena koe, Mr Speaker. <SPEAKS TE REO Tena koe, Mr Speaker. <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> I I stand I stand to I stand to acknowledge I stand to acknowledge the I stand to acknowledge the PM I stand to acknowledge the PM without I stand to acknowledge the PM without necessarily I stand to acknowledge the PM without necessarily getting I stand to acknowledge the PM without necessarily getting another without necessarily getting another opportunity without necessarily getting another opportunity to without necessarily getting another opportunity to do without necessarily getting another opportunity to do it, without necessarily getting another opportunity to do it, on without necessarily getting another opportunity to do it, on behalf without necessarily getting another opportunity to do it, on behalf of opportunity to do it, on behalf of the opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori Party opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori Party to opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori Party to the opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori Party to the PM opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori Party to the PM of opportunity to do it, on behalf of the Maori Party to the PM of the the Maori Party to the PM of the day, the Maori Party to the PM of the day, still the Maori Party to the PM of the day, still John the Maori Party to the PM of the day, still John Key, the Maori Party to the PM of the day, still John Key, and the Maori Party to the PM of the day, still John Key, and thank the Maori Party to the PM of the day, still John Key, and thank him day, still John Key, and thank him for day, still John Key, and thank him for his day, still John Key, and thank him for his willingness day, still John Key, and thank him for his willingness to day, still John Key, and thank him for his willingness to work day, still John Key, and thank him for his willingness to work with day, still John Key, and thank him for his willingness to work with the for his willingness to work with the Maori for his willingness to work with the Maori Party. for his willingness to work with the Maori Party. People for his willingness to work with the Maori Party. People have for his willingness to work with the Maori Party. People have to for his willingness to work with the Maori Party. People have to remember Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Party Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Party comes Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Party comes about Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Party comes about from Maori Party. People have to remember the Maori Party comes about from an the Maori Party comes about from an invitation the Maori Party comes about from an invitation to the Maori Party comes about from an invitation to sit the Maori Party comes about from an invitation to sit next the Maori Party comes about from an invitation to sit next to the Maori Party comes about from an invitation to sit next to National invitation to sit next to National and invitation to sit next to National and in invitation to sit next to National and in the invitation to sit next to National and in the eight invitation to sit next to National and in the eight years invitation to sit next to National and in the eight years or invitation to sit next to National and in the eight years or so invitation to sit next to National and in the eight years or so we invitation to sit next to National and in the eight years or so we have and in the eight years or so we have been and in the eight years or so we have been here and in the eight years or so we have been here - and in the eight years or so we have been here - actually and in the eight years or so we have been here - actually longer and in the eight years or so we have been here - actually longer than been here - actually longer than that been here - actually longer than that but been here - actually longer than that but in been here - actually longer than that but in the been here - actually longer than that but in the eight been here - actually longer than that but in the eight years been here - actually longer than that but in the eight years we been here - actually longer than that but in the eight years we have that but in the eight years we have had that but in the eight years we have had a that but in the eight years we have had a relationship that but in the eight years we have had a relationship with that but in the eight years we have had a relationship with the that but in the eight years we have had a relationship with the National had a relationship with the National Party, had a relationship with the National Party, it had a relationship with the National Party, it has had a relationship with the National Party, it has come had a relationship with the National Party, it has come about had a relationship with the National Party, it has come about from had a relationship with the National Party, it has come about from an Party, it has come about from an invitation Party, it has come about from an invitation from Party, it has come about from an invitation from the Party, it has come about from an invitation from the PM Party, it has come about from an invitation from the PM to Party, it has come about from an invitation from the PM to the Party, it has come about from an invitation from the PM to the Maori invitation from the PM to the Maori Party invitation from the PM to the Maori Party to invitation from the PM to the Maori Party to sit invitation from the PM to the Maori Party to sit as invitation from the PM to the Maori Party to sit as a invitation from the PM to the Maori Party to sit as a partner invitation from the PM to the Maori Party to sit as a partner with Party to sit as a partner with Government. Party to sit as a partner with Government. Why? Party to sit as a partner with Government. Why? Because, Party to sit as a partner with Government. Why? Because, for Government. Why? Because, for whatever Government. Why? Because, for whatever reason, Government. Why? Because, for whatever reason, the Government. Why? Because, for whatever reason, the PM Government. Why? Because, for whatever reason, the PM felt Government. Why? Because, for whatever reason, the PM felt that Government. Why? Because, for whatever reason, the PM felt that we whatever reason, the PM felt that we brought whatever reason, the PM felt that we brought something whatever reason, the PM felt that we brought something extra, whatever reason, the PM felt that we brought something extra, something brought something extra, something dynamic, brought something extra, something dynamic, something brought something extra, something dynamic, something unique, brought something extra, something dynamic, something unique, something dynamic, something unique, something wonderful, dynamic, something unique, something wonderful, something dynamic, something unique, something wonderful, something mana-enhancing, wonderful, something mana-enhancing, something wonderful, something mana-enhancing, something beautiful, wonderful, something mana-enhancing, something beautiful, something something beautiful, something advantageous something beautiful, something advantageous - something beautiful, something advantageous - that's something beautiful, something advantageous - that's right, advantageous - that's right, valuable, advantageous - that's right, valuable, all advantageous - that's right, valuable, all of advantageous - that's right, valuable, all of those advantageous - that's right, valuable, all of those words, advantageous - that's right, valuable, all of those words, my valuable, all of those words, my sister valuable, all of those words, my sister - valuable, all of those words, my sister - to valuable, all of those words, my sister - to the valuable, all of those words, my sister - to the country, valuable, all of those words, my sister - to the country, but valuable, all of those words, my sister - to the country, but also, sister - to the country, but also, strangely sister - to the country, but also, strangely enough, sister - to the country, but also, strangely enough, allow sister - to the country, but also, strangely enough, allow us sister - to the country, but also, strangely enough, allow us to sister - to the country, but also, strangely enough, allow us to vote strangely enough, allow us to vote against strangely enough, allow us to vote against the strangely enough, allow us to vote against the Government strangely enough, allow us to vote against the Government if strangely enough, allow us to vote against the Government if we strangely enough, allow us to vote against the Government if we wanted against the Government if we wanted to. against the Government if we wanted to. He, against the Government if we wanted to. He, as against the Government if we wanted to. He, as well against the Government if we wanted to. He, as well as against the Government if we wanted to. He, as well as other against the Government if we wanted to. He, as well as other ministers, to. He, as well as other ministers, have to. He, as well as other ministers, have acknowledged to. He, as well as other ministers, have acknowledged that to. He, as well as other ministers, have acknowledged that sometimes have acknowledged that sometimes that have acknowledged that sometimes that is have acknowledged that sometimes that is not have acknowledged that sometimes that is not all have acknowledged that sometimes that is not all the have acknowledged that sometimes that is not all the best have acknowledged that sometimes that is not all the best thing have acknowledged that sometimes that is not all the best thing from that is not all the best thing from their that is not all the best thing from their perspective, that is not all the best thing from their perspective, but that is not all the best thing from their perspective, but from that is not all the best thing from their perspective, but from our that is not all the best thing from their perspective, but from our part their perspective, but from our part and their perspective, but from our part and certainly their perspective, but from our part and certainly from their perspective, but from our part and certainly from myself, their perspective, but from our part and certainly from myself, from and certainly from myself, from Marama, and certainly from myself, from Marama, my and certainly from myself, from Marama, my colleague, and certainly from myself, from Marama, my colleague, and and certainly from myself, from Marama, my colleague, and the and certainly from myself, from Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Sir Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Sir Peter Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Sir Peter Sharples, Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Sir Peter Sharples, I'm Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure Marama, my colleague, and the Hon Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they bring Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they bring a Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they bring a huge Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they bring a huge amount Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they bring a huge amount of Sir Peter Sharples, I'm sure that they bring a huge amount of respect they bring a huge amount of respect for they bring a huge amount of respect for the they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM John they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM John Key they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM John Key for they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM John Key for what they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM John Key for what he they bring a huge amount of respect for the PM John Key for what he has for the PM John Key for what he has done for the PM John Key for what he has done with for the PM John Key for what he has done with this for the PM John Key for what he has done with this mana-enhancing done with this mana-enhancing relationship. done with this mana-enhancing relationship. It done with this mana-enhancing relationship. It has done with this mana-enhancing relationship. It has always done with this mana-enhancing relationship. It has always been done with this mana-enhancing relationship. It has always been on relationship. It has always been on the relationship. It has always been on the ingredient relationship. It has always been on the ingredient of relationship. It has always been on the ingredient of being relationship. It has always been on the ingredient of being an relationship. It has always been on the ingredient of being an element the ingredient of being an element of the ingredient of being an element of integrity, the ingredient of being an element of integrity, being the ingredient of being an element of integrity, being straight the ingredient of being an element of integrity, being straight up, of integrity, being straight up, true of integrity, being straight up, true to of integrity, being straight up, true to your of integrity, being straight up, true to your word of integrity, being straight up, true to your word and of integrity, being straight up, true to your word and trustworthy of integrity, being straight up, true to your word and trustworthy in true to your word and trustworthy in the true to your word and trustworthy in the words true to your word and trustworthy in the words you true to your word and trustworthy in the words you say true to your word and trustworthy in the words you say to true to your word and trustworthy in the words you say to one true to your word and trustworthy in the words you say to one another true to your word and trustworthy in the words you say to one another and the words you say to one another and even the words you say to one another and even as the words you say to one another and even as recently the words you say to one another and even as recently as the words you say to one another and even as recently as five the words you say to one another and even as recently as five minutes the words you say to one another and even as recently as five minutes ago even as recently as five minutes ago we even as recently as five minutes ago we acknowledged even as recently as five minutes ago we acknowledged that even as recently as five minutes ago we acknowledged that in even as recently as five minutes ago we acknowledged that in his even as recently as five minutes ago we acknowledged that in his office we acknowledged that in his office to we acknowledged that in his office to say we acknowledged that in his office to say thank we acknowledged that in his office to say thank you we acknowledged that in his office to say thank you for we acknowledged that in his office to say thank you for the to say thank you for the contribution, to say thank you for the contribution, not to say thank you for the contribution, not only to say thank you for the contribution, not only to to say thank you for the contribution, not only to the contribution, not only to the country contribution, not only to the country but contribution, not only to the country but certainly contribution, not only to the country but certainly for contribution, not only to the country but certainly for allowing country but certainly for allowing the country but certainly for allowing the Maori country but certainly for allowing the Maori Party country but certainly for allowing the Maori Party to country but certainly for allowing the Maori Party to be country but certainly for allowing the Maori Party to be with country but certainly for allowing the Maori Party to be with the the Maori Party to be with the National the Maori Party to be with the National Party the Maori Party to be with the National Party when the Maori Party to be with the National Party when he the Maori Party to be with the National Party when he has the Maori Party to be with the National Party when he has never, National Party when he has never, ever National Party when he has never, ever needed National Party when he has never, ever needed us National Party when he has never, ever needed us but National Party when he has never, ever needed us but he National Party when he has never, ever needed us but he has National Party when he has never, ever needed us but he has believed ever needed us but he has believed in ever needed us but he has believed in us ever needed us but he has believed in us to ever needed us but he has believed in us to bring ever needed us but he has believed in us to bring something ever needed us but he has believed in us to bring something absolutely in us to bring something absolutely extra in us to bring something absolutely extra to in us to bring something absolutely extra to the in us to bring something absolutely extra to the relationship in us to bring something absolutely extra to the relationship accord extra to the relationship accord with extra to the relationship accord with the extra to the relationship accord with the National extra to the relationship accord with the National Government. extra to the relationship accord with the National Government. Have with the National Government. Have we with the National Government. Have we achieved with the National Government. Have we achieved things? with the National Government. Have we achieved things? Hell, with the National Government. Have we achieved things? Hell, yeah. with the National Government. Have we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not been we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not been for we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not been for the we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not been for the ability we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not been for the ability to we achieved things? Hell, yeah. Had it not been for the ability to sit it not been for the ability to sit next it not been for the ability to sit next to it not been for the ability to sit next to our it not been for the ability to sit next to our Government, it not been for the ability to sit next to our Government, the it not been for the ability to sit next to our Government, the Maori next to our Government, the Maori Purposes next to our Government, the Maori Purposes Bill, next to our Government, the Maori Purposes Bill, and next to our Government, the Maori Purposes Bill, and whanau next to our Government, the Maori Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, next to our Government, the Maori Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would not Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would not have Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would not have been Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would not have been this Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would not have been this stuff. Purposes Bill, and whanau Ora, there would not have been this stuff. So would not have been this stuff. So we would not have been this stuff. So we wish would not have been this stuff. So we wish him would not have been this stuff. So we wish him well would not have been this stuff. So we wish him well in would not have been this stuff. So we wish him well in the would not have been this stuff. So we wish him well in the future. would not have been this stuff. So we wish him well in the future. We we wish him well in the future. We understand we wish him well in the future. We understand his we wish him well in the future. We understand his whanau we wish him well in the future. We understand his whanau is we wish him well in the future. We understand his whanau is important understand his whanau is important and understand his whanau is important and we understand his whanau is important and we allow understand his whanau is important and we allow him understand his whanau is important and we allow him to understand his whanau is important and we allow him to go understand his whanau is important and we allow him to go back understand his whanau is important and we allow him to go back to understand his whanau is important and we allow him to go back to his and we allow him to go back to his whanau, and we allow him to go back to his whanau, well and we allow him to go back to his whanau, well done. There There are There are times There are times in There are times in life There are times in life to There are times in life to be There are times in life to be gracious. There are times in life to be gracious. I There are times in life to be gracious. I want There are times in life to be gracious. I want to There are times in life to be gracious. I want to align There are times in life to be gracious. I want to align myself gracious. I want to align myself with gracious. I want to align myself with the gracious. I want to align myself with the views gracious. I want to align myself with the views of gracious. I want to align myself with the views of the gracious. I want to align myself with the views of the Hon gracious. I want to align myself with the views of the Hon Bill with the views of the Hon Bill English with the views of the Hon Bill English and with the views of the Hon Bill English and Hon with the views of the Hon Bill English and Hon Gerry with the views of the Hon Bill English and Hon Gerry Brownlee with the views of the Hon Bill English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and with the views of the Hon Bill English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I want English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I want to English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I want to honour English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I want to honour the English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I want to honour the contributions English and Hon Gerry Brownlee and I want to honour the contributions of want to honour the contributions of Te want to honour the contributions of Te Ururoa want to honour the contributions of Te Ururoa Flavell want to honour the contributions of Te Ururoa Flavell and want to honour the contributions of Te Ururoa Flavell and the want to honour the contributions of Te Ururoa Flavell and the member want to honour the contributions of Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the ACT Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the ACT Party Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the ACT Party who Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the ACT Party who spoke Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the ACT Party who spoke before Te Ururoa Flavell and the member of the ACT Party who spoke before him the ACT Party who spoke before him and the ACT Party who spoke before him and Peter the ACT Party who spoke before him and Peter Dunne, the ACT Party who spoke before him and Peter Dunne, who, the ACT Party who spoke before him and Peter Dunne, who, although the ACT Party who spoke before him and Peter Dunne, who, although he and Peter Dunne, who, although he hasn't and Peter Dunne, who, although he hasn't spoken and Peter Dunne, who, although he hasn't spoken today, and Peter Dunne, who, although he hasn't spoken today, made and Peter Dunne, who, although he hasn't spoken today, made similar hasn't spoken today, made similar remarks hasn't spoken today, made similar remarks yesterday. hasn't spoken today, made similar remarks yesterday. It hasn't spoken today, made similar remarks yesterday. It doesn't hasn't spoken today, made similar remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean the remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean the leaders remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean the leaders of remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean the leaders of those remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean the leaders of those parties remarks yesterday. It doesn't mean the leaders of those parties endorse the leaders of those parties endorse everything the leaders of those parties endorse everything that the leaders of those parties endorse everything that the the leaders of those parties endorse everything that the National the leaders of those parties endorse everything that the National Party everything that the National Party leads everything that the National Party leads and everything that the National Party leads and decides everything that the National Party leads and decides - everything that the National Party leads and decides - far everything that the National Party leads and decides - far from everything that the National Party leads and decides - far from it, everything that the National Party leads and decides - far from it, and leads and decides - far from it, and that leads and decides - far from it, and that is leads and decides - far from it, and that is a leads and decides - far from it, and that is a matter leads and decides - far from it, and that is a matter of leads and decides - far from it, and that is a matter of public leads and decides - far from it, and that is a matter of public record. that is a matter of public record. But that is a matter of public record. But we that is a matter of public record. But we have that is a matter of public record. But we have there that is a matter of public record. But we have there the that is a matter of public record. But we have there the leaders that is a matter of public record. But we have there the leaders of But we have there the leaders of three But we have there the leaders of three parties But we have there the leaders of three parties who But we have there the leaders of three parties who have But we have there the leaders of three parties who have shown But we have there the leaders of three parties who have shown that, three parties who have shown that, through three parties who have shown that, through relationships three parties who have shown that, through relationships where three parties who have shown that, through relationships where there three parties who have shown that, through relationships where there is through relationships where there is mutual through relationships where there is mutual respect, through relationships where there is mutual respect, a through relationships where there is mutual respect, a genuine through relationships where there is mutual respect, a genuine desire through relationships where there is mutual respect, a genuine desire to mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus on mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus on the mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus on the issues mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus on the issues that mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus on the issues that matter mutual respect, a genuine desire to focus on the issues that matter to focus on the issues that matter to New focus on the issues that matter to New Zealanders, focus on the issues that matter to New Zealanders, and focus on the issues that matter to New Zealanders, and a focus on the issues that matter to New Zealanders, and a realisation New Zealanders, and a realisation that New Zealanders, and a realisation that under New Zealanders, and a realisation that under the New Zealanders, and a realisation that under the MMP New Zealanders, and a realisation that under the MMP system New Zealanders, and a realisation that under the MMP system of that under the MMP system of politics, that under the MMP system of politics, at that under the MMP system of politics, at times that under the MMP system of politics, at times compromises that under the MMP system of politics, at times compromises are politics, at times compromises are necessary, politics, at times compromises are necessary, we politics, at times compromises are necessary, we have politics, at times compromises are necessary, we have enjoyed politics, at times compromises are necessary, we have enjoyed over politics, at times compromises are necessary, we have enjoyed over the necessary, we have enjoyed over the last necessary, we have enjoyed over the last eight necessary, we have enjoyed over the last eight years necessary, we have enjoyed over the last eight years a necessary, we have enjoyed over the last eight years a highly necessary, we have enjoyed over the last eight years a highly successful last eight years a highly successful period last eight years a highly successful period in last eight years a highly successful period in Governmenta last eight years a highly successful period in Governmenta warmly last eight years a highly successful period in Governmenta warmly salute period in Governmenta warmly salute all period in Governmenta warmly salute all three period in Governmenta warmly salute all three of period in Governmenta warmly salute all three of those period in Governmenta warmly salute all three of those parties period in Governmenta warmly salute all three of those parties for period in Governmenta warmly salute all three of those parties for their all three of those parties for their significant all three of those parties for their significant contributions all three of those parties for their significant contributions to all three of those parties for their significant contributions to that. significant contributions to that. What significant contributions to that. What a significant contributions to that. What a shame, significant contributions to that. What a shame, therefore, significant contributions to that. What a shame, therefore, we significant contributions to that. What a shame, therefore, we haven't What a shame, therefore, we haven't seen What a shame, therefore, we haven't seen the What a shame, therefore, we haven't seen the same What a shame, therefore, we haven't seen the same degree What a shame, therefore, we haven't seen the same degree of What a shame, therefore, we haven't seen the same degree of graciousness seen the same degree of graciousness from seen the same degree of graciousness from members seen the same degree of graciousness from members who seen the same degree of graciousness from members who have seen the same degree of graciousness from members who have spoken seen the same degree of graciousness from members who have spoken across from members who have spoken across the from members who have spoken across the House, from members who have spoken across the House, although from members who have spoken across the House, although I from members who have spoken across the House, although I do from members who have spoken across the House, although I do acknowledge the House, although I do acknowledge the the House, although I do acknowledge the remarks the House, although I do acknowledge the remarks that the House, although I do acknowledge the remarks that the the House, although I do acknowledge the remarks that the Hon the House, although I do acknowledge the remarks that the Hon Annette the remarks that the Hon Annette King the remarks that the Hon Annette King commenced the remarks that the Hon Annette King commenced with, the remarks that the Hon Annette King commenced with, and the remarks that the Hon Annette King commenced with, and I the remarks that the Hon Annette King commenced with, and I thank the remarks that the Hon Annette King commenced with, and I thank her King commenced with, and I thank her for King commenced with, and I thank her for that. King commenced with, and I thank her for that. So King commenced with, and I thank her for that. So like King commenced with, and I thank her for that. So like New King commenced with, and I thank her for that. So like New Zealanders, King commenced with, and I thank her for that. So like New Zealanders, I for that. So like New Zealanders, I didn't for that. So like New Zealanders, I didn't wake for that. So like New Zealanders, I didn't wake up for that. So like New Zealanders, I didn't wake up yesterday for that. So like New Zealanders, I didn't wake up yesterday expecting didn't wake up yesterday expecting the didn't wake up yesterday expecting the PM didn't wake up yesterday expecting the PM to didn't wake up yesterday expecting the PM to announce didn't wake up yesterday expecting the PM to announce his didn't wake up yesterday expecting the PM to announce his resignation. the PM to announce his resignation. But the PM to announce his resignation. But after the PM to announce his resignation. But after I the PM to announce his resignation. But after I got the PM to announce his resignation. But after I got over the PM to announce his resignation. But after I got over the the PM to announce his resignation. But after I got over the shock the PM to announce his resignation. But after I got over the shock of But after I got over the shock of what But after I got over the shock of what had But after I got over the shock of what had occurred, But after I got over the shock of what had occurred, and But after I got over the shock of what had occurred, and thought But after I got over the shock of what had occurred, and thought about what had occurred, and thought about it what had occurred, and thought about it over what had occurred, and thought about it over the what had occurred, and thought about it over the day, what had occurred, and thought about it over the day, I what had occurred, and thought about it over the day, I realised what had occurred, and thought about it over the day, I realised it what had occurred, and thought about it over the day, I realised it was it over the day, I realised it was exactly it over the day, I realised it was exactly what it over the day, I realised it was exactly what I it over the day, I realised it was exactly what I was it over the day, I realised it was exactly what I was always it over the day, I realised it was exactly what I was always expected it over the day, I realised it was exactly what I was always expected - exactly what I was always expected - that exactly what I was always expected - that John exactly what I was always expected - that John Key exactly what I was always expected - that John Key would exactly what I was always expected - that John Key would choose exactly what I was always expected - that John Key would choose the that John Key would choose the timing that John Key would choose the timing and that John Key would choose the timing and the that John Key would choose the timing and the manner that John Key would choose the timing and the manner of that John Key would choose the timing and the manner of his timing and the manner of his departure timing and the manner of his departure and timing and the manner of his departure and that timing and the manner of his departure and that he timing and the manner of his departure and that he would timing and the manner of his departure and that he would have timing and the manner of his departure and that he would have the departure and that he would have the opportunity departure and that he would have the opportunity to departure and that he would have the opportunity to leave departure and that he would have the opportunity to leave this departure and that he would have the opportunity to leave this house departure and that he would have the opportunity to leave this house with opportunity to leave this house with his opportunity to leave this house with his head opportunity to leave this house with his head held opportunity to leave this house with his head held high, opportunity to leave this house with his head held high, and opportunity to leave this house with his head held high, and enjoying opportunity to leave this house with his head held high, and enjoying the his head held high, and enjoying the appreciation his head held high, and enjoying the appreciation and his head held high, and enjoying the appreciation and admiration his head held high, and enjoying the appreciation and admiration of his head held high, and enjoying the appreciation and admiration of an appreciation and admiration of an overwhelming appreciation and admiration of an overwhelming number appreciation and admiration of an overwhelming number of appreciation and admiration of an overwhelming number of New overwhelming number of New Zealanders. overwhelming number of New Zealanders. That, overwhelming number of New Zealanders. That, in overwhelming number of New Zealanders. That, in itself, overwhelming number of New Zealanders. That, in itself, is overwhelming number of New Zealanders. That, in itself, is a Zealanders. That, in itself, is a very Zealanders. That, in itself, is a very rare Zealanders. That, in itself, is a very rare achievement Zealanders. That, in itself, is a very rare achievement for Zealanders. That, in itself, is a very rare achievement for any very rare achievement for any politician. very rare achievement for any politician. Despite very rare achievement for any politician. Despite the very rare achievement for any politician. Despite the cheap very rare achievement for any politician. Despite the cheap and politician. Despite the cheap and churlish politician. Despite the cheap and churlish attacks politician. Despite the cheap and churlish attacks that politician. Despite the cheap and churlish attacks that we politician. Despite the cheap and churlish attacks that we heard politician. Despite the cheap and churlish attacks that we heard from churlish attacks that we heard from particularly churlish attacks that we heard from particularly the churlish attacks that we heard from particularly the New churlish attacks that we heard from particularly the New Zealand churlish attacks that we heard from particularly the New Zealand First particularly the New Zealand First party particularly the New Zealand First party today, particularly the New Zealand First party today, and particularly the New Zealand First party today, and also particularly the New Zealand First party today, and also the particularly the New Zealand First party today, and also the leader particularly the New Zealand First party today, and also the leader of party today, and also the leader of the party today, and also the leader of the Greens, party today, and also the leader of the Greens, the party today, and also the leader of the Greens, the fact party today, and also the leader of the Greens, the fact of party today, and also the leader of the Greens, the fact of the party today, and also the leader of the Greens, the fact of the matter the Greens, the fact of the matter is the Greens, the fact of the matter is that the Greens, the fact of the matter is that our the Greens, the fact of the matter is that our PM the Greens, the fact of the matter is that our PM has the Greens, the fact of the matter is that our PM has always the Greens, the fact of the matter is that our PM has always and is that our PM has always and unrelentingly is that our PM has always and unrelentingly focused is that our PM has always and unrelentingly focused on is that our PM has always and unrelentingly focused on the is that our PM has always and unrelentingly focused on the things unrelentingly focused on the things that unrelentingly focused on the things that matter unrelentingly focused on the things that matter most unrelentingly focused on the things that matter most to unrelentingly focused on the things that matter most to New unrelentingly focused on the things that matter most to New Zealanders that matter most to New Zealanders and that matter most to New Zealanders and one that matter most to New Zealanders and one of that matter most to New Zealanders and one of the that matter most to New Zealanders and one of the reasons that matter most to New Zealanders and one of the reasons why that matter most to New Zealanders and one of the reasons why I that matter most to New Zealanders and one of the reasons why I have and one of the reasons why I have been and one of the reasons why I have been so and one of the reasons why I have been so proud and one of the reasons why I have been so proud to and one of the reasons why I have been so proud to be and one of the reasons why I have been so proud to be a and one of the reasons why I have been so proud to be a member and one of the reasons why I have been so proud to be a member of and one of the reasons why I have been so proud to be a member of the been so proud to be a member of the party been so proud to be a member of the party while been so proud to be a member of the party while he been so proud to be a member of the party while he has been so proud to be a member of the party while he has been been so proud to be a member of the party while he has been our been so proud to be a member of the party while he has been our PM been so proud to be a member of the party while he has been our PM has party while he has been our PM has been party while he has been our PM has been that party while he has been our PM has been that we party while he has been our PM has been that we have party while he has been our PM has been that we have made party while he has been our PM has been that we have made a party while he has been our PM has been that we have made a significant been that we have made a significant difference been that we have made a significant difference in been that we have made a significant difference in areas been that we have made a significant difference in areas that been that we have made a significant difference in areas that matter, difference in areas that matter, through difference in areas that matter, through some difference in areas that matter, through some of difference in areas that matter, through some of the difference in areas that matter, through some of the most difference in areas that matter, through some of the most challenging through some of the most challenging times through some of the most challenging times that through some of the most challenging times that our through some of the most challenging times that our country through some of the most challenging times that our country could times that our country could possibly times that our country could possibly have times that our country could possibly have imagined. times that our country could possibly have imagined. No-one times that our country could possibly have imagined. No-one else possibly have imagined. No-one else in possibly have imagined. No-one else in our possibly have imagined. No-one else in our lifetime possibly have imagined. No-one else in our lifetime has possibly have imagined. No-one else in our lifetime has governed possibly have imagined. No-one else in our lifetime has governed through in our lifetime has governed through a in our lifetime has governed through a global in our lifetime has governed through a global financial in our lifetime has governed through a global financial crisis in our lifetime has governed through a global financial crisis of in our lifetime has governed through a global financial crisis of such a global financial crisis of such magnitude. a global financial crisis of such magnitude. No-one a global financial crisis of such magnitude. No-one else a global financial crisis of such magnitude. No-one else in a global financial crisis of such magnitude. No-one else in our magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime has magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime has had magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime has had to magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime has had to lead magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime has had to lead a magnitude. No-one else in our lifetime has had to lead a country lifetime has had to lead a country through lifetime has had to lead a country through the lifetime has had to lead a country through the devastating lifetime has had to lead a country through the devastating Canterbury through the devastating Canterbury earthquakes through the devastating Canterbury earthquakes and, through the devastating Canterbury earthquakes and, more through the devastating Canterbury earthquakes and, more recently, through the devastating Canterbury earthquakes and, more recently, the earthquakes and, more recently, the Kaikoura earthquakes and, more recently, the Kaikoura earthquakes, earthquakes and, more recently, the Kaikoura earthquakes, its earthquakes and, more recently, the Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact earthquakes and, more recently, the Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Wellington Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Wellington and Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Wellington and the Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Wellington and the long Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Wellington and the long period Kaikoura earthquakes, its impact on Wellington and the long period of Wellington and the long period of instability Wellington and the long period of instability and Wellington and the long period of instability and huge Wellington and the long period of instability and huge fiscal Wellington and the long period of instability and huge fiscal impact instability and huge fiscal impact that instability and huge fiscal impact that those instability and huge fiscal impact that those events instability and huge fiscal impact that those events have instability and huge fiscal impact that those events have had. instability and huge fiscal impact that those events have had. We've that those events have had. We've also that those events have had. We've also seen that those events have had. We've also seen a that those events have had. We've also seen a number that those events have had. We've also seen a number of that those events have had. We've also seen a number of other that those events have had. We've also seen a number of other major also seen a number of other major challenges also seen a number of other major challenges - also seen a number of other major challenges - the also seen a number of other major challenges - the Rina also seen a number of other major challenges - the Rina disaster, also seen a number of other major challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, floods, challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, floods, you challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, floods, you name challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, floods, you name it, challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, floods, you name it, the challenges - the Rina disaster, Pike River, floods, you name it, the list River, floods, you name it, the list goes River, floods, you name it, the list goes on. River, floods, you name it, the list goes on. On River, floods, you name it, the list goes on. On every River, floods, you name it, the list goes on. On every one River, floods, you name it, the list goes on. On every one of River, floods, you name it, the list goes on. On every one of those goes on. On every one of those occasions, goes on. On every one of those occasions, the goes on. On every one of those occasions, the PM goes on. On every one of those occasions, the PM and goes on. On every one of those occasions, the PM and the goes on. On every one of those occasions, the PM and the team goes on. On every one of those occasions, the PM and the team he occasions, the PM and the team he has occasions, the PM and the team he has led occasions, the PM and the team he has led have occasions, the PM and the team he has led have stood occasions, the PM and the team he has led have stood beside occasions, the PM and the team he has led have stood beside the occasions, the PM and the team he has led have stood beside the people has led have stood beside the people that has led have stood beside the people that were has led have stood beside the people that were affected, has led have stood beside the people that were affected, have has led have stood beside the people that were affected, have been has led have stood beside the people that were affected, have been there that were affected, have been there to that were affected, have been there to provide that were affected, have been there to provide the that were affected, have been there to provide the support that were affected, have been there to provide the support that that were affected, have been there to provide the support that is to provide the support that is necessary, to provide the support that is necessary, and to provide the support that is necessary, and that to provide the support that is necessary, and that is to provide the support that is necessary, and that is why to provide the support that is necessary, and that is why he to provide the support that is necessary, and that is why he has necessary, and that is why he has maintained necessary, and that is why he has maintained the necessary, and that is why he has maintained the fwrud necessary, and that is why he has maintained the fwrud -- necessary, and that is why he has maintained the fwrud -- gratitude maintained the fwrud -- gratitude and maintained the fwrud -- gratitude and respect maintained the fwrud -- gratitude and respect of maintained the fwrud -- gratitude and respect of so maintained the fwrud -- gratitude and respect of so many maintained the fwrud -- gratitude and respect of so many New and respect of so many New Zealanders. and respect of so many New Zealanders. In and respect of so many New Zealanders. In 2002, and respect of so many New Zealanders. In 2002, John and respect of so many New Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and respect of so many New Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and and respect of so many New Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I were Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I were both Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I were both new Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I were both new candidates Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I were both new candidates for Zealanders. In 2002, John Key and I were both new candidates for the were both new candidates for the National were both new candidates for the National Party. were both new candidates for the National Party. I were both new candidates for the National Party. I have were both new candidates for the National Party. I have to were both new candidates for the National Party. I have to say were both new candidates for the National Party. I have to say that National Party. I have to say that his National Party. I have to say that his campaign National Party. I have to say that his campaign as National Party. I have to say that his campaign as the National Party. I have to say that his campaign as the candidate National Party. I have to say that his campaign as the candidate for his campaign as the candidate for Helensville his campaign as the candidate for Helensville was his campaign as the candidate for Helensville was considerably his campaign as the candidate for Helensville was considerably more Helensville was considerably more successful Helensville was considerably more successful than Helensville was considerably more successful than mine Helensville was considerably more successful than mine was Helensville was considerably more successful than mine was that Helensville was considerably more successful than mine was that year successful than mine was that year in successful than mine was that year in the successful than mine was that year in the devastating successful than mine was that year in the devastating election successful than mine was that year in the devastating election which in the devastating election which saw in the devastating election which saw me in the devastating election which saw me absolutely in the devastating election which saw me absolutely hammered in the devastating election which saw me absolutely hammered in saw me absolutely hammered in Tauranga. saw me absolutely hammered in Tauranga. But saw me absolutely hammered in Tauranga. But I saw me absolutely hammered in Tauranga. But I enjoyed saw me absolutely hammered in Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting saw me absolutely hammered in Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to know Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to know him Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to know him then Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to know him then and Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to know him then and hugely Tauranga. But I enjoyed getting to know him then and hugely admired know him then and hugely admired watching know him then and hugely admired watching his know him then and hugely admired watching his progress know him then and hugely admired watching his progress during know him then and hugely admired watching his progress during the watching his progress during the next watching his progress during the next few watching his progress during the next few years watching his progress during the next few years and watching his progress during the next few years and was watching his progress during the next few years and was very watching his progress during the next few years and was very pleased next few years and was very pleased to next few years and was very pleased to see next few years and was very pleased to see him next few years and was very pleased to see him take next few years and was very pleased to see him take the next few years and was very pleased to see him take the leadership next few years and was very pleased to see him take the leadership of to see him take the leadership of the to see him take the leadership of the party to see him take the leadership of the party when to see him take the leadership of the party when he to see him take the leadership of the party when he did. to see him take the leadership of the party when he did. I to see him take the leadership of the party when he did. I believe the party when he did. I believe that the party when he did. I believe that New the party when he did. I believe that New Zealanders the party when he did. I believe that New Zealanders generally the party when he did. I believe that New Zealanders generally will that New Zealanders generally will acknowledge that New Zealanders generally will acknowledge him that New Zealanders generally will acknowledge him warmly, that New Zealanders generally will acknowledge him warmly, contrary that New Zealanders generally will acknowledge him warmly, contrary to acknowledge him warmly, contrary to what acknowledge him warmly, contrary to what Mr acknowledge him warmly, contrary to what Mr Prosser acknowledge him warmly, contrary to what Mr Prosser said, acknowledge him warmly, contrary to what Mr Prosser said, the acknowledge him warmly, contrary to what Mr Prosser said, the historians what Mr Prosser said, the historians will what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look back what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look back on what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look back on some what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look back on some of what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look back on some of the what Mr Prosser said, the historians will look back on some of the issues will look back on some of the issues that will look back on some of the issues that I will look back on some of the issues that I have will look back on some of the issues that I have just will look back on some of the issues that I have just referred will look back on some of the issues that I have just referred to will look back on some of the issues that I have just referred to and will look back on some of the issues that I have just referred to and the that I have just referred to and the really that I have just referred to and the really significant that I have just referred to and the really significant role that I have just referred to and the really significant role that that I have just referred to and the really significant role that our really significant role that our minor really significant role that our minor party really significant role that our minor party supporters really significant role that our minor party supporters have really significant role that our minor party supporters have played, minor party supporters have played, particularly minor party supporters have played, particularly over minor party supporters have played, particularly over the minor party supporters have played, particularly over the treaty particularly over the treaty settlement particularly over the treaty settlement process, particularly over the treaty settlement process, and particularly over the treaty settlement process, and they particularly over the treaty settlement process, and they will settlement process, and they will judge settlement process, and they will judge him settlement process, and they will judge him highly, settlement process, and they will judge him highly, as settlement process, and they will judge him highly, as he settlement process, and they will judge him highly, as he deserves settlement process, and they will judge him highly, as he deserves to judge him highly, as he deserves to be, judge him highly, as he deserves to be, because judge him highly, as he deserves to be, because it judge him highly, as he deserves to be, because it is judge him highly, as he deserves to be, because it is never judge him highly, as he deserves to be, because it is never possible judge him highly, as he deserves to be, because it is never possible to be, because it is never possible to please be, because it is never possible to please all be, because it is never possible to please all of be, because it is never possible to please all of the be, because it is never possible to please all of the people be, because it is never possible to please all of the people all be, because it is never possible to please all of the people all of be, because it is never possible to please all of the people all of the please all of the people all of the time, please all of the people all of the time, but please all of the people all of the time, but to please all of the people all of the time, but to have please all of the people all of the time, but to have retained please all of the people all of the time, but to have retained the please all of the people all of the time, but to have retained the level time, but to have retained the level of time, but to have retained the level of support time, but to have retained the level of support that time, but to have retained the level of support that he time, but to have retained the level of support that he has time, but to have retained the level of support that he has done time, but to have retained the level of support that he has done in time, but to have retained the level of support that he has done in the of support that he has done in the polls of support that he has done in the polls is of support that he has done in the polls is no of support that he has done in the polls is no coincidence of support that he has done in the polls is no coincidence - of support that he has done in the polls is no coincidence - it of support that he has done in the polls is no coincidence - it shows polls is no coincidence - it shows that polls is no coincidence - it shows that he polls is no coincidence - it shows that he has polls is no coincidence - it shows that he has been polls is no coincidence - it shows that he has been somebody polls is no coincidence - it shows that he has been somebody who polls is no coincidence - it shows that he has been somebody who has that he has been somebody who has been that he has been somebody who has been there, that he has been somebody who has been there, focusing that he has been somebody who has been there, focusing on that he has been somebody who has been there, focusing on the that he has been somebody who has been there, focusing on the things been there, focusing on the things that been there, focusing on the things that matter, been there, focusing on the things that matter, and been there, focusing on the things that matter, and achieved been there, focusing on the things that matter, and achieved wonderful that matter, and achieved wonderful things, that matter, and achieved wonderful things, with that matter, and achieved wonderful things, with the that matter, and achieved wonderful things, with the delivery that matter, and achieved wonderful things, with the delivery of that matter, and achieved wonderful things, with the delivery of better things, with the delivery of better public things, with the delivery of better public services, things, with the delivery of better public services, the things, with the delivery of better public services, the treaty public services, the treaty settlement public services, the treaty settlement process public services, the treaty settlement process that public services, the treaty settlement process that I've settlement process that I've referred settlement process that I've referred to, settlement process that I've referred to, the settlement process that I've referred to, the focus settlement process that I've referred to, the focus in settlement process that I've referred to, the focus in particular referred to, the focus in particular on referred to, the focus in particular on vulnerable referred to, the focus in particular on vulnerable New referred to, the focus in particular on vulnerable New Zealanders, on vulnerable New Zealanders, raising on vulnerable New Zealanders, raising benefits, on vulnerable New Zealanders, raising benefits, introducing on vulnerable New Zealanders, raising benefits, introducing free raising benefits, introducing free doctors' raising benefits, introducing free doctors' visits raising benefits, introducing free doctors' visits for raising benefits, introducing free doctors' visits for children raising benefits, introducing free doctors' visits for children under doctors' visits for children under 13. doctors' visits for children under 13. Measures doctors' visits for children under 13. Measures to doctors' visits for children under 13. Measures to deal doctors' visits for children under 13. Measures to deal with doctors' visits for children under 13. Measures to deal with our 13. Measures to deal with our problems, 13. Measures to deal with our problems, particularly 13. Measures to deal with our problems, particularly for 13. Measures to deal with our problems, particularly for emergency problems, particularly for emergency housing problems, particularly for emergency housing - problems, particularly for emergency housing - the problems, particularly for emergency housing - the list problems, particularly for emergency housing - the list goes problems, particularly for emergency housing - the list goes on. problems, particularly for emergency housing - the list goes on. His housing - the list goes on. His unrelenting housing - the list goes on. His unrelenting focus housing - the list goes on. His unrelenting focus on housing - the list goes on. His unrelenting focus on raising unrelenting focus on raising standards unrelenting focus on raising standards of unrelenting focus on raising standards of achievement unrelenting focus on raising standards of achievement in standards of achievement in education. standards of achievement in education. Sir, standards of achievement in education. Sir, he standards of achievement in education. Sir, he has standards of achievement in education. Sir, he has been standards of achievement in education. Sir, he has been an education. Sir, he has been an outstanding education. Sir, he has been an outstanding PM. education. Sir, he has been an outstanding PM. He education. Sir, he has been an outstanding PM. He leaves education. Sir, he has been an outstanding PM. He leaves a education. Sir, he has been an outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy that outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy that will outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy that will be outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy that will be admired, outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy that will be admired, and outstanding PM. He leaves a legacy that will be admired, and is that will be admired, and is admired, that will be admired, and is admired, by that will be admired, and is admired, by international that will be admired, and is admired, by international leaders, admired, by international leaders, and admired, by international leaders, and I admired, by international leaders, and I am admired, by international leaders, and I am incredibly admired, by international leaders, and I am incredibly proud admired, by international leaders, and I am incredibly proud to admired, by international leaders, and I am incredibly proud to have and I am incredibly proud to have been and I am incredibly proud to have been a and I am incredibly proud to have been a part and I am incredibly proud to have been a part of and I am incredibly proud to have been a part of that and I am incredibly proud to have been a part of that team. and I am incredibly proud to have been a part of that team. I and I am incredibly proud to have been a part of that team. I salute been a part of that team. I salute him been a part of that team. I salute him and been a part of that team. I salute him and I been a part of that team. I salute him and I thank been a part of that team. I salute him and I thank him been a part of that team. I salute him and I thank him sincerely been a part of that team. I salute him and I thank him sincerely on him and I thank him sincerely on behalf him and I thank him sincerely on behalf of him and I thank him sincerely on behalf of my him and I thank him sincerely on behalf of my constituents him and I thank him sincerely on behalf of my constituents and him and I thank him sincerely on behalf of my constituents and all behalf of my constituents and all New behalf of my constituents and all New Zealanders. behalf of my constituents and all New Zealanders. The behalf of my constituents and all New Zealanders. The time behalf of my constituents and all New Zealanders. The time for behalf of my constituents and all New Zealanders. The time for this New Zealanders. The time for this debate