This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Ericsson This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access Services Ericsson Access Services for Ericsson Access Services for the Ericsson Access Services for the Office Ericsson Access Services for the Office of Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, humbly Almighty God, humbly acknowledging Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need for humbly acknowledging our need for your humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all things, your guidance in all things, and your guidance in all things, and laying your guidance in all things, and laying aside your guidance in all things, and laying aside all your guidance in all things, and laying aside all private and laying aside all private and and laying aside all private and personal and laying aside all private and personal interests, and personal interests, we and personal interests, we ask and personal interests, we ask that and personal interests, we ask that you and personal interests, we ask that you grant we ask that you grant that we ask that you grant that we we ask that you grant that we may we ask that you grant that we may conduct we ask that you grant that we may conduct the we ask that you grant that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House that we may conduct the affairs of this House and that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our country of this House and of our country to of this House and of our country to the of this House and of our country to the glory of this House and of our country to the glory of of this House and of our country to the glory of your of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy name, to the glory of your holy name, the to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true religion the maintenance of true religion and the maintenance of true religion and justice, and justice, the and justice, the honour and justice, the honour of and justice, the honour of the and justice, the honour of the Queen, the honour of the Queen, and the honour of the Queen, and the the honour of the Queen, and the public the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, peace, and the public welfare, peace, and and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New Zealand, and tranquillity of New Zealand, through and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our Lord. through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen. The The PM The PM I The PM I seek The PM I seek leave The PM I seek leave to The PM I seek leave to make The PM I seek leave to make a The PM I seek leave to make a personal The PM I seek leave to make a personal explanation, The PM I seek leave to make a personal explanation, to The PM I seek leave to make a personal explanation, to correct The PM I seek leave to make a personal explanation, to correct an personal explanation, to correct an answer personal explanation, to correct an answer to personal explanation, to correct an answer to - personal explanation, to correct an answer to - I personal explanation, to correct an answer to - I gave personal explanation, to correct an answer to - I gave to personal explanation, to correct an answer to - I gave to a answer to - I gave to a supplementary answer to - I gave to a supplementary question answer to - I gave to a supplementary question - answer to - I gave to a supplementary question - question answer to - I gave to a supplementary question - question 7 supplementary question - question 7 - supplementary question - question 7 supplementary supplementary question - question 7 - on 5 supplementary question - question 7 - on 5 April supplementary question - question 7 - on 5 April 2017. supplementary question - question 7 - on 5 April 2017. Leave supplementary question - question 7 - on 5 April 2017. Leave is supplementary question - question 7 - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought for - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought for that - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought for that course - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought for that course of - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought for that course of action. - on 5 April 2017. Leave is sought for that course of action. Any for that course of action. Any objection? for that course of action. Any objection? There for that course of action. Any objection? There is for that course of action. Any objection? There is none. for that course of action. Any objection? There is none. The for that course of action. Any objection? There is none. The Rt for that course of action. Any objection? There is none. The Rt Hon objection? There is none. The Rt Hon PM. objection? There is none. The Rt Hon PM. In objection? There is none. The Rt Hon PM. In response objection? There is none. The Rt Hon PM. In response to objection? There is none. The Rt Hon PM. In response to supplementary PM. In response to supplementary question PM. In response to supplementary question I PM. In response to supplementary question I stated PM. In response to supplementary question I stated that PM. In response to supplementary question I stated that the PM. In response to supplementary question I stated that the police question I stated that the police receive question I stated that the police receive $4,6111 question I stated that the police receive $4,6111 -- question I stated that the police receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 question I stated that the police receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. question I stated that the police receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I should receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I should clarify receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I should clarify the receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I should clarify the police receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I should clarify the police receive receive $4,6111 -- 4,6111 calls. I should clarify the police receive on should clarify the police receive on average should clarify the police receive on average 2,400 should clarify the police receive on average 2,400 111 should clarify the police receive on average 2,400 111 calls should clarify the police receive on average 2,400 111 calls a should clarify the police receive on average 2,400 111 calls a day. should clarify the police receive on average 2,400 111 calls a day. The average 2,400 111 calls a day. The totalling average 2,400 111 calls a day. The totalling of average 2,400 111 calls a day. The totalling of 4,600 average 2,400 111 calls a day. The totalling of 4,600 calls average 2,400 111 calls a day. The totalling of 4,600 calls includes totalling of 4,600 calls includes star totalling of 4,600 calls includes star triple totalling of 4,600 calls includes star triple five totalling of 4,600 calls includes star triple five calls, totalling of 4,600 calls includes star triple five calls, nonemergency star triple five calls, nonemergency calls star triple five calls, nonemergency calls and star triple five calls, nonemergency calls and crime star triple five calls, nonemergency calls and crime reporting star triple five calls, nonemergency calls and crime reporting line star triple five calls, nonemergency calls and crime reporting line calls calls and crime reporting line calls received calls and crime reporting line calls received by calls and crime reporting line calls received by the calls and crime reporting line calls received by the police calls and crime reporting line calls received by the police communication received by the police communication centre. received by the police communication centre. A received by the police communication centre. A petition received by the police communication centre. A petition has received by the police communication centre. A petition has been centre. A petition has been delivered centre. A petition has been delivered to centre. A petition has been delivered to the centre. A petition has been delivered to the Clarke centre. A petition has been delivered to the Clarke for delivered to the Clarke for presentation. Petition Petition of Petition of Andy Petition of Andy Espersen Petition of Andy Espersen requesting Petition of Andy Espersen requesting that Petition of Andy Espersen requesting that the Petition of Andy Espersen requesting that the House Petition of Andy Espersen requesting that the House recommend that the House recommend that that the House recommend that the that the House recommend that the Government that the House recommend that the Government establish that the Government establish a that the Government establish a Royal that the Government establish a Royal Commission that the Government establish a Royal Commission to that the Government establish a Royal Commission to report that the Government establish a Royal Commission to report on that the Government establish a Royal Commission to report on harm a Royal Commission to report on harm to a Royal Commission to report on harm to our a Royal Commission to report on harm to our schizophrenic a Royal Commission to report on harm to our schizophrenic population to our schizophrenic population from to our schizophrenic population from changes to our schizophrenic population from changes in to our schizophrenic population from changes in the to our schizophrenic population from changes in the Mental to our schizophrenic population from changes in the Mental Health from changes in the Mental Health and from changes in the Mental Health and the from changes in the Mental Health and the closure from changes in the Mental Health and the closure of from changes in the Mental Health and the closure of residential and the closure of residential psychiatric and the closure of residential psychiatric hospitals. That That stands That stands referred That stands referred to That stands referred to the That stands referred to the select That stands referred to the select committee That stands referred to the select committee allocated That stands referred to the select committee allocated by That stands referred to the select committee allocated by the That stands referred to the select committee allocated by the Clerk. I I present I present the I present the report I present the report of I present the report of the I present the report of the Controller I present the report of the Controller and I present the report of the Controller and Auditor-General the Controller and Auditor-General entitled the Controller and Auditor-General entitled Draft the Controller and Auditor-General entitled Draft Annual the Controller and Auditor-General entitled Draft Annual Plan the Controller and Auditor-General entitled Draft Annual Plan 2017/18. entitled Draft Annual Plan 2017/18. Those entitled Draft Annual Plan 2017/18. Those papers entitled Draft Annual Plan 2017/18. Those papers are entitled Draft Annual Plan 2017/18. Those papers are published entitled Draft Annual Plan 2017/18. Those papers are published under Those papers are published under the Those papers are published under the authority Those papers are published under the authority of Those papers are published under the authority of the Those papers are published under the authority of the House. Select Select committee Select committee reports Select committee reports have Select committee reports have been Select committee reports have been delivered Select committee reports have been delivered for Select committee reports have been delivered for presentation. Report Report of Report of the Report of the Govt Report of the Govt Administration Report of the Govt Administration Committee Report of the Govt Administration Committee on Report of the Govt Administration Committee on the Report of the Govt Administration Committee on the Report Committee on the Report of Committee on the Report of the Committee on the Report of the Controller Committee on the Report of the Controller and of the Controller and Auditor-General, of the Controller and Auditor-General, reflections Auditor-General, reflections from Auditor-General, reflections from our Auditor-General, reflections from our audits Auditor-General, reflections from our audits - from our audits - governance from our audits - governance and from our audits - governance and accountability. governance and accountability. Report governance and accountability. Report of governance and accountability. Report of the governance and accountability. Report of the Law governance and accountability. Report of the Law and governance and accountability. Report of the Law and Order Report of the Law and Order Committee Report of the Law and Order Committee on Report of the Law and Order Committee on the Report of the Law and Order Committee on the inquiry Report of the Law and Order Committee on the inquiry into Report of the Law and Order Committee on the inquiry into issues Committee on the inquiry into issues relating Committee on the inquiry into issues relating to Committee on the inquiry into issues relating to the Committee on the inquiry into issues relating to the illegal Committee on the inquiry into issues relating to the illegal possession relating to the illegal possession of relating to the illegal possession of firearms relating to the illegal possession of firearms in relating to the illegal possession of firearms in New relating to the illegal possession of firearms in New Zealand. of firearms in New Zealand. Report of firearms in New Zealand. Report of of firearms in New Zealand. Report of the of firearms in New Zealand. Report of the Local of firearms in New Zealand. Report of the Local Government Report of the Local Government and Report of the Local Government and Environment Report of the Local Government and Environment Committee and Environment Committee on and Environment Committee on the and Environment Committee on the report and Environment Committee on the report of and Environment Committee on the report of the and Environment Committee on the report of the Controller on the report of the Controller and on the report of the Controller and Auditor-General, and Auditor-General, Auckland and Auditor-General, Auckland Council and Auditor-General, Auckland Council - Auckland Council - how Auckland Council - how it Auckland Council - how it deals Auckland Council - how it deals with Auckland Council - how it deals with complaints. how it deals with complaints. The how it deals with complaints. The reports how it deals with complaints. The reports on how it deals with complaints. The reports on the how it deals with complaints. The reports on the Controller The reports on the Controller and The reports on the Controller and Auditor-General's The reports on the Controller and Auditor-General's reports and Auditor-General's reports and and Auditor-General's reports and the and Auditor-General's reports and the report and Auditor-General's reports and the report on and Auditor-General's reports and the report on the and Auditor-General's reports and the report on the inquiry and the report on the inquiry are and the report on the inquiry are set and the report on the inquiry are set down and the report on the inquiry are set down for and the report on the inquiry are set down for consideration No No bills No bills have No bills have been No bills have been introduced. No bills have been introduced. The No bills have been introduced. The House No bills have been introduced. The House cops No bills have been introduced. The House cops to No bills have been introduced. The House cops to questions No bills have been introduced. The House cops to questions for No bills have been introduced. The House cops to questions for -- No bills have been introduced. The House cops to questions for -- comes House cops to questions for -- comes to House cops to questions for -- comes to Oral House cops to questions for -- comes to Oral Questions. House cops to questions for -- comes to Oral Questions. Question House cops to questions for -- comes to Oral Questions. Question No. House cops to questions for -- comes to Oral Questions. Question No. 1. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by his Minister: Does he stand by his statement Minister: Does he stand by his statement on Minister: Does he stand by his statement on the Minister: Does he stand by his statement on the housing Minister: Does he stand by his statement on the housing crisis Minister: Does he stand by his statement on the housing crisis that statement on the housing crisis that "I statement on the housing crisis that "I wouldn't statement on the housing crisis that "I wouldn't call statement on the housing crisis that "I wouldn't call it statement on the housing crisis that "I wouldn't call it a statement on the housing crisis that "I wouldn't call it a crisis. statement on the housing crisis that "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We have "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We have strong "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We have strong demand, "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We have strong demand, we "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We have strong demand, we have "I wouldn't call it a crisis. We have strong demand, we have an have strong demand, we have an uplift have strong demand, we have an uplift in have strong demand, we have an uplift in prices have strong demand, we have an uplift in prices - have strong demand, we have an uplift in prices - these have strong demand, we have an uplift in prices - these are have strong demand, we have an uplift in prices - these are good uplift in prices - these are good problems uplift in prices - these are good problems to uplift in prices - these are good problems to have uplift in prices - these are good problems to have actually"? Yes, Yes, and Yes, and as Yes, and as I Yes, and as I have Yes, and as I have - Yes, and as I have - I Yes, and as I have - I said Yes, and as I have - I said in Yes, and as I have - I said in that Yes, and as I have - I said in that interview, Yes, and as I have - I said in that interview, the Yes, and as I have - I said in that interview, the Government Yes, and as I have - I said in that interview, the Government is interview, the Government is spending interview, the Government is spending over interview, the Government is spending over $300 interview, the Government is spending over $300 million interview, the Government is spending over $300 million in spending over $300 million in emergency spending over $300 million in emergency housing spending over $300 million in emergency housing to spending over $300 million in emergency housing to provide spending over $300 million in emergency housing to provide an emergency housing to provide an extra emergency housing to provide an extra 2,150 emergency housing to provide an extra 2,150 emergency emergency housing to provide an extra 2,150 emergency housing emergency housing to provide an extra 2,150 emergency housing places extra 2,150 emergency housing places around extra 2,150 emergency housing places around New extra 2,150 emergency housing places around New Zealand, extra 2,150 emergency housing places around New Zealand, enough extra 2,150 emergency housing places around New Zealand, enough to around New Zealand, enough to support around New Zealand, enough to support 8,000 around New Zealand, enough to support 8,000 families around New Zealand, enough to support 8,000 families a around New Zealand, enough to support 8,000 families a year. around New Zealand, enough to support 8,000 families a year. Of support 8,000 families a year. Of course, support 8,000 families a year. Of course, getting support 8,000 families a year. Of course, getting more support 8,000 families a year. Of course, getting more houses support 8,000 families a year. Of course, getting more houses built course, getting more houses built faster course, getting more houses built faster would course, getting more houses built faster would be course, getting more houses built faster would be easier course, getting more houses built faster would be easier if course, getting more houses built faster would be easier if the course, getting more houses built faster would be easier if the Labour faster would be easier if the Labour Party faster would be easier if the Labour Party wasn't faster would be easier if the Labour Party wasn't organising faster would be easier if the Labour Party wasn't organising opposition Party wasn't organising opposition to Party wasn't organising opposition faster Party wasn't organising opposition to two of Party wasn't organising opposition to two of the Party wasn't organising opposition to two of the large Party wasn't organising opposition to two of the large new Party wasn't organising opposition to two of the large new developments to two of the large new developments in to two of the large new developments in Auckland. to two of the large new developments in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In Three in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In Three Kings in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In Three Kings and in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In Three Kings and the in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In Three Kings and the Point in Auckland. <INTERRUPTION> In Three Kings and the Point England In Three Kings and the Point England Reserve. In Three Kings and the Point England Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What does Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What does he Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What does he say Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What does he say to Reserve. <INTERRUPTION> Order! What does he say to the Order! What does he say to the Salvation Order! What does he say to the Salvation Army Order! What does he say to the Salvation Army that Order! What does he say to the Salvation Army that they Order! What does he say to the Salvation Army that they are Order! What does he say to the Salvation Army that they are now Salvation Army that they are now turning Salvation Army that they are now turning around Salvation Army that they are now turning around 2 Salvation Army that they are now turning around 2 to Salvation Army that they are now turning around 2 to 3 Salvation Army that they are now turning around 2 to 3 homeless turning around 2 to 3 homeless families turning around 2 to 3 homeless families a turning around 2 to 3 homeless families a day turning around 2 to 3 homeless families a day saying, turning around 2 to 3 homeless families a day saying, "We've turning around 2 to 3 homeless families a day saying, "We've got families a day saying, "We've got nowhere families a day saying, "We've got nowhere to families a day saying, "We've got nowhere to send families a day saying, "We've got nowhere to send them."? families a day saying, "We've got nowhere to send them."? Well, families a day saying, "We've got nowhere to send them."? Well, I nowhere to send them."? Well, I would nowhere to send them."? Well, I would say nowhere to send them."? Well, I would say to nowhere to send them."? Well, I would say to the nowhere to send them."? Well, I would say to the Salvation nowhere to send them."? Well, I would say to the Salvation Army would say to the Salvation Army first would say to the Salvation Army first to would say to the Salvation Army first to thank would say to the Salvation Army first to thank them would say to the Salvation Army first to thank them for would say to the Salvation Army first to thank them for the would say to the Salvation Army first to thank them for the way would say to the Salvation Army first to thank them for the way they first to thank them for the way they are first to thank them for the way they are working first to thank them for the way they are working very first to thank them for the way they are working very closely first to thank them for the way they are working very closely with first to thank them for the way they are working very closely with the are working very closely with the Government, are working very closely with the Government, along are working very closely with the Government, along with are working very closely with the Government, along with the are working very closely with the Government, along with the other Government, along with the other NGOs Government, along with the other NGOs in Government, along with the other NGOs in Auckland Government, along with the other NGOs in Auckland to Government, along with the other NGOs in Auckland to get Government, along with the other NGOs in Auckland to get more Government, along with the other NGOs in Auckland to get more houses NGOs in Auckland to get more houses on NGOs in Auckland to get more houses on the NGOs in Auckland to get more houses on the ground NGOs in Auckland to get more houses on the ground faster. NGOs in Auckland to get more houses on the ground faster. But, NGOs in Auckland to get more houses on the ground faster. But, of on the ground faster. But, of course, on the ground faster. But, of course, both on the ground faster. But, of course, both the on the ground faster. But, of course, both the Government on the ground faster. But, of course, both the Government and on the ground faster. But, of course, both the Government and the course, both the Government and the Salvation course, both the Government and the Salvation Army course, both the Government and the Salvation Army would course, both the Government and the Salvation Army would find course, both the Government and the Salvation Army would find it course, both the Government and the Salvation Army would find it easier Salvation Army would find it easier if Salvation Army would find it easier NGOs Salvation Army would find it easier if the Labour Salvation Army would find it easier if the Labour Party Salvation Army would find it easier if the Labour Party wasn't if the Labour Party wasn't organising if the Labour Party wasn't organising opposition if the Labour Party wasn't organising opposition to if the Labour Party wasn't organising opposition to the if the Labour Party wasn't organising opposition to the Three organising opposition to the Three Kings organising opposition to the Three Kings development, organising opposition to the Three Kings development, which organising opposition to the Three Kings development, which I organising opposition to the Three Kings development, which I think organising opposition to the Three Kings development, which I think is Kings development, which I think is 1500 Kings development, which I think is 1500 homes... Kings development, which I think is 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> And 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> And the 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> And the east 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> And the east Tamaki... 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> And the east Tamaki... The 1500 homes... <INTERRUPTION> And the east Tamaki... The Point And the east Tamaki... The Point England And the east Tamaki... The Point England Reserve, And the east Tamaki... The Point England Reserve, which And the east Tamaki... The Point England Reserve, which is And the east Tamaki... The Point England Reserve, which is also England Reserve, which is also hundreds... England Reserve, which is also England England Reserve, which is also hundreds... Order! The England Reserve, which is also hundreds... Order! The answer England Reserve, which is also hundreds... Order! The answer has hundreds... Order! The answer has gone hundreds... Order! The answer has gone on hundreds... Order! The answer has gone on for hundreds... Order! The answer has gone on for long hundreds... Order! The answer has gone on for long enough. gone on for long enough. Supplementary gone on for long enough. Supplementary question. gone on for long enough. Supplementary question. After gone on for long enough. Supplementary question. After the Supplementary question. After the heartbreaking Supplementary question. After the heartbreaking scenes Supplementary question. After the heartbreaking scenes last Supplementary question. After the heartbreaking scenes last winter Supplementary question. After the heartbreaking scenes last winter of heartbreaking scenes last winter of families heartbreaking scenes last winter of families sleeping heartbreaking scenes last winter of families sleeping in heartbreaking scenes last winter of families sleeping in cars heartbreaking scenes last winter of families sleeping in cars and families sleeping in cars and garages families sleeping in cars and garages and families sleeping in cars and garages and the families sleeping in cars and garages and the promises families sleeping in cars and garages and the promises from families sleeping in cars and garages and the promises from his garages and the promises from his Government garages and the promises from his Government to garages and the promises from his Government to fix garages and the promises from his Government to fix the garages and the promises from his Government to fix the issue, garages and the promises from his Government to fix the issue, why garages and the promises from his Government to fix the issue, why is Government to fix the issue, why is the Government to fix the issue, why is the crisis Government to fix the issue, why is the crisis still Government to fix the issue, why is the crisis still getting Government to fix the issue, why is the crisis still getting worse? the crisis still getting worse? Well, the crisis still getting worse? Well, as the crisis still getting worse? Well, as I the crisis still getting worse? Well, as I said the crisis still getting worse? Well, as I said to the crisis still getting worse? Well, as I said to the the crisis still getting worse? Well, as I said to the member, the crisis still getting worse? Well, as I said to the member, the Well, as I said to the member, the Salvation Well, as I said to the member, the Salvation Army Well, as I said to the member, the Salvation Army and Well, as I said to the member, the Salvation Army and others Well, as I said to the member, the Salvation Army and others are Salvation Army and others are working Salvation Army and others are working very Salvation Army and others are working very closely Salvation Army and others are working very closely with Salvation Army and others are working very closely with the working very closely with the Government working very closely with the Government around working very closely with the Government around the working very closely with the Government around the - working very closely with the Government around the - getting working very closely with the Government around the - getting the Government around the - getting the 300 Government around the - getting the 300 million Government around the - getting the 300 million spent Government around the - getting the 300 million spent - Government around the - getting the 300 million spent - I Government around the - getting the 300 million spent - I mean, Government around the - getting the 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt isn't 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt isn't really 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt isn't really the 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt isn't really the con-- 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt isn't really the con-- money 300 million spent - I mean, manhunt isn't really the con-- money isn't isn't really the con-- money isn't really isn't really the con-- money isn't 300 isn't really the con-- money isn't really the constraint, isn't really the con-- money isn't really the constraint, it's isn't really the con-- money isn't really the constraint, it's the really the constraint, it's the ability really the constraint, it's the ability to really the constraint, it's the ability to get really the constraint, it's the ability to get the really the constraint, it's the ability to get the houses really the constraint, it's the ability to get the houses and really the constraint, it's the ability to get the houses and the ability to get the houses and the non-Government ability to get the houses and the non-Government organisations ability to get the houses and the non-Government organisations on ability to get the houses and the non-Government organisations on the non-Government organisations on the ground non-Government organisations on the ability non-Government organisations on the ground able to non-Government organisations on the ground able to execute. ground able to execute. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Of <INTERRUPTION> Of course, <INTERRUPTION> Of course, we <INTERRUPTION> Of course, we would <INTERRUPTION> Of course, we would all <INTERRUPTION> Of course, we would all find <INTERRUPTION> Of course, we would all find it Of course, we would all find it easier Of course, we would all find it easier if Of course, we would all find it easier if the Of course, we would all find it easier if the Labour Of course, we would all find it easier if the Labour Party Of course, we would all find it easier if the Labour Party wasn't easier if the Labour Party wasn't opposing easier if the Labour Party wasn't opposing developments easier if the Labour Party wasn't opposing developments in easier if the Labour Party wasn't opposing developments in Auckland. opposing developments in Auckland. Order! opposing developments in Auckland. Order! Point opposing developments in Auckland. Order! Point of opposing developments in Auckland. Order! Point of order. opposing developments in Auckland. Order! Point of order. In opposing developments in Auckland. Order! Point of order. In all opposing developments in Auckland. Order! Point of order. In all three Order! Point of order. In all three of Order! Point of order. In all three of the Order! Point of order. In all three of the PM's Order! Point of order. In all three of the PM's answers Order! Point of order. In all three of the PM's answers he's Order! Point of order. In all three of the PM's answers he's introduced of the PM's answers he's introduced material of the PM's answers he's introduced material that's of the PM's answers he's introduced material that's irrelevant of the PM's answers he's introduced material that's irrelevant and of the PM's answers he's introduced material that's irrelevant and for material that's irrelevant and for which material that's irrelevant and for which he's material that's irrelevant and for which he's not material that's irrelevant and for which he's not responsible. which he's not responsible. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I <INTERRUPTION> Order! I don't <INTERRUPTION> Order! I don't agree <INTERRUPTION> Order! I don't agree with <INTERRUPTION> Order! I don't agree with the Order! I don't agree with the member. Order! I don't agree with the member. The Order! I don't agree with the member. The original Order! I don't agree with the member. The original question Order! I don't agree with the member. The original question talked member. The original question talked about member. The original question talked about a member. The original question talked about a housing member. The original question talked about a housing crisis. member. The original question talked about a housing crisis. The member. The original question talked about a housing crisis. The PM's about a housing crisis. The PM's taken about a housing crisis. The PM's taken the about a housing crisis. The PM's taken the opportunity about a housing crisis. The PM's taken the opportunity of about a housing crisis. The PM's taken the opportunity of addressing taken the opportunity of addressing what taken the opportunity of addressing what he taken the opportunity of addressing what he thinks taken the opportunity of addressing what he thinks is taken the opportunity of addressing what he thinks is part taken the opportunity of addressing what he thinks is part of taken the opportunity of addressing what he thinks is part of the what he thinks is part of the problem. what he thinks is part of the problem. One what he thinks is part of the problem. One of what he thinks is part of the problem. One of the what he thinks is part of the problem. One of the questions what he thinks is part of the problem. One of the questions was, problem. One of the questions was, "What problem. One of the questions was, "What would problem. One of the questions was, "What would he problem. One of the questions was, "What would he say problem. One of the questions was, "What would he say to problem. One of the questions was, "What would he say to the problem. One of the questions was, "What would he say to the Salvation "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" I "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" I suspect "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" I suspect if "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" I suspect if the "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" I suspect if the PM "What would he say to the Salvation Army?" I suspect if the PM was Army?" I suspect if the PM was talking Army?" I suspect if the PM was talking to Army?" I suspect if the PM was talking to the Army?" I suspect if the PM was talking to the Salvation Army?" I suspect if the PM was talking to the Salvation Army Army?" I suspect if the PM was talking to the Salvation Army he talking to the Salvation Army he would talking to the Salvation Army he Army?" talking to the Salvation Army he would be saying talking to the Salvation Army he would be saying exactly talking to the Salvation Army he would be saying exactly the talking to the Salvation Army he would be saying exactly the things would be saying exactly the things he would be saying exactly the things Army?" would be saying exactly the things he is saying would be saying exactly the things he is saying in would be saying exactly the things he is saying in these would be saying exactly the things he is saying in these answers. he is saying in these answers. Further he is saying in these answers. Further supplementary he is saying in these answers. Further supplementary question? Further supplementary question? Putting Further supplementary question? Putting aside Further supplementary question? Putting aside the Further supplementary question? Putting aside the Labour Further supplementary question? Putting aside the Labour Party's Putting aside the Labour Party's long-standing Putting aside the Labour Party's long-standing support Putting aside the Labour Party's long-standing support for Putting aside the Labour Party's long-standing support for the long-standing support for the Hobsonville long-standing support for the Hobsonville project long-standing support for the Hobsonville project and long-standing support for the Hobsonville project and the Hobsonville project and the redevelopment Hobsonville project and the redevelopment company Hobsonville project and the redevelopment company what Hobsonville project and the redevelopment company what effect redevelopment company what effect has redevelopment company what effect has the redevelopment company what effect has the state redevelopment company what effect has the state house redevelopment company what effect has the state house sell-off redevelopment company what effect has the state house sell-off had redevelopment company what effect has the state house sell-off had on has the state house sell-off had on the has the state house sell-off had on the stock has the state house sell-off had on the stock of has the state house sell-off had on the stock of state has the state house sell-off had on the stock of state houses has the state house sell-off had on the stock of state houses available the stock of state houses available today, the stock of state houses available today, and the stock of state houses available today, and just the stock of state houses available today, and just be the stock of state houses available today, and just be straight the stock of state houses available today, and just be straight with the stock of state houses available today, and just be straight with me today, and just be straight with me - today, and just be straight with me today, today, and just be straight with me - are there today, and just be straight with me - are there more today, and just be straight with me - are there more or today, and just be straight with me - are there more or fewer today, and just be straight with me - are there more or fewer than today, and just be straight with me - are there more or fewer than when - are there more or fewer than when we - are there more or fewer than when we started? - are there more or fewer than when we started? <INTERRUPTION> we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, because we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, because of we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, because of the we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, because of the reforms we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, because of the reforms of we started? <INTERRUPTION> Well, because of the reforms of the Well, because of the reforms of the - Well, because of the reforms of the - of Well, because of the reforms of the - of state Well, because of the reforms of the - of state - Well, because of the reforms of the - of state - traditional Well, because of the reforms of the - of state - traditional state - of state - traditional state housing - of state - traditional state housing - - of state - traditional state housing - we - of state - traditional state housing - we now - of state - traditional state housing - we now have - of state - traditional state housing - we now have a - of state - traditional state housing - we now have a great - of state - traditional state housing - we now have a great deal housing - we now have a great deal more housing - we now have a great deal more interest housing - we now have a great deal more interest in housing - we now have a great deal more interest in providing housing - we now have a great deal more interest in providing social more interest in providing social housing, more interest in providing social housing, more more interest in providing social housing, more capital, more interest in providing social housing, more capital, more more interest in providing social housing, more capital, more ex-- housing, more capital, more ex-- expertise, housing, more capital, more ex-- expertise, and housing, more capital, more ex-- expertise, and thousands housing, more capital, more ex-- expertise, and thousands of housing, more capital, more ex-- expertise, and thousands of them expertise, and thousands of them being expertise, and thousands of them expertise, expertise, and thousands of them being built. But, expertise, and thousands of them being built. But, of expertise, and thousands of them being built. But, of course, expertise, and thousands of them being built. But, of course, we expertise, and thousands of them being built. But, of course, we also being built. But, of course, we also need being built. But, of course, we also need the being built. But, of course, we also need the development being built. But, of course, we also need the development at being built. But, of course, we also need the development at the being built. But, of course, we also need the development at the Three need the development at the Three Kings, need the development at the Three Kings, which need the development at the Three Kings, which the need the development at the Three Kings, which the Labour need the development at the Three Kings, which the Labour Party need the development at the Three Kings, which the Labour Party are Kings, which the Labour Party are opposing, Kings, which the Labour Party are opposing, and Kings, which the Labour Party are opposing, and the Kings, which the Labour Party are opposing, and the Point Kings, which the Labour Party are opposing, and the Point England opposing, and the Point England Reserve opposing, and the Point England Reserve development opposing, and the Point England Reserve development which opposing, and the Point England Reserve development which they Reserve development which they supported Reserve development which they supported before Reserve development which they supported before they Reserve development which they supported before they changed Reserve development which they supported before they changed their supported before they changed their mind supported before they changed their mind and supported before they changed their mind and now supported before they changed their mind and now oppose. supported before they changed their mind and now oppose. So, supported before they changed their mind and now oppose. So, how supported before they changed their mind and now oppose. So, how could mind and now oppose. So, how could they mind and now oppose. So, how could they possibly mind and now oppose. So, how could they possibly get mind and now oppose. So, how could they possibly get 100,000 mind and now oppose. So, how could they possibly get 100,000 houses they possibly get 100,000 houses built they possibly get 100,000 houses built if they possibly get 100,000 houses built if they they possibly get 100,000 houses built if they were they possibly get 100,000 houses built if they were opposed they possibly get 100,000 houses built if they were opposed to they possibly get 100,000 houses built if they were opposed to any built if they were opposed to any development? built if they were opposed to any development? <INTERRUPTION> development? <INTERRUPTION> supplementary development? <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. development? <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Order! development? <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Order! How supplementary question. Order! How many supplementary question. Order! How many families supplementary question. Order! How many families a supplementary question. Order! How many families a night supplementary question. Order! How many families a night are supplementary question. Order! How many families a night are staying supplementary question. Order! How many families a night are staying in many families a night are staying in motels many families a night are staying in motels because many families a night are staying in motels because there many families a night are staying in motels because there aren't many families a night are staying in motels because there aren't enough motels because there aren't enough state motels because there aren't enough state houses motels because there aren't enough state houses for motels because there aren't enough state houses for them? motels because there aren't enough state houses for them? Well, motels because there aren't enough state houses for them? Well, there state houses for them? Well, there are state houses for them? Well, there are of state houses for them? Well, there are of course state houses for them? Well, there are of course a state houses for them? Well, there are of course a number state houses for them? Well, there are of course a number in state houses for them? Well, there are of course a number in motels. are of course a number in motels. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> And <INTERRUPTION> And the <INTERRUPTION> And the Government's <INTERRUPTION> And the Government's - <INTERRUPTION> And the Government's - the And the Government's - the Government's And the Government's - the Government's response And the Government's - the Government's response to And the Government's - the Government's response to that And the Government's - the Government's response to that issue Government's response to that issue has Government's response to that issue has been Government's response to that issue has been to Government's response to that issue has been to spend Government's response to that issue has been to spend $300 Government's response to that issue has been to spend $300 million Government's response to that issue has been to spend $300 million on has been to spend $300 million on emergency has been to spend $300 million on emergency housing, has been to spend $300 million on emergency housing, ah, has been to spend $300 million on emergency housing, ah, and has been to spend $300 million on emergency housing, ah, and building emergency housing, ah, and building - emergency housing, ah, and building - building emergency housing, ah, and building - building and emergency housing, ah, and building - building and procuring emergency housing, ah, and building - building and procuring significant - building and procuring significant numbers - building and procuring significant - - building and procuring significant numbers more of - building and procuring significant numbers more of social - building and procuring significant numbers more of social houses. - building and procuring significant numbers more of social houses. But, numbers more of social houses. But, of numbers more of social houses. But, of course, numbers more of social houses. But, of course, we're numbers more of social houses. But, of course, we're in numbers more of social houses. But, of course, we're in a numbers more of social houses. But, of course, we're in a market numbers more of social houses. But, of course, we're in a market - numbers more of social houses. But, of course, we're in a market - we're of course, we're in a market - we're competing of course, we're in a market - we're competing in of course, we're in a market - we're competing in the of course, we're in a market - we're competing in the market, of course, we're in a market - we're competing in the market, which of course, we're in a market - we're competing in the market, which is of course, we're in a market - we're competing in the market, which is a competing in the market, which is a bit competing in the market, which is a bit tight, competing in the market, which is a bit tight, because competing in the market, which is a bit tight, because the competing in the market, which is a bit tight, because the Three competing in the market, which is a bit tight, because the Three Kings bit tight, because the Three Kings development bit tight, because the Three Kings development has bit tight, because the Three Kings development has been bit tight, because the Three Kings development has been delayed bit tight, because the Three Kings development has been delayed now bit tight, because the Three Kings development has been delayed now for development has been delayed now for several development has been delayed now for several years development has been delayed now for several years - development has been delayed now for several years - the development has been delayed now for several years - the opposition development has been delayed now for several years - the opposition to development has been delayed now for several years - the opposition to it several years - the opposition to it has several years - the opposition to it has been several years - the opposition to it has been organised several years - the opposition to it has been organised by several years - the opposition to it has been organised by the several years - the opposition to it has been organised by the Labour has been organised by the Labour Party. has been organised by the Labour Party. Now has been organised by the Labour Party. Now they has been organised by the Labour Party. Now they are has been organised by the Labour Party. Now they are setting has been organised by the Labour Party. Now they are setting out has been organised by the Labour Party. Now they are setting out to Party. Now they are setting out to oppose Party. Now they are setting out to oppose the Party. Now they are setting out to oppose the Point Party. Now they are setting out to oppose the Point England Party. Now they are setting out to oppose the Point England Reserve oppose the Point England Reserve development, oppose the Point England Reserve development, and oppose the Point England Reserve development, and undo oppose the Point England Reserve development, and undo a oppose the Point England Reserve development, and undo a treaty development, and undo a treaty settlement. development, and undo a treaty settlement. And development, and undo a treaty settlement. And that's development, and undo a treaty settlement. And that's all development, and undo a treaty settlement. And that's all been settlement. And that's all been organised settlement. And that's all been settlement. settlement. And that's all been organised by the settlement. And that's all been organised by the Labour settlement. And that's all been organised by the Labour Party. organised by the Labour Party. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> point <INTERRUPTION> point of <INTERRUPTION> point of order. <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I seek <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I seek leave <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I seek leave to point of order. I seek leave to table point of order. I seek leave to table a point of order. I seek leave to table a report point of order. I seek leave to table a report from point of order. I seek leave to table a report from the table a report from the Parliamentary table a report from the Parliamentary library table a report from the Parliamentary library hitherto Parliamentary library hitherto unpublished Parliamentary library hitherto unpublished and Parliamentary library hitherto unpublished and unknown, Parliamentary library hitherto unpublished and unknown, dated unpublished and unknown, dated today, unpublished and unknown, dated today, confirming unpublished and unknown, dated today, confirming that unpublished and unknown, dated today, confirming that the unpublished and unknown, dated today, confirming that the number unpublished and unknown, dated today, confirming that the number of today, confirming that the number of motel today, confirming that the number of motel rooms today, confirming that the number of motel rooms per today, confirming that the number of motel rooms per night today, confirming that the number of motel rooms per night that today, confirming that the number of motel rooms per night that is motel rooms per night that is currently motel rooms per night that is currently being motel rooms per night that is currently being funded motel rooms per night that is currently being funded by motel rooms per night that is currently being funded by the currently being funded by the Government currently being funded by the Government is currently being funded by the Government is 400. currently being funded by the Government is 400. Leave currently being funded by the Government is 400. Leave is currently being funded by the Government is 400. Leave is sought Government is 400. Leave is sought to Government is 400. Leave is sought to table Government is 400. Leave is sought to table that Government is 400. Leave is sought to table that information. Government is 400. Leave is sought to table that information. Is Government is 400. Leave is sought to table that information. Is there to table that information. Is there any to table that information. Is there any objection? to table that information. Is there any objection? There to table that information. Is there any objection? There is to table that information. Is there any objection? There is none. to table that information. Is there any objection? There is none. It to table that information. Is there any objection? There is none. It can any objection? There is none. It can be... any objection? There is none. It can be... Supplementary any objection? There is none. It can be... Supplementary question. any objection? There is none. It can be... Supplementary question. How be... Supplementary question. How many be... Supplementary question. How many of be... Supplementary question. How many of those be... Supplementary question. How many of those 400 be... Supplementary question. How many of those 400 families be... Supplementary question. How many of those 400 families have be... Supplementary question. How many of those 400 families have been many of those 400 families have been put many of those 400 families have been put up many of those 400 families have been put up in many of those 400 families have been put up in motels many of those 400 families have been put up in motels because many of those 400 families have been put up in motels because he many of those 400 families have been put up in motels because he sold many of those 400 families have been put up in motels because he sold the put up in motels because he sold the state put up in motels because he sold the state houses, put up in motels because he sold the state houses, are put up in motels because he sold the state houses, are facing put up in motels because he sold the state houses, are facing being state houses, are facing being booted state houses, are facing being booted out state houses, are facing being booted out of state houses, are facing being booted out of the state houses, are facing being booted out of the motel state houses, are facing being booted out of the motel and state houses, are facing being booted out of the motel and on state houses, are facing being booted out of the motel and on to booted out of the motel and on to the booted out of the motel and on to the street booted out of the motel and on to the street because booted out of the motel and on to the street because the booted out of the motel and on to the street because the rooms booted out of the motel and on to the street because the rooms are the street because the rooms are needed the street because the rooms are needed for the street because the rooms are needed for thousands the street because the rooms are needed for thousands of the street because the rooms are needed for thousands of visiting needed for thousands of visiting tourists needed for thousands of visiting tourists attending needed for thousands of visiting tourists attending the needed for thousands of visiting tourists attending the World needed for thousands of visiting tourists attending the World Masters tourists attending the World Masters Games tourists attending the World Masters Games and tourists attending the World Masters Games and the tourists attending the World Masters Games and the Lions tourists attending the World Masters Games and the Lions tour? tourists attending the World Masters Games and the Lions tour? Of tourists attending the World Masters Games and the Lions tour? Of course, Games and the Lions tour? Of course, the Games and the Lions tour? Of course, the Government Games and the Lions tour? Of course, the Government agencies Games and the Lions tour? Of course, the Government agencies and the Government agencies and non-Government the Government agencies and Games the Government agencies and non-Government organisations will the Government agencies and non-Government organisations will do non-Government organisations will do whatever non-Government organisations will do whatever they non-Government organisations will do whatever they can non-Government organisations will do whatever they can to non-Government organisations will do whatever they can to meet non-Government organisations will do whatever they can to meet the non-Government organisations will do whatever they can to meet the needs whatever they can to meet the needs of whatever they can to meet the needs of people whatever they can to meet the needs of people who whatever they can to meet the needs of people who have whatever they can to meet the needs of people who have serious whatever they can to meet the needs of people who have serious housing of people who have serious housing need. of people who have serious housing need. They of people who have serious housing need. They would of people who have serious housing need. They would like of people who have serious housing need. They would like to of people who have serious housing need. They would like to be need. They would like to be supported need. They would like to be supported by need. They would like to be supported by the need. They would like to be supported by the Labour need. They would like to be supported by the Labour Party, supported by the Labour Party, supporting supported by the Labour Party, supporting development supported by the Labour Party, supporting development because supported by the Labour Party, supporting development because we supporting development because we could supporting development because we could get supporting development because we could get more supporting development because we could get more social supporting development because we could get more social houses supporting development because we could get more social houses in could get more social houses in Three could get more social houses in supported could get more social houses in Three Kings if could get more social houses in Three Kings if the could get more social houses in Three Kings if the Labour could get more social houses in Three Kings if the Labour Party Three Kings if the Labour Party wasn't Three Kings if the Labour Party wasn't opposing Three Kings if the Labour Party wasn't opposing the Three Kings if the Labour Party wasn't opposing the development. Three Kings if the Labour Party wasn't opposing the development. And wasn't opposing the development. And we wasn't opposing the development. And we could wasn't opposing the development. And we could build... wasn't opposing the development. And we could build... Order! wasn't opposing the development. And we could build... Order! Hundreds wasn't opposing the development. And we could build... Order! Hundreds of we could build... Order! Hundreds of them we could build... Order! Hundreds of them in we could build... Order! Hundreds of them in Point we could build... Order! Hundreds of them in Point England, we could build... Order! Hundreds of them in Point England, if we could build... Order! Hundreds of them in Point England, if you we could build... Order! Hundreds of them in Point England, if you didn't them in Point England, if you didn't Aussie them in Point England, if you didn't Aussie # them in Point England, if you didn't Aussie # -- them in Point England, if you didn't Aussie # -- oppose them in Point England, if you didn't Aussie # -- oppose the them in Point England, if you didn't Aussie # -- oppose the development. Aussie # -- oppose the development. There Aussie # -- oppose the development. There is Aussie # -- oppose the development. There is little Aussie # -- oppose the development. There is little point Aussie # -- oppose the development. There is little point in Aussie # -- oppose the development. There is little point in going Aussie # -- oppose the development. There is little point in going on There is little point in going on unless There is little point in going on unless Mr There is little point in going on unless Mr Robertson There is little point in going on unless Mr Robertson ceases There is little point in going on unless Mr Robertson ceases The unless Mr Robertson ceases The reason unless Mr Robertson ceases The reason for unless Mr Robertson ceases The reason for my unless Mr Robertson ceases The reason for my interjections unless Mr Robertson ceases The reason for my interjections is reason for my interjections is because reason for my interjections is because the reason for my interjections is because the PM reason for my interjections is because the PM continued reason for my interjections is because the PM continued to because the PM continued to misrepresent because the PM continued to because because the PM continued to misrepresent Labour Party because the PM continued to misrepresent Labour Party positions misrepresent Labour Party positions for misrepresent Labour Party positions for which misrepresent Labour Party positions for which he misrepresent Labour Party positions for which he is misrepresent Labour Party positions for which he is not... for which he is not... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> For <INTERRUPTION> For which <INTERRUPTION> For which she <INTERRUPTION> For which she -- <INTERRUPTION> For which she -- he <INTERRUPTION> For which she -- he is <INTERRUPTION> For which she -- he is not For which she -- he is not responsible For which she -- he is not responsible at For which she -- he is not responsible at all. For which she -- he is not responsible at all. Order! For which she -- he is not responsible at all. Order! That For which she -- he is not responsible at all. Order! That is responsible at all. Order! That is no responsible at all. Order! That is no reason responsible at all. Order! That is no reason - responsible at all. Order! That is no reason - the responsible at all. Order! That is no reason - the sort responsible at all. Order! That is no reason - the sort of responsible at all. Order! That is no reason - the sort of behaviour no reason - the sort of behaviour from no reason - the sort of behaviour from the no reason - the sort of behaviour from the member no reason - the sort of behaviour from the member and no reason - the sort of behaviour from the member and the no reason - the sort of behaviour from the member and the level no reason - the sort of behaviour from the member and the level of from the member and the level of this from the member and the level of this interjection. from the member and the level of this interjection. If from the member and the level of this interjection. If he from the member and the level of this interjection. If he feels from the member and the level of this interjection. If he feels he's this interjection. If he feels he's been this interjection. If he feels he's from this interjection. If he feels he's been misrepresented, then this interjection. If he feels he's been misrepresented, then he this interjection. If he feels he's been misrepresented, then he knows been misrepresented, then he knows there been misrepresented, then he knows there is been misrepresented, then he knows there is a been misrepresented, then he knows there is a process been misrepresented, then he knows there is a process for been misrepresented, then he knows there is a process for that. been misrepresented, then he knows there is a process for that. He there is a process for that. He lodges there is a process for that. He lodges a there is a process for that. He lodges a breach there is a process for that. He lodges a breach of there is a process for that. He lodges a breach of privilege there is a process for that. He lodges a breach of privilege via lodges a breach of privilege via Standing lodges a breach of privilege via Standing Order lodges a breach of privilege via Standing Order - lodges a breach of privilege via Standing Order - well, lodges a breach of privilege via Standing Order - well, the lodges a breach of privilege via Standing Order - well, the member Standing Order - well, the member shakes Standing Order - well, the member there Standing Order - well, the member shakes his head Standing Order - well, the member shakes his head as Standing Order - well, the member shakes his head as if Standing Order - well, the member shakes his head as if he Standing Order - well, the member shakes his head as if he knows shakes his head as if he knows that's shakes his head as if he knows that's not shakes his head as if he knows that's not the shakes his head as if he knows that's not the case. shakes his head as if he knows that's not the case. That shakes his head as if he knows that's not the case. That is that's not the case. That is Standing that's not the case. That is Standing Orders. that's not the case. That is Standing Orders. Certainly that's not the case. That is Standing Orders. Certainly the that's not the case. That is Standing Orders. Certainly the way Standing Orders. Certainly the way to Standing Orders. Certainly the way Standing Standing Orders. Certainly the way to address it Standing Orders. Certainly the way to address it is Standing Orders. Certainly the way to address it is not Standing Orders. Certainly the way to address it is not the Standing Orders. Certainly the way to address it is not the way Standing Orders. Certainly the way to address it is not the way the to address it is not the way the member to address it is not the way the member just to address it is not the way the member just did, to address it is not the way the member just did, by to address it is not the way the member just did, by yelling to address it is not the way the member just did, by yelling across member just did, by yelling across the member just did, by yelling across the House. member just did, by yelling across the House. <INTERRUPTION> the House. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! The Order! The level Order! The level of Order! The level of interjection Order! The level of interjection from Order! The level of interjection from all Order! The level of interjection from all sides Order! The level of interjection from all sides is Order! The level of interjection from all sides is out Order! The level of interjection from all sides is out of Order! The level of interjection from all sides is out of order. from all sides is out of order. Frankly, from all sides is out of order. Frankly, out from all sides is out of order. Frankly, out of from all sides is out of order. Frankly, out of control. from all sides is out of order. Frankly, out of control. It from all sides is out of order. Frankly, out of control. It will Frankly, out of control. It will settle Frankly, out of control. It will settle down Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and if Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and if I Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and if I need Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and if I need to Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and if I need to do Frankly, out of control. It will settle down and if I need to do it settle down and if I need to do it with settle down and if I need to do it with a settle down and if I need to do it with a more settle down and if I need to do it with a more stringent settle down and if I need to do it with a more stringent measure, settle down and if I need to do it with a more stringent measure, then with a more stringent measure, then I with a more stringent measure, then I will with a more stringent measure, then I will do with a more stringent measure, then I will do so. with a more stringent measure, then I will do so. Andrew with a more stringent measure, then I will do so. Andrew Little. I will do so. Andrew Little. Supplementary I will do so. Andrew Little. Supplementary question. I will do so. Andrew Little. Supplementary question. Thank I will do so. Andrew Little. Supplementary question. Thank you. Supplementary question. Thank you. How Supplementary question. Thank you. How badly Supplementary question. Thank you. How badly has Supplementary question. Thank you. How badly has his Supplementary question. Thank you. How badly has his Government Supplementary question. Thank you. How badly has his Government failed How badly has his Government failed New How badly has his Government failed New Zealanders How badly has his Government failed New Zealanders when How badly has his Government failed New Zealanders when the How badly has his Government failed New Zealanders when the social New Zealanders when the social Housing New Zealanders when the social Housing Minister's New Zealanders when the social Housing Minister's answer New Zealanders when the social Housing Minister's answer to New Zealanders when the social Housing Minister's answer to the Housing Minister's answer to the housing Housing Minister's answer to the housing crisis Housing Minister's answer to the housing crisis this Housing Minister's answer to the housing crisis this morning Housing Minister's answer to the housing crisis this morning was Housing Minister's answer to the housing crisis this morning was to housing crisis this morning was to shrug housing crisis this morning was to shrug her housing crisis this morning was to shrug her shoulders housing crisis this morning was to shrug her shoulders and housing crisis this morning was to shrug her shoulders and say, housing crisis this morning was to shrug her shoulders and say, "A shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is better shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is better than shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is better than a shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is better than a car." shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is better than a car." Is shrug her shoulders and say, "A motel is better than a car." Is a motel is better than a car." Is a house motel is better than a car." Is a house really motel is better than a car." Is a house really too motel is better than a car." Is a house really too much motel is better than a car." Is a house really too much to motel is better than a car." Is a house really too much to ask motel is better than a car." Is a house really too much to ask for house really too much to ask for from house really too much to ask for from this house really too much to ask for from this National house really too much to ask for from this National Government? from this National Government? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order. <INTERRUPTION> Order. No. <INTERRUPTION> Order. No. In <INTERRUPTION> Order. No. In fact, <INTERRUPTION> Order. No. In fact, Government Order. No. In fact, Government agencies Order. No. In fact, Government agencies out Order. No. In fact, Government agencies out around Order. No. In fact, Government agencies out around - Order. No. In fact, Government agencies out around - particularly agencies out around - particularly in agencies out around - particularly in Auckland agencies out around - particularly in Auckland but agencies out around - particularly in Auckland but other agencies out around - particularly in Auckland but other polices agencies out around - particularly in Auckland but other polices - in Auckland but other polices - asking in Auckland but other polices - asking exactly to in Auckland but other polices - asking exactly to get in Auckland but other polices - asking exactly to get the in Auckland but other polices - asking exactly to get the houses in Auckland but other polices - asking exactly to get the houses we asking exactly to get the houses we need, asking exactly to get the houses we need, and asking exactly to get the houses we need, and one asking exactly to get the houses we need, and one way asking exactly to get the houses we need, and one way the asking exactly to get the houses we need, and one way the Labour asking exactly to get the houses we need, and one way the Labour Party need, and one way the Labour Party could need, and one way the Labour Party could contribute need, and one way the Labour Party could contribute to need, and one way the Labour Party could contribute to it need, and one way the Labour Party could contribute to it is need, and one way the Labour Party could contribute to it is to need, and one way the Labour Party could contribute to it is to stop could contribute to it is to stop opposing could contribute to it is to stop opposing the could contribute to it is to stop opposing the Point could contribute to it is to stop opposing the Point England could contribute to it is to stop opposing the Point England bill opposing the Point England bill going opposing the Point England bill going through opposing the Point England bill going through the opposing the Point England bill going through the House, opposing the Point England bill going through the House, because going through the House, because that going through the House, because that will going through the House, because that will enable going through the House, because that will enable hundreds going through the House, because that will enable hundreds of going through the House, because that will enable hundreds of social that will enable hundreds of social houses that will enable hundreds of social houses to that will enable hundreds of social houses to be that will enable hundreds of social houses to be built, that will enable hundreds of social houses to be built, but that will enable hundreds of social houses to be built, but the that will enable hundreds of social houses to be built, but the Labour houses to be built, but the Labour Party houses to be built, but the Labour Party is houses to be built, but the Labour Party is opposing houses to be built, but the Labour Party is opposing it, houses to be built, but the Labour Party is opposing it, as houses to be built, but the Labour Party is opposing it, as they houses to be built, but the Labour Party is opposing it, as they are Party is opposing it, as they are opposing Party is opposing it, as they are opposing the Party is opposing it, as they are opposing the Three Party is opposing it, as they are opposing the Three Kings Party is opposing it, as they are opposing the Three Kings development opposing the Three Kings development which opposing the Three Kings development which equally opposing the Three Kings development which equally would opposing the Three Kings development which equally would allow opposing the Three Kings development which equally would allow for which equally would allow for hundreds which equally would allow for hundreds more which equally would allow for hundreds more social which equally would allow for hundreds more social houses. which equally would allow for hundreds more social houses. Order! hundreds more social houses. Order! And hundreds more social houses. Order! And I hundreds more social houses. Order! And I ask hundreds more social houses. Order! And I ask them hundreds more social houses. Order! And I ask them to hundreds more social houses. Order! And I ask them to change hundreds more social houses. Order! And I ask them to change their hundreds more social houses. Order! And I ask them to change their mind. And I ask them to change their mind. That And I ask them to change their mind. That answer And I ask them to change their mind. That answer is And I ask them to change their mind. That answer is long And I ask them to change their mind. That answer is long enough. That answer is long enough. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Mr Twyford, Mr Twyford, when Mr Twyford, when I Mr Twyford, when I stand Mr Twyford, when I stand to Mr Twyford, when I stand to my Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that is Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that is certainly Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that is certainly the Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that is certainly the time Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that is certainly the time to Mr Twyford, when I stand to my feet that is certainly the time to cease that is certainly the time to cease interjecting. that is certainly the time to cease interjecting. Supplementary interjecting. Supplementary question. interjecting. Supplementary question. PM, interjecting. Supplementary question. PM, if interjecting. Supplementary question. PM, if political interjecting. Supplementary question. PM, if political parties question. PM, if political parties have question. PM, if political parties have supported question. PM, if political parties have supported 70,000 question. PM, if political parties have supported 70,000 net question. PM, if political parties have supported 70,000 net - question. PM, if political parties have supported 70,000 net - the have supported 70,000 net - the population have supported 70,000 net - the population of have supported 70,000 net - the population of Rotorua, have supported 70,000 net - the population of Rotorua, coming have supported 70,000 net - the population of Rotorua, coming here population of Rotorua, coming here every population of Rotorua, coming here population population of Rotorua, coming here every here without population of Rotorua, coming here every here without building population of Rotorua, coming here every here without building the every here without building the infrastructure, every here without building the infrastructure, including every here without building the infrastructure, including housing infrastructure, including housing every infrastructure, including housing every year, infrastructure, including housing every year, why infrastructure, including housing every year, why are infrastructure, including housing every year, why are we infrastructure, including housing every year, why are we having infrastructure, including housing every year, why are we having this every year, why are we having this sad every year, why are we having this sad argument every year, why are we having this sad argument between every year, why are we having this sad argument between the every year, why are we having this sad argument between the guilty sad argument between the guilty parties? sad argument between the guilty parties? <INTERRUPTION> parties? <INTERRUPTION> Of parties? <INTERRUPTION> Of course, parties? <INTERRUPTION> Of course, the parties? <INTERRUPTION> Of course, the member parties? <INTERRUPTION> Of course, the member may parties? <INTERRUPTION> Of course, the member may not Of course, the member may not realise, Of course, the member may not realise, but Of course, the member may not realise, but the Of course, the member may not realise, but the people Of course, the member may not realise, but the people - Of course, the member may not realise, but the people - the Of course, the member may not realise, but the people - the people realise, but the people - the people who realise, but the people - the people who - realise, but the people - the people who - in realise, but the people - the people who - in his realise, but the people - the people who - in his words realise, but the people - the people who - in his words - realise, but the people - the people who - in his words - are realise, but the people - the people who - in his words - are guilty realise, but the people - the people who - in his words - are guilty are who - in his words - are guilty are the who - in his words - are guilty are the Kiwis who - in his words - are guilty are the Kiwis not who - in his words - are guilty are the Kiwis not leaving. who - in his words - are guilty are the Kiwis not leaving. Since... the Kiwis not leaving. Since... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Since <INTERRUPTION> Since he <INTERRUPTION> Since he moved <INTERRUPTION> Since he moved out <INTERRUPTION> Since he moved out of <INTERRUPTION> Since he moved out of Government <INTERRUPTION> Since he moved out of Government - Since he moved out of Government - since Since he moved out of Government - since he Since he moved out of Government - since he moved Since he moved out of Government - since he moved out Since he moved out of Government - since he moved out of Since he moved out of Government - since he moved out of Government, since he moved out of Government, 40,000 since he moved out of Government, 40,000 Kiwis since he moved out of Government, 40,000 Kiwis per since he moved out of Government, 40,000 Kiwis per year since he moved out of Government, 40,000 Kiwis per year more since he moved out of Government, 40,000 Kiwis per year more are 40,000 Kiwis per year more are staying 40,000 Kiwis per year more are staying in 40,000 Kiwis per year more are staying in New 40,000 Kiwis per year more are staying in New Zealand. staying in New Zealand. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> And <INTERRUPTION> And I <INTERRUPTION> And I would <INTERRUPTION> And I would have <INTERRUPTION> And I would have thought <INTERRUPTION> And I would have thought that <INTERRUPTION> And I would have thought that New And I would have thought that New Zealand And I would have thought that New Zealand First And I would have thought that New Zealand First would And I would have thought that New Zealand First would regard And I would have thought that New Zealand First would regard that And I would have thought that New Zealand First would regard that as Zealand First would regard that as success. Zealand First would regard that as success. <INTERRUPTION> success. <INTERRUPTION> Order! success. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question success. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question number success. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question number 26789 success. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question number 26789 -- success. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question number 26789 -- 2. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: What My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has he Finance: What reports has he received Finance: What reports has he received on Finance: What reports has he received on job Finance: What reports has he received on job growth Finance: What reports has he received on job growth in Finance: What reports has he received on job growth in the Finance: What reports has he received on job growth in the New received on job growth in the New Zealand received on job growth in the New Zealand economy? Over Over the Over the last Over the last Year Over the last Year 137,000 Over the last Year 137,000 jobs Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have been Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have been added Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have been added into Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have been added into the Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have been added into the New Over the last Year 137,000 jobs have been added into the New Zealand been added into the New Zealand economy. been added into the New Zealand economy. <INTERRUPTION> economy. <INTERRUPTION> This economy. <INTERRUPTION> This job economy. <INTERRUPTION> This job growth economy. <INTERRUPTION> This job growth has economy. <INTERRUPTION> This job growth has been economy. <INTERRUPTION> This job growth has been accompanied This job growth has been accompanied by This job growth has been accompanied by rising This job growth has been accompanied by rising wages This job growth has been accompanied by rising wages for This job growth has been accompanied by rising wages for Kiwi This job growth has been accompanied by rising wages for Kiwi families, by rising wages for Kiwi families, with by rising wages for Kiwi families, with the by rising wages for Kiwi families, with the average by rising wages for Kiwi families, with the average wage by rising wages for Kiwi families, with the average wage growing by rising wages for Kiwi families, with the average wage growing at with the average wage growing at twice with the average wage growing at twice the with the average wage growing at twice the rate with the average wage growing at twice the rate of with the average wage growing at twice the rate of inflation, with the average wage growing at twice the rate of inflation, to twice the rate of inflation, to $58,700 twice the rate of inflation, to $58,700 annually twice the rate of inflation, to $58,700 annually currently, twice the rate of inflation, to $58,700 annually currently, and $58,700 annually currently, and forecast $58,700 annually currently, and forecast to $58,700 annually currently, and forecast to reach $58,700 annually currently, and forecast to reach 66,000 $58,700 annually currently, and forecast to reach 66,000 by $58,700 annually currently, and forecast to reach 66,000 by 2021. forecast to reach 66,000 by 2021. Our forecast to reach 66,000 by 2021. Zealand forecast to reach 66,000 by 2021. Our strong employment forecast to reach 66,000 by 2021. Our strong employment growth forecast to reach 66,000 by 2021. Our strong employment growth has Our strong employment growth has been Our strong employment growth has been coupled Our strong employment growth has been coupled with Our strong employment growth has been coupled with strong Our strong employment growth has been coupled with strong economic been coupled with strong economic growth been coupled with strong economic been been coupled with strong economic growth of over been coupled with strong economic growth of over 3%. been coupled with strong economic growth of over 3%. This been coupled with strong economic growth of over 3%. This hasn't growth of over 3%. This hasn't happened growth of over 3%. This hasn't happened by growth of over 3%. This hasn't happened by accident growth of over 3%. This hasn't happened by accident - growth of over 3%. This hasn't happened by accident - it's growth of over 3%. This hasn't happened by accident - it's the happened by accident - it's the result happened by accident - it's the been happened by accident - it's the result of hard happened by accident - it's the result of hard work happened by accident - it's the result of hard work by happened by accident - it's the result of hard work by households result of hard work by households and result of hard work by households and businesses, result of hard work by households and businesses, backed result of hard work by households and businesses, backed by result of hard work by households and businesses, backed by the and businesses, backed by the Government's and businesses, backed by the and and businesses, backed by the Government's clear economic and businesses, backed by the Government's clear economic plan and businesses, backed by the Government's clear economic plan for Government's clear economic plan for our Government's clear economic plan for our country's Government's clear economic plan for our country's future. Government's clear economic plan for our country's future. <INTERRUPTION> our country's future. <INTERRUPTION> . our country's future. <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary our country's future. <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. our country's future. <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. How our country's future. <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. How does . Supplementary question. How does New . Supplementary question. How does New Zealand's . Supplementary question. How does New Zealand's employment . Supplementary question. How does New Zealand's employment statistics New Zealand's employment statistics stack New Zealand's employment statistics stack up New Zealand's employment statistics stack up against New Zealand's employment statistics stack up against our New Zealand's employment statistics stack up against our international stack up against our international competitors? stack up against our international competitors? <INTERRUPTION> competitors? <INTERRUPTION> Very competitors? <INTERRUPTION> Very well, competitors? <INTERRUPTION> Very well, in competitors? <INTERRUPTION> Very well, in fact. competitors? <INTERRUPTION> Very well, in fact. New competitors? <INTERRUPTION> Very well, in fact. New Zealand's Very well, in fact. New Zealand's employment Very well, in fact. New Zealand's employment rate Very well, in fact. New Zealand's employment rate - Very well, in fact. New Zealand's employment rate - the Very well, in fact. New Zealand's employment rate - the proportion Very well, in fact. New Zealand's employment rate - the proportion of employment rate - the proportion of the employment rate - the proportion of stack employment rate - the proportion of the total population employment rate - the proportion of the total population aged employment rate - the proportion of the total population aged 15 employment rate - the proportion of the total population aged 15 years the total population aged 15 years or the total population aged 15 years or older, the total population aged 15 years or older, right the total population aged 15 years or older, right up the total population aged 15 years or older, right up to the total population aged 15 years or older, right up to 115 the total population aged 15 years or older, right up to 115 - the total population aged 15 years or older, right up to 115 - at the total population aged 15 years or older, right up to 115 - at work or older, right up to 115 - at work is or older, right up to 115 - at work is 66.9%. or older, right up to 115 - at work is 66.9%. That's or older, right up to 115 - at work is 66.9%. That's the or older, right up to 115 - at work is 66.9%. That's the highest or older, right up to 115 - at work is 66.9%. That's the highest rate is 66.9%. That's the highest rate that is 66.9%. That's the highest rate or is 66.9%. That's the highest rate that New Zealand is 66.9%. That's the highest rate that New Zealand has is 66.9%. That's the highest rate that New Zealand has ever is 66.9%. That's the highest rate that New Zealand has ever had is 66.9%. That's the highest rate that New Zealand has ever had and that New Zealand has ever had and the that New Zealand has ever had and the second that New Zealand has ever had and the second highest that New Zealand has ever had and the second highest employment that New Zealand has ever had and the second highest employment rate the second highest employment rate in the second highest employment rate the the second highest employment rate in the whole the second highest employment rate in the whole of the second highest employment rate in the whole of the the second highest employment rate in the whole of the developed the second highest employment rate in the whole of the developed world. in the whole of the developed world. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> ? <INTERRUPTION> ? Particular, <INTERRUPTION> ? Particular, we're <INTERRUPTION> ? Particular, we're significantly ? Particular, we're significantly ahead ? Particular, we're significantly ahead of ? Particular, we're significantly ahead of our ? Particular, we're significantly ahead of our closest ? Particular, we're significantly ahead of our closest neighbour, ahead of our closest neighbour, Australia, ahead of our closest neighbour, Australia, who's ahead of our closest neighbour, Australia, who's employment ahead of our closest neighbour, Australia, who's employment rate ahead of our closest neighbour, Australia, who's employment rate is Australia, who's employment rate is only Australia, who's employment rate is only 60.8%. Australia, who's employment rate is only 60.8%. <INTERRUPTION> only 60.8%. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary only 60.8%. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. only 60.8%. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Order! only 60.8%. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Order! Are supplementary question. Order! Are the supplementary question. Order! Are the jobs supplementary question. Order! Are the jobs being supplementary question. Order! Are the jobs being created supplementary question. Order! Are the jobs being created in supplementary question. Order! Are the jobs being created in New the jobs being created in New Zealand the jobs being created in New Zealand predominantly the jobs being created in New Zealand predominantly full-time the jobs being created in New Zealand predominantly full-time or Zealand predominantly full-time or part-time Zealand predominantly full-time or only Zealand predominantly full-time or part-time and how Zealand predominantly full-time or part-time and how does Zealand predominantly full-time or part-time and how does this Zealand predominantly full-time or part-time and how does this compare part-time and how does this compare to part-time and how does this compare to Australia? part-time and how does this compare to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I am to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I am waiting to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I am waiting for to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I am waiting for Tracey to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to Australia? <INTERRUPTION> . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to stop . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to stop interjecting, . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to stop interjecting, and . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to stop interjecting, and then . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to stop interjecting, and then we . I am waiting for Tracey Martin to stop interjecting, and then we will stop interjecting, and then we will have stop interjecting, and then we will have the stop interjecting, and then we will have the answer. stop interjecting, and then we will have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The bulk have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The bulk of have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The bulk of the have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The bulk of the jobs have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The bulk of the jobs being have the answer. <INTERRUPTION> The bulk of the jobs being created The bulk of the jobs being created in The bulk of the jobs being created in New Zealand The bulk of the jobs being created in New Zealand are The bulk of the jobs being created in New Zealand are full-time The bulk of the jobs being created in New Zealand are full-time jobs. in New Zealand are full-time jobs. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> ? <INTERRUPTION> ? Just <INTERRUPTION> ? Just the <INTERRUPTION> ? Just the last <INTERRUPTION> ? Just the last year, <INTERRUPTION> ? Just the last year, the <INTERRUPTION> ? Just the last year, the percentage ? Just the last year, the percentage of ? Just the last year, the percentage of New ? Just the last year, the percentage of New Zealand's ? Just the last year, the percentage of New Zealand's labour ? Just the last year, the percentage of New Zealand's labour force of New Zealand's labour force employed of New Zealand's labour force employed full-time of New Zealand's labour force employed full-time rose of New Zealand's labour force employed full-time rose to of New Zealand's labour force employed full-time rose to just employed full-time rose to just under employed full-time rose to just under 75%. employed full-time rose to just under 75%. If employed full-time rose to just under 75%. If you employed full-time rose to just under 75%. If you compare employed full-time rose to just under 75%. If you compare that employed full-time rose to just under 75%. If you compare that with under 75%. If you compare that with Australia, under 75%. If you compare that with Australia, their under 75%. If you compare that with Australia, their rate under 75%. If you compare that with Australia, their rate fell under 75%. If you compare that with Australia, their rate fell to under 75%. If you compare that with Australia, their rate fell to just Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. In Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. In fact, Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. In fact, over Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. In fact, over half Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. In fact, over half of Australia, their rate fell to just 64%. In fact, over half of New 64%. In fact, over half of New Zealand's 64%. In fact, over half of New Zealand's entire 64%. In fact, over half of New Zealand's entire population 64%. In fact, over half of New Zealand's entire population over 64%. In fact, over half of New Zealand's entire population over 15 Zealand's entire population over 15 is Zealand's entire population over 15 is now Zealand's entire population over 15 is now employed Zealand's entire population over 15 is now employed full-time, Zealand's entire population over 15 is now employed full-time, compared is now employed full-time, compared to is now employed full-time, compared to just is now employed full-time, compared to just 42% is now employed full-time, compared to just 42% in is now employed full-time, compared to just 42% in Australia. is now employed full-time, compared to just 42% in Australia. So, is now employed full-time, compared to just 42% in Australia. So, with to just 42% in Australia. So, with this to just 42% in Australia. So, with this record to just 42% in Australia. So, with this record it to just 42% in Australia. So, with this record it is to just 42% in Australia. So, with this record it is strange to just 42% in Australia. So, with this record it is strange to to just 42% in Australia. So, with this record it is strange to see this record it is strange to see some this record it is strange to see some commentators this record it is strange to see some commentators advocate this record it is strange to see some commentators advocate for this record it is strange to see some commentators advocate for New some commentators advocate for New Zealand's some commentators advocate for New Zealand's monetary some commentators advocate for New Zealand's monetary framework some commentators advocate for New Zealand's monetary framework to some commentators advocate for New Zealand's monetary framework to be Zealand's monetary framework to be more Zealand's monetary framework to be Zealand's Zealand's monetary framework to be more like Australia's. Zealand's monetary framework to be more like Australia's. We've more like Australia's. We've achieved more like Australia's. We've achieved excellent more like Australia's. We've achieved excellent results more like Australia's. We've achieved excellent results in more like Australia's. We've achieved excellent results in his achieved excellent results in his country. achieved excellent results in his country. I achieved excellent results in his country. I think achieved excellent results in his country. I think it's achieved excellent results in his country. I think it's possibly country. I think it's possibly Australia country. I think it's possibly Australia should country. I think it's possibly Australia should change country. I think it's possibly Australia should change to country. I think it's possibly Australia should change to ours. Australia should change to ours. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> How <INTERRUPTION> How is <INTERRUPTION> How is New <INTERRUPTION> How is New Zealand's <INTERRUPTION> How is New Zealand's actual <INTERRUPTION> How is New Zealand's actual job How is New Zealand's actual job creation How is New Zealand's actual job creation tracking How is New Zealand's actual job creation tracking against How is New Zealand's actual job creation tracking against previous creation tracking against previous estimates creation tracking against previous estimates of creation tracking against previous estimates of job creation tracking against previous estimates of job growth? creation tracking against previous estimates of job growth? Very creation tracking against previous estimates of job growth? Very well. estimates of job growth? Very well. There estimates of job growth? Very well. There have estimates of job growth? Very well. There have been estimates of job growth? Very well. There have been 328,000 estimates of job growth? Very well. There have been 328,000 jobs estimates of job growth? Very well. There have been 328,000 jobs in There have been 328,000 jobs in addition There have been 328,000 jobs in addition created There have been 328,000 jobs in addition created since There have been 328,000 jobs in addition created since 2008, There have been 328,000 jobs in addition created since 2008, and addition created since 2008, and Treasurer addition created since 2008, and addition addition created since 2008, and Treasurer expects a addition created since 2008, and Treasurer expects a further addition created since 2008, and Treasurer expects a further strong Treasurer expects a further strong growth Treasurer expects a further strong growth over Treasurer expects a further strong growth over the Treasurer expects a further strong growth over the coming Treasurer expects a further strong growth over the coming years. growth over the coming years. Members growth over the coming years. Members may growth over the coming years. Members may recall growth over the coming years. Members may recall Treasury's growth over the coming years. Members may recall Treasury's 2011 Members may recall Treasury's 2011 estimate, Members may recall Treasury's 2011 estimate, for Members may recall Treasury's 2011 estimate, for 170,000 Members may recall Treasury's 2011 estimate, for 170,000 jobs Members may recall Treasury's 2011 estimate, for 170,000 jobs to Members may recall Treasury's 2011 estimate, for 170,000 jobs to be estimate, for 170,000 jobs to be created estimate, for 170,000 jobs to be Members estimate, for 170,000 jobs to be created over the estimate, for 170,000 jobs to be created over the following estimate, for 170,000 jobs to be created over the following four created over the following four years. created over the following four years. This created over the following four years. This was created over the following four years. This was attacked created over the following four years. This was attacked by created over the following four years. This was attacked by some years. This was attacked by some critics years. This was attacked by some critics as years. This was attacked by some critics as a years. This was attacked by some critics as a failure, years. This was attacked by some critics as a failure, and years. This was attacked by some critics as a failure, and a years. This was attacked by some critics as a failure, and a broken critics as a failure, and a broken promise critics as a failure, and a broken promise because critics as a failure, and a broken promise because they critics as a failure, and a broken promise because they didn't critics as a failure, and a broken promise because they didn't think critics as a failure, and a broken promise because they didn't think it promise because they didn't think it would promise because they didn't think it would be promise because they didn't think it would be achieved. promise because they didn't think it would be achieved. Only promise because they didn't think it would be achieved. Only for promise because they didn't think it would be achieved. Only for the would be achieved. Only for the actual would be achieved. Only for the actual figure would be achieved. Only for the actual figure to would be achieved. Only for the actual figure to come would be achieved. Only for the actual figure to come in would be achieved. Only for the actual figure to come in yacht would be achieved. Only for the actual figure to come in yacht 197 actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- at actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- at 197,000, actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- at 197,000, some actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- at 197,000, some 27,000 actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more actual figure to come in yacht 197 -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs than -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs than anticipated. -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs than anticipated. It -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs than anticipated. It would -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs than anticipated. It would be -- at 197,000, some 27,000 more jobs than anticipated. It would be a than anticipated. It would be a shame than anticipated. It would be a shame for than anticipated. It would be a shame for the than anticipated. It would be a shame for the critics than anticipated. It would be a shame for the critics to than anticipated. It would be a shame for the critics to repeat shame for the critics to repeat their shame for the critics to repeat their mistake, shame for the critics to repeat their mistake, just shame for the critics to repeat their mistake, just because shame for the critics to repeat their mistake, just because it shame for the critics to repeat their mistake, just because it is shame for the critics to repeat their mistake, just because it is an their mistake, just because it is an election their mistake, just because it is an election year. their mistake, just because it is an election year. <INTERRUPTION> election year. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. election year. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Thank election year. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Thank you. election year. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Thank you. According Supplementary. Thank you. According to Supplementary. Thank you. According to the Supplementary. Thank you. According to the household Supplementary. Thank you. According to the household labour Supplementary. Thank you. According to the household labour force to the household labour force survey, to the household labour force survey, how to the household labour force survey, how many to the household labour force survey, how many more to the household labour force survey, how many more New to the household labour force survey, how many more New Zealanders survey, how many more New Zealanders are survey, how many more New Zealanders are unemployed survey, how many more New Zealanders are unemployed now survey, how many more New Zealanders are unemployed now than survey, how many more New Zealanders are unemployed now than when survey, how many more New Zealanders are unemployed now than when his are unemployed now than when his Government are unemployed now than when his Government took are unemployed now than when his Government took office? are unemployed now than when his Government took office? I are unemployed now than when his Government took office? I don't are unemployed now than when his Government took office? I don't have Government took office? I don't have - Government took office? I don't have - the Government took office? I don't have - the exact Government took office? I don't have - the exact number Government took office? I don't have - the exact number with Government took office? I don't have - the exact number with me. - the exact number with me. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> But <INTERRUPTION> But the <INTERRUPTION> But the point <INTERRUPTION> But the point is <INTERRUPTION> But the point is for <INTERRUPTION> But the point is for the <INTERRUPTION> But the point is for the member's But the point is for the member's benefit But the point is for the member's benefit the But the point is for the member's benefit the key But the point is for the member's benefit the key - But the point is for the member's benefit the key - the But the point is for the member's benefit the key - the key But the point is for the member's benefit the key - the key point But the point is for the member's benefit the key - the key point is benefit the key - the key point is how benefit the key - the key point is how many benefit the key - the key point is how many people benefit the key - the key point is how many people are benefit the key - the key point is how many people are employed, benefit the key - the key point is how many people are employed, and benefit the key - the key point is how many people are employed, and in how many people are employed, and in New how many people are employed, and in New Zealand, how many people are employed, and in New Zealand, in how many people are employed, and in New Zealand, in this how many people are employed, and in New Zealand, in this country, how many people are employed, and in New Zealand, in this country, we New Zealand, in this country, we have New Zealand, in this country, we have passed New Zealand, in this country, we have passed 2.5 New Zealand, in this country, we have passed 2.5 million New Zealand, in this country, we have passed 2.5 million employed New Zealand, in this country, we have passed 2.5 million employed for have passed 2.5 million employed for the have passed 2.5 million employed for the first have passed 2.5 million employed for the first time have passed 2.5 million employed for the first time and have passed 2.5 million employed for the first time and we have passed 2.5 million employed for the first time and we have have passed 2.5 million employed for the first time and we have the the first time and we have the second the first time and we have the second highest the first time and we have the second highest employment the first time and we have the second highest employment rate the first time and we have the second highest employment rate in second highest employment rate in the second highest employment rate in the OECD. second highest employment rate in the OECD. That second highest employment rate in the OECD. That is second highest employment rate in the OECD. That is progress! the OECD. That is progress! <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Order! <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Order! Thank <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Order! Thank you. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he seen Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he seen any Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he seen any reports Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he seen any reports about Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he seen any reports about the Supplementary. Order! Thank you. Has he seen any reports about the loss he seen any reports about the loss of he seen any reports about the loss of jobs he seen any reports about the loss of jobs and he seen any reports about the loss of jobs and livelihoods he seen any reports about the loss of jobs and livelihoods caused he seen any reports about the loss of jobs and livelihoods caused by of jobs and livelihoods caused by more of jobs and livelihoods caused by more frequent of jobs and livelihoods caused by more frequent and of jobs and livelihoods caused by more frequent and more of jobs and livelihoods caused by more frequent and more severe of jobs and livelihoods caused by more frequent and more severe floods more frequent and more severe floods and more frequent and more severe floods and droughts more frequent and more severe floods and droughts resulting more frequent and more severe floods and droughts resulting from more frequent and more severe floods and droughts resulting from climate and droughts resulting from climate change? and droughts resulting from climate change? No, and droughts resulting from climate change? No, I and droughts resulting from climate change? No, I haven't and droughts resulting from climate change? No, I haven't seen and droughts resulting from climate change? No, I haven't seen any change? No, I haven't seen any reports change? No, I haven't seen any and change? No, I haven't seen any reports in that change? No, I haven't seen any reports in that regard. change? No, I haven't seen any reports in that regard. What change? No, I haven't seen any reports in that regard. What I change? No, I haven't seen any reports in that regard. What I can reports in that regard. What I can say reports in that regard. What I can say to reports in that regard. What I can say to the reports in that regard. What I can say to the member reports in that regard. What I can say to the member is reports in that regard. What I can say to the member is actually reports in that regard. What I can say to the member is actually all say to the member is actually all the say to the member is actually all the reports say to the member is actually all the reports in say to the member is actually all the reports in New say to the member is actually all the reports in New Zealand say to the member is actually all the reports in New Zealand of the reports in New Zealand of increasing the reports in New Zealand of increasing numbers the reports in New Zealand of increasing numbers of the reports in New Zealand of increasing numbers of jobs the reports in New Zealand of increasing numbers of jobs in the reports in New Zealand of increasing numbers of jobs in net increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. As increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. As I increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. As I said, increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. As I said, 137,000 increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. As I said, 137,000 extra increasing numbers of jobs in net terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs added terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs added to terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs added to the terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs added to the New terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs added to the New Zealand terms. As I said, 137,000 extra jobs added to the New Zealand economy added to the New Zealand economy last added to the New Zealand economy terms. added to the New Zealand economy last year. The added to the New Zealand economy last year. The second-highest last year. The second-highest employment last year. The second-highest terms. last year. The second-highest employment rate in last year. The second-highest employment rate in the last year. The second-highest employment rate in the OECD, last year. The second-highest employment rate in the OECD, and employment rate in the OECD, and that's employment rate in the OECD, and that's under employment rate in the OECD, and that's under the employment rate in the OECD, and that's under the existing that's under the existing Government's that's under the existing Government's policies that's under the existing Government's policies with that's under the existing Government's policies with support Government's policies with support for Government's policies with support for the Government's policies with support for the existing Government's policies with support for the existing Government Government's policies with support for the existing Government monetary for the existing Government monetary policy for the existing Government monetary policy framework, for the existing Government monetary policy framework, which for the existing Government monetary policy framework, which seems for the existing Government monetary policy framework, which seems to for the existing Government monetary policy framework, which seems to me policy framework, which seems to me an policy framework, which seems to me an indication policy framework, which seems to me an indication that policy framework, which seems to me an indication that other policy framework, which seems to me an indication that other countries an indication that other countries should an indication that other countries an an indication that other countries should look to an indication that other countries should look to us an indication that other countries should look to us for an indication that other countries should look to us for inspiration. should look to us for inspiration. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What reports <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What reports has <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What reports has he Supplementary. What reports has he seen Supplementary. What reports has he seen about Supplementary. What reports has he seen about the Supplementary. What reports has he seen about the jobs Supplementary. What reports has he seen about the jobs lost Supplementary. What reports has he seen about the jobs lost because Supplementary. What reports has he seen about the jobs lost because of seen about the jobs lost because of the seen about the jobs lost because of the 2013 seen about the jobs lost because of the 2013 drought seen about the jobs lost because of the 2013 drought that seen about the jobs lost because of the 2013 drought that wiped seen about the jobs lost because of the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 billion the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 billion off the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 billion off the the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 billion off the economy the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 billion off the economy or the 2013 drought that wiped $1.5 billion off the economy or more billion off the economy or more recent billion off the economy or more recent droughts billion off the economy or more recent droughts in billion off the economy or more recent droughts in Northland billion off the economy or more recent droughts in Northland and recent droughts in Northland and North recent droughts in Northland and North Canterbury? recent droughts in Northland and North Canterbury? One recent droughts in Northland and North Canterbury? One of recent droughts in Northland and North Canterbury? One of the North Canterbury? One of the challenges North Canterbury? One of the North North Canterbury? One of the challenges to the North Canterbury? One of the challenges to the New North Canterbury? One of the challenges to the New Zealand challenges to the New Zealand economy, challenges to the New Zealand economy, particularly challenges to the New Zealand economy, particularly in challenges to the New Zealand economy, particularly in the challenges to the New Zealand economy, particularly in the primary economy, particularly in the primary sector, economy, particularly in the primary sector, is economy, particularly in the primary sector, is that economy, particularly in the primary sector, is that droughts economy, particularly in the primary sector, is that droughts occur economy, particularly in the primary sector, is that droughts occur from sector, is that droughts occur from time-to-time. sector, is that droughts occur from time-to-time. That sector, is that droughts occur from time-to-time. That is sector, is that droughts occur from time-to-time. That is one sector, is that droughts occur from time-to-time. That is one of sector, is that droughts occur from time-to-time. That is one of the time-to-time. That is one of the reasons time-to-time. That is one of the reasons why time-to-time. That is one of the reasons why this time-to-time. That is one of the reasons why this Government time-to-time. That is one of the reasons why this Government is time-to-time. That is one of the reasons why this Government is the reasons why this Government is the so reasons why this Government is the so keen reasons why this Government is the so keen to reasons why this Government is the so keen to encourage reasons why this Government is the so keen to encourage the reasons why this Government is the so keen to encourage the development so keen to encourage the development of so keen to encourage the development of a so keen to encourage the development of a water so keen to encourage the development of a water storage so keen to encourage the development of a water storage in so keen to encourage the development of a water storage in those so keen to encourage the development of a water storage in those areas, of a water storage in those areas, so of a water storage in those areas, so that of a water storage in those areas, so that those of a water storage in those areas, so that those businesses of a water storage in those areas, so that those businesses can of a water storage in those areas, so that those businesses can be of a water storage in those areas, so that those businesses can be more so that those businesses can be more sustained, so that those businesses can be more sustained, and so that those businesses can be more sustained, and can so that those businesses can be more sustained, and can retain so that those businesses can be more sustained, and can retain and so that those businesses can be more sustained, and can retain and grow sustained, and can retain and grow more sustained, and can retain and grow more jobs. sustained, and can retain and grow more jobs. Those sustained, and can retain and grow more jobs. Those dams sustained, and can retain and grow more jobs. Those dams also sustained, and can retain and grow more jobs. Those dams also provide more jobs. Those dams also provide better more jobs. Those dams also provide better environmental more jobs. Those dams also provide better environmental outcomes more jobs. Those dams also provide better environmental outcomes by better environmental outcomes by improving better environmental outcomes by so better environmental outcomes by improving water flows. better environmental outcomes by improving water flows. So better environmental outcomes by improving water flows. So given better environmental outcomes by improving water flows. So given the improving water flows. So given the member's improving water flows. So given the so improving water flows. So given the member's concern look improving water flows. So given the member's concern look forward improving water flows. So given the member's concern look forward to improving water flows. So given the member's concern look forward to his member's concern look forward to his support member's concern look forward to his support for member's concern look forward to his support for that member's concern look forward to his support for that policy. support for that policy. Supplementary. support for that policy. Supplementary. What support for that policy. Supplementary. What reports support for that policy. Supplementary. What reports has support for that policy. Supplementary. What reports has he Supplementary. What reports has he seen Supplementary. What reports has he seen about Supplementary. What reports has he seen about jobs Supplementary. What reports has he seen about jobs lost Supplementary. What reports has he seen about jobs lost and Supplementary. What reports has he seen about jobs lost and small seen about jobs lost and small businesses seen about jobs lost and small businesses ruined seen about jobs lost and small businesses ruined from seen about jobs lost and small businesses ruined from severe businesses ruined from severe flooding businesses ruined from severe flooding in businesses ruined from severe flooding in # businesses ruined from severe flooding in # Northland businesses ruined from severe flooding in # Northland or businesses ruined from severe flooding in # Northland or edgecomb. flooding in # Northland or edgecomb. The flooding in # Northland or edgecomb. The member flooding in # Northland or edgecomb. The member raises flooding in # Northland or edgecomb. The member raises some flooding in # Northland or edgecomb. The member raises some challenging The member raises some challenging times The member raises some challenging times in The member raises some challenging times in terms The member raises some challenging times in terms of The member raises some challenging times in terms of those The member raises some challenging times in terms of those floods The member raises some challenging times in terms of those floods for times in terms of those floods for affected times in terms of those floods for affected businesses times in terms of those floods for affected businesses and times in terms of those floods for affected businesses and the affected businesses and the Government affected businesses and the Government has affected businesses and the Government has been affected businesses and the Government has been very affected businesses and the Government has been very supportive Government has been very supportive - Government has been very supportive - not Government has been very supportive - not just Government has been very supportive - not just in Government has been very supportive - not just in terms Government has been very supportive - not just in terms of Government has been very supportive - not just in terms of floods Government has been very supportive - not just in terms of floods but Government has been very supportive - not just in terms of floods but in - not just in terms of floods but in terms - not just in terms of floods but in terms of - not just in terms of floods but in terms of earthquakes - not just in terms of floods but in terms of earthquakes as - not just in terms of floods but in terms of earthquakes as well, - not just in terms of floods but in terms of earthquakes as well, and - not just in terms of floods but in terms of earthquakes as well, and we terms of earthquakes as well, and we are terms of earthquakes as well, and we are very terms of earthquakes as well, and we are very supportive terms of earthquakes as well, and we are very supportive of terms of earthquakes as well, and we are very supportive of tiding are very supportive of tiding businesses are very supportive of tiding businesses over are very supportive of tiding businesses over where are very supportive of tiding businesses over where we are very supportive of tiding businesses over where we can are very supportive of tiding businesses over where we can until businesses over where we can until their businesses over where we can until their solutions businesses over where we can until their solutions are businesses over where we can until their solutions are solve businesses over where we can until their solutions are solve and businesses over where we can until their solutions are solve and their their solutions are solve and their insurance their solutions are solve and their insurance pays their solutions are solve and their insurance pays out. their solutions are solve and their insurance pays out. This their solutions are solve and their insurance pays out. This country their solutions are solve and their insurance pays out. This country is insurance pays out. This country is challenged insurance pays out. This country is challenged by insurance pays out. This country is challenged by some insurance pays out. This country is challenged by some of insurance pays out. This country is challenged by some of the insurance pays out. This country is challenged by some of the weather challenged by some of the weather events challenged by some of the weather are challenged by some of the weather events and has challenged by some of the weather events and has been challenged by some of the weather events and has been for challenged by some of the weather events and has been for pretty challenged by some of the weather events and has been for pretty much events and has been for pretty much all events and has been for pretty much all the events and has been for pretty much all the time events and has been for pretty much all the time that events and has been for pretty much all the time that people events and has been for pretty much all the time that people have events and has been for pretty much all the time that people have lived all the time that people have lived here. all the time that people have lived here. It all the time that people have lived here. It is all the time that people have lived here. It is important all the time that people have lived here. It is important that all the time that people have lived here. It is important that we all the time that people have lived here. It is important that we set all the time that people have lived here. It is important that we set up here. It is important that we set up a here. It is important that we set up a system here. It is important that we set up a system which here. It is important that we set up a system which helped here. It is important that we set up a system which helped them here. It is important that we set up a system which helped them respond, a system which helped them respond, but a system which helped them respond, but New a system which helped them respond, but New Zealanders a system which helped them respond, but New Zealanders are a system which helped them respond, but New Zealanders are very but New Zealanders are very resilient but New Zealanders are very resilient and but New Zealanders are very resilient and actually but New Zealanders are very resilient and actually we but New Zealanders are very resilient and actually we see but New Zealanders are very resilient and actually we see more resilient and actually we see more than resilient and actually we see more than 100,000 resilient and actually we see more than 100,000 jobs resilient and actually we see more than 100,000 jobs added resilient and actually we see more than 100,000 jobs added just resilient and actually we see more than 100,000 jobs added just last than 100,000 jobs added just last year, than 100,000 jobs added just last year, and than 100,000 jobs added just last year, and that than 100,000 jobs added just last year, and that indicated than 100,000 jobs added just last year, and that indicated the year, and that indicated the resilience year, and that indicated the year, year, and that indicated the resilience of the year, and that indicated the resilience of the New year, and that indicated the resilience of the New Zealand resilience of the New Zealand economy. resilience of the New Zealand economy. 137,000 resilience of the New Zealand economy. 137,000 jobs, resilience of the New Zealand economy. 137,000 jobs, in resilience of the New Zealand economy. 137,000 jobs, in fact. economy. 137,000 jobs, in fact. Supplementary. economy. 137,000 jobs, in fact. Supplementary. Does economy. 137,000 jobs, in fact. Supplementary. Does he economy. 137,000 jobs, in fact. Supplementary. Does he agree economy. 137,000 jobs, in fact. Supplementary. Does he agree with Supplementary. Does he agree with the Supplementary. Does he agree with the Insurance Supplementary. Does he agree with the Insurance Council's Supplementary. Does he agree with the Insurance Council's position the Insurance Council's position that the Insurance Council's position that if the Insurance Council's position that if nothing the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is done the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is done to the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is done to adapt the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is done to adapt to that if nothing is done to adapt to climate that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change then that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change then there that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change then there are that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change then there are "going climate change then there are "going to climate change then there are "going to be climate change then there are "going to be increased climate change then there are "going to be increased claims climate change then there are "going to be increased claims and climate change then there are "going to be increased claims and higher to be increased claims and higher losses to be increased claims and higher losses which to be increased claims and higher losses which could to be increased claims and higher losses which could lead to be increased claims and higher losses which could lead to to be increased claims and higher losses which could lead to higher losses which could lead to higher premiums losses which could lead to higher premiums and losses which could lead to higher premiums and cover losses which could lead to higher premiums and cover being losses which could lead to higher premiums and cover being withdrawn"? premiums and cover being withdrawn"? Actually premiums and cover being withdrawn"? Actually the premiums and cover being withdrawn"? Actually the insurance premiums and cover being withdrawn"? Actually the insurance industry premiums and cover being withdrawn"? Actually the insurance industry and Actually the insurance industry and New Actually the insurance industry and New Zealanders Actually the insurance industry and New Zealanders respond Actually the insurance industry and New Zealanders respond to Actually the insurance industry and New Zealanders respond to changes Actually the insurance industry and New Zealanders respond to changes in New Zealanders respond to changes in the New Zealanders respond to changes in Actually New Zealanders respond to changes in the insurance environment New Zealanders respond to changes in the insurance environment all New Zealanders respond to changes in the insurance environment all the the insurance environment all the time. the insurance environment all the time. The the insurance environment all the time. The biggest the insurance environment all the time. The biggest impact the insurance environment all the time. The biggest impact on the insurance environment all the time. The biggest impact on risk the insurance environment all the time. The biggest impact on risk for time. The biggest impact on risk for New time. The biggest impact on risk for New Zealanders time. The biggest impact on risk for New Zealanders is, time. The biggest impact on risk for New Zealanders is, in time. The biggest impact on risk for New Zealanders is, in fact, New Zealanders is, in fact, earthquakes New Zealanders is, in fact, earthquakes and New Zealanders is, in fact, earthquakes and the New Zealanders is, in fact, earthquakes and the challenges New Zealanders is, in fact, earthquakes and the challenges that earthquakes and the challenges that they earthquakes and the challenges that they bring earthquakes and the challenges that they bring and earthquakes and the challenges that they bring and we earthquakes and the challenges that they bring and we have earthquakes and the challenges that they bring and we have seen earthquakes and the challenges that they bring and we have seen that earthquakes and the challenges that they bring and we have seen that in they bring and we have seen that in sharp they bring and we have seen that in sharp relief they bring and we have seen that in sharp relief in they bring and we have seen that in sharp relief in recent they bring and we have seen that in sharp relief in recent years. sharp relief in recent years. Flooding sharp relief in recent years. Flooding is sharp relief in recent years. Flooding is another sharp relief in recent years. Flooding is another risk. sharp relief in recent years. Flooding is another risk. There sharp relief in recent years. Flooding is another risk. There are Flooding is another risk. There are other Flooding is another risk. There are other risks, Flooding is another risk. There are other risks, of Flooding is another risk. There are other risks, of course, Flooding is another risk. There are other risks, of course, in Flooding is another risk. There are other risks, of course, in terms Flooding is another risk. There are other risks, of course, in terms of other risks, of course, in terms of fires other risks, of course, in terms of fires and other risks, of course, in terms of fires and so other risks, of course, in terms of fires and so on. other risks, of course, in terms of fires and so on. And other risks, of course, in terms of fires and so on. And the other risks, of course, in terms of fires and so on. And the way other risks, of course, in terms of fires and so on. And the way we fires and so on. And the way we actually fires and so on. And the way we actually ensure fires and so on. And the way we actually ensure that fires and so on. And the way we actually ensure that New fires and so on. And the way we actually ensure that New Zealanders actually ensure that New Zealanders are actually ensure that New Zealanders are resilient actually ensure that New Zealanders are resilient and actually ensure that New Zealanders are resilient and able actually ensure that New Zealanders are resilient and able to actually ensure that New Zealanders are resilient and able to respond actually ensure that New Zealanders are resilient and able to respond to are resilient and able to respond to that are resilient and able to respond to that is are resilient and able to respond to that is keeping are resilient and able to respond to that is keeping their are resilient and able to respond to that is keeping their incomes are resilient and able to respond to that is keeping their incomes high that is keeping their incomes high and that is keeping their incomes high and growing, that is keeping their incomes high and growing, encouraging that is keeping their incomes high and growing, encouraging the and growing, encouraging the development and growing, encouraging the development of and growing, encouraging the development of our and growing, encouraging the development of our economy, development of our economy, investment development of our economy, investment in development of our economy, investment in our development of our economy, investment in our productive investment in our productive industries, investment in our productive industries, and investment in our productive industries, and ensure investment in our productive industries, and ensure thank investment in our productive industries, and ensure thank the industries, and ensure thank the Government industries, and ensure thank the Government accounts industries, and ensure thank the Government accounts are industries, and ensure thank the Government accounts are strong Government accounts are strong enough Government accounts are strong enough to Government accounts are strong enough to be Government accounts are strong enough to be able Government accounts are strong enough to be able to Government accounts are strong enough to be able to support Government accounts are strong enough to be able to support people enough to be able to support people in enough to be able to support people in their enough to be able to support people in their hour enough to be able to support people in their hour of enough to be able to support people in their hour of need, enough to be able to support people in their hour of need, and enough to be able to support people in their hour of need, and that's in their hour of need, and that's very in their hour of need, and that's very much in their hour of need, and that's very much the in their hour of need, and that's very much the focus in their hour of need, and that's very much the focus of in their hour of need, and that's very much the focus of the very much the focus of the Government. very much the focus of the Government. Point very much the focus of the Government. Point of very much the focus of the Government. Point of order. very much the focus of the Government. Point of order. There Government. Point of order. There are Government. Point of order. There are two Government. Point of order. There are two parts Government. Point of order. There are two parts in Government. Point of order. There are two parts in my Government. Point of order. There are two parts in my question Government. Point of order. There are two parts in my question which are two parts in my question which was are two parts in my question which was whether are two parts in my question which was whether he are two parts in my question which was whether he agreed are two parts in my question which was whether he agreed with are two parts in my question which was whether he agreed with the was whether he agreed with the Insurance was whether he agreed with the Insurance Council's was whether he agreed with the Insurance Council's position... was whether he agreed with the Insurance Council's position... I Insurance Council's position... I heard Insurance Council's position... I are Insurance Council's position... I heard the question Insurance Council's position... I heard the question clearly. Insurance Council's position... I heard the question clearly. I Insurance Council's position... I heard the question clearly. I don't heard the question clearly. I don't think heard the question clearly. I don't think it heard the question clearly. I don't think it has heard the question clearly. I don't think it has been heard the question clearly. I don't think it has been addressed. heard the question clearly. I don't think it has been addressed. I heard the question clearly. I don't think it has been addressed. I will think it has been addressed. I will invite think it has been addressed. I will invite the think it has been addressed. I will invite the member think it has been addressed. I will invite the member to think it has been addressed. I will invite the member to ask think it has been addressed. I will invite the member to ask the invite the member to ask the question invite the member to ask the question again. invite the member to ask the question again. Thank invite the member to ask the question again. Thank you. invite the member to ask the question again. Thank you. Does invite the member to ask the question again. Thank you. Does he question again. Thank you. Does he agree question again. Thank you. Does he agree with question again. Thank you. Does he agree with the question again. Thank you. Does he agree with the Insurance question again. Thank you. Does he agree with the Insurance Council's agree with the Insurance Council's position agree with the Insurance Council's position that agree with the Insurance Council's position that if agree with the Insurance Council's position that if nothing agree with the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is agree with the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is done agree with the Insurance Council's position that if nothing is done to position that if nothing is done to adapt position that if nothing is done to adapt to position that if nothing is done to adapt to climate position that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change, position that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change, then position that if nothing is done to adapt to climate change, then there adapt to climate change, then there are adapt to climate change, then there are going adapt to climate change, then there are going to adapt to climate change, then there are going to be adapt to climate change, then there are going to be increased adapt to climate change, then there are going to be increased claims adapt to climate change, then there are going to be increased claims and are going to be increased claims and higher are going to be increased claims and higher losses are going to be increased claims and higher losses which are going to be increased claims and higher losses which could are going to be increased claims and higher losses which could lead are going to be increased claims and higher losses which could lead to higher losses which could lead to higher higher losses which could lead to higher premiums, higher losses which could lead to higher premiums, and higher losses which could lead to higher premiums, and cover higher losses which could lead to higher premiums, and cover being higher premiums, and cover being withdrawn? higher premiums, and cover being withdrawn? Well, higher premiums, and cover being withdrawn? Well, the higher premiums, and cover being withdrawn? Well, the Insurance withdrawn? Well, the Insurance Council withdrawn? Well, the Insurance Council always withdrawn? Well, the Insurance Council always has withdrawn? Well, the Insurance Council always has their withdrawn? Well, the Insurance Council always has their views withdrawn? Well, the Insurance Council always has their views in Council always has their views in terms Council always has their views in terms of Council always has their views in terms of things Council always has their views in terms of things could Council always has their views in terms of things could be Council always has their views in terms of things could be impacted, terms of things could be impacted, not terms of things could be impacted, not just terms of things could be impacted, not just by terms of things could be impacted, not just by climate terms of things could be impacted, not just by climate change terms of things could be impacted, not just by climate change by not just by climate change by earthquakes. not just by climate change by higher not just by climate change by earthquakes. I was not just by climate change by earthquakes. I was pointing not just by climate change by earthquakes. I was pointing out not just by climate change by earthquakes. I was pointing out to earthquakes. I was pointing out to the earthquakes. I was pointing out to higher earthquakes. I was pointing out to the member there earthquakes. I was pointing out to the member there is earthquakes. I was pointing out to the member there is a earthquakes. I was pointing out to the member there is a range earthquakes. I was pointing out to the member there is a range of earthquakes. I was pointing out to the member there is a range of risks the member there is a range of risks to the member there is a range of risks to New the member there is a range of risks to New Zealand. the member there is a range of risks to New Zealand. Those the member there is a range of risks to New Zealand. Those risks the member there is a range of risks to New Zealand. Those risks and the member there is a range of risks to New Zealand. Those risks and the to New Zealand. Those risks and the insurance to New Zealand. Those risks and the insurance industry's to New Zealand. Those risks and the insurance industry's perception to New Zealand. Those risks and the insurance industry's perception of insurance industry's perception of those insurance industry's perception of those risks insurance industry's perception of those risks change insurance industry's perception of those risks change from those risks change from time-to-time. those risks change from time-to-time. I those risks change from time-to-time. I appreciate those risks change from time-to-time. I appreciate their time-to-time. I appreciate their view. time-to-time. I appreciate their view. And, time-to-time. I appreciate their view. And, certainly, time-to-time. I appreciate their view. And, certainly, I time-to-time. I appreciate their view. And, certainly, I think time-to-time. I appreciate their view. And, certainly, I think New view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander know view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander know they view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander know they do view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander know they do have view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander know they do have to view. And, certainly, I think New Zealander know they do have to be Zealander know they do have to be prepared, Zealander know they do have to be prepared, and Zealander know they do have to be prepared, and this Zealander know they do have to be prepared, and this Government Zealander know they do have to be prepared, and this Government is prepared, and this Government is focused prepared, and this Government is focused on prepared, and this Government is focused on being prepared, and this Government is focused on being prepared prepared, and this Government is focused on being prepared for prepared, and this Government is focused on being prepared for any focused on being prepared for any events, focused on being prepared for any events, not focused on being prepared for any events, not just focused on being prepared for any events, not just climate focused on being prepared for any events, not just climate events. events, not just climate events. When events, not just climate events. When New events, not just climate events. When New Zealand events, not just climate events. When New Zealand jobs events, not just climate events. When New Zealand jobs are events, not just climate events. When New Zealand jobs are on events, not just climate events. When New Zealand jobs are on the When New Zealand jobs are on the line, When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does he When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does he agree When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does he agree with When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does he agree with the When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does he agree with the PM When New Zealand jobs are on the line, does he agree with the PM that line, does he agree with the PM that when line, does he agree with the PM that when it line, does he agree with the PM that when it comes line, does he agree with the PM that when it comes to line, does he agree with the PM that when it comes to the line, does he agree with the PM that when it comes to the question line, does he agree with the PM that when it comes to the question of when it comes to the question of whether when it comes to the question of whether climate when it comes to the question of whether climate change when it comes to the question of whether climate change is when it comes to the question of whether climate change is causing whether climate change is causing more whether climate change is causing more floods whether climate change is causing more floods and whether climate change is causing more floods and more whether climate change is causing more floods and more droughts whether climate change is causing more floods and more droughts that, more floods and more droughts that, "We more floods and more droughts that, "We don't more floods and more droughts that, "We don't spend more floods and more droughts that, "We don't spend time more floods and more droughts that, "We don't spend time trying more floods and more droughts that, "We don't spend time trying to "We don't spend time trying to connect "We don't spend time trying to connect the "We don't spend time trying to connect the two."? "We don't spend time trying to connect the two."? The "We don't spend time trying to connect the two."? The Government connect the two."? The Government focuses connect the two."? The Government focuses on connect the two."? The Government focuses on the connect the two."? The Government focuses on the range connect the two."? The Government focuses on the range of connect the two."? The Government focuses on the range of risks connect the two."? The Government focuses on the range of risks that focuses on the range of risks that present focuses on the range of risks that present for focuses on the range of risks that present for New focuses on the range of risks that present for New Zealanders focuses on the range of risks that present for New Zealanders and focuses on the range of risks that present for New Zealanders and those present for New Zealanders and those risks present for New Zealanders and those risks that present for New Zealanders and those risks that you present for New Zealanders and those risks that you identify present for New Zealanders and those risks that you identify is present for New Zealanders and those risks that you identify is one risks that you identify is one group. risks that you identify is one group. As risks that you identify is one group. As I risks that you identify is one group. As I pointed risks that you identify is one group. As I pointed out risks that you identify is one group. As I pointed out a risks that you identify is one group. As I pointed out a number risks that you identify is one group. As I pointed out a number of group. As I pointed out a number of times group. As I pointed out a number of times already, group. As I pointed out a number of times already, some group. As I pointed out a number of times already, some of group. As I pointed out a number of times already, some of the group. As I pointed out a number of times already, some of the bigger times already, some of the bigger risks times already, some of the bigger focuses times already, some of the bigger risks are those times already, some of the bigger risks are those that times already, some of the bigger risks are those that don't times already, some of the bigger risks are those that don't involve risks are those that don't involve climate risks are those that don't involve climate change, risks are those that don't involve climate change, including climate change, including earthquakes. climate change, including earthquakes. So, climate change, including earthquakes. So, you climate change, including earthquakes. So, you have climate change, including earthquakes. So, you have to climate change, including earthquakes. So, you have to respond earthquakes. So, you have to respond to earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all of earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all of the earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all of the range earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all of the range of earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all of the range of risks earthquakes. So, you have to respond to all of the range of risks that to all of the range of risks that presents to all of the range of risks that presents for to all of the range of risks that presents for people. to all of the range of risks that presents for people. It to all of the range of risks that presents for people. It is to all of the range of risks that presents for people. It is something presents for people. It is something the presents for people. It is something the Government presents for people. It is something the Government focuses presents for people. It is something the Government focuses on presents for people. It is something the Government focuses on a presents for people. It is something the Government focuses on a lot, presents for people. It is something the Government focuses on a lot, and the Government focuses on a lot, and certainly the Government focuses on a lot, and certainly in the Government focuses on a lot, and certainly in terms the Government focuses on a lot, and certainly in terms of the Government focuses on a lot, and certainly in terms of making the Government focuses on a lot, and certainly in terms of making sure certainly in terms of making sure our certainly in terms of making sure our books certainly in terms of making sure our books are certainly in terms of making sure our books are resilient, certainly in terms of making sure our books are resilient, so certainly in terms of making sure our books are resilient, so that certainly in terms of making sure our books are resilient, so that if our books are resilient, so that if we our books are resilient, so that if we have our books are resilient, so that if we have big our books are resilient, so that if we have big incidents our books are resilient, so that if we have big incidents and our books are resilient, so that if we have big incidents and shocks, we have big incidents and shocks, the we have big incidents and shocks, the way we have big incidents and shocks, the way that we have big incidents and shocks, the way that we we have big incidents and shocks, the way that we have we have big incidents and shocks, the way that we have seen we have big incidents and shocks, the way that we have seen in we have big incidents and shocks, the way that we have seen in recent the way that we have seen in recent years, the way that we have seen in recent years, that the way that we have seen in recent years, that we the way that we have seen in recent years, that we can the way that we have seen in recent years, that we can respond the way that we have seen in recent years, that we can respond and years, that we can respond and support years, that we can respond and support New years, that we can respond and support New Zealanders. years, that we can respond and support New Zealanders. Point years, that we can respond and support New Zealanders. Point of support New Zealanders. Point of order. support New Zealanders. Point of order. My support New Zealanders. Point of order. My question support New Zealanders. Point of order. My question was support New Zealanders. Point of order. My question was whether support New Zealanders. Point of order. My question was whether he order. My question was whether he agreed order. My question was whether he support order. My question was whether he agreed with the order. My question was whether he agreed with the PM's order. My question was whether he agreed with the PM's quote. order. My question was whether he agreed with the PM's quote. He agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't even agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't even mention agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't even mention the agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't even mention the PM... agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't even mention the PM... It agreed with the PM's quote. He didn't even mention the PM... It is didn't even mention the PM... It is a didn't even mention the PM... It is a very didn't even mention the PM... It is a very marginal didn't even mention the PM... It is a very marginal call. didn't even mention the PM... It is a very marginal call. He didn't even mention the PM... It is a very marginal call. He talked a very marginal call. He talked about a very marginal call. He talked about then a very marginal call. He talked about then a a very marginal call. He talked about then a range a very marginal call. He talked about then a range of a very marginal call. He talked about then a range of risks a very marginal call. He talked about then a range of risks and a very marginal call. He talked about then a range of risks and the about then a range of risks and the Minister about then a range of risks and the Minister responded about then a range of risks and the Minister responded to about then a range of risks and the Minister responded to that. about then a range of risks and the Minister responded to that. The Minister responded to that. The Minister Minister responded to that. The Minister said Minister responded to that. The Minister said it Minister responded to that. The Minister said it was Minister responded to that. The Minister said it was a Minister responded to that. The Minister said it was a focus Minister responded to that. The Minister said it was a focus of Minister responded to that. The Minister said it was a focus of his Minister said it was a focus of his Government. Minister said it was a focus of his Government. But Minister said it was a focus of his Government. But on Minister said it was a focus of his Government. But on balance, Minister said it was a focus of his Government. But on balance, I Minister said it was a focus of his Government. But on balance, I will Government. But on balance, I will let Government. But on balance, I will let the Government. But on balance, I will let the member Government. But on balance, I will let the member ask Government. But on balance, I will let the member ask that Government. But on balance, I will let the member ask that question let the member ask that question again. let the member ask that question again. Thank let the member ask that question again. Thank you. let the member ask that question again. Thank you. Does let the member ask that question again. Thank you. Does he let the member ask that question again. Thank you. Does he agree let the member ask that question again. Thank you. Does he agree with again. Thank you. Does he agree with the again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM that again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM that when again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM that when it again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM that when it comes again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM that when it comes to again. Thank you. Does he agree with the PM that when it comes to the the PM that when it comes to the question the PM that when it comes to the question of the PM that when it comes to the question of whether the PM that when it comes to the question of whether climate the PM that when it comes to the question of whether climate change question of whether climate change is question of whether climate change is causing question of whether climate change is causing more question of whether climate change is causing more floods question of whether climate change is causing more floods and question of whether climate change is causing more floods and more is causing more floods and more droughts is causing more floods and more droughts that, is causing more floods and more droughts that, "We is causing more floods and more droughts that, "We don't is causing more floods and more droughts that, "We don't spend is causing more floods and more droughts that, "We don't spend time droughts that, "We don't spend time trying droughts that, "We don't spend time question droughts that, "We don't spend time trying to connect droughts that, "We don't spend time trying to connect the droughts that, "We don't spend time trying to connect the two."? droughts that, "We don't spend time trying to connect the two."? Well, droughts that, "We don't spend time trying to connect the two."? Well, I trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree with trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree with the trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree with the sentiment trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree with the sentiment of trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree with the sentiment of the trying to connect the two."? Well, I agree with the sentiment of the PM, agree with the sentiment of the PM, which agree with the sentiment of the PM, which is agree with the sentiment of the PM, which is actually agree with the sentiment of the PM, which is actually we agree with the sentiment of the PM, which is actually we focus agree with the sentiment of the PM, which is actually we focus on agree with the sentiment of the PM, which is actually we focus on the which is actually we focus on the risks which is actually we focus on the risks and which is actually we focus on the risks and managing which is actually we focus on the risks and managing those which is actually we focus on the risks and managing those risks. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he have My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he have confidence My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he have confidence in Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister of Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister of Police; Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister of Police; if Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister of Police; if so, Minister: Does he have confidence in his Minister of Police; if so, why? Yes, Yes, because Yes, because she's Yes, because she's a Yes, because she's a competent Yes, because she's a competent Minister Yes, because she's a competent Minister and Yes, because she's a competent Minister and is Yes, because she's a competent Minister and is working Yes, because she's a competent Minister and is working with Yes, because she's a competent Minister and is working with the Minister and is working with the police Minister and is working with the police to Minister and is working with the police to implement Minister and is working with the police to implement a Minister and is working with the police to implement a half Minister and is working with the police to implement a half billion police to implement a half billion dollar police to implement a half billion dollar investment police to implement a half billion dollar investment in police to implement a half billion dollar investment in the police to implement a half billion dollar investment in the police police to implement a half billion dollar investment in the police of dollar investment in the police of 1100 dollar investment in the police of 1100 new dollar investment in the police of 1100 new staff, dollar investment in the police of 1100 new staff, including dollar investment in the police of 1100 new staff, including 880 1100 new staff, including 880 uniform 1100 new staff, including 880 uniform staff, 1100 new staff, including 880 uniform staff, right 1100 new staff, including 880 uniform staff, right around 1100 new staff, including 880 uniform staff, right around the uniform staff, right around the country. uniform staff, right around the country. Thank uniform staff, right around the country. Thank you. uniform staff, right around the country. Thank you. To uniform staff, right around the country. Thank you. To the uniform staff, right around the country. Thank you. To the PM: uniform staff, right around the country. Thank you. To the PM: Is uniform staff, right around the country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that New country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that New Zealand country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that New Zealand First country. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that New Zealand First lodged aware that New Zealand First lodged an aware that New Zealand First lodged an Official aware that New Zealand First lodged an Official Information aware that New Zealand First lodged an Official Information Act aware that New Zealand First lodged an Official Information Act request an Official Information Act request with an Official Information Act request with both an Official Information Act request with both his an Official Information Act request with both his office an Official Information Act request with both his office and an Official Information Act request with both his office and with an Official Information Act request with both his office and with the with both his office and with the Minister with both his office and with the Minister of with both his office and with the Minister of Police with both his office and with the Minister of Police on with both his office and with the Minister of Police on 3 with both his office and with the Minister of Police on 3 February Minister of Police on 3 February requesting Minister of Police on 3 February requesting all Minister of Police on 3 February requesting all documents Minister of Police on 3 February requesting all documents relating Minister of Police on 3 February requesting all documents relating to requesting all documents relating to his requesting all documents relating to his announcement requesting all documents relating to his announcement to requesting all documents relating to his announcement to increase requesting all documents relating to his announcement to increase police his announcement to increase police numbers his announcement to increase police numbers to his announcement to increase police numbers to 880 his announcement to increase police numbers to 880 and his announcement to increase police numbers to 880 and that his announcement to increase police numbers to 880 and that his his announcement to increase police numbers to 880 and that his office numbers to 880 and that his office partially numbers to 880 and that his office partially transferred numbers to 880 and that his office partially transferred that numbers to 880 and that his office partially transferred that request partially transferred that request to partially transferred that request to the partially transferred that request to the Minister partially transferred that request to the Minister of partially transferred that request to the Minister of Police partially transferred that request to the Minister of Police on partially transferred that request to the Minister of Police on 16 to the Minister of Police on 16 February? to the Minister of Police on 16 February? Are to the Minister of Police on 16 February? Are you to the Minister of Police on 16 February? Are you aware to the Minister of Police on 16 February? Are you aware of to the Minister of Police on 16 February? Are you aware of that? to the Minister of Police on 16 February? Are you aware of that? I'm February? Are you aware of that? I'm not February? Are you aware of that? I'm not aware February? Are you aware of that? I'm not aware of February? Are you aware of that? I'm not aware of all February? Are you aware of that? I'm not aware of all the February? Are you aware of that? I'm not aware of all the administrative not aware of all the administrative details. not aware of all the administrative details. But not aware of all the administrative details. But I not aware of all the administrative details. But I understand not aware of all the administrative details. But I understand some details. But I understand some documents details. But I understand some documents related details. But I understand some documents related were details. But I understand some documents related were appropriately documents related were appropriately related documents related were appropriately related to documents related were appropriately related to the documents related were appropriately related to the decision documents related were appropriately related to the decision were related to the decision were released related to the decision were released yesterday. related to the decision were released yesterday. To related to the decision were released yesterday. To the related to the decision were released yesterday. To the PM: related to the decision were released yesterday. To the PM: Is related to the decision were released yesterday. To the PM: Is he released yesterday. To the PM: Is he aware released yesterday. To the PM: Is he aware that, released yesterday. To the PM: Is he aware that, one, released yesterday. To the PM: Is he aware that, one, a released yesterday. To the PM: Is he aware that, one, a month released yesterday. To the PM: Is he aware that, one, a month after aware that, one, a month after receiving aware that, one, a month after receiving our aware that, one, a month after receiving our original aware that, one, a month after receiving our original OIA aware that, one, a month after receiving our original OIA she aware that, one, a month after receiving our original OIA she then receiving our original OIA she then wrote receiving our original OIA she then wrote to receiving our original OIA she then wrote to New receiving our original OIA she then wrote to New Zealand receiving our original OIA she then wrote to New Zealand First receiving our original OIA she then wrote to New Zealand First saying wrote to New Zealand First saying that wrote to New Zealand First saying that she wrote to New Zealand First saying that she was wrote to New Zealand First saying that she was extending wrote to New Zealand First saying that she was extending her wrote to New Zealand First saying that she was extending her response that she was extending her response to that she was extending her response to 7 that she was extending her response to 7 April, that she was extending her response to 7 April, and, that she was extending her response to 7 April, and, two, that she was extending her response to 7 April, and, two, that that she was extending her response to 7 April, and, two, that on that she was extending her response to 7 April, and, two, that on 5 to 7 April, and, two, that on 5 April, to 7 April, and, two, that on 5 April, two to 7 April, and, two, that on 5 April, two months to 7 April, and, two, that on 5 April, two months after to 7 April, and, two, that on 5 April, two months after receiving April, two months after receiving the April, two months after receiving the initial April, two months after receiving the initial OIA, April, two months after receiving the initial OIA, she's April, two months after receiving the initial OIA, she's then April, two months after receiving the initial OIA, she's then said April, two months after receiving the initial OIA, she's then said she the initial OIA, she's then said she could the initial OIA, she's then said she could not the initial OIA, she's then said she could not reply the initial OIA, she's then said she could not reply until the initial OIA, she's then said she could not reply until 10 the initial OIA, she's then said she could not reply until 10 May? the initial OIA, she's then said she could not reply until 10 May? Is could not reply until 10 May? Is that could not reply until 10 May? Is that a could not reply until 10 May? Is that a cable could not reply until 10 May? Is that a cable Minister? that a cable Minister? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Two <INTERRUPTION> Two supplementary <INTERRUPTION> Two supplementary questions <INTERRUPTION> Two supplementary questions there. Two supplementary questions there. I'm Two supplementary questions there. I'm sure Two supplementary questions there. I'm sure it's Two supplementary questions there. I'm sure it's the Two supplementary questions there. I'm sure it's the hablt Two supplementary questions there. I'm sure it's the hablt of Two supplementary questions there. I'm sure it's the hablt of New I'm sure it's the hablt of New Zealand I'm sure it's the hablt of New I'm I'm sure it's the hablt of New Zealand First that I'm sure it's the hablt of New Zealand First that the I'm sure it's the hablt of New Zealand First that the -- I'm sure it's the hablt of New Zealand First that the -- habit I'm sure it's the hablt of New Zealand First that the -- habit of Zealand First that the -- habit of New Zealand First that the -- habit of New Zealand Zealand First that the -- habit of New Zealand First Zealand First that the -- habit of New Zealand First that Zealand First that the -- habit of New Zealand First that possible New Zealand First that possible deputy New Zealand First that possible deputy leader New Zealand First that possible deputy leader consults New Zealand First that possible deputy leader consults with New Zealand First that possible deputy leader consults with his New Zealand First that possible deputy leader consults with his - deputy leader consults with his - the deputy leader consults with his - New deputy leader consults with his - the leader - deputy leader consults with his - the leader - on deputy leader consults with his - the leader - on all deputy leader consults with his - the leader - on all matters deputy leader consults with his - the leader - on all matters related the leader - on all matters related to the leader - on all matters related to correspondence. the leader - on all matters related to correspondence. But the leader - on all matters related to correspondence. But in the leader - on all matters related to correspondence. But in the to correspondence. But in the National to correspondence. But in the National Government to correspondence. But in the National Government the to correspondence. But in the National Government the Deputy to correspondence. But in the National Government the Deputy PM National Government the Deputy PM does National Government the Deputy PM does not National Government the Deputy PM does not consult National Government the Deputy PM does not consult me National Government the Deputy PM does not consult me on National Government the Deputy PM does not consult me on all National Government the Deputy PM does not consult me on all matters does not consult me on all matters related does not consult me on all matters related to does not consult me on all matters related to correspondence. related to correspondence. Supplementary. related to correspondence. Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Order! So Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Order! So she Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Order! So she is Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Order! So she is not Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Order! So she is not capable? Order! So she is not capable? Supplementary... Order! So she is not capable? Supplementary... <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary... <INTERRUPTION> To Supplementary... <INTERRUPTION> To the Supplementary... <INTERRUPTION> To the PM: To the PM: (LAUGHS) (LAUGHS) Order! (LAUGHS) Order! Interjections (LAUGHS) Order! Interjections must (LAUGHS) Order! Interjections must cease (LAUGHS) Order! Interjections must cease from Order! Interjections must cease from both. Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank you. Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank you. To Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank you. To the Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank you. To the PM: Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank you. To the PM: Is Order! Interjections must cease from both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 April both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 April at both. Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 April at 6:26pm... aware that on 10 April at 6:26pm... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Well, <INTERRUPTION> Well, we <INTERRUPTION> Well, we know <INTERRUPTION> Well, we know the <INTERRUPTION> Well, we know the Minister <INTERRUPTION> Well, we know the Minister doesn't Well, we know the Minister doesn't know Well, we know the Minister doesn't know what's Well, we know the Minister doesn't know what's going Well, we know the Minister doesn't know what's going on Well, we know the Minister doesn't know what's going on in Well, we know the Minister doesn't know what's going on in her know what's going on in her department, know what's going on in her department, don't know what's going on in her department, don't we? know what's going on in her department, don't we? Order! know what's going on in her department, don't we? Order! Can know what's going on in her department, don't we? Order! Can I department, don't we? Order! Can I just department, don't we? Order! Can I just ask department, don't we? Order! Can I just ask for department, don't we? Order! Can I just ask for some department, don't we? Order! Can I just ask for some cooperation department, don't we? Order! Can I just ask for some cooperation from just ask for some cooperation from the just ask for some cooperation from the my just ask for some cooperation from the my right-hand just ask for some cooperation from the my right-hand side just ask for some cooperation from the my right-hand side so just ask for some cooperation from the my right-hand side so we just ask for some cooperation from the my right-hand side so we can the my right-hand side so we can hear the my right-hand side so we can hear the the my right-hand side so we can hear the question the my right-hand side so we can hear the question without hear the question without interjection? hear the question without interjection? Thank hear the question without interjection? Thank you. hear the question without interjection? Thank you. To hear the question without interjection? Thank you. To the hear the question without interjection? Thank you. To the PM: interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 April interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 April at interjection? Thank you. To the PM: Is he aware that on 10 April at 6. Is he aware that on 10 April at 6. 26pm Is he aware that on 10 April at 6. 26pm the Is he aware that on 10 April at 6. 26pm the Minister's Is he aware that on 10 April at 6. 26pm the Minister's office Is he aware that on 10 April at 6. 26pm the Minister's office informed 26pm the Minister's office informed us 26pm the Minister's office informed us that 26pm the Minister's office informed us that they 26pm the Minister's office informed us that they would 26pm the Minister's office informed us that they would release us that they would release information us that they would release information that us that they would release information that we us that they would release information that we requested us that they would release information that we requested on us that they would release information that we requested on 3 information that we requested on 3 February information that we requested on 3 February to information that we requested on 3 February to the information that we requested on 3 February to the public... February to the public... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> And <INTERRUPTION> And is <INTERRUPTION> And is that <INTERRUPTION> And is that the <INTERRUPTION> And is that the actions <INTERRUPTION> And is that the actions of <INTERRUPTION> And is that the actions of an <INTERRUPTION> And is that the actions of an open, And is that the actions of an open, honest And is that the actions of an open, honest and And is that the actions of an open, honest and transparent And is that the actions of an open, honest and transparent Minister? And is that the actions of an open, honest and transparent Minister? Not honest and transparent Minister? Not only honest and transparent Minister? Not only open honest and transparent Minister? Not only open and honest and transparent Minister? Not only open and honest, honest and transparent Minister? Not only open and honest, but honest and transparent Minister? Not only open and honest, but also only open and honest, but also remarkably only open and honest, but also remarkably precise only open and honest, but also remarkably precise by only open and honest, but also remarkably precise by the only open and honest, but also remarkably precise by the sound only open and honest, but also remarkably precise by the sound of remarkably precise by the sound of it! remarkably precise by the sound of honest it! <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. it! <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't wore Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't wore you Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't wore you sweetheart Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't wore you sweetheart - Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't wore you sweetheart - there Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Don't wore you sweetheart - there is Don't wore you sweetheart - there is more Don't wore you sweetheart - there is more coming! Don't wore you sweetheart - there is more coming! Order! Don't wore you sweetheart - there is more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On this more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On this occasion more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On this occasion I more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On this occasion I do more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On this occasion I do acknowledge more coming! Order! <INTERRUPTION> On this occasion I do acknowledge he On this occasion I do acknowledge he was On this occasion I do acknowledge he was responding On this occasion I do acknowledge he was responding to On this occasion I do acknowledge he was responding to an On this occasion I do acknowledge he was responding to an interjection. On this occasion I do acknowledge he was responding to an interjection. I was responding to an interjection. I will was responding to an interjection. I will allow was responding to an interjection. I will allow the was responding to an interjection. I will allow the member was responding to an interjection. I will allow the member now was responding to an interjection. I will allow the member now to will allow the member now to continue will allow the member now to continue with will allow the member now to continue with his will allow the member now to continue with his supplementary. continue with his supplementary. Point continue with his supplementary. Point of continue with his supplementary. Point of order. continue with his supplementary. Point of order. You continue with his supplementary. Point of order. You will continue with his supplementary. Point of order. You will have Point of order. You will have observed Point of order. You will have observed - Point of order. You will have observed - it's Point of order. You will have observed - it's happening Point of order. You will have observed - it's happening right Point of order. You will have observed - it's happening right now observed - it's happening right now - observed - it's happening right now - that observed - it's happening right now - that when observed - it's happening right now - that when my observed - it's happening right now - that when my colleague observed - it's happening right now - that when my colleague has observed - it's happening right now - that when my colleague has got observed - it's happening right now - that when my colleague has got to - that when my colleague has got to his - that when my colleague has got to his first - that when my colleague has got to his first a - that when my colleague has got to his first a barrage - that when my colleague has got to his first a barrage is - that when my colleague has got to his first a barrage is coming - that when my colleague has got to his first a barrage is coming from his first a barrage is coming from the his first a barrage is coming from the frontbench his first a barrage is coming from the frontbench of his first a barrage is coming from the frontbench of the his first a barrage is coming from the frontbench of the National the frontbench of the National Party, the frontbench of the National Party, which the frontbench of the National Party, which is the frontbench of the National Party, which is inexcusable, the frontbench of the National Party, which is inexcusable, against Party, which is inexcusable, against Standing Party, which is inexcusable, against Standing Orders, Party, which is inexcusable, against Standing Orders, and Party, which is inexcusable, against Standing Orders, and they Party, which is inexcusable, against Standing Orders, and they should Party, which is inexcusable, against Standing Orders, and they should be Standing Orders, and they should be stopped. Standing Orders, and they should be stopped. I Standing Orders, and they should be stopped. I haven't Standing Orders, and they should be stopped. I haven't - Standing Orders, and they should be stopped. I haven't - I Standing Orders, and they should be stopped. I haven't - I haven't stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed it stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed it exactly stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed it exactly the stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed it exactly the same stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed it exactly the same way stopped. I haven't - I haven't observed it exactly the same way as observed it exactly the same way as the observed it exactly the same way as the member observed it exactly the same way as the member described. observed it exactly the same way as the member described. The observed it exactly the same way as the member described. The member the member described. The member rose the member described. The member rose to the member described. The member rose to his the member described. The member rose to his feet the member described. The member rose to his feet and the member described. The member rose to his feet and started the member described. The member rose to his feet and started his rose to his feet and started his supplementary rose to his feet and started his supplementary question rose to his feet and started his supplementary question without rose to his feet and started his supplementary question without any supplementary question without any barrage supplementary question without any barrage of supplementary question without any barrage of interjection supplementary question without any barrage of interjection at supplementary question without any barrage of interjection at all, supplementary question without any barrage of interjection at all, but barrage of interjection at all, but as barrage of interjection at all, but rose barrage of interjection at all, but as the Minister barrage of interjection at all, but as the Minister - barrage of interjection at all, but as the Minister - as barrage of interjection at all, but as the Minister - as the barrage of interjection at all, but as the Minister - as the member barrage of interjection at all, but as the Minister - as the member then as the Minister - as the member then got as the Minister - as the member then got into as the Minister - as the member then got into his as the Minister - as the member then got into his question as the Minister - as the member then got into his question and as the Minister - as the member then got into his question and some as the Minister - as the member then got into his question and some of got into his question and some of the got into his question and some of the facts got into his question and some of the facts that got into his question and some of the facts that he got into his question and some of the facts that he detailed got into his question and some of the facts that he detailed in got into his question and some of the facts that he detailed in his the facts that he detailed in his question, the facts that he detailed in his question, that's the facts that he detailed in his question, that's when the facts that he detailed in his question, that's when I the facts that he detailed in his question, that's when I received question, that's when I received without question, that's when I received without cooperation question, that's when I received without cooperation further without cooperation further interjection without cooperation further interjection from without cooperation further interjection from my without cooperation further interjection from my right. without cooperation further interjection from my right. I without cooperation further interjection from my right. I then interjection from my right. I then told interjection from my right. I then told them interjection from my right. I then told them they interjection from my right. I then told them they had interjection from my right. I then told them they had to interjection from my right. I then told them they had to cease. told them they had to cease. Further... told them they had to cease. Further... Thank told them they had to cease. Further... Thank you told them they had to cease. Further... Thank you very told them they had to cease. Further... Thank you very much. told them they had to cease. Further... Thank you very much. To Further... Thank you very much. To the Further... Thank you very much. To the PM: Further... Thank you very much. To the PM: How Further... Thank you very much. To the PM: How can Further... Thank you very much. To the PM: How can he Further... Thank you very much. To the PM: How can he possibly Further... Thank you very much. To the PM: How can he possibly have the PM: How can he possibly have confidence the PM: How can he possibly have confidence in the PM: How can he possibly have confidence in a the PM: How can he possibly have confidence in a Minister the PM: How can he possibly have confidence in a Minister of the PM: How can he possibly have confidence in a Minister of Police confidence in a Minister of Police who confidence in a Minister of Police who manipulates, confidence in a Minister of Police who manipulates, obfuscates, confidence in a Minister of Police who manipulates, obfuscates, delays, who manipulates, obfuscates, delays, deceives who manipulates, obfuscates, delays, deceives and who manipulates, obfuscates, delays, deceives and misleads who manipulates, obfuscates, delays, deceives and misleads Parliament, who manipulates, obfuscates, delays, deceives and misleads Parliament, or deceives and misleads Parliament, or is deceives and misleads Parliament, or is this deceives and misleads Parliament, or is this the deceives and misleads Parliament, or is this the new deceives and misleads Parliament, or is this the new standard deceives and misleads Parliament, or is this the new standard of is this the new standard of Government is this the new standard of deceives is this the new standard of Government that he is this the new standard of Government that he is is this the new standard of Government that he is trying is this the new standard of Government that he is trying to Government that he is trying to lead? Well, Well, Mr Well, Mr Speaker, Well, Mr Speaker, the Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Police Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Police has Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Police has my Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Police has my full Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Police has my full confidence. Well, Mr Speaker, the Minister of Police has my full confidence. It Police has my full confidence. It Police has my full confidence. It Police has my full confidence. It sound like Police has my full confidence. It sound like she Police has my full confidence. It sound like she did Police has my full confidence. It sound like she did a Police has my full confidence. It sound like she did a remarkably sound like she did a remarkably thorough sound like she did a remarkably thorough job sound like she did a remarkably thorough job of sound like she did a remarkably thorough job of dealing sound like she did a remarkably thorough job of dealing with sound like she did a remarkably thorough job of dealing with what thorough job of dealing with what was thorough job of dealing with what was no thorough job of dealing with what was no doubt thorough job of dealing with what was no doubt a thorough job of dealing with what was no doubt a well-intentioned was no doubt a well-intentioned Official was no doubt a well-intentioned Official Information was no doubt a well-intentioned Official Information Act was no doubt a well-intentioned Official Information Act request was no doubt a well-intentioned Official Information Act request and Official Information Act request and now Official Information Act request and now all Official Information Act request and now all the Official Information Act request and now all the details Official Information Act request and now all the details of Official Information Act request and now all the details of the now all the details of the considerations now all the details of the considerations are now all the details of the considerations are available now all the details of the considerations are available to now all the details of the considerations are available to that considerations are available to that member considerations are available to that member as considerations are available to that member as they considerations are available to that member as they are considerations are available to that member as they are to considerations are available to that member as they are to the considerations are available to that member as they are to the public. member as they are to the public. Point member as they are to the public. Point of member as they are to the public. Point of order. member as they are to the public. Point of order. I member as they are to the public. Point of order. I apologise member as they are to the public. Point of order. I apologise to member as they are to the public. Point of order. I apologise to the Point of order. I apologise to the Point of order. I apologise to the Point of order. I apologise to the member. I Point of order. I apologise to the member. I have Point of order. I apologise to the member. I have a Point of order. I apologise to the member. I have a number Point of order. I apologise to the member. I have a number of Point of order. I apologise to the member. I have a number of tables Point of order. I apologise to the member. I have a number of tables I member. I have a number of tables I seek member. I have a number of tables I seek leave member. I have a number of tables I seek leave to member. I have a number of tables I seek leave to document member. I have a number of tables I seek leave to document - member. I have a number of tables I seek leave to document - a member. I have a number of tables I seek leave to document - a number member. I have a number of tables I seek leave to document - a number of seek leave to document - a number of documents seek leave to document - a number of documents I seek leave to document - a number of documents I seek seek leave to document - a number of documents I seek leave seek leave to document - a number of documents I seek leave to seek leave to document - a number of documents I seek leave to table. seek leave to document - a number of documents I seek leave to table. The documents I seek leave to table. The first documents I seek leave to table. The first one documents I seek leave to table. The first one is documents I seek leave to table. The first one is an documents I seek leave to table. The first one is an OIA documents I seek leave to table. The first one is an OIA request first one is an OIA request announcing first one is an OIA request announcing police first one is an OIA request announcing police resourcing announcing police resourcing announcement announcing police resourcing announcement dated announcing police resourcing announcement dated 3 announcing police resourcing announcement dated 3 February. announcement dated 3 February. Second announcement dated 3 February. Second document? announcement dated 3 February. Second document? The announcement dated 3 February. Second document? The second announcement dated 3 February. Second document? The second one announcement dated 3 February. Second document? The second one is announcement dated 3 February. Second document? The second one is a Second document? The second one is a letter Second document? The second one is a letter dated Second document? The second one is a letter dated 16 Second document? The second one is a letter dated 16 February Second document? The second one is a letter dated 16 February from Second document? The second one is a letter dated 16 February from the Second document? The second one is a letter dated 16 February from the PM letter dated 16 February from the PM of letter dated 16 February from the PM of partial letter dated 16 February from the PM of partial transfer letter dated 16 February from the PM of partial transfer to letter dated 16 February from the PM of partial transfer to the letter dated 16 February from the PM of partial transfer to the Minister of partial transfer to the Minister of of partial transfer to the Minister of Police, of partial transfer to the Minister of Police, an of partial transfer to the Minister of Police, an extension of partial transfer to the Minister of Police, an extension letter of partial transfer to the Minister of Police, an extension letter dated of Police, an extension letter dated 1 of Police, an extension letter dated 1 March of Police, an extension letter dated 1 March from of Police, an extension letter dated 1 March from the of Police, an extension letter dated 1 March from the Minister of Police, an extension letter dated 1 March from the Minister of of Police, an extension letter dated 1 March from the Minister of Police 1 March from the Minister of Police extending 1 March from the Minister of Police extending deadline 1 March from the Minister of Police extending deadline to 1 March from the Minister of Police extending deadline to 7 1 March from the Minister of Police extending deadline to 7 April. 1 March from the Minister of Police extending deadline to 7 April. An extending deadline to 7 April. An extension extending deadline to 7 April. An extension letter extending deadline to 7 April. An extension letter dated extending deadline to 7 April. An extension letter dated 6 extending deadline to 7 April. An extension letter dated 6 March extension letter dated 6 March rarding extension letter dated 6 March rarding an extension letter dated 6 March rarding an transfer extension letter dated 6 March rarding an transfer request extension letter dated 6 March rarding an transfer request from extension letter dated 6 March rarding an transfer request from the rarding an transfer request from the PM rarding an transfer request from the PM extending rarding an transfer request from the PM extending the rarding an transfer request from the PM extending the deadline rarding an transfer request from the PM extending the deadline to rarding an transfer request from the PM extending the deadline to 7 PM extending the deadline to 7 April. PM extending the deadline to 7 April. A PM extending the deadline to 7 April. A letter PM extending the deadline to 7 April. A letter dated PM extending the deadline to 7 April. A letter dated 4 PM extending the deadline to 7 April. A letter dated 4 April PM extending the deadline to 7 April. A letter dated 4 April from April. A letter dated 4 April from the April. A letter dated 4 April from the Minister April. A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of April. A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of Police April. A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of Police declining April. A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of Police declining - the Minister of Police declining - point the Minister of Police declining - point of the Minister of Police declining - point of order. the Minister of Police declining - point of order. The the Minister of Police declining - point of order. The member the Minister of Police declining - point of order. The member is the Minister of Police declining - point of order. The member is op the Minister of Police declining - point of order. The member is op a point of order. The member is op a point point of order. The member is op a point of point of order. The member is op a point of order. point of order. The member is op a point of order. Would point of order. The member is op a point of order. Would he point of order. The member is op a point of order. Would he hurry point of order. The member is op a point of order. Would he hurry up point of order. Would he hurry up and point of order. Would he hurry up and describe point of order. Would he hurry up and describe the point of order. Would he hurry up and describe the documents. point of order. Would he hurry up and describe the documents. The and describe the documents. The point and describe the documents. The point of and describe the documents. The point of order and describe the documents. The point of order is and describe the documents. The point of order is interjection. and describe the documents. The point of order is interjection. The point of order is interjection. The member point of order is interjection. The member is point of order is interjection. The member is on point of order is interjection. The member is on a point of order is interjection. The member is on a point point of order is interjection. The member is on a point of point of order is interjection. The member is on a point of order. point of order is interjection. The member is on a point of order. I member is on a point of order. I know, member is on a point of order. I know, and member is on a point of order. I know, and I member is on a point of order. I know, and I just member is on a point of order. I know, and I just raised member is on a point of order. I know, and I just raised another know, and I just raised another point know, and I just raised another point of know, and I just raised another point of order. know, and I just raised another point of order. We know, and I just raised another point of order. We will know, and I just raised another point of order. We will deal know, and I just raised another point of order. We will deal with point of order. We will deal with the point of order. We will deal with the first point of order. We will deal with the first one point of order. We will deal with the first one first. point of order. We will deal with the first one first. Can point of order. We will deal with the first one first. Can you point of order. We will deal with the first one first. Can you shut the first one first. Can you shut them the first one first. Can you shut them up? the first one first. Can you shut them up? I the first one first. Can you shut them up? I eat the first one first. Can you shut them up? I eat getting the first one first. Can you shut them up? I eat getting to the first one first. Can you shut them up? I eat getting to the the first one first. Can you shut them up? I eat getting to the -- the first one first. Can you shut them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm getting them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm getting to them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm getting to the them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm getting to the stage them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm getting to the stage where them up? I eat getting to the -- I'm getting to the stage where my getting to the stage where my patience getting to the stage where my patience will getting to the stage where my patience will not getting to the stage where my patience will not last getting to the stage where my patience will not last much getting to the stage where my patience will not last much longer. patience will not last much longer. A patience will not last much longer. A letter patience will not last much longer. A letter dated patience will not last much longer. A letter dated 4 patience will not last much longer. A letter dated 4 April patience will not last much longer. A letter dated 4 April from patience will not last much longer. A letter dated 4 April from the A letter dated 4 April from the Minister A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of Police. A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of Police. Just A letter dated 4 April from the Minister of Police. Just describe Minister of Police. Just describe Minister of Police. Just describe Minister of Police. Just describe the documents. Minister of Police. Just describe the documents. Sir? Minister of Police. Just describe the documents. Sir? A Minister of Police. Just describe the documents. Sir? A letter Minister of Police. Just describe the documents. Sir? A letter dated Minister of Police. Just describe the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 April the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 April from the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 April from the the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 April from the Minister the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 April from the Minister of the documents. Sir? A letter dated 5 April from the Minister of Police April from the Minister of Police extending April from the Minister of Police extending the April from the Minister of Police extending the OIA April from the Minister of Police extending the OIA response April from the Minister of Police extending the OIA response to April from the Minister of Police extending the OIA response to 10 extending the OIA response to 10 May. extending the OIA response to 10 May. An extending the OIA response to 10 May. An email extending the OIA response to 10 May. An email from extending the OIA response to 10 May. An email from the extending the OIA response to 10 May. An email from the police extending the OIA response to 10 May. An email from the police stated May. An email from the police stated 10 May. An email from the police stated 10 April May. An email from the police stated 10 April 3:59pm May. An email from the police stated 10 April 3:59pm advising May. An email from the police stated 10 April 3:59pm advising the May. An email from the police stated 10 April 3:59pm advising the release 10 April 3:59pm advising the release May. 10 April 3:59pm advising the release of 10 April 3:59pm advising the release of material that day. 10 April 3:59pm advising the release of material that day. An 10 April 3:59pm advising the release of material that day. An email 10 April 3:59pm advising the release of material that day. An email from of material that day. An email from the of material that day. An email from the Minister of material that day. An email from the Minister of of material that day. An email from the Minister of Police's of material that day. An email from the Minister of Police's office the Minister of Police's office the Minister of Police's office the Minister of Police's office dated 6:26 the Minister of Police's office dated 6:26 the the Minister of Police's office dated 6:26 the same the Minister of Police's office dated 6:26 the same day the Minister of Police's office dated 6:26 the same day advising the Minister of Police's office dated 6:26 the same day advising the dated 6:26 the same day advising the material dated 6:26 the same day advising the material will dated 6:26 the same day advising the material will released dated 6:26 the same day advising the material will released to dated 6:26 the same day advising the material will released to the material will released to the public. material will released to the public. I material will released to the public. I will material will released to the public. I will not material will released to the public. I will not go material will released to the public. I will not go back material will released to the public. I will not go back and material will released to the public. I will not go back and relay public. I will not go back and relay public. I will not go back and relay public. I will not go back and relay all of public. I will not go back and relay all of those. public. I will not go back and relay all of those. There public. I will not go back and relay all of those. There is public. I will not go back and relay all of those. There is 9 public. I will not go back and relay all of those. There is 9 documents. all of those. There is 9 documents. The all of those. There is 9 documents. The member all of those. There is 9 documents. The member is all of those. There is 9 documents. The member is seeking all of those. There is 9 documents. The member is seeking to all of those. There is 9 documents. The member is seeking to table all of those. There is 9 documents. The member is seeking to table them, The member is seeking to table them, is The member is seeking to table them, is there The member is seeking to table them, is there any The member is seeking to table them, is there any objection The member is seeking to table them, is there any objection to those The member is seeking to table them, is there any objection to those 9 is there any objection to those 9 documents is there any objection to those 9 documents being is there any objection to those 9 documents being tabled? is there any objection to those 9 documents being tabled? There is there any objection to those 9 documents being tabled? There is documents being tabled? There is documents being tabled? There is documents being tabled? There is not, they documents being tabled? There is not, they can documents being tabled? There is not, they can be documents being tabled? There is not, they can be tabled. documents being tabled? There is not, they can be tabled. Point documents being tabled? There is not, they can be tabled. Point of not, they can be tabled. Point of order. not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point of not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point of order. not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point of order. Is not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point of order. Is it not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point of order. Is it still not, they can be tabled. Point of order. Point of order. Is it still a order. Point of order. Is it still a Standing order. Point of order. Is it still a Standing Order order. Point of order. Is it still a Standing Order in order. Point of order. Is it still a Standing Order in the order. Point of order. Is it still a Standing Order in the Speaker's Standing Order in the Speaker's ruling Standing Order in the Speaker's ruling judgement Standing Order in the Speaker's ruling judgement that Standing Order in the Speaker's ruling judgement that points Standing Order in the Speaker's ruling judgement that points of ruling judgement that points of ruling judgement that points of ruling judgement that points of order will ruling judgement that points of order will be ruling judgement that points of order will be heard ruling judgement that points of order will be heard in ruling judgement that points of order will be heard in silence? ruling judgement that points of order will be heard in silence? Yes, order will be heard in silence? Yes, order will be heard in silence? Yes, order will be heard in silence? Yes, there is, order will be heard in silence? Yes, there is, and order will be heard in silence? Yes, there is, and the order will be heard in silence? Yes, there is, and the member order will be heard in silence? Yes, there is, and the member knows order will be heard in silence? Yes, there is, and the member knows that. there is, and the member knows that. On there is, and the member knows that. On many there is, and the member knows that. On many occasions there is, and the member knows that. On many occasions during there is, and the member knows that. On many occasions during points there is, and the member knows that. On many occasions during points of On many occasions during points of order On many occasions during points of order he On many occasions during points of order he has On many occasions during points of order he has been On many occasions during points of order he has been guilty On many occasions during points of order he has been guilty of order he has been guilty of interjecting order he has been guilty of interjecting as order he has been guilty of interjecting as well. order he has been guilty of interjecting as well. Point order he has been guilty of interjecting as well. Point of interjecting as well. Point of order. interjecting as well. Point of order. Point interjecting as well. Point of order. Point of interjecting as well. Point of order. Point of order. interjecting as well. Point of order. Point of order. I interjecting as well. Point of order. Point of order. I didn't interjecting as well. Point of order. Point of order. I didn't ask order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or not order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or not in order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or not in the order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or not in the past order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or not in the past that order. Point of order. I didn't ask whether or not in the past that had whether or not in the past that had happened, whether or not in the past that had happened, I whether or not in the past that had happened, I wanted whether or not in the past that had happened, I wanted to whether or not in the past that had happened, I wanted to know whether or not in the past that had happened, I wanted to know whether happened, I wanted to know whether it happened, I wanted to know whether it was happened, I wanted to know whether it was still happened, I wanted to know whether it was still a happened, I wanted to know whether it was still a rule happened, I wanted to know whether it was still a rule now happened, I wanted to know whether it was still a rule now and happened, I wanted to know whether it was still a rule now and was happened, I wanted to know whether it was still a rule now and was it it was still a rule now and was it being it was still a rule now and was it being applied it was still a rule now and was it being applied because it was still a rule now and was it being applied because when it was still a rule now and was it being applied because when my being applied because when my colleague being applied because when my colleague was being applied because when my colleague was on being applied because when my colleague was on his being applied because when my colleague was on his feet... being applied because when my colleague was on his feet... The colleague was on his feet... The member colleague was on his feet... The member will colleague was on his feet... The member will resume colleague was on his feet... The member will resume his colleague was on his feet... The member will resume his seat. colleague was on his feet... The member will resume his seat. If colleague was on his feet... The member will resume his seat. If the member will resume his seat. If the member member will resume his seat. If the member had member will resume his seat. If the member had bothered member will resume his seat. If the member had bothered to member will resume his seat. If the member had bothered to listen member will resume his seat. If the member had bothered to listen I member will resume his seat. If the member had bothered to listen I said member had bothered to listen I said right member had bothered to listen I said right at member had bothered to listen I said right at the member had bothered to listen I said right at the start member had bothered to listen I said right at the start when member had bothered to listen I said right at the start when I member had bothered to listen I said right at the start when I got member had bothered to listen I said right at the start when I got to member had bothered to listen I said right at the start when I got to my right at the start when I got to my feet, right at the start when I got to my feet, yes, right at the start when I got to my feet, yes, there right at the start when I got to my feet, yes, there is right at the start when I got to my feet, yes, there is such right at the start when I got to my feet, yes, there is such a right at the start when I got to my feet, yes, there is such a Standing feet, yes, there is such a Standing Order feet, yes, there is such a Standing Order and feet, yes, there is such a Standing Order and Speaker's ruling. feet, yes, there is such a Standing Order and Speaker's ruling. It Order and Speaker's ruling. It requires Order and Speaker's ruling. It requires cooperation Order and Speaker's ruling. It requires cooperation from Order and Speaker's ruling. It requires cooperation from everybody. requires cooperation from everybody. Question requires cooperation from everybody. Question No. requires cooperation from everybody. Question No. 5, requires cooperation from everybody. Question No. 5, Jacinda requires cooperation from everybody. Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. requires cooperation from everybody. Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. Sore Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. Sore you, Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. Sore you, we Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. Sore you, we got Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. Sore you, we got interrupted. Question No. 5, Jacinda Arden. Sore you, we got interrupted. Question you, we got interrupted. Question No. you, we got interrupted. Question No. 4. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Police: My question is to the Minister of Police: What My question is to the Minister of Police: What updates My question is to the Minister of Police: What updates has My question is to the Minister of Police: What updates has she Police: What updates has she received Police: What updates has she received about Police: What updates has she received about the Police: What updates has she received about the effectiveness Police: What updates has she received about the effectiveness of received about the effectiveness of the received about the effectiveness of the Government's received about the effectiveness of the Government's scheme received about the effectiveness of the Government's scheme to received about the effectiveness of the Government's scheme to allow the Government's scheme to allow people the Government's scheme to allow people to the Government's scheme to allow people to find the Government's scheme to allow people to find out the Government's scheme to allow people to find out whether the Government's scheme to allow people to find out whether their people to find out whether their partner people to find out whether their partner has people to find out whether their partner has a people to find out whether their partner has a history people to find out whether their partner has a history of people to find out whether their partner has a history of domestic partner has a history of domestic violence? In In December In December 2015 In December 2015 we In December 2015 we introduced In December 2015 we introduced a In December 2015 we introduced a scheme In December 2015 we introduced a scheme which In December 2015 we introduced a scheme which allowed In December 2015 we introduced a scheme which allowed people In December 2015 we introduced a scheme which allowed people to In December 2015 we introduced a scheme which allowed people to ask scheme which allowed people to ask police scheme which allowed people to ask police about scheme which allowed people to ask police about whether scheme which allowed people to ask police about whether their scheme which allowed people to ask police about whether their partner police about whether their partner has police about whether their partner has a police about whether their partner has a violent police about whether their partner has a violent past. police about whether their partner has a violent past. Sadly, police about whether their partner has a violent past. Sadly, there has a violent past. Sadly, there have has a violent past. Sadly, there have been has a violent past. Sadly, there have been too has a violent past. Sadly, there have been too many has a violent past. Sadly, there have been too many cases has a violent past. Sadly, there have been too many cases where have been too many cases where police have been too many cases where people have been too many cases where people have been unable have been too many cases where people have been unable to have been too many cases where people have been unable to find have been too many cases where people have been unable to find out people have been unable to find out whether people have been unable to find out whether their people have been unable to find out whether their partner people have been unable to find out whether their partner or people have been unable to find out whether their partner or the people have been unable to find out whether their partner or the partner whether their partner or the partner of whether their partner or the partner of someone whether their partner or the partner of someone close whether their partner or the partner of someone close to whether their partner or the partner of someone close to them whether their partner or the partner of someone close to them has whether their partner or the partner of someone close to them has a of someone close to them has a history of someone close to them has a history of of someone close to them has a history of violence. The The scheme The scheme has The scheme has been The scheme has been used The scheme has been used 158 The scheme has been used 158 times The scheme has been used 158 times since The scheme has been used 158 times since it The scheme has been used 158 times since it began The scheme has been used 158 times since it began and The scheme has been used 158 times since it began and 74% The scheme has been used 158 times since it began and 74% of The scheme has been used 158 times since it began and 74% of requests since it began and 74% of requests for since it began and 74% of requests for information since it began and 74% of requests for information have since it began and 74% of requests for information have been since it began and 74% of requests for information have been approved for information have been approved for information have been approved for information have been approved by police. for information have been approved by police. When for information have been approved by police. When police for information have been approved by police. When police have for information have been approved by police. When police have been by police. When police have been able by police. When police have been able to by police. When police have been able to provide by police. When police have been able to provide information by police. When police have been able to provide information people able to provide information people can able to provide information people can then able to provide information people can then make able to provide information people can then make up able to provide information people can then make up more able to provide information people can then make up more informed can then make up more informed chases can then make up more informed chases about can then make up more informed chases about their can then make up more informed chases about their relationships. chases about their relationships. Supplementary chases about their relationships. Supplementary question. chases about their relationships. Supplementary question. To chases about their relationships. Supplementary question. To the Supplementary question. To the minister, Supplementary question. To the minister, how Supplementary question. To the minister, how does Supplementary question. To the minister, how does the Supplementary question. To the minister, how does the scheme Supplementary question. To the minister, how does the scheme work? minister, how does the scheme work? A minister, how does the scheme work? A disclosure minister, how does the scheme work? A disclosure request minister, how does the scheme work? A disclosure request can minister, how does the scheme work? A disclosure request can be minister, how does the scheme work? A disclosure request can be made minister, how does the scheme work? A disclosure request can be made to A disclosure request can be made to police A disclosure request can be made to police by A disclosure request can be made to police by the A disclosure request can be made to police by the partner A disclosure request can be made to police by the partner of A disclosure request can be made to police by the partner of the police by the partner of the potentially police by the partner of the potentially violent police by the partner of the potentially violent person police by the partner of the potentially violent person or police by the partner of the potentially violent person or a potentially violent person or a concerned potentially violent person or a concerned third potentially violent person or a concerned third party potentially violent person or a concerned third party such potentially violent person or a concerned third party such as potentially violent person or a concerned third party such as a concerned third party such as a family concerned third party such as a family member. concerned third party such as a family member. Police concerned third party such as a family member. Police can concerned third party such as a family member. Police can also family member. Police can also proactively family member. Police can also proactively release family member. Police can also proactively release information family member. Police can also proactively release information if proactively release information if proactively release information if proactively release information if they believe proactively release information if they believe someone proactively release information if they believe someone is proactively release information if they believe someone is at proactively release information if they believe someone is at risk proactively release information if they believe someone is at risk of they believe someone is at risk of violence they believe someone is at risk of violence from they believe someone is at risk of violence from their they believe someone is at risk of violence from their partner. they believe someone is at risk of violence from their partner. The violence from their partner. The police violence from their partner. The police have violence from their partner. The police have made violence from their partner. The police have made 117 violence from their partner. The police have made 117 proactive police have made 117 proactive requests, police have made 117 proactive requests, 41 police have made 117 proactive requests, 41 have police have made 117 proactive requests, 41 have been police have made 117 proactive requests, 41 have been by police have made 117 proactive requests, 41 have been by a police have made 117 proactive requests, 41 have been by a third requests, 41 have been by a third party, requests, 41 have been by a third party, preventing requests, 41 have been by a third party, preventing family requests, 41 have been by a third party, preventing family violence requests, 41 have been by a third party, preventing family violence is party, preventing family violence is a party, preventing family violence is a priority party, preventing family violence is a priority for party, preventing family violence is a priority for police party, preventing family violence is a priority for police and party, preventing family violence is a priority for police and this a priority for police and this Government. a priority for police and this Government. Supplementary a priority for police and this Government. Supplementary question. Government. Supplementary question. What Government. Supplementary question. What examples Government. Supplementary question. What examples does Government. Supplementary question. What examples does she Government. Supplementary question. What examples does she have Government. Supplementary question. What examples does she have of Government. Supplementary question. What examples does she have of how What examples does she have of how the What examples does she have of how the scheme What examples does she have of how the scheme has What examples does she have of how the scheme has helped What examples does she have of how the scheme has helped people What examples does she have of how the scheme has helped people leave the scheme has helped people leave potentially the scheme has helped people leave potentially violent the scheme has helped people leave potentially violent relationships? potentially violent relationships? Police potentially violent relationships? Police have potentially violent relationships? Police have told potentially violent relationships? Police have told me potentially violent relationships? Police have told me about potentially violent relationships? Police have told me about a Police have told me about a potentially Police have told me about a disclosure they made Police have told me about a disclosure they made to Police have told me about a disclosure they made to a Police have told me about a disclosure they made to a young disclosure they made to a young woman disclosure they made to a young woman who disclosure they made to a young woman who was disclosure they made to a young woman who was in disclosure they made to a young woman who was in a disclosure they made to a young woman who was in a relationship disclosure they made to a young woman who was in a relationship with woman who was in a relationship with a woman who was in a relationship with a man woman who was in a relationship with a man that woman who was in a relationship with a man that they woman who was in a relationship with a man that they knew woman who was in a relationship with a man that they knew to woman who was in a relationship with a man that they knew to have woman who was in a relationship with a man that they knew to have had a man that they knew to have had multiple a man that they knew to have had multiple relationships a man that they knew to have had multiple relationships with a man that they knew to have had multiple relationships with very multiple relationships with very young multiple relationships with very young women multiple relationships with very young women where multiple relationships with very young women where he multiple relationships with very young women where he began multiple relationships with very young women where he began to young women where he began to manipulate young women where he began to manipulate and young women where he began to manipulate and used young women where he began to manipulate and used emotional young women where he began to manipulate and used emotional abuse manipulate and used emotional abuse and manipulate and used emotional abuse and they manipulate and used emotional abuse and they saw manipulate and used emotional abuse and they saw that manipulate and used emotional abuse and they saw that increasing. manipulate and used emotional abuse and they saw that increasing. Police and they saw that increasing. Police believed and they saw that increasing. Police believed the and they saw that increasing. Police believed the woman and they saw that increasing. Police believed the woman was and they saw that increasing. Police believed the woman was at and they saw that increasing. Police believed the woman was at risk and they saw that increasing. Police believed the woman was at risk as believed the woman was at risk as his believed the woman was at risk as his behaviour believed the woman was at risk as his behaviour was believed the woman was at risk as his behaviour was escalating believed the woman was at risk as his behaviour was escalating towards his behaviour was escalating towards his behaviour was escalating towards his behaviour was escalating towards becoming violent. his behaviour was escalating towards becoming violent. When his behaviour was escalating towards becoming violent. When police becoming violent. When police becoming violent. When police becoming violent. When police approached her becoming violent. When police approached her to becoming violent. When police approached her to make becoming violent. When police approached her to make a becoming violent. When police approached her to make a voluntary approached her to make a voluntary disclosure approached her to make a voluntary disclosure she approached her to make a voluntary disclosure she said approached her to make a voluntary disclosure she said she approached her to make a voluntary disclosure she said she had approached her to make a voluntary disclosure she said she had seen approached her to make a voluntary disclosure she said she had seen the disclosure she said she had seen the man's disclosure she said she had seen the man's behaviour disclosure she said she had seen the man's behaviour deteriorating disclosure she said she had seen the man's behaviour deteriorating and disclosure she said she had seen the man's behaviour deteriorating and as disclosure she said she had seen the man's disclosure she said she had seen the a result she disclosure she said she had seen the a result she left disclosure she said she had seen the a result she left the disclosure she said she had seen the a result she left the relationship a result she left the relationship a result she left the relationship a result she left the relationship and moved a result she left the relationship and moved back a result she left the relationship and moved back in a result she left the relationship and moved back in with a result she left the relationship and moved back in with family. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he stand by his Minister: Does he stand by his statement Minister: Does he stand by his statement in Minister: Does he stand by his statement in regards Minister: Does he stand by his statement in regards to Minister: Does he stand by his statement in regards to survivors Minister: Does he stand by his statement in regards to survivors of statement in regards to survivors of abuse statement in regards to survivors of abuse while statement in regards to survivors of abuse while in statement in regards to survivors of abuse while in State statement in regards to survivors of abuse while in State care statement in regards to survivors of abuse while in State care that abuse while in State care that "they've abuse while in State care that "they've been abuse while in State care that "they've been able abuse while in State care that "they've been able to abuse while in State care that "they've been able to come abuse while in State care that "they've been able to come forward, "they've been able to come forward, have "they've been able to come forward, have their "they've been able to come forward, have their story "they've been able to come forward, have their story heard, "they've been able to come forward, have their story heard, get "they've been able to come forward, have their story heard, get some have their story heard, get some compensation. have their story heard, get some compensation. Some have their story heard, get some compensation. Some of have their story heard, get some compensation. Some of them have their story heard, get some compensation. Some of them aren't compensation. Some of them aren't necessarily compensation. Some of them aren't necessarily satisfied compensation. Some of them aren't necessarily satisfied with compensation. Some of them aren't necessarily satisfied with that"? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, yes, Mr Speaker, yes, we Mr Speaker, yes, we have Mr Speaker, yes, we have no Mr Speaker, yes, we have no problem Mr Speaker, yes, we have no problem acknowledging Mr Speaker, yes, we have no problem acknowledging that Mr Speaker, yes, we have no problem acknowledging that for Mr Speaker, yes, we have no problem acknowledging that for some Mr Speaker, yes, we have no problem acknowledging that for some people acknowledging that for some people in acknowledging that for some people in State acknowledging that for some people in State care acknowledging that for some people in State care in acknowledging that for some people in State care in past acknowledging that for some people in State care in past decades acknowledging that for some people in State care in past decades abuse in State care in past decades abuse in State care in past decades abuse in State care in past decades abuse occurred of in State care in past decades abuse occurred of the in State care in past decades abuse occurred of the type in State care in past decades abuse occurred of the type which in State care in past decades abuse occurred of the type which has in State care in past decades abuse occurred of the type which has left occurred of the type which has left them occurred of the type which has left them with occurred of the type which has left them with long-lasting occurred of the type which has left them with long-lasting and occurred of the type which has left them with long-lasting and traumatic them with long-lasting and traumatic damage. them with long-lasting and traumatic damage. The them with long-lasting and traumatic damage. The Government them with long-lasting and traumatic damage. The Government is them with long-lasting and traumatic damage. The Government is focused them with long-lasting and traumatic damage. The Government is focused on damage. The Government is focused on two damage. The Government is focused on two responses damage. The Government is focused on two responses to damage. The Government is focused on two responses to that. damage. The Government is focused on two responses to that. One damage. The Government is focused on two responses to that. One is two responses to that. One is two responses to that. One is two responses to that. One is through various two responses to that. One is through various forms two responses to that. One is through various forms such two responses to that. One is through various forms such as two responses to that. One is through various forms such as the through various forms such as the listening through various forms such as the listening service through various forms such as the listening service and through various forms such as the listening service and now through various forms such as the listening service and now the listening service and now the service listening service and now the service offered listening service and now the service offered by listening service and now the service offered by MSD, listening service and now the service offered by MSD, individuals service offered by MSD, individuals affected service offered by MSD, individuals affected can service offered by MSD, individuals affected can come service offered by MSD, individuals affected can come forward service offered by MSD, individuals affected can come forward and service offered by MSD, individuals affected can come forward and have affected can come forward and have their affected can come forward and have their story affected can come forward and have their story heard affected can come forward and have their story heard and affected can come forward and have their story heard and be affected can come forward and have their story heard and be paid their story heard and be paid their story heard and be paid their story heard and be paid compensation and their story heard and be paid compensation and if their story heard and be paid compensation and if criminal their story heard and be paid compensation and if criminal matters compensation and if criminal matters arise compensation and if criminal matters compensation compensation and if criminal matters arise from that compensation and if criminal matters arise from that they compensation and if criminal matters arise from that they can compensation and if criminal matters arise from that they can go compensation and if criminal matters arise from that they can go to compensation and if criminal matters arise from that they can go to the arise from that they can go to the police. arise from that they can go to the police. The arise from that they can go to the police. The second arise from that they can go to the police. The second strand arise from that they can go to the police. The second strand has arise from that they can go to the police. The second strand has been police. The second strand has been police. The second strand has been police. The second strand has been to set police. The second strand has been to set out police. The second strand has been to set out to police. The second strand has been to set out to change police. The second strand has been to set out to change the police. The second strand has been to set out to change the system, to set out to change the system, which to set out to change the system, which I to set out to change the system, which I understand to set out to change the system, which I understand many to set out to change the system, which I understand many of to set out to change the system, which I understand many of the which I understand many of the victims which I understand many of the victims would like which I understand many of the victims would like to which I understand many of the victims would like to see, which I understand many of the victims would like to see, and which I understand many of the victims would like to see, and that victims would like to see, and that is victims would like to see, and that is why victims would like to see, and that is why we victims would like to see, and that is why we have victims would like to see, and that is why we have recently victims would like to see, and that is why we have recently launched victims would like to see, and that is why we have recently launched the is why we have recently launched the ministry is why we have recently launched the ministry for is why we have recently launched the ministry for vulnerable is why we have recently launched the ministry for vulnerable children, ministry for vulnerable children, Oranga ministry for vulnerable children, Oranga tamariki, ministry for vulnerable children, Oranga tamariki, precisely ministry for vulnerable children, Oranga tamariki, precisely to ministry for vulnerable children, Oranga tamariki, precisely to move Oranga tamariki, precisely to move on Oranga tamariki, precisely to move on from, Oranga tamariki, precisely to move on from, and Oranga tamariki, precisely to move on from, and greatly Oranga tamariki, precisely to move on from, and greatly improve Oranga tamariki, precisely to move on from, and greatly improve on, on from, and greatly improve on, some on from, and greatly improve on, some of on from, and greatly improve on, some of the on from, and greatly improve on, some of the errors on from, and greatly improve on, some of the errors of on from, and greatly improve on, some of the errors of the on from, and greatly improve on, some of the errors of the past. some of the errors of the past. Supplementary some of the errors of the past. Supplementary question. some of the errors of the past. Supplementary question. When some of the errors of the past. Supplementary question. When he Supplementary question. When he said, Supplementary question. When he said, "There Supplementary question. When he said, "There has Supplementary question. When he said, "There has been Supplementary question. When he said, "There has been a Supplementary question. When he said, "There has been a form Supplementary question. When he said, "There has been a form of Supplementary question. When he said, "There has been a form of that said, "There has been a form of that inquiry said, "There has been a form of that inquiry through said, "There has been a form of that inquiry through the said, "There has been a form of that inquiry through the listening inquiry through the listening service inquiry through the listening service that inquiry through the listening service that ran inquiry through the listening service that ran for inquiry through the listening service that ran for seven service that ran for seven years service that ran for seven service that ran for seven years designed to service that ran for seven years designed to get service that ran for seven years designed to get to the service that ran for seven years designed to get to the bottom service that ran for seven years designed to get to the bottom of designed to get to the bottom of these designed to get to the bottom of these issues", designed to get to the bottom of these issues", did designed to get to the bottom of these issues", did he designed to get to the bottom of these issues", did he realise designed to get to the bottom of these issues", did he realise that these issues", did he realise that this these issues", did he realise that this service these issues", did he realise that this service closed these issues", did he realise that this service closed while these issues", did he realise that this service closed while there these issues", did he realise that this service closed while there was this service closed while there was still this service closed while there was still people this service closed while there was still people waiting this service closed while there was still people waiting to this service closed while there was still people waiting to be this service closed while there was still people waiting to be heard? still people waiting to be heard? Yes, still people waiting to be heard? Yes, and still people waiting to be heard? Yes, and that still people waiting to be heard? Yes, and that is still people waiting to be heard? Yes, and that is why still people waiting to be heard? Yes, and that is why the still people waiting to be heard? Yes, and that is why the opportunity Yes, and that is why the opportunity made Yes, and that is why the opportunity made available Yes, and that is why the opportunity made available to Yes, and that is why the opportunity made available to them Yes, and that is why the opportunity made available to them subsequent Yes, and that is why the opportunity made available to them subsequent to made available to them subsequent to the made available to them subsequent to the closure made available to them subsequent to the closure of made available to them subsequent to the closure of the made available to them subsequent to the closure of the service made available to them subsequent to the closure of the service has made available to them subsequent to the closure of the service has been the closure of the service has been significantly the closure of the service has been significantly improved, significantly improved, significantly significantly improved, significantly sped significantly improved, significantly sped up significantly improved, significantly sped up in significantly improved, significantly sped up in a significantly improved, significantly sped up in a way significantly improved, significantly sped up in a way that significantly improved, significantly significantly improved, enables more people significantly improved, enables more people to significantly improved, enables more people to be significantly improved, enables more people to be heard, significantly improved, enables more people to be heard, to enables more people to be heard, to receive enables more people to be heard, to receive an enables more people to be heard, to receive an apology enables more people to be heard, to receive an apology and enables more people to be heard, to receive an apology and to enables more people to be heard, to receive an apology and to receive receive an apology and to receive receive an apology and to receive receive an apology and to receive compensation. Supplementary compensation. Supplementary question. compensation. Supplementary question. If compensation. Supplementary question. If those compensation. Supplementary question. If those abused compensation. Supplementary question. If those abused in compensation. Supplementary question. If those abused in State question. If those abused in State care question. If those abused in State care have question. If those abused in State care have "had question. If those abused in State care have "had their question. If those abused in State care have "had their story question. If those abused in State care have "had their story heard" care have "had their story heard" why care have "had their story heard" why did care have "had their story heard" why did Carolyn care have "had their story heard" why did Carolyn Henwood, care have "had their story heard" why did Carolyn Henwood, the care have "had their story heard" why did Carolyn Henwood, the person why did Carolyn Henwood, the person charged why did Carolyn Henwood, the person charged with why did Carolyn Henwood, the person charged with hearing why did Carolyn Henwood, the person charged with hearing those why did Carolyn Henwood, the person charged with hearing those stories charged with hearing those stories as charged with hearing those stories as part charged with hearing those stories as part of charged with hearing those stories as part of the charged with hearing those stories as part of the Government's charged with hearing those stories as part of the Government's closed as part of the Government's closed confidential as part of the Government's closed confidential listening as part of the Government's closed confidential listening and confidential listening and confidential listening and confidential listening and assistance service confidential listening and assistance service recommend confidential listening and assistance service recommend that confidential listening and assistance service recommend that an assistance service recommend that an independent assistance service recommend that an independent body assistance service recommend that an independent body be assistance service recommend that an independent body be set assistance service recommend that an independent body be set up assistance service recommend that an independent body be set up to assistance service recommend that an independent body be set up to look independent body be set up to look at independent body be set up to look at the independent body be set up to look at the extent independent body be set up to look at the extent of independent body be set up to look at the extent of State independent body be set up to look at the extent of State abuse? independent body be set up to look at the extent of State abuse? Well, at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr Speaker, at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr Speaker, the at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr Speaker, the - at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr Speaker, the - judge at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood at the extent of State abuse? Well, Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a report Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a report on Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a report on the Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a report on the basis Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a report on the basis of Mr Speaker, the - judge Henwood make a report on the basis of the a report on the basis of the listening a report on the basis of the listening service, a report on the basis of the listening service, when a report on the basis of the listening service, when it a report on the basis of the listening service, when it was listening service, when it was concluded. listening service, when it was concluded. I listening service, when it was concluded. I understand listening service, when it was concluded. I understand and concluded. I understand and concluded. I understand and concluded. I understand and appreciate that concluded. I understand and appreciate that some concluded. I understand and appreciate that some people, appreciate that some people, including appreciate that some people, including judge appreciate that some people, including judge Henwood appreciate that some people, including judge Henwood do appreciate that some people, including judge Henwood do have appreciate that some people, including judge Henwood do have a including judge Henwood do have a view including judge Henwood do have a view that including judge Henwood do have a view that there including judge Henwood do have a view that there should including judge Henwood do have a view that there should be including judge Henwood do have a view that there should be a including judge Henwood do have a view that there should be a broad view that there should be a broad inquiry. view that there should be a broad inquiry. So view that there should be a broad inquiry. So there view that there should be a broad inquiry. So there has view that there should be a broad inquiry. So there has been view that there should be a broad inquiry. So there has been some inquiry. So there has been some discussion inquiry. So there has been some view inquiry. So there has been some discussion publicly about inquiry. So there has been some discussion publicly about just what discussion publicly about just what would discussion publicly about just what would be discussion publicly about just what would be achieved discussion publicly about just what would be achieved by discussion publicly about just what would be achieved by such discussion publicly about just what would be achieved by such an discussion publicly about just what would be achieved by such an inquiry would be achieved by such an inquiry in would be achieved by such an inquiry in addition would be achieved by such an inquiry in addition to would be achieved by such an inquiry in addition to hearing would be achieved by such an inquiry in addition to hearing the in addition to hearing the individual in addition to hearing the individual cases in addition to hearing the individual cases apologising in addition to hearing the individual cases apologising and individual cases apologising and compensating individual cases apologising and compensating and individual cases apologising and compensating and completely individual cases apologising and compensating and completely changing compensating and completely changing a compensating and completely changing a system compensating and completely changing a system in compensating and completely changing a system in a compensating and completely changing a system in a way, compensating and completely changing a system in a way, on compensating and completely changing a system in a way, on a compensating and completely changing a system in a way, on a scale compensating and completely changing a system in a way, on a scale that a system in a way, on a scale that hasn't a system in a way, on a scale that a a system in a way, on a scale that hasn't occurred since a system in a way, on a scale that hasn't occurred since the a system in a way, on a scale that hasn't occurred since the late a system in a way, on a scale that hasn't occurred since the late '80s. hasn't occurred since the late '80s. Supplementary hasn't occurred since the late '80s. Supplementary question. hasn't occurred since the late '80s. Supplementary question. Has hasn't occurred since the late '80s. Supplementary question. Has he hasn't occurred since the late '80s. Supplementary question. Has he seen Supplementary question. Has he seen the Supplementary question. Has he seen the interviews Supplementary question. Has he seen the interviews in Supplementary question. Has he seen the interviews in full Supplementary question. Has he seen the interviews in full with Supplementary question. Has he seen the interviews in full with those Supplementary question. Has he seen the interviews in full with those in the interviews in full with those in State the interviews in full with those in State care the interviews in full with those in State care who the interviews in full with those in State care who featured the interviews in full with those in State care who featured on the interviews in full with those in State care who featured on the the interviews in full with those in State care who featured on the Hui State care who featured on the Hui on State care who featured on the Hui on Sunday? State care who featured on the Hui on Sunday? I State care who featured on the Hui on Sunday? I haven't State care who featured on the Hui on Sunday? I haven't seen State care who featured on the Hui on Sunday? I haven't seen those on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews but on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews but - on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews but - well, on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews but - well, just on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews but - well, just listen on Sunday? I haven't seen those interviews but - well, just listen - interviews but - well, just listen - had interviews but - well, just listen - had the interviews but - well, just listen - had the opportunity interviews but - well, just listen - had the opportunity - interviews but - well, just listen - had the opportunity - no interviews but - well, just listen - had the opportunity - no - interviews but - well, just listen - had the opportunity - no - had interviews but - well, just listen - had the opportunity - no - had the had the opportunity - no - had the opportunity had the opportunity - no - had the opportunity as had the opportunity - no - had the opportunity as a had the opportunity - no - had the opportunity as a Member had the opportunity - no - had the opportunity as a Member of opportunity as a Member of Parliament opportunity as a Member of Parliament to opportunity as a Member of Parliament to sit opportunity as a Member of Parliament to sit through opportunity as a Member of Parliament to sit through dozens opportunity as a Member of Parliament to sit through dozens of Parliament to sit through dozens of such Parliament to sit through dozens of such interviews. Parliament to sit through dozens of such interviews. Dozens Parliament to sit through dozens of such interviews. Dozens of Parliament to sit through dozens of such interviews. Dozens of them. Parliament to sit through dozens of such interviews. Dozens of them. Not such interviews. Dozens of them. Not such interviews. Dozens of them. Not such interviews. Dozens of them. Not just in such interviews. Dozens of them. Not just in those such interviews. Dozens of them. Not just in those who such interviews. Dozens of them. Not just in those who were such interviews. Dozens of them. Not just in those who were children such interviews. Dozens of them. Not just in those who were children in just in those who were children in care just in those who were children in care of just in those who were children in care of the just in those who were children in care of the State just in those who were children in care of the State but just in those who were children in care of the State but also just in those who were children in care of the State but also those just in those who were children in care of the State but also those who care of the State but also those who had care of the State but also those who had suffered care of the State but also those who had suffered significant care of the State but also those who had suffered significant abuse care of the State but also those who had suffered significant abuse in had suffered significant abuse in our had suffered significant abuse in our mental had suffered significant abuse in our mental health had suffered significant abuse in our mental health services had suffered significant abuse in our mental health services and had suffered significant abuse in our mental health services and in our mental health services and in our our mental health services and in our prisons. our mental health services and in our prisons. Again, our mental health services and in our prisons. Again, I'd our mental health services and in our prisons. Again, I'd repeat our mental health services and in our prisons. Again, I'd repeat - I our prisons. Again, I'd repeat - I repeat our prisons. Again, I'd repeat - I repeat the our prisons. Again, I'd repeat - I repeat the Government our prisons. Again, I'd repeat - I repeat the Government is our prisons. Again, I'd repeat - I repeat the Government is providing repeat the Government is providing the repeat the Government is providing the opportunity, repeat the Government is providing the opportunity, which repeat the Government is providing the opportunity, which we repeat the Government is providing the opportunity, which we are repeat the Government is providing the opportunity, which we are quite the opportunity, which we are quite open the opportunity, which we are quite open to the opportunity, which we are quite open to tweaking the opportunity, which we are quite open to tweaking or the opportunity, which we are quite open to tweaking or changing the opportunity, which we are quite open to tweaking or changing if the opportunity, which we are quite open to tweaking or changing if the open to tweaking or changing if the discussion open to tweaking or changing if the discussion leads open to tweaking or changing if the discussion leads us open to tweaking or changing if the discussion leads us that open to tweaking or changing if the discussion leads us that way, open to tweaking or changing if the discussion leads us that way, for discussion leads us that way, for discussion leads us that way, for discussion leads us that way, for cases to discussion leads us that way, for cases to be discussion leads us that way, for cases to be heard, discussion leads us that way, for cases to be heard, for discussion leads us that way, for cases to be heard, for an discussion leads us that way, for cases to be heard, for an apology, cases to be heard, for an apology, for cases to be heard, for an apology, for compensation, cases to be heard, for an apology, for compensation, and, cases to be heard, for an apology, for compensation, and, more for compensation, and, more significantly, for compensation, and, more significantly, have for compensation, and, more significantly, have set for compensation, and, more significantly, have set out for compensation, and, more significantly, have set out to significantly, have set out to change significantly, have set out to significantly, significantly, have set out to change the system. significantly, have set out to change the system. Because significantly, have set out to change the system. Because in significantly, have set out to change the system. Because in my change the system. Because in my discussions change the system. Because in my discussions with change the system. Because in my discussions with people change the system. Because in my discussions with people who change the system. Because in my discussions with people who were discussions with people who were victim discussions with people who were victim victims discussions with people who were victim victims they discussions with people who were victim victims they want discussions with people who were victim victims they want both discussions with people who were victim victims they want both of victim victims they want both of victim victims they want both of victim victims they want both of those things victim victims they want both of those things to victim victims they want both of those things to happen. those things to happen. Supplementary those things to happen. Supplementary question. those things to happen. Supplementary question. How those things to happen. Supplementary question. How can those things to happen. Supplementary question. How can he Supplementary question. How can he guarantee Supplementary question. How can he guarantee that Supplementary question. How can he guarantee that harm Supplementary question. How can he guarantee that harm is Supplementary question. How can he guarantee that harm is not Supplementary question. How can he guarantee that harm is not happening guarantee that harm is not happening now guarantee that harm is not happening now when guarantee that harm is not happening now when we guarantee that harm is not happening now when we still guarantee that harm is not happening now when we still don't guarantee that harm is not happening now when we still don't even guarantee that harm is not happening now when we still don't even have guarantee that harm is not happening now when we still don't even have an now when we still don't even have an independent now when we still don't even have an Supplementary now when we still don't even have an independent complaints process now when we still don't even have an independent complaints process for independent complaints process for children independent complaints process for children and independent complaints process for children and their independent complaints process for children and their families independent complaints process for children and their families who independent complaints process for children and their families who are independent complaints process for Supplementary independent complaints process for in care? The independent complaints process for in care? The member independent complaints process for in care? The member raises independent complaints process for in care? The member raises a independent complaints process for in care? The member raises a very in care? The member raises a very pertinent in care? The member raises a very pertinent issue. in care? The member raises a very pertinent issue. So in care? The member raises a very pertinent issue. So the in care? The member raises a very pertinent issue. So the first in care? The member raises a very pertinent issue. So the first step in care? The member raises a very in in care? The member raises a very that's been taken in care? The member raises a very that's been taken there in care? The member raises a very that's been taken there has in care? The member raises a very that's been taken there has been in care? The member raises a very that's been taken there has been the that's been taken there has been the that's been taken there has been the that's been taken there has been the setting up that's been taken there has been the setting up of that's been taken there has been the setting up of an that's been taken there has been the setting up of an independent that's been taken there has been the setting up of an independent NGO setting up of an independent NGO entity setting up of an independent NGO entity called setting up of an independent NGO entity called Voice, setting up of an independent NGO entity called Voice, and setting up of an independent NGO entity called Voice, and a setting up of an independent NGO entity called Voice, and a number setting up of an independent NGO entity called Voice, and a number of entity called Voice, and a number of entity called Voice, and a number of entity called Voice, and a number of us have entity called Voice, and a number of us have met entity called Voice, and a number of us have met the entity called Voice, and a number of us have met the people entity called Voice, and a number of us have met the people involved entity called Voice, and a number of us have met the people involved with us have met the people involved with that, us have met the people involved with that, which us have met the people involved with that, which gives us have met the people involved with that, which gives a us have met the people involved with that, which gives a voice us have met the people involved with that, which gives a voice - us have met the people involved with that, which gives a voice - an that, which gives a voice - an that, which gives a voice - an that, which gives a voice - an independent advocacy that, which gives a voice - an independent advocacy for that, which gives a voice - an independent advocacy for children. independent advocacy for children. So independent advocacy for children. So children independent advocacy for children. So children in independent advocacy for children. So children in care independent advocacy for children. So children in care today independent advocacy for children. So children in care today can independent advocacy for children. So children in care today can go independent advocacy for children. So children in care today can go to So children in care today can go to So children in care today can go to So children in care today can go to that service So children in care today can go to that service and So children in care today can go to that service and is So children in care today can go to that service and is quite that service and is quite that that service and is quite independent that service and is quite independent from Government and that service and is quite independent from Government and will independent from Government and will be independent from Government and will be protected, independent from Government and will be protected, I independent from Government and will be protected, I can independent from Government and will be protected, I can assure independent from Government and will be protected, I can assure the be protected, I can assure the member be protected, I can assure the member of be protected, I can assure the member of that. be protected, I can assure the member of that. With be protected, I can assure the member of that. With respect be protected, I can assure the member of that. With respect to be protected, I can assure the member of that. With respect to a member of that. With respect to a proper member of that. With respect to a proper independent member of that. With respect to a proper independent complaints proper independent complaints inquiry, proper independent complaints inquiry, I proper independent complaints inquiry, I understand proper independent complaints inquiry, I understand that proper independent complaints inquiry, I understand that is proper independent complaints inquiry, I understand that is under inquiry, I understand that is under discussion inquiry, I understand that is under discussion for inquiry, I understand that is under discussion for the inquiry, I understand that is under discussion for the reasons inquiry, I understand that is under discussion for the reasons that inquiry, I understand that is under discussion for the reasons that I'm discussion for the reasons that I'm sure discussion for the reasons that I'm sure the discussion for the reasons that I'm sure the member discussion for the reasons that I'm sure the member would discussion for the reasons that I'm sure the member would like discussion for the reasons that I'm sure the member would like to discussion for the reasons that I'm sure the member would like to see. sure the member would like to see. sure the member would like to see. sure the member would like to see. Supplementary question. sure the member would like to see. Supplementary question. To sure the member would like to see. Supplementary question. To the sure the member would like to see. Supplementary question. To the PM, Supplementary question. To the PM, is Supplementary question. To the PM, is he Supplementary question. To the PM, is he claiming Supplementary question. To the PM, is he claiming that Supplementary question. To the PM, is he claiming that Voice, Supplementary question. To the PM, is he claiming that Voice, a Supplementary question. To the PM, is he claiming that Voice, a group is he claiming that Voice, a group funded is he claiming that Voice, a group funded by is he claiming that Voice, a group funded by the is he claiming that Voice, a group funded by the the is he claiming that Voice, a group funded by the the endal is he claiming that Voice, a group funded by the the endal foundation funded by the the endal foundation and funded by the the endal foundation and the funded by the the endal foundation and the Vodafone funded by the the endal foundation and the Vodafone Foundation funded by the the endal foundation and the Vodafone Foundation is funded by the the endal foundation and the Vodafone Foundation is the and the Vodafone Foundation is the official and the Vodafone Foundation is the official complaints and the Vodafone Foundation is the official complaints process and the Vodafone Foundation is the official complaints process for official complaints process for CYFs? official complaints process for CYFs? No, official complaints process for CYFs? No, I official complaints process for CYFs? No, I said official complaints process for CYFs? No, I said it official complaints process for CYFs? No, I said it was official complaints process for CYFs? No, I said it was a official complaints process for CYFs? No, I said it was a first official complaints process for CYFs? No, I said it was a first step CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the first CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the first time CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the first time there CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the first time there is CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the first time there is a CYFs? No, I said it was a first step and for the first time there is a - and for the first time there is a - there and for the first time there is a - there is and for the first time there is a - there is the and for the first time there is a - there is the opportunity and for the first time there is a - there is the opportunity for there is the opportunity for children there is the opportunity for children to there is the opportunity for children to obtain there is the opportunity for children to obtain independent children to obtain independent advocacy children to obtain independent advocacy with children to obtain independent advocacy with respect children to obtain independent advocacy with respect to children to obtain independent advocacy with respect to independent advocacy with respect to independent complaints advocacy with respect to independent complaints services, advocacy with respect to independent complaints services, the advocacy with respect to independent complaints services, the Children's complaints services, the Children's Commissioner complaints services, the Children's Commissioner has complaints services, the Children's Commissioner has been complaints services, the Children's Commissioner has been there complaints services, the Children's Commissioner has been there since Commissioner has been there since 1989. Commissioner has been there since 1989. That Commissioner has been there since 1989. That has Commissioner has been there since 1989. That has turned Commissioner has been there since 1989. That has turned out Commissioner has been there since 1989. That has turned out not Commissioner has been there since 1989. That has turned out not to Commissioner has been there since 1989. That has turned out not to be 1989. That has turned out not to be satisfactory. 1989. That has turned out not to be satisfactory. So 1989. That has turned out not to be satisfactory. So there 1989. That has turned out not to be satisfactory. So there is 1989. That has turned out not to be satisfactory. So there is discussion satisfactory. So there is discussion going satisfactory. So there is discussion going on satisfactory. So there is discussion going on as satisfactory. So there is discussion going on as we satisfactory. So there is discussion going on as we speak satisfactory. So there is discussion going on as we speak about satisfactory. So there is discussion going on as we speak about an going on as we speak about an independent going on as we speak about an independent complaints going on as we speak about an independent complaints service. Order! My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Energy My question is to the Minister of Energy and My question is to the Minister of Energy and Resources: My question is to the Minister of Energy and Resources: Why My question is to the Minister of Energy and Resources: Why hasn't My question is to the Minister of Energy and Resources: Why hasn't the Energy and Resources: Why hasn't the Government Energy and Resources: Why hasn't the Government called Energy and Resources: Why hasn't the Government called for Energy and Resources: Why hasn't the Government called for a Energy and Resources: Why hasn't the Government called for a full-scale Government called for a full-scale inquiry Government called for a full-scale inquiry into Government called for a full-scale inquiry into retail Government called for a full-scale inquiry into retail electricity inquiry into retail electricity prices, inquiry into retail electricity prices, given inquiry into retail electricity prices, given the inquiry into retail electricity prices, given the percentage prices, given the percentage increase prices, given the percentage increase in prices, given the percentage increase in power prices, given the percentage increase in power pricing? We We are We are not We are not calling We are not calling for We are not calling for a We are not calling for a full-scale We are not calling for a full-scale inquiry We are not calling for a full-scale inquiry into We are not calling for a full-scale inquiry into retail We are not calling for a full-scale inquiry into retail electricity inquiry into retail electricity inquiry into retail electricity inquiry into retail electricity prices because inquiry into retail electricity prices because there inquiry into retail electricity prices because there is inquiry into retail electricity prices because there is no inquiry into retail electricity prices because there is no reason prices because there is no reason to. prices because there is no reason to. The prices because there is no reason to. The electricity prices because there is no reason to. The electricity market prices because there is no reason to. The electricity market is prices because there is no reason to. The electricity market is more to. The electricity market is more competitive to. The electricity market is more competitive than to. The electricity market is more competitive than it to. The electricity market is more competitive than it has to. The electricity market is more competitive than it has ever to. The electricity market is more competitive than it has ever been competitive than it has ever been following competitive than it has ever been following this competitive than it has ever been following this Government's competitive than it has ever been following this Government's 2009 following this Government's 2009 ministerial following this Government's 2009 ministerial review following this Government's 2009 ministerial review of following this Government's 2009 ministerial review of the ministerial review of the electricity ministerial review of the electricity market. ministerial review of the electricity market. Retail ministerial review of the electricity market. Retail power electricity market. Retail power prices electricity market. Retail power prices have electricity market. Retail power prices have fallen electricity market. Retail power prices have fallen for electricity market. Retail power prices have fallen for the electricity market. Retail power prices have fallen for the first prices have fallen for the first time prices have fallen for the first time in prices have fallen for the first time in real prices have fallen for the first time in real terms prices have fallen for the first time in real terms in prices have fallen for the first time in real terms in 15 prices have fallen for the first time in real terms in 15 years prices have fallen for the first time in real terms in 15 years in time in real terms in 15 years in the time in real terms in 15 years in the year time in real terms in 15 years in the year to time in real terms in 15 years in the year to March time in real terms in 15 years in the year to March 2016 time in real terms in 15 years in the year to March 2016 by time in real terms in 15 years in the year to March 2016 by 2.1%. the year to March 2016 by 2.1%. Statistics the year to March 2016 by 2.1%. Statistics New the year to March 2016 by 2.1%. Statistics New Zealand's the year to March 2016 by 2.1%. Statistics New Zealand's 2015/16 Statistics New Zealand's 2015/16 household Statistics New Zealand's 2015/16 household expenditure Statistics New Zealand's 2015/16 household expenditure survey Statistics New Zealand's 2015/16 household expenditure survey shows household expenditure survey shows electricity household expenditure survey shows electricity is household expenditure survey shows electricity is just household expenditure survey shows electricity is just 2.9% household expenditure survey shows electricity is just 2.9% of household expenditure survey shows electricity is just 2.9% of average electricity is just 2.9% of average weekly electricity is just 2.9% of average weekly household electricity is just 2.9% of average weekly household expenditure, electricity is just 2.9% of average weekly household expenditure, the weekly household expenditure, the lowest weekly household expenditure, the lowest proportion weekly household expenditure, the lowest proportion of weekly household expenditure, the lowest proportion of household lowest proportion of household budget lowest proportion of household budget since lowest proportion of household budget since 2000-2001. lowest proportion of household budget since 2000-2001. That budget since 2000-2001. That compares budget since 2000-2001. That compares to budget since 2000-2001. That compares to 3.6% budget since 2000-2001. That compares to 3.6% in budget since 2000-2001. That compares to 3.6% in the budget since 2000-2001. That compares to 3.6% in the previous compares to 3.6% in the previous survey compares to 3.6% in the previous survey of compares to 3.6% in the previous survey of 2012/13. compares to 3.6% in the previous survey of 2012/13. That compares to 3.6% in the previous survey of 2012/13. That is compares to 3.6% in the previous survey of 2012/13. That is a compares to 3.6% in the previous survey of 2012/13. That is a decree survey of 2012/13. That is a decree of survey of 2012/13. That is a decree of 5.6%. survey of 2012/13. That is a decree of 5.6%. . survey of 2012/13. That is a decree of 5.6%. . Order! survey of 2012/13. That is a decree of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary question. of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary question. To of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary question. To the of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary question. To the minister, of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary question. To the minister, can of 5.6%. . Order! Supplementary question. To the minister, can she question. To the minister, can she explain question. To the minister, can she explain to question. To the minister, can she explain to Kiwi question. To the minister, can she explain to Kiwi families question. To the minister, can she explain to Kiwi families and question. To the minister, can she explain to Kiwi families and small explain to Kiwi families and small businesses explain to Kiwi families and small businesses why explain to Kiwi families and small businesses why electricity explain to Kiwi families and small businesses why electricity prices businesses why electricity prices have businesses why electricity prices have sky businesses why electricity prices have sky rocketed businesses why electricity prices have sky rocketed 148% businesses why electricity prices have sky rocketed 148% since have sky rocketed 148% since National's have sky rocketed 148% since National's so-called have sky rocketed 148% since National's so-called 1998 have sky rocketed 148% since National's so-called 1998 reforms National's so-called 1998 reforms National's so-called 1998 reforms National's so-called 1998 reforms that were National's so-called 1998 reforms that were meant National's so-called 1998 reforms that were meant to National's so-called 1998 reforms that were meant to lower National's so-called 1998 reforms that were meant to lower prices? that were meant to lower prices? Order! that were meant to lower prices? Order! I that were meant to lower prices? Order! I will that were meant to lower prices? Order! I will hear that were meant to lower prices? Order! I will hear from that were meant to lower prices? Order! I will hear from the that were meant to lower prices? Order! I will hear from the Hon Order! I will hear from the Hon Judith Order! I will hear from the Hon Judith Collins. Order! I will hear from the Hon Judith Collins. Mr Order! I will hear from the Hon Judith Collins. Mr Speaker... Judith Collins. Mr Speaker... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! The <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member is <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member is simply <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member is simply wrong. Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm happy Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm happy to Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm happy to provide Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm happy to provide and Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm happy to provide and to Order! The member is simply wrong. I'm happy to provide and to table I'm happy to provide and to table for I'm happy to provide and to table for that I'm happy to provide and to table for that member's I'm happy to provide and to table for that member's benefit I'm happy to provide and to table for that member's benefit the for that member's benefit the figures for that member's benefit the figures given for that member's benefit the figures given to for that member's benefit the figures given to me for that member's benefit the figures given to me by for that member's benefit the figures given to me by the for that member's benefit the figures given to me by the Ministry figures given to me by the Ministry figures given to me by the Ministry figures given to me by the Ministry of Business, figures given to me by the Ministry of Business, Innovation figures given to me by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and of Business, Innovation and Employment of Business, Innovation and Employment relating of Business, Innovation and Employment relating to of Business, Innovation and Employment relating to this. of Business, Innovation and Employment relating to this. These Employment relating to this. These Employment relating to this. These Employment relating to this. These are obtained Employment relating to this. These are obtained specifically Employment relating to this. These are obtained specifically from Employment relating to this. These are obtained specifically from the are obtained specifically from the Dept are obtained specifically from the Dept of are obtained specifically from the Dept of Statistics. are obtained specifically from the Dept of Statistics. Supplementary Dept of Statistics. Supplementary question. Dept of Statistics. Supplementary question. How Dept of Statistics. Supplementary question. How could Dept of Statistics. Supplementary question. How could wholesale question. How could wholesale electricity question. How could wholesale electricity prices question. How could wholesale electricity prices like question. How could wholesale electricity prices like OTAHUHU question. How could wholesale electricity prices like OTAHUHU for question. How could wholesale electricity question. How could wholesale example average just question. How could wholesale example average just over question. How could wholesale example average just over 6 question. How could wholesale example average just over 6 cents question. How could wholesale example average just over 6 cents a example average just over 6 cents a kilo example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt hour example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt hour but example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt hour but become example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt hour but become 29 example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt hour but become 29 cents example average just over 6 cents a kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour when kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour when they kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour when they are kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour when they are sold kilo watt hour but become 29 cents a kilo watt hour when they are sold to kilo watt hour when they are sold to consumers kilo watt hour when they are sold to consumers and kilo watt hour when they are sold to consumers and small kilo watt hour when they are sold to consumers and small businesses? kilo watt hour when they are sold to consumers and small businesses? I consumers and small businesses? I suggest consumers and small businesses? I suggest there consumers and small businesses? I suggest there is consumers and small businesses? I suggest there is often consumers and small businesses? I suggest there is often a consumers and small businesses? I suggest there is often a difference suggest there is often a difference between suggest there is often a difference between wholesale suggest there is often a difference between wholesale prices suggest there is often a difference between wholesale prices and suggest there is often a difference between wholesale prices and retail between wholesale prices and retail prices. between wholesale prices and retail prices. Supplementary between wholesale prices and retail prices. Supplementary question. between wholesale prices and retail prices. Supplementary question. Does prices. Supplementary question. Does she prices. Supplementary question. Does she believe prices. Supplementary question. Does she believe that prices. Supplementary question. Does she believe that after-tax prices. Supplementary question. Does she believe that after-tax profits she believe that after-tax profits of she believe that after-tax profits of over she believe that after-tax profits of over $500 she believe that after-tax profits of over $500 million she believe that after-tax profits of over $500 million reported she believe that after-tax profits of over $500 million reported by of over $500 million reported by Mercury, of over $500 million reported by Mercury, Meridian of over $500 million reported by Mercury, Meridian and of over $500 million reported by Mercury, Meridian and others of over $500 million reported by Mercury, Meridian and others last Mercury, Meridian and others last year Mercury, Meridian and others last year alone Mercury, Meridian and others last year alone are Mercury, Meridian and others last year alone are good Mercury, Meridian and others last year alone are good for Mercury, Meridian and others last year alone are good for household year alone are good for household year alone are good for household year alone are good for household incomes for year alone are good for household incomes for for year alone are good for household incomes for for that year alone are good for household incomes for for that matter year alone are good for household incomes for for that matter small incomes for for that matter small businesses incomes for for that matter small businesses just incomes for for that matter small businesses just trying incomes for for that matter small businesses just trying to incomes for for that matter small businesses just trying to stay businesses just trying to stay businesses just trying to stay businesses just trying to stay afloat? I businesses just trying to stay afloat? I think businesses just trying to stay afloat? I think I businesses just trying to stay afloat? I think I can businesses just trying to stay afloat? I think I can say businesses just trying to stay afloat? I think I can say that afloat? I think I can say that average afloat? I think I can say that average electricity afloat? I think I can say that average electricity spend afloat? I think I can say that average electricity spend for afloat? I think I can say that average electricity spend for a average electricity spend for a household average electricity spend for a household is average electricity spend for a household is just average electricity spend for a household is just 2.9% average electricity spend for a household is just 2.9% of average electricity spend for a household is just 2.9% of the household is just 2.9% of the average household is just 2.9% of the average weekly household is just 2.9% of the average weekly household household is just 2.9% of the average weekly household xur, household is just 2.9% of the average weekly household xur, then average weekly household xur, then that average weekly household xur, then that is average weekly household xur, then that is -- average weekly household xur, then that is -- expenditure, average weekly household xur, then that is -- expenditure, that average weekly household xur, then that is -- expenditure, that is average weekly household xur, then that is -- expenditure, that is a that is -- expenditure, that is a relatively that is -- expenditure, that is a relatively good that is -- expenditure, that is a relatively good percentage that is -- expenditure, that is a relatively good percentage compared relatively good percentage compared to relatively good percentage compared to other relatively good percentage compared to other places relatively good percentage compared to other places in relatively good percentage compared to other places in the relatively good percentage compared to other places in the world. relatively good percentage compared to other places in the world. I to other places in the world. I would to other places in the world. I would say to other places in the world. I would say our to other places in the world. I would say our electricity to other places in the world. I would say our electricity market to other places in the world. I would say our electricity market has would say our electricity market has would say our electricity market has would say our electricity market has not undergone would say our electricity market has not undergone some would say our electricity market has not undergone some of the would say our electricity market has not undergone some of the issues not undergone some of the issues some not undergone some of the issues some other not undergone some of the issues some other electricity not undergone some of the issues some other electricity markets not undergone some of the issues some other electricity markets have, some other electricity markets have, particularly some other electricity markets have, particularly around some other electricity markets have, particularly around security some other electricity markets have, particularly around security of particularly around security of particularly around security of particularly around security of supply. Point particularly around security of supply. Point of particularly around security of supply. Point of order, particularly around security of supply. Point of order, Richard supply. Point of order, Richard Prosser. supply. Point of order, Richard Prosser. I supply. Point of order, Richard Prosser. I seek supply. Point of order, Richard Prosser. I seek your supply. Point of order, Richard Prosser. I seek your guidance supply. Point of order, Richard Prosser. I seek your guidance with Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards to Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards to the Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards to the point Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards to the point of Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards to the point of order Prosser. I seek your guidance with regards to the point of order raised regards to the point of order raised regards to the point of order raised regards to the point of order raised by Mr regards to the point of order raised by Mr Mark regards to the point of order raised by Mr Mark in regards to the point of order raised by Mr Mark in the regards to the point of order raised by Mr Mark in the earlier regards to the point of order raised by Mr Mark in the earlier question by Mr Mark in the earlier question when, by Mr Mark in the earlier question when, during by Mr Mark in the earlier question when, during the by Mr Mark in the earlier question when, during the course by Mr Mark in the earlier question when, during the course of by Mr Mark in the earlier question when, during the course of making when, during the course of making his when, during the course of making by when, during the course of making his point of when, during the course of making his point of order when, during the course of making his point of order he when, during the course of making his point of order he sought when, during the course of making his point of order he sought to when, during the course of making his point of order he sought to make his point of order he sought to make another his point of order he sought to make by his point of order he sought to make another point of his point of order he sought to make another point of order. his point of order he sought to make another point of order. Looking his point of order he sought to make another point of order. Looking at another point of order. Looking at Speakers another point of order. Looking at Speakers Ruling, another point of order. Looking at Speakers Ruling, 21(6), another point of order. Looking at Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this another point of order. Looking at Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers to Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers to debate Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers to debate and Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers to debate and there Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers to debate and there doesn't Speakers Ruling, 21(6), this refers to debate and there doesn't appear to debate and there doesn't appear to to debate and there doesn't appear to be to debate and there doesn't appear to be anything to debate and there doesn't appear to be anything in to debate and there doesn't appear to be anything in Standing to debate and there doesn't appear to be anything in Standing Orders to debate and there doesn't appear to be anything in Standing Orders to to be anything in Standing Orders to preclude to be anything in Standing Orders to to to be anything in Standing Orders to preclude the calling to be anything in Standing Orders to preclude the calling of to be anything in Standing Orders to preclude the calling of a to be anything in Standing Orders to preclude the calling of a point to be anything in Standing Orders to preclude the calling of a point of preclude the calling of a point of order preclude the calling of a point of order within preclude the calling of a point of order within a preclude the calling of a point of order within a point preclude the calling of a point of order within a point of preclude the calling of a point of order within a point of order. preclude the calling of a point of order within a point of order. I order within a point of order. I wonder order within a point of order. I wonder if order within a point of order. I wonder if you order within a point of order. I wonder if you could order within a point of order. I wonder if you could give order within a point of order. I wonder if you could give some wonder if you could give some thought wonder if you could give some thought to wonder if you could give some thought to this wonder if you could give some thought to this and wonder if you could give some thought to this and come wonder if you could give some thought to this and come back wonder if you could give some thought to this and come back to wonder if you could give some thought to this and come back to us thought to this and come back to us and thought to this and come back to us and clarify thought to this and come back to us and clarify whether thought to this and come back to us and clarify whether - thought to this and come back to us and clarify whether - in thought to this and come back to us and clarify whether - in other and clarify whether - in other words, and clarify whether - in other words, calling and clarify whether - in other words, calling attention and clarify whether - in other words, calling attention to and clarify whether - in other words, calling attention to a and clarify whether - in other words, calling attention to a breach words, calling attention to a breach of words, calling attention to a breach of order words, calling attention to a breach of order which, words, calling attention to a breach of order which, Mr words, calling attention to a breach of order which, Mr Mark words, calling attention to a breach of order which, Mr Mark was, words, calling attention to a breach of order which, Mr Mark was, with of order which, Mr Mark was, with reference of order which, Mr Mark was, with reference to of order which, Mr Mark was, with reference to an of order which, Mr Mark was, with reference to an interjection. of order which, Mr Mark was, with reference to an interjection. I of order which, Mr Mark was, with reference to an interjection. I will reference to an interjection. I will hear reference to an interjection. I will hear from reference to an interjection. I will hear from Mr reference to an interjection. I will hear from Mr Brownlee. reference to an interjection. I will hear from Mr Brownlee. One reference to an interjection. I will hear from Mr Brownlee. One of reference to an interjection. I will hear from Mr Brownlee. One of the hear from Mr Brownlee. One of the hear hear from Mr Brownlee. One of the important things about hear from Mr Brownlee. One of the important things about calling hear from Mr Brownlee. One of the important things about calling a important things about calling a point important things about calling a point of important things about calling a point of order important things about calling a point of order is important things about calling a point of order is it important things about calling a point of order is it is, important things about calling a point of order is it is, in important things about calling a point of order is it is, in fact, important things about calling a point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order is it is, in fact, a point point of order is it is, in fact, a point of point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order and point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order and not point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order and not a point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order and not a device point of order is it is, in fact, a point of order and not a device to point of order and not a device to attract point of order and not a device to attract attention to one's point of order and not a device to attract attention to one's self. attract attention to one's self. Order! attract attention to one's self. Order! I attract attention to one's self. Order! I will attract attention to one's self. Order! I will hear attract attention to one's self. Order! I will hear from attract attention to one's self. Order! I will hear from Ron attract attention to one's self. Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. That Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. That is Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. That is precisely Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. That is precisely the Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. That is precisely the point. Order! I will hear from Ron Mark. That is precisely the point. How That is precisely the point. How would That is precisely the point. How would you That is precisely the point. How would you or That is precisely the point. How would you or Mr That is precisely the point. How would you or Mr Brownlee That is precisely the point. How would you or Mr Brownlee know That is precisely the point. How would you or Mr Brownlee know if That is precisely the point. How would you or Mr Brownlee know if my would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point of would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point of order would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point of order was would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point of order was or would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point of order was or was would you or Mr Brownlee know if my second point of order was or was not second point of order was or was not a second point of order was or was not a legitimate second point of order was or was not a legitimate point second point of order was or was not a legitimate point of second point of order was or was not a legitimate point of order second point of order was or was not a legitimate point of order if second point of order was or was not a legitimate point of order if you a legitimate point of order if you did a legitimate point of order if you did not a legitimate point of order if you did not hear a legitimate point of order if you did not hear it? a legitimate point of order if you did not hear it? If a legitimate point of order if you did not hear it? If Mr a legitimate point of order if you did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee a legitimate point of order if you did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a crystal did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a crystal ball did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a crystal ball down did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a crystal ball down there, did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a crystal ball down there, I did not hear it? If Mr Brownlee has a crystal ball down there, I would a crystal ball down there, I would love a crystal ball down there, I would love to a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a look a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a look at a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a look at it a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a look at it some a crystal ball down there, I would love to have a look at it some time. love to have a look at it some time. <INTERRUPTION> I, I, myself, I, myself, am I, myself, am blushing. I, myself, am blushing. Can I, myself, am blushing. Can we I, myself, am blushing. Can we have I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little bit I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little bit of I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little bit of order I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little bit of order while I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little bit of order while I I, myself, am blushing. Can we have a little bit of order while I rule a little bit of order while I rule on a little bit of order while I rule on that a little bit of order while I rule on that this a little bit of order while I rule on that this matter? a little bit of order while I rule on that this matter? All a little bit of order while I rule on that this matter? All points a little bit of order while I rule on that this matter? All points of on that this matter? All points of order on that this matter? All points of order - on that this matter? All points of order - the on that this matter? All points of order - the circumstances on that this matter? All points of order - the circumstances at on that this matter? All points of order - the circumstances at any order - the circumstances at any time order - the circumstances at any time - order - the circumstances at any time - I'm order - the circumstances at any time - I'm addressing order - the circumstances at any time - I'm addressing Richard time - I'm addressing Richard Prosser's time - I'm addressing Richard Prosser's point time - I'm addressing Richard Prosser's point of time - I'm addressing Richard Prosser's point of order. time - I'm addressing Richard Prosser's point of order. The Prosser's point of order. The point Prosser's point of order. The Prosser's point of order. The point of order Prosser's point of order. The point of order and Prosser's point of order. The point of order and circumstances Prosser's point of order. The point of order and circumstances are Prosser's point of order. The point of order and circumstances are never of order and circumstances are never quite of order and circumstances are never quite the of order and circumstances are never quite the same of order and circumstances are never quite the same on of order and circumstances are never quite the same on two of order and circumstances are never quite the same on two occasions. quite the same on two occasions. When quite the same on two occasions. When I quite the same on two occasions. When I consider quite the same on two occasions. When I consider the quite the same on two occasions. When I consider the laborious When I consider the laborious process When I consider the laborious process Mr When I consider the laborious process Mr Mark When I consider the laborious process Mr Mark was When I consider the laborious process Mr Mark was going When I consider the laborious process Mr Mark was going through When I consider the laborious process Mr Mark was going through in process Mr Mark was going through in seeking process Mr Mark was going through in seeking to process Mr Mark was going through in seeking to table process Mr Mark was going through in seeking to table documents process Mr Mark was going through in seeking to table documents that process Mr Mark was going through in seeking to table documents that he seeking to table documents that he thought seeking to table documents that he thought might seeking to table documents that he thought might have seeking to table documents that he thought might have been seeking to table documents that he thought might have been informative thought might have been informative to thought might have been informative to the thought might have been informative to the House, thought might have been informative to the House, but thought might have been informative to the House, but when thought might have been informative to the House, but when I thought might have been informative to the House, but when I consider to the House, but when I consider them to the House, but when I consider them now to the House, but when I consider them now were to the House, but when I consider them now were more to the House, but when I consider them now were more about to the House, but when I consider them now were more about making to the House, but when I consider them now were more about making a them now were more about making a political them now were more about making a political point, them now were more about making a political point, inevitably them now were more about making a political point, inevitably there them now were more about making a political point, inevitably there is political point, inevitably there is going political point, inevitably there is going to political point, inevitably there is going to be political point, inevitably there is going to be an political point, inevitably there is going to be an objection political point, inevitably there is going to be an objection or political point, inevitably there is going to be an objection or an going to be an objection or an interjection going to be an objection or an interjection across going to be an objection or an interjection across the going to be an objection or an interjection across the House. going to be an objection or an interjection across the House. It interjection across the House. It shouldn't interjection across the House. It shouldn't happen interjection across the House. It shouldn't happen but interjection across the House. It shouldn't happen but it interjection across the House. It shouldn't happen but it is interjection across the House. It shouldn't happen but it is no shouldn't happen but it is no different shouldn't happen but it is no different than shouldn't happen but it is no different than an shouldn't happen but it is no different than an answer shouldn't happen but it is no different than an answer being shouldn't happen but it is no different than an answer being given different than an answer being given recently different than an answer being given recently by different than an answer being given recently by the different than an answer being given recently by the minister, different than an answer being given recently by the minister, Judith recently by the minister, Judith Collins, recently by the minister, Judith Collins, and recently by the minister, Judith Collins, and Mr recently by the minister, Judith Collins, and Mr Winston recently by the minister, Judith Collins, and Mr Winston Peters Collins, and Mr Winston Peters taking Collins, and Mr Winston Peters taking objection Collins, and Mr Winston Peters taking objection to Collins, and Mr Winston Peters taking objection to it Collins, and Mr Winston Peters taking objection to it and taking objection to it and taking objection to it and taking objection to it and interjecting to taking objection to it and interjecting to that taking objection to it and interjecting to that answer taking objection to it and interjecting to that answer across interjecting to that answer across interjecting to that answer across interjecting to that answer across the House. interjecting to that answer across the House. I interjecting to that answer across the House. I will interjecting to that answer across the House. I will do interjecting to that answer across the House. I will do my interjecting to that answer across the House. I will do my best interjecting to that answer across the House. I will do my best to the House. I will do my best to maintain the House. I will do my best to maintain order the House. I will do my best to maintain order in the House. I will do my best to maintain order in the the House. I will do my best to maintain order in the House the House. I will do my best to maintain order in the House and the House. I will do my best to maintain order in the House and it maintain order in the House and it is maintain order in the House and it is certainly maintain order in the House and it is certainly not maintain order in the House and it is certainly not helped maintain order in the House and it is certainly not helped by maintain order in the House and it is certainly not helped by the maintain order in the House and it is certainly not helped by the last is certainly not helped by the last point is certainly not helped by the last point of is certainly not helped by the last point of order is certainly not helped by the last point of order raised is certainly not helped by the last point of order raised by is certainly not helped by the last point of order raised by Ron is certainly not helped by the last point of order raised by Ron Mark. point of order raised by Ron Mark. Fresh point of order raised by Ron Mark. Fresh point point of order raised by Ron Mark. Fresh point of point of order raised by Ron Mark. Fresh point of order? point of order raised by Ron Mark. Fresh point of order? Totally. point of order raised by Ron Mark. Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I take Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I take it Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I take it now Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I take it now from Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I take it now from your Fresh point of order? Totally. Shall I take it now from your very I take it now from your very considered I take it now from your very considered view I take it now from your very considered view just I take it now from your very considered view just given I take it now from your very considered view just given that I take it now from your very considered view just given that if I take it now from your very considered view just given that if I considered view just given that if I think considered view just given that if I think a considered view just given that if I think a Government considered view just given that if I think a Government member considered view just given that if I think a Government member is considered view just given that if I think a Government member is giving think a Government member is giving a think a Government member is giving a laborious think a Government member is giving a laborious reply think a Government member is giving a laborious reply or think a Government member is giving a laborious reply or a think a Government member is giving a laborious reply or a laborious a laborious reply or a laborious point a laborious reply or a laborious point of a laborious reply or a laborious point of order a laborious reply or a laborious point of order that a laborious reply or a laborious point of order that it a laborious reply or a laborious point of order that it is a laborious reply or a laborious point of order that it is quite a laborious reply or a laborious point of order that it is quite OK point of order that it is quite OK for point of order that it is quite OK for me point of order that it is quite OK for me to point of order that it is quite OK for me to interject point of order that it is quite OK for me to interject like point of order that it is quite OK for me to interject like that for me to interject like that manoeuvre for me to interject like that manoeuvre there for me to interject like that manoeuvre there did? for me to interject like that manoeuvre there did? I for me to interject like that manoeuvre there did? I remind for me to interject like that manoeuvre there did? I remind the for me to interject like that manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that man manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that man over manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that man over there manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that man over there did? manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that man over there did? I manoeuvre there did? I remind the -- that man over there did? I remind that man over there did? I remind that man over there did? I remind that man over there did? I remind the member that man over there did? I remind the member that that man over there did? I remind the member that on that man over there did? I remind the member that on many that man over there did? I remind the member that on many occasions that man over there did? I remind the member that on many occasions he that man over there did? I remind the that man over there did? I remind has done just that man over there did? I remind has done just that. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Education: My question is to the Minister of Education: What My question is to the Minister of Education: What recent My question is to the Minister of Education: What recent announcements Education: What recent announcements has Education: What recent announcements has she Education: What recent announcements has she made Education: What recent announcements has she made regarding Education: What recent announcements has she made regarding Communities has she made regarding Communities of has she made regarding Communities of Learning? Tena Tena koe, Tena koe, Mr Tena koe, Mr Speaker. Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I was Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I was pleased Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I was pleased to Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I was pleased to announce Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I was pleased to announce that Tena koe, Mr Speaker. This morning I was pleased to announce that a was pleased to announce that a further was pleased to announce that a further 17 was pleased to announce that a further 17 communities was pleased to announce that a further 17 communities of was pleased to announce that a further 17 communities of learning further 17 communities of learning have further 17 communities of learning have been further 17 communities of learning have been established further 17 communities of learning have been established bringing further 17 communities of learning have been established bringing the have been established bringing the total have been established bringing the total to have been established bringing the total to almost have been established bringing the total to almost 200. have been established bringing the total to almost 200. There have been established bringing the total to almost 200. There are have been established bringing the total to almost 200. There are now total to almost 200. There are now 184 total to almost 200. There are now 184 Early total to almost 200. There are now 184 Early Learning total to almost 200. There are now 184 Early Learning Services total to almost 200. There are now 184 Early Learning Services and 184 Early Learning Services and 184 Early Learning Services and 184 Early Learning Services and 1,630 schools 184 Early Learning Services and 1,630 schools and 184 Early Learning Services and 1,630 schools and four 184 Early Learning Services and 1,630 schools and four tertiary 1,630 schools and four tertiary providers 1,630 schools and four tertiary providers covering 1,630 schools and four tertiary providers covering more 1,630 schools and four tertiary providers covering more than providers covering more than $500,000 providers covering more than $500,000 young providers covering more than $500,000 young people providers covering more than $500,000 young people across providers covering more than $500,000 young people across the $500,000 young people across the country. $500,000 young people across the country. I $500,000 young people across the country. I am $500,000 young people across the country. I am particularly country. I am particularly pleased country. I am particularly country. I am particularly pleased to see country. I am particularly pleased to see that country. I am particularly pleased to see that the country. I am particularly pleased to see that the number country. I am particularly pleased to see that the number of country. I am particularly pleased to see that the number of early to see that the number of early services to see that the number of early services joining to see that the number of early services joining Communities to see that the number of early services joining Communities of services joining Communities of Learning services joining Communities of Learning has services joining Communities of Learning has doubled services joining Communities of Learning has doubled in services joining Communities of Learning has doubled in just services joining Communities of Learning has doubled in just four Learning has doubled in just four months Learning has doubled in just four months with Learning has doubled in just four months with 24% Learning has doubled in just four months with 24% of Learning has doubled in just four months with 24% of them Learning has doubled in just four months with 24% of them now Learning has doubled in just four months with 24% of them now having months with 24% of them now having the months with 24% of them now having the full months with 24% of them now having the full 0-18 months with 24% of them now having the full 0-18 learning months with 24% of them now having the full 0-18 learning pathway the full 0-18 learning pathway the full 0-18 learning pathway the full 0-18 learning pathway represented. Finally the full 0-18 learning pathway represented. Finally in the full 0-18 learning pathway represented. Finally in amongst the full 0-18 learning pathway represented. Finally in amongst all represented. Finally in amongst all this represented. Finally in amongst all this good represented. Finally in amongst all this good new, represented. Finally in amongst all this good new, I represented. Finally in amongst all this good new, I was represented. Finally in amongst all this good new, I was spaced represented. Finally in amongst all this good new, I was spaced to this good new, I was spaced to announce this good new, I was spaced to announce that this good new, I was spaced to announce that more this good new, I was spaced to announce that more than this good new, I was spaced to announce that more than 1,100 announce that more than 1,100 teachers announce that more than 1,100 teachers and announce that more than 1,100 teachers and principals announce that more than 1,100 teachers and principals have teachers and principals have been teachers and principals have teachers and principals have been appointed to teachers and principals have been appointed to new teachers and principals have been appointed to new roles. teachers and principals have been appointed to new roles. It teachers and principals have been appointed to new roles. It is appointed to new roles. It is fantastic appointed to new roles. It is fantastic to appointed to new roles. It is fantastic to see appointed to new roles. It is fantastic to see so appointed to new roles. It is fantastic to see so many appointed to new roles. It is fantastic to see so many talented fantastic to see so many talented individuals fantastic to see so many talented individuals in fantastic to see so many talented individuals in the fantastic to see so many talented individuals in the sector fantastic to see so many talented individuals in the sector taking fantastic to see so many talented individuals in the sector taking up individuals in the sector taking up these individuals in the sector taking up these new individuals in the sector taking up these new roles. individuals in the sector taking up these new roles. Supplementary these new roles. Supplementary question. these new roles. Supplementary question. How these new roles. Supplementary question. How do these new roles. Supplementary question. How do Communities these new roles. Supplementary question. How do Communities of question. How do Communities of question. How do Communities of question. How do Communities of Learning support question. How do Communities of Learning support achievement question. How do Communities of Learning support achievement for question. How do Communities of Learning support achievement for our Learning support achievement for our Learning support achievement for our Learning support achievement for our young people? Learning support achievement for our young people? Well, Learning support achievement for our young people? Well, in Learning support achievement for our young people? Well, in so Learning support achievement for our young people? Well, in so many Learning support achievement for our young people? Well, in so many ways. young people? Well, in so many ways. Communities young people? Well, in so many ways. Communities of young people? Well, in so many ways. Communities of Learning young people? Well, in so many ways. Communities of Learning are young people? Well, in so many ways. Communities of Learning are about Communities of Learning are about end-to-end Communities of Learning are about end-to-end education Communities of Learning are about end-to-end education pathways Communities of Learning are about end-to-end education pathways with end-to-end education pathways with end-to-end education pathways with end-to-end education pathways with children and end-to-end education pathways with children and young end-to-end education pathways with children and young people end-to-end education pathways with children and young people at children and young people at the children and young people at children and young people at the very centre. children and young people at the very centre. The children and young people at the very centre. The achievement very centre. The achievement very centre. The achievement very centre. The achievement challenges that very centre. The achievement challenges that are very centre. The achievement challenges that are set very centre. The achievement challenges that are set using very centre. The achievement challenges that are set using the challenges that are set using the shared challenges that are set using the shared data challenges that are set using the shared data are challenges that are set using the shared data are about challenges that are set using the shared data are about raising challenges that are set using the shared data are about raising the shared data are about raising the achievement shared data are about raising the achievement of shared data are about raising the achievement of all achievement of all participating achievement of all achievement of all participating opportunities. Commun achievement of all participating opportunities. Commun 'tis achievement of all participating opportunities. Commun 'tis of opportunities. Commun 'tis of learning opportunities. Commun 'tis of learning are opportunities. Commun 'tis of learning are are opportunities. Commun 'tis of learning are are designed opportunities. Commun 'tis of learning are are designed that opportunities. Commun 'tis of learning are are designed that all learning are are designed that all children learning are are designed that all children and learning are are designed that all children and young learning are are designed that all children and young people learning are are designed that all children and young people can children and young people can experience children and young people can experience from children and young people can experience from the children and young people can experience from the expertise children and young people can experience from the expertise of experience from the expertise of leaders experience from the expertise of leaders and experience from the expertise of leaders and people experience from the expertise of leaders and people in experience from the expertise of leaders and people in their leaders and people in their community. community. <SPEAKS community. <SPEAKS TE community. <SPEAKS TE REO community. <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it is <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it is intended <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it is intended to <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it is intended to raise <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it is intended to raise the <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> it is intended to raise the quality it is intended to raise the quality of it is intended to raise the quality of teaching it is intended to raise the quality of teaching and it is intended to raise the quality of teaching and leadership it is intended to raise the quality of teaching and leadership across it is intended to raise the quality of teaching and leadership across a of teaching and leadership across a whole of teaching and leadership across a whole community of teaching and leadership across a whole community through of teaching and leadership across a whole community through sharing whole community through sharing expertise whole community through sharing expertise and whole community through sharing expertise and resources. whole community through sharing expertise and resources. I whole community through sharing expertise and resources. I thank whole community through sharing expertise and resources. I thank the expertise and resources. I thank the member expertise and resources. I thank the member from expertise and resources. I thank the member from New expertise and resources. I thank the member from New Zealand expertise and resources. I thank the member from New Zealand First expertise and resources. I thank the member from New Zealand First for member from New Zealand First for enjoying member from New Zealand First for enjoying that member from New Zealand First for enjoying that answer member from New Zealand First for enjoying that answer so member from New Zealand First for enjoying that answer so much. member from New Zealand First for enjoying that answer so much. Order! enjoying that answer so much. Order! The enjoying that answer so much. Order! The minister enjoying that answer so much. Order! The minister can enjoying that answer so much. Order! The minister can resume enjoying that answer so much. Order! The minister can resume her enjoying that answer so much. Order! The minister can resume her seat. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he stand My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he stand by My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he stand by the Finance: Does he stand by the statement Finance: Does he stand by the statement he Finance: Does he stand by the statement he made Finance: Does he stand by the statement he made on Finance: Does he stand by the statement he made on behalf Finance: Does he stand by the statement he made on behalf of Finance: Does he stand by the statement he made on behalf of the statement he made on behalf of the then statement he made on behalf of the then Minister statement he made on behalf of the then Minister of statement he made on behalf of the then Minister of Finance, statement he made on behalf of the then Minister of Finance, "we statement he made on behalf of the then Minister of Finance, "we have statement he made on behalf of the then Minister of Finance, "we have a then Minister of Finance, "we have a very then Minister of Finance, "we have a very ambitious then Minister of Finance, "we have a very ambitious target then Minister of Finance, "we have a very ambitious target for then Minister of Finance, "we have a very ambitious target for export very ambitious target for export growth"; very ambitious target for export growth"; if very ambitious target for export growth"; if so, very ambitious target for export growth"; if so, what very ambitious target for export growth"; if so, what progress very ambitious target for export growth"; if so, what progress has growth"; if so, what progress has been growth"; if so, what progress has been made growth"; if so, what progress has been made towards growth"; if so, what progress has been made towards that growth"; if so, what progress has been made towards that target? Yes, Yes, it Yes, it is Yes, it is an Yes, it is an ambitious Yes, it is an ambitious target Yes, it is an ambitious target the Yes, it is an ambitious target the Government Yes, it is an ambitious target the Government is Yes, it is an ambitious target the Government is committed Yes, it is an ambitious target the Government is committed to Yes, it is an ambitious target the Government is committed to under Yes, it is an ambitious target the Government is committed to under the Government is committed to under the business Government is committed to under the business growth Government is committed to under the business growth agenda Government is committed to under the business growth agenda by Government is committed to under the business growth agenda by 2015, business growth agenda by 2015, which business growth agenda by 2015, which I business growth agenda by 2015, which I remind business growth agenda by 2015, which I remind the business growth agenda by 2015, which I remind the member business growth agenda by 2015, which I remind the member is business growth agenda by 2015, which I remind the member is just which I remind the member is just which I remind the member is just which I remind the member is just eight years which I remind the member is just eight years ago. which I remind the member is just eight years ago. Notwithstanding eight years ago. Notwithstanding some eight years ago. Notwithstanding some current eight years ago. Notwithstanding some current headwind eight years ago. Notwithstanding some current headwind which eight years ago. Notwithstanding some current headwind which include some current headwind which include some current headwind which include some current headwind which include a decrease some current headwind which include a decrease in some current headwind which include a decrease in world some current headwind which include a decrease in world trade some current headwind which include a decrease in world trade intensity, a decrease in world trade intensity, the a decrease in world trade intensity, the big a decrease in world trade intensity, the big drop a decrease in world trade intensity, the big drop in a decrease in world trade intensity, the big drop in dairy a decrease in world trade intensity, the big drop in dairy prices a decrease in world trade intensity, the big drop in dairy prices and a decrease in world trade intensity, the big drop in dairy prices and an the big drop in dairy prices and an unscheduled the big drop in dairy prices and an unscheduled Stats the big drop in dairy prices and an unscheduled Stats New the big drop in dairy prices and an unscheduled Stats New Zealand unscheduled Stats New Zealand revision, unscheduled Stats New Zealand revision, exports unscheduled Stats New Zealand revision, exports by unscheduled Stats New Zealand revision, exports by value unscheduled Stats New Zealand revision, exports by value have revision, exports by value have grown revision, exports by value have grown and revision, exports by value have grown and real revision, exports by value have grown and real exports revision, exports by value have grown and real exports as revision, exports by value have grown and real exports as a grown and real exports as a percentage grown and real exports as a percentage of grown and real exports as a percentage of GDP grown and real exports as a percentage of GDP has grown and real exports as a percentage of GDP has held percentage of GDP has held relatively percentage of GDP has held relatively steady percentage of GDP has held relatively steady and percentage of GDP has held relatively steady and our percentage of GDP has held relatively steady and our goods percentage of GDP has held relatively steady and our goods and relatively steady and our goods and services relatively steady and our goods and services exports relatively steady and our goods and services exports have relatively steady and our goods and services exports have grown services exports have grown tremendously services exports have grown tremendously in services exports have grown tremendously in markets services exports have grown tremendously in markets where services exports have grown tremendously in markets where we tremendously in markets where we tremendously tremendously in markets where we have Free Trade tremendously in markets where we have Free Trade Agreements. have Free Trade Agreements. Supplementary have Free Trade Agreements. Supplementary question. have Free Trade Agreements. Supplementary question. Can have Free Trade Agreements. Supplementary question. Can he Supplementary question. Can he confirm Supplementary question. Can he confirm that Supplementary question. Can he confirm that the Supplementary question. Can he confirm that the export Supplementary question. Can he confirm that the export target confirm that the export target confirm that the export target confirm that the export target referred to confirm that the export target referred to in confirm that the export target referred to in the confirm that the export target referred to in the primary confirm that the export target referred to in the primary question referred to in the primary question was referred to in the primary question was that referred to in the primary question was that his referred to in the primary question was that his Government referred to in the primary question was that his Government would referred to in the primary question was that his Government would lift was that his Government would lift exports was that his Government would lift exports from was that his Government would lift exports from 30% was that his Government would lift exports from 30% to was that his Government would lift exports from 30% to 40% was that his Government would lift exports from 30% to 40% of was that his Government would lift exports from 30% to 40% of GDP was that his Government would lift exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and that exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and that using exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and that using the exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and that using the methodology exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and that using the methodology used exports from 30% to 40% of GDP and that using the methodology used in that using the methodology used in The that using the methodology used in The Business that using the methodology used in The Business Growth that using the methodology used in The Business Growth Agenda that using the methodology used in The Business Growth Agenda exports The Business Growth Agenda exports have, The Business Growth Agenda exports have, in The Business Growth Agenda exports have, in fact, The Business Growth Agenda exports have, in fact, decreased The Business Growth Agenda exports have, in fact, decreased as The Business Growth Agenda exports have, in fact, decreased as a have, in fact, decreased as a percentage have, in fact, decreased as a percentage of have, in fact, decreased as a percentage of GDP? have, in fact, decreased as a percentage of GDP? Mr have, in fact, decreased as a percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, have, in fact, decreased as a percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in terms of percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in terms of the percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in terms of the first percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in terms of the first part percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in terms of the first part of percentage of GDP? Mr Speaker, in terms of the first part of the terms of the first part of the question, terms of the first part of the question, that terms of the first part of the question, that is terms of the first part of the question, that is the terms of the first part of the question, that is the target terms of the first part of the question, that is the target to terms of the first part of the question, that is the target to be question, that is the target to be achieved question, that is the target to be achieved by question, that is the target to be achieved by 2025. question, that is the target to be achieved by 2025. In question, that is the target to be achieved by 2025. In terms question, that is the target to be achieved by 2025. In terms of question, that is the target to be achieved by 2025. In terms of the achieved by 2025. In terms of the second achieved by 2025. In terms of the second part achieved by 2025. In terms of the second part of achieved by 2025. In terms of the second part of the achieved by 2025. In terms of the second part of the question, achieved by 2025. In terms of the second part of the question, real second part of the question, real exports, second part of the question, real exports, as second part of the question, real exports, as a second part of the question, real exports, as a percentage second part of the question, real exports, as a percentage of second part of the question, real exports, as a percentage of GDP, exports, as a percentage of GDP, which exports, as a percentage of GDP, which is exports, as a percentage of GDP, which is the exports, as a percentage of GDP, which is the figure exports, as a percentage of GDP, which is the figure I exports, as a percentage of GDP, which is the figure I am exports, as a percentage of GDP, which is the figure I am referring which is the figure I am referring to which is the figure I am referring to have which is the figure I am referring to have dropped which is the figure I am referring to have dropped slightly which is the figure I am referring to have dropped slightly in which is the figure I am referring to have dropped slightly in the which is the figure I am referring to have dropped slightly in the last to have dropped slightly in the last calendar to have dropped slightly in the last calendar year to have dropped slightly in the last calendar year but to have dropped slightly in the last calendar year but have to have dropped slightly in the last calendar year but have been calendar year but have been remarkably calendar year but have been remarkably steady calendar year but have been remarkably steady over calendar year but have been remarkably steady over the calendar year but have been remarkably steady over the past calendar year but have been remarkably steady over the past 10 remarkably steady over the past 10 or remarkably steady over the past 10 or 12 remarkably steady over the past 10 or 12 years remarkably steady over the past 10 or 12 years and remarkably steady over the past 10 or 12 years and I remarkably steady over the past 10 or 12 years and I think remarkably steady over the past 10 or 12 years and I think the or 12 years and I think the achievement or 12 years and I think the achievement for or 12 years and I think the achievement for our or 12 years and I think the achievement for our exporters or 12 years and I think the achievement for our exporters has achievement for our exporters has been achievement for our exporters has been despite achievement for our exporters has been despite a achievement for our exporters has been despite a large achievement for our exporters has been despite a large drop achievement for our exporters has been despite a large drop in achievement for our exporters has been despite a large drop in dairy been despite a large drop in dairy exports, been despite a large drop in dairy exports, the been despite a large drop in dairy exports, the exports been despite a large drop in dairy exports, the exports overall been despite a large drop in dairy exports, the exports overall have exports, the exports overall have grown. exports, the exports overall have grown. Supplementary exports, the exports overall have grown. Supplementary question. exports, the exports overall have grown. Supplementary question. Why grown. Supplementary question. Why has grown. Supplementary question. Why has the grown. Supplementary question. Why has the value grown. Supplementary question. Why has the value of grown. Supplementary question. Why has the value of New grown. Supplementary question. Why has the value of New Zealand's has the value of New Zealand's has the value of New Zealand's has the value of New Zealand's overseas merchandise has the value of New Zealand's overseas merchandise trade has the value of New Zealand's overseas merchandise trade fallen has the value of New Zealand's overseas merchandise trade fallen in overseas merchandise trade fallen in real overseas merchandise trade fallen in real terms overseas merchandise trade fallen in real terms by overseas merchandise trade fallen in real terms by $603 overseas merchandise trade fallen in real terms by $603 million overseas merchandise trade fallen in real terms by $603 million since real terms by $603 million since 2008? real terms by $603 million since 2008? In real terms by $603 million since 2008? In the real terms by $603 million since 2008? In the modern real terms by $603 million since 2008? In the modern world real terms by $603 million since 2008? In the modern world we real terms by $603 million since 2008? In the modern world we don't 2008? In the modern world we don't just 2008? In the modern world we don't just talk 2008? In the modern world we don't just talk about 2008? In the modern world we don't just talk about merchandise 2008? In the modern world we don't just talk about merchandise trade, just talk about merchandise trade, just talk about merchandise trade, just talk about merchandise trade, we talk just talk about merchandise trade, we talk about just talk about merchandise trade, we talk about goods just talk about merchandise trade, we talk about goods and just talk about merchandise trade, we talk about goods and services. just talk about merchandise trade, we talk about goods and services. In we talk about goods and services. In fact, we talk about goods and services. In fact, for we talk about goods and services. In fact, for the we talk about goods and services. In fact, for the member's we talk about goods and services. In fact, for the member's benefit, we talk about goods and services. In fact, for the member's benefit, more we talk about goods and services. In we we talk about goods and services. In and more of we talk about goods and services. In and more of New we talk about goods and services. In and more of New Zealand's we talk about goods and services. In and more of New Zealand's exports and more of New Zealand's exports have and more of New Zealand's exports have now and more of New Zealand's exports have now in and more of New Zealand's exports have now in services and more of New Zealand's exports have now in services rather and more of New Zealand's exports have now in services rather than and more of New Zealand's exports have now in services rather than in have now in services rather than in goods, have now in services rather than in have have now in services rather than in goods, which is have now in services rather than in goods, which is all have now in services rather than in goods, which is all about have now in services rather than in goods, which is all about adding goods, which is all about adding value goods, which is all about adding value to goods, which is all about adding value to volume, goods, which is all about adding value to volume, which goods, which is all about adding value to volume, which I goods, which is all about adding value to volume, which I think goods, which is all about adding value to volume, which I think the value to volume, which I think the member value to volume, which I think the value value to volume, which I think the member used to be value to volume, which I think the member used to be in value to volume, which I think the member used to be in favour value to volume, which I think the member used to be in favour of. value to volume, which I think the member used to be in favour of. So, member used to be in favour of. So, Mr member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, over member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, over all member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, over all our member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, over all our exports member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, over all our exports - member used to be in favour of. So, Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I don't Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I don't have Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I don't have the Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I don't have the figures Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I don't have the figures since Mr Speaker, over all our exports - I don't have the figures since 2008 don't have the figures since 2008 but don't have the figures since 2008 but overall don't have the figures since 2008 but overall our don't have the figures since 2008 but overall our exports don't have the figures since 2008 but overall our exports in don't have the figures since 2008 but overall our exports in the don't have the figures since 2008 but overall our exports in the last but overall our exports in the last 2.5 but overall our exports in the last 2.5 years but overall our exports in the last 2.5 years have but overall our exports in the last 2.5 years have grown but overall our exports in the last 2.5 years have grown from but overall our exports in the last 2.5 years have grown from just but overall our exports in the last 2.5 years have grown from just under 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million to 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million to $70 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million to $70 -- 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million to $70 -- $68 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion 2.5 years have grown from just under $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 billion $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 billion despite $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 billion despite a $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 billion despite a drop $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 billion despite a drop of $68 million to $70 -- $68 billion to $70 billion despite a drop of $5 $70 billion despite a drop of $5 billion $70 billion despite a drop of $5 billion in $70 billion despite a drop of $5 billion in dairy $70 billion despite a drop of $5 billion in dairy exports. $70 billion despite a drop of $5 billion in dairy exports. Why $70 billion despite a drop of $5 billion in dairy exports. Why was billion in dairy exports. Why was billion in dairy exports. Why was billion in dairy exports. Why was the target billion in dairy exports. Why was the target to billion in dairy exports. Why was the target to lift billion in dairy exports. Why was the target to lift exports billion in dairy exports. Why was the target to lift exports to billion in dairy exports. Why was the target to lift exports to 40% billion in dairy exports. Why was the target to lift exports to 40% of the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP not the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP not included the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP not included in the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP not included in the the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP not included in the trade the target to lift exports to 40% of GDP not included in the trade agenda GDP not included in the trade agenda 2030 GDP not included in the trade agenda 2030 policy GDP not included in the trade agenda 2030 policy announced GDP not included in the trade agenda 2030 policy announced recently by 2030 policy announced recently by the 2030 policy announced recently by the Government? 2030 policy announced recently by the Government? It 2030 policy announced recently by the Government? It is 2030 policy announced recently by the Government? It is included 2030 policy announced recently by the Government? It is included in the Government? It is included in the the Government? It is included in the business the Government? It is included in the business growth the Government? It is included in the business growth agenda the Government? It is included in the business growth agenda targets the business growth agenda targets and the business growth agenda targets and will the business growth agenda targets and will be the business growth agenda targets and will be in the business growth agenda targets and will be in the the business growth agenda targets and will be in the next the business growth agenda targets and will be in the next update. and will be in the next update. Train and will be in the next update. Train spotting and will be in the next update. Train spotting again. and will be in the next update. Train spotting again. Order! and will be in the next update. Train spotting again. Order! When and will be in the next update. Train spotting again. Order! When he Train spotting again. Order! When he was Train spotting again. Order! When he was asked Train spotting again. Order! When he was asked in Train spotting again. Order! When he was asked in February Train spotting again. Order! When he was asked in February what Train spotting again. Order! When he was asked in February what had was asked in February what had happened was asked in February what had happened to was asked in February what had happened to the was asked in February what had happened to the target was asked in February what had happened to the target to was asked in February what had happened to the target to lift happened to the target to lift exports happened to the target to lift exports as happened to the target to lift exports as a happened to the target to lift exports as a percentage happened to the target to lift exports as a percentage of happened to the target to lift exports as a percentage of GDP happened to the target to lift exports as a percentage of GDP and exports as a percentage of GDP and he exports as a percentage of GDP and he said exports as a percentage of GDP and he said "watch exports as a percentage of GDP and he said "watch this exports as a percentage of GDP and he said "watch this space", exports as a percentage of GDP and he said "watch this space", did exports as a percentage of GDP and he said "watch this space", did he he said "watch this space", did he mean he said "watch this space", did he mean literally he said "watch this space", did he mean literally that he said "watch this space", did he mean literally that there he said "watch this space", did he mean literally that there was he said "watch this space", did he mean literally that there was now he said "watch this space", did he mean literally that there was now a mean literally that there was now a void mean literally that there was now a void because mean literally that there was now a void because he mean literally that there was now a void because he ditched mean literally that there was now a void because he ditched the mean literally that there was now a void because he ditched the target? void because he ditched the target? That void because he ditched the target? mean void because he ditched the target? That is why void because he ditched the target? That is why the void because he ditched the target? That is why the member void because he ditched the target? That is why the member is void because he ditched the target? That is why the member is known void because he ditched the target? That is why the member is known as void because he ditched the target? That is why the member is known as a That is why the member is known as a train That is why the member is known as a train spotter. That is why the member is known as a train spotter. He That is why the member is known as a train spotter. He is That is why the member is known as a train spotter. He is an That is why the member is known as a train spotter. He is an absolute train spotter. He is an absolute train train spotter. He is an absolute train spotter. train spotter. He is an absolute train spotter. He train spotter. He is an absolute train spotter. He does train spotter. He is an absolute train spotter. He does not train spotter. He is an absolute train spotter. He does not actually train spotter. He does not actually focus train spotter. He does not actually focus on train spotter. He does not actually focus on the train spotter. He does not actually focus on the substance train spotter. He does not actually focus on the substance of train spotter. He does not actually focus on the substance of anything. focus on the substance of anything. He focus on the substance of anything. He literally focus on the substance of anything. He literally looks focus on the substance of anything. He literally looks at focus on the substance of anything. He literally looks at little focus on the substance of anything. He literally looks at little bits focus on the substance of anything. He literally looks at little bits of He literally looks at little bits of paper He literally looks at little bits of paper all He literally looks at little bits of paper all day He literally looks at little bits of paper all day and He literally looks at little bits of paper all day and tries He literally looks at little bits of paper all day and tries to He literally looks at little bits of paper all day and tries to work He literally looks at little bits of paper all day and tries to work out paper all day and tries to work out where paper all day and tries to work out where the paper all day and tries to work out where the inconsistency paper all day and tries to work out where the inconsistency is paper all day and tries to work out where the inconsistency is and, paper all day and tries to work out where the inconsistency is and, Mr where the inconsistency is and, Mr Speaker, where the inconsistency is and, Mr Speaker, this where the inconsistency is and, Mr Speaker, this Government where the inconsistency is and, Mr Speaker, this Government is where the inconsistency is and, Mr Speaker, this Government is proud where the inconsistency is and, Mr Speaker, this Government is proud of Speaker, this Government is proud of its Speaker, this Government is proud of its record, Speaker, this Government is proud of its record, which Speaker, this Government is proud of its record, which has Speaker, this Government is proud of its record, which has seen Speaker, this Government is proud of its record, which has seen exports its record, which has seen exports grow its record, which has seen exports grow at its record, which has seen exports grow at the its record, which has seen exports grow at the same its record, which has seen exports grow at the same time its record, which has seen exports grow at the same time as its record, which has seen exports grow at the same time as the its record, which has seen exports grow at the same time as the dairy grow at the same time as the dairy industry grow at the same time as the dairy industry has grow at the same time as the dairy industry has gone grow at the same time as the dairy industry has gone back grow at the same time as the dairy industry has gone back $5 grow at the same time as the dairy industry has gone back $5 billion. industry has gone back $5 billion. Now industry has gone back $5 billion. Now the industry has gone back $5 billion. Now the member industry has gone back $5 billion. Now the member might industry has gone back $5 billion. Now the member might recall industry has gone back $5 billion. Now the member might recall that industry has gone back $5 billion. Now the member might recall that a Now the member might recall that a couple Now the member might recall that a couple of Now the member might recall that a couple of years Now the member might recall that a couple of years ago Now the member might recall that a couple of years ago he Now the member might recall that a couple of years ago he thought Now the member might recall that a couple of years ago he thought that couple of years ago he thought that would couple of years ago he thought that would mean couple of years ago he thought that would mean - couple of years ago he thought that would mean - the couple of years ago he thought that would mean - the dairy couple of years ago he thought that would mean - the dairy industry would mean - the dairy industry declining would mean - the dairy industry declining would would mean - the dairy industry declining would mean would mean - the dairy industry declining would mean the would mean - the dairy industry declining would mean the end would mean - the dairy industry declining would mean the end of would mean - the dairy industry declining would mean the end of New declining would mean the end of New declining would mean the end of New declining would mean the end of New Zealand exports. declining would mean the end of New Zealand exports. He declining would mean the end of New Zealand exports. He was declining would mean the end of New Zealand exports. He was wrong. declining would mean the end of New Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. I Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. I seek Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. I seek leave Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. I seek leave of Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. I seek leave of the Zealand exports. He was wrong. Point of order. I seek leave of the House of order. I seek leave of the House to of order. I seek leave of the House to table of order. I seek leave of the House to table a of order. I seek leave of the House to table a document of order. I seek leave of the House to table a document compiled of order. I seek leave of the House to table a document compiled by of order. I seek leave of the House to table a document compiled by the to table a document compiled by the parliamentary to table a document compiled by the parliamentary library to table a document compiled by the parliamentary library tracking parliamentary library tracking parliamentary library tracking parliamentary library tracking exports of parliamentary library tracking exports of goods parliamentary library tracking exports of goods and parliamentary library tracking exports of goods and services parliamentary library tracking exports of goods and services as parliamentary library tracking exports of goods and services as a exports of goods and services as a percentage exports of goods and services as a percentage of exports of goods and services as a percentage of GDP exports of goods and services as a percentage of GDP showing exports of goods and services as a percentage of GDP showing that exports of goods and services as a percentage of GDP showing that it percentage of GDP showing that it has percentage of GDP showing that it has dropped percentage of GDP showing that it has dropped since... percentage of GDP showing that it has dropped since... Leave percentage of GDP showing that it has dropped since... Leave is percentage of GDP showing that it has dropped since... Leave is sought has dropped since... Leave is sought to has dropped since... Leave is sought to table has dropped since... Leave is sought to table that has dropped since... Leave is sought to table that particular to table that particular information. to table that particular information. Is to table that particular information. Is there to table that particular information. Is there objection? to table that particular information. Is there objection? I to table that particular information. to table that particular just wanted to to table that particular just wanted to check to table that particular just wanted to check whether to table that particular just wanted to check whether it to table that particular just wanted to check whether it was just wanted to check whether it was real just wanted to check whether it was real or just wanted to check whether it was real or nominal? just wanted to check whether it was real or nominal? It just wanted to check whether it was real or nominal? It is just wanted to check whether it was real or nominal? It is real. just wanted to check whether it was real or nominal? It is real. I just wanted to check whether it was real or nominal? It is real. I will real or nominal? It is real. I will put real or nominal? It is real. I will put the real or nominal? It is real. I will put the leave real or nominal? It is real. I will put the leave and real or nominal? It is real. I will put the leave and the real or nominal? It is real. I will put the leave and the House real or nominal? It is real. I will put the leave and the House will put the leave and the House will decide. put the leave and the House will decide. Leave put the leave and the House will decide. Leave is put the leave and the House will decide. Leave is sought put the leave and the House will decide. Leave is sought to put the leave and the House will decide. Leave is sought to table put the leave and the House will decide. Leave is sought to table it. decide. Leave is sought to table it. Is decide. Leave is sought to table it. Is there decide. Leave is sought to table it. Is there any decide. Leave is sought to table it. Is there any objection? decide. Leave is sought to table it. Is there any objection? No Is there any objection? No objection. Is there any objection? No objection. It Is there any objection? No objection. It can Is there any objection? No objection. It can be Is there any objection? No objection. It can be tabled. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Building My question is to the Minister for Building and My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does he Building and Construction: Does he agree Building and Construction: Does he agree with Building and Construction: Does he agree with Liam Building and Construction: Does he agree with Liam Dann Building and Construction: Does he agree with Liam Dann in Building and Construction: Does he agree with Liam Dann in the Building and Construction: Does he agree with Liam Dann in the New agree with Liam Dann in the New Zealand agree with Liam Dann in the New Zealand Herald agree with Liam Dann in the New Zealand Herald that agree with Liam Dann in the New Zealand Herald that "Young agree with Liam Dann in the New Zealand Herald that "Young house Zealand Herald that "Young house hunters Zealand Herald that "Young house hunters should Zealand Herald that "Young house hunters should just Zealand Herald that "Young house hunters should just give Zealand Herald that "Young house hunters should just give up"; Zealand Herald that "Young house hunters should just give up"; if hunters should just give up"; if not, hunters should just give up"; if not, why hunters should just give up"; if not, why not? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the Minister On behalf of the Minister for On behalf of the Minister for Building On behalf of the Minister for Building and On behalf of the Minister for Building and Construction, On behalf of the Minister for Building and Construction, no, On behalf of the Minister for Building and Construction, no, for On behalf of the Minister for Building and Construction, no, for a Building and Construction, no, for a number Building and Construction, no, for a number of Building and Construction, no, for a number of reasons. Building and Construction, no, for a number of reasons. Firstly Building and Construction, no, for a number of reasons. Firstly because number of reasons. Firstly because the number of reasons. Firstly because the Auckland number of reasons. Firstly because the Auckland market number of reasons. Firstly because the Auckland market is number of reasons. Firstly because the Auckland market is easing number of reasons. Firstly because the Auckland market is easing and number of reasons. Firstly because the Auckland market is easing and we the Auckland market is easing and we have the Auckland market is easing and we have seen the Auckland market is easing and we have seen median the Auckland market is easing and we have seen median house the Auckland market is easing and we have seen median house prices the Auckland market is easing and we have seen median house prices in have seen median house prices in Auckland have seen median house prices in Auckland fall have seen median house prices in Auckland fall 8.5% have seen median house prices in Auckland fall 8.5% since have seen median house prices in Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, we Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, we are Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, we are in Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, we are in the Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, we are in the middle Auckland fall 8.5% since October. Secondly, we are in the middle of Secondly, we are in the middle of the Secondly, we are in the middle of the longest, Secondly, we are in the middle of the longest, strongest Secondly, we are in the middle of the longest, strongest boom, the longest, strongest boom, Auckland the longest, strongest boom, Auckland has the longest, strongest boom, Auckland has ever the longest, strongest boom, Auckland has ever seen the longest, strongest boom, Auckland has ever seen and the longest, strongest boom, Auckland has ever seen and only Auckland has ever seen and only today Auckland has ever seen and only today Colliers Auckland has ever seen and only today Colliers reported Auckland has ever seen and only today Colliers reported 2,770 today Colliers reported 2,770 today Colliers reported 2,770 today Colliers reported 2,770 apartments are today Colliers reported 2,770 apartments are due today Colliers reported 2,770 apartments are due to today Colliers reported 2,770 apartments are due to be today Colliers reported 2,770 apartments are due to be completed apartments are due to be completed this apartments are due to be completed this year, apartments are due to be completed this year, the apartments are due to be completed this year, the highest apartments are due to be completed this year, the highest since apartments are due to be completed this year, the highest since 2005, this year, the highest since 2005, with this year, the highest since 2005, with 3,840 this year, the highest since 2005, with 3,840 apartments this year, the highest since 2005, with 3,840 apartments expected this year, the highest since 2005, with 3,840 apartments expected next with 3,840 apartments expected next year. with 3,840 apartments expected next year. Thirdly, with 3,840 apartments expected next year. Thirdly, the with 3,840 apartments expected next year. Thirdly, the HomeStart with 3,840 apartments expected next year. Thirdly, the HomeStart grants year. Thirdly, the HomeStart grants scheme, year. Thirdly, the HomeStart grants scheme, the year. Thirdly, the HomeStart grants scheme, the most year. Thirdly, the HomeStart grants scheme, the most generous year. Thirdly, the HomeStart grants scheme, the most generous support scheme, the most generous support scheme, the most generous support scheme, the most generous support for first scheme, the most generous support for first home scheme, the most generous support for first home buyers scheme, the most generous support for first home buyers in scheme, the most generous support for first home buyers in a for first home buyers in a generation, for first home buyers in a generation, has for first home buyers in a generation, has provided for first home buyers in a generation, has provided almost for first home buyers in a generation, has provided almost $130 generation, has provided almost $130 million generation, has provided almost $130 million in generation, has provided almost $130 million in grants generation, has provided almost $130 million in grants that generation, has provided almost $130 million in grants that have generation, has provided almost $130 million in grants that have helped million in grants that have helped over million in grants that have helped over 27,000 million in grants that have helped over 27,000 people million in grants that have helped over 27,000 people into million in grants that have helped over 27,000 people into their million in grants that have helped over 27,000 people into their first over 27,000 people into their first home, over 27,000 people into their first home, about over 27,000 people into their first home, about 2.5,000 over 27,000 people into their first home, about 2.5,000 of over 27,000 people into their first home, about 2.5,000 of them over 27,000 people into their first home, about 2.5,000 of them in home, about 2.5,000 of them in Auckland. home, about 2.5,000 of them in Auckland. I home, about 2.5,000 of them in Auckland. I know home, about 2.5,000 of them in Auckland. I know that home, about 2.5,000 of them in Auckland. I know that there home, about 2.5,000 of them in Auckland. I know that there are Auckland. I know that there are currently Auckland. I know that there are currently over Auckland. I know that there are currently over 1,800 Auckland. I know that there are currently over 1,800 listings Auckland. I know that there are currently over 1,800 listings on currently over 1,800 listings on trademan currently over 1,800 listings on trademan Auckland currently over 1,800 listings on trademan Auckland for currently over 1,800 listings on trademan Auckland for properties trademan Auckland for properties trademan Auckland for properties trademan Auckland for properties listed under trademan Auckland for properties listed under $600,000. trademan Auckland for properties listed under $600,000. Supplementary listed under $600,000. Supplementary question. listed under $600,000. Supplementary question. With listed under $600,000. Supplementary question. With respect listed under $600,000. Supplementary question. With respect to listed under $600,000. Supplementary question. With respect to the listed under $600,000. Supplementary question. With respect to the number question. With respect to the number of question. With respect to the number of homes question. With respect to the number of homes being question. With respect to the number of homes being built, question. With respect to the number of homes being built, does question. With respect to the number of homes being built, does the of homes being built, does the minister of homes being built, does the minister agree of homes being built, does the minister agree that of homes being built, does the minister agree that the of homes being built, does the minister agree that the current minister agree that the current so-called minister agree that the current so-called house minister agree that the current so-called house building minister agree that the current so-called house building boom minister agree that the current so-called house building boom still so-called house building boom still gives so-called house building boom still gives us so-called house building boom still gives us a so-called house building boom still gives us a lower so-called house building boom still gives us a lower number so-called house building boom still gives us a lower number of so-called house building boom still gives us a lower number of homes gives us a lower number of homes built gives us a lower number of homes built per gives us a lower number of homes built per capita gives us a lower number of homes built per capita than gives us a lower number of homes built per capita than any gives us a lower number of homes built per capita than any of gives us a lower number of homes built per capita than any of the built per capita than any of the built per capita than any of the built per capita than any of the decades in built per capita than any of the decades in the built per capita than any of the decades in the 1970s, built per capita than any of the decades in the 1970s, 1980s, built per capita than any of the decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the 2000s? decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the 2000s? On decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the 2000s? On by decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the 2000s? On by half decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the 2000s? On by half of decades in the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s or the 2000s? On by half of the or the 2000s? On by half of the minister or the 2000s? On by half of the minister of build -- or the 2000s? On by half of the minister of build -- on or the 2000s? On by half of the minister of build -- on behalf or the 2000s? On by half of the minister of build -- on behalf of minister of build -- on behalf of minister of build -- on behalf of minister of build -- on behalf of the Minister minister of build -- on behalf of the Minister for minister of build -- on behalf of the Minister for Building minister of build -- on behalf of the Minister for Building and the Minister for Building and the Minister for Building and the Minister for Building and Construction, I the Minister for Building and Construction, I haven't the Minister for Building and Construction, I haven't had the Minister for Building and Construction, I haven't had an Construction, I haven't had an Construction, I haven't had an Construction, I haven't had an opportunity to Construction, I haven't had an opportunity to study Construction, I haven't had an opportunity to study the Construction, I haven't had an opportunity to study the data Construction, I haven't had an opportunity to study the data he Construction, I haven't had an opportunity to study the data he is opportunity to study the data he is referring opportunity to study the data he is referring to opportunity to study the data he is referring to but opportunity to study the data he is referring to but the opportunity to study the data he is referring to but the number opportunity to study the data he is referring to but the number of referring to but the number of houses referring to but the number of houses being referring to but the number of houses being built referring to but the number of houses being built in referring to but the number of houses being built in Auckland referring to but the number of houses being built in Auckland at houses being built in Auckland at houses being built in Auckland at houses being built in Auckland at the moment houses being built in Auckland at the moment of houses being built in Auckland at the moment of 10,000 houses being built in Auckland at the moment of 10,000 a houses being built in Auckland at the moment of 10,000 a year houses being built in Auckland at the moment of 10,000 a year is houses being built in Auckland at the moment of 10,000 a year is the the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest in the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest in 10 the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest in 10 years the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest in 10 years and, the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest in 10 years and, sir, the moment of 10,000 a year is the highest in 10 years and, sir, the highest in 10 years and, sir, the work highest in 10 years and, sir, the work that highest in 10 years and, sir, the work that this highest in 10 years and, sir, the work that this Government highest in 10 years and, sir, the work that this Government has highest in 10 years and, sir, the work that this Government has done work that this Government has done work that this Government has done work that this Government has done around freeing work that this Government has done around freeing up work that this Government has done around freeing up land work that this Government has done around freeing up land supply, around freeing up land supply, around around freeing up land supply, around supporting around freeing up land supply, around supporting housing around freeing up land supply, around supporting housing projects, around freeing up land supply, it is around freeing up land supply, it is a around freeing up land supply, it is a big around freeing up land supply, it is a big part around freeing up land supply, it is a big part of around freeing up land supply, it is a big part of the around freeing up land supply, it is a big part of the reason around freeing up land supply, it is a big part of the reason for it is a big part of the reason for that it is a big part of the reason for that growth it is a big part of the reason for that growth but it is a big part of the reason for that growth but we it is a big part of the reason for that growth but we could it is a big part of the reason for that growth but we could move it is a big part of the reason for that growth but we could move a it is a big part of the reason for that growth but we could move a lot that growth but we could move a lot faster that growth but we could move a lot it that growth but we could move a lot faster if there that growth but we could move a lot faster if there was that growth but we could move a lot faster if there was more that growth but we could move a lot faster if there was more support faster if there was more support faster if there was more support faster if there was more support across communities faster if there was more support across communities in faster if there was more support across communities in this faster if there was more support across communities in this House. across communities in this House. Supplementary across communities in this House. Supplementary question. across communities in this House. Supplementary question. Is across communities in this House. Supplementary question. Is it across communities in this House. Supplementary question. Is it wrong Supplementary question. Is it wrong Supplementary question. Is it wrong Supplementary question. Is it wrong to say Supplementary question. Is it wrong to say that Supplementary question. Is it wrong to say that New Supplementary question. Is it wrong to say that New Zealand Supplementary question. Is it wrong to say that New Zealand has to say that New Zealand has underbuilt to say that New Zealand has underbuilt to to say that New Zealand has underbuilt to the to say that New Zealand has underbuilt to the tune to say that New Zealand has underbuilt to the tune of to say that New Zealand has underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 houses and underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 houses and if underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 houses and if not, underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 houses and if not, why underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 houses and if not, why not? underbuilt to the tune of 500,000 houses and if not, why not? On houses and if not, why not? On behalf houses and if not, why not? On behalf of houses and if not, why not? On behalf of the houses and if not, why not? On behalf of the minister houses and if not, why not? On behalf of the minister of houses and if not, why not? On behalf of the minister of building behalf of the minister of building an behalf of the minister of building an construction, behalf of the minister of building an construction, what behalf of the minister of building an construction, what I behalf of the minister of building an construction, what I would behalf of the minister of building an construction, what I would say behalf of the minister of building an construction, what I would say is an construction, what I would say is that an construction, what I would say is that this an construction, what I would say is that this is an construction, what I would say is that this is a an construction, what I would say is that this is a Government an construction, what I would say is that this is a Government that an construction, what I would say is that this is a Government that is that this is a Government that is doing that this is a Government that is doing everything that this is a Government that is doing everything it that this is a Government that is doing everything it can that this is a Government that is doing everything it can to that this is a Government that is doing everything it can to see that this is a Government that is doing everything it can to see more doing everything it can to see more houses doing everything it can to see more houses being doing everything it can to see more houses being built doing everything it can to see more houses being built which doing everything it can to see more houses being built which is doing everything it can to see more houses being built which is why doing everything it can to see more houses being built which is why the houses being built which is why the houses being built which is why the houses being built which is why the number has houses being built which is why the number has almost houses being built which is why the number has almost doubled houses being built which is why the number has almost doubled since houses being built which is why the number has almost doubled since we number has almost doubled since we have number has almost doubled since we have been number has almost doubled since we have been in number has almost doubled since we have been in government number has almost doubled since we have been in government and number has almost doubled since we have been in government and if number has almost doubled since we have been in government and if it have been in government and if it wasn't have been in government and if it wasn't for have been in government and if it wasn't for opposition have been in government and if it wasn't for opposition across have been in government and if it wasn't for opposition across this wasn't for opposition across this House wasn't for opposition across this House and wasn't for opposition across this House and communities wasn't for opposition across this House and communities to wasn't for opposition across this House and communities to things wasn't for opposition across this House and communities to things like House and communities to things like the House and communities to things like the RMA House and communities to things like the RMA reform House and communities to things like the RMA reform and House and communities to things like the RMA reform and things House and communities to things like the RMA reform and things like House and communities to things like the RMA reform and things like the the RMA reform and things like the Special the RMA reform and things like the Special Housing the RMA reform and things like the Special Housing Areas the RMA reform and things like the Special Housing Areas and the RMA reform and things like the Special Housing Areas and things Special Housing Areas and things like Special Housing Areas and things like three Special Housing Areas and things like three Kings Special Housing Areas and things like three Kings and Special Housing Areas and things like three Kings and point Special Housing Areas and things like three Kings and point England like three Kings and point England we like three Kings and point England we would like three Kings and point England we would see like three Kings and point England we would see more like three Kings and point England we would see more houses like three Kings and point England we would see more houses being like three Kings and point England we would see more houses being built we would see more houses being built even we would see more houses being built even faster. we would see more houses being built even faster. Thanks we would see more houses being built even faster. Thanks to we would see more houses being built even faster. Thanks to this even faster. Thanks to this even faster. Thanks to this even faster. Thanks to this Government we even faster. Thanks to this Government we are even faster. Thanks to this Government we are seeing even faster. Thanks to this Government we are seeing more even faster. Thanks to this Government we are seeing more built Government we are seeing more built in Government we are seeing more built in Auckland Government we are seeing more built in Auckland than Government we are seeing more built in Auckland than we Government we are seeing more built in Auckland than we have Government we are seeing more built in Auckland than we have for Government we are seeing more built in Auckland than we have for 10 in Auckland than we have for 10 years. in Auckland than we have for 10 years. Supplementary in Auckland than we have for 10 years. Supplementary question. in Auckland than we have for 10 years. Supplementary question. With years. Supplementary question. With respect years. Supplementary question. With respect to years. Supplementary question. With respect to RMA years. Supplementary question. With respect to RMA reform, years. Supplementary question. With respect to RMA reform, is years. Supplementary question. With respect to RMA reform, is the respect to RMA reform, is the respect to RMA reform, is the respect to RMA reform, is the minister disappointed respect to RMA reform, is the minister disappointed that respect to RMA reform, is the minister disappointed that his respect to RMA reform, is the minister disappointed that his own minister disappointed that his own Government minister disappointed that his own Government ended minister disappointed that his own Government ended up minister disappointed that his own Government ended up voting minister disappointed that his own Government ended up voting against Government ended up voting against many Government ended up voting against many of Government ended up voting against many of Amy Government ended up voting against many of Amy Adams' Government ended up voting against many of Amy Adams' most Government ended up voting against many of Amy Adams' most important many of Amy Adams' most important proposed many of Amy Adams' most important proposed reforms many of Amy Adams' most important proposed reforms that many of Amy Adams' most important proposed reforms that I many of Amy Adams' most important proposed reforms that I put many of Amy Adams' most important proposed reforms that I put up many of Amy Adams' most important proposed reforms that I put up in proposed reforms that I put up in the proposed reforms that I put up in the RMA proposed reforms that I put up in the RMA bill proposed reforms that I put up in the RMA bill as proposed reforms that I put up in the RMA bill as amendments proposed reforms that I put up in the RMA bill as amendments at proposed reforms that I put up in the RMA bill as amendments at the the RMA bill as amendments at the committee the RMA bill as amendments at the committee stage the RMA bill as amendments at the committee stage such the RMA bill as amendments at the committee stage such as the RMA bill as amendments at the committee stage such as recognising committee stage such as recognising the committee stage such as recognising the importance committee stage such as recognising the importance of committee stage such as recognising the importance of land committee stage such as recognising the importance of land supply, the importance of land supply, economic the importance of land supply, economic development the importance of land supply, economic development and economic development and infrastructure, economic development and infrastructure, which economic development and infrastructure, which would economic development and infrastructure, which would have infrastructure, which would have made infrastructure, which would have made it's infrastructure, which would have made it's dwror infrastructure, which would have made it's dwror build infrastructure, which would have made it's dwror build homes? infrastructure, which would have made it's dwror build homes? -- infrastructure, which would have made it's dwror build homes? -- it made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier to made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier to build made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier to build homes? made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier to build homes? What made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier to build homes? What I made it's dwror build homes? -- it easier to build homes? What I will easier to build homes? What I will easier to build homes? What I will easier to build homes? What I will say is easier to build homes? What I will say is that easier to build homes? What I will say is that this easier to build homes? What I will say is that this Government easier to build homes? What I will say is that this Government is say is that this Government is absolutely say is that this Government is absolutely confident say is that this Government is absolutely confident that say is that this Government is absolutely confident that the absolutely confident that the reforms absolutely confident that the reforms we absolutely confident that the reforms we have absolutely confident that the reforms we have passed absolutely confident that the reforms we have passed will absolutely confident that the reforms we have passed will help absolutely confident that the reforms we have passed will help to reforms we have passed will help to further reforms we have passed will help to further speed reforms we have passed will help to further speed up reforms we have passed will help to further speed up the reforms we have passed will help to further speed up the supply reforms we have passed will help to further speed up the supply of reforms we have passed will help to further speed up the supply of land further speed up the supply of land and further speed up the supply of land and houses further speed up the supply of land and houses into further speed up the supply of land and houses into both further speed up the supply of land and houses into both the further speed up the supply of land and houses into both the Auckland and houses into both the Auckland and and houses into both the Auckland and New Zealand markets. and New Zealand markets. Does and New Zealand markets. Does the and New Zealand markets. Does the minister and New Zealand markets. Does the minister have and New Zealand markets. Does the minister have any and New Zealand markets. Does the minister have any advice and New Zealand markets. Does the minister have any advice for and New Zealand markets. Does the minister have any advice for thrifty minister have any advice for thrifty young minister have any advice for thrifty young homebuyers minister have any advice for thrifty young homebuyers attempting minister have any advice for thrifty young homebuyers attempting to minister have any advice for thrifty young homebuyers attempting to save young homebuyers attempting to save father young homebuyers attempting to save father than young homebuyers attempting to save father than they young homebuyers attempting to save father than they can young homebuyers attempting to save father than they can earn young homebuyers attempting to save father than they can earn when young homebuyers attempting to save father than they can earn when the father than they can earn when the average father than they can earn when the average price father than they can earn when the average price of father than they can earn when the average price of housing father than they can earn when the average price of housing in father than they can earn when the average price of housing in Auckland average price of housing in Auckland rose average price of housing in Auckland rose by average price of housing in Auckland rose by $114,000 average price of housing in Auckland rose by $114,000 last average price of housing in Auckland rose by $114,000 last year average price of housing in Auckland rose by $114,000 last year and average price of housing in Auckland rose by $114,000 last year and is rose by $114,000 last year and is now rose by $114,000 last year and is now over rose by $114,000 last year and is now over $1 rose by $114,000 last year and is now over $1 million? rose by $114,000 last year and is now over $1 million? On rose by $114,000 last year and is now over $1 million? On be rose by $114,000 last year and is now over $1 million? On be half rose by $114,000 last year and is now over $1 million? On be half of now over $1 million? On be half of the now over $1 million? On be half of the minister now over $1 million? On be half of the minister of now over $1 million? On be half of the minister of building now over $1 million? On be half of the minister of building an the minister of building an construction, the minister of building an construction, what the minister of building an construction, what I the minister of building an construction, what I would the minister of building an construction, what I would say the minister of building an construction, what I would say to construction, what I would say to construction, what I would say to construction, what I would say to homebuyers is construction, what I would say to homebuyers is that construction, what I would say to homebuyers is that with construction, what I would say to homebuyers is that with interest homebuyers is that with interest rates homebuyers is that with interest rates at homebuyers is that with interest rates at low homebuyers is that with interest rates at low levels homebuyers is that with interest rates at low levels houses homebuyers is that with interest rates at low levels houses are homebuyers is that with interest rates at low levels houses are more rates at low levels houses are more rates at low levels houses are more rates at low levels houses are more affordable now rates at low levels houses are more affordable now than rates at low levels houses are more affordable now than they rates at low levels houses are more affordable now than they have rates at low levels houses are more affordable now than they have been affordable now than they have been rates affordable now than they have been for some time affordable now than they have been for some time and affordable now than they have been for some time and actually affordable now than they have been for some time and actually whether for some time and actually whether out for some time and actually whether out look for some time and actually whether out look at for some time and actually whether out look at the for some time and actually whether out look at the average for some time and actually whether out look at the average or for some time and actually whether out look at the average or the out look at the average or the median out look at the average or the median house out look at the average or the median house prices out look at the average or the median house prices in out look at the average or the median house prices in Auckland, median house prices in Auckland, median house prices in Auckland, median house prices in Auckland, over the median house prices in Auckland, over the last median house prices in Auckland, over the last several median house prices in Auckland, over the last several months, median house prices in Auckland, over the last several months, they over the last several months, they have over the last several months, they have been over the last several months, they have been falling, over the last several months, they have been falling, which over the last several months, they have been falling, which is over the last several months, they have been falling, which is an have been falling, which is an encouraging have been falling, which is an encouraging sign. have been falling, which is an encouraging sign. Point have been falling, which is an encouraging sign. Point of have been falling, which is an encouraging sign. Point of order. have been falling, which is an encouraging sign. Point of order. I encouraging sign. Point of order. I want encouraging sign. Point of order. I want to encouraging sign. Point of order. I want to check encouraging sign. Point of order. I want to check the encouraging sign. Point of order. I want to check the number encouraging sign. Point of order. I want to check the number of want to check the number of supplementary want to check the number of supplementary questions want to check the number of supplementary questions this want to check the number of supplementary questions this member supplementary questions this member has supplementary questions this member has been supplementary questions this member has been given. supplementary questions this member has been given. I supplementary questions this member has been given. I can't supplementary questions this member has been given. I can't believe supplementary questions this member has been given. I can't believe the has been given. I can't believe the sadism has been given. I can't believe the sadism should has been given. I can't believe the sadism should go has been given. I can't believe the sadism should go on has been given. I can't believe the sadism should go on like has been given. I can't believe the sadism should go on like it has been given. I can't believe the sadism should go on like it is. has been given. I can't believe the sadism should go on like it is. If sadism should go on like it is. If the sadism should go on like it is. If the member sadism should go on like it is. If the member using sadism should go on like it is. If the member using - sadism should go on like it is. If the member using - attempts sadism should go on like it is. If the member using - attempts to sadism should go on like it is. If the member using - attempts to use the member using - attempts to use more the member using - attempts to use more than the member using - attempts to use more than his the member using - attempts to use more than his allocation the member using - attempts to use more than his allocation I the member using - attempts to use more than his allocation I will more than his allocation I will handle more than his allocation I will handle it. Has Has thor Has thor n Has thor n enjoy Has thor n enjoy standing Has thor n enjoy standing in Has thor n enjoy standing in for Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Smith Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Smith today Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Smith today and Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Smith today and has Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Smith today and has she Has thor n enjoy standing in for Nick Smith today and has she asked Nick Smith today and has she asked the Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM if Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM if she Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM if she can Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM if she can do Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM if she can do it Nick Smith today and has she asked the PM if she can do it more the PM if she can do it more permanently the PM if she can do it more permanently as the PM if she can do it more permanently as of the PM if she can do it more permanently as of 1 the PM if she can do it more permanently as of 1 May? permanently as of 1 May? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> I <INTERRUPTION> I always <INTERRUPTION> I always enjoy <INTERRUPTION> I always enjoy being <INTERRUPTION> I always enjoy being a <INTERRUPTION> I always enjoy being a part <INTERRUPTION> I always enjoy being a part of <INTERRUPTION> I always enjoy being a part of this I always enjoy being a part of this team. I always enjoy being a part of this team. <INTERRUPTION> team. <INTERRUPTION> Order! team. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr team. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Peters, team. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Peters, you team. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Peters, you may team. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Mr Peters, you may have Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed we Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed we have Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed we have now Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed we have now a Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed we have now a point Order! Mr Peters, you may have noticed we have now a point of noticed we have now a point of order. noticed we have now a point of order. It noticed we have now a point of order. It is noticed we have now a point of order. It is meant noticed we have now a point of order. It is meant to noticed we have now a point of order. It is meant to be noticed we have now a point of order. It is meant to be heard noticed we have now a point of order. It is meant to be heard in order. It is meant to be heard in silence. order. It is meant to be heard in silence. Point order. It is meant to be heard in silence. Point of order. It is meant to be heard in silence. Point of order, order. It is meant to be heard in silence. Point of order, David silence. Point of order, David Seymour. silence. Point of order, David silence. silence. Point of order, David Seymour. Point of silence. Point of order, David Seymour. Point of order. silence. Point of order, David Seymour. Point of order. In silence. Point of order, David Seymour. Point of order. In the Seymour. Point of order. In the course Seymour. Point of order. In the course of Seymour. Point of order. In the course of some Seymour. Point of order. In the course of some of Seymour. Point of order. In the course of some of the Seymour. Point of order. In the course of some of the barracking Seymour. Point of order. In the course of some of the barracking in course of some of the barracking in this course of some of the barracking in this question, course of some of the barracking in this question, Ron course of some of the barracking in this question, Ron Mark course of some of the barracking in this question, Ron Mark called course of some of the barracking in this question, Ron Mark called me, course of some of the barracking in this question, Ron Mark called me, I this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, an this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, an idiot this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, an idiot which this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, an idiot which is this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, an idiot which is not this question, Ron Mark called me, I think, an idiot which is not only think, an idiot which is not only unparliamentary, think, an idiot which is not only unparliamentary, but think, an idiot which is not only unparliamentary, but as think, an idiot which is not only unparliamentary, but as the think, an idiot which is not only unparliamentary, but as the events unparliamentary, but as the events of unparliamentary, but as the events of today unparliamentary, but as the events of today have unparliamentary, but as the events of today have shown unparliamentary, but as the events of today have shown a unparliamentary, but as the events of today have shown a bit of today have shown a bit hypocritical! of today have shown a bit hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I was hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I was going hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I was going to hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I was going to assist hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I was going to assist the hypocritical! <INTERRUPTION> I was going to assist the member I was going to assist the member until I was going to assist the member until the I was going to assist the member until the last I was going to assist the member until the last part I was going to assist the member until the last part of I was going to assist the member until the last part of his I was going to assist the member until the last part of his point I was going to assist the member until the last part of his point of until the last part of his point of order. until the last part of his point of order. Question until the last part of his point of order. Question No. until the last part of his point of order. Question No. 10. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Veterans' My question is to the Minister of Veterans' Affairs: My question is to the Minister of Veterans' Affairs: What Veterans' Affairs: What announcements Veterans' Affairs: What announcements has Veterans' Affairs: What announcements has he Veterans' Affairs: What announcements has he made Veterans' Affairs: What announcements has he made regarding announcements has he made regarding repatriation announcements has he made regarding repatriation of announcements has he made regarding repatriation of military announcements has he made regarding repatriation of military personnel repatriation of military personnel remains? The The New The New Zealand The New Zealand Government The New Zealand Government has The New Zealand Government has announced The New Zealand Government has announced we The New Zealand Government has announced we are The New Zealand Government has announced we are giving The New Zealand Government has announced we are giving the The New Zealand Government has announced we are giving the families announced we are giving the families of announced we are giving the families of military announced we are giving the families of military personnel announced we are giving the families of military personnel and announced we are giving the families of military personnel and their of military personnel and their dependants of military personnel and their dependants the of military personnel and their dependants the opportunity of military personnel and their dependants the opportunity to dependants the opportunity to repatriate dependants the opportunity to repatriate the dependants the opportunity to repatriate the remains dependants the opportunity to repatriate the remains of dependants the opportunity to repatriate the remains of their repatriate the remains of their loved repatriate the remains of their loved ones, repatriate the remains of their loved ones, buried repatriate the remains of their loved ones, buried in repatriate the remains of their loved ones, buried in Malaysia repatriate the remains of their loved ones, buried in Malaysia and loved ones, buried in Malaysia and Singapore loved ones, buried in Malaysia and Singapore between loved ones, buried in Malaysia and Singapore between 1955 loved ones, buried in Malaysia and Singapore between 1955 and loved ones, buried in Malaysia and Singapore between 1955 and 1971. Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This decision Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This decision comes Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This decision comes as Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This decision comes as a Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This decision comes as a result Singapore between 1955 and 1971. This decision comes as a result of This decision comes as a result of recommendations This decision comes as a result of recommendations of This decision comes as a result of recommendations of the This decision comes as a result of recommendations of the veterans recommendations of the veterans Advisory recommendations of the veterans This recommendations of the veterans Advisory Board and recommendations of the veterans Advisory Board and the recommendations of the veterans Advisory Board and the advocacy recommendations of the veterans Advisory Board and the advocacy of Advisory Board and the advocacy of the Advisory Board and the advocacy of the Royal Advisory Board and the advocacy of the Royal New Advisory Board and the advocacy of the Royal New Zealand Advisory Board and the advocacy of the Royal New Zealand returned the Royal New Zealand returned services the Royal New Zealand returned services association the Royal New Zealand returned services association and the Royal New Zealand returned services association and affected services association and affected families. services association and affected families. I services association and affected families. I would services association and affected families. I would like services association and affected families. I would like to services association and affected families. I would like to especially families. I would like to especially acknowledge families. I would like to especially acknowledge the families. I would like to especially acknowledge the petition families. I would like to especially acknowledge the petition of families. I would like to especially acknowledge the petition of the acknowledge the petition of the families acknowledge the petition of the families of acknowledge the petition of the families of the acknowledge the petition of the families of the forgotten acknowledge the petition of the families of the forgotten fallen families of the forgotten fallen that families of the forgotten fallen families families of the forgotten fallen that presented to families of the forgotten fallen that presented to this families of the forgotten fallen that presented to this Parliament that presented to this Parliament last that presented to this Parliament that that presented to this Parliament last year. It that presented to this Parliament last year. It is that presented to this Parliament last year. It is about that presented to this Parliament last year. It is about making that presented to this Parliament last year. It is about making an last year. It is about making an unfair last year. It is about making an unfair situation last year. It is about making an unfair situation fair. unfair situation fair. <APPLAUSE> <APPLAUSE> . <APPLAUSE> . Order! <APPLAUSE> . Order! How <APPLAUSE> . Order! How many <APPLAUSE> . Order! How many veterans <APPLAUSE> . Order! How many veterans would <APPLAUSE> . Order! How many veterans would be . Order! How many veterans would be potentially . Order! How many veterans would be potentially included . Order! How many veterans would be potentially included in . Order! How many veterans would be potentially included in this potentially included in this announcement? potentially included in this announcement? Between potentially included in this announcement? Between 1955 potentially included in this announcement? Between 1955 and potentially included in this announcement? Between 1955 and 1971 announcement? Between 1955 and 1971 there announcement? Between 1955 and 1971 there was announcement? Between 1955 and 1971 there was inconsistency announcement? Between 1955 and 1971 there was inconsistency in announcement? Between 1955 and 1971 there was inconsistency in how there was inconsistency in how repatriation there was inconsistency in how there there was inconsistency in how repatriation occurred. Prior there was inconsistency in how repatriation occurred. Prior to there was inconsistency in how repatriation occurred. Prior to 1955 repatriation occurred. Prior to 1955 there repatriation occurred. Prior to 1955 there was repatriation occurred. Prior to 1955 there was no repatriation occurred. Prior to 1955 there was no expectation repatriation occurred. Prior to 1955 there was no expectation of there was no expectation of repatriation. there was no expectation of repatriation. After there was no expectation of repatriation. After 1971 there was no expectation of repatriation. After 1971 all there was no expectation of repatriation. After 1971 all bodies repatriation. After 1971 all bodies were repatriation. After 1971 all bodies were repatriated. repatriation. After 1971 all bodies were repatriated. Between repatriation. After 1971 all bodies were repatriated. Between 1955 repatriation. After 1971 all bodies were repatriated. Between 1955 and were repatriated. Between 1955 and 1971 were repatriated. Between 1955 and 1971 some were repatriated. Between 1955 and 1971 some families were repatriated. Between 1955 and 1971 some families had were repatriated. Between 1955 and 1971 some families had repatriation 1971 some families had repatriation where 1971 some families had repatriation where they 1971 some families had repatriation where they paid 1971 some families had repatriation where they paid towards 1971 some families had repatriation where they paid towards the 1971 some families had repatriation where they paid towards the cost. where they paid towards the cost. Others where they paid towards the cost. Others were where they paid towards the cost. Others were not where they paid towards the cost. Others were not informed where they paid towards the cost. Others were not informed or Others were not informed or discouraged Others were not informed or discouraged from Others were not informed or discouraged from repatriation. discouraged from repatriation. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Meanwhile, <INTERRUPTION> Meanwhile, civil <INTERRUPTION> Meanwhile, civil servants <INTERRUPTION> Meanwhile, civil servants were Meanwhile, civil servants were repatriated. Meanwhile, civil servants were repatriated. There Meanwhile, civil servants were repatriated. There are Meanwhile, civil servants were repatriated. There are 36 Meanwhile, civil servants were repatriated. There are 36 families repatriated. There are 36 families that repatriated. There are 36 families that will repatriated. There are 36 families that will be repatriated. There are 36 families that will be given repatriated. There are 36 families that will be given the repatriated. There are 36 families that will be given the opportunity that will be given the opportunity to that will be given the opportunity to repatriate that will be given the opportunity to repatriate from that will be given the opportunity to repatriate from cemeteries that will be given the opportunity to repatriate from cemeteries in to repatriate from cemeteries in Singapore to repatriate from cemeteries in Singapore and to repatriate from cemeteries in Singapore and Malaysia. to repatriate from cemeteries in Singapore and Malaysia. This to repatriate from cemeteries in Singapore and Malaysia. This covers Singapore and Malaysia. This covers the Singapore and Malaysia. This covers the Malaya Singapore and Malaysia. This covers the Malaya and Singapore and Malaysia. This covers the Malaya and Vietnam Singapore and Malaysia. This covers the Malaya and Vietnam conflict the Malaya and Vietnam conflict personnel. the Malaya and Vietnam conflict personnel. The the Malaya and Vietnam conflict personnel. The New the Malaya and Vietnam conflict personnel. The New Zealand the Malaya and Vietnam conflict personnel. The New Zealand Defence personnel. The New Zealand Defence Force personnel. The New Zealand Defence Force will personnel. The New Zealand Defence Force will consider personnel. The New Zealand Defence Force will consider extending personnel. The New Zealand Defence Force will consider extending the Force will consider extending the process Force will consider extending the Force Force will consider extending the process to a Force will consider extending the process to a further Force will consider extending the process to a further 13 Force will consider extending the process to a further 13 family Force will consider extending the process to a further 13 family that process to a further 13 family that have process to a further 13 family that have loved process to a further 13 family that have loved ones process to a further 13 family that have loved ones buried process to a further 13 family that have loved ones buried in process to a further 13 family that have loved ones buried in other have loved ones buried in other locations have loved ones buried in other locations around have loved ones buried in other locations around the have loved ones buried in other locations around the world, have loved ones buried in other locations around the world, from have loved ones buried in other locations around the world, from the locations around the world, from the same locations around the world, from the same period locations around the world, from the same period of locations around the world, from the same period of time. locations around the world, from the same period of time. The locations around the world, from the same period of time. The Government same period of time. The Government is same period of time. The Government is rectifying same period of time. The Government is rectifying the same period of time. The Government is rectifying the inconsistencies same period of time. The Government is rectifying the inconsistencies of is rectifying the inconsistencies of the is rectifying the inconsistencies of the past, is rectifying the inconsistencies of the past, and is rectifying the inconsistencies of the past, and repatriation is rectifying the inconsistencies of the past, and repatriation of the past, and repatriation of affected the past, and repatriation of affected families. the past, and repatriation of affected families. Well the past, and repatriation of affected families. Well done! the past, and repatriation of affected families. Well done! What affected families. Well done! What are affected families. Well done! What affected affected families. Well done! What are the options affected families. Well done! What are the options for affected families. Well done! What are the options for the affected families. Well done! What are the options for the families affected families. Well done! What are the options for the families for are the options for the families for repatriation? are the options for the families for repatriation? The are the options for the families for repatriation? The initial are the options for the families for repatriation? The initial step are the options for the families for repatriation? The initial step in repatriation? The initial step in the repatriation? The initial step in the processes repatriation? The initial step in the processes for repatriation? The initial step in the processes for families repatriation? The initial step in the processes for families to the processes for families to contact the processes for families to contact the the processes for families to contact the New the processes for families to contact the New Zealand the processes for families to contact the New Zealand Defence contact the New Zealand Defence Force. contact the New Zealand Defence Force. The contact the New Zealand Defence Force. The family contact the New Zealand Defence Force. The family have contact the New Zealand Defence Force. The family have the contact the New Zealand Defence Force. The family have the choice contact the New Zealand Defence Force. The family have the choice as Force. The family have the choice as to Force. The family have the choice as Force. Force. The family have the choice as to whether or Force. The family have the choice as to whether or not Force. The family have the choice as to whether or not to Force. The family have the choice as to whether or not to repatriate Force. The family have the choice as to whether or not to repatriate from to whether or not to repatriate from the to whether or not to repatriate from the overseas to whether or not to repatriate from the overseas cemeteries. to whether or not to repatriate from the overseas cemeteries. We the overseas cemeteries. We understand the overseas cemeteries. We understand that the overseas cemeteries. We understand that this the overseas cemeteries. We understand that this is the overseas cemeteries. We understand that this is a the overseas cemeteries. We understand that this is a sensitive understand that this is a sensitive issue understand that this is a sensitive issue to understand that this is a sensitive issue to many understand that this is a sensitive issue to many families, understand that this is a sensitive issue to many families, especially issue to many families, especially with issue to many families, especially with particular issue to many families, especially with particular cultural with particular cultural considerations. with particular cultural considerations. For with particular cultural considerations. For those with particular cultural considerations. For those that considerations. For those that choose considerations. For those that choose to considerations. For those that choose to have considerations. For those that choose to have their considerations. For those that choose to have their loved considerations. For those that choose to have their loved ones choose to have their loved ones brought choose to have their loved ones with choose to have their loved ones brought back to choose to have their loved ones brought back to New choose to have their loved ones brought back to New Zealand, choose to have their loved ones brought back to New Zealand, it choose to have their loved ones brought back to New Zealand, it is brought back to New Zealand, it is now brought back to New Zealand, it is now a brought back to New Zealand, it is now a process brought back to New Zealand, it is now a process which brought back to New Zealand, it is now a process which will brought back to New Zealand, it is now a process which will be brought back to New Zealand, it is now a process which will be worked now a process which will be worked through now a process which will be worked through with now a process which will be worked through with the now a process which will be worked through with the New now a process which will be worked through with the New Zealand now a process which will be worked through with the New Zealand Defence through with the New Zealand Defence Force. through with the New Zealand Defence Force. The through with the New Zealand Defence Force. The Government through with the New Zealand Defence Force. The Government is through with the New Zealand Defence Force. The Government is determined Force. The Government is determined to Force. The Government is determined to righting Force. The Government is determined to righting the Force. The Government is determined to righting the wrongs Force. The Government is determined to righting the wrongs of Force. The Government is determined to righting the wrongs of the Force. The Government is determined to righting the wrongs of the past to righting the wrongs of the past and to righting the wrongs of the past and give to righting the wrongs of the past and give repatriation to righting the wrongs of the past and give repatriation to to righting the wrongs of the past and give repatriation to those and give repatriation to those families and give repatriation to those families that and give repatriation to those families that wish and give repatriation to those families that wish to and give repatriation to those families that wish to do and give repatriation to those families that wish to do so. and give repatriation to those families that wish to do so. It and give repatriation to those families that wish to do so. It is families that wish to do so. It is time families that wish to do so. It is time to families that wish to do so. It is time to bring families that wish to do so. It is time to bring them families that wish to do so. It is time to bring them home. families that wish to do so. It is time to bring them home. Hear, families that wish to do so. It is time to bring them home. Hear, hear! time to bring them home. Hear, hear! Question time to bring them home. Hear, hear! Question No. time to bring them home. Hear, hear! Question No. 11. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Social My question is to the Minister for Social Development: My question is to the Minister for Social Development: Is My question is to the Minister for Social Development: Is she My question is to the Minister for Social Development: Is she satisfied Social Development: Is she satisfied that, Social Development: Is she satisfied that, according Social Development: Is she satisfied that, according to Social Development: Is she satisfied that, according to her Social Development: Is she satisfied that, according to her answer Social Development: Is she satisfied that, according to her answer to that, according to her answer to written that, according to her answer to written question that, according to her answer to written question 1048, that, according to her answer to written question 1048, she that, according to her answer to written question 1048, she could that, according to her answer to written question 1048, she could not written question 1048, she could not say written question 1048, she could not say how written question 1048, she could not say how many written question 1048, she could not say how many children written question 1048, she could not say how many children were written question 1048, she could not say how many children were reported say how many children were reported to say how many children were reported to have say how many children were reported to have been say how many children were reported to have been seriously say how many children were reported to have been seriously abused say how many children were reported to have been seriously abused in to have been seriously abused in State to have been seriously abused in State care to have been seriously abused in State care in to have been seriously abused in State care in 2015/16? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the Minister On behalf of the Minister - On behalf of the Minister - yes. On behalf of the Minister - yes. As On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is explained On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is explained in On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is explained in the On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is explained in the answer On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is explained in the answer to On behalf of the Minister - yes. As is explained in the answer to the is explained in the answer to the written is explained in the answer to the written question, is explained in the answer to the written question, the is explained in the answer to the written question, the methodology written question, the methodology for written question, the methodology State written question, the methodology for the reporting written question, the methodology for the reporting of written question, the methodology for the reporting of the written question, the methodology for the reporting of the abuse written question, the methodology for the reporting of the abuse of for the reporting of the abuse of children for the reporting of the abuse of children in for the reporting of the abuse of children in care for the reporting of the abuse of children in care is for the reporting of the abuse of children in care is changing for the reporting of the abuse of children in care is changing quite children in care is changing quite dramatically children in care is changing quite for children in care is changing quite dramatically from previous children in care is changing quite dramatically from previous years. dramatically from previous years. The dramatically from previous years. The approach dramatically from previous years. The approach for dramatically from previous years. The approach for 2015/16 dramatically from previous years. The approach for 2015/16 is dramatically from previous years. The approach for 2015/16 is that dramatically from previous years. The approach for 2015/16 is that all The approach for 2015/16 is that all types The approach for 2015/16 is that all types of The approach for 2015/16 is that all types of abuse The approach for 2015/16 is that all types of abuse across The approach for 2015/16 is that all types of abuse across a The approach for 2015/16 is that all types of abuse across a larger types of abuse across a larger population types of abuse across a larger population will types of abuse across a larger population will now types of abuse across a larger population will now be types of abuse across a larger population will now be considered population will now be considered and population will now be considered and the population will now be considered and the manual population will now be considered and the manual work population will now be considered and the manual work required population will now be considered and the manual work required to and the manual work required to create and the manual work required to create the and the manual work required to create the starter and the manual work required to create the starter set and the manual work required to create the starter set hasn't and the manual work required to create the starter set hasn't yet create the starter set hasn't yet been create the starter set hasn't yet been completed, create the starter set hasn't yet been completed, but create the starter set hasn't yet been completed, but will create the starter set hasn't yet been completed, but will be create the starter set hasn't yet been completed, but will be publicly been completed, but will be publicly available been completed, but will be publicly population been completed, but will be publicly available in the been completed, but will be publicly available in the second been completed, but will be publicly available in the second half been completed, but will be publicly available in the second half of been completed, but will be publicly available in the second half of the available in the second half of the year. available in the second half of the year. I available in the second half of the year. I would available in the second half of the year. I would like available in the second half of the year. I would like to available in the second half of the year. I would like to note available in the second half of the year. I would like to note that available in the second half of the year. I would like to note that it year. I would like to note that it was year. I would like to note that it was only year. I would like to note that it was only under year. I would like to note that it was only under this year. I would like to note that it was only under this Government year. I would like to note that it was only under this Government that was only under this Government that reporting was only under this Government that reporting began was only under this Government that reporting began on was only under this Government that reporting began on these was only under this Government that reporting began on these numbers was only under this Government that reporting began on these numbers in reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. I reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. I would reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. I would like reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. I would like to reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. I would like to add reporting began on these numbers in 2010/11. I would like to add that 2010/11. I would like to add that the 2010/11. I would like to add that the previously 2010/11. I would like to add that the previously Child, 2010/11. I would like to add that the previously Child, Youth, 2010/11. I would like to add that the previously Child, Youth, and the previously Child, Youth, and Family the previously Child, Youth, and Family and the previously Child, Youth, and Family and now the previously Child, Youth, and Family and now the the previously Child, Youth, and Family and now the Ministry the previously Child, Youth, and Family and now the Ministry For Family and now the Ministry For Vulnerable Family and now the Ministry For Vulnerable Children Family and now the Ministry For Vulnerable Children put Family and now the Ministry For Vulnerable Children put the Family and now the Ministry For Vulnerable Children put the safety Vulnerable Children put the safety and Vulnerable Children put the safety and wellbeing Vulnerable Children put the safety and wellbeing of Vulnerable Children put the safety and wellbeing of children Vulnerable Children put the safety and wellbeing of children in Vulnerable Children put the safety and wellbeing of children in their and wellbeing of children in their care and wellbeing of children in their care above and wellbeing of children in their care above all and wellbeing of children in their care above all else. and wellbeing of children in their care above all else. It and wellbeing of children in their care above all else. It has and wellbeing of children in their care above all else. It has policy care above all else. It has policy and care above all else. It has policy and guidelines care above all else. It has policy and guidelines for care above all else. It has policy and guidelines for responding care above all else. It has policy and guidelines for responding to and guidelines for responding to complaints and guidelines for responding to complaints of and guidelines for responding to complaints of allegations, and guidelines for responding to complaints of allegations, including complaints of allegations, including safety complaints of allegations, including safety assessments complaints of allegations, including safety assessments and complaints of allegations, including safety assessments and referral complaints of allegations, including safety assessments and referral to safety assessments and referral to police safety assessments and referral to police when safety assessments and referral to police when warranted. safety assessments and referral to police when warranted. Does safety assessments and referral to police when warranted. Does she police when warranted. Does she share police when warranted. Does she share the police when warranted. Does she share the concern police when warranted. Does she share the concern of police when warranted. Does she share the concern of former police when warranted. Does she share the concern of former Social share the concern of former Social Development share the concern of former Social Development Minister share the concern of former Social Development Minister Paula share the concern of former Social Development Minister Paula Bennett, Development Minister Paula Bennett, who Development Minister Paula Bennett, who in Development Minister Paula Bennett, who in response Development Minister Paula Bennett, who in response to Development Minister Paula Bennett, who in response to questions Development Minister Paula Bennett, who in response to questions from who in response to questions from the who in response to questions from police who in response to questions from the Green Party who in response to questions from the Green Party about who in response to questions from the Green Party about why who in response to questions from the Green Party about why the the Green Party about why the Government the Green Party about why the Government wasn't the Green Party about why the Government wasn't reporting the Green Party about why the Government wasn't reporting in the Green Party about why the Government wasn't reporting in 2011 Government wasn't reporting in 2011 said, Government wasn't reporting in 2011 said, "It Government wasn't reporting in 2011 said, "It quite Government wasn't reporting in 2011 said, "It quite frankly Government wasn't reporting in 2011 said, "It quite frankly horrified Government wasn't reporting in 2011 said, "It quite frankly horrified me said, "It quite frankly horrified me that said, "It quite frankly horrified me that we said, "It quite frankly horrified me that we didn't said, "It quite frankly horrified me that we didn't know said, "It quite frankly horrified me that we didn't know how said, "It quite frankly horrified me that we didn't know how many that we didn't know how many children that we didn't know how many children and that we didn't know how many children and young that we didn't know how many children and young people that we didn't know how many children and young people in that we didn't know how many children and young people in our children and young people in our care children and young people in our care were children and young people in our care were abused children and young people in our care were abused and children and young people in our care were abused and reabused, care were abused and reabused, particularly care were abused and reabused, particularly at care were abused and reabused, particularly at this care were abused and reabused, particularly at this time care were abused and reabused, particularly at this time of particularly at this time of restructuring particularly at this time of restructuring when particularly at this time of restructuring when potentially restructuring when potentially mistakes restructuring when potentially mistakes might restructuring when potentially mistakes might be restructuring when potentially mistakes might be made restructuring when potentially mistakes might be made that restructuring when potentially mistakes might be made that could mistakes might be made that could result mistakes might be made that could result in mistakes might be made that could result in more mistakes might be made that could result in more children mistakes might be made that could result in more children being mistakes might be made that could result in more children being hurt." result in more children being hurt." ? result in more children being hurt." ? On result in more children being hurt." ? On behalf result in more children being hurt." ? On behalf of result in more children being hurt." ? On behalf of the result in more children being hurt." ? On behalf of the Minister result in more children being hurt." ? On behalf of the Minister - result in more children being hurt." ? On behalf of the Minister - we ? On behalf of the Minister - we absolutely ? On behalf of the Minister - we absolutely recognise ? On behalf of the Minister - we absolutely recognise the ? On behalf of the Minister - we absolutely recognise the need ? On behalf of the Minister - we absolutely recognise the need to absolutely recognise the need to know absolutely recognise the need to absolutely absolutely recognise the need to know and understand absolutely recognise the need to know and understand how absolutely recognise the need to know and understand how many know and understand how many children know and understand how many children in know and understand how many children in care know and understand how many children in care have know and understand how many children in care have been know and understand how many children in care have been abused, children in care have been abused, which children in care have been abused, which is children in care have been abused, which is why children in care have been abused, which is why we're children in care have been abused, which is why we're now children in care have been abused, which is why we're now taking children in care have been abused, which is why we're now taking the which is why we're now taking the opportunity which is why we're now taking the opportunity to which is why we're now taking the opportunity to count which is why we're now taking the opportunity to count larger which is why we're now taking the opportunity to count larger numbers opportunity to count larger numbers of opportunity to count larger numbers of abuse opportunity to count larger numbers of abuse types opportunity to count larger numbers of abuse types across opportunity to count larger numbers of abuse types across a opportunity to count larger numbers of abuse types across a larger of abuse types across a larger population of abuse types across a larger opportunity of abuse types across a larger population because while of abuse types across a larger population because while this population because while this Government population because while this opportunity population because while this Government started the population because while this Government started the collection population because while this Government started the collection of Government started the collection of that Government started the collection of that data, Government started the collection of that data, we Government started the collection of that data, we now Government started the collection of that data, we now want Government started the collection of that data, we now want to Government started the collection of that data, we now want to go Government started the collection of that data, we now want to go further that data, we now want to go further and that data, we now want to go further and ensure that data, we now want to go further and ensure we that data, we now want to go further and ensure we have that data, we now want to go further and ensure we have the that data, we now want to go further and ensure we have the fullest and ensure we have the fullest possible and ensure we have the fullest possible picture and ensure we have the fullest possible picture of and ensure we have the fullest possible picture of the and ensure we have the fullest possible picture of the abuse and ensure we have the fullest possible picture of the abuse that possible picture of the abuse that might possible picture of the abuse that Government possible picture of the abuse that might happen at possible picture of the abuse that might happen at any possible picture of the abuse that might happen at any type possible picture of the abuse that might happen at any type of possible picture of the abuse that might happen at any type of state might happen at any type of state care. might happen at any type of state care. That might happen at any type of state care. That work might happen at any type of state care. That work is might happen at any type of state care. That work is taking might happen at any type of state care. That work is taking time might happen at any type of state care. That work is taking time but care. That work is taking time but it care. That work is taking time but it is care. That work is taking time but it is being care. That work is taking time but it is being collected care. That work is taking time but it is being collected and care. That work is taking time but it is being collected and will care. That work is taking time but it is being collected and will be it is being collected and will be reported. it is being collected and will be reported. Why it is being collected and will be reported. Why isn't it is being collected and will be reported. Why isn't she it is being collected and will be reported. Why isn't she adding it is being collected and will be reported. Why isn't she adding extra reported. Why isn't she adding extra reporting reported. Why isn't she adding extra it reported. Why isn't she adding extra reporting criterias to reported. Why isn't she adding extra reporting criterias to the reported. Why isn't she adding extra reporting criterias to the previous reporting criterias to the previous one reporting criterias to the previous one instead reporting criterias to the previous one instead of reporting criterias to the previous one instead of creating reporting criterias to the previous one instead of creating a reporting criterias to the previous one instead of creating a new reporting criterias to the previous one instead of creating a new one one instead of creating a new one making one instead of creating a new one making it one instead of creating a new one making it impossible one instead of creating a new one making it impossible to one instead of creating a new one making it impossible to track one instead of creating a new one making it impossible to track if making it impossible to track if more making it impossible to track if more or making it impossible to track if more or fewer making it impossible to track if more or fewer kids making it impossible to track if more or fewer kids are making it impossible to track if more or fewer kids are experiencing more or fewer kids are experiencing serious more or fewer kids are experiencing serious abuse more or fewer kids are experiencing serious abuse in more or fewer kids are experiencing serious abuse in care? more or fewer kids are experiencing serious abuse in care? Well, more or fewer kids are experiencing serious abuse in care? Well, we more or fewer kids are experiencing serious abuse in care? Well, we are serious abuse in care? Well, we are adding serious abuse in care? Well, we are adding further serious abuse in care? Well, we are adding further criteria, serious abuse in care? Well, we are adding further criteria, but serious abuse in care? Well, we are adding further criteria, but what serious abuse in care? Well, we are adding further criteria, but what we adding further criteria, but what we have adding further criteria, but what we serious adding further criteria, but what we have to do adding further criteria, but what we have to do is adding further criteria, but what we have to do is go adding further criteria, but what we have to do is go through adding further criteria, but what we have to do is go through the adding further criteria, but what we have to do is go through the files have to do is go through the files manually have to do is go through the files manually and have to do is go through the files manually and if have to do is go through the files manually and if we have to do is go through the files manually and if we had have to do is go through the files manually and if we had gone have to do is go through the files manually and if we had gone through manually and if we had gone through them manually and if we had gone through them manually manually and if we had gone through them manually on manually and if we had gone through them manually on the manually and if we had gone through them manually on the old manually and if we had gone through them manually on the old set manually and if we had gone through them manually on the old set that them manually on the old set that would them manually on the old set that would have them manually on the old set that would have taken them manually on the old set that would have taken even them manually on the old set that would have taken even longer them manually on the old set that would have taken even longer and would have taken even longer and duplicated would have taken even longer and them would have taken even longer and duplicated the work. would have taken even longer and duplicated the work. To would have taken even longer and duplicated the work. To get would have taken even longer and duplicated the work. To get to would have taken even longer and duplicated the work. To get to the duplicated the work. To get to the answer, duplicated the work. To get to the answer, the duplicated the work. To get to the answer, the decision duplicated the work. To get to the answer, the decision was duplicated the work. To get to the answer, the decision was made duplicated the work. To get to the answer, the decision was made by duplicated the work. To get to the answer, the decision was made by MSD answer, the decision was made by MSD that answer, the decision was made by MSD that rather answer, the decision was made by MSD that rather than answer, the decision was made by MSD that rather than duplicate answer, the decision was made by MSD that rather than duplicate the that rather than duplicate the repeat that rather than duplicate the that that rather than duplicate the repeat of the that rather than duplicate the repeat of the narrow that rather than duplicate the repeat of the narrow set, that rather than duplicate the repeat of the narrow set, they repeat of the narrow set, they wanted repeat of the narrow set, they wanted to repeat of the narrow set, they wanted to go repeat of the narrow set, they wanted to go through repeat of the narrow set, they wanted to go through those repeat of the narrow set, they wanted to go through those files repeat of the narrow set, they wanted to go through those files and wanted to go through those files and get wanted to go through those files and get the wanted to go through those files and get the most wanted to go through those files and get the most comprehensive wanted to go through those files and get the most comprehensive answer. get the most comprehensive answer. We're get the most comprehensive answer. We're not get the most comprehensive answer. We're not going get the most comprehensive answer. We're not going to get the most comprehensive answer. We're not going to be get the most comprehensive answer. We're not going to be losing We're not going to be losing visibility. We're not going to be losing visibility. That We're not going to be losing visibility. That information We're not going to be losing visibility. That information is visibility. That information is being visibility. That information is get visibility. That information is being collected and visibility. That information is being collected and will visibility. That information is being collected and will be visibility. That information is being collected and will be reported being collected and will be reported in being collected and will be reported in the being collected and will be reported in the second being collected and will be reported in the second half being collected and will be reported in the second half of being collected and will be reported in the second half of this being collected and will be reported in the second half of this year. in the second half of this year. What in the second half of this year. What work in the second half of this year. What work is in the second half of this year. What work is the in the second half of this year. What work is the Minister in the second half of this year. What work is the Minister doing in the second half of this year. What work is the Minister doing to What work is the Minister doing to ensure What work is the Minister doing to ensure current What work is the Minister doing to ensure current and What work is the Minister doing to ensure current and future What work is the Minister doing to ensure current and future children ensure current and future children in ensure current and future children ensure ensure current and future children in care are ensure current and future children in care are able ensure current and future children in care are able to ensure current and future children in care are able to raise ensure current and future children in care are able to raise any in care are able to raise any concerns in care are able to raise any concerns or in care are able to raise any concerns or complaints? in care are able to raise any concerns or complaints? On in care are able to raise any concerns or complaints? On behalf in care are able to raise any concerns or complaints? On behalf of concerns or complaints? On behalf of the concerns or complaints? On behalf of the Minister concerns or complaints? On behalf of the Minister of concerns or complaints? On behalf of the Minister of Social concerns or complaints? On behalf of the Minister of Social Development concerns or complaints? On behalf of the Minister of Social Development - the Minister of Social Development - as the Minister of Social Development - as part the Minister of Social Development - as part of the Minister of Social Development - as part of the the Minister of Social Development - as part of the new the Minister of Social Development - as part of the new Ministry the Minister of Social Development - as part of the new Ministry For as part of the new Ministry For Vulnerable as part of the new Ministry For Vulnerable Children, as part of the new Ministry For Vulnerable Children, launched as part of the new Ministry For Vulnerable Children, launched on as part of the new Ministry For Vulnerable Children, launched on 1 Vulnerable Children, launched on 1 April, Vulnerable Children, launched on 1 April, changes Vulnerable Children, launched on 1 April, changes have Vulnerable Children, launched on 1 April, changes have already Vulnerable Children, launched on 1 April, changes have already been April, changes have already been made April, changes have already been made to April, changes have already been made to ensure April, changes have already been made to ensure that April, changes have already been made to ensure that children April, changes have already been made to ensure that children and made to ensure that children and young made to ensure that children and young people made to ensure that children and young people have made to ensure that children and young people have increased young people have increased visibility young people have increased visibility and young people have increased visibility and access young people have increased visibility and access to young people have increased visibility and access to a young people have increased visibility and access to a feedback visibility and access to a feedback and visibility and access to a feedback and complaints visibility and access to a feedback and complaints mechanism visibility and access to a feedback and complaints mechanism that and complaints mechanism that listens and complaints mechanism that listens and and complaints mechanism that listens and responds and complaints mechanism that listens and responds to and complaints mechanism that listens and responds to their listens and responds to their voices. listens and responds to their voices. The listens and responds to their voices. The feedback listens and responds to their voices. The feedback and listens and responds to their voices. The feedback and complaints voices. The feedback and complaints response voices. The feedback and complaints response is voices. The feedback and complaints response is a voices. The feedback and complaints response is a crucial voices. The feedback and complaints response is a crucial component voices. The feedback and complaints response is a crucial component of response is a crucial component of the response is a crucial component of the support response is a crucial component of the support we response is a crucial component of the support we wrap response is a crucial component of the support we wrap around response is a crucial component of the support we wrap around our response is a crucial component of the support we wrap around our most the support we wrap around our most vulnerable the support we wrap around our most vulnerable children the support we wrap around our most vulnerable children to the support we wrap around our most vulnerable children to help vulnerable children to help conveniency vulnerable children to help conveniency sure vulnerable children to help conveniency sure their vulnerable children to help conveniency sure their safety vulnerable children to help conveniency sure their safety and conveniency sure their safety and support conveniency sure their safety and support them conveniency sure their safety and support them to conveniency sure their safety and support them to thrive. conveniency sure their safety and support them to thrive. Work conveniency sure their safety and support them to thrive. Work is support them to thrive. Work is underway support them to thrive. Work is underway to support them to thrive. Work is underway to establish support them to thrive. Work is underway to establish an support them to thrive. Work is underway to establish an oversight underway to establish an oversight of underway to establish an oversight of the underway to establish an oversight of the ministry's underway to establish an oversight of the ministry's feedback underway to establish an oversight of the ministry's feedback and of the ministry's feedback and complaint of the ministry's feedback and complaint mechanism. of the ministry's feedback and complaint mechanism. Also of the ministry's feedback and complaint mechanism. Also launched complaint mechanism. Also launched from complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 April complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 April is complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 April is an complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 April is an NGO complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 April is an NGO that complaint mechanism. Also launched from 1 April is an NGO that provides from 1 April is an NGO that provides children from 1 April is an NGO that provides children and from 1 April is an NGO that provides children and young from 1 April is an NGO that provides children and young people from 1 April is an NGO that provides children and young people in from 1 April is an NGO that provides children and young people in care children and young people in care with children and young people in care with a children and young people in care with a network children and young people in care with a network of children and young people in care with a network of contacts children and young people in care with a network of contacts that children and young people in care with a network of contacts that will with a network of contacts that will support with a network of contacts that will support them with a network of contacts that will support them and with a network of contacts that will support them and ensure with a network of contacts that will support them and ensure their with a network of contacts that will support them and ensure their voices support them and ensure their voices are support them and ensure their voices with support them and ensure their voices are heard. When support them and ensure their voices are heard. When the support them and ensure their voices are heard. When the last support them and ensure their voices are heard. When the last available are heard. When the last available figures are heard. When the last available figures showed are heard. When the last available figures showed that are heard. When the last available figures showed that a are heard. When the last available figures showed that a child are heard. When the last available figures showed that a child in are heard. When the last available figures showed that a child in state figures showed that a child in state care figures showed that a child in state care was figures showed that a child in state care was being figures showed that a child in state care was being seriously figures showed that a child in state care was being seriously abused care was being seriously abused every care was being seriously abused every nine care was being seriously abused every nine days, care was being seriously abused every nine days, a care was being seriously abused every nine days, a 25% care was being seriously abused every nine days, a 25% increase care was being seriously abused every nine days, a 25% increase in every nine days, a 25% increase in the every nine days, a 25% increase in the very every nine days, a 25% increase in the very short every nine days, a 25% increase in the very short time every nine days, a 25% increase in the very short time that every nine days, a 25% increase in the very short time that her the very short time that her Government the very short time that her Government reported, the very short time that her Government reported, how the very short time that her Government reported, how is the very short time that her Government reported, how is it the very short time that her Government reported, how is it OK the very short time that her Government reported, how is it OK to Government reported, how is it OK to stop Government reported, how is it OK to stop reporting Government reported, how is it OK to stop reporting this Government reported, how is it OK to stop reporting this information? Government reported, how is it OK to stop reporting this information? On stop reporting this information? On behalf stop reporting this information? On behalf of stop reporting this information? On behalf of the stop reporting this information? On behalf of the Minister stop reporting this information? On behalf of the Minister - stop reporting this information? On behalf of the Minister - I stop reporting this information? On behalf of the Minister - I repeat behalf of the Minister - I repeat again behalf of the Minister - I repeat again we behalf of the Minister - I repeat again we have behalf of the Minister - I repeat again we have not behalf of the Minister - I repeat again we have not stopped behalf of the Minister - I repeat again we have not stopped collecting again we have not stopped collecting the again we have not stopped collecting the information. again we have not stopped collecting the information. We again we have not stopped collecting the information. We are, again we have not stopped collecting the information. We are, in again we have not stopped collecting the information. We are, in fact, the information. We are, in fact, going the information. We are, in fact, going through the information. We are, in fact, going through the the information. We are, in fact, going through the process the information. We are, in fact, going through the process of going through the process of building going through the process of building a going through the process of building a much going through the process of building a much more going through the process of building a much more comprehensive building a much more comprehensive way building a much more comprehensive way of building a much more comprehensive way of reporting, building a much more comprehensive way of reporting, counting building a much more comprehensive way of reporting, counting a building a much more comprehensive way of reporting, counting a wider way of reporting, counting a wider scope way of reporting, counting a wider scope of way of reporting, counting a wider scope of abuse way of reporting, counting a wider scope of abuse across way of reporting, counting a wider scope of abuse across a way of reporting, counting a wider scope of abuse across a wider scope of abuse across a wider population, scope of abuse across a wider population, because, scope of abuse across a wider population, because, in scope of abuse across a wider population, because, in this population, because, in this Government's population, because, in this Government's view, population, because, in this Government's view, all population, because, in this Government's view, all abuse population, because, in this Government's view, all abuse in population, because, in this Government's view, all abuse in any Government's view, all abuse in any form Government's view, all abuse in any building Government's view, all abuse in any form of state Government's view, all abuse in any form of state care Government's view, all abuse in any form of state care is Government's view, all abuse in any form of state care is insidious Government's view, all abuse in any form of state care is insidious and form of state care is insidious and unacceptable. form of state care is insidious and unacceptable. We form of state care is insidious and unacceptable. We want form of state care is insidious and unacceptable. We want to form of state care is insidious and unacceptable. We want to have unacceptable. We want to have visible unacceptable. We want to have unacceptable. unacceptable. We want to have visible of it unacceptable. We want to have visible of it all. unacceptable. We want to have visible of it all. That unacceptable. We want to have visible of it all. That data unacceptable. We want to have visible of it all. That data is visible of it all. That data is being visible of it all. That data is being collected visible of it all. That data is being collected and visible of it all. That data is being collected and will visible of it all. That data is being collected and will be visible of it all. That data is being collected and will be reported being collected and will be reported this being collected and will be reported visible being collected and will be reported this year. Is being collected and will be reported this year. Is the being collected and will be reported this year. Is the Minister being collected and will be reported this year. Is the Minister hiding being collected and will be reported this year. Is the Minister hiding an this year. Is the Minister hiding an increase this year. Is the Minister hiding an increase in this year. Is the Minister hiding an increase in the this year. Is the Minister hiding an increase in the number this year. Is the Minister hiding an increase in the number of this year. Is the Minister hiding an increase in the number of children increase in the number of children being increase in the number of children being abused increase in the number of children being abused in increase in the number of children being abused in state increase in the number of children being abused in state care? increase in the number of children being abused in state care? On being abused in state care? On behalf being abused in state care? On behalf of being abused in state care? On behalf of the being abused in state care? On behalf of the Minister being abused in state care? On behalf of the Minister - being abused in state care? On behalf of the Minister - I'm being abused in state care? On behalf of the Minister - I'm not behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure how behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure how I behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure how I can behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure how I can put behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure how I can put this behalf of the Minister - I'm not sure how I can put this anymore sure how I can put this anymore clearly. sure how I can put this anymore clearly. The sure how I can put this anymore clearly. The information sure how I can put this anymore clearly. The information is sure how I can put this anymore clearly. The information is being clearly. The information is being counted clearly. The information is being clearly. clearly. The information is being counted and will clearly. The information is being counted and will be clearly. The information is being counted and will be released clearly. The information is being counted and will be released and clearly. The information is being counted and will be released and it counted and will be released and it will counted and will be released and it will be counted and will be released and it will be more counted and will be released and it will be more comprehensive counted and will be released and it will be more comprehensive than counted and will be released and it will be more comprehensive than any will be more comprehensive than any information will be more comprehensive than any counted will be more comprehensive than any information that has will be more comprehensive than any information that has previously will be more comprehensive than any information that has previously been information that has previously been put information that has previously been put out. information that has previously been put out. I information that has previously been put out. I think information that has previously been put out. I think I information that has previously been put out. I think I have information that has previously been put out. I think I have made information that has previously been put out. I think I have made that put out. I think I have made that very put out. I think I have made that very clear, put out. I think I have made that very clear, that put out. I think I have made that very clear, that we put out. I think I have made that very clear, that we want put out. I think I have made that very clear, that we want to put out. I think I have made that very clear, that we want to see put out. I think I have made that very clear, that we want to see the very clear, that we want to see the widest very clear, that we want to see the widest range very clear, that we want to see the widest range of very clear, that we want to see the widest range of analysis very clear, that we want to see the widest range of analysis of very clear, that we want to see the widest range of analysis of all widest range of analysis of all types widest range of analysis of all information widest range of analysis of all types of abuse widest range of analysis of all types of abuse and widest range of analysis of all types of abuse and all widest range of analysis of all types of abuse and all types widest range of analysis of all types of abuse and all types of types of abuse and all types of care. types of abuse and all types of care. That types of abuse and all types of care. That work types of abuse and all types of care. That work is types of abuse and all types of care. That work is being types of abuse and all types of care. That work is being done types of abuse and all types of care. That work is being done now care. That work is being done now and care. That work is being done now and will care. That work is being done now and will be care. That work is being done now and will be reported. care. That work is being done now and will be reported. There care. That work is being done now and will be reported. There has care. That work is being done now and will be reported. There has been and will be reported. There has been no and will be reported. There has been no stop and will be reported. There has been no stop in and will be reported. There has been no stop in collection, and will be reported. There has been no stop in collection, there and will be reported. There has been no stop in collection, there has no stop in collection, there has been no stop in collection, there has been no no stop in collection, there has been no hiding no stop in collection, there has been no hiding of no stop in collection, there has been no hiding of data. no stop in collection, there has been no hiding of data. We no stop in collection, there has been no hiding of data. We are been no hiding of data. We are getting been no hiding of data. We are getting the been no hiding of data. We are getting the information been no hiding of data. We are getting the information now been no hiding of data. We are getting the information now and been no hiding of data. We are getting the information now and it getting the information now and it will getting the information now and it will be getting the information now and it will be reported getting the information now and it will be reported in getting the information now and it will be reported in the getting the information now and it will be reported in the second getting the information now and it will be reported in the second half will be reported in the second half of will be reported in the second half of this will be reported in the second half of this year. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Associate My question is to the Associate Minister My question is to the Associate Minister for My question is to the Associate Minister for Social My question is to the Associate Minister for Social Housing: My question is to the Associate Minister for Social Housing: Does My question is to the Associate Minister for Social Housing: Does he Minister for Social Housing: Does he stand Minister for Social Housing: Does he stand by Minister for Social Housing: Does he stand by the Minister for Social Housing: Does he stand by the former Minister for Social Housing: Does he stand by the former Prime Minister for Social Housing: Does he stand by the former Prime Minister stand by the former Prime Minister who stand by the former Prime Minister who said stand by the former Prime Minister who said "If stand by the former Prime Minister who said "If they're stand by the former Prime Minister who said "If they're sleeping stand by the former Prime Minister who said "If they're sleeping in stand by the former Prime Minister who said "If they're sleeping in a who said "If they're sleeping in a car, who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my very who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my very strong who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my very strong advice who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my very strong advice is who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my very strong advice is to who said "If they're sleeping in a car, my very strong advice is to go car, my very strong advice is to go and car, my very strong advice is to go and see car, my very strong advice is to go and see Work car, my very strong advice is to go and see Work and car, my very strong advice is to go and see Work and Income car, my very strong advice is to go and see Work and Income and car, my very strong advice is to go and see Work and Income and we'll and see Work and Income and we'll see and see Work and Income and we'll see what and see Work and Income and we'll see what we and see Work and Income and we'll see what we can and see Work and Income and we'll see what we can do"? No-one No-one in No-one in genuine No-one in genuine hardship No-one in genuine hardship should No-one in genuine hardship should be No-one in genuine hardship should be living No-one in genuine hardship should be living rough No-one in genuine hardship should be living rough on No-one in genuine hardship should be living rough on the No-one in genuine hardship should be living rough on the streets No-one in genuine hardship should be living rough on the streets or No-one in genuine hardship should be living rough on the streets or in living rough on the streets or in cars. living rough on the streets or in cars. I living rough on the streets or in cars. I do living rough on the streets or in cars. I do agree living rough on the streets or in cars. I do agree with living rough on the streets or in cars. I do agree with the living rough on the streets or in cars. I do agree with the former living rough on the streets or in cars. I do agree with the former PM cars. I do agree with the former PM - cars. I do agree with the former PM - they cars. I do agree with the former PM - they should cars. I do agree with the former PM - they should go cars. I do agree with the former PM - they should go and cars. I do agree with the former PM - they should go and see cars. I do agree with the former PM - they should go and see Work cars. I do agree with the former PM - they should go and see Work and - they should go and see Work and Income. - they should go and see Work and Income. What - they should go and see Work and Income. What impact - they should go and see Work and Income. What impact will - they should go and see Work and Income. What impact will the Income. What impact will the upcoming Income. What impact will the upcoming world Income. What impact will the upcoming world Masters Income. What impact will the upcoming world Masters cap Income. What impact will the upcoming world Masters cap the upcoming world Masters cap the Games, upcoming world Masters cap the Games, estimate upcoming world Masters cap the Games, estimate -- upcoming world Masters cap the Games, estimate -- World upcoming world Masters cap the Games, estimate -- World Masters Games, estimate -- World Masters Games Games, estimate -- World Masters Games which Games, estimate -- World Masters Games which is Games, estimate -- World Masters Games which is estimated Games, estimate -- World Masters Games which is estimated to Games, estimate -- World Masters Games which is estimated to draw Games which is estimated to draw 30,000 Games which is estimated to draw 30,000 contestants Games which is estimated to draw 30,000 contestants and Games which is estimated to draw 30,000 contestants and supporters 30,000 contestants and supporters have 30,000 contestants and supporters have on 30,000 contestants and supporters have on individuals 30,000 contestants and supporters have on individuals requiring have on individuals requiring emergency have on individuals requiring emergency accommodation have on individuals requiring emergency accommodation from have on individuals requiring emergency accommodation from 31 have on individuals requiring emergency accommodation from 31 to emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... We emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... We have emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... We have been emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... We have been working emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... We have been working hard, emergency accommodation from 31 to 20... We have been working hard, the 20... We have been working hard, the team 20... We have been working hard, the team has 20... We have been working hard, the team has been 20... We have been working hard, the team has been working 20... We have been working hard, the team has been working lard 20... We have been working hard, the team has been working lard to 20... We have been working hard, the team has been working lard to ensure team has been working lard to ensure we team has been working lard to ensure we have team has been working lard to ensure we have a team has been working lard to ensure we have a range team has been working lard to ensure we have a range of team has been working lard to ensure we have a range of options team has been working lard to ensure we have a range of options available we have a range of options available to we have a range of options available to our we have a range of options available to our families we have a range of options available to our families and we have a range of options available to our families and to we have a range of options available to our families and to our to our families and to our individuals to our families and to our individuals as to our families and to our individuals as well. to our families and to our individuals as well. We've to our families and to our individuals as well. We've prebooked individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, rooms individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, rooms at individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, rooms at rates individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, rooms at rates which individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, rooms at rates which are individuals as well. We've prebooked motels, rooms at rates which are not motels, rooms at rates which are not much motels, rooms at rates which are not much more motels, rooms at rates which are not much more greater motels, rooms at rates which are not much more greater than motels, rooms at rates which are not much more greater than what motels, rooms at rates which are not much more greater than what we much more greater than what we usually much more greater than what we usually expect much more greater than what we usually expect to much more greater than what we usually expect to pay. much more greater than what we usually expect to pay. What much more greater than what we usually expect to pay. What I much more greater than what we usually expect to pay. What I can usually expect to pay. What I can assure usually expect to pay. What I can assure the usually expect to pay. What I can assure the member usually expect to pay. What I can assure the member too usually expect to pay. What I can assure the member too is usually expect to pay. What I can assure the member too is that usually expect to pay. What I can assure the member too is that since assure the member too is that since we've assure the member too is that since we've invested assure the member too is that since we've invested the assure the member too is that since we've invested the first assure the member too is that since we've invested the first Government we've invested the first Government of we've invested the first Government of $354 we've invested the first Government of $354 million we've invested the first Government of $354 million into we've invested the first Government of $354 million into emergency of $354 million into emergency housing, of $354 million into emergency housing, our of $354 million into emergency housing, our baseline of $354 million into emergency housing, our baseline is of $354 million into emergency housing, our baseline is that of $354 million into emergency housing, our baseline is that we housing, our baseline is that we have housing, our baseline is that we have 265 housing, our baseline is that we have 265 places housing, our baseline is that we have 265 places that housing, our baseline is that we have 265 places that are housing, our baseline is that we have 265 places that are tenanted housing, our baseline is that we have 265 places that are tenanted by have 265 places that are tenanted by families, have 265 places that are tenanted by families, another have 265 places that are tenanted by families, another 2230 have 265 places that are tenanted by families, another 2230 will have 265 places that are tenanted by families, another 2230 will the have 265 places that are tenanted by families, another 2230 will the next families, another 2230 will the next few families, another 2230 will the next few months families, another 2230 will the next few months coming families, another 2230 will the next few months coming online, families, another 2230 will the next few months coming online, and families, another 2230 will the next few months coming online, and we families, another 2230 will the next few months coming online, and we can few months coming online, and we can say few months coming online, and we can few few months coming online, and we can say an top few months coming online, and we can say an top of few months coming online, and we can say an top of that few months coming online, and we can say an top of that another few months coming online, and we can say an top of that another 430 say an top of that another 430 places say an top of that another 430 places - say an top of that another 430 places - roughly say an top of that another 430 places - roughly half say an top of that another 430 places - roughly half of say an top of that another 430 places - roughly half of those places - roughly half of those coming places - roughly half of those say places - roughly half of those coming online in places - roughly half of those coming online in the places - roughly half of those coming online in the next places - roughly half of those coming online in the next few places - roughly half of those coming online in the next few months coming online in the next few months as coming online in the next few months as well. coming online in the next few months as well. <INTERRUPTION> as well. <INTERRUPTION> How as well. <INTERRUPTION> How many as well. <INTERRUPTION> How many motel as well. <INTERRUPTION> How many motel rooms as well. <INTERRUPTION> How many motel rooms has as well. <INTERRUPTION> How many motel rooms has he How many motel rooms has he prebooked How many motel rooms has he prebooked during How many motel rooms has he prebooked during the How many motel rooms has he prebooked during the Masters How many motel rooms has he prebooked during the Masters Games prebooked during the Masters Games period prebooked during the Masters Games period to prebooked during the Masters Games period to ensure prebooked during the Masters Games period to ensure those prebooked during the Masters Games period to ensure those requiring period to ensure those requiring emergency period to ensure those requiring emergency accommodation period to ensure those requiring emergency accommodation have period to ensure those requiring emergency accommodation have access emergency accommodation have access to emergency accommodation have access to it, emergency accommodation have access to it, particularly emergency accommodation have access to it, particularly in emergency accommodation have access to it, particularly in light emergency accommodation have access to it, particularly in light of emergency accommodation have access to it, particularly in light of the to it, particularly in light of the numbers to it, particularly in light of the numbers of to it, particularly in light of the numbers of 400 to it, particularly in light of the numbers of 400 per to it, particularly in light of the numbers of 400 per night to it, particularly in light of the numbers of 400 per night that to it, particularly in light of the numbers of 400 per night that we numbers of 400 per night that we know numbers of 400 per night that we know are numbers of 400 per night that we know are requiring numbers of 400 per night that we know are requiring emergency know are requiring emergency accommodation know are requiring emergency numbers know are requiring emergency accommodation already at know are requiring emergency accommodation already at this know are requiring emergency accommodation already at this time? accommodation already at this time? What accommodation already at this time? What I accommodation already at this time? What I can accommodation already at this time? What I can tell accommodation already at this time? What I can tell the accommodation already at this time? What I can tell the member accommodation already at this time? What I can tell the member - accommodation already at this time? What I can tell the member - there What I can tell the member - there is What I can tell the member - there is roughly What I can tell the member - there is roughly around What I can tell the member - there is roughly around 350 What I can tell the member - there is roughly around 350 that What I can tell the member - there is roughly around 350 that access is roughly around 350 that access the is roughly around 350 that access the special is roughly around 350 that access the special need is roughly around 350 that access the special need grants is roughly around 350 that access the special need grants a is roughly around 350 that access the special need grants a week. is roughly around 350 that access the special need grants a week. Of the special need grants a week. Of those, the special need grants a week. Of those, we the special need grants a week. Of those, we know the special need grants a week. Of those, we know there the special need grants a week. Of those, we know there are the special need grants a week. Of those, we know there are places the special need grants a week. Of those, we know there are places that those, we know there are places that are those, we know there are places that are already those, we know there are places that are already in those, we know there are places that are already in place, those, we know there are places that are already in place, as those, we know there are places that are already in place, as I those, we know there are places that are already in place, as I have are already in place, as I have said. are already in place, as I have said. 265 are already in place, as I have said. 265 places are already in place, as I have said. 265 places that are already in place, as I have said. 265 places that are are already in place, as I have said. 265 places that are there are already in place, as I have said. 265 places that are there as said. 265 places that are there as well. said. 265 places that are there as well. We said. 265 places that are there as well. We have said. 265 places that are there as well. We have a said. 265 places that are there as well. We have a range said. 265 places that are there as well. We have a range of said. 265 places that are there as well. We have a range of options, well. We have a range of options, not well. We have a range of options, not just well. We have a range of options, not just motels. well. We have a range of options, not just motels. There well. We have a range of options, not just motels. There are well. We have a range of options, not just motels. There are other not just motels. There are other options. not just motels. There are other options. We not just motels. There are other options. We also not just motels. There are other options. We also too not just motels. There are other options. We also too have not just motels. There are other options. We also too have the options. We also too have the emergency options. We also too have the emergency houses options. We also too have the emergency houses coming options. We also too have the emergency houses coming online options. We also too have the emergency houses coming online as emergency houses coming online as well. emergency houses coming online as well. What emergency houses coming online as well. What I emergency houses coming online as well. What I can emergency houses coming online as well. What I can say emergency houses coming online as well. What I can say to emergency houses coming online as well. What I can say to the emergency houses coming online as well. What I can say to the member emergency houses coming online as well. What I can say to the member - well. What I can say to the member - what well. What I can say to the member - what the well. What I can say to the member - what the PM well. What I can say to the member - what the PM earlier well. What I can say to the member - what the PM earlier this well. What I can say to the member - what the PM earlier this month well. What I can say to the member - what the PM earlier this month - well. What I can say to the member - what the PM earlier this month - we what the PM earlier this month - we launched what the PM earlier this month - we launched Luke what the PM earlier this month - we launched Luke Street. what the PM earlier this month - we launched Luke Street. That what the PM earlier this month - we launched Luke Street. That is what the PM earlier this month - we launched Luke Street. That is 53 launched Luke Street. That is 53 units launched Luke Street. That is 53 units of launched Luke Street. That is 53 units of transitional launched Luke Street. That is 53 units of transitional housing. launched Luke Street. That is 53 units of transitional housing. That units of transitional housing. That means units of transitional housing. That means 250 units of transitional housing. That means 250 mums units of transitional housing. That means 250 mums and units of transitional housing. That means 250 mums and dads units of transitional housing. That means 250 mums and dads and units of transitional housing. That means 250 mums and dads and their means 250 mums and dads and their children means 250 mums and dads and their means means 250 mums and dads and their children for up means 250 mums and dads and their children for up to means 250 mums and dads and their children for up to 12 means 250 mums and dads and their children for up to 12 week means 250 mums and dads and their children for up to 12 week also means 250 mums and dads and their children for up to 12 week also have children for up to 12 week also have warm, children for up to 12 week also have warm, dry children for up to 12 week also have warm, dry accommodation. children for up to 12 week also have warm, dry accommodation. In children for up to 12 week also have warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, as warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, as soon warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, as soon as warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, as soon as the warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, as soon as the weather warm, dry accommodation. In Kepa Road, as soon as the weather clears. Road, as soon as the weather clears. Be Road, as soon as the weather clears. Be six Road, as soon as the weather clears. Be six modular Road, as soon as the weather clears. Be six modular houses. Road, as soon as the weather clears. Be six modular houses. In Road, as soon as the weather clears. Be six modular houses. In South Be six modular houses. In South Auckland, Be six modular houses. In South Auckland, there Be six modular houses. In South Auckland, there will Be six modular houses. In South Auckland, there will be Be six modular houses. In South Auckland, there will be another Be six modular houses. In South Auckland, there will be another 63 Auckland, there will be another 63 units Auckland, there will be another 63 units available Auckland, there will be another 63 units available as Auckland, there will be another 63 units available as well. Auckland, there will be another 63 units available as well. My Auckland, there will be another 63 units available as well. My question units available as well. My question was units available as well. My question was really units available as well. My question was really clear units available as well. My question was really clear - units available as well. My question was really clear - I units available as well. My question was really clear - I asked units available as well. My question was really clear - I asked how units available as well. My question was really clear - I asked how many was really clear - I asked how many motel was really clear - I asked how many motel rooms was really clear - I asked how many motel rooms he was really clear - I asked how many motel rooms he booked was really clear - I asked how many motel rooms he booked during was really clear - I asked how many motel rooms he booked during the motel rooms he booked during the Masters motel rooms he booked during the Masters Games. motel rooms he booked during the Masters Games. He's... motel rooms he booked during the Masters Games. He's... That's motel rooms he booked during the Masters Games. He's... That's all motel rooms he booked during the Masters Games. He's... That's all we Masters Games. He's... That's all we need Masters Games. He's... That's all we Road, Masters Games. He's... That's all we need T question Masters Games. He's... That's all we need T question is Masters Games. He's... That's all we need T question is how Masters Games. He's... That's all we need T question is how many Masters Games. He's... That's all we need T question is how many motel need T question is how many motel rooms need T question is how many motel rooms have need T question is how many motel rooms have been need T question is how many motel rooms have been prebooked need T question is how many motel rooms have been prebooked during need T question is how many motel rooms have been prebooked during the rooms have been prebooked during the Games? rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In my rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In my answer, rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In my answer, what rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In my answer, what I rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In my answer, what I did rooms have been prebooked during the Games? In my answer, what I did - Games? In my answer, what I did - there Games? In my answer, what I did - there are Games? In my answer, what I did - there are have Games? In my answer, what I did - there are have a Games? In my answer, what I did - there are have a number Games? In my answer, what I did - there are have a number that Games? In my answer, what I did - there are have a number that are there are have a number that are been there are have a number that are been prebooked. there are have a number that are been prebooked. I there are have a number that are been prebooked. I can there are have a number that are been prebooked. I can get there are have a number that are been prebooked. I can get the been prebooked. I can get the number, been prebooked. I can get the number, if been prebooked. I can get the number, if the been prebooked. I can get the number, if the member been prebooked. I can get the number, if the member would been prebooked. I can get the number, if the member would like been prebooked. I can get the number, if the member would like to number, if the member would like to get number, if the member would like to number, number, if the member would like to get the question number, if the member would like to get the question in number, if the member would like to get the question in writing. number, if the member would like to get the question in writing. There get the question in writing. There have get the question in writing. There have been get the question in writing. There have been prebooked get the question in writing. There have been prebooked motels, get the question in writing. There have been prebooked motels, there have been prebooked motels, there are... have been prebooked motels, there are... Order! have been prebooked motels, there are... Order! The have been prebooked motels, there are... Order! The question have been prebooked motels, there are... Order! The question has have been prebooked motels, there are... Order! The question has now are... Order! The question has now been are... Order! The question has now have are... Order! The question has now been addressed. Supplementary been addressed. Supplementary question. been addressed. Supplementary question. Given been addressed. Supplementary question. Given that been addressed. Supplementary question. Given that Auckland question. Given that Auckland accommodation question. Given that Auckland accommodation is question. Given that Auckland accommodation is so question. Given that Auckland accommodation is so stretched question. Given that Auckland accommodation is so stretched that accommodation is so stretched that 53 accommodation is so stretched that 53 American accommodation is so stretched that 53 American tourists accommodation is so stretched that 53 American tourists stranded accommodation is so stretched that 53 American tourists stranded by 53 American tourists stranded by cancelled 53 American tourists stranded by cancelled flights 53 American tourists stranded by cancelled flights had 53 American tourists stranded by cancelled flights had to 53 American tourists stranded by cancelled flights had to stay 53 American tourists stranded by cancelled flights had to stay over cancelled flights had to stay over night cancelled flights had to stay over night at cancelled flights had to stay over night at a cancelled flights had to stay over night at a may cancelled flights had to stay over night at a may rye, cancelled flights had to stay over night at a may rye, how cancelled flights had to stay over night at a may rye, how does cancelled flights had to stay over night at a may rye, how does he night at a may rye, how does he expect night at a may rye, how does he expect Work night at a may rye, how does he expect Work and night at a may rye, how does he expect Work and Income night at a may rye, how does he expect Work and Income to night at a may rye, how does he expect Work and Income to ensure expect Work and Income to ensure homeless expect Work and Income to ensure homeless families expect Work and Income to ensure homeless families aren't expect Work and Income to ensure homeless families aren't sleeping expect Work and Income to ensure homeless families aren't sleeping in homeless families aren't sleeping in their homeless families aren't sleeping in homeless homeless families aren't sleeping in their cars when homeless families aren't sleeping in their cars when there homeless families aren't sleeping in their cars when there is homeless families aren't sleeping in their cars when there is 35,000 their cars when there is 35,000 extra their cars when there is 35,000 homeless their cars when there is 35,000 extra tourists in their cars when there is 35,000 extra tourists in Auckland their cars when there is 35,000 extra tourists in Auckland needing extra tourists in Auckland needing accommodation? extra tourists in Auckland needing extra extra tourists in Auckland needing accommodation? This Government extra tourists in Auckland needing accommodation? This Government has accommodation? This Government has been accommodation? This Government has been working accommodation? This Government has been working in accommodation? This Government has been working in partnership accommodation? This Government has been working in partnership with accommodation? This Government has been working in partnership with a been working in partnership with a number been working in partnership with a number of been working in partnership with a number of providers. been working in partnership with a number of providers. Part been working in partnership with a number of providers. Part of been working in partnership with a number of providers. Part of that number of providers. Part of that initiative number of providers. Part of that initiative is number of providers. Part of that initiative is around number of providers. Part of that initiative is around the number of providers. Part of that initiative is around the Housing initiative is around the Housing First initiative is around the Housing initiative initiative is around the Housing First Auckland. This initiative is around the Housing First Auckland. This complements initiative is around the Housing First Auckland. This complements the First Auckland. This complements the programme First Auckland. This complements the programme the First Auckland. This complements the programme the work First Auckland. This complements the programme the work the First Auckland. This complements the programme the work the Government programme the work the Government has programme the work the Government has been programme the work the Government has been doing programme the work the Government has been doing at programme the work the Government has been doing at the programme the work the Government has been doing at the moment. programme the work the Government has been doing at the moment. We programme the work the Government has been doing at the moment. We are has been doing at the moment. We are piloting has been doing at the moment. We are piloting a has been doing at the moment. We are piloting a programme has been doing at the moment. We are piloting a programme of has been doing at the moment. We are piloting a programme of 470 has been doing at the moment. We are piloting a programme of 470 homeless piloting a programme of 470 homeless over piloting a programme of 470 homeless over Auckland, piloting a programme of 470 homeless over Auckland, costing piloting a programme of 470 homeless over Auckland, costing around piloting a programme of 470 homeless over Auckland, costing around about over Auckland, costing around about $4.5 over Auckland, costing around about $4.5 million over Auckland, costing around about $4.5 million over over Auckland, costing around about $4.5 million over two over Auckland, costing around about $4.5 million over two years. over Auckland, costing around about $4.5 million over two years. It $4.5 million over two years. It takes $4.5 million over two years. It takes seriously $4.5 million over two years. It takes seriously the $4.5 million over two years. It takes seriously the responsibility takes seriously the responsibility around takes seriously the responsibility around homelessness. takes seriously the responsibility around homelessness. The takes seriously the responsibility around homelessness. The question around homelessness. The question around around homelessness. The question around homelessness around homelessness. The question around homelessness is around homelessness. The question around homelessness is a around homelessness. The question around homelessness is a partnership around homelessness is a partnership with around homelessness is a partnership with Government around homelessness is a partnership with Government and around homelessness is a partnership with Government and emergency with Government and emergency housing with Government and emergency housing providers with Government and emergency housing providers as with Government and emergency housing providers as well with Government and emergency housing providers as well as housing providers as well as community housing providers as well as community housing housing providers as well as community housing providers housing providers as well as community housing providers also. community housing providers also. Well community housing providers also. Well said! community housing providers also. Well said! Can community housing providers also. Well said! Can he community housing providers also. Well said! Can he guarantee community housing providers also. Well said! Can he guarantee his Well said! Can he guarantee his "team Well said! Can he guarantee his "team has Well said! Can he guarantee his "team has been Well said! Can he guarantee his "team has been working Well said! Can he guarantee his "team has been working hard Well said! Can he guarantee his "team has been working hard to Well said! Can he guarantee his "team has been working hard to make "team has been working hard to make sure "team has been working hard to make sure we "team has been working hard to make sure we have "team has been working hard to make sure we have got "team has been working hard to make sure we have got that "team has been working hard to make sure we have got that covered", "team has been working hard to make sure we have got that covered", and sure we have got that covered", and that sure we have got that covered", and that no-one sure we have got that covered", and that no-one who sure we have got that covered", and that no-one who approaches sure we have got that covered", and that no-one who approaches Work sure we have got that covered", and that no-one who approaches Work and that no-one who approaches Work and Income that no-one who approaches Work and sure that no-one who approaches Work and Income in need that no-one who approaches Work and Income in need of that no-one who approaches Work and Income in need of emergency Income in need of emergency accommodation Income in need of emergency accommodation during Income in need of emergency accommodation during the Income in need of emergency accommodation during the Masters accommodation during the Masters Games accommodation during the Masters Games will accommodation during the Masters Games will be accommodation during the Masters Games will be turned accommodation during the Masters Games will be turned away accommodation during the Masters Games will be turned away without Games will be turned away without some Games will be turned away without some form Games will be turned away without some form of Games will be turned away without some form of safe Games will be turned away without some form of safe housing? Games will be turned away without some form of safe housing? I Games will be turned away without some form of safe housing? I have some form of safe housing? I have great some form of safe housing? I have great faith some form of safe housing? I have great faith in some form of safe housing? I have great faith in the some form of safe housing? I have great faith in the teams some form of safe housing? I have great faith in the teams that some form of safe housing? I have great faith in the teams that have great faith in the teams that have been great faith in the teams that have been working great faith in the teams that have been working hard. great faith in the teams that have been working hard. We great faith in the teams that have been working hard. We work great faith in the teams that have been working hard. We work hard been working hard. We work hard because been working hard. We work hard because there been working hard. We work hard because there is been working hard. We work hard because there is a been working hard. We work hard because there is a genuine been working hard. We work hard because there is a genuine response because there is a genuine response to because there is a genuine response to meet because there is a genuine response to meet needs. because there is a genuine response to meet needs. Our because there is a genuine response to meet needs. Our providers because there is a genuine response to meet needs. Our providers are because there is a genuine response to meet needs. Our providers are in to meet needs. Our providers are in touch to meet needs. Our providers are in touch on to meet needs. Our providers are in touch on the to meet needs. Our providers are in touch on the ground, to meet needs. Our providers are in touch on the ground, we to meet needs. Our providers are in touch on the ground, we are to meet needs. Our providers are in touch on the ground, we are working touch on the ground, we are working with touch on the ground, we are working with emergency touch on the ground, we are working with emergency housing touch on the ground, we are working with emergency housing providers touch on the ground, we are working with emergency housing providers to with emergency housing providers to ensure with emergency housing providers to with with emergency housing providers to ensure that we with emergency housing providers to ensure that we have with emergency housing providers to ensure that we have confidence with emergency housing providers to ensure that we have confidence that ensure that we have confidence that we ensure that we have confidence that with ensure that we have confidence that we are meeting ensure that we have confidence that we are meeting those ensure that we have confidence that we are meeting those needs. ensure that we have confidence that we are meeting those needs. If ensure that we have confidence that we are meeting those needs. If there we are meeting those needs. If there are we are meeting those needs. If there are contingencies we are meeting those needs. If there are contingencies that we are meeting those needs. If there are contingencies that need we are meeting those needs. If there are contingencies that need to we are meeting those needs. If there are contingencies that need to be are contingencies that need to be put are contingencies that need to be put in are contingencies that need to be put in place, are contingencies that need to be put in place, we are contingencies that need to be put in place, we know are contingencies that need to be put in place, we know the are contingencies that need to be put in place, we know the team are contingencies that need to be put in place, we know the team is put in place, we know the team is prepare put in place, we know the team is prepare and put in place, we know the team is prepare and ready put in place, we know the team is prepare and ready for put in place, we know the team is prepare and ready for that put in place, we know the team is prepare and ready for that as put in place, we know the team is prepare and ready for that as well. prepare and ready for that as well. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . That <INTERRUPTION> . That concludes <INTERRUPTION> . That concludes questions <INTERRUPTION> . That concludes questions for <INTERRUPTION> . That concludes questions for oral