This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Ericsson This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access Services Ericsson Access Services for Ericsson Access Services for the Ericsson Access Services for the Office Ericsson Access Services for the Office of Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, humbly Almighty God, humbly acknowledging Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need for humbly acknowledging our need for your humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all things, your guidance in all things, and your guidance in all things, and laying your guidance in all things, and laying aside your guidance in all things, and laying aside all your guidance in all things, and laying aside all private and laying aside all private and and laying aside all private and personal and laying aside all private and personal interests, and personal interests, we and personal interests, we ask and personal interests, we ask that and personal interests, we ask that you and personal interests, we ask that you grant we ask that you grant that we ask that you grant that we we ask that you grant that we may we ask that you grant that we may conduct we ask that you grant that we may conduct the we ask that you grant that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House that we may conduct the affairs of this House and that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our country of this House and of our country to of this House and of our country to the of this House and of our country to the glory of this House and of our country to the glory of of this House and of our country to the glory of your of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy name, to the glory of your holy name, the to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true religion the maintenance of true religion and the maintenance of true religion and justice, and justice, the and justice, the honour and justice, the honour of and justice, the honour of the and justice, the honour of the Queen, the honour of the Queen, and the honour of the Queen, and the the honour of the Queen, and the public the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, peace, and the public welfare, peace, and and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New Zealand, and tranquillity of New Zealand, through and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our Lord. through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen. Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, Point Mr Speaker, Point of Mr Speaker, Point of order. Mr Speaker, Point of order. I Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek leave Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek leave to Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek leave to move Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek leave to move a Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek leave to move a motion Mr Speaker, Point of order. I seek leave to move a motion without leave to move a motion without notice leave to move a motion without notice on leave to move a motion without notice on the leave to move a motion without notice on the terror leave to move a motion without notice on the terror attacks leave to move a motion without notice on the terror attacks in notice on the terror attacks in London. London. Is London. Is there London. Is there any London. Is there any objection London. Is there any objection to London. Is there any objection to that Is there any objection to that course Is there any objection to that course of Is there any objection to that course of action Is there any objection to that course of action being Is there any objection to that course of action being followed? course of action being followed? There course of action being followed? There is course of action being followed? There is none. The The Hon The Hon Deputy The Hon Deputy PM. The Hon Deputy PM. I The Hon Deputy PM. I move The Hon Deputy PM. I move that The Hon Deputy PM. I move that this The Hon Deputy PM. I move that this House The Hon Deputy PM. I move that this House condemn The Hon Deputy PM. I move that this House condemn the The Hon Deputy PM. I move that this House condemn the terrorist The Hon Deputy PM. I move that this House condemn the terrorist attack House condemn the terrorist attack in House condemn the terrorist attack in London House condemn the terrorist attack in London and House condemn the terrorist attack in London and extend House condemn the terrorist attack in London and extend its House condemn the terrorist attack in London and extend its condolences in London and extend its condolences to in London and extend its condolences to the in London and extend its condolences to the family in London and extend its condolences to the family and in London and extend its condolences to the family and friends in London and extend its condolences to the family and friends of in London and extend its condolences to the family and friends of those to the family and friends of those killed to the family and friends of those killed and to the family and friends of those killed and injured. to the family and friends of those killed and injured. Our to the family and friends of those killed and injured. Our thoughts killed and injured. Our thoughts killed and injured. Our thoughts killed and injured. Our thoughts also go killed and injured. Our thoughts also go out killed and injured. Our thoughts also go out to killed and injured. Our thoughts also go out to New killed and injured. Our thoughts also go out to New Zealander killed and injured. Our thoughts also go out to New Zealander Oliver also go out to New Zealander Oliver Dowling also go out to New Zealander Oliver Dowling and also go out to New Zealander Oliver Dowling and his also go out to New Zealander Oliver Dowling and his family, also go out to New Zealander Oliver Dowling and his family, as also go out to New Zealander Oliver Dowling and his family, as he Dowling and his family, as he recovers Dowling and his family, as he recovers in Dowling and his family, as he recovers in a Dowling and his family, as he recovers in a London Dowling and his family, as he recovers in a London hospital. Dowling and his family, as he recovers in a London hospital. While recovers in a London hospital. While there recovers in a London hospital. While there is recovers in a London hospital. While there is no recovers in a London hospital. While there is no indication recovers in a London hospital. While there is no indication of recovers in a London hospital. While there is no indication of any recovers in a London hospital. While there is no indication of any other there is no indication of any other New there is no indication of any other New Zealanders there is no indication of any other New Zealanders involved, there is no indication of any other New Zealanders involved, the there is no indication of any other New Zealanders involved, the high New Zealanders involved, the high commission New Zealanders involved, the high commission in New Zealanders involved, the high commission in London New Zealanders involved, the high commission in London continues New Zealanders involved, the high commission in London continues to commission in London continues to liaise commission in London continues to liaise with commission in London continues to liaise with local commission in London continues to liaise with local authorities. commission in London continues to liaise with local authorities. Mr liaise with local authorities. Mr Speaker, liaise with local authorities. Mr Speaker, terror liaise with local authorities. Mr Speaker, terror attacks liaise with local authorities. Mr Speaker, terror attacks took liaise with local authorities. Mr Speaker, terror attacks took place Speaker, terror attacks took place Speaker, terror attacks took place Speaker, terror attacks took place on Saturday Speaker, terror attacks took place on Saturday night Speaker, terror attacks took place on Saturday night when Speaker, terror attacks took place on Saturday night when Londoners on Saturday night when Londoners were on Saturday night when Londoners were out on Saturday night when Londoners were out enjoying on Saturday night when Londoners were out enjoying themselves. on Saturday night when Londoners were out enjoying themselves. Two were out enjoying themselves. Two attacks were out enjoying themselves. Two attacks occurred, were out enjoying themselves. Two attacks occurred, one were out enjoying themselves. Two attacks occurred, one on were out enjoying themselves. Two attacks occurred, one on London attacks occurred, one on London Bridge, attacks occurred, one on London Bridge, one attacks occurred, one on London Bridge, one in attacks occurred, one on London Bridge, one in nearby attacks occurred, one on London Bridge, one in nearby Borough Bridge, one in nearby Borough Markets. Bridge, one in nearby Borough Markets. A Bridge, one in nearby Borough Markets. A white Bridge, one in nearby Borough Markets. A white van Bridge, one in nearby Borough Markets. A white van drove Bridge, one in nearby Borough Markets. A white van drove in Markets. A white van drove in pedestrians Markets. A white van drove in pedestrians on Markets. A white van drove in pedestrians on London Markets. A white van drove in pedestrians on London Bridge, Markets. A white van drove in pedestrians on London Bridge, the pedestrians on London Bridge, the van pedestrians on London Bridge, the van crashed pedestrians on London Bridge, the van crashed and pedestrians on London Bridge, the van crashed and the pedestrians on London Bridge, the van crashed and the suspects pedestrians on London Bridge, the van crashed and the suspects ran pedestrians on London Bridge, the van crashed and the suspects ran to van crashed and the suspects ran to Borough van crashed and the suspects ran to Borough Market van crashed and the suspects ran to Borough Market and van crashed and the suspects ran to Borough Market and stabbed van crashed and the suspects ran to Borough Market and stabbed people van crashed and the suspects ran to Borough Market and stabbed people in Borough Market and stabbed people in an Borough Market and stabbed people in an area Borough Market and stabbed people in an area crowded Borough Market and stabbed people in an area crowded with Borough Market and stabbed people in an area crowded with bars Borough Market and stabbed people in an area crowded with bars and an area crowded with bars and van an area crowded with bars and restaurants. This is an area crowded with bars and restaurants. This is the an area crowded with bars and restaurants. This is the third an area crowded with bars and restaurants. This is the third such restaurants. This is the third such attack restaurants. This is the third such attack in restaurants. This is the third such attack in the restaurants. This is the third such attack in the UK restaurants. This is the third such attack in the UK in restaurants. This is the third such attack in the UK in recent restaurants. This is the third such attack in the UK in recent weeks restaurants. This is the third such attack in the UK in recent weeks and attack in the UK in recent weeks and in attack in the UK in recent weeks and in this attack in the UK in recent weeks and in this one attack in the UK in recent weeks and in this one seven attack in the UK in recent weeks and in this one seven people attack in the UK in recent weeks and in this one seven people to attack in the UK in recent weeks and in this one seven people to date in this one seven people to date have in this one seven people to date have died. in this one seven people to date have died. 48 in this one seven people to date have died. 48 are in this one seven people to date have died. 48 are reported in this one seven people to date have died. 48 are reported injured, have died. 48 are reported injured, one, have died. 48 are reported injured, one, of have died. 48 are reported injured, one, of course, have died. 48 are reported injured, one, of course, as have died. 48 are reported injured, one, of course, as we have died. 48 are reported injured, one, of course, as we have have died. 48 are reported injured, one, of course, as we have mentioned one, of course, as we have mentioned is one, of course, as we have mentioned is from one, of course, as we have mentioned is from New one, of course, as we have mentioned is from New Zealand. one, of course, as we have mentioned is from New Zealand. 18 one, of course, as we have mentioned is from New Zealand. 18 of one, of course, as we have mentioned is from New Zealand. 18 of those is from New Zealand. 18 of those remain is from New Zealand. 18 of those remain in is from New Zealand. 18 of those remain in a is from New Zealand. 18 of those remain in a critical is from New Zealand. 18 of those remain in a critical condition. remain in a critical condition. Several remain in a critical condition. Several people remain in a critical condition. Several people are remain in a critical condition. Several people are still remain in a critical condition. Several people are still missing remain in a critical condition. Several people are still missing and Several people are still missing and not Several people are still missing and not yet Several people are still missing and not yet accounted Several people are still missing and not yet accounted for Several people are still missing and not yet accounted for and Several people are still missing and not yet accounted for and the Several people are still missing and not yet accounted for and the three not yet accounted for and the three suspects not yet accounted for and the three suspects were not yet accounted for and the three suspects were also not yet accounted for and the three suspects were also shot not yet accounted for and the three suspects were also shot by not yet accounted for and the three suspects were also shot by police. suspects were also shot by police. Although suspects were also shot by police. Although it suspects were also shot by police. Although it is suspects were also shot by police. Although it is so suspects were also shot by police. Although it is so very suspects were also shot by police. Although it is so very far suspects were also shot by police. Although it is so very far away, suspects were also shot by police. Although it is so very far away, it Although it is so very far away, it also Although it is so very far away, it also feels Although it is so very far away, it also feels very Although it is so very far away, it also feels very close Although it is so very far away, it also feels very close and Although it is so very far away, it also feels very close and personal also feels very close and personal to also feels very close and personal to us also feels very close and personal to us here also feels very close and personal to us here in also feels very close and personal to us here in New also feels very close and personal to us here in New Zealand. also feels very close and personal to us here in New Zealand. As also feels very close and personal to us here in New Zealand. As that to us here in New Zealand. As that initial to us here in New Zealand. As that initial headline to us here in New Zealand. As that initial headline comes to us here in New Zealand. As that initial headline comes up to us here in New Zealand. As that initial headline comes up across to us here in New Zealand. As that initial headline comes up across our initial headline comes up across our TV initial headline comes up across our TV screens initial headline comes up across our TV screens or initial headline comes up across our TV screens or on initial headline comes up across our TV screens or on our initial headline comes up across our TV screens or on our phones initial headline comes up across our TV screens or on our phones our TV screens or on our phones our hearts TV screens or on our phones our hearts leap TV screens or on our phones our hearts leap into TV screens or on our phones our hearts leap into our TV screens or on our phones our hearts leap into our throats TV screens or on our phones our hearts leap into our throats as TV screens or on our phones our hearts leap into our throats as we hearts leap into our throats as we think hearts leap into our throats as we think this hearts leap into our throats as we think this could hearts leap into our throats as we think this could be hearts leap into our throats as we think this could be someone hearts leap into our throats as we think this could be someone we hearts leap into our throats as we think this could be someone we know, think this could be someone we know, someone think this could be someone we know, someone we think this could be someone we know, someone we love, think this could be someone we know, someone we love, who think this could be someone we know, someone we love, who is think this could be someone we know, someone we love, who is visiting think this could be someone we know, someone we love, who is visiting or someone we love, who is visiting or living someone we love, who is visiting or living there. someone we love, who is visiting or living there. It someone we love, who is visiting or living there. It could someone we love, who is visiting or living there. It could be someone we love, who is visiting or living there. It could be someone living there. It could be someone that living there. It could be someone that we living there. It could be someone that we know living there. It could be someone that we know that living there. It could be someone that we know that has living there. It could be someone that we know that has been living there. It could be someone that we know that has been faced that we know that has been faced with that we know that has been faced with these that we know that has been faced with these terrorists. that we know that has been faced with these terrorists. So that we know that has been faced with these terrorists. So we that we know that has been faced with these terrorists. So we stand with these terrorists. So we stand united with these terrorists. So we stand united with with these terrorists. So we stand united with London with these terrorists. So we stand united with London and with these terrorists. So we stand united with London and condemn with these terrorists. So we stand united with London and condemn these united with London and condemn these attacks united with London and condemn these attacks and united with London and condemn these attacks and pledge united with London and condemn these attacks and pledge toet united with London and condemn these attacks and pledge toet continue attacks and pledge toet continue with attacks and pledge toet continue with the attacks and pledge toet continue with the international attacks and pledge toet continue with the international community attacks and pledge toet continue with the international community in with the international community in its with the international community in its efforts with the international community in its efforts to with the international community in its efforts to combat with the international community in its efforts to combat terrorism. its efforts to combat terrorism. Grant its efforts to combat terrorism. Grant Robertson. its efforts to combat terrorism. Grant Robertson. On its efforts to combat terrorism. Grant Robertson. On behalf its efforts to combat terrorism. Grant Robertson. On behalf of its efforts to combat terrorism. Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Party Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Party I Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Party I rise Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Party I rise to Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Party I rise to support Grant Robertson. On behalf of the Labour Party I rise to support the Labour Party I rise to support the Government's Labour Party I rise to support the Government's motion. Labour Party I rise to support the Government's motion. Our Labour Party I rise to support the Government's motion. Our thoughts Government's motion. Our thoughts and Government's motion. Our thoughts and love Government's motion. Our thoughts and love are Government's motion. Our thoughts and love are with Government's motion. Our thoughts and love are with the Government's motion. Our thoughts and love are with the victims, Government's motion. Our thoughts and love are with the victims, their and love are with the victims, their families and love are with the victims, their families and and love are with the victims, their families and all and love are with the victims, their families and all those and love are with the victims, their families and all those in and love are with the victims, their families and all those in London and love are with the victims, their families and all those in London who families and all those in London who are families and all those in London who are dealing families and all those in London who are dealing with families and all those in London who are dealing with the families and all those in London who are dealing with the hurt, families and all those in London who are dealing with the hurt, anxiety are dealing with the hurt, anxiety and are dealing with the hurt, anxiety and fear are dealing with the hurt, anxiety and fear that are dealing with the hurt, anxiety and fear that these are dealing with the hurt, anxiety and fear that these horrific are dealing with the hurt, anxiety and fear that these horrific attacks and fear that these horrific attacks have and fear that these horrific attacks have caused. and fear that these horrific attacks have caused. Wherever and fear that these horrific attacks have caused. Wherever in and fear that these horrific attacks have caused. Wherever in the and fear that these horrific attacks have caused. Wherever in the world have caused. Wherever in the world terrorist have caused. Wherever in the world terrorist attacks have caused. Wherever in the world terrorist attacks occur, have caused. Wherever in the world terrorist attacks occur, we have caused. Wherever in the world terrorist attacks occur, we feel have caused. Wherever in the world terrorist attacks occur, we feel the terrorist attacks occur, we feel the pain terrorist attacks occur, we feel the pain of terrorist attacks occur, we feel the pain of those terrorist attacks occur, we feel the pain of those involved terrorist attacks occur, we feel the pain of those involved and terrorist attacks occur, we feel the pain of those involved and during pain of those involved and during the pain of those involved and during the last pain of those involved and during the last few pain of those involved and during the last few days pain of those involved and during the last few days we pain of those involved and during the last few days we have pain of those involved and during the last few days we have seen the last few days we have seen massive the last few days we have seen massive damage the last few days we have seen massive damage in the last few days we have seen massive damage in Kabul the last few days we have seen massive damage in Kabul as the last few days we have seen massive damage in Kabul as well the last few days we have seen massive damage in Kabul as well and massive damage in Kabul as well and massive damage in Kabul as well and massive damage in Kabul as well and we think massive damage in Kabul as well and we think of massive damage in Kabul as well and we think of those massive damage in Kabul as well and we think of those who massive damage in Kabul as well and we think of those who lost massive damage in Kabul as well and we think of those who lost loved we think of those who lost loved we think of those who lost loved we think of those who lost loved ones there we think of those who lost loved ones there too. we think of those who lost loved ones there too. For we think of those who lost loved ones there too. For many we think of those who lost loved ones there too. For many New ones there too. For many New Zealanders ones there too. For many New Zealanders they ones there too. For many New Zealanders they feel ones there too. For many New Zealanders they feel this ones there too. For many New Zealanders they feel this tragedy Zealanders they feel this tragedy even Zealanders they feel this tragedy even more Zealanders they feel this tragedy even more so Zealanders they feel this tragedy even more so because Zealanders they feel this tragedy even more so because we Zealanders they feel this tragedy even more so because we ourselves even more so because we ourselves have even more so because we ourselves have been even more so because we ourselves have been to even more so because we ourselves have been to those even more so because we ourselves have been to those very even more so because we ourselves have been to those very spots even more so because we ourselves have been to those very spots around have been to those very spots around London have been to those very spots around London bridge have been to those very spots around London bridge and have been to those very spots around London bridge and Borough have been to those very spots around London bridge and Borough Market have been to those very spots around London bridge and Borough Market and London bridge and Borough Market and we London bridge and Borough Market and we have London bridge and Borough Market and we have family London bridge and Borough Market and we have family and London bridge and Borough Market and we have family and friends London bridge and Borough Market and we have family and friends who London bridge and Borough Market and we have family and friends who live we have family and friends who live in we have family and friends who live in London. we have family and friends who live in London. On we have family and friends who live in London. On that we have family and friends who live in London. On that note we have family and friends who live in London. On that note I we have family and friends who live in London. On that note I want we have family and friends who live in London. On that note I want to in London. On that note I want to express in London. On that note I want to express to in London. On that note I want to express to Oliver in London. On that note I want to express to Oliver Dowling in London. On that note I want to express to Oliver Dowling and in London. On that note I want to express to Oliver Dowling and his express to Oliver Dowling and his express to Oliver Dowling and his express to Oliver Dowling and his family our express to Oliver Dowling and his family our very express to Oliver Dowling and his family our very best express to Oliver Dowling and his family our very best wishes express to Oliver Dowling and his family our very best wishes for express to Oliver Dowling and his family our very best wishes for his family our very best wishes for his recovery. family our very best wishes for his recovery. To family our very best wishes for his recovery. To the family our very best wishes for his recovery. To the people family our very best wishes for his recovery. To the people of family our very best wishes for his recovery. To the people of London recovery. To the people of London and, recovery. To the people of London and, in recovery. To the people of London and, in particular, recovery. To the people of London and, in particular, their recovery. To the people of London and, in particular, their mayor and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq Khan and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq Khan I and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq Khan I want and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq Khan I want to and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq Khan I want to expression and, in particular, their mayor Sadiq Khan I want to expression our Sadiq Khan I want to expression our ongoing Sadiq Khan I want to expression our ongoing support. Sadiq Khan I want to expression our ongoing support. To Sadiq Khan I want to expression our ongoing support. To the Sadiq Khan I want to expression our ongoing support. To the emergency ongoing support. To the emergency ongoing support. To the emergency ongoing support. To the emergency services personnel ongoing support. To the emergency services personnel who ongoing support. To the emergency services personnel who once ongoing support. To the emergency services personnel who once again services personnel who once again services personnel who once again services personnel who once again found themselves services personnel who once again found themselves in services personnel who once again found themselves in harm's services personnel who once again found themselves in harm's way, services personnel who once again found themselves in harm's way, your found themselves in harm's way, your bravery found themselves in harm's way, your bravery and found themselves in harm's way, your bravery and courage found themselves in harm's way, your bravery and courage are found themselves in harm's way, your bravery and courage are remarkable. bravery and courage are remarkable. There bravery and courage are remarkable. There were bravery and courage are remarkable. There were many bravery and courage are remarkable. There were many ordinary bravery and courage are remarkable. There were many ordinary people bravery and courage are remarkable. There were many ordinary people out There were many ordinary people out enjoying There were many ordinary people out enjoying a There were many ordinary people out enjoying a Saturday There were many ordinary people out enjoying a Saturday evening There were many ordinary people out enjoying a Saturday evening who enjoying a Saturday evening who showed enjoying a Saturday evening who showed similar enjoying a Saturday evening who showed similar courage enjoying a Saturday evening who showed similar courage by enjoying a Saturday evening who showed similar courage by standing showed similar courage by standing up showed similar courage by standing up to showed similar courage by standing up to the showed similar courage by standing up to the attackers showed similar courage by standing up to the attackers and showed similar courage by standing up to the attackers and we showed similar courage by standing up to the attackers and we thank showed similar courage by standing up to the attackers and we thank all up to the attackers and we thank all of up to the attackers and we thank all of them up to the attackers and we thank all of them too. up to the attackers and we thank all of them too. Then up to the attackers and we thank all of them too. Then there up to the attackers and we thank all of them too. Then there were up to the attackers and we thank all of them too. Then there were the of them too. Then there were the symbolic of them too. Then there were the symbolic acts of them too. Then there were the symbolic acts of of them too. Then there were the symbolic acts of kindness, of them too. Then there were the symbolic acts of kindness, and symbolic acts of kindness, and frankly, symbolic acts of kindness, and frankly, Britishness symbolic acts of kindness, and frankly, Britishness that symbolic acts of kindness, and frankly, Britishness that happened. frankly, Britishness that happened. The frankly, Britishness that happened. The man frankly, Britishness that happened. The man who frankly, Britishness that happened. The man who burn frankly, Britishness that happened. The man who burn returned frankly, Britishness that happened. The man who burn returned to frankly, Britishness that happened. The man who burn returned to -- frankly, Britishness that happened. The man who burn returned to -- who The man who burn returned to -- who returned The man who burn returned to -- who symbolic The man who burn returned to -- who returned to the The man who burn returned to -- who returned to the bar The man who burn returned to -- who returned to the bar on The man who burn returned to -- who returned to the bar on Sunday The man who burn returned to -- who returned to the bar on Sunday to The man who burn returned to -- who returned to the bar on Sunday to pay returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his bill. returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his bill. And returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his bill. And to returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his bill. And to all returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his bill. And to all Armstrong returned to the bar on Sunday to pay his bill. And to all Armstrong who his bill. And to all Armstrong who is his bill. And to all Armstrong who is the his bill. And to all Armstrong who is the most his bill. And to all Armstrong who is the most unlikely his bill. And to all Armstrong who is the most unlikely hero his bill. And to all Armstrong who is the most unlikely hero for his bill. And to all Armstrong who is the most unlikely hero for the is the most unlikely hero for the most is the most unlikely hero for the most British is the most unlikely hero for the most British approach is the most unlikely hero for the most British approach of is the most unlikely hero for the most British approach of taking is the most unlikely hero for the most British approach of taking his most British approach of taking his half-drunk most British approach of taking his half-drunk pint most British approach of taking his half-drunk pint with most British approach of taking his half-drunk pint with him most British approach of taking his half-drunk pint with him as most British approach of taking his half-drunk pint with him as he most British approach of taking his half-drunk pint with him as he fled half-drunk pint with him as he fled the half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. Having half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. Having been half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. Having been to half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. Having been to some half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. Having been to some of half-drunk pint with him as he fled the bars. Having been to some of the the bars. Having been to some of the bars the bars. Having been to some of the bars in the bars. Having been to some of the bars in Borough the bars. Having been to some of the bars in Borough Market the bars. Having been to some of the bars in Borough Market and the bars. Having been to some of the bars in Borough Market and having bars in Borough Market and having paid bars in Borough Market and having paid five bars in Borough Market and having paid five pounds bars in Borough Market and having paid five pounds for bars in Borough Market and having paid five pounds for a bars in Borough Market and having paid five pounds for a beer, bars in Borough Market and having paid five pounds for a beer, that paid five pounds for a beer, that was paid five pounds for a beer, that was an paid five pounds for a beer, that was an act paid five pounds for a beer, that was an act of paid five pounds for a beer, that was an act of pure paid five pounds for a beer, that was an act of pure common paid five pounds for a beer, that was an act of pure common sense. paid five pounds for a beer, that was an act of pure common sense. As was an act of pure common sense. As the was an act of pure common sense. As the UK was an act of pure common sense. As the UK heads was an act of pure common sense. As the UK heads towards was an act of pure common sense. As the UK heads towards its was an act of pure common sense. As the UK heads towards its election was an act of pure common sense. As the UK heads towards its election at the UK heads towards its election at the the UK heads towards its election at the end the UK heads towards its election at the end of the UK heads towards its election at the end of the the UK heads towards its election at the end of the week, the UK heads towards its election at the end of the week, now the UK heads towards its election at the end of the week, now is the UK heads towards its election at the end of the week, now is the the UK heads towards its election at the end of the week, now is the time the end of the week, now is the time for the end of the week, now is the time for all the end of the week, now is the time for all of the end of the week, now is the time for all of us the end of the week, now is the time for all of us to the end of the week, now is the time for all of us to stand the end of the week, now is the time for all of us to stand up the end of the week, now is the time for all of us to stand up for the end of the week, now is the time for all of us to stand up for the for all of us to stand up for the values for all of us to stand up for the for for all of us to stand up for the values of democracy. for all of us to stand up for the values of democracy. Our for all of us to stand up for the values of democracy. Our commitment values of democracy. Our commitment to values of democracy. Our commitment to freedom, values of democracy. Our commitment to freedom, fairness values of democracy. Our commitment to freedom, fairness and values of democracy. Our commitment to freedom, fairness and inclusion to freedom, fairness and inclusion must to freedom, fairness and inclusion must never to freedom, fairness and inclusion must never be to freedom, fairness and inclusion must never be broken to freedom, fairness and inclusion must never be broken by to freedom, fairness and inclusion must never be broken by terrorism to freedom, fairness and inclusion must never be broken by terrorism or must never be broken by terrorism or extremism. must never be broken by terrorism or extremism. We must never be broken by terrorism or extremism. We will must never be broken by terrorism or extremism. We will strengthen must never be broken by terrorism or extremism. We will strengthen all must never be broken by terrorism or extremism. We will strengthen all of extremism. We will strengthen all of our extremism. We will strengthen all of our communities extremism. We will strengthen all of our communities as extremism. We will strengthen all of our communities as we extremism. We will strengthen all of our communities as we stand extremism. We will strengthen all of our communities as we stand united our communities as we stand united in our communities as we stand united must our communities as we stand united in support of our communities as we stand united in support of the our communities as we stand united in support of the people our communities as we stand united in support of the people of our communities as we stand united in support of the people of London, in support of the people of London, Manchester in support of the people of London, Manchester and in support of the people of London, Manchester and all in support of the people of London, Manchester and all around in support of the people of London, Manchester and all around the in support of the people of London, Manchester and all around the world Manchester and all around the world and Manchester and all around the world and against Manchester and all around the world and against those Manchester and all around the world and against those who Manchester and all around the world and against those who seek Manchester and all around the world and against those who seek to Manchester and all around the world and against those who seek to divide and against those who seek to divide us. and against those who seek to divide us. In and against those who seek to divide us. In New and against those who seek to divide us. In New Zealand and against those who seek to divide us. In New Zealand we and against those who seek to divide us. In New Zealand we think and against those who seek to divide us. In New Zealand we think of and against those who seek to divide us. In New Zealand we think of all us. In New Zealand we think of all of us. In New Zealand we think of all of those us. In New Zealand we think of all of those affected us. In New Zealand we think of all of those affected including us. In New Zealand we think of all of those affected including the of those affected including the members of those affected including the members and of those affected including the members and supporters of those affected including the members and supporters of of those affected including the members and supporters of the members and supporters of the British members and supporters of the British and members and supporters of the British and Irish members and supporters of the British and Irish Lions members and supporters of the British and Irish Lions who members and supporters of the British and Irish Lions who will British and Irish Lions who will feel British and Irish Lions who will feel very British and Irish Lions who will feel very far British and Irish Lions who will feel very far from British and Irish Lions who will feel very far from home British and Irish Lions who will feel very far from home at British and Irish Lions who will feel very far from home at this feel very far from home at this time. feel very far from home at this time. We feel very far from home at this time. We should feel very far from home at this time. We should also feel very far from home at this time. We should also show feel very far from home at this time. We should also show our time. We should also show our support time. We should also show our support to time. We should also show our support to the time. We should also show our support to the Muslim time. We should also show our support to the Muslim community time. We should also show our support to the Muslim community here support to the Muslim community here support to the Muslim community here support to the Muslim community here in New support to the Muslim community here in New Zealand support to the Muslim community here in New Zealand who support to the Muslim community here in New Zealand who are support to the Muslim community here in New Zealand who are as support to the Muslim community here in New Zealand who are as appalled in New Zealand who are as appalled and in New Zealand who are as appalled and disgusted in New Zealand who are as appalled and disgusted by in New Zealand who are as appalled and disgusted by the in New Zealand who are as appalled and disgusted by the actions in New Zealand who are as appalled and disgusted by the actions of and disgusted by the actions of these and disgusted by the actions of these terrorists and disgusted by the actions of these terrorists as and disgusted by the actions of these terrorists as anyone and disgusted by the actions of these terrorists as anyone else. and disgusted by the actions of these terrorists as anyone else. We these terrorists as anyone else. We can these terrorists as anyone else. We can defeat these terrorists as anyone else. We can defeat these these terrorists as anyone else. We can defeat these extremists these terrorists as anyone else. We can defeat these extremists through can defeat these extremists through our can defeat these extremists through our unity, can defeat these extremists through our unity, acceptance can defeat these extremists through our unity, acceptance of can defeat these extremists through our unity, acceptance of diversity our unity, acceptance of diversity and our unity, acceptance of diversity and our our unity, acceptance of diversity and our resolve our unity, acceptance of diversity and our resolve to our unity, acceptance of diversity and our resolve to not our unity, acceptance of diversity and our resolve to not allow our unity, acceptance of diversity and our resolve to not allow hatred and our resolve to not allow hatred and and our resolve to not allow hatred and intolerance and our resolve to not allow hatred and intolerance to and our resolve to not allow hatred and intolerance to grow. and our resolve to not allow hatred and intolerance to grow. As and our resolve to not allow hatred and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan has and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan has said and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan has said today, and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan has said today, our and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan has said today, our city and intolerance to grow. As Sadiq Khan has said today, our city is Khan has said today, our city is filled Khan has said today, our city is filled with Khan has said today, our city is filled with great Khan has said today, our city is filled with great sorrow Khan has said today, our city is filled with great sorrow and Khan has said today, our city is filled with great sorrow and anger filled with great sorrow and anger tonight filled with great sorrow and anger tonight but filled with great sorrow and anger tonight but also filled with great sorrow and anger tonight but also great filled with great sorrow and anger tonight but also great resolve filled with great sorrow and anger tonight but also great resolve and tonight but also great resolve and determination tonight but also great resolve and determination because tonight but also great resolve and determination because our tonight but also great resolve and determination because our unity tonight but also great resolve and determination because our unity and determination because our unity and love determination because our unity and love will determination because our unity and love will always determination because our unity and love will always be determination because our unity and love will always be stronger determination because our unity and love will always be stronger than love will always be stronger than the love will always be stronger than the hate love will always be stronger than the hate of love will always be stronger than the hate of the love will always be stronger than the hate of the extremists. love will always be stronger than the hate of the extremists. Here love will always be stronger than the hate of the extremists. Here in the hate of the extremists. Here in New the hate of the extremists. Here in New Zealand the hate of the extremists. Here in New Zealand we express the hate of the extremists. Here in New Zealand we express our the hate of the extremists. Here in New Zealand we express our unity New Zealand we express our unity with New Zealand we express our unity with all New Zealand we express our unity with all of New Zealand we express our unity with all of those New Zealand we express our unity with all of those in New Zealand we express our unity with all of those in London New Zealand we express our unity with all of those in London and with all of those in London and beyond. beyond. <SPEAKS beyond. <SPEAKS TE beyond. <SPEAKS TE REO beyond. <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> James James Shaw. James Shaw. I James Shaw. I rise James Shaw. I rise on James Shaw. I rise on behalf James Shaw. I rise on behalf of James Shaw. I rise on behalf of the James Shaw. I rise on behalf of the Green James Shaw. I rise on behalf of the Green Party James Shaw. I rise on behalf of the Green Party to James Shaw. I rise on behalf of the Green Party to express James Shaw. I rise on behalf of the Green Party to express our Green Party to express our condolences Green Party to express our condolences and Green Party to express our condolences and our Green Party to express our condolences and our deepest condolences and our deepest sympathies condolences and our deepest sympathies to condolences and our deepest sympathies to those condolences and our deepest sympathies to those families condolences and our deepest sympathies to those families in sympathies to those families in London, sympathies to those families in London, the sympathies to those families in London, the communities sympathies to those families in London, the communities in sympathies to those families in London, the communities in London London, the communities in London London, the communities in London London, the communities in London who have London, the communities in London who have been London, the communities in London who have been affected London, the communities in London who have been affected by who have been affected by this who have been affected by who have been affected by this attack. I who have been affected by this attack. I want who have been affected by this attack. I want to who have been affected by this attack. I want to agree who have been affected by this attack. I want to agree with who have been affected by this attack. I want to agree with some who have been affected by this attack. I want to agree with some of attack. I want to agree with some of the attack. I want to agree with some of the previous attack. I want to agree with some of the previous sentiments attack. I want to agree with some of the previous sentiments that attack. I want to agree with some of the previous sentiments that there the previous sentiments that there are the previous sentiments that there are attacks the previous sentiments that there are attacks occurring the previous sentiments that there are attacks occurring in the previous sentiments that there are attacks occurring in many are attacks occurring in many countries are attacks occurring in many countries around are attacks occurring in many countries around the are attacks occurring in many countries around the world, are attacks occurring in many countries around the world, every countries around the world, every day countries around the world, every day of countries around the world, every day of the countries around the world, every day of the week. countries around the world, every day of the week. Yet, countries around the world, every day of the week. Yet, because countries around the world, every day of the week. Yet, because this day of the week. Yet, because this one day of the week. Yet, because this one was day of the week. Yet, because this one was in day of the week. Yet, because this one was in London day of the week. Yet, because this one was in London and day of the week. Yet, because this one was in London and so day of the week. Yet, because this one was in London and so many day of the week. Yet, because this one was in London and so many New one was in London and so many New Zealanders one was in London and so many New Zealanders have one was in London and so many New Zealanders have such one was in London and so many New Zealanders have such deep one was in London and so many New Zealanders have such deep personal Zealanders have such deep personal relationships Zealanders have such deep personal relationships with Zealanders have such deep personal relationships with the Zealanders have such deep personal relationships with the United relationships with the United Kingdom, relationships with the United Kingdom, with relationships with the United Kingdom, with London, relationships with the United Kingdom, with London, that relationships with the United Kingdom, with London, that this relationships with the United Kingdom, with London, that this one Kingdom, with London, that this one feels Kingdom, with London, that this one feels so Kingdom, with London, that this one feels so much Kingdom, with London, that this one feels so much more Kingdom, with London, that this one feels so much more personal. Kingdom, with London, that this one feels so much more personal. As feels so much more personal. As someone feels so much more personal. As someone who feels so much more personal. As someone who lived feels so much more personal. As someone who lived there feels so much more personal. As someone who lived there myself feels so much more personal. As someone who lived there myself for someone who lived there myself for many someone who lived there myself for many years someone who lived there myself for many years and someone who lived there myself for many years and had someone who lived there myself for many years and had my someone who lived there myself for many years and had my first someone who lived there myself for many years and had my first pub many years and had my first pub lunch many years and had my first pub lunch at many years and had my first pub lunch at the many years and had my first pub lunch at the pub many years and had my first pub lunch at the pub that many years and had my first pub lunch at the pub that was many years and had my first pub lunch at the pub that was attacked lunch at the pub that was attacked that lunch at the pub that was attacked that day, lunch at the pub that was attacked that day, it lunch at the pub that was attacked that day, it does lunch at the pub that was attacked that day, it does feel lunch at the pub that was attacked that day, it does feel extremely that day, it does feel extremely personal that day, it does feel extremely personal that that day, it does feel extremely personal that this that day, it does feel extremely personal that this happened that day, it does feel extremely personal that this happened even personal that this happened even though personal that this happened even though it personal that this happened even though it is personal that this happened even though it is on personal that this happened even though it is on the personal that this happened even though it is on the soer personal that this happened even though it is on the soer side personal that this happened even though it is on the soer side of personal that this happened even though it is on the soer side of the though it is on the soer side of the world. though it is on the soer side of the world. London though it is on the soer side of the world. London is, though it is on the soer side of the world. London is, of though it is on the soer side of the world. London is, of course, though it is on the soer side of the world. London is, of course, sadly world. London is, of course, sadly not world. London is, of course, sadly not unfamiliar world. London is, of course, sadly not unfamiliar with world. London is, of course, sadly not unfamiliar with terrorist not unfamiliar with terrorist not unfamiliar with terrorist not unfamiliar with terrorist attacks. Going not unfamiliar with terrorist attacks. Going back not unfamiliar with terrorist attacks. Going back through not unfamiliar with terrorist attacks. Going back through much attacks. Going back through much of attacks. Going back through much attacks. Going back through much of its history, attacks. Going back through much of its history, in attacks. Going back through much of its history, in the attacks. Going back through much of its history, in the time attacks. Going back through much of its history, in the time that attacks. Going back through much of its history, in the time that I attacks. Going back through much of its history, in the time that I was its history, in the time that I was there its history, in the time that I was there somebody its history, in the time that I was there somebody let its history, in the time that I was there somebody let off its history, in the time that I was there somebody let off three its history, in the time that I was there somebody let off three nail there somebody let off three nail bombs there somebody let off three nail bombs in there somebody let off three nail bombs in various there somebody let off three nail bombs in various parts there somebody let off three nail bombs in various parts hoping there somebody let off three nail bombs in various parts hoping to bombs in various parts hoping to drive bombs in various parts hoping to drive the bombs in various parts hoping to drive the Indian bombs in various parts hoping to drive the Indian community, bombs in various parts hoping to drive the Indian community, the drive the Indian community, the African drive the Indian community, the African community drive the Indian community, the African community and drive the Indian community, the African community and the drive the Indian community, the African community and the gay African community and the gay community African community and the gay community into African community and the gay community into the African community and the gay community into the ocean. African community and the gay community into the ocean. A African community and the gay community into the ocean. A second community into the ocean. A second set community into the ocean. A second set of community into the ocean. A second set of bombings community into the ocean. A second set of bombings occurred, community into the ocean. A second set of bombings occurred, of community into the ocean. A second set of bombings occurred, of course set of bombings occurred, of course the set of bombings occurred, of course the infamous set of bombings occurred, of course the infamous 7 set of bombings occurred, of course the infamous 7 July set of bombings occurred, of course the infamous 7 July bombings set of bombings occurred, of course the infamous 7 July bombings in set of bombings occurred, of course the infamous 7 July bombings in the the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube and the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube and on the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube and on buses the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube and on buses and the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube and on buses and now the infamous 7 July bombings in the tube and on buses and now this. tube and on buses and now this. London tube and on buses and now this. London has tube and on buses and now this. London has always tube and on buses and now this. London has always kept tube and on buses and now this. London has always kept going, tube and on buses and now this. London has always kept going, has London has always kept going, has stood London has always kept going, has stood strong London has always kept going, has stood strong through London has always kept going, has stood strong through all London has always kept going, has stood strong through all of London has always kept going, has stood strong through all of these stood strong through all of these stood strong through all of these stood strong through all of these but all stood strong through all of these but all of stood strong through all of these but all of them stood strong through all of these but all of them are stood strong through all of these but all of them are a stood strong through all of these but all of them are a tragedy stood strong through all of these but all of them are a tragedy and but all of them are a tragedy and but all of them are a tragedy and but all of them are a tragedy and this one but all of them are a tragedy and this one no but all of them are a tragedy and this one no less. but all of them are a tragedy and this one no less. We but all of them are a tragedy and this one no less. We do but all of them are a tragedy and this one no less. We do offer but all of them are a tragedy and this one no less. We do offer our this one no less. We do offer our deepest this one no less. We do offer our deepest sympathies this one no less. We do offer our deepest sympathies and this one no less. We do offer our deepest sympathies and our deepest sympathies and our condolences deepest sympathies and our condolences to deepest sympathies and our condolences to all deepest sympathies and our condolences to all of deepest sympathies and our condolences to all of those, condolences to all of those, condolences to all of those, condolences to all of those, particularly to condolences to all of those, particularly to the condolences to all of those, particularly to the family condolences to all of those, particularly to the family of condolences to all of those, particularly to the family of Oliver particularly to the family of Oliver Dowling, particularly to the family of Oliver Dowling, the particularly to the family of Oliver Dowling, the New particularly to the family of Oliver Dowling, the New Zealander particularly to the family of Oliver Dowling, the New Zealander who particularly to the family of Oliver Dowling, the New Zealander who was Dowling, the New Zealander who was Dowling, the New Zealander who was Dowling, the New Zealander who was killed there. Dowling, the New Zealander who was killed there. To Dowling, the New Zealander who was killed there. To the Dowling, the New Zealander who was killed there. To the mayor, Dowling, the New Zealander who was killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, and killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, and the killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, and the people killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, and the people of killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, and the people of London, killed there. To the mayor, Sadiq Khan, and the people of London, we Khan, and the people of London, we Khan, Khan, and the people of London, we want to say, Khan, and the people of London, we want to say, "We Khan, and the people of London, we want to say, "We are Khan, and the people of London, we want to say, "We are with Khan, and the people of London, we want to say, "We are with you." want to say, "We are with you." want to say, "We are with you." want to say, "We are with you." <SPEAKS TE want to say, "We are with you." <SPEAKS TE REO want to say, "We are with you." <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> The <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> The Rt <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> The Rt Hon <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> The Rt Hon Winston <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> The Rt Hon Winston Peters. <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New Zealand The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New Zealand First The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New Zealand First joins The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New Zealand First joins with The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New Zealand First joins with others The Rt Hon Winston Peters. New Zealand First joins with others in Zealand First joins with others in their Zealand First joins with others in their sentiments Zealand First joins with others in their sentiments regarding Zealand First joins with others in their sentiments regarding the their sentiments regarding the disastrous their sentiments regarding the disastrous outrage their sentiments regarding the disastrous outrage in their sentiments regarding the disastrous outrage in Britain, disastrous outrage in Britain, especially disastrous outrage in Britain, especially those disastrous outrage in Britain, especially those families disastrous outrage in Britain, especially those families affected especially those families affected by especially those families affected by this especially those families affected by this latest especially those families affected by this latest atrocity. especially those families affected by this latest atrocity. This by this latest atrocity. This includes, by this latest atrocity. This includes, as by this latest atrocity. This includes, as we by this latest atrocity. This includes, as we know, by this latest atrocity. This includes, as we know, a by this latest atrocity. This includes, as we know, a New includes, as we know, a New Zealander includes, as we know, a New Zealander and includes, as we know, a New Zealander and our includes, as we know, a New Zealander and our con includes, as we know, a New Zealander and our con dollences includes, as we know, a New Zealander and our con dollences go Zealander and our con dollences go out Zealander and our con dollences go out to Zealander and our con dollences go out to all Zealander and our con dollences go out to all his Zealander and our con dollences go out to all his family Zealander and our con dollences go out to all his family -- Zealander and our con dollences go out to all his family -- condolences out to all his family -- condolences go out to all his family -- condolences go out out to all his family -- condolences go out to out to all his family -- condolences go out to all out to all his family -- condolences go out to all his out to all his family -- condolences go out to all his family out to all his family -- condolences go out to all his family and go out to all his family and friends. go out to all his family and friends. Our go out to all his family and friends. Our con go out to all his family and friends. Our con dollences go out to all his family and friends. Our con dollences extend friends. Our con dollences extend across friends. Our con dollences extend across the friends. Our con dollences extend across the Tasman friends. Our con dollences extend across the Tasman with friends. Our con dollences extend across the Tasman with events friends. Our con dollences extend across the Tasman with events today across the Tasman with events today no across the Tasman with events today no Melbourne. across the Tasman with events today no Melbourne. This across the Tasman with events today no Melbourne. This shows across the Tasman with events today no Melbourne. This shows a across the Tasman with events today no Melbourne. This shows a degree across the Tasman with events today no Melbourne. This shows a degree of no Melbourne. This shows a degree of calculation no Melbourne. This shows a degree of calculation with no Melbourne. This shows a degree of calculation with their no Melbourne. This shows a degree of calculation with their general calculation with their general election calculation with their general election this calculation with their general election this week calculation with their general election this week in calculation with their general election this week in Britain. calculation with their general election this week in Britain. It election this week in Britain. It becomes election this week in Britain. It becomes nothing election this week in Britain. It becomes nothing less election this week in Britain. It becomes nothing less than election this week in Britain. It becomes nothing less than an election this week in Britain. It becomes nothing less than an attack becomes nothing less than an attack on becomes nothing less than an attack on democracy, becomes nothing less than an attack on democracy, which becomes nothing less than an attack on democracy, which must becomes nothing less than an attack on democracy, which must not becomes nothing less than an attack on democracy, which must not be on democracy, which must not be allowed on democracy, which must not be allowed to on democracy, which must not be allowed to succeed. on democracy, which must not be allowed to succeed. There on democracy, which must not be allowed to succeed. There has on democracy, which must not be allowed to succeed. There has been on democracy, which must not be allowed to succeed. There has been a allowed to succeed. There has been a tendency allowed to succeed. There has been a tendency to allowed to succeed. There has been a tendency to minimise allowed to succeed. There has been a tendency to minimise these allowed to succeed. There has been a tendency to minimise these attacks tendency to minimise these attacks tendency to minimise these attacks tendency to minimise these attacks as self-radicalised, tendency to minimise these attacks as self-radicalised, lone tendency to minimise these attacks as self-radicalised, lone wolves tendency to minimise these attacks as self-radicalised, lone wolves or as self-radicalised, lone wolves or passed as self-radicalised, lone wolves or passed off as self-radicalised, lone wolves or passed off from as self-radicalised, lone wolves or passed off from people as self-radicalised, lone wolves or passed off from people who as self-radicalised, lone wolves or passed off from people who are passed off from people who are unhinged. passed off from people who are unhinged. That passed off from people who are unhinged. That needs passed off from people who are unhinged. That needs to passed off from people who are unhinged. That needs to be unhinged. That needs to be completely unhinged. That needs to be completely rethought unhinged. That needs to be completely rethought in unhinged. That needs to be completely rethought in the unhinged. That needs to be completely rethought in the West. unhinged. That needs to be completely rethought in the West. 77 completely rethought in the West. 77 days completely rethought in the West. 77 days on completely rethought in the West. 77 days on from completely rethought in the West. 77 days on from the completely rethought in the West. 77 days on from the last completely rethought in the West. 77 days on from the last motion completely rethought in the West. 77 days on from the last motion in completely rethought in the West. 77 days on from the last motion in this days on from the last motion in this house days on from the last motion in this house following days on from the last motion in this house following the days on from the last motion in this house following the murder days on from the last motion in this house following the murder of days on from the last motion in this house following the murder of five house following the murder of five people house following the murder of five people on house following the murder of five people on Westminster house following the murder of five people on Westminster Bridge, house following the murder of five people on Westminster Bridge, what people on Westminster Bridge, what people on Westminster Bridge, what people on Westminster Bridge, what have we people on Westminster Bridge, what have we seen? people on Westminster Bridge, what have we seen? Within people on Westminster Bridge, what have we seen? Within several people on Westminster Bridge, what have we seen? Within several weeks have we seen? Within several weeks of have we seen? Within several weeks of that have we seen? Within several weeks of that attack have we seen? Within several weeks of that attack on have we seen? Within several weeks of that attack on 3 have we seen? Within several weeks of that attack on 3 April, have we seen? Within several weeks of that attack on 3 April, innocents of that attack on 3 April, innocents were of that attack on 3 April, innocents were murdered of that attack on 3 April, innocents were murdered on of that attack on 3 April, innocents were murdered on the of that attack on 3 April, innocents were murdered on the St of that attack on 3 April, innocents were murdered on the St Petersburg were murdered on the St Petersburg metro were murdered on the St Petersburg metro by were murdered on the St Petersburg metro by a were murdered on the St Petersburg metro by a jihadist were murdered on the St Petersburg metro by a jihadist suitcase were murdered on the St Petersburg metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb and four metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb and four days metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb and four days later metro by a jihadist suitcase bomb and four days later a and four days later a rejected and four days later a and four days later a rejected asylum seeker and four days later a rejected asylum seeker in and four days later a rejected asylum seeker in Stockholm and four days later a rejected asylum seeker in Stockholm used and four days later a rejected asylum seeker in Stockholm used a asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck to asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck to murder asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck to murder five asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck to murder five people. asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck to murder five people. Then asylum seeker in Stockholm used a truck to murder five people. Then in truck to murder five people. Then in Manchester, truck to murder five people. Then in Manchester, 22 truck to murder five people. Then in Manchester, 22 people, truck to murder five people. Then in Manchester, 22 people, many truck to murder five people. Then in Manchester, 22 people, many of truck to murder five people. Then in Manchester, 22 people, many of them Manchester, 22 people, many of them children, Manchester, 22 people, many of them children, were Manchester, 22 people, many of them children, were murdered Manchester, 22 people, many of them children, were murdered by Manchester, 22 people, many of them children, were murdered by a Manchester, 22 people, many of them children, were murdered by a nail children, were murdered by a nail bomb. children, were murdered by a nail bomb. This children, were murdered by a nail bomb. This terrorist, children, were murdered by a nail bomb. This terrorist, while children, were murdered by a nail bomb. This terrorist, while British bomb. This terrorist, while British born, bomb. This terrorist, while British born, was bomb. This terrorist, while British born, was the bomb. This terrorist, while British born, was the son bomb. This terrorist, while British born, was the son of bomb. This terrorist, while British born, was the son of asylum bomb. This terrorist, while British born, was the son of asylum seekers born, was the son of asylum seekers who born, was the son of asylum seekers who were born, was the son of asylum seekers who were given born, was the son of asylum seekers who were given sanctuary born, was the son of asylum seekers who were given sanctuary in born, was the son of asylum seekers who were given sanctuary in the born, was the son of asylum seekers who were given sanctuary in the UK who were given sanctuary in the UK from who were given sanctuary in the UK from the who were given sanctuary in the UK from the rule who were given sanctuary in the UK from the rule of who were given sanctuary in the UK from the rule of Colonel who were given sanctuary in the UK from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. They from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. They were from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. They were a from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. They were a family from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. They were a family that from the rule of Colonel Gaddafi. They were a family that maintained They were a family that maintained close They were a family that maintained close ties They were a family that maintained close ties nevertheless They were a family that maintained close ties nevertheless with They were a family that maintained close ties nevertheless with Libyan close ties nevertheless with Libyan jihadists. close ties nevertheless with Libyan jihadists. What close ties nevertheless with Libyan jihadists. What we close ties nevertheless with Libyan jihadists. What we know close ties nevertheless with Libyan jihadists. What we know about close ties nevertheless with Libyan jihadists. What we know about the jihadists. What we know about the London jihadists. What we know about the London Bridge jihadists. What we know about the London Bridge attackers jihadists. What we know about the London Bridge attackers is jihadists. What we know about the London Bridge attackers is that jihadists. What we know about the London Bridge attackers is that two London Bridge attackers is that two of London Bridge attackers is that two of them London Bridge attackers is that two of them arrived London Bridge attackers is that two of them arrived in London Bridge attackers is that two of them arrived in the London Bridge attackers is that two of them arrived in the UK London Bridge attackers is that two of them arrived in the UK as of them arrived in the UK as immigrants. of them arrived in the UK as immigrants. One of them arrived in the UK as immigrants. One was of them arrived in the UK as immigrants. One was known of them arrived in the UK as immigrants. One was known to immigrants. One was known to officials immigrants. One was known to officials and immigrants. One was known to officials and even immigrants. One was known to officials and even TV immigrants. One was known to officials and even TV audiences. immigrants. One was known to officials and even TV audiences. We officials and even TV audiences. We must officials and even TV audiences. We must ask officials and even TV audiences. We must ask how officials and even TV audiences. We must ask how could officials and even TV audiences. We must ask how could people officials and even TV audiences. We must ask how could people plan officials and even TV audiences. We must ask how could people plan such must ask how could people plan such terrible must ask how could people plan such terrible deeds must ask how could people plan such terrible deeds but must ask how could people plan such terrible deeds but leave must ask how could people plan such terrible deeds but leave their terrible deeds but leave their friends, terrible deeds but leave their friends, fathers, terrible deeds but leave their friends, fathers, mothers, terrible deeds but leave their friends, fathers, mothers, ziers terrible deeds but leave their friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and spouses completely friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and spouses completely in friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and spouses completely in the friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and spouses completely in the dark. friends, fathers, mothers, ziers and spouses completely in the dark. We spouses completely in the dark. We will spouses completely in the dark. We will be spouses completely in the dark. We will be told spouses completely in the dark. We will be told that spouses completely in the dark. We will be told that if spouses completely in the dark. We will be told that if wider spouses completely in the dark. We will be told that if wider community will be told that if wider community knew will be told that if wider community knew nothing will be told that if wider community knew nothing and will be told that if wider community knew nothing and neither will be told that if wider community knew nothing and neither did will be told that if wider community knew nothing and neither did the knew nothing and neither did the friends knew nothing and neither did the will knew nothing and neither did the friends of the knew nothing and neither did the friends of the family. knew nothing and neither did the friends of the family. How knew nothing and neither did the friends of the family. How many friends of the family. How many times friends of the family. How many times have friends of the family. How many times have we friends of the family. How many times have we heard friends of the family. How many times have we heard this? friends of the family. How many times have we heard this? It friends of the family. How many times have we heard this? It is times have we heard this? It is washing times have we heard this? It is washing seriously times have we heard this? It is washing seriously thin. times have we heard this? It is washing seriously thin. What times have we heard this? It is washing seriously thin. What is washing seriously thin. What is happening washing seriously thin. What is happening is washing seriously thin. What is happening is that washing seriously thin. What is happening is that family, washing seriously thin. What is happening is that family, friends washing seriously thin. What is happening is that family, friends an happening is that family, friends an confidants happening is that family, friends an confidants are happening is that family, friends an confidants are choosing happening is that family, friends an confidants are choosing to happening is that family, friends an confidants are choosing to turn happening is that family, friends an confidants are choosing to turn the confidants are choosing to turn the other confidants are choosing to turn the other cheek, confidants are choosing to turn the other cheek, choosing confidants are choosing to turn the other cheek, choosing silence confidants are choosing to turn the other cheek, choosing silence rather other cheek, choosing silence rather than other cheek, choosing silence rather than to other cheek, choosing silence rather than to turn other cheek, choosing silence rather than to turn these other cheek, choosing silence rather than to turn these monsters other cheek, choosing silence rather than to turn these monsters in. other cheek, choosing silence rather than to turn these monsters in. That than to turn these monsters in. That may than to turn these monsters in. That may be than to turn these monsters in. That may be the than to turn these monsters in. That may be the culture than to turn these monsters in. That may be the culture of than to turn these monsters in. That may be the culture of Damascus than to turn these monsters in. That may be the culture of Damascus but may be the culture of Damascus but it may be the culture of Damascus but it is may be the culture of Damascus but it is not may be the culture of Damascus but it is not ours. may be the culture of Damascus but it is not ours. It may be the culture of Damascus but it is not ours. It may may be the culture of Damascus but it is not ours. It may be may be the culture of Damascus but it is not ours. It may be acceptable it is not ours. It may be acceptable in it is not ours. It may be acceptable in Tripoli, it is not ours. It may be acceptable in Tripoli, but it is not ours. It may be acceptable in Tripoli, but it it is not ours. It may be acceptable in Tripoli, but it most it is not ours. It may be acceptable in Tripoli, but it most certainly it is not ours. It may be acceptable in Tripoli, but it most certainly is in Tripoli, but it most certainly is in Tripoli, but it most certainly is in Tripoli, but it most certainly is not acceptable in Tripoli, but it most certainly is not acceptable in in Tripoli, but it most certainly is not acceptable in New in Tripoli, but it most certainly is not acceptable in New Zealand. in Tripoli, but it most certainly is not acceptable in New Zealand. While not acceptable in New Zealand. While the not acceptable in New Zealand. While the Islamic not acceptable in New Zealand. While the Islamic community not acceptable in New Zealand. While the Islamic community must not acceptable in New Zealand. While the Islamic community must clean the Islamic community must clean house the Islamic community must clean house by the Islamic community must clean house by turning the Islamic community must clean house by turning these the Islamic community must clean house by turning these monsters the Islamic community must clean house by turning these monsters in, house by turning these monsters in, it house by turning these monsters in, it starts house by turning these monsters in, it starts with house by turning these monsters in, it starts with their house by turning these monsters in, it starts with their own house by turning these monsters in, it starts with their own families. it starts with their own families. it starts with their own families. it starts with their own families. For New it starts with their own families. For New Zealand it starts with their own families. For New Zealand we it starts with their own families. For New Zealand we must it starts with their own families. For New Zealand we must avoid it starts with their own families. For New Zealand we must avoid the For New Zealand we must avoid the For New Zealand we must avoid the For New Zealand we must avoid the same politically For New Zealand we must avoid the same politically correct For New Zealand we must avoid the same politically correct trap For New Zealand we must avoid the same politically correct trap that same politically correct trap that has same politically correct trap that has allowed same politically correct trap that has allowed such same politically correct trap that has allowed such communities same politically correct trap that has allowed such communities apart has allowed such communities apart has allowed such communities apart has allowed such communities apart to form. has allowed such communities apart to form. That has allowed such communities apart to form. That is, has allowed such communities apart to form. That is, it has allowed such communities apart to form. That is, it is has allowed such communities apart to form. That is, it is we has allowed such communities apart to form. That is, it is we who has allowed such communities apart to form. That is, it is we who must to form. That is, it is we who must change, to form. That is, it is we who must change, they to form. That is, it is we who must change, they say, to form. That is, it is we who must change, they say, to to form. That is, it is we who must change, they say, to accommodate to form. That is, it is we who must change, they say, to accommodate the change, they say, to accommodate the cultural change, they say, to accommodate the cultural practices change, they say, to accommodate the cultural practices and change, they say, to accommodate the cultural practices and traditions change, they say, to accommodate the cultural practices and traditions of cultural practices and traditions of others. cultural practices and traditions of others. That cultural practices and traditions of others. That in cultural practices and traditions of others. That in some cultural practices and traditions of others. That in some twists cultural practices and traditions of others. That in some twists way cultural practices and traditions of others. That in some twists way of others. That in some twists way of inclusiveness, others. That in some twists way of inclusiveness, it others. That in some twists way of inclusiveness, it is others. That in some twists way of inclusiveness, it is we others. That in some twists way of inclusiveness, it is we who others. That in some twists way of inclusiveness, it is we who must inclusiveness, it is we who must change inclusiveness, it is we who must others. inclusiveness, it is we who must change and not inclusiveness, it is we who must change and not them. inclusiveness, it is we who must change and not them. No inclusiveness, it is we who must change and not them. No longer. inclusiveness, it is we who must change and not them. No longer. We change and not them. No longer. We must change and not them. No longer. We must stop change and not them. No longer. We must stop the change and not them. No longer. We must stop the slide change and not them. No longer. We must stop the slide as change and not them. No longer. We must stop the slide as a change and not them. No longer. We must stop the slide as a people, change and not them. No longer. We must stop the slide as a people, as must stop the slide as a people, as a must stop the slide as a people, as a culture must stop the slide as a people, as a culture in must stop the slide as a people, as a culture in the must stop the slide as a people, as a culture in the West, must stop the slide as a people, as a culture in the West, as must stop the slide as a people, as a culture in the West, as people must stop the slide as a people, as a culture in the West, as people who a culture in the West, as people who believe a culture in the West, as people who believe in a culture in the West, as people who believe in freedom a culture in the West, as people who believe in freedom and a culture in the West, as people who believe in freedom and liberty a culture in the West, as people who believe in freedom and liberty and believe in freedom and liberty and believe in freedom and liberty and believe in freedom and liberty and lead as believe in freedom and liberty and lead as a believe in freedom and liberty and lead as a country believe in freedom and liberty and lead as a country before believe in freedom and liberty and lead as a country before we believe in freedom and liberty and lead as a country before we see believe in freedom and liberty and lead as a country before we see in lead as a country before we see in lead as a country before we see in lead as a country before we see in this country, lead as a country before we see in this country, in lead as a country before we see in this country, in a lead as a country before we see in this country, in a New lead as a country before we see in this country, in a New Zealand this country, in a New Zealand locality, this country, in a New Zealand locality, a this country, in a New Zealand locality, a repeat this country, in a New Zealand locality, a repeat of this country, in a New Zealand locality, a repeat of these this country, in a New Zealand locality, a repeat of these events. locality, a repeat of these events. locality, a repeat of these events. locality, a repeat of these events. If we locality, a repeat of these events. If we are locality, a repeat of these events. If we are to locality, a repeat of these events. If we are to learn locality, a repeat of these events. If we are to learn from locality, a repeat of these events. If we are to learn from these If we are to learn from these attacks, If we are to learn from these attacks, we If we are to learn from these attacks, we must If we are to learn from these attacks, we must make If we are to learn from these attacks, we must make it If we are to learn from these attacks, we must make it clear If we are to learn from these attacks, we must make it clear that attacks, we must make it clear that attacks, we must make it clear that attacks, we must make it clear that we treasure attacks, we must make it clear that we treasure freedom attacks, we must make it clear that we treasure freedom of attacks, we must make it clear that we treasure freedom of expression we treasure freedom of expression we treasure freedom of expression we treasure freedom of expression and the we treasure freedom of expression and the liberty we treasure freedom of expression and the liberty of we treasure freedom of expression and the liberty of separate we treasure freedom of expression and the liberty of separate religion and the liberty of separate religion and and the liberty of separate religion and creeds and the liberty of separate religion and creeds and and the liberty of separate religion and creeds and that and the liberty of separate religion and creeds and that is and the liberty of separate religion and creeds and that is our and the liberty of separate religion and creeds and that is our system and creeds and that is our system and and creeds and that is our system and that and creeds and that is our system and that we and creeds and that is our system and that we will and creeds and that is our system and that we will do and creeds and that is our system and that we will do everything and creeds and that is our system and that we will do everything in and that we will do everything in and that we will do everything in and that we will do everything in every part and that we will do everything in every part of and that we will do everything in every part of our and that we will do everything in every part of our system and that we will do everything in every part of our system to and that we will do everything in every part of our system to defend every part of our system to defend it. every part of our system to defend it. Marama every part of our system to defend it. Marama Fox. every part of our system to defend it. every part of our system to defend <SPEAKS TE REO every part of our system to defend <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS <SPEAKS TE <SPEAKS TE REO <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> We We stand, We stand, Mr We stand, Mr Speaker, We stand, Mr Speaker, to We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn this We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn this act We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn this act of We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn this act of extremism We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn this act of extremism and We stand, Mr Speaker, to condemn this act of extremism and terrorism this act of extremism and terrorism that this act of extremism and terrorism that has this act of extremism and terrorism that has again this act of extremism and terrorism that has again hurt this act of extremism and terrorism that has again hurt the this act of extremism and terrorism that has again hurt the people this act of extremism and terrorism that has again hurt the people of that has again hurt the people of London, that has again hurt the people of London, the that has again hurt the people of London, the people that has again hurt the people of London, the people of that has again hurt the people of London, the people of England that has again hurt the people of London, the people of England and that has again hurt the people of London, the people of England and as London, the people of England and as London, the people of England and as London, the people of England and as has been London, the people of England and as has been expressed London, the people of England and as has been expressed continues London, the people of England and as has been expressed continues to has been expressed continues to carry has been expressed continues to carry on has been expressed continues to carry on around has been expressed continues to carry on around the has been expressed continues to carry on around the rest has been expressed continues to carry on around the rest of has been expressed continues to carry on around the rest of the carry on around the rest of the world. carry on around the rest of the world. Our carry on around the rest of the world. Our thoughts carry on around the rest of the world. Our thoughts are carry on around the rest of the world. Our thoughts are with carry on around the rest of the world. Our thoughts are with the world. Our thoughts are with the families world. Our thoughts are with the families of world. Our thoughts are with the families of those world. Our thoughts are with the families of those killed world. Our thoughts are with the families of those killed and families of those killed and injured, families of those killed and injured, including families of those killed and injured, including the families of those killed and injured, including the family families of those killed and injured, including the family of injured, including the family of Oliver injured, including the family of injured, injured, including the family of Oliver Dowling. London injured, including the family of Oliver Dowling. London acts injured, including the family of Oliver Dowling. London acts as injured, including the family of Oliver Dowling. London acts as a Oliver Dowling. London acts as a magnet Oliver Dowling. London acts as a magnet for Oliver Dowling. London acts as a magnet for the Oliver Dowling. London acts as a magnet for the people Oliver Dowling. London acts as a magnet for the people around Oliver Dowling. London acts as a magnet for the people around the magnet for the people around the magnet for the people around the magnet for the people around the globe and magnet for the people around the globe and it magnet for the people around the globe and it is magnet for the people around the globe and it is no magnet for the people around the globe and it is no surprise magnet for the people around the globe and it is no surprise that magnet for the people around the globe and it is no surprise that the globe and it is no surprise that the victims globe and it is no surprise that the victims include globe and it is no surprise that the victims include those globe and it is no surprise that the victims include those who globe and it is no surprise that the victims include those who have globe and it is no surprise that the victims include those who have made victims include those who have made the victims include those who have made the city victims include those who have made the city their victims include those who have made the city their home. victims include those who have made the city their home. We victims include those who have made the city their home. We also victims include those who have made the city their home. We also honour the city their home. We also honour the the city their home. We also honour the bravery the city their home. We also honour the bravery of the city their home. We also honour the bravery of those the city their home. We also honour the bravery of those who the city their home. We also honour the bravery of those who put the city their home. We also honour the bravery of those who put their the bravery of those who put their own the bravery of those who put their own safety the bravery of those who put their own safety at the bravery of those who put their own safety at risk the bravery of those who put their own safety at risk to the bravery of those who put their own safety at risk to save the bravery of those who put their own safety at risk to save others. own safety at risk to save others. The own safety at risk to save others. The terrorists own safety at risk to save others. The terrorists and own safety at risk to save others. The terrorists and extremists own safety at risk to save others. The terrorists and extremists who The terrorists and extremists who purr The terrorists and extremists who purr pech The terrorists and extremists who purr pech waited The terrorists and extremists who purr pech waited this The terrorists and extremists who purr pech waited this December The terrorists and extremists who purr pech waited this December spic purr pech waited this December spic purr pech waited this December spic purr pech waited this December spic spetion spetion purr pech waited this December spic spetion spetion perpetuated purr pech waited this December spic spetion spetion perpetuated the spetion spetion perpetuated the spetion spetion perpetuated the spetion spetion perpetuated the despicable act spetion spetion perpetuated the despicable act psych spetion spetion perpetuated the despicable act psych to spetion spetion perpetuated the despicable act psych to drive spetion spetion perpetuated the despicable act psych to drive a despicable act psych to drive a wedge despicable act psych to drive a wedge between despicable act psych to drive a wedge between communities. despicable act psych to drive a wedge between communities. They despicable act psych to drive a wedge between communities. They will wedge between communities. They will wedge wedge between communities. They will not succeed. Now wedge between communities. They will not succeed. Now like wedge between communities. They will not succeed. Now like many wedge between communities. They will not succeed. Now like many times not succeed. Now like many times before not succeed. Now like many times before in not succeed. Now like many times before in its not succeed. Now like many times before in its history, not succeed. Now like many times before in its history, London not succeed. Now like many times before in its history, London stands before in its history, London stands united before in its history, London stands united against before in its history, London stands united against a before in its history, London stands united against a threat. before in its history, London stands united against a threat. Over before in its history, London stands united against a threat. Over the united against a threat. Over the years united against a threat. Over the years London united against a threat. Over the years London has united against a threat. Over the years London has endured united against a threat. Over the years London has endured attack years London has endured attack after years London has endured attack after attack years London has endured attack after attack and years London has endured attack after attack and each years London has endured attack after attack and each time years London has endured attack after attack and each time it years London has endured attack after attack and each time it bands after attack and each time it bands together, after attack and each time it bands together, regardless after attack and each time it bands together, regardless of after attack and each time it bands together, regardless of colour, together, regardless of colour, creed together, regardless of colour, creed or together, regardless of colour, creed or race. together, regardless of colour, creed or race. I together, regardless of colour, creed or race. I was together, regardless of colour, creed or race. I was heartened together, regardless of colour, creed or race. I was heartened when creed or race. I was heartened when I creed or race. I was heartened when I went creed or race. I was heartened when I went to Twitter creed or race. I was heartened when I went to Twitter to creed or race. I was heartened when I went to Twitter to see creed or race. I was heartened when I went to Twitter to see what creed or race. I was heartened when I went to Twitter to see what had I went to Twitter to see what had happened I went to Twitter to see what had happened to I went to Twitter to see what had happened to find I went to Twitter to see what had happened to find somebody I went to Twitter to see what had happened to find somebody had I went to Twitter to see what had happened to find somebody had taken happened to find somebody had taken a happened to find somebody had taken a picture happened to find somebody had taken a picture on happened to find somebody had taken a picture on their happened to find somebody had taken a picture on their video happened to find somebody had taken a picture on their video of happened to find somebody had taken a picture on their video of a happened to find somebody had taken a picture on their video of a police a picture on their video of a police officer a picture on their video of a police officer dancing a picture on their video of a police officer dancing in a picture on their video of a police officer dancing in a a picture on their video of a police officer dancing in a circle a picture on their video of a police officer dancing in a circle with officer dancing in a circle with young officer dancing in a circle with young children officer dancing in a circle with young children on officer dancing in a circle with young children on the officer dancing in a circle with young children on the streets. officer dancing in a circle with young children on the streets. As young children on the streets. As the young children on the streets. As the mayor young children on the streets. As the mayor said, young children on the streets. As the mayor said, Londoners young children on the streets. As the mayor said, Londoners will young children on the streets. As the mayor said, Londoners will never the mayor said, Londoners will never be the mayor said, Londoners will never be cowered the mayor said, Londoners will never be cowered by the mayor said, Londoners will never be cowered by terrorism. the mayor said, Londoners will never be cowered by terrorism. No the mayor said, Londoners will never be cowered by terrorism. No one be cowered by terrorism. No one anywhere be cowered by terrorism. No one anywhere should be cowered by terrorism. No one anywhere should be be cowered by terrorism. No one anywhere should be cowered be cowered by terrorism. No one anywhere should be cowered by anywhere should be cowered by terrorism anywhere should be cowered by terrorism and anywhere should be cowered by terrorism and extremism. anywhere should be cowered by terrorism and extremism. The terrorism and extremism. The terrorism and extremism. The terrorism and extremism. The terrorists will terrorism and extremism. The terrorists will not terrorism and extremism. The terrorists will not win. terrorism and extremism. The terrorists will not win. Humanity terrorists will not win. Humanity will terrorists will not win. Humanity will win terrorists will not win. Humanity will win and terrorists will not win. Humanity will win and love terrorists will not win. Humanity will win and love will will win and love will always overthrow will win and love will always overthrow evil. will win and love will always overthrow evil. Tena will win and love will always overthrow evil. Tena koe. will win and love will always overthrow evil. Tena koe. David overthrow evil. Tena koe. David Seymour. overthrow evil. Tena koe. David Seymour. The overthrow evil. Tena koe. David Seymour. The Act overthrow evil. Tena koe. David Seymour. The Act Party overthrow evil. Tena koe. David Seymour. The Act Party joins overthrow evil. Tena koe. David Seymour. The Act Party joins with Seymour. The Act Party joins with other Seymour. The Act Party joins with other parties Seymour. The Act Party joins with other parties in Seymour. The Act Party joins with other parties in expressing Seymour. The Act Party joins with other parties in expressing our other parties in expressing our sincere other parties in expressing our sincere condolences other parties in expressing our sincere condolences for other parties in expressing our sincere condolences for the other parties in expressing our sincere condolences for the people sincere condolences for the people of sincere condolences for the people of London sincere condolences for the people of London and sincere condolences for the people of London and the sincere condolences for the people of London and the UK sincere condolences for the people of London and the UK and sincere condolences for the people of London and the UK and in of London and the UK and in particular of London and the UK and in particular the of London and the UK and in particular the family of London and the UK and in particular the family of particular the family of Oliver particular the family of particular the family of Oliver Dowling. Mr particular the family of Oliver Dowling. Mr Speaker, particular the family of Oliver Dowling. Mr Speaker, these particular the family of Oliver Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events will always Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events will always lead Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events will always lead to Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events will always lead to pause Dowling. Mr Speaker, these events will always lead to pause for will always lead to pause for reflection will always lead to pause for reflection and will always lead to pause for reflection and there will always lead to pause for reflection and there have will always lead to pause for reflection and there have been will always lead to pause for reflection and there have been so reflection and there have been so many reflection and there have been so many with reflection and there have been so many with seemingly reflection and there have been so many with seemingly increasing many with seemingly increasing frequency many with seemingly increasing frequency in many with seemingly increasing frequency in past many with seemingly increasing frequency in past months many with seemingly increasing frequency in past months and many with seemingly increasing frequency in past months and years frequency in past months and years and frequency in past months and years and getting frequency in past months and years and getting increasingly frequency in past months and years and getting increasingly close frequency in past months and years and getting increasingly close to and getting increasingly close to New and getting increasingly close to New Zealand, and getting increasingly close to New Zealand, both and getting increasingly close to New Zealand, both culturally and getting increasingly close to New Zealand, both culturally and New Zealand, both culturally and geographically. New Zealand, both culturally and geographically. There New Zealand, both culturally and geographically. There is New Zealand, both culturally and geographically. There is going New Zealand, both culturally and geographically. There is going to geographically. There is going to have geographically. There is going to have to geographically. There is going to have to be geographically. There is going to have to be a geographically. There is going to have to be a wider geographically. There is going to have to be a wider and geographically. There is going to have to be a wider and more geographically. There is going to have to be a wider and more serious have to be a wider and more serious debate have to be a wider and more serious debate about have to be a wider and more serious debate about when have to be a wider and more serious debate about when and have to be a wider and more serious debate about when and whether have to be a wider and more serious debate about when and whether such debate about when and whether such an debate about when and whether such an event debate about when and whether such an event can debate about when and whether such an event can happen debate about when and whether such an event can happen here. debate about when and whether such an event can happen here. It debate about when and whether such an event can happen here. It will an event can happen here. It will have an event can happen here. It will have to an event can happen here. It will have to be an event can happen here. It will have to be a an event can happen here. It will have to be a debate an event can happen here. It will have to be a debate without an event can happen here. It will have to be a debate without naked have to be a debate without naked political have to be a debate without naked political opportunism, have to be a debate without naked political opportunism, as have to be a debate without naked political opportunism, as we have to be a debate without naked political opportunism, as we have political opportunism, as we have heard political opportunism, as we have heard from political opportunism, as we have heard from New political opportunism, as we have heard from New Zealand political opportunism, as we have heard from New Zealand First, political opportunism, as we have heard from New Zealand First, but heard from New Zealand First, but also heard from New Zealand First, but also without heard from New Zealand First, but also without the heard from New Zealand First, but also without the naivety heard from New Zealand First, but also without the naivety that heard from New Zealand First, but also without the naivety that these also without the naivety that these events also without the naivety that these events are also without the naivety that these events are completely also without the naivety that these events are completely random, also without the naivety that these events are completely random, that events are completely random, that they events are completely random, that they are events are completely random, that they are not events are completely random, that they are not systematic events are completely random, that they are not systematic and events are completely random, that they are not systematic and that they are not systematic and that they they are not systematic and that they cannot they are not systematic and that they cannot be they are not systematic and that they cannot be detected they are not systematic and that they cannot be detected and they cannot be detected and prevented. they cannot be detected and prevented. We they cannot be detected and prevented. We will they cannot be detected and prevented. We will need they cannot be detected and prevented. We will need to they cannot be detected and prevented. We will need to hear they cannot be detected and prevented. We will need to hear from prevented. We will need to hear from our prevented. We will need to hear from our PM prevented. We will need to hear from our PM and prevented. We will need to hear from our PM and Government prevented. We will need to hear from our PM and Government what prevented. We will need to hear from our PM and Government what they our PM and Government what they adoing our PM and Government what they adoing to our PM and Government what they adoing to ensure our PM and Government what they adoing to ensure that our PM and Government what they adoing to ensure that such our PM and Government what they adoing to ensure that such things our PM and Government what they adoing to ensure that such things do adoing to ensure that such things do not adoing to ensure that such things do not happen adoing to ensure that such things do not happen here. adoing to ensure that such things do not happen here. As adoing to ensure that such things do not happen here. As I adoing to ensure that such things do not happen here. As I said adoing to ensure that such things do not happen here. As I said to adoing to ensure that such things do not happen here. As I said to the not happen here. As I said to the terrorists not happen here. As I said to the terrorists last not happen here. As I said to the terrorists last time not happen here. As I said to the terrorists last time we not happen here. As I said to the terrorists last time we had not happen here. As I said to the terrorists last time we had such not happen here. As I said to the terrorists last time we had such a terrorists last time we had such a motion, terrorists last time we had such a motion, they terrorists last time we had such a motion, they will terrorists last time we had such a motion, they will not terrorists last time we had such a motion, they will not win terrorists last time we had such a motion, they will not win because motion, they will not win because there motion, they will not win because there are motion, they will not win because there are too motion, they will not win because there are too many motion, they will not win because there are too many of motion, they will not win because there are too many of us motion, they will not win because there are too many of us and motion, they will not win because there are too many of us and we motion, they will not win because there are too many of us and we love there are too many of us and we love our there are too many of us and we love our freedom there are too many of us and we love our freedom and there are too many of us and we love our freedom and each there are too many of us and we love our freedom and each other there are too many of us and we love our freedom and each other far there are too many of us and we love our freedom and each other far too our freedom and each other far too much. our freedom and each other far too much. Thank our freedom and each other far too much. Thank you, our freedom and each other far too much. Thank you, Mr our freedom and each other far too much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. our freedom and each other far too much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The our freedom and each other far too much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Peter much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Peter Dunne. much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Peter Dunne. On much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Peter Dunne. On behalf much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Peter Dunne. On behalf of much. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future I Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future I stand Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future I stand with Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future I stand with those Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future I stand with those in Peter Dunne. On behalf of United Future I stand with those in the Future I stand with those in the House Future I stand with those in the Future Future I stand with those in the House this afternoon Future I stand with those in the House this afternoon who Future I stand with those in the House this afternoon who have House this afternoon who have expressed House this afternoon who have expressed their House this afternoon who have expressed their sympathy House this afternoon who have expressed their sympathy to House this afternoon who have expressed their sympathy to the expressed their sympathy to the people expressed their sympathy to the people of expressed their sympathy to the people of London expressed their sympathy to the people of London and expressed their sympathy to the people of London and before expressed their sympathy to the people of London and before then expressed their sympathy to the people of London and before then the people of London and before then the people of London and before then the people of London and before then the people of people of London and before then the people of Manchester people of London and before then the people of Manchester at people of London and before then the people of Manchester at the people of London and before then the people of Manchester at the horrific people of Manchester at the horrific people people of Manchester at the horrific incidents people of Manchester at the horrific incidents that have taken people of Manchester at the horrific incidents that have taken place people of Manchester at the horrific incidents that have taken place in incidents that have taken place in their incidents that have taken place in their cities incidents that have taken place in their cities in incidents that have taken place in their cities in recent incidents that have taken place in their cities in recent weeks. incidents that have taken place in their cities in recent weeks. No incidents that have taken place in their cities in recent weeks. No one their cities in recent weeks. No one can their cities in recent weeks. No one can condone their cities in recent weeks. No one can condone whatever their cities in recent weeks. No one can condone whatever the their cities in recent weeks. No one can condone whatever the motivation, can condone whatever the motivation, can condone whatever the motivation, can condone whatever the motivation, the activities can condone whatever the motivation, the activities of can condone whatever the motivation, the activities of those the activities of those who the activities of those the activities of those who aimlessly slaughter the activities of those who aimlessly slaughter people the activities of those who aimlessly slaughter people in the activities of those who aimlessly slaughter people in such the activities of those who aimlessly slaughter people in such a aimlessly slaughter people in such a aimlessly slaughter people in such a aimlessly slaughter people in such a way. No aimlessly slaughter people in such a way. No one aimlessly slaughter people in such a way. No one can aimlessly slaughter people in such a way. No one can condone aimlessly slaughter people in such a way. No one can condone the aimlessly slaughter people in such a way. No one can condone the callous way. No one can condone the callous indifference way. No one can condone the callous indifference that way. No one can condone the callous indifference that they way. No one can condone the callous indifference that they show way. No one can condone the callous indifference that they show towards indifference that they show towards their indifference that they show towards their victims. indifference that they show towards their victims. I indifference that they show towards their victims. I extend indifference that they show towards their victims. I extend my indifference that they show towards their victims. I extend my sympathy their victims. I extend my sympathy to their victims. I extend my sympathy to the their victims. I extend my sympathy to the family their victims. I extend my sympathy to the family of their victims. I extend my sympathy to the family of all their victims. I extend my sympathy to the family of all of their victims. I extend my sympathy to the family of all of those their victims. I extend my sympathy to the family of all of those who to the family of all of those who to the family of all of those who to the family of all of those who have lost to the family of all of those who have lost loved to the family of all of those who have lost loved ones to the family of all of those who have lost loved ones in to the family of all of those who have lost loved ones in this to the family of all of those who have lost loved ones in this latest have lost loved ones in this latest atrocity, have lost loved ones in this latest atrocity, particularly have lost loved ones in this latest atrocity, particularly the have lost loved ones in this latest atrocity, particularly the family have lost loved ones in this latest atrocity, particularly the family of atrocity, particularly the family of Oliver atrocity, particularly the family of Oliver Dowling atrocity, particularly the family of Oliver Dowling and atrocity, particularly the family of Oliver Dowling and let atrocity, particularly the family of Oliver Dowling and let them atrocity, particularly the family of Oliver Dowling and let them know Oliver Dowling and let them know that Oliver Dowling and let them know that our Oliver Dowling and let them know that our thoughts Oliver Dowling and let them know that our thoughts are Oliver Dowling and let them know that our thoughts are with Oliver Dowling and let them know that our thoughts are with them Oliver Dowling and let them know that our thoughts are with them at that our thoughts are with them at this that our thoughts are with them at this trying that our thoughts are with them at this trying time. that our thoughts are with them at this trying time. Mr that our thoughts are with them at this trying time. Mr Speaker, that our thoughts are with them at this trying time. Mr Speaker, much this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will be this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will be said, this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will be said, and this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will be said, and has this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will be said, and has already this trying time. Mr Speaker, much will be said, and has already been will be said, and has already been said, will be said, and has already been said, about will be said, and has already been said, about the will be said, and has already been said, about the causes will be said, and has already been said, about the causes and will be said, and has already been said, about the causes and the said, about the causes and the lessons said, about the causes and the lessons from said, about the causes and the lessons from these said, about the causes and the lessons from these events. said, about the causes and the lessons from these events. We said, about the causes and the lessons from these events. We do lessons from these events. We do need lessons from these events. We do need to lessons from these events. We do need to be lessons from these events. We do need to be on lessons from these events. We do need to be on guard. lessons from these events. We do need to be on guard. We lessons from these events. We do need to be on guard. We do lessons from these events. We do need to be on guard. We do need lessons from these events. We do need to be on guard. We do need to need to be on guard. We do need to make need to be on guard. We do need to make sure need to be on guard. We do need to make sure that need to be on guard. We do need to make sure that we need to be on guard. We do need to make sure that we do need to be on guard. We do need to make sure that we do not need to be on guard. We do need to make sure that we do not surrender, make sure that we do not surrender, but make sure that we do not surrender, but equally make sure that we do not surrender, but equally we make sure that we do not surrender, but equally we need make sure that we do not surrender, but equally we need to make sure that we do not surrender, but equally we need to make make sure that we do not surrender, but equally we need to make sure but equally we need to make sure that but equally we need to make sure that we but equally we need to make sure that we do but equally we need to make sure that we do not but equally we need to make sure that we do not surrender but equally we need to make sure that we do not surrender to but equally we need to make sure that we do not surrender to the that we do not surrender to the forces that we do not surrender to the forces of that we do not surrender to the forces of bigotry that we do not surrender to the forces of bigotry and that we do not surrender to the forces of bigotry and intolerance forces of bigotry and intolerance forces of bigotry and intolerance forces of bigotry and intolerance who will forces of bigotry and intolerance who will milk forces of bigotry and intolerance who will milk these forces of bigotry and intolerance who will milk these evens forces of bigotry and intolerance who will milk these evens for forces of bigotry and intolerance who will milk these evens for every who will milk these evens for every opportunity who will milk these evens for every opportunity they who will milk these evens for every opportunity they can. who will milk these evens for every opportunity they can. Our who will milk these evens for every opportunity they can. Our world opportunity they can. Our world faces opportunity they can. Our world faces a opportunity they can. Our world faces a threat opportunity they can. Our world faces a threat to opportunity they can. Our world faces a threat to its opportunity they can. Our world faces a threat to its stability opportunity they can. Our world faces a threat to its stability in opportunity they can. Our world faces a threat to its stability in a faces a threat to its stability in a way faces a threat to its stability in a way that faces a threat to its stability in a way that it faces a threat to its stability in a way that it has faces a threat to its stability in a way that it has not faces a threat to its stability in a way that it has not known way that it has not known previously. way that it has not known previously. People way that it has not known previously. People of way that it has not known previously. People of goodwill way that it has not known previously. People of goodwill and previously. People of goodwill and spirit previously. People of goodwill and previously. previously. People of goodwill and spirit need to previously. People of goodwill and spirit need to come previously. People of goodwill and spirit need to come together previously. People of goodwill and spirit need to come together to previously. People of goodwill and spirit need to come together to work spirit need to come together to work out spirit need to come together to work out sensible spirit need to come together to work out sensible resolutions spirit need to come together to work out sensible resolutions to spirit need to come together to work out sensible resolutions to these out sensible resolutions to these problems out sensible resolutions to these problems not out sensible resolutions to these problems not revel out sensible resolutions to these problems not revel in out sensible resolutions to these problems not revel in the out sensible resolutions to these problems not revel in the pit out sensible resolutions to these problems not revel in the pit of problems not revel in the pit of bigotry problems not revel in the pit of bigotry and problems not revel in the pit of bigotry and intolerance problems not revel in the pit of bigotry and intolerance because problems not revel in the pit of bigotry and intolerance because that bigotry and intolerance because that only bigotry and intolerance because that only gives bigotry and intolerance because that only gives rise bigotry and intolerance because that only gives rise to bigotry and intolerance because that only gives rise to hatred bigotry and intolerance because that only gives rise to hatred and bigotry and intolerance because that only gives rise to hatred and rise only gives rise to hatred and rise to only gives rise to hatred and rise to the only gives rise to hatred and rise to the next only gives rise to hatred and rise to the next event. only gives rise to hatred and rise to the next event. We only gives rise to hatred and rise to the next event. We have to the next event. We have geographic to the next event. We have geographic distance to the next event. We have geographic distance in to the next event. We have geographic distance in this to the next event. We have geographic distance in this country geographic distance in this country geographic distance in this country geographic distance in this country but we geographic distance in this country but we do geographic distance in this country but we do not geographic distance in this country but we do not have geographic distance in this country but we do not have the geographic distance in this country but we do not have the cam geographic distance in this country but we do not have the cam play but we do not have the cam play sensy but we do not have the cam play sensy that but we do not have the cam play sensy that that but we do not have the cam play sensy that that might but we do not have the cam play sensy that that might give but we do not have the cam play sensy that that might give rise but we do not have the cam play sensy that that might give rise to sensy that that might give rise to in sensy that that might give rise to in certain sensy that that might give rise to in certain circumstances. sensy that that might give rise to in certain circumstances. We sensy that that might give rise to in certain circumstances. We need sensy that that might give rise to in certain circumstances. We need to in certain circumstances. We need to be in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant and in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant and we in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant and we also in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant and we also need in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant and we also need to in certain circumstances. We need to be vigilant and we also need to be be vigilant and we also need to be tolerant. be vigilant and we also need to be tolerant. I be vigilant and we also need to be tolerant. I contrast be vigilant and we also need to be tolerant. I contrast the be vigilant and we also need to be tolerant. I contrast the events be vigilant and we also need to be tolerant. I contrast the events of tolerant. I contrast the events of the tolerant. I contrast the events of the weekend tolerant. I contrast the events of the weekend with tolerant. I contrast the events of the weekend with something tolerant. I contrast the events of the weekend with something that tolerant. I contrast the events of the weekend with something that took the weekend with something that took place the weekend with something that took place in the weekend with something that took place in this the weekend with something that took place in this parliament the weekend with something that took place in this parliament last place in this parliament last Thursday place in this parliament last Thursday evening, place in this parliament last Thursday evening, where place in this parliament last Thursday evening, where the place in this parliament last Thursday evening, where the Muslim Thursday evening, where the Muslim Thursday evening, where the Muslim Thursday evening, where the Muslim community of Thursday evening, where the Muslim community of New Thursday evening, where the Muslim community of New Zealand Thursday evening, where the Muslim community of New Zealand came community of New Zealand came together community of New Zealand came together to community of New Zealand came together to celebrate community of New Zealand came together to celebrate the community of New Zealand came together to celebrate the start community of New Zealand came together to celebrate the start of together to celebrate the start of the together to celebrate the start of the month together to celebrate the start of the month of together to celebrate the start of the month of Ramadan together to celebrate the start of the month of Ramadan in together to celebrate the start of the month of Ramadan in peace together to celebrate the start of the month of Ramadan in peace and the month of Ramadan in peace and goodwill, the month of Ramadan in peace and goodwill, in the month of Ramadan in peace and goodwill, in tolerance the month of Ramadan in peace and goodwill, in tolerance and the month of Ramadan in peace and goodwill, in tolerance and openness. goodwill, in tolerance and openness. goodwill, in tolerance and openness. goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need to goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need to be goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need to be working goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need to be working with goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need to be working with people goodwill, in tolerance and openness. We need to be working with people of We need to be working with people of like We need to be working with people of like mind We need to be working with people of like mind to We need to be working with people of like mind to achieve We need to be working with people of like mind to achieve positive like mind to achieve positive outcomes, like mind to achieve positive outcomes, not like mind to achieve positive outcomes, not simply like mind to achieve positive outcomes, not simply fuelling like mind to achieve positive outcomes, not simply fuelling the outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires of outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires of bigot outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires of bigot try. outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires of bigot try. The outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires of bigot try. The question outcomes, not simply fuelling the fires of bigot try. The question is fires of bigot try. The question is that fires of bigot try. The question is that the fires of bigot try. The question is that the motion fires of bigot try. The question is that the motion be fires of bigot try. The question is that the motion be agreed fires of bigot try. The question is that the motion be agreed to? fires of bigot try. The question is that the motion be agreed to? The that the motion be agreed to? The ayes that the motion be agreed to? The ayes have that the motion be agreed to? The ayes have it. that the motion be agreed to? The ayes have it. Point that the motion be agreed to? The ayes have it. Point of that the motion be agreed to? The ayes have it. Point of order, that the motion be agreed to? The ayes have it. Point of order, Mr ayes have it. Point of order, Mr Speaker. ayes have it. Point of order, Mr Speaker. I ayes have it. Point of order, Mr Speaker. I would ayes have it. Point of order, Mr Speaker. I would like ayes have it. Point of order, Mr Speaker. I would like to ayes have it. Point of order, Mr Speaker. I would like to correct Speaker. I would like to correct something Speaker. I would like to correct something that Speaker. I would like to correct something that I Speaker. I would like to correct something that I said Speaker. I would like to correct something that I said in Speaker. I would like to correct something that I said in those something that I said in those comments something that I said in those comments before. something that I said in those comments before. I something that I said in those comments before. I misspoke something that I said in those comments before. I misspoke when something that I said in those comments before. I misspoke when I comments before. I misspoke when I said comments before. I misspoke when I said that comments before. I misspoke when I said that Oliver comments before. I misspoke when I said that Oliver Dowling comments before. I misspoke when I said that Oliver Dowling had comments before. I misspoke when I said that Oliver Dowling had been said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I mint said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I mint to said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I mint to say said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I mint to say that said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I mint to say that he said that Oliver Dowling had been killed, I mint to say that he had killed, I mint to say that he had been killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed -- killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed -- meant killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed -- meant to killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed -- meant to say killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed -- meant to say that killed, I mint to say that he had been stabbed -- meant to say that he been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been stabbed been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been stabbed but been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been stabbed but not been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been stabbed but not killed. been stabbed -- meant to say that he had been stabbed but not killed. No had been stabbed but not killed. No petitions had been stabbed but not killed. No petitions have had been stabbed but not killed. No petitions have been had been stabbed but not killed. No petitions have been delivered had been stabbed but not killed. No petitions have been delivered to had been stabbed but not killed. No petitions have been delivered to the petitions have been delivered to the Clerk petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. No petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. No papers Clerk for presentation. No papers Clerk for presentation. No papers Clerk for presentation. No papers have been Clerk for presentation. No papers have been presented. Reports Reports of Reports of the Reports of the Health Reports of the Health Committee Reports of the Health Committee on Reports of the Health Committee on the on the Care on the Care and on the Care and Support on the Care and Support Worker on the Care and Support Worker (Pay Care and Support Worker (Pay Equity) Care and Support Worker (Pay Equity) Settlement Care and Support Worker (Pay Equity) Settlement Bill. Equity) Settlement Bill. Petition Equity) Settlement Bill. Petition 2014/61 Equity) Settlement Bill. Petition 2014/61 of Equity) Settlement Bill. Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Henderson Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Henderson on Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Henderson on behalf Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Henderson on behalf of Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Henderson on behalf of the Petition 2014/61 of Evangelia Henderson on behalf of the New Henderson on behalf of the New Zealand Henderson on behalf of the New Zealand Breast Henderson on behalf of the New Zealand Breast Cancer Henderson on behalf of the New Zealand Breast Cancer Foundation Henderson on behalf of the New Zealand Breast Cancer Foundation and Zealand Breast Cancer Foundation and 10,000 Zealand Breast Cancer Foundation and 10,000 others. 10,000 others. Report 10,000 others. Report of 10,000 others. Report of the 10,000 others. Report of the Local 10,000 others. Report of the Local Government 10,000 others. Report of the Local Government and Report of the Local Government and Environment Report of the Local Government and Environment Committee Report of the Local Government and Environment Committee on Report of the Local Government and Environment Committee on the Environment Committee on the Petition Environment Committee on the Petition 2014/90 Environment Committee on the Petition 2014/90 of Environment Committee on the Petition 2014/90 of Norman Environment Committee on the Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Carter Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Carter on Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Carter on behalf Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Carter on behalf of Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Carter on behalf of the Petition 2014/90 of Norman John Carter on behalf of the Cornwall Carter on behalf of the Cornwall Park Carter on behalf of the Cornwall Park Leaseholder Carter on behalf of the Cornwall Park Leaseholder Association Carter on behalf of the Cornwall Park Leaseholder Association Inc. Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Bill Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Bill is Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Bill is set Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Bill is set down Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Bill is set down for Park Leaseholder Association Inc. The Bill is set down for second The Bill is set down for second reading. No No bills No bills have No bills have been No bills have been introduced. No bills have been introduced. The No bills have been introduced. The House No bills have been introduced. The House comes No bills have been introduced. The House comes to No bills have been introduced. The House comes to Oral No bills have been introduced. The House comes to Oral Questions. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: What My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has he Finance: What reports has he Finance: What reports has he Finance: What reports has he received on Finance: What reports has he received on the Finance: What reports has he received on the Government's Finance: What reports has he received on the Government's fiscal received on the Government's fiscal position? The The latest The latest Government The latest Government accounts The latest Government accounts have The latest Government accounts have been The latest Government accounts have been released The latest Government accounts have been released today The latest Government accounts have been released today for The latest Government accounts have been released today for the The latest Government accounts have been released today for the ten been released today for the ten months been released today for the ten months to been released today for the ten months to 30 been released today for the ten months to 30 April been released today for the ten months to 30 April and been released today for the ten months to 30 April and show been released today for the ten months to 30 April and show a months to 30 April and show a surplus months to 30 April and show a surplus of months to 30 April and show a surplus of $2.5 months to 30 April and show a surplus of $2.5 billion months to 30 April and show a surplus of $2.5 billion helped months to 30 April and show a surplus of $2.5 billion helped by surplus of $2.5 billion helped by higher-than-expected surplus of $2.5 billion helped by higher-than-expected revenue. surplus of $2.5 billion helped by higher-than-expected revenue. It higher-than-expected revenue. It must higher-than-expected revenue. It must be higher-than-expected revenue. It must be noted higher-than-expected revenue. It must be noted that higher-than-expected revenue. It must be noted that around higher-than-expected revenue. It must be noted that around $1 higher-than-expected revenue. It must be noted that around $1 billion must be noted that around $1 billion of must be noted that around $1 billion of this must be noted that around $1 billion of this monthly must be noted that around $1 billion of this monthly surplus must be noted that around $1 billion of this monthly surplus is must be noted that around $1 billion of this monthly surplus is due must be noted that around $1 billion of this monthly surplus is due to of this monthly surplus is due to the of this monthly surplus is due to the annual peak in of this monthly surplus is due to the annual peak in provisional of this monthly surplus is due to the annual peak in provisional tax the annual peak in provisional tax assessments the annual peak in provisional tax assessments and the annual peak in provisional tax assessments and estimates the annual peak in provisional tax assessments and estimates occurring assessments and estimates occurring assessments and estimates occurring assessments and estimates occurring a month assessments and estimates occurring a month earlier assessments and estimates occurring a month earlier than assessments and estimates occurring a month earlier than expected. a month earlier than expected. Treasury a month earlier than expected. Treasury and a month earlier than expected. Treasury and inland a month earlier than expected. Treasury and inland revenue a month earlier than expected. Treasury and inland revenue expect Treasury and inland revenue expect this Treasury and inland revenue expect this to Treasury and inland revenue expect this to be Treasury and inland revenue expect this to be reversed Treasury and inland revenue expect this to be reversed in Treasury and inland revenue expect this to be reversed in the Treasury and inland revenue expect this to be reversed in the May this to be reversed in the May statements, this to be reversed in the May statements, therefore this to be reversed in the May statements, therefore it is statements, therefore it is important statements, therefore it is important not statements, therefore it is important not to statements, therefore it is important not to take statements, therefore it is important not to take too statements, therefore it is important not to take too much statements, therefore it is important not to take too much from important not to take too much from a important not to take too much from a single important not to take too much from a single month's important not to take too much from a single month's figures. important not to take too much from a single month's figures. The a single month's figures. The accounts a single month's figures. The accounts overall a single month's figures. The accounts overall do a single month's figures. The accounts overall do underline a single month's figures. The accounts overall do underline the accounts overall do underline the Government's accounts overall do underline the Government's improving accounts overall do underline the Government's improving fiscal Government's improving fiscal position. Government's improving fiscal position. How Government's improving fiscal position. How did Government's improving fiscal position. How did this Government's improving fiscal position. How did this month's position. How did this month's financial position. How did this month's financial results position. How did this month's financial results affect position. How did this month's financial results affect the financial results affect the financial results affect the financial results affect the expected outturn financial results affect the expected outturn for financial results affect the expected outturn for the financial results affect the expected outturn for the full financial results affect the expected outturn for the full year? expected outturn for the full year? The expected outturn for the full year? The Treasury's expected outturn for the full year? The Treasury's current expected outturn for the full year? The Treasury's current expectations The Treasury's current expectations that The Treasury's current expectations that the The Treasury's current expectations that the forecast The Treasury's current expectations that the forecast surplus The Treasury's current expectations that the forecast surplus for The Treasury's current expectations that the forecast surplus for the that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 year that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 year of that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 year of $1.6 that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is that the forecast surplus for the 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is on 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is on track. 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is on track. This 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is on track. This improving 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is on track. This improving fiscal 2016/17 year of $1.6 billion is on track. This improving fiscal portion track. This improving fiscal portion which track. This improving fiscal portion which has track. This improving fiscal portion which has now track. This improving fiscal portion which has now occurred track. This improving fiscal portion which has now occurred over track. This improving fiscal portion which has now occurred over a track. This improving fiscal portion which has now occurred over a number which has now occurred over a number of which has now occurred over a number of years which has now occurred over a number of years is which has now occurred over a number of years is a which has now occurred over a number of years is a result which has now occurred over a number of years is a result of which has now occurred over a number of years is a result of New which has now occurred over a number of years is a result of New Zealand of years is a result of New Zealand companies of years is a result of New Zealand companies making of years is a result of New Zealand companies making the of years is a result of New Zealand companies making the most of years is a result of New Zealand companies making the most of of years is a result of New Zealand companies making the most of the companies making the most of the companies making the most of the companies making the most of the current economic companies making the most of the current economic conditions companies making the most of the current economic conditions and current economic conditions and getting current economic conditions and getting out current economic conditions and getting out and current economic conditions and getting out and competing getting out and competing successfully getting out and competing successfully on getting out and competing successfully on the getting out and competing successfully on the world getting out and competing successfully on the world stage. getting out and competing successfully on the world stage. The successfully on the world stage. The Government's successfully on the world stage. The Government's strong successfully on the world stage. The Government's strong economic successfully on the world stage. The Government's strong economic plan successfully on the world stage. The Government's strong economic plan is Government's strong economic plan is giving Government's strong economic plan is giving companies Government's strong economic plan is giving companies the Government's strong economic plan is giving companies the confidence Government's strong economic plan is giving companies the confidence to giving companies the confidence to invest giving companies the confidence to invest and giving companies the confidence to invest and expand, giving companies the confidence to invest and expand, hire giving companies the confidence to invest and expand, hire more giving companies the confidence to invest and expand, hire more staff invest and expand, hire more staff and invest and expand, hire more staff and increase invest and expand, hire more staff and increase production. invest and expand, hire more staff and increase production. What invest and expand, hire more staff and increase production. What is invest and expand, hire more staff and increase production. What is the and increase production. What is the forecast and increase production. What is the forecast surplus and increase production. What is the forecast surplus track and increase production. What is the forecast surplus track for and increase production. What is the forecast surplus track for the and increase production. What is the forecast surplus track for the Crown forecast surplus track for the Crown forecast surplus track for the Crown forecast surplus track for the Crown over the forecast surplus track for the Crown over the next forecast surplus track for the Crown over the next four forecast surplus track for the Crown over the next four years. forecast surplus track for the Crown over the next four years. --? forecast surplus track for the Crown over the next four years. --? Last over the next four years. --? Last month's over the next four years. --? Last month's Budget, over the next four years. --? Last month's Budget, Economic over the next four years. --? Last month's Budget, Economic and over the next four years. --? Last month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal Update shows month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal Update shows we month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal Update shows we made month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal Update shows we made good month's Budget, Economic and Fiscal Update shows we made good progress Update shows we made good progress in Update shows we made good progress in restoring Update shows we made good progress in restoring the Update shows we made good progress in restoring the health Update shows we made good progress in restoring the health of Update shows we made good progress in restoring the health of the Update shows we made good progress in restoring the health of the funds in restoring the health of the funds over in restoring the health of the funds over the in restoring the health of the funds over the last in restoring the health of the funds over the last four in restoring the health of the funds over the last four years. in restoring the health of the funds over the last four years. OBEGAL in restoring the health of the funds over the last four years. OBEGAL is over the last four years. OBEGAL is over the last four years. OBEGAL is over the last four years. OBEGAL is expected to over the last four years. OBEGAL is expected to rise over the last four years. OBEGAL is expected to rise this over the last four years. OBEGAL is expected to rise this year over the last four years. OBEGAL is expected to rise this year to over the last four years. OBEGAL is expected to rise this year to $7.2 expected to rise this year to $7.2 billion expected to rise this year to $7.2 billion by expected to rise this year to $7.2 billion by 2020/21. expected to rise this year to $7.2 billion by 2020/21. The expected to rise this year to $7.2 billion by 2020/21. The residual billion by 2020/21. The residual cash billion by 2020/21. The residual cash position billion by 2020/21. The residual cash position is billion by 2020/21. The residual cash position is different billion by 2020/21. The residual cash position is different mainly cash position is different mainly because cash position is different mainly because of cash position is different mainly because of the cash position is different mainly because of the massive because of the massive because of the massive because of the massive infrastructure investment because of the massive infrastructure investment we because of the massive infrastructure investment we are infrastructure investment we are making infrastructure investment we are making in infrastructure investment we are making in new infrastructure investment we are making in new infrastructure infrastructure investment we are making in new infrastructure for making in new infrastructure for a making in new infrastructure for making in new infrastructure for a growing country. making in new infrastructure for a growing country. Over making in new infrastructure for a growing country. Over the making in new infrastructure for a growing country. Over the next making in new infrastructure for a growing country. Over the next four growing country. Over the next four growing country. Over the next four growing country. Over the next four years the growing country. Over the next four years the net growing country. Over the next four years the net residual growing country. Over the next four years the net residual cash growing country. Over the next four years the net residual cash position years the net residual cash position is years the net residual cash position is currently years the net residual cash position is currently expected years the net residual cash position is currently expected to years the net residual cash position is currently expected to be is currently expected to be basically is currently expected to be basically zero is currently expected to be basically zero over is currently expected to be basically zero over those is currently expected to be basically zero over those four basically zero over those four years. basically zero over those four years. Given basically zero over those four years. Given the basically zero over those four years. Given the fiscal basically zero over those four years. Given the fiscal position basically zero over those four years. Given the fiscal position he years. Given the fiscal position he has years. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, years. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, does years. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, does he years. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, does he think years. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, does he think it years. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, does he think it is has outlined, does he think it is fair has outlined, does he think it is fair that has outlined, does he think it is fair that over has outlined, does he think it is fair that over the has outlined, does he think it is fair that over the next has outlined, does he think it is fair that over the next five has outlined, does he think it is fair that over the next five years fair that over the next five years average fair that over the next five years average real fair that over the next five years average real wages fair that over the next five years average real wages are fair that over the next five years average real wages are set to fair that over the next five years average real wages are set to grow average real wages are set to grow by average real wages are set to grow by 1.3% average real wages are set to grow by 1.3% in average real wages are set to grow by 1.3% in total, average real wages are set to grow by 1.3% in total, which average real wages are set to grow by 1.3% in total, which calculates by 1.3% in total, which calculates to by 1.3% in total, which calculates to a by 1.3% in total, which calculates to a real by 1.3% in total, which calculates to a real increase by 1.3% in total, which calculates to a real increase for by 1.3% in total, which calculates to a real increase for an by 1.3% in total, which calculates to a real increase for an average to a real increase for an average worker to a real increase for an average worker of to a real increase for an average worker of 8 to a real increase for an average worker of 8 cents to a real increase for an average worker of 8 cents an to a real increase for an average worker of 8 cents an hour to a real increase for an average worker of 8 cents an hour a to a real increase for an average worker of 8 cents an hour a year? worker of 8 cents an hour a year? Well worker of 8 cents an hour a year? Well let's worker of 8 cents an hour a year? Well let's see worker of 8 cents an hour a year? Well let's see how worker of 8 cents an hour a year? Well let's see how that worker of 8 cents an hour a year? Well let's see how that estimate Well let's see how that estimate plays Well let's see how that estimate plays out. Well let's see how that estimate plays out. That's Well let's see how that estimate plays out. That's Treasury's plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. My plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. My view plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. My view is plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. My view is that plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. My view is that it plays out. That's Treasury's forecast. My view is that it will forecast. My view is that it will grow forecast. My view is that it will grow faster forecast. My view is that it will grow faster than forecast. My view is that it will grow faster than that forecast. My view is that it will grow faster than that as forecast. My view is that it will grow faster than that as it forecast. My view is that it will grow faster than that as it has forecast. My view is that it will grow faster than that as it has over grow faster than that as it has over the grow faster than that as it has over the last grow faster than that as it has over the last few grow faster than that as it has over the last few years grow faster than that as it has over the last few years where grow faster than that as it has over the last few years where wages grow faster than that as it has over the last few years where wages have the last few years where wages have been the last few years where wages have been growing the last few years where wages have been growing at the last few years where wages have been growing at approximately the last few years where wages have been growing at approximately twice been growing at approximately twice the been growing at approximately twice the rate been growing at approximately twice the rate of been growing at approximately twice the rate of inflation. been growing at approximately twice the rate of inflation. Given been growing at approximately twice the rate of inflation. Given the the rate of inflation. Given the fiscal the rate of inflation. Given the fiscal position the rate of inflation. Given the fiscal position he the rate of inflation. Given the fiscal position he has the rate of inflation. Given the fiscal position he has outlined, fiscal position he has outlined, does fiscal position he has outlined, fiscal fiscal position he has outlined, does it surprise fiscal position he has outlined, does it surprise him fiscal position he has outlined, does it surprise him that does it surprise him that does it surprise him that does it surprise him that unemployment will does it surprise him that unemployment will not does it surprise him that unemployment will not drop does it surprise him that unemployment will not drop below unemployment will not drop below 5% unemployment will not drop below unemployment will not drop below 5% for the unemployment will not drop below 5% for the next unemployment will not drop below 5% for the next two unemployment will not drop below 5% for the next two years? unemployment will not drop below 5% for the next two years? The unemployment will not drop below 5% for the next two years? The member for the next two years? The member may for the next two years? The member may not for the next two years? The member may not have for the next two years? The member may not have been for the next two years? The member may not have been updated for the next two years? The member may not have been updated but may not have been updated but actually may not have been updated but actually it may not have been updated but actually it is may not have been updated but actually it is below may not have been updated but actually it is below 5% may not have been updated but actually it is below 5% now, may not have been updated but actually it is below 5% now, in actually it is below 5% now, in fact, actually it is below 5% now, in fact, as actually it is below 5% now, in fact, as a actually it is below 5% now, in fact, as a result actually it is below 5% now, in fact, as a result of actually it is below 5% now, in fact, as a result of the actually it is below 5% now, in fact, as a result of the March fact, as a result of the March quarter, fact, as a result of the March quarter, the fact, as a result of the March quarter, the Household fact, as a result of the March quarter, the Household Labour fact, as a result of the March quarter, the Household Labour Force quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. The quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. The good quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. The good news quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. The good news for quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. The good news for the quarter, the Household Labour Force Survey. The good news for the member Survey. The good news for the member is Survey. The good news for the member is that Survey. The good news for the member is that the Survey. The good news for the member is that the employment Survey. The good news for the member is that the employment rate Survey. The good news for the member is that the employment rate is Survey. The good news for the member is that the employment rate is at is that the employment rate is at 76.1% is that the employment rate is at 76.1% of is that the employment rate is at 76.1% of all is that the employment rate is at 76.1% of all people is that the employment rate is at 76.1% of all people aged is that the employment rate is at 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which is 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which is a 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which is a record 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which is a record for 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which is a record for New 76.1% of all people aged 15-64, which is a record for New Zealand which is a record for New Zealand and which is a record for New Zealand and this which is a record for New Zealand and this Government which is a record for New Zealand and this Government has which is a record for New Zealand and this Government has now which is a record for New Zealand and this Government has now the and this Government has now the second and this Government has now the second highest and this Government has now the second highest rate and this Government has now the second highest rate of and this Government has now the second highest rate of employment and this Government has now the second highest rate of employment in second highest rate of employment in the second highest rate of employment in the OECD second highest rate of employment in the OECD and second highest rate of employment in the OECD and as a second highest rate of employment in the OECD and as a result second highest rate of employment in the OECD and as a result more second highest rate of employment in the OECD and as a result more and the OECD and as a result more and more the OECD and as a result more and more people the OECD and as a result more and more people are the OECD and as a result more and more people are joining the OECD and as a result more and more people are joining the the OECD and as a result more and more people are joining the labour more people are joining the labour force more people are joining the labour force and more people are joining the labour force and I'm more people are joining the labour force and I'm very more people are joining the labour force and I'm very pleased more people are joining the labour force and I'm very pleased with force and I'm very pleased with that. force and I'm very pleased with that. How force and I'm very pleased with that. How is force and I'm very pleased with that. How is the force and I'm very pleased with that. How is the Government's force and I'm very pleased with that. How is the Government's strong that. How is the Government's strong fiscal that. How is the Government's strong fiscal position that. How is the Government's strong fiscal position helping that. How is the Government's strong fiscal position helping deliver that. How is the Government's strong fiscal position helping deliver for fiscal position helping deliver for New fiscal position helping deliver for New Zealanders? The The Government's The Government's strong The Government's strong economic The Government's strong economic plan The Government's strong economic plan means The Government's strong economic plan means we The Government's strong economic plan means we get The Government's strong economic plan means we get to The Government's strong economic plan means we get to make The Government's strong economic plan means we get to make the The Government's strong economic plan means we get to make the sort plan means we get to make the sort of plan means we get to make the sort of choices plan means we get to make the sort of choices we plan means we get to make the sort of choices we were plan means we get to make the sort of choices we were able plan means we get to make the sort of choices we were able to plan means we get to make the sort of choices we were able to make plan means we get to make the sort of choices we were able to make in of choices we were able to make in the of choices we were able to make in fiscal of choices we were able to make in the Budget that's of choices we were able to make in the Budget that's just of choices we were able to make in the Budget that's just been the Budget that's just been the Budget that's just been the Budget that's just been delivered. The the Budget that's just been delivered. The Government the Budget that's just been delivered. The Government is delivered. The Government is investing delivered. The Government is investing $7 delivered. The Government is investing $7 billion delivered. The Government is investing $7 billion of delivered. The Government is investing $7 billion of money delivered. The Government is investing $7 billion of money over investing $7 billion of money over four investing $7 billion of money over four years investing $7 billion of money over four years in investing $7 billion of money over four years in improving investing $7 billion of money over four years in improving public four years in improving public four years in improving public four years in improving public services, as four years in improving public services, as well four years in improving public services, as well as four years in improving public services, as well as $4 four years in improving public services, as well as $4 billion four years in improving public services, as well as $4 billion in services, as well as $4 billion in new services, as well as $4 billion in new money services, as well as $4 billion in new money for services, as well as $4 billion in new money for additional new money for additional infrastructure, new money for additional infrastructure, taking new money for additional infrastructure, taking the new money for additional infrastructure, taking the total infrastructure, taking the total investment infrastructure, taking the total investment over infrastructure, taking the total investment over the infrastructure, taking the total investment over the next infrastructure, taking the total investment over the next four infrastructure, taking the total investment over the next four years investment over the next four years to investment over the next four years to $32.5 investment over the next four years to $32.5 billion investment over the next four years to $32.5 billion and investment over the next four years to $32.5 billion and the investment over the next four years to $32.5 billion and the $2 investment over the next four years to $32.5 billion and the $2 billion to $32.5 billion and the $2 billion Family to $32.5 billion and the $2 billion Family Incomes to $32.5 billion and the $2 billion Family Incomes Package to $32.5 billion and the $2 billion Family Incomes Package that to $32.5 billion and the $2 billion Family Incomes Package that has Family Incomes Package that has received Family Incomes Package that has received reasonably Family Incomes Package that has received reasonably broad Family Incomes Package that has received reasonably broad support received reasonably broad support from received reasonably broad support from across received reasonably broad support from across the received reasonably broad support from across the parliament. received reasonably broad support from across the parliament. It received reasonably broad support from across the parliament. It is from across the parliament. It is only from across the parliament. It is only with from across the parliament. It is only with a from across the parliament. It is only with a consistent from across the parliament. It is only with a consistent economic from across the parliament. It is only with a consistent economic plan only with a consistent economic plan that only with a consistent economic plan that we only with a consistent economic plan that we will only with a consistent economic plan that we will continue only with a consistent economic plan that we will continue to only with a consistent economic plan that we will continue to have only with a consistent economic plan that we will continue to have the that we will continue to have the capacity that we will continue to have the capacity to that we will continue to have the capacity to make that we will continue to have the capacity to make more that we will continue to have the capacity to make more positive capacity to make more positive decisions capacity to make more positive decisions into capacity to make more positive decisions into the capacity to make more positive decisions into the future. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Building My question is to the Minister for Building and My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does he Building and Construction: Does he stand Building and Construction: Does he stand by Building and Construction: Does he stand by his Building and Construction: Does he stand by his statement Building and Construction: Does he stand by his statement that Building and Construction: Does he stand by his statement that this Building and Construction: Does he stand by his statement that this is stand by his statement that this is a stand by his statement that this is a "golden stand by his statement that this is a "golden era" stand by his statement that this is a "golden era" for stand by his statement that this is a "golden era" for the stand by his statement that this is a "golden era" for the building a "golden era" for the building industry; a "golden era" for the building industry; if a "golden era" for the building industry; if so, a "golden era" for the building industry; if so, why? Yes, Yes, Mr Yes, Mr Speaker. Yes, Mr Speaker. The Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made three Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made three years Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made three years ago Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made three years ago in Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made three years ago in 2014 Yes, Mr Speaker. The statement was made three years ago in 2014 when made three years ago in 2014 when releasing made three years ago in 2014 when releasing the made three years ago in 2014 when releasing the construction made three years ago in 2014 when releasing the construction pipeline releasing the construction pipeline report releasing the construction pipeline report which releasing the construction pipeline report which projected releasing the construction pipeline report which projected at releasing the construction pipeline report which projected at least releasing the construction pipeline report which projected at least a report which projected at least a 10% report which projected at least a 10% per report which projected at least a 10% per annum report which projected at least a 10% per annum growth report which projected at least a 10% per annum growth in 10% per annum growth in construction. 10% per annum growth in construction. This 10% per annum growth in construction. This has 10% per annum growth in construction. This has Tranh 10% per annum growth in construction. This has Tranh spired. construction. This has Tranh spired. Commercial construction. This has Tranh spired. Commercial and construction. This has Tranh spired. Commercial and residential construction. This has Tranh spired. Commercial and residential building Commercial and residential building Commercial and residential building Commercial and residential building has increased Commercial and residential building has increased from Commercial and residential building has increased from 13 Commercial and residential building has increased from 13 billion Commercial and residential building has increased from 13 billion a Commercial and residential building has increased from 13 billion a year has increased from 13 billion a year to has increased from 13 billion a year to 20 has increased from 13 billion a year to 20 billion has increased from 13 billion a year to 20 billion per has increased from 13 billion a year to 20 billion per year. has increased from 13 billion a year to 20 billion per year. This has increased from 13 billion a year to 20 billion per year. This is to 20 billion per year. This is significantly to 20 billion per year. This is significantly higher to 20 billion per year. This is significantly higher than to 20 billion per year. This is significantly higher than previous significantly higher than previous construction significantly higher than previous construction booms significantly higher than previous construction booms in significantly higher than previous construction booms in 2003 significantly higher than previous construction booms in 2003 and significantly higher than previous construction booms in 2003 and 1996, construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real terms, construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real terms, IE, construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real terms, IE, it construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real terms, IE, it is construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real terms, IE, it is a construction booms in 2003 and 1996, in real terms, IE, it is a higher in real terms, IE, it is a higher level in real terms, IE, it is a higher level of in real terms, IE, it is a higher level of activity in real terms, IE, it is a higher level of activity than in real terms, IE, it is a higher level of activity than last in real terms, IE, it is a higher level of activity than last time in real terms, IE, it is a higher to in real terms, IE, it is a higher there in real terms, IE, it is a higher there was a boom. in real terms, IE, it is a higher there was a boom. Is in real terms, IE, it is a higher there was a boom. Is it in real terms, IE, it is a higher there was a boom. Is it a in real terms, IE, it is a higher there was a boom. Is it a "golden there was a boom. Is it a "golden era" there was a boom. Is it a "golden era" when there was a boom. Is it a "golden era" when data there was a boom. Is it a "golden era" when data from there was a boom. Is it a "golden era" when data from Statistics there was a boom. Is it a "golden era" when data from Statistics NZ era" when data from Statistics NZ era" when data from Statistics NZ era" when data from Statistics NZ out today era" when data from Statistics NZ out today shows era" when data from Statistics NZ out today shows that era" when data from Statistics NZ out today shows that in era" when data from Statistics NZ out today shows that in the era" when data from Statistics NZ out today shows that in the latest out today shows that in the latest quarter out today shows that in the latest quarter there out today shows that in the latest quarter there was out today shows that in the latest quarter there was the out today shows that in the latest quarter there was the biggest out today shows that in the latest quarter there was the biggest drop quarter there was the biggest drop in quarter there was the biggest drop in construction quarter there was the biggest drop in construction activity quarter there was the biggest drop in construction activity for quarter there was the biggest drop in construction activity for six in construction activity for six in construction activity for six in construction activity for six years? Mr in construction activity for six years? Mr Speaker, in construction activity for six years? Mr Speaker, that in construction activity for six years? Mr Speaker, that was in construction activity for six years? Mr Speaker, that was in years? Mr Speaker, that was in respect years? Mr Speaker, that was in respect of years? Mr Speaker, that was in respect of commercial years? Mr Speaker, that was in respect of commercial building respect of commercial building activity respect of commercial building activity that respect of commercial building activity that has respect of commercial building activity that has actually respect of commercial building activity that has actually been respect of commercial building activity that has actually been at activity that has actually been at incredibly activity that has actually been at incredibly high activity that has actually been at incredibly high levels. activity that has actually been at incredibly high levels. The activity that has actually been at incredibly high levels. The total incredibly high levels. The total level incredibly high levels. The total level of incredibly high levels. The total level of building incredibly high levels. The total level of building activity incredibly high levels. The total level of building activity over incredibly high levels. The total level of building activity over the level of building activity over the last level of building activity over the last year level of building activity over the last year is level of building activity over the last year is $20 level of building activity over the last year is $20 billion, level of building activity over the last year is $20 billion, the level of building activity over the last year is $20 billion, the last last year is $20 billion, the last peak last year is $20 billion, the last peak in last year is $20 billion, the last peak in 2004 last year is $20 billion, the last peak in 2004 was last year is $20 billion, the last peak in 2004 was over last year is $20 billion, the last peak in 2004 was over $14 last year is $20 billion, the last peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. last year is $20 billion, the last peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I would point peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I would point out peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I would point out to peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I would point out to the peak in 2004 was over $14 billion. I would point out to the member would point out to the member would point out to the member would point out to the member interjecting, we would point out to the member interjecting, we are would point out to the member interjecting, we are now would point out to the member interjecting, we are now building interjecting, we are now building over interjecting, we are now building interjecting, interjecting, we are now building over 30,000 houses interjecting, we are now building over 30,000 houses a interjecting, we are now building over 30,000 houses a year. interjecting, we are now building over 30,000 houses a year. That interjecting, we are now building over 30,000 houses a year. That has over 30,000 houses a year. That has over 30,000 houses a year. That has over 30,000 houses a year. That has only occurred over 30,000 houses a year. That has only occurred twice over 30,000 houses a year. That has only occurred twice in over 30,000 houses a year. That has only occurred twice in the over 30,000 houses a year. That has only occurred twice in the last over 30,000 houses a year. That has only occurred twice in the last 50 only occurred twice in the last 50 only occurred twice in the last 50 To To the To the minister, To the minister, if To the minister, if we To the minister, if we are To the minister, if we are still To the minister, if we are still in To the minister, if we are still in a To the minister, if we are still in a "golden To the minister, if we are still in a "golden era" To the minister, if we are still in a "golden era" for To the minister, if we are still in a "golden era" for housing, To the minister, if we are still in a "golden era" for housing, how To the minister, if we are still in a "golden era" for housing, how is a "golden era" for housing, how is it a "golden era" for housing, how is it that a "golden era" for housing, how is it that in a "golden era" for housing, how is it that in the a "golden era" for housing, how is it that in the last a "golden era" for housing, how is it that in the last year a "golden era" for housing, how is it that in the last year we a "golden era" for housing, how is it that in the last year we have it that in the last year we have seen it that in the last year we have seen decreases it that in the last year we have seen decreases in it that in the last year we have seen decreases in rental it that in the last year we have seen decreases in rental stock it that in the last year we have seen decreases in rental stock in seen decreases in rental stock in Wellington, seen decreases in rental stock in Wellington, of seen decreases in rental stock in Wellington, of 65%, seen decreases in rental stock in Wellington, of 65%, Otago, seen decreases in rental stock in Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Bay Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Bay of Plenty, Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Bay of Plenty, 52%, Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Bay of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Bay of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% Wellington, of 65%, Otago, 61%, Bay of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and Auckland of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and Auckland 42% of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and Auckland 42% resulting of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and Auckland 42% resulting in of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and Auckland 42% resulting in very of Plenty, 52%, Canterbury, 48% and Auckland 42% resulting in very large Auckland 42% resulting in very large rent Auckland 42% resulting in very large rent increases? Auckland 42% resulting in very large rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> Order! rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! The rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! The member rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! The member would rent increases? <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! The member would note Order! Order! The member would note that Order! Order! The member would note that actually Order! Order! The member would note that actually in Order! Order! The member would note that actually in Christchurch Order! Order! The member would note that actually in Christchurch rents that actually in Christchurch rents have that actually in Christchurch rents have declined. that actually in Christchurch rents have declined. We that actually in Christchurch rents have declined. We have that actually in Christchurch rents have declined. We have radically have declined. We have radically have declined. We have radically have declined. We have radically increased land have declined. We have radically increased land supply. have declined. We have radically increased land supply. That have declined. We have radically increased land supply. That is have declined. We have radically increased land supply. That is why have declined. We have radically increased land supply. That is why I increased land supply. That is why I look increased land supply. That is why I look forward increased land supply. That is why I look forward to increased land supply. That is why I look forward to New increased land supply. That is why I look forward to New Zealand increased land supply. That is why I look forward to New Zealand First look forward to New Zealand First party look forward to New Zealand First party support look forward to New Zealand First party support for look forward to New Zealand First party support for being look forward to New Zealand First party support for being part look forward to New Zealand First party support for being part of look forward to New Zealand First party support for being part of the party support for being part of the solution party support for being part of the solution rather party support for being part of the solution rather than party support for being part of the solution rather than being party support for being part of the solution rather than being part party support for being part of the solution rather than being part of solution rather than being part of the solution rather than being part of the problem solution rather than being part of the problem by solution rather than being part of the problem by increasing solution rather than being part of the problem by increasing land the problem by increasing land supply the problem by increasing land supply in the problem by increasing land supply in other the problem by increasing land supply in other parts the problem by increasing land supply in other parts of the problem by increasing land supply in other parts of New the problem by increasing land supply in other parts of New Zealand supply in other parts of New Zealand are supply in other parts of New Zealand are the supply in other parts of New Zealand are the housing supply in other parts of New Zealand are the housing market supply in other parts of New Zealand are the housing market are supply in other parts of New Zealand are the housing market are under are the housing market are under pressure. are the housing market are under pressure. A are the housing market are under pressure. A point are the housing market are under pressure. A point of are the housing market are under pressure. A point of order. are the housing market are under pressure. A point of order. That pressure. A point of order. That minister pressure. A point of order. That minister was pressure. A point of order. That minister was asked pressure. A point of order. That minister was asked about pressure. A point of order. That minister was asked about rental minister was asked about rental stock, minister was asked about rental stock, not minister was asked about rental stock, not rentals. minister was asked about rental stock, not rentals. He minister was asked about rental stock, not rentals. He is minister was asked about rental stock, not rentals. He is refusing stock, not rentals. He is refusing to stock, not rentals. He is refusing to answer stock, not rentals. He is refusing to answer the stock, not rentals. He is refusing to answer the question. stock, not rentals. He is refusing to answer the question. No, stock, not rentals. He is refusing to answer the question. No, no, stock, not rentals. He is refusing to answer the question. No, no, the to answer the question. No, no, the member to answer the question. No, no, the member - to answer the question. No, no, the member - I to answer the question. No, no, the member - I don't to answer the question. No, no, the member - I don't need to answer the question. No, no, the member - I don't need assistance member - I don't need assistance from member - I don't need assistance from the member - I don't need assistance from the minister member - I don't need assistance from the minister because member - I don't need assistance from the minister because on member - I don't need assistance from the minister because on this from the minister because on this occasion from the minister because on this occasion the from the minister because on this occasion the question from the minister because on this occasion the question was from the minister because on this occasion the question was without occasion the question was without doubt occasion the question was without doubt addressed. occasion the question was without doubt addressed. Supplement doubt addressed. Supplement question. doubt addressed. Supplement question. Is doubt addressed. Supplement question. Is it doubt addressed. Supplement question. Is it a doubt addressed. Supplement question. Is it a "golden doubt addressed. Supplement question. Is it a "golden era" doubt addressed. Supplement question. Is it a "golden era" when question. Is it a "golden era" when schools question. Is it a "golden era" when schools in question. Is it a "golden era" when schools in Auckland question. Is it a "golden era" when schools in Auckland are question. Is it a "golden era" when schools in Auckland are looking question. Is it a "golden era" when schools in Auckland are looking at schools in Auckland are looking at building schools in Auckland are looking at building houses schools in Auckland are looking at building houses themselves schools in Auckland are looking at building houses themselves on schools in Auckland are looking at building houses themselves on school building houses themselves on school grounds building houses themselves on school grounds or building houses themselves on school grounds or sending building houses themselves on school grounds or sending students building houses themselves on school grounds or sending students home grounds or sending students home because grounds or sending students home because their grounds or sending students home because their teachers grounds or sending students home because their teachers cannot grounds or sending students home because their teachers cannot find because their teachers cannot find because their teachers cannot find because their teachers cannot find affordable housing? because their teachers cannot find affordable housing? I because their teachers cannot find affordable housing? I remind because their teachers cannot find affordable housing? I remind the affordable housing? I remind the member affordable housing? I remind the member again, affordable housing? I remind the member again, the affordable housing? I remind the member again, the "golden affordable housing? I remind the member again, the "golden era" member again, the "golden era" comment member again, the "golden era" comment was member again, the "golden era" comment was made member again, the "golden era" comment was made three member again, the "golden era" comment was made three years member again, the "golden era" comment was made three years ago member again, the "golden era" comment was made three years ago in comment was made three years ago in respect comment was made three years ago in respect of comment was made three years ago in respect of the comment was made three years ago in respect of the growth comment was made three years ago in respect of the growth in comment was made three years ago in respect of the growth in the comment was made three years ago in comment comment was made three years ago in building sector. It comment was made three years ago in building sector. It projected comment was made three years ago in building sector. It projected a comment was made three years ago in building sector. It projected a 10% building sector. It projected a 10% growth building sector. It projected a 10% growth per building sector. It projected a 10% growth per year building sector. It projected a 10% growth per year in building sector. It projected a 10% growth per year in construction building sector. It projected a 10% growth per year in construction and growth per year in construction and we've growth per year in construction and we've actually growth per year in construction and we've actually achieved growth per year in construction and we've actually achieved almost we've actually achieved almost double we've actually achieved almost double that we've actually achieved almost double that was we've actually achieved almost double that was projected we've actually achieved almost double that was projected three we've actually achieved almost double we've actually achieved almost years ago. Is we've actually achieved almost years ago. Is it we've actually achieved almost years ago. Is it a we've actually achieved almost years ago. Is it a "golden we've actually achieved almost years ago. Is it a "golden era" we've actually achieved almost years ago. Is it a "golden era" when years ago. Is it a "golden era" when the years ago. Is it a "golden era" when the number years ago. Is it a "golden era" when the number of years ago. Is it a "golden era" when the number of rentals years ago. Is it a "golden era" when the number of rentals available years ago. Is it a "golden era" when the number of rentals available in the number of rentals available in Wellington the number of rentals available in Wellington has the number of rentals available in Wellington has plummeted the number of rentals available in Wellington has plummeted 65% the number of rentals available in Wellington has plummeted 65% and the number of rentals available in Wellington has plummeted 65% and the Wellington has plummeted 65% and the average Wellington has plummeted 65% and the average rent Wellington has plummeted 65% and the average rent in Wellington has plummeted 65% and the average rent in Wellington Wellington has plummeted 65% and the average rent in Wellington has Wellington has plummeted 65% and the average rent in Wellington has gone average rent in Wellington has gone up average rent in Wellington has gone up by average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 per average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 per year average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 per year or average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 per year or is average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 per year or is that, average rent in Wellington has gone up by $2,340 per year or is that, as up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the PM up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the PM said, up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the PM said, a up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the PM said, a problem up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the PM said, a problem of up by $2,340 per year or is that, as the PM said, a problem of success? the PM said, a problem of success? There the PM said, a problem of success? There is the PM said, a problem of success? There is no the PM said, a problem of success? There is no question the PM said, a problem of success? There is no question that the PM said, a problem of success? There is no question that New There is no question that New Zealand There is no question that New Zealand is There is no question that New Zealand is doing There is no question that New Zealand is doing exceptionally There is no question that New Zealand is doing exceptionally well. Zealand is doing exceptionally well. That Zealand is doing exceptionally well. That means Zealand is doing exceptionally well. That means that Zealand is doing exceptionally well. That means that Kiwis Zealand is doing exceptionally well. That means that Kiwis aren't Zealand is doing exceptionally well. That means that Kiwis aren't leaving That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and our That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and our population That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and our population is That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and our population is growing. That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and our population is growing. As That means that Kiwis aren't leaving and our population is growing. As a and our population is growing. As a consequence and our population is growing. As a consequence this and our population is growing. As a consequence this Government and our population is growing. As a consequence this Government is consequence this Government is growing consequence this Government is growing investment consequence this Government is growing investment in consequence this Government is growing investment in the growing investment in the residential growing investment in the residential area, growing investment in the residential area, the growing investment in the residential area, the commercial residential area, the commercial area residential area, the commercial area and residential area, the commercial area and in residential area, the commercial area and in the residential area, the commercial area and in the Budget, residential area, the commercial area and in the Budget, a residential area, the commercial area and in the Budget, a very residential area, the commercial area and in the Budget, a very large area and in the Budget, a very large area and in the Budget, a very large area and in the Budget, a very large increase in area and in the Budget, a very large increase in infrastructure. area and in the Budget, a very large increase in infrastructure. It area and in the Budget, a very large increase in infrastructure. It is area and in the Budget, a very large increase in infrastructure. It is a increase in infrastructure. It is a golden increase in infrastructure. It is a golden era increase in infrastructure. It is a golden era in increase in infrastructure. It is a golden era in building increase in infrastructure. It is a golden era in building an golden era in building an construction golden era in building an construction -- golden era in building an construction -- and golden era in building an construction -- and construction construction -- and construction across construction -- and construction across New construction -- and construction across New Zealand construction -- and construction across New Zealand as construction -- and construction across New Zealand as we construction -- and construction across New Zealand as we build construction -- and construction across New Zealand as we build this across New Zealand as we build this great across New Zealand as we build this great nation. across New Zealand as we build this great nation. Is across New Zealand as we build this great nation. Is it across New Zealand as we build this great nation. Is it a across New Zealand as we build this great nation. Is it a "golden across New Zealand as we build this great nation. Is it a "golden era" great nation. Is it a "golden era" or great nation. Is it a "golden era" or a great nation. Is it a "golden era" or a problem great nation. Is it a "golden era" or a problem of great nation. Is it a "golden era" or a problem of success great nation. Is it a "golden era" or a problem of success when or a problem of success when families or a problem of success when families like or a problem of success when families like Ashley or a problem of success when families like Ashley Portland or a problem of success when families like Ashley Portland and families like Ashley Portland and her families like Ashley Portland and her two families like Ashley Portland and her two young families like Ashley Portland and her two young children families like Ashley Portland and her two young children who families like Ashley Portland and her two young children who are her two young children who are living her two young children who are living in her two young children who are living in a her two young children who are living in a tiny her two young children who are living in a tiny cold her two young children who are living in a tiny cold caravan her two young children who are living in a tiny cold caravan and living in a tiny cold caravan and report living in a tiny cold caravan and report that living in a tiny cold caravan and report that the living in a tiny cold caravan and report that the kids living in a tiny cold caravan and report that the kids are living in a tiny cold caravan and report that the kids are regularly report that the kids are regularly getting report that the kids are regularly getting sick report that the kids are regularly getting sick because report that the kids are regularly getting sick because of report that the kids are regularly getting sick because of the report that the kids are regularly getting sick because of the cold report that the kids are regularly getting sick because of the cold and getting sick because of the cold and the getting sick because of the cold and the damp, getting sick because of the cold and the damp, they getting sick because of the cold and the damp, they have getting sick because of the cold and the damp, they have been getting sick because of the cold and the damp, they have been there getting sick because of the cold and the damp, they have been there for the damp, they have been there for four the damp, they have been there for four months the damp, they have been there for four months because the damp, they have been there for four months because Ashley the damp, they have been there for four months because Ashley similarly four months because Ashley similarly cannot four months because Ashley similarly cannot find four months because Ashley similarly cannot find anywhere four months because Ashley similarly cannot find anywhere affordable cannot find anywhere affordable to cannot find anywhere affordable cannot find anywhere affordable to rent? The cannot find anywhere affordable to rent? The issue cannot find anywhere affordable to rent? The issue for cannot find anywhere affordable to rent? The issue for that cannot find anywhere affordable to rent? The issue for that family cannot find anywhere affordable to rent? The issue for that family and rent? The issue for that family and others, rent? The issue for that family and others, and rent? The issue for that family and others, and the rent? The issue for that family and others, and the main rent? The issue for that family and others, and the main solution, rent? The issue for that family and others, and the main solution, is others, and the main solution, is the others, and the main solution, is the grow others, and the main solution, is the grow if others, and the main solution, is the grow if number others, and the main solution, is the grow if number of others, and the main solution, is the grow if number of houses others, and the main solution, is the grow if number of houses that the grow if number of houses that are the grow if number of houses that are being the grow if number of houses that are being -- the grow if number of houses that are being -- the the grow if number of houses that are being -- the number the grow if number of houses that are being -- the number of the grow if number of houses that are being -- the number of houses are being -- the number of houses that are being -- the number of houses that are are being -- the number of houses that are being are being -- the number of houses that are being built. are being -- the number of houses that are being built. We are being -- the number of houses that are being built. We have are being -- the number of houses that are being built. We have for that are being built. We have for the that are being built. We have for the very that are being built. We have for the very first that are being built. We have for the very first time... the very first time... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> What <INTERRUPTION> What members <INTERRUPTION> What members opposite <INTERRUPTION> What members opposite will <INTERRUPTION> What members opposite will note <INTERRUPTION> What members opposite will note is What members opposite will note is that What members opposite will note is that for What members opposite will note is that for the What members opposite will note is that for the first What members opposite will note is that for the first time What members opposite will note is that for the first time in What members opposite will note is that for the first time in New that for the first time in New Zealand that for the first time in New Zealand history that for the first time in New Zealand history we that for the first time in New Zealand history we have that for the first time in New Zealand history we have had that for the first time in New Zealand history we have had five Zealand history we have had five straight Zealand history we have had five straight years Zealand history we have had five straight years of Zealand history we have had five straight years of growth Zealand history we have had five straight years of growth in Zealand history we have had five straight years of growth in building straight years of growth in building construction straight years of growth in building construction such straight years of growth in building construction such that straight years of growth in building construction such that we straight years of growth in building construction such that we have straight years of growth in building construction such that we have a construction such that we have a record construction such that we have a record high construction such that we have a record high level construction such that we have a record high level of construction such that we have a record high level of construction record high level of construction activity. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: What, My question is to the Prime Minister: What, if My question is to the Prime Minister: What, if anything, My question is to the Prime Minister: What, if anything, has My question is to the Prime Minister: What, if anything, has he Minister: What, if anything, has he said Minister: What, if anything, has he said to Minister: What, if anything, has he said to United Minister: What, if anything, has he said to United States Minister: What, if anything, has he said to United States Secretary Minister: What, if anything, has he said to United States Secretary of said to United States Secretary of State said to United States Secretary of State Rex said to United States Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said to United States Secretary of State Rex Tillerson about said to United States Secretary of State Rex Tillerson about President State Rex Tillerson about President Trump's State Rex Tillerson about President Trump's decision State Rex Tillerson about President Trump's decision to State Rex Tillerson about President Trump's decision to withdraw State Rex Tillerson about President Trump's decision to withdraw the Trump's decision to withdraw the United Trump's decision to withdraw the United States Trump's decision to withdraw the United States from Trump's decision to withdraw the United States from the Trump's decision to withdraw the United States from the Paris Trump's decision to withdraw the United States from the Paris Climate United States from the Paris Climate United States from the Paris Climate On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the PM, On behalf of the PM, the On behalf of the PM, the meeting On behalf of the PM, the meeting with On behalf of the PM, the meeting with Mr On behalf of the PM, the meeting with Mr Tillerson On behalf of the PM, the meeting with Mr Tillerson has On behalf of the PM, the meeting with Mr Tillerson has only On behalf of the PM, the meeting with Mr Tillerson has only just with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded and with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded and as with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded and as such with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded and as such I with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded and as such I haven't with Mr Tillerson has only just concluded and as such I haven't had concluded and as such I haven't had a concluded and as such I haven't had concluded concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to talk concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to talk to concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to talk to the concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to talk to the PM concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to talk to the PM in concluded and as such I haven't had a chance to talk to the PM in person a chance to talk to the PM in person a chance to talk to the PM in person a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I note a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I note the a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I note the PM a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I note the PM has a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I note the PM has said a chance to talk to the PM in person yet but I note the PM has said he yet but I note the PM has said he will yet but I note the PM has said he will express yet but I note the PM has said he will express New yet but I note the PM has said he will express New Zealand's will express New Zealand's disagreement will express New Zealand's disagreement with will express New Zealand's disagreement with a will express New Zealand's disagreement with a decision will express New Zealand's disagreement with a decision and disagreement with a decision and reiterate disagreement with a decision and reiterate that disagreement with a decision and reiterate that New disagreement with a decision and reiterate that New Zealand reiterate that New Zealand remains reiterate that New Zealand reiterate that New Zealand remains committed to reiterate that New Zealand remains committed to the reiterate that New Zealand remains committed to the Paris reiterate that New Zealand remains committed to the Paris agreement. Does Does the Does the PM Does the PM think Does the PM think that Does the PM think that simply Does the PM think that simply expressing Does the PM think that simply expressing disappointment Does the PM think that simply expressing disappointment is Does the PM think that simply expressing disappointment is strong expressing disappointment is strong enough expressing disappointment is strong enough in expressing disappointment is strong enough in response expressing disappointment is strong enough in response to expressing disappointment is strong enough in response to to expressing disappointment is strong enough in response to to the expressing disappointment is strong enough in response to to the US enough in response to to the US undermining enough in response to to the US undermining the enough in response to to the US undermining the efforts enough in response to to the US undermining the efforts of enough in response to to the US undermining the efforts of nearly undermining the efforts of nearly every undermining the efforts of nearly every other undermining the efforts of nearly every other country undermining the efforts of nearly every other country on undermining the efforts of nearly every other country on earth undermining the efforts of nearly every other country on earth to every other country on earth to stave every other country on earth to undermining every other country on earth to stave off worldwide every other country on earth to stave off worldwide disaster? stave off worldwide disaster? The stave off worldwide disaster? The Hon stave off worldwide disaster? The Hon Paula stave off worldwide disaster? The Hon Paula Bennett stave off worldwide disaster? The Hon Paula Bennett on stave off worldwide disaster? The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf stave off worldwide disaster? The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. Mr The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, on The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of The Hon Paula Bennett on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I think the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I think he's the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I think he's been the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I think he's been very the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I think he's been very clear the PM. Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I think he's been very clear that PM I think he's been very clear that New PM I think he's been very clear that New Zealand PM I think he's been very clear that New Zealand does PM I think he's been very clear that New Zealand does not PM I think he's been very clear that New Zealand does not agree PM I think he's been very clear that New Zealand does not agree with PM I think he's been very clear that New Zealand does not agree with what New Zealand does not agree with what the New Zealand does not agree with what the US New Zealand does not agree with what the US has New Zealand does not agree with what the US has done. New Zealand does not agree with what the US has done. It's New Zealand does not agree with what the US has done. It's not New Zealand does not agree with what the US has done. It's not something the US has done. It's not something that the US has done. It's not something that New the US has done. It's not something that New Zealand the US has done. It's not something that New Zealand is the US has done. It's not something that New Zealand is looking the US has done. It's not something that New Zealand is looking at. the US has done. It's not something that New Zealand is looking at. We that New Zealand is looking at. We stay that New Zealand is looking at. We stay strongly that New Zealand is looking at. We stay strongly committed that New Zealand is looking at. We stay strongly committed to that New Zealand is looking at. We stay strongly committed to the that New Zealand is looking at. We stay strongly committed to the Paris stay strongly committed to the Paris Agreement. stay strongly committed to the Paris Agreement. I'm stay strongly committed to the Paris Agreement. I'm not stay strongly committed to the Paris Agreement. I'm not sure stay strongly committed to the Paris Agreement. I'm not sure that stay strongly committed to the Paris Agreement. I'm not sure that there's Agreement. I'm not sure that there's a Agreement. I'm not sure that there's a different Agreement. I'm not sure that there's a different response Agreement. I'm not sure that there's a different response from Agreement. I'm not sure that there's a different response from New a different response from New Zealand a different response from New Zealand that a different response from New Zealand that would a different response from New Zealand that would get a different response from New Zealand that would get a a different response from New Zealand that would get a different Zealand that would get a different answer Zealand that would get a different a Zealand that would get a different answer from the Zealand that would get a different answer from the President Zealand that would get a different answer from the President of Zealand that would get a different answer from the President of the answer from the President of the United answer from the President of the United States. United States. Did United States. Did the United States. Did the PM United States. Did the PM inform United States. Did the PM inform Secretary Did the PM inform Secretary Tillerson Did the PM inform Secretary Tillerson that Did the PM inform Secretary Tillerson that the Did the PM inform Secretary Tillerson that the New Did the PM inform Secretary Tillerson that the New Zealand Tillerson that the New Zealand Defence Tillerson that the New Zealand Defence Force Tillerson that the New Zealand Defence Force considers Tillerson that the New Zealand Defence Force considers climate Defence Force considers climate change Defence Force considers climate Tillerson Defence Force considers climate change a major Defence Force considers climate change a major emerging Defence Force considers climate change a major emerging stabt Defence Force considers climate change a major emerging stabt threat change a major emerging stabt threat in change a major emerging stabt threat in the change a major emerging stabt threat in the Pacific change a major emerging stabt threat in the Pacific region change a major emerging stabt threat in the Pacific region and, change a major emerging stabt threat in the Pacific region and, if change a major emerging stabt threat in the Pacific region and, if so, in the Pacific region and, if so, what in the Pacific region and, if so, what was in the Pacific region and, if so, what was Secretary in the Pacific region and, if so, what was Secretary Tillerso in the Pacific region and, if so, what was Secretary Tillerso nashgs's what was Secretary Tillerso nashgs's response? response? -- response? -- Tillerson's response? -- Tillerson's response? -- Tillerson's response? As -- Tillerson's response? As I -- Tillerson's response? As I noted -- Tillerson's response? As I noted in -- Tillerson's response? As I noted in my -- Tillerson's response? As I noted in my answer, -- Tillerson's response? As I noted in my answer, that As I noted in my answer, that meeting As I noted in my answer, that meeting has As I noted in my answer, that meeting has just As I noted in my answer, that meeting has just concluded As I noted in my answer, that meeting has just concluded and As I noted in my answer, that meeting has just concluded and I meeting has just concluded and I don't meeting has just concluded and I As meeting has just concluded and I don't know what meeting has just concluded and I don't know what they meeting has just concluded and I don't know what they spoke meeting has just concluded and I don't know what they spoke of. don't know what they spoke of. Did don't know what they spoke of. Did the don't know what they spoke of. Did the PM don't know what they spoke of. Did the PM tell don't know what they spoke of. Did the PM tell Secretary don't know what they spoke of. Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson if Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson if the Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson if the United Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson if the United States Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson if the United States want Did the PM tell Secretary Tillerson if the United States want to if the United States want to continue if the United States want to As if the United States want to continue to play if the United States want to continue to play a if the United States want to continue to play a leadership if the United States want to continue to play a leadership role continue to play a leadership role in continue to play a leadership role in the continue to play a leadership role in the Pacific continue to play a leadership role in the Pacific it continue to play a leadership role in the Pacific it will continue to play a leadership role in the Pacific it will need continue to play a leadership role in the Pacific it will need to in the Pacific it will need to understand in the Pacific it will need to understand the in the Pacific it will need to understand the actions in the Pacific it will need to understand the actions it's in the Pacific it will need to understand the actions it's taken understand the actions it's taken cethly understand the actions it's taken cethly threaten understand the actions it's taken cethly threaten the understand the actions it's taken cethly threaten the continued cethly threaten the continued survival cethly threaten the continued survival and cethly threaten the continued survival and existence cethly threaten the continued survival and existence of cethly threaten the continued survival and existence of a cethly threaten the continued survival and existence of a number survival and existence of a number of survival and existence of a number understand survival and existence of a number of Pacific Island survival and existence of a number of Pacific Island states? of Pacific Island states? Mr of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, as of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, as I of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, as I stated of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, as I stated on of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of Pacific Island states? Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the PM, Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the PM, I'm Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the PM, I'm not Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the PM, I'm not sure Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the PM, I'm not sure exactly Mr Speaker, as I stated on behalf of the PM, I'm not sure exactly what the PM, I'm not sure exactly what those the PM, I'm not sure exactly what those discussions the PM, I'm not sure exactly what those discussions were, the PM, I'm not sure exactly what those discussions were, as the PM, I'm not sure exactly what those discussions were, as they the PM, I'm not sure exactly what those discussions were, as they have those discussions were, as they have just those discussions were, as they have just taken those discussions were, as they have just taken place. those discussions were, as they have just taken place. The those discussions were, as they have just taken place. The best those discussions were, as they have just taken place. The best I those discussions were, as they have just taken place. The best I can just taken place. The best I can give just taken place. The best I can give the just taken place. The best I can give the member just taken place. The best I can give the member is just taken place. The best I can give the member is a just taken place. The best I can give the member is a Twitter just taken place. The best I can give the member is a Twitter feed give the member is a Twitter feed from give the member is a Twitter feed from Vernon give the member is a Twitter feed from Vernon Small give the member is a Twitter feed from Vernon Small which give the member is a Twitter feed from Vernon Small which said give the member is a Twitter feed from Vernon Small which said that from Vernon Small which said that the from Vernon Small which said that the US from Vernon Small which said that the US is from Vernon Small which said that the US is proud from Vernon Small which said that the US is proud of from Vernon Small which said that the US is proud of its the US is proud of its record-reducing the US is proud of its record-reducing greenhouse the US is proud of its record-reducing greenhouse gases the US is proud of its record-reducing greenhouse gases and record-reducing greenhouse gases and he record-reducing greenhouse gases and he quoted, record-reducing greenhouse gases and he quoted, "I record-reducing greenhouse gases and he quoted, "I don't record-reducing greenhouse gases and he quoted, "I don't think record-reducing greenhouse gases and he quoted, "I don't think anyone he quoted, "I don't think anyone should he quoted, "I don't think anyone give he quoted, "I don't think anyone should interpret the he quoted, "I don't think anyone should interpret the US he quoted, "I don't think anyone should interpret the US has he quoted, "I don't think anyone should interpret the US has stepped should interpret the US has stepped away should interpret the US has stepped away from should interpret the US has stepped away from these should interpret the US has stepped away from these issues", should interpret the US has stepped away from these issues", end should interpret the US has stepped away from these issues", end quote. away from these issues", end quote. Did away from these issues", end quote. Did the away from these issues", end quote. Did the PM away from these issues", end quote. Did the PM convey away from these issues", end quote. Did the PM convey with away from these issues", end quote. Did the PM convey with urgency away from these issues", end quote. Did the PM convey with urgency to Did the PM convey with urgency to Secretary Did the PM convey with urgency to Secretary tell Did the PM convey with urgency to Secretary tell tell Did the PM convey with urgency to Secretary tell tell that Did the PM convey with urgency to Secretary tell tell that climate Secretary tell tell that climate change Secretary tell tell that climate change is Secretary tell tell that climate change is the Secretary tell tell that climate change is the single Secretary tell tell that climate change is the single byes Secretary tell tell that climate change is the single byes guest change is the single byes guest issue change is the single byes guest issue to change is the single byes guest issue to those change is the single byes guest issue to those who change is the single byes guest issue to those who will change is the single byes guest issue to those who will face issue to those who will face replacement issue to those who will face replacement in issue to those who will face replacement in terms issue to those who will face replacement in terms of issue to those who will face replacement in terms of climate replacement in terms of climate change replacement in terms of climate change when replacement in terms of climate change when the replacement in terms of climate change when the US replacement in terms of climate change when the US is replacement in terms of climate change when the US is the replacement in terms of climate change when the US is the number replacement in terms of climate change when the US is the number one change when the US is the number one polluter change when the US is the number one polluter in change when the US is the number one polluter in terms change when the US is the number one polluter in terms of change when the US is the number one polluter in terms of capita change when the US is the number one polluter in terms of capita item polluter in terms of capita item emissions, polluter in terms of capita item emissions, compared polluter in terms of capita item emissions, compared with polluter in terms of capita item emissions, compared with the polluter in terms of capita item emissions, compared with the Pacific emissions, compared with the Pacific Island emissions, compared with the Pacific Island emissions emissions, compared with the Pacific Island emissions of emissions, compared with the Pacific Island emissions of approximately Island emissions of approximately 0.96 Island emissions of approximately emissions, Island emissions of approximately 0.96 tonnes of Island emissions of approximately 0.96 tonnes of carbon Island emissions of approximately 0.96 tonnes of carbon dioxide Island emissions of approximately 0.96 tonnes of carbon dioxide per 0.96 tonnes of carbon dioxide per year? year? The year? The Hon year? The Hon Paula year? The Hon Paula Ben year? The Hon Paula Ben fet year? The Hon Paula Ben fet on year? The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf year? The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I am The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon Paula the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon Paula Ben the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon Paula Ben fet the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon Paula Ben fet on the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf the PM. Mr Speaker, I am unshurp -- The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I am The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, The Hon Paula Ben fet on behalf of the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not had the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not had a the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not had a chance the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not had a chance to the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not had a chance to see the PM. Mr Speaker, I am un, because I have not had a chance to see how I have not had a chance to see how that I have not had a chance to see how that conversation I have not had a chance to see how that conversation went. I have not had a chance to see how that conversation went. Hopefully that conversation went. Hopefully the that conversation went. Hopefully the renegotiating that conversation went. Hopefully the renegotiating means that conversation went. Hopefully the renegotiating means something the renegotiating means something meaningful the renegotiating means something meaningful but the renegotiating means something meaningful but the the renegotiating means something meaningful but the rest the renegotiating means something meaningful but the rest of the renegotiating means something meaningful but the rest of the the renegotiating means something meaningful but the rest of the world meaningful but the rest of the world is meaningful but the rest of the world is unsure. meaningful but the rest of the world is unsure. We meaningful but the rest of the world is unsure. We voice meaningful but the rest of the world is unsure. We voice our is unsure. We voice our disappointment, is unsure. We voice our disappointment, stand is unsure. We voice our disappointment, stand with is unsure. We voice our disappointment, stand with our disappointment, stand with our Pacific disappointment, stand with our is disappointment, stand with our Pacific cousins in disappointment, stand with our Pacific cousins in making disappointment, stand with our Pacific cousins in making sure disappointment, stand with our Pacific cousins in making sure we Pacific cousins in making sure we lower Pacific cousins in making sure we lower our Pacific cousins in making sure we lower our emissions Pacific cousins in making sure we lower our emissions and Pacific cousins in making sure we lower our emissions and work Pacific cousins in making sure we lower our emissions and work with lower our emissions and work with the lower our emissions and work with is lower our emissions and work with the rest of lower our emissions and work with the rest of the lower our emissions and work with the rest of the world lower our emissions and work with the rest of the world in lower our emissions and work with the rest of the world in doing lower our emissions and work with the rest of the world in doing so. the rest of the world in doing so. Does the rest of the world in doing so. Does the the rest of the world in doing so. Does the PM the rest of the world in doing so. Does the PM agree the rest of the world in doing so. Does the PM agree with the rest of the world in doing so. Does the PM agree with his the rest of the world in doing so. Does the PM agree with his Minister Does the PM agree with his Minister of Does the PM agree with his Minister of Foreign Does the PM agree with his Minister of Foreign Affairs Does the PM agree with his Minister of Foreign Affairs that Does the PM agree with his Minister of Foreign Affairs that quote, Does the PM agree with his Minister of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In the of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In Does of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In the end it of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In the end it is of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In the end it is 2 of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In the end it is 2 trading of Foreign Affairs that quote, "In the end it is 2 trading relationship the end it is 2 trading relationship that's the end it is 2 trading relationship that's pretty the end it is 2 trading relationship that's pretty important the end it is 2 trading relationship that's pretty important to the end it is 2 trading relationship that's pretty important to us", the end it is 2 trading relationship that's pretty important to us", end that's pretty important to us", end quote. that's pretty important to us", end the that's pretty important to us", end quote. If so, that's pretty important to us", end quote. If so, how that's pretty important to us", end quote. If so, how does that's pretty important to us", end quote. If so, how does he that's pretty important to us", end quote. If so, how does he think that's pretty important to us", end quote. If so, how does he think that quote. If so, how does he think that the quote. If so, how does he think that the trading quote. If so, how does he think that the trading relationship quote. If so, how does he think that the trading relationship will quote. If so, how does he think that the trading relationship will be the trading relationship will be affected the trading relationship will be affected by the trading relationship will be affected by increasing the trading relationship will be affected by increasing droughts the trading relationship will be affected by increasing droughts and affected by increasing droughts and floods affected by increasing droughts and affected affected by increasing droughts and floods savaging our affected by increasing droughts and floods savaging our export floods savaging our export industries, floods savaging our export industries, massive floods savaging our export industries, massive movements floods savaging our export industries, massive movements of industries, massive movements of people industries, massive movements of people leaving industries, massive movements of people leaving uninhabitable people leaving uninhabitable homelands people leaving uninhabitable homelands and people leaving uninhabitable homelands and as people leaving uninhabitable homelands and as the people leaving uninhabitable homelands and as the Pentagon people leaving uninhabitable homelands and as the Pentagon itself homelands and as the Pentagon itself worries, homelands and as the Pentagon itself worries, increasing homelands and as the Pentagon itself worries, increasing instability homelands and as the Pentagon itself worries, increasing instability from worries, increasing instability from climate worries, increasing instability from people worries, increasing instability from climate change. On worries, increasing instability from climate change. On behalf worries, increasing instability from climate change. On behalf of worries, increasing instability from climate change. On behalf of the worries, increasing instability from climate change. On behalf of the PM climate change. On behalf of the PM I climate change. On behalf of the PM I think climate change. On behalf of the PM I think it's climate change. On behalf of the PM I think it's a climate change. On behalf of the PM I think it's a number climate change. On behalf of the PM I think it's a number of climate change. On behalf of the PM I think it's a number of different I think it's a number of different facets I think it's a number of different facets to I think it's a number of different facets to the I think it's a number of different facets to the relationship I think it's a number of different facets to the relationship with I think it's a number of different facets to the relationship with the facets to the relationship with the US facets to the relationship with the US that facets to the relationship with the US that is facets to the relationship with the US that is important facets to the relationship with the US that is important to facets to the relationship with the US that is important to us. facets to the relationship with the US that is important to us. Trade facets to the relationship with the US that is important to us. Trade is US that is important to us. Trade is one, US that is important to us. Trade is one, as US that is important to us. Trade is one, as is US that is important to us. Trade is one, as is our US that is important to us. Trade is one, as is our security. US that is important to us. Trade is one, as is our security. We US that is important to us. Trade is one, as is our security. We are one, as is our security. We are disappointed one, as is our security. We are disappointed to one, as is our security. We are disappointed to see one, as is our security. We are disappointed to see they've one, as is our security. We are disappointed to see they've pulled disappointed to see they've pulled out disappointed to see they've pulled out of disappointed to see they've pulled out of the disappointed to see they've pulled out of the Paris disappointed to see they've pulled out of the Paris Agreement disappointed to see they've pulled out of the Paris Agreement wu disappointed to see they've pulled out of the Paris Agreement wu hope out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we can out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we can continue out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we can continue to out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we can continue to work out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we can continue to work in out of the Paris Agreement wu hope we can continue to work in someway we can continue to work in someway to we can continue to work in someway to reduce we can continue to work in someway to reduce their we can continue to work in someway to reduce their own we can continue to work in someway to reduce their own emissions we can continue to work in someway to reduce their own emissions in we can continue to work in someway to reduce their own emissions in the to reduce their own emissions in the US. US. Given US. Given New US. Given New Zealand's US. Given New Zealand's proud US. Given New Zealand's proud history US. Given New Zealand's proud history of Given New Zealand's proud history of standing Given New Zealand's proud history of standing up Given New Zealand's proud history of standing up for Given New Zealand's proud history of standing up for the Given New Zealand's proud history of standing up for the United Given New Zealand's proud history of standing up for the United States standing up for the United States over standing up for the United States over nuclear standing up for the United States over nuclear weapons, standing up for the United States over nuclear weapons, isn't standing up for the United States over nuclear weapons, isn't today over nuclear weapons, isn't today the over nuclear weapons, isn't today over over nuclear weapons, isn't today the day that over nuclear weapons, isn't today the day that our over nuclear weapons, isn't today the day that our PM over nuclear weapons, isn't today the day that our PM should over nuclear weapons, isn't today the day that our PM should be the day that our PM should be standing the day that our PM should be standing up the day that our PM should be standing up to the day that our PM should be standing up to the the day that our PM should be standing up to the United the day that our PM should be standing up to the United States standing up to the United States about standing up to the United States about climate standing up to the United States about climate change standing up to the United States about climate change and standing up to the United States about climate change and condemn about climate change and condemn Trump's about climate change and condemn Trump's decision about climate change and condemn Trump's decision to about climate change and condemn Trump's decision to withdraw about climate change and condemn Trump's decision to withdraw from Trump's decision to withdraw from the Trump's decision to withdraw from Trump's Trump's decision to withdraw from the Paris Agreement? the Paris Agreement? Mr the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on behalf the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on behalf of the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on behalf of the the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I the Paris Agreement? Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do note Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do note that Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do note that there Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do note that there are Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do note that there are states Mr Speaker, on behalf of the PM I do note that there are states within note that there are states within America note that there are states within America that note that there are states within America that are note that there are states within America that are still note that there are states within America that are still very America that are still very committed America that are still very committed to America that are still very committed to reducing America that are still very committed to reducing emissions America that are still very committed to reducing emissions and committed to reducing emissions and in committed to reducing emissions and in fact committed to reducing emissions and in fact California committed to reducing emissions and in fact California have committed to reducing emissions and in fact California have one committed to reducing emissions and in fact California have one of committed to reducing emissions and in fact California have one of the committed to reducing emissions and in fact California have one of the - in fact California have one of the - an in fact California have one of the - an emissions in fact California have one of the - an emissions trading in fact California have one of the - an emissions trading scheme in fact California have one of the - an emissions trading scheme that an emissions trading scheme that works an emissions trading scheme that works well an emissions trading scheme that works well and an emissions trading scheme that works well and you an emissions trading scheme that works well and you can an emissions trading scheme that works well and you can see an emissions trading scheme that works well and you can see the works well and you can see the emissions works well and you can see the emissions tracking works well and you can see the emissions tracking down. works well and you can see the emissions tracking down. Equally emissions tracking down. Equally there emissions tracking down. Equally there are emissions tracking down. Equally there are big emissions tracking down. Equally there are big US emissions tracking down. Equally there are big US businesses emissions tracking down. Equally there are big US businesses that there are big US businesses that understand, there are big US businesses that understand, they there are big US businesses that understand, they to there are big US businesses that understand, they to have there are big US businesses that understand, they to have a there are big US businesses that understand, they to have a future understand, they to have a future they understand, they to have a future they need understand, they to have a future they need more understand, they to have a future they need more clean understand, they to have a future they need more clean energy understand, they to have a future they need more clean energy and understand, they to have a future they need more clean energy and are they need more clean energy and are committed they need more clean energy and are committed to they need more clean energy and are committed to that. they need more clean energy and are committed to that. I they need more clean energy and are committed to that. I think they need more clean energy and are committed to that. I think in they need more clean energy and are committed to that. I think in con committed to that. I think in con Democrating committed to that. I think in con Democrating the committed to that. I think in con Democrating the whole committed to that. I think in con Democrating the whole US committed to that. I think in con Democrating the whole US with committed to that. I think in con Democrating the whole US with the Democrating the whole US with the stance Democrating the whole US with the stance -- Democrating the whole US with the stance -- condemning Democrating the whole US with the stance -- condemning the Democrating the whole US with the stance -- condemning the whole Democrating the whole US with the stance -- condemning the whole US stance -- condemning the whole US with stance -- condemning the whole US with the stance -- condemning the whole US with the stance stance -- condemning the whole US with the stance the stance -- condemning the whole US with the stance the current with the stance the current administration with the stance the current with with the stance the current administration has taken with the stance the current administration has taken would with the stance the current administration has taken would be administration has taken would be wrong administration has taken would be wrong in administration has taken would be wrong in my administration has taken would be wrong in my opinion. wrong in my opinion. Isn't wrong in my opinion. Isn't the wrong in my opinion. Isn't the real wrong in my opinion. Isn't the real reason wrong in my opinion. Isn't the real reason why wrong in my opinion. Isn't the real reason why the wrong in my opinion. Isn't the real reason why the PM wrong in my opinion. Isn't the real reason why the PM is Isn't the real reason why the PM is failing Isn't the real reason why the PM is failing to Isn't the real reason why the PM is failing to strongly Isn't the real reason why the PM is failing to strongly condemn failing to strongly condemn President's failing to strongly condemn President's -- failing to strongly condemn President's -- President failing to strongly condemn President's -- President Trump's President's -- President Trump's decision President's -- President Trump's decision is President's -- President Trump's decision is mormly President's -- President Trump's decision is mormly he President's -- President Trump's decision is mormly he doesn't President's -- President Trump's decision is mormly he doesn't have President's -- President Trump's decision is mormly he doesn't have a decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to stand decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to stand on decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to stand on because decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to stand on because in decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to stand on because in his decision is mormly he doesn't have a leg to stand on because in his watch leg to stand on because in his watch there's leg to stand on because in his watch there's been leg to stand on because in his watch there's been a leg to stand on because in his watch there's been a massive leg to stand on because in his watch there's been a massive expansion leg to stand on because in his watch there's been a massive expansion of there's been a massive expansion of oil there's been a massive expansion of oil exploration there's been a massive expansion of oil exploration and there's been a massive expansion of oil exploration and New there's been a massive expansion of oil exploration and New Zealand oil exploration and New Zealand emissions oil exploration and New Zealand emissions have oil exploration and New Zealand emissions have increased oil exploration and New Zealand emissions have increased 19% oil exploration and New Zealand emissions have increased 19% since emissions have increased 19% since this emissions have increased 19% since emissions emissions have increased 19% since this Government came emissions have increased 19% since this Government came to emissions have increased 19% since this Government came to office? this Government came to office? Mr this Government came to office? Mr Speaker, this Government came to office? Mr Speaker, no, this Government came to office? Mr Speaker, no, this this Government came to office? Mr Speaker, no, this part this Government came to office? Mr Speaker, no, this part of this Government came to office? Mr Speaker, no, this part of the Mr Speaker, no, this part of the House, Mr Speaker, no, this part of the House, this Mr Speaker, no, this part of the House, this Government, Mr Speaker, no, this part of the House, this Government, is Mr Speaker, no, this part of the House, this Government, is proud Mr Speaker, no, this part of the House, this Government, is proud of House, this Government, is proud of the House, this Government, is proud of the ambitious House, this Government, is proud of the ambitious targets House, this Government, is proud of the ambitious targets that House, this Government, is proud of the ambitious targets that we've House, this Government, is proud of the ambitious targets that we've set the ambitious targets that we've set for the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. We the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. We want the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. We want to the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. We want to bend the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. We want to bend the the ambitious targets that we've set for 2030. We want to bend the curve for 2030. We want to bend the curve of for 2030. We want to bend the curve of emissions for 2030. We want to bend the curve of emissions in for 2030. We want to bend the curve of emissions in this for 2030. We want to bend the curve of emissions in this country for 2030. We want to bend the curve of emissions in this country and for 2030. We want to bend the curve of emissions in this country and are of emissions in this country and are doing of emissions in this country and are doing a of emissions in this country and are doing a whole of emissions in this country and are doing a whole lot of emissions in this country and are doing a whole lot of of emissions in this country and are doing a whole lot of very of emissions in this country and are doing a whole lot of very sensible doing a whole lot of very sensible things doing a whole lot of very sensible doing doing a whole lot of very sensible things to make doing a whole lot of very sensible things to make sure doing a whole lot of very sensible things to make sure we doing a whole lot of very sensible things to make sure we arrive doing a whole lot of very sensible things to make sure we arrive there. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Education: My question is to the Minister of Education: How My question is to the Minister of Education: How many My question is to the Minister of Education: How many schools Education: How many schools throughout Education: How many schools throughout New Education: How many schools throughout New Zealand Education: How many schools throughout New Zealand has Education: How many schools throughout New Zealand has the throughout New Zealand has the Ministry throughout New Zealand has the Ministry of throughout New Zealand has the Ministry of Education throughout New Zealand has the Ministry of Education identified throughout New Zealand has the Ministry of Education identified as Ministry of Education identified as being Ministry of Education identified as being over Ministry of Education identified as being over capacity Ministry of Education identified as being over capacity or Ministry of Education identified as being over capacity or at Ministry of Education identified as being over capacity or at risk Ministry of Education identified as being over capacity or at risk of being over capacity or at risk of overcrowding? In In calling In calling the In calling the Hon In calling the Hon Nikki In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my office In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my office has In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my office has been In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my office has been advised In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my office has been advised the In calling the Hon Nikki Kaye my office has been advised the answer office has been advised the answer may office has been advised the answer being office has been advised the answer may be longer office has been advised the answer may be longer than office has been advised the answer may be longer than normal. may be longer than normal. I'm may be longer than normal. I'm advised may be longer than normal. I'm advised the may be longer than normal. I'm advised the ministry may be longer than normal. I'm advised the ministry has may be longer than normal. I'm advised the ministry has a I'm advised the ministry has a pretty I'm advised the ministry has a pretty crude I'm advised the ministry has a pretty crude system I'm advised the ministry has a pretty crude system of I'm advised the ministry has a pretty crude system of identifying pretty crude system of identifying and pretty crude system of identifying and classifying pretty crude system of identifying and classifying these pretty crude system of identifying and classifying these schools pretty crude system of identifying and classifying these schools that and classifying these schools that may and classifying these schools that may have and classifying these schools that may have been and classifying these schools that may have been in and classifying these schools that may have been in the and classifying these schools that may have been in the past and classifying these schools that may have been in the past defined and classifying these schools that may have been in the past defined as may have been in the past defined as over-capacity may have been in the past defined as over-capacity or may have been in the past defined as over-capacity or at may have been in the past defined as over-capacity or at risk may have been in the past defined as over-capacity or at risk of over-capacity or at risk of overcrowding, over-capacity or at risk of overcrowding, including over-capacity or at risk of overcrowding, including role overcrowding, including role reversal overcrowding, including role reversal data overcrowding, including role reversal data collected overcrowding, including role reversal data collected only overcrowding, including role reversal data collected only twice overcrowding, including role reversal data collected only twice a reversal data collected only twice a year. reversal data collected only twice a year. The reversal data collected only twice a year. The figures reversal data collected only twice a year. The figures I reversal data collected only twice a year. The figures I have reversal data collected only twice a year. The figures I have are reversal data collected only twice a year. The figures I have are 2016 year. The figures I have are 2016 figures year. The figures I have are 2016 figures which year. The figures I have are 2016 figures which are year. The figures I have are 2016 figures which are misleading year. The figures I have are 2016 figures which are misleading and year. The figures I have are 2016 figures which are misleading and out figures which are misleading and out of figures which are misleading and out year. figures which are misleading and out of date. At figures which are misleading and out of date. At that figures which are misleading and out of date. At that time figures which are misleading and out of date. At that time there figures which are misleading and out of date. At that time there were figures which are misleading and out of date. At that time there were 230 of date. At that time there were 230 schools of date. At that time there were 230 schools that of date. At that time there were 230 schools that they of date. At that time there were 230 schools that they identified of date. At that time there were 230 schools that they identified that schools that they identified that were schools that they identified that were above schools that they identified that were above capacity. schools that they identified that were above capacity. However, schools that they identified that were above capacity. However, this were above capacity. However, this categorisation were above capacity. However, this categorisation does were above capacity. However, this categorisation does not were above capacity. However, this categorisation does not take were above capacity. However, this categorisation does not take into categorisation does not take into account categorisation does not take into categorisation categorisation does not take into account whether the categorisation does not take into account whether the school categorisation does not take into account whether the school has account whether the school has bought account whether the school has bought own account whether the school has bought own property, account whether the school has bought own property, leasing bought own property, leasing property bought own property, leasing property or bought own property, leasing property or any bought own property, leasing property or any property bought own property, leasing property or any property solutions property or any property solutions under property or any property solutions property property or any property solutions under way. The property or any property solutions under way. The label property or any property solutions under way. The label doesn't property or any property solutions under way. The label doesn't mean property or any property solutions under way. The label doesn't mean a under way. The label doesn't mean a school under way. The label doesn't mean a school is under way. The label doesn't mean a school is overcrowded under way. The label doesn't mean a school is overcrowded or under way. The label doesn't mean a school is overcrowded or unsafe. under way. The label doesn't mean a school is overcrowded or unsafe. I'm school is overcrowded or unsafe. I'm advised school is overcrowded or unsafe. I'm advised the school is overcrowded or unsafe. I'm advised the ministry school is overcrowded or unsafe. I'm advised the ministry is school is overcrowded or unsafe. I'm advised the ministry is confident advised the ministry is confident there advised the ministry is confident there are advised the ministry is confident there are no advised the ministry is confident there are no health advised the ministry is confident there are no health and advised the ministry is confident there are no health and safety there are no health and safety issues, there are no health and safety advised there are no health and safety issues, in part there are no health and safety issues, in part because there are no health and safety issues, in part because our there are no health and safety issues, in part because our property issues, in part because our property allocation issues, in part because our property allocation is issues, in part because our property allocation is very issues, in part because our property allocation is very generous issues, in part because our property allocation is very generous compared allocation is very generous compared to allocation is very generous compared to other allocation is very generous compared to other countries, allocation is very generous compared to other countries, so allocation is very generous compared to other countries, so a allocation is very generous compared to other countries, so a school allocation is very generous compared to other countries, so a school with to other countries, so a school with be to other countries, so a school with be at to other countries, so a school with be at 100% to other countries, so a school with be at 100% capacity to other countries, so a school with be at 100% capacity and to other countries, so a school with be at 100% capacity and cannot to other countries, so a school with be at 100% capacity and cannot be be at 100% capacity and cannot be overcrowded. be at 100% capacity and cannot be overcrowded. I'm be at 100% capacity and cannot be overcrowded. I'm also be at 100% capacity and cannot be overcrowded. I'm also advised be at 100% capacity and cannot be overcrowded. I'm also advised in overcrowded. I'm also advised in this overcrowded. I'm also advised in this year's overcrowded. I'm also advised in this year's Budget overcrowded. I'm also advised in this year's Budget $8 overcrowded. I'm also advised in this year's Budget $8 million overcrowded. I'm also advised in this year's Budget $8 million was this year's Budget $8 million was announced this year's Budget $8 million was announced to this year's Budget $8 million was announced to enhance this year's Budget $8 million was announced to enhance the this year's Budget $8 million was announced to enhance the ministry's announced to enhance the ministry's strategic announced to enhance the ministry's strategic planning announced to enhance the ministry's strategic planning capabilities announced to enhance the ministry's strategic planning capabilities to strategic planning capabilities to enable strategic planning capabilities to enable them strategic planning capabilities to enable them to strategic planning capabilities to enable them to better strategic planning capabilities to enable them to better forecast strategic planning capabilities to enable them to better forecast and enable them to better forecast and plan enable them to better forecast and announced enable them to better forecast and plan for growth. plan for growth. Supplementary plan for growth. Supplementary question, plan for growth. Supplementary question, Chris Supplementary question, Chris Hipkins. Supplementary question, Chris Hipkins. Why Supplementary question, Chris Hipkins. Why does Supplementary question, Chris Hipkins. Why does she Supplementary question, Chris Hipkins. Why does she continue Supplementary question, Chris Hipkins. Why does she continue deny Hipkins. Why does she continue deny a Hipkins. Why does she continue deny a problem Hipkins. Why does she continue deny a problem when Hipkins. Why does she continue deny a problem when the Hipkins. Why does she continue deny a problem when the Ministry Hipkins. Why does she continue deny a problem when the Ministry of a problem when the Ministry of Education, a problem when the Ministry of Education, quote, a problem when the Ministry of Education, quote, "Historic a problem when the Ministry of Education, quote, "Historic property Education, quote, "Historic property responses Education, quote, "Historic property Supplementary Education, quote, "Historic property responses have not Education, quote, "Historic property responses have not been Education, quote, "Historic property responses have not been able Education, quote, "Historic property responses have not been able to Education, quote, "Historic property responses have not been able to keep responses have not been able to keep up responses have not been able to keep up with responses have not been able to keep up with demand responses have not been able to keep up with demand resulting responses have not been able to keep up with demand resulting in up with demand resulting in region-wide up with demand resulting in region-wide call up with demand resulting in region-wide call pressures"? region-wide call pressures"? Mr region-wide call pressures"? Mr Speaker, region-wide call pressures"? Mr Speaker, I region-wide call pressures"? Mr Speaker, I have region-wide call pressures"? Mr Speaker, I have never region-wide call pressures"? Mr Speaker, I have never stated Mr Speaker, I have never stated there Mr Speaker, I have never stated region-wide Mr Speaker, I have never stated there is no Mr Speaker, I have never stated there is no problem. Mr Speaker, I have never stated there is no problem. What Mr Speaker, I have never stated there is no problem. What I Mr Speaker, I have never stated there is no problem. What I can Mr Speaker, I have never stated there is no problem. What I can tell there is no problem. What I can tell the there is no problem. What I can tell the member there is no problem. What I can tell the member is there is no problem. What I can tell the member is when there is no problem. What I can tell the member is when you there is no problem. What I can tell the member is when you look there is no problem. What I can tell the member is when you look back there is no problem. What I can tell the member is when you look back at the member is when you look back at historical the member is when you look back at historical figures the member is when you look back at historical figures I'm the member is when you look back at historical figures I'm advised the member is when you look back at historical figures I'm advised that historical figures I'm advised that over historical figures I'm advised that over successive historical figures I'm advised that over successive governments historical figures I'm advised that over successive governments it's over successive governments it's been over successive governments it's been quite over successive governments it's been quite similar over successive governments it's been quite similar in over successive governments it's been quite similar in terms over successive governments it's been quite similar in terms of over successive governments it's been quite similar in terms of the been quite similar in terms of the system been quite similar in terms of the system we've been quite similar in terms of the system we've had been quite similar in terms of the system we've had and been quite similar in terms of the system we've had and the been quite similar in terms of the system we've had and the numbers been quite similar in terms of the system we've had and the numbers of system we've had and the numbers of schools system we've had and the numbers of schools that system we've had and the numbers of schools that have system we've had and the numbers of schools that have been system we've had and the numbers of schools that have been at-capacity schools that have been at-capacity or schools that have been at-capacity or considered schools that have been at-capacity or considered at schools that have been at-capacity or considered at risk. schools that have been at-capacity or considered at risk. What schools that have been at-capacity or considered at risk. What I schools that have been at-capacity or considered at risk. What I can or considered at risk. What I can tell or considered at risk. What I can tell the or considered at risk. What I can tell the member or considered at risk. What I can tell the member is or considered at risk. What I can tell the member is under or considered at risk. What I can tell the member is under our tell the member is under our government tell the member is under our or tell the member is under our government we've put tell the member is under our government we've put $5 tell the member is under our government we've put $5 billion government we've put $5 billion previously government we've put $5 billion government government we've put $5 billion previously and we government we've put $5 billion previously and we have government we've put $5 billion previously and we have $4.85 government we've put $5 billion previously and we have $4.85 billion previously and we have $4.85 billion coming previously and we have $4.85 billion government previously and we have $4.85 billion coming in the previously and we have $4.85 billion coming in the next previously and we have $4.85 billion coming in the next four previously and we have $4.85 billion coming in the next four years. coming in the next four years. If coming in the next four years. If over coming in the next four years. If over 700 coming in the next four years. If over 700 schools coming in the next four years. If over 700 schools have coming in the next four years. If over 700 schools have been If over 700 schools have been identified If over 700 schools have been identified by If over 700 schools have been identified by the If over 700 schools have been identified by the ministry If over 700 schools have been identified by the ministry as identified by the ministry as overcrowded identified by the ministry as overcrowded or identified by the ministry as overcrowded or at identified by the ministry as overcrowded or at risk identified by the ministry as overcrowded or at risk of overcrowded or at risk of overcrowding overcrowded or at risk of overcrowding and overcrowded or at risk of overcrowding and the overcrowded or at risk of overcrowding and the Ministry overcrowded or at risk of overcrowding and the Ministry of overcrowding and the Ministry of Education overcrowding and the Ministry of Education is overcrowding and the Ministry of Education is describing overcrowding and the Ministry of Education is describing the Education is describing the situation Education is describing the situation as Education is describing the situation as critical, Education is describing the situation as critical, how Education is describing the situation as critical, how much Education is describing the situation as critical, how much more situation as critical, how much more ifd situation as critical, how much more overcrowding situation as critical, how much more ifd does she situation as critical, how much more ifd does she need situation as critical, how much more ifd does she need before situation as critical, how much more ifd does she need before she situation as critical, how much more ifd does she need before she will ifd does she need before she will admit ifd does she need before she will admit that ifd does she need before she will admit that the ifd does she need before she will admit that the Government ifd does she need before she will admit that the Government have admit that the Government have failed admit that the Government have failed to admit that the Government have failed to keep admit that the Government have failed to keep pace admit that the Government have failed to keep pace with admit that the Government have failed to keep pace with demand admit that the Government have failed to keep pace with demand for failed to keep pace with demand for extra failed to keep pace with demand for extra places failed to keep pace with demand for extra places in failed to keep pace with demand for extra places in schools? extra places in schools? Well, extra places in schools? Well, Mr extra places in schools? Well, Mr Speaker, extra places in schools? Well, Mr Speaker, the extra places in schools? Well, Mr Speaker, the member extra places in schools? Well, Mr Speaker, the member has extra places in schools? Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not listened Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not listened to Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not listened to any Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not listened to any of Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not listened to any of my Well, Mr Speaker, the member has not listened to any of my previous listened to any of my previous answer listened to any of my previous answer and listened to any of my previous answer and it's listened to any of my previous answer and it's incredibly listened to any of my previous answer and it's incredibly alarmist answer and it's incredibly alarmist to answer and it's incredibly alarmist to say answer and it's incredibly alarmist to say that answer and it's incredibly alarmist to say that 700 answer and it's incredibly alarmist to say that 700 schools answer and it's incredibly alarmist to say that 700 schools are to say that 700 schools are overcrowded. to say that 700 schools are overcrowded. That to say that 700 schools are overcrowded. That is to say that 700 schools are overcrowded. That is not to say that 700 schools are overcrowded. That is not correct. overcrowded. That is not correct. It's overcrowded. That is not correct. overcrowded. overcrowded. That is not correct. It's totally wrong. It's totally wrong. How It's totally wrong. How many It's totally wrong. How many schools It's totally wrong. How many schools are It's totally wrong. How many schools are using It's totally wrong. How many schools are using library How many schools are using library space, How many schools are using library space, gymnasiums, How many schools are using library space, gymnasiums, halls, How many schools are using library space, gymnasiums, halls, or How many schools are using library space, gymnasiums, halls, or even space, gymnasiums, halls, or even old space, gymnasiums, halls, or even old dental space, gymnasiums, halls, or even old dental clinics space, gymnasiums, halls, or even old dental clinics as space, gymnasiums, halls, or even old dental clinics as teaching old dental clinics as teaching spaces old dental clinics as teaching spaces because old dental clinics as teaching spaces because they old dental clinics as teaching spaces because they don't old dental clinics as teaching spaces because they don't have spaces because they don't have enough spaces because they don't have spaces spaces because they don't have enough classrooms to spaces because they don't have enough classrooms to cope spaces because they don't have enough classrooms to cope with enough classrooms to cope with demand? demand? Well, demand? Well, Mr demand? Well, Mr Speaker, demand? Well, Mr Speaker, I demand? Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, demand? Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I demand? Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do demand? Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that figure Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that figure to Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that figure to hand. Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that figure to hand. What Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that figure to hand. What I Well, Mr Speaker, I cannot, I do not have that figure to hand. What I can have that figure to hand. What I can say have that figure to hand. What I can say to have that figure to hand. What I can say to the have that figure to hand. What I can say to the member have that figure to hand. What I can say to the member is have that figure to hand. What I can say to the member is as have that figure to hand. What I can say to the member is as I've say to the member is as I've explained say to the member is as I've explained previously, say to the member is as I've explained previously, under say to the member is as I've explained previously, under both explained previously, under both successive explained previously, under both successive National explained previously, under both successive National and explained previously, under both successive National and Labour successive National and Labour Governments successive National and Labour Governments we've successive National and Labour Governments we've always successive National and Labour Governments we've always had successive National and Labour Governments we've always had a Governments we've always had a system Governments we've always had a Governments Governments we've always had a system where schools Governments we've always had a system where schools choose Governments we've always had a system where schools choose how Governments we've always had a system where schools choose how they system where schools choose how they use system where schools choose how they Governments system where schools choose how they use their space system where schools choose how they use their space but system where schools choose how they use their space but we've system where schools choose how they use their space but we've got system where schools choose how they use their space but we've got a use their space but we've got a generous use their space but we've got a generous system use their space but we've got a generous system of use their space but we've got a generous system of property generous system of property allocation generous system of property allocation and generous system of property allocation and I generous system of property allocation and I can generous system of property allocation and I can confirm generous system of property allocation and I can confirm to generous system of property allocation and I can confirm to the allocation and I can confirm to the member allocation and I can confirm to the member that allocation and I can confirm to the member that utilisation allocation and I can confirm to the member that utilisation figures allocation and I can confirm to the member that utilisation figures in member that utilisation figures in New member that utilisation figures in New Zealand member that utilisation figures in New Zealand have member that utilisation figures in New Zealand have dropped member that utilisation figures in New Zealand have dropped since member that utilisation figures in New Zealand have dropped since that New Zealand have dropped since that member, New Zealand have dropped since that member New Zealand have dropped since that member, that government New Zealand have dropped since that member, that government was New Zealand have dropped since that member, that government was in member, that government was in power. power. U power. U supplementary power. U supplementary question, power. U supplementary question, Mr U supplementary question, Mr Speaker. U supplementary question, Mr Speaker. Order! Speaker. Order! Who Speaker. Order! Who is Speaker. Order! Who is responsible Speaker. Order! Who is responsible for Speaker. Order! Who is responsible for ensuring Speaker. Order! Who is responsible for ensuring that Who is responsible for ensuring that New Who is responsible for ensuring that power. Who is responsible for ensuring that New Zealand schools Who is responsible for ensuring that New Zealand schools have Who is responsible for ensuring that New Zealand schools have had Who is responsible for ensuring that New Zealand schools have had their New Zealand schools have had their capacity New Zealand schools have had their capacity expanded New Zealand schools have had their capacity expanded to New Zealand schools have had their capacity expanded to cope New Zealand schools have had their capacity expanded to cope with New Zealand schools have had their capacity expanded to cope with the capacity expanded to cope with the fact capacity expanded to cope with the fact that capacity expanded to cope with the fact that the capacity expanded to cope with the fact that the population capacity expanded to cope with the fact that the population has capacity expanded to cope with the fact that the population has grown fact that the population has grown by fact that the population has grown by nurly fact that the population has grown by nurly 500,000 fact that the population has grown by nurly 500,000 in fact that the population has grown by nurly 500,000 in the fact that the population has grown by nurly 500,000 in the last fact that the population has grown by nurly 500,000 in the last nine by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? Is by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? Is it by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? Is it the by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? Is it the government by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? Is it the government that by nurly 500,000 in the last nine years? Is it the government that was years? Is it the government that was in years? Is it the government that was in power years? Is it the government that was in power nine years? Is it the government that was in power nine years years? Is it the government that was in power nine years ago years? Is it the government that was in power nine years ago or years? Is it the government that was in power nine years ago or the years? Is it the government that was in power nine years ago or the one in power nine years ago or the one in in power nine years ago or the one in power in power nine years ago or the one in power today? in power today? The in power today? The Hon in power today? The Hon Nikki in power today? The Hon Nikki Kaye. in power today? The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr in power today? The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, in power today? The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, the The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, the numbers The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, the numbers in The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, the numbers in terms The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, the numbers in terms of The Hon Nikki Kaye. Mr Speaker, the numbers in terms of population numbers in terms of population growth, numbers in terms of population growth, I numbers in terms of population growth, I am numbers in terms of population growth, I am advised numbers in terms of population growth, I am advised that numbers in terms of population growth, I am advised that even growth, I am advised that even though growth, I am advised that even numbers growth, I am advised that even though we've had growth, I am advised that even though we've had tens growth, I am advised that even though we've had tens of growth, I am advised that even though we've had tens of thousands though we've had tens of thousands more though we've had tens of thousands more in though we've had tens of thousands more in terms though we've had tens of thousands more in terms of though we've had tens of thousands more in terms of population though we've had tens of thousands more in terms of population growth, more in terms of population growth, the more in terms of population growth, the overall more in terms of population growth, the overall utilisation more in terms of population growth, the overall utilisation figure more in terms of population growth, the overall utilisation figure under the overall utilisation figure under our the overall utilisation figure under the the overall utilisation figure under our government has the overall utilisation figure under our government has gone the overall utilisation figure under our government has gone down. the overall utilisation figure under our government has gone down. We the overall utilisation figure under our government has gone down. We we our government has gone down. We we have our government has gone down. We we have $4.5 our government has gone down. We we have $4.5 coming, our government has gone down. We we have $4.5 coming, and our government has gone down. We we have $4.5 coming, and we our government has gone down. We we have $4.5 coming, and we are have $4.5 coming, and we are hundreds have $4.5 coming, and we are hundreds ahead. have $4.5 coming, and we are hundreds ahead. So have $4.5 coming, and we are hundreds ahead. So the have $4.5 coming, and we are hundreds ahead. So the point have $4.5 coming, and we are hundreds ahead. So the point is hundreds ahead. So the point is under hundreds ahead. So the point is under our hundreds ahead. So the point is under our government hundreds ahead. So the point is under our government the hundreds ahead. So the point is under our government the situation under our government the situation is under our government the situation under under our government the situation is better. We under our government the situation is better. We will under our government the situation is better. We will continue under our government the situation is better. We will continue to is better. We will continue to improve is better. We will continue to improve it. improve it. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Police: My question is to the Minister of Police: What My question is to the Minister of Police: What is My question is to the Minister of Police: What is the My question is to the Minister of Police: What is the Government My question is to the Minister of Police: What is the Government doing Police: What is the Government doing to Police: What is the Government doing to prevent Police: What is the Government doing to prevent offending Police: What is the Government doing to prevent offending in Police: What is the Government doing to prevent offending in Counties to prevent offending in Counties Manukau? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, the Mr Speaker, the police Mr Speaker, the police in Mr Speaker, the police in Counties Mr Speaker, the police in Counties Mamakau Mr Speaker, the police in Counties Mamakau have Mr Speaker, the police in Counties Mamakau have had Mr Speaker, the police in Counties Mamakau have had an Mr Speaker, the police in Counties Mamakau have had an indepth Mamakau have had an indepth programme Mamakau have had an indepth programme in Mamakau have had an indepth programme in crime Mamakau have had an indepth programme in crime prevention Mamakau have had an indepth programme in crime prevention around programme in crime prevention around aggravated programme in crime prevention around programme programme in crime prevention around aggravated robberies in programme in crime prevention around aggravated robberies in particular. aggravated robberies in particular. That's aggravated robberies in particular. That's why aggravated robberies in particular. That's why last aggravated robberies in particular. That's why last week aggravated robberies in particular. That's why last week I aggravated robberies in particular. That's why last week I announced aggravated robberies in particular. That's why last week I announced the That's why last week I announced the next That's why last week I announced the next step That's why last week I announced the next step, That's why last week I announced the next step, to That's why last week I announced the next step, to fund That's why last week I announced the next step, to fund an That's why last week I announced the next step, to fund an amount That's why last week I announced the next step, to fund an amount to next step, to fund an amount to assist next step, to fund an amount to assist 1,000 next step, to fund an amount to assist 1,000 who next step, to fund an amount to assist 1,000 who are next step, to fund an amount to assist 1,000 who are considered next step, to fund an amount to assist 1,000 who are considered at assist 1,000 who are considered at high assist 1,000 who are considered at high risk assist 1,000 who are considered at high risk of assist 1,000 who are considered at high risk of aggravated assist 1,000 who are considered at high risk of aggravated robberies, high risk of aggravated robberies, for high risk of aggravated robberies, for those high risk of aggravated robberies, for those that high risk of aggravated robberies, for those that can't high risk of aggravated robberies, for those that can't afford high risk of aggravated robberies, for those that can't afford to high risk of aggravated robberies, for those that can't afford to have for those that can't afford to have these for those that can't afford to have these measures for those that can't afford to have these measures themselves for those that can't afford to have these measures themselves and for those that can't afford to have these measures themselves and the these measures themselves and the Government these measures themselves and the Government is these measures themselves and the Government is helping these measures themselves and the Government is helping them. Government is helping them. Mr Government is helping them. Mr Speaker, Government is helping them. Mr Speaker, has Government is helping them. Mr Speaker, has the Government is helping them. Mr Speaker, has the minister Government is helping them. Mr Speaker, has the minister seen Mr Speaker, has the minister seen any Mr Speaker, has the minister seen any comments Mr Speaker, has the minister seen any comments from Mr Speaker, has the minister seen any comments from the Mr Speaker, has the minister seen any comments from the industry Mr Speaker, has the minister seen any comments from the industry about any comments from the industry about the any comments from the industry about these any comments from the industry about the new fund? the new fund? Yes, the new fund? Yes, I the new fund? Yes, I had the new fund? Yes, I had a the new fund? Yes, I had a number the new fund? Yes, I had a number of the new fund? Yes, I had a number of dairy the new fund? Yes, I had a number of dairy owners Yes, I had a number of dairy owners tell Yes, I had a number of dairy owners tell me Yes, I had a number of dairy owners tell me they're Yes, I had a number of dairy owners tell me they're grateful Yes, I had a number of dairy owners tell me they're grateful for Yes, I had a number of dairy owners tell me they're grateful for this tell me they're grateful for this assistance tell me they're grateful for this assistance so tell me they're grateful for this assistance so they tell me they're grateful for this assistance so they can tell me they're grateful for this assistance so they can get tell me they're grateful for this assistance so they can get either assistance so they can get either canons assistance so they can get either canons or assistance so they can get either canons or personal assistance so they can get either canons or personal alarms assistance so they can get either canons or personal alarms or assistance so they can get either canons or personal alarms or time canons or personal alarms or time safes canons or personal alarms or time safes there canons or personal alarms or time safes there as canons or personal alarms or time safes there as well. canons or personal alarms or time safes there as well. Retail canons or personal alarms or time safes there as well. Retail New safes there as well. Retail New Zealand safes there as well. Retail New Zealand said, safes there as well. Retail New Zealand said, I safes there as well. Retail New Zealand said, I quote, safes there as well. Retail New Zealand said, I quote, they're, Zealand said, I quote, they're, "Delighted Zealand said, I quote, they're, "Delighted the Zealand said, I quote, they're, "Delighted the Government Zealand said, I quote, they're, "Delighted the Government is Zealand said, I quote, they're, "Delighted the Government is making "Delighted the Government is making funding "Delighted the Government is making "Delighted "Delighted the Government is making funding veil to "Delighted the Government is making funding veil to support "Delighted the Government is making funding veil to support security funding veil to support security improvements. funding veil to support security improvements. We funding veil to support security improvements. We hope funding veil to support security improvements. We hope it funding veil to support security improvements. We hope it will funding veil to support security improvements. We hope it will lis improvements. We hope it will lis courage improvements. We hope it will lis courage criminals improvements. We hope it will lis courage criminals and improvements. We hope it will lis courage criminals and anti-social courage criminals and anti-social elements courage criminals and anti-social elements from courage criminals and anti-social elements from undertaking courage criminals and anti-social elements from undertaking their elements from undertaking their criminal elements from undertaking their criminal acts. criminal acts. " Can Can the Can the minister Can the minister update Can the minister update the Can the minister update the house Can the minister update the house on Can the minister update the house on Operation Can the minister update the house on Operation Dukar? Operation Dukar? Mr Operation Dukar? Mr Speaker, Operation Dukar? Mr Speaker, operation Operation Dukar? Mr Speaker, operation Ducan Operation Dukar? Mr Speaker, operation Ducan is Mr Speaker, operation Ducan is running Mr Speaker, operation Ducan is running across Mr Speaker, operation Ducan is running across the Mr Speaker, operation Ducan is running across the three Mr Speaker, operation Ducan is running across the three districts. running across the three districts. It running across the three districts. It is running across the three districts. It is based running across the three districts. It is based on running across the three districts. It is based on evidence running across the three districts. It is based on evidence that running across the three districts. It is based on evidence that small It is based on evidence that small changes It is based on evidence that small changes in It is based on evidence that small changes in the It is based on evidence that small changes in the physical It is based on evidence that small changes in the physical environment changes in the physical environment and changes in the physical environment and awareness changes in the physical environment and awareness can changes in the physical environment and awareness can reduce changes in the physical environment and awareness can reduce the changes in the physical environment and awareness can reduce the like and awareness can reduce the like hihood and awareness can reduce the like hihood of and awareness can reduce the like hihood of becoming and awareness can reduce the like hihood of becoming a and awareness can reduce the like hihood of becoming a victim and awareness can reduce the like hihood of becoming a victim of hihood of becoming a victim of crime. hihood of becoming a victim of crime. Police hihood of becoming a victim of crime. Police have hihood of becoming a victim of crime. Police have recently hihood of becoming a victim of crime. Police have recently visited crime. Police have recently visited over crime. Police have recently visited over 1,000 crime. Police have recently visited over 1,000 small crime. Police have recently visited over 1,000 small businesses crime. Police have recently visited over 1,000 small businesses in over 1,000 small businesses in Auckland over 1,000 small businesses in Auckland to over 1,000 small businesses in Auckland to provide over 1,000 small businesses in Auckland to provide reassurance over 1,000 small businesses in Auckland to provide reassurance and Auckland to provide reassurance and crime Auckland to provide reassurance and crime prevention Auckland to provide reassurance and crime prevention advice, Auckland to provide reassurance and crime prevention advice, have Auckland to provide reassurance and crime prevention advice, have upped crime prevention advice, have upped their crime prevention advice, have upped crime crime prevention advice, have upped their - got crime prevention advice, have upped their - got more crime prevention advice, have upped their - got more police crime prevention advice, have upped their - got more police on crime prevention advice, have upped their - got more police on the crime prevention advice, have upped their - got more police on the beat. their - got more police on the beat. Mr their - got more police on the beat. Mr Speak their - got more police on the beat. Mr Speak toshgs their - got more police on the beat. Mr Speak toshgs the their - got more police on the beat. Mr Speak toshgs the minister their - got more police on the beat. Mr Speak toshgs the minister - their - got more police on the beat. Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why should Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why should the Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why should the people Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why should the people of Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why should the people of Counties Mr Speak toshgs the minister - why should the people of Counties Manaka should the people of Counties Manaka believe should the people of Counties Manaka believe this should the people of Counties Manaka believe this Government's should the people of Counties Manaka believe this Government's assurances believe this Government's assurances when believe this Government's assurances when dispiet believe this Government's assurances when dispiet nine believe this Government's assurances when dispiet nine years believe this Government's assurances when dispiet nine years of believe this Government's assurances when dispiet nine years of spin believe this Government's assurances when dispiet nine years of spin -- when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite nine when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite nine years when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite nine years of when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite nine years of spin when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite nine years of spin that when dispiet nine years of spin -- despite nine years of spin that the despite nine years of spin that the numbers despite nine years of spin that the numbers have despite nine years of spin that the numbers have gone despite nine years of spin that the numbers have gone down despite nine years of spin that the numbers have gone down the numbers have gone down the Government's numbers have gone down the Government's own numbers have gone down the Government's own data numbers have gone down the Government's own data sets numbers have gone down the Government's own data sets show Government's own data sets show clearly Government's own data sets show clearly that Government's own data sets show clearly that burglaries Government's own data sets show clearly that burglaries in Government's own data sets show clearly that burglaries in Counties clearly that burglaries in Counties Manaka clearly that burglaries in Counties clearly clearly that burglaries in Counties Manaka have gone clearly that burglaries in Counties Manaka have gone up clearly that burglaries in Counties Manaka have gone up 80% clearly that burglaries in Counties Manaka have gone up 80% and Manaka have gone up 80% and nationwide Manaka have gone up 80% and nationwide up Manaka have gone up 80% and nationwide up 40%. Manaka have gone up 80% and nationwide up 40%. How Manaka have gone up 80% and nationwide up 40%. How is Manaka have gone up 80% and nationwide up 40%. How is raising nationwide up 40%. How is raising the nationwide up 40%. How is raising the age nationwide up 40%. How is raising the age of nationwide up 40%. How is raising the age of criminal nationwide up 40%. How is raising the age of criminal responsibility the age of criminal responsibility going the age of criminal responsibility the the age of criminal responsibility going to fix the age of criminal responsibility going to fix that? going to fix that? Two going to fix that? Two questions going to fix that? Two questions there. going to fix that? Two questions there. The going to fix that? Two questions there. The number going to fix that? Two questions there. The number I Two questions there. The number I have Two questions there. The number I have seen Two questions there. The number I have seen for Two questions there. The number I have seen for Counties Two questions there. The number I have seen for Counties Manakau Two questions there. The number I have seen for Counties Manakau are have seen for Counties Manakau are not have seen for Counties Manakau are the have seen for Counties Manakau are not that high. have seen for Counties Manakau are not that high. But have seen for Counties Manakau are not that high. But there's have seen for Counties Manakau are not that high. But there's been have seen for Counties Manakau are not that high. But there's been an not that high. But there's been an increase not that high. But there's been an increase in not that high. But there's been an increase in the not that high. But there's been an increase in the number not that high. But there's been an increase in the number of not that high. But there's been an increase in the number of agar not that high. But there's been an increase in the number of agar gra increase in the number of agar gra vated increase in the number of agar gra vated robberies, increase in the number of agar gra vated robberies, police increase in the number of agar gra vated robberies, police have increase in the number of agar gra vated robberies, police have done increase in the number of agar gra vated robberies, police have done an vated robberies, police have done an outstanding vated robberies, police have done an outstanding job vated robberies, police have done an outstanding job in vated robberies, police have done an outstanding job in capturing vated robberies, police have done an outstanding job in capturing these outstanding job in capturing these criminals. outstanding job in capturing these criminals. They outstanding job in capturing these criminals. They have outstanding job in capturing these criminals. They have made outstanding job in capturing these criminals. They have made 100 criminals. They have made 100 arrests criminals. They have made 100 criminals. criminals. They have made 100 arrests already and criminals. They have made 100 arrests already and continue criminals. They have made 100 arrests already and continue to criminals. They have made 100 arrests already and continue to be arrests already and continue to be focused arrests already and continue to be criminals. arrests already and continue to be focused on that. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: My question is to the Minister of Health: Has My question is to the Minister of Health: Has he My question is to the Minister of Health: Has he seen My question is to the Minister of Health: Has he seen the My question is to the Minister of Health: Has he seen the TARGIT My question is to the Minister of Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of 3,451 Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of 3,451 women Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of 3,451 women in Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of 3,451 women in 11 Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of 3,451 women in 11 countries Health: Has he seen the TARGIT study of 3,451 women in 11 countries with of 3,451 women in 11 countries with breast of 3,451 women in 11 countries with breast cancer, of 3,451 women in 11 countries with breast cancer, which of 3,451 women in 11 countries with breast cancer, which found of 3,451 women in 11 countries with breast cancer, which found that breast cancer, which found that intraoperative breast cancer, which found that intraoperative radiotherapy breast cancer, which found that intraoperative radiotherapy has intraoperative radiotherapy has similar intraoperative radiotherapy has similar survival intraoperative radiotherapy has similar survival and intraoperative radiotherapy has similar survival and recurrence similar survival and recurrence rates, similar survival and recurrence rates, and similar survival and recurrence rates, and significantly similar survival and recurrence rates, and significantly fewer rates, and significantly fewer mortalities rates, and significantly fewer mortalities from rates, and significantly fewer mortalities from other rates, and significantly fewer mortalities from other complications mortalities from other complications after mortalities from other complications after 5 mortalities from other complications after 5 years mortalities from other complications after 5 years than mortalities from other complications after 5 years than external mortalities from other complications after 5 years than external beam after 5 years than external beam radiotherapy, after 5 years than external beam radiotherapy, and after 5 years than external beam radiotherapy, and what after 5 years than external beam radiotherapy, and what progress after 5 years than external beam radiotherapy, and what progress is radiotherapy, and what progress is being radiotherapy, and what progress is being made radiotherapy, and what progress is being made introducing being made introducing intraoperative being made introducing intraoperative radiotherapy being made introducing intraoperative radiotherapy into being made introducing intraoperative radiotherapy into the intraoperative radiotherapy into the New intraoperative radiotherapy into the New Zealand intraoperative radiotherapy into the New Zealand Public intraoperative radiotherapy into the New Zealand Public Health intraoperative radiotherapy into the New Zealand Public Health Service? Order! Order! The Order! The Hon Order! The Hon Dr Order! The Hon Dr Jonathan Order! The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Order! The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, Order! The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, I The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, I am The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, I am aware. The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, I am aware. An The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, I am aware. An initial The Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman. Yes, I am aware. An initial investment am aware. An initial investment examining am aware. An initial investment examining the am aware. An initial investment examining the clinical am aware. An initial investment examining the clinical safety am aware. An initial investment examining the clinical safety and examining the clinical safety and effectiveness examining the clinical safety and effectiveness of examining the clinical safety and effectiveness of IORT examining the clinical safety and effectiveness of IORT was examining the clinical safety and effectiveness of IORT was published effectiveness of IORT was published by effectiveness of IORT was published by the effectiveness of IORT was published by the National effectiveness of IORT was published by the National Health effectiveness of IORT was published by the National Health Committee effectiveness of IORT was published by the National Health Committee in by the National Health Committee in 2015. by the National Health Committee in 2015. Following by the National Health Committee in 2015. Following this by the National Health Committee in 2015. Following this assessment by the National Health Committee in 2015. Following this assessment of 2015. Following this assessment of examining 2015. Following this assessment of examining the 2015. Following this assessment of examining the potential 2015. Following this assessment of examining the potential health examining the potential health impacts examining the potential health impacts of examining the potential health impacts of introducing examining the potential health impacts of introducing it examining the potential health impacts of introducing it was impacts of introducing it was published impacts of introducing it was impacts impacts of introducing it was published this year. impacts of introducing it was published this year. Having published this year. Having considered published this year. Having considered this published this year. Having considered this the published this year. Having considered this the Ministry published this year. Having considered this the Ministry of considered this the Ministry of Health considered this the Ministry of Health included considered this the Ministry of Health included there's considered this the Ministry of Health included there's insufficient Health included there's insufficient evidence Health included there's insufficient evidence to Health included there's insufficient evidence to introduce Health included there's insufficient evidence to introduce IORT Health included there's insufficient evidence to introduce IORT in Health included there's insufficient evidence to introduce IORT in the evidence to introduce IORT in the New evidence to introduce IORT in the New Zealand evidence to introduce IORT in the New Zealand public evidence to introduce IORT in the New Zealand public health evidence to introduce IORT in the New Zealand public health system evidence to introduce IORT in the New Zealand public health system at New Zealand public health system at this New Zealand public health system at considered New Zealand public health system at this time. I'm New Zealand public health system at this time. I'm as New Zealand public health system at this time. I'm as vieded New Zealand public health system at this time. I'm as vieded the New Zealand public health system at this time. I'm as vieded the key this time. I'm as vieded the key issue this time. I'm as vieded the key issue is this time. I'm as vieded the key issue is that this time. I'm as vieded the key issue is that clinical this time. I'm as vieded the key issue is that clinical eqif this time. I'm as vieded the key issue is that clinical eqif lency issue is that clinical eqif lency between issue is that clinical eqif lency between IORT issue is that clinical eqif lency between IORT and issue is that clinical eqif lency between IORT and EBRT issue is that clinical eqif lency between IORT and EBRT has issue is that clinical eqif lency between IORT and EBRT has not issue is that clinical eqif lency between IORT and EBRT has not within between IORT and EBRT has not within established between IORT and EBRT has not within established yet. between IORT and EBRT has not within established yet. Further between IORT and EBRT has not within established yet. Further trials between IORT and EBRT has not within established yet. Further trials are established yet. Further trials are under established yet. Further trials are under way established yet. Further trials are under way internationally, established yet. Further trials are under way internationally, with under way internationally, with results under way internationally, with established under way internationally, with results expected after under way internationally, with results expected after 2020. results expected after 2020. Why, results expected after 2020. Why, then, results expected after 2020. Why, then, did results expected after 2020. Why, then, did the results expected after 2020. Why, then, did the Tier results expected after 2020. Why, then, did the Tier 3 results expected after 2020. Why, then, did the Tier 3 report Why, then, did the Tier 3 report from Why, then, did the Tier 3 report from the Why, then, did the Tier 3 report from the Ministry Why, then, did the Tier 3 report from the Ministry of Why, then, did the Tier 3 report from the Ministry of Health Why, then, did the Tier 3 report from the Ministry of Health say from the Ministry of Health say that, from the Ministry of Health say that, quote, from the Ministry of Health say that, quote, "The from the Ministry of Health say that, quote, "The TARGIT from the Ministry of Health say that, quote, "The TARGIT A from the Ministry of Health say that, quote, "The TARGIT A trial that, quote, "The TARGIT A trial provided that, quote, "The TARGIT A trial provided sufficient that, quote, "The TARGIT A trial provided sufficient evidence that, quote, "The TARGIT A trial provided sufficient evidence to provided sufficient evidence to carry provided sufficient evidence to Why, provided sufficient evidence to carry out work provided sufficient evidence to carry out work on provided sufficient evidence to carry out work on the provided sufficient evidence to carry out work on the National carry out work on the National Health carry out work on the National Health Committee's carry out work on the National Health Committee's other carry out work on the National Health Committee's other domains carry out work on the National Health Committee's other domains and Health Committee's other domains and there Health Committee's other domains and there is Health Committee's other domains and there is reasonably Health Committee's other domains and there is reasonably good Health Committee's other domains and there is reasonably good evidence there is reasonably good evidence that there is reasonably good evidence that the there is reasonably good evidence that the follow-up there is reasonably good evidence that the follow-up is there is reasonably good evidence that the follow-up is sufficient there is reasonably good evidence that the follow-up is sufficient and that the follow-up is sufficient and non-inferiority that the follow-up is sufficient and non-inferiority has that the follow-up is sufficient and non-inferiority has been non-inferiority has been demonstrated? demonstrated? Well, demonstrated? Well, Mr demonstrated? Well, Mr Speaker demonstrated? Well, Mr Speaker thshgs demonstrated? Well, Mr Speaker thshgs is Well, Mr Speaker thshgs is essentially Well, Mr Speaker thshgs is essentially a Well, Mr Speaker thshgs is essentially a debate Well, Mr Speaker thshgs is essentially a debate between essentially a debate between clinicians essentially a debate between clinicians and essentially a debate between clinicians and scientists essentially a debate between clinicians and scientists as essentially a debate between clinicians and scientists as to essentially a debate between clinicians and scientists as to the clinicians and scientists as to the most clinicians and scientists as to the Well, clinicians and scientists as to the most effective treatment. clinicians and scientists as to the most effective treatment. The clinicians and scientists as to the most effective treatment. The best most effective treatment. The best advice most effective treatment. The best advice is most effective treatment. The best advice is the most effective treatment. The best advice is the evidence most effective treatment. The best advice is the evidence around most effective treatment. The best advice is the evidence around IORT advice is the evidence around IORT is advice is the evidence around IORT is still advice is the evidence around IORT is still emerging, advice is the evidence around IORT is still emerging, that advice is the evidence around IORT is still emerging, that it's advice is the evidence around IORT is still emerging, that it's not is still emerging, that it's not conclusive is still emerging, that it's not most is still emerging, that it's not conclusive and, look, is still emerging, that it's not conclusive and, look, ministers conclusive and, look, ministers getting conclusive and, look, ministers getting involved conclusive and, look, ministers getting involved this conclusive and, look, ministers getting involved this this conclusive and, look, ministers getting involved this this situation getting involved this this situation would getting involved this this situation would be getting involved this this situation would be a getting involved this this situation would be a bit getting involved this this situation would be a bit like getting involved this this situation would be a bit like reaching getting involved this this situation would be a bit like reaching into would be a bit like reaching into PHARMAC would be a bit like reaching into PHARMAC and would be a bit like reaching into PHARMAC and directing would be a bit like reaching into PHARMAC and directing that would be a bit like reaching into PHARMAC and directing that certain PHARMAC and directing that certain drugs PHARMAC and directing that certain PHARMAC PHARMAC and directing that certain drugs are funded. PHARMAC and directing that certain drugs are funded. The PHARMAC and directing that certain drugs are funded. The fact PHARMAC and directing that certain drugs are funded. The fact is PHARMAC and directing that certain drugs are funded. The fact is we drugs are funded. The fact is we have drugs are funded. The fact is we drugs drugs are funded. The fact is we have to take drugs are funded. The fact is we have to take the drugs are funded. The fact is we have to take the best drugs are funded. The fact is we have to take the best expert drugs are funded. The fact is we have to take the best expert advice. have to take the best expert advice. That's have to take the best expert advice. That's what have to take the best expert advice. That's what I'm have to take the best expert advice. That's what I'm going have to take the best expert advice. That's what I'm going on. That's what I'm going on. What That's what I'm going on. What did That's what I'm going on. What did the That's what I'm going on. What did the Deloitte That's what I'm going on. What did the Deloitte report, What did the Deloitte report, commissioned What did the Deloitte report, commissioned by What did the Deloitte report, commissioned by the What did the Deloitte report, commissioned by the Ministry What did the Deloitte report, commissioned by the Ministry of commissioned by the Ministry of Health commissioned by the Ministry of commissioned commissioned by the Ministry of Health find with commissioned by the Ministry of Health find with respect commissioned by the Ministry of Health find with respect o commissioned by the Ministry of Health find with respect o the commissioned by the Ministry of Health find with respect o the cost Health find with respect o the cost effectiveness Health find with respect o the cost effectiveness of Health find with respect o the cost effectiveness of IORT Health find with respect o the cost effectiveness of IORT verses effectiveness of IORT verses conventional effectiveness of IORT verses Health effectiveness of IORT verses conventional breast cancer conventional breast cancer treatments? treatments? Well, treatments? Well, look, treatments? Well, look, it treatments? Well, look, it may treatments? Well, look, it may well treatments? Well, look, it may well be treatments? Well, look, it may well be cost Well, look, it may well be cost effective Well, look, it may well be cost effective in Well, look, it may well be cost effective in certain Well, look, it may well be cost effective in certain cases Well, look, it may well be cost effective in certain cases but Well, look, it may well be cost effective in certain cases but can Well, look, it may well be cost effective in certain cases but can I effective in certain cases but can I tell effective in certain cases but can I tell you effective in certain cases but can I tell you directly effective in certain cases but can I tell you directly what effective in certain cases but can I tell you directly what that effective in certain cases but can I tell you directly what that report tell you directly what that report does tell you directly what that report does say, tell you directly what that report does say, and tell you directly what that report does say, and here tell you directly what that report does say, and here it tell you directly what that report does say, and here it is tell you directly what that report does say, and here it is in tell you directly what that report does say, and here it is in quotes, does say, and here it is in quotes, "Extant does say, and here it is in quotes, "Extant evidence does say, and here it is in quotes, "Extant evidence for does say, and here it is in quotes, "Extant evidence for the does say, and here it is in quotes, "Extant evidence for the efficacy "Extant evidence for the efficacy and "Extant evidence for the efficacy and safety "Extant evidence for the efficacy and safety of "Extant evidence for the efficacy and safety of IORT "Extant evidence for the efficacy and safety of IORT compared "Extant evidence for the efficacy and safety of IORT compared to "Extant evidence for the efficacy and safety of IORT compared to EBRT and safety of IORT compared to EBRT remains and safety of IORT compared to EBRT remains eqif and safety of IORT compared to EBRT remains eqif col", and safety of IORT compared to EBRT remains eqif col", closed and safety of IORT compared to EBRT remains eqif col", closed quotes. remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why was remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why was that, remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why was that, the remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why was that, the authors remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why was that, the authors of remains eqif col", closed quotes. Why was that, the authors of that Why was that, the authors of that Deloitte Why was that, the authors of that Deloitte report Why was that, the authors of that Deloitte report not Why was that, the authors of that Deloitte report not provided Why was that, the authors of that Deloitte report not provided with Deloitte report not provided with the Deloitte report not provided with the Tier Deloitte report not provided with the Tier 3 Deloitte report not provided with the Tier 3 report Deloitte report not provided with the Tier 3 report that Deloitte report not provided with the Tier 3 report that I Deloitte report not provided with the Tier 3 report that I mentioned the Tier 3 report that I mentioned in the Tier 3 report that I mentioned in my the Tier 3 report that I mentioned in my earlier the Tier 3 report that I mentioned in my earlier supplementary the Tier 3 report that I mentioned in my earlier supplementary in in my earlier supplementary in Mr in my earlier supplementary in Mr Speaker, in my earlier supplementary in Mr Speaker, I'm in my earlier supplementary in Mr Speaker, I'm not in my earlier supplementary in Mr Speaker, I'm not aware in my earlier supplementary in Mr Speaker, I'm not aware they Mr Speaker, I'm not aware they weren't. weren't. Is weren't. Is it weren't. Is it not weren't. Is it not the weren't. Is it not the case weren't. Is it not the case that weren't. Is it not the case that new Is it not the case that new technology Is it not the case that new technology in Is it not the case that new technology in the Is it not the case that new technology in the form Is it not the case that new technology in the form of Is it not the case that new technology in the form of IORT Is it not the case that new technology in the form of IORT could technology in the form of IORT could save technology in the form of IORT could save enormous technology in the form of IORT could save enormous inconvenience technology in the form of IORT could save enormous inconvenience and technology in the form of IORT could save enormous inconvenience and pain save enormous inconvenience and pain to save enormous inconvenience and pain to 1,000 save enormous inconvenience and pain to 1,000 whimper save enormous inconvenience and pain to 1,000 whimper year save enormous inconvenience and pain to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed save enormous inconvenience and pain to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with early to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with early stage to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with early stage breast to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, but to 1,000 whimper year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, but the early stage breast cancer, but the Ministry early stage breast cancer, but the Ministry of early stage breast cancer, but the Ministry of -- early stage breast cancer, but the Ministry of -- whimper early stage breast cancer, but the Ministry of -- whimper year Ministry of -- whimper year diagnosed Ministry of -- whimper year diagnosed with Ministry of -- whimper year diagnosed with early Ministry of -- whimper year diagnosed with early stage Ministry of -- whimper year diagnosed with early stage -- Ministry of -- whimper year diagnosed with early stage -- women diagnosed with early stage -- women per diagnosed with early stage -- women per year diagnosed with early stage -- women per year diagnosed diagnosed with early stage -- women per year diagnosed with diagnosed with early stage -- women per year diagnosed with early diagnosed with early stage -- women per year diagnosed with early stage per year diagnosed with early stage breast per year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, per year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, but per year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, but when per year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, but when five per year diagnosed with early stage breast cancer, but when five years breast cancer, but when five years of breast cancer, but when five years of evidence breast cancer, but when five years of evidence have breast cancer, but when five years of evidence have been breast cancer, but when five years of evidence have been published breast cancer, but when five years of evidence have been published in of evidence have been published in reputable of evidence have been published in reputable journals of evidence have been published in reputable journals but of evidence have been published in reputable journals but the of evidence have been published in reputable journals but the women reputable journals but the women will reputable journals but the women reputable reputable journals but the women will miss out reputable journals but the women will miss out because reputable journals but the women will miss out because the reputable journals but the women will miss out because the ministry will miss out because the ministry is will miss out because the ministry is dragging will miss out because the ministry is dragging its will miss out because the ministry is dragging its heels? will miss out because the ministry is dragging its heels? It's will miss out because the ministry is dragging its heels? It's not will miss out because the ministry is dragging its heels? It's not the is dragging its heels? It's not the case. is dragging its heels? It's not the case. The is dragging its heels? It's not the case. The ministry is dragging its heels? It's not the case. The ministry is is dragging its heels? It's not the case. The ministry is up is dragging its heels? It's not the case. The ministry is up to is dragging its heels? It's not the case. The ministry is up to date case. The ministry is up to date with case. The ministry is up to date with the case. The ministry is up to date with the latest case. The ministry is up to date with the latest evidence. case. The ministry is up to date with the latest evidence. The case. The ministry is up to date with the latest evidence. The best with the latest evidence. The best advice with the latest evidence. The best advice is with the latest evidence. The best advice is the with the latest evidence. The best advice is the evidence with the latest evidence. The best advice is the evidence is with the latest evidence. The best advice is the evidence is equiv with the latest evidence. The best advice is the evidence is equiv -- advice is the evidence is equiv -- equivocal advice is the evidence is equiv -- equivocal and advice is the evidence is equiv -- equivocal and there's advice is the evidence is equiv -- equivocal and there's no advice is the evidence is equiv -- equivocal and there's no difference equivocal and there's no difference between equivocal and there's no difference between IORT equivocal and there's no difference between IORT and equivocal and there's no difference between IORT and EBRT. between IORT and EBRT. Given between IORT and EBRT. Given of between IORT and EBRT. Given of the between IORT and EBRT. Given of the 120 between IORT and EBRT. Given of the 120 women between IORT and EBRT. Given of the 120 women are between IORT and EBRT. Given of the 120 women are ekreefed Given of the 120 women are ekreefed this Given of the 120 women are ekreefed this treatment Given of the 120 women are ekreefed this treatment because Given of the 120 women are ekreefed this treatment because they Given of the 120 women are ekreefed this treatment because they paid Given of the 120 women are ekreefed this treatment because they paid for this treatment because they paid for it, this treatment because they paid for it, only this treatment because they paid for it, only one this treatment because they paid for it, only one was this treatment because they paid for it, only one was Maori, this treatment because they paid for it, only one was Maori, the this treatment because they paid for it, only one was Maori, the disparty it, only one was Maori, the disparty needs it, only one was Maori, the disparty needs to it, only one was Maori, the disparty needs to be it, only one was Maori, the disparty needs to be addressed. it, only one was Maori, the disparty needs to be addressed. Can it, only one was Maori, the disparty needs to be addressed. Can the needs to be addressed. Can the minister needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell us needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell us what needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell us what he needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell us what he will needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell us what he will do needs to be addressed. Can the minister tell us what he will do to minister tell us what he will do to correct minister tell us what he will do to correct the minister tell us what he will do to correct the disparity minister tell us what he will do to correct the disparity for minister tell us what he will do to correct the disparity for Maori minister tell us what he will do to correct the disparity for Maori and correct the disparity for Maori and Pacificer correct the disparity for Maori and it, correct the disparity for Maori and Pacificer and the correct the disparity for Maori and Pacificer and the opportunity correct the disparity for Maori and Pacificer and the opportunity to Pacificer and the opportunity to receive Pacificer and the opportunity to receive this Pacificer and the opportunity to receive this treatment? receive this treatment? Mr receive this treatment? Mr Speaker, receive this treatment? Mr Speaker, look, receive this treatment? Mr Speaker, look, it's receive this treatment? Mr Speaker, look, it's very Mr Speaker, look, it's very important Mr Speaker, look, it's very important people Mr Speaker, look, it's very important people in Mr Speaker, look, it's very important people in New Mr Speaker, look, it's very important people in New Zealand Mr Speaker, look, it's very important people in New Zealand get important people in New Zealand get access important people in New Zealand get access to important people in New Zealand get access to the important people in New Zealand get access to the very important people in New Zealand get access to the very best important people in New Zealand get access to the very best treatments access to the very best treatments regardless access to the very best treatments regardless of access to the very best treatments regardless of their access to the very best treatments regardless of their ethnic regardless of their ethnic background regardless of their ethnic background and regardless of their ethnic background and that's regardless of their ethnic background and that's absolutely background and that's absolutely what background and that's absolutely what the background and that's absolutely what the Government background and that's absolutely what the Government is background and that's absolutely what the Government is committed background and that's absolutely what the Government is committed to what the Government is committed to doing. doing. Can doing. Can the doing. Can the minister doing. Can the minister give doing. Can the minister give any doing. Can the minister give any indication Can the minister give any indication to Can the minister give any indication to women Can the minister give any indication to women of Can the minister give any indication to women of when Can the minister give any indication to women of when he Can the minister give any indication to women of when he expects Can the minister give any indication to women of when he expects this Can the minister give any indication to women of when he expects this new to women of when he expects this new technology to women of when he expects this new technology already to women of when he expects this new technology already is to women of when he expects this new technology already is in to women of when he expects this new technology already is in Australia, technology already is in Australia, Canada, technology already is in Australia, Canada, the technology already is in Australia, Canada, the UK, technology already is in Australia, Canada, the UK, the technology already is in Australia, Canada, the UK, the US, technology already is in Australia, Canada, the UK, the US, even technology already is in Australia, Canada, the UK, the US, even China, Canada, the UK, the US, even China, to Canada, the UK, the US, even China, to be Canada, the UK, the US, even China, to be available Canada, the UK, the US, even China, to be available in Canada, the UK, the US, even China, to be available in New Canada, the UK, the US, even China, to be available in New Zealand's to be available in New Zealand's public to be available in New Zealand's Canada, to be available in New Zealand's public health system? public health system? Well, public health system? Well, if public health system? Well, if the public health system? Well, if the member public health system? Well, if the member thinks public health system? Well, if the member thinks back public health system? Well, if the member thinks back to Well, if the member thinks back to the Well, if the member thinks back to Well, Well, if the member thinks back to the primary answer, Well, if the member thinks back to the primary answer, I Well, if the member thinks back to the primary answer, I said Well, if the member thinks back to the primary answer, I said further the primary answer, I said further clinical the primary answer, I said further clinical trials the primary answer, I said further clinical trials are the primary answer, I said further clinical trials are under the primary answer, I said further clinical trials are under way clinical trials are under way internationally clinical trials are under way internationally with clinical trials are under way internationally with results internationally with results expected internationally with results expected to internationally with results expected to be internationally with results expected to be available internationally with results expected to be available after internationally with results expected to be available after 2020. expected to be available after 2020. Given expected to be available after 2020. Given that expected to be available after 2020. Given that women expected to be available after 2020. Given that women who expected to be available after 2020. Given that women who live expected to be available after 2020. Given that women who live rurally Given that women who live rurally have Given that women who live rurally have to Given that women who live rurally have to have Given that women who live rurally have to have ongoing Given that women who live rurally have to have ongoing radiotherapy have to have ongoing radiotherapy over have to have ongoing radiotherapy over a have to have ongoing radiotherapy over a period have to have ongoing radiotherapy over a period of have to have ongoing radiotherapy over a period of months, have to have ongoing radiotherapy over a period of months, the over a period of months, the inconvenience over a period of months, the inconvenience to over a period of months, the inconvenience to them over a period of months, the inconvenience to them and over a period of months, the inconvenience to them and their inconvenience to them and their families, inconvenience to them and their inconvenience inconvenience to them and their families, majority of inconvenience to them and their families, majority of them inconvenience to them and their families, majority of them women, families, majority of them women, number families, majority of them women, number one families, majority of them women, number one cause families, majority of them women, number one cause of families, majority of them women, number one cause of death families, majority of them women, number one cause of death in families, majority of them women, number one cause of death in this number one cause of death in this country number one cause of death in this country by number one cause of death in this country by cancer number one cause of death in this country by cancer for number one cause of death in this country by cancer for women, number one cause of death in this country by cancer for women, will country by cancer for women, will the country by cancer for women, will the minister country by cancer for women, will the minister ensure country by cancer for women, will the minister ensure that country by cancer for women, will the minister ensure that those the minister ensure that those trials the minister ensure that those trials are the minister ensure that those trials are speedily the minister ensure that those trials are speedily and the minister ensure that those trials are speedily and this trials are speedily and this implemented? implemented? Mr implemented? Mr Speaker, implemented? Mr Speaker, I implemented? Mr Speaker, I don't implemented? Mr Speaker, I don't have implemented? Mr Speaker, I don't have any implemented? Mr Speaker, I don't have any power Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Minister Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Minister of Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Minister of Health Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Minister of Health to Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Minister of Health to speed Mr Speaker, I don't have any power as Minister of Health to speed up as Minister of Health to speed up international as Minister of Health to speed up international trials. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Defence: My question is to the Minister of Defence: What My question is to the Minister of Defence: What announcements My question is to the Minister of Defence: What announcements have Defence: What announcements have been Defence: What announcements have been made Defence: What announcements have been made as Defence: What announcements have been made as a Defence: What announcements have been made as a part Defence: What announcements have been made as a part of Defence: What announcements have been made as a part of Budget Defence: What announcements have been made as a part of Budget 2017 been made as a part of Budget 2017 about been made as a part of Budget 2017 about the been made as a part of Budget 2017 about the Government's been made as a part of Budget 2017 about the Government's investment been made as a part of Budget 2017 about the Government's investment in about the Government's investment in defence? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Before <INTERRUPTION> Order! Before I <INTERRUPTION> Order! Before I call <INTERRUPTION> Order! Before I call the <INTERRUPTION> Order! Before I call the minister, <INTERRUPTION> Order! Before I call the minister, I Order! Before I call the minister, I will Order! Before I call the minister, I will require Order! Before I call the minister, I will require substantially Order! Before I call the minister, I will require substantially less will require substantially less interjection will require substantially less defence? will require substantially less interjection from members will require substantially less interjection from members of will require substantially less interjection from members of the will require substantially less interjection from members of the New interjection from members of the New Zealand interjection from members of the New defence? interjection from members of the New Zealand First quarters. Zealand First quarters. Thank Zealand First quarters. Thank you Zealand First quarters. Thank you Mr Zealand First quarters. Thank you Mr Speaker. Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've a Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've a good Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've a good mind Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've a good mind to Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've a good mind to ask Thank you Mr Speaker. Order! I've a good mind to ask you Order! I've a good mind to ask you to Order! I've a good mind to ask you to leave Order! I've a good mind to ask you to leave the Order! I've a good mind to ask you to leave the Chamber, Order! I've a good mind to ask you to leave the Chamber, you Order! I've a good mind to ask you to leave the Chamber, you have to leave the Chamber, you have interjected to leave the Chamber, you have interjected in to leave the Chamber, you have interjected in every to leave the Chamber, you have interjected in every question to leave the Chamber, you have interjected in every question and interjected in every question and answer interjected in every question and interjected interjected in every question and answer so far. interjected in every question and answer so far. If interjected in every question and answer so far. If it interjected in every question and answer so far. If it happens interjected in every question and answer so far. If it happens again, answer so far. If it happens again, then answer so far. If it happens again, then I answer so far. If it happens again, then I will answer so far. If it happens again, then I will ask answer so far. If it happens again, then I will ask the answer so far. If it happens again, then I will ask the member answer so far. If it happens again, then I will ask the member to answer so far. If it happens again, then I will ask the member to leave. then I will ask the member to leave. I then I will ask the member to leave. I apologise then I will ask the member to leave. I apologise to then I will ask the member to leave. I apologise to the then I will ask the member to leave. I apologise to the minister. I apologise to the minister. A I apologise to the minister. A lot I apologise to the minister. A lot of I apologise to the minister. A lot of excitement I apologise to the minister. A lot of excitement over I apologise to the minister. A lot of excitement over there, I apologise to the minister. A lot of excitement over there, Mr A lot of excitement over there, Mr Speaker. A lot of excitement over there, Mr Speaker. Budget A lot of excitement over there, Mr Speaker. Budget 207 A lot of excitement over there, Mr Speaker. Budget 207 delivers A lot of excitement over there, Mr Speaker. Budget 207 delivers a Speaker. Budget 207 delivers a significant Speaker. Budget 207 delivers a significant investment Speaker. Budget 207 delivers a significant investment in Speaker. Budget 207 delivers a significant investment in the significant investment in the Defence significant investment in the Speaker. significant investment in the Defence Force. The significant investment in the Defence Force. The Government significant investment in the Defence Force. The Government has Defence Force. The Government has committed Defence Force. The Government has committed $406 Defence Force. The Government has committed $406 million Defence Force. The Government has committed $406 million over Defence Force. The Government has committed $406 million over the Defence Force. The Government has committed $406 million over the next committed $406 million over the next four committed $406 million over the next four years committed $406 million over the next four years and committed $406 million over the next four years and a committed $406 million over the next four years and a capital committed $406 million over the next four years and a capital boost committed $406 million over the next four years and a capital boost of four years and a capital boost of $576 four years and a capital boost of four four years and a capital boost of $576 million to four years and a capital boost of $576 million to deliver four years and a capital boost of $576 million to deliver a four years and a capital boost of $576 million to deliver a range four years and a capital boost of $576 million to deliver a range of $576 million to deliver a range of capabilities $576 million to deliver a range of capabilities identified $576 million to deliver a range of capabilities identified through $576 million to deliver a range of capabilities identified through the capabilities identified through the 2016 capabilities identified through the 2016 Defence capabilities identified through the 2016 Defence White capabilities identified through the 2016 Defence White Paper. capabilities identified through the 2016 Defence White Paper. This 2016 Defence White Paper. This funding 2016 Defence White Paper. This funding ensures 2016 Defence White Paper. This funding ensures we're 2016 Defence White Paper. This funding ensures we're investing 2016 Defence White Paper. This funding ensures we're investing in funding ensures we're investing in our funding ensures we're investing in our greatest funding ensures we're investing in our greatest asset funding ensures we're investing in our greatest asset - funding ensures we're investing in our greatest asset - our funding ensures we're investing in our greatest asset - our personnel funding ensures we're investing in our greatest asset - our personnel - our greatest asset - our personnel - and our greatest asset - our personnel - and giving our greatest asset - our personnel - and giving them our greatest asset - our personnel - and giving them the our greatest asset - our personnel - and giving them the modern, and giving them the modern, effective and giving them the modern, effective tools and giving them the modern, effective tools they and giving them the modern, effective tools they need and giving them the modern, effective tools they need to and giving them the modern, effective tools they need to provide effective tools they need to provide security effective tools they need to provide and effective tools they need to provide security at home effective tools they need to provide security at home and effective tools they need to provide security at home and abroad. security at home and abroad. Thank security at home and abroad. Thank you, security at home and abroad. Thank you, Mr security at home and abroad. Thank you, Mr Speaker. security at home and abroad. Thank you, Mr Speaker. To security at home and abroad. Thank you, Mr Speaker. To the Thank you, Mr Speaker. To the minister: Thank you, Mr Speaker. To the minister: How Thank you, Mr Speaker. To the minister: How is Thank you, Mr Speaker. To the minister: How is New Thank you, Mr Speaker. To the minister: How is New Zealand minister: How is New Zealand contributing minister: How is New Zealand contributing to minister: How is New Zealand contributing to regional minister: How is New Zealand contributing to regional security minister: How is New Zealand contributing to regional security in contributing to regional security in Asia-Pacific? Asia-Pacific? New Asia-Pacific? New Zealand Asia-Pacific? New Zealand contributes Asia-Pacific? New Zealand contributes in Asia-Pacific? New Zealand contributes in a Asia-Pacific? New Zealand contributes in a number New Zealand contributes in a number of New Zealand contributes in a number of ways, New Zealand contributes in a number of ways, including New Zealand contributes in a number of ways, including joint New Zealand contributes in a number of ways, including joint exercises, of ways, including joint exercises, training of ways, including joint exercises, of of ways, including joint exercises, training and information of ways, including joint exercises, training and information sharing. of ways, including joint exercises, training and information sharing. At training and information sharing. At the training and information sharing. At the Shrangila training and information sharing. At the Shrangila dialogue training and information sharing. At the Shrangila dialogue last training and information sharing. At the Shrangila dialogue last week training and information sharing. At the Shrangila dialogue last week a the Shrangila dialogue last week a clear the Shrangila dialogue last week a clear message the Shrangila dialogue last week a clear message from the Shrangila dialogue last week a clear message from our the Shrangila dialogue last week a clear message from our friends the Shrangila dialogue last week a clear message from our friends is clear message from our friends is that clear message from our friends is that they clear message from our friends is that they greatly clear message from our friends is that they greatly value clear message from our friends is that they greatly value New that they greatly value New Zealand's that they greatly value New that that they greatly value New Zealand's efforts in that they greatly value New Zealand's efforts in the that they greatly value New Zealand's efforts in the region that they greatly value New Zealand's efforts in the region and Zealand's efforts in the region and rely Zealand's efforts in the region and that Zealand's efforts in the region and rely on our Zealand's efforts in the region and rely on our expertise. Zealand's efforts in the region and rely on our expertise. While Zealand's efforts in the region and rely on our expertise. While away Zealand's efforts in the region and rely on our expertise. While away I rely on our expertise. While away I signed rely on our expertise. While away I signed a rely on our expertise. While away I signed a joint rely on our expertise. While away I signed a joint statement rely on our expertise. While away I signed a joint statement on rely on our expertise. While away I signed a joint statement on defence signed a joint statement on defence with signed a joint statement on defence with New signed a joint statement on defence with New Zealand signed a joint statement on defence with New Zealand and signed a joint statement on defence with New Zealand and reaffirmed signed a joint statement on defence with New Zealand and reaffirmed -- with New Zealand and reaffirmed -- with with New Zealand and reaffirmed -- rely with New Zealand and reaffirmed -- with Indonesia. I with New Zealand and reaffirmed -- with Indonesia. I reaffirmed with New Zealand and reaffirmed -- with Indonesia. I reaffirmed our with Indonesia. I reaffirmed our oldest with Indonesia. I reaffirmed our oldest security with Indonesia. I reaffirmed our oldest security agreement. with Indonesia. I reaffirmed our oldest security agreement. As with Indonesia. I reaffirmed our oldest security agreement. As a oldest security agreement. As a country oldest security agreement. As a oldest oldest security agreement. As a country we can oldest security agreement. As a country we can be oldest security agreement. As a country we can be proud oldest security agreement. As a country we can be proud of oldest security agreement. As a country we can be proud of our country we can be proud of our contribution country we can be proud of our contribution to country we can be proud of our contribution to the country we can be proud of our contribution to the regional contribution to the regional security contribution to the regional security and contribution to the regional security and the contribution to the regional security and the unique contribution to the regional security and the unique role contribution to the regional security and the unique role we contribution to the regional security and the unique role we play security and the unique role we play advocating security and the unique role we play advocating for security and the unique role we play advocating for small security and the unique role we play advocating for small states security and the unique role we play advocating for small states and advocating for small states and addressing advocating for small states and addressing global advocating for small states and addressing global challenges advocating for small states and addressing global challenges like addressing global challenges like violent addressing global challenges like violent extremism, addressing global challenges like violent extremism, territorial violent extremism, territorial disputes violent extremism, territorial disputes and violent extremism, territorial disputes and rogue violent extremism, territorial disputes and rogue states. disputes and rogue states. How disputes and rogue states. How can disputes and rogue states. How can the disputes and rogue states. How can the New disputes and rogue states. How can the New Zealand disputes and rogue states. How can the New Zealand people disputes and rogue states. How can the New Zealand people take How can the New Zealand people take seriously How can the New Zealand people take seriously his How can the New Zealand people take seriously his desire How can the New Zealand people take seriously his desire for How can the New Zealand people take seriously his desire for regional seriously his desire for regional security seriously his desire for regional security in seriously his desire for regional security in the seriously his desire for regional security in the Asia-Pacific, security in the Asia-Pacific, military security in the Asia-Pacific, military asset security in the Asia-Pacific, military asset pror security in the Asia-Pacific, military asset pror cluration, military asset pror cluration, defence military asset pror cluration, defence alliances military asset pror cluration, defence alliances -- military asset pror cluration, defence alliances -- procluration, defence alliances -- procluration, defence defence alliances -- procluration, defence alliances, defence alliances -- procluration, defence alliances, when defence alliances -- procluration, defence alliances, when the defence alliances -- procluration, defence alliances, when the number defence alliances, when the number one defence alliances, when the number defence defence alliances, when the number one priority seems defence alliances, when the number one priority seems to defence alliances, when the number one priority seems to be defence alliances, when the number one priority seems to be make one priority seems to be make defence one priority seems to be make defence smoke-free by one priority seems to be make defence smoke-free by 2020? defence smoke-free by 2020? I'm defence smoke-free by 2020? I'm pleased defence smoke-free by 2020? I'm pleased that defence smoke-free by 2020? I'm pleased that the defence smoke-free by 2020? I'm pleased that the New defence smoke-free by 2020? I'm pleased that the New Zealand I'm pleased that the New Zealand dephones I'm pleased that the New Zealand dephones forces I'm pleased that the New Zealand dephones forces create I'm pleased that the New Zealand dephones forces create an dephones forces create an environment dephones forces create an defence dephones forces create an environment to allow dephones forces create an environment to allow people dephones forces create an environment to allow people to dephones forces create an environment to allow people to make environment to allow people to make their environment to allow people to make their own environment to allow people to make their own choice environment to allow people to make their own choice in environment to allow people to make their own choice in terms environment to allow people to make their own choice in terms of environment to allow people to make their own choice in terms of whether their own choice in terms of whether they their own choice in terms of whether they want their own choice in terms of whether they want to their own choice in terms of whether they want to be their own choice in terms of whether they want to be smoke-free. their own choice in terms of whether they want to be smoke-free. I they want to be smoke-free. I reaffirm they want to be smoke-free. I reaffirm our they want to be smoke-free. I reaffirm our focus they want to be smoke-free. I reaffirm our focus as they want to be smoke-free. I reaffirm our focus as a they want to be smoke-free. I reaffirm our focus as a Defence reaffirm our focus as a Defence Force reaffirm our focus as a Defence Force is reaffirm our focus as a Defence Force is continued reaffirm our focus as a Defence Force is continued engagement reaffirm our focus as a Defence Force is continued engagement with Force is continued engagement with the Force is continued engagement with the security Force is continued engagement with the security architecture Force is continued engagement with the security architecture to Force is continued engagement with the security architecture to ensure the security architecture to ensure that the security architecture to ensure the the security architecture to ensure that the Asia-Pacific the security architecture to ensure that the Asia-Pacific region the security architecture to ensure that the Asia-Pacific region and that the Asia-Pacific region and wider that the Asia-Pacific region and wider region that the Asia-Pacific region and wider region remains that the Asia-Pacific region and wider region remains safe that the Asia-Pacific region and wider region remains safe and wider region remains safe and secure. Point Point of Point of order. Point of order. Seeking Point of order. Seeking clarification Point of order. Seeking clarification on Point of order. Seeking clarification on the Point of order. Seeking clarification on the transfer Point of order. Seeking clarification on the transfer of Point of order. Seeking clarification on the transfer of the clarification on the transfer of the question clarification on the transfer of the question on clarification on the transfer of the question on the clarification on the transfer of the question on the Minister clarification on the transfer of the question on the Minister for clarification on the transfer of the question on the Minister for Social question on the Minister for Social Housing question on the Minister for Social Housing and question on the Minister for Social Housing and wonder question on the Minister for Social Housing and wonder iffing question on the Minister for Social Housing and wonder iffing the Housing and wonder iffing the Government Housing and wonder iffing the Government is Housing and wonder iffing the Government is saying Housing and wonder iffing the Government is saying boarding Housing and wonder iffing the Government is saying boarding houses Government is saying boarding houses are Government is saying boarding houses are not Government is saying boarding houses are not a Government is saying boarding houses are not a firm Government is saying boarding houses are not a firm of Government is saying boarding houses are not a firm of emergency Government is saying boarding houses are not a firm of emergency housing? are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm aware are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm aware that are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm aware that the are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm aware that the question are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm aware that the question has are not a firm of emergency housing? I'm aware that the question has been I'm aware that the question has been transferred. I'm aware that the question has been transferred. It I'm aware that the question has been transferred. It is, I'm aware that the question has been transferred. It is, as I'm aware that the question has been transferred. It is, as I've transferred. It is, as I've mentioned, transferred. It is, as I've mentioned, many transferred. It is, as I've mentioned, many times transferred. It is, as I've mentioned, many times the transferred. It is, as I've mentioned, many times the right transferred. It is, as I've mentioned, many times the right of mentioned, many times the right of the mentioned, many times the right of transferred. mentioned, many times the right of the Government to mentioned, many times the right of the Government to transfer mentioned, many times the right of the Government to transfer a the Government to transfer a question. the Government to transfer a question. It the Government to transfer a question. It is the Government to transfer a question. It is the the Government to transfer a question. It is the responsibility question. It is the responsibility of question. It is the responsibility question. question. It is the responsibility of the Government question. It is the responsibility of the Government to question. It is the responsibility of the Government to make question. It is the responsibility of the Government to make sure question. It is the responsibility of the Government to make sure the of the Government to make sure the question of the Government to make sure the question goes of the Government to make sure the question goes to of the Government to make sure the question goes to the of the Government to make sure the question goes to the minister of the Government to make sure the question goes to the minister whom question goes to the minister whom they question goes to the minister whom they consider question goes to the minister whom they consider is question goes to the minister whom they consider is most question goes to the minister whom they consider is most responsible they consider is most responsible for they consider is most responsible they they consider is most responsible for the answer they consider is most responsible for the answer to they consider is most responsible for the answer to be they consider is most responsible for the answer to be given. they consider is most responsible for the answer to be given. The for the answer to be given. The question for the answer to be given. The question will for the answer to be given. The question will receive for the answer to be given. The question will receive to for the answer to be given. The question will receive to the question will receive to the minister question will receive to the minister to question will receive to the minister to whom question will receive to the minister to whom it's question will receive to the minister to whom it's been minister to whom it's been transferred minister to whom it's been minister minister to whom it's been transferred unless the minister to whom it's been transferred unless the member minister to whom it's been transferred unless the member would transferred unless the member would like transferred unless the member would transferred transferred unless the member would like us not transferred unless the member would like us not to transferred unless the member would like us not to ask transferred unless the member would like us not to ask that transferred unless the member would like us not to ask that question, like us not to ask that question, her like us not to ask that question, her point. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Building My question is to the Minister for Building and My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does he Building and Construction: Does he agree Building and Construction: Does he agree that Building and Construction: Does he agree that due Building and Construction: Does he agree that due to Building and Construction: Does he agree that due to the Building and Construction: Does he agree that due to the housing Building and Construction: Does he agree that due to the housing crisis agree that due to the housing crisis some agree that due to the housing crisis some boarding agree that due to the housing crisis some boarding house agree that due to the housing crisis some boarding house landlords agree that due to the housing crisis some boarding house landlords are some boarding house landlords are exploiting some boarding house landlords are exploiting vulnerable some boarding house landlords are exploiting vulnerable New exploiting vulnerable New Zealanders? Boarding Boarding houses Boarding houses have Boarding houses have always Boarding houses have always accommodated Boarding houses have always accommodated more Boarding houses have always accommodated more vulnerable Boarding houses have always accommodated more vulnerable tenants accommodated more vulnerable tenants and accommodated more vulnerable tenants and they accommodated more vulnerable tenants and they have accommodated more vulnerable tenants and they have featured accommodated more vulnerable tenants and they have featured regularly and they have featured regularly over and they have featured regularly and and they have featured regularly over the past and they have featured regularly over the past 20 and they have featured regularly over the past 20 years and they have featured regularly over the past 20 years in and they have featured regularly over the past 20 years in stories and they have featured regularly over the past 20 years in stories of over the past 20 years in stories of exploitation. over the past 20 years in stories of exploitation. This over the past 20 years in stories of exploitation. This Government over the past 20 years in stories of exploitation. This Government has exploitation. This Government has changed exploitation. This Government has changed the exploitation. This Government has changed the tenancy exploitation. This Government has changed the tenancy law exploitation. This Government has changed the tenancy law and exploitation. This Government has changed the tenancy law and set exploitation. This Government has changed the tenancy law and set up changed the tenancy law and set up the changed the tenancy law and set up the new changed the tenancy law and set up the new tenancy changed the tenancy law and set up the new tenancy compliance changed the tenancy law and set up the new tenancy compliance and the new tenancy compliance and investigations the new tenancy compliance and investigations team the new tenancy compliance and investigations team to the new tenancy compliance and investigations team to better investigations team to better protect investigations team to better the investigations team to better protect vulnerable tenants investigations team to better protect vulnerable tenants in investigations team to better protect vulnerable tenants in this protect vulnerable tenants in this type protect vulnerable tenants in this protect protect vulnerable tenants in this type of accommodation. type of accommodation. Is type of accommodation. Is the type of accommodation. Is the reason type of accommodation. Is the reason why type of accommodation. Is the reason why he type of accommodation. Is the reason why he is type of accommodation. Is the reason why he is answering Is the reason why he is answering the Is the reason why he is answering the question Is the reason why he is answering the question and Is the reason why he is answering the question and not Is the reason why he is answering the question and not the Is the reason why he is answering the question and not the Minister the question and not the Minister for the question and not the Minister Is the question and not the Minister for Social Housing the question and not the Minister for Social Housing because the question and not the Minister for Social Housing because he for Social Housing because he believes for Social Housing because he believes that for Social Housing because he believes that New for Social Housing because he believes that New Zealand for Social Housing because he believes that New Zealand is for Social Housing because he believes that New Zealand is paying believes that New Zealand is paying $250 believes that New Zealand is paying $250 a believes that New Zealand is paying $250 a week believes that New Zealand is paying $250 a week to believes that New Zealand is paying $250 a week to live believes that New Zealand is paying $250 a week to live in believes that New Zealand is paying $250 a week to live in slum-like $250 a week to live in slum-like boarding $250 a week to live in slum-like boarding houses, $250 a week to live in slum-like boarding houses, and $250 a week to live in slum-like boarding houses, and that's $250 a week to live in slum-like boarding houses, and that's not $250 a week to live in slum-like boarding houses, and that's not an boarding houses, and that's not an issue boarding houses, and that's not an issue to boarding houses, and that's not an issue to emergency boarding houses, and that's not an issue to emergency housing boarding houses, and that's not an issue to emergency housing or boarding houses, and that's not an issue to emergency housing or social issue to emergency housing or social housing issue to emergency housing or social $250 housing availability. No. housing availability. No. My housing availability. No. My ministerial No. My ministerial responsibilitieses No. My ministerial responsibilitieses make No. My ministerial responsibilitieses make me responsibilitieses make me responsible responsibilitieses make me responsible for responsibilitieses make me responsible for tenancy responsibilitieses make me responsible for tenancy law responsibilitieses make me responsible for tenancy law which responsible for tenancy law which deals responsible for tenancy law which deals with responsible for tenancy law which deals with the responsible for tenancy law which deals with the issues responsible for tenancy law which deals with the issues of responsible for tenancy law which deals with the issues of standards, deals with the issues of standards, and deals with the issues of standards, and issues deals with the issues of standards, and issues such deals with the issues of standards, and issues such as deals with the issues of standards, and issues such as boarding deals with the issues of standards, and issues such as boarding houses. and issues such as boarding houses. Secondly, and issues such as boarding houses. Secondly, I'm and issues such as boarding houses. Secondly, I'm responsible and issues such as boarding houses. Secondly, I'm responsible for and issues such as boarding houses. Secondly, I'm responsible for the Secondly, I'm responsible for the Building Secondly, I'm responsible for the Building Act Secondly, I'm responsible for the Building Act which Secondly, I'm responsible for the Building Act which deals Secondly, I'm responsible for the Building Act which deals with Building Act which deals with sanitary Building Act which deals with Building Building Act which deals with sanitary and unsafe Building Act which deals with sanitary and unsafe buildings. sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does he sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does he accept sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does he accept that sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does he accept that as sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does he accept that as the sanitary and unsafe buildings. Does he accept that as the housing Does he accept that as the housing crisis Does he accept that as the housing crisis intensifies, Does he accept that as the housing crisis intensifies, New Does he accept that as the housing crisis intensifies, New Zealanders crisis intensifies, New Zealanders are crisis intensifies, New Zealanders are becoming crisis intensifies, New Zealanders are becoming more crisis intensifies, New Zealanders are becoming more December crisis intensifies, New Zealanders are becoming more December brat crisis intensifies, New Zealanders are becoming more December brat and are becoming more December brat and are are becoming more December brat and Does are becoming more December brat and are left with are becoming more December brat and are left with no are becoming more December brat and are left with no choice are becoming more December brat and are left with no choice but are becoming more December brat and are left with no choice but to are becoming more December brat and are left with no choice but to live are left with no choice but to live in are left with no choice but to live in their are left with no choice but to live in their cars are left with no choice but to live in their cars -- are left with no choice but to live in their cars -- desperate are left with no choice but to live in their cars -- desperate and are left with no choice but to live in their cars -- desperate and are in their cars -- desperate and are left in their cars -- desperate and are in in their cars -- desperate and are left with no in their cars -- desperate and are left with no choice in their cars -- desperate and are left with no choice but in their cars -- desperate and are left with no choice but to in their cars -- desperate and are left with no choice but to live in their cars -- desperate and are left with no choice but to live in left with no choice but to live in cars left with no choice but to live in cars or left with no choice but to live in cars or slum-like left with no choice but to live in cars or slum-like boarding left with no choice but to live in cars or slum-like boarding houses? cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr Speaker, cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr Speaker, no, cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr Speaker, no, because cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr Speaker, no, because we cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr Speaker, no, because we are cars or slum-like boarding houses? Mr Speaker, no, because we are now Mr Speaker, no, because we are now building Mr Speaker, no, because we are now building over Mr Speaker, no, because we are now building over 30,000 Mr Speaker, no, because we are now building over 30,000 homes Mr Speaker, no, because we are now building over 30,000 homes per Mr Speaker, no, because we are now building over 30,000 homes per year, building over 30,000 homes per year, for building over 30,000 homes per year, for the building over 30,000 homes per year, for the first building over 30,000 homes per year, for the first time building over 30,000 homes per year, for the first time ever building over 30,000 homes per year, for the first time ever the for the first time ever the Government for the first time ever the Government is for the first time ever the Government is providing for the first time ever the Government is providing direct Government is providing direct financial Government is providing direct financial support Government is providing direct financial support for Government is providing direct financial support for emergency financial support for emergency housing, financial support for emergency housing, and financial support for emergency housing, and even financial support for emergency housing, and even last financial support for emergency housing, and even last year financial support for emergency housing, and even last year the housing, and even last year the Government housing, and even last year the Government completed housing, and even last year the Government completed the Government completed the construction Government completed the construction of Government completed the construction of more Government completed the construction of more homes Government completed the construction of more homes than Government completed the construction of more homes than any construction of more homes than any government construction of more homes than any government in construction of more homes than any government in more construction of more homes than any government in more than construction of more homes than any government in more than 20 construction of more homes than any government in more than 20 years. government in more than 20 years. Supplementary, government in more than 20 years. Supplementary, Maureen government in more than 20 years. Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. government in more than 20 years. Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What changes Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What changes has Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What changes has the Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What changes has the Government Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What changes has the Government made Supplementary, Maureen Pugh. What changes has the Government made to changes has the Government made to improve changes has the Government made to improve rental changes has the Government made to improve rental conditions changes has the Government made to improve rental conditions for improve rental conditions for boarding improve rental conditions for Government improve rental conditions for boarding house tenants? boarding house tenants? Mr boarding house tenants? Mr Speaker, boarding house tenants? Mr Speaker, the boarding house tenants? Mr Speaker, the Government boarding house tenants? Mr Speaker, the Government has boarding house tenants? Mr Speaker, the Government has made Mr Speaker, the Government has made five Mr Speaker, the Government has made five changes Mr Speaker, the Government has made five changes in Mr Speaker, the Government has made five changes in toughening Mr Speaker, the Government has made five changes in toughening up Mr Speaker, the Government has made five changes in toughening up the five changes in toughening up the standards five changes in toughening up the standards required five changes in toughening up the standards required of five changes in toughening up the standards required of boarding standards required of boarding houses standards required of boarding boarding standards required of boarding houses from 1 standards required of boarding houses from 1 July standards required of boarding houses from 1 July last standards required of boarding houses from 1 July last year standards required of boarding houses from 1 July last year they houses from 1 July last year they were houses from 1 July last year they were required houses from 1 July last year they were required to houses from 1 July last year they were required to have houses from 1 July last year they were required to have smoke houses from 1 July last year they were required to have smoke alarms. were required to have smoke alarms. Secondly were required to have smoke alarms. Secondly there's were required to have smoke alarms. Secondly there's a were required to have smoke alarms. Secondly there's a specific Secondly there's a specific requirement Secondly there's a specific requirement for Secondly there's a specific requirement for them Secondly there's a specific requirement for them to Secondly there's a specific requirement for them to declare Secondly there's a specific requirement for them to declare the requirement for them to declare the level requirement for them to declare the level of requirement for them to declare the level of insulation requirement for them to declare the level of insulation and requirement for them to declare the level of insulation and for requirement for them to declare the level of insulation and for all requirement for them to declare the level of insulation and for all such level of insulation and for all such residences level of insulation and for all such residences to level of insulation and for all such residences to be level of insulation and for all such residences to be insulated level of insulation and for all such residences to be insulated by level of insulation and for all such residences to be insulated by 1 level of insulation and for all such residences to be insulated by 1 July residences to be insulated by 1 July 2019. residences to be insulated by 1 July 2019. Thirdly, residences to be insulated by 1 July 2019. Thirdly, we residences to be insulated by 1 July 2019. Thirdly, we have residences to be insulated by 1 July 2019. Thirdly, we have tightened residences to be insulated by 1 July 2019. Thirdly, we have tightened the 2019. Thirdly, we have tightened the electrical 2019. Thirdly, we have tightened the electrical safety 2019. Thirdly, we have tightened the electrical safety requirements. electrical safety requirements. Fourthly, electrical safety requirements. Fourthly, we electrical safety requirements. Fourthly, we have electrical safety requirements. Fourthly, we have introduced electrical safety requirements. Fourthly, we have introduced the electrical safety requirements. Fourthly, we have introduced the new Fourthly, we have introduced the new enforcement Fourthly, we have introduced the new enforcement regime, Fourthly, we have introduced the new enforcement regime, with Fourthly, we have introduced the new enforcement regime, with a Fourthly, we have introduced the new enforcement regime, with a tenancy enforcement regime, with a tenancy compliance enforcement regime, wit enforcement enforcement regime, wit compliance and investigations enforcement regime, wit compliance and investigations team. compliance and investigations team. And compliance and investigations team. And fifthly, compliance and investigations team. And fifthly, we compliance and investigations team. And fifthly, we have compliance and investigations team. And fifthly, we have strengthened And fifthly, we have strengthened the And fifthly, we have strengthened And And fifthly, we have strengthened the retaliatory provisions And fifthly, we have strengthened the retaliatory provisions to And fifthly, we have strengthened the retaliatory provisions to ensure the retaliatory provisions to ensure tenants the retaliatory provisions to ensure the the retaliatory provisions to ensure tenants have the the retaliatory provisions to ensure tenants have the confidence the retaliatory provisions to ensure tenants have the confidence to tenants have the confidence to actually tenants have the confidence to tenants tenants have the confidence to actually be able tenants have the confidence to actually be able to tenants have the confidence to actually be able to hold tenants have the confidence to actually be able to hold landlords actually be able to hold landlords to actually be able to hold landlords to account actually be able to hold landlords to account for actually be able to hold landlords to account for meeting actually be able to hold landlords to account for meeting the actually be able to hold landlords to account for meeting the housing to account for meeting the housing regulations. regulations. After regulations. After nine regulations. After nine years regulations. After nine years of regulations. After nine years of his regulations. After nine years of his government, After nine years of his government, why After nine years of his government, why is After nine years of his government, why is there After nine years of his government, why is there still After nine years of his government, why is there still no After nine years of his government, why is there still no housing After nine years of his government, why is there still no housing for why is there still no housing for boarding why is there still no housing for boarding house why is there still no housing for boarding house tenants why is there still no housing for boarding house tenants like why is there still no housing for boarding house tenants like Glen boarding house tenants like Glen Sharman, boarding house tenants like Glen Sharman, who boarding house tenants like Glen Sharman, who said, boarding house tenants like Glen Sharman, who said, quote, Sharman, who said, quote, "Personally Sharman, who said, quote, "Personally I Sharman, who said, quote, "Personally I wouldn't Sharman, who said, quote, "Personally I wouldn't live Sharman, who said, quote, "Personally I wouldn't live where Sharman, who said, quote, "Personally I wouldn't live where I "Personally I wouldn't live where I am "Personally I wouldn't live where I boarding "Personally I wouldn't live where I am living now. "Personally I wouldn't live where I am living now. Why "Personally I wouldn't live where I am living now. Why am "Personally I wouldn't live where I am living now. Why am I? "Personally I wouldn't live where I am living now. Why am I? I "Personally I wouldn't live where I am living now. Why am I? I have am living now. Why am I? I have nowhere am living now. Why am I? I have nowhere else am living now. Why am I? I have nowhere else to am living now. Why am I? I have nowhere else to go", am living now. Why am I? I have nowhere else to go", end am living now. Why am I? I have nowhere else to go", end quote. nowhere else to go", end quote. Could nowhere else to go", end quote. Could this nowhere else to go", end quote. Could this be nowhere else to go", end quote. Could this be because nowhere else to go", end quote. Could this be because the nowhere else to go", end quote. Could this be because the number nowhere else to go", end quote. Could this be because the number of Could this be because the number of state Could this be because the number of state houses Could this be because the number of state houses has Could this be because the number of state houses has reduced Could this be because the number of state houses has reduced by Could this be because the number of state houses has reduced by 2,500 state houses has reduced by 2,500 under state houses has reduced by 2,500 Could state houses has reduced by 2,500 under his Government's state houses has reduced by 2,500 under his Government's watch? under his Government's watch? Mr under his Government's watch? Mr Speaker, under his Government's watch? Mr Speaker, I under his Government's watch? Mr Speaker, I do under his Government's watch? Mr Speaker, I do find under his Government's watch? Mr Speaker, I do find the Mr Speaker, I do find the Opposition's Mr Speaker, I do find the Opposition's figures Mr Speaker, I do find the Opposition's figures around Mr Speaker, I do find the Opposition's figures around the Opposition's figures around the number Opposition's figures around the number of Opposition's figures around the number of state Opposition's figures around the number of state houses Opposition's figures around the number of state houses very Opposition's figures around the number of state houses very dodgy, number of state houses very dodgy, because number of state houses very dodgy, because they number of state houses very dodgy, because they exclude number of state houses very dodgy, because they exclude those number of state houses very dodgy, because they exclude those numbers because they exclude those numbers that because they exclude those numbers that are because they exclude those numbers that are transferred because they exclude those numbers that are transferred to because they exclude those numbers that are transferred to the because they exclude those numbers that are transferred to the Tamiki that are transferred to the Tamiki redevelopment. that are transferred to the Tamiki because that are transferred to the Tamiki redevelopment. The real that are transferred to the Tamiki redevelopment. The real question redevelopment. The real question should redevelopment. The real question should be redevelopment. The real question should be the redevelopment. The real question should be the number redevelopment. The real question should be the number of redevelopment. The real question should be the number of social should be the number of social houses should be the number of social houses and should be the number of social houses and members should be the number of social houses and members representing houses and members representing electorates houses and members representing because houses and members representing electorates all over houses and members representing electorates all over New houses and members representing electorates all over New Zealand electorates all over New Zealand would electorates all over New Zealand electorates electorates all over New Zealand would know the electorates all over New Zealand would know the degree electorates all over New Zealand would know the degree to electorates all over New Zealand would know the degree to which electorates all over New Zealand would know the degree to which the would know the degree to which the number would know the degree to which the would would know the degree to which the number of social would know the degree to which the number of social houses would know the degree to which the number of social houses being number of social houses being provided, number of social houses being provided, not number of social houses being provided, not just number of social houses being provided, not just by number of social houses being provided, not just by Housing number of social houses being provided, not just by Housing New provided, not just by Housing New Zealand, provided, not just by Housing New Zealand, but provided, not just by Housing New Zealand, but other provided, not just by Housing New Zealand, but other agencies, provided, not just by Housing New Zealand, but other agencies, is Zealand, but other agencies, is expanding Zealand, but other agencies, is Zealand, expanding rapidly. Will expanding rapidly. Will the expanding rapidly. Will the minister expanding rapidly. Will the minister support expanding rapidly. Will the minister support the Will the minister support the petition Will the minister support the petition currently Will the minister support the petition currently before Will the minister support the petition currently before the Will the minister support the petition currently before the Social petition currently before the Social Services petition currently before the Social petition petition currently before the Social Services select committee petition currently before the Social Services select committee to Services select committee to implement Services select committee to petition Services select committee to implement recommendations from Services select committee to implement recommendations from the implement recommendations from the 2014 implement recommendations from the 2014 inquiry implement recommendations from the 2014 inquiry into implement recommendations from the 2014 inquiry into boarding implement recommendations from the 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why is 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why is he 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why is he content 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why is he content to 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why is he content to see 2014 inquiry into boarding houses? If not, why is he content to see New If not, why is he content to see New Zealanders If not, why is he content to see New Zealanders living If not, why is he content to see New Zealanders living in If not, why is he content to see New Zealanders living in slums? Zealanders living in slums? Mr Zealanders living in slums? Mr Speaker, Zealanders living in slums? Mr Speaker, quite Zealanders living in slums? Mr Speaker, quite the Zealanders living in slums? Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. Zealanders living in slums? Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. I've Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. I've outlined Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. I've outlined the Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. I've outlined the five Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. I've outlined the five different Mr Speaker, quite the opposite. I've outlined the five different measures outlined the five different measures this outlined the five different measures this Government outlined the five different measures this Government has outlined the five different measures this Government has taken outlined the five different measures this Government has taken to outlined the five different measures this Government has taken to improve this Government has taken to improve the this Government has taken to improve the regulation this Government has taken to improve the regulation around this Government has taken to improve the regulation around boarding the regulation around boarding hostels. the regulation around boarding outlined the regulation around boarding hostels. I have the regulation around boarding hostels. I have to the regulation around boarding hostels. I have to tell the regulation around boarding hostels. I have to tell you the regulation around boarding hostels. I have to tell you in the regulation around boarding hostels. I have to tell you in every hostels. I have to tell you in every Parliament hostels. I have to tell you in every Parliament in hostels. I have to tell you in every Parliament in the hostels. I have to tell you in every Parliament in the last hostels. I have to tell you in every Parliament in the last two hostels. I have to tell you in every Parliament in the last two decades, Parliament in the last two decades, there Parliament in the last two decades, there have Parliament in the last two decades, there have been Parliament in the last two decades, there have been issues Parliament in the last two decades, there have been issues with Parliament in the last two decades, there have been issues with boarding there have been issues with boarding houses. there have been issues with boarding houses. The there have been issues with boarding houses. The only there have been issues with boarding houses. The only difference there have been issues with boarding houses. The only difference with houses. The only difference with this houses. The only difference with houses. houses. The only difference with this government is houses. The only difference with this government is we've houses. The only difference with this government is we've done this government is we've done something this government is we've done this this government is we've done something about it. something about it. <INTERRUPTION> My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Climate My question is to the Minister for Climate Change My question is to the Minister for Climate Change Issues: My question is to the Minister for Climate Change Issues: Will My question is to the Minister for Climate Change Issues: Will she Climate Change Issues: Will she release Climate Change Issues: Will she release updated Climate Change Issues: Will she release updated guidance Climate Change Issues: Will she release updated guidance before Climate Change Issues: Will she release updated guidance before this release updated guidance before this year's release updated guidance before this year's general release updated guidance before this year's general election release updated guidance before this year's general election on release updated guidance before this year's general election on the year's general election on the extent year's general election on the extent of year's general election on the extent of sea-level year's general election on the extent of sea-level rise year's general election on the extent of sea-level rise which year's general election on the extent of sea-level rise which local extent of sea-level rise which local authorities extent of sea-level rise which local authorities should extent of sea-level rise which local authorities should plan extent of sea-level rise which local authorities should plan for? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, the Mr Speaker, the Ministry Mr Speaker, the Ministry for Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Environment Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Environment is Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Environment is still Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Environment is still in Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Environment is still in the Mr Speaker, the Ministry for the Environment is still in the process Environment is still in the process of Environment is still in the process of finalising Environment is still in the process of finalising their Environment is still in the process of finalising their updated Environment is still in the process of finalising their updated coastal of finalising their updated coastal hazards of finalising their updated coastal of of finalising their updated coastal hazards guidance for of finalising their updated coastal hazards guidance for councils. of finalising their updated coastal hazards guidance for councils. It of finalising their updated coastal hazards guidance for councils. It is hazards guidance for councils. It is important hazards guidance for councils. It is of hazards guidance for councils. It is important it goes hazards guidance for councils. It is important it goes through hazards guidance for councils. It is important it goes through a hazards guidance for councils. It is important it goes through a thorough important it goes through a thorough process important it goes through a thorough process so important it goes through a thorough process so councils important it goes through a thorough process so councils can important it goes through a thorough process so councils can make important it goes through a thorough process so councils can make sound process so councils can make sound planning process so councils can make sound planning decisions process so councils can make sound planning decisions and process so councils can make sound planning decisions and as process so councils can make sound planning decisions and as such, process so councils can make sound planning decisions and as such, I planning decisions and as such, I cannot planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give a planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give a date planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give a date as planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give a date as to planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give a date as to when planning decisions and as such, I cannot yet give a date as to when it cannot yet give a date as to when it will cannot yet give a date as to when it will be cannot yet give a date as to when it will be ready cannot yet give a date as to when it will be ready for cannot yet give a date as to when it will be ready for release. will be ready for release. Supplementary will be ready for release. Supplementary question, will be ready for release. Supplementary question, Eugenie Supplementary question, Eugenie Sage. Supplementary question, Eugenie Sage. Is Supplementary question, Eugenie Sage. Is it Supplementary question, Eugenie Sage. Is it appropriate Supplementary question, Eugenie Sage. Is it appropriate for Supplementary question, Eugenie Sage. Is it appropriate for councils Sage. Is it appropriate for councils to Sage. Is it appropriate for councils Supplementary Sage. Is it appropriate for councils to continue to Sage. Is it appropriate for councils to continue to use Sage. Is it appropriate for councils to continue to use nine-year-old to continue to use nine-year-old government to continue to use nine-year-old government guidance to continue to use nine-year-old government guidance to to continue to use nine-year-old government guidance to respond to continue to use nine-year-old government guidance to respond to government guidance to respond to sea government guidance to respond to government government guidance to respond to sea level rise government guidance to respond to sea level rise give government guidance to respond to sea level rise give thn government guidance to respond to sea level rise give thn guidance sea level rise give thn guidance massively sea level rise give thn guidance massively underestimates sea level rise give thn guidance massively underestimates how sea level rise give thn guidance massively underestimates how high massively underestimates how high sea massively underestimates how high government massively underestimates how high sea level is massively underestimates how high sea level is likely massively underestimates how high sea level is likely to massively underestimates how high sea level is likely to rise? sea level is likely to rise? Mr sea level is likely to rise? Mr Speaker, sea level is likely to rise? Mr Speaker, the sea level is likely to rise? Mr Speaker, the member's sea level is likely to rise? Mr Speaker, the member's making Mr Speaker, the member's making assumptions Mr Speaker, the member's making Mr Mr Speaker, the member's making assumptions as to Mr Speaker, the member's making assumptions as to whether Mr Speaker, the member's making assumptions as to whether or Mr Speaker, the member's making assumptions as to whether or not Mr Speaker, the member's making assumptions as to whether or not it assumptions as to whether or not it is assumptions as to whether or not it is out assumptions as to whether or not it is out of assumptions as to whether or not it is out of date, assumptions as to whether or not it is out of date, it assumptions as to whether or not it is out of date, it is assumptions as to whether or not it is out of date, it is currently assumptions as to whether or not it is out of date, it is currently in is out of date, it is currently in date is out of date, it is currently in date and is out of date, it is currently in date and we is out of date, it is currently in date and we will is out of date, it is currently in date and we will be is out of date, it is currently in date and we will be working is out of date, it is currently in date and we will be working on is out of date, it is currently in date and we will be working on that date and we will be working on that when date and we will be working on that when it's date and we will be working on that when it's ready. when it's ready. How when it's ready. How does when it's ready. How does she when it's ready. How does she respond when it's ready. How does she respond to when it's ready. How does she respond to a when it's ready. How does she respond to a district How does she respond to a district mayor's How does she respond to a district mayor's question, How does she respond to a district mayor's question, and How does she respond to a district mayor's question, and I How does she respond to a district mayor's question, and I quote, How does she respond to a district mayor's question, and I quote, "What mayor's question, and I quote, "What do mayor's question, and I quote, "What How mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want us mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want us to mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want us to do mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want us to do and mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want us to do and where mayor's question, and I quote, "What do you want us to do and where is do you want us to do and where is the do you want us to do and where is the money do you want us to do and where is the money to do you want us to do and where is the money to do do you want us to do and where is the money to do it?" the money to do it?" Mr the money to do it?" Mr Speaker, the money to do it?" Mr Speaker, a the money to do it?" Mr Speaker, a good, the money to do it?" Mr Speaker, a good, feisty, Mr Speaker, a good, feisty, intelligent Mr Speaker, a good, feisty, intelligent woman Mr Speaker, a good, feisty, intelligent woman putting Mr Speaker, a good, feisty, intelligent woman putting her Mr Speaker, a good, feisty, intelligent woman putting her voice intelligent woman putting her voice forward intelligent woman putting her voice forward and intelligent woman putting her voice forward and put intelligent woman putting her voice forward and put sticking intelligent woman putting her voice forward and put sticking up intelligent woman putting her voice forward and put sticking up for intelligent woman putting her voice forward and put sticking up for her forward and put sticking up for her community forward and put sticking up for her community wants forward and put sticking up for her community wants to forward and put sticking up for her community wants to make forward and put sticking up for her community wants to make a forward and put sticking up for her community wants to make a difference community wants to make a difference and community wants to make a difference forward community wants to make a difference and needs help community wants to make a difference and needs help as community wants to make a difference and needs help as to community wants to make a difference and needs help as to where community wants to make a difference and needs help as to where to community wants to make a difference and needs help as to where to put and needs help as to where to put that, and needs help as to where to put that, I and needs help as to where to put that, I suppose. that, I suppose. Is that, I suppose. Is the that, I suppose. Is the real that, I suppose. Is the real reason that, I suppose. Is the real reason she that, I suppose. Is the real reason she hasn't Is the real reason she hasn't released Is the real reason she hasn't released updated Is the real reason she hasn't released updated guidance Is the real reason she hasn't released updated guidance to released updated guidance to councils released updated guidance to councils on released updated guidance to councils on sea released updated guidance to councils on sea level released updated guidance to councils on sea level rise released updated guidance to councils on sea level rise this released updated guidance to councils on sea level rise this year councils on sea level rise this year that councils on sea level rise this year that National councils on sea level rise this year that National doesn't councils on sea level rise this year that National doesn't want councils on sea level rise this year that National doesn't want to councils on sea level rise this year that National doesn't want to tackle that National doesn't want to tackle the that National doesn't want to tackle the hard that National doesn't want to tackle the hard issues that National doesn't want to tackle the hard issues in that National doesn't want to tackle the hard issues in an that National doesn't want to tackle the hard issues in an election that National doesn't want to tackle the hard issues in an election year the hard issues in an election year and the hard issues in an election year and doesn't the hard issues in an election year and doesn't want the hard issues in an election year and doesn't want to the hard issues in an election year and doesn't want to talk the hard issues in an election year and doesn't want to talk about the hard issues in an election year and doesn't want to talk about the and doesn't want to talk about the real and doesn't want to talk about the real impacts and doesn't want to talk about the real impacts that and doesn't want to talk about the real impacts that climate and doesn't want to talk about the real impacts that climate change and doesn't want to talk about the real impacts that climate change is real impacts that climate change is having real impacts that climate change is having in real impacts that climate change is having in New real impacts that climate change is having in New Zealand real impacts that climate change is having in New Zealand right real impacts that climate change is having in New Zealand right now? having in New Zealand right now? No. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: My question is to the Minister of Health: Does My question is to the Minister of Health: Does he My question is to the Minister of Health: Does he stand My question is to the Minister of Health: Does he stand by My question is to the Minister of Health: Does he stand by his Health: Does he stand by his statement Health: Does he stand by his statement that Health: Does he stand by his statement that the Health: Does he stand by his statement that the wish-list Health: Does he stand by his statement that the wish-list figure statement that the wish-list figure for statement that the wish-list figure for district statement that the wish-list figure for district health statement that the wish-list figure for district health boards statement that the wish-list figure for district health boards to statement that the wish-list figure for district health boards to meet for district health boards to meet their for district health boards to meet their total for district health boards to meet their total cost for district health boards to meet their total cost pressures for district health boards to meet their total cost pressures is for district health boards to meet their total cost pressures is "round their total cost pressures is "round the their total cost pressures is "round the amount their total cost pressures is "round the amount of their total cost pressures is "round the amount of the their total cost pressures is "round the amount of the allocation their total cost pressures is "round the amount of the allocation plus the amount of the allocation plus about the amount of the allocation plus about 1 the amount of the allocation plus about 1 percent the amount of the allocation plus about 1 percent of the amount of the allocation plus about 1 percent of the the amount of the allocation plus about 1 percent of the baseline", about 1 percent of the baseline", and about 1 percent of the baseline", and what about 1 percent of the baseline", and what is about 1 percent of the baseline", and what is the about 1 percent of the baseline", and what is the total about 1 percent of the baseline", and what is the total cost about 1 percent of the baseline", and what is the total cost pressure and what is the total cost pressure including and what is the total cost pressure including wage, and what is the total cost pressure including wage, demographic, and what is the total cost pressure including wage, demographic, and including wage, demographic, and inflation including wage, demographic, and inflation for including wage, demographic, and inflation for all including wage, demographic, and inflation for all district including wage, demographic, and inflation for all district health inflation for all district health boards inflation for all district health boards in inflation for all district health boards in dollars inflation for all district health boards in dollars for inflation for all district health boards in dollars for 2017/18? Yes. Yes. The Yes. The total Yes. The total theoretical Yes. The total theoretical pressure Yes. The total theoretical pressure is Yes. The total theoretical pressure is their Yes. The total theoretical pressure is their allocation Yes. The total theoretical pressure is their allocation of Yes. The total theoretical pressure is their allocation of $439 Yes. The total theoretical pressure is their allocation of $439 million is their allocation of $439 million is their allocation of $439 million is their allocation of $439 million plus around is their allocation of $439 million plus around 1% is their allocation of $439 million plus around 1% of is their allocation of $439 million plus around 1% of the is their allocation of $439 million plus around 1% of the total is their allocation of $439 million plus around 1% of the total DHB plus around 1% of the total DHB Budget, plus around 1% of the total DHB Budget, so plus around 1% of the total DHB Budget, so around plus around 1% of the total DHB Budget, so around $530 plus around 1% of the total DHB Budget, so around $530 million. plus around 1% of the total DHB Budget, so around $530 million. Just Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember this Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember this will Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember this will always Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember this will always only Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember this will always only be Budget, so around $530 million. Just remember this will always only be an remember this will always only be an estimate remember this will always only be an estimate because remember this will always only be an estimate because the remember this will always only be an estimate because the final remember this will always only be an estimate because the final figure estimate because the final figure for estimate because the final figure for the estimate because the final figure for the year estimate because the final figure for the year is estimate because the final figure for the year is dependent estimate because the final figure for the year is dependent on for the year is dependent on inflation, for the year is dependent on inflation, wage for the year is dependent on inflation, wage settlements for the year is dependent on inflation, wage settlements and inflation, wage settlements and other inflation, wage settlements and other costs, inflation, wage settlements and other costs, changing inflation, wage settlements and other costs, changing fact inflation, wage settlements and other costs, changing fact yortion. inflation, wage settlements and other inflation, wage settlements and I know the inflation, wage settlements and I know the member inflation, wage settlements and I know the member will inflation, wage settlements and I know the member will be inflation, wage settlements and I know the member will be excited inflation, wage settlements and I know the member will be excited to I know the member will be excited to hear, I know the member will be excited to hear, and I know the member will be excited to hear, and probably I know the member will be excited to hear, and probably poor I know the member will be excited to hear, and probably poor the I know the member will be excited to hear, and probably poor the first hear, and probably poor the first time, hear, and probably poor the first time, that hear, and probably poor the first time, that health hear, and probably poor the first time, that health has hear, and probably poor the first time, that health has received hear, and probably poor the first time, that health has received its time, that health has received its biggest time, that health has received its biggest increase time, that health has received its biggest increase in time, that health has received its biggest increase in 11 time, that health has received its biggest increase in 11 years, time, that health has received its biggest increase in 11 years, $888 biggest increase in 11 years, $888 million. Does Does the Does the Ministry Does the Ministry of Does the Ministry of Health Does the Ministry of Health use Does the Ministry of Health use the Does the Ministry of Health use the measure Does the Ministry of Health use the measure of Does the Ministry of Health use the measure of demographic Does the Ministry of Health use the measure of demographic cost measure of demographic cost pressures measure of demographic cost pressures when measure of demographic cost pressures when they measure of demographic cost pressures when they advise measure of demographic cost pressures when they advise him measure of demographic cost pressures when they advise him of pressures when they advise him of what pressures when they advise him of what the pressures when they advise him of what the total pressures when they advise him of what the total cost pressures when they advise him of what the total cost pressures pressures when they advise him of what the total cost pressures are pressures when they advise him of what the total cost pressures are in what the total cost pressures are in Vote what the total cost pressures are in Vote Health what the total cost pressures are in Vote Health for what the total cost pressures are in Vote Health for his what the total cost pressures are in Vote Health for his Budget what the total cost pressures are in Vote Health for his Budget meetings Vote Health for his Budget meetings with Vote Health for his Budget meetings with the Vote Health for his Budget meetings with the Finance Vote Health for his Budget meetings with the Finance Minister? Vote Health for his Budget meetings with the Finance Minister? I'm Vote Health for his Budget meetings with the Finance Minister? I'm not with the Finance Minister? I'm not with the Finance Minister? I'm not with the Finance Minister? I'm not sure that with the Finance Minister? I'm not sure that makes with the Finance Minister? I'm not sure that makes sense, with the Finance Minister? I'm not sure that makes sense, that sure that makes sense, that question, sure that makes sense, that question, to sure that makes sense, that question, to be sure that makes sense, that question, to be honest. sure that makes sense, that question, to be honest. But, sure that makes sense, that question, to be honest. But, yes, question, to be honest. But, yes, they question, to be honest. But, yes, they factor question, to be honest. But, yes, they factor in question, to be honest. But, yes, they factor in all question, to be honest. But, yes, they factor in all pressures, they factor in all pressures, demographic, they factor in all pressures, demographic, population they factor in all pressures, demographic, population and demographic, population and incourse, demographic, population and incourse, inflation. demographic, population and incourse, inflation. Why demographic, population and incourse, inflation. Why does demographic, population and incourse, inflation. Why does he demographic, population and incourse, inflation. Why does he not demographic, population and demographic, demographic, population and use the same demographic, population and use the same measure? demographic, population and use the same measure? I'm demographic, population and use the same measure? I'm pretty use the same measure? I'm pretty sure use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I do. use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I do. What use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I do. What does use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I do. What does he use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I do. What does he say use the same measure? I'm pretty sure I do. What does he say to sure I do. What does he say to Sharon sure I do. What does he say to Sharon wards, sure I do. What does he say to Sharon wards, a sure I do. What does he say to Sharon wards, a hospital sure I do. What does he say to Sharon wards, a hospital manager, Sharon wards, a hospital manager, who Sharon wards, a hospital manager, who pleaded Sharon wards, a hospital manager, who pleaded last Sharon wards, a hospital manager, who pleaded last week Sharon wards, a hospital manager, who pleaded last week to Sharon wards, a hospital manager, who pleaded last week to MidCentral who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB not who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB not to who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB not to make who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB not to make further who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB not to make further cuts who pleaded last week to MidCentral DHB not to make further cuts saying, DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer has DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer has not DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer has not stopped, DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer has not stopped, has DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer has not stopped, has it? DHB not to make further cuts saying, "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have been "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have been asked "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have been asked to "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have been asked to live "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have been asked to live within "Cancer has not stopped, has it? We have been asked to live within our have been asked to live within our means. have been asked to live within our means. Don't have been asked to live within our means. Don't chip have been asked to live within our means. Don't chip away have been asked to live within our means. Don't chip away at have been asked to live within our means. Don't chip away at our means. Don't chip away at our means." means. Don't chip away at our means." ? means. Don't chip away at our means." ? What means. Don't chip away at our means." ? What I means. Don't chip away at our means." ? What I would means. Don't chip away at our means." ? What I would say means. Don't chip away at our means." ? What I would say is means. Don't chip away at our means." ? What I would say is that means." ? What I would say is that in means." ? What I would say is that in this means." ? What I would say is that in this Budget, means." ? What I would say is that in this Budget, MidCentral's means." ? What I would say is that in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up by in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up by $19 in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up by $19 million. in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up by $19 million. It in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up by $19 million. It has in this Budget, MidCentral's Budget went up by $19 million. It has gone went up by $19 million. It has gone up went up by $19 million. It has gone up by went up by $19 million. It has gone up by $158 went up by $19 million. It has gone up by $158 million went up by $19 million. It has gone up by $158 million over went up by $19 million. It has gone up by $158 million over the went up by $19 million. It has gone up by $158 million over the last up by $158 million over the last nine up by $158 million over the last nine Budgets up by $158 million over the last nine Budgets and up by $158 million over the last nine Budgets and the up by $158 million over the last nine Budgets and the member up by $158 million over the last nine Budgets and the member is nine Budgets and the member is completely nine Budgets and the member is completely incorrect, nine Budgets and the member is completely incorrect, and, nine Budgets and the member is completely incorrect, and, in nine Budgets and the member is completely incorrect, and, in fact, completely incorrect, and, in fact, misleading completely incorrect, and, in fact, misleading to completely incorrect, and, in fact, misleading to say completely incorrect, and, in fact, misleading to say that completely incorrect, and, in fact, misleading to say that services completely incorrect, and, in fact, misleading to say that services and misleading to say that services and Budgets misleading to say that services and Budgets have misleading to say that services and Budgets have been misleading to say that services and Budgets have been cut misleading to say that services and Budgets have been cut because misleading to say that services and Budgets have been cut because they Budgets have been cut because they haven't, Budgets have been cut because they haven't, they've Budgets have been cut because they haven't, they've been Budgets have been cut because they haven't, they've been increased. Budgets have been cut because they haven't, they've been increased. Why haven't, they've been increased. Why have haven't, they've been increased. Why have services haven't, they've been increased. Why have services been haven't, they've been increased. Why have services been cut haven't, they've been increased. Why have services been cut at haven't, they've been increased. Why have services been cut at that haven't, they've been increased. Why have services been cut at that DHB? have services been cut at that DHB? Services have services been cut at that DHB? Services have have services been cut at that DHB? Services have not have services been cut at that DHB? Services have not been have services been cut at that DHB? Services have not been cut have services been cut at that DHB? Services have not been cut at have services been cut at that DHB? Services have not been cut at that Services have not been cut at that DHB. Services have not been cut at that DHB. Why Services have not been cut at that DHB. Why in Services have not been cut at that DHB. Why in contrast Services have not been cut at that DHB. Why in contrast to Services have not been cut at that DHB. Why in contrast to the Services have not been cut at that DHB. Why in contrast to the advice DHB. Why in contrast to the advice he DHB. Why in contrast to the advice he has DHB. Why in contrast to the advice he has received DHB. Why in contrast to the advice he has received from DHB. Why in contrast to the advice he has received from his DHB. Why in contrast to the advice he has received from his officials, he has received from his officials, does he has received from his officials, does he he has received from his officials, does he insist he has received from his officials, does he insist on he has received from his officials, does he insist on tweeting he has received from his officials, does he insist on tweeting about does he insist on tweeting about population does he insist on tweeting about population growth does he insist on tweeting about population growth rather does he insist on tweeting about population growth rather than population growth rather than demographic population growth rather than demographic growth population growth rather than demographic growth in population growth rather than demographic growth in reference population growth rather than demographic growth in reference to demographic growth in reference to demographic growth in reference to demographic growth in reference to the inadequate demographic growth in reference to the inadequate funding demographic growth in reference to the inadequate funding for demographic growth in reference to the inadequate funding for Vote the inadequate funding for Vote Health the inadequate funding for Vote Health and the inadequate funding for Vote Health and doesn't the inadequate funding for Vote Health and doesn't he the inadequate funding for Vote Health and doesn't he just the inadequate funding for Vote Health and doesn't he just mean Health and doesn't he just mean cough Health and doesn't he just mean cough McVie Health and doesn't he just mean cough McVie -- Health and doesn't he just mean cough McVie -- Cofveve? Health and doesn't he just mean cough McVie -- Cofveve? The Health and doesn't he just mean cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not inadequate. cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not inadequate. It cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not inadequate. It has cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not inadequate. It has gone cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not inadequate. It has gone up cough McVie -- Cofveve? The funding is not inadequate. It has gone up by is not inadequate. It has gone up by $888 is not inadequate. It has gone up by $888 million, is not inadequate. It has gone up by $888 million, $5 is not inadequate. It has gone up by $888 million, $5 billion is not inadequate. It has gone up by $888 million, $5 billion over is not inadequate. It has gone up by $888 million, $5 billion over the $888 million, $5 billion over the course $888 million, $5 billion over the course of $888 million, $5 billion over the course of this $888 million, $5 billion over the course of this Government. $888 million, $5 billion over the course of this Government. So $888 million, $5 billion over the course of this Government. So it $888 million, $5 billion over the course of this Government. So it has course of this Government. So it has gone course of this Government. So it has gone well course of this Government. So it has gone well ahead course of this Government. So it has gone well ahead and course of this Government. So it has gone well ahead and we course of this Government. So it has gone well ahead and we fully course of this Government. So it has gone well ahead and we fully funded gone well ahead and we fully funded population gone well ahead and we fully funded population growth gone well ahead and we fully funded population growth and gone well ahead and we fully funded population growth and inflation. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he still My question is to the Prime Minister: Does he still have Minister: Does he still have confidence Minister: Does he still have confidence in Minister: Does he still have confidence in all Minister: Does he still have confidence in all his Minister: Does he still have confidence in all his Ministers; Minister: Does he still have confidence in all his Ministers; if confidence in all his Ministers; if so, confidence in all his Ministers; if so, why? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the PM, On behalf of the PM, yes, On behalf of the PM, yes, because On behalf of the PM, yes, because they On behalf of the PM, yes, because they are On behalf of the PM, yes, because they are competent On behalf of the PM, yes, because they are competent and On behalf of the PM, yes, because they are competent and hard On behalf of the PM, yes, because they are competent and hard working they are competent and hard working and they are competent and hard working and especially they are competent and hard working and especially my they are competent and hard working and especially my deputy. they are competent and hard working and especially my deputy. Who's and especially my deputy. Who's that? and especially my deputy. Who's that? Supplement and especially my deputy. Who's that? Supplement question, and especially my deputy. Who's that? Supplement question, I that? Supplement question, I think. that? Supplement question, I that? Supplement question, I think. Can't with that? Supplement question, I think. Can't with you. that? Supplement question, I think. Can't with you. The that? Supplement question, I think. Can't with you. The Rt that? Supplement question, I think. Can't with you. The Rt Hon that? Supplement question, I think. Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Does Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Does he Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Does he agree Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Does he agree with Can't with you. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Does he agree with the Peters. Does he agree with the Cabinet Peters. Does he agree with the Cabinet manual Peters. Does he agree with the Cabinet manual that Peters. Does he agree with the Cabinet manual that ministers Cabinet manual that ministers should, Cabinet manual that ministers should, "Not Cabinet manual that ministers should, "Not inappropriately should, "Not inappropriately influence should, "Not inappropriately influence officials should, "Not inappropriately influence officials or should, "Not inappropriately influence officials or involve influence officials or involve themselves influence officials or involve themselves in influence officials or involve themselves in matters influence officials or involve themselves in matters that influence officials or involve themselves in matters that are influence officials or involve themselves in matters that are not themselves in matters that are not their themselves in matters that are not their responsibility." themselves in matters that are not their responsibility." If themselves in matters that are not their responsibility." If so, themselves in matters that are not their responsibility." If so, what their responsibility." If so, what would their responsibility." If so, what would he their responsibility." If so, what would he do their responsibility." If so, what would he do if their responsibility." If so, what would he do if a their responsibility." If so, what would he do if a minister their responsibility." If so, what would he do if a minister did their responsibility." If so, what would he do if a minister did just would he do if a minister did just that? would he do if a minister did just that? On would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf of would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf of the would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf of the PM, would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf of the PM, yes, would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I would he do if a minister did just that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do agree that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do that? that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do agree with the that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do agree with the Cabinet that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do agree with the Cabinet Manual. that? On behalf of the PM, yes, I do agree with the Cabinet Manual. If agree with the Cabinet Manual. If the agree with the Cabinet Manual. If the new agree with the Cabinet Manual. If the new standard agree with the Cabinet Manual. If the new standard of agree with the Cabinet Manual. If the new standard of Government the new standard of Government includes the new standard of Government includes being the new standard of Government includes being more the new standard of Government includes being more transparent the new standard of Government includes being more transparent and includes being more transparent and accountable, includes being more transparent and accountable, does includes being more transparent and accountable, does that includes being more transparent and accountable, does that include accountable, does that include accountable, does that include accountable, does that include ministers not accountable, does that include ministers not intervening accountable, does that include ministers not intervening in ministers not intervening in organisational ministers not intervening in organisational and ministers not intervening in organisational and administrative organisational and administrative decisions organisational and administrative decisions that organisational and administrative decisions that are organisational and administrative decisions that are not organisational and administrative decisions that are not their decisions that are not their responsibility? decisions that are not their responsibility? It decisions that are not their responsibility? It is decisions that are not their responsibility? It is a decisions that are not their responsibility? It is a close responsibility? It is a close relationship responsibility? It is a close relationship with responsibility? It is a close relationship with ministers responsibility? It is a close relationship with ministers and relationship with ministers and their relationship with ministers and their departments. relationship with ministers and their departments. I'd relationship with ministers and their departments. I'd expect relationship with ministers and their departments. I'd expect that relationship with ministers and their departments. I'd expect that a relationship with ministers and responsibility? relationship with ministers and chief executive runs relationship with ministers and chief executive runs their chief executive runs their chief executive runs their chief executive runs their departments and chief executive runs their departments and ministers chief executive runs their departments and ministers and chief executive runs their departments and ministers and such departments and ministers and such departments and ministers and such departments and ministers and such are providing departments and ministers and such are providing vision departments and ministers and such are providing vision and departments and ministers and such are providing vision and giving departments and ministers and such are providing vision and giving the are providing vision and giving the policy are providing vision and giving the policy direction are providing vision and giving the policy direction but are providing vision and giving the policy direction but as are providing vision and giving the policy direction but as it are providing vision and giving the policy direction but as it is are providing vision and giving the policy direction but as it is a are providing vision and giving the policy direction but as it is a very policy direction but as it is a very close policy direction but as it is a very close relationship, policy direction but as it is a very close relationship, there policy direction but as it is a very close relationship, there are policy direction but as it is a very close relationship, there are times close relationship, there are times when close relationship, there are times when I'm close relationship, there are times when I'm sure close relationship, there are times when I'm sure it close relationship, there are times when I'm sure it gets close relationship, there are times when I'm sure it gets close. close relationship, there are times when I'm sure it gets close. If close relationship, there are times when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if an when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if an SOE's when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if an SOE's legal when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if an SOE's legal team when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if an SOE's legal team has when I'm sure it gets close. If SOEs - if an SOE's legal team has advise - if an SOE's legal team has advise administer - if an SOE's legal team has advise administer that - if an SOE's legal team has advise administer that they - if an SOE's legal team has advise administer that they would, administer that they would, "Struggle administer that they would, "Struggle to administer that they would, "Struggle to justify administer that they would, "Struggle to justify non-release administer that they would, "Struggle to justify non-release of "Struggle to justify non-release of "Struggle to justify non-release of "Struggle to justify non-release of information", does "Struggle to justify non-release of information", does she "Struggle to justify non-release of information", does she think "Struggle to justify non-release of information", does she think it "Struggle to justify non-release of information", does she think it is information", does she think it is appropriate information", does she think it is appropriate for information", does she think it is appropriate for a information", does she think it is appropriate for a minister information", does she think it is appropriate for a minister to information", does she think it is appropriate for a minister to email appropriate for a minister to email a appropriate for a minister to email a general appropriate for a minister to email a general manager appropriate for a minister to email a general manager opposing appropriate for a minister to email a general manager opposing the a general manager opposing the organisations a general manager opposing the organisations decision a general manager opposing the organisations decision to a general manager opposing the organisations decision to release organisations decision to release organisations decision to release organisations decision to release information? On organisations decision to release information? On behalf organisations decision to release information? On behalf of organisations decision to release information? On behalf of the organisations decision to release information? On behalf of the PM, organisations decision to release information? On behalf of the PM, I information? On behalf of the PM, I would information? On behalf of the PM, I would have information? On behalf of the PM, I would have to information? On behalf of the PM, I would have to see information? On behalf of the PM, I would have to see the information? On behalf of the PM, I would have to see the details information? On behalf of the PM, I would have to see the details of would have to see the details of would have to see the details of would have to see the details of that to would have to see the details of that to make would have to see the details of that to make any would have to see the details of that to make any judgement. would have to see the details of that to make any judgement. Point would have to see the details of that to make any judgement. Point of that to make any judgement. Point of that to make any judgement. Point of that to make any judgement. Point of order. I that to make any judgement. Point of order. I seek that to make any judgement. Point of order. I seek leave that to make any judgement. Point of order. I seek leave to that to make any judgement. Point of order. I seek leave to table that to make any judgement. Point of order. I seek leave to table a order. I seek leave to table a summary order. I seek leave to table a summary of order. I seek leave to table a summary of emails order. I seek leave to table a summary of emails from order. I seek leave to table a summary of emails from the order. I seek leave to table a summary of emails from the Minister summary of emails from the Minister of summary of emails from the Minister of Transport's summary of emails from the Minister of Transport's office summary of emails from the Minister of Transport's office challenging of Transport's office challenging KiwiRail's of Transport's office challenging KiwiRail's decision of Transport's office challenging KiwiRail's decision to of Transport's office challenging KiwiRail's decision to release KiwiRail's decision to release information. KiwiRail's decision to release information. Leave KiwiRail's decision to release information. Leave is KiwiRail's decision to release information. Leave is sought KiwiRail's decision to release information. Leave is sought to information. Leave is sought to table information. Leave is sought to table that information. Leave is sought to table that series information. Leave is sought to table that series of information. Leave is sought to table that series of emails, information. Leave is sought to table that series of emails, is table that series of emails, is there table that series of emails, is there any table that series of emails, is there any objection table that series of emails, is there any objection to table that series of emails, is there any objection to it table that series of emails, is there any objection to it being there any objection to it being there any objection to it being there any objection to it being tabled? There there any objection to it being tabled? There is there any objection to it being tabled? There is not. there any objection to it being tabled? There is not. It there any objection to it being tabled? There is not. It can there any objection to it being tabled? There is not. It can be tabled? There is not. It can be tabled. tabled? There is not. It can be tabled. What tabled? There is not. It can be tabled. What on tabled? There is not. It can be tabled. What on earth tabled? There is not. It can be tabled. What on earth was tabled? There is not. It can be tabled. What on earth was his tabled. What on earth was his Transport tabled. What on earth was his Transport Minister tabled. What on earth was his Transport Minister trying tabled. What on earth was his Transport Minister trying to tabled. What on earth was his Transport Minister trying to achieve Transport Minister trying to achieve when Transport Minister trying to achieve when his Transport Minister trying to achieve when his office Transport Minister trying to achieve when his office emailed Transport Minister trying to achieve when his office emailed a Transport Minister trying to achieve when his office emailed a general when his office emailed a general manager when his office emailed a general manager of when his office emailed a general manager of KiwiRail when his office emailed a general manager of KiwiRail trying when his office emailed a general manager of KiwiRail trying to when his office emailed a general manager of KiwiRail trying to step manager of KiwiRail trying to step in manager of KiwiRail trying to step in and manager of KiwiRail trying to step in and prevent manager of KiwiRail trying to step in and prevent the manager of KiwiRail trying to step in and prevent the official in and prevent the official correspondence in and prevent the official correspondence unit in and prevent the official correspondence unit from in and prevent the official correspondence unit from releasing correspondence unit from releasing correspondence unit from releasing correspondence unit from releasing information? I'd correspondence unit from releasing information? I'd have correspondence unit from releasing information? I'd have to correspondence unit from releasing information? I'd have to see correspondence unit from releasing information? I'd have to see details information? I'd have to see details but information? I'd have to see details but it information? I'd have to see details but it sounds information? I'd have to see details but it sounds to information? I'd have to see details but it sounds to me information? I'd have to see details but it sounds to me like information? I'd have to see details but it sounds to me like the but it sounds to me like the minister but it sounds to me like the minister is but it sounds to me like the minister is doing but it sounds to me like the minister is doing their but it sounds to me like the minister is doing their job but it sounds to me like the minister is doing their job and but it sounds to me like the minister is doing their job and you minister is doing their job and you have minister is doing their job and you have some minister is doing their job and you have some email minister is doing their job and you have some email from minister is doing their job and you have some email from an minister is doing their job and you have some email from an official have some email from an official that have some email from an official that might have some email from an official that might be have some email from an official that might be doing have some email from an official that might be doing something have some email from an official that might be doing something else. that might be doing something else. We'd that might be doing something else. We'd have that might be doing something else. We'd have to that might be doing something else. We'd have to have that might be doing something else. We'd have to have a that might be doing something else. We'd have to have a look that might be doing something else. We'd have to have a look at that might be doing something else. We'd have to have a look at it that might be doing something else. We'd have to have a look at it to We'd have to have a look at it to We'd have to have a look at it to We'd have to have a look at it to see if We'd have to have a look at it to see if there We'd have to have a look at it to see if there is We'd have to have a look at it to see if there is anything We'd have to have a look at it to see if there is anything in We'd have to have a look at it to see if there is anything in it. We'd have to have a look at it to see if there is anything in it. If see if there is anything in it. If see if there is anything in it. If see if there is anything in it. If the first see if there is anything in it. If the first answer see if there is anything in it. If the first answer to see if there is anything in it. If the first answer to the see if there is anything in it. If the first answer to the first the first answer to the first question the first answer to the first question was the first answer to the first question was that the first answer to the first question was that there the first answer to the first question was that there was the first answer to the first question was that there was respect question was that there was respect for question was that there was respect for the question was that there was respect for the Cabinet question was that there was respect for the Cabinet Manual, question was that there was respect for the Cabinet Manual, and question was that there was respect for the Cabinet Manual, and if question was that there was respect for the Cabinet Manual, and if he for the Cabinet Manual, and if he has for the Cabinet Manual, and if he has said for the Cabinet Manual, and if he has said that for the Cabinet Manual, and if he has said that Alfred for the Cabinet Manual, and if he has said that Alfred Ngaro's has said that Alfred Ngaro's comments has said that Alfred Ngaro's comments were has said that Alfred Ngaro's comments were "naive" has said that Alfred Ngaro's comments were "naive" and has said that Alfred Ngaro's comments were "naive" and Steven comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce claims comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce claims "it's comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce claims "it's not comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce claims "it's not the comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce claims "it's not the way comments were "naive" and Steven Joyce claims "it's not the way we Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", then Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", then what Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", then what on Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", then what on earth Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", then what on earth does Joyce claims "it's not the way we operate", then what on earth does he operate", then what on earth does he have operate", then what on earth does he have to operate", then what on earth does he have to say operate", then what on earth does he have to say about operate", then what on earth does he have to say about Simon operate", then what on earth does he have to say about Simon Bridges' have to say about Simon Bridges' office have to say about Simon Bridges' office deliberately have to say about Simon Bridges' office deliberately trying have to say about Simon Bridges' office deliberately trying to office deliberately trying to influence office deliberately trying to influence officials office deliberately trying to influence officials behind office deliberately trying to influence officials behind closed influence officials behind closed doors, influence officials behind closed doors, covertly influence officials behind closed doors, covertly and influence officials behind closed doors, covertly and secretly influence officials behind closed doors, covertly and secretly not influence officials behind closed doors, covertly and secretly not to doors, covertly and secretly not to doors, covertly and secretly not to doors, covertly and secretly not to release information doors, covertly and secretly not to release information that doors, covertly and secretly not to release information that is doors, covertly and secretly not to release information that is owed doors, covertly and secretly not to release information that is owed to release information that is owed to the release information that is owed to the public release information that is owed to the public of release information that is owed to the public of this release information that is owed to the public of this country? release information that is owed to the public of this country? On the public of this country? On behalf the public of this country? On behalf of the public of this country? On behalf of the the public of this country? On behalf of the PM, the public of this country? On behalf of the PM, I the public of this country? On behalf of the PM, I really the public of this country? On behalf of the PM, I really would behalf of the PM, I really would have behalf of the PM, I really would have to behalf of the PM, I really would have to see behalf of the PM, I really would have to see the behalf of the PM, I really would have to see the details. behalf of the PM, I really would have to see the details. The have to see the details. The member's have to see the details. The member's been have to see the details. The member's been around have to see the details. The member's been around for a have to see the details. The member's been around for a long member's been around for a long time, member's been around for a long time, made member's been around for a long time, made a member's been around for a long time, made a lot of member's been around for a long time, made a lot of allegations member's been around for a long time, made a lot of allegations over time, made a lot of allegations over a time, made a lot of allegations over a lot time, made a lot of allegations over a lot of time, made a lot of allegations over a lot of years time, made a lot of allegations over a lot of years and time, made a lot of allegations over a lot of years and most time, made a lot of allegations over a lot of years and most of time, made a lot of allegations over a lot of years and most of them a lot of years and most of them actually a lot of years and most of them actually haven't a lot of years and most of them actually haven't stacked a lot of years and most of them actually haven't stacked up a lot of years and most of them actually haven't stacked up so a lot of years and most of them actually haven't stacked up so I'd actually haven't stacked up so I'd be actually haven't stacked up so I'd be surprised actually haven't stacked up so I'd be surprised in actually haven't stacked up so I'd be surprised in this actually haven't stacked up so I'd be surprised in this one actually haven't stacked up so I'd be surprised in this one does. actually haven't stacked up so I'd be surprised in this one does. Point be surprised in this one does. Point be be surprised in this one does. Point of order. Order! be surprised in this one does. Point of order. Order! Point be surprised in this one does. Point of order. Order! Point of be surprised in this one does. Point of order. Order! Point of order. be surprised in this one does. Point of order. Order! Point of order. I'm of order. Order! Point of order. I'm asking of order. Order! Point of order. I'm asking the of order. Order! Point of order. I'm asking the minister of order. Order! Point of order. I'm asking the minister for of order. Order! Point of order. I'm asking the minister for a of order. Order! Point of order. I'm asking the minister for a reply asking the minister for a reply given asking the minister for a reply given the asking the minister for a reply given the Cabinet asking the minister for a reply given the Cabinet Manual asking the minister for a reply given the Cabinet Manual provisions given the Cabinet Manual provisions given the Cabinet Manual provisions given the Cabinet Manual provisions which she given the Cabinet Manual provisions which she says given the Cabinet Manual provisions which she says she given the Cabinet Manual provisions which she says she understands. given the Cabinet Manual provisions which she says she understands. I which she says she understands. I have which she says she understands. I have listened which she says she understands. I have listened to which she says she understands. I have listened to the which she says she understands. I have listened to the question, which she says she understands. I have listened to the question, it have listened to the question, it was have listened to the question, it was a have listened to the question, it was a very have listened to the question, it was a very long have listened to the question, it was a very long question, have listened to the question, it was a very long question, I've was a very long question, I've listened was a very long question, I've listened to was a very long question, I've listened to the was a very long question, I've listened to the answer. was a very long question, I've listened to the answer. The was a very long question, I've listened to the answer. The question listened to the answer. The question has listened to the answer. The question has been listened to the answer. The question has been addressed. listened to the answer. The question has been addressed. I listened to the answer. The question has been addressed. I beg listened to the answer. The question has been addressed. I beg your has been addressed. I beg your pardon? has been addressed. I beg your pardon? Could has been addressed. I beg your pardon? Could you has been addressed. I beg your pardon? Could you clarify has been addressed. I beg your pardon? Could you clarify for has been addressed. I beg your pardon? Could you clarify for me pardon? Could you clarify for me what pardon? Could you clarify for me what you pardon? Could you clarify for me what you meant pardon? Could you clarify for me what you meant when pardon? Could you clarify for me what you meant when you pardon? Could you clarify for me what you meant when you said pardon? Could you clarify for me what you meant when you said that? pardon? Could you clarify for me what you meant when you said that? I what you meant when you said that? I said what you meant when you said that? I said the what you meant when you said that? I said the question what you meant when you said that? I said the question has what you meant when you said that? I said the question has been said the question has been addressed. said the question has been addressed. Point said the question has been addressed. Point of said the question has been addressed. Point of order. said the question has been addressed. Point of order. I said the question has been addressed. Point of order. I raised addressed. Point of order. I raised a addressed. Point of order. I raised a point addressed. Point of order. I raised a point of addressed. Point of order. I raised a point of order addressed. Point of order. I raised a point of order on addressed. Point of order. I raised a point of order on the addressed. Point of order. I raised a point of order on the basis addressed. Point of order. I raised a point of order on the basis of a point of order on the basis of some a point of order on the basis of some clarity a point of order on the basis of some clarity around a point of order on the basis of some clarity around the a point of order on the basis of some clarity around the Cabinet some clarity around the Cabinet Manual some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and the some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and the answer some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and the answer she some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and the answer she gave some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and the answer she gave was some clarity around the Cabinet Manual and the answer she gave was a Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal attack Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal attack upon Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal attack upon me Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal attack upon me but Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal attack upon me but not Manual and the answer she gave was a verbal attack upon me but not the verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet Manual. verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet Manual. Go verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet Manual. Go back verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet Manual. Go back and verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet Manual. Go back and look verbal attack upon me but not the Cabinet Manual. Go back and look at Cabinet Manual. Go back and look at the Cabinet Manual. Go back and look at the question. Cabinet Manual. Go back and look at the question. The Cabinet Manual. Go back and look at the question. The question Cabinet Manual. Go back and look at the question. The question was the question. The question was the question. The question was the question. The question was hardly in the question. The question was hardly in order the question. The question was hardly in order when the question. The question was hardly in order when I the question. The question was hardly in order when I look the question. The question was hardly in order when I look at hardly in order when I look at Standing hardly in order when I look at Standing Order hardly in order when I look at Standing Order 380. hardly in order when I look at Standing Order 380. I hardly in order when I look at Standing Order 380. I was hardly in order when I look at Standing Order 380. I was very Standing Order 380. I was very generous Standing Order 380. I was very generous to Standing Order 380. I was very generous to the Standing Order 380. I was very generous to the member Standing Order 380. I was very generous to the member in Standing Order 380. I was very generous to the member in letting Standing Order 380. I was very generous to the member in letting it generous to the member in letting it stand generous to the member in letting it stand and generous to the member in letting it stand and I generous to the member in letting it stand and I have generous to the member in letting it stand and I have said generous to the member in letting it stand and I have said now generous to the member in letting it stand and I have said now on generous to the member in letting it stand and I have said now on two stand and I have said now on two occasions, stand and I have said now on two occasions, and stand and I have said now on two occasions, and I stand and I have said now on two occasions, and I don't stand and I have said now on two occasions, and I don't intend stand and I have said now on two occasions, and I don't intend to occasions, and I don't intend to have occasions, and I don't intend to have to occasions, and I don't intend to have to repeat occasions, and I don't intend to have to repeat it, occasions, and I don't intend to have to repeat it, the occasions, and I don't intend to have to repeat it, the question occasions, and I don't intend to have to repeat it, the question has have to repeat it, the question has been have to repeat it, the question has been addressed. have to repeat it, the question has been addressed. Point have to repeat it, the question has been addressed. Point of have to repeat it, the question has been addressed. Point of order. have to repeat it, the question has been addressed. Point of order. If been addressed. Point of order. If it been addressed. Point of order. If it is been addressed. Point of order. If it is a been addressed. Point of order. If it is a fresh been addressed. Point of order. If it is a fresh point been addressed. Point of order. If it is a fresh point of been addressed. Point of order. If it is a fresh point of order been addressed. Point of order. If it is a fresh point of order if it is a fresh point of order if not... it is a fresh point of order if not... It it is a fresh point of order if not... It is it is a fresh point of order if not... It is a it is a fresh point of order if not... It is a fresh it is a fresh point of order if not... It is a fresh point it is a fresh point of order if not... It is a fresh point of it is a fresh point of order if not... It is a fresh point of order. not... It is a fresh point of order. New not... It is a fresh point of order. New Zealand not... It is a fresh point of order. New Zealand First not... It is a fresh point of order. New Zealand First does not... It is a fresh point of order. New Zealand First does not not... It is a fresh point of order. New Zealand First does not expect New Zealand First does not expect any New Zealand First does not expect any special New Zealand First does not expect any special conditions New Zealand First does not expect any special conditions in New Zealand First does not expect any special conditions in respect New Zealand First does not expect any special conditions in respect to any special conditions in respect to any special conditions in respect to any special conditions in respect to questions. If any special conditions in respect to questions. If the any special conditions in respect to questions. If the question any special conditions in respect to questions. If the question was any special conditions in respect to questions. If the question was not questions. If the question was not in questions. If the question was not in order, questions. If the question was not in order, why questions. If the question was not in order, why didn't questions. If the question was not in order, why didn't you questions. If the question was not in order, why didn't you say questions. If the question was not in order, why didn't you say so? in order, why didn't you say so? Because in order, why didn't you say so? Because I'd in order, why didn't you say so? Because I'd be in order, why didn't you say so? Because I'd be ruling in order, why didn't you say so? Because I'd be ruling out in order, why didn't you say so? Because I'd be ruling out just in order, why didn't you say so? Because I'd be ruling out just about Because I'd be ruling out just about Because I'd be ruling out just about Because I'd be ruling out just about every supplement Because I'd be ruling out just about every supplement question Because I'd be ruling out just about every supplement question the Because I'd be ruling out just about every supplement question the member every supplement question the member ever every supplement question the member ever asked. every supplement question the member ever asked. Point every supplement question the member ever asked. Point of every supplement question the member ever asked. Point of order, every supplement question the member ever asked. Point of order, speaker. ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a bint ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a bint of ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a bint of order ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a bint of order and ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a bint of order and it ever asked. Point of order, speaker. This is a bint of order and it will This is a bint of order and it will be This is a bint of order and it will be heard This is a bint of order and it will be heard in This is a bint of order and it will be heard in -- This is a bint of order and it will be heard in -- point This is a bint of order and it will be heard in -- point of This is a bint of order and it will be heard in -- point of order This is a bint of order and it will be heard in -- point of order and This is a bint of order and it will be heard in -- point of order and it be heard in -- point of order and it will be heard in -- point of order and it will be be heard in -- point of order and it will be heard be heard in -- point of order and it will be heard in be heard in -- point of order and it will be heard in silence. be heard in -- point of order and it will be heard in silence. What will be heard in silence. What degree will be heard in silence. What degree of will be heard in silence. What degree of order will be heard in silence. What degree of order do will be heard in silence. What degree of order do you will be heard in silence. What degree of order do you expect will be heard in silence. What degree of order do you expect to degree of order do you expect to maintain degree of order do you expect to maintain in degree of order do you expect to maintain in the degree of order do you expect to maintain in the House degree of order do you expect to maintain in the House when degree of order do you expect to maintain in the House when you, degree of order do you expect to maintain in the House when you, of maintain in the House when you, of all maintain in the House when you, of all people, maintain in the House when you, of all people, given maintain in the House when you, of all people, given your maintain in the House when you, of all people, given your background, all people, given your background, all people, given your background, all people, given your background, make a all people, given your background, make a statement all people, given your background, make a statement like all people, given your background, make a statement like that? make a statement like that? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Over <INTERRUPTION> Order! Over time <INTERRUPTION> Order! Over time the <INTERRUPTION> Order! Over time the breadth <INTERRUPTION> Order! Over time the breadth of Order! Over time the breadth of questions, Order! Over time the breadth of questions, the Order! Over time the breadth of questions, the amount Order! Over time the breadth of questions, the amount of Order! Over time the breadth of questions, the amount of additional questions, the amount of additional questions, the amount of additional questions, the amount of additional wording that questions, the amount of additional wording that is questions, the amount of additional wording that is put questions, the amount of additional wording that is put into wording that is put into questions wording that is put into wording that is put into questions has expanded. wording that is put into questions has expanded. It wording that is put into questions has expanded. It is wording that is put into questions has expanded. It is over wording that is put into questions has expanded. It is over to wording that is put into questions has expanded. It is over to me has expanded. It is over to me whether has expanded. It is over to me whether I has expanded. It is over to me whether I allow has expanded. It is over to me whether I allow it has expanded. It is over to me whether I allow it to has expanded. It is over to me whether I allow it to happen has expanded. It is over to me whether I allow it to happen and has expanded. It is over to me whether I allow it to happen and I whether I allow it to happen and I have whether I allow it to happen and I have been whether I allow it to happen and I have been relatively whether I allow it to happen and I have been relatively generous whether I allow it to happen and I have been relatively generous not have been relatively generous not only have been relatively generous not only with have been relatively generous not only with the have been relatively generous not only with the member have been relatively generous not only with the member but have been relatively generous not only with the member but with have been relatively generous not only with the member but with all only with the member but with all members, only with the member but with all members, accepting only with the member but with all members, accepting this only with the member but with all members, accepting this is only with the member but with all members, accepting this is a members, accepting this is a debating members, accepting this is a debating Chamber members, accepting this is a debating Chamber where members, accepting this is a debating Chamber where politics members, accepting this is a debating Chamber where politics will debating Chamber where politics will play debating Chamber where politics will play its debating Chamber where politics will play its part. debating Chamber where politics will play its part. The debating Chamber where politics will play its part. The essence debating Chamber where politics will play its part. The essence of debating Chamber where politics will play its part. The essence of the play its part. The essence of the member's play its part. The essence of the member's point play its part. The essence of the member's point of play its part. The essence of the member's point of order play its part. The essence of the member's point of order is play its part. The essence of the member's point of order is was play its part. The essence of the member's point of order is was his member's point of order is was his question member's point of order is was his question satisfactorily member's point of order is was his question satisfactorily addressed. question satisfactorily addressed. The question satisfactorily addressed. The member question satisfactorily addressed. The member obviously question satisfactorily addressed. The member obviously doesn't question satisfactorily addressed. The member obviously doesn't think The member obviously doesn't think it The member obviously doesn't think it was. The member obviously doesn't think it was. I The member obviously doesn't think it was. I am The member obviously doesn't think it was. I am not surprised The member obviously doesn't think it was. I am not surprised by The member obviously doesn't think it was. I am not surprised by that it was. I am not surprised by that but it was. I am not surprised by that but it it was. I am not surprised by that but it is it was. I am not surprised by that but it is my it was. I am not surprised by that but it is my decision it was. I am not surprised by that but it is my decision that it was. I am not surprised by that but it is my decision that it it was. I am not surprised by that but it is my decision that it was. but it is my decision that it was. We but it is my decision that it was. We now but it is my decision that it was. We now move but it is my decision that it was. We now move to but it is my decision that it was. We now move to Question but it is my decision that it was. We now move to Question No. but it is my decision that it was. We now move to Question No. 12. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Disability My question is to the Minister for Disability Issues: My question is to the Minister for Disability Issues: What My question is to the Minister for Disability Issues: What recent Disability Issues: What recent Budget Disability Issues: What recent Budget announcements Disability Issues: What recent Budget announcements has Disability Issues: What recent Budget announcements has the Budget announcements has the Government Budget announcements has the Government made Budget announcements has the Government made regarding Budget announcements has the Government made regarding investment Government made regarding investment into Government made regarding investment into disability Government made regarding investment into disability support Government made regarding investment into disability support services? Budget Budget 2017 Budget 2017 will Budget 2017 will invest Budget 2017 will invest an Budget 2017 will invest an extra Budget 2017 will invest an extra $205.4 Budget 2017 will invest an extra $205.4 million Budget 2017 will invest an extra $205.4 million over Budget 2017 will invest an extra $205.4 million over four Budget 2017 will invest an extra $205.4 million over four years Budget 2017 will invest an extra $205.4 million over four years to $205.4 million over four years to maintain $205.4 million over four years to maintain and $205.4 million over four years to maintain and improve $205.4 million over four years to maintain and improve disability maintain and improve disability support maintain and improve disability support services, maintain and improve disability support services, taking maintain and improve disability support services, taking the maintain and improve disability support services, taking the fotal support services, taking the fotal funding support services, taking the fotal funding to support services, taking the fotal funding to $1.2 support services, taking the fotal funding to $1.2 billion support services, taking the fotal funding to $1.2 billion for support services, taking the fotal funding to $1.2 billion for the funding to $1.2 billion for the year, funding to $1.2 billion for the year, 2017/18. funding to $1.2 billion for the year, 2017/18. This funding to $1.2 billion for the year, 2017/18. This covers year, 2017/18. This covers community-based year, 2017/18. This covers community-based home year, 2017/18. This covers community-based home support, community-based home support, personal community-based home support, personal care, community-based home support, personal care, caregiver community-based home support, personal care, caregiver support community-based home support, personal care, caregiver support and personal care, caregiver support and residential personal care, caregiver support and residential care personal care, caregiver support and residential care as personal care, caregiver support and residential care as well personal care, caregiver support and residential care as well as residential care as well as equipment residential care as well as equipment services. residential care as well as equipment services. Around residential care as well as equipment services. Around 32,000 equipment services. Around 32,000 New equipment services. Around 32,000 New Zealanders equipment services. Around 32,000 New Zealanders and equipment services. Around 32,000 New Zealanders and their equipment services. Around 32,000 New Zealanders and their families New Zealanders and their families New Zealanders and their families New Zealanders and their families will benefit New Zealanders and their families will benefit from New Zealanders and their families will benefit from these New Zealanders and their families will benefit from these services will benefit from these services every will benefit from these services every year. will benefit from these services every year. How will benefit from these services every year. How does will benefit from these services every year. How does Budget will benefit from these services every year. How does Budget 2017 every year. How does Budget 2017 progress every year. How does Budget 2017 progress the every year. How does Budget 2017 progress the expansion every year. How does Budget 2017 progress the expansion of every year. How does Budget 2017 progress the expansion of Enabling progress the expansion of Enabling Good progress the expansion of Enabling Good Lives? progress the expansion of Enabling Good Lives? Budget progress the expansion of Enabling Good Lives? Budget 2017 progress the expansion of Enabling Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests progress the expansion of Enabling Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 million Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 million over Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 million over three Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 million over three years Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 million over three years for Good Lives? Budget 2017 invests 27.1 million over three years for the million over three years for the expansion million over three years for the expansion of million over three years for the expansion of Enabling million over three years for the expansion of Enabling Good million over three years for the expansion of Enabling Good Lives million over three years for the expansion of Enabling Good Lives in expansion of Enabling Good Lives in the expansion of Enabling Good Lives in the MidCentral expansion of Enabling Good Lives in the MidCentral region. expansion of Enabling Good Lives in the MidCentral region. Enabling expansion of Enabling Good Lives in the MidCentral region. Enabling Good the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives is the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives is based the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives is based on the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives is based on the the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives is based on the principles the MidCentral region. Enabling Good Lives is based on the principles to Lives is based on the principles to give Lives is based on the principles to give disabled Lives is based on the principles to give disabled people Lives is based on the principles to give disabled people more Lives is based on the principles to give disabled people more choice Lives is based on the principles to give disabled people more choice and give disabled people more choice and more give disabled people more choice and more control give disabled people more choice and more control over give disabled people more choice and more control over their give disabled people more choice and more control over their lives. give disabled people more choice and more control over their lives. The more control over their lives. The trials, more control over their lives. The trials, demonstrations, more control over their lives. The trials, demonstrations, have more control over their lives. The trials, demonstrations, have already trials, demonstrations, have already benefited trials, demonstrations, have already benefited hundreds trials, demonstrations, have already benefited hundreds of trials, demonstrations, have already benefited hundreds of disabled benefited hundreds of disabled people benefited hundreds of disabled people and benefited hundreds of disabled people and their benefited hundreds of disabled people and their families benefited hundreds of disabled people and their families in people and their families in Waikato people and their families in people and their families in Waikato and Christchurch. people and their families in Waikato and Christchurch. The people and their families in Waikato and Christchurch. The Government people and their families in Waikato and Christchurch. The Government is and Christchurch. The Government is working and Christchurch. The Government is working closely and Christchurch. The Government is working closely with and Christchurch. The Government is working closely with the and Christchurch. The Government is working closely with the disability working closely with the disability sector working closely with the disability sector to working closely with the disability sector to co-design working closely with the disability sector to co-design the working closely with the disability sector to co-design the Enabling sector to co-design the Enabling Good sector to co-design the Enabling Good Lives sector to co-design the Enabling Good Lives model, sector to co-design the Enabling Good Lives model, to sector to co-design the Enabling Good Lives model, to transform Good Lives model, to transform disability Good Lives model, to transform disability support Good Lives model, to transform disability support services Good Lives model, to transform disability support services and Good Lives model, to transform disability support services and give disability support services and give disabled disability support services and give disabled people disability support services and give disabled people greater disability support services and give disabled people greater independence disabled people greater independence disabled people greater independence disabled people greater independence and flexibility. disabled people greater independence and flexibility. That disabled people greater independence and flexibility. That concludes disabled people greater independence and flexibility. That concludes Oral