This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Ericsson This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access This programme is live captioned by Ericsson Access Services Ericsson Access Services for Ericsson Access Services for the Ericsson Access Services for the Office Ericsson Access Services for the Office of Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Ericsson Access Services for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, humbly Almighty God, humbly acknowledging Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need Almighty God, humbly acknowledging our need for humbly acknowledging our need for your humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all humbly acknowledging our need for your guidance in all things, your guidance in all things, and your guidance in all things, and laying your guidance in all things, and laying aside your guidance in all things, and laying aside all your guidance in all things, and laying aside all private and laying aside all private and and laying aside all private and personal and laying aside all private and personal interests, and personal interests, we and personal interests, we ask and personal interests, we ask that and personal interests, we ask that you and personal interests, we ask that you grant we ask that you grant that we ask that you grant that we we ask that you grant that we may we ask that you grant that we may conduct we ask that you grant that we may conduct the we ask that you grant that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House that we may conduct the affairs of this House and that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our that we may conduct the affairs of this House and of our country of this House and of our country to of this House and of our country to the of this House and of our country to the glory of this House and of our country to the glory of of this House and of our country to the glory of your of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy of this House and of our country to the glory of your holy name, to the glory of your holy name, the to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true to the glory of your holy name, the maintenance of true religion the maintenance of true religion and the maintenance of true religion and justice, and justice, the and justice, the honour and justice, the honour of and justice, the honour of the and justice, the honour of the Queen, the honour of the Queen, and the honour of the Queen, and the the honour of the Queen, and the public the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, the honour of the Queen, and the public welfare, peace, and the public welfare, peace, and and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New and the public welfare, peace, and tranquillity of New Zealand, and tranquillity of New Zealand, through and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our and tranquillity of New Zealand, through Jesus Christ our Lord. through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen. A A petition A petition has A petition has been A petition has been delivered A petition has been delivered to A petition has been delivered to the A petition has been delivered to the Clerk A petition has been delivered to the Clerk for A petition has been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. Petition Petition of Petition of Ann Petition of Ann Ruxton Petition of Ann Ruxton and Petition of Ann Ruxton and 3,596 Petition of Ann Ruxton and 3,596 others Petition of Ann Ruxton and 3,596 others requesting Petition of Ann Ruxton and 3,596 others requesting that Petition of Ann Ruxton and 3,596 others requesting that the Petition of Ann Ruxton and 3,596 others requesting that the House others requesting that the House consider others requesting that the House consider a others requesting that the House consider a law others requesting that the House consider a law change others requesting that the House consider a law change banning consider a law change banning single-use consider a law change banning single-use plastic consider a law change banning single-use plastic shopping consider a law change banning single-use plastic shopping bags consider a law change banning single-use plastic shopping bags in single-use plastic shopping bags in New single-use plastic shopping bags in New Zealand. That That petition That petition stands That petition stands referred That petition stands referred to That petition stands referred to a That petition stands referred to a select That petition stands referred to a select committee. That petition stands referred to a select committee. A That petition stands referred to a select committee. A paper That petition stands referred to a select committee. A paper has That petition stands referred to a select committee. A paper has been select committee. A paper has been referred to to for to for presentation. NZ NZ Police, NZ Police, Four NZ Police, Four Year NZ Police, Four Year Plan, NZ Police, Four Year Plan, 2017/18-2020/2021. NZ Police, Four Year Plan, 2017/18-2020/2021. The NZ Police, Four Year Plan, 2017/18-2020/2021. The Safest 2017/18-2020/2021. The Safest Country: 2017/18-2020/2021. The Safest Country: Policing 2017/18-2020/2021. The Safest Country: Policing 2021. Country: Policing 2021. I Country: Policing 2021. I present Country: Policing 2021. I present the Country: Policing 2021. I present the report Country: Policing 2021. I present the report of Country: Policing 2021. I present the report of the I present the report of the Controller I present the report of the Controller and I present the report of the Controller and Auditor-General Controller and Auditor-General entitled Controller and Auditor-General entitled The Controller and Auditor-General entitled The Auditor-General's entitled The Auditor-General's Strategic entitled The Auditor-General's Strategic Intentions entitled The Auditor-General's Strategic Intentions to entitled The Auditor-General's Strategic Intentions to 2025. Strategic Intentions to 2025. Those Strategic Intentions to 2025. Those papers Strategic Intentions to 2025. Those papers are Strategic Intentions to 2025. Those papers are published Strategic Intentions to 2025. Those papers are published under Strategic Intentions to 2025. Those papers are published under the Those papers are published under the authority Those papers are published under the authority of Those papers are published under the authority of the Those papers are published under the authority of the House. Select Select committee Select committee Reports Select committee Reports have Select committee Reports have been Select committee Reports have been delivered Select committee Reports have been delivered for Select committee Reports have been delivered for presentation. Select committee Reports have been delivered for presentation.. Reports Reports of Reports of the Reports of the Finance Reports of the Finance and Reports of the Finance and Expenditure Reports of the Finance and Expenditure Committee The The Rob The Rob bank The Rob bank stability The Rob bank stability report The Rob bank stability report of The Rob bank stability report of May The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, reports The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, reports of The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, reports of the The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, reports of the how The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, reports of the how and The Rob bank stability report of May 2017, reports of the how and order 2017, reports of the how and order committee 2017, reports of the how and order committee on 2017, reports of the how and order committee on the 2017, reports of the how and order committee on the petition 2017, reports of the how and order committee on the petition of 2017, reports of the how and order committee on the petition of Jing 2017, reports of the how and order committee on the petition of Jing Wu committee on the petition of Jing Wu and committee on the petition of Jing Wu and 2,077 committee on the petition of Jing Wu and 2,077 others, committee on the petition of Jing Wu and 2,077 others, and committee on the petition of Jing Wu and 2,077 others, and the committee on the petition of Jing Wu and 2,077 others, and the petition and 2,077 others, and the petition of and 2,077 others, and the petition of Karl and 2,077 others, and the petition of Karl Teangiotau and 2,077 others, and the petition of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. and 2,077 others, and the petition of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The and 2,077 others, and the petition of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob # of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob # -- of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob # -- Reserve of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of of Karl Teangiotau Nuku. The report on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New Zealand on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New Zealand report on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New Zealand report is on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New Zealand report is set on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New Zealand report is set down on the Rob # -- Reserve Bank of New Zealand report is set down for Zealand report is set down for consideration. Zealand report is set down for on Zealand report is set down for consideration. The Clerk Zealand report is set down for consideration. The Clerk has Zealand report is set down for consideration. The Clerk has been consideration. The Clerk has been inform consideration. The Clerk has been inform offend consideration. The Clerk has been inform offend the consideration. The Clerk has been inform offend the pro-duction consideration. The Clerk has been inform offend the pro-duction of inform offend the pro-duction of bill inform offend the pro-duction of inform inform offend the pro-duction of bill -- has inform offend the pro-duction of bill -- has been inform offend the pro-duction of bill -- has been inform inform offend the pro-duction of bill -- has been inform offend inform offend the pro-duction of bill -- has been inform offend the bill -- has been inform offend the introduction bill -- has been inform offend the introduction of bill -- has been inform offend the introduction of bills Criminal introduction of bills Criminal Records introduction of bills Criminal Records (Expungement introduction of bills Criminal Records (Expungement of introduction of bills Criminal Records (Expungement of Convictions Criminal Records (Expungement of Convictions for Criminal Records (Expungement of Convictions for Historical Convictions for Historical Historical Historical Homosexual Historical Homosexual Offences) Historical Homosexual Offences) Bill. Homosexual Offences) Bill. Heretaunga Homosexual Offences) Bill. Heretaunga Tamatea Homosexual Offences) Bill. Heretaunga Tamatea Claims Homosexual Offences) Bill. Heretaunga Tamatea Claims Settlement Heretaunga Tamatea Claims Settlement Bill. Bill. Those Bill. Those bills Bill. Those bills are Bill. Those bills are set Bill. Those bills are set down Bill. Those bills are set down for Bill. Those bills are set down for first Those bills are set down for first reading. reading. The reading. The House reading. The House comes reading. The House comes to reading. The House comes to oral reading. The House comes to oral questions. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: What My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has My question is to the Minister of Finance: What reports has he Finance: What reports has he received Finance: What reports has he received on Finance: What reports has he received on the Finance: What reports has he received on the state Finance: What reports has he received on the state of Finance: What reports has he received on the state of the Finance: What reports has he received on the state of the rural received on the state of the rural economy? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Rabo <INTERRUPTION> Rabo bank's <INTERRUPTION> Rabo bank's latest <INTERRUPTION> Rabo bank's latest confidence <INTERRUPTION> Rabo bank's latest confidence survey Rabo bank's latest confidence survey shows Rabo bank's latest confidence survey shows rural Rabo bank's latest confidence survey shows rural sector Rabo bank's latest confidence survey shows rural sector confidence Rabo bank's latest confidence survey shows rural sector confidence rose shows rural sector confidence rose to shows rural sector confidence rose shows shows rural sector confidence rose to 54% in shows rural sector confidence rose to 54% in the shows rural sector confidence rose to 54% in the June shows rural sector confidence rose to 54% in the June quarter. shows rural sector confidence rose to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! Double to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! Double that to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! Double that of to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! Double that of the to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! Double that of the previous to 54% in the June quarter. Thanks! Double that of the previous Carter Double that of the previous Carter on Double that of the previous Carter on the Double that of the previous Carter on the back Double that of the previous Carter on the back of Double that of the previous Carter on the back of rising Double that of the previous Carter on the back of rising commodity on the back of rising commodity prices. on the back of rising commodity prices. The on the back of rising commodity prices. The survey on the back of rising commodity prices. The survey shows on the back of rising commodity prices. The survey shows farmer on the back of rising commodity prices. The survey shows farmer are prices. The survey shows farmer are now prices. The survey shows farmer are now more prices. The survey shows farmer are now more up-beat prices. The survey shows farmer are now more up-beat about prices. The survey shows farmer are now more up-beat about their now more up-beat about their economic now more up-beat about their now now more up-beat about their economic prospects than now more up-beat about their economic prospects than at now more up-beat about their economic prospects than at any now more up-beat about their economic prospects than at any point economic prospects than at any point since economic prospects than at any point since 2003 economic prospects than at any point since 2003 when economic prospects than at any point since 2003 when the economic prospects than at any point since 2003 when the survey economic prospects than at any point since 2003 when the survey began. economic prospects than at any point since 2003 when the survey began. Of since 2003 when the survey began. Of course, since 2003 when the survey began. Of course, rural since 2003 when the survey began. Of course, rural sector since 2003 when the survey began. Of course, rural sector confidence since 2003 when the survey began. Of course, rural sector confidence is course, rural sector confidence is important course, rural sector confidence is course, course, rural sector confidence is important for the course, rural sector confidence is important for the confidence course, rural sector confidence is important for the confidence of course, rural sector confidence is important for the confidence of New important for the confidence of New Zealand's important for the confidence of New Zealand's regions, important for the confidence of New Zealand's regions, and important for the confidence of New Zealand's regions, and the important for the confidence of New Zealand's regions, and the Westpac Zealand's regions, and the Westpac McDermott Zealand's regions, and the Westpac McDermott confidence Zealand's regions, and the Westpac McDermott confidence survey Zealand's regions, and the Westpac McDermott confidence survey was McDermott confidence survey was released McDermott confidence survey was released this McDermott confidence survey was released this morning McDermott confidence survey was released this morning and McDermott confidence survey was released this morning and shows released this morning and shows regional released this morning and shows regional economic released this morning and shows regional economic confidence regional economic confidence continues regional economic confidence continues to regional economic confidence continues to rise, regional economic confidence continues to rise, with regional economic confidence continues to rise, with the continues to rise, with the non-dairy continues to rise, with the non-dairy areas continues to rise, with the non-dairy areas of continues to rise, with the non-dairy areas of Nelson, non-dairy areas of Nelson, Marlborough non-dairy areas of Nelson, Marlborough and non-dairy areas of Nelson, Marlborough and the non-dairy areas of Nelson, Marlborough and the West non-dairy areas of Nelson, Marlborough and the West Coast Marlborough and the West Coast leading Marlborough and the West Coast leading the Marlborough and the West Coast leading the charge. Marlborough and the West Coast leading the charge. How Marlborough and the West Coast leading the charge. How have Marlborough and the West Coast leading the charge. How have New leading the charge. How have New Zealand's leading the charge. How have New Zealand's agriculture leading the charge. How have New Zealand's agriculture exports leading the charge. How have New Zealand's agriculture exports fared Zealand's agriculture exports fared recently? Zealand's agriculture exports fared recently? According Zealand's agriculture exports fared recently? According to Zealand's agriculture exports fared recently? According to the Zealand's agriculture exports fared recently? According to the latest recently? According to the latest data recently? According to the latest data from recently? According to the latest data from Statistics recently? According to the latest data from Statistics NZ, recently? According to the latest data from Statistics NZ, strong data from Statistics NZ, strong demand data from Statistics NZ, strong demand for data from Statistics NZ, strong demand for New data from Statistics NZ, strong demand for New Zealand data from Statistics NZ, strong demand for New Zealand produce data from Statistics NZ, strong demand for New Zealand produce or demand for New Zealand produce or merchandise demand for New Zealand produce or merchandise exports demand for New Zealand produce or merchandise exports in demand for New Zealand produce or merchandise exports in May demand for New Zealand produce or merchandise exports in May rise demand for New Zealand produce or merchandise exports in May rise to merchandise exports in May rise to their merchandise exports in May rise to their highest merchandise exports in May rise to their highest monthly merchandise exports in May rise to their highest monthly level merchandise exports in May rise to their highest monthly level in merchandise exports in May rise to their highest monthly level in more their highest monthly level in more than their highest monthly level in more than three their highest monthly level in more than three years, their highest monthly level in more than three years, up their highest monthly level in more than three years, up 8.7%, their highest monthly level in more than three years, up 8.7%, to their highest monthly level in more than three years, up 8.7%, to just than three years, up 8.7%, to just under than three years, up 8.7%, to just under $5 than three years, up 8.7%, to just under $5 billion, than three years, up 8.7%, to just under $5 billion, compared than three years, up 8.7%, to just under $5 billion, compared with than three years, up 8.7%, to just under $5 billion, compared with the under $5 billion, compared with the same under $5 billion, compared with the same month under $5 billion, compared with the same month last under $5 billion, compared with the same month last year. under $5 billion, compared with the same month last year. That under $5 billion, compared with the same month last year. That was under $5 billion, compared with the same month last year. That was on same month last year. That was on the same month last year. That was on the back same month last year. That was on the back of same month last year. That was on the back of strong same month last year. That was on the back of strong demand same month last year. That was on the back of strong demand for same month last year. That was on the back of strong demand for dairy, the back of strong demand for dairy, particularly the back of strong demand for dairy, particularly out the back of strong demand for dairy, particularly out of the back of strong demand for dairy, particularly out of China, the back of strong demand for dairy, particularly out of China, with particularly out of China, with export particularly out of China, with export values particularly out of China, with export values increasing particularly out of China, with export values increasing by particularly out of China, with export values increasing by $342 export values increasing by $342 million export values increasing by $342 million across export values increasing by $342 million across the export values increasing by $342 million across the month. export values increasing by $342 million across the month. Other million across the month. Other agriculture million across the month. Other agriculture export million across the month. Other agriculture export category, million across the month. Other agriculture export category, such million across the month. Other agriculture export category, such as agriculture export category, such as beef agriculture export category, such as beef and agriculture export category, such as beef and lamb, agriculture export category, such as beef and lamb, forestry, agriculture export category, such as beef and lamb, forestry, fruit agriculture export category, such as beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and wine, beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and wine, also beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and wine, also saw beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and wine, also saw increased beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and wine, also saw increased demand beef and lamb, forestry, fruit and wine, also saw increased demand in wine, also saw increased demand in May. wine, also saw increased demand in May. How wine, also saw increased demand in May. How well wine, also saw increased demand in May. How well placed wine, also saw increased demand in May. How well placed is wine, also saw increased demand in May. How well placed is New wine, also saw increased demand in May. How well placed is New Zealand May. How well placed is New Zealand to May. How well placed is New Zealand to cope May. How well placed is New Zealand to cope with May. How well placed is New Zealand to cope with commodity May. How well placed is New Zealand to cope with commodity price May. How well placed is New Zealand to cope with commodity price swings? to cope with commodity price swings? Well, to cope with commodity price swings? Well, over to cope with commodity price swings? Well, over the to cope with commodity price swings? Well, over the past to cope with commodity price swings? Well, over the past eight to cope with commodity price swings? Well, over the past eight years to cope with commodity price swings? Well, over the past eight years the Well, over the past eight years the Government Well, over the past eight years the Government has Well, over the past eight years the Government has worked Well, over the past eight years the Government has worked to Well, over the past eight years the Government has worked to diversify Government has worked to diversify the Government has worked to diversify the economy, Government has worked to diversify the economy, so Government has worked to diversify the economy, so that Government has worked to diversify the economy, so that a Government has worked to diversify the economy, so that a sudden Government has worked to diversify the economy, so that a sudden price the economy, so that a sudden price change the economy, so that a sudden price change in the economy, so that a sudden price change in one the economy, so that a sudden price change in one commodity the economy, so that a sudden price change in one commodity doesn't the economy, so that a sudden price change in one commodity doesn't add change in one commodity doesn't add versely change in one commodity doesn't add the change in one commodity doesn't add versely affect the change in one commodity doesn't add versely affect the rest change in one commodity doesn't add versely affect the rest -- change in one commodity doesn't add versely affect the rest -- adversely versely affect the rest -- adversely affect versely affect the rest -- adversely the versely affect the rest -- adversely affect the rest versely affect the rest -- adversely affect the rest of versely affect the rest -- adversely affect the rest of the versely affect the rest -- adversely affect the rest of the economy. affect the rest of the economy. That's affect the rest of the economy. That's indeed affect the rest of the economy. That's indeed happen affect the rest of the economy. That's indeed happen as affect the rest of the economy. That's indeed happen as we affect the rest of the economy. That's indeed happen as we have affect the rest of the economy. That's indeed happen as we have seen That's indeed happen as we have seen experts That's indeed happen as we have seen experts hold That's indeed happen as we have seen experts hold up That's indeed happen as we have seen experts hold up while That's indeed happen as we have seen experts hold up while the That's indeed happen as we have seen experts hold up while the dairy experts hold up while the dairy sector experts hold up while the dairy sector struggled. experts hold up while the dairy sector struggled. The sector struggled. The diversification sector struggled. The diversification occurred sector struggled. The diversification occurred in sector struggled. The diversification occurred in the diversification occurred in the agriculture diversification occurred in the agriculture sector. diversification occurred in the agriculture sector. Dairy diversification occurred in the agriculture sector. Dairy is agriculture sector. Dairy is complemented agriculture sector. Dairy is complemented by agriculture sector. Dairy is complemented by other agriculture sector. Dairy is complemented by other fast agriculture sector. Dairy is complemented by other fast growing complemented by other fast growing sectors, complemented by other fast growing sectors, which complemented by other fast growing sectors, which are complemented by other fast growing sectors, which are also complemented by other fast growing sectors, which are also helping complemented by other fast growing sectors, which are also helping us sectors, which are also helping us climb sectors, which are also helping us climb up sectors, which are also helping us climb up the sectors, which are also helping us climb up the export sectors, which are also helping us climb up the export value sectors, which are also helping us climb up the export value chain. sectors, which are also helping us climb up the export value chain. The climb up the export value chain. The Government's climb up the export value chain. The Government's economic climb up the export value chain. The Government's economic plan climb up the export value chain. The Government's economic plan is Government's economic plan is working, Government's economic plan is working, as Government's economic plan is working, as we Government's economic plan is working, as we saw, Government's economic plan is working, as we saw, when Government's economic plan is working, as we saw, when the Government's economic plan is working, as we saw, when the overall working, as we saw, when the overall economy working, as we saw, when the overall economy continued working, as we saw, when the overall economy continued to working, as we saw, when the overall economy continued to grow working, as we saw, when the overall economy continued to grow despite economy continued to grow despite the economy continued to grow despite the dairy economy continued to grow despite the dairy industry economy continued to grow despite the dairy industry struggling. economy continued to grow despite the dairy industry struggling. Thank the dairy industry struggling. Thank you. the dairy industry struggling. Thank you. What the dairy industry struggling. Thank you. What are the dairy industry struggling. Thank you. What are the the dairy industry struggling. Thank you. What are the long-term you. What are the long-term prospects you. What are the long-term prospects for you. What are the long-term prospects for the you. What are the long-term prospects for the agriculture prospects for the agriculture sector? prospects for the agriculture sector? Good prospects for the agriculture sector? Good question! prospects for the agriculture sector? Good question! Order! prospects for the agriculture sector? Good question! Order! The sector? Good question! Order! The long-term sector? Good question! Order! The long-term prospects sector? Good question! Order! The long-term prospects are sector? Good question! Order! The long-term prospects are very sector? Good question! Order! The long-term prospects are very good. long-term prospects are very good. New long-term prospects are very good. New Zealand long-term prospects are very good. New Zealand is long-term prospects are very good. New Zealand is well long-term prospects are very good. New Zealand is well positioned, long-term prospects are very good. New Zealand is well positioned, high New Zealand is well positioned, high growth New Zealand is well positioned, high growth markets New Zealand is well positioned, high growth markets near New Zealand is well positioned, high growth markets near South-East New Zealand is well positioned, high growth markets near South-East Asia, growth markets near South-East Asia, rising growth markets near South-East Asia, rising incomes growth markets near South-East Asia, rising incomes are growth markets near South-East Asia, rising incomes are driving growth markets near South-East Asia, rising incomes are driving demand rising incomes are driving demand for rising incomes are driving demand for the rising incomes are driving demand for the premium rising incomes are driving demand for the premium agriculture for the premium agriculture products, for the premium agriculture products, including for the premium agriculture products, including meat, for the premium agriculture products, including meat, milk for the premium agriculture products, including meat, milk and products, including meat, milk and fruit. products, including meat, milk and fruit. We products, including meat, milk and fruit. We have products, including meat, milk and fruit. We have got products, including meat, milk and fruit. We have got an products, including meat, milk and fruit. We have got an approach products, including meat, milk and fruit. We have got an approach of fruit. We have got an approach of adding fruit. We have got an approach of adding value fruit. We have got an approach of adding value to fruit. We have got an approach of adding value to volume, fruit. We have got an approach of adding value to volume, and fruit. We have got an approach of adding value to volume, and 2016 adding value to volume, and 2016 primary adding value to volume, and 2016 fruit. adding value to volume, and 2016 primary products general adding value to volume, and 2016 primary products general Ratted adding value to volume, and 2016 primary products general Ratted $37 primary products general Ratted $37 billion primary products general Ratted $37 billion in primary products general Ratted $37 billion in export primary products general Ratted $37 billion in export revenue, primary products general Ratted $37 billion in export revenue, forecast billion in export revenue, forecast to billion in export revenue, forecast to grow billion in export revenue, forecast to grow to billion in export revenue, forecast to grow to $45 billion in export revenue, forecast to grow to $45 billion billion in export revenue, forecast to grow to $45 billion by billion in export revenue, forecast to grow to $45 billion by 2021, billion in export revenue, forecast to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it is to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it is expected to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it is expected to to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it is expected to be to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it is expected to be equivalent to grow to $45 billion by 2021, when it is expected to be equivalent to it is expected to be equivalent to 14% it is expected to be equivalent to 14% of it is expected to be equivalent to 14% of our it is expected to be equivalent to 14% of our economy. it is expected to be equivalent to 14% of our economy. The it is expected to be equivalent to 14% of our economy. The Government 14% of our economy. The Government continues 14% of our economy. The Government continues to 14% of our economy. The Government continues to encourage 14% of our economy. The Government continues to encourage primary continues to encourage primary sector continues to encourage primary sector growth continues to encourage primary sector growth through continues to encourage primary sector growth through the continues to encourage primary sector growth through the trade sector growth through the trade agenda sector growth through the trade agenda 2030 sector growth through the trade agenda 2030 ensuring sector growth through the trade agenda 2030 ensuring greater sector growth through the trade agenda 2030 ensuring greater market agenda 2030 ensuring greater market access agenda 2030 ensuring greater market access for agenda 2030 ensuring greater market access for our agenda 2030 ensuring greater market access for our farmers agenda 2030 ensuring greater market access for our farmers and agenda 2030 ensuring greater market access for our farmers and export access for our farmers and export businesses. businesses. (INTERJECTIONS) businesses. (INTERJECTIONS) Order! businesses. (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before businesses. (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I businesses. (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question 2, (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question 2, there (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question 2, there were (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question 2, there were quite (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question 2, there were quite a (INTERJECTIONS) Order! Before I call question 2, there were quite a few question 2, there were quite a few emails question 2, there were quite a few emails through question 2, there were quite a few emails through yesterday question 2, there were quite a few emails through yesterday complaining emails through yesterday complaining about emails through yesterday complaining about the emails through yesterday complaining about the level emails through yesterday complaining about the level of emails through yesterday complaining about the level of interjection emails through yesterday complaining about the level of interjection that about the level of interjection that I about the level of interjection that I was about the level of interjection that I was allowing, about the level of interjection that I was allowing, suggesting about the level of interjection that I was allowing, suggesting I about the level of interjection that I was allowing, suggesting I was I was allowing, suggesting I was being I was allowing, suggesting I was being soft I was allowing, suggesting I was being soft on I was allowing, suggesting I was being soft on some I was allowing, suggesting I was being soft on some members. I was allowing, suggesting I was being soft on some members. I I was allowing, suggesting I was being soft on some members. I may being soft on some members. I may have being soft on some members. I may have to being soft on some members. I may have to address being soft on some members. I may have to address that being soft on some members. I may have to address that relatively have to address that relatively quickly have to address that relatively quickly in have to address that relatively quickly in this have to address that relatively quickly in this session, have to address that relatively quickly in this session, unless... quickly in this session, unless... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> No, <INTERRUPTION> No, they <INTERRUPTION> No, they came <INTERRUPTION> No, they came from <INTERRUPTION> No, they came from all <INTERRUPTION> No, they came from all sides <INTERRUPTION> No, they came from all sides of <INTERRUPTION> No, they came from all sides of the No, they came from all sides of the House. No, they came from all sides of the House. Including No, they came from all sides of the House. Including the No, they came from all sides of the House. Including the member No, they came from all sides of the House. Including the member who No, they came from all sides of the House. Including the member who just House. Including the member who just interjected. House. Including the member who just interjected. <INTERRUPTION> interjected. <INTERRUPTION> I interjected. <INTERRUPTION> I require interjected. <INTERRUPTION> I require more interjected. <INTERRUPTION> I require more cooperation. interjected. <INTERRUPTION> I require more cooperation. Point interjected. <INTERRUPTION> I require more cooperation. Point of I require more cooperation. Point of order, I require more cooperation. Point of order, Chris I require more cooperation. Point of order, Chris Hipkins. I require more cooperation. Point of order, Chris Hipkins. We I require more cooperation. Point of order, Chris Hipkins. We too I require more cooperation. Point of order, Chris Hipkins. We too have order, Chris Hipkins. We too have had order, Chris Hipkins. We too have had further order, Chris Hipkins. We too have had further correspondence order, Chris Hipkins. We too have had further correspondence as order, Chris Hipkins. We too have had further correspondence as a had further correspondence as a result had further correspondence as a had had further correspondence as a result of question had further correspondence as a result of question time had further correspondence as a result of question time yesterday. result of question time yesterday. One result of question time yesterday. One of result of question time yesterday. One of the result of question time yesterday. One of the points result of question time yesterday. One of the points that result of question time yesterday. One of the points that I result of question time yesterday. One of the points that I would result of question time yesterday. One of the points that I would ask One of the points that I would ask you One of the points that I would ask you to One of the points that I would ask you to consider One of the points that I would ask you to consider in One of the points that I would ask you to consider in that One of the points that I would ask you to consider in that is One of the points that I would ask you to consider in that is - One of the points that I would ask you to consider in that is - taking you to consider in that is - taking a you to consider in that is - taking a strict you to consider in that is - taking a strict approach you to consider in that is - taking a strict approach - you to consider in that is - taking a strict approach - I you to consider in that is - taking a strict approach - I think you to consider in that is - taking a strict approach - I think mimic a strict approach - I think mimic phone a strict approach - I think mimic phone - a strict approach - I think mimic phone - you a strict approach - I think mimic phone - you have a strict approach - I think mimic phone - you have taken a strict approach - I think mimic phone - you have taken a a strict approach - I think mimic phone - you have taken a strict phone - you have taken a strict approach phone - you have taken a strict approach to phone - you have taken a strict approach to the phone - you have taken a strict approach to the questions phone - you have taken a strict approach to the questions that phone - you have taken a strict approach to the questions that can approach to the questions that can be approach to the questions that can be asked approach to the questions that can be asked in approach to the questions that can be asked in relation approach to the questions that can be asked in relation to approach to the questions that can be asked in relation to this approach to the questions that can be asked in relation to this matter. be asked in relation to this matter. I be asked in relation to this matter. I also be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that - be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that - in be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that - in doing be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that - in doing so be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that - in doing so - be asked in relation to this matter. I also ask that - in doing so - you I also ask that - in doing so - you take I also ask that - in doing so - you take a I also ask that - in doing so - you take a strict I also ask that - in doing so - you take a strict approach I also ask that - in doing so - you take a strict approach to I also ask that - in doing so - you take a strict approach to the take a strict approach to the answers take a strict approach to the be take a strict approach to the answers that can take a strict approach to the answers that can be take a strict approach to the answers that can be give take a strict approach to the answers that can be give end take a strict approach to the answers that can be give end and answers that can be give end and where answers that can be give end and where they answers that can be give end and where they deviate answers that can be give end and where they deviate significantly where they deviate significantly from where they deviate significantly from the where they deviate significantly from the questions where they deviate significantly from the questions that where they deviate significantly from the questions that you where they deviate significantly from the questions that you are from the questions that you are quick from the questions that you are quick to from the questions that you are quick to shut from the questions that you are quick to shut those from the questions that you are quick to shut those down from the questions that you are quick to shut those down as from the questions that you are quick to shut those down as well. from the questions that you are quick to shut those down as well. I quick to shut those down as well. I will quick to shut those down as well. I will hear quick to shut those down as well. I will hear from quick to shut those down as well. I will hear from the quick to shut those down as well. I will hear from the honourable quick to shut those down as well. I will hear from the honourable Simon will hear from the honourable Simon Bridges. will hear from the honourable Simon Bridges. Order. will hear from the honourable Simon Bridges. Order. Again, will hear from the honourable Simon Bridges. Order. Again, this will hear from the honourable Simon Bridges. Order. Again, this is will hear from the honourable Simon Bridges. Order. Again, this is a Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of order. Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of order. It Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of order. It will Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of order. It will be Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of order. It will be heard Bridges. Order. Again, this is a point of order. It will be heard in point of order. It will be heard in silence. point of order. It will be heard in silence. Unless point of order. It will be heard in silence. Unless members point of order. It will be heard in silence. Unless members are point of order. It will be heard in silence. Unless members are quite silence. Unless members are quite keen silence. Unless members are quite keen to silence. Unless members are quite keen to go silence. Unless members are quite keen to go back silence. Unless members are quite keen to go back to silence. Unless members are quite keen to go back to their silence. Unless members are quite keen to go back to their offices keen to go back to their offices instead keen to go back to their offices instead of keen to go back to their offices instead of having keen to go back to their offices instead of having to keen to go back to their offices instead of having to endure keen to go back to their offices instead of having to endure question instead of having to endure question time. instead of having to endure question time. The instead of having to endure question time. The honourable instead of having to endure question time. The honourable Simon instead of having to endure question time. The honourable Simon Bridges. time. The honourable Simon Bridges. In time. The honourable Simon Bridges. In fact, time. The honourable Simon Bridges. In fact, reflecting time. The honourable Simon Bridges. In fact, reflecting on time. The honourable Simon Bridges. In fact, reflecting on yesterday, In fact, reflecting on yesterday, whilst In fact, reflecting on yesterday, whilst you're In fact, reflecting on yesterday, whilst you're ruling In fact, reflecting on yesterday, whilst you're ruling - In fact, reflecting on yesterday, whilst you're ruling - was In fact, reflecting on yesterday, whilst you're ruling - was very whilst you're ruling - was very helpful whilst you're ruling - was very In whilst you're ruling - was very helpful - what, whilst you're ruling - was very helpful - what, in whilst you're ruling - was very helpful - what, in fact, whilst you're ruling - was very helpful - what, in fact, was helpful - what, in fact, was happening helpful - what, in fact, was happening was helpful - what, in fact, was happening was the helpful - what, in fact, was happening was the questions happening was the questions ultimately happening was the questions ultimately were happening was the questions ultimately were asking happening was the questions ultimately were asking about ultimately were asking about something ultimately were asking about something there ultimately were asking about something there wasn't ultimately were asking about something there wasn't ministerial something there wasn't ministerial responsibility something there wasn't ministerial responsibility for. something there wasn't ministerial responsibility for. Nevertheless, responsibility for. Nevertheless, the responsibility for. Nevertheless, the PM responsibility for. Nevertheless, the PM was responsibility for. Nevertheless, the PM was giving responsibility for. Nevertheless, the PM was giving answers responsibility for. Nevertheless, the PM was giving answers as responsibility for. Nevertheless, the PM was giving answers as - the PM was giving answers as - because the PM was giving answers as - the the PM was giving answers as - because the question the PM was giving answers as - because the question was the PM was giving answers as - because the question was there. the PM was giving answers as - because the question was there. I because the question was there. I think because the question was there. I think that, because the question was there. I think that, in because the question was there. I think that, in itself, because the question was there. I think that, in itself, was because the question was there. I think that, in itself, was part because the question was there. I think that, in itself, was part of think that, in itself, was part of the think that, in itself, was part of the issue. think that, in itself, was part of the issue. So, think that, in itself, was part of the issue. So, I think that, in itself, was part of the issue. So, I don't think that, in itself, was part of the issue. So, I don't think, think that, in itself, was part of the issue. So, I don't think, unlike the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip kip the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip kip over the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip kip over on the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip kip over on the the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip kip over on the -- the issue. So, I don't think, unlike Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on the Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on the other Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on the other side, Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on the other side, it Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on the other side, it was Mr Kip kip over on the -- Hipkins over on the other side, it was a over on the other side, it was a question over on the other side, it was a question of over on the other side, it was a question of the over on the other side, it was a question of the strict question of the strict interpretation question of the strict the question of the strict interpretation of the question of the strict interpretation of the questions question of the strict interpretation of the questions at interpretation of the questions at all, interpretation of the questions at all, it interpretation of the questions at all, it was interpretation of the questions at all, it was the interpretation of the questions at all, it was the fact interpretation of the questions at all, it was the fact that interpretation of the questions at all, it was the fact that they interpretation of the questions at all, it was the fact that they were all, it was the fact that they were let all, it was the fact that they were let through, all, it was the fact that they were let through, and all, it was the fact that they were let through, and that all, it was the fact that they were let through, and that led all, it was the fact that they were let through, and that led to all, it was the fact that they were let through, and that led to - all, it was the fact that they were let through, and that led to - or let through, and that led to - or was let through, and that led to - or was part let through, and that led to - or was part of, let through, and that led to - or was part of, I let through, and that led to - or was part of, I think, let through, and that led to - or was part of, I think, the let through, and that led to - or was part of, I think, the situation was part of, I think, the situation we was part of, I think, the situation we had. was part of, I think, the situation we had. <INTERRUPTION> we had. <INTERRUPTION> . we had. <INTERRUPTION> . I we had. <INTERRUPTION> . I don't we had. <INTERRUPTION> . I don't need we had. <INTERRUPTION> . I don't need any we had. <INTERRUPTION> . I don't need any further . I don't need any further assistance, . I don't need any further assistance, unless . I don't need any further assistance, unless it . I don't need any further assistance, unless it is . I don't need any further assistance, unless it is another assistance, unless it is another point assistance, unless it is another assistance, assistance, unless it is another point of order. assistance, unless it is another point of order. I assistance, unless it is another point of order. I will assistance, unless it is another point of order. I will ajudge assistance, unless it is another point of order. I will ajudge the point of order. I will ajudge the quality point of order. I will ajudge the quality of point of order. I will ajudge the quality of the point of order. I will ajudge the quality of the answers point of order. I will ajudge the quality of the answers on point of order. I will ajudge the quality of the answers on each quality of the answers on each occasion. quality of the answers on each occasion. I quality of the answers on each occasion. I feel quality of the answers on each occasion. I feel the quality of the answers on each occasion. I feel the answer quality of the answers on each occasion. I feel the answer is occasion. I feel the answer is deviating occasion. I feel the answer is deviating significantly occasion. I feel the answer is deviating significantly from deviating significantly from addressing deviating significantly from addressing the deviating significantly from addressing the question, deviating significantly from addressing the question, then deviating significantly from addressing the question, then I deviating significantly from addressing the question, then I will addressing the question, then I will cease addressing the question, then I will cease the addressing the question, then I will cease the answers, addressing the question, then I will cease the answers, and addressing the question, then I will cease the answers, and I addressing the question, then I will cease the answers, and I will addressing the question, then I will cease the answers, and I will also addressing the question, then I will cease the answers, and I will also - cease the answers, and I will also - if cease the answers, and I will also - if the cease the answers, and I will also - if the question cease the answers, and I will also - if the question is cease the answers, and I will also - if the question is relatively if the question is relatively political, if the question is relatively political, give if the question is relatively political, give some if the question is relatively political, give some latitude if the question is relatively political, give some latitude to if the question is relatively political, give some latitude to the political, give some latitude to the minister political, give some latitude to the minister answering. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Have My question is to the Prime Minister: Have he My question is to the Prime Minister: Have he or My question is to the Prime Minister: Have he or any My question is to the Prime Minister: Have he or any of My question is to the Prime Minister: Have he or any of his Minister: Have he or any of his Ministers Minister: Have he or any of his Ministers ever Minister: Have he or any of his Ministers ever deviated Minister: Have he or any of his Ministers ever deviated from Minister: Have he or any of his Ministers ever deviated from the Ministers ever deviated from the ministerial Ministers ever deviated from the ministerial standards Ministers ever deviated from the ministerial standards he Ministers ever deviated from the ministerial standards he expects, Ministers ever deviated from the ministerial standards he expects, in ministerial standards he expects, in order ministerial standards he expects, in order to ministerial standards he expects, in order to maintain ministerial standards he expects, in order to maintain the ministerial standards he expects, in order to maintain the House's order to maintain the House's confidence order to maintain the House's confidence in order to maintain the House's confidence in the order to maintain the House's confidence in the Government? No. No. I No. I would No. I would expect No. I would expect ministers No. I would expect ministers to No. I would expect ministers to maintain No. I would expect ministers to maintain standards. No. I would expect ministers to maintain standards. For No. I would expect ministers to maintain standards. For instance, No. I would expect ministers to maintain standards. For instance, I maintain standards. For instance, I wouldn't maintain standards. For instance, I wouldn't expect maintain standards. For instance, I wouldn't expect my maintain standards. For instance, I wouldn't expect my ministers maintain standards. For instance, I wouldn't expect my ministers to maintain standards. For instance, I wouldn't expect my ministers to be wouldn't expect my ministers to be involved wouldn't expect my ministers to be involved in wouldn't expect my ministers to be involved in foreign wouldn't expect my ministers to be involved in foreign worker involved in foreign worker exploitation. involved in foreign worker exploitation. <INTERRUPTION> exploitation. <INTERRUPTION> Order! exploitation. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary exploitation. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. exploitation. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. Did Order! Supplementary question. Did he Order! Supplementary question. Did he cover-up Order! Supplementary question. Did he cover-up his Order! Supplementary question. Did he cover-up his knowledge Order! Supplementary question. Did he cover-up his knowledge of Order! Supplementary question. Did he cover-up his knowledge of the he cover-up his knowledge of the Barclay he cover-up his knowledge of the Barclay bark he cover-up his knowledge of the Barclay bark affair he cover-up his knowledge of the Barclay bark affair for he cover-up his knowledge of the Barclay bark affair for -- he cover-up his knowledge of the Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay affair Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay affair for Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay affair for 18 Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay affair for 18 months Barclay bark affair for -- Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to Barclay affair for 18 months to project Barclay affair for 18 months to project the Barclay affair for 18 months to project the Government's Barclay affair for 18 months to project the Government's majority Barclay affair for 18 months to project the Government's majority in project the Government's majority in the project the Government's majority in project project the Government's majority in the House? If project the Government's majority in the House? If not, project the Government's majority in the House? If not, why project the Government's majority in the House? If not, why did project the Government's majority in the House? If not, why did he the House? If not, why did he participate the House? If not, why did he participate in the House? If not, why did he participate in the the House? If not, why did he participate in the cover-up? the House? If not, why did he participate in the cover-up? Good participate in the cover-up? Good question! participate in the cover-up? Good question! Point participate in the cover-up? Good question! Point of participate in the cover-up? Good question! Point of order. participate in the cover-up? Good question! Point of order. I participate in the cover-up? Good question! Point of order. I think question! Point of order. I think the question! Point of order. I think participate question! Point of order. I think the issue here question! Point of order. I think the issue here is question! Point of order. I think the issue here is - question! Point of order. I think the issue here is - again question! Point of order. I think the issue here is - again - question! Point of order. I think the issue here is - again - this question! Point of order. I think the issue here is - again - this is the issue here is - again - this is something the issue here is - again - this is something he the issue here is - again - this is something he doesn't the issue here is - again - this is something he doesn't have something he doesn't have responsibility something he doesn't have the something he doesn't have responsibility for as something he doesn't have responsibility for as PM. something he doesn't have responsibility for as PM. On something he doesn't have responsibility for as PM. On this responsibility for as PM. On this occasion, responsibility for as PM. On this occasion, judging responsibility for as PM. On this occasion, judging from responsibility for as PM. On this occasion, judging from the responsibility for as PM. On this occasion, judging from the questions occasion, judging from the questions yesterday, occasion, judging from the questions occasion, occasion, judging from the questions yesterday, other matters occasion, judging from the questions yesterday, other matters that occasion, judging from the questions yesterday, other matters that have yesterday, other matters that have been yesterday, other matters that have been raised, yesterday, other matters that have been raised, and yesterday, other matters that have been raised, and a yesterday, other matters that have been raised, and a considerable been raised, and a considerable amount been raised, and a considerable amount of been raised, and a considerable amount of media been raised, and a considerable amount of media coverage, been raised, and a considerable amount of media coverage, I'm been raised, and a considerable amount of media coverage, I'm not been raised, and a considerable amount of media coverage, I'm not in amount of media coverage, I'm not in a amount of media coverage, I'm not in a position amount of media coverage, I'm not in a position to amount of media coverage, I'm not in a position to judge amount of media coverage, I'm not in a position to judge whether amount of media coverage, I'm not in a position to judge whether the amount of media coverage, I'm not in a position to judge whether the PM a position to judge whether the PM spoke a position to judge whether the PM spoke in a position to judge whether the PM spoke in his a position to judge whether the PM spoke in his capacity a position to judge whether the PM spoke in his capacity as a position to judge whether the PM spoke in his capacity as leader a position to judge whether the PM spoke in his capacity as leader of a position to judge whether the PM spoke in his capacity as leader of a spoke in his capacity as leader of a political spoke in his capacity as leader of a political party, spoke in his capacity as leader of a political party, leader spoke in his capacity as leader of a political party, leader of spoke in his capacity as leader of a political party, leader of a spoke in his capacity as leader of a political party, leader of a Caucus, political party, leader of a Caucus, or political party, leader of a Caucus, or as political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But I political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But I have political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But I have no political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But I have no doubt political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But I have no doubt the political party, leader of a Caucus, or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM will or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM will have or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM will have no or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM will have no difficulty or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM will have no difficulty in or as PM. But I have no doubt the PM will have no difficulty in informing will have no difficulty in informing the will have no difficulty in informing the House. will have no difficulty in informing the House. I will have no difficulty in informing the House. I am will have no difficulty in informing the House. I am going will have no difficulty in informing the House. I am going to will have no difficulty in informing the House. I am going to account will have no difficulty in informing the House. I am going to account the the House. I am going to account the member the House. I am going to account the member Andrew the House. I am going to account the member Andrew Little the House. I am going to account the member Andrew Little to the House. I am going to account the member Andrew Little to repeat the House. I am going to account the member Andrew Little to repeat the member Andrew Little to repeat the question member Andrew Little to repeat the question now member Andrew Little to repeat the question now it's member Andrew Little to repeat the question now it's been member Andrew Little to repeat the question now it's been interrupted. question now it's been interrupted. Did question now it's been interrupted. Did he question now it's been interrupted. Did he cover question now it's been interrupted. Did he cover up question now it's been interrupted. Did he cover up his question now it's been interrupted. Did he cover up his knowledge question now it's been interrupted. Did he cover up his knowledge of question now it's been interrupted. Did he cover up his knowledge of the Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Barclay Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Barclay affair Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Barclay affair for Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Barclay affair for 18 Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Barclay affair for 18 months Did he cover up his knowledge of the Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to protect Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to protect the Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to protect the Government's Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to protect the Government's majority Todd Barclay affair for 18 months to protect the Government's majority in protect the Government's majority in the protect the Government's majority in protect protect the Government's majority in the House? If protect the Government's majority in the House? If not, protect the Government's majority in the House? If not, why protect the Government's majority in the House? If not, why did protect the Government's majority in the House? If not, why did he the House? If not, why did he participate the House? If not, why did he participate in the House? If not, why did he participate in that the House? If not, why did he participate in that cover-up? the House? If not, why did he participate in that cover-up? No, the House? If not, why did he participate in that cover-up? No, I participate in that cover-up? No, I completely participate in that cover-up? No, I completely reject participate in that cover-up? No, I completely reject the participate in that cover-up? No, I completely reject the member's completely reject the member's assertions completely reject the member's assertions and completely reject the member's assertions and he completely reject the member's assertions and he needs completely reject the member's assertions and he needs to assertions and he needs to understand assertions and he needs to understand that assertions and he needs to understand that just assertions and he needs to understand that just because assertions and he needs to understand that just because he understand that just because he admitted understand that just because he admitted to understand that just because he admitted to foreign understand that just because he admitted to foreign workers admitted to foreign workers exploitation admitted to foreign workers exploitation doesn't admitted to foreign workers exploitation doesn't mean admitted to foreign workers exploitation doesn't mean the admitted to foreign workers exploitation doesn't mean the 85 exploitation doesn't mean the 85 students exploitation doesn't mean the 85 students aren't exploitation doesn't mean the 85 students aren't still exploitation doesn't mean the 85 students aren't still here. students aren't still here. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Without <INTERRUPTION> Without wanting <INTERRUPTION> Without wanting to <INTERRUPTION> Without wanting to veer <INTERRUPTION> Without wanting to veer into- <INTERRUPTION> Without wanting to veer into- Order! Without wanting to veer into- Order! We Without wanting to veer into- Order! We will Without wanting to veer into- Order! We will just Without wanting to veer into- Order! We will just have Without wanting to veer into- Order! We will just have the Without wanting to veer into- Order! We will just have the supplementary We will just have the supplementary question. We will just have the supplementary question. No, We will just have the supplementary question. No, no, We will just have the supplementary question. No, no, Steven. We will just have the supplementary question. No, no, Steven. Order! question. No, no, Steven. Order! (INTERRUPTION) (INTERRUPTION) Order! (INTERRUPTION) Order! My (INTERRUPTION) Order! My warning (INTERRUPTION) Order! My warning to (INTERRUPTION) Order! My warning to all (INTERRUPTION) Order! My warning to all members Order! My warning to all members about Order! My warning to all members about the Order! My warning to all members about the level Order! My warning to all members about the level of Order! My warning to all members about the level of the Order! My warning to all members about the level of the noise Order! My warning to all members about the level of the noise and about the level of the noise and interjection about the level of the noise and interjection yesterday about the level of the noise and interjection yesterday now about the level of the noise and interjection yesterday now applies interjection yesterday now applies to interjection yesterday now applies to all interjection yesterday now applies to all members interjection yesterday now applies to all members regardless interjection yesterday now applies to all members regardless of interjection yesterday now applies to all members regardless of their to all members regardless of their seniority. to all members regardless of their seniority. I to all members regardless of their seniority. I am to all members regardless of their seniority. I am asking to all members regardless of their seniority. I am asking Andrew to all members regardless of their seniority. I am asking Andrew Little seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. Thank seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. Thank you. seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. Thank you. Does seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. Thank you. Does he seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. Thank you. Does he or seniority. I am asking Andrew Little to rise. Thank you. Does he or any to rise. Thank you. Does he or any member to rise. Thank you. Does he or any member of to rise. Thank you. Does he or any member of his to rise. Thank you. Does he or any member of his staff to rise. Thank you. Does he or any member of his staff have to rise. Thank you. Does he or any member of his staff have any member of his staff have any knowledge member of his staff have any knowledge of member of his staff have any knowledge of any member of his staff have any knowledge of any person member of his staff have any knowledge of any person advising knowledge of any person advising Todd knowledge of any person advising Todd Barclay knowledge of any person advising Todd Barclay to knowledge of any person advising Todd Barclay to delete knowledge of any person advising Todd Barclay to delete the knowledge of any person advising Todd Barclay to delete the tapes knowledge of any person advising Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who was Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who was it? Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who was it? No, Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who was it? No, I Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who was it? No, I have Todd Barclay to delete the tapes and if so who was it? No, I have no if so who was it? No, I have no further if so who was it? No, I have no further comment if so who was it? No, I have no further comment to if so who was it? No, I have no further comment to add if so who was it? No, I have no further comment to add to if so who was it? No, I have no further comment to add to the further comment to add to the 10-month further comment to add to the 10-month police further comment to add to the 10-month police investigation further comment to add to the 10-month police investigation there 10-month police investigation there has 10-month police investigation there has been 10-month police investigation there has been in 10-month police investigation there has been in relation 10-month police investigation there has been in relation to 10-month police investigation there has been in relation to that 10-month police investigation there has been in relation to that matter. has been in relation to that matter. What has been in relation to that matter. What steps has been in relation to that matter. What steps has has been in relation to that matter. What steps has the has been in relation to that matter. What steps has the Government has been in relation to that matter. What steps has the Government taken What steps has the Government taken that What steps has the Government taken that have What steps has the Government taken that have helped What steps has the Government taken that have helped to What steps has the Government taken that have helped to maintain What steps has the Government taken that have helped to maintain the that have helped to maintain the House's that have helped to maintain the has that have helped to maintain the House's confidence in that have helped to maintain the House's confidence in it? that have helped to maintain the House's confidence in it? The that have helped to maintain the House's confidence in it? The best House's confidence in it? The best thing House's confidence in it? The best thing the House's confidence in it? The best thing the Government House's confidence in it? The best thing the Government can House's confidence in it? The best thing the Government can do House's confidence in it? The best thing the Government can do to thing the Government can do to maintain thing the Government can do to maintain the thing the Government can do to maintain the House's thing the Government can do to maintain the House's confidence thing the Government can do to maintain the House's confidence is maintain the House's confidence is to maintain the House's confidence is to deliver maintain the House's confidence is to deliver for maintain the House's confidence is to deliver for New maintain the House's confidence is to deliver for New Zealanders maintain the House's confidence is to deliver for New Zealanders and to deliver for New Zealanders and maintain to deliver for New Zealanders and maintain their to deliver for New Zealanders and maintain their confidence, to deliver for New Zealanders and maintain their confidence, which to deliver for New Zealanders and maintain their confidence, which is maintain their confidence, which is exactly maintain their confidence, which is exactly what maintain their confidence, which is exactly what we're maintain their confidence, which is exactly what we're doing. maintain their confidence, which is exactly what we're doing. For exactly what we're doing. For instance, exactly what we're doing. For instance, the exactly what we're doing. For instance, the Government's instance, the Government's delivering instance, the Government's delivering more instance, the Government's delivering more jobs, instance, the Government's delivering more jobs, more delivering more jobs, more apprenticeships delivering more jobs, more apprenticeships and delivering more jobs, more apprenticeships and more delivering more jobs, more apprenticeships and more police, apprenticeships and more police, better apprenticeships and more police, better roads, apprenticeships and more police, better roads, better apprenticeships and more police, better roads, better classrooms, apprenticeships and more police, better roads, better classrooms, and better roads, better classrooms, and better better roads, better classrooms, and better broadband, better roads, better classrooms, and better broadband, and better roads, better classrooms, and better broadband, and has better roads, better classrooms, and better broadband, and has enough better broadband, and has enough confidence better broadband, and has enough confidence of better broadband, and has enough confidence of New better broadband, and has enough confidence of New Zealanders better broadband, and has enough confidence of New Zealanders that better broadband, and has enough confidence of New Zealanders that we confidence of New Zealanders that we can confidence of New Zealanders that we can find confidence of New Zealanders that we can find our confidence of New Zealanders that we can find our own confidence of New Zealanders that we can find our own people confidence of New Zealanders that we can find our own people to confidence of New Zealanders that we can find our own people to canvas can find our own people to canvas and can find our own people to canvas and telephone can find our own people to canvas and telephone while can find our own people to canvas and telephone while the can find our own people to canvas and telephone while the Labour can find our own people to canvas and telephone while the Labour Party and telephone while the Labour Party has and telephone while the Labour Party has to and telephone while the Labour Party has to import and telephone while the Labour Party has to import free and telephone while the Labour Party has to import free workers... and telephone while the Labour Party has to import free workers... Order! has to import free workers... Order! <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> . <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. Does <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. Does he <INTERRUPTION> . Supplementary question. Does he or . Supplementary question. Does he or any . Supplementary question. Does he or any member . Supplementary question. Does he or any member of . Supplementary question. Does he or any member of his . Supplementary question. Does he or any member of his staff . Supplementary question. Does he or any member of his staff have . Supplementary question. Does he or any member of his staff have any any member of his staff have any knowledge any member of his staff have any knowledge of any member of his staff have any knowledge of any any member of his staff have any knowledge of any person any member of his staff have any knowledge of any person advising knowledge of any person advising Glenys knowledge of any person advising knowledge knowledge of any person advising Glenys Dickson to knowledge of any person advising Glenys Dickson to withdraw knowledge of any person advising Glenys Dickson to withdraw her Glenys Dickson to withdraw her complaint Glenys Dickson to withdraw her complaint because Glenys Dickson to withdraw her complaint because it Glenys Dickson to withdraw her complaint because it threatened Glenys Dickson to withdraw her complaint because it threatened the complaint because it threatened the Government's complaint because it threatened the Government's majority complaint because it threatened the Government's majority to complaint because it threatened the Government's majority to pass Government's majority to pass legislation. Government's majority to pass legislation. If Government's majority to pass legislation. If so, Government's majority to pass legislation. If so, who Government's majority to pass legislation. If so, who was Government's majority to pass legislation. If so, who was it? Government's majority to pass legislation. If so, who was it? I legislation. If so, who was it? I have legislation. If so, who was it? I have nothing legislation. If so, who was it? I have nothing to legislation. If so, who was it? I have nothing to add legislation. If so, who was it? I have nothing to add to legislation. If so, who was it? I have nothing to add to the have nothing to add to the 10-month... have nothing to add to the 10-month... <INTERRUPTION> 10-month... <INTERRUPTION> The 10-month... <INTERRUPTION> The 10-month 10-month... <INTERRUPTION> The 10-month police 10-month... <INTERRUPTION> The 10-month police investigation The 10-month police investigation into The 10-month police investigation into those The 10-month police investigation into those matters. The 10-month police investigation into those matters. Does The 10-month police investigation into those matters. Does he The 10-month police investigation into those matters. Does he or The 10-month police investigation into those matters. Does he or any into those matters. Does he or any member into those matters. Does he or any member of into those matters. Does he or any member of his into those matters. Does he or any member of his staff into those matters. Does he or any member of his staff have into those matters. Does he or any member of his staff have any member of his staff have any knowledge member of his staff have any knowledge of member of his staff have any knowledge of the member of his staff have any knowledge of the sex member of his staff have any knowledge of the sex and member of his staff have any knowledge of the sex and drugs knowledge of the sex and drugs matters knowledge of the sex and drugs matters Todd knowledge of the sex and drugs matters Todd Barclay knowledge of the sex and drugs matters Todd Barclay was knowledge of the sex and drugs matters Todd Barclay was involved matters Todd Barclay was involved in? matters Todd Barclay was involved in? I matters Todd Barclay was involved in? I have matters Todd Barclay was involved in? I have absolutely matters Todd Barclay was involved in? I have absolutely no matters Todd Barclay was involved in? I have absolutely no ministerial in? I have absolutely no ministerial responsibility in? I have absolutely no ministerial responsibility for in? I have absolutely no ministerial responsibility for whatever in? I have absolutely no ministerial responsibility for whatever matters responsibility for whatever matters he's... responsibility for whatever matters matters responsibility for whatever matters he's... He's... Um... responsibility for whatever matters he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring to. he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring to. But he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring to. But I he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring to. But I know he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring to. But I know he he's... He's... Um... <INTERRUPTION> He is referring to. But I know he is He is referring to. But I know he is responsible He is referring to. But I know he is responsible for He is referring to. But I know he is responsible for 85 He is referring to. But I know he is responsible for 85 foreign He is referring to. But I know he is responsible for 85 foreign workers responsible for 85 foreign workers imported responsible for 85 foreign workers imported to responsible for 85 foreign workers imported to canvas responsible for 85 foreign workers imported to canvas for responsible for 85 foreign workers imported to canvas for the responsible for 85 foreign workers imported to canvas for the Labour imported to canvas for the Labour Party. imported to canvas for the Labour Party. <INTERRUPTION> Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Why Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Why was Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Why was he Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Why was he failed Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Why was he failed to Party. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Why was he failed to report Order! Why was he failed to report his Order! Why was he failed to report his knowledge Order! Why was he failed to report his knowledge of Order! Why was he failed to report his knowledge of potential his knowledge of potential obstruction his knowledge of potential obstruction of his knowledge of potential obstruction of justice his knowledge of potential obstruction of justice in his knowledge of potential obstruction of justice in relation obstruction of justice in relation to obstruction of justice in relation to the obstruction of justice in relation to the police obstruction of justice in relation to the police investigation obstruction of justice in relation to the police investigation of obstruction of justice in relation to the police investigation of Todd to the police investigation of Todd Barclay? to the police investigation of Todd Barclay? Insofar to the police investigation of Todd Barclay? Insofar as to the police investigation of Todd Barclay? Insofar as there to the police investigation of Todd Barclay? Insofar as there may to the police investigation of Todd Barclay? Insofar as there may be Barclay? Insofar as there may be ministerial Barclay? Insofar as there may be ministerial responsibility, Barclay? Insofar as there may be ministerial responsibility, the ministerial responsibility, the right ministerial responsibility, the right haunl ministerial responsibility, the right haunl PM. ministerial responsibility, the right haunl PM. I ministerial responsibility, the right haunl PM. I reject ministerial responsibility, the right haunl PM. I reject the right haunl PM. I reject the member's right haunl PM. I reject the member's assertions. right haunl PM. I reject the member's assertions. Can right haunl PM. I reject the member's assertions. Can he right haunl PM. I reject the member's assertions. Can he confirm member's assertions. Can he confirm that member's assertions. Can he confirm that the member's assertions. Can he confirm that the Government's member's assertions. Can he confirm that the Government's tam member's assertions. Can he confirm that the Government's tam rack member's assertions. Can he confirm that the Government's tam rack can member's assertions. Can he confirm that the Government's tam rack can I that the Government's tam rack can I bill, that the Government's tam rack can I bill, local that the Government's tam rack can I bill, local Government that the Government's tam rack can I bill, local Government bill, that the Government's tam rack can I bill, local Government bill, and that the Government's tam rack can I bill, local Government bill, and the bill, local Government bill, and the employment bill, local Government bill, and the employment relations bill, local Government bill, and the employment relations bill bill, local Government bill, and the employment relations bill are employment relations bill are reliant employment relations bill are reliant on employment relations bill are reliant on a employment relations bill are reliant on a single employment relations bill are reliant on a single vote employment relations bill are reliant on a single vote to employment relations bill are reliant on a single vote to pass employment relations bill are reliant on a single vote to pass and reliant on a single vote to pass and would reliant on a single vote to pass and would fail reliant on a single vote to pass and would fail if reliant on a single vote to pass and would fail if Todd reliant on a single vote to pass and would fail if Todd Barclay reliant on a single vote to pass and would fail if Todd Barclay resigned would fail if Todd Barclay resigned immediately? would fail if Todd Barclay resigned immediately? I would fail if Todd Barclay resigned immediately? I can would fail if Todd Barclay resigned immediately? I can confirm would fail if Todd Barclay resigned immediately? I can confirm the immediately? I can confirm the Government's immediately? I can confirm the Government's always immediately? I can confirm the Government's always operated immediately? I can confirm the Government's always operated on immediately? I can confirm the Government's always operated on a Government's always operated on a slim Government's always operated on a Government's Government's always operated on a slim majority for Government's always operated on a slim majority for to Government's always operated on a slim majority for to whole Government's always operated on a slim majority for to whole time Government's always operated on a slim majority for to whole time it slim majority for to whole time it has slim majority for to whole time it has been slim majority for to whole time it has been in slim majority for to whole time it has been in Government. slim majority for to whole time it has been in Government. And slim majority for to whole time it has been in Government. And I slim majority for to whole time it has been in Government. And I can has been in Government. And I can also has been in Government. And I can also confirm has been in Government. And I can also confirm that has been in Government. And I can also confirm that the has been in Government. And I can also confirm that the - has been in Government. And I can also confirm that the - while has been in Government. And I can also confirm that the - while we has been in Government. And I can also confirm that the - while we are also confirm that the - while we are reliant also confirm that the - while we are reliant on also confirm that the - while we are reliant on a also confirm that the - while we are reliant on a small also confirm that the - while we are reliant on a small majority, also confirm that the - while we are reliant on a small majority, the reliant on a small majority, the Labour reliant on a small majority, the Labour Party reliant on a small majority, the Labour Party # reliant on a small majority, the Labour Party # -- reliant on a small majority, the Labour Party # -- the reliant on a small majority, the Labour Party # -- the Labour reliant on a small majority, the Labour Party # -- the Labour Party Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is reliant Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is reliant on Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is reliant on foreign Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is reliant on foreign workers Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is reliant on foreign workers to Labour Party # -- the Labour Party is reliant on foreign workers to do is reliant on foreign workers to do its is reliant on foreign workers to do its campaigning is reliant on foreign workers to do its campaigning for is reliant on foreign workers to do its campaigning for it. its campaigning for it. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> supplementary Order! <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Order! <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Why Order! <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Why is Order! <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. Why is he supplementary question. Why is he prepared supplementary question. Why is he prepared for supplementary question. Why is he prepared for his supplementary question. Why is he prepared for his Government's prepared for his Government's support prepared for his Government's support in prepared for his Government's support in this prepared for his Government's support in this House prepared for his Government's support in this House to prepared for his Government's support in this House to rest prepared for his Government's support in this House to rest on prepared for his Government's support in this House to rest on a support in this House to rest on a person support in this House to rest on a person whose support in this House to rest on a person whose behaviour support in this House to rest on a person whose behaviour the support in this House to rest on a person whose behaviour the PM person whose behaviour the PM described person whose behaviour the PM described as person whose behaviour the PM described as unacceptable, person whose behaviour the PM described as unacceptable, who described as unacceptable, who recorded described as unacceptable, who recorded his described as unacceptable, who recorded his staff, described as unacceptable, who recorded his staff, who described as unacceptable, who recorded his staff, who has described as unacceptable, who recorded his staff, who has refused recorded his staff, who has refused to recorded his staff, who has refused to cooperate recorded his staff, who has refused to cooperate with recorded his staff, who has refused to cooperate with the recorded his staff, who has refused to cooperate with the police, recorded his staff, who has refused to cooperate with the police, and to cooperate with the police, and whose to cooperate with the police, and whose conduct to cooperate with the police, and whose conduct has to cooperate with the police, and whose conduct has fallen to cooperate with the police, and whose conduct has fallen so to cooperate with the police, and whose conduct has fallen so far whose conduct has fallen so far below whose conduct has fallen so far below acceptable whose conduct has fallen so far below acceptable standards whose conduct has fallen so far below acceptable standards that whose conduct has fallen so far below acceptable standards that he's below acceptable standards that he's felt below acceptable standards that he's below below acceptable standards that he's felt the need below acceptable standards that he's felt the need to below acceptable standards that he's felt the need to leave below acceptable standards that he's felt the need to leave Parliament? felt the need to leave Parliament? Or felt the need to leave Parliament? Or is felt the need to leave Parliament? Or is that felt the need to leave Parliament? Or is that the felt the need to leave Parliament? Or is that the Bill felt the need to leave Parliament? Or is that the Bill English felt the need to leave Parliament? Or is that the Bill English way? Or is that the Bill English way? Again, Or is that the Bill English way? Again, I Or is that the Bill English way? Again, I reject Or is that the Bill English way? Again, I reject the Or is that the Bill English way? Again, I reject the member's Again, I reject the member's assertions. Again, I reject the member's assertions. This Again, I reject the member's assertions. This Parliament Again, I reject the member's assertions. This Parliament includes assertions. This Parliament includes the assertions. This Parliament includes the party assertions. This Parliament includes the party that assertions. This Parliament includes the party that has assertions. This Parliament includes the party that has imported assertions. This Parliament includes the party that has imported 85 the party that has imported 85 foreign the party that has imported 85 foreign workers the party that has imported 85 foreign workers that the party that has imported 85 foreign workers that won't the party that has imported 85 foreign workers that won't pay the party that has imported 85 foreign workers that won't pay to the party that has imported 85 foreign workers that won't pay to - foreign workers that won't pay to - just foreign workers that won't pay to - just to foreign workers that won't pay to - just to keep foreign workers that won't pay to - just to keep it foreign workers that won't pay to - just to keep it as foreign workers that won't pay to - just to keep it as a foreign workers that won't pay to - just to keep it as a viable just to keep it as a viable opposition. just to keep it as a viable opposition. <INTERRUPTION> opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does he opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does he agree opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does he agree with opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does he agree with his opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does he agree with his old opposition. <INTERRUPTION> Does he agree with his old local Does he agree with his old local paper, Does he agree with his old local paper, the Does he agree with his old local paper, the Southland Does he agree with his old local paper, the Southland Times Does he agree with his old local paper, the Southland Times that, paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics is paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics is not paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics is not a paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics is not a game paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics is not a game in paper, the Southland Times that, "Politics is not a game in which "Politics is not a game in which bluffing "Politics is not a game in which bluffing and "Politics is not a game in which bluffing and misdirection "Politics is not a game in which bluffing and misdirection are "Politics is not a game in which bluffing and misdirection are to "Politics is not a game in which bluffing and misdirection are to be bluffing and misdirection are to be placidly bluffing and misdirection are to be placidly accepted bluffing and misdirection are to be placidly accepted as bluffing and misdirection are to be placidly accepted as tactical placidly accepted as tactical necessities, placidly accepted as tactical necessities, and placidly accepted as tactical necessities, and isn't placidly accepted as tactical necessities, and isn't it placidly accepted as tactical necessities, and isn't it time placidly accepted as tactical necessities, and isn't it time to necessities, and isn't it time to cut necessities, and isn't it time to cut the necessities, and isn't it time to cut the crap necessities, and isn't it time to cut the crap and necessities, and isn't it time to cut the crap and come necessities, and isn't it time to cut the crap and come clean necessities, and isn't it time to cut the crap and come clean on necessities, and isn't it time to cut the crap and come clean on the cut the crap and come clean on the Barclay cut the crap and come clean on the Barclay cover-up?" cut the crap and come clean on the Barclay cover-up?" (INTERRUPTION) Barclay cover-up?" (INTERRUPTION) Again... Barclay cover-up?" (INTERRUPTION) Again... Order! Barclay cover-up?" (INTERRUPTION) Again... Order! Again, Barclay cover-up?" (INTERRUPTION) Again... Order! Again, insofar Barclay cover-up?" (INTERRUPTION) Again... Order! Again, insofar as Again... Order! Again, insofar as there Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be PM... Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be PM... No. Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be PM... No. But Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be PM... No. But nor Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be PM... No. But nor do Again... Order! Again, insofar as there may be PM... No. But nor do I there may be PM... No. But nor do I think there may be PM... No. But nor do I think politics there may be PM... No. But nor do I think politics is there may be PM... No. But nor do I think politics is a there may be PM... No. But nor do I think politics is a game there may be PM... No. But nor do I think politics is a game where there may be PM... No. But nor do I think politics is a game where you think politics is a game where you import think politics is a game where you import cheap think politics is a game where you import cheap foreign think politics is a game where you import cheap foreign labour think politics is a game where you import cheap foreign labour to think politics is a game where you import cheap foreign labour to try import cheap foreign labour to try and import cheap foreign labour to try and beat import cheap foreign labour to try and beat up import cheap foreign labour to try and beat up your import cheap foreign labour to try and beat up your public import cheap foreign labour to try and beat up your public support. and beat up your public support. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question No. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question No. 3. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question No. 3. Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question No. 3. Order! I <INTERRUPTION> Order! Question No. 3. Order! I gave Order! Question No. 3. Order! I gave warnings Order! Question No. 3. Order! I gave warnings earlier. Order! Question No. 3. Order! I gave warnings earlier. Chris Order! Question No. 3. Order! I gave warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins Order! warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't managed to warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't managed to hear warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't managed to hear it. warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't managed to hear it. So warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't managed to hear it. So I warnings earlier. Chris Hipkins hasn't managed to hear it. So I now hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct it hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct it to hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct it to him hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct it to him specifically. hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct it to him specifically. If hasn't managed to hear it. So I now direct it to him specifically. If he direct it to him specifically. If he continues direct it to him specifically. If he continues to direct it to him specifically. If he continues to interrupt, direct it to him specifically. If he continues to interrupt, at direct it to him specifically. If he continues to interrupt, at that direct it to him specifically. If he continues to interrupt, at that sort continues to interrupt, at that sort of continues to interrupt, at that sort direct continues to interrupt, at that sort of level, then continues to interrupt, at that sort of level, then I continues to interrupt, at that sort of level, then I will continues to interrupt, at that sort of level, then I will be continues to interrupt, at that sort of level, then I will be asking continues to interrupt, at that sort of level, then I will be asking him of level, then I will be asking him to of level, then I will be asking him to leave of level, then I will be asking him to leave early. of level, then I will be asking him to leave early. Sarah of level, then I will be asking him to leave early. Sarah Dowie, to leave early. Sarah Dowie, Question to leave early. Sarah Dowie, Question No. to leave early. Sarah Dowie, Question No. 3. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: My question is to the Minister of Health: What My question is to the Minister of Health: What work My question is to the Minister of Health: What work is My question is to the Minister of Health: What work is being Health: What work is being undertaken Health: What work is being undertaken to Health: What work is being undertaken to ensure Health: What work is being undertaken to ensure that Health: What work is being undertaken to ensure that from Health: What work is being undertaken to ensure that from 1 undertaken to ensure that from 1 July undertaken to ensure that from 1 July 2017, undertaken to ensure that from 1 July 2017, 55,000 undertaken to ensure that from 1 July 2017, 55,000 care undertaken to ensure that from 1 July 2017, 55,000 care and undertaken to ensure that from 1 July 2017, 55,000 care and support July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers will July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers will begin July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers will begin to July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers will begin to be July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers will begin to be paid July 2017, 55,000 care and support workers will begin to be paid their workers will begin to be paid their share workers will begin to be paid their share of workers will begin to be paid their share of the workers will begin to be paid their share of the $2 workers will begin to be paid their share of the $2 billion workers will begin to be paid their share of the $2 billion pay workers will begin to be paid their share of the $2 billion pay equity share of the $2 billion pay equity settlement share of the $2 billion pay equity settlement announced share of the $2 billion pay equity settlement announced earlier share of the $2 billion pay equity settlement announced earlier this settlement announced earlier this year? Since Since the Since the settlement Since the settlement was Since the settlement was announced Since the settlement was announced in Since the settlement was announced in April, Since the settlement was announced in April, I Since the settlement was announced in April, I have Since the settlement was announced in April, I have been Since the settlement was announced in April, I have been receiving in April, I have been receiving regular in April, I have been receiving regular updates in April, I have been receiving regular updates on in April, I have been receiving regular updates on the regular updates on the implementation. regular updates on the implementation. I'm regular updates on the implementation. I'm assured regular updates on the implementation. I'm assured by regular updates on the implementation. I'm assured by the implementation. I'm assured by the officials implementation. I'm assured by the officials that implementation. I'm assured by the officials that the implementation. I'm assured by the officials that the implementation implementation. I'm assured by the officials that the implementation is officials that the implementation is on officials that the implementation is officials officials that the implementation is on track. I officials that the implementation is on track. I have officials that the implementation is on track. I have been officials that the implementation is on track. I have been advised officials that the implementation is on track. I have been advised that on track. I have been advised that all on track. I have been advised that all providers on track. I have been advised that all providers have on track. I have been advised that all providers have indicated on track. I have been advised that all providers have indicated that all providers have indicated that they all providers have indicated that all all providers have indicated that they are ready all providers have indicated that they are ready to all providers have indicated that they are ready to pay all providers have indicated that they are ready to pay eligible they are ready to pay eligible employees they are ready to pay eligible employees the they are ready to pay eligible employees the increased they are ready to pay eligible employees the increased hourly they are ready to pay eligible employees the increased hourly wages employees the increased hourly wages from employees the increased hourly wages employees employees the increased hourly wages from 1 July. employees the increased hourly wages from 1 July. Funds employees the increased hourly wages from 1 July. Funds will employees the increased hourly wages from 1 July. Funds will be from 1 July. Funds will be transferred from 1 July. Funds will be transferred to from 1 July. Funds will be transferred to 653 from 1 July. Funds will be transferred to 653 providers from 1 July. Funds will be transferred to 653 providers by from 1 July. Funds will be transferred to 653 providers by the transferred to 653 providers by the end transferred to 653 providers by the end of transferred to 653 providers by the end of this transferred to 653 providers by the end of this week, transferred to 653 providers by the end of this week, and transferred to 653 providers by the end of this week, and that transferred to 653 providers by the end of this week, and that will end of this week, and that will enable end of this week, and that will enable providers end of this week, and that will enable providers to end of this week, and that will enable providers to have end of this week, and that will enable providers to have funds end of this week, and that will enable providers to have funds in enable providers to have funds in their enable providers to have funds in their accounts enable providers to have funds in their accounts to enable providers to have funds in their accounts to pay enable providers to have funds in their accounts to pay the enable providers to have funds in their accounts to pay the 55,000 their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers from their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers from next their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers from next week. their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers from next week. This their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers from next week. This is their accounts to pay the 55,000 workers from next week. This is part workers from next week. This is part of workers from next week. This is part of this workers from next week. This is part of this year's workers from next week. This is part of this year's $880 workers from next week. This is part of this year's $880 million workers from next week. This is part of this year's $880 million increase of this year's $880 million increase in of this year's $880 million increase in Vote of this year's $880 million increase in Vote Health, of this year's $880 million increase in Vote Health, the of this year's $880 million increase in Vote Health, the largest of this year's $880 million increase in Vote Health, the largest increase in Vote Health, the largest increase in in Vote Health, the largest increase in 11 in Vote Health, the largest increase in 11 years. in Vote Health, the largest increase in 11 years. Thank in Vote Health, the largest increase in 11 years. Thank you. in Vote Health, the largest increase in 11 years. Thank you. To in Vote Health, the largest increase in 11 years. Thank you. To the in 11 years. Thank you. To the Minister: in 11 years. Thank you. To the Minister: Can in 11 years. Thank you. To the Minister: Can the in 11 years. Thank you. To the Minister: Can the Minister in 11 years. Thank you. To the Minister: Can the Minister confirm Minister: Can the Minister confirm how Minister: Can the Minister confirm how much Minister: Can the Minister confirm how much extra Minister: Can the Minister confirm how much extra employees Minister: Can the Minister confirm how much extra employees will how much extra employees will receive how much extra employees will receive from how much extra employees will receive from the how much extra employees will receive from the settlement? how much extra employees will receive from the settlement? This receive from the settlement? This dedicated receive from the settlement? This dedicated and receive from the settlement? This dedicated and predominantly receive from the settlement? This dedicated and predominantly female dedicated and predominantly female workforce, dedicated and predominantly female workforce, who dedicated and predominantly female workforce, who are dedicated and predominantly female workforce, who are mostly dedicated and predominantly female workforce, who are mostly on dedicated and predominantly female workforce, who are mostly on or workforce, who are mostly on or around workforce, who are mostly on or around the workforce, who are mostly on or around the minimum workforce, who are mostly on or around the minimum wage, workforce, who are mostly on or around the minimum wage, will around the minimum wage, will receive around the minimum wage, will receive a around the minimum wage, will receive a pay around the minimum wage, will receive a pay rise around the minimum wage, will receive a pay rise between around the minimum wage, will receive a pay rise between around around the minimum wage, will receive a pay rise between around 15 receive a pay rise between around 15 and receive a pay rise between around 15 and 50%, receive a pay rise between around 15 and 50%, depending receive a pay rise between around 15 and 50%, depending on receive a pay rise between around 15 and 50%, depending on their and 50%, depending on their experience and 50%, depending on their experience and/or and 50%, depending on their experience and/or their experience and/or their qualifications. experience and/or their qualifications. For experience and/or their qualifications. For the experience and/or their qualifications. For the 20,000 qualifications. For the 20,000 workers qualifications. For the 20,000 workers currently qualifications. For the 20,000 workers currently on qualifications. For the 20,000 workers currently on the qualifications. For the 20,000 workers currently on the minimum workers currently on the minimum wage, workers currently on the minimum wage, it workers currently on the minimum wage, it means workers currently on the minimum wage, it means they workers currently on the minimum wage, it means they will workers currently on the minimum wage, it means they will move workers currently on the minimum wage, it means they will move to workers currently on the minimum wage, it means they will move to at wage, it means they will move to at least wage, it means they will move to at least $19 wage, it means they will move to at least $19 per wage, it means they will move to at least $19 per hour, wage, it means they will move to at least $19 per hour, a wage, it means they will move to at least $19 per hour, a 21% wage, it means they will move to at least $19 per hour, a 21% pay wage, it means they will move to at least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. For least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. For a least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. For a full-time least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. For a full-time worker, least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. For a full-time worker, this least $19 per hour, a 21% pay rise. For a full-time worker, this means For a full-time worker, this means they For a full-time worker, this means they will For a full-time worker, this means they will be For a full-time worker, this means they will be taking For a full-time worker, this means they will be taking home For a full-time worker, this means they will be taking home around For a full-time worker, this means they will be taking home around an they will be taking home around an extra they will be taking home around an extra $100 they will be taking home around an extra $100 a they will be taking home around an extra $100 a week, they will be taking home around an extra $100 a week, which they will be taking home around an extra $100 a week, which is they will be taking home around an extra $100 a week, which is over extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 per extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 per year extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 per year in extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 per year in the extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 per year in the hand. extra $100 a week, which is over $5,000 per year in the hand. This $5,000 per year in the hand. This will $5,000 per year in the hand. This will make $5,000 per year in the hand. This will make a $5,000 per year in the hand. This will make a massive $5,000 per year in the hand. This will make a massive difference $5,000 per year in the hand. This will make a massive difference to will make a massive difference to some will make a massive difference to some of will make a massive difference to some of the will make a massive difference to some of the hardest will make a massive difference to some of the hardest working, will make a massive difference to some of the hardest working, most some of the hardest working, most deserving, some of the hardest working, most deserving, but some of the hardest working, most deserving, but lowest-paid some of the hardest working, most deserving, but lowest-paid people some of the hardest working, most deserving, but lowest-paid people in deserving, but lowest-paid people in this deserving, but lowest-paid people in this country deserving, but lowest-paid people in this country and deserving, but lowest-paid people in this country and their deserving, but lowest-paid people in this country and their families. this country and their families. <INTERRUPTION> My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he recall My question is to the Minister of Finance: Does he recall his Finance: Does he recall his statement, Finance: Does he recall his statement, "I'm Finance: Does he recall his statement, "I'm sure Finance: Does he recall his statement, "I'm sure we'll Finance: Does he recall his statement, "I'm sure we'll talk statement, "I'm sure we'll talk about statement, "I'm sure we'll talk about tax statement, "I'm sure we'll talk about tax policy statement, "I'm sure we'll talk about tax policy again statement, "I'm sure we'll talk about tax policy again between statement, "I'm sure we'll talk about tax policy again between now about tax policy again between now and about tax policy again between now and the about tax policy again between now and the election about tax policy again between now and the election but about tax policy again between now and the election but we'll about tax policy again between now and the election but we'll deal about tax policy again between now and the election but we'll deal with and the election but we'll deal with that and the election but we'll deal with that at and the election but we'll deal with that at the and the election but we'll deal with that at the time"; and the election but we'll deal with that at the time"; if and the election but we'll deal with that at the time"; if so, and the election but we'll deal with that at the time"; if so, were and the election but we'll deal with that at the time"; if so, were the that at the time"; if so, were the Prime that at the time"; if so, were the Prime Minister's that at the time"; if so, were the Prime Minister's "hints" that at the time"; if so, were the Prime Minister's "hints" of that at the time"; if so, were the Prime Minister's "hints" of further Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts in Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts in the Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts in the weekend Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts in the weekend what Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts in the weekend what he Prime Minister's "hints" of further tax cuts in the weekend what he was tax cuts in the weekend what he was referring tax cuts in the weekend what he was referring to? Yes. Yes. I Yes. I recall Yes. I recall making Yes. I recall making that Yes. I recall making that statement Yes. I recall making that statement the Yes. I recall making that statement the day Yes. I recall making that statement the day after Yes. I recall making that statement the day after the Yes. I recall making that statement the day after the Budget. Yes. I recall making that statement the day after the Budget. In Yes. I recall making that statement the day after the Budget. In terms the day after the Budget. In terms of the day after the Budget. In terms of further the day after the Budget. In terms of further discussions the day after the Budget. In terms of further discussions about the day after the Budget. In terms of further discussions about tax of further discussions about tax policy, of further discussions about tax policy, my of further discussions about tax policy, my comments of further discussions about tax policy, my comments related of further discussions about tax policy, my comments related to of further discussions about tax policy, my comments related to the policy, my comments related to the fact policy, my comments related to the fact that policy, my comments related to the fact that between policy, my comments related to the fact that between the policy, my comments related to the fact that between the Budget policy, my comments related to the fact that between the Budget and fact that between the Budget and election fact that between the Budget and election day, fact that between the Budget and election day, the fact that between the Budget and election day, the issue fact that between the Budget and election day, the issue of fact that between the Budget and election day, the issue of tax election day, the issue of tax policy election day, the issue of tax policy would election day, the issue of tax policy would likely election day, the issue of tax policy would likely be election day, the issue of tax policy would likely be raised election day, the issue of tax policy would likely be raised many policy would likely be raised many times. policy would likely be raised many times. The policy would likely be raised many times. The member policy would likely be raised many times. The member is policy would likely be raised many times. The member is right policy would likely be raised many times. The member is right to policy would likely be raised many times. The member is right to be times. The member is right to be observant times. The member is right to be observant to times. The member is right to be observant to work times. The member is right to be observant to work out times. The member is right to be observant to work out that times. The member is right to be observant to work out that the times. The member is right to be observant to work out that the PM's observant to work out that the PM's statement observant to work out that the PM's statement of observant to work out that the PM's statement of priorities observant to work out that the PM's statement of priorities on observant to work out that the PM's statement of priorities on the statement of priorities on the weekend statement of priorities on the weekend was, statement of priorities on the weekend was, indeed, statement of priorities on the weekend was, indeed, one statement of priorities on the weekend was, indeed, one of statement of priorities on the weekend was, indeed, one of those weekend was, indeed, one of those times. weekend was, indeed, one of those times. <INTERRUPTION> times. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary times. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. times. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. What times. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. What is times. <INTERRUPTION> supplementary question. What is the supplementary question. What is the fiscal supplementary question. What is the fiscal impact supplementary question. What is the fiscal impact of supplementary question. What is the fiscal impact of the supplementary question. What is the fiscal impact of the new supplementary question. What is the fiscal impact of the new proposed fiscal impact of the new proposed further fiscal impact of the new proposed further round fiscal impact of the new proposed further round of fiscal impact of the new proposed further round of tax fiscal impact of the new proposed further round of tax cuts fiscal impact of the new proposed further round of tax cuts on fiscal impact of the new proposed further round of tax cuts on the further round of tax cuts on the Budget further round of tax cuts on the Budget and further round of tax cuts on the Budget and economic further round of tax cuts on the Budget and economic fiscal further round of tax cuts on the Budget and economic fiscal update Budget and economic fiscal update released Budget and economic fiscal update released in Budget and economic fiscal update released in May? Budget and economic fiscal update released in May? The Budget and economic fiscal update released in May? The member Budget and economic fiscal update released in May? The member should released in May? The member should note released in May? The member should note that released in May? The member should note that the released in May? The member should note that the Government released in May? The member should note that the Government and released in May? The member should note that the Government and the released in May? The member should note that the Government and the PM note that the Government and the PM made note that the Government and the PM made the note that the Government and the PM made the comments note that the Government and the PM made the comments on note that the Government and the PM made the comments on the note that the Government and the PM made the comments on the weekend made the comments on the weekend that made the comments on the weekend that if made the comments on the weekend that if we made the comments on the weekend that if we get made the comments on the weekend that if we get the made the comments on the weekend that if we get the economy made the comments on the weekend that if we get the economy to made the comments on the weekend that if we get the economy to grow that if we get the economy to grow faster, that if we get the economy to grow faster, then that if we get the economy to grow faster, then we that if we get the economy to grow faster, then we would that if we get the economy to grow faster, then we would have that if we get the economy to grow faster, then we would have the that if we get the economy to grow faster, then we would have the room faster, then we would have the room to faster, then we would have the room to do faster, then we would have the room to do more. faster, then we would have the room to do more. That faster, then we would have the room to do more. That implies faster, then we would have the room to do more. That implies faster faster, then we would have the room to do more. That implies faster than to do more. That implies faster than the to do more. That implies faster than the current to do more. That implies faster than the current Budget to do more. That implies faster than the current Budget position, to do more. That implies faster than the current Budget position, and the current Budget position, and that the current Budget position, and that is the current Budget position, and that is indeed the current Budget position, and that is indeed what the current Budget position, and that is indeed what the the current Budget position, and that is indeed what the PM the current Budget position, and that is indeed what the PM was that is indeed what the PM was referring that is indeed what the PM was referring to. that is indeed what the PM was referring to. So, that is indeed what the PM was referring to. So, on that is indeed what the PM was referring to. So, on the that is indeed what the PM was referring to. So, on the basis that is indeed what the PM was referring to. So, on the basis that referring to. So, on the basis that the referring to. So, on the basis that the economy referring to. So, on the basis that the economy grows referring to. So, on the basis that the economy grows more referring to. So, on the basis that the economy grows more strongly, referring to. So, on the basis that the economy grows more strongly, and the economy grows more strongly, and the the economy grows more strongly, and the Government's the economy grows more strongly, and the Government's fiscal the economy grows more strongly, and the Government's fiscal position the economy grows more strongly, and the Government's fiscal position is the Government's fiscal position is contained, the Government's fiscal position is contained, then the Government's fiscal position is contained, then we the Government's fiscal position is contained, then we would the Government's fiscal position is contained, then we would have the Government's fiscal position is contained, then we would have the contained, then we would have the opportunity contained, then we would have the opportunity to contained, then we would have the opportunity to potentially contained, then we would have the opportunity to potentially do contained, then we would have the opportunity to potentially do more opportunity to potentially do more over opportunity to potentially do more over the opportunity to potentially do more over the next opportunity to potentially do more over the next term opportunity to potentially do more over the next term of opportunity to potentially do more over the next term of Government. over the next term of Government. Supplementary over the next term of Government. Supplementary question. over the next term of Government. Supplementary question. Further over the next term of Government. Supplementary question. Further to Supplementary question. Further to that Supplementary question. Further to that answer, Supplementary question. Further to that answer, is Supplementary question. Further to that answer, is the Supplementary question. Further to that answer, is the Minister Supplementary question. Further to that answer, is the Minister of that answer, is the Minister of Finance that answer, is the Minister of Finance confirming that answer, is the Minister of Finance confirming he that answer, is the Minister of Finance confirming he has that answer, is the Minister of Finance confirming he has made that answer, is the Minister of Finance confirming he has made no Finance confirming he has made no attempt Finance confirming he has made no opportunity Finance confirming he has made no attempt to gauge Finance confirming he has made no attempt to gauge the Finance confirming he has made no attempt to gauge the fiscal Finance confirming he has made no attempt to gauge the fiscal impact attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of the attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of the proposed attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of the proposed second attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of the proposed second round attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of the proposed second round of attempt to gauge the fiscal impact of the proposed second round of tax of the proposed second round of tax cuts of the proposed second round of tax cuts that of the proposed second round of tax cuts that the of the proposed second round of tax cuts that the PM of the proposed second round of tax cuts that the PM noted of the proposed second round of tax cuts that the PM noted on of the proposed second round of tax cuts that the PM noted on the cuts that the PM noted on the weekend? cuts that the PM noted on the weekend? Sherlock cuts that the PM noted on the weekend? Sherlock over cuts that the PM noted on the weekend? Sherlock over there cuts that the PM noted on the weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite worked weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite worked out weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite worked out that weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite worked out that the weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite worked out that the PM weekend? Sherlock over there hasn't quite worked out that the PM said quite worked out that the PM said that quite worked out that the PM said that he quite worked out that the PM said that he would quite worked out that the PM said that he would like quite worked out that the PM said that he would like the quite worked out that the PM said that he would like the opportunity that he would like the opportunity to that he would like the opportunity to do that he would like the opportunity to do it that he would like the opportunity to do it again, that he would like the opportunity to do it again, and that he would like the opportunity to do it again, and that that he would like the opportunity to do it again, and that if that he would like the opportunity to do it again, and that if we that he would like the opportunity to do it again, and that if we got to do it again, and that if we got the to do it again, and that if we got the room, to do it again, and that if we got the room, we to do it again, and that if we got the room, we would to do it again, and that if we got the room, we would be to do it again, and that if we got the room, we would be able to do it again, and that if we got the room, we would be able to to do it again, and that if we got the room, we would be able to do to do it again, and that if we got the room, we would be able to do so. the room, we would be able to do so. Of the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, we the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, we have the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, we have to the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, we have to first the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, we have to first get the room, we would be able to do so. Of course, we have to first get the Of course, we have to first get the Family Of course, we have to first get the Family Income Of course, we have to first get the Family Income Package Of course, we have to first get the Family Income Package into Family Income Package into Government, Family Income Package into Government, into Family Income Package into Government, into place Family Income Package into Government, into place on Family Income Package into Government, into place on 1 Family Income Package into Government, into place on 1 April Government, into place on 1 April next Government, into place on 1 April next year. Government, into place on 1 April next year. I Government, into place on 1 April next year. I note Government, into place on 1 April next year. I note the Government, into place on 1 April next year. I note the Labour Government, into place on 1 April next year. I note the Labour Party next year. I note the Labour Party is next year. I note the Labour Party is still next year. I note the Labour Party is still opposed next year. I note the Labour Party is still opposed to next year. I note the Labour Party is still opposed to the next year. I note the Labour Party is still opposed to the family is still opposed to the family income is still opposed to the family income package, is still opposed to the family income package, so is still opposed to the family income package, so we is still opposed to the family income package, so we have is still opposed to the family income package, so we have to is still opposed to the family income package, so we have to deal income package, so we have to deal with income package, so we have to deal with that income package, so we have to deal with that one income package, so we have to deal with that one first. income package, so we have to deal with that one first. Point income package, so we have to deal with that one first. Point of income package, so we have to deal with that one first. Point of order. with that one first. Point of order. Point with that one first. Point of order. Point of with that one first. Point of order. Point of order. with that one first. Point of order. Point of order. Two with that one first. Point of order. Point of order. Two points with that one first. Point of order. Point of order. Two points of with that one first. Point of order. Point of order. Two points of order. Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, two Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, two points. Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, two points. The Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, two points. The first Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, two points. The first of... Point of order. Two points of order. Oh, two points. The first of... The Oh, two points. The first of... The first Oh, two points. The first of... The first of Oh, two points. The first of... The first of those Oh, two points. The first of... The first of those is Oh, two points. The first of... The first of those is that Oh, two points. The first of... The first of those is that Mr Oh, two points. The first of... The first of those is that Mr Joyce Oh, two points. The first of... The first of those is that Mr Joyce has first of those is that Mr Joyce has been first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here a first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here a long first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here a long time first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here a long time and first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here a long time and he first of those is that Mr Joyce has been here a long time and he knows been here a long time and he knows not been here a long time and he knows not to been here a long time and he knows not to refer been here a long time and he knows not to refer to been here a long time and he knows not to refer to members been here a long time and he knows not to refer to members by been here a long time and he knows not to refer to members by anything not to refer to members by anything other not to refer to members by anything other than not to refer to members by anything other than their not to refer to members by anything other than their name not to refer to members by anything other than their name or not to refer to members by anything other than their name or their other than their name or their electorate other than their name or their electorate that other than their name or their electorate that they other than their name or their electorate that they represent. other than their name or their electorate that they represent. The electorate that they represent. The second electorate that they represent. The second point electorate that they represent. The second point of electorate that they represent. The second point of order electorate that they represent. The second point of order is electorate that they represent. The second point of order is that electorate that they represent. The second point of order is that I second point of order is that I asked second point of order is that I second second point of order is that I asked him a second point of order is that I asked him a very second point of order is that I asked him a very - second point of order is that I asked him a very - well, second point of order is that I asked him a very - well, I second point of order is that I asked him a very - well, I asked second point of order is that I asked him a very - well, I asked him asked him a very - well, I asked him a asked him a very - well, I asked him a straight asked him a very - well, I asked him a straight question asked him a very - well, I asked him a straight question then, asked him a very - well, I asked him a straight question then, a asked him a very - well, I asked him a straight question then, a specific a straight question then, a specific follow-up a straight question then, a specific follow-up question a straight question then, a specific follow-up question to a straight question then, a specific follow-up question to assess a straight question then, a specific follow-up question to assess whether follow-up question to assess whether or follow-up question to assess whether follow-up follow-up question to assess whether or not any follow-up question to assess whether or not any work follow-up question to assess whether or not any work had follow-up question to assess whether or not any work had been follow-up question to assess whether or not any work had been done follow-up question to assess whether or not any work had been done on follow-up question to assess whether or not any work had been done on the or not any work had been done on the fiscal or not any work had been done on the fiscal impact or not any work had been done on the fiscal impact of or not any work had been done on the fiscal impact of proposed or not any work had been done on the fiscal impact of proposed second fiscal impact of proposed second round fiscal impact of proposed second round of fiscal impact of proposed second round of tax fiscal impact of proposed second round of tax cuts. fiscal impact of proposed second round of tax cuts. He fiscal impact of proposed second round of tax cuts. He didn't fiscal impact of proposed second round of tax cuts. He didn't answer round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that question. round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that question. OK. round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that question. OK. I round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that question. OK. I have round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that question. OK. I have missed round of tax cuts. He didn't answer that question. OK. I have missed the that question. OK. I have missed the point that question. OK. I have missed the point in that question. OK. I have missed the point in the that question. OK. I have missed the point in the answer that question. OK. I have missed the point in the answer where that question. OK. I have missed the point in the answer where Mr that question. OK. I have missed the point in the answer where Mr Joyce point in the answer where Mr Joyce may point in the answer where Mr Joyce may not point in the answer where Mr Joyce may not have point in the answer where Mr Joyce may not have referred point in the answer where Mr Joyce may not have referred to point in the answer where Mr Joyce may not have referred to the point in the answer where Mr Joyce may not have referred to the member may not have referred to the member correctly. may not have referred to the member correctly. I may not have referred to the member correctly. I apologise. may not have referred to the member correctly. I apologise. I may not have referred to the member correctly. I apologise. I missed correctly. I apologise. I missed that correctly. I apologise. I missed that because correctly. I apologise. I missed that because I correctly. I apologise. I missed that because I was correctly. I apologise. I missed that because I was busily correctly. I apologise. I missed that because I was busily looking that because I was busily looking through that because I was busily looking through my that because I was busily looking through my Speaker's that because I was busily looking through my Speaker's ruling that because I was busily looking through my Speaker's ruling because through my Speaker's ruling because I through my Speaker's ruling because I knew through my Speaker's ruling because I knew the through my Speaker's ruling because I knew the member through my Speaker's ruling because I knew the member would through my Speaker's ruling because I knew the member would raise through my Speaker's ruling because I knew the member would raise a I knew the member would raise a question I knew the member would raise a question about I knew the member would raise a question about the I knew the member would raise a question about the quality I knew the member would raise a question about the quality of I knew the member would raise a question about the quality of the question about the quality of the answer question about the quality of the I question about the quality of the answer he was question about the quality of the answer he was giving. question about the quality of the answer he was giving. I question about the quality of the answer he was giving. I refer question about the quality of the answer he was giving. I refer the answer he was giving. I refer the member answer he was giving. I refer the member please answer he was giving. I refer the member please to answer he was giving. I refer the member please to 1956, answer he was giving. I refer the member please to 1956, which answer he was giving. I refer the member please to 1956, which talks member please to 1956, which talks about member please to 1956, which talks about the member please to 1956, which talks about the answer member please to 1956, which talks about the answer the member please to 1956, which talks about the answer the member member please to 1956, which talks about the answer the member can about the answer the member can expect about the answer the member can answer about the answer the member can expect if he about the answer the member can expect if he asks about the answer the member can expect if he asks a about the answer the member can expect if he asks a hypothetical expect if he asks a hypothetical question. expect if he asks a hypothetical question. Supplementary expect if he asks a hypothetical question. Supplementary question. expect if he asks a hypothetical question. Supplementary question. We question. Supplementary question. We won't question. Supplementary question. We answer question. Supplementary question. We won't deal with question. Supplementary question. We won't deal with the question. Supplementary question. We won't deal with the first question. Supplementary question. We won't deal with the first point question. Supplementary question. We won't deal with the first point of won't deal with the first point of order? won't deal with the first point of order? No, won't deal with the first point of order? No, I won't deal with the first point of order? No, I did. won't deal with the first point of order? No, I did. I won't deal with the first point of order? No, I did. I said won't deal with the first point of order? No, I did. I said I won't deal with the first point of order? No, I did. I said I didn't order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it because order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it because I order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it because I was order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it because I was busy... order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it because I was busy... I order? No, I did. I said I didn't hear it because I was busy... I flew hear it because I was busy... I flew the hear it because I was busy... I flew the member hear it because I was busy... I flew the member would hear it because I was busy... I flew the member would raise hear it because I was busy... I flew the member would raise a hear it because I was busy... I flew the member would raise a question the member would raise a question about the member would raise a question won't the member would raise a question about a pint the member would raise a question about a pint of the member would raise a question about a pint of order the member would raise a question about a pint of order about the member would raise a question about a pint of order about the about a pint of order about the answer. about a pint of order about the answer. I about a pint of order about the answer. I do about a pint of order about the answer. I do advise about a pint of order about the answer. I do advise the about a pint of order about the answer. I do advise the member about a pint of order about the answer. I do advise the member if about a pint of order about the answer. I do advise the member if he answer. I do advise the member if he continues answer. I do advise the member if he continues with answer. I do advise the member if he continues with hypothetical continues with hypothetical questions, continues with hypothetical questions, like continues with hypothetical questions, like a continues with hypothetical questions, like a proposed continues with hypothetical questions, like a proposed round continues with hypothetical questions, like a proposed round of questions, like a proposed round of tax questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he is questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he is likely questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he is likely not questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he is likely not to questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he is likely not to get questions, like a proposed round of tax cuts, he is likely not to get an tax cuts, he is likely not to get an answer tax cuts, he is likely not to get an answer that tax cuts, he is likely not to get an answer that satisfies tax cuts, he is likely not to get an answer that satisfies him. tax cuts, he is likely not to get an answer that satisfies him. So, tax cuts, he is likely not to get an answer that satisfies him. So, he's answer that satisfies him. So, he's telling answer that satisfies him. So, he's telling the answer that satisfies him. So, he's telling the House answer that satisfies him. So, he's telling the House that answer that satisfies him. So, he's telling the House that the answer that satisfies him. So, he's telling the House that the National telling the House that the National Party telling the House that the National Party has telling the House that the National Party has done telling the House that the National Party has done no telling the House that the National Party has done no costings telling the House that the National Party has done no costings for telling the House that the National Party has done no costings for what Party has done no costings for what the Party has done no costings for what the PM Party has done no costings for what the PM said Party has done no costings for what the PM said would Party has done no costings for what the PM said would be Party has done no costings for what the PM said would be a Party has done no costings for what the PM said would be a priority Party has done no costings for what the PM said would be a priority for the PM said would be a priority for a the PM said would be a priority for a future the PM said would be a priority for a future national the PM said would be a priority for a future national Government, the PM said would be a priority for a future national Government, and a future national Government, and doesn't a future national Government, and a a future national Government, and doesn't he recognise a future national Government, and doesn't he recognise that a future national Government, and doesn't he recognise that the a future national Government, and doesn't he recognise that the Budget doesn't he recognise that the Budget he doesn't he recognise that the Budget he produced doesn't he recognise that the Budget he produced in doesn't he recognise that the Budget he produced in May doesn't he recognise that the Budget he produced in May is doesn't he recognise that the Budget he produced in May is now doesn't he recognise that the Budget he produced in May is now completely he produced in May is now completely irrelevant? he produced in May is now completely irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . Insofar... irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . Insofar... In irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . Insofar... In answer irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . Insofar... In answer to irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . Insofar... In answer to the irrelevant? <INTERRUPTION> . Insofar... In answer to the second . Insofar... In answer to the second part . Insofar... In answer to the second part of . Insofar... In answer to the second part of the . Insofar... In answer to the second part of the question . Insofar... In answer to the second part of the question - . Insofar... In answer to the second part of the question - no. . Insofar... In answer to the second part of the question - no. Quest. part of the question - no. Quest. Supplementary part of the question - no. Quest. Supplementary question. part of the question - no. Quest. Supplementary question. # part of the question - no. Quest. Supplementary question. # Why part of the question - no. Quest. Supplementary question. # Why is Supplementary question. # Why is giving Supplementary question. # Why is giving every Supplementary question. # Why is giving every member Supplementary question. # Why is giving every member of Supplementary question. # Why is giving every member of this Supplementary question. # Why is giving every member of this House Supplementary question. # Why is giving every member of this House a giving every member of this House a $1,000 giving every member of this House a $1,000 a giving every member of this House a $1,000 a year giving every member of this House a $1,000 a year tax giving every member of this House a $1,000 a year tax cut giving every member of this House a $1,000 a year tax cut a giving every member of this House a $1,000 a year tax cut a higher $1,000 a year tax cut a higher priority $1,000 a year tax cut a higher priority for $1,000 a year tax cut a higher priority for him $1,000 a year tax cut a higher priority for him than $1,000 a year tax cut a higher priority for him than more $1,000 a year tax cut a higher priority for him than more funding priority for him than more funding for priority for him than more funding for housing, priority for him than more funding for housing, health, priority for him than more funding for housing, health, education, priority for him than more funding for housing, health, education, or for housing, health, education, or police? for housing, health, education, or police? We for housing, health, education, or police? We actually for housing, health, education, or police? We actually think for housing, health, education, or police? We actually think that police? We actually think that people police? We actually think that police? police? We actually think that people working in police? We actually think that people working in New police? We actually think that people working in New Zealand police? We actually think that people working in New Zealand should people working in New Zealand should get people working in New Zealand should get rewarded people working in New Zealand should get rewarded for people working in New Zealand should get rewarded for their people working in New Zealand should get rewarded for their labour. get rewarded for their labour. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> And <INTERRUPTION> And actually <INTERRUPTION> And actually I <INTERRUPTION> And actually I think <INTERRUPTION> And actually I think we <INTERRUPTION> And actually I think we are <INTERRUPTION> And actually I think we are getting, And actually I think we are getting, though, And actually I think we are getting, though, to And actually I think we are getting, though, to the And actually I think we are getting, though, to the crux And actually I think we are getting, though, to the crux of And actually I think we are getting, though, to the crux of the And actually I think we are getting, though, to the crux of the problem though, to the crux of the problem from though, to the crux of the problem from Grant though, to the crux of the problem from Grant Robertson's though, to the crux of the problem from Grant Robertson's perspective, from Grant Robertson's perspective, which from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is that from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is that he from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is that he hates from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is that he hates the from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is that he hates the idea from Grant Robertson's perspective, which is that he hates the idea of which is that he hates the idea of returning which is that he hates the idea of returning tax which is that he hates the idea of returning tax income which is that he hates the idea of returning tax income to which is that he hates the idea of returning tax income to New which is that he hates the idea of returning tax income to New Zealand returning tax income to New Zealand families, returning tax income to New Zealand families, and returning tax income to New Zealand families, and actually returning tax income to New Zealand families, and actually this returning tax income to New Zealand families, and actually this $2 families, and actually this $2 billion families, and actually this $2 families, families, and actually this $2 billion Family Income families, and actually this $2 billion Family Income Package families, and actually this $2 billion Family Income Package is billion Family Income Package is delivering billion Family Income Package is billion billion Family Income Package is delivering to New billion Family Income Package is delivering to New Zealanders. billion Family Income Package is delivering to New Zealanders. He delivering to New Zealanders. He hates delivering to New Zealanders. He delivering delivering to New Zealanders. He hates that. He's delivering to New Zealanders. He hates that. He's against delivering to New Zealanders. He hates that. He's against it, delivering to New Zealanders. He hates that. He's against it, because hates that. He's against it, because he hates that. He's against it, because he thinks hates that. He's against it, because he thinks he hates that. He's against it, because he thinks he should hates that. He's against it, because he thinks he should be hates that. He's against it, because he thinks he should be able hates that. He's against it, because he thinks he should be able to hates that. He's against it, because he thinks he should be able to spend he thinks he should be able to spend all he thinks he should be able to spend all the he thinks he should be able to spend all the tax he thinks he should be able to spend all the tax that he thinks he should be able to spend all the tax that the he thinks he should be able to spend all the tax that the Government all the tax that the Government collects. all the tax that the Government collects. <INTERRUPTION> collects. <INTERRUPTION> . collects. <INTERRUPTION> . Order! collects. <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Question collects. <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Question No. collects. <INTERRUPTION> . Order! Question No. 5. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Why My question is to the Prime Minister: Why did My question is to the Prime Minister: Why did he My question is to the Prime Minister: Why did he say My question is to the Prime Minister: Why did he say that My question is to the Prime Minister: Why did he say that "we Minister: Why did he say that "we accept Minister: Why did he say that "we accept there Minister: Why did he say that "we accept there is Minister: Why did he say that "we accept there is growing Minister: Why did he say that "we accept there is growing public accept there is growing public concern" accept there is growing public concern" over accept there is growing public concern" over bottling accept there is growing public concern" over bottling and accept there is growing public concern" over bottling and exporting concern" over bottling and exporting water concern" over bottling and exporting water for concern" over bottling and exporting water for profit, concern" over bottling and exporting water for profit, and concern" over bottling and exporting water for profit, and when concern" over bottling and exporting water for profit, and when will concern" over bottling and exporting water for profit, and when will he water for profit, and when will he address water for profit, and when will he address that water for profit, and when will he address that concern water for profit, and when will he address that concern by water for profit, and when will he address that concern by putting water for profit, and when will he address that concern by putting a address that concern by putting a charge address that concern by putting a charge on address that concern by putting a charge on water address that concern by putting a charge on water bottling? I I said I said it I said it because I said it because there I said it because there was, I said it because there was, and I said it because there was, and is, I said it because there was, and is, and I said it because there was, and is, and that I said it because there was, and is, and that is I said it because there was, and is, and that is why I said it because there was, and is, and that is why we I said it because there was, and is, and that is why we have I said it because there was, and is, and that is why we have asked I said it because there was, and is, and that is why we have asked a and that is why we have asked a technical and that is why we have asked a technical advisory and that is why we have asked a technical advisory group and that is why we have asked a technical advisory group on and that is why we have asked a technical advisory group on water technical advisory group on water allocation technical advisory group on water technical technical advisory group on water allocation to look technical advisory group on water allocation to look at technical advisory group on water allocation to look at the technical advisory group on water allocation to look at the issue technical advisory group on water allocation to look at the issue and allocation to look at the issue and we allocation to look at the issue and we look allocation to look at the issue and we look forward allocation to look at the issue and we look forward to allocation to look at the issue and we look forward to considering allocation to look at the issue and we look forward to considering their we look forward to considering their report we look forward to considering their allocation we look forward to considering their report later on we look forward to considering their report later on this we look forward to considering their report later on this year. we look forward to considering their report later on this year. It we look forward to considering their report later on this year. It is we look forward to considering their report later on this year. It is an report later on this year. It is an issue report later on this year. It is an issue which report later on this year. It is an issue which needs report later on this year. It is an issue which needs to report later on this year. It is an issue which needs to be report later on this year. It is an issue which needs to be seen report later on this year. It is an issue which needs to be seen in report later on this year. It is an issue which needs to be seen in the issue which needs to be seen in the context issue which needs to be seen in the context of issue which needs to be seen in the context of all issue which needs to be seen in the context of all the issue which needs to be seen in the context of all the other issue which needs to be seen in the context of all the other intensive context of all the other intensive work context of all the other intensive work going context of all the other intensive work going on context of all the other intensive work going on to context of all the other intensive work going on to focus context of all the other intensive work going on to focus on context of all the other intensive work going on to focus on higher context of all the other intensive work going on to focus on higher - work going on to focus on higher - better work going on to focus on higher - better use work going on to focus on higher - better use and work going on to focus on higher - better use and higher work going on to focus on higher - better use and higher quality work going on to focus on higher - better use and higher quality of better use and higher quality of fresh better use and higher quality of allocation better use and higher quality of fresh water in better use and higher quality of fresh water in New better use and higher quality of fresh water in New Zealand. better use and higher quality of fresh water in New Zealand. Will better use and higher quality of fresh water in New Zealand. Will he fresh water in New Zealand. Will he commit fresh water in New Zealand. Will he commit to fresh water in New Zealand. Will he commit to implementing fresh water in New Zealand. Will he commit to implementing a fresh water in New Zealand. Will he commit to implementing a resource commit to implementing a resource rental commit to implementing a resource commit commit to implementing a resource rental on water, commit to implementing a resource rental on water, if commit to implementing a resource rental on water, if the commit to implementing a resource rental on water, if the technical rental on water, if the technical advisory rental on water, if the technical advisory group rental on water, if the technical advisory group recommends rental on water, if the technical advisory group recommends it? rental on water, if the technical advisory group recommends it? Well, advisory group recommends it? Well, the advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as you advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as you - advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as you - leapt advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as you - leapt to advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as you - leapt to a advisory group recommends it? Well, the member, as you - leapt to a much the member, as you - leapt to a much broader the member, as you - leapt to a much broader assertion the member, as you - leapt to a much broader assertion about the member, as you - leapt to a much broader assertion about resource broader assertion about resource rentals broader assertion about resource rentals on broader assertion about resource rentals on water. broader assertion about resource rentals on water. We broader assertion about resource rentals on water. We have broader assertion about resource rentals on water. We have yet broader assertion about resource rentals on water. We have yet to broader assertion about resource rentals on water. We have yet to see rentals on water. We have yet to see what rentals on water. We have yet to see what the rentals on water. We have yet to see what the technical rentals on water. We have yet to see what the technical advisory rentals on water. We have yet to see what the technical advisory group what the technical advisory group coming what the technical advisory group coming up what the technical advisory group coming up with. what the technical advisory group coming up with. Will what the technical advisory group coming up with. Will he what the technical advisory group coming up with. Will he commit what the technical advisory group coming up with. Will he commit to coming up with. Will he commit to implementing coming up with. Will he commit to implementing a coming up with. Will he commit to implementing a price coming up with. Will he commit to implementing a price on coming up with. Will he commit to implementing a price on water implementing a price on water bottling implementing a price on water bottling if implementing a price on water bottling if the implementing a price on water bottling if the technical implementing a price on water bottling if the technical advisory bottling if the technical advisory group bottling if the technical advisory bottling bottling if the technical advisory group recommends it? bottling if the technical advisory group recommends it? Well, bottling if the technical advisory group recommends it? Well, I group recommends it? Well, I wouldn't... group recommends it? Well, I wouldn't... It group recommends it? Well, I wouldn't... It doesn't group recommends it? Well, I wouldn't... It doesn't make group recommends it? Well, I wouldn't... It doesn't make sense group recommends it? Well, I wouldn't... It doesn't make sense to wouldn't... It doesn't make sense to make wouldn't... It doesn't make sense to make open-ended wouldn't... It doesn't make sense to make open-ended commitments wouldn't... It doesn't make sense to make open-ended commitments well make open-ended commitments well before make open-ended commitments well before we make open-ended commitments well before we have make open-ended commitments well before we have got make open-ended commitments well before we have got an make open-ended commitments well before we have got an indication make open-ended commitments well before we have got an indication of before we have got an indication of the before we have got an indication of the advice. before we have got an indication of the advice. But before we have got an indication of the advice. But what before we have got an indication of the advice. But what I before we have got an indication of the advice. But what I would before we have got an indication of the advice. But what I would say before we have got an indication of the advice. But what I would say - the advice. But what I would say - what the advice. But what I would say - what I the advice. But what I would say - what I would the advice. But what I would say - what I would say the advice. But what I would say - what I would say is the advice. But what I would say - what I would say is that the advice. But what I would say - what I would say is that over the advice. But what I would say - what I would say is that over the what I would say is that over the last what I would say is that over the last five what I would say is that over the last five or what I would say is that over the last five or six what I would say is that over the last five or six years what I would say is that over the last five or six years the last five or six years the Government last five or six years the Government has last five or six years the Government has done last five or six years the Government has done intensive last five or six years the Government has done intensive work Government has done intensive work on Government has done intensive work on all Government has done intensive work on all these Government has done intensive work on all these water-related Government has done intensive work on all these water-related issues on all these water-related issues and on all these water-related issues and from on all these water-related issues and from that on all these water-related issues and from that we on all these water-related issues and from that we have on all these water-related issues and from that we have learnt on all these water-related issues and from that we have learnt the and from that we have learnt the importance and from that we have learnt the importance of and from that we have learnt the importance of getting and from that we have learnt the importance of getting the and from that we have learnt the importance of getting the science importance of getting the science right, importance of getting the science right, getting importance of getting the science right, getting a importance of getting the science right, getting a very importance of getting the science right, getting a very good right, getting a very good understanding right, getting a very good right, right, getting a very good understanding of all right, getting a very good understanding of all the right, getting a very good understanding of all the different understanding of all the different dimensions understanding of all the different dimensions of understanding of all the different dimensions of the understanding of all the different dimensions of the problems understanding of all the different dimensions of the problems related dimensions of the problems related to dimensions of the problems related dimensions dimensions of the problems related to the use dimensions of the problems related to the use of dimensions of the problems related to the use of water dimensions of the problems related to the use of water and dimensions of the problems related to the use of water and the dimensions of the problems related to the use of water and the quality to the use of water and the quality of to the use of water and the quality of water, to the use of water and the quality of water, and to the use of water and the quality of water, and we to the use of water and the quality of water, and we have to the use of water and the quality of water, and we have learnt to the use of water and the quality of water, and we have learnt not to the use of water and the quality of water, and we have learnt not to of water, and we have learnt not to jump of water, and we have learnt not to jump to of water, and we have learnt not to jump to conclusions of water, and we have learnt not to jump to conclusions about of water, and we have learnt not to jump to conclusions about what of water, and we have learnt not to jump to conclusions about what the jump to conclusions about what the right jump to conclusions about what the right answer jump to conclusions about what the right answer is. jump to conclusions about what the right answer is. Giflten jump to conclusions about what the right answer is. Giflten that jump to conclusions about what the right answer is. Giflten that the right answer is. Giflten that the Government right answer is. Giflten that the dimensions right answer is. Giflten that the Government -- give right answer is. Giflten that the Government -- give den right answer is. Giflten that the Government -- give den Government Government -- give den Government failed Government -- give den Government failed to Government -- give den Government failed to implement Government -- give den Government failed to implement many Government -- give den Government failed to implement many of Government -- give den Government failed to implement many of the Government -- give den Government failed to implement many of the key failed to implement many of the key recommendations failed to implement many of the key recommendations of failed to implement many of the key recommendations of the failed to implement many of the key recommendations of the land failed to implement many of the key recommendations of the land yard recommendations of the land yard water recommendations of the land yard water forum, recommendations of the land yard water forum, why recommendations of the land yard water forum, why should recommendations of the land yard water forum, why should the recommendations of the land yard water forum, why should the public water forum, why should the public have water forum, why should the public recommendations water forum, why should the public have any confidence water forum, why should the public have any confidence that water forum, why should the public have any confidence that he water forum, why should the public have any confidence that he will have any confidence that he will follow have any confidence that he will follow the have any confidence that he will follow the advice have any confidence that he will follow the advice of have any confidence that he will follow the advice of the have any confidence that he will follow the advice of the technical follow the advice of the technical advisory follow the advice of the technical advisory group? follow the advice of the technical advisory group? The follow the advice of the technical advisory group? The member follow the advice of the technical advisory group? The member is follow the advice of the technical advisory group? The member is just advisory group? The member is just wrong. advisory group? The member is just wrong. The advisory group? The member is just wrong. The land advisory group? The member is just wrong. The land yard advisory group? The member is just wrong. The land yard water advisory group? The member is just wrong. The land yard water forum advisory group? The member is just wrong. The land yard water forum was wrong. The land yard water forum was a wrong. The land yard water forum was a radical wrong. The land yard water forum was a radical departure wrong. The land yard water forum was a radical departure from wrong. The land yard water forum was a radical departure from the wrong. The land yard water forum was a radical departure from the usual a radical departure from the usual systems. a radical departure from the usual systems. It a radical departure from the usual systems. It took a radical departure from the usual systems. It took a a radical departure from the usual systems. It took a big a radical departure from the usual systems. It took a big leap a radical departure from the usual systems. It took a big leap to a radical departure from the usual systems. It took a big leap to a systems. It took a big leap to a collaborative systems. It took a big leap to a collaborative process, systems. It took a big leap to a collaborative process, with, systems. It took a big leap to a collaborative process, with, I collaborative process, with, I think, collaborative process, with, I think, 70 collaborative process, with, I think, 70 organisations collaborative process, with, I think, 70 organisations involved collaborative process, with, I think, 70 organisations involved in think, 70 organisations involved in formulating think, 70 organisations involved in formulating a think, 70 organisations involved in formulating a policy. think, 70 organisations involved in formulating a policy. We think, 70 organisations involved in formulating a policy. We have formulating a policy. We have implemented formulating a policy. We have implemented most formulating a policy. We have implemented most of formulating a policy. We have implemented most of the implemented most of the recommendations, implemented most of the recommendations, probably implemented most of the recommendations, probably the implemented most of the recommendations, probably the major recommendations, probably the major one recommendations, probably the major one we recommendations, probably the major one we haven't recommendations, probably the major one we haven't implemented recommendations, probably the major one we haven't implemented is recommendations, probably the major one we haven't implemented is the one we haven't implemented is the Government one we haven't implemented is the formulating one we haven't implemented is the Government appointing all one we haven't implemented is the Government appointing all the Government appointing all the Regional Government appointing all the Regional Councils, Government appointing all the Regional Councils, I Government appointing all the Regional Councils, I think Government appointing all the Regional Councils, I think even Government appointing all the Regional Councils, I think even the Regional Councils, I think even the member Regional Councils, I think even the member might Regional Councils, I think even the member might be Regional Councils, I think even the member might be opposed Regional Councils, I think even the member might be opposed to Regional Councils, I think even the member might be opposed to that Regional Councils, I think even the member might be opposed to that one. member might be opposed to that one. How member might be opposed to that one. How comfortable member might be opposed to that one. How comfortable is member might be opposed to that one. How comfortable is he member might be opposed to that one. How comfortable is he with member might be opposed to that one. How comfortable is he with the member might be opposed to that one. How comfortable is he with the idea How comfortable is he with the idea that How comfortable is he with the idea that local How comfortable is he with the idea that local authorities How comfortable is he with the idea that local authorities and How comfortable is he with the idea that local authorities and whenua How comfortable is he with the idea that local authorities and whenua in that local authorities and whenua in New that local authorities and whenua in How that local authorities and whenua in New Zealand are that local authorities and whenua in New Zealand are missing that local authorities and whenua in New Zealand are missing out that local authorities and whenua in New Zealand are missing out on New Zealand are missing out on millions New Zealand are missing out on millions of New Zealand are missing out on millions of dollars New Zealand are missing out on millions of dollars in New Zealand are missing out on millions of dollars in royalties millions of dollars in royalties from millions of dollars in royalties from water millions of dollars in royalties from water bottling millions of dollars in royalties from water bottling that millions of dollars in royalties from water bottling that could millions of dollars in royalties from water bottling that could be from water bottling that could be used from water bottling that could be used to from water bottling that could be used to improve from water bottling that could be used to improve monitoring from water bottling that could be used to improve monitoring and from water bottling that could be used to improve monitoring and to used to improve monitoring and to help used to improve monitoring and to help farmers used to improve monitoring and to help farmers to used to improve monitoring and to help farmers to fence used to improve monitoring and to help farmers to fence rivers used to improve monitoring and to help farmers to fence rivers and help farmers to fence rivers and plant help farmers to fence rivers and plant trees? help farmers to fence rivers and plant trees? Well, help farmers to fence rivers and plant trees? Well, the help farmers to fence rivers and plant trees? Well, the member help farmers to fence rivers and plant trees? Well, the member -- plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, the plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, the member plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, the member is plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, the member is welcome plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, the member is welcome to plant trees? Well, the member -- Well, the member is welcome to put Well, the member is welcome to put forward Well, the member is welcome to put forward to Well, the member is welcome to put forward to the Well, the member is welcome to put forward to the public Well, the member is welcome to put forward to the public the Well, the member is welcome to put forward to the public the view Well, the member is welcome to put forward to the public the view he forward to the public the view he stressed, forward to the public the view he stressed, that forward to the public the view he stressed, that council forward to the public the view he stressed, that council and forward to the public the view he stressed, that council and iwi stressed, that council and iwi should stressed, that council and iwi stressed, stressed, that council and iwi should have hundreds stressed, that council and iwi should have hundreds and stressed, that council and iwi should have hundreds and millions stressed, that council and iwi should have hundreds and millions of should have hundreds and millions of dollars should have hundreds and millions of dollars from should have hundreds and millions of dollars from royalties should have hundreds and millions of dollars from royalties from should have hundreds and millions of dollars from royalties from fresh dollars from royalties from fresh water. dollars from royalties from fresh water. As dollars from royalties from fresh water. As it dollars from royalties from fresh water. As it happens, dollars from royalties from fresh water. As it happens, the dollars from royalties from fresh water. As it happens, the farming water. As it happens, the farming community water. As it happens, the farming community without water. As it happens, the farming community without the water. As it happens, the farming community without the benefit water. As it happens, the farming community without the benefit of community without the benefit of royalty community without the benefit of royalty incomes community without the benefit of royalty incomes is community without the benefit of royalty incomes is actually community without the benefit of royalty incomes is actually fencing royalty incomes is actually fencing almost royalty incomes is actually fencing almost all royalty incomes is actually fencing almost all the royalty incomes is actually fencing almost all the waterways royalty incomes is actually fencing almost all the waterways in almost all the waterways in grazeable almost all the waterways in almost almost all the waterways in grazeable - certainly almost all the waterways in grazeable - certainly in almost all the waterways in grazeable - certainly in grazeable grazeable - certainly in grazeable areas grazeable - certainly in grazeable grazeable grazeable - certainly in grazeable areas of New grazeable - certainly in grazeable areas of New Zealand. grazeable - certainly in grazeable areas of New Zealand. It's grazeable - certainly in grazeable areas of New Zealand. It's been grazeable - certainly in grazeable areas of New Zealand. It's been a areas of New Zealand. It's been a massive areas of New Zealand. It's been a massive investment areas of New Zealand. It's been a massive investment by areas of New Zealand. It's been a massive investment by the areas of New Zealand. It's been a massive investment by the farming massive investment by the farming community, massive investment by the farming community, alongside massive investment by the farming community, alongside all massive investment by the farming community, alongside all the massive investment by the farming community, alongside all the other community, alongside all the other investments community, alongside all the other community, community, alongside all the other investments and changes community, alongside all the other investments and changes in community, alongside all the other investments and changes in farming investments and changes in farming practices investments and changes in farming investments investments and changes in farming practices they are investments and changes in farming practices they are putting investments and changes in farming practices they are putting in. investments and changes in farming practices they are putting in. I'm practices they are putting in. I'm hoping practices they are putting in. I'm hoping that practices they are putting in. I'm hoping that councils practices they are putting in. I'm hoping that councils will practices they are putting in. I'm hoping that councils will be practices they are putting in. I'm hoping that councils will be able practices they are putting in. I'm hoping that councils will be able to hoping that councils will be able to respond hoping that councils will be able to respond as hoping that councils will be able to respond as effectively hoping that councils will be able to respond as effectively as hoping that councils will be able to respond as effectively as the respond as effectively as the farming respond as effectively as the respond respond as effectively as the farming community when respond as effectively as the farming community when the respond as effectively as the farming community when the focus farming community when the focus shifts farming community when the focus shifts to farming community when the focus shifts to the farming community when the focus shifts to the quality farming community when the focus shifts to the quality of farming community when the focus shifts to the quality of urban farming community when the focus shifts to the quality of urban water shifts to the quality of urban water where shifts to the quality of urban water where his shifts to the quality of urban water where his voters shifts to the quality of urban water where his voters will shifts to the quality of urban water where his voters will actually shifts to the quality of urban water where his voters will actually - shifts to the quality of urban water where his voters will actually - may where his voters will actually - may have where his voters will actually - may have to where his voters will actually - may have to pay where his voters will actually - may have to pay rates where his voters will actually - may have to pay rates in where his voters will actually - may have to pay rates in order where his voters will actually - may have to pay rates in order to have to pay rates in order to achieve have to pay rates in order to achieve the have to pay rates in order to achieve the high have to pay rates in order to achieve the high quality have to pay rates in order to achieve the high quality of have to pay rates in order to achieve the high quality of water, achieve the high quality of water, rather achieve the high quality of water, rather than achieve the high quality of water, rather than just achieve the high quality of water, rather than just leaving achieve the high quality of water, rather than just leaving the achieve the high quality of water, rather than just leaving the burden rather than just leaving the burden to rather than just leaving the burden to the rather than just leaving the burden to the farmers. rather than just leaving the burden to the farmers. What rather than just leaving the burden to the farmers. What other rather than just leaving the burden to the farmers. What other natural to the farmers. What other natural resources to the farmers. What other natural have to the farmers. What other natural resources is the to the farmers. What other natural resources is the Government resources is the Government intending resources is the Government intending to resources is the Government intending to give resources is the Government intending to give away resources is the Government intending to give away to resources is the Government intending to give away to commercial intending to give away to commercial companies intending to give away to commercial companies to intending to give away to commercial companies to onsell intending to give away to commercial companies to onsell for intending to give away to commercial companies to onsell for free? intending to give away to commercial companies to onsell for free? Well, companies to onsell for free? Well, Governments companies to onsell for free? Well, Governments given companies to onsell for free? Well, Governments given water companies to onsell for free? Well, Governments given water to companies to onsell for free? Well, Governments given water to our Governments given water to our electricity Governments given water to our electricity companies Governments given water to our electricity companies for Governments given water to our electricity companies for for electricity companies for for years... electricity companies for for years... You electricity companies for for years... You can electricity companies for for years... You can argue electricity companies for for years... You can argue about electricity companies for for years... You can argue about - electricity companies for for years... You can argue about - which years... You can argue about - which are years... You can argue about - which are then years... You can argue about - which are then on-sold years... You can argue about - which are then on-sold for years... You can argue about - which are then on-sold for free. years... You can argue about - which are then on-sold for free. You years... You can argue about - which are then on-sold for free. You can are then on-sold for free. You can argue are then on-sold for free. You can argue about are then on-sold for free. You can argue about whether are then on-sold for free. You can argue about whether that are then on-sold for free. You can argue about whether that is are then on-sold for free. You can argue about whether that is the argue about whether that is the right argue about whether that is the are argue about whether that is the right thing or argue about whether that is the right thing or the argue about whether that is the right thing or the most argue about whether that is the right thing or the most effective right thing or the most effective economic right thing or the most effective economic way right thing or the most effective economic way of right thing or the most effective economic way of allocating right thing or the most effective economic way of allocating water. economic way of allocating water. The economic way of allocating water. The advisory economic way of allocating water. The advisory group economic way of allocating water. The advisory group is economic way of allocating water. The advisory group is getting economic way of allocating water. The advisory group is getting to The advisory group is getting to gripping The advisory group is getting to economic The advisory group is getting to gripping with all The advisory group is getting to gripping with all of The advisory group is getting to gripping with all of these The advisory group is getting to gripping with all of these issues, gripping with all of these issues, and gripping with all of these issues, and if gripping with all of these issues, and if the gripping with all of these issues, and if the member gripping with all of these issues, and if the member actually gripping with all of these issues, and if the member actually got gripping with all of these issues, and if the member actually got out and if the member actually got out and and if the member actually got out and ability he and if the member actually got out and ability he would and if the member actually got out and ability he would see and if the member actually got out and ability he would see that, and if the member actually got out and ability he would see that, in and if the member actually got out and ability he would see that, in a and ability he would see that, in a number and ability he would see that, in a number of and ability he would see that, in a number of communities and ability he would see that, in a number of communities and and ability he would see that, in a number of communities and water number of communities and water catchments, number of communities and water catchments, there number of communities and water catchments, there is number of communities and water catchments, there is a number of communities and water catchments, there is a sophisticated catchments, there is a sophisticated discussion catchments, there is a sophisticated catchments, catchments, there is a sophisticated discussion going on, catchments, there is a sophisticated discussion going on, both catchments, there is a sophisticated discussion going on, both about catchments, there is a sophisticated discussion going on, both about the discussion going on, both about the allocation discussion going on, both about the allocation of discussion going on, both about the allocation of fresh discussion going on, both about the allocation of fresh water discussion going on, both about the allocation of fresh water and discussion going on, both about the allocation of fresh water and the allocation of fresh water and the allocation allocation of fresh water and the allocation of allocation of fresh water and the allocation of polluted allocation of fresh water and the allocation of polluted water. allocation of fresh water and the allocation of polluted water. Point allocation of polluted water. Point of allocation of polluted water. Point allocation allocation of polluted water. Point of order. Mr allocation of polluted water. Point of order. Mr Speaker, allocation of polluted water. Point of order. Mr Speaker, my allocation of polluted water. Point of order. Mr Speaker, my question of order. Mr Speaker, my question was of order. Mr Speaker, my question was about of order. Mr Speaker, my question was about other of order. Mr Speaker, my question was about other natural of order. Mr Speaker, my question was about other natural resources was about other natural resources than was about other natural resources was was about other natural resources than water, and was about other natural resources than water, and the was about other natural resources than water, and the PM was about other natural resources than water, and the PM did was about other natural resources than water, and the PM did not than water, and the PM did not address than water, and the PM did not address that than water, and the PM did not address that question. than water, and the PM did not address that question. I than water, and the PM did not address that question. I think than water, and the PM did not address that question. I think the address that question. I think the PM address that question. I think the PM did, address that question. I think the PM did, because, address that question. I think the PM did, because, again, address that question. I think the PM did, because, again, it address that question. I think the PM did, because, again, it was address that question. I think the PM did, because, again, it was a PM did, because, again, it was a hypothetical PM did, because, again, it was a hypothetical question PM did, because, again, it was a hypothetical question about PM did, because, again, it was a hypothetical question about what hypothetical question about what other hypothetical question about what other natural hypothetical question about what other natural resources hypothetical question about what other natural resources the other natural resources the Government other natural resources the Government might other natural resources the Government might consider other natural resources the Government might consider giving Government might consider giving away Government might consider giving away for Government might consider giving away for free. Government might consider giving away for free. Very Government might consider giving away for free. Very hypothetical Government might consider giving away for free. Very hypothetical in away for free. Very hypothetical in the away for free. Very hypothetical in the question. away for free. Very hypothetical in the question. Therefore, away for free. Very hypothetical in the question. Therefore, I away for free. Very hypothetical in the question. Therefore, I refer away for free. Very hypothetical in the question. Therefore, I refer the the question. Therefore, I refer the member the question. Therefore, I refer the member to the question. Therefore, I refer the member to 1955 the question. Therefore, I refer the member to 1955 and the question. Therefore, I refer the member to 1955 and 6. the question. Therefore, I refer the member to 1955 and 6. Does the question. Therefore, I refer the member to 1955 and 6. Does he the question. Therefore, I refer the member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand by member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand by his member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand by his statement member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand by his statement that, member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand by his statement that, "It member to 1955 and 6. Does he stand by his statement that, "It doesn't by his statement that, "It doesn't matter by his statement that, "It doesn't matter whether by his statement that, "It doesn't matter whether it's by his statement that, "It doesn't matter whether it's fair by his statement that, "It doesn't matter whether it's fair or by his statement that, "It doesn't matter whether it's fair or not", by his statement that, "It doesn't matter whether it's fair or not", if matter whether it's fair or not", if water matter whether it's fair or not", if water bottling matter whether it's fair or not", if water bottling companies matter whether it's fair or not", if water bottling companies are matter whether it's fair or not", if water bottling companies are charged water bottling companies are charged and water bottling companies are charged water water bottling companies are charged and how would water bottling companies are charged and how would he water bottling companies are charged and how would he explain water bottling companies are charged and how would he explain that water bottling companies are charged and how would he explain that to water bottling companies are charged and how would he explain that to the and how would he explain that to the people and how would he explain that to the people of and how would he explain that to the people of have and how would he explain that to the people of have luck and how would he explain that to the people of have luck North and how would he explain that to the people of have luck North depending people of have luck North depending on people of have luck North depending on bottle people of have luck North depending on bottle water people of have luck North depending on bottle water when people of have luck North depending on bottle water when their people of have luck North depending on bottle water when their own on bottle water when their own drinking on bottle water when their own drinking water on bottle water when their own drinking water was on bottle water when their own drinking water was contaminated? drinking water was contaminated? Again, drinking water was contaminated? Again, there drinking water was contaminated? Again, there were drinking water was contaminated? Again, there were two drinking water was contaminated? Again, there were two questions. drinking water was contaminated? Again, there were two questions. I'm Again, there were two questions. I'm not Again, there were two questions. I'm not sure Again, there were two questions. I'm not sure what Again, there were two questions. I'm not sure what the Again, there were two questions. I'm not sure what the member Again, there were two questions. I'm not sure what the member means. Again, there were two questions. I'm not sure what the member means. I not sure what the member means. I mean, not sure what the member means. I mean, the not sure what the member means. I mean, the situation not sure what the member means. I mean, the situation in not sure what the member means. I mean, the situation in - not sure what the member means. I mean, the situation in - it not sure what the member means. I mean, the situation in - it doesn't mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear to mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear to be mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear to be to mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear to be to do mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear to be to do with mean, the situation in - it doesn't appear to be to do with bottled appear to be to do with bottled water, appear to be to do with bottled water, although appear to be to do with bottled water, although they appear to be to do with bottled water, although they had appear to be to do with bottled water, although they had to appear to be to do with bottled water, although they had to use appear to be to do with bottled water, although they had to use it. water, although they had to use it. It water, although they had to use it. It is water, although they had to use it. It is about water, although they had to use it. It is about local water, although they had to use it. It is about local government It is about local government performance It is about local government performance and It is about local government performance and overseeing It is about local government performance and overseeing ratepayer performance and overseeing ratepayer funded performance and overseeing ratepayer funded assets performance and overseeing ratepayer funded assets whose performance and overseeing ratepayer funded assets whose purpose performance and overseeing ratepayer funded assets whose purpose is performance and overseeing ratepayer funded assets whose purpose is to funded assets whose purpose is to deliver funded assets whose purpose is to deliver keen funded assets whose purpose is to deliver keen and funded assets whose purpose is to deliver keen and healthy funded assets whose purpose is to deliver keen and healthy water funded assets whose purpose is to deliver keen and healthy water to deliver keen and healthy water to its deliver keen and healthy water to its local deliver keen and healthy water to its local people. deliver keen and healthy water to its local people. And deliver keen and healthy water to its local people. And their its local people. And their extensive its local people. And their its its local people. And their extensive inquiry into its local people. And their extensive inquiry into that its local people. And their extensive inquiry into that incident extensive inquiry into that incident was extensive inquiry into that incident was warranted extensive inquiry into that incident was warranted by extensive inquiry into that incident was warranted by widespread extensive inquiry into that incident was warranted by widespread illness was warranted by widespread illness in was warranted by widespread illness in the was warranted by widespread illness in the area, was warranted by widespread illness in the area, but was warranted by widespread illness in the area, but it's was warranted by widespread illness in the area, but it's not was warranted by widespread illness in the area, but it's not about in the area, but it's not about charging in the area, but it's not about charging for in the area, but it's not about charging for water, in the area, but it's not about charging for water, it in the area, but it's not about charging for water, it is in the area, but it's not about charging for water, it is about charging for water, it is about local charging for water, it is about local body charging for water, it is about local body performance charging for water, it is about local body performance and local body performance and overseeing local body performance and overseeing the local body performance and overseeing the fresh local body performance and overseeing the fresh water local body performance and overseeing the fresh water system. overseeing the fresh water system. Or overseeing the fresh water system. Or clean overseeing the fresh water system. Or clean water overseeing the fresh water system. Or clean water system. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: In My question is to the Prime Minister: In his My question is to the Prime Minister: In his Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: In his Prime Ministerial Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand by Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand by all Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand by all his capacity, does he stand by all his statements capacity, does he stand by all his statements on capacity, does he stand by all his statements on the capacity, does he stand by all his statements on the Clutha-Southland statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue; statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue; if statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue; if so, statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue; if so, how electorate office issue; if so, how does electorate office issue; if so, how does he electorate office issue; if so, how does he do electorate office issue; if so, how does he do that? Those Those statements Those statements weren't Those statements weren't made Those statements weren't made in Those statements weren't made in my Those statements weren't made in my prime Those statements weren't made in my prime ministerial Those statements weren't made in my prime ministerial capacity. prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. In prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. In that Supplementary question. In that case, Supplementary question. In that case, if Supplementary question. In that case, if there's... Supplementary question. In that case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> point case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> point of case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> point of order. case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I'm case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I'm sorry case, if there's... <INTERRUPTION> point of order. I'm sorry to point of order. I'm sorry to interrupt point of order. I'm sorry to interrupt the point of order. I'm sorry to interrupt the member point of order. I'm sorry to interrupt the member asking point of order. I'm sorry to interrupt the member asking the interrupt the member asking the interrupt the member asking the interrupt the member asking the question. The interrupt the member asking the question. The PM's interrupt the member asking the question. The PM's answer interrupt the member asking the question. The PM's answer cannot interrupt the member asking the question. The PM's answer cannot be question. The PM's answer cannot be question. The PM's answer cannot be question. The PM's answer cannot be allowed to question. The PM's answer cannot be allowed to stand question. The PM's answer cannot be allowed to stand because question. The PM's answer cannot be allowed to stand because he question. The PM's answer cannot be allowed to stand because he has question. The PM's answer cannot be allowed to stand because he has made allowed to stand because he has made allowed to stand because he has made allowed to stand because he has made statements on allowed to stand because he has made statements on that allowed to stand because he has made statements on that matter allowed to stand because he has made statements on that matter in allowed to stand because he has made statements on that matter in the statements on that matter in the House statements on that matter in the House in statements on that matter in the House in his statements on that matter in the House in his capacity statements on that matter in the House in his capacity as statements on that matter in the House in his capacity as PM statements on that matter in the House in his capacity as PM he statements on that matter in the House in his capacity as PM he has House in his capacity as PM he has answered House in his capacity as PM he has answered questions House in his capacity as PM he has answered questions as House in his capacity as PM he has answered questions as PM House in his capacity as PM he has answered questions as PM and House in his capacity as PM he has answered questions as PM and he answered questions as PM and he needs answered questions as PM and he needs to answered questions as PM and he needs to therefore answered questions as PM and he needs to therefore be answered questions as PM and he needs to therefore be able answered questions as PM and he needs to therefore be able to answered questions as PM and he needs to therefore be able to answer needs to therefore be able to answer for needs to therefore be able to answer for at needs to therefore be able to answer for at least needs to therefore be able to answer for at least those needs to therefore be able to answer for at least those statements needs to therefore be able to answer for at least those statements that for at least those statements that needs for at least those statements that he for at least those statements that he has made. The for at least those statements that he has made. The PM's for at least those statements that he has made. The PM's answer for at least those statements that he has made. The PM's answer will he has made. The PM's answer will stand he has made. The PM's answer will stand and he has made. The PM's answer will stand and it he has made. The PM's answer will stand and it will he has made. The PM's answer will stand and it will be he has made. The PM's answer will stand and it will be for he has made. The PM's answer will stand and it will be for the he has made. The PM's answer will stand and it will be for the people stand and it will be for the people stand and it will be for the people stand and it will be for the people in this stand and it will be for the people in this House stand and it will be for the people in this House and stand and it will be for the people in this House and for stand and it will be for the people in this House and for the stand and it will be for the people in this House and for the public stand and it will be for the people in this House and for the public to in this House and for the public to he in this House and for the public to judge in this House and for the public to judge it. Supplementary question. in this House and for the public to judge it. Supplementary question. If judge it. Supplementary question. If his judge it. Supplementary question. If his line judge it. Supplementary question. If his line of judge it. Supplementary question. If his line of defence judge it. Supplementary question. If his line of defence in judge it. Supplementary question. If his line of defence in this judge it. Supplementary question. If his line of defence in this matter his line of defence in this matter his line of defence in this matter his line of defence in this matter continues to his line of defence in this matter continues to be his line of defence in this matter continues to be "statements his line of defence in this matter continues to be "statements were his line of defence in this matter continues to be "statements were not continues to be "statements were not made continues to be "statements were not made in continues to be "statements were not made in my continues to be "statements were not made in my ministerial continues to be "statements were not made in my ministerial capacity" continues to be "statements were not made in my ministerial capacity" but made in my ministerial capacity" but as made in my ministerial capacity" but as National made in my ministerial capacity" but as National Party made in my ministerial capacity" but as National Party leader, made in my ministerial capacity" but as National Party leader, then made in my ministerial capacity" but as National Party leader, then why as National Party leader, then why as National Party leader, then why as National Party leader, then why did he as National Party leader, then why did he not as National Party leader, then why did he not correct as National Party leader, then why did he not correct Susie as National Party leader, then why did he not correct Susie ferg did he not correct Susie ferg useson did he not correct Susie ferg did he not correct Susie ferg useson on morning did he not correct Susie ferg useson on morning Report, did he not correct Susie ferg useson on morning Report, Duncan did he not correct Susie ferg useson on morning Report, Duncan garner did he not correct Susie ferg useson on morning Report, Duncan garner on on morning Report, Duncan garner on on morning Report, Duncan garner on on morning Report, Duncan garner on the AM on morning Report, Duncan garner on the AM show, on morning Report, Duncan garner on the AM show, Hillary on morning Report, Duncan garner on the AM show, Hillary Barry on morning Report, Duncan garner on the AM show, Hillary Barry on on morning Report, Duncan garner on the AM show, Hillary Barry on the the AM show, Hillary Barry on the Breakfast the AM show, Hillary Barry on the Breakfast Show the AM show, Hillary Barry on the Breakfast Show when the AM show, Hillary Barry on the Breakfast Show when he the AM show, Hillary Barry on the Breakfast Show when he was the AM show, Hillary Barry on the Breakfast Show when he was asked Breakfast Show when he was asked questions Breakfast Show when he was asked questions on Breakfast Show when he was asked questions on this Breakfast Show when he was asked questions on this matter Breakfast Show when he was asked questions on this matter on Breakfast Show when he was asked questions on this matter on Monday questions on this matter on Monday as questions on this matter on Monday as the questions on this matter on Monday as the PM? questions on this matter on Monday as the PM? I questions on this matter on Monday as the PM? I just questions on this matter on Monday as the PM? I just simply questions on this matter on Monday as the PM? I just simply reiterate as the PM? I just simply reiterate as the PM? I just simply reiterate as the PM? I just simply reiterate the answer as the PM? I just simply reiterate the answer to as the PM? I just simply reiterate the answer to my as the PM? I just simply reiterate the answer to my first as the PM? I just simply reiterate the answer to my first question, as the PM? I just simply reiterate the answer to my first question, I the answer to my first question, I the answer to my first question, I the answer to my first question, I don't agree the answer to my first question, I don't agree with the answer to my first question, I don't agree with the the answer to my first question, I don't agree with the member's don't agree with the member's assertions. don't agree with the member's assertions. <INTERRUPTION> assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! That assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! That is assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! That is the assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! That is the sort assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! That is the sort of assertions. <INTERRUPTION> Order! That is the sort of remark Order! That is the sort of remark that Order! That is the sort of remark Order! Order! That is the sort of remark that will lead Order! That is the sort of remark that will lead to Order! That is the sort of remark that will lead to gross Order! That is the sort of remark that will lead to gross disorder. that will lead to gross disorder. Supplementary that will lead to gross disorder. Supplementary question. that will lead to gross disorder. Supplementary question. To that will lead to gross disorder. Supplementary question. To the that will lead to gross disorder. Supplementary question. To the PM, Supplementary question. To the PM, if Supplementary question. To the PM, if that Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is true, Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is true, did Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is true, did he Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is true, did he lie Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is true, did he lie to Supplementary question. To the PM, if that is true, did he lie to the if that is true, did he lie to the nation, if that is true, did he lie to the nation, Q&A, if that is true, did he lie to the nation, Q&A, Morning if that is true, did he lie to the nation, Q&A, Morning Report, if that is true, did he lie to the nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the if that is true, did he lie to the nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike hosinging, nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike hosinging, the nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike hosinging, the country Show, Mike hosinging, the country and Show, Mike hosinging, the country and others Show, Mike hosinging, the country and others given Show, Mike hosinging, the country and others given he Show, Mike hosinging, the country and others given he now Show, Mike hosinging, the country and others given he now says... and others given he now says... Order! and others given he now says... Order! I and others given he now says... Order! I will and others given he now says... Order! I will give and others given he now says... Order! I will give the and others given he now says... Order! I will give the member and others given he now says... Order! I will give the member a Order! I will give the member a chance Order! I will give the member a chance to Order! I will give the member a chance to rephrase Order! I will give the member a chance to rephrase that Order! I will give the member a chance to rephrase that question. chance to rephrase that question. You chance to rephrase that question. You cannot chance to rephrase that question. You cannot accuse chance to rephrase that question. You cannot accuse another chance to rephrase that question. You cannot accuse another member chance to rephrase that question. You cannot accuse another member of You cannot accuse another member of You cannot accuse another member of You cannot accuse another member of lying in You cannot accuse another member of lying in this You cannot accuse another member of lying in this House. You cannot accuse another member of lying in this House. Point You cannot accuse another member of lying in this House. Point of You cannot accuse another member of lying in this House. Point of order. lying in this House. Point of order. The lying in this House. Point of order. The member lying in this House. Point of order. The member didn't lying in this House. Point of order. The member didn't make lying in this House. Point of order. The member didn't make an The member didn't make an The member didn't make an The member didn't make an accusation, he The member didn't make an accusation, he asked The member didn't make an accusation, he asked a The member didn't make an accusation, he asked a question. The member didn't make an accusation, he asked a question. If accusation, he asked a question. If we accusation, he asked a question. If we go accusation, he asked a question. If we go back accusation, he asked a question. If we go back through accusation, he asked a question. If we go back through Hansard accusation, he asked a question. If we go back through Hansard you accusation, he asked a question. If we go back through Hansard you will we go back through Hansard you will find we go back through Hansard you will we we go back through Hansard you will find copious examples we go back through Hansard you will find copious examples of we go back through Hansard you will find copious examples of where find copious examples of where ministers find copious examples of where ministers have find copious examples of where ministers have been find copious examples of where ministers have been asked find copious examples of where ministers have been asked where find copious examples of where ministers have been asked where they ministers have been asked where they have ministers have been asked where they have told ministers have been asked where they have told the ministers have been asked where they have told the truth ministers have been asked where they have told the truth about ministers have been asked where they have told the truth about something have told the truth about something have told the truth about something have told the truth about something or whether have told the truth about something or whether they have told the truth about something or whether they have have told the truth about something or whether they have lied have told the truth about something or whether they have lied about or whether they have lied about something. or whether they have lied about something. This or whether they have lied about something. This is or whether they have lied about something. This is certainly or whether they have lied about something. This is certainly not or whether they have lied about something. This is certainly not the something. This is certainly not the something. This is certainly not the something. This is certainly not the first time something. This is certainly not the first time it something. This is certainly not the first time it has something. This is certainly not the first time it has been something. This is certainly not the first time it has been used something. This is certainly not the first time it has been used in something. This is certainly not the first time it has been used in a first time it has been used in a first time it has been used in a first time it has been used in a question. It first time it has been used in a question. It is first time it has been used in a question. It is absolutely first time it has been used in a question. It is absolutely out first time it has been used in a question. It is absolutely out of question. It is absolutely out of question. It is absolutely out of question. It is absolutely out of order to question. It is absolutely out of order to accuse question. It is absolutely out of order to accuse someone question. It is absolutely out of order to accuse someone of question. It is absolutely out of order to accuse someone of it, question. It is absolutely out of order to accuse someone of it, it question. It is absolutely out of order to accuse someone of it, it is order to accuse someone of it, it is not order to accuse someone of it, it is not out order to accuse someone of it, it is not out of order to accuse someone of it, it is not out of order order to accuse someone of it, it is not out of order to order to accuse someone of it, it is not out of order to ask order to accuse someone of it, it is not out of order to ask somebody not out of order to ask somebody not out of order to ask somebody not out of order to ask somebody whether they not out of order to ask somebody whether they did not out of order to ask somebody whether they did it. not out of order to ask somebody whether they did it. I not out of order to ask somebody whether they did it. I will not out of order to ask somebody whether they did it. I will listen whether they did it. I will listen to whether they did it. I will listen to the whether they did it. I will listen to the member whether they did it. I will listen to the member as whether they did it. I will listen to the member as he whether they did it. I will listen to the member as he rephrases whether they did it. I will listen to the member as he rephrases or to the member as he rephrases or to the member as he rephrases or to the member as he rephrases or runs that to the member as he rephrases or runs that same to the member as he rephrases or runs that same question. to the member as he rephrases or runs that same question. If to the member as he rephrases or runs that same question. If I to the member as he rephrases or runs that same question. If I don't runs that same question. If I don't like runs that same question. If I don't like the runs that same question. If I don't like the tone runs that same question. If I don't like the tone of runs that same question. If I don't like the tone of the runs that same question. If I don't like the tone of the question, runs that same question. If I don't like the tone of the question, and runs that same question. If I don't like the tone of the question, and I like the tone of the question, and I feel like the tone of the question, and I feel that like the tone of the question, and I feel that it like the tone of the question, and I feel that it then like the tone of the question, and I feel that it then breaches like the tone of the question, and I feel that it then breaches Speaker's feel that it then breaches Speaker's feel that it then breaches Speaker's feel that it then breaches Speaker's rulings 48, feel that it then breaches Speaker's rulings 48, it feel that it then breaches Speaker's rulings 48, it could feel that it then breaches Speaker's rulings 48, it could then feel that it then breaches Speaker's rulings 48, it could then be feel that it then breaches Speaker's rulings 48, it could then be ruled rulings 48, it could then be ruled out. rulings 48, it could then be ruled rulings rulings 48, it could then be ruled out. I will rulings 48, it could then be ruled out. I will give rulings 48, it could then be ruled out. I will give the rulings 48, it could then be ruled out. I will give the member rulings 48, it could then be ruled out. I will give the member another out. I will give the member another chance. out. I will give the member another chance. My out. I will give the member another chance. My question out. I will give the member another chance. My question to out. I will give the member another chance. My question to the out. I will give the member another chance. My question to the PM out. I will give the member another chance. My question to the PM is, out. I will give the member another chance. My question to the PM is, if chance. My question to the PM is, if that chance. My question to the PM is, if that is chance. My question to the PM is, if that is his chance. My question to the PM is, if that is his answer, chance. My question to the PM is, if that is his answer, is chance. My question to the PM is, if that is his answer, is it chance. My question to the PM is, if that is his answer, is it true chance. My question to the PM is, if that is his answer, is it true that that is his answer, is it true that he that is his answer, is it true that he did that is his answer, is it true that he did not that is his answer, is it true that he did not tell that is his answer, is it true that he did not tell the that is his answer, is it true that he did not tell the truth that is his answer, is it true that he did not tell the truth to that is his answer, is it true that he did not tell the truth to the he did not tell the truth to the Nation, he did not tell the truth to the Nation, Q&A, he did not tell the truth to the Nation, Q&A, Morning he did not tell the truth to the Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, he did not tell the truth to the Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the he did not tell the truth to the Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike hosingings Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike hosingings and Nation, Q&A, Morning Report, the AM Show, Mike hosingings and others Show, Mike hosingings and others given Show, Mike hosingings and others given that Show, Mike hosingings and others given that he Show, Mike hosingings and others given that he now Show, Mike hosingings and others given that he now says Show, Mike hosingings and others given that he now says that Show, Mike hosingings and others given that he now says that he Show, Mike hosingings and others given that he now says that he spoke given that he now says that he spoke only given that he now says that he spoke only as given that he now says that he spoke only as the given that he now says that he spoke only as the leader given that he now says that he spoke only as the leader of given that he now says that he spoke only as the leader of the given that he now says that he spoke only as the leader of the National only as the leader of the National Party? only as the leader of the National Party? No, only as the leader of the National Party? No, and only as the leader of the National Party? No, and if only as the leader of the National Party? No, and if I only as the leader of the National Party? No, and if I was only as the leader of the National Party? No, and if I was that only as the leader of the National Party? No, and if I was that member Party? No, and if I was that member I Party? No, and if I was that member only Party? No, and if I was that member I would be Party? No, and if I was that member I would be more Party? No, and if I was that member I would be more worried Party? No, and if I was that member I would be more worried about Party? No, and if I was that member I would be more worried about Shane I would be more worried about Shane Jones I would be more worried about Shane Jones showing I would be more worried about Shane Jones showing up I would be more worried about Shane Jones showing up in I would be more worried about Shane Jones showing up in his I would be more worried about Shane Jones showing up in his caucus I would be more worried about Shane Jones showing up in his caucus room. Jones showing up in his caucus room. Pretty Jones showing up in his caucus room. Pretty desperate. Jones showing up in his caucus room. Pretty desperate. Supplementary. Pretty desperate. Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. Order! Supplementary question. Desperate Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! In Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! In so Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! In so far Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! In so far - Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! In so far - to Order! Supplementary question. Desperate stuff! In so far - to the Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, in Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, in so Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, in so far Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, in so far as Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, in so far as the Desperate stuff! In so far - to the PM, in so far as the PM's PM, in so far as the PM's ministerial PM, in so far as the PM's ministerial responsibilities, PM, in so far as the PM's ministerial responsibilities, what ministerial responsibilities, what is ministerial responsibilities, what is the ministerial responsibilities, what is the difference ministerial responsibilities, what is the difference between ministerial responsibilities, what is the difference between Tito is the difference between Tito Phillip's is the difference between Tito Phillip's Fields is the difference between Tito Phillip's Fields bribery is the difference between Tito Phillip's Fields bribery and Phillip's Fields bribery and Phillip's Fields bribery and Phillip's Fields bribery and corruption conviction Phillip's Fields bribery and corruption conviction and Phillip's Fields bribery and corruption conviction and a Phillip's Fields bribery and corruption conviction and a minister corruption conviction and a minister miss corruption conviction and a minister miss appropriating corruption conviction and a minister miss appropriating $100,000 corruption conviction and a minister miss appropriating $100,000 in corruption conviction and a minister miss appropriating $100,000 in an miss appropriating $100,000 in an attempt miss appropriating $100,000 in an attempt to miss appropriating $100,000 in an attempt to silence miss appropriating $100,000 in an attempt to silence a miss appropriating $100,000 in an attempt to silence a staff miss appropriating $100,000 in an attempt to silence a staff member attempt to silence a staff member and attempt to silence a staff member and to attempt to silence a staff member and to prevent attempt to silence a staff member and to prevent the attempt to silence a staff member and to prevent the police attempt to silence a staff member and to prevent the police from and to prevent the police from laying and to prevent the police from laying criminal and to prevent the police from laying criminal charges and to prevent the police from laying criminal charges against and to prevent the police from laying criminal charges against his laying criminal charges against his backbench laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? In laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? In so laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? In so far laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? In so far as laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? In so far as the laying criminal charges against his backbench MP? In so far as the PM backbench MP? In so far as the PM can backbench MP? In so far as the PM can take backbench MP? In so far as the PM can take only backbench MP? In so far as the PM can take only prime backbench MP? In so far as the PM can take only prime ministerial can take only prime ministerial responsibility can take only prime ministerial responsibility I can take only prime ministerial responsibility I invite can take only prime ministerial responsibility I invite him can take only prime ministerial responsibility I invite him to responsibility I invite him to responsibility I invite him to responsibility I invite him to answer it. responsibility I invite him to answer it. I responsibility I invite him to answer it. I reject responsibility I invite him to answer it. I reject the answer it. I reject the member's answer it. I reject the answer it. I reject the member's assertions but answer it. I reject the member's assertions but he answer it. I reject the member's assertions but he needs answer it. I reject the member's assertions but he needs to answer it. I reject the member's assertions but he needs to work answer it. I reject the member's assertions but he needs to work out assertions but he needs to work out soon assertions but he needs to work out soon the assertions but he needs to work out soon the difference assertions but he needs to work out soon the difference between assertions but he needs to work out soon the difference between Shane soon the difference between Shane soon the difference between Shane soon the difference between Shane Jones and soon the difference between Shane Jones and the soon the difference between Shane Jones and the deputy soon the difference between Shane Jones and the deputy leader soon the difference between Shane Jones and the deputy leader of soon the difference between Shane Jones and the deputy leader of the Jones and the deputy leader of the New Jones and the deputy leader of the New Zealand Jones and the deputy leader of the New Zealand First Jones and the deputy leader of the New Zealand First party. Jones and the deputy leader of the New Zealand First party. You Jones and the deputy leader of the New Zealand First party. You can Jones and the deputy leader of the New Zealand First party. You can run New Zealand First party. You can run but New Zealand First party. You can run but you New Zealand First party. You can run but you can't New Zealand First party. You can run but you can't hide, New Zealand First party. You can run but you can't hide, Bill. but you can't hide, Bill. Supplementary but you can't hide, Bill. Supplementary question. Supplementary question. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will invite <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will invite the <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will invite the member <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will invite the member to Order! I will invite the member to ask Order! I will invite the member to ask it. Order! I will invite the member to ask it. But Order! I will invite the member to ask it. But he Order! I will invite the member to ask it. But he just Order! I will invite the member to ask it. But he just asks Order! I will invite the member to ask it. But he just asks it Order! I will invite the member to ask it. But he just asks it and ask it. But he just asks it and doesn't ask it. But he just asks it and doesn't need ask it. But he just asks it and doesn't need the ask it. But he just asks it and doesn't need the introduction. doesn't need the introduction. Supplementary doesn't need the introduction. Supplementary question. doesn't need the introduction. Supplementary question. Why, doesn't need the introduction. Supplementary question. Why, after Supplementary question. Why, after she Supplementary question. Why, after she served Supplementary question. Why, after she served him Supplementary question. Why, after she served him loyally, Supplementary question. Why, after she served him loyally, faithfully she served him loyally, faithfully she served him loyally, faithfully she served him loyally, faithfully and honestly she served him loyally, faithfully and honestly for she served him loyally, faithfully and honestly for 18 she served him loyally, faithfully and honestly for 18 years, she served him loyally, faithfully and honestly for 18 years, did she served him loyally, faithfully and honestly for 18 years, did he and honestly for 18 years, did he throw and honestly for 18 years, did he throw Glenys and honestly for 18 years, did he throw Glenys Dickson and honestly for 18 years, did he throw Glenys Dickson under and honestly for 18 years, did he throw Glenys Dickson under the and honestly for 18 years, did he throw Glenys Dickson under the bus throw Glenys Dickson under the bus and throw Glenys Dickson under the bus and shouldn't throw Glenys Dickson under the bus and shouldn't he throw Glenys Dickson under the bus and shouldn't he just throw Glenys Dickson under the bus and shouldn't he just do throw Glenys Dickson under the bus and shouldn't he just do the and shouldn't he just do the honourable and shouldn't he just do the honourable thing and shouldn't he just do the honourable thing and and shouldn't he just do the honourable thing and resign and shouldn't he just do the honourable thing and resign now? and shouldn't he just do the honourable thing and resign now? I honourable thing and resign now? I don't honourable thing and resign now? I and honourable thing and resign now? I don't believe there honourable thing and resign now? I don't believe there is honourable thing and resign now? I don't believe there is any honourable thing and resign now? I don't believe there is any prime don't believe there is any prime ministerial don't believe there is any prime ministerial responsibility don't believe there is any prime ministerial responsibility for don't believe there is any prime ministerial responsibility for that. ministerial responsibility for that. ministerial responsibility for that. ministerial responsibility for that. The question ministerial responsibility for that. The question is ministerial responsibility for that. The question is out ministerial responsibility for that. The question is out of ministerial responsibility for that. The question is out of order. The question is out of order. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I <INTERRUPTION> Order! I have <INTERRUPTION> Order! I have now <INTERRUPTION> Order! I have now called <INTERRUPTION> Order! I have now called Marama Order! I have now called Marama Davidson. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Maori My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: Is My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: Is he My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: Is he satisfied Maori Development: Is he satisfied that Maori Development: Is he satisfied that all Maori Development: Is he satisfied that all Vote Maori Development: Is he satisfied that all Vote Maori Maori Development: Is he satisfied that all Vote Maori Development that all Vote Maori Development initiatives that all Vote Maori Development initiatives were that all Vote Maori Development initiatives were adequately that all Vote Maori Development initiatives were adequately funded initiatives were adequately funded and initiatives were adequately funded and planned initiatives were adequately funded and planned in initiatives were adequately funded and planned in Budget initiatives were adequately funded and planned in Budget 2017? The The Hon The Hon Steven The Hon Steven Joyce. The Hon Steven Joyce. On The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf of The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf of the The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf of the Minister The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf of the Minister of The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf of the Minister of Maori The Hon Steven Joyce. On behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, the Minister of Maori Development, and the Minister of Maori Development, yes, in the the Minister of Maori Development, yes, in the context the Minister of Maori Development, yes, in the context of the Minister of Maori Development, yes, in the context of the the Minister of Maori Development, yes, in the context of the stage the Minister of Maori Development, yes, in the context of the stage of yes, in the context of the stage of development yes, in the context of the stage of development of yes, in the context of the stage of development of each yes, in the context of the stage of development of each initiatives. development of each initiatives. Budget development of each initiatives. Budget 2017 development of each initiatives. Budget 2017 contains development of each initiatives. Budget 2017 contains over development of each initiatives. Budget 2017 contains over a development of each initiatives. Budget 2017 contains over a dozen Budget 2017 contains over a dozen Vote Budget 2017 contains over a dozen Vote Maori Budget 2017 contains over a dozen Vote Maori Development Budget 2017 contains over a dozen Vote Maori Development initiatives Vote Maori Development initiatives spanning Vote Maori Development initiatives spanning housing Vote Maori Development initiatives spanning housing to Vote Maori Development initiatives spanning housing to sustaining Vote Maori Development initiatives spanning housing to sustaining Maori Vote Maori Development initiatives spanning Vote Maori Development initiatives culture and they Vote Maori Development initiatives culture and they have Vote Maori Development initiatives culture and they have received Vote Maori Development initiatives culture and they have received more culture and they have received more than culture and they have received more than ever culture and they have received more than ever before culture and they have received more than ever before deliver culture and they have received more than ever before deliver improved than ever before deliver improved outcomes than ever before deliver improved outcomes for than ever before deliver improved outcomes for Maori. than ever before deliver improved outcomes for Maori. In than ever before deliver improved outcomes for Maori. In addition outcomes for Maori. In addition Budget outcomes for Maori. In addition Budget 2017's outcomes for Maori. In addition Budget 2017's $2 outcomes for Maori. In addition Budget 2017's $2 billion Budget 2017's $2 billion Family Budget 2017's $2 billion Budget 2017's $2 billion Family Incomes Package Budget 2017's $2 billion Family Incomes Package puts Budget 2017's $2 billion Family Incomes Package puts more Budget 2017's $2 billion Family Incomes Package puts more money Budget 2017's $2 billion Family Incomes Package puts more money into Incomes Package puts more money into the Incomes Package puts more money into the pockets Incomes Package puts more money into the pockets of Incomes Package puts more money into the pockets of Maoris Incomes Package puts more money into the pockets of Maoris by Incomes Package puts more money into the pockets of Maoris by increasing the pockets of Maoris by increasing the pockets of Maoris by increasing the pockets of Maoris by increasing the personal the pockets of Maoris by increasing the personal income the pockets of Maoris by increasing the personal income tax the pockets of Maoris by increasing the personal income tax thresholds, the personal income tax thresholds, increasing the personal income tax thresholds, increasing work the personal income tax thresholds, increasing work g the personal income tax thresholds, increasing work g for the personal income tax thresholds, increasing work g for fam the personal income tax thresholds, increasing work g for fam ing the personal income tax thresholds, increasing work g for fam ing for increasing work g for fam ing for families increasing work g for fam ing for families payments increasing work g for fam ing for families payments and increasing work g for fam ing for families payments and boosting increasing work g for fam ing for families payments and boosting the families payments and boosting the families payments and boosting the families payments and boosting the accommodation supplement. families payments and boosting the accommodation supplement. How families payments and boosting the accommodation supplement. How can accommodation supplement. How can accommodation supplement. How can accommodation supplement. How can the public accommodation supplement. How can the public have accommodation supplement. How can the public have any accommodation supplement. How can the public have any confidence accommodation supplement. How can the public have any confidence in the public have any confidence in the the public have any confidence in the national/Maori the public have any confidence in the national/Maori Party the public have any confidence in the national/Maori Party health the public have any confidence in clinic pilot the public have any confidence in clinic pilot when the public have any confidence in clinic pilot when TPK the public have any confidence in clinic pilot when TPK stated the public have any confidence in clinic pilot when TPK stated this clinic pilot when TPK stated this month clinic pilot when TPK stated this month that clinic pilot when TPK stated this month that there clinic pilot when TPK stated this month that there was clinic pilot when TPK stated this month that there was no clinic pilot when TPK stated this month that there was no needs month that there was no needs analysis, month that there was no needs analysis, it month that there was no needs analysis, it doesn't month that there was no needs analysis, it doesn't have month that there was no needs analysis, it doesn't have a month that there was no needs analysis, it doesn't have a design, analysis, it doesn't have a design, it analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't know analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't know how analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't know how is analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't know how is it analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't know how is it going analysis, it doesn't have a design, it doesn't know how is it going to it doesn't know how is it going to it doesn't know how is it going to it doesn't know how is it going to operate and it doesn't know how is it going to operate and doesn't it doesn't know how is it going to operate and doesn't have it doesn't know how is it going to operate and doesn't have targeted operate and doesn't have targeted outcomes? operate and doesn't have targeted outcomes? On operate and doesn't have targeted outcomes? On behalf operate and doesn't have targeted outcomes? On behalf of operate and doesn't have targeted outcomes? On behalf of the operate and doesn't have targeted outcomes? On behalf of the Minister outcomes? On behalf of the Minister of outcomes? On behalf of the Minister of Maori outcomes? On behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, outcomes? On behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, international of Maori Development, international of Maori Development, international of Maori Development, international research shows of Maori Development, international research shows that of Maori Development, international research shows that mobile of Maori Development, international research shows that mobile health research shows that mobile health clinics research shows that mobile health clinics can research shows that mobile health clinics can improve research shows that mobile health clinics can improve individual clinics can improve individual health clinics can improve individual health outcomes, clinics can improve individual health outcomes, advance clinics can improve individual health outcomes, advance population health outcomes, advance population health health outcomes, advance population health and health outcomes, advance population health and reduce health outcomes, advance population health and reduce healthcare health outcomes, advance population health and reduce healthcare costs health and reduce healthcare costs compared health and reduce healthcare costs compared to health and reduce healthcare costs compared to traditional health and reduce healthcare costs compared to traditional primary health and reduce healthcare costs healthcare services. health and reduce healthcare costs healthcare services. Maori health and reduce healthcare costs healthcare services. Maori make health and reduce healthcare costs healthcare services. Maori make up healthcare services. Maori make up approximately healthcare services. Maori make up approximately 15.6% healthcare services. Maori make up approximately 15.6% of healthcare services. Maori make up approximately 15.6% of the approximately 15.6% of the rural approximately 15.6% of the approximately 15.6% of the rural population nationally approximately 15.6% of the rural population nationally and approximately 15.6% of the rural population nationally and experience population nationally and experience poorer population nationally and experience poorer health population nationally and experience poorer health outcomes population nationally and experience poorer health outcomes than poorer health outcomes than non-Maori. poorer health outcomes than non-Maori. This poorer health outcomes than non-Maori. This is poorer health outcomes than non-Maori. This is an poorer health outcomes than non-Maori. This is an innovative non-Maori. This is an innovative non-Maori. This is an innovative non-Maori. This is an innovative proposal and non-Maori. This is an innovative proposal and I non-Maori. This is an innovative proposal and I suspect non-Maori. This is an innovative proposal and I suspect the non-Maori. This is an innovative proposal and I suspect the member non-Maori. This is an innovative proposal and I suspect the member is proposal and I suspect the member is indicating proposal and I suspect the member is indicating he proposal and I suspect the member is indicating he is proposal and I suspect the member is indicating he is against proposal and I suspect the member is indicating he is against it. proposal and I suspect the member is indicating he is against it. In proposal and I suspect the member is indicating he is against it. In that indicating he is against it. In that case, indicating he is against it. In that case, what indicating he is against it. In that case, what are indicating he is against it. In that case, what are the indicating he is against it. In that case, what are the targeted indicating he is against it. In that case, what are the targeted outcomes case, what are the targeted outcomes for case, what are the targeted outcomes for specific case, what are the targeted outcomes for specific conditions, case, what are the targeted outcomes for specific conditions, including for specific conditions, including rheumatic for specific conditions, including rheumatic fever, for specific conditions, including rheumatic fever, diabetes, for specific conditions, including rheumatic fever, diabetes, renal rheumatic fever, diabetes, renal favour, rheumatic fever, diabetes, renal favour, which rheumatic fever, diabetes, renal favour, which disproportionately favour, which disproportionately affect favour, which disproportionately affect Maori? favour, which disproportionately affect Maori? On favour, which disproportionately affect Maori? On behalf favour, which disproportionately affect Maori? On behalf of favour, which disproportionately affect Maori? On behalf of the favour, which disproportionately favour, favour, which disproportionately Minister for Maori favour, which disproportionately Minister for Maori Development, Minister for Maori Development, those Minister for Maori Development, those outcomes Minister for Maori Development, those outcomes are Minister for Maori Development, those outcomes are currently Minister for Maori Development, those outcomes are currently - Minister for Maori Development, those outcomes are currently - those those outcomes are currently - those desired those outcomes are currently - those desired outcomes those outcomes are currently - those desired outcomes are those outcomes are currently - those desired outcomes are currently those outcomes are currently - those desired outcomes are currently being desired outcomes are currently being desired outcomes are currently being desired outcomes are currently being set and desired outcomes are currently being set and will desired outcomes are currently being set and will be desired outcomes are currently being set and will be as desired outcomes are currently being set and will be as the desired outcomes are currently being set and will be as the project desired outcomes are currently being set and will be as the project is set and will be as the project is rolled set and will be as the project is rolled out, set and will be as the project is rolled out, as set and will be as the project is rolled out, as yet set and will be as the project is rolled out, as yet another set and will be as the project is rolled out, as yet another of set and will be as the project is rolled out, as yet another of the rolled out, as yet another of the initiatives, rolled out, as yet another of the initiatives, innovative rolled out, as yet another of the initiatives, innovative initiatives, initiatives, innovative initiatives, initiatives, innovative initiatives, initiatives, innovative initiatives, that this initiatives, innovative initiatives, that this Government initiatives, innovative initiatives, that this Government has initiatives, innovative initiatives, that this Government has come initiatives, innovative initiatives, that this Government has come up that this Government has come up with. that this Government has come up with. All that this Government has come up with. All those that this Government has come up with. All those details that this Government has come up with. All those details will that this Government has come up with. All those details will be with. All those details will be finalised. with. All those details will be finalised. <INTERRUPTION> finalised. <INTERRUPTION> Order! finalised. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Is finalised. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Is it finalised. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Is it the finalised. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Is it the national/Maori Order! Is it the national/Maori Party Order! Is it the national/Maori Party Government Order! Is it the national/Maori Party Government style Order! Is it the national/Maori Party Government style to Order! Is it the national/Maori Party Government style to allocate Party Government style to allocate funding Party Government style to allocate funding for Party Government style to allocate funding for initiatives Party Government style to allocate funding for initiatives like Party Government style to allocate funding for initiatives like marae funding for initiatives like marae order funding for initiatives like marae order which funding for initiatives like marae order which also funding for initiatives like marae order which also has funding for initiatives like marae order which also has no funding for initiatives like marae order which also has no operational order which also has no operational plan, order which also has no operational plan, no order which also has no operational plan, no criteria order which also has no operational plan, no criteria for order which also has no operational plan, no criteria for marae order which also has no operational plan, no criteria for marae to order which also has no operational plan, no criteria for marae to meet plan, no criteria for marae to meet to plan, no criteria for marae to meet to get plan, no criteria for marae to meet to get funding plan, no criteria for marae to meet to get funding and plan, no criteria for marae to meet to get funding and ask plan, no criteria for marae to meet to get funding and ask when plan, no criteria for marae to meet to get funding and ask when asked to get funding and ask when asked how to get funding and ask when asked how many to get funding and ask when asked how many marae to get funding and ask when asked how many marae will to get funding and ask when asked how many marae will benefit to get funding and ask when asked how many marae will benefit the how many marae will benefit the answer how many marae will benefit the answer from how many marae will benefit the answer from the how many marae will benefit the answer from the minister how many marae will benefit the answer from the minister was how many marae will benefit the answer from the minister was "a answer from the minister was "a number"? answer from the minister was "a number"? Does answer from the minister was "a number"? Does the answer from the minister was "a number"? Does the minister answer from the minister was "a number"? Does the minister realise number"? Does the minister realise zero number"? Does the minister realise zero is number"? Does the minister realise zero is a number"? Does the minister realise zero is a number? number"? Does the minister realise zero is a number? Again, number"? Does the minister realise zero is a number? Again, there number"? Does the minister realise zero is a number? Again, there are zero is a number? Again, there are two zero is a number? Again, there are two questions. zero is a number? Again, there are two questions. On zero is a number? Again, there are two questions. On behalf zero is a number? Again, there are two questions. On behalf of zero is a number? Again, there are two questions. On behalf of the two questions. On behalf of the Minister two questions. On behalf of the Minister for two questions. On behalf of the Minister for Maori two questions. On behalf of the Minister for Maori Development, two questions. On behalf of the Minister for Maori Development, I'm two questions. On behalf of the Minister two questions. On behalf of the thrilled that the two questions. On behalf of the thrilled that the member two questions. On behalf of the thrilled that the member is two questions. On behalf of the thrilled that the member is raising thrilled that the member is raising these thrilled that the member is raising these Budget thrilled that the member is raising these Budget initiatives thrilled that the member is raising these Budget initiatives in thrilled that the member is raising these Budget initiatives in the these Budget initiatives in the House these Budget initiatives in the House today these Budget initiatives in the House today and these Budget initiatives in the House today and giving these Budget initiatives in the House today and giving them these Budget initiatives in the House today and giving them a these Budget initiatives in the House today and giving them a little House today and giving them a little bit House today and giving them a little bit of House today and giving them a little bit of extra House today and giving them a little bit of extra publicity. House today and giving them a little bit of extra publicity. The bit of extra publicity. The sustaining bit of extra publicity. The sustaining the bit of extra publicity. The sustaining the marae bit of extra publicity. The sustaining the marae initiative sustaining the marae initiative the sustaining the marae initiative sustaining the marae initiative the $10 million sustaining the marae initiative the $10 million over sustaining the marae initiative the $10 million over four sustaining the marae initiative the $10 million over four years sustaining the marae initiative the $10 million over four years for sustaining the marae initiative the $10 million over four years for a $10 million over four years for a contestable $10 million over four years for a contestable fund $10 million over four years for a contestable fund to $10 million over four years for a contestable fund to improve, $10 million over four years for a contestable fund to improve, restore contestable fund to improve, restore contestable fund to improve, restore contestable fund to improve, restore and revitalise contestable fund to improve, restore and revitalise the contestable fund to improve, restore and revitalise the cultural contestable fund to improve, restore and revitalise the cultural and and revitalise the cultural and and revitalise the cultural and and revitalise the cultural and physical integrity and revitalise the cultural and physical integrity of and revitalise the cultural and physical integrity of marae, physical integrity of marae, including physical integrity of marae, including investments physical integrity of marae, including investments to physical integrity of marae, including investments to meet including investments to meet earthquake including investments to meet earthquake and including investments to meet earthquake and health including investments to meet earthquake and health and including investments to meet earthquake and health and safety earthquake and health and safety requirements, earthquake and health and safety requirements, particularly earthquake and health and safety requirements, particularly where requirements, particularly where physical requirements, particularly where physical restoration requirements, particularly where physical restoration projects requirements, particularly where physical restoration projects are requirements, particularly where physical restoration projects are a physical restoration projects are a catalyst physical restoration projects are a catalyst for physical restoration projects are a catalyst for strengthening catalyst for strengthening knowledge. catalyst for strengthening knowledge. This catalyst for strengthening knowledge. This is catalyst for strengthening knowledge. This is a catalyst for strengthening knowledge. This is a wonderful knowledge. This is a wonderful initiative. knowledge. This is a wonderful initiative. I knowledge. This is a wonderful initiative. I thank knowledge. This is a wonderful initiative. I thank the knowledge. This is a wonderful initiative. I thank the member knowledge. This is a wonderful initiative. I thank the member for initiative. I thank the member for initiative. I thank the member for initiative. I thank the member for highlighting it initiative. I thank the member for highlighting it and initiative. I thank the member for highlighting it and I'm initiative. I thank the member for highlighting it and I'm sure initiative. I thank the member for highlighting it and I'm sure that highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi in highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi in his highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi in his area highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi in his area will highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi in his area will be highlighting it and I'm sure that iwi in his area will be interested iwi in his area will be interested in iwi in his area will be interested in applying iwi in his area will be interested in applying to iwi in his area will be interested in applying to it iwi in his area will be interested in applying to it to iwi in his area will be interested in applying to it to strengthen iwi in his area will be interested in applying to it to strengthen and in applying to it to strengthen and sustain in applying to it to strengthen and sustain their in applying to it to strengthen and sustain their marae. in applying to it to strengthen and sustain their marae. <INTERRUPTION> sustain their marae. <INTERRUPTION> Order! sustain their marae. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary sustain their marae. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question, Order! Supplementary question, Kelvin Order! Supplementary question, Kelvin Davis Order! Supplementary question, Kelvin Davis What Order! Supplementary question, Kelvin Davis What kind Order! Supplementary question, Kelvin Davis What kind of Order! Supplementary question, Kelvin Davis What kind of minister Kelvin Davis What kind of minister bids Kelvin Davis What kind of minister bids for Kelvin Davis What kind of minister bids for initiatives Kelvin Davis What kind of minister bids for initiatives that Kelvin Davis What kind of minister bids for initiatives that have Kelvin Davis What kind of minister bids for initiatives that have no bids for initiatives that have no operational bids for initiatives that have no operational plan, bids for initiatives that have no operational plan, no bids for initiatives that have no operational plan, no design bids for initiatives that have no operational plan, no design and bids for initiatives that have no operational plan, no design and no operational plan, no design and no targets? operational plan, no design and no targets? No, operational plan, no design and no targets? No, we've operational plan, no design and no targets? No, we've got operational plan, no design and no targets? No, we've got one! operational plan, no design and no targets? No, we've got one! On targets? No, we've got one! On behalf targets? No, we've got one! On behalf of targets? No, we've got one! On behalf of the targets? No, we've got one! On behalf of the Minister targets? No, we've got one! On behalf of the Minister of targets? No, we've got one! On behalf of the Minister of Maori behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, it behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, it is behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, it is important behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, it is important to behalf of the Minister of Maori Development, it is important to bid Development, it is important to bid for Development, it is important to bid for initiatives Development, it is important to bid for initiatives that Development, it is important to bid for initiatives that create Development, it is important to bid for initiatives that create new for initiatives that create new opportunities for initiatives that create new opportunities in for initiatives that create new opportunities in the for initiatives that create new opportunities in the future. for initiatives that create new opportunities in the future. For opportunities in the future. For example, opportunities in the future. For example, we opportunities in the future. For example, we could opportunities in the future. For example, we could find opportunities in the future. For example, we could find there opportunities in the future. For example, we could find there was opportunities in the future. For example, we could find there was a example, we could find there was a marae example, we could find there was a marae that example, we could find there was a marae that actually example, we could find there was a marae that actually had example, we could find there was a marae that actually had broken marae that actually had broken showers marae that actually had broken showers or marae that actually had broken showers or perhaps marae that actually had broken showers or perhaps limited showers or perhaps limited showers or perhaps limited showers or perhaps limited accommodation and showers or perhaps limited accommodation and we showers or perhaps limited accommodation and we might showers or perhaps limited accommodation and we might want showers or perhaps limited accommodation and we might want to accommodation and we might want to invest accommodation and we might want to invest in accommodation and we might want to invest in sustaining accommodation and we might want to invest in sustaining that accommodation and we might want to invest in sustaining that marae, invest in sustaining that marae, particularly invest in sustaining that marae, particularly if invest in sustaining that marae, particularly if a invest in sustaining that marae, particularly if a political particularly if a political party particularly if a political particularly if a political party had brought particularly if a political party had brought people particularly if a political party had brought people there particularly if a political party had brought people there on particularly if a political party had brought people there on false had brought people there on false pre had brought people there on false pre tenses had brought people there on false pre tenses and had brought people there on false pre tenses and tried had brought people there on false pre tenses and tried to had brought people there on false pre tenses and tried to tell had brought people there on false pre tenses and tried to tell them pre tenses and tried to tell them pre pre tenses and tried to tell them that pre tenses and tried to tell them that it was a pre tenses and tried to tell them that it was a good pre tenses and tried to tell them that it was a good place pre tenses and tried to tell them that it was a good place for that it was a good place for that it was a good place for that it was a good place for accommodation. That that it was a good place for accommodation. That is that it was a good place for accommodation. That is why that it was a good place for accommodation. That is why you that it was a good place for accommodation. That is why you have accommodation. That is why you have these accommodation. That is why you have these sores accommodation. That is why you have these sores of accommodation. That is why you have these sores of initiatives accommodation. That is why you have these sores of initiatives to accommodation. That is why you have these sores of initiatives to cater these sores of initiatives to cater for these sores of initiatives to cater for the these sores of initiatives to cater for the opportunities these sores of initiatives to cater for the opportunities as these sores of initiatives to cater for the opportunities as they these sores of initiatives to cater for the opportunities as they come for the opportunities as they come up, for the opportunities as they come up, Mr for the opportunities as they come up, Mr Speaker. for the opportunities as they come up, Mr Speaker. <INTERRUPTION> up, Mr Speaker. <INTERRUPTION> Order! up, Mr Speaker. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! up, Mr Speaker. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! Question up, Mr Speaker. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! Question number8. Order! Order! Question number8. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! , <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I can't <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I can't hear <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I can't hear with <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I can't hear with the <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I can't hear with the level Order! , I can't hear with the level <INTERRUPTION> Order! , I can't hear with the level of interjections. I Order! , I can't hear with the level of interjections. I will Order! , I can't hear with the level of interjections. I will have Order! , I can't hear with the level of interjections. I will have to of interjections. I will have to give of interjections. I will have to give a of interjections. I will have to give a couple of interjections. I will have to give a couple of of interjections. I will have to give a couple of final of interjections. I will have to give a couple of final warnings of interjections. I will have to give a couple of final warnings and give a couple of final warnings and one give a couple of final warnings and one will give a couple of final warnings and one will be give a couple of final warnings and one will be to give a couple of final warnings and one will be to Grant give a couple of final warnings and one will be to Grant Robertson. give a couple of final warnings and one will be to Grant Robertson. I one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't hear one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't hear where one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't hear where it one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't hear where it came one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't hear where it came from one will be to Grant Robertson. I didn't hear where it came from that didn't hear where it came from that time didn't hear where it came from that time but didn't hear where it came from that time but members didn't hear where it came from that time but members are didn't hear where it came from that time but members are - didn't hear where it came from that time but members are - Kris didn't hear where it came from that time but members are - Kris Faafoi time but members are - Kris Faafoi has time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned up time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned up so time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned up so we time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned up so we will time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned up so we will make time but members are - Kris Faafoi has owned up so we will make it has owned up so we will make it quite has owned up so we will make it quite clear has owned up so we will make it quite clear to has owned up so we will make it quite clear to Kris has owned up so we will make it quite clear to Kris Faafoi has owned up so we will make it quite clear to Kris Faafoi if has owned up so we will make it quite clear to Kris Faafoi if he quite clear to Kris Faafoi if he interjects quite clear to Kris Faafoi if he interjects again quite clear to Kris Faafoi if he interjects again through interjects again through question interjects again through interjects again through question time I interjects again through question time I will interjects again through question time I will ask interjects again through question time I will ask him interjects again through question time I will ask him to interjects again through question time I will ask him to leave. interjects again through question time I will ask him to leave. Thank time I will ask him to leave. Thank you. time I will ask him to leave. Thank you. My time I will ask him to leave. Thank you. My pleasure. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Primary My question is to the Minister for Primary Industries: My question is to the Minister for Primary Industries: How My question is to the Minister for Primary Industries: How is My question is to the Minister for Primary Industries: How is the Primary Industries: How is the Government Primary Industries: How is the Government supporting Primary Industries: How is the Government supporting the Primary Industries: How is the Government supporting the primary Government supporting the primary sector Government supporting the primary sector to Government supporting the primary sector to grow Government supporting the primary sector to grow sustainably Government supporting the primary sector to grow sustainably through sector to grow sustainably through science? Minister Minister Paul Minister Paul Goldsmith Minister Paul Goldsmith and Minister Paul Goldsmith and I Minister Paul Goldsmith and I recently Minister Paul Goldsmith and I recently launched Minister Paul Goldsmith and I recently launched a Minister Paul Goldsmith and I recently launched a primary Minister Paul Goldsmith and I recently launched a primary sector recently launched a primary sector road recently launched a primary sector science? recently launched a primary sector road map. Science recently launched a primary sector road map. Science will recently launched a primary sector road map. Science will be recently launched a primary sector road map. Science will be a recently launched a primary sector road map. Science will be a key road map. Science will be a key driver road map. Science will be a key driver in road map. Science will be a key driver in doubling road map. Science will be a key driver in doubling the road map. Science will be a key driver in doubling the value road map. Science will be a key driver in doubling the value of road map. Science will be a key driver in doubling the value of our driver in doubling the value of our overall driver in doubling the value of our overall primary driver in doubling the value of our overall primary sector driver in doubling the value of our overall primary sector exports driver in doubling the value of our overall primary sector exports by overall primary sector exports by 2025. overall primary sector exports by 2025. This overall primary sector exports by 2025. This road overall primary sector exports by 2025. This road map overall primary sector exports by 2025. This road map will overall primary sector exports by 2025. This road map will inform 2025. This road map will inform research 2025. This road map will inform research conducted 2025. This road map will inform research conducted by 2025. This road map will inform research conducted by New 2025. This road map will inform research conducted by New Zealand research conducted by New Zealand science research conducted by New Zealand science and research conducted by New Zealand science and technology research conducted by New Zealand science and technology teams research conducted by New Zealand science and technology teams and science and technology teams and organisations science and technology teams and organisations along science and technology teams and organisations along with science and technology teams and organisations along with their organisations along with their organisations along with their organisations along with their international partners. organisations along with their international partners. It organisations along with their international partners. It provides international partners. It provides a international partners. It provides a shared international partners. It provides a shared view international partners. It provides a shared view across international partners. It provides a shared view across the a shared view across the primary a shared view across the a shared view across the primary sector on a shared view across the primary sector on the a shared view across the primary sector on the science a shared view across the primary sector on the science and a shared view across the primary sector on the science and technology sector on the science and technology needs sector on the science and technology needs for sector on the science and technology needs for the sector on the science and technology needs for the sector sector on the science and technology needs for the sector and sector on the science and technology needs for the sector and where needs for the sector and where needs for the sector and where needs for the sector and where investment needs needs for the sector and where investment needs to needs for the sector and where investment needs to be needs for the sector and where investment needs to be focussed. investment needs to be focussed. Supplementary investment needs to be focussed. Supplementary question. investment needs to be focussed. Supplementary question. To investment needs to be focussed. Supplementary question. To the Supplementary question. To the Supplementary question. To the Supplementary question. To the minister, how Supplementary question. To the minister, how is Supplementary question. To the minister, how is the Supplementary question. To the minister, how is the Government minister, how is the Government minister, how is the Government minister, how is the Government partnering with minister, how is the Government partnering with farmers minister, how is the Government partnering with farmers and minister, how is the Government partnering with farmers and growers partnering with farmers and growers at partnering with farmers and growers at a partnering with farmers and growers at a grassroots partnering with farmers and growers at a grassroots level partnering with farmers and growers at a grassroots level to partnering with farmers and growers at a grassroots level to adapt partnering with farmers and growers at a grassroots level to adapt to at a grassroots level to adapt to environmental at a grassroots level to adapt to environmental challenges? at a grassroots level to adapt to environmental challenges? That's at a grassroots level to adapt to environmental challenges? That's a environmental challenges? That's a environmental challenges? That's a environmental challenges? That's a very good environmental challenges? That's a very good question. environmental challenges? That's a very good question. The environmental challenges? That's a very good question. The Sustainable very good question. The Sustainable Farming very good question. The Sustainable Farming Fund very good question. The Sustainable Farming Fund supports very good question. The Sustainable Farming Fund supports the very good question. The Sustainable Farming Fund supports the primary Farming Fund supports the primary Farming Fund supports the primary Farming Fund supports the primary sector's own Farming Fund supports the primary sector's own forward Farming Fund supports the primary sector's own forward thinking Farming Fund supports the primary sector's own forward thinking and sector's own forward thinking and its sector's own forward thinking and its Kiwi sector's own forward thinking and its Kiwi ingenuity sector's own forward thinking and its Kiwi ingenuity which, sector's own forward thinking and its Kiwi ingenuity which, in sector's own forward thinking and its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps keep its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps keep New its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps keep New Zealand its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps keep New Zealand ahead its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps keep New Zealand ahead of its Kiwi ingenuity which, in turn, helps keep New Zealand ahead of the helps keep New Zealand ahead of the game. helps keep New Zealand ahead of the game. 1,000 helps keep New Zealand ahead of the game. 1,000 projects helps keep New Zealand ahead of the game. 1,000 projects have helps keep New Zealand ahead of the game. 1,000 projects have now helps keep New Zealand ahead of the game. 1,000 projects have now been game. 1,000 projects have now been funded game. 1,000 projects have now been funded since game. 1,000 projects have now been funded since the game. 1,000 projects have now been funded since the fund game. 1,000 projects have now been funded since the fund was game. 1,000 projects have now been funded since the fund was initiated funded since the fund was initiated in funded since the fund was initiated in 2000. funded since the fund was initiated in 2000. This funded since the fund was initiated in 2000. This represents funded since the fund was initiated in 2000. This represents around funded since the fund was initiated in 2000. This represents around 150 in 2000. This represents around 150 million in 2000. This represents around 150 million in in 2000. This represents around 150 million in Government in 2000. This represents around 150 million in Government funding, million in Government funding, alongside million in Government funding, alongside a million in Government funding, alongside a significant million in Government funding, alongside a significant overall alongside a significant overall level alongside a significant overall level of alongside a significant overall level of local alongside a significant overall level of local support. alongside a significant overall level of local support. Each alongside a significant overall level of local support. Each project level of local support. Each project brings level of local support. Each project brings together level of local support. Each project brings together farmers, level of local support. Each project brings together farmers, growers level of local support. Each project brings together farmers, growers and brings together farmers, growers and foresters brings together farmers, growers and foresters to brings together farmers, growers and foresters to work brings together farmers, growers and foresters to work alongside foresters to work alongside scientists foresters to work alongside scientists and foresters to work alongside scientists and researchers foresters to work alongside scientists and researchers to foresters to work alongside scientists and researchers to solve scientists and researchers to solve a scientists and researchers to solve a problem scientists and researchers to solve a problem and scientists and researchers to solve a problem and overall scientists and researchers to solve a problem and overall seize a problem and overall seize a problem and overall seize a problem and overall seize opportunities. Question a problem and overall seize opportunities. Question number9. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: In My question is to the Prime Minister: In his My question is to the Prime Minister: In his Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: In his Prime Ministerial Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand by Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand by all Minister: In his Prime Ministerial capacity, does he stand by all his capacity, does he stand by all his statements capacity, does he stand by all his statements on capacity, does he stand by all his statements on the capacity, does he stand by all his statements on the Clutha-Southland statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue even statements on the Clutha-Southland electorate office issue even if electorate office issue even if facts electorate office issue even if facts known electorate office issue even if facts known to electorate office issue even if facts known to him electorate office issue even if facts known to him make electorate office issue even if facts known to him make doing electorate office issue even if facts known to him make doing so facts known to him make doing so extraordinarily facts known to him make doing so extraordinarily difficult; facts known to him make doing so extraordinarily difficult; if facts known to him make doing so extraordinarily difficult; if so, extraordinarily difficult; if so, how? Those Those statements Those statements are Those statements are not Those statements are not made Those statements are not made in Those statements are not made in my Those statements are not made in my prime Those statements are not made in my prime ministerial prime ministerial capacity. prime ministerial prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. In prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. In light prime ministerial capacity. Supplementary question. In light of Supplementary question. In light of recent Supplementary question. In light of recent comments Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has made Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has made as Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has made as PM, recent comments he has made as PM, was recent comments he has made as PM, was he recent comments he has made as PM, was he deliberately recent comments he has made as PM, was he deliberately being recent comments he has made as PM, was he deliberately being dismissive was he deliberately being dismissive was he deliberately being dismissive was he deliberately being dismissive about recordings was he deliberately being dismissive about recordings because was he deliberately being dismissive about recordings because one about recordings because one intercepted about recordings because one intercepted conversation about recordings because one intercepted conversation involved intercepted conversation involved talk intercepted conversation involved talk of intercepted conversation involved talk of sex intercepted conversation involved talk of sex and intercepted conversation involved talk of sex and drugs, intercepted conversation involved talk of sex and drugs, as intercepted conversation involved talk of sex and drugs, as reported talk of sex and drugs, as reported by talk of sex and drugs, as reported by Newsroom? talk of sex and drugs, as reported by Newsroom? I talk of sex and drugs, as reported by Newsroom? I have talk of sex and drugs, as reported by Newsroom? I have nothing talk of sex and drugs, as reported by Newsroom? I have nothing to talk of sex and drugs, as reported by Newsroom? I have nothing to add by Newsroom? I have nothing to add by Newsroom? I have nothing to add by Newsroom? I have nothing to add to what's by Newsroom? I have nothing to add to what's been by Newsroom? I have nothing to add to what's been covered by Newsroom? I have nothing to add to what's been covered by by Newsroom? I have nothing to add to what's been covered by a by Newsroom? I have nothing to add to what's been covered by a 10-month to what's been covered by a 10-month police to what's been covered by a 10-month police investigation to what's been covered by a 10-month police investigation and I police investigation and I understand police investigation and I understand the police investigation and I understand the police police investigation and I understand the police are police investigation and I understand the police are reopening police investigation and I understand police investigation and I that investigation. Supplementary that investigation. Supplementary question. that investigation. Supplementary question. <INTERRUPTION> question. <INTERRUPTION> Order! question. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. question. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. In Order! Supplementary question. In light Order! Supplementary question. In light of Order! Supplementary question. In light of recent Order! Supplementary question. In light of recent comments Order! Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he Order! Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has Order! Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has made light of recent comments he has made as light of recent comments he has made as PM, light of recent comments he has made as PM, is light of recent comments he has made as PM, is he light of recent comments he has made as PM, is he deliberately light of recent comments he has made as PM, is he deliberately attempting as PM, is he deliberately attempting to as PM, is he deliberately attempting to mislead as PM, is he deliberately attempting to mislead because as PM, is he deliberately attempting to mislead because the as PM, is he deliberately attempting to mislead because the facts as PM, is he deliberately attempting to mislead because the facts known to mislead because the facts known to mislead because the facts known to mislead because the facts known to him to mislead because the facts known to him include to mislead because the facts known to him include matters to mislead because the facts known to him include matters relating to mislead because the facts known to him include matters relating to to him include matters relating to sex to him include matters relating to sex and to him include matters relating to sex and drugs? to him include matters relating to sex and drugs? As to him include matters relating to sex and drugs? As I to him include matters relating to sex and drugs? As I said, to him include matters relating to sex and drugs? As I said, I to him include matters relating to sex and drugs? As I said, I have sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to add sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to add to sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to add to what sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to add to what has sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to add to what has been sex and drugs? As I said, I have nothing to add to what has been a nothing to add to what has been a 10-month nothing to add to what has been a 10-month police nothing to add to what has been a 10-month police investigation, nothing to add to what has been a 10-month police investigation, an 10-month police investigation, an investigation 10-month police investigation, an investigation that 10-month police investigation, an investigation that has 10-month police investigation, an investigation that has now 10-month police investigation, an investigation that has now been investigation that has now been reopened. investigation that has now been reopened. Supplementary investigation that has now been reopened. Supplementary question. investigation that has now been reopened. Supplementary question. In reopened. Supplementary question. In reopened. Supplementary question. In reopened. Supplementary question. In light of reopened. Supplementary question. In light of recent reopened. Supplementary question. In light of recent comments reopened. Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he reopened. Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has reopened. Supplementary question. In light of recent comments he has made light of recent comments he has made as light of recent comments he has made as PM, light of recent comments he has made as PM, when light of recent comments he has made as PM, when his light of recent comments he has made as PM, when his text light of recent comments he has made as PM, when his text read light of recent comments he has made as PM, when his text read "everyone as PM, when his text read "everyone as PM, when his text read "everyone as PM, when his text read "everyone unhappy" was as PM, when his text read "everyone unhappy" was he as PM, when his text read "everyone unhappy" was he referring as PM, when his text read "everyone unhappy" was he referring to as PM, when his text read "everyone unhappy" was he referring to the unhappy" was he referring to the huge unhappy" was he referring to the huge settlement unhappy" was he referring to the huge settlement or unhappy" was he referring to the huge settlement or was unhappy" was he referring to the huge settlement or was it unhappy" was he referring to the huge settlement or was it because unhappy" was he referring to the huge settlement or was it because he huge settlement or was it because he knew huge settlement or was it because he knew the huge settlement or was it because he knew the contents huge settlement or was it because he knew the contents of huge settlement or was it because he knew the contents of the huge settlement or was it because he knew the contents of the recording knew the contents of the recording huge knew the contents of the recording included knew the contents of the recording included sex and drugs knew the contents of the recording included sex and drugs matters? knew the contents of the recording included sex and drugs matters? I included sex and drugs matters? I reject included sex and drugs matters? I reject the included sex and drugs matters? I reject the member's included sex and drugs matters? I reject the member's assertions included sex and drugs matters? I reject the member's assertions but, reject the member's assertions but, as reject the member's assertions but, as I've reject the member's assertions but, as I've said reject the member's assertions but, as I've said before, reject the member's assertions but, as I've said before, this reject the member's assertions but, as I've said before, this was reject the member's assertions but, as I've said before, this was a as I've said before, this was a matter as I've said before, this was a matter of as I've said before, this was a matter of two as I've said before, this was a matter of two people as I've said before, this was a matter of two people who as I've said before, this was a matter of two people who fell as I've said before, this was a matter of two people who fell out matter of two people who fell out very matter of two people who fell out very intensely matter of two people who fell out very intensely and matter of two people who fell out very intensely and that matter of two people who fell out very intensely and that has matter of two people who fell out very intensely and that has had matter of two people who fell out very intensely and that has had a very intensely and that has had a lot very intensely and that has had a lot of very intensely and that has had a lot of implications very intensely and that has had a lot of implications and very intensely and that has had a lot of implications and I very intensely and that has had a lot of implications and I hope very intensely and that has had a lot of implications and I hope they lot of implications and I hope they lot of implications and I hope they lot of implications and I hope they can find lot of implications and I hope they can find some lot of implications and I hope they can find some resolution lot of implications and I hope they can find some resolution to lot of implications and I hope they can find some resolution to their can find some resolution to their differences. can find some resolution to their differences. <INTERRUPTION> differences. <INTERRUPTION> Order! differences. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary differences. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. differences. <INTERRUPTION> Order! Supplementary question. As Order! Supplementary question. As PM, Order! Supplementary question. As PM, has Order! Supplementary question. As PM, has he Order! Supplementary question. As PM, has he attempted Order! Supplementary question. As PM, has he attempted to Order! Supplementary question. As PM, has he attempted to contact PM, has he attempted to contact Glenys PM, has he attempted to contact Glenys Dickson PM, has he attempted to contact Glenys Dickson to PM, has he attempted to contact Glenys Dickson to apologise PM, has he attempted to contact Glenys Dickson to apologise for PM, has he attempted to contact Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Glenys Dickson to apologise for her treatment by Glenys Dickson to apologise for her treatment by a Glenys Dickson to apologise for her treatment by a member Glenys Dickson to apologise for her treatment by a member of Glenys Dickson to apologise for her treatment by a member of his Glenys Dickson to apologise for her lot Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Government? If not, Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Government? If not, why Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Government? If not, why not? Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Government? If not, why not? In Glenys Dickson to apologise for her Government? If not, why not? In so Government? If not, why not? In so far Government? If not, why not? In so far as Government? If not, why not? In so far as there Government? If not, why not? In so far as there is Government? If not, why not? In so far as there is prime Government? If not, why not? In so far as there is prime ministerial far as there is prime ministerial responsibility far as there is prime ministerial responsibility the far as there is prime ministerial responsibility the Rt far as there is prime ministerial responsibility the Rt Hon far as there is prime ministerial responsibility the Rt Hon PM. far as there is prime ministerial responsibility the Rt Hon PM. I far as there is prime ministerial responsibility the Rt Hon PM. I have responsibility the Rt Hon PM. I have no responsibility the Rt Hon PM. I have no prime responsibility the Rt Hon PM. I have no prime ministerial responsibility the Rt Hon PM. I have no prime ministerial responsibility no prime ministerial responsibility for no prime ministerial responsibility for that. no prime ministerial responsibility for that. Point no prime ministerial responsibility for that. Point of no prime ministerial responsibility for that. Point of order. no prime ministerial responsibility for that. Point of order. With for that. Point of order. With regards for that. Point of order. With regards to for that. Point of order. With regards to the for that. Point of order. With regards to the line for that. Point of order. With regards to the line of for that. Point of order. With regards to the line of questioning regards to the line of questioning regards to the line of questioning regards to the line of questioning that has regards to the line of questioning that has been regards to the line of questioning that has been going regards to the line of questioning that has been going on regards to the line of questioning that has been going on for regards to the line of questioning that has been going on for the regards to the line of questioning that has been going on for the last that has been going on for the last that has been going on for the last that has been going on for the last couple of that has been going on for the last couple of days, that has been going on for the last couple of days, I that has been going on for the last couple of days, I seek that has been going on for the last couple of days, I seek your that has been going on for the last couple of days, I seek your guidance couple of days, I seek your guidance couple of days, I seek your guidance couple of days, I seek your guidance with regards couple of days, I seek your guidance with regards to couple of days, I seek your guidance with regards to Speaker's couple of days, I seek your guidance with regards to Speaker's ruling with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and to with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and to a with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and to a lesser with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and to a lesser degree with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, with regards to Speaker's ruling 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 with 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 4, all 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 4, all of 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 4, all of which 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 4, all of which touch 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 4, all of which touch on 1751 and to a lesser degree 173, 3 and 4, all of which touch on the and 4, all of which touch on the and 4, all of which touch on the and 4, all of which touch on the same #1ub9, and 4, all of which touch on the same #1ub9, the and 4, all of which touch on the same #1ub9, the fact and 4, all of which touch on the same #1ub9, the fact that and 4, all of which touch on the same #1ub9, the fact that a and 4, all of which touch on the same #1ub9, the fact that a minister same #1ub9, the fact that a minister same #1ub9, the fact that a minister same #1ub9, the fact that a minister has no same #1ub9, the fact that a minister has no legal same #1ub9, the fact that a minister has no legal control same #1ub9, the fact that a minister has no legal control over same #1ub9, the fact that a minister has no legal control over a same #1ub9, the fact that a minister has no legal control over a certain has no legal control over a certain action has no legal control over a certain action does has no legal control over a certain action does not has no legal control over a certain action does not mean has no legal control over a certain action does not mean there has no legal control over a certain action does not mean there is has no legal control over a certain action does not mean there is no action does not mean there is no ministerial action does not mean there is no ministerial responsibility action does not mean there is no ministerial responsibility to ministerial responsibility to answer ministerial responsibility to ministerial responsibility to answer a question. ministerial responsibility to answer a question. It ministerial responsibility to answer a question. It says ministerial responsibility to answer a question. It says nevertheless a question. It says nevertheless the a question. It says nevertheless a question. It says nevertheless the minister assumes a question. It says nevertheless the minister assumes the a question. It says nevertheless the minister assumes the political minister assumes the political responsibility minister assumes the political responsibility of minister assumes the political responsibility of the minister assumes the political responsibility of the House minister assumes the political responsibility of the House to minister assumes the political responsibility minister assumes the political answer questions on minister assumes the political answer questions on those minister assumes the political answer questions on those matters. answer questions on those matters. I'm answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering - answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering - I answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering - I know answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering - I know you answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering - I know you have answer questions on those matters. I'm wondering - I know you have made I'm wondering - I know you have made reference I'm wondering - I know you have made reference to I'm wondering - I know you have made reference to Speaker's I'm wondering - I know you have made reference to Speaker's ruling I'm wondering - I know you have made reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, it reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, it appears reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, it appears to reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, it appears to me reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, it appears to me that reference to Speaker's ruling 1731 and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and 1751 and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and 1751 are and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and 1751 are almost and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and 1751 are almost the and 2, it appears to me that 1733 and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of that and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of that and and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of that and do and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of that and do seem and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of that and do seem to and 4 and 1751 are almost the polar opposite of that and do seem to lay opposite of that and do seem to lay out opposite of that and do seem to lay out that opposite of that and do seem to lay out that even opposite of that and do seem to lay out that even though opposite of that and do seem to lay out that even though the opposite of that and do seem to lay out that even though the minister out that even though the minister does out that even though the minister does not out that even though the minister does not have out that even though the minister does not have legal out that even though the minister does not have legal or out that even though the minister does not have legal or ministerial does not have legal or ministerial does not have legal or ministerial does not have legal or ministerial responsibility he does not have legal or ministerial responsibility he does does not have legal or ministerial responsibility he does have does not have legal or ministerial responsibility he does have a responsibility he does have a political responsibility he does have a political responsibility responsibility he does have a political responsibility to responsibility he does have a political responsibility to the political responsibility to the political responsibility to the political responsibility to the House to political responsibility to the House to an political responsibility to the House to an those political responsibility to the House to an those questions. House to an those questions. Speaker's House to an those questions. Speaker's rulings House to an those questions. Speaker's rulings particularly House to an those questions. Speaker's rulings particularly on Speaker's rulings particularly on 175 Speaker's rulings particularly on 175 refer Speaker's rulings particularly on 175 refer to Speaker's rulings particularly on 175 refer to operational Speaker's rulings particularly on 175 refer to operational matters. Speaker's rulings particularly on 175 refer to operational matters. I 175 refer to operational matters. I am 175 refer to operational matters. I am confident 175 refer to operational matters. I am confident that 175 refer to operational matters. I am confident that you 175 refer to operational matters. I am confident that you can 175 refer to operational matters. I am confident that you can find am confident that you can find am confident that you can find am confident that you can find Speaker's rulings am confident that you can find Speaker's rulings that am confident that you can find Speaker's rulings that appear am confident that you can find Speaker's rulings that appear to Speaker's rulings that appear to Speaker's rulings that appear to Speaker's rulings that appear to contradict each Speaker's rulings that appear to contradict each other. Speaker's rulings that appear to contradict each other. The Speaker's rulings that appear to contradict each other. The ones Speaker's rulings that appear to contradict each other. The ones that contradict each other. The ones that contradict each other. The ones that contradict each other. The ones that pertain to contradict each other. The ones that pertain to these contradict each other. The ones that pertain to these matters contradict each other. The ones that pertain to these matters I contradict each other. The ones that pertain to these matters I have contradict each other. The ones that pertain to these matters I have used pertain to these matters I have used consistently pertain to these matters I have used consistently over pertain to these matters I have used consistently over the pertain to these matters I have used consistently over the past pertain to these matters I have used consistently over the past week pertain to these matters I have used consistently over the past week and consistently over the past week and have consistently over the past week and have done so in consistently over the past week and have done so in two consistently over the past week and have done so in two rulings consistently over the past week and have done so in two rulings now consistently over the past week and have done so in two rulings now and have done so in two rulings now and they have done so in two rulings now and they apply have done so in two rulings now and they apply particularly have done so in two rulings now and they apply particularly to have done so in two rulings now and they apply particularly to pages have done so in two rulings now and they apply particularly to pages 172 they apply particularly to pages 172 and they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. I they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. I do they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. I do thank they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. I do thank the they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. I do thank the member they apply particularly to pages 172 and 173. I do thank the member for and 173. I do thank the member for his and 173. I do thank the member for his assistance. and 173. I do thank the member for his assistance. Question and 173. I do thank the member for his assistance. Question No. and 173. I do thank the member for his assistance. Question No. 10. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Associate My question is to the Associate Minister My question is to the Associate Minister for My question is to the Associate Minister for Social My question is to the Associate Minister for Social Housing: My question is to the Associate Minister for Social Housing: Is My question is to the Associate Minister for Social Housing: Is the Minister for Social Housing: Is the demand Minister for Social Housing: Is the demand for Minister for Social Housing: Is the demand for New Minister for Social Housing: Is the demand for New Zealanders Minister for Social Housing: Is the demand for New Zealanders seeking demand for New Zealanders seeking emergency demand for New Zealanders seeking emergency accommodation demand for New Zealanders seeking emergency accommodation increasing emergency accommodation increasing or emergency accommodation increasing or decreasing? Demand Demand for Demand for emergency Demand for emergency housing Demand for emergency housing is Demand for emergency housing is increasing Demand for emergency housing is increasing because Demand for emergency housing is increasing because such Demand for emergency housing is increasing because such assistance Demand for emergency housing is is now Demand for emergency housing is is now available. Demand for emergency housing is is now available. <INTERRUPTION> is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm trying is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm trying to is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm trying to get is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm trying to get a is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm trying to get a bit is now available. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm trying to get a bit of Order! I'm trying to get a bit of Order! I'm trying to get a bit of Order! I'm trying to get a bit of silence and Order! I'm trying to get a bit of silence and a Order! I'm trying to get a bit of silence and a fair Order! I'm trying to get a bit of silence and a fair go Order! I'm trying to get a bit of silence and a fair go for Order! I'm trying to get a bit of silence and a fair go for the silence and a fair go for the member. silence and a fair go for the member. Supplementary silence and a fair go for the member. Supplementary question. silence and a fair go for the member. Supplementary question. Is member. Supplementary question. Is he member. Supplementary question. Is he concerned member. Supplementary question. Is he concerned that member. Supplementary question. Is he concerned that the member. Supplementary question. Is he concerned that the number member. Supplementary question. Is he concerned that the number of he concerned that the number of approved he concerned that the number of approved emergency he concerned that the number of approved emergency housing he concerned that the number of approved emergency housing special approved emergency housing special needs approved emergency housing special needs grants approved emergency housing special needs grants applications approved emergency housing special needs grants applications have approved emergency housing special needs grants applications have again needs grants applications have again increased needs grants applications have again increased from needs grants applications have again increased from 8,860 needs grants applications have again increased from 8,860 in needs grants applications have again increased from 8,860 in the needs grants applications have again increased from 8,860 in the December increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 quarter increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 quarter to increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 quarter to 9,218 increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 quarter to 9,218 in increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the increased from 8,860 in the December 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2017 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2017 quarter? 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2017 quarter? We 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2017 quarter? We know 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2017 quarter? We know that 2016 quarter to 9,218 in the March 2017 quarter? We know that we're 2017 quarter? We know that we're making 2017 quarter? We know that we're making a 2017 quarter? We know that we're making a difference 2017 quarter? We know that we're making a difference because 2017 quarter? We know that we're making a difference because there 2017 quarter? We know that we're making a difference because there is making a difference because there is more making a difference because there is more than making a difference because there is more than providing making a difference because there is more than providing a making a difference because there is more than providing a roof, making a difference because there is more than providing a roof, when more than providing a roof, when someone more than providing a roof, when someone is more than providing a roof, when someone is living more than providing a roof, when someone is living in more than providing a roof, when someone is living in transitional someone is living in transitional accommodation. someone is living in transitional accommodation. We someone is living in transitional accommodation. We are someone is living in transitional accommodation. We are really someone is living in transitional accommodation. We are really clear accommodation. We are really clear that accommodation. We are really clear that the accommodation. We are really clear that the fact accommodation. We are really clear that the fact is accommodation. We are really clear that the fact is that accommodation. We are really clear that the fact is that the accommodation. We are really clear that the fact is that the demand accommodation. We are really clear that the fact is that the demand for that the fact is that the demand for emergency that the fact is that the demand for emergency accommodation that the fact is that the demand for emergency accommodation will emergency accommodation will increase emergency accommodation will increase over emergency accommodation will increase over the emergency accommodation will increase over the winter emergency accommodation will increase over the winter months emergency accommodation will increase over the winter months so increase over the winter months so we increase over the winter months so we know increase over the winter months so we know that increase over the winter months so we know that less increase over the winter months so we know that less desirable increase over the winter months so we know that less desirable living we know that less desirable living situations we know that less desirable living situations become we know that less desirable living situations become untenable. we know that less desirable living situations become untenable. Events situations become untenable. Events such situations become untenable. Events such as situations become untenable. Events such as World situations become untenable. Events such as World Masters. situations become untenable. Events such as World Masters. The situations become untenable. Events such as World Masters. The member such as World Masters. The member can't such as World Masters. The member can't have such as World Masters. The member can't have it such as World Masters. The member can't have it both such as World Masters. The member can't have it both ways such as World Masters. The member can't have it both ways to such as World Masters. The member can't have it both ways to criticise can't have it both ways to criticise the can't have it both ways to criticise the Government can't have it both ways to criticise the Government for can't have it both ways to criticise the Government for both can't have it both ways to criticise the Government for both not can't have it both ways to criticise the Government for both not having the Government for both not having can't the Government for both not having the support and the Government for both not having the support and then the Government for both not having the support and then criticising the Government for both not having the support and then criticising the the support and then criticising the Government the support and then criticising the Government for the support and then criticising the Government for not the support and then criticising the Government for not - the support and then criticising the Government for not - for the support and then criticising the Government for not - for spending Government for not - for spending too Government for not - for spending too much. Government for not - for spending too much. Supplementary Government for not - for spending too much. Supplementary question. too much. Supplementary question. Can too much. Supplementary question. Can he too much. Supplementary question. Can he guarantee too much. Supplementary question. Can he guarantee that too much. Supplementary question. Can he guarantee that the too much. Supplementary question. Can he guarantee that the Government Can he guarantee that the Government has Can he guarantee that the Government has planned Can he guarantee that the Government has planned for Can he guarantee that the Government has planned for enough Can he guarantee that the Government has planned for enough emergency has planned for enough emergency housing has planned for enough emergency housing places has planned for enough emergency housing places across has planned for enough emergency housing places across the has planned for enough emergency housing places across the regions housing places across the regions for housing places across the regions for New housing places across the regions for New Zealanders housing places across the regions for New Zealanders in housing places across the regions for New Zealanders in 2017 housing places across the regions for New Zealanders in 2017 in housing places across the regions for New Zealanders in 2017 in light for New Zealanders in 2017 in light of for New Zealanders in 2017 in light of the for New Zealanders in 2017 in light of the growing for New Zealanders in 2017 in light of the growing demand for New Zealanders in 2017 in light of the growing demand for for New Zealanders in 2017 in light of the growing demand for emergency of the growing demand for emergency of the growing demand for emergency of the growing demand for emergency housing support? of the growing demand for emergency housing support? The of the growing demand for emergency housing support? The Government of the growing demand for emergency housing support? The Government has housing support? The Government has set housing support? The Government has set its housing support? The Government has set its intentions housing support? The Government has set its intentions out housing support? The Government has set its intentions out quite housing support? The Government has set its intentions out quite clearly set its intentions out quite clearly that set its intentions out quite clearly that it set its intentions out quite clearly that it expects set its intentions out quite clearly that it expects to set its intentions out quite clearly that it expects to secure set its intentions out quite clearly that it expects to secure 2,150 that it expects to secure 2,150 places that it expects to secure 2,150 places by that it expects to secure 2,150 places by the that it expects to secure 2,150 places by the end that it expects to secure 2,150 places by the end of that it expects to secure 2,150 places by the end of the that it expects to secure 2,150 places by the end of the year. that it expects to secure 2,150 places by the end of the year. I places by the end of the year. I understand places by the end of the year. I understand the places by the end of the year. I understand the ministry places by the end of the year. I understand the ministry expects places by the end of the year. I understand the ministry expects to understand the ministry expects to have understand the ministry expects to have around understand the ministry expects to have around 1,300 understand the ministry expects to have around 1,300 places understand the ministry expects to have around 1,300 places available have around 1,300 places available by have around 1,300 places available by June have around 1,300 places available by June with have around 1,300 places available by June with a have around 1,300 places available by June with a further have around 1,300 places available by June with a further 230 have around 1,300 places available by June with a further 230 places by June with a further 230 places expected by June with a further 230 places expected to by June with a further 230 places expected to come by June with a further 230 places expected to come in by June with a further 230 places expected to come in online by June with a further 230 places expected to come in online in by June with a further 230 places expected to come in online in early expected to come in online in early expected to come in online in early expected to come in online in early July. With expected to come in online in early July. With those expected to come in online in early July. With those places expected to come in online in early July. With those places in expected to come in online in early July. With those places in play expected to come in online in early July. With those places in play we July. With those places in play we will July. With those places in play we will be July. With those places in play we will be able July. With those places in play we will be able to July. With those places in play we will be able to support July. With those places in play we will be able to support 5,600 will be able to support 5,600 families. will be able to support 5,600 families. Supplementary will be able to support 5,600 families. Supplementary question. families. Supplementary question. What families. Supplementary question. What does families. Supplementary question. What does he families. Supplementary question. What does he say families. Supplementary question. What does he say to families. Supplementary question. What does he say to the families. Supplementary question. What does he say to the 196 families. Supplementary question. What does he say to the 196 families What does he say to the 196 families in What does he say to the 196 families in the What does he say to the 196 families in the central What does he say to the 196 families in the central North What does he say to the 196 families in the central North Island What does he say to the 196 families in the central North Island who in the central North Island who needed in the central North Island who needed emergency in the central North Island who needed emergency accommodation needed emergency accommodation between needed emergency accommodation between January needed emergency accommodation between January and needed emergency accommodation between January and March needed emergency accommodation between January and March of needed emergency accommodation between January and March of this between January and March of this between January and March of this between January and March of this year but between January and March of this year but only between January and March of this year but only had between January and March of this year but only had access between January and March of this year but only had access to between January and March of this year but only had access to 14 year but only had access to 14 Government year but only had access to 14 Government emergency year but only had access to 14 Government emergency housing year but only had access to 14 Government emergency housing places? Government emergency housing places? I Government emergency housing places? I would, Government emergency housing places? I would, what Government emergency housing places? I would, what you Government emergency housing places? I would, what you call, Government emergency housing places? I would, what you call, continue Government emergency housing places? I would, what you call, continue to I would, what you call, continue to support I would, what you call, continue to support and I would, what you call, continue to support and we I would, what you call, continue to support and we have I would, what you call, continue to support and we have put I would, what you call, continue to support and we have put out I would, what you call, continue to support and we have put out some I would, what you call, continue to support and we have put out some PRs support and we have put out some PRs just support and we have put out some PRs just of support and we have put out some PRs just of late support and we have put out some PRs just of late to support and we have put out some PRs just of late to talk support and we have put out some PRs just of late to talk about support and we have put out some PRs just of late to talk about the just of late to talk about the demands just of late to talk about the demands in just of late to talk about the demands in which we just of late to talk about the demands in which we have just of late to talk about the demands in which we have been demands in which we have been meeting demands in which we have been meeting that. demands in which we have been meeting that. Two demands in which we have been meeting that. Two motels demands in which we have been meeting that. Two motels in demands in which we have been meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just last meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just last week meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just last week in meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just last week in order meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just last week in order to meeting that. Two motels in Hawke's Bay just last week in order to meet Bay just last week in order to meet those Bay just last week in order to meet those demands, Bay just last week in order to meet those demands, I Bay just last week in order to meet those demands, I have Bay just last week in order to meet those demands, I have been Bay just last week in order to meet those demands, I have been out those demands, I have been out and those demands, I have been out those demands, I have been out and to the those demands, I have been out and to the areas those demands, I have been out and to the areas working those demands, I have been out and to the areas working with those demands, I have been out and to the areas working with providers to the areas working with providers in to the areas working with providers in those to the areas working with providers in those areas, to the areas working with providers in those areas, who to the areas working with providers in those areas, who will to the areas working with providers in those areas, who will be in those areas, who will be providing in those areas, who will be providing those in those areas, who will be providing those accommodations in those areas, who will be providing those accommodations to providing those accommodations to meet providing those accommodations to meet those providing those accommodations to meet those needs providing those accommodations to meet those needs in providing those accommodations to meet those needs in taur providing those accommodations to meet those needs in taur ranga providing those accommodations to meet those needs in taur ranga and meet those needs in taur ranga and in meet those needs in taur ranga and in Rotorua. meet those needs in taur ranga and in Rotorua. Are meet those needs in taur ranga and in Rotorua. Are foreign meet those needs in taur ranga and in Rotorua. Are foreign workers in Rotorua. Are foreign workers being in Rotorua. Are foreign workers being exploited in Rotorua. Are foreign workers being exploited by in Rotorua. Are foreign workers being exploited by political in Rotorua. Are foreign workers being exploited by political parties being exploited by political parties in being exploited by political parties in sub-standard being exploited by political parties in sub-standard acomoation being exploited by political parties in sub-standard acomoation eligible in sub-standard acomoation eligible in sub-standard acomoation eligible in sub-standard acomoation eligible for emergency in sub-standard acomoation eligible for emergency housing in sub-standard acomoation eligible for emergency housing -- for emergency housing -- accommodation for emergency housing -- accommodation eligible for emergency housing -- accommodation eligible for for emergency housing -- accommodation eligible for emergency accommodation eligible for emergency housing accommodation eligible for emergency housing in accommodation eligible for emergency housing in That accommodation eligible for emergency housing in That is accommodation eligible for emergency housing in That is a accommodation eligible for emergency housing in That is a question housing in That is a question clearly housing in That is a question clearly designed housing in That is a question clearly designed to housing in That is a question clearly designed to attack housing in That is a question clearly designed to attack the clearly designed to attack the opposition clearly designed to attack the opposition and clearly designed to attack the opposition and that clearly designed to attack the opposition and that is clearly designed to attack the opposition and that is not clearly designed to attack the opposition and that is not the opposition and that is not the question opposition and that is not the question of opposition and that is not the question of using opposition and that is not the question of using Government's question of using Government's supplementary question of using Government's supplementary questions. supplementary questions. Supplementary supplementary questions. Supplementary question... Supplementary question... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Order! Supplementary Order! Order! Supplementary question. Order! Order! Supplementary question. Given Order! Order! Supplementary question. Given that Order! Order! Supplementary question. Given that the Order! Order! Supplementary question. Given that the number Order! Order! Supplementary question. Given that the number of question. Given that the number of emergency question. Given that the number of emergency housing question. Given that the number of emergency housing grants question. Given that the number of emergency housing grants have emergency housing grants have emergency housing grants have emergency housing grants have doubled in emergency housing grants have doubled in the emergency housing grants have doubled in the Taranaki emergency housing grants have doubled in the Taranaki region emergency housing grants have doubled in the Taranaki region since doubled in the Taranaki region since December doubled in the Taranaki region since December 2016, doubled in the Taranaki region since December 2016, will doubled in the Taranaki region since December 2016, will the doubled in the Taranaki region since December 2016, will the minister doubled in the Taranaki region since December 2016, will the minister be December 2016, will the minister be pushing December 2016, will the minister be pushing for December 2016, will the minister be pushing for the December 2016, will the minister be pushing for the state December 2016, will the minister be pushing for the state housing pushing for the state housing development pushing for the state housing development there pushing for the state housing development there that pushing for the state housing development there that was pushing for the state housing development there that was dropped development there that was dropped by development there that was dropped by this development there that was dropped by this Government development there that was dropped by this Government to development there that was dropped by this Government to be development there that was dropped by this Government to be immediately by this Government to be immediately resumed? by this Government to be immediately resumed? I by this Government to be immediately resumed? I am by this Government to be immediately resumed? I am not by this Government to be immediately resumed? I am not aware by this Government to be immediately resumed? I am not aware of by this Government to be immediately resumed? I am not aware of that resumed? I am not aware of that particular resumed? I am not aware of that particular project resumed? I am not aware of that particular project that resumed? I am not aware of that particular project that the resumed? I am not aware of that particular project that the member particular project that the member has particular project that the member has been particular project that the member has been mentioning particular project that the member has been mentioning but particular project that the member has been mentioning but what particular project that the member has been mentioning but what I particular project that the member has been mentioning but what I can has been mentioning but what I can say has been mentioning but what I can say to has been mentioning but what I can say to the has been mentioning but what I can say to the member has been mentioning but what I can say to the member is has been mentioning but what I can say to the member is this has been mentioning but what I can say to the member is this Government say to the member is this Government has say to the member is this Government has the say to the member is this Government has the intention, say to the member is this Government has the intention, the say to the member is this Government has the intention, the first has the intention, the first Government, has the intention, the first Government, in has the intention, the first Government, in the has the intention, the first Government, in the 2016 has the intention, the first Government, in the 2016 to has the intention, the first Government, in the 2016 to have has the intention, the first Government, in the 2016 to have $350 Government, in the 2016 to have $350 million Government, in the 2016 to have $350 million more Government, in the 2016 to have $350 million more in Government, in the 2016 to have $350 million more in housing Government, in the 2016 to have $350 million more in housing support Government, in the 2016 to have $350 million more in housing support to million more in housing support to support million more in housing support to support 8,600 million more in housing support to support 8,600 families million more in housing support to support 8,600 families over million more in housing support to support 8,600 families over this support 8,600 families over this support 8,600 families over this support 8,600 families over this period of support 8,600 families over this period of time. support 8,600 families over this period of time. Supplementary period of time. Supplementary period of time. Supplementary period of time. Supplementary question. What period of time. Supplementary question. What written question. What written communications question. What written communications has question. What written communications has he question. What written communications has he received question. What written communications has he received from communications has he received from regional communications has he received from regional Work communications has he received from regional Work and communications has he received from regional Work and Income communications has he received from regional Work and Income offices regional Work and Income offices that regional Work and Income offices that emergency regional Work and Income offices that emergency housing regional Work and Income offices that emergency housing demand regional Work and Income offices that emergency housing demand is regional Work and Income offices that emergency housing demand is far that emergency housing demand is far exceeding that emergency housing demand is far exceeding the that emergency housing demand is far exceeding the number that emergency housing demand is far exceeding the number of that emergency housing demand is far exceeding the number of emergency exceeding the number of emergency housing exceeding the number of emergency housing places exceeding the number of emergency housing places that exceeding the number of emergency housing places that are exceeding the number of emergency housing places that are available? exceeding the number of emergency housing places that are available? I housing places that are available? I haven't housing places that are available? I haven't personally housing places that are available? I haven't personally received housing places that are available? I haven't personally received any haven't personally received any written haven't personally received any written communications haven't personally received any written communications or written communications or correspondence written communications or correspondence to written communications or correspondence to my written communications or correspondence to my office. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Disability My question is to the Minister for Disability Issues: My question is to the Minister for Disability Issues: What Disability Issues: What announcements Disability Issues: What announcements has Disability Issues: What announcements has she Disability Issues: What announcements has she made Disability Issues: What announcements has she made regarding announcements has she made regarding improved announcements has she made regarding improved access announcements has she made regarding improved access to announcements has she made regarding improved access to written announcements has she made regarding improved access to written materials improved access to written materials for improved access to written materials for blind, improved access to written materials for blind, visually improved access to written materials for blind, visually impaired, improved access to written materials for blind, visually impaired, and for blind, visually impaired, and otherwise for blind, visually impaired, and otherwise print- for blind, visually impaired, and otherwise print- disabled for blind, visually impaired, and otherwise print- disabled New otherwise print- disabled New Zealanders? The The Government The Government has The Government has announced The Government has announced that The Government has announced that it The Government has announced that it will The Government has announced that it will join The Government has announced that it will join the The Government has announced that it will join the Marrakech The Government has announced that it will join the Marrakech treaty, The Government has announced that it will join the Marrakech treaty, that will join the Marrakech treaty, that is will join the Marrakech treaty, that is an will join the Marrakech treaty, that is an international will join the Marrakech treaty, that is an international framework will join the Marrakech treaty, that is an international framework that is an international framework that will is an international framework that will enable is an international framework that will enable the is an international framework that will enable the reproduction is an international framework that will enable the reproduction and will enable the reproduction and will enable the reproduction and will enable the reproduction and distribution of will enable the reproduction and distribution of books will enable the reproduction and distribution of books and will enable the reproduction and distribution of books and other distribution of books and other literary distribution of books and other literary works distribution of books and other literary works in distribution of books and other literary works in accessible literary works in accessible formats. literary works in accessible formats. Supplementary literary works in accessible formats. Supplementary question. literary works in accessible formats. Supplementary question. To formats. Supplementary question. To the formats. Supplementary question. To the Minister, formats. Supplementary question. To the Minister, how formats. Supplementary question. To the Minister, how will formats. Supplementary question. To the Minister, how will the formats. Supplementary question. To the Minister, how will the Marrakech the Minister, how will the Marrakech treaty the Minister, how will the Marrakech treaty benefit the Minister, how will the Marrakech treaty benefit disabled the Minister, how will the Marrakech treaty benefit disabled New treaty benefit disabled New Zealanders? treaty benefit disabled New Zealanders? An treaty benefit disabled New Zealanders? An estimated treaty benefit disabled New Zealanders? An estimated 90% treaty benefit disabled New Zealanders? An estimated 90% of treaty benefit disabled New Zealanders? An estimated 90% of all Zealanders? An estimated 90% of all written Zealanders? An estimated 90% of all written materials Zealanders? An estimated 90% of all written materials worldwide Zealanders? An estimated 90% of all written materials worldwide are Zealanders? An estimated 90% of all written materials worldwide are not written materials worldwide are not published written materials worldwide are not published in written materials worldwide are not published in accessible written materials worldwide are not published in accessible formats written materials worldwide are not published in accessible formats such published in accessible formats such as published in accessible formats such as braille, published in accessible formats such as braille, audio published in accessible formats such as braille, audio or published in accessible formats such as braille, audio or larget published in accessible formats such as braille, audio or larget print. as braille, audio or larget print. For as braille, audio or larget print. For -- as braille, audio or larget print. For -- large as braille, audio or larget print. For -- large print. as braille, audio or larget print. For -- large print. For as braille, audio or larget print. For -- large print. For about For -- large print. For about 168,000 For -- large print. For about 168,000 New For -- large print. For about 168,000 New Zealanders For -- large print. For about 168,000 New Zealanders with For -- large print. For about 168,000 New Zealanders with a For -- large print. For about 168,000 New Zealanders with a print 168,000 New Zealanders with a print disability 168,000 New Zealanders with a print disability in 168,000 New Zealanders with a print disability in is 168,000 New Zealanders with a print disability in is a 168,000 New Zealanders with a print disability in is a barrier 168,000 New Zealanders with a print disability in is a barrier to disability in is a barrier to participation disability in is a barrier to participation in disability in is a barrier to participation in public disability in is a barrier to participation in public life disability in is a barrier to participation in public life and participation in public life and restricts participation in public life and restricts employment, participation in public life and restricts employment, education participation in public life and restricts employment, education and restricts employment, education and restricts employment, education and restricts employment, education and recreation. This restricts employment, education and recreation. This treaty restricts employment, education and recreation. This treaty will restricts employment, education and recreation. This treaty will make restricts employment, education and recreation. This treaty will make a recreation. This treaty will make a participation recreation. This treaty will make a meaningful change to recreation. This treaty will make a meaningful change to the recreation. This treaty will make a meaningful change to the lives recreation. This treaty will make a meaningful change to the lives of meaningful change to the lives of thousands meaningful change to the lives of thousands of meaningful change to the lives of thousands of New meaningful change to the lives of thousands of New Zealanders meaningful change to the lives of thousands of New Zealanders by thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring that thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring that they thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring that they have thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring that they have access thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring that they have access to thousands of New Zealanders by ensuring that they have access to a ensuring that they have access to a greater ensuring that they have access to a greater variety ensuring that they have access to a greater variety of ensuring that they have access to a greater variety of books ensuring that they have access to a greater variety of books and ensuring that they have access to a greater variety of books and other greater variety of books and other publications greater variety of books and other publications in greater variety of books and other publications in accessible greater variety of books and other publications in accessible formats. publications in accessible formats. It publications in accessible formats. It also publications in accessible formats. It also supports publications in accessible formats. It also supports the publications in accessible formats. It also supports the Government's It also supports the Government's vision It also supports the Government's vision for It also supports the Government's vision for creating It also supports the Government's vision for creating a It also supports the Government's vision for creating a non--disabling vision for creating a non--disabling society vision for creating a non--disabling society as vision for creating a non--disabling society as outlined vision for creating a non--disabling society as outlined in vision for creating a non--disabling society as outlined in the vision for creating a non--disabling society as outlined in the New society as outlined in the New society as outlined in the New society as outlined in the New Zealand disability society as outlined in the New Zealand disability Strategy. society as outlined in the New Zealand disability Strategy. I society as outlined in the New Zealand disability Strategy. I wish Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to thank Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to thank my Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to thank my colleagues Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to thank my colleagues the Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to thank my colleagues the Hon Zealand disability Strategy. I wish to thank my colleagues the Hon goal to thank my colleagues the Hon goal to thank my colleagues the Hon goal to thank my colleagues the Hon goal Goldsmith and to thank my colleagues the Hon goal Goldsmith and the to thank my colleagues the Hon goal Goldsmith and the Hon to thank my colleagues the Hon goal Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui to thank my colleagues the Hon goal Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean as Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean as well as Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean as well as the Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean as well as the Blind Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean as well as the Blind Foundation, Goldsmith and the Hon Jacqui Dean as well as the Blind Foundation, Blind well as the Blind Foundation, Blind Citizens well as the Blind Foundation, Blind Citizens for well as the Blind Foundation, Blind Citizens for New well as the Blind Foundation, Blind Citizens for New Zealand well as the Blind Foundation, Blind Citizens for New Zealand and well as the Blind Foundation, Blind Citizens for New Zealand and other Citizens for New Zealand and other Citizens for New Zealand and other Citizens for New Zealand and other advocates for Citizens for New Zealand and other advocates for their Citizens for New Zealand and other advocates for their hard Citizens for New Zealand and other advocates for their hard work Citizens for New Zealand and other advocates for their hard work in advocates for their hard work in advocates for their hard work in advocates for their hard work in making this advocates for their hard work in making this happen. advocates for their hard work in making this happen. Question advocates for their hard work in making this happen. Question No. advocates for their hard work in making this happen. Question No. 12. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Foreign My question is to the Minister of Foreign Affairs: My question is to the Minister of Foreign Affairs: Does My question is to the Minister of Foreign Affairs: Does he My question is to the Minister of Foreign Affairs: Does he support My question is to the Minister of Foreign Affairs: Does he support the Foreign Affairs: Does he support the negotiations Foreign Affairs: Does he support the negotiations for Foreign Affairs: Does he support the negotiations for a Foreign Affairs: Does he support the negotiations for a nuclear Foreign Affairs: Does he support the negotiations for a nuclear weapons negotiations for a nuclear weapons convention negotiations for a nuclear weapons convention currently negotiations for a nuclear weapons convention currently under negotiations for a nuclear weapons convention currently under way negotiations for a nuclear weapons convention currently under way in convention currently under way in New convention currently under way in New York, convention currently under way in New York, which convention currently under way in New York, which would convention currently under way in New York, which would result convention currently under way in New York, which would result in New York, which would result in States New York, which would result in States parties New York, which would result in States parties agreeing New York, which would result in States parties agreeing to New York, which would result in States parties agreeing to prohibit States parties agreeing to prohibit the States parties agreeing to prohibit the manufacture, States parties agreeing to prohibit the manufacture, possession, States parties agreeing to prohibit the manufacture, possession, and States parties agreeing to prohibit the manufacture, possession, and use the manufacture, possession, and use of the manufacture, possession, and use of nuclear the manufacture, possession, and use of nuclear weapons; the manufacture, possession, and use of nuclear weapons; if the manufacture, possession, and use of nuclear weapons; if not, the manufacture, possession, and use of nuclear weapons; if not, why the manufacture, possession, and use of nuclear weapons; if not, why not? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the Minister On behalf of the Minister of On behalf of the Minister of Foreign On behalf of the Minister of Foreign Affairs, On behalf of the Minister of Foreign Affairs, yes. Affairs, yes. Supplementary Affairs, yes. Affairs, yes. Supplementary question. Will Affairs, yes. Supplementary question. Will the Affairs, yes. Supplementary question. Will the minister question. Will the minister encourage question. Will the minister encourage his question. Will the minister encourage his counterparts question. Will the minister encourage his counterparts of question. Will the minister encourage his counterparts of all encourage his counterparts of all the encourage his counterparts of all the nuclear encourage his counterparts of all the nuclear weapon encourage his counterparts of all the nuclear weapon states encourage his counterparts of all the nuclear weapon states to the nuclear weapon states to participate the nuclear weapon states to participate in the nuclear weapon states to participate in the the nuclear weapon states to participate in the participations? participate in the participations? On participate in the participations? On behalf participate in the participations? On behalf of participate in the participations? On behalf of the participate in the participations? On behalf of the minister, participate in the participations? On behalf of the minister, yes, participate in the participations? On behalf of the minister, yes, we On behalf of the minister, yes, we think On behalf of the minister, yes, we On On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is a On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is a good On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is a good idea On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is a good idea to On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is a good idea to take On behalf of the minister, yes, we think it is a good idea to take part think it is a good idea to take part in think it is a good idea to take part in negotiations think it is a good idea to take part in negotiations for think it is a good idea to take part in negotiations for this think it is a good idea to take part in negotiations for this convention. in negotiations for this convention. Of in negotiations for this convention. Of course in negotiations for this convention. Of course it in negotiations for this convention. Of course it is in negotiations for this convention. Of course it is at in negotiations for this convention. Of course it is at a in negotiations for this convention. Of course it is at a very in negotiations for this convention. Of course it is at a very early Of course it is at a very early stage. Of course it is at a very early stage. It's Of course it is at a very early stage. It's really Of course it is at a very early stage. It's really a Of course it is at a very early stage. It's really a draft Of course it is at a very early stage. It's really a draft treaty stage. It's really a draft treaty phase stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and it stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and it is stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and it is still stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and it is still subject stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and it is still subject to, stage. It's really a draft treaty phase and it is still subject to, I phase and it is still subject to, I think, phase and it is still subject to, I think, quite phase and it is still subject to, I think, quite a phase and it is still subject to, I think, quite a long phase and it is still subject to, I think, quite a long period phase and it is still subject to, I think, quite a long period of think, quite a long period of negotiations. think, quite a long period of negotiations. . think, quite a long period of negotiations. . Given think, quite a long period of negotiations. . Given that, think, quite a long period of negotiations. . Given that, in think, quite a long period of negotiations. . Given that, in fact, negotiations. . Given that, in fact, the negotiations. . Given that, in fact, the negotiations negotiations. . Given that, in fact, the negotiations are negotiations. . Given that, in fact, the negotiations are not negotiations. . Given that, in fact, the negotiations are not that negotiations. . Given that, in fact, the negotiations are not that far negotiations. . Given that, in fact, in negotiations. . Given that, in fact, away from completion negotiations. . Given that, in fact, away from completion and negotiations. . Given that, in fact, away from completion and that negotiations. . Given that, in fact, away from completion and that a negotiations. . Given that, in fact, away from completion and that a text away from completion and that a text could away from completion and that a text could be away from completion and that a text could be opened away from completion and that a text could be opened for away from completion and that a text could be opened for signature could be opened for signature possibly could be opened for signature possibly by could be opened for signature possibly by 7 could be opened for signature possibly by 7 July, could be opened for signature possibly by 7 July, does could be opened for signature possibly by 7 July, does the possibly by 7 July, does the minister possibly by 7 July, does the minister share possibly by 7 July, does the minister share the possibly by 7 July, does the minister share the pride possibly by 7 July, does the minister share the pride felt possibly by 7 July, does the minister share the pride felt by possibly by 7 July, does the minister share the pride felt by New minister share the pride felt by New Zealand minister share the pride felt by New Zealand citizens minister share the pride felt by New Zealand citizens that minister share the pride felt by New Zealand citizens that our Zealand citizens that our disarmament Zealand citizens that our disarmament ambassador Zealand citizens that our disarmament ambassador is Zealand citizens that our disarmament ambassador is one Zealand citizens that our disarmament ambassador is one of Zealand citizens that our disarmament ambassador is one of the disarmament ambassador is one of the disarmament ambassador is one of the disarmament ambassador is one of the vice chairs disarmament ambassador is one of the vice chairs of disarmament ambassador is one of the vice chairs of the disarmament ambassador is one of the vice chairs of the negotiations? disarmament ambassador is one of the vice chairs of the negotiations? On vice chairs of the negotiations? On behalf vice chairs of the negotiations? On behalf of vice chairs of the negotiations? On behalf of the vice chairs of the negotiations? On behalf of the Minister vice chairs of the negotiations? On behalf of the Minister for vice chairs of the negotiations? On behalf of the Minister for Foreign behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, we behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, we share behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, we share the behalf of the Minister for Foreign Affairs, we share the pride. Affairs, we share the pride. Supplementary Affairs, we share the pride. Supplementary question. Affairs, we share the pride. Supplementary question. In Affairs, we share the pride. Supplementary question. In the Supplementary question. In the Supplementary question. In the Supplementary question. In the fullness of Supplementary question. In the fullness of sharing Supplementary question. In the fullness of sharing the Supplementary question. In the fullness of sharing the pride, Supplementary question. In the fullness of sharing the pride, why fullness of sharing the pride, why did fullness of sharing the pride, why did the fullness of sharing the pride, why did the minister fullness of sharing the pride, why did the minister oppose fullness of sharing the pride, why did the minister oppose the fullness of sharing the pride, why did the minister oppose the Green did the minister oppose the Green Party's did the minister oppose the Green Party's amendment did the minister oppose the Green Party's amendment to did the minister oppose the Green Party's amendment to the did the minister oppose the Green Party's amendment to the notice did the minister oppose the Green Party's amendment to the notice of Party's amendment to the notice of motion Party's amendment to the notice of motion of Party's amendment to the notice of motion of 8 Party's amendment to the notice of motion of 8 June Party's amendment to the notice of motion of 8 June calling Party's amendment to the notice of motion of 8 June calling upon Party's amendment to the notice of motion of 8 June calling upon all motion of 8 June calling upon all states motion of 8 June calling upon all states to motion of 8 June calling upon all states to support motion of 8 June calling upon all states to support the motion of 8 June calling upon all states to support the ongoing states to support the ongoing negotiations states to support the ongoing negotiations for states to support the ongoing negotiations for the states to support the ongoing negotiations for the convention states to support the ongoing negotiations for the convention in negotiations for the convention in which negotiations for the convention in which New negotiations for the convention in which New Zealand negotiations for the convention in which New Zealand is negotiations for the convention in which New Zealand is actively which New Zealand is actively engaged? which New Zealand is actively engaged? On which New Zealand is actively engaged? On behalf which New Zealand is actively engaged? On behalf of which New Zealand is actively engaged? On behalf of the which New Zealand is actively engaged? On behalf of the Minister engaged? On behalf of the Minister of engaged? On behalf of the Minister of Foreign engaged? On behalf of the Minister of Foreign Affairs engaged? On behalf of the Minister of Foreign Affairs because engaged? On behalf of the Minister of Foreign Affairs because the engaged? On behalf of the Minister of engaged? On behalf of the Minister motion engaged? On behalf of the Minister motion was to mark engaged? On behalf of the Minister motion was to mark 30 engaged? On behalf of the Minister motion was to mark 30 years engaged? On behalf of the Minister motion was to mark 30 years of engaged? On behalf of the Minister motion was to mark 30 years of our motion was to mark 30 years of our nuclear-free motion was to mark 30 years of our nuclear-free legislation, motion was to mark 30 years of our nuclear-free legislation, which motion was to mark 30 years of our nuclear-free legislation, which has nuclear-free legislation, which has become nuclear-free legislation, which has become a nuclear-free legislation, which has become a defining nuclear-free legislation, which has become a defining aspect nuclear-free legislation, which has become a defining aspect of nuclear-free legislation, which has become a defining aspect of this become a defining aspect of this country's become a defining aspect of this country's international become a defining aspect of this country's international reputation country's international reputation on country's international reputation on which country's international reputation on which we country's international reputation on which we can country's international reputation on which we can all country's international reputation on which we can all share country's international reputation on which we can all share the country's international reputation on which we can all share the pride, on which we can all share the pride, not on which we can all share the pride, not to on which we can all share the pride, not to discuss on which we can all share the pride, not to discuss ongoingations not to discuss ongoingations negotiation not to discuss ongoingations negotiation ---ations not to discuss ongoingations negotiation ---ations to not to discuss ongoingations negotiation ---ations to discuss negotiation ---ations to discuss United negotiation ---ations to discuss United Nations negotiation ---ations to discuss United Nations ongoing negotiation ---ations to discuss United Nations ongoing negotiations, United Nations ongoing negotiations, not United Nations ongoing negotiations, not to United Nations ongoing negotiations, not to discuss United Nations ongoing negotiations, not to discuss a United Nations ongoing negotiations, not to discuss a nuclear-free United Nations ongoing negotiations, not to discuss a nuclear-free world. not to discuss a nuclear-free world. Would not to discuss a nuclear-free world. Would some not to discuss a nuclear-free world. Would some honourable not to discuss a nuclear-free world. Would some honourable member not to discuss a nuclear-free world. Would some honourable member care not to discuss a nuclear-free world. Would some honourable member care to Would some honourable member care to move Would some honourable member care to move that Would some honourable member care to move that the Would some honourable member care to move that the House Would some honourable member care to move that the House take Would some honourable member care to move that the House take note Would some honourable member care to move that the House take note of move that the House take note of move