This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Red This programme is live captioned by Red Bee This programme is live captioned by Red Bee Media Red Bee Media for Red Bee Media for the Red Bee Media for the Office Red Bee Media for the Office of Red Bee Media for the Office of the Red Bee Media for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Mr Mr Speaker! Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, we Almighty God, we give Almighty God, we give thanks Almighty God, we give thanks for Almighty God, we give thanks for the Almighty God, we give thanks for the blessings we give thanks for the blessings which we give thanks for the blessings which have we give thanks for the blessings which have been we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on us. which have been bestowed on us. Laying which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal interests, Laying aside all personal interests, we Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Queen we acknowledge the Queen and we acknowledge the Queen and pray we acknowledge the Queen and pray for we acknowledge the Queen and pray for guidance and pray for guidance in and pray for guidance in our and pray for guidance in our deliberations, in our deliberations, that in our deliberations, that we in our deliberations, that we may in our deliberations, that we may conduct that we may conduct the that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House the affairs of this House with the affairs of this House with wisdom, the affairs of this House with wisdom, justice, the affairs of this House with wisdom, justice, mercy, with wisdom, justice, mercy, and with wisdom, justice, mercy, and humility and humility for and humility for the and humility for the welfare and humility for the welfare and and humility for the welfare and peace for the welfare and peace of for the welfare and peace of New for the welfare and peace of New Zealand. for the welfare and peace of New Zealand. Amen. Mbs, Mbs, I Mbs, I am Mbs, I am sure Mbs, I am sure you Mbs, I am sure you would Mbs, I am sure you would wish Mbs, I am sure you would wish the Mbs, I am sure you would wish the welcome Mbs, I am sure you would wish the welcome Steingrimum Mbs, I am sure you would wish the welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, Speaker welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, Speaker of welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, Speaker of Althingi, welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, Speaker of Althingi, the welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, Speaker of Althingi, the republic welcome Steingrimum Sigfusson, Speaker of Althingi, the republic of Speaker of Althingi, the republic of iceland, Speaker of Althingi, the republic of iceland, and Speaker of Althingi, the republic of iceland, and his Speaker of Althingi, the republic of iceland, and his delegation Speaker of Althingi, the republic of iceland, and his delegation who Speaker of Althingi, the republic of iceland, and his delegation who are iceland, and his delegation who are present iceland, and his delegation who are present if iceland, and his delegation who are present if the iceland, and his delegation who are present if the Gallery iceland, and his delegation who are present if the Gallery and iceland, and his delegation who are present if the Gallery and the present if the Gallery and the Speaker present if the Gallery and the Speaker is present if the Gallery and the Speaker is to present if the Gallery and the Speaker is to my present if the Gallery and the Speaker is to my left. present if the Gallery and the Speaker is to my left. <APPLAUSE> Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, I Mr Speaker, I move Mr Speaker, I move that Mr Speaker, I move that this Mr Speaker, I move that this House Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... No, Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... No, I Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... No, I think Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... No, I think we Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... No, I think we have Mr Speaker, I move that this House express... No, I think we have boot express... No, I think we have boot a express... No, I think we have boot a presentation express... No, I think we have boot a presentation first. express... No, I think we have boot a presentation first. I express... No, I think we have boot a presentation first. I present express... No, I think we have boot a presentation first. I present the a presentation first. I present the PM a presentation first. I present the PM as a presentation first. I present the PM as statement. a presentation first. I present the PM as statement. That a presentation first. I present the PM as statement. That paper a presentation first. I present the PM as statement. That paper is PM as statement. That paper is published PM as statement. That paper is published under PM as statement. That paper is published under the PM as statement. That paper is published under the authority PM as statement. That paper is published under the authority of PM as statement. That paper is published under the authority of the published under the authority of the House. published under the authority of the House. Copies published under the authority of the House. Copies are published under the authority of the House. Copies are available published under the authority of the House. Copies are available on published under the authority of the House. Copies are available on the House. Copies are available on the table. House. Copies are available on the table. I House. Copies are available on the table. I call House. Copies are available on the table. I call on House. Copies are available on the table. I call on government House. Copies are available on the table. I call on government order House. Copies are available on the table. I call on government order of table. I call on government order of table. table. I call on government order of the day. The table. I call on government order of the day. The debate table. I call on government order of the day. The debate on table. I call on government order of the day. The debate on the table. I call on government order of the day. The debate on the PM table. I call on government order of the day. The debate on the PM as the day. The debate on the PM as statement. the day. The debate on the PM as statement. The the day. The debate on the PM as statement. The Rt the day. The debate on the PM as statement. The Rt Hon the day. The debate on the PM as statement. The Rt Hon PM. the day. The debate on the PM as statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr Speaker, statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr Speaker, I statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr Speaker, I move statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr Speaker, I move again statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr Speaker, I move again with statement. The Rt Hon PM. Mr Speaker, I move again with much Speaker, I move again with much enthusiasm Speaker, I move again with much enthusiasm that Speaker, I move again with much enthusiasm that this Speaker, I move again with much enthusiasm that this House Speaker, I move again with much enthusiasm that this House ex Speaker, I move again with much enthusiasm that this House ex press enthusiasm that this House ex press its enthusiasm that this House ex press its confidence enthusiasm that this House ex press its confidence in enthusiasm that this House ex press its confidence in the enthusiasm that this House ex press its confidence in the Coalition its confidence in the Coalition government its confidence in the Coalition government and its confidence in the Coalition government and commend its confidence in the Coalition government and commend its its confidence in the Coalition government and commend its programme government and commend its programme for government and commend its programme for 2020, government and commend its programme for 2020, as government and commend its programme for 2020, as set government and commend its programme for 2020, as set out government and commend its programme for 2020, as set out in government and commend its programme for 2020, as set out in the government and commend its programme for 2020, as set out in the PM government and commend its programme for 2020, as set out in the PM as for 2020, as set out in the PM as statement. for 2020, as set out in the PM as statement. Mr for 2020, as set out in the PM as statement. Mr Speaker, for 2020, as set out in the PM as statement. Mr Speaker, I for 2020, as set out in the PM as statement. Mr Speaker, I want for 2020, as set out in the PM as statement. Mr Speaker, I want to statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start where statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start where I statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start where I started statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start where I started in statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start where I started in January, statement. Mr Speaker, I want to start where I started in January, as start where I started in January, as it start where I started in January, as it were, start where I started in January, as it were, because start where I started in January, as it were, because today start where I started in January, as it were, because today is start where I started in January, as it were, because today is not start where I started in January, as it were, because today is not the it were, because today is not the first it were, because today is not the first time it were, because today is not the first time that it were, because today is not the first time that I it were, because today is not the first time that I have it were, because today is not the first time that I have spoken it were, because today is not the first time that I have spoken of it were, because today is not the first time that I have spoken of the first time that I have spoken of the as first time that I have spoken of the as spare first time that I have spoken of the as spare ration first time that I have spoken of the as spare ration that first time that I have spoken of the as spare ration that this first time that I have spoken of the as spare ration that this government as spare ration that this government has as spare ration that this government has for as spare ration that this government has for news as spare ration that this government has for news and as spare ration that this government has for news and this as spare ration that this government has for news and this government as spare ration that this government has for news and this government as has for news and this government as programme has for news and this government as programme for has for news and this government as programme for the has for news and this government as programme for the next has for news and this government as programme for the next year. has for news and this government as programme for the next year. The programme for the next year. The first programme for the next year. The first time programme for the next year. The first time that programme for the next year. The first time that I programme for the next year. The first time that I spoke programme for the next year. The first time that I spoke of programme for the next year. The first time that I spoke of the first time that I spoke of the aspirations first time that I spoke of the aspirations of first time that I spoke of the aspirations of this first time that I spoke of the aspirations of this government first time that I spoke of the aspirations of this government in aspirations of this government in 2020 aspirations of this government in 2020 was aspirations of this government in 2020 was on aspirations of this government in 2020 was on 31 aspirations of this government in 2020 was on 31 January. aspirations of this government in 2020 was on 31 January. It aspirations of this government in 2020 was on 31 January. It was aspirations of this government in 2020 was on 31 January. It was under 2020 was on 31 January. It was under somewhat 2020 was on 31 January. It was under somewhat more 2020 was on 31 January. It was under somewhat more private 2020 was on 31 January. It was under somewhat more private circumstances. somewhat more private circumstances. It somewhat more private circumstances. It was somewhat more private circumstances. It was when somewhat more private circumstances. It was when I somewhat more private circumstances. It was when I last somewhat more private circumstances. It was when I last visited somewhat more private circumstances. It was when I last visited Mike It was when I last visited Mike Moore It was when I last visited Mike Moore and It was when I last visited Mike Moore and he It was when I last visited Mike Moore and he asked, It was when I last visited Mike Moore and he asked, in It was when I last visited Mike Moore and he asked, in a It was when I last visited Mike Moore and he asked, in a way It was when I last visited Mike Moore and he asked, in a way that Moore and he asked, in a way that only Moore and he asked, in a way that only Mike Moore and he asked, in a way that only Mike Moore Moore and he asked, in a way that only Mike Moore can, Moore and he asked, in a way that only Mike Moore can, after Moore and he asked, in a way that only Mike Moore can, after with Moore and he asked, in a way that only Mike Moore can, after with had only Mike Moore can, after with had exchanged only Mike Moore can, after with had exchanged very only Mike Moore can, after with had exchanged very brief only Mike Moore can, after with had exchanged very brief pleasantries. exchanged very brief pleasantries. He exchanged very brief pleasantries. He said, exchanged very brief pleasantries. He said, "What exchanged very brief pleasantries. He said, "What are exchanged very brief pleasantries. He said, "What are you exchanged very brief pleasantries. He said, "What are you doing exchanged very brief pleasantries. He said, "What are you doing next?" He said, "What are you doing next?" The He said, "What are you doing next?" The answer He said, "What are you doing next?" The answer to He said, "What are you doing next?" The answer to that He said, "What are you doing next?" The answer to that is He said, "What are you doing next?" The answer to that is simple. He said, "What are you doing next?" The answer to that is simple. More. The answer to that is simple. More. I The answer to that is simple. More. I want The answer to that is simple. More. I want to The answer to that is simple. More. I want to share The answer to that is simple. More. I want to share with The answer to that is simple. More. I want to share with this The answer to that is simple. More. I want to share with this House The answer to that is simple. More. I want to share with this House what I want to share with this House what I I want to share with this House what I shared I want to share with this House what I shared with I want to share with this House what I shared with Mike I want to share with this House what I shared with Mike Moore I want to share with this House what I shared with Mike Moore that I want to share with this House what I shared with Mike Moore that day. I shared with Mike Moore that day. That I shared with Mike Moore that day. That our I shared with Mike Moore that day. That our agenda I shared with Mike Moore that day. That our agenda for I shared with Mike Moore that day. That our agenda for 2020 I shared with Mike Moore that day. That our agenda for 2020 is I shared with Mike Moore that day. That our agenda for 2020 is based, That our agenda for 2020 is based, both That our agenda for 2020 is based, both on That our agenda for 2020 is based, both on where That our agenda for 2020 is based, both on where with That our agenda for 2020 is based, both on where with started. That our agenda for 2020 is based, both on where with started. The both on where with started. The circumstances both on where with started. The circumstances and both on where with started. The circumstances and context both on where with started. The circumstances and context under circumstances and context under which circumstances and context under which this circumstances and context under which this government circumstances and context under which this government took circumstances and context under which this government took office. which this government took office. It which this government took office. It is which this government took office. It is based which this government took office. It is based on which this government took office. It is based on where which this government took office. It is based on where we which this government took office. It is based on where we are which this government took office. It is based on where we are now. which this government took office. It is based on where we are now. The It is based on where we are now. The environment It is based on where we are now. The environment that It is based on where we are now. The environment that we It is based on where we are now. The environment that we are It is based on where we are now. The environment that we are operating It is based on where we are now. The environment that we are operating in environment that we are operating in and environment that we are operating in and the environment that we are operating in and the experience environment that we are operating in and the experience of environment that we are operating in and the experience of New environment that we are operating in and the experience of New Zealanders and the experience of New Zealanders and and the experience of New Zealanders and it and the experience of New Zealanders and it is and the experience of New Zealanders and it is focused and the experience of New Zealanders and it is focused on and the experience of New Zealanders and it is focused on where and the experience of New Zealanders and it is focused on where with and the experience of New Zealanders and it is focused on where with food and it is focused on where with food to and it is focused on where with food to go. and it is focused on where with food to go. So, and it is focused on where with food to go. So, Mr and it is focused on where with food to go. So, Mr Speaker, and it is focused on where with food to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's and it is focused on where with food to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start at to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start at the to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start at the very to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start at the very start. to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start at the very start. In to go. So, Mr Speaker, let's start at the very start. In the at the very start. In the beginning... beginning... <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> Before <LAUGHTER> Before there <LAUGHTER> Before there was <LAUGHTER> Before there was light... Before there was light... <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> There <LAUGHTER> There were <LAUGHTER> There were nine <LAUGHTER> There were nine years <LAUGHTER> There were nine years of <LAUGHTER> There were nine years of darkness... There were nine years of darkness... <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> It <LAUGHTER> It wasn't <LAUGHTER> It wasn't like <LAUGHTER> It wasn't like a <LAUGHTER> It wasn't like a black <LAUGHTER> It wasn't like a black darkness. It wasn't like a black darkness. More It wasn't like a black darkness. More a It wasn't like a black darkness. More a dark It wasn't like a black darkness. More a dark shade It wasn't like a black darkness. More a dark shade of It wasn't like a black darkness. More a dark shade of blue It wasn't like a black darkness. More a dark shade of blue kind It wasn't like a black darkness. More a dark shade of blue kind of More a dark shade of blue kind of darkness. darkness. <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> The <LAUGHTER> The worst <LAUGHTER> The worst kind. <LAUGHTER> The worst kind. Now, <LAUGHTER> The worst kind. Now, those <LAUGHTER> The worst kind. Now, those words <LAUGHTER> The worst kind. Now, those words may The worst kind. Now, those words may be The worst kind. Now, those words may be familiar, The worst kind. Now, those words may be familiar, at The worst kind. Now, those words may be familiar, at least The worst kind. Now, those words may be familiar, at least to The worst kind. Now, those words may be familiar, at least to members The worst kind. Now, those words may be familiar, at least to members on be familiar, at least to members on this be familiar, at least to members on this side be familiar, at least to members on this side of be familiar, at least to members on this side of the be familiar, at least to members on this side of the House. be familiar, at least to members on this side of the House. They be familiar, at least to members on this side of the House. They were this side of the House. They were written this side of the House. They were written by this side of the House. They were written by a this side of the House. They were written by a very this side of the House. They were written by a very grat this side of the House. They were written by a very grat writer, this side of the House. They were written by a very grat writer, Kevin written by a very grat writer, Kevin Davies. Davies. <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> After <LAUGHTER> After mine <LAUGHTER> After mine long <LAUGHTER> After mine long years, <LAUGHTER> After mine long years, it <LAUGHTER> After mine long years, it may <LAUGHTER> After mine long years, it may not After mine long years, it may not have After mine long years, it may not have been After mine long years, it may not have been a After mine long years, it may not have been a blue After mine long years, it may not have been a blue smoke, After mine long years, it may not have been a blue smoke, Mr After mine long years, it may not have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there was have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there was plan have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there was plan write have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there was plan write of have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there was plan write of denial have been a blue smoke, Mr Speaker, but there was plan write of denial T but there was plan write of denial T there but there was plan write of denial T there was but there was plan write of denial T there was denial but there was plan write of denial T there was denial that but there was plan write of denial T there was denial that we but there was plan write of denial T there was denial that we had but there was plan write of denial T there was denial that we had a there was denial that we had a housing there was denial that we had a housing crisis. there was denial that we had a housing crisis. There there was denial that we had a housing crisis. There was there was denial that we had a housing crisis. There was a there was denial that we had a housing crisis. There was a denial housing crisis. There was a denial that housing crisis. There was a denial that kids housing crisis. There was a denial that kids were housing crisis. There was a denial that kids were doing housing crisis. There was a denial that kids were doing their housing crisis. There was a denial that kids were doing their homework that kids were doing their homework in that kids were doing their homework in cars. that kids were doing their homework in cars. There that kids were doing their homework in cars. There was that kids were doing their homework in cars. There was denial that kids were doing their homework in cars. There was denial that in cars. There was denial that children in cars. There was denial that children in in cars. There was denial that children in this in cars. There was denial that children in this country, in cars. There was denial that children in this country, an children in this country, an affluent children in this country, an affluent country, children in this country, an affluent country, did children in this country, an affluent country, did not children in this country, an affluent country, did not have children in this country, an affluent country, did not have all affluent country, did not have all that affluent country, did not have all that it affluent country, did not have all that it needed affluent country, did not have all that it needed to affluent country, did not have all that it needed to thrive. affluent country, did not have all that it needed to thrive. There affluent country, did not have all that it needed to thrive. There was that it needed to thrive. There was denial that it needed to thrive. There was denial that that it needed to thrive. There was denial that we that it needed to thrive. There was denial that we had that it needed to thrive. There was denial that we had an that it needed to thrive. There was denial that we had an Prince that it needed to thrive. There was denial that we had an Prince Harry denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit and denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit and we denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit and we were denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit and we were all denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit and we were all suffering denial that we had an Prince Harry deficit and we were all suffering as deficit and we were all suffering as a deficit and we were all suffering as a nation deficit and we were all suffering as a nation as deficit and we were all suffering as a nation as a deficit and we were all suffering as a nation as a result. deficit and we were all suffering as a nation as a result. There deficit and we were all suffering as a nation as a result. There was a nation as a result. There was denial a nation as a result. There was denial that a nation as a result. There was denial that our a nation as a result. There was denial that our hospitals a nation as a result. There was denial that our hospitals were denial that our hospitals were broken denial that our hospitals were broken and denial that our hospitals were broken and I denial that our hospitals were broken and I done denial that our hospitals were broken and I done say denial that our hospitals were broken and I done say that denial that our hospitals were broken and I done say that lightly. broken and I done say that lightly. Simple broken and I done say that lightly. Simple things, broken and I done say that lightly. Simple things, like broken and I done say that lightly. Simple things, like pipes broken and I done say that lightly. Simple things, like pipes being Simple things, like pipes being replaced.vators Simple things, like pipes being replaced.vators could Simple things, like pipes being replaced.vators could still Simple things, like pipes being replaced.vators could still work Simple things, like pipes being replaced.vators could still work or, replaced.vators could still work or, worse replaced.vators could still work or, worse still, replaced.vators could still work or, worse still, suage replaced.vators could still work or, worse still, suage down replaced.vators could still work or, worse still, suage down walls replaced.vators could still work or, worse still, suage down walls was worse still, suage down walls was the worse still, suage down walls was the ultimate worse still, suage down walls was the ultimate man worse still, suage down walls was the ultimate man manifestation. the ultimate man manifestation. There the ultimate man manifestation. There was the ultimate man manifestation. There was denial. the ultimate man manifestation. There was denial. That the ultimate man manifestation. There was denial. That denial the ultimate man manifestation. There was denial. That denial seemed There was denial. That denial seemed to There was denial. That denial seemed to exist There was denial. That denial seemed to exist until There was denial. That denial seemed to exist until after There was denial. That denial seemed to exist until after those There was denial. That denial seemed to exist until after those nine to exist until after those nine years to exist until after those nine years we to exist until after those nine years we entered to exist until after those nine years we entered into to exist until after those nine years we entered into an to exist until after those nine years we entered into an election years we entered into an election phase years we entered into an election phase and years we entered into an election phase and when years we entered into an election phase and when with years we entered into an election phase and when with entered years we entered into an election phase and when with entered into phase and when with entered into that phase and when with entered into that election phase and when with entered into that election phase phase and when with entered into that election phase National phase and when with entered into that election phase National emerged that election phase National emerged from that election phase National emerged from the that election phase National emerged from the smoke that election phase National emerged from the smoke of that election phase National emerged from the smoke of defile that election phase National emerged from the smoke of defile with that election phase National emerged from the smoke of defile with a from the smoke of defile with a weighty from the smoke of defile with a weighty tone from the smoke of defile with a weighty tone known from the smoke of defile with a weighty tone known as from the smoke of defile with a weighty tone known as as from the smoke of defile with a weighty tone known as as statement weighty tone known as as statement and weighty tone known as as statement and in weighty tone known as as statement and in that weighty tone known as as statement and in that press weighty tone known as as statement and in that press statement weighty tone known as as statement and in that press statement they and in that press statement they promised and in that press statement they promised much. and in that press statement they promised much. They and in that press statement they promised much. They promised and in that press statement they promised much. They promised roads, promised much. They promised roads, they promised much. They promised roads, they promised promised much. They promised roads, they promised infrastructure. promised much. They promised roads, they promised infrastructure. They they promised infrastructure. They even they promised infrastructure. They even made they promised infrastructure. They even made promises they promised infrastructure. They even made promises about they promised infrastructure. They even made promises about child even made promises about child poverty. even made promises about child poverty. But, even made promises about child poverty. But, Mr even made promises about child poverty. But, Mr Speaker, even made promises about child poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as even made promises about child poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a even made promises about child poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man said poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man said on poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man said on the poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man said on the Pied poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man said on the Pied Pie poverty. But, Mr Speaker, as a very wise man said on the Pied Pie at wise man said on the Pied Pie at Waitangi, wise man said on the Pied Pie at Waitangi, no wise man said on the Pied Pie at Waitangi, no aspire wise man said on the Pied Pie at Waitangi, no aspire our wise man said on the Pied Pie at Waitangi, no aspire our deads, wise man said on the Pied Pie at Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire who Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire who we Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire who we do. Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire who we do. Not Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire who we do. Not at Waitangi, no aspire our deads, no aspire who we do. Not at the aspire who we do. Not at the eleventh-hour aspire who we do. Not at the eleventh-hour before aspire who we do. Not at the eleventh-hour before we aspire who we do. Not at the eleventh-hour before we go aspire who we do. Not at the eleventh-hour before we go to aspire who we do. Not at the eleventh-hour before we go to the eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That is eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That is why eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That is why I eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That is why I wish eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That is why I wish to eleventh-hour before we go to the polls. That is why I wish to reflect polls. That is why I wish to reflect on polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where we polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where we are polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where we are now, polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where we are now, as polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where we are now, as well polls. That is why I wish to reflect on where we are now, as well Aspro on where we are now, as well Aspro jecting on where we are now, as well Aspro jecting forward on where we are now, as well Aspro jecting forward into on where we are now, as well Aspro jecting forward into where on where we are now, as well Aspro jecting forward into where we on where we are now, as well Aspro jecting forward into where we must jecting forward into where we must bo. jecting forward into where we must bo. Those jecting forward into where we must bo. Those deeds jecting forward into where we must bo. Those deeds tell jecting forward into where we must bo. Those deeds tell you jecting forward into where we must bo. Those deeds tell you a jecting forward into where we must bo. Those deeds tell you a story. bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first thing bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first thing they bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first thing they tell bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first thing they tell to bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first thing they tell to you, bo. Those deeds tell you a story. The first thing they tell to you, Mr The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, is The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, is that The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, is that we The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, is that we are The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, is that we are a The first thing they tell to you, Mr Speaker, is that we are a government Speaker, is that we are a government of Speaker, is that we are a government of infrastructure. Speaker, is that we are a government of infrastructure. Undeniably. Speaker, is that we are a government of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, I of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, I have of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, I have a of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, I have a visual of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, I have a visual aid of infrastructure. Undeniably. Mr Speaker, I have a visual aid that Speaker, I have a visual aid that the Speaker, I have a visual aid that the Leader Speaker, I have a visual aid that the Leader of Speaker, I have a visual aid that the Leader of the Speaker, I have a visual aid that the Leader of the Opposition Speaker, I have a visual aid that the Leader of the Opposition loves the Leader of the Opposition loves this the Leader of the Opposition loves this one. the Leader of the Opposition loves this one. The the Leader of the Opposition loves this one. The Leader the Leader of the Opposition loves this one. The Leader of the Leader of the Opposition loves this one. The Leader of the this one. The Leader of the Opposition this one. The Leader of the Opposition is this one. The Leader of the Opposition is particularly this one. The Leader of the Opposition is particularly fond this one. The Leader of the Opposition is particularly fond of Opposition is particularly fond of this Opposition is particularly fond of this graph. Opposition is particularly fond of this graph. Mr Opposition is particularly fond of this graph. Mr Speaker, Opposition is particularly fond of this graph. Mr Speaker, this Opposition is particularly fond of this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph tells this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph tells a this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph tells a story this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph tells a story better this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph tells a story better than this graph. Mr Speaker, this graph tells a story better than anything. tells a story better than anything. This tells a story better than anything. This is tells a story better than anything. This is of tells a story better than anything. This is of course, tells a story better than anything. This is of course, based tells a story better than anything. This is of course, based on tells a story better than anything. This is of course, based on Treasury This is of course, based on Treasury as This is of course, based on Treasury as data. This is of course, based on Treasury as data. This This is of course, based on Treasury as data. This shows This is of course, based on Treasury as data. This shows capital as data. This shows capital investment as data. This shows capital investment and as data. This shows capital investment and it as data. This shows capital investment and it demonstrates investment and it demonstrates happenfully investment and it demonstrates happenfully in investment and it demonstrates happenfully in a investment and it demonstrates happenfully in a colour-coded investment and it demonstrates happenfully in a colour-coded manner happenfully in a colour-coded manner that happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in 2016 happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in 2016 with happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in 2016 with saw happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in 2016 with saw no happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in 2016 with saw no new happenfully in a colour-coded manner that in 2016 with saw no new dollars that in 2016 with saw no new dollars for that in 2016 with saw no new dollars for health that in 2016 with saw no new dollars for health capital that in 2016 with saw no new dollars for health capital expenditure. that in 2016 with saw no new dollars for health capital expenditure. In for health capital expenditure. In 2017, for health capital expenditure. In 2017, we for health capital expenditure. In 2017, we saw for health capital expenditure. In 2017, we saw just for health capital expenditure. In 2017, we saw just $150 for health capital expenditure. In 2017, we saw just $150 million. for health capital expenditure. In 2017, we saw just $150 million. No 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder we 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder we had 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder we had sewerage 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder we had sewerage in 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder we had sewerage in the 2017, we saw just $150 million. No wonder we had sewerage in the walls. wonder we had sewerage in the walls. Within wonder we had sewerage in the walls. Within two wonder we had sewerage in the walls. Within two years, wonder we had sewerage in the walls. Within two years, of wonder we had sewerage in the walls. Within two years, of course, wonder we had sewerage in the walls. Within two years, of course, Mr Within two years, of course, Mr Speaker, Within two years, of course, Mr Speaker, we Within two years, of course, Mr Speaker, we have Within two years, of course, Mr Speaker, we have invested Within two years, of course, Mr Speaker, we have invested $2.5 Speaker, we have invested $2.5 billion Speaker, we have invested $2.5 billion into Speaker, we have invested $2.5 billion into Health. Speaker, we have invested $2.5 billion into Health. Now, Speaker, we have invested $2.5 billion into Health. Now, that billion into Health. Now, that number, billion into Health. Now, that number, it billion into Health. Now, that number, it doesn't billion into Health. Now, that number, it doesn't tell billion into Health. Now, that number, it doesn't tell you billion into Health. Now, that number, it doesn't tell you the number, it doesn't tell you the story number, it doesn't tell you the story of number, it doesn't tell you the story of the number, it doesn't tell you the story of the mental number, it doesn't tell you the story of the mental health number, it doesn't tell you the story of the mental health wards story of the mental health wards that story of the mental health wards that we story of the mental health wards that we are story of the mental health wards that we are making story of the mental health wards that we are making safe story of the mental health wards that we are making safe again story of the mental health wards that we are making safe again by story of the mental health wards that we are making safe again by are that we are making safe again by are building that we are making safe again by are building them that we are making safe again by are building them in that we are making safe again by are building them in the that we are making safe again by are building them in the central that we are making safe again by are building them in the central North building them in the central North Island. building them in the central North Island. It building them in the central North Island. It doesn't building them in the central North Island. It doesn't tell building them in the central North Island. It doesn't tell you building them in the central North Island. It doesn't tell you about Island. It doesn't tell you about the Island. It doesn't tell you about the investment Island. It doesn't tell you about the investment we Island. It doesn't tell you about the investment we are Island. It doesn't tell you about the investment we are putting Island. It doesn't tell you about the investment we are putting in the investment we are putting in that the investment we are putting in that doesn't the investment we are putting in that doesn't have the investment we are putting in that doesn't have beds the investment we are putting in that doesn't have beds for the investment we are putting in that doesn't have beds for alcohol that doesn't have beds for alcohol and that doesn't have beds for alcohol and drug that doesn't have beds for alcohol and drug rehabilitation that doesn't have beds for alcohol and drug rehabilitation and that doesn't have beds for alcohol and drug rehabilitation and it and drug rehabilitation and it doesn't and drug rehabilitation and it doesn't tell and drug rehabilitation and it doesn't tell you and drug rehabilitation and it doesn't tell you about and drug rehabilitation and it doesn't tell you about the and drug rehabilitation and it doesn't tell you about the new and drug rehabilitation and it and and drug rehabilitation and it maternity services and and drug rehabilitation and it maternity services and child and drug rehabilitation and it maternity services and child health maternity services and child health services maternity services and child health services at maternity services and child health services at Starship maternity services and child health services at Starship than maternity services and child health services at Starship than we maternity services and child health services at Starship than we are services at Starship than we are rebuilding services at Starship than we are rebuilding and services at Starship than we are rebuilding and expanding. services at Starship than we are rebuilding and expanding. That services at Starship than we are rebuilding and expanding. That is rebuilding and expanding. That is what rebuilding and expanding. That is what that rebuilding and expanding. That is what that $2.25 rebuilding and expanding. That is what that $2.25 million. rebuilding and expanding. That is what that $2.25 million. We rebuilding and expanding. That is what that $2.25 million. We can't rebuilding and expanding. That is what that $2.25 million. We can't of what that $2.25 million. We can't of course what that $2.25 million. We can't of course forget what that $2.25 million. We can't of course forget Dunedin what that $2.25 million. We can't of course forget Dunedin hospital. what that $2.25 million. We can't of course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 billion course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 billion into course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 billion into schools. course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 billion into schools. For course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 billion into schools. For the course forget Dunedin hospital. $1.5 billion into schools. For the first billion into schools. For the first time billion into schools. For the first time ever billion into schools. For the first time ever we billion into schools. For the first time ever we have billion into schools. For the first time ever we have long-term billion into schools. For the first time ever we have long-term planning time ever we have long-term planning to time ever we have long-term planning to make time ever we have long-term planning to make sure time ever we have long-term planning to make sure that time ever we have long-term planning to make sure that we time ever we have long-term planning to make sure that we can time ever we have long-term planning to make sure that we can cater time ever we have long-term planning to make sure that we can cater for to make sure that we can cater for over to make sure that we can cater for over 100,000 to make sure that we can cater for over 100,000 students to make sure that we can cater for over 100,000 students coming to make sure that we can cater for over 100,000 students coming into over 100,000 students coming into our over 100,000 students coming into our schooling over 100,000 students coming into our schooling system. over 100,000 students coming into our schooling system. Again, over 100,000 students coming into our schooling system. Again, the our schooling system. Again, the message our schooling system. Again, the message that our schooling system. Again, the message that you our schooling system. Again, the message that you don't our schooling system. Again, the message that you don't see our schooling system. Again, the message that you don't see in our schooling system. Again, the message that you don't see in just our schooling system. Again, the message that you don't see in just a message that you don't see in just a graph message that you don't see in just a graph is message that you don't see in just a graph is that message that you don't see in just a graph is that we message that you don't see in just a graph is that we are message that you don't see in just a graph is that we are putting message that you don't see in just a graph is that we are putting money graph is that we are putting money into graph is that we are putting money into every graph is that we are putting money into every single graph is that we are putting money into every single school, graph is that we are putting money into every single school, up graph is that we are putting money into every single school, up to into every single school, up to $400,000 into every single school, up to $400,000 for into every single school, up to $400,000 for most into every single school, up to $400,000 for most state into every single school, up to $400,000 for most state schools, into every single school, up to $400,000 for most state schools, so $400,000 for most state schools, so that $400,000 for most state schools, so that they $400,000 for most state schools, so that they can $400,000 for most state schools, so that they can do $400,000 for most state schools, so that they can do simple $400,000 for most state schools, so that they can do simple things. that they can do simple things. Simple that they can do simple things. Simple things that they can do simple things. Simple things like that they can do simple things. Simple things like are that they can do simple things. Simple things like are pair that they can do simple things. Simple things like are pair the that they can do simple things. Simple things like are pair the roof Simple things like are pair the roof or Simple things like are pair the roof or put Simple things like are pair the roof or put down Simple things like are pair the roof or put down new Simple things like are pair the roof or put down new carpet. Simple things like are pair the roof or put down new carpet. I'll Simple things like are pair the roof or put down new carpet. I'll forever or put down new carpet. I'll forever Reserve or put down new carpet. I'll forever Reserve Bank or put down new carpet. I'll forever Reserve Bank the or put down new carpet. I'll forever Reserve Bank the story or put down new carpet. I'll forever Reserve Bank the story of or put down new carpet. I'll forever Reserve Bank the story of Grant Reserve Bank the story of Grant Robertson Reserve Bank the story of Grant Robertson saying Reserve Bank the story of Grant Robertson saying he Reserve Bank the story of Grant Robertson saying he visited Reserve Bank the story of Grant Robertson saying he visited a Reserve Bank the story of Grant Robertson saying he visited a local Robertson saying he visited a local school Robertson saying he visited a local school and Robertson saying he visited a local school and couldn't Robertson saying he visited a local school and couldn't fine Robertson saying he visited a local school and couldn't fine the school and couldn't fine the principal. school and couldn't fine the principal. It school and couldn't fine the principal. It was school and couldn't fine the principal. It was January school and couldn't fine the principal. It was January I school and couldn't fine the principal. It was January I believe. principal. It was January I believe. They principal. It was January I believe. They were principal. It was January I believe. They were out principal. It was January I believe. They were out and principal. It was January I believe. They were out and about principal. It was January I believe. They were out and about walking They were out and about walking around They were out and about walking around with They were out and about walking around with a They were out and about walking around with a tradie They were out and about walking around with a tradie talking They were out and about walking around with a tradie talking about around with a tradie talking about all around with a tradie talking about all of around with a tradie talking about all of the around with a tradie talking about all of the work around with a tradie talking about all of the work they around with a tradie talking about all of the work they could around with a tradie talking about all of the work they could do all of the work they could do because all of the work they could do because of all of the work they could do because of what all of the work they could do because of what we all of the work they could do because of what we delivered all of the work they could do because of what we delivered at all of the work they could do because of what we delivered at the because of what we delivered at the end because of what we delivered at the end of because of what we delivered at the end of last because of what we delivered at the end of last year. because of what we delivered at the end of last year. That because of what we delivered at the end of last year. That is because of what we delivered at the end of last year. That is of because of what we delivered at the end of last year. That is of course end of last year. That is of course before end of last year. That is of course before you end of last year. That is of course before you take end of last year. That is of course before you take into end of last year. That is of course before you take into account end of last year. That is of course before you take into account just before you take into account just the before you take into account just the huge, before you take into account just the huge, tend before you take into account just the huge, tend of before you take into account just the huge, tend of what before you take into account just the huge, tend of what we before you take into account just the huge, tend of what we mutt before you take into account just the huge, tend of what we mutt in the huge, tend of what we mutt in through the huge, tend of what we mutt in through the the huge, tend of what we mutt in through the New the huge, tend of what we mutt in through the New Zealand the huge, tend of what we mutt in through the New Zealand Upgrade through the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. through the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. $12 through the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. $12 billion, through the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. $12 billion, which through the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. $12 billion, which adds through the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. $12 billion, which adds a Programme. $12 billion, which adds a significant Programme. $12 billion, which adds a significant amount Programme. $12 billion, which adds a significant amount to Programme. $12 billion, which adds a significant amount to making Programme. $12 billion, which adds a significant amount to making sure significant amount to making sure that significant amount to making sure that with significant amount to making sure that with got significant amount to making sure that with got New significant amount to making sure that with got New Zealanders significant amount to making sure that with got New Zealanders out significant amount to making sure that with got New Zealanders out of that with got New Zealanders out of congestion, that with got New Zealanders out of congestion, that that with got New Zealanders out of congestion, that with that with got New Zealanders out of congestion, that with give that with got New Zealanders out of congestion, that with give them congestion, that with give them options congestion, that with give them options for congestion, that with give them options for walking congestion, that with give them options for walking and congestion, that with give them options for walking and cycling congestion, that with give them options for walking and cycling and options for walking and cycling and rail. options for walking and cycling and rail. That options for walking and cycling and rail. That we options for walking and cycling and rail. That we continue options for walking and cycling and rail. That we continue to options for walking and cycling and rail. That we continue to make options for walking and cycling and rail. That we continue to make sure rail. That we continue to make sure that rail. That we continue to make sure that safety rail. That we continue to make sure that safety improvements rail. That we continue to make sure that safety improvements are rail. That we continue to make sure that safety improvements are also that safety improvements are also continuing that safety improvements are also continuing to that safety improvements are also continuing to be that safety improvements are also continuing to be at that safety improvements are also continuing to be at the that safety improvements are also continuing to be at the top that safety improvements are also continuing to be at the top of that safety improvements are also continuing to be at the top of her continuing to be at the top of her awe continuing to be at the top of her awe Jen continuing to be at the top of her awe Jen da. continuing to be at the top of her awe Jen da. Infrastructure, continuing to be at the top of her awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, means awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, means just awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, means just goingon awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, means just goingon that awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, means just goingon that rebuild awe Jen da. Infrastructure, though, means just goingon that rebuild and means just goingon that rebuild and future means just goingon that rebuild and future planning. means just goingon that rebuild and future planning. The means just goingon that rebuild and future planning. The infrastructure future planning. The infrastructure Commission future planning. The infrastructure Commission has future planning. The infrastructure Commission has been future planning. The infrastructure Commission has been key. future planning. The infrastructure Commission has been key. Financing Commission has been key. Financing has Commission has been key. Financing has been Commission has been key. Financing has been key Commission has been key. Financing has been key through Commission has been key. Financing has been key through the has been key through the Infrastructure has been key through the Infrastructure Funding has been key through the Infrastructure Funding and has been key through the Infrastructure Funding and Financing Infrastructure Funding and Financing Bill Infrastructure Funding and Financing Bill to Infrastructure Funding and Financing Bill to support Infrastructure Funding and Financing Bill to support future Infrastructure Funding and Financing Bill to support future housing Infrastructure Funding and Financing Bill to support future housing and Bill to support future housing and urban Bill to support future housing and urban development. Bill to support future housing and urban development. Mr Bill to support future housing and urban development. Mr Speaker, urban development. Mr Speaker, ultimately, urban development. Mr Speaker, ultimately, I urban development. Mr Speaker, ultimately, I stand urban development. Mr Speaker, ultimately, I stand proudly urban development. Mr Speaker, ultimately, I stand proudly as urban development. Mr Speaker, ultimately, I stand proudly as the ultimately, I stand proudly as the PM ultimately, I stand proudly as the PM for ultimately, I stand proudly as the PM for the ultimately, I stand proudly as the PM for the government ultimately, I stand proudly as the PM for the government of PM for the government of Infrastructure. PM for the government of Infrastructure. It PM for the government of Infrastructure. It is PM for the government of Infrastructure. It is undeniable. Infrastructure. It is undeniable. <APPLAUSE> <APPLAUSE> It <APPLAUSE> It is <APPLAUSE> It is undeniable. <APPLAUSE> It is undeniable. Mr <APPLAUSE> It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, <APPLAUSE> It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if <APPLAUSE> It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of course It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of course to It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of course to be It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of course to be the It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of course to be the government It is undeniable. Mr Speaker, if we, of course to be the government of of course to be the government of Infrastructure of course to be the government of Infrastructure we of course to be the government of Infrastructure we have of course to be the government of Infrastructure we have to of course to be the government of Infrastructure we have to be of course to be the government of Infrastructure we have to be the Infrastructure we have to be the government Infrastructure we have to be the government of Infrastructure we have to be the government of training Infrastructure we have to be the government of training and government of training and education. government of training and education. We government of training and education. We simply government of training and education. We simply cannot government of training and education. We simply cannot deliver education. We simply cannot deliver this education. We simply cannot deliver this infrastructure education. We simply cannot deliver this infrastructure without education. We simply cannot deliver this infrastructure without having this infrastructure without having that this infrastructure without having that relentless this infrastructure without having that relentless focus this infrastructure without having that relentless focus on this infrastructure without having that relentless focus on training that relentless focus on training and that relentless focus on training and education. that relentless focus on training and education. When that relentless focus on training and education. When we that relentless focus on training and education. When we came that relentless focus on training and education. When we came in, that relentless focus on training and education. When we came in, we and education. When we came in, we moved and education. When we came in, we moved swiftly, and education. When we came in, we moved swiftly, with and education. When we came in, we moved swiftly, with moved and education. When we came in, we moved swiftly, with moved swiftly and education. When we came in, we moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to implement moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to implement fees-free moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to implement fees-free and moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to implement fees-free and not moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to implement fees-free and not only moved swiftly, with moved swiftly to implement fees-free and not only has implement fees-free and not only has that implement fees-free and not only has that reduced implement fees-free and not only has that reduced the implement fees-free and not only has that reduced the bun implement fees-free and not only has that reduced the bun of implement fees-free and not only has that reduced the bun of debt implement fees-free and not only has that reduced the bun of debt for implement fees-free and not only has that reduced the bun of debt for our that reduced the bun of debt for our young that reduced the bun of debt for our young people that reduced the bun of debt for our young people for that reduced the bun of debt for our young people for generations that reduced the bun of debt for our young people for generations to young people for generations to come. young people for generations to come. It young people for generations to come. It has young people for generations to come. It has meant young people for generations to come. It has meant that young people for generations to come. It has meant that those young people for generations to come. It has meant that those moving come. It has meant that those moving into come. It has meant that those moving into apprenticeships, come. It has meant that those moving into apprenticeships, for come. It has meant that those moving into apprenticeships, for those into apprenticeships, for those first into apprenticeships, for those first two into apprenticeships, for those first two years into apprenticeships, for those first two years they into apprenticeships, for those first two years they pay into apprenticeships, for those first two years they pay nothing, first two years they pay nothing, and first two years they pay nothing, and that first two years they pay nothing, and that has first two years they pay nothing, and that has made first two years they pay nothing, and that has made a first two years they pay nothing, and that has made a different. first two years they pay nothing, and that has made a different. 3, and that has made a different. 3, 900 and that has made a different. 3, 900 Kiwis and that has made a different. 3, 900 Kiwis have and that has made a different. 3, 900 Kiwis have taken and that has made a different. 3, 900 Kiwis have taken up and that has made a different. 3, 900 Kiwis have taken up construction 900 Kiwis have taken up construction aprep 900 Kiwis have taken up construction aprep tisships. 900 Kiwis have taken up construction aprep tisships. That 900 Kiwis have taken up construction aprep tisships. That is 900 Kiwis have taken up construction aprep tisships. That is exactly 900 Kiwis have taken up construction aprep tisships. That is exactly what aprep tisships. That is exactly what this aprep tisships. That is exactly what this country aprep tisships. That is exactly what this country needed. aprep tisships. That is exactly what this country needed. Not aprep tisships. That is exactly what this country needed. Not only aprep tisships. That is exactly what this country needed. Not only that, this country needed. Not only that, we this country needed. Not only that, we have this country needed. Not only that, we have boasted this country needed. Not only that, we have boasted vocational this country needed. Not only that, we have boasted vocational edge this country needed. Not only that, we have boasted vocational edge igs we have boasted vocational edge igs ka we have boasted vocational edge igs ka training. we have boasted vocational edge igs ka training. 400 we have boasted vocational edge igs ka training. 400 places we have boasted vocational edge igs ka training. 400 places for we have boasted vocational edge igs ka training. 400 places for trades ka training. 400 places for trades academy ka training. 400 places for trades academy and ka training. 400 places for trades academy and gateway ka training. 400 places for trades academy and gateway places. ka training. 400 places for trades academy and gateway places. Money ka training. 400 places for trades academy and gateway places. Money ma academy and gateway places. Money ma and academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi I academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi I will academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi I will prefer academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi I will prefer be academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi I will prefer be proud academy and gateway places. Money ma and mahi I will prefer be proud of and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. We and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. We are and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. We are just and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. We are just at and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. We are just at the and mahi I will prefer be proud of this. We are just at the beginning this. We are just at the beginning of this. We are just at the beginning of that this. We are just at the beginning of that programme, this. We are just at the beginning of that programme, but this. We are just at the beginning of that programme, but I this. We are just at the beginning of that programme, but I read this. We are just at the beginning of that programme, but I read the of that programme, but I read the reports of that programme, but I read the reports and of that programme, but I read the reports and I of that programme, but I read the reports and I read of that programme, but I read the reports and I read the of that programme, but I read the reports and I read the stories, of that programme, but I read the reports and I read the stories, for reports and I read the stories, for instance, reports and I read the stories, for instance, of reports and I read the stories, for instance, of the reports and I read the stories, for instance, of the young reports and I read the stories, for instance, of the young person reports and I read the stories, for instance, of the young person who instance, of the young person who had instance, of the young person who had been instance, of the young person who had been on instance, of the young person who had been on a instance, of the young person who had been on a long-term instance, of the young person who had been on a long-term benefit instance, of the young person who had been on a long-term benefit who had been on a long-term benefit who found had been on a long-term benefit who found through had been on a long-term benefit who found through mana had been on a long-term benefit who found through mana and had been on a long-term benefit who found through mana and mahi had been on a long-term benefit who found through mana and mahi a found through mana and mahi a subsidised found through mana and mahi a subsidised role found through mana and mahi a subsidised role working found through mana and mahi a subsidised role working in subsidised role working in landscaping. subsidised role working in landscaping. The subsidised role working in landscaping. The difference subsidised role working in landscaping. The difference it subsidised role working in landscaping. The difference it made landscaping. The difference it made to landscaping. The difference it made to their landscaping. The difference it made to their mental landscaping. The difference it made to their mental health landscaping. The difference it made to their mental health in landscaping. The difference it made to their mental health in their landscaping. The difference it made to their mental health in their own to their mental health in their own words to their mental health in their own words was to their mental health in their own words was undeniable. to their mental health in their own words was undeniable. I to their mental health in their own words was undeniable. I am to their mental health in their own words was undeniable. I am so to their mental health in their own words was undeniable. I am so proud words was undeniable. I am so proud of words was undeniable. I am so proud of that words was undeniable. I am so proud of that programme. words was undeniable. I am so proud of that programme. It words was undeniable. I am so proud of that programme. It sits' words was undeniable. I am so proud of that programme. It sits' long of that programme. It sits' long side of that programme. It sits' long side hipotama of that programme. It sits' long side hipotama rangatahi of that programme. It sits' long side hipotama rangatahi Maori of that programme. It sits' long side hipotama rangatahi Maori as side hipotama rangatahi Maori as well. side hipotama rangatahi Maori as well. We side hipotama rangatahi Maori as well. We replacing side hipotama rangatahi Maori as well. We replacing so side hipotama rangatahi Maori as well. We replacing so many side hipotama rangatahi Maori as well. We replacing so many people well. We replacing so many people through well. We replacing so many people through that well. We replacing so many people through that programme well. We replacing so many people through that programme no well. We replacing so many people through that programme no work. through that programme no work. Increasing through that programme no work. Increasing construction Increasing construction apprenticeships. Increasing construction apprenticeships. More Increasing construction apprenticeships. More than Increasing construction apprenticeships. More than 11,000 apprenticeships. More than 11,000 cooees apprenticeships. More than 11,000 cooees in apprenticeships. More than 11,000 cooees in the apprenticeships. More than 11,000 cooees in the construction apprenticeships. More than 11,000 cooees in the construction sector apprenticeships. More than 11,000 cooees in the construction sector in cooees in the construction sector in the cooees in the construction sector in the last cooees in the construction sector in the last couple cooees in the construction sector in the last couple of cooees in the construction sector in the last couple of years. cooees in the construction sector in the last couple of years. We cooees in the construction sector in the last couple of years. We are the last couple of years. We are making the last couple of years. We are making a the last couple of years. We are making a difference. the last couple of years. We are making a difference. Of the last couple of years. We are making a difference. Of course the last couple of years. We are making a difference. Of course we making a difference. Of course we need making a difference. Of course we need every making a difference. Of course we need every single making a difference. Of course we need every single one making a difference. Of course we need every single one of making a difference. Of course we need every single one of those making a difference. Of course we need every single one of those young need every single one of those young people need every single one of those young people and need every single one of those young people and people need every single one of those young people and people in need every single one of those young people and people in apprenticeships people and people in apprenticeships because people and people in apprenticeships because we people and people in apprenticeships because we are people and people in apprenticeships because we are also people and people in apprenticeships because we are also proudly people and people in apprenticeships because we are also proudly a because we are also proudly a government because we are also proudly a government of because we are also proudly a government of housing. because we are also proudly a government of housing. I because we are also proudly a government of housing. I say because we are also proudly a government of housing. I say that government of housing. I say that firmly government of housing. I say that firmly and government of housing. I say that firmly and proudly. government of housing. I say that firmly and proudly. Mr government of housing. I say that firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, government of housing. I say that firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... I firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... I am firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... I am going firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... I am going the firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... I am going the spook, firmly and proudly. Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. If Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. If you Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. If you will Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. If you will allow Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. If you will allow many Speaker... I am going the spook, Mr Speaker. If you will allow many to Speaker. If you will allow many to review Speaker. If you will allow many to review the Speaker. If you will allow many to review the last Speaker. If you will allow many to review the last government Speaker. If you will allow many to review the last government as review the last government as record. review the last government as record. Because review the last government as record. Because that review the last government as record. Because that side review the last government as record. Because that side of review the last government as record. Because that side of the record. Because that side of the House record. Because that side of the House has record. Because that side of the House has nothing record. Because that side of the House has nothing but record. Because that side of the House has nothing but a record. Because that side of the House has nothing but a foundation House has nothing but a foundation of House has nothing but a foundation of shame House has nothing but a foundation of shame when House has nothing but a foundation of shame when it House has nothing but a foundation of shame when it comes House has nothing but a foundation of shame when it comes to House has nothing but a foundation of shame when it comes to housing. of shame when it comes to housing. APPLAUSE of shame when it comes to housing. APPLAUSE Homelessness of shame when it comes to housing. APPLAUSE Homelessness and of shame when it comes to housing. APPLAUSE Homelessness and the of shame when it comes to housing. APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer audacity APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer audacity - APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer audacity - homelessness APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer audacity - homelessness rates APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer audacity - homelessness rates at APPLAUSE Homelessness and the sheer audacity - homelessness rates at the audacity - homelessness rates at the worst audacity - homelessness rates at the worst levels audacity - homelessness rates at the worst levels with audacity - homelessness rates at the worst levels with had audacity - homelessness rates at the worst levels with had seen audacity - homelessness rates at the worst levels with had seen in audacity - homelessness rates at the worst levels with had seen in the worst levels with had seen in the OECD, worst levels with had seen in the OECD, Mr worst levels with had seen in the OECD, Mr Speaker. worst levels with had seen in the OECD, Mr Speaker. Home worst levels with had seen in the OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership worst levels with had seen in the OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst sin OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst sin 1951. OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst sin 1951. Mr OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at OECD, Mr Speaker. Home ownership the worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a time worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a time when worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a time when children worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a time when children were worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a time when children were sleeping worst sin 1951. Mr Speaker, at a time when children were sleeping in time when children were sleeping in cars, time when children were sleeping in cars, what time when children were sleeping in cars, what did time when children were sleeping in cars, what did they time when children were sleeping in cars, what did they do time when children were sleeping in cars, what did they do to time when children were sleeping in cars, what did they do to state cars, what did they do to state houses? cars, what did they do to state houses? They cars, what did they do to state houses? They decreased cars, what did they do to state houses? They decreased our cars, what did they do to state houses? They decreased our - cars, what did they do to state houses? They decreased our - net houses? They decreased our - net stock houses? They decreased our - net stock housing houses? They decreased our - net stock housing decreased houses? They decreased our - net stock housing decreased by houses? They decreased our - net stock housing decreased by 5,000. stock housing decreased by 5,000. When stock housing decreased by 5,000. When with stock housing decreased by 5,000. When with needed stock housing decreased by 5,000. When with needed housing stock housing decreased by 5,000. When with needed housing the stock housing decreased by 5,000. When with needed housing the most, When with needed housing the most, that When with needed housing the most, that government When with needed housing the most, that government sold When with needed housing the most, that government sold them When with needed housing the most, that government sold them and When with needed housing the most, that government sold them and it When with needed housing the most, that government sold them and it is that government sold them and it is a that government sold them and it is a disgrace that government sold them and it is a disgrace and that government sold them and it is a disgrace and we that government sold them and it is a disgrace and we have that government sold them and it is a disgrace and we have had that government sold them and it is a disgrace and we have had to that government sold them and it is a disgrace and we have had to are a disgrace and we have had to are build a disgrace and we have had to are build ever a disgrace and we have had to are build ever since, a disgrace and we have had to are build ever since, but a disgrace and we have had to are build ever since, but Mr a disgrace and we have had to are build ever since, but Mr Speaker, a disgrace and we have had to are build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! We build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! We have build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! We have now build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! We have now create build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! We have now create ed build ever since, but Mr Speaker, we have! We have now create ed more have! We have now create ed more than have! We have now create ed more than 4, have! We have now create ed more than 4, 258 have! We have now create ed more than 4, 258 public have! We have now create ed more than 4, 258 public housing have! We have now create ed more than 4, 258 public housing places. than 4, 258 public housing places. Every than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single one than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single one of than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single one of these than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single one of these is than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single one of these is a than 4, 258 public housing places. Every single one of these is a home. Every single one of these is a home. Every Every single one of these is a home. Every single Every single one of these is a home. Every single one Every single one of these is a home. Every single one of Every single one of these is a home. Every single one of these Every single one of these is a home. Every single one of these is Every single one of these is a home. Every single one of these is a Every single one of these is a home. Every single one of these is a home Every single one of these is a home for Every single one of these is a home for someone Every single one of these is a home for someone that Every single one of these is a home for someone that did Every single one of these is a home for someone that did not Every single one of these is a home for someone that did not exist for someone that did not exist before. for someone that did not exist before. In for someone that did not exist before. In the for someone that did not exist before. In the time for someone that did not exist before. In the time it for someone that did not exist before. In the time it has for someone that did not exist before. In the time it has taken for someone that did not exist before. In the time it has taken to before. In the time it has taken to are before. In the time it has taken to are build before. In the time it has taken to are build what before. In the time it has taken to are build what they before. In the time it has taken to are build what they created, before. In the time it has taken to are build what they created, we before. In the time it has taken to are build what they created, we have are build what they created, we have put are build what they created, we have put people are build what they created, we have put people in are build what they created, we have put people in hopes. are build what they created, we have put people in hopes. It are build what they created, we have put people in hopes. It is are build what they created, we have put people in hopes. It is making are build what they created, we have put people in hopes. It is making a put people in hopes. It is making a difference. put people in hopes. It is making a difference. Mr put people in hopes. It is making a difference. Mr Speaker, put people in hopes. It is making a difference. Mr Speaker, first put people in hopes. It is making a difference. Mr Speaker, first home difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers new difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers new makes difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers new makes up difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers new makes up 24% difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers new makes up 24% of difference. Mr Speaker, first home buyers new makes up 24% of the buyers new makes up 24% of the market. buyers new makes up 24% of the market. That buyers new makes up 24% of the market. That is buyers new makes up 24% of the market. That is through buyers new makes up 24% of the market. That is through the buyers new makes up 24% of the market. That is through the changes market. That is through the changes that market. That is through the changes that with market. That is through the changes that with made market. That is through the changes that with made to market. That is through the changes that with made to tax market. That is through the changes that with made to tax loopholes market. That is through the changes that with made to tax loopholes to that with made to tax loopholes to make that with made to tax loopholes to make sure that with made to tax loopholes to make sure with that with made to tax loopholes to make sure with shut that with made to tax loopholes to make sure with shut down that with made to tax loopholes to make sure with shut down overseas make sure with shut down overseas investment make sure with shut down overseas investment in make sure with shut down overseas investment in our make sure with shut down overseas investment in our housing make sure with shut down overseas investment in our housing market. investment in our housing market. Changes investment in our housing market. Changes with investment in our housing market. Changes with mad investment in our housing market. Changes with mad to investment in our housing market. Changes with mad to income investment in our housing market. Changes with mad to income support Changes with mad to income support to Changes with mad to income support to those Changes with mad to income support to those buying Changes with mad to income support to those buying houses. Changes with mad to income support to those buying houses. We Changes with mad to income support to those buying houses. We have to those buying houses. We have ensured to those buying houses. We have ensured that to those buying houses. We have ensured that 1, to those buying houses. We have ensured that 1, 100 to those buying houses. We have ensured that 1, 100 households to those buying houses. We have ensured that 1, 100 households have ensured that 1, 100 households have been ensured that 1, 100 households have been housed ensured that 1, 100 households have been housed through ensured that 1, 100 households have been housed through Housing ensured that 1, 100 households have been housed through Housing First. been housed through Housing First. There been housed through Housing First. There is been housed through Housing First. There is more been housed through Housing First. There is more to been housed through Housing First. There is more to come, been housed through Housing First. There is more to come, Mr been housed through Housing First. There is more to come, Mr Speaker, There is more to come, Mr Speaker, because There is more to come, Mr Speaker, because we There is more to come, Mr Speaker, because we currently There is more to come, Mr Speaker, because we currently have There is more to come, Mr Speaker, because we currently have 3, There is more to come, Mr Speaker, because we currently have 3, 480 because we currently have 3, 480 houses because we currently have 3, 480 houses under because we currently have 3, 480 houses under construction because we currently have 3, 480 houses under construction in because we currently have 3, 480 houses under construction in the houses under construction in the Government houses under construction in the Government Build houses under construction in the Government Build Programme. houses under construction in the Government Build Programme. I Government Build Programme. I understand Government Build Programme. I understand why Government Build Programme. I understand why you Government Build Programme. I understand why you are Government Build Programme. I understand why you are aly Government Build Programme. I understand why you are aly defensive understand why you are aly defensive because understand why you are aly defensive because we understand why you are aly defensive because we are understand why you are aly defensive because we are fixing understand why you are aly defensive because we are fixing what understand why you are aly defensive because we are fixing what you understand why you are aly defensive because we are fixing what you Brock because we are fixing what you Brock and because we are fixing what you Brock and you because we are fixing what you Brock and you broke because we are fixing what you Brock and you broke our because we are fixing what you Brock and you broke our housing because we are fixing what you Brock and you broke our housing market. and you broke our housing market. You and you broke our housing market. You stood and you broke our housing market. You stood idoly and you broke our housing market. You stood idoly by and you broke our housing market. You stood idoly by while and you broke our housing market. You stood idoly by while people You stood idoly by while people lived You stood idoly by while people lived on You stood idoly by while people lived on the You stood idoly by while people lived on the streets. You stood idoly by while people lived on the streets. Mr You stood idoly by while people lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, You stood idoly by while people lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am proud lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am proud of lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am proud of what lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am proud of what we lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am proud of what we have lived on the streets. Mr Speaker, I am proud of what we have achieved. am proud of what we have achieved. It am proud of what we have achieved. It was am proud of what we have achieved. It was only am proud of what we have achieved. It was only over am proud of what we have achieved. It was only over summer am proud of what we have achieved. It was only over summer that am proud of what we have achieved. It was only over summer that we am proud of what we have achieved. It was only over summer that we of It was only over summer that we of course It was only over summer that we of course continue It was only over summer that we of course continue to It was only over summer that we of course continue to acknowledge It was only over summer that we of course continue to acknowledge that course continue to acknowledge that there course continue to acknowledge that there is course continue to acknowledge that there is more course continue to acknowledge that there is more work course continue to acknowledge that there is more work to course continue to acknowledge that there is more work to do. course continue to acknowledge that there is more work to do. We course continue to acknowledge that there is more work to do. We have there is more work to do. We have houses there is more work to do. We have houses under there is more work to do. We have houses under stress there is more work to do. We have houses under stress and there is more work to do. We have houses under stress and over there is more work to do. We have houses under stress and over the houses under stress and over the summer houses under stress and over the summer I houses under stress and over the summer I was houses under stress and over the summer I was speaking houses under stress and over the summer I was speaking with houses under stress and over the summer I was speaking with some houses under stress and over the summer I was speaking with some of summer I was speaking with some of the summer I was speaking with some of the individuals summer I was speaking with some of the individuals who summer I was speaking with some of the individuals who did summer I was speaking with some of the individuals who did see summer I was speaking with some of the individuals who did see the summer I was speaking with some of the individuals who did see the City the individuals who did see the City Mission the individuals who did see the City Mission over the individuals who did see the City Mission over the the individuals who did see the City Mission over the Christmas the individuals who did see the City Mission over the Christmas period. Mission over the Christmas period. One Mission over the Christmas period. One thing Mission over the Christmas period. One thing that Mission over the Christmas period. One thing that stood Mission over the Christmas period. One thing that stood out Mission over the Christmas period. One thing that stood out to Mission over the Christmas period. One thing that stood out to me Mission over the Christmas period. One thing that stood out to me is, One thing that stood out to me is, yes, One thing that stood out to me is, yes, they One thing that stood out to me is, yes, they were One thing that stood out to me is, yes, they were seeking One thing that stood out to me is, yes, they were seeking stance One thing that stood out to me is, yes, they were seeking stance at yes, they were seeking stance at that yes, they were seeking stance at that time yes, they were seeking stance at that time of yes, they were seeking stance at that time of your, yes, they were seeking stance at that time of your, but yes, they were seeking stance at that time of your, but the yes, they were seeking stance at that time of your, but the number yes, they were seeking stance at that time of your, but the number of that time of your, but the number of those that time of your, but the number of those people that time of your, but the number of those people I that time of your, but the number of those people I spoke that time of your, but the number of those people I spoke to that time of your, but the number of those people I spoke to who that time of your, but the number of those people I spoke to who had that time of your, but the number of those people I spoke to who had in those people I spoke to who had in recent those people I spoke to who had in recent months those people I spoke to who had in recent months moved those people I spoke to who had in recent months moved into those people I spoke to who had in recent months moved into new those people I spoke to who had in recent months moved into new state recent months moved into new state houses recent months moved into new state houses was recent months moved into new state houses was fan recent months moved into new state houses was fan nominal recent months moved into new state houses was fan nominal and recent months moved into new state houses was fan nominal and the houses was fan nominal and the message houses was fan nominal and the message they houses was fan nominal and the message they gave houses was fan nominal and the message they gave me houses was fan nominal and the message they gave me is houses was fan nominal and the message they gave me is "we houses was fan nominal and the message they gave me is "we are houses was fan nominal and the message they gave me is "we are now message they gave me is "we are now warm message they gave me is "we are now warm and message they gave me is "we are now warm and dry." message they gave me is "we are now warm and dry." What message they gave me is "we are now warm and dry." What a message they gave me is "we are now warm and dry." What a difference warm and dry." What a difference that warm and dry." What a difference that policy warm and dry." What a difference that policy is warm and dry." What a difference that policy is paying warm and dry." What a difference that policy is paying to warm and dry." What a difference that policy is paying to New that policy is paying to New Zealanders that policy is paying to New Zealanders everywhere. that policy is paying to New Zealanders everywhere. This that policy is paying to New Zealanders everywhere. This week Zealanders everywhere. This week have Zealanders everywhere. This week have announced Zealanders everywhere. This week have announced an Zealanders everywhere. This week have announced an extra Zealanders everywhere. This week have announced an extra $300 Zealanders everywhere. This week have announced an extra $300 million have announced an extra $300 million into have announced an extra $300 million into homelessness have announced an extra $300 million into homelessness with have announced an extra $300 million into homelessness with more have announced an extra $300 million into homelessness with more dills have announced an extra $300 million into homelessness with more dills to into homelessness with more dills to come. into homelessness with more dills to come. We're into homelessness with more dills to come. We're proudly into homelessness with more dills to come. We're proudly a into homelessness with more dills to come. We're proudly a government into homelessness with more dills to come. We're proudly a government of come. We're proudly a government of Mission come. We're proudly a government of housing and the come. We're proudly a government of housing and the new come. We're proudly a government of housing and the new builds come. We're proudly a government of housing and the new builds prove come. We're proudly a government of housing and the new builds prove it. housing and the new builds prove it. Mr housing and the new builds prove it. Mr Speaker, housing and the new builds prove it. Mr Speaker, the housing and the new builds prove it. Mr Speaker, the reason housing and the new builds prove it. Mr Speaker, the reason that housing and the new builds prove it. Mr Speaker, the reason that housing Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so important Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so important to Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so important to us Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so important to us of Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so important to us of course Mr Speaker, the reason that housing is so important to us of course is is so important to us of course is because is so important to us of course is because family is so important to us of course is because family wellbeing is so important to us of course is because family wellbeing and is so important to us of course is because family wellbeing and child because family wellbeing and child wellbeing because family wellbeing and child wellbeing sits because family wellbeing and child wellbeing sits at because family wellbeing and child wellbeing sits at the because family wellbeing and child wellbeing sits at the heart because family wellbeing and child wellbeing sits at the heart of wellbeing sits at the heart of everything wellbeing sits at the heart of everything this wellbeing sits at the heart of everything this we wellbeing sits at the heart of everything this we do. wellbeing sits at the heart of everything this we do. Now, wellbeing sits at the heart of everything this we do. Now, we wellbeing sits at the heart of everything this we do. Now, we have everything this we do. Now, we have demonstrated everything this we do. Now, we have demonstrated that everything this we do. Now, we have demonstrated that from everything this we do. Now, we have demonstrated that from the everything this we do. Now, we have demonstrated that from the moment everything this we do. Now, we have demonstrated that from the moment we demonstrated that from the moment we came demonstrated that from the moment we came into demonstrated that from the moment we came into this demonstrated that from the moment we came into this place demonstrated that from the moment we came into this place with demonstrated that from the moment we came into this place with the came into this place with the family's came into this place with the family's package. came into this place with the family's package. I came into this place with the family's package. I am came into this place with the family's package. I am proud came into this place with the family's package. I am proud that family's package. I am proud that this family's package. I am proud that this year family's package. I am proud that this year we family's package. I am proud that this year we will family's package. I am proud that this year we will be family's package. I am proud that this year we will be celebrating this year we will be celebrating another this year we will be celebrating another increase this year we will be celebrating another increase in this year we will be celebrating another increase in paid this year we will be celebrating another increase in paid parental another increase in paid parental leave. another increase in paid parental leave. Of another increase in paid parental leave. Of course another increase in paid parental leave. Of course with another increase in paid parental leave. Of course with avenue another increase in paid parental leave. Of course with avenue had leave. Of course with avenue had that leave. Of course with avenue had that aspiration leave. Of course with avenue had that aspiration of leave. Of course with avenue had that aspiration of lifting leave. Of course with avenue had that aspiration of lifting it leave. Of course with avenue had that aspiration of lifting it to leave. Of course with avenue had that aspiration of lifting it to 26 that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks and that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks and we that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks and we will. that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks and we will. That that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks and we will. That is that aspiration of lifting it to 26 weeks and we will. That is an weeks and we will. That is an incredible weeks and we will. That is an incredible mile weeks and we will. That is an incredible mile stolen weeks and we will. That is an incredible mile stolen for weeks and we will. That is an incredible mile stolen for us. incredible mile stolen for us. Continue incredible mile stolen for us. Continue it incredible mile stolen for us. Continue it with incredible mile stolen for us. Continue it with the incredible mile stolen for us. Continue it with the payment incredible mile stolen for us. Continue it with the payment that Continue it with the payment that continues Continue it with the payment that continues to Continue it with the payment that continues to roll Continue it with the payment that continues to roll out. Continue it with the payment that continues to roll out. Increases Continue it with the payment that continues to roll out. Increases to continues to roll out. Increases to the continues to roll out. Increases to the family continues to roll out. Increases to the family - continues to roll out. Increases to the family - Working continues to roll out. Increases to the family - Working for continues to roll out. Increases to the family - Working for Families the family - Working for Families Package, the family - Working for Families Package, Mr the family - Working for Families Package, Mr Speaker, the family - Working for Families Package, Mr Speaker, and the family - Working for Families Package, Mr Speaker, and of the family - Working for Families Package, Mr Speaker, and of course Package, Mr Speaker, and of course the Package, Mr Speaker, and of course the Winter Package, Mr Speaker, and of course the Winter Energy Package, Mr Speaker, and of course the Winter Energy Payment. Package, Mr Speaker, and of course the Winter Energy Payment. You Package, Mr Speaker, and of course the Winter Energy Payment. You will the Winter Energy Payment. You will see the Winter Energy Payment. You will see from the Winter Energy Payment. You will see from the the Winter Energy Payment. You will see from the State the Winter Energy Payment. You will see from the State of the Winter Energy Payment. You will see from the State of the the Winter Energy Payment. You will see from the State of the Nation see from the State of the Nation Report see from the State of the Nation Report today see from the State of the Nation Report today the see from the State of the Nation Report today the Salvation see from the State of the Nation Report today the Salvation Army see from the State of the Nation Report today the Salvation Army is Report today the Salvation Army is acknowledging Report today the Salvation Army is acknowledging the Report today the Salvation Army is acknowledging the difference Report today the Salvation Army is acknowledging the difference that acknowledging the difference that haven't acknowledging the difference that haven't is acknowledging the difference that haven't is making acknowledging the difference that haven't is making to acknowledging the difference that haven't is making to low-income haven't is making to low-income families. haven't is making to low-income families. On haven't is making to low-income families. On top haven't is making to low-income families. On top of haven't is making to low-income families. On top of that, haven't is making to low-income families. On top of that, with haven't is making to low-income families. On top of that, with had families. On top of that, with had the families. On top of that, with had the indexion families. On top of that, with had the indexion of families. On top of that, with had the indexion of benefits. families. On top of that, with had the indexion of benefits. That families. On top of that, with had the indexion of benefits. That moons the indexion of benefits. That moons when the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages go the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages go up, the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages go up, not the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages go up, not only the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages go up, not only do the indexion of benefits. That moons when wages go up, not only do our when wages go up, not only do our super when wages go up, not only do our super want when wages go up, not only do our super want benefit, when wages go up, not only do our super want benefit, but when wages go up, not only do our super want benefit, but those when wages go up, not only do our super want benefit, but those on when wages go up, not only do our super want benefit, but those on the super want benefit, but those on the tight super want benefit, but those on the tight incomes super want benefit, but those on the tight incomes that super want benefit, but those on the tight incomes that are super want benefit, but those on the tight incomes that are on super want benefit, but those on the tight incomes that are on government tight incomes that are on government support, tight incomes that are on government support, they tight incomes that are on government support, they will tight incomes that are on government support, they will also tight incomes that are on government support, they will also see tight incomes that are on government support, they will also see that support, they will also see that increase support, they will also see that increase to support, they will also see that increase to happen support, they will also see that increase to happen them support, they will also see that increase to happen them keep support, they will also see that increase to happen them keep pace increase to happen them keep pace with increase to happen them keep pace with the increase to happen them keep pace with the cost increase to happen them keep pace with the cost of increase to happen them keep pace with the cost of living. increase to happen them keep pace with the cost of living. It increase to happen them keep pace with the cost of living. It all with the cost of living. It all makes with the cost of living. It all makes a with the cost of living. It all makes a difference. with the cost of living. It all makes a difference. We with the cost of living. It all makes a difference. We know with the cost of living. It all makes a difference. We know from makes a difference. We know from those makes a difference. We know from those changes makes a difference. We know from those changes between makes a difference. We know from those changes between 50-70,000 those changes between 50-70,000 children those changes between 50-70,000 children will those changes between 50-70,000 children will be those changes between 50-70,000 children will be lifted those changes between 50-70,000 children will be lifted out those changes between 50-70,000 children will be lifted out of children will be lifted out of poverty children will be lifted out of poverty and children will be lifted out of poverty and what children will be lifted out of poverty and what could children will be lifted out of poverty and what could be children will be lifted out of poverty and what could be more poverty and what could be more important poverty and what could be more important than poverty and what could be more important than that? poverty and what could be more important than that? Couple poverty and what could be more important than that? Couple that important than that? Couple that alongside, important than that? Couple that alongside, Mr important than that? Couple that alongside, Mr Speaker, important than that? Couple that alongside, Mr Speaker, those alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases to alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases to the alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases to the minute alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases to the minute new alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases to the minute new wage alongside, Mr Speaker, those increases to the minute new wage and increases to the minute new wage and I increases to the minute new wage and I acknowledge increases to the minute new wage and I acknowledge New increases to the minute new wage and I acknowledge New Zealand increases to the minute new wage and I acknowledge New Zealand First. increases to the minute new wage and I acknowledge New Zealand First. It I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was part I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was part of I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was part of their I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was part of their lig I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was part of their lig agreement I acknowledge New Zealand First. It was part of their lig agreement so was part of their lig agreement so we was part of their lig agreement so we will was part of their lig agreement so we will see was part of their lig agreement so we will see that was part of their lig agreement so we will see that go was part of their lig agreement so we will see that go up was part of their lig agreement so we will see that go up once was part of their lig agreement so we will see that go up once again was part of their lig agreement so we will see that go up once again in we will see that go up once again in April we will see that go up once again in April this we will see that go up once again in April this year. we will see that go up once again in April this year. By we will see that go up once again in April this year. By the we will see that go up once again in April this year. By the time we will see that go up once again in April this year. By the time that April this year. By the time that happens, April this year. By the time that happens, those April this year. By the time that happens, those people April this year. By the time that happens, those people on April this year. By the time that happens, those people on a April this year. By the time that happens, those people on a minimum happens, those people on a minimum wage happens, those people on a minimum wage will happens, those people on a minimum wage will be happens, those people on a minimum wage will be $126 happens, those people on a minimum wage will be $126 a happens, those people on a minimum wage will be $126 a week happens, those people on a minimum wage will be $126 a week better happens, those people on a minimum wage will be $126 a week better off wage will be $126 a week better off from wage will be $126 a week better off from the wage will be $126 a week better off from the changes wage will be $126 a week better off from the changes that wage will be $126 a week better off from the changes that we wage will be $126 a week better off from the changes that we as wage will be $126 a week better off from the changes that we as a from the changes that we as a government from the changes that we as a government have from the changes that we as a government have made. from the changes that we as a government have made. <APPLAUSE> government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, I government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, I am government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, I am happy government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, I am happy to government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk government have made. <APPLAUSE> Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the cost Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the cost of Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the cost of living. Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the cost of living. We Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the cost of living. We know Mr Speaker, I am happy to talk about the cost of living. We know that the cost of living. We know that there the cost of living. We know that there are the cost of living. We know that there are too the cost of living. We know that there are too many the cost of living. We know that there are too many New the cost of living. We know that there are too many New Zealand there are too many New Zealand families there are too many New Zealand families who there are too many New Zealand families who feel there are too many New Zealand families who feel the there are too many New Zealand families who feel the strain. families who feel the strain. Dropping families who feel the strain. Dropping things families who feel the strain. Dropping things like families who feel the strain. Dropping things like NCEA families who feel the strain. Dropping things like NCEA fees, Dropping things like NCEA fees, increasing Dropping things like NCEA fees, increasing support Dropping things like NCEA fees, increasing support for Dropping things like NCEA fees, increasing support for schools, Dropping things like NCEA fees, increasing support for schools, so increasing support for schools, so that increasing support for schools, so that they increasing support for schools, so that they don't increasing support for schools, so that they don't have increasing support for schools, so that they don't have for increasing support for schools, so that they don't have for school that they don't have for school donations, that they don't have for school donations, reducing that they don't have for school donations, reducing the that they don't have for school donations, reducing the cost that they don't have for school donations, reducing the cost of donations, reducing the cost of going donations, reducing the cost of going to donations, reducing the cost of going to the donations, reducing the cost of going to the doctor. donations, reducing the cost of going to the doctor. Mr donations, reducing the cost of going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making shoo going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making shoo our going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making shoo our that going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making shoo our that we going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making shoo our that we are going to the doctor. Mr Speaker, making shoo our that we are driving making shoo our that we are driving more making shoo our that we are driving more housing making shoo our that we are driving more housing supply making shoo our that we are driving more housing supply to making shoo our that we are driving more housing supply to try making shoo our that we are driving more housing supply to try and making shoo our that we are driving more housing supply to try and bring more housing supply to try and bring down more housing supply to try and bring down the more housing supply to try and bring down the housing more housing supply to try and bring down the housing costs more housing supply to try and bring down the housing costs in more housing supply to try and bring down the housing costs in the down the housing costs in the private down the housing costs in the private sector down the housing costs in the private sector as down the housing costs in the private sector as well. down the housing costs in the private sector as well. Overall, down the housing costs in the private sector as well. Overall, Mr private sector as well. Overall, Mr Speaker, private sector as well. Overall, Mr Speaker, of private sector as well. Overall, Mr Speaker, of course, private sector as well. Overall, Mr Speaker, of course, making private sector as well. Overall, Mr Speaker, of course, making sure private sector as well. Overall, Mr Speaker, of course, making sure when Speaker, of course, making sure when there Speaker, of course, making sure when there is Speaker, of course, making sure when there is a Speaker, of course, making sure when there is a market Speaker, of course, making sure when there is a market failure Speaker, of course, making sure when there is a market failure and there is a market failure and problem there is a market failure and problem in there is a market failure and problem in the there is a market failure and problem in the market there is a market failure and problem in the market like there is a market failure and problem in the market like fuel there is a market failure and problem in the market like fuel with problem in the market like fuel with do problem in the market like fuel with do something problem in the market like fuel with do something about problem in the market like fuel with do something about it. problem in the market like fuel with do something about it. We problem in the market like fuel with do something about it. We will problem in the market like fuel with do something about it. We will coop do something about it. We will coop doing do something about it. We will coop doing something do something about it. We will coop doing something about do something about it. We will coop doing something about it. do something about it. We will coop doing something about it. We do something about it. We will coop doing something about it. We are doing something about it. We are also doing something about it. We are also proudly doing something about it. We are also proudly a doing something about it. We are also proudly a government doing something about it. We are also proudly a government of doing something about it. We are also proudly a government of health also proudly a government of health and also proudly a government of health and mental also proudly a government of health and mental health also proudly a government of health and mental health and, also proudly a government of health and mental health and, again, also proudly a government of health and mental health and, again, I also proudly a government of health and mental health and, again, I let and mental health and, again, I let the and mental health and, again, I let the numbers and mental health and, again, I let the numbers tell and mental health and, again, I let the numbers tell the and mental health and, again, I let the numbers tell the entire and mental health and, again, I let the numbers tell the entire story. the numbers tell the entire story. First the numbers tell the entire story. First of the numbers tell the entire story. First of all, the numbers tell the entire story. First of all, we the numbers tell the entire story. First of all, we have the numbers tell the entire story. First of all, we have grown the numbers tell the entire story. First of all, we have grown the First of all, we have grown the health First of all, we have grown the health workforce. First of all, we have grown the health workforce. 3,000 First of all, we have grown the health workforce. 3,000 new First of all, we have grown the health workforce. 3,000 new medical health workforce. 3,000 new medical professionals. health workforce. 3,000 new medical professionals. We've health workforce. 3,000 new medical professionals. We've had health workforce. 3,000 new medical professionals. We've had 1, health workforce. 3,000 new medical professionals. We've had 1, 699 professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses and professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses and they professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses and they are professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses and they are paid professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses and they are paid more. professionals. We've had 1, 699 nurses and they are paid more. Of nurses and they are paid more. Of course nurses and they are paid more. Of course with nurses and they are paid more. Of course with the nurses and they are paid more. Of course with the important nurses and they are paid more. Of course with the important settlement course with the important settlement this course with the important settlement this with course with the important settlement this with were course with the important settlement this with were a course with the important settlement this with were a part course with the important settlement this with were a part of. course with the important settlement this with were a part of. 736 this with were a part of. 736 doctors. this with were a part of. 736 doctors. We this with were a part of. 736 doctors. We have this with were a part of. 736 doctors. We have soon this with were a part of. 736 doctors. We have soon an this with were a part of. 736 doctors. We have soon an increase this with were a part of. 736 doctors. We have soon an increase in doctors. We have soon an increase in pharmacy. doctors. We have soon an increase in pharmacy. That doctors. We have soon an increase in pharmacy. That has doctors. We have soon an increase in pharmacy. That has meant doctors. We have soon an increase in pharmacy. That has meant a doctors. We have soon an increase in pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on affect pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on affect there pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on affect there is pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on affect there is more pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on affect there is more funding pharmacy. That has meant a flow-on affect there is more funding for affect there is more funding for affect there is more funding for affect there is more funding for important drugs affect there is more funding for important drugs like affect there is more funding for important drugs like those affect there is more funding for important drugs like those who affect there is more funding for important drugs like those who have important drugs like those who have benefited important drugs like those who have benefited those important drugs like those who have benefited those who important drugs like those who have benefited those who are, important drugs like those who have benefited those who are, Mr important drugs like those who have benefited those who are, Mr Speaker, benefited those who are, Mr Speaker, sadly benefited those who are, Mr Speaker, sadly experiencing benefited those who are, Mr Speaker, sadly experiencing battles benefited those who are, Mr Speaker, sadly experiencing battles with sadly experiencing battles with cancer. sadly experiencing battles with cancer. Many sadly experiencing battles with cancer. Many of sadly experiencing battles with cancer. Many of us sadly experiencing battles with cancer. Many of us will sadly experiencing battles with cancer. Many of us will have sadly experiencing battles with cancer. Many of us will have stories cancer. Many of us will have stories of cancer. Many of us will have stories of people cancer. Many of us will have stories of people stopping cancer. Many of us will have stories of people stopping them cancer. Many of us will have stories of people stopping them on cancer. Many of us will have stories of people stopping them on the cancer. Many of us will have stories of people stopping them on the treat of people stopping them on the treat and of people stopping them on the treat and telling of people stopping them on the treat and telling them of people stopping them on the treat and telling them what of people stopping them on the treat and telling them what a of people stopping them on the treat and telling them what a difference and telling them what a difference it and telling them what a difference it has and telling them what a difference it has made and telling them what a difference it has made and and telling them what a difference it has made and I and telling them what a difference it has made and I am and telling them what a difference it has made and I am one and telling them what a difference it has made and I am one of and telling them what a difference it has made and I am one of them. it has made and I am one of them. Very it has made and I am one of them. Very proudly, it has made and I am one of them. Very proudly, the it has made and I am one of them. Very proudly, the largest it has made and I am one of them. Very proudly, the largest funding Very proudly, the largest funding boost Very proudly, the largest funding boost in Very proudly, the largest funding boost in mental Very proudly, the largest funding boost in mental health Very proudly, the largest funding boost in mental health that Very proudly, the largest funding boost in mental health that this boost in mental health that this country boost in mental health that this country has boost in mental health that this country has ever boost in mental health that this country has ever soon. boost in mental health that this country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht Just country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht Just idea country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht Just idea I country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht Just idea I was country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht Just idea I was looking country has ever soon. <APPLAUSE> Zblncht Just idea I was looking at Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some of Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some of the Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some of the numbers Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some of the numbers and Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some of the numbers and people Zblncht Just idea I was looking at some of the numbers and people who some of the numbers and people who are some of the numbers and people who are already some of the numbers and people who are already benefiting some of the numbers and people who are already benefiting from some of the numbers and people who are already benefiting from those are already benefiting from those front-line are already benefiting from those front-line mental are already benefiting from those front-line mental health are already benefiting from those front-line mental health stories are already benefiting from those front-line mental health stories and front-line mental health stories and services front-line mental health stories and services and front-line mental health stories and services and they front-line mental health stories and services and they are front-line mental health stories and services and they are at front-line mental health stories and services and they are at their front-line mental health stories and services and they are at their GPs' services and they are at their GPs' offices. services and they are at their GPs' offices. They services and they are at their GPs' offices. They are services and they are at their GPs' offices. They are in services and they are at their GPs' offices. They are in schools services and they are at their GPs' offices. They are in schools for offices. They are in schools for kids. offices. They are in schools for kids. They offices. They are in schools for kids. They are offices. They are in schools for kids. They are in offices. They are in schools for kids. They are in our offices. They are in schools for kids. They are in our schools offices. They are in schools for kids. They are in our schools for kids. They are in our schools for our kids. They are in our schools for our young kids. They are in our schools for our young people. kids. They are in our schools for our young people. We kids. They are in our schools for our young people. We are kids. They are in our schools for our young people. We are making kids. They are in our schools for our young people. We are making sure our young people. We are making sure that our young people. We are making sure that wherever our young people. We are making sure that wherever someone our young people. We are making sure that wherever someone is, our young people. We are making sure that wherever someone is, help our young people. We are making sure that wherever someone is, help is that wherever someone is, help is not that wherever someone is, help is not far that wherever someone is, help is not far away. that wherever someone is, help is not far away. Whether that wherever someone is, help is not far away. Whether it that wherever someone is, help is not far away. Whether it is that wherever someone is, help is not far away. Whether it is picking not far away. Whether it is picking up not far away. Whether it is picking up tele-health not far away. Whether it is picking up tele-health services not far away. Whether it is picking up tele-health services or not far away. Whether it is picking up tele-health services or visiting up tele-health services or visiting their up tele-health services or visiting their local up tele-health services or visiting their local doctor up tele-health services or visiting their local doctor because up tele-health services or visiting their local doctor because the up tele-health services or visiting their local doctor because the need their local doctor because the need is their local doctor because the need is so their local doctor because the need is so great. their local doctor because the need is so great. There their local doctor because the need is so great. There is their local doctor because the need is so great. There is more their local doctor because the need is so great. There is more work to is so great. There is more work to do. is so great. There is more work to do. The is so great. There is more work to do. The suicide is so great. There is more work to do. The suicide prevention is so great. There is more work to do. The suicide prevention office do. The suicide prevention office will do. The suicide prevention office will be do. The suicide prevention office will be key. do. The suicide prevention office will be key. We do. The suicide prevention office will be key. We are do. The suicide prevention office will be key. We are currently do. The suicide prevention office will be key. We are currently going will be key. We are currently going out will be key. We are currently going out with will be key. We are currently going out with RFPs will be key. We are currently going out with RFPs for will be key. We are currently going out with RFPs for our will be key. We are currently going out with RFPs for our Pacific will be key. We are currently going out with RFPs for our Pacific and out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori services out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori services and out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori services and this out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori services and this year out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori services and this year we out with RFPs for our Pacific and Maori services and this year we will Maori services and this year we will keep Maori services and this year we will keep seeing Maori services and this year we will keep seeing the, Maori services and this year we will keep seeing the, pannion Maori services and this year we will keep seeing the, pannion of Maori services and this year we will keep seeing the, pannion of those keep seeing the, pannion of those front-line keep seeing the, pannion of those front-line services keep seeing the, pannion of those front-line services this keep seeing the, pannion of those front-line services this we keep seeing the, pannion of those front-line services this we are keep seeing the, pannion of those front-line services this we are so front-line services this we are so proud front-line services this we are so proud of. front-line services this we are so proud of. Mr front-line services this we are so proud of. Mr Speaker, front-line services this we are so proud of. Mr Speaker, again, front-line services this we are so proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no matter proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no matter where proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no matter where we proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no matter where we turn, proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no matter where we turn, health, proud of. Mr Speaker, again, no matter where we turn, health, mental matter where we turn, health, mental health, matter where we turn, health, mental health, every matter where we turn, health, mental health, every part matter where we turn, health, mental health, every part of matter where we turn, health, mental health, every part of the matter where we turn, health, mental health, every part of the system matter where we turn, health, mental health, every part of the system we health, every part of the system we have health, every part of the system we have found health, every part of the system we have found need. health, every part of the system we have found need. I health, every part of the system we have found need. I find health, every part of the system we have found need. I find it health, every part of the system we have found need. I find it ironic health, every part of the system we have found need. I find it ironic to have found need. I find it ironic to see have found need. I find it ironic to see the have found need. I find it ironic to see the other have found need. I find it ironic to see the other part have found need. I find it ironic to see the other part so have found need. I find it ironic to see the other part so vocal have found need. I find it ironic to see the other part so vocal on have found need. I find it ironic to see the other part so vocal on this see the other part so vocal on this issue. see the other part so vocal on this issue. They see the other part so vocal on this issue. They will see the other part so vocal on this issue. They will point see the other part so vocal on this issue. They will point to see the other part so vocal on this issue. They will point to some see the other part so vocal on this issue. They will point to some of issue. They will point to some of the issue. They will point to some of the extra issue. They will point to some of the extra work issue. They will point to some of the extra work we issue. They will point to some of the extra work we need issue. They will point to some of the extra work we need to issue. They will point to some of the extra work we need to do issue. They will point to some of the extra work we need to do because the extra work we need to do because where the extra work we need to do because where ever the extra work we need to do because where ever we the extra work we need to do because where ever we have the extra work we need to do because where ever we have turned the extra work we need to do because where ever we have turned there the extra work we need to do because where ever we have turned there have where ever we have turned there have been where ever we have turned there have been problem where ever we have turned there have been problem these where ever we have turned there have been problem these we where ever we have turned there have been problem these we need where ever we have turned there have been problem these we need to been problem these we need to address. been problem these we need to address. Next, been problem these we need to address. Next, Mr been problem these we need to address. Next, Mr Speaker, been problem these we need to address. Next, Mr Speaker, of been problem these we need to address. Next, Mr Speaker, of course address. Next, Mr Speaker, of course is address. Next, Mr Speaker, of course is dealing address. Next, Mr Speaker, of course is dealing with address. Next, Mr Speaker, of course is dealing with the address. Next, Mr Speaker, of course is dealing with the structural is dealing with the structural issues is dealing with the structural issues because is dealing with the structural issues because of is dealing with the structural issues because of course is dealing with the structural issues because of course it is dealing with the structural issues because of course it is is dealing with the structural issues because of course it is not issues because of course it is not just issues because of course it is not just enough issues because of course it is not just enough for issues because of course it is not just enough for us issues because of course it is not just enough for us to issues because of course it is not just enough for us to say issues because of course it is not just enough for us to say that issues because of course it is not just enough for us to say that we just enough for us to say that we deal just enough for us to say that we deal with just enough for us to say that we deal with these just enough for us to say that we deal with these things just enough for us to say that we deal with these things down just enough for us to say that we deal with these things down track. deal with these things down track. We deal with these things down track. We need deal with these things down track. We need to deal with these things down track. We need to make deal with these things down track. We need to make we deal with these things down track. We need to make we have deal with these things down track. We need to make we have an deal with these things down track. We need to make we have an economy We need to make we have an economy that We need to make we have an economy that is We need to make we have an economy that is supporting We need to make we have an economy that is supporting everyone, We need to make we have an economy that is supporting everyone, that We need to make we have an economy that is supporting everyone, that is that is supporting everyone, that is delivering that is supporting everyone, that is delivering prosperity that is supporting everyone, that is delivering prosperity for that is supporting everyone, that is delivering prosperity for even that is supporting everyone, that is delivering prosperity for even and delivering prosperity for even and it delivering prosperity for even and it has delivering prosperity for even and it has been delivering prosperity for even and it has been a delivering prosperity for even and it has been a mantra delivering prosperity for even and it has been a mantra you delivering prosperity for even and it has been a mantra you will delivering prosperity for even and it has been a mantra you will have it has been a mantra you will have heard it has been a mantra you will have heard from it has been a mantra you will have heard from the it has been a mantra you will have heard from the Minister it has been a mantra you will have heard from the Minister of it has been a mantra you will have heard from the Minister of Finance heard from the Minister of Finance consist heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. I heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. I am heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. I am happy heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. I am happy to heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. I am happy to let heard from the Minister of Finance consist tptly. I am happy to let the consist tptly. I am happy to let the numbers consist tptly. I am happy to let the numbers speak consist tptly. I am happy to let the numbers speak for consist tptly. I am happy to let the numbers speak for themselves. consist tptly. I am happy to let the numbers speak for themselves. We consist tptly. I am happy to let the numbers speak for themselves. We are numbers speak for themselves. We are a numbers speak for themselves. We are a government numbers speak for themselves. We are a government that numbers speak for themselves. We are a government that has numbers speak for themselves. We are a government that has delivered numbers speak for themselves. We are a government that has delivered GDP a government that has delivered GDP growth a government that has delivered GDP growth of a government that has delivered GDP growth of 2. a government that has delivered GDP growth of 2. 8%. a government that has delivered GDP growth of 2. 8%. When a government that has delivered GDP growth of 2. 8%. When you a government that has delivered GDP growth of 2. 8%. When you look growth of 2. 8%. When you look around growth of 2. 8%. When you look around us, growth of 2. 8%. When you look around us, Mr growth of 2. 8%. When you look around us, Mr Speaker, growth of 2. 8%. When you look around us, Mr Speaker, others growth of 2. 8%. When you look around us, Mr Speaker, others are around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling on around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling on hard around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling on hard times around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling on hard times and around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling on hard times and there around us, Mr Speaker, others are falling on hard times and there is falling on hard times and there is no falling on hard times and there is no denying falling on hard times and there is no denying it falling on hard times and there is no denying it has falling on hard times and there is no denying it has had falling on hard times and there is no denying it has had an falling on hard times and there is no denying it has had an impact falling on hard times and there is no denying it has had an impact for no denying it has had an impact for us, no denying it has had an impact for us, but no denying it has had an impact for us, but when no denying it has had an impact for us, but when you no denying it has had an impact for us, but when you take no denying it has had an impact for us, but when you take into no denying it has had an impact for us, but when you take into account us, but when you take into account the us, but when you take into account the net us, but when you take into account the net average us, but when you take into account the net average with us, but when you take into account the net average with had us, but when you take into account the net average with had under us, but when you take into account the net average with had under the the net average with had under the national the net average with had under the national government the net average with had under the national government the the net average with had under the national government the average the net average with had under the national government the average GDP national government the average GDP growth national government the average GDP growth was national government the average GDP growth was 2.1%, national government the average GDP growth was 2.1%, I national government the average GDP growth was 2.1%, I fell national government the average GDP growth was 2.1%, I fell confident growth was 2.1%, I fell confident this growth was 2.1%, I fell confident national growth was 2.1%, I fell confident this we are growth was 2.1%, I fell confident this we are doing growth was 2.1%, I fell confident this we are doing well. this we are doing well. Unemployment, this we are doing well. Unemployment, Mr this we are doing well. Unemployment, Mr Speaker, this we are doing well. Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of this we are doing well. Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Reserve Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Reserve Bank Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Reserve Bank would Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Reserve Bank would tell Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Reserve Bank would tell you Unemployment, Mr Speaker, of course the Reserve Bank would tell you we the Reserve Bank would tell you we are the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at full the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at full employment the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at full employment at the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at full employment at 4%. the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at full employment at 4%. It the Reserve Bank would tell you we are at full employment at 4%. It is are at full employment at 4%. It is a are at full employment at 4%. It is a tight are at full employment at 4%. It is a tight labour are at full employment at 4%. It is a tight labour market. are at full employment at 4%. It is a tight labour market. Again, are at full employment at 4%. It is a tight labour market. Again, Mr are at full employment at 4%. It is a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll to a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll to what a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll to what with a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll to what with inher a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll to what with inher writted a tight labour market. Again, Mr Mr, roll to what with inher writted 4. roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% when roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% when we roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% when we came roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% when we came into roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% when we came into office. roll to what with inher writted 4. 8% when we came into office. The 8% when we came into office. The average 8% when we came into office. The average hourly 8% when we came into office. The average hourly wage 8% when we came into office. The average hourly wage sitting 8% when we came into office. The average hourly wage sitting at 8% when we came into office. The average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In that average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In that government average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In that government as average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In that government as first average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In that government as first term average hourly wage sitting at 3.6%. In that government as first term it In that government as first term it was In that government as first term it was roughly In that government as first term it was roughly 2.1% In that government as first term it was roughly 2.1% with In that government as first term it was roughly 2.1% with were In that government as first term it was roughly 2.1% with were seeing was roughly 2.1% with were seeing those was roughly 2.1% with were seeing those increases was roughly 2.1% with were seeing those increases in was roughly 2.1% with were seeing those increases in hourly was roughly 2.1% with were seeing those increases in hourly wages. was roughly 2.1% with were seeing those increases in hourly wages. Net those increases in hourly wages. Net dependent, those increases in hourly wages. Net dependent, 21%s those increases in hourly wages. Net dependent, 21%s very those increases in hourly wages. Net dependent, 21%s very sus those increases in hourly wages. Net dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% those increases in hourly wages. Net dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the last dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the last government. dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the last government. We dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the last government. We have dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the last government. We have soon dependent, 21%s very sus 22.9% under the last government. We have soon 13 the last government. We have soon 13 billion the last government. We have soon 13 billion in the last government. We have soon 13 billion in surpluses the last government. We have soon 13 billion in surpluses in the last government. We have soon 13 billion in surpluses in our the last government. We have soon 13 billion in surpluses in our first billion in surpluses in our first two billion in surpluses in our first two years billion in surpluses in our first two years and billion in surpluses in our first two years and 11 billion in surpluses in our first two years and 11 billion billion in surpluses in our first two years and 11 billion in two years and 11 billion in surpluses two years and 11 billion in surpluses in two years and 11 billion in surpluses in our two years and 11 billion in surpluses in our next two years and 11 billion in surpluses in our next five. two years and 11 billion in surpluses in our next five. I two years and 11 billion in surpluses in our next five. I am surpluses in our next five. I am proud surpluses in our next five. I am proud of surpluses in our next five. I am proud of this surpluses in our next five. I am proud of this government surpluses in our next five. I am proud of this government as surpluses in our next five. I am proud of this government as record proud of this government as record when proud of this government as record when it proud of this government as record when it comes proud of this government as record when it comes to proud of this government as record when it comes to the proud of this government as record when it comes to the management proud of this government as record when it comes to the management of when it comes to the management of the when it comes to the management of the economy, when it comes to the management of the economy, but when it comes to the management of the economy, but more when it comes to the management of the economy, but more than when it comes to the management of the economy, but more than just when it comes to the management of the economy, but more than just the the economy, but more than just the numbers. the economy, but more than just the numbers. I the economy, but more than just the numbers. I am the economy, but more than just the numbers. I am proud the economy, but more than just the numbers. I am proud that the economy, but more than just the numbers. I am proud that we the economy, but more than just the numbers. I am proud that we have numbers. I am proud that we have soon numbers. I am proud that we have soon unemployment numbers. I am proud that we have soon unemployment go numbers. I am proud that we have soon unemployment go down numbers. I am proud that we have soon unemployment go down in soon unemployment go down in Northland, soon unemployment go down in Northland, Bay soon unemployment go down in Northland, Bay of soon unemployment go down in Northland, Bay of Plenty, soon unemployment go down in Northland, Bay of Plenty, Gisborne, Northland, Bay of Plenty, Gisborne, Hawke's Northland, Bay of Plenty, Gisborne, Hawke's Bay, Northland, Bay of Plenty, Gisborne, Hawke's Bay, Otago, Northland, Bay of Plenty, Gisborne, Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland Northland, Bay of Plenty, Gisborne, Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland and Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland and that Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland and that is Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland and that is because Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland and that is because of Hawke's Bay, Otago, Southland and that is because of deliberate that is because of deliberate environment. that is because of deliberate environment. 530PG that is because of deliberate environment. 530PG projects that is because of deliberate environment. 530PG projects across environment. 530PG projects across the environment. 530PG projects across the country environment. 530PG projects across the country making environment. 530PG projects across the country making a environment. 530PG projects across the country making a huge the country making a huge difference. the country making a huge difference. Mr the country making a huge difference. Mr Speaker, the country making a huge difference. Mr Speaker, again, the country making a huge difference. Mr Speaker, again, the difference. Mr Speaker, again, the words difference. Mr Speaker, again, the words tell difference. Mr Speaker, again, the words tell a difference. Mr Speaker, again, the words tell a story. difference. Mr Speaker, again, the words tell a story. Gisborne difference. Mr Speaker, again, the words tell a story. Gisborne in words tell a story. Gisborne in Hawke's words tell a story. Gisborne in Hawke's Bay words tell a story. Gisborne in Hawke's Bay we words tell a story. Gisborne in Hawke's Bay we are words tell a story. Gisborne in Hawke's Bay we are seeing Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment rates Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment rates as Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment rates as high Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment rates as high as Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment rates as high as 8% Hawke's Bay we are seeing unemployment rates as high as 8% to unemployment rates as high as 8% to 4.1%. unemployment rates as high as 8% to 4.1%. That unemployment rates as high as 8% to 4.1%. That is unemployment rates as high as 8% to 4.1%. That is a unemployment rates as high as 8% to 4.1%. That is a huge unemployment rates as high as 8% to 4.1%. That is a huge difference. 4.1%. That is a huge difference. <APPLAUSE> <APPLAUSE> Again, <APPLAUSE> Again, region <APPLAUSE> Again, region until <APPLAUSE> Again, region until growth <APPLAUSE> Again, region until growth sits Again, region until growth sits alongside Again, region until growth sits alongside our Again, region until growth sits alongside our plan Again, region until growth sits alongside our plan for Again, region until growth sits alongside our plan for trade alongside our plan for trade diversification. alongside our plan for trade diversification. It alongside our plan for trade diversification. It sits alongside our plan for trade diversification. It sits alongside diversification. It sits alongside diversification. It sits alongside diversification. It sits alongside our investment diversification. It sits alongside our investment of diversification. It sits alongside our investment of research diversification. It sits alongside our investment of research and our investment of research and development our investment of research and development and our investment of research and development and it our investment of research and development and it is our investment of research and development and it is about our investment of research and development and it is about driving, development and it is about driving, not development and it is about driving, not just development and it is about driving, not just any development and it is about driving, not just any job, development and it is about driving, not just any job, but development and it is about driving, not just any job, but don't not just any job, but don't high-wage not just any job, but don't high-wage jobs not just any job, but don't high-wage jobs for not just any job, but don't high-wage jobs for our not just any job, but don't high-wage jobs for our New high-wage jobs for our New Zealanders high-wage jobs for our New Zealanders and high-wage jobs for our New Zealanders and we high-wage jobs for our New Zealanders and we are high-wage jobs for our New Zealanders and we are delivering high-wage jobs for our New Zealanders and we are delivering on Zealanders and we are delivering on that. Zealanders and we are delivering on that. Of Zealanders and we are delivering on that. Of course, Zealanders and we are delivering on that. Of course, Mr Zealanders and we are delivering on that. Of course, Mr Speaker, that. Of course, Mr Speaker, underpinning that. Of course, Mr Speaker, underpinning all that. Of course, Mr Speaker, underpinning all of that. Of course, Mr Speaker, underpinning all of this that. Of course, Mr Speaker, underpinning all of this is that. Of course, Mr Speaker, underpinning all of this is the underpinning all of this is the vine. underpinning all of this is the vine. None underpinning all of this is the vine. None of underpinning all of this is the vine. None of this underpinning all of this is the vine. None of this matters underpinning all of this is the vine. None of this matters we underpinning all of this is the vine. None of this matters we don't vine. None of this matters we don't have vine. None of this matters we don't have a vine. None of this matters we don't have a planet vine. None of this matters we don't have a planet that vine. None of this matters we don't have a planet that we vine. None of this matters we don't have a planet that we can vine. None of this matters we don't have a planet that we can sustain have a planet that we can sustain ourselves have a planet that we can sustain ourselves on. have a planet that we can sustain ourselves on. When have a planet that we can sustain ourselves on. When with have a planet that we can sustain ourselves on. When with came have a planet that we can sustain ourselves on. When with came into ourselves on. When with came into office, ourselves on. When with came into office, there ourselves on. When with came into office, there was ourselves on. When with came into office, there was no ourselves on. When with came into office, there was no plan ourselves on. When with came into office, there was no plan for office, there was no plan for climate office, there was no plan for climate action. office, there was no plan for climate action. There office, there was no plan for climate action. There was office, there was no plan for climate action. There was no office, there was no plan for climate action. There was no plan. climate action. There was no plan. We climate action. There was no plan. We had climate action. There was no plan. We had 4,000 climate action. There was no plan. We had 4,000 native climate action. There was no plan. We had 4,000 native species climate action. There was no plan. We had 4,000 native species at climate action. There was no plan. We had 4,000 native species at risk We had 4,000 native species at risk of We had 4,000 native species at risk of extinction We had 4,000 native species at risk of extinction or We had 4,000 native species at risk of extinction or threatened. We had 4,000 native species at risk of extinction or threatened. We've of extinction or threatened. We've had of extinction or threatened. We've had a of extinction or threatened. We've had a record of extinction or threatened. We've had a record boost of extinction or threatened. We've had a record boost into of extinction or threatened. We've had a record boost into conservation had a record boost into conservation over had a record boost into conservation over a had a record boost into conservation over a small had a record boost into conservation over a small space had a record boost into conservation over a small space of had a record boost into conservation over a small space of time. had a record boost into conservation over a small space of time. We had a record boost into conservation over a small space of time. We a had a record boost into conservation over a small space of time. We a had over a small space of time. We a had a over a small space of time. We a had a list over a small space of time. We a had a list on over a small space of time. We a had a list on climate over a small space of time. We a had a list on climate change over a small space of time. We a had a list on climate change that over a small space of time. We a had a list on climate change that is a list on climate change that is almost a list on climate change that is almost too a list on climate change that is almost too long a list on climate change that is almost too long for a list on climate change that is almost too long for many a list on climate change that is almost too long for many to a list on climate change that is almost too long for many to read a list on climate change that is almost too long for many to read in almost too long for many to read in 1 almost too long for many to read in 1 minute almost too long for many to read in 1 minute and almost too long for many to read in 1 minute and 23 almost too long for many to read in 1 minute and 23 seconds. almost too long for many to read in 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho almost too long for many to read in 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about almost too long for many to read in 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a quick 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a quick go. 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a quick go. Zero 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a quick go. Zero carbon 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a quick go. Zero carbon act 1 minute and 23 seconds. Ho about I have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have reformed have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have reformed the have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have reformed the ETS, have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have reformed the ETS, we have a quick go. Zero carbon act we have reformed the ETS, we have have reformed the ETS, we have worked have reformed the ETS, we have worked with have reformed the ETS, we have worked with farmers have reformed the ETS, we have worked with farmers on have reformed the ETS, we have worked with farmers on a worked with farmers on a world-breaking worked with farmers on a world-breaking rerd worked with farmers on a world-breaking rerd new worked with farmers on a world-breaking rerd new agreement world-breaking rerd new agreement dealing world-breaking rerd new agreement dealing with world-breaking rerd new agreement dealing with pictions. world-breaking rerd new agreement dealing with pictions. Farms world-breaking rerd new agreement dealing with pictions. Farms have dealing with pictions. Farms have been dealing with pictions. Farms have been built. dealing with pictions. Farms have been built. The dealing with pictions. Farms have been built. The new dealing with pictions. Farms have been built. The new energy dealing with pictions. Farms have been built. The new energy research been built. The new energy research centre been built. The new energy research centre in been built. The new energy research centre in Taranaki. been built. The new energy research centre in Taranaki. Of been built. The new energy research centre in Taranaki. Of course been built. The new energy research centre in Taranaki. Of course we been built. The new energy research centre in Taranaki. Of course we are centre in Taranaki. Of course we are switching centre in Taranaki. Of course we are switching our centre in Taranaki. Of course we are switching our public centre in Taranaki. Of course we are switching our public buildings centre in Taranaki. Of course we are switching our public buildings to switching our public buildings to clean switching our public buildings to clean energy switching our public buildings to clean energy and switching our public buildings to clean energy and the switching our public buildings to clean energy and the upgrades switching our public buildings to clean energy and the upgrades alone clean energy and the upgrades alone and clean energy and the upgrades alone and public clean energy and the upgrades alone and public transport clean energy and the upgrades alone and public transport are clean energy and the upgrades alone and public transport are worth clean energy and the upgrades alone and public transport are worth $5.3 and public transport are worth $5.3 billion and public transport are worth $5.3 billion for and public transport are worth $5.3 billion for rail, and public transport are worth $5.3 billion for rail, walking and public transport are worth $5.3 billion for rail, walking and billion for rail, walking and cycling billion for rail, walking and cycling options. billion for rail, walking and cycling options. Mr billion for rail, walking and cycling options. Mr Speaker, billion for rail, walking and cycling options. Mr Speaker, next cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste and cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste and next cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste and next is cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste and next is fresh cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste and next is fresh water. cycling options. Mr Speaker, next waste and next is fresh water. We waste and next is fresh water. We have waste and next is fresh water. We have more waste and next is fresh water. We have more to waste and next is fresh water. We have more to do. waste and next is fresh water. We have more to do. Finally, waste and next is fresh water. We have more to do. Finally, and waste and next is fresh water. We have more to do. Finally, and the have more to do. Finally, and the member, have more to do. Finally, and the member, the have more to do. Finally, and the member, the Leader have more to do. Finally, and the member, the Leader of have more to do. Finally, and the member, the Leader of the have more to do. Finally, and the member, the Leader of the Opposition member, the Leader of the Opposition will member, the Leader of the Opposition will hate member, the Leader of the Opposition will hate this member, the Leader of the Opposition will hate this - member, the Leader of the Opposition will hate this - 1,800 member, the Leader of the Opposition will hate this - 1,800 new member, the Leader of the Opposition will hate this - 1,800 new police will hate this - 1,800 new police officers. will hate this - 1,800 new police officers. <CHEERING> officers. <CHEERING> 500 officers. <CHEERING> 500 to officers. <CHEERING> 500 to support officers. <CHEERING> 500 to support our officers. <CHEERING> 500 to support our small officers. <CHEERING> 500 to support our small business 500 to support our small business owners 500 to support our small business owners and, 500 to support our small business owners and, Mr 500 to support our small business owners and, Mr Speaker, 500 to support our small business owners and, Mr Speaker, it 500 to support our small business owners and, Mr Speaker, it is 500 to support our small business owners and, Mr Speaker, it is all owners and, Mr Speaker, it is all about owners and, Mr Speaker, it is all about prevention owners and, Mr Speaker, it is all about prevention and owners and, Mr Speaker, it is all about prevention and supporting owners and, Mr Speaker, it is all about prevention and supporting the about prevention and supporting the safety about prevention and supporting the safety of about prevention and supporting the safety of New about prevention and supporting the safety of New Zealanders. about prevention and supporting the safety of New Zealanders. Finally, safety of New Zealanders. Finally, we safety of New Zealanders. Finally, we are safety of New Zealanders. Finally, we are the safety of New Zealanders. Finally, we are the government safety of New Zealanders. Finally, we are the government of we are the government of infrastructure. we are the government of infrastructure. We we are the government of infrastructure. We are we are the government of infrastructure. We are the infrastructure. We are the government infrastructure. We are the government of infrastructure. We are the government of housing. infrastructure. We are the government of housing. We infrastructure. We are the government of housing. We are infrastructure. We are the government of housing. We are the government of housing. We are the government government of housing. We are the government of government of housing. We are the government of family government of housing. We are the government of family and government of housing. We are the government of family and child government of family and child wellbeing government of family and child wellbeing and government of family and child wellbeing and mental government of family and child wellbeing and mental health government of family and child wellbeing and mental health and government of family and child wellbeing and mental health and the wellbeing and mental health and the government wellbeing and mental health and the government for wellbeing and mental health and the government for the wellbeing and mental health and the government for the environment. wellbeing and mental health and the government for the environment. We government for the environment. We are government for the environment. We are a government for the environment. We are a government government for the environment. We are a government of government for the environment. We are a government of progress. government for the environment. We are a government of progress. There are a government of progress. There is are a government of progress. There is more are a government of progress. There is more to are a government of progress. There is more to do. are a government of progress. There is more to do. After are a government of progress. There is more to do. After nine are a government of progress. There is more to do. After nine years are a government of progress. There is more to do. After nine years and is more to do. After nine years and blue is more to do. After nine years and blue smoke is more to do. After nine years and blue smoke and is more to do. After nine years and blue smoke and darkness, is more to do. After nine years and blue smoke and darkness, there is more to do. After nine years and blue smoke and darkness, there is blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty more blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty more to blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty more to do, blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty more to do, but, blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty more to do, but, Mr blue smoke and darkness, there is plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this year plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this year is plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this year is the plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this year is the chance plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this year is the chance for plenty more to do, but, Mr Speaker, this year is the chance for New this year is the chance for New Zealanders this year is the chance for New Zealanders to this year is the chance for New Zealanders to have this year is the chance for New Zealanders to have their this year is the chance for New Zealanders to have their say this year is the chance for New Zealanders to have their say in Zealanders to have their say in making Zealanders to have their say in making sure Zealanders to have their say in making sure we, Zealanders to have their say in making sure we, as Zealanders to have their say in making sure we, as a Zealanders to have their say in making sure we, as a government, making sure we, as a government, continue making sure we, as a government, continue to making sure we, as a government, continue to get making sure we, as a government, continue to get the making sure we, as a government, continue to get the job making sure we, as a government, continue to get the job done. continue to get the job done. <CHEERING> Order. Order. <CHEERING Order. <CHEERING AND Order. <CHEERING AND APPLAUSE> The The request The request is The request is that The request is that the The request is that the position The request is that the position be The request is that the position be agreed The request is that the position be agreed to. The request is that the position be agreed to. The The request is that the position be agreed to. The Leader The request is that the position be agreed to. The Leader of The request is that the position be agreed to. The Leader of the agreed to. The Leader of the Opposition. agreed to. The Leader of the Opposition. Mr agreed to. The Leader of the Opposition. Mr Speaker, agreed to. The Leader of the Opposition. Mr Speaker, I agreed to. The Leader of the Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move agreed to. The Leader of the Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that all Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that all the Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that all the words Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that all the words after Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that all the words after "that" Opposition. Mr Speaker, I move that all the words after "that" be all the words after "that" be deleted all the words after "that" be deleted and all the words after "that" be deleted and have all the words after "that" be deleted and have placed all the words after "that" be deleted and have placed with all the words after "that" be deleted and have placed with "this deleted and have placed with "this House deleted and have placed with "this House has deleted and have placed with "this House has no deleted and have placed with "this House has no confidence deleted and have placed with "this House has no confidence in deleted and have placed with "this House has no confidence in the House has no confidence in the Labour-led House has no confidence in the Labour-led government". House has no confidence in the Labour-led government". Because, House has no confidence in the Labour-led government". Because, in Labour-led government". Because, in just Labour-led government". Because, in just two Labour-led government". Because, in just two short Labour-led government". Because, in just two short years, Labour-led government". Because, in just two short years, it Labour-led government". Because, in just two short years, it has Labour-led government". Because, in just two short years, it has plunged just two short years, it has plunged now just two short years, it has plunged now into just two short years, it has plunged now into deficit just two short years, it has plunged now into deficit and just two short years, it has plunged now into deficit and failed just two short years, it has plunged now into deficit and failed to now into deficit and failed to deliver now into deficit and failed to deliver on now into deficit and failed to deliver on any now into deficit and failed to deliver on any of now into deficit and failed to deliver on any of it now into deficit and failed to deliver on any of it promises. now into deficit and failed to deliver on any of it promises. Mr deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, I deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, I can deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, I can see deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, I can see the deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, I can see the relief deliver on any of it promises. Mr Speaker, I can see the relief on Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Ardern Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Ardern as Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Ardern as face Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Ardern as face that Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Ardern as face that that Speaker, I can see the relief on Jacinda Ardern as face that that is Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going to Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going to be Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going to be her Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going to be her last Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going to be her last PM Jacinda Ardern as face that that is going to be her last PM statement. going to be her last PM statement. Actually, going to be her last PM statement. Actually, I going to be her last PM statement. Actually, I am going to be her last PM statement. Actually, I am not going to be her last PM statement. Actually, I am not sure going to be her last PM statement. Actually, I am not sure where going to be her last PM statement. Actually, I am not sure where the Actually, I am not sure where the relief Actually, I am not sure where the relief is Actually, I am not sure where the relief is more Actually, I am not sure where the relief is more palpable Actually, I am not sure where the relief is more palpable on Actually, I am not sure where the relief is more palpable on her Actually, I am not sure where the relief is more palpable on her face relief is more palpable on her face or relief is more palpable on her face or her relief is more palpable on her face or her Caucasus, relief is more palpable on her face or her Caucasus, Mr relief is more palpable on her face or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. relief is more palpable on her face or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, relief is more palpable on her face or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be fair, or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be fair, after or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be fair, after almost or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be fair, after almost three or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be fair, after almost three years or her Caucasus, Mr Speaker. But, to be fair, after almost three years - be fair, after almost three years - well, be fair, after almost three years - well, we be fair, after almost three years - well, we will be fair, after almost three years - well, we will see be fair, after almost three years - well, we will see on be fair, after almost three years - well, we will see on the be fair, after almost three years - well, we will see on the TV be fair, after almost three years - well, we will see on the TV son be fair, after almost three years - well, we will see on the TV son cool well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin Davis, well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin Davis, I well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin Davis, I would well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin Davis, I would say well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin Davis, I would say rather well, we will see on the TV son cool Vin Davis, I would say rather well, Vin Davis, I would say rather well, Mr Vin Davis, I would say rather well, Mr Speaker. Vin Davis, I would say rather well, Mr Speaker. After Vin Davis, I would say rather well, Mr Speaker. After almost Vin Davis, I would say rather well, Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors of Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors of dithering Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors of dithering and Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors of dithering and ex Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors of dithering and ex permenting Mr Speaker. After almost threeiors of dithering and ex permenting and of dithering and ex permenting and mismaining of dithering and ex permenting and mismaining the of dithering and ex permenting and mismaining the economy of dithering and ex permenting and mismaining the economy and of dithering and ex permenting and mismaining the economy and failing mismaining the economy and failing to mismaining the economy and failing to deliver mismaining the economy and failing to deliver on mismaining the economy and failing to deliver on her mismaining the economy and failing to deliver on her promises, mismaining the economy and failing to deliver on her promises, New to deliver on her promises, New Zealanders to deliver on her promises, New Zealanders can to deliver on her promises, New Zealanders can finally to deliver on her promises, New Zealanders can finally see to deliver on her promises, New Zealanders can finally see light to deliver on her promises, New Zealanders can finally see light at Zealanders can finally see light at the Zealanders can finally see light at the end Zealanders can finally see light at the end of Zealanders can finally see light at the end of the Zealanders can finally see light at the end of the tunnel. Zealanders can finally see light at the end of the tunnel. Actually, the end of the tunnel. Actually, they the end of the tunnel. Actually, they can't the end of the tunnel. Actually, they can't because the end of the tunnel. Actually, they can't because Labour the end of the tunnel. Actually, they can't because Labour cancelled they can't because Labour cancelled it. they can't because Labour cancelled it. But they can't because Labour cancelled it. But don't they can't because Labour cancelled it. But don't worry they can't because Labour cancelled it. But don't worry because they can't because Labour cancelled it. But don't worry because National it. But don't worry because National gets it. But don't worry because National gets things it. But don't worry because National gets things done it. But don't worry because National gets things done and it. But don't worry because National gets things done and we it. But don't worry because National gets things done and we will it. But don't worry because National gets things done and we will build gets things done and we will build it, gets things done and we will build it, Mr gets things done and we will build it, Mr Speaker! gets things done and we will build it, Mr Speaker! We gets things done and we will build it, Mr Speaker! We won't gets things done and we will build it, Mr Speaker! We won't have gets things done and we will build it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear any it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear any more it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear any more next it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear any more next year it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear any more next year hol it, Mr Speaker! We won't have to hear any more next year hol low hear any more next year hol low statements hear any more next year hol low statements from hear any more next year hol low statements from the hear any more next year hol low statements from the PM. hear any more next year hol low statements from the PM. She's hear any more next year hol low statements from the PM. She's not statements from the PM. She's not going statements from the PM. She's not going to statements from the PM. She's not going to have statements from the PM. She's not going to have to statements from the PM. She's not going to have to stand statements from the PM. She's not going to have to stand up statements from the PM. She's not going to have to stand up and statements from the PM. She's not going to have to stand up and make going to have to stand up and make empty going to have to stand up and make empty promises going to have to stand up and make empty promises about going to have to stand up and make empty promises about building empty promises about building 100,000 empty promises about building 100,000 Kiwi empty promises about building 100,000 Kiwi build empty promises about building 100,000 Kiwi build houses empty promises about building 100,000 Kiwi build houses in empty promises about building 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and just 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and just hop 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and just hop for 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and just hop for the 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and just hop for the best. 100,000 Kiwi build houses in 10 years and just hop for the best. By years and just hop for the best. By the years and just hop for the best. By the way, years and just hop for the best. By the way, did years and just hop for the best. By the way, did she years and just hop for the best. By the way, did she mention years and just hop for the best. By the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: No! the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: No! Is the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: No! Is it the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: No! Is it in the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: No! Is it in this the way, did she mention KiwiBuild? ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! I ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! I find ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! I find that ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! I find that staggering. ALL: No! Is it in this document? ALL: No! I find that staggering. The ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says "know ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says "know us ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says "know us by ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says "know us by our ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says "know us by our deeds". ALL: No! I find that staggering. The PM says "know us by our deeds". How PM says "know us by our deeds". How many PM says "know us by our deeds". How many KiwiBuild PM says "know us by our deeds". How many KiwiBuild houses PM says "know us by our deeds". How many KiwiBuild houses have PM says "know us by our deeds". How many KiwiBuild houses have think many KiwiBuild houses have think built? many KiwiBuild houses have think built? 200 many KiwiBuild houses have think built? 200 or many KiwiBuild houses have think built? 200 or 300. many KiwiBuild houses have think built? 200 or 300. They many KiwiBuild houses have think built? 200 or 300. They have built? 200 or 300. They have cancelled built? 200 or 300. They have cancelled more built? 200 or 300. They have cancelled more houses built? 200 or 300. They have cancelled more houses at built? 200 or 300. They have cancelled more houses at Eamatu built? 200 or 300. They have cancelled more houses at Eamatu than cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they have cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they have built cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they have built in cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they have built in this cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they have built in this term cancelled more houses at Eamatu than they have built in this term in they have built in this term in government. they have built in this term in government. She they have built in this term in government. She has they have built in this term in government. She has the they have built in this term in government. She has the audacity they have built in this term in government. She has the audacity to government. She has the audacity to say government. She has the audacity to say she government. She has the audacity to say she is government. She has the audacity to say she is running government. She has the audacity to say she is running a government. She has the audacity to say she is running a fact-based say she is running a fact-based campaign say she is running a fact-based campaign this say she is running a fact-based campaign this year say she is running a fact-based campaign this year where say she is running a fact-based campaign this year where they say she is running a fact-based campaign this year where they are campaign this year where they are the campaign this year where they are the part campaign this year where they are the part of campaign this year where they are the part of infrastructure. campaign this year where they are the part of infrastructure. I campaign this year where they are the part of infrastructure. I don't the part of infrastructure. I don't think the part of infrastructure. I don't think so. the part of infrastructure. I don't think so. She the part of infrastructure. I don't think so. She won't the part of infrastructure. I don't think so. She won't have the part of infrastructure. I don't think so. She won't have to the part of infrastructure. I don't think so. She won't have to make think so. She won't have to make ridiculous think so. She won't have to make ridiculous comments think so. She won't have to make ridiculous comments like think so. She won't have to make ridiculous comments like they'll think so. She won't have to make ridiculous comments like they'll get ridiculous comments like they'll get light ridiculous comments like they'll get light rail ridiculous comments like they'll get light rail down ridiculous comments like they'll get light rail down Dominion ridiculous comments like they'll get light rail down Dominion Road ridiculous comments like they'll get light rail down Dominion Road before light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 and light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 and just light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 and just hope light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 and just hope for light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 and just hope for the light rail down Dominion Road before 2021 and just hope for the best. 2021 and just hope for the best. Where 2021 and just hope for the best. Where is 2021 and just hope for the best. Where is that 2021 and just hope for the best. Where is that light 2021 and just hope for the best. Where is that light rail? 2021 and just hope for the best. Where is that light rail? You 2021 and just hope for the best. Where is that light rail? You see, Where is that light rail? You see, MichaelEd Where is that light rail? You see, MichaelEd with Where is that light rail? You see, MichaelEd with quotes Where is that light rail? You see, MichaelEd with quotes out Where is that light rail? You see, MichaelEd with quotes out from Where is that light rail? You see, MichaelEd with quotes out from his MichaelEd with quotes out from his house MichaelEd with quotes out from his house in MichaelEd with quotes out from his house in Mount MichaelEd with quotes out from his house in Mount Roskill MichaelEd with quotes out from his house in Mount Roskill every MichaelEd with quotes out from his house in Mount Roskill every single house in Mount Roskill every single morning house in Mount Roskill every single morning and house in Mount Roskill every single morning and he house in Mount Roskill every single morning and he looks house in Mount Roskill every single morning and he looks for house in Mount Roskill every single morning and he looks for it. house in Mount Roskill every single morning and he looks for it. He house in Mount Roskill every single morning and he looks for it. He will morning and he looks for it. He will be morning and he looks for it. He will be looking morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a heck morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a heck of morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a heck of a morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a heck of a long morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a heck of a long time, morning and he looks for it. He will be looking a heck of a long time, Mr be looking a heck of a long time, Mr Speaker. be looking a heck of a long time, Mr Speaker. It be looking a heck of a long time, Mr Speaker. It hasn't be looking a heck of a long time, Mr Speaker. It hasn't been be looking a heck of a long time, Mr Speaker. It hasn't been built, be looking a heck of a long time, Mr Speaker. It hasn't been built, it Speaker. It hasn't been built, it hasn't Speaker. It hasn't been built, it hasn't been Speaker. It hasn't been built, it hasn't been planned, Speaker. It hasn't been built, it hasn't been planned, it Speaker. It hasn't been built, it hasn't been planned, it hasn't Speaker. It hasn't been built, it hasn't been planned, it hasn't been hasn't been planned, it hasn't been funded, hasn't been planned, it hasn't been funded, it hasn't been planned, it hasn't been funded, it hasn't hasn't been planned, it hasn't been funded, it hasn't been hasn't been planned, it hasn't been funded, it hasn't been constanted. funded, it hasn't been constanted. Nothing funded, it hasn't been constanted. Nothing ever funded, it hasn't been constanted. Nothing ever has funded, it hasn't been constanted. Nothing ever has happened. funded, it hasn't been constanted. Nothing ever has happened. She funded, it hasn't been constanted. Nothing ever has happened. She won't Nothing ever has happened. She won't have Nothing ever has happened. She won't have to Nothing ever has happened. She won't have to talk Nothing ever has happened. She won't have to talk about Nothing ever has happened. She won't have to talk about ending Nothing ever has happened. She won't have to talk about ending poverty Nothing ever has happened. She won't have to talk about ending poverty at have to talk about ending poverty at her have to talk about ending poverty at her first have to talk about ending poverty at her first winter have to talk about ending poverty at her first winter because have to talk about ending poverty at her first winter because we have to talk about ending poverty at her first winter because we know have to talk about ending poverty at her first winter because we know her her first winter because we know her by her first winter because we know her by her her first winter because we know her by her deeds her first winter because we know her by her deeds and her first winter because we know her by her deeds and we her first winter because we know her by her deeds and we know her first winter because we know her by her deeds and we know that her first winter because we know her by her deeds and we know that it her first winter because we know her by her deeds and we know that it is by her deeds and we know that it is getting by her deeds and we know that it is getting worse by her deeds and we know that it is getting worse and by her deeds and we know that it is getting worse and a by her deeds and we know that it is getting worse and a Salvation by her deeds and we know that it is getting worse and a Salvation Army getting worse and a Salvation Army report getting worse and a Salvation Army report makes getting worse and a Salvation Army report makes that getting worse and a Salvation Army report makes that very getting worse and a Salvation Army report makes that very clear getting worse and a Salvation Army report makes that very clear today, report makes that very clear today, Mr report makes that very clear today, Mr Speaker. report makes that very clear today, Mr Speaker. Jacinda report makes that very clear today, Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern report makes that very clear today, Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as government Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as government will Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as government will go Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as government will go down Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as government will go down in Mr Speaker. Jacinda Ardern as government will go down in history government will go down in history as government will go down in history as a government will go down in history as a story government will go down in history as a story of government will go down in history as a story of lost government will go down in history as a story of lost opportunities government will go down in history as a story of lost opportunities for as a story of lost opportunities for New as a story of lost opportunities for New Zealanders. as a story of lost opportunities for New Zealanders. Whether as a story of lost opportunities for New Zealanders. Whether it as a story of lost opportunities for New Zealanders. Whether it will as a story of lost opportunities for New Zealanders. Whether it will be New Zealanders. Whether it will be no New Zealanders. Whether it will be no infrastructure New Zealanders. Whether it will be no infrastructure projects New Zealanders. Whether it will be no infrastructure projects starting no infrastructure projects starting anywhere no infrastructure projects starting anywhere many no infrastructure projects starting anywhere many New no infrastructure projects starting anywhere many New Zealand no infrastructure projects starting anywhere many New Zealand - no infrastructure projects starting anywhere many New Zealand - and anywhere many New Zealand - and there anywhere many New Zealand - and there is anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a story anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a story - anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a story - well, anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a story - well, you anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a story - well, you say, anywhere many New Zealand - and there is a story - well, you say, I there is a story - well, you say, I har there is a story - well, you say, I har you there is a story - well, you say, I har you say there is a story - well, you say, I har you say Shane there is a story - well, you say, I har you say Shane gence there is a story - well, you say, I har you say Shane gence around har you say Shane gence around about, har you say Shane gence around about, "Even har you say Shane gence around about, "Even that har you say Shane gence around about, "Even that hasn't har you say Shane gence around about, "Even that hasn't started", about, "Even that hasn't started", as about, "Even that hasn't started", as I about, "Even that hasn't started", as I understand about, "Even that hasn't started", as I understand it, about, "Even that hasn't started", as I understand it, Mr about, "Even that hasn't started", as I understand it, Mr Speaker. about, "Even that hasn't started", as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. Not as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. Not a as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. Not a single as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. Not a single far as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. Not a single far project as I understand it, Mr Speaker. Not enthat. Not a single far project in enthat. Not a single far project in her enthat. Not a single far project in her three enthat. Not a single far project in her three years enthat. Not a single far project in her three years in enthat. Not a single far project in her three years in government. enthat. Not a single far project in her three years in government. Not her three years in government. Not light her three years in government. Not light rail. her three years in government. Not light rail. No her three years in government. Not light rail. No KiwiBuild. her three years in government. Not light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not her three years in government. Not light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. No light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. No nothing. light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. No nothing. More light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. No nothing. More than light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. No nothing. More than 30,000, light rail. No KiwiBuild. Not roads. No nothing. More than 30,000, I No nothing. More than 30,000, I should No nothing. More than 30,000, I should say No nothing. More than 30,000, I should say almost No nothing. More than 30,000, I should say almost 30,000 No nothing. More than 30,000, I should say almost 30,000 people No nothing. More than 30,000, I should say almost 30,000 people on should say almost 30,000 people on the should say almost 30,000 people on the dole should say almost 30,000 people on the dole and should say almost 30,000 people on the dole and seven should say almost 30,000 people on the dole and seven out should say almost 30,000 people on the dole and seven out of should say almost 30,000 people on the dole and seven out of nine should say almost 30,000 people on the dole and seven out of nine child the dole and seven out of nine child poverty the dole and seven out of nine child poverty indicators the dole and seven out of nine child poverty indicators getting the dole and seven out of nine child poverty indicators getting worse poverty indicators getting worse under poverty indicators getting worse under this poverty indicators getting worse under this government. poverty indicators getting worse under this government. She poverty indicators getting worse under this government. She has poverty indicators getting worse under this government. She has the under this government. She has the ter under this government. She has the ter MrTy under this government. She has the ter MrTy to under this government. She has the ter MrTy to say under this government. She has the ter MrTy to say she under this government. She has the ter MrTy to say she is under this government. She has the ter MrTy to say she is starting under this government. She has the ter MrTy to say she is starting at ter MrTy to say she is starting at the ter MrTy to say she is starting at the beginning ter MrTy to say she is starting at the beginning because ter MrTy to say she is starting at the beginning because things ter MrTy to say she is starting at the beginning because things were ter MrTy to say she is starting at the beginning because things were -- the beginning because things were -- deeper the beginning because things were -- deeper to the beginning because things were -- deeper to MrTy the beginning because things were -- deeper to MrTy to the beginning because things were -- deeper to MrTy to say the beginning because things were -- deeper to MrTy to say that the beginning because things were -- deeper to MrTy to say that she the beginning because things were -- deeper to MrTy to say that she is deeper to MrTy to say that she is starting deeper to MrTy to say that she is starting at deeper to MrTy to say that she is starting at the deeper to MrTy to say that she is starting at the beginning deeper to MrTy to say that she is starting at the beginning because starting at the beginning because things starting at the beginning because things were starting at the beginning because things were so starting at the beginning because things were so bad starting at the beginning because things were so bad things starting at the beginning because things were so bad things are things were so bad things are getting things were so bad things are getting worse. things were so bad things are getting worse. That things were so bad things are getting worse. That is things were so bad things are getting worse. That is what things were so bad things are getting worse. That is what is getting worse. That is what is happening getting worse. That is what is happening in getting worse. That is what is happening in New getting worse. That is what is happening in New Zealand getting worse. That is what is happening in New Zealand right getting worse. That is what is happening in New Zealand right now happening in New Zealand right now and happening in New Zealand right now and these happening in New Zealand right now and these are happening in New Zealand right now and these are not happening in New Zealand right now and these are not just happening in New Zealand right now and these are not just statistics. and these are not just statistics. This and these are not just statistics. This are and these are not just statistics. This are ral and these are not just statistics. This are ral people and these are not just statistics. This are ral people on and these are not just statistics. This are ral people on the and these are not just statistics. This are ral people on the ground and these are not just statistics. This are ral people on the ground in This are ral people on the ground in your This are ral people on the ground in your electorate, This are ral people on the ground in your electorate, actually, This are ral people on the ground in your electorate, actually, Kelvin your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis who your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis who are your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis who are getting your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis who are getting poorer your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis who are getting poorer and your electorate, actually, Kelvin Davis who are getting poorer and who Davis who are getting poorer and who Davis who are getting poorer and who Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have houses Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have houses and Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have houses and have Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have houses and have to Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have houses and have to go Davis who are getting poorer and who don't have houses and have to go for don't have houses and have to go for food don't have houses and have to go for food parcels don't have houses and have to go for food parcels because don't have houses and have to go for food parcels because your don't have houses and have to go for food parcels because your government food parcels because your government is food parcels because your government is failing food parcels because your government is failing to food parcels because your government is failing to deliver food parcels because your government is failing to deliver on food parcels because your government is failing to deliver on its is failing to deliver on its promises, is failing to deliver on its promises, Mr is failing to deliver on its promises, Mr Speaker. is failing to deliver on its promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE is failing to deliver on its promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is even promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is even worse promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is even worse about promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is even worse about the promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is even worse about the speech promises, Mr Speaker. APPLAUSE What is even worse about the speech we is even worse about the speech we have is even worse about the speech we have just is even worse about the speech we have just hard is even worse about the speech we have just hard in is even worse about the speech we have just hard in this is even worse about the speech we have just hard in this long is even worse about the speech we have just hard in this long diatribe have just hard in this long diatribe here have just hard in this long diatribe here of have just hard in this long diatribe here of hollowness have just hard in this long diatribe here of hollowness where have just hard in this long diatribe here of hollowness where nothing have just hard in this long diatribe here of hollowness where nothing is here of hollowness where nothing is happening, here of hollowness where nothing is happening, not here of hollowness where nothing is happening, not only here of hollowness where nothing is happening, not only have here of hollowness where nothing is happening, not only have they happening, not only have they achieved happening, not only have they achieved anything happening, not only have they achieved anything in happening, not only have they achieved anything in there happening, not only have they achieved anything in there years, achieved anything in there years, achieved anything in there years, achieved anything in there years, there is achieved anything in there years, there is nothing achieved anything in there years, there is nothing new. achieved anything in there years, there is nothing new. There achieved anything in there years, there is nothing new. There is achieved anything in there years, there is nothing new. There is a there is nothing new. There is a sense there is nothing new. There is a sense of there is nothing new. There is a sense of being there is nothing new. There is a sense of being berespect there is nothing new. There is a sense of being berespect of there is nothing new. There is a sense of being berespect of anything sense of being berespect of anything new sense of being berespect of anything new for sense of being berespect of anything new for New sense of being berespect of anything new for New Zealand. sense of being berespect of anything new for New Zealand. A sense of being berespect of anything new for New Zealand. A sense sense of being berespect of anything new for New Zealand. A sense of new for New Zealand. A sense of aspiration new for New Zealand. A sense of aspiration and new for New Zealand. A sense of aspiration and delivery new for New Zealand. A sense of aspiration and delivery for new for New Zealand. A sense of aspiration and delivery for this aspiration and delivery for this country aspiration and delivery for this country in aspiration and delivery for this country in the aspiration and delivery for this country in the years aspiration and delivery for this country in the years to aspiration and delivery for this country in the years to come. aspiration and delivery for this country in the years to come. We aspiration and delivery for this country in the years to come. We had country in the years to come. We had 300 country in the years to come. We had 300 KiwiBuild country in the years to come. We had 300 KiwiBuild houses country in the years to come. We had 300 KiwiBuild houses and country in the years to come. We had 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight twie 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight twie -- 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight twie -- Phil 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight twie -- Phil Twyford 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight twie -- Phil Twyford looks 300 KiwiBuild houses and Twilight twie -- Phil Twyford looks down twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because he twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because he knows twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because he knows the twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because he knows the record. twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because he knows the record. We twie -- Phil Twyford looks down because he knows the record. We were because he knows the record. We were supposed because he knows the record. We were supposed to because he knows the record. We were supposed to be because he knows the record. We were supposed to be at because he knows the record. We were supposed to be at 6,000, because he knows the record. We were supposed to be at 6,000, at because he knows the record. We were supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 because he knows the record. We were supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a year, supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a year, at supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a year, at 100,000 supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a year, at 100,000 over supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a year, at 100,000 over the supposed to be at 6,000, at 10,000 a year, at 100,000 over the next year, at 100,000 over the next decade year, at 100,000 over the next decade and year, at 100,000 over the next decade and counting year, at 100,000 over the next decade and counting and year, at 100,000 over the next decade and counting and they year, at 100,000 over the next decade and counting and they have decade and counting and they have cancelled decade and counting and they have cancelled more decade and counting and they have cancelled more than decade and counting and they have cancelled more than they decade and counting and they have cancelled more than they have cancelled more than they have started. cancelled more than they have started. Not cancelled more than they have started. Not a cancelled more than they have started. Not a single cancelled more than they have started. Not a single kilometre cancelled more than they have started. Not a single kilometre of started. Not a single kilometre of track started. Not a single kilometre of track of started. Not a single kilometre of track of light started. Not a single kilometre of track of light written started. Not a single kilometre of track of light written down started. Not a single kilometre of track of light written down Dominion track of light written down Dominion Road track of light written down Dominion Road when track of light written down Dominion Road when it track of light written down Dominion Road when it was track of light written down Dominion Road when it was meant track of light written down Dominion Road when it was meant to track of light written down Dominion Road when it was meant to be track of light written down Dominion Road when it was meant to be built Road when it was meant to be built by Road when it was meant to be built by 2021, Road when it was meant to be built by 2021, Mr Road when it was meant to be built by 2021, Mr Speaker. Road when it was meant to be built by 2021, Mr Speaker. They Road when it was meant to be built by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped Road when it was meant to be built by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up fuel by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up fuel prices by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up fuel prices they by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up fuel prices they raised by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up fuel prices they raised a by 2021, Mr Speaker. They pumped up fuel prices they raised a regional fuel prices they raised a regional fuel fuel prices they raised a regional fuel tax fuel prices they raised a regional fuel tax that fuel prices they raised a regional fuel tax that is fuel prices they raised a regional fuel tax that is really fuel prices they raised a regional fuel tax that is really helping fuel tax that is really helping those fuel tax that is really helping those people fuel tax that is really helping those people that fuel tax that is really helping those people that cool fuel tax that is really helping those people that cool Vin fuel tax that is really helping those people that cool Vin Davis fuel tax that is really helping those people that cool Vin Davis - those people that cool Vin Davis - with those people that cool Vin Davis - with no those people that cool Vin Davis - with no who those people that cool Vin Davis - with no who the those people that cool Vin Davis - with no who the flosser those people that cool Vin Davis - with no who the flosser in those people that cool Vin Davis - with no who the flosser in chief those people that cool Vin Davis - with no who the flosser in chief is with no who the flosser in chief is and with no who the flosser in chief is and it with no who the flosser in chief is and it isn't with no who the flosser in chief is and it isn't you. with no who the flosser in chief is and it isn't you. They with no who the flosser in chief is and it isn't you. They have with no who the flosser in chief is and it isn't you. They have done with no who the flosser in chief is and it isn't you. They have done all and it isn't you. They have done all of and it isn't you. They have done all of these and it isn't you. They have done all of these things and it isn't you. They have done all of these things and and it isn't you. They have done all of these things and instead and it isn't you. They have done all of these things and instead of of these things and instead of getting of these things and instead of getting new of these things and instead of getting new roads of these things and instead of getting new roads and of these things and instead of getting new roads and doing of these things and instead of getting new roads and doing new getting new roads and doing new infrastructure getting new roads and doing new infrastructure in getting new roads and doing new infrastructure in this getting new roads and doing new infrastructure in this country, getting new roads and doing new infrastructure in this country, we infrastructure in this country, we have infrastructure in this country, we have also infrastructure in this country, we have also happening infrastructure in this country, we have also happening than infrastructure in this country, we have also happening than before infrastructure in this country, we have also happening than before in infrastructure in this country, we have also happening than before in a have also happening than before in a very, have also happening than before in a very, very have also happening than before in a very, very long have also happening than before in a very, very long time. have also happening than before in a very, very long time. The have also happening than before in a very, very long time. The amazing very, very long time. The amazing thing very, very long time. The amazing thing about very, very long time. The amazing thing about this very, very long time. The amazing thing about this document, very, very long time. The amazing thing about this document, I very, very long time. The amazing thing about this document, I think thing about this document, I think it thing about this document, I think it is thing about this document, I think it is on thing about this document, I think it is on page thing about this document, I think it is on page 3, thing about this document, I think it is on page 3, they thing about this document, I think it is on page 3, they start thing about this document, I think it is on page 3, they start by it is on page 3, they start by saying, it is on page 3, they start by saying, because it is on page 3, they start by saying, because they it is on page 3, they start by saying, because they are it is on page 3, they start by saying, because they are obsessed saying, because they are obsessed with saying, because they are obsessed with the saying, because they are obsessed with the National-led saying, because they are obsessed with the National-led government, with the National-led government, how with the National-led government, how terrible with the National-led government, how terrible it with the National-led government, how terrible it was with the National-led government, how terrible it was that with the National-led government, how terrible it was that we how terrible it was that we overinvested how terrible it was that we overinvested in how terrible it was that we overinvested in roads. how terrible it was that we overinvested in roads. Six overinvested in roads. Six paragraphs overinvested in roads. Six paragraphs down, overinvested in roads. Six paragraphs down, what overinvested in roads. Six paragraphs down, what does overinvested in roads. Six paragraphs down, what does she overinvested in roads. Six paragraphs down, what does she say? paragraphs down, what does she say? "We paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are going paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are going to paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are going to bill paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are going to bill lots paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are going to bill lots of paragraphs down, what does she say? "We are going to bill lots of rods." "We are going to bill lots of rods." APPLAUSE "We are going to bill lots of rods." APPLAUSE She "We are going to bill lots of rods." APPLAUSE She spents "We are going to bill lots of rods." APPLAUSE She spents more "We are going to bill lots of rods." APPLAUSE She spents more time "We are going to bill lots of rods." APPLAUSE She spents more time in APPLAUSE She spents more time in this APPLAUSE She spents more time in this speech APPLAUSE She spents more time in this speech talking APPLAUSE She spents more time in this speech talking about APPLAUSE She spents more time in this speech talking about roads APPLAUSE She spents more time in this speech talking about roads than this speech talking about roads than she this speech talking about roads than she does this speech talking about roads than she does about this speech talking about roads than she does about light this speech talking about roads than she does about light rail, this speech talking about roads than she does about light rail, the this speech talking about roads than she does about light rail, the one she does about light rail, the one thin she does about light rail, the one thin they she does about light rail, the one thin they did she does about light rail, the one thin they did promise she does about light rail, the one thin they did promise because thin they did promise because actually thin they did promise because actually New thin they did promise because actually New Zealanders thin they did promise because actually New Zealanders know thin they did promise because actually New Zealanders know they actually New Zealanders know they can't actually New Zealanders know they can't deliver actually New Zealanders know they can't deliver on actually New Zealanders know they can't deliver on their actually New Zealanders know they can't deliver on their promises, actually New Zealanders know they can't deliver on their promises, Mr can't deliver on their promises, Mr Speaker. can't deliver on their promises, Mr Speaker. They can't deliver on their promises, Mr Speaker. They have can't deliver on their promises, Mr Speaker. They have cancelled can't deliver on their promises, Mr Speaker. They have cancelled more can't deliver on their promises, Mr Speaker. They have cancelled more in Speaker. They have cancelled more in Kelvin Speaker. They have cancelled more in Kelvin Davis's Speaker. They have cancelled more in Kelvin Davis's elect Speaker. They have cancelled more in Kelvin Davis's elect transport Speaker. They have cancelled more in Kelvin Davis's elect transport than Kelvin Davis's elect transport than they Kelvin Davis's elect transport than they have Kelvin Davis's elect transport than they have started Kelvin Davis's elect transport than they have started anywhere Kelvin Davis's elect transport than they have started anywhere around they have started anywhere around New they have started anywhere around New Zealand. they have started anywhere around New Zealand. The they have started anywhere around New Zealand. The East they have started anywhere around New Zealand. The East West they have started anywhere around New Zealand. The East West Link, New Zealand. The East West Link, first New Zealand. The East West Link, first ruey New Zealand. The East West Link, first ruey to New Zealand. The East West Link, first ruey to the New Zealand. The East West Link, first ruey to the Northern New Zealand. The East West Link, first ruey to the Northern Link, first ruey to the Northern Link, cutie, first ruey to the Northern Link, cutie, cutie, first ruey to the Northern Link, cutie, cutie, network first ruey to the Northern Link, cutie, cutie, network connections, cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni to cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni to Link cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni to Link road cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni to Link road and cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni to Link road and Chris cutie, cutie, network connections, Petoni to Link road and Chris Bishop Petoni to Link road and Chris Bishop the Petoni to Link road and Chris Bishop the interchange. Petoni to Link road and Chris Bishop the interchange. All Petoni to Link road and Chris Bishop the interchange. All cancelled. Petoni to Link road and Chris Bishop the interchange. All cancelled. None the interchange. All cancelled. None of the interchange. All cancelled. None of it the interchange. All cancelled. None of it happening. the interchange. All cancelled. None of it happening. Now the interchange. All cancelled. None of it happening. Now Phil the interchange. All cancelled. None of it happening. Now Phil Twyford the interchange. All cancelled. None of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear at of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear at speeches, of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear at speeches, he of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear at speeches, he is of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear at speeches, he is not of it happening. Now Phil Twyford I hear at speeches, he is not sure hear at speeches, he is not sure what hear at speeches, he is not sure what to hear at speeches, he is not sure what to say. hear at speeches, he is not sure what to say. He hear at speeches, he is not sure what to say. He literally, hear at speeches, he is not sure what to say. He literally, well, hear at speeches, he is not sure what to say. He literally, well, he what to say. He literally, well, he is what to say. He literally, well, he is not what to say. He literally, well, he is not allowed what to say. He literally, well, he is not allowed to what to say. He literally, well, he is not allowed to talk. what to say. He literally, well, he is not allowed to talk. Sometimes what to say. He literally, well, he is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets out. is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets out. Jacinda is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets out. Jacinda gets is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets out. Jacinda gets angry is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets out. Jacinda gets angry at is not allowed to talk. Sometimes he gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets out gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets out and gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets out and he gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets out and he talks. gets out. Jacinda gets angry at him but he gets out and he talks. Order. but he gets out and he talks. Order. Jacinda but he gets out and he talks. Order. Jacinda Ardern. but he gets out and he talks. Order. Jacinda Ardern. True but he gets out and he talks. Order. Jacinda Ardern. True to but he gets out and he talks. Order. Jacinda Ardern. True to their but he gets out and he talks. Order. Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, what Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, what we Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, what we know Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, what we know about Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, what we know about this Jacinda Ardern. True to their form, what we know about this government what we know about this government is what we know about this government is they what we know about this government is they are what we know about this government is they are first-class what we know about this government is they are first-class at is they are first-class at announcements. is they are first-class at announcements. I is they are first-class at announcements. I don't is they are first-class at announcements. I don't even is they are first-class at announcements. I don't even think announcements. I don't even think they announcements. I don't even think they are announcements. I don't even think they are third announcements. I don't even think they are third rate announcements. I don't even think they are third rate at announcements. I don't even think they are third rate at delivery. they are third rate at delivery. They they are third rate at delivery. They are they are third rate at delivery. They are hopeless they are third rate at delivery. They are hopeless at they are third rate at delivery. They are hopeless at it they are third rate at delivery. They are hopeless at it and they are third rate at delivery. They are hopeless at it and New They are hopeless at it and New Zealanders They are hopeless at it and New Zealanders deserve They are hopeless at it and New Zealanders deserve much They are hopeless at it and New Zealanders deserve much better They are hopeless at it and New Zealanders deserve much better than Zealanders deserve much better than 2.5 Zealanders deserve much better than 2.5 years Zealanders deserve much better than 2.5 years in, Zealanders deserve much better than 2.5 years in, coming Zealanders deserve much better than 2.5 years in, coming back Zealanders deserve much better than 2.5 years in, coming back and 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, "Yes, 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, "Yes, we 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, "Yes, we will 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, "Yes, we will do 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, "Yes, we will do some 2.5 years in, coming back and saying, "Yes, we will do some of saying, "Yes, we will do some of these saying, "Yes, we will do some of these projects", saying, "Yes, we will do some of these projects", the saying, "Yes, we will do some of these projects", the best saying, "Yes, we will do some of these projects", the best they saying, "Yes, we will do some of these projects", the best they can these projects", the best they can offer these projects", the best they can offer is these projects", the best they can offer is one these projects", the best they can offer is one or these projects", the best they can offer is one or two these projects", the best they can offer is one or two will these projects", the best they can offer is one or two will have these projects", the best they can offer is one or two will have a offer is one or two will have a cycle offer is one or two will have a cycle way. offer is one or two will have a cycle way. Julie offer is one or two will have a cycle way. Julie Anne offer is one or two will have a cycle way. Julie Anne Genter offer is one or two will have a cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might be cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might be happy cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might be happy with cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might be happy with that, cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might be happy with that, but cycle way. Julie Anne Genter might be happy with that, but New be happy with that, but New Zealanders be happy with that, but New Zealanders are be happy with that, but New Zealanders are not, be happy with that, but New Zealanders are not, Mr be happy with that, but New Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. be happy with that, but New Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are mightily Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are mightily brassed Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are mightily brassed off Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are mightily brassed off at Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are mightily brassed off at the Zealanders are not, Mr Speaker. They are mightily brassed off at the lack are mightily brassed off at the lack of are mightily brassed off at the lack of delivery are mightily brassed off at the lack of delivery when are mightily brassed off at the lack of delivery when another are mightily brassed off at the lack of delivery when another important of delivery when another important issue of delivery when another important issue cost of delivery when another important issue cost is of delivery when another important issue cost is going of delivery when another important issue cost is going through of delivery when another important issue cost is going through the issue cost is going through the roof. issue cost is going through the roof. If issue cost is going through the roof. If only issue cost is going through the roof. If only they issue cost is going through the roof. If only they were issue cost is going through the roof. If only they were building roof. If only they were building roofs. roof. If only they were building roofs. They roof. If only they were building roofs. They are roof. If only they were building roofs. They are not roof. If only they were building roofs. They are not but roof. If only they were building roofs. They are not but cost roof. If only they were building roofs. They are not but cost of roofs. They are not but cost of living roofs. They are not but cost of living is roofs. They are not but cost of living is going roofs. They are not but cost of living is going through roofs. They are not but cost of living is going through the roofs. They are not but cost of living is going through the roof. roofs. They are not but cost of living is going through the roof. We living is going through the roof. We hear living is going through the roof. We hear the living is going through the roof. We hear the stories living is going through the roof. We hear the stories every living is going through the roof. We hear the stories every single living is going through the roof. We hear the stories every single day hear the stories every single day around hear the stories every single day around New hear the stories every single day around New Zealand hear the stories every single day around New Zealand of hear the stories every single day around New Zealand of New hear the stories every single day around New Zealand of New Zealanders around New Zealand of New Zealanders who around New Zealand of New Zealanders who feel around New Zealand of New Zealanders who feel they around New Zealand of New Zealanders who feel they are around New Zealand of New Zealanders who feel they are working around New Zealand of New Zealanders who feel they are working harder, who feel they are working harder, they who feel they are working harder, they are who feel they are working harder, they are trying who feel they are working harder, they are trying harder, who feel they are working harder, they are trying harder, they who feel they are working harder, they are trying harder, they are they are trying harder, they are doing they are trying harder, they are doing more, they are trying harder, they are doing more, they they are trying harder, they are doing more, they are they are trying harder, they are doing more, they are spending they are trying harder, they are doing more, they are spending more doing more, they are spending more time doing more, they are spending more time at doing more, they are spending more time at work, doing more, they are spending more time at work, but doing more, they are spending more time at work, but the doing more, they are spending more time at work, but the tax, doing more, they are spending more time at work, but the tax, the doing more, they are spending more time at work, but the tax, the cost, time at work, but the tax, the cost, the time at work, but the tax, the cost, the regulation, time at work, but the tax, the cost, the regulation, whether time at work, but the tax, the cost, the regulation, whether they time at work, but the tax, the cost, the regulation, whether they are the regulation, whether they are working the regulation, whether they are working for the regulation, whether they are working for someone the regulation, whether they are working for someone or the regulation, whether they are working for someone or they the regulation, whether they are working for someone or they are working for someone or they are employed working for someone or they are employed by working for someone or they are employed by - working for someone or they are employed by - or working for someone or they are employed by - or they working for someone or they are employed by - or they are working for someone or they are employed by - or they are their working for someone or they are employed by - or they are their on employed by - or they are their on employer, employed by - or they are their on employer, is employed by - or they are their on employer, is making employed by - or they are their on employer, is making things employed by - or they are their on employer, is making things harder employer, is making things harder and employer, is making things harder and taxes employer, is making things harder and taxes are employer, is making things harder and taxes are geeing employer, is making things harder and taxes are geeing on employer, is making things harder and taxes are geeing on others employer, is making things harder and taxes are geeing on others and and taxes are geeing on others and not and taxes are geeing on others and not on and taxes are geeing on others and not on them, and taxes are geeing on others and not on them, as and taxes are geeing on others and not on them, as money and taxes are geeing on others and not on them, as money is and taxes are geeing on others and not on them, as money is wasted and taxes are geeing on others and not on them, as money is wasted by not on them, as money is wasted by this not on them, as money is wasted by this government not on them, as money is wasted by this government like not on them, as money is wasted by this government like it not on them, as money is wasted by this government like it is not on them, as money is wasted by this government like it is a not on them, as money is wasted by this government like it is a drunken this government like it is a drunken sailor. this government like it is a drunken sailor. Cost this government like it is a drunken sailor. Cost of this government like it is a drunken sailor. Cost of living, this government like it is a drunken sailor. Cost of living, I this government like it is a drunken sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, this government like it is a drunken sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is going sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is going through sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is going through the sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is going through the roof, sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is going through the roof, whether sailor. Cost of living, I repeat, is going through the roof, whether it going through the roof, whether it is going through the roof, whether it is 2 going through the roof, whether it is 2 $2,600, going through the roof, whether it is 2 $2,600, need going through the roof, whether it is 2 $2,600, need yep going through the roof, whether it is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't going through the roof, whether it is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has again is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has again up is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has again up a is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has again up a year is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has again up a year under is 2 $2,600, need yep aren't has again up a year under this again up a year under this government. again up a year under this government. It again up a year under this government. It is again up a year under this government. It is $55 again up a year under this government. It is $55 more again up a year under this government. It is $55 more a again up a year under this government. It is $55 more a wok. government. It is $55 more a wok. This government. It is $55 more a wok. This PM government. It is $55 more a wok. This PM over government. It is $55 more a wok. This PM over here government. It is $55 more a wok. This PM over here talks government. It is $55 more a wok. This PM over here talks about This PM over here talks about 80-migrant This PM over here talks about 80-migrant dollars This PM over here talks about 80-migrant dollars a This PM over here talks about 80-migrant dollars a week This PM over here talks about 80-migrant dollars a week more. This PM over here talks about 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most has 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most has again 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most has again on 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most has again on rent, 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most has again on rent, Mr 80-migrant dollars a week more. Most has again on rent, Mr Speaker. has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, $200 has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, $200 more has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, $200 more a has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, $200 more a year, has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, $200 more a year, just has again on rent, Mr Speaker. Petrol, $200 more a year, just in Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the tax Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the tax additional Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the tax additional that Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the tax additional that has Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the tax additional that has been Petrol, $200 more a year, just in the tax additional that has been put the tax additional that has been put on the tax additional that has been put on for the tax additional that has been put on for a the tax additional that has been put on for a typical the tax additional that has been put on for a typical first the tax additional that has been put on for a typical first person. on for a typical first person. Cancelled on for a typical first person. Cancelled tax on for a typical first person. Cancelled tax cut on for a typical first person. Cancelled tax cut these on for a typical first person. Cancelled tax cut these takes on for a typical first person. Cancelled tax cut these takes us Cancelled tax cut these takes us another Cancelled tax cut these takes us another $1,000 Cancelled tax cut these takes us another $1,000 a Cancelled tax cut these takes us another $1,000 a year Cancelled tax cut these takes us another $1,000 a year that Cancelled tax cut these takes us another $1,000 a year that people another $1,000 a year that people could another $1,000 a year that people could have another $1,000 a year that people could have had another $1,000 a year that people could have had in another $1,000 a year that people could have had in their another $1,000 a year that people could have had in their pocket, another $1,000 a year that people could have had in their pocket, that could have had in their pocket, that would could have had in their pocket, that would have could have had in their pocket, that would have made could have had in their pocket, that would have made a could have had in their pocket, that would have made a difference could have had in their pocket, that would have made a difference in would have made a difference in terms would have made a difference in terms of would have made a difference in terms of paying would have made a difference in terms of paying those would have made a difference in terms of paying those bills, would have made a difference in terms of paying those bills, getting terms of paying those bills, getting those terms of paying those bills, getting those school terms of paying those bills, getting those school uniforms terms of paying those bills, getting those school uniforms and terms of paying those bills, getting those school uniforms and doing terms of paying those bills, getting those school uniforms and doing the those school uniforms and doing the things those school uniforms and doing the things that those school uniforms and doing the things that mart. those school uniforms and doing the things that mart. Never those school uniforms and doing the things that mart. Never the those school uniforms and doing the things that mart. Never the less, things that mart. Never the less, under things that mart. Never the less, under this things that mart. Never the less, under this government things that mart. Never the less, under this government that things that mart. Never the less, under this government that cancelled under this government that cancelled they under this government that cancelled they are under this government that cancelled they are some under this government that cancelled they are some $4,000 under this government that cancelled they are some $4,000 a under this government that cancelled they are some $4,000 a year under this government that cancelled they are some $4,000 a year worse they are some $4,000 a year worse off. they are some $4,000 a year worse off. Mr they are some $4,000 a year worse off. Mr Speaker, they are some $4,000 a year worse off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 they are some $4,000 a year worse off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people they are some $4,000 a year worse off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the deal. off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the deal. What off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the deal. What is off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the deal. What is that? off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the deal. What is that? Half off. Mr Speaker, 28,000 people more on the deal. What is that? Half of on the deal. What is that? Half of Whanganui. on the deal. What is that? Half of Whanganui. A on the deal. What is that? Half of Whanganui. A couple on the deal. What is that? Half of Whanganui. A couple of on the deal. What is that? Half of Whanganui. A couple of tuck on the deal. What is that? Half of Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, more Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, more people Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, more people on Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, more people on the Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, more people on the deal. Whanganui. A couple of tuck tan flies, more people on the deal. When flies, more people on the deal. When New flies, more people on the deal. When New Zealanders flies, more people on the deal. When New Zealanders are flies, more people on the deal. When New Zealanders are working flies, more people on the deal. When New Zealanders are working harder New Zealanders are working harder and New Zealanders are working harder and fed New Zealanders are working harder and fed up New Zealanders are working harder and fed up with New Zealanders are working harder and fed up with the New Zealanders are working harder and fed up with the cost New Zealanders are working harder and fed up with the cost they New Zealanders are working harder and fed up with the cost they are and fed up with the cost they are paying, and fed up with the cost they are paying, there and fed up with the cost they are paying, there are and fed up with the cost they are paying, there are more and fed up with the cost they are paying, there are more people and fed up with the cost they are paying, there are more people who paying, there are more people who are paying, there are more people who are on paying, there are more people who are on the paying, there are more people who are on the deal paying, there are more people who are on the deal right paying, there are more people who are on the deal right now paying, there are more people who are on the deal right now because are on the deal right now because job are on the deal right now because job growth are on the deal right now because job growth has are on the deal right now because job growth has flat are on the deal right now because job growth has flat lined are on the deal right now because job growth has flat lined because job growth has flat lined because there job growth has flat lined because there are job growth has flat lined because there are no job growth has flat lined because there are no expectations job growth has flat lined because there are no expectations under job growth has flat lined because there are no expectations under this there are no expectations under this government there are no expectations under this government to there are no expectations under this government to get there are no expectations under this government to get a there are no expectations under this government to get a job there are no expectations under this government to get a job and there are no expectations under this government to get a job and now there are no expectations under this government to get a job and now we government to get a job and now we have government to get a job and now we have - government to get a job and now we have - and government to get a job and now we have - and they government to get a job and now we have - and they laugh, government to get a job and now we have - and they laugh, but government to get a job and now we have - and they laugh, but New have - and they laugh, but New Zealanders have - and they laugh, but New Zealanders are have - and they laugh, but New Zealanders are not have - and they laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing. have - and they laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing. They Zealanders are not laughing. They laugh, Zealanders are not laughing. They laugh, but Zealanders are not laughing. They laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing. They laugh, but New Zealanders Zealanders are not laughing. They laugh, but New Zealanders are Zealanders are not laughing. They laugh, but New Zealanders are not laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing because laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing because they laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing because they see laugh, but New Zealanders are not laughing because they see a laughing because they see a situation. laughing because they see a situation. There laughing because they see a situation. There has laughing because they see a situation. There has been laughing because they see a situation. There has been lack laughing because they see a situation. There has been lack of situation. There has been lack of delivery. situation. There has been lack of delivery. Where situation. There has been lack of delivery. Where there situation. There has been lack of delivery. Where there is situation. There has been lack of delivery. Where there is no situation. There has been lack of delivery. Where there is no far. delivery. Where there is no far. Where delivery. Where there is no far. Where the delivery. Where there is no far. Where the economy delivery. Where there is no far. Where the economy is delivery. Where there is no far. Where the economy is getting delivery. Where there is no far. Where the economy is getting worse. Where the economy is getting worse. Where Where the economy is getting worse. Where a Where the economy is getting worse. Where a situation Where the economy is getting worse. Where a situation where Where the economy is getting worse. Where a situation where people Where the economy is getting worse. Where a situation where people are Where a situation where people are facing Where a situation where people are facing more Where a situation where people are facing more costs. Where a situation where people are facing more costs. Where Where a situation where people are facing more costs. Where there Where a situation where people are facing more costs. Where there is facing more costs. Where there is 7,000 facing more costs. Where there is 7,000 more facing more costs. Where there is 7,000 more children facing more costs. Where there is 7,000 more children and facing more costs. Where there is 7,000 more children and poverty 7,000 more children and poverty today 7,000 more children and poverty today than 7,000 more children and poverty today than there 7,000 more children and poverty today than there were 7,000 more children and poverty today than there were a 7,000 more children and poverty today than there were a couple 7,000 more children and poverty today than there were a couple of today than there were a couple of years today than there were a couple of years ago today than there were a couple of years ago Ron today than there were a couple of years ago Ron Mark. today than there were a couple of years ago Ron Mark. 8,000 today than there were a couple of years ago Ron Mark. 8,000 people years ago Ron Mark. 8,000 people more. years ago Ron Mark. 8,000 people more. Children. years ago Ron Mark. 8,000 people more. Children. Actuallien years ago Ron Mark. 8,000 people more. Children. Actuallien of more. Children. Actuallien of thousands more. Children. Actuallien of thousands sitting more. Children. Actuallien of thousands sitting there more. Children. Actuallien of thousands sitting there in more. Children. Actuallien of thousands sitting there in the thousands sitting there in the Christchurch thousands sitting there in the Christchurch City thousands sitting there in the Christchurch City Mission thousands sitting there in the Christchurch City Mission says thousands sitting there in the Christchurch City Mission says that Christchurch City Mission says that things Christchurch City Mission says that things were Christchurch City Mission says that things were better Christchurch City Mission says that things were better under Christchurch City Mission says that things were better under us Christchurch City Mission says that things were better under us and things were better under us and things things were better under us and things have things were better under us and things have got things were better under us and things have got much, things were better under us and things have got much, much things were better under us and things have got much, much worse. things have got much, much worse. Hardship things have got much, much worse. Hardship grants things have got much, much worse. Hardship grants have things have got much, much worse. Hardship grants have doubled. Hardship grants have doubled. Emergency Hardship grants have doubled. Emergency housing Hardship grants have doubled. Emergency housing grants Hardship grants have doubled. Emergency housing grants have Emergency housing grants have increased Emergency housing grants have increased by Emergency housing grants have increased by 500% Emergency housing grants have increased by 500% and Emergency housing grants have increased by 500% and the Emergency housing grants have increased by 500% and the social increased by 500% and the social housing increased by 500% and the social housing waiting increased by 500% and the social housing waiting list increased by 500% and the social housing waiting list has increased by 500% and the social housing waiting list has more increased by 500% and the social housing waiting list has more than housing waiting list has more than doubled housing waiting list has more than doubled to housing waiting list has more than doubled to of housing waiting list has more than doubled to of 13,000 housing waiting list has more than doubled to of 13,000 families. housing waiting list has more than doubled to of 13,000 families. They doubled to of 13,000 families. They have doubled to of 13,000 families. They have been doubled to of 13,000 families. They have been better doubled to of 13,000 families. They have been better at doubled to of 13,000 families. They have been better at filling doubled to of 13,000 families. They have been better at filling motels have been better at filling motels than have been better at filling motels than they have been better at filling motels than they have have been better at filling motels than they have at have been better at filling motels than they have at building have been better at filling motels than they have at building houses. than they have at building houses. Hundreds than they have at building houses. Hundreds of than they have at building houses. Hundreds of millions than they have at building houses. Hundreds of millions of than they have at building houses. Hundreds of millions of dollars Hundreds of millions of dollars going Hundreds of millions of dollars going on Hundreds of millions of dollars going on people Hundreds of millions of dollars going on people and Hundreds of millions of dollars going on people and the Hundreds of millions of dollars going on people and the PM Hundreds of millions of dollars going on people and the PM finished going on people and the PM finished on going on people and the PM finished on what going on people and the PM finished on what you going on people and the PM finished on what you would going on people and the PM finished on what you would think going on people and the PM finished on what you would think you going on people and the PM finished on what you would think you would on what you would think you would finish on what you would think you would finish on on what you would think you would finish on a on what you would think you would finish on a strong on what you would think you would finish on a strong point on what you would think you would finish on a strong point actually. finish on a strong point actually. She finish on a strong point actually. She finished finish on a strong point actually. She finished on finish on a strong point actually. She finished on 1,800 finish on a strong point actually. She finished on 1,800 new finish on a strong point actually. She finished on 1,800 new police She finished on 1,800 new police officers. She finished on 1,800 new police officers. I She finished on 1,800 new police officers. I say She finished on 1,800 new police officers. I say again, She finished on 1,800 new police officers. I say again, I She finished on 1,800 new police officers. I say again, I thought officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda Ardern officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda Ardern we officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda Ardern we were officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda Ardern we were going officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda Ardern we were going to officers. I say again, I thought Jacinda Ardern we were going to have Jacinda Ardern we were going to have a Jacinda Ardern we were going to have a facts-based Jacinda Ardern we were going to have a facts-based campaign Jacinda Ardern we were going to have a facts-based campaign this Jacinda Ardern we were going to have a facts-based campaign this year. Jacinda Ardern we were going to have a facts-based campaign this year. If a facts-based campaign this year. If you a facts-based campaign this year. If you don't a facts-based campaign this year. If you don't like a facts-based campaign this year. If you don't like what a facts-based campaign this year. If you don't like what you a facts-based campaign this year. If you don't like what you promised, you don't like what you promised, just you don't like what you promised, just change you don't like what you promised, just change the you don't like what you promised, just change the target. you don't like what you promised, just change the target. Pretend you don't like what you promised, just change the target. Pretend this just change the target. Pretend this nothing just change the target. Pretend this nothing happened. just change the target. Pretend this nothing happened. Say just change the target. Pretend this nothing happened. Say black just change the target. Pretend this nothing happened. Say black is just change the target. Pretend this nothing happened. Say black is white nothing happened. Say black is white and nothing happened. Say black is white and white nothing happened. Say black is white and white is nothing happened. Say black is white and white is black nothing happened. Say black is white and white is black and nothing happened. Say black is white and white is black and hold nothing happened. Say black is white and white is black and hold up nothing happened. Say black is white and white is black and hold up a and white is black and hold up a graph and white is black and hold up a graph that and white is black and hold up a graph that is and white is black and hold up a graph that is blank and white is black and hold up a graph that is blank and and white is black and hold up a graph that is blank and red. and white is black and hold up a graph that is blank and red. That graph that is blank and red. That supposedly graph that is blank and red. That supposedly means graph that is blank and red. That supposedly means something. graph that is blank and red. That supposedly means something. They supposedly means something. They said supposedly means something. They said they supposedly means something. They said they will supposedly means something. They said they will deliver, supposedly means something. They said they will deliver, while supposedly means something. They said they will deliver, while we supposedly means something. They said they will deliver, while we are said they will deliver, while we are on said they will deliver, while we are on promises, said they will deliver, while we are on promises, 100% said they will deliver, while we are on promises, 100% early said they will deliver, while we are on promises, 100% early childhood on promises, 100% early childhood qualified on promises, 100% early childhood qualified teachers. on promises, 100% early childhood qualified teachers. Where on promises, 100% early childhood qualified teachers. Where is on promises, 100% early childhood qualified teachers. Where is it? qualified teachers. Where is it? Today qualified teachers. Where is it? Today we qualified teachers. Where is it? Today we hear, qualified teachers. Where is it? Today we hear, we qualified teachers. Where is it? Today we hear, we are qualified teachers. Where is it? Today we hear, we are waiting qualified teachers. Where is it? Today we hear, we are waiting longer Today we hear, we are waiting longer and Today we hear, we are waiting longer and longer Today we hear, we are waiting longer and longer and Today we hear, we are waiting longer and longer and lodger Today we hear, we are waiting longer and longer and lodger for Today we hear, we are waiting longer and longer and lodger for children and longer and lodger for children with and longer and lodger for children with special and longer and lodger for children with special needs and longer and lodger for children with special needs who and longer and lodger for children with special needs who need and longer and lodger for children with special needs who need special with special needs who need special attention with special needs who need special attention in with special needs who need special attention in our with special needs who need special attention in our schools. with special needs who need special attention in our schools. 1 with special needs who need special attention in our schools. 1 billion attention in our schools. 1 billion tree attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - where attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - where are attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - where are they? attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - where are they? The attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - where are they? The best attention in our schools. 1 billion tree - where are they? The best he's tree - where are they? The best he's give tree - where are they? The best he's give even tree - where are they? The best he's give even us tree - where are they? The best he's give even us is tree - where are they? The best he's give even us is a tree - where are they? The best he's give even us is a small tree - where are they? The best he's give even us is a small dying tree - where are they? The best he's give even us is a small dying shrub give even us is a small dying shrub and give even us is a small dying shrub and someone give even us is a small dying shrub and someone paid give even us is a small dying shrub and someone paid a give even us is a small dying shrub and someone paid a donation give even us is a small dying shrub and someone paid a donation for give even us is a small dying shrub and someone paid a donation for it, and someone paid a donation for it, Mr and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, but and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, but that and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, but that is and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, but that is the and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, but that is the way and someone paid a donation for it, Mr Speaker, but that is the way it Mr Speaker, but that is the way it goes. Mr Speaker, but that is the way it goes. They Mr Speaker, but that is the way it goes. They have Mr Speaker, but that is the way it goes. They have been Mr Speaker, but that is the way it goes. They have been so Mr Speaker, but that is the way it goes. They have been so incompetent. goes. They have been so incompetent. They goes. They have been so incompetent. They haven't goes. They have been so incompetent. They haven't delivered goes. They have been so incompetent. They haven't delivered and goes. They have been so incompetent. They haven't delivered and they goes. They have been so incompetent. They haven't delivered and they are They haven't delivered and they are for They haven't delivered and they are for managing They haven't delivered and they are for managing the They haven't delivered and they are for managing the economy They haven't delivered and they are for managing the economy at They haven't delivered and they are for managing the economy at all for managing the economy at all well. for managing the economy at all well. In for managing the economy at all well. In fact, for managing the economy at all well. In fact, with for managing the economy at all well. In fact, with see for managing the economy at all well. In fact, with see things for managing the economy at all well. In fact, with see things going well. In fact, with see things going become well. In fact, with see things going become wards, well. In fact, with see things going become wards, a well. In fact, with see things going become wards, a situation well. In fact, with see things going become wards, a situation where become wards, a situation where decades become wards, a situation where decades of become wards, a situation where decades of surpluses become wards, a situation where decades of surpluses actually become wards, a situation where decades of surpluses actually as become wards, a situation where decades of surpluses actually as far decades of surpluses actually as far as decades of surpluses actually as far as the decades of surpluses actually as far as the eye decades of surpluses actually as far as the eye can decades of surpluses actually as far as the eye can see, decades of surpluses actually as far as the eye can see, according decades of surpluses actually as far as the eye can see, according to as the eye can see, according to Treasury. as the eye can see, according to Treasury. The as the eye can see, according to Treasury. The legacy as the eye can see, according to Treasury. The legacy of as the eye can see, according to Treasury. The legacy of John as the eye can see, according to Treasury. The legacy of John Key as the eye can see, according to Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Bill Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Bill English Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Bill English a Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Bill English a situation Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Bill English a situation from Treasury. The legacy of John Key and Bill English a situation from where Bill English a situation from where GFC Bill English a situation from where GFC we Bill English a situation from where GFC we within Bill English a situation from where GFC we within to Bill English a situation from where GFC we within to prosperity Bill English a situation from where GFC we within to prosperity and Bill English a situation from where GFC we within to prosperity and now GFC we within to prosperity and now they GFC we within to prosperity and now they have GFC we within to prosperity and now they have got GFC we within to prosperity and now they have got us GFC we within to prosperity and now they have got us back GFC we within to prosperity and now they have got us back in GFC we within to prosperity and now they have got us back in deficit. GFC we within to prosperity and now they have got us back in deficit. If they have got us back in deficit. If Grant they have got us back in deficit. If Grant Robertson they have got us back in deficit. If Grant Robertson was they have got us back in deficit. If Grant Robertson was here... they have got us back in deficit. If Grant Robertson was here... Order! Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The member Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The member knows Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The member knows he Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The member knows he is Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The member knows he is out Grant Robertson was here... Order! Order! The member knows he is out of Order! The member knows he is out of order. Order! The member knows he is out of order. Or Order! The member knows he is out of order. Or he Order! The member knows he is out of order. Or he should. Order! The member knows he is out of order. Or he should. And Order! The member knows he is out of order. Or he should. And Grant order. Or he should. And Grant Robertson order. Or he should. And Grant Robertson will order. Or he should. And Grant Robertson will tell order. Or he should. And Grant Robertson will tell us order. Or he should. And Grant Robertson will tell us that order. Or he should. And Grant Robertson will tell us that the Robertson will tell us that the situation Robertson will tell us that the situation that Robertson will tell us that the situation that deficit, Robertson will tell us that the situation that deficit, "No, Robertson will tell us that the situation that deficit, "No, we Robertson will tell us that the situation that deficit, "No, we will situation that deficit, "No, we will be situation that deficit, "No, we will be back situation that deficit, "No, we will be back in situation that deficit, "No, we will be back in surpluses situation that deficit, "No, we will be back in surpluses soon." situation that deficit, "No, we will be back in surpluses soon." One be back in surpluses soon." One thing be back in surpluses soon." One thing I be back in surpluses soon." One thing I know be back in surpluses soon." One thing I know about be back in surpluses soon." One thing I know about Labour be back in surpluses soon." One thing I know about Labour Parties be back in surpluses soon." One thing I know about Labour Parties is thing I know about Labour Parties is once thing I know about Labour Parties is once you thing I know about Labour Parties is once you are thing I know about Labour Parties is once you are in thing I know about Labour Parties is once you are in deaf thing I know about Labour Parties is once you are in deaf set thing I know about Labour Parties is once you are in deaf set they thing I know about Labour Parties is once you are in deaf set they never once you are in deaf set they never go once you are in deaf set they never go back. once you are in deaf set they never go back. They once you are in deaf set they never go back. They have once you are in deaf set they never go back. They have a once you are in deaf set they never go back. They have a taste once you are in deaf set they never go back. They have a taste for go back. They have a taste for wasteful go back. They have a taste for wasteful spending go back. They have a taste for wasteful spending and go back. They have a taste for wasteful spending and that go back. They have a taste for wasteful spending and that is go back. They have a taste for wasteful spending and that is the wasteful spending and that is the situation. wasteful spending and that is the situation. We wasteful spending and that is the situation. We will wasteful spending and that is the situation. We will see wasteful spending and that is the situation. We will see Jacinda situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern at situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern at this situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern at this budget. situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern at this budget. You situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern at this budget. You have situation. We will see Jacinda Ardern at this budget. You have been Ardern at this budget. You have been be Ardern at this budget. You have been be quoeted Ardern at this budget. You have been be quoeted a Ardern at this budget. You have been be quoeted a fantastic Ardern at this budget. You have been be quoeted a fantastic legacy Ardern at this budget. You have been be quoeted a fantastic legacy and be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you have be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you have failed be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you have failed to be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you have failed to deliver be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you have failed to deliver and be quoeted a fantastic legacy and you have failed to deliver and you you have failed to deliver and you have you have failed to deliver and you have squandered you have failed to deliver and you have squandered it you have failed to deliver and you have squandered it in you have failed to deliver and you have squandered it in just you have failed to deliver and you have squandered it in just three have squandered it in just three short have squandered it in just three short years. have squandered it in just three short years. There have squandered it in just three short years. There years have squandered it in just three short years. There years ago have squandered it in just three short years. There years ago our short years. There years ago our economy short years. There years ago our economy was short years. There years ago our economy was agreeing short years. There years ago our economy was agreeing at short years. There years ago our economy was agreeing at nearly short years. There years ago our economy was agreeing at nearly 8% economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. We economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. We are economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. We are now economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. We are now almost economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. We are now almost half economy was agreeing at nearly 8% per annum. We are now almost half -- per annum. We are now almost half -- growing per annum. We are now almost half -- growing at per annum. We are now almost half -- growing at nearly per annum. We are now almost half -- growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are now almost half -- growing at nearly 8% per per annum. We are now almost half -- growing at nearly 8% per annum. per annum. We are now almost half -- growing at nearly 8% per annum. We growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are half growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are half of growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are half of that. growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are half of that. Cost growing at nearly 8% per annum. We are half of that. Cost and are half of that. Cost and regulation. are half of that. Cost and regulation. You are half of that. Cost and regulation. You want are half of that. Cost and regulation. You want to are half of that. Cost and regulation. You want to go are half of that. Cost and regulation. You want to go through regulation. You want to go through the regulation. You want to go through the taxes? regulation. You want to go through the taxes? Huh? regulation. You want to go through the taxes? Huh? Oh, regulation. You want to go through the taxes? Huh? Oh, you regulation. You want to go through the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want regulation. You want to go through the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to regulation. You want to go through the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why is the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why is one the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why is one of the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why is one of your the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why is one of your MPs the taxes? Huh? Oh, you want to talk about, why is one of your MPs been about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, Mr about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, Mr Davis? about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, Mr Davis? Why about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, Mr Davis? Why is about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the about, why is one of your MPs been challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over here challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over here who challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over here who only challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over here who only has challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over here who only has been challenged, Mr Davis? Why is the guy over here who only has been in over here who only has been in Parliament over here who only has been in Parliament about over here who only has been in Parliament about 5 over here who only has been in Parliament about 5 minutes over here who only has been in Parliament about 5 minutes going over here who only has been in Parliament about 5 minutes going on Parliament about 5 minutes going on the Parliament about 5 minutes going on the list Parliament about 5 minutes going on the list because Parliament about 5 minutes going on the list because he Parliament about 5 minutes going on the list because he can't Parliament about 5 minutes going on the list because he can't hack Parliament about 5 minutes going on the list because he can't hack it?! the list because he can't hack it?! I the list because he can't hack it?! I thought the list because he can't hack it?! I thought he the list because he can't hack it?! I thought he was the list because he can't hack it?! I thought he was one the list because he can't hack it?! I thought he was one of the list because he can't hack it?! I thought he was one of the the list because he can't hack it?! I thought he was one of the tough I thought he was one of the tough guys. I thought he was one of the tough guys. One I thought he was one of the tough guys. One of I thought he was one of the tough guys. One of the I thought he was one of the tough guys. One of the good I thought he was one of the tough guys. One of the good guys. I thought he was one of the tough guys. One of the good guys. This I thought he was one of the tough guys. One of the good guys. This is guys. One of the good guys. This is a guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy who guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy who wants guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy who wants to guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy who wants to run guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy who wants to run these guys. One of the good guys. This is a guy who wants to run these things a guy who wants to run these things when a guy who wants to run these things when we a guy who wants to run these things when we know a guy who wants to run these things when we know the a guy who wants to run these things when we know the situation. a guy who wants to run these things when we know the situation. We a guy who wants to run these things when we know the situation. We have when we know the situation. We have slept, when we know the situation. We have slept, Mr when we know the situation. We have slept, Mr Speaker, when we know the situation. We have slept, Mr Speaker, we when we know the situation. We have slept, Mr Speaker, we have when we know the situation. We have slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped down slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped down the slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped down the GDP slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped down the GDP per slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped down the GDP per capital slept, Mr Speaker, we have slipped down the GDP per capital tables down the GDP per capital tables behind down the GDP per capital tables behind Chile, down the GDP per capital tables behind Chile, Hungary, down the GDP per capital tables behind Chile, Hungary, Poland, behind Chile, Hungary, Poland, Latvia, behind Chile, Hungary, Poland, Latvia, esstolen behind Chile, Hungary, Poland, Latvia, esstolen yes, behind Chile, Hungary, Poland, Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania behind Chile, Hungary, Poland, Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Spain. Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Spain. Even Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Spain. Even Greece. Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Spain. Even Greece. Was Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Spain. Even Greece. Was it Latvia, esstolen yes, Lithuania and Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Peters Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Peters who Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Peters who spoke Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Peters who spoke about Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Peters who spoke about a Spain. Even Greece. Was it Winston Peters who spoke about a polish Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? I Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? I think Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? I think it Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? I think it was Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? I think it was his Peters who spoke about a polish shipyard? I think it was his ment shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. That shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. That is shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. That is where shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. That is where we shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. That is where we are shipyard? I think it was his ment tor. That is where we are going tor. That is where we are going under tor. That is where we are going under this tor. That is where we are going under this government. tor. That is where we are going under this government. We tor. That is where we are going under this government. We are under this government. We are slipping under this government. We are slipping behind under this government. We are slipping behind and under this government. We are slipping behind and Ron under this government. We are slipping behind and Ron Mark under this government. We are slipping behind and Ron Mark you under this government. We are slipping behind and Ron Mark you may slipping behind and Ron Mark you may be slipping behind and Ron Mark you may be laughing, slipping behind and Ron Mark you may be laughing, but slipping behind and Ron Mark you may be laughing, but New slipping behind and Ron Mark you may be laughing, but New Zealanders be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. On be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. On this be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. On this side be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. On this side of be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. On this side of the be laughing, but New Zealanders aren't. On this side of the House, aren't. On this side of the House, we aren't. On this side of the House, we have aren't. On this side of the House, we have a aren't. On this side of the House, we have a plan aren't. On this side of the House, we have a plan to aren't. On this side of the House, we have a plan to fix aren't. On this side of the House, we have a plan to fix that aren't. On this side of the House, we have a plan to fix that that we have a plan to fix that that involves we have a plan to fix that that involves giving we have a plan to fix that that involves giving more we have a plan to fix that that involves giving more money we have a plan to fix that that involves giving more money to we have a plan to fix that that involves giving more money to people involves giving more money to people as involves giving more money to people as pockets. involves giving more money to people as pockets. Making involves giving more money to people as pockets. Making a involves giving more money to people as pockets. Making a stronger as pockets. Making a stronger economy. as pockets. Making a stronger economy. Actually as pockets. Making a stronger economy. Actually building as pockets. Making a stronger economy. Actually building the economy. Actually building the infrastructure. economy. Actually building the infrastructure. Let's economy. Actually building the infrastructure. Let's actually economy. Actually building the infrastructure. Let's actually do infrastructure. Let's actually do this, infrastructure. Let's actually do this, Stuart infrastructure. Let's actually do this, Stuart Nash. infrastructure. Let's actually do this, Stuart Nash. Let's infrastructure. Let's actually do this, Stuart Nash. Let's - infrastructure. Let's actually do this, Stuart Nash. Let's - and this, Stuart Nash. Let's - and making this, Stuart Nash. Let's - and making communities this, Stuart Nash. Let's - and making communities safer. this, Stuart Nash. Let's - and making communities safer. I this, Stuart Nash. Let's - and making communities safer. I see making communities safer. I see Stuart making communities safer. I see Stuart Nash making communities safer. I see Stuart Nash over making communities safer. I see Stuart Nash over there making communities safer. I see Stuart Nash over there and making communities safer. I see Stuart Nash over there and a Stuart Nash over there and a situation Stuart Nash over there and a situation where Stuart Nash over there and a situation where right Stuart Nash over there and a situation where right now Stuart Nash over there and a situation where right now around Stuart Nash over there and a situation where right now around New situation where right now around New Zealand situation where right now around New Zealand and situation where right now around New Zealand and in situation where right now around New Zealand and in his situation where right now around New Zealand and in his electorate situation where right now around New Zealand and in his electorate there Zealand and in his electorate there is Zealand and in his electorate there is op-gang Zealand and in his electorate there is op-gang warfare. Zealand and in his electorate there is op-gang warfare. 50 Zealand and in his electorate there is op-gang warfare. 50 gain Zealand and in his electorate there is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members brawling is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members brawling a is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members brawling a few is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members brawling a few weeks is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members brawling a few weeks ago, is op-gang warfare. 50 gain members brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart Nash. brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart Nash. 50. brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart Nash. 50. AK-47s. brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How brawling a few weeks ago, Stuart Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many were Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many were arrested? Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many were arrested? Four, Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many were arrested? Four, I Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many were arrested? Four, I am Nash. 50. AK-47s. Guns. How many were arrested? Four, I am told. were arrested? Four, I am told. Because were arrested? Four, I am told. Because under were arrested? Four, I am told. Because under Stuart were arrested? Four, I am told. Because under Stuart Nash were arrested? Four, I am told. Because under Stuart Nash we were arrested? Four, I am told. Because under Stuart Nash we have were arrested? Four, I am told. Because under Stuart Nash we have a Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag and Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag and release Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag and release policy Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag and release policy that Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag and release policy that is Because under Stuart Nash we have a tag and release policy that is not tag and release policy that is not going tag and release policy that is not going to tag and release policy that is not going to work, tag and release policy that is not going to work, Mr tag and release policy that is not going to work, Mr Speaker. tag and release policy that is not going to work, Mr Speaker. New going to work, Mr Speaker. New Zealanders going to work, Mr Speaker. New Zealanders deserve going to work, Mr Speaker. New Zealanders deserve better going to work, Mr Speaker. New Zealanders deserve better than going to work, Mr Speaker. New Zealanders deserve better than this Zealanders deserve better than this government. Zealanders deserve better than this government. They Zealanders deserve better than this government. They deserve Zealanders deserve better than this government. They deserve a Zealanders deserve better than this government. They deserve a strong government. They deserve a strong economy government. They deserve a strong economy to government. They deserve a strong economy to build government. They deserve a strong economy to build the government. They deserve a strong economy to build the roads, government. They deserve a strong economy to build the roads, to government. They deserve a strong economy to build the roads, to do economy to build the roads, to do first-class economy to build the roads, to do first-class infrastructure, economy to build the roads, to do first-class infrastructure, to economy to build the roads, to do first-class infrastructure, to build first-class infrastructure, to build the first-class infrastructure, to build the world-class first-class infrastructure, to build the world-class schools. first-class infrastructure, to build the world-class schools. They the world-class schools. They deserve the world-class schools. They deserve financial the world-class schools. They deserve financial security, the world-class schools. They deserve financial security, so the world-class schools. They deserve financial security, so that deserve financial security, so that with deserve financial security, so that with can deserve financial security, so that with can look deserve financial security, so that with can look after deserve financial security, so that with can look after their deserve financial security, so that with can look after their families with can look after their families and with can look after their families and good with can look after their families and good and with can look after their families and good and bad with can look after their families and good and bad times. with can look after their families and good and bad times. They with can look after their families and good and bad times. They deserve and good and bad times. They deserve the and good and bad times. They deserve the ability and good and bad times. They deserve the ability the and good and bad times. They deserve the ability the fill and good and bad times. They deserve the ability the fill up and good and bad times. They deserve the ability the fill up their and good and bad times. They deserve the ability the fill up their petrol the ability the fill up their petrol tank the ability the fill up their petrol tank and the ability the fill up their petrol tank and to the ability the fill up their petrol tank and to have the ability the fill up their petrol tank and to have a the ability the fill up their petrol tank and to have a better the ability the fill up their petrol tank and to have a better cost the ability the fill up their petrol tank and to have a better cost of tank and to have a better cost of living tank and to have a better cost of living in tank and to have a better cost of living in this tank and to have a better cost of living in this country. tank and to have a better cost of living in this country. They tank and to have a better cost of living in this country. They deserve living in this country. They deserve the living in this country. They deserve the vienl living in this country. They deserve the vienl that living in this country. They deserve the vienl that Jacinda living in this country. They deserve the vienl that Jacinda Ardern living in this country. They deserve the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James Shaw the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James Shaw talk the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James Shaw talk so the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James Shaw talk so much the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James Shaw talk so much about the vienl that Jacinda Ardern and James Shaw talk so much about that James Shaw talk so much about that have James Shaw talk so much about that have soon James Shaw talk so much about that have soon emissions James Shaw talk so much about that have soon emissions going James Shaw talk so much about that have soon emissions going down James Shaw talk so much about that have soon emissions going down under have soon emissions going down under us have soon emissions going down under us to have soon emissions going down under us to up have soon emissions going down under us to up under have soon emissions going down under us to up under them, have soon emissions going down under us to up under them, Mr have soon emissions going down under us to up under them, Mr Speaker. us to up under them, Mr Speaker. Cool us to up under them, Mr Speaker. Cool Vin us to up under them, Mr Speaker. Cool Vin Davis us to up under them, Mr Speaker. Cool Vin Davis keeps us to up under them, Mr Speaker. Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and he Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and he obviously Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and he obviously didn't Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and he obviously didn't get Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and he obviously didn't get the Cool Vin Davis keeps interjecting and he obviously didn't get the Mem and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo they and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo they send and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo they send around and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo they send around before and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo they send around before about and he obviously didn't get the Mem mo they send around before about not mo they send around before about not doing mo they send around before about not doing that. mo they send around before about not doing that. He mo they send around before about not doing that. He never mo they send around before about not doing that. He never was mo they send around before about not doing that. He never was the mo they send around before about not doing that. He never was the smart doing that. He never was the smart doing doing that. He never was the smart one in the doing that. He never was the smart one in the class,let's doing that. He never was the smart one in the class,let's be doing that. He never was the smart one in the class,let's be honest one in the class,let's be honest about one in the class,let's be honest about that. one in the class,let's be honest about that. But one in the class,let's be honest about that. But here one in the class,let's be honest about that. But here is one in the class,let's be honest about that. But here is the one in the class,let's be honest about that. But here is the thing one in the class,let's be honest about that. But here is the thing - about that. But here is the thing - some about that. But here is the thing - some say, about that. But here is the thing - some say, some about that. But here is the thing - some say, some say, about that. But here is the thing - some say, some say, some about that. But here is the thing - some say, some say, some say... some say, some say, some say... Order! some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! . some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! . I some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! . I am some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! . I am going some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! . I am going the some say, some say, some say... Order! Order! . I am going the now Order! Order! . I am going the now ask Order! Order! . I am going the now ask both Order! Order! . I am going the now ask both sides Order! Order! . I am going the now ask both sides to Order! Order! . I am going the now ask both sides to settle Order! Order! . I am going the now ask both sides to settle down. Order! Order! . I am going the now ask both sides to settle down. When ask both sides to settle down. When I ask both sides to settle down. When I am ask both sides to settle down. When I am on ask both sides to settle down. When I am on my ask both sides to settle down. When I am on my feet, ask both sides to settle down. When I am on my feet, the ask both sides to settle down. When I am on my feet, the member ask both sides to settle down. When I am on my feet, the member will I am on my feet, the member will sit. I am on my feet, the member will sit. That I am on my feet, the member will sit. That might I am on my feet, the member will sit. That might not I am on my feet, the member will sit. That might not have I am on my feet, the member will sit. That might not have been I am on my feet, the member will sit. That might not have been in I am on my feet, the member will sit. That might not have been in the sit. That might not have been in the best sit. That might not have been in the best taste, sit. That might not have been in the best taste, but sit. That might not have been in the best taste, but it sit. That might not have been in the best taste, but it does sit. That might not have been in the best taste, but it does set sit. That might not have been in the best taste, but it does set the sit. That might not have been in the best taste, but it does set the tone best taste, but it does set the tone for best taste, but it does set the tone for the best taste, but it does set the tone for the debate best taste, but it does set the tone for the debate and best taste, but it does set the tone for the debate and Ile best taste, but it does set the tone for the debate and Ile a best taste, but it does set the tone for the debate and Ile a geeing best taste, but it does set the tone for the debate and Ile a geeing to for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask the for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask the member for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask the member to for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask the member to continue, for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask the member to continue, but for the debate and Ile a geeing to ask the member to continue, but some ask the member to continue, but some of ask the member to continue, but some of those ask the member to continue, but some of those interjections ask the member to continue, but some of those interjections are ask the member to continue, but some of those interjections are to ask the member to continue, but some of those interjections are to stop of those interjections are to stop as of those interjections are to stop as well. of those interjections are to stop as well. Not of those interjections are to stop as well. Not that of those interjections are to stop as well. Not that member, of those interjections are to stop as well. Not that member, the of those interjections are to stop as well. Not that member, the ones as well. Not that member, the ones in as well. Not that member, the ones in reaction as well. Not that member, the ones in reaction to as well. Not that member, the ones in reaction to what as well. Not that member, the ones in reaction to what the as well. Not that member, the ones in reaction to what the minister in reaction to what the minister said. in reaction to what the minister said. Some in reaction to what the minister said. Some say in reaction to what the minister said. Some say that in reaction to what the minister said. Some say that none in reaction to what the minister said. Some say that none - in reaction to what the minister said. Some say that none - tie in reaction to what the minister said. Some say that none - tie toy said. Some say that none - tie toy tie said. Some say that none - tie toy tie can't said. Some say that none - tie toy tie can't do said. Some say that none - tie toy tie can't do any said. Some say that none - tie toy tie can't do any infrastructure. tie can't do any infrastructure. Carmel tie can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni tie can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has tie can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted tie can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about tie can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about -- Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about -- Phil Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about -- Phil Twyford Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about -- Phil Twyford can't Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about -- Phil Twyford can't do Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about -- Phil Twyford can't do any Phil Twyford can't do any infrastructure. Phil Twyford can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Phil Twyford can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni Phil Twyford can't do any infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about getting infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about getting things infrastructure. Carmel Sepuloni has boasted about getting things under boasted about getting things under criminal boasted about getting things under criminal but boasted about getting things under criminal but people boasted about getting things under criminal but people are boasted about getting things under criminal but people are still criminal but people are still languishing criminal but people are still languishing under criminal but people are still languishing under the criminal but people are still languishing under the doll. criminal but people are still languishing under the doll. David languishing under the doll. David Clerk languishing under the doll. David Clerk sends languishing under the doll. David Clerk sends out languishing under the doll. David Clerk sends out the languishing under the doll. David Clerk sends out the front languishing under the doll. David Clerk sends out the front on Clerk sends out the front on coronavirus Clerk sends out the front on coronavirus and Clerk sends out the front on coronavirus and he Clerk sends out the front on coronavirus and he is Clerk sends out the front on coronavirus and he is missing Clerk sends out the front on coronavirus and he is missing in coronavirus and he is missing in action. coronavirus and he is missing in action. Somehow coronavirus and he is missing in action. Somehow these coronavirus and he is missing in action. Somehow these are coronavirus and he is missing in action. Somehow these are not coronavirus and he is missing in action. Somehow these are not her action. Somehow these are not her problem. action. Somehow these are not her problem. I action. Somehow these are not her problem. I say action. Somehow these are not her problem. I say let's action. Somehow these are not her problem. I say let's stop action. Somehow these are not her problem. I say let's stop making problem. I say let's stop making excuses problem. I say let's stop making excuses for problem. I say let's stop making excuses for Jacinda problem. I say let's stop making excuses for Jacinda Ardern. problem. I say let's stop making excuses for Jacinda Ardern. Leaders excuses for Jacinda Ardern. Leaders lead. excuses for Jacinda Ardern. Leaders lead. Actually excuses for Jacinda Ardern. Leaders lead. Actually leaders excuses for Jacinda Ardern. Leaders lead. Actually leaders get excuses for Jacinda Ardern. Leaders lead. Actually leaders get things lead. Actually leaders get things done lead. Actually leaders get things done and lead. Actually leaders get things done and New lead. Actually leaders get things done and New Zealanders lead. Actually leaders get things done and New Zealanders know lead. Actually leaders get things done and New Zealanders know - lead. Actually leaders get things done and New Zealanders know - and done and New Zealanders know - and she done and New Zealanders know - and she laughs done and New Zealanders know - and she laughs about done and New Zealanders know - and she laughs about that. done and New Zealanders know - and she laughs about that. Where done and New Zealanders know - and she laughs about that. Where has done and New Zealanders know - and she laughs about that. Where has her she laughs about that. Where has her minister she laughs about that. Where has her minister been she laughs about that. Where has her minister been on she laughs about that. Where has her minister been on coronavirus? she laughs about that. Where has her minister been on coronavirus? Where minister been on coronavirus? Where has minister been on coronavirus? Where has Phil minister been on coronavirus? Where has Phil Twyford minister been on coronavirus? Where has Phil Twyford been? minister been on coronavirus? Where has Phil Twyford been? Where minister been on coronavirus? Where has Phil Twyford been? Where has minister been on coronavirus? Where has Phil Twyford been? Where has the has Phil Twyford been? Where has the Minister has Phil Twyford been? Where has the Minister for has Phil Twyford been? Where has the Minister for Housing, has Phil Twyford been? Where has the Minister for Housing, the has Phil Twyford been? Where has the Minister for Housing, the new has Phil Twyford been? Where has the Minister for Housing, the new one, Minister for Housing, the new one, the Minister for Housing, the new one, the next Minister for Housing, the new one, the next one, Minister for Housing, the new one, the next one, been Minister for Housing, the new one, the next one, been on Minister for Housing, the new one, the next one, been on these Minister for Housing, the new one, the next one, been on these issues? the next one, been on these issues? They the next one, been on these issues? They have the next one, been on these issues? They have been the next one, been on these issues? They have been out the next one, been on these issues? They have been out for the next one, been on these issues? They have been out for the the next one, been on these issues? They have been out for the count, the next one, been on these issues? They have been out for the count, Mr They have been out for the count, Mr Speaker. They have been out for the count, Mr Speaker. The They have been out for the count, Mr Speaker. The National They have been out for the count, Mr Speaker. The National Party They have been out for the count, Mr Speaker. The National Party has They have been out for the count, Mr Speaker. The National Party has a Speaker. The National Party has a plan. Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We have Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We have a Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We have a very Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We have a very clear Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We have a very clear plan. Speaker. The National Party has a plan. We have a very clear plan. It plan. We have a very clear plan. It is plan. We have a very clear plan. It is not plan. We have a very clear plan. It is not a plan. We have a very clear plan. It is not a complicated plan. We have a very clear plan. It is not a complicated plan. plan. We have a very clear plan. It is not a complicated plan. It is not a complicated plan. It doesn't is not a complicated plan. It doesn't involve is not a complicated plan. It doesn't involve fake is not a complicated plan. It doesn't involve fake news is not a complicated plan. It doesn't involve fake news and is not a complicated plan. It doesn't involve fake news and graphs doesn't involve fake news and graphs that doesn't involve fake news and graphs that are doesn't involve fake news and graphs that are "based doesn't involve fake news and graphs that are "based on doesn't involve fake news and graphs that are "based on Treasury", doesn't involve fake news and graphs that are "based on Treasury", but that are "based on Treasury", but actually that are "based on Treasury", but actually she that are "based on Treasury", but actually she has that are "based on Treasury", but actually she has added that are "based on Treasury", but actually she has added to that are "based on Treasury", but actually she has added to and that are "based on Treasury", but actually she has added to and they actually she has added to and they laugh. actually she has added to and they laugh. And actually she has added to and they laugh. And they actually she has added to and they laugh. And they laugh. actually she has added to and they laugh. And they laugh. Because actually she has added to and they laugh. And they laugh. Because right laugh. And they laugh. Because right at laugh. And they laugh. Because right at the laugh. And they laugh. Because right at the start laugh. And they laugh. Because right at the start of laugh. And they laugh. Because right at the start of this laugh. And they laugh. Because right at the start of this year laugh. And they laugh. Because right at the start of this year Jacinda at the start of this year Jacinda Ardern at the start of this year Jacinda Ardern went at the start of this year Jacinda Ardern went out at the start of this year Jacinda Ardern went out with at the start of this year Jacinda Ardern went out with a at the start of this year Jacinda Ardern went out with a transparency Ardern went out with a transparency toll. Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She said Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She said she Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She said she was Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She said she was going Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She said she was going to Ardern went out with a transparency toll. She said she was going to be toll. She said she was going to be the toll. She said she was going to be the most toll. She said she was going to be the most transparent toll. She said she was going to be the most transparent in toll. She said she was going to be the most transparent in all toll. She said she was going to be the most transparent in all of toll. She said she was going to be the most transparent in all of these the most transparent in all of these things. the most transparent in all of these things. Well, the most transparent in all of these things. Well, right the most transparent in all of these things. Well, right new the most transparent in all of these things. Well, right new they the most transparent in all of these things. Well, right new they are things. Well, right new they are pedalling things. Well, right new they are pedalling paid things. Well, right new they are pedalling paid advertisements things. Well, right new they are pedalling paid advertisements all pedalling paid advertisements all over pedalling paid advertisements all over Facebook, pedalling paid advertisements all over Facebook, bigger pedalling paid advertisements all over Facebook, bigger New pedalling paid advertisements all over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for money over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for money for over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for money for the over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for money for the Labour over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for money for the Labour Party. over Facebook, bigger New Zealanders for money for the Labour Party. Have for money for the Labour Party. Have they for money for the Labour Party. Have they signed for money for the Labour Party. Have they signed up for money for the Labour Party. Have they signed up to for money for the Labour Party. Have they signed up to the for money for the Labour Party. Have they signed up to the transparent they signed up to the transparent tool? they signed up to the transparent tool? No. they signed up to the transparent tool? No. Has they signed up to the transparent tool? No. Has Jacinda they signed up to the transparent tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern they signed up to the transparent tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up for tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up for her tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up for her perform tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up for her perform page? tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up for her perform page? Has tool? No. Has Jacinda Ardern signed up for her perform page? Has the up for her perform page? Has the Labour up for her perform page? Has the Labour Party? up for her perform page? Has the Labour Party? Has up for her perform page? Has the Labour Party? Has the up for her perform page? Has the Labour Party? Has the government? Labour Party? Has the government? No, Labour Party? Has the government? No, they Labour Party? Has the government? No, they haven't! Labour Party? Has the government? No, they haven't! That Labour Party? Has the government? No, they haven't! That was Labour Party? Has the government? No, they haven't! That was the Labour Party? Has the government? No, they haven't! That was the big No, they haven't! That was the big song No, they haven't! That was the big song and No, they haven't! That was the big song and dance No, they haven't! That was the big song and dance and No, they haven't! That was the big song and dance and they No, they haven't! That was the big song and dance and they haven't. No, they haven't! That was the big song and dance and they haven't. You song and dance and they haven't. You see, song and dance and they haven't. You see, on song and dance and they haven't. You see, on this song and dance and they haven't. You see, on this side song and dance and they haven't. You see, on this side of song and dance and they haven't. You see, on this side of the song and dance and they haven't. You see, on this side of the House song and dance and they haven't. You see, on this side of the House New see, on this side of the House New Zealanders see, on this side of the House New Zealanders know, see, on this side of the House New Zealanders know, like see, on this side of the House New Zealanders know, like Bill see, on this side of the House New Zealanders know, like Bill English Zealanders know, like Bill English dish Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and John Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and John Coup Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and John Coup did, Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and John Coup did, I Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and John Coup did, I will. Zealanders know, like Bill English dish and John Coup did, I will. We dish and John Coup did, I will. We will dish and John Coup did, I will. We will deliver dish and John Coup did, I will. We will deliver a dish and John Coup did, I will. We will deliver a stronger dish and John Coup did, I will. We will deliver a stronger economy. dish and John Coup did, I will. We will deliver a stronger economy. We will deliver a stronger economy. We know will deliver a stronger economy. We know in will deliver a stronger economy. We know in uncertain will deliver a stronger economy. We know in uncertain times will deliver a stronger economy. We know in uncertain times what will deliver a stronger economy. We know in uncertain times what to will deliver a stronger economy. We know in uncertain times what to do. know in uncertain times what to do. We know in uncertain times what to do. We will know in uncertain times what to do. We will provide know in uncertain times what to do. We will provide the know in uncertain times what to do. We will provide the tax know in uncertain times what to do. We will provide the tax relief know in uncertain times what to do. We will provide the tax relief that We will provide the tax relief that is We will provide the tax relief that is required We will provide the tax relief that is required and We will provide the tax relief that is required and we We will provide the tax relief that is required and we have We will provide the tax relief that is required and we have already is required and we have already started is required and we have already started laying is required and we have already started laying out is required and we have already started laying out that is required and we have already started laying out that map. is required and we have already started laying out that map. We is required and we have already started laying out that map. We will started laying out that map. We will make started laying out that map. We will make sure started laying out that map. We will make sure there started laying out that map. We will make sure there is started laying out that map. We will make sure there is less started laying out that map. We will make sure there is less regulation make sure there is less regulation for make sure there is less regulation for small make sure there is less regulation for small businesses make sure there is less regulation for small businesses and make sure there is less regulation for small businesses and we will make sure there is less regulation for small businesses and we will do for small businesses and we will do the for small businesses and we will do the infrastructure for small businesses and we will do the infrastructure that for small businesses and we will do the infrastructure that is for small businesses and we will do the infrastructure that is required. the infrastructure that is required. That the infrastructure that is required. That is the infrastructure that is required. That is the the infrastructure that is required. That is the cked the infrastructure that is required. That is the cked is the infrastructure that is required. That is the cked is part the infrastructure that is required. That is the cked is part of the infrastructure that is required. That is the cked is part of this That is the cked is part of this plan. That is the cked is part of this plan. We That is the cked is part of this plan. We will That is the cked is part of this plan. We will build That is the cked is part of this plan. We will build some That is the cked is part of this plan. We will build some roads. That is the cked is part of this plan. We will build some roads. We plan. We will build some roads. We will plan. We will build some roads. We will actually plan. We will build some roads. We will actually do plan. We will build some roads. We will actually do this, plan. We will build some roads. We will actually do this, cool plan. We will build some roads. We will actually do this, cool Vin will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty or will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty or what will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty or what your will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty or what your name will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty or what your name is. will actually do this, cool Vin McNulty or what your name is. I McNulty or what your name is. I don't McNulty or what your name is. I don't know McNulty or what your name is. I don't know what McNulty or what your name is. I don't know what your McNulty or what your name is. I don't know what your name McNulty or what your name is. I don't know what your name is. McNulty or what your name is. I don't know what your name is. We don't know what your name is. We will don't know what your name is. We will do don't know what your name is. We will do this don't know what your name is. We will do this by don't know what your name is. We will do this by building don't know what your name is. We will do this by building roads will do this by building roads around will do this by building roads around New will do this by building roads around New Zealand will do this by building roads around New Zealand and will do this by building roads around New Zealand and New around New Zealand and New Zealanders around New Zealand and New Zealanders know around New Zealand and New Zealanders know that around New Zealand and New Zealanders know that we around New Zealand and New Zealanders know that we will Zealanders know that we will actually Zealanders know that we will actually deliver. Zealanders know that we will actually deliver. Stuart Zealanders know that we will actually deliver. Stuart Nash Zealanders know that we will actually deliver. Stuart Nash and actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew Little actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew Little we actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew Little we will actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew Little we will make actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew Little we will make sure actually deliver. Stuart Nash and Andrew Little we will make sure that Andrew Little we will make sure that New Andrew Little we will make sure that New Zealanders Andrew Little we will make sure that New Zealanders have Andrew Little we will make sure that New Zealanders have the Andrew Little we will make sure that New Zealanders have the safety Andrew Little we will make sure that New Zealanders have the safety and New Zealanders have the safety and the New Zealanders have the safety and the security New Zealanders have the safety and the security that New Zealanders have the safety and the security that they New Zealanders have the safety and the security that they deserve. New Zealanders have the safety and the security that they deserve. We the security that they deserve. We understand the security that they deserve. We understand that the security that they deserve. We understand that be the security that they deserve. We understand that be hype the security that they deserve. We understand that be hype the understand that be hype the statistics, understand that be hype the statistics, where understand that be hype the statistics, where there understand that be hype the statistics, where there are understand that be hype the statistics, where there are tens statistics, where there are tens of,000 statistics, where there are tens of,000 san statistics, where there are tens of,000 san more statistics, where there are tens of,000 san more victims statistics, where there are tens of,000 san more victims of statistics, where there are tens of,000 san more victims of crim of,000 san more victims of crim right of,000 san more victims of crim right new, of,000 san more victims of crim right new, where of,000 san more victims of crim right new, where burglaries of,000 san more victims of crim right new, where burglaries are right new, where burglaries are going right new, where burglaries are going up, right new, where burglaries are going up, where right new, where burglaries are going up, where sexual right new, where burglaries are going up, where sexual violence right new, where burglaries are going up, where sexual violence is going up, where sexual violence is going going up, where sexual violence is going up, going up, where sexual violence is going up, where going up, where sexual violence is going up, where robberies going up, where sexual violence is going up, where robberies are going up, where sexual violence is going up, where robberies are going going up, where robberies are going up, going up, where robberies are going up, where going up, where robberies are going up, where gang going up, where robberies are going up, where gang members going up, where robberies are going up, where gang members are going up, where robberies are going up, where gang members are up going up, where robberies are going up, where gang members are up 30% up, where gang members are up 30% expedentially up, where gang members are up 30% expedentially in up, where gang members are up 30% expedentially in his up, where gang members are up 30% expedentially in his on up, where gang members are up 30% expedentially in his on electorate, expedentially in his on electorate, we expedentially in his on electorate, we are expedentially in his on electorate, we are not expedentially in his on electorate, we are not going expedentially in his on electorate, we are not going to expedentially in his on electorate, we are not going to do expedentially in his on electorate, we are not going to do tag expedentially in his on electorate, we are not going to do tag and we are not going to do tag and release. we are not going to do tag and release. We we are not going to do tag and release. We are we are not going to do tag and release. We are going we are not going to do tag and release. We are going to we are not going to do tag and release. We are going to resource release. We are going to resource those release. We are going to resource those police release. We are going to resource those police - release. We are going to resource those police - whether release. We are going to resource those police - whether it release. We are going to resource those police - whether it is release. We are going to resource those police - whether it is 1,400 those police - whether it is 1,400 or those police - whether it is 1,400 or whatever those police - whether it is 1,400 or whatever the those police - whether it is 1,400 or whatever the number those police - whether it is 1,400 or whatever the number is those police - whether it is 1,400 or whatever the number is in those police - whether it is 1,400 or whatever the number is in reality or whatever the number is in reality - or whatever the number is in reality - we or whatever the number is in reality - we are or whatever the number is in reality - we are going or whatever the number is in reality - we are going to or whatever the number is in reality - we are going to make or whatever the number is in reality - we are going to make sure or whatever the number is in reality - we are going to make sure that or whatever the number is in reality - we are going to make sure that New - we are going to make sure that New Zealanders - we are going to make sure that New Zealanders are - we are going to make sure that New Zealanders are safer. - we are going to make sure that New Zealanders are safer. There - we are going to make sure that New Zealanders are safer. There is - we are going to make sure that New Zealanders are safer. There is a Zealanders are safer. There is a contrust Zealanders are safer. There is a contrust in Zealanders are safer. There is a contrust in this Zealanders are safer. There is a contrust in this Parliament Zealanders are safer. There is a contrust in this Parliament between contrust in this Parliament between big contrust in this Parliament between big talk, contrust in this Parliament between big talk, a contrust in this Parliament between big talk, a lack contrust in this Parliament between big talk, a lack of contrust in this Parliament between big talk, a lack of delivery, contrust in this Parliament between big talk, a lack of delivery, zero big talk, a lack of delivery, zero substance big talk, a lack of delivery, zero substance behind big talk, a lack of delivery, zero substance behind that big talk, a lack of delivery, zero substance behind that part big talk, a lack of delivery, zero substance behind that part over substance behind that part over there substance behind that part over there years, substance behind that part over there years, failing substance behind that part over there years, failing to substance behind that part over there years, failing to deliver substance behind that part over there years, failing to deliver for there years, failing to deliver for New there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand and there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand and on there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand and on this there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand and on this side there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand and on this side a there years, failing to deliver for New Zealand and on this side a party New Zealand and on this side a party that New Zealand and on this side a party that when New Zealand and on this side a party that when it New Zealand and on this side a party that when it says New Zealand and on this side a party that when it says it New Zealand and on this side a party that when it says it will New Zealand and on this side a party that when it says it will do that when it says it will do something that when it says it will do something delivers that when it says it will do something delivers for that when it says it will do something delivers for nowers. that when it says it will do something delivers for nowers. That something delivers for nowers. That is something delivers for nowers. That is going something delivers for nowers. That is going to something delivers for nowers. That is going to deliver something delivers for nowers. That is going to deliver that something delivers for nowers. That is going to deliver that money something delivers for nowers. That is going to deliver that money into is going to deliver that money into their is going to deliver that money into their pockets is going to deliver that money into their pockets that is going to deliver that money into their pockets that is is going to deliver that money into their pockets that is going is going to deliver that money into their pockets that is going to their pockets that is going to deliver their pockets that is going to deliver the their pockets that is going to deliver the infrastructure their pockets that is going to deliver the infrastructure that their pockets that is going to deliver the infrastructure that is deliver the infrastructure that is required deliver the infrastructure that is required and deliver the infrastructure that is required and deliver deliver the infrastructure that is required and deliver a deliver the infrastructure that is required and deliver a safer deliver the infrastructure that is required and deliver a safer New required and deliver a safer New Zealand required and deliver a safer New Zealand for required and deliver a safer New Zealand for all required and deliver a safer New Zealand for all families. Zealand for all families. <CHEERING Zealand for all families. <CHEERING AND Zealand for all families. <CHEERING AND APPLAUSE> I I can't I can't call I can't call a I can't call a member I can't call a member yet. I can't call a member yet. I I can't call a member yet. I am I can't call a member yet. I am waiting I can't call a member yet. I am waiting for I can't call a member yet. I am waiting for the I can't call a member yet. I am waiting for the Leader I can't call a member yet. I am waiting for the Leader of I can't call a member yet. I am waiting for the Leader of the waiting for the Leader of the Opposition waiting for the Leader of the Opposition to waiting for the Leader of the Opposition to comply waiting for the Leader of the Opposition to comply withstanding Opposition to comply withstanding order Opposition to comply withstanding order 124. It It is It is an It is an issue It is an issue I It is an issue I dolt It is an issue I dolt with It is an issue I dolt with last It is an issue I dolt with last year. It is an issue I dolt with last year. -- It is an issue I dolt with last year. -- dealt It is an issue I dolt with last year. -- dealt with It is an issue I dolt with last year. -- dealt with last It is an issue I dolt with last year. -- dealt with last year. No, No, sit No, sit down. No, sit down. The No, sit down. The member No, sit down. The member will No, sit down. The member will stand, No, sit down. The member will stand, withdraw No, sit down. The member will stand, withdraw and No, sit down. The member will stand, withdraw and apologise. No, sit down. The member will stand, withdraw and apologise. I No, sit down. The member will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I want withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I want to withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I want to indicate withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I want to indicate to and apologise. I want to indicate to the and apologise. I want to indicate to the member and apologise. I want to indicate to the member that and apologise. I want to indicate to the member that the and apologise. I want to indicate to the member that the standing and apologise. I want to indicate to the member that the standing orders the member that the standing orders are the member that the standing orders are not the member that the standing orders are not pretty. the member that the standing orders are not pretty. They the member that the standing orders are not pretty. They are the member that the standing orders are not pretty. They are very are not pretty. They are very definite. are not pretty. They are very definite. They are not pretty. They are very definite. They are are not pretty. They are very definite. They are very are not pretty. They are very definite. They are very clear. are not pretty. They are very definite. They are very clear. You definite. They are very clear. You had definite. They are very clear. You had one definite. They are very clear. You had one chance definite. They are very clear. You had one chance last definite. They are very clear. You had one chance last year definite. They are very clear. You had one chance last year and definite. They are very clear. You had one chance last year and he's had one chance last year and he's made had one chance last year and he's made a had one chance last year and he's made a miss had one chance last year and he's made a miss of had one chance last year and he's made a miss of it had one chance last year and he's made a miss of it and had one chance last year and he's made a miss of it and he's had one chance last year and he's made a miss of it and he's done had one chance last year and he's made a miss of it and he's done it made a miss of it and he's done it again made a miss of it and he's done it again and made a miss of it and he's done it again and calling made a miss of it and he's done it again and calling many made a miss of it and he's done it again and calling many "petty" made a miss of it and he's done it again and calling many "petty" for again and calling many "petty" for insisting again and calling many "petty" for insisting that again and calling many "petty" for insisting that he again and calling many "petty" for insisting that he comply again and calling many "petty" for insisting that he comply with insisting that he comply with standarding insisting that he comply with standarding orders insisting that he comply with standarding orders is, insisting that he comply with standarding orders is, as insisting that he comply with standarding orders is, as far insisting that he comply with standarding orders is, as far as insisting that he comply with standarding orders is, as far as I standarding orders is, as far as I am standarding orders is, as far as I am concern, standarding orders is, as far as I am concern, outrageous. standarding orders is, as far as I am concern, outrageous. The standarding orders is, as far as I am concern, outrageous. The Rt standarding orders is, as far as I am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon Winston am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Point am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Point of am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Point of order. am concern, outrageous. The Rt Hon Winston Peters. Point of order. I Winston Peters. Point of order. I have Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not said Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not said that Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not said that you Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not said that you are Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not said that you are pretty. Winston Peters. Point of order. I have not said that you are pretty. I have not said that you are pretty. I would have not said that you are pretty. I would ask have not said that you are pretty. I would ask if have not said that you are pretty. I would ask if you have not said that you are pretty. I would ask if you are have not said that you are pretty. I would ask if you are going have not said that you are pretty. I would ask if you are going to have not said that you are pretty. I would ask if you are going to make would ask if you are going to make that would ask if you are going to make that sort would ask if you are going to make that sort of would ask if you are going to make that sort of quite would ask if you are going to make that sort of quite serious would ask if you are going to make that sort of quite serious statement that sort of quite serious statement in that sort of quite serious statement in this that sort of quite serious statement in this House, that sort of quite serious statement in this House, you that sort of quite serious statement in this House, you back that sort of quite serious statement in this House, you back it that sort of quite serious statement in this House, you back it up. that sort of quite serious statement in this House, you back it up. Bus in this House, you back it up. Bus it in this House, you back it up. Bus it is in this House, you back it up. Bus it is not in this House, you back it up. Bus it is not true. in this House, you back it up. Bus it is not true. The in this House, you back it up. Bus it is not true. The second in this House, you back it up. Bus it is not true. The second point in this House, you back it up. Bus it is not true. The second point I it is not true. The second point I would it is not true. The second point I would make, it is not true. The second point I would make, there it is not true. The second point I would make, there may it is not true. The second point I would make, there may well it is not true. The second point I would make, there may well be would make, there may well be standing would make, there may well be standing orders would make, there may well be standing orders on would make, there may well be standing orders on this would make, there may well be standing orders on this matter, would make, there may well be standing orders on this matter, but standing orders on this matter, but for standing orders on this matter, but for the standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 years standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 years I standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 years I have standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 years I have been standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 years I have been in standing orders on this matter, but for the 12 years I have been in this for the 12 years I have been in this parliament for the 12 years I have been in this parliament when for the 12 years I have been in this parliament when things for the 12 years I have been in this parliament when things are for the 12 years I have been in this parliament when things are tabled, parliament when things are tabled, when parliament when things are tabled, when motions parliament when things are tabled, when motions like parliament when things are tabled, when motions like that parliament when things are tabled, when motions like that are parliament when things are tabled, when motions like that are put, when motions like that are put, there when motions like that are put, there is when motions like that are put, there is custom when motions like that are put, there is custom mayorly when motions like that are put, there is custom mayorly a when motions like that are put, there is custom mayorly a period when motions like that are put, there is custom mayorly a period of there is custom mayorly a period of time there is custom mayorly a period of time in there is custom mayorly a period of time in which there is custom mayorly a period of time in which to there is custom mayorly a period of time in which to put there is custom mayorly a period of time in which to put that there is custom mayorly a period of time in which to put that before. there is custom mayorly a period of time in which to put that before. I time in which to put that before. I had time in which to put that before. I had just time in which to put that before. I had just finished time in which to put that before. I had just finished my time in which to put that before. I had just finished my speech time in which to put that before. I had just finished my speech and time in which to put that before. I had just finished my speech and if time in which to put that before. I had just finished my speech and if I had just finished my speech and if I wanted had just finished my speech and if I wanted to had just finished my speech and if I wanted to take had just finished my speech and if I wanted to take a had just finished my speech and if I wanted to take a little had just finished my speech and if I wanted to take a little time had just finished my speech and if I wanted to take a little time and wanted to take a little time and actually wanted to take a little time and actually let wanted to take a little time and actually let Mr wanted to take a little time and actually let Mr Peters wanted to take a little time and actually let Mr Peters start actually let Mr Peters start speaking actually let Mr Peters start speaking and actually let Mr Peters start speaking and hand actually let Mr Peters start speaking and hand it actually let Mr Peters start speaking and hand it over actually let Mr Peters start speaking and hand it over to actually let Mr Peters start speaking and hand it over to the speaking and hand it over to the chrk, speaking and hand it over to the chrk, I speaking and hand it over to the chrk, I think speaking and hand it over to the chrk, I think that speaking and hand it over to the chrk, I think that is speaking and hand it over to the chrk, I think that is incredibly chrk, I think that is incredibly reasonable. chrk, I think that is incredibly reasonable. Right. chrk, I think that is incredibly reasonable. Right. The chrk, I think that is incredibly reasonable. Right. The member chrk, I think that is incredibly reasonable. Right. The member might reasonable. Right. The member might believe reasonable. Right. The member might believe that, reasonable. Right. The member might believe that, but reasonable. Right. The member might believe that, but he reasonable. Right. The member might believe that, but he might reasonable. Right. The member might believe that, but he might believe reasonable. Right. The member might believe that, but he might believe a believe that, but he might believe a whole believe that, but he might believe a whole pile believe that, but he might believe a whole pile of believe that, but he might believe a whole pile of other believe that, but he might believe a whole pile of other things. believe that, but he might believe a whole pile of other things. Any whole pile of other things. Any competent whole pile of other things. Any competent member whole pile of other things. Any competent member knows, whole pile of other things. Any competent member knows, any competent member knows, any competent competent member knows, any competent member competent member knows, any competent member knows... Nick Nick Smith Nick Smith will Nick Smith will stand, Nick Smith will stand, withdraw Nick Smith will stand, withdraw and Nick Smith will stand, withdraw and apologise. Nick Smith will stand, withdraw and apologise. I Nick Smith will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw Nick Smith will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and Nick Smith will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and appear apologise. I withdraw and appear xwis. apologise. I withdraw and appear xwis. -- apologise. I withdraw and appear xwis. -- apologise. apologise. I withdraw and appear xwis. -- apologise. Any apologise. I withdraw and appear xwis. -- apologise. Any member apologise. I withdraw and appear xwis. -- apologise. Any member with xwis. -- apologise. Any member with the xwis. -- apologise. Any member with the knowledge xwis. -- apologise. Any member with the knowledge of xwis. -- apologise. Any member with the knowledge of standing xwis. -- apologise. Any member with the knowledge of standing orders xwis. -- apologise. Any member with the knowledge of standing orders and the knowledge of standing orders and anyone the knowledge of standing orders and anyone who the knowledge of standing orders and anyone who has the knowledge of standing orders and anyone who has observed the knowledge of standing orders and anyone who has observed this the knowledge of standing orders and anyone who has observed this House anyone who has observed this House noes anyone who has observed this House noes that anyone who has observed this House noes that it anyone who has observed this House noes that it is anyone who has observed this House noes that it is the anyone who has observed this House noes that it is the practice anyone who has observed this House noes that it is the practice to anyone who has observed this House noes that it is the practice to give noes that it is the practice to give to noes that it is the practice to give to the noes that it is the practice to give to the Whips noes that it is the practice to give to the Whips a noes that it is the practice to give to the Whips a copy noes that it is the practice to give to the Whips a copy of noes that it is the practice to give to the Whips a copy of an noes that it is the practice to give to the Whips a copy of an amendment to the Whips a copy of an amendment which to the Whips a copy of an amendment which is to the Whips a copy of an amendment which is given to the Whips a copy of an amendment which is given to to the Whips a copy of an amendment which is given to the to the Whips a copy of an amendment which is given to the Clerk to the Whips a copy of an amendment which is given to the Clerk during which is given to the Clerk during the which is given to the Clerk during the speech which is given to the Clerk during the speech because which is given to the Clerk during the speech because it which is given to the Clerk during the speech because it has which is given to the Clerk during the speech because it has to which is given to the Clerk during the speech because it has to be which is given to the Clerk during the speech because it has to be put the speech because it has to be put by the speech because it has to be put by the the speech because it has to be put by the Speaker the speech because it has to be put by the Speaker at the speech because it has to be put by the Speaker at the the speech because it has to be put by the Speaker at the end the speech because it has to be put by the Speaker at the end of the speech because it has to be put by the Speaker at the end of the by the Speaker at the end of the speech. by the Speaker at the end of the speech. The by the Speaker at the end of the speech. The question by the Speaker at the end of the speech. The question is by the Speaker at the end of the speech. The question is now by the Speaker at the end of the speech. The question is now that by the Speaker at the end of the speech. The question is now that Mr speech. The question is now that Mr Bridges's speech. The question is now that Mr Bridges's amendment speech. The question is now that Mr Bridges's amendment be speech. The question is now that Mr Bridges's amendment be agreed speech. The question is now that Mr Bridges's amendment be agreed to. Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Hon Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Hon foot Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Hon foot Peters. Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I Bridges's amendment be agreed to. The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it is The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it is very The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it is very difficult The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it is very difficult the The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it is very difficult the make The Rt Hon foot Peters. Can I say that it is very difficult the make a that it is very difficult the make a silk that it is very difficult the make a silk purse that it is very difficult the make a silk purse out that it is very difficult the make a silk purse out of that it is very difficult the make a silk purse out of a that it is very difficult the make a silk purse out of a sow's that it is very difficult the make a silk purse out of a sow's ear. silk purse out of a sow's ear. <LAUGHTER> All All of All of the All of the elocution All of the elocution lessons, All of the elocution lessons, all All of the elocution lessons, all of All of the elocution lessons, all of the All of the elocution lessons, all of the lessons All of the elocution lessons, all of the lessons on All of the elocution lessons, all of the lessons on how All of the elocution lessons, all of the lessons on how to All of the elocution lessons, all of the lessons on how to stand, All of the elocution lessons, all of the lessons on how to stand, pull the lessons on how to stand, pull your the lessons on how to stand, pull your children the lessons on how to stand, pull your children in, the lessons on how to stand, pull your children in, speak the lessons on how to stand, pull your children in, speak deeply, the lessons on how to stand, pull your children in, speak deeply, all your children in, speak deeply, all of your children in, speak deeply, all of the your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons on your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons on how your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons on how to your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons on how to look your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons on how to look like your children in, speak deeply, all of the lessons on how to look like a of the lessons on how to look like a states of the lessons on how to look like a states man of the lessons on how to look like a states man have of the lessons on how to look like a states man have all of the lessons on how to look like a states man have all been of the lessons on how to look like a states man have all been wasted. of the lessons on how to look like a states man have all been wasted. He states man have all been wasted. He tock states man have all been wasted. He tock 17 states man have all been wasted. He tock 17 minutes states man have all been wasted. He tock 17 minutes of states man have all been wasted. He tock 17 minutes of a states man have all been wasted. He tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute speech tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute speech to tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute speech to say tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute speech to say "the tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute speech to say "the National tock 17 minutes of a 20-minute speech to say "the National Party speech to say "the National Party has speech to say "the National Party has a speech to say "the National Party has a plan". has a plan". <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> 17 <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. Now, <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. Now, can <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. Now, can I <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. Now, can I say <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. Now, can I say to <LAUGHTER> 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. I 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. I just 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. I just saw 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. I just saw a 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. I just saw a pole 17 minutes. Now, can I say to the bank benches. I just saw a pole this bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. It bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. It is bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. It is about bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. It is about the bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. It is about the leaders bank benches. I just saw a pole this morning. It is about the leaders of morning. It is about the leaders of political morning. It is about the leaders of political partiesment morning. It is about the leaders of political partiesment one morning. It is about the leaders of political partiesment one of morning. It is about the leaders of political partiesment one of these political partiesment one of these poles political partiesment one of these poles had political partiesment one of these poles had a political partiesment one of these poles had a positive political partiesment one of these poles had a positive equal political partiesment one of these poles had a positive equal lick political partiesment one of these poles had a positive equal lick yum. poles had a positive equal lick yum. I poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will say poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will say it poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will say it slowly poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will say it slowly than poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will say it slowly than the poles had a positive equal lick yum. I will say it slowly than the big I will say it slowly than the big chap I will say it slowly than the big chap because I will say it slowly than the big chap because he I will say it slowly than the big chap because he can I will say it slowly than the big chap because he can do I will say it slowly than the big chap because he can do better I will say it slowly than the big chap because he can do better than chap because he can do better than that. chap because he can do better than that. The chap because he can do better than that. The wood chap because he can do better than that. The wood work chap because he can do better than that. The wood work teacher, chap because he can do better than that. The wood work teacher, I chap because he can do better than that. The wood work teacher, I moan. that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed with that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed with work that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed with work teacher that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed with work teacher could that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed with work teacher could do that. The wood work teacher, I moan. Theed with work teacher could do it Theed with work teacher could do it better Theed with work teacher could do it better than Theed with work teacher could do it better than that. Theed with work teacher could do it better than that. Here Theed with work teacher could do it better than that. Here comes Theed with work teacher could do it better than that. Here comes the Theed with work teacher could do it better than that. Here comes the - better than that. Here comes the - oh, better than that. Here comes the - oh, the better than that. Here comes the - oh, the Tradies. better than that. Here comes the - oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> he oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> he wouldn't oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> he wouldn't know oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> he wouldn't know a oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> he wouldn't know a hard oh, the Tradies. <LAUGHS> he wouldn't know a hard diwork he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically if he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically if he he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically if he saw he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically if he saw it he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically if he saw it and he wouldn't know a hard diwork physically if he saw it and it physically if he saw it and it shows. physically if he saw it and it shows. Look physically if he saw it and it shows. Look at physically if he saw it and it shows. Look at his physically if he saw it and it shows. Look at his soft physically if he saw it and it shows. Look at his soft hands! shows. Look at his soft hands! <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> He <LAUGHTER> He doesn't <LAUGHTER> He doesn't know <LAUGHTER> He doesn't know what <LAUGHTER> He doesn't know what work <LAUGHTER> He doesn't know what work smells, He doesn't know what work smells, tastes He doesn't know what work smells, tastes and He doesn't know what work smells, tastes and feels He doesn't know what work smells, tastes and feels like. He doesn't know what work smells, tastes and feels like. It He doesn't know what work smells, tastes and feels like. It is tastes and feels like. It is demonstrable, tastes and feels like. It is demonstrable, have tastes and feels like. It is demonstrable, have a tastes and feels like. It is demonstrable, have a look tastes and feels like. It is demonstrable, have a look in tastes and feels like. It is demonstrable, have a look in the demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. Now, demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. Now, back demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. Now, back to demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. Now, back to my demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. Now, back to my point demonstrable, have a look in the mirror. Now, back to my point - mirror. Now, back to my point - there mirror. Now, back to my point - there was mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a poll mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a poll and mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a poll and I mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a poll and I saw mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a poll and I saw it mirror. Now, back to my point - there was a poll and I saw it this there was a poll and I saw it this morning there was a poll and I saw it this morning of there was a poll and I saw it this morning of the there was a poll and I saw it this morning of the leaders there was a poll and I saw it this morning of the leaders of there was a poll and I saw it this morning of the leaders of political morning of the leaders of political parts morning of the leaders of political parts in morning of the leaders of political parts in this morning of the leaders of political parts in this country. morning of the leaders of political parts in this country. One morning of the leaders of political parts in this country. One party morning of the leaders of political parts in this country. One party has parts in this country. One party has a parts in this country. One party has a leader parts in this country. One party has a leader whose parts in this country. One party has a leader whose positive-negative a leader whose positive-negative rating a leader whose positive-negative rating is a leader whose positive-negative rating is -32%. a leader whose positive-negative rating is -32%. I a leader whose positive-negative rating is -32%. I don't a leader whose positive-negative rating is -32%. I don't care a leader whose positive-negative rating is -32%. I don't care what rating is -32%. I don't care what the rating is -32%. I don't care what the Australian rating is -32%. I don't care what the Australian Liberal rating is -32%. I don't care what the Australian Liberal Party rating is -32%. I don't care what the Australian Liberal Party told the Australian Liberal Party told you the Australian Liberal Party told you from the Australian Liberal Party told you from the the Australian Liberal Party told you from the book the Australian Liberal Party told you from the book bench the Australian Liberal Party told you from the book bench over the Australian Liberal Party told you from the book bench over there, you from the book bench over there, you you from the book bench over there, you can't you from the book bench over there, you can't make you from the book bench over there, you can't make it you from the book bench over there, you can't make it from you from the book bench over there, you can't make it from that you from the book bench over there, you can't make it from that per you can't make it from that per season you can't make it from that per season table. you can't make it from that per season table. It you can't make it from that per season table. It is you can't make it from that per season table. It is all you can't make it from that per season table. It is all over season table. It is all over involver. season table. It is all over involver. I season table. It is all over involver. I have season table. It is all over involver. I have got season table. It is all over involver. I have got great season table. It is all over involver. I have got great news involver. I have got great news therefore involver. I have got great news therefore for involver. I have got great news therefore for Judd involver. I have got great news therefore for Judd dit. involver. I have got great news therefore for Judd dit. Judd involver. I have got great news therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit involver. I have got great news therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can do therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can do better therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can do better than therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can do better than that therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can do better than that after therefore for Judd dit. Judd dit can do better than that after seeing do better than that after seeing that do better than that after seeing that poll do better than that after seeing that poll as do better than that after seeing that poll as well. do better than that after seeing that poll as well. They do better than that after seeing that poll as well. They are do better than that after seeing that poll as well. They are in that poll as well. They are in serious, that poll as well. They are in serious, serious that poll as well. They are in serious, serious trouble, that poll as well. They are in serious, serious trouble, but that poll as well. They are in serious, serious trouble, but I that poll as well. They are in serious, serious trouble, but I want serious, serious trouble, but I want to serious, serious trouble, but I want to begin serious, serious trouble, but I want to begin by serious, serious trouble, but I want to begin by saying, serious, serious trouble, but I want to begin by saying, you serious, serious trouble, but I want to begin by saying, you know, serious, serious trouble, but I want to begin by saying, you know, that to begin by saying, you know, that the to begin by saying, you know, that the New to begin by saying, you know, that the New Zealand to begin by saying, you know, that the New Zealand First to begin by saying, you know, that the New Zealand First party to begin by saying, you know, that the New Zealand First party is to begin by saying, you know, that the New Zealand First party is a the New Zealand First party is a party the New Zealand First party is a party where the New Zealand First party is a party where the the New Zealand First party is a party where the differences the New Zealand First party is a party where the differences in the New Zealand First party is a party where the differences in what party where the differences in what you party where the differences in what you just party where the differences in what you just heard party where the differences in what you just heard are party where the differences in what you just heard are so party where the differences in what you just heard are so obvious. you just heard are so obvious. Optimism you just heard are so obvious. Optimism versus you just heard are so obvious. Optimism versus pessimism. you just heard are so obvious. Optimism versus pessimism. More Optimism versus pessimism. More progress Optimism versus pessimism. More progress versus Optimism versus pessimism. More progress versus back Optimism versus pessimism. More progress versus back to Optimism versus pessimism. More progress versus back to the Optimism versus pessimism. More progress versus back to the future. progress versus back to the future. Environment progress versus back to the future. Environment versus progress versus back to the future. Environment versus die progress versus back to the future. Environment versus die vastment. Environment versus die vastment. Unity Environment versus die vastment. Unity versus Environment versus die vastment. Unity versus division Environment versus die vastment. Unity versus division and Environment versus die vastment. Unity versus division and what Unity versus division and what happened Unity versus division and what happened to Unity versus division and what happened to the Unity versus division and what happened to the Christian happened to the Christian upbringing. happened to the Christian upbringing. That happened to the Christian upbringing. That was happened to the Christian upbringing. That was pretty happened to the Christian upbringing. That was pretty nasty. happened to the Christian upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have got upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have got to upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have got to wonder, upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have got to wonder, which upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have got to wonder, which part upbringing. That was pretty nasty. I have got to wonder, which part of have got to wonder, which part of the have got to wonder, which part of the senior have got to wonder, which part of the senior Mon have got to wonder, which part of the senior Mon did have got to wonder, which part of the senior Mon did he have got to wonder, which part of the senior Mon did he miss? have got to wonder, which part of the senior Mon did he miss? But have got to wonder, which part of the senior Mon did he miss? But that the senior Mon did he miss? But that was the senior Mon did he miss? But that was not the senior Mon did he miss? But that was not nice. the senior Mon did he miss? But that was not nice. It the senior Mon did he miss? But that was not nice. It was the senior Mon did he miss? But that was not nice. It was pretty the senior Mon did he miss? But that was not nice. It was pretty basic. was not nice. It was pretty basic. We was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin the was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin the year was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin the year in was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin the year in good was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin the year in good heart, was not nice. It was pretty basic. We begin the year in good heart, in We begin the year in good heart, in good We begin the year in good heart, in good standing. We begin the year in good heart, in good standing. The We begin the year in good heart, in good standing. The position We begin the year in good heart, in good standing. The position of We begin the year in good heart, in good standing. The position of this good standing. The position of this centre good standing. The position of this centre party good standing. The position of this centre party of good standing. The position of this centre party of this good standing. The position of this centre party of this country, centre party of this country, ensuring centre party of this country, ensuring that centre party of this country, ensuring that balanced centre party of this country, ensuring that balanced common centre party of this country, ensuring that balanced common sense ensuring that balanced common sense and ensuring that balanced common sense and good ensuring that balanced common sense and good policy ensuring that balanced common sense and good policy prevail ensuring that balanced common sense and good policy prevail over ensuring that balanced common sense and good policy prevail over rampant and good policy prevail over rampant ideology and good policy prevail over rampant ideology and and good policy prevail over rampant ideology and bad and good policy prevail over rampant ideology and bad ideas and good policy prevail over rampant ideology and bad ideas and,let and good policy prevail over rampant ideology and bad ideas and,let me ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell you ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell you this ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell you this bar ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell you this bar row ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell you this bar row metric ideology and bad ideas and,let me tell you this bar row metric measure tell you this bar row metric measure of tell you this bar row metric measure of that tell you this bar row metric measure of that when tell you this bar row metric measure of that when it tell you this bar row metric measure of that when it comes tell you this bar row metric measure of that when it comes to tell you this bar row metric measure of that when it comes to politics tell you this bar row metric measure of that when it comes to politics is of that when it comes to politics is to of that when it comes to politics is to let of that when it comes to politics is to let us of that when it comes to politics is to let us attack of that when it comes to politics is to let us attack on of that when it comes to politics is to let us attack on you of that when it comes to politics is to let us attack on you know of that when it comes to politics is to let us attack on you know who. to let us attack on you know who. Has to let us attack on you know who. Has it to let us attack on you know who. Has it got to let us attack on you know who. Has it got a to let us attack on you know who. Has it got a familiar to let us attack on you know who. Has it got a familiar ring to let us attack on you know who. Has it got a familiar ring about to let us attack on you know who. Has it got a familiar ring about it? Has it got a familiar ring about it? You Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, I Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, I don't Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, I don't want Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, I don't want to Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, I don't want to sound Has it got a familiar ring about it? You know, I don't want to sound like You know, I don't want to sound like this You know, I don't want to sound like this because You know, I don't want to sound like this because it You know, I don't want to sound like this because it might You know, I don't want to sound like this because it might sound You know, I don't want to sound like this because it might sound are this because it might sound are began this because it might sound are began - this because it might sound are began - it this because it might sound are began - it is this because it might sound are began - it is notmiwards this because it might sound are began - it is notmiwards - this because it might sound are began - it is notmiwards - when this because it might sound are began - it is notmiwards - when a began - it is notmiwards - when a true began - it is notmiwards - when a true genius began - it is notmiwards - when a true genius arrives began - it is notmiwards - when a true genius arrives in began - it is notmiwards - when a true genius arrives in this began - it is notmiwards - when a true genius arrives in this world true genius arrives in this world you true genius arrives in this world you will true genius arrives in this world you will know true genius arrives in this world you will know him true genius arrives in this world you will know him by true genius arrives in this world you will know him by this true genius arrives in this world you will know him by this mark, true genius arrives in this world you will know him by this mark, all you will know him by this mark, all of you will know him by this mark, all of the you will know him by this mark, all of the condition you will know him by this mark, all of the condition fed you will know him by this mark, all of the condition fed rates you will know him by this mark, all of the condition fed rates run of the condition fed rates run against of the condition fed rates run against him of the condition fed rates run against him and of the condition fed rates run against him and I of the condition fed rates run against him and I am of the condition fed rates run against him and I am looking of the condition fed rates run against him and I am looking at of the condition fed rates run against him and I am looking at him against him and I am looking at him right against him and I am looking at him right now against him and I am looking at him right now at against him and I am looking at him right now at this against him and I am looking at him right now at this point against him and I am looking at him right now at this point of against him and I am looking at him right now at this point of time. right now at this point of time. Where right now at this point of time. Where constructive right now at this point of time. Where constructive and right now at this point of time. Where constructive and throughout Where constructive and throughout this Where constructive and throughout this term Where constructive and throughout this term we Where constructive and throughout this term we have Where constructive and throughout this term we have looked Where constructive and throughout this term we have looked at Where constructive and throughout this term we have looked at capacity this term we have looked at capacity in this term we have looked at capacity in our this term we have looked at capacity in our central this term we have looked at capacity in our central social this term we have looked at capacity in our central social services, in our central social services, addressing in our central social services, addressing the in our central social services, addressing the massive in our central social services, addressing the massive disparity addressing the massive disparity between addressing the massive disparity between country addressing the massive disparity between country and addressing the massive disparity between country and town addressing the massive disparity between country and town and addressing the massive disparity between country and town and city between country and town and city and between country and town and city and the between country and town and city and the provinces, between country and town and city and the provinces, laying and the provinces, laying foundations and the provinces, laying foundations for and the provinces, laying foundations for a and the provinces, laying foundations for a more and the provinces, laying foundations for a more just and the provinces, laying foundations for a more just society foundations for a more just society and foundations for a more just society and creating foundations for a more just society and creating a foundations for a more just society and creating a comparatively foundations for a more just society and creating a comparatively robust and creating a comparatively robust economy and creating a comparatively robust economy for and creating a comparatively robust economy for all and creating a comparatively robust economy for all to and creating a comparatively robust economy for all to share and creating a comparatively robust economy for all to share in. and creating a comparatively robust economy for all to share in. Not economy for all to share in. Not just economy for all to share in. Not just for economy for all to share in. Not just for the economy for all to share in. Not just for the few economy for all to share in. Not just for the few and economy for all to share in. Not just for the few and the economy for all to share in. Not just for the few and the very economy for all to share in. Not just for the few and the very few. just for the few and the very few. Since just for the few and the very few. Since then, just for the few and the very few. Since then, growth just for the few and the very few. Since then, growth is just for the few and the very few. Since then, growth is up. Since then, growth is up. Immigration Since then, growth is up. Immigration is Since then, growth is up. Immigration is down. Since then, growth is up. Immigration is down. The Since then, growth is up. Immigration is down. The minimum Immigration is down. The minimum wage Immigration is down. The minimum wage is Immigration is down. The minimum wage is up. Immigration is down. The minimum wage is up. Unemployment Immigration is down. The minimum wage is up. Unemployment is Immigration is down. The minimum wage is up. Unemployment is down. wage is up. Unemployment is down. Infrastructure wage is up. Unemployment is down. Infrastructure investment wage is up. Unemployment is down. Infrastructure investment is wage is up. Unemployment is down. Infrastructure investment is up. Infrastructure investment is up. Business Infrastructure investment is up. Business pessimism Infrastructure investment is up. Business pessimism is Infrastructure investment is up. Business pessimism is down. Infrastructure investment is up. Business pessimism is down. 1 Business pessimism is down. 1 billion Business pessimism is down. 1 billion trees Business pessimism is down. 1 billion trees are Business pessimism is down. 1 billion trees are going Business pessimism is down. 1 billion trees are going up. Business pessimism is down. 1 billion trees are going up. The billion trees are going up. The National billion trees are going up. The National Party billion trees are going up. The National Party as billion trees are going up. The National Party as support billion trees are going up. The National Party as support is National Party as support is crashing National Party as support is crashing down. National Party as support is crashing down. <LAUGHS> crashing down. <LAUGHS> <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> The <LAUGHTER> The PM <LAUGHTER> The PM just <LAUGHTER> The PM just shared <LAUGHTER> The PM just shared another <LAUGHTER> The PM just shared another poll <LAUGHTER> The PM just shared another poll that The PM just shared another poll that she The PM just shared another poll that she learnt The PM just shared another poll that she learnt about The PM just shared another poll that she learnt about - The PM just shared another poll that she learnt about - I The PM just shared another poll that she learnt about - I can't The PM just shared another poll that she learnt about - I can't tell The PM just shared another poll that she learnt about - I can't tell you she learnt about - I can't tell you of she learnt about - I can't tell you of course she learnt about - I can't tell you of course because she learnt about - I can't tell you of course because it she learnt about - I can't tell you of course because it is of course because it is confidential. confidential. <LAUGHTER> <LAUGHTER> If <LAUGHTER> If I <LAUGHTER> If I was <LAUGHTER> If I was over <LAUGHTER> If I was over there, <LAUGHTER> If I was over there, I <LAUGHTER> If I was over there, I would <LAUGHTER> If I was over there, I would know If I was over there, I would know the If I was over there, I would know the feeling. If I was over there, I would know the feeling. Three If I was over there, I would know the feeling. Three more If I was over there, I would know the feeling. Three more years If I was over there, I would know the feeling. Three more years and the feeling. Three more years and possibly the feeling. Three more years and possibly there the feeling. Three more years and possibly there more the feeling. Three more years and possibly there more years the feeling. Three more years and possibly there more years of the feeling. Three more years and possibly there more years of goinger possibly there more years of goinger in possibly there more years of goinger in fast. possibly there more years of goinger in fast. That possibly there more years of goinger in fast. That is possibly there more years of goinger in fast. That is why possibly there more years of goinger in fast. That is why they possibly there more years of goinger in fast. That is why they are in fast. That is why they are deserting in fast. That is why they are deserting in in fast. That is why they are deserting in their in fast. That is why they are deserting in their droves. in fast. That is why they are deserting in their droves. That in fast. That is why they are deserting in their droves. That is deserting in their droves. That is why deserting in their droves. That is why they deserting in their droves. That is why they are deserting in their droves. That is why they are tiring deserting in their droves. That is why they are tiring from deserting in their droves. That is why they are tiring from safe deserting in their droves. That is why they are tiring from safe seats. why they are tiring from safe seats. They why they are tiring from safe seats. They are why they are tiring from safe seats. They are saying, why they are tiring from safe seats. They are saying, "I why they are tiring from safe seats. They are saying, "I don't why they are tiring from safe seats. They are saying, "I don't want why they are tiring from safe seats. They are saying, "I don't want to why they are tiring from safe seats. They are saying, "I don't want to be They are saying, "I don't want to be here They are saying, "I don't want to be here under They are saying, "I don't want to be here under this They are saying, "I don't want to be here under this sort They are saying, "I don't want to be here under this sort of They are saying, "I don't want to be here under this sort of leadership." here under this sort of leadership." We here under this sort of leadership." We are here under this sort of leadership." We are ambitious here under this sort of leadership." We are ambitious to here under this sort of leadership." We are ambitious to do here under this sort of leadership." We are ambitious to do more here under this sort of leadership." We are ambitious to do more and We are ambitious to do more and achieve We are ambitious to do more and achieve more, We are ambitious to do more and achieve more, after We are ambitious to do more and achieve more, after all We are ambitious to do more and achieve more, after all we We are ambitious to do more and achieve more, after all we are We are ambitious to do more and achieve more, after all we are only achieve more, after all we are only just achieve more, after all we are only just got achieve more, after all we are only just got started. achieve more, after all we are only just got started. New achieve more, after all we are only just got started. New Zealand achieve more, after all we are only just got started. New Zealand First just got started. New Zealand First stands just got started. New Zealand First stands for just got started. New Zealand First stands for in just got started. New Zealand First stands for in this just got started. New Zealand First stands for in this election just got started. New Zealand First stands for in this election and just got started. New Zealand First stands for in this election and the stands for in this election and the best stands for in this election and the best place stands for in this election and the best place to stands for in this election and the best place to outline stands for in this election and the best place to outline that stands for in this election and the best place to outline that is stands for in this election and the best place to outline that is to best place to outline that is to tell best place to outline that is to tell you best place to outline that is to tell you what best place to outline that is to tell you what we best place to outline that is to tell you what we are best place to outline that is to tell you what we are not best place to outline that is to tell you what we are not going best place to outline that is to tell you what we are not going to tell you what we are not going to stand tell you what we are not going to stand for. tell you what we are not going to stand for. We tell you what we are not going to stand for. We are tell you what we are not going to stand for. We are a tell you what we are not going to stand for. We are a party tell you what we are not going to stand for. We are a party that tell you what we are not going to stand for. We are a party that won't stand for. We are a party that won't tolerate stand for. We are a party that won't tolerate this stand for. We are a party that won't tolerate this country stand for. We are a party that won't tolerate this country falling stand for. We are a party that won't tolerate this country falling into stand for. We are a party that won't tolerate this country falling into a tolerate this country falling into a pattern tolerate this country falling into a pattern of tolerate this country falling into a pattern of decline tolerate this country falling into a pattern of decline and tolerate this country falling into a pattern of decline and drift. tolerate this country falling into a pattern of decline and drift. The pattern of decline and drift. The previous pattern of decline and drift. The previous National pattern of decline and drift. The previous National Party pattern of decline and drift. The previous National Party was pattern of decline and drift. The previous National Party was comply previous National Party was comply send previous National Party was comply send and previous National Party was comply send and unconcerned previous National Party was comply send and unconcerned about previous National Party was comply send and unconcerned about unable previous National Party was comply send and unconcerned about unable to send and unconcerned about unable to address send and unconcerned about unable to address agreeing send and unconcerned about unable to address agreeing inequality send and unconcerned about unable to address agreeing inequality and address agreeing inequality and social address agreeing inequality and social stress. address agreeing inequality and social stress. The address agreeing inequality and social stress. The PM address agreeing inequality and social stress. The PM laid address agreeing inequality and social stress. The PM laid them address agreeing inequality and social stress. The PM laid them out social stress. The PM laid them out one social stress. The PM laid them out one after social stress. The PM laid them out one after the social stress. The PM laid them out one after the other social stress. The PM laid them out one after the other and social stress. The PM laid them out one after the other and there social stress. The PM laid them out one after the other and there they one after the other and there they are one after the other and there they are in one after the other and there they are in massive one after the other and there they are in massive denial one after the other and there they are in massive denial with are in massive denial with incompetent are in massive denial with incompetent hopless are in massive denial with incompetent hopless people are in massive denial with incompetent hopless people like are in massive denial with incompetent hopless people like Nick incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith shouting incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith shouting at incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith shouting at the incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith shouting at the top incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith shouting at the top of incompetent hopless people like Nick Smith shouting at the top of his Smith shouting at the top of his breath, Smith shouting at the top of his breath, looking Smith shouting at the top of his breath, looking like Smith shouting at the top of his breath, looking like a Smith shouting at the top of his breath, looking like a vape Smith shouting at the top of his breath, looking like a vape might Smith shouting at the top of his breath, looking like a vape might go breath, looking like a vape might go on breath, looking like a vape might go on his breath, looking like a vape might go on his income. breath, looking like a vape might go on his income. That breath, looking like a vape might go on his income. That is breath, looking like a vape might go on his income. That is how breath, looking like a vape might go on his income. That is how angry breath, looking like a vape might go on his income. That is how angry he on his income. That is how angry he was. on his income. That is how angry he was. The on his income. That is how angry he was. The kind on his income. That is how angry he was. The kind of on his income. That is how angry he was. The kind of guy on his income. That is how angry he was. The kind of guy born on his income. That is how angry he was. The kind of guy born with on his income. That is how angry he was. The kind of guy born with a was. The kind of guy born with a sense was. The kind of guy born with a sense of was. The kind of guy born with a sense of bl, was. The kind of guy born with a sense of bl, sablig, was. The kind of guy born with a sense of bl, sablig, but was. The kind of guy born with a sense of bl, sablig, but with was. The kind of guy born with a sense of bl, sablig, but with that sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He thinks sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He thinks he sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He thinks he is sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He thinks he is born sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He thinks he is born to sense of bl, sablig, but with that class. He thinks he is born to rule. class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they look class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they look like class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they look like they class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they look like they are class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they look like they are born class. He thinks he is born to rule. Do they look like they are born to Do they look like they are born to rule? Do they look like they are born to rule? Have Do they look like they are born to rule? Have a Do they look like they are born to rule? Have a good, Do they look like they are born to rule? Have a good, hard Do they look like they are born to rule? Have a good, hard look. rule? Have a good, hard look. Haven't rule? Have a good, hard look. Haven't been rule? Have a good, hard look. Haven't been in rule? Have a good, hard look. Haven't been in business rule? Have a good, hard look. Haven't been in business themselves. Haven't been in business themselves. The Haven't been in business themselves. The PM, Haven't been in business themselves. The PM, the Haven't been in business themselves. The PM, the Deputy Haven't been in business themselves. The PM, the Deputy PM Haven't been in business themselves. The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't Haven't been in business themselves. The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know how The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know how to The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know how to run The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know how to run the The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know how to run the university The PM, the Deputy PM wouldn't know how to run the university tuckshop. how to run the university tuckshop. They how to run the university tuckshop. They have how to run the university tuckshop. They have never, how to run the university tuckshop. They have never, run how to run the university tuckshop. They have never, run a how to run the university tuckshop. They have never, run a business how to run the university tuckshop. They have never, run a business and They have never, run a business and nor They have never, run a business and nor has They have never, run a business and nor has their They have never, run a business and nor has their finance They have never, run a business and nor has their finance spokesman They have never, run a business and nor has their finance spokesman gold nor has their finance spokesman gold Smith. nor has their finance spokesman gold Smith. He's nor has their finance spokesman gold Smith. He's spent nor has their finance spokesman gold Smith. He's spent his nor has their finance spokesman gold Smith. He's spent his life nor has their finance spokesman gold Smith. He's spent his life writing Smith. He's spent his life writing about Smith. He's spent his life writing about businessman, Smith. He's spent his life writing about businessman, but Smith. He's spent his life writing about businessman, but he's Smith. He's spent his life writing about businessman, but he's never about businessman, but he's never been about businessman, but he's never been one about businessman, but he's never been one himself. about businessman, but he's never been one himself. You about businessman, but he's never been one himself. You cannot about businessman, but he's never been one himself. You cannot learn been one himself. You cannot learn on been one himself. You cannot learn on the been one himself. You cannot learn on the job. been one himself. You cannot learn on the job. You been one himself. You cannot learn on the job. You eater been one himself. You cannot learn on the job. You eater have been one himself. You cannot learn on the job. You eater have done been one himself. You cannot learn on the job. You eater have done it on the job. You eater have done it or on the job. You eater have done it or you on the job. You eater have done it or you ain, on the job. You eater have done it or you ain, son. on the job. You eater have done it or you ain, son. And on the job. You eater have done it or you ain, son. And you on the job. You eater have done it or you ain, son. And you ain't. on the job. You eater have done it or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back to or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back to my or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back to my point. or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back to my point. Order. or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back to my point. Order. Son. or you ain, son. And you ain't. Back to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, you to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, you know to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, you know some to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, you know some people to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, you know some people would to my point. Order. Son. Sorry. Well, you know some people would be Well, you know some people would be proud Well, you know some people would be proud of Well, you know some people would be proud of that. Well, you know some people would be proud of that. Never Well, you know some people would be proud of that. Never Moyne. Well, you know some people would be proud of that. Never Moyne. Nop proud of that. Never Moyne. Nop forgets proud of that. Never Moyne. Nop forgets about proud of that. Never Moyne. Nop forgets about distorted proud of that. Never Moyne. Nop forgets about distorted National proud of that. Never Moyne. Nop forgets about distorted National and forgets about distorted National and the forgets about distorted National and the economy forgets about distorted National and the economy was forgets about distorted National and the economy was and forgets about distorted National and the economy was and how forgets about distorted National and the economy was and how run forgets about distorted National and the economy was and how run down forgets about distorted National and the economy was and how run down the the economy was and how run down the social the economy was and how run down the social services the economy was and how run down the social services were. the economy was and how run down the social services were. They the economy was and how run down the social services were. They had the economy was and how run down the social services were. They had one social services were. They had one plan social services were. They had one plan and social services were. They had one plan and one social services were. They had one plan and one plan social services were. They had one plan and one plan alone social services were. They had one plan and one plan alone - social services were. They had one plan and one plan alone - open social services were. They had one plan and one plan alone - open the plan and one plan alone - open the floodgates plan and one plan alone - open the floodgates of plan and one plan alone - open the floodgates of immigration. plan and one plan alone - open the floodgates of immigration. That plan and one plan alone - open the floodgates of immigration. That is plan and one plan alone - open the floodgates of immigration. That is a floodgates of immigration. That is a fact. floodgates of immigration. That is a fact. Between floodgates of immigration. That is a fact. Between the floodgates of immigration. That is a fact. Between the 1990s floodgates of immigration. That is a fact. Between the 1990s and floodgates of immigration. That is a fact. Between the 1990s and the fact. Between the 1990s and the 2000s fact. Between the 1990s and the 2000s immigration fact. Between the 1990s and the 2000s immigration was fact. Between the 1990s and the 2000s immigration was around fact. Between the 1990s and the 2000s immigration was around 12,000 fact. Between the 1990s and the 2000s fact. Between the 1990s and the per an up fact. Between the 1990s and the per an up in. fact. Between the 1990s and the per an up in. Under fact. Between the 1990s and the per an up in. Under National fact. Between the 1990s and the per an up in. Under National after per an up in. Under National after 2014 per an up in. Under National after 2014 it per an up in. Under National after 2014 it massively, per an up in. Under National after 2014 it massively, pleaded. per an up in. Under National after 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, per an up in. Under National after 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The your 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The your after 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The your after 2015, 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The your after 2015, 58, 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The your after 2015, 58, 300. 2014 it massively, pleaded. 38, 300. The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and by The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and by tis The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and by tis troop, The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and by tis troop, 72, The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. The your after 2015, 58, 300. 61, 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only had 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only had one 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only had one part 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only had one part of 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only had one part of their 100 and by tis troop, 72, 300. They only had one part of their plan, only had one part of their plan, just only had one part of their plan, just to only had one part of their plan, just to explode only had one part of their plan, just to explode the only had one part of their plan, just to explode the population. only had one part of their plan, just to explode the population. Even just to explode the population. Even knows just to explode the population. Even knows what just to explode the population. Even knows what that just to explode the population. Even knows what that mean. just to explode the population. Even knows what that mean. Everyone knows what that mean. Everyone around knows what that mean. Everyone around the knows what that mean. Everyone around the country knows what that mean. Everyone around the country knows knows what that mean. Everyone around the country knows what knows what that mean. Everyone around the country knows what that around the country knows what that meant. around the country knows what that meant. House around the country knows what that meant. House prices around the country knows what that meant. House prices going around the country knows what that meant. House prices going through meant. House prices going through the meant. House prices going through the roof. meant. House prices going through the roof. A meant. House prices going through the roof. A lack meant. House prices going through the roof. A lack of meant. House prices going through the roof. A lack of housing meant. House prices going through the roof. A lack of housing and the roof. A lack of housing and massive the roof. A lack of housing and massive depend, the roof. A lack of housing and massive depend, schools, the roof. A lack of housing and massive depend, schools, hospitals massive depend, schools, hospitals and massive depend, schools, hospitals and infrastructure. massive depend, schools, hospitals and infrastructure. The massive depend, schools, hospitals and infrastructure. The stress massive depend, schools, hospitals and infrastructure. The stress was and infrastructure. The stress was minus and infrastructure. The stress was minus and and infrastructure. The stress was minus and immigration and infrastructure. The stress was minus and immigration explains and infrastructure. The stress was minus and immigration explains the minus and immigration explains the housing minus and immigration explains the housing market minus and immigration explains the housing market distortion minus and immigration explains the housing market distortion and housing market distortion and crippling housing market distortion and crippling far housing market distortion and crippling far deficit. housing market distortion and crippling far deficit. Health, crippling far deficit. Health, education, crippling far deficit. Health, education, social crippling far deficit. Health, education, social services crippling far deficit. Health, education, social services run crippling far deficit. Health, education, social services run down. education, social services run down. Evidence education, social services run down. Evidence of education, social services run down. Evidence of neglect education, social services run down. Evidence of neglect was education, social services run down. Evidence of neglect was everywhere Evidence of neglect was everywhere from Evidence of neglect was everywhere from people Evidence of neglect was everywhere from people sleeping Evidence of neglect was everywhere from people sleeping in Evidence of neglect was everywhere from people sleeping in cars. Evidence of neglect was everywhere from people sleeping in cars. The from people sleeping in cars. The other from people sleeping in cars. The other day from people sleeping in cars. The other day I from people sleeping in cars. The other day I picked from people sleeping in cars. The other day I picked up from people sleeping in cars. The other day I picked up the from people sleeping in cars. The other day I picked up the Advocate other day I picked up the Advocate and other day I picked up the Advocate and there other day I picked up the Advocate and there was other day I picked up the Advocate and there was an other day I picked up the Advocate and there was an advertisement other day I picked up the Advocate and there was an advertisement from and there was an advertisement from Mr and there was an advertisement from Mr Ready and there was an advertisement from Mr Ready on and there was an advertisement from Mr Ready on the and there was an advertisement from Mr Ready on the highway and there was an advertisement from Mr Ready on the highway to and there was an advertisement from Mr Ready on the highway to Mars Mr Ready on the highway to Mars don't Mr Ready on the highway to Mars don't Point. Mr Ready on the highway to Mars don't Point. The Mr Ready on the highway to Mars don't Point. The advertisement Mr Ready on the highway to Mars don't Point. The advertisement said don't Point. The advertisement said it don't Point. The advertisement said it had don't Point. The advertisement said it had been don't Point. The advertisement said it had been are don't Point. The advertisement said it had been are instated. don't Point. The advertisement said it had been are instated. Dr don't Point. The advertisement said it had been are instated. Dr Ready, it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs Tell it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs Tell us it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs Tell us how it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs Tell us how many it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs Tell us how many dollars it had been are instated. Dr Ready, Mrs Tell us how many dollars were Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set aside Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set aside by Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set aside by the Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set aside by the National Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set aside by the National Party Mrs Tell us how many dollars were set aside by the National Party with set aside by the National Party with respect set aside by the National Party with respect to set aside by the National Party with respect to Marsden set aside by the National Party with respect to Marsden Point? set aside by the National Party with respect to Marsden Point? Put set aside by the National Party with respect to Marsden Point? Put your respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up if respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up if $1 respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up if $1 was respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up if $1 was assigned respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up if $1 was assigned to respect to Marsden Point? Put your hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't Point hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't Point to hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't Point to whanau hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't Point to whanau marae? hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't Point to whanau marae? You hand up if $1 was assigned to Mars don't Point to whanau marae? You see don't Point to whanau marae? You see he don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is an don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is an honest don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is an honest man. don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is an honest man. I don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is an honest man. I admire don't Point to whanau marae? You see he is an honest man. I admire him. he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't have he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't have your he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't have your part he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't have your part put he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't have your part put that he is an honest man. I admire him. Don't have your part put that out Don't have your part put that out and Don't have your part put that out and think Don't have your part put that out and think you Don't have your part put that out and think you can Don't have your part put that out and think you can got Don't have your part put that out and think you can got away Don't have your part put that out and think you can got away with Don't have your part put that out and think you can got away with it. and think you can got away with it. The and think you can got away with it. The same and think you can got away with it. The same for and think you can got away with it. The same for example and think you can got away with it. The same for example north and think you can got away with it. The same for example north of and think you can got away with it. The same for example north of ta The same for example north of ta wrong The same for example north of ta wrong G. The same for example north of ta wrong G. There The same for example north of ta wrong G. There is The same for example north of ta wrong G. There is the The same for example north of ta wrong G. There is the member The same for example north of ta wrong G. There is the member for The same for example north of ta wrong G. There is the member for ta wrong G. There is the member for ta long wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga and wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga and all wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga and all the wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga and all the way wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga and all the way to wrong G. There is the member for ta long ga and all the way to cutie, long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. OK, long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. OK, Mr long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your long ga and all the way to cutie, cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 was cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 was assigned cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 was assigned by cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 was assigned by you cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 was assigned by you as cutie. OK, Mr Burgess, put your hand up if $1 was assigned by you as the up if $1 was assigned by you as the Transport up if $1 was assigned by you as the Transport Minister up if $1 was assigned by you as the Transport Minister for up if $1 was assigned by you as the Transport Minister for that up if $1 was assigned by you as the Transport Minister for that road? up if $1 was assigned by you as the Transport Minister for that road? He Transport Minister for that road? He can't Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell a Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell a lie Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell a lie either. Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell a lie either. I Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell a lie either. I hop Transport Minister for that road? He can't tell a lie either. I hop some can't tell a lie either. I hop some of can't tell a lie either. I hop some of you can't tell a lie either. I hop some of you in can't tell a lie either. I hop some of you in the can't tell a lie either. I hop some of you in the media can't tell a lie either. I hop some of you in the media is can't tell a lie either. I hop some of you in the media is watching of you in the media is watching because of you in the media is watching because now of you in the media is watching because now we of you in the media is watching because now we are of you in the media is watching because now we are having of you in the media is watching because now we are having a because now we are having a confusional. because now we are having a confusional. We because now we are having a confusional. We having because now we are having a confusional. We having omission. because now we are having a confusional. We having omission. We confusional. We having omission. We are confusional. We having omission. We are getting confusional. We having omission. We are getting it confusional. We having omission. We are getting it out confusional. We having omission. We are getting it out of confusional. We having omission. We are getting it out of them. confusional. We having omission. We are getting it out of them. Boy, confusional. We having omission. We are getting it out of them. Boy, how are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it has are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it has been. are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it has been. Boy, are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it has been. Boy, where are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it has been. Boy, where was are getting it out of them. Boy, how hard it has been. Boy, where was the hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? Well, hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? Well, it hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? Well, it was hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? Well, it was never hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? Well, it was never there, hard it has been. Boy, where was the money? Well, it was never there, but money? Well, it was never there, but he money? Well, it was never there, but he got money? Well, it was never there, but he got up money? Well, it was never there, but he got up and money? Well, it was never there, but he got up and said money? Well, it was never there, but he got up and said it. money? Well, it was never there, but he got up and said it. He money? Well, it was never there, but he got up and said it. He read money? Well, it was never there, but he got up and said it. He read a he got up and said it. He read a list he got up and said it. He read a list out he got up and said it. He read a list out of he got up and said it. He read a list out of what he got up and said it. He read a list out of what they he got up and said it. He read a list out of what they promised, list out of what they promised, accepting list out of what they promised, accepting as list out of what they promised, accepting as Grant list out of what they promised, accepting as Grant Robertson list out of what they promised, accepting as Grant Robertson will accepting as Grant Robertson will tell accepting as Grant Robertson will tell you accepting as Grant Robertson will tell you and accepting as Grant Robertson will tell you and Mr accepting as Grant Robertson will tell you and Mr Twyford accepting as Grant Robertson will tell you and Mr Twyford will accepting as Grant Robertson will tell you and Mr Twyford will tell tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, there tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, there was tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, there was no tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, there was no money tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, there was no money assigned tell you and Mr Twyford will tell you, there was no money assigned to you, there was no money assigned to it. you, there was no money assigned to it. When you, there was no money assigned to it. When it you, there was no money assigned to it. When it comes you, there was no money assigned to it. When it comes to you, there was no money assigned to it. When it comes to Defence, you, there was no money assigned to it. When it comes to Defence, they it. When it comes to Defence, they had it. When it comes to Defence, they had a it. When it comes to Defence, they had a $20 it. When it comes to Defence, they had a $20 billion it. When it comes to Defence, they had a $20 billion plan it. When it comes to Defence, they had a $20 billion plan with it. When it comes to Defence, they had a $20 billion plan with not it. When it comes to Defence, they had a $20 billion plan with not one had a $20 billion plan with not one dollar had a $20 billion plan with not one dollar assigned had a $20 billion plan with not one dollar assigned to had a $20 billion plan with not one dollar assigned to it. had a $20 billion plan with not one dollar assigned to it. Along had a $20 billion plan with not one dollar assigned to it. Along comes dollar assigned to it. Along comes Ron dollar assigned to it. Along comes Ron Mark dollar assigned to it. Along comes Ron Mark and dollar assigned to it. Along comes Ron Mark and in dollar assigned to it. Along comes Ron Mark and in very dollar assigned to it. Along comes Ron Mark and in very difficult Ron Mark and in very difficult trying Ron Mark and in very difficult trying circumstances Ron Mark and in very difficult trying circumstances with Ron Mark and in very difficult trying circumstances with the Ron Mark and in very difficult trying circumstances with the minute trying circumstances with the minute of trying circumstances with the minute of finance trying circumstances with the minute of finance starts trying circumstances with the minute of finance starts to trying circumstances with the minute of finance starts to get trying circumstances with the minute of finance starts to get the trying circumstances with the minute of finance starts to get the funding of finance starts to get the funding that of finance starts to get the funding that Defence of finance starts to get the funding that Defence nobody. of finance starts to get the funding that Defence nobody. Our of finance starts to get the funding that Defence nobody. Our troops of finance starts to get the funding that Defence nobody. Our troops are that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping this that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping this country that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping this country as that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping this country as image that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping this country as image in that Defence nobody. Our troops are helping this country as image in how helping this country as image in how man helping this country as image in how man tearian helping this country as image in how man tearian work. helping this country as image in how man tearian work. It helping this country as image in how man tearian work. It is man tearian work. It is multi-facetted. man tearian work. It is multi-facetted. It man tearian work. It is multi-facetted. It is man tearian work. It is multi-facetted. It is this multi-facetted. It is this government multi-facetted. It is this government that multi-facetted. It is this government that is multi-facetted. It is this government that is doing multi-facetted. It is this government that is doing it, multi-facetted. It is this government that is doing it, much multi-facetted. It is this government that is doing it, much to government that is doing it, much to the government that is doing it, much to the surprise government that is doing it, much to the surprise of government that is doing it, much to the surprise of the government that is doing it, much to the surprise of the Defence government that is doing it, much to the surprise of the Defence Force. the surprise of the Defence Force. They the surprise of the Defence Force. They always the surprise of the Defence Force. They always thought the surprise of the Defence Force. They always thought that the surprise of the Defence Force. They always thought that National They always thought that National was They always thought that National was for They always thought that National was for them, They always thought that National was for them, except They always thought that National was for them, except they They always thought that National was for them, except they never They always thought that National was for them, except they never were was for them, except they never were when was for them, except they never were when it was for them, except they never were when it came was for them, except they never were when it came to was for them, except they never were when it came to giving was for them, except they never were when it came to giving them was for them, except they never were when it came to giving them what when it came to giving them what they when it came to giving them what they promised. when it came to giving them what they promised. The when it came to giving them what they promised. The PM when it came to giving them what they promised. The PM is when it came to giving them what they promised. The PM is listening. they promised. The PM is listening. I they promised. The PM is listening. I gave they promised. The PM is listening. I gave it they promised. The PM is listening. I gave it to they promised. The PM is listening. I gave it to her they promised. The PM is listening. I gave it to her before they promised. The PM is listening. I gave it to her before we they promised. The PM is listening. I gave it to her before we started. I gave it to her before we started. In I gave it to her before we started. In fact, I gave it to her before we started. In fact, she I gave it to her before we started. In fact, she could I gave it to her before we started. In fact, she could have I gave it to her before we started. In fact, she could have written I gave it to her before we started. In fact, she could have written it In fact, she could have written it herself. In fact, she could have written it herself. <LAUGHS> herself. <LAUGHS> When herself. <LAUGHS> When I herself. <LAUGHS> When I was herself. <LAUGHS> When I was the herself. <LAUGHS> When I was the Acting herself. <LAUGHS> When I was the Acting PM herself. <LAUGHS> When I was the Acting PM I herself. <LAUGHS> When I was the Acting PM I can herself. <LAUGHS> When I was the Acting PM I can tell When I was the Acting PM I can tell you When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what happened When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what happened one When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what happened one day When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what happened one day and When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what happened one day and I When I was the Acting PM I can tell you what happened one day and I will you what happened one day and I will never you what happened one day and I will never further you what happened one day and I will never further it you what happened one day and I will never further it because you what happened one day and I will never further it because I you what happened one day and I will never further it because I was never further it because I was shocked. never further it because I was shocked. In never further it because I was shocked. In the never further it because I was shocked. In the room never further it because I was shocked. In the room came never further it because I was shocked. In the room came a never further it because I was shocked. In the room came a group never further it because I was shocked. In the room came a group of shocked. In the room came a group of civil shocked. In the room came a group of civil servants shocked. In the room came a group of civil servants to shocked. In the room came a group of civil servants to tell shocked. In the room came a group of civil servants to tell me shocked. In the room came a group of civil servants to tell me that shocked. In the room came a group of civil servants to tell me that the civil servants to tell me that the tsunami civil servants to tell me that the tsunami Dartboy civil servants to tell me that the tsunami Dartboy Programme civil servants to tell me that the tsunami Dartboy Programme which civil servants to tell me that the tsunami Dartboy Programme which for tsunami Dartboy Programme which for decades tsunami Dartboy Programme which for decades we tsunami Dartboy Programme which for decades we had tsunami Dartboy Programme which for decades we had been tsunami Dartboy Programme which for decades we had been financing tsunami Dartboy Programme which for decades we had been financing to decades we had been financing to warn decades we had been financing to warn us decades we had been financing to warn us that decades we had been financing to warn us that if decades we had been financing to warn us that if a decades we had been financing to warn us that if a tsunami decades we had been financing to warn us that if a tsunami was decades we had been financing to warn us that if a tsunami was coming warn us that if a tsunami was coming our warn us that if a tsunami was coming our way warn us that if a tsunami was coming our way and warn us that if a tsunami was coming our way and our warn us that if a tsunami was coming our way and our Pacific warn us that if a tsunami was coming our way and our Pacific neighbours our way and our Pacific neighbours as our way and our Pacific neighbours as well our way and our Pacific neighbours as well had our way and our Pacific neighbours as well had all our way and our Pacific neighbours as well had all been our way and our Pacific neighbours as well had all been allowed our way and our Pacific neighbours as well had all been allowed to our way and our Pacific neighbours as well had all been allowed to run as well had all been allowed to run down as well had all been allowed to run down and as well had all been allowed to run down and the as well had all been allowed to run down and the last as well had all been allowed to run down and the last one as well had all been allowed to run down and the last one was as well had all been allowed to run down and the last one was on as well had all been allowed to run down and the last one was on the down and the last one was on the blink. down and the last one was on the blink. This down and the last one was on the blink. This - down and the last one was on the blink. This - if down and the last one was on the blink. This - if you down and the last one was on the blink. This - if you want down and the last one was on the blink. This - if you want to down and the last one was on the blink. This - if you want to look down and the last one was on the blink. This - if you want to look at blink. This - if you want to look at any blink. This - if you want to look at any evidence blink. This - if you want to look at any evidence of blink. This - if you want to look at any evidence of how blink. This - if you want to look at any evidence of how shocking blink. This - if you want to look at any evidence of how shocking and any evidence of how shocking and neglectful any evidence of how shocking and neglectful they any evidence of how shocking and neglectful they were, any evidence of how shocking and neglectful they were, they any evidence of how shocking and neglectful they were, they were neglectful they were, they were prepared neglectful they were, they were prepared to neglectful they were, they were prepared to see neglectful they were, they were prepared to see the neglectful they were, they were prepared to see the tsunami neglectful they were, they were prepared to see the tsunami come prepared to see the tsunami come down prepared to see the tsunami come down and prepared to see the tsunami come down and sweep prepared to see the tsunami come down and sweep through prepared to see the tsunami come down and sweep through the prepared to see the tsunami come down and sweep through the Pacific down and sweep through the Pacific islands down and sweep through the Pacific islands and down and sweep through the Pacific islands and take down and sweep through the Pacific islands and take the down and sweep through the Pacific islands and take the top down and sweep through the Pacific islands and take the top of down and sweep through the Pacific islands and take the top of the islands and take the top of the North islands and take the top of the North Island islands and take the top of the North Island out islands and take the top of the North Island out without islands and take the top of the North Island out without wanting islands and take the top of the North Island out without wanting us. North Island out without wanting us. I North Island out without wanting us. I couldn't North Island out without wanting us. I couldn't believe North Island out without wanting us. I couldn't believe it. North Island out without wanting us. I couldn't believe it. My North Island out without wanting us. I couldn't believe it. My colleagues I couldn't believe it. My colleagues know I couldn't believe it. My colleagues know what I couldn't believe it. My colleagues know what happened. I couldn't believe it. My colleagues know what happened. They I couldn't believe it. My colleagues know what happened. They were know what happened. They were sitting know what happened. They were sitting here know what happened. They were sitting here now. know what happened. They were sitting here now. They know what happened. They were sitting here now. They said, know what happened. They were sitting here now. They said, "We know what happened. They were sitting here now. They said, "We are sitting here now. They said, "We are getting sitting here now. They said, "We are getting on sitting here now. They said, "We are getting on to sitting here now. They said, "We are getting on to this. sitting here now. They said, "We are getting on to this. With sitting here now. They said, "We are getting on to this. With won't sitting here now. They said, "We are getting on to this. With won't waste getting on to this. With won't waste a getting on to this. With won't waste a day. getting on to this. With won't waste a day. We getting on to this. With won't waste a day. We will getting on to this. With won't waste a day. We will rebuild getting on to this. With won't waste a day. We will rebuild them." getting on to this. With won't waste a day. We will rebuild them." Five a day. We will rebuild them." Five were a day. We will rebuild them." Five were subpoena a day. We will rebuild them." Five were subpoena to a day. We will rebuild them." Five were subpoena to the a day. We will rebuild them." Five were subpoena to the Pacific a day. We will rebuild them." Five were subpoena to the Pacific before were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and by were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and by the were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and by the even were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and by the even on were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and by the even on of were subpoena to the Pacific before Christmas and by the even on of the Christmas and by the even on of the year Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 will Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 will be Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 will be in Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 will be in place. Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 will be in place. That Christmas and by the even on of the year 15 will be in place. That is year 15 will be in place. That is the year 15 will be in place. That is the difference. year 15 will be in place. That is the difference. There year 15 will be in place. That is the difference. There is year 15 will be in place. That is the difference. There is nobody year 15 will be in place. That is the difference. There is nobody in the difference. There is nobody in that the difference. There is nobody in that back the difference. There is nobody in that back bench the difference. There is nobody in that back bench who the difference. There is nobody in that back bench who was the difference. There is nobody in that back bench who was told the difference. There is nobody in that back bench who was told that, that back bench who was told that, that that back bench who was told that, that we that back bench who was told that, that we could that back bench who was told that, that we could have that back bench who was told that, that we could have had that back bench who was told that, that we could have had a that we could have had a circumstance that we could have had a circumstance where that we could have had a circumstance where the that we could have had a circumstance where the media that we could have had a circumstance where the media asked, circumstance where the media asked, what circumstance where the media asked, what happened circumstance where the media asked, what happened here? circumstance where the media asked, what happened here? We circumstance where the media asked, what happened here? We would circumstance where the media asked, what happened here? We would have what happened here? We would have found what happened here? We would have found that what happened here? We would have found that the what happened here? We would have found that the so what happened here? We would have found that the so called what happened here? We would have found that the so called government found that the so called government of found that the so called government of Gerry found that the so called government of Gerry Brownlee found that the so called government of Gerry Brownlee and found that the so called government of Gerry Brownlee and Mr found that the so called government of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges allowed of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges allowed the of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges allowed the whole of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges allowed the whole warning of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges allowed the whole warning system of Gerry Brownlee and Mr Bridges allowed the whole warning system for allowed the whole warning system for the allowed the whole warning system for the Pacific allowed the whole warning system for the Pacific and allowed the whole warning system for the Pacific and ourselves allowed the whole warning system for the Pacific and ourselves the allowed the whole warning system for the Pacific and ourselves the lapse the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot and the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot and decay. the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot and decay. You the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot and decay. You done the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot and decay. You done need the Pacific and ourselves the lapse and rot and decay. You done need to and rot and decay. You done need to no and rot and decay. You done need to no any and rot and decay. You done need to no any more and rot and decay. You done need to no any more about and rot and decay. You done need to no any more about government and rot and decay. You done need to no any more about government or no any more about government or policies, no any more about government or policies, but no any more about government or policies, but to no any more about government or policies, but to know no any more about government or policies, but to know that no any more about government or policies, but to know that and, no any more about government or policies, but to know that and, more policies, but to know that and, more importantly, policies, but to know that and, more importantly, the policies, but to know that and, more importantly, the Australians policies, but to know that and, more importantly, the Australians were importantly, the Australians were shocked importantly, the Australians were shocked and importantly, the Australians were shocked and said, importantly, the Australians were shocked and said, "We importantly, the Australians were shocked and said, "We will importantly, the Australians were shocked and said, "We will happen shocked and said, "We will happen out." shocked and said, "We will happen out." I shocked and said, "We will happen out." I spoke shocked and said, "We will happen out." I spoke to shocked and said, "We will happen out." I spoke to the shocked and said, "We will happen out." I spoke to the United shocked and said, "We will happen out." I spoke to the United States out." I spoke to the United States and out." I spoke to the United States and they out." I spoke to the United States and they said, out." I spoke to the United States and they said, "we out." I spoke to the United States and they said, "we will out." I spoke to the United States and they said, "we will happen out." I spoke to the United States and they said, "we will happen as and they said, "we will happen as well", and they said, "we will happen as well", but and they said, "we will happen as well", but they and they said, "we will happen as well", but they couldn't and they said, "we will happen as well", but they couldn't into and they said, "we will happen as well", but they couldn't into that well", but they couldn't into that the well", but they couldn't into that the very well", but they couldn't into that the very people well", but they couldn't into that the very people who well", but they couldn't into that the very people who put well", but they couldn't into that the very people who put that well", but they couldn't into that the very people who put that in the very people who put that in place the very people who put that in place and the very people who put that in place and under the very people who put that in place and under former the very people who put that in place and under former responsible place and under former responsible governments place and under former responsible governments had place and under former responsible governments had allowed place and under former responsible governments had allowed that place and under former responsible governments had allowed that to governments had allowed that to happen. governments had allowed that to happen. Mr governments had allowed that to happen. Mr Brownlee governments had allowed that to happen. Mr Brownlee is governments had allowed that to happen. Mr Brownlee is still happen. Mr Brownlee is still probably happen. Mr Brownlee is still probably unaware happen. Mr Brownlee is still probably unaware of happen. Mr Brownlee is still probably unaware of what happen. Mr Brownlee is still probably unaware of what happened. probably unaware of what happened. If probably unaware of what happened. If you probably unaware of what happened. If you are probably unaware of what happened. If you are not probably unaware of what happened. If you are not spending probably unaware of what happened. If you are not spending your probably unaware of what happened. If you are not spending your time If you are not spending your time focusing If you are not spending your time focusing on If you are not spending your time focusing on politics If you are not spending your time focusing on politics and If you are not spending your time focusing on politics and other focusing on politics and other things, focusing on politics and other things, you focusing on politics and other things, you can focusing on politics and other things, you can possibly focusing on politics and other things, you can possibly lose focusing on politics and other things, you can possibly lose the things, you can possibly lose the plot. things, you can possibly lose the plot. Can things, you can possibly lose the plot. Can I things, you can possibly lose the plot. Can I say things, you can possibly lose the plot. Can I say one things, you can possibly lose the plot. Can I say one thin, things, you can possibly lose the plot. Can I say one thin, the plot. Can I say one thin, the National plot. Can I say one thin, the National Party plot. Can I say one thin, the National Party today plot. Can I say one thin, the National Party today and plot. Can I say one thin, the National Party today and its plot. Can I say one thin, the National Party today and its image National Party today and its image is National Party today and its image is very National Party today and its image is very clear, National Party today and its image is very clear, is National Party today and its image is very clear, is a National Party today and its image is very clear, is a party National Party today and its image is very clear, is a party with National Party today and its image is very clear, is a party with a is very clear, is a party with a small is very clear, is a party with a small in. is very clear, is a party with a small in. It is very clear, is a party with a small in. It is is very clear, is a party with a small in. It is not is very clear, is a party with a small in. It is not a is very clear, is a party with a small in. It is not a centre is very clear, is a party with a small in. It is not a centre part small in. It is not a centre part anymore. small in. It is not a centre part anymore. It small in. It is not a centre part anymore. It is small in. It is not a centre part anymore. It is still small in. It is not a centre part anymore. It is still in small in. It is not a centre part anymore. It is still in the small in. It is not a centre part anymore. It is still in the there anymore. It is still in the there tos anymore. It is still in the there tos of anymore. It is still in the there tos of ruthanomics,in' anymore. It is still in the there tos of ruthanomics,in' though anymore. It is still in the there tos of ruthanomics,in' though that tos of ruthanomics,in' though that was tos of ruthanomics,in' though that was a tos of ruthanomics,in' though that was a disaster tos of ruthanomics,in' though that was a disaster that took tos of ruthanomics,in' though that was a disaster that took the was a disaster that took the National was a disaster that took the National Party was a disaster that took the National Party in was a disaster that took the National Party in the was a disaster that took the National Party in the space was a disaster that took the National Party in the space of was a disaster that took the National Party in the space of three National Party in the space of three years National Party in the space of three years for National Party in the space of three years for the National Party in the space of three years for the biggest National Party in the space of three years for the biggest majority National Party in the space of three years for the biggest majority ever years for the biggest majority ever to years for the biggest majority ever to a years for the biggest majority ever to a hung years for the biggest majority ever to a hung Parliament years for the biggest majority ever to a hung Parliament in years for the biggest majority ever to a hung Parliament in there years for the biggest majority ever to a hung Parliament in there years to a hung Parliament in there years flat. to a hung Parliament in there years flat. Think to a hung Parliament in there years flat. Think still to a hung Parliament in there years flat. Think still hand to a hung Parliament in there years flat. Think still hand consider to a hung Parliament in there years flat. Think still hand consider for flat. Think still hand consider for that. flat. Think still hand consider for that. They flat. Think still hand consider for that. They still flat. Think still hand consider for that. They still have flat. Think still hand consider for that. They still have got flat. Think still hand consider for that. They still have got control flat. Think still hand consider for that. They still have got control of that. They still have got control of the that. They still have got control of the National that. They still have got control of the National Party that. They still have got control of the National Party and-for-the that. They still have got control of the National Party and-for-the rrs the National Party and-for-the rrs of the National Party and-for-the rrs of the the National Party and-for-the rrs of the back the National Party and-for-the rrs of the back benches, the National Party and-for-the rrs of the back benches, they the National Party and-for-the rrs of the back benches, they have the National Party and-for-the rrs of the back benches, they have got of the back benches, they have got no of the back benches, they have got no influence of the back benches, they have got no influence what of the back benches, they have got no influence what so of the back benches, they have got no influence what so ever. of the back benches, they have got no influence what so ever. Here of the back benches, they have got no influence what so ever. Here we no influence what so ever. Here we have no influence what so ever. Here we have Mr no influence what so ever. Here we have Mr Goldsmith. no influence what so ever. Here we have Mr Goldsmith. You no influence what so ever. Here we have Mr Goldsmith. You know no influence what so ever. Here we have Mr Goldsmith. You know what no influence what so ever. Here we have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience is. have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience is. He have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience is. He is have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience is. He is looking have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience is. He is looking to have Mr Goldsmith. You know what his experience is. He is looking to cut experience is. He is looking to cut anything experience is. He is looking to cut anything and experience is. He is looking to cut anything and everything. experience is. He is looking to cut anything and everything. He experience is. He is looking to cut anything and everything. He spent anything and everything. He spent time anything and everything. He spent time en anything and everything. He spent time en massive,season anything and everything. He spent time en massive,season shall anything and everything. He spent time en massive,season shall at time en massive,season shall at provincial time en massive,season shall at provincial New time en massive,season shall at provincial New Zealand time en massive,season shall at provincial New Zealand scoffing time en massive,season shall at provincial New Zealand scoffing at provincial New Zealand scoffing at every provincial New Zealand scoffing at every idea. provincial New Zealand scoffing at every idea. Parked provincial New Zealand scoffing at every idea. Parked up provincial New Zealand scoffing at every idea. Parked up in provincial New Zealand scoffing at every idea. Parked up in Epsom. provincial New Zealand scoffing at every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no tor every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no tor use every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no tor use of every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no tor use of course every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no tor use of course because every idea. Parked up in Epsom. He is no tor use of course because he is no tor use of course because he is is no tor use of course because he is the is no tor use of course because he is the only is no tor use of course because he is the only politician is no tor use of course because he is the only politician in is no tor use of course because he is the only politician in the is no tor use of course because he is the only politician in the whole is the only politician in the whole Weren't is the only politician in the whole Weren't world is the only politician in the whole Weren't world who is the only politician in the whole Weren't world who is is the only politician in the whole Weren't world who is Reserve is the only politician in the whole Weren't world who is Reserve Banks Weren't world who is Reserve Banks for Weren't world who is Reserve Banks for pulling Weren't world who is Reserve Banks for pulling his Weren't world who is Reserve Banks for pulling his hoards Weren't world who is Reserve Banks for pulling his hoards down. Weren't world who is Reserve Banks for pulling his hoards down. Not for pulling his hoards down. Not pulling for pulling his hoards down. Not pulling them for pulling his hoards down. Not pulling them up, for pulling his hoards down. Not pulling them up, but for pulling his hoards down. Not pulling them up, but pulling for pulling his hoards down. Not pulling them up, but pulling them pulling them up, but pulling them down. pulling them up, but pulling them down. We pulling them up, but pulling them down. We have pulling them up, but pulling them down. We have never pulling them up, but pulling them down. We have never soon pulling them up, but pulling them down. We have never soon that down. We have never soon that anywhere down. We have never soon that anywhere in down. We have never soon that anywhere in the down. We have never soon that anywhere in the Weren't down. We have never soon that anywhere in the Weren't world. down. We have never soon that anywhere in the Weren't world. He anywhere in the Weren't world. He knows anywhere in the Weren't world. He knows the anywhere in the Weren't world. He knows the political anywhere in the Weren't world. He knows the political cut anywhere in the Weren't world. He knows the political cut hole anywhere in the Weren't world. He knows the political cut hole from knows the political cut hole from Epsom knows the political cut hole from Epsom is knows the political cut hole from Epsom is shouting knows the political cut hole from Epsom is shouting out knows the political cut hole from Epsom is shouting out now knows the political cut hole from Epsom is shouting out now - knows the political cut hole from Epsom is shouting out now - the knows the political cut hole from Epsom is shouting out now - the one Epsom is shouting out now - the one looking Epsom is shouting out now - the one looking for Epsom is shouting out now - the one looking for a Epsom is shouting out now - the one looking for a statistic Epsom is shouting out now - the one looking for a statistic tango looking for a statistic tango partner? looking for a statistic tango partner? <LAUGHS> partner? <LAUGHS> In partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I saw partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I saw the partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I saw the other partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I saw the other night partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I saw the other night on partner? <LAUGHS> In fact, I saw the other night on TV In fact, I saw the other night on TV In In fact, I saw the other night on TV him dancing. It In fact, I saw the other night on TV him dancing. It was In fact, I saw the other night on TV him dancing. It was on In fact, I saw the other night on TV him dancing. It was on the In fact, I saw the other night on TV him dancing. It was on the week In fact, I saw the other night on TV him dancing. It was on the week show him dancing. It was on the week show and him dancing. It was on the week show and I him dancing. It was on the week show and I had him dancing. It was on the week show and I had a him dancing. It was on the week show and I had a good him dancing. It was on the week show and I had a good hard him dancing. It was on the week show and I had a good hard look him dancing. It was on the week show and I had a good hard look at him dancing. It was on the week show and I had a good hard look at myself and I had a good hard look at myself and and I had a good hard look at myself and I and I had a good hard look at myself and I thought, and I had a good hard look at myself and I thought, this and I had a good hard look at myself and I thought, this cannot and I had a good hard look at myself and I thought, this cannot - and I had a good hard look at myself and I thought, this cannot - we and I had a good hard look at myself and I thought, this cannot - we in and I thought, this cannot - we in New and I thought, this cannot - we in New Zealand and I thought, this cannot - we in New Zealand have and I thought, this cannot - we in New Zealand have a and I thought, this cannot - we in New Zealand have a Parliament and I thought, this cannot - we in New Zealand have a Parliament where New Zealand have a Parliament where people New Zealand have a Parliament where people are New Zealand have a Parliament where people are so New Zealand have a Parliament where people are so desperate New Zealand have a Parliament where people are so desperate for people are so desperate for publicity people are so desperate for publicity they people are so desperate for publicity they better people are so desperate for publicity they better do people are so desperate for publicity they better do that. publicity they better do that. <LAUGHS> <LAUGHS> Special <LAUGHS> Special moments <LAUGHS> Special moments on <LAUGHS> Special moments on national <LAUGHS> Special moments on national TV <LAUGHS> Special moments on national TV to Special moments on national TV to humiliate Special moments on national TV to humiliate themselves. Special moments on national TV to humiliate themselves. But, Special moments on national TV to humiliate themselves. But, you Special moments on national TV to humiliate themselves. But, you know, humiliate themselves. But, you know, can humiliate themselves. But, you know, can you humiliate themselves. But, you know, can you Reserve humiliate themselves. But, you know, can you Reserve Bank humiliate themselves. But, you know, can you Reserve Bank the humiliate themselves. But, you know, can you Reserve Bank the National can you Reserve Bank the National Party can you Reserve Bank the National Party that can you Reserve Bank the National Party that lived can you Reserve Bank the National Party that lived the can you Reserve Bank the National Party that lived the ACT can you Reserve Bank the National Party that lived the ACT Party can you Reserve Bank the National Party that lived the ACT Party as Party that lived the ACT Party as leadership? Party that lived the ACT Party as leadership? I Party that lived the ACT Party as leadership? I do. Party that lived the ACT Party as leadership? I do. Remember Party that lived the ACT Party as leadership? I do. Remember who Party that lived the ACT Party as leadership? I do. Remember who the leadership? I do. Remember who the first leadership? I do. Remember who the first one leadership? I do. Remember who the first one was? leadership? I do. Remember who the first one was? Douglas. leadership? I do. Remember who the first one was? Douglas. Then first one was? Douglas. Then Prebble. first one was? Douglas. Then Prebble. Then first one was? Douglas. Then Prebble. Then Hyde. first one was? Douglas. Then Prebble. Then Hyde. Then first one was? Douglas. Then Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, first one was? Douglas. Then Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was it? Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was it? Who Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was it? Who else? Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was it? Who else? Somebody Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was it? Who else? Somebody in Prebble. Then Hyde. Then White, was it? Who else? Somebody in between? it? Who else? Somebody in between? Don it? Who else? Somebody in between? Don British, it? Who else? Somebody in between? Don British, yes. it? Who else? Somebody in between? Don British, yes. Don it? Who else? Somebody in between? Don British, yes. Don British it? Who else? Somebody in between? Don British, yes. Don British and Don British, yes. Don British and now Don British, yes. Don British and now seem Don British, yes. Don British and now seem more. Don British, yes. Don British and now seem more. Look, Don British, yes. Don British and now seem more. Look, this Don British, yes. Don British and now seem more. Look, this is Don British, yes. Don British and now seem more. Look, this is a Don British, yes. Don British and now seem more. Look, this is a case now seem more. Look, this is a case of now seem more. Look, this is a case of serious now seem more. Look, this is a case of serious mortal now seem more. Look, this is a case of serious mortal mental now seem more. Look, this is a case of serious mortal mental deficiency. of serious mortal mental deficiency. It of serious mortal mental deficiency. It shows. of serious mortal mental deficiency. It shows. 7 of serious mortal mental deficiency. It shows. 7 litres. of serious mortal mental deficiency. It shows. 7 litres. 7. of serious mortal mental deficiency. It shows. 7 litres. 7. The of serious mortal mental deficiency. It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is only It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is only there It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is only there news It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is only there news because It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is only there news because there It shows. 7 litres. 7. The President is only there news because there is is only there news because there is not is only there news because there is not a is only there news because there is not a second is only there news because there is not a second vote. is only there news because there is not a second vote. That is only there news because there is not a second vote. That is is only there news because there is not a second vote. That is what is only there news because there is not a second vote. That is what he not a second vote. That is what he is not a second vote. That is what he is doing not a second vote. That is what he is doing here. not a second vote. That is what he is doing here. By not a second vote. That is what he is doing here. By the not a second vote. That is what he is doing here. By the way not a second vote. That is what he is doing here. By the way when not a second vote. That is what he is doing here. By the way when you is doing here. By the way when you say is doing here. By the way when you say something is doing here. By the way when you say something like is doing here. By the way when you say something like you is doing here. By the way when you say something like you said is doing here. By the way when you say something like you said the say something like you said the other say something like you said the other day, say something like you said the other day, if say something like you said the other day, if I say something like you said the other day, if I thought say something like you said the other day, if I thought he say something like you said the other day, if I thought he had say something like you said the other day, if I thought he had a other day, if I thought he had a croon other day, if I thought he had a croon I other day, if I thought he had a croon I would other day, if I thought he had a croon I would sue other day, if I thought he had a croon I would sue him, other day, if I thought he had a croon I would sue him, but other day, if I thought he had a croon I would sue him, but he other day, if I thought he had a croon I would sue him, but he said croon I would sue him, but he said on croon I would sue him, but he said on TV croon I would sue him, but he said on TV something croon I would sue him, but he said on TV something that croon I would sue him, but he said on TV something that is croon I would sue him, but he said on TV something that is defamatory. on TV something that is defamatory. "If on TV something that is defamatory. "If I on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought he on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought he had on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought he had any on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought he had any money on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought he had any money or on TV something that is defamatory. "If I thought he had any money or he "If I thought he had any money or he had "If I thought he had any money or he had a "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense of "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense of being "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense of being able "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense of being able to "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense of being able to pay "If I thought he had any money or he had a sense of being able to pay me, had a sense of being able to pay me, I had a sense of being able to pay me, I would had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue him. had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue him. But had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue him. But I had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue him. But I am had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue him. But I am not had a sense of being able to pay me, I would sue him. But I am not going I would sue him. But I am not going to I would sue him. But I am not going to waste I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my money I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my money to I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my money to get" I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my money to get" - I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my money to get" - no, I would sue him. But I am not going to waste my money to get" - no, talk to waste my money to get" - no, talk is to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not that to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not that chap. to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not that chap. He to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not that chap. He is to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not that chap. He is going to waste my money to get" - no, talk is not that chap. He is going to is not that chap. He is going to fine is not that chap. He is going to fine it is not that chap. He is going to fine it difficult, is not that chap. He is going to fine it difficult, how, is not that chap. He is going to fine it difficult, how, opinionsive fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This is fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This is a fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This is a member fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This is a member who fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This is a member who is fine it difficult, how, opinionsive it is. This is a member who is all it is. This is a member who is all over it is. This is a member who is all over tape it is. This is a member who is all over tape recording it is. This is a member who is all over tape recording of it is. This is a member who is all over tape recording of funding it is. This is a member who is all over tape recording of funding of over tape recording of funding of the over tape recording of funding of the National over tape recording of funding of the National Party. over tape recording of funding of the National Party. The over tape recording of funding of the National Party. The tape the National Party. The tape recording the National Party. The tape recording will the National Party. The tape recording will be the National Party. The tape recording will be disclose the National Party. The tape recording will be disclose somebody recording will be disclose somebody this recording will be disclose somebody this Parliament recording will be disclose somebody this Parliament shortly recording will be disclose somebody this Parliament shortly and recording will be disclose somebody this Parliament shortly and he recording will be disclose somebody this Parliament shortly and he is this Parliament shortly and he is shouting this Parliament shortly and he is shouting out this Parliament shortly and he is shouting out he's this Parliament shortly and he is shouting out he's innocent. this Parliament shortly and he is shouting out he's innocent. Is this Parliament shortly and he is shouting out he's innocent. Is it shouting out he's innocent. Is it shouting out he's innocent. Is it shouting out he's innocent. Is it someone else shouting out he's innocent. Is it someone else as shouting out he's innocent. Is it someone else as voice? shouting out he's innocent. Is it someone else as voice? Is shouting out he's innocent. Is it someone else as voice? Is it someone else as voice? Is it somebodiless someone else as voice? Is it somebodiless as someone else as voice? Is it somebodiless as voice? someone else as voice? Is it somebodiless as voice? Mr someone else as voice? Is it somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the voices somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the voices play, somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the voices play, will somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the voices play, will it somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the voices play, will it be somebodiless as voice? Mr Bridges, whoen the voices play, will it be Mr whoen the voices play, will it be Mr Bridge whoen the voices play, will it be Mr Bridge as whoen the voices play, will it be Mr Bridge as voice whoen the voices play, will it be Mr Bridge as voice or whoen the voices play, will it be Mr Bridge as voice or someone whoen the voices play, will it be Mr Bridge as voice or someone else's? Bridge as voice or someone else's? If Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it is Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it is his Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it is his voice Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it is his voice he Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it is his voice he is Bridge as voice or someone else's? If it is his voice he is deeply If it is his voice he is deeply implicated. If it is his voice he is deeply implicated. No If it is his voice he is deeply implicated. No wonder If it is his voice he is deeply implicated. No wonder he If it is his voice he is deeply implicated. No wonder he said If it is his voice he is deeply implicated. No wonder he said he implicated. No wonder he said he wanted implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to move implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to move on. implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to move on. He implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to move on. He wanted implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to move on. He wanted to implicated. No wonder he said he wanted to move on. He wanted to move wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. Can wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. Can I wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. Can I just wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. Can I just say wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. Can I just say recently wanted to move on. He wanted to move on. Can I just say recently the on. Can I just say recently the Fitch on. Can I just say recently the Fitch rating on. Can I just say recently the Fitch rating agency on. Can I just say recently the Fitch rating agency head on. Can I just say recently the Fitch rating agency head New on. Can I just say recently the Fitch rating agency head New Zealand Fitch rating agency head New Zealand had Fitch rating agency head New Zealand had sound Fitch rating agency head New Zealand had sound fiscal Fitch rating agency head New Zealand had sound fiscal managing, Fitch rating agency head New Zealand had sound fiscal managing, low had sound fiscal managing, low declining had sound fiscal managing, low declining debt had sound fiscal managing, low declining debt in had sound fiscal managing, low declining debt in relation had sound fiscal managing, low declining debt in relation to had sound fiscal managing, low declining debt in relation to GDP. declining debt in relation to GDP. They declining debt in relation to GDP. They said declining debt in relation to GDP. They said this declining debt in relation to GDP. They said this would declining debt in relation to GDP. They said this would enhance declining debt in relation to GDP. They said this would enhance the They said this would enhance the country's They said this would enhance the country's resilience They said this would enhance the country's resilience to They said this would enhance the country's resilience to economic They said this would enhance the country's resilience to economic and country's resilience to economic and financial country's resilience to economic and financial shocks. country's resilience to economic and financial shocks. The country's resilience to economic and financial shocks. The reality country's resilience to economic and financial shocks. The reality is country's resilience to economic and financial shocks. The reality is we financial shocks. The reality is we faced financial shocks. The reality is we faced difficult financial shocks. The reality is we faced difficult times financial shocks. The reality is we faced difficult times that financial shocks. The reality is we faced difficult times that I financial shocks. The reality is we faced difficult times that I have faced difficult times that I have forecast faced difficult times that I have forecast in faced difficult times that I have forecast in the faced difficult times that I have forecast in the past, faced difficult times that I have forecast in the past, not faced difficult times that I have forecast in the past, not trying faced difficult times that I have forecast in the past, not trying to forecast in the past, not trying to be forecast in the past, not trying to be wise forecast in the past, not trying to be wise before forecast in the past, not trying to be wise before the forecast in the past, not trying to be wise before the event, forecast in the past, not trying to be wise before the event, but forecast in the past, not trying to be wise before the event, but we be wise before the event, but we look be wise before the event, but we look at be wise before the event, but we look at the be wise before the event, but we look at the level be wise before the event, but we look at the level of be wise before the event, but we look at the level of bank be wise before the event, but we look at the level of bank indebted look at the level of bank indebted ness look at the level of bank indebted ness around look at the level of bank indebted ness around the look at the level of bank indebted ness around the world look at the level of bank indebted ness around the world and look at the level of bank indebted ness around the world and the look at the level of bank indebted ness around the world and the amount ness around the world and the amount of ness around the world and the amount of money ness around the world and the amount of money that's ness around the world and the amount of money that's been ness around the world and the amount of money that's been given ness around the world and the amount of money that's been given to ness around the world and the amount of money that's been given to cheap of money that's been given to cheap interest, of money that's been given to cheap interest, then of money that's been given to cheap interest, then you of money that's been given to cheap interest, then you have of money that's been given to cheap interest, then you have to of money that's been given to cheap interest, then you have to ask interest, then you have to ask yourself, interest, then you have to ask yourself, when interest, then you have to ask yourself, when does interest, then you have to ask yourself, when does the interest, then you have to ask yourself, when does the payment interest, then you have to ask yourself, when does the payment has yourself, when does the payment has to yourself, when does the payment has to be yourself, when does the payment has to be paid, yourself, when does the payment has to be paid, when yourself, when does the payment has to be paid, when will yourself, when does the payment has to be paid, when will the yourself, when does the payment has to be paid, when will the day yourself, when does the payment has to be paid, when will the day of to be paid, when will the day of reckoning to be paid, when will the day of reckoning be? to be paid, when will the day of reckoning be? So to be paid, when will the day of reckoning be? So for to be paid, when will the day of reckoning be? So for this to be paid, when will the day of reckoning be? So for this Government reckoning be? So for this Government to reckoning be? So for this Government to be reckoning be? So for this Government to be positioning reckoning be? So for this Government to be positioning itself reckoning be? So for this Government to be positioning itself in to be positioning itself in preparation to be positioning itself in preparation for to be positioning itself in preparation for these to be positioning itself in preparation for these sorts to be positioning itself in preparation for these sorts of preparation for these sorts of potential preparation for these sorts of potential financial preparation for these sorts of potential financial difficulties, preparation for these sorts of potential financial difficulties, is potential financial difficulties, is a potential financial difficulties, is a very, potential financial difficulties, is a very, very potential financial difficulties, is a very, very sound potential financial difficulties, is a very, very sound measure. potential financial difficulties, is a very, very sound measure. For potential financial difficulties, is a very, very sound measure. For all a very, very sound measure. For all those a very, very sound measure. For all those who a very, very sound measure. For all those who say a very, very sound measure. For all those who say otherwise, a very, very sound measure. For all those who say otherwise, bear a very, very sound measure. For all those who say otherwise, bear this those who say otherwise, bear this in those who say otherwise, bear this in mind. those who say otherwise, bear this in mind. When those who say otherwise, bear this in mind. When the those who say otherwise, bear this in mind. When the shock those who say otherwise, bear this in mind. When the shock happens, those who say otherwise, bear this in mind. When the shock happens, we in mind. When the shock happens, we will in mind. When the shock happens, we will be in mind. When the shock happens, we will be affected, in mind. When the shock happens, we will be affected, just in mind. When the shock happens, we will be affected, just like in mind. When the shock happens, we will be affected, just like we in mind. When the shock happens, we will be affected, just like we are will be affected, just like we are with will be affected, just like we are with coronavirus will be affected, just like we are with coronavirus as will be affected, just like we are with coronavirus as we will be affected, just like we are with coronavirus as we speak will be affected, just like we are with coronavirus as we speak where with coronavirus as we speak where we with coronavirus as we speak where we will with coronavirus as we speak where we will have with coronavirus as we speak where we will have a with coronavirus as we speak where we will have a 2% with coronavirus as we speak where we will have a 2% effect, with coronavirus as we speak where we will have a 2% effect, it with coronavirus as we speak where we will have a 2% effect, it looks we will have a 2% effect, it looks like, we will have a 2% effect, it looks like, on we will have a 2% effect, it looks like, on the we will have a 2% effect, it looks like, on the Chinese we will have a 2% effect, it looks like, on the Chinese economy. we will have a 2% effect, it looks like, on the Chinese economy. There like, on the Chinese economy. There will like, on the Chinese economy. There will be like, on the Chinese economy. There will be international like, on the Chinese economy. There will be international ramifications. will be international ramifications. The will be international ramifications. The issue will be international ramifications. The issue is will be international ramifications. The issue is have will be international ramifications. The issue is have we will be international ramifications. The issue is have we done will be international ramifications. The issue is have we done all will be international ramifications. The issue is have we done all that The issue is have we done all that we The issue is have we done all that we can The issue is have we done all that we can to The issue is have we done all that we can to ensure The issue is have we done all that we can to ensure that The issue is have we done all that we can to ensure that we've we can to ensure that we've protected we can to ensure that we've protected and we can to ensure that we've protected and shielded we can to ensure that we've protected and shielded our we can to ensure that we've protected and shielded our people protected and shielded our people from protected and shielded our people from those protected and shielded our people from those consequences. protected and shielded our people from those consequences. I protected and shielded our people from those consequences. I believe from those consequences. I believe we from those consequences. I believe we have. from those consequences. I believe we have. We from those consequences. I believe we have. We are from those consequences. I believe we have. We are looking from those consequences. I believe we have. We are looking for from those consequences. I believe we have. We are looking for ways from those consequences. I believe we have. We are looking for ways to we have. We are looking for ways to support we have. We are looking for ways to support small we have. We are looking for ways to support small and we have. We are looking for ways to support small and medium we have. We are looking for ways to support small and medium businesses support small and medium businesses and support small and medium businesses and in support small and medium businesses and in that support small and medium businesses and in that regard support small and medium businesses and in that regard the support small and medium businesses and in that regard the following and in that regard the following principles and in that regard the following principles are and in that regard the following principles are guiding and in that regard the following principles are guiding our and in that regard the following principles are guiding our policy principles are guiding our policy development. principles are guiding our policy development. The principles are guiding our policy development. The ease principles are guiding our policy development. The ease of development. The ease of understanding development. The ease of understanding and development. The ease of understanding and compliance. development. The ease of understanding and compliance. Tax understanding and compliance. Tax efficiency, understanding and compliance. Tax efficiency, practical understanding and compliance. Tax efficiency, practical tax understanding and compliance. Tax efficiency, practical tax relief efficiency, practical tax relief that efficiency, practical tax relief that will efficiency, practical tax relief that will have efficiency, practical tax relief that will have a efficiency, practical tax relief that will have a real efficiency, practical tax relief that will have a real impact efficiency, practical tax relief that will have a real impact on that will have a real impact on economic that will have a real impact on economic growth. that will have a real impact on economic growth. Innovation that will have a real impact on economic growth. Innovation and economic growth. Innovation and productivity. economic growth. Innovation and productivity. We economic growth. Innovation and productivity. We are economic growth. Innovation and productivity. We are going, economic growth. Innovation and productivity. We are going, compared productivity. We are going, compared to productivity. We are going, compared to other productivity. We are going, compared to other economies, productivity. We are going, compared to other economies, very, productivity. We are going, compared to other economies, very, very productivity. We are going, compared to other economies, very, very well, to other economies, very, very well, but to other economies, very, very well, but we to other economies, very, very well, but we could to other economies, very, very well, but we could do to other economies, very, very well, but we could do and to other economies, very, very well, but we could do and can to other economies, very, very well, but we could do and can do to other economies, very, very well, but we could do and can do a to other economies, very, very well, but we could do and can do a whole but we could do and can do a whole lot but we could do and can do a whole lot better. but we could do and can do a whole lot better. Now but we could do and can do a whole lot better. Now you but we could do and can do a whole lot better. Now you remember but we could do and can do a whole lot better. Now you remember the lot better. Now you remember the National lot better. Now you remember the National Party lot better. Now you remember the National Party and lot better. Now you remember the National Party and his lot better. Now you remember the National Party and his rail National Party and his rail privatisation National Party and his rail privatisation programme, National Party and his rail privatisation programme, in National Party and his rail privatisation programme, in 1993 privatisation programme, in 1993 they privatisation programme, in 1993 they flogged privatisation programme, in 1993 they flogged it privatisation programme, in 1993 they flogged it off privatisation programme, in 1993 they flogged it off to privatisation programme, in 1993 they flogged it off to their they flogged it off to their friends. they flogged it off to their friends. Then they flogged it off to their friends. Then they they flogged it off to their friends. Then they recapitalised they flogged it off to their friends. Then they recapitalised it friends. Then they recapitalised it and friends. Then they recapitalised it and theshires friends. Then they recapitalised it and theshires went friends. Then they recapitalised it and theshires went up friends. Then they recapitalised it and theshires went up to friends. Then they recapitalised it and theshires went up to $9.42. and theshires went up to $9.42. After and theshires went up to $9.42. After they and theshires went up to $9.42. After they recapitalised and theshires went up to $9.42. After they recapitalised it and theshires went up to $9.42. After they recapitalised it and After they recapitalised it and gauged After they recapitalised it and gauged it, After they recapitalised it and gauged it, the After they recapitalised it and gauged it, the shares After they recapitalised it and gauged it, the shares went After they recapitalised it and gauged it, the shares went down After they recapitalised it and gauged it, the shares went down to gauged it, the shares went down to 28 gauged it, the shares went down to 28 cents. gauged it, the shares went down to 28 cents. That gauged it, the shares went down to 28 cents. That is gauged it, the shares went down to 28 cents. That is their gauged it, the shares went down to 28 cents. That is their record gauged it, the shares went down to 28 cents. That is their record on 28 cents. That is their record on rail. 28 cents. That is their record on rail. The 28 cents. That is their record on rail. The Labour 28 cents. That is their record on rail. The Labour Party 28 cents. That is their record on rail. The Labour Party brought 28 cents. That is their record on rail. The Labour Party brought it rail. The Labour Party brought it back rail. The Labour Party brought it back having rail. The Labour Party brought it back having realised rail. The Labour Party brought it back having realised this rail. The Labour Party brought it back having realised this was rail. The Labour Party brought it back having realised this was not rail. The Labour Party brought it back having realised this was not a back having realised this was not a very back having realised this was not a very wise back having realised this was not a very wise thing back having realised this was not a very wise thing to back having realised this was not a very wise thing to do, back having realised this was not a very wise thing to do, put back having realised this was not a very wise thing to do, put it back having realised this was not a very wise thing to do, put it back very wise thing to do, put it back together very wise thing to do, put it back together again, very wise thing to do, put it back together again, national very wise thing to do, put it back together again, national gets very wise thing to do, put it back together again, national gets back together again, national gets back in together again, national gets back in and together again, national gets back in and deliberately together again, national gets back in and deliberately set together again, national gets back in and deliberately set out together again, national gets back in and deliberately set out to together again, national gets back in and deliberately set out to run in and deliberately set out to run it in and deliberately set out to run it into in and deliberately set out to run it into the in and deliberately set out to run it into the ground in and deliberately set out to run it into the ground again. in and deliberately set out to run it into the ground again. Rubbish! in and deliberately set out to run it into the ground again. Rubbish! I it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it is it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it is rubbish it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it is rubbish and it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it is rubbish and that it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it is rubbish and that is it into the ground again. Rubbish! I know it is rubbish and that is your know it is rubbish and that is your specialty. know it is rubbish and that is your specialty. Unbelievable. know it is rubbish and that is your specialty. Unbelievable. What know it is rubbish and that is your specialty. Unbelievable. What a specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, hey. specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, hey. What specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, hey. What a specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, hey. What a sucker. specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, hey. What a sucker. I specialty. Unbelievable. What a sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to focus sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to focus on sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to focus on my sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to focus on my speech sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to focus on my speech otherwise sucker, hey. What a sucker. I want to focus on my speech otherwise I'd to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a field to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a field day. to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a field day. It to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a field day. It is to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a field day. It is like to focus on my speech otherwise I'd have a field day. It is like having have a field day. It is like having a have a field day. It is like having a dual have a field day. It is like having a dual of have a field day. It is like having a dual of wits have a field day. It is like having a dual of wits with have a field day. It is like having a dual of wits with an have a field day. It is like having a dual of wits with an unarmed a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! I a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! I am a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! I am a a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! I am a nice a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. a dual of wits with an unarmed opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The big opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The big thing opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The big thing that's opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The big thing that's going opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The big thing that's going to opponent, mate! I am a nice guy. The big thing that's going to happen big thing that's going to happen this big thing that's going to happen this year, big thing that's going to happen this year, and big thing that's going to happen this year, and it big thing that's going to happen this year, and it is big thing that's going to happen this year, and it is important big thing that's going to happen this year, and it is important for this year, and it is important for New this year, and it is important for New Zealand this year, and it is important for New Zealand to this year, and it is important for New Zealand to recognise this year, and it is important for New Zealand to recognise this, this year, and it is important for New Zealand to recognise this, is New Zealand to recognise this, is that New Zealand to recognise this, is that we New Zealand to recognise this, is that we need New Zealand to recognise this, is that we need a New Zealand to recognise this, is that we need a dialogue New Zealand to recognise this, is that we need a dialogue with New Zealand to recognise this, is that we need a dialogue with the New Zealand to recognise this, is that we need a dialogue with the New that we need a dialogue with the New Zealand that we need a dialogue with the New Zealand people that we need a dialogue with the New Zealand people about that we need a dialogue with the New Zealand people about our that we need a dialogue with the New Zealand people about our future Zealand people about our future population Zealand people about our future population policy Zealand people about our future population policy because Zealand people about our future population policy because the population policy because the forecast population policy because the forecast of population policy because the forecast of New population policy because the forecast of New Zealand's population policy because the forecast of New Zealand's population forecast of New Zealand's population by forecast of New Zealand's population by 2050 forecast of New Zealand's population by 2050 has forecast of New Zealand's population by 2050 has got forecast of New Zealand's population by 2050 has got us forecast of New Zealand's population by 2050 has got us there forecast of New Zealand's population by 2050 has got us there already. by 2050 has got us there already. All by 2050 has got us there already. All the by 2050 has got us there already. All the forecasts by 2050 has got us there already. All the forecasts said by 2050 has got us there already. All the forecasts said that by 2050 has got us there already. All the forecasts said that where All the forecasts said that where New All the forecasts said that where New Zealand All the forecasts said that where New Zealand would All the forecasts said that where New Zealand would be All the forecasts said that where New Zealand would be in All the forecasts said that where New Zealand would be in 2050 All the forecasts said that where New Zealand would be in 2050 is New Zealand would be in 2050 is today's New Zealand would be in 2050 is today's population New Zealand would be in 2050 is today's population and New Zealand would be in 2050 is today's population and no New Zealand would be in 2050 is today's population and no one New Zealand would be in 2050 is today's population and no one has today's population and no one has had today's population and no one has had a today's population and no one has had a discussion today's population and no one has had a discussion with today's population and no one has had a discussion with any today's population and no one has had a discussion with any New had a discussion with any New Zealanders had a discussion with any New Zealanders at had a discussion with any New Zealanders at all. had a discussion with any New Zealanders at all. The had a discussion with any New Zealanders at all. The consequences Zealanders at all. The consequences are Zealanders at all. The consequences are huge. Zealanders at all. The consequences are huge. We Zealanders at all. The consequences are huge. We can Zealanders at all. The consequences are huge. We can see Zealanders at all. The consequences are huge. We can see the Zealanders at all. The consequences are huge. We can see the straining are huge. We can see the straining and are huge. We can see the straining and suffering are huge. We can see the straining and suffering out are huge. We can see the straining and suffering out there are huge. We can see the straining and suffering out there where are huge. We can see the straining and suffering out there where we and suffering out there where we have and suffering out there where we have third-world and suffering out there where we have third-world problems and suffering out there where we have third-world problems that and suffering out there where we have third-world problems that we have third-world problems that we have third-world problems that we have third-world problems that we have allowed have third-world problems that we have allowed to have third-world problems that we have allowed to be have third-world problems that we have allowed to be created have third-world problems that we have allowed to be created because have allowed to be created because we have allowed to be created because we haven't have allowed to be created because we haven't had have allowed to be created because we haven't had a have allowed to be created because we haven't had a focused, have allowed to be created because we haven't had a focused, smart we haven't had a focused, smart policy. we haven't had a focused, smart policy. Where we haven't had a focused, smart policy. Where they we haven't had a focused, smart policy. Where they were we haven't had a focused, smart policy. Where they were going we haven't had a focused, smart policy. Where they were going to, policy. Where they were going to, mainly policy. Where they were going to, mainly to policy. Where they were going to, mainly to Auckland, policy. Where they were going to, mainly to Auckland, all policy. Where they were going to, mainly to Auckland, all around policy. Where they were going to, mainly to Auckland, all around the mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces we mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces we need mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces we need workers mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces we need workers so mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces we need workers so we mainly to Auckland, all around the provinces we need workers so we need provinces we need workers so we need a provinces we need workers so we need a focused provinces we need workers so we need a focused immigration provinces we need workers so we need a focused immigration policy provinces we need workers so we need a focused immigration policy that a focused immigration policy that looks a focused immigration policy that looks at a focused immigration policy that looks at making a focused immigration policy that looks at making sure a focused immigration policy that looks at making sure the a focused immigration policy that looks at making sure the provinces looks at making sure the provinces get looks at making sure the provinces get their looks at making sure the provinces get their fair looks at making sure the provinces get their fair share looks at making sure the provinces get their fair share of looks at making sure the provinces get their fair share of overseas get their fair share of overseas expertise get their fair share of overseas expertise as get their fair share of overseas expertise as well. get their fair share of overseas expertise as well. Meanwhile get their fair share of overseas expertise as well. Meanwhile out get their fair share of overseas expertise as well. Meanwhile out in expertise as well. Meanwhile out in the expertise as well. Meanwhile out in the provinces expertise as well. Meanwhile out in the provinces there expertise as well. Meanwhile out in the provinces there is expertise as well. Meanwhile out in the provinces there is a expertise as well. Meanwhile out in the provinces there is a different the provinces there is a different dichotomy the provinces there is a different dichotomy of the provinces there is a different dichotomy of ageing the provinces there is a different dichotomy of ageing where the provinces there is a different dichotomy of ageing where they the provinces there is a different dichotomy of ageing where they are dichotomy of ageing where they are older dichotomy of ageing where they are older than dichotomy of ageing where they are older than the dichotomy of ageing where they are older than the big dichotomy of ageing where they are older than the big cities dichotomy of ageing where they are older than the big cities with dichotomy of ageing where they are older than the big cities with so older than the big cities with so much older than the big cities with so much immigration. older than the big cities with so much immigration. What older than the big cities with so much immigration. What that older than the big cities with so much immigration. What that means older than the big cities with so much immigration. What that means in much immigration. What that means in the much immigration. What that means in the long much immigration. What that means in the long run much immigration. What that means in the long run is, much immigration. What that means in the long run is, they much immigration. What that means in the long run is, they will much immigration. What that means in the long run is, they will be much immigration. What that means in the long run is, they will be gauged the long run is, they will be gauged out the long run is, they will be gauged out as the long run is, they will be gauged out as well the long run is, they will be gauged out as well until the long run is, they will be gauged out as well until the the long run is, they will be gauged out as well until the services the long run is, they will be gauged out as well until the services all out as well until the services all go. out as well until the services all go. We out as well until the services all go. We need out as well until the services all go. We need to out as well until the services all go. We need to look out as well until the services all go. We need to look after out as well until the services all go. We need to look after New go. We need to look after New Zealand go. We need to look after New Zealand from go. We need to look after New Zealand from Invercargill go. We need to look after New Zealand from Invercargill to go. We need to look after New Zealand from Invercargill to Kaitaia Zealand from Invercargill to Kaitaia to Zealand from Invercargill to Kaitaia to understand Zealand from Invercargill to Kaitaia to understand this Zealand from Invercargill to Kaitaia to understand this more Zealand from Invercargill to Kaitaia to understand this more than to understand this more than anything to understand this more than anything else to understand this more than anything else that to understand this more than anything else that it to understand this more than anything else that it is to understand this more than anything else that it is the to understand this more than anything else that it is the riches anything else that it is the riches of anything else that it is the riches of the anything else that it is the riches of the provinces anything else that it is the riches of the provinces that anything else that it is the riches of the provinces that keeps anything else that it is the riches of the provinces that keeps this of the provinces that keeps this country of the provinces that keeps this country going. of the provinces that keeps this country going. That of the provinces that keeps this country going. That you of the provinces that keeps this country going. That you can of the provinces that keeps this country going. That you can burn country going. That you can burn down country going. That you can burn down our country going. That you can burn down our cities country going. That you can burn down our cities but country going. That you can burn down our cities but the country going. That you can burn down our cities but the provinces down our cities but the provinces will down our cities but the provinces will build down our cities but the provinces will build them down our cities but the provinces will build them up. down our cities but the provinces will build them up. But down our cities but the provinces will build them up. But you down our cities but the provinces will build them up. But you burn will build them up. But you burn down will build them up. But you burn down the will build them up. But you burn down the provinces will build them up. But you burn down the provinces and will build them up. But you burn down the provinces and you're will build them up. But you burn down the provinces and you're gone. down the provinces and you're gone. One down the provinces and you're gone. One party down the provinces and you're gone. One party understands down the provinces and you're gone. One party understands that. down the provinces and you're gone. One party understands that. I down the provinces and you're gone. One party understands that. I want One party understands that. I want to One party understands that. I want to tell One party understands that. I want to tell people One party understands that. I want to tell people in One party understands that. I want to tell people in provincial One party understands that. I want to tell people in provincial New to tell people in provincial New Zealand to tell people in provincial New Zealand that to tell people in provincial New Zealand that they to tell people in provincial New Zealand that they have to tell people in provincial New Zealand that they have all to tell people in provincial New Zealand that they have all these Zealand that they have all these Members Zealand that they have all these Members of Zealand that they have all these Members of Parliament Zealand that they have all these Members of Parliament from Zealand that they have all these Members of Parliament from the Members of Parliament from the National Members of Parliament from the National Party Members of Parliament from the National Party from Members of Parliament from the National Party from the Members of Parliament from the National Party from the provinces. National Party from the provinces. They National Party from the provinces. They are National Party from the provinces. They are Lions National Party from the provinces. They are Lions in National Party from the provinces. They are Lions in the National Party from the provinces. They are Lions in the electorate National Party from the provinces. They are Lions in the electorate and They are Lions in the electorate and lambs They are Lions in the electorate and lambs in They are Lions in the electorate and lambs in the They are Lions in the electorate and lambs in the caucus. They are Lions in the electorate and lambs in the caucus. They They are Lions in the electorate and lambs in the caucus. They have They are Lions in the electorate and lambs in the caucus. They have never lambs in the caucus. They have never defended lambs in the caucus. They have never defended the lambs in the caucus. They have never defended the interests lambs in the caucus. They have never defended the interests of lambs in the caucus. They have never defended the interests of the defended the interests of the provinces defended the interests of the provinces when defended the interests of the provinces when it defended the interests of the provinces when it comes defended the interests of the provinces when it comes to defended the interests of the provinces when it comes to exporters provinces when it comes to exporters and provinces when it comes to exporters and farmers. provinces when it comes to exporters and farmers. Let provinces when it comes to exporters and farmers. Let me provinces when it comes to exporters and farmers. Let me say, provinces when it comes to exporters and farmers. Let me say, because provinces when it comes to exporters and farmers. Let me say, because I and farmers. Let me say, because I was and farmers. Let me say, because I was a and farmers. Let me say, because I was a member and farmers. Let me say, because I was a member of and farmers. Let me say, because I was a member of the and farmers. Let me say, because I was a member of the National and farmers. Let me say, because I was a member of the National Party was a member of the National Party once, was a member of the National Party once, in was a member of the National Party once, in your was a member of the National Party once, in your choice was a member of the National Party once, in your choice as was a member of the National Party once, in your choice as a was a member of the National Party once, in your choice as a young once, in your choice as a young person once, in your choice as a young person is once, in your choice as a young person is to once, in your choice as a young person is to join once, in your choice as a young person is to join the once, in your choice as a young person is to join the National once, in your choice as a young person is to join the National Party person is to join the National Party because person is to join the National Party because you person is to join the National Party because you are person is to join the National Party because you are trying person is to join the National Party because you are trying to person is to join the National Party because you are trying to find person is to join the National Party because you are trying to find a because you are trying to find a wife because you are trying to find a wife or because you are trying to find a wife or a because you are trying to find a wife or a husband, because you are trying to find a wife or a husband, there because you are trying to find a wife or a husband, there are because you are trying to find a wife or a husband, there are better wife or a husband, there are better places wife or a husband, there are better places to wife or a husband, there are better places to go wife or a husband, there are better places to go for wife or a husband, there are better places to go for real wife or a husband, there are better places to go for real company. wife or a husband, there are better places to go for real company. The places to go for real company. The problem places to go for real company. The problem is places to go for real company. The problem is that places to go for real company. The problem is that once places to go for real company. The problem is that once they places to go for real company. The problem is that once they get places to go for real company. The problem is that once they get here problem is that once they get here the problem is that once they get here the big problem is that once they get here the big banks problem is that once they get here the big banks get problem is that once they get here the big banks get to problem is that once they get here the big banks get to them problem is that once they get here the big banks get to them and problem is that once they get here the big banks get to them and they the big banks get to them and they stop the big banks get to them and they stop speaking the big banks get to them and they stop speaking for the big banks get to them and they stop speaking for the the big banks get to them and they stop speaking for the provinces. the big banks get to them and they stop speaking for the provinces. For stop speaking for the provinces. For example, stop speaking for the provinces. For example, when stop speaking for the provinces. For example, when is stop speaking for the provinces. For example, when is the stop speaking for the provinces. For example, when is the last stop speaking for the provinces. For example, when is the last time stop speaking for the provinces. For example, when is the last time a example, when is the last time a speech example, when is the last time a speech was example, when is the last time a speech was made example, when is the last time a speech was made about example, when is the last time a speech was made about Invercargill. speech was made about Invercargill. When speech was made about Invercargill. When is speech was made about Invercargill. When is the speech was made about Invercargill. When is the last speech was made about Invercargill. When is the last time speech was made about Invercargill. When is the last time that speech was made about Invercargill. When is the last time that Mr When is the last time that Mr McKelvie When is the last time that Mr McKelvie made When is the last time that Mr McKelvie made a When is the last time that Mr McKelvie made a speech When is the last time that Mr McKelvie made a speech about When is the last time that Mr McKelvie made a speech about the McKelvie made a speech about the provinces. McKelvie made a speech about the provinces. When McKelvie made a speech about the provinces. When was McKelvie made a speech about the provinces. When was the McKelvie made a speech about the provinces. When was the last McKelvie made a speech about the provinces. When was the last time provinces. When was the last time anybody provinces. When was the last time anybody in provinces. When was the last time anybody in the provinces. When was the last time anybody in the countryside provinces. When was the last time anybody in the countryside from provinces. When was the last time anybody in the countryside from the anybody in the countryside from the National anybody in the countryside from the National Party anybody in the countryside from the National Party got anybody in the countryside from the National Party got up anybody in the countryside from the National Party got up and anybody in the countryside from the National Party got up and told anybody in the countryside from the National Party got up and told the National Party got up and told the world National Party got up and told the world what National Party got up and told the world what the National Party got up and told the world what the country National Party got up and told the world what the country needed. National Party got up and told the world what the country needed. It National Party got up and told the world what the country needed. It is world what the country needed. It is deafening. world what the country needed. It is deafening. They world what the country needed. It is deafening. They can't world what the country needed. It is deafening. They can't tell world what the country needed. It is deafening. They can't tell me world what the country needed. It is deafening. They can't tell me one deafening. They can't tell me one example. deafening. They can't tell me one example. Who deafening. They can't tell me one example. Who was deafening. They can't tell me one example. Who was the deafening. They can't tell me one example. Who was the last deafening. They can't tell me one example. Who was the last one deafening. They can't tell me one example. Who was the last one who example. Who was the last one who made example. Who was the last one who made a example. Who was the last one who made a speech? example. Who was the last one who made a speech? Please example. Who was the last one who made a speech? Please don't example. Who was the last one who made a speech? Please don't tell example. Who was the last one who made a speech? Please don't tell me made a speech? Please don't tell me the made a speech? Please don't tell me the guy made a speech? Please don't tell me the guy from made a speech? Please don't tell me the guy from the made a speech? Please don't tell me the guy from the prosecution made a speech? Please don't tell me the guy from the prosecution office the guy from the prosecution office from the guy from the prosecution office from Tauranga, the guy from the prosecution office from Tauranga, even the guy from the prosecution office from Tauranga, even though the guy from the prosecution office from Tauranga, even though he the guy from the prosecution office from Tauranga, even though he didn't from Tauranga, even though he didn't have from Tauranga, even though he didn't have a from Tauranga, even though he didn't have a warrant. from Tauranga, even though he didn't have a warrant. Please from Tauranga, even though he didn't have a warrant. Please don't from Tauranga, even though he didn't have a warrant. Please don't say from Tauranga, even though he didn't have a warrant. Please don't say he have a warrant. Please don't say he speaks have a warrant. Please don't say he speaks for have a warrant. Please don't say he speaks for the have a warrant. Please don't say he speaks for the country. have a warrant. Please don't say he speaks for the country. Yes, have a warrant. Please don't say he speaks for the country. Yes, it speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on the speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on the CV, speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on the CV, he speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on the CV, he used speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on the CV, he used to speaks for the country. Yes, it sounds good on the CV, he used to be sounds good on the CV, he used to be a sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, he sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, he says. sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, he says. He sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, he says. He used sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, he says. He used to sounds good on the CV, he used to be a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a Crown a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a Crown prosecutor. a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a Crown prosecutor. Mr a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, a prosecutor, he says. He used to be a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did you a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did you have a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did you have a a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did you have a warrant? a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did you have a warrant? No. a Crown prosecutor. Mr Bridges, did you have a warrant? No. Again you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. It you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. It is you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. It is like you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. It is like taking you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. It is like taking candy you have a warrant? No. Again exposed. It is like taking candy off exposed. It is like taking candy off a exposed. It is like taking candy off a baby, exposed. It is like taking candy off a baby, isn't exposed. It is like taking candy off a baby, isn't it? exposed. It is like taking candy off a baby, isn't it? Just exposed. It is like taking candy off a baby, isn't it? Just ask exposed. It is like taking candy off a baby, isn't it? Just ask the a baby, isn't it? Just ask the question a baby, isn't it? Just ask the question - a baby, isn't it? Just ask the question - oh, a baby, isn't it? Just ask the question - oh, Judith a baby, isn't it? Just ask the question - oh, Judith knows a baby, isn't it? Just ask the question - oh, Judith knows because question - oh, Judith knows because Judith question - oh, Judith knows because Judith has question - oh, Judith knows because Judith has a question - oh, Judith knows because Judith has a real question - oh, Judith knows because Judith has a real background question - oh, Judith knows because Judith has a real background in question - oh, Judith knows because Judith has a real background in law. Judith has a real background in law. I Judith has a real background in law. I do Judith has a real background in law. I do respect Judith has a real background in law. I do respect that. Judith has a real background in law. I do respect that. When Judith has a real background in law. I do respect that. When it Judith has a real background in law. I do respect that. When it comes Judith has a real background in law. I do respect that. When it comes to I do respect that. When it comes to the I do respect that. When it comes to the man I do respect that. When it comes to the man with I do respect that. When it comes to the man with all I do respect that. When it comes to the man with all the I do respect that. When it comes to the man with all the beef I do respect that. When it comes to the man with all the beef from the man with all the beef from Tauranga, the man with all the beef from Tauranga, no the man with all the beef from Tauranga, no go, the man with all the beef from Tauranga, no go, no the man with all the beef from Tauranga, no go, no show. the man with all the beef from Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank the man with all the beef from Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you very Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you very much. Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you very much. The Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you very much. The Hon Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you very much. The Hon James Tauranga, no go, no show. Thank you very much. The Hon James Shaw. very much. The Hon James Shaw. <SPEAKS very much. The Hon James Shaw. <SPEAKS TE very much. The Hon James Shaw. <SPEAKS TE REO very much. The Hon James Shaw. <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before I <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before I turn <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before I turn my <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before I turn my attention <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before I turn my attention to <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> Before I turn my attention to the Before I turn my attention to the PM's Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement I Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement I just Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement I just want Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement I just want to Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement I just want to take Before I turn my attention to the PM's statement I just want to take a PM's statement I just want to take a moment PM's statement I just want to take a moment to PM's statement I just want to take a moment to draw PM's statement I just want to take a moment to draw this PM's statement I just want to take a moment to draw this House's moment to draw this House's attention moment to draw this House's attention and moment to draw this House's attention and our moment to draw this House's attention and our memory moment to draw this House's attention and our memory to moment to draw this House's attention and our memory to the attention and our memory to the catastrophic attention and our memory to the catastrophic fires attention and our memory to the catastrophic fires that attention and our memory to the catastrophic fires that occurred attention and our memory to the catastrophic fires that occurred in catastrophic fires that occurred in Australia catastrophic fires that occurred in Australia over catastrophic fires that occurred in Australia over the catastrophic fires that occurred in Australia over the summer catastrophic fires that occurred in Australia over the summer and catastrophic fires that occurred in Australia over the summer and many Australia over the summer and many of Australia over the summer and many of which Australia over the summer and many of which are Australia over the summer and many of which are still Australia over the summer and many of which are still burning Australia over the summer and many of which are still burning now. Australia over the summer and many of which are still burning now. I of which are still burning now. I think of which are still burning now. I think it of which are still burning now. I think it is of which are still burning now. I think it is pretty of which are still burning now. I think it is pretty easy of which are still burning now. I think it is pretty easy amongst of which are still burning now. I think it is pretty easy amongst all think it is pretty easy amongst all the think it is pretty easy amongst all the hurly-burly think it is pretty easy amongst all the hurly-burly of think it is pretty easy amongst all the hurly-burly of our think it is pretty easy amongst all the hurly-burly of our election think it is pretty easy amongst all the hurly-burly of our election year the hurly-burly of our election year to the hurly-burly of our election year to forget the hurly-burly of our election year to forget the the hurly-burly of our election year to forget the cry the hurly-burly of our election year to forget the cry sees the hurly-burly of our election year to forget the cry sees that the hurly-burly of our election year to forget the cry sees that have to forget the cry sees that have occurred to forget the cry sees that have occurred to to forget the cry sees that have occurred to our to forget the cry sees that have occurred to our nearest to forget the cry sees that have occurred to our nearest neighbour occurred to our nearest neighbour but occurred to our nearest neighbour but there occurred to our nearest neighbour but there was, occurred to our nearest neighbour but there was, and occurred to our nearest neighbour but there was, and has occurred to our nearest neighbour but there was, and has been, but there was, and has been, extraordinary but there was, and has been, extraordinary loss but there was, and has been, extraordinary loss of but there was, and has been, extraordinary loss of wildlife, but there was, and has been, extraordinary loss of wildlife, of extraordinary loss of wildlife, of human extraordinary loss of wildlife, of human life, extraordinary loss of wildlife, of human life, of extraordinary loss of wildlife, of human life, of forestry extraordinary loss of wildlife, of human life, of forestry and extraordinary loss of wildlife, of human life, of forestry and of human life, of forestry and of property. human life, of forestry and of property. The human life, of forestry and of property. The areas human life, of forestry and of property. The areas that human life, of forestry and of property. The areas that were human life, of forestry and of property. The areas that were burned property. The areas that were burned extraordinary property. The areas that were burned by the fires, property. The areas that were burned by the fires, if property. The areas that were burned by the fires, if that property. The areas that were burned by the fires, if that had property. The areas that were burned by the fires, if that had occurred by the fires, if that had occurred here by the fires, if that had occurred here in by the fires, if that had occurred here in New by the fires, if that had occurred here in New Zealand, by the fires, if that had occurred here in New Zealand, would by the fires, if that had occurred here in New Zealand, would have here in New Zealand, would have stretched here in New Zealand, would have stretched from here in New Zealand, would have stretched from cape here in New Zealand, would have stretched from cape Rianga here in New Zealand, would have stretched from cape Rianga in here in New Zealand, would have stretched from cape Rianga in the stretched from cape Rianga in the north stretched from cape Rianga in the north to stretched from cape Rianga in the north to Rotorua stretched from cape Rianga in the north to Rotorua and stretched from cape Rianga in the north to Rotorua and burned north to Rotorua and burned everything north to Rotorua and burned everything in north to Rotorua and burned everything in between. north to Rotorua and burned everything in between. I north to Rotorua and burned everything in between. I just north to Rotorua and burned everything in between. I just think everything in between. I just think if everything in between. I just think if we everything in between. I just think if we could everything in between. I just think if we could just everything in between. I just think if we could just take everything in between. I just think if we could just take a everything in between. I just think if we could just take a moment everything in between. I just think if we could just take a moment to if we could just take a moment to just if we could just take a moment to just acknowledge if we could just take a moment to just acknowledge the if we could just take a moment to just acknowledge the scale if we could just take a moment to just acknowledge the scale of if we could just take a moment to just acknowledge the scale of what just acknowledge the scale of what has just acknowledge the scale of what has happened just acknowledge the scale of what has happened in just acknowledge the scale of what has happened in Australia just acknowledge the scale of what has happened in Australia because has happened in Australia because this has happened in Australia because this House has happened in Australia because this House has has happened in Australia because this House has not has happened in Australia because this House has not yet has happened in Australia because this House has not yet had has happened in Australia because this House has not yet had an this House has not yet had an opportunity this House has not yet had an opportunity to this House has not yet had an opportunity to reflect this House has not yet had an opportunity to reflect or opportunity to reflect or acknowledge opportunity to reflect or acknowledge the opportunity to reflect or acknowledge the catastrophe opportunity to reflect or acknowledge the catastrophe that opportunity to reflect or acknowledge the catastrophe that has acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen Australia acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen Australia so acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen Australia so I acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen Australia so I just acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen Australia so I just want acknowledge the catastrophe that has befallen Australia so I just want to befallen Australia so I just want to take befallen Australia so I just want to take this befallen Australia so I just want to take this moment befallen Australia so I just want to take this moment to befallen Australia so I just want to take this moment to do befallen Australia so I just want to take this moment to do so befallen Australia so I just want to take this moment to do so before befallen Australia so I just want to take this moment to do so before we take this moment to do so before we begin. take this moment to do so before we begin. Mr take this moment to do so before we begin. Mr Speaker, take this moment to do so before we begin. Mr Speaker, sitting take this moment to do so before we begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and listening begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and listening to begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and listening to the begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and listening to the PM's begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and listening to the PM's statement begin. Mr Speaker, sitting and listening to the PM's statement I listening to the PM's statement I felt listening to the PM's statement I felt enormously listening to the PM's statement I felt enormously proud listening to the PM's statement I felt enormously proud of listening to the PM's statement I felt enormously proud of everything felt enormously proud of everything that felt enormously proud of everything that this felt enormously proud of everything that this Government felt enormously proud of everything that this Government has felt enormously proud of everything that this Government has done, felt enormously proud of everything that this Government has done, is that this Government has done, is doing that this Government has done, is doing and that this Government has done, is doing and is that this Government has done, is doing and is going that this Government has done, is doing and is going to that this Government has done, is doing and is going to do that this Government has done, is doing and is going to do to that this Government has done, is doing and is going to do to make doing and is going to do to make this doing and is going to do to make this country doing and is going to do to make this country even doing and is going to do to make this country even better. doing and is going to do to make this country even better. And doing and is going to do to make this country even better. And to this country even better. And to ensure this country even better. And to ensure that this country even better. And to ensure that it this country even better. And to ensure that it is this country even better. And to ensure that it is a this country even better. And to ensure that it is a great this country even better. And to ensure that it is a great place this country even better. And to ensure that it is a great place to ensure that it is a great place to live ensure that it is a great place to live for ensure that it is a great place to live for all ensure that it is a great place to live for all of ensure that it is a great place to live for all of us ensure that it is a great place to live for all of us and ensure that it is a great place to live for all of us and not ensure that it is a great place to live for all of us and not just ensure that it is a great place to live for all of us and not just all live for all of us and not just all of live for all of us and not just all of us live for all of us and not just all of us now live for all of us and not just all of us now but live for all of us and not just all of us now but for live for all of us and not just all of us now but for generations live for all of us and not just all of us now but for generations to of us now but for generations to come. of us now but for generations to come. And of us now but for generations to come. And so of us now but for generations to come. And so it of us now but for generations to come. And so it is of us now but for generations to come. And so it is with of us now but for generations to come. And so it is with great come. And so it is with great pleasure come. And so it is with great pleasure that come. And so it is with great pleasure that I come. And so it is with great pleasure that I do come. And so it is with great pleasure that I do stand come. And so it is with great pleasure that I do stand on come. And so it is with great pleasure that I do stand on behalf pleasure that I do stand on behalf of pleasure that I do stand on behalf of the pleasure that I do stand on behalf of the Green pleasure that I do stand on behalf of the Green Party pleasure that I do stand on behalf of the Green Party to pleasure that I do stand on behalf of the Green Party to support pleasure that I do stand on behalf of the Green Party to support the of the Green Party to support the PM's of the Green Party to support the PM's motion of the Green Party to support the PM's motion and of the Green Party to support the PM's motion and her of the Green Party to support the PM's motion and her statement of the Green Party to support the PM's motion and her statement that PM's motion and her statement that this PM's motion and her statement that this House PM's motion and her statement that this House has PM's motion and her statement that this House has confidence PM's motion and her statement that this House has confidence in PM's motion and her statement that this House has confidence in this this House has confidence in this Government. this House has confidence in this Government. I this House has confidence in this Government. I do this House has confidence in this Government. I do hope this House has confidence in this Government. I do hope that this House has confidence in this Government. I do hope that the Government. I do hope that the politics Government. I do hope that the politics of Government. I do hope that the politics of this Government. I do hope that the politics of this place, Government. I do hope that the politics of this place, and Government. I do hope that the politics of this place, and we Government. I do hope that the politics of this place, and we have politics of this place, and we have seen politics of this place, and we have seen that politics of this place, and we have seen that amplified politics of this place, and we have seen that amplified already politics of this place, and we have seen that amplified already by politics of this place, and we have seen that amplified already by the seen that amplified already by the proximity seen that amplified already by the proximity of seen that amplified already by the proximity of the seen that amplified already by the proximity of the election, seen that amplified already by the proximity of the election, even proximity of the election, even though proximity of the election, even though it proximity of the election, even though it is proximity of the election, even though it is still proximity of the election, even though it is still something proximity of the election, even though it is still something like proximity of the election, even though it is still something like 8 though it is still something like 8 months though it is still something like 8 months away, though it is still something like 8 months away, won't though it is still something like 8 months away, won't distract though it is still something like 8 months away, won't distract us though it is still something like 8 months away, won't distract us from months away, won't distract us from the months away, won't distract us from the fact months away, won't distract us from the fact that months away, won't distract us from the fact that we months away, won't distract us from the fact that we still months away, won't distract us from the fact that we still have months away, won't distract us from the fact that we still have some months away, won't distract us from the fact that we still have some big the fact that we still have some big decisions the fact that we still have some big decisions to the fact that we still have some big decisions to make the fact that we still have some big decisions to make that the fact that we still have some big decisions to make that will the fact that we still have some big decisions to make that will have the fact that we still have some big decisions to make that will have a decisions to make that will have a profound decisions to make that will have a profound effect decisions to make that will have a profound effect on decisions to make that will have a profound effect on the decisions to make that will have a profound effect on the lives decisions to make that will have a profound effect on the lives of decisions to make that will have a profound effect on the lives of New profound effect on the lives of New Zealanders. profound effect on the lives of New Zealanders. Whether profound effect on the lives of New Zealanders. Whether it profound effect on the lives of New Zealanders. Whether it is profound effect on the lives of New Zealanders. Whether it is to profound effect on the lives of New Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure that Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure that people Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure that people have Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure that people have warm Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure that people have warm and Zealanders. Whether it is to ensure that people have warm and safe that people have warm and safe houses that people have warm and safe houses or that people have warm and safe houses or whether that people have warm and safe houses or whether it that people have warm and safe houses or whether it is that people have warm and safe houses or whether it is ending that people have warm and safe houses or whether it is ending child houses or whether it is ending child poverty houses or whether it is ending child poverty or houses or whether it is ending child poverty or supporting houses or whether it is ending child poverty or supporting young houses or whether it is ending child poverty or supporting young people poverty or supporting young people who poverty or supporting young people who are poverty or supporting young people who are going poverty or supporting young people who are going through poverty or supporting young people who are going through a poverty or supporting young people who are going through a rough poverty or supporting young people who are going through a rough time, who are going through a rough time, it who are going through a rough time, it is who are going through a rough time, it is within who are going through a rough time, it is within these who are going through a rough time, it is within these four who are going through a rough time, it is within these four walls who are going through a rough time, it is within these four walls that it is within these four walls that we it is within these four walls that we can it is within these four walls that we can make, it is within these four walls that we can make, and it is within these four walls that we can make, and do it is within these four walls that we can make, and do make, it is within these four walls that we can make, and do make, a it is within these four walls that we can make, and do make, a huge we can make, and do make, a huge difference we can make, and do make, a huge difference to we can make, and do make, a huge difference to people's we can make, and do make, a huge difference to people's lives. we can make, and do make, a huge difference to people's lives. Some difference to people's lives. Some of difference to people's lives. Some of us difference to people's lives. Some of us have difference to people's lives. Some of us have got difference to people's lives. Some of us have got different difference to people's lives. Some of us have got different ideas difference to people's lives. Some of us have got different ideas about of us have got different ideas about how of us have got different ideas about how to of us have got different ideas about how to do of us have got different ideas about how to do that of us have got different ideas about how to do that than of us have got different ideas about how to do that than others of us have got different ideas about how to do that than others but how to do that than others but either how to do that than others but either way, how to do that than others but either way, I how to do that than others but either way, I think how to do that than others but either way, I think all how to do that than others but either way, I think all of how to do that than others but either way, I think all of us how to do that than others but either way, I think all of us in either way, I think all of us in this either way, I think all of us in this House either way, I think all of us in this House should either way, I think all of us in this House should remember either way, I think all of us in this House should remember that either way, I think all of us in this House should remember that it this House should remember that it is this House should remember that it is a this House should remember that it is a responsibility this House should remember that it is a responsibility and this House should remember that it is a responsibility and that this House should remember that it is a responsibility and that - this House should remember that it is a responsibility and that - and is a responsibility and that - and with is a responsibility and that - and with humility, is a responsibility and that - and with humility, that is a responsibility and that - and with humility, that it is a responsibility and that - and with humility, that it is is a responsibility and that - and with humility, that it is a with humility, that it is a responsibility with humility, that it is a responsibility that with humility, that it is a responsibility that we with humility, that it is a responsibility that we walk with humility, that it is a responsibility that we walk into responsibility that we walk into every responsibility that we walk into every time responsibility that we walk into every time we responsibility that we walk into every time we walk responsibility that we walk into every time we walk into responsibility that we walk into every time we walk into this every time we walk into this Chamber. every time we walk into this Chamber. For every time we walk into this Chamber. For this every time we walk into this Chamber. For this place, every time we walk into this Chamber. For this place, it every time we walk into this Chamber. For this place, it doesn't Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to us, Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to us, to Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to us, to the Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to us, to the 120 Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to us, to the 120 members Chamber. For this place, it doesn't belong to us, to the 120 members of belong to us, to the 120 members of this belong to us, to the 120 members of this parliament. belong to us, to the 120 members of this parliament. It belong to us, to the 120 members of this parliament. It belongs belong to us, to the 120 members of this parliament. It belongs to belong to us, to the 120 members of this parliament. It belongs to the this parliament. It belongs to the people this parliament. It belongs to the people of this parliament. It belongs to the people of Aotearoa this parliament. It belongs to the people of Aotearoa New this parliament. It belongs to the people of Aotearoa New Zealand, this parliament. It belongs to the people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it belongs people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it belongs to people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it belongs to people people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it belongs to people who people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it belongs to people who tonight people of Aotearoa New Zealand, it belongs to people who tonight will belongs to people who tonight will be belongs to people who tonight will be sitting belongs to people who tonight will be sitting around belongs to people who tonight will be sitting around the belongs to people who tonight will be sitting around the dinner belongs to people who tonight will be sitting around the dinner table be sitting around the dinner table worrying be sitting around the dinner table worrying about be sitting around the dinner table worrying about how be sitting around the dinner table worrying about how to be sitting around the dinner table worrying about how to pay be sitting around the dinner table worrying about how to pay the be sitting around the dinner table worrying about how to pay the bills. worrying about how to pay the bills. It worrying about how to pay the bills. It will worrying about how to pay the bills. It will be worrying about how to pay the bills. It will be the worrying about how to pay the bills. It will be the people worrying about how to pay the bills. It will be the people who worrying about how to pay the bills. It will be the people who are It will be the people who are working It will be the people who are working tirelessly It will be the people who are working tirelessly to It will be the people who are working tirelessly to improve It will be the people who are working tirelessly to improve our working tirelessly to improve our communities, working tirelessly to improve our communities, people working tirelessly to improve our communities, people up working tirelessly to improve our communities, people up and working tirelessly to improve our communities, people up and down working tirelessly to improve our communities, people up and down the communities, people up and down the country communities, people up and down the country who communities, people up and down the country who are communities, people up and down the country who are starting communities, people up and down the country who are starting and communities, people up and down the country who are starting and running country who are starting and running businesses. country who are starting and running businesses. In country who are starting and running businesses. In the country who are starting and running businesses. In the next country who are starting and running businesses. In the next eight country who are starting and running businesses. In the next eight months businesses. In the next eight months we businesses. In the next eight months we will businesses. In the next eight months we will be businesses. In the next eight months we will be asking businesses. In the next eight months we will be asking those businesses. In the next eight months we will be asking those people, businesses. In the next eight months we will be asking those people, the we will be asking those people, the people we will be asking those people, the people who we will be asking those people, the people who put we will be asking those people, the people who put us we will be asking those people, the people who put us here, we will be asking those people, the people who put us here, to we will be asking those people, the people who put us here, to hold we will be asking those people, the people who put us here, to hold us people who put us here, to hold us to people who put us here, to hold us to account people who put us here, to hold us to account for people who put us here, to hold us to account for what people who put us here, to hold us to account for what we people who put us here, to hold us to account for what we have people who put us here, to hold us to account for what we have done. people who put us here, to hold us to account for what we have done. We to account for what we have done. We too, to account for what we have done. We too, in to account for what we have done. We too, in the to account for what we have done. We too, in the Greens, to account for what we have done. We too, in the Greens, will to account for what we have done. We too, in the Greens, will ask to account for what we have done. We too, in the Greens, will ask them to account for what we have done. We too, in the Greens, will ask them to too, in the Greens, will ask them to support too, in the Greens, will ask them to support the too, in the Greens, will ask them to support the ideas too, in the Greens, will ask them to support the ideas that too, in the Greens, will ask them to support the ideas that we too, in the Greens, will ask them to support the ideas that we have too, in the Greens, will ask them to support the ideas that we have about support the ideas that we have about where support the ideas that we have about where to support the ideas that we have about where to go support the ideas that we have about where to go next. support the ideas that we have about where to go next. And support the ideas that we have about where to go next. And most support the ideas that we have about where to go next. And most of support the ideas that we have about where to go next. And most of these where to go next. And most of these New where to go next. And most of these New Zealanders, where to go next. And most of these New Zealanders, I'm where to go next. And most of these New Zealanders, I'm sure, where to go next. And most of these New Zealanders, I'm sure, want where to go next. And most of these New Zealanders, I'm sure, want a New Zealanders, I'm sure, want a Government New Zealanders, I'm sure, want a Government that New Zealanders, I'm sure, want a Government that will New Zealanders, I'm sure, want a Government that will not New Zealanders, I'm sure, want a Government that will not just Government that will not just confront Government that will not just confront the Government that will not just confront the challenges Government that will not just confront the challenges that Government that will not just confront the challenges that we Government that will not just confront the challenges that we face confront the challenges that we face at confront the challenges that we face at the confront the challenges that we face at the urgency confront the challenges that we face at the urgency and confront the challenges that we face at the urgency and the confront the challenges that we face at the urgency and the scale confront the challenges that we face at the urgency and the scale that at the urgency and the scale that that at the urgency and the scale that that requires at the urgency and the scale that that requires but at the urgency and the scale that that requires but actually at the urgency and the scale that that requires but actually to at the urgency and the scale that that requires but actually to solve that requires but actually to solve those that requires but actually to solve those challenges, that requires but actually to solve those challenges, not that requires but actually to solve those challenges, not just that requires but actually to solve those challenges, not just to those challenges, not just to acknowledge those challenges, not just to acknowledge that those challenges, not just to acknowledge that there those challenges, not just to acknowledge that there is those challenges, not just to acknowledge that there is a those challenges, not just to acknowledge that there is a problem acknowledge that there is a problem but acknowledge that there is a problem but to acknowledge that there is a problem but to actually acknowledge that there is a problem but to actually deal acknowledge that there is a problem but to actually deal with acknowledge that there is a problem but to actually deal with it. but to actually deal with it. Creating but to actually deal with it. Creating a but to actually deal with it. Creating a better but to actually deal with it. Creating a better future but to actually deal with it. Creating a better future for but to actually deal with it. Creating a better future for their Creating a better future for their kids Creating a better future for their kids and Creating a better future for their kids and for Creating a better future for their kids and for their Creating a better future for their kids and for their grandkids, Creating a better future for their kids and for their grandkids, a kids and for their grandkids, a thriving, kids and for their grandkids, a thriving, natural kids and for their grandkids, a thriving, natural world, kids and for their grandkids, a thriving, natural world, a kids and for their grandkids, a thriving, natural world, a cleaner, thriving, natural world, a cleaner, greener thriving, natural world, a cleaner, greener and thriving, natural world, a cleaner, greener and safer thriving, natural world, a cleaner, greener and safer community thriving, natural world, a cleaner, greener and safer community in thriving, natural world, a cleaner, greener and safer community in every greener and safer community in every part greener and safer community in every part of greener and safer community in every part of the greener and safer community in every part of the country. greener and safer community in every part of the country. A greener and safer community in every part of the country. A zero greener and safer community in every part of the country. A zero carbon part of the country. A zero carbon economy part of the country. A zero carbon economy and part of the country. A zero carbon economy and a part of the country. A zero carbon economy and a world part of the country. A zero carbon economy and a world where part of the country. A zero carbon economy and a world where every part of the country. A zero carbon economy and a world where every New economy and a world where every New Zealander economy and a world where every New Zealander can economy and a world where every New Zealander can earn economy and a world where every New Zealander can earn not economy and a world where every New Zealander can earn not just economy and a world where every New Zealander can earn not just enough Zealander can earn not just enough to Zealander can earn not just enough to meet Zealander can earn not just enough to meet their Zealander can earn not just enough to meet their basic Zealander can earn not just enough to meet their basic living Zealander can earn not just enough to meet their basic living costs Zealander can earn not just enough to meet their basic living costs but to meet their basic living costs but to to meet their basic living costs but to enjoy to meet their basic living costs but to enjoy those to meet their basic living costs but to enjoy those things to meet their basic living costs but to enjoy those things that to meet their basic living costs but to enjoy those things that many to meet their basic living costs but to enjoy those things that many of to enjoy those things that many of us, to enjoy those things that many of us, and to enjoy those things that many of us, and certainly to enjoy those things that many of us, and certainly all to enjoy those things that many of us, and certainly all of to enjoy those things that many of us, and certainly all of us to enjoy those things that many of us, and certainly all of us in to enjoy those things that many of us, and certainly all of us in this us, and certainly all of us in this Chamber us, and certainly all of us in this Chamber take us, and certainly all of us in this Chamber take for us, and certainly all of us in this Chamber take for granted, us, and certainly all of us in this Chamber take for granted, like us, and certainly all of us in this Chamber take for granted, like time Chamber take for granted, like time away Chamber take for granted, like time away with Chamber take for granted, like time away with a Chamber take for granted, like time away with a whanau Chamber take for granted, like time away with a whanau or Chamber take for granted, like time away with a whanau or a Chamber take for granted, like time away with a whanau or a treat Chamber take for granted, like time away with a whanau or a treat at Chamber take for granted, like time away with a whanau or a treat at the away with a whanau or a treat at the weekends. away with a whanau or a treat at the weekends. Now, away with a whanau or a treat at the weekends. Now, Mr away with a whanau or a treat at the weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, away with a whanau or a treat at the weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one away with a whanau or a treat at the weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of Government weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of Government was weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of Government was never weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of Government was never going weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of Government was never going to weekends. Now, Mr Speaker, one term of Government was never going to be of Government was never going to be enough of Government was never going to be enough to of Government was never going to be enough to fix of Government was never going to be enough to fix everything of Government was never going to be enough to fix everything that of Government was never going to be enough to fix everything that needed enough to fix everything that needed to enough to fix everything that needed to be enough to fix everything that needed to be fixed enough to fix everything that needed to be fixed but enough to fix everything that needed to be fixed but we enough to fix everything that needed to be fixed but we have enough to fix everything that needed to be fixed but we have made enough to fix everything that needed to be fixed but we have made an to be fixed but we have made an incredible to be fixed but we have made an incredible start to be fixed but we have made an incredible start and to be fixed but we have made an incredible start and New to be fixed but we have made an incredible start and New Zealanders incredible start and New Zealanders know incredible start and New Zealanders know it. incredible start and New Zealanders know it. Nine incredible start and New Zealanders know it. Nine years incredible start and New Zealanders know it. Nine years of incredible start and New Zealanders know it. Nine years of a incredible start and New Zealanders know it. Nine years of a national know it. Nine years of a national life know it. Nine years of a national life led know it. Nine years of a national life led Government know it. Nine years of a national life led Government demanded know it. Nine years of a national life led Government demanded it. life led Government demanded it. Look life led Government demanded it. Look back life led Government demanded it. Look back at life led Government demanded it. Look back at that life led Government demanded it. Look back at that 9-year life led Government demanded it. Look back at that 9-year period life led Government demanded it. Look back at that 9-year period and Look back at that 9-year period and what Look back at that 9-year period and what most Look back at that 9-year period and what most people Look back at that 9-year period and what most people will Look back at that 9-year period and what most people will see Look back at that 9-year period and what most people will see is Look back at that 9-year period and what most people will see is the what most people will see is the familiar what most people will see is the familiar pattern what most people will see is the familiar pattern of what most people will see is the familiar pattern of neglect what most people will see is the familiar pattern of neglect that familiar pattern of neglect that accompanies familiar pattern of neglect that accompanies every familiar pattern of neglect that accompanies every National accompanies every National Government, accompanies every National Government, not accompanies every National Government, not just accompanies every National Government, not just this accompanies every National Government, not just this last accompanies every National Government, not just this last one Government, not just this last one but Government, not just this last one but the Government, not just this last one but the one Government, not just this last one but the one before Government, not just this last one but the one before that Government, not just this last one but the one before that and Government, not just this last one but the one before that and the Government, not just this last one but the one before that and the one but the one before that and the one before but the one before that and the one before that. but the one before that and the one before that. Look but the one before that and the one before that. Look back but the one before that and the one before that. Look back on but the one before that and the one before that. Look back on that before that. Look back on that 9-year before that. Look back on that 9-year period before that. Look back on that 9-year period that before that. Look back on that 9-year period that most before that. Look back on that 9-year period that most people before that. Look back on that 9-year period that most people will 9-year period that most people will see 9-year period that most people will see as 9-year period that most people will see as that 9-year period that most people will see as that familiar 9-year period that most people will see as that familiar pattern 9-year period that most people will see as that familiar pattern of see as that familiar pattern of neglect. see as that familiar pattern of neglect. They see as that familiar pattern of neglect. They will see as that familiar pattern of neglect. They will see see as that familiar pattern of neglect. They will see families see as that familiar pattern of neglect. They will see families that neglect. They will see families that are neglect. They will see families that are struggling neglect. They will see families that are struggling to neglect. They will see families that are struggling to make neglect. They will see families that are struggling to make ends neglect. They will see families that are struggling to make ends meet, are struggling to make ends meet, forced are struggling to make ends meet, forced to are struggling to make ends meet, forced to make are struggling to make ends meet, forced to make impossible are struggling to make ends meet, forced to make impossible choices forced to make impossible choices between forced to make impossible choices between heating forced to make impossible choices between heating their forced to make impossible choices between heating their home forced to make impossible choices between heating their home or between heating their home or putting between heating their home or putting food between heating their home or putting food on between heating their home or putting food on the between heating their home or putting food on the table. between heating their home or putting food on the table. They between heating their home or putting food on the table. They will putting food on the table. They will see putting food on the table. They will see polluted putting food on the table. They will see polluted rivers putting food on the table. They will see polluted rivers and putting food on the table. They will see polluted rivers and a putting food on the table. They will see polluted rivers and a nearly see polluted rivers and a nearly cataclysmic see polluted rivers and a nearly cataclysmic absence see polluted rivers and a nearly cataclysmic absence of see polluted rivers and a nearly cataclysmic absence of the see polluted rivers and a nearly cataclysmic absence of the native cataclysmic absence of the native creatures cataclysmic absence of the native creatures that cataclysmic absence of the native creatures that we cataclysmic absence of the native creatures that we know cataclysmic absence of the native creatures that we know should creatures that we know should inhabit creatures that we know should inhabit our creatures that we know should inhabit our forests creatures that we know should inhabit our forests and creatures that we know should inhabit our forests and our creatures that we know should inhabit our forests and our land. creatures that we know should inhabit our forests and our land. A inhabit our forests and our land. A complete inhabit our forests and our land. A complete absence inhabit our forests and our land. A complete absence of inhabit our forests and our land. A complete absence of meaningful complete absence of meaningful action complete absence of meaningful action to complete absence of meaningful action to tackle complete absence of meaningful action to tackle the complete absence of meaningful action to tackle the climate complete absence of meaningful action to tackle the climate crisis. action to tackle the climate crisis. That's action to tackle the climate crisis. That's what action to tackle the climate crisis. That's what they action to tackle the climate crisis. That's what they will action to tackle the climate crisis. That's what they will look action to tackle the climate crisis. That's what they will look back action to tackle the climate crisis. That's what they will look back on That's what they will look back on on That's what they will look back on on those That's what they will look back on on those last That's what they will look back on on those last Nine That's what they will look back on on those last Nine years That's what they will look back on on those last Nine years and That's what they will look back on on those last Nine years and on That's what they will look back on on those last Nine years and on the on those last Nine years and on the last on those last Nine years and on the last point, on those last Nine years and on the last point, you on those last Nine years and on the last point, you well on those last Nine years and on the last point, you well know on those last Nine years and on the last point, you well know there on those last Nine years and on the last point, you well know there are last point, you well know there are kids last point, you well know there are kids growing last point, you well know there are kids growing up last point, you well know there are kids growing up today last point, you well know there are kids growing up today who last point, you well know there are kids growing up today who are last point, you well know there are kids growing up today who are deeply kids growing up today who are deeply worried kids growing up today who are deeply worried about kids growing up today who are deeply worried about the kids growing up today who are deeply worried about the future kids growing up today who are deeply worried about the future they kids growing up today who are deeply worried about the future they will worried about the future they will inherit worried about the future they will inherit as worried about the future they will inherit as climate worried about the future they will inherit as climate change worried about the future they will inherit as climate change impacts inherit as climate change impacts their inherit as climate change impacts their lives. inherit as climate change impacts their lives. It inherit as climate change impacts their lives. It is inherit as climate change impacts their lives. It is hardly inherit as climate change impacts their lives. It is hardly surprising their lives. It is hardly surprising when their lives. It is hardly surprising when you their lives. It is hardly surprising when you consider their lives. It is hardly surprising when you consider that their lives. It is hardly surprising when you consider that every their lives. It is hardly surprising when you consider that every year when you consider that every year that when you consider that every year that they when you consider that every year that they have when you consider that every year that they have been when you consider that every year that they have been alive when you consider that every year that they have been alive has when you consider that every year that they have been alive has been that they have been alive has been the that they have been alive has been the hottest that they have been alive has been the hottest on that they have been alive has been the hottest on record. that they have been alive has been the hottest on record. Every that they have been alive has been the hottest on record. Every year the hottest on record. Every year for the hottest on record. Every year for teenagers the hottest on record. Every year for teenagers growing the hottest on record. Every year for teenagers growing up the hottest on record. Every year for teenagers growing up today the hottest on record. Every year for teenagers growing up today has for teenagers growing up today has been for teenagers growing up today has been the for teenagers growing up today has been the hottest for teenagers growing up today has been the hottest on for teenagers growing up today has been the hottest on record. been the hottest on record. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> As <INTERRUPTION> As they <INTERRUPTION> As they think <INTERRUPTION> As they think about <INTERRUPTION> As they think about their <INTERRUPTION> As they think about their future As they think about their future they're As they think about their future they're looking As they think about their future they're looking at As they think about their future they're looking at us As they think about their future they're looking at us and As they think about their future they're looking at us and wondering they're looking at us and wondering whether they're looking at us and wondering whether we they're looking at us and wondering whether we have they're looking at us and wondering whether we have the they're looking at us and wondering whether we have the courage they're looking at us and wondering whether we have the courage to they're looking at us and wondering whether we have the courage to step whether we have the courage to step up. whether we have the courage to step up. They whether we have the courage to step up. They want whether we have the courage to step up. They want to whether we have the courage to step up. They want to know whether we have the courage to step up. They want to know if whether we have the courage to step up. They want to know if we whether we have the courage to step up. They want to know if we will up. They want to know if we will take up. They want to know if we will take the up. They want to know if we will take the action up. They want to know if we will take the action to up. They want to know if we will take the action to create up. They want to know if we will take the action to create that take the action to create that better take the action to create that better and take the action to create that better and cleaner take the action to create that better and cleaner world take the action to create that better and cleaner world for take the action to create that better and cleaner world for them better and cleaner world for them and better and cleaner world for them and their better and cleaner world for them and their families better and cleaner world for them and their families or better and cleaner world for them and their families or they better and cleaner world for them and their families or they - better and cleaner world for them and their families or they - what and their families or they - what they and their families or they - what they will and their families or they - what they will inherit and their families or they - what they will inherit from and their families or they - what they will inherit from us and their families or they - what they will inherit from us for and their families or they - what they will inherit from us for their they will inherit from us for their children. they will inherit from us for their children. <INTERRUPTION> children. <INTERRUPTION> I children. <INTERRUPTION> I know children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I want children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I want to children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I want to be children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I want to be able children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I want to be able to children. <INTERRUPTION> I know what I want to be able to say I know what I want to be able to say to I know what I want to be able to say to them. I know what I want to be able to say to them. Climate I know what I want to be able to say to them. Climate change, I know what I want to be able to say to them. Climate change, it I know what I want to be able to say to them. Climate change, it is I know what I want to be able to say to them. Climate change, it is not to them. Climate change, it is not just to them. Climate change, it is not just another to them. Climate change, it is not just another subject, to them. Climate change, it is not just another subject, it to them. Climate change, it is not just another subject, it is to them. Climate change, it is not just another subject, it is a just another subject, it is a prisoner. just another subject, it is a prisoner. Through just another subject, it is a prisoner. Through which just another subject, it is a prisoner. Through which young just another subject, it is a prisoner. Through which young -- prisoner. Through which young -- prisoner. prisoner. Through which young -- prisoner. -- prisoner. Through which young -- prisoner. -- prism prisoner. Through which young -- prisoner. -- prism through prisoner. Through which young -- prisoner. -- prism through which prisoner. -- prism through which young prisoner. -- prism through which young people prisoner. -- prism through which young people see prisoner. -- prism through which young people see the prisoner. -- prism through which young people see the world. prisoner. -- prism through which young people see the world. In prisoner. -- prism through which young people see the world. In their young people see the world. In their term young people see the world. In their term of young people see the world. In their term of Government young people see the world. In their term of Government National term of Government National squandered term of Government National squandered nearly term of Government National squandered nearly a term of Government National squandered nearly a decade term of Government National squandered nearly a decade of squandered nearly a decade of opportunity squandered nearly a decade of opportunity to squandered nearly a decade of opportunity to do squandered nearly a decade of opportunity to do something squandered nearly a decade of opportunity to do something about squandered nearly a decade of opportunity to do something about it opportunity to do something about it and opportunity to do something about it and give opportunity to do something about it and give a opportunity to do something about it and give a better opportunity to do something about it and give a better future. opportunity to do something about it and give a better future. They opportunity to do something about it and give a better future. They gave and give a better future. They gave us and give a better future. They gave us no and give a better future. They gave us no reason and give a better future. They gave us no reason to and give a better future. They gave us no reason to hope and give a better future. They gave us no reason to hope and and give a better future. They gave us no reason to hope and eroded and give a better future. They gave us no reason to hope and eroded no us no reason to hope and eroded no promise us no reason to hope and eroded no promise of us no reason to hope and eroded no promise of change. us no reason to hope and eroded no promise of change. They us no reason to hope and eroded no promise of change. They became us no reason to hope and eroded no promise of change. They became a promise of change. They became a risk promise of change. They became a risk to promise of change. They became a risk to our promise of change. They became a risk to our shared promise of change. They became a risk to our shared future. promise of change. They became a risk to our shared future. That promise of change. They became a risk to our shared future. That is risk to our shared future. That is not risk to our shared future. That is not just risk to our shared future. That is not just negligent, risk to our shared future. That is not just negligent, that risk to our shared future. That is not just negligent, that is not just negligent, that is unforgivable. not just negligent, that is unforgivable. So not just negligent, that is unforgivable. So here, not just negligent, that is unforgivable. So here, two not just negligent, that is unforgivable. So here, two years unforgivable. So here, two years into unforgivable. So here, two years into what unforgivable. So here, two years into what we unforgivable. So here, two years into what we will unforgivable. So here, two years into what we will hope unforgivable. So here, two years into what we will hope will unforgivable. So here, two years into what we will hope will be unforgivable. So here, two years into what we will hope will be a into what we will hope will be a very into what we will hope will be a very long into what we will hope will be a very long period into what we will hope will be a very long period of into what we will hope will be a very long period of opposition into what we will hope will be a very long period of opposition for very long period of opposition for them, very long period of opposition for them, instead very long period of opposition for them, instead of very long period of opposition for them, instead of using very long period of opposition for them, instead of using that very long period of opposition for them, instead of using that time very long period of opposition for them, instead of using that time to them, instead of using that time to think them, instead of using that time to think up them, instead of using that time to think up ideas them, instead of using that time to think up ideas about them, instead of using that time to think up ideas about how them, instead of using that time to think up ideas about how to them, instead of using that time to think up ideas about how to undo them, instead of using that time to think up ideas about how to undo the think up ideas about how to undo the damage think up ideas about how to undo the damage that think up ideas about how to undo the damage that they think up ideas about how to undo the damage that they did, think up ideas about how to undo the damage that they did, the think up ideas about how to undo the damage that they did, the only think up ideas about how to undo the damage that they did, the only thing damage that they did, the only thing that damage that they did, the only thing that they damage that they did, the only thing that they have damage that they did, the only thing that they have managed damage that they did, the only thing that they have managed to damage that they did, the only thing that they have managed to prioritise that they have managed to prioritise is that they have managed to prioritise is an that they have managed to prioritise is an ugly that they have managed to prioritise is an ugly politics that they have managed to prioritise is an ugly politics of that they have managed to prioritise is an ugly politics of fear that they have managed to prioritise is an ugly politics of fear and is an ugly politics of fear and misinformation is an ugly politics of fear and misinformation and is an ugly politics of fear and misinformation and resentment. is an ugly politics of fear and misinformation and resentment. As is an ugly politics of fear and misinformation and resentment. As we misinformation and resentment. As we get misinformation and resentment. As we get closer misinformation and resentment. As we get closer to misinformation and resentment. As we get closer to the misinformation and resentment. As we get closer to the election, misinformation and resentment. As we get closer to the election, and get closer to the election, and we're get closer to the election, and we're eight get closer to the election, and we're eight months get closer to the election, and we're eight months out get closer to the election, and we're eight months out and get closer to the election, and we're eight months out and you get closer to the election, and we're eight months out and you have we're eight months out and you have to we're eight months out and you have to remember we're eight months out and you have to remember what we're eight months out and you have to remember what you we're eight months out and you have to remember what you just we're eight months out and you have to remember what you just saw we're eight months out and you have to remember what you just saw from to remember what you just saw from the to remember what you just saw from the Leader to remember what you just saw from the Leader of to remember what you just saw from the Leader of the to remember what you just saw from the Leader of the Opposition, to remember what you just saw from the Leader of the Opposition, that's the Leader of the Opposition, that's going the Leader of the Opposition, that's going to the Leader of the Opposition, that's going to get the Leader of the Opposition, that's going to get worse, the Leader of the Opposition, that's going to get worse, the the Leader of the Opposition, that's going to get worse, the National going to get worse, the National Party... going to get worse, the National Party... <INTERRUPTION> Party... <INTERRUPTION> The Party... <INTERRUPTION> The National Party... <INTERRUPTION> The National Party Party... <INTERRUPTION> The National Party will Party... <INTERRUPTION> The National Party will pit Party... <INTERRUPTION> The National Party will pit country The National Party will pit country against The National Party will pit country against town, The National Party will pit country against town, they The National Party will pit country against town, they will The National Party will pit country against town, they will promise against town, they will promise simple against town, they will promise simple fixes against town, they will promise simple fixes to against town, they will promise simple fixes to complex against town, they will promise simple fixes to complex solutions. simple fixes to complex solutions. In simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, Mr simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, Mr Bridges simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, Mr Bridges even simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, Mr Bridges even said simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, Mr Bridges even said in simple fixes to complex solutions. In fact, Mr Bridges even said in his In fact, Mr Bridges even said in his speech, In fact, Mr Bridges even said in his speech, "It's In fact, Mr Bridges even said in his speech, "It's simple, In fact, Mr Bridges even said in his speech, "It's simple, just In fact, Mr Bridges even said in his speech, "It's simple, just build speech, "It's simple, just build more speech, "It's simple, just build more roads." speech, "It's simple, just build more roads." The speech, "It's simple, just build more roads." The answer speech, "It's simple, just build more roads." The answer to speech, "It's simple, just build more roads." The answer to every more roads." The answer to every single more roads." The answer to every single question, more roads." The answer to every single question, every more roads." The answer to every single question, every single single question, every single challenge, single question, every single challenge, more single question, every single challenge, more roads single question, every single challenge, more roads is single question, every single challenge, more roads is the single question, every single challenge, more roads is the answer challenge, more roads is the answer to challenge, more roads is the answer to every challenge, more roads is the answer to every question challenge, more roads is the answer to every question that challenge, more roads is the answer to every question that they challenge, more roads is the answer to every question that they have. to every question that they have. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Worst <INTERRUPTION> Worst of <INTERRUPTION> Worst of all, <INTERRUPTION> Worst of all, they <INTERRUPTION> Worst of all, they deny <INTERRUPTION> Worst of all, they deny their Worst of all, they deny their responsibility Worst of all, they deny their responsibility for Worst of all, they deny their responsibility for creating Worst of all, they deny their responsibility for creating the Worst of all, they deny their responsibility for creating the very responsibility for creating the very problems responsibility for creating the very problems that responsibility for creating the very problems that they responsibility for creating the very problems that they say responsibility for creating the very problems that they say that responsibility for creating the very problems that they say that they problems that they say that they want problems that they say that they want to problems that they say that they want to solve. problems that they say that they want to solve. But, problems that they say that they want to solve. But, Mr problems that they say that they want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, problems that they say that they want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we will want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we will not want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we will not adopt want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we will not adopt those want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we will not adopt those tactics. want to solve. But, Mr Speaker, we will not adopt those tactics. We will not adopt those tactics. We will will not adopt those tactics. We will not will not adopt those tactics. We will not say will not adopt those tactics. We will not say just will not adopt those tactics. We will not say just whatever will not adopt those tactics. We will not say just whatever comes will not say just whatever comes into will not say just whatever comes into our will not say just whatever comes into our heads will not say just whatever comes into our heads because will not say just whatever comes into our heads because we will not say just whatever comes into our heads because we think will not say just whatever comes into our heads because we think it into our heads because we think it might into our heads because we think it might work. into our heads because we think it might work. We into our heads because we think it might work. We will into our heads because we think it might work. We will not into our heads because we think it might work. We will not make into our heads because we think it might work. We will not make up might work. We will not make up stuff might work. We will not make up stuff about might work. We will not make up stuff about the might work. We will not make up stuff about the overwhelming stuff about the overwhelming scientific stuff about the overwhelming scientific consensus stuff about the overwhelming scientific consensus on stuff about the overwhelming scientific consensus on climate scientific consensus on climate change scientific consensus on climate change and scientific consensus on climate change and we scientific consensus on climate change and we will scientific consensus on climate change and we will not scientific consensus on climate change and we will not exploit change and we will not exploit people's change and we will not exploit people's genuine change and we will not exploit people's genuine concerns change and we will not exploit people's genuine concerns for people's genuine concerns for political people's genuine concerns for political gain. We We will We will win We will win by We will win by talking We will win by talking to We will win by talking to New We will win by talking to New Zealanders We will win by talking to New Zealanders about We will win by talking to New Zealanders about the We will win by talking to New Zealanders about the type We will win by talking to New Zealanders about the type of We will win by talking to New Zealanders about the type of future Zealanders about the type of future that Zealanders about the type of future that they Zealanders about the type of future that they want Zealanders about the type of future that they want and Zealanders about the type of future that they want and the Zealanders about the type of future that they want and the ideas Zealanders about the type of future that they want and the ideas that Zealanders about the type of future that they want and the ideas that we that they want and the ideas that we have that they want and the ideas that we have about that they want and the ideas that we have about how that they want and the ideas that we have about how to that they want and the ideas that we have about how to get that they want and the ideas that we have about how to get there. that they want and the ideas that we have about how to get there. We that they want and the ideas that we have about how to get there. We will have about how to get there. We will win have about how to get there. We will win because have about how to get there. We will win because of have about how to get there. We will win because of our have about how to get there. We will win because of our track have about how to get there. We will win because of our track record have about how to get there. We will win because of our track record in win because of our track record in Government win because of our track record in Government regardless win because of our track record in Government regardless of win because of our track record in Government regardless of anything Government regardless of anything that Government regardless of anything that they Government regardless of anything that they say. Government regardless of anything that they say. More Government regardless of anything that they say. More than Government regardless of anything that they say. More than two Government regardless of anything that they say. More than two years that they say. More than two years ago, that they say. More than two years ago, the that they say. More than two years ago, the Green that they say. More than two years ago, the Green Party that they say. More than two years ago, the Green Party Members that they say. More than two years ago, the Green Party Members of ago, the Green Party Members of Parliament ago, the Green Party Members of Parliament elected ago, the Green Party Members of Parliament elected to ago, the Green Party Members of Parliament elected to take ago, the Green Party Members of Parliament elected to take seats ago, the Green Party Members of Parliament elected to take seats in Parliament elected to take seats in this Parliament elected to take seats in this place, Parliament elected to take seats in this place, helped Parliament elected to take seats in this place, helped to Parliament elected to take seats in this place, helped to create Parliament elected to take seats in this place, helped to create a this place, helped to create a Government this place, helped to create a Government that this place, helped to create a Government that is this place, helped to create a Government that is committed this place, helped to create a Government that is committed to Government that is committed to reversing Government that is committed to reversing the Government that is committed to reversing the negligence Government that is committed to reversing the negligence of Government that is committed to reversing the negligence of nine reversing the negligence of nine years reversing the negligence of nine years of reversing the negligence of nine years of the reversing the negligence of nine years of the previous reversing the negligence of nine years of the previous National years of the previous National administration. years of the previous National administration. We years of the previous National administration. We made years of the previous National administration. We made a years of the previous National administration. We made a promise years of the previous National administration. We made a promise to administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa that administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa that we administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa that we would administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa that we would not administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa that we would not shy administration. We made a promise to Aotearoa that we would not shy away Aotearoa that we would not shy away from Aotearoa that we would not shy away from the Aotearoa that we would not shy away from the future Aotearoa that we would not shy away from the future that Aotearoa that we would not shy away from the future that demanded Aotearoa that we would not shy away from the future that demanded us, from the future that demanded us, but from the future that demanded us, but work from the future that demanded us, but work to from the future that demanded us, but work to shape from the future that demanded us, but work to shape it. from the future that demanded us, but work to shape it. And from the future that demanded us, but work to shape it. And we from the future that demanded us, but work to shape it. And we here but work to shape it. And we here today but work to shape it. And we here today have but work to shape it. And we here today have a but work to shape it. And we here today have a track but work to shape it. And we here today have a track record but work to shape it. And we here today have a track record of but work to shape it. And we here today have a track record of huge today have a track record of huge progress. today have a track record of huge progress. In today have a track record of huge progress. In our today have a track record of huge progress. In our first today have a track record of huge progress. In our first two today have a track record of huge progress. In our first two years, today have a track record of huge progress. In our first two years, we progress. In our first two years, we have progress. In our first two years, we have taken progress. In our first two years, we have taken more progress. In our first two years, we have taken more action progress. In our first two years, we have taken more action on progress. In our first two years, we have taken more action on climate have taken more action on climate change have taken more action on climate change than have taken more action on climate change than the have taken more action on climate change than the last have taken more action on climate change than the last 30 have taken more action on climate change than the last 30 years have taken more action on climate change than the last 30 years of change than the last 30 years of Government's change than the last 30 years of Government's combined. change than the last 30 years of Government's combined. The change than the last 30 years of Government's combined. The Zero Government's combined. The Zero Carbon Government's combined. The Zero Carbon Act, Government's combined. The Zero Carbon Act, if Government's combined. The Zero Carbon Act, if Climate Government's combined. The Zero Carbon Act, if Climate Change Carbon Act, if Climate Change Commission Carbon Act, if Climate Change Commission the Carbon Act, if Climate Change Commission the emissions Carbon Act, if Climate Change Commission the emissions trading Commission the emissions trading scheme Commission the emissions trading scheme reforms, Commission the emissions trading scheme reforms, the Commission the emissions trading scheme reforms, the first Commission the emissions trading scheme reforms, the first set Commission the emissions trading scheme reforms, the first set of scheme reforms, the first set of emissions scheme reforms, the first set of emissions budgets, scheme reforms, the first set of emissions budgets, the scheme reforms, the first set of emissions budgets, the billions scheme reforms, the first set of emissions budgets, the billions of emissions budgets, the billions of dollars emissions budgets, the billions of dollars that emissions budgets, the billions of dollars that we emissions budgets, the billions of dollars that we are emissions budgets, the billions of dollars that we are investing emissions budgets, the billions of dollars that we are investing in dollars that we are investing in rail, dollars that we are investing in rail, in dollars that we are investing in rail, in light dollars that we are investing in rail, in light rail dollars that we are investing in rail, in light rail and dollars that we are investing in rail, in light rail and in dollars that we are investing in rail, in light rail and in buses dollars that we are investing in rail, in light rail and in buses and rail, in light rail and in buses and walking rail, in light rail and in buses and walking and rail, in light rail and in buses and walking and cycling rail, in light rail and in buses and walking and cycling infrastructure. walking and cycling infrastructure. The walking and cycling infrastructure. The billion walking and cycling infrastructure. The billion trees walking and cycling infrastructure. The billion trees programme, walking and cycling infrastructure. The billion trees programme, the walking and cycling infrastructure. The billion trees programme, the end The billion trees programme, the end of The billion trees programme, the end of offshore The billion trees programme, the end of offshore oil The billion trees programme, the end of offshore oil and The billion trees programme, the end of offshore oil and gas The billion trees programme, the end of offshore oil and gas exploration. of offshore oil and gas exploration. Electrifying of offshore oil and gas exploration. Electrifying the of offshore oil and gas exploration. Electrifying the public of offshore oil and gas exploration. Electrifying the public service of offshore oil and gas exploration. Electrifying the public service car Electrifying the public service car fleet. Electrifying the public service car fleet. Companies Electrifying the public service car fleet. Companies reporting Electrifying the public service car fleet. Companies reporting to Electrifying the public service car fleet. Companies reporting to their fleet. Companies reporting to their shareholders fleet. Companies reporting to their shareholders and fleet. Companies reporting to their shareholders and state fleet. Companies reporting to their shareholders and state services shareholders and state services organisations shareholders and state services organisations reporting shareholders and state services organisations reporting to shareholders and state services organisations reporting to their organisations reporting to their ministers organisations reporting to their ministers on organisations reporting to their ministers on their organisations reporting to their ministers on their climate-related ministers on their climate-related risks. ministers on their climate-related risks. I ministers on their climate-related risks. I know ministers on their climate-related risks. I know - ministers on their climate-related risks. I know - I ministers on their climate-related risks. I know - I know ministers on their climate-related risks. I know - I know that ministers on their climate-related risks. I know - I know that there risks. I know - I know that there will risks. I know - I know that there will be risks. I know - I know that there will be people risks. I know - I know that there will be people out risks. I know - I know that there will be people out there risks. I know - I know that there will be people out there who risks. I know - I know that there will be people out there who say risks. I know - I know that there will be people out there who say we will be people out there who say we have will be people out there who say we have not will be people out there who say we have not gone will be people out there who say we have not gone far will be people out there who say we have not gone far enough will be people out there who say we have not gone far enough but will be people out there who say we have not gone far enough but no will be people out there who say we have not gone far enough but no one have not gone far enough but no one should have not gone far enough but no one should ever have not gone far enough but no one should ever think have not gone far enough but no one should ever think <INTERRUPTION> should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No one should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No one should should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No one should ever should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No one should ever think should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No one should ever think that should ever think <INTERRUPTION> No one should ever think that the No one should ever think that the hard No one should ever think that the hard work No one should ever think that the hard work is No one should ever think that the hard work is not No one should ever think that the hard work is not worth No one should ever think that the hard work is not worth it No one should ever think that the hard work is not worth it because No one should ever think that the hard work is not worth it because we hard work is not worth it because we haven't hard work is not worth it because we haven't got hard work is not worth it because we haven't got everything hard work is not worth it because we haven't got everything we hard work is not worth it because we haven't got everything we want. hard work is not worth it because we haven't got everything we want. You haven't got everything we want. You try haven't got everything we want. You try telling haven't got everything we want. You try telling that haven't got everything we want. You try telling that to haven't got everything we want. You try telling that to Marama haven't got everything we want. You try telling that to Marama Davidson try telling that to Marama Davidson who try telling that to Marama Davidson who has try telling that to Marama Davidson who has worked try telling that to Marama Davidson who has worked so try telling that to Marama Davidson who has worked so hard try telling that to Marama Davidson who has worked so hard to try telling that to Marama Davidson who has worked so hard to ensure who has worked so hard to ensure that who has worked so hard to ensure that our who has worked so hard to ensure that our loved who has worked so hard to ensure that our loved ones, who has worked so hard to ensure that our loved ones, friends who has worked so hard to ensure that our loved ones, friends and that our loved ones, friends and whanau that our loved ones, friends and whanau have that our loved ones, friends and whanau have warm, that our loved ones, friends and whanau have warm, safe that our loved ones, friends and whanau have warm, safe and that our loved ones, friends and whanau have warm, safe and dry whanau have warm, safe and dry houses whanau have warm, safe and dry houses in whanau have warm, safe and dry houses in which whanau have warm, safe and dry houses in which to whanau have warm, safe and dry houses in which to live. whanau have warm, safe and dry houses in which to live. Or whanau have warm, safe and dry houses in which to live. Or tell houses in which to live. Or tell that houses in which to live. Or tell that to houses in which to live. Or tell that to Eugenie houses in which to live. Or tell that to Eugenie Sage houses in which to live. Or tell that to Eugenie Sage who houses in which to live. Or tell that to Eugenie Sage who has that to Eugenie Sage who has delivered that to Eugenie Sage who has delivered the that to Eugenie Sage who has delivered the largest that to Eugenie Sage who has delivered the largest boost that to Eugenie Sage who has delivered the largest boost to delivered the largest boost to conversation delivered the largest boost to conversation conservation delivered the largest boost to conversation conservation funding conversation conservation funding since conversation conservation funding since the conversation conservation funding since the Dept conversation conservation funding since the Dept of conversation conservation funding since the Dept of Conservation conversation conservation funding since the Dept of Conservation was since the Dept of Conservation was founded since the Dept of Conservation was founded in since the Dept of Conservation was founded in the since the Dept of Conservation was founded in the 1980s. since the Dept of Conservation was founded in the 1980s. Most since the Dept of Conservation was founded in the 1980s. Most people founded in the 1980s. Most people are founded in the 1980s. Most people are shopping founded in the 1980s. Most people are shopping with founded in the 1980s. Most people are shopping with their founded in the 1980s. Most people are shopping with their own founded in the 1980s. Most people are shopping with their own bags are shopping with their own bags rather are shopping with their own bags rather that are shopping with their own bags rather that end are shopping with their own bags rather that end suffocating are shopping with their own bags rather that end suffocating single rather that end suffocating single use rather that end suffocating single use plastic rather that end suffocating single use plastic that rather that end suffocating single use plastic that we rather that end suffocating single use plastic that we came rather that end suffocating single use plastic that we came to rather that end suffocating single use plastic that we came to rely rather that end suffocating single use plastic that we came to rely on. use plastic that we came to rely on. Or use plastic that we came to rely on. Or tell use plastic that we came to rely on. Or tell that use plastic that we came to rely on. Or tell that to use plastic that we came to rely on. Or tell that to Julie use plastic that we came to rely on. Or tell that to Julie Anne use plastic that we came to rely on. Or tell that to Julie Anne Genter Or tell that to Julie Anne Genter who Or tell that to Julie Anne Genter who has Or tell that to Julie Anne Genter who has led Or tell that to Julie Anne Genter who has led a Or tell that to Julie Anne Genter who has led a massive who has led a massive reprioritisation who has led a massive reprioritisation of who has led a massive reprioritisation of transport reprioritisation of transport spending reprioritisation of transport spending to reprioritisation of transport spending to give reprioritisation of transport spending to give people reprioritisation of transport spending to give people better spending to give people better cleaner spending to give people better cleaner and spending to give people better cleaner and safer spending to give people better cleaner and safer options spending to give people better cleaner and safer options for cleaner and safer options for getting cleaner and safer options for getting around. cleaner and safer options for getting around. Let cleaner and safer options for getting around. Let me cleaner and safer options for getting around. Let me say cleaner and safer options for getting around. Let me say this getting around. Let me say this about getting around. Let me say this about the getting around. Let me say this about the Advertising getting around. Let me say this about the Advertising Standards about the Advertising Standards Authority about the Advertising Standards Authority finding about the Advertising Standards Authority finding on about the Advertising Standards Authority finding on the about the Advertising Standards Authority finding on the National Authority finding on the National Party Authority finding on the National Party who Authority finding on the National Party who found Authority finding on the National Party who found yesterday Authority finding on the National Party who found yesterday that Authority finding on the National Party who found yesterday that the Party who found yesterday that the National Party who found yesterday that the National Party Party who found yesterday that the National Party thinks Party who found yesterday that the National Party thinks that Party who found yesterday that the National Party thinks that they National Party thinks that they cannot National Party thinks that they cannot hold National Party thinks that they cannot hold this National Party thinks that they cannot hold this Government National Party thinks that they cannot hold this Government to cannot hold this Government to account cannot hold this Government to account without cannot hold this Government to account without lying cannot hold this Government to account without lying about cannot hold this Government to account without lying about what cannot hold this Government to account without lying about what it account without lying about what it is account without lying about what it is that account without lying about what it is that we account without lying about what it is that we are account without lying about what it is that we are doing. account without lying about what it is that we are doing. Order! account without lying about what it is that we are doing. Order! I account without lying about what it is that we are doing. Order! I beg is that we are doing. Order! I beg your is that we are doing. Order! I beg your pardon, is that we are doing. Order! I beg your pardon, Mr is that we are doing. Order! I beg your pardon, Mr Speaker. is that we are doing. Order! I beg your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try is that we are doing. Order! I beg your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan Logie your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan Logie that your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan Logie that the your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan Logie that the work your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan Logie that the work to your pardon, Mr Speaker. Try telling Jan Logie that the work to reform Jan Logie that the work to reform the Jan Logie that the work to reform the way Jan Logie that the work to reform the way that Jan Logie that the work to reform the way that we Jan Logie that the work to reform the way that we manage Jan Logie that the work to reform the way that we manage and Jan Logie that the work to reform the way that we manage and reduce the way that we manage and reduce sexual the way that we manage and reduce sexual and the way that we manage and reduce sexual and domestic the way that we manage and reduce sexual and domestic violence the way that we manage and reduce sexual and domestic violence has the way that we manage and reduce sexual and domestic violence has not sexual and domestic violence has not been sexual and domestic violence has not been worth sexual and domestic violence has not been worth it sexual and domestic violence has not been worth it or sexual and domestic violence has not been worth it or try sexual and domestic violence has not been worth it or try telling sexual and domestic violence has not been worth it or try telling Gareth been worth it or try telling Gareth Hughes been worth it or try telling Gareth Hughes who been worth it or try telling Gareth Hughes who has been worth it or try telling Gareth Hughes who has changed been worth it or try telling Gareth Hughes who has changed the been worth it or try telling Gareth Hughes who has changed the future Hughes who has changed the future direction Hughes who has changed the future direction of Hughes who has changed the future direction of this Hughes who has changed the future direction of this country Hughes who has changed the future direction of this country by Hughes who has changed the future direction of this country by working direction of this country by working successfully direction of this country by working successfully to direction of this country by working successfully to end direction of this country by working successfully to end offshore direction of this country by working successfully to end offshore oil direction of this country by working successfully to end offshore oil and successfully to end offshore oil and gas successfully to end offshore oil and gas permits successfully to end offshore oil and gas permits that successfully to end offshore oil and gas permits that that successfully to end offshore oil and gas permits that that has successfully to end offshore oil and gas permits that that has not successfully to end offshore oil and gas permits that that has not been gas permits that that has not been worth gas permits that that has not been worth it gas permits that that has not been worth it or gas permits that that has not been worth it or Chloe gas permits that that has not been worth it or Chloe Swarbrick gas permits that that has not been worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who gas permits that that has not been worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done so worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done so much worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done so much to worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done so much to ensure worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done so much to ensure young worth it or Chloe Swarbrick who has done so much to ensure young people done so much to ensure young people have done so much to ensure young people have the done so much to ensure young people have the support done so much to ensure young people have the support they done so much to ensure young people have the support they need done so much to ensure young people have the support they need when done so much to ensure young people have the support they need when they have the support they need when they need have the support they need when they need it have the support they need when they need it to have the support they need when they need it to fill have the support they need when they need it to fill fulfilling have the support they need when they need it to fill fulfilling lives. have the support they need when they need it to fill fulfilling lives. It need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work that need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work that reminds need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work that reminds us need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work that reminds us that need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work that reminds us that we need it to fill fulfilling lives. It is work that reminds us that we are is work that reminds us that we are stronger is work that reminds us that we are stronger when is work that reminds us that we are stronger when we is work that reminds us that we are stronger when we have is work that reminds us that we are stronger when we have each is work that reminds us that we are stronger when we have each other's stronger when we have each other's backs, stronger when we have each other's backs, when stronger when we have each other's backs, when we stronger when we have each other's backs, when we are stronger when we have each other's backs, when we are looking stronger when we have each other's backs, when we are looking out stronger when we have each other's backs, when we are looking out for backs, when we are looking out for one backs, when we are looking out for one another. backs, when we are looking out for one another. When backs, when we are looking out for one another. When we backs, when we are looking out for one another. When we are backs, when we are looking out for one another. When we are giving one another. When we are giving support one another. When we are giving support that one another. When we are giving support that makes one another. When we are giving support that makes sense one another. When we are giving support that makes sense to one another. When we are giving support that makes sense to the support that makes sense to the people support that makes sense to the people who support that makes sense to the people who are support that makes sense to the people who are needing support that makes sense to the people who are needing it. support that makes sense to the people who are needing it. Tell support that makes sense to the people who are needing it. Tell that people who are needing it. Tell that to people who are needing it. Tell that to Golriz people who are needing it. Tell that to Golriz Ghabhraman people who are needing it. Tell that to Golriz Ghabhraman who people who are needing it. Tell that to Golriz Ghabhraman who has to Golriz Ghabhraman who has championed to Golriz Ghabhraman who has championed changes to Golriz Ghabhraman who has championed changes to to Golriz Ghabhraman who has championed changes to our to Golriz Ghabhraman who has championed changes to our democracy championed changes to our democracy that championed changes to our democracy that build championed changes to our democracy that build trust championed changes to our democracy that build trust and championed changes to our democracy that build trust and make championed changes to our democracy that build trust and make us championed changes to our democracy that build trust and make us more that build trust and make us more accountable that build trust and make us more accountable to that build trust and make us more accountable to the that build trust and make us more accountable to the people that build trust and make us more accountable to the people that that build trust and make us more accountable to the people that we that build trust and make us more accountable to the people that we - accountable to the people that we - who accountable to the people that we - who put accountable to the people that we - who put us accountable to the people that we - who put us here. accountable to the people that we - who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker, who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker, we who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker, we have who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker, we have done who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker, we have done all who put us here. <INTERRUPTION> Mr Speaker, we have done all of Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We have Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We have done Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We have done all Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We have done all of Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We have done all of this Mr Speaker, we have done all of this. We have done all of this and this. We have done all of this and so this. We have done all of this and so much this. We have done all of this and so much more this. We have done all of this and so much more with this. We have done all of this and so much more with just this. We have done all of this and so much more with just eight this. We have done all of this and so much more with just eight Members so much more with just eight Members of so much more with just eight Members of Parliament so much more with just eight Members of Parliament Imagine so much more with just eight Members of Parliament Imagine what so much more with just eight Members of Parliament Imagine what we so much more with just eight Members of Parliament Imagine what we could of Parliament Imagine what we could do of Parliament Imagine what we could do with of Parliament Imagine what we could do with just of Parliament Imagine what we could do with just a of Parliament Imagine what we could do with just a few of Parliament Imagine what we could do with just a few more. of Parliament Imagine what we could do with just a few more. There of Parliament Imagine what we could do with just a few more. There will do with just a few more. There will never do with just a few more. There will never be do with just a few more. There will never be a do with just a few more. There will never be a moment do with just a few more. There will never be a moment that do with just a few more. There will never be a moment that we do with just a few more. There will never be a moment that we can do with just a few more. There will never be a moment that we can say never be a moment that we can say that never be a moment that we can say that we never be a moment that we can say that we are never be a moment that we can say that we are done never be a moment that we can say that we are done or never be a moment that we can say that we are done or that never be a moment that we can say that we are done or that we never be a moment that we can say that we are done or that we have that we are done or that we have won. that we are done or that we have won. Lasting that we are done or that we have won. Lasting change that we are done or that we have won. Lasting change demands that we are done or that we have won. Lasting change demands that that we are done or that we have won. Lasting change demands that we won. Lasting change demands that we keep won. Lasting change demands that we keep working won. Lasting change demands that we keep working every won. Lasting change demands that we keep working every single won. Lasting change demands that we keep working every single day. keep working every single day. Further keep working every single day. Further and keep working every single day. Further and faster keep working every single day. Further and faster towards keep working every single day. Further and faster towards a keep working every single day. Further and faster towards a future Further and faster towards a future where Further and faster towards a future where all Further and faster towards a future where all New Further and faster towards a future where all New Zealanders Further and faster towards a future where all New Zealanders have where all New Zealanders have everything where all New Zealanders have everything that where all New Zealanders have everything that they where all New Zealanders have everything that they need where all New Zealanders have everything that they need to where all New Zealanders have everything that they need to live everything that they need to live fulfilling everything that they need to live fulfilling and everything that they need to live fulfilling and meaningful everything that they need to live fulfilling and meaningful and fulfilling and meaningful and prosperous fulfilling and meaningful and prosperous lives. fulfilling and meaningful and prosperous lives. Where fulfilling and meaningful and prosperous lives. Where everything prosperous lives. Where everything from prosperous lives. Where everything from our prosperous lives. Where everything from our morning prosperous lives. Where everything from our morning coffee prosperous lives. Where everything from our morning coffee to from our morning coffee to travelling from our morning coffee to travelling to from our morning coffee to travelling to and from our morning coffee to travelling to and from from our morning coffee to travelling to and from work, from our morning coffee to travelling to and from work, to travelling to and from work, to warming travelling to and from work, to warming our travelling to and from work, to warming our homes, travelling to and from work, to warming our homes, is travelling to and from work, to warming our homes, is powered travelling to and from work, to warming our homes, is powered by warming our homes, is powered by clean warming our homes, is powered by clean renewable warming our homes, is powered by clean renewable energy, warming our homes, is powered by clean renewable energy, where warming our homes, is powered by clean renewable energy, where our clean renewable energy, where our precious clean renewable energy, where our precious plans clean renewable energy, where our precious plans and clean renewable energy, where our precious plans and our clean renewable energy, where our precious plans and our animals clean renewable energy, where our precious plans and our animals are precious plans and our animals are protected precious plans and our animals are protected and precious plans and our animals are protected and our precious plans and our animals are protected and our wild precious plans and our animals are protected and our wild places precious plans and our animals are protected and our wild places are protected and our wild places are looked protected and our wild places are looked after protected and our wild places are looked after for protected and our wild places are looked after for future protected and our wild places are looked after for future generations. looked after for future generations. This looked after for future generations. This Government looked after for future generations. This Government of looked after for future generations. This Government of three looked after for future generations. This Government of three parties looked after for future generations. This Government of three parties has This Government of three parties has shown This Government of three parties has shown how This Government of three parties has shown how we This Government of three parties has shown how we can This Government of three parties has shown how we can work This Government of three parties has shown how we can work through This Government of three parties has shown how we can work through our shown how we can work through our differences shown how we can work through our differences and shown how we can work through our differences and find shown how we can work through our differences and find common shown how we can work through our differences and find common ground differences and find common ground that differences and find common ground that benefits differences and find common ground that benefits all differences and find common ground that benefits all New differences and find common ground that benefits all New Zealanders. that benefits all New Zealanders. Who that benefits all New Zealanders. Who will that benefits all New Zealanders. Who will be that benefits all New Zealanders. Who will be around that benefits all New Zealanders. Who will be around the that benefits all New Zealanders. Who will be around the table that benefits all New Zealanders. Who will be around the table for Who will be around the table for those Who will be around the table for those discussions Who will be around the table for those discussions after Who will be around the table for those discussions after the Who will be around the table for those discussions after the election those discussions after the election is those discussions after the election is a those discussions after the election is a matter those discussions after the election is a matter for those discussions after the election is a matter for New those discussions after the election is a matter for New Zealanders those discussions after the election is a matter for New Zealanders to is a matter for New Zealanders to decide is a matter for New Zealanders to decide but is a matter for New Zealanders to decide but for is a matter for New Zealanders to decide but for those is a matter for New Zealanders to decide but for those who is a matter for New Zealanders to decide but for those who say is a matter for New Zealanders to decide but for those who say they decide but for those who say they want decide but for those who say they want us decide but for those who say they want us to decide but for those who say they want us to do decide but for those who say they want us to do more, decide but for those who say they want us to do more, I decide but for those who say they want us to do more, I say decide but for those who say they want us to do more, I say get want us to do more, I say get involved. want us to do more, I say get involved. Get want us to do more, I say get involved. Get involved want us to do more, I say get involved. Get involved in want us to do more, I say get involved. Get involved in the want us to do more, I say get involved. Get involved in the issues involved. Get involved in the issues that involved. Get involved in the issues that are involved. Get involved in the issues that are affecting involved. Get involved in the issues that are affecting your involved. Get involved in the issues that are affecting your communities that are affecting your communities and that are affecting your communities and our that are affecting your communities and our nation. that are affecting your communities and our nation. Whether that are affecting your communities and our nation. Whether that's and our nation. Whether that's online and our nation. Whether that's online or and our nation. Whether that's online or at and our nation. Whether that's online or at a and our nation. Whether that's online or at a neighbourhood online or at a neighbourhood meeting, online or at a neighbourhood meeting, whether online or at a neighbourhood meeting, whether that online or at a neighbourhood meeting, whether that is meeting, whether that is conversations meeting, whether that is conversations with meeting, whether that is conversations with your meeting, whether that is conversations with your friends meeting, whether that is conversations with your friends and conversations with your friends and family. conversations with your friends and family. Talk conversations with your friends and family. Talk about conversations with your friends and family. Talk about your conversations with your friends and family. Talk about your ideas conversations with your friends and family. Talk about your ideas for family. Talk about your ideas for solving family. Talk about your ideas for solving the family. Talk about your ideas for solving the issues family. Talk about your ideas for solving the issues that family. Talk about your ideas for solving the issues that matter family. Talk about your ideas for solving the issues that matter to solving the issues that matter to you. solving the issues that matter to you. Demand solving the issues that matter to you. Demand more solving the issues that matter to you. Demand more of solving the issues that matter to you. Demand more of us. solving the issues that matter to you. Demand more of us. Knock solving the issues that matter to you. Demand more of us. Knock on you. Demand more of us. Knock on some you. Demand more of us. Knock on some doors. you. Demand more of us. Knock on some doors. You you. Demand more of us. Knock on some doors. You never you. Demand more of us. Knock on some doors. You never know, you. Demand more of us. Knock on some doors. You never know, that some doors. You never know, that small some doors. You never know, that small action some doors. You never know, that small action that some doors. You never know, that small action that you some doors. You never know, that small action that you take some doors. You never know, that small action that you take - some doors. You never know, that small action that you take - that small action that you take - that might small action that you take - that might change small action that you take - that might change the small action that you take - that might change the political might change the political environment might change the political environment in might change the political environment in which might change the political environment in which the might change the political environment in which the next environment in which the next Government environment in which the next Government has environment in which the next Government has no environment in which the next Government has no option environment in which the next Government has no option but environment in which the next Government has no option but to environment in which the next Government has no option but to move Government has no option but to move further Government has no option but to move further and Government has no option but to move further and faster Government has no option but to move further and faster towards Government has no option but to move further and faster towards that further and faster towards that future further and faster towards that future that further and faster towards that future that we further and faster towards that future that we need. further and faster towards that future that we need. With further and faster towards that future that we need. With two further and faster towards that future that we need. With two years future that we need. With two years at future that we need. With two years at the future that we need. With two years at the heart future that we need. With two years at the heart of future that we need. With two years at the heart of Government, future that we need. With two years at the heart of Government, the at the heart of Government, the Green at the heart of Government, the Green Party's at the heart of Government, the Green Party's first at the heart of Government, the Green Party's first ever at the heart of Government, the Green Party's first ever time at the heart of Government, the Green Party's first ever time in Green Party's first ever time in Government. Green Party's first ever time in Government. We Green Party's first ever time in Government. We have Green Party's first ever time in Government. We have done Green Party's first ever time in Government. We have done a Green Party's first ever time in Government. We have done a huge Government. We have done a huge amount Government. We have done a huge amount to Government. We have done a huge amount to create Government. We have done a huge amount to create a Government. We have done a huge amount to create a better Government. We have done a huge amount to create a better future Government. We have done a huge amount to create a better future for amount to create a better future for our amount to create a better future for our kids amount to create a better future for our kids and amount to create a better future for our kids and grandchildren. amount to create a better future for our kids and grandchildren. What amount to create a better future for our kids and grandchildren. What we our kids and grandchildren. What we do our kids and grandchildren. What we do next our kids and grandchildren. What we do next is our kids and grandchildren. What we do next is where our kids and grandchildren. What we do next is where you our kids and grandchildren. What we do next is where you will our kids and grandchildren. What we do next is where you will find our kids and grandchildren. What we do next is where you will find our do next is where you will find our better do next is where you will find our better future. do next is where you will find our better future. An do next is where you will find our better future. An Aotearoa do next is where you will find our better future. An Aotearoa defined better future. An Aotearoa defined by better future. An Aotearoa defined by its better future. An Aotearoa defined by its leadership better future. An Aotearoa defined by its leadership on better future. An Aotearoa defined by its leadership on climate better future. An Aotearoa defined by its leadership on climate change, by its leadership on climate change, by by its leadership on climate change, by fairs by its leadership on climate change, by fairs and by its leadership on climate change, by fairs and equality by its leadership on climate change, by fairs and equality and by its leadership on climate change, by fairs and equality and a by its leadership on climate change, by fairs and equality and a thriving by fairs and equality and a thriving -- by fairs and equality and a thriving -- fairs by fairs and equality and a thriving -- fairs and by fairs and equality and a thriving -- fairs and e-- by fairs and equality and a thriving -- fairs and e-- fairness by fairs and equality and a thriving -- fairs and e-- fairness and -- fairs and e-- fairness and equality -- fairs and e-- fairness and equality and -- fairs and e-- fairness and equality and a -- fairs and e-- fairness and equality and a thriving -- fairs and e-- fairness and equality and a thriving natural equality and a thriving natural economy. equality and a thriving natural economy. Making equality and a thriving natural economy. Making this equality and a thriving natural economy. Making this happen equality and a thriving natural economy. Making this happen is equality and a thriving natural economy. Making this happen is the economy. Making this happen is the only economy. Making this happen is the only way economy. Making this happen is the only way we economy. Making this happen is the only way we can economy. Making this happen is the only way we can keep economy. Making this happen is the only way we can keep our economy. Making this happen is the only way we can keep our promise economy. Making this happen is the only way we can keep our promise to only way we can keep our promise to future only way we can keep our promise to future generations, only way we can keep our promise to future generations, that only way we can keep our promise to future generations, that we only way we can keep our promise to future generations, that we will future generations, that we will leave future generations, that we will leave behind future generations, that we will leave behind a future generations, that we will leave behind a world future generations, that we will leave behind a world that future generations, that we will leave behind a world that is future generations, that we will leave behind a world that is better leave behind a world that is better off leave behind a world that is better off for leave behind a world that is better off for what leave behind a world that is better off for what we leave behind a world that is better off for what we did. off for what we did. INTERPRETER: off for what we did. INTERPRETER: And off for what we did. INTERPRETER: And so off for what we did. INTERPRETER: And so I off for what we did. INTERPRETER: And so I say off for what we did. INTERPRETER: And so I say greetings INTERPRETER: And so I say greetings to INTERPRETER: And so I say greetings to us INTERPRETER: And so I say greetings to us all. INTERPRETER: And so I say greetings to us all. <APPLAUSE> to us all. <APPLAUSE> David to us all. <APPLAUSE> David Seymour. to us all. <APPLAUSE> David Seymour. I to us all. <APPLAUSE> David Seymour. I rise to us all. <APPLAUSE> David Seymour. I rise on to us all. <APPLAUSE> David Seymour. I rise on behalf to us all. <APPLAUSE> David Seymour. I rise on behalf of David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the ACT David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the ACT Party David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the ACT Party in David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the ACT Party in opposition David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the ACT Party in opposition to David Seymour. I rise on behalf of the ACT Party in opposition to the the ACT Party in opposition to the PM's the ACT Party in opposition to the PM's motion the ACT Party in opposition to the PM's motion and the ACT Party in opposition to the PM's motion and with the ACT Party in opposition to the PM's motion and with some the ACT Party in opposition to the PM's motion and with some support PM's motion and with some support for PM's motion and with some support for the PM's motion and with some support for the National PM's motion and with some support for the National Leader's PM's motion and with some support for the National Leader's amendments for the National Leader's amendments that for the National Leader's amendments that you for the National Leader's amendments that you finally for the National Leader's amendments that you finally received for the National Leader's amendments that you finally received on for the National Leader's amendments that you finally received on the that you finally received on the table that you finally received on the table and that you finally received on the table and with that you finally received on the table and with a that you finally received on the table and with a few that you finally received on the table and with a few additional table and with a few additional comments. table and with a few additional comments. Mr table and with a few additional comments. Mr Speaker, table and with a few additional comments. Mr Speaker, this table and with a few additional comments. Mr Speaker, this year table and with a few additional comments. Mr Speaker, this year New comments. Mr Speaker, this year New Zealand comments. Mr Speaker, this year New Zealand faces comments. Mr Speaker, this year New Zealand faces a comments. Mr Speaker, this year New Zealand faces a choice comments. Mr Speaker, this year New Zealand faces a choice between comments. Mr Speaker, this year New Zealand faces a choice between the Zealand faces a choice between the politics Zealand faces a choice between the politics of Zealand faces a choice between the politics of gesture Zealand faces a choice between the politics of gesture and Zealand faces a choice between the politics of gesture and the Zealand faces a choice between the politics of gesture and the best politics of gesture and the best political politics of gesture and the best political marketer politics of gesture and the best political marketer in politics of gesture and the best political marketer in the politics of gesture and the best political marketer in the world politics of gesture and the best political marketer in the world who political marketer in the world who is political marketer in the world who is also political marketer in the world who is also the political marketer in the world who is also the world's political marketer in the world who is also the world's worst political marketer in the world who is also the world's worst policy is also the world's worst policy deliverer. is also the world's worst policy deliverer. A is also the world's worst policy deliverer. A choice is also the world's worst policy deliverer. A choice between is also the world's worst policy deliverer. A choice between a is also the world's worst policy deliverer. A choice between a speech deliverer. A choice between a speech which deliverer. A choice between a speech which delivered deliverer. A choice between a speech which delivered no deliverer. A choice between a speech which delivered no substance which delivered no substance whatsoever, which delivered no substance whatsoever, there which delivered no substance whatsoever, there were which delivered no substance whatsoever, there were lots which delivered no substance whatsoever, there were lots of whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, you whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, you have whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, you have to whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, you have to hand whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, you have to hand it whatsoever, there were lots of intentions, you have to hand it to intentions, you have to hand it to the intentions, you have to hand it to the PM intentions, you have to hand it to the PM for intentions, you have to hand it to the PM for outlining intentions, you have to hand it to the PM for outlining the intentions, you have to hand it to the PM for outlining the intentions. the PM for outlining the intentions. Everyone the PM for outlining the intentions. Everyone wants the PM for outlining the intentions. Everyone wants a the PM for outlining the intentions. Everyone wants a better the PM for outlining the intentions. Everyone wants a better world the PM for outlining the intentions. Everyone wants a better world but Everyone wants a better world but not Everyone wants a better world but not once Everyone wants a better world but not once did Everyone wants a better world but not once did she Everyone wants a better world but not once did she describe Everyone wants a better world but not once did she describe how Everyone wants a better world but not once did she describe how it not once did she describe how it would not once did she describe how it would be not once did she describe how it would be delivered. not once did she describe how it would be delivered. And not once did she describe how it would be delivered. And as not once did she describe how it would be delivered. And as for not once did she describe how it would be delivered. And as for the would be delivered. And as for the Deputy would be delivered. And as for the Deputy Prime would be delivered. And as for the Deputy Prime Minister, would be delivered. And as for the Deputy Prime Minister, for would be delivered. And as for the Deputy Prime Minister, for now, would be delivered. And as for the Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give a Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give a bit Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give a bit of Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give a bit of an Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give a bit of an education Deputy Prime Minister, for now, well let me give a bit of an education in let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of the let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of the basic let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of the basic shapes. let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of the basic shapes. This let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of the basic shapes. This is let me give a bit of an education in some let me give a bit of an education in some of the basic shapes. This is a let me give a bit of an education in some some of the basic shapes. This is a Pentagon. let me give a bit of an education in some This This is This is a This is a hex This is a hex go This is a hex go on. This is a hex go on. This This is a hex go on. This is This is a hex go on. This is an This is a hex go on. This is an octagon. This is a hex go on. This is an octagon. And This is a hex go on. This is an octagon. And this This is a hex go on. This is an octagon. And this is This is a hex go on. This is an octagon. And this is a This is a hex go on. This is an octagon. And this is a should There There are There are so There are so many There are so many reasons There are so many reasons why There are so many reasons why he There are so many reasons why he should There are so many reasons why he should be There are so many reasons why he should be done. There are so many reasons why he should be done. He There are so many reasons why he should be done. He says, There are so many reasons why he should be done. He says, "I'd There are so many reasons why he should be done. He says, "I'd sue should be done. He says, "I'd sue but should be done. He says, "I'd sue but you should be done. He says, "I'd sue but you don't should be done. He says, "I'd sue but you don't have should be done. He says, "I'd sue but you don't have any should be done. He says, "I'd sue but you don't have any money". but you don't have any money". Here's but you don't have any money". Here's the but you don't have any money". Here's the truth. but you don't have any money". Here's the truth. The but you don't have any money". Here's the truth. The truth but you don't have any money". Here's the truth. The truth is but you don't have any money". Here's the truth. The truth is that Here's the truth. The truth is that it's Here's the truth. The truth is that it's all Here's the truth. The truth is that it's all gone Here's the truth. The truth is that it's all gone wrong. Here's the truth. The truth is that it's all gone wrong. The Here's the truth. The truth is that it's all gone wrong. The facts Here's the truth. The truth is that it's all gone wrong. The facts are it's all gone wrong. The facts are out it's all gone wrong. The facts are out there. it's all gone wrong. The facts are out there. People it's all gone wrong. The facts are out there. People know it's all gone wrong. The facts are out there. People know what's it's all gone wrong. The facts are out there. People know what's been out there. People know what's been going out there. People know what's been going on. out there. People know what's been going on. And out there. People know what's been going on. And he out there. People know what's been going on. And he can out there. People know what's been going on. And he can bluff out there. People know what's been going on. And he can bluff and out there. People know what's been going on. And he can bluff and he going on. And he can bluff and he can going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster and going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster and he going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster and he can going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster and he can huff going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster and he can huff and going on. And he can bluff and he can bluster and he can huff and puff can bluster and he can huff and puff and can bluster and he can huff and puff and threaten can bluster and he can huff and puff and threaten to can bluster and he can huff and puff and threaten to blow can bluster and he can huff and puff and threaten to blow our can bluster and he can huff and puff and threaten to blow our House can bluster and he can huff and puff and threaten to blow our House down and threaten to blow our House down but and threaten to blow our House down but the and threaten to blow our House down but the truth and threaten to blow our House down but the truth is and threaten to blow our House down but the truth is going and threaten to blow our House down but the truth is going to and threaten to blow our House down but the truth is going to come and threaten to blow our House down but the truth is going to come out but the truth is going to come out and but the truth is going to come out and it but the truth is going to come out and it is but the truth is going to come out and it is going but the truth is going to come out and it is going to but the truth is going to come out and it is going to finish but the truth is going to come out and it is going to finish a but the truth is going to come out and it is going to finish a career. and it is going to finish a career. The and it is going to finish a career. The tragedy and it is going to finish a career. The tragedy of and it is going to finish a career. The tragedy of that and it is going to finish a career. The tragedy of that career and it is going to finish a career. The tragedy of that career being The tragedy of that career being finished The tragedy of that career being finished is The tragedy of that career being finished is this The tragedy of that career being finished is this - The tragedy of that career being finished is this - people The tragedy of that career being finished is this - people are The tragedy of that career being finished is this - people are going finished is this - people are going to finished is this - people are going to sit finished is this - people are going to sit down finished is this - people are going to sit down and finished is this - people are going to sit down and try finished is this - people are going to sit down and try and finished is this - people are going to sit down and try and write finished is this - people are going to sit down and try and write what to sit down and try and write what the to sit down and try and write what the legacy to sit down and try and write what the legacy of to sit down and try and write what the legacy of Winston to sit down and try and write what the legacy of Winston Peters to sit down and try and write what the legacy of Winston Peters - the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll try the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll try to the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll try to compare the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll try to compare to the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll try to compare to the the legacy of Winston Peters - they'll try to compare to the legacy they'll try to compare to the legacy of they'll try to compare to the legacy of perhaps they'll try to compare to the legacy of perhaps a they'll try to compare to the legacy of perhaps a Mike they'll try to compare to the legacy of perhaps a Mike Moore they'll try to compare to the legacy of perhaps a Mike Moore who they'll try to compare to the legacy of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed this of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed this country of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed this country nor of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed this country nor the of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed this country nor the better of perhaps a Mike Moore who changed this country nor the better forever. this country nor the better forever. As this country nor the better forever. As they this country nor the better forever. As they sit this country nor the better forever. As they sit and this country nor the better forever. As they sit and they this country nor the better forever. As they sit and they try this country nor the better forever. As they sit and they try to this country nor the better forever. As they sit and they try to describe As they sit and they try to describe what As they sit and they try to describe what Winston As they sit and they try to describe what Winston Peters As they sit and they try to describe what Winston Peters has As they sit and they try to describe what Winston Peters has achieved As they sit and they try to describe what Winston Peters has achieved in what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 years, what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 years, they what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 years, they will what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 years, they will find what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 years, they will find they what Winston Peters has achieved in 40 years, they will find they have 40 years, they will find they have nothing 40 years, they will find they have nothing to 40 years, they will find they have nothing to write. 40 years, they will find they have nothing to write. What 40 years, they will find they have nothing to write. What a 40 years, they will find they have nothing to write. What a shame. 40 years, they will find they have nothing to write. What a shame. What nothing to write. What a shame. What a nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. But nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. But sadly, nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. But sadly, it nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. But sadly, it is nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. But sadly, it is still nothing to write. What a shame. What a shame. But sadly, it is still true a shame. But sadly, it is still true that a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he is a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he is taking a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he is taking the a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he is taking the shape a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he is taking the shape of a shame. But sadly, it is still true that he is taking the shape of a that he is taking the shape of a should-be-gone. that he is taking the shape of a should-be-gone. This that he is taking the shape of a should-be-gone. This Government that he is taking the shape of a should-be-gone. This Government is should-be-gone. This Government is so should-be-gone. This Government is so filled should-be-gone. This Government is so filled with should-be-gone. This Government is so filled with good should-be-gone. This Government is so filled with good intentions should-be-gone. This Government is so filled with good intentions and so filled with good intentions and yet so filled with good intentions and yet none so filled with good intentions and yet none of so filled with good intentions and yet none of them so filled with good intentions and yet none of them work. so filled with good intentions and yet none of them work. Most so filled with good intentions and yet none of them work. Most of so filled with good intentions and yet none of them work. Most of them, yet none of them work. Most of them, it yet none of them work. Most of them, it turns yet none of them work. Most of them, it turns out, yet none of them work. Most of them, it turns out, actually yet none of them work. Most of them, it turns out, actually are yet none of them work. Most of them, it turns out, actually are a it turns out, actually are a failure. it turns out, actually are a failure. The it turns out, actually are a failure. The PM, it turns out, actually are a failure. The PM, as it turns out, actually are a failure. The PM, as has it turns out, actually are a failure. The PM, as has been it turns out, actually are a failure. The PM, as has been noted, failure. The PM, as has been noted, didn't failure. The PM, as has been noted, didn't talk failure. The PM, as has been noted, didn't talk about failure. The PM, as has been noted, didn't talk about KiwiBuild. didn't talk about KiwiBuild. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> I <INTERRUPTION> I think <INTERRUPTION> I think she <INTERRUPTION> I think she talked <INTERRUPTION> I think she talked about <INTERRUPTION> I think she talked about the <INTERRUPTION> I think she talked about the child I think she talked about the child poverty I think she talked about the child poverty reduction I think she talked about the child poverty reduction Act. I think she talked about the child poverty reduction Act. What I think she talked about the child poverty reduction Act. What has I think she talked about the child poverty reduction Act. What has it poverty reduction Act. What has it done? poverty reduction Act. What has it done? It poverty reduction Act. What has it done? It has poverty reduction Act. What has it done? It has seen poverty reduction Act. What has it done? It has seen child poverty reduction Act. What has it done? It has seen child poverty poverty reduction Act. What has it done? It has seen child poverty go done? It has seen child poverty go up done? It has seen child poverty go up as done? It has seen child poverty go up as if done? It has seen child poverty go up as if passing done? It has seen child poverty go up as if passing a done? It has seen child poverty go up as if passing a law done? It has seen child poverty go up as if passing a law to done? It has seen child poverty go up as if passing a law to measure up as if passing a law to measure child up as if passing a law to measure child poverty up as if passing a law to measure child poverty was up as if passing a law to measure child poverty was actually up as if passing a law to measure child poverty was actually going up as if passing a law to measure child poverty was actually going to child poverty was actually going to reduce child poverty was actually going to reduce it! child poverty was actually going to reduce it! We child poverty was actually going to reduce it! We have child poverty was actually going to reduce it! We have seen child poverty was actually going to reduce it! We have seen intrusive reduce it! We have seen intrusive market reduce it! We have seen intrusive market studies reduce it! We have seen intrusive market studies into reduce it! We have seen intrusive market studies into whole reduce it! We have seen intrusive market studies into whole sectors market studies into whole sectors such market studies into whole sectors such as market studies into whole sectors such as petrol market studies into whole sectors such as petrol retailing market studies into whole sectors such as petrol retailing and market studies into whole sectors such as petrol retailing and get such as petrol retailing and get this, such as petrol retailing and get this, the such as petrol retailing and get this, the Minister such as petrol retailing and get this, the Minister of such as petrol retailing and get this, the Minister of Commerce such as petrol retailing and get this, the Minister of Commerce says this, the Minister of Commerce says that this, the Minister of Commerce says that they this, the Minister of Commerce says that they are this, the Minister of Commerce says that they are going this, the Minister of Commerce says that they are going to this, the Minister of Commerce says that they are going to bring this, the Minister of Commerce says that they are going to bring down that they are going to bring down the that they are going to bring down the price that they are going to bring down the price of that they are going to bring down the price of petrol, that they are going to bring down the price of petrol, 32 that they are going to bring down the price of petrol, 32 cents, that they are going to bring down the price of petrol, 32 cents, by the price of petrol, 32 cents, by attacking the price of petrol, 32 cents, by attacking the the price of petrol, 32 cents, by attacking the cut the price of petrol, 32 cents, by attacking the cut that the price of petrol, 32 cents, by attacking the cut that petrol attacking the cut that petrol companies attacking the cut that petrol companies take. attacking the cut that petrol companies take. The attacking the cut that petrol companies take. The petrol attacking the cut that petrol companies take. The petrol companies companies take. The petrol companies only companies take. The petrol companies only take companies take. The petrol companies only take 25 companies take. The petrol companies only take 25 cents companies take. The petrol companies only take 25 cents a companies take. The petrol companies only take 25 cents a litre. companies take. The petrol companies only take 25 cents a litre. So companies take. The petrol companies only take 25 cents a litre. So can only take 25 cents a litre. So can the only take 25 cents a litre. So can the Minister only take 25 cents a litre. So can the Minister of only take 25 cents a litre. So can the Minister of Commerce, only take 25 cents a litre. So can the Minister of Commerce, I've only take 25 cents a litre. So can the Minister of Commerce, I've gone the Minister of Commerce, I've gone geometry the Minister of Commerce, I've gone geometry for the Minister of Commerce, I've gone geometry for the the Minister of Commerce, I've gone geometry for the Deputy the Minister of Commerce, I've gone geometry for the Deputy Prime geometry for the Deputy Prime Minister. geometry for the Deputy Prime Minister. Maybe geometry for the Deputy Prime Minister. Maybe the geometry for the Deputy Prime Minister. Maybe the minister geometry for the Deputy Prime Minister. Maybe the minister of Minister. Maybe the minister of needs Minister. Maybe the minister of needs to Minister. Maybe the minister of needs to learn Minister. Maybe the minister of needs to learn basic Minister. Maybe the minister of needs to learn basic arithmetic needs to learn basic arithmetic because needs to learn basic arithmetic because you needs to learn basic arithmetic because you can't needs to learn basic arithmetic because you can't cut needs to learn basic arithmetic because you can't cut the needs to learn basic arithmetic because you can't cut the price needs to learn basic arithmetic because you can't cut the price of because you can't cut the price of petrol because you can't cut the price of petrol 32 because you can't cut the price of petrol 32 cents because you can't cut the price of petrol 32 cents by because you can't cut the price of petrol 32 cents by reducing because you can't cut the price of petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol company's petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol company's cut petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol company's cut when petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol company's cut when the petrol 32 cents by reducing the petrol company's cut when the petrol petrol company's cut when the petrol company petrol company's cut when the petrol company only petrol company's cut when the petrol company only takes petrol company's cut when the petrol company only takes 25 petrol company's cut when the petrol company only takes 25 cents. petrol company's cut when the petrol company only takes 25 cents. That's company only takes 25 cents. That's the company only takes 25 cents. That's the problem company only takes 25 cents. That's the problem in company only takes 25 cents. That's the problem in a company only takes 25 cents. That's the problem in a nutshell company only takes 25 cents. That's the problem in a nutshell with company only takes 25 cents. That's the problem in a nutshell with this the problem in a nutshell with this Government. the problem in a nutshell with this Government. Then the problem in a nutshell with this Government. Then they the problem in a nutshell with this Government. Then they want the problem in a nutshell with this Government. Then they want plastic Government. Then they want plastic bags Government. Then they want plastic bags to Government. Then they want plastic bags to reduce Government. Then they want plastic bags to reduce the Government. Then they want plastic bags to reduce the amount Government. Then they want plastic bags to reduce the amount of Government. Then they want plastic bags to reduce the amount of plastic bags to reduce the amount of plastic in bags to reduce the amount of plastic in the bags to reduce the amount of plastic in the ocean. bags to reduce the amount of plastic in the ocean. Well bags to reduce the amount of plastic in the ocean. Well there's bags to reduce the amount of plastic in the ocean. Well there's two in the ocean. Well there's two problems in the ocean. Well there's two problems with in the ocean. Well there's two problems with that. in the ocean. Well there's two problems with that. I in the ocean. Well there's two problems with that. I actually in the ocean. Well there's two problems with that. I actually asked problems with that. I actually asked the problems with that. I actually asked the Government problems with that. I actually asked the Government how problems with that. I actually asked the Government how much problems with that. I actually asked the Government how much of problems with that. I actually asked the Government how much of the the Government how much of the plastic the Government how much of the plastic from the Government how much of the plastic from the the Government how much of the plastic from the ocean the Government how much of the plastic from the ocean comes the Government how much of the plastic from the ocean comes from plastic from the ocean comes from plastic plastic from the ocean comes from plastic bags plastic from the ocean comes from plastic bags in plastic from the ocean comes from plastic bags in New plastic from the ocean comes from plastic bags in New Zealand? plastic from the ocean comes from plastic bags in New Zealand? Do plastic from the ocean comes from plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how much plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how much it plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how much it was? plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how much it was? No, plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how much it was? No, neither plastic bags in New Zealand? Do you know how much it was? No, neither do know how much it was? No, neither do they? know how much it was? No, neither do they? The know how much it was? No, neither do they? The Government know how much it was? No, neither do they? The Government can't know how much it was? No, neither do they? The Government can't tell know how much it was? No, neither do they? The Government can't tell you they? The Government can't tell you how they? The Government can't tell you how big they? The Government can't tell you how big the they? The Government can't tell you how big the problem they? The Government can't tell you how big the problem is they? The Government can't tell you how big the problem is they they? The Government can't tell you how big the problem is they were how big the problem is they were trying how big the problem is they were trying to how big the problem is they were trying to solve. how big the problem is they were trying to solve. And how big the problem is they were trying to solve. And so how big the problem is they were trying to solve. And so they how big the problem is they were trying to solve. And so they have trying to solve. And so they have got trying to solve. And so they have got us trying to solve. And so they have got us all trying to solve. And so they have got us all walking trying to solve. And so they have got us all walking out trying to solve. And so they have got us all walking out of trying to solve. And so they have got us all walking out of the trying to solve. And so they have got us all walking out of the Saul got us all walking out of the Saul market got us all walking out of the Saul market like got us all walking out of the Saul market like this got us all walking out of the Saul market like this or got us all walking out of the Saul market like this or buying got us all walking out of the Saul market like this or buying even market like this or buying even thicker market like this or buying even thicker bags market like this or buying even thicker bags with market like this or buying even thicker bags with more market like this or buying even thicker bags with more plastic market like this or buying even thicker bags with more plastic to thicker bags with more plastic to solve thicker bags with more plastic to solve a thicker bags with more plastic to solve a problem thicker bags with more plastic to solve a problem they thicker bags with more plastic to solve a problem they don't thicker bags with more plastic to solve a problem they don't even thicker bags with more plastic to solve a problem they don't even know solve a problem they don't even know exists. solve a problem they don't even know exists. I solve a problem they don't even know exists. I could solve a problem they don't even know exists. I could go solve a problem they don't even know exists. I could go on solve a problem they don't even know exists. I could go on and solve a problem they don't even know exists. I could go on and on solve a problem they don't even know exists. I could go on and on talking exists. I could go on and on talking about exists. I could go on and on talking about ineffectual exists. I could go on and on talking about ineffectual policies exists. I could go on and on talking about ineffectual policies that exists. I could go on and on talking about ineffectual policies that this about ineffectual policies that this Government about ineffectual policies that this Government has about ineffectual policies that this Government has put about ineffectual policies that this Government has put in about ineffectual policies that this Government has put in place. about ineffectual policies that this Government has put in place. Here's Government has put in place. Here's one Government has put in place. Here's one - Government has put in place. Here's one - we Government has put in place. Here's one - we have Government has put in place. Here's one - we have a Government has put in place. Here's one - we have a real Government has put in place. Here's one - we have a real problem Government has put in place. Here's one - we have a real problem in Government has put in place. Here's one - we have a real problem in this one - we have a real problem in this country one - we have a real problem in this country with one - we have a real problem in this country with our one - we have a real problem in this country with our firearm one - we have a real problem in this country with our firearm laws. one - we have a real problem in this country with our firearm laws. We country with our firearm laws. We know country with our firearm laws. We know this country with our firearm laws. We know this because country with our firearm laws. We know this because in country with our firearm laws. We know this because in an country with our firearm laws. We know this because in an Australian know this because in an Australian weirdo, know this because in an Australian weirdo, and know this because in an Australian weirdo, and frankly know this because in an Australian weirdo, and frankly as know this because in an Australian weirdo, and frankly as it know this because in an Australian weirdo, and frankly as it turns know this because in an Australian weirdo, and frankly as it turns out weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of the weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of the most weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of the most evil weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of the most evil people weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of the most evil people to weirdo, and frankly as it turns out one of the most evil people to set one of the most evil people to set foot one of the most evil people to set foot on one of the most evil people to set foot on our one of the most evil people to set foot on our shores, one of the most evil people to set foot on our shores, is one of the most evil people to set foot on our shores, is able one of the most evil people to set foot on our shores, is able to one of the most evil people to set foot on our shores, is able to get foot on our shores, is able to get off foot on our shores, is able to get off the foot on our shores, is able to get off the plane foot on our shores, is able to get off the plane and foot on our shores, is able to get off the plane and he foot on our shores, is able to get off the plane and he is foot on our shores, is able to get off the plane and he is somebody foot on our shores, is able to get off the plane and he is somebody - off the plane and he is somebody - he off the plane and he is somebody - he is off the plane and he is somebody - he is a off the plane and he is somebody - he is a single off the plane and he is somebody - he is a single male, off the plane and he is somebody - he is a single male, he off the plane and he is somebody - he is a single male, he lives off the plane and he is somebody - he is a single male, he lives alone, he is a single male, he lives alone, he he is a single male, he lives alone, he just he is a single male, he lives alone, he just got he is a single male, he lives alone, he just got here, he is a single male, he lives alone, he just got here, he he is a single male, he lives alone, he just got here, he gets he is a single male, he lives alone, he just got here, he gets a he is a single male, he lives alone, he just got here, he gets a licence, he just got here, he gets a licence, gets he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an AR15, he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an AR15, the he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an AR15, the police he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an AR15, the police sign he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an AR15, the police sign off he just got here, he gets a licence, gets an AR15, the police sign off on gets an AR15, the police sign off on 3,000 gets an AR15, the police sign off on 3,000 rounds gets an AR15, the police sign off on 3,000 rounds of gets an AR15, the police sign off on 3,000 rounds of ammunition, gets an AR15, the police sign off on 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and gets an AR15, the police sign off on 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no alarm 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no alarm bells 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no alarm bells were 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no alarm bells were rung, 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no alarm bells were rung, no 3,000 rounds of ammunition, and no alarm bells were rung, no one alarm bells were rung, no one thought, alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, this alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, this is alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, this is a alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, this is a bit alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, this is a bit of alarm bells were rung, no one thought, "Gee, this is a bit of a thought, "Gee, this is a bit of a problem." thought, "Gee, this is a bit of a problem." What's thought, "Gee, this is a bit of a problem." What's the thought, "Gee, this is a bit of a problem." What's the Government problem." What's the Government done? problem." What's the Government done? They problem." What's the Government done? They haven't problem." What's the Government done? They haven't solved problem." What's the Government done? They haven't solved any problem." What's the Government done? They haven't solved any of done? They haven't solved any of those done? They haven't solved any of those problems. done? They haven't solved any of those problems. What done? They haven't solved any of those problems. What they done? They haven't solved any of those problems. What they have done? They haven't solved any of those problems. What they have done those problems. What they have done is those problems. What they have done is they've those problems. What they have done is they've gone those problems. What they have done is they've gone and those problems. What they have done is they've gone and isolated those problems. What they have done is they've gone and isolated and is they've gone and isolated and undignified is they've gone and isolated and undignified and is they've gone and isolated and undignified and collectively undignified and collectively punished undignified and collectively punished 250,000 undignified and collectively punished 250,000 New undignified and collectively punished 250,000 New Zealanders undignified and collectively punished 250,000 New Zealanders who punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing wrong. punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing wrong. How punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing wrong. How is punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing wrong. How is that punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing wrong. How is that for punished 250,000 New Zealanders who did nothing wrong. How is that for a did nothing wrong. How is that for a Government did nothing wrong. How is that for a Government of did nothing wrong. How is that for a Government of inclusion did nothing wrong. How is that for a Government of inclusion and Government of inclusion and kindness? Government of inclusion and kindness? It Government of inclusion and kindness? It is Government of inclusion and kindness? It is another Government of inclusion and kindness? It is another damaging kindness? It is another damaging policy kindness? It is another damaging policy that kindness? It is another damaging policy that is kindness? It is another damaging policy that is ineffectual. kindness? It is another damaging policy that is ineffectual. Then kindness? It is another damaging policy that is ineffectual. Then the policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the temerity policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the temerity to policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the temerity to say policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the temerity to say - policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the temerity to say - I policy that is ineffectual. Then the PM had the temerity to say - I guess PM had the temerity to say - I guess if PM had the temerity to say - I guess if you PM had the temerity to say - I guess if you are PM had the temerity to say - I guess if you are 100% PM had the temerity to say - I guess if you are 100% marketing PM had the temerity to say - I guess if you are 100% marketing led PM had the temerity to say - I guess if you are 100% marketing led you if you are 100% marketing led you can if you are 100% marketing led you can say if you are 100% marketing led you can say these if you are 100% marketing led you can say these things if you are 100% marketing led you can say these things regard if you are 100% marketing led you can say these things regard less if you are 100% marketing led you can say these things regard less of can say these things regard less of their can say these things regard less of their veracity, can say these things regard less of their veracity, that can say these things regard less of their veracity, that this can say these things regard less of their veracity, that this is can say these things regard less of their veracity, that this is the their veracity, that this is the Government their veracity, that this is the Government of their veracity, that this is the Government of infrastructure. their veracity, that this is the Government of infrastructure. I Government of infrastructure. I mean, Government of infrastructure. I mean, how Government of infrastructure. I mean, how does Government of infrastructure. I mean, how does a Government of infrastructure. I mean, how does a Government Government of infrastructure. I mean, how does a Government of mean, how does a Government of infrastructure mean, how does a Government of infrastructure spend mean, how does a Government of infrastructure spend two mean, how does a Government of infrastructure spend two years infrastructure spend two years trying infrastructure spend two years trying to infrastructure spend two years trying to work infrastructure spend two years trying to work out infrastructure spend two years trying to work out which infrastructure spend two years trying to work out which projects trying to work out which projects are trying to work out which projects are idea trying to work out which projects are idea logically trying to work out which projects are idea logically opposed trying to work out which projects are idea logically opposed to trying to work out which projects are idea logically opposed to and are idea logically opposed to and then are idea logically opposed to and then try are idea logically opposed to and then try to are idea logically opposed to and then try to take are idea logically opposed to and then try to take the are idea logically opposed to and then try to take the credit are idea logically opposed to and then try to take the credit for then try to take the credit for building then try to take the credit for building infrastructure then try to take the credit for building infrastructure that then try to take the credit for building infrastructure that could building infrastructure that could have building infrastructure that could have been building infrastructure that could have been started building infrastructure that could have been started two building infrastructure that could have been started two years building infrastructure that could have been started two years ago. building infrastructure that could have been started two years ago. If have been started two years ago. If that have been started two years ago. If that is have been started two years ago. If that is a have been started two years ago. If that is a Government have been started two years ago. If that is a Government of that is a Government of infrastructure, that is a Government of infrastructure, then that is a Government of infrastructure, then I'd that is a Government of infrastructure, then I'd hate that is a Government of infrastructure, then I'd hate to that is a Government of infrastructure, then I'd hate to see infrastructure, then I'd hate to see one infrastructure, then I'd hate to see one that infrastructure, then I'd hate to see one that actually infrastructure, then I'd hate to see one that actually does infrastructure, then I'd hate to see one that actually does things infrastructure, then I'd hate to see one that actually does things on one that actually does things on time. one that actually does things on time. Not one that actually does things on time. Not only one that actually does things on time. Not only are one that actually does things on time. Not only are their one that actually does things on time. Not only are their policies time. Not only are their policies ineffective time. Not only are their policies ineffective at time. Not only are their policies ineffective at making time. Not only are their policies ineffective at making New time. Not only are their policies ineffective at making New Zealand time. Not only are their policies ineffective at making New Zealand a ineffective at making New Zealand a better ineffective at making New Zealand a better place, ineffective at making New Zealand a better place, they ineffective at making New Zealand a better place, they are ineffective at making New Zealand a better place, they are actually better place, they are actually damaging. better place, they are actually damaging. You better place, they are actually damaging. You see, better place, they are actually damaging. You see, Mr better place, they are actually damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, better place, they are actually damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, this damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, this Government damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, this Government sees damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, this Government sees every damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, this Government sees every aspect damaging. You see, Mr Speaker, this Government sees every aspect of Government sees every aspect of public Government sees every aspect of public policy Government sees every aspect of public policy through Government sees every aspect of public policy through the Government sees every aspect of public policy through the lens Government sees every aspect of public policy through the lens of public policy through the lens of class public policy through the lens of class warfare. public policy through the lens of class warfare. Employers public policy through the lens of class warfare. Employers - public policy through the lens of class warfare. Employers - employers class warfare. Employers - employers are class warfare. Employers - employers are people class warfare. Employers - employers are people who class warfare. Employers - employers are people who save class warfare. Employers - employers are people who save up, class warfare. Employers - employers are people who save up, invest are people who save up, invest capital, are people who save up, invest capital, have are people who save up, invest capital, have ideas, are people who save up, invest capital, have ideas, attract capital, have ideas, attract customers, capital, have ideas, attract customers, so capital, have ideas, attract customers, so they capital, have ideas, attract customers, so they can capital, have ideas, attract customers, so they can give capital, have ideas, attract customers, so they can give someone customers, so they can give someone a customers, so they can give someone a job. customers, so they can give someone a job. I customers, so they can give someone a job. I think customers, so they can give someone a job. I think that's customers, so they can give someone a job. I think that's pretty customers, so they can give someone a job. I think that's pretty cool. customers, so they can give someone a job. I think that's pretty cool. I a job. I think that's pretty cool. I think a job. I think that's pretty cool. I think that's a job. I think that's pretty cool. I think that's admirable. a job. I think that's pretty cool. I think that's admirable. Not a job. I think that's pretty cool. I think that's admirable. Not this think that's admirable. Not this Government. think that's admirable. Not this Government. At think that's admirable. Not this Government. At every think that's admirable. Not this Government. At every step think that's admirable. Not this Government. At every step of think that's admirable. Not this Government. At every step of the think that's admirable. Not this Government. At every step of the way Government. At every step of the way minimum Government. At every step of the way minimum wage Government. At every step of the way minimum wage increases, Government. At every step of the way minimum wage increases, national minimum wage increases, national awards minimum wage increases, national awards under minimum wage increases, national awards under the minimum wage increases, national awards under the new minimum wage increases, national awards under the new name minimum wage increases, national awards under the new name of minimum wage increases, national awards under the new name of fair awards under the new name of fair pay awards under the new name of fair pay agreements, awards under the new name of fair pay agreements, new awards under the new name of fair pay agreements, new regulations awards under the new name of fair pay agreements, new regulations on pay agreements, new regulations on every pay agreements, new regulations on every aspect pay agreements, new regulations on every aspect of pay agreements, new regulations on every aspect of employment, pay agreements, new regulations on every aspect of employment, they every aspect of employment, they actually every aspect of employment, they actually make every aspect of employment, they actually make it every aspect of employment, they actually make it harder every aspect of employment, they actually make it harder for every aspect of employment, they actually make it harder for people actually make it harder for people to actually make it harder for people to employ. actually make it harder for people to employ. They actually make it harder for people to employ. They actually actually make it harder for people to employ. They actually make actually make it harder for people to employ. They actually make it to employ. They actually make it harder to employ. They actually make it harder for to employ. They actually make it harder for people to employ. They actually make it harder for people to to employ. They actually make it harder for people to get to employ. They actually make it harder for people to get jobs. harder for people to get jobs. That's harder for people to get jobs. That's why harder for people to get jobs. That's why you've harder for people to get jobs. That's why you've got harder for people to get jobs. That's why you've got record harder for people to get jobs. That's why you've got record terms That's why you've got record terms of That's why you've got record terms of trade That's why you've got record terms of trade and That's why you've got record terms of trade and the That's why you've got record terms of trade and the welfare That's why you've got record terms of trade and the welfare role That's why you've got record terms of trade and the welfare role is of trade and the welfare role is going of trade and the welfare role is going up. of trade and the welfare role is going up. Only of trade and the welfare role is going up. Only thisset of trade and the welfare role is going up. Only thisset Government going up. Only thisset Government could going up. Only thisset Government could manage going up. Only thisset Government could manage those going up. Only thisset Government could manage those two going up. Only thisset Government could manage those two things could manage those two things simultaneously. could manage those two things simultaneously. Mr could manage those two things simultaneously. Mr Speaker, could manage those two things simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take landlords simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take landlords - simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take landlords - landlords simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take landlords - landlords are simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take landlords - landlords are people simultaneously. Mr Speaker, take landlords - landlords are people who landlords - landlords are people who save landlords - landlords are people who save up, landlords - landlords are people who save up, invest, landlords - landlords are people who save up, invest, manage landlords - landlords are people who save up, invest, manage property landlords - landlords are people who save up, invest, manage property and save up, invest, manage property and for save up, invest, manage property and for a save up, invest, manage property and for a weekly save up, invest, manage property and for a weekly fee, save up, invest, manage property and for a weekly fee, which save up, invest, manage property and for a weekly fee, which is save up, invest, manage property and for a weekly fee, which is often for a weekly fee, which is often less for a weekly fee, which is often less than for a weekly fee, which is often less than the for a weekly fee, which is often less than the mortgage for a weekly fee, which is often less than the mortgage on for a weekly fee, which is often less than the mortgage on the less than the mortgage on the property, less than the mortgage on the property, provide less than the mortgage on the property, provide accommodation. less than the mortgage on the property, provide accommodation. I property, provide accommodation. I think property, provide accommodation. I think it property, provide accommodation. I think it is property, provide accommodation. I think it is a property, provide accommodation. I think it is a wonderful property, provide accommodation. I think it is a wonderful service. property, provide accommodation. I think it is a wonderful service. I think it is a wonderful service. I think think it is a wonderful service. I think they think it is a wonderful service. I think they are think it is a wonderful service. I think they are great think it is a wonderful service. I think they are great people. think it is a wonderful service. I think they are great people. Not think they are great people. Not this think they are great people. Not this Government. think they are great people. Not this Government. Constantly think they are great people. Not this Government. Constantly such this Government. Constantly such people this Government. Constantly such people find this Government. Constantly such people find themselves this Government. Constantly such people find themselves under this Government. Constantly such people find themselves under attack people find themselves under attack with people find themselves under attack with more people find themselves under attack with more and people find themselves under attack with more and more people find themselves under attack with more and more rules people find themselves under attack with more and more rules and with more and more rules and regulations with more and more rules and regulations that with more and more rules and regulations that make with more and more rules and regulations that make it with more and more rules and regulations that make it harder with more and more rules and regulations that make it harder to regulations that make it harder to do regulations that make it harder to do their regulations that make it harder to do their job. regulations that make it harder to do their job. The regulations that make it harder to do their job. The irony regulations that make it harder to do their job. The irony of regulations that make it harder to do their job. The irony of ironies, do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker is do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker is that do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker is that not do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker is that not only do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker is that not only is do their job. The irony of ironies, Mr Speaker is that not only is it Mr Speaker is that not only is it bad Mr Speaker is that not only is it bad poor Mr Speaker is that not only is it bad poor the Mr Speaker is that not only is it bad poor the landlords Mr Speaker is that not only is it bad poor the landlords but Mr Speaker is that not only is it bad poor the landlords but because bad poor the landlords but because landlords bad poor the landlords but because landlords and bad poor the landlords but because landlords and tenants bad poor the landlords but because landlords and tenants have bad poor the landlords but because landlords and tenants have a landlords and tenants have a symbiotic landlords and tenants have a symbiotic relationship, landlords and tenants have a symbiotic relationship, this symbiotic relationship, this Government symbiotic relationship, this Government manages symbiotic relationship, this Government manages to symbiotic relationship, this Government manages to hurt symbiotic relationship, this Government manages to hurt the symbiotic relationship, this Government manages to hurt the exact Government manages to hurt the exact people Government manages to hurt the exact symbiotic Government manages to hurt the exact people it is Government manages to hurt the exact people it is trying Government manages to hurt the exact people it is trying to Government manages to hurt the exact people it is trying to help. Government manages to hurt the exact people it is trying to help. Almost people it is trying to help. Almost everything people it is trying to help. Almost everything they people it is trying to help. Almost everything they do people it is trying to help. Almost everything they do harms people it is trying to help. Almost everything they do harms the people it is trying to help. Almost everything they do harms the people everything they do harms the people they everything they do harms the people they are everything they do harms the people they are trying everything they do harms the people they are trying to everything they do harms the people they are trying to help everything they do harms the people they are trying to help and everything they do harms the people they are trying to help and defeats they are trying to help and defeats the they are trying to help and defeats the purpose they are trying to help and defeats the purpose they they are trying to help and defeats the purpose they are they are trying to help and defeats the purpose they are trying they are trying to help and defeats the purpose they are trying to the purpose they are trying to achieve the purpose they are trying to achieve because the purpose they are trying to achieve because they the purpose they are trying to achieve because they just the purpose they are trying to achieve because they just don't the purpose they are trying to achieve because they just don't get achieve because they just don't get basic achieve because they just don't get basic economics, achieve because they just don't get basic economics, basic achieve because they just don't get basic economics, basic logic achieve because they just don't get basic economics, basic logic and achieve because they just don't get basic economics, basic logic and the basic economics, basic logic and the basic basic economics, basic logic and the basic ways basic economics, basic logic and the basic ways that basic economics, basic logic and the basic ways that this basic economics, basic logic and the basic ways that this society basic economics, basic logic and the basic ways that this society works. basic ways that this society works. Mr basic ways that this society works. Mr Speaker, basic ways that this society works. Mr Speaker, this basic ways that this society works. Mr Speaker, this country basic ways that this society works. Mr Speaker, this country deserves Mr Speaker, this country deserves better. Mr Speaker, this country deserves better. This Mr Speaker, this country deserves better. This country Mr Speaker, this country deserves better. This country deserves Mr Speaker, this country deserves better. This country deserves a better. This country deserves a society better. This country deserves a society that better. This country deserves a society that works better. This country deserves a society that works because better. This country deserves a society that works because it better. This country deserves a society that works because it gets society that works because it gets better society that works because it gets better policies society that works because it gets better policies that society that works because it gets better policies that actually better policies that actually deliver better policies that actually deliver the better policies that actually deliver the intentions, better policies that actually deliver the intentions, not better policies that actually deliver the intentions, not just deliver the intentions, not just serve deliver the intentions, not just serve as deliver the intentions, not just serve as background deliver the intentions, not just serve as background to deliver the intentions, not just serve as background to an deliver the intentions, not just serve as background to an unending serve as background to an unending marketing serve as background to an unending marketing campaign serve as background to an unending marketing campaign by serve as background to an unending marketing campaign by the serve as background to an unending marketing campaign by the PM, serve as background to an unending marketing campaign by the PM, who serve as background to an unending marketing campaign by the PM, who I marketing campaign by the PM, who I will marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give it marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give it to marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give it to her, marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give it to her, is marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give it to her, is the marketing campaign by the PM, who I will give it to her, is the best will give it to her, is the best marketer will give it to her, is the best marketer in will give it to her, is the best marketer in world will give it to her, is the best marketer in world politics will give it to her, is the best marketer in world politics but will give it to her, is the best marketer in world politics but the marketer in world politics but the worst marketer in world politics but the worst public marketer in world politics but the worst public policy marketer in world politics but the worst public policy deliverer. marketer in world politics but the worst public policy deliverer. Let worst public policy deliverer. Let me worst public policy deliverer. Let me say worst public policy deliverer. Let me say finally, worst public policy deliverer. Let me say finally, Mr worst public policy deliverer. Let me say finally, Mr Speaker, worst public policy deliverer. Let me say finally, Mr Speaker, in me say finally, Mr Speaker, in relation me say finally, Mr Speaker, in relation to me say finally, Mr Speaker, in relation to our me say finally, Mr Speaker, in relation to our parliament, me say finally, Mr Speaker, in relation to our parliament, if me say finally, Mr Speaker, in relation to our parliament, if there relation to our parliament, if there is relation to our parliament, if there is one relation to our parliament, if there is one thing relation to our parliament, if there is one thing we relation to our parliament, if there is one thing we could relation to our parliament, if there is one thing we could all relation to our parliament, if there is one thing we could all be relation to our parliament, if there is one thing we could all be proud is one thing we could all be proud of is one thing we could all be proud of and is one thing we could all be proud of and agree is one thing we could all be proud of and agree on is one thing we could all be proud of and agree on is is one thing we could all be proud of and agree on is that is one thing we could all be proud of and agree on is that we is one thing we could all be proud of and agree on is that we have is one thing we could all be proud of and agree on is that we have been of and agree on is that we have been enormously of and agree on is that we have been enormously fortunate of and agree on is that we have been enormously fortunate to of and agree on is that we have been enormously fortunate to inherit enormously fortunate to inherit parliamentary enormously fortunate to inherit parliamentary democracy. enormously fortunate to inherit parliamentary democracy. There enormously fortunate to inherit parliamentary democracy. There is enormously fortunate to inherit parliamentary democracy. There is a parliamentary democracy. There is a long parliamentary democracy. There is a long history parliamentary democracy. There is a long history where parliamentary democracy. There is a long history where gradually parliamentary democracy. There is a long history where gradually power long history where gradually power shifted long history where gradually power shifted from long history where gradually power shifted from the long history where gradually power shifted from the monarch long history where gradually power shifted from the monarch to long history where gradually power shifted from the monarch to the shifted from the monarch to the people shifted from the monarch to the people who shifted from the monarch to the people who sent shifted from the monarch to the people who sent representatives shifted from the monarch to the people who sent representatives to people who sent representatives to the people who sent representatives to the capital people who sent representatives to the capital city people who sent representatives to the capital city to people who sent representatives to the capital city to speak people who sent representatives to the capital city to speak for people who sent representatives to the capital city to speak for them. the capital city to speak for them. It's the capital city to speak for them. It's because the capital city to speak for them. It's because of the capital city to speak for them. It's because of the the capital city to speak for them. It's because of the importance the capital city to speak for them. It's because of the importance of It's because of the importance of that It's because of the importance of that job, It's because of the importance of that job, holding It's because of the importance of that job, holding the It's because of the importance of that job, holding the Crown It's because of the importance of that job, holding the Crown to that job, holding the Crown to account, that job, holding the Crown to account, that that job, holding the Crown to account, that we that job, holding the Crown to account, that we have that job, holding the Crown to account, that we have such that job, holding the Crown to account, that we have such great account, that we have such great privileges. account, that we have such great privileges. Traditionally, account, that we have such great privileges. Traditionally, Mr privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, it privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, it has privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, it has been privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, it has been the privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, it has been the person privileges. Traditionally, Mr Speaker, it has been the person in Speaker, it has been the person in your Speaker, it has been the person in your role Speaker, it has been the person in your role who Speaker, it has been the person in your role who is Speaker, it has been the person in your role who is the Speaker, it has been the person in your role who is the PM Speaker, it has been the person in your role who is the PM defender Speaker, it has been the person in your role who is the PM defender of your role who is the PM defender of that your role who is the PM defender of that tradition. your role who is the PM defender of that tradition. Early your role who is the PM defender of that tradition. Early Speakers that tradition. Early Speakers literally that tradition. Early Speakers literally lost that tradition. Early Speakers literally lost their that tradition. Early Speakers literally lost their heads that tradition. Early Speakers literally lost their heads for literally lost their heads for speaking literally lost their heads for speaking up literally lost their heads for speaking up for literally lost their heads for speaking up for and literally lost their heads for speaking up for and defending literally lost their heads for speaking up for and defending the speaking up for and defending the rights speaking up for and defending the rights of speaking up for and defending the rights of parliamentarians speaking up for and defending the rights of parliamentarians versus rights of parliamentarians versus the rights of parliamentarians versus the Crown. rights of parliamentarians versus the Crown. I rights of parliamentarians versus the Crown. I watched rights of parliamentarians versus the Crown. I watched your rights of parliamentarians versus the Crown. I watched your ruling rights of parliamentarians versus the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Crown. I watched your ruling on the the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Leader the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Leader of the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Leader of the the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Leader of the Opposition the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Leader of the Opposition and the Crown. I watched your ruling on the Leader of the Opposition and I the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the way the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the way that the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the way that you the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the way that you treated the Leader of the Opposition and I observed the way that you treated me observed the way that you treated me through observed the way that you treated me through question observed the way that you treated me through question time observed the way that you treated me through question time towards observed the way that you treated me through question time towards the through question time towards the end through question time towards the end of through question time towards the end of last through question time towards the end of last year. through question time towards the end of last year. I through question time towards the end of last year. I put through question time towards the end of last year. I put it through question time towards the end of last year. I put it to through question time towards the end of last year. I put it to you end of last year. I put it to you that end of last year. I put it to you that as end of last year. I put it to you that as the end of last year. I put it to you that as the person end of last year. I put it to you that as the person with end of last year. I put it to you that as the person with the that as the person with the privilege that as the person with the privilege of that as the person with the privilege of upholding that as the person with the privilege of upholding the privilege of upholding the parliamentary privilege of upholding the parliamentary tradition, privilege of upholding the parliamentary tradition, you, privilege of upholding the parliamentary tradition, you, for parliamentary tradition, you, for now, parliamentary tradition, you, for now, have parliamentary tradition, you, for now, have all parliamentary tradition, you, for now, have all the parliamentary tradition, you, for now, have all the power parliamentary tradition, you, for now, have all the power except parliamentary tradition, you, for now, have all the power except for now, have all the power except for one, now, have all the power except for one, which now, have all the power except for one, which is now, have all the power except for one, which is to now, have all the power except for one, which is to choose now, have all the power except for one, which is to choose how now, have all the power except for one, which is to choose how others one, which is to choose how others will one, which is to choose how others will judge one, which is to choose how others will judge you one, which is to choose how others will judge you as one, which is to choose how others will judge you as you one, which is to choose how others will judge you as you leave one, which is to choose how others will judge you as you leave this will judge you as you leave this place will judge you as you leave this place in will judge you as you leave this place in future. will judge you as you leave this place in future. Thank will judge you as you leave this place in future. Thank you, will judge you as you leave this place in future. Thank you, Mr place in future. Thank you, Mr Speaker. place in future. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Following place in future. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Following agreement place in future. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Following agreement of place in future. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Following agreement of the Speaker. Following agreement of the Business Speaker. Following agreement of the Business Committee Speaker. Following agreement of the Business Committee the Speaker. Following agreement of the Business Committee the debate Speaker. Following agreement of the Business Committee the debate on Speaker. Following agreement of the Business Committee the debate on the Business Committee the debate on the PM's Business Committee the debate on the PM's statement Business Committee the debate on the PM's statement will Business Committee the debate on the PM's statement will now Business Committee the debate on the PM's statement will now be Business Committee the debate on the PM's statement will now be adjourned PM's statement will now be adjourned and PM's statement will now be adjourned and oral PM's statement will now be adjourned and oral questions PM's statement will now be adjourned and oral questions held. PM's statement will now be adjourned and oral questions held. The PM's statement will now be adjourned and oral questions held. The debate and oral questions held. The debate is and oral questions held. The debate is adjourned and oral questions held. The debate is adjourned and and oral questions held. The debate is adjourned and set and oral questions held. The debate is adjourned and set down and oral questions held. The debate is adjourned and set down for is adjourned and set down for resumption is adjourned and set down for resumption next is adjourned and set down for resumption next sitting is adjourned and set down for resumption next sitting day. is adjourned and set down for resumption next sitting day. A is adjourned and set down for resumption next sitting day. A point resumption next sitting day. A point of resumption next sitting day. A point of order, resumption next sitting day. A point of order, the resumption next sitting day. A point of order, the Hon resumption next sitting day. A point of order, the Hon David resumption next sitting day. A point of order, the Hon David Clark. resumption next sitting day. A point of order, the Hon David Clark. I of order, the Hon David Clark. I wish of order, the Hon David Clark. I wish to of order, the Hon David Clark. I wish to make of order, the Hon David Clark. I wish to make a of order, the Hon David Clark. I wish to make a ministerial of order, the Hon David Clark. I wish to make a ministerial statement wish to make a ministerial statement in wish to make a ministerial statement in accordance wish to make a ministerial statement in accordance with wish to make a ministerial statement in accordance with Standing wish to make a ministerial statement in accordance with Standing Order in accordance with Standing Order 355 in accordance with Standing Order 355 about in accordance with Standing Order 355 about the in accordance with Standing Order 355 about the novel in accordance with Standing Order 355 about the novel coronavirus. in accordance with Standing Order 355 about the novel coronavirus. The 355 about the novel coronavirus. The novel 355 about the novel coronavirus. The novel coronavirus 355 about the novel coronavirus. The novel coronavirus recently 355 about the novel coronavirus. The novel coronavirus recently named 355 about the novel coronavirus. The novel coronavirus recently named as novel coronavirus recently named as COVID-19 novel coronavirus recently named as COVID-19 was novel coronavirus recently named as COVID-19 was first novel coronavirus recently named as COVID-19 was first reported novel coronavirus recently named as COVID-19 was first reported to novel coronavirus recently named as COVID-19 was first reported to the COVID-19 was first reported to the World COVID-19 was first reported to the World Health COVID-19 was first reported to the World Health Organization COVID-19 was first reported to the World Health Organization on COVID-19 was first reported to the World Health Organization on 31 World Health Organization on 31 December. World Health Organization on 31 December. As World Health Organization on 31 December. As members World Health Organization on 31 December. As members will World Health Organization on 31 December. As members will be World Health Organization on 31 December. As members will be aware, December. As members will be aware, since December. As members will be aware, since that December. As members will be aware, since that time December. As members will be aware, since that time there December. As members will be aware, since that time there have December. As members will be aware, since that time there have been December. As members will be aware, since that time there have been more since that time there have been more than since that time there have been more than 43,000 since that time there have been more than 43,000 cases since that time there have been more than 43,000 cases and since that time there have been more than 43,000 cases and over since that time there have been more than 43,000 cases and over 1,000 than 43,000 cases and over 1,000 deaths. than 43,000 cases and over 1,000 deaths. The than 43,000 cases and over 1,000 deaths. The vast than 43,000 cases and over 1,000 deaths. The vast majority than 43,000 cases and over 1,000 deaths. The vast majority within deaths. The vast majority within China. deaths. The vast majority within China. In deaths. The vast majority within China. In New deaths. The vast majority within China. In New Zealand deaths. The vast majority within China. In New Zealand we deaths. The vast majority within China. In New Zealand we have deaths. The vast majority within China. In New Zealand we have not China. In New Zealand we have not yet China. In New Zealand we have not yet had China. In New Zealand we have not yet had a China. In New Zealand we have not yet had a confirmed China. In New Zealand we have not yet had a confirmed case China. In New Zealand we have not yet had a confirmed case but China. In New Zealand we have not yet had a confirmed case but we China. In New Zealand we have not yet had a confirmed case but we are yet had a confirmed case but we are taking yet had a confirmed case but we are taking the yet had a confirmed case but we are taking the threat yet had a confirmed case but we are taking the threat very yet had a confirmed case but we are taking the threat very seriously yet had a confirmed case but we are taking the threat very seriously and taking the threat very seriously and we taking the threat very seriously and we are taking the threat very seriously and we are well taking the threat very seriously and we are well prepared. taking the threat very seriously and we are well prepared. Our we are well prepared. Our comprehensive we are well prepared. Our comprehensive health we are well prepared. Our comprehensive health response we are well prepared. Our comprehensive health response began comprehensive health response began on comprehensive health response began on 6 comprehensive health response began on 6 January comprehensive health response began on 6 January when comprehensive health response began on 6 January when the comprehensive health response began on 6 January when the minister comprehensive health response began on 6 January when the minister - on 6 January when the minister - Ministry on 6 January when the minister - Ministry of on 6 January when the minister - Ministry of Health on 6 January when the minister - Ministry of Health first on 6 January when the minister - Ministry of Health first sent on 6 January when the minister - Ministry of Health first sent out Ministry of Health first sent out advice Ministry of Health first sent out advice to Ministry of Health first sent out advice to DHBs Ministry of Health first sent out advice to DHBs and Ministry of Health first sent out advice to DHBs and primary Ministry of Health first sent out advice to DHBs and primary care advice to DHBs and primary care about advice to DHBs and primary care about the advice to DHBs and primary care about the virus. advice to DHBs and primary care about the virus. Arrangements advice to DHBs and primary care about the virus. Arrangements were about the virus. Arrangements were quickly about the virus. Arrangements were quickly made about the virus. Arrangements were quickly made to about the virus. Arrangements were quickly made to ensure about the virus. Arrangements were quickly made to ensure that about the virus. Arrangements were quickly made to ensure that health quickly made to ensure that health advice quickly made to ensure that health advice was quickly made to ensure that health advice was being quickly made to ensure that health advice was being provided quickly made to ensure that health advice was being provided at quickly made to ensure that health advice was being provided at the advice was being provided at the border advice was being provided at the border in advice was being provided at the border in a advice was being provided at the border in a range advice was being provided at the border in a range of advice was being provided at the border in a range of languages border in a range of languages including border in a range of languages including traditional border in a range of languages including traditional and border in a range of languages including traditional and simplified including traditional and simplified Chinese. including traditional and simplified Chinese. I'm including traditional and simplified Chinese. I'm advised including traditional and simplified Chinese. I'm advised that including traditional and simplified Chinese. I'm advised that providing Chinese. I'm advised that providing clear Chinese. I'm advised that providing clear health Chinese. I'm advised that providing clear health advice Chinese. I'm advised that providing clear health advice remains Chinese. I'm advised that providing clear health advice remains our Chinese. I'm advised that providing clear health advice remains our best clear health advice remains our best protection clear health advice remains our best protection against clear health advice remains our best protection against the clear health advice remains our best protection against the spread clear health advice remains our best protection against the spread of clear health advice remains our best protection against the spread of the protection against the spread of the coronavirus protection against the spread of the coronavirus and protection against the spread of the coronavirus and that protection against the spread of the coronavirus and that remains protection against the spread of the coronavirus and that remains a protection against the spread of the coronavirus and that remains a key coronavirus and that remains a key part coronavirus and that remains a key part of coronavirus and that remains a key part of our coronavirus and that remains a key part of our ongoing coronavirus and that remains a key part of our ongoing response coronavirus and that remains a key part of our ongoing response to coronavirus and that remains a key part of our ongoing response to this part of our ongoing response to this issue. part of our ongoing response to this issue. An part of our ongoing response to this issue. An incident part of our ongoing response to this issue. An incident control part of our ongoing response to this issue. An incident control team part of our ongoing response to this issue. An incident control team was issue. An incident control team was set issue. An incident control team was set up issue. An incident control team was set up within issue. An incident control team was set up within the issue. An incident control team was set up within the ministry issue. An incident control team was set up within the ministry in issue. An incident control team was set up within the ministry in the set up within the ministry in the week set up within the ministry in the week of set up within the ministry in the week of 20 set up within the ministry in the week of 20 January. set up within the ministry in the week of 20 January. That set up within the ministry in the week of 20 January. That same set up within the ministry in the week of 20 January. That same week, week of 20 January. That same week, on week of 20 January. That same week, week week of 20 January. That same week, on 24 January, week of 20 January. That same week, on 24 January, the week of 20 January. That same week, on 24 January, the Government's on 24 January, the Government's interagency on 24 January, the Government's interagency pandemic on 24 January, the Government's interagency pandemic group on 24 January, the Government's interagency pandemic group met on 24 January, the Government's interagency pandemic group met as on 24 January, the Government's interagency pandemic group met as a interagency pandemic group met as a precaution. interagency pandemic group met as a precaution. At interagency pandemic group met as a precaution. At all interagency pandemic group met as a precaution. At all times interagency pandemic group met as a precaution. At all times our precaution. At all times our response precaution. At all times our response to precaution. At all times our response to the precaution. At all times our response to the coronavirus precaution. At all times our response to the coronavirus has precaution. At all times our response to the coronavirus has been response to the coronavirus has been informed response to the coronavirus has been informed by response to the coronavirus has been informed by the response to the coronavirus has been informed by the best response to the coronavirus has been informed by the best available informed by the best available public informed by the best available public health informed by the best available public health advice informed by the best available public health advice from informed by the best available public health advice from doctors public health advice from doctors and public health advice from doctors and clinical public health advice from doctors and clinical experts. public health advice from doctors and clinical experts. That public health advice from doctors and clinical experts. That advice and clinical experts. That advice and and clinical experts. That advice and our and clinical experts. That advice and our response and clinical experts. That advice and our response is and clinical experts. That advice and our response is under and clinical experts. That advice and our response is under constant and our response is under constant review and our response is under constant review to and our response is under constant review to ensure and our response is under constant review to ensure we and our response is under constant review to ensure we continue and our response is under constant review to ensure we continue to review to ensure we continue to follow review to ensure we continue to follow best review to ensure we continue to follow best practice review to ensure we continue to follow best practice and review to ensure we continue to follow best practice and work follow best practice and work closely follow best practice and work closely with follow best practice and work closely with our follow best practice and work closely with our international closely with our international partners. closely with our international partners. Based closely with our international partners. Based on closely with our international partners. Based on expert closely with our international partners. Based on expert public partners. Based on expert public health partners. Based on expert public health advice partners. Based on expert public health advice on partners. Based on expert public health advice on 27 partners. Based on expert public health advice on 27 January partners. Based on expert public health advice on 27 January we health advice on 27 January we deployed health advice on 27 January we deployed public health advice on 27 January we deployed public health health advice on 27 January we deployed public health nurses health advice on 27 January we deployed public health nurses at deployed public health nurses at Christchurch deployed public health nurses at Christchurch and deployed public health nurses at Christchurch and Auckland Christchurch and Auckland international Christchurch and Auckland international airport Christchurch and Auckland international airport to Christchurch and Auckland international airport to meet Christchurch and Auckland international airport to meet all international airport to meet all flights international airport to meet all flights from international airport to meet all flights from mainland international airport to meet all flights from mainland China international airport to meet all flights from mainland China to flights from mainland China to provide flights from mainland China to provide advice flights from mainland China to provide advice and flights from mainland China to provide advice and check flights from mainland China to provide advice and check any flights from mainland China to provide advice and check any one provide advice and check any one displaying provide advice and check any one displaying symptoms. provide advice and check any one displaying symptoms. Those provide advice and check any one displaying symptoms. Those measures displaying symptoms. Those measures are displaying symptoms. Those measures are ongoing. displaying symptoms. Those measures are ongoing. On displaying symptoms. Those measures are ongoing. On 28 displaying symptoms. Those measures are ongoing. On 28 January displaying symptoms. Those measures are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for the are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for the first are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for the first time are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for the first time this are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for the first time this year are ongoing. On 28 January Cabinet met for the first time this year and met for the first time this year and made met for the first time this year and made the met for the first time this year and made the novel met for the first time this year and made the novel coronavirus met for the first time this year and made the novel coronavirus a made the novel coronavirus a notifiable made the novel coronavirus a notifiable disease made the novel coronavirus a notifiable disease under made the novel coronavirus a notifiable disease under the made the novel coronavirus a notifiable disease under the Health notifiable disease under the Health Act. notifiable disease under the Health Act. That notifiable disease under the Health Act. That means notifiable disease under the Health Act. That means we notifiable disease under the Health Act. That means we have notifiable disease under the Health Act. That means we have all notifiable disease under the Health Act. That means we have all the Act. That means we have all the appropriate Act. That means we have all the appropriate public Act. That means we have all the appropriate public health Act. That means we have all the appropriate public health powers Act. That means we have all the appropriate public health powers in appropriate public health powers in place appropriate public health powers in place to appropriate public health powers in place to deal appropriate public health powers in place to deal with appropriate public health powers in place to deal with the appropriate public health powers in place to deal with the COVID-19 appropriate public health powers in place to deal with the COVID-19 if place to deal with the COVID-19 if and place to deal with the COVID-19 if and when place to deal with the COVID-19 if and when it place to deal with the COVID-19 if and when it arrives place to deal with the COVID-19 if and when it arrives in place to deal with the COVID-19 if and when it arrives in New place to deal with the COVID-19 if and when it arrives in New Zealand. and when it arrives in New Zealand. That and when it arrives in New Zealand. That same and when it arrives in New Zealand. That same day and when it arrives in New Zealand. That same day the and when it arrives in New Zealand. That same day the Ministry and when it arrives in New Zealand. That same day the Ministry of and when it arrives in New Zealand. That same day the Ministry of Health That same day the Ministry of Health activated That same day the Ministry of Health activated the That same day the Ministry of Health activated the national That same day the Ministry of Health activated the national health activated the national health coordination activated the national health coordination centre activated the national health coordination centre which activated the national health coordination centre which is coordination centre which is operating coordination centre which is operating 7 coordination centre which is operating 7 days coordination centre which is operating 7 days a coordination centre which is operating 7 days a week coordination centre which is operating 7 days a week to coordination centre which is operating 7 days a week to monitor operating 7 days a week to monitor the operating 7 days a week to monitor the situation operating 7 days a week to monitor the situation and operating 7 days a week to monitor the situation and which operating 7 days a week to monitor the situation and which provides the situation and which provides updated the situation and which provides updated advice the situation and which provides updated advice on the situation and which provides updated advice on a the situation and which provides updated advice on a daily the situation and which provides updated advice on a daily basis. the situation and which provides updated advice on a daily basis. Mr updated advice on a daily basis. Mr Speaker, updated advice on a daily basis. Mr Speaker, our updated advice on a daily basis. Mr Speaker, our response updated advice on a daily basis. Mr Speaker, our response to updated advice on a daily basis. Mr Speaker, our response to the Speaker, our response to the coronavirus Speaker, our response to the coronavirus has Speaker, our response to the coronavirus has been Speaker, our response to the coronavirus has been measured Speaker, our response to the coronavirus has been measured and coronavirus has been measured and responsive. coronavirus has been measured and responsive. As coronavirus has been measured and responsive. As the coronavirus has been measured and responsive. As the number coronavirus has been measured and responsive. As the number of coronavirus has been measured and responsive. As the number of cases responsive. As the number of cases has responsive. As the number of cases has increased responsive. As the number of cases has increased and responsive. As the number of cases has increased and disease responsive. As the number of cases has increased and disease has has increased and disease has spread, has increased and disease has spread, we has increased and disease has spread, we have has increased and disease has spread, we have been has increased and disease has spread, we have been constantly spread, we have been constantly reviewing spread, we have been constantly reviewing our spread, we have been constantly reviewing our position spread, we have been constantly reviewing our position to spread, we have been constantly reviewing our position to ensure spread, we have been constantly reviewing our position to ensure we reviewing our position to ensure we are reviewing our position to ensure we are doing reviewing our position to ensure we are doing what reviewing our position to ensure we are doing what is reviewing our position to ensure we are doing what is required reviewing our position to ensure we are doing what is required to reviewing our position to ensure we are doing what is required to keep are doing what is required to keep New are doing what is required to keep New Zealanders are doing what is required to keep New Zealanders safe. are doing what is required to keep New Zealanders safe. On are doing what is required to keep New Zealanders safe. On Monday are doing what is required to keep New Zealanders safe. On Monday 3 New Zealanders safe. On Monday 3 February, New Zealanders safe. On Monday 3 February, the New Zealanders safe. On Monday 3 February, the Government New Zealanders safe. On Monday 3 February, the Government introduced February, the Government introduced travel February, the Government introduced travel restrictions February, the Government introduced travel restrictions that February, the Government introduced travel restrictions that prevent travel restrictions that prevent anyone travel restrictions that prevent anyone other travel restrictions that prevent anyone other than travel restrictions that prevent anyone other than New travel restrictions that prevent anyone other than New Zealand anyone other than New Zealand citizens anyone other than New Zealand citizens or anyone other than New Zealand citizens or permanent anyone other than New Zealand citizens or permanent residents anyone other than New Zealand citizens or permanent residents who citizens or permanent residents who have citizens or permanent residents who have been citizens or permanent residents who have been in citizens or permanent residents who have been in China citizens or permanent residents who have been in China in citizens or permanent residents who have been in China in the citizens or permanent residents who have been in China in the last citizens or permanent residents who have been in China in the last 14 have been in China in the last 14 days have been in China in the last 14 days from have been in China in the last 14 days from entering have been in China in the last 14 days from entering New have been in China in the last 14 days from entering New Zealand. have been in China in the last 14 days from entering New Zealand. This days from entering New Zealand. This step days from entering New Zealand. This step was days from entering New Zealand. This step was not days from entering New Zealand. This step was not taken days from entering New Zealand. This step was not taken lightly days from entering New Zealand. This step was not taken lightly but step was not taken lightly but followed step was not taken lightly but followed updated step was not taken lightly but followed updated health step was not taken lightly but followed updated health advice step was not taken lightly but followed updated health advice and followed updated health advice and was followed updated health advice and was in followed updated health advice and was in step followed updated health advice and was in step with followed updated health advice and was in step with Australia, followed updated health advice and was in step with Australia, the followed updated health advice and was in step with Australia, the US was in step with Australia, the US and was in step with Australia, the US and several was in step with Australia, the US and several other was in step with Australia, the US and several other countries. was in step with Australia, the US and several other countries. More and several other countries. More have and several other countries. More have since and several other countries. More have since followed and several other countries. More have since followed suit. and several other countries. More have since followed suit. I and several other countries. More have since followed suit. I would have since followed suit. I would note have since followed suit. I would note that have since followed suit. I would note that our have since followed suit. I would note that our border have since followed suit. I would note that our border restrictions note that our border restrictions compliment note that our border restrictions compliment the note that our border restrictions compliment the actions note that our border restrictions compliment the actions taken note that our border restrictions compliment the actions taken by note that our border restrictions compliment the actions taken by the compliment the actions taken by the Chinese compliment the actions taken by the Chinese Government compliment the actions taken by the Chinese Government to compliment the actions taken by the Chinese Government to contain compliment the actions taken by the Chinese Government to contain this Chinese Government to contain this virus Chinese Government to contain this virus within Chinese Government to contain this virus within its Chinese Government to contain this virus within its borders. Chinese Government to contain this virus within its borders. No Chinese Government to contain this virus within its borders. No country virus within its borders. No country has virus within its borders. No country has taken virus within its borders. No country has taken stricter virus within its borders. No country has taken stricter measures virus within its borders. No country has taken stricter measures at virus within its borders. No country has taken stricter measures at their has taken stricter measures at their border has taken stricter measures at their border than has taken stricter measures at their border than China has taken stricter measures at their border than China itself. has taken stricter measures at their border than China itself. All has taken stricter measures at their border than China itself. All New border than China itself. All New Zealanders border than China itself. All New Zealanders who border than China itself. All New Zealanders who have border than China itself. All New Zealanders who have been border than China itself. All New Zealanders who have been in border than China itself. All New Zealanders who have been in China border than China itself. All New Zealanders who have been in China in Zealanders who have been in China in the Zealanders who have been in China in the last Zealanders who have been in China in the last 14 Zealanders who have been in China in the last 14 days Zealanders who have been in China in the last 14 days and Zealanders who have been in China in the last 14 days and have Zealanders who have been in China in the last 14 days and have returned the last 14 days and have returned home the last 14 days and have returned home since the last 14 days and have returned home since the the last 14 days and have returned home since the travel the last 14 days and have returned home since the travel restrictions home since the travel restrictions were home since the travel restrictions were introduced home since the travel restrictions were introduced have home since the travel restrictions were introduced have been home since the travel restrictions were introduced have been asked home since the travel restrictions were introduced have been asked to were introduced have been asked to go were introduced have been asked to go into were introduced have been asked to go into self-isolation were introduced have been asked to go into self-isolation for were introduced have been asked to go into self-isolation for 14 were introduced have been asked to go into self-isolation for 14 days go into self-isolation for 14 days which go into self-isolation for 14 days which is go into self-isolation for 14 days which is believed go into self-isolation for 14 days which is believed to go into self-isolation for 14 days which is believed to be go into self-isolation for 14 days which is believed to be longer go into self-isolation for 14 days which is believed to be longer than which is believed to be longer than the which is believed to be longer than the incubation which is believed to be longer than the incubation period which is believed to be longer than the incubation period of which is believed to be longer than the incubation period of this which is believed to be longer than the incubation period of this virus. the incubation period of this virus. Previous the incubation period of this virus. Previous experience the incubation period of this virus. Previous experience suggests the incubation period of this virus. Previous experience suggests that Previous experience suggests that self-isolation Previous experience suggests that self-isolation compliance Previous experience suggests that self-isolation compliance rates Previous experience suggests that self-isolation compliance rates will self-isolation compliance rates will be self-isolation compliance rates will be high self-isolation compliance rates will be high as self-isolation compliance rates will be high as people self-isolation compliance rates will be high as people are self-isolation compliance rates will be high as people are conscious self-isolation compliance rates will be high as people are conscious of be high as people are conscious of the be high as people are conscious of the risks be high as people are conscious of the risks that be high as people are conscious of the risks that infectious be high as people are conscious of the risks that infectious diseases the risks that infectious diseases pose the risks that infectious diseases pose to the risks that infectious diseases pose to their the risks that infectious diseases pose to their family, the risks that infectious diseases pose to their family, whanau the risks that infectious diseases pose to their family, whanau and pose to their family, whanau and community. pose to their family, whanau and community. For pose to their family, whanau and community. For example, pose to their family, whanau and community. For example, during pose to their family, whanau and community. For example, during the community. For example, during the 2009 community. For example, during the 2009 influenza community. For example, during the 2009 influenza pandemic community. For example, during the 2009 influenza pandemic there community. For example, during the 2009 influenza pandemic there were 2009 influenza pandemic there were high 2009 influenza pandemic there were high rates 2009 influenza pandemic there were high rates of 2009 influenza pandemic there were high rates of compliance 2009 influenza pandemic there were high rates of compliance in 2009 influenza pandemic there were high rates of compliance in the high rates of compliance in the initial high rates of compliance in the initial weeks high rates of compliance in the initial weeks of high rates of compliance in the initial weeks of the high rates of compliance in the initial weeks of the event high rates of compliance in the initial weeks of the event and high rates of compliance in the initial weeks of the event and the initial weeks of the event and the ministry initial weeks of the event and the ministry did initial weeks of the event and the ministry did not initial weeks of the event and the ministry did not need initial weeks of the event and the ministry did not need to initial weeks of the event and the ministry did not need to use initial weeks of the event and the ministry did not need to use any ministry did not need to use any powers ministry did not need to use any powers to ministry did not need to use any powers to enforce ministry did not need to use any powers to enforce self-isolation. ministry did not need to use any powers to enforce self-isolation. So powers to enforce self-isolation. So far powers to enforce self-isolation. So far more powers to enforce self-isolation. So far more than powers to enforce self-isolation. So far more than 1,800 powers to enforce self-isolation. So far more than 1,800 people powers to enforce self-isolation. So far more than 1,800 people have far more than 1,800 people have self-registered far more than 1,800 people have self-registered with far more than 1,800 people have self-registered with Healthline self-registered with Healthline about self-registered with Healthline about their self-registered with Healthline about their isolation. self-registered with Healthline about their isolation. And about their isolation. And Healthline about their isolation. And Healthline staff about their isolation. And Healthline staff are about their isolation. And Healthline staff are keeping about their isolation. And Healthline staff are keeping in Healthline staff are keeping in regular Healthline staff are keeping in regular contact Healthline staff are keeping in regular contact with Healthline staff are keeping in regular contact with those Healthline staff are keeping in regular contact with those people Healthline staff are keeping in regular contact with those people to regular contact with those people to provide regular contact with those people to provide them regular contact with those people to provide them advice regular contact with those people to provide them advice and regular contact with those people to provide them advice and support regular contact with those people to provide them advice and support and provide them advice and support and to provide them advice and support and to check provide them advice and support and to check on provide them advice and support and to check on their provide them advice and support and to check on their welfare. provide them advice and support and to check on their welfare. Customs to check on their welfare. Customs and to check on their welfare. Customs and the to check on their welfare. Customs and the Ministry to check on their welfare. Customs and the Ministry of to check on their welfare. Customs and the Ministry of Health to check on their welfare. Customs and the Ministry of Health are to check on their welfare. Customs and the Ministry of Health are also and the Ministry of Health are also sharing and the Ministry of Health are also sharing data and the Ministry of Health are also sharing data to and the Ministry of Health are also sharing data to enable and the Ministry of Health are also sharing data to enable Healthline and the Ministry of Health are also sharing data to enable Healthline to sharing data to enable Healthline to proactively sharing data to enable Healthline to proactively contact sharing data to enable Healthline to proactively contact anyone sharing data to enable Healthline to proactively contact anyone who sharing data to enable Healthline to proactively contact anyone who has proactively contact anyone who has returned proactively contact anyone who has returned from proactively contact anyone who has returned from China proactively contact anyone who has returned from China but proactively contact anyone who has returned from China but has proactively contact anyone who has returned from China but has yet proactively contact anyone who has returned from China but has yet to returned from China but has yet to register returned from China but has yet to register with returned from China but has yet to register with Healthline. returned from China but has yet to register with Healthline. Members register with Healthline. Members will register with Healthline. Members will also register with Healthline. Members will also be register with Healthline. Members will also be aware register with Healthline. Members will also be aware that register with Healthline. Members will also be aware that the will also be aware that the Government will also be aware that the Government arranged will also be aware that the Government arranged an will also be aware that the Government arranged an evacuation Government arranged an evacuation flight Government arranged an evacuation flight for Government arranged an evacuation flight for New Government arranged an evacuation flight for New Zealanders Government arranged an evacuation flight for New Zealanders and flight for New Zealanders and Pacific flight for New Zealanders and Pacific island flight for New Zealanders and Pacific island citizens flight for New Zealanders and Pacific island citizens in flight for New Zealanders and Pacific island citizens in the flight for New Zealanders and Pacific island citizens in the city Pacific island citizens in the city of Pacific island citizens in the city of Wuhan. Pacific island citizens in the city of Wuhan. 157 Pacific island citizens in the city of Wuhan. 157 people Pacific island citizens in the city of Wuhan. 157 people remain Pacific island citizens in the city of Wuhan. 157 people remain in of Wuhan. 157 people remain in isolation of Wuhan. 157 people remain in isolation at of Wuhan. 157 people remain in isolation at the of Wuhan. 157 people remain in isolation at the military of Wuhan. 157 people remain in isolation at the military facility isolation at the military facility at isolation at the military facility at fanga isolation at the military facility at fanga par isolation at the military facility at fanga par rohe. isolation at the military facility at fanga par rohe. They isolation at the military facility at fanga par rohe. They are at fanga par rohe. They are receiving at fanga par rohe. They are receiving regular at fanga par rohe. They are receiving regular health at fanga par rohe. They are receiving regular health checks at fanga par rohe. They are receiving regular health checks and receiving regular health checks and if receiving regular health checks and if anyone receiving regular health checks and if anyone displays receiving regular health checks and if anyone displays any receiving regular health checks and if anyone displays any symptoms receiving regular health checks and if anyone displays any symptoms they if anyone displays any symptoms they are if anyone displays any symptoms they are being if anyone displays any symptoms they are being tested if anyone displays any symptoms they are being tested for if anyone displays any symptoms they are being tested for coronavirus. if anyone displays any symptoms they are being tested for coronavirus. To are being tested for coronavirus. To date are being tested for coronavirus. To date no are being tested for coronavirus. To date no one are being tested for coronavirus. To date no one has are being tested for coronavirus. To date no one has tested are being tested for coronavirus. To date no one has tested positive. are being tested for coronavirus. To date no one has tested positive. New date no one has tested positive. New Zealand date no one has tested positive. New Zealand is date no one has tested positive. New Zealand is well date no one has tested positive. New Zealand is well placed date no one has tested positive. New Zealand is well placed to date no one has tested positive. New Zealand is well placed to respond date no one has tested positive. New Zealand is well placed to respond to Zealand is well placed to respond to emerging Zealand is well placed to respond to emerging infectious Zealand is well placed to respond to emerging infectious diseases Zealand is well placed to respond to emerging infectious diseases and Zealand is well placed to respond to emerging infectious diseases and we emerging infectious diseases and we have emerging infectious diseases and we have strong emerging infectious diseases and we have strong measures emerging infectious diseases and we have strong measures and emerging infectious diseases and we have strong measures and we emerging infectious diseases and we have strong measures and we have emerging infectious diseases and we have strong measures and we have an have strong measures and we have an strong have strong measures and we have an strong understanding have strong measures and we have an strong understanding of have strong measures and we have an strong understanding of a strong understanding of a comprehensive strong understanding of a comprehensive pandemic. strong understanding of a comprehensive pandemic. The strong understanding of a comprehensive pandemic. The Hon comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. I comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. I rise comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. I rise to comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. I rise to speak comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. I rise to speak on comprehensive pandemic. The Hon Bridges. I rise to speak on this Bridges. I rise to speak on this matter Bridges. I rise to speak on this matter given Bridges. I rise to speak on this matter given its Bridges. I rise to speak on this matter given its significance Bridges. I rise to speak on this matter given its significance for matter given its significance for New matter given its significance for New Zealand matter given its significance for New Zealand and matter given its significance for New Zealand and globally matter given its significance for New Zealand and globally and matter given its significance for New Zealand and globally and also New Zealand and globally and also given New Zealand and globally and also given the New Zealand and globally and also given the significant New Zealand and globally and also given the significant uncertainty given the significant uncertainty there given the significant uncertainty there is given the significant uncertainty there is in given the significant uncertainty there is in relation given the significant uncertainty there is in relation to given the significant uncertainty there is in relation to this given the significant uncertainty there is in relation to this matter. there is in relation to this matter. I there is in relation to this matter. I want there is in relation to this matter. I want to there is in relation to this matter. I want to say there is in relation to this matter. I want to say on there is in relation to this matter. I want to say on the there is in relation to this matter. I want to say on the outset there is in relation to this matter. I want to say on the outset on I want to say on the outset on coronavirus I want to say on the outset on coronavirus that I want to say on the outset on coronavirus that the I want to say on the outset on coronavirus that the Opposition coronavirus that the Opposition stand coronavirus that the Opposition stand ready coronavirus that the Opposition stand ready to coronavirus that the Opposition stand ready to collaborate coronavirus that the Opposition stand ready to collaborate and coronavirus that the Opposition stand ready to collaborate and to stand ready to collaborate and to work stand ready to collaborate and to work with stand ready to collaborate and to work with the stand ready to collaborate and to work with the Government stand ready to collaborate and to work with the Government on stand ready to collaborate and to work with the Government on this work with the Government on this matter work with the Government on this matter of work with the Government on this matter of great work with the Government on this matter of great importance work with the Government on this matter of great importance in work with the Government on this matter of great importance in every matter of great importance in every facet matter of great importance in every facet of matter of great importance in every facet of it. matter of great importance in every facet of it. I, matter of great importance in every facet of it. I, myself, matter of great importance in every facet of it. I, myself, have matter of great importance in every facet of it. I, myself, have been facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking about facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking about it facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking about it from facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking about it from very facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking about it from very early facet of it. I, myself, have been thinking about it from very early on thinking about it from very early on when thinking about it from very early on when I thinking about it from very early on when I heard thinking about it from very early on when I heard about thinking about it from very early on when I heard about it thinking about it from very early on when I heard about it in thinking about it from very early on when I heard about it in China thinking about it from very early on when I heard about it in China and when I heard about it in China and making when I heard about it in China and making sure when I heard about it in China and making sure every when I heard about it in China and making sure every single when I heard about it in China and making sure every single day when I heard about it in China and making sure every single day I making sure every single day I understand making sure every single day I understand what making sure every single day I understand what is making sure every single day I understand what is happening making sure every single day I understand what is happening on making sure every single day I understand what is happening on it. understand what is happening on it. Indeed, understand what is happening on it. Indeed, that's understand what is happening on it. Indeed, that's partly understand what is happening on it. Indeed, that's partly why understand what is happening on it. Indeed, that's partly why my understand what is happening on it. Indeed, that's partly why my health Indeed, that's partly why my health spokesperson Indeed, that's partly why my health spokesperson was Indeed, that's partly why my health spokesperson was very Indeed, that's partly why my health spokesperson was very quick Indeed, that's partly why my health spokesperson was very quick to Indeed, that's partly why my health spokesperson was very quick to call spokesperson was very quick to call for spokesperson was very quick to call for actions spokesperson was very quick to call for actions in spokesperson was very quick to call for actions in this spokesperson was very quick to call for actions in this area spokesperson was very quick to call for actions in this area and spokesperson was very quick to call for actions in this area and there for actions in this area and there has for actions in this area and there has been for actions in this area and there has been some for actions in this area and there has been some criticism for actions in this area and there has been some criticism of for actions in this area and there has been some criticism of that for actions in this area and there has been some criticism of that but has been some criticism of that but I has been some criticism of that but I make has been some criticism of that but I make no has been some criticism of that but I make no apology has been some criticism of that but I make no apology on has been some criticism of that but I make no apology on an has been some criticism of that but I make no apology on an issue has been some criticism of that but I make no apology on an issue for I make no apology on an issue for the I make no apology on an issue for the significance, I make no apology on an issue for the significance, for I make no apology on an issue for the significance, for the I make no apology on an issue for the significance, for the opposition the significance, for the opposition and the significance, for the opposition and the the significance, for the opposition and the National the significance, for the opposition and the National Party the significance, for the opposition and the National Party to the significance, for the opposition and the National Party to hold the significance, for the opposition and the National Party to hold the and the National Party to hold the Government and the National Party to hold the Government to and the National Party to hold the Government to account and the National Party to hold the Government to account on and the National Party to hold the Government to account on it. and the National Party to hold the Government to account on it. I Government to account on it. I regret Government to account on it. I regret that Government to account on it. I regret that at Government to account on it. I regret that at every Government to account on it. I regret that at every single Government to account on it. I regret that at every single step Government to account on it. I regret that at every single step of regret that at every single step of the regret that at every single step of the way regret that at every single step of the way my regret that at every single step of the way my clear regret that at every single step of the way my clear view regret that at every single step of the way my clear view is regret that at every single step of the way my clear view is that regret that at every single step of the way my clear view is that the the way my clear view is that the Government the way my clear view is that the Government has the way my clear view is that the Government has done the way my clear view is that the Government has done too the way my clear view is that the Government has done too little, the way my clear view is that the Government has done too little, too Government has done too little, too late. Government has done too little, too late. We Government has done too little, too late. We have Government has done too little, too late. We have had Government has done too little, too late. We have had comprehensive late. We have had comprehensive analysis late. We have had comprehensive analysis conducted late. We have had comprehensive analysis conducted on late. We have had comprehensive analysis conducted on where late. We have had comprehensive analysis conducted on where the analysis conducted on where the United analysis conducted on where the United Kingdom, analysis conducted on where the United Kingdom, Australia analysis conducted on where the United Kingdom, Australia and analysis conducted on where the United Kingdom, Australia and the United Kingdom, Australia and the United United Kingdom, Australia and the United States United Kingdom, Australia and the United States have United Kingdom, Australia and the United States have been United Kingdom, Australia and the United States have been and United Kingdom, Australia and the United States have been and at United Kingdom, Australia and the United States have been and at every United States have been and at every step United States have been and at every step as United States have been and at every step as they United States have been and at every step as they have United States have been and at every step as they have done United States have been and at every step as they have done thing, United States have been and at every step as they have done thing, we step as they have done thing, we have step as they have done thing, we have been step as they have done thing, we have been several step as they have done thing, we have been several days step as they have done thing, we have been several days behind step as they have done thing, we have been several days behind them. have been several days behind them. I have been several days behind them. I could have been several days behind them. I could run have been several days behind them. I could run through have been several days behind them. I could run through that have been several days behind them. I could run through that in have been several days behind them. I could run through that in some I could run through that in some detail I could run through that in some detail but I could run through that in some detail but I I could run through that in some detail but I simply I could run through that in some detail but I simply want I could run through that in some detail but I simply want to I could run through that in some detail but I simply want to touch I could run through that in some detail but I simply want to touch on detail but I simply want to touch on screening detail but I simply want to touch on screening and detail but I simply want to touch on screening and the detail but I simply want to touch on screening and the many detail but I simply want to touch on screening and the many examples detail but I simply want to touch on screening and the many examples I screening and the many examples I have screening and the many examples I have been screening and the many examples I have been told screening and the many examples I have been told about screening and the many examples I have been told about from screening and the many examples I have been told about from members screening and the many examples I have been told about from members of have been told about from members of my have been told about from members of my Caucus, have been told about from members of my Caucus, from have been told about from members of my Caucus, from members have been told about from members of my Caucus, from members of have been told about from members of my Caucus, from members of the my Caucus, from members of the public my Caucus, from members of the public who my Caucus, from members of the public who have my Caucus, from members of the public who have spoken my Caucus, from members of the public who have spoken to my Caucus, from members of the public who have spoken to me my Caucus, from members of the public who have spoken to me about public who have spoken to me about this public who have spoken to me about this issue. public who have spoken to me about this issue. In public who have spoken to me about this issue. In theory, public who have spoken to me about this issue. In theory, there public who have spoken to me about this issue. In theory, there is this issue. In theory, there is screening this issue. In theory, there is screening happening this issue. In theory, there is screening happening now this issue. In theory, there is screening happening now in this issue. In theory, there is screening happening now in New screening happening now in New Zealand screening happening now in New Zealand on screening happening now in New Zealand on affected screening happening now in New Zealand on affected flights screening happening now in New Zealand on affected flights coming Zealand on affected flights coming to Zealand on affected flights coming to New Zealand on affected flights coming to New Zealand. Zealand on affected flights coming to New Zealand. This Zealand on affected flights coming to New Zealand. This weekend, Zealand on affected flights coming to New Zealand. This weekend, for to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and it to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and it is to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and it is the to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and it is the only to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and it is the only one to New Zealand. This weekend, for example, and it is the only one I example, and it is the only one I will example, and it is the only one I will give, example, and it is the only one I will give, I example, and it is the only one I will give, I talked example, and it is the only one I will give, I talked to example, and it is the only one I will give, I talked to a example, and it is the only one I will give, I talked to a constituent will give, I talked to a constituent of will give, I talked to a constituent of mine will give, I talked to a constituent of mine on will give, I talked to a constituent of mine on the will give, I talked to a constituent of mine on the telephone will give, I talked to a constituent of mine on the telephone who, will give, I talked to a constituent of mine on the telephone who, in of mine on the telephone who, in fact, of mine on the telephone who, in fact, lives of mine on the telephone who, in fact, lives very of mine on the telephone who, in fact, lives very close of mine on the telephone who, in fact, lives very close to of mine on the telephone who, in fact, lives very close to where of mine on the telephone who, in fact, lives very close to where I fact, lives very close to where I live. fact, lives very close to where I live. His fact, lives very close to where I live. His clear fact, lives very close to where I live. His clear view, fact, lives very close to where I live. His clear view, bringing fact, lives very close to where I live. His clear view, bringing his live. His clear view, bringing his family live. His clear view, bringing his family back live. His clear view, bringing his family back from live. His clear view, bringing his family back from a live. His clear view, bringing his family back from a neighbouring family back from a neighbouring province, family back from a neighbouring province, and family back from a neighbouring province, and with family back from a neighbouring province, and with great family back from a neighbouring province, and with great concerns province, and with great concerns about province, and with great concerns about the province, and with great concerns about the affect province, and with great concerns about the affect of province, and with great concerns about the affect of this province, and with great concerns about the affect of this on province, and with great concerns about the affect of this on them, about the affect of this on them, was about the affect of this on them, was that about the affect of this on them, was that there about the affect of this on them, was that there was about the affect of this on them, was that there was nothing about the affect of this on them, was that there was nothing that was that there was nothing that happened was that there was nothing that happened as was that there was nothing that happened as they was that there was nothing that happened as they came was that there was nothing that happened as they came through was that there was nothing that happened as they came through New happened as they came through New Zealand, happened as they came through New Zealand, no happened as they came through New Zealand, no screening, happened as they came through New Zealand, no screening, no happened as they came through New Zealand, no screening, no checks, happened as they came through New Zealand, no screening, no checks, no Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. And Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. And what Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. And what is Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. And what is also Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. And what is also true Zealand, no screening, no checks, no nothing. And what is also true is nothing. And what is also true is that nothing. And what is also true is that as nothing. And what is also true is that as I nothing. And what is also true is that as I rang nothing. And what is also true is that as I rang him nothing. And what is also true is that as I rang him because nothing. And what is also true is that as I rang him because he'd that as I rang him because he'd contracted that as I rang him because he'd contracted my that as I rang him because he'd contracted my office that as I rang him because he'd contracted my office and that as I rang him because he'd contracted my office and I that as I rang him because he'd contracted my office and I think contracted my office and I think I've contracted my office and I think I've met contracted my office and I think I've met him contracted my office and I think I've met him before, contracted my office and I think I've met him before, he contracted my office and I think I've met him before, he was contracted my office and I think I've met him before, he was out contracted my office and I think I've met him before, he was out in I've met him before, he was out in self-isolation I've met him before, he was out in self-isolation in I've met him before, he was out in self-isolation in a I've met him before, he was out in self-isolation in a public I've met him before, he was out in self-isolation in a public space self-isolation in a public space where self-isolation in a public space where many self-isolation in a public space where many other self-isolation in a public space where many other people self-isolation in a public space where many other people were self-isolation in a public space where many other people were and self-isolation in a public space where many other people were and he where many other people were and he made where many other people were and he made quite where many other people were and he made quite clear where many other people were and he made quite clear that where many other people were and he made quite clear that no where many other people were and he made quite clear that no one where many other people were and he made quite clear that no one has made quite clear that no one has contracted made quite clear that no one has contracted him. made quite clear that no one has contracted him. He made quite clear that no one has contracted him. He has made quite clear that no one has contracted him. He has had made quite clear that no one has contracted him. He has had nothing contracted him. He has had nothing happen contracted him. He has had nothing happen in contracted him. He has had nothing happen in relation contracted him. He has had nothing happen in relation to contracted him. He has had nothing happen in relation to that happen in relation to that "self-isolation". happen in relation to that "self-isolation". I happen in relation to that "self-isolation". I suggest happen in relation to that "self-isolation". I suggest that "self-isolation". I suggest that actually "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if we "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if we don't "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if we don't see "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if we don't see harm "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if we don't see harm in "self-isolation". I suggest that actually if we don't see harm in New actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, it actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, it will actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, it will be actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, it will be much actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, it will be much more actually if we don't see harm in New Zealand, it will be much more by Zealand, it will be much more by good Zealand, it will be much more by good luck Zealand, it will be much more by good luck than Zealand, it will be much more by good luck than by Zealand, it will be much more by good luck than by good Zealand, it will be much more by good luck than by good management good luck than by good management and good luck than by good management and good good luck than by good management and good practice good luck than by good management and good practice by good luck than by good management and good practice by the good luck than by good management and good practice by the Government. and good practice by the Government. I and good practice by the Government. I regret and good practice by the Government. I regret to and good practice by the Government. I regret to say and good practice by the Government. I regret to say I and good practice by the Government. I regret to say I don't and good practice by the Government. I regret to say I don't believe and good practice by the Government. I regret to say I don't believe the I regret to say I don't believe the minister I regret to say I don't believe the minister is I regret to say I don't believe the minister is leading I regret to say I don't believe the minister is leading on I regret to say I don't believe the minister is leading on this I regret to say I don't believe the minister is leading on this issue I regret to say I don't believe the minister is leading on this issue in minister is leading on this issue in any minister is leading on this issue in any way, minister is leading on this issue in any way, shape minister is leading on this issue in any way, shape or minister is leading on this issue in any way, shape or form. minister is leading on this issue in any way, shape or form. He minister is leading on this issue in any way, shape or form. He waited any way, shape or form. He waited for any way, shape or form. He waited for the any way, shape or form. He waited for the first any way, shape or form. He waited for the first Cabinet any way, shape or form. He waited for the first Cabinet to any way, shape or form. He waited for the first Cabinet to make for the first Cabinet to make preliminary for the first Cabinet to make preliminary decisions for the first Cabinet to make preliminary decisions on for the first Cabinet to make preliminary decisions on this preliminary decisions on this matter. preliminary decisions on this matter. When preliminary decisions on this matter. When a preliminary decisions on this matter. When a week preliminary decisions on this matter. When a week earlier preliminary decisions on this matter. When a week earlier than matter. When a week earlier than that matter. When a week earlier than that decisions matter. When a week earlier than that decisions should matter. When a week earlier than that decisions should have matter. When a week earlier than that decisions should have been matter. When a week earlier than that decisions should have been made that decisions should have been made on that decisions should have been made on this that decisions should have been made on this incredibly that decisions should have been made on this incredibly significant on this incredibly significant issue. on this incredibly significant issue. I on this incredibly significant issue. I believe on this incredibly significant issue. I believe we on this incredibly significant issue. I believe we must on this incredibly significant issue. I believe we must be on this incredibly significant issue. I believe we must be more issue. I believe we must be more proactive, issue. I believe we must be more proactive, more issue. I believe we must be more proactive, more precautionary, issue. I believe we must be more proactive, more precautionary, in proactive, more precautionary, in the proactive, more precautionary, in the way proactive, more precautionary, in the way we proactive, more precautionary, in the way we handle proactive, more precautionary, in the way we handle this proactive, more precautionary, in the way we handle this issue proactive, more precautionary, in the way we handle this issue of the way we handle this issue of coronavirus. the way we handle this issue of coronavirus. The the way we handle this issue of coronavirus. The minister's the way we handle this issue of coronavirus. The minister's said coronavirus. The minister's said that coronavirus. The minister's said that the coronavirus. The minister's said that the Government, coronavirus. The minister's said that the Government, Ministry coronavirus. The minister's said that the Government, Ministry of that the Government, Ministry of Health, that the Government, Ministry of Health, has that the Government, Ministry of Health, has been that the Government, Ministry of Health, has been measured. that the Government, Ministry of Health, has been measured. I that the Government, Ministry of Health, has been measured. I regret Health, has been measured. I regret to Health, has been measured. I regret to say Health, has been measured. I regret to say I Health, has been measured. I regret to say I think Health, has been measured. I regret to say I think what Health, has been measured. I regret to say I think what he Health, has been measured. I regret to say I think what he really Health, has been measured. I regret to say I think what he really means to say I think what he really means is to say I think what he really means is laid to say I think what he really means is laid back. to say I think what he really means is laid back. Kiwis to say I think what he really means is laid back. Kiwis are to say I think what he really means is laid back. Kiwis are laid to say I think what he really means is laid back. Kiwis are laid back is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on an is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on an issue is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on an issue like is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on an issue like this, is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on an issue like this, that is laid back. Kiwis are laid back but on an issue like this, that is but on an issue like this, that is not but on an issue like this, that is not good but on an issue like this, that is not good enough. but on an issue like this, that is not good enough. I but on an issue like this, that is not good enough. I want but on an issue like this, that is not good enough. I want to but on an issue like this, that is not good enough. I want to record not good enough. I want to record the not good enough. I want to record the Chinese not good enough. I want to record the Chinese community's not good enough. I want to record the Chinese community's very not good enough. I want to record the Chinese community's very clear the Chinese community's very clear outpouring the Chinese community's very clear outpouring of the Chinese community's very clear outpouring of views the Chinese community's very clear outpouring of views and the Chinese community's very clear outpouring of views and concerns the Chinese community's very clear outpouring of views and concerns in outpouring of views and concerns in relation outpouring of views and concerns in relation to outpouring of views and concerns in relation to this outpouring of views and concerns in relation to this throughout outpouring of views and concerns in relation to this throughout New relation to this throughout New Zealand. relation to this throughout New Zealand. They've relation to this throughout New Zealand. They've been relation to this throughout New Zealand. They've been strong, relation to this throughout New Zealand. They've been strong, they Zealand. They've been strong, they have Zealand. They've been strong, they have been Zealand. They've been strong, they have been forthright Zealand. They've been strong, they have been forthright and, Zealand. They've been strong, they have been forthright and, as Zealand. They've been strong, they have been forthright and, as I Zealand. They've been strong, they have been forthright and, as I say, have been forthright and, as I say, they have been forthright and, as I say, they have have been forthright and, as I say, they have been have been forthright and, as I say, they have been concerned have been forthright and, as I say, they have been concerned - have been forthright and, as I say, they have been concerned - deeply they have been concerned - deeply concerned they have been concerned - deeply concerned - they have been concerned - deeply concerned - about they have been concerned - deeply concerned - about the they have been concerned - deeply concerned - about the lack they have been concerned - deeply concerned - about the lack of concerned - about the lack of measure, concerned - about the lack of measure, the concerned - about the lack of measure, the lateness concerned - about the lack of measure, the lateness of concerned - about the lack of measure, the lateness of the measure, the lateness of the measures measure, the lateness of the measures in measure, the lateness of the measures in relation measure, the lateness of the measures in relation to measure, the lateness of the measures in relation to these measures in relation to these matters. measures in relation to these matters. I measures in relation to these matters. I record measures in relation to these matters. I record as measures in relation to these matters. I record as well measures in relation to these matters. I record as well my measures in relation to these matters. I record as well my view matters. I record as well my view that matters. I record as well my view that the matters. I record as well my view that the House matters. I record as well my view that the House agrees matters. I record as well my view that the House agrees with matters. I record as well my view that the House agrees with that that the House agrees with that there that the House agrees with that there is that the House agrees with that there is absolutely that the House agrees with that there is absolutely no that the House agrees with that there is absolutely no room that the House agrees with that there is absolutely no room for there is absolutely no room for racism there is absolutely no room for racism in there is absolutely no room for racism in this there is absolutely no room for racism in this country there is absolutely no room for racism in this country on there is absolutely no room for racism in this country on this there is absolutely no room for racism in this country on this issue racism in this country on this issue in racism in this country on this issue in relation racism in this country on this issue in relation to racism in this country on this issue in relation to our racism in this country on this issue in relation to our Chinese racism in this country on this issue in relation to our Chinese community in relation to our Chinese community who in relation to our Chinese community who are in relation to our Chinese community who are valued in relation to our Chinese community who are valued members in relation to our Chinese community who are valued members of in relation to our Chinese community who are valued members of our who are valued members of our society. who are valued members of our society. I who are valued members of our society. I also who are valued members of our society. I also want who are valued members of our society. I also want to who are valued members of our society. I also want to make who are valued members of our society. I also want to make this society. I also want to make this final society. I also want to make this final point society. I also want to make this final point that society. I also want to make this final point that is society. I also want to make this final point that is wider society. I also want to make this final point that is wider than final point that is wider than health final point that is wider than health when final point that is wider than health when it final point that is wider than health when it comes final point that is wider than health when it comes to final point that is wider than health when it comes to coronavirus. health when it comes to coronavirus. It health when it comes to coronavirus. It is health when it comes to coronavirus. It is quite health when it comes to coronavirus. It is quite clear health when it comes to coronavirus. It is quite clear on health when it comes to coronavirus. It is quite clear on reports health when it comes to coronavirus. It is quite clear on reports that It is quite clear on reports that are It is quite clear on reports that are out It is quite clear on reports that are out in It is quite clear on reports that are out in international It is quite clear on reports that are out in international media It is quite clear on reports that are out in international media about are out in international media about a are out in international media about a very are out in international media about a very significant are out in international media about a very significant shut are out in international media about a very significant shut down a very significant shut down throughout a very significant shut down throughout China a very significant shut down throughout China of a very significant shut down throughout China of manufacturing a very significant shut down throughout China of manufacturing in throughout China of manufacturing in industry. throughout China of manufacturing in industry. There throughout China of manufacturing in industry. There is throughout China of manufacturing in industry. There is undoubtedly throughout China of manufacturing in industry. There is undoubtedly an industry. There is undoubtedly an economic industry. There is undoubtedly an economic effect industry. There is undoubtedly an economic effect that industry. There is undoubtedly an economic effect that will industry. There is undoubtedly an economic effect that will hit industry. There is undoubtedly an economic effect that will hit and industry. There is undoubtedly an economic effect that will hit and is economic effect that will hit and is hitting economic effect that will hit and is hitting this economic effect that will hit and is hitting this country, economic effect that will hit and is hitting this country, even economic effect that will hit and is hitting this country, even today hitting this country, even today where hitting this country, even today where this hitting this country, even today where this issue hitting this country, even today where this issue to hitting this country, even today where this issue to resolve hitting this country, even today where this issue to resolve itself where this issue to resolve itself it where this issue to resolve itself it would where this issue to resolve itself it would not where this issue to resolve itself it would not be where this issue to resolve itself it would not be insignificant. where this issue to resolve itself it would not be insignificant. I it would not be insignificant. I look it would not be insignificant. I look forward it would not be insignificant. I look forward to it would not be insignificant. I look forward to hearing it would not be insignificant. I look forward to hearing very it would not be insignificant. I look forward to hearing very clearly look forward to hearing very clearly from look forward to hearing very clearly from the look forward to hearing very clearly from the Government look forward to hearing very clearly from the Government what look forward to hearing very clearly from the Government what their from the Government what their economic from the Government what their economic strategy from the Government what their economic strategy in from the Government what their economic strategy in relation from the Government what their economic strategy in relation to economic strategy in relation to this economic strategy in relation to this issue, economic strategy in relation to this issue, that economic strategy in relation to this issue, that is economic strategy in relation to this issue, that is a economic strategy in relation to this issue, that is a health economic strategy in relation to this issue, that is a health issue, this issue, that is a health issue, but this issue, that is a health issue, but is this issue, that is a health issue, but is also this issue, that is a health issue, but is also much this issue, that is a health issue, but is also much wider this issue, that is a health issue, but is also much wider and this issue, that is a health issue, but is also much wider and affects but is also much wider and affects our but is also much wider and affects our economy, but is also much wider and affects our economy, is but is also much wider and affects our economy, is and but is also much wider and affects our economy, is and will but is also much wider and affects our economy, is and will be. The The Hon The Hon Dr The Hon Dr David The Hon Dr David Clark The Hon Dr David Clark in The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to respond The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to respond to The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to respond to a The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to respond to a few The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to respond to a few of The Hon Dr David Clark in reply. Just to respond to a few of the Just to respond to a few of the member's Just to respond to a few of the member's points, Just to respond to a few of the member's points, first Just to respond to a few of the member's points, first of Just to respond to a few of the member's points, first of all Just to respond to a few of the member's points, first of all I member's points, first of all I would member's points, first of all I would stress member's points, first of all I would stress that member's points, first of all I would stress that all member's points, first of all I would stress that all decisions member's points, first of all I would stress that all decisions that would stress that all decisions that have would stress that all decisions that have been would stress that all decisions that have been taken would stress that all decisions that have been taken in would stress that all decisions that have been taken in response would stress that all decisions that have been taken in response of would stress that all decisions that have been taken in response of the have been taken in response of the coronavirus have been taken in response of the coronavirus have have been taken in response of the coronavirus have been have been taken in response of the coronavirus have been taken have been taken in response of the coronavirus have been taken with have been taken in response of the coronavirus have been taken with the coronavirus have been taken with the public coronavirus have been taken with the public health coronavirus have been taken with the public health of coronavirus have been taken with the public health of New coronavirus have been taken with the public health of New Zealanders coronavirus have been taken with the public health of New Zealanders and public health of New Zealanders and the public health of New Zealanders and the public public health of New Zealanders and the public safety public health of New Zealanders and the public safety of public health of New Zealanders and the public safety of New public health of New Zealanders and the public safety of New Zealanders the public safety of New Zealanders as the public safety of New Zealanders as our the public safety of New Zealanders as our primary the public safety of New Zealanders as our primary concern. the public safety of New Zealanders as our primary concern. All as our primary concern. All decisions as our primary concern. All decisions have as our primary concern. All decisions have been as our primary concern. All decisions have been taken as our primary concern. All decisions have been taken informed decisions have been taken informed by decisions have been taken informed by the decisions have been taken informed by the science. decisions have been taken informed by the science. The decisions have been taken informed by the science. The advice decisions have been taken informed by the science. The advice that decisions have been taken informed by the science. The advice that we by the science. The advice that we have by the science. The advice that we have received by the science. The advice that we have received from by the science. The advice that we have received from doctors by the science. The advice that we have received from doctors and have received from doctors and clinical have received from doctors and clinical experts have received from doctors and clinical experts has have received from doctors and clinical experts has informed have received from doctors and clinical experts has informed every clinical experts has informed every step clinical experts has informed every step that clinical experts has informed every step that we clinical experts has informed every step that we have clinical experts has informed every step that we have taken. clinical experts has informed every step that we have taken. You clinical experts has informed every step that we have taken. You will step that we have taken. You will see step that we have taken. You will see that step that we have taken. You will see that we step that we have taken. You will see that we have step that we have taken. You will see that we have moved step that we have taken. You will see that we have moved very step that we have taken. You will see that we have moved very quickly see that we have moved very quickly after see that we have moved very quickly after Australia see that we have moved very quickly after Australia to see that we have moved very quickly after Australia to close see that we have moved very quickly after Australia to close our after Australia to close our borders. after Australia to close our borders. Upon after Australia to close our borders. Upon reviewing after Australia to close our borders. Upon reviewing the after Australia to close our borders. Upon reviewing the evidence borders. Upon reviewing the evidence and borders. Upon reviewing the evidence and receiving borders. Upon reviewing the evidence and receiving the borders. Upon reviewing the evidence and receiving the advice borders. Upon reviewing the evidence and receiving the advice from borders. Upon reviewing the evidence and receiving the advice from the and receiving the advice from the experts. and receiving the advice from the experts. And and receiving the advice from the experts. And to and receiving the advice from the experts. And to date and receiving the advice from the experts. And to date I and receiving the advice from the experts. And to date I stress, and receiving the advice from the experts. And to date I stress, in experts. And to date I stress, in this experts. And to date I stress, in this House, experts. And to date I stress, in this House, and experts. And to date I stress, in this House, and members experts. And to date I stress, in this House, and members will experts. And to date I stress, in this House, and members will know this House, and members will know this, this House, and members will know this, that this House, and members will know this, that we this House, and members will know this, that we have this House, and members will know this, that we have not this House, and members will know this, that we have not had this House, and members will know this, that we have not had a this House, and members will know this, that we have not had a single this, that we have not had a single case this, that we have not had a single case of this, that we have not had a single case of the this, that we have not had a single case of the coronavirus this, that we have not had a single case of the coronavirus in this, that we have not had a single case of the coronavirus in New case of the coronavirus in New Zealand case of the coronavirus in New Zealand and case of the coronavirus in New Zealand and we case of the coronavirus in New Zealand and we have, case of the coronavirus in New Zealand and we have, indeed, case of the coronavirus in New Zealand and we have, indeed, only Zealand and we have, indeed, only had Zealand and we have, indeed, only had one Zealand and we have, indeed, only had one case Zealand and we have, indeed, only had one case that Zealand and we have, indeed, only had one case that could Zealand and we have, indeed, only had one case that could have Zealand and we have, indeed, only had one case that could have even had one case that could have even been had one case that could have even been suspected had one case that could have even been suspected to had one case that could have even been suspected to have had one case that could have even been suspected to have met had one case that could have even been suspected to have met the had one case that could have even been suspected to have met the test been suspected to have met the test of been suspected to have met the test of the been suspected to have met the test of the virus been suspected to have met the test of the virus and been suspected to have met the test of the virus and that been suspected to have met the test of the virus and that proved been suspected to have met the test of the virus and that proved to been suspected to have met the test of the virus and that proved to be of the virus and that proved to be negative. of the virus and that proved to be negative. We of the virus and that proved to be negative. We take of the virus and that proved to be negative. We take no of the virus and that proved to be negative. We take no apology of the virus and that proved to be negative. We take no apology though negative. We take no apology though for negative. We take no apology though for taking negative. We take no apology though for taking a negative. We take no apology though for taking a precautionary negative. We take no apology though for taking a precautionary approach for taking a precautionary approach and for taking a precautionary approach and making for taking a precautionary approach and making sure for taking a precautionary approach and making sure that, for taking a precautionary approach and making sure that, for for taking a precautionary approach and making sure that, for example, and making sure that, for example, we and making sure that, for example, we had and making sure that, for example, we had full and making sure that, for example, we had full Cabinet and making sure that, for example, we had full Cabinet consideration and making sure that, for example, we had full Cabinet consideration of we had full Cabinet consideration of the we had full Cabinet consideration of the categorising we had full Cabinet consideration of the categorising of we had full Cabinet consideration of the categorising of the we had full Cabinet consideration of the categorising of the disease. we had full Cabinet consideration of the categorising of the disease. Mr the categorising of the disease. Mr Speaker, the categorising of the disease. Mr Speaker, we the categorising of the disease. Mr Speaker, we have the categorising of the disease. Mr Speaker, we have the the categorising of the disease. Mr Speaker, we have the health the categorising of the disease. Mr Speaker, we have the health pathways Speaker, we have the health pathways in Speaker, we have the health pathways in place. Speaker, we have the health pathways in place. The Speaker, we have the health pathways in place. The doctors Speaker, we have the health pathways in place. The doctors were Speaker, we have the health pathways in place. The doctors were ready Speaker, we have the health pathways in place. The doctors were ready to in place. The doctors were ready to refer. in place. The doctors were ready to refer. The in place. The doctors were ready to refer. The powers in place. The doctors were ready to refer. The powers that in place. The doctors were ready to refer. The powers that we in place. The doctors were ready to refer. The powers that we now in place. The doctors were ready to refer. The powers that we now have refer. The powers that we now have in refer. The powers that we now have in place refer. The powers that we now have in place can refer. The powers that we now have in place can be refer. The powers that we now have in place can be invoked refer. The powers that we now have in place can be invoked at refer. The powers that we now have in place can be invoked at any refer. The powers that we now have in place can be invoked at any time in place can be invoked at any time but in place can be invoked at any time but historically in place can be invoked at any time but historically in in place can be invoked at any time but historically in situations in place can be invoked at any time but historically in situations like but historically in situations like this but historically in situations like this they but historically in situations like this they have but historically in situations like this they have not but historically in situations like this they have not been but historically in situations like this they have not been required this they have not been required because this they have not been required because New this they have not been required because New Zealanders this they have not been required because New Zealanders understand because New Zealanders understand the because New Zealanders understand the importance because New Zealanders understand the importance of because New Zealanders understand the importance of taking because New Zealanders understand the importance of taking care because New Zealanders understand the importance of taking care of the importance of taking care of their the importance of taking care of their friends the importance of taking care of their friends and the importance of taking care of their friends and family the importance of taking care of their friends and family and the importance of taking care of their friends and family and those their friends and family and those that their friends and family and those that are their friends and family and those that are around their friends and family and those that are around them. their friends and family and those that are around them. In their friends and family and those that are around them. In closing, their friends and family and those that are around them. In closing, I that are around them. In closing, I would that are around them. In closing, I would say that are around them. In closing, I would say that that are around them. In closing, I would say that we that are around them. In closing, I would say that we will that are around them. In closing, I would say that we will continue that are around them. In closing, I would say that we will continue to would say that we will continue to review would say that we will continue to review the would say that we will continue to review the situation. would say that we will continue to review the situation. The would say that we will continue to review the situation. The member would say that we will continue to review the situation. The member at review the situation. The member at one review the situation. The member at one point review the situation. The member at one point says review the situation. The member at one point says we review the situation. The member at one point says we should review the situation. The member at one point says we should move review the situation. The member at one point says we should move faster one point says we should move faster and one point says we should move faster and more one point says we should move faster and more stringently, one point says we should move faster and more stringently, at one point says we should move faster and more stringently, at the one point says we should move faster and more stringently, at the other and more stringently, at the other he and more stringently, at the other he acknowledges and more stringently, at the other he acknowledges that and more stringently, at the other he acknowledges that there and more stringently, at the other he acknowledges that there are he acknowledges that there are economic he acknowledges that there are economic effects he acknowledges that there are economic effects of he acknowledges that there are economic effects of this he acknowledges that there are economic effects of this virus economic effects of this virus around economic effects of this virus around the economic effects of this virus around the worm. economic effects of this virus around the worm. We economic effects of this virus around the worm. We are economic effects of this virus around the worm. We are reviewing around the worm. We are reviewing the around the worm. We are reviewing the situation around the worm. We are reviewing the situation because around the worm. We are reviewing the situation because we around the worm. We are reviewing the situation because we do around the worm. We are reviewing the situation because we do not around the worm. We are reviewing the situation because we do not want the situation because we do not want this the situation because we do not want this situation the situation because we do not want this situation to the situation because we do not want this situation to be the situation because we do not want this situation to be in the situation because we do not want this situation to be in place the situation because we do not want this situation to be in place any this situation to be in place any longer this situation to be in place any longer than this situation to be in place any longer than is this situation to be in place any longer than is necessary this situation to be in place any longer than is necessary for this situation to be in place any longer than is necessary for the longer than is necessary for the public longer than is necessary for the public health longer than is necessary for the public health and longer than is necessary for the public health and safety longer than is necessary for the public health and safety of longer than is necessary for the public health and safety of New public health and safety of New Zealanders. public health and safety of New Zealanders. We public health and safety of New Zealanders. We are public health and safety of New Zealanders. We are a public health and safety of New Zealanders. We are a trading public health and safety of New Zealanders. We are a trading nation Zealanders. We are a trading nation and Zealanders. We are a trading nation and we Zealanders. We are a trading nation and we are Zealanders. We are a trading nation and we are concerned Zealanders. We are a trading nation and we are concerned to Zealanders. We are a trading nation and we are concerned to ensure Zealanders. We are a trading nation and we are concerned to ensure that and we are concerned to ensure that we and we are concerned to ensure that we are and we are concerned to ensure that we are doing and we are concerned to ensure that we are doing the and we are concerned to ensure that we are doing the right and we are concerned to ensure that we are doing the right thing and we are concerned to ensure that we are doing the right thing for and we are concerned to ensure that we are doing the right thing for the we are doing the right thing for the health we are doing the right thing for the health of we are doing the right thing for the health of our we are doing the right thing for the health of our people we are doing the right thing for the health of our people and we are doing the right thing for the health of our people and we we are doing the right thing for the health of our people and we will health of our people and we will also health of our people and we will also look health of our people and we will also look to health of our people and we will also look to the health of our people and we will also look to the economy. health of our people and we will also look to the economy. Question also look to the economy. Question No.1. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: Minister of Finance: Does Minister of Finance: Does he Minister of Finance: Does he agree Minister of Finance: Does he agree with Minister of Finance: Does he agree with the Does he agree with the Salvation Does he agree with the Salvation Army's Salvation Army's State Salvation Army's State of Salvation Army's State of the Salvation Army's State of the Nation Salvation Army's State of the Nation Report, State of the Nation Report, which State of the Nation Report, which said State of the Nation Report, which said that which said that "despite which said that "despite some which said that "despite some significant which said that "despite some significant progress, "despite some significant progress, much "despite some significant progress, much more "despite some significant progress, much more needs "despite some significant progress, much more needs to "despite some significant progress, much more needs to be "despite some significant progress, much more needs to be done much more needs to be done to much more needs to be done to ensure much more needs to be done to ensure the much more needs to be done to ensure the growing much more needs to be done to ensure the growing prosperity to ensure the growing prosperity of to ensure the growing prosperity of our to ensure the growing prosperity of our economy of our economy is of our economy is shared of our economy is shared more of our economy is shared more fairly"? I I agree I agree with I agree with the I agree with the Salvation I agree with the Salvation Army I agree with the Salvation Army report I agree with the Salvation Army report when I agree with the Salvation Army report when it I agree with the Salvation Army report when it says I agree with the Salvation Army report when it says and I agree with the Salvation Army report when it says and I I agree with the Salvation Army report when it says and I quote, report when it says and I quote, "This report when it says and I quote, "This report report when it says and I quote, "This report points report when it says and I quote, "This report points to report when it says and I quote, "This report points to significant "This report points to significant progress, "This report points to significant progress, including "This report points to significant progress, including an "This report points to significant progress, including an increase "This report points to significant progress, including an increase in progress, including an increase in average progress, including an increase in average incomes, progress, including an increase in average incomes, a progress, including an increase in average incomes, a much-needed progress, including an increase in average incomes, a much-needed extra average incomes, a much-needed extra spend average incomes, a much-needed extra spend on average incomes, a much-needed extra spend on welfare average incomes, a much-needed extra spend on welfare and average incomes, a much-needed extra spend on welfare and hardship, spend on welfare and hardship, support spend on welfare and hardship, support for spend on welfare and hardship, support for beneficiaries, spend on welfare and hardship, support for beneficiaries, a spend on welfare and hardship, support for beneficiaries, a decline support for beneficiaries, a decline in support for beneficiaries, a decline in offending support for beneficiaries, a decline in offending and support for beneficiaries, a decline in offending and imprisonment support for beneficiaries, a decline in offending and imprisonment rates, in offending and imprisonment rates, an in offending and imprisonment rates, an increase in offending and imprisonment rates, an increase in in offending and imprisonment rates, an increase in the in offending and imprisonment rates, an increase in the number in offending and imprisonment rates, an increase in the number of in offending and imprisonment rates, an increase in the number of social an increase in the number of social houses an increase in the number of social houses and an increase in the number of social houses and new an increase in the number of social houses and new house an increase in the number of social houses and new house builds an increase in the number of social houses and new house builds at an increase in the number of social houses and new house builds at a houses and new house builds at a 45-year houses and new house builds at a 45-year high." houses and new house builds at a 45-year high." I houses and new house builds at a 45-year high." I do houses and new house builds at a 45-year high." I do acknowledge houses and new house builds at a 45-year high." I do acknowledge that 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is more 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is more that 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is more that we 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is more that we can 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is more that we can do 45-year high." I do acknowledge that there is more that we can do and there is more that we can do and this there is more that we can do and this Government there is more that we can do and this Government remains there is more that we can do and this Government remains committed there is more that we can do and this Government remains committed to this Government remains committed to ensuring this Government remains committed to ensuring that this Government remains committed to ensuring that all this Government remains committed to ensuring that all New this Government remains committed to ensuring that all New Zealanders this Government remains committed to ensuring that all New Zealanders get ensuring that all New Zealanders get their ensuring that all New Zealanders get their fair ensuring that all New Zealanders get their fair share ensuring that all New Zealanders get their fair share of ensuring that all New Zealanders get their fair share of the ensuring that all New Zealanders get their fair share of the benefits ensuring that all New Zealanders get their fair share of the benefits of their fair share of the benefits of economic their fair share of the benefits of economic growth. their fair share of the benefits of economic growth. Does their fair share of the benefits of economic growth. Does he their fair share of the benefits of economic growth. Does he agree their fair share of the benefits of economic growth. Does he agree with economic growth. Does he agree with the economic growth. Does he agree with the Salvation economic growth. Does he agree with the Salvation Army economic growth. Does he agree with the Salvation Army report economic growth. Does he agree with the Salvation Army report that economic growth. Does he agree with the Salvation Army report that this the Salvation Army report that this Government the Salvation Army report that this Government has the Salvation Army report that this Government has taken, the Salvation Army report that this Government has taken, "The the Salvation Army report that this Government has taken, "The first Government has taken, "The first steps Government has taken, "The first steps towards Government has taken, "The first steps towards the Government has taken, "The first steps towards the society-wide steps towards the society-wide change steps towards the society-wide change that steps towards the society-wide change that is steps towards the society-wide change that is needed" steps towards the society-wide change that is needed" and steps towards the society-wide change that is needed" and if steps towards the society-wide change that is needed" and if so, change that is needed" and if so, what change that is needed" and if so, what are change that is needed" and if so, what are the change that is needed" and if so, what are the next change that is needed" and if so, what are the next steps change that is needed" and if so, what are the next steps to change that is needed" and if so, what are the next steps to share what are the next steps to share Aotearoa's what are the next steps to share Aotearoa's prosperity what are the next steps to share Aotearoa's prosperity more what are the next steps to share Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Yes, Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Yes, the Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Yes, the Government Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Yes, the Government is Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Yes, the Government is committed Aotearoa's prosperity more fairly? Yes, the Government is committed to Yes, the Government is committed to improving Yes, the Government is committed to improving the Yes, the Government is committed to improving the living Yes, the Government is committed to improving the living standards Yes, the Government is committed to improving the living standards and improving the living standards and wellbeing improving the living standards and wellbeing of improving the living standards and wellbeing of all improving the living standards and wellbeing of all New improving the living standards and wellbeing of all New Zealanders. improving the living standards and wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In this wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In this year's wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In this year's Wellbeing wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In this year's Wellbeing Budget wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In this year's Wellbeing Budget we wellbeing of all New Zealanders. In this year's Wellbeing Budget we saw this year's Wellbeing Budget we saw significant this year's Wellbeing Budget we saw significant investments this year's Wellbeing Budget we saw significant investments to this year's Wellbeing Budget we saw significant investments to make this year's Wellbeing Budget we saw significant investments to make sure significant investments to make sure New significant investments to make sure New Zealanders significant investments to make sure New Zealanders see significant investments to make sure New Zealanders see their significant investments to make sure New Zealanders see their fair significant investments to make sure New Zealanders see their fair share New Zealanders see their fair share of New Zealanders see their fair share of prosperity. New Zealanders see their fair share of prosperity. I New Zealanders see their fair share of prosperity. I will New Zealanders see their fair share of prosperity. I will point New Zealanders see their fair share of prosperity. I will point to New Zealanders see their fair share of prosperity. I will point to just of prosperity. I will point to just a of prosperity. I will point to just a couple of prosperity. I will point to just a couple of of prosperity. I will point to just a couple of those of prosperity. I will point to just a couple of those including of prosperity. I will point to just a couple of those including the a couple of those including the indexation a couple of those including the indexation of a couple of those including the indexation of main a couple of those including the indexation of main benefits a couple of those including the indexation of main benefits to a couple of those including the indexation of main benefits to wages indexation of main benefits to wages and indexation of main benefits to wages and lifts indexation of main benefits to wages and lifts in indexation of main benefits to wages and lifts in the indexation of main benefits to wages and lifts in the abatement indexation of main benefits to wages and lifts in the abatement rate. indexation of main benefits to wages and lifts in the abatement rate. In and lifts in the abatement rate. In this and lifts in the abatement rate. In this year's and lifts in the abatement rate. In this year's budget and lifts in the abatement rate. In this year's budget there and lifts in the abatement rate. In this year's budget there will and lifts in the abatement rate. In this year's budget there will be this year's budget there will be five this year's budget there will be five priorities this year's budget there will be five priorities all this year's budget there will be five priorities all of this year's budget there will be five priorities all of which this year's budget there will be five priorities all of which will five priorities all of which will support five priorities all of which will support that five priorities all of which will support that including five priorities all of which will support that including the five priorities all of which will support that including the just support that including the just transition, support that including the just transition, future support that including the just transition, future of support that including the just transition, future of work support that including the just transition, future of work work transition, future of work work particularly transition, future of work work particularly around transition, future of work work particularly around living transition, future of work work particularly around living Maori transition, future of work work particularly around living Maori and particularly around living Maori and Pacific particularly around living Maori and Pacific incomes, particularly around living Maori and Pacific incomes, stills particularly around living Maori and Pacific incomes, stills and Pacific incomes, stills and opportunities Pacific incomes, stills and opportunities and Pacific incomes, stills and opportunities and reducing Pacific incomes, stills and opportunities and reducing child opportunities and reducing child poverty opportunities and reducing child poverty and opportunities and reducing child poverty and child opportunities and reducing child poverty and child wellbeing. opportunities and reducing child poverty and child wellbeing. We opportunities and reducing child poverty and child wellbeing. We are poverty and child wellbeing. We are making poverty and child wellbeing. We are making significant poverty and child wellbeing. We are making significant investments poverty and child wellbeing. We are making significant investments in making significant investments in all making significant investments in all these making significant investments in all these areas making significant investments in all these areas and making significant investments in all these areas and we making significant investments in all these areas and we must making significant investments in all these areas and we must continue all these areas and we must continue to all these areas and we must continue to do all these areas and we must continue to do so. all these areas and we must continue to do so. Can all these areas and we must continue to do so. Can people all these areas and we must continue to do so. Can people struggling all these areas and we must continue to do so. Can people struggling in to do so. Can people struggling in our to do so. Can people struggling in our communities to do so. Can people struggling in our communities be to do so. Can people struggling in our communities be confident to do so. Can people struggling in our communities be confident this our communities be confident this Government our communities be confident this Government recognises our communities be confident this Government recognises the our communities be confident this Government recognises the need our communities be confident this Government recognises the need to Government recognises the need to urgently Government recognises the need to urgently increase Government recognises the need to urgently increase incomes Government recognises the need to urgently increase incomes and Government recognises the need to urgently increase incomes and that urgently increase incomes and that he's urgently increase incomes and that he's listening urgently increase incomes and that he's listening to urgently increase incomes and that he's listening to the urgently increase incomes and that he's listening to the evidence he's listening to the evidence presented he's listening to the evidence presented by he's listening to the evidence presented by exports he's listening to the evidence presented by exports like he's listening to the evidence presented by exports like the presented by exports like the welfare presented by exports like the welfare expert presented by exports like the welfare expert advisory presented by exports like the welfare expert advisory group presented by exports like the welfare expert advisory group and welfare expert advisory group and the welfare expert advisory group and the Salvation welfare expert advisory group and the Salvation Army welfare expert advisory group and the Salvation Army report welfare expert advisory group and the Salvation Army report about welfare expert advisory group and the Salvation Army report about ways the Salvation Army report about ways to the Salvation Army report about ways to achieve the Salvation Army report about ways to achieve this? the Salvation Army report about ways to achieve this? In the Salvation Army report about ways to achieve this? In answer the Salvation Army report about ways to achieve this? In answer to the Salvation Army report about ways to achieve this? In answer to the to achieve this? In answer to the second to achieve this? In answer to the second part to achieve this? In answer to the second part of to achieve this? In answer to the second part of that to achieve this? In answer to the second part of that question, second part of that question, absolutely. second part of that question, absolutely. I second part of that question, absolutely. I have second part of that question, absolutely. I have a second part of that question, absolutely. I have a great second part of that question, absolutely. I have a great deal second part of that question, absolutely. I have a great deal of absolutely. I have a great deal of respect absolutely. I have a great deal of respect for absolutely. I have a great deal of respect for both absolutely. I have a great deal of respect for both the absolutely. I have a great deal of respect for both the Salvation absolutely. I have a great deal of respect for both the Salvation Army respect for both the Salvation Army for respect for both the Salvation Army for their respect for both the Salvation Army for their work respect for both the Salvation Army for their work in respect for both the Salvation Army for their work in in respect for both the Salvation Army for their work in in area respect for both the Salvation Army for their work in in area and respect for both the Salvation Army for their work in in area and the for their work in in area and the WEAG for their work in in area and the WEAG report. for their work in in area and the WEAG report. We for their work in in area and the WEAG report. We are for their work in in area and the WEAG report. We are at for their work in in area and the WEAG report. We are at a for their work in in area and the WEAG report. We are at a time for their work in in area and the WEAG report. We are at a time where WEAG report. We are at a time where incomes WEAG report. We are at a time where incomes are WEAG report. We are at a time where incomes are growing. WEAG report. We are at a time where incomes are growing. We WEAG report. We are at a time where incomes are growing. We see WEAG report. We are at a time where incomes are growing. We see wage incomes are growing. We see wage growth incomes are growing. We see wage growth at incomes are growing. We see wage growth at its incomes are growing. We see wage growth at its highest incomes are growing. We see wage growth at its highest level. incomes are growing. We see wage growth at its highest level. We incomes are growing. We see wage growth at its highest level. We see growth at its highest level. We see the growth at its highest level. We see the minimum growth at its highest level. We see the minimum wage growth at its highest level. We see the minimum wage rising, growth at its highest level. We see the minimum wage rising, we growth at its highest level. We see the minimum wage rising, we see the minimum wage rising, we see settlements the minimum wage rising, we see settlements across the minimum wage rising, we see settlements across the the minimum wage rising, we see settlements across the public the minimum wage rising, we see settlements across the public sector settlements across the public sector and settlements across the public sector and state settlements across the public sector and state sector settlements across the public sector and state sector supporting settlements across the public sector and state sector supporting those settlements across the public sector and state sector supporting those on and state sector supporting those on middle and state sector supporting those on middle and and state sector supporting those on middle and low and state sector supporting those on middle and low incomes and state sector supporting those on middle and low incomes as and state sector supporting those on middle and low incomes as well. and state sector supporting those on middle and low incomes as well. We middle and low incomes as well. We are middle and low incomes as well. We are committed middle and low incomes as well. We are committed to middle and low incomes as well. We are committed to seeing middle and low incomes as well. We are committed to seeing wages middle and low incomes as well. We are committed to seeing wages rise are committed to seeing wages rise in are committed to seeing wages rise in New are committed to seeing wages rise in New Zealand are committed to seeing wages rise in New Zealand and are committed to seeing wages rise in New Zealand and incomes are committed to seeing wages rise in New Zealand and incomes across in New Zealand and incomes across the in New Zealand and incomes across the board in New Zealand and incomes across the board rise in New Zealand and incomes across the board rise and in New Zealand and incomes across the board rise and I in New Zealand and incomes across the board rise and I believe in New Zealand and incomes across the board rise and I believe we in New Zealand and incomes across the board rise and I believe we are the board rise and I believe we are seeing the board rise and I believe we are seeing evidence the board rise and I believe we are seeing evidence of the board rise and I believe we are seeing evidence of that. the board rise and I believe we are seeing evidence of that. Ace the board rise and I believe we are seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, will seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, will he seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, will he be seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, will he be looking seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, will he be looking to seeing evidence of that. Ace Finance Minister, will he be looking to use Minister, will he be looking to use Budget Minister, will he be looking to use Budget 2020 Minister, will he be looking to use Budget 2020 to Minister, will he be looking to use Budget 2020 to deliver Minister, will he be looking to use Budget 2020 to deliver on Minister, will he be looking to use Budget 2020 to deliver on the Budget 2020 to deliver on the Welfare Budget 2020 to deliver on the Welfare Expert Budget 2020 to deliver on the Welfare Expert Advisory Budget 2020 to deliver on the Welfare Expert Advisory Group's Welfare Expert Advisory Group's recommendation Welfare Expert Advisory Group's recommendation to Welfare Expert Advisory Group's recommendation to raise Welfare Expert Advisory Group's recommendation to raise core Welfare Expert Advisory Group's recommendation to raise core benefit recommendation to raise core benefit levels? recommendation to raise core benefit levels? As recommendation to raise core benefit levels? As the recommendation to raise core benefit levels? As the member recommendation to raise core benefit levels? As the member knows recommendation to raise core benefit levels? As the member knows we recommendation to raise core benefit levels? As the member knows we don't levels? As the member knows we don't comment levels? As the member knows we don't comment on levels? As the member knows we don't comment on the levels? As the member knows we don't comment on the Budget levels? As the member knows we don't comment on the Budget outcomes levels? As the member knows we don't comment on the Budget outcomes until comment on the Budget outcomes until they comment on the Budget outcomes until they are comment on the Budget outcomes until they are completed comment on the Budget outcomes until they are completed but comment on the Budget outcomes until they are completed but it comment on the Budget outcomes until they are completed but it does comment on the Budget outcomes until they are completed but it does give they are completed but it does give me they are completed but it does give me the they are completed but it does give me the opportunity they are completed but it does give me the opportunity to they are completed but it does give me the opportunity to say they are completed but it does give me the opportunity to say to they are completed but it does give me the opportunity to say to the me the opportunity to say to the House me the opportunity to say to the House today me the opportunity to say to the House today that me the opportunity to say to the House today that the me the opportunity to say to the House today that the budget me the opportunity to say to the House today that the budget will me the opportunity to say to the House today that the budget will be House today that the budget will be delivered House today that the budget will be delivered on House today that the budget will be delivered on Thursday House today that the budget will be delivered on Thursday 14 House today that the budget will be delivered on Thursday 14 May. House today that the budget will be delivered on Thursday 14 May. Does delivered on Thursday 14 May. Does the delivered on Thursday 14 May. Does the minister delivered on Thursday 14 May. Does the minister understand delivered on Thursday 14 May. Does the minister understand that delivered on Thursday 14 May. Does the minister understand that some the minister understand that some people the minister understand that some people had the minister understand that some people had hoped the minister understand that some people had hoped to the minister understand that some people had hoped to see the minister understand that some people had hoped to see more the minister understand that some people had hoped to see more action people had hoped to see more action from people had hoped to see more action from the people had hoped to see more action from the Government people had hoped to see more action from the Government to people had hoped to see more action from the Government to reduce people had hoped to see more action from the Government to reduce income from the Government to reduce income inequality from the Government to reduce income inequality given from the Government to reduce income inequality given unemployment from the Government to reduce income inequality given unemployment is from the Government to reduce income inequality given unemployment is at inequality given unemployment is at a inequality given unemployment is at a record inequality given unemployment is at a record low inequality given unemployment is at a record low and inequality given unemployment is at a record low and the inequality given unemployment is at a record low and the Crown's a record low and the Crown's accounts a record low and the Crown's accounts are a record low and the Crown's accounts are in a record low and the Crown's accounts are in good a record low and the Crown's accounts are in good shape a record low and the Crown's accounts are in good shape yet a record low and the Crown's accounts are in good shape yet too accounts are in good shape yet too many accounts are in good shape yet too many families accounts are in good shape yet too many families are accounts are in good shape yet too many families are still accounts are in good shape yet too many families are still doing accounts are in good shape yet too many families are still doing it many families are still doing it many families are still doing it many families are still doing it tough? It's many families are still doing it tough? It's always many families are still doing it tough? It's always my many families are still doing it tough? It's always my expectation tough? It's always my expectation that tough? It's always my expectation that the tough? It's always my expectation that the public tough? It's always my expectation that the public will tough? It's always my expectation that the public will have tough? It's always my expectation that the public will have high that the public will have high expectations that the public will have high expectations of that the public will have high expectations of the that the public will have high expectations of the Government that the public will have high expectations of the Government but that the public will have high expectations of the Government but I expectations of the Government but I am expectations of the Government but I am extremely expectations of the Government but I am extremely proud expectations of the Government but I am extremely proud of expectations of the Government but I am extremely proud of the expectations of the Government but I am extremely proud of the record expectations of the Government but I am extremely proud of the record of am extremely proud of the record of this am extremely proud of the record of this Government am extremely proud of the record of this Government in am extremely proud of the record of this Government in delivering am extremely proud of the record of this Government in delivering to this Government in delivering to low- this Government in delivering to low- and this Government in delivering to low- and middle-income this Government in delivering to low- and middle-income New low- and middle-income New Zealanders low- and middle-income New Zealanders and low- and middle-income New Zealanders and I low- and middle-income New Zealanders and I can't low- and middle-income New Zealanders and I can't think low- and middle-income New Zealanders and I can't think of Zealanders and I can't think of anything Zealanders and I can't think of anything better Zealanders and I can't think of anything better to Zealanders and I can't think of anything better to evidence Zealanders and I can't think of anything better to evidence that anything better to evidence that than anything better to evidence that than the anything better to evidence that than the Families anything better to evidence that than the Families Package anything better to evidence that than the Families Package where anything better to evidence that than the Families Package where we than the Families Package where we turned than the Families Package where we turned around than the Families Package where we turned around a than the Families Package where we turned around a set than the Families Package where we turned around a set of than the Families Package where we turned around a set of tax than the Families Package where we turned around a set of tax cuts than the Families Package where we turned around a set of tax cuts that turned around a set of tax cuts that would turned around a set of tax cuts that would have turned around a set of tax cuts that would have disproportionately would have disproportionately benefited would have disproportionately benefited the would have disproportionately benefited the highest would have disproportionately benefited the highest income would have disproportionately benefited the highest income earners benefited the highest income earners in benefited the highest income earners in New benefited the highest income earners in New Zealand benefited the highest income earners in New Zealand to benefited the highest income earners in New Zealand to ensure benefited the highest income earners in New Zealand to ensure that benefited the highest income earners in New Zealand to ensure that we in New Zealand to ensure that we delivered in New Zealand to ensure that we delivered to in New Zealand to ensure that we delivered to low- in New Zealand to ensure that we delivered to low- and in New Zealand to ensure that we delivered to low- and middle-income delivered to low- and middle-income earners. delivered to low- and middle-income earners. <INTERRUPTION> earners. <INTERRUPTION> Homelessness earners. <INTERRUPTION> Homelessness has earners. <INTERRUPTION> Homelessness has tripled! earners. <INTERRUPTION> Homelessness has tripled! Question Homelessness has tripled! Question No. Homelessness has tripled! Question No. 2 Homelessness has tripled! Question No. 2 The. Homelessness Homelessness has Homelessness has tripled! Homelessness has tripled! Question Homelessness has tripled! Question No. Homelessness has tripled! Question No. 2 Homelessness has tripled! Question No. 2 The. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: Prime Minister: Does Prime Minister: Does she Prime Minister: Does she stand Prime Minister: Does she stand by Prime Minister: Does she stand by all Prime Minister: Does she stand by all her Does she stand by all her Government's Does she stand by all her Government's statements Does she stand by all her Government's statements and Does she stand by all her Government's statements and actions? Yes, Yes, particularly Yes, particularly the Yes, particularly the Government's Yes, particularly the Government's $12 Yes, particularly the Government's $12 billion Yes, particularly the Government's $12 billion New Yes, particularly the Government's $12 billion New Zealand Yes, particularly the Government's $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme which $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme which will $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme which will see $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme which will see road, $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme which will see road, rail, Programme which will see road, rail, schools Programme which will see road, rail, schools and Programme which will see road, rail, schools and hospitals Programme which will see road, rail, schools and hospitals built Programme which will see road, rail, schools and hospitals built or schools and hospitals built or upgraded schools and hospitals built or upgraded throughout schools and hospitals built or upgraded throughout New schools and hospitals built or upgraded throughout New Zealand. upgraded throughout New Zealand. Even upgraded throughout New Zealand. Even though upgraded throughout New Zealand. Even though we upgraded throughout New Zealand. Even though we only upgraded throughout New Zealand. Even though we only recently upgraded throughout New Zealand. Even though we only recently made Even though we only recently made the Even though we only recently made the announcement Even though we only recently made the announcement for Even though we only recently made the announcement for schools Even though we only recently made the announcement for schools in the announcement for schools in particular the announcement for schools in particular I'm the announcement for schools in particular I'm hearing the announcement for schools in particular I'm hearing about particular I'm hearing about projects particular I'm hearing about projects that particular I'm hearing about projects that are particular I'm hearing about projects that are already particular I'm hearing about projects that are already under particular I'm hearing about projects that are already under way. projects that are already under way. Can projects that are already under way. Can she projects that are already under way. Can she name projects that are already under way. Can she name one projects that are already under way. Can she name one project projects that are already under way. Can she name one project that projects that are already under way. Can she name one project that is Can she name one project that is already Can she name one project that is already under Can she name one project that is already under way Can she name one project that is already under way from Can she name one project that is already under way from the Can she name one project that is already under way from the $12 already under way from the $12 billion already under way from the $12 billion spend already under way from the $12 billion spend up? already under way from the $12 billion spend up? As already under way from the $12 billion spend up? As I already under way from the $12 billion spend up? As I just billion spend up? As I just mentioned billion spend up? As I just mentioned the billion spend up? As I just mentioned the $400 billion spend up? As I just mentioned the $400 million billion spend up? As I just mentioned the $400 million that billion spend up? As I just mentioned the $400 million that has mentioned the $400 million that has gone mentioned the $400 million that has gone into mentioned the $400 million that has gone into schools, mentioned the $400 million that has gone into schools, we mentioned the $400 million that has gone into schools, we are mentioned the $400 million that has gone into schools, we are already gone into schools, we are already seeing gone into schools, we are already seeing individual gone into schools, we are already seeing individual schooling seeing individual schooling projects, seeing individual schooling projects, I seeing individual schooling projects, I mentioned seeing individual schooling projects, I mentioned Grant projects, I mentioned Grant Robertson's projects, I mentioned Grant Robertson's election projects, I mentioned Grant Robertson's election in projects, I mentioned Grant Robertson's election in one, projects, I mentioned Grant Robertson's election in one, I projects, I mentioned Grant Robertson's election in one, I have Robertson's election in one, I have heard Robertson's election in one, I have heard from Robertson's election in one, I have heard from Chris Robertson's election in one, I have heard from Chris Hipkins Robertson's election in one, I have heard from Chris Hipkins in Robertson's election in one, I have heard from Chris Hipkins in his heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. In heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. In fact, heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. In fact, if heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. In fact, if the heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. In fact, if the member heard from Chris Hipkins in his area. In fact, if the member cares area. In fact, if the member cares to area. In fact, if the member cares to ask area. In fact, if the member cares to ask members area. In fact, if the member cares to ask members on area. In fact, if the member cares to ask members on his area. In fact, if the member cares to ask members on his side, area. In fact, if the member cares to ask members on his side, every to ask members on his side, every single to ask members on his side, every single school to ask members on his side, every single school in to ask members on his side, every single school in their to ask members on his side, every single school in their areas to ask members on his side, every single school in their areas will single school in their areas will have single school in their areas will have a single school in their areas will have a project single school in their areas will have a project that single school in their areas will have a project that they single school in their areas will have a project that they will single school in their areas will have a project that they will be have a project that they will be delivering have a project that they will be delivering with have a project that they will be delivering with that have a project that they will be delivering with that funding. delivering with that funding. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> What <INTERRUPTION> What advice <INTERRUPTION> What advice has <INTERRUPTION> What advice has she <INTERRUPTION> What advice has she received <INTERRUPTION> What advice has she received on <INTERRUPTION> What advice has she received on the What advice has she received on the economic What advice has she received on the economic effect What advice has she received on the economic effect of What advice has she received on the economic effect of coronavirus What advice has she received on the economic effect of coronavirus on economic effect of coronavirus on New economic effect of coronavirus on New Zealand? economic effect of coronavirus on New Zealand? The economic effect of coronavirus on New Zealand? The advice economic effect of coronavirus on New Zealand? The advice that economic effect of coronavirus on New Zealand? The advice that I've New Zealand? The advice that I've seen New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus far New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus far has New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus far has said New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus far has said it New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus far has said it is New Zealand? The advice that I've seen thus far has said it is too seen thus far has said it is too early seen thus far has said it is too early to seen thus far has said it is too early to make seen thus far has said it is too early to make any seen thus far has said it is too early to make any assumptions early to make any assumptions because early to make any assumptions because much early to make any assumptions because much of early to make any assumptions because much of what early to make any assumptions because much of what we early to make any assumptions because much of what we are early to make any assumptions because much of what we are seeing because much of what we are seeing could because much of what we are seeing could well because much of what we are seeing could well be because much of what we are seeing could well be temporary. because much of what we are seeing could well be temporary. In because much of what we are seeing could well be temporary. In tourism could well be temporary. In tourism the could well be temporary. In tourism the question could well be temporary. In tourism the question is could well be temporary. In tourism the question is whether could well be temporary. In tourism the question is whether or could well be temporary. In tourism the question is whether or not could well be temporary. In tourism the question is whether or not the the question is whether or not the 13% the question is whether or not the 13% of the question is whether or not the 13% of tourism the question is whether or not the 13% of tourism we the question is whether or not the 13% of tourism we see the question is whether or not the 13% of tourism we see come the question is whether or not the 13% of tourism we see come in the question is whether or not the 13% of tourism we see come in from 13% of tourism we see come in from the 13% of tourism we see come in from the Chinese 13% of tourism we see come in from the Chinese market 13% of tourism we see come in from the Chinese market will 13% of tourism we see come in from the Chinese market will postpone the Chinese market will postpone their the Chinese market will postpone their visits the Chinese market will postpone their visits or the Chinese market will postpone their visits or whether the Chinese market will postpone their visits or whether or the Chinese market will postpone their visits or whether or not the Chinese market will postpone their visits or whether or not they their visits or whether or not they will their visits or whether or not they will indeed their visits or whether or not they will indeed turn their visits or whether or not they will indeed turn into their visits or whether or not they will indeed turn into cancellations. will indeed turn into cancellations. Regardless will indeed turn into cancellations. Regardless we will indeed turn into cancellations. Regardless we are will indeed turn into cancellations. Regardless we are not will indeed turn into cancellations. Regardless we are not waiting. will indeed turn into cancellations. Regardless we are not waiting. We Regardless we are not waiting. We are Regardless we are not waiting. We are looking Regardless we are not waiting. We are looking at Regardless we are not waiting. We are looking at within Regardless we are not waiting. We are looking at within tourism Regardless we are not waiting. We are looking at within tourism for are looking at within tourism for instance, are looking at within tourism for instance, packaging are looking at within tourism for instance, packaging that are looking at within tourism for instance, packaging that may are looking at within tourism for instance, packaging that may help instance, packaging that may help redirect instance, packaging that may help redirect some instance, packaging that may help redirect some of instance, packaging that may help redirect some of those instance, packaging that may help redirect some of those tourist redirect some of those tourist dollars redirect some of those tourist dollars into redirect some of those tourist dollars into other redirect some of those tourist dollars into other parts redirect some of those tourist dollars into other parts of redirect some of those tourist dollars into other parts of the dollars into other parts of the market, dollars into other parts of the market, even dollars into other parts of the market, even our dollars into other parts of the market, even our domestic dollars into other parts of the market, even our domestic market. dollars into other parts of the market, even our domestic market. We market, even our domestic market. We are market, even our domestic market. We are asking market, even our domestic market. We are asking tourism market, even our domestic market. We are asking tourism to market, even our domestic market. We are asking tourism to work market, even our domestic market. We are asking tourism to work with market, even our domestic market. We are asking tourism to work with IRD are asking tourism to work with IRD for are asking tourism to work with IRD for instance are asking tourism to work with IRD for instance on are asking tourism to work with IRD for instance on provisional are asking tourism to work with IRD for instance on provisional tax for instance on provisional tax relief for instance on provisional tax relief as for instance on provisional tax relief as a for instance on provisional tax relief as a way for instance on provisional tax relief as a way of for instance on provisional tax relief as a way of easing for instance on provisional tax relief as a way of easing the for instance on provisional tax relief as a way of easing the burden relief as a way of easing the burden on relief as a way of easing the burden on the relief as a way of easing the burden on the some relief as a way of easing the burden on the some 100 relief as a way of easing the burden on the some 100 SMEs relief as a way of easing the burden on the some 100 SMEs that relief as a way of easing the burden on the some 100 SMEs that rely on the some 100 SMEs that rely directly on the some 100 SMEs that rely directly on on the some 100 SMEs that rely directly on tourism on the some 100 SMEs that rely directly on tourism that on the some 100 SMEs that rely directly on tourism that comes on the some 100 SMEs that rely directly on tourism that comes in directly on tourism that comes in from directly on tourism that comes in from the directly on tourism that comes in from the Chinese directly on tourism that comes in from the Chinese market from the Chinese market predominantly from the Chinese market predominantly intoing from the Chinese market predominantly intoing Auckland, predominantly intoing Auckland, Rotorua predominantly intoing Auckland, Rotorua and predominantly intoing Auckland, Rotorua and Queenstown. predominantly intoing Auckland, Rotorua and Queenstown. We predominantly intoing Auckland, Rotorua and Queenstown. We have predominantly intoing Auckland, Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the member, Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the member, if Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the member, if he Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the member, if he listened Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the member, if he listened to Rotorua and Queenstown. We have also if the member, if he listened to my if the member, if he listened to my post if the member, if he listened to my post cab, if the member, if he listened to my post cab, we if the member, if he listened to my post cab, we have if the member, if he listened to my post cab, we have taken if the member, if he listened to my post cab, we have taken a if the member, if he listened to my post cab, we have taken a sweep post cab, we have taken a sweep across post cab, we have taken a sweep across forestry, post cab, we have taken a sweep across forestry, in post cab, we have taken a sweep across forestry, in particular post cab, we have taken a sweep across forestry, in particular the across forestry, in particular the rock across forestry, in particular the rock lobster across forestry, in particular the rock lobster industry. across forestry, in particular the rock lobster industry. Those across forestry, in particular the rock lobster industry. Those who across forestry, in particular the rock lobster industry. Those who are rock lobster industry. Those who are seeing rock lobster industry. Those who are seeing direct rock lobster industry. Those who are seeing direct effects rock lobster industry. Those who are seeing direct effects now rock lobster industry. Those who are seeing direct effects now we rock lobster industry. Those who are seeing direct effects now we are seeing direct effects now we are working seeing direct effects now we are working closely seeing direct effects now we are working closely with seeing direct effects now we are working closely with and seeing direct effects now we are working closely with and in seeing direct effects now we are working closely with and in the working closely with and in the education working closely with and in the education sector working closely with and in the education sector we working closely with and in the education sector we have working closely with and in the education sector we have already education sector we have already worked education sector we have already worked with education sector we have already worked with education education sector we have already worked with education to education sector we have already worked with education to extend worked with education to extend visas worked with education to extend visas to worked with education to extend visas to students worked with education to extend visas to students that worked with education to extend visas to students that may worked with education to extend visas to students that may be visas to students that may be affected visas to students that may be affected by visas to students that may be affected by the visas to students that may be affected by the border visas to students that may be affected by the border controls. visas to students that may be affected by the border controls. How affected by the border controls. How significant affected by the border controls. How significant does affected by the border controls. How significant does she affected by the border controls. How significant does she believe affected by the border controls. How significant does she believe the significant does she believe the effect significant does she believe the effect of significant does she believe the effect of coronavirus significant does she believe the effect of coronavirus will significant does she believe the effect of coronavirus will be significant does she believe the effect of coronavirus will be on significant does she believe the effect of coronavirus will be on our effect of coronavirus will be on our economy effect of coronavirus will be on our economy both effect of coronavirus will be on our economy both now effect of coronavirus will be on our economy both now and effect of coronavirus will be on our economy both now and in effect of coronavirus will be on our economy both now and in the effect of coronavirus will be on our economy both now and in the future? economy both now and in the future? As economy both now and in the future? As I economy both now and in the future? As I have economy both now and in the future? As I have said, economy both now and in the future? As I have said, actually economy both now and in the future? As I have said, actually whilst economy both now and in the future? As I have said, actually whilst it As I have said, actually whilst it is As I have said, actually whilst it is difficult As I have said, actually whilst it is difficult for As I have said, actually whilst it is difficult for us As I have said, actually whilst it is difficult for us to As I have said, actually whilst it is difficult for us to quantify As I have said, actually whilst it is difficult for us to quantify it is difficult for us to quantify it now, is difficult for us to quantify it now, it is difficult for us to quantify it now, it is is difficult for us to quantify it now, it is almost is difficult for us to quantify it now, it is almost inevitable. is difficult for us to quantify it now, it is almost inevitable. I is difficult for us to quantify it now, it is almost inevitable. I have now, it is almost inevitable. I have already now, it is almost inevitable. I have already said now, it is almost inevitable. I have already said that now, it is almost inevitable. I have already said that I now, it is almost inevitable. I have already said that I expect now, it is almost inevitable. I have already said that I expect in now, it is almost inevitable. I have already said that I expect in June already said that I expect in June when already said that I expect in June when we already said that I expect in June when we receive already said that I expect in June when we receive the already said that I expect in June when we receive the GDP already said that I expect in June when we receive the GDP results already said that I expect in June when we receive the GDP results that when we receive the GDP results that cover when we receive the GDP results that cover this when we receive the GDP results that cover this period when we receive the GDP results that cover this period I when we receive the GDP results that cover this period I absolutely cover this period I absolutely expect cover this period I absolutely expect for cover this period I absolutely expect for us cover this period I absolutely expect for us to cover this period I absolutely expect for us to see cover this period I absolutely expect for us to see that cover this period I absolutely expect for us to see that reflected expect for us to see that reflected in expect for us to see that reflected in our expect for us to see that reflected in our GDP expect for us to see that reflected in our GDP numbers. expect for us to see that reflected in our GDP numbers. As expect for us to see that reflected in our GDP numbers. As you expect for us to see that reflected in our GDP numbers. As you can in our GDP numbers. As you can imagine, in our GDP numbers. As you can imagine, Mr in our GDP numbers. As you can imagine, Mr Speaker, in our GDP numbers. As you can imagine, Mr Speaker, as in our GDP numbers. As you can imagine, Mr Speaker, as a in our GDP numbers. As you can imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, one imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, one that imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, one that receives imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, one that receives a imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, one that receives a lot imagine, Mr Speaker, as a trading nation, one that receives a lot of nation, one that receives a lot of tourism nation, one that receives a lot of tourism from nation, one that receives a lot of tourism from China, nation, one that receives a lot of tourism from China, one nation, one that receives a lot of tourism from China, one that nation, one that receives a lot of tourism from China, one that has nation, one that receives a lot of tourism from China, one that has an tourism from China, one that has an education tourism from China, one that has an education sector tourism from China, one that has an education sector that tourism from China, one that has an education sector that has tourism from China, one that has an education sector that has a tourism from China, one that has an education sector that has a lot tourism from China, one that has an education sector that has a lot of education sector that has a lot of students education sector that has a lot of students coming education sector that has a lot of students coming in education sector that has a lot of students coming in from education sector that has a lot of students coming in from that education sector that has a lot of students coming in from that market students coming in from that market and students coming in from that market and given students coming in from that market and given China students coming in from that market and given China themselves students coming in from that market and given China themselves have and given China themselves have already and given China themselves have already reflected and given China themselves have already reflected in and given China themselves have already reflected in their and given China themselves have already reflected in their forecast already reflected in their forecast for already reflected in their forecast for GDP already reflected in their forecast for GDP a already reflected in their forecast for GDP a downgrade already reflected in their forecast for GDP a downgrade inevitably already reflected in their forecast for GDP a downgrade inevitably we for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will see for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will see impacts for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will see impacts in for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will see impacts in New for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will see impacts in New Zealand for GDP a downgrade inevitably we will see impacts in New Zealand but will see impacts in New Zealand but we will see impacts in New Zealand but we are will see impacts in New Zealand but we are working will see impacts in New Zealand but we are working to will see impacts in New Zealand but we are working to mitigate will see impacts in New Zealand but we are working to mitigate that will see impacts in New Zealand but we are working to mitigate that to we are working to mitigate that to the we are working to mitigate that to the best we are working to mitigate that to the best of we are working to mitigate that to the best of our we are working to mitigate that to the best of our ability. we are working to mitigate that to the best of our ability. What we are working to mitigate that to the best of our ability. What does the best of our ability. What does she the best of our ability. What does she believe the best of our ability. What does she believe the the best of our ability. What does she believe the Government's she believe the Government's response she believe the Government's response to she believe the Government's response to the she believe the Government's response to the economic she believe the Government's response to the economic effects she believe the Government's response to the economic effects of response to the economic effects of coronavirus response to the economic effects of coronavirus should response to the economic effects of coronavirus should be, response to the economic effects of coronavirus should be, not response to the economic effects of coronavirus should be, not just response to the economic effects of coronavirus should be, not just in coronavirus should be, not just in tourism coronavirus should be, not just in tourism but coronavirus should be, not just in tourism but in coronavirus should be, not just in tourism but in education coronavirus should be, not just in tourism but in education and coronavirus should be, not just in tourism but in education and primary tourism but in education and primary exports? tourism but in education and primary exports? As tourism but in education and primary exports? As I tourism but in education and primary exports? As I have tourism but in education and primary exports? As I have said, tourism but in education and primary exports? As I have said, at tourism but in education and primary exports? As I have said, at the exports? As I have said, at the moment exports? As I have said, at the moment the exports? As I have said, at the moment the most exports? As I have said, at the moment the most direct exports? As I have said, at the moment the most direct impact exports? As I have said, at the moment the most direct impact we exports? As I have said, at the moment the most direct impact we are moment the most direct impact we are seeing moment the most direct impact we are seeing for moment the most direct impact we are seeing for exports moment the most direct impact we are seeing for exports are moment the most direct impact we are seeing for exports are in moment the most direct impact we are seeing for exports are in the moment the most direct impact we are seeing for exports are in the live seeing for exports are in the live export, seeing for exports are in the live export, MPI seeing for exports are in the live export, MPI have seeing for exports are in the live export, MPI have worked seeing for exports are in the live export, MPI have worked closely seeing for exports are in the live export, MPI have worked closely with export, MPI have worked closely with the export, MPI have worked closely with the rock export, MPI have worked closely with the rock lobster export, MPI have worked closely with the rock lobster industry export, MPI have worked closely with the rock lobster industry to export, MPI have worked closely with the rock lobster industry to allow the rock lobster industry to allow them the rock lobster industry to allow them for the rock lobster industry to allow them for instance, the rock lobster industry to allow them for instance, where the rock lobster industry to allow them for instance, where pots the rock lobster industry to allow them for instance, where pots are the rock lobster industry to allow them for instance, where pots are in them for instance, where pots are in the them for instance, where pots are in the sea, them for instance, where pots are in the sea, where them for instance, where pots are in the sea, where they them for instance, where pots are in the sea, where they have them for instance, where pots are in the sea, where they have been the sea, where they have been collected, the sea, where they have been collected, they the sea, where they have been collected, they are the sea, where they have been collected, they are able the sea, where they have been collected, they are able to the sea, where they have been collected, they are able to be collected, they are able to be released collected, they are able to be released and collected, they are able to be released and alternative collected, they are able to be released and alternative situations released and alternative situations MPI released and alternative situations MPI are released and alternative situations MPI are working released and alternative situations MPI are working in released and alternative situations MPI are working in conjunction released and alternative situations MPI are working in conjunction with MPI are working in conjunction with the MPI are working in conjunction with the industry MPI are working in conjunction with the industry to MPI are working in conjunction with the industry to give MPI are working in conjunction with the industry to give permissions the industry to give permissions where the industry to give permissions where appropriate the industry to give permissions where appropriate for the industry to give permissions where appropriate for release. the industry to give permissions where appropriate for release. At where appropriate for release. At the where appropriate for release. At the moment where appropriate for release. At the moment the where appropriate for release. At the moment the minister where appropriate for release. At the moment the minister for the moment the minister for fisheries the moment the minister for fisheries is the moment the minister for fisheries is consulting the moment the minister for fisheries is consulting on the moment the minister for fisheries is consulting on whether fisheries is consulting on whether or fisheries is consulting on whether or not fisheries is consulting on whether or not their fisheries is consulting on whether or not their take fisheries is consulting on whether or not their take should fisheries is consulting on whether or not their take should be fisheries is consulting on whether or not their take should be carried or not their take should be carried over or not their take should be carried over into or not their take should be carried over into the or not their take should be carried over into the new or not their take should be carried over into the new year. or not their take should be carried over into the new year. That or not their take should be carried over into the new year. That is over into the new year. That is something over into the new year. That is something that over into the new year. That is something that has over into the new year. That is something that has been over into the new year. That is something that has been consulted something that has been consulted on. something that has been consulted on. When something that has been consulted on. When it something that has been consulted on. When it comes something that has been consulted on. When it comes to something that has been consulted on. When it comes to wider something that has been consulted on. When it comes to wider exports, on. When it comes to wider exports, at on. When it comes to wider exports, at the on. When it comes to wider exports, at the moment on. When it comes to wider exports, at the moment logging on. When it comes to wider exports, at the moment logging is on. When it comes to wider exports, at the moment logging is probably at the moment logging is probably the at the moment logging is probably the area at the moment logging is probably the area with at the moment logging is probably the area with the at the moment logging is probably the area with the next at the moment logging is probably the area with the next biggest the area with the next biggest impacts. the area with the next biggest impacts. That the area with the next biggest impacts. That is the area with the next biggest impacts. That is not the area with the next biggest impacts. That is not just impacts. That is not just coronavirus. impacts. That is not just coronavirus. There impacts. That is not just coronavirus. There is impacts. That is not just coronavirus. There is a impacts. That is not just coronavirus. There is a beater coronavirus. There is a beater England coronavirus. There is a beater England in coronavirus. There is a beater England in Europe coronavirus. There is a beater England in Europe which coronavirus. There is a beater England in Europe which is coronavirus. There is a beater England in Europe which is causing coronavirus. There is a beater England in Europe which is causing a England in Europe which is causing a large England in Europe which is causing a large amount England in Europe which is causing a large amount of England in Europe which is causing a large amount of logs England in Europe which is causing a large amount of logs to England in Europe which is causing a large amount of logs to be England in Europe which is causing a large amount of logs to be exported large amount of logs to be exported into large amount of logs to be exported into China. large amount of logs to be exported into China. The large amount of logs to be exported into China. The supply large amount of logs to be exported into China. The supply chain large amount of logs to be exported into China. The supply chain there into China. The supply chain there has into China. The supply chain there has a into China. The supply chain there has a bag into China. The supply chain there has a bag log into China. The supply chain there has a bag log because into China. The supply chain there has a bag log because people into China. The supply chain there has a bag log because people are into China. The supply chain there has a bag log because people are not has a bag log because people are not necessarily has a bag log because people are not necessarily unloading has a bag log because people are not necessarily unloading at has a bag log because people are not necessarily unloading at the has a bag log because people are not necessarily unloading at the port. necessarily unloading at the port. We necessarily unloading at the port. We are necessarily unloading at the port. We are working necessarily unloading at the port. We are working on necessarily unloading at the port. We are working on areas necessarily unloading at the port. We are working on areas most We are working on areas most affected We are working on areas most affected particularly We are working on areas most affected particularly Tairawhiti affected particularly Tairawhiti that affected particularly Tairawhiti that MSD affected particularly Tairawhiti that MSD is affected particularly Tairawhiti that MSD is catering affected particularly Tairawhiti that MSD is catering for affected particularly Tairawhiti that MSD is catering for needs affected particularly Tairawhiti that MSD is catering for needs that that MSD is catering for needs that we that MSD is catering for needs that we might that MSD is catering for needs that we might see that MSD is catering for needs that we might see from that MSD is catering for needs that we might see from contractors that MSD is catering for needs that we might see from contractors in we might see from contractors in harvesting we might see from contractors in harvesting or we might see from contractors in harvesting or also we might see from contractors in harvesting or also whether we might see from contractors in harvesting or also whether or we might see from contractors in harvesting or also whether or not we might see from contractors in harvesting or also whether or not we harvesting or also whether or not we can harvesting or also whether or not we can marry harvesting or also whether or not we can marry up harvesting or also whether or not we can marry up those harvesting or also whether or not we can marry up those feeling harvesting or also whether or not we can marry up those feeling the can marry up those feeling the impact can marry up those feeling the impact to can marry up those feeling the impact to other can marry up those feeling the impact to other parts can marry up those feeling the impact to other parts of can marry up those feeling the impact to other parts of our can marry up those feeling the impact to other parts of our foresty impact to other parts of our foresty industry. impact to other parts of our foresty industry. We impact to other parts of our foresty industry. We are impact to other parts of our foresty industry. We are seeking impact to other parts of our foresty industry. We are seeking to impact to other parts of our foresty industry. We are seeking to be impact to other parts of our foresty industry. We are seeking to be as industry. We are seeking to be as proactive industry. We are seeking to be as proactive as industry. We are seeking to be as proactive as we industry. We are seeking to be as proactive as we can. industry. We are seeking to be as proactive as we can. Given industry. We are seeking to be as proactive as we can. Given the proactive as we can. Given the consensus proactive as we can. Given the consensus reports proactive as we can. Given the consensus reports about proactive as we can. Given the consensus reports about a proactive as we can. Given the consensus reports about a 0.5% proactive as we can. Given the consensus reports about a 0.5% of consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP at consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP at the consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP at the moment, consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP at the moment, that consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP at the moment, that being consensus reports about a 0.5% of GDP at the moment, that being about GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 billion GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 billion and GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 billion and a GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 billion and a $5 GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 billion and a $5 million GDP at the moment, that being about $1.5 billion and a $5 million less $1.5 billion and a $5 million less in $1.5 billion and a $5 million less in revenue, $1.5 billion and a $5 million less in revenue, what $1.5 billion and a $5 million less in revenue, what will $1.5 billion and a $5 million less in revenue, what will that $1.5 billion and a $5 million less in revenue, what will that lower in revenue, what will that lower revenue in revenue, what will that lower revenue have in revenue, what will that lower revenue have on in revenue, what will that lower revenue have on the in revenue, what will that lower revenue have on the effects in revenue, what will that lower revenue have on the effects of in revenue, what will that lower revenue have on the effects of this revenue have on the effects of this year revenue have on the effects of this year and revenue have on the effects of this year and the revenue have on the effects of this year and the budgetary revenue have on the effects of this year and the budgetary process? year and the budgetary process? Those year and the budgetary process? Those are year and the budgetary process? Those are some year and the budgetary process? Those are some of year and the budgetary process? Those are some of the year and the budgetary process? Those are some of the estimated year and the budgetary process? Those are some of the estimated and Those are some of the estimated and assumed Those are some of the estimated and assumed impacts. Those are some of the estimated and assumed impacts. At Those are some of the estimated and assumed impacts. At this Those are some of the estimated and assumed impacts. At this point Those are some of the estimated and assumed impacts. At this point in assumed impacts. At this point in time assumed impacts. At this point in time it assumed impacts. At this point in time it is assumed impacts. At this point in time it is just assumed impacts. At this point in time it is just too assumed impacts. At this point in time it is just too early assumed impacts. At this point in time it is just too early to assumed impacts. At this point in time it is just too early to say. assumed impacts. At this point in time it is just too early to say. We time it is just too early to say. We have time it is just too early to say. We have really time it is just too early to say. We have really until time it is just too early to say. We have really until through time it is just too early to say. We have really until through to time it is just too early to say. We have really until through to April have really until through to April for have really until through to April for some have really until through to April for some parts have really until through to April for some parts of have really until through to April for some parts of the have really until through to April for some parts of the education for some parts of the education sector for some parts of the education sector to for some parts of the education sector to see for some parts of the education sector to see whether for some parts of the education sector to see whether or for some parts of the education sector to see whether or not for some parts of the education sector to see whether or not that sector to see whether or not that will sector to see whether or not that will have sector to see whether or not that will have a sector to see whether or not that will have a long-term sector to see whether or not that will have a long-term impact. will have a long-term impact. Roughly will have a long-term impact. Roughly 59% will have a long-term impact. Roughly 59% of will have a long-term impact. Roughly 59% of the will have a long-term impact. Roughly 59% of the overseas Roughly 59% of the overseas education Roughly 59% of the overseas education market Roughly 59% of the overseas education market have Roughly 59% of the overseas education market have their Roughly 59% of the overseas education market have their students education market have their students already education market have their students already in education market have their students already in New education market have their students already in New Zealand. education market have their students already in New Zealand. Of education market have their students already in New Zealand. Of course education market have their students already in New Zealand. Of course we already in New Zealand. Of course we expect already in New Zealand. Of course we expect for already in New Zealand. Of course we expect for the already in New Zealand. Of course we expect for the university already in New Zealand. Of course we expect for the university sector expect for the university sector that expect for the university sector that even expect for the university sector that even if expect for the university sector that even if delayed expect for the university sector that even if delayed students expect for the university sector that even if delayed students are that even if delayed students are most that even if delayed students are most likely that even if delayed students are most likely to that even if delayed students are most likely to come that even if delayed students are most likely to come if that even if delayed students are most likely to come if border most likely to come if border restrictions most likely to come if border restrictions lift most likely to come if border restrictions lift in most likely to come if border restrictions lift in an most likely to come if border restrictions lift in an appropriate restrictions lift in an appropriate time. restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It is restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It is really restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It is really just restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It is really just too restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It is really just too early restrictions lift in an appropriate time. It is really just too early to time. It is really just too early to say time. It is really just too early to say at time. It is really just too early to say at this time. It is really just too early to say at this point time. It is really just too early to say at this point what time. It is really just too early to say at this point what the time. It is really just too early to say at this point what the wider say at this point what the wider impacts say at this point what the wider impacts will say at this point what the wider impacts will be. say at this point what the wider impacts will be. Question say at this point what the wider impacts will be. Question No.3. impacts impacts will impacts will be. impacts will be. Question impacts will be. Question No.3. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: Prime Minister: Does Prime Minister: Does she Prime Minister: Does she stand Prime Minister: Does she stand by Prime Minister: Does she stand by all Prime Minister: Does she stand by all her Does she stand by all her Government's Does she stand by all her Government's statements Does she stand by all her Government's statements and Does she stand by all her Government's statements and actions? Absolutely, Absolutely, particularly Absolutely, particularly the Absolutely, particularly the 18-page Absolutely, particularly the 18-page comprehensive Absolutely, particularly the 18-page comprehensive statement Absolutely, particularly the 18-page comprehensive statement that Absolutely, particularly the 18-page comprehensive statement that I comprehensive statement that I released comprehensive statement that I released today comprehensive statement that I released today which comprehensive statement that I released today which includes comprehensive statement that I released today which includes a comprehensive statement that I released today which includes a long released today which includes a long list released today which includes a long list of released today which includes a long list of significant released today which includes a long list of significant achievements released today which includes a long list of significant achievements I list of significant achievements I am list of significant achievements I am incredibly list of significant achievements I am incredibly proud list of significant achievements I am incredibly proud of list of significant achievements I am incredibly proud of and list of significant achievements I am incredibly proud of and couldn't am incredibly proud of and couldn't possibly am incredibly proud of and couldn't possibly pack am incredibly proud of and couldn't possibly pack into am incredibly proud of and couldn't possibly pack into a am incredibly proud of and couldn't possibly pack into a mere am incredibly proud of and couldn't possibly pack into a mere 20 possibly pack into a mere 20 minutes. possibly pack into a mere 20 minutes. How possibly pack into a mere 20 minutes. How much possibly pack into a mere 20 minutes. How much of possibly pack into a mere 20 minutes. How much of that possibly pack into a mere 20 minutes. How much of that PM's minutes. How much of that PM's statement minutes. How much of that PM's statement has minutes. How much of that PM's statement has been minutes. How much of that PM's statement has been done minutes. How much of that PM's statement has been done then? minutes. How much of that PM's statement has been done then? If minutes. How much of that PM's statement has been done then? If the statement has been done then? If the member statement has been done then? If the member had statement has been done then? If the member had actually statement has been done then? If the member had actually read statement has been done then? If the member had actually read the statement has been done then? If the member had actually read the report member had actually read the report he member had actually read the report he would member had actually read the report he would have member had actually read the report he would have seen member had actually read the report he would have seen that member had actually read the report he would have seen that it member had actually read the report he would have seen that it is member had actually read the report he would have seen that it is a he would have seen that it is a reflection he would have seen that it is a reflection of he would have seen that it is a reflection of all he would have seen that it is a reflection of all the he would have seen that it is a reflection of all the things he would have seen that it is a reflection of all the things that reflection of all the things that we've reflection of all the things that we've delivered reflection of all the things that we've delivered and reflection of all the things that we've delivered and includes reflection of all the things that we've delivered and includes for we've delivered and includes for instance we've delivered and includes for instance a we've delivered and includes for instance a snapshot we've delivered and includes for instance a snapshot of we've delivered and includes for instance a snapshot of our we've delivered and includes for instance a snapshot of our economic instance a snapshot of our economic record, instance a snapshot of our economic record, 2.7% instance a snapshot of our economic record, 2.7% growth, instance a snapshot of our economic record, 2.7% growth, unemployment instance a snapshot of our economic record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. Of record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. Of course, record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. Of course, we record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. Of course, we are record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. Of course, we are also record, 2.7% growth, unemployment at 4%. Of course, we are also debt 4%. Of course, we are also debt down, 4%. Of course, we are also debt down, 21% 4%. Of course, we are also debt down, 21% lower 4%. Of course, we are also debt down, 21% lower than 4%. Of course, we are also debt down, 21% lower than what 4%. Of course, we are also debt down, 21% lower than what we down, 21% lower than what we inherited. down, 21% lower than what we inherited. Even down, 21% lower than what we inherited. Even when down, 21% lower than what we inherited. Even when you down, 21% lower than what we inherited. Even when you take down, 21% lower than what we inherited. Even when you take into inherited. Even when you take into account inherited. Even when you take into account going inherited. Even when you take into account going out inherited. Even when you take into account going out with inherited. Even when you take into account going out with the inherited. Even when you take into account going out with the upgrade account going out with the upgrade programme account going out with the upgrade programme of account going out with the upgrade programme of $12 account going out with the upgrade programme of $12 billion account going out with the upgrade programme of $12 billion we account going out with the upgrade programme of $12 billion we still programme of $12 billion we still have programme of $12 billion we still have debt programme of $12 billion we still have debt at programme of $12 billion we still have debt at lower programme of $12 billion we still have debt at lower rates programme of $12 billion we still have debt at lower rates than programme of $12 billion we still have debt at lower rates than what have debt at lower rates than what we have debt at lower rates than what we inherited. have debt at lower rates than what we inherited. There's have debt at lower rates than what we inherited. There's a have debt at lower rates than what we inherited. There's a long have debt at lower rates than what we inherited. There's a long list have debt at lower rates than what we inherited. There's a long list in we inherited. There's a long list in there we inherited. There's a long list in there of we inherited. There's a long list in there of achievements we inherited. There's a long list in there of achievements all we inherited. There's a long list in there of achievements all of we inherited. There's a long list in there of achievements all of which there of achievements all of which I'm there of achievements all of which I'm very there of achievements all of which I'm very proud there of achievements all of which I'm very proud of. there of achievements all of which I'm very proud of. What there of achievements all of which I'm very proud of. What is there of achievements all of which I'm very proud of. What is her I'm very proud of. What is her Government I'm very proud of. What is her Government currently I'm very proud of. What is her Government currently doing I'm very proud of. What is her Government currently doing in Government currently doing in relation Government currently doing in relation to Government currently doing in relation to the Government currently doing in relation to the dispute Government currently doing in relation to the dispute at Government currently doing in relation to the dispute at ohu relation to the dispute at ohu marto? relation to the dispute at ohu marto? The relation to the dispute at ohu marto? The member relation to the dispute at ohu marto? The member will relation to the dispute at ohu marto? The member will remember relation to the dispute at ohu marto? The member will remember that marto? The member will remember that in marto? The member will remember that in July marto? The member will remember that in July there marto? The member will remember that in July there was marto? The member will remember that in July there was a marto? The member will remember that in July there was a dispute marto? The member will remember that in July there was a dispute at marto? The member will remember that in July there was a dispute at that in July there was a dispute at that land. in July there was a dispute at that land. It in July there was a dispute at that land. It was in July there was a dispute at that land. It was an in July there was a dispute at that land. It was an agreement in July there was a dispute at that land. It was an agreement between land. It was an agreement between Fletchers land. It was an agreement between Fletchers and land. It was an agreement between Fletchers and mana land. It was an agreement between Fletchers and mana whenua land. It was an agreement between Fletchers and mana whenua that Fletchers and mana whenua that nothing Fletchers and mana whenua that nothing would Fletchers and mana whenua that nothing would happen Fletchers and mana whenua that nothing would happen there Fletchers and mana whenua that nothing would happen there until Fletchers and mana whenua that nothing would happen there until a nothing would happen there until a solution nothing would happen there until a solution was nothing would happen there until a solution was found. nothing would happen there until a solution was found. We nothing would happen there until a solution was found. We have nothing would happen there until a solution was found. We have simply solution was found. We have simply played solution was found. We have simply played a solution was found. We have simply played a role solution was found. We have simply played a role in solution was found. We have simply played a role in assisting solution was found. We have simply played a role in assisting to solution was found. We have simply played a role in assisting to try played a role in assisting to try and played a role in assisting to try and broker played a role in assisting to try and broker that played a role in assisting to try and broker that solution. played a role in assisting to try and broker that solution. I played a role in assisting to try and broker that solution. I would and broker that solution. I would like and broker that solution. I would like to and broker that solution. I would like to think and broker that solution. I would like to think that and broker that solution. I would like to think that that's and broker that solution. I would like to think that that's what like to think that that's what leadership like to think that that's what leadership is. like to think that that's what leadership is. When like to think that that's what leadership is. When she like to think that that's what leadership is. When she said like to think that that's what leadership is. When she said last leadership is. When she said last year leadership is. When she said last year she leadership is. When she said last year she hoped leadership is. When she said last year she hoped it leadership is. When she said last year she hoped it would leadership is. When she said last year she hoped it would be leadership is. When she said last year she hoped it would be resolved year she hoped it would be resolved by year she hoped it would be resolved by Christmas, year she hoped it would be resolved by Christmas, has year she hoped it would be resolved by Christmas, has that year she hoped it would be resolved by Christmas, has that come year she hoped it would be resolved by Christmas, has that come to year she hoped it would be resolved by Christmas, has that come to pass? by Christmas, has that come to pass? It by Christmas, has that come to pass? It is by Christmas, has that come to pass? It is currently by Christmas, has that come to pass? It is currently 12 by Christmas, has that come to pass? It is currently 12 February. by Christmas, has that come to pass? It is currently 12 February. The It is currently 12 February. The member It is currently 12 February. The member will It is currently 12 February. The member will well It is currently 12 February. The member will well be It is currently 12 February. The member will well be aware It is currently 12 February. The member will well be aware we It is currently 12 February. The member will well be aware we have member will well be aware we have past member will well be aware we have past Christmas. member will well be aware we have past Christmas. It member will well be aware we have past Christmas. It has member will well be aware we have past Christmas. It has been member will well be aware we have past Christmas. It has been our past Christmas. It has been our aspiration past Christmas. It has been our aspiration to past Christmas. It has been our aspiration to see past Christmas. It has been our aspiration to see a past Christmas. It has been our aspiration to see a dispute past Christmas. It has been our aspiration to see a dispute like aspiration to see a dispute like that aspiration to see a dispute like that resolved aspiration to see a dispute like that resolved as aspiration to see a dispute like that resolved as soon aspiration to see a dispute like that resolved as soon as aspiration to see a dispute like that resolved as soon as possible. that resolved as soon as possible. That that resolved as soon as possible. That is that resolved as soon as possible. That is in that resolved as soon as possible. That is in everyone's that resolved as soon as possible. That is in everyone's interest. that resolved as soon as possible. That is in everyone's interest. I That is in everyone's interest. I would That is in everyone's interest. I would include That is in everyone's interest. I would include in That is in everyone's interest. I would include in that That is in everyone's interest. I would include in that New That is in everyone's interest. I would include in that New Zealand's would include in that New Zealand's interest would include in that New Zealand's interest and would include in that New Zealand's interest and if would include in that New Zealand's interest and if the would include in that New Zealand's interest and if the member would include in that New Zealand's interest and if the member had would include in that New Zealand's interest and if the member had an interest and if the member had an eye interest and if the member had an eye to interest and if the member had an eye to the interest and if the member had an eye to the kind interest and if the member had an eye to the kind of interest and if the member had an eye to the kind of relations interest and if the member had an eye to the kind of relations that interest and if the member had an eye to the kind of relations that we eye to the kind of relations that we want eye to the kind of relations that we want to eye to the kind of relations that we want to Foster eye to the kind of relations that we want to Foster in eye to the kind of relations that we want to Foster in this eye to the kind of relations that we want to Foster in this country, eye to the kind of relations that we want to Foster in this country, then want to Foster in this country, then that want to Foster in this country, then that member want to Foster in this country, then that member might want to Foster in this country, then that member might look want to Foster in this country, then that member might look for want to Foster in this country, then that member might look for a that member might look for a solution that member might look for a solution as that member might look for a solution as well that member might look for a solution as well rather that member might look for a solution as well rather than that member might look for a solution as well rather than stoking solution as well rather than stoking cheap solution as well rather than stoking cheap politics. solution as well rather than stoking cheap politics. Did solution as well rather than stoking cheap politics. Did she solution as well rather than stoking cheap politics. Did she resolve solution as well rather than stoking cheap politics. Did she resolve it cheap politics. Did she resolve it by cheap politics. Did she resolve it by Waitangi, cheap politics. Did she resolve it by Waitangi, like cheap politics. Did she resolve it by Waitangi, like she cheap politics. Did she resolve it by Waitangi, like she said cheap politics. Did she resolve it by Waitangi, like she said she by Waitangi, like she said she would? by Waitangi, like she said she would? That by Waitangi, like she said she would? That member by Waitangi, like she said she would? That member is by Waitangi, like she said she would? That member is - would? That member is - unfortunately would? That member is - unfortunately has would? That member is - unfortunately has a would? That member is - unfortunately has a poor unfortunately has a poor understanding unfortunately has a poor understanding of unfortunately has a poor understanding of the unfortunately has a poor understanding of the situation. unfortunately has a poor understanding of the situation. If understanding of the situation. If he understanding of the situation. If he believes understanding of the situation. If he believes that understanding of the situation. If he believes that there understanding of the situation. If he believes that there is understanding of the situation. If he believes that there is only understanding of the situation. If he believes that there is only one he believes that there is only one party he believes that there is only one party involved he believes that there is only one party involved in he believes that there is only one party involved in this, he believes that there is only one party involved in this, there he believes that there is only one party involved in this, there is party involved in this, there is mana party involved in this, there is mana whenua, party involved in this, there is mana whenua, there party involved in this, there is mana whenua, there is party involved in this, there is mana whenua, there is the party involved in this, there is mana whenua, there is the private mana whenua, there is the private company mana whenua, there is the private company in mana whenua, there is the private company in Fletchers mana whenua, there is the private company in Fletchers and mana whenua, there is the private company in Fletchers and of mana whenua, there is the private company in Fletchers and of course company in Fletchers and of course we company in Fletchers and of course we are company in Fletchers and of course we are trying company in Fletchers and of course we are trying to company in Fletchers and of course we are trying to play company in Fletchers and of course we are trying to play to company in Fletchers and of course we are trying to play to broker company in Fletchers and of course we are trying to play to broker a we are trying to play to broker a solution. we are trying to play to broker a solution. Will we are trying to play to broker a solution. Will taxpayers' we are trying to play to broker a solution. Will taxpayers' or solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' money solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' money be solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' money be spent solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' money be spent on solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' money be spent on the solution. Will taxpayers' or ratepayers' money be spent on the I ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue marto ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue marto dispute? ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue marto dispute? As ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue marto dispute? As I ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue marto dispute? As I said ratepayers' money be spent on the I hue marto dispute? As I said many hue marto dispute? As I said many times hue marto dispute? As I said many times in hue marto dispute? As I said many times in this hue marto dispute? As I said many times in this House, hue marto dispute? As I said many times in this House, a hue marto dispute? As I said many times in this House, a solution hue marto dispute? As I said many times in this House, a solution is times in this House, a solution is still times in this House, a solution is still yet times in this House, a solution is still yet to times in this House, a solution is still yet to be times in this House, a solution is still yet to be announced times in this House, a solution is still yet to be announced or times in this House, a solution is still yet to be announced or a still yet to be announced or a resolution still yet to be announced or a resolution announced. still yet to be announced or a resolution announced. What still yet to be announced or a resolution announced. What has still yet to be announced or a resolution announced. What has been resolution announced. What has been key resolution announced. What has been key in resolution announced. What has been key in all resolution announced. What has been key in all of resolution announced. What has been key in all of this resolution announced. What has been key in all of this is resolution announced. What has been key in all of this is keeping resolution announced. What has been key in all of this is keeping in key in all of this is keeping in mind key in all of this is keeping in mind that key in all of this is keeping in mind that there key in all of this is keeping in mind that there is key in all of this is keeping in mind that there is a key in all of this is keeping in mind that there is a heritage mind that there is a heritage proposed mind that there is a heritage proposed heritage mind that there is a heritage proposed heritage order mind that there is a heritage proposed heritage order over mind that there is a heritage proposed heritage order over the proposed heritage order over the land. proposed heritage order over the land. That proposed heritage order over the land. That puts proposed heritage order over the land. That puts Fletchers proposed heritage order over the land. That puts Fletchers in proposed heritage order over the land. That puts Fletchers in a proposed heritage order over the land. That puts Fletchers in a very land. That puts Fletchers in a very difficult land. That puts Fletchers in a very difficult position. land. That puts Fletchers in a very difficult position. I land. That puts Fletchers in a very difficult position. I ask land. That puts Fletchers in a very difficult position. I ask the land. That puts Fletchers in a very difficult position. I ask the member difficult position. I ask the member who difficult position. I ask the member who I difficult position. I ask the member who I would difficult position. I ask the member who I would imagine difficult position. I ask the member who I would imagine would difficult position. I ask the member who I would imagine would have difficult position. I ask the member who I would imagine would have an who I would imagine would have an interest who I would imagine would have an interest in who I would imagine would have an interest in that, who I would imagine would have an interest in that, what who I would imagine would have an interest in that, what would who I would imagine would have an interest in that, what would he who I would imagine would have an interest in that, what would he do interest in that, what would he do in interest in that, what would he do in this interest in that, what would he do in this situation interest in that, what would he do in this situation for interest in that, what would he do in this situation for a interest in that, what would he do in this situation for a company interest in that, what would he do in this situation for a company that in this situation for a company that after in this situation for a company that after the in this situation for a company that after the bumbling in this situation for a company that after the bumbling decision in this situation for a company that after the bumbling decision of in this situation for a company that after the bumbling decision of a after the bumbling decision of a housing after the bumbling decision of a housing minister after the bumbling decision of a housing minister that after the bumbling decision of a housing minister that left after the bumbling decision of a housing minister that left the housing minister that left the ministry housing minister that left the ministry situation housing minister that left the ministry situation by housing minister that left the ministry situation by calling housing minister that left the ministry situation by calling it housing minister that left the ministry situation by calling it a ministry situation by calling it a Special ministry situation by calling it a Special Housing ministry situation by calling it a Special Housing Area, ministry situation by calling it a Special Housing Area, what ministry situation by calling it a Special Housing Area, what would Special Housing Area, what would that Special Housing Area, what would that member Special Housing Area, what would that member do Special Housing Area, what would that member do in Special Housing Area, what would that member do in this Special Housing Area, what would that member do in this situation. Special Housing Area, what would that member do in this situation. In that member do in this situation. In lack that member do in this situation. In lack of that member do in this situation. In lack of the that member do in this situation. In lack of the light that member do in this situation. In lack of the light of that member do in this situation. In lack of the light of legal lack of the light of legal significance lack of the light of legal significance around lack of the light of legal significance around the lack of the light of legal significance around the will lack of the light of legal significance around the will status, significance around the will status, why significance around the will status, why is significance around the will status, why is he significance around the will status, why is he considering significance around the will status, why is he considering spending why is he considering spending taxpayers' why is he considering spending taxpayers' money why is he considering spending taxpayers' money on why is he considering spending taxpayers' money on the why is he considering spending taxpayers' money on the Ihumatao taxpayers' money on the Ihumatao dispute. taxpayers' money on the Ihumatao dispute. The taxpayers' money on the Ihumatao dispute. The member's taxpayers' money on the Ihumatao dispute. The member's recollection dispute. The member's recollection of dispute. The member's recollection of the dispute. The member's recollection of the heritage dispute. The member's recollection of the heritage status dispute. The member's recollection of the heritage status and dispute. The member's recollection of the heritage status and its of the heritage status and its effect of the heritage status and its effect is of the heritage status and its effect is inaccurate. of the heritage status and its effect is inaccurate. Does of the heritage status and its effect is inaccurate. Does she effect is inaccurate. Does she believe effect is inaccurate. Does she believe resolution effect is inaccurate. Does she believe resolution of effect is inaccurate. Does she believe resolution of this effect is inaccurate. Does she believe resolution of this dispute believe resolution of this dispute with believe resolution of this dispute with taxpayers' believe resolution of this dispute with taxpayers' money believe resolution of this dispute with taxpayers' money will believe resolution of this dispute with taxpayers' money will encourage with taxpayers' money will encourage more with taxpayers' money will encourage more protests with taxpayers' money will encourage more protests around with taxpayers' money will encourage more protests around New with taxpayers' money will encourage more protests around New Zealand? more protests around New Zealand? That's more protests around New Zealand? That's a more protests around New Zealand? That's a hypothetical. more protests around New Zealand? That's a hypothetical. Does more protests around New Zealand? That's a hypothetical. Does she more protests around New Zealand? That's a hypothetical. Does she mean That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's not That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's not going That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's not going to That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's not going to be That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's not going to be - That's a hypothetical. Does she mean that it's not going to be - the that it's not going to be - the dispute that it's not going to be - the dispute is that it's not going to be - the dispute is not that it's not going to be - the dispute is not going that it's not going to be - the dispute is not going to that it's not going to be - the dispute is not going to be that it's not going to be - the dispute is not going to be resolved? dispute is not going to be resolved? As dispute is not going to be resolved? As I've dispute is not going to be resolved? As I've said dispute is not going to be resolved? As I've said many dispute is not going to be resolved? As I've said many times dispute is not going to be resolved? As I've said many times in dispute is not going to be resolved? As I've said many times in this As I've said many times in this House, As I've said many times in this House, once As I've said many times in this House, once there As I've said many times in this House, once there is As I've said many times in this House, once there is a As I've said many times in this House, once there is a resolution As I've said many times in this House, once there is a resolution I House, once there is a resolution I would House, once there is a resolution I would happily House, once there is a resolution I would happily debate House, once there is a resolution I would happily debate it House, once there is a resolution I would happily debate it with House, once there is a resolution I would happily debate it with that would happily debate it with that member. would happily debate it with that member. I would happily debate it with that member. I would would happily debate it with that member. I would like would happily debate it with that member. I would like to would happily debate it with that member. I would like to see would happily debate it with that member. I would like to see what would happily debate it with that member. I would like to see what his member. I would like to see what his proposals member. I would like to see what his proposals would member. I would like to see what his proposals would be. member. I would like to see what his proposals would be. If member. I would like to see what his proposals would be. If he member. I would like to see what his proposals would be. If he believes member. I would like to see what his proposals would be. If he believes a proposals would be. If he believes a solution proposals would be. If he believes a solution for proposals would be. If he believes a solution for New proposals would be. If he believes a solution for New Zealand proposals would be. If he believes a solution for New Zealand is proposals would be. If he believes a solution for New Zealand is to proposals would be. If he believes a solution for New Zealand is to see solution for New Zealand is to see protests, solution for New Zealand is to see protests, violence solution for New Zealand is to see protests, violence and solution for New Zealand is to see protests, violence and a solution for New Zealand is to see protests, violence and a dispute protests, violence and a dispute continue protests, violence and a dispute continue after protests, violence and a dispute continue after that protests, violence and a dispute continue after that side protests, violence and a dispute continue after that side of protests, violence and a dispute continue after that side of the continue after that side of the House continue after that side of the House declared continue after that side of the House declared this continue after that side of the House declared this a continue after that side of the House declared this a specialising House declared this a specialising housing House declared this a specialising housing area House declared this a specialising housing area without House declared this a specialising housing area without any House declared this a specialising housing area without any plan House declared this a specialising housing area without any plan on housing area without any plan on managing housing area without any plan on managing that, housing area without any plan on managing that, if housing area without any plan on managing that, if that housing area without any plan on managing that, if that that, housing area without any plan on managing that, if that that, if managing that, if that that, if chaos, managing that, if that that, if chaos, protest managing that, if that that, if chaos, protest and managing that, if that that, if chaos, protest and violence managing that, if that that, if chaos, protest and violence is managing that, if that that, if chaos, protest and violence is their chaos, protest and violence is their response chaos, protest and violence is their response to chaos, protest and violence is their response to that chaos, protest and violence is their response to that situation chaos, protest and violence is their response to that situation then chaos, protest and violence is their response to that situation then that response to that situation then that is response to that situation then that is their response to that situation then that is their leader response to that situation then that is their leader of response to that situation then that is their leader of leadership, response to that situation then that is their leader of leadership, they is their leader of leadership, they are is their leader of leadership, they are welcome is their leader of leadership, they are welcome to is their leader of leadership, they are welcome to it. is their leader of leadership, they are welcome to it. So is their leader of leadership, they are welcome to it. So when is their leader of leadership, they are welcome to it. So when will is their leader of leadership, they are welcome to it. So when will this are welcome to it. So when will this be are welcome to it. So when will this be resolved are welcome to it. So when will this be resolved by are welcome to it. So when will this be resolved by the are welcome to it. So when will this be resolved by the PM? are welcome to it. So when will this be resolved by the PM? Again, are welcome to it. So when will this be resolved by the PM? Again, I be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't take be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't take such be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't take such an be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't take such an arrogant be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't take such an arrogant view be resolved by the PM? Again, I don't take such an arrogant view of don't take such an arrogant view of my don't take such an arrogant view of my role don't take such an arrogant view of my role in don't take such an arrogant view of my role in this don't take such an arrogant view of my role in this situation. my role in this situation. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Question <INTERRUPTION> Question No.4. Question Question No.4. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: Minister of Finance: What Minister of Finance: What reports Minister of Finance: What reports has Minister of Finance: What reports has he Minister of Finance: What reports has he seen What reports has he seen on What reports has he seen on the What reports has he seen on the economic What reports has he seen on the economic impact on the economic impact of on the economic impact of the on the economic impact of the New on the economic impact of the New Zealand of the New Zealand Upgrade of the New Zealand Upgrade Programme? I've I've seen I've seen a I've seen a range I've seen a range of I've seen a range of reports I've seen a range of reports from I've seen a range of reports from business I've seen a range of reports from business leaders I've seen a range of reports from business leaders emphasising I've seen a range of reports from business leaders emphasising the business leaders emphasising the significant business leaders emphasising the significant impact business leaders emphasising the significant impact that business leaders emphasising the significant impact that the significant impact that the Government's significant impact that the Government's $12 significant impact that the Government's $12 billion significant impact that the Government's $12 billion New significant impact that the Government's $12 billion New Zealand Government's $12 billion New Zealand Government's Government's $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme will Government's $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme will have Government's $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme will have for Government's $12 billion New Zealand Upgrade Programme will have for the Upgrade Programme will have for the economy Upgrade Programme will have for the economy and Upgrade Programme will have for the economy and for Upgrade Programme will have for the economy and for businesses. economy and for businesses. BusinessNZ economy and for businesses. BusinessNZ chief economy and for businesses. BusinessNZ chief executive economy and for businesses. BusinessNZ chief executive said, BusinessNZ chief executive said, "The BusinessNZ chief executive said, "The additional BusinessNZ chief executive said, "The additional spending BusinessNZ chief executive said, "The additional spending on BusinessNZ chief executive said, "The additional spending on road "The additional spending on road infrastructure "The additional spending on road infrastructure will "The additional spending on road infrastructure will be "The additional spending on road infrastructure will be positive "The additional spending on road infrastructure will be positive for infrastructure will be positive for businesses infrastructure will be positive for businesses while infrastructure will be positive for businesses while money infrastructure will be positive for businesses while money for infrastructure will be positive for businesses while money for rail businesses while money for rail services businesses while money for rail services in businesses while money for rail services in Auckland businesses while money for rail services in Auckland and businesses while money for rail services in Auckland and the services in Auckland and the Wellington services in Auckland and the Wellington region services in Auckland and the Wellington region will services in Auckland and the Wellington region will help services in Auckland and the Wellington region will help build Wellington region will help build efficiency Wellington region will help build efficiency and Wellington region will help build efficiency and efficiency." Wellington region will help build efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher Building efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher Building CEO efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher Building CEO said, efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher Building CEO said, "This efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher Building CEO said, "This isn't efficiency and efficiency." Fletcher Building CEO said, "This isn't just. Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often there Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often there were Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often there were quite Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often there were quite a Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often there were quite a lot Building CEO said, "This isn't just. ..Often there were quite a lot of ..Often there were quite a lot of plans ..Often there were quite a lot of plans and ..Often there were quite a lot of plans and options ..Often there were quite a lot of plans and options for ..Often there were quite a lot of plans and options for projects ..Often there were quite a lot of plans and options for projects with plans and options for projects with price plans and options for projects with price tags plans and options for projects with price tags that plans and options for projects with price tags that might plans and options for projects with price tags that might be plans and options for projects with price tags that might be years plans and options for projects with price tags that might be years away. price tags that might be years away. I price tags that might be years away. I can price tags that might be years away. I can see price tags that might be years away. I can see this price tags that might be years away. I can see this is price tags that might be years away. I can see this is the price tags that might be years away. I can see this is the infrastructure I can see this is the infrastructure which I can see this is the infrastructure which is I can see this is the infrastructure which is needed I can see this is the infrastructure which is needed and I can see this is the infrastructure which is needed and it I can see this is the infrastructure which is needed and it will I can see this is the infrastructure which is needed and it will happen." which is needed and it will happen." I which is needed and it will happen." I am which is needed and it will happen." I am pleased which is needed and it will happen." I am pleased to which is needed and it will happen." I am pleased to be which is needed and it will happen." I am pleased to be part which is needed and it will happen." I am pleased to be part of which is needed and it will happen." I am pleased to be part of a I am pleased to be part of a Government I am pleased to be part of a Government that I am pleased to be part of a Government that is I am pleased to be part of a Government that is getting I am pleased to be part of a Government that is getting on I am pleased to be part of a Government that is getting on with Government that is getting on with the Government that is getting on with the job Government that is getting on with the job of Government that is getting on with the job of addressing Government that is getting on with the job of addressing years Government that is getting on with the job of addressing years of Government that is getting on with the job of addressing years of under the job of addressing years of under investment the job of addressing years of under investment in the job of addressing years of under investment in New the job of addressing years of under investment in New Zealand's investment in New Zealand's infrastructure. investment in New Zealand's infrastructure. What investment in New Zealand's infrastructure. What reports investment in New Zealand's infrastructure. What reports has investment in New Zealand's infrastructure. What reports has he infrastructure. What reports has he seen infrastructure. What reports has he seen on infrastructure. What reports has he seen on the infrastructure. What reports has he seen on the economic infrastructure. What reports has he seen on the economic impact infrastructure. What reports has he seen on the economic impact of infrastructure. What reports has he seen on the economic impact of the seen on the economic impact of the New seen on the economic impact of the New Zealand seen on the economic impact of the New Zealand Upgrade seen on the economic impact of the New Zealand Upgrade Programme seen on the economic impact of the New Zealand Upgrade Programme from New Zealand Upgrade Programme from the New Zealand Upgrade Programme from the infrastructure New Zealand Upgrade Programme from the infrastructure sector? the infrastructure sector? Infrastructure the infrastructure sector? Infrastructure New the infrastructure sector? Infrastructure New Zealand the infrastructure sector? Infrastructure New Zealand CEO the infrastructure sector? Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Blair Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Blair said Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Blair said that Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Blair said that the Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Blair said that the Government's Infrastructure New Zealand CEO Paul Blair said that the Government's $12 Blair said that the Government's $12 billion Blair said that the Government's $12 billion infrastructure Blair said that the Government's $12 billion infrastructure programme Blair said that the Government's $12 billion infrastructure programme is billion infrastructure programme is an billion infrastructure programme is an fantastic billion infrastructure programme is an fantastic start billion infrastructure programme is an fantastic start towards billion infrastructure programme is an fantastic start towards building an fantastic start towards building the an fantastic start towards building the infrastructure an fantastic start towards building the infrastructure New an fantastic start towards building the infrastructure New Zealand an fantastic start towards building the infrastructure New Zealand needs the infrastructure New Zealand needs to the infrastructure New Zealand needs to realise the infrastructure New Zealand needs to realise its the infrastructure New Zealand needs to realise its potential. the infrastructure New Zealand needs to realise its potential. The to realise its potential. The additional to realise its potential. The additional spending to realise its potential. The additional spending and to realise its potential. The additional spending and multi-year additional spending and multi-year nature additional spending and multi-year nature of additional spending and multi-year nature of the additional spending and multi-year nature of the package additional spending and multi-year nature of the package should additional spending and multi-year nature of the package should provide nature of the package should provide the nature of the package should provide the sector nature of the package should provide the sector with nature of the package should provide the sector with the nature of the package should provide the sector with the confidence nature of the package should provide the sector with the confidence to the sector with the confidence to ramp the sector with the confidence to ramp up the sector with the confidence to ramp up recruitment the sector with the confidence to ramp up recruitment training the sector with the confidence to ramp up recruitment training and ramp up recruitment training and capital ramp up recruitment training and capital investment." ramp up recruitment training and capital investment." The ramp up recruitment training and capital investment." The New ramp up recruitment training and capital investment." The New Zealand capital investment." The New Zealand arm capital investment." The New Zealand arm of capital investment." The New Zealand arm of global capital investment." The New Zealand arm of global engineering capital investment." The New Zealand arm of global engineering and capital investment." The New Zealand arm of global engineering and design arm of global engineering and design consultanty, arm of global engineering and design consultanty, WSP arm of global engineering and design consultanty, WSP said arm of global engineering and design consultanty, WSP said it arm of global engineering and design consultanty, WSP said it will consultanty, WSP said it will dramatically consultanty, WSP said it will dramatically increase consultanty, WSP said it will dramatically increase its dramatically increase its recruitment dramatically increase its recruitment staff dramatically increase its recruitment staff adding dramatically increase its recruitment staff adding hundreds dramatically increase its recruitment staff adding hundreds of recruitment staff adding hundreds of designers recruitment staff adding hundreds of designers and recruitment staff adding hundreds of designers and engineers recruitment staff adding hundreds of designers and engineers to recruitment staff adding hundreds of designers and engineers to support designers and engineers to support the designers and engineers to support the New designers and engineers to support the New Zealand designers and engineers to support the New Zealand Upgrade designers and engineers to support the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It is the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It is great the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It is great to the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It is great to see the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It is great to see the the New Zealand Upgrade Programme. It is great to see the sector It is great to see the sector getting It is great to see the sector getting behind It is great to see the sector getting behind this It is great to see the sector getting behind this package. It is great to see the sector getting behind this package. What getting behind this package. What getting behind this package. What getting behind this package. What reports has getting behind this package. What reports has he getting behind this package. What reports has he seen getting behind this package. What reports has he seen on getting behind this package. What reports has he seen on the getting behind this package. What reports has he seen on the impact getting behind this package. What reports has he seen on the impact of reports has he seen on the impact of the reports has he seen on the impact of the Government's reports has he seen on the impact of the Government's increased the Government's increased investments the Government's increased investments in the Government's increased investments in the the Government's increased investments in the economy the Government's increased investments in the economy on the Government's increased investments in the economy on the investments in the economy on the Crown's investments in the economy on the Crown's finances? investments in the economy on the Crown's finances? According investments in the economy on the Crown's finances? According to Crown's finances? According to forecasts Crown's finances? According to forecasts in Crown's finances? According to forecasts in The Crown's finances? According to forecasts in The Treasury's forecasts in The Treasury's half-year forecasts in The Treasury's half-year and forecasts in The Treasury's half-year and fiscal forecasts in The Treasury's half-year and fiscal update, forecasts in The Treasury's half-year and fiscal update, net half-year and fiscal update, net core half-year and fiscal update, net core Crown half-year and fiscal update, net core Crown debt half-year and fiscal update, net core Crown debt is half-year and fiscal update, net core Crown debt is expected half-year and fiscal update, net core Crown debt is expected to half-year and fiscal update, net core Crown debt is expected to peak core Crown debt is expected to peak at core Crown debt is expected to peak at 21.5% core Crown debt is expected to peak at 21.5% of core Crown debt is expected to peak at 21.5% of GDP core Crown debt is expected to peak at 21.5% of GDP in core Crown debt is expected to peak at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. core Crown debt is expected to peak at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well below at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well below the at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well below the 22.9% at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well below the 22.9% we at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well below the 22.9% we inherited at 21.5% of GDP in 2021/22. Well below the 22.9% we inherited from below the 22.9% we inherited from the below the 22.9% we inherited from the previous below the 22.9% we inherited from the previous Government. below the 22.9% we inherited from the previous Government. Fitch the previous Government. Fitch Ratings the previous Government. Fitch Ratings revised the previous Government. Fitch Ratings revised its the previous Government. Fitch Ratings revised its rating the previous Government. Fitch Ratings revised its rating for the previous Government. Fitch Ratings revised its rating for New Ratings revised its rating for New Zealand Ratings revised its rating for New Zealand to Ratings revised its rating for New Zealand to AA Ratings revised its rating for New Zealand to AA positive, Ratings revised its rating for New Zealand to AA positive, reflecting Zealand to AA positive, reflecting New Zealand to AA positive, reflecting New Zealand's Zealand to AA positive, reflecting New Zealand's found Zealand to AA positive, reflecting New Zealand's found fiscal New Zealand's found fiscal management, New Zealand's found fiscal management, low New Zealand's found fiscal management, low government New Zealand's found fiscal management, low government debt, management, low government debt, which management, low government debt, which the management, low government debt, which the country's management, low government debt, which the country's resilience management, low government debt, which the country's resilience to which the country's resilience to economic which the country's resilience to economic shocks". which the country's resilience to economic shocks". What which the country's resilience to economic shocks". What reports which the country's resilience to economic shocks". What reports has economic shocks". What reports has he economic shocks". What reports has he seen economic shocks". What reports has he seen on economic shocks". What reports has he seen on the economic shocks". What reports has he seen on the economic economic shocks". What reports has he seen on the economic impact economic shocks". What reports has he seen on the economic impact of he seen on the economic impact of his he seen on the economic impact of his Government he seen on the economic impact of his Government cancelling he seen on the economic impact of his Government cancelling or his Government cancelling or postponing his Government cancelling or postponing Nationals' his Government cancelling or postponing Nationals' projects his Government cancelling or postponing Nationals' projects two postponing Nationals' projects two years postponing Nationals' projects two years ago? postponing Nationals' projects two years ago? The postponing Nationals' projects two years ago? The premise postponing Nationals' projects two years ago? The premise of postponing Nationals' projects two years ago? The premise of the years ago? The premise of the member's years ago? The premise of the member's question years ago? The premise of the member's question is years ago? The premise of the member's question is utterly years ago? The premise of the member's question is utterly wrong member's question is utterly wrong because member's question is utterly wrong because there member's question is utterly wrong because there is member's question is utterly wrong because there is no member's question is utterly wrong because there is no way member's question is utterly wrong because there is no way to member's question is utterly wrong because there is no way to cancel because there is no way to cancel ghost because there is no way to cancel ghost projects. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: Minister of Finance: What Minister of Finance: What steps, Minister of Finance: What steps, if Minister of Finance: What steps, if any, Minister of Finance: What steps, if any, has Minister of Finance: What steps, if any, has he Minister of Finance: What steps, if any, has he taken What steps, if any, has he taken to What steps, if any, has he taken to ensure What steps, if any, has he taken to ensure the What steps, if any, has he taken to ensure the integrity to ensure the integrity of to ensure the integrity of ministerial to ensure the integrity of ministerial decisions of ministerial decisions in of ministerial decisions in the of ministerial decisions in the major of ministerial decisions in the major spending of ministerial decisions in the major spending programmes in the major spending programmes announced in the major spending programmes announced in in the major spending programmes announced in the in the major spending programmes announced in the previous announced in the previous two announced in the previous two Budgets? With With regards With regards to With regards to ministerial With regards to ministerial decisions With regards to ministerial decisions I With regards to ministerial decisions I am With regards to ministerial decisions I am responsible With regards to ministerial decisions I am responsible in With regards to ministerial decisions I am responsible in terms decisions I am responsible in terms of decisions I am responsible in terms of the decisions I am responsible in terms of the major decisions I am responsible in terms of the major spending decisions I am responsible in terms of the major spending programmes of the major spending programmes announced of the major spending programmes announced in of the major spending programmes announced in the of the major spending programmes announced in the previous of the major spending programmes announced in the previous two announced in the previous two Budgets announced in the previous two Budgets I announced in the previous two Budgets I took announced in the previous two Budgets I took to announced in the previous two Budgets I took to ensure announced in the previous two Budgets I took to ensure the Budgets I took to ensure the Budgets I took to ensure the Budgets I took to ensure the integrity of Budgets I took to ensure the integrity of them Budgets I took to ensure the integrity of them in Budgets I took to ensure the integrity of them in line Budgets I took to ensure the integrity of them in line the integrity of them in line the regular integrity of them in line the regular Budget integrity of them in line the regular Budget decision-making regular Budget decision-making projects regular Budget decision-making projects similar regular Budget decision-making projects similar to regular Budget decision-making projects similar to previous projects similar to previous ministers projects similar to previous ministers of projects similar to previous ministers of Finance, projects similar to previous ministers of Finance, like projects similar to previous ministers of Finance, like Bill ministers of Finance, like Bill English ministers of Finance, like Bill ministers ministers of Finance, like Bill English and Steven ministers of Finance, like Bill English and Steven Joyce. ministers of Finance, like Bill English and Steven Joyce. That English and Steven Joyce. That process English and Steven Joyce. That process is English and Steven Joyce. That process is that English and Steven Joyce. That process is that Budget English and Steven Joyce. That process is that Budget initiatives process is that Budget initiatives are process is that Budget initiatives are submitted process is that Budget initiatives are submitted by process is that Budget initiatives are submitted by ministers, process is that Budget initiatives are submitted by ministers, in process is that Budget initiatives are submitted by ministers, in most are submitted by ministers, in most cases are submitted by ministers, in most cases prior are submitted by ministers, in most cases prior to are submitted by ministers, in most cases prior to Christmas. are submitted by ministers, in most cases prior to Christmas. Individual cases prior to Christmas. Individual initiatives cases prior to Christmas. Individual initiatives are cases prior to Christmas. Individual initiatives are assessed cases prior to Christmas. Individual initiatives are assessed by cases prior to Christmas. Individual initiatives are assessed by The initiatives are assessed by The Treasury initiatives are assessed by The Treasury in initiatives are assessed by The Treasury in some initiatives are assessed by The Treasury in some instances initiatives are assessed by The Treasury in some instances and initiatives are assessed by The Treasury in some instances and by Treasury in some instances and by secretariats Treasury in some instances and by secretariats and Treasury in some instances and by secretariats and officials Treasury in some instances and by secretariats and officials in Treasury in some instances and by secretariats and officials in other secretariats and officials in other instances. secretariats and officials in other instances. Budget secretariats and officials in other instances. Budget decisions secretariats and officials in other instances. Budget decisions are instances. Budget decisions are assessed instances. Budget decisions are assessed in instances. Budget decisions are assessed in line instances. Budget decisions are assessed in line with instances. Budget decisions are assessed in line with a instances. Budget decisions are assessed in line with a range instances. Budget decisions are assessed in line with a range of assessed in line with a range of factors, assessed in line with a range of factors, including assessed in line with a range of factors, including their assessed in line with a range of factors, including their robustness factors, including their robustness and factors, including their robustness and value factors, including their robustness and value for factors, including their robustness and value for money. factors, including their robustness and value for money. These and value for money. These assessments and value for money. These assessments are and value for money. These assessments are pulled and value for money. These assessments are pulled together and value for money. These assessments are pulled together to assessments are pulled together to give assessments are pulled together to give advice assessments are pulled together to give advice to assessments are pulled together to give advice to ministers assessments are pulled together to give advice to ministers on assessments are pulled together to give advice to ministers on a give advice to ministers on a package give advice to ministers on a package of give advice to ministers on a package of initiatives give advice to ministers on a package of initiatives that give advice to ministers on a package of initiatives that could give advice to ministers on a package of initiatives that could be package of initiatives that could be funded package of initiatives that could be funded through package of initiatives that could be funded through the package of initiatives that could be funded through the Budget. package of initiatives that could be funded through the Budget. Ministers funded through the Budget. Ministers meet funded through the Budget. Ministers meet and funded through the Budget. Ministers meet and take funded through the Budget. Ministers meet and take decisions funded through the Budget. Ministers meet and take decisions on funded through the Budget. Ministers meet and take decisions on packages meet and take decisions on packages to meet and take decisions on packages to be meet and take decisions on packages to be considered meet and take decisions on packages to be considered by meet and take decisions on packages to be considered by Cabinet meet and take decisions on packages to be considered by Cabinet then to be considered by Cabinet then considers to be considered by Cabinet then considers it to be considered by Cabinet then considers it and to be considered by Cabinet then considers it and makes to be considered by Cabinet then considers it and makes Final considers it and makes Final decisions considers it and makes Final decisions on considers it and makes Final decisions on a considers it and makes Final decisions on a final considers it and makes Final decisions on a final Budget considers it and makes Final decisions on a final Budget and decisions on a final Budget and after decisions on a final Budget and after that, decisions on a final Budget and after that, the decisions on a final Budget and after that, the Government decisions on a final Budget and after that, the Government passes after that, the Government passes the after that, the Government passes the Budget. the Budget. Has the Budget. Has anything the Budget. Has anything he the Budget. Has anything he has the Budget. Has anything he has seen the Budget. Has anything he has seen in the Budget. Has anything he has seen in the the Budget. Has anything he has seen in the past Has anything he has seen in the past three Has anything he has seen in the past three days Has anything he has seen in the past three days caused Has anything he has seen in the past three days caused him Has anything he has seen in the past three days caused him to Has anything he has seen in the past three days caused him to question Has anything he has seen in the past three days caused him to question or three days caused him to question or doubt three days caused him to question or doubt the three days caused him to question or doubt the integrity three days caused him to question or doubt the integrity of three days caused him to question or doubt the integrity of ministerial doubt the integrity of ministerial decision-making doubt the integrity of ministerial decision-making about doubt the integrity of ministerial decision-making about major doubt the integrity of ministerial decision-making about major spending decision-making about major spending projects decision-making about major spending projects has decision-making about major spending projects has been decision-making about major spending projects has been maintained? decision-making about major spending projects has been maintained? Mr projects has been maintained? Mr Speaker, projects has been maintained? Mr Speaker, no. projects has been maintained? Mr Speaker, no. Has projects has been maintained? Mr Speaker, no. Has he projects has been maintained? Mr Speaker, no. Has he been projects has been maintained? Mr Speaker, no. Has he been following Speaker, no. Has he been following the Speaker, no. Has he been following the news Speaker, no. Has he been following the news since Speaker, no. Has he been following the news since Monday? Speaker, no. Has he been following the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, no. Has he been following the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, Speaker, no. Has he been following the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, I the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, I absolutely the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, I absolutely have the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, I absolutely have been the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, I absolutely have been and, the news since Monday? Mr Speaker, I absolutely have been and, once absolutely have been and, once again, absolutely have been and, once again, the absolutely have been and, once again, the Government absolutely have been and, once again, the Government has absolutely have been and, once again, the Government has been again, the Government has been making again, the Government has been making announcements again, the Government has been making announcements that again, the Government has been making announcements that benefit making announcements that benefit the making announcements that benefit the New making announcements that benefit the New Zealand making announcements that benefit the New Zealand economy making announcements that benefit the New Zealand economy across making announcements that benefit the New Zealand economy across the the New Zealand economy across the Board. the New Zealand economy across the Board. We've the New Zealand economy across the Board. We've got the New Zealand economy across the Board. We've got a the New Zealand economy across the Board. We've got a situation the New Zealand economy across the Board. We've got a situation just Board. We've got a situation just today Board. We've got a situation just today where Board. We've got a situation just today where we've Board. We've got a situation just today where we've seen Board. We've got a situation just today where we've seen interest today where we've seen interest rates today where we've seen interest rates held, today where we've seen interest rates held, and today where we've seen interest rates held, and the today where we've seen interest rates held, and the Reserve today where we've seen interest rates held, and the Reserve Bank rates held, and the Reserve Bank Governor rates held, and the Reserve Bank Governor or rates held, and the Reserve Bank Governor or the rates held, and the Reserve Bank Governor or the Monetary rates held, and the Reserve Bank Governor or the Monetary Policy Governor or the Monetary Policy Committee Governor or the Monetary Policy Committee reflecting Governor or the Monetary Policy Committee reflecting on Governor or the Monetary Policy Committee reflecting on the Committee reflecting on the importance Committee reflecting on the importance of Committee reflecting on the importance of the Committee reflecting on the importance of the role Committee reflecting on the importance of the role the importance of the role the Government's importance of the role the Government's fiscal importance of the role the Government's fiscal importance importance of the role the Government's fiscal importance is Government's fiscal importance is playing. Government's fiscal importance is playing. On Government's fiscal importance is playing. On the Government's fiscal importance is playing. On the matters Government's fiscal importance is playing. On the matters for Government's fiscal importance is playing. On the matters for which Government's fiscal importance is playing. On the matters for which I playing. On the matters for which I am playing. On the matters for which I am responsible playing. On the matters for which I am responsible I playing. On the matters for which I am responsible I keep playing. On the matters for which I am responsible I keep a playing. On the matters for which I am responsible I keep a close playing. On the matters for which I am responsible I keep a close eye playing. On the matters for which I am responsible I keep a close eye on am responsible I keep a close eye on the am responsible I keep a close eye on the news. am responsible I keep a close eye on the news. Has am responsible I keep a close eye on the news. Has he am responsible I keep a close eye on the news. Has he considered the news. Has he considered reviewing the news. Has he considered reviewing major the news. Has he considered reviewing major spending the news. Has he considered reviewing major spending decision reviewing major spending decision involving reviewing major spending decision involving New reviewing major spending decision involving New Zealand reviewing major spending decision involving New Zealand First involving New Zealand First ministers involving New Zealand First ministers while involving New Zealand First ministers while matters involving New Zealand First ministers while matters raised involving New Zealand First ministers while matters raised by ministers while matters raised by the ministers while matters raised by the Electoral ministers while matters raised by the Electoral Commission ministers while matters raised by the Electoral Commission and the Electoral Commission and referred the Electoral Commission and referred to the Electoral Commission and referred to the the Electoral Commission and referred to the SFO the Electoral Commission and referred to the SFO are the Electoral Commission and referred to the SFO are resolved? the Electoral Commission and referred to the SFO are resolved? I referred to the SFO are resolved? I will referred to the SFO are resolved? I will have referred to the SFO are resolved? I will have to referred to the SFO are resolved? I will have to bow referred to the SFO are resolved? I will have to bow to referred to the SFO are resolved? I will have to bow to the referred to the SFO are resolved? I will have to bow to the member's will have to bow to the member's superior will have to bow to the member's superior knowledge will have to bow to the member's superior knowledge of will have to bow to the member's superior knowledge of the will have to bow to the member's superior knowledge of the Serious superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud Office superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud Office but superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud Office but I superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud Office but I will superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud Office but I will await superior knowledge of the Serious Fraud Office but I will await the Fraud Office but I will await the outcome Fraud Office but I will await the outcome of Fraud Office but I will await the outcome of the Fraud Office but I will await the outcome of the inquiry, Fraud Office but I will await the outcome of the inquiry, but outcome of the inquiry, but otherwise outcome of the inquiry, but otherwise the outcome of the inquiry, but otherwise the government outcome of the inquiry, but otherwise the government gets outcome of the inquiry, but otherwise the government gets on otherwise the government gets on with otherwise the government gets on with its otherwise the government gets on with its order otherwise the government gets on with its order of otherwise the government gets on with its order of business. otherwise the government gets on with its order of business. With with its order of business. With respect with its order of business. With respect to with its order of business. With respect to four with its order of business. With respect to four matter with its order of business. With respect to four matter which with its order of business. With respect to four matter which is with its order of business. With respect to four matter which is are respect to four matter which is are subjudice respect to four matter which is are subjudice cases, respect to four matter which is are subjudice cases, has respect to four matter which is are subjudice cases, has any respect to four matter which is are subjudice cases, has any evidence subjudice cases, has any evidence been subjudice cases, has any evidence been put subjudice cases, has any evidence been put before subjudice cases, has any evidence been put before the subjudice cases, has any evidence been put before the commission subjudice cases, has any evidence been put before the commission for been put before the commission for consideration? been put before the commission for consideration? Obviously been put before the commission for consideration? Obviously various consideration? Obviously various political consideration? Obviously various political parties consideration? Obviously various political parties will consideration? Obviously various political parties will have consideration? Obviously various political parties will have matters political parties will have matters referred political parties will have matters referred to political parties will have matters referred to the political parties will have matters referred to the Serious political parties will have matters referred to the Serious Fraud referred to the Serious Fraud Office. referred to the Serious Fraud Office. There referred to the Serious Fraud Office. There are referred to the Serious Fraud Office. There are avenues referred to the Serious Fraud Office. There are avenues available Office. There are avenues available to Office. There are avenues available to parliamentarians Office. There are avenues available to parliamentarians if Office. There are avenues available to parliamentarians if they Office. There are avenues available to parliamentarians if they have to parliamentarians if they have concerns to parliamentarians if they have concerns about to parliamentarians if they have concerns about Government to parliamentarians if they have concerns about Government spending. concerns about Government spending. We've concerns about Government spending. We've seen concerns about Government spending. We've seen that concerns about Government spending. We've seen that in concerns about Government spending. We've seen that in the concerns about Government spending. We've seen that in the past. concerns about Government spending. We've seen that in the past. I concerns about Government spending. We've seen that in the past. I think We've seen that in the past. I think of We've seen that in the past. I think of the We've seen that in the past. I think of the Saudi We've seen that in the past. I think of the Saudi sheep We've seen that in the past. I think of the Saudi sheep deal. We've seen that in the past. I think of the Saudi sheep deal. That's We've seen that in the past. I think of the Saudi sheep deal. That's been of the Saudi sheep deal. That's been an of the Saudi sheep deal. That's been an excellent of the Saudi sheep deal. That's been an excellent example of the Saudi sheep deal. That's been an excellent example of of the Saudi sheep deal. That's been an excellent example of paltarians, an excellent example of paltarians, if an excellent example of paltarians, if they an excellent example of paltarians, if they have an excellent example of paltarians, if they have concern, an excellent example of paltarians, if they have concern, they an excellent example of paltarians, if they have concern, they know an excellent example of paltarians, if they have concern, they know what if they have concern, they know what to if they have concern, they know what to do. if they have concern, they know what to do. In if they have concern, they know what to do. In the if they have concern, they know what to do. In the past if they have concern, they know what to do. In the past three if they have concern, they know what to do. In the past three ways, if they have concern, they know what to do. In the past three ways, has to do. In the past three ways, has he to do. In the past three ways, has he reassured to do. In the past three ways, has he reassured New to do. In the past three ways, has he reassured New Zealanders to do. In the past three ways, has he reassured New Zealanders about he reassured New Zealanders about the he reassured New Zealanders about the integrity he reassured New Zealanders about the integrity of he reassured New Zealanders about the integrity of decision-making. the integrity of decision-making. I've the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken to the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken to the the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken to the Deputy the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken to the Deputy PM the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken to the Deputy PM on the integrity of decision-making. I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a number I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a number of I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a number of occasions I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a number of occasions over I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a number of occasions over the I've spoken to the Deputy PM on a number of occasions over the last number of occasions over the last three number of occasions over the last three days number of occasions over the last three days but number of occasions over the last three days but I number of occasions over the last three days but I certainly number of occasions over the last three days but I certainly haven't three days but I certainly haven't felt three days but I certainly haven't felt the three days but I certainly haven't felt the need three days but I certainly haven't felt the need to three days but I certainly haven't felt the need to do three days but I certainly haven't felt the need to do it three days but I certainly haven't felt the need to do it on three days but I certainly haven't felt the need to do it on that felt the need to do it on that particular felt the need to do it on that particular topic. felt the need to do it on that particular topic. Notwithstanding particular topic. Notwithstanding the particular topic. Notwithstanding the House's particular topic. Notwithstanding the House's Electoral particular topic. Notwithstanding the House's Electoral Commission the House's Electoral Commission statement the House's Electoral Commission statement it the House's Electoral Commission statement it is the House's Electoral Commission statement it is just statement it is just business-as-usual statement it is just business-as-usual for statement it is just business-as-usual for ministerial business-as-usual for ministerial decision-making business-as-usual for ministerial decision-making around business-as-usual for ministerial decision-making around large-scale decision-making around large-scale investments? decision-making around large-scale investments? I decision-making around large-scale investments? I think decision-making around large-scale investments? I think the decision-making around large-scale investments? I think the member decision-making around large-scale investments? I think the member is investments? I think the member is making investments? I think the member is making a investments? I think the member is making a huge, investments? I think the member is making a huge, logical investments? I think the member is making a huge, logical leap investments? I think the member is making a huge, logical leap in investments? I think the member is making a huge, logical leap in his making a huge, logical leap in his question making a huge, logical leap in his question there. making a huge, logical leap in his question there. We making a huge, logical leap in his question there. We are making a huge, logical leap in his question there. We are getting making a huge, logical leap in his question there. We are getting on question there. We are getting on the question there. We are getting on the business question there. We are getting on the business of question there. We are getting on the business of Government, question there. We are getting on the business of Government, we're the business of Government, we're positive the business of Government, we're positive about the business of Government, we're positive about the the business of Government, we're positive about the future the business of Government, we're positive about the future of the business of Government, we're positive about the future of New positive about the future of New Zealand positive about the future of New Zealand and positive about the future of New Zealand and we're positive about the future of New Zealand and we're focused positive about the future of New Zealand and we're focused on positive about the future of New Zealand and we're focused on the Zealand and we're focused on the issues Zealand and we're focused on the issues that Zealand and we're focused on the issues that matter Zealand and we're focused on the issues that matter to Zealand and we're focused on the issues that matter to New issues that matter to New Zealanders. issues that matter to New Zealanders. Question issues that matter to New Zealanders. Question no. issues that matter to New Zealanders. Question no. 6, issues that matter to New Zealanders. Question no. 6, the issues that matter to New Zealanders. Question no. 6, the Hon Zealanders. Question no. 6, the Hon Woodhouse Zealanders. Question no. 6, the Hon Woodhouse -- Zealanders. Question no. 6, the Hon Woodhouse -- Michael Zealanders. Question no. 6, the Hon Woodhouse -- Michael Woodhouse. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: Minister of Health: Is Minister of Health: Is he Minister of Health: Is he satisfied Minister of Health: Is he satisfied that Minister of Health: Is he satisfied that the Minister of Health: Is he satisfied that the response Minister of Health: Is he satisfied that the response to Is he satisfied that the response to the Is he satisfied that the response to the 2019 Is he satisfied that the response to the 2019 novel Is he satisfied that the response to the 2019 novel coronavirus Is he satisfied that the response to the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak was the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak was timely the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak was timely and the 2019 novel coronavirus outbreak was timely and appropriate? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, yes, Mr Speaker, yes, and Mr Speaker, yes, and it Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be so. Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be so. All Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be so. All the Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be so. All the decisions Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be so. All the decisions we Mr Speaker, yes, and it continues to be so. All the decisions we have be so. All the decisions we have taken be so. All the decisions we have taken have be so. All the decisions we have taken have been be so. All the decisions we have taken have been informed be so. All the decisions we have taken have been informed by be so. All the decisions we have taken have been informed by science. taken have been informed by science. Why taken have been informed by science. Why is taken have been informed by science. Why is there taken have been informed by science. Why is there no taken have been informed by science. Why is there no screening taken have been informed by science. Why is there no screening of Why is there no screening of passengers Why is there no screening of passengers arriving Why is there no screening of passengers arriving from Why is there no screening of passengers arriving from China Why is there no screening of passengers arriving from China who passengers arriving from China who transit passengers arriving from China who transit through passengers arriving from China who transit through another passengers arriving from China who transit through another country? passengers arriving from China who transit through another country? Mr transit through another country? Mr Speaker, transit through another country? Mr Speaker, all transit through another country? Mr Speaker, all passengers transit through another country? Mr Speaker, all passengers who transit through another country? Mr Speaker, all passengers who come Speaker, all passengers who come through Speaker, all passengers who come through from Speaker, all passengers who come through from another Speaker, all passengers who come through from another country, Speaker, all passengers who come through from another country, being through from another country, being checked through from another country, being checked as through from another country, being checked as they through from another country, being checked as they come through from another country, being checked as they come through through from another country, being checked as they come through to through from another country, being checked as they come through to New checked as they come through to New Zealand, checked as they come through to New Zealand, we checked as they come through to New Zealand, we track checked as they come through to New Zealand, we track who checked as they come through to New Zealand, we track who has checked as they come through to New Zealand, we track who has been checked as they come through to New Zealand, we track who has been in Zealand, we track who has been in China Zealand, we track who has been in China in Zealand, we track who has been in China in the Zealand, we track who has been in China in the last Zealand, we track who has been in China in the last 14 Zealand, we track who has been in China in the last 14 days Zealand, we track who has been in China in the last 14 days and Zealand, we track who has been in China in the last 14 days and if China in the last 14 days and if they China in the last 14 days and if they are China in the last 14 days and if they are permanent China in the last 14 days and if they are permanent residents China in the last 14 days and if they are permanent residents or China in the last 14 days and if they are permanent residents or New they are permanent residents or New Zealand they are permanent residents or New Zealand citizens, they are permanent residents or New Zealand citizens, then they are permanent residents or New Zealand citizens, then of they are permanent residents or New Zealand citizens, then of course Zealand citizens, then of course they Zealand citizens, then of course they are Zealand citizens, then of course they are allowed Zealand citizens, then of course they are allowed into Zealand citizens, then of course they are allowed into New Zealand citizens, then of course they are allowed into New Zealand they are allowed into New Zealand and they are allowed into New Zealand and they they are allowed into New Zealand and they are they are allowed into New Zealand and they are given they are allowed into New Zealand and they are given advice they are allowed into New Zealand and they are given advice on they are allowed into New Zealand and they are given advice on where and they are given advice on where to and they are given advice on where to seek and they are given advice on where to seek help and they are given advice on where to seek help if and they are given advice on where to seek help if they and they are given advice on where to seek help if they have and they are given advice on where to seek help if they have any to seek help if they have any symptoms. to seek help if they have any symptoms. They to seek help if they have any symptoms. They are to seek help if they have any symptoms. They are also to seek help if they have any symptoms. They are also given to seek help if they have any symptoms. They are also given advice symptoms. They are also given advice on symptoms. They are also given advice on health symptoms. They are also given advice on health measures, symptoms. They are also given advice on health measures, basic symptoms. They are also given advice on health measures, basic hand on health measures, basic hand hygiene on health measures, basic hand hygiene of on health measures, basic hand hygiene of course, on health measures, basic hand hygiene of course, is on health measures, basic hand hygiene of course, is one on health measures, basic hand hygiene of course, is one of on health measures, basic hand hygiene of course, is one of the hygiene of course, is one of the critical hygiene of course, is one of the critical things hygiene of course, is one of the critical things in hygiene of course, is one of the critical things in preventing hygiene of course, is one of the critical things in preventing the critical things in preventing the spread critical things in preventing the spread of critical things in preventing the spread of the critical things in preventing the spread of the virus critical things in preventing the spread of the virus as critical things in preventing the spread of the virus as well critical things in preventing the spread of the virus as well as critical things in preventing the spread of the virus as well as they spread of the virus as well as they self-isolate spread of the virus as well as they self-isolate for spread of the virus as well as they self-isolate for that spread of the virus as well as they self-isolate for that 14-day spread of the virus as well as they self-isolate for that 14-day period. self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those people self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those people who self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those people who are self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those people who are not self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those people who are not New self-isolate for that 14-day period. Those people who are not New Zealand Those people who are not New Zealand citizens, Those people who are not New Zealand citizens, permanent Those people who are not New Zealand citizens, permanent residents Those people who are not New Zealand citizens, permanent residents or Those people who are not New Zealand citizens, permanent residents or a citizens, permanent residents or a member citizens, permanent residents or a member of citizens, permanent residents or a member of the citizens, permanent residents or a member of the family citizens, permanent residents or a member of the family are citizens, permanent residents or a member of the family are turned member of the family are turned back. member of the family are turned back. Is member of the family are turned back. Is the member of the family are turned back. Is the Minister member of the family are turned back. Is the Minister telling member of the family are turned back. Is the Minister telling the back. Is the Minister telling the House back. Is the Minister telling the House that back. Is the Minister telling the House that a back. Is the Minister telling the House that a passenger back. Is the Minister telling the House that a passenger arriving back. Is the Minister telling the House that a passenger arriving from House that a passenger arriving from China House that a passenger arriving from China who House that a passenger arriving from China who transits House that a passenger arriving from China who transits through, House that a passenger arriving from China who transits through, say, China who transits through, say, Seoul China who transits through, say, Seoul or China who transits through, say, Seoul or Sydney, China who transits through, say, Seoul or Sydney, and China who transits through, say, Seoul or Sydney, and arrives China who transits through, say, Seoul or Sydney, and arrives at Seoul or Sydney, and arrives at Dunedin Seoul or Sydney, and arrives at Dunedin or Seoul or Sydney, and arrives at Dunedin or Queenstown Seoul or Sydney, and arrives at Dunedin or Queenstown International Dunedin or Queenstown International Airport Dunedin or Queenstown International Airport is Dunedin or Queenstown International Airport is given Dunedin or Queenstown International Airport is given the Dunedin or Queenstown International Airport is given the information Dunedin or Queenstown International Airport is given the information he Airport is given the information he just Airport is given the information he just described? Airport is given the information he just described? As Airport is given the information he just described? As people Airport is given the information he just described? As people come Airport is given the information he just described? As people come into just described? As people come into New just described? As people come into New Zealand just described? As people come into New Zealand they're just described? As people come into New Zealand they're given just described? As people come into New Zealand they're given the just described? As people come into New Zealand they're given the public New Zealand they're given the public health New Zealand they're given the public health information New Zealand they're given the public health information in New Zealand they're given the public health information in simple health information in simple Chinese, health information in simple Chinese, in health information in simple Chinese, in traditional health information in simple Chinese, in traditional Chinese health information in simple Chinese, in traditional Chinese and Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in English. Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in English. We Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in English. We are Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in English. We are looking Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in English. We are looking to Chinese, in traditional Chinese and in English. We are looking to make in English. We are looking to make sure in English. We are looking to make sure that in English. We are looking to make sure that anyone in English. We are looking to make sure that anyone who in English. We are looking to make sure that anyone who has in English. We are looking to make sure that anyone who has been in English. We are looking to make sure that anyone who has been in sure that anyone who has been in China sure that anyone who has been in China in sure that anyone who has been in China in the sure that anyone who has been in China in the last sure that anyone who has been in China in the last 14 sure that anyone who has been in China in the last 14 days sure that anyone who has been in China in the last 14 days is sure that anyone who has been in China in the last 14 days is in China in the last 14 days is in receipt China in the last 14 days is in receipt of China in the last 14 days is in receipt of that China in the last 14 days is in receipt of that information. China in the last 14 days is in receipt of that information. Are receipt of that information. Are passengers receipt of that information. Are passengers arriving receipt of that information. Are passengers arriving from receipt of that information. Are passengers arriving from affected passengers arriving from affected areas passengers arriving from affected areas via passengers arriving from affected areas via cruise passengers arriving from affected areas via cruise ships passengers arriving from affected areas via cruise ships being areas via cruise ships being screened areas via cruise ships being screened for areas via cruise ships being screened for the areas via cruise ships being screened for the virus? areas via cruise ships being screened for the virus? Mr areas via cruise ships being screened for the virus? Mr Speaker, screened for the virus? Mr Speaker, the screened for the virus? Mr Speaker, the passengers, screened for the virus? Mr Speaker, the passengers, any screened for the virus? Mr Speaker, the passengers, any passengers, the passengers, any passengers, arriving the passengers, any passengers, arriving on the passengers, any passengers, arriving on cruise the passengers, any passengers, arriving on cruise ships the passengers, any passengers, arriving on cruise ships are the passengers, any passengers, arriving on cruise ships are being arriving on cruise ships are being arriving on cruise ships are being arriving on cruise ships are being given the arriving on cruise ships are being given the same arriving on cruise ships are being given the same information arriving on cruise ships are being given the same information as arriving on cruise ships are being given the same information as those given the same information as those who given the same information as those who arrive given the same information as those who arrive at given the same information as those who arrive at airports. given the same information as those who arrive at airports. Who given the same information as those who arrive at airports. Who is who arrive at airports. Who is correct who arrive at airports. Who is correct - who arrive at airports. Who is correct - the who arrive at airports. Who is correct - the Minister who arrive at airports. Who is correct - the Minister who who arrive at airports. Who is correct - the Minister who advises correct - the Minister who advises the correct - the Minister who advises the screening correct - the Minister who advises the screening processes correct - the Minister who advises the screening processes are the screening processes are diligently the screening processes are diligently followed, the screening processes are diligently followed, or the screening processes are diligently followed, or the the screening processes are diligently followed, or the New diligently followed, or the New diligently diligently followed, or the New Zealander who came diligently followed, or the New Zealander who came back diligently followed, or the New Zealander who came back from diligently followed, or the New Zealander who came back from Wuhan Zealander who came back from Wuhan and Zealander who came back from Wuhan and who Zealander who came back from Wuhan and who said, Zealander who came back from Wuhan and who said, "Coming Zealander who came back from Wuhan and who said, "Coming into Zealander who came back from Wuhan and who said, "Coming into New and who said, "Coming into New Zealand, and who said, "Coming into New Zealand, there and who said, "Coming into New Zealand, there was and who said, "Coming into New Zealand, there was nothing. and who said, "Coming into New Zealand, there was nothing. For and who said, "Coming into New Zealand, there was nothing. For me, Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like we Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like we got Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like we got off Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like we got off the Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like we got off the plane Zealand, there was nothing. For me, it was like we got off the plane and it was like we got off the plane and walked it was like we got off the plane and walked through, it was like we got off the plane and walked through, and it was like we got off the plane and walked through, and no-one it was like we got off the plane and walked through, and no-one really walked through, and no-one really seemed walked through, and no-one really seemed that walked through, and no-one really seemed that concerned"? walked through, and no-one really seemed that concerned"? Mr walked through, and no-one really seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, the seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, the provision seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, the provision of seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, the provision of information seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, the provision of information at seemed that concerned"? Mr Speaker, the provision of information at the the provision of information at the airports the provision of information at the airports is the provision of information at the airports is the the provision of information at the airports is the thing the provision of information at the airports is the thing that the provision of information at the airports is the thing that we the provision of information at the airports is the thing that we are airports is the thing that we are advise airports is the thing that we are advise by airports is the thing that we are advise by the airports is the thing that we are advise by the medical airports is the thing that we are advise by the medical experts, airports is the thing that we are advise by the medical experts, the advise by the medical experts, the science, advise by the medical experts, the science, is advise by the medical experts, the science, is the advise by the medical experts, the science, is the best advise by the medical experts, the science, is the best and advise by the medical experts, the science, is the best and most science, is the best and most effective science, is the best and most effective thing science, is the best and most effective thing we science, is the best and most effective thing we can science, is the best and most effective thing we can do. science, is the best and most effective thing we can do. Because effective thing we can do. Because it effective thing we can do. Because it makes effective thing we can do. Because it makes sure effective thing we can do. Because it makes sure that effective thing we can do. Because it makes sure that when effective thing we can do. Because it makes sure that when people effective thing we can do. Because it makes sure that when people have it makes sure that when people have the it makes sure that when people have the symptoms, it makes sure that when people have the symptoms, if it makes sure that when people have the symptoms, if they it makes sure that when people have the symptoms, if they have it makes sure that when people have the symptoms, if they have any the symptoms, if they have any symptoms, the symptoms, if they have any symptoms, they the symptoms, if they have any symptoms, they know the symptoms, if they have any symptoms, they know where the symptoms, if they have any symptoms, they know where to the symptoms, if they have any symptoms, they know where to get symptoms, they know where to get help, symptoms, they know where to get help, to symptoms, they know where to get help, to call symptoms, they know where to get help, to call Health symptoms, they know where to get help, to call Health Line. symptoms, they know where to get help, to call Health Line. They symptoms, they know where to get help, to call Health Line. They know help, to call Health Line. They know how help, to call Health Line. They know how to help, to call Health Line. They know how to self-isolate help, to call Health Line. They know how to self-isolate effectively, how to self-isolate effectively, they how to self-isolate effectively, they know how to self-isolate effectively, they know how how to self-isolate effectively, they know how to how to self-isolate effectively, they know how to do how to self-isolate effectively, they know how to do hand how to self-isolate effectively, they know how to do hand hygiene, they know how to do hand hygiene, cough they know how to do hand hygiene, cough high they know how to do hand hygiene, cough high gen they know how to do hand hygiene, cough high gen and they know how to do hand hygiene, cough high gen and other they know how to do hand hygiene, cough high gen and other things they know how to do hand hygiene, cough high gen and other things that cough high gen and other things that prevent cough high gen and other things that prevent the cough high gen and other things that prevent the spread cough high gen and other things that prevent the spread of cough high gen and other things that prevent the spread of this cough high gen and other things that prevent the spread of this virus. cough high gen and other things that prevent the spread of this virus. We prevent the spread of this virus. We have prevent the spread of this virus. We have taking prevent the spread of this virus. We have taking the prevent the spread of this virus. We have taking the measures prevent the spread of this virus. We have taking the measures that prevent the spread of this virus. We have taking the measures that the have taking the measures that the clinical have taking the measures that the clinical experts, have taking the measures that the clinical experts, the have taking the measures that the clinical experts, the doctors have taking the measures that the clinical experts, the doctors have clinical experts, the doctors have recommended. clinical experts, the doctors have recommended. At clinical experts, the doctors have recommended. At every clinical experts, the doctors have recommended. At every point clinical experts, the doctors have recommended. At every point we clinical experts, the doctors have recommended. At every point we have recommended. At every point we have made recommended. At every point we have made sure recommended. At every point we have made sure that recommended. At every point we have made sure that our recommended. At every point we have made sure that our decisions recommended. At every point we have made sure that our decisions have made sure that our decisions have been made sure that our decisions have been informed made sure that our decisions have been informed by made sure that our decisions have been informed by science. made sure that our decisions have been informed by science. Question been informed by science. Question No. been informed by science. Question No. 7, been informed by science. Question No. 7, Paul been informed by science. Question No. 7, Paul Eagle. been informed by science. Question No. 7, Paul Eagle. Thank been informed by science. Question No. 7, Paul Eagle. Thank you, been informed by science. Question No. 7, Paul Eagle. Thank you, Mr No. 7, Paul Eagle. Thank you, Mr Speaker. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Transport: Minister of Transport: In Minister of Transport: In what Minister of Transport: In what ways, Minister of Transport: In what ways, if Minister of Transport: In what ways, if any, Minister of Transport: In what ways, if any, will Minister of Transport: In what ways, if any, will the In what ways, if any, will the New In what ways, if any, will the New Zealand In what ways, if any, will the New Zealand Upgrade In what ways, if any, will the New Zealand Upgrade Programme New Zealand Upgrade Programme help New Zealand Upgrade Programme help futureproof New Zealand Upgrade Programme help futureproof the New Zealand Upgrade Programme help futureproof the economy help futureproof the economy and help futureproof the economy and get help futureproof the economy and get our help futureproof the economy and get our cities help futureproof the economy and get our cities moving? The The Hon The Hon Phil The Hon Phil Twyford. The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, Mr The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The New The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The New Zealand The Hon Phil Twyford. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The New Zealand Upgrade Speaker. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme Speaker. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme will Speaker. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme will help Speaker. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme will help future-proof Speaker. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme will help future-proof the Programme will help future-proof the economy Programme will help future-proof the economy by Programme will help future-proof the economy by providing Programme will help future-proof the economy by providing a Programme will help future-proof the economy by providing a fully-funded economy by providing a fully-funded pipeline economy by providing a fully-funded pipeline of economy by providing a fully-funded pipeline of transport economy by providing a fully-funded pipeline of transport projects economy by providing a fully-funded pipeline of transport projects over pipeline of transport projects over the pipeline of transport projects over the next pipeline of transport projects over the next decade pipeline of transport projects over the next decade on pipeline of transport projects over the next decade on top pipeline of transport projects over the next decade on top of pipeline of transport projects over the next decade on top of the pipeline of transport projects over the next decade on top of the ones the next decade on top of the ones already the next decade on top of the ones already funded the next decade on top of the ones already funded and the next decade on top of the ones already funded and being the next decade on top of the ones already funded and being delivered already funded and being delivered through already funded and being delivered through the already funded and being delivered through the National already funded and being delivered through the National Land already funded and being delivered through the National Land Transport through the National Land Transport programme through the National Land Transport programme cap through the National Land Transport programme cap -- through the National Land Transport programme cap -- Programme. through the National Land Transport programme cap -- Programme. It through the National Land Transport programme cap -- Programme. It will programme cap -- Programme. It will help programme cap -- Programme. It will help get programme cap -- Programme. It will help get our programme cap -- Programme. It will help get our cities programme cap -- Programme. It will help get our cities moving programme cap -- Programme. It will help get our cities moving for help get our cities moving for billions help get our cities moving for billions invested help get our cities moving for billions invested for help get our cities moving for billions invested for roads, billions invested for roads, cycling. billions invested for roads, cycling. It billions invested for roads, cycling. It is billions invested for roads, cycling. It is proof billions invested for roads, cycling. It is proof positive billions invested for roads, cycling. It is proof positive that cycling. It is proof positive that we cycling. It is proof positive that we are cycling. It is proof positive that we are the cycling. It is proof positive that we are the Government cycling. It is proof positive that we are the Government of we are the Government of Infrastructure. we are the Government of Infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What Infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What reactions Infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What reactions has Infrastructure. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. What reactions has he Supplementary. What reactions has he seen Supplementary. What reactions has he Supplementary. Supplementary. What reactions has he seen from the Supplementary. What reactions has he seen from the industry Supplementary. What reactions has he seen from the industry to Supplementary. What reactions has he seen from the industry to the Supplementary. What reactions has he seen from the industry to the New seen from the industry to the New Zealand seen from the industry to the New Zealand Upgrade seen from the industry to the New Zealand Upgrade Programme? seen from the industry to the New Zealand Upgrade Programme? Mr Zealand Upgrade Programme? Mr Speaker, Zealand Upgrade Programme? Mr Speaker, civil Zealand Upgrade Programme? Mr Speaker, civil contractors Zealand Upgrade Programme? Mr Speaker, civil contractors Chief Speaker, civil contractors Chief Executive Speaker, civil contractors Chief Executive Peter Speaker, civil contractors Chief Executive Peter Silcox Speaker, civil contractors Chief Executive Peter Silcox said Speaker, civil contractors Chief Executive Peter Silcox said the Executive Peter Silcox said the Government Executive Peter Silcox said the Government was Executive Peter Silcox said the Government was looking Executive Peter Silcox said the Government was looking at Executive Peter Silcox said the Government was looking at a Executive Peter Silcox said the Government was looking at a wide Government was looking at a wide range Government was looking at a wide range of Government was looking at a wide range of projects Government was looking at a wide range of projects including Government was looking at a wide range of projects including roads range of projects including roads and range of projects including roads and that range of projects including roads and that this range of projects including roads and that this announcement range of projects including roads and that this announcement was range of projects including roads and that this announcement was a and that this announcement was a welcome and that this announcement was a welcome one and that this announcement was a welcome one for and that this announcement was a welcome one for the and that this announcement was a welcome one for the country's and that this announcement was a welcome one for the country's road welcome one for the country's road builders welcome one for the country's road builders and welcome one for the country's road builders and civil welcome one for the country's road builders and civil construction builders and civil construction companies. builders and civil construction companies. Kirk builders and civil construction companies. Kirk Hope builders and civil construction companies. Kirk Hope of builders and civil construction companies. Kirk Hope of Business builders and civil construction companies. Kirk Hope of Business New companies. Kirk Hope of Business New Zealand companies. Kirk Hope of Business New Zealand said companies. Kirk Hope of Business New Zealand said this companies. Kirk Hope of Business New Zealand said this announcement companies. Kirk Hope of Business New Zealand said this announcement was Zealand said this announcement was "positive Zealand said this announcement was "positive for Zealand said this announcement was "positive for business". Zealand said this announcement was "positive for business". It's Zealand said this announcement was "positive for business". It's fair "positive for business". It's fair to "positive for business". It's fair to say "positive for business". It's fair to say the "positive for business". It's fair to say the New "positive for business". It's fair to say the New Zealand "positive for business". It's fair to say the New Zealand Upgrade to say the New Zealand Upgrade Programme to say the New Zealand Upgrade Programme has to say the New Zealand Upgrade Programme has had to say the New Zealand Upgrade Programme has had glowing to say the New Zealand Upgrade Programme has had glowing reviews Programme has had glowing reviews from Programme has had glowing reviews from industry Programme has had glowing reviews from industry across Programme has had glowing reviews from industry across the Programme has had glowing reviews from industry across the board. Programme has had glowing reviews from industry across the board. What from industry across the board. What job from industry across the board. What job opportunities from industry across the board. What job opportunities will from industry across the board. What job opportunities will be from industry across the board. What job opportunities will be created job opportunities will be created because job opportunities will be created because of job opportunities will be created because of the job opportunities will be created because of the package? job opportunities will be created because of the package? The because of the package? The Transport because of the package? The Transport Agency because of the package? The Transport Agency estimates because of the package? The Transport Agency estimates the Transport Agency estimates the package Transport Agency estimates the package could Transport Agency estimates the package could initially Transport Agency estimates the package could initially create Transport Agency estimates the package could initially create 800 package could initially create 800 to package could initially create 800 to 1,000 package could initially create 800 to 1,000 new package could initially create 800 to 1,000 new job package could initially create 800 to 1,000 new job directly package could initially create 800 to 1,000 new job directly in package could initially create 800 to 1,000 new job directly in our to 1,000 new job directly in our construction to 1,000 new job directly in our construction industry to 1,000 new job directly in our construction industry as to 1,000 new job directly in our construction industry as the to 1,000 new job directly in our construction industry as the first construction industry as the first five construction industry as the first five projects construction industry as the first five projects get construction industry as the first five projects get under construction industry as the first five projects get under way construction industry as the first five projects get under way in construction industry as the first five projects get under way in the five projects get under way in the next five projects get under way in the next 12 five projects get under way in the next 12 months. five projects get under way in the next 12 months. That five projects get under way in the next 12 months. That is five projects get under way in the next 12 months. That is State next 12 months. That is State Highway next 12 months. That is State Highway 1, next 12 months. That is State Highway 1, pup next 12 months. That is State Highway 1, pup -- next 12 months. That is State Highway 1, pup -- papakuri next 12 months. That is State Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to next 12 months. That is State Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and it Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and it is Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and it is designed Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and it is designed to Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and it is designed to create Highway 1, pup -- papakuri to Drury and it is designed to create 7,000 and it is designed to create 7,000 to and it is designed to create 7,000 to 9,000 and it is designed to create 7,000 to 9,000 jobs and it is designed to create 7,000 to 9,000 jobs in and it is designed to create 7,000 to 9,000 jobs in the and it is designed to create 7,000 to 9,000 jobs in the wider and it is designed to create 7,000 to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. This to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. This is to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. This is based to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. This is based on to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. This is based on what to 9,000 jobs in the wider supply chain. This is based on what has chain. This is based on what has happened chain. This is based on what has happened on chain. This is based on what has happened on similar chain. This is based on what has happened on similar projects happened on similar projects recently happened on similar projects recently and happened on similar projects recently and from happened on similar projects recently and from NZTA's happened on similar projects recently and from NZTA's discussions recently and from NZTA's discussions with recently and from NZTA's discussions with the recently and from NZTA's discussions with the industry. recently and from NZTA's discussions with the industry. It recently and from NZTA's discussions with the industry. It will recently and from NZTA's discussions with the industry. It will also with the industry. It will also provide with the industry. It will also provide opportunities with the industry. It will also provide opportunities to with the industry. It will also provide opportunities to upskill with the industry. It will also provide opportunities to upskill our provide opportunities to upskill our workforce. provide opportunities to upskill our workforce. Importantly, provide opportunities to upskill our workforce. Importantly, the provide opportunities to upskill our workforce. Importantly, the package workforce. Importantly, the package gives workforce. Importantly, the package gives industry workforce. Importantly, the package gives industry the workforce. Importantly, the package gives industry the certainty workforce. Importantly, the package gives industry the certainty that gives industry the certainty that they've gives industry the certainty that they've been gives industry the certainty that they've been asking gives industry the certainty that they've been asking for, gives industry the certainty that they've been asking for, a gives industry the certainty that they've been asking for, a pipeline they've been asking for, a pipeline of they've been asking for, a pipeline of work they've been asking for, a pipeline of work for they've been asking for, a pipeline of work for the they've been asking for, a pipeline of work for the next they've been asking for, a pipeline of work for the next decade, of work for the next decade, enabling of work for the next decade, enabling them of work for the next decade, enabling them to of work for the next decade, enabling them to invest of work for the next decade, enabling them to invest in of work for the next decade, enabling them to invest in their enabling them to invest in their people. enabling them to invest in their people. <INTERRUPTION> people. <INTERRUPTION> Chris people. <INTERRUPTION> Chris Bishop. people. <INTERRUPTION> Chris Bishop. Has people. <INTERRUPTION> Chris Bishop. Has he people. <INTERRUPTION> Chris Bishop. Has he received people. <INTERRUPTION> Chris Bishop. Has he received any Chris Bishop. Has he received any advocacy Chris Bishop. Has he received any advocacy from Chris Bishop. Has he received any advocacy from a Chris Bishop. Has he received any advocacy from a Member Chris Bishop. Has he received any advocacy from a Member of Chris Bishop. Has he received any advocacy from a Member of Parliament advocacy from a Member of Parliament for advocacy from a Member of Parliament for Rongotai advocacy from a Member of Parliament for Rongotai about advocacy from a Member of Parliament for Rongotai about the advocacy from a Member of Parliament for Rongotai about the necessity advocacy from a Member of Parliament for Rongotai about the necessity of for Rongotai about the necessity of bringing for Rongotai about the necessity of bringing forward for Rongotai about the necessity of bringing forward a for Rongotai about the necessity of bringing forward a second for Rongotai about the necessity of bringing forward a second Mount bringing forward a second Mount Victoria bringing forward a second Mount Victoria Tunnel bringing forward a second Mount Victoria Tunnel as bringing forward a second Mount Victoria Tunnel as part bringing forward a second Mount Victoria Tunnel as part of bringing forward a second Mount Victoria Tunnel as part of the bringing forward a second Mount Victoria Tunnel as part of the New Victoria Tunnel as part of the New Zealand Victoria Tunnel as part of the New Zealand Upgrade Victoria Tunnel as part of the New Zealand Upgrade Programme? Victoria Tunnel as part of the New Zealand Upgrade Programme? The Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member for Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member for Rongotai Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member for Rongotai is Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member for Rongotai is a Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member for Rongotai is a very Zealand Upgrade Programme? The member for Rongotai is a very active member for Rongotai is a very active on member for Rongotai is a very active on behalf member for Rongotai is a very active on behalf of member for Rongotai is a very active on behalf of his member for Rongotai is a very active on behalf of his constituents member for Rongotai is a very active on behalf of his constituents and on behalf of his constituents and what on behalf of his constituents and what he on behalf of his constituents and what he tells on behalf of his constituents and what he tells me on behalf of his constituents and what he tells me is on behalf of his constituents and what he tells me is that on behalf of his constituents and what he tells me is that the on behalf of his constituents and what he tells me is that the members what he tells me is that the members of what he tells me is that the members of - what he tells me is that the members of - the what he tells me is that the members of - the people what he tells me is that the members of - the people who what he tells me is that the members of - the people who live what he tells me is that the members of - the people who live in what he tells me is that the members of - the people who live in his of - the people who live in his electorate of - the people who live in his electorate are of - the people who live in his electorate are overwhelmingly of - the people who live in his electorate are overwhelmingly happy electorate are overwhelmingly happy that electorate are overwhelmingly happy that they electorate are overwhelmingly happy that they have electorate are overwhelmingly happy that they have a electorate are overwhelmingly happy that they have a Government electorate are overwhelmingly happy that they have a Government that's that they have a Government that's committed that they have a Government that's committed $6.5 that they have a Government that's committed $6.5 billion that they have a Government that's committed $6.5 billion of that they have a Government that's committed $6.5 billion of multimodal committed $6.5 billion of multimodal transport committed $6.5 billion of multimodal transport investments committed $6.5 billion of multimodal transport investments to committed $6.5 billion of multimodal transport investments to Wellington transport investments to Wellington after transport investments to Wellington after nine transport investments to Wellington after nine years transport investments to Wellington after nine years when transport investments to Wellington after nine years when the transport investments to Wellington after nine years when the former after nine years when the former Government, after nine years when the former Government, the after nine years when the former Government, the only after nine years when the former Government, the only thing after nine years when the former Government, the only thing that after nine years when the former Government, the only thing that they Government, the only thing that they did Government, the only thing that they did was Government, the only thing that they did was fail Government, the only thing that they did was fail to Government, the only thing that they did was fail to impose Government, the only thing that they did was fail to impose a Government, the only thing that they did was fail to impose a giant did was fail to impose a giant concrete did was fail to impose a giant concrete flyover did was fail to impose a giant concrete flyover at did was fail to impose a giant concrete flyover at the did was fail to impose a giant concrete flyover at the Basin concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. I concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. I don't concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. I don't think concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. I don't think I concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. I don't think I need concrete flyover at the Basin Reserve. I don't think I need a Reserve. I don't think I need a point Reserve. I don't think I need a point of Reserve. I don't think I need a point of order. Reserve. I don't think I need a point of order. I Reserve. I don't think I need a point of order. I think Reserve. I don't think I need a point of order. I think the Reserve. I don't think I need a point of order. I think the member point of order. I think the member will point of order. I think the member will now point of order. I think the member will now address point of order. I think the member will now address the point of order. I think the member will now address the question. point of order. I think the member will now address the question. The will now address the question. The member will now address the question. The member for will now address the question. The member for Rongotai will now address the question. The member for Rongotai is will now address the question. The member for Rongotai is a will now address the question. The member for Rongotai is a very will now address the question. The member for Rongotai is a very active member for Rongotai is a very active member member for Rongotai is a very active member on member for Rongotai is a very active member on behalf member for Rongotai is a very active member on behalf of member for Rongotai is a very active member on behalf of his member for Rongotai is a very active member on behalf of his certificates member on behalf of his certificates -- member on behalf of his certificates -- constituents member on behalf of his certificates -- constituents and member on behalf of his certificates -- constituents and he member on behalf of his certificates -- constituents and he wants member on behalf of his certificates -- constituents and he wants to member on behalf of his certificates -- constituents and he wants to see -- constituents and he wants to see all -- constituents and he wants to see all the -- constituents and he wants to see all the packages -- constituents and he wants to see all the packages of -- constituents and he wants to see all the packages of the -- constituents and he wants to see all the packages of the Let's -- constituents and he wants to see all the packages of the Let's Get all the packages of the Let's Get Wellington all the packages of the Let's Get Wellington Moving all the packages of the Let's Get Wellington Moving Forward all the packages of the Let's Get Wellington Moving Forward introduced Wellington Moving Forward introduced as Wellington Moving Forward introduced as fast Wellington Moving Forward introduced as fast as Wellington Moving Forward introduced as fast as possible. Wellington Moving Forward introduced as fast as possible. Why Wellington Moving Forward introduced as fast as possible. Why didn't Wellington Moving Forward introduced as fast as possible. Why didn't the as fast as possible. Why didn't the Government as fast as possible. Why didn't the Government announce as fast as possible. Why didn't the Government announce this as fast as possible. Why didn't the Government announce this package as fast as possible. Why didn't the Government announce this package two Government announce this package two years Government announce this package two years ago Government announce this package two years ago when Government announce this package two years ago when it Government announce this package two years ago when it took Government announce this package two years ago when it took power? years ago when it took power? Because years ago when it took power? Because we years ago when it took power? Because we have years ago when it took power? Because we have re-balanced years ago when it took power? Because we have re-balanced the Because we have re-balanced the transport Because we have re-balanced the transport policy Because we have re-balanced the transport policy by Because we have re-balanced the transport policy by spending Because we have re-balanced the transport policy by spending - Because we have re-balanced the transport policy by spending - we've Because we have re-balanced the Because Because we have re-balanced the made a 4 Because we have re-balanced the made a 4 billion-dollar Because we have re-balanced the made a 4 billion-dollar investment made a 4 billion-dollar investment in made a 4 billion-dollar investment in rail. made a 4 billion-dollar investment in rail. <INTERRUPTION> in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We are in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We are doing in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We are doing 70% in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We are doing 70% more in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We are doing 70% more maintenance in rail. <INTERRUPTION> We are doing 70% more maintenance of We are doing 70% more maintenance of the We are doing 70% more maintenance of the State We are doing 70% more maintenance of the State Highway We are doing 70% more maintenance of the State Highway network. We are doing 70% more maintenance of the State Highway network. We're the State Highway network. We're informationing the State Highway network. We're informationing $1.4 the State Highway network. We're informationing $1.4 billion the State Highway network. We're informationing $1.4 billion in informationing $1.4 billion in safety informationing $1.4 billion in safety upgrades informationing $1.4 billion in safety upgrades on informationing $1.4 billion in safety upgrades on 3,300km informationing $1.4 billion in safety upgrades on 3,300km of informationing $1.4 billion in safety upgrades on 3,300km of State safety upgrades on 3,300km of State Highways safety upgrades on 3,300km of State Highways and safety upgrades on 3,300km of State Highways and local safety upgrades on 3,300km of State Highways and local roads. safety upgrades on 3,300km of State Highways and local roads. After safety upgrades on 3,300km of State Highways and local roads. After the Highways and local roads. After the NZ Highways and local roads. After the NZ Upgrade Highways and local roads. After the NZ Upgrade Programme Highways and local roads. After the NZ Upgrade Programme we Highways and local roads. After the NZ Upgrade Programme we are Highways and local roads. After the NZ Upgrade Programme we are spending NZ Upgrade Programme we are spending $7 NZ Upgrade Programme we are spending $7 billion NZ Upgrade Programme we are spending $7 billion more NZ Upgrade Programme we are spending $7 billion more on NZ Upgrade Programme we are spending $7 billion more on transport $7 billion more on transport infrastructure $7 billion more on transport infrastructure than $7 billion more on transport infrastructure than the $7 billion more on transport infrastructure than the former infrastructure than the former Government infrastructure than the former Government - infrastructure than the former Government - $7 infrastructure than the former Government - $7 billion infrastructure than the former Government - $7 billion more. infrastructure than the former Government - $7 billion more. Can Government - $7 billion more. Can the Government - $7 billion more. Can the Minister Government - $7 billion more. Can the Minister explain Government - $7 billion more. Can the Minister explain how Government - $7 billion more. Can the Minister explain how doing Government - $7 billion more. Can the Minister explain how doing any the Minister explain how doing any of the Minister explain how doing any of that the Minister explain how doing any of that prevented the Minister explain how doing any of that prevented him the Minister explain how doing any of that prevented him from of that prevented him from announcing of that prevented him from announcing the of that prevented him from announcing the New of that prevented him from announcing the New Zealand of that prevented him from announcing the New Zealand Upgrade announcing the New Zealand Upgrade Programme announcing the New Zealand Upgrade Programme two announcing the New Zealand Upgrade Programme two years announcing the New Zealand Upgrade Programme two years ago? announcing the New Zealand Upgrade Programme two years ago? Because announcing the New Zealand Upgrade Programme two years ago? Because it Programme two years ago? Because it was Programme two years ago? Because it was necessary, Programme two years ago? Because it was necessary, after Programme two years ago? Because it was necessary, after nine Programme two years ago? Because it was necessary, after nine years Programme two years ago? Because it was necessary, after nine years of was necessary, after nine years of neglect was necessary, after nine years of neglect to was necessary, after nine years of neglect to address... was necessary, after nine years of neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> ..the neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> ..the deficit, neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> ..the deficit, the neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> ..the deficit, the deficit neglect to address... <INTERRUPTION> ..the deficit, the deficit of ..the deficit, the deficit of transport ..the deficit, the deficit of transport infrastructure ..the deficit, the deficit of transport infrastructure we transport infrastructure we inherited. transport infrastructure we inherited. We transport infrastructure we inherited. We had transport infrastructure we inherited. We had to transport infrastructure we inherited. We had to rebalance transport infrastructure we inherited. We had to rebalance the inherited. We had to rebalance the transport inherited. We had to rebalance the transport policy. inherited. We had to rebalance the transport policy. We inherited. We had to rebalance the transport policy. We have. inherited. We had to rebalance the transport policy. We have. We inherited. We had to rebalance the transport policy. We have. We are transport policy. We have. We are now transport policy. We have. We are now in transport policy. We have. We are now in a transport policy. We have. We are now in a position transport policy. We have. We are now in a position to transport policy. We have. We are now in a position to bring transport policy. We have. We are now in a position to bring forward now in a position to bring forward and now in a position to bring forward and fund now in a position to bring forward and fund projects now in a position to bring forward and fund projects that now in a position to bring forward and fund projects that that now in a position to bring forward and fund projects that that party and fund projects that that party promised and fund projects that that party promised in and fund projects that that party promised in a and fund projects that that party promised in a press and fund projects that that party promised in a press release and fund projects that that party promised in a press release but promised in a press release but never promised in a press release but never funded. promised in a press release but never funded. Question promised in a press release but never funded. Question No. promised in a press release but never funded. Question No. 8, promised in a press release but never funded. Question No. 8, the never funded. Question No. 8, the Louise never funded. Question No. 8, the Louise Upston. never funded. Question No. 8, the Louise Upston. -- never funded. Question No. 8, the Louise Upston. -- Question never funded. Question No. 8, the Louise Upston. -- Question No. never funded. Question No. 8, the Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Chris Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Chris Bishop... Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Chris Bishop... Sorry, Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Chris Bishop... Sorry, I Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't Louise Upston. -- Question No. 9, Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Well, Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Well, I Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Well, I will Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Well, I will go Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Well, I will go back Chris Bishop... Sorry, I didn't hear you, sorry. Well, I will go back to you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member but you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member but it's you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member but it's up you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member but it's up to you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member but it's up to her you, sorry. Well, I will go back to the member but it's up to her to the member but it's up to her to listen. the member but it's up to her to listen. The the member but it's up to her to listen. The Hon the member but it's up to her to listen. The Hon Louise the member but it's up to her to listen. The Hon Louise Upston. the member but it's up to her to listen. The Hon Louise Upston. Thank listen. The Hon Louise Upston. Thank you, listen. The Hon Louise Upston. Thank you, Mr listen. The Hon Louise Upston. Thank you, Mr Speaker. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Social My question is to the Minister for Social Development: Minister for Social Development: Does Minister for Social Development: Does she Minister for Social Development: Does she stand Minister for Social Development: Does she stand by Minister for Social Development: Does she stand by her Minister for Social Development: Does she stand by her statement Minister for Social Development: Does she stand by her statement that Does she stand by her statement that "the Does she stand by her statement that "the Government's Does she stand by her statement that "the Government's plan Does she stand by her statement that "the Government's plan to Does she stand by her statement that "the Government's plan to get Does she stand by her statement that "the Government's plan to get people "the Government's plan to get people off "the Government's plan to get people off the "the Government's plan to get people off the benefit "the Government's plan to get people off the benefit and "the Government's plan to get people off the benefit and into "the Government's plan to get people off the benefit and into work off the benefit and into work is off the benefit and into work is starting off the benefit and into work is starting to off the benefit and into work is starting to pay off the benefit and into work is starting to pay off"? The The Hon The Hon Carmel The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. I The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. I stand The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. I stand by The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. I stand by the The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. I stand by the 42,834 The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Yes. I stand by the 42,834 cancellations stand by the 42,834 cancellations into stand by the 42,834 cancellations into work stand by the 42,834 cancellations into work that stand by the 42,834 cancellations into work that have stand by the 42,834 cancellations into work that have occurred stand by the 42,834 cancellations into work that have occurred since into work that have occurred since July into work that have occurred since July following into work that have occurred since July following our into work that have occurred since July following our investment into work that have occurred since July following our investment into July following our investment into 170 July following our investment into 170 extra July following our investment into 170 extra front-line July following our investment into 170 extra front-line case July following our investment into 170 extra front-line case managers 170 extra front-line case managers to 170 extra front-line case managers to support 170 extra front-line case managers to support people 170 extra front-line case managers to support people into 170 extra front-line case managers to support people into work. 170 extra front-line case managers to support people into work. There to support people into work. There have to support people into work. There have been to support people into work. There have been 6,703 to support people into work. There have been 6,703 cancellations to support people into work. There have been 6,703 cancellations into have been 6,703 cancellations into work have been 6,703 cancellations into work in have been 6,703 cancellations into work in the have been 6,703 cancellations into work in the last have been 6,703 cancellations into work in the last month have been 6,703 cancellations into work in the last month alone, have been 6,703 cancellations into work in the last month alone, an work in the last month alone, an increase work in the last month alone, an increase of work in the last month alone, an increase of 27.9% work in the last month alone, an increase of 27.9% from work in the last month alone, an increase of 27.9% from this work in the last month alone, an increase of 27.9% from this time increase of 27.9% from this time last increase of 27.9% from this time last year. increase of 27.9% from this time last year. And increase of 27.9% from this time last year. And the increase of 27.9% from this time last year. And the highest increase of 27.9% from this time last year. And the highest number increase of 27.9% from this time last year. And the highest number of last year. And the highest number of exits last year. And the highest number of exits into last year. And the highest number of exits into work last year. And the highest number of exits into work for last year. And the highest number of exits into work for the last year. And the highest number of exits into work for the month last year. And the highest number of exits into work for the month of exits into work for the month of January exits into work for the month of January in exits into work for the month of January in the exits into work for the month of January in the last exits into work for the month of January in the last five exits into work for the month of January in the last five years. exits into work for the month of January in the last five years. We January in the last five years. We have January in the last five years. We have more January in the last five years. We have more New January in the last five years. We have more New Zealanders January in the last five years. We have more New Zealanders in January in the last five years. We have more New Zealanders in work have more New Zealanders in work than have more New Zealanders in work than every have more New Zealanders in work than every before have more New Zealanders in work than every before and have more New Zealanders in work than every before and the have more New Zealanders in work than every before and the weekly than every before and the weekly average than every before and the weekly average wage than every before and the weekly average wage is than every before and the weekly average wage is up than every before and the weekly average wage is up $80 than every before and the weekly average wage is up $80 since than every before and the weekly average wage is up $80 since we than every before and the weekly average wage is up $80 since we took average wage is up $80 since we took office. average wage is up $80 since we took office. 16,000 average wage is up $80 since we took office. 16,000 MSD average wage is up $80 since we took office. 16,000 MSD clients average wage is up $80 since we took office. 16,000 MSD clients have average wage is up $80 since we took office. 16,000 MSD clients have been office. 16,000 MSD clients have been supported office. 16,000 MSD clients have been supported towards office. 16,000 MSD clients have been supported towards employment office. 16,000 MSD clients have been supported towards employment through supported towards employment through upskilling supported towards employment through upskilling and supported towards employment through upskilling and training supported towards employment through upskilling and training in supported towards employment through upskilling and training in 2019. upskilling and training in 2019. This upskilling and training in 2019. This Government upskilling and training in 2019. This Government is upskilling and training in 2019. This Government is committed upskilling and training in 2019. This Government is committed to This Government is committed to supporting This Government is committed to supporting people This Government is committed to supporting people into This Government is committed to supporting people into sustainable supporting people into sustainable work supporting people into sustainable work and supporting people into sustainable work and these supporting people into sustainable work and these figures supporting people into sustainable work and these figures show supporting people into sustainable work and these figures show that supporting people into sustainable work and these figures show that we work and these figures show that we are work and these figures show that we are making work and these figures show that we are making real work and these figures show that we are making real progress. work and these figures show that we are making real progress. Does work and these figures show that we are making real progress. Does she are making real progress. Does she accept are making real progress. Does she accept that are making real progress. Does she accept that Labour are making real progress. Does she accept that Labour has are making real progress. Does she accept that Labour has overseen are making real progress. Does she accept that Labour has overseen the accept that Labour has overseen the three accept that Labour has overseen the three lowest-ever accept that Labour has overseen the three lowest-ever quarters accept that Labour has overseen the three lowest-ever quarters for accept that Labour has overseen the three lowest-ever quarters for the three lowest-ever quarters for the number three lowest-ever quarters for the number of three lowest-ever quarters for the number of people three lowest-ever quarters for the number of people moving three lowest-ever quarters for the number of people moving off three lowest-ever quarters for the number of people moving off benefit number of people moving off benefit and number of people moving off benefit and into number of people moving off benefit and into work? number of people moving off benefit and into work? As number of people moving off benefit and into work? As I've number of people moving off benefit and into work? As I've already and into work? As I've already stated, and into work? As I've already stated, what and into work? As I've already stated, what we've and into work? As I've already stated, what we've seen and into work? As I've already stated, what we've seen is, stated, what we've seen is, actuallying stated, what we've seen is, actuallying an stated, what we've seen is, actuallying an increase stated, what we've seen is, actuallying an increase in stated, what we've seen is, actuallying an increase in the actuallying an increase in the number actuallying an increase in the number of actuallying an increase in the number of people actuallying an increase in the number of people exiting actuallying an increase in the number of people exiting benefit actuallying an increase in the number of people exiting benefit for number of people exiting benefit for work, number of people exiting benefit for work, Mr number of people exiting benefit for work, Mr Speaker. number of people exiting benefit for work, Mr Speaker. Quite number of people exiting benefit for work, Mr Speaker. Quite often number of people exiting benefit for work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in this work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in this House, work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in this House, the work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in this House, the member work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in this House, the member likes work, Mr Speaker. Quite often in this House, the member likes to this House, the member likes to refer this House, the member likes to refer to this House, the member likes to refer to the this House, the member likes to refer to the raw this House, the member likes to refer to the raw figures, this House, the member likes to refer to the raw figures, Mr refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but even refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but even if refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but even if we refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but even if we look refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but even if we look at refer to the raw figures, Mr Speaker, but even if we look at the Speaker, but even if we look at the proportion Speaker, but even if we look at the proportion of Speaker, but even if we look at the proportion of working Speaker, but even if we look at the proportion of working age Speaker, but even if we look at the proportion of working age New proportion of working age New Zealanders proportion of working age New Zealanders on proportion of working age New Zealanders on benefit, proportion of working age New Zealanders on benefit, at proportion of working age New Zealanders on benefit, at the proportion of working age New Zealanders on benefit, at the moment Zealanders on benefit, at the moment it's Zealanders on benefit, at the moment it's 10.5% Zealanders on benefit, at the moment it's 10.5% compared Zealanders on benefit, at the moment it's 10.5% compared to Zealanders on benefit, at the moment it's 10.5% compared to December it's 10.5% compared to December 2014, it's 10.5% compared to December 2014, where it's 10.5% compared to December 2014, where it it's 10.5% compared to December 2014, where it was it's 10.5% compared to December 2014, where it was 11.2%. Does Does she Does she believe Does she believe that Does she believe that the Does she believe that the Government's Does she believe that the Government's plan Does she believe that the Government's plan is Does she believe that the Government's plan is paying Does she believe that the Government's plan is paying off Does she believe that the Government's plan is paying off for Government's plan is paying off for the Government's plan is paying off for the 20,000 Government's plan is paying off for the 20,000 more Government's plan is paying off for the 20,000 more New Government's plan is paying off for the 20,000 more New Zealanders Government's plan is paying off for the 20,000 more New Zealanders on the 20,000 more New Zealanders on job the 20,000 more New Zealanders on job seeker the 20,000 more New Zealanders on job seeker support the 20,000 more New Zealanders on job seeker support since the 20,000 more New Zealanders on job seeker support since Labour the 20,000 more New Zealanders on job seeker support since Labour took job seeker support since Labour took office? job seeker support since Labour took office? Mr job seeker support since Labour took office? Mr Speaker, job seeker support since Labour took office? Mr Speaker, do job seeker support since Labour took office? Mr Speaker, do I job seeker support since Labour took office? Mr Speaker, do I think job seeker support since Labour took office? Mr Speaker, do I think that office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've got office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've got more office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've got more to office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've got more to do? office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've got more to do? Absolutely, office? Mr Speaker, do I think that we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr Speaker. we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr Speaker. But we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr Speaker. But as we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr Speaker. But as I've we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr Speaker. But as I've said, we've got more to do? Absolutely, Mr Speaker. But as I've said, this Speaker. But as I've said, this Government Speaker. But as I've said, this Government is Speaker. But as I've said, this Government is focused Speaker. But as I've said, this Government is focused on Speaker. But as I've said, this Government is focused on supporting Government is focused on supporting New Government is focused on supporting New Zealanders Government is focused on supporting New Zealanders into Government is focused on supporting New Zealanders into upskilling Government is focused on supporting New Zealanders into upskilling and New Zealanders into upskilling and training, New Zealanders into upskilling and training, and New Zealanders into upskilling and training, and into New Zealanders into upskilling and training, and into employment. New Zealanders into upskilling and training, and into employment. That training, and into employment. That is training, and into employment. That is why training, and into employment. That is why we training, and into employment. That is why we have training, and into employment. That is why we have invested training, and into employment. That is why we have invested in is why we have invested in programmes is why we have invested in programmes like is why we have invested in programmes like mana is why we have invested in programmes like mana and is why we have invested in programmes like mana and mahi. is why we have invested in programmes like mana and mahi. We programmes like mana and mahi. We recognise, programmes like mana and mahi. We recognise, particularly programmes like mana and mahi. We recognise, particularly I programmes like mana and mahi. We recognise, particularly I when programmes like mana and mahi. We recognise, particularly I when I programmes like mana and mahi. We recognise, particularly I when I go recognise, particularly I when I go across recognise, particularly I when I go across the recognise, particularly I when I go across the country recognise, particularly I when I go across the country -- recognise, particularly I when I go across the country -- particularly recognise, particularly I when I go across the country -- particularly I across the country -- particularly I when across the country -- particularly I when I across the country -- particularly I when I go across the country -- particularly I when I go across across the country -- particularly I when I go across the across the country -- particularly I when I go across the country, across the country -- particularly I when I go across the country, that when I go across the country, that many when I go across the country, that many of when I go across the country, that many of the when I go across the country, that many of the jobs when I go across the country, that many of the jobs that when I go across the country, that many of the jobs that are when I go across the country, that many of the jobs that are advertised many of the jobs that are advertised within many of the jobs that are advertised within our many of the jobs that are advertised within our MSZ many of the jobs that are advertised within our MSZ office, many of the jobs that are advertised within our MSZ office, require many of the jobs that are advertised within our MSZ office, require a many of the jobs that are advertised within our MSZ office, require a -- within our MSZ office, require a -- MSD within our MSZ office, require a -- MSD Office, within our MSZ office, require a -- MSD Office, require within our MSZ office, require a -- MSD Office, require a within our MSZ office, require a -- MSD Office, require a level within our MSZ office, require a -- MSD Office, require a level of MSD Office, require a level of skill, MSD Office, require a level of skill, skill MSD Office, require a level of skill, skill that MSD Office, require a level of skill, skill that wasn't MSD Office, require a level of skill, skill that wasn't invested MSD Office, require a level of skill, skill that wasn't invested in skill, skill that wasn't invested in by skill, skill that wasn't invested in by the skill, skill that wasn't invested in by the previous skill, skill that wasn't invested in by the previous Government. skill, skill that wasn't invested in by the previous Government. People by the previous Government. People who by the previous Government. People who come by the previous Government. People who come through by the previous Government. People who come through the by the previous Government. People who come through the MSD by the previous Government. People who come through the MSD office who come through the MSD office aren't who come through the MSD office aren't necessarily who come through the MSD office aren't necessarily equipped who come through the MSD office aren't necessarily equipped with who come through the MSD office aren't necessarily equipped with the aren't necessarily equipped with the skills aren't necessarily equipped with the skills and aren't necessarily equipped with the skills and to aren't necessarily equipped with the skills and to take aren't necessarily equipped with the skills and to take in aren't necessarily equipped with the skills and to take in the aren't necessarily equipped with the skills and to take in the roles. skills and to take in the roles. We're skills and to take in the roles. We're committed skills and to take in the roles. We're committed to skills and to take in the roles. We're committed to make skills and to take in the roles. We're committed to make sure skills and to take in the roles. We're committed to make sure that We're committed to make sure that they We're committed to make sure that they have We're committed to make sure that they have those We're committed to make sure that they have those skills, We're committed to make sure that they have those skills, that We're committed to make sure that they have those skills, that they they have those skills, that they have they have those skills, that they have those they have those skills, that they have those qualifications they have those skills, that they have those qualifications and they have those skills, that they have those qualifications and that have those qualifications and that they have those qualifications and that they are have those qualifications and that they are supported have those qualifications and that they are supported into have those qualifications and that they are supported into the have those qualifications and that they are supported into the jobs they are supported into the jobs that they are supported into the jobs that are they are supported into the jobs that are available. they are supported into the jobs that are available. If they are supported into the jobs that are available. If your they are supported into the jobs that are available. If your plan they are supported into the jobs that are available. If your plan is that are available. If your plan is paying that are available. If your plan is paying off, that are available. If your plan is paying off, why that are available. If your plan is paying off, why has that are available. If your plan is paying off, why has the that are available. If your plan is paying off, why has the proportion paying off, why has the proportion of paying off, why has the proportion of people paying off, why has the proportion of people who paying off, why has the proportion of people who go paying off, why has the proportion of people who go back paying off, why has the proportion of people who go back onto paying off, why has the proportion of people who go back onto benefit, of people who go back onto benefit, 16 of people who go back onto benefit, 16 weeks of people who go back onto benefit, 16 weeks after of people who go back onto benefit, 16 weeks after completing of people who go back onto benefit, 16 weeks after completing an 16 weeks after completing an intervention, 16 weeks after completing an intervention, increased 16 weeks after completing an intervention, increased every 16 weeks after completing an intervention, increased every year intervention, increased every year under intervention, increased every year under your intervention, increased every year under your Government? intervention, increased every year under your Government? Mr intervention, increased every year under your Government? Mr Speaker, under your Government? Mr Speaker, that's under your Government? Mr Speaker, that's an under your Government? Mr Speaker, that's an interesting under your Government? Mr Speaker, that's an interesting question that's an interesting question because that's an interesting question because under that's an interesting question because under the that's an interesting question because under the previous because under the previous Government, because under the previous Government, I because under the previous Government, I was because under the previous Government, I was highly because under the previous Government, I was highly critical because under the previous Government, I was highly critical of Government, I was highly critical of the Government, I was highly critical of the fact Government, I was highly critical of the fact that Government, I was highly critical of the fact that they Government, I was highly critical of the fact that they were Government, I was highly critical of the fact that they were not Government, I was highly critical of the fact that they were not actually the fact that they were not actually measuring the fact that they were not actually measuring whether the fact that they were not actually measuring whether or the fact that they were not actually measuring whether or not the fact that they were not actually measuring whether or not the measuring whether or not the employment measuring whether or not the employment that measuring whether or not the employment that they measuring whether or not the employment that they were measuring whether or not the employment that they were putting employment that they were putting people employment that they were putting people into employment that they were putting people into was employment that they were putting people into was sustainable employment that they were putting people into was sustainable or employment that they were putting people into was sustainable or not. people into was sustainable or not. Under people into was sustainable or not. Under them, people into was sustainable or not. Under them, we people into was sustainable or not. Under them, we saw people into was sustainable or not. Under them, we saw a people into was sustainable or not. Under them, we saw a large people into was sustainable or not. Under them, we saw a large number people into was sustainable or not. Under them, we saw a large number of Under them, we saw a large number of people Under them, we saw a large number of people who Under them, we saw a large number of people who did Under them, we saw a large number of people who did exit Under them, we saw a large number of people who did exit benefit Under them, we saw a large number of people who did exit benefit for people who did exit benefit for work, people who did exit benefit for work, back people who did exit benefit for work, back on people who did exit benefit for work, back on benefit people who did exit benefit for work, back on benefit within people who did exit benefit for work, back on benefit within the work, back on benefit within the next work, back on benefit within the next 18 work, back on benefit within the next 18 months, work, back on benefit within the next 18 months, Mr work, back on benefit within the next 18 months, Mr Speaker. work, back on benefit within the next 18 months, Mr Speaker. Just next 18 months, Mr Speaker. Just recently, next 18 months, Mr Speaker. Just recently, actually, I next 18 months, Mr Speaker. Just recently, actually, I was next 18 months, Mr Speaker. Just recently, actually, I was given recently, actually, I was given advice, recently, actually, I was given advice, because recently, actually, I was given advice, because we recently, actually, I was given advice, because we are recently, actually, I was given advice, because we are starting recently, actually, I was given advice, because we are starting to advice, because we are starting to look advice, because we are starting to look at advice, because we are starting to look at sustainable advice, because we are starting to look at sustainable employment, advice, because we are starting to look at sustainable employment, that look at sustainable employment, that just look at sustainable employment, that just over look at sustainable employment, that just over the look at sustainable employment, that just over the last look at sustainable employment, that just over the last three look at sustainable employment, that just over the last three months, just over the last three months, sustainable just over the last three months, sustainable employment just over the last three months, sustainable employment places just over the last three months, sustainable employment places have sustainable employment places have gone sustainable employment places have gone up sustainable employment places have gone up month-on-month. sustainable employment places have gone up month-on-month. So sustainable employment places have gone up month-on-month. So I'm gone up month-on-month. So I'm really gone up month-on-month. So I'm really glad gone up month-on-month. So I'm really glad that, gone up month-on-month. So I'm really glad that, as gone up month-on-month. So I'm really glad that, as a gone up month-on-month. So I'm really glad that, as a Government, really glad that, as a Government, we really glad that, as a Government, we are really glad that, as a Government, we are actually really glad that, as a Government, we are actually measuring really glad that, as a Government, we are actually measuring things we are actually measuring things we are actually measuring things we are actually measuring things that count we are actually measuring things that count - we are actually measuring things that count - unlike we are actually measuring things that count - unlike the we are actually measuring things that count - unlike the previous that count - unlike the previous Government. that count - unlike the previous Government. How that count - unlike the previous Government. How many that count - unlike the previous Government. How many more that count - unlike the previous Government. How many more people Government. How many more people will Government. How many more people will go Government. How many more people will go onto Government. How many more people will go onto the Government. How many more people will go onto the dole Government. How many more people will go onto the dole before Government. How many more people will go onto the dole before you will go onto the dole before you admit will go onto the dole before you admit that will go onto the dole before you admit that your will go onto the dole before you admit that your welfare... will go onto the dole before you admit that your welfare... Order! admit that your welfare... Order! The admit that your welfare... Order! The member admit that your welfare... Order! The member is admit that your welfare... Order! The member is going admit that your welfare... Order! The member is going to admit that your welfare... Order! The member is going to start admit that your welfare... Order! The member is going to start the The member is going to start the question The member is going to start the question again. The member is going to start the question again. I've The member is going to start the question again. I've let The member is going to start the question again. I've let her The member is going to start the question again. I've let her run question again. I've let her run twice question again. I've let her run twice with question again. I've let her run twice with out question again. I've let her run twice with out of question again. I've let her run twice with out of order question again. I've let her run twice with out of order questions. twice with out of order questions. This twice with out of order questions. This time twice with out of order questions. This time she's twice with out of order questions. This time she's not twice with out of order questions. This time she's not going twice with out of order questions. This time she's not going to twice with out of order questions. This time she's not going to bring This time she's not going to bring me This time she's not going to bring me into This time she's not going to bring me into it. This time she's not going to bring me into it. How This time she's not going to bring me into it. How many This time she's not going to bring me into it. How many people This time she's not going to bring me into it. How many people will This time she's not going to bring me into it. How many people will go me into it. How many people will go onto me into it. How many people will go onto the me into it. How many people will go onto the dole me into it. How many people will go onto the dole before me into it. How many people will go onto the dole before the me into it. How many people will go onto the dole before the Minister onto the dole before the Minister admits onto the dole before the Minister admits that onto the dole before the Minister admits that her onto the dole before the Minister admits that her welfare onto the dole before the Minister admits that her welfare plans onto the dole before the Minister admits that her welfare plans aren't admits that her welfare plans aren't paying admits that her welfare plans aren't paying off admits that her welfare plans aren't paying off and admits that her welfare plans aren't paying off and consider admits that her welfare plans aren't paying off and consider taking admits that her welfare plans aren't paying off and consider taking some paying off and consider taking some advice paying off and consider taking some advice from paying off and consider taking some advice from National paying off and consider taking some advice from National about paying off and consider taking some advice from National about how paying off and consider taking some advice from National about how to advice from National about how to give advice from National about how to give people advice from National about how to give people opportunities advice from National about how to give people opportunities to advice from National about how to give people opportunities to get give people opportunities to get ahead? give people opportunities to get ahead? Mr give people opportunities to get ahead? Mr Speaker, give people opportunities to get ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm give people opportunities to get ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident with ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident with the ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident with the plan ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident with the plan that ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident with the plan that we ahead? Mr Speaker, I'm very confident with the plan that we have confident with the plan that we have in confident with the plan that we have in place confident with the plan that we have in place on confident with the plan that we have in place on this confident with the plan that we have in place on this side confident with the plan that we have in place on this side of confident with the plan that we have in place on this side of the confident with the plan that we have in place on this side of the House. in place on this side of the House. We in place on this side of the House. We recognise in place on this side of the House. We recognise that in place on this side of the House. We recognise that it in place on this side of the House. We recognise that it is in place on this side of the House. We recognise that it is about in place on this side of the House. We recognise that it is about the We recognise that it is about the welfare We recognise that it is about the welfare system, We recognise that it is about the welfare system, but We recognise that it is about the welfare system, but also We recognise that it is about the welfare system, but also about We recognise that it is about the welfare system, but also about the welfare system, but also about the investment welfare system, but also about the investment that welfare system, but also about the investment that we welfare system, but also about the investment that we put welfare system, but also about the investment that we put into investment that we put into education investment that we put into education and investment that we put into education and other investment that we put into education and other areas investment that we put into education and other areas as investment that we put into education and other areas as well. education and other areas as well. Also, education and other areas as well. Also, I education and other areas as well. Also, I would education and other areas as well. Also, I would like education and other areas as well. Also, I would like to education and other areas as well. Also, I would like to say education and other areas as well. Also, I would like to say on education and other areas as well. Also, I would like to say on the Also, I would like to say on the record Also, I would like to say on the record that Also, I would like to say on the record that if Also, I would like to say on the record that if that Also, I would like to say on the record that if that member Also, I would like to say on the record that if that member ever Also, I would like to say on the record that if that member ever asks record that if that member ever asks me record that if that member ever asks me a record that if that member ever asks me a question record that if that member ever asks me a question again record that if that member ever asks me a question again in record that if that member ever asks me a question again in this record that if that member ever asks me a question again in this House me a question again in this House about me a question again in this House about a me a question again in this House about a thing me a question again in this House about a thing called me a question again in this House about a thing called "the me a question again in this House about a thing called "the dole", about a thing called "the dole", which about a thing called "the dole", which does about a thing called "the dole", which does not about a thing called "the dole", which does not exist, about a thing called "the dole", which does not exist, I about a thing called "the dole", which does not exist, I will about a thing called "the dole", which does not exist, I will refuse which does not exist, I will refuse to which does not exist, I will refuse to answer which does not exist, I will refuse to answer the which does not exist, I will refuse to answer the questionment which does not exist, I will refuse to answer the questionment Question to answer the questionment Question to answer the questionment Question to answer the questionment Question No. 9, to answer the questionment Question No. 9, Chris to answer the questionment Question No. 9, Chris Bishop. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Transport: Minister of Transport: Does Minister of Transport: Does he Minister of Transport: Does he stand Minister of Transport: Does he stand by Does he stand by his Does he stand by his reported Does he stand by his reported comment Does he stand by his reported comment on Does he stand by his reported comment on 10 Does he stand by his reported comment on 10 July Does he stand by his reported comment on 10 July 2019 his reported comment on 10 July 2019 in his reported comment on 10 July 2019 in relation his reported comment on 10 July 2019 in relation to his reported comment on 10 July 2019 in relation to 12 his reported comment on 10 July 2019 in relation to 12 roading his reported comment on 10 July 2019 in relation to 12 roading projects in relation to 12 roading projects that in relation to 12 roading projects that "If in relation to 12 roading projects that "If we in relation to 12 roading projects that "If we were in relation to 12 roading projects that "If we were to in relation to 12 roading projects that "If we were to do that "If we were to do what that "If we were to do what the that "If we were to do what the Business that "If we were to do what the Business Advisory that "If we were to do what the Business Advisory Council what the Business Advisory Council was what the Business Advisory Council was saying, was saying, it was saying, it would was saying, it would mean it would mean spending it would mean spending a it would mean spending a great it would mean spending a great deal it would mean spending a great deal of it would mean spending a great deal of money, spending a great deal of money, more spending a great deal of money, more than spending a great deal of money, more than $12 spending a great deal of money, more than $12 billion, more than $12 billion, on more than $12 billion, on projects more than $12 billion, on projects that more than $12 billion, on projects that have on projects that have very on projects that have very low on projects that have very low economic on projects that have very low economic value," very low economic value," and very low economic value," and what very low economic value," and what role very low economic value," and what role did very low economic value," and what role did he very low economic value," and what role did he play and what role did he play in and what role did he play in the and what role did he play in the selection in the selection of in the selection of the in the selection of the transport in the selection of the transport projects of the transport projects in of the transport projects in the of the transport projects in the Government's in the Government's New in the Government's New Zealand in the Government's New Zealand Upgrade in the Government's New Zealand Upgrade Programme? Yes, Yes, in Yes, in the Yes, in the context Yes, in the context it Yes, in the context it was Yes, in the context it was made. Yes, in the context it was made. As Yes, in the context it was made. As the Yes, in the context it was made. As the member Yes, in the context it was made. As the member knows, Yes, in the context it was made. As the member knows, I Yes, in the context it was made. As the member knows, I think, Yes, in the context it was made. As the member knows, I think, these the member knows, I think, these projects the member knows, I think, these projects have the member knows, I think, these projects have been the member knows, I think, these projects have been re-evaluated the member knows, I think, these projects have been re-evaluated to projects have been re-evaluated to align projects have been re-evaluated to align with projects have been re-evaluated to align with our projects have been re-evaluated to align with our Government projects have been re-evaluated to align with our Government Policy align with our Government Policy Statement align with our Government Policy Statement on align with our Government Policy Statement on land align with our Government Policy Statement on land transport, align with our Government Policy Statement on land transport, which Statement on land transport, which includes Statement on land transport, which includes value Statement on land transport, which includes value for Statement on land transport, which includes value for money Statement on land transport, which includes value for money as Statement on land transport, which includes value for money as a includes value for money as a priority. includes value for money as a priority. Our includes value for money as a priority. Our state includes value for money as a priority. Our state highway includes value for money as a priority. Our state highway projects priority. Our state highway projects have priority. Our state highway projects have been priority. Our state highway projects have been future-proofed priority. Our state highway projects have been future-proofed to priority. Our state highway projects have been future-proofed to include have been future-proofed to include dedicated have been future-proofed to include dedicated walking have been future-proofed to include dedicated walking and have been future-proofed to include dedicated walking and cycling have been future-proofed to include dedicated walking and cycling paths, dedicated walking and cycling paths, and dedicated walking and cycling paths, and with dedicated walking and cycling paths, and with NZTA dedicated walking and cycling paths, and with NZTA looking dedicated walking and cycling paths, and with NZTA looking to dedicated walking and cycling paths, and with NZTA looking to managed and with NZTA looking to managed lanes and with NZTA looking to managed lanes dedicated and with NZTA looking to managed lanes dedicated to and with NZTA looking to managed lanes dedicated to freight, and with NZTA looking to managed lanes dedicated to freight, high lanes dedicated to freight, high lanes lanes dedicated to freight, high occupancy vehicles and lanes dedicated to freight, high occupancy vehicles and public occupancy vehicles and public transport. occupancy vehicles and public transport. Too occupancy vehicles and public transport. Too the occupancy vehicles and public transport. Too the second occupancy vehicles and public transport. Too the second part occupancy vehicles and public transport. Too the second part of transport. Too the second part of the transport. Too the second part of the question, transport. Too the second part of the question, I transport. Too the second part of the question, I worked transport. Too the second part of the question, I worked closely transport. Too the second part of the question, I worked closely with the question, I worked closely with the the question, I worked closely with the Minister the question, I worked closely with the Minister of the question, I worked closely with the Minister of Finance, the question, I worked closely with the Minister of Finance, relying the question, I worked closely with the Minister of Finance, relying on the Minister of Finance, relying on NZTA's the Minister of Finance, relying on NZTA's advice the Minister of Finance, relying on NZTA's advice on the Minister of Finance, relying on NZTA's advice on the the Minister of Finance, relying on NZTA's advice on the selection the Minister of Finance, relying on NZTA's advice on the selection of NZTA's advice on the selection of multimodal NZTA's advice on the selection of multimodal transport NZTA's advice on the selection of multimodal transport projects NZTA's advice on the selection of multimodal transport projects for multimodal transport projects for the multimodal transport projects for the Upgrade multimodal transport projects for the Upgrade Programme, multimodal transport projects for the Upgrade Programme, which multimodal transport projects for the Upgrade Programme, which will the Upgrade Programme, which will speed the Upgrade Programme, which will speed up the Upgrade Programme, which will speed up travel the Upgrade Programme, which will speed up travel times, the Upgrade Programme, which will speed up travel times, ease speed up travel times, ease congestion, speed up travel times, ease congestion, make speed up travel times, ease congestion, make our speed up travel times, ease congestion, make our roads speed up travel times, ease congestion, make our roads safer, congestion, make our roads safer, and congestion, make our roads safer, and give congestion, make our roads safer, and give people congestion, make our roads safer, and give people real congestion, make our roads safer, and give people real transport and give people real transport choices. and give people real transport choices. Does and give people real transport choices. Does he and give people real transport choices. Does he still and give people real transport choices. Does he still think and give people real transport choices. Does he still think New choices. Does he still think New Zealand choices. Does he still think New Zealand has choices. Does he still think New Zealand has over-invested choices. Does he still think New Zealand has over-invested in choices. Does he still think New Zealand has over-invested in roads Zealand has over-invested in roads and Zealand has over-invested in roads and motorways Zealand has over-invested in roads and motorways for Zealand has over-invested in roads and motorways for decades? Zealand has over-invested in roads and motorways for decades? I Zealand has over-invested in roads and motorways for decades? I stand and motorways for decades? I stand by and motorways for decades? I stand by the and motorways for decades? I stand by the full and motorways for decades? I stand by the full quotation, and motorways for decades? I stand by the full quotation, not and motorways for decades? I stand by the full quotation, not the and motorways for decades? I stand by the full quotation, not the one by the full quotation, not the one that by the full quotation, not the one that has by the full quotation, not the one that has been by the full quotation, not the one that has been so by the full quotation, not the one that has been so selectively that has been so selectively misrepresented that has been so selectively misrepresented by that has been so selectively misrepresented by the that has been so selectively misrepresented by the National misrepresented by the National Party. misrepresented by the National Party. What misrepresented by the National Party. What I misrepresented by the National Party. What I said misrepresented by the National Party. What I said was misrepresented by the National Party. What I said was that misrepresented by the National Party. What I said was that New Party. What I said was that New Zealand Party. What I said was that New Zealand has, Party. What I said was that New Zealand has, in Party. What I said was that New Zealand has, in the Party. What I said was that New Zealand has, in the past, Zealand has, in the past, underinvested Zealand has, in the past, underinvested in Zealand has, in the past, underinvested in roads Zealand has, in the past, underinvested in roads at Zealand has, in the past, underinvested in roads at the underinvested in roads at the expense underinvested in roads at the expense of underinvested in roads at the expense of other underinvested in roads at the expense of other parts underinvested in roads at the expense of other parts of underinvested in roads at the expense of other parts of the expense of other parts of the transport expense of other parts of the transport certainly expense of other parts of the transport certainly particularly transport certainly particularly public transport certainly particularly public transport. transport certainly particularly public transport. I transport certainly particularly public transport. I stand transport certainly particularly public transport. I stand by transport certainly particularly public transport. I stand by that, public transport. I stand by that, and public transport. I stand by that, and our public transport. I stand by that, and our Government public transport. I stand by that, and our Government is public transport. I stand by that, and our Government is dedicated public transport. I stand by that, and our Government is dedicated to public transport. I stand by that, and our Government is dedicated to a and our Government is dedicated to a balanced, and our Government is dedicated to a balanced, modern and our Government is dedicated to a balanced, modern transport and our Government is dedicated to a balanced, modern transport policy balanced, modern transport policy that balanced, modern transport policy that serves balanced, modern transport policy that serves the balanced, modern transport policy that serves the whole balanced, modern transport policy that serves the whole country balanced, modern transport policy that serves the whole country and that serves the whole country and all that serves the whole country and all transport that serves the whole country and all transport modes. that serves the whole country and all transport modes. I that serves the whole country and all transport modes. I am that serves the whole country and all transport modes. I am just that serves the whole country and all transport modes. I am just going all transport modes. I am just going to all transport modes. I am just going to interrupt. all transport modes. I am just going to interrupt. I all transport modes. I am just going to interrupt. I think all transport modes. I am just going to interrupt. I think the all transport modes. I am just going to interrupt. I think the member to interrupt. I think the member might to interrupt. I think the member might have to interrupt. I think the member might have misspoken to interrupt. I think the member might have misspoken right to interrupt. I think the member might have misspoken right at to interrupt. I think the member might have misspoken right at the might have misspoken right at the beginning might have misspoken right at the beginning of might have misspoken right at the beginning of his might have misspoken right at the beginning of his quotation. might have misspoken right at the beginning of his quotation. It might have misspoken right at the beginning of his quotation. It might beginning of his quotation. It might be beginning of his quotation. It might be good beginning of his quotation. It might be good to beginning of his quotation. It might be good to tidy beginning of his quotation. It might be good to tidy it beginning of his quotation. It might be good to tidy it up beginning of his quotation. It might be good to tidy it up now. beginning of his quotation. It might be good to tidy it up now. Thank be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, Mr be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, Mr Speaker. be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The full be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The full quote be good to tidy it up now. Thank you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that New you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that New Zealand you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that New Zealand has, you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that New Zealand has, in you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that New Zealand has, in the you, Mr Speaker. The full quote was that New Zealand has, in the past, that New Zealand has, in the past, that that New Zealand has, in the past, over-invested in roads that New Zealand has, in the past, over-invested in roads at that New Zealand has, in the past, over-invested in roads at the over-invested in roads at the expense over-invested in roads at the expense of over-invested in roads at the expense of other over-invested in roads at the expense of other parts over-invested in roads at the expense of other parts of over-invested in roads at the expense of other parts of the expense of other parts of the transport expense of other parts of the transport system. expense of other parts of the transport system. Thank expense of other parts of the transport system. Thank you. expense of other parts of the transport system. Thank you. Why expense of other parts of the transport system. Thank you. Why did transport system. Thank you. Why did the transport system. Thank you. Why did the Canterbury transport system. Thank you. Why did the Canterbury region transport system. Thank you. Why did the Canterbury region receive transport system. Thank you. Why did the Canterbury region receive only the Canterbury region receive only 2.3% the Canterbury region receive only 2.3% of the Canterbury region receive only 2.3% of the the Canterbury region receive only 2.3% of the $6.8 the Canterbury region receive only 2.3% of the $6.8 billion the Canterbury region receive only 2.3% of the $6.8 billion transport 2.3% of the $6.8 billion transport component 2.3% of the $6.8 billion transport component of 2.3% of the $6.8 billion transport component of the 2.3% of the $6.8 billion transport component of the Upgrade 2.3% of the $6.8 billion transport component of the Upgrade Programme? component of the Upgrade Programme? So, component of the Upgrade Programme? So, Mr component of the Upgrade Programme? So, Mr Speaker, component of the Upgrade Programme? So, Mr Speaker, I component of the Upgrade Programme? So, Mr Speaker, I would component of the Upgrade Programme? So, Mr Speaker, I would note component of the Upgrade Programme? So, Mr Speaker, I would note that So, Mr Speaker, I would note that there So, Mr Speaker, I would note that there has So, Mr Speaker, I would note that there has been So, Mr Speaker, I would note that there has been substantial So, Mr Speaker, I would note that there has been substantial transport there has been substantial transport investment there has been substantial transport investment in there has been substantial transport investment in Canterbury there has been substantial transport investment in Canterbury in there has been substantial transport investment in Canterbury in the there has been substantial transport investment in Canterbury in the last investment in Canterbury in the last few investment in Canterbury in the last few years... investment in Canterbury in the last few years... <INTERRUPTION> few years... <INTERRUPTION> few years... <INTERRUPTION> ..an few years... <INTERRUPTION> ..an entire few years... <INTERRUPTION> ..an entire new few years... <INTERRUPTION> ..an entire new motorway few years... <INTERRUPTION> ..an entire new motorway network ..an entire new motorway network hack ..an entire new motorway network hack constructed. ..an entire new motorway network hack constructed. ald ..an entire new motorway network hack constructed. ald say ..an entire new motorway network hack constructed. ald say that ..an entire new motorway network hack constructed. ald say that -- ..an entire new motorway network hack constructed. ald say that -- I hack constructed. ald say that -- I would hack constructed. ald say that -- I would also hack constructed. ald say that -- I would also say, hack constructed. ald say that -- I would also say, under hack constructed. ald say that -- I would also say, under this would also say, under this Government would also say, under this Government the would also say, under this Government the South would also say, under this Government the South Island would also say, under this Government the South Island is Government the South Island is getting Government the South Island is getting $3.9 Government the South Island is getting $3.9 million Government the South Island is getting $3.9 million because Government the South Island is getting $3.9 million because of Government the South Island is getting $3.9 million because of the getting $3.9 million because of the transport getting $3.9 million because of the transport project. getting $3.9 million because of the transport project. This getting $3.9 million because of the transport project. This Government transport project. This Government is transport project. This Government is spending transport project. This Government is spending more transport project. This Government is spending more on transport project. This Government is spending more on transport transport project. This Government is spending more on transport than is spending more on transport than the is spending more on transport than the former is spending more on transport than the former Government is spending more on transport than the former Government did is spending more on transport than the former Government did in is spending more on transport than the former Government did in the the former Government did in the South the former Government did in the South Island. the former Government did in the South Island. Has the former Government did in the South Island. Has he the former Government did in the South Island. Has he received the former Government did in the South Island. Has he received any South Island. Has he received any correspondence South Island. Has he received any correspondence from South Island. Has he received any correspondence from Julie South Island. Has he received any correspondence from Julie Anne correspondence from Julie Anne Genter correspondence from Julie Anne Genter in correspondence from Julie Anne Genter in her correspondence from Julie Anne Genter in her capacity correspondence from Julie Anne Genter in her capacity as correspondence from Julie Anne Genter in her capacity as Transport Genter in her capacity as Transport spokesperson Genter in her capacity as Transport spokesperson for Genter in her capacity as Transport spokesperson for the Genter in her capacity as Transport spokesperson for the Green Genter in her capacity as Transport spokesperson for the Green Party Genter in her capacity as Transport spokesperson for the Green Party or, spokesperson for the Green Party or, indeed, spokesperson for the Green Party or, indeed, the spokesperson for the Green Party or, indeed, the Associate spokesperson for the Green Party or, indeed, the Associate Minister spokesperson for the Green Party or, indeed, the Associate Minister of indeed, the Associate Minister of Transport, indeed, the Associate Minister of Transport, in indeed, the Associate Minister of Transport, in relation indeed, the Associate Minister of Transport, in relation to indeed, the Associate Minister of Transport, in relation to the Transport, in relation to the transport Transport, in relation to the transport component Transport, in relation to the transport component of Transport, in relation to the transport component of the Transport, in relation to the transport component of the Upgrade transport component of the Upgrade Programme? transport component of the Upgrade Programme? I transport component of the Upgrade Programme? I have transport component of the Upgrade Programme? I have received Programme? I have received correspondence Programme? I have received correspondence from Programme? I have received correspondence from the Programme? I have received correspondence from the Associate correspondence from the Associate Minister correspondence from the Associate Minister and correspondence from the Associate Minister and I'm correspondence from the Associate Minister and I'm pleased correspondence from the Associate Minister and I'm pleased to correspondence from the Associate Minister and I'm pleased to say correspondence from the Associate Minister and I'm pleased to say that Minister and I'm pleased to say that both Minister and I'm pleased to say that both the Minister and I'm pleased to say that both the Coalition Minister and I'm pleased to say that both the Coalition and Minister and I'm pleased to say that both the Coalition and our both the Coalition and our confidence both the Coalition and our confidence in both the Coalition and our confidence in supply both the Coalition and our confidence in supply partners both the Coalition and our confidence in supply partners have confidence in supply partners have been confidence in supply partners have been fully confidence in supply partners have been fully involved confidence in supply partners have been fully involved in confidence in supply partners have been fully involved in the confidence in supply partners have been fully involved in the design been fully involved in the design and been fully involved in the design and development been fully involved in the design and development of been fully involved in the design and development of the been fully involved in the design and development of the informZ and development of the informZ Upgrade and development of the informZ Upgrade programme and development of the informZ Upgrade programme and and development of the informZ Upgrade programme and they and development of the informZ Upgrade programme and they support Upgrade programme and they support it. Upgrade programme and they support it. How Upgrade programme and they support it. How many Upgrade programme and they support it. How many of Upgrade programme and they support it. How many of the Upgrade programme and they support it. How many of the 12 Upgrade programme and they support it. How many of the 12 roading it. How many of the 12 roading projects it. How many of the 12 roading projects mentioned it. How many of the 12 roading projects mentioned in it. How many of the 12 roading projects mentioned in the it. How many of the 12 roading projects mentioned in the primary projects mentioned in the primary question projects mentioned in the primary question were projects mentioned in the primary question were fully projects mentioned in the primary question were fully planned, question were fully planned, consented question were fully planned, consented and question were fully planned, consented and fully-funded question were fully planned, consented and fully-funded when question were fully planned, consented and fully-funded when he consented and fully-funded when he became consented and fully-funded when he became the consented and fully-funded when he became the Minister? consented and fully-funded when he became the Minister? Well, consented and fully-funded when he became the Minister? Well, Mr became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, it's became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, it's a became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, it's a very became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, it's a very short became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, it's a very short answer became the Minister? Well, Mr Speaker, it's a very short answer - Speaker, it's a very short answer - there Speaker, it's a very short answer - there were Speaker, it's a very short answer - there were none Speaker, it's a very short answer - there were none that Speaker, it's a very short answer - there were none that were Speaker, it's a very short answer - there were none that were fully there were none that were fully planned, there were none that were fully planned, designated, there were none that were fully planned, designated, scon there were none that were fully planned, designated, scon -- planned, designated, scon -- consented planned, designated, scon -- consented or planned, designated, scon -- consented or funded. planned, designated, scon -- consented or funded. Zero. planned, designated, scon -- consented or funded. Zero. The planned, designated, scon -- consented or funded. Zero. The Hon consented or funded. Zero. The Hon Shane consented or funded. Zero. The Hon Shane Jonesment consented or funded. Zero. The Hon Shane Jonesment Can consented or funded. Zero. The Hon Shane Jonesment Can he consented or funded. Zero. The Hon Shane Jonesment Can he confirm consented or funded. Zero. The Hon Shane Jonesment Can he confirm that Shane Jonesment Can he confirm that the Shane Jonesment Can he confirm that the four-lane Shane Jonesment Can he confirm that the four-lane stretch Shane Jonesment Can he confirm that the four-lane stretch of Shane Jonesment Can he confirm that the four-lane stretch of highway the four-lane stretch of highway from the four-lane stretch of highway from Whangarei the four-lane stretch of highway from Whangarei to the four-lane stretch of highway from Whangarei to Marsden the four-lane stretch of highway from Whangarei to Marsden Point from Whangarei to Marsden Point reflects from Whangarei to Marsden Point reflects the from Whangarei to Marsden Point reflects the very from Whangarei to Marsden Point reflects the very strong reflects the very strong collaborative reflects the very strong collaborative relationship reflects the very strong collaborative relationship he reflects the very strong collaborative relationship he has collaborative relationship he has with collaborative relationship he has with the collaborative relationship he has with the Associate collaborative relationship he has with the Associate Transport with the Associate Transport Minister? with the Associate Transport Minister? I with the Associate Transport Minister? I can with the Associate Transport Minister? I can confirm with the Associate Transport Minister? I can confirm that. with the Associate Transport Minister? I can confirm that. The Minister? I can confirm that. The Associate Minister? I can confirm that. The Associate Transport Minister? I can confirm that. The Associate Transport Minister Minister? I can confirm that. The Associate Transport Minister made Associate Transport Minister made very Associate Transport Minister made very strong Associate Transport Minister made very strong representations Associate Transport Minister made very strong representations on very strong representations on behalf very strong representations on behalf of very strong representations on behalf of the very strong representations on behalf of the people very strong representations on behalf of the people of very strong representations on behalf of the people of the very strong representations on behalf of the people of the North. behalf of the people of the North. The behalf of the people of the North. The response behalf of the people of the North. The response from behalf of the people of the North. The response from the behalf of the people of the North. The response from the people behalf of the people of the North. The response from the people of behalf of the people of the North. The response from the people of the The response from the people of the North The response from the people of the North has The response from the people of the North has been The response from the people of the North has been very, The response from the people of the North has been very, very The response from the people of the North has been very, very positive. North has been very, very positive. Is North has been very, very positive. Is he North has been very, very positive. Is he aware North has been very, very positive. Is he aware if North has been very, very positive. Is he aware if any North has been very, very positive. Is he aware if any funding North has been very, very positive. Is he aware if any funding was Is he aware if any funding was provided Is he aware if any funding was provided to Is he aware if any funding was provided to progress Is he aware if any funding was provided to progress Sky Is he aware if any funding was provided to progress Sky Path Is he aware if any funding was provided to progress Sky Path after provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki Kaye provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki Kaye said provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki Kaye said in provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki Kaye said in 2016 provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she provided to progress Sky Path after Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really wants Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really wants the Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really wants the project Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really wants the project to Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really wants the project to happen? Nikki Kaye said in 2016 she really wants the project to happen? In wants the project to happen? In spite wants the project to happen? In spite of wants the project to happen? In spite of the wants the project to happen? In spite of the enthusiasm... wants the project to happen? In spite of the enthusiasm... Order! spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who was spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who was that? spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who was that? No, spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who was that? No, who spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who was that? No, who made spite of the enthusiasm... Order! Who was that? No, who made the Who was that? No, who made the interjection Who was that? No, who made the Who Who was that? No, who made the interjection then as Who was that? No, who made the interjection then as to Who was that? No, who made the interjection then as to the Who was that? No, who made the interjection then as to the date Who was that? No, who made the interjection then as to the date of interjection then as to the date of my interjection then as to the date of my birth, interjection then as to the date of my birth, a interjection then as to the date of my birth, a totally interjection then as to the date of my birth, a totally inaccurate interjection then as to the date of my birth, a totally inaccurate one? my birth, a totally inaccurate one? Mr my birth, a totally inaccurate one? Mr O'Connor my birth, a totally inaccurate one? Mr O'Connor will my birth, a totally inaccurate one? Mr O'Connor will stand, my birth, a totally inaccurate one? Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw my birth, a totally inaccurate one? Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw and Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw and apologise. Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw and apologise. I Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and Mr O'Connor will stand, withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. I apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. I think apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. I think we'll apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. I think we'll go apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. I think we'll go back apologise. I withdraw and apologise. Thank you. I think we'll go back to Thank you. I think we'll go back to - Thank you. I think we'll go back to - we Thank you. I think we'll go back to - we were... Thank you. I think we'll go back to - we were... In Thank you. I think we'll go back to - we were... In spite Thank you. I think we'll go back to - we were... In spite of Thank you. I think we'll go back to - we were... In spite of the - we were... In spite of the enthusiasm - we were... In spite of the enthusiasm of - we were... In spite of the enthusiasm of the - we were... In spite of the enthusiasm of the Auckland - we were... In spite of the enthusiasm of the Auckland Central enthusiasm of the Auckland Central Member enthusiasm of the Auckland Central Member of enthusiasm of the Auckland Central Member of Parliament, enthusiasm of the Auckland Central Member of Parliament, the enthusiasm of the Auckland Central Member of Parliament, the Transport Member of Parliament, the Transport Minister Member of Parliament, the Transport Minister at Member of Parliament, the Transport Minister at the Member of Parliament, the Transport Minister at the time, Member of Parliament, the Transport Minister at the time, Simon Member of Parliament, the Transport Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did not Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did not put Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did not put any Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did not put any funding Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did not put any funding towards Minister at the time, Simon Bridges, did not put any funding towards Sky did not put any funding towards Sky Path did not put any funding towards Sky Path at did not put any funding towards Sky Path at all did not put any funding towards Sky Path at all but, did not put any funding towards Sky Path at all but, luckily did not put any funding towards Sky Path at all but, luckily for did not put any funding towards Sky Path at all but, luckily for Ms Path at all but, luckily for Ms Kaye, Path at all but, luckily for Ms Kaye, this Path at all but, luckily for Ms Kaye, this Government Path at all but, luckily for Ms Kaye, this Government has Path at all but, luckily for Ms Kaye, this Government has guaranteed Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding not Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding not only Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding not only for Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding not only for Sky Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding not only for Sky Path Kaye, this Government has guaranteed funding not only for Sky Path but funding not only for Sky Path but the funding not only for Sky Path but the 3-kilometre funding not only for Sky Path but the 3-kilometre shared funding not only for Sky Path but the 3-kilometre shared path the 3-kilometre shared path connecting the 3-kilometre shared path connecting the the 3-kilometre shared path connecting the Sky the 3-kilometre shared path connecting the Sky Path the 3-kilometre shared path connecting the Sky Path to the 3-kilometre shared path connecting the Sky Path to Northcote connecting the Sky Path to Northcote and connecting the Sky Path to Northcote and Takapuna. connecting the Sky Path to Northcote and Takapuna. How connecting the Sky Path to Northcote and Takapuna. How much connecting the Sky Path to Northcote and Takapuna. How much is connecting the Sky Path to Northcote and Takapuna. How much is earmarked and Takapuna. How much is earmarked for and Takapuna. How much is earmarked for green and Takapuna. How much is earmarked for green transport, and Takapuna. How much is earmarked for green transport, and and Takapuna. How much is earmarked for green transport, and did and Takapuna. How much is earmarked for green transport, and did the for green transport, and did the previous for green transport, and did the previous Government for green transport, and did the previous Government fund for green transport, and did the previous Government fund any for green transport, and did the previous Government fund any of for green transport, and did the previous Government fund any of it? previous Government fund any of it? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm going <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm going to <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm going to remind <INTERRUPTION> Order! I'm going to remind members Order! I'm going to remind members for Order! I'm going to remind members for the Order! I'm going to remind members for the last Order! I'm going to remind members for the last time, Order! I'm going to remind members for the last time, including Order! I'm going to remind members for the last time, including the for the last time, including the member for the last time, including the member sitting for the last time, including the member sitting next for the last time, including the member sitting next to for the last time, including the member sitting next to the for the last time, including the member sitting next to the Shadow member sitting next to the Shadow Leader member sitting next to the Shadow Leader of member sitting next to the Shadow Leader of the member sitting next to the Shadow Leader of the House, member sitting next to the Shadow Leader of the House, that member sitting next to the Shadow Leader of the House, that they member sitting next to the Shadow Leader of the House, that they do Leader of the House, that they do not Leader of the House, that they do not interject Leader of the House, that they do not interject during Leader of the House, that they do not interject during the Leader of the House, that they do not interject during the asking Leader of the House, that they do not interject during the asking of not interject during the asking of questions. not interject during the asking of questions. Phil not interject during the asking of questions. Phil Twyford. not interject during the asking of questions. Phil Twyford. The not interject during the asking of questions. Phil Twyford. The New questions. Phil Twyford. The New Zealand questions. Phil Twyford. The New Zealand Upgrade questions. Phil Twyford. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme questions. Phil Twyford. The New Zealand Upgrade Programme will Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver approximately Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver approximately $1.6 Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver approximately $1.6 billion deliver approximately $1.6 billion of deliver approximately $1.6 billion of funding deliver approximately $1.6 billion of funding for deliver approximately $1.6 billion of funding for new, deliver approximately $1.6 billion of funding for new, clean deliver approximately $1.6 billion of funding for new, clean transport of funding for new, clean transport projects of funding for new, clean transport projects - of funding for new, clean transport projects - none of funding for new, clean transport projects - none of of funding for new, clean transport projects - none of which of funding for new, clean transport projects - none of which had of funding for new, clean transport projects - none of which had funding projects - none of which had funding set projects - none of which had funding set aside projects - none of which had funding set aside under projects - none of which had funding set aside under the projects - none of which had funding set aside under the previous set aside under the previous Government. set aside under the previous Government. This set aside under the previous Government. This includes set aside under the previous Government. This includes $370 Government. This includes $370 million Government. This includes $370 million for Government. This includes $370 million for extending Government. This includes $370 million for extending rail million for extending rail electrification million for extending rail electrification to million for extending rail electrification to Pukakoihi million for extending rail electrification to Pukakoihi and electrification to Pukakoihi and more electrification to Pukakoihi and more than electrification to Pukakoihi and more than $100 electrification to Pukakoihi and more than $100 million electrification to Pukakoihi and more than $100 million to electrification to Pukakoihi and more than $100 million to deliver more than $100 million to deliver faster, more than $100 million to deliver faster, more more than $100 million to deliver faster, more frequent more than $100 million to deliver faster, more frequent bus more than $100 million to deliver faster, more frequent bus services faster, more frequent bus services in faster, more frequent bus services in Christchurch faster, more frequent bus services in Christchurch and faster, more frequent bus services in Christchurch and Queenstown. faster, more frequent bus services in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is it in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is it true in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is it true the in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is it true the New in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is it true the New Zealand in Christchurch and Queenstown. Is it true the New Zealand Upgrade it true the New Zealand Upgrade Programme it true the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will it true the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver it true the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver as it true the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will deliver as many Programme will deliver as many kilometres Programme will deliver as many kilometres as Programme will deliver as many kilometres as safe, Programme will deliver as many kilometres as safe, separated kilometres as safe, separated cycleways kilometres as safe, separated cycleways as kilometres as safe, separated cycleways as new kilometres as safe, separated cycleways as new state kilometres as safe, separated cycleways as new state highways? cycleways as new state highways? Yes, cycleways as new state highways? Yes, the cycleways as new state highways? Yes, the New cycleways as new state highways? Yes, the New Zealand cycleways as new state highways? Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Programme Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will see Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will see 99km Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will see 99km of Yes, the New Zealand Upgrade Programme will see 99km of safe, Programme will see 99km of safe, separated Programme will see 99km of safe, separated walking Programme will see 99km of safe, separated walking and Programme will see 99km of safe, separated walking and cycling separated walking and cycling facilities separated walking and cycling facilities rolled separated walking and cycling facilities rolled out separated walking and cycling facilities rolled out across separated walking and cycling facilities rolled out across the facilities rolled out across the country facilities rolled out across the country so facilities rolled out across the country so that facilities rolled out across the country so that people facilities rolled out across the country so that people feel facilities rolled out across the country so that people feel safe country so that people feel safe walking country so that people feel safe walking and country so that people feel safe walking and cycling country so that people feel safe walking and cycling with country so that people feel safe walking and cycling with their country so that people feel safe walking and cycling with their kids. walking and cycling with their kids. Question walking and cycling with their kids. Question number walking and cycling with their kids. Question number 10, walking and cycling with their kids. Question number 10, Angie Question number 10, Angie Warren-Clark. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: Minister of Health: What Minister of Health: What recent Minister of Health: What recent announcements What recent announcements has What recent announcements has he What recent announcements has he made has he made about has he made about child has he made about child and has he made about child and maternal has he made about child and maternal health about child and maternal health facilities? The The Hon The Hon Clark The Hon Clark -- The Hon Clark -- Hon The Hon Clark -- Hon David The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. New The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. New Zealand's The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. New Zealand's ambition The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. New Zealand's ambition is The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. New Zealand's ambition is to The Hon Clark -- Hon David Clark. New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand's ambition is to make New New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand the New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand the best New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand the best place New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand the best place to New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand the best place to be New Zealand's ambition is to make New Zealand the best place to be a New Zealand the best place to be a child. New Zealand the best place to be a child. $83 New Zealand the best place to be a child. $83 million New Zealand the best place to be a child. $83 million has New Zealand the best place to be a child. $83 million has been New Zealand the best place to be a child. $83 million has been set child. $83 million has been set aside child. $83 million has been set aside for child. $83 million has been set aside for child child. $83 million has been set aside for child and child. $83 million has been set aside for child and maternal child. $83 million has been set aside for child and maternal health aside for child and maternal health facilities. aside for child and maternal health facilities. We're aside for child and maternal health facilities. We're investing aside for child and maternal health facilities. We're investing in facilities. We're investing in neonatal facilities. We're investing in neonatal and facilities. We're investing in neonatal and paediatric facilities. We're investing in neonatal and paediatric intensive neonatal and paediatric intensive care neonatal and paediatric intensive care units neonatal and paediatric intensive care units in neonatal and paediatric intensive care units in Auckland, neonatal and paediatric intensive care units in Auckland, Hutt neonatal and paediatric intensive care units in Auckland, Hutt Valley. care units in Auckland, Hutt Valley. We're care units in Auckland, Hutt Valley. We're investing care units in Auckland, Hutt Valley. We're investing in care units in Auckland, Hutt Valley. We're investing in maternal We're investing in maternal facilities We're investing in maternal facilities in We're investing in maternal facilities in Hutt We're investing in maternal facilities in Hutt Valley We're investing in maternal facilities in Hutt Valley in We're investing in maternal facilities in Hutt Valley in South facilities in Hutt Valley in South Canterbury facilities in Hutt Valley in South Canterbury and facilities in Hutt Valley in South Canterbury and new, facilities in Hutt Valley in South Canterbury and new, and facilities in Hutt Valley in South Canterbury and new, and upgraded Canterbury and new, and upgraded dental Canterbury and new, and upgraded dental vans. Canterbury and new, and upgraded dental vans. These Canterbury and new, and upgraded dental vans. These projects Canterbury and new, and upgraded dental vans. These projects will dental vans. These projects will make dental vans. These projects will make a dental vans. These projects will make a real dental vans. These projects will make a real difference dental vans. These projects will make a real difference to dental vans. These projects will make a real difference to families make a real difference to families up make a real difference to families up and make a real difference to families up and down make a real difference to families up and down New make a real difference to families up and down New Zealand. make a real difference to families up and down New Zealand. How make a real difference to families up and down New Zealand. How will up and down New Zealand. How will patients up and down New Zealand. How will patients at up and down New Zealand. How will patients at Starship up and down New Zealand. How will patients at Starship Hospital patients at Starship Hospital benefit patients at Starship Hospital benefit from patients at Starship Hospital benefit from the patients at Starship Hospital benefit from the New patients at Starship Hospital benefit from the New Zealand benefit from the New Zealand Upgrade? benefit from the New Zealand Upgrade? Starship benefit from the New Zealand Upgrade? Starship is benefit from the New Zealand Upgrade? Starship is home benefit from the New Zealand Upgrade? Starship is home to benefit from the New Zealand Upgrade? Starship is home to New Upgrade? Starship is home to New Zealand's Upgrade? Starship is home to New Zealand's only Upgrade? Starship is home to New Zealand's only specialist Upgrade? Starship is home to New Zealand's only specialist and Zealand's only specialist and paediatric Zealand's only specialist and paediatric intensive Zealand's only specialist and paediatric intensive scare paediatric intensive scare specialists. paediatric intensive scare specialists. They paediatric intensive scare specialists. They do paediatric intensive scare specialists. They do amazing paediatric intensive scare specialists. They do amazing work, specialists. They do amazing work, they specialists. They do amazing work, they look specialists. They do amazing work, they look after specialists. They do amazing work, they look after the specialists. They do amazing work, they look after the most specialists. They do amazing work, they look after the most unwell they look after the most unwell children they look after the most unwell children from they look after the most unwell children from all they look after the most unwell children from all over they look after the most unwell children from all over the they look after the most unwell children from all over the country children from all over the country including children from all over the country including those children from all over the country including those who children from all over the country including those who need children from all over the country including those who need cardiac including those who need cardiac surgery including those who need cardiac surgery and including those who need cardiac surgery and transplantation. including those who need cardiac surgery and transplantation. We including those who need cardiac surgery and transplantation. We are surgery and transplantation. We are investing surgery and transplantation. We are investing $25 surgery and transplantation. We are investing $25 million surgery and transplantation. We are investing $25 million into surgery and transplantation. We are investing $25 million into the investing $25 million into the expansion investing $25 million into the expansion of investing $25 million into the expansion of the investing $25 million into the expansion of the paediatric expansion of the paediatric intensive expansion of the paediatric intensive care expansion of the paediatric intensive care unit, expansion of the paediatric intensive care unit, or expansion of the paediatric intensive care unit, or PICU, expansion of the paediatric intensive care unit, or PICU, at intensive care unit, or PICU, at Starship. intensive care unit, or PICU, at Starship. This intensive care unit, or PICU, at Starship. This will intensive care unit, or PICU, at Starship. This will take intensive care unit, or PICU, at Starship. This will take capacity intensive care unit, or PICU, at Starship. This will take capacity at Starship. This will take capacity at the Starship. This will take capacity at the unit Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from 22 Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from 22 beds Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from 22 beds to Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from 22 beds to 32 Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds Starship. This will take capacity at the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as well the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as well as the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as well as provide the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as well as provide for the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as well as provide for improved the unit from 22 beds to 32 beds as well as provide for improved whanau well as provide for improved whanau spaces. well as provide for improved whanau spaces. Why well as provide for improved whanau spaces. Why is well as provide for improved whanau spaces. Why is this well as provide for improved whanau spaces. Why is this investment spaces. Why is this investment needed spaces. Why is this investment needed at spaces. Why is this investment needed at Starship? spaces. Why is this investment needed at Starship? Starship's spaces. Why is this investment needed at Starship? Starship's PICU needed at Starship? Starship's PICU currently needed at Starship? Starship's PICU currently treats needed at Starship? Starship's PICU currently treats around needed at Starship? Starship's PICU currently treats around 1,100 needed at Starship? Starship's PICU currently treats around 1,100 to currently treats around 1,100 to 1,200 currently treats around 1,100 to 1,200 children currently treats around 1,100 to 1,200 children each currently treats around 1,100 to 1,200 children each year. currently treats around 1,100 to 1,200 children each year. Demand currently treats around 1,100 to 1,200 children each year. Demand has 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown by 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown by 30% 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown by 30% over 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown by 30% over the 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown by 30% over the past 1,200 children each year. Demand has grown by 30% over the past three grown by 30% over the past three years grown by 30% over the past three years and grown by 30% over the past three years and is grown by 30% over the past three years and is expected grown by 30% over the past three years and is expected to grown by 30% over the past three years and is expected to continue grown by 30% over the past three years and is expected to continue to years and is expected to continue to grow. years and is expected to continue to grow. We years and is expected to continue to grow. We need years and is expected to continue to grow. We need to years and is expected to continue to grow. We need to act years and is expected to continue to grow. We need to act now years and is expected to continue to grow. We need to act now to years and is expected to continue to grow. We need to act now to ensure grow. We need to act now to ensure we grow. We need to act now to ensure we have grow. We need to act now to ensure we have enough grow. We need to act now to ensure we have enough beds grow. We need to act now to ensure we have enough beds to grow. We need to act now to ensure we have enough beds to care grow. We need to act now to ensure we have enough beds to care for we have enough beds to care for these we have enough beds to care for these most we have enough beds to care for these most vulnerable we have enough beds to care for these most vulnerable of we have enough beds to care for these most vulnerable of patients. these most vulnerable of patients. Construction these most vulnerable of patients. Construction work these most vulnerable of patients. Construction work is these most vulnerable of patients. Construction work is planned these most vulnerable of patients. Construction work is planned to Construction work is planned to begin Construction work is planned to begin in Construction work is planned to begin in early Construction work is planned to begin in early 2021. Construction work is planned to begin in early 2021. Question Construction work is planned to begin in early 2021. Question number begin in early 2021. Question number 11, begin in early 2021. Question number 11, Melissa begin in early 2021. Question number 11, Melissa Lee. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Broadcasting, My question is to the Minister of Broadcasting, Communications Broadcasting, Communications and Broadcasting, Communications and Digital Broadcasting, Communications and Digital Media: and Digital Media: Does and Digital Media: Does he and Digital Media: Does he stand and Digital Media: Does he stand by Does he stand by all Does he stand by all his Does he stand by all his actions Does he stand by all his actions and Does he stand by all his actions and policies? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, in Mr Speaker, in the Mr Speaker, in the context Mr Speaker, in the context in Mr Speaker, in the context in which Mr Speaker, in the context in which they Mr Speaker, in the context in which they were Mr Speaker, in the context in which they were given, Mr Speaker, in the context in which they were given, yes. Mr Speaker, in the context in which they were given, yes. In Mr Speaker, in the context in which they were given, yes. In particular, they were given, yes. In particular, I they were given, yes. In particular, I stand they were given, yes. In particular, I stand by they were given, yes. In particular, I stand by my they were given, yes. In particular, I stand by my statement they were given, yes. In particular, I stand by my statement that they were given, yes. In particular, I stand by my statement that "New I stand by my statement that "New Zealanders I stand by my statement that "New Zealanders must I stand by my statement that "New Zealanders must have I stand by my statement that "New Zealanders must have access I stand by my statement that "New Zealanders must have access to I stand by my statement that "New Zealanders must have access to a Zealanders must have access to a strong Zealanders must have access to a strong and Zealanders must have access to a strong and independent Zealanders must have access to a strong and independent public Zealanders must have access to a strong and independent public media strong and independent public media service strong and independent public media service for strong and independent public media service for decades strong and independent public media service for decades to strong and independent public media service for decades to come. strong and independent public media service for decades to come. This service for decades to come. This will service for decades to come. This will ensure service for decades to come. This will ensure that service for decades to come. This will ensure that New service for decades to come. This will ensure that New Zealand will ensure that New Zealand audiences will ensure that New Zealand audiences will..." will ensure that New Zealand audiences will..." In will ensure that New Zealand audiences will..." In Budget will ensure that New Zealand audiences will..." In Budget 2018 will ensure that New Zealand audiences will..." In Budget 2018 we audiences will..." In Budget 2018 we increased audiences will..." In Budget 2018 we increased media audiences will..." In Budget 2018 we increased media funding audiences will..." In Budget 2018 we increased media funding by audiences will..." In Budget 2018 we increased media funding by $15 increased media funding by $15 million. increased media funding by $15 million. In increased media funding by $15 million. In Budget increased media funding by $15 million. In Budget 2019, increased media funding by $15 million. In Budget 2019, we million. In Budget 2019, we increased million. In Budget 2019, we increased public million. In Budget 2019, we increased public media million. In Budget 2019, we increased public media funding. million. In Budget 2019, we increased public media funding. When increased public media funding. When was increased public media funding. When was he increased public media funding. When was he first increased public media funding. When was he first made increased public media funding. When was he first made aware increased public media funding. When was he first made aware of increased public media funding. When was he first made aware of RNZ's was he first made aware of RNZ's plan was he first made aware of RNZ's plan for was he first made aware of RNZ's plan for the was he first made aware of RNZ's plan for the axing was he first made aware of RNZ's plan for the axing of was he first made aware of RNZ's plan for the axing of RNZ was he first made aware of RNZ's plan for the axing of RNZ Concert plan for the axing of RNZ Concert and plan for the axing of RNZ Concert and the plan for the axing of RNZ Concert and the removal plan for the axing of RNZ Concert and the removal of plan for the axing of RNZ Concert and the removal of its plan for the axing of RNZ Concert and the removal of its broadcasting and the removal of its broadcasting from and the removal of its broadcasting from the and the removal of its broadcasting from the FM and the removal of its broadcasting from the FM frequency and the removal of its broadcasting from the FM frequency in and the removal of its broadcasting from the FM frequency in favour and the removal of its broadcasting from the FM frequency in favour of and the removal of its broadcasting from the FM frequency in favour of a from the FM frequency in favour of a youth from the FM frequency in favour of a youth radio from the FM frequency in favour of a youth radio station? from the FM frequency in favour of a youth radio station? Order! from the FM frequency in favour of a youth radio station? Order! I'm youth radio station? Order! I'm going youth radio station? Order! I'm going to youth radio station? Order! I'm going to let youth radio station? Order! I'm going to let this youth radio station? Order! I'm going to let this question youth radio station? Order! I'm going to let this question go youth radio station? Order! I'm going to let this question go but youth radio station? Order! I'm going to let this question go but to going to let this question go but to warn going to let this question go but to warn members going to let this question go but to warn members that, going to let this question go but to warn members that, in going to let this question go but to warn members that, in future, going to let this question go but to warn members that, in future, when warn members that, in future, when they warn members that, in future, when they are warn members that, in future, when they are asking warn members that, in future, when they are asking about warn members that, in future, when they are asking about actions warn members that, in future, when they are asking about actions and they are asking about actions and policies, they are asking about actions and policies, then they are asking about actions and policies, then the they are asking about actions and policies, then the substantive they are asking about actions and policies, then the substantive or policies, then the substantive or the policies, then the substantive or the supplementary policies, then the substantive or the supplementary question policies, then the substantive or the supplementary question has policies, then the substantive or the supplementary question has to the supplementary question has to relate the supplementary question has to relate to the supplementary question has to relate to that. the supplementary question has to relate to that. Kris the supplementary question has to relate to that. Kris Faafoi. the supplementary question has to relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I the supplementary question has to relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed by relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed by Radio relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed by Radio New relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed by Radio New Zealand relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed by Radio New Zealand about relate to that. Kris Faafoi. I was briefed by Radio New Zealand about - briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that they briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that they were briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that they were working briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that they were working on briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that they were working on a briefed by Radio New Zealand about - that they were working on a youth that they were working on a youth strategy that they were working on a youth strategy in that they were working on a youth strategy in August that they were working on a youth strategy in August and that they were working on a youth strategy in August and October that they were working on a youth strategy in August and October of strategy in August and October of 2019. strategy in August and October of 2019. They strategy in August and October of 2019. They brought strategy in August and October of 2019. They brought their strategy in August and October of 2019. They brought their final 2019. They brought their final proposal 2019. They brought their final proposal to 2019. They brought their final proposal to me 2019. They brought their final proposal to me around 2019. They brought their final proposal to me around their 2019. They brought their final proposal to me around their youth proposal to me around their youth strategy proposal to me around their youth strategy and proposal to me around their youth strategy and the proposal to me around their youth strategy and the impacts proposal to me around their youth strategy and the impacts of proposal to me around their youth strategy and the impacts of that proposal to me around their youth strategy and the impacts of that to strategy and the impacts of that to me strategy and the impacts of that to me on strategy and the impacts of that to me on 29 strategy and the impacts of that to me on 29 January, strategy and the impacts of that to me on 29 January, 2020. strategy and the impacts of that to me on 29 January, 2020. Has strategy and the impacts of that to me on 29 January, 2020. Has has strategy and the impacts of that to me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said publicly, me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said publicly, I me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said publicly, I raised me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said publicly, I raised a me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said publicly, I raised a number me on 29 January, 2020. Has has been said publicly, I raised a number of said publicly, I raised a number of concerns said publicly, I raised a number of concerns with said publicly, I raised a number of concerns with them. said publicly, I raised a number of concerns with them. Most concerns with them. Most substantively concerns with them. Most substantively was concerns with them. Most substantively was the concerns with them. Most substantively was the issue concerns with them. Most substantively was the issue of substantively was the issue of moving substantively was the issue of moving Radio substantively was the issue of moving Radio New substantively was the issue of moving Radio New Zealand substantively was the issue of moving Radio New Zealand Concert substantively was the issue of moving Radio New Zealand Concert off moving Radio New Zealand Concert off its moving Radio New Zealand Concert off its current moving Radio New Zealand Concert off its current frequency moving Radio New Zealand Concert off its current frequency of moving Radio New Zealand Concert off its current frequency of 92.5FM. moving Radio New Zealand Concert off its current frequency of 92.5FM. I its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said would its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said would work its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said would work on its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said would work on making its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said would work on making sure its current frequency of 92.5FM. I said would work on making sure that said would work on making sure that the said would work on making sure that the youth said would work on making sure that the youth strategy said would work on making sure that the youth strategy could said would work on making sure that the youth strategy could have the youth strategy could have another the youth strategy could have another alternative the youth strategy could have another alternative frequency the youth strategy could have another alternative frequency to another alternative frequency to operate another alternative frequency to operate onened another alternative frequency to operate onened that's another alternative frequency to operate onened that's what another alternative frequency to operate onened that's what I another alternative frequency to operate onened that's what I did. operate onened that's what I did. Why operate onened that's what I did. Why did operate onened that's what I did. Why did he operate onened that's what I did. Why did he say, operate onened that's what I did. Why did he say, and operate onened that's what I did. Why did he say, and I operate onened that's what I did. Why did he say, and I quote, operate onened that's what I did. Why did he say, and I quote, "It's Why did he say, and I quote, "It's not Why did he say, and I quote, "It's not for Why did he say, and I quote, "It's not for the Why did he say, and I quote, "It's not for the Government Why did he say, and I quote, "It's not for the Government to Why did he say, and I quote, "It's not for the Government to decide not for the Government to decide what not for the Government to decide what it's not for the Government to decide what it's utilised not for the Government to decide what it's utilised for", not for the Government to decide what it's utilised for", in not for the Government to decide what it's utilised for", in regards what it's utilised for", in regards to what it's utilised for", in regards to the what it's utilised for", in regards to the Youth what it's utilised for", in regards to the Youth Radio what it's utilised for", in regards to the Youth Radio spectrum what it's utilised for", in regards to the Youth Radio spectrum when what it's utilised for", in regards to the Youth Radio spectrum when the to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has said, to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has said, and to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has said, and I to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has said, and I quote, to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has said, and I quote, "The to the Youth Radio spectrum when the PM has said, and I quote, "The new PM has said, and I quote, "The new frequency PM has said, and I quote, "The new frequency was PM has said, and I quote, "The new frequency was always PM has said, and I quote, "The new frequency was always intended PM has said, and I quote, "The new frequency was always intended for frequency was always intended for youth frequency was always intended for youth raidio frequency was always intended for youth raidio and frequency was always intended for youth raidio and youth frequency was always intended for youth raidio and youth programming"? youth raidio and youth programming"? Because youth raidio and youth programming"? Because that youth raidio and youth programming"? Because that question youth raidio and youth programming"? Because that question that youth raidio and youth programming"? Because that question that the Because that question that the member Because that question that the member herself Because that question that the member herself asked Because that question that the member herself asked me Because that question that the member herself asked me at Because that question that the member herself asked me at the member herself asked me at the select member herself asked me at the select committee member herself asked me at the select committee in member herself asked me at the select committee in June member herself asked me at the select committee in June last member herself asked me at the select committee in June last year select committee in June last year pertained select committee in June last year pertained to select committee in June last year pertained to both select committee in June last year pertained to both frequency select committee in June last year pertained to both frequency for select committee in June last year pertained to both frequency for both pertained to both frequency for both Maori pertained to both frequency for both Maori and pertained to both frequency for both Maori and youth. pertained to both frequency for both Maori and youth. And pertained to both frequency for both Maori and youth. And my pertained to both frequency for both Maori and youth. And my reading pertained to both frequency for both Maori and youth. And my reading of Maori and youth. And my reading of the Maori and youth. And my reading of the transcript, Maori and youth. And my reading of the transcript, I Maori and youth. And my reading of the transcript, I was Maori and youth. And my reading of the transcript, I was saying Maori and youth. And my reading of the transcript, I was saying that Maori and youth. And my reading of the transcript, I was saying that it the transcript, I was saying that it wasn't the transcript, I was saying that it wasn't for the transcript, I was saying that it wasn't for Government the transcript, I was saying that it wasn't for Government alone the transcript, I was saying that it wasn't for Government alone to wasn't for Government alone to decide wasn't for Government alone to decide who wasn't for Government alone to decide who - wasn't for Government alone to decide who - how wasn't for Government alone to decide who - how these wasn't for Government alone to decide who - how these spectrums decide who - how these spectrums should decide who - how these spectrums should be decide who - how these spectrums should be - decide who - how these spectrums should be - how decide who - how these spectrums should be - how the decide who - how these spectrums should be - how the spectrum decide who - how these spectrums should be - how the spectrum should should be - how the spectrum should be should be - how the spectrum should be used. should be - how the spectrum should be used. Both should be - how the spectrum should be used. Both of should be - how the spectrum should be used. Both of those, should be - how the spectrum should be used. Both of those, 103 should be - how the spectrum should be used. Both of those, 103 and should be - how the spectrum should be used. Both of those, 103 and 102, be used. Both of those, 103 and 102, frequencies be used. Both of those, 103 and 102, frequencies are be used. Both of those, 103 and 102, frequencies are assigned be used. Both of those, 103 and 102, frequencies are assigned for be used. Both of those, 103 and 102, frequencies are assigned for Maori frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, or frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, or the frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, or the 102 frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, or the 102 for frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, or the 102 for a frequencies are assigned for Maori purposes, or the 102 for a youth purposes, or the 102 for a youth network purposes, or the 102 for a youth network strategy. purposes, or the 102 for a youth network strategy. And purposes, or the 102 for a youth network strategy. And one purposes, or the 102 for a youth network strategy. And one of purposes, or the 102 for a youth network strategy. And one of those, network strategy. And one of those, it's network strategy. And one of those, it's not network strategy. And one of those, it's not for network strategy. And one of those, it's not for Government network strategy. And one of those, it's not for Government alone network strategy. And one of those, it's not for Government alone to it's not for Government alone to dictate it's not for Government alone to dictate exactly it's not for Government alone to dictate exactly how it's not for Government alone to dictate exactly how that it's not for Government alone to dictate exactly how that spectrum it's not for Government alone to dictate exactly how that spectrum is dictate exactly how that spectrum is allocated dictate exactly how that spectrum is allocated or dictate exactly how that spectrum is allocated or used. dictate exactly how that spectrum is allocated or used. Does dictate exactly how that spectrum is allocated or used. Does he dictate exactly how that spectrum is allocated or used. Does he agree allocated or used. Does he agree with allocated or used. Does he agree with the allocated or used. Does he agree with the statement allocated or used. Does he agree with the statement by allocated or used. Does he agree with the statement by former allocated or used. Does he agree with the statement by former PM allocated or used. Does he agree with the statement by former PM Rt with the statement by former PM Rt Hon with the statement by former PM Rt with with the statement by former PM Rt Hon Helen Clark with the statement by former PM Rt Hon Helen Clark that with the statement by former PM Rt Hon Helen Clark that the with the statement by former PM Rt Hon Helen Clark that the Concert with the statement by former PM Rt Hon Helen Clark that the Concert FM Hon Helen Clark that the Concert FM issue Hon Helen Clark that the Concert FM issue has Hon Helen Clark that the Concert FM issue has been Hon Helen Clark that the Concert FM issue has been "handled issue has been "handled disastrously"? issue has been "handled disastrously"? If issue has been "handled disastrously"? If so, issue has been "handled disastrously"? If so, does issue has been "handled disastrously"? If so, does he issue has been "handled disastrously"? If so, does he accept disastrously"? If so, does he accept responsibility disastrously"? If so, does he accept responsibility for disastrously"? If so, does he accept responsibility for this disastrously"? If so, does he accept responsibility for this disastrous responsibility for this disastrous handling? responsibility for this disastrous handling? It's responsibility for this disastrous handling? It's very responsibility for this disastrous handling? It's very important responsibility for this disastrous handling? It's very important that handling? It's very important that Governments handling? It's very important that Governments keep handling? It's very important that Governments keep away handling? It's very important that Governments keep away from Governments keep away from operational Governments keep away from operational decisions Governments keep away from operational decisions that Governments keep away from operational decisions that public operational decisions that public broadcasters operational decisions that public broadcasters make. operational decisions that public broadcasters make. The operational decisions that public broadcasters make. The decision operational decisions that public broadcasters make. The decision to broadcasters make. The decision to run broadcasters make. The decision to run a broadcasters make. The decision to run a consultation broadcasters make. The decision to run a consultation with broadcasters make. The decision to run a consultation with their broadcasters make. The decision to run a consultation with their staff run a consultation with their staff around run a consultation with their staff around a run a consultation with their staff around a youth run a consultation with their staff around a youth network run a consultation with their staff around a youth network strategy run a consultation with their staff around a youth network strategy was around a youth network strategy was theirs. around a youth network strategy was theirs. They around a youth network strategy was theirs. They have around a youth network strategy was theirs. They have subsequently around a youth network strategy was theirs. They have subsequently taken theirs. They have subsequently taken action theirs. They have subsequently taken action to theirs. They have subsequently taken action to keep theirs. They have subsequently taken action to keep Concert theirs. They have subsequently taken action to keep Concert FM theirs. They have subsequently taken action to keep Concert FM where theirs. They have subsequently taken action to keep Concert FM where it action to keep Concert FM where it is. action to keep Concert FM where it is. The action to keep Concert FM where it is. The former action to keep Concert FM where it is. The former PM action to keep Concert FM where it is. The former PM is action to keep Concert FM where it is. The former PM is entitled action to keep Concert FM where it is. The former PM is entitled to action to keep Concert FM where it is. The former PM is entitled to her is. The former PM is entitled to her opinion. is. The former PM is entitled to her opinion. Question is. The former PM is entitled to her opinion. Question number is. The former PM is entitled to her opinion. Question number 12, is. The former PM is entitled to her opinion. Question number 12, Dr opinion. Question number 12, Dr Parmjeet opinion. Question number 12, Dr Parmjeet Parmar. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Research, My question is to the Minister of Research, Science My question is to the Minister of Research, Science and My question is to the Minister of Research, Science and Innovation: of Research, Science and Innovation: Is of Research, Science and Innovation: Is the of Research, Science and Innovation: Is the Government of Research, Science and Innovation: Is the Government delivering Is the Government delivering improved Is the Government delivering improved outcomes improved outcomes in improved outcomes in research improved outcomes in research and improved outcomes in research and innovation? The The Hon The Hon Megan The Hon Megan Woods. The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two years The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two years we've The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two years we've been The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two years we've been in The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two years we've been in office The Hon Megan Woods. Yes, in the two years we've been in office we've years we've been in office we've delivered years we've been in office we've delivered across years we've been in office we've delivered across a years we've been in office we've delivered across a wide years we've been in office we've delivered across a wide range years we've been in office we've delivered across a wide range of delivered across a wide range of areas delivered across a wide range of areas in delivered across a wide range of areas in research delivered across a wide range of areas in research and delivered across a wide range of areas in research and innovation. areas in research and innovation. But areas in research and innovation. But there areas in research and innovation. But there is areas in research and innovation. But there is always areas in research and innovation. But there is always more areas in research and innovation. But there is always more to areas in research and innovation. But there is always more to do. areas in research and innovation. But there is always more to do. An But there is always more to do. An edited But there is always more to do. An edited list But there is always more to do. An edited list of But there is always more to do. An edited list of our But there is always more to do. An edited list of our highlights But there is always more to do. An edited list of our highlights of edited list of our highlights of things edited list of our highlights of things we edited list of our highlights of things we have edited list of our highlights of things we have done, edited list of our highlights of things we have done, we edited list of our highlights of things we have done, we have things we have done, we have invested things we have done, we have invested $1. things we have done, we have invested $1. 1 things we have done, we have invested $1. 1 billion things we have done, we have invested $1. 1 billion and things we have done, we have invested $1. 1 billion and a things we have done, we have invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% things we have done, we have invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax incentive, invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax incentive, which invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax incentive, which we've invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax incentive, which we've yet invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax incentive, which we've yet to invested $1. 1 billion and a 15% tax incentive, which we've yet to see incentive, which we've yet to see the incentive, which we've yet to see the impact incentive, which we've yet to see the impact from. incentive, which we've yet to see the impact from. We've incentive, which we've yet to see the impact from. We've funded the impact from. We've funded Callahan the impact from. We've funded Callahan Campus the impact from. We've funded Callahan Campus redevelopment the impact from. We've funded Callahan Campus redevelopment and Callahan Campus redevelopment and established Callahan Campus redevelopment and established a Callahan Campus redevelopment and established a new Callahan Campus redevelopment and established a new innovation established a new innovation development established a new innovation development centre established a new innovation development centre to established a new innovation development centre to ensure established a new innovation development centre to ensure we established a new innovation development centre to ensure we have development centre to ensure we have world-class, development centre to ensure we have world-class, innovative world-class, innovative infrastructure. world-class, innovative infrastructure. We world-class, innovative infrastructure. We have world-class, innovative infrastructure. We have signed infrastructure. We have signed agreements infrastructure. We have signed agreements to infrastructure. We have signed agreements to foster infrastructure. We have signed agreements to foster greater agreements to foster greater collaboration agreements to foster greater collaboration with agreements to foster greater collaboration with government agreements to foster greater collaboration with government and collaboration with government and innovation collaboration with government and innovation in collaboration with government and innovation in the collaboration with government and innovation in the sector. collaboration with government and innovation in the sector. We've innovation in the sector. We've invested innovation in the sector. We've invested in innovation in the sector. We've invested in renewable innovation in the sector. We've invested in renewable energy, invested in renewable energy, agriculture invested in renewable energy, agriculture and invested in renewable energy, agriculture and climate invested in renewable energy, agriculture and climate science, invested in renewable energy, agriculture and climate science, and agriculture and climate science, and continue agriculture and climate science, and continue to agriculture and climate science, and continue to our agriculture and climate science, and continue to our space agriculture and climate science, and continue to our space research continue to our space research capability, continue to our space research capability, including continue to our space research capability, including hosting capability, including hosting Mission capability, including hosting Mission Control capability, including hosting Mission Control for capability, including hosting Mission Control for New capability, including hosting Mission Control for New Zealand's Mission Control for New Zealand's first Mission Control for New Zealand's first space Mission Control for New Zealand's first space mission. Mission Control for New Zealand's first space mission. This Mission Control for New Zealand's first space mission. This Government first space mission. This Government has first space mission. This Government has set first space mission. This Government has set out... first space mission. This Government has set out... Order! first space mission. This Government has set out... Order! That first space mission. This Government has set out... Order! That - first space mission. This Government has set out... Order! That - you has set out... Order! That - you know, has set out... Order! That - you know, that has set out... Order! That - you know, that is has set out... Order! That - you know, that is enough. has set out... Order! That - you know, that is enough. The has set out... Order! That - you know, that is enough. The member know, that is enough. The member gets know, that is enough. The member gets a know, that is enough. The member gets a 10-minute know, that is enough. The member gets a 10-minute speech know, that is enough. The member gets a 10-minute speech later. know, that is enough. The member gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr Speaker, gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr Speaker, how gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr Speaker, how can gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr Speaker, how can she gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr Speaker, how can she say gets a 10-minute speech later. Mr Speaker, how can she say her Speaker, how can she say her Government Speaker, how can she say her Government is Speaker, how can she say her Government is delivering Speaker, how can she say her Government is delivering improved Government is delivering improved outcomes Government is delivering improved outcomes and Government is delivering improved outcomes and innovation Government is delivering improved outcomes and innovation when Government is delivering improved outcomes and innovation when New outcomes and innovation when New Zealand's outcomes and innovation when New Zealand's ranking outcomes and innovation when New Zealand's ranking on outcomes and innovation when New Zealand's ranking on the outcomes and innovation when New Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Innovation Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Innovation Index Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Innovation Index fell Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Innovation Index fell by Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Innovation Index fell by five Zealand's ranking on the Bloomberg Innovation Index fell by five places Innovation Index fell by five places this Innovation Index fell by five places this year Innovation Index fell by five places this year to Innovation Index fell by five places this year to 29 Innovation Index fell by five places this year to 29 in Innovation Index fell by five places this year to 29 in the Innovation Index fell by five places this year to 29 in the world? Innovation Index fell by five places this year to 29 in the world? The this year to 29 in the world? The Bloomberg this year to 29 in the world? The Bloomberg Innovation this year to 29 in the world? The Bloomberg Innovation Survey this year to 29 in the world? The Bloomberg Innovation Survey to this year to 29 in the world? The Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which the Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which the member Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which the member refers Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which the member refers is Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which the member refers is measured Bloomberg Innovation Survey to which the member refers is measured across the member refers is measured across seven the member refers is measured across seven domains the member refers is measured across seven domains out the member refers is measured across seven domains out of the member refers is measured across seven domains out of 100, the member refers is measured across seven domains out of 100, all the member refers is measured across seven domains out of 100, all of seven domains out of 100, all of which seven domains out of 100, all of which are seven domains out of 100, all of which are weighted seven domains out of 100, all of which are weighted equally seven domains out of 100, all of which are weighted equally across which are weighted equally across that. which are weighted equally across that. It which are weighted equally across that. It is which are weighted equally across that. It is important which are weighted equally across that. It is important to which are weighted equally across that. It is important to note which are weighted equally across that. It is important to note this that. It is important to note this is that. It is important to note this is a that. It is important to note this is a composite that. It is important to note this is a composite survey, that. It is important to note this is a composite survey, only that. It is important to note this is a composite survey, only that, is a composite survey, only that, doesn't is a composite survey, only that, doesn't take is a composite survey, only that, doesn't take into is a composite survey, only that, doesn't take into innovation. is a composite survey, only that, doesn't take into innovation. The doesn't take into innovation. The seven doesn't take into innovation. The seven domains doesn't take into innovation. The seven domains include doesn't take into innovation. The seven domains include tertiary seven domains include tertiary education, seven domains include tertiary education, research seven domains include tertiary education, research and education, research and concentration, education, research and concentration, and education, research and concentration, and product education, research and concentration, and product activity. concentration, and product activity. In concentration, and product activity. In fact, concentration, and product activity. In fact, the concentration, and product activity. In fact, the area concentration, and product activity. In fact, the area where concentration, and product activity. In fact, the area where New concentration, and product activity. In fact, the area where New Zealand In fact, the area where New Zealand did In fact, the area where New Zealand did drop In fact, the area where New Zealand did drop the In fact, the area where New Zealand did drop the most In fact, the area where New Zealand did drop the most was In fact, the area where New Zealand did drop the most was in In fact, the area where New Zealand did drop the most was in the did drop the most was in the manufacturing did drop the most was in the manufacturing value did drop the most was in the manufacturing value added did drop the most was in the manufacturing value added rather manufacturing value added rather than manufacturing value added rather than the manufacturing value added rather than the innovation manufacturing value added rather than the innovation measures manufacturing value added rather than the innovation measures that than the innovation measures that are than the innovation measures that are captured than the innovation measures that are captured in than the innovation measures that are captured in that than the innovation measures that are captured in that survey. than the innovation measures that are captured in that survey. In are captured in that survey. In fact, are captured in that survey. In fact, in are captured in that survey. In fact, in some are captured in that survey. In fact, in some of are captured in that survey. In fact, in some of the are captured in that survey. In fact, in some of the innovation fact, in some of the innovation domains fact, in some of the innovation domains that fact, in some of the innovation domains that are fact, in some of the innovation domains that are measured fact, in some of the innovation domains that are measured in fact, in some of the innovation domains that are measured in that, domains that are measured in that, we domains that are measured in that, we actually domains that are measured in that, we actually performed domains that are measured in that, we actually performed ahead domains that are measured in that, we actually performed ahead of domains that are measured in that, we actually performed ahead of every we actually performed ahead of every country we actually performed ahead of every country except we actually performed ahead of every country except three we actually performed ahead of every country except three or we actually performed ahead of every country except three or four we actually performed ahead of every country except three or four that country except three or four that are country except three or four that are ahead country except three or four that are ahead of country except three or four that are ahead of us. country except three or four that are ahead of us. What country except three or four that are ahead of us. What the country except three or four that are ahead of us. What the member are ahead of us. What the member also are ahead of us. What the member also should are ahead of us. What the member also should note are ahead of us. What the member also should note is are ahead of us. What the member also should note is that are ahead of us. What the member also should note is that the are ahead of us. What the member also should note is that the New also should note is that the New Zealand also should note is that the New Zealand score, also should note is that the New Zealand score, the also should note is that the New Zealand score, the raw also should note is that the New Zealand score, the raw score, also should note is that the New Zealand score, the raw score, on also should note is that the New Zealand score, the raw score, on the Zealand score, the raw score, on the index Zealand score, the raw score, on the index has Zealand score, the raw score, on the index has been Zealand score, the raw score, on the index has been in Zealand score, the raw score, on the index has been in decline Zealand score, the raw score, on the index has been in decline from Zealand score, the raw score, on the index has been in decline from 2015 index has been in decline from 2015 to index has been in decline from 2015 to 2018. index has been in decline from 2015 to 2018. That index has been in decline from 2015 to 2018. That decline index has been in decline from 2015 to 2018. That decline was index has been in decline from 2015 to 2018. That decline was reversed to 2018. That decline was reversed in to 2018. That decline was reversed in 2018 to 2018. That decline was reversed in 2018 and to 2018. That decline was reversed in 2018 and stabilised, to 2018. That decline was reversed in 2018 and stabilised, Mr to 2018. That decline was reversed in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in 2019. in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in 2019. We, in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in 2019. We, as in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in 2019. We, as a in 2018 and stabilised, Mr Speaker, only in 2019. We, as a Government, only in 2019. We, as a Government, believe only in 2019. We, as a Government, believe that, only in 2019. We, as a Government, believe that, actually, only in 2019. We, as a Government, believe that, actually, what only in 2019. We, as a Government, believe that, actually, what sits believe that, actually, what sits behind believe that, actually, what sits behind that believe that, actually, what sits behind that is believe that, actually, what sits behind that is our believe that, actually, what sits behind that is our drive believe that, actually, what sits behind that is our drive to believe that, actually, what sits behind that is our drive to lift believe that, actually, what sits behind that is our drive to lift our behind that is our drive to lift our very behind that is our drive to lift our very Lee behind that is our drive to lift our very Lee -- behind that is our drive to lift our very Lee -- low behind that is our drive to lift our very Lee -- low percentage behind that is our drive to lift our very Lee -- low percentage of behind that is our drive to lift our very Lee -- low percentage of GDP very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which we very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which we spend, very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which we spend, which very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which we spend, which we very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which we spend, which we as very Lee -- low percentage of GDP which we spend, which we as a which we spend, which we as a Government which we spend, which we as a Government his which we spend, which we as a Government his seen which we spend, which we as a Government his seen movementle which we spend, which we as a Government his seen movementle of. which we spend, which we as a Government his seen movementle of. A Government his seen movementle of. A point Government his seen movementle of. A point of Government his seen movementle of. A point of order, Government his seen movementle of. A point of order, the Government his seen movementle of. A point of order, the Hon... Government his seen movementle of. A point of order, the Hon... Mr point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, I point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, I seek point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, I seek leave point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, I seek leave to point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, I seek leave to table point of order, the Hon... Mr Speaker, I seek leave to table this Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph which Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph which shows Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph which shows the Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph which shows the fact Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph which shows the fact that Speaker, I seek leave to table this graph which shows the fact that New graph which shows the fact that New Zealand's graph which shows the fact that New Zealand's score graph which shows the fact that New Zealand's score on graph which shows the fact that New Zealand's score on the graph which shows the fact that New Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Weighted Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Weighted Average Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Weighted Average has Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Weighted Average has been Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Weighted Average has been in Zealand's score on the Bloomberg Weighted Average has been in decline Weighted Average has been in decline for Weighted Average has been in decline for a Weighted Average has been in decline for a number Weighted Average has been in decline for a number of Weighted Average has been in decline for a number of years Weighted Average has been in decline for a number of years but Weighted Average has been in decline for a number of years but has Weighted Average has been in decline for a number of years but has indeed for a number of years but has indeed stabilised for a number of years but has indeed stabilised over for a number of years but has indeed stabilised over the for a number of years but has indeed stabilised over the years for a number of years but has indeed stabilised over the years 2018-2019? stabilised over the years 2018-2019? Is stabilised over the years 2018-2019? Is there stabilised over the years 2018-2019? Is there any stabilised over the years 2018-2019? Is there any objection stabilised over the years 2018-2019? Is there any objection to stabilised over the years 2018-2019? Is there any objection to that? Is there any objection to that? There Is there any objection to that? There appears Is there any objection to that? There appears to Is there any objection to that? There appears to be Is there any objection to that? There appears to be none. Is there any objection to that? There appears to be none. Parmjeet There appears to be none. Parmjeet Parmar, There appears to be none. Parmjeet Parmar, supplementary. There appears to be none. Parmjeet Parmar, supplementary. Why There appears to be none. Parmjeet Parmar, supplementary. Why is There appears to be none. Parmjeet Parmar, supplementary. Why is she Parmar, supplementary. Why is she blaming Parmar, supplementary. Why is she blaming the Parmar, supplementary. Why is she blaming the last Parmar, supplementary. Why is she blaming the last National blaming the last National Government, blaming the last National Government, because blaming the last National Government, because when blaming the last National Government, because when she blaming the last National Government, because when she came blaming the last National Government, because when she came in Government, because when she came in Government, Government, because when she came in Government, New Government, because when she came in Government, New Zealand Government, because when she came in Government, New Zealand was Government, because when she came in Government, New Zealand was 18 Government, because when she came in Government, New Zealand was 18 on Government, New Zealand was 18 on the Government, New Zealand was 18 on the Bloomberg Government, New Zealand was 18 on the Bloomberg Innovation Government, New Zealand was 18 on the Bloomberg Innovation Index the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking and the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking and now the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking and now we the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking and now we 29 the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking and now we 29 under the Bloomberg Innovation Index ranking and now we 29 under her ranking and now we 29 under her watch? ranking and now we 29 under her watch? I ranking and now we 29 under her watch? I think ranking and now we 29 under her watch? I think we ranking and now we 29 under her watch? I think we gave ranking and now we 29 under her watch? I think we gave quite ranking and now we 29 under her watch? I think we gave quite a watch? I think we gave quite a thorough watch? I think we gave quite a thorough answer watch? I think we gave quite a thorough answer to watch? I think we gave quite a thorough answer to the watch? I think we gave quite a thorough answer to the initial thorough answer to the initial question. thorough answer to the initial question. That, thorough answer to the initial question. That, in thorough answer to the initial question. That, in fact, thorough answer to the initial question. That, in fact, what thorough answer to the initial question. That, in fact, what I'm question. That, in fact, what I'm saying question. That, in fact, what I'm saying is question. That, in fact, what I'm saying is there question. That, in fact, what I'm saying is there are question. That, in fact, what I'm saying is there are a question. That, in fact, what I'm saying is there are a range question. That, in fact, what I'm saying is there are a range of saying is there are a range of domains saying is there are a range of domains that saying is there are a range of domains that it saying is there are a range of domains that it is saying is there are a range of domains that it is measured saying is there are a range of domains that it is measured across. domains that it is measured across. I domains that it is measured across. I am domains that it is measured across. I am going domains that it is measured across. I am going to domains that it is measured across. I am going to go domains that it is measured across. I am going to go through domains that it is measured across. I am going to go through some domains that it is measured across. I am going to go through some of I am going to go through some of those I am going to go through some of those raw I am going to go through some of those raw numbers I am going to go through some of those raw numbers in I am going to go through some of those raw numbers in terms I am going to go through some of those raw numbers in terms of I am going to go through some of those raw numbers in terms of that. those raw numbers in terms of that. In those raw numbers in terms of that. In 2013, those raw numbers in terms of that. In 2013, the those raw numbers in terms of that. In 2013, the year those raw numbers in terms of that. In 2013, the year in those raw numbers in terms of that. In 2013, the year in which those raw numbers in terms of that. In 2013, the year in which Callahan In 2013, the year in which Callahan Innovation In 2013, the year in which Callahan Innovation was In 2013, the year in which Callahan Innovation was established, In 2013, the year in which Callahan Innovation was established, 57.73 Innovation was established, 57.73 was Innovation was established, 57.73 was our Innovation was established, 57.73 was our weighted Innovation was established, 57.73 was our weighted number. Innovation was established, 57.73 was our weighted number. That Innovation was established, 57.73 was our weighted number. That did was our weighted number. That did jump was our weighted number. That did jump slightly was our weighted number. That did jump slightly in was our weighted number. That did jump slightly in 2014 was our weighted number. That did jump slightly in 2014 to was our weighted number. That did jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. was our weighted number. That did jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But then jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But then did jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But then did decline, jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But then did decline, all jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But then did decline, all the jump slightly in 2014 to 75.09. But then did decline, all the way then did decline, all the way through then did decline, all the way through to then did decline, all the way through to the then did decline, all the way through to the beginning then did decline, all the way through to the beginning of then did decline, all the way through to the beginning of 2018, then did decline, all the way through to the beginning of 2018, to through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. What through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. What we through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. What we have through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. What we have seen through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. What we have seen over through to the beginning of 2018, to 67.4. What we have seen over the 67.4. What we have seen over the years 67.4. What we have seen over the years 2019-2020 67.4. What we have seen over the years 2019-2020 is 67.4. What we have seen over the years 2019-2020 is 68.12 67.4. What we have seen over the years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 67.4. What we have seen over the years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I think years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I think what years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I think what all years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I think what all members years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I think what all members of years 2019-2020 is 68.12 and 68.08. I think what all members of this I think what all members of this House, I think what all members of this House, regardless I think what all members of this House, regardless of I think what all members of this House, regardless of what I think what all members of this House, regardless of what side I think what all members of this House, regardless of what side they House, regardless of what side they sit House, regardless of what side they sit on, House, regardless of what side they sit on, should House, regardless of what side they sit on, should be House, regardless of what side they sit on, should be dedicated House, regardless of what side they sit on, should be dedicated to House, regardless of what side they sit on, should be dedicated to the sit on, should be dedicated to the fact sit on, should be dedicated to the fact that sit on, should be dedicated to the fact that New sit on, should be dedicated to the fact that New Zealand sit on, should be dedicated to the fact that New Zealand has sit on, should be dedicated to the fact that New Zealand has a sit on, should be dedicated to the fact that New Zealand has a woeful fact that New Zealand has a woeful percentage fact that New Zealand has a woeful percentage of fact that New Zealand has a woeful percentage of GDP fact that New Zealand has a woeful percentage of GDP expenditure fact that New Zealand has a woeful percentage of GDP expenditure and percentage of GDP expenditure and that percentage of GDP expenditure and that is percentage of GDP expenditure and that is something percentage of GDP expenditure and that is something that percentage of GDP expenditure and that is something that this that is something that this Government that is something that this Government has that is something that this Government has seen that is something that this Government has seen real that is something that this Government has seen real movement Government has seen real movement on, Government has seen real movement on, unlike Government has seen real movement on, unlike the Government has seen real movement on, unlike the previous Government has seen real movement on, unlike the previous Government. on, unlike the previous Government. Is on, unlike the previous Government. Is she on, unlike the previous Government. Is she at on, unlike the previous Government. Is she at all on, unlike the previous Government. Is she at all concerned on, unlike the previous Government. Is she at all concerned that on, unlike the previous Government. Is she at all concerned that New Is she at all concerned that New Zealand Is she at all concerned that New Zealand had Is she at all concerned that New Zealand had the Is she at all concerned that New Zealand had the largest Is she at all concerned that New Zealand had the largest fall Is she at all concerned that New Zealand had the largest fall of Is she at all concerned that New Zealand had the largest fall of any Zealand had the largest fall of any single Zealand had the largest fall of any single country, Zealand had the largest fall of any single country, making Zealand had the largest fall of any single country, making New Zealand had the largest fall of any single country, making New Zealand single country, making New Zealand the single country, making New Zealand the biggest single country, making New Zealand the biggest loser single country, making New Zealand the biggest loser in single country, making New Zealand the biggest loser in the single country, making New Zealand the biggest loser in the latest the biggest loser in the latest Bloomberg the biggest loser in the latest Bloomberg Innovation the biggest loser in the latest Bloomberg Innovation Index? the biggest loser in the latest Bloomberg Innovation Index? Mr the biggest loser in the latest single the biggest loser in the latest Speaker, I am the biggest loser in the latest Speaker, I am always the biggest loser in the latest Speaker, I am always concerned the biggest loser in the latest Speaker, I am always concerned of Speaker, I am always concerned of where Speaker, I am always concerned of where New Speaker, I am always concerned of where New Zealand Speaker, I am always concerned of where New Zealand ranks Speaker, I am always concerned of where New Zealand ranks in Speaker, I am always concerned of where New Zealand ranks in the Speaker, I am always concerned of where New Zealand ranks in the world where New Zealand ranks in the world but where New Zealand ranks in the world but I where New Zealand ranks in the world but I will where New Zealand ranks in the world but I will reiterate where New Zealand ranks in the world but I will reiterate again where New Zealand ranks in the world but I will reiterate again that where New Zealand ranks in the world but I will reiterate again that that but I will reiterate again that that is but I will reiterate again that that is a but I will reiterate again that that is a composite but I will reiterate again that that is a composite index but I will reiterate again that that is a composite index the but I will reiterate again that that is a composite index the member but I will reiterate again that that is a composite index the member has is a composite index the member has referred is a composite index the member has referred to. is a composite index the member has referred to. That, is a composite index the member has referred to. That, in is a composite index the member has referred to. That, in fact, is a composite index the member has referred to. That, in fact, the is a composite index the member has referred to. That, in fact, the area referred to. That, in fact, the area where referred to. That, in fact, the area where it referred to. That, in fact, the area where it had referred to. That, in fact, the area where it had its referred to. That, in fact, the area where it had its biggest referred to. That, in fact, the area where it had its biggest fall referred to. That, in fact, the area where it had its biggest fall was where it had its biggest fall was not where it had its biggest fall was not one where it had its biggest fall was not one related where it had its biggest fall was not one related to where it had its biggest fall was not one related to innovation, where it had its biggest fall was not one related to innovation, but not one related to innovation, but that not one related to innovation, but that doesn't not one related to innovation, but that doesn't stop not one related to innovation, but that doesn't stop me not one related to innovation, but that doesn't stop me being that doesn't stop me being concerned. that doesn't stop me being concerned. What that doesn't stop me being concerned. What I that doesn't stop me being concerned. What I would that doesn't stop me being concerned. What I would also that doesn't stop me being concerned. What I would also point concerned. What I would also point out concerned. What I would also point out to concerned. What I would also point out to the concerned. What I would also point out to the member, concerned. What I would also point out to the member, that concerned. What I would also point out to the member, that these concerned. What I would also point out to the member, that these are out to the member, that these are proportionate out to the member, that these are proportionate to out to the member, that these are proportionate to GDP. out to the member, that these are proportionate to GDP. I out to the member, that these are proportionate to GDP. I will out to the member, that these are proportionate to GDP. I will remind proportionate to GDP. I will remind the proportionate to GDP. I will remind the member proportionate to GDP. I will remind the member that proportionate to GDP. I will remind the member that New proportionate to GDP. I will remind the member that New Zealand proportionate to GDP. I will remind the member that New Zealand had the member that New Zealand had higher the member that New Zealand had higher GDP the member that New Zealand had higher GDP percentage the member that New Zealand had higher GDP percentage growth the member that New Zealand had higher GDP percentage growth than higher GDP percentage growth than other higher GDP percentage growth than other advanced higher GDP percentage growth than other advanced economies higher GDP percentage growth than other advanced economies that higher GDP percentage growth than other advanced economies that it higher GDP percentage growth than other advanced economies that it has other advanced economies that it has been other advanced economies that it has been compared other advanced economies that it has been compared to other advanced economies that it has been compared to in other advanced economies that it has been compared to in that