. This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Red This programme is live captioned by Red Bee This programme is live captioned by Red Bee Media Red Bee Media for Red Bee Media for the Red Bee Media for the Office Red Bee Media for the Office of Red Bee Media for the Office of the Red Bee Media for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Mr Mr Speaker. INTERPRETER: Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, we Almighty God, we give Almighty God, we give thanks Almighty God, we give thanks for Almighty God, we give thanks for the Almighty God, we give thanks for the blessings we give thanks for the blessings which we give thanks for the blessings which have we give thanks for the blessings which have been we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on us. which have been bestowed on us. Laying which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal interests, Laying aside all personal interests, we Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Queen we acknowledge the Queen and we acknowledge the Queen and pray we acknowledge the Queen and pray for we acknowledge the Queen and pray for your we acknowledge the Queen and pray for your guidance and pray for your guidance in and pray for your guidance in our and pray for your guidance in our deliberations, in our deliberations, so in our deliberations, so that in our deliberations, so that we in our deliberations, so that we conduct so that we conduct the so that we conduct the affairs so that we conduct the affairs of so that we conduct the affairs of this so that we conduct the affairs of this House the affairs of this House with the affairs of this House with wisdom the affairs of this House with wisdom and the affairs of this House with wisdom and humility with wisdom and humility for with wisdom and humility for the with wisdom and humility for the public with wisdom and humility for the public welfare with wisdom and humility for the public welfare and with wisdom and humility for the public welfare and peace And And compassion And compassion of And compassion of New And compassion of New Zealand. Point Point of Point of order. Point of order. I Point of order. I seek Point of order. I seek leave Point of order. I seek leave to Point of order. I seek leave to move Point of order. I seek leave to move a Point of order. I seek leave to move a motion I seek leave to move a motion without I seek leave to move a motion without notice I seek leave to move a motion without notice and I seek leave to move a motion without notice and without I seek leave to move a motion without notice and without debate without notice and without debate to without notice and without debate to recognise without notice and without debate to recognise the without notice and without debate to recognise the second to recognise the second anniversary to recognise the second anniversary of to recognise the second anniversary of the to recognise the second anniversary of the attacks anniversary of the attacks on anniversary of the attacks on the anniversary of the attacks on the Christchurch anniversary of the attacks on the Christchurch masjidain. on the Christchurch masjidain. Is on the Christchurch masjidain. Is there on the Christchurch masjidain. Is there any on the Christchurch masjidain. Is there any objection on the Christchurch masjidain. Is there any objection to on the Christchurch masjidain. Is there any objection to that Is there any objection to that course Is there any objection to that course of Is there any objection to that course of action Is there any objection to that course of action being Is there any objection to that course of action being followed? course of action being followed? There course of action being followed? There is course of action being followed? There is none. There is none. I There is none. I move, There is none. I move, That There is none. I move, That this There is none. I move, That this House There is none. I move, That this House mark I move, That this House mark the I move, That this House mark the second I move, That this House mark the second anniversary I move, That this House mark the second anniversary of I move, That this House mark the second anniversary of the I move, That this House mark the second anniversary of the terror the second anniversary of the terror attacks the second anniversary of the terror attacks that the second anniversary of the terror attacks that targeted the second anniversary of the terror attacks that targeted Christchurch attacks that targeted Christchurch masjidain attacks that targeted Christchurch masjidain on attacks that targeted Christchurch masjidain on 15 attacks that targeted Christchurch masjidain on 15 March attacks that targeted Christchurch masjidain on 15 March 2019, masjidain on 15 March 2019, that masjidain on 15 March 2019, that we masjidain on 15 March 2019, that we remember masjidain on 15 March 2019, that we remember the masjidain on 15 March 2019, that we remember the 51 masjidain on 15 March 2019, that we remember the 51 people masjidain on 15 March 2019, that we remember the 51 people whose that we remember the 51 people whose lives that we remember the 51 people whose lives were that we remember the 51 people whose lives were taken that we remember the 51 people whose lives were taken in that we remember the 51 people whose lives were taken in the that we remember the 51 people whose lives were taken in the most that we remember the 51 people whose lives were taken in the most tragic lives were taken in the most tragic and lives were taken in the most tragic and horrific lives were taken in the most tragic and horrific way lives were taken in the most tragic and horrific way and lives were taken in the most tragic and horrific way and the lives were taken in the most tragic and horrific way and the more and horrific way and the more than and horrific way and the more than 40 and horrific way and the more than 40 people and horrific way and the more than 40 people who and horrific way and the more than 40 people who were and horrific way and the more than 40 people who were injured, than 40 people who were injured, shattering than 40 people who were injured, shattering Muslim than 40 people who were injured, shattering Muslim families shattering Muslim families and shattering Muslim families and communities shattering Muslim families and communities forever. and communities forever. The and communities forever. The Question and communities forever. The Question is, and communities forever. The Question is, That The Question is, That the The Question is, That the motion The Question is, That the motion be The Question is, That the motion be agreed The Question is, That the motion be agreed to. the motion be agreed to. Those the motion be agreed to. Those of the motion be agreed to. Those of that the motion be agreed to. Those of that opinion the motion be agreed to. Those of that opinion will the motion be agreed to. Those of that opinion will say the motion be agreed to. Those of that opinion will say Aye, Those of that opinion will say Aye, to Those of that opinion will say Aye, to the Those of that opinion will say Aye, to the contrary, Those of that opinion will say Aye, to the contrary, No. to the contrary, No. The to the contrary, No. The Ayes to the contrary, No. The Ayes have to the contrary, No. The Ayes have it. No No petitions No petitions have No petitions have been No petitions have been delivered No petitions have been delivered to No petitions have been delivered to the No petitions have been delivered to the Clerk No petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for No petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. No No bills No bills have No bills have been No bills have been introduced. No bills have been introduced. But No bills have been introduced. But Ministers No bills have been introduced. But Ministers have No bills have been introduced. But Ministers have delivered No bills have been introduced. But Ministers have delivered papers. Annual Annual Reports Annual Reports 2019/20: Annual Reports 2019/20: Teaching Annual Reports 2019/20: Teaching Council Annual Reports 2019/20: Teaching Council of Annual Reports 2019/20: Teaching Council of Aotearoa Annual Reports 2019/20: Teaching Council of Aotearoa New Teaching Council of Aotearoa New Zealand, Zealand, Peke Zealand, Peke Waihanga Zealand, Peke Waihanga - Zealand, Peke Waihanga - Artificial Zealand, Peke Waihanga - Artificial Limb Peke Waihanga - Artificial Limb Service. Service. Report Service. Report on Service. Report on Unappropriated Service. Report on Unappropriated Expenses Report on Unappropriated Expenses and Report on Unappropriated Expenses and Capital Report on Unappropriated Expenses and Capital Expenditure Report on Unappropriated Expenses and Capital Expenditure for Report on Unappropriated Expenses and Capital Expenditure for the and Capital Expenditure for the financial and Capital Expenditure for the financial year and Capital Expenditure for the financial year ended and Capital Expenditure for the financial year ended 30 and Capital Expenditure for the financial year ended 30 June and Capital Expenditure for the financial year ended 30 June 2020. financial year ended 30 June 2020. Report financial year ended 30 June 2020. Report on financial year ended 30 June 2020. Report on the financial year ended 30 June 2020. Report on the Government Report on the Government Superannuation Report on the Government Superannuation Fund Superannuation Fund Actuarial Superannuation Fund Actuarial Valuation Superannuation Fund Actuarial Valuation as Superannuation Fund Actuarial Valuation as at Superannuation Fund Actuarial Valuation as at 30 Superannuation Fund Actuarial Valuation as at 30 June Actuarial Valuation as at 30 June 2020. 2020. Those 2020. Those papers 2020. Those papers are 2020. Those papers are published Those papers are published under Those papers are published under the Those papers are published under the authority Those papers are published under the authority of Those papers are published under the authority of the Those papers are published under the authority of the House. Select Select committee Select committee reports Select committee reports have Select committee reports have been Select committee reports have been delivered Select committee reports have been delivered for Select committee reports have been delivered for presentation. delivered for presentation. Report delivered for presentation. Report of delivered for presentation. Report of the delivered for presentation. Report of the Foreign delivered for presentation. Report of the Foreign Affairs, Report of the Foreign Affairs, Dcfence Report of the Foreign Affairs, Dcfence and Report of the Foreign Affairs, Dcfence and Tradc Report of the Foreign Affairs, Dcfence and Tradc Committee Dcfence and Tradc Committee on Dcfence and Tradc Committee on the Dcfence and Tradc Committee on the International Dcfence and Tradc Committee on the International treaty on the International treaty examination examination of examination of the examination of the Regional examination of the Regional Comprehensive of the Regional Comprehensive Economic of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership Agreement. Economic Partnership Agreement. Reports Economic Partnership Agreement. Reports of Economic Partnership Agreement. Reports of the Economic Partnership Agreement. Reports of the Health Economic Partnership Agreement. Reports of the Health Committee Economic Partnership Agreement. Reports of the Health Committee on Reports of the Health Committee on the the petitions the petitions of the petitions of Emma the petitions of Emma Richardson the petitions of Emma Richardson and petitions of Emma Richardson and Evangelia petitions of Emma Richardson and Evangelia Henderson. Evangelia Henderson. International Evangelia Henderson. International treaty Evangelia Henderson. International treaty set Evangelia Henderson. International treaty set down Evangelia Henderson. International treaty set down for International treaty set down for consideration The The House The House comes The House comes to The House comes to Oral The House comes to Oral Questions. The House comes to Oral Questions. Question The House comes to Oral Questions. Question No. The House comes to Oral Questions. Question No. 1. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: Minister: Does Minister: Does she Minister: Does she stand Minister: Does she stand by Minister: Does she stand by all Minister: Does she stand by all her Does she stand by all her Government's Does she stand by all her Government's statements Does she stand by all her Government's statements and Does she stand by all her Government's statements and actions? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the PM, On behalf of the PM, yes, On behalf of the PM, yes, including On behalf of the PM, yes, including the On behalf of the PM, yes, including the Government's On behalf of the PM, yes, including the Government's $136.5 On behalf of the PM, yes, including the Government's $136.5 million the Government's $136.5 million investment the Government's $136.5 million investment in the Government's $136.5 million investment in supporting the Government's $136.5 million investment in supporting the the Government's $136.5 million investment in supporting the hosting investment in supporting the hosting of investment in supporting the hosting of the investment in supporting the hosting of the 36th investment in supporting the hosting of the 36th America's investment in supporting the hosting of the 36th America's Cup. investment in supporting the hosting of the 36th America's Cup. In of the 36th America's Cup. In particular, of the 36th America's Cup. In particular, the of the 36th America's Cup. In particular, the development of the 36th America's Cup. In particular, the development of of the 36th America's Cup. In particular, the development of the particular, the development of the Cup particular, the development of the Cup Village, particular, the development of the Cup Village, which particular, the development of the Cup Village, which is particular, the development of the Cup Village, which is a particular, the development of the Cup Village, which is a legacy particular, the development of the Cup Village, which is a legacy for Cup Village, which is a legacy for the Cup Village, which is a legacy for the people Cup Village, which is a legacy for the people of Cup Village, which is a legacy for the people of Auckland Cup Village, which is a legacy for the people of Auckland for the people of Auckland for generations the people of Auckland for generations to the people of Auckland for generations to come. the people of Auckland for generations to come. And the people of Auckland for generations to come. And on the people of Auckland for generations to come. And on behalf generations to come. And on behalf of generations to come. And on behalf of the generations to come. And on behalf of the PM, generations to come. And on behalf of the PM, I generations to come. And on behalf of the PM, I want generations to come. And on behalf of the PM, I want to generations to come. And on behalf of the PM, I want to wish generations to come. And on behalf of the PM, I want to wish Peter of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley and of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley and the of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley and the team of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley and the team all of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley and the team all the of the PM, I want to wish Peter Burley and the team all the very Burley and the team all the very best Burley and the team all the very Burley Burley and the team all the very best for today. Burley and the team all the very best for today. And Burley and the team all the very best for today. And if Burley and the team all the very best for today. And if the Burley and the team all the very best for today. And if the wind Burley and the team all the very best for today. And if the wind does best for today. And if the wind does not best for today. And if the wind does not behave, best for today. And if the wind does not behave, for best for today. And if the wind does not behave, for tomorrow best for today. And if the wind does not behave, for tomorrow as best for today. And if the wind does not behave, for tomorrow as well. not behave, for tomorrow as well. What not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does she not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does she say not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does she say to not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does she say to the not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does she say to the people not behave, for tomorrow as well. What does she say to the people of What does she say to the people of South What does she say to the people of South Auckland What does she say to the people of South Auckland who What does she say to the people of South Auckland who last What does she say to the people of South Auckland who last week What does she say to the people of South Auckland who last week heard South Auckland who last week heard that South Auckland who last week heard that Counties South Auckland who last week heard that Counties Manukau South Auckland who last week heard that Counties Manukau DHB South Auckland who last week heard that Counties Manukau DHB is South Auckland who last week heard that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 nurses that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 nurses short? that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 nurses short? And that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 nurses short? And when that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 nurses short? And when can that Counties Manukau DHB is 150 nurses short? And when can they nurses short? And when can they expect nurses short? And when can they expect a nurses short? And when can they expect a trans-Tasman nurses short? And when can they expect a trans-Tasman bubble nurses short? And when can they expect a trans-Tasman bubble to nurses short? And when can they expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up to expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up to free expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up to free up expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up to free up 40% expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up to free up 40% of expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be opened up to free up 40% of MIQ opened up to free up 40% of MIQ spaces opened up to free up 40% of MIQ spaces that opened up to free up 40% of MIQ spaces that could opened up to free up 40% of MIQ spaces that could be opened up to free up 40% of MIQ spaces that could be available opened up to free up 40% of MIQ spaces that could be available for spaces that could be available for more spaces that could be available for more nurses? spaces that could be available for more nurses? In spaces that could be available for more nurses? In answer spaces that could be available for more nurses? In answer to spaces that could be available for more nurses? In answer to the spaces that could be available for more nurses? In answer to the first more nurses? In answer to the first part more nurses? In answer to the first part of more nurses? In answer to the first part of the more nurses? In answer to the first part of the question, more nurses? In answer to the first part of the question, what more nurses? In answer to the first part of the question, what I more nurses? In answer to the first part of the question, what I say more nurses? In answer to the first part of the question, what I say to part of the question, what I say to the part of the question, what I say to the people part of the question, what I say to the people on part of the question, what I say to the people on behalf part of the question, what I say to the people on behalf of part of the question, what I say to the people on behalf of the part of the question, what I say to the people on behalf of the PM, part of the question, what I say to the people on behalf of the PM, what the people on behalf of the PM, what I the people on behalf of the PM, what I say the people on behalf of the PM, what I say to the people on behalf of the PM, what I say to the the people on behalf of the PM, what I say to the people the people on behalf of the PM, what I say to the people of the people on behalf of the PM, what I say to the people of South I say to the people of South Auckland, I say to the people of South Auckland, is I say to the people of South Auckland, is it I say to the people of South Auckland, is it is I say to the people of South Auckland, is it is a I say to the people of South Auckland, is it is a pity I say to the people of South Auckland, is it is a pity it I say to the people of South Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't a Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't a Labour-led Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't a Labour-led Government Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't a Labour-led Government for Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't a Labour-led Government for the Auckland, is it is a pity it wasn't a Labour-led Government for the nine a Labour-led Government for the nine years a Labour-led Government for the nine years when a Labour-led Government for the nine years when National a Labour-led Government for the nine years when National consistently years when National consistently underfunded years when National consistently underfunded the years when National consistently underfunded the Counties years when National consistently underfunded the Counties Manukau underfunded the Counties Manukau DHB. underfunded the Counties Manukau DHB. Would underfunded the Counties Manukau DHB. Would bringing underfunded the Counties Manukau DHB. Would bringing more underfunded the Counties Manukau DHB. Would bringing more healthcare DHB. Would bringing more healthcare workers DHB. Would bringing more healthcare workers into DHB. Would bringing more healthcare workers into the DHB. Would bringing more healthcare workers into the country DHB. Would bringing more healthcare workers into the country help DHB. Would bringing more healthcare workers into the country help to workers into the country help to speed workers into the country help to speed up workers into the country help to speed up our workers into the country help to speed up our vaccine workers into the country help to speed up our vaccine rollout. workers into the country help to speed up our vaccine rollout. If workers into the country help to speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, why speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, why is speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, why is she speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, why is she refusing speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, why is she refusing to speed up our vaccine rollout. If so, why is she refusing to immediately why is she refusing to immediately open why is she refusing to immediately open the why is she refusing to immediately open the trans-Tasman why is she refusing to immediately open the trans-Tasman bubble why is she refusing to immediately open the trans-Tasman bubble to why is she refusing to immediately open the trans-Tasman bubble to free open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% of open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% of MIQ open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% of MIQ spaces? open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% of MIQ spaces? On open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf open the trans-Tasman bubble to free up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the PM, up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the PM, no. up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the PM, no. Are up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the PM, no. Are there up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the PM, no. Are there any up 40% of MIQ spaces? On behalf of the PM, no. Are there any benefits the PM, no. Are there any benefits to the PM, no. Are there any benefits to healthcare the PM, no. Are there any benefits to healthcare workers the PM, no. Are there any benefits to healthcare workers to the PM, no. Are there any benefits to healthcare workers to opening the PM, no. Are there any benefits to healthcare workers to opening up to healthcare workers to opening up a to healthcare workers to opening up a trans-Tasman to healthcare workers to opening up a trans-Tasman bubble? to healthcare workers to opening up a trans-Tasman bubble? I to healthcare workers to opening up a trans-Tasman bubble? I find to healthcare workers to opening up a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, on a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, on behalf a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, on behalf of a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, on behalf of the a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, on behalf of the PM, a trans-Tasman bubble? I find that difficult, on behalf of the PM, I difficult, on behalf of the PM, I find difficult, on behalf of the PM, I find that difficult, on behalf of the PM, I find that question difficult, on behalf of the PM, I find that question difficult difficult, on behalf of the PM, I find that question difficult to find that question difficult to answer. find that question difficult to answer. Benefits find that question difficult to answer. Benefits to find that question difficult to answer. Benefits to healthcare answer. Benefits to healthcare workers answer. Benefits to healthcare workers of answer. Benefits to healthcare workers of opening answer. Benefits to healthcare workers of opening up answer. Benefits to healthcare workers of opening up the answer. Benefits to healthcare workers of opening up the bubble workers of opening up the bubble would workers of opening up the bubble would be workers of opening up the bubble would be similar workers of opening up the bubble would be similar benefits workers of opening up the bubble would be similar benefits to workers of opening up the bubble would be similar benefits to those would be similar benefits to those in would be similar benefits to those in a would be similar benefits to those in a number would be similar benefits to those in a number of would be similar benefits to those in a number of other would be similar benefits to those in a number of other industries. would be similar benefits to those in a number of other industries. I in a number of other industries. I don't in a number of other industries. I don't particularly in a number of other industries. I don't particularly think in a number of other industries. I don't particularly think it in a number of other industries. I don't particularly think it is don't particularly think it is special don't particularly think it is special to don't particularly think it is special to the don't particularly think it is special to the healthcare don't particularly think it is special to the healthcare workers. special to the healthcare workers. Does special to the healthcare workers. Does she special to the healthcare workers. Does she agree special to the healthcare workers. Does she agree that special to the healthcare workers. Does she agree that having special to the healthcare workers. Does she agree that having stressed Does she agree that having stressed and Does she agree that having stressed and overworked Does she agree that having stressed and overworked nurses Does she agree that having stressed and overworked nurses in Does she agree that having stressed and overworked nurses in our Does she agree that having stressed and overworked nurses in our MIQ and overworked nurses in our MIQ facility and overworked nurses in our MIQ facility increases and overworked nurses in our MIQ facility increases the and overworked nurses in our MIQ facility increases the risk and overworked nurses in our MIQ facility increases the risk of facility increases the risk of another facility increases the risk of another border facility increases the risk of another border failure, facility increases the risk of another border failure, and facility increases the risk of another border failure, and that another border failure, and that freeing another border failure, and that freeing up another border failure, and that freeing up MIQ another border failure, and that freeing up MIQ capacity another border failure, and that freeing up MIQ capacity to another border failure, and that freeing up MIQ capacity to bring freeing up MIQ capacity to bring more freeing up MIQ capacity to bring more healthcare freeing up MIQ capacity to bring more healthcare workers freeing up MIQ capacity to bring more healthcare workers into freeing up MIQ capacity to bring more healthcare workers into the more healthcare workers into the country more healthcare workers into the country could more healthcare workers into the country could make more healthcare workers into the country could make the more healthcare workers into the country could make the border more healthcare workers into the country could make the border safer? country could make the border safer? We country could make the border safer? We are country could make the border safer? We are acutely country could make the border safer? We are acutely aware country could make the border safer? We are acutely aware of country could make the border safer? We are acutely aware of the country could make the border safer? We are acutely aware of the hard We are acutely aware of the hard work We are acutely aware of the hard work that We are acutely aware of the hard work that is We are acutely aware of the hard work that is being We are acutely aware of the hard work that is being done We are acutely aware of the hard work that is being done on We are acutely aware of the hard work that is being done on behalf We are acutely aware of the hard work that is being done on behalf of work that is being done on behalf of all work that is being done on behalf of all New work that is being done on behalf of all New Zealanders work that is being done on behalf of all New Zealanders by work that is being done on behalf of all New Zealanders by healthcare all New Zealanders by healthcare workers, all New Zealanders by healthcare workers, and all New Zealanders by healthcare workers, and we're all New Zealanders by healthcare workers, and we're in all New Zealanders by healthcare workers, and we're in constant workers, and we're in constant communication workers, and we're in constant communication with workers, and we're in constant communication with them workers, and we're in constant communication with them and workers, and we're in constant communication with them and with communication with them and with those communication with them and with those who communication with them and with those who employ communication with them and with those who employ them communication with them and with those who employ them to communication with them and with those who employ them to ensure communication with them and with those who employ them to ensure that those who employ them to ensure that their those who employ them to ensure that their wellbeing those who employ them to ensure that their wellbeing is those who employ them to ensure that their wellbeing is maintained. those who employ them to ensure that their wellbeing is maintained. How their wellbeing is maintained. How many their wellbeing is maintained. How many lifesaving their wellbeing is maintained. How many lifesaving surgeries their wellbeing is maintained. How many lifesaving surgeries in their wellbeing is maintained. How many lifesaving surgeries in New many lifesaving surgeries in New Zealand many lifesaving surgeries in New Zealand public many lifesaving surgeries in New Zealand public hospitals many lifesaving surgeries in New Zealand public hospitals have many lifesaving surgeries in New Zealand public hospitals have been Zealand public hospitals have been affected Zealand public hospitals have been affected by Zealand public hospitals have been affected by the Zealand public hospitals have been affected by the absence Zealand public hospitals have been affected by the absence of Zealand public hospitals have been affected by the absence of a affected by the absence of a trans-Tasman affected by the absence of a trans-Tasman bubble affected by the absence of a trans-Tasman bubble that affected by the absence of a trans-Tasman bubble that has trans-Tasman bubble that has prevented trans-Tasman bubble that has prevented highly trans-Tasman bubble that has prevented highly skilled trans-Tasman bubble that has prevented highly skilled Australian prevented highly skilled Australian working prevented highly skilled Australian working in prevented highly skilled Australian working in our prevented highly skilled Australian working in our -- prevented highly skilled Australian working in our -- specialists working in our -- specialists working working in our -- specialists working in working in our -- specialists working in our working in our -- specialists working in our DHBs? working in our -- specialists working in our DHBs? I working in our -- specialists working in our DHBs? I would working in our DHBs? I would question, working in our DHBs? I would question, on working in our DHBs? I would question, on behalf working in our DHBs? I would question, on behalf of working in our DHBs? I would question, on behalf of the working in our DHBs? I would question, on behalf of the PM, working in our DHBs? I would question, on behalf of the PM, I question, on behalf of the PM, I would question, on behalf of the PM, I would question question, on behalf of the PM, I would question the question, on behalf of the PM, I would question the premise question, on behalf of the PM, I would question the premise of question, on behalf of the PM, I would question the premise of the would question the premise of the member's would question the premise of the member's question. would question the premise of the member's question. What would question the premise of the member's question. What I would question the premise of the member's question. What I would would question the premise of the member's question. What I would say member's question. What I would say is member's question. What I would say is that member's question. What I would say is that we member's question. What I would say is that we have member's question. What I would say is that we have put member's question. What I would say is that we have put significant is that we have put significant extra is that we have put significant extra resources is that we have put significant extra resources in is that we have put significant extra resources in to is that we have put significant extra resources in to make is that we have put significant extra resources in to make up is that we have put significant extra resources in to make up for extra resources in to make up for delays extra resources in to make up for delays that extra resources in to make up for delays that were extra resources in to make up for delays that were caused extra resources in to make up for delays that were caused by extra resources in to make up for delays that were caused by the delays that were caused by the original delays that were caused by the original COVID delays that were caused by the original COVID lockdown, delays that were caused by the original COVID lockdown, to delays that were caused by the original COVID lockdown, to ensure original COVID lockdown, to ensure that original COVID lockdown, to ensure that New original COVID lockdown, to ensure that New Zealanders original COVID lockdown, to ensure that New Zealanders are original COVID lockdown, to ensure that New Zealanders are getting original COVID lockdown, to ensure that New Zealanders are getting the that New Zealanders are getting the surgery that New Zealanders are getting the surgery and that New Zealanders are getting the surgery and services that New Zealanders are getting the surgery and services they that New Zealanders are getting the surgery and services they need. surgery and services they need. Would surgery and services they need. Would opening surgery and services they need. Would opening a surgery and services they need. Would opening a trans-Tasman surgery and services they need. Would opening a trans-Tasman bubble Would opening a trans-Tasman bubble improve Would opening a trans-Tasman bubble improve the Would opening a trans-Tasman bubble improve the number Would opening a trans-Tasman bubble improve the number of Would opening a trans-Tasman bubble improve the number of healthcare improve the number of healthcare workers improve the number of healthcare workers in improve the number of healthcare workers in New improve the number of healthcare workers in New Zealand improve the number of healthcare workers in New Zealand that improve the number of healthcare workers in New Zealand that would workers in New Zealand that would further workers in New Zealand that would further improve workers in New Zealand that would further improve our workers in New Zealand that would further improve our coronavirus further improve our coronavirus response? further improve our coronavirus response? Well, further improve our coronavirus response? Well, the further improve our coronavirus response? Well, the situation further improve our coronavirus response? Well, the situation we response? Well, the situation we have response? Well, the situation we have in response? Well, the situation we have in New response? Well, the situation we have in New Zealand response? Well, the situation we have in New Zealand at response? Well, the situation we have in New Zealand at the response? Well, the situation we have in New Zealand at the moment response? Well, the situation we have in New Zealand at the moment is have in New Zealand at the moment is a have in New Zealand at the moment is a hardworking have in New Zealand at the moment is a hardworking health have in New Zealand at the moment is a hardworking health workforce have in New Zealand at the moment is a hardworking health workforce that a hardworking health workforce that is a hardworking health workforce that is doing a hardworking health workforce that is doing their a hardworking health workforce that is doing their job a hardworking health workforce that is doing their job well. a hardworking health workforce that is doing their job well. It a hardworking health workforce that is doing their job well. It is a hardworking health workforce that is doing their job well. It is not is doing their job well. It is not the is doing their job well. It is not the goal is doing their job well. It is not the goal of is doing their job well. It is not the goal of a is doing their job well. It is not the goal of a safe is doing their job well. It is not the goal of a safe travel is doing their job well. It is not the goal of a safe travel zone is doing their job well. It is not the goal of a safe travel zone with the goal of a safe travel zone with Australia the goal of a safe travel zone with Australia in the goal of a safe travel zone with Australia in particular the goal of a safe travel zone with Australia in particular to the goal of a safe travel zone with Australia in particular to improve Australia in particular to improve the Australia in particular to improve the number Australia in particular to improve the number of Australia in particular to improve the number of health Australia in particular to improve the number of health workers Australia in particular to improve the number of health workers that Australia in particular to improve the number of health workers that we the number of health workers that we have. the number of health workers that we have. We the number of health workers that we have. We are the number of health workers that we have. We are doing the number of health workers that we have. We are doing the the number of health workers that we have. We are doing the job the number of health workers that we have. We are doing the job on the number of health workers that we have. We are doing the job on behalf have. We are doing the job on behalf of have. We are doing the job on behalf of New have. We are doing the job on behalf of New Zealanders have. We are doing the job on behalf of New Zealanders to have. We are doing the job on behalf of New Zealanders to plan have. We are doing the job on behalf of New Zealanders to plan for have. We are doing the job on behalf of New Zealanders to plan for this. of New Zealanders to plan for this. But, of New Zealanders to plan for this. But, more of New Zealanders to plan for this. But, more importantly of New Zealanders to plan for this. But, more importantly than of New Zealanders to plan for this. But, more importantly than that, But, more importantly than that, those But, more importantly than that, those health But, more importantly than that, those health workers But, more importantly than that, those health workers are But, more importantly than that, those health workers are doing But, more importantly than that, those health workers are doing their those health workers are doing their job those health workers are doing their job on those health workers are doing their job on behalf those health workers are doing their job on behalf of those health workers are doing their job on behalf of New those health workers are doing their job on behalf of New Zealand, those health workers are doing their job on behalf of New Zealand, and those health workers are doing their job on behalf of New Zealand, and we job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should be job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should be very job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should be very grateful job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should be very grateful to job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should be very grateful to them job on behalf of New Zealand, and we should be very grateful to them for should be very grateful to them for that. that. Question that. Question No. that. Question No. 2, that. Question No. 2, Angela that. Question No. 2, Angela Roberts. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Education: of Education: What of Education: What response of Education: What response has of Education: What response has he of Education: What response has he seen of Education: What response has he seen to What response has he seen to Government What response has he seen to Government initiatives Government initiatives to Government initiatives to support Government initiatives to support training Government initiatives to support training and to support training and apprenticeships? The The Hon The Hon Chris The Hon Chris Hipkins. The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. I'm The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. I'm pleased The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. I'm pleased to The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. I'm pleased to report The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. I'm pleased to report that The Hon Chris Hipkins. Good news. I'm pleased to report that New I'm pleased to report that New Zealanders I'm pleased to report that New Zealanders are I'm pleased to report that New Zealanders are flocking I'm pleased to report that New Zealanders are flocking to I'm pleased to report that New Zealanders are flocking to the Zealanders are flocking to the trades, Zealanders are flocking to the trades, with Zealanders are flocking to the trades, with more Zealanders are flocking to the trades, with more than Zealanders are flocking to the trades, with more than 100,000 trades, with more than 100,000 learners trades, with more than 100,000 learners supported trades, with more than 100,000 learners supported in trades, with more than 100,000 learners supported in free learners supported in free vocational learners supported in free vocational training learners supported in free vocational training and vocational training and apprenticeships vocational training and apprenticeships under vocational training and apprenticeships under the vocational training and apprenticeships under the Targeted apprenticeships under the Targeted Training apprenticeships under the Targeted Training and apprenticeships under the Targeted Training and Apprenticeships apprenticeships under the Targeted Training and Apprenticeships Fund, Training and Apprenticeships Fund, or Training and Apprenticeships Fund, or TTAF. Training and Apprenticeships Fund, or TTAF. The Training and Apprenticeships Fund, or TTAF. The latest Training and Apprenticeships Fund, or TTAF. The latest enrolment Training and Apprenticeships Fund, or TTAF. The latest enrolment data or TTAF. The latest enrolment data shows or TTAF. The latest enrolment data shows 106,600 or TTAF. The latest enrolment data shows 106,600 people or TTAF. The latest enrolment data shows 106,600 people have or TTAF. The latest enrolment data shows 106,600 people have taken shows 106,600 people have taken advantage shows 106,600 people have taken advantage of shows 106,600 people have taken advantage of free shows 106,600 people have taken advantage of free trades shows 106,600 people have taken advantage of free trades training advantage of free trades training since advantage of free trades training since we advantage of free trades training since we introduced advantage of free trades training since we introduced it advantage of free trades training since we introduced it in advantage of free trades training since we introduced it in July advantage of free trades training since we introduced it in July last since we introduced it in July last year, since we introduced it in July last year, including since we introduced it in July last year, including more since we introduced it in July last year, including more than since we introduced it in July last year, including more than 58,000 year, including more than 58,000 apprentices. year, including more than 58,000 apprentices. The year, including more than 58,000 apprentices. The Government apprentices. The Government introduced apprentices. The Government introduced TTAF apprentices. The Government introduced TTAF in apprentices. The Government introduced TTAF in July apprentices. The Government introduced TTAF in July last apprentices. The Government introduced TTAF in July last year introduced TTAF in July last year and introduced TTAF in July last year and it introduced TTAF in July last year and it makes introduced TTAF in July last year and it makes a introduced TTAF in July last year and it makes a range introduced TTAF in July last year and it makes a range of and it makes a range of qualifications and it makes a range of qualifications in and it makes a range of qualifications in targeted and it makes a range of qualifications in targeted areas, qualifications in targeted areas, and qualifications in targeted areas, and all qualifications in targeted areas, and all apprenticeships qualifications in targeted areas, and all apprenticeships free qualifications in targeted areas, and all apprenticeships free until and all apprenticeships free until December and all apprenticeships free until December 2022. and all apprenticeships free until December 2022. What and all apprenticeships free until December 2022. What industries and all apprenticeships free until December 2022. What industries are December 2022. What industries are these December 2022. What industries are these students December 2022. What industries are these students and December 2022. What industries are these students and apprentices these students and apprentices working these students and apprentices working in? these students and apprentices working in? Good these students and apprentices working in? Good news these students and apprentices working in? Good news - these students and apprentices working in? Good news - one-third these students and apprentices working in? Good news - one-third of working in? Good news - one-third of TTAF working in? Good news - one-third of TTAF learners working in? Good news - one-third of TTAF learners are working in? Good news - one-third of TTAF learners are in working in? Good news - one-third of TTAF learners are in the working in? Good news - one-third of TTAF learners are in the building TTAF learners are in the building and TTAF learners are in the building and construction TTAF learners are in the building and construction industry, TTAF learners are in the building and construction industry, with TTAF learners are in the building and construction industry, with the and construction industry, with the next and construction industry, with the next most and construction industry, with the next most popular and construction industry, with the next most popular areas and construction industry, with the next most popular areas primary next most popular areas primary industries next most popular areas primary industries and next most popular areas primary industries and then next most popular areas primary industries and then community industries and then community support. industries and then community support. Once industries and then community support. Once qualified, industries and then community support. Once qualified, these support. Once qualified, these workers support. Once qualified, these workers will support. Once qualified, these workers will help support. Once qualified, these workers will help support support. Once qualified, these workers will help support New workers will help support New Zealand's workers will help support New Zealand's effort workers will help support New Zealand's effort to workers will help support New Zealand's effort to recover workers will help support New Zealand's effort to recover from Zealand's effort to recover from COVID-19 Zealand's effort to recover from COVID-19 and Zealand's effort to recover from COVID-19 and develop Zealand's effort to recover from COVID-19 and develop our Zealand's effort to recover from COVID-19 and develop our economy Zealand's effort to recover from COVID-19 and develop our economy in COVID-19 and develop our economy in the COVID-19 and develop our economy in the years COVID-19 and develop our economy in the years to COVID-19 and develop our economy in the years to come. COVID-19 and develop our economy in the years to come. Are COVID-19 and develop our economy in the years to come. Are Maori, the years to come. Are Maori, Pacific the years to come. Are Maori, Pacific people the years to come. Are Maori, Pacific people and the years to come. Are Maori, Pacific people and older the years to come. Are Maori, Pacific people and older workers Pacific people and older workers well-represented Pacific people and older workers well-represented in Pacific people and older workers well-represented in the Pacific people and older workers well-represented in the programme? well-represented in the programme? Very well-represented in the programme? Very good well-represented in the programme? Very good question. well-represented in the programme? Very good question. Yes, well-represented in the programme? Very good question. Yes, it's well-represented in the programme? Very good question. Yes, it's good Very good question. Yes, it's good to Very good question. Yes, it's good to see Very good question. Yes, it's good to see very Very good question. Yes, it's good to see very strong Very good question. Yes, it's good to see very strong interest Very good question. Yes, it's good to see very strong interest from to see very strong interest from across to see very strong interest from across the to see very strong interest from across the community. to see very strong interest from across the community. 19% to see very strong interest from across the community. 19% are to see very strong interest from across the community. 19% are Maori, across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% Pacific, across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% Pacific, and across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% Pacific, and 13% across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also across the community. 19% are Maori, 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in terms 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in terms of 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in terms of age 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in terms of age cohorts, 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in terms of age cohorts, this 9% Pacific, and 13% Asian. Also in terms of age cohorts, this isn't terms of age cohorts, this isn't just terms of age cohorts, this isn't just designed terms of age cohorts, this isn't just designed for terms of age cohorts, this isn't just designed for school-leavers, just designed for school-leavers, but just designed for school-leavers, but for just designed for school-leavers, but for people just designed for school-leavers, but for people in just designed for school-leavers, but for people in a just designed for school-leavers, but for people in a wide just designed for school-leavers, but for people in a wide range just designed for school-leavers, but for people in a wide range of but for people in a wide range of circumstances but for people in a wide range of circumstances throughout but for people in a wide range of circumstances throughout their circumstances throughout their lives. circumstances throughout their lives. People circumstances throughout their lives. People have circumstances throughout their lives. People have taken circumstances throughout their lives. People have taken that circumstances throughout their lives. People have taken that on lives. People have taken that on board. lives. People have taken that on board. Nearly lives. People have taken that on board. Nearly a lives. People have taken that on board. Nearly a quarter lives. People have taken that on board. Nearly a quarter are lives. People have taken that on board. Nearly a quarter are over lives. People have taken that on board. Nearly a quarter are over the board. Nearly a quarter are over the age board. Nearly a quarter are over the age of board. Nearly a quarter are over the age of 40. board. Nearly a quarter are over the age of 40. And board. Nearly a quarter are over the age of 40. And about board. Nearly a quarter are over the age of 40. And about two-thirds age of 40. And about two-thirds overall age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are over age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are over the age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are over the age age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are over the age of age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are over the age of 25. age of 40. And about two-thirds overall are over the age of 25. What overall are over the age of 25. What reports overall are over the age of 25. What reports has overall are over the age of 25. What reports has he overall are over the age of 25. What reports has he seen overall are over the age of 25. What reports has he seen about overall are over the age of 25. What reports has he seen about other reports has he seen about other Government reports has he seen about other Government initiatives reports has he seen about other Government initiatives to reports has he seen about other Government initiatives to support Government initiatives to support training Government initiatives to support training and Government initiatives to support training and apprenticeships? Government initiatives to support training and apprenticeships? More training and apprenticeships? More good training and apprenticeships? More good news. training and apprenticeships? More good news. As training and apprenticeships? More good news. As well training and apprenticeships? More good news. As well as training and apprenticeships? More good news. As well as the training and apprenticeships? More good news. As well as the Free good news. As well as the Free Training good news. As well as the Free Training For good news. As well as the Free Training For Learners, good news. As well as the Free Training For Learners, we're good news. As well as the Free Training For Learners, we're backing Training For Learners, we're backing employers Training For Learners, we're backing employers to Training For Learners, we're backing employers to keep Training For Learners, we're backing employers to keep their Training For Learners, we're backing employers to keep their apprentices employers to keep their apprentices in employers to keep their apprentices in work employers to keep their apprentices in work through employers to keep their apprentices in work through their employers to keep their apprentices in work through their training, in work through their training, through in work through their training, through the in work through their training, through the Apprenticeship in work through their training, through the Apprenticeship Boost through the Apprenticeship Boost Scheme. through the Apprenticeship Boost Scheme. Apprenticeship through the Apprenticeship Boost Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost provides Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost provides a Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost provides a subsidy Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost provides a subsidy for Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost provides a subsidy for employers Scheme. Apprenticeship Boost provides a subsidy for employers of provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a month provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a month for provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a month for the provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a month for the first provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a month for the first year provides a subsidy for employers of $1,000 a month for the first year of $1,000 a month for the first year of an $1,000 a month for the first year of an apprentice's $1,000 a month for the first year of an apprentice's work, $1,000 a month for the first year of an apprentice's work, and $1,000 a month for the first year of an apprentice's work, and $500 $1,000 a month for the first year of an apprentice's work, and $500 a an apprentice's work, and $500 a month an apprentice's work, and $500 a month in an apprentice's work, and $500 a month in the an apprentice's work, and $500 a month in the second an apprentice's work, and $500 a month in the second year. an apprentice's work, and $500 a month in the second year. Since an apprentice's work, and $500 a month in the second year. Since the month in the second year. Since the Apprenticeship month in the second year. Since the Apprenticeship Boost month in the second year. Since the Apprenticeship Boost was month in the second year. Since the Apprenticeship Boost was rolled month in the second year. Since the Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out in Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out in August Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out in August last Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out in August last year, Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out in August last year, over Apprenticeship Boost was rolled out in August last year, over 10,000 in August last year, over 10,000 employers in August last year, over 10,000 employers have in August last year, over 10,000 employers have signed in August last year, over 10,000 employers have signed up in August last year, over 10,000 employers have signed up and employers have signed up and received employers have signed up and received almost employers have signed up and received almost $97 employers have signed up and received almost $97 million employers have signed up and received almost $97 million worth employers have signed up and received almost $97 million worth of received almost $97 million worth of subsidies received almost $97 million worth of subsidies for received almost $97 million worth of subsidies for 21,000 received almost $97 million worth of subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. received almost $97 million worth of subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the second subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the second half subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the second half of subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the second half of last subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the second half of last year, subsidies for 21,000 apprentices. In the second half of last year, it the second half of last year, it roughly the second half of last year, it roughly doubled the second half of last year, it roughly doubled the the second half of last year, it roughly doubled the number the second half of last year, it roughly doubled the number of roughly doubled the number of apprentice roughly doubled the number of apprentice new roughly doubled the number of apprentice new starts roughly doubled the number of apprentice new starts signed roughly doubled the number of apprentice new starts signed up apprentice new starts signed up compared apprentice new starts signed up compared to apprentice new starts signed up compared to the apprentice new starts signed up compared to the year apprentice new starts signed up compared to the year before. compared to the year before. Question compared to the year before. Question No. compared to the year before. Question No. 3, compared to the year before. Question No. 3, Jan compared to the year before. Question No. 3, Jan Logie. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for ACC: for ACC: Will for ACC: Will she for ACC: Will she direct for ACC: Will she direct ACC for ACC: Will she direct ACC to for ACC: Will she direct ACC to ensure for ACC: Will she direct ACC to ensure all Will she direct ACC to ensure all survivors, Will she direct ACC to ensure all survivors, including Will she direct ACC to ensure all survivors, including families Will she direct ACC to ensure all survivors, including families and survivors, including families and witnesses, survivors, including families and witnesses, of survivors, including families and witnesses, of the survivors, including families and witnesses, of the tragic survivors, including families and witnesses, of the tragic terrorist witnesses, of the tragic terrorist attack witnesses, of the tragic terrorist attack on witnesses, of the tragic terrorist attack on 15 witnesses, of the tragic terrorist attack on 15 March witnesses, of the tragic terrorist attack on 15 March 2019 attack on 15 March 2019 can attack on 15 March 2019 can access attack on 15 March 2019 can access ACC attack on 15 March 2019 can access ACC support? The The Hon The Hon Carmel The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As a The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As a Government, The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As a Government, we The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As a Government, we continue The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As a Government, we continue to The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. As a Government, we continue to provide Government, we continue to provide support Government, we continue to provide support to Government, we continue to provide support to survivors Government, we continue to provide support to survivors of Government, we continue to provide support to survivors of the Government, we continue to provide support to survivors of the 15 Government, we continue to provide support to survivors of the 15 March support to survivors of the 15 March mosque support to survivors of the 15 March mosque attacks support to survivors of the 15 March mosque attacks and support to survivors of the 15 March mosque attacks and their support to survivors of the 15 March mosque attacks and their whanau mosque attacks and their whanau through mosque attacks and their whanau through a mosque attacks and their whanau through a range mosque attacks and their whanau through a range of mosque attacks and their whanau through a range of mechanisms, through a range of mechanisms, depending through a range of mechanisms, depending on through a range of mechanisms, depending on need through a range of mechanisms, depending on need and through a range of mechanisms, depending on need and circumstance. depending on need and circumstance. MSD depending on need and circumstance. MSD established depending on need and circumstance. MSD established a depending on need and circumstance. MSD established a bespoke depending on need and circumstance. MSD established a bespoke welfare MSD established a bespoke welfare programme MSD established a bespoke welfare programme for MSD established a bespoke welfare programme for those MSD established a bespoke welfare programme for those affected MSD established a bespoke welfare programme for those affected by MSD established a bespoke welfare programme for those affected by the programme for those affected by the mosque programme for those affected by the mosque attacks. programme for those affected by the mosque attacks. We programme for those affected by the mosque attacks. We invested programme for those affected by the mosque attacks. We invested into mosque attacks. We invested into mental mosque attacks. We invested into mosque mosque attacks. We invested into mental health support mosque attacks. We invested into mental health support services mosque attacks. We invested into mental health support services at mental health support services at the mental health support services at the Canterbury mental health support services at the Canterbury DHB, mental health support services at the Canterbury DHB, have mental health support services at the Canterbury DHB, have made the Canterbury DHB, have made changes the Canterbury DHB, have made changes to the Canterbury DHB, have made changes to visa the Canterbury DHB, have made changes to visa programmes the Canterbury DHB, have made changes to visa programmes to the Canterbury DHB, have made changes to visa programmes to allow changes to visa programmes to allow greater changes to visa programmes to allow greater access changes to visa programmes to allow greater access to changes to visa programmes to allow greater access to domestic changes to visa programmes to allow greater access to domestic support greater access to domestic support for greater access to domestic support for survivors. greater access to domestic support for survivors. And, greater access to domestic support for survivors. And, of greater access to domestic support for survivors. And, of course, greater access to domestic support for survivors. And, of course, ACC for survivors. And, of course, ACC continues for survivors. And, of course, ACC continues to for survivors. And, of course, ACC continues to cover for survivors. And, of course, ACC continues to cover those for survivors. And, of course, ACC continues to cover those who for survivors. And, of course, ACC continues to cover those who are continues to cover those who are entitled continues to cover those who are entitled to continues to cover those who are entitled to the continues to cover those who are entitled to the scheme. continues to cover those who are entitled to the scheme. To continues to cover those who are entitled to the scheme. To ensure entitled to the scheme. To ensure people entitled to the scheme. To ensure people are entitled to the scheme. To ensure people are able entitled to the scheme. To ensure people are able to entitled to the scheme. To ensure people are able to navigate entitled to the scheme. To ensure people are able to navigate that people are able to navigate that support, people are able to navigate that support, MSD people are able to navigate that support, MSD has people are able to navigate that support, MSD has also people are able to navigate that support, MSD has also been people are able to navigate that support, MSD has also been providing support, MSD has also been providing an support, MSD has also been providing an intensive support, MSD has also been providing an intensive case support, MSD has also been providing an intensive case management an intensive case management service, an intensive case management service, Kai-Whaka an intensive case management service, Kai-Whaka Oranga. an intensive case management service, Kai-Whaka Oranga. This service, Kai-Whaka Oranga. This ensures service, Kai-Whaka Oranga. This ensures survivors, service, Kai-Whaka Oranga. This ensures survivors, witnesses service, Kai-Whaka Oranga. This ensures survivors, witnesses and ensures survivors, witnesses and their ensures survivors, witnesses and their whanau ensures survivors, witnesses and their whanau have ensures survivors, witnesses and their whanau have a ensures survivors, witnesses and their whanau have a single ensures survivors, witnesses and their whanau have a single point ensures survivors, witnesses and their whanau have a single point of their whanau have a single point of contact their whanau have a single point of contact for their whanau have a single point of contact for accessing their whanau have a single point of contact for accessing support their whanau have a single point of contact for accessing support across contact for accessing support across Government contact for accessing support across Government and contact for accessing support across Government and in contact for accessing support across Government and in their contact for accessing support across Government and in their communities. Government and in their communities. While Government and in their communities. While we Government and in their communities. While we continue Government and in their communities. While we continue to Government and in their communities. While we continue to assess Government and in their communities. While we continue to assess the While we continue to assess the situation While we continue to assess the situation for While we continue to assess the situation for ways While we continue to assess the situation for ways we While we continue to assess the situation for ways we can While we continue to assess the situation for ways we can better situation for ways we can better understand situation for ways we can better understand and situation for ways we can better understand and address situation for ways we can better understand and address the situation for ways we can better understand and address the needs situation for ways we can better understand and address the needs of understand and address the needs of survivors understand and address the needs of survivors across understand and address the needs of survivors across Government, understand and address the needs of survivors across Government, I understand and address the needs of survivors across Government, I have survivors across Government, I have no survivors across Government, I have no immediate survivors across Government, I have no immediate plans survivors across Government, I have no immediate plans to survivors across Government, I have no immediate plans to direct survivors across Government, I have no immediate plans to direct ACC survivors across Government, I have no immediate plans to direct ACC in no immediate plans to direct ACC in the no immediate plans to direct ACC in the way no immediate plans to direct ACC in the way the no immediate plans to direct ACC in the way the member no immediate plans to direct ACC in the way the member suggests. no immediate plans to direct ACC in the way the member suggests. Does the way the member suggests. Does she the way the member suggests. Does she agree the way the member suggests. Does she agree that the way the member suggests. Does she agree that mental the way the member suggests. Does she agree that mental injury the way the member suggests. Does she agree that mental injury and she agree that mental injury and trauma, she agree that mental injury and trauma, as she agree that mental injury and trauma, as a she agree that mental injury and trauma, as a result she agree that mental injury and trauma, as a result of she agree that mental injury and trauma, as a result of experiencing trauma, as a result of experiencing a trauma, as a result of experiencing a deadly trauma, as a result of experiencing a deadly terrorist trauma, as a result of experiencing a deadly terrorist attack, trauma, as a result of experiencing a deadly terrorist attack, may trauma, as a result of experiencing a deadly terrorist attack, may have a deadly terrorist attack, may have as a deadly terrorist attack, may have as significant a deadly terrorist attack, may have as significant an a deadly terrorist attack, may have as significant an impact a deadly terrorist attack, may have as significant an impact as a deadly terrorist attack, may have as significant an impact as a as significant an impact as a physical as significant an impact as a physical injury as significant an impact as a physical injury and as significant an impact as a physical injury and also as significant an impact as a physical injury and also require as significant an impact as a physical injury and also require a physical injury and also require a higher physical injury and also require a higher level physical injury and also require a higher level of physical injury and also require a higher level of compensation physical injury and also require a higher level of compensation for higher level of compensation for inability higher level of compensation for inability to higher level of compensation for inability to work higher level of compensation for inability to work and higher level of compensation for inability to work and ongoing inability to work and ongoing support? inability to work and ongoing support? I inability to work and ongoing support? I don't inability to work and ongoing support? I don't think inability to work and ongoing support? I don't think any inability to work and ongoing support? I don't think any of inability to work and ongoing support? I don't think any of us inability to work and ongoing support? I don't think any of us can support? I don't think any of us can underestimate support? I don't think any of us can underestimate the support? I don't think any of us can underestimate the mental support? I don't think any of us can underestimate the mental trauma support? I don't think any of us can underestimate the mental trauma that underestimate the mental trauma that those underestimate the mental trauma that those who underestimate the mental trauma that those who were underestimate the mental trauma that those who were witnesses underestimate the mental trauma that those who were witnesses to underestimate the mental trauma that those who were witnesses to the those who were witnesses to the mosque those who were witnesses to the mosque attack those who were witnesses to the mosque attack have those who were witnesses to the mosque attack have experienced. those who were witnesses to the mosque attack have experienced. And mosque attack have experienced. And the mosque attack have experienced. And the decision mosque attack have experienced. And the decision was mosque attack have experienced. And the decision was made mosque attack have experienced. And the decision was made to mosque attack have experienced. And the decision was made to put the decision was made to put additional the decision was made to put additional support the decision was made to put additional support into the decision was made to put additional support into place additional support into place through additional support into place through the additional support into place through the DHB additional support into place through the DHB with additional support into place through the DHB with regards additional support into place through the DHB with regards to through the DHB with regards to mental through the DHB with regards to mental health. through the DHB with regards to mental health. Also, through the DHB with regards to mental health. Also, the through the DHB with regards to mental health. Also, the single mental health. Also, the single point mental health. Also, the single point of mental health. Also, the single point of contact mental health. Also, the single point of contact and mental health. Also, the single point of contact and the mental health. Also, the single point of contact and the wrap-around point of contact and the wrap-around support point of contact and the wrap-around support via point of contact and the wrap-around support via MSD. point of contact and the wrap-around support via MSD. And point of contact and the wrap-around support via MSD. And we point of contact and the wrap-around support via MSD. And we continue point of contact and the wrap-around support via MSD. And we continue to support via MSD. And we continue to monitor support via MSD. And we continue to monitor the support via MSD. And we continue to monitor the situation support via MSD. And we continue to monitor the situation to support via MSD. And we continue to monitor the situation to see support via MSD. And we continue to monitor the situation to see how support via MSD. And we continue to monitor the situation to see how we monitor the situation to see how we can monitor the situation to see how we can continue monitor the situation to see how we can continue to monitor the situation to see how we can continue to support monitor the situation to see how we can continue to support those monitor the situation to see how we can continue to support those who can continue to support those who have can continue to support those who have been can continue to support those who have been impacted can continue to support those who have been impacted by can continue to support those who have been impacted by the can continue to support those who have been impacted by the mosque have been impacted by the mosque attacks. attacks. What attacks. What is attacks. What is the attacks. What is the Minister's attacks. What is the Minister's response attacks. What is the Minister's response to What is the Minister's response to those What is the Minister's response to those victims What is the Minister's response to those victims who What is the Minister's response to those victims who have What is the Minister's response to those victims who have clearly What is the Minister's response to those victims who have clearly said those victims who have clearly said that those victims who have clearly said that the those victims who have clearly said that the support those victims who have clearly said that the support from those victims who have clearly said that the support from the those victims who have clearly said that the support from the health those victims who have clearly said that the support from the health and that the support from the health and welfare that the support from the health and welfare systems that the support from the health and welfare systems has that the support from the health and welfare systems has not that the support from the health and welfare systems has not been welfare systems has not been adequate? welfare systems has not been adequate? We welfare systems has not been adequate? We have welfare systems has not been adequate? We have an welfare systems has not been adequate? We have an ongoing adequate? We have an ongoing programme adequate? We have an ongoing programme to adequate? We have an ongoing programme to ensure adequate? We have an ongoing programme to ensure that adequate? We have an ongoing programme to ensure that we adequate? We have an ongoing programme to ensure that we are programme to ensure that we are looking programme to ensure that we are looking at programme to ensure that we are looking at ways programme to ensure that we are looking at ways in programme to ensure that we are looking at ways in which programme to ensure that we are looking at ways in which we programme to ensure that we are looking at ways in which we can looking at ways in which we can support looking at ways in which we can support those looking at ways in which we can support those who looking at ways in which we can support those who have looking at ways in which we can support those who have been looking at ways in which we can support those who have been impacted support those who have been impacted by support those who have been impacted by the support those who have been impacted by the mosque support those who have been impacted by the mosque attacks. support those who have been impacted by the mosque attacks. That support those who have been impacted by the mosque attacks. That work by the mosque attacks. That work involves by the mosque attacks. That work involves a by the mosque attacks. That work involves a range by the mosque attacks. That work involves a range of by the mosque attacks. That work involves a range of Ministers, involves a range of Ministers, including involves a range of Ministers, including Minister involves a range of Ministers, including Minister Radhakrishnan involves a range of Ministers, including Minister Radhakrishnan and including Minister Radhakrishnan and Minister including Minister Radhakrishnan and Minister Little including Minister Radhakrishnan and Minister Little and including Minister Radhakrishnan and Minister Little and myself including Minister Radhakrishnan and Minister Little and myself as including Minister Radhakrishnan and Minister Little and myself as the Minister Little and myself as the Minister Minister Little and myself as the Minister for Minister Little and myself as the Minister for ACC, Minister Little and myself as the Minister for ACC, and Minister Little and myself as the Minister for ACC, and others Minister Little and myself as the Minister for ACC, and others also. Minister for ACC, and others also. So, Minister for ACC, and others also. So, we Minister for ACC, and others also. So, we want Minister for ACC, and others also. So, we want to Minister for ACC, and others also. So, we want to continue Minister for ACC, and others also. So, we want to continue to Minister for ACC, and others also. So, we want to continue to assess So, we want to continue to assess the So, we want to continue to assess the situation So, we want to continue to assess the situation and So, we want to continue to assess the situation and ensure So, we want to continue to assess the situation and ensure that So, we want to continue to assess the situation and ensure that the the situation and ensure that the supports the situation and ensure that the supports that the situation and ensure that the supports that are the situation and ensure that the supports that are in the situation and ensure that the supports that are in place the situation and ensure that the supports that are in place are supports that are in place are working. supports that are in place are working. If supports that are in place are working. If the supports that are in place are working. If the member supports that are in place are working. If the member comes supports that are in place are working. If the member comes across working. If the member comes across families working. If the member comes across families or working. If the member comes across families or individuals working. If the member comes across families or individuals who working. If the member comes across families or individuals who she families or individuals who she feels families or individuals who she feels are families or individuals who she feels are not families or individuals who she feels are not getting families or individuals who she feels are not getting access families or individuals who she feels are not getting access to families or individuals who she feels are not getting access to the feels are not getting access to the supports feels are not getting access to the supports that feels are not getting access to the supports that we've feels are not getting access to the supports that we've put feels are not getting access to the supports that we've put in feels are not getting access to the supports that we've put in place, feels are not getting access to the supports that we've put in place, or supports that we've put in place, or that supports that we've put in place, or that they supports that we've put in place, or that they are supports that we've put in place, or that they are not supports that we've put in place, or that they are not adequate, supports that we've put in place, or that they are not adequate, then supports that we've put in place, or that they are not adequate, then I that they are not adequate, then I would that they are not adequate, then I would encourage that they are not adequate, then I would encourage the that they are not adequate, then I would encourage the member that they are not adequate, then I would encourage the member to that they are not adequate, then I would encourage the member to send would encourage the member to send those would encourage the member to send those cases would encourage the member to send those cases through would encourage the member to send those cases through to would encourage the member to send those cases through to us. would encourage the member to send those cases through to us. Does would encourage the member to send those cases through to us. Does she those cases through to us. Does she agree those cases through to us. Does she agree that those cases through to us. Does she agree that ACC those cases through to us. Does she agree that ACC can those cases through to us. Does she agree that ACC can provide those cases through to us. Does she agree that ACC can provide a those cases through to us. Does she agree that ACC can provide a greater agree that ACC can provide a greater level agree that ACC can provide a greater level of agree that ACC can provide a greater level of ongoing agree that ACC can provide a greater level of ongoing support agree that ACC can provide a greater level of ongoing support and level of ongoing support and healthcare level of ongoing support and healthcare than level of ongoing support and healthcare than is level of ongoing support and healthcare than is otherwise healthcare than is otherwise available? healthcare than is otherwise available? I healthcare than is otherwise available? I am healthcare than is otherwise available? I am often healthcare than is otherwise available? I am often approached healthcare than is otherwise available? I am often approached - available? I am often approached - and available? I am often approached - and I available? I am often approached - and I think available? I am often approached - and I think every available? I am often approached - and I think every ACC available? I am often approached - and I think every ACC Minister available? I am often approached - and I think every ACC Minister would and I think every ACC Minister would have and I think every ACC Minister would have been and I think every ACC Minister would have been across and I think every ACC Minister would have been across the and I think every ACC Minister would have been across the course and I think every ACC Minister would have been across the course of and I think every ACC Minister would have been across the course of time have been across the course of time that have been across the course of time that this have been across the course of time that this scheme have been across the course of time that this scheme has have been across the course of time that this scheme has been have been across the course of time that this scheme has been in have been across the course of time that this scheme has been in place have been across the course of time that this scheme has been in place - that this scheme has been in place - to that this scheme has been in place - to look that this scheme has been in place - to look at that this scheme has been in place - to look at expansion that this scheme has been in place - to look at expansion and that this scheme has been in place - to look at expansion and ways that this scheme has been in place - to look at expansion and ways to to look at expansion and ways to expand. to look at expansion and ways to expand. And to look at expansion and ways to expand. And that to look at expansion and ways to expand. And that is to look at expansion and ways to expand. And that is not to look at expansion and ways to expand. And that is not just to look at expansion and ways to expand. And that is not just with expand. And that is not just with regards expand. And that is not just with regards to expand. And that is not just with regards to the expand. And that is not just with regards to the mosque expand. And that is not just with regards to the mosque attacks expand. And that is not just with regards to the mosque attacks and regards to the mosque attacks and the regards to the mosque attacks and the mental regards to the mosque attacks and the mental trauma regards to the mosque attacks and the mental trauma that regards to the mosque attacks and the mental trauma that people regards to the mosque attacks and the mental trauma that people have the mental trauma that people have experienced the mental trauma that people have experienced here. the mental trauma that people have experienced here. You the mental trauma that people have experienced here. You know, the mental trauma that people have experienced here. You know, moving experienced here. You know, moving forward, experienced here. You know, moving forward, we experienced here. You know, moving forward, we need experienced here. You know, moving forward, we need to experienced here. You know, moving forward, we need to continue experienced here. You know, moving forward, we need to continue to experienced here. You know, moving forward, we need to continue to look forward, we need to continue to look at forward, we need to continue to look at the forward, we need to continue to look at the scheme forward, we need to continue to look at the scheme and forward, we need to continue to look at the scheme and see forward, we need to continue to look at the scheme and see that forward, we need to continue to look at the scheme and see that it's forward, we need to continue to look at the scheme and see that it's fit at the scheme and see that it's fit for at the scheme and see that it's fit for purpose. at the scheme and see that it's fit for purpose. But at the scheme and see that it's fit for purpose. But with at the scheme and see that it's fit for purpose. But with regards at the scheme and see that it's fit for purpose. But with regards to at the scheme and see that it's fit for purpose. But with regards to the for purpose. But with regards to the suggested for purpose. But with regards to the suggested directive for purpose. But with regards to the suggested directive that for purpose. But with regards to the suggested directive that the for purpose. But with regards to the suggested directive that the member suggested directive that the member has suggested directive that the member has asked suggested directive that the member has asked that suggested directive that the member has asked that I suggested directive that the member has asked that I make suggested directive that the member has asked that I make today, suggested directive that the member has asked that I make today, there has asked that I make today, there is has asked that I make today, there is no has asked that I make today, there is no consideration has asked that I make today, there is no consideration being has asked that I make today, there is no consideration being given has asked that I make today, there is no consideration being given to is no consideration being given to that is no consideration being given to that type is no consideration being given to that type of is no consideration being given to that type of directive. that type of directive. Is that type of directive. Is she that type of directive. Is she unwilling that type of directive. Is she unwilling to that type of directive. Is she unwilling to extend that type of directive. Is she unwilling to extend ACC that type of directive. Is she unwilling to extend ACC to Is she unwilling to extend ACC to cover Is she unwilling to extend ACC to cover mental Is she unwilling to extend ACC to cover mental injury Is she unwilling to extend ACC to cover mental injury to Is she unwilling to extend ACC to cover mental injury to all Is she unwilling to extend ACC to cover mental injury to all victims cover mental injury to all victims of cover mental injury to all victims of the cover mental injury to all victims of the attack cover mental injury to all victims of the attack alone cover mental injury to all victims of the attack alone because cover mental injury to all victims of the attack alone because the cover mental injury to all victims of the attack alone because the cost of the attack alone because the cost of of the attack alone because the cost of compensation of the attack alone because the cost of compensation for of the attack alone because the cost of compensation for inability of the attack alone because the cost of compensation for inability to of compensation for inability to work of compensation for inability to work is of compensation for inability to work is considered of compensation for inability to work is considered too of compensation for inability to work is considered too high? of compensation for inability to work is considered too high? I of compensation for inability to work is considered too high? I think work is considered too high? I think it work is considered too high? I think it would work is considered too high? I think it would be work is considered too high? I think it would be unfair work is considered too high? I think it would be unfair to work is considered too high? I think it would be unfair to put work is considered too high? I think it would be unfair to put the work is considered too high? I think it would be unfair to put the reason it would be unfair to put the reason for it would be unfair to put the reason for not it would be unfair to put the reason for not utilising it would be unfair to put the reason for not utilising ACC, it would be unfair to put the reason for not utilising ACC, or it would be unfair to put the reason for not utilising ACC, or looking it would be unfair to put the reason for not utilising ACC, or looking to for not utilising ACC, or looking to expand for not utilising ACC, or looking to expand it for not utilising ACC, or looking to expand it in for not utilising ACC, or looking to expand it in this for not utilising ACC, or looking to expand it in this circumstance, for not utilising ACC, or looking to expand it in this circumstance, down expand it in this circumstance, down to expand it in this circumstance, down to just expand it in this circumstance, down to just the expand it in this circumstance, down to just the fiscal, expand it in this circumstance, down to just the fiscal, to expand it in this circumstance, down to just the fiscal, to any expand it in this circumstance, down to just the fiscal, to any kind expand it in this circumstance, down to just the fiscal, to any kind of to just the fiscal, to any kind of fiscal to just the fiscal, to any kind of fiscal constraint. to just the fiscal, to any kind of fiscal constraint. We to just the fiscal, to any kind of fiscal constraint. We need to just the fiscal, to any kind of fiscal constraint. We need to to just the fiscal, to any kind of fiscal constraint. We need to keep fiscal constraint. We need to keep in fiscal constraint. We need to keep in mind fiscal constraint. We need to keep in mind that fiscal constraint. We need to keep in mind that there fiscal constraint. We need to keep in mind that there are fiscal constraint. We need to keep in mind that there are numerous in mind that there are numerous situations in mind that there are numerous situations where in mind that there are numerous situations where ACC in mind that there are numerous situations where ACC have in mind that there are numerous situations where ACC have an situations where ACC have an expectation situations where ACC have an expectation placed situations where ACC have an expectation placed on situations where ACC have an expectation placed on them situations where ACC have an expectation placed on them that situations where ACC have an expectation placed on them that they expectation placed on them that they would expectation placed on them that they would look expectation placed on them that they would look to expectation placed on them that they would look to expand expectation placed on them that they would look to expand the expectation placed on them that they would look to expand the provisions would look to expand the provisions of would look to expand the provisions of ACC. would look to expand the provisions of ACC. And would look to expand the provisions of ACC. And to would look to expand the provisions of ACC. And to the would look to expand the provisions of ACC. And to the member, would look to expand the provisions of ACC. And to the member, I would look to expand the provisions of ACC. And to the member, I will of ACC. And to the member, I will say of ACC. And to the member, I will say that of ACC. And to the member, I will say that I of ACC. And to the member, I will say that I am of ACC. And to the member, I will say that I am comfortable of ACC. And to the member, I will say that I am comfortable with say that I am comfortable with regards say that I am comfortable with regards to say that I am comfortable with regards to where say that I am comfortable with regards to where we say that I am comfortable with regards to where we settled say that I am comfortable with regards to where we settled in regards to where we settled in ensuring regards to where we settled in ensuring that regards to where we settled in ensuring that we regards to where we settled in ensuring that we had regards to where we settled in ensuring that we had adequate ensuring that we had adequate wrap-around ensuring that we had adequate wrap-around support ensuring that we had adequate wrap-around support across ensuring that we had adequate wrap-around support across the wrap-around support across the agencies wrap-around support across the agencies that wrap-around support across the agencies that I wrap-around support across the agencies that I spoke wrap-around support across the agencies that I spoke about, wrap-around support across the agencies that I spoke about, with agencies that I spoke about, with the agencies that I spoke about, with the two agencies that I spoke about, with the two ministries agencies that I spoke about, with the two ministries leading agencies that I spoke about, with the two ministries leading that agencies that I spoke about, with the two ministries leading that work the two ministries leading that work being the two ministries leading that work being the the two ministries leading that work being the Ministry the two ministries leading that work being the Ministry for the two ministries leading that work being the Ministry for Social being the Ministry for Social Development being the Ministry for Social Development and being the Ministry for Social Development and the being the Ministry for Social Development and the Ministry being the Ministry for Social Development and the Ministry for Development and the Ministry for Health. Development and the Ministry for Health. Could Development and the Ministry for Health. Could a Development and the Ministry for Health. Could a decision Development and the Ministry for Health. Could a decision to Development and the Ministry for Health. Could a decision to extend Health. Could a decision to extend just Health. Could a decision to extend just for Health. Could a decision to extend just for these Health. Could a decision to extend just for these additional Health. Could a decision to extend just for these additional victims Health. Could a decision to extend just for these additional victims of just for these additional victims of the just for these additional victims of the terrorist just for these additional victims of the terrorist attack just for these additional victims of the terrorist attack force just for these additional victims of the terrorist attack force wider the terrorist attack force wider reform the terrorist attack force wider reform if the terrorist attack force wider reform if Cabinet the terrorist attack force wider reform if Cabinet didn't the terrorist attack force wider reform if Cabinet didn't support reform if Cabinet didn't support that? reform if Cabinet didn't support that? If reform if Cabinet didn't support that? If I'm reform if Cabinet didn't support that? If I'm interpreting reform if Cabinet didn't support that? If I'm interpreting the that? If I'm interpreting the member's that? If I'm interpreting the member's question that? If I'm interpreting the member's question correctly, that? If I'm interpreting the member's question correctly, I that? If I'm interpreting the member's question correctly, I think member's question correctly, I think that member's question correctly, I think that it member's question correctly, I think that it would member's question correctly, I think that it would be member's question correctly, I think that it would be fair member's question correctly, I think that it would be fair to member's question correctly, I think that it would be fair to say member's question correctly, I think that it would be fair to say that member's question correctly, I think that it would be fair to say that if that it would be fair to say that if there that it would be fair to say that if there was that it would be fair to say that if there was any that it would be fair to say that if there was any expansion that it would be fair to say that if there was any expansion of that it would be fair to say that if there was any expansion of ACC there was any expansion of ACC scheme there was any expansion of ACC scheme to there was any expansion of ACC scheme to cover there was any expansion of ACC scheme to cover the there was any expansion of ACC scheme to cover the area there was any expansion of ACC scheme to cover the area that there was any expansion of ACC scheme to cover the area that the scheme to cover the area that the member scheme to cover the area that the member has scheme to cover the area that the member has spoken scheme to cover the area that the member has spoken about, scheme to cover the area that the member has spoken about, then scheme to cover the area that the member has spoken about, then there member has spoken about, then there would member has spoken about, then there would be member has spoken about, then there would be expectations member has spoken about, then there would be expectations from member has spoken about, then there would be expectations from a member has spoken about, then there would be expectations from a broader would be expectations from a broader range would be expectations from a broader range of would be expectations from a broader range of New would be expectations from a broader range of New Zealand would be expectations from a broader range of New Zealand to would be expectations from a broader range of New Zealand to also would be expectations from a broader range of New Zealand to also revisit range of New Zealand to also revisit other range of New Zealand to also revisit other decisions. range of New Zealand to also revisit other decisions. And range of New Zealand to also revisit other decisions. And so range of New Zealand to also revisit other decisions. And so we range of New Zealand to also revisit other decisions. And so we do range of New Zealand to also revisit other decisions. And so we do need other decisions. And so we do need to other decisions. And so we do need to make other decisions. And so we do need to make sure other decisions. And so we do need to make sure that other decisions. And so we do need to make sure that we other decisions. And so we do need to make sure that we are other decisions. And so we do need to make sure that we are looking other decisions. And so we do need to make sure that we are looking at to make sure that we are looking at the to make sure that we are looking at the entire to make sure that we are looking at the entire landscape to make sure that we are looking at the entire landscape and to make sure that we are looking at the entire landscape and picture the entire landscape and picture with the entire landscape and picture with regards the entire landscape and picture with regards to the entire landscape and picture with regards to the the entire landscape and picture with regards to the support the entire landscape and picture with regards to the support that the entire landscape and picture with regards to the support that ACC with regards to the support that ACC offers, with regards to the support that ACC offers, and with regards to the support that ACC offers, and taking with regards to the support that ACC offers, and taking into offers, and taking into consideration offers, and taking into consideration the offers, and taking into consideration the expectations offers, and taking into consideration the expectations of consideration the expectations of New consideration the expectations of New Zealanders consideration the expectations of New Zealanders in consideration the expectations of New Zealanders in a consideration the expectations of New Zealanders in a range consideration the expectations of New Zealanders in a range of New Zealanders in a range of different New Zealanders in a range of different circumstances. different circumstances. Question different circumstances. Question No. different circumstances. Question No. 4, different circumstances. Question No. 4, Andrew different circumstances. Question No. 4, Andrew Bayly. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: of Finance: Has of Finance: Has he of Finance: Has he asked of Finance: Has he asked Treasury of Finance: Has he asked Treasury for of Finance: Has he asked Treasury for advice of Finance: Has he asked Treasury for advice on Has he asked Treasury for advice on the Has he asked Treasury for advice on the economic Has he asked Treasury for advice on the economic cost Has he asked Treasury for advice on the economic cost to Has he asked Treasury for advice on the economic cost to New Has he asked Treasury for advice on the economic cost to New Zealand the economic cost to New Zealand of the economic cost to New Zealand of not the economic cost to New Zealand of not opening the economic cost to New Zealand of not opening a the economic cost to New Zealand of not opening a trans-Tasman the economic cost to New Zealand of not opening a trans-Tasman travel of not opening a trans-Tasman travel bubble; bubble; if bubble; if so, bubble; if so, what bubble; if so, what is bubble; if so, what is the bubble; if so, what is the estimated if so, what is the estimated cost if so, what is the estimated cost per if so, what is the estimated cost per day? The The Hon The Hon Grant The Hon Grant Robertson. The Hon Grant Robertson. The The Hon Grant Robertson. The Government The Hon Grant Robertson. The Government continues The Hon Grant Robertson. The Government continues to The Hon Grant Robertson. The Government continues to do The Hon Grant Robertson. The Government continues to do the The Hon Grant Robertson. The Government continues to do the work Government continues to do the work required Government continues to do the work required to Government continues to do the work required to open Government continues to do the work required to open a Government continues to do the work required to open a safe Government continues to do the work required to open a safe travel Government continues to do the work required to open a safe travel zone required to open a safe travel zone with required to open a safe travel zone with Australia required to open a safe travel zone with Australia so required to open a safe travel zone with Australia so that required to open a safe travel zone with Australia so that it required to open a safe travel zone with Australia so that it is required to open a safe travel zone with Australia so that it is in required to open a safe travel zone with Australia so that it is in the with Australia so that it is in the best with Australia so that it is in the best interests with Australia so that it is in the best interests of with Australia so that it is in the best interests of New with Australia so that it is in the best interests of New Zealanders, best interests of New Zealanders, and best interests of New Zealanders, and where best interests of New Zealanders, and where the best interests of New Zealanders, and where the appropriate best interests of New Zealanders, and where the appropriate protocols and where the appropriate protocols and and where the appropriate protocols and safeguards and where the appropriate protocols and safeguards are and where the appropriate protocols and safeguards are in and where the appropriate protocols and safeguards are in place. and where the appropriate protocols and safeguards are in place. Not and safeguards are in place. Not being and safeguards are in place. Not being of and safeguards are in place. Not being of a and safeguards are in place. Not being of a negative and safeguards are in place. Not being of a negative mindset, and safeguards are in place. Not being of a negative mindset, I and safeguards are in place. Not being of a negative mindset, I have being of a negative mindset, I have not being of a negative mindset, I have not asked being of a negative mindset, I have not asked for being of a negative mindset, I have not asked for advice being of a negative mindset, I have not asked for advice about being of a negative mindset, I have not asked for advice about not not asked for advice about not opening not asked for advice about not opening a not asked for advice about not opening a trans-Tasman not asked for advice about not opening a trans-Tasman bubble. not asked for advice about not opening a trans-Tasman bubble. I opening a trans-Tasman bubble. I have opening a trans-Tasman bubble. I have previously opening a trans-Tasman bubble. I have previously asked opening a trans-Tasman bubble. I have previously asked for opening a trans-Tasman bubble. I have previously asked for advice have previously asked for advice about have previously asked for advice about the have previously asked for advice about the economic have previously asked for advice about the economic impact have previously asked for advice about the economic impact of about the economic impact of trans-Tasman about the economic impact of trans-Tasman travel about the economic impact of trans-Tasman travel settings, about the economic impact of trans-Tasman travel settings, as trans-Tasman travel settings, as both trans-Tasman travel settings, as both countries trans-Tasman travel settings, as both countries take trans-Tasman travel settings, as both countries take measures trans-Tasman travel settings, as both countries take measures to both countries take measures to protect both countries take measures to protect their both countries take measures to protect their citizens both countries take measures to protect their citizens from both countries take measures to protect their citizens from the protect their citizens from the global protect their citizens from the global COVID-19 protect their citizens from the global COVID-19 pandemic. protect their citizens from the global COVID-19 pandemic. The protect their citizens from the global COVID-19 pandemic. The member global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can read global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can read about global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can read about this global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can read about this himself global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can read about this himself in global COVID-19 pandemic. The member can read about this himself in the can read about this himself in the 26 can read about this himself in the 26 June can read about this himself in the 26 June 2020 can read about this himself in the 26 June 2020 Weekly can read about this himself in the 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic can read about this himself in the 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update that 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update that has 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update that has been 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update that has been published 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update that has been published on 26 June 2020 Weekly Economic Update that has been published on The that has been published on The Treasury's that has been published on The Treasury's website that has been published on The Treasury's website N that has been published on The Treasury's website N answer that has been published on The Treasury's website N answer to that has been published on The Treasury's website N answer to the Treasury's website N answer to the second Treasury's website N answer to the second part Treasury's website N answer to the second part of Treasury's website N answer to the second part of the Treasury's website N answer to the second part of the question, Treasury's website N answer to the second part of the question, that second part of the question, that information second part of the question, that information does second part of the question, that information does not second part of the question, that information does not give second part of the question, that information does not give a second part of the question, that information does not give a per-day information does not give a per-day cost information does not give a per-day cost or information does not give a per-day cost or benefit, information does not give a per-day cost or benefit, which information does not give a per-day cost or benefit, which is cost or benefit, which is understandable cost or benefit, which is understandable given cost or benefit, which is understandable given the cost or benefit, which is understandable given the significant understandable given the significant uncertainties understandable given the significant uncertainties about understandable given the significant uncertainties about what understandable given the significant uncertainties about what the understandable given the significant uncertainties about what the scale uncertainties about what the scale of uncertainties about what the scale uncertainties uncertainties about what the scale of travel between uncertainties about what the scale of travel between the uncertainties about what the scale of travel between the two uncertainties about what the scale of travel between the two countries of travel between the two countries would of travel between the two countries would be of travel between the two countries would be in of travel between the two countries would be in the of travel between the two countries would be in the current of travel between the two countries would be in the current environment. would be in the current environment. Why would be in the current environment. Why is would be in the current environment. Why is his would be in the current environment. Why is his Government would be in the current environment. Why is his Government dragging would be in the current environment. Why is his Government dragging its Why is his Government dragging its heels Why is his Government dragging its heels on Why is his Government dragging its heels on the Why is his Government dragging its heels on the trans-Tasman Why is his Government dragging its heels on the trans-Tasman bubble Why is his Government dragging its heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at great heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at great cost heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at great cost to heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at great cost to the heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at great cost to the New heels on the trans-Tasman bubble at great cost to the New Zealand great cost to the New Zealand economy, great cost to the New Zealand economy, when great cost to the New Zealand economy, when public great cost to the New Zealand economy, when public health great cost to the New Zealand economy, when public health expert economy, when public health expert Michael economy, when public health expert Michael Baker economy, when public health expert Michael Baker has economy, when public health expert Michael Baker has said economy, when public health expert Michael Baker has said Australians Michael Baker has said Australians pose Michael Baker has said Australians pose incredibly Michael Baker has said Australians pose incredibly low Michael Baker has said Australians pose incredibly low COVID-19 Michael Baker has said Australians pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In answer pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In answer to pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In answer to the pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In answer to the first pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In answer to the first part pose incredibly low COVID-19 risk? In answer to the first part of In answer to the first part of the... In answer to the first part of the... Oh, In answer to the first part of the... Oh, sorry. In answer to the first part of the... Oh, sorry. Well, In answer to the first part of the... Oh, sorry. Well, I In answer to the first part of the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, In answer to the first part of the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the member the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the member answer the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the member answer it, the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the member answer it, but the... Oh, sorry. Well, I mean, I will let the member answer it, but I will let the member answer it, but I am will let the member answer it, but I am being will let the member answer it, but I am being quite will let the member answer it, but I am being quite generous, will let the member answer it, but I am being quite generous, because will let the member answer it, but I am being quite generous, because it am being quite generous, because it does am being quite generous, because it does not am being quite generous, because it does not relate am being quite generous, because it does not relate to am being quite generous, because it does not relate to the am being quite generous, because it does not relate to the primary does not relate to the primary question. does not relate to the primary question. With does not relate to the primary question. With respect does not relate to the primary question. With respect to does not relate to the primary question. With respect to the does not relate to the primary question. With respect to the first question. With respect to the first part question. With respect to the first part of question. With respect to the first part of the question. With respect to the first part of the question, question. With respect to the first part of the question, I question. With respect to the first part of the question, I completely part of the question, I completely disagree part of the question, I completely disagree with part of the question, I completely disagree with the part of the question, I completely disagree with the member's part of the question, I completely disagree with the member's premise. disagree with the member's premise. What disagree with the member's premise. What we're disagree with the member's premise. What we're doing disagree with the member's premise. What we're doing on disagree with the member's premise. What we're doing on this disagree with the member's premise. What we're doing on this side disagree with the member's premise. What we're doing on this side of disagree with the member's premise. What we're doing on this side of the What we're doing on this side of the House What we're doing on this side of the House is What we're doing on this side of the House is acting What we're doing on this side of the House is acting in What we're doing on this side of the House is acting in the What we're doing on this side of the House is acting in the interests What we're doing on this side of the House is acting in the interests of House is acting in the interests of New House is acting in the interests of New Zealanders House is acting in the interests of New Zealanders to House is acting in the interests of New Zealanders to make House is acting in the interests of New Zealanders to make sure House is acting in the interests of New Zealanders to make sure that New Zealanders to make sure that arrangements New Zealanders to make sure that arrangements we New Zealanders to make sure that arrangements we make New Zealanders to make sure that arrangements we make have New Zealanders to make sure that arrangements we make have the New Zealanders to make sure that arrangements we make have the proper arrangements we make have the proper protocols arrangements we make have the proper protocols and arrangements we make have the proper protocols and safeguards arrangements we make have the proper protocols and safeguards in arrangements we make have the proper protocols and safeguards in place. protocols and safeguards in place. How protocols and safeguards in place. How many protocols and safeguards in place. How many jobs protocols and safeguards in place. How many jobs would protocols and safeguards in place. How many jobs would be protocols and safeguards in place. How many jobs would be saved protocols and safeguards in place. How many jobs would be saved by How many jobs would be saved by opening How many jobs would be saved by opening the How many jobs would be saved by opening the trans-Tasman How many jobs would be saved by opening the trans-Tasman bubble opening the trans-Tasman bubble immediately opening the trans-Tasman bubble immediately in opening the trans-Tasman bubble immediately in places opening the trans-Tasman bubble immediately in places like opening the trans-Tasman bubble immediately in places like Rotorua, immediately in places like Rotorua, Taupo, immediately in places like Rotorua, Taupo, Queenstown immediately in places like Rotorua, Taupo, Queenstown and immediately in places like Rotorua, Taupo, Queenstown and the immediately in places like Rotorua, Taupo, Queenstown and the West Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In order Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In order to Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In order to be Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In order to be able Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In order to be able to Taupo, Queenstown and the West Coast? In order to be able to answer Coast? In order to be able to answer that Coast? In order to be able to answer that very, Coast? In order to be able to answer that very, very Coast? In order to be able to answer that very, very specific Coast? In order to be able to answer that very, very specific question, that very, very specific question, we that very, very specific question, we would that very, very specific question, we would need that very, very specific question, we would need to that very, very specific question, we would need to know that very, very specific question, we would need to know a that very, very specific question, we would need to know a lot that very, very specific question, we would need to know a lot about we would need to know a lot about the we would need to know a lot about the behaviour we would need to know a lot about the behaviour of we would need to know a lot about the behaviour of Australians. we would need to know a lot about the behaviour of Australians. And we would need to know a lot about the behaviour of Australians. And I the behaviour of Australians. And I would the behaviour of Australians. And I would note, the behaviour of Australians. And I would note, for the behaviour of Australians. And I would note, for the the behaviour of Australians. And I would note, for the member's would note, for the member's benefit, would note, for the member's benefit, I would note, for the member's benefit, I would would note, for the member's benefit, I would note would note, for the member's benefit, I would note for would note, for the member's benefit, I would note for the benefit, I would note for the member's benefit, I would note for the member's benefit benefit, I would note for the member's benefit that benefit, I would note for the member's benefit that for benefit, I would note for the member's benefit that for an member's benefit that for an Australian member's benefit that for an Australian to member's benefit that for an Australian to travel member's benefit that for an Australian to travel to member's benefit that for an Australian to travel to New member's benefit that for an Australian to travel to New Zealand Australian to travel to New Zealand right Australian to travel to New Zealand right now, Australian to travel to New Zealand right now, they Australian to travel to New Zealand right now, they require Australian to travel to New Zealand right now, they require an Australian to travel to New Zealand right now, they require an exit right now, they require an exit visa. right now, they require an exit visa. And right now, they require an exit visa. And so right now, they require an exit visa. And so what right now, they require an exit visa. And so what we right now, they require an exit visa. And so what we would right now, they require an exit visa. And so what we would have right now, they require an exit visa. And so what we would have to visa. And so what we would have to know visa. And so what we would have to know is visa. And so what we would have to know is just visa. And so what we would have to know is just how visa. And so what we would have to know is just how many visa. And so what we would have to know is just how many Australians know is just how many Australians will know is just how many Australians will be know is just how many Australians will be prepared know is just how many Australians will be prepared to know is just how many Australians will be prepared to go know is just how many Australians will be prepared to go through know is just how many Australians will be prepared to go through the will be prepared to go through the rigmarole will be prepared to go through the rigmarole of will be prepared to go through the rigmarole of that. will be prepared to go through the rigmarole of that. In will be prepared to go through the rigmarole of that. In return, will be prepared to go through the rigmarole of that. In return, in rigmarole of that. In return, in terms rigmarole of that. In return, in terms of rigmarole of that. In return, in terms of the rigmarole of that. In return, in terms of the net rigmarole of that. In return, in terms of the net benefit rigmarole of that. In return, in terms of the net benefit to rigmarole of that. In return, in terms of the net benefit to New terms of the net benefit to New Zealand, terms of the net benefit to New Zealand, how terms of the net benefit to New Zealand, how many terms of the net benefit to New Zealand, how many New terms of the net benefit to New Zealand, how many New Zealanders Zealand, how many New Zealanders would Zealand, how many New Zealanders would go Zealand, how many New Zealanders would go to Zealand, how many New Zealanders would go to Australia? Zealand, how many New Zealanders would go to Australia? These Zealand, how many New Zealanders would go to Australia? These are would go to Australia? These are matters would go to Australia? These are matters that would go to Australia? These are matters that are would go to Australia? These are matters that are very would go to Australia? These are matters that are very difficult would go to Australia? These are matters that are very difficult to matters that are very difficult to quantify. matters that are very difficult to quantify. Our matters that are very difficult to quantify. Our premise matters that are very difficult to quantify. Our premise is matters that are very difficult to quantify. Our premise is a quantify. Our premise is a principled quantify. Our premise is a principled one. quantify. Our premise is a principled one. That quantify. Our premise is a principled one. That we quantify. Our premise is a principled one. That we will quantify. Our premise is a principled one. That we will do quantify. Our premise is a principled one. That we will do this principled one. That we will do this in principled one. That we will do this in the principled one. That we will do this in the interests principled one. That we will do this in the interests of principled one. That we will do this in the interests of New principled one. That we will do this in the interests of New Zealanders in the interests of New Zealanders and in the interests of New Zealanders and making in the interests of New Zealanders and making sure in the interests of New Zealanders and making sure that in the interests of New Zealanders and making sure that we in the interests of New Zealanders and making sure that we have in the interests of New Zealanders and making sure that we have the and making sure that we have the right and making sure that we have the right safeguards and making sure that we have the right safeguards in and making sure that we have the right safeguards in place. right safeguards in place. What right safeguards in place. What is right safeguards in place. What is his right safeguards in place. What is his response right safeguards in place. What is his response to right safeguards in place. What is his response to businesses What is his response to businesses who What is his response to businesses who are What is his response to businesses who are desperate What is his response to businesses who are desperate for What is his response to businesses who are desperate for workers What is his response to businesses who are desperate for workers right who are desperate for workers right now who are desperate for workers right now and, who are desperate for workers right now and, according who are desperate for workers right now and, according for who are desperate for workers right now and, according for the who are desperate for workers right now and, according for the freeing now and, according for the freeing up now and, according for the freeing up of now and, according for the freeing up of the now and, according for the freeing up of the 40% now and, according for the freeing up of the 40% of now and, according for the freeing up of the 40% of MIQ now and, according for the freeing up of the 40% of MIQ spaces up of the 40% of MIQ spaces currently up of the 40% of MIQ spaces currently taken up of the 40% of MIQ spaces currently taken up up of the 40% of MIQ spaces currently taken up by up of the 40% of MIQ spaces currently taken up by people currently taken up by people arriving currently taken up by people arriving from currently taken up by people arriving from Australia? arriving from Australia? Well, arriving from Australia? Well, it's arriving from Australia? Well, it's about arriving from Australia? Well, it's about as arriving from Australia? Well, it's about as related arriving from Australia? Well, it's about as related as... Well, it's about as related as... I'll Well, it's about as related as... I'll let Well, it's about as related as... I'll let it Well, it's about as related as... I'll let it go. Well, it's about as related as... I'll let it go. The Well, it's about as related as... I'll let it go. The member Well, it's about as related as... I'll let it go. The member needs Well, it's about as related as... I'll let it go. The member needs to I'll let it go. The member needs to think I'll let it go. The member needs to think carefully I'll let it go. The member needs to think carefully through I'll let it go. The member needs to think carefully through what I'll let it go. The member needs to think carefully through what he's think carefully through what he's saying think carefully through what he's saying there. think carefully through what he's saying there. In think carefully through what he's saying there. In fact, think carefully through what he's saying there. In fact, if think carefully through what he's saying there. In fact, if he think carefully through what he's saying there. In fact, if he wants saying there. In fact, if he wants to saying there. In fact, if he wants to quote saying there. In fact, if he wants to quote Michael saying there. In fact, if he wants to quote Michael Baker saying there. In fact, if he wants to quote Michael Baker as saying there. In fact, if he wants to quote Michael Baker as he saying there. In fact, if he wants to quote Michael Baker as he did to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, he to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, he could to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, he could look to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, he could look at to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, he could look at one to quote Michael Baker as he did earlier, he could look at one of earlier, he could look at one of Michael earlier, he could look at one of Michael Baker's earlier, he could look at one of Michael Baker's statements earlier, he could look at one of Michael Baker's statements earlier Michael Baker's statements earlier today, Michael Baker's statements earlier today, which Michael Baker's statements earlier today, which is Michael Baker's statements earlier today, which is that Michael Baker's statements earlier today, which is that when Michael Baker's statements earlier today, which is that when those today, which is that when those spaces today, which is that when those spaces are today, which is that when those spaces are freed today, which is that when those spaces are freed up today, which is that when those spaces are freed up in today, which is that when those spaces are freed up in MIQ, today, which is that when those spaces are freed up in MIQ, when today, which is that when those spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do get spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do get ourselves spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do get ourselves to spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do get ourselves to a spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do get ourselves to a safe spaces are freed up in MIQ, when we do get ourselves to a safe travel do get ourselves to a safe travel zone, do get ourselves to a safe travel zone, we do get ourselves to a safe travel zone, we will do get ourselves to a safe travel zone, we will have do get ourselves to a safe travel zone, we will have higher-risk zone, we will have higher-risk travellers zone, we will have higher-risk travellers who zone, we will have higher-risk travellers who will zone, we will have higher-risk travellers who will be zone, we will have higher-risk travellers who will be in zone, we will have higher-risk travellers who will be in New travellers who will be in New Zealand travellers who will be in New Zealand at travellers who will be in New Zealand at that travellers who will be in New Zealand at that point. travellers who will be in New Zealand at that point. And travellers who will be in New Zealand at that point. And Mr travellers who will be in New Zealand at that point. And Mr Baker Zealand at that point. And Mr Baker is Zealand at that point. And Mr Baker is actually Zealand at that point. And Mr Baker is actually concerned Zealand at that point. And Mr Baker is actually concerned about Zealand at that point. And Mr Baker is actually concerned about the is actually concerned about the availability is actually concerned about the availability of is actually concerned about the availability of space is actually concerned about the availability of space at is actually concerned about the availability of space at that is actually concerned about the availability of space at that point. availability of space at that point. What availability of space at that point. What regions availability of space at that point. What regions are availability of space at that point. What regions are expected availability of space at that point. What regions are expected to availability of space at that point. What regions are expected to suffer What regions are expected to suffer the What regions are expected to suffer the highest What regions are expected to suffer the highest economic What regions are expected to suffer the highest economic cost What regions are expected to suffer the highest economic cost due What regions are expected to suffer the highest economic cost due to What regions are expected to suffer the highest economic cost due to the the highest economic cost due to the lack the highest economic cost due to the lack of the highest economic cost due to the lack of a the highest economic cost due to the lack of a trans-Tasman the highest economic cost due to the lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? the highest economic cost due to the lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware on lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware on this lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware on this side lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware on this side of lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware on this side of the lack of a trans-Tasman bubble? We're well aware on this side of the House well aware on this side of the House that well aware on this side of the House that there well aware on this side of the House that there are well aware on this side of the House that there are certain well aware on this side of the House that there are certain regions well aware on this side of the House that there are certain regions of that there are certain regions of New that there are certain regions of New Zealand that there are certain regions of New Zealand who that there are certain regions of New Zealand who have that there are certain regions of New Zealand who have been that there are certain regions of New Zealand who have been affected New Zealand who have been affected more New Zealand who have been affected more in New Zealand who have been affected more in terms New Zealand who have been affected more in terms of New Zealand who have been affected more in terms of the New Zealand who have been affected more in terms of the loss New Zealand who have been affected more in terms of the loss of more in terms of the loss of international more in terms of the loss of international tourism. more in terms of the loss of international tourism. And more in terms of the loss of international tourism. And the international tourism. And the member international tourism. And the member will international tourism. And the member will be international tourism. And the member will be well international tourism. And the member will be well aware international tourism. And the member will be well aware of international tourism. And the member will be well aware of which member will be well aware of which those member will be well aware of which those regions member will be well aware of which those regions are, member will be well aware of which those regions are, the member will be well aware of which those regions are, the likes member will be well aware of which those regions are, the likes of those regions are, the likes of Queenstown those regions are, the likes of Queenstown and those regions are, the likes of Queenstown and Westland those regions are, the likes of Queenstown and Westland and Queenstown and Westland and elsewhere. Queenstown and Westland and elsewhere. We Queenstown and Westland and elsewhere. We are Queenstown and Westland and elsewhere. We are working Queenstown and Westland and elsewhere. We are working actively elsewhere. We are working actively with elsewhere. We are working actively with those elsewhere. We are working actively with those regions elsewhere. We are working actively with those regions on elsewhere. We are working actively with those regions on plans elsewhere. We are working actively with those regions on plans to with those regions on plans to support with those regions on plans to support them, with those regions on plans to support them, on with those regions on plans to support them, on top with those regions on plans to support them, on top of with those regions on plans to support them, on top of the with those regions on plans to support them, on top of the $400 support them, on top of the $400 million support them, on top of the $400 million that support them, on top of the $400 million that has support them, on top of the $400 million that has gone support them, on top of the $400 million that has gone in support them, on top of the $400 million that has gone in to support them, on top of the $400 million that has gone in to support million that has gone in to support the million that has gone in to support the tourism million that has gone in to support the tourism sector, million that has gone in to support the tourism sector, the million that has gone in to support the tourism sector, the $1.8 million that has gone in to support the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion of the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion of wage the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion of wage subsidy the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion of wage subsidy funding the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion of wage subsidy funding that the tourism sector, the $1.8 billion of wage subsidy funding that went of wage subsidy funding that went into of wage subsidy funding that went into support of wage subsidy funding that went into support the of wage subsidy funding that went into support the tourism of wage subsidy funding that went into support the tourism sector. into support the tourism sector. Amounts into support the tourism sector. Amounts of into support the tourism sector. Amounts of money, into support the tourism sector. Amounts of money, I into support the tourism sector. Amounts of money, I might into support the tourism sector. Amounts of money, I might say, into support the tourism sector. Amounts of money, I might say, that Amounts of money, I might say, that are Amounts of money, I might say, that are significantly Amounts of money, I might say, that are significantly larger Amounts of money, I might say, that are significantly larger than Amounts of money, I might say, that are significantly larger than what Amounts of money, I might say, that are significantly larger than what I are significantly larger than what I heard are significantly larger than what I heard being are significantly larger than what I heard being offered are significantly larger than what I heard being offered by are significantly larger than what I heard being offered by the are significantly larger than what I heard being offered by the other heard being offered by the other side heard being offered by the other side of heard being offered by the other side of the heard being offered by the other side of the House heard being offered by the other side of the House during heard being offered by the other side of the House during the side of the House during the election. election. David election. David Seymour. election. David Seymour. Will election. David Seymour. Will the election. David Seymour. Will the higher-risk David Seymour. Will the higher-risk travellers David Seymour. Will the higher-risk travellers the David Seymour. Will the higher-risk travellers the Minister David Seymour. Will the higher-risk travellers the Minister just travellers the Minister just referred travellers the Minister just referred to travellers the Minister just referred to including travellers the Minister just referred to including Nala travellers the Minister just referred to including Nala and referred to including Nala and Simba? referred to including Nala and Simba? I'm referred to including Nala and Simba? I'm pleased referred to including Nala and Simba? I'm pleased that referred to including Nala and Simba? I'm pleased that the referred to including Nala and Simba? I'm pleased that the member Simba? I'm pleased that the member has Simba? I'm pleased that the member has spent Simba? I'm pleased that the member has spent his Simba? I'm pleased that the member has spent his time Simba? I'm pleased that the member has spent his time learning Simba? I'm pleased that the member has spent his time learning the has spent his time learning the names has spent his time learning the names of has spent his time learning the names of the has spent his time learning the names of the characters has spent his time learning the names of the characters of has spent his time learning the names of the characters of The has spent his time learning the names of the characters of The Lion names of the characters of The Lion King. names of the characters of The Lion King. What names of the characters of The Lion King. What I names of the characters of The Lion King. What I would names of the characters of The Lion King. What I would say names of the characters of The Lion King. What I would say to names of the characters of The Lion King. What I would say to the names of the characters of The Lion King. What I would say to the member King. What I would say to the member is King. What I would say to the member is that King. What I would say to the member is that throughout King. What I would say to the member is that throughout the King. What I would say to the member is that throughout the period King. What I would say to the member is that throughout the period of is that throughout the period of COVID-19 is that throughout the period of COVID-19 we is that throughout the period of COVID-19 we have is that throughout the period of COVID-19 we have prioritised is that throughout the period of COVID-19 we have prioritised the COVID-19 we have prioritised the return COVID-19 we have prioritised the return of COVID-19 we have prioritised the return of New COVID-19 we have prioritised the return of New Zealanders COVID-19 we have prioritised the return of New Zealanders to COVID-19 we have prioritised the return of New Zealanders to their return of New Zealanders to their home return of New Zealanders to their home country. return of New Zealanders to their home country. Where return of New Zealanders to their home country. Where possible return of New Zealanders to their home country. Where possible we return of New Zealanders to their home country. Where possible we have home country. Where possible we have made home country. Where possible we have made available home country. Where possible we have made available spaces home country. Where possible we have made available spaces for home country. Where possible we have made available spaces for those home country. Where possible we have made available spaces for those who made available spaces for those who are made available spaces for those who are playing made available spaces for those who are playing significant made available spaces for those who are playing significant roles made available spaces for those who are playing significant roles in made available spaces for those who are playing significant roles in the are playing significant roles in the economy, are playing significant roles in the economy, and are playing significant roles in the economy, and we are playing significant roles in the economy, and we have are playing significant roles in the economy, and we have made are playing significant roles in the economy, and we have made space are playing significant roles in the economy, and we have made space for economy, and we have made space for cultural economy, and we have made space for cultural and economy, and we have made space for cultural and sporting economy, and we have made space for cultural and sporting events, cultural and sporting events, because cultural and sporting events, because that cultural and sporting events, because that is cultural and sporting events, because that is part cultural and sporting events, because that is part of cultural and sporting events, because that is part of making cultural and sporting events, because that is part of making sure because that is part of making sure that because that is part of making sure that New because that is part of making sure that New Zealanders because that is part of making sure that New Zealanders have because that is part of making sure that New Zealanders have actually that New Zealanders have actually been that New Zealanders have actually been able that New Zealanders have actually been able to that New Zealanders have actually been able to enjoy that New Zealanders have actually been able to enjoy some that New Zealanders have actually been able to enjoy some time that New Zealanders have actually been able to enjoy some time over been able to enjoy some time over the been able to enjoy some time over the last been able to enjoy some time over the last few been able to enjoy some time over the last few months. the last few months. The the last few months. The Hon the last few months. The Hon Chris the last few months. The Hon Chris Hipkins. the last few months. The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the last few months. The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the tourism The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the tourism regions The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the tourism regions of The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the tourism regions of New The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the tourism regions of New Zealand The Hon Chris Hipkins. Could the tourism regions of New Zealand end tourism regions of New Zealand end up tourism regions of New Zealand end up worse tourism regions of New Zealand end up worse off tourism regions of New Zealand end up worse off if tourism regions of New Zealand end up worse off if restrictions up worse off if restrictions preventing up worse off if restrictions preventing New up worse off if restrictions preventing New Zealanders up worse off if restrictions preventing New Zealanders travelling preventing New Zealanders travelling to preventing New Zealanders travelling to Australia preventing New Zealanders travelling to Australia are preventing New Zealanders travelling to Australia are removed preventing New Zealanders travelling to Australia are removed whilst to Australia are removed whilst Australia to Australia are removed whilst Australia continues to Australia are removed whilst Australia continues to to Australia are removed whilst Australia continues to maintain to Australia are removed whilst Australia continues to maintain the Australia continues to maintain the requirement Australia continues to maintain the requirement for Australia continues to maintain the requirement for Australians requirement for Australians travelling requirement for Australians travelling to requirement for Australians travelling to New requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand to requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand to have travelling to New Zealand to have exit travelling to New Zealand to have exit visas? travelling to New Zealand to have exit visas? Well, travelling to New Zealand to have exit visas? Well, that's travelling to New Zealand to have exit visas? Well, that's absolutely exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good point, exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good point, and exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good point, and comes exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good point, and comes back exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good point, and comes back to exit visas? Well, that's absolutely a good point, and comes back to my a good point, and comes back to my primary a good point, and comes back to my primary answer a good point, and comes back to my primary answer to a good point, and comes back to my primary answer to the a good point, and comes back to my primary answer to the member, a good point, and comes back to my primary answer to the member, is primary answer to the member, is this primary answer to the member, is this a primary answer to the member, is this a two-way primary answer to the member, is this a two-way street. primary answer to the member, is this a two-way street. And primary answer to the member, is this a two-way street. And if this a two-way street. And if Australians this a two-way street. And if Australians still this a two-way street. And if Australians still require this a two-way street. And if Australians still require an this a two-way street. And if Australians still require an exit Australians still require an exit visa, Australians still require an exit visa, we Australians still require an exit visa, we could Australians still require an exit visa, we could end Australians still require an exit visa, we could end up Australians still require an exit visa, we could end up with Australians still require an exit visa, we could end up with a Australians still require an exit visa, we could end up with a net visa, we could end up with a net loss visa, we could end up with a net loss to visa, we could end up with a net loss to New visa, we could end up with a net loss to New Zealand. loss to New Zealand. Question loss to New Zealand. Question No. loss to New Zealand. Question No. 5, loss to New Zealand. Question No. 5, Terisa loss to New Zealand. Question No. 5, Terisa Ngobi. Question No. 5, Terisa Ngobi. Kia Question No. 5, Terisa Ngobi. Kia ora. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Social My question is to the Minister for Social Development for Social Development and for Social Development and Employment: and Employment: What and Employment: What announcements and Employment: What announcements has and Employment: What announcements has she and Employment: What announcements has she made What announcements has she made about What announcements has she made about the What announcements has she made about the social What announcements has she made about the social work What announcements has she made about the social work profession? The The Hon The Hon Carmel The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on World The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on World Social The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on World Social Work The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on World Social Work Day, The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on World Social Work Day, I The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. Today, on World Social Work Day, I announced World Social Work Day, I announced that World Social Work Day, I announced that New World Social Work Day, I announced that New Zealand World Social Work Day, I announced that New Zealand has World Social Work Day, I announced that New Zealand has now World Social Work Day, I announced that New Zealand has now reached World Social Work Day, I announced that New Zealand has now reached a that New Zealand has now reached a milestone that New Zealand has now reached a milestone of that New Zealand has now reached a milestone of 10,300 that New Zealand has now reached a milestone of 10,300 registered milestone of 10,300 registered social milestone of 10,300 registered social workers milestone of 10,300 registered social workers - milestone of 10,300 registered social workers - an milestone of 10,300 registered social workers - an increase milestone of 10,300 registered social workers - an increase of social workers - an increase of 3,600 social workers - an increase of 3,600 over social workers - an increase of 3,600 over the social workers - an increase of 3,600 over the last social workers - an increase of 3,600 over the last four social workers - an increase of 3,600 over the last four years. social workers - an increase of 3,600 over the last four years. This 3,600 over the last four years. This milestone 3,600 over the last four years. This milestone follows 3,600 over the last four years. This milestone follows the 3,600 over the last four years. This milestone follows the introduction milestone follows the introduction on milestone follows the introduction on 27 milestone follows the introduction on 27 February, milestone follows the introduction on 27 February, 2019 milestone follows the introduction on 27 February, 2019 of milestone follows the introduction on 27 February, 2019 of mandatory on 27 February, 2019 of mandatory registration on 27 February, 2019 of mandatory registration legislation on 27 February, 2019 of mandatory registration legislation - on 27 February, 2019 of mandatory registration legislation - a on 27 February, 2019 of mandatory registration legislation - a measure registration legislation - a measure that registration legislation - a measure that has registration legislation - a measure that has been registration legislation - a measure that has been long registration legislation - a measure that has been long sought registration legislation - a measure that has been long sought by registration legislation - a measure that has been long sought by the that has been long sought by the sector. that has been long sought by the sector. Today that has been long sought by the sector. Today we that has been long sought by the sector. Today we celebrate that has been long sought by the sector. Today we celebrate the sector. Today we celebrate the progress sector. Today we celebrate the progress that sector. Today we celebrate the progress that has sector. Today we celebrate the progress that has been sector. Today we celebrate the progress that has been maded sector. Today we celebrate the progress that has been maded in progress that has been maded in futureproofing progress that has been maded in futureproofing the progress that has been maded in futureproofing the profession, progress that has been maded in futureproofing the profession, as futureproofing the profession, as well futureproofing the profession, as well as futureproofing the profession, as well as acknowledging futureproofing the profession, as well as acknowledging the futureproofing the profession, as well as acknowledging the 10,300 well as acknowledging the 10,300 registered well as acknowledging the 10,300 registered social well as acknowledging the 10,300 registered social workers well as acknowledging the 10,300 registered social workers who registered social workers who continue registered social workers who continue to registered social workers who continue to serve registered social workers who continue to serve on registered social workers who continue to serve on the registered social workers who continue to serve on the front registered social workers who continue to serve on the front line, continue to serve on the front line, supporting continue to serve on the front line, supporting some continue to serve on the front line, supporting some of continue to serve on the front line, supporting some of New continue to serve on the front line, supporting some of New Zealand's supporting some of New Zealand's most supporting some of New Zealand's most vulnerable supporting some of New Zealand's most vulnerable tamariki, supporting some of New Zealand's most vulnerable tamariki, whanau supporting some of New Zealand's most vulnerable tamariki, whanau and most vulnerable tamariki, whanau and communities. most vulnerable tamariki, whanau and communities. Why most vulnerable tamariki, whanau and communities. Why is most vulnerable tamariki, whanau and communities. Why is mandatory communities. Why is mandatory registration communities. Why is mandatory registration important communities. Why is mandatory registration important for communities. Why is mandatory registration important for social registration important for social work registration important for social work profession? registration important for social work profession? Our registration important for social work profession? Our social registration important for social work profession? Our social workers work profession? Our social workers are work profession? Our social workers are at work profession? Our social workers are at the work profession? Our social workers are at the front work profession? Our social workers are at the front line, work profession? Our social workers are at the front line, providing are at the front line, providing assistance are at the front line, providing assistance to are at the front line, providing assistance to those are at the front line, providing assistance to those who are at the front line, providing assistance to those who most are at the front line, providing assistance to those who most need assistance to those who most need it. assistance to those who most need it. Mandatory assistance to those who most need it. Mandatory registration assistance to those who most need it. Mandatory registration is assistance to those who most need it. Mandatory registration is a assistance to those who most need it. Mandatory registration is a step it. Mandatory registration is a step forward, it. Mandatory registration is a step forward, recognising it. Mandatory registration is a step forward, recognising the forward, recognising the professional forward, recognising the professional nature forward, recognising the professional nature of forward, recognising the professional nature of the professional nature of the workforce. professional nature of the workforce. It professional nature of the workforce. It offers professional nature of the workforce. It offers reassurance professional nature of the workforce. It offers reassurance to workforce. It offers reassurance to the workforce. It offers reassurance to the public workforce. It offers reassurance to the public that workforce. It offers reassurance to the public that social workforce. It offers reassurance to the public that social workers workforce. It offers reassurance to the public that social workers are the public that social workers are qualified, the public that social workers are qualified, adhere the public that social workers are qualified, adhere to the public that social workers are qualified, adhere to a the public that social workers are qualified, adhere to a code the public that social workers are qualified, adhere to a code of qualified, adhere to a code of ethics, qualified, adhere to a code of ethics, are qualified, adhere to a code of ethics, are annually qualified, adhere to a code of ethics, are annually updating qualified, adhere to a code of ethics, are annually updating their ethics, are annually updating their ethics, ethics, are annually updating their practising certificate, and practising certificate, and continually practising certificate, and continually engaged practising certificate, and continually engaged in practising certificate, and continually engaged in professional continually engaged in professional development. continually engaged in professional development. This continually engaged in professional development. This gives continually engaged in professional development. This gives New development. This gives New Zealanders development. This gives New Zealanders confidence development. This gives New Zealanders confidence in development. This gives New Zealanders confidence in the development. This gives New Zealanders confidence in the care, Zealanders confidence in the care, advice Zealanders confidence in the care, advice and Zealanders confidence in the care, advice and support Zealanders confidence in the care, advice and support they Zealanders confidence in the care, advice and support they need Zealanders confidence in the care, advice and support they need from advice and support they need from the advice and support they need from the social advice and support they need from the social work advice and support they need from the social work profession. the social work profession. What the social work profession. What actions the social work profession. What actions has the social work profession. What actions has the the social work profession. What actions has the Government What actions has the Government taken What actions has the Government taken to What actions has the Government taken to support What actions has the Government taken to support and What actions has the Government taken to support and increase taken to support and increase mandatory taken to support and increase mandatory registration taken to support and increase mandatory registration in taken to support and increase mandatory registration in the mandatory registration in the profession? mandatory registration in the profession? The mandatory registration in the profession? The Government mandatory registration in the profession? The Government invested profession? The Government invested just profession? The Government invested just over profession? The Government invested just over $2 profession? The Government invested just over $2 million profession? The Government invested just over $2 million in profession? The Government invested just over $2 million in Budget profession? The Government invested just over $2 million in Budget 2019 just over $2 million in Budget 2019 to just over $2 million in Budget 2019 to support just over $2 million in Budget 2019 to support the just over $2 million in Budget 2019 to support the social just over $2 million in Budget 2019 to support the social workers' to support the social workers' registration to support the social workers' registration board's to support the social workers' registration board's implementation registration board's implementation of registration board's implementation of mandatory registration board's implementation of mandatory registration registration board's implementation of mandatory registration over registration board's implementation of mandatory registration over two of mandatory registration over two years of mandatory registration over two years N of mandatory registration over two years N another of mandatory registration over two years N another step of mandatory registration over two years N another step forward, of mandatory registration over two years N another step forward, I've years N another step forward, I've asked years N another step forward, I've asked the years N another step forward, I've asked the Social years N another step forward, I've asked the Social Workers' asked the Social Workers' Registration asked the Social Workers' Registration Board asked the Social Workers' Registration Board to asked the Social Workers' Registration Board to act asked the Social Workers' Registration Board to act as asked the Social Workers' Registration Board to act as the Registration Board to act as the lead Registration Board to act as the lead agency Registration Board to act as the lead agency on Registration Board to act as the lead agency on workforce Registration Board to act as the lead agency on workforce planning. lead agency on workforce planning. They lead agency on workforce planning. They are lead agency on workforce planning. They are looking lead agency on workforce planning. They are looking at lead agency on workforce planning. They are looking at scope lead agency on workforce planning. They are looking at scope of They are looking at scope of practice, They are looking at scope of practice, which They are looking at scope of practice, which will They are looking at scope of practice, which will provide They are looking at scope of practice, which will provide a practice, which will provide a higher practice, which will provide a higher level practice, which will provide a higher level of practice, which will provide a higher level of description practice, which will provide a higher level of description of higher level of description of social higher level of description of social work higher level of description of social work practice. higher level of description of social work practice. These higher level of description of social work practice. These measures social work practice. These measures aim social work practice. These measures aim to social work practice. These measures aim to encourage social work practice. These measures aim to encourage more social work practice. These measures aim to encourage more social social work practice. These measures aim to encourage more social workers aim to encourage more social workers into aim to encourage more social workers into the aim to encourage more social workers into the profession aim to encourage more social workers into the profession and aim to encourage more social workers into the profession and underlines into the profession and underlines the into the profession and underlines into into the profession and underlines the Government's plan into the profession and underlines the Government's plan to into the profession and underlines the Government's plan to support the Government's plan to support healthier, the Government's plan to support healthier, safer the Government's plan to support healthier, safer and the Government's plan to support healthier, safer and more the Government's plan to support healthier, safer and more connected healthier, safer and more connected communities. healthier, safer and more connected communities. Question healthier, safer and more connected communities. Question No. healthier, safer and more connected communities. Question No. 6. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: Minister: Does Minister: Does she Minister: Does she stand Minister: Does she stand by Minister: Does she stand by all Minister: Does she stand by all her Does she stand by all her Government's Does she stand by all her Government's statements Does she stand by all her Government's statements and Does she stand by all her Government's statements and actions Government's statements and actions in Government's statements and actions in relation Government's statements and actions in relation to Government's statements and actions in relation to the Government's statements and actions in relation to the land Government's statements and actions in relation to the land at Government's statements and actions in relation to the land at Ihumatao? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the PM, On behalf of the PM, yes, On behalf of the PM, yes, in On behalf of the PM, yes, in the On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context in On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context in which On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context in which they On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context in which they were On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context in which they were made On behalf of the PM, yes, in the context in which they were made and context in which they were made and undertaken. context in which they were made and undertaken. Does context in which they were made and undertaken. Does she context in which they were made and undertaken. Does she stand context in which they were made and undertaken. Does she stand by context in which they were made and undertaken. Does she stand by the undertaken. Does she stand by the statement undertaken. Does she stand by the statement of undertaken. Does she stand by the statement of Grant undertaken. Does she stand by the statement of Grant Robertson undertaken. Does she stand by the statement of Grant Robertson on undertaken. Does she stand by the statement of Grant Robertson on 17 statement of Grant Robertson on 17 December statement of Grant Robertson on 17 December about statement of Grant Robertson on 17 December about the statement of Grant Robertson on 17 December about the Ihumatao statement of Grant Robertson on 17 December about the Ihumatao deal, December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's be December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's be very December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's be very clear. December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's be very clear. This December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's be very clear. This is December about the Ihumatao deal, "Let's be very clear. This is not "Let's be very clear. This is not part "Let's be very clear. This is not part of "Let's be very clear. This is not part of the "Let's be very clear. This is not part of the treaty "Let's be very clear. This is not part of the treaty settlement part of the treaty settlement process"? part of the treaty settlement process"? On part of the treaty settlement process"? On behalf part of the treaty settlement process"? On behalf of part of the treaty settlement process"? On behalf of the part of the treaty settlement process"? On behalf of the PM, part of the treaty settlement process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. Did process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. Did the process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. Did the Ministry process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. Did the Ministry of process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. Did the Ministry of Housing process"? On behalf of the PM, yes. Did the Ministry of Housing and Did the Ministry of Housing and Urban Did the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, Did the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, the Did the Ministry of Housing and Urban Development, the Government Urban Development, the Government agency Urban Development, the Government agency that Urban Development, the Government agency that paid Urban Development, the Government agency that paid Fletcher Urban Development, the Government agency that paid Fletcher Building agency that paid Fletcher Building $29.9 agency that paid Fletcher Building $29.9 million agency that paid Fletcher Building $29.9 million for agency that paid Fletcher Building $29.9 million for the agency that paid Fletcher Building $29.9 million for the land, agency that paid Fletcher Building $29.9 million for the land, ever $29.9 million for the land, ever advise $29.9 million for the land, ever advise that $29.9 million for the land, ever advise that the $29.9 million for the land, ever advise that the payment $29.9 million for the land, ever advise that the payment might $29.9 million for the land, ever advise that the payment might be advise that the payment might be part advise that the payment might be part of advise that the payment might be part of a advise that the payment might be part of a treaty advise that the payment might be part of a treaty settlement advise that the payment might be part of a treaty settlement process? part of a treaty settlement process? On part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the PM, part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the PM, on part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the PM, on a part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the PM, on a very On behalf of the PM, on a very specific On behalf of the PM, on a very specific question On behalf of the PM, on a very specific question like On behalf of the PM, on a very specific question like that, On behalf of the PM, on a very specific question like that, the specific question like that, the member specific question like that, the member will specific question like that, the member will understand specific question like that, the member will understand I specific question like that, the member will understand I would specific question like that, the member will understand I would need member will understand I would need to member will understand I would need to be member will understand I would need to be able member will understand I would need to be able to member will understand I would need to be able to go member will understand I would need to be able to go back member will understand I would need to be able to go back and member will understand I would need to be able to go back and check. member will understand I would need to be able to go back and check. My to be able to go back and check. My recollection to be able to go back and check. My recollection is to be able to go back and check. My recollection is that to be able to go back and check. My recollection is that there to be able to go back and check. My recollection is that there was to be able to go back and check. My recollection is that there was a recollection is that there was a range recollection is that there was a range of recollection is that there was a range of views recollection is that there was a range of views discussed recollection is that there was a range of views discussed throughout range of views discussed throughout a range of views discussed throughout a period range of views discussed throughout a period of range of views discussed throughout a period of well range of views discussed throughout a period of well over range of views discussed throughout a period of well over a range of views discussed throughout a period of well over a year range of views discussed throughout a period of well over a year about a period of well over a year about how a period of well over a year about how a a period of well over a year about how a settlement a period of well over a year about how a settlement could a period of well over a year about how a settlement could be a period of well over a year about how a settlement could be reached a period of well over a year about how a settlement could be reached at how a settlement could be reached at Ihumatao how a settlement could be reached at Ihumatao that how a settlement could be reached at Ihumatao that would how a settlement could be reached at Ihumatao that would not how a settlement could be reached at Ihumatao that would not breach how a settlement could be reached at Ihumatao that would not breach the Ihumatao that would not breach the treaty Ihumatao that would not breach the treaty settlement Ihumatao that would not breach the treaty settlement process, Ihumatao that would not breach the treaty settlement process, and Ihumatao that would not breach the treaty settlement process, and the treaty settlement process, and the Government treaty settlement process, and the Government was treaty settlement process, and the Government was very treaty settlement process, and the Government was very confident treaty settlement process, and the Government was very confident that Government was very confident that we Government was very confident that we have Government was very confident that we have reached Government was very confident that we have reached that Government was very confident that we have reached that settlement. we have reached that settlement. Could we have reached that settlement. Could the we have reached that settlement. Could the redacted we have reached that settlement. Could the redacted parts we have reached that settlement. Could the redacted parts of we have reached that settlement. Could the redacted parts of this Could the redacted parts of this Cabinet Could the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper Could the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper refer Could the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper refer to Could the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper refer to the Could the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper refer to the deal Cabinet paper refer to the deal being Cabinet paper refer to the deal being part Cabinet paper refer to the deal being part of Cabinet paper refer to the deal being part of a Cabinet paper refer to the deal being part of a treaty Cabinet paper refer to the deal being part of a treaty settlement being part of a treaty settlement process? being part of a treaty settlement process? On being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the PM, being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I've process? On behalf of the PM, I've recently process? On behalf of the PM, I've recently got process? On behalf of the PM, I've recently got new process? On behalf of the PM, I've recently got new glasses, process? On behalf of the PM, I've recently got new glasses, but process? On behalf of the PM, I've recently got new glasses, but I recently got new glasses, but I can't recently got new glasses, but I can't quite recently got new glasses, but I can't quite read recently got new glasses, but I can't quite read that recently got new glasses, but I can't quite read that Cabinet recently got new glasses, but I can't quite read that Cabinet paper can't quite read that Cabinet paper from can't quite read that Cabinet paper from here. can't quite read that Cabinet paper from here. Order! can't quite read that Cabinet paper from here. Order! I'm can't quite read that Cabinet paper from here. Order! I'm actually can't quite read that Cabinet paper from here. Order! I'm actually going from here. Order! I'm actually going to from here. Order! I'm actually going to ask from here. Order! I'm actually going to ask David from here. Order! I'm actually going to ask David Seymour from here. Order! I'm actually going to ask David Seymour to from here. Order! I'm actually going to ask David Seymour to ask from here. Order! I'm actually going to ask David Seymour to ask the to ask David Seymour to ask the question to ask David Seymour to ask the question again, to ask David Seymour to ask the question again, and to ask David Seymour to ask the question again, and I'm to ask David Seymour to ask the question again, and I'm going to ask David Seymour to ask the question again, and I'm going to to ask David Seymour to ask the question again, and I'm going to ask question again, and I'm going to ask the question again, and I'm going to ask the PM question again, and I'm going to ask the PM to question again, and I'm going to ask the PM to answer question again, and I'm going to ask the PM to answer it. question again, and I'm going to ask the PM to answer it. Could question again, and I'm going to ask the PM to answer it. Could the the PM to answer it. Could the redacted the PM to answer it. Could the redacted part the PM to answer it. Could the redacted part of the PM to answer it. Could the redacted part of this the PM to answer it. Could the redacted part of this Cabinet the PM to answer it. Could the redacted part of this Cabinet paper redacted part of this Cabinet paper possibly redacted part of this Cabinet paper possibly refer redacted part of this Cabinet paper possibly refer to redacted part of this Cabinet paper possibly refer to the redacted part of this Cabinet paper possibly refer to the deal redacted part of this Cabinet paper possibly refer to the deal at possibly refer to the deal at Ihumatao possibly refer to the deal at Ihumatao being possibly refer to the deal at Ihumatao being part possibly refer to the deal at Ihumatao being part of possibly refer to the deal at Ihumatao being part of a possibly refer to the deal at Ihumatao being part of a treaty Ihumatao being part of a treaty settlement Ihumatao being part of a treaty settlement process? Ihumatao being part of a treaty settlement process? On Ihumatao being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf Ihumatao being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of Ihumatao being part of a treaty settlement process? On behalf of the settlement process? On behalf of the PM, settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I would settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I would need settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I would need to settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I would need to see settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I would need to see that settlement process? On behalf of the PM, I would need to see that Cabinet PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. What PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. What I PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. What I do PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. What I do know PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. What I do know is PM, I would need to see that Cabinet paper. What I do know is the paper. What I do know is the Government paper. What I do know is the Government is paper. What I do know is the Government is confident paper. What I do know is the Government is confident that paper. What I do know is the Government is confident that we paper. What I do know is the Government is confident that we have Government is confident that we have reached Government is confident that we have reached an Government is confident that we have reached an arrangement Government is confident that we have reached an arrangement at Government is confident that we have reached an arrangement at Ihumatao reached an arrangement at Ihumatao that reached an arrangement at Ihumatao that upholds reached an arrangement at Ihumatao that upholds and reached an arrangement at Ihumatao that upholds and protects reached an arrangement at Ihumatao that upholds and protects the reached an arrangement at Ihumatao that upholds and protects the treaty that upholds and protects the treaty settlement that upholds and protects the treaty settlement process. that upholds and protects the treaty settlement process. Nicola that upholds and protects the treaty settlement process. Nicola Willis. settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why are settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why are we settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why are we in settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why are we in a settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why are we in a situation settlement process. Nicola Willis. Why are we in a situation where Why are we in a situation where KiwiBuild Why are we in a situation where KiwiBuild money, Why are we in a situation where KiwiBuild money, meant Why are we in a situation where KiwiBuild money, meant to Why are we in a situation where KiwiBuild money, meant to be Why are we in a situation where KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent on KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent on building KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent on building houses, KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent on building houses, has KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent on building houses, has been KiwiBuild money, meant to be spent on building houses, has been spent on building houses, has been spent instead on building houses, has been spent instead on on building houses, has been spent instead on stopping on building houses, has been spent instead on stopping houses on building houses, has been spent instead on stopping houses being instead on stopping houses being built? instead on stopping houses being built? On instead on stopping houses being built? On behalf instead on stopping houses being built? On behalf of instead on stopping houses being built? On behalf of the instead on stopping houses being built? On behalf of the PM, instead on stopping houses being built? On behalf of the PM, we instead on stopping houses being built? On behalf of the PM, we are built? On behalf of the PM, we are not. built? On behalf of the PM, we are not. Why, built? On behalf of the PM, we are not. Why, then, built? On behalf of the PM, we are not. Why, then, does built? On behalf of the PM, we are not. Why, then, does the built? On behalf of the PM, we are not. Why, then, does the redacted not. Why, then, does the redacted parts not. Why, then, does the redacted parts of not. Why, then, does the redacted parts of this not. Why, then, does the redacted parts of this Cabinet not. Why, then, does the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper, not. Why, then, does the redacted parts of this Cabinet paper, when parts of this Cabinet paper, when cut-and-paste parts of this Cabinet paper, when cut-and-paste out parts of this Cabinet paper, when cut-and-paste out of parts of this Cabinet paper, when cut-and-paste out of the parts of this Cabinet paper, when cut-and-paste out of the PDF parts of this Cabinet paper, when cut-and-paste out of the PDF and cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into Word, cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into Word, say, cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into Word, say, "Crown cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into Word, say, "Crown law cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into Word, say, "Crown law and cut-and-paste out of the PDF and into Word, say, "Crown law and Te into Word, say, "Crown law and Te Aro into Word, say, "Crown law and Te Aro Phiti, into Word, say, "Crown law and Te Aro Phiti, have into Word, say, "Crown law and Te Aro Phiti, have been into Word, say, "Crown law and Te Aro Phiti, have been working into Word, say, "Crown law and Te Aro Phiti, have been working through Aro Phiti, have been working through - Aro Phiti, have been working through - due Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to the Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to the fact Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to the fact the Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to the fact the land Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to the fact the land has Aro Phiti, have been working through - due to the fact the land has been - due to the fact the land has been purchased - due to the fact the land has been purchased by - due to the fact the land has been purchased by an - due to the fact the land has been purchased by an agency - due to the fact the land has been purchased by an agency whose - due to the fact the land has been purchased by an agency whose land - due to the fact the land has been purchased by an agency whose land is purchased by an agency whose land is not purchased by an agency whose land is not available purchased by an agency whose land is not available for purchased by an agency whose land is not available for treaty purchased by an agency whose land is not available for treaty purposes, not available for treaty purposes, for not available for treaty purposes, for a not available for treaty purposes, for a specific not available for treaty purposes, for a specific purpose" not available for treaty purposes, for a specific purpose" EG, not available for treaty purposes, for a specific purpose" EG, housing, for a specific purpose" EG, housing, right for a specific purpose" EG, housing, right there. for a specific purpose" EG, housing, right there. If for a specific purpose" EG, housing, right there. If the for a specific purpose" EG, housing, right there. If the member for a specific purpose" EG, housing, right there. If the member considers right there. If the member considers what right there. If the member considers what he right there. If the member considers what he just right there. If the member considers what he just said, right there. If the member considers what he just said, he right there. If the member considers what he just said, he said right there. If the member considers what he just said, he said these what he just said, he said these issues what he just said, he said these issues were what he just said, he said these issues were being what he just said, he said these issues were being worked what he just said, he said these issues were being worked through, issues were being worked through, which issues were being worked through, which is issues were being worked through, which is exactly issues were being worked through, which is exactly what issues were being worked through, which is exactly what I issues were being worked through, which is exactly what I said issues were being worked through, which is exactly what I said in issues were being worked through, which is exactly what I said in a which is exactly what I said in a previous which is exactly what I said in a previous answer which is exactly what I said in a previous answer to which is exactly what I said in a previous answer to this which is exactly what I said in a previous answer to this question. which is exactly what I said in a previous answer to this question. We previous answer to this question. We worked previous answer to this question. We worked through previous answer to this question. We worked through a previous answer to this question. We worked through a process previous answer to this question. We worked through a process with previous answer to this question. We worked through a process with a worked through a process with a range worked through a process with a range of worked through a process with a range of agencies worked through a process with a range of agencies to worked through a process with a range of agencies to ensure worked through a process with a range of agencies to ensure that worked through a process with a range of agencies to ensure that we range of agencies to ensure that we had range of agencies to ensure that we had a range of agencies to ensure that we had a resolution range of agencies to ensure that we had a resolution in range of agencies to ensure that we had a resolution in Ihumatao range of agencies to ensure that we had a resolution in Ihumatao that had a resolution in Ihumatao that upholds had a resolution in Ihumatao that upholds the had a resolution in Ihumatao that upholds the treaty had a resolution in Ihumatao that upholds the treaty settlement upholds the treaty settlement process, upholds the treaty settlement process, and upholds the treaty settlement process, and we upholds the treaty settlement process, and we achieved upholds the treaty settlement process, and we achieved that. upholds the treaty settlement process, and we achieved that. Did process, and we achieved that. Did the process, and we achieved that. Did the Government process, and we achieved that. Did the Government receive process, and we achieved that. Did the Government receive advice process, and we achieved that. Did the Government receive advice saying the Government receive advice saying that the Government receive advice saying that the the Government receive advice saying that the deal, the Government receive advice saying that the deal, as the Government receive advice saying that the deal, as conceived, the Government receive advice saying that the deal, as conceived, would that the deal, as conceived, would be that the deal, as conceived, would be part that the deal, as conceived, would be part of that the deal, as conceived, would be part of a that the deal, as conceived, would be part of a treaty that the deal, as conceived, would be part of a treaty settlement be part of a treaty settlement process be part of a treaty settlement process or be part of a treaty settlement process or not? be part of a treaty settlement process or not? As be part of a treaty settlement process or not? As I've be part of a treaty settlement process or not? As I've already process or not? As I've already answered process or not? As I've already answered in process or not? As I've already answered in the process or not? As I've already answered in the previous process or not? As I've already answered in the previous questions, answered in the previous questions, we answered in the previous questions, we worked answered in the previous questions, we worked through answered in the previous questions, we worked through whether answered in the previous questions, we worked through whether or answered in the previous questions, we worked through whether or not answered in the previous questions, we worked through whether or not the we worked through whether or not the settlement we worked through whether or not the settlement would we worked through whether or not the settlement would do we worked through whether or not the settlement would do that. we worked through whether or not the settlement would do that. That's settlement would do that. That's exactly settlement would do that. That's exactly what settlement would do that. That's exactly what the settlement would do that. That's exactly what the member settlement would do that. That's exactly what the member has settlement would do that. That's exactly what the member has just exactly what the member has just said. exactly what the member has just said. And exactly what the member has just said. And the exactly what the member has just said. And the outcome exactly what the member has just said. And the outcome of exactly what the member has just said. And the outcome of which exactly what the member has just said. And the outcome of which is exactly what the member has just said. And the outcome of which is we said. And the outcome of which is we have said. And the outcome of which is we have a said. And the outcome of which is we have a deal said. And the outcome of which is we have a deal that said. And the outcome of which is we have a deal that does said. And the outcome of which is we have a deal that does not said. And the outcome of which is we have a deal that does not undermine have a deal that does not undermine the have a deal that does not undermine the treaty have a deal that does not undermine the treaty settlement have a deal that does not undermine the treaty settlement process. the treaty settlement process. What the treaty settlement process. What does the treaty settlement process. What does she the treaty settlement process. What does she think the treaty settlement process. What does she think New the treaty settlement process. What does she think New Zealanders What does she think New Zealanders in What does she think New Zealanders in general, What does she think New Zealanders in general, and What does she think New Zealanders in general, and iwi What does she think New Zealanders in general, and iwi in What does she think New Zealanders in general, and iwi in particular, in general, and iwi in particular, should in general, and iwi in particular, should think in general, and iwi in particular, should think about in general, and iwi in particular, should think about a in general, and iwi in particular, should think about a Government in general, and iwi in particular, should think about a Government that should think about a Government that told should think about a Government that told them should think about a Government that told them the should think about a Government that told them the Ihumatao should think about a Government that told them the Ihumatao deal should think about a Government that told them the Ihumatao deal was should think about a Government that told them the Ihumatao deal was not told them the Ihumatao deal was not part told them the Ihumatao deal was not part of told them the Ihumatao deal was not part of a told them the Ihumatao deal was not part of a treaty told them the Ihumatao deal was not part of a treaty settlement told them the Ihumatao deal was not part of a treaty settlement process, part of a treaty settlement process, part of a treaty settlement process, part of a treaty settlement process, and then, part of a treaty settlement process, and then, dastardly part of a treaty settlement process, and then, dastardly and part of a treaty settlement process, and then, dastardly and failedly, and then, dastardly and failedly, tried and then, dastardly and failedly, tried to and then, dastardly and failedly, tried to hide and then, dastardly and failedly, tried to hide those and then, dastardly and failedly, tried to hide those details? and then, dastardly and failedly, tried to hide those details? No, and then, dastardly and failedly, tried to hide those details? No, no. tried to hide those details? No, no. I tried to hide those details? No, no. I mean, tried to hide those details? No, no. I mean, I'm tried to hide those details? No, no. I mean, I'm reluctant tried to hide those details? No, no. I mean, I'm reluctant to tried to hide those details? No, no. I mean, I'm reluctant to ask tried to hide those details? No, no. I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member to I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member to ask I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member to ask it I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member to ask it again. I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member to ask it again. But I mean, I'm reluctant to ask the member to ask it again. But there member to ask it again. But there was member to ask it again. But there was certainly member to ask it again. But there was certainly some member to ask it again. But there was certainly some words member to ask it again. But there was certainly some words in member to ask it again. But there was certainly some words in there was certainly some words in there which was certainly some words in there which he was certainly some words in there which he knows was certainly some words in there which he knows adds was certainly some words in there which he knows adds no was certainly some words in there which he knows adds no value was certainly some words in there which he knows adds no value and which he knows adds no value and characterise which he knows adds no value and characterise something which he knows adds no value and characterise something in which he knows adds no value and characterise something in a which he knows adds no value and characterise something in a way characterise something in a way which characterise something in a way which is characterise something in a way which is inappropriate. characterise something in a way which is inappropriate. I'm characterise something in a way which is inappropriate. I'm going characterise something in a way which is inappropriate. I'm going to which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the PM which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the PM to which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the PM to ignore which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the PM to ignore those which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the PM to ignore those words which is inappropriate. I'm going to ask the PM to ignore those words and ask the PM to ignore those words and just ask the PM to ignore those words and just answer ask the PM to ignore those words and just answer the ask the PM to ignore those words and just answer the question. ask the PM to ignore those words and just answer the question. Well, ask the PM to ignore those words and just answer the question. Well, on just answer the question. Well, on behalf just answer the question. Well, on behalf of just answer the question. Well, on behalf of the just answer the question. Well, on behalf of the PM, just answer the question. Well, on behalf of the PM, what just answer the question. Well, on behalf of the PM, what New behalf of the PM, what New Zealanders behalf of the PM, what New Zealanders in behalf of the PM, what New Zealanders in general behalf of the PM, what New Zealanders in general are behalf of the PM, what New Zealanders in general are seeing behalf of the PM, what New Zealanders in general are seeing is Zealanders in general are seeing is a Zealanders in general are seeing is a situation Zealanders in general are seeing is a situation where Zealanders in general are seeing is a situation where there Zealanders in general are seeing is a situation where there was Zealanders in general are seeing is a situation where there was a a situation where there was a significant a situation where there was a significant stand-off, a situation where there was a significant stand-off, there a situation where there was a significant stand-off, there was a situation where there was a significant stand-off, there was an significant stand-off, there was an inability significant stand-off, there was an inability for significant stand-off, there was an inability for Fletchers, significant stand-off, there was an inability for Fletchers, who significant stand-off, there was an inability for Fletchers, who owned inability for Fletchers, who owned the inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, to inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, to be inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, to be able inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, to be able to inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, to be able to pursue inability for Fletchers, who owned the land, to be able to pursue a the land, to be able to pursue a development. the land, to be able to pursue a development. . the land, to be able to pursue a development. . And the land, to be able to pursue a development. . And what the land, to be able to pursue a development. . And what they've the land, to be able to pursue a development. . And what they've seen development. . And what they've seen is development. . And what they've seen is a development. . And what they've seen is a government development. . And what they've seen is a government that development. . And what they've seen is a government that actually development. . And what they've seen is a government that actually wants is a government that actually wants to is a government that actually wants to bring is a government that actually wants to bring New is a government that actually wants to bring New Zealanders is a government that actually wants to bring New Zealanders together is a government that actually wants to bring New Zealanders together for to bring New Zealanders together for a to bring New Zealanders together for a settlement to bring New Zealanders together for a settlement that to bring New Zealanders together for a settlement that will to bring New Zealanders together for a settlement that will build to bring New Zealanders together for a settlement that will build houses a settlement that will build houses and a settlement that will build houses and also a settlement that will build houses and also build a settlement that will build houses and also build a a settlement that will build houses and also build a much a settlement that will build houses and also build a much stronger a settlement that will build houses and also build a much stronger and and also build a much stronger and more and also build a much stronger and more cohesive and also build a much stronger and more cohesive society. and also build a much stronger and more cohesive society. Does and also build a much stronger and more cohesive society. Does the and also build a much stronger and more cohesive society. Does the PM more cohesive society. Does the PM accept more cohesive society. Does the PM accept that more cohesive society. Does the PM accept that the more cohesive society. Does the PM accept that the land more cohesive society. Does the PM accept that the land was more cohesive society. Does the PM accept that the land was stolen more cohesive society. Does the PM accept that the land was stolen from accept that the land was stolen from Maori, accept that the land was stolen from Maori, and accept that the land was stolen from Maori, and regardless accept that the land was stolen from Maori, and regardless of accept that the land was stolen from Maori, and regardless of the Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, the Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, the land Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, the land had Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, the land had to Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, the land had to be Maori, and regardless of the mechanism, the land had to be given mechanism, the land had to be given back? mechanism, the land had to be given back? On mechanism, the land had to be given back? On behalf mechanism, the land had to be given back? On behalf of mechanism, the land had to be given back? On behalf of the mechanism, the land had to be given back? On behalf of the PM, mechanism, the land had to be given back? On behalf of the PM, they're back? On behalf of the PM, they're not back? On behalf of the PM, they're not the back? On behalf of the PM, they're not the terms back? On behalf of the PM, they're not the terms under back? On behalf of the PM, they're not the terms under which back? On behalf of the PM, they're not the terms under which this not the terms under which this agreement not the terms under which this agreement has not the terms under which this agreement has been not the terms under which this agreement has been made. not the terms under which this agreement has been made. The not the terms under which this agreement has been made. The terms agreement has been made. The terms under agreement has been made. The terms under which agreement has been made. The terms under which this agreement has been made. The terms under which this agreement agreement has been made. The terms under which this agreement has agreement has been made. The terms under which this agreement has been under which this agreement has been made under which this agreement has been made is under which this agreement has been made is that under which this agreement has been made is that we under which this agreement has been made is that we have under which this agreement has been made is that we have an under which this agreement has been made is that we have an opportunity made is that we have an opportunity now made is that we have an opportunity now to made is that we have an opportunity now to see made is that we have an opportunity now to see a made is that we have an opportunity now to see a development made is that we have an opportunity now to see a development at made is that we have an opportunity now to see a development at Ihumatao now to see a development at Ihumatao that now to see a development at Ihumatao that is now to see a development at Ihumatao that is supported now to see a development at Ihumatao that is supported by now to see a development at Ihumatao that is supported by Mana now to see a development at Ihumatao that is supported by Mana Whenua, that is supported by Mana Whenua, that that is supported by Mana Whenua, that is that is supported by Mana Whenua, that is supported that is supported by Mana Whenua, that is supported by that is supported by Mana Whenua, that is supported by the that is supported by Mana Whenua, that is supported by the wider that is supported by the wider people that is supported by the wider people of that is supported by the wider people of Auckland that is supported by the wider people of Auckland and that is supported by the wider people of Auckland and New that is supported by the wider people of Auckland and New Zealand, people of Auckland and New Zealand, and people of Auckland and New Zealand, and that people of Auckland and New Zealand, and that the people of Auckland and New Zealand, and that the Government people of Auckland and New Zealand, and that the Government can people of Auckland and New Zealand, and that the Government can help and that the Government can help with. and that the Government can help with. This and that the Government can help with. This is and that the Government can help with. This is a and that the Government can help with. This is a win-win-win with. This is a win-win-win argument, with. This is a win-win-win argument, and with. This is a win-win-win argument, and I'm with. This is a win-win-win argument, and I'm very with. This is a win-win-win argument, and I'm very pleased with. This is a win-win-win argument, and I'm very pleased the argument, and I'm very pleased the Government argument, and I'm very pleased the Government has argument, and I'm very pleased the Government has got argument, and I'm very pleased the Government has got to argument, and I'm very pleased the Government has got to this argument, and I'm very pleased the Government has got to this point, Government has got to this point, alongside, Government has got to this point, alongside, I Government has got to this point, alongside, I might Government has got to this point, alongside, I might say, Government has got to this point, alongside, I might say, the alongside, I might say, the tremendous alongside, I might say, the tremendous efforts alongside, I might say, the tremendous efforts of alongside, I might say, the tremendous efforts of the tremendous efforts of the kingitanga, tremendous efforts of the kingitanga, who tremendous efforts of the kingitanga, who need tremendous efforts of the kingitanga, who need to tremendous efforts of the kingitanga, who need to be kingitanga, who need to be recognised kingitanga, who need to be recognised for kingitanga, who need to be recognised for the kingitanga, who need to be recognised for the work kingitanga, who need to be recognised for the work they kingitanga, who need to be recognised for the work they did kingitanga, who need to be recognised for the work they did to recognised for the work they did to bring recognised for the work they did to bring together recognised for the work they did to bring together all recognised for the work they did to bring together all of recognised for the work they did to bring together all of the recognised for the work they did to bring together all of the mana bring together all of the mana whenua. bring together all of the mana whenua. Question bring together all of the mana whenua. Question No. bring together all of the mana whenua. Question No. 7. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: for COVID-19 Response: Is for COVID-19 Response: Is New for COVID-19 Response: Is New Zealand for COVID-19 Response: Is New Zealand still for COVID-19 Response: Is New Zealand still negotiating Is New Zealand still negotiating a Is New Zealand still negotiating a joint Is New Zealand still negotiating a joint decision-making Is New Zealand still negotiating a joint decision-making framework a joint decision-making framework with a joint decision-making framework with Australia with Australia regarding with Australia regarding the with Australia regarding the proposed with Australia regarding the proposed trans-Tasman regarding the proposed trans-Tasman safe regarding the proposed trans-Tasman safe travel regarding the proposed trans-Tasman safe travel zone; safe travel zone; if safe travel zone; if so, safe travel zone; if so, what safe travel zone; if so, what remaining safe travel zone; if so, what remaining issues, if so, what remaining issues, if if so, what remaining issues, if any, if so, what remaining issues, if any, are if so, what remaining issues, if any, are being if so, what remaining issues, if any, are being discussed if any, are being discussed in if any, are being discussed in the if any, are being discussed in the negotiations? The The Hon The Hon Chris The Hon Chris Hipkins. The Hon Chris Hipkins. In The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the first The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the first part The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the first part of The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the first part of the The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the first part of the question, The Hon Chris Hipkins. In answer to the first part of the question, no. the first part of the question, no. As the first part of the question, no. As I the first part of the question, no. As I told the first part of the question, no. As I told the the first part of the question, no. As I told the member the first part of the question, no. As I told the member last the first part of the question, no. As I told the member last week, the first part of the question, no. As I told the member last week, we As I told the member last week, we have As I told the member last week, we have moved As I told the member last week, we have moved from As I told the member last week, we have moved from discussing As I told the member last week, we have moved from discussing a As I told the member last week, we have moved from discussing a joint have moved from discussing a joint decision-making have moved from discussing a joint decision-making framework have moved from discussing a joint decision-making framework with decision-making framework with Australia decision-making framework with Australia to decision-making framework with Australia to discussing decision-making framework with Australia to discussing more decision-making framework with Australia to discussing more of decision-making framework with Australia to discussing more of a Australia to discussing more of a unilateral Australia to discussing more of a unilateral approach Australia to discussing more of a unilateral approach to unilateral approach to decision-making, unilateral approach to decision-making, and unilateral approach to decision-making, and those decision-making, and those discussions decision-making, and those discussions continue. decision-making, and those discussions continue. Issues decision-making, and those discussions continue. Issues that discussions continue. Issues that we're discussions continue. Issues that we're working discussions continue. Issues that we're working through discussions continue. Issues that we're working through include we're working through include understanding we're working through include understanding the we're working through include understanding the circumstances we're working through include understanding the circumstances that understanding the circumstances that could understanding the circumstances that could lead understanding the circumstances that could lead to understanding the circumstances that could lead to a understanding the circumstances that could lead to a suspension understanding the circumstances that could lead to a suspension of could lead to a suspension of green-zone could lead to a suspension of green-zone travel could lead to a suspension of green-zone travel on could lead to a suspension of green-zone travel on either could lead to a suspension of green-zone travel on either side could lead to a suspension of green-zone travel on either side of green-zone travel on either side of the green-zone travel on either side of the Tasman. green-zone travel on either side of the Tasman. What green-zone travel on either side of the Tasman. What we green-zone travel on either side of the Tasman. What we would green-zone travel on either side of the Tasman. What we would do green-zone travel on either side of the Tasman. What we would do with the Tasman. What we would do with those the Tasman. What we would do with those whose the Tasman. What we would do with those whose travel the Tasman. What we would do with those whose travel is the Tasman. What we would do with those whose travel is disrupted the Tasman. What we would do with those whose travel is disrupted by those whose travel is disrupted by the those whose travel is disrupted by the suspension those whose travel is disrupted by the suspension of those whose travel is disrupted by the suspension of a those whose travel is disrupted by the suspension of a green those whose travel is disrupted by the suspension of a green zone. the suspension of a green zone. Testing the suspension of a green zone. Testing requirements the suspension of a green zone. Testing requirements that the suspension of a green zone. Testing requirements that may the suspension of a green zone. Testing requirements that may be the suspension of a green zone. Testing requirements that may be put Testing requirements that may be put in Testing requirements that may be put in place Testing requirements that may be put in place on Testing requirements that may be put in place on either Testing requirements that may be put in place on either side. Testing requirements that may be put in place on either side. Australia's in place on either side. Australia's current in place on either side. Australia's current exit in place on either side. Australia's current exit visa in place on either side. Australia's current exit visa restriction in place on either side. Australia's current exit visa restriction that current exit visa restriction that prevents current exit visa restriction that prevents Australians current exit visa restriction that prevents Australians travelling current exit visa restriction that prevents Australians travelling to prevents Australians travelling to New prevents Australians travelling to New Zealand prevents Australians travelling to New Zealand without prevents Australians travelling to New Zealand without a prevents Australians travelling to New Zealand without a visa. prevents Australians travelling to New Zealand without a visa. The New Zealand without a visa. The state-by-state New Zealand without a visa. The state-by-state differences New Zealand without a visa. The state-by-state differences in state-by-state differences in decision-making state-by-state differences in decision-making in state-by-state differences in decision-making in Australia. decision-making in Australia. Decision-making decision-making in Australia. Decision-making around decision-making in Australia. Decision-making around expansion decision-making in Australia. Decision-making around expansion to Decision-making around expansion to other Decision-making around expansion to other countries Decision-making around expansion to other countries outside Decision-making around expansion to other countries outside of Decision-making around expansion to other countries outside of the Decision-making around expansion to other countries outside of the safe other countries outside of the safe travel other countries outside of the safe travel zone, other countries outside of the safe travel zone, and other countries outside of the safe travel zone, and who other countries outside of the safe travel zone, and who would other countries outside of the safe travel zone, and who would make travel zone, and who would make those, travel zone, and who would make those, and travel zone, and who would make those, and whether travel zone, and who would make those, and whether New travel zone, and who would make those, and whether New Zealand travel zone, and who would make those, and whether New Zealand would those, and whether New Zealand would have those, and whether New Zealand would have any those, and whether New Zealand would have any input those, and whether New Zealand would have any input into those, and whether New Zealand would have any input into that those, and whether New Zealand would have any input into that process. have any input into that process. And have any input into that process. And contact have any input into that process. And contact tracing have any input into that process. And contact tracing system And contact tracing system interoperability And contact tracing system interoperability in And contact tracing system interoperability in the And contact tracing system interoperability in the event And contact tracing system interoperability in the event that interoperability in the event that we interoperability in the event that we needed interoperability in the event that we needed to interoperability in the event that we needed to do interoperability in the event that we needed to do contact interoperability in the event that we needed to do contact tracing interoperability in the event that we needed to do contact tracing for we needed to do contact tracing for people we needed to do contact tracing for people who we needed to do contact tracing for people who had we needed to do contact tracing for people who had been we needed to do contact tracing for people who had been in we needed to do contact tracing for people who had been in one we needed to do contact tracing for people who had been in one country people who had been in one country and people who had been in one country and were people who had been in one country and were then people who had been in one country and were then identified people who had been in one country and were then identified as people who had been in one country and were then identified as being and were then identified as being more and were then identified as being more at and were then identified as being more at risk and were then identified as being more at risk after and were then identified as being more at risk after they and were then identified as being more at risk after they had more at risk after they had travelled more at risk after they had travelled to more at risk after they had travelled to another more at risk after they had travelled to another country. more at risk after they had travelled to another country. Thank travelled to another country. Thank you travelled to another country. Thank you for travelled to another country. Thank you for that travelled to another country. Thank you for that answer. travelled to another country. Thank you for that answer. Has travelled to another country. Thank you for that answer. Has Cabinet you for that answer. Has Cabinet ruled you for that answer. Has Cabinet ruled out you for that answer. Has Cabinet ruled out unilaterally you for that answer. Has Cabinet ruled out unilaterally declaring ruled out unilaterally declaring that ruled out unilaterally declaring that people ruled out unilaterally declaring that people from ruled out unilaterally declaring that people from Australia ruled out unilaterally declaring that people from Australia can ruled out unilaterally declaring that people from Australia can come that people from Australia can come to that people from Australia can come to New that people from Australia can come to New Zealand that people from Australia can come to New Zealand without that people from Australia can come to New Zealand without undertaking to New Zealand without undertaking isolation to New Zealand without undertaking isolation and to New Zealand without undertaking isolation and quarantine? to New Zealand without undertaking isolation and quarantine? And, to New Zealand without undertaking isolation and quarantine? And, if isolation and quarantine? And, if not, isolation and quarantine? And, if not, why isolation and quarantine? And, if not, why not? isolation and quarantine? And, if not, why not? No, isolation and quarantine? And, if not, why not? No, we've isolation and quarantine? And, if not, why not? No, we've not isolation and quarantine? And, if not, why not? No, we've not ruled not, why not? No, we've not ruled that not, why not? No, we've not ruled that out. not, why not? No, we've not ruled that out. And not, why not? No, we've not ruled that out. And the not, why not? No, we've not ruled that out. And the reason not, why not? No, we've not ruled that out. And the reason we not, why not? No, we've not ruled that out. And the reason we haven't that out. And the reason we haven't ruled that out. And the reason we haven't ruled it that out. And the reason we haven't ruled it out that out. And the reason we haven't ruled it out is that out. And the reason we haven't ruled it out is because that out. And the reason we haven't ruled it out is because that's ruled it out is because that's actually ruled it out is because that's actually where ruled it out is because that's actually where we're ruled it out is because that's actually where we're most ruled it out is because that's actually where we're most likely ruled it out is because that's actually where we're most likely to actually where we're most likely to end actually where we're most likely to end up. end up. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> The <INTERRUPTION> The member <INTERRUPTION> The member clearly <INTERRUPTION> The member clearly didn't <INTERRUPTION> The member clearly didn't listen <INTERRUPTION> The member clearly didn't listen to The member clearly didn't listen to my The member clearly didn't listen to my answers The member clearly didn't listen to my answers last The member clearly didn't listen to my answers last week. The member clearly didn't listen to my answers last week. I The member clearly didn't listen to my answers last week. I actually my answers last week. I actually told my answers last week. I actually told him my answers last week. I actually told him that my answers last week. I actually told him that last my answers last week. I actually told him that last week. told him that last week. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> We <INTERRUPTION> We have <INTERRUPTION> We have moved <INTERRUPTION> We have moved from <INTERRUPTION> We have moved from the <INTERRUPTION> We have moved from the notion <INTERRUPTION> We have moved from the notion of <INTERRUPTION> We have moved from the notion of a We have moved from the notion of a joint We have moved from the notion of a joint decision-making We have moved from the notion of a joint decision-making framework We have moved from the notion of a joint decision-making framework to joint decision-making framework to having joint decision-making framework to having a joint decision-making framework to having a unilateral joint decision-making framework to having a unilateral decision-making having a unilateral decision-making framework, having a unilateral decision-making framework, where having a unilateral decision-making framework, where each having a unilateral decision-making framework, where each country framework, where each country reserves framework, where each country reserves its framework, where each country reserves its ability framework, where each country reserves its ability to framework, where each country reserves its ability to make framework, where each country reserves its ability to make its framework, where each country reserves its ability to make its own reserves its ability to make its own decisions reserves its ability to make its own decisions about reserves its ability to make its own decisions about the reserves its ability to make its own decisions about the suspension reserves its ability to make its own decisions about the suspension and decisions about the suspension and opening-up decisions about the suspension and opening-up of decisions about the suspension and opening-up of the decisions about the suspension and opening-up of the green decisions about the suspension and opening-up of the green travel decisions about the suspension and opening-up of the green travel zone. opening-up of the green travel zone. When opening-up of the green travel zone. When was opening-up of the green travel zone. When was the opening-up of the green travel zone. When was the issue opening-up of the green travel zone. When was the issue of opening-up of the green travel zone. When was the issue of stranded When was the issue of stranded travellers When was the issue of stranded travellers being When was the issue of stranded travellers being potentially When was the issue of stranded travellers being potentially stuck travellers being potentially stuck in travellers being potentially stuck in Australia travellers being potentially stuck in Australia first travellers being potentially stuck in Australia first identified travellers being potentially stuck in Australia first identified by travellers being potentially stuck in Australia first identified by the in Australia first identified by the officials? in Australia first identified by the officials? That's in Australia first identified by the officials? That's been in Australia first identified by the officials? That's been one in Australia first identified by the officials? That's been one of in Australia first identified by the officials? That's been one of the officials? That's been one of the items officials? That's been one of the items that's officials? That's been one of the items that's been officials? That's been one of the items that's been ongoing officials? That's been one of the items that's been ongoing through items that's been ongoing through the items that's been ongoing through the discussions items that's been ongoing through the discussions right items that's been ongoing through the discussions right the items that's been ongoing through the discussions right the way the discussions right the way through, the discussions right the way through, including the discussions right the way through, including when the discussions right the way through, including when we the discussions right the way through, including when we were through, including when we were discussing through, including when we were discussing a through, including when we were discussing a joint through, including when we were discussing a joint decision through, including when we were discussing a joint decision may discussing a joint decision may being discussing a joint decision may being framework. discussing a joint decision may being framework. One discussing a joint decision may being framework. One of discussing a joint decision may being framework. One of the discussing a joint decision may being framework. One of the goals being framework. One of the goals for being framework. One of the goals for having being framework. One of the goals for having a being framework. One of the goals for having a joint being framework. One of the goals for having a joint decision-making for having a joint decision-making framework for having a joint decision-making framework was for having a joint decision-making framework was so for having a joint decision-making framework was so that for having a joint decision-making framework was so that we for having a joint decision-making framework was so that we could for having a joint decision-making framework was so that we could avoid framework was so that we could avoid people framework was so that we could avoid people being framework was so that we could avoid people being stranded. framework was so that we could avoid people being stranded. We framework was so that we could avoid people being stranded. We have people being stranded. We have already people being stranded. We have already seen people being stranded. We have already seen examples people being stranded. We have already seen examples of people being stranded. We have already seen examples of people's already seen examples of people's travel already seen examples of people's travel being already seen examples of people's travel being disrupted already seen examples of people's travel being disrupted and already seen examples of people's travel being disrupted and people travel being disrupted and people being travel being disrupted and people being stranded travel being disrupted and people being stranded as travel being disrupted and people being stranded as a travel being disrupted and people being stranded as a result travel being disrupted and people being stranded as a result of being stranded as a result of Australia's being stranded as a result of Australia's suspension being stranded as a result of Australia's suspension of being stranded as a result of Australia's suspension of the being stranded as a result of Australia's suspension of the green Australia's suspension of the green zone. Australia's suspension of the green zone. We've Australia's suspension of the green zone. We've had Australia's suspension of the green zone. We've had flights Australia's suspension of the green zone. We've had flights on Australia's suspension of the green zone. We've had flights on the zone. We've had flights on the tarmac zone. We've had flights on the tarmac at zone. We've had flights on the tarmac at Auckland, zone. We've had flights on the tarmac at Auckland, about zone. We've had flights on the tarmac at Auckland, about to zone. We've had flights on the tarmac at Auckland, about to take tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that have tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that have had tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that have had to tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that have had to turn tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that have had to turn back tarmac at Auckland, about to take off, that have had to turn back when off, that have had to turn back when Australia, off, that have had to turn back when Australia, at off, that have had to turn back when Australia, at very off, that have had to turn back when Australia, at very short off, that have had to turn back when Australia, at very short notice, off, that have had to turn back when Australia, at very short notice, has Australia, at very short notice, has suspended Australia, at very short notice, has suspended green Australia, at very short notice, has suspended green zone Australia, at very short notice, has suspended green zone travel. Australia, at very short notice, has suspended green zone travel. I Australia, at very short notice, has suspended green zone travel. I do suspended green zone travel. I do want suspended green zone travel. I do want to suspended green zone travel. I do want to note suspended green zone travel. I do want to note that suspended green zone travel. I do want to note that at suspended green zone travel. I do want to note that at the suspended green zone travel. I do want to note that at the moment suspended green zone travel. I do want to note that at the moment only want to note that at the moment only Victoria want to note that at the moment only Victoria and want to note that at the moment only Victoria and New want to note that at the moment only Victoria and New South want to note that at the moment only Victoria and New South Wales want to note that at the moment only Victoria and New South Wales are Victoria and New South Wales are allowing Victoria and New South Wales are allowing people Victoria and New South Wales are allowing people to Victoria and New South Wales are allowing people to arrive Victoria and New South Wales are allowing people to arrive in Victoria and New South Wales are allowing people to arrive in those allowing people to arrive in those countries allowing people to arrive in those countries without allowing people to arrive in those countries without mandatory countries without mandatory quarantine countries without mandatory quarantine or countries without mandatory quarantine or mandatory countries without mandatory quarantine or mandatory isolation, quarantine or mandatory isolation, but quarantine or mandatory isolation, but they quarantine or mandatory isolation, but they are quarantine or mandatory isolation, but they are still quarantine or mandatory isolation, but they are still requiring quarantine or mandatory isolation, but they are still requiring those but they are still requiring those travelling but they are still requiring those travelling from but they are still requiring those travelling from Auckland but they are still requiring those travelling from Auckland to travelling from Auckland to self-isolate travelling from Auckland to self-isolate for travelling from Auckland to self-isolate for 72 travelling from Auckland to self-isolate for 72 hours travelling from Auckland to self-isolate for 72 hours and travelling from Auckland to self-isolate for 72 hours and return self-isolate for 72 hours and return a self-isolate for 72 hours and return a negative self-isolate for 72 hours and return a negative COVID-19 self-isolate for 72 hours and return a negative COVID-19 test self-isolate for 72 hours and return a negative COVID-19 test upon a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival. a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival. When a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival. When was a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival. When was the a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival. When was the last a negative COVID-19 test upon arrival. When was the last time arrival. When was the last time COVID-19 arrival. When was the last time COVID-19 was arrival. When was the last time COVID-19 was detected arrival. When was the last time COVID-19 was detected in arrival. When was the last time COVID-19 was detected in managed COVID-19 was detected in managed isolation COVID-19 was detected in managed isolation and COVID-19 was detected in managed isolation and quarantine COVID-19 was detected in managed isolation and quarantine in COVID-19 was detected in managed isolation and quarantine in an isolation and quarantine in an arrival isolation and quarantine in an arrival from isolation and quarantine in an arrival from Australia, isolation and quarantine in an arrival from Australia, who isolation and quarantine in an arrival from Australia, who had isolation and quarantine in an arrival from Australia, who had come arrival from Australia, who had come direct arrival from Australia, who had come direct from arrival from Australia, who had come direct from Australia arrival from Australia, who had come direct from Australia and arrival from Australia, who had come direct from Australia and had arrival from Australia, who had come direct from Australia and had not direct from Australia and had not transited direct from Australia and had not transited via direct from Australia and had not transited via Australia direct from Australia and had not transited via Australia from direct from Australia and had not transited via Australia from another transited via Australia from another country? transited via Australia from another country? There's transited via Australia from another country? There's been transited via Australia from another country? There's been one transited via Australia from another country? There's been one case transited via Australia from another country? There's been one case this country? There's been one case this year. country? There's been one case this year. I country? There's been one case this year. I think country? There's been one case this year. I think overall country? There's been one case this year. I think overall about country? There's been one case this year. I think overall about two year. I think overall about two dozen year. I think overall about two dozen cases year. I think overall about two dozen cases in year. I think overall about two dozen cases in total year. I think overall about two dozen cases in total since year. I think overall about two dozen cases in total since we've year. I think overall about two dozen cases in total since we've had dozen cases in total since we've had the dozen cases in total since we've had the border dozen cases in total since we've had the border restrictions dozen cases in total since we've had the border restrictions in dozen cases in total since we've had the border restrictions in place. dozen cases in total since we've had the border restrictions in place. I the border restrictions in place. I don't the border restrictions in place. I don't have the border restrictions in place. I don't have the the border restrictions in place. I don't have the exact the border restrictions in place. I don't have the exact dates the border restrictions in place. I don't have the exact dates of the border restrictions in place. I don't have the exact dates of those don't have the exact dates of those off don't have the exact dates of those off the don't have the exact dates of those off the top don't have the exact dates of those off the top of don't have the exact dates of those off the top of my don't have the exact dates of those off the top of my head. don't have the exact dates of those off the top of my head. It don't have the exact dates of those off the top of my head. It is don't have the exact dates of those off the top of my head. It is a off the top of my head. It is a relatively off the top of my head. It is a relatively small off the top of my head. It is a relatively small number, off the top of my head. It is a relatively small number, but off the top of my head. It is a relatively small number, but that's relatively small number, but that's in relatively small number, but that's in the relatively small number, but that's in the context relatively small number, but that's in the context of relatively small number, but that's in the context of a relatively small number, but that's in the context of a relatively relatively small number, but that's in the context of a relatively small in the context of a relatively small number in the context of a relatively small number of in the context of a relatively small number of people in the context of a relatively small number of people coming in the context of a relatively small number of people coming into in the context of a relatively small number of people coming into the number of people coming into the country number of people coming into the country in number of people coming into the country in total. number of people coming into the country in total. It's number of people coming into the country in total. It's worth country in total. It's worth remembering country in total. It's worth remembering that country in total. It's worth remembering that at country in total. It's worth remembering that at the country in total. It's worth remembering that at the moment country in total. It's worth remembering that at the moment we remembering that at the moment we deal remembering that at the moment we deal with remembering that at the moment we deal with probably remembering that at the moment we deal with probably several remembering that at the moment we deal with probably several hundred deal with probably several hundred arrivals deal with probably several hundred arrivals to deal with probably several hundred arrivals to New deal with probably several hundred arrivals to New Zealand deal with probably several hundred arrivals to New Zealand per deal with probably several hundred arrivals to New Zealand per day deal with probably several hundred arrivals to New Zealand per day in arrivals to New Zealand per day in total. arrivals to New Zealand per day in total. We arrivals to New Zealand per day in total. We would arrivals to New Zealand per day in total. We would be arrivals to New Zealand per day in total. We would be talking arrivals to New Zealand per day in total. We would be talking about, total. We would be talking about, with total. We would be talking about, with a total. We would be talking about, with a return total. We would be talking about, with a return to total. We would be talking about, with a return to trans-Tasman total. We would be talking about, with a return to trans-Tasman travel with a return to trans-Tasman travel pre-COVID-19 with a return to trans-Tasman travel pre-COVID-19 levels, with a return to trans-Tasman travel pre-COVID-19 levels, between with a return to trans-Tasman travel pre-COVID-19 levels, between 8,000 pre-COVID-19 levels, between 8,000 and pre-COVID-19 levels, between 8,000 and 12,000 pre-COVID-19 levels, between 8,000 and 12,000 people pre-COVID-19 levels, between 8,000 and 12,000 people travelling pre-COVID-19 levels, between 8,000 and 12,000 people travelling across and 12,000 people travelling across the and 12,000 people travelling across the Tasman and 12,000 people travelling across the Tasman every and 12,000 people travelling across the Tasman every single and 12,000 people travelling across the Tasman every single day. the Tasman every single day. Why the Tasman every single day. Why does the Tasman every single day. Why does the the Tasman every single day. Why does the Government the Tasman every single day. Why does the Government say the Tasman every single day. Why does the Government say that Why does the Government say that Australians Why does the Government say that Australians being Why does the Government say that Australians being required Why does the Government say that Australians being required to Why does the Government say that Australians being required to have Australians being required to have an Australians being required to have an exit Australians being required to have an exit visa Australians being required to have an exit visa to Australians being required to have an exit visa to leave Australians being required to have an exit visa to leave Australia Australians being required to have an exit visa to leave Australia is an exit visa to leave Australia is an an exit visa to leave Australia is an impediment an exit visa to leave Australia is an impediment to an exit visa to leave Australia is an impediment to the an exit visa to leave Australia is an impediment to the trans-Tasman an impediment to the trans-Tasman save an impediment to the trans-Tasman save travel an impediment to the trans-Tasman save travel zone, an impediment to the trans-Tasman save travel zone, when an impediment to the trans-Tasman save travel zone, when the an impediment to the trans-Tasman save travel zone, when the PM an impediment to the trans-Tasman save travel zone, when the PM of save travel zone, when the PM of Australia save travel zone, when the PM of Australia has save travel zone, when the PM of Australia has made save travel zone, when the PM of Australia has made it save travel zone, when the PM of Australia has made it very save travel zone, when the PM of Australia has made it very clear Australia has made it very clear he's Australia has made it very clear he's happy Australia has made it very clear he's happy for Australia has made it very clear he's happy for Australians Australia has made it very clear he's happy for Australians to he's happy for Australians to holiday he's happy for Australians to holiday in he's happy for Australians to holiday in New he's happy for Australians to holiday in New Zealand? he's happy for Australians to holiday in New Zealand? Well, he's happy for Australians to holiday in New Zealand? Well, if he's happy for Australians to holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look forward holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look forward to holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look forward to his holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look forward to his removal holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look forward to his removal of holiday in New Zealand? Well, if so, I look forward to his removal of the I look forward to his removal of the requirement I look forward to his removal of the requirement for I look forward to his removal of the requirement for Australians requirement for Australians travelling requirement for Australians travelling to requirement for Australians travelling to New requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand to requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand to have requirement for Australians travelling to New Zealand to have an travelling to New Zealand to have an exit travelling to New Zealand to have an exit visa travelling to New Zealand to have an exit visa in travelling to New Zealand to have an exit visa in order travelling to New Zealand to have an exit visa in order to travelling to New Zealand to have an exit visa in order to do travelling to New Zealand to have an exit visa in order to do so. exit visa in order to do so. Question exit visa in order to do so. Question No. exit visa in order to do so. Question No. 8, exit visa in order to do so. Question No. 8, Ibrahim exit visa in order to do so. Question No. 8, Ibrahim Omer. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Lead My question is to the Lead Coordination My question is to the Lead Coordination Minister Coordination Minister for Coordination Minister for the Coordination Minister for the Government's Coordination Minister for the Government's Response for the Government's Response to for the Government's Response to the for the Government's Response to the Royal for the Government's Response to the Royal Commission's for the Government's Response to the Royal Commission's Report to the Royal Commission's Report into to the Royal Commission's Report into the to the Royal Commission's Report into the Terrorist to the Royal Commission's Report into the Terrorist Attack into the Terrorist Attack on into the Terrorist Attack on the into the Terrorist Attack on the Christchurch into the Terrorist Attack on the Christchurch Mosques: on the Christchurch Mosques: What on the Christchurch Mosques: What recent on the Christchurch Mosques: What recent announcements on the Christchurch Mosques: What recent announcements has What recent announcements has he What recent announcements has he made What recent announcements has he made regarding What recent announcements has he made regarding ongoing What recent announcements has he made regarding ongoing work he made regarding ongoing work with he made regarding ongoing work with survivors he made regarding ongoing work with survivors of he made regarding ongoing work with survivors of the he made regarding ongoing work with survivors of the 15 he made regarding ongoing work with survivors of the 15 March with survivors of the 15 March 2019 with survivors of the 15 March 2019 mosque with survivors of the 15 March 2019 mosque attacks? The The Hon The Hon Andrew The Hon Andrew Little. The Hon Andrew Little. (SPEAKS The Hon Andrew Little. (SPEAKS OTHER The Hon Andrew Little. (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an attack (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an attack on (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an attack on all (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an attack on all of (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an attack on all of us, (SPEAKS OTHER LANGUAGE) It was an attack on all of us, but It was an attack on all of us, but it It was an attack on all of us, but it was It was an attack on all of us, but it was particularly It was an attack on all of us, but it was particularly an It was an attack on all of us, but it was particularly an attack It was an attack on all of us, but it was particularly an attack on It was an attack on all of us, but it was particularly an attack on the it was particularly an attack on the Muslim it was particularly an attack on the Muslim community. it was particularly an attack on the Muslim community. In it was particularly an attack on the Muslim community. In response it was particularly an attack on the Muslim community. In response to it was particularly an attack on the Muslim community. In response to the Muslim community. In response to the recommendations Muslim community. In response to the recommendations of Muslim community. In response to the recommendations of the Muslim community. In response to the recommendations of the royal recommendations of the royal commission recommendations of the royal commission of recommendations of the royal commission of inquiry recommendations of the royal commission of inquiry and recommendations of the royal commission of inquiry and following commission of inquiry and following engagement commission of inquiry and following engagement with commission of inquiry and following engagement with faith commission of inquiry and following engagement with faith and commission of inquiry and following engagement with faith and ethnic engagement with faith and ethnic communities, engagement with faith and ethnic communities, the engagement with faith and ethnic communities, the Government engagement with faith and ethnic communities, the Government last communities, the Government last week communities, the Government last week announced communities, the Government last week announced the communities, the Government last week announced the following. communities, the Government last week announced the following. An week announced the following. An implementation week announced the following. An implementation of week announced the following. An implementation of oversight week announced the following. An implementation of oversight advisory implementation of oversight advisory group implementation of oversight advisory group to implementation of oversight advisory group to ensure implementation of oversight advisory group to ensure timely, implementation of oversight advisory group to ensure timely, effective group to ensure timely, effective and group to ensure timely, effective and accountable group to ensure timely, effective and accountable response group to ensure timely, effective and accountable response to group to ensure timely, effective and accountable response to the and accountable response to the royal and accountable response to the royal commission and accountable response to the royal commission report. and accountable response to the royal commission report. Next, and accountable response to the royal commission report. Next, a royal commission report. Next, a collective royal commission report. Next, a collective impact royal commission report. Next, a collective impact board royal commission report. Next, a collective impact board that royal commission report. Next, a collective impact board that will collective impact board that will enable collective impact board that will enable affected collective impact board that will enable affected whanau collective impact board that will enable affected whanau of collective impact board that will enable affected whanau of the collective impact board that will enable affected whanau of the 15 enable affected whanau of the 15 March enable affected whanau of the 15 March victims enable affected whanau of the 15 March victims to enable affected whanau of the 15 March victims to guide enable affected whanau of the 15 March victims to guide and enable affected whanau of the 15 March victims to guide and advise enable affected whanau of the 15 March victims to guide and advise on March victims to guide and advise on services March victims to guide and advise on services to March victims to guide and advise on services to support March victims to guide and advise on services to support their March victims to guide and advise on services to support their long-term services to support their long-term recovery services to support their long-term recovery needs. services to support their long-term recovery needs. Next, services to support their long-term recovery needs. Next, a services to support their long-term recovery needs. Next, a boosted recovery needs. Next, a boosted safer recovery needs. Next, a boosted safer communities recovery needs. Next, a boosted safer communities fund recovery needs. Next, a boosted safer communities fund with recovery needs. Next, a boosted safer communities fund with $3.255 safer communities fund with $3.255 million safer communities fund with $3.255 million available safer communities fund with $3.255 million available to safer communities fund with $3.255 million available to provide safer communities fund with $3.255 million available to provide a million available to provide a broader million available to provide a broader range million available to provide a broader range of million available to provide a broader range of communities million available to provide a broader range of communities with broader range of communities with funding broader range of communities with funding to broader range of communities with funding to upgrade broader range of communities with funding to upgrade and broader range of communities with funding to upgrade and implement funding to upgrade and implement security funding to upgrade and implement security measures. funding to upgrade and implement security measures. Next, funding to upgrade and implement security measures. Next, the funding to upgrade and implement security measures. Next, the ethnic security measures. Next, the ethnic and security measures. Next, the ethnic and faith security measures. Next, the ethnic and faith community security measures. Next, the ethnic and faith community engagement and faith community engagement response and faith community engagement response fund and faith community engagement response fund to and faith community engagement response fund to help and faith community engagement response fund to help minority response fund to help minority ethnic response fund to help minority ethnic and response fund to help minority ethnic and faith response fund to help minority ethnic and faith communities response fund to help minority ethnic and faith communities engage ethnic and faith communities engage with ethnic and faith communities engage with the ethnic and faith communities engage with the Government, ethnic and faith communities engage with the Government, to ethnic and faith communities engage with the Government, to inform ethnic and faith communities engage with the Government, to inform it ethnic and faith communities engage with the Government, to inform it on with the Government, to inform it on its with the Government, to inform it on its response with the Government, to inform it on its response to with the Government, to inform it on its response to the with the Government, to inform it on its response to the royal its response to the royal commission's its response to the royal commission's report. its response to the royal commission's report. And, its response to the royal commission's report. And, finally, commission's report. And, finally, the commission's report. And, finally, the ethnic commission's report. And, finally, the ethnic communities commission's report. And, finally, the ethnic communities graduate the ethnic communities graduate programme, the ethnic communities graduate programme, which the ethnic communities graduate programme, which will the ethnic communities graduate programme, which will create programme, which will create employment programme, which will create employment opportunities programme, which will create employment opportunities for employment opportunities for graduates employment opportunities for graduates and employment opportunities for graduates and build employment opportunities for graduates and build the employment opportunities for graduates and build the diversity employment opportunities for graduates and build the diversity of graduates and build the diversity of knowledge graduates and build the diversity of knowledge and graduates and build the diversity of knowledge and experience graduates and build the diversity of knowledge and experience within graduates and build the diversity of knowledge and experience within the knowledge and experience within the public knowledge and experience within the public sector. public sector. What public sector. What other public sector. What other commitments public sector. What other commitments has public sector. What other commitments has the What other commitments has the Government What other commitments has the Government made What other commitments has the Government made to What other commitments has the Government made to respond What other commitments has the Government made to respond to What other commitments has the Government made to respond to the Government made to respond to the royal Government made to respond to the royal commission's Government made to respond to the royal commission's recommendations? royal commission's recommendations? The royal commission's recommendations? The Government royal commission's recommendations? The Government has royal commission's recommendations? The Government has a royal commission's recommendations? The Government has a number royal commission's recommendations? The Government has a number of royal commission's recommendations? The Government has a number of other The Government has a number of other new The Government has a number of other new and The Government has a number of other new and ongoing The Government has a number of other new and ongoing initiatives The Government has a number of other new and ongoing initiatives under new and ongoing initiatives under way new and ongoing initiatives under way that new and ongoing initiatives under way that focus new and ongoing initiatives under way that focus on new and ongoing initiatives under way that focus on three new and ongoing initiatives under way that focus on three key new and ongoing initiatives under way that focus on three key areas. way that focus on three key areas. Supporting way that focus on three key areas. Supporting our way that focus on three key areas. Supporting our diverse way that focus on three key areas. Supporting our diverse communities, Supporting our diverse communities, tackling Supporting our diverse communities, tackling harmful Supporting our diverse communities, tackling harmful behaviour Supporting our diverse communities, tackling harmful behaviour and tackling harmful behaviour and discrimination, tackling harmful behaviour and discrimination, and tackling harmful behaviour and discrimination, and keeping tackling harmful behaviour and discrimination, and keeping New discrimination, and keeping New Zealand discrimination, and keeping New Zealand safe. discrimination, and keeping New Zealand safe. As discrimination, and keeping New Zealand safe. As part discrimination, and keeping New Zealand safe. As part of discrimination, and keeping New Zealand safe. As part of its Zealand safe. As part of its response, Zealand safe. As part of its response, the Zealand safe. As part of its response, the Government Zealand safe. As part of its response, the Government will response, the Government will establish response, the Government will establish a response, the Government will establish a Ministry response, the Government will establish a Ministry of response, the Government will establish a Ministry of Ethnic establish a Ministry of Ethnic Communities, establish a Ministry of Ethnic Communities, establish establish a Ministry of Ethnic Communities, establish a establish a Ministry of Ethnic Communities, establish a National Communities, establish a National Centre Communities, establish a National Centre of Communities, establish a National Centre of Excellence Communities, establish a National Centre of Excellence for Communities, establish a National Centre of Excellence for Independent Centre of Excellence for Independent Research Centre of Excellence for Independent Research Into Centre of Excellence for Independent Research Into Violent Centre of Excellence for Independent Research Into Violent Extremism. Research Into Violent Extremism. Implement Research Into Violent Extremism. Implement a Research Into Violent Extremism. Implement a trial Research Into Violent Extremism. Implement a trial to Research Into Violent Extremism. Implement a trial to support Research Into Violent Extremism. Implement a trial to support young Implement a trial to support young children Implement a trial to support young children to Implement a trial to support young children to improve Implement a trial to support young children to improve their children to improve their self-regulation, children to improve their self-regulation, resilience children to improve their self-regulation, resilience and self-regulation, resilience and social self-regulation, resilience and social skills. self-regulation, resilience and social skills. Establish self-regulation, resilience and social skills. Establish the self-regulation, resilience and social skills. Establish the NZ social skills. Establish the NZ Police social skills. Establish the NZ Police Programme, social skills. Establish the NZ Police Programme, a social skills. Establish the NZ Police Programme, a data social skills. Establish the NZ Police Programme, a data collection Police Programme, a data collection process Police Programme, a data collection process for Police Programme, a data collection process for hate Police Programme, a data collection process for hate crime. Police Programme, a data collection process for hate crime. Increase Police Programme, a data collection process for hate crime. Increase the process for hate crime. Increase the capacity process for hate crime. Increase the capacity of process for hate crime. Increase the capacity of the process for hate crime. Increase the capacity of the Human process for hate crime. Increase the capacity of the Human Rights capacity of the Human Rights Commission. capacity of the Human Rights Commission. Change capacity of the Human Rights Commission. Change hate capacity of the Human Rights Commission. Change hate speech Commission. Change hate speech legislation. Commission. Change hate speech legislation. Strengthen Commission. Change hate speech legislation. Strengthen New legislation. Strengthen New Zealand's legislation. Strengthen New Zealand's counter-terrorism legislation. Strengthen New Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Establish Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Establish a Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Establish a new Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Establish a new Crown Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Establish a new Crown entity Zealand's counter-terrorism laws. Establish a new Crown entity for Establish a new Crown entity for strategic Establish a new Crown entity for strategic intelligence Establish a new Crown entity for strategic intelligence and Establish a new Crown entity for strategic intelligence and security strategic intelligence and security leadership. strategic intelligence and security leadership. And strategic intelligence and security leadership. And accede strategic intelligence and security leadership. And accede to strategic intelligence and security leadership. And accede to the leadership. And accede to the Budapest leadership. And accede to the Budapest Convention leadership. And accede to the Budapest Convention on leadership. And accede to the Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What are Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What are the Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What are the next Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What are the next steps Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What are the next steps in Budapest Convention on Cybercrime. What are the next steps in the What are the next steps in the process What are the next steps in the process going What are the next steps in the process going forward What are the next steps in the process going forward to What are the next steps in the process going forward to implement process going forward to implement the process going forward to implement the royal process going forward to implement the royal commission's the royal commission's recommendations? the royal commission's recommendations? We the royal commission's recommendations? We will the royal commission's recommendations? We will be the royal commission's recommendations? We will be phasing recommendations? We will be phasing the recommendations? We will be phasing the work recommendations? We will be phasing the work programme, recommendations? We will be phasing the work programme, prioritising the work programme, prioritising safety the work programme, prioritising safety of the work programme, prioritising safety of communities the work programme, prioritising safety of communities and the work programme, prioritising safety of communities and social safety of communities and social inclusion. safety of communities and social inclusion. One safety of communities and social inclusion. One of safety of communities and social inclusion. One of our safety of communities and social inclusion. One of our key safety of communities and social inclusion. One of our key priorities inclusion. One of our key priorities at inclusion. One of our key priorities at the inclusion. One of our key priorities at the moment inclusion. One of our key priorities at the moment is inclusion. One of our key priorities at the moment is setting inclusion. One of our key priorities at the moment is setting up inclusion. One of our key priorities at the moment is setting up the at the moment is setting up the implementation at the moment is setting up the implementation oversight at the moment is setting up the implementation oversight advisory implementation oversight advisory group. implementation oversight advisory group. That implementation oversight advisory group. That group implementation oversight advisory group. That group will implementation oversight advisory group. That group will provide group. That group will provide independent group. That group will provide independent advice group. That group will provide independent advice to group. That group will provide independent advice to me, group. That group will provide independent advice to me, as group. That group will provide independent advice to me, as the independent advice to me, as the lead independent advice to me, as the lead coordinator independent advice to me, as the lead coordinator and independent advice to me, as the lead coordinator and Minister independent advice to me, as the lead coordinator and Minister for lead coordinator and Minister for the lead coordinator and Minister for the Government's lead coordinator and Minister for the Government's response, lead coordinator and Minister for the Government's response, and lead coordinator and Minister for the Government's response, and the the Government's response, and the group's the Government's response, and the group's work the Government's response, and the group's work will the Government's response, and the group's work will include the Government's response, and the group's work will include advice the Government's response, and the group's work will include advice on group's work will include advice on work group's work will include advice on work programme group's work will include advice on work programme priorities. group's work will include advice on work programme priorities. We're work programme priorities. We're also work programme priorities. We're also currently work programme priorities. We're also currently focused work programme priorities. We're also currently focused on also currently focused on establishing also currently focused on establishing the also currently focused on establishing the Collective also currently focused on establishing the Collective Impact establishing the Collective Impact Board establishing the Collective Impact Board for establishing the Collective Impact Board for the establishing the Collective Impact Board for the Canterbury establishing the Collective Impact Board for the Canterbury region Board for the Canterbury region which, Board for the Canterbury region which, will Board for the Canterbury region which, will enable Board for the Canterbury region which, will enable affected which, will enable affected communities which, will enable affected communities of which, will enable affected communities of the which, will enable affected communities of the 15 which, will enable affected communities of the 15 March communities of the 15 March terrorist communities of the 15 March terrorist attack communities of the 15 March terrorist attack to communities of the 15 March terrorist attack to shape communities of the 15 March terrorist attack to shape ongoing terrorist attack to shape ongoing support terrorist attack to shape ongoing support services terrorist attack to shape ongoing support services for terrorist attack to shape ongoing support services for their terrorist attack to shape ongoing support services for their long-term support services for their long-term recovery support services for their long-term recovery needs. recovery needs. Question recovery needs. Question No. recovery needs. Question No. 9. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Tourism: of Tourism: What of Tourism: What advice, of Tourism: What advice, if of Tourism: What advice, if any, of Tourism: What advice, if any, has of Tourism: What advice, if any, has he of Tourism: What advice, if any, has he received What advice, if any, has he received on What advice, if any, has he received on the What advice, if any, has he received on the forecast What advice, if any, has he received on the forecast benefit on the forecast benefit of on the forecast benefit of a on the forecast benefit of a trans-Tasman on the forecast benefit of a trans-Tasman travel on the forecast benefit of a trans-Tasman travel bubble of a trans-Tasman travel bubble on of a trans-Tasman travel bubble on tourism of a trans-Tasman travel bubble on tourism businesses on tourism businesses in on tourism businesses in New on tourism businesses in New Zealand, in New Zealand, and in New Zealand, and by in New Zealand, and by what in New Zealand, and by what date in New Zealand, and by what date does in New Zealand, and by what date does he in New Zealand, and by what date does he expect in New Zealand, and by what date does he expect a and by what date does he expect a trans-Tasman and by what date does he expect a trans-Tasman bubble and by what date does he expect a trans-Tasman bubble to and by what date does he expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be and by what date does he expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be in and by what date does he expect a trans-Tasman bubble to be in place? For For the For the first For the first part For the first part of For the first part of the For the first part of the question, For the first part of the question, I For the first part of the question, I have For the first part of the question, I have received For the first part of the question, I have received advice For the first part of the question, I have received advice on I have received advice on trans-Tasman I have received advice on trans-Tasman travel, I have received advice on trans-Tasman travel, for I have received advice on trans-Tasman travel, for example, trans-Tasman travel, for example, The trans-Tasman travel, for example, The Treasury trans-Tasman travel, for example, The Treasury has trans-Tasman travel, for example, The Treasury has provided trans-Tasman travel, for example, The Treasury has provided advice The Treasury has provided advice that The Treasury has provided advice that Australians The Treasury has provided advice that Australians contributed The Treasury has provided advice that Australians contributed about that Australians contributed about $2.6 that Australians contributed about $2.6 billion that Australians contributed about $2.6 billion to that Australians contributed about $2.6 billion to the that Australians contributed about $2.6 billion to the New that Australians contributed about $2.6 billion to the New Zealand $2.6 billion to the New Zealand economy, $2.6 billion to the New Zealand economy, but $2.6 billion to the New Zealand economy, but New $2.6 billion to the New Zealand economy, but New Zealanders $2.6 billion to the New Zealand economy, but New Zealanders also economy, but New Zealanders also spent economy, but New Zealanders also spent $2.3 economy, but New Zealanders also spent $2.3 billion economy, but New Zealanders also spent $2.3 billion in economy, but New Zealanders also spent $2.3 billion in Australia. spent $2.3 billion in Australia. I've spent $2.3 billion in Australia. I've also spent $2.3 billion in Australia. I've also received spent $2.3 billion in Australia. I've also received advice spent $2.3 billion in Australia. I've also received advice there spent $2.3 billion in Australia. I've also received advice there has I've also received advice there has been I've also received advice there has been a I've also received advice there has been a surge I've also received advice there has been a surge in I've also received advice there has been a surge in domestic I've also received advice there has been a surge in domestic tourism, been a surge in domestic tourism, and been a surge in domestic tourism, and for been a surge in domestic tourism, and for the been a surge in domestic tourism, and for the month been a surge in domestic tourism, and for the month of been a surge in domestic tourism, and for the month of January been a surge in domestic tourism, and for the month of January 2021, and for the month of January 2021, the and for the month of January 2021, the last and for the month of January 2021, the last month and for the month of January 2021, the last month that and for the month of January 2021, the last month that we and for the month of January 2021, the last month that we have and for the month of January 2021, the last month that we have the the last month that we have the data, the last month that we have the data, domestic the last month that we have the data, domestic tourism the last month that we have the data, domestic tourism was the last month that we have the data, domestic tourism was up the last month that we have the data, domestic tourism was up by data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. In data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. In January data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. In January 2020, data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. In January 2020, with data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. In January 2020, with a data, domestic tourism was up by 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly spend 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly spend of 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly spend of about 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly spend of about $1.16 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly spend of about $1.16 billion. 24%. In January 2020, with a monthly spend of about $1.16 billion. In spend of about $1.16 billion. In some spend of about $1.16 billion. In some areas spend of about $1.16 billion. In some areas like spend of about $1.16 billion. In some areas like Queenstown, spend of about $1.16 billion. In some areas like Queenstown, for some areas like Queenstown, for example, some areas like Queenstown, for example, the some areas like Queenstown, for example, the domestic some areas like Queenstown, for example, the domestic spend some areas like Queenstown, for example, the domestic spend was some areas like Queenstown, for example, the domestic spend was up example, the domestic spend was up by example, the domestic spend was up by 71% example, the domestic spend was up by 71% to example, the domestic spend was up by 71% to $60 example, the domestic spend was up by 71% to $60 million example, the domestic spend was up by 71% to $60 million compared example, the domestic spend was up by 71% to $60 million compared to by 71% to $60 million compared to January by 71% to $60 million compared to January the by 71% to $60 million compared to January the previous by 71% to $60 million compared to January the previous year. by 71% to $60 million compared to January the previous year. I've by 71% to $60 million compared to January the previous year. I've also January the previous year. I've also received January the previous year. I've also received advice January the previous year. I've also received advice the January the previous year. I've also received advice the Government January the previous year. I've also received advice the Government has received advice the Government has provided received advice the Government has provided $400 received advice the Government has provided $400 million received advice the Government has provided $400 million tourism received advice the Government has provided $400 million tourism Rory provided $400 million tourism Rory package provided $400 million tourism Rory package and provided $400 million tourism Rory package and that provided $400 million tourism Rory package and that an provided $400 million tourism Rory package and that an estimated provided $400 million tourism Rory package and that an estimated $1.8 package and that an estimated $1.8 billion package and that an estimated $1.8 billion in package and that an estimated $1.8 billion in wage package and that an estimated $1.8 billion in wage subsidy package and that an estimated $1.8 billion in wage subsidy payments. package and that an estimated $1.8 billion in wage subsidy payments. To billion in wage subsidy payments. To the billion in wage subsidy payments. To the second billion in wage subsidy payments. To the second part billion in wage subsidy payments. To the second part of billion in wage subsidy payments. To the second part of the billion in wage subsidy payments. To the second part of the question, the second part of the question, we've the second part of the question, we've always the second part of the question, we've always maintained the second part of the question, we've always maintained that the second part of the question, we've always maintained that we we've always maintained that we would we've always maintained that we would commence we've always maintained that we would commence a we've always maintained that we would commence a safe we've always maintained that we would commence a safe travel we've always maintained that we would commence a safe travel bubble would commence a safe travel bubble with would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia when would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia when it would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia when it is would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia when it is safe would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia when it is safe to would commence a safe travel bubble with Australia when it is safe to do with Australia when it is safe to do so. with Australia when it is safe to do so. Opening with Australia when it is safe to do so. Opening the with Australia when it is safe to do so. Opening the bubble with Australia when it is safe to do so. Opening the bubble involves so. Opening the bubble involves balancing so. Opening the bubble involves balancing the so. Opening the bubble involves balancing the opportunities so. Opening the bubble involves balancing the opportunities with so. Opening the bubble involves balancing the opportunities with the balancing the opportunities with the risks balancing the opportunities with the risks of balancing the opportunities with the risks of an balancing the opportunities with the risks of an outbreak. balancing the opportunities with the risks of an outbreak. Order! balancing the opportunities with the risks of an outbreak. Order! I balancing the opportunities with the risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't require risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't require you risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't require you to risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't require you to apologise, risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't require you to apologise, but risks of an outbreak. Order! I won't require you to apologise, but please require you to apologise, but please keep require you to apologise, but please keep me require you to apologise, but please keep me out require you to apologise, but please keep me out of require you to apologise, but please keep me out of the require you to apologise, but please keep me out of the debate. require you to apologise, but please keep me out of the debate. Why require you to apologise, but please keep me out of the debate. Why did keep me out of the debate. Why did he keep me out of the debate. Why did he say keep me out of the debate. Why did he say to keep me out of the debate. Why did he say to a keep me out of the debate. Why did he say to a West keep me out of the debate. Why did he say to a West Coast keep me out of the debate. Why did he say to a West Coast community he say to a West Coast community meeting, he say to a West Coast community meeting, "Until he say to a West Coast community meeting, "Until we he say to a West Coast community meeting, "Until we get he say to a West Coast community meeting, "Until we get 70% he say to a West Coast community meeting, "Until we get 70% herd meeting, "Until we get 70% herd immunity meeting, "Until we get 70% herd immunity with meeting, "Until we get 70% herd immunity with the meeting, "Until we get 70% herd immunity with the vaccine, meeting, "Until we get 70% herd immunity with the vaccine, then meeting, "Until we get 70% herd immunity with the vaccine, then the immunity with the vaccine, then the borders immunity with the vaccine, then the borders are immunity with the vaccine, then the borders are not immunity with the vaccine, then the borders are not going immunity with the vaccine, then the borders are not going to immunity with the vaccine, then the borders are not going to open immunity with the vaccine, then the borders are not going to open at borders are not going to open at all, borders are not going to open at all, not borders are not going to open at all, not even borders are not going to open at all, not even with borders are not going to open at all, not even with Australia, borders are not going to open at all, not even with Australia, and all, not even with Australia, and this all, not even with Australia, and this wouldn't all, not even with Australia, and this wouldn't happen all, not even with Australia, and this wouldn't happen until all, not even with Australia, and this wouldn't happen until January this wouldn't happen until January of this wouldn't happen until January of next this wouldn't happen until January of next year, this wouldn't happen until January of next year, if this wouldn't happen until January of next year, if you're this wouldn't happen until January of next year, if you're lucky"? this wouldn't happen until January of next year, if you're lucky"? I of next year, if you're lucky"? I did of next year, if you're lucky"? I did not of next year, if you're lucky"? I did not say of next year, if you're lucky"? I did not say that of next year, if you're lucky"? I did not say that at of next year, if you're lucky"? I did not say that at all. did not say that at all. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> In <INTERRUPTION> In fact, <INTERRUPTION> In fact, in <INTERRUPTION> In fact, in fact, <INTERRUPTION> In fact, in fact, you <INTERRUPTION> In fact, in fact, you can <INTERRUPTION> In fact, in fact, you can ask <INTERRUPTION> In fact, in fact, you can ask my In fact, in fact, you can ask my colleague, In fact, in fact, you can ask my colleague, the In fact, in fact, you can ask my colleague, the Hon In fact, in fact, you can ask my colleague, the Hon Damien In fact, in fact, you can ask my colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who was colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who was there. colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who was there. I colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who was there. I have colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who was there. I have always colleague, the Hon Damien O'Connor, who was there. I have always been who was there. I have always been very, who was there. I have always been very, very who was there. I have always been very, very clear who was there. I have always been very, very clear that who was there. I have always been very, very clear that in who was there. I have always been very, very clear that in terms who was there. I have always been very, very clear that in terms of very, very clear that in terms of opening very, very clear that in terms of opening our very, very clear that in terms of opening our international very, very clear that in terms of opening our international borders very, very clear that in terms of opening our international borders to opening our international borders to tourists, opening our international borders to tourists, we opening our international borders to tourists, we are opening our international borders to tourists, we are probably opening our international borders to tourists, we are probably not opening our international borders to tourists, we are probably not gonna tourists, we are probably not gonna see tourists, we are probably not gonna see them tourists, we are probably not gonna see them in tourists, we are probably not gonna see them in our tourists, we are probably not gonna see them in our country tourists, we are probably not gonna see them in our country until tourists, we are probably not gonna see them in our country until next see them in our country until next year. see them in our country until next year. However, see them in our country until next year. However, I see them in our country until next year. However, I have see them in our country until next year. However, I have always see them in our country until next year. However, I have always been year. However, I have always been clear year. However, I have always been clear about year. However, I have always been clear about this, year. However, I have always been clear about this, the year. However, I have always been clear about this, the Government year. However, I have always been clear about this, the Government is clear about this, the Government is working clear about this, the Government is working incredibly clear about this, the Government is working incredibly hard clear about this, the Government is working incredibly hard on clear about this, the Government is working incredibly hard on a working incredibly hard on a trans-Tasman working incredibly hard on a trans-Tasman bubble. working incredibly hard on a trans-Tasman bubble. What working incredibly hard on a trans-Tasman bubble. What is working incredibly hard on a trans-Tasman bubble. What is his trans-Tasman bubble. What is his response trans-Tasman bubble. What is his response to trans-Tasman bubble. What is his response to the trans-Tasman bubble. What is his response to the Auckland trans-Tasman bubble. What is his response to the Auckland Airport trans-Tasman bubble. What is his response to the Auckland Airport CEO response to the Auckland Airport CEO Adrian response to the Auckland Airport CEO Adrian Littlewood, response to the Auckland Airport CEO Adrian Littlewood, who response to the Auckland Airport CEO Adrian Littlewood, who said response to the Auckland Airport CEO Adrian Littlewood, who said there Adrian Littlewood, who said there was Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real risk Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real risk that Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real risk that we Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real risk that we as Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real risk that we as a Adrian Littlewood, who said there was "real risk that we as a country was "real risk that we as a country will was "real risk that we as a country will be was "real risk that we as a country will be left was "real risk that we as a country will be left behind was "real risk that we as a country will be left behind while was "real risk that we as a country will be left behind while the was "real risk that we as a country will be left behind while the rest will be left behind while the rest of will be left behind while the rest of the will be left behind while the rest of the world will be left behind while the rest of the world gets will be left behind while the rest of the world gets on" will be left behind while the rest of the world gets on" in will be left behind while the rest of the world gets on" in respect will be left behind while the rest of the world gets on" in respect of of the world gets on" in respect of tourism? of the world gets on" in respect of tourism? It's of the world gets on" in respect of tourism? It's Mr of the world gets on" in respect of tourism? It's Mr Littlewood's tourism? It's Mr Littlewood's opinion. opinion. Order! opinion. Order! That's opinion. Order! That's not opinion. Order! That's not kind opinion. Order! That's not kind to opinion. Order! That's not kind to either opinion. Order! That's not kind to either of Order! That's not kind to either of them. Order! That's not kind to either of them. To Order! That's not kind to either of them. To the Order! That's not kind to either of them. To the Minister: Order! That's not kind to either of them. To the Minister: What Order! That's not kind to either of them. To the Minister: What is Order! That's not kind to either of them. To the Minister: What is his them. To the Minister: What is his response them. To the Minister: What is his response to them. To the Minister: What is his response to Queenstown them. To the Minister: What is his response to Queenstown Mayor them. To the Minister: What is his response to Queenstown Mayor Jim response to Queenstown Mayor Jim Bolt response to Queenstown Mayor Jim Bolt in response to Queenstown Mayor Jim Bolt in respect response to Queenstown Mayor Jim Bolt in respect of response to Queenstown Mayor Jim Bolt in respect of a response to Queenstown Mayor Jim Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman bubble, Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman bubble, who Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman bubble, who said Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman bubble, who said yesterday, Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman bubble, who said yesterday, and Bolt in respect of a trans-Tasman bubble, who said yesterday, and I bubble, who said yesterday, and I quote, bubble, who said yesterday, and I quote, "Right bubble, who said yesterday, and I quote, "Right now bubble, who said yesterday, and I quote, "Right now businesses bubble, who said yesterday, and I quote, "Right now businesses are quote, "Right now businesses are looking quote, "Right now businesses are looking down quote, "Right now businesses are looking down a quote, "Right now businesses are looking down a black quote, "Right now businesses are looking down a black hole. quote, "Right now businesses are looking down a black hole. There's looking down a black hole. There's no looking down a black hole. There's no light looking down a black hole. There's no light at looking down a black hole. There's no light at the looking down a black hole. There's no light at the end looking down a black hole. There's no light at the end of looking down a black hole. There's no light at the end of it. looking down a black hole. There's no light at the end of it. If looking down a black hole. There's no light at the end of it. If they no light at the end of it. If they know no light at the end of it. If they know a no light at the end of it. If they know a date no light at the end of it. If they know a date in no light at the end of it. If they know a date in which no light at the end of it. If they know a date in which they no light at the end of it. If they know a date in which they are no light at the end of it. If they know a date in which they are likely know a date in which they are likely to know a date in which they are likely to get know a date in which they are likely to get going know a date in which they are likely to get going again, know a date in which they are likely to get going again, they know a date in which they are likely to get going again, they can know a date in which they are likely to get going again, they can talk know a date in which they are likely to get going again, they can talk to to get going again, they can talk to their to get going again, they can talk to their bank, to get going again, they can talk to their bank, they to get going again, they can talk to their bank, they can to get going again, they can talk to their bank, they can talk to get going again, they can talk to their bank, they can talk to to get going again, they can talk to their bank, they can talk to their their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, and their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, and find their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, and find a their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, and find a way their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, and find a way to their bank, they can talk to their lawyers, and find a way to scrape lawyers, and find a way to scrape through"? lawyers, and find a way to scrape through"? I'm lawyers, and find a way to scrape through"? I'm aware lawyers, and find a way to scrape through"? I'm aware there lawyers, and find a way to scrape through"? I'm aware there are lawyers, and find a way to scrape through"? I'm aware there are a through"? I'm aware there are a number through"? I'm aware there are a number of through"? I'm aware there are a number of businesses through"? I'm aware there are a number of businesses that through"? I'm aware there are a number of businesses that are through"? I'm aware there are a number of businesses that are doing number of businesses that are doing it number of businesses that are doing it really number of businesses that are doing it really tough number of businesses that are doing it really tough in number of businesses that are doing it really tough in Queenstown. number of businesses that are doing it really tough in Queenstown. I've it really tough in Queenstown. I've always it really tough in Queenstown. I've always acknowledged it really tough in Queenstown. I've always acknowledged that. it really tough in Queenstown. I've always acknowledged that. I it really tough in Queenstown. I've always acknowledged that. I also always acknowledged that. I also acknowledge always acknowledged that. I also acknowledge that always acknowledged that. I also acknowledge that Queenstown always acknowledged that. I also acknowledge that Queenstown at always acknowledged that. I also acknowledge that Queenstown at this acknowledge that Queenstown at this point acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in time acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in time is acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in time is a acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in time is a bit acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in time is a bit of acknowledge that Queenstown at this point in time is a bit of a point in time is a bit of a two-speed point in time is a bit of a two-speed economy. point in time is a bit of a two-speed economy. You've point in time is a bit of a two-speed economy. You've got point in time is a bit of a two-speed economy. You've got some two-speed economy. You've got some areas, two-speed economy. You've got some areas, like two-speed economy. You've got some areas, like infrastructure, two-speed economy. You've got some areas, like infrastructure, like areas, like infrastructure, like construction, areas, like infrastructure, like construction, that areas, like infrastructure, like construction, that are areas, like infrastructure, like construction, that are doing areas, like infrastructure, like construction, that are doing quite construction, that are doing quite well. construction, that are doing quite well. About construction, that are doing quite well. About 3.9% construction, that are doing quite well. About 3.9% unemployment construction, that are doing quite well. About 3.9% unemployment in well. About 3.9% unemployment in Queenstown. well. About 3.9% unemployment in Queenstown. But well. About 3.9% unemployment in Queenstown. But I'm well. About 3.9% unemployment in Queenstown. But I'm also well. About 3.9% unemployment in Queenstown. But I'm also aware well. About 3.9% unemployment in Queenstown. But I'm also aware and Queenstown. But I'm also aware and I've Queenstown. But I'm also aware and I've acknowledged Queenstown. But I'm also aware and I've acknowledged that Queenstown. But I'm also aware and I've acknowledged that a Queenstown. But I'm also aware and I've acknowledged that a number Queenstown. But I'm also aware and I've acknowledged that a number of I've acknowledged that a number of businesses I've acknowledged that a number of businesses that I've acknowledged that a number of businesses that have I've acknowledged that a number of businesses that have really businesses that have really struggled businesses that have really struggled to businesses that have really struggled to morph businesses that have really struggled to morph from businesses that have really struggled to morph from a businesses that have really struggled to morph from a pure businesses that have really struggled to morph from a pure focus struggled to morph from a pure focus on struggled to morph from a pure focus on international struggled to morph from a pure focus on international to struggled to morph from a pure focus on international to a struggled to morph from a pure focus on international to a domestic on international to a domestic market on international to a domestic market are on international to a domestic market are struggling. on international to a domestic market are struggling. As on international to a domestic market are struggling. As mentioned, market are struggling. As mentioned, domestic market are struggling. As mentioned, domestic spend market are struggling. As mentioned, domestic spend in market are struggling. As mentioned, domestic spend in Queenstown market are struggling. As mentioned, domestic spend in Queenstown for domestic spend in Queenstown for January domestic spend in Queenstown for January was domestic spend in Queenstown for January was up domestic spend in Queenstown for January was up by domestic spend in Queenstown for January was up by over domestic spend in Queenstown for January was up by over 70%. January was up by over 70%. Has January was up by over 70%. Has he January was up by over 70%. Has he asked January was up by over 70%. Has he asked for January was up by over 70%. Has he asked for advice January was up by over 70%. Has he asked for advice on January was up by over 70%. Has he asked for advice on the Has he asked for advice on the number Has he asked for advice on the number of Has he asked for advice on the number of tourism Has he asked for advice on the number of tourism business Has he asked for advice on the number of tourism business closures number of tourism business closures and number of tourism business closures and job number of tourism business closures and job losses number of tourism business closures and job losses that number of tourism business closures and job losses that would number of tourism business closures and job losses that would occur number of tourism business closures and job losses that would occur if and job losses that would occur if New and job losses that would occur if New Zealand and job losses that would occur if New Zealand was and job losses that would occur if New Zealand was to and job losses that would occur if New Zealand was to stay and job losses that would occur if New Zealand was to stay closed and job losses that would occur if New Zealand was to stay closed to New Zealand was to stay closed to Australian New Zealand was to stay closed to Australian visitors New Zealand was to stay closed to Australian visitors until New Zealand was to stay closed to Australian visitors until January New Zealand was to stay closed to Australian visitors until January of Australian visitors until January of next Australian visitors until January of next year, Australian visitors until January of next year, as Australian visitors until January of next year, as he Australian visitors until January of next year, as he stated Australian visitors until January of next year, as he stated in Australian visitors until January of next year, as he stated in a Australian visitors until January of next year, as he stated in a public next year, as he stated in a public meeting, next year, as he stated in a public meeting, and next year, as he stated in a public meeting, and in next year, as he stated in a public meeting, and in particular...? meeting, and in particular...? Order! meeting, and in particular...? Order! I meeting, and in particular...? Order! I just meeting, and in particular...? Order! I just want meeting, and in particular...? Order! I just want to meeting, and in particular...? Order! I just want to make Order! I just want to make absolutely Order! I just want to make absolutely clear, Order! I just want to make absolutely clear, we've Order! I just want to make absolutely clear, we've had Order! I just want to make absolutely clear, we've had an absolutely clear, we've had an assurance absolutely clear, we've had an assurance from absolutely clear, we've had an assurance from a absolutely clear, we've had an assurance from a Minister absolutely clear, we've had an assurance from a Minister that absolutely clear, we've had an assurance from a Minister that he assurance from a Minister that he did assurance from a Minister that he did not assurance from a Minister that he did not make assurance from a Minister that he did not make a assurance from a Minister that he did not make a statement. assurance from a Minister that he did not make a statement. I'm assurance from a Minister that he did not make a statement. I'm just did not make a statement. I'm just making did not make a statement. I'm just making clear did not make a statement. I'm just making clear that did not make a statement. I'm just making clear that this did not make a statement. I'm just making clear that this is did not make a statement. I'm just making clear that this is a making clear that this is a different making clear that this is a different statement making clear that this is a different statement and making clear that this is a different statement and not making clear that this is a different statement and not the making clear that this is a different statement and not the same different statement and not the same statement? different statement and not the same statement? You've different statement and not the same statement? You've had different statement and not the same statement? You've had a different statement and not the same statement? You've had a clear statement? You've had a clear assurance statement? You've had a clear assurance from statement? You've had a clear assurance from a statement? You've had a clear assurance from a Minister statement? You've had a clear assurance from a Minister on statement? You've had a clear assurance from a Minister on the assurance from a Minister on the subject. assurance from a Minister on the subject. You assurance from a Minister on the subject. You stopped assurance from a Minister on the subject. You stopped me, assurance from a Minister on the subject. You stopped me, Mr assurance from a Minister on the subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before I subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before I said, subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before I said, "As subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before I said, "As reported subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before I said, "As reported in subject. You stopped me, Mr Speaker, before I said, "As reported in the before I said, "As reported in the media". before I said, "As reported in the media". Well, before I said, "As reported in the media". Well, I before I said, "As reported in the media". Well, I think... before I said, "As reported in the media". Well, I think... Continue. before I said, "As reported in the media". Well, I think... Continue. media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as reported media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as reported in media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as reported in the media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as reported in the media, media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as reported in the media, and media". Well, I think... Continue. ..as reported in the media, and in ..as reported in the media, and in particular ..as reported in the media, and in particular that ..as reported in the media, and in particular that domestic ..as reported in the media, and in particular that domestic tourists particular that domestic tourists that particular that domestic tourists that - particular that domestic tourists that - in particular that domestic tourists that - in particular, particular that domestic tourists that - in particular, that particular that domestic tourists that - in particular, that domestic that - in particular, that domestic tourism that - in particular, that domestic tourism spend that - in particular, that domestic tourism spend would that - in particular, that domestic tourism spend would have that - in particular, that domestic tourism spend would have to that - in particular, that domestic tourism spend would have to increase tourism spend would have to increase by tourism spend would have to increase by 72% tourism spend would have to increase by 72% just tourism spend would have to increase by 72% just to tourism spend would have to increase by 72% just to draw tourism spend would have to increase by 72% just to draw even tourism spend would have to increase by 72% just to draw even with tourism spend would have to increase by 72% just to draw even with the by 72% just to draw even with the loss by 72% just to draw even with the loss of by 72% just to draw even with the loss of international by 72% just to draw even with the loss of international spend? by 72% just to draw even with the loss of international spend? One loss of international spend? One thing loss of international spend? One thing I loss of international spend? One thing I would loss of international spend? One thing I would say loss of international spend? One thing I would say is loss of international spend? One thing I would say is I loss of international spend? One thing I would say is I am loss of international spend? One thing I would say is I am always thing I would say is I am always very thing I would say is I am always very clear thing I would say is I am always very clear when thing I would say is I am always very clear when I thing I would say is I am always very clear when I talk thing I would say is I am always very clear when I talk about thing I would say is I am always very clear when I talk about tourism very clear when I talk about tourism going very clear when I talk about tourism going forward very clear when I talk about tourism going forward that very clear when I talk about tourism going forward that we very clear when I talk about tourism going forward that we will very clear when I talk about tourism going forward that we will not very clear when I talk about tourism going forward that we will not see going forward that we will not see tour going forward that we will not see tour buses going forward that we will not see tour buses with going forward that we will not see tour buses with British, going forward that we will not see tour buses with British, German, tour buses with British, German, Chinese, tour buses with British, German, Chinese, Japanese tour buses with British, German, Chinese, Japanese tourists tour buses with British, German, Chinese, Japanese tourists up tour buses with British, German, Chinese, Japanese tourists up and Chinese, Japanese tourists up and down Chinese, Japanese tourists up and down our Chinese, Japanese tourists up and down our motorways Chinese, Japanese tourists up and down our motorways this Chinese, Japanese tourists up and down our motorways this year. down our motorways this year. However, down our motorways this year. However, I down our motorways this year. However, I am down our motorways this year. However, I am always down our motorways this year. However, I am always very down our motorways this year. However, I am always very clear down our motorways this year. However, I am always very clear to However, I am always very clear to say However, I am always very clear to say the However, I am always very clear to say the Government However, I am always very clear to say the Government is However, I am always very clear to say the Government is working say the Government is working incredibly say the Government is working incredibly hard say the Government is working incredibly hard to say the Government is working incredibly hard to open say the Government is working incredibly hard to open up say the Government is working incredibly hard to open up a incredibly hard to open up a trans-Tasman incredibly hard to open up a trans-Tasman bubble incredibly hard to open up a trans-Tasman bubble with incredibly hard to open up a trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I stand trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I stand by trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I stand by that. trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I stand by that. And trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I stand by that. And if, trans-Tasman bubble with Australia, and I stand by that. And if, in and I stand by that. And if, in fact, and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that was and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that was what and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that was what was and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that was what was said and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that was what was said in and I stand by that. And if, in fact, that was what was said in the fact, that was what was said in the media, fact, that was what was said in the media, I fact, that was what was said in the media, I was fact, that was what was said in the media, I was absolutely fact, that was what was said in the media, I was absolutely misquoted media, I was absolutely misquoted and media, I was absolutely misquoted and I media, I was absolutely misquoted and I refute media, I was absolutely misquoted and I refute that. media, I was absolutely misquoted and I refute that. The media, I was absolutely misquoted and I refute that. The Hon media, I was absolutely misquoted and I refute that. The Hon Grant and I refute that. The Hon Grant Robertson. and I refute that. The Hon Grant Robertson. Which and I refute that. The Hon Grant Robertson. Which approach and I refute that. The Hon Grant Robertson. Which approach does and I refute that. The Hon Grant Robertson. Which approach does the Robertson. Which approach does the member Robertson. Which approach does the member think Robertson. Which approach does the member think would Robertson. Which approach does the member think would be Robertson. Which approach does the member think would be better Robertson. Which approach does the member think would be better overall member think would be better overall for member think would be better overall for the member think would be better overall for the tourism member think would be better overall for the tourism industry? member think would be better overall for the tourism industry? One member think would be better overall for the tourism industry? One where for the tourism industry? One where a for the tourism industry? One where a Government for the tourism industry? One where a Government sticks for the tourism industry? One where a Government sticks to for the tourism industry? One where a Government sticks to a for the tourism industry? One where a Government sticks to a plan for the tourism industry? One where a Government sticks to a plan of for the tourism industry? One where a Government sticks to a plan of an a Government sticks to a plan of an elimination a Government sticks to a plan of an elimination strategy a Government sticks to a plan of an elimination strategy that a Government sticks to a plan of an elimination strategy that sees elimination strategy that sees domestic elimination strategy that sees domestic tourism elimination strategy that sees domestic tourism able elimination strategy that sees domestic tourism able to elimination strategy that sees domestic tourism able to operate elimination strategy that sees domestic tourism able to operate at domestic tourism able to operate at almost domestic tourism able to operate at almost normal domestic tourism able to operate at almost normal and domestic tourism able to operate at almost normal and even domestic tourism able to operate at almost normal and even above domestic tourism able to operate at almost normal and even above levels? almost normal and even above levels? Or almost normal and even above levels? Or an almost normal and even above levels? Or an approach almost normal and even above levels? Or an approach which almost normal and even above levels? Or an approach which flip-flops, Or an approach which flip-flops, with Or an approach which flip-flops, with the Or an approach which flip-flops, with the border Or an approach which flip-flops, with the border opening Or an approach which flip-flops, with the border opening or Or an approach which flip-flops, with the border opening or closing with the border opening or closing depending with the border opening or closing depending on with the border opening or closing depending on who with the border opening or closing depending on who the with the border opening or closing depending on who the Opposition depending on who the Opposition Leader depending on who the Opposition Leader was. depending on who the Opposition Leader was. Order! depending on who the Opposition Leader was. Order! Supplementary Leader was. Order! Supplementary question? Leader was. Order! Supplementary question? No. Leader was. Order! Supplementary question? No. Right. Leader was. Order! Supplementary question? No. Right. Question Leader was. Order! Supplementary question? No. Right. Question No. question? No. Right. Question No. 10. question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena koe. question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena koe. Order! question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena koe. Order! We question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena koe. Order! We have question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a question? No. Right. Question No. 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of order. 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of order. 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of order. ..why 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of order. ..why you 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of order. ..why you removed 10. Tena koe. Order! We have a point of order. ..why you removed two of order. ..why you removed two supplementary of order. ..why you removed two supplementary questions of order. ..why you removed two supplementary questions from supplementary questions from Nationals' supplementary questions from Nationals' allocation supplementary questions from Nationals' allocation during supplementary questions from Nationals' allocation during that Nationals' allocation during that last Nationals' allocation during that last question? Nationals' allocation during that last question? No, Nationals' allocation during that last question? No, I Nationals' allocation during that last question? No, I took Nationals' allocation during that last question? No, I took one Nationals' allocation during that last question? No, I took one from last question? No, I took one from the last question? No, I took one from the National last question? No, I took one from the National Party last question? No, I took one from the National Party allocation, last question? No, I took one from the National Party allocation, and the National Party allocation, and the the National Party allocation, and the reason the National Party allocation, and the reason was the National Party allocation, and the reason was there the National Party allocation, and the reason was there was the National Party allocation, and the reason was there was an the reason was there was an interjection the reason was there was an interjection while the reason was there was an interjection while a the reason was there was an interjection while a member the reason was there was an interjection while a member was interjection while a member was asking interjection while a member was asking a interjection while a member was asking a supplementary interjection while a member was asking a supplementary question. interjection while a member was asking a supplementary question. It asking a supplementary question. It could asking a supplementary question. It could be asking a supplementary question. It could be described asking a supplementary question. It could be described as asking a supplementary question. It could be described as a asking a supplementary question. It could be described as a guffaw asking a supplementary question. It could be described as a guffaw that could be described as a guffaw that came could be described as a guffaw that came from could be described as a guffaw that came from the could be described as a guffaw that came from the direction could be described as a guffaw that came from the direction of could be described as a guffaw that came from the direction of the came from the direction of the member. came from the direction of the member. In came from the direction of the member. In the came from the direction of the member. In the process came from the direction of the member. In the process of came from the direction of the member. In the process of Mr came from the direction of the member. In the process of Mr McLean member. In the process of Mr McLean asking member. In the process of Mr McLean asking that member. In the process of Mr McLean asking that question, member. In the process of Mr McLean asking that question, a member. In the process of Mr McLean asking that question, a loud member. In the process of Mr McLean asking that question, a loud voice asking that question, a loud voice yelled asking that question, a loud voice yelled out asking that question, a loud voice yelled out something yelled out something unparliamentary, yelled out something unparliamentary, and yelled out something unparliamentary, and there yelled out something unparliamentary, and there was unparliamentary, and there was absolutely unparliamentary, and there was absolutely no unparliamentary, and there was absolutely no consequence unparliamentary, and there was absolutely no consequence for unparliamentary, and there was absolutely no consequence for that. absolutely no consequence for that. Well, absolutely no consequence for that. Well, actually, absolutely no consequence for that. Well, actually, there absolutely no consequence for that. Well, actually, there was. absolutely no consequence for that. Well, actually, there was. The Well, actually, there was. The member's Well, actually, there was. The member's team Well, actually, there was. The member's team got Well, actually, there was. The member's team got an Well, actually, there was. The member's team got an extra Well, actually, there was. The member's team got an extra question. member's team got an extra question. Is member's team got an extra question. Is the member's team got an extra question. Is the member member's team got an extra question. Is the member finished member's team got an extra question. Is the member finished now? member's team got an extra question. Is the member finished now? Question Is the member finished now? Question No. Is the member finished now? Question No. 10, Is the member finished now? Question No. 10, Shanan Is the member finished now? Question No. 10, Shanan Halbert. Is the member finished now? Question No. 10, Shanan Halbert. Tena Is the member finished now? Question No. 10, Shanan Halbert. Tena koe. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Transport: of Transport: What of Transport: What recent of Transport: What recent announcement of Transport: What recent announcement has of Transport: What recent announcement has he of Transport: What recent announcement has he made What recent announcement has he made about What recent announcement has he made about investment What recent announcement has he made about investment in What recent announcement has he made about investment in Auckland about investment in Auckland transport? The The Hon The Hon Michael The Hon Michael Wood. The Hon Michael Wood. On The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself and The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself and so The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself and so on The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself and so on Auckland The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself and so on Auckland Mayor The Hon Michael Wood. On Friday, myself and so on Auckland Mayor Phil myself and so on Auckland Mayor Phil Goff myself and so on Auckland Mayor Phil Goff announced myself and so on Auckland Mayor Phil Goff announced the myself and so on Auckland Mayor Phil Goff announced the Auckland Goff announced the Auckland Transport Goff announced the Auckland Transport Alignment Goff announced the Auckland Transport Alignment Project, Goff announced the Auckland Transport Alignment Project, ATAP, Transport Alignment Project, ATAP, 2021/31 Transport Alignment Project, ATAP, 2021/31 package, Transport Alignment Project, ATAP, 2021/31 package, which Transport Alignment Project, ATAP, 2021/31 package, which invests Transport Alignment Project, ATAP, 2021/31 package, which invests $31 2021/31 package, which invests $31 billion 2021/31 package, which invests $31 billion into 2021/31 package, which invests $31 billion into services 2021/31 package, which invests $31 billion into services across billion into services across Auckland. billion into services across Auckland. For billion into services across Auckland. For the billion into services across Auckland. For the first billion into services across Auckland. For the first time billion into services across Auckland. For the first time ever, Auckland. For the first time ever, we're Auckland. For the first time ever, we're turning Auckland. For the first time ever, we're turning around Auckland. For the first time ever, we're turning around the Auckland. For the first time ever, we're turning around the average we're turning around the average transport we're turning around the average transport emissions we're turning around the average transport emissions of we're turning around the average transport emissions of Aucklanders. transport emissions of Aucklanders. The transport emissions of Aucklanders. The ATAP2021/31 transport emissions of Aucklanders. The ATAP2021/31 package transport emissions of Aucklanders. The ATAP2021/31 package alone transport emissions of Aucklanders. The ATAP2021/31 package alone will The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result in The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result in a The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result in a 13% The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result in a 13% decrease The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result in a 13% decrease in The ATAP2021/31 package alone will result in a 13% decrease in the result in a 13% decrease in the emissions result in a 13% decrease in the emissions per result in a 13% decrease in the emissions per capita result in a 13% decrease in the emissions per capita of result in a 13% decrease in the emissions per capita of Aucklanders emissions per capita of Aucklanders using emissions per capita of Aucklanders using the emissions per capita of Aucklanders using the transport emissions per capita of Aucklanders using the transport system emissions per capita of Aucklanders using the transport system when using the transport system when compared using the transport system when compared to using the transport system when compared to the using the transport system when compared to the previous using the transport system when compared to the previous package. compared to the previous package. And compared to the previous package. And it's compared to the previous package. And it's projected compared to the previous package. And it's projected to compared to the previous package. And it's projected to increase And it's projected to increase public And it's projected to increase public transport And it's projected to increase public transport trips And it's projected to increase public transport trips by And it's projected to increase public transport trips by 91% And it's projected to increase public transport trips by 91% over public transport trips by 91% over the public transport trips by 91% over the forecast public transport trips by 91% over the forecast period. public transport trips by 91% over the forecast period. There's public transport trips by 91% over the forecast period. There's much the forecast period. There's much more the forecast period. There's much more to the forecast period. There's much more to do the forecast period. There's much more to do to the forecast period. There's much more to do to decarbonise the forecast period. There's much more to do to decarbonise our more to do to decarbonise our transport more to do to decarbonise our transport system. more to do to decarbonise our transport system. It's more to do to decarbonise our transport system. It's also transport system. It's also projected transport system. It's also projected to transport system. It's also projected to reduce transport system. It's also projected to reduce the transport system. It's also projected to reduce the Auckland projected to reduce the Auckland road projected to reduce the Auckland road toll projected to reduce the Auckland road toll by projected to reduce the Auckland road toll by 65% projected to reduce the Auckland road toll by 65% by projected to reduce the Auckland road toll by 65% by 2031, projected to reduce the Auckland road toll by 65% by 2031, or projected to reduce the Auckland road toll by 65% by 2031, or around road toll by 65% by 2031, or around 1,700 road toll by 65% by 2031, or around 1,700 fewer road toll by 65% by 2031, or around 1,700 fewer deaths road toll by 65% by 2031, or around 1,700 fewer deaths and road toll by 65% by 2031, or around 1,700 fewer deaths and serious 1,700 fewer deaths and serious injuries 1,700 fewer deaths and serious injuries over 1,700 fewer deaths and serious injuries over the 1,700 fewer deaths and serious injuries over the decade. injuries over the decade. What injuries over the decade. What projects injuries over the decade. What projects does injuries over the decade. What projects does the injuries over the decade. What projects does the package What projects does the package include? What projects does the package include? There What projects does the package include? There are What projects does the package include? There are a What projects does the package include? There are a number What projects does the package include? There are a number of include? There are a number of projects include? There are a number of projects already include? There are a number of projects already under include? There are a number of projects already under way include? There are a number of projects already under way which include? There are a number of projects already under way which are projects already under way which are helping projects already under way which are helping with projects already under way which are helping with our projects already under way which are helping with our economic projects already under way which are helping with our economic recovery helping with our economic recovery and helping with our economic recovery and which helping with our economic recovery and which will helping with our economic recovery and which will reduce helping with our economic recovery and which will reduce conjection, and which will reduce conjection, like and which will reduce conjection, like the and which will reduce conjection, like the Glen and which will reduce conjection, like the Glen Innes and which will reduce conjection, like the Glen Innes to and which will reduce conjection, like the Glen Innes to Tamaki and which will reduce conjection, like the Glen Innes to Tamaki Drive like the Glen Innes to Tamaki Drive shared like the Glen Innes to Tamaki Drive shared path, like the Glen Innes to Tamaki Drive shared path, the like the Glen Innes to Tamaki Drive shared path, the third like the Glen Innes to Tamaki Drive shared path, the third main shared path, the third main railline, shared path, the third main railline, upgrades shared path, the third main railline, upgrades to shared path, the third main railline, upgrades to State shared path, the third main railline, upgrades to State Highway railline, upgrades to State Highway 20B railline, upgrades to State Highway 20B and railline, upgrades to State Highway 20B and the railline, upgrades to State Highway 20B and the northern railline, upgrades to State Highway 20B and the northern busway 20B and the northern busway extension. 20B and the northern busway extension. The 20B and the northern busway extension. The regional 20B and the northern busway extension. The regional fuel 20B and the northern busway extension. The regional fuel tax 20B and the northern busway extension. The regional fuel tax has extension. The regional fuel tax has meant extension. The regional fuel tax has meant projects extension. The regional fuel tax has meant projects in extension. The regional fuel tax has meant projects in ATAP extension. The regional fuel tax has meant projects in ATAP like extension. The regional fuel tax has meant projects in ATAP like the meant projects in ATAP like the Eastern meant projects in ATAP like the Eastern busway, meant projects in ATAP like the Eastern busway, and meant projects in ATAP like the Eastern busway, and the meant projects in ATAP like the Eastern busway, and the downtown Eastern busway, and the downtown ferry Eastern busway, and the downtown ferry terminal Eastern busway, and the downtown ferry terminal redevelopment, Eastern busway, and the downtown ferry terminal redevelopment, could ferry terminal redevelopment, could get ferry terminal redevelopment, could get under ferry terminal redevelopment, could get under way. ferry terminal redevelopment, could get under way. I'm ferry terminal redevelopment, could get under way. I'm looking ferry terminal redevelopment, could get under way. I'm looking forward get under way. I'm looking forward to get under way. I'm looking forward to seeing get under way. I'm looking forward to seeing work get under way. I'm looking forward to seeing work start get under way. I'm looking forward to seeing work start on get under way. I'm looking forward to seeing work start on the to seeing work start on the north-west to seeing work start on the north-west bus to seeing work start on the north-west bus improvements, north-west bus improvements, removing north-west bus improvements, removing level north-west bus improvements, removing level crossings north-west bus improvements, removing level crossings and north-west bus improvements, removing level crossings and new removing level crossings and new trains, removing level crossings and new trains, to removing level crossings and new trains, to make removing level crossings and new trains, to make sure removing level crossings and new trains, to make sure that removing level crossings and new trains, to make sure that we removing level crossings and new trains, to make sure that we get removing level crossings and new trains, to make sure that we get the trains, to make sure that we get the full trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits of trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits of the trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits of the CRL trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits of the CRL as trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits of the CRL as soon trains, to make sure that we get the full benefits of the CRL as soon as full benefits of the CRL as soon as it's full benefits of the CRL as soon as it's finished. full benefits of the CRL as soon as it's finished. What full benefits of the CRL as soon as it's finished. What ATAP full benefits of the CRL as soon as it's finished. What ATAP initiatives it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will help it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will help those it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will help those on it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will help those on lower it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will help those on lower incomes it's finished. What ATAP initiatives will help those on lower incomes get will help those on lower incomes get around? will help those on lower incomes get around? Well, will help those on lower incomes get around? Well, I will help those on lower incomes get around? Well, I was will help those on lower incomes get around? Well, I was extremely around? Well, I was extremely pleased around? Well, I was extremely pleased on around? Well, I was extremely pleased on Friday around? Well, I was extremely pleased on Friday to around? Well, I was extremely pleased on Friday to be around? Well, I was extremely pleased on Friday to be able around? Well, I was extremely pleased on Friday to be able to pleased on Friday to be able to announce pleased on Friday to be able to announce the pleased on Friday to be able to announce the Community pleased on Friday to be able to announce the Community Connect announce the Community Connect Concession announce the Community Connect Concession Card announce the Community Connect Concession Card pilot, announce the Community Connect Concession Card pilot, which announce the Community Connect Concession Card pilot, which will Concession Card pilot, which will reduce Concession Card pilot, which will reduce public Concession Card pilot, which will reduce public transport Concession Card pilot, which will reduce public transport fares Concession Card pilot, which will reduce public transport fares by Concession Card pilot, which will reduce public transport fares by 50% reduce public transport fares by 50% for reduce public transport fares by 50% for holders reduce public transport fares by 50% for holders of reduce public transport fares by 50% for holders of a reduce public transport fares by 50% for holders of a Community reduce public transport fares by 50% for holders of a Community Service for holders of a Community Service Card for holders of a Community Service Card in for holders of a Community Service Card in Auckland. for holders of a Community Service Card in Auckland. This for holders of a Community Service Card in Auckland. This will for holders of a Community Service Card in Auckland. This will mean Card in Auckland. This will mean around Card in Auckland. This will mean around 2.7 Card in Auckland. This will mean around 2.7 million Card in Auckland. This will mean around 2.7 million more Card in Auckland. This will mean around 2.7 million more public around 2.7 million more public transport around 2.7 million more public transport trips around 2.7 million more public transport trips around around 2.7 million more public transport trips around Auckland around 2.7 million more public transport trips around Auckland in transport trips around Auckland in its transport trips around Auckland in its first transport trips around Auckland in its first year, transport trips around Auckland in its first year, reducing transport trips around Auckland in its first year, reducing congestion, its first year, reducing congestion, reducing its first year, reducing congestion, reducing emissions, its first year, reducing congestion, reducing emissions, and its first year, reducing congestion, reducing emissions, and reducing reducing emissions, and reducing transport reducing emissions, and reducing transport poverty reducing emissions, and reducing transport poverty in reducing emissions, and reducing transport poverty in our reducing emissions, and reducing transport poverty in our biggest transport poverty in our biggest city. transport poverty in our biggest city. Officials transport poverty in our biggest city. Officials have transport poverty in our biggest city. Officials have advised transport poverty in our biggest city. Officials have advised this city. Officials have advised this project city. Officials have advised this project will city. Officials have advised this project will be city. Officials have advised this project will be ready city. Officials have advised this project will be ready to city. Officials have advised this project will be ready to roll city. Officials have advised this project will be ready to roll out city. Officials have advised this project will be ready to roll out by project will be ready to roll out by around project will be ready to roll out by around about project will be ready to roll out by around about mid-2022, project will be ready to roll out by around about mid-2022, and project will be ready to roll out by around about mid-2022, and I'll project will be ready to roll out by around about mid-2022, and I'll be around about mid-2022, and I'll be working around about mid-2022, and I'll be working hard around about mid-2022, and I'll be working hard to around about mid-2022, and I'll be working hard to see around about mid-2022, and I'll be working hard to see it around about mid-2022, and I'll be working hard to see it implemented working hard to see it implemented as working hard to see it implemented as quickly working hard to see it implemented as quickly as working hard to see it implemented as quickly as possible. working hard to see it implemented as quickly as possible. And as quickly as possible. And depending as quickly as possible. And depending on as quickly as possible. And depending on its as quickly as possible. And depending on its success, as quickly as possible. And depending on its success, to depending on its success, to consider depending on its success, to consider rolling depending on its success, to consider rolling it depending on its success, to consider rolling it out depending on its success, to consider rolling it out further consider rolling it out further across consider rolling it out further across the consider rolling it out further across the country. across the country. Julie across the country. Julie Anne across the country. Julie Anne Genter. across the country. Julie Anne Genter. Thank across the country. Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. across the country. Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is across the country. Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he concerned Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he concerned that Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he concerned that the Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he concerned that the ATAP Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he concerned that the ATAP package Julie Anne Genter. Thank you. Is he concerned that the ATAP package is concerned that the ATAP package is forecast concerned that the ATAP package is forecast to concerned that the ATAP package is forecast to increase concerned that the ATAP package is forecast to increase total concerned that the ATAP package is forecast to increase total carbon forecast to increase total carbon emissions forecast to increase total carbon emissions from forecast to increase total carbon emissions from transport forecast to increase total carbon emissions from transport through forecast to increase total carbon emissions from transport through to emissions from transport through to 2031, emissions from transport through to 2031, when emissions from transport through to 2031, when we emissions from transport through to 2031, when we need emissions from transport through to 2031, when we need to emissions from transport through to 2031, when we need to substantially 2031, when we need to substantially reduce 2031, when we need to substantially reduce total 2031, when we need to substantially reduce total carbon 2031, when we need to substantially reduce total carbon emissions 2031, when we need to substantially reduce total carbon emissions in reduce total carbon emissions in order reduce total carbon emissions in order to reduce total carbon emissions in order to meet reduce total carbon emissions in order to meet our reduce total carbon emissions in order to meet our climate order to meet our climate obligations? order to meet our climate obligations? Well, order to meet our climate obligations? Well, I order to meet our climate obligations? Well, I agree order to meet our climate obligations? Well, I agree with order to meet our climate obligations? Well, I agree with the obligations? Well, I agree with the member obligations? Well, I agree with the member of obligations? Well, I agree with the member of the obligations? Well, I agree with the member of the overriding obligations? Well, I agree with the member of the overriding importance member of the overriding importance of member of the overriding importance of meeting member of the overriding importance of meeting the member of the overriding importance of meeting the targets member of the overriding importance of meeting the targets set member of the overriding importance of meeting the targets set by member of the overriding importance of meeting the targets set by the of meeting the targets set by the Independent of meeting the targets set by the Independent Climate of meeting the targets set by the Independent Climate Commission of meeting the targets set by the Independent Climate Commission to Independent Climate Commission to reduce Independent Climate Commission to reduce our Independent Climate Commission to reduce our emissions Independent Climate Commission to reduce our emissions over Independent Climate Commission to reduce our emissions over that reduce our emissions over that period. reduce our emissions over that period. As reduce our emissions over that period. As identified, reduce our emissions over that period. As identified, the period. As identified, the interventions period. As identified, the interventions lead period. As identified, the interventions lead to period. As identified, the interventions lead to a period. As identified, the interventions lead to a 13% period. As identified, the interventions lead to a 13% decrease interventions lead to a 13% decrease per interventions lead to a 13% decrease per capita interventions lead to a 13% decrease per capita in interventions lead to a 13% decrease per capita in Auckland. interventions lead to a 13% decrease per capita in Auckland. Auckland per capita in Auckland. Auckland sustained per capita in Auckland. Auckland sustained significant per capita in Auckland. Auckland sustained significant population sustained significant population growth, sustained significant population growth, does sustained significant population growth, does mean sustained significant population growth, does mean we sustained significant population growth, does mean we face sustained significant population growth, does mean we face that growth, does mean we face that prospect growth, does mean we face that prospect as growth, does mean we face that prospect as outlined growth, does mean we face that prospect as outlined by growth, does mean we face that prospect as outlined by the growth, does mean we face that prospect as outlined by the member. prospect as outlined by the member. That's prospect as outlined by the member. That's why prospect as outlined by the member. That's why it's prospect as outlined by the member. That's why it's important prospect as outlined by the member. That's why it's important we prospect as outlined by the member. That's why it's important we don't That's why it's important we don't look That's why it's important we don't look at That's why it's important we don't look at ATAP That's why it's important we don't look at ATAP alone, That's why it's important we don't look at ATAP alone, we That's why it's important we don't look at ATAP alone, we look That's why it's important we don't look at ATAP alone, we look at That's why it's important we don't look at ATAP alone, we look at other look at ATAP alone, we look at other interventions look at ATAP alone, we look at other interventions and look at ATAP alone, we look at other interventions and policies look at ATAP alone, we look at other interventions and policies we look at ATAP alone, we look at other interventions and policies we can interventions and policies we can roll interventions and policies we can roll out interventions and policies we can roll out to interventions and policies we can roll out to reduce interventions and policies we can roll out to reduce emissions. interventions and policies we can roll out to reduce emissions. I interventions and policies we can roll out to reduce emissions. I note roll out to reduce emissions. I note the roll out to reduce emissions. I note the Government roll out to reduce emissions. I note the Government has roll out to reduce emissions. I note the Government has already roll out to reduce emissions. I note the Government has already committed the Government has already committed to the Government has already committed to a the Government has already committed to a clean the Government has already committed to a clean car the Government has already committed to a clean car standard, the Government has already committed to a clean car standard, to the Government has already committed to a clean car standard, to make the Government has already committed to a clean car standard, to make new to a clean car standard, to make new cars to a clean car standard, to make new cars coming to a clean car standard, to make new cars coming into to a clean car standard, to make new cars coming into our to a clean car standard, to make new cars coming into our fleet to a clean car standard, to make new cars coming into our fleet 40% cars coming into our fleet 40% cleaner cars coming into our fleet 40% cleaner than cars coming into our fleet 40% cleaner than they cars coming into our fleet 40% cleaner than they are cars coming into our fleet 40% cleaner than they are now, cars coming into our fleet 40% cleaner than they are now, the cleaner than they are now, the decarbonisation cleaner than they are now, the the cleaner than they are now, the decarbonisation of public cleaner than they are now, the decarbonisation of public buses cleaner than they are now, the decarbonisation of public buses and decarbonisation of public buses and the decarbonisation of public buses and the rollout decarbonisation of public buses and the rollout of decarbonisation of public buses and the rollout of a decarbonisation of public buses and the rollout of a biofuels decarbonisation of public buses and the rollout of a biofuels mandate. the rollout of a biofuels mandate. These the rollout of a biofuels mandate. These measures the rollout of a biofuels mandate. These measures with the rollout of a biofuels mandate. These measures with ATAP the rollout of a biofuels mandate. These measures with ATAP would the rollout of a biofuels mandate. These measures with ATAP would get These measures with ATAP would get Auckland These measures with ATAP would get Auckland to These measures with ATAP would get Auckland to the These measures with ATAP would get Auckland to the point These measures with ATAP would get Auckland to the point of These measures with ATAP would get Auckland to the point of a These measures with ATAP would get Auckland to the point of a gross Auckland to the point of a gross emissions Auckland to the point of a gross emissions reduction. Auckland to the point of a gross emissions reduction. But Auckland to the point of a gross emissions reduction. But we emissions reduction. But we acknowledge emissions reduction. But we acknowledge that emissions reduction. But we acknowledge that there emissions reduction. But we acknowledge that there is emissions reduction. But we acknowledge that there is much emissions reduction. But we acknowledge that there is much more acknowledge that there is much more to acknowledge that there is much more to do. acknowledge that there is much more to do. And acknowledge that there is much more to do. And I'll acknowledge that there is much more to do. And I'll be acknowledge that there is much more to do. And I'll be working acknowledge that there is much more to do. And I'll be working on acknowledge that there is much more to do. And I'll be working on that to do. And I'll be working on that with to do. And I'll be working on that with officials to do. And I'll be working on that with officials over to do. And I'll be working on that with officials over the to do. And I'll be working on that with officials over the remainder to do. And I'll be working on that with officials over the remainder of with officials over the remainder of this with officials over the remainder of this year with officials over the remainder of this year as with officials over the remainder of this year as we with officials over the remainder of this year as we produce with officials over the remainder of this year as we produce a with officials over the remainder of this year as we produce a Transport this year as we produce a Transport Eemissions this year as we produce a Transport Eemissions Action this year as we produce a Transport Eemissions Action Plan this year as we produce a Transport Eemissions Action Plan in this year as we produce a Transport Eemissions Action Plan in response Eemissions Action Plan in response to Eemissions Action Plan in response to the Eemissions Action Plan in response to the Independent Eemissions Action Plan in response to the Independent Climate to the Independent Climate Commission's to the Independent Climate Commission's recommendations. to the Independent Climate Commission's recommendations. What Commission's recommendations. What additional Commission's recommendations. What additional steps Commission's recommendations. What additional steps will Commission's recommendations. What additional steps will he Commission's recommendations. What additional steps will he take Commission's recommendations. What additional steps will he take to additional steps will he take to update additional steps will he take to update ATAP additional steps will he take to update ATAP in additional steps will he take to update ATAP in the additional steps will he take to update ATAP in the future additional steps will he take to update ATAP in the future to additional steps will he take to update ATAP in the future to ensure update ATAP in the future to ensure that update ATAP in the future to ensure that that update ATAP in the future to ensure that that $31 update ATAP in the future to ensure that that $31 billion update ATAP in the future to ensure that that $31 billion of update ATAP in the future to ensure that that $31 billion of investment that that $31 billion of investment is that that $31 billion of investment is doing that that $31 billion of investment is doing the that that $31 billion of investment is doing the maximum that that $31 billion of investment is doing the maximum it that that $31 billion of investment is doing the maximum it can that that $31 billion of investment is doing the maximum it can to is doing the maximum it can to reduce is doing the maximum it can to reduce total is doing the maximum it can to reduce total overall is doing the maximum it can to reduce total overall carbon reduce total overall carbon emissions reduce total overall carbon emissions over reduce total overall carbon emissions over the reduce total overall carbon emissions over the next reduce total overall carbon emissions over the next decade? emissions over the next decade? Well, emissions over the next decade? Well, I'll emissions over the next decade? Well, I'll be emissions over the next decade? Well, I'll be working emissions over the next decade? Well, I'll be working closely emissions over the next decade? Well, I'll be working closely with Well, I'll be working closely with Auckland Well, I'll be working closely with Auckland Council Well, I'll be working closely with Auckland Council to Well, I'll be working closely with Auckland Council to make Well, I'll be working closely with Auckland Council to make sure Well, I'll be working closely with Auckland Council to make sure that Auckland Council to make sure that we Auckland Council to make sure that we move Auckland Council to make sure that we move towards Auckland Council to make sure that we move towards our Auckland Council to make sure that we move towards our shared Auckland Council to make sure that we move towards our shared ambitions we move towards our shared ambitions to we move towards our shared ambitions to be we move towards our shared ambitions to be decarbonising we move towards our shared ambitions to be decarbonising the we move towards our shared ambitions to be decarbonising the transport to be decarbonising the transport system. to be decarbonising the transport system. I to be decarbonising the transport system. I think to be decarbonising the transport system. I think the to be decarbonising the transport system. I think the direction to be decarbonising the transport system. I think the direction of system. I think the direction of travel system. I think the direction of travel is system. I think the direction of travel is clear. system. I think the direction of travel is clear. It's system. I think the direction of travel is clear. It's about travel is clear. It's about providing travel is clear. It's about providing Aucklanders travel is clear. It's about providing Aucklanders and travel is clear. It's about providing Aucklanders and people providing Aucklanders and people around providing Aucklanders and people around New providing Aucklanders and people around New Zealand providing Aucklanders and people around New Zealand with providing Aucklanders and people around New Zealand with real around New Zealand with real transport around New Zealand with real transport choices around New Zealand with real transport choices so around New Zealand with real transport choices so that around New Zealand with real transport choices so that people transport choices so that people have transport choices so that people have got transport choices so that people have got the transport choices so that people have got the opportunity transport choices so that people have got the opportunity to transport choices so that people have got the opportunity to access have got the opportunity to access high-quality, have got the opportunity to access high-quality, frequent have got the opportunity to access high-quality, frequent public high-quality, frequent public transport high-quality, frequent public transport and high-quality, frequent public transport and mass high-quality, frequent public transport and mass transit, high-quality, frequent public transport and mass transit, and transport and mass transit, and safe, transport and mass transit, and safe, appropriate transport and mass transit, and safe, appropriate walking transport and mass transit, and safe, appropriate walking and safe, appropriate walking and cycling safe, appropriate walking and cycling options. safe, appropriate walking and cycling options. I'll safe, appropriate walking and cycling options. I'll be safe, appropriate walking and cycling options. I'll be continuing cycling options. I'll be continuing to cycling options. I'll be continuing to work cycling options. I'll be continuing to work with cycling options. I'll be continuing to work with my cycling options. I'll be continuing to work with my officials cycling options. I'll be continuing to work with my officials and cycling options. I'll be continuing to work with my officials and local to work with my officials and local government to work with my officials and local government partners to work with my officials and local government partners to to work with my officials and local government partners to see to work with my officials and local government partners to see those government partners to see those opportunities government partners to see those opportunities are government partners to see those opportunities are given government partners to see those opportunities are given to government partners to see those opportunities are given to New opportunities are given to New Zealanders opportunities are given to New Zealanders to opportunities are given to New Zealanders to help opportunities are given to New Zealanders to help us opportunities are given to New Zealanders to help us reduce opportunities are given to New Zealanders to help us reduce our Zealanders to help us reduce our emissions. Zealanders to help us reduce our emissions. Question Zealanders to help us reduce our emissions. Question No. Zealanders to help us reduce our emissions. Question No. 11. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Immigration: of Immigration: Does of Immigration: Does he of Immigration: Does he stand of Immigration: Does he stand by of Immigration: Does he stand by his of Immigration: Does he stand by his statement, Does he stand by his statement, "many Does he stand by his statement, "many members Does he stand by his statement, "many members in Does he stand by his statement, "many members in this Does he stand by his statement, "many members in this House Does he stand by his statement, "many members in this House will "many members in this House will know "many members in this House will know just "many members in this House will know just how "many members in this House will know just how much "many members in this House will know just how much demand "many members in this House will know just how much demand there "many members in this House will know just how much demand there is know just how much demand there is on know just how much demand there is on managed know just how much demand there is on managed isolation"; on managed isolation"; if on managed isolation"; if so, on managed isolation"; if so, what on managed isolation"; if so, what advice, if so, what advice, if if so, what advice, if any, if so, what advice, if any, has if so, what advice, if any, has he if so, what advice, if any, has he received if any, has he received that if any, has he received that improving if any, has he received that improving utilisation that improving utilisation of that improving utilisation of managed that improving utilisation of managed isolation that improving utilisation of managed isolation and that improving utilisation of managed isolation and quarantine of managed isolation and quarantine capacity capacity could capacity could support capacity could support the capacity could support the reunification could support the reunification of could support the reunification of split could support the reunification of split migrant could support the reunification of split migrant families? The The Hon The Hon Kris The Hon Kris Faafoi. The Hon Kris Faafoi. To The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part of The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part of the The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part of the question, The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part of the question, yes. The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part of the question, yes. To The Hon Kris Faafoi. To the first part of the question, yes. To the part of the question, yes. To the second, part of the question, yes. To the second, I'm part of the question, yes. To the second, I'm regularly part of the question, yes. To the second, I'm regularly advised part of the question, yes. To the second, I'm regularly advised by part of the question, yes. To the second, I'm regularly advised by the second, I'm regularly advised by the Minister second, I'm regularly advised by the Minister of second, I'm regularly advised by the Minister of COVID second, I'm regularly advised by the Minister of COVID Response second, I'm regularly advised by the Minister of COVID Response that Minister of COVID Response that demand Minister of COVID Response that demand for Minister of COVID Response that demand for managed Minister of COVID Response that demand for managed isolation demand for managed isolation continues demand for managed isolation continues to demand for managed isolation continues to be demand for managed isolation continues to be high, demand for managed isolation continues to be high, and demand for managed isolation continues to be high, and is continues to be high, and is expected continues to be high, and is expected to continues to be high, and is expected to be continues to be high, and is expected to be at continues to be high, and is expected to be at full continues to be high, and is expected to be at full capacity continues to be high, and is expected to be at full capacity well expected to be at full capacity well into expected to be at full capacity well into this expected to be at full capacity well into this year. expected to be at full capacity well into this year. Utilisational expected to be at full capacity well into this year. Utilisational rates into this year. Utilisational rates of into this year. Utilisational rates of available into this year. Utilisational rates of available spaces into this year. Utilisational rates of available spaces in into this year. Utilisational rates of available spaces in managed of available spaces in managed isolation of available spaces in managed isolation are of available spaces in managed isolation are currently of available spaces in managed isolation are currently already of available spaces in managed isolation are currently already very isolation are currently already very high, isolation are currently already very high, but isolation are currently already very high, but we isolation are currently already very high, but we are isolation are currently already very high, but we are always isolation are currently already very high, but we are always looking isolation are currently already very high, but we are always looking for high, but we are always looking for ways high, but we are always looking for ways to high, but we are always looking for ways to improve high, but we are always looking for ways to improve and high, but we are always looking for ways to improve and refine high, but we are always looking for ways to improve and refine our ways to improve and refine our processes ways to improve and refine our processes to ways to improve and refine our processes to give ways to improve and refine our processes to give us ways to improve and refine our processes to give us more ways to improve and refine our processes to give us more options. processes to give us more options. It's processes to give us more options. It's important processes to give us more options. It's important for processes to give us more options. It's important for the processes to give us more options. It's important for the House processes to give us more options. It's important for the House to processes to give us more options. It's important for the House to note It's important for the House to note that It's important for the House to note that New It's important for the House to note that New Zealanders It's important for the House to note that New Zealanders trust It's important for the House to note that New Zealanders trust the that New Zealanders trust the Government that New Zealanders trust the Government to that New Zealanders trust the Government to maintain that New Zealanders trust the Government to maintain the that New Zealanders trust the Government to maintain the system, Government to maintain the system, as Government to maintain the system, as our Government to maintain the system, as our first Government to maintain the system, as our first and Government to maintain the system, as our first and best Government to maintain the system, as our first and best defence as our first and best defence against as our first and best defence against COVID, as our first and best defence against COVID, while as our first and best defence against COVID, while the as our first and best defence against COVID, while the vaccine as our first and best defence against COVID, while the vaccine is against COVID, while the vaccine is being against COVID, while the vaccine is being rolled against COVID, while the vaccine is being rolled out. being rolled out. Why, being rolled out. Why, then, being rolled out. Why, then, have being rolled out. Why, then, have 126 being rolled out. Why, then, have 126 members being rolled out. Why, then, have 126 members of being rolled out. Why, then, have 126 members of the Why, then, have 126 members of the Lion Why, then, have 126 members of the Lion King Why, then, have 126 members of the Lion King production Why, then, have 126 members of the Lion King production been Why, then, have 126 members of the Lion King production been allowed Lion King production been allowed into Lion King production been allowed into New Lion King production been allowed into New Zealand, Lion King production been allowed into New Zealand, while Lion King production been allowed into New Zealand, while nurses Lion King production been allowed into New Zealand, while nurses who into New Zealand, while nurses who arrived into New Zealand, while nurses who arrived to into New Zealand, while nurses who arrived to meet into New Zealand, while nurses who arrived to meet our into New Zealand, while nurses who arrived to meet our critical arrived to meet our critical healthcare arrived to meet our critical healthcare needs arrived to meet our critical healthcare needs have arrived to meet our critical healthcare needs have been arrived to meet our critical healthcare needs have been separated healthcare needs have been separated from healthcare needs have been separated from their healthcare needs have been separated from their partners healthcare needs have been separated from their partners and healthcare needs have been separated from their partners and children healthcare needs have been separated from their partners and children for from their partners and children for a from their partners and children for a year? from their partners and children for a year? The from their partners and children for a year? The application from their partners and children for a year? The application that from their partners and children for a year? The application that the a year? The application that the member a year? The application that the member speaks a year? The application that the member speaks of a year? The application that the member speaks of is a year? The application that the member speaks of is under a year? The application that the member speaks of is under the a year? The application that the member speaks of is under the "other member speaks of is under the "other exceptions" member speaks of is under the "other exceptions" tranche member speaks of is under the "other exceptions" tranche of member speaks of is under the "other exceptions" tranche of visas member speaks of is under the "other exceptions" tranche of visas that exceptions" tranche of visas that were exceptions" tranche of visas that were introduced exceptions" tranche of visas that were introduced as exceptions" tranche of visas that were introduced as of exceptions" tranche of visas that were introduced as of June exceptions" tranche of visas that were introduced as of June last were introduced as of June last year. were introduced as of June last year. Since were introduced as of June last year. Since that were introduced as of June last year. Since that time, were introduced as of June last year. Since that time, 6,500 year. Since that time, 6,500 exceptions year. Since that time, 6,500 exceptions in year. Since that time, 6,500 exceptions in the year. Since that time, 6,500 exceptions in the "other" year. Since that time, 6,500 exceptions in the "other" category exceptions in the "other" category have exceptions in the "other" category have been exceptions in the "other" category have been approved, exceptions in the "other" category have been approved, 1,800 exceptions in the "other" category have been approved, 1,800 for have been approved, 1,800 for research have been approved, 1,800 for research and have been approved, 1,800 for research and development, have been approved, 1,800 for research and development, 1,300 have been approved, 1,800 for research and development, 1,300 for research and development, 1,300 for primary research and development, 1,300 for primary industries, research and development, 1,300 for primary industries, and research and development, 1,300 for primary industries, and 335 research and development, 1,300 for primary industries, and 335 for primary industries, and 335 for manufacturing. primary industries, and 335 for manufacturing. While primary industries, and 335 for manufacturing. While the primary industries, and 335 for manufacturing. While the member manufacturing. While the member might manufacturing. While the member might want manufacturing. While the member might want to manufacturing. While the member might want to focus manufacturing. While the member might want to focus on manufacturing. While the member might want to focus on a manufacturing. While the member might want to focus on a small might want to focus on a small number might want to focus on a small number of might want to focus on a small number of entertainers, might want to focus on a small number of entertainers, I'd might want to focus on a small number of entertainers, I'd also number of entertainers, I'd also note number of entertainers, I'd also note that number of entertainers, I'd also note that the number of entertainers, I'd also note that the hotels, number of entertainers, I'd also note that the hotels, the number of entertainers, I'd also note that the hotels, the bars number of entertainers, I'd also note that the hotels, the bars and note that the hotels, the bars and restaurants note that the hotels, the bars and restaurants that note that the hotels, the bars and restaurants that will note that the hotels, the bars and restaurants that will benefit note that the hotels, the bars and restaurants that will benefit from restaurants that will benefit from that restaurants that will benefit from that particular restaurants that will benefit from that particular production restaurants that will benefit from that particular production happening that particular production happening are that particular production happening are desperately that particular production happening are desperately calling that particular production happening are desperately calling out that particular production happening are desperately calling out for that particular production happening are desperately calling out for this are desperately calling out for this kind are desperately calling out for this kind of are desperately calling out for this kind of business. kind of business. Can kind of business. Can he kind of business. Can he explain kind of business. Can he explain how kind of business. Can he explain how a kind of business. Can he explain how a migrant kind of business. Can he explain how a migrant nurse, Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who left Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who left New Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who left New Zealand Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who left New Zealand last Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who left New Zealand last month, Can he explain how a migrant nurse, who left New Zealand last month, is who left New Zealand last month, is now who left New Zealand last month, is now returning who left New Zealand last month, is now returning as who left New Zealand last month, is now returning as a who left New Zealand last month, is now returning as a critical now returning as a critical healthcare now returning as a critical healthcare worker now returning as a critical healthcare worker with now returning as a critical healthcare worker with her now returning as a critical healthcare worker with her family, healthcare worker with her family, taking healthcare worker with her family, taking up healthcare worker with her family, taking up two healthcare worker with her family, taking up two MIQ healthcare worker with her family, taking up two MIQ rooms, healthcare worker with her family, taking up two MIQ rooms, which healthcare worker with her family, taking up two MIQ rooms, which would taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have only taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have only been taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have only been one taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have only been one room taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have only been one room had taking up two MIQ rooms, which would have only been one room had he have only been one room had he allowed have only been one room had he allowed her have only been one room had he allowed her family have only been one room had he allowed her family to have only been one room had he allowed her family to travel have only been one room had he allowed her family to travel here allowed her family to travel here without allowed her family to travel here without her? allowed her family to travel here without her? As allowed her family to travel here without her? As has allowed her family to travel here without her? As has already allowed her family to travel here without her? As has already been without her? As has already been mentioned, without her? As has already been mentioned, I without her? As has already been mentioned, I think without her? As has already been mentioned, I think last without her? As has already been mentioned, I think last week, without her? As has already been mentioned, I think last week, was mentioned, I think last week, was that mentioned, I think last week, was that there mentioned, I think last week, was that there is mentioned, I think last week, was that there is an mentioned, I think last week, was that there is an anomaly mentioned, I think last week, was that there is an anomaly within mentioned, I think last week, was that there is an anomaly within the that there is an anomaly within the system, that there is an anomaly within the system, which that there is an anomaly within the system, which we that there is an anomaly within the system, which we are that there is an anomaly within the system, which we are currently system, which we are currently looking system, which we are currently looking at. looking at. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> And <INTERRUPTION> And we <INTERRUPTION> And we also <INTERRUPTION> And we also think <INTERRUPTION> And we also think the <INTERRUPTION> And we also think the 4,500 <INTERRUPTION> And we also think the 4,500 critical And we also think the 4,500 critical health And we also think the 4,500 critical health workers And we also think the 4,500 critical health workers that And we also think the 4,500 critical health workers that we And we also think the 4,500 critical health workers that we have And we also think the 4,500 critical health workers that we have brought health workers that we have brought into health workers that we have brought into the health workers that we have brought into the country health workers that we have brought into the country since health workers that we have brought into the country since the health workers that we have brought into the country since the borders into the country since the borders closed. into the country since the borders closed. Point into the country since the borders closed. Point of into the country since the borders closed. Point of order. into the country since the borders closed. Point of order. I into the country since the borders closed. Point of order. I don't closed. Point of order. I don't think closed. Point of order. I don't think that closed. Point of order. I don't think that he closed. Point of order. I don't think that he addressed closed. Point of order. I don't think that he addressed quite closed. Point of order. I don't think that he addressed quite the think that he addressed quite the specific think that he addressed quite the specific question think that he addressed quite the specific question that think that he addressed quite the specific question that I think that he addressed quite the specific question that I asked. think that he addressed quite the specific question that I asked. The specific question that I asked. The anomaly specific question that I asked. The anomaly has specific question that I asked. The anomaly has got specific question that I asked. The anomaly has got nothing specific question that I asked. The anomaly has got nothing to specific question that I asked. The anomaly has got nothing to do specific question that I asked. The anomaly has got nothing to do with anomaly has got nothing to do with the anomaly has got nothing to do with the question anomaly has got nothing to do with the question I anomaly has got nothing to do with the question I asked. anomaly has got nothing to do with the question I asked. I'll anomaly has got nothing to do with the question I asked. I'll get anomaly has got nothing to do with the question I asked. I'll get the the question I asked. I'll get the member the question I asked. I'll get the member to the question I asked. I'll get the member to ask the question I asked. I'll get the member to ask it the question I asked. I'll get the member to ask it again. the question I asked. I'll get the member to ask it again. I the question I asked. I'll get the member to ask it again. I thought the question I asked. I'll get the member to ask it again. I thought he member to ask it again. I thought he came member to ask it again. I thought he came very member to ask it again. I thought he came very close, member to ask it again. I thought he came very close, if member to ask it again. I thought he came very close, if he member to ask it again. I thought he came very close, if he didn't. member to ask it again. I thought he came very close, if he didn't. Ask came very close, if he didn't. Ask the came very close, if he didn't. Ask the question came very close, if he didn't. Ask the question again came very close, if he didn't. Ask the question again J came very close, if he didn't. Ask the question again J can came very close, if he didn't. Ask the question again J can he came very close, if he didn't. Ask the question again J can he explain the question again J can he explain how the question again J can he explain how a the question again J can he explain how a migrant the question again J can he explain how a migrant nurse the question again J can he explain how a migrant nurse who the question again J can he explain how a migrant nurse who left the question again J can he explain how a migrant nurse who left New how a migrant nurse who left New Zealand how a migrant nurse who left New Zealand last how a migrant nurse who left New Zealand last month how a migrant nurse who left New Zealand last month Is how a migrant nurse who left New Zealand last month Is now how a migrant nurse who left New Zealand last month Is now returning Zealand last month Is now returning as Zealand last month Is now returning as a Zealand last month Is now returning as a critical Zealand last month Is now returning as a critical healthcare Zealand last month Is now returning as a critical healthcare worker... as a critical healthcare worker... Order! as a critical healthcare worker... Order! I'm as a critical healthcare worker... Order! I'm going as a critical healthcare worker... Order! I'm going to as a critical healthcare worker... Order! I'm going to stop as a critical healthcare worker... Order! I'm going to stop the as a critical healthcare worker... Order! I'm going to stop the member Order! I'm going to stop the member now. Order! I'm going to stop the member now. I'm Order! I'm going to stop the member now. I'm going Order! I'm going to stop the member now. I'm going back Order! I'm going to stop the member now. I'm going back to Order! I'm going to stop the member now. I'm going back to what Order! I'm going to stop the member now. I'm going back to what the now. I'm going back to what the Minister now. I'm going back to what the Minister said, now. I'm going back to what the Minister said, and now. I'm going back to what the Minister said, and he now. I'm going back to what the Minister said, and he did now. I'm going back to what the Minister said, and he did address Minister said, and he did address the Minister said, and he did address the question. Minister said, and he did address the question. All Minister said, and he did address the question. All he Minister said, and he did address the question. All he had Minister said, and he did address the question. All he had to Minister said, and he did address the question. All he had to do Minister said, and he did address the question. All he had to do was the question. All he had to do was say the question. All he had to do was say yes, the question. All he had to do was say yes, and the question. All he had to do was say yes, and he the question. All he had to do was say yes, and he had. say yes, and he had. Has say yes, and he had. Has he say yes, and he had. Has he received say yes, and he had. Has he received advice say yes, and he had. Has he received advice that say yes, and he had. Has he received advice that a Has he received advice that a trans-Tasman Has he received advice that a trans-Tasman bubble Has he received advice that a trans-Tasman bubble would Has he received advice that a trans-Tasman bubble would allow Has he received advice that a trans-Tasman bubble would allow him trans-Tasman bubble would allow him to trans-Tasman bubble would allow him to reunite trans-Tasman bubble would allow him to reunite migrant trans-Tasman bubble would allow him to reunite migrant nurses trans-Tasman bubble would allow him to reunite migrant nurses with trans-Tasman bubble would allow him to reunite migrant nurses with their to reunite migrant nurses with their families, to reunite migrant nurses with their families, without to reunite migrant nurses with their families, without those to reunite migrant nurses with their families, without those nurses families, without those nurses having families, without those nurses having to families, without those nurses having to leave families, without those nurses having to leave New families, without those nurses having to leave New Zealand families, without those nurses having to leave New Zealand and having to leave New Zealand and their having to leave New Zealand and their jobs having to leave New Zealand and their jobs in having to leave New Zealand and their jobs in a having to leave New Zealand and their jobs in a sector having to leave New Zealand and their jobs in a sector that having to leave New Zealand and their jobs in a sector that is their jobs in a sector that is critically their jobs in a sector that is critically short-staffed? their jobs in a sector that is critically short-staffed? As their jobs in a sector that is critically short-staffed? As I their jobs in a sector that is critically short-staffed? As I said critically short-staffed? As I said in critically short-staffed? As I said in the critically short-staffed? As I said in the answer critically short-staffed? As I said in the answer to critically short-staffed? As I said in the answer to the critically short-staffed? As I said in the answer to the primary in the answer to the primary question, in the answer to the primary question, we're in the answer to the primary question, we're continually in the answer to the primary question, we're continually and question, we're continually and regularly question, we're continually and regularly getting question, we're continually and regularly getting advice question, we're continually and regularly getting advice from question, we're continually and regularly getting advice from the regularly getting advice from the Minister regularly getting advice from the Minister of regularly getting advice from the Minister of COVID-19 regularly getting advice from the Minister of COVID-19 Response, regularly getting advice from the Minister of COVID-19 Response, but Minister of COVID-19 Response, but the Minister of COVID-19 Response, but the utilisation Minister of COVID-19 Response, but the utilisation of Minister of COVID-19 Response, but the utilisation of managed Minister of COVID-19 Response, but the utilisation of managed isolation the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and if the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and if we the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and if we can the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and if we can do the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and if we can do better the utilisation of managed isolation spaces, and if we can do better in spaces, and if we can do better in some spaces, and if we can do better in some of spaces, and if we can do better in some of those spaces, and if we can do better in some of those processes. spaces, and if we can do better in some of those processes. What spaces, and if we can do better in some of those processes. What we some of those processes. What we might some of those processes. What we might be some of those processes. What we might be able some of those processes. What we might be able to some of those processes. What we might be able to do some of those processes. What we might be able to do for some of those processes. What we might be able to do for people some of those processes. What we might be able to do for people who might be able to do for people who would might be able to do for people who would like might be able to do for people who would like to might be able to do for people who would like to come might be able to do for people who would like to come into might be able to do for people who would like to come into New might be able to do for people who would like to come into New Zealand would like to come into New Zealand but would like to come into New Zealand but cannot would like to come into New Zealand but cannot at would like to come into New Zealand but cannot at the would like to come into New Zealand but cannot at the moment would like to come into New Zealand but cannot at the moment because would like to come into New Zealand but cannot at the moment because of but cannot at the moment because of the but cannot at the moment because of the very but cannot at the moment because of the very limited but cannot at the moment because of the very limited amount but cannot at the moment because of the very limited amount of but cannot at the moment because of the very limited amount of managed the very limited amount of managed isolation the very limited amount of managed isolation spaces the very limited amount of managed isolation spaces available. the very limited amount of managed isolation spaces available. Question isolation spaces available. Question No. isolation spaces available. Question No. 12. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Conservation: of Conservation: What of Conservation: What recent of Conservation: What recent announcements of Conservation: What recent announcements has of Conservation: What recent announcements has she What recent announcements has she made made regarding made regarding Jobs made regarding Jobs for made regarding Jobs for Nature regarding Jobs for Nature projects regarding Jobs for Nature projects in regarding Jobs for Nature projects in South regarding Jobs for Nature projects in South Westland? Last Last week, Last week, I Last week, I was Last week, I was in Last week, I was in Franz Last week, I was in Franz Josef Last week, I was in Franz Josef to Last week, I was in Franz Josef to announce Last week, I was in Franz Josef to announce the Last week, I was in Franz Josef to announce the launch Last week, I was in Franz Josef to announce the launch of Last week, I was in Franz Josef to announce the launch of an Last week, I was in Franz Josef to announce the launch of an ambitious announce the launch of an ambitious project announce the launch of an ambitious project that announce the launch of an ambitious project that will announce the launch of an ambitious project that will restore announce the launch of an ambitious project that will restore nature announce the launch of an ambitious project that will restore nature and project that will restore nature and sustain project that will restore nature and sustain jobs project that will restore nature and sustain jobs in project that will restore nature and sustain jobs in COVID-hit project that will restore nature and sustain jobs in COVID-hit South sustain jobs in COVID-hit South Westland. sustain jobs in COVID-hit South Westland. Predator sustain jobs in COVID-hit South Westland. Predator free sustain jobs in COVID-hit South Westland. Predator free South Westland. Predator free South Westland Westland. Predator free South Westland represents Westland. Predator free South Westland represents the Westland. Predator free South Westland represents the biggest Westland. Predator free South Westland represents the biggest yet Westland represents the biggest yet towards Westland represents the biggest yet towards the Westland represents the biggest yet towards the predator Westland represents the biggest yet towards the predator free Westland represents the biggest yet towards the predator free 2050 Westland represents the biggest yet towards the predator free 2050 goal. towards the predator free 2050 goal. It towards the predator free 2050 goal. It aims towards the predator free 2050 goal. It aims to towards the predator free 2050 goal. It aims to eliminate towards the predator free 2050 goal. It aims to eliminate possums, towards the predator free 2050 goal. It aims to eliminate possums, rats It aims to eliminate possums, rats and It aims to eliminate possums, rats and stoats It aims to eliminate possums, rats and stoats from It aims to eliminate possums, rats and stoats from 100,000 It aims to eliminate possums, rats and stoats from 100,000 hectares and stoats from 100,000 hectares between and stoats from 100,000 hectares between two and stoats from 100,000 hectares between two rivers. and stoats from 100,000 hectares between two rivers. The and stoats from 100,000 hectares between two rivers. The crest and stoats from 100,000 hectares between two rivers. The crest of and stoats from 100,000 hectares between two rivers. The crest of the between two rivers. The crest of the southern between two rivers. The crest of the southern Alps between two rivers. The crest of the southern Alps and between two rivers. The crest of the southern Alps and the between two rivers. The crest of the southern Alps and the shores between two rivers. The crest of the southern Alps and the shores of between two rivers. The crest of the southern Alps and the shores of the southern Alps and the shores of the Tasman southern Alps and the shores of the Tasman Sea, southern Alps and the shores of the Tasman Sea, including southern Alps and the shores of the Tasman Sea, including -- southern Alps and the shores of the Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. southern Alps and the shores of the Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How will Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How will this Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How will this project Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How will this project support Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How will this project support the Tasman Sea, including -- Sea. How will this project support the local will this project support the local community will this project support the local community in will this project support the local community in South will this project support the local community in South Westland? will this project support the local community in South Westland? Can will this project support the local community in South Westland? Can I community in South Westland? Can I first community in South Westland? Can I first acknowledge community in South Westland? Can I first acknowledge that community in South Westland? Can I first acknowledge that the community in South Westland? Can I first acknowledge that the community first acknowledge that the community is first acknowledge that the community is one first acknowledge that the community is one of first acknowledge that the community is one of the first acknowledge that the community is one of the worst first acknowledge that the community is one of the worst affected is one of the worst affected economically is one of the worst affected economically by is one of the worst affected economically by COVID? is one of the worst affected economically by COVID? And is one of the worst affected economically by COVID? And that economically by COVID? And that while economically by COVID? And that while this economically by COVID? And that while this project economically by COVID? And that while this project is economically by COVID? And that while this project is not economically by COVID? And that while this project is not a economically by COVID? And that while this project is not a silver while this project is not a silver bullet, while this project is not a silver bullet, it while this project is not a silver bullet, it will while this project is not a silver bullet, it will provide while this project is not a silver bullet, it will provide real bullet, it will provide real opportunities. bullet, it will provide real opportunities. Over bullet, it will provide real opportunities. Over the bullet, it will provide real opportunities. Over the length bullet, it will provide real opportunities. Over the length of opportunities. Over the length of the opportunities. Over the length of the project, opportunities. Over the length of the project, up opportunities. Over the length of the project, up to opportunities. Over the length of the project, up to 50 opportunities. Over the length of the project, up to 50 people opportunities. Over the length of the project, up to 50 people are the project, up to 50 people are expected the project, up to 50 people are expected to the project, up to 50 people are expected to be the project, up to 50 people are expected to be employed, the project, up to 50 people are expected to be employed, with the project, up to 50 people are expected to be employed, with 18 expected to be employed, with 18 locals expected to be employed, with 18 locals already expected to be employed, with 18 locals already on expected to be employed, with 18 locals already on board, expected to be employed, with 18 locals already on board, including locals already on board, including some locals already on board, including some who locals already on board, including some who have locals already on board, including some who have been locals already on board, including some who have been working locals already on board, including some who have been working in locals already on board, including some who have been working in the some who have been working in the tourism some who have been working in the tourism industry. some who have been working in the tourism industry. Over some who have been working in the tourism industry. Over the some who have been working in the tourism industry. Over the longer tourism industry. Over the longer term, tourism industry. Over the longer term, it tourism industry. Over the longer term, it is tourism industry. Over the longer term, it is anticipated tourism industry. Over the longer term, it is anticipated that tourism industry. Over the longer term, it is anticipated that the term, it is anticipated that the project term, it is anticipated that the project will term, it is anticipated that the project will provide term, it is anticipated that the project will provide career term, it is anticipated that the project will provide career pathways project will provide career pathways for project will provide career pathways for locals project will provide career pathways for locals and project will provide career pathways for locals and young project will provide career pathways for locals and young people project will provide career pathways for locals and young people to for locals and young people to maintain for locals and young people to maintain predator-free for locals and young people to maintain predator-free zones for locals and young people to maintain predator-free zones and maintain predator-free zones and expand maintain predator-free zones and expand them maintain predator-free zones and expand them into maintain predator-free zones and expand them into new maintain predator-free zones and expand them into new areas. expand them into new areas. What expand them into new areas. What outcomes expand them into new areas. What outcomes for expand them into new areas. What outcomes for nature expand them into new areas. What outcomes for nature is expand them into new areas. What outcomes for nature is this What outcomes for nature is this project What outcomes for nature is this project expected What outcomes for nature is this project expected to What outcomes for nature is this project expected to deliver, What outcomes for nature is this project expected to deliver, and What outcomes for nature is this project expected to deliver, and how project expected to deliver, and how will project expected to deliver, and how will they project expected to deliver, and how will they be project expected to deliver, and how will they be achieved? project expected to deliver, and how will they be achieved? Eliminating will they be achieved? Eliminating pests will they be achieved? Eliminating pests in will they be achieved? Eliminating pests in this will they be achieved? Eliminating pests in this area will they be achieved? Eliminating pests in this area will will they be achieved? Eliminating pests in this area will protect will they be achieved? Eliminating pests in this area will protect New pests in this area will protect New Zealand's pests in this area will protect New Zealand's rarest pests in this area will protect New Zealand's rarest kiwi, pests in this area will protect New Zealand's rarest kiwi, along pests in this area will protect New Zealand's rarest kiwi, along with Zealand's rarest kiwi, along with many Zealand's rarest kiwi, along with many other Zealand's rarest kiwi, along with many other rare Zealand's rarest kiwi, along with many other rare and Zealand's rarest kiwi, along with many other rare and threatened many other rare and threatened species, many other rare and threatened species, including many other rare and threatened species, including kotukou many other rare and threatened species, including kotukou kia, many other rare and threatened species, including kotukou kia, and species, including kotukou kia, and the species, including kotukou kia, and the recently species, including kotukou kia, and the recently rediscovered species, including kotukou kia, and the recently rediscovered gecko. species, including kotukou kia, and the recently rediscovered gecko. The the recently rediscovered gecko. The project the recently rediscovered gecko. The project will the recently rediscovered gecko. The project will deploy project will deploy boots-on-the-ground project will deploy boots-on-the-ground labour project will deploy boots-on-the-ground labour and boots-on-the-ground labour and innovative boots-on-the-ground labour and innovative reporting boots-on-the-ground labour and innovative reporting devices. boots-on-the-ground labour and innovative reporting devices. The innovative reporting devices. The mountains innovative reporting devices. The mountains and innovative reporting devices. The mountains and rivers innovative reporting devices. The mountains and rivers and innovative reporting devices. The mountains and rivers and lakes innovative reporting devices. The mountains and rivers and lakes being mountains and rivers and lakes being used mountains and rivers and lakes being used as mountains and rivers and lakes being used as a mountains and rivers and lakes being used as a natural mountains and rivers and lakes being used as a natural barrier mountains and rivers and lakes being used as a natural barrier so, mountains and rivers and lakes being used as a natural barrier so, no used as a natural barrier so, no fences, used as a natural barrier so, no fences, against used as a natural barrier so, no fences, against predator fences, against predator re-invasion. fences, against predator re-invasion. Can fences, against predator re-invasion. Can I fences, against predator re-invasion. Can I thank fences, against predator re-invasion. Can I thank the re-invasion. Can I thank the community re-invasion. Can I thank the community partners re-invasion. Can I thank the community partners involved, community partners involved, including community partners involved, including zero community partners involved, including zero invasive community partners involved, including zero invasive predator, including zero invasive predator, Osprey, including zero invasive predator, Osprey, for including zero invasive predator, Osprey, for their including zero invasive predator, Osprey, for their hard including zero invasive predator, Osprey, for their hard work including zero invasive predator, Osprey, for their hard work and Osprey, for their hard work and dedication Osprey, for their hard work and dedication towards Osprey, for their hard work and dedication towards this Osprey, for their hard work and dedication towards this ambitious dedication towards this ambitious and dedication towards this ambitious and exciting dedication towards this ambitious and exciting project. I I can't