This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Red This programme is live captioned by Red Bee This programme is live captioned by Red Bee Media Red Bee Media for Red Bee Media for the Red Bee Media for the Office Red Bee Media for the Office of Red Bee Media for the Office of the Red Bee Media for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. Mr Mr Speaker. Almighty Almighty God, Almighty God, we Almighty God, we give Almighty God, we give thanks Almighty God, we give thanks for Almighty God, we give thanks for the Almighty God, we give thanks for the blessings we give thanks for the blessings which we give thanks for the blessings which have we give thanks for the blessings which have been we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on us. which have been bestowed on us. Laying which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal interests, Laying aside all personal interests, we Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Queen we acknowledge the Queen and we acknowledge the Queen and pray we acknowledge the Queen and pray for we acknowledge the Queen and pray for guidance and pray for guidance in and pray for guidance in our and pray for guidance in our deliberations, in our deliberations, that in our deliberations, that we in our deliberations, that we may in our deliberations, that we may conduct that we may conduct the that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House the affairs of this House with the affairs of this House with wisdom, the affairs of this House with wisdom, justice, the affairs of this House with wisdom, justice, mercy, with wisdom, justice, mercy, and with wisdom, justice, mercy, and humility and humility for and humility for the and humility for the welfare and humility for the welfare and and humility for the welfare and peace for the welfare and peace of for the welfare and peace of New for the welfare and peace of New Zealand. for the welfare and peace of New Zealand. Amen. Petitions Petitions have Petitions have been Petitions have been delivered Petitions have been delivered to Petitions have been delivered to the Petitions have been delivered to the Clerk Petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for Petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. to the Clerk for presentation. Petition to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of Wayne to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of Wayne Lowry to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting that Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting that the Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting that the House Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting that the House urge Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting that the House urge the Petition of Wayne Lowry requesting that the House urge the Government that the House urge the Government to that the House urge the Government to include that the House urge the Government to include the that the House urge the Government to include the Lower that the House urge the Government to include the Lower Kaimai that the House urge the Government to include the Lower Kaimai area that the House urge the Government to include the Lower Kaimai area of to include the Lower Kaimai area of the to include the Lower Kaimai area of the Bay to include the Lower Kaimai area of the Bay of to include the Lower Kaimai area of the Bay of Plenty to include the Lower Kaimai area of the Bay of Plenty Electorate to include the Lower Kaimai area of the Bay of Plenty Electorate in to include the Lower Kaimai area of the Bay of Plenty Electorate in the the Bay of Plenty Electorate in the Crown the Bay of Plenty Electorate in the Crown Fibre the Bay of Plenty Electorate in the Crown Fibre Ultra the Bay of Plenty Electorate in the Crown Fibre Ultra Fast the Bay of Plenty Electorate in the Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband area Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband area to Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband area to promote Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband area to promote connection Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband area to promote connection as Crown Fibre Ultra Fast Broadband area to promote connection as a area to promote connection as a community, area to promote connection as a community, improve area to promote connection as a community, improve educational community, improve educational opportunities community, improve educational opportunities and community, improve educational opportunities and support community, improve educational opportunities and support small opportunities and support small business opportunities and support small business owners opportunities and support small business owners who opportunities and support small business owners who frequently opportunities and support small business owners who frequently work business owners who frequently work from business owners who frequently work from home. from home. Petition from home. Petition of from home. Petition of James from home. Petition of James Meharg from home. Petition of James Meharg requesting Petition of James Meharg requesting that Petition of James Meharg requesting that the Petition of James Meharg requesting that the House Petition of James Meharg requesting that the House urge Petition of James Meharg requesting that the House urge the Petition of James Meharg requesting that the House urge the Government that the House urge the Government to that the House urge the Government to make that the House urge the Government to make the that the House urge the Government to make the use that the House urge the Government to make the use and that the House urge the Government to make the use and supply that the House urge the Government to make the use and supply of to make the use and supply of glitter to make the use and supply of glitter and to make the use and supply of glitter and similar to make the use and supply of glitter and similar products to make the use and supply of glitter and similar products illegal glitter and similar products illegal in glitter and similar products illegal in New glitter and similar products illegal in New Zealand. in New Zealand. Those in New Zealand. Those petitions in New Zealand. Those petitions stand in New Zealand. Those petitions stand referred Those petitions stand referred to Those petitions stand referred to the Those petitions stand referred to the Petitions Those petitions stand referred to the Petitions Committee. A A paper A paper has A paper has been A paper has been delivered. A paper has been delivered. Climate Climate Change Climate Change Commission Climate Change Commission - Climate Change Commission - Inaia Climate Change Commission - Inaia tonu Climate Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: a Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: a low Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions future Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions future for Change Commission - Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions future for Aotearoa. a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Advice a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Advice to a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Advice to the a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Advice to the New a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Advice to the New Zealand a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Advice to the New Zealand Government Advice to the New Zealand Government on Advice to the New Zealand Government on its Advice to the New Zealand Government on its first Advice to the New Zealand Government on its first three Advice to the New Zealand Government on its first three emissions Advice to the New Zealand Government on its first three emissions budgets on its first three emissions budgets and on its first three emissions budgets and direction on its first three emissions budgets and direction for on its first three emissions budgets and direction for its on its first three emissions budgets and direction for its emissions and direction for its emissions reduction and direction for its emissions reduction plan and direction for its emissions reduction plan 2022-2025. reduction plan 2022-2025. That reduction plan 2022-2025. That paper reduction plan 2022-2025. That paper is reduction plan 2022-2025. That paper is published That paper is published under That paper is published under the That paper is published under the authority That paper is published under the authority of That paper is published under the authority of the That paper is published under the authority of the House. A A report A report has A report has been A report has been delivered. A report has been delivered. Report A report has been delivered. Report of A report has been delivered. Report of the A report has been delivered. Report of the Maori A report has been delivered. Report of the Maori Affairs Report of the Maori Affairs Committee Report of the Maori Affairs Committee on Report of the Maori Affairs Committee on the Committee on the Petition Committee on the Petition of Committee on the Petition of Anameka Committee on the Petition of Anameka Paenga: Committee on the Petition of Anameka Paenga: Maori Petition of Anameka Paenga: Maori commissioning Petition of Anameka Paenga: Maori commissioning for Petition of Anameka Paenga: Maori commissioning for the Petition of Anameka Paenga: Maori commissioning for the Maori Petition of Anameka Paenga: Maori commissioning for the Maori Health commissioning for the Maori Health Authority. I I wish I wish to I wish to make I wish to make a I wish to make a ministerial I wish to make a ministerial statement I wish to make a ministerial statement relating I wish to make a ministerial statement relating to ministerial statement relating to the ministerial statement relating to the release ministerial statement relating to the release of ministerial statement relating to the release of the ministerial statement relating to the release of the Climate ministerial statement relating to the release of the Climate Change the release of the Climate Change Commission's the release of the Climate Change Commission's report, the release of the Climate Change Commission's report, Inaia the release of the Climate Change Commission's report, Inaia tonu Commission's report, Inaia tonu nei: Commission's report, Inaia tonu nei: a Commission's report, Inaia tonu nei: a low Commission's report, Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions Commission's report, Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions future Commission's report, Inaia tonu nei: a low emissions future for nei: a low emissions future for Aotearoa. Thank Thank you, Thank you, Mr Thank you, Mr Speaker. Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today I Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today I tabled Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today I tabled the Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today I tabled the advice Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today I tabled the advice in Thank you, Mr Speaker. Earlier today I tabled the advice in Parliament I tabled the advice in Parliament that I tabled the advice in Parliament that the I tabled the advice in Parliament that the government I tabled the advice in Parliament that the government has I tabled the advice in Parliament that the government has received that the government has received from that the government has received from the that the government has received from the politically that the government has received from the politically independent from the politically independent science from the politically independent science led, from the politically independent science led, Climate from the politically independent science led, Climate Change science led, Climate Change Commission, science led, Climate Change Commission, on science led, Climate Change Commission, on the science led, Climate Change Commission, on the total science led, Climate Change Commission, on the total amount science led, Climate Change Commission, on the total amount of Commission, on the total amount of global Commission, on the total amount of global warming Commission, on the total amount of global warming population Commission, on the total amount of global warming population that global warming population that Aotearoa global warming population that Aotearoa New global warming population that Aotearoa New Zealand global warming population that Aotearoa New Zealand must global warming population that Aotearoa New Zealand must cut global warming population that Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over the Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over the next Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over the next 15 Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over the next 15 years. Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over the next 15 years. The Aotearoa New Zealand must cut over the next 15 years. The commission's the next 15 years. The commission's advice the next 15 years. The commission's advice provides the next 15 years. The commission's advice provides an the next 15 years. The commission's advice provides an achievable, advice provides an achievable, affordable advice provides an achievable, affordable and advice provides an achievable, affordable and technologically affordable and technologically feasible affordable and technologically affordable affordable and technologically feasible blueprint for affordable and technologically feasible blueprint for achieving feasible blueprint for achieving this. feasible blueprint for achieving this. Mr feasible blueprint for achieving this. Mr Speaker, feasible blueprint for achieving this. Mr Speaker, as feasible blueprint for achieving this. Mr Speaker, as members feasible blueprint for achieving this. Mr Speaker, as members read this. Mr Speaker, as members read through this. Mr Speaker, as members read through the this. Mr Speaker, as members read through the advice this. Mr Speaker, as members read through the advice in this. Mr Speaker, as members read through the advice in the this. Mr Speaker, as members read through the advice in the coming through the advice in the coming days through the advice in the coming days and through the advice in the coming days and weeks, through the advice in the coming days and weeks, there's through the advice in the coming days and weeks, there's four through the advice in the coming days and weeks, there's four main days and weeks, there's four main points days and weeks, there's four main points in days and weeks, there's four main points in keep days and weeks, there's four main points in keep in days and weeks, there's four main points in keep in mind, days and weeks, there's four main points in keep in mind, they days and weeks, there's four main points in keep in mind, they are points in keep in mind, they are that points in keep in mind, they are that addressing points in keep in mind, they are that addressing the points in keep in mind, they are that addressing the climate points in keep in mind, they are that addressing the climate crisis that addressing the climate crisis is that addressing the climate crisis is achievable, that addressing the climate crisis is achievable, it that addressing the climate crisis is achievable, it is that addressing the climate crisis is achievable, it is affordable, that addressing the climate crisis is achievable, it is affordable, it is achievable, it is affordable, it offers is achievable, it is affordable, it offers huge is achievable, it is affordable, it offers huge opportunities is achievable, it is affordable, it offers huge opportunities for offers huge opportunities for improved offers huge opportunities for improved wellbeing offers huge opportunities for improved wellbeing and offers huge opportunities for improved wellbeing and innovation, improved wellbeing and innovation, and improved wellbeing and innovation, and it improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must be improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must be planned improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must be planned in improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must be planned in a improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must be planned in a fair improved wellbeing and innovation, and it must be planned in a fair and and it must be planned in a fair and equitable and it must be planned in a fair and equitable way, and it must be planned in a fair and equitable way, and and it must be planned in a fair and equitable way, and starting and it must be planned in a fair and equitable way, and starting with and it must be planned in a fair and equitable way, and starting with the equitable way, and starting with the targets equitable way, and starting with the targets themselves, equitable way, and starting with the targets themselves, I equitable way, and starting with the targets themselves, I like equitable way, and starting with the targets themselves, I like to equitable way, and starting with the targets themselves, I like to take targets themselves, I like to take each targets themselves, I like to take each of targets themselves, I like to take each of these targets themselves, I like to take each of these in targets themselves, I like to take each of these in turn. targets themselves, I like to take each of these in turn. Mr targets themselves, I like to take each of these in turn. Mr Speaker, each of these in turn. Mr Speaker, the each of these in turn. Mr Speaker, the Climate each of these in turn. Mr Speaker, the Climate Change each of these in turn. Mr Speaker, the Climate Change Commission each of these in turn. Mr Speaker, the Climate Change Commission says the Climate Change Commission says our the Climate Change Commission says our climate the Climate Change Commission says our climate change the Climate Change Commission says our climate change targets the Climate Change Commission says our climate change targets are our climate change targets are achievable our climate change targets are achievable and our climate change targets are achievable and can our climate change targets are achievable and can be our climate change targets are achievable and can be met our climate change targets are achievable and can be met with achievable and can be met with existing achievable and can be met with existing technology, achievable and can be met with existing technology, but achievable and can be met with existing technology, but only achievable and can be met with existing technology, but only if achievable and can be met with existing technology, but only if we existing technology, but only if we act existing technology, but only if we act now. existing technology, but only if we act now. Over existing technology, but only if we act now. Over the existing technology, but only if we act now. Over the last existing technology, but only if we act now. Over the last 3 existing technology, but only if we act now. Over the last 3 and existing technology, but only if we act now. Over the last 3 and a existing technology, but only if we act now. Over the last 3 and a half act now. Over the last 3 and a half years act now. Over the last 3 and a half years this act now. Over the last 3 and a half years this Government act now. Over the last 3 and a half years this Government has act now. Over the last 3 and a half years this Government has laid act now. Over the last 3 and a half years this Government has laid the years this Government has laid the foundations years this Government has laid the foundations from years this Government has laid the foundations from when years this Government has laid the foundations from when the foundations from when the commissioners foundations from when the commissioners are foundations from when the commissioners are now foundations from when the commissioners are now asking foundations from when the commissioners are now asking us foundations from when the commissioners are now asking us to commissioners are now asking us to build. commissioners are now asking us to build. This commissioners are now asking us to build. This will commissioners are now asking us to build. This will help commissioners are now asking us to build. This will help to commissioners are now asking us to build. This will help to ensure commissioners are now asking us to build. This will help to ensure a build. This will help to ensure a sustained build. This will help to ensure a sustained decline build. This will help to ensure a sustained decline in build. This will help to ensure a sustained decline in the build. This will help to ensure a sustained decline in the population sustained decline in the population we sustained decline in the population we put sustained decline in the population we put into sustained decline in the population we put into the sustained decline in the population we put into the atmosphere, sustained decline in the population we put into the atmosphere, and sustained decline in the population we put into the atmosphere, and it we put into the atmosphere, and it will we put into the atmosphere, and it will mean we put into the atmosphere, and it will mean future we put into the atmosphere, and it will mean future governments we put into the atmosphere, and it will mean future governments can will mean future governments can ensure will mean future governments can ensure this will mean future governments can ensure this decline will mean future governments can ensure this decline continues will mean future governments can ensure this decline continues and will mean future governments can ensure this decline continues and in ensure this decline continues and in fact, ensure this decline continues and in fact, picks ensure this decline continues and in fact, picks up ensure this decline continues and in fact, picks up pace ensure this decline continues and in fact, picks up pace every ensure this decline continues and in fact, picks up pace every year ensure this decline continues and in fact, picks up pace every year until fact, picks up pace every year until we fact, picks up pace every year until we hit fact, picks up pace every year until we hit net fact, picks up pace every year until we hit net zero. fact, picks up pace every year until we hit net zero. The fact, picks up pace every year until we hit net zero. The commission fact, picks up pace every year until we hit net zero. The commission is we hit net zero. The commission is also we hit net zero. The commission is also clear we hit net zero. The commission is also clear that we hit net zero. The commission is also clear that taking we hit net zero. The commission is also clear that taking the we hit net zero. The commission is also clear that taking the action also clear that taking the action required also clear that taking the action required of also clear that taking the action required of us also clear that taking the action required of us is also clear that taking the action required of us is affordable. also clear that taking the action required of us is affordable. Mr required of us is affordable. Mr Speaker, required of us is affordable. Mr Speaker, according required of us is affordable. Mr Speaker, according to required of us is affordable. Mr Speaker, according to the required of us is affordable. Mr Speaker, according to the world's Speaker, according to the world's leading Speaker, according to the world's leading scientist, Speaker, according to the world's leading scientist, we Speaker, according to the world's leading scientist, we must Speaker, according to the world's leading scientist, we must cut leading scientist, we must cut global leading scientist, we must cut global emissions leading scientist, we must cut global emissions in leading scientist, we must cut global emissions in half leading scientist, we must cut global emissions in half by leading scientist, we must cut global emissions in half by 2030 leading scientist, we must cut global emissions in half by 2030 to global emissions in half by 2030 to have global emissions in half by 2030 to have any global emissions in half by 2030 to have any chance global emissions in half by 2030 to have any chance of global emissions in half by 2030 to have any chance of staying global emissions in half by 2030 to have any chance of staying within have any chance of staying within the have any chance of staying within the 1.5 have any chance of staying within the 1.5 global have any chance of staying within the 1.5 global warming have any chance of staying within the 1.5 global warming threshold. the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's now the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's now less the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's now less than the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's now less than 9 the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's now less than 9 years the 1.5 global warming threshold. That's now less than 9 years away. That's now less than 9 years away. In That's now less than 9 years away. In we That's now less than 9 years away. In we delay That's now less than 9 years away. In we delay action That's now less than 9 years away. In we delay action for That's now less than 9 years away. In we delay action for another That's now less than 9 years away. In we delay action for another year, In we delay action for another year, that In we delay action for another year, that drops In we delay action for another year, that drops to In we delay action for another year, that drops to eight. In we delay action for another year, that drops to eight. The In we delay action for another year, that drops to eight. The size In we delay action for another year, that drops to eight. The size of In we delay action for another year, that drops to eight. The size of the that drops to eight. The size of the effort that drops to eight. The size of the effort doesn't that drops to eight. The size of the effort doesn't get that drops to eight. The size of the effort doesn't get smaller. that drops to eight. The size of the effort doesn't get smaller. We that drops to eight. The size of the effort doesn't get smaller. We still effort doesn't get smaller. We still need effort doesn't get smaller. We still need to effort doesn't get smaller. We still need to cut effort doesn't get smaller. We still need to cut the effort doesn't get smaller. We still need to cut the same effort doesn't get smaller. We still need to cut the same amount effort doesn't get smaller. We still need to cut the same amount of need to cut the same amount of population, need to cut the same amount of population, where need to cut the same amount of population, where we need to cut the same amount of population, where we do need to cut the same amount of population, where we do it need to cut the same amount of population, where we do it in need to cut the same amount of population, where we do it in seven population, where we do it in seven years, population, where we do it in seven years, or population, where we do it in seven years, or eight, population, where we do it in seven years, or eight, or population, where we do it in seven years, or eight, or 9. population, where we do it in seven years, or eight, or 9. Those population, where we do it in seven years, or eight, or 9. Those calling years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for delay years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for delay as years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for delay as they years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for delay as they always years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for delay as they always do years, or eight, or 9. Those calling for delay as they always do are for delay as they always do are calling for delay as they always do are calling for for delay as they always do are calling for higher for delay as they always do are calling for higher costs for delay as they always do are calling for higher costs and for delay as they always do are calling for higher costs and greater calling for higher costs and greater economic calling for higher costs and greater economic disruption calling for higher costs and greater economic disruption than calling for higher costs and greater economic disruption than is economic disruption than is necessary. economic disruption than is necessary. And economic disruption than is necessary. And the economic disruption than is necessary. And the commission economic disruption than is necessary. And the commission makes necessary. And the commission makes that necessary. And the commission makes that clear. necessary. And the commission makes that clear. It necessary. And the commission makes that clear. It predicts necessary. And the commission makes that clear. It predicts that that clear. It predicts that delaying that clear. It predicts that delaying action that clear. It predicts that delaying action would that clear. It predicts that delaying action would cost that clear. It predicts that delaying action would cost us that clear. It predicts that delaying action would cost us 2.3% delaying action would cost us 2.3% of delaying action would cost us 2.3% of GDP, delaying action would cost us 2.3% of GDP, double delaying action would cost us 2.3% of GDP, double the delaying action would cost us 2.3% of GDP, double the cost delaying action would cost us 2.3% of GDP, double the cost to delaying action would cost us 2.3% of GDP, double the cost to our of GDP, double the cost to our economy of GDP, double the cost to our economy of of GDP, double the cost to our economy of acting of GDP, double the cost to our economy of acting now. of GDP, double the cost to our economy of acting now. The of GDP, double the cost to our economy of acting now. The third economy of acting now. The third point, economy of acting now. The third point, Mr economy of acting now. The third point, Mr Speaker, economy of acting now. The third point, Mr Speaker, is economy of acting now. The third point, Mr Speaker, is to economy of acting now. The third point, Mr Speaker, is to draw point, Mr Speaker, is to draw members' point, Mr Speaker, is to draw members' attention point, Mr Speaker, is to draw members' attention to point, Mr Speaker, is to draw members' attention to the members' attention to the opportunities members' attention to the opportunities within members' attention to the opportunities within our members' attention to the opportunities within our grasp. members' attention to the opportunities within our grasp. As members' attention to the opportunities within our grasp. As a opportunities within our grasp. As a zero opportunities within our grasp. As a zero carbon opportunities within our grasp. As a zero carbon economy opportunities within our grasp. As a zero carbon economy we'll opportunities within our grasp. As a zero carbon economy we'll create zero carbon economy we'll create cleaner zero carbon economy we'll create cleaner and zero carbon economy we'll create cleaner and more zero carbon economy we'll create cleaner and more vibrant cleaner and more vibrant communities. cleaner and more vibrant communities. It cleaner and more vibrant communities. It will cleaner and more vibrant communities. It will connect cleaner and more vibrant communities. It will connect our communities. It will connect our towns communities. It will connect our towns and communities. It will connect our towns and cities communities. It will connect our towns and cities with communities. It will connect our towns and cities with trains communities. It will connect our towns and cities with trains and towns and cities with trains and buses. towns and cities with trains and buses. It towns and cities with trains and buses. It will towns and cities with trains and buses. It will create towns and cities with trains and buses. It will create green towns and cities with trains and buses. It will create green jobs buses. It will create green jobs that buses. It will create green jobs that pay buses. It will create green jobs that pay people buses. It will create green jobs that pay people enough buses. It will create green jobs that pay people enough to buses. It will create green jobs that pay people enough to provide that pay people enough to provide for that pay people enough to provide for their that pay people enough to provide for their families that pay people enough to provide for their families and that pay people enough to provide for their families and put that pay people enough to provide for their families and put a that pay people enough to provide for their families and put a roof for their families and put a roof over for their families and put a roof over their for their families and put a roof over their heads. for their families and put a roof over their heads. It for their families and put a roof over their heads. It will for their families and put a roof over their heads. It will support over their heads. It will support innovation, over their heads. It will support innovation, and over their heads. It will support innovation, and clean over their heads. It will support innovation, and clean tech over their heads. It will support innovation, and clean tech high innovation, and clean tech high value innovation, and clean tech high value industries. innovation, and clean tech high value industries. It innovation, and clean tech high value industries. It will innovation, and clean tech high value industries. It will benefit value industries. It will benefit people's value industries. It will benefit people's health value industries. It will benefit people's health because value industries. It will benefit people's health because of value industries. It will benefit people's health because of warmer, people's health because of warmer, drier people's health because of warmer, drier homes, people's health because of warmer, drier homes, less people's health because of warmer, drier homes, less air people's health because of warmer, drier homes, less air pollution. drier homes, less air pollution. When drier homes, less air pollution. When the drier homes, less air pollution. When the commission drier homes, less air pollution. When the commission released drier homes, less air pollution. When the commission released its When the commission released its draft When the commission released its draft advice When the commission released its draft advice in When the commission released its draft advice in January, When the commission released its draft advice in January, I When the commission released its draft advice in January, I said When the commission released its draft advice in January, I said I draft advice in January, I said I never draft advice in January, I said I never felt draft advice in January, I said I never felt more draft advice in January, I said I never felt more confident draft advice in January, I said I never felt more confident than draft advice in January, I said I never felt more confident than a never felt more confident than a climate never felt more confident than a climate friendly, never felt more confident than a climate friendly, healthy never felt more confident than a climate friendly, healthy and climate friendly, healthy and prosperous climate friendly, healthy and prosperous future climate friendly, healthy and prosperous future for climate friendly, healthy and prosperous future for New climate friendly, healthy and prosperous future for New Zealand prosperous future for New Zealand was prosperous future for New Zealand was within prosperous future for New Zealand was within reach. prosperous future for New Zealand was within reach. I prosperous future for New Zealand was within reach. I still prosperous future for New Zealand was within reach. I still feel prosperous future for New Zealand was within reach. I still feel the was within reach. I still feel the same was within reach. I still feel the same today. was within reach. I still feel the same today. Finally, was within reach. I still feel the same today. Finally, Mr was within reach. I still feel the same today. Finally, Mr Speaker, same today. Finally, Mr Speaker, though same today. Finally, Mr Speaker, though the same today. Finally, Mr Speaker, though the commission's same today. Finally, Mr Speaker, though the commission's advice same today. Finally, Mr Speaker, though the commission's advice makes though the commission's advice makes clear though the commission's advice makes clear the though the commission's advice makes clear the overall though the commission's advice makes clear the overall benefit though the commission's advice makes clear the overall benefit to though the commission's advice makes clear the overall benefit to New clear the overall benefit to New Zealand clear the overall benefit to New Zealand of clear the overall benefit to New Zealand of the clear the overall benefit to New Zealand of the transition clear the overall benefit to New Zealand of the transition to clear the overall benefit to New Zealand of the transition to a clear the overall benefit to New Zealand of the transition to a low Zealand of the transition to a low emissions Zealand of the transition to a low emissions future, Zealand of the transition to a low emissions future, it Zealand of the transition to a low emissions future, it does Zealand of the transition to a low emissions future, it does say Zealand of the transition to a low emissions future, it does say the emissions future, it does say the impacts emissions future, it does say the impacts will emissions future, it does say the impacts will not emissions future, it does say the impacts will not necessarily emissions future, it does say the impacts will not necessarily be impacts will not necessarily be evenly impacts will not necessarily be evenly felt. impacts will not necessarily be evenly felt. There impacts will not necessarily be evenly felt. There will impacts will not necessarily be evenly felt. There will be impacts will not necessarily be evenly felt. There will be people impacts will not necessarily be evenly felt. There will be people up evenly felt. There will be people up and evenly felt. There will be people up and down evenly felt. There will be people up and down the evenly felt. There will be people up and down the country, evenly felt. There will be people up and down the country, wondering evenly felt. There will be people up and down the country, wondering what and down the country, wondering what the and down the country, wondering what the transition and down the country, wondering what the transition means and down the country, wondering what the transition means for and down the country, wondering what the transition means for their the transition means for their families the transition means for their families and the transition means for their families and for the transition means for their families and for their the transition means for their families and for their livelihoods. families and for their livelihoods. On families and for their livelihoods. On this, families and for their livelihoods. On this, the families and for their livelihoods. On this, the commission families and for their livelihoods. On this, the commission presses families and for their livelihoods. On this, the commission presses upon On this, the commission presses upon the On this, the commission presses upon the Government On this, the commission presses upon the Government the On this, the commission presses upon the Government the need On this, the commission presses upon the Government the need to On this, the commission presses upon the Government the need to plan On this, the commission presses upon the Government the need to plan our the Government the need to plan our transition the Government the need to plan our transition in the Government the need to plan our transition in a the Government the need to plan our transition in a fair the Government the need to plan our transition in a fair and the Government the need to plan our transition in a fair and equitable transition in a fair and equitable way. transition in a fair and equitable way. That transition in a fair and equitable way. That means transition in a fair and equitable way. That means working transition in a fair and equitable way. That means working in way. That means working in partnership way. That means working in partnership with way. That means working in partnership with iwi way. That means working in partnership with iwi Maori, way. That means working in partnership with iwi Maori, local partnership with iwi Maori, local communities, partnership with iwi Maori, local communities, and partnership with iwi Maori, local communities, and signalling partnership with iwi Maori, local communities, and signalling policies communities, and signalling policies well communities, and signalling policies well in communities, and signalling policies well in advance communities, and signalling policies well in advance to communities, and signalling policies well in advance to give communities, and signalling policies well in advance to give everyone well in advance to give everyone time well in advance to give everyone time to well in advance to give everyone time to plan. well in advance to give everyone time to plan. Mr well in advance to give everyone time to plan. Mr Speaker, well in advance to give everyone time to plan. Mr Speaker, the well in advance to give everyone time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first chance time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first chance the time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first chance the Government time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first chance the Government will time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first chance the Government will have time to plan. Mr Speaker, the first chance the Government will have to chance the Government will have to show chance the Government will have to show that chance the Government will have to show that we chance the Government will have to show that we can chance the Government will have to show that we can equal chance the Government will have to show that we can equal to chance the Government will have to show that we can equal to the show that we can equal to the challenge show that we can equal to the challenge that show that we can equal to the challenge that the show that we can equal to the challenge that the Climate show that we can equal to the challenge that the Climate Change challenge that the Climate Change Commission challenge that the Climate Change Commission has challenge that the Climate Change Commission has set challenge that the Climate Change Commission has set us challenge that the Climate Change Commission has set us will challenge that the Climate Change Commission has set us will come challenge that the Climate Change Commission has set us will come with Commission has set us will come with the Commission has set us will come with the setting Commission has set us will come with the setting of Commission has set us will come with the setting of the Commission has set us will come with the setting of the first Commission has set us will come with the setting of the first three the setting of the first three emissions the setting of the first three emissions budgets the setting of the first three emissions budgets and the setting of the first three emissions budgets and their emissions budgets and their emissions emissions budgets and their emissions reduction emissions budgets and their emissions reduction plan. emissions budgets and their emissions reduction plan. This emissions budgets and their emissions reduction plan. This plan emissions reduction plan. This plan will emissions reduction plan. This plan will need emissions reduction plan. This plan will need to emissions reduction plan. This plan will need to include emissions reduction plan. This plan will need to include policies emissions reduction plan. This plan will need to include policies and will need to include policies and strategies will need to include policies and strategies that will need to include policies and strategies that cut will need to include policies and strategies that cut across will need to include policies and strategies that cut across every strategies that cut across every sector strategies that cut across every sector of strategies that cut across every sector of the strategies that cut across every sector of the economy, strategies that cut across every sector of the economy, including sector of the economy, including agriculture, sector of the economy, including agriculture, and sector of the economy, including agriculture, and forestry, agriculture, and forestry, transport, agriculture, and forestry, transport, building agriculture, and forestry, transport, building and transport, building and construction, transport, building and construction, waste, transport, building and construction, waste, and transport, building and construction, waste, and heat construction, waste, and heat industry construction, waste, and heat industry and construction, waste, and heat industry and power. construction, waste, and heat industry and power. It construction, waste, and heat industry and power. It will construction, waste, and heat industry and power. It will also industry and power. It will also look industry and power. It will also look at industry and power. It will also look at the industry and power. It will also look at the changes industry and power. It will also look at the changes needed industry and power. It will also look at the changes needed across look at the changes needed across the look at the changes needed across the finance look at the changes needed across the finance system, look at the changes needed across the finance system, infrastructure, the finance system, infrastructure, and the finance system, infrastructure, and planning, the finance system, infrastructure, and planning, and the finance system, infrastructure, and planning, and emissions the finance system, infrastructure, and planning, and emissions pricing. and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr Speaker, and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr Speaker, we and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr Speaker, we will and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr Speaker, we will consult and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr Speaker, we will consult on and planning, and emissions pricing. Mr Speaker, we will consult on the Mr Speaker, we will consult on the plan Mr Speaker, we will consult on the plan and Mr Speaker, we will consult on the plan and there Mr Speaker, we will consult on the plan and there will Mr Speaker, we will consult on the plan and there will be Mr Speaker, we will consult on the plan and there will be opportunities plan and there will be opportunities for plan and there will be opportunities for members plan and there will be opportunities for members to plan and there will be opportunities for members to consider plan and there will be opportunities for members to consider the for members to consider the emissions for members to consider the emissions budgets. for members to consider the emissions budgets. In for members to consider the emissions budgets. In doing for members to consider the emissions budgets. In doing so, for members to consider the emissions budgets. In doing so, I emissions budgets. In doing so, I hope emissions budgets. In doing so, I hope they'll emissions budgets. In doing so, I hope they'll take emissions budgets. In doing so, I hope they'll take heed emissions budgets. In doing so, I hope they'll take heed of emissions budgets. In doing so, I hope they'll take heed of the hope they'll take heed of the commission's hope they'll take heed of the commission's point, hope they'll take heed of the commission's point, that hope they'll take heed of the commission's point, that some hope they'll take heed of the commission's point, that some issues commission's point, that some issues are commission's point, that some issues are too commission's point, that some issues are too big commission's point, that some issues are too big for commission's point, that some issues are too big for politics. commission's point, that some issues are too big for politics. And commission's point, that some issues are too big for politics. And in are too big for politics. And in turn, are too big for politics. And in turn, the are too big for politics. And in turn, the calls are too big for politics. And in turn, the calls for are too big for politics. And in turn, the calls for cross-party turn, the calls for cross-party consensus turn, the calls for cross-party consensus from turn, the calls for cross-party consensus from business turn, the calls for cross-party consensus from business and turn, the calls for cross-party consensus from business and local consensus from business and local communities. consensus from business and local communities. To consensus from business and local communities. To close, consensus from business and local communities. To close, Mr consensus from business and local communities. To close, Mr Speaker, consensus from business and local communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I like communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I like to communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I like to take communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I like to take the communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I like to take the opportunity communities. To close, Mr Speaker, I like to take the opportunity to like to take the opportunity to thank like to take the opportunity to thank the like to take the opportunity to thank the commission like to take the opportunity to thank the commission for like to take the opportunity to thank the commission for their like to take the opportunity to thank the commission for their hard thank the commission for their hard work, thank the commission for their hard work, their thank the commission for their hard work, their analytical thank the commission for their hard work, their analytical honesty thank the commission for their hard work, their analytical honesty and work, their analytical honesty and their work, their analytical honesty and their rigour. work, their analytical honesty and their rigour. What work, their analytical honesty and their rigour. What they work, their analytical honesty and their rigour. What they have their rigour. What they have achieved their rigour. What they have achieved with their rigour. What they have achieved with their their rigour. What they have achieved with their advice their rigour. What they have achieved with their advice will their rigour. What they have achieved with their advice will have achieved with their advice will have a achieved with their advice will have a lasting achieved with their advice will have a lasting impact achieved with their advice will have a lasting impact on achieved with their advice will have a lasting impact on the achieved with their advice will have a lasting impact on the type achieved with their advice will have a lasting impact on the type of a lasting impact on the type of planet a lasting impact on the type of planet our a lasting impact on the type of planet our children a lasting impact on the type of planet our children inherit a lasting impact on the type of planet our children inherit from a lasting impact on the type of planet our children inherit from us. planet our children inherit from us. I planet our children inherit from us. I call planet our children inherit from us. I call the planet our children inherit from us. I call the member. planet our children inherit from us. I call the member. Thank planet our children inherit from us. I call the member. Thank you, planet our children inherit from us. I call the member. Thank you, Mr I call the member. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I call the member. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'm I call the member. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'm glad I call the member. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'm glad the I call the member. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'm glad the commission I call the member. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I'm glad the commission has Speaker. I'm glad the commission has listened Speaker. I'm glad the commission has listened to Speaker. I'm glad the commission has listened to the Speaker. I'm glad the commission has listened to the National Speaker. I'm glad the commission has listened to the National Party listened to the National Party through listened to the National Party through our listened to the National Party through our submission, listened to the National Party through our submission, and listened to the National Party through our submission, and on listened to the National Party through our submission, and on their through our submission, and on their original through our submission, and on their original draft, through our submission, and on their original draft, and through our submission, and on their original draft, and dropped through our submission, and on their original draft, and dropped the original draft, and dropped the recommended original draft, and dropped the recommended policy original draft, and dropped the recommended policy positions original draft, and dropped the recommended policy positions they recommended policy positions they had recommended policy positions they had in recommended policy positions they had in their recommended policy positions they had in their draft recommended policy positions they had in their draft report. recommended policy positions they had in their draft report. The had in their draft report. The National had in their draft report. The National Party had in their draft report. The National Party has had in their draft report. The National Party has a had in their draft report. The National Party has a history had in their draft report. The National Party has a history of National Party has a history of mitigating National Party has a history of mitigating the National Party has a history of mitigating the effects National Party has a history of mitigating the effects of National Party has a history of mitigating the effects of climate mitigating the effects of climate change, mitigating the effects of climate change, under mitigating the effects of climate change, under the mitigating the effects of climate change, under the National change, under the National government, change, under the National government, renewables change, under the National government, renewables increased government, renewables increased from government, renewables increased from 65% government, renewables increased from 65% to government, renewables increased from 65% to 85%, government, renewables increased from 65% to 85%, and government, renewables increased from 65% to 85%, and we government, renewables increased from 65% to 85%, and we - government, renewables increased from 65% to 85%, and we - we from 65% to 85%, and we - we supported from 65% to 85%, and we - we supported the from 65% to 85%, and we - we supported the Paris from 65% to 85%, and we - we supported the Paris accord, from 65% to 85%, and we - we supported the Paris accord, or supported the Paris accord, or signed supported the Paris accord, or signed the supported the Paris accord, or signed the Paris supported the Paris accord, or signed the Paris accord, supported the Paris accord, or signed the Paris accord, with supported the Paris accord, or signed the Paris accord, with we signed the Paris accord, with we supported signed the Paris accord, with we supported zero signed the Paris accord, with we supported zero carbon signed the Paris accord, with we supported zero carbon Act. signed the Paris accord, with we supported zero carbon Act. We signed the Paris accord, with we supported zero carbon Act. We also supported zero carbon Act. We also supported supported zero carbon Act. We also supported the supported zero carbon Act. We also supported the establishment supported zero carbon Act. We also supported the establishment of supported zero carbon Act. We also supported the establishment of the supported the establishment of the Climate supported the establishment of the Climate Change supported the establishment of the Climate Change Commission. supported the establishment of the Climate Change Commission. We supported the establishment of the Climate Change Commission. We still, Climate Change Commission. We still, however, Climate Change Commission. We still, however, have Climate Change Commission. We still, however, have some Climate Change Commission. We still, however, have some concerns however, have some concerns regarding however, have some concerns regarding the however, have some concerns regarding the policy however, have some concerns regarding the policy interventions regarding the policy interventions addressed regarding the policy interventions addressed in regarding the policy interventions addressed in the regarding the policy interventions addressed in the report. regarding the policy interventions addressed in the report. But regarding the policy interventions addressed in the report. But we addressed in the report. But we support addressed in the report. But we support a addressed in the report. But we support a split addressed in the report. But we support a split gas addressed in the report. But we support a split gas approach addressed in the report. But we support a split gas approach and addressed in the report. But we support a split gas approach and we support a split gas approach and we also support a split gas approach and we also support support a split gas approach and we also support the support a split gas approach and we also support the use support a split gas approach and we also support the use of support a split gas approach and we also support the use of carbon also support the use of carbon budgets also support the use of carbon budgets to also support the use of carbon budgets to reach also support the use of carbon budgets to reach our also support the use of carbon budgets to reach our goals. also support the use of carbon budgets to reach our goals. Farmers budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being asked budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being asked to budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being asked to do budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being asked to do more budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being asked to do more in budgets to reach our goals. Farmers are being asked to do more in the are being asked to do more in the final are being asked to do more in the final report are being asked to do more in the final report than are being asked to do more in the final report than they are being asked to do more in the final report than they were are being asked to do more in the final report than they were under final report than they were under the final report than they were under the zero final report than they were under the zero carbon final report than they were under the zero carbon act final report than they were under the zero carbon act and final report than they were under the zero carbon act and that final report than they were under the zero carbon act and that really the zero carbon act and that really does the zero carbon act and that really does raise the zero carbon act and that really does raise some the zero carbon act and that really does raise some concerns the zero carbon act and that really does raise some concerns because the zero carbon act and that really does raise some concerns because the does raise some concerns because the zero does raise some concerns because the zero carbon does raise some concerns because the zero carbon act does raise some concerns because the zero carbon act targets does raise some concerns because the zero carbon act targets were zero carbon act targets were significantly zero carbon act targets were significantly challenging zero carbon act targets were significantly challenging in zero carbon act targets were significantly challenging in and zero carbon act targets were significantly challenging in and of significantly challenging in and of themselves. significantly challenging in and of themselves. Also, significantly challenging in and of themselves. Also, of significantly challenging in and of themselves. Also, of concern, significantly challenging in and of themselves. Also, of concern, is significantly challenging in and of themselves. Also, of concern, is the themselves. Also, of concern, is the first themselves. Also, of concern, is the first emissions themselves. Also, of concern, is the first emissions budget, themselves. Also, of concern, is the first emissions budget, which themselves. Also, of concern, is the first emissions budget, which has first emissions budget, which has New first emissions budget, which has New Zealand first emissions budget, which has New Zealand reducing first emissions budget, which has New Zealand reducing emissions first emissions budget, which has New Zealand reducing emissions by first emissions budget, which has New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in just New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in just four New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in just four years. New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in just four years. And New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in just four years. And given New Zealand reducing emissions by 8% in just four years. And given that, in just four years. And given that, under in just four years. And given that, under this in just four years. And given that, under this Government, in just four years. And given that, under this Government, emissions under this Government, emissions have under this Government, emissions have increased under this Government, emissions have increased by under this Government, emissions have increased by 2%, under this Government, emissions have increased by 2%, and under this Government, emissions have increased by 2%, and we're under this Government, emissions have increased by 2%, and we're on have increased by 2%, and we're on track have increased by 2%, and we're on track to have increased by 2%, and we're on track to burn have increased by 2%, and we're on track to burn over have increased by 2%, and we're on track to burn over 2 have increased by 2%, and we're on track to burn over 2 million have increased by 2%, and we're on track to burn over 2 million tonnes track to burn over 2 million tonnes of track to burn over 2 million tonnes of coal track to burn over 2 million tonnes of coal this track to burn over 2 million tonnes of coal this year, track to burn over 2 million tonnes of coal this year, generating of coal this year, generating electricity, of coal this year, generating electricity, we of coal this year, generating electricity, we first of coal this year, generating electricity, we first have of coal this year, generating electricity, we first have to of coal this year, generating electricity, we first have to slow electricity, we first have to slow down electricity, we first have to slow down our electricity, we first have to slow down our emissions electricity, we first have to slow down our emissions before electricity, we first have to slow down our emissions before - electricity, we first have to slow down our emissions before - to electricity, we first have to slow down our emissions before - to bring down our emissions before - to bring them down our emissions before - to bring them back down our emissions before - to bring them back to down our emissions before - to bring them back to zero, down our emissions before - to bring them back to zero, before down our emissions before - to bring them back to zero, before we down our emissions before - to bring them back to zero, before we start them back to zero, before we start reducing them back to zero, before we start reducing them. them back to zero, before we start reducing them. It's them back to zero, before we start reducing them. It's quite them back to zero, before we start reducing them. It's quite a reducing them. It's quite a challenge. reducing them. It's quite a challenge. However, reducing them. It's quite a challenge. However, as reducing them. It's quite a challenge. However, as the challenge. However, as the Government challenge. However, as the Government reflects challenge. However, as the Government reflects on challenge. However, as the Government reflects on and challenge. However, as the Government reflects on and works Government reflects on and works through Government reflects on and works through this Government reflects on and works through this report, Government reflects on and works through this report, we Government reflects on and works through this report, we will through this report, we will continue through this report, we will continue to through this report, we will continue to advocate through this report, we will continue to advocate for through this report, we will continue to advocate for New continue to advocate for New Zealanders continue to advocate for New Zealanders to continue to advocate for New Zealanders to ensure continue to advocate for New Zealanders to ensure that continue to advocate for New Zealanders to ensure that we continue to advocate for New Zealanders to ensure that we are continue to advocate for New Zealanders to ensure that we are not Zealanders to ensure that we are not forced Zealanders to ensure that we are not forced to Zealanders to ensure that we are not forced to have Zealanders to ensure that we are not forced to have command Zealanders to ensure that we are not forced to have command and Zealanders to ensure that we are not forced to have command and control forced to have command and control policies forced to have command and control policies foisted forced to have command and control policies foisted upon forced to have command and control policies foisted upon us. forced to have command and control policies foisted upon us. I forced to have command and control policies foisted upon us. I now forced to have command and control policies foisted upon us. I now like policies foisted upon us. I now like to policies foisted upon us. I now like to ask policies foisted upon us. I now like to ask the policies foisted upon us. I now like to ask the minister policies foisted upon us. I now like to ask the minister a policies foisted upon us. I now like to ask the minister a couple policies foisted upon us. I now like to ask the minister a couple of to ask the minister a couple of questions to ask the minister a couple of questions if to ask the minister a couple of questions if I to ask the minister a couple of questions if I may, to ask the minister a couple of questions if I may, Mr to ask the minister a couple of questions if I may, Mr Speaker. to ask the minister a couple of questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is the questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is the minister questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is the minister confident questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is the minister confident that questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is the minister confident that the questions if I may, Mr Speaker. Is the minister confident that the two the minister confident that the two months the minister confident that the two months allowed the minister confident that the two months allowed for the minister confident that the two months allowed for the the minister confident that the two months allowed for the commission the minister confident that the two months allowed for the commission to months allowed for the commission to consider months allowed for the commission to consider the months allowed for the commission to consider the over months allowed for the commission to consider the over 15,000 months allowed for the commission to consider the over 15,000 submissions consider the over 15,000 submissions was consider the over 15,000 submissions was enough consider the over 15,000 submissions was enough to consider the over 15,000 submissions was enough to then consider the over 15,000 submissions was enough to then reflect consider the over 15,000 submissions was enough to then reflect the was enough to then reflect the submissions was enough to then reflect the submissions in was enough to then reflect the submissions in the was enough to then reflect the submissions in the final was enough to then reflect the submissions in the final report? was enough to then reflect the submissions in the final report? Mr submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, yes, submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, yes, I submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, yes, I am submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, yes, I am confident. submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, yes, I am confident. If submissions in the final report? Mr Speaker, yes, I am confident. If the Speaker, yes, I am confident. If the commission Speaker, yes, I am confident. If the commission advised Speaker, yes, I am confident. If the commission advised me Speaker, yes, I am confident. If the commission advised me they Speaker, yes, I am confident. If the commission advised me they couldn't commission advised me they couldn't do commission advised me they couldn't do it, commission advised me they couldn't do it, they commission advised me they couldn't do it, they didn't commission advised me they couldn't do it, they didn't say commission advised me they couldn't do it, they didn't say at commission advised me they couldn't do it, they didn't say at any commission advised me they couldn't do it, they didn't say at any point do it, they didn't say at any point they do it, they didn't say at any point they couldn't do it, they didn't say at any point they couldn't do do it, they didn't say at any point they couldn't do it. do it, they didn't say at any point they couldn't do it. We do it, they didn't say at any point they couldn't do it. We did do it, they didn't say at any point they couldn't do it. We did give they couldn't do it. We did give them they couldn't do it. We did give them an they couldn't do it. We did give them an extension they couldn't do it. We did give them an extension during they couldn't do it. We did give them an extension during the they couldn't do it. We did give them an extension during the initial them an extension during the initial consultation them an extension during the initial consultation phase. them an extension during the initial consultation phase. When them an extension during the initial consultation phase. When they them an extension during the initial consultation phase. When they asked consultation phase. When they asked for consultation phase. When they asked for that. consultation phase. When they asked for that. I consultation phase. When they asked for that. I did consultation phase. When they asked for that. I did ask consultation phase. When they asked for that. I did ask them consultation phase. When they asked for that. I did ask them whether for that. I did ask them whether that for that. I did ask them whether that left for that. I did ask them whether that left them for that. I did ask them whether that left them with for that. I did ask them whether that left them with sufficient for that. I did ask them whether that left them with sufficient time that left them with sufficient time to that left them with sufficient time to consider that left them with sufficient time to consider the that left them with sufficient time to consider the responses that left them with sufficient time to consider the responses and that left them with sufficient time to consider the responses and they to consider the responses and they said to consider the responses and they said they to consider the responses and they said they did. to consider the responses and they said they did. Is to consider the responses and they said they did. Is the to consider the responses and they said they did. Is the minister said they did. Is the minister satisfied said they did. Is the minister satisfied with said they did. Is the minister satisfied with the said they did. Is the minister satisfied with the commission's satisfied with the commission's handling satisfied with the commission's handling of satisfied with the commission's handling of the satisfied with the commission's handling of the media, satisfied with the commission's handling of the media, given satisfied with the commission's handling of the media, given the satisfied with the commission's handling of the media, given the 40 handling of the media, given the 40 minutes handling of the media, given the 40 minutes they handling of the media, given the 40 minutes they were handling of the media, given the 40 minutes they were given handling of the media, given the 40 minutes they were given to handling of the media, given the 40 minutes they were given to read handling of the media, given the 40 minutes they were given to read the minutes they were given to read the report minutes they were given to read the report before minutes they were given to read the report before going minutes they were given to read the report before going into minutes they were given to read the report before going into a minutes they were given to read the report before going into a press report before going into a press conference report before going into a press conference to report before going into a press conference to ask report before going into a press conference to ask the report before going into a press conference to ask the PM's report before going into a press conference to ask the PM's questions conference to ask the PM's questions on conference to ask the PM's questions on the conference to ask the PM's questions on the report. conference to ask the PM's questions on the report. And, conference to ask the PM's questions on the report. And, going conference to ask the PM's questions on the report. And, going back conference to ask the PM's questions on the report. And, going back to on the report. And, going back to the on the report. And, going back to the draft on the report. And, going back to the draft report on the report. And, going back to the draft report that on the report. And, going back to the draft report that some on the report. And, going back to the draft report that some hand the draft report that some hand picked the draft report that some hand picked journalists the draft report that some hand picked journalists were the draft report that some hand picked journalists were given the draft report that some hand picked journalists were given an picked journalists were given an advance picked journalists were given an advance copy picked journalists were given an advance copy of picked journalists were given an advance copy of the picked journalists were given an advance copy of the draft picked journalists were given an advance copy of the draft report? advance copy of the draft report? Well, advance copy of the draft report? Well, in advance copy of the draft report? Well, in the advance copy of the draft report? Well, in the concerns advance copy of the draft report? Well, in the concerns about advance copy of the draft report? Well, in the concerns about today's Well, in the concerns about today's lockups Well, in the concerns about today's lockups should Well, in the concerns about today's lockups should be Well, in the concerns about today's lockups should be directed Well, in the concerns about today's lockups should be directed at Well, in the concerns about today's lockups should be directed at me, lockups should be directed at me, rather lockups should be directed at me, rather than lockups should be directed at me, rather than at lockups should be directed at me, rather than at the lockups should be directed at me, rather than at the commission. lockups should be directed at me, rather than at the commission. It rather than at the commission. It was rather than at the commission. It was my rather than at the commission. It was my office rather than at the commission. It was my office that rather than at the commission. It was my office that organised rather than at the commission. It was my office that organised that, was my office that organised that, not was my office that organised that, not the was my office that organised that, not the commission. was my office that organised that, not the commission. I was my office that organised that, not the commission. I did was my office that organised that, not the commission. I did ask was my office that organised that, not the commission. I did ask if was my office that organised that, not the commission. I did ask if you not the commission. I did ask if you were not the commission. I did ask if you were satisfied. not the commission. I did ask if you were satisfied. Well, not the commission. I did ask if you were satisfied. Well, you not the commission. I did ask if you were satisfied. Well, you asked not the commission. I did ask if you were satisfied. Well, you asked if not the commission. I did ask if you were satisfied. Well, you asked if I were satisfied. Well, you asked if I was were satisfied. Well, you asked if I was satisfied were satisfied. Well, you asked if I was satisfied with were satisfied. Well, you asked if I was satisfied with the were satisfied. Well, you asked if I was satisfied with the commission, was satisfied with the commission, the was satisfied with the commission, the response was satisfied with the commission, the response is was satisfied with the commission, the response is yes, was satisfied with the commission, the response is yes, they was satisfied with the commission, the response is yes, they didn't the response is yes, they didn't hand the response is yes, they didn't hand today's the response is yes, they didn't hand today's media, the response is yes, they didn't hand today's media, I the response is yes, they didn't hand today's media, I did. the response is yes, they didn't hand today's media, I did. Is the response is yes, they didn't hand today's media, I did. Is the hand today's media, I did. Is the minister hand today's media, I did. Is the minister satisfied hand today's media, I did. Is the minister satisfied that hand today's media, I did. Is the minister satisfied that the minister satisfied that the commissioners minister satisfied that the commissioners had minister satisfied that the commissioners had enough minister satisfied that the commissioners had enough time minister satisfied that the commissioners had enough time to commissioners had enough time to read commissioners had enough time to read the commissioners had enough time to read the report commissioners had enough time to read the report before commissioners had enough time to read the report before they commissioners had enough time to read the report before they signed read the report before they signed it read the report before they signed it off? read the report before they signed it off? I read the report before they signed it off? I think read the report before they signed it off? I think given read the report before they signed it off? I think given the read the report before they signed it off? I think given the calibre read the report before they signed it off? I think given the calibre of it off? I think given the calibre of people it off? I think given the calibre of people on it off? I think given the calibre of people on the it off? I think given the calibre of people on the commission it off? I think given the calibre of people on the commission they people on the commission they wouldn't people on the commission they wouldn't have people on the commission they wouldn't have signed people on the commission they wouldn't have signed off people on the commission they wouldn't have signed off something wouldn't have signed off something they wouldn't have signed off something they felt wouldn't have signed off something they felt they wouldn't have signed off something they felt they didn't wouldn't have signed off something they felt they didn't have wouldn't have signed off something they felt they didn't have time wouldn't have signed off something they felt they didn't have time to they felt they didn't have time to consider. they felt they didn't have time to consider. I they felt they didn't have time to consider. I also they felt they didn't have time to consider. I also would they felt they didn't have time to consider. I also would say they felt they didn't have time to consider. I also would say that they felt they didn't have time to consider. I also would say that I've consider. I also would say that I've been consider. I also would say that I've been advised consider. I also would say that I've been advised that consider. I also would say that I've been advised that every consider. I also would say that I've been advised that every single been advised that every single recommendation been advised that every single recommendation in been advised that every single recommendation in there been advised that every single recommendation in there was been advised that every single recommendation in there was by been advised that every single recommendation in there was by the recommendation in there was by the unanimous recommendation in there was by the unanimous consent recommendation in there was by the unanimous consent of recommendation in there was by the unanimous consent of the unanimous consent of the commissioners. unanimous consent of the commissioners. We've unanimous consent of the commissioners. We've received commissioners. We've received reports commissioners. We've received reports that commissioners. We've received reports that commissioners commissioners. We've received reports that commissioners had commissioners. We've received reports that commissioners had less reports that commissioners had less than reports that commissioners had less than 24 reports that commissioners had less than 24 hours reports that commissioners had less than 24 hours to reports that commissioners had less than 24 hours to consider reports that commissioners had less than 24 hours to consider the reports that commissioners had less than 24 hours to consider the report than 24 hours to consider the report before than 24 hours to consider the report before signing than 24 hours to consider the report before signing that than 24 hours to consider the report before signing that off. than 24 hours to consider the report before signing that off. Is than 24 hours to consider the report before signing that off. Is the before signing that off. Is the minister before signing that off. Is the minister aware before signing that off. Is the minister aware of before signing that off. Is the minister aware of that, before signing that off. Is the minister aware of that, even before signing that off. Is the minister aware of that, even if before signing that off. Is the minister aware of that, even if he minister aware of that, even if he isn't, minister aware of that, even if he isn't, does minister aware of that, even if he isn't, does he minister aware of that, even if he isn't, does he think minister aware of that, even if he isn't, does he think it's isn't, does he think it's satisfactory, isn't, does he think it's satisfactory, given isn't, does he think it's satisfactory, given the isn't, does he think it's satisfactory, given the report isn't, does he think it's satisfactory, given the report is satisfactory, given the report is over satisfactory, given the report is over 400 satisfactory, given the report is over 400 pages? satisfactory, given the report is over 400 pages? I satisfactory, given the report is over 400 pages? I haven't satisfactory, given the report is over 400 pages? I haven't received over 400 pages? I haven't received those over 400 pages? I haven't received those reports, over 400 pages? I haven't received those reports, no. over 400 pages? I haven't received those reports, no. Does over 400 pages? I haven't received those reports, no. Does the over 400 pages? I haven't received those reports, no. Does the minister those reports, no. Does the minister think those reports, no. Does the minister think the those reports, no. Does the minister think the public those reports, no. Does the minister think the public would those reports, no. Does the minister think the public would have those reports, no. Does the minister think the public would have any think the public would have any confidence think the public would have any confidence in think the public would have any confidence in the think the public would have any confidence in the final think the public would have any confidence in the final report think the public would have any confidence in the final report if think the public would have any confidence in the final report if it confidence in the final report if it turned confidence in the final report if it turned out confidence in the final report if it turned out that confidence in the final report if it turned out that the confidence in the final report if it turned out that the commissioners turned out that the commissioners had turned out that the commissioners had less turned out that the commissioners had less than turned out that the commissioners had less than 24 turned out that the commissioners had less than 24 hours turned out that the commissioners had less than 24 hours to turned out that the commissioners had less than 24 hours to consider had less than 24 hours to consider the had less than 24 hours to consider the report had less than 24 hours to consider the report before had less than 24 hours to consider the report before signing had less than 24 hours to consider the report before signing it had less than 24 hours to consider the report before signing it off? had less than 24 hours to consider the report before signing it off? I the report before signing it off? I think the report before signing it off? I think that the report before signing it off? I think that question the report before signing it off? I think that question really the report before signing it off? I think that question really should the report before signing it off? I think that question really should be think that question really should be directed think that question really should be directed at think that question really should be directed at the think that question really should be directed at the commission directed at the commission themselves. directed at the commission themselves. There directed at the commission themselves. There are directed at the commission themselves. There are - directed at the commission themselves. There are - there's directed at the commission themselves. There are - there's an themselves. There are - there's an extraordinary themselves. There are - there's an extraordinary body themselves. There are - there's an extraordinary body of themselves. There are - there's an extraordinary body of people. themselves. There are - there's an extraordinary body of people. They extraordinary body of people. They have extraordinary body of people. They have put extraordinary body of people. They have put a extraordinary body of people. They have put a huge extraordinary body of people. They have put a huge amount extraordinary body of people. They have put a huge amount of extraordinary body of people. They have put a huge amount of work extraordinary body of people. They have put a huge amount of work in have put a huge amount of work in the have put a huge amount of work in the preceding have put a huge amount of work in the preceding 18 have put a huge amount of work in the preceding 18 months. have put a huge amount of work in the preceding 18 months. I have put a huge amount of work in the preceding 18 months. I don't the preceding 18 months. I don't know the preceding 18 months. I don't know where the preceding 18 months. I don't know where he's the preceding 18 months. I don't know where he's getting the preceding 18 months. I don't know where he's getting his the preceding 18 months. I don't know where he's getting his rumours know where he's getting his rumours from. know where he's getting his rumours from. Is know where he's getting his rumours from. Is the know where he's getting his rumours from. Is the minister know where he's getting his rumours from. Is the minister aware know where he's getting his rumours from. Is the minister aware that know where he's getting his rumours from. Is the minister aware that Dr from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod Carr from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod Carr is from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod Carr is not from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod Carr is not a from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod Carr is not a Member from. Is the minister aware that Dr Rod Carr is not a Member of Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament and Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament and I Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament and I can't Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament and I can't ask Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament and I can't ask him Rod Carr is not a Member of Parliament and I can't ask him that Parliament and I can't ask him that question Parliament and I can't ask him that question in Parliament and I can't ask him that question in the Parliament and I can't ask him that question in the House? Parliament and I can't ask him that question in the House? Yes. question in the House? Yes. The question in the House? Yes. The Hon... question in the House? Yes. The Hon... question in the House? Yes. The Hon... ..before question in the House? Yes. The Hon... ..before the question in the House? Yes. The Hon... ..before the member question in the House? Yes. The Hon... ..before the member does, question in the House? Yes. The Hon... ..before the member does, I Hon... ..before the member does, I do Hon... ..before the member does, I do want Hon... ..before the member does, I do want to Hon... ..before the member does, I do want to - Hon... ..before the member does, I do want to - before Hon... ..before the member does, I do want to - before the Hon... ..before the member does, I do want to - before the member do want to - before the member speaks, do want to - before the member speaks, sincerely do want to - before the member speaks, sincerely apologise do want to - before the member speaks, sincerely apologise to do want to - before the member speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, I speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, I just speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, I just had speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, I just had a speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, I just had a complete speaks, sincerely apologise to Mr Smith, I just had a complete blank Smith, I just had a complete blank on Smith, I just had a complete blank on his Smith, I just had a complete blank on his name. Smith, I just had a complete blank on his name. And Smith, I just had a complete blank on his name. And I Smith, I just had a complete blank on his name. And I do Smith, I just had a complete blank on his name. And I do apologise. Smith, I just had a complete blank on his name. And I do apologise. The on his name. And I do apologise. The Hon... on his name. And I do apologise. The Hon... Thank on his name. And I do apologise. The Hon... Thank you, on his name. And I do apologise. The Hon... Thank you, Mr on his name. And I do apologise. The Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. on his name. And I do apologise. The Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's my Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's my pleasure Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's my pleasure to Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's my pleasure to welcome Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's my pleasure to welcome the Hon... Thank you, Mr Speaker. It's my pleasure to welcome the Climate my pleasure to welcome the Climate Change my pleasure to welcome the Climate Change Commission my pleasure to welcome the Climate Change Commission final my pleasure to welcome the Climate Change Commission final advice Change Commission final advice outlining Change Commission final advice outlining a Change Commission final advice outlining a blueprint Change Commission final advice outlining a blueprint for Change Commission final advice outlining a blueprint for tackling outlining a blueprint for tackling climate outlining a blueprint for tackling climate change outlining a blueprint for tackling climate change by outlining a blueprint for tackling climate change by achieving outlining a blueprint for tackling climate change by achieving the climate change by achieving the reduction climate change by achieving the reduction targets climate change by achieving the reduction targets agreed climate change by achieving the reduction targets agreed to climate change by achieving the reduction targets agreed to under reduction targets agreed to under the reduction targets agreed to under the zero reduction targets agreed to under the zero carbon reduction targets agreed to under the zero carbon act. reduction targets agreed to under the zero carbon act. Nearly reduction targets agreed to under the zero carbon act. Nearly six the zero carbon act. Nearly six years the zero carbon act. Nearly six years ago the zero carbon act. Nearly six years ago I the zero carbon act. Nearly six years ago I had the zero carbon act. Nearly six years ago I had the the zero carbon act. Nearly six years ago I had the privilege the zero carbon act. Nearly six years ago I had the privilege along years ago I had the privilege along with years ago I had the privilege along with the years ago I had the privilege along with the Hon years ago I had the privilege along with the Hon James years ago I had the privilege along with the Hon James Shaw, years ago I had the privilege along with the Hon James Shaw, as with the Hon James Shaw, as Opposition with the Hon James Shaw, as Opposition members with the Hon James Shaw, as Opposition members of with the Hon James Shaw, as Opposition members of the Opposition members of the Parliament, Opposition members of the Parliament, being Opposition members of the Parliament, being part Opposition members of the Parliament, being part of Opposition members of the Parliament, being part of New Parliament, being part of New Zealand's Parliament, being part of New Zealand's delegation Parliament, being part of New Zealand's delegation to Parliament, being part of New Zealand's delegation to the Parliament, being part of New Zealand's delegation to the Paris Zealand's delegation to the Paris climate Zealand's delegation to the Paris climate talks. Zealand's delegation to the Paris climate talks. Over Zealand's delegation to the Paris climate talks. Over the Zealand's delegation to the Paris climate talks. Over the course Zealand's delegation to the Paris climate talks. Over the course of climate talks. Over the course of the climate talks. Over the course of the two climate talks. Over the course of the two weeks, climate talks. Over the course of the two weeks, representatives climate talks. Over the course of the two weeks, representatives from the two weeks, representatives from governments the two weeks, representatives from governments and the two weeks, representatives from governments and civil the two weeks, representatives from governments and civil society the two weeks, representatives from governments and civil society came governments and civil society came together governments and civil society came together to governments and civil society came together to wrestle governments and civil society came together to wrestle with governments and civil society came together to wrestle with how governments and civil society came together to wrestle with how as governments and civil society came together to wrestle with how as a together to wrestle with how as a globe together to wrestle with how as a globe made together to wrestle with how as a globe made up together to wrestle with how as a globe made up of together to wrestle with how as a globe made up of individual together to wrestle with how as a globe made up of individual nations globe made up of individual nations we globe made up of individual nations we could globe made up of individual nations we could confront globe made up of individual nations we could confront climate globe made up of individual nations we could confront climate change. we could confront climate change. During we could confront climate change. During that we could confront climate change. During that time, we could confront climate change. During that time, there we could confront climate change. During that time, there were During that time, there were numerous During that time, there were numerous conversations During that time, there were numerous conversations about During that time, there were numerous conversations about how During that time, there were numerous conversations about how New numerous conversations about how New Zealand numerous conversations about how New Zealand could numerous conversations about how New Zealand could meet numerous conversations about how New Zealand could meet the numerous conversations about how New Zealand could meet the targets numerous conversations about how New Zealand could meet the targets we Zealand could meet the targets we were Zealand could meet the targets we were signing Zealand could meet the targets we were signing up Zealand could meet the targets we were signing up for. Zealand could meet the targets we were signing up for. And Zealand could meet the targets we were signing up for. And today Zealand could meet the targets we were signing up for. And today marks were signing up for. And today marks a were signing up for. And today marks a momentous were signing up for. And today marks a momentous milestone were signing up for. And today marks a momentous milestone in were signing up for. And today marks a momentous milestone in putting were signing up for. And today marks a momentous milestone in putting in a momentous milestone in putting in place a momentous milestone in putting in place the a momentous milestone in putting in place the plan a momentous milestone in putting in place the plan to a momentous milestone in putting in place the plan to do a momentous milestone in putting in place the plan to do just a momentous milestone in putting in place the plan to do just that. a momentous milestone in putting in place the plan to do just that. To place the plan to do just that. To meet place the plan to do just that. To meet our place the plan to do just that. To meet our obligations place the plan to do just that. To meet our obligations and place the plan to do just that. To meet our obligations and to place the plan to do just that. To meet our obligations and to prepare meet our obligations and to prepare for meet our obligations and to prepare for ambition. meet our obligations and to prepare for ambition. The meet our obligations and to prepare for ambition. The PM meet our obligations and to prepare for ambition. The PM has meet our obligations and to prepare for ambition. The PM has described for ambition. The PM has described this for ambition. The PM has described this report for ambition. The PM has described this report as for ambition. The PM has described this report as one for ambition. The PM has described this report as one of for ambition. The PM has described this report as one of the for ambition. The PM has described this report as one of the most this report as one of the most significant this report as one of the most significant she this report as one of the most significant she will this report as one of the most significant she will receive this report as one of the most significant she will receive as this report as one of the most significant she will receive as PM. significant she will receive as PM. Decisions significant she will receive as PM. Decisions we significant she will receive as PM. Decisions we make significant she will receive as PM. Decisions we make as significant she will receive as PM. Decisions we make as a significant she will receive as PM. Decisions we make as a result significant she will receive as PM. Decisions we make as a result of Decisions we make as a result of this Decisions we make as a result of this report Decisions we make as a result of this report will Decisions we make as a result of this report will shape Decisions we make as a result of this report will shape our Decisions we make as a result of this report will shape our future Decisions we make as a result of this report will shape our future as this report will shape our future as a this report will shape our future as a nation. this report will shape our future as a nation. Significantly, this report will shape our future as a nation. Significantly, it this report will shape our future as a nation. Significantly, it lays this report will shape our future as a nation. Significantly, it lays out a nation. Significantly, it lays out that a nation. Significantly, it lays out that not a nation. Significantly, it lays out that not taking a nation. Significantly, it lays out that not taking action a nation. Significantly, it lays out that not taking action will a nation. Significantly, it lays out that not taking action will cost a nation. Significantly, it lays out that not taking action will cost us. that not taking action will cost us. Cost that not taking action will cost us. Cost us that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to the that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to the tune that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to the tune of that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to the tune of 2.3% that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of that not taking action will cost us. Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP by Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP by 2050. Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP by 2050. In Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP by 2050. In other Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP by 2050. In other words, Cost us to the tune of 2.3% of GDP by 2050. In other words, delaying by 2050. In other words, delaying action by 2050. In other words, delaying action will by 2050. In other words, delaying action will make by 2050. In other words, delaying action will make of by 2050. In other words, delaying action will make of the action will make of the decarbonising action will make of the decarbonising job action will make of the decarbonising job harder action will make of the decarbonising job harder and action will make of the decarbonising job harder and more decarbonising job harder and more expensive decarbonising job harder and more expensive in decarbonising job harder and more expensive in the decarbonising job harder and more expensive in the long decarbonising job harder and more expensive in the long run. decarbonising job harder and more expensive in the long run. So decarbonising job harder and more expensive in the long run. So this expensive in the long run. So this is expensive in the long run. So this is not expensive in the long run. So this is not only expensive in the long run. So this is not only a expensive in the long run. So this is not only a blueprint expensive in the long run. So this is not only a blueprint for expensive in the long run. So this is not only a blueprint for change, is not only a blueprint for change, it is not only a blueprint for change, it is is not only a blueprint for change, it is an is not only a blueprint for change, it is an opportunity is not only a blueprint for change, it is an opportunity for is not only a blueprint for change, it is an opportunity for us is not only a blueprint for change, it is an opportunity for us not is not only a blueprint for change, it is an opportunity for us not to it is an opportunity for us not to squander. it is an opportunity for us not to squander. It it is an opportunity for us not to squander. It also it is an opportunity for us not to squander. It also tells it is an opportunity for us not to squander. It also tells us it is an opportunity for us not to squander. It also tells us that squander. It also tells us that meeting squander. It also tells us that meeting targets squander. It also tells us that meeting targets is squander. It also tells us that meeting targets is achievable. squander. It also tells us that meeting targets is achievable. We meeting targets is achievable. We already meeting targets is achievable. We already have meeting targets is achievable. We already have the meeting targets is achievable. We already have the tools meeting targets is achievable. We already have the tools we meeting targets is achievable. We already have the tools we need already have the tools we need available already have the tools we need available to already have the tools we need available to us. already have the tools we need available to us. We already have the tools we need available to us. We don't already have the tools we need available to us. We don't need already have the tools we need available to us. We don't need any available to us. We don't need any magic available to us. We don't need any magic wands, available to us. We don't need any magic wands, Mr available to us. We don't need any magic wands, Mr Speaker. available to us. We don't need any magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's available to us. We don't need any magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more is magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more is the magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more is the Government magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more is the Government is magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more is the Government is already magic wands, Mr Speaker. What's more is the Government is already taking is the Government is already taking action is the Government is already taking action in is the Government is already taking action in the is the Government is already taking action in the right is the Government is already taking action in the right areas. is the Government is already taking action in the right areas. But, is the Government is already taking action in the right areas. But, we action in the right areas. But, we must action in the right areas. But, we must move action in the right areas. But, we must move faster action in the right areas. But, we must move faster and action in the right areas. But, we must move faster and there action in the right areas. But, we must move faster and there is action in the right areas. But, we must move faster and there is much must move faster and there is much more must move faster and there is much more work must move faster and there is much more work to must move faster and there is much more work to do. must move faster and there is much more work to do. We must move faster and there is much more work to do. We have must move faster and there is much more work to do. We have begun. must move faster and there is much more work to do. We have begun. We more work to do. We have begun. We have more work to do. We have begun. We have banned more work to do. We have begun. We have banned new more work to do. We have begun. We have banned new offshore more work to do. We have begun. We have banned new offshore oil more work to do. We have begun. We have banned new offshore oil and more work to do. We have begun. We have banned new offshore oil and gas have banned new offshore oil and gas exploration, have banned new offshore oil and gas exploration, we have banned new offshore oil and gas exploration, we have have banned new offshore oil and gas exploration, we have passed have banned new offshore oil and gas exploration, we have passed the have banned new offshore oil and gas exploration, we have passed the zero exploration, we have passed the zero carbon exploration, we have passed the zero carbon act, exploration, we have passed the zero carbon act, we exploration, we have passed the zero carbon act, we have exploration, we have passed the zero carbon act, we have established exploration, we have passed the zero carbon act, we have established the carbon act, we have established the Climate carbon act, we have established the Climate Change carbon act, we have established the Climate Change Commission, carbon act, we have established the Climate Change Commission, we carbon act, we have established the Climate Change Commission, we have Climate Change Commission, we have doubled Climate Change Commission, we have doubled our Climate Change Commission, we have doubled our climate Climate Change Commission, we have doubled our climate change Climate Change Commission, we have doubled our climate change aid Climate Change Commission, we have doubled our climate change aid to doubled our climate change aid to the doubled our climate change aid to the Pacific, doubled our climate change aid to the Pacific, we doubled our climate change aid to the Pacific, we have doubled our climate change aid to the Pacific, we have overhauled doubled our climate change aid to the Pacific, we have overhauled the the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, we the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, we have the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, we have overseen the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, we have overseen the the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, we have overseen the more the Pacific, we have overhauled the ETS, we have overseen the more than ETS, we have overseen the more than doubling ETS, we have overseen the more than doubling of ETS, we have overseen the more than doubling of the ETS, we have overseen the more than doubling of the carbon ETS, we have overseen the more than doubling of the carbon price, ETS, we have overseen the more than doubling of the carbon price, we doubling of the carbon price, we have doubling of the carbon price, we have ploughed doubling of the carbon price, we have ploughed billions doubling of the carbon price, we have ploughed billions into have ploughed billions into infrastructure have ploughed billions into infrastructure for have ploughed billions into infrastructure for buses have ploughed billions into infrastructure for buses and have ploughed billions into infrastructure for buses and trains, infrastructure for buses and trains, cycling infrastructure for buses and trains, cycling and infrastructure for buses and trains, cycling and walking, infrastructure for buses and trains, cycling and walking, we infrastructure for buses and trains, cycling and walking, we have infrastructure for buses and trains, cycling and walking, we have helped cycling and walking, we have helped businesses cycling and walking, we have helped businesses switch cycling and walking, we have helped businesses switch to cycling and walking, we have helped businesses switch to clean cycling and walking, we have helped businesses switch to clean energy businesses switch to clean energy and businesses switch to clean energy and invested businesses switch to clean energy and invested in businesses switch to clean energy and invested in EV businesses switch to clean energy and invested in EV charging and invested in EV charging infrastructure and invested in EV charging infrastructure and and invested in EV charging infrastructure and brought and invested in EV charging infrastructure and brought back and invested in EV charging infrastructure and brought back the infrastructure and brought back the mandate infrastructure and brought back the mandate to infrastructure and brought back the mandate to include infrastructure and brought back the mandate to include biofuels infrastructure and brought back the mandate to include biofuels in mandate to include biofuels in petrol. mandate to include biofuels in petrol. The mandate to include biofuels in petrol. The commission mandate to include biofuels in petrol. The commission says mandate to include biofuels in petrol. The commission says we mandate to include biofuels in petrol. The commission says we must petrol. The commission says we must build petrol. The commission says we must build on petrol. The commission says we must build on the petrol. The commission says we must build on the progress petrol. The commission says we must build on the progress and petrol. The commission says we must build on the progress and this petrol. The commission says we must build on the progress and this work build on the progress and this work needs build on the progress and this work needs to build on the progress and this work needs to start build on the progress and this work needs to start now. build on the progress and this work needs to start now. We build on the progress and this work needs to start now. We don't build on the progress and this work needs to start now. We don't need needs to start now. We don't need miracle needs to start now. We don't need miracle technologies, needs to start now. We don't need miracle technologies, but needs to start now. We don't need miracle technologies, but we needs to start now. We don't need miracle technologies, but we do needs to start now. We don't need miracle technologies, but we do need miracle technologies, but we do need to miracle technologies, but we do need to get miracle technologies, but we do need to get them miracle technologies, but we do need to get them into miracle technologies, but we do need to get them into place. miracle technologies, but we do need to get them into place. Further to get them into place. Further steps to get them into place. Further steps need to get them into place. Further steps need to to get them into place. Further steps need to be to get them into place. Further steps need to be taken to get them into place. Further steps need to be taken to to get them into place. Further steps need to be taken to address steps need to be taken to address the steps need to be taken to address the unevenly steps need to be taken to address the unevenly distributed steps need to be taken to address the unevenly distributed impacts the unevenly distributed impacts climate the unevenly distributed impacts climate change the unevenly distributed impacts climate change on the unevenly distributed impacts climate change on New the unevenly distributed impacts climate change on New Zealanders, climate change on New Zealanders, including climate change on New Zealanders, including our climate change on New Zealanders, including our most climate change on New Zealanders, including our most vulnerable. including our most vulnerable. Government including our most vulnerable. Government needs including our most vulnerable. Government needs to including our most vulnerable. Government needs to signal including our most vulnerable. Government needs to signal policies Government needs to signal policies early Government needs to signal policies early to Government needs to signal policies early to give Government needs to signal policies early to give business Government needs to signal policies early to give business and early to give business and communities early to give business and communities time early to give business and communities time to early to give business and communities time to adjust. early to give business and communities time to adjust. And early to give business and communities time to adjust. And we communities time to adjust. And we need communities time to adjust. And we need a communities time to adjust. And we need a clear communities time to adjust. And we need a clear and communities time to adjust. And we need a clear and strong communities time to adjust. And we need a clear and strong partnership need a clear and strong partnership with need a clear and strong partnership with local need a clear and strong partnership with local government need a clear and strong partnership with local government and need a clear and strong partnership with local government and with need a clear and strong partnership with local government and with iwi with local government and with iwi Maori. with local government and with iwi Maori. As with local government and with iwi Maori. As energy with local government and with iwi Maori. As energy minister, with local government and with iwi Maori. As energy minister, I with local government and with iwi Maori. As energy minister, I also Maori. As energy minister, I also welcome Maori. As energy minister, I also welcome the Maori. As energy minister, I also welcome the recommendation Maori. As energy minister, I also welcome the recommendation we welcome the recommendation we develop welcome the recommendation we develop a welcome the recommendation we develop a national welcome the recommendation we develop a national energy welcome the recommendation we develop a national energy strategy. develop a national energy strategy. This develop a national energy strategy. This is develop a national energy strategy. This is with develop a national energy strategy. This is with the develop a national energy strategy. This is with the other develop a national energy strategy. This is with the other 33 This is with the other 33 recommendations This is with the other 33 recommendations will This is with the other 33 recommendations will be This is with the other 33 recommendations will be carefully recommendations will be carefully considered recommendations will be carefully considered and recommendations will be carefully considered and consulted recommendations will be carefully considered and consulted on recommendations will be carefully considered and consulted on over recommendations will be carefully considered and consulted on over the considered and consulted on over the coming considered and consulted on over the coming months. considered and consulted on over the coming months. So considered and consulted on over the coming months. So to considered and consulted on over the coming months. So to conclude, considered and consulted on over the coming months. So to conclude, now coming months. So to conclude, now that coming months. So to conclude, now that we coming months. So to conclude, now that we have coming months. So to conclude, now that we have the coming months. So to conclude, now that we have the commission's that we have the commission's advice, that we have the commission's advice, we that we have the commission's advice, we have that we have the commission's advice, we have an that we have the commission's advice, we have an amazing advice, we have an amazing opportunity advice, we have an amazing opportunity and advice, we have an amazing opportunity and chance advice, we have an amazing opportunity and chance to advice, we have an amazing opportunity and chance to transform opportunity and chance to transform our opportunity and chance to transform our economy opportunity and chance to transform our economy as opportunity and chance to transform our economy as well opportunity and chance to transform our economy as well as opportunity and chance to transform our economy as well as the opportunity and chance to transform our economy as well as the lives opportunity and chance to transform our economy as well as the lives of our economy as well as the lives of our our economy as well as the lives of our children, our economy as well as the lives of our children, our our economy as well as the lives of our children, our grandchildren, our economy as well as the lives of our children, our grandchildren, but our children, our grandchildren, but we our children, our grandchildren, but we must our children, our grandchildren, but we must work our children, our grandchildren, but we must work with our children, our grandchildren, but we must work with renewed our children, our grandchildren, but we must work with renewed urgency we must work with renewed urgency and we must work with renewed urgency and determination. we must work with renewed urgency and determination. The we must work with renewed urgency and determination. The job we must work with renewed urgency and determination. The job is we must work with renewed urgency and determination. The job is not and determination. The job is not yet and determination. The job is not yet done. and determination. The job is not yet done. David and determination. The job is not yet done. David Seymour. and determination. The job is not yet done. David Seymour. Well, and determination. The job is not yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank you, yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank you, Mr yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank you, Mr Speaker. yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank you, Mr Speaker. The yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank you, Mr Speaker. The ACT yet done. David Seymour. Well, thank you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party stands you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party stands strongly you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party stands strongly opposed you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party stands strongly opposed to you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party stands strongly opposed to the you, Mr Speaker. The ACT Party stands strongly opposed to the zero stands strongly opposed to the zero carbon stands strongly opposed to the zero carbon act stands strongly opposed to the zero carbon act policy stands strongly opposed to the zero carbon act policy to stands strongly opposed to the zero carbon act policy to this carbon act policy to this commission, carbon act policy to this commission, and carbon act policy to this commission, and to carbon act policy to this commission, and to its carbon act policy to this commission, and to its report. carbon act policy to this commission, and to its report. Why, commission, and to its report. Why, basically commission, and to its report. Why, basically three commission, and to its report. Why, basically three reasons commission, and to its report. Why, basically three reasons and commission, and to its report. Why, basically three reasons and three basically three reasons and three big basically three reasons and three big problems basically three reasons and three big problems with basically three reasons and three big problems with this basically three reasons and three big problems with this initiative. big problems with this initiative. The big problems with this initiative. The first big problems with this initiative. The first is big problems with this initiative. The first is that big problems with this initiative. The first is that the big problems with this initiative. The first is that the way big problems with this initiative. The first is that the way it big problems with this initiative. The first is that the way it tries The first is that the way it tries to The first is that the way it tries to micromanage The first is that the way it tries to micromanage and The first is that the way it tries to micromanage and plan The first is that the way it tries to micromanage and plan the The first is that the way it tries to micromanage and plan the economy to micromanage and plan the economy well to micromanage and plan the economy well into to micromanage and plan the economy well into the to micromanage and plan the economy well into the future to micromanage and plan the economy well into the future is to micromanage and plan the economy well into the future is completely well into the future is completely indefensible. well into the future is completely indefensible. I well into the future is completely indefensible. I just well into the future is completely indefensible. I just heard well into the future is completely indefensible. I just heard the indefensible. I just heard the minister indefensible. I just heard the minister of indefensible. I just heard the minister of energy indefensible. I just heard the minister of energy and indefensible. I just heard the minister of energy and the indefensible. I just heard the minister of energy and the Minister minister of energy and the Minister of minister of energy and the Minister of Climate minister of energy and the Minister of Climate Change minister of energy and the Minister of Climate Change get minister of energy and the Minister of Climate Change get up minister of energy and the Minister of Climate Change get up and minister of energy and the Minister of Climate Change get up and say of Climate Change get up and say that of Climate Change get up and say that these of Climate Change get up and say that these actions of Climate Change get up and say that these actions will of Climate Change get up and say that these actions will save of Climate Change get up and say that these actions will save the that these actions will save the economy that these actions will save the economy 2.3% that these actions will save the economy 2.3% in that these actions will save the economy 2.3% in 2050. that these actions will save the economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? that these actions will save the economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any of economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any of them economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any of them name economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any of them name any economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any of them name any economists economy 2.3% in 2050. Really? Can any of them name any economists in any of them name any economists in the any of them name any economists in the past any of them name any economists in the past century any of them name any economists in the past century who any of them name any economists in the past century who have any of them name any economists in the past century who have been any of them name any economists in the past century who have been able the past century who have been able to the past century who have been able to forecast the past century who have been able to forecast GDP the past century who have been able to forecast GDP 29 the past century who have been able to forecast GDP 29 years the past century who have been able to forecast GDP 29 years out the past century who have been able to forecast GDP 29 years out to the past century who have been able to forecast GDP 29 years out to the to forecast GDP 29 years out to the nearest to forecast GDP 29 years out to the nearest 0.1%? to forecast GDP 29 years out to the nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And all nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And all of nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And all of the nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And all of the assumptions nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And all of the assumptions have nearest 0.1%? <INTERRUPTION> And all of the assumptions have been And all of the assumptions have been - And all of the assumptions have been - and And all of the assumptions have been - and David And all of the assumptions have been - and David Parker And all of the assumptions have been - and David Parker says And all of the assumptions have been - and David Parker says Sir And all of the assumptions have been - and David Parker says Sir Roger - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he is - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he is the - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he is the only - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he is the only one - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he is the only one and - and David Parker says Sir Roger Douglas, he is the only one and he Douglas, he is the only one and he doesn't Douglas, he is the only one and he doesn't agree. Douglas, he is the only one and he doesn't agree. Sir Douglas, he is the only one and he doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas, he is the only one and he doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas wouldn't doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas wouldn't agree doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas wouldn't agree with doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas wouldn't agree with them doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas wouldn't agree with them either. doesn't agree. Sir Roger Douglas wouldn't agree with them either. The wouldn't agree with them either. The fact wouldn't agree with them either. The fact is, wouldn't agree with them either. The fact is, like wouldn't agree with them either. The fact is, like all wouldn't agree with them either. The fact is, like all of wouldn't agree with them either. The fact is, like all of the wouldn't agree with them either. The fact is, like all of the assumptions fact is, like all of the assumptions that fact is, like all of the assumptions that are fact is, like all of the assumptions that are put fact is, like all of the assumptions that are put into fact is, like all of the assumptions that are put into this fact is, like all of the assumptions that are put into this plan, fact is, like all of the assumptions that are put into this plan, they fact is, like all of the assumptions that are put into this plan, they do that are put into this plan, they do not that are put into this plan, they do not hold that are put into this plan, they do not hold water. that are put into this plan, they do not hold water. The that are put into this plan, they do not hold water. The micromanagement, not hold water. The micromanagement, the not hold water. The micromanagement, the banning not hold water. The micromanagement, the banning of not hold water. The micromanagement, the banning of technology, not hold water. The micromanagement, the banning of technology, is not hold water. The micromanagement, the banning of technology, is the the banning of technology, is the wrong the banning of technology, is the wrong way the banning of technology, is the wrong way to the banning of technology, is the wrong way to reduce the banning of technology, is the wrong way to reduce emissions. wrong way to reduce emissions. Because wrong way to reduce emissions. Because this wrong way to reduce emissions. Because this Government wrong way to reduce emissions. Because this Government now wrong way to reduce emissions. Because this Government now has wrong way to reduce emissions. Because this Government now has two Because this Government now has two contradictory Because this Government now has two contradictory climate Because this Government now has two contradictory climate change contradictory climate change policies. contradictory climate change policies. One contradictory climate change policies. One is contradictory climate change policies. One is the contradictory climate change policies. One is the emissions policies. One is the emissions trading policies. One is the emissions trading scheme, policies. One is the emissions trading scheme, which policies. One is the emissions trading scheme, which sets policies. One is the emissions trading scheme, which sets a policies. One is the emissions trading scheme, which sets a cap policies. One is the emissions trading scheme, which sets a cap on trading scheme, which sets a cap on total trading scheme, which sets a cap on total emissions. trading scheme, which sets a cap on total emissions. And trading scheme, which sets a cap on total emissions. And if trading scheme, which sets a cap on total emissions. And if the total emissions. And if the objective total emissions. And if the objective is total emissions. And if the objective is to total emissions. And if the objective is to reduce total emissions. And if the objective is to reduce total objective is to reduce total emissions objective is to reduce total emissions in objective is to reduce total emissions in New objective is to reduce total emissions in New Zealand, objective is to reduce total emissions in New Zealand, the objective is to reduce total emissions in New Zealand, the right emissions in New Zealand, the right thing emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to do emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to do is emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to do is to emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to do is to set emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to do is to set that emissions in New Zealand, the right thing to do is to set that cap, thing to do is to set that cap, auction thing to do is to set that cap, auction off thing to do is to set that cap, auction off the thing to do is to set that cap, auction off the units, thing to do is to set that cap, auction off the units, let thing to do is to set that cap, auction off the units, let people auction off the units, let people respond auction off the units, let people respond to auction off the units, let people respond to the auction off the units, let people respond to the price auction off the units, let people respond to the price signals auction off the units, let people respond to the price signals and respond to the price signals and make respond to the price signals and make choices respond to the price signals and make choices about respond to the price signals and make choices about how respond to the price signals and make choices about how they respond to the price signals and make choices about how they live respond to the price signals and make choices about how they live and make choices about how they live and do make choices about how they live and do their make choices about how they live and do their work make choices about how they live and do their work and make choices about how they live and do their work and build make choices about how they live and do their work and build their do their work and build their businesses do their work and build their businesses within do their work and build their businesses within that do their work and build their businesses within that constraint. businesses within that constraint. The businesses within that constraint. The second businesses within that constraint. The second policy, businesses within that constraint. The second policy, which businesses within that constraint. The second policy, which works The second policy, which works against The second policy, which works against it, The second policy, which works against it, is The second policy, which works against it, is the The second policy, which works against it, is the zero The second policy, which works against it, is the zero carbon The second policy, which works against it, is the zero carbon act, against it, is the zero carbon act, that against it, is the zero carbon act, that requires against it, is the zero carbon act, that requires a against it, is the zero carbon act, that requires a plethora against it, is the zero carbon act, that requires a plethora of against it, is the zero carbon act, that requires a plethora of new that requires a plethora of new bureaucracies that requires a plethora of new bureaucracies and that requires a plethora of new bureaucracies and micromanagement bureaucracies and micromanagement that bureaucracies and micromanagement that will bureaucracies and micromanagement that will try bureaucracies and micromanagement that will try and bureaucracies and micromanagement that will try and control bureaucracies and micromanagement that will try and control each that will try and control each sector that will try and control each sector and that will try and control each sector and say that will try and control each sector and say there that will try and control each sector and say there should that will try and control each sector and say there should be that will try and control each sector and say there should be 13% sector and say there should be 13% fewer sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows and sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows and the sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows and the type sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows and the type of sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows and the type of car sector and say there should be 13% fewer cows and the type of car you fewer cows and the type of car you can fewer cows and the type of car you can import fewer cows and the type of car you can import should fewer cows and the type of car you can import should change fewer cows and the type of car you can import should change in fewer cows and the type of car you can import should change in this can import should change in this year, can import should change in this year, and can import should change in this year, and you can import should change in this year, and you should can import should change in this year, and you should cook can import should change in this year, and you should cook your year, and you should cook your burgers year, and you should cook your burgers at year, and you should cook your burgers at a year, and you should cook your burgers at a restaurant year, and you should cook your burgers at a restaurant with year, and you should cook your burgers at a restaurant with this burgers at a restaurant with this type burgers at a restaurant with this type of burgers at a restaurant with this type of energy burgers at a restaurant with this type of energy source. burgers at a restaurant with this type of energy source. And burgers at a restaurant with this type of energy source. And all burgers at a restaurant with this type of energy source. And all of type of energy source. And all of that type of energy source. And all of that micromanagement, type of energy source. And all of that micromanagement, not type of energy source. And all of that micromanagement, not only type of energy source. And all of that micromanagement, not only will that micromanagement, not only will turn that micromanagement, not only will turn out that micromanagement, not only will turn out to that micromanagement, not only will turn out to be that micromanagement, not only will turn out to be wrong, that micromanagement, not only will turn out to be wrong, because that micromanagement, not only will turn out to be wrong, because the turn out to be wrong, because the predictions turn out to be wrong, because the predictions of turn out to be wrong, because the predictions of the turn out to be wrong, because the predictions of the future turn out to be wrong, because the predictions of the future technology predictions of the future technology so predictions of the future technology so often predictions of the future technology so often are, predictions of the future technology so often are, but predictions of the future technology so often are, but also predictions of the future technology so often are, but also they predictions of the future technology so often are, but also they are so often are, but also they are pointless, so often are, but also they are pointless, to so often are, but also they are pointless, to the so often are, but also they are pointless, to the extent so often are, but also they are pointless, to the extent that so often are, but also they are pointless, to the extent that any so often are, but also they are pointless, to the extent that any of pointless, to the extent that any of them pointless, to the extent that any of them do pointless, to the extent that any of them do reduce pointless, to the extent that any of them do reduce emissions, pointless, to the extent that any of them do reduce emissions, they pointless, to the extent that any of them do reduce emissions, they free them do reduce emissions, they free up them do reduce emissions, they free up carbon them do reduce emissions, they free up carbon units them do reduce emissions, they free up carbon units that them do reduce emissions, they free up carbon units that someone them do reduce emissions, they free up carbon units that someone else up carbon units that someone else can up carbon units that someone else can use up carbon units that someone else can use under up carbon units that someone else can use under the up carbon units that someone else can use under the same up carbon units that someone else can use under the same cap. up carbon units that someone else can use under the same cap. There's can use under the same cap. There's two can use under the same cap. There's two contradictory can use under the same cap. There's two contradictory policies can use under the same cap. There's two contradictory policies this two contradictory policies this Government two contradictory policies this Government has. two contradictory policies this Government has. Added two contradictory policies this Government has. Added together, two contradictory policies this Government has. Added together, they Government has. Added together, they don't Government has. Added together, they don't work. Government has. Added together, they don't work. The Government has. Added together, they don't work. The second Government has. Added together, they don't work. The second problem Government has. Added together, they don't work. The second problem is don't work. The second problem is the don't work. The second problem is the total don't work. The second problem is the total disconnect don't work. The second problem is the total disconnect from don't work. The second problem is the total disconnect from the don't work. The second problem is the total disconnect from the rest the total disconnect from the rest of the total disconnect from the rest of the the total disconnect from the rest of the world. the total disconnect from the rest of the world. This the total disconnect from the rest of the world. This report the total disconnect from the rest of the world. This report issued of the world. This report issued today of the world. This report issued today says of the world. This report issued today says that of the world. This report issued today says that we of the world. This report issued today says that we should of the world. This report issued today says that we should not of the world. This report issued today says that we should not in of the world. This report issued today says that we should not in New today says that we should not in New Zealand today says that we should not in New Zealand be today says that we should not in New Zealand be able today says that we should not in New Zealand be able to today says that we should not in New Zealand be able to use today says that we should not in New Zealand be able to use foreign Zealand be able to use foreign carbon Zealand be able to use foreign carbon credits. Zealand be able to use foreign carbon credits. Really? Zealand be able to use foreign carbon credits. Really? What's Zealand be able to use foreign carbon credits. Really? What's it carbon credits. Really? What's it saying carbon credits. Really? What's it saying is carbon credits. Really? What's it saying is the carbon credits. Really? What's it saying is the Government carbon credits. Really? What's it saying is the Government would carbon credits. Really? What's it saying is the Government would like saying is the Government would like New saying is the Government would like New Zealanders saying is the Government would like New Zealanders to saying is the Government would like New Zealanders to pay saying is the Government would like New Zealanders to pay people saying is the Government would like New Zealanders to pay people in New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's Bay New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's Bay to New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's Bay to sell New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's Bay to sell up New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's Bay to sell up their New Zealanders to pay people in Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep and Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep and beef Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep and beef farms Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep and beef farms and Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep and beef farms and turn Hawke's Bay to sell up their sheep and beef farms and turn a and beef farms and turn a monoculture and beef farms and turn a monoculture of and beef farms and turn a monoculture of more and beef farms and turn a monoculture of more pine and beef farms and turn a monoculture of more pine trees, monoculture of more pine trees, instead monoculture of more pine trees, instead of monoculture of more pine trees, instead of paying monoculture of more pine trees, instead of paying Brazilians monoculture of more pine trees, instead of paying Brazilians to instead of paying Brazilians to recede instead of paying Brazilians to recede the instead of paying Brazilians to recede the Amazon, instead of paying Brazilians to recede the Amazon, or instead of paying Brazilians to recede the Amazon, or pay instead of paying Brazilians to recede the Amazon, or pay them instead of paying Brazilians to recede the Amazon, or pay them to recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop burning recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop burning it recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop burning it down, recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop burning it down, is recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop burning it down, is it recede the Amazon, or pay them to stop burning it down, is it really stop burning it down, is it really the stop burning it down, is it really the right stop burning it down, is it really the right answer stop burning it down, is it really the right answer for stop burning it down, is it really the right answer for someone stop burning it down, is it really the right answer for someone who the right answer for someone who wants the right answer for someone who wants to the right answer for someone who wants to think the right answer for someone who wants to think global the right answer for someone who wants to think global and the right answer for someone who wants to think global and act the right answer for someone who wants to think global and act local? wants to think global and act local? <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Also <INTERRUPTION> Also completely <INTERRUPTION> Also completely wrong <INTERRUPTION> Also completely wrong our Also completely wrong our competitors Also completely wrong our competitors can Also completely wrong our competitors can do Also completely wrong our competitors can do that, Also completely wrong our competitors can do that, and Also completely wrong our competitors can do that, and buy competitors can do that, and buy cheaper competitors can do that, and buy cheaper carbon competitors can do that, and buy cheaper carbon credits, competitors can do that, and buy cheaper carbon credits, exposing competitors can do that, and buy cheaper carbon credits, exposing New cheaper carbon credits, exposing New Zealand cheaper carbon credits, exposing New Zealand business. cheaper carbon credits, exposing New Zealand business. The cheaper carbon credits, exposing New Zealand business. The third cheaper carbon credits, exposing New Zealand business. The third problem Zealand business. The third problem is Zealand business. The third problem is the Zealand business. The third problem is the goal Zealand business. The third problem is the goal is Zealand business. The third problem is the goal is set Zealand business. The third problem is the goal is set by Zealand business. The third problem is the goal is set by New Zealand business. The third problem is the goal is set by New Zealand Zealand business. The third problem is the goal is set by New Zealand as is the goal is set by New Zealand as if is the goal is set by New Zealand as if we're is the goal is set by New Zealand as if we're totally is the goal is set by New Zealand as if we're totally isolated is the goal is set by New Zealand as if we're totally isolated from is the goal is set by New Zealand as if we're totally isolated from the if we're totally isolated from the global if we're totally isolated from the global economy if we're totally isolated from the global economy and if we're totally isolated from the global economy and climate. if we're totally isolated from the global economy and climate. It if we're totally isolated from the global economy and climate. It says global economy and climate. It says that global economy and climate. It says that New global economy and climate. It says that New Zealand global economy and climate. It says that New Zealand agriculture global economy and climate. It says that New Zealand agriculture and global economy and climate. It says that New Zealand agriculture and New that New Zealand agriculture and New Zealand that New Zealand agriculture and New Zealand business, that New Zealand agriculture and New Zealand business, New that New Zealand agriculture and New Zealand business, New Zealand Zealand business, New Zealand transport Zealand business, New Zealand transport and Zealand business, New Zealand transport and energy, Zealand business, New Zealand transport and energy, must Zealand business, New Zealand transport and energy, must reach transport and energy, must reach certain transport and energy, must reach certain goals, transport and energy, must reach certain goals, set transport and energy, must reach certain goals, set in transport and energy, must reach certain goals, set in legislation, certain goals, set in legislation, regardless certain goals, set in legislation, regardless of certain goals, set in legislation, regardless of what certain goals, set in legislation, regardless of what the certain goals, set in legislation, regardless of what the rest certain goals, set in legislation, regardless of what the rest of certain goals, set in legislation, regardless of what the rest of the regardless of what the rest of the world regardless of what the rest of the world does. regardless of what the rest of the world does. So regardless of what the rest of the world does. So they're regardless of what the rest of the world does. So they're happy regardless of what the rest of the world does. So they're happy to regardless of what the rest of the world does. So they're happy to say world does. So they're happy to say if world does. So they're happy to say if the world does. So they're happy to say if the rest world does. So they're happy to say if the rest of world does. So they're happy to say if the rest of the world does. So they're happy to say if the rest of the world world does. So they're happy to say if the rest of the world decides world does. So they're happy to say if the rest of the world decides not if the rest of the world decides not to if the rest of the world decides not to meet if the rest of the world decides not to meet these if the rest of the world decides not to meet these targets, if the rest of the world decides not to meet these targets, New if the rest of the world decides not to meet these targets, New Zealand to meet these targets, New Zealand should to meet these targets, New Zealand should destroy to meet these targets, New Zealand should destroy its to meet these targets, New Zealand should destroy its economy to meet these targets, New Zealand should destroy its economy and to meet these targets, New Zealand should destroy its economy and the should destroy its economy and the way should destroy its economy and the way of should destroy its economy and the way of life should destroy its economy and the way of life of should destroy its economy and the way of life of its should destroy its economy and the way of life of its people should destroy its economy and the way of life of its people to should destroy its economy and the way of life of its people to reach way of life of its people to reach these way of life of its people to reach these targets way of life of its people to reach these targets that way of life of its people to reach these targets that no-one way of life of its people to reach these targets that no-one else way of life of its people to reach these targets that no-one else is these targets that no-one else is seeking. these targets that no-one else is seeking. And these targets that no-one else is seeking. And therefore, these targets that no-one else is seeking. And therefore, New these targets that no-one else is seeking. And therefore, New Zealand seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has no seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has no impact. seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has no impact. That's seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has no impact. That's why seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has no impact. That's why we seeking. And therefore, New Zealand has no impact. That's why we oppose has no impact. That's why we oppose it. has no impact. That's why we oppose it. And has no impact. That's why we oppose it. And those has no impact. That's why we oppose it. And those are has no impact. That's why we oppose it. And those are the has no impact. That's why we oppose it. And those are the three has no impact. That's why we oppose it. And those are the three things it. And those are the three things that it. And those are the three things that are it. And those are the three things that are wrong it. And those are the three things that are wrong with it. And those are the three things that are wrong with it. it. And those are the three things that are wrong with it. But it. And those are the three things that are wrong with it. But I it. And those are the three things that are wrong with it. But I just that are wrong with it. But I just like that are wrong with it. But I just like to that are wrong with it. But I just like to quickly that are wrong with it. But I just like to quickly ask that are wrong with it. But I just like to quickly ask the that are wrong with it. But I just like to quickly ask the minister that are wrong with it. But I just like to quickly ask the minister a like to quickly ask the minister a question like to quickly ask the minister a question - like to quickly ask the minister a question - does like to quickly ask the minister a question - does he like to quickly ask the minister a question - does he think, like to quickly ask the minister a question - does he think, not like to quickly ask the minister a question - does he think, not the question - does he think, not the commissioner question - does he think, not the commissioner - question - does he think, not the commissioner - does question - does he think, not the commissioner - does he question - does he think, not the commissioner - does he think question - does he think, not the commissioner - does he think the question - does he think, not the commissioner - does he think the way commissioner - does he think the way that commissioner - does he think the way that select commissioner - does he think the way that select journalists commissioner - does he think the way that select journalists were commissioner - does he think the way that select journalists were given that select journalists were given access that select journalists were given access to that select journalists were given access to the that select journalists were given access to the material that select journalists were given access to the material beforehand, access to the material beforehand, and access to the material beforehand, and the access to the material beforehand, and the 40 access to the material beforehand, and the 40 minutes access to the material beforehand, and the 40 minutes that access to the material beforehand, and the 40 minutes that other and the 40 minutes that other journalists and the 40 minutes that other journalists were and the 40 minutes that other journalists were given and the 40 minutes that other journalists were given to and the 40 minutes that other journalists were given to read and the 40 minutes that other journalists were given to read the journalists were given to read the material journalists were given to read the material before journalists were given to read the material before questioning journalists were given to read the material before questioning the journalists were given to read the material before questioning the PM, material before questioning the PM, does material before questioning the PM, does he material before questioning the PM, does he think material before questioning the PM, does he think that material before questioning the PM, does he think that was material before questioning the PM, does he think that was adequate? material before questioning the PM, does he think that was adequate? The does he think that was adequate? The Hon does he think that was adequate? The Hon James does he think that was adequate? The Hon James Shaw. does he think that was adequate? The Hon James Shaw. Mr does he think that was adequate? The Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, does he think that was adequate? The Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup was Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup was provided Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup was provided in Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup was provided in much Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup was provided in much the Hon James Shaw. Mr Speaker, the lockup was provided in much the same lockup was provided in much the same conditions lockup was provided in much the same conditions as lockup was provided in much the same conditions as a lockup was provided in much the same conditions as a budget lockup was provided in much the same conditions as a budget lockup. lockup was provided in much the same conditions as a budget lockup. So lockup was provided in much the same conditions as a budget lockup. So we conditions as a budget lockup. So we have conditions as a budget lockup. So we have take conditions as a budget lockup. So we have take that conditions as a budget lockup. So we have take that somewhat have take that somewhat non-committal have take that somewhat non-committal response have take that somewhat non-committal response he have take that somewhat non-committal response he does have take that somewhat non-committal response he does think non-committal response he does think it's non-committal response he does think it's OK. non-committal response he does think it's OK. One non-committal response he does think it's OK. One of non-committal response he does think it's OK. One of the non-committal response he does think it's OK. One of the most non-committal response he does think it's OK. One of the most significant it's OK. One of the most significant economic it's OK. One of the most significant economic and it's OK. One of the most significant economic and environmental it's OK. One of the most significant economic and environmental policy economic and environmental policy changes economic and environmental policy changes in economic and environmental policy changes in a economic and environmental policy changes in a generation economic and environmental policy changes in a generation and economic and environmental policy changes in a generation and he changes in a generation and he thinks changes in a generation and he thinks the changes in a generation and he thinks the conditions changes in a generation and he thinks the conditions were changes in a generation and he thinks the conditions were fine. changes in a generation and he thinks the conditions were fine. I'm thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad the thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad the press thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad the press gallery thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad the press gallery got thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad the press gallery got an thinks the conditions were fine. I'm glad the press gallery got an answer glad the press gallery got an answer from glad the press gallery got an answer from James glad the press gallery got an answer from James Shaw glad the press gallery got an answer from James Shaw on glad the press gallery got an answer from James Shaw on that. glad the press gallery got an answer from James Shaw on that. Does glad the press gallery got an answer from James Shaw on that. Does he from James Shaw on that. Does he believe from James Shaw on that. Does he believe the from James Shaw on that. Does he believe the 24 from James Shaw on that. Does he believe the 24 hours from James Shaw on that. Does he believe the 24 hours that from James Shaw on that. Does he believe the 24 hours that the believe the 24 hours that the commissioners believe the 24 hours that the commissioners were believe the 24 hours that the commissioners were given believe the 24 hours that the commissioners were given to believe the 24 hours that the commissioners were given to look believe the 24 hours that the commissioners were given to look at commissioners were given to look at the commissioners were given to look at the draft commissioners were given to look at the draft was commissioners were given to look at the draft was adequate, commissioners were given to look at the draft was adequate, or commissioners were given to look at the draft was adequate, or is commissioners were given to look at the draft was adequate, or is he the draft was adequate, or is he denying the draft was adequate, or is he denying that the draft was adequate, or is he denying that happened? the draft was adequate, or is he denying that happened? No, the draft was adequate, or is he denying that happened? No, I the draft was adequate, or is he denying that happened? No, I just denying that happened? No, I just don't denying that happened? No, I just don't have denying that happened? No, I just don't have to denying that happened? No, I just don't have to source denying that happened? No, I just don't have to source of denying that happened? No, I just don't have to source of those don't have to source of those rumours. don't have to source of those rumours. We don't have to source of those rumours. We come don't have to source of those rumours. We come to don't have to source of those rumours. We come to oral don't have to source of those rumours. We come to oral questions. Well, Well, I Well, I think Well, I think what Well, I think what I'm Well, I think what I'm going Well, I think what I'm going to Well, I think what I'm going to do Well, I think what I'm going to do is Well, I think what I'm going to do is seek Well, I think what I'm going to do is seek leave Well, I think what I'm going to do is seek leave for Well, I think what I'm going to do is seek leave for Debbie is seek leave for Debbie Ngarewa-Packer is seek leave for Debbie Ngarewa-Packer to is seek leave for Debbie Ngarewa-Packer to make is seek leave for Debbie Ngarewa-Packer to make a is seek leave for Debbie Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on behalf Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on behalf of Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on behalf of the Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on behalf of the Maori Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on behalf of the Maori party Ngarewa-Packer to make a statement on behalf of the Maori party here. on behalf of the Maori party here. Because on behalf of the Maori party here. Because there's on behalf of the Maori party here. Because there's not on behalf of the Maori party here. Because there's not an on behalf of the Maori party here. Because there's not an entitlement. Because there's not an entitlement. Can Because there's not an entitlement. Can I Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest we Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest we put Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest we put it Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest we put it down Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest we put it down as Because there's not an entitlement. Can I suggest we put it down as a Can I suggest we put it down as a matter Can I suggest we put it down as a matter of Can I suggest we put it down as a matter of business Can I suggest we put it down as a matter of business for Can I suggest we put it down as a matter of business for the Can I suggest we put it down as a matter of business for the Business matter of business for the Business Committee matter of business for the Business Committee to matter of business for the Business Committee to see matter of business for the Business Committee to see if matter of business for the Business Committee to see if we matter of business for the Business Committee to see if we can matter of business for the Business Committee to see if we can agree matter of business for the Business Committee to see if we can agree to Committee to see if we can agree to an Committee to see if we can agree to an order Committee to see if we can agree to an order for Committee to see if we can agree to an order for the Committee to see if we can agree to an order for the rest Committee to see if we can agree to an order for the rest of Committee to see if we can agree to an order for the rest of the Committee to see if we can agree to an order for the rest of the year Committee to see if we can agree to an order for the rest of the year so an order for the rest of the year so we an order for the rest of the year so we don't an order for the rest of the year so we don't run an order for the rest of the year so we don't run into an order for the rest of the year so we don't run into this an order for the rest of the year so we don't run into this problem we don't run into this problem again. we don't run into this problem again. Is we don't run into this problem again. Is there we don't run into this problem again. Is there any we don't run into this problem again. Is there any objection we don't run into this problem again. Is there any objection to again. Is there any objection to that? again. Is there any objection to that? There again. Is there any objection to that? There appears again. Is there any objection to that? There appears to again. Is there any objection to that? There appears to be again. Is there any objection to that? There appears to be none. that? There appears to be none. Further that? There appears to be none. Further point that? There appears to be none. Further point of that? There appears to be none. Further point of order. that? There appears to be none. Further point of order. I that? There appears to be none. Further point of order. I may that? There appears to be none. Further point of order. I may be Further point of order. I may be able Further point of order. I may be able to Further point of order. I may be able to short Further point of order. I may be able to short circuit Further point of order. I may be able to short circuit the Further point of order. I may be able to short circuit the process able to short circuit the process and able to short circuit the process and seek able to short circuit the process and seek leave able to short circuit the process and seek leave for able to short circuit the process and seek leave for the able to short circuit the process and seek leave for the Maori able to short circuit the process and seek leave for the Maori party and seek leave for the Maori party to and seek leave for the Maori party to be and seek leave for the Maori party to be considered and seek leave for the Maori party to be considered a and seek leave for the Maori party to be considered a specified and seek leave for the Maori party to be considered a specified party to be considered a specified party for to be considered a specified party for the to be considered a specified party for the purposes to be considered a specified party for the purposes of to be considered a specified party for the purposes of standing to be considered a specified party for the purposes of standing orders. for the purposes of standing orders. Is for the purposes of standing orders. Is there for the purposes of standing orders. Is there any for the purposes of standing orders. Is there any objection for the purposes of standing orders. Is there any objection to for the purposes of standing orders. Is there any objection to that? Is there any objection to that? There Is there any objection to that? There is Is there any objection to that? There is objection. Is there any objection to that? There is objection. We Is there any objection to that? There is objection. We will Is there any objection to that? There is objection. We will undo Is there any objection to that? There is objection. We will undo the There is objection. We will undo the short There is objection. We will undo the short circuit There is objection. We will undo the short circuit and There is objection. We will undo the short circuit and take There is objection. We will undo the short circuit and take the There is objection. We will undo the short circuit and take the long short circuit and take the long route. short circuit and take the long route. Is short circuit and take the long route. Is there short circuit and take the long route. Is there any short circuit and take the long route. Is there any objection short circuit and take the long route. Is there any objection to route. Is there any objection to Ngarewa-Packer route. Is there any objection to Ngarewa-Packer making route. Is there any objection to Ngarewa-Packer making a route. Is there any objection to Ngarewa-Packer making a statement Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? I Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? I thought Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? I thought I Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? I thought I was Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? I thought I was interrupted Ngarewa-Packer making a statement now? I thought I was interrupted by now? I thought I was interrupted by the now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader of now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader of the now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader of the House. now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader of the House. If now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader of the House. If I now? I thought I was interrupted by the Leader of the House. If I have the Leader of the House. If I have already the Leader of the House. If I have already got the Leader of the House. If I have already got it, the Leader of the House. If I have already got it, we'll the Leader of the House. If I have already got it, we'll keep the Leader of the House. If I have already got it, we'll keep going. already got it, we'll keep going. INTERPRETER: already got it, we'll keep going. INTERPRETER: I already got it, we'll keep going. INTERPRETER: I will already got it, we'll keep going. INTERPRETER: I will stand already got it, we'll keep going. INTERPRETER: I will stand again. INTERPRETER: I will stand again. Thank INTERPRETER: I will stand again. Thank you, INTERPRETER: I will stand again. Thank you, Mr INTERPRETER: I will stand again. Thank you, Mr Speaker. INTERPRETER: I will stand again. Thank you, Mr Speaker. My Thank you, Mr Speaker. My acknowledgments Thank you, Mr Speaker. My acknowledgments to Thank you, Mr Speaker. My acknowledgments to all Thank you, Mr Speaker. My acknowledgments to all of Thank you, Mr Speaker. My acknowledgments to all of us Thank you, Mr Speaker. My acknowledgments to all of us here. acknowledgments to all of us here. To acknowledgments to all of us here. To do acknowledgments to all of us here. To do that acknowledgments to all of us here. To do that today acknowledgments to all of us here. To do that today and acknowledgments to all of us here. To do that today and acknowledge acknowledgments to all of us here. To do that today and acknowledge the To do that today and acknowledge the release To do that today and acknowledge the release of To do that today and acknowledge the release of the To do that today and acknowledge the release of the climate To do that today and acknowledge the release of the climate commission's release of the climate commission's final release of the climate commission's final advice release of the climate commission's final advice and release of the climate commission's final advice and the release of the climate commission's final advice and the minister's final advice and the minister's statement final advice and the minister's statement in final advice and the minister's statement in the final advice and the minister's statement in the House final advice and the minister's statement in the House today. statement in the House today. Despite statement in the House today. Despite decades statement in the House today. Despite decades of statement in the House today. Despite decades of warnings, Despite decades of warnings, protests Despite decades of warnings, protests and Despite decades of warnings, protests and discussions, Despite decades of warnings, protests and discussions, the Despite decades of warnings, protests and discussions, the planet protests and discussions, the planet is protests and discussions, the planet is continuing protests and discussions, the planet is continuing to protests and discussions, the planet is continuing to warm. protests and discussions, the planet is continuing to warm. Since protests and discussions, the planet is continuing to warm. Since 2016, is continuing to warm. Since 2016, Aotearoa is continuing to warm. Since 2016, Aotearoa had is continuing to warm. Since 2016, Aotearoa had three is continuing to warm. Since 2016, Aotearoa had three of is continuing to warm. Since 2016, Aotearoa had three of its is continuing to warm. Since 2016, Aotearoa had three of its hottest Aotearoa had three of its hottest years Aotearoa had three of its hottest years on Aotearoa had three of its hottest years on the Aotearoa had three of its hottest years on the record Aotearoa had three of its hottest years on the record since Aotearoa had three of its hottest years on the record since recordings years on the record since recordings began. years on the record since recordings began. Extreme years on the record since recordings began. Extreme climate years on the record since recordings began. Extreme climate conditions began. Extreme climate conditions are began. Extreme climate conditions are continuing began. Extreme climate conditions are continuing to began. Extreme climate conditions are continuing to Accelerate. began. Extreme climate conditions are continuing to Accelerate. The are continuing to Accelerate. The IPCC are continuing to Accelerate. The IPCC released are continuing to Accelerate. The IPCC released a are continuing to Accelerate. The IPCC released a landmark are continuing to Accelerate. The IPCC released a landmark report are continuing to Accelerate. The IPCC released a landmark report that IPCC released a landmark report that made IPCC released a landmark report that made it IPCC released a landmark report that made it clear IPCC released a landmark report that made it clear there IPCC released a landmark report that made it clear there were IPCC released a landmark report that made it clear there were only IPCC released a landmark report that made it clear there were only 12 made it clear there were only 12 years made it clear there were only 12 years left made it clear there were only 12 years left to made it clear there were only 12 years left to limit made it clear there were only 12 years left to limit the made it clear there were only 12 years left to limit the climate years left to limit the climate catastrophe, years left to limit the climate catastrophe, there's years left to limit the climate catastrophe, there's no years left to limit the climate catastrophe, there's no time years left to limit the climate catastrophe, there's no time for catastrophe, there's no time for inaction catastrophe, there's no time for inaction or catastrophe, there's no time for inaction or delay. catastrophe, there's no time for inaction or delay. Mr catastrophe, there's no time for inaction or delay. Mr Speaker, inaction or delay. Mr Speaker, Indigenous inaction or delay. Mr Speaker, Indigenous peoples inaction or delay. Mr Speaker, Indigenous peoples are inaction or delay. Mr Speaker, Indigenous peoples are at inaction or delay. Mr Speaker, Indigenous peoples are at the Indigenous peoples are at the forefront Indigenous peoples are at the forefront of Indigenous peoples are at the forefront of fighting Indigenous peoples are at the forefront of fighting to Indigenous peoples are at the forefront of fighting to protect Indigenous peoples are at the forefront of fighting to protect our forefront of fighting to protect our climate forefront of fighting to protect our climate for forefront of fighting to protect our climate for our forefront of fighting to protect our climate for our children forefront of fighting to protect our climate for our children yet forefront of fighting to protect our climate for our children yet to climate for our children yet to come. climate for our children yet to come. We climate for our children yet to come. We have climate for our children yet to come. We have the climate for our children yet to come. We have the most climate for our children yet to come. We have the most to climate for our children yet to come. We have the most to lose climate for our children yet to come. We have the most to lose from come. We have the most to lose from a come. We have the most to lose from a failure come. We have the most to lose from a failure to come. We have the most to lose from a failure to act come. We have the most to lose from a failure to act on come. We have the most to lose from a failure to act on climate come. We have the most to lose from a failure to act on climate change, a failure to act on climate change, despite a failure to act on climate change, despite a a failure to act on climate change, despite a relatively a failure to act on climate change, despite a relatively tiny despite a relatively tiny contribution despite a relatively tiny contribution to despite a relatively tiny contribution to global despite a relatively tiny contribution to global emissions. contribution to global emissions. Many contribution to global emissions. Many of contribution to global emissions. Many of our contribution to global emissions. Many of our Pasefika contribution to global emissions. Many of our Pasefika families contribution to global emissions. Many of our Pasefika families face Many of our Pasefika families face the Many of our Pasefika families face the prospect Many of our Pasefika families face the prospect of Many of our Pasefika families face the prospect of losing Many of our Pasefika families face the prospect of losing their the prospect of losing their islands. the prospect of losing their islands. Here the prospect of losing their islands. Here in the prospect of losing their islands. Here in Aotearoa, the prospect of losing their islands. Here in Aotearoa, from the prospect of losing their islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the places, islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the places, we islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the places, we have islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the places, we have seen islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the places, we have seen that islands. Here in Aotearoa, from all the places, we have seen that Maori the places, we have seen that Maori are the places, we have seen that Maori are on the places, we have seen that Maori are on the the places, we have seen that Maori are on the forefront the places, we have seen that Maori are on the forefront of the places, we have seen that Maori are on the forefront of resisting are on the forefront of resisting extractive are on the forefront of resisting extractive industries are on the forefront of resisting extractive industries that are on the forefront of resisting extractive industries that pollute extractive industries that pollute our extractive industries that pollute our environment. extractive industries that pollute our environment. We extractive industries that pollute our environment. We cannot extractive industries that pollute our environment. We cannot achieve our environment. We cannot achieve environmental our environment. We cannot achieve environmental protection our environment. We cannot achieve environmental protection and environmental protection and restoration environmental protection and restoration without environmental protection and restoration without acknowledging restoration without acknowledging and restoration without acknowledging and implementing restoration without acknowledging and implementing Maori restoration without acknowledging and implementing Maori rights restoration without acknowledging and implementing Maori rights and and implementing Maori rights and recognising and implementing Maori rights and recognising the and implementing Maori rights and recognising the rights and implementing Maori rights and recognising the rights of and implementing Maori rights and recognising the rights of tangata recognising the rights of tangata whenua. recognising the rights of tangata whenua. That recognising the rights of tangata whenua. That includes recognising the rights of tangata whenua. That includes actually whenua. That includes actually returning whenua. That includes actually returning our whenua. That includes actually returning our land whenua. That includes actually returning our land and whenua. That includes actually returning our land and our returning our land and our resources, returning our land and our resources, we returning our land and our resources, we cannot returning our land and our resources, we cannot beat returning our land and our resources, we cannot beat the resources, we cannot beat the climate resources, we cannot beat the climate crisis resources, we cannot beat the climate crisis without resources, we cannot beat the climate crisis without restoring climate crisis without restoring lands climate crisis without restoring lands to climate crisis without restoring lands to their climate crisis without restoring lands to their rightful climate crisis without restoring lands to their rightful Indigenous lands to their rightful Indigenous owners lands to their rightful Indigenous owners who lands to their rightful Indigenous owners who know lands to their rightful Indigenous owners who know how lands to their rightful Indigenous owners who know how to lands to their rightful Indigenous owners who know how to manage lands to their rightful Indigenous owners who know how to manage that owners who know how to manage that land owners who know how to manage that land in owners who know how to manage that land in harmony owners who know how to manage that land in harmony with owners who know how to manage that land in harmony with the owners who know how to manage that land in harmony with the climate. owners who know how to manage that land in harmony with the climate. I land in harmony with the climate. I acknowledge land in harmony with the climate. I acknowledge last land in harmony with the climate. I acknowledge last term's land in harmony with the climate. I acknowledge last term's decision land in harmony with the climate. I acknowledge last term's decision to acknowledge last term's decision to ban acknowledge last term's decision to ban new acknowledge last term's decision to ban new offshore acknowledge last term's decision to ban new offshore oil acknowledge last term's decision to ban new offshore oil and acknowledge last term's decision to ban new offshore oil and gas ban new offshore oil and gas permits, ban new offshore oil and gas permits, but ban new offshore oil and gas permits, but we ban new offshore oil and gas permits, but we must ban new offshore oil and gas permits, but we must go ban new offshore oil and gas permits, but we must go further. ban new offshore oil and gas permits, but we must go further. We permits, but we must go further. We need permits, but we must go further. We need to permits, but we must go further. We need to end permits, but we must go further. We need to end new permits, but we must go further. We need to end new onshore permits, but we must go further. We need to end new onshore oil permits, but we must go further. We need to end new onshore oil and permits, but we must go further. We need to end new onshore oil and gas need to end new onshore oil and gas permits need to end new onshore oil and gas permits and need to end new onshore oil and gas permits and withdraw need to end new onshore oil and gas permits and withdraw both need to end new onshore oil and gas permits and withdraw both existing permits and withdraw both existing onshore permits and withdraw both existing onshore and permits and withdraw both existing onshore and offshore permits and withdraw both existing onshore and offshore permits permits and withdraw both existing onshore and offshore permits with onshore and offshore permits with the onshore and offshore permits with the target onshore and offshore permits with the target of onshore and offshore permits with the target of decommissioning onshore and offshore permits with the target of decommissioning all the target of decommissioning all sites the target of decommissioning all sites by the target of decommissioning all sites by 2030. the target of decommissioning all sites by 2030. This the target of decommissioning all sites by 2030. This House the target of decommissioning all sites by 2030. This House has sites by 2030. This House has another sites by 2030. This House has another opportunity sites by 2030. This House has another opportunity to sites by 2030. This House has another opportunity to take sites by 2030. This House has another opportunity to take action another opportunity to take action on another opportunity to take action on protecting another opportunity to take action on protecting and another opportunity to take action on protecting and restoring another opportunity to take action on protecting and restoring the on protecting and restoring the biodiversity on protecting and restoring the biodiversity of on protecting and restoring the biodiversity of our on protecting and restoring the biodiversity of our oceans on protecting and restoring the biodiversity of our oceans by biodiversity of our oceans by supporting biodiversity of our oceans by supporting my biodiversity of our oceans by supporting my member's biodiversity of our oceans by supporting my member's bill, biodiversity of our oceans by supporting my member's bill, the supporting my member's bill, the problems supporting my member's bill, the problems on supporting my member's bill, the problems on seabed supporting my member's bill, the problems on seabed mining problems on seabed mining legislation problems on seabed mining legislation -- problems on seabed mining legislation -- prohibition problems on seabed mining legislation -- prohibition on problems on seabed mining legislation -- prohibition on seabed legislation -- prohibition on seabed mining legislation -- prohibition on seabed mining legislation legislation -- prohibition on seabed mining legislation bill. legislation -- prohibition on seabed mining legislation bill. We legislation -- prohibition on seabed mining legislation bill. We must mining legislation bill. We must fundamentally mining legislation bill. We must fundamentally transform mining legislation bill. We must fundamentally transform our fundamentally transform our transport fundamentally transform our transport system, fundamentally transform our transport system, we fundamentally transform our transport system, we must fundamentally transform our transport system, we must transition transport system, we must transition faster transport system, we must transition faster to transport system, we must transition faster to renewable transport system, we must transition faster to renewable energy transport system, we must transition faster to renewable energy and faster to renewable energy and energy faster to renewable energy and energy efficiency. faster to renewable energy and energy efficiency. This faster to renewable energy and energy efficiency. This House faster to renewable energy and energy efficiency. This House must energy efficiency. This House must stop energy efficiency. This House must stop ignoring energy efficiency. This House must stop ignoring the energy efficiency. This House must stop ignoring the elephant energy efficiency. This House must stop ignoring the elephant in energy efficiency. This House must stop ignoring the elephant in the stop ignoring the elephant in the room, stop ignoring the elephant in the room, the stop ignoring the elephant in the room, the effective stop ignoring the elephant in the room, the effective exclusion stop ignoring the elephant in the room, the effective exclusion of room, the effective exclusion of industrial room, the effective exclusion of industrial agriculture room, the effective exclusion of industrial agriculture to room, the effective exclusion of industrial agriculture to our industrial agriculture to our response. industrial agriculture to our response. It's industrial agriculture to our response. It's clear industrial agriculture to our response. It's clear beyond industrial agriculture to our response. It's clear beyond all response. It's clear beyond all doubt response. It's clear beyond all doubt that response. It's clear beyond all doubt that significant response. It's clear beyond all doubt that significant and response. It's clear beyond all doubt that significant and lasting doubt that significant and lasting reductions doubt that significant and lasting reductions in doubt that significant and lasting reductions in methane doubt that significant and lasting reductions in methane emissions doubt that significant and lasting reductions in methane emissions is reductions in methane emissions is absolutely reductions in methane emissions is absolutely critical. reductions in methane emissions is absolutely critical. Mr reductions in methane emissions is absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, reductions in methane emissions is absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth is absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth is simple absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth is simple and absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth is simple and staring absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth is simple and staring us absolutely critical. Mr Speaker, the truth is simple and staring us all truth is simple and staring us all in truth is simple and staring us all in the truth is simple and staring us all in the face, truth is simple and staring us all in the face, even truth is simple and staring us all in the face, even the truth is simple and staring us all in the face, even the Government truth is simple and staring us all in the face, even the Government of in the face, even the Government of the in the face, even the Government of the minister in the face, even the Government of the minister fails in the face, even the Government of the minister fails to in the face, even the Government of the minister fails to acknowledge the minister fails to acknowledge it, the minister fails to acknowledge it, we the minister fails to acknowledge it, we need the minister fails to acknowledge it, we need less the minister fails to acknowledge it, we need less cows. the minister fails to acknowledge it, we need less cows. There's the minister fails to acknowledge it, we need less cows. There's a it, we need less cows. There's a huge it, we need less cows. There's a huge economic it, we need less cows. There's a huge economic opportunity it, we need less cows. There's a huge economic opportunity in it, we need less cows. There's a huge economic opportunity in the huge economic opportunity in the going huge economic opportunity in the going for huge economic opportunity in the going for value huge economic opportunity in the going for value add huge economic opportunity in the going for value add products huge economic opportunity in the going for value add products and going for value add products and making going for value add products and making our going for value add products and making our clean going for value add products and making our clean green going for value add products and making our clean green brand going for value add products and making our clean green brand more making our clean green brand more than making our clean green brand more than just making our clean green brand more than just a making our clean green brand more than just a brand making our clean green brand more than just a brand but making our clean green brand more than just a brand but a making our clean green brand more than just a brand but a reality. than just a brand but a reality. Organic than just a brand but a reality. Organic and than just a brand but a reality. Organic and regenerative than just a brand but a reality. Organic and regenerative agriculture Organic and regenerative agriculture is Organic and regenerative agriculture is the Organic and regenerative agriculture is the future Organic and regenerative agriculture is the future and Organic and regenerative agriculture is the future and I'm Organic and regenerative agriculture is the future and I'm glad Organic and regenerative agriculture is the future and I'm glad the is the future and I'm glad the people is the future and I'm glad the people on is the future and I'm glad the people on this is the future and I'm glad the people on this side is the future and I'm glad the people on this side of is the future and I'm glad the people on this side of the is the future and I'm glad the people on this side of the House is the future and I'm glad the people on this side of the House are people on this side of the House are animated. people on this side of the House are animated. Our people on this side of the House are animated. Our Te people on this side of the House are animated. Our Te Paati people on this side of the House are animated. Our Te Paati Maori animated. Our Te Paati Maori manifesto animated. Our Te Paati Maori manifesto in animated. Our Te Paati Maori manifesto in the animated. Our Te Paati Maori manifesto in the last animated. Our Te Paati Maori manifesto in the last election manifesto in the last election committed manifesto in the last election committed us manifesto in the last election committed us to manifesto in the last election committed us to take manifesto in the last election committed us to take real manifesto in the last election committed us to take real action manifesto in the last election committed us to take real action on committed us to take real action on methane. committed us to take real action on methane. We committed us to take real action on methane. We would committed us to take real action on methane. We would face committed us to take real action on methane. We would face out committed us to take real action on methane. We would face out synthetic methane. We would face out synthetic fertilisers methane. We would face out synthetic fertilisers by methane. We would face out synthetic fertilisers by 2025. methane. We would face out synthetic fertilisers by 2025. It's methane. We would face out synthetic fertilisers by 2025. It's driving fertilisers by 2025. It's driving the fertilisers by 2025. It's driving the surge fertilisers by 2025. It's driving the surge in fertilisers by 2025. It's driving the surge in climate fertilisers by 2025. It's driving the surge in climate and fertilisers by 2025. It's driving the surge in climate and water the surge in climate and water pollution the surge in climate and water pollution coming the surge in climate and water pollution coming out the surge in climate and water pollution coming out of the surge in climate and water pollution coming out of the the surge in climate and water pollution coming out of the New pollution coming out of the New Zealand pollution coming out of the New Zealand farms pollution coming out of the New Zealand farms in pollution coming out of the New Zealand farms in recent pollution coming out of the New Zealand farms in recent decades. pollution coming out of the New Zealand farms in recent decades. We Zealand farms in recent decades. We also Zealand farms in recent decades. We also establish Zealand farms in recent decades. We also establish a Zealand farms in recent decades. We also establish a $300 Zealand farms in recent decades. We also establish a $300 million Zealand farms in recent decades. We also establish a $300 million fund also establish a $300 million fund to also establish a $300 million fund to support also establish a $300 million fund to support Maori also establish a $300 million fund to support Maori farmers also establish a $300 million fund to support Maori farmers to to support Maori farmers to transition to support Maori farmers to transition towards to support Maori farmers to transition towards regenerative to support Maori farmers to transition towards regenerative and transition towards regenerative and value transition towards regenerative and value added transition towards regenerative and value added agricultural transition towards regenerative and value added agricultural models. transition towards regenerative and value added agricultural models. We value added agricultural models. We have value added agricultural models. We have an value added agricultural models. We have an obligation value added agricultural models. We have an obligation to value added agricultural models. We have an obligation to unite value added agricultural models. We have an obligation to unite and value added agricultural models. We have an obligation to unite and to have an obligation to unite and to do have an obligation to unite and to do everything have an obligation to unite and to do everything to have an obligation to unite and to do everything to protect have an obligation to unite and to do everything to protect our have an obligation to unite and to do everything to protect our Tiau do everything to protect our Tiau and do everything to protect our Tiau and our do everything to protect our Tiau and our farmers do everything to protect our Tiau and our farmers from do everything to protect our Tiau and our farmers from the do everything to protect our Tiau and our farmers from the climate and our farmers from the climate crisis. and our farmers from the climate crisis. I and our farmers from the climate crisis. I appreciate and our farmers from the climate crisis. I appreciate the and our farmers from the climate crisis. I appreciate the clear crisis. I appreciate the clear advice crisis. I appreciate the clear advice from crisis. I appreciate the clear advice from the crisis. I appreciate the clear advice from the climate crisis. I appreciate the clear advice from the climate commission advice from the climate commission that advice from the climate commission that sets advice from the climate commission that sets out advice from the climate commission that sets out how advice from the climate commission that sets out how we advice from the climate commission that sets out how we can advice from the climate commission that sets out how we can do advice from the climate commission that sets out how we can do that advice from the climate commission that sets out how we can do that in that sets out how we can do that in our that sets out how we can do that in our context that sets out how we can do that in our context here that sets out how we can do that in our context here in that sets out how we can do that in our context here in Aotearoa. that sets out how we can do that in our context here in Aotearoa. As our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our job our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our job to our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our job to step our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our job to step up, our context here in Aotearoa. As MPs, it's our job to step up, take MPs, it's our job to step up, take the MPs, it's our job to step up, take the action MPs, it's our job to step up, take the action that MPs, it's our job to step up, take the action that is MPs, it's our job to step up, take the action that is so MPs, it's our job to step up, take the action that is so urgently the action that is so urgently needed. the action that is so urgently needed. We the action that is so urgently needed. We come the action that is so urgently needed. We come now the action that is so urgently needed. We come now to the action that is so urgently needed. We come now to oral needed. We come now to oral questions. needed. We come now to oral questions. Question needed. We come now to oral questions. Question No. needed. We come now to oral questions. Question No. 1 needed. We come now to oral questions. Question No. 1 is needed. We come now to oral questions. Question No. 1 is in needed. We come now to oral questions. Question No. 1 is in the questions. Question No. 1 is in the name questions. Question No. 1 is in the name of questions. Question No. 1 is in the name of David questions. Question No. 1 is in the name of David Seymour. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all her Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's policies Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's policies and Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's policies and actions? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, yes, Mr Speaker, yes, particularly Mr Speaker, yes, particularly the Mr Speaker, yes, particularly the Government's Mr Speaker, yes, particularly the Government's climate Mr Speaker, yes, particularly the Government's climate change Mr Speaker, yes, particularly the Government's climate change work Government's climate change work programme, Government's climate change work programme, including Government's climate change work programme, including the Government's climate change work programme, including the release Government's climate change work programme, including the release of programme, including the release of the programme, including the release of the final programme, including the release of the final advice programme, including the release of the final advice from programme, including the release of the final advice from the programme, including the release of the final advice from the Climate the final advice from the Climate Change the final advice from the Climate Change Commission. the final advice from the Climate Change Commission. It the final advice from the Climate Change Commission. It shows the final advice from the Climate Change Commission. It shows the Change Commission. It shows the 30-year Change Commission. It shows the 30-year transition Change Commission. It shows the 30-year transition to Change Commission. It shows the 30-year transition to a Change Commission. It shows the 30-year transition to a low 30-year transition to a low emissions 30-year transition to a low emissions economy 30-year transition to a low emissions economy is 30-year transition to a low emissions economy is achievable, emissions economy is achievable, will emissions economy is achievable, will create emissions economy is achievable, will create jobs emissions economy is achievable, will create jobs and emissions economy is achievable, will create jobs and new will create jobs and new opportunities will create jobs and new opportunities for will create jobs and new opportunities for Kiwi will create jobs and new opportunities for Kiwi businesses opportunities for Kiwi businesses and opportunities for Kiwi businesses and provide opportunities for Kiwi businesses and provide business opportunities for Kiwi businesses and provide business with opportunities for Kiwi businesses and provide business with certainty and provide business with certainty to and provide business with certainty to invest and provide business with certainty to invest in and provide business with certainty to invest in new and provide business with certainty to invest in new technology and provide business with certainty to invest in new technology to and provide business with certainty to invest in new technology to enter to invest in new technology to enter anywhere to invest in new technology to enter anywhere -- to invest in new technology to enter anywhere -- enter to invest in new technology to enter anywhere -- enter new to invest in new technology to enter anywhere -- enter new markets. to invest in new technology to enter anywhere -- enter new markets. The anywhere -- enter new markets. The Government anywhere -- enter new markets. The Government has anywhere -- enter new markets. The Government has passed anywhere -- enter new markets. The Government has passed the anywhere -- enter new markets. The Government has passed the zero Government has passed the zero carbon Government has passed the zero carbon act Government has passed the zero carbon act and Government has passed the zero carbon act and improving Government has passed the zero carbon act and improving the carbon act and improving the emissions carbon act and improving the emissions trading carbon act and improving the emissions trading scheme, carbon act and improving the emissions trading scheme, and emissions trading scheme, and investing emissions trading scheme, and investing in emissions trading scheme, and investing in EV emissions trading scheme, and investing in EV infrastructure investing in EV infrastructure around investing in EV infrastructure around the investing in EV infrastructure around the country. investing in EV infrastructure around the country. It's investing in EV infrastructure around the country. It's developing around the country. It's developing a around the country. It's developing a vehicles around the country. It's developing a vehicles emissions around the country. It's developing a vehicles emissions standards around the country. It's developing a vehicles emissions standards for a vehicles emissions standards for new a vehicles emissions standards for new imports a vehicles emissions standards for new imports and a vehicles emissions standards for new imports and a a vehicles emissions standards for new imports and a mandate a vehicles emissions standards for new imports and a mandate to a vehicles emissions standards for new imports and a mandate to include new imports and a mandate to include biofuels new imports and a mandate to include biofuels in new imports and a mandate to include biofuels in petrol new imports and a mandate to include biofuels in petrol and new imports and a mandate to include biofuels in petrol and diesel, new imports and a mandate to include biofuels in petrol and diesel, and biofuels in petrol and diesel, and helping biofuels in petrol and diesel, and helping businesses biofuels in petrol and diesel, and helping businesses to biofuels in petrol and diesel, and helping businesses to switch biofuels in petrol and diesel, and helping businesses to switch to helping businesses to switch to clean helping businesses to switch to clean energy. helping businesses to switch to clean energy. The helping businesses to switch to clean energy. The commission's clean energy. The commission's report clean energy. The commission's report makes clean energy. The commission's report makes clear clean energy. The commission's report makes clear there's clean energy. The commission's report makes clear there's more clean energy. The commission's report makes clear there's more to report makes clear there's more to do report makes clear there's more to do and report makes clear there's more to do and we'll report makes clear there's more to do and we'll consider report makes clear there's more to do and we'll consider the do and we'll consider the commission's do and we'll consider the commission's advice do and we'll consider the commission's advice over do and we'll consider the commission's advice over coming commission's advice over coming months commission's advice over coming months as commission's advice over coming months as we commission's advice over coming months as we develop commission's advice over coming months as we develop our commission's advice over coming months as we develop our emissions months as we develop our emissions reduction months as we develop our emissions reduction plan. months as we develop our emissions reduction plan. Which months as we develop our emissions reduction plan. Which of months as we develop our emissions reduction plan. Which of the months as we develop our emissions reduction plan. Which of the Climate reduction plan. Which of the Climate Change reduction plan. Which of the Climate Change Commission's reduction plan. Which of the Climate Change Commission's recommendations, Change Commission's recommendations, if Change Commission's recommendations, if any, Change Commission's recommendations, if any, will Change Commission's recommendations, if any, will the Change Commission's recommendations, if any, will the PM Change Commission's recommendations, if any, will the PM rule Change Commission's recommendations, if any, will the PM rule out if any, will the PM rule out implementing? if any, will the PM rule out implementing? Mr if any, will the PM rule out implementing? Mr Speaker, if any, will the PM rule out implementing? Mr Speaker, by if any, will the PM rule out implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, if any, will the PM rule out implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we are implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we are required implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we are required as implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we are required as a implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we are required as a Government implementing? Mr Speaker, by law, we are required as a Government under are required as a Government under the are required as a Government under the zero are required as a Government under the zero carbon are required as a Government under the zero carbon act are required as a Government under the zero carbon act to are required as a Government under the zero carbon act to go are required as a Government under the zero carbon act to go through the zero carbon act to go through due the zero carbon act to go through due process the zero carbon act to go through due process as the zero carbon act to go through due process as we the zero carbon act to go through due process as we formulate the zero carbon act to go through due process as we formulate an due process as we formulate an emissions due process as we formulate an emissions reduction due process as we formulate an emissions reduction plan due process as we formulate an emissions reduction plan and due process as we formulate an emissions reduction plan and our emissions reduction plan and our budgets. emissions reduction plan and our budgets. I'm emissions reduction plan and our budgets. I'm going emissions reduction plan and our budgets. I'm going to emissions reduction plan and our budgets. I'm going to undertake emissions reduction plan and our budgets. I'm going to undertake that budgets. I'm going to undertake that in budgets. I'm going to undertake that in good budgets. I'm going to undertake that in good faith. budgets. I'm going to undertake that in good faith. Why budgets. I'm going to undertake that in good faith. Why does budgets. I'm going to undertake that in good faith. Why does the budgets. I'm going to undertake that in good faith. Why does the PM in good faith. Why does the PM expect in good faith. Why does the PM expect the in good faith. Why does the PM expect the public in good faith. Why does the PM expect the public to in good faith. Why does the PM expect the public to believe in good faith. Why does the PM expect the public to believe that expect the public to believe that the expect the public to believe that the population expect the public to believe that the population will expect the public to believe that the population will keep expect the public to believe that the population will keep growing, the population will keep growing, the the population will keep growing, the economy the population will keep growing, the economy and the population will keep growing, the economy and living the population will keep growing, the economy and living standards the economy and living standards will the economy and living standards will keep the economy and living standards will keep growing, the economy and living standards will keep growing, and the economy and living standards will keep growing, and carbon will keep growing, and carbon emissions will keep growing, and carbon emissions will will keep growing, and carbon emissions will reduce will keep growing, and carbon emissions will reduce by will keep growing, and carbon emissions will reduce by 63% will keep growing, and carbon emissions will reduce by 63% in will keep growing, and carbon emissions will reduce by 63% in the emissions will reduce by 63% in the next emissions will reduce by 63% in the next 14 emissions will reduce by 63% in the next 14 years? emissions will reduce by 63% in the next 14 years? That's emissions will reduce by 63% in the next 14 years? That's more emissions will reduce by 63% in the next 14 years? That's more than next 14 years? That's more than half... next 14 years? That's more than half... Order, next 14 years? That's more than half... Order, order. next 14 years? That's more than half... Order, order. The next 14 years? That's more than half... Order, order. The member's half... Order, order. The member's asked half... Order, order. The member's asked a half... Order, order. The member's asked a question. half... Order, order. The member's asked a question. It's half... Order, order. The member's asked a question. It's a half... Order, order. The member's asked a question. It's a very half... Order, order. The member's asked a question. It's a very long asked a question. It's a very long one asked a question. It's a very long one already. asked a question. It's a very long one already. Tiny asked a question. It's a very long one already. Tiny little asked a question. It's a very long one already. Tiny little addition? one already. Tiny little addition? If one already. Tiny little addition? If it's one already. Tiny little addition? If it's - one already. Tiny little addition? If it's - if one already. Tiny little addition? If it's - if it's one already. Tiny little addition? If it's - if it's a one already. Tiny little addition? If it's - if it's a question, one already. Tiny little addition? If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's - if it's a question, yes. If If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, no. If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, no. OK. If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, no. OK. Well, If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, no. OK. Well, all If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I If it's - if it's a question, yes. If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going to If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going to add, If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going to add, Mr If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going to add, Mr Speaker, If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going to add, Mr Speaker, for If it's not, no. OK. Well, all I was going to add, Mr Speaker, for the going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's benefit, going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's benefit, is going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's benefit, is give going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's benefit, is give her going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's benefit, is give her a going to add, Mr Speaker, for the PM's benefit, is give her a little PM's benefit, is give her a little context PM's benefit, is give her a little context that PM's benefit, is give her a little context that carbon PM's benefit, is give her a little context that carbon emissions PM's benefit, is give her a little context that carbon emissions have context that carbon emissions have been context that carbon emissions have been rising context that carbon emissions have been rising every context that carbon emissions have been rising every year context that carbon emissions have been rising every year this context that carbon emissions have been rising every year this century been rising every year this century in been rising every year this century in contrast... been rising every year this century in contrast... That's been rising every year this century in contrast... That's in been rising every year this century in contrast... That's in conflict in contrast... That's in conflict with in contrast... That's in conflict with what in contrast... That's in conflict with what I in contrast... That's in conflict with what I just in contrast... That's in conflict with what I just said. in contrast... That's in conflict with what I just said. The in contrast... That's in conflict with what I just said. The member with what I just said. The member can with what I just said. The member can start with what I just said. The member can start again with what I just said. The member can start again and with what I just said. The member can start again and use with what I just said. The member can start again and use another can start again and use another supplementary. can start again and use another supplementary. Expensive can start again and use another supplementary. Expensive business. supplementary. Expensive business. How supplementary. Expensive business. How does supplementary. Expensive business. How does the supplementary. Expensive business. How does the PM supplementary. Expensive business. How does the PM expect supplementary. Expensive business. How does the PM expect the supplementary. Expensive business. How does the PM expect the public supplementary. Expensive business. How does the PM expect the public to How does the PM expect the public to believe How does the PM expect the public to believe that How does the PM expect the public to believe that emissions How does the PM expect the public to believe that emissions are How does the PM expect the public to believe that emissions are going How does the PM expect the public to believe that emissions are going to believe that emissions are going to painlessly believe that emissions are going to painlessly decrease believe that emissions are going to painlessly decrease by believe that emissions are going to painlessly decrease by 63% believe that emissions are going to painlessly decrease by 63% in believe that emissions are going to painlessly decrease by 63% in the painlessly decrease by 63% in the next painlessly decrease by 63% in the next 14 painlessly decrease by 63% in the next 14 years painlessly decrease by 63% in the next 14 years when painlessly decrease by 63% in the next 14 years when every painlessly decrease by 63% in the next 14 years when every year painlessly decrease by 63% in the next 14 years when every year this next 14 years when every year this century next 14 years when every year this century on next 14 years when every year this century on average next 14 years when every year this century on average emissions next 14 years when every year this century on average emissions have century on average emissions have increased century on average emissions have increased so century on average emissions have increased so far. century on average emissions have increased so far. I century on average emissions have increased so far. I don't century on average emissions have increased so far. I don't think increased so far. I don't think everyone increased so far. I don't think everyone is increased so far. I don't think everyone is suggesting increased so far. I don't think everyone is suggesting that increased so far. I don't think everyone is suggesting that change everyone is suggesting that change won't everyone is suggesting that change won't be everyone is suggesting that change won't be required. everyone is suggesting that change won't be required. The everyone is suggesting that change won't be required. The point everyone is suggesting that change won't be required. The point the won't be required. The point the Climate won't be required. The point the Climate Change won't be required. The point the Climate Change Commission won't be required. The point the Climate Change Commission has won't be required. The point the Climate Change Commission has made Climate Change Commission has made is Climate Change Commission has made is that Climate Change Commission has made is that the Climate Change Commission has made is that the foundations Climate Change Commission has made is that the foundations the is that the foundations the Government is that the foundations the Government has is that the foundations the Government has laid is that the foundations the Government has laid are is that the foundations the Government has laid are the is that the foundations the Government has laid are the right Government has laid are the right ones, Government has laid are the right ones, which Government has laid are the right ones, which we Government has laid are the right ones, which we just Government has laid are the right ones, which we just need Government has laid are the right ones, which we just need to Government has laid are the right ones, which we just need to make ones, which we just need to make sure ones, which we just need to make sure we ones, which we just need to make sure we keep ones, which we just need to make sure we keep going ones, which we just need to make sure we keep going and ones, which we just need to make sure we keep going and we ones, which we just need to make sure we keep going and we lift ones, which we just need to make sure we keep going and we lift the sure we keep going and we lift the pace. sure we keep going and we lift the pace. The sure we keep going and we lift the pace. The alternative, sure we keep going and we lift the pace. The alternative, if sure we keep going and we lift the pace. The alternative, if we sure we keep going and we lift the pace. The alternative, if we don't pace. The alternative, if we don't do pace. The alternative, if we don't do that, pace. The alternative, if we don't do that, is pace. The alternative, if we don't do that, is that pace. The alternative, if we don't do that, is that the pace. The alternative, if we don't do that, is that the potential pace. The alternative, if we don't do that, is that the potential cost do that, is that the potential cost to do that, is that the potential cost to the do that, is that the potential cost to the economy do that, is that the potential cost to the economy will do that, is that the potential cost to the economy will be do that, is that the potential cost to the economy will be greater do that, is that the potential cost to the economy will be greater due to the economy will be greater due to to the economy will be greater due to inaction to the economy will be greater due to inaction than to the economy will be greater due to inaction than it to the economy will be greater due to inaction than it will to the economy will be greater due to inaction than it will be to the economy will be greater due to inaction than it will be via to inaction than it will be via action. to inaction than it will be via action. Supplementary. to inaction than it will be via action. Supplementary. When to inaction than it will be via action. Supplementary. When the to inaction than it will be via action. Supplementary. When the PM action. Supplementary. When the PM said action. Supplementary. When the PM said that action. Supplementary. When the PM said that the action. Supplementary. When the PM said that the Government action. Supplementary. When the PM said that the Government has action. Supplementary. When the PM said that the Government has laid said that the Government has laid the said that the Government has laid the foundations said that the Government has laid the foundations and said that the Government has laid the foundations and needs said that the Government has laid the foundations and needs to the foundations and needs to increase the foundations and needs to increase the the foundations and needs to increase the pace, the foundations and needs to increase the pace, was the foundations and needs to increase the pace, was he the foundations and needs to increase the pace, was he -- the foundations and needs to increase the pace, was he -- she increase the pace, was he -- she referring increase the pace, was he -- she referring to increase the pace, was he -- she referring to the increase the pace, was he -- she referring to the record increase the pace, was he -- she referring to the record 1.1 increase the pace, was he -- she referring to the record 1.1 million referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes of referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes of coal referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes of coal imported referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes of coal imported or referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes of coal imported or the referring to the record 1.1 million tonnes of coal imported or the fact tonnes of coal imported or the fact that tonnes of coal imported or the fact that emissions tonnes of coal imported or the fact that emissions have tonnes of coal imported or the fact that emissions have increased tonnes of coal imported or the fact that emissions have increased under that emissions have increased under her that emissions have increased under her Government? that emissions have increased under her Government? Which that emissions have increased under her Government? Which is that emissions have increased under her Government? Which is she that emissions have increased under her Government? Which is she going her Government? Which is she going to her Government? Which is she going to accelerate? her Government? Which is she going to accelerate? The her Government? Which is she going to accelerate? The member her Government? Which is she going to accelerate? The member raises her Government? Which is she going to accelerate? The member raises the to accelerate? The member raises the issue to accelerate? The member raises the issue with to accelerate? The member raises the issue with New to accelerate? The member raises the issue with New Zealand's to accelerate? The member raises the issue with New Zealand's electricity issue with New Zealand's electricity generation, issue with New Zealand's electricity generation, one issue with New Zealand's electricity generation, one of issue with New Zealand's electricity generation, one of the issue with New Zealand's electricity generation, one of the issues issue with New Zealand's electricity generation, one of the issues we're generation, one of the issues we're facing generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst we generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst we have generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst we have a generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst we have a high generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst we have a high rate generation, one of the issues we're facing whilst we have a high rate of facing whilst we have a high rate of renewables facing whilst we have a high rate of renewables in facing whilst we have a high rate of renewables in New facing whilst we have a high rate of renewables in New Zealand, facing whilst we have a high rate of renewables in New Zealand, in facing whilst we have a high rate of renewables in New Zealand, in a renewables in New Zealand, in a hydrological renewables in New Zealand, in a hydrological dry renewables in New Zealand, in a hydrological dry year, renewables in New Zealand, in a hydrological dry year, we renewables in New Zealand, in a hydrological dry year, we have renewables in New Zealand, in a hydrological dry year, we have a hydrological dry year, we have a major hydrological dry year, we have a major problem. hydrological dry year, we have a major problem. We hydrological dry year, we have a major problem. We have hydrological dry year, we have a major problem. We have to hydrological dry year, we have a major problem. We have to look hydrological dry year, we have a major problem. We have to look at major problem. We have to look at options major problem. We have to look at options to major problem. We have to look at options to overcome major problem. We have to look at options to overcome that. major problem. We have to look at options to overcome that. We major problem. We have to look at options to overcome that. We have options to overcome that. We have laid options to overcome that. We have laid the options to overcome that. We have laid the foundation options to overcome that. We have laid the foundation for options to overcome that. We have laid the foundation for that options to overcome that. We have laid the foundation for that piece laid the foundation for that piece of laid the foundation for that piece of work. laid the foundation for that piece of work. We're laid the foundation for that piece of work. We're laying laid the foundation for that piece of work. We're laying the of work. We're laying the foundations of work. We're laying the foundations for of work. We're laying the foundations for New of work. We're laying the foundations for New Zealand of work. We're laying the foundations for New Zealand to of work. We're laying the foundations for New Zealand to have foundations for New Zealand to have clean foundations for New Zealand to have clean car foundations for New Zealand to have clean car standards foundations for New Zealand to have clean car standards so foundations for New Zealand to have clean car standards so we foundations for New Zealand to have clean car standards so we don't clean car standards so we don't continue, clean car standards so we don't continue, particularly clean car standards so we don't continue, particularly in clean car standards so we don't continue, particularly in an clean car standards so we don't continue, particularly in an era continue, particularly in an era where continue, particularly in an era where other continue, particularly in an era where other countries continue, particularly in an era where other countries will continue, particularly in an era where other countries will start where other countries will start phasing where other countries will start phasing out where other countries will start phasing out the where other countries will start phasing out the use where other countries will start phasing out the use of where other countries will start phasing out the use of internal phasing out the use of internal combustion phasing out the use of internal combustion engines, phasing out the use of internal combustion engines, we'll phasing out the use of internal combustion engines, we'll put phasing out the use of internal combustion engines, we'll put some combustion engines, we'll put some standards combustion engines, we'll put some standards around combustion engines, we'll put some standards around what combustion engines, we'll put some standards around what is combustion engines, we'll put some standards around what is imported combustion engines, we'll put some standards around what is imported to standards around what is imported to New standards around what is imported to New Zealand standards around what is imported to New Zealand so standards around what is imported to New Zealand so we standards around what is imported to New Zealand so we don't standards around what is imported to New Zealand so we don't end standards around what is imported to New Zealand so we don't end up standards around what is imported to New Zealand so we don't end up being New Zealand so we don't end up being the New Zealand so we don't end up being the dumping New Zealand so we don't end up being the dumping ground New Zealand so we don't end up being the dumping ground of New Zealand so we don't end up being the dumping ground of other the dumping ground of other countries. the dumping ground of other countries. We're the dumping ground of other countries. We're starting the dumping ground of other countries. We're starting the the dumping ground of other countries. We're starting the work countries. We're starting the work by countries. We're starting the work by incentivising countries. We're starting the work by incentivising industry countries. We're starting the work by incentivising industry to by incentivising industry to transition, by incentivising industry to transition, and by incentivising industry to transition, and it's by incentivising industry to transition, and it's excellent by incentivising industry to transition, and it's excellent to transition, and it's excellent to see transition, and it's excellent to see some transition, and it's excellent to see some of transition, and it's excellent to see some of those transition, and it's excellent to see some of those higher transition, and it's excellent to see some of those higher uses, transition, and it's excellent to see some of those higher uses, the see some of those higher uses, the likes see some of those higher uses, the likes of see some of those higher uses, the likes of Fonterra, see some of those higher uses, the likes of Fonterra, making see some of those higher uses, the likes of Fonterra, making ambitious likes of Fonterra, making ambitious plans likes of Fonterra, making ambitious plans to likes of Fonterra, making ambitious plans to change likes of Fonterra, making ambitious plans to change the likes of Fonterra, making ambitious plans to change the way likes of Fonterra, making ambitious plans to change the way they plans to change the way they undertake plans to change the way they undertake their plans to change the way they undertake their processing that plans to change the way they undertake their processing that will undertake their processing that will be undertake their processing that will be good undertake their processing that will be good for undertake their processing that will be good for all undertake their processing that will be good for all of undertake their processing that will be good for all of us. undertake their processing that will be good for all of us. Sorry? undertake their processing that will be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon Court. be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon Court. Will be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon Court. Will the be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon Court. Will the PM be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon Court. Will the PM commit be good for all of us. Sorry? Simon Court. Will the PM commit to Court. Will the PM commit to ensuring Court. Will the PM commit to ensuring any Court. Will the PM commit to ensuring any climate Court. Will the PM commit to ensuring any climate change Court. Will the PM commit to ensuring any climate change policies ensuring any climate change policies are ensuring any climate change policies are subject ensuring any climate change policies are subject to ensuring any climate change policies are subject to a ensuring any climate change policies are subject to a cost ensuring any climate change policies are subject to a cost benefit are subject to a cost benefit analysis? are subject to a cost benefit analysis? Mr are subject to a cost benefit analysis? Mr Speaker, are subject to a cost benefit analysis? Mr Speaker, we are subject to a cost benefit analysis? Mr Speaker, we are are subject to a cost benefit analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged to analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged to go analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged to go through analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged to go through a analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged to go through a rigorous analysis? Mr Speaker, we are obliged to go through a rigorous process. to go through a rigorous process. And to go through a rigorous process. And of to go through a rigorous process. And of course, to go through a rigorous process. And of course, the to go through a rigorous process. And of course, the Climate to go through a rigorous process. And of course, the Climate Change And of course, the Climate Change Commission And of course, the Climate Change Commission has And of course, the Climate Change Commission has part And of course, the Climate Change Commission has part of And of course, the Climate Change Commission has part of their And of course, the Climate Change Commission has part of their report Commission has part of their report has Commission has part of their report has encouraged Commission has part of their report has encouraged us Commission has part of their report has encouraged us to Commission has part of their report has encouraged us to undertake Commission has part of their report has encouraged us to undertake that has encouraged us to undertake that process, has encouraged us to undertake that process, including has encouraged us to undertake that process, including - has encouraged us to undertake that process, including - and has encouraged us to undertake that process, including - and let's process, including - and let's acknowledge process, including - and let's acknowledge what process, including - and let's acknowledge what they process, including - and let's acknowledge what they said process, including - and let's acknowledge what they said around acknowledge what they said around our acknowledge what they said around our ambition acknowledge what they said around our ambition of acknowledge what they said around our ambition of 100% acknowledge what they said around our ambition of 100% renewable our ambition of 100% renewable electricity, our ambition of 100% renewable electricity, that's our ambition of 100% renewable electricity, that's one our ambition of 100% renewable electricity, that's one of our ambition of 100% renewable electricity, that's one of the our ambition of 100% renewable electricity, that's one of the areas electricity, that's one of the areas where electricity, that's one of the areas where they electricity, that's one of the areas where they called electricity, that's one of the areas where they called for electricity, that's one of the areas where they called for that. electricity, that's one of the areas where they called for that. Aware where they called for that. Aware undertaking where they called for that. Aware undertaking a where they called for that. Aware undertaking a business where they called for that. Aware undertaking a business case where they called for that. Aware undertaking a business case around undertaking a business case around the undertaking a business case around the way undertaking a business case around the way we undertaking a business case around the way we would undertaking a business case around the way we would achieve undertaking a business case around the way we would achieve that, the way we would achieve that, through the way we would achieve that, through projects the way we would achieve that, through projects like the way we would achieve that, through projects like Onslow. the way we would achieve that, through projects like Onslow. The through projects like Onslow. The member through projects like Onslow. The member can through projects like Onslow. The member can engage through projects like Onslow. The member can engage in through projects like Onslow. The member can engage in that through projects like Onslow. The member can engage in that process member can engage in that process over member can engage in that process over the member can engage in that process over the next member can engage in that process over the next several member can engage in that process over the next several months member can engage in that process over the next several months and member can engage in that process over the next several months and I over the next several months and I encourage over the next several months and I encourage him over the next several months and I encourage him to over the next several months and I encourage him to do over the next several months and I encourage him to do so. over the next several months and I encourage him to do so. The encourage him to do so. The honourable encourage him to do so. The honourable Judith encourage him to do so. The honourable Judith Collins. encourage him to do so. The honourable Judith Collins. Is encourage him to do so. The honourable Judith Collins. Is she honourable Judith Collins. Is she aware honourable Judith Collins. Is she aware when honourable Judith Collins. Is she aware when she honourable Judith Collins. Is she aware when she referenced honourable Judith Collins. Is she aware when she referenced Fonterra aware when she referenced Fonterra they're aware when she referenced Fonterra they're having aware when she referenced Fonterra they're having to aware when she referenced Fonterra they're having to actually aware when she referenced Fonterra they're having to actually burn aware when she referenced Fonterra they're having to actually burn coal they're having to actually burn coal to they're having to actually burn coal to dry they're having to actually burn coal to dry the they're having to actually burn coal to dry the wood they're having to actually burn coal to dry the wood at they're having to actually burn coal to dry the wood at brightwater? they're having to actually burn coal to dry the wood at brightwater? Mr to dry the wood at brightwater? Mr Speaker, to dry the wood at brightwater? Mr Speaker, I to dry the wood at brightwater? Mr Speaker, I reference to dry the wood at brightwater? Mr Speaker, I reference the to dry the wood at brightwater? Mr Speaker, I reference the fact Speaker, I reference the fact they're Speaker, I reference the fact they're working Speaker, I reference the fact they're working to Speaker, I reference the fact they're working to transition Speaker, I reference the fact they're working to transition their they're working to transition their energy they're working to transition their energy generation they're working to transition their energy generation and they're working to transition their energy generation and their energy generation and their processing energy generation and their processing plants. energy generation and their processing plants. If energy generation and their processing plants. If the energy generation and their processing plants. If the member energy generation and their processing plants. If the member is processing plants. If the member is contesting processing plants. If the member is contesting that processing plants. If the member is contesting that ambition, processing plants. If the member is contesting that ambition, I processing plants. If the member is contesting that ambition, I suggest contesting that ambition, I suggest she contesting that ambition, I suggest she raise contesting that ambition, I suggest she raise it contesting that ambition, I suggest she raise it with contesting that ambition, I suggest she raise it with Fonterra, contesting that ambition, I suggest she raise it with Fonterra, if contesting that ambition, I suggest she raise it with Fonterra, if the she raise it with Fonterra, if the member she raise it with Fonterra, if the member thinks she raise it with Fonterra, if the member thinks it's she raise it with Fonterra, if the member thinks it's our she raise it with Fonterra, if the member thinks it's our benefit she raise it with Fonterra, if the member thinks it's our benefit to member thinks it's our benefit to continue member thinks it's our benefit to continue to member thinks it's our benefit to continue to use member thinks it's our benefit to continue to use fossil member thinks it's our benefit to continue to use fossil fuels member thinks it's our benefit to continue to use fossil fuels as member thinks it's our benefit to continue to use fossil fuels as part continue to use fossil fuels as part of continue to use fossil fuels as part of our continue to use fossil fuels as part of our clean, continue to use fossil fuels as part of our clean, green continue to use fossil fuels as part of our clean, green image, continue to use fossil fuels as part of our clean, green image, she's continue to use fossil fuels as part of our clean, green image, she's out of our clean, green image, she's out of of our clean, green image, she's out of step of our clean, green image, she's out of step where of our clean, green image, she's out of step where Fonterra of our clean, green image, she's out of step where Fonterra is of our clean, green image, she's out of step where Fonterra is heading. of step where Fonterra is heading. Will of step where Fonterra is heading. Will she of step where Fonterra is heading. Will she rule of step where Fonterra is heading. Will she rule out of step where Fonterra is heading. Will she rule out implementing of step where Fonterra is heading. Will she rule out implementing the Will she rule out implementing the commission's Will she rule out implementing the commission's recommendations Will she rule out implementing the commission's recommendations that commission's recommendations that could commission's recommendations that could see commission's recommendations that could see total commission's recommendations that could see total beef commission's recommendations that could see total beef and commission's recommendations that could see total beef and cattle could see total beef and cattle numbers could see total beef and cattle numbers fall could see total beef and cattle numbers fall by could see total beef and cattle numbers fall by 13%? could see total beef and cattle numbers fall by 13%? I could see total beef and cattle numbers fall by 13%? I refer could see total beef and cattle numbers fall by 13%? I refer to could see total beef and cattle numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the first numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the first answer, numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the first answer, the numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the first answer, the first numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the first answer, the first answer numbers fall by 13%? I refer to the first answer, the first answer I first answer, the first answer I gave first answer, the first answer I gave to first answer, the first answer I gave to Mr first answer, the first answer I gave to Mr Seymour first answer, the first answer I gave to Mr Seymour around first answer, the first answer I gave to Mr Seymour around fulfilling gave to Mr Seymour around fulfilling our gave to Mr Seymour around fulfilling our obligations gave to Mr Seymour around fulfilling our obligations in gave to Mr Seymour around fulfilling our obligations in not gave to Mr Seymour around fulfilling our obligations in not responding our obligations in not responding immediately our obligations in not responding immediately but our obligations in not responding immediately but going our obligations in not responding immediately but going through our obligations in not responding immediately but going through due immediately but going through due process immediately but going through due process in immediately but going through due process in considering immediately but going through due process in considering the process in considering the commission's process in considering the commission's report. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: What My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent reports My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent reports has My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent reports has he Finance: What recent reports has he seen Finance: What recent reports has he seen on Finance: What recent reports has he seen on the Finance: What recent reports has he seen on the New Finance: What recent reports has he seen on the New Zealand Finance: What recent reports has he seen on the New Zealand economy? The The wholesale The wholesale and The wholesale and manufacturing The wholesale and manufacturing sectors The wholesale and manufacturing sectors are The wholesale and manufacturing sectors are contributing The wholesale and manufacturing sectors are contributing to sectors are contributing to supporting sectors are contributing to supporting the sectors are contributing to supporting the recovery. sectors are contributing to supporting the recovery. This supporting the recovery. This morning supporting the recovery. This morning stats supporting the recovery. This morning stats New supporting the recovery. This morning stats New Zealand supporting the recovery. This morning stats New Zealand reported supporting the recovery. This morning stats New Zealand reported a morning stats New Zealand reported a continued morning stats New Zealand reported a continued rise morning stats New Zealand reported a continued rise in morning stats New Zealand reported a continued rise in manufacturing continued rise in manufacturing sales continued rise in manufacturing sales volumes, continued rise in manufacturing sales volumes, up continued rise in manufacturing sales volumes, up 0.4% continued rise in manufacturing sales volumes, up 0.4% from continued rise in manufacturing sales volumes, up 0.4% from the sales volumes, up 0.4% from the previous sales volumes, up 0.4% from the previous quarter sales volumes, up 0.4% from the previous quarter to sales volumes, up 0.4% from the previous quarter to reach sales volumes, up 0.4% from the previous quarter to reach a sales volumes, up 0.4% from the previous quarter to reach a record previous quarter to reach a record peak. previous quarter to reach a record peak. The previous quarter to reach a record peak. The biggest previous quarter to reach a record peak. The biggest contribution previous quarter to reach a record peak. The biggest contribution came peak. The biggest contribution came from peak. The biggest contribution came from the peak. The biggest contribution came from the electronic peak. The biggest contribution came from the electronic and peak. The biggest contribution came from the electronic and electrical from the electronic and electrical equipment from the electronic and electrical equipment manufacturing from the electronic and electrical equipment manufacturing sector. from the electronic and electrical equipment manufacturing sector. It equipment manufacturing sector. It fed equipment manufacturing sector. It fed into equipment manufacturing sector. It fed into the equipment manufacturing sector. It fed into the exports equipment manufacturing sector. It fed into the exports of equipment manufacturing sector. It fed into the exports of optical, fed into the exports of optical, medical, fed into the exports of optical, medical, and fed into the exports of optical, medical, and measuring fed into the exports of optical, medical, and measuring equipment medical, and measuring equipment goods, medical, and measuring equipment goods, that medical, and measuring equipment goods, that increased medical, and measuring equipment goods, that increased over medical, and measuring equipment goods, that increased over 50% goods, that increased over 50% during goods, that increased over 50% during the goods, that increased over 50% during the last goods, that increased over 50% during the last 12 goods, that increased over 50% during the last 12 months. goods, that increased over 50% during the last 12 months. Meat goods, that increased over 50% during the last 12 months. Meat and during the last 12 months. Meat and dairy during the last 12 months. Meat and dairy products during the last 12 months. Meat and dairy products rose during the last 12 months. Meat and dairy products rose 1.3% during the last 12 months. Meat and dairy products rose 1.3% in during the last 12 months. Meat and dairy products rose 1.3% in the dairy products rose 1.3% in the March dairy products rose 1.3% in the March 2021 dairy products rose 1.3% in the March 2021 quarter. dairy products rose 1.3% in the March 2021 quarter. Wholesale dairy products rose 1.3% in the March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales rose March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales rose 3.7%, March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales rose 3.7%, a March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales rose 3.7%, a rebound March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in March 2021 quarter. Wholesale trade sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in the sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in the decline sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in the decline from sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in the decline from the sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in the decline from the previous sales rose 3.7%, a rebound in the decline from the previous quarter. decline from the previous quarter. It decline from the previous quarter. It came decline from the previous quarter. It came from decline from the previous quarter. It came from the decline from the previous quarter. It came from the motor decline from the previous quarter. It came from the motor vehicle decline from the previous quarter. It came from the motor vehicle and It came from the motor vehicle and parts It came from the motor vehicle and parts industry. It came from the motor vehicle and parts industry. What It came from the motor vehicle and parts industry. What other It came from the motor vehicle and parts industry. What other reports parts industry. What other reports hey parts industry. What other reports hey has parts industry. What other reports hey has seen parts industry. What other reports hey has seen on parts industry. What other reports hey has seen on the parts industry. What other reports hey has seen on the economy? parts industry. What other reports hey has seen on the economy? The hey has seen on the economy? The Government's hey has seen on the economy? The Government's effects hey has seen on the economy? The Government's effects to hey has seen on the economy? The Government's effects to secure hey has seen on the economy? The Government's effects to secure the Government's effects to secure the recovery Government's effects to secure the recovery is Government's effects to secure the recovery is reflected Government's effects to secure the recovery is reflected in Government's effects to secure the recovery is reflected in the Government's effects to secure the recovery is reflected in the jobs recovery is reflected in the jobs markets. recovery is reflected in the jobs markets. It recovery is reflected in the jobs markets. It increased recovery is reflected in the jobs markets. It increased to recovery is reflected in the jobs markets. It increased to a recovery is reflected in the jobs markets. It increased to a record markets. It increased to a record high markets. It increased to a record high for markets. It increased to a record high for job markets. It increased to a record high for job advertising markets. It increased to a record high for job advertising numbers. high for job advertising numbers. For high for job advertising numbers. For the high for job advertising numbers. For the year, high for job advertising numbers. For the year, job high for job advertising numbers. For the year, job ads high for job advertising numbers. For the year, job ads rose high for job advertising numbers. For the year, job ads rose 193 high for job advertising numbers. For the year, job ads rose 193 %. For the year, job ads rose 193 %. It's For the year, job ads rose 193 %. It's now For the year, job ads rose 193 %. It's now surpassed For the year, job ads rose 193 %. It's now surpassed pre-COVID For the year, job ads rose 193 %. It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's not It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's not enough It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's not enough to It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's not enough to say It's now surpassed pre-COVID marks. It's not enough to say job It's not enough to say job advertising It's not enough to say job advertising has It's not enough to say job advertising has fully It's not enough to say job advertising has fully recovered, It's not enough to say job advertising has fully recovered, it advertising has fully recovered, it is advertising has fully recovered, it is now advertising has fully recovered, it is now exceptionally advertising has fully recovered, it is now exceptionally strong. is now exceptionally strong. Supplementary. is now exceptionally strong. Supplementary. What is now exceptionally strong. Supplementary. What reports is now exceptionally strong. Supplementary. What reports has is now exceptionally strong. Supplementary. What reports has he Supplementary. What reports has he seen Supplementary. What reports has he seen on Supplementary. What reports has he seen on the Supplementary. What reports has he seen on the impact Supplementary. What reports has he seen on the impact of Supplementary. What reports has he seen on the impact of climate Supplementary. What reports has he seen on the impact of climate change seen on the impact of climate change on seen on the impact of climate change on the seen on the impact of climate change on the economy? seen on the impact of climate change on the economy? Mr seen on the impact of climate change on the economy? Mr Speaker, seen on the impact of climate change on the economy? Mr Speaker, as seen on the impact of climate change on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard today, on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard today, the on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard today, the final on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard today, the final report on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard today, the final report of on the economy? Mr Speaker, as we heard today, the final report of the heard today, the final report of the climate heard today, the final report of the climate commission heard today, the final report of the climate commission has heard today, the final report of the climate commission has released. heard today, the final report of the climate commission has released. It climate commission has released. It shows climate commission has released. It shows that climate commission has released. It shows that we climate commission has released. It shows that we can climate commission has released. It shows that we can build climate commission has released. It shows that we can build on climate commission has released. It shows that we can build on the shows that we can build on the progress shows that we can build on the progress the shows that we can build on the progress the Government shows that we can build on the progress the Government has shows that we can build on the progress the Government has made shows that we can build on the progress the Government has made to progress the Government has made to meet progress the Government has made to meet our progress the Government has made to meet our climate progress the Government has made to meet our climate targets progress the Government has made to meet our climate targets in progress the Government has made to meet our climate targets in a progress the Government has made to meet our climate targets in a way meet our climate targets in a way that's meet our climate targets in a way that's affordable meet our climate targets in a way that's affordable and meet our climate targets in a way that's affordable and achievable. that's affordable and achievable. The that's affordable and achievable. The commission that's affordable and achievable. The commission has that's affordable and achievable. The commission has revised that's affordable and achievable. The commission has revised its The commission has revised its modelling The commission has revised its modelling of The commission has revised its modelling of the The commission has revised its modelling of the GDP The commission has revised its modelling of the GDP impact, The commission has revised its modelling of the GDP impact, it The commission has revised its modelling of the GDP impact, it now modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates the modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates the level modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates the level of modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates the level of GDP modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates the level of GDP could modelling of the GDP impact, it now estimates the level of GDP could be estimates the level of GDP could be around estimates the level of GDP could be around 0.5% estimates the level of GDP could be around 0.5% lower estimates the level of GDP could be around 0.5% lower in estimates the level of GDP could be around 0.5% lower in 2035, estimates the level of GDP could be around 0.5% lower in 2035, and estimates the level of GDP could be around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% lower around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% lower in around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% lower in 2050 around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% lower in 2050 it around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% lower in 2050 it would around 0.5% lower in 2035, and 1.2% lower in 2050 it would have lower in 2050 it would have otherwise lower in 2050 it would have otherwise been. lower in 2050 it would have otherwise been. Importantly, lower in 2050 it would have otherwise been. Importantly, the otherwise been. Importantly, the commission otherwise been. Importantly, the commission has otherwise been. Importantly, the commission has now otherwise been. Importantly, the commission has now included otherwise been. Importantly, the commission has now included an commission has now included an estimate commission has now included an estimate of commission has now included an estimate of the commission has now included an estimate of the impact commission has now included an estimate of the impact on commission has now included an estimate of the impact on GDP commission has now included an estimate of the impact on GDP of estimate of the impact on GDP of delaying estimate of the impact on GDP of delaying action. estimate of the impact on GDP of delaying action. It estimate of the impact on GDP of delaying action. It says estimate of the impact on GDP of delaying action. It says that estimate of the impact on GDP of delaying action. It says that delay, delaying action. It says that delay, particularly delaying action. It says that delay, particularly in delaying action. It says that delay, particularly in deploying delaying action. It says that delay, particularly in deploying electric particularly in deploying electric vehicles particularly in deploying electric vehicles and particularly in deploying electric vehicles and improved particularly in deploying electric vehicles and improved farm particularly in deploying electric vehicles and improved farm practises vehicles and improved farm practises could vehicles and improved farm practises could result vehicles and improved farm practises could result in vehicles and improved farm practises could result in a vehicles and improved farm practises could result in a level vehicles and improved farm practises could result in a level of vehicles and improved farm practises could result in a level of GDP could result in a level of GDP falling could result in a level of GDP falling by could result in a level of GDP falling by 2.3% could result in a level of GDP falling by 2.3% in could result in a level of GDP falling by 2.3% in 2050. could result in a level of GDP falling by 2.3% in 2050. The falling by 2.3% in 2050. The Government falling by 2.3% in 2050. The Government welcomes falling by 2.3% in 2050. The Government welcomes this falling by 2.3% in 2050. The Government welcomes this report falling by 2.3% in 2050. The Government welcomes this report and Government welcomes this report and is Government welcomes this report and is now Government welcomes this report and is now working Government welcomes this report and is now working its Government welcomes this report and is now working its way Government welcomes this report and is now working its way through Government welcomes this report and is now working its way through its is now working its way through its recommendations is now working its way through its recommendations for is now working its way through its recommendations for its is now working its way through its recommendations for its response. recommendations for its response. Has recommendations for its response. Has he recommendations for its response. Has he seen recommendations for its response. Has he seen the recommendations for its response. Has he seen the ANZ recommendations for its response. Has he seen the ANZ New recommendations for its response. Has he seen the ANZ New Zealand Has he seen the ANZ New Zealand business Has he seen the ANZ New Zealand business outlook Has he seen the ANZ New Zealand business outlook report Has he seen the ANZ New Zealand business outlook report that Has he seen the ANZ New Zealand business outlook report that showed business outlook report that showed that business outlook report that showed that 86% business outlook report that showed that 86% of business outlook report that showed that 86% of businesses business outlook report that showed that 86% of businesses are business outlook report that showed that 86% of businesses are expecting that 86% of businesses are expecting higher that 86% of businesses are expecting higher costs that 86% of businesses are expecting higher costs ahead, that 86% of businesses are expecting higher costs ahead, which that 86% of businesses are expecting higher costs ahead, which is that 86% of businesses are expecting higher costs ahead, which is bad higher costs ahead, which is bad news higher costs ahead, which is bad news for higher costs ahead, which is bad news for super higher costs ahead, which is bad news for super antants higher costs ahead, which is bad news for super antants and higher costs ahead, which is bad news for super antants and low news for super antants and low income news for super antants and low income earners? news for super antants and low income earners? I news for super antants and low income earners? I have news for super antants and low income earners? I have seen news for super antants and low income earners? I have seen that income earners? I have seen that report, income earners? I have seen that report, what income earners? I have seen that report, what it income earners? I have seen that report, what it does income earners? I have seen that report, what it does say income earners? I have seen that report, what it does say is income earners? I have seen that report, what it does say is that report, what it does say is that firms report, what it does say is that firms are report, what it does say is that firms are very report, what it does say is that firms are very optimistic report, what it does say is that firms are very optimistic about firms are very optimistic about their firms are very optimistic about their own firms are very optimistic about their own outlook, firms are very optimistic about their own outlook, their firms are very optimistic about their own outlook, their investment their own outlook, their investment and their own outlook, their investment and export their own outlook, their investment and export expectations their own outlook, their investment and export expectations and their own outlook, their investment and export expectations and their and export expectations and their profit and export expectations and their profit expectations. and export expectations and their profit expectations. I and export expectations and their profit expectations. I tend and export expectations and their profit expectations. I tend to and export expectations and their profit expectations. I tend to look profit expectations. I tend to look at profit expectations. I tend to look at the profit expectations. I tend to look at the optimistic profit expectations. I tend to look at the optimistic side profit expectations. I tend to look at the optimistic side of profit expectations. I tend to look at the optimistic side of the at the optimistic side of the report, at the optimistic side of the report, Mr at the optimistic side of the report, Mr Speaker. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all of Minister: Does she stand by all of her Minister: Does she stand by all of her Government's Minister: Does she stand by all of her Government's statements Minister: Does she stand by all of her Government's statements and her Government's statements and actions? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, yes. Mr Speaker, yes. In Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I stand Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I stand by Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I stand by this Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I stand by this Government's Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I stand by this Government's focus Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, I stand by this Government's focus on stand by this Government's focus on a stand by this Government's focus on a COVID-19 stand by this Government's focus on a COVID-19 immunisation stand by this Government's focus on a COVID-19 immunisation programme a COVID-19 immunisation programme centred a COVID-19 immunisation programme centred on a COVID-19 immunisation programme centred on the a COVID-19 immunisation programme centred on the Pfizer a COVID-19 immunisation programme centred on the Pfizer vaccine a COVID-19 immunisation programme centred on the Pfizer vaccine and centred on the Pfizer vaccine and welcome centred on the Pfizer vaccine and welcome yesterday's centred on the Pfizer vaccine and welcome yesterday's announcement centred on the Pfizer vaccine and welcome yesterday's announcement of welcome yesterday's announcement of 1 welcome yesterday's announcement of 1 million welcome yesterday's announcement of 1 million doses welcome yesterday's announcement of 1 million doses arriving welcome yesterday's announcement of 1 million doses arriving in welcome yesterday's announcement of 1 million doses arriving in July. 1 million doses arriving in July. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> This <INTERRUPTION> This means <INTERRUPTION> This means double <INTERRUPTION> This means double the <INTERRUPTION> This means double the number <INTERRUPTION> This means double the number of This means double the number of vaccines This means double the number of vaccines will This means double the number of vaccines will be This means double the number of vaccines will be received This means double the number of vaccines will be received by This means double the number of vaccines will be received by the This means double the number of vaccines will be received by the end vaccines will be received by the end of vaccines will be received by the end of next vaccines will be received by the end of next month vaccines will be received by the end of next month and vaccines will be received by the end of next month and we'll vaccines will be received by the end of next month and we'll have vaccines will be received by the end of next month and we'll have enough of next month and we'll have enough stock of next month and we'll have enough stock to of next month and we'll have enough stock to fully of next month and we'll have enough stock to fully vaccinate of next month and we'll have enough stock to fully vaccinate one of next month and we'll have enough stock to fully vaccinate one million stock to fully vaccinate one million New stock to fully vaccinate one million New Zealanders. stock to fully vaccinate one million New Zealanders. With stock to fully vaccinate one million New Zealanders. With this New Zealanders. With this announcement New Zealanders. With this announcement we New Zealanders. With this announcement we can New Zealanders. With this announcement we can continue New Zealanders. With this announcement we can continue ramping announcement we can continue ramping up announcement we can continue ramping up our announcement we can continue ramping up our rollout announcement we can continue ramping up our rollout and announcement we can continue ramping up our rollout and will announcement we can continue ramping up our rollout and will ensure announcement we can continue ramping up our rollout and will ensure that up our rollout and will ensure that everyone up our rollout and will ensure that everyone in up our rollout and will ensure that everyone in New up our rollout and will ensure that everyone in New Zealand up our rollout and will ensure that everyone in New Zealand who up our rollout and will ensure that everyone in New Zealand who wants up our rollout and will ensure that everyone in New Zealand who wants a everyone in New Zealand who wants a vaccine everyone in New Zealand who wants a vaccine will everyone in New Zealand who wants a vaccine will be everyone in New Zealand who wants a vaccine will be offered everyone in New Zealand who wants a vaccine will be offered one. everyone in New Zealand who wants a vaccine will be offered one. With vaccine will be offered one. With 20,000 vaccine will be offered one. With 20,000 doses vaccine will be offered one. With 20,000 doses a vaccine will be offered one. With 20,000 doses a day vaccine will be offered one. With 20,000 doses a day being 20,000 doses a day being administered 20,000 doses a day being administered and 20,000 doses a day being administered and greater 20,000 doses a day being administered and greater certainty administered and greater certainty of administered and greater certainty of supply, administered and greater certainty of supply, the administered and greater certainty of supply, the Government administered and greater certainty of supply, the Government is administered and greater certainty of supply, the Government is on of supply, the Government is on track of supply, the Government is on track to of supply, the Government is on track to reach of supply, the Government is on track to reach the of supply, the Government is on track to reach the peak of supply, the Government is on track to reach the peak of of supply, the Government is on track to reach the peak of our track to reach the peak of our programme track to reach the peak of our programme in track to reach the peak of our programme in August track to reach the peak of our programme in August and track to reach the peak of our programme in August and September, programme in August and September, where programme in August and September, where we'll programme in August and September, where we'll deliver programme in August and September, where we'll deliver 50,000 programme in August and September, where we'll deliver 50,000 doses programme in August and September, where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per day. where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per day. Mr where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per day. Mr Speaker, where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per day. Mr Speaker, offering where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per day. Mr Speaker, offering a where we'll deliver 50,000 doses per day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to every day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to every New day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to every New Zealander day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to every New Zealander who day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to every New Zealander who wants day. Mr Speaker, offering a vaccine to every New Zealander who wants one to every New Zealander who wants one is to every New Zealander who wants one is the to every New Zealander who wants one is the best to every New Zealander who wants one is the best way to every New Zealander who wants one is the best way as to every New Zealander who wants one is the best way as a to every New Zealander who wants one is the best way as a country to every New Zealander who wants one is the best way as a country we to every New Zealander who wants one is the best way as a country we can is the best way as a country we can secure is the best way as a country we can secure our is the best way as a country we can secure our recovery. is the best way as a country we can secure our recovery. Supplementary. secure our recovery. Supplementary. Why secure our recovery. Supplementary. Why has secure our recovery. Supplementary. Why has she secure our recovery. Supplementary. Why has she prioritised secure our recovery. Supplementary. Why has she prioritised a secure our recovery. Supplementary. Why has she prioritised a cycling Why has she prioritised a cycling bridge Why has she prioritised a cycling bridge that Why has she prioritised a cycling bridge that may Why has she prioritised a cycling bridge that may benefit Why has she prioritised a cycling bridge that may benefit 3,000 bridge that may benefit 3,000 people, bridge that may benefit 3,000 people, over bridge that may benefit 3,000 people, over developing bridge that may benefit 3,000 people, over developing the bridge that may benefit 3,000 people, over developing the Mill people, over developing the Mill Road people, over developing the Mill Road highway people, over developing the Mill Road highway to people, over developing the Mill Road highway to support people, over developing the Mill Road highway to support 20,000 Road highway to support 20,000 people Road highway to support 20,000 people living Road highway to support 20,000 people living in Road highway to support 20,000 people living in southern Road highway to support 20,000 people living in southern Auckland? people living in southern Auckland? Mr people living in southern Auckland? Mr Speaker, people living in southern Auckland? Mr Speaker, I people living in southern Auckland? Mr Speaker, I refer people living in southern Auckland? Mr Speaker, I refer the people living in southern Auckland? Mr Speaker, I refer the member people living in southern Auckland? Mr Speaker, I refer the member to Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the fact Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the fact we Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the fact we have Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the fact we have varied Mr Speaker, I refer the member to the fact we have varied the the fact we have varied the investment the fact we have varied the investment around the fact we have varied the investment around Mill the fact we have varied the investment around Mill Road the fact we have varied the investment around Mill Road because investment around Mill Road because without investment around Mill Road because without that, investment around Mill Road because without that, it investment around Mill Road because without that, it would investment around Mill Road because without that, it would have investment around Mill Road because without that, it would have - investment around Mill Road because without that, it would have - it without that, it would have - it would without that, it would have - it would have without that, it would have - it would have been without that, it would have - it would have been the without that, it would have - it would have been the most without that, it would have - it would have been the most expensive would have been the most expensive road would have been the most expensive road in would have been the most expensive road in the would have been the most expensive road in the country. would have been the most expensive road in the country. At would have been the most expensive road in the country. At $3.5 road in the country. At $3.5 million. road in the country. At $3.5 million. It road in the country. At $3.5 million. It was road in the country. At $3.5 million. It was prudent road in the country. At $3.5 million. It was prudent and million. It was prudent and necessary million. It was prudent and necessary to million. It was prudent and necessary to take million. It was prudent and necessary to take another million. It was prudent and necessary to take another look million. It was prudent and necessary to take another look at necessary to take another look at that necessary to take another look at that investment. necessary to take another look at that investment. The necessary to take another look at that investment. The changes necessary to take another look at that investment. The changes that necessary to take another look at that investment. The changes that we that investment. The changes that we have that investment. The changes that we have made that investment. The changes that we have made will that investment. The changes that we have made will still that investment. The changes that we have made will still allow that investment. The changes that we have made will still allow the have made will still allow the acceleration have made will still allow the acceleration of have made will still allow the acceleration of housing have made will still allow the acceleration of housing development acceleration of housing development in acceleration of housing development in a acceleration of housing development in a really acceleration of housing development in a really critical acceleration of housing development in a really critical area acceleration of housing development in a really critical area of in a really critical area of Auckland. in a really critical area of Auckland. Why in a really critical area of Auckland. Why has in a really critical area of Auckland. Why has she in a really critical area of Auckland. Why has she prioritised in a really critical area of Auckland. Why has she prioritised a Auckland. Why has she prioritised a $765 Auckland. Why has she prioritised a $765 million Auckland. Why has she prioritised a $765 million cycle Auckland. Why has she prioritised a $765 million cycle bridge Auckland. Why has she prioritised a $765 million cycle bridge to Auckland. Why has she prioritised a $765 million cycle bridge to the $765 million cycle bridge to the north $765 million cycle bridge to the north shore, $765 million cycle bridge to the north shore, when $765 million cycle bridge to the north shore, when commuting $765 million cycle bridge to the north shore, when commuting to $765 million cycle bridge to the north shore, when commuting to the north shore, when commuting to the CBD north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes more north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes more than north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes more than an north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes more than an hour north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes more than an hour by north shore, when commuting to the CBD takes more than an hour by car, CBD takes more than an hour by car, and CBD takes more than an hour by car, and over CBD takes more than an hour by car, and over 80 CBD takes more than an hour by car, and over 80 minutes CBD takes more than an hour by car, and over 80 minutes one CBD takes more than an hour by car, and over 80 minutes one way CBD takes more than an hour by car, and over 80 minutes one way using and over 80 minutes one way using rail? and over 80 minutes one way using rail? Mr and over 80 minutes one way using rail? Mr Speaker, and over 80 minutes one way using rail? Mr Speaker, you'll and over 80 minutes one way using rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see and over 80 minutes one way using rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency in rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency in the rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency in the fact rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency in the fact we rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency in the fact we have rail? Mr Speaker, you'll see a consistency in the fact we have made consistency in the fact we have made decisions consistency in the fact we have made decisions that consistency in the fact we have made decisions that are consistency in the fact we have made decisions that are investing consistency in the fact we have made decisions that are investing in consistency in the fact we have made decisions that are investing in high decisions that are investing in high growth decisions that are investing in high growth areas decisions that are investing in high growth areas while decisions that are investing in high growth areas while working decisions that are investing in high growth areas while working to decisions that are investing in high growth areas while working to reduce growth areas while working to reduce emissions. growth areas while working to reduce emissions. Investments growth areas while working to reduce emissions. Investments in growth areas while working to reduce emissions. Investments in the growth areas while working to reduce emissions. Investments in the south emissions. Investments in the south are emissions. Investments in the south are about emissions. Investments in the south are about better emissions. Investments in the south are about better connectivity. emissions. Investments in the south are about better connectivity. We are about better connectivity. We have are about better connectivity. We have another are about better connectivity. We have another train are about better connectivity. We have another train station are about better connectivity. We have another train station going have another train station going into have another train station going into an have another train station going into an area have another train station going into an area of have another train station going into an area of high have another train station going into an area of high growth, have another train station going into an area of high growth, because into an area of high growth, because our into an area of high growth, because our view into an area of high growth, because our view is into an area of high growth, because our view is we into an area of high growth, because our view is we need into an area of high growth, because our view is we need to into an area of high growth, because our view is we need to provide our view is we need to provide options our view is we need to provide options for our view is we need to provide options for those our view is we need to provide options for those looking our view is we need to provide options for those looking to our view is we need to provide options for those looking to move options for those looking to move around options for those looking to move around the options for those looking to move around the city. options for those looking to move around the city. At options for those looking to move around the city. At the options for those looking to move around the city. At the moment options for those looking to move around the city. At the moment we around the city. At the moment we have around the city. At the moment we have over around the city. At the moment we have over a around the city. At the moment we have over a number around the city. At the moment we have over a number of around the city. At the moment we have over a number of decades around the city. At the moment we have over a number of decades a around the city. At the moment we have over a number of decades a very have over a number of decades a very significant have over a number of decades a very significant investment have over a number of decades a very significant investment in have over a number of decades a very significant investment in roading significant investment in roading and significant investment in roading and not significant investment in roading and not enough significant investment in roading and not enough investment and not enough investment consistently and not enough investment consistently in and not enough investment consistently in public and not enough investment consistently in public transport consistently in public transport options. consistently in public transport options. Supplementary. consistently in public transport options. Supplementary. Does consistently in public transport options. Supplementary. Does she options. Supplementary. Does she stand options. Supplementary. Does she stand by options. Supplementary. Does she stand by the options. Supplementary. Does she stand by the Government's stand by the Government's investments stand by the Government's investments through stand by the Government's investments through the stand by the Government's investments through the New stand by the Government's investments through the New Zealand investments through the New Zealand upgrade investments through the New Zealand upgrade programme investments through the New Zealand upgrade programme and investments through the New Zealand upgrade programme and the investments through the New Zealand upgrade programme and the Papakura upgrade programme and the Papakura electorate upgrade programme and the Papakura electorate in upgrade programme and the Papakura electorate in terms upgrade programme and the Papakura electorate in terms of upgrade programme and the Papakura electorate in terms of the upgrade programme and the Papakura electorate in terms of the State electorate in terms of the State Highway electorate in terms of the State Highway 1 electorate in terms of the State Highway 1 investment electorate in terms of the State Highway 1 investment between Highway 1 investment between Papakura Highway 1 investment between Papakura and Highway 1 investment between Papakura and Drury, Highway 1 investment between Papakura and Drury, ask Highway 1 investment between Papakura and Drury, ask the Papakura and Drury, ask the electrification Papakura and Drury, ask the electrification programme? Papakura and Drury, ask the electrification programme? Order. electrification programme? Order. I'm electrification programme? Order. I'm going electrification programme? Order. I'm going to electrification programme? Order. I'm going to rule electrification programme? Order. I'm going to rule the electrification programme? Order. I'm going to rule the question electrification programme? Order. I'm going to rule the question out. I'm going to rule the question out. Because I'm going to rule the question out. Because I've I'm going to rule the question out. Because I've been I'm going to rule the question out. Because I've been making I'm going to rule the question out. Because I've been making it I'm going to rule the question out. Because I've been making it clear I'm going to rule the question out. Because I've been making it clear to Because I've been making it clear to members Because I've been making it clear to members they Because I've been making it clear to members they don't Because I've been making it clear to members they don't add Because I've been making it clear to members they don't add extra Because I've been making it clear to members they don't add extra things members they don't add extra things on members they don't add extra things on when members they don't add extra things on when they members they don't add extra things on when they have members they don't add extra things on when they have finished members they don't add extra things on when they have finished their on when they have finished their question on when they have finished their question in on when they have finished their question in the on when they have finished their question in the way on when they have finished their question in the way the on when they have finished their question in the way the minister on when they have finished their question in the way the minister did question in the way the minister did then. question in the way the minister did then. Supplementary. question in the way the minister did then. Supplementary. Why question in the way the minister did then. Supplementary. Why has question in the way the minister did then. Supplementary. Why has - then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, what then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, what is then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, what is her then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, what is her response then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, what is her response to then. Supplementary. Why has - sorry, what is her response to chair sorry, what is her response to chair of sorry, what is her response to chair of the sorry, what is her response to chair of the infrastructure sorry, what is her response to chair of the infrastructure commission, sorry, what is her response to chair of the infrastructure commission, Dr of the infrastructure commission, Dr Alan of the infrastructure commission, Dr Alan bollard, of the infrastructure commission, Dr Alan bollard, who of the infrastructure commission, Dr Alan bollard, who says of the infrastructure commission, Dr Alan bollard, who says the of the infrastructure commission, Dr Alan bollard, who says the cycle Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it will Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it will move Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it will move less Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it will move less than Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it will move less than 1% Alan bollard, who says the cycle bridge "it will move less than 1% of bridge "it will move less than 1% of the bridge "it will move less than 1% of the existing bridge "it will move less than 1% of the existing bridge bridge "it will move less than 1% of the existing bridge traffic, bridge "it will move less than 1% of the existing bridge traffic, while the existing bridge traffic, while subsidising the existing bridge traffic, while subsidising one the existing bridge traffic, while subsidising one of the existing bridge traffic, while subsidising one of the the existing bridge traffic, while subsidising one of the wealthiest subsidising one of the wealthiest suburbs subsidising one of the wealthiest suburbs in subsidising one of the wealthiest suburbs in the subsidising one of the wealthiest suburbs in the country. subsidising one of the wealthiest suburbs in the country. The suburbs in the country. The arithmetic suburbs in the country. The arithmetic doesn't suburbs in the country. The arithmetic doesn't stack suburbs in the country. The arithmetic doesn't stack up." suburbs in the country. The arithmetic doesn't stack up." I arithmetic doesn't stack up." I don't arithmetic doesn't stack up." I don't expect arithmetic doesn't stack up." I don't expect every arithmetic doesn't stack up." I don't expect every individual arithmetic doesn't stack up." I don't expect every individual to don't expect every individual to support don't expect every individual to support the don't expect every individual to support the idea don't expect every individual to support the idea of don't expect every individual to support the idea of providing support the idea of providing multimodal support the idea of providing multimodal transport. support the idea of providing multimodal transport. I support the idea of providing multimodal transport. I believe support the idea of providing multimodal transport. I believe if multimodal transport. I believe if we're multimodal transport. I believe if we're going multimodal transport. I believe if we're going to multimodal transport. I believe if we're going to create multimodal transport. I believe if we're going to create an we're going to create an international we're going to create an international city, we're going to create an international city, where we're going to create an international city, where we we're going to create an international city, where we can international city, where we can move international city, where we can move people international city, where we can move people around international city, where we can move people around the international city, where we can move people around the city international city, where we can move people around the city through move people around the city through various move people around the city through various modes move people around the city through various modes of move people around the city through various modes of transport, move people around the city through various modes of transport, and move people around the city through various modes of transport, and we various modes of transport, and we have various modes of transport, and we have as various modes of transport, and we have as a various modes of transport, and we have as a party various modes of transport, and we have as a party and various modes of transport, and we have as a party and as various modes of transport, and we have as a party and as a various modes of transport, and we have as a party and as a Government have as a party and as a Government made have as a party and as a Government made a have as a party and as a Government made a commitment have as a party and as a Government made a commitment to have as a party and as a Government made a commitment to enabling have as a party and as a Government made a commitment to enabling that made a commitment to enabling that between made a commitment to enabling that between the made a commitment to enabling that between the north made a commitment to enabling that between the north shore made a commitment to enabling that between the north shore and made a commitment to enabling that between the north shore and the made a commitment to enabling that between the north shore and the CBD, between the north shore and the CBD, but between the north shore and the CBD, but we're between the north shore and the CBD, but we're struck between the north shore and the CBD, but we're struck with between the north shore and the CBD, but we're struck with a between the north shore and the CBD, but we're struck with a structural but we're struck with a structural issue but we're struck with a structural issue that but we're struck with a structural issue that prevents but we're struck with a structural issue that prevents that, but we're struck with a structural issue that prevents that, we're issue that prevents that, we're working issue that prevents that, we're working to issue that prevents that, we're working to find issue that prevents that, we're working to find our issue that prevents that, we're working to find our way issue that prevents that, we're working to find our way around issue that prevents that, we're working to find our way around that. working to find our way around that. That's working to find our way around that. That's what working to find our way around that. That's what we working to find our way around that. That's what we proposed. working to find our way around that. That's what we proposed. I working to find our way around that. That's what we proposed. I do working to find our way around that. That's what we proposed. I do note That's what we proposed. I do note it That's what we proposed. I do note it seems That's what we proposed. I do note it seems a That's what we proposed. I do note it seems a significant That's what we proposed. I do note it seems a significant departure That's what we proposed. I do note it seems a significant departure for it seems a significant departure for the it seems a significant departure for the member it seems a significant departure for the member and it seems a significant departure for the member and her it seems a significant departure for the member and her party, it seems a significant departure for the member and her party, who the member and her party, who previously the member and her party, who previously had the member and her party, who previously had supported the member and her party, who previously had supported a the member and her party, who previously had supported a route previously had supported a route that previously had supported a route that connected previously had supported a route that connected the previously had supported a route that connected the north previously had supported a route that connected the north shore previously had supported a route that connected the north shore and that connected the north shore and the that connected the north shore and the CBD, that connected the north shore and the CBD, I that connected the north shore and the CBD, I notice that connected the north shore and the CBD, I notice they that connected the north shore and the CBD, I notice they no that connected the north shore and the CBD, I notice they no longer the CBD, I notice they no longer support the CBD, I notice they no longer support that. the CBD, I notice they no longer support that. I the CBD, I notice they no longer support that. I would the CBD, I notice they no longer support that. I would be the CBD, I notice they no longer support that. I would be very support that. I would be very interested support that. I would be very interested to support that. I would be very interested to know support that. I would be very interested to know whether support that. I would be very interested to know whether or support that. I would be very interested to know whether or not interested to know whether or not that's interested to know whether or not that's the interested to know whether or not that's the view interested to know whether or not that's the view of interested to know whether or not that's the view of all interested to know whether or not that's the view of all their interested to know whether or not that's the view of all their members that's the view of all their members in that's the view of all their members in Auckland. that's the view of all their members in Auckland. Is that's the view of all their members in Auckland. Is $785 that's the view of all their members in Auckland. Is $785 million that's the view of all their members in Auckland. Is $785 million to that's the view of all their members in Auckland. Is $785 million to move in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less than in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less than 1% in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less than 1% of in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less than 1% of traffic in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less than 1% of traffic from in Auckland. Is $785 million to move less than 1% of traffic from the less than 1% of traffic from the bridge less than 1% of traffic from the bridge the less than 1% of traffic from the bridge the type less than 1% of traffic from the bridge the type of less than 1% of traffic from the bridge the type of return less than 1% of traffic from the bridge the type of return she bridge the type of return she expects bridge the type of return she expects when bridge the type of return she expects when investing bridge the type of return she expects when investing taxpayer expects when investing taxpayer money? expects when investing taxpayer money? Mr expects when investing taxpayer money? Mr Speaker, expects when investing taxpayer money? Mr Speaker, I expects when investing taxpayer money? Mr Speaker, I have expects when investing taxpayer money? Mr Speaker, I have previously money? Mr Speaker, I have previously seen money? Mr Speaker, I have previously seen that money? Mr Speaker, I have previously seen that member's money? Mr Speaker, I have previously seen that member's party money? Mr Speaker, I have previously seen that member's party make seen that member's party make decisions seen that member's party make decisions on seen that member's party make decisions on roading seen that member's party make decisions on roading projects seen that member's party make decisions on roading projects that decisions on roading projects that did decisions on roading projects that did not decisions on roading projects that did not stack decisions on roading projects that did not stack up. decisions on roading projects that did not stack up. We decisions on roading projects that did not stack up. We have decisions on roading projects that did not stack up. We have made decisions on roading projects that did not stack up. We have made a did not stack up. We have made a judgement, did not stack up. We have made a judgement, for did not stack up. We have made a judgement, for instance, did not stack up. We have made a judgement, for instance, on did not stack up. We have made a judgement, for instance, on Mill judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, that judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, that we judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, that we could judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, that we could not judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, that we could not justify judgement, for instance, on Mill Road, that we could not justify the Road, that we could not justify the investment Road, that we could not justify the investment in Road, that we could not justify the investment in what Road, that we could not justify the investment in what would Road, that we could not justify the investment in what would become Road, that we could not justify the investment in what would become the investment in what would become the most investment in what would become the most expensive investment in what would become the most expensive project investment in what would become the most expensive project in investment in what would become the most expensive project in the most expensive project in the country. most expensive project in the country. We most expensive project in the country. We have most expensive project in the country. We have a most expensive project in the country. We have a connection most expensive project in the country. We have a connection where country. We have a connection where people country. We have a connection where people cannot country. We have a connection where people cannot walk, country. We have a connection where people cannot walk, cannot country. We have a connection where people cannot walk, cannot cycle, people cannot walk, cannot cycle, they're people cannot walk, cannot cycle, they're cut people cannot walk, cannot cycle, they're cut off people cannot walk, cannot cycle, they're cut off from people cannot walk, cannot cycle, they're cut off from joining people cannot walk, cannot cycle, they're cut off from joining other they're cut off from joining other public they're cut off from joining other public transport they're cut off from joining other public transport networks they're cut off from joining other public transport networks between public transport networks between the public transport networks between the north public transport networks between the north shore public transport networks between the north shore and public transport networks between the north shore and the public transport networks between the north shore and the CBD. public transport networks between the north shore and the CBD. We public transport networks between the north shore and the CBD. We have the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates of the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates of how the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates of how many the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates of how many would the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates of how many would use the north shore and the CBD. We have estimates of how many would use that estimates of how many would use that daily, estimates of how many would use that daily, that's estimates of how many would use that daily, that's on estimates of how many would use that daily, that's on a estimates of how many would use that daily, that's on a previous estimates of how many would use that daily, that's on a previous business daily, that's on a previous business case, daily, that's on a previous business case, but daily, that's on a previous business case, but our daily, that's on a previous business case, but our view daily, that's on a previous business case, but our view it's daily, that's on a previous business case, but our view it's a daily, that's on a previous business case, but our view it's a connection case, but our view it's a connection that's case, but our view it's a connection that's required. case, but our view it's a connection that's required. By case, but our view it's a connection that's required. By how case, but our view it's a connection that's required. By how many case, but our view it's a connection that's required. By how many minutes that's required. By how many minutes will that's required. By how many minutes will the that's required. By how many minutes will the $785 that's required. By how many minutes will the $785 million that's required. By how many minutes will the $785 million cycle that's required. By how many minutes will the $785 million cycle bridge will the $785 million cycle bridge reduce will the $785 million cycle bridge reduce the will the $785 million cycle bridge reduce the average will the $785 million cycle bridge reduce the average commute will the $785 million cycle bridge reduce the average commute time will the $785 million cycle bridge reduce the average commute time from reduce the average commute time from the reduce the average commute time from the north reduce the average commute time from the north shore reduce the average commute time from the north shore to reduce the average commute time from the north shore to the reduce the average commute time from the north shore to the CBD, reduce the average commute time from the north shore to the CBD, if reduce the average commute time from the north shore to the CBD, if any? the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two points, the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two points, using the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two points, using two the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two points, using two lanes the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two points, using two lanes of the north shore to the CBD, if any? Two points, using two lanes of the Two points, using two lanes of the harbour Two points, using two lanes of the harbour bridge Two points, using two lanes of the harbour bridge to Two points, using two lanes of the harbour bridge to provide Two points, using two lanes of the harbour bridge to provide the Two points, using two lanes of the harbour bridge to provide the same harbour bridge to provide the same thing harbour bridge to provide the same thing will harbour bridge to provide the same thing will likely harbour bridge to provide the same thing will likely contribute harbour bridge to provide the same thing will likely contribute to thing will likely contribute to congestion thing will likely contribute to congestion on thing will likely contribute to congestion on the thing will likely contribute to congestion on the existing thing will likely contribute to congestion on the existing route. congestion on the existing route. That's congestion on the existing route. That's why congestion on the existing route. That's why we congestion on the existing route. That's why we have congestion on the existing route. That's why we have not congestion on the existing route. That's why we have not favoured congestion on the existing route. That's why we have not favoured that That's why we have not favoured that option. That's why we have not favoured that option. When That's why we have not favoured that option. When it That's why we have not favoured that option. When it comes That's why we have not favoured that option. When it comes to That's why we have not favoured that option. When it comes to commute option. When it comes to commute times option. When it comes to commute times for option. When it comes to commute times for this option. When it comes to commute times for this current option. When it comes to commute times for this current proposal, option. When it comes to commute times for this current proposal, if times for this current proposal, if the times for this current proposal, if the members times for this current proposal, if the members chooses times for this current proposal, if the members chooses to times for this current proposal, if the members chooses to put times for this current proposal, if the members chooses to put a the members chooses to put a question the members chooses to put a question on the members chooses to put a question on notice, the members chooses to put a question on notice, I'm the members chooses to put a question on notice, I'm sure the members chooses to put a question on notice, I'm sure I the members chooses to put a question on notice, I'm sure I can question on notice, I'm sure I can provide question on notice, I'm sure I can provide further question on notice, I'm sure I can provide further information. question on notice, I'm sure I can provide further information. What question on notice, I'm sure I can provide further information. What is provide further information. What is her provide further information. What is her response provide further information. What is her response to provide further information. What is her response to the provide further information. What is her response to the people provide further information. What is her response to the people of her response to the people of Ashburton, her response to the people of Ashburton, emailing her response to the people of Ashburton, emailing me, her response to the people of Ashburton, emailing me, asking her response to the people of Ashburton, emailing me, asking how Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she was Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she was able Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she was able to Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she was able to find Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she was able to find $785 Ashburton, emailing me, asking how she was able to find $785 million she was able to find $785 million for she was able to find $785 million for a she was able to find $785 million for a cycle she was able to find $785 million for a cycle bring she was able to find $785 million for a cycle bring in she was able to find $785 million for a cycle bring in Auckland, she was able to find $785 million for a cycle bring in Auckland, but for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 million for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 million to for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 million to build for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 million to build them for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 million to build them a for a cycle bring in Auckland, but not $30 million to build them a much not $30 million to build them a much needed not $30 million to build them a much needed car not $30 million to build them a much needed car bridge not $30 million to build them a much needed car bridge across not $30 million to build them a much needed car bridge across the needed car bridge across the Ashburton needed car bridge across the Ashburton River? needed car bridge across the Ashburton River? This needed car bridge across the Ashburton River? This is needed car bridge across the Ashburton River? This is a Ashburton River? This is a commitment Ashburton River? This is a commitment that Ashburton River? This is a commitment that has Ashburton River? This is a commitment that has been Ashburton River? This is a commitment that has been made Ashburton River? This is a commitment that has been made some commitment that has been made some time commitment that has been made some time ago. commitment that has been made some time ago. As commitment that has been made some time ago. As I commitment that has been made some time ago. As I pointed commitment that has been made some time ago. As I pointed out time ago. As I pointed out yesterday... time ago. As I pointed out yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> As yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> As I yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> As I pointed yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> As I pointed out yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> As I pointed out yesterday, yesterday... <INTERRUPTION> As I pointed out yesterday, the As I pointed out yesterday, the issue As I pointed out yesterday, the issue has As I pointed out yesterday, the issue has been As I pointed out yesterday, the issue has been engineering As I pointed out yesterday, the issue has been engineering works As I pointed out yesterday, the issue has been engineering works has issue has been engineering works has - issue has been engineering works has - the issue has been engineering works has - the engineering issue has been engineering works has - the engineering work issue has been engineering works has - the engineering work has - the engineering work has demonstrated - the engineering work has demonstrated to - the engineering work has demonstrated to us - the engineering work has demonstrated to us the - the engineering work has demonstrated to us the original - the engineering work has demonstrated to us the original plan demonstrated to us the original plan is demonstrated to us the original plan is not demonstrated to us the original plan is not feasible. demonstrated to us the original plan is not feasible. The demonstrated to us the original plan is not feasible. The second demonstrated to us the original plan is not feasible. The second point demonstrated to us the original plan is not feasible. The second point on is not feasible. The second point on Ashburton, is not feasible. The second point on Ashburton, the is not feasible. The second point on Ashburton, the Minister is not feasible. The second point on Ashburton, the Minister of is not feasible. The second point on Ashburton, the Minister of Transport Ashburton, the Minister of Transport visited Ashburton, the Minister of Transport visited with Ashburton, the Minister of Transport visited with the Ashburton, the Minister of Transport visited with the mayor Ashburton, the Minister of Transport visited with the mayor only Ashburton, the Minister of Transport visited with the mayor only last visited with the mayor only last week. visited with the mayor only last week. Obviously visited with the mayor only last week. Obviously the visited with the mayor only last week. Obviously the issues visited with the mayor only last week. Obviously the issues that week. Obviously the issues that we've week. Obviously the issues that we've seen week. Obviously the issues that we've seen from week. Obviously the issues that we've seen from slash week. Obviously the issues that we've seen from slash and week. Obviously the issues that we've seen from slash and the we've seen from slash and the significant we've seen from slash and the significant flooding we've seen from slash and the significant flooding event we've seen from slash and the significant flooding event has we've seen from slash and the significant flooding event has had significant flooding event has had an significant flooding event has had an impact significant flooding event has had an impact on significant flooding event has had an impact on the significant flooding event has had an impact on the bridge. significant flooding event has had an impact on the bridge. NZTA significant flooding event has had an impact on the bridge. NZTA are an impact on the bridge. NZTA are working an impact on the bridge. NZTA are working very an impact on the bridge. NZTA are working very hard an impact on the bridge. NZTA are working very hard to an impact on the bridge. NZTA are working very hard to get an impact on the bridge. NZTA are working very hard to get heavy working very hard to get heavy vehicles working very hard to get heavy vehicles back working very hard to get heavy vehicles back over working very hard to get heavy vehicles back over the working very hard to get heavy vehicles back over the bridge working very hard to get heavy vehicles back over the bridge in vehicles back over the bridge in night vehicles back over the bridge in night hours, vehicles back over the bridge in night hours, because vehicles back over the bridge in night hours, because at vehicles back over the bridge in night hours, because at the vehicles back over the bridge in night hours, because at the moment night hours, because at the moment in night hours, because at the moment in the night hours, because at the moment in the evenings night hours, because at the moment in the evenings they're night hours, because at the moment in the evenings they're taking night hours, because at the moment in the evenings they're taking a in the evenings they're taking a detour. in the evenings they're taking a detour. I in the evenings they're taking a detour. I understand in the evenings they're taking a detour. I understand that in the evenings they're taking a detour. I understand that NZTA in the evenings they're taking a detour. I understand that NZTA are detour. I understand that NZTA are talking detour. I understand that NZTA are talking to detour. I understand that NZTA are talking to local detour. I understand that NZTA are talking to local government detour. I understand that NZTA are talking to local government about detour. I understand that NZTA are talking to local government about a talking to local government about a business talking to local government about a business case talking to local government about a business case for talking to local government about a business case for potentially business case for potentially alternative business case for potentially alternative routes. business case for potentially alternative routes. To business case for potentially alternative routes. To date business case for potentially alternative routes. To date that alternative routes. To date that hasn't alternative routes. To date that hasn't existed. alternative routes. To date that hasn't existed. But alternative routes. To date that hasn't existed. But we're alternative routes. To date that hasn't existed. But we're working hasn't existed. But we're working closely hasn't existed. But we're working closely with hasn't existed. But we're working closely with them, hasn't existed. But we're working closely with them, because hasn't existed. But we're working closely with them, because we hasn't existed. But we're working closely with them, because we see closely with them, because we see the closely with them, because we see the fragility closely with them, because we see the fragility of closely with them, because we see the fragility of the closely with them, because we see the fragility of the connection closely with them, because we see the fragility of the connection down the fragility of the connection down south the fragility of the connection down south that's the fragility of the connection down south that's caused the fragility of the connection down south that's caused by the fragility of the connection down south that's caused by this the fragility of the connection down south that's caused by this flood. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Climate My question is to the Minister of Climate Change: My question is to the Minister of Climate Change: Will My question is to the Minister of Climate Change: Will the My question is to the Minister of Climate Change: Will the Government Climate Change: Will the Government follow Climate Change: Will the Government follow the Climate Change: Will the Government follow the final Climate Change: Will the Government follow the final advice Climate Change: Will the Government follow the final advice of Climate Change: Will the Government follow the final advice of He Climate Change: Will the Government follow the final advice of He Pou Climate Change: Will the Government follow the final advice of He Pou a follow the final advice of He Pou a Rangi, follow the final advice of He Pou a Rangi, the follow the final advice of He Pou a Rangi, the Climate follow the final advice of He Pou a Rangi, the Climate Change Rangi, the Climate Change Commission? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, the Mr Speaker, the commission Mr Speaker, the commission has Mr Speaker, the commission has set Mr Speaker, the commission has set out Mr Speaker, the commission has set out a Mr Speaker, the commission has set out a clear Mr Speaker, the commission has set out a clear direction Mr Speaker, the commission has set out a clear direction for Mr Speaker, the commission has set out a clear direction for our Mr Speaker, the commission has set out a clear direction for our path out a clear direction for our path to out a clear direction for our path to ensure out a clear direction for our path to ensure a out a clear direction for our path to ensure a safe out a clear direction for our path to ensure a safe climate out a clear direction for our path to ensure a safe climate for out a clear direction for our path to ensure a safe climate for future to ensure a safe climate for future generations to ensure a safe climate for future generations and to ensure a safe climate for future generations and we're to ensure a safe climate for future generations and we're already to ensure a safe climate for future generations and we're already moving generations and we're already moving in generations and we're already moving in that generations and we're already moving in that direction. generations and we're already moving in that direction. Cabinet generations and we're already moving in that direction. Cabinet will in that direction. Cabinet will still in that direction. Cabinet will still need in that direction. Cabinet will still need to in that direction. Cabinet will still need to make in that direction. Cabinet will still need to make decisions in that direction. Cabinet will still need to make decisions over still need to make decisions over the still need to make decisions over the coming still need to make decisions over the coming months still need to make decisions over the coming months and still need to make decisions over the coming months and I still need to make decisions over the coming months and I cannot the coming months and I cannot pre-empt the coming months and I cannot pre-empt those the coming months and I cannot pre-empt those decisions the coming months and I cannot pre-empt those decisions today. the coming months and I cannot pre-empt those decisions today. But pre-empt those decisions today. But I pre-empt those decisions today. But I can pre-empt those decisions today. But I can say, pre-empt those decisions today. But I can say, under pre-empt those decisions today. But I can say, under the pre-empt those decisions today. But I can say, under the 0 pre-empt those decisions today. But I can say, under the 0 carbon pre-empt those decisions today. But I can say, under the 0 carbon act, I can say, under the 0 carbon act, the I can say, under the 0 carbon act, the government I can say, under the 0 carbon act, the government has I can say, under the 0 carbon act, the government has to I can say, under the 0 carbon act, the government has to either I can say, under the 0 carbon act, the government has to either follow the government has to either follow the the government has to either follow the commission's the government has to either follow the commission's advice the government has to either follow the commission's advice or the government has to either follow the commission's advice or come the government has to either follow the commission's advice or come up the commission's advice or come up with the commission's advice or come up with a the commission's advice or come up with a better the commission's advice or come up with a better alternative. the commission's advice or come up with a better alternative. Does the commission's advice or come up with a better alternative. Does he with a better alternative. Does he accept with a better alternative. Does he accept the with a better alternative. Does he accept the commission's with a better alternative. Does he accept the commission's conclusion accept the commission's conclusion that accept the commission's conclusion that current accept the commission's conclusion that current policies accept the commission's conclusion that current policies are accept the commission's conclusion that current policies are not accept the commission's conclusion that current policies are not enough that current policies are not enough to that current policies are not enough to meet that current policies are not enough to meet our that current policies are not enough to meet our targets that current policies are not enough to meet our targets for that current policies are not enough to meet our targets for a that current policies are not enough to meet our targets for a low to meet our targets for a low emissions to meet our targets for a low emissions future? to meet our targets for a low emissions future? Do, to meet our targets for a low emissions future? Do, Mr to meet our targets for a low emissions future? Do, Mr Speaker, emissions future? Do, Mr Speaker, that's emissions future? Do, Mr Speaker, that's why emissions future? Do, Mr Speaker, that's why the emissions future? Do, Mr Speaker, that's why the government emissions future? Do, Mr Speaker, that's why the government is that's why the government is planning that's why the government is planning to that's why the government is planning to build that's why the government is planning to build on that's why the government is planning to build on the that's why the government is planning to build on the work that's why the government is planning to build on the work we planning to build on the work we have planning to build on the work we have already planning to build on the work we have already begun planning to build on the work we have already begun to planning to build on the work we have already begun to reduce have already begun to reduce emissions. have already begun to reduce emissions. I have already begun to reduce emissions. I recommend have already begun to reduce emissions. I recommend the emissions. I recommend the commission's emissions. I recommend the commission's conclusions emissions. I recommend the commission's conclusions that commission's conclusions that existing commission's conclusions that existing technologies commission's conclusions that existing technologies make commission's conclusions that existing technologies make taking existing technologies make taking action existing technologies make taking action affordable, existing technologies make taking action affordable, delaying existing technologies make taking action affordable, delaying would existing technologies make taking action affordable, delaying would be action affordable, delaying would be costly, action affordable, delaying would be costly, and action affordable, delaying would be costly, and reducing action affordable, delaying would be costly, and reducing emissions action affordable, delaying would be costly, and reducing emissions can costly, and reducing emissions can have costly, and reducing emissions can have good costly, and reducing emissions can have good outcomes costly, and reducing emissions can have good outcomes for costly, and reducing emissions can have good outcomes for people's have good outcomes for people's health have good outcomes for people's health and have good outcomes for people's health and energy have good outcomes for people's health and energy bills. have good outcomes for people's health and energy bills. The health and energy bills. The commission health and energy bills. The commission has health and energy bills. The commission has told health and energy bills. The commission has told us health and energy bills. The commission has told us we're health and energy bills. The commission has told us we're acting commission has told us we're acting in commission has told us we're acting in the commission has told us we're acting in the right commission has told us we're acting in the right areas commission has told us we're acting in the right areas like commission has told us we're acting in the right areas like transport, in the right areas like transport, energy, in the right areas like transport, energy, agriculture in the right areas like transport, energy, agriculture and in the right areas like transport, energy, agriculture and waste, in the right areas like transport, energy, agriculture and waste, but energy, agriculture and waste, but we energy, agriculture and waste, but we need energy, agriculture and waste, but we need our energy, agriculture and waste, but we need our actions energy, agriculture and waste, but we need our actions to energy, agriculture and waste, but we need our actions to be energy, agriculture and waste, but we need our actions to be both we need our actions to be both bolder we need our actions to be both bolder and we need our actions to be both bolder and faster. we need our actions to be both bolder and faster. How we need our actions to be both bolder and faster. How will we need our actions to be both bolder and faster. How will he bolder and faster. How will he ensure bolder and faster. How will he ensure the bolder and faster. How will he ensure the Government bolder and faster. How will he ensure the Government follows bolder and faster. How will he ensure the Government follows the ensure the Government follows the commission's ensure the Government follows the commission's advice ensure the Government follows the commission's advice to ensure the Government follows the commission's advice to work ensure the Government follows the commission's advice to work in commission's advice to work in partnership commission's advice to work in partnership with commission's advice to work in partnership with iwi commission's advice to work in partnership with iwi Maori? commission's advice to work in partnership with iwi Maori? Mr partnership with iwi Maori? Mr Speaker, partnership with iwi Maori? Mr Speaker, when partnership with iwi Maori? Mr Speaker, when Parliament partnership with iwi Maori? Mr Speaker, when Parliament unanimously Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed the Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed the zero Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed the zero carbon Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed the zero carbon act, Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed the zero carbon act, we Speaker, when Parliament unanimously passed the zero carbon act, we have passed the zero carbon act, we have a passed the zero carbon act, we have a legal passed the zero carbon act, we have a legal requirement passed the zero carbon act, we have a legal requirement to passed the zero carbon act, we have a legal requirement to pay passed the zero carbon act, we have a legal requirement to pay attention a legal requirement to pay attention to a legal requirement to pay attention to the a legal requirement to pay attention to the impacts a legal requirement to pay attention to the impacts on a legal requirement to pay attention to the impacts on iwi a legal requirement to pay attention to the impacts on iwi Maori. a legal requirement to pay attention to the impacts on iwi Maori. That a legal requirement to pay attention to the impacts on iwi Maori. That is to the impacts on iwi Maori. That is very to the impacts on iwi Maori. That is very important to the impacts on iwi Maori. That is very important to to the impacts on iwi Maori. That is very important to the to the impacts on iwi Maori. That is very important to the Government. very important to the Government. When very important to the Government. When will very important to the Government. When will the very important to the Government. When will the Government very important to the Government. When will the Government follow very important to the Government. When will the Government follow the When will the Government follow the commission's When will the Government follow the commission's recommendations When will the Government follow the commission's recommendations to commission's recommendations to incentivise commission's recommendations to incentivise the commission's recommendations to incentivise the uptake commission's recommendations to incentivise the uptake of commission's recommendations to incentivise the uptake of electric incentivise the uptake of electric cars? incentivise the uptake of electric cars? Budget incentivise the uptake of electric cars? Budget 2021 incentivise the uptake of electric cars? Budget 2021 included incentivise the uptake of electric cars? Budget 2021 included $300 cars? Budget 2021 included $300 million cars? Budget 2021 included $300 million to cars? Budget 2021 included $300 million to incentivise cars? Budget 2021 included $300 million to incentivise the cars? Budget 2021 included $300 million to incentivise the uptake cars? Budget 2021 included $300 million to incentivise the uptake of million to incentivise the uptake of electric million to incentivise the uptake of electric vehicles million to incentivise the uptake of electric vehicles and million to incentivise the uptake of electric vehicles and we'll million to incentivise the uptake of electric vehicles and we'll be electric vehicles and we'll be making electric vehicles and we'll be making an electric vehicles and we'll be making an announcement electric vehicles and we'll be making an announcement about electric vehicles and we'll be making an announcement about that making an announcement about that very making an announcement about that very soon. making an announcement about that very soon. Does making an announcement about that very soon. Does they making an announcement about that very soon. Does they support making an announcement about that very soon. Does they support the very soon. Does they support the commission's very soon. Does they support the commission's advice very soon. Does they support the commission's advice to very soon. Does they support the commission's advice to establish commission's advice to establish 300,000 commission's advice to establish 300,000 hectares commission's advice to establish 300,000 hectares of commission's advice to establish 300,000 hectares of new commission's advice to establish 300,000 hectares of new native 300,000 hectares of new native forest 300,000 hectares of new native forest in 300,000 hectares of new native forest in the 300,000 hectares of new native forest in the next 300,000 hectares of new native forest in the next few 300,000 hectares of new native forest in the next few years, forest in the next few years, including forest in the next few years, including integrated forest in the next few years, including integrated pest including integrated pest management? including integrated pest management? Native including integrated pest management? Native forests including integrated pest management? Native forests are management? Native forests are essential management? Native forests are essential to management? Native forests are essential to achieving management? Native forests are essential to achieving both management? Native forests are essential to achieving both our essential to achieving both our climate essential to achieving both our climate change essential to achieving both our climate change targets, essential to achieving both our climate change targets, improving climate change targets, improving our climate change targets, improving our biodiversity climate change targets, improving our biodiversity and climate change targets, improving our biodiversity and restoring climate change targets, improving our biodiversity and restoring the our biodiversity and restoring the ecosystems our biodiversity and restoring the ecosystems that our biodiversity and restoring the ecosystems that sustain our biodiversity and restoring the ecosystems that sustain us. our biodiversity and restoring the ecosystems that sustain us. Native ecosystems that sustain us. Native forestry ecosystems that sustain us. Native forestry can ecosystems that sustain us. Native forestry can provide ecosystems that sustain us. Native forestry can provide enduring ecosystems that sustain us. Native forestry can provide enduring carbon forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks that forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks that clean forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks that clean our forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks that clean our air. forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks that clean our air. What forestry can provide enduring carbon sinks that clean our air. What does sinks that clean our air. What does he sinks that clean our air. What does he expect sinks that clean our air. What does he expect another sinks that clean our air. What does he expect another ministers sinks that clean our air. What does he expect another ministers to sinks that clean our air. What does he expect another ministers to do sinks that clean our air. What does he expect another ministers to do in he expect another ministers to do in response he expect another ministers to do in response to he expect another ministers to do in response to the he expect another ministers to do in response to the Climate he expect another ministers to do in response to the Climate Change response to the Climate Change Commission's response to the Climate Change Commission's advice? response to the Climate Change Commission's advice? It response to the Climate Change Commission's advice? It requires response to the Climate Change Commission's advice? It requires a Commission's advice? It requires a response Commission's advice? It requires a response right Commission's advice? It requires a response right across Commission's advice? It requires a response right across the response right across the Government. response right across the Government. Many response right across the Government. Many ministers response right across the Government. Many ministers are Government. Many ministers are already Government. Many ministers are already working Government. Many ministers are already working together Government. Many ministers are already working together to Government. Many ministers are already working together to develop already working together to develop the already working together to develop the emissions already working together to develop the emissions reduction already working together to develop the emissions reduction plan already working together to develop the emissions reduction plan and the emissions reduction plan and many the emissions reduction plan and many departments the emissions reduction plan and many departments and the emissions reduction plan and many departments and agencies the emissions reduction plan and many departments and agencies are many departments and agencies are doing many departments and agencies are doing their many departments and agencies are doing their bit. many departments and agencies are doing their bit. We many departments and agencies are doing their bit. We know many departments and agencies are doing their bit. We know we many departments and agencies are doing their bit. We know we have many departments and agencies are doing their bit. We know we have the doing their bit. We know we have the right doing their bit. We know we have the right tools doing their bit. We know we have the right tools in doing their bit. We know we have the right tools in the doing their bit. We know we have the right tools in the tool doing their bit. We know we have the right tools in the tool box, doing their bit. We know we have the right tools in the tool box, now doing their bit. We know we have the right tools in the tool box, now we right tools in the tool box, now we need right tools in the tool box, now we need to right tools in the tool box, now we need to put right tools in the tool box, now we need to put them right tools in the tool box, now we need to put them to right tools in the tool box, now we need to put them to use. right tools in the tool box, now we need to put them to use. As right tools in the tool box, now we need to put them to use. As chair right tools in the tool box, now we need to put them to use. As chair of need to put them to use. As chair of the need to put them to use. As chair of the Climate need to put them to use. As chair of the Climate Change need to put them to use. As chair of the Climate Change Commission need to put them to use. As chair of the Climate Change Commission said the Climate Change Commission said today, the Climate Change Commission said today, we the Climate Change Commission said today, we just the Climate Change Commission said today, we just need the Climate Change Commission said today, we just need to the Climate Change Commission said today, we just need to get the Climate Change Commission said today, we just need to get on the Climate Change Commission said today, we just need to get on with today, we just need to get on with it My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: What My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: What recent COVID-19 Response: What recent Minister COVID-19 Response: What recent Minister for COVID-19 Response: What recent Minister for COVID-19 COVID-19 Response: What recent Minister for COVID-19 Response: COVID-19 Response: What recent Minister for COVID-19 Response: What Minister for COVID-19 Response: What recent recent announcements recent announcements has recent announcements has he recent announcements has he made recent announcements has he made on recent announcements has he made on the announcements has he made on the roll-out announcements has he made on the roll-out of announcements has he made on the roll-out of the announcements has he made on the roll-out of the vaccination roll-out of the vaccination programme? - - now. - now. Yesterday - now. Yesterday the - now. Yesterday the PM - now. Yesterday the PM and - now. Yesterday the PM and I - now. Yesterday the PM and I announced - now. Yesterday the PM and I announced that - now. Yesterday the PM and I announced that Pfizer - now. Yesterday the PM and I announced that Pfizer has - now. Yesterday the PM and I announced that Pfizer has scheduled announced that Pfizer has scheduled delivery announced that Pfizer has scheduled delivery of announced that Pfizer has scheduled delivery of an announced that Pfizer has scheduled delivery of an estimated announced that Pfizer has scheduled delivery of an estimated 1 announced that Pfizer has scheduled delivery of an estimated 1 million delivery of an estimated 1 million additional delivery of an estimated 1 million additional doses delivery of an estimated 1 million additional doses of delivery of an estimated 1 million additional doses of the delivery of an estimated 1 million additional doses of the vaccine delivery of an estimated 1 million additional doses of the vaccine to additional doses of the vaccine to New additional doses of the vaccine to New Zealand additional doses of the vaccine to New Zealand during additional doses of the vaccine to New Zealand during July. additional doses of the vaccine to New Zealand during July. These New Zealand during July. These consignments New Zealand during July. These consignments will New Zealand during July. These consignments will double New Zealand during July. These consignments will double the New Zealand during July. These consignments will double the number consignments will double the number of consignments will double the number of Pfizer consignments will double the number of Pfizer doses consignments will double the number of Pfizer doses we consignments will double the number of Pfizer doses we have consignments will double the number of Pfizer doses we have received of Pfizer doses we have received this of Pfizer doses we have received this year, of Pfizer doses we have received this year, to of Pfizer doses we have received this year, to more of Pfizer doses we have received this year, to more than of Pfizer doses we have received this year, to more than 1.9 of Pfizer doses we have received this year, to more than 1.9 million. this year, to more than 1.9 million. While this year, to more than 1.9 million. While we this year, to more than 1.9 million. While we know this year, to more than 1.9 million. While we know the this year, to more than 1.9 million. While we know the ongoing this year, to more than 1.9 million. While we know the ongoing pandemic While we know the ongoing pandemic can While we know the ongoing pandemic can impact While we know the ongoing pandemic can impact on While we know the ongoing pandemic can impact on vaccine While we know the ongoing pandemic can impact on vaccine delivery can impact on vaccine delivery schedules, can impact on vaccine delivery schedules, Pfizer can impact on vaccine delivery schedules, Pfizer has can impact on vaccine delivery schedules, Pfizer has given can impact on vaccine delivery schedules, Pfizer has given us schedules, Pfizer has given us further schedules, Pfizer has given us further assurances schedules, Pfizer has given us further assurances the schedules, Pfizer has given us further assurances the remaining further assurances the remaining deliveries further assurances the remaining deliveries for further assurances the remaining deliveries for 2021 further assurances the remaining deliveries for 2021 are further assurances the remaining deliveries for 2021 are on further assurances the remaining deliveries for 2021 are on track, deliveries for 2021 are on track, just deliveries for 2021 are on track, just as deliveries for 2021 are on track, just as the deliveries for 2021 are on track, just as the deliveries deliveries for 2021 are on track, just as the deliveries right deliveries for 2021 are on track, just as the deliveries right the deliveries for 2021 are on track, just as the deliveries right the way just as the deliveries right the way through just as the deliveries right the way through the just as the deliveries right the way through the year just as the deliveries right the way through the year so just as the deliveries right the way through the year so far just as the deliveries right the way through the year so far have just as the deliveries right the way through the year so far have been. through the year so far have been. Supplementary. through the year so far have been. Supplementary. How through the year so far have been. Supplementary. How will through the year so far have been. Supplementary. How will these Supplementary. How will these additional Supplementary. How will these additional deliveries Supplementary. How will these additional deliveries support Supplementary. How will these additional deliveries support our additional deliveries support our vaccine additional deliveries support our vaccine rollout? additional deliveries support our vaccine rollout? Mr additional deliveries support our vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, additional deliveries support our vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, the vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, the deliveries vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, the deliveries will vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, the deliveries will enable vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, the deliveries will enable us vaccine rollout? Mr Speaker, the deliveries will enable us to deliveries will enable us to continue deliveries will enable us to continue vaccinating deliveries will enable us to continue vaccinating groups deliveries will enable us to continue vaccinating groups 1, deliveries will enable us to continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and 3, continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and 3, while continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and 3, while giving continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and 3, while giving us continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and 3, while giving us the continue vaccinating groups 1, 2, and 3, while giving us the certainty and 3, while giving us the certainty we and 3, while giving us the certainty we need and 3, while giving us the certainty we need to and 3, while giving us the certainty we need to start and 3, while giving us the certainty we need to start the and 3, while giving us the certainty we need to start the general we need to start the general population we need to start the general population rollout we need to start the general population rollout as we need to start the general population rollout as we we need to start the general population rollout as we had population rollout as we had planned. population rollout as we had planned. The population rollout as we had planned. The supply population rollout as we had planned. The supply means population rollout as we had planned. The supply means to population rollout as we had planned. The supply means to DHBs planned. The supply means to DHBs can planned. The supply means to DHBs can continue planned. The supply means to DHBs can continue on planned. The supply means to DHBs can continue on with planned. The supply means to DHBs can continue on with their planned. The supply means to DHBs can continue on with their plans. can continue on with their plans. We're can continue on with their plans. We're administering can continue on with their plans. We're administering 20,000 can continue on with their plans. We're administering 20,000 doses can continue on with their plans. We're administering 20,000 doses a We're administering 20,000 doses a day, We're administering 20,000 doses a day, our We're administering 20,000 doses a day, our highest We're administering 20,000 doses a day, our highest point We're administering 20,000 doses a day, our highest point was We're administering 20,000 doses a day, our highest point was just day, our highest point was just under day, our highest point was just under 23,000 day, our highest point was just under 23,000 doses, day, our highest point was just under 23,000 doses, and day, our highest point was just under 23,000 doses, and the day, our highest point was just under 23,000 doses, and the Pfizer under 23,000 doses, and the Pfizer deliveries under 23,000 doses, and the Pfizer deliveries throughout under 23,000 doses, and the Pfizer deliveries throughout July under 23,000 doses, and the Pfizer deliveries throughout July will deliveries throughout July will enable deliveries throughout July will enable us deliveries throughout July will enable us to deliveries throughout July will enable us to ramp deliveries throughout July will enable us to ramp this deliveries throughout July will enable us to ramp this up enable us to ramp this up significantly. enable us to ramp this up significantly. At enable us to ramp this up significantly. At its enable us to ramp this up significantly. At its peak enable us to ramp this up significantly. At its peak of enable us to ramp this up significantly. At its peak of the significantly. At its peak of the process, significantly. At its peak of the process, in significantly. At its peak of the process, in August significantly. At its peak of the process, in August and significantly. At its peak of the process, in August and September, process, in August and September, it's process, in August and September, it's projected process, in August and September, it's projected we'll process, in August and September, it's projected we'll be it's projected we'll be administering it's projected we'll be administering on it's projected we'll be administering on average it's projected we'll be administering on average up it's projected we'll be administering on average up to administering on average up to 50,000 administering on average up to 50,000 doses administering on average up to 50,000 doses per administering on average up to 50,000 doses per day. administering on average up to 50,000 doses per day. This administering on average up to 50,000 doses per day. This will administering on average up to 50,000 doses per day. This will add 50,000 doses per day. This will add to 50,000 doses per day. This will add to significant 50,000 doses per day. This will add to significant momentum 50,000 doses per day. This will add to significant momentum to 50,000 doses per day. This will add to significant momentum to the to significant momentum to the programme, to significant momentum to the programme, the to significant momentum to the programme, the momentum to significant momentum to the programme, the momentum that's programme, the momentum that's already programme, the momentum that's already being programme, the momentum that's already being generated. already being generated. Supplementary. already being generated. Supplementary. How already being generated. Supplementary. How are already being generated. Supplementary. How are these Supplementary. How are these deliveries Supplementary. How are these deliveries expected Supplementary. How are these deliveries expected to Supplementary. How are these deliveries expected to be deliveries expected to be distributed? deliveries expected to be distributed? Mr deliveries expected to be distributed? Mr Speaker, deliveries expected to be distributed? Mr Speaker, the distributed? Mr Speaker, the COVID-19... distributed? Mr Speaker, the COVID-19... <INTERRUPTION> COVID-19... <INTERRUPTION> Pfizer COVID-19... <INTERRUPTION> Pfizer have COVID-19... <INTERRUPTION> Pfizer have been COVID-19... <INTERRUPTION> Pfizer have been delivering COVID-19... <INTERRUPTION> Pfizer have been delivering us Pfizer have been delivering us weekly Pfizer have been delivering us weekly amounts Pfizer have been delivering us weekly amounts of Pfizer have been delivering us weekly amounts of the Pfizer have been delivering us weekly amounts of the -- Pfizer have been delivering us weekly amounts of the -- vaccine Pfizer have been delivering us weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we expect weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we expect that weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we expect that to weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we expect that to continue. weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we expect that to continue. It weekly amounts of the -- vaccine and we expect that to continue. It gets we expect that to continue. It gets up we expect that to continue. It gets up to we expect that to continue. It gets up to a we expect that to continue. It gets up to a larger we expect that to continue. It gets up to a larger quantity we expect that to continue. It gets up to a larger quantity in we expect that to continue. It gets up to a larger quantity in the up to a larger quantity in the second up to a larger quantity in the second two up to a larger quantity in the second two weeks up to a larger quantity in the second two weeks of up to a larger quantity in the second two weeks of July, up to a larger quantity in the second two weeks of July, that second two weeks of July, that aligns second two weeks of July, that aligns with second two weeks of July, that aligns with our second two weeks of July, that aligns with our work second two weeks of July, that aligns with our work to second two weeks of July, that aligns with our work to ramp second two weeks of July, that aligns with our work to ramp up second two weeks of July, that aligns with our work to ramp up the aligns with our work to ramp up the programme. aligns with our work to ramp up the programme. I'm aligns with our work to ramp up the programme. I'm pleased aligns with our work to ramp up the programme. I'm pleased to aligns with our work to ramp up the programme. I'm pleased to announce programme. I'm pleased to announce the programme. I'm pleased to announce the extra programme. I'm pleased to announce the extra ultra programme. I'm pleased to announce the extra ultra low programme. I'm pleased to announce the extra ultra low storage programme. I'm pleased to announce the extra ultra low storage freezers the extra ultra low storage freezers have the extra ultra low storage freezers have been the extra ultra low storage freezers have been delivered the extra ultra low storage freezers have been delivered and the extra ultra low storage freezers have been delivered and are the extra ultra low storage freezers have been delivered and are now the extra ultra low storage freezers have been delivered and are now in have been delivered and are now in place have been delivered and are now in place in have been delivered and are now in place in Auckland have been delivered and are now in place in Auckland and have been delivered and are now in place in Auckland and Christchurch, place in Auckland and Christchurch, that place in Auckland and Christchurch, that means place in Auckland and Christchurch, that means the place in Auckland and Christchurch, that means the deliveries place in Auckland and Christchurch, that means the deliveries can place in Auckland and Christchurch, that means the deliveries can be that means the deliveries can be delivered that means the deliveries can be delivered directly that means the deliveries can be delivered directly to that means the deliveries can be delivered directly to Christchurch delivered directly to Christchurch now. delivered directly to Christchurch now. Is delivered directly to Christchurch now. Is he delivered directly to Christchurch now. Is he confident delivered directly to Christchurch now. Is he confident we're delivered directly to Christchurch now. Is he confident we're prepared now. Is he confident we're prepared for now. Is he confident we're prepared for the now. Is he confident we're prepared for the national now. Is he confident we're prepared for the national rollout? now. Is he confident we're prepared for the national rollout? Yes, for the national rollout? Yes, District for the national rollout? Yes, District Heath for the national rollout? Yes, District Heath Boards for the national rollout? Yes, District Heath Boards are for the national rollout? Yes, District Heath Boards are currently District Heath Boards are currently performing District Heath Boards are currently performing over District Heath Boards are currently performing over 10% District Heath Boards are currently performing over 10% ahead District Heath Boards are currently performing over 10% ahead of District Heath Boards are currently performing over 10% ahead of their performing over 10% ahead of their delivery performing over 10% ahead of their delivery plans. performing over 10% ahead of their delivery plans. We performing over 10% ahead of their delivery plans. We have performing over 10% ahead of their delivery plans. We have - performing over 10% ahead of their delivery plans. We have - we performing over 10% ahead of their delivery plans. We have - we are delivery plans. We have - we are vaccinating delivery plans. We have - we are vaccinating more delivery plans. We have - we are vaccinating more people delivery plans. We have - we are vaccinating more people each delivery plans. We have - we are vaccinating more people each week, vaccinating more people each week, week vaccinating more people each week, week on vaccinating more people each week, week on week, vaccinating more people each week, week on week, and vaccinating more people each week, week on week, and more vaccinating more people each week, week on week, and more than vaccinating more people each week, week on week, and more than 7,000 week on week, and more than 7,000 vaccinators week on week, and more than 7,000 vaccinators have week on week, and more than 7,000 vaccinators have completed week on week, and more than 7,000 vaccinators have completed the vaccinators have completed the necessary vaccinators have completed the necessary training vaccinators have completed the necessary training to vaccinators have completed the necessary training to administer vaccinators have completed the necessary training to administer the necessary training to administer the vaccine. necessary training to administer the vaccine. It's necessary training to administer the vaccine. It's exciting necessary training to administer the vaccine. It's exciting and vaccine. It's exciting and reassuring vaccine. It's exciting and reassuring to vaccine. It's exciting and reassuring to see vaccine. It's exciting and reassuring to see the vaccine. It's exciting and reassuring to see the programme vaccine. It's exciting and reassuring to see the programme is reassuring to see the programme is continuing reassuring to see the programme is continuing to reassuring to see the programme is continuing to ramp reassuring to see the programme is continuing to ramp up. reassuring to see the programme is continuing to ramp up. We reassuring to see the programme is continuing to ramp up. We have reassuring to see the programme is continuing to ramp up. We have at continuing to ramp up. We have at our continuing to ramp up. We have at our disposal continuing to ramp up. We have at our disposal one continuing to ramp up. We have at our disposal one of continuing to ramp up. We have at our disposal one of the continuing to ramp up. We have at our disposal one of the best our disposal one of the best vaccines our disposal one of the best vaccines on our disposal one of the best vaccines on the our disposal one of the best vaccines on the market our disposal one of the best vaccines on the market and our disposal one of the best vaccines on the market and we're vaccines on the market and we're making vaccines on the market and we're making it vaccines on the market and we're making it available vaccines on the market and we're making it available for vaccines on the market and we're making it available for free vaccines on the market and we're making it available for free to making it available for free to everyone making it available for free to everyone in making it available for free to everyone in New making it available for free to everyone in New Zealand making it available for free to everyone in New Zealand who making it available for free to everyone in New Zealand who is everyone in New Zealand who is eligible, everyone in New Zealand who is eligible, through everyone in New Zealand who is eligible, through the everyone in New Zealand who is eligible, through the course everyone in New Zealand who is eligible, through the course of eligible, through the course of 2021. eligible, through the course of 2021. Why eligible, through the course of 2021. Why are eligible, through the course of 2021. Why are 3800 eligible, through the course of 2021. Why are 3800 border eligible, through the course of 2021. Why are 3800 border workers 2021. Why are 3800 border workers still 2021. Why are 3800 border workers still not 2021. Why are 3800 border workers still not vaccinated 2021. Why are 3800 border workers still not vaccinated when 2021. Why are 3800 border workers still not vaccinated when the still not vaccinated when the COVID-19 still not vaccinated when the COVID-19 website still not vaccinated when the COVID-19 website says still not vaccinated when the COVID-19 website says as still not vaccinated when the COVID-19 website says as members still not vaccinated when the COVID-19 website says as members of COVID-19 website says as members of group COVID-19 website says as members of group 1, COVID-19 website says as members of group 1, they COVID-19 website says as members of group 1, they will COVID-19 website says as members of group 1, they will be COVID-19 website says as members of group 1, they will be vaccinated COVID-19 website says as members of group 1, they will be vaccinated by group 1, they will be vaccinated by the group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end of group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end of March group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end of March 2021? group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end of March 2021? Mr group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, group 1, they will be vaccinated by the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't actually the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't actually accept the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't actually accept that the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't actually accept that is the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't actually accept that is a the end of March 2021? Mr Speaker, I don't actually accept that is a fair don't actually accept that is a fair conclusion don't actually accept that is a fair conclusion to don't actually accept that is a fair conclusion to reach. don't actually accept that is a fair conclusion to reach. There don't actually accept that is a fair conclusion to reach. There are don't actually accept that is a fair conclusion to reach. There are some conclusion to reach. There are some issues conclusion to reach. There are some issues around conclusion to reach. There are some issues around the conclusion to reach. There are some issues around the way conclusion to reach. There are some issues around the way people conclusion to reach. There are some issues around the way people are issues around the way people are coded issues around the way people are coded within issues around the way people are coded within the issues around the way people are coded within the vaccination. issues around the way people are coded within the vaccination. So issues around the way people are coded within the vaccination. So we coded within the vaccination. So we have coded within the vaccination. So we have seen, coded within the vaccination. So we have seen, for coded within the vaccination. So we have seen, for example, coded within the vaccination. So we have seen, for example, some coded within the vaccination. So we have seen, for example, some people have seen, for example, some people in have seen, for example, some people in group have seen, for example, some people in group 1B, have seen, for example, some people in group 1B, categorised have seen, for example, some people in group 1B, categorised as have seen, for example, some people in group 1B, categorised as group have seen, for example, some people in group 1B, categorised as group 3. in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms of in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms of group in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms of group 1A, in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms of group 1A, in in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms of group 1A, in terms in group 1B, categorised as group 3. In terms of group 1A, in terms of In terms of group 1A, in terms of group In terms of group 1A, in terms of group 1A... In terms of group 1A, in terms of group 1A... In terms of group 1A, in terms of group 1A... ..order. In terms of group 1A, in terms of group 1A... ..order. I In terms of group 1A, in terms of group 1A... ..order. I think In terms of group 1A, in terms of group 1A... ..order. I think this group 1A... ..order. I think this is group 1A... ..order. I think this is a group 1A... ..order. I think this is a matter group 1A... ..order. I think this is a matter that group 1A... ..order. I think this is a matter that most group 1A... ..order. I think this is a matter that most members group 1A... ..order. I think this is a matter that most members of group 1A... ..order. I think this is a matter that most members of the is a matter that most members of the House is a matter that most members of the House are is a matter that most members of the House are trying is a matter that most members of the House are trying to is a matter that most members of the House are trying to take is a matter that most members of the House are trying to take seriously. House are trying to take seriously. Having House are trying to take seriously. Having the House are trying to take seriously. Having the minister House are trying to take seriously. Having the minister shouted House are trying to take seriously. Having the minister shouted down House are trying to take seriously. Having the minister shouted down by Having the minister shouted down by two Having the minister shouted down by two of Having the minister shouted down by two of the Having the minister shouted down by two of the - Having the minister shouted down by two of the - well, Having the minister shouted down by two of the - well, one Having the minister shouted down by two of the - well, one of Having the minister shouted down by two of the - well, one of the Having the minister shouted down by two of the - well, one of the more two of the - well, one of the more senior two of the - well, one of the more senior members two of the - well, one of the more senior members and two of the - well, one of the more senior members and the two of the - well, one of the more senior members and the Shadow two of the - well, one of the more senior members and the Shadow Leader senior members and the Shadow Leader of senior members and the Shadow Leader of the senior members and the Shadow Leader of the House senior members and the Shadow Leader of the House doesn't senior members and the Shadow Leader of the House doesn't help senior members and the Shadow Leader of the House doesn't help the senior members and the Shadow Leader of the House doesn't help the House of the House doesn't help the House hear. of the House doesn't help the House hear. In of the House doesn't help the House hear. In terms of the House doesn't help the House hear. In terms of of the House doesn't help the House hear. In terms of group of the House doesn't help the House hear. In terms of group 1A, of the House doesn't help the House hear. In terms of group 1A, which hear. In terms of group 1A, which includes hear. In terms of group 1A, which includes the hear. In terms of group 1A, which includes the MIQ hear. In terms of group 1A, which includes the MIQ workforce hear. In terms of group 1A, which includes the MIQ workforce and includes the MIQ workforce and others includes the MIQ workforce and others at includes the MIQ workforce and others at the includes the MIQ workforce and others at the border, includes the MIQ workforce and others at the border, where others at the border, where individual others at the border, where individual cases others at the border, where individual cases have others at the border, where individual cases have aarrived others at the border, where individual cases have aarrived to individual cases have aarrived to work, individual cases have aarrived to work, at individual cases have aarrived to work, at MIQ, individual cases have aarrived to work, at MIQ, for individual cases have aarrived to work, at MIQ, for example, individual cases have aarrived to work, at MIQ, for example, and individual cases have aarrived to work, at MIQ, for example, and the work, at MIQ, for example, and the border work, at MIQ, for example, and the border worker work, at MIQ, for example, and the border worker testing work, at MIQ, for example, and the border worker testing registration border worker testing registration has border worker testing registration has suggested border worker testing registration has suggested they border worker testing registration has suggested they have border worker testing registration has suggested they have not border worker testing registration has suggested they have not been has suggested they have not been vaccinated, has suggested they have not been vaccinated, when has suggested they have not been vaccinated, when that's has suggested they have not been vaccinated, when that's been vaccinated, when that's been investigated vaccinated, when that's been investigated it's vaccinated, when that's been investigated it's found vaccinated, when that's been investigated it's found they vaccinated, when that's been investigated it's found they have investigated it's found they have been investigated it's found they have been vaccinated, investigated it's found they have been vaccinated, but investigated it's found they have been vaccinated, but there's investigated it's found they have been vaccinated, but there's a investigated it's found they have been vaccinated, but there's a data been vaccinated, but there's a data issue been vaccinated, but there's a data issue in been vaccinated, but there's a data issue in terms been vaccinated, but there's a data issue in terms of been vaccinated, but there's a data issue in terms of the been vaccinated, but there's a data issue in terms of the comparability issue in terms of the comparability between issue in terms of the comparability between data issue in terms of the comparability between data sets. issue in terms of the comparability between data sets. The issue in terms of the comparability between data sets. The area issue in terms of the comparability between data sets. The area where issue in terms of the comparability between data sets. The area where we between data sets. The area where we have between data sets. The area where we have lower between data sets. The area where we have lower than between data sets. The area where we have lower than accepted between data sets. The area where we have lower than accepted rates between data sets. The area where we have lower than accepted rates is between data sets. The area where we have lower than accepted rates is at have lower than accepted rates is at the have lower than accepted rates is at the maritime have lower than accepted rates is at the maritime ports have lower than accepted rates is at the maritime ports and have lower than accepted rates is at the maritime ports and further have lower than accepted rates is at the maritime ports and further work the maritime ports and further work is the maritime ports and further work is being the maritime ports and further work is being done the maritime ports and further work is being done on the maritime ports and further work is being done on that. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Transport: My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does the My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does the Government Transport: Does the Government expect Transport: Does the Government expect to Transport: Does the Government expect to deliver Transport: Does the Government expect to deliver all Transport: Does the Government expect to deliver all the Transport: Does the Government expect to deliver all the transport expect to deliver all the transport projects expect to deliver all the transport projects it expect to deliver all the transport projects it announced expect to deliver all the transport projects it announced in expect to deliver all the transport projects it announced in January projects it announced in January 2020 projects it announced in January 2020 as projects it announced in January 2020 as part projects it announced in January 2020 as part of projects it announced in January 2020 as part of the projects it announced in January 2020 as part of the NZ projects it announced in January 2020 as part of the NZ Upgrade 2020 as part of the NZ Upgrade Programme; 2020 as part of the NZ Upgrade Programme; if 2020 as part of the NZ Upgrade Programme; if not, 2020 as part of the NZ Upgrade Programme; if not, which 2020 as part of the NZ Upgrade Programme; if not, which projects Programme; if not, which projects will Programme; if not, which projects will not Programme; if not, which projects will not go Programme; if not, which projects will not go ahead Programme; if not, which projects will not go ahead as Programme; if not, which projects will not go ahead as originally will not go ahead as originally announced? Mr Mr Speaker. Mr Speaker. As Mr Speaker. As I Mr Speaker. As I announced Mr Speaker. As I announced last Mr Speaker. As I announced last Friday Mr Speaker. As I announced last Friday the Mr Speaker. As I announced last Friday the Government Mr Speaker. As I announced last Friday the Government is Mr Speaker. As I announced last Friday the Government is delivering Friday the Government is delivering New Friday the Government is delivering New Zealand Friday the Government is delivering New Zealand upgrade Friday the Government is delivering New Zealand upgrade programme New Zealand upgrade programme projects New Zealand upgrade programme projects in New Zealand upgrade programme projects in all New Zealand upgrade programme projects in all the New Zealand upgrade programme projects in all the regions New Zealand upgrade programme projects in all the regions first projects in all the regions first announced projects in all the regions first announced in projects in all the regions first announced in January projects in all the regions first announced in January 2020. projects in all the regions first announced in January 2020. All announced in January 2020. All projects announced in January 2020. All projects announced announced in January 2020. All projects announced have announced in January 2020. All projects announced have had announced in January 2020. All projects announced have had some projects announced have had some level projects announced have had some level of projects announced have had some level of change projects announced have had some level of change from projects announced have had some level of change from when projects announced have had some level of change from when they projects announced have had some level of change from when they were level of change from when they were first level of change from when they were first announced, level of change from when they were first announced, for level of change from when they were first announced, for example, level of change from when they were first announced, for example, with first announced, for example, with scope first announced, for example, with scope changes first announced, for example, with scope changes and/or first announced, for example, with scope changes and/or cost first announced, for example, with scope changes and/or cost changes. scope changes and/or cost changes. Point scope changes and/or cost changes. Point of scope changes and/or cost changes. Point of order. scope changes and/or cost changes. Point of order. The scope changes and/or cost changes. Point of order. The Hon scope changes and/or cost changes. Point of order. The Hon Michael Point of order. The Hon Michael Woodhouse. Point of order. The Hon Michael Woodhouse. The Point of order. The Hon Michael Woodhouse. The second Point of order. The Hon Michael Woodhouse. The second part Point of order. The Hon Michael Woodhouse. The second part of Point of order. The Hon Michael Woodhouse. The second part of that Woodhouse. The second part of that question Woodhouse. The second part of that question was Woodhouse. The second part of that question was which Woodhouse. The second part of that question was which projects Woodhouse. The second part of that question was which projects will Woodhouse. The second part of that question was which projects will not question was which projects will not go question was which projects will not go ahead question was which projects will not go ahead as question was which projects will not go ahead as originally question was which projects will not go ahead as originally announced? question was which projects will not go ahead as originally announced? I go ahead as originally announced? I don't go ahead as originally announced? I don't think go ahead as originally announced? I don't think the go ahead as originally announced? I don't think the minister go ahead as originally announced? I don't think the minister had don't think the minister had addressed don't think the minister had addressed that don't think the minister had addressed that question. don't think the minister had addressed that question. Well, don't think the minister had addressed that question. Well, I addressed that question. Well, I think addressed that question. Well, I think he addressed that question. Well, I think he did. addressed that question. Well, I think he did. I addressed that question. Well, I think he did. I think addressed that question. Well, I think he did. I think he addressed that question. Well, I think he did. I think he said addressed that question. Well, I think he did. I think he said all addressed that question. Well, I think he did. I think he said all of think he did. I think he said all of them, think he did. I think he said all of them, didn't think he did. I think he said all of them, didn't he? think he did. I think he said all of them, didn't he? Well think he did. I think he said all of them, didn't he? Well he think he did. I think he said all of them, didn't he? Well he said think he did. I think he said all of them, didn't he? Well he said there them, didn't he? Well he said there were them, didn't he? Well he said there were changes them, didn't he? Well he said there were changes made them, didn't he? Well he said there were changes made to them, didn't he? Well he said there were changes made to all them, didn't he? Well he said there were changes made to all of them, didn't he? Well he said there were changes made to all of them. were changes made to all of them. That's... were changes made to all of them. That's... To were changes made to all of them. That's... To the were changes made to all of them. That's... To the minister, were changes made to all of them. That's... To the minister, what were changes made to all of them. That's... To the minister, what were That's... To the minister, what were the That's... To the minister, what were the characteristics That's... To the minister, what were the characteristics of That's... To the minister, what were the characteristics of the That's... To the minister, what were the characteristics of the Otaki That's... To the minister, what were the characteristics of the Otaki to the characteristics of the Otaki to north the characteristics of the Otaki to north of the characteristics of the Otaki to north of Levin the characteristics of the Otaki to north of Levin projects the characteristics of the Otaki to north of Levin projects that north of Levin projects that justified north of Levin projects that justified it north of Levin projects that justified it continuing, north of Levin projects that justified it continuing, and north of Levin projects that justified it continuing, and will justified it continuing, and will they justified it continuing, and will they present justified it continuing, and will they present in justified it continuing, and will they present in the justified it continuing, and will they present in the bridge justified it continuing, and will they present in the bridge project? they present in the bridge project? All they present in the bridge project? All are they present in the bridge project? All are assessed they present in the bridge project? All are assessed on they present in the bridge project? All are assessed on their they present in the bridge project? All are assessed on their merits, All are assessed on their merits, including All are assessed on their merits, including the All are assessed on their merits, including the issue All are assessed on their merits, including the issue of All are assessed on their merits, including the issue of how All are assessed on their merits, including the issue of how cost including the issue of how cost escalations including the issue of how cost escalations will including the issue of how cost escalations will be including the issue of how cost escalations will be managed. including the issue of how cost escalations will be managed. I including the issue of how cost escalations will be managed. I note escalations will be managed. I note in escalations will be managed. I note in the escalations will be managed. I note in the case escalations will be managed. I note in the case of escalations will be managed. I note in the case of the escalations will be managed. I note in the case of the Mill escalations will be managed. I note in the case of the Mill Road escalations will be managed. I note in the case of the Mill Road project in the case of the Mill Road project the in the case of the Mill Road project the escalation in the case of the Mill Road project the escalation was in the case of the Mill Road project the escalation was in in the case of the Mill Road project the escalation was in the in the case of the Mill Road project the escalation was in the order in the case of the Mill Road project the escalation was in the order of the escalation was in the order of $2.2 the escalation was in the order of $2.2 million, the escalation was in the order of $2.2 million, a the escalation was in the order of $2.2 million, a three the escalation was in the order of $2.2 million, a three times the escalation was in the order of $2.2 million, a three times increase $2.2 million, a three times increase in $2.2 million, a three times increase in the $2.2 million, a three times increase in the Otaki $2.2 million, a three times increase in the Otaki to $2.2 million, a three times increase in the Otaki to Levin $2.2 million, a three times increase in the Otaki to Levin project. in the Otaki to Levin project. Unlike in the Otaki to Levin project. Unlike the in the Otaki to Levin project. Unlike the previous in the Otaki to Levin project. Unlike the previous government, in the Otaki to Levin project. Unlike the previous government, they Unlike the previous government, they kicked Unlike the previous government, they kicked it Unlike the previous government, they kicked it down Unlike the previous government, they kicked it down to Unlike the previous government, they kicked it down to road Unlike the previous government, they kicked it down to road to Unlike the previous government, they kicked it down to road to be Unlike the previous government, they kicked it down to road to be cleaned kicked it down to road to be cleaned up, kicked it down to road to be cleaned up, we kicked it down to road to be cleaned up, we think kicked it down to road to be cleaned up, we think it's kicked it down to road to be cleaned up, we think it's more kicked it down to road to be cleaned up, we think it's more responsible up, we think it's more responsible to up, we think it's more responsible to deal up, we think it's more responsible to deal with up, we think it's more responsible to deal with them up, we think it's more responsible to deal with them at up, we think it's more responsible to deal with them at the up, we think it's more responsible to deal with them at the time. up, we think it's more responsible to deal with them at the time. Were to deal with them at the time. Were electoral to deal with them at the time. Were electoral characteristics to deal with them at the time. Were electoral characteristics one to deal with them at the time. Were electoral characteristics one of electoral characteristics one of those electoral characteristics one of those considerations? electoral characteristics one of those considerations? No. electoral characteristics one of those considerations? No. To electoral characteristics one of those considerations? No. To the those considerations? No. To the minister, those considerations? No. To the minister, does those considerations? No. To the minister, does he those considerations? No. To the minister, does he agree those considerations? No. To the minister, does he agree with those considerations? No. To the minister, does he agree with the minister, does he agree with the Minister minister, does he agree with the Minister of minister, does he agree with the Minister of Finance minister, does he agree with the Minister of Finance who minister, does he agree with the Minister of Finance who said minister, does he agree with the Minister of Finance who said at minister, does he agree with the Minister of Finance who said at the Minister of Finance who said at the launch Minister of Finance who said at the launch of Minister of Finance who said at the launch of the Minister of Finance who said at the launch of the upgrade Minister of Finance who said at the launch of the upgrade programme launch of the upgrade programme quote, launch of the upgrade programme quote, "The launch of the upgrade programme quote, "The big launch of the upgrade programme quote, "The big difference launch of the upgrade programme quote, "The big difference is quote, "The big difference is they're quote, "The big difference is they're funded. quote, "The big difference is they're funded. Every quote, "The big difference is they're funded. Every dollar they're funded. Every dollar required they're funded. Every dollar required for they're funded. Every dollar required for the they're funded. Every dollar required for the projects they're funded. Every dollar required for the projects is they're funded. Every dollar required for the projects is in they're funded. Every dollar required for the projects is in the required for the projects is in the government's required for the projects is in the government's accounts required for the projects is in the government's accounts today." required for the projects is in the government's accounts today." I'm government's accounts today." I'm very government's accounts today." I'm very pleased government's accounts today." I'm very pleased to government's accounts today." I'm very pleased to confirm government's accounts today." I'm very pleased to confirm as government's accounts today." I'm very pleased to confirm as a government's accounts today." I'm very pleased to confirm as a result very pleased to confirm as a result of very pleased to confirm as a result of the very pleased to confirm as a result of the decisions very pleased to confirm as a result of the decisions we very pleased to confirm as a result of the decisions we took very pleased to confirm as a result of the decisions we took on very pleased to confirm as a result of the decisions we took on Friday, of the decisions we took on Friday, every of the decisions we took on Friday, every single of the decisions we took on Friday, every single project of the decisions we took on Friday, every single project of of the decisions we took on Friday, every single project of the of the decisions we took on Friday, every single project of the New every single project of the New Zealand every single project of the New Zealand upgrade every single project of the New Zealand upgrade programme every single project of the New Zealand upgrade programme is every single project of the New Zealand upgrade programme is funded Zealand upgrade programme is funded according Zealand upgrade programme is funded according to Zealand upgrade programme is funded according to the Zealand upgrade programme is funded according to the advice Zealand upgrade programme is funded according to the advice we Zealand upgrade programme is funded according to the advice we have according to the advice we have received according to the advice we have received from according to the advice we have received from Waka according to the advice we have received from Waka Kotahi according to the advice we have received from Waka Kotahi and received from Waka Kotahi and KiwiRail. received from Waka Kotahi and KiwiRail. Given received from Waka Kotahi and KiwiRail. Given that received from Waka Kotahi and KiwiRail. Given that answer, received from Waka Kotahi and KiwiRail. Given that answer, will KiwiRail. Given that answer, will the KiwiRail. Given that answer, will the projects KiwiRail. Given that answer, will the projects go KiwiRail. Given that answer, will the projects go ahead KiwiRail. Given that answer, will the projects go ahead as KiwiRail. Given that answer, will the projects go ahead as announced? the projects go ahead as announced? Yes, the projects go ahead as announced? Yes, Mr the projects go ahead as announced? Yes, Mr Speaker. the projects go ahead as announced? Yes, Mr Speaker. That's the projects go ahead as announced? Yes, Mr Speaker. That's the Yes, Mr Speaker. That's the intention Yes, Mr Speaker. That's the intention of Yes, Mr Speaker. That's the intention of the Yes, Mr Speaker. That's the intention of the Government. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Police: My question is to the Minister of Police: What My question is to the Minister of Police: What recent My question is to the Minister of Police: What recent reports My question is to the Minister of Police: What recent reports has My question is to the Minister of Police: What recent reports has she Police: What recent reports has she seen Police: What recent reports has she seen regarding Police: What recent reports has she seen regarding Police's Police: What recent reports has she seen regarding Police's efforts Police: What recent reports has she seen regarding Police's efforts to seen regarding Police's efforts to disrupt seen regarding Police's efforts to disrupt organised seen regarding Police's efforts to disrupt organised crime? I've I've seen I've seen reports I've seen reports that I've seen reports that police I've seen reports that police have I've seen reports that police have concluded I've seen reports that police have concluded a I've seen reports that police have concluded a number I've seen reports that police have concluded a number of I've seen reports that police have concluded a number of operations I've seen reports that police have concluded a number of operations to concluded a number of operations to disrupt concluded a number of operations to disrupt transnational concluded a number of operations to disrupt transnational organised disrupt transnational organised crime, disrupt transnational organised crime, as disrupt transnational organised crime, as part disrupt transnational organised crime, as part of disrupt transnational organised crime, as part of Operation disrupt transnational organised crime, as part of Operation Trojan crime, as part of Operation Trojan Shield crime, as part of Operation Trojan Shield and crime, as part of Operation Trojan Shield and Operation crime, as part of Operation Trojan Shield and Operation Spyglass. crime, as part of Operation Trojan Shield and Operation Spyglass. It Shield and Operation Spyglass. It has Shield and Operation Spyglass. It has seen Shield and Operation Spyglass. It has seen a Shield and Operation Spyglass. It has seen a worldwide Shield and Operation Spyglass. It has seen a worldwide crackdown Shield and Operation Spyglass. It has seen a worldwide crackdown on has seen a worldwide crackdown on organised has seen a worldwide crackdown on organised crime. has seen a worldwide crackdown on organised crime. Mr has seen a worldwide crackdown on organised crime. Mr Speaker, has seen a worldwide crackdown on organised crime. Mr Speaker, I has seen a worldwide crackdown on organised crime. Mr Speaker, I want organised crime. Mr Speaker, I want to organised crime. Mr Speaker, I want to take organised crime. Mr Speaker, I want to take this organised crime. Mr Speaker, I want to take this opportunity organised crime. Mr Speaker, I want to take this opportunity to to take this opportunity to congratulate to take this opportunity to congratulate the to take this opportunity to congratulate the police to take this opportunity to congratulate the police for to take this opportunity to congratulate the police for their congratulate the police for their role congratulate the police for their role in congratulate the police for their role in Operation congratulate the police for their role in Operation Trojan congratulate the police for their role in Operation Trojan Shield congratulate the police for their role in Operation Trojan Shield and role in Operation Trojan Shield and in role in Operation Trojan Shield and in keeping role in Operation Trojan Shield and in keeping our role in Operation Trojan Shield and in keeping our communities role in Operation Trojan Shield and in keeping our communities safe. role in Operation Trojan Shield and in keeping our communities safe. How in keeping our communities safe. How has in keeping our communities safe. How has Operation in keeping our communities safe. How has Operation Trojan in keeping our communities safe. How has Operation Trojan Shield has Operation Trojan Shield disrupted has Operation Trojan Shield disrupted organised has Operation Trojan Shield disrupted organised crime has Operation Trojan Shield disrupted organised crime locally? disrupted organised crime locally? Mr disrupted organised crime locally? Mr Speaker, disrupted organised crime locally? Mr Speaker, more disrupted organised crime locally? Mr Speaker, more than disrupted organised crime locally? Mr Speaker, more than 300 disrupted organised crime locally? Mr Speaker, more than 300 officers Mr Speaker, more than 300 officers executed Mr Speaker, more than 300 officers executed 37 Mr Speaker, more than 300 officers executed 37 search Mr Speaker, more than 300 officers executed 37 search warrants Mr Speaker, more than 300 officers executed 37 search warrants across executed 37 search warrants across the executed 37 search warrants across the north executed 37 search warrants across the north island, executed 37 search warrants across the north island, with executed 37 search warrants across the north island, with illegal the north island, with illegal firearms, the north island, with illegal firearms, methamphetamine, the north island, with illegal firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, and firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, and more firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, and more than firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, and more than an firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, and more than an estimated firearms, methamphetamine, cannabis, and more than an estimated $1 and more than an estimated $1 million and more than an estimated $1 million in and more than an estimated $1 million in cash and more than an estimated $1 million in cash has and more than an estimated $1 million in cash has also and more than an estimated $1 million in cash has also been million in cash has also been recovered. million in cash has also been recovered. Police million in cash has also been recovered. Police have million in cash has also been recovered. Police have also million in cash has also been recovered. Police have also arrested recovered. Police have also arrested 35 recovered. Police have also arrested 35 individuals recovered. Police have also arrested 35 individuals and recovered. Police have also arrested 35 individuals and laid recovered. Police have also arrested 35 individuals and laid over recovered. Police have also arrested 35 individuals and laid over 900 35 individuals and laid over 900 charges. 35 individuals and laid over 900 charges. How 35 individuals and laid over 900 charges. How is 35 individuals and laid over 900 charges. How is the 35 individuals and laid over 900 charges. How is the Government's charges. How is the Government's supporting charges. How is the Government's supporting police charges. How is the Government's supporting police in charges. How is the Government's supporting police in their charges. How is the Government's supporting police in their efforts supporting police in their efforts to supporting police in their efforts to disrupt supporting police in their efforts to disrupt organised supporting police in their efforts to disrupt organised crime? supporting police in their efforts to disrupt organised crime? Mr to disrupt organised crime? Mr Speaker, to disrupt organised crime? Mr Speaker, this to disrupt organised crime? Mr Speaker, this Government to disrupt organised crime? Mr Speaker, this Government has to disrupt organised crime? Mr Speaker, this Government has made to disrupt organised crime? Mr Speaker, this Government has made it Speaker, this Government has made it very Speaker, this Government has made it very clear Speaker, this Government has made it very clear we Speaker, this Government has made it very clear we will Speaker, this Government has made it very clear we will not Speaker, this Government has made it very clear we will not tolerate very clear we will not tolerate organised very clear we will not tolerate organised crime very clear we will not tolerate organised crime and very clear we will not tolerate organised crime and gangs. very clear we will not tolerate organised crime and gangs. Last organised crime and gangs. Last month, organised crime and gangs. Last month, we organised crime and gangs. Last month, we announced organised crime and gangs. Last month, we announced our organised crime and gangs. Last month, we announced our intention organised crime and gangs. Last month, we announced our intention to month, we announced our intention to amend month, we announced our intention to amend the month, we announced our intention to amend the proceeds month, we announced our intention to amend the proceeds of month, we announced our intention to amend the proceeds of crime amend the proceeds of crime legislation, amend the proceeds of crime legislation, to amend the proceeds of crime legislation, to ensure amend the proceeds of crime legislation, to ensure those legislation, to ensure those involved legislation, to ensure those involved in legislation, to ensure those involved in organised legislation, to ensure those involved in organised crime legislation, to ensure those involved in organised crime will involved in organised crime will have involved in organised crime will have to involved in organised crime will have to demonstrate involved in organised crime will have to demonstrate their involved in organised crime will have to demonstrate their assets have to demonstrate their assets were have to demonstrate their assets were obtained have to demonstrate their assets were obtained through have to demonstrate their assets were obtained through legitimate were obtained through legitimate means. were obtained through legitimate means. If were obtained through legitimate means. If they were obtained through legitimate means. If they can't, were obtained through legitimate means. If they can't, their were obtained through legitimate means. If they can't, their assets means. If they can't, their assets will means. If they can't, their assets will be means. If they can't, their assets will be seized. means. If they can't, their assets will be seized. This means. If they can't, their assets will be seized. This Government means. If they can't, their assets will be seized. This Government has will be seized. This Government has put will be seized. This Government has put on will be seized. This Government has put on record will be seized. This Government has put on record a will be seized. This Government has put on record a number will be seized. This Government has put on record a number of will be seized. This Government has put on record a number of police will be seized. This Government has put on record a number of police on put on record a number of police on the put on record a number of police on the front-line put on record a number of police on the front-line has put on record a number of police on the front-line has a put on record a number of police on the front-line has a specific put on record a number of police on the front-line has a specific focus the front-line has a specific focus on the front-line has a specific focus on organised the front-line has a specific focus on organised crime. the front-line has a specific focus on organised crime. This on organised crime. This Government's on organised crime. This Government's record on organised crime. This Government's record investment on organised crime. This Government's record investment in Government's record investment in police Government's record investment in police will Government's record investment in police will include Government's record investment in police will include 700 Government's record investment in police will include 700 additional police will include 700 additional investigators. police will include 700 additional investigators. It police will include 700 additional investigators. It highlights police will include 700 additional investigators. It highlights the investigators. It highlights the excellent investigators. It highlights the excellent impact investigators. It highlights the excellent impact these investigators. It highlights the excellent impact these officers investigators. It highlights the excellent impact these officers can excellent impact these officers can have. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all her Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's statements Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's statements and Minister: Does she stand by all her Government's statements and actions? Mr Mr Speaker, Mr Speaker, yes. Mr Speaker, yes. In Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, our Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, our targeted Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, our targeted support Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, our targeted support in Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, our targeted support in this Mr Speaker, yes. In particular, our targeted support in this year's targeted support in this year's budget targeted support in this year's budget to targeted support in this year's budget to support targeted support in this year's budget to support Maori targeted support in this year's budget to support Maori in targeted support in this year's budget to support Maori in areas budget to support Maori in areas like budget to support Maori in areas like housing, budget to support Maori in areas like housing, health, budget to support Maori in areas like housing, health, education, like housing, health, education, tamariki, like housing, health, education, tamariki, whanau, like housing, health, education, tamariki, whanau, and like housing, health, education, tamariki, whanau, and justice tamariki, whanau, and justice reform. tamariki, whanau, and justice reform. It tamariki, whanau, and justice reform. It invests tamariki, whanau, and justice reform. It invests in tamariki, whanau, and justice reform. It invests in areas tamariki, whanau, and justice reform. It invests in areas right reform. It invests in areas right across reform. It invests in areas right across our reform. It invests in areas right across our economic reform. It invests in areas right across our economic recovery. reform. It invests in areas right across our economic recovery. Key across our economic recovery. Key initiatives across our economic recovery. Key initiatives include across our economic recovery. Key initiatives include Maori across our economic recovery. Key initiatives include Maori housing, initiatives include Maori housing, Maori initiatives include Maori housing, Maori health initiatives include Maori housing, Maori health initiatives, initiatives include Maori housing, Maori health initiatives, the Maori health initiatives, the settling Maori health initiatives, the settling up Maori health initiatives, the settling up of Maori health initiatives, the settling up of the Maori health initiatives, the settling up of the Maori Maori health initiatives, the settling up of the Maori health settling up of the Maori health authority, settling up of the Maori health authority, Maori settling up of the Maori health authority, Maori education settling up of the Maori health authority, Maori education and settling up of the Maori health authority, Maori education and in authority, Maori education and in particular authority, Maori education and in particular support authority, Maori education and in particular support for authority, Maori education and in particular support for Maori particular support for Maori boarding particular support for Maori boarding schools particular support for Maori boarding schools and particular support for Maori boarding schools and to particular support for Maori boarding schools and to lift boarding schools and to lift teachers' boarding schools and to lift teachers' pay. boarding schools and to lift teachers' pay. $42 boarding schools and to lift teachers' pay. $42 million boarding schools and to lift teachers' pay. $42 million to boarding schools and to lift teachers' pay. $42 million to build teachers' pay. $42 million to build a teachers' pay. $42 million to build a Maori teachers' pay. $42 million to build a Maori media teachers' pay. $42 million to build a Maori media sector teachers' pay. $42 million to build a Maori media sector and teachers' pay. $42 million to build a Maori media sector and invest teachers' pay. $42 million to build a Maori media sector and invest in a Maori media sector and invest in programme a Maori media sector and invest in programme content, a Maori media sector and invest in programme content, funding a Maori media sector and invest in programme content, funding for a Maori media sector and invest in programme content, funding for Maori programme content, funding for Maori tourism, programme content, funding for Maori tourism, and programme content, funding for Maori tourism, and the programme content, funding for Maori tourism, and the implementation programme content, funding for Maori tourism, and the implementation of tourism, and the implementation of the tourism, and the implementation of the Maori tourism, and the implementation of the Maori language tourism, and the implementation of the Maori language strategy. tourism, and the implementation of the Maori language strategy. It tourism, and the implementation of the Maori language strategy. It help the Maori language strategy. It help our the Maori language strategy. It help our economic the Maori language strategy. It help our economic recovery the Maori language strategy. It help our economic recovery and the Maori language strategy. It help our economic recovery and support our economic recovery and support Maori. our economic recovery and support Maori. Does our economic recovery and support Maori. Does she our economic recovery and support Maori. Does she stand our economic recovery and support Maori. Does she stand by our economic recovery and support Maori. Does she stand by her Maori. Does she stand by her international Maori. Does she stand by her international commitments Maori. Does she stand by her international commitments as Maori. Does she stand by her international commitments as part Maori. Does she stand by her international commitments as part of international commitments as part of the international commitments as part of the Christchurch international commitments as part of the Christchurch call international commitments as part of the Christchurch call to international commitments as part of the Christchurch call to protect the Christchurch call to protect citizens the Christchurch call to protect citizens from the Christchurch call to protect citizens from online the Christchurch call to protect citizens from online hate the Christchurch call to protect citizens from online hate speech the Christchurch call to protect citizens from online hate speech and citizens from online hate speech and violent citizens from online hate speech and violent threats, citizens from online hate speech and violent threats, does citizens from online hate speech and violent threats, does it citizens from online hate speech and violent threats, does it include violent threats, does it include protection violent threats, does it include protection of violent threats, does it include protection of tangata violent threats, does it include protection of tangata whenua? violent threats, does it include protection of tangata whenua? Yes, protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you will protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you will see protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you will see from protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you will see from the protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you will see from the work protection of tangata whenua? Yes, you will see from the work programme you will see from the work programme off you will see from the work programme off the you will see from the work programme off the back you will see from the work programme off the back of you will see from the work programme off the back of particularly you will see from the work programme off the back of particularly the off the back of particularly the royal off the back of particularly the royal commission, off the back of particularly the royal commission, so off the back of particularly the royal commission, so in off the back of particularly the royal commission, so in tandem off the back of particularly the royal commission, so in tandem with royal commission, so in tandem with the royal commission, so in tandem with the work royal commission, so in tandem with the work on royal commission, so in tandem with the work on the royal commission, so in tandem with the work on the Christchurch royal commission, so in tandem with the work on the Christchurch call, the work on the Christchurch call, but the work on the Christchurch call, but on the work on the Christchurch call, but on the the work on the Christchurch call, but on the royal the work on the Christchurch call, but on the royal commission, the work on the Christchurch call, but on the royal commission, a but on the royal commission, a really but on the royal commission, a really strong but on the royal commission, a really strong theme but on the royal commission, a really strong theme coming but on the royal commission, a really strong theme coming through really strong theme coming through their really strong theme coming through their that really strong theme coming through their that we really strong theme coming through their that we need really strong theme coming through their that we need to really strong theme coming through their that we need to involve their that we need to involve conversation their that we need to involve conversation and their that we need to involve conversation and dialogue, their that we need to involve conversation and dialogue, through conversation and dialogue, through the conversation and dialogue, through the reform conversation and dialogue, through the reform process, conversation and dialogue, through the reform process, with conversation and dialogue, through the reform process, with all the reform process, with all communities, the reform process, with all communities, but the reform process, with all communities, but particularly communities, but particularly tangata communities, but particularly tangata whenua communities, but particularly tangata whenua as communities, but particularly tangata whenua as well. communities, but particularly tangata whenua as well. That's communities, but particularly tangata whenua as well. That's a communities, but particularly tangata whenua as well. That's a big tangata whenua as well. That's a big part tangata whenua as well. That's a big part of tangata whenua as well. That's a big part of our tangata whenua as well. That's a big part of our response tangata whenua as well. That's a big part of our response to tangata whenua as well. That's a big part of our response to the tangata whenua as well. That's a big part of our response to the royal part of our response to the royal commission's part of our response to the royal commission's report. part of our response to the royal commission's report. Supplementary. commission's report. Supplementary. Has commission's report. Supplementary. Has she commission's report. Supplementary. Has she received commission's report. Supplementary. Has she received any commission's report. Supplementary. Has she received any reports commission's report. Supplementary. Has she received any reports from Has she received any reports from the Has she received any reports from the police Has she received any reports from the police or Has she received any reports from the police or the Has she received any reports from the police or the intelligence the police or the intelligence agencies the police or the intelligence agencies that the police or the intelligence agencies that demonstrate the police or the intelligence agencies that demonstrate the the police or the intelligence agencies that demonstrate the rising agencies that demonstrate the rising volume agencies that demonstrate the rising volume of agencies that demonstrate the rising volume of white agencies that demonstrate the rising volume of white supremacist agencies that demonstrate the rising volume of white supremacist hate agencies that demonstrate the rising volume of white supremacist hate and volume of white supremacist hate and violence volume of white supremacist hate and violence against volume of white supremacist hate and violence against tangata volume of white supremacist hate and violence against tangata whenua, volume of white supremacist hate and violence against tangata whenua, as violence against tangata whenua, as expressed violence against tangata whenua, as expressed by violence against tangata whenua, as expressed by a violence against tangata whenua, as expressed by a masked violence against tangata whenua, as expressed by a masked white expressed by a masked white supremacist expressed by a masked white supremacist who expressed by a masked white supremacist who threatened expressed by a masked white supremacist who threatened to supremacist who threatened to slaughter supremacist who threatened to slaughter tens supremacist who threatened to slaughter tens of supremacist who threatened to slaughter tens of thousands supremacist who threatened to slaughter tens of thousands of supremacist who threatened to slaughter tens of thousands of Maori slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and burn slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and burn down slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and burn down our slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and burn down our marae? slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and burn down our marae? While slaughter tens of thousands of Maori and burn down our marae? While we and burn down our marae? While we don't and burn down our marae? While we don't tend and burn down our marae? While we don't tend to and burn down our marae? While we don't tend to comment and burn down our marae? While we don't tend to comment on and burn down our marae? While we don't tend to comment on the don't tend to comment on the specifics don't tend to comment on the specifics of don't tend to comment on the specifics of intelligence don't tend to comment on the specifics of intelligence reporting, specifics of intelligence reporting, it specifics of intelligence reporting, it is specifics of intelligence reporting, it is - specifics of intelligence reporting, it is - really specifics of intelligence reporting, it is - really be specifics of intelligence reporting, it is - really be obvious specifics of intelligence reporting, it is - really be obvious to it is - really be obvious to everyone it is - really be obvious to everyone in it is - really be obvious to everyone in this it is - really be obvious to everyone in this House it is - really be obvious to everyone in this House we it is - really be obvious to everyone in this House we have it is - really be obvious to everyone in this House we have seen everyone in this House we have seen extremist everyone in this House we have seen extremist groups, everyone in this House we have seen extremist groups, those everyone in this House we have seen extremist groups, those who everyone in this House we have seen extremist groups, those who hold extremist groups, those who hold extremist extremist groups, those who hold extremist ideology, extremist groups, those who hold extremist ideology, those extremist groups, those who hold extremist ideology, those who extremist groups, those who hold extremist ideology, those who hold extremist ideology, those who hold racist extremist ideology, those who hold racist ideology, extremist ideology, those who hold racist ideology, are extremist ideology, those who hold racist ideology, are certainly extremist ideology, those who hold racist ideology, are certainly in racist ideology, are certainly in existence racist ideology, are certainly in existence in racist ideology, are certainly in existence in Aotearoa racist ideology, are certainly in existence in Aotearoa New racist ideology, are certainly in existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to make existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to make sure existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to make sure we existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to make sure we work existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to make sure we work in existence in Aotearoa New Zealand. Our job is to make sure we work in a Our job is to make sure we work in a preventative Our job is to make sure we work in a preventative fashion Our job is to make sure we work in a preventative fashion to Our job is to make sure we work in a preventative fashion to try Our job is to make sure we work in a preventative fashion to try to preventative fashion to try to protect preventative fashion to try to protect people preventative fashion to try to protect people from preventative fashion to try to protect people from that preventative fashion to try to protect people from that ideology protect people from that ideology and protect people from that ideology and we protect people from that ideology and we respond protect people from that ideology and we respond where protect people from that ideology and we respond where we protect people from that ideology and we respond where we see protect people from that ideology and we respond where we see it protect people from that ideology and we respond where we see it using and we respond where we see it using the and we respond where we see it using the full and we respond where we see it using the full force and we respond where we see it using the full force of and we respond where we see it using the full force of the and we respond where we see it using the full force of the criminal the full force of the criminal justice the full force of the criminal justice system. the full force of the criminal justice system. It's the full force of the criminal justice system. It's up the full force of the criminal justice system. It's up to the full force of the criminal justice system. It's up to our justice system. It's up to our police justice system. It's up to our police to justice system. It's up to our police to make justice system. It's up to our police to make sure justice system. It's up to our police to make sure they justice system. It's up to our police to make sure they are justice system. It's up to our police to make sure they are doing police to make sure they are doing that. police to make sure they are doing that. They police to make sure they are doing that. They have police to make sure they are doing that. They have operational that. They have operational independence. that. They have operational independence. I that. They have operational independence. I understand that. They have operational independence. I understand the independence. I understand the minister independence. I understand the minister has independence. I understand the minister has sought independence. I understand the minister has sought to independence. I understand the minister has sought to meet independence. I understand the minister has sought to meet both minister has sought to meet both with minister has sought to meet both with the minister has sought to meet both with the commissioner minister has sought to meet both with the commissioner of minister has sought to meet both with the commissioner of police with the commissioner of police around with the commissioner of police around those with the commissioner of police around those issues with the commissioner of police around those issues and with the commissioner of police around those issues and has with the commissioner of police around those issues and has met with the commissioner of police around those issues and has met with around those issues and has met with the around those issues and has met with the minister around those issues and has met with the minister for around those issues and has met with the minister for responsibility around those issues and has met with the minister for responsibility for the minister for responsibility for our the minister for responsibility for our intelligence the minister for responsibility for our intelligence agencies. the minister for responsibility for our intelligence agencies. I the minister for responsibility for our intelligence agencies. I hope the minister for responsibility for our intelligence agencies. I hope he our intelligence agencies. I hope he received our intelligence agencies. I hope he received a our intelligence agencies. I hope he received a receptive our intelligence agencies. I hope he received a receptive audience our intelligence agencies. I hope he received a receptive audience to received a receptive audience to addressing received a receptive audience to addressing the received a receptive audience to addressing the challenges received a receptive audience to addressing the challenges the received a receptive audience to addressing the challenges the member addressing the challenges the member has addressing the challenges the member has raised. addressing the challenges the member has raised. Point addressing the challenges the member has raised. Point of addressing the challenges the member has raised. Point of order. addressing the challenges the member has raised. Point of order. A addressing the challenges the member has raised. Point of order. A point has raised. Point of order. A point of has raised. Point of order. A point of order. has raised. Point of order. A point of order. Just has raised. Point of order. A point of order. Just for has raised. Point of order. A point of order. Just for clarity has raised. Point of order. A point of order. Just for clarity of has raised. Point of order. A point of order. Just for clarity of the of order. Just for clarity of the House, of order. Just for clarity of the House, the of order. Just for clarity of the House, the Commissioner of order. Just for clarity of the House, the Commissioner didn't of order. Just for clarity of the House, the Commissioner didn't turn House, the Commissioner didn't turn up House, the Commissioner didn't turn up today. House, the Commissioner didn't turn up today. Supplementary. House, the Commissioner didn't turn up today. Supplementary. Are House, the Commissioner didn't turn up today. Supplementary. Are core up today. Supplementary. Are core policies up today. Supplementary. Are core policies sufficient up today. Supplementary. Are core policies sufficient when up today. Supplementary. Are core policies sufficient when a up today. Supplementary. Are core policies sufficient when a video policies sufficient when a video that policies sufficient when a video that threatened policies sufficient when a video that threatened genocide policies sufficient when a video that threatened genocide on policies sufficient when a video that threatened genocide on tangata that threatened genocide on tangata whenua that threatened genocide on tangata whenua was that threatened genocide on tangata whenua was online that threatened genocide on tangata whenua was online for that threatened genocide on tangata whenua was online for longer that threatened genocide on tangata whenua was online for longer than that threatened genocide on tangata whenua was online for longer than 24 whenua was online for longer than 24 hours. whenua was online for longer than 24 hours. Two whenua was online for longer than 24 hours. Two responses whenua was online for longer than 24 hours. Two responses to whenua was online for longer than 24 hours. Two responses to that. whenua was online for longer than 24 hours. Two responses to that. Of hours. Two responses to that. Of course, hours. Two responses to that. Of course, for hours. Two responses to that. Of course, for an hours. Two responses to that. Of course, for an incident hours. Two responses to that. Of course, for an incident that hours. Two responses to that. Of course, for an incident that occurs course, for an incident that occurs we course, for an incident that occurs we expect course, for an incident that occurs we expect that course, for an incident that occurs we expect that when course, for an incident that occurs we expect that when that course, for an incident that occurs we expect that when that is course, for an incident that occurs we expect that when that is raised we expect that when that is raised that we expect that when that is raised that is we expect that when that is raised that is dealt we expect that when that is raised that is dealt with we expect that when that is raised that is dealt with by we expect that when that is raised that is dealt with by the we expect that when that is raised that is dealt with by the NZ we expect that when that is raised that is dealt with by the NZ Police that is dealt with by the NZ Police according that is dealt with by the NZ Police according to that is dealt with by the NZ Police according to the that is dealt with by the NZ Police according to the law. that is dealt with by the NZ Police according to the law. I that is dealt with by the NZ Police according to the law. I understand according to the law. I understand an according to the law. I understand an arrest according to the law. I understand an arrest may according to the law. I understand an arrest may have according to the law. I understand an arrest may have been according to the law. I understand an arrest may have been made according to the law. I understand an arrest may have been made in according to the law. I understand an arrest may have been made in the an arrest may have been made in the particular an arrest may have been made in the particular case an arrest may have been made in the particular case that an arrest may have been made in the particular case that has an arrest may have been made in the particular case that has been particular case that has been raised. particular case that has been raised. When particular case that has been raised. When it particular case that has been raised. When it comes particular case that has been raised. When it comes to particular case that has been raised. When it comes to the particular case that has been raised. When it comes to the issue raised. When it comes to the issue of raised. When it comes to the issue of the raised. When it comes to the issue of the removal raised. When it comes to the issue of the removal of raised. When it comes to the issue of the removal of content raised. When it comes to the issue of the removal of content that raised. When it comes to the issue of the removal of content that is of the removal of content that is considered of the removal of content that is considered to of the removal of content that is considered to be of the removal of content that is considered to be offensive of the removal of content that is considered to be offensive or considered to be offensive or objectionable, considered to be offensive or objectionable, we considered to be offensive or objectionable, we are considered to be offensive or objectionable, we are doing considered to be offensive or objectionable, we are doing work considered to be offensive or objectionable, we are doing work to objectionable, we are doing work to ensure objectionable, we are doing work to ensure we objectionable, we are doing work to ensure we have objectionable, we are doing work to ensure we have consistency objectionable, we are doing work to ensure we have consistency in objectionable, we are doing work to ensure we have consistency in the ensure we have consistency in the way ensure we have consistency in the way that ensure we have consistency in the way that we ensure we have consistency in the way that we treat ensure we have consistency in the way that we treat material ensure we have consistency in the way that we treat material whether way that we treat material whether it way that we treat material whether it is way that we treat material whether it is on way that we treat material whether it is on and way that we treat material whether it is on and online way that we treat material whether it is on and online platform, way that we treat material whether it is on and online platform, social it is on and online platform, social media it is on and online platform, social media content it is on and online platform, social media content or it is on and online platform, social media content or through it is on and online platform, social media content or through some it is on and online platform, social media content or through some of it is on and online platform, social media content or through some of our media content or through some of our usual media content or through some of our usual mainstream media content or through some of our usual mainstream ways media content or through some of our usual mainstream ways we media content or through some of our usual mainstream ways we have usual mainstream ways we have accessed usual mainstream ways we have accessed content usual mainstream ways we have accessed content in usual mainstream ways we have accessed content in the usual mainstream ways we have accessed content in the past usual mainstream ways we have accessed content in the past through accessed content in the past through broadcasting. accessed content in the past through broadcasting. We accessed content in the past through broadcasting. We know accessed content in the past through broadcasting. We know there accessed content in the past through broadcasting. We know there is accessed content in the past through broadcasting. We know there is more broadcasting. We know there is more work broadcasting. We know there is more work we broadcasting. We know there is more work we need broadcasting. We know there is more work we need too broadcasting. We know there is more work we need too do broadcasting. We know there is more work we need too do there broadcasting. We know there is more work we need too do there and work we need too do there and equally work we need too do there and equally we work we need too do there and equally we are work we need too do there and equally we are trying work we need too do there and equally we are trying to work we need too do there and equally we are trying to lead work we need too do there and equally we are trying to lead the equally we are trying to lead the charge equally we are trying to lead the charge internationally equally we are trying to lead the charge internationally on equally we are trying to lead the charge internationally on making charge internationally on making sure charge internationally on making sure there charge internationally on making sure there is charge internationally on making sure there is a charge internationally on making sure there is a consistent charge internationally on making sure there is a consistent approach sure there is a consistent approach to sure there is a consistent approach to takedown sure there is a consistent approach to takedown through sure there is a consistent approach to takedown through social sure there is a consistent approach to takedown through social need sure there is a consistent approach to takedown through social need what to takedown through social need what platforms to takedown through social need what platforms too. to takedown through social need what platforms too. I to takedown through social need what platforms too. I understand to takedown through social need what platforms too. I understand the platforms too. I understand the Commissioner platforms too. I understand the Commissioner has platforms too. I understand the Commissioner has made platforms too. I understand the Commissioner has made a platforms too. I understand the Commissioner has made a commitment Commissioner has made a commitment to Commissioner has made a commitment to reschedule Commissioner has made a commitment to reschedule with Commissioner has made a commitment to reschedule with the Commissioner has made a commitment to reschedule with the Maori Commissioner has made a commitment to reschedule with the Maori Party to reschedule with the Maori Party on to reschedule with the Maori Party on the to reschedule with the Maori Party on the basis to reschedule with the Maori Party on the basis of to reschedule with the Maori Party on the basis of the to reschedule with the Maori Party on the basis of the unavailability on the basis of the unavailability of on the basis of the unavailability of meeting on the basis of the unavailability of meeting today. on the basis of the unavailability of meeting today. Will on the basis of the unavailability of meeting today. Will she on the basis of the unavailability of meeting today. Will she support of meeting today. Will she support the of meeting today. Will she support the establishment of meeting today. Will she support the establishment of of meeting today. Will she support the establishment of a of meeting today. Will she support the establishment of a joint the establishment of a joint COVID-19 the establishment of a joint COVID-19 task the establishment of a joint COVID-19 task force the establishment of a joint COVID-19 task force that the establishment of a joint COVID-19 task force that includes COVID-19 task force that includes the COVID-19 task force that includes the NZSIS COVID-19 task force that includes the NZSIS and COVID-19 task force that includes the NZSIS and NZ COVID-19 task force that includes the NZSIS and NZ Police COVID-19 task force that includes the NZSIS and NZ Police that COVID-19 task force that includes the NZSIS and NZ Police that is the NZSIS and NZ Police that is focused the NZSIS and NZ Police that is focused on the NZSIS and NZ Police that is focused on protecting the NZSIS and NZ Police that is focused on protecting tangata the NZSIS and NZ Police that is focused on protecting tangata whenua focused on protecting tangata whenua from focused on protecting tangata whenua from white focused on protecting tangata whenua from white supremacists focused on protecting tangata whenua from white supremacists and focused on protecting tangata whenua from white supremacists and if focused on protecting tangata whenua from white supremacists and if not, from white supremacists and if not, why from white supremacists and if not, why not? from white supremacists and if not, why not? I from white supremacists and if not, why not? I would from white supremacists and if not, why not? I would have from white supremacists and if not, why not? I would have an from white supremacists and if not, why not? I would have an expectation why not? I would have an expectation that why not? I would have an expectation that we why not? I would have an expectation that we would why not? I would have an expectation that we would be why not? I would have an expectation that we would be undertaking why not? I would have an expectation that we would be undertaking or why not? I would have an expectation that we would be undertaking or our that we would be undertaking or our agencies that we would be undertaking or our agencies would that we would be undertaking or our agencies would be that we would be undertaking or our agencies would be doing that we would be undertaking or our agencies would be doing that that we would be undertaking or our agencies would be doing that work that we would be undertaking or our agencies would be doing that work as agencies would be doing that work as a agencies would be doing that work as a matter agencies would be doing that work as a matter of agencies would be doing that work as a matter of course agencies would be doing that work as a matter of course in agencies would be doing that work as a matter of course in their agencies would be doing that work as a matter of course in their daily a matter of course in their daily duties. a matter of course in their daily duties. So a matter of course in their daily duties. So those a matter of course in their daily duties. So those operational duties. So those operational decisions duties. So those operational decisions ultimately duties. So those operational decisions ultimately do duties. So those operational decisions ultimately do exist duties. So those operational decisions ultimately do exist for decisions ultimately do exist for them decisions ultimately do exist for them but decisions ultimately do exist for them but I decisions ultimately do exist for them but I think decisions ultimately do exist for them but I think everyone decisions ultimately do exist for them but I think everyone in decisions ultimately do exist for them but I think everyone in this them but I think everyone in this House them but I think everyone in this House would them but I think everyone in this House would expect them but I think everyone in this House would expect that them but I think everyone in this House would expect that anyone them but I think everyone in this House would expect that anyone that House would expect that anyone that receives House would expect that anyone that receives threats, House would expect that anyone that receives threats, anyone House would expect that anyone that receives threats, anyone that House would expect that anyone that receives threats, anyone that is House would expect that anyone that receives threats, anyone that is the receives threats, anyone that is the subject receives threats, anyone that is the subject of receives threats, anyone that is the subject of threats receives threats, anyone that is the subject of threats either receives threats, anyone that is the subject of threats either online receives threats, anyone that is the subject of threats either online or subject of threats either online or in subject of threats either online or in any subject of threats either online or in any environment subject of threats either online or in any environment experiences subject of threats either online or in any environment experiences the in any environment experiences the full in any environment experiences the full force in any environment experiences the full force of in any environment experiences the full force of the in any environment experiences the full force of the law in any environment experiences the full force of the law and in any environment experiences the full force of the law and that in any environment experiences the full force of the law and that if in any environment experiences the full force of the law and that if we full force of the law and that if we are full force of the law and that if we are seeing full force of the law and that if we are seeing the full force of the law and that if we are seeing the rise full force of the law and that if we are seeing the rise of full force of the law and that if we are seeing the rise of some full force of the law and that if we are seeing the rise of some of full force of the law and that if we are seeing the rise of some of these are seeing the rise of some of these groups, are seeing the rise of some of these groups, and are seeing the rise of some of these groups, and I are seeing the rise of some of these groups, and I believe are seeing the rise of some of these groups, and I believe we are seeing the rise of some of these groups, and I believe we are, are seeing the rise of some of these groups, and I believe we are, both groups, and I believe we are, both globally groups, and I believe we are, both globally and groups, and I believe we are, both globally and in groups, and I believe we are, both globally and in our groups, and I believe we are, both globally and in our own globally and in our own jurisdiction, globally and in our own jurisdiction, that globally and in our own jurisdiction, that is globally and in our own jurisdiction, that is agencies globally and in our own jurisdiction, that is agencies would jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to that. jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to that. Question jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to that. Question No.9. jurisdiction, jurisdiction, that jurisdiction, that is jurisdiction, that is agencies jurisdiction, that is agencies would jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to that. jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to that. Question jurisdiction, that is agencies would respond to that. Question No.9. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Agriculture: My question is to the Minister of Agriculture: What My question is to the Minister of Agriculture: What recent Agriculture: What recent announcements Agriculture: What recent announcements has Agriculture: What recent announcements has he Agriculture: What recent announcements has he made Agriculture: What recent announcements has he made about announcements has he made about integrated announcements has he made about integrated farm announcements has he made about integrated farm planning? The The Hon The Hon Damien The Hon Damien O'Connor. The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday I The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday I released The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday I released the The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday I released the Good The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday I released the Good Farm The Hon Damien O'Connor. Yesterday I released the Good Farm Planning released the Good Farm Planning Principles released the Good Farm Planning Principles Guide released the Good Farm Planning Principles Guide to released the Good Farm Planning Principles Guide to provide released the Good Farm Planning Principles Guide to provide guidance Principles Guide to provide guidance for Principles Guide to provide guidance for farmers Principles Guide to provide guidance for farmers on Principles Guide to provide guidance for farmers on how Principles Guide to provide guidance for farmers on how they Principles Guide to provide guidance for farmers on how they can Principles Guide to provide guidance for farmers on how they can organise for farmers on how they can organise their for farmers on how they can organise their business for farmers on how they can organise their business operations for farmers on how they can organise their business operations and for farmers on how they can organise their business operations and help their business operations and help New their business operations and help New Zealand their business operations and help New Zealand meet their business operations and help New Zealand meet significant New Zealand meet significant environmental New Zealand meet significant environmental challenges New Zealand meet significant environmental challenges and New Zealand meet significant environmental challenges and market environmental challenges and market opportunities. environmental challenges and market opportunities. This environmental challenges and market opportunities. This guide environmental challenges and market opportunities. This guide is environmental challenges and market opportunities. This guide is the opportunities. This guide is the gateway opportunities. This guide is the gateway to opportunities. This guide is the gateway to an opportunities. This guide is the gateway to an integrated opportunities. This guide is the gateway to an integrated farm gateway to an integrated farm planning gateway to an integrated farm planning approach gateway to an integrated farm planning approach and gateway to an integrated farm planning approach and that gateway to an integrated farm planning approach and that is gateway to an integrated farm planning approach and that is that planning approach and that is that each planning approach and that is that each farmer planning approach and that is that each farmer is planning approach and that is that each farmer is looking planning approach and that is that each farmer is looking at planning approach and that is that each farmer is looking at their planning approach and that is that each farmer is looking at their farm each farmer is looking at their farm as each farmer is looking at their farm as a each farmer is looking at their farm as a whole each farmer is looking at their farm as a whole to each farmer is looking at their farm as a whole to supremeline as a whole to supremeline compliance, as a whole to supremeline compliance, avoid as a whole to supremeline compliance, avoid duplication, as a whole to supremeline compliance, avoid duplication, boost compliance, avoid duplication, boost productivity compliance, avoid duplication, boost productivity and compliance, avoid duplication, boost productivity and improve productivity and improve environmental productivity and improve environmental outcomes. productivity and improve environmental outcomes. We productivity and improve environmental outcomes. We have environmental outcomes. We have developed environmental outcomes. We have developed the environmental outcomes. We have developed the guide environmental outcomes. We have developed the guide if environmental outcomes. We have developed the guide if partnership developed the guide if partnership with developed the guide if partnership with senior developed the guide if partnership with senior representatives developed the guide if partnership with senior representatives from with senior representatives from farming with senior representatives from farming industry with senior representatives from farming industry organisations, farming industry organisations, councils farming industry organisations, councils and farming industry organisations, councils and Maori farming industry organisations, councils and Maori agribusiness farming industry organisations, councils and Maori agribusiness and councils and Maori agribusiness and I councils and Maori agribusiness and I welcome councils and Maori agribusiness and I welcome their councils and Maori agribusiness and I welcome their commitment councils and Maori agribusiness and I welcome their commitment to I welcome their commitment to promoting I welcome their commitment to promoting the I welcome their commitment to promoting the value I welcome their commitment to promoting the value of I welcome their commitment to promoting the value of integrated promoting the value of integrated farm promoting the value of integrated farm planning promoting the value of integrated farm planning across promoting the value of integrated farm planning across the promoting the value of integrated farm planning across the sector. promoting the value of integrated farm planning across the sector. How farm planning across the sector. How will farm planning across the sector. How will integrated farm planning across the sector. How will integrated farm farm planning across the sector. How will integrated farm planning farm planning across the sector. How will integrated farm planning help will integrated farm planning help farmers will integrated farm planning help farmers and will integrated farm planning help farmers and growers will integrated farm planning help farmers and growers to will integrated farm planning help farmers and growers to meet will integrated farm planning help farmers and growers to meet their farmers and growers to meet their climate farmers and growers to meet their climate change farmers and growers to meet their climate change targets? farmers and growers to meet their climate change targets? Under farmers and growers to meet their climate change targets? Under the climate change targets? Under the <SPEAKS climate change targets? Under the <SPEAKS TE climate change targets? Under the <SPEAKS TE REO climate change targets? Under the <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> A <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> A partnership, <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> A partnership, 25% <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> A partnership, 25% of <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> A partnership, 25% of farmers <SPEAKS TE REO MAORI> A partnership, 25% of farmers and A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers will A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers will need A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers will need to A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers will need to have A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers will need to have a A partnership, 25% of farmers and growers will need to have a written growers will need to have a written plan growers will need to have a written plan in growers will need to have a written plan in place growers will need to have a written plan in place to growers will need to have a written plan in place to measure growers will need to have a written plan in place to measure and growers will need to have a written plan in place to measure and manage plan in place to measure and manage their plan in place to measure and manage their emissions plan in place to measure and manage their emissions by plan in place to measure and manage their emissions by the plan in place to measure and manage their emissions by the start plan in place to measure and manage their emissions by the start of plan in place to measure and manage their emissions by the start of next their emissions by the start of next year their emissions by the start of next year and their emissions by the start of next year and 100% their emissions by the start of next year and 100% will their emissions by the start of next year and 100% will need their emissions by the start of next year and 100% will need to their emissions by the start of next year and 100% will need to have their emissions by the start of next year and 100% will need to have this year and 100% will need to have this in year and 100% will need to have this in place year and 100% will need to have this in place by year and 100% will need to have this in place by the year and 100% will need to have this in place by the beginning year and 100% will need to have this in place by the beginning of year and 100% will need to have this in place by the beginning of 2025. in place by the beginning of 2025. In in place by the beginning of 2025. In addition, in place by the beginning of 2025. In addition, in in place by the beginning of 2025. In addition, in its in place by the beginning of 2025. In addition, in its final in place by the beginning of 2025. In addition, in its final advice in place by the beginning of 2025. In addition, in its final advice out In addition, in its final advice out today In addition, in its final advice out today the In addition, in its final advice out today the climate In addition, in its final advice out today the climate Commission today the climate Commission emphasised today the climate Commission emphasised the today the climate Commission emphasised the importance today the climate Commission emphasised the importance of emphasised the importance of improving emphasised the importance of improving on-farm emphasised the importance of improving on-farm practices emphasised the importance of improving on-farm practices and improving on-farm practices and disseminating improving on-farm practices and disseminating existing improving on-farm practices and disseminating existing good improving on-farm practices and disseminating existing good practice disseminating existing good practice more disseminating existing good practice more widely. disseminating existing good practice more widely. The disseminating existing good practice more widely. The integrated disseminating existing good practice more widely. The integrated Farm more widely. The integrated Farm Planning more widely. The integrated Farm Planning Guide more widely. The integrated Farm Planning Guide released more widely. The integrated Farm Planning Guide released yesterday Planning Guide released yesterday incorporates Planning Guide released yesterday incorporates the Planning Guide released yesterday incorporates the farm Planning Guide released yesterday incorporates the farm planning incorporates the farm planning guidelines incorporates the farm planning guidelines for incorporates the farm planning guidelines for greenhouse incorporates the farm planning guidelines for greenhouse gas guidelines for greenhouse gas emissions guidelines for greenhouse gas emissions that guidelines for greenhouse gas emissions that was guidelines for greenhouse gas emissions that was released guidelines for greenhouse gas emissions that was released in emissions that was released in December emissions that was released in December last emissions that was released in December last year emissions that was released in December last year and emissions that was released in December last year and making emissions that was released in December last year and making it December last year and making it easier December last year and making it easier for December last year and making it easier for farmers December last year and making it easier for farmers and December last year and making it easier for farmers and growers December last year and making it easier for farmers and growers to easier for farmers and growers to integrate easier for farmers and growers to integrate climate easier for farmers and growers to integrate climate change integrate climate change requirements integrate climate change requirements into integrate climate change requirements into their integrate climate change requirements into their current integrate climate change requirements into their current farm requirements into their current farm planning. requirements into their current farm planning. This requirements into their current farm planning. This Government requirements into their current farm planning. This Government is planning. This Government is committed planning. This Government is committed to planning. This Government is committed to helping planning. This Government is committed to helping increase planning. This Government is committed to helping increase the committed to helping increase the uptake committed to helping increase the uptake of committed to helping increase the uptake of integrated committed to helping increase the uptake of integrated farm committed to helping increase the uptake of integrated farm planning uptake of integrated farm planning across uptake of integrated farm planning across the uptake of integrated farm planning across the country uptake of integrated farm planning across the country in uptake of integrated farm planning across the country in support uptake of integrated farm planning across the country in support of uptake of integrated farm planning across the country in support of our across the country in support of our climate across the country in support of our climate ambition across the country in support of our climate ambition so across the country in support of our climate ambition so that across the country in support of our climate ambition so that more climate ambition so that more farmers climate ambition so that more farmers and climate ambition so that more farmers and growers climate ambition so that more farmers and growers better farmers and growers better understand farmers and growers better understand their farmers and growers better understand their climate farmers and growers better understand their climate impacts farmers and growers better understand their climate impacts and understand their climate impacts and what understand their climate impacts and what actions understand their climate impacts and what actions may understand their climate impacts and what actions may be understand their climate impacts and what actions may be required understand their climate impacts and what actions may be required to understand their climate impacts and what actions may be required to met what actions may be required to met gait what actions may be required to met gait them. what actions may be required to met gait them. How what actions may be required to met gait them. How is what actions may be required to met gait them. How is the what actions may be required to met gait them. How is the Government gait them. How is the Government supporting gait them. How is the Government supporting the gait them. How is the Government supporting the roll gait them. How is the Government supporting the roll out gait them. How is the Government supporting the roll out of supporting the roll out of integrated supporting the roll out of integrated farm supporting the roll out of integrated farm planning? supporting the roll out of integrated farm planning? Budget integrated farm planning? Budget 2021 integrated farm planning? Budget 2021 invests integrated farm planning? Budget 2021 invests $37 integrated farm planning? Budget 2021 invests $37 million integrated farm planning? Budget 2021 invests $37 million towards integrated farm planning? Budget 2021 invests $37 million towards a 2021 invests $37 million towards a national 2021 invests $37 million towards a national integrated 2021 invests $37 million towards a national integrated farm 2021 invests $37 million towards a national integrated farm planning national integrated farm planning system. national integrated farm planning system. It national integrated farm planning system. It will national integrated farm planning system. It will deliver national integrated farm planning system. It will deliver 100 national integrated farm planning system. It will deliver 100 more system. It will deliver 100 more professionals system. It will deliver 100 more professionals and system. It will deliver 100 more professionals and work system. It will deliver 100 more professionals and work with system. It will deliver 100 more professionals and work with existing professionals and work with existing organisations professionals and work with existing organisations who professionals and work with existing organisations who have professionals and work with existing organisations who have the professionals and work with existing organisations who have the skills professionals and work with existing organisations who have the skills to organisations who have the skills to provide organisations who have the skills to provide advice organisations who have the skills to provide advice to organisations who have the skills to provide advice to farmers organisations who have the skills to provide advice to farmers and provide advice to farmers and growers provide advice to farmers and growers with provide advice to farmers and growers with aspects provide advice to farmers and growers with aspects of provide advice to farmers and growers with aspects of planning. provide advice to farmers and growers with aspects of planning. It growers with aspects of planning. It will growers with aspects of planning. It will also growers with aspects of planning. It will also improve growers with aspects of planning. It will also improve information growers with aspects of planning. It will also improve information and will also improve information and data will also improve information and data interoperability will also improve information and data interoperability across will also improve information and data interoperability across the data interoperability across the primary data interoperability across the primary industries data interoperability across the primary industries and data interoperability across the primary industries and between primary industries and between regulators primary industries and between regulators in primary industries and between regulators in industry primary industries and between regulators in industry assurance regulators in industry assurance programmes. regulators in industry assurance programmes. An regulators in industry assurance programmes. An accelerator regulators in industry assurance programmes. An accelerator fund regulators in industry assurance programmes. An accelerator fund will programmes. An accelerator fund will be programmes. An accelerator fund will be set programmes. An accelerator fund will be set up programmes. An accelerator fund will be set up to programmes. An accelerator fund will be set up to broaden programmes. An accelerator fund will be set up to broaden the programmes. An accelerator fund will be set up to broaden the uptake programmes. An accelerator fund will be set up to broaden the uptake of be set up to broaden the uptake of integrated be set up to broaden the uptake of integrated farm be set up to broaden the uptake of integrated farm planning be set up to broaden the uptake of integrated farm planning through integrated farm planning through great integrated farm planning through great organisations integrated farm planning through great organisations like integrated farm planning through great organisations like catchment great organisations like catchment management great organisations like catchment management groups. great organisations like catchment management groups. Once great organisations like catchment management groups. Once integrated management groups. Once integrated farm management groups. Once integrated farm planning management groups. Once integrated farm planning is management groups. Once integrated farm planning is fully management groups. Once integrated farm planning is fully rolled management groups. Once integrated farm planning is fully rolled out management groups. Once integrated farm planning is fully rolled out up farm planning is fully rolled out up to farm planning is fully rolled out up to 40,000 farm planning is fully rolled out up to 40,000 farmers farm planning is fully rolled out up to 40,000 farmers and farm planning is fully rolled out up to 40,000 farmers and growers farm planning is fully rolled out up to 40,000 farmers and growers will to 40,000 farmers and growers will have to 40,000 farmers and growers will have the to 40,000 farmers and growers will have the tools to 40,000 farmers and growers will have the tools they to 40,000 farmers and growers will have the tools they need to 40,000 farmers and growers will have the tools they need to to 40,000 farmers and growers will have the tools they need to improve have the tools they need to improve the have the tools they need to improve the on have the tools they need to improve the on farm have the tools they need to improve the on farm performance have the tools they need to improve the on farm performance and have the tools they need to improve the on farm performance and meet the on farm performance and meet their the on farm performance and meet their freshwater the on farm performance and meet their freshwater and the on farm performance and meet their freshwater and greenhouse the on farm performance and meet their freshwater and greenhouse gas their freshwater and greenhouse gas requirements. their freshwater and greenhouse gas requirements. Question their freshwater and greenhouse gas requirements. Question Number their freshwater and greenhouse gas requirements. Question Number 10. requirements. Question Number 10. Tim requirements. Question Number 10. Tim van requirements. Question Number 10. Tim van de requirements. Question Number 10. Tim van de Molen. requirements. requirements. Question requirements. Question Number requirements. Question Number 10. requirements. Question Number 10. Tim requirements. Question Number 10. Tim van requirements. Question Number 10. Tim van de requirements. Question Number 10. Tim van de Molen. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Building My question is to the Minister for Building and My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does My question is to the Minister for Building and Construction: Does she Building and Construction: Does she stand Building and Construction: Does she stand by Building and Construction: Does she stand by her Building and Construction: Does she stand by her statement, Building and Construction: Does she stand by her statement, when Building and Construction: Does she stand by her statement, when asked stand by her statement, when asked if stand by her statement, when asked if Budget stand by her statement, when asked if Budget 2021 stand by her statement, when asked if Budget 2021 is stand by her statement, when asked if Budget 2021 is wrong stand by her statement, when asked if Budget 2021 is wrong in stand by her statement, when asked if Budget 2021 is wrong in respect if Budget 2021 is wrong in respect of if Budget 2021 is wrong in respect of the if Budget 2021 is wrong in respect of the Residential if Budget 2021 is wrong in respect of the Residential Earthquake-Prone of the Residential Earthquake-Prone Building of the Residential Earthquake-Prone Building Financial of the Residential Earthquake-Prone Building Financial Assistance Building Financial Assistance Scheme, Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that "on Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that "on the Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that "on the face Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that "on the face of Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that "on the face of it, Building Financial Assistance Scheme, that "on the face of it, it Scheme, that "on the face of it, it would Scheme, that "on the face of it, it would appear Scheme, that "on the face of it, it would appear to Scheme, that "on the face of it, it would appear to be"? The The Hon The Hon Poto The Hon Poto Williams. The Hon Poto Williams. In The Hon Poto Williams. In so The Hon Poto Williams. In so far The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there is The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there is a The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there is a typo The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there is a typo in The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there is a typo in the The Hon Poto Williams. In so far that there is a typo in the overview that there is a typo in the overview of that there is a typo in the overview of vote that there is a typo in the overview of vote page that there is a typo in the overview of vote page on that there is a typo in the overview of vote page on vote that there is a typo in the overview of vote page on vote building that there is a typo in the overview of vote page on vote building and of vote page on vote building and construction of vote page on vote building and construction that of vote page on vote building and construction that uses of vote page on vote building and construction that uses the of vote page on vote building and construction that uses the phrase, construction that uses the phrase, "Just construction that uses the phrase, "Just under construction that uses the phrase, "Just under $11 construction that uses the phrase, "Just under $11 million construction that uses the phrase, "Just under $11 million to construction that uses the phrase, "Just under $11 million to make "Just under $11 million to make assistance "Just under $11 million to make assistance available "Just under $11 million to make assistance available to "Just under $11 million to make assistance available to owner assistance available to owner occupiers assistance available to owner occupiers or assistance available to owner occupiers or investors assistance available to owner occupiers or investors in, assistance available to owner occupiers or investors in, or assistance available to owner occupiers or investors in, or facing occupiers or investors in, or facing hardship" occupiers or investors in, or facing hardship" rather occupiers or investors in, or facing hardship" rather than occupiers or investors in, or facing hardship" rather than simply hardship" rather than simply "owner-occupiers", hardship" rather than simply "owner-occupiers", yes. hardship" rather than simply "owner-occupiers", yes. So hardship" rather than simply "owner-occupiers", yes. So did hardship" rather than simply "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the minister "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the minister bother "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the minister bother to "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the minister bother to proof "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the minister bother to proof read "owner-occupiers", yes. So did the minister bother to proof read the minister bother to proof read the appropriation minister bother to proof read the appropriation for minister bother to proof read the appropriation for the minister bother to proof read the appropriation for the budget? minister bother to proof read the appropriation for the budget? Mr appropriation for the budget? Mr Speaker, appropriation for the budget? Mr Speaker, it appropriation for the budget? Mr Speaker, it is appropriation for the budget? Mr Speaker, it is unfortunate appropriation for the budget? Mr Speaker, it is unfortunate there appropriation for the budget? Mr Speaker, it is unfortunate there is Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo in Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo in the Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo in the overview Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo in the overview but Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo in the overview but it Speaker, it is unfortunate there is a typo in the overview but it does a typo in the overview but it does not a typo in the overview but it does not affect a typo in the overview but it does not affect the a typo in the overview but it does not affect the budget a typo in the overview but it does not affect the budget appropriation not affect the budget appropriation in not affect the budget appropriation in any not affect the budget appropriation in any way. not affect the budget appropriation in any way. So not affect the budget appropriation in any way. So in not affect the budget appropriation in any way. So in relation not affect the budget appropriation in any way. So in relation to not affect the budget appropriation in any way. So in relation to the in any way. So in relation to the criteria in any way. So in relation to the criteria then in any way. So in relation to the criteria then for in any way. So in relation to the criteria then for investors in any way. So in relation to the criteria then for investors being criteria then for investors being excluded, criteria then for investors being excluded, how criteria then for investors being excluded, how many criteria then for investors being excluded, how many applications, criteria then for investors being excluded, how many applications, as excluded, how many applications, as opposed excluded, how many applications, as opposed to excluded, how many applications, as opposed to expressions excluded, how many applications, as opposed to expressions of excluded, how many applications, as opposed to expressions of interest, opposed to expressions of interest, have opposed to expressions of interest, have been opposed to expressions of interest, have been received opposed to expressions of interest, have been received for opposed to expressions of interest, have been received for the opposed to expressions of interest, have been received for the scheme? have been received for the scheme? Mr have been received for the scheme? Mr Speaker, have been received for the scheme? Mr Speaker, as have been received for the scheme? Mr Speaker, as I have been received for the scheme? Mr Speaker, as I have have been received for the scheme? Mr Speaker, as I have told have been received for the scheme? Mr Speaker, as I have told this Mr Speaker, as I have told this House Mr Speaker, as I have told this House on Mr Speaker, as I have told this House on a Mr Speaker, as I have told this House on a number Mr Speaker, as I have told this House on a number of Mr Speaker, as I have told this House on a number of occasions Mr Speaker, as I have told this House on a number of occasions now, House on a number of occasions now, we House on a number of occasions now, we are House on a number of occasions now, we are supporting House on a number of occasions now, we are supporting people House on a number of occasions now, we are supporting people who House on a number of occasions now, we are supporting people who have we are supporting people who have made we are supporting people who have made expressions we are supporting people who have made expressions of we are supporting people who have made expressions of interest we are supporting people who have made expressions of interest into we are supporting people who have made expressions of interest into - made expressions of interest into - to made expressions of interest into - to become made expressions of interest into - to become ready made expressions of interest into - to become ready to made expressions of interest into - to become ready to submit made expressions of interest into - to become ready to submit but made expressions of interest into - to become ready to submit but at to become ready to submit but at this to become ready to submit but at this stage to become ready to submit but at this stage we to become ready to submit but at this stage we have to become ready to submit but at this stage we have not to become ready to submit but at this stage we have not received to become ready to submit but at this stage we have not received any this stage we have not received any applications. this stage we have not received any applications. <INTERRUPTION> applications. <INTERRUPTION> Order! applications. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I applications. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will applications. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will apologise applications. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will apologise to applications. <INTERRUPTION> Order! I will apologise to the Order! I will apologise to the House. Order! I will apologise to the House. I Order! I will apologise to the House. I should Order! I will apologise to the House. I should have Order! I will apologise to the House. I should have ruled Order! I will apologise to the House. I should have ruled that House. I should have ruled that question House. I should have ruled that question out. House. I should have ruled that question out. It House. I should have ruled that question out. It didn't House. I should have ruled that question out. It didn't flow House. I should have ruled that question out. It didn't flow from question out. It didn't flow from either question out. It didn't flow from either the question out. It didn't flow from either the question question out. It didn't flow from either the question or question out. It didn't flow from either the question or the question out. It didn't flow from either the question or the answer. either the question or the answer. Further either the question or the answer. Further supplementary, either the question or the answer. Further supplementary, Tim either the question or the answer. Further supplementary, Tim van either the question or the answer. Further supplementary, Tim van de Further supplementary, Tim van de Molen. Further supplementary, Tim van de Molen. Has Further supplementary, Tim van de Molen. Has the Further supplementary, Tim van de Molen. Has the more Further supplementary, Tim van de Molen. Has the more than Further supplementary, Tim van de Molen. Has the more than 700,000 Molen. Has the more than 700,000 spent Molen. Has the more than 700,000 spent on Molen. Has the more than 700,000 spent on administering Molen. Has the more than 700,000 spent on administering the Molen. Has the more than 700,000 spent on administering the scheme, spent on administering the scheme, including spent on administering the scheme, including promotion spent on administering the scheme, including promotion to spent on administering the scheme, including promotion to applicants, including promotion to applicants, been including promotion to applicants, been effective including promotion to applicants, been effective given including promotion to applicants, been effective given there including promotion to applicants, been effective given there have including promotion to applicants, been effective given there have been been effective given there have been zero been effective given there have been zero applications? been effective given there have been zero applications? As been effective given there have been zero applications? As I been effective given there have been zero applications? As I explained been effective given there have been zero applications? As I explained to zero applications? As I explained to the zero applications? As I explained to the member zero applications? As I explained to the member during zero applications? As I explained to the member during the zero applications? As I explained to the member during the estimates the member during the estimates debate, the member during the estimates debate, that the member during the estimates debate, that appropriation the member during the estimates debate, that appropriation in the member during the estimates debate, that appropriation in the debate, that appropriation in the spending debate, that appropriation in the spending thus debate, that appropriation in the spending thus far debate, that appropriation in the spending thus far has debate, that appropriation in the spending thus far has been debate, that appropriation in the spending thus far has been to spending thus far has been to support spending thus far has been to support those spending thus far has been to support those who spending thus far has been to support those who were spending thus far has been to support those who were expressed spending thus far has been to support those who were expressed an support those who were expressed an interest support those who were expressed an interest in support those who were expressed an interest in taking support those who were expressed an interest in taking part support those who were expressed an interest in taking part in support those who were expressed an interest in taking part in the interest in taking part in the scheme. interest in taking part in the scheme. It interest in taking part in the scheme. It is interest in taking part in the scheme. It is a interest in taking part in the scheme. It is a complex interest in taking part in the scheme. It is a complex matter scheme. It is a complex matter needing scheme. It is a complex matter needing engineering. scheme. It is a complex matter needing engineering. We scheme. It is a complex matter needing engineering. We are scheme. It is a complex matter needing engineering. We are talking needing engineering. We are talking about needing engineering. We are talking about people needing engineering. We are talking about people generally needing engineering. We are talking about people generally who needing engineering. We are talking about people generally who do needing engineering. We are talking about people generally who do not about people generally who do not have about people generally who do not have technical about people generally who do not have technical expertise about people generally who do not have technical expertise but about people generally who do not have technical expertise but part about people generally who do not have technical expertise but part of have technical expertise but part of the have technical expertise but part of the issue have technical expertise but part of the issue is have technical expertise but part of the issue is to have technical expertise but part of the issue is to ensure have technical expertise but part of the issue is to ensure that have technical expertise but part of the issue is to ensure that they've the issue is to ensure that they've got the issue is to ensure that they've got the the issue is to ensure that they've got the right the issue is to ensure that they've got the right expertise, the issue is to ensure that they've got the right expertise, the the issue is to ensure that they've got the right expertise, the right got the right expertise, the right advice got the right expertise, the right advice and got the right expertise, the right advice and that got the right expertise, the right advice and that all got the right expertise, the right advice and that all the got the right expertise, the right advice and that all the other advice and that all the other criteria advice and that all the other criteria are advice and that all the other criteria are met, advice and that all the other criteria are met, including advice and that all the other criteria are met, including that criteria are met, including that they criteria are met, including that they have criteria are met, including that they have made criteria are met, including that they have made applications criteria are met, including that they have made applications for they have made applications for funding they have made applications for funding and they have made applications for funding and have they have made applications for funding and have been they have made applications for funding and have been turned they have made applications for funding and have been turned down. funding and have been turned down. So funding and have been turned down. So with funding and have been turned down. So with a funding and have been turned down. So with a view funding and have been turned down. So with a view to funding and have been turned down. So with a view to trying funding and have been turned down. So with a view to trying to funding and have been turned down. So with a view to trying to attract So with a view to trying to attract a So with a view to trying to attract a single So with a view to trying to attract a single applicant, So with a view to trying to attract a single applicant, will So with a view to trying to attract a single applicant, will she So with a view to trying to attract a single applicant, will she seek a single applicant, will she seek advice a single applicant, will she seek advice from a single applicant, will she seek advice from the a single applicant, will she seek advice from the Hon a single applicant, will she seek advice from the Hon Megan a single applicant, will she seek advice from the Hon Megan Woods a single applicant, will she seek advice from the Hon Megan Woods on advice from the Hon Megan Woods on how advice from the Hon Megan Woods on how to advice from the Hon Megan Woods on how to effectively advice from the Hon Megan Woods on how to effectively promote advice from the Hon Megan Woods on how to effectively promote a advice from the Hon Megan Woods on how to effectively promote a scheme how to effectively promote a scheme by how to effectively promote a scheme by perhaps how to effectively promote a scheme by perhaps using how to effectively promote a scheme by perhaps using drones? how to effectively promote a scheme by perhaps using drones? Question by perhaps using drones? Question number by perhaps using drones? Question number 11,s by perhaps using drones? Question number 11,s Tamati by perhaps using drones? Question number 11,s Tamati Coffey. number number 11,s number 11,s Tamati number 11,s Tamati Coffey. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Maori My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: What My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: What steps My question is to the Minister for Maori Development: What steps has Maori Development: What steps has the Maori Development: What steps has the Government Maori Development: What steps has the Government taken Maori Development: What steps has the Government taken to Maori Development: What steps has the Government taken to support the Government taken to support Maori the Government taken to support Maori housing the Government taken to support Maori housing aspirations? The The Hon The Hon Willie The Hon Willie Jackson. The Hon Willie Jackson. Since The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 Budget, The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 Budget, since The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 Budget, since that The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 Budget, since that Budget, The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 Budget, since that Budget, the The Hon Willie Jackson. Since 2019 Budget, since that Budget, the TPK Budget, since that Budget, the TPK housing Budget, since that Budget, the TPK housing investment Budget, since that Budget, the TPK housing investment programme Budget, since that Budget, the TPK housing investment programme has housing investment programme has provided housing investment programme has provided funding housing investment programme has provided funding for housing investment programme has provided funding for 53 housing investment programme has provided funding for 53 Houses housing investment programme has provided funding for 53 Houses on provided funding for 53 Houses on Papakainga provided funding for 53 Houses on Papakainga and provided funding for 53 Houses on Papakainga and infrastructure provided funding for 53 Houses on Papakainga and infrastructure for Papakainga and infrastructure for 115 Papakainga and infrastructure for 115 individual Papakainga and infrastructure for 115 individual house Papakainga and infrastructure for 115 individual house sites, Papakainga and infrastructure for 115 individual house sites, 824 115 individual house sites, 824 housing 115 individual house sites, 824 housing repairs 115 individual house sites, 824 housing repairs projects 115 individual house sites, 824 housing repairs projects and 115 individual house sites, 824 housing repairs projects and 89 housing repairs projects and 89 sorted housing repairs projects and 89 sorted kainga housing repairs projects and 89 sorted kainga programmes housing repairs projects and 89 sorted kainga programmes to housing repairs projects and 89 sorted kainga programmes to build sorted kainga programmes to build whanau sorted kainga programmes to build whanau financial sorted kainga programmes to build whanau financial capability. sorted kainga programmes to build whanau financial capability. Over whanau financial capability. Over the whanau financial capability. Over the past whanau financial capability. Over the past six whanau financial capability. Over the past six months whanau financial capability. Over the past six months I whanau financial capability. Over the past six months I have whanau financial capability. Over the past six months I have been whanau financial capability. Over the past six months I have been able the past six months I have been able to the past six months I have been able to visit the past six months I have been able to visit with the past six months I have been able to visit with a the past six months I have been able to visit with a number the past six months I have been able to visit with a number of the past six months I have been able to visit with a number of Maori to visit with a number of Maori housing to visit with a number of Maori housing developments to visit with a number of Maori housing developments if to visit with a number of Maori housing developments if Papakainga housing developments if Papakainga to housing developments if Papakainga to affordable housing developments if Papakainga to affordable rentals housing developments if Papakainga to affordable rentals like housing developments if Papakainga to affordable rentals like the housing developments if Papakainga to affordable rentals like the ones to affordable rentals like the ones being to affordable rentals like the ones being provided to affordable rentals like the ones being provided by to affordable rentals like the ones being provided by the to affordable rentals like the ones being provided by the marae to affordable rentals like the ones being provided by the marae in being provided by the marae in Christchurch being provided by the marae in Christchurch and being provided by the marae in Christchurch and I being provided by the marae in Christchurch and I am being provided by the marae in Christchurch and I am proud being provided by the marae in Christchurch and I am proud this Christchurch and I am proud this Government Christchurch and I am proud this Government is Christchurch and I am proud this Government is partnering Christchurch and I am proud this Government is partnering with Christchurch and I am proud this Government is partnering with Maori Government is partnering with Maori to Government is partnering with Maori to deliver Government is partnering with Maori to deliver long Government is partnering with Maori to deliver long term, Government is partnering with Maori to deliver long term, healthy, to deliver long term, healthy, sustainable to deliver long term, healthy, sustainable housing to deliver long term, healthy, sustainable housing options to deliver long term, healthy, sustainable housing options for to deliver long term, healthy, sustainable housing options for our sustainable housing options for our people. sustainable housing options for our people. Supplementary. sustainable housing options for our people. Supplementary. How sustainable housing options for our people. Supplementary. How does sustainable housing options for our people. Supplementary. How does the people. Supplementary. How does the Wellbeing people. Supplementary. How does the Wellbeing Budget people. Supplementary. How does the Wellbeing Budget 2021 people. Supplementary. How does the Wellbeing Budget 2021 support people. Supplementary. How does the Wellbeing Budget 2021 support Maori Wellbeing Budget 2021 support Maori housing Wellbeing Budget 2021 support Maori housing aspirations? Wellbeing Budget 2021 support Maori housing aspirations? In Wellbeing Budget 2021 support Maori housing aspirations? In Budget Wellbeing Budget 2021 support Maori housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 -- housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 -- 2021, housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 -- 2021, 380 housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 -- 2021, 380 million housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 -- 2021, 380 million has housing aspirations? In Budget 20201 -- 2021, 380 million has been -- 2021, 380 million has been invested -- 2021, 380 million has been invested over -- 2021, 380 million has been invested over four -- 2021, 380 million has been invested over four years -- 2021, 380 million has been invested over four years in -- 2021, 380 million has been invested over four years in a invested over four years in a programme invested over four years in a programme jointly <AUDIO LOSS> Supplementary, <AUDIO LOSS> Supplementary, will <AUDIO LOSS> Supplementary, will the <AUDIO LOSS> Supplementary, will the almost <AUDIO LOSS> Supplementary, will the almost $500 Supplementary, will the almost $500 million Supplementary, will the almost $500 million in Supplementary, will the almost $500 million in taxpayer Supplementary, will the almost $500 million in taxpayer money Supplementary, will the almost $500 million in taxpayer money he Supplementary, will the almost $500 million in taxpayer money he is million in taxpayer money he is spending million in taxpayer money he is spending to million in taxpayer money he is spending to restructure million in taxpayer money he is spending to restructure the million in taxpayer money he is spending to restructure the health spending to restructure the health sector spending to restructure the health sector deliver spending to restructure the health sector deliver any spending to restructure the health sector deliver any additional sector deliver any additional front-line sector deliver any additional front-line doctors sector deliver any additional front-line doctors or sector deliver any additional front-line doctors or nurses, sector deliver any additional front-line doctors or nurses, if sector deliver any additional front-line doctors or nurses, if so, front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? Part front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? Part of front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? Part of the front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? Part of the $46 front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? Part of the $46 to front-line doctors or nurses, if so, how many? Part of the $46 to million how many? Part of the $46 to million -- how many? Part of the $46 to million -- $460 how many? Part of the $46 to million -- $460 million how many? Part of the $46 to million -- $460 million includes how many? Part of the $46 to million -- $460 million includes new -- $460 million includes new commissioning -- $460 million includes new commissioning funding -- $460 million includes new commissioning funding for -- $460 million includes new commissioning funding for the commissioning funding for the interim commissioning funding for the interim Maori commissioning funding for the interim Maori health commissioning funding for the interim Maori health authority commissioning funding for the interim Maori health authority and interim Maori health authority and interim interim Maori health authority and interim health interim Maori health authority and interim health NZ. interim Maori health authority and interim health NZ. That interim Maori health authority and interim health NZ. That will interim Maori health authority and interim health NZ. That will mean interim health NZ. That will mean new interim health NZ. That will mean new services, interim health NZ. That will mean new services, that interim health NZ. That will mean new services, that means interim health NZ. That will mean new services, that means services new services, that means services that new services, that means services that do new services, that means services that do not new services, that means services that do not exist new services, that means services that do not exist now new services, that means services that do not exist now but new services, that means services that do not exist now but will new services, that means services that do not exist now but will in that do not exist now but will in the that do not exist now but will in the future. that do not exist now but will in the future. How that do not exist now but will in the future. How those that do not exist now but will in the future. How those organisations the future. How those organisations who the future. How those organisations who are the future. How those organisations who are cracked the future. How those organisations who are cracked or the future. How those organisations who are cracked or commissioned the future. How those organisations who are cracked or commissioned to who are cracked or commissioned to provide who are cracked or commissioned to provide those who are cracked or commissioned to provide those services who are cracked or commissioned to provide those services staff who are cracked or commissioned to provide those services staff those provide those services staff those be provide those services staff those be for provide those services staff those be for them provide those services staff those be for them but provide those services staff those be for them but -- provide those services staff those be for them but -- services provide those services staff those be for them but -- services will provide those services staff those be for them but -- services will be be for them but -- services will be for be for them but -- services will be for them be for them but -- services will be for them but be for them but -- services will be for them but they be for them but -- services will be for them but they will be for them but -- services will be for them but they will be be for them but -- services will be for them but they will be additional for them but they will be additional services for them but they will be additional services and for them but they will be additional services and will for them but they will be additional services and will add for them but they will be additional services and will add to for them but they will be additional services and will add to the services and will add to the capacity services and will add to the capacity of services and will add to the capacity of our services and will add to the capacity of our health services and will add to the capacity of our health system. capacity of our health system. Supplementary. capacity of our health system. Supplementary. How capacity of our health system. Supplementary. How can capacity of our health system. Supplementary. How can he capacity of our health system. Supplementary. How can he be Supplementary. How can he be confident Supplementary. How can he be confident the Supplementary. How can he be confident the Government Supplementary. How can he be confident the Government can Supplementary. How can he be confident the Government can deliver confident the Government can deliver COVID-19 confident the Government can deliver COVID-19 vaccinations confident the Government can deliver COVID-19 vaccinations to confident the Government can deliver COVID-19 vaccinations to every confident the Government can deliver COVID-19 vaccinations to every New COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by the COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by the end COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by the end of COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by the end of the COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by the end of the year COVID-19 vaccinations to every New Zealander by the end of the year as Zealander by the end of the year as planned Zealander by the end of the year as planned when Zealander by the end of the year as planned when the Zealander by the end of the year as planned when the health Zealander by the end of the year as planned when the health workforce planned when the health workforce are planned when the health workforce are struggling planned when the health workforce are struggling to planned when the health workforce are struggling to operate planned when the health workforce are struggling to operate with are struggling to operate with business are struggling to operate with business as are struggling to operate with business as usual? are struggling to operate with business as usual? It are struggling to operate with business as usual? It is are struggling to operate with business as usual? It is struggling business as usual? It is struggling but business as usual? It is struggling but carry business as usual? It is struggling but carry on. business as usual? It is struggling but carry on. Without business as usual? It is struggling but carry on. Without wanting business as usual? It is struggling but carry on. Without wanting to but carry on. Without wanting to trade but carry on. Without wanting to trade on but carry on. Without wanting to trade on the but carry on. Without wanting to trade on the toes but carry on. Without wanting to trade on the toes of but carry on. Without wanting to trade on the toes of my but carry on. Without wanting to trade on the toes of my very but carry on. Without wanting to trade on the toes of my very good trade on the toes of my very good colleague, trade on the toes of my very good colleague, the trade on the toes of my very good colleague, the Minister trade on the toes of my very good colleague, the Minister for trade on the toes of my very good colleague, the Minister for COVID-19 colleague, the Minister for COVID-19 Response, colleague, the Minister for COVID-19 Response, the colleague, the Minister for COVID-19 Response, the Hon colleague, the Minister for COVID-19 Response, the Hon Chris colleague, the Minister for COVID-19 Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I can Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I can say Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I can say is Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I can say is because Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I can say is because of Response, the Hon Chris Hipkins, what I can say is because of the what I can say is because of the very what I can say is because of the very fine what I can say is because of the very fine planning what I can say is because of the very fine planning done what I can say is because of the very fine planning done by what I can say is because of the very fine planning done by those very fine planning done by those responsible very fine planning done by those responsible for very fine planning done by those responsible for it very fine planning done by those responsible for it that very fine planning done by those responsible for it that we very fine planning done by those responsible for it that we are very fine planning done by those responsible for it that we are ahead responsible for it that we are ahead of responsible for it that we are ahead of our responsible for it that we are ahead of our planned responsible for it that we are ahead of our planned target responsible for it that we are ahead of our planned target achievement of our planned target achievement for of our planned target achievement for the of our planned target achievement for the COVID-19 of our planned target achievement for the COVID-19 vaccination of our planned target achievement for the COVID-19 vaccination roll for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out and for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out and we for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out and we remain for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out and we remain confident for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out and we remain confident we for the COVID-19 vaccination roll out and we remain confident we will out and we remain confident we will fulfil out and we remain confident we will fulfil our out and we remain confident we will fulfil our vaccination out and we remain confident we will fulfil our vaccination target out and we remain confident we will fulfil our vaccination target as out and we remain confident we will fulfil our vaccination target as ap fulfil our vaccination target as ap plied