. This This programme This programme is This programme is live This programme is live captioned This programme is live captioned by This programme is live captioned by Red This programme is live captioned by Red Bee This programme is live captioned by Red Bee Media Red Bee Media for Red Bee Media for the Red Bee Media for the Office Red Bee Media for the Office of Red Bee Media for the Office of the Red Bee Media for the Office of the Clerk for the Office of the Clerk of for the Office of the Clerk of the for the Office of the Clerk of the House for the Office of the Clerk of the House of for the Office of the Clerk of the House of Representatives. INTERPRETER: INTERPRETER: Almighty INTERPRETER: Almighty God, Almighty God, we Almighty God, we give Almighty God, we give thanks Almighty God, we give thanks for Almighty God, we give thanks for the Almighty God, we give thanks for the blessings we give thanks for the blessings which we give thanks for the blessings which have we give thanks for the blessings which have been we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on we give thanks for the blessings which have been bestowed on us. which have been bestowed on us. Laying which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal which have been bestowed on us. Laying aside all personal interests, Laying aside all personal interests, we Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Laying aside all personal interests, we acknowledge the Queen we acknowledge the Queen and we acknowledge the Queen and pray we acknowledge the Queen and pray for we acknowledge the Queen and pray for guidance and pray for guidance in and pray for guidance in our and pray for guidance in our deliberations, in our deliberations, that in our deliberations, that we in our deliberations, that we may in our deliberations, that we may conduct that we may conduct the that we may conduct the affairs that we may conduct the affairs of that we may conduct the affairs of this that we may conduct the affairs of this House the affairs of this House with the affairs of this House with wisdom, the affairs of this House with wisdom, justice, the affairs of this House with wisdom, justice, mercy, with wisdom, justice, mercy, and with wisdom, justice, mercy, and humility and humility for and humility for the and humility for the welfare and humility for the welfare and and humility for the welfare and peace for the welfare and peace of for the welfare and peace of New for the welfare and peace of New Zealand. for the welfare and peace of New Zealand. Amen. I I have I have been I have been advised I have been advised by I have been advised by the I have been advised by the Electoral I have been advised by the Electoral Commissioner I have been advised by the Electoral Commissioner that, by the Electoral Commissioner that, under by the Electoral Commissioner that, under section by the Electoral Commissioner that, under section 137 by the Electoral Commissioner that, under section 137 of under section 137 of the under section 137 of the Electoral under section 137 of the Electoral Act under section 137 of the Electoral Act 1993, the Electoral Act 1993, Harete the Electoral Act 1993, Harete Hipango the Electoral Act 1993, Harete Hipango has the Electoral Act 1993, Harete Hipango has been the Electoral Act 1993, Harete Hipango has been declared Harete Hipango has been declared to Harete Hipango has been declared to be Harete Hipango has been declared to be elected Harete Hipango has been declared to be elected a Harete Hipango has been declared to be elected a member Harete Hipango has been declared to be elected a member of Harete Hipango has been declared to be elected a member of the Harete Hipango has been declared to be elected a member of the House to be elected a member of the House of to be elected a member of the House of Representatives to be elected a member of the House of Representatives in to be elected a member of the House of Representatives in place of Representatives in place of of Representatives in place of the of Representatives in place of the Hon of Representatives in place of the Hon Dr of Representatives in place of the Hon Dr Nick of Representatives in place of the Hon Dr Nick Smith. I I understand I understand that I understand that Harete I understand that Harete Hipango I understand that Harete Hipango is I understand that Harete Hipango is present I understand that Harete Hipango is present and I understand that Harete Hipango is present and wishes I understand that Harete Hipango is present and wishes to I understand that Harete Hipango is present and wishes to take is present and wishes to take the is present and wishes to take the Oath is present and wishes to take the Oath of is present and wishes to take the Oath of Allegiance. the Oath of Allegiance. Would the Oath of Allegiance. Would she the Oath of Allegiance. Would she please the Oath of Allegiance. Would she please come the Oath of Allegiance. Would she please come forward Would she please come forward to Would she please come forward to the Would she please come forward to the chair Would she please come forward to the chair on Would she please come forward to the chair on my Would she please come forward to the chair on my right. I'm I'm not I'm not sure I'm not sure whether I'm not sure whether I I'm not sure whether I should I'm not sure whether I should view I'm not sure whether I should view that I'm not sure whether I should view that with I'm not sure whether I should view that with some I'm not sure whether I should view that with some concern! I'm not sure whether I should view that with some concern! <LAUGHTER> that with some concern! <LAUGHTER> INTERPRETER: I'm I'm not I'm not sure I'm not sure whether I'm not sure whether I I'm not sure whether I should I'm not sure whether I should view I'm not sure whether I should view that I'm not sure whether I should view that with I'm not sure whether I should view that with some I'm not sure whether I should view that with some concern! I'm not sure whether I should view that with some concern! <LAUGHTER> INTERPRETER: INTERPRETER: INTERPRETER: I, I, Harete I, Harete Hipango, I, Harete Hipango, swear I, Harete Hipango, swear that I, Harete Hipango, swear that I I, Harete Hipango, swear that I will I, Harete Hipango, swear that I will be I, Harete Hipango, swear that I will be faithful I, Harete Hipango, swear that I will be faithful and I, Harete Hipango, swear that I will be faithful and bear that I will be faithful and bear true that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance that I will be faithful and bear true allegiance to true allegiance to Her true allegiance to Her Majesty true allegiance to Her Majesty Queen true allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth true allegiance to Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, Her Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, Her heirs Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, Her heirs and Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, Her heirs and successors, Her Majesty Queen Elizabeth II, Her heirs and successors, according Her heirs and successors, according to Her heirs and successors, according to law. to law. So to law. So help to law. So help me to law. So help me God. Thank Thank you. Thank you. <APPLAUSE> It It has It has been It has been drawn It has been drawn to It has been drawn to my It has been drawn to my that It has been drawn to my that the It has been drawn to my that the recent It has been drawn to my that the recent decision It has been drawn to my that the recent decision of It has been drawn to my that the recent decision of the It has been drawn to my that the recent decision of the High It has been drawn to my that the recent decision of the High Court recent decision of the High Court raises recent decision of the High Court raises a recent decision of the High Court raises a general recent decision of the High Court raises a general matter recent decision of the High Court raises a general matter of recent decision of the High Court raises a general matter of privilege raises a general matter of privilege that raises a general matter of privilege that requires raises a general matter of privilege that requires further raises a general matter of privilege that requires further examination. that requires further examination. This that requires further examination. This matter that requires further examination. This matter has that requires further examination. This matter has not that requires further examination. This matter has not been that requires further examination. This matter has not been raised that requires further examination. This matter has not been raised by This matter has not been raised by complaint This matter has not been raised by complaint from This matter has not been raised by complaint from a This matter has not been raised by complaint from a member This matter has not been raised by complaint from a member but This matter has not been raised by complaint from a member but it This matter has not been raised by complaint from a member but it is, complaint from a member but it is, in complaint from a member but it is, in my complaint from a member but it is, in my opinion, complaint from a member but it is, in my opinion, the complaint from a member but it is, in my opinion, the subject complaint from a member but it is, in my opinion, the subject - complaint from a member but it is, in my opinion, the subject - that in my opinion, the subject - that the in my opinion, the subject - that the subject in my opinion, the subject - that the subject is in my opinion, the subject - that the subject is sufficiently the subject is sufficiently important the subject is sufficiently important to the subject is sufficiently important to exercise the subject is sufficiently important to exercise my the subject is sufficiently important to exercise my authority important to exercise my authority under important to exercise my authority under Standing important to exercise my authority under Standing Order important to exercise my authority under Standing Order 414. important to exercise my authority under Standing Order 414. The under Standing Order 414. The decision under Standing Order 414. The decision in under Standing Order 414. The decision in Staples under Standing Order 414. The decision in Staples versus under Standing Order 414. The decision in Staples versus Freeman decision in Staples versus Freeman 2021 decision in Staples versus Freeman 2021 New decision in Staples versus Freeman 2021 New Zealand decision in Staples versus Freeman 2021 New Zealand High decision in Staples versus Freeman 2021 New Zealand High Court decision in Staples versus Freeman 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 4 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 4 June 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 4 June 2021 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 4 June 2021 relates 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 4 June 2021 relates to 2021 New Zealand High Court 1308 dated 4 June 2021 relates to an dated 4 June 2021 relates to an action dated 4 June 2021 relates to an action for dated 4 June 2021 relates to an action for defamation dated 4 June 2021 relates to an action for defamation and action for defamation and substantively action for defamation and substantively considers action for defamation and substantively considers a action for defamation and substantively considers a speech substantively considers a speech made substantively considers a speech made in substantively considers a speech made in the substantively considers a speech made in the House substantively considers a speech made in the House on substantively considers a speech made in the House on 23 substantively considers a speech made in the House on 23 July substantively considers a speech made in the House on 23 July 2014. made in the House on 23 July 2014. The made in the House on 23 July 2014. The issue made in the House on 23 July 2014. The issue for made in the House on 23 July 2014. The issue for consideration made in the House on 23 July 2014. The issue for consideration by made in the House on 23 July 2014. The issue for consideration by the The issue for consideration by the Privileges The issue for consideration by the Privileges Committee The issue for consideration by the Privileges Committee is The issue for consideration by the Privileges Committee is whether The issue for consideration by the Privileges Committee is whether the Privileges Committee is whether the court's Privileges Committee is whether the court's treatment Privileges Committee is whether the court's treatment of Privileges Committee is whether the court's treatment of the Privileges Committee is whether the court's treatment of the member's court's treatment of the member's speech court's treatment of the member's speech in court's treatment of the member's speech in its court's treatment of the member's speech in its determination court's treatment of the member's speech in its determination of court's treatment of the member's speech in its determination of the speech in its determination of the action speech in its determination of the action for speech in its determination of the action for defamation speech in its determination of the action for defamation compromises action for defamation compromises the action for defamation compromises the House's action for defamation compromises the House's privilege action for defamation compromises the House's privilege if action for defamation compromises the House's privilege if free action for defamation compromises the House's privilege if free speech the House's privilege if free speech is the House's privilege if free speech is described the House's privilege if free speech is described in the House's privilege if free speech is described in the the House's privilege if free speech is described in the Parliamentary is described in the Parliamentary Privilege is described in the Parliamentary Privilege Act is described in the Parliamentary Privilege Act 2014 is described in the Parliamentary Privilege Act 2014 and is described in the Parliamentary Privilege Act 2014 and in is described in the Parliamentary Privilege Act 2014 and in article is described in the Parliamentary Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 of Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 of the Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 of the Bill Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 of the Bill of Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 of the Bill of Rights. Privilege Act 2014 and in article 9 of the Bill of Rights. The of the Bill of Rights. The Privileges of the Bill of Rights. The Privileges Committee of the Bill of Rights. The Privileges Committee is of the Bill of Rights. The Privileges Committee is the of the Bill of Rights. The Privileges Committee is the body Privileges Committee is the body that Privileges Committee is the body that is Privileges Committee is the body that is House Privileges Committee is the body that is House has Privileges Committee is the body that is House has established Privileges Committee is the body that is House has established to that is House has established to investigate that is House has established to investigate such that is House has established to investigate such matters. that is House has established to investigate such matters. It that is House has established to investigate such matters. It has that is House has established to investigate such matters. It has the investigate such matters. It has the power investigate such matters. It has the power to investigate such matters. It has the power to hear investigate such matters. It has the power to hear evidence investigate such matters. It has the power to hear evidence and investigate such matters. It has the power to hear evidence and to power to hear evidence and to formulate power to hear evidence and to formulate recommendations power to hear evidence and to formulate recommendations for power to hear evidence and to formulate recommendations for the formulate recommendations for the House formulate recommendations for the House that formulate recommendations for the House that will formulate recommendations for the House that will provide formulate recommendations for the House that will provide guidance formulate recommendations for the House that will provide guidance for House that will provide guidance for the House that will provide guidance for the future. House that will provide guidance for the future. No House that will provide guidance for the future. No bills House that will provide guidance for the future. No bills have House that will provide guidance for the future. No bills have been the future. No bills have been introduced. the the future. the future. No the future. No bills the future. No bills have the future. No bills have been the future. No bills have been introduced. Petitions Petitions have Petitions have been Petitions have been delivered Petitions have been delivered to Petitions have been delivered to the Petitions have been delivered to the Clerk Petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for Petitions have been delivered to the Clerk for presentation. to the Clerk for presentation. Petition to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of Alexandra to the Clerk for presentation. Petition of Alexandra Johnston Petition of Alexandra Johnston requesting Petition of Alexandra Johnston requesting that Petition of Alexandra Johnston requesting that the Petition of Alexandra Johnston requesting that the House Petition of Alexandra Johnston requesting that the House amend requesting that the House amend the requesting that the House amend the Dog requesting that the House amend the Dog Control requesting that the House amend the Dog Control Act requesting that the House amend the Dog Control Act 1996 requesting that the House amend the Dog Control Act 1996 to requesting that the House amend the Dog Control Act 1996 to give the Dog Control Act 1996 to give courts the Dog Control Act 1996 to give courts more the Dog Control Act 1996 to give courts more discretion the Dog Control Act 1996 to give courts more discretion when the Dog Control Act 1996 to give courts more discretion when ordering courts more discretion when ordering the courts more discretion when ordering the destruction courts more discretion when ordering the destruction of courts more discretion when ordering the destruction of a courts more discretion when ordering the destruction of a dog courts more discretion when ordering the destruction of a dog that courts more discretion when ordering the destruction of a dog that has the destruction of a dog that has made the destruction of a dog that has made an the destruction of a dog that has made an attack the destruction of a dog that has made an attack under the destruction of a dog that has made an attack under section the destruction of a dog that has made an attack under section 57 the destruction of a dog that has made an attack under section 57 (1), made an attack under section 57 (1), or made an attack under section 57 (1), or to made an attack under section 57 (1), or to provide made an attack under section 57 (1), or to provide three made an attack under section 57 (1), or to provide three chances made an attack under section 57 (1), or to provide three chances for made an attack under section 57 (1), or to provide three chances for dogs or to provide three chances for dogs if or to provide three chances for dogs if the or to provide three chances for dogs if the first or to provide three chances for dogs if the first and or to provide three chances for dogs if the first and second or to provide three chances for dogs if the first and second attacks if the first and second attacks were if the first and second attacks were not if the first and second attacks were not fatal if the first and second attacks were not fatal or if the first and second attacks were not fatal or against if the first and second attacks were not fatal or against a if the first and second attacks were not fatal or against a person. were not fatal or against a person. Petition were not fatal or against a person. Petition of were not fatal or against a person. Petition of Degu were not fatal or against a person. Petition of Degu Geddebo were not fatal or against a person. Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting that Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting that the Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting that the House Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting that the House urge Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting that the House urge the Petition of Degu Geddebo requesting that the House urge the Government that the House urge the Government to that the House urge the Government to condemn that the House urge the Government to condemn the that the House urge the Government to condemn the ongoing that the House urge the Government to condemn the ongoing atrocities to condemn the ongoing atrocities of to condemn the ongoing atrocities of the to condemn the ongoing atrocities of the Amhara to condemn the ongoing atrocities of the Amhara ethnic to condemn the ongoing atrocities of the Amhara ethnic group of the Amhara ethnic group in of the Amhara ethnic group in Ethiopia, of the Amhara ethnic group in Ethiopia, and of the Amhara ethnic group in Ethiopia, and urge in Ethiopia, and urge the in Ethiopia, and urge the Ethiopian in Ethiopia, and urge the Ethiopian Government in Ethiopia, and urge the Ethiopian Government to in Ethiopia, and urge the Ethiopian Government to prevent the Ethiopian Government to prevent further the Ethiopian Government to prevent further human the Ethiopian Government to prevent further human rights the Ethiopian Government to prevent further human rights violations further human rights violations against further human rights violations against the further human rights violations against the vulnerable further human rights violations against the vulnerable Amhara against the vulnerable Amhara and against the vulnerable Amhara and other against the vulnerable Amhara and other ethnic against the vulnerable Amhara and other ethnic minority against the vulnerable Amhara and other ethnic minority groups and other ethnic minority groups residing and other ethnic minority groups residing in and other ethnic minority groups residing in different and other ethnic minority groups residing in different regions. residing in different regions. Petition residing in different regions. Petition of residing in different regions. Petition of Arya residing in different regions. Petition of Arya Nair residing in different regions. Petition of Arya Nair requesting Petition of Arya Nair requesting that Petition of Arya Nair requesting that the Petition of Arya Nair requesting that the House Petition of Arya Nair requesting that the House urge Petition of Arya Nair requesting that the House urge the Petition of Arya Nair requesting that the House urge the Government that the House urge the Government to that the House urge the Government to give that the House urge the Government to give special that the House urge the Government to give special consideration to give special consideration to to give special consideration to registered to give special consideration to registered nurses to give special consideration to registered nurses (with to give special consideration to registered nurses (with permanent to registered nurses (with permanent residence) to registered nurses (with permanent residence) when to registered nurses (with permanent residence) when determining residence) when determining whether residence) when determining whether our residence) when determining whether our partners residence) when determining whether our partners are residence) when determining whether our partners are eligible whether our partners are eligible for whether our partners are eligible for partners' whether our partners are eligible for partners' visas, for partners' visas, including for partners' visas, including when for partners' visas, including when we for partners' visas, including when we do for partners' visas, including when we do not for partners' visas, including when we do not meet including when we do not meet the including when we do not meet the living-together including when we do not meet the living-together requirement. the living-together requirement. Petition the living-together requirement. Petition of the living-together requirement. Petition of Ehab the living-together requirement. Petition of Ehab Takawi the living-together requirement. Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the House Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the House urge Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the House urge the Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the House urge the PM Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the House urge the PM to Petition of Ehab Takawi requesting that the House urge the PM to remove that the House urge the PM to remove the that the House urge the PM to remove the Hon that the House urge the PM to remove the Hon Kris that the House urge the PM to remove the Hon Kris Faafoi the Hon Kris Faafoi as the Hon Kris Faafoi as Immigration the Hon Kris Faafoi as Immigration Minister. as Immigration Minister. Those as Immigration Minister. Those petitions as Immigration Minister. Those petitions stand as Immigration Minister. Those petitions stand referred Those petitions stand referred to Those petitions stand referred to a Those petitions stand referred to a select Those petitions stand referred to a select committee Those petitions stand referred to a select committee allocated to a select committee allocated by to a select committee allocated by the to a select committee allocated by the Clerk. Ministers Ministers have Ministers have delivered Ministers have delivered papers. The The member The member must The member must not The member must not take The member must not take leave The member must not take leave of The member must not take leave of that The member must not take leave of that action. The member must not take leave of that action. The The member must not take leave of that action. The Clerk. The member must not take leave of that action. The Clerk. Te The member must not take leave of that action. The Clerk. Te Takawa that action. The Clerk. Te Takawa Mataho that action. The Clerk. Te Takawa Mataho strategic that action. The Clerk. Te Takawa Mataho strategic directions. Mataho strategic directions. Southern Mataho strategic directions. Southern earth Mataho strategic directions. Southern earth -- Mataho strategic directions. Southern earth -- statement Mataho strategic directions. Southern earth -- statement of Southern earth -- statement of intent Southern earth -- statement of intent for Southern earth -- statement of intent for financial Southern earth -- statement of intent for financial years Southern earth -- statement of intent for financial years 2022 Southern earth -- statement of intent for financial years 2022 to intent for financial years 2022 to 2026. intent for financial years 2022 to 2026. Transport intent for financial years 2022 to 2026. Transport Accident 2026. Transport Accident Investigation 2026. Transport Accident Investigation Commission 2026. Transport Accident Investigation Commission statement Investigation Commission statement of Investigation Commission statement of performance Investigation Commission statement of performance expectations Investigation Commission statement of performance expectations 2021/22 of performance expectations 2021/22 and of performance expectations 2021/22 and statement of performance expectations 2021/22 and statement of of performance expectations 2021/22 and statement of intent of performance expectations 2021/22 and statement of intent 2021 of performance expectations 2021/22 and statement of intent 2021 to of performance expectations 2021/22 and statement of intent 2021 to 25. and statement of intent 2021 to 25. Those and statement of intent 2021 to 25. Those papers and statement of intent 2021 to 25. Those papers are and statement of intent 2021 to 25. Those papers are published and statement of intent 2021 to 25. Those papers are published under and statement of intent 2021 to 25. Those papers are published under the Those papers are published under the authority Those papers are published under the authority of Those papers are published under the authority of the Those papers are published under the authority of the House. Select Select committee Select committee reports Select committee reports have Select committee reports have been Select committee reports have been delivered Select committee reports have been delivered for Select committee reports have been delivered for presentation. delivered for presentation. Report delivered for presentation. Report of delivered for presentation. Report of the delivered for presentation. Report of the Environment delivered for presentation. Report of the Environment Committee Report of the Environment Committee on Report of the Environment Committee on the Report of the Environment Committee on the petition Report of the Environment Committee on the petition of Report of the Environment Committee on the petition of Erin on the petition of Erin Hampson-Tindale: Hampson-Tindale: report Hampson-Tindale: report of Hampson-Tindale: report of the Hampson-Tindale: report of the Foreign Hampson-Tindale: report of the Foreign Affairs, report of the Foreign Affairs, Defence report of the Foreign Affairs, Defence and report of the Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade report of the Foreign Affairs, Defence and Trade Committee Defence and Trade Committee on Defence and Trade Committee on the Defence and Trade Committee on the Intelligence Defence and Trade Committee on the Intelligence and Defence and Trade Committee on the Intelligence and Security on the Intelligence and Security (Review) on the Intelligence and Security (Review) Amendment on the Intelligence and Security (Review) Amendment Bill, (Review) Amendment Bill, report (Review) Amendment Bill, report of (Review) Amendment Bill, report of the (Review) Amendment Bill, report of the Governance report of the Governance and report of the Governance and Administration report of the Governance and Administration Committee and Administration Committee on and Administration Committee on the and Administration Committee on the Office and Administration Committee on the Office of and Administration Committee on the Office of the and Administration Committee on the Office of the Ombudsman, on the Office of the Ombudsman, report on the Office of the Ombudsman, report on on the Office of the Ombudsman, report on Local on the Office of the Ombudsman, report on Local Government on the Office of the Ombudsman, report on Local Government Official report on Local Government Official Information report on Local Government Official Information and report on Local Government Official Information and Meeting report on Local Government Official Information and Meeting Act Information and Meeting Act compliance Information and Meeting Act compliance and Information and Meeting Act compliance and practice, compliance and practice, Porirua compliance and practice, Porirua City compliance and practice, Porirua City Council, Porirua City Council, report Porirua City Council, report of Porirua City Council, report of the Porirua City Council, report of the Health Porirua City Council, report of the Health Committee report of the Health Committee on report of the Health Committee on the report of the Health Committee on the petition report of the Health Committee on the petition of report of the Health Committee on the petition of Nancy report of the Health Committee on the petition of Nancy Loucas on the petition of Nancy Loucas Sutthoff Sutthoff for Sutthoff for Aotearoa Sutthoff for Aotearoa Vapers for Aotearoa Vapers Community for Aotearoa Vapers Community Advocacy, Community Advocacy, Debate Community Advocacy, Debate proposal Community Advocacy, Debate proposal to Community Advocacy, Debate proposal to ban Community Advocacy, Debate proposal to ban flavours Debate proposal to ban flavours for Debate proposal to ban flavours for nicotine Debate proposal to ban flavours for nicotine e-liquid, for nicotine e-liquid, report for nicotine e-liquid, report of for nicotine e-liquid, report of the for nicotine e-liquid, report of the Petitions for nicotine e-liquid, report of the Petitions Committee report of the Petitions Committee on report of the Petitions Committee on the report of the Petitions Committee on the petition report of the Petitions Committee on the petition of report of the Petitions Committee on the petition of Andy report of the Petitions Committee on the petition of Andy Earl on the petition of Andy Earl for on the petition of Andy Earl for AE on the petition of Andy Earl for AE Insurance, for AE Insurance, reinstate for AE Insurance, reinstate Upgrade for AE Insurance, reinstate Upgrade on for AE Insurance, reinstate Upgrade on SH2 reinstate Upgrade on SH2 Tauranga reinstate Upgrade on SH2 Tauranga to reinstate Upgrade on SH2 Tauranga to Katikati, Tauranga to Katikati, prioritise Tauranga to Katikati, prioritise capacity Tauranga to Katikati, prioritise capacity and Tauranga to Katikati, prioritise capacity and safety, prioritise capacity and safety, report prioritise capacity and safety, report of prioritise capacity and safety, report of the prioritise capacity and safety, report of the Primary prioritise capacity and safety, report of the Primary Production report of the Primary Production Committee Committee on Committee on the Committee on the briefing Committee on the briefing into Committee on the briefing into Optimus Committee on the briefing into Optimus Group, on the briefing into Optimus Group, reports on the briefing into Optimus Group, reports of on the briefing into Optimus Group, reports of the on the briefing into Optimus Group, reports of the Transport reports of the Transport and reports of the Transport and Infrastructure reports of the Transport and Infrastructure Committee and Infrastructure Committee on and Infrastructure Committee on the and Infrastructure Committee on the Land and Infrastructure Committee on the Land Transport on the Land Transport (Drug on the Land Transport (Drug Driving) on the Land Transport (Drug Driving) Amendment on the Land Transport (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill, (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill, petition (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill, petition of (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill, petition of Barbara (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill, petition of Barbara Kuriger, petition of Barbara Kuriger, build petition of Barbara Kuriger, build a petition of Barbara Kuriger, build a roundabout petition of Barbara Kuriger, build a roundabout at petition of Barbara Kuriger, build a roundabout at the petition of Barbara Kuriger, build a roundabout at the Whatawhata build a roundabout at the Whatawhata State build a roundabout at the Whatawhata State Highway build a roundabout at the Whatawhata State Highway intersection, State Highway intersection, report State Highway intersection, report of State Highway intersection, report of the State Highway intersection, report of the Attorney-General report of the Attorney-General under report of the Attorney-General under the report of the Attorney-General under the New report of the Attorney-General under the New Zealand report of the Attorney-General under the New Zealand Bill report of the Attorney-General under the New Zealand Bill of report of the Attorney-General under the New Zealand Bill of Rights under the New Zealand Bill of Rights ACT under the New Zealand Bill of Rights ACT 1990 ACT 1990 on ACT 1990 on the ACT 1990 on the Land ACT 1990 on the Land Transport ACT 1990 on the Land Transport (Drug ACT 1990 on the Land Transport (Drug Driving) on the Land Transport (Drug Driving) Amendment on the Land Transport (Drug Driving) Amendment Bill. Amendment Bill. The Amendment Bill. The bills Amendment Bill. The bills are Amendment Bill. The bills are set Amendment Bill. The bills are set down The bills are set down for The bills are set down for second The bills are set down for second reading. for second reading. The for second reading. The reports for second reading. The reports on for second reading. The reports on the for second reading. The reports on the Ombudsman's for second reading. The reports on the Ombudsman's ask The reports on the Ombudsman's ask report The reports on the Ombudsman's ask report and The reports on the Ombudsman's ask report and the The reports on the Ombudsman's ask report and the briefing The reports on the Ombudsman's ask report and the briefing are The reports on the Ombudsman's ask report and the briefing are set report and the briefing are set down report and the briefing are set down for report and the briefing are set down for consideration. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Finance: My question is to the Minister of Finance: What My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent reports My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent reports has My question is to the Minister of Finance: What recent reports has he The The Government's The Government's eff The Government's eff years The Government's eff years to The Government's eff years to secure The Government's eff years to secure our The Government's eff years to secure our recovery The Government's eff years to secure our recovery have The Government's eff years to secure our recovery have been The Government's eff years to secure our recovery have been reflected The Government's eff years to secure our recovery have been reflected in our recovery have been reflected in the our recovery have been reflected in the latest our recovery have been reflected in the latest measure our recovery have been reflected in the latest measure of our recovery have been reflected in the latest measure of the our recovery have been reflected in the latest measure of the country's the latest measure of the country's economic the latest measure of the country's economic health. the latest measure of the country's economic health. Statistics the latest measure of the country's economic health. Statistics NZ economic health. Statistics NZ reported economic health. Statistics NZ reported last economic health. Statistics NZ reported last week economic health. Statistics NZ reported last week that economic health. Statistics NZ reported last week that GDP economic health. Statistics NZ reported last week that GDP rose economic health. Statistics NZ reported last week that GDP rose by reported last week that GDP rose by 1.6% reported last week that GDP rose by 1.6% for reported last week that GDP rose by 1.6% for the reported last week that GDP rose by 1.6% for the March reported last week that GDP rose by 1.6% for the March 2021 reported last week that GDP rose by 1.6% for the March 2021 quarter 1.6% for the March 2021 quarter exceeding 1.6% for the March 2021 quarter exceeding the 1.6% for the March 2021 quarter exceeding the expectations 1.6% for the March 2021 quarter exceeding the expectations of 1.6% for the March 2021 quarter exceeding the expectations of even exceeding the expectations of even the exceeding the expectations of even the most exceeding the expectations of even the most optimistic exceeding the expectations of even the most optimistic commentators. the most optimistic commentators. New the most optimistic commentators. New Zealanders' the most optimistic commentators. New Zealanders' confidence the most optimistic commentators. New Zealanders' confidence in the most optimistic commentators. New Zealanders' confidence in the New Zealanders' confidence in the recovery New Zealanders' confidence in the recovery saw New Zealanders' confidence in the recovery saw a New Zealanders' confidence in the recovery saw a boost New Zealanders' confidence in the recovery saw a boost in New Zealanders' confidence in the recovery saw a boost in retail recovery saw a boost in retail spending recovery saw a boost in retail spending particularly recovery saw a boost in retail spending particularly on recovery saw a boost in retail spending particularly on big recovery saw a boost in retail spending particularly on big ticket spending particularly on big ticket household spending particularly on big ticket household items spending particularly on big ticket household items and spending particularly on big ticket household items and holiday household items and holiday accommodation. household items and holiday accommodation. The household items and holiday accommodation. The construction accommodation. The construction sector accommodation. The construction sector returned accommodation. The construction sector returned to accommodation. The construction sector returned to near accommodation. The construction sector returned to near level accommodation. The construction sector returned to near level record sector returned to near level record levels sector returned to near level record levels and sector returned to near level record levels and business sector returned to near level record levels and business investment sector returned to near level record levels and business investment in levels and business investment in plant levels and business investment in plant and levels and business investment in plant and machinery levels and business investment in plant and machinery jumped levels and business investment in plant and machinery jumped by levels and business investment in plant and machinery jumped by rover plant and machinery jumped by rover 15%. plant and machinery jumped by rover 15%. The plant and machinery jumped by rover 15%. The higher plant and machinery jumped by rover 15%. The higher COVID-19 plant and machinery jumped by rover 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels during 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels during the 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels during the quarter 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels during the quarter only 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels during the quarter only had 15%. The higher COVID-19 alert levels during the quarter only had a levels during the quarter only had a limited levels during the quarter only had a limited impact levels during the quarter only had a limited impact on levels during the quarter only had a limited impact on the levels during the quarter only had a limited impact on the recovery limited impact on the recovery thanks limited impact on the recovery thanks to limited impact on the recovery thanks to a limited impact on the recovery thanks to a quick limited impact on the recovery thanks to a quick response limited impact on the recovery thanks to a quick response that thanks to a quick response that provided thanks to a quick response that provided cash thanks to a quick response that provided cash flow thanks to a quick response that provided cash flow and thanks to a quick response that provided cash flow and confidence. provided cash flow and confidence. Quarterly provided cash flow and confidence. Quarterly activity provided cash flow and confidence. Quarterly activity in provided cash flow and confidence. Quarterly activity in March provided cash flow and confidence. Quarterly activity in March has provided cash flow and confidence. Quarterly activity in March has now Quarterly activity in March has now exceeded Quarterly activity in March has now exceeded the Quarterly activity in March has now exceeded the December Quarterly activity in March has now exceeded the December 2019 Quarterly activity in March has now exceeded the December 2019 quarter exceeded the December 2019 quarter pre-pandemic exceeded the December 2019 quarter pre-pandemic level. exceeded the December 2019 quarter pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless exceeded the December 2019 quarter pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the data pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the data does pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the data does show pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the data does show the pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the data does show the volatility pre-pandemic level. Nevertheless the data does show the volatility that data does show the volatility that New data does show the volatility that New Zealand data does show the volatility that New Zealand has data does show the volatility that New Zealand has to data does show the volatility that New Zealand has to deal data does show the volatility that New Zealand has to deal with data does show the volatility that New Zealand has to deal with during New Zealand has to deal with during the New Zealand has to deal with during the pandemic. New Zealand has to deal with during the pandemic. This New Zealand has to deal with during the pandemic. This 1.6% New Zealand has to deal with during the pandemic. This 1.6% increase the pandemic. This 1.6% increase followed the pandemic. This 1.6% increase followed a the pandemic. This 1.6% increase followed a 1% the pandemic. This 1.6% increase followed a 1% decline the pandemic. This 1.6% increase followed a 1% decline in the pandemic. This 1.6% increase followed a 1% decline in the followed a 1% decline in the December followed a 1% decline in the December quarter followed a 1% decline in the December quarter and followed a 1% decline in the December quarter and a followed a 1% decline in the December quarter and a record followed a 1% decline in the December quarter and a record 14.1% December quarter and a record 14.1% increase December quarter and a record 14.1% increase in December quarter and a record 14.1% increase in the December quarter and a record 14.1% increase in the September December quarter and a record 14.1% increase in the September quarter. Supplementary. Supplementary. How Supplementary. How does Supplementary. How does New Supplementary. How does New Zealand's Supplementary. How does New Zealand's economic Supplementary. How does New Zealand's economic performance Zealand's economic performance compare Zealand's economic performance compare with Zealand's economic performance compare with other Zealand's economic performance compare with other countries? Zealand's economic performance compare with other countries? This compare with other countries? This result compare with other countries? This result is compare with other countries? This result is further compare with other countries? This result is further evidence compare with other countries? This result is further evidence that compare with other countries? This result is further evidence that our result is further evidence that our public result is further evidence that our public health result is further evidence that our public health strategy result is further evidence that our public health strategy of result is further evidence that our public health strategy of going result is further evidence that our public health strategy of going hard public health strategy of going hard and public health strategy of going hard and early public health strategy of going hard and early to public health strategy of going hard and early to beat public health strategy of going hard and early to beat COVID public health strategy of going hard and early to beat COVID was public health strategy of going hard and early to beat COVID was also public health strategy of going hard and early to beat COVID was also the and early to beat COVID was also the correct and early to beat COVID was also the correct response and early to beat COVID was also the correct response for and early to beat COVID was also the correct response for the and early to beat COVID was also the correct response for the economy. correct response for the economy. Getting correct response for the economy. Getting our correct response for the economy. Getting our economy correct response for the economy. Getting our economy back correct response for the economy. Getting our economy back up correct response for the economy. Getting our economy back up and Getting our economy back up and running Getting our economy back up and running either Getting our economy back up and running either without Getting our economy back up and running either without COVID Getting our economy back up and running either without COVID in Getting our economy back up and running either without COVID in the running either without COVID in the community running either without COVID in the community has running either without COVID in the community has meant running either without COVID in the community has meant households running either without COVID in the community has meant households and community has meant households and businesses community has meant households and businesses can community has meant households and businesses can move community has meant households and businesses can move about community has meant households and businesses can move about and businesses can move about and operate businesses can move about and operate more businesses can move about and operate more freely businesses can move about and operate more freely than businesses can move about and operate more freely than in businesses can move about and operate more freely than in many operate more freely than in many other operate more freely than in many other countries. operate more freely than in many other countries. The operate more freely than in many other countries. The New operate more freely than in many other countries. The New Zealand other countries. The New Zealand economy other countries. The New Zealand economy was other countries. The New Zealand economy was 2.4% other countries. The New Zealand economy was 2.4% above other countries. The New Zealand economy was 2.4% above where other countries. The New Zealand economy was 2.4% above where it other countries. The New Zealand economy was 2.4% above where it was economy was 2.4% above where it was in economy was 2.4% above where it was in the economy was 2.4% above where it was in the March economy was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter economy was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter last economy was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter last year economy was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter last year out in the March quarter last year out performing in the March quarter last year out performing the in the March quarter last year out performing the countries in the March quarter last year out performing the countries we in the March quarter last year out performing the countries we compare performing the countries we compare our performing the countries we compare our self-s performing the countries we compare our self-s with. performing the countries we compare our self-s with. In performing the countries we compare our self-s with. In the performing the countries we compare our self-s with. In the same performing the countries we compare our self-s with. In the same period our self-s with. In the same period Australia our self-s with. In the same period Australia rose our self-s with. In the same period Australia rose by our self-s with. In the same period Australia rose by 1.1%, our self-s with. In the same period Australia rose by 1.1%, the our self-s with. In the same period Australia rose by 1.1%, the United Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States by Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States by 0.4%, Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States by 0.4%, Canada Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States by 0.4%, Canada by Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% Australia rose by 1.1%, the United States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while Japan States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while Japan declined States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while Japan declined by States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while Japan declined by 1.5% States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while Japan declined by 1.5% and States by 0.4%, Canada by 0.3% while Japan declined by 1.5% and the Japan declined by 1.5% and the United Japan declined by 1.5% and the United Kingdom Japan declined by 1.5% and the United Kingdom by Japan declined by 1.5% and the United Kingdom by 6.1%. Japan declined by 1.5% and the United Kingdom by 6.1%. The Japan declined by 1.5% and the United Kingdom by 6.1%. The global United Kingdom by 6.1%. The global economy United Kingdom by 6.1%. The global economy is United Kingdom by 6.1%. The global economy is recovering United Kingdom by 6.1%. The global economy is recovering but United Kingdom by 6.1%. The global economy is recovering but the economy is recovering but the ongoing economy is recovering but the ongoing and economy is recovering but the ongoing and uneven economy is recovering but the ongoing and uneven impact economy is recovering but the ongoing and uneven impact of ongoing and uneven impact of COVID-19 ongoing and uneven impact of COVID-19 means ongoing and uneven impact of COVID-19 means that ongoing and uneven impact of COVID-19 means that the ongoing and uneven impact of COVID-19 means that the environment COVID-19 means that the environment will COVID-19 means that the environment will remain COVID-19 means that the environment will remain volatile COVID-19 means that the environment will remain volatile for COVID-19 means that the environment will remain volatile for some COVID-19 means that the environment will remain volatile for some time. will remain volatile for some time. What will remain volatile for some time. What reactions will remain volatile for some time. What reactions has will remain volatile for some time. What reactions has he will remain volatile for some time. What reactions has he seen will remain volatile for some time. What reactions has he seen to will remain volatile for some time. What reactions has he seen to the What reactions has he seen to the GDP What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? We What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? We are What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? We are doing What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? We are doing it What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? We are doing it in What reactions has he seen to the GDP report? We are doing it in real GDP report? We are doing it in real time GDP report? We are doing it in real time here GDP report? We are doing it in real time here but GDP report? We are doing it in real time here but previous GDP report? We are doing it in real time here but previous three GDP report? We are doing it in real time here but previous three ANZ time here but previous three ANZ economists time here but previous three ANZ economists called time here but previous three ANZ economists called the time here but previous three ANZ economists called the result time here but previous three ANZ economists called the result eye economists called the result eye popping economists called the result eye popping and economists called the result eye popping and noted economists called the result eye popping and noted that economists called the result eye popping and noted that "the economists called the result eye popping and noted that "the rise economists called the result eye popping and noted that "the rise in popping and noted that "the rise in GDP popping and noted that "the rise in GDP confirms popping and noted that "the rise in GDP confirms that popping and noted that "the rise in GDP confirms that New popping and noted that "the rise in GDP confirms that New Zealand popping and noted that "the rise in GDP confirms that New Zealand has GDP confirms that New Zealand has seen GDP confirms that New Zealand has seen a GDP confirms that New Zealand has seen a spectacular GDP confirms that New Zealand has seen a spectacular economic seen a spectacular economic recovery." seen a spectacular economic recovery." That seen a spectacular economic recovery." That sentiment seen a spectacular economic recovery." That sentiment was recovery." That sentiment was reflected recovery." That sentiment was reflected in recovery." That sentiment was reflected in other recovery." That sentiment was reflected in other commentaries. reflected in other commentaries. Kiwi reflected in other commentaries. Kiwi Bank reflected in other commentaries. Kiwi Bank said, reflected in other commentaries. Kiwi Bank said, "The reflected in other commentaries. Kiwi Bank said, "The report reflected in other commentaries. Kiwi Bank said, "The report was Kiwi Bank said, "The report was stronger Kiwi Bank said, "The report was stronger than Kiwi Bank said, "The report was stronger than expected Kiwi Bank said, "The report was stronger than expected pretty Kiwi Bank said, "The report was stronger than expected pretty much stronger than expected pretty much across stronger than expected pretty much across the stronger than expected pretty much across the board stronger than expected pretty much across the board and stronger than expected pretty much across the board and the stronger than expected pretty much across the board and the economy stronger than expected pretty much across the board and the economy has across the board and the economy has confidently across the board and the economy has confidently returned across the board and the economy has confidently returned to across the board and the economy has confidently returned to pre-COVID confidently returned to pre-COVID levels." confidently returned to pre-COVID levels." As confidently returned to pre-COVID levels." As the confidently returned to pre-COVID levels." As the ASB confidently returned to pre-COVID levels." As the ASB noted, confidently returned to pre-COVID levels." As the ASB noted, "The levels." As the ASB noted, "The sheer levels." As the ASB noted, "The sheer unexpected levels." As the ASB noted, "The sheer unexpected strength levels." As the ASB noted, "The sheer unexpected strength of levels." As the ASB noted, "The sheer unexpected strength of quarter sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP growth sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP growth adds sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP growth adds to sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP growth adds to the sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP growth adds to the weight sheer unexpected strength of quarter 1 GDP growth adds to the weight of 1 GDP growth adds to the weight of evidence 1 GDP growth adds to the weight of evidence that 1 GDP growth adds to the weight of evidence that the 1 GDP growth adds to the weight of evidence that the New 1 GDP growth adds to the weight of evidence that the New Zealand evidence that the New Zealand economy evidence that the New Zealand economy is evidence that the New Zealand economy is on evidence that the New Zealand economy is on very evidence that the New Zealand economy is on very firm evidence that the New Zealand economy is on very firm footing economy is on very firm footing despite economy is on very firm footing despite the economy is on very firm footing despite the global economy is on very firm footing despite the global pandemic." economy is on very firm footing despite the global pandemic." This despite the global pandemic." This Government's despite the global pandemic." This Government's economic despite the global pandemic." This Government's economic recovery despite the global pandemic." This Government's economic recovery plan Government's economic recovery plan is Government's economic recovery plan is working, Government's economic recovery plan is working, we Government's economic recovery plan is working, we are Government's economic recovery plan is working, we are supporting is working, we are supporting businesses is working, we are supporting businesses and is working, we are supporting businesses and workers is working, we are supporting businesses and workers to is working, we are supporting businesses and workers to succeed businesses and workers to succeed despite businesses and workers to succeed despite the businesses and workers to succeed despite the uncertainty businesses and workers to succeed despite the uncertainty of businesses and workers to succeed despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the naysayers despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the naysayers on despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the naysayers on the despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the naysayers on the other despite the uncertainty of COVID-19 and the naysayers on the other side and the naysayers on the other side of and the naysayers on the other side of the and the naysayers on the other side of the House. and the naysayers on the other side of the House. Question and the naysayers on the other side of the House. Question number22, of the House. Question number22, David of the House. Question number22, David Seymour. of the House. Question number22, David Seymour. On of the House. Question number22, David Seymour. On behalf of the House. Question number22, David Seymour. On behalf of of the House. Question number22, David Seymour. On behalf of Act of the House. Question number22, David Seymour. On behalf of Act I David Seymour. On behalf of Act I would David Seymour. On behalf of Act I would like David Seymour. On behalf of Act I would like to David Seymour. On behalf of Act I would like to congratulate David Seymour. On behalf of Act I would like to congratulate you David Seymour. On behalf of Act I would like to congratulate you on would like to congratulate you on becoming would like to congratulate you on becoming the would like to congratulate you on becoming the father would like to congratulate you on becoming the father of would like to congratulate you on becoming the father of the would like to congratulate you on becoming the father of the House. would like to congratulate you on becoming the father of the House. My becoming the father of the House. My question becoming the father of the House. My question is becoming the father of the House. My question is to becoming the father of the House. My question is to the becoming the father of the House. My question is to the PM. becoming the father of the House. My question is to the PM. ... becoming the father of the House. My question is to the PM. ... I'm question is to the PM. ... I'm tempted question is to the PM. ... I'm tempted to question is to the PM. ... I'm tempted to say question is to the PM. ... I'm tempted to say grandson question is to the PM. ... I'm tempted to say grandson or question is to the PM. ... I'm tempted to say grandson or something tempted to say grandson or something but tempted to say grandson or something but just tempted to say grandson or something but just keep tempted to say grandson or something but just keep going. tempted to say grandson or something but just keep going. All tempted to say grandson or something but just keep going. All righty but just keep going. All righty grandad. but just keep going. All righty grandad. He but just keep going. All righty grandad. He started but just keep going. All righty grandad. He started it! grandad. grandad. He grandad. He started grandad. He started it! My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by her Minister: Does she stand by her statement Minister: Does she stand by her statement that Minister: Does she stand by her statement that "A Minister: Does she stand by her statement that "A large Minister: Does she stand by her statement that "A large number Minister: Does she stand by her statement that "A large number of statement that "A large number of those statement that "A large number of those buyers statement that "A large number of those buyers of statement that "A large number of those buyers of those statement that "A large number of those buyers of those vehicles statement that "A large number of those buyers of those vehicles are those buyers of those vehicles are not those buyers of those vehicles are not using those buyers of those vehicles are not using them those buyers of those vehicles are not using them for those buyers of those vehicles are not using them for the those buyers of those vehicles are not using them for the legitimate not using them for the legitimate use?" The The Rt The Rt Hon The Rt Hon PM. The Rt Hon PM. I The Rt Hon PM. I stand The Rt Hon PM. I stand by The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making even The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making even though The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making even though I The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making even though I do The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making even though I do - The Rt Hon PM. I stand by the point I was making even though I do - I I was making even though I do - I will I was making even though I do - I will absolutely I was making even though I do - I will absolutely say I was making even though I do - I will absolutely say that I was making even though I do - I will absolutely say that I I was making even though I do - I will absolutely say that I think I was making even though I do - I will absolutely say that I think I will absolutely say that I think I could will absolutely say that I think I could have will absolutely say that I think I could have been will absolutely say that I think I could have been clearer will absolutely say that I think I could have been clearer in will absolutely say that I think I could have been clearer in the will absolutely say that I think I could have been clearer in the way will absolutely say that I think I could have been clearer in the way I could have been clearer in the way I made could have been clearer in the way I made it. could have been clearer in the way I made it. As could have been clearer in the way I made it. As a could have been clearer in the way I made it. As a Cabinet could have been clearer in the way I made it. As a Cabinet we could have been clearer in the way I made it. As a Cabinet we gave could have been clearer in the way I made it. As a Cabinet we gave full made it. As a Cabinet we gave full consideration made it. As a Cabinet we gave full consideration to made it. As a Cabinet we gave full consideration to the made it. As a Cabinet we gave full consideration to the option made it. As a Cabinet we gave full consideration to the option of consideration to the option of creating consideration to the option of creating a consideration to the option of creating a carve consideration to the option of creating a carve out consideration to the option of creating a carve out for consideration to the option of creating a carve out for those creating a carve out for those vehicles creating a carve out for those vehicles for creating a carve out for those vehicles for which creating a carve out for those vehicles for which there creating a carve out for those vehicles for which there currently vehicles for which there currently aren't vehicles for which there currently aren't equivalent vehicles for which there currently aren't equivalent low-emission aren't equivalent low-emission alternative aren't equivalent low-emission alternative options, aren't equivalent low-emission alternative options, where aren't equivalent low-emission alternative options, where those alternative options, where those vehicles alternative options, where those vehicles were, alternative options, where those vehicles were, for alternative options, where those vehicles were, for instance, alternative options, where those vehicles were, for instance, used vehicles were, for instance, used for vehicles were, for instance, used for business vehicles were, for instance, used for business or vehicles were, for instance, used for business or work vehicles were, for instance, used for business or work purposes, vehicles were, for instance, used for business or work purposes, as for business or work purposes, as the for business or work purposes, as the member for business or work purposes, as the member - for business or work purposes, as the member - and for business or work purposes, as the member - and I for business or work purposes, as the member - and I know for business or work purposes, as the member - and I know many for business or work purposes, as the member - and I know many in for business or work purposes, as the member - and I know many in this the member - and I know many in this House the member - and I know many in this House will the member - and I know many in this House will appreciate the member - and I know many in this House will appreciate drawing the member - and I know many in this House will appreciate drawing such the member - and I know many in this House will appreciate drawing such a House will appreciate drawing such a distinction, House will appreciate drawing such a distinction, does House will appreciate drawing such a distinction, does raise House will appreciate drawing such a distinction, does raise issues House will appreciate drawing such a distinction, does raise issues of distinction, does raise issues of fairness, distinction, does raise issues of fairness, consistency distinction, does raise issues of fairness, consistency and fairness, consistency and implementation. fairness, consistency and implementation. I fairness, consistency and implementation. I would fairness, consistency and implementation. I would make fairness, consistency and implementation. I would make the implementation. I would make the point implementation. I would make the point to implementation. I would make the point to the implementation. I would make the point to the member implementation. I would make the point to the member that implementation. I would make the point to the member that almost point to the member that almost two-thirds point to the member that almost two-thirds of point to the member that almost two-thirds of the point to the member that almost two-thirds of the utes point to the member that almost two-thirds of the utes sold point to the member that almost two-thirds of the utes sold in point to the member that almost two-thirds of the utes sold in New two-thirds of the utes sold in New Zealand two-thirds of the utes sold in New Zealand last two-thirds of the utes sold in New Zealand last year two-thirds of the utes sold in New Zealand last year would two-thirds of the utes sold in New Zealand last year would not two-thirds of the utes sold in New Zealand last year would not be Zealand last year would not be covered Zealand last year would not be covered by Zealand last year would not be covered by this Zealand last year would not be covered by this policy Zealand last year would not be covered by this policy as Zealand last year would not be covered by this policy as they Zealand last year would not be covered by this policy as they were covered by this policy as they were part covered by this policy as they were part of covered by this policy as they were part of the covered by this policy as they were part of the existing covered by this policy as they were part of the existing second-hand part of the existing second-hand market. part of the existing second-hand market. We part of the existing second-hand market. We also part of the existing second-hand market. We also expect part of the existing second-hand market. We also expect new part of the existing second-hand market. We also expect new models part of the existing second-hand market. We also expect new models to market. We also expect new models to become market. We also expect new models to become available market. We also expect new models to become available over market. We also expect new models to become available over time. become available over time. Supplementary. become available over time. Supplementary. So become available over time. Supplementary. So as become available over time. Supplementary. So as the become available over time. Supplementary. So as the feed become available over time. Supplementary. So as the feed back Supplementary. So as the feed back policy Supplementary. So as the feed back policy was Supplementary. So as the feed back policy was finalised Supplementary. So as the feed back policy was finalised with Supplementary. So as the feed back policy was finalised with that policy was finalised with that advice, policy was finalised with that advice, will policy was finalised with that advice, will people policy was finalised with that advice, will people who policy was finalised with that advice, will people who are policy was finalised with that advice, will people who are use policy was finalised with that advice, will people who are use Agut advice, will people who are use Agut for advice, will people who are use Agut for their advice, will people who are use Agut for their -- advice, will people who are use Agut for their -- a advice, will people who are use Agut for their -- a ute advice, will people who are use Agut for their -- a ute for advice, will people who are use Agut for their -- a ute for their for their -- a ute for their legitimate for their -- a ute for their legitimate use for their -- a ute for their legitimate use still for their -- a ute for their legitimate use still have for their -- a ute for their legitimate use still have to for their -- a ute for their legitimate use still have to pay for their -- a ute for their legitimate use still have to pay tax legitimate use still have to pay tax under legitimate use still have to pay tax under fee legitimate use still have to pay tax under fee bathe. legitimate use still have to pay tax under fee bathe. -- legitimate use still have to pay tax under fee bathe. -- feebate. legitimate use still have to pay tax under fee bathe. -- feebate. It legitimate use still have to pay tax under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was not under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was not the under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was not the advice under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was not the advice officials under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was not the advice officials that under fee bathe. -- feebate. It was not the advice officials that we not the advice officials that we have not the advice officials that we have a not the advice officials that we have a carve not the advice officials that we have a carve out not the advice officials that we have a carve out and not the advice officials that we have a carve out and their not the advice officials that we have a carve out and their view not the advice officials that we have a carve out and their view is have a carve out and their view is that have a carve out and their view is that we have a carve out and their view is that we should have a carve out and their view is that we should not. have a carve out and their view is that we should not. That have a carve out and their view is that we should not. That did have a carve out and their view is that we should not. That did not that we should not. That did not stop that we should not. That did not stop Cabinet that we should not. That did not stop Cabinet having that we should not. That did not stop Cabinet having a that we should not. That did not stop Cabinet having a discussion stop Cabinet having a discussion over stop Cabinet having a discussion over the stop Cabinet having a discussion over the fact stop Cabinet having a discussion over the fact that stop Cabinet having a discussion over the fact that there stop Cabinet having a discussion over the fact that there are stop Cabinet having a discussion over the fact that there are for over the fact that there are for many over the fact that there are for many not over the fact that there are for many not an over the fact that there are for many not an alternative over the fact that there are for many not an alternative for over the fact that there are for many not an alternative for a over the fact that there are for many not an alternative for a ute many not an alternative for a ute that many not an alternative for a ute that is many not an alternative for a ute that is used many not an alternative for a ute that is used for many not an alternative for a ute that is used for business many not an alternative for a ute that is used for business purposes that is used for business purposes for that is used for business purposes for many that is used for business purposes for many that that is used for business purposes for many that there that is used for business purposes for many that there is that is used for business purposes for many that there is not that is used for business purposes for many that there is not an for many that there is not an alternative for many that there is not an alternative currently for many that there is not an alternative currently no-emissions alternative currently no-emissions vehicle alternative currently no-emissions vehicle on alternative currently no-emissions vehicle on the alternative currently no-emissions vehicle on the market. alternative currently no-emissions vehicle on the market. That alternative currently no-emissions vehicle on the market. That is alternative currently no-emissions vehicle on the market. That is why vehicle on the market. That is why we vehicle on the market. That is why we had vehicle on the market. That is why we had that vehicle on the market. That is why we had that discussion. vehicle on the market. That is why we had that discussion. As vehicle on the market. That is why we had that discussion. As I vehicle on the market. That is why we had that discussion. As I have we had that discussion. As I have said we had that discussion. As I have said in we had that discussion. As I have said in my we had that discussion. As I have said in my primary we had that discussion. As I have said in my primary answer, we had that discussion. As I have said in my primary answer, there said in my primary answer, there were said in my primary answer, there were issues said in my primary answer, there were issues around said in my primary answer, there were issues around how said in my primary answer, there were issues around how you said in my primary answer, there were issues around how you would were issues around how you would implement were issues around how you would implement such were issues around how you would implement such a were issues around how you would implement such a carve were issues around how you would implement such a carve out were issues around how you would implement such a carve out so implement such a carve out so ultimately implement such a carve out so ultimately the implement such a carve out so ultimately the decision implement such a carve out so ultimately the decision was implement such a carve out so ultimately the decision was taken implement such a carve out so ultimately the decision was taken to ultimately the decision was taken to have ultimately the decision was taken to have a ultimately the decision was taken to have a much ultimately the decision was taken to have a much more ultimately the decision was taken to have a much more straightforward have a much more straightforward scheme have a much more straightforward scheme recognising have a much more straightforward scheme recognising what have a much more straightforward scheme recognising what was have a much more straightforward scheme recognising what was coming scheme recognising what was coming on scheme recognising what was coming on stream scheme recognising what was coming on stream and scheme recognising what was coming on stream and the scheme recognising what was coming on stream and the point scheme recognising what was coming on stream and the point I scheme recognising what was coming on stream and the point I make scheme recognising what was coming on stream and the point I make to on stream and the point I make to the on stream and the point I make to the member, on stream and the point I make to the member, no on stream and the point I make to the member, no one on stream and the point I make to the member, no one who on stream and the point I make to the member, no one who currently the member, no one who currently owns the member, no one who currently owns a the member, no one who currently owns a ute the member, no one who currently owns a ute is the member, no one who currently owns a ute is affected the member, no one who currently owns a ute is affected by the member, no one who currently owns a ute is affected by this owns a ute is affected by this policy. owns a ute is affected by this policy. This owns a ute is affected by this policy. This is owns a ute is affected by this policy. This is for owns a ute is affected by this policy. This is for new owns a ute is affected by this policy. This is for new and owns a ute is affected by this policy. This is for new and imported policy. This is for new and imported vehicles policy. This is for new and imported vehicles rather policy. This is for new and imported vehicles rather than policy. This is for new and imported vehicles rather than those policy. This is for new and imported vehicles rather than those that policy. This is for new and imported vehicles rather than those that are vehicles rather than those that are existing vehicles rather than those that are existing and vehicles rather than those that are existing and in vehicles rather than those that are existing and in the vehicles rather than those that are existing and in the country vehicles rather than those that are existing and in the country and vehicles rather than those that are existing and in the country and in existing and in the country and in the existing and in the country and in the second-hand existing and in the country and in the second-hand market, existing and in the country and in the second-hand market, a existing and in the country and in the second-hand market, a point existing and in the country and in the second-hand market, a point that the second-hand market, a point that I the second-hand market, a point that I note the second-hand market, a point that I note is the second-hand market, a point that I note is not the second-hand market, a point that I note is not being the second-hand market, a point that I note is not being made the second-hand market, a point that I note is not being made by the second-hand market, a point that I note is not being made by all I note is not being made by all members I note is not being made by all members in I note is not being made by all members in this I note is not being made by all members in this House. members in this House. Supplementary. members in this House. Supplementary. Could members in this House. Supplementary. Could nose members in this House. Supplementary. Could nose people Supplementary. Could nose people buying Supplementary. Could nose people buying utes Supplementary. Could nose people buying utes for Supplementary. Could nose people buying utes for "legitimate Supplementary. Could nose people buying utes for "legitimate uses" buying utes for "legitimate uses" avoid buying utes for "legitimate uses" avoid the buying utes for "legitimate uses" avoid the tax buying utes for "legitimate uses" avoid the tax by buying utes for "legitimate uses" avoid the tax by purchasing buying utes for "legitimate uses" avoid the tax by purchasing an avoid the tax by purchasing an electric avoid the tax by purchasing an electric ute avoid the tax by purchasing an electric ute from avoid the tax by purchasing an electric ute from Toyota avoid the tax by purchasing an electric ute from Toyota and avoid the tax by purchasing an electric ute from Toyota and if avoid the tax by purchasing an electric ute from Toyota and if not, electric ute from Toyota and if not, why electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? At electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? At present, electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? At present, those electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? At present, those who electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? At present, those who are why not? At present, those who are bringing why not? At present, those who are bringing in why not? At present, those who are bringing in electric why not? At present, those who are bringing in electric vehicles why not? At present, those who are bringing in electric vehicles into bringing in electric vehicles into the bringing in electric vehicles into the market bringing in electric vehicles into the market within bringing in electric vehicles into the market within the bringing in electric vehicles into the market within the next bringing in electric vehicles into the market within the next 12-24 the market within the next 12-24 months the market within the next 12-24 months include the market within the next 12-24 months include LDV, the market within the next 12-24 months include LDV, Toyota the market within the next 12-24 months include LDV, Toyota have months include LDV, Toyota have themselves months include LDV, Toyota have themselves said, months include LDV, Toyota have themselves said, "They months include LDV, Toyota have themselves said, "They hope months include LDV, Toyota have themselves said, "They hope to months include LDV, Toyota have themselves said, "They hope to have themselves said, "They hope to have a themselves said, "They hope to have a Hilux themselves said, "They hope to have a Hilux hybrid themselves said, "They hope to have a Hilux hybrid into themselves said, "They hope to have a Hilux hybrid into the themselves said, "They hope to have a Hilux hybrid into the market a Hilux hybrid into the market before a Hilux hybrid into the market before the a Hilux hybrid into the market before the end a Hilux hybrid into the market before the end of a Hilux hybrid into the market before the end of next a Hilux hybrid into the market before the end of next year" a Hilux hybrid into the market before the end of next year" that before the end of next year" that statement before the end of next year" that statement was before the end of next year" that statement was made before the end of next year" that statement was made by before the end of next year" that statement was made by the before the end of next year" that statement was made by the Toyota before the end of next year" that statement was made by the Toyota New statement was made by the Toyota New Zealand statement was made by the Toyota New Zealand CEO statement was made by the Toyota New Zealand CEO on statement was made by the Toyota New Zealand CEO on 22... Zealand CEO on 22... <AUDIO Zealand CEO on 22... <AUDIO LOSS> Not Not affected Not affected and Not affected and this Not affected and this policy Not affected and this policy that Not affected and this policy that we've Not affected and this policy that we've applied Not affected and this policy that we've applied does Not affected and this policy that we've applied does cover Not affected and this policy that we've applied does cover incentives we've applied does cover incentives or we've applied does cover incentives or no we've applied does cover incentives or no fees we've applied does cover incentives or no fees for we've applied does cover incentives or no fees for low we've applied does cover incentives or no fees for low and we've applied does cover incentives or no fees for low and hybrid or no fees for low and hybrid vehicles, or no fees for low and hybrid vehicles, not or no fees for low and hybrid vehicles, not just or no fees for low and hybrid vehicles, not just EVs. vehicles, not just EVs. Supplementary. vehicles, not just EVs. Supplementary. The vehicles, not just EVs. Supplementary. The Hon vehicles, not just EVs. Supplementary. The Hon Judith Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To the Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To the PM, Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To the PM, is Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To the PM, is it Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To the PM, is it the Supplementary. The Hon Judith Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job to Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job to tell Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job to tell Kiwis Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job to tell Kiwis whether Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job to tell Kiwis whether or Collins. To the PM, is it the PM's job to tell Kiwis whether or not job to tell Kiwis whether or not their job to tell Kiwis whether or not their vehicle job to tell Kiwis whether or not their vehicle choices job to tell Kiwis whether or not their vehicle choices are their vehicle choices are legitimate? their vehicle choices are legitimate? The their vehicle choices are legitimate? The member, their vehicle choices are legitimate? The member, if their vehicle choices are legitimate? The member, if she legitimate? The member, if she listened legitimate? The member, if she listened to legitimate? The member, if she listened to my legitimate? The member, if she listened to my first legitimate? The member, if she listened to my first answer, legitimate? The member, if she listened to my first answer, would listened to my first answer, would have listened to my first answer, would have heard listened to my first answer, would have heard me listened to my first answer, would have heard me clarify listened to my first answer, would have heard me clarify that listened to my first answer, would have heard me clarify that actually have heard me clarify that actually drawing have heard me clarify that actually drawing those have heard me clarify that actually drawing those distinctions have heard me clarify that actually drawing those distinctions are drawing those distinctions are incredibly drawing those distinctions are incredibly difficult. drawing those distinctions are incredibly difficult. So drawing those distinctions are incredibly difficult. So creating drawing those distinctions are incredibly difficult. So creating a incredibly difficult. So creating a carve incredibly difficult. So creating a carve out, incredibly difficult. So creating a carve out, although incredibly difficult. So creating a carve out, although it incredibly difficult. So creating a carve out, although it was carve out, although it was considered carve out, although it was considered by carve out, although it was considered by Cabinet, carve out, although it was considered by Cabinet, was carve out, although it was considered by Cabinet, was just carve out, although it was considered by Cabinet, was just not considered by Cabinet, was just not something considered by Cabinet, was just not something that considered by Cabinet, was just not something that we considered by Cabinet, was just not something that we felt considered by Cabinet, was just not something that we felt we considered by Cabinet, was just not something that we felt we could considered by Cabinet, was just not something that we felt we could do something that we felt we could do fairly. something that we felt we could do fairly. I something that we felt we could do fairly. I would something that we felt we could do fairly. I would say something that we felt we could do fairly. I would say to something that we felt we could do fairly. I would say to the something that we felt we could do fairly. I would say to the member fairly. I would say to the member that fairly. I would say to the member that given fairly. I would say to the member that given Stuart fairly. I would say to the member that given Stuart Smith fairly. I would say to the member that given Stuart Smith says fairly. I would say to the member that given Stuart Smith says I'm that given Stuart Smith says I'm against that given Stuart Smith says I'm against subsidies that given Stuart Smith says I'm against subsidies for that given Stuart Smith says I'm against subsidies for EVs, that given Stuart Smith says I'm against subsidies for EVs, Michael against subsidies for EVs, Michael Woodhouse against subsidies for EVs, Michael Woodhouse says against subsidies for EVs, Michael Woodhouse says National against subsidies for EVs, Michael Woodhouse says National supports Woodhouse says National supports introducing Woodhouse says National supports introducing financial Woodhouse says National supports introducing financial incentives Woodhouse says National supports introducing financial incentives for introducing financial incentives for EVs. introducing financial incentives for EVs. Chris introducing financial incentives for EVs. Chris Bishop introducing financial incentives for EVs. Chris Bishop says introducing financial incentives for EVs. Chris Bishop says National introducing financial incentives for EVs. Chris Bishop says National is EVs. Chris Bishop says National is the EVs. Chris Bishop says National is the party EVs. Chris Bishop says National is the party for EVs. Chris Bishop says National is the party for EVs. EVs. Chris Bishop says National is the party for EVs. Mark EVs. Chris Bishop says National is the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell says the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell says he the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell says he would the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell says he would incentivise the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell says he would incentivise them the party for EVs. Mark Mitchell says he would incentivise them and says he would incentivise them and Todd says he would incentivise them and Todd Muller says he would incentivise them and Todd Muller says says he would incentivise them and Todd Muller says he says he would incentivise them and Todd Muller says he is says he would incentivise them and Todd Muller says he is broadly Todd Muller says he is broadly supportive. Todd Muller says he is broadly supportive. I Todd Muller says he is broadly supportive. I personally Todd Muller says he is broadly supportive. I personally would Todd Muller says he is broadly supportive. I personally would be supportive. I personally would be interested supportive. I personally would be interested in supportive. I personally would be interested in what supportive. I personally would be interested in what National's supportive. I personally would be interested in what National's policy interested in what National's policy is interested in what National's policy is on interested in what National's policy is on this interested in what National's policy is on this issue. interested in what National's policy is on this issue. Supplementary. is on this issue. Supplementary. Does is on this issue. Supplementary. Does she is on this issue. Supplementary. Does she view is on this issue. Supplementary. Does she view driving... Does she view driving... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! The <INTERRUPTION> Order! The extra <INTERRUPTION> Order! The extra questions <INTERRUPTION> Order! The extra questions are Order! The extra questions are mitigated Order! The extra questions are mitigated by Order! The extra questions are mitigated by the Order! The extra questions are mitigated by the fact Order! The extra questions are mitigated by the fact that Order! The extra questions are mitigated by the fact that laughter mitigated by the fact that laughter came mitigated by the fact that laughter came from mitigated by the fact that laughter came from both mitigated by the fact that laughter came from both sides. mitigated by the fact that laughter came from both sides. Supplementary. came from both sides. Supplementary. Does came from both sides. Supplementary. Does she came from both sides. Supplementary. Does she view came from both sides. Supplementary. Does she view driving came from both sides. Supplementary. Does she view driving a came from both sides. Supplementary. Does she view driving a seven-seater Does she view driving a seven-seater people Does she view driving a seven-seater people mover Does she view driving a seven-seater people mover like Does she view driving a seven-seater people mover like the Does she view driving a seven-seater people mover like the Mazda Does she view driving a seven-seater people mover like the Mazda CX9 Does she view driving a seven-seater people mover like the Mazda CX9 as people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate and people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate and if people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate and if not people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate and if not why people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate and if not why is people mover like the Mazda CX9 as illegitimate and if not why is she illegitimate and if not why is she putting illegitimate and if not why is she putting a illegitimate and if not why is she putting a tax illegitimate and if not why is she putting a tax on illegitimate and if not why is she putting a tax on them? illegitimate and if not why is she putting a tax on them? Again illegitimate and if not why is she putting a tax on them? Again this illegitimate and if not why is she putting a tax on them? Again this is putting a tax on them? Again this is also putting a tax on them? Again this is also about putting a tax on them? Again this is also about trying putting a tax on them? Again this is also about trying to putting a tax on them? Again this is also about trying to make putting a tax on them? Again this is also about trying to make sure putting a tax on them? Again this is also about trying to make sure that also about trying to make sure that we also about trying to make sure that we are also about trying to make sure that we are incentivising also about trying to make sure that we are incentivising and also about trying to make sure that we are incentivising and discounting we are incentivising and discounting low-emissions we are incentivising and discounting low-emissions - we are incentivising and discounting low-emissions - not we are incentivising and discounting low-emissions - not just we are incentivising and discounting low-emissions - not just EV we are incentivising and discounting low-emissions - not just EV but low-emissions - not just EV but low-emissions low-emissions - not just EV but low-emissions - low-emissions - not just EV but low-emissions - options. low-emissions - not just EV but low-emissions - options. We low-emissions - not just EV but low-emissions - options. We know low-emissions - options. We know from low-emissions - options. We know from research low-emissions - options. We know from research that low-emissions - options. We know from research that praising from research that praising incentives from research that praising incentives at from research that praising incentives at the from research that praising incentives at the point from research that praising incentives at the point of from research that praising incentives at the point of sale incentives at the point of sale supports incentives at the point of sale supports those incentives at the point of sale supports those who incentives at the point of sale supports those who otherwise incentives at the point of sale supports those who otherwise may incentives at the point of sale supports those who otherwise may not supports those who otherwise may not have supports those who otherwise may not have the supports those who otherwise may not have the ability supports those who otherwise may not have the ability to supports those who otherwise may not have the ability to ultimately have the ability to ultimately purchase have the ability to ultimately purchase a have the ability to ultimately purchase a vehicle have the ability to ultimately purchase a vehicle which have the ability to ultimately purchase a vehicle which would have the ability to ultimately purchase a vehicle which would be purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper over purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper over the purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper over the life purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper over the life time purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper over the life time cost. purchase a vehicle which would be cheaper over the life time cost. A cheaper over the life time cost. A Toyota cheaper over the life time cost. A Toyota Esteema cheaper over the life time cost. A Toyota Esteema 7 cheaper over the life time cost. A Toyota Esteema 7 seater cheaper over the life time cost. A Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces cheaper over the life time cost. A Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a discount, Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a discount, a Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a discount, a Toyota Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a discount, a Toyota Prius Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a discount, a Toyota Prius has Toyota Esteema 7 seater produces a discount, a Toyota Prius has a discount, a Toyota Prius has a $1,310 discount, a Toyota Prius has a $1,310 discount discount, a Toyota Prius has a $1,310 discount and discount, a Toyota Prius has a $1,310 discount and a discount, a Toyota Prius has a $1,310 discount and a Nissan discount, a Toyota Prius has a $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven seater $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven seater has $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven seater has a $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven seater has a $3,450 $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven seater has a $3,450 discount $1,310 discount and a Nissan seven seater has a $3,450 discount and seater has a $3,450 discount and they seater has a $3,450 discount and they are seater has a $3,450 discount and they are all seater has a $3,450 discount and they are all used seater has a $3,450 discount and they are all used vehicles. seater has a $3,450 discount and they are all used vehicles. In seater has a $3,450 discount and they are all used vehicles. In fact, they are all used vehicles. In fact, out they are all used vehicles. In fact, out of they are all used vehicles. In fact, out of 10 they are all used vehicles. In fact, out of 10 of they are all used vehicles. In fact, out of 10 of New they are all used vehicles. In fact, out of 10 of New Zealand's they are all used vehicles. In fact, out of 10 of New Zealand's most out of 10 of New Zealand's most popular out of 10 of New Zealand's most popular used out of 10 of New Zealand's most popular used vehicles out of 10 of New Zealand's most popular used vehicles either out of 10 of New Zealand's most popular used vehicles either have out of 10 of New Zealand's most popular used vehicles either have no popular used vehicles either have no fee popular used vehicles either have no fee or popular used vehicles either have no fee or attract popular used vehicles either have no fee or attract an popular used vehicles either have no fee or attract an incentive popular used vehicles either have no fee or attract an incentive or popular used vehicles either have no fee or attract an incentive or a fee or attract an incentive or a discount. fee or attract an incentive or a discount. Supplementary. fee or attract an incentive or a discount. Supplementary. Has fee or attract an incentive or a discount. Supplementary. Has the fee or attract an incentive or a discount. Supplementary. Has the PM discount. Supplementary. Has the PM driven discount. Supplementary. Has the PM driven an discount. Supplementary. Has the PM driven an electric discount. Supplementary. Has the PM driven an electric ute discount. Supplementary. Has the PM driven an electric ute from discount. Supplementary. Has the PM driven an electric ute from Toyota driven an electric ute from Toyota and driven an electric ute from Toyota and if driven an electric ute from Toyota and if not, driven an electric ute from Toyota and if not, why driven an electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? driven an electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? As driven an electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? As I driven an electric ute from Toyota and if not, why not? As I have and if not, why not? As I have already and if not, why not? As I have already said, and if not, why not? As I have already said, LDV and if not, why not? As I have already said, LDV are and if not, why not? As I have already said, LDV are bringing and if not, why not? As I have already said, LDV are bringing the already said, LDV are bringing the electric already said, LDV are bringing the electric vehicles, already said, LDV are bringing the electric vehicles, Toyota already said, LDV are bringing the electric vehicles, Toyota themselves electric vehicles, Toyota themselves have electric vehicles, Toyota themselves have acknowledged electric vehicles, Toyota themselves have acknowledged they electric vehicles, Toyota themselves have acknowledged they are electric vehicles, Toyota themselves have acknowledged they are bringing have acknowledged they are bringing in have acknowledged they are bringing in a have acknowledged they are bringing in a hybrid. have acknowledged they are bringing in a hybrid. Again, have acknowledged they are bringing in a hybrid. Again, no have acknowledged they are bringing in a hybrid. Again, no one have acknowledged they are bringing in a hybrid. Again, no one here have acknowledged they are bringing in a hybrid. Again, no one here is in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying - in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying - this in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying - this is in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying - this is the in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying - this is the very in a hybrid. Again, no one here is saying - this is the very listen saying - this is the very listen reason saying - this is the very listen reason we saying - this is the very listen reason we have saying - this is the very listen reason we have discussed saying - this is the very listen reason we have discussed the saying - this is the very listen reason we have discussed the carve reason we have discussed the carve out reason we have discussed the carve out issue, reason we have discussed the carve out issue, that reason we have discussed the carve out issue, that there reason we have discussed the carve out issue, that there currently reason we have discussed the carve out issue, that there currently is out issue, that there currently is that out issue, that there currently is that immediate out issue, that there currently is that immediate issue out issue, that there currently is that immediate issue however out issue, that there currently is that immediate issue however as out issue, that there currently is that immediate issue however as has that immediate issue however as has been that immediate issue however as has been said that immediate issue however as has been said by that immediate issue however as has been said by Drive that immediate issue however as has been said by Drive Electric, that immediate issue however as has been said by Drive Electric, "Taken been said by Drive Electric, "Taken together been said by Drive Electric, "Taken together the been said by Drive Electric, "Taken together the emissions been said by Drive Electric, "Taken together the emissions standards been said by Drive Electric, "Taken together the emissions standards and together the emissions standards and consumer together the emissions standards and consumer incentive together the emissions standards and consumer incentive puts together the emissions standards and consumer incentive puts New together the emissions standards and consumer incentive puts New Zealand consumer incentive puts New Zealand on consumer incentive puts New Zealand on the consumer incentive puts New Zealand on the map consumer incentive puts New Zealand on the map for consumer incentive puts New Zealand on the map for electric consumer incentive puts New Zealand on the map for electric vehicle on the map for electric vehicle manufacturers. on the map for electric vehicle manufacturers. We on the map for electric vehicle manufacturers. We are on the map for electric vehicle manufacturers. We are telling on the map for electric vehicle manufacturers. We are telling them manufacturers. We are telling them New manufacturers. We are telling them New Zealand manufacturers. We are telling them New Zealand is manufacturers. We are telling them New Zealand is a manufacturers. We are telling them New Zealand is a serious manufacturers. We are telling them New Zealand is a serious market manufacturers. We are telling them New Zealand is a serious market for New Zealand is a serious market for electric New Zealand is a serious market for electric vehicles New Zealand is a serious market for electric vehicles and New Zealand is a serious market for electric vehicles and we New Zealand is a serious market for electric vehicles and we want New Zealand is a serious market for electric vehicles and we want that electric vehicles and we want that supply. electric vehicles and we want that supply. We electric vehicles and we want that supply. We are electric vehicles and we want that supply. We are looking electric vehicles and we want that supply. We are looking forward electric vehicles and we want that supply. We are looking forward to supply. We are looking forward to them supply. We are looking forward to them bringing supply. We are looking forward to them bringing in supply. We are looking forward to them bringing in new supply. We are looking forward to them bringing in new ranges supply. We are looking forward to them bringing in new ranges and them bringing in new ranges and models." them bringing in new ranges and models." New them bringing in new ranges and models." New Zealand, them bringing in new ranges and models." New Zealand, Mr them bringing in new ranges and models." New Zealand, Mr Speaker, models." New Zealand, Mr Speaker, may models." New Zealand, Mr Speaker, may have models." New Zealand, Mr Speaker, may have otherwise models." New Zealand, Mr Speaker, may have otherwise suffered models." New Zealand, Mr Speaker, may have otherwise suffered from may have otherwise suffered from manufacturers may have otherwise suffered from manufacturers not may have otherwise suffered from manufacturers not necessarily manufacturers not necessarily supplying manufacturers not necessarily supplying New manufacturers not necessarily supplying New Zealand manufacturers not necessarily supplying New Zealand with supplying New Zealand with alternatives supplying New Zealand with alternatives if supplying New Zealand with alternatives if we supplying New Zealand with alternatives if we did supplying New Zealand with alternatives if we did not supplying New Zealand with alternatives if we did not have alternatives if we did not have clean alternatives if we did not have clean car alternatives if we did not have clean car standards alternatives if we did not have clean car standards and alternatives if we did not have clean car standards and incentives. clean car standards and incentives. Will clean car standards and incentives. Will it clean car standards and incentives. Will it be clean car standards and incentives. Will it be a clean car standards and incentives. Will it be a legitimate clean car standards and incentives. Will it be a legitimate use clean car standards and incentives. Will it be a legitimate use for clean car standards and incentives. Will it be a legitimate use for a Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota electric Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota electric ute Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota electric ute to Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota electric ute to drive Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota electric ute to drive it Will it be a legitimate use for a Toyota electric ute to drive it on Toyota electric ute to drive it on the Toyota electric ute to drive it on the bike Toyota electric ute to drive it on the bike bridge Toyota electric ute to drive it on the bike bridge that Toyota electric ute to drive it on the bike bridge that the Toyota electric ute to drive it on the bike bridge that the Government the bike bridge that the Government announced the bike bridge that the Government announced last the bike bridge that the Government announced last week the bike bridge that the Government announced last week and the bike bridge that the Government announced last week and if the bike bridge that the Government announced last week and if not, the bike bridge that the Government announced last week and if not, why announced last week and if not, why not? announced last week and if not, why not? Order! announced last week and if not, why not? Order! Supplementary announced last week and if not, why not? Order! Supplementary question, not? Order! Supplementary question, Mr not? Order! Supplementary question, Mr Speaker. not? Order! Supplementary question, Mr Speaker. Now, not? Order! Supplementary question, Mr Speaker. Now, I've not? Order! Supplementary question, Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled not? Order! Supplementary question, Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled the Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled the question Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled the question out Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled the question out because Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled the question out because it Mr Speaker. Now, I've ruled the question out because it involves question out because it involves irony, question out because it involves irony, the question out because it involves irony, the member question out because it involves irony, the member knows question out because it involves irony, the member knows that, question out because it involves irony, the member knows that, the irony, the member knows that, the member irony, the member knows that, the member notes irony, the member knows that, the member notes it irony, the member knows that, the member notes it is irony, the member knows that, the member notes it is out irony, the member knows that, the member notes it is out of irony, the member knows that, the member notes it is out of order. irony, the member knows that, the member notes it is out of order. If member notes it is out of order. If he member notes it is out of order. If he is member notes it is out of order. If he is going member notes it is out of order. If he is going to member notes it is out of order. If he is going to really member notes it is out of order. If he is going to really argue member notes it is out of order. If he is going to really argue that member notes it is out of order. If he is going to really argue that it he is going to really argue that it doesn't he is going to really argue that it doesn't he he is going to really argue that it doesn't he will he is going to really argue that it doesn't he will have he is going to really argue that it doesn't he will have to he is going to really argue that it doesn't he will have to make he is going to really argue that it doesn't he will have to make a doesn't he will have to make a pretty doesn't he will have to make a pretty good doesn't he will have to make a pretty good argument. doesn't he will have to make a pretty good argument. Mr doesn't he will have to make a pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, there pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, there is pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, there is a pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, there is a perfectly pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, there is a perfectly legitimate pretty good argument. Mr Speaker, there is a perfectly legitimate line there is a perfectly legitimate line of there is a perfectly legitimate line of questioning there is a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about there is a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about the there is a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about the legitimacy of questioning about the legitimacy of of questioning about the legitimacy of different of questioning about the legitimacy of different use of questioning about the legitimacy of different use of of questioning about the legitimacy of different use of vehicles. of questioning about the legitimacy of different use of vehicles. The of questioning about the legitimacy of different use of vehicles. The PM of different use of vehicles. The PM has of different use of vehicles. The PM has tried of different use of vehicles. The PM has tried to of different use of vehicles. The PM has tried to tell of different use of vehicles. The PM has tried to tell New of different use of vehicles. The PM has tried to tell New Zealanders has tried to tell New Zealanders what has tried to tell New Zealanders what that has tried to tell New Zealanders what that is has tried to tell New Zealanders what that is and has tried to tell New Zealanders what that is and people has tried to tell New Zealanders what that is and people want has tried to tell New Zealanders what that is and people want answers what that is and people want answers about what that is and people want answers about what what that is and people want answers about what it what that is and people want answers about what it might what that is and people want answers about what it might be. what that is and people want answers about what it might be. There what that is and people want answers about what it might be. There is about what it might be. There is also about what it might be. There is also a about what it might be. There is also a perfectly about what it might be. There is also a perfectly legitimate about what it might be. There is also a perfectly legitimate line about what it might be. There is also a perfectly legitimate line of also a perfectly legitimate line of questioning also a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about also a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about the also a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about the utility also a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about the utility to also a perfectly legitimate line of questioning about the utility to be questioning about the utility to be derived questioning about the utility to be derived from questioning about the utility to be derived from the questioning about the utility to be derived from the Government's derived from the Government's announcement derived from the Government's announcement of derived from the Government's announcement of a derived from the Government's announcement of a bike derived from the Government's announcement of a bike bridge. derived from the Government's announcement of a bike bridge. I announcement of a bike bridge. I don't announcement of a bike bridge. I don't think announcement of a bike bridge. I don't think it announcement of a bike bridge. I don't think it is announcement of a bike bridge. I don't think it is unreasonable announcement of a bike bridge. I don't think it is unreasonable to don't think it is unreasonable to ask don't think it is unreasonable to ask what don't think it is unreasonable to ask what the don't think it is unreasonable to ask what the scope don't think it is unreasonable to ask what the scope of don't think it is unreasonable to ask what the scope of that don't think it is unreasonable to ask what the scope of that bridge ask what the scope of that bridge is. ask what the scope of that bridge is. I'm ask what the scope of that bridge is. I'm glad ask what the scope of that bridge is. I'm glad that ask what the scope of that bridge is. I'm glad that you ask what the scope of that bridge is. I'm glad that you find ask what the scope of that bridge is. I'm glad that you find it is. I'm glad that you find it entertaining, is. I'm glad that you find it entertaining, Mr is. I'm glad that you find it entertaining, Mr Speaker, is. I'm glad that you find it entertaining, Mr Speaker, but is. I'm glad that you find it entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at home entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at home want entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at home want ans entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at home want ans to entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at home want ans to these entertaining, Mr Speaker, but people at home want ans to these serious at home want ans to these serious questions. at home want ans to these serious questions. The at home want ans to these serious questions. The Hon at home want ans to these serious questions. The Hon Grant at home want ans to these serious questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the PM questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the PM think questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the PM think it questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the PM think it is questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the PM think it is possible questions. The Hon Grant Robertson. Does the PM think it is possible for Does the PM think it is possible for New Does the PM think it is possible for New Zealand Does the PM think it is possible for New Zealand to Does the PM think it is possible for New Zealand to reach Does the PM think it is possible for New Zealand to reach its Does the PM think it is possible for New Zealand to reach its climate New Zealand to reach its climate change New Zealand to reach its climate change commitments, New Zealand to reach its climate change commitments, including New Zealand to reach its climate change commitments, including those change commitments, including those signed change commitments, including those signed up change commitments, including those signed up to change commitments, including those signed up to in change commitments, including those signed up to in Paris, change commitments, including those signed up to in Paris, by change commitments, including those signed up to in Paris, by changing signed up to in Paris, by changing absolutely signed up to in Paris, by changing absolutely nothing signed up to in Paris, by changing absolutely nothing about signed up to in Paris, by changing absolutely nothing about our signed up to in Paris, by changing absolutely nothing about our vehicle absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? No. absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? No. In absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? No. In fact, absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? No. In fact, the absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? No. In fact, the majority absolutely nothing about our vehicle fleet? No. In fact, the majority of fleet? No. In fact, the majority of New fleet? No. In fact, the majority of New Zealanders fleet? No. In fact, the majority of New Zealanders when fleet? No. In fact, the majority of New Zealanders when surveyed fleet? No. In fact, the majority of New Zealanders when surveyed support New Zealanders when surveyed support initiatives New Zealanders when surveyed support initiatives in New Zealanders when surveyed support initiatives in this New Zealanders when surveyed support initiatives in this area New Zealanders when surveyed support initiatives in this area because initiatives in this area because unlike initiatives in this area because unlike the initiatives in this area because unlike the member initiatives in this area because unlike the member asking initiatives in this area because unlike the member asking the unlike the member asking the question unlike the member asking the question they unlike the member asking the question they do unlike the member asking the question they do not unlike the member asking the question they do not believe unlike the member asking the question they do not believe that unlike the member asking the question they do not believe that we question they do not believe that we can question they do not believe that we can sit question they do not believe that we can sit back question they do not believe that we can sit back while question they do not believe that we can sit back while the question they do not believe that we can sit back while the world can sit back while the world continues can sit back while the world continues to can sit back while the world continues to move can sit back while the world continues to move and can sit back while the world continues to move and change can sit back while the world continues to move and change around continues to move and change around us continues to move and change around us without continues to move and change around us without getting continues to move and change around us without getting in continues to move and change around us without getting in front continues to move and change around us without getting in front of continues to move and change around us without getting in front of this us without getting in front of this issue. us without getting in front of this issue. We us without getting in front of this issue. We are us without getting in front of this issue. We are behind us without getting in front of this issue. We are behind the us without getting in front of this issue. We are behind the rest us without getting in front of this issue. We are behind the rest of us without getting in front of this issue. We are behind the rest of the issue. We are behind the rest of the world issue. We are behind the rest of the world when issue. We are behind the rest of the world when it issue. We are behind the rest of the world when it comes issue. We are behind the rest of the world when it comes to issue. We are behind the rest of the world when it comes to the issue. We are behind the rest of the world when it comes to the uptake issue. We are behind the rest of the world when it comes to the uptake of world when it comes to the uptake of electric world when it comes to the uptake of electric vehicles world when it comes to the uptake of electric vehicles and world when it comes to the uptake of electric vehicles and a world when it comes to the uptake of electric vehicles and a good world when it comes to the uptake of electric vehicles and a good reason electric vehicles and a good reason for electric vehicles and a good reason for that electric vehicles and a good reason for that is electric vehicles and a good reason for that is because electric vehicles and a good reason for that is because the electric vehicles and a good reason for that is because the price electric vehicles and a good reason for that is because the price point for that is because the price point at for that is because the price point at the for that is because the price point at the point for that is because the price point at the point of for that is because the price point at the point of sale for that is because the price point at the point of sale is for that is because the price point at the point of sale is high. for that is because the price point at the point of sale is high. This at the point of sale is high. This is at the point of sale is high. This is one at the point of sale is high. This is one way at the point of sale is high. This is one way we at the point of sale is high. This is one way we can at the point of sale is high. This is one way we can support at the point of sale is high. This is one way we can support New is one way we can support New Zealanders is one way we can support New Zealanders and is one way we can support New Zealanders and it is one way we can support New Zealanders and it will is one way we can support New Zealanders and it will reduce is one way we can support New Zealanders and it will reduce the Zealanders and it will reduce the life Zealanders and it will reduce the life time Zealanders and it will reduce the life time costs Zealanders and it will reduce the life time costs of Zealanders and it will reduce the life time costs of their Zealanders and it will reduce the life time costs of their vehicle. life time costs of their vehicle. That life time costs of their vehicle. That member life time costs of their vehicle. That member wants life time costs of their vehicle. That member wants them life time costs of their vehicle. That member wants them to life time costs of their vehicle. That member wants them to pay life time costs of their vehicle. That member wants them to pay more That member wants them to pay more at That member wants them to pay more at the That member wants them to pay more at the pump That member wants them to pay more at the pump instead. That member wants them to pay more at the pump instead. Supplementary. at the pump instead. Supplementary. If at the pump instead. Supplementary. If Toyota at the pump instead. Supplementary. If Toyota electric at the pump instead. Supplementary. If Toyota electric utes at the pump instead. Supplementary. If Toyota electric utes did at the pump instead. Supplementary. If Toyota electric utes did exist, If Toyota electric utes did exist, would If Toyota electric utes did exist, would it If Toyota electric utes did exist, would it be If Toyota electric utes did exist, would it be legitimate If Toyota electric utes did exist, would it be legitimate to If Toyota electric utes did exist, would it be legitimate to use If Toyota electric utes did exist, would it be legitimate to use them would it be legitimate to use them on would it be legitimate to use them on the would it be legitimate to use them on the bridge would it be legitimate to use them on the bridge recently would it be legitimate to use them on the bridge recently announced would it be legitimate to use them on the bridge recently announced by on the bridge recently announced by the on the bridge recently announced by the Government? on the bridge recently announced by the Government? No. on the bridge recently announced by the Government? No. Supplementary. the Government? No. Supplementary. If the Government? No. Supplementary. If Toyota the Government? No. Supplementary. If Toyota electric the Government? No. Supplementary. If Toyota electric utes the Government? No. Supplementary. If Toyota electric utes did the Government? No. Supplementary. If Toyota electric utes did exist If Toyota electric utes did exist and If Toyota electric utes did exist and they If Toyota electric utes did exist and they were If Toyota electric utes did exist and they were able If Toyota electric utes did exist and they were able to If Toyota electric utes did exist and they were able to be If Toyota electric utes did exist and they were able to be driven If Toyota electric utes did exist and they were able to be driven on and they were able to be driven on that and they were able to be driven on that bridge, and they were able to be driven on that bridge, would and they were able to be driven on that bridge, would that and they were able to be driven on that bridge, would that help and they were able to be driven on that bridge, would that help raise that bridge, would that help raise the that bridge, would that help raise the benefit-cost that bridge, would that help raise the benefit-cost ratio that bridge, would that help raise the benefit-cost ratio for that bridge, would that help raise the benefit-cost ratio for the the benefit-cost ratio for the bridge the benefit-cost ratio for the bridge from the benefit-cost ratio for the bridge from the the benefit-cost ratio for the bridge from the measly the benefit-cost ratio for the bridge from the measly 0.4 the benefit-cost ratio for the bridge from the measly 0.4 reported bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in the bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in the herald bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in the herald on bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in the herald on Friday? bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in the herald on Friday? Look, bridge from the measly 0.4 reported in the herald on Friday? Look, on in the herald on Friday? Look, on the in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one hand in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one hand I in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one hand I do in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one hand I do want in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one hand I do want to in the herald on Friday? Look, on the one hand I do want to applaud the one hand I do want to applaud the the one hand I do want to applaud the ACT the one hand I do want to applaud the ACT Party the one hand I do want to applaud the ACT Party for the one hand I do want to applaud the ACT Party for finally the one hand I do want to applaud the ACT Party for finally agreeing the ACT Party for finally agreeing that the ACT Party for finally agreeing that climate the ACT Party for finally agreeing that climate change the ACT Party for finally agreeing that climate change exists. the ACT Party for finally agreeing that climate change exists. That the ACT Party for finally agreeing that climate change exists. That is that climate change exists. That is a that climate change exists. That is a vast that climate change exists. That is a vast improvement that climate change exists. That is a vast improvement on that climate change exists. That is a vast improvement on where that climate change exists. That is a vast improvement on where you that climate change exists. That is a vast improvement on where you were a vast improvement on where you were 10 a vast improvement on where you were 10 years a vast improvement on where you were 10 years ago. a vast improvement on where you were 10 years ago. I a vast improvement on where you were 10 years ago. I sat a vast improvement on where you were 10 years ago. I sat in a vast improvement on where you were 10 years ago. I sat in this a vast improvement on where you were 10 years ago. I sat in this House 10 years ago. I sat in this House when 10 years ago. I sat in this House when Rodney 10 years ago. I sat in this House when Rodney Hide 10 years ago. I sat in this House when Rodney Hide instigated 10 years ago. I sat in this House when Rodney Hide instigated a 10 years ago. I sat in this House when Rodney Hide instigated a select when Rodney Hide instigated a select committee when Rodney Hide instigated a select committee to when Rodney Hide instigated a select committee to inquire when Rodney Hide instigated a select committee to inquire into when Rodney Hide instigated a select committee to inquire into the committee to inquire into the existence committee to inquire into the existence of committee to inquire into the existence of climate committee to inquire into the existence of climate change. committee to inquire into the existence of climate change. So, existence of climate change. So, look, existence of climate change. So, look, congratulations existence of climate change. So, look, congratulations for existence of climate change. So, look, congratulations for moving existence of climate change. So, look, congratulations for moving on look, congratulations for moving on some look, congratulations for moving on some way look, congratulations for moving on some way but look, congratulations for moving on some way but the look, congratulations for moving on some way but the member look, congratulations for moving on some way but the member at look, congratulations for moving on some way but the member at least look, congratulations for moving on some way but the member at least if some way but the member at least if he some way but the member at least if he wants some way but the member at least if he wants to some way but the member at least if he wants to acknowledge some way but the member at least if he wants to acknowledge that some way but the member at least if he wants to acknowledge that climate he wants to acknowledge that climate change he wants to acknowledge that climate change exists he wants to acknowledge that climate change exists perhaps he wants to acknowledge that climate change exists perhaps now he wants to acknowledge that climate change exists perhaps now is he wants to acknowledge that climate change exists perhaps now is the change exists perhaps now is the time change exists perhaps now is the time to change exists perhaps now is the time to actually change exists perhaps now is the time to actually support change exists perhaps now is the time to actually support some time to actually support some initiatives time to actually support some initiatives that time to actually support some initiatives that will time to actually support some initiatives that will do time to actually support some initiatives that will do something initiatives that will do something about initiatives that will do something about it. initiatives that will do something about it. Supplementary. initiatives that will do something about it. Supplementary. Is initiatives that will do something about it. Supplementary. Is this about it. Supplementary. Is this line about it. Supplementary. Is this line of about it. Supplementary. Is this line of questioning about it. Supplementary. Is this line of questioning getting about it. Supplementary. Is this line of questioning getting under line of questioning getting under the line of questioning getting under the PM's line of questioning getting under the PM's skin? line of questioning getting under the PM's skin? Further the PM's skin? Further supplementary. the PM's skin? Further supplementary. Mr the PM's skin? Further supplementary. Mr Speaker, the PM's skin? Further supplementary. Mr Speaker, I the PM's skin? Further supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM's skin? Further supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM if supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM if Toyota supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM if Toyota electric supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM if Toyota electric utes supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM if Toyota electric utes did supplementary. Mr Speaker, I ask the PM if Toyota electric utes did exist PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and could PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and could be PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and could be driven PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and could be driven on PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and could be driven on the PM if Toyota electric utes did exist and could be driven on the bridge and could be driven on the bridge and and could be driven on the bridge and it and could be driven on the bridge and it would and could be driven on the bridge and it would make and could be driven on the bridge and it would make the and could be driven on the bridge and it would make the bridge and could be driven on the bridge and it would make the bridge viable and it would make the bridge viable under and it would make the bridge viable under benefit-cost and it would make the bridge viable under benefit-cost ratio, and it would make the bridge viable under benefit-cost ratio, what and it would make the bridge viable under benefit-cost ratio, what would under benefit-cost ratio, what would be under benefit-cost ratio, what would be the under benefit-cost ratio, what would be the Government's under benefit-cost ratio, what would be the Government's plan under benefit-cost ratio, what would be the Government's plan for be the Government's plan for disposing be the Government's plan for disposing of be the Government's plan for disposing of all be the Government's plan for disposing of all those be the Government's plan for disposing of all those thousands be the Government's plan for disposing of all those thousands of disposing of all those thousands of toxic disposing of all those thousands of toxic EV disposing of all those thousands of toxic EV batteries? disposing of all those thousands of toxic EV batteries? So disposing of all those thousands of toxic EV batteries? So the disposing of all those thousands of toxic EV batteries? So the member toxic EV batteries? So the member unfortunately toxic EV batteries? So the member unfortunately believes toxic EV batteries? So the member unfortunately believes that toxic EV batteries? So the member unfortunately believes that we, toxic EV batteries? So the member unfortunately believes that we, as toxic EV batteries? So the member unfortunately believes that we, as a unfortunately believes that we, as a nation, unfortunately believes that we, as a nation, will unfortunately believes that we, as a nation, will be unfortunately believes that we, as a nation, will be better unfortunately believes that we, as a nation, will be better off unfortunately believes that we, as a nation, will be better off instead nation, will be better off instead becoming nation, will be better off instead becoming the nation, will be better off instead becoming the dumping nation, will be better off instead becoming the dumping ground nation, will be better off instead becoming the dumping ground for nation, will be better off instead becoming the dumping ground for all becoming the dumping ground for all of becoming the dumping ground for all of those becoming the dumping ground for all of those high-emissions becoming the dumping ground for all of those high-emissions vehicles of those high-emissions vehicles that of those high-emissions vehicles that other of those high-emissions vehicles that other countries of those high-emissions vehicles that other countries are of those high-emissions vehicles that other countries are currently that other countries are currently banning. that other countries are currently banning. No that other countries are currently banning. No one that other countries are currently banning. No one in that other countries are currently banning. No one in New that other countries are currently banning. No one in New Zealand, that other countries are currently banning. No one in New Zealand, I banning. No one in New Zealand, I would banning. No one in New Zealand, I would have banning. No one in New Zealand, I would have thought, banning. No one in New Zealand, I would have thought, would banning. No one in New Zealand, I would have thought, would think banning. No one in New Zealand, I would have thought, would think that would have thought, would think that is would have thought, would think that is a would have thought, would think that is a good would have thought, would think that is a good idea would have thought, would think that is a good idea unless would have thought, would think that is a good idea unless we would have thought, would think that is a good idea unless we move would have thought, would think that is a good idea unless we move to would have thought, would think that is a good idea unless we move to a is a good idea unless we move to a combination is a good idea unless we move to a combination of is a good idea unless we move to a combination of clean is a good idea unless we move to a combination of clean car is a good idea unless we move to a combination of clean car standards combination of clean car standards and combination of clean car standards and incentives, combination of clean car standards and incentives, we combination of clean car standards and incentives, we will combination of clean car standards and incentives, we will be combination of clean car standards and incentives, we will be the and incentives, we will be the dumping and incentives, we will be the dumping ground and incentives, we will be the dumping ground of and incentives, we will be the dumping ground of the and incentives, we will be the dumping ground of the rest and incentives, we will be the dumping ground of the rest of and incentives, we will be the dumping ground of the rest of the dumping ground of the rest of the world. dumping ground of the rest of the world. I dumping ground of the rest of the world. I also dumping ground of the rest of the world. I also note dumping ground of the rest of the world. I also note that dumping ground of the rest of the world. I also note that countries world. I also note that countries that world. I also note that countries that he world. I also note that countries that he likes world. I also note that countries that he likes to world. I also note that countries that he likes to replicate, world. I also note that countries that he likes to replicate, the that he likes to replicate, the lines that he likes to replicate, the lines of that he likes to replicate, the lines of Singapore, that he likes to replicate, the lines of Singapore, has that he likes to replicate, the lines of Singapore, has a that he likes to replicate, the lines of Singapore, has a clean that he likes to replicate, the lines of Singapore, has a clean car lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive such lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive such as lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive such as the lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive such as the one lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive such as the one that lines of Singapore, has a clean car incentive such as the one that New incentive such as the one that New Zealand incentive such as the one that New Zealand is incentive such as the one that New Zealand is proposing. incentive such as the one that New Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could the Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could the PM Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could the PM please Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could the PM please now Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could the PM please now answer Zealand is proposing. Supplementary. Could the PM please now answer my Could the PM please now answer my previous Could the PM please now answer my previous question, Could the PM please now answer my previous question, what Could the PM please now answer my previous question, what is Could the PM please now answer my previous question, what is New previous question, what is New Zealand's previous question, what is New Zealand's plan previous question, what is New Zealand's plan for previous question, what is New Zealand's plan for disposing previous question, what is New Zealand's plan for disposing of previous question, what is New Zealand's plan for disposing of EV Zealand's plan for disposing of EV batteries? Zealand's plan for disposing of EV batteries? It Zealand's plan for disposing of EV batteries? It is Zealand's plan for disposing of EV batteries? It is a Zealand's plan for disposing of EV batteries? It is a serious Zealand's plan for disposing of EV batteries? It is a serious question. batteries? It is a serious question. I batteries? It is a serious question. I would batteries? It is a serious question. I would be batteries? It is a serious question. I would be forgiven batteries? It is a serious question. I would be forgiven for batteries? It is a serious question. I would be forgiven for not batteries? It is a serious question. I would be forgiven for not thinking I would be forgiven for not thinking it I would be forgiven for not thinking it was I would be forgiven for not thinking it was a I would be forgiven for not thinking it was a serious I would be forgiven for not thinking it was a serious question. I would be forgiven for not thinking it was a serious question. A I would be forgiven for not thinking it was a serious question. A point it was a serious question. A point of it was a serious question. A point of order, it was a serious question. A point of order, Michael it was a serious question. A point of order, Michael Wood. it was a serious question. A point of order, Michael Wood. The it was a serious question. A point of order, Michael Wood. The member's of order, Michael Wood. The member's had of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go but of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go but it of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go but it is of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go but it is very of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go but it is very hard of order, Michael Wood. The member's had a fair go but it is very hard to had a fair go but it is very hard to see had a fair go but it is very hard to see how had a fair go but it is very hard to see how that had a fair go but it is very hard to see how that question had a fair go but it is very hard to see how that question stems had a fair go but it is very hard to see how that question stems at had a fair go but it is very hard to see how that question stems at all see how that question stems at all from see how that question stems at all from the see how that question stems at all from the primary see how that question stems at all from the primary question. see how that question stems at all from the primary question. I see how that question stems at all from the primary question. I think from the primary question. I think unfortunately, from the primary question. I think unfortunately, because from the primary question. I think unfortunately, because the from the primary question. I think unfortunately, because the PM from the primary question. I think unfortunately, because the PM was unfortunately, because the PM was fairly unfortunately, because the PM was fairly fast unfortunately, because the PM was fairly fast to unfortunately, because the PM was fairly fast to answer unfortunately, because the PM was fairly fast to answer the unfortunately, because the PM was fairly fast to answer the previous fairly fast to answer the previous question fairly fast to answer the previous question when fairly fast to answer the previous question when I fairly fast to answer the previous question when I would fairly fast to answer the previous question when I would have fairly fast to answer the previous question when I would have probably question when I would have probably ruled question when I would have probably ruled it question when I would have probably ruled it out, question when I would have probably ruled it out, by question when I would have probably ruled it out, by her question when I would have probably ruled it out, by her answer question when I would have probably ruled it out, by her answer she question when I would have probably ruled it out, by her answer she made ruled it out, by her answer she made the ruled it out, by her answer she made the subject ruled it out, by her answer she made the subject area ruled it out, by her answer she made the subject area broad ruled it out, by her answer she made the subject area broad enough ruled it out, by her answer she made the subject area broad enough for ruled it out, by her answer she made the subject area broad enough for Mr the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour to the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour to ask the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour to ask his the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour to ask his question the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour to ask his question - the subject area broad enough for Mr Seymour to ask his question - just. Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Speaker, Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Speaker, I Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Speaker, I could Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Speaker, I could be Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven Seymour to ask his question - just. Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for not Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for not taking Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for not taking the Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for not taking the member's Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for not taking the member's question Mr Speaker, I could be forgiven for not taking the member's question as not taking the member's question as seriously not taking the member's question as seriously as not taking the member's question as seriously as he not taking the member's question as seriously as he intended not taking the member's question as seriously as he intended for not taking the member's question as seriously as he intended for the seriously as he intended for the nature seriously as he intended for the nature in seriously as he intended for the nature in which seriously as he intended for the nature in which he seriously as he intended for the nature in which he asked seriously as he intended for the nature in which he asked it seriously as he intended for the nature in which he asked it but seriously as he intended for the nature in which he asked it but when nature in which he asked it but when it nature in which he asked it but when it comes nature in which he asked it but when it comes to nature in which he asked it but when it comes to the nature in which he asked it but when it comes to the issue nature in which he asked it but when it comes to the issue of nature in which he asked it but when it comes to the issue of batteries it comes to the issue of batteries these it comes to the issue of batteries these are it comes to the issue of batteries these are of it comes to the issue of batteries these are of course it comes to the issue of batteries these are of course things it comes to the issue of batteries these are of course things the it comes to the issue of batteries these are of course things the lines these are of course things the lines of these are of course things the lines of MFE these are of course things the lines of MFE continue these are of course things the lines of MFE continue to these are of course things the lines of MFE continue to work these are of course things the lines of MFE continue to work through these are of course things the lines of MFE continue to work through but of MFE continue to work through but I of MFE continue to work through but I could of MFE continue to work through but I could caution of MFE continue to work through but I could caution the of MFE continue to work through but I could caution the member of MFE continue to work through but I could caution the member around I could caution the member around the I could caution the member around the idea I could caution the member around the idea that I could caution the member around the idea that somehow I could caution the member around the idea that somehow that I could caution the member around the idea that somehow that is I could caution the member around the idea that somehow that is a the idea that somehow that is a reason the idea that somehow that is a reason for the idea that somehow that is a reason for us the idea that somehow that is a reason for us to the idea that somehow that is a reason for us to continue, the idea that somehow that is a reason for us to continue, as the idea that somehow that is a reason for us to continue, as I've reason for us to continue, as I've said, reason for us to continue, as I've said, to reason for us to continue, as I've said, to be reason for us to continue, as I've said, to be the reason for us to continue, as I've said, to be the dumping reason for us to continue, as I've said, to be the dumping ground reason for us to continue, as I've said, to be the dumping ground of said, to be the dumping ground of vehicles said, to be the dumping ground of vehicles that said, to be the dumping ground of vehicles that many, said, to be the dumping ground of vehicles that many, many said, to be the dumping ground of vehicles that many, many other vehicles that many, many other countries vehicles that many, many other countries we vehicles that many, many other countries we import vehicles that many, many other countries we import from vehicles that many, many other countries we import from are countries we import from are banning. countries we import from are banning. The countries we import from are banning. The Hon countries we import from are banning. The Hon David countries we import from are banning. The Hon David Parker. countries we import from are banning. The Hon David Parker. Is banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the PM banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the PM aware banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the PM aware that banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the PM aware that the banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the PM aware that the lead banning. The Hon David Parker. Is the PM aware that the lead acid the PM aware that the lead acid batteries the PM aware that the lead acid batteries in the PM aware that the lead acid batteries in cars the PM aware that the lead acid batteries in cars and the PM aware that the lead acid batteries in cars and trucks the PM aware that the lead acid batteries in cars and trucks are batteries in cars and trucks are amongst batteries in cars and trucks are amongst the batteries in cars and trucks are amongst the most batteries in cars and trucks are amongst the most recycled batteries in cars and trucks are amongst the most recycled item batteries in cars and trucks are amongst the most recycled item on amongst the most recycled item on the amongst the most recycled item on the planet amongst the most recycled item on the planet and amongst the most recycled item on the planet and is amongst the most recycled item on the planet and is she amongst the most recycled item on the planet and is she as amongst the most recycled item on the planet and is she as confident the planet and is she as confident as the planet and is she as confident as the the planet and is she as confident as the minister the planet and is she as confident as the minister of the planet and is she as confident as the minister of the the planet and is she as confident as the minister of the environment as the minister of the environment that as the minister of the environment that such as the minister of the environment that such systems as the minister of the environment that such systems will as the minister of the environment that such systems will also as the minister of the environment that such systems will also be as the minister of the environment that such systems will also be used that such systems will also be used in that such systems will also be used in the that such systems will also be used in the future that such systems will also be used in the future for that such systems will also be used in the future for lithium-ion in the future for lithium-ion batteries? in the future for lithium-ion batteries? Yes. in the future for lithium-ion batteries? Yes. Question in the future for lithium-ion batteries? Yes. Question No. in the future for lithium-ion batteries? Yes. Question No. 3, batteries? Yes. Question No. 3, Terisa batteries? Yes. Question No. 3, Terisa Ngobi. batteries? batteries? Yes. batteries? Yes. Question batteries? Yes. Question No. batteries? Yes. Question No. 3, batteries? Yes. Question No. 3, Terisa batteries? Yes. Question No. 3, Terisa Ngobi. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Social My question is to the Minister for Social Development My question is to the Minister for Social Development and My question is to the Minister for Social Development and Employment: Social Development and Employment: What Social Development and Employment: What reports Social Development and Employment: What reports has Social Development and Employment: What reports has she Social Development and Employment: What reports has she seen Social Development and Employment: What reports has she seen regarding What reports has she seen regarding the What reports has she seen regarding the number What reports has she seen regarding the number of What reports has she seen regarding the number of people What reports has she seen regarding the number of people receiving What reports has she seen regarding the number of people receiving a the number of people receiving a main the number of people receiving a main benefit? The The Hon The Hon Carmel The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly benefit The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly benefit update The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly benefit update for The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly benefit update for May The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly benefit update for May shows The Hon Carmel Sepuloni. The monthly benefit update for May shows a benefit update for May shows a further benefit update for May shows a further decrease benefit update for May shows a further decrease in benefit update for May shows a further decrease in the benefit update for May shows a further decrease in the number benefit update for May shows a further decrease in the number of further decrease in the number of people further decrease in the number of people receiving further decrease in the number of people receiving a further decrease in the number of people receiving a main further decrease in the number of people receiving a main benefit. further decrease in the number of people receiving a main benefit. As people receiving a main benefit. As of people receiving a main benefit. As of 31 people receiving a main benefit. As of 31 May people receiving a main benefit. As of 31 May there people receiving a main benefit. As of 31 May there were people receiving a main benefit. As of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a main benefit. As of 31 May there were 357,591 people of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a main of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a main benefit, of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a main benefit, a of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a main benefit, a fall of 31 May there were 357,591 people receiving a main benefit, a fall of receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 ,087 receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 ,087 from receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 ,087 from April receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 ,087 from April 2021. receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall receiving a main benefit, a fall of 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the number 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the number of 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the number of people 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the number of people receiving 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the number of people receiving a 3 ,087 from April 2021. Overall the number of people receiving a main number of people receiving a main benefit number of people receiving a main benefit has number of people receiving a main benefit has fallen number of people receiving a main benefit has fallen 32,010 number of people receiving a main benefit has fallen 32,010 since number of people receiving a main benefit has fallen 32,010 since the benefit has fallen 32,010 since the end benefit has fallen 32,010 since the end of benefit has fallen 32,010 since the end of January. benefit has fallen 32,010 since the end of January. 20,484 benefit has fallen 32,010 since the end of January. 20,484 of benefit has fallen 32,010 since the end of January. 20,484 of these end of January. 20,484 of these people end of January. 20,484 of these people moved end of January. 20,484 of these people moved off end of January. 20,484 of these people moved off the end of January. 20,484 of these people moved off the Jobseeker end of January. 20,484 of these people moved off the Jobseeker work people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready benefit. people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready benefit. It people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready benefit. It is people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready benefit. It is clear people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready benefit. It is clear that people moved off the Jobseeker work Ready benefit. It is clear that the Ready benefit. It is clear that the Government's Ready benefit. It is clear that the Government's quick Ready benefit. It is clear that the Government's quick action Ready benefit. It is clear that the Government's quick action in Government's quick action in combatting Government's quick action in combatting COVID-19 Government's quick action in combatting COVID-19 has Government's quick action in combatting COVID-19 has lessened Government's quick action in combatting COVID-19 has lessened the combatting COVID-19 has lessened the expected combatting COVID-19 has lessened the expected economic combatting COVID-19 has lessened the expected economic impact combatting COVID-19 has lessened the expected economic impact and combatting COVID-19 has lessened the expected economic impact and kept expected economic impact and kept people expected economic impact and kept people in expected economic impact and kept people in jobs. expected economic impact and kept people in jobs. We expected economic impact and kept people in jobs. We are expected economic impact and kept people in jobs. We are not expected economic impact and kept people in jobs. We are not out expected economic impact and kept people in jobs. We are not out of people in jobs. We are not out of the people in jobs. We are not out of the woods people in jobs. We are not out of the woods yet people in jobs. We are not out of the woods yet but people in jobs. We are not out of the woods yet but the people in jobs. We are not out of the woods yet but the signs people in jobs. We are not out of the woods yet but the signs are people in jobs. We are not out of the woods yet but the signs are very the woods yet but the signs are very promising. the woods yet but the signs are very promising. What the woods yet but the signs are very promising. What is the woods yet but the signs are very promising. What is the the woods yet but the signs are very promising. What is the Government promising. What is the Government doing promising. What is the Government doing to promising. What is the Government doing to get promising. What is the Government doing to get people promising. What is the Government doing to get people work promising. What is the Government doing to get people work ready promising. What is the Government doing to get people work ready and doing to get people work ready and off doing to get people work ready and off a doing to get people work ready and off a main doing to get people work ready and off a main benefit? doing to get people work ready and off a main benefit? In doing to get people work ready and off a main benefit? In the doing to get people work ready and off a main benefit? In the March off a main benefit? In the March quarter off a main benefit? In the March quarter we off a main benefit? In the March quarter we saw off a main benefit? In the March quarter we saw a off a main benefit? In the March quarter we saw a record off a main benefit? In the March quarter we saw a record number off a main benefit? In the March quarter we saw a record number of quarter we saw a record number of people quarter we saw a record number of people cancel quarter we saw a record number of people cancel their quarter we saw a record number of people cancel their benefit quarter we saw a record number of people cancel their benefit and quarter we saw a record number of people cancel their benefit and move people cancel their benefit and move into people cancel their benefit and move into work. people cancel their benefit and move into work. This people cancel their benefit and move into work. This trend people cancel their benefit and move into work. This trend continued people cancel their benefit and move into work. This trend continued in into work. This trend continued in May into work. This trend continued in May 2021 into work. This trend continued in May 2021 with into work. This trend continued in May 2021 with a into work. This trend continued in May 2021 with a further into work. This trend continued in May 2021 with a further 10,881 May 2021 with a further 10,881 people May 2021 with a further 10,881 people more May 2021 with a further 10,881 people more people May 2021 with a further 10,881 people more people leaving May 2021 with a further 10,881 people more people leaving a May 2021 with a further 10,881 people more people leaving a main people more people leaving a main benefit people more people leaving a main benefit and people more people leaving a main benefit and moving people more people leaving a main benefit and moving into people more people leaving a main benefit and moving into work. people more people leaving a main benefit and moving into work. The benefit and moving into work. The Government benefit and moving into work. The Government has benefit and moving into work. The Government has invested benefit and moving into work. The Government has invested heavily benefit and moving into work. The Government has invested heavily in Government has invested heavily in programmes Government has invested heavily in programmes that Government has invested heavily in programmes that focus Government has invested heavily in programmes that focus on Government has invested heavily in programmes that focus on upskilling programmes that focus on upskilling people programmes that focus on upskilling people and programmes that focus on upskilling people and getting programmes that focus on upskilling people and getting them programmes that focus on upskilling people and getting them ready programmes that focus on upskilling people and getting them ready for people and getting them ready for work. people and getting them ready for work. Mana people and getting them ready for work. Mana in people and getting them ready for work. Mana in Mahi, people and getting them ready for work. Mana in Mahi, Flexi-wage people and getting them ready for work. Mana in Mahi, Flexi-wage and work. Mana in Mahi, Flexi-wage and apprenticeship work. Mana in Mahi, Flexi-wage and apprenticeship boost work. Mana in Mahi, Flexi-wage and apprenticeship boost have work. Mana in Mahi, Flexi-wage and apprenticeship boost have been apprenticeship boost have been particularly apprenticeship boost have been particularly successful apprenticeship boost have been particularly successful in apprenticeship boost have been particularly successful in getting particularly successful in getting people particularly successful in getting people ready particularly successful in getting people ready for particularly successful in getting people ready for jobs particularly successful in getting people ready for jobs on particularly successful in getting people ready for jobs on offer particularly successful in getting people ready for jobs on offer in people ready for jobs on offer in the people ready for jobs on offer in the labour people ready for jobs on offer in the labour market. people ready for jobs on offer in the labour market. Budget people ready for jobs on offer in the labour market. Budget 2021 the labour market. Budget 2021 Vinnests the labour market. Budget 2021 Vinnests over the labour market. Budget 2021 Vinnests over 92 the labour market. Budget 2021 Vinnests over 92 million the labour market. Budget 2021 Vinnests over 92 million over the labour market. Budget 2021 Vinnests over 92 million over two Vinnests over 92 million over two years Vinnests over 92 million over two years to Vinnests over 92 million over two years to bolster Vinnests over 92 million over two years to bolster MSD's Vinnests over 92 million over two years to bolster MSD's front-line years to bolster MSD's front-line work years to bolster MSD's front-line work focused years to bolster MSD's front-line work focused work years to bolster MSD's front-line work focused work services years to bolster MSD's front-line work focused work services to years to bolster MSD's front-line work focused work services to get work focused work services to get people work focused work services to get people back work focused work services to get people back into work focused work services to get people back into work. work focused work services to get people back into work. What work focused work services to get people back into work. What is work focused work services to get people back into work. What is if people back into work. What is if Government people back into work. What is if Government doing people back into work. What is if Government doing to people back into work. What is if Government doing to get people back into work. What is if Government doing to get long-term Government doing to get long-term job Government doing to get long-term job sookers Government doing to get long-term job sookers into Government doing to get long-term job sookers into work? Government doing to get long-term job sookers into work? -- Government doing to get long-term job sookers into work? -- job job sookers into work? -- job seekers job sookers into work? -- job seekers into job sookers into work? -- job seekers into work. job sookers into work? -- job seekers into work. In job sookers into work? -- job seekers into work. In the job sookers into work? -- job seekers into work. In the March seekers into work. In the March quarter seekers into work. In the March quarter 4,137 seekers into work. In the March quarter 4,137 people seekers into work. In the March quarter 4,137 people who seekers into work. In the March quarter 4,137 people who had seekers into work. In the March quarter 4,137 people who had been quarter 4,137 people who had been receiving quarter 4,137 people who had been receiving a quarter 4,137 people who had been receiving a benefit quarter 4,137 people who had been receiving a benefit for quarter 4,137 people who had been receiving a benefit for longer quarter 4,137 people who had been receiving a benefit for longer than receiving a benefit for longer than a receiving a benefit for longer than a year receiving a benefit for longer than a year exited receiving a benefit for longer than a year exited the receiving a benefit for longer than a year exited the job receiving a benefit for longer than a year exited the job seeker receiving a benefit for longer than a year exited the job seeker work a year exited the job seeker work ready a year exited the job seeker work ready benefit a year exited the job seeker work ready benefit into a year exited the job seeker work ready benefit into employment. a year exited the job seeker work ready benefit into employment. Most ready benefit into employment. Most people ready benefit into employment. Most people on ready benefit into employment. Most people on a ready benefit into employment. Most people on a benefit ready benefit into employment. Most people on a benefit want ready benefit into employment. Most people on a benefit want to ready benefit into employment. Most people on a benefit want to work ready benefit into employment. Most people on a benefit want to work but people on a benefit want to work but many people on a benefit want to work but many have people on a benefit want to work but many have barriers people on a benefit want to work but many have barriers to people on a benefit want to work but many have barriers to employment. many have barriers to employment. The many have barriers to employment. The role many have barriers to employment. The role of many have barriers to employment. The role of MSD many have barriers to employment. The role of MSD is many have barriers to employment. The role of MSD is to many have barriers to employment. The role of MSD is to find many have barriers to employment. The role of MSD is to find ways many have barriers to employment. The role of MSD is to find ways to The role of MSD is to find ways to overcome The role of MSD is to find ways to overcome these The role of MSD is to find ways to overcome these barriers The role of MSD is to find ways to overcome these barriers and The role of MSD is to find ways to overcome these barriers and as The role of MSD is to find ways to overcome these barriers and as the overcome these barriers and as the numbers overcome these barriers and as the numbers show overcome these barriers and as the numbers show we overcome these barriers and as the numbers show we are overcome these barriers and as the numbers show we are having overcome these barriers and as the numbers show we are having some numbers show we are having some success. numbers show we are having some success. But numbers show we are having some success. But we numbers show we are having some success. But we also numbers show we are having some success. But we also have numbers show we are having some success. But we also have programmes success. But we also have programmes in success. But we also have programmes in place success. But we also have programmes in place to success. But we also have programmes in place to incentivise success. But we also have programmes in place to incentivise employers success. But we also have programmes in place to incentivise employers in in place to incentivise employers in taking in place to incentivise employers in taking a in place to incentivise employers in taking a chance in place to incentivise employers in taking a chance on in place to incentivise employers in taking a chance on those in place to incentivise employers in taking a chance on those who in place to incentivise employers in taking a chance on those who are taking a chance on those who are disadvantaged taking a chance on those who are disadvantaged in taking a chance on those who are disadvantaged in the taking a chance on those who are disadvantaged in the labour taking a chance on those who are disadvantaged in the labour market. disadvantaged in the labour market. One disadvantaged in the labour market. One such disadvantaged in the labour market. One such programme disadvantaged in the labour market. One such programme is disadvantaged in the labour market. One such programme is flexi disadvantaged in the labour market. One such programme is flexi wage One such programme is flexi wage which One such programme is flexi wage which has One such programme is flexi wage which has placed One such programme is flexi wage which has placed 3,582 One such programme is flexi wage which has placed 3,582 people One such programme is flexi wage which has placed 3,582 people who which has placed 3,582 people who are which has placed 3,582 people who are at which has placed 3,582 people who are at risk which has placed 3,582 people who are at risk of which has placed 3,582 people who are at risk of long-term which has placed 3,582 people who are at risk of long-term benefit are at risk of long-term benefit dependency are at risk of long-term benefit dependency into are at risk of long-term benefit dependency into work are at risk of long-term benefit dependency into work since are at risk of long-term benefit dependency into work since February dependency into work since February 2021. dependency into work since February 2021. 97% dependency into work since February 2021. 97% of dependency into work since February 2021. 97% of these dependency into work since February 2021. 97% of these placements dependency into work since February 2021. 97% of these placements have 2021. 97% of these placements have not 2021. 97% of these placements have not returned 2021. 97% of these placements have not returned to 2021. 97% of these placements have not returned to benefit. 2021. 97% of these placements have not returned to benefit. Question not returned to benefit. Question No. not returned to benefit. Question No. 4, not returned to benefit. Question No. 4, the No. No. 4, No. 4, the No. 4, the Hon No. 4, the Hon Judith No. 4, the Hon Judith Collins. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Prime My question is to the Prime Minister: My question is to the Prime Minister: Does My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all My question is to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by all of Minister: Does she stand by all of her Minister: Does she stand by all of her Government's Minister: Does she stand by all of her Government's statements Minister: Does she stand by all of her Government's statements and her Government's statements and actions? Yes, Yes, particularly Yes, particularly the Yes, particularly the Government's Yes, particularly the Government's efforts Yes, particularly the Government's efforts to Yes, particularly the Government's efforts to secure Yes, particularly the Government's efforts to secure our Yes, particularly the Government's efforts to secure our recovery Yes, particularly the Government's efforts to secure our recovery which efforts to secure our recovery which have efforts to secure our recovery which have been efforts to secure our recovery which have been reflected efforts to secure our recovery which have been reflected in efforts to secure our recovery which have been reflected in GDP have been reflected in GDP increasing have been reflected in GDP increasing 1.6% have been reflected in GDP increasing 1.6% in have been reflected in GDP increasing 1.6% in the have been reflected in GDP increasing 1.6% in the first have been reflected in GDP increasing 1.6% in the first three increasing 1.6% in the first three months increasing 1.6% in the first three months of increasing 1.6% in the first three months of 2021. increasing 1.6% in the first three months of 2021. Overall increasing 1.6% in the first three months of 2021. Overall the increasing 1.6% in the first three months of 2021. Overall the economy months of 2021. Overall the economy was months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% above months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% above where months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% above where it months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% above where it was months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% above where it was in months of 2021. Overall the economy was 2.4% above where it was in the was 2.4% above where it was in the March was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter last was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter last year was 2.4% above where it was in the March quarter last year out March quarter last year out performing March quarter last year out performing the March quarter last year out performing the countries March quarter last year out performing the countries we March quarter last year out performing the countries we compare performing the countries we compare ourselves performing the countries we compare ourselves to performing the countries we compare ourselves to such performing the countries we compare ourselves to such as performing the countries we compare ourselves to such as Australia, performing the countries we compare ourselves to such as Australia, the ourselves to such as Australia, the United ourselves to such as Australia, the United States, ourselves to such as Australia, the United States, Canada, ourselves to such as Australia, the United States, Canada, the ourselves to such as Australia, the United States, Canada, the United United States, Canada, the United Kingdom United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Japan. United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Japan. While United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Japan. While there United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Japan. While there is United States, Canada, the United Kingdom and Japan. While there is a Kingdom and Japan. While there is a lot Kingdom and Japan. While there is a lot of Kingdom and Japan. While there is a lot of uncertainty Kingdom and Japan. While there is a lot of uncertainty on Kingdom and Japan. While there is a lot of uncertainty on how Kingdom and Japan. While there is a lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 will lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 will affect lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 will affect different lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 will affect different parts lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 will affect different parts of lot of uncertainty on how COVID-19 will affect different parts of the will affect different parts of the global will affect different parts of the global economy, will affect different parts of the global economy, our will affect different parts of the global economy, our recovery will affect different parts of the global economy, our recovery plan will affect different parts of the global economy, our recovery plan is global economy, our recovery plan is to global economy, our recovery plan is to keep global economy, our recovery plan is to keep people global economy, our recovery plan is to keep people in global economy, our recovery plan is to keep people in jobs global economy, our recovery plan is to keep people in jobs with to keep people in jobs with unemployment to keep people in jobs with unemployment in to keep people in jobs with unemployment in the to keep people in jobs with unemployment in the March to keep people in jobs with unemployment in the March quarter to keep people in jobs with unemployment in the March quarter of unemployment in the March quarter of 4.7% unemployment in the March quarter of 4.7% and unemployment in the March quarter of 4.7% and supported unemployment in the March quarter of 4.7% and supported businesses unemployment in the March quarter of 4.7% and supported businesses with 4.7% and supported businesses with ongoing 4.7% and supported businesses with ongoing targeted 4.7% and supported businesses with ongoing targeted stimulus. 4.7% and supported businesses with ongoing targeted stimulus. The ongoing targeted stimulus. The Government ongoing targeted stimulus. The Government will ongoing targeted stimulus. The Government will keep ongoing targeted stimulus. The Government will keep its ongoing targeted stimulus. The Government will keep its focus ongoing targeted stimulus. The Government will keep its focus on Government will keep its focus on keeping Government will keep its focus on keeping New Government will keep its focus on keeping New Zealanders Government will keep its focus on keeping New Zealanders safe Government will keep its focus on keeping New Zealanders safe from keeping New Zealanders safe from COVID-19, keeping New Zealanders safe from COVID-19, accelerating keeping New Zealanders safe from COVID-19, accelerating our keeping New Zealanders safe from COVID-19, accelerating our recovery COVID-19, accelerating our recovery and COVID-19, accelerating our recovery and making COVID-19, accelerating our recovery and making progress COVID-19, accelerating our recovery and making progress on COVID-19, accelerating our recovery and making progress on long COVID-19, accelerating our recovery and making progress on long standing and making progress on long standing issues and making progress on long standing issues such and making progress on long standing issues such as and making progress on long standing issues such as climate and making progress on long standing issues such as climate change, issues such as climate change, housing issues such as climate change, housing and issues such as climate change, housing and child issues such as climate change, housing and child wellbeing. issues such as climate change, housing and child wellbeing. Does housing and child wellbeing. Does she housing and child wellbeing. Does she think housing and child wellbeing. Does she think New housing and child wellbeing. Does she think New Zealanders housing and child wellbeing. Does she think New Zealanders would housing and child wellbeing. Does she think New Zealanders would have she think New Zealanders would have expected she think New Zealanders would have expected her she think New Zealanders would have expected her Government she think New Zealanders would have expected her Government to she think New Zealanders would have expected her Government to have expected her Government to have delivered expected her Government to have delivered more expected her Government to have delivered more than expected her Government to have delivered more than just expected her Government to have delivered more than just five expected her Government to have delivered more than just five extra delivered more than just five extra acute delivered more than just five extra acute mental delivered more than just five extra acute mental health delivered more than just five extra acute mental health beds delivered more than just five extra acute mental health beds in delivered more than just five extra acute mental health beds in the delivered more than just five extra acute mental health beds in the two acute mental health beds in the two years acute mental health beds in the two years since acute mental health beds in the two years since she acute mental health beds in the two years since she announced acute mental health beds in the two years since she announced $1.9 years since she announced $1.9 billion years since she announced $1.9 billion for years since she announced $1.9 billion for mental years since she announced $1.9 billion for mental health? years since she announced $1.9 billion for mental health? On years since she announced $1.9 billion for mental health? On our billion for mental health? On our mental billion for mental health? On our mental health billion for mental health? On our mental health programme, billion for mental health? On our mental health programme, we billion for mental health? On our mental health programme, we were mental health programme, we were very mental health programme, we were very clear mental health programme, we were very clear from mental health programme, we were very clear from the mental health programme, we were very clear from the outset mental health programme, we were very clear from the outset that mental health programme, we were very clear from the outset that we very clear from the outset that we wanted very clear from the outset that we wanted to very clear from the outset that we wanted to focus very clear from the outset that we wanted to focus on very clear from the outset that we wanted to focus on trying very clear from the outset that we wanted to focus on trying to very clear from the outset that we wanted to focus on trying to support wanted to focus on trying to support those wanted to focus on trying to support those New wanted to focus on trying to support those New Zealanders wanted to focus on trying to support those New Zealanders who wanted to focus on trying to support those New Zealanders who find those New Zealanders who find themselves those New Zealanders who find themselves in those New Zealanders who find themselves in our those New Zealanders who find themselves in our mental those New Zealanders who find themselves in our mental health themselves in our mental health system themselves in our mental health system and themselves in our mental health system and often themselves in our mental health system and often at themselves in our mental health system and often at the themselves in our mental health system and often at the very themselves in our mental health system and often at the very acute system and often at the very acute end system and often at the very acute end without system and often at the very acute end without necessarily system and often at the very acute end without necessarily having system and often at the very acute end without necessarily having had end without necessarily having had support end without necessarily having had support through end without necessarily having had support through primary end without necessarily having had support through primary mental support through primary mental health support through primary mental health services. support through primary mental health services. So support through primary mental health services. So we support through primary mental health services. So we have support through primary mental health services. So we have been health services. So we have been building health services. So we have been building those health services. So we have been building those primary health services. So we have been building those primary mental health services. So we have been building those primary mental health building those primary mental health services. building those primary mental health services. 1.4 building those primary mental health services. 1.4 million building those primary mental health services. 1.4 million New building those primary mental health services. 1.4 million New Zealanders services. 1.4 million New Zealanders are services. 1.4 million New Zealanders are now services. 1.4 million New Zealanders are now enrolled services. 1.4 million New Zealanders are now enrolled in services. 1.4 million New Zealanders are now enrolled in primary services. 1.4 million New Zealanders are now enrolled in primary health are now enrolled in primary health care are now enrolled in primary health care with are now enrolled in primary health care with access are now enrolled in primary health care with access to are now enrolled in primary health care with access to mental are now enrolled in primary health care with access to mental health care with access to mental health and care with access to mental health and addiction care with access to mental health and addiction services. care with access to mental health and addiction services. They care with access to mental health and addiction services. They are and addiction services. They are offering and addiction services. They are offering 10,000 and addiction services. They are offering 10,000 sessions and addiction services. They are offering 10,000 sessions per and addiction services. They are offering 10,000 sessions per month. offering 10,000 sessions per month. Those offering 10,000 sessions per month. Those are offering 10,000 sessions per month. Those are sessions offering 10,000 sessions per month. Those are sessions that offering 10,000 sessions per month. Those are sessions that did offering 10,000 sessions per month. Those are sessions that did not Those are sessions that did not exist Those are sessions that did not exist before. Those are sessions that did not exist before. Take Those are sessions that did not exist before. Take that Those are sessions that did not exist before. Take that alongside exist before. Take that alongside funding exist before. Take that alongside funding for exist before. Take that alongside funding for youthline, exist before. Take that alongside funding for youthline, for exist before. Take that alongside funding for youthline, for our exist before. Take that alongside funding for youthline, for our youth funding for youthline, for our youth health funding for youthline, for our youth health services, funding for youthline, for our youth health services, the funding for youthline, for our youth health services, the roll funding for youthline, for our youth health services, the roll out funding for youthline, for our youth health services, the roll out of health services, the roll out of health health services, the roll out of health services health services, the roll out of health services in health services, the roll out of health services in schools, health services, the roll out of health services in schools, Mana health services, the roll out of health services in schools, Mana Ake health services in schools, Mana Ake and health services in schools, Mana Ake and counselling health services in schools, Mana Ake and counselling services health services in schools, Mana Ake and counselling services in health services in schools, Mana Ake and counselling services in schools, and counselling services in schools, we and counselling services in schools, we are and counselling services in schools, we are building and counselling services in schools, we are building the and counselling services in schools, we are building the front and counselling services in schools, we are building the front end and counselling services in schools, we are building the front end of we are building the front end of mental we are building the front end of mental health. we are building the front end of mental health. When we are building the front end of mental health. When it we are building the front end of mental health. When it comes we are building the front end of mental health. When it comes to mental health. When it comes to capital mental health. When it comes to capital and mental health. When it comes to capital and bed mental health. When it comes to capital and bed space mental health. When it comes to capital and bed space the mental health. When it comes to capital and bed space the member capital and bed space the member will capital and bed space the member will know capital and bed space the member will know well capital and bed space the member will know well the capital and bed space the member will know well the time capital and bed space the member will know well the time it capital and bed space the member will know well the time it takes. capital and bed space the member will know well the time it takes. I will know well the time it takes. I understand will know well the time it takes. I understand in will know well the time it takes. I understand in 2015, will know well the time it takes. I understand in 2015, Minister will know well the time it takes. I understand in 2015, Minister Little, understand in 2015, Minister Little, that understand in 2015, Minister Little, that one understand in 2015, Minister Little, that one programme understand in 2015, Minister Little, that one programme or understand in 2015, Minister Little, that one programme or project understand in 2015, Minister Little, that one programme or project that that one programme or project that National that one programme or project that National funded that one programme or project that National funded took that one programme or project that National funded took over that one programme or project that National funded took over five that one programme or project that National funded took over five years National funded took over five years to National funded took over five years to deliver. National funded took over five years to deliver. We National funded took over five years to deliver. We want National funded took over five years to deliver. We want to National funded took over five years to deliver. We want to do National funded took over five years to deliver. We want to do things to deliver. We want to do things more to deliver. We want to do things more quickly to deliver. We want to do things more quickly than to deliver. We want to do things more quickly than that to deliver. We want to do things more quickly than that but to deliver. We want to do things more quickly than that but building more quickly than that but building buildings more quickly than that but building buildings and more quickly than that but building buildings and creating more quickly than that but building buildings and creating bed more quickly than that but building buildings and creating bed space buildings and creating bed space does buildings and creating bed space does take buildings and creating bed space does take longer. buildings and creating bed space does take longer. Why buildings and creating bed space does take longer. Why does buildings and creating bed space does take longer. Why does it buildings and creating bed space does take longer. Why does it take does take longer. Why does it take two does take longer. Why does it take two years does take longer. Why does it take two years just does take longer. Why does it take two years just to does take longer. Why does it take two years just to put does take longer. Why does it take two years just to put in does take longer. Why does it take two years just to put in five does take longer. Why does it take two years just to put in five extra two years just to put in five extra acute two years just to put in five extra acute mental two years just to put in five extra acute mental health two years just to put in five extra acute mental health beds? two years just to put in five extra acute mental health beds? Under two years just to put in five extra acute mental health beds? Under that acute mental health beds? Under that Government acute mental health beds? Under that Government there acute mental health beds? Under that Government there was acute mental health beds? Under that Government there was no acute mental health beds? Under that Government there was no business Government there was no business cases Government there was no business cases for Government there was no business cases for any Government there was no business cases for any new Government there was no business cases for any new acute Government there was no business cases for any new acute mental cases for any new acute mental health cases for any new acute mental health services. cases for any new acute mental health services. We cases for any new acute mental health services. We have cases for any new acute mental health services. We have had cases for any new acute mental health services. We have had to health services. We have had to build health services. We have had to build from health services. We have had to build from scratch health services. We have had to build from scratch in health services. We have had to build from scratch in some health services. We have had to build from scratch in some areas. build from scratch in some areas. For build from scratch in some areas. For instance, build from scratch in some areas. For instance, in build from scratch in some areas. For instance, in the build from scratch in some areas. For instance, in the East build from scratch in some areas. For instance, in the East Coast For instance, in the East Coast where For instance, in the East Coast where there For instance, in the East Coast where there have For instance, in the East Coast where there have not For instance, in the East Coast where there have not been For instance, in the East Coast where there have not been drug For instance, in the East Coast where there have not been drug and where there have not been drug and alcohol where there have not been drug and alcohol addiction where there have not been drug and alcohol addiction rehabilitation alcohol addiction rehabilitation beds alcohol addiction rehabilitation beds we alcohol addiction rehabilitation beds we are alcohol addiction rehabilitation beds we are starting alcohol addiction rehabilitation beds we are starting from alcohol addiction rehabilitation beds we are starting from scratch. beds we are starting from scratch. So beds we are starting from scratch. So the beds we are starting from scratch. So the member beds we are starting from scratch. So the member may beds we are starting from scratch. So the member may like beds we are starting from scratch. So the member may like to beds we are starting from scratch. So the member may like to reflect beds we are starting from scratch. So the member may like to reflect on So the member may like to reflect on her So the member may like to reflect on her own So the member may like to reflect on her own time So the member may like to reflect on her own time in So the member may like to reflect on her own time in office So the member may like to reflect on her own time in office as So the member may like to reflect on her own time in office as to So the member may like to reflect on her own time in office as to why So the member may like to reflect on her own time in office as to why we her own time in office as to why we have her own time in office as to why we have had her own time in office as to why we have had to her own time in office as to why we have had to do her own time in office as to why we have had to do that. her own time in office as to why we have had to do that. Is her own time in office as to why we have had to do that. Is she have had to do that. Is she satisfied have had to do that. Is she satisfied with have had to do that. Is she satisfied with the have had to do that. Is she satisfied with the implementation have had to do that. Is she satisfied with the implementation of satisfied with the implementation of her satisfied with the implementation of her $1.9 satisfied with the implementation of her $1.9 billion satisfied with the implementation of her $1.9 billion mental satisfied with the implementation of her $1.9 billion mental health her $1.9 billion mental health announcement her $1.9 billion mental health announcement from her $1.9 billion mental health announcement from Budget her $1.9 billion mental health announcement from Budget 2019 her $1.9 billion mental health announcement from Budget 2019 when announcement from Budget 2019 when only announcement from Budget 2019 when only 0.2% announcement from Budget 2019 when only 0.2% of announcement from Budget 2019 when only 0.2% of the announcement from Budget 2019 when only 0.2% of the funding announcement from Budget 2019 when only 0.2% of the funding for announcement from Budget 2019 when only 0.2% of the funding for new only 0.2% of the funding for new facilities only 0.2% of the funding for new facilities has only 0.2% of the funding for new facilities has been only 0.2% of the funding for new facilities has been spent only 0.2% of the funding for new facilities has been spent after only 0.2% of the funding for new facilities has been spent after two facilities has been spent after two years? facilities has been spent after two years? Over facilities has been spent after two years? Over 200 facilities has been spent after two years? Over 200 general facilities has been spent after two years? Over 200 general practice years? Over 200 general practice sites years? Over 200 general practice sites are years? Over 200 general practice sites are delivering years? Over 200 general practice sites are delivering integrated sites are delivering integrated primary sites are delivering integrated primary mental sites are delivering integrated primary mental health sites are delivering integrated primary mental health and sites are delivering integrated primary mental health and addiction primary mental health and addiction services. primary mental health and addiction services. Over primary mental health and addiction services. Over 520 primary mental health and addiction services. Over 520 full-time services. Over 520 full-time equivalents services. Over 520 full-time equivalents are services. Over 520 full-time equivalents are contracted services. Over 520 full-time equivalents are contracted to equivalents are contracted to provide equivalents are contracted to provide services. equivalents are contracted to provide services. 134,000 equivalents are contracted to provide services. 134,000 sessions provide services. 134,000 sessions have provide services. 134,000 sessions have been provide services. 134,000 sessions have been delivered provide services. 134,000 sessions have been delivered by provide services. 134,000 sessions have been delivered by new provide services. 134,000 sessions have been delivered by new primary have been delivered by new primary mental have been delivered by new primary mental health have been delivered by new primary mental health and have been delivered by new primary mental health and addiction have been delivered by new primary mental health and addiction services mental health and addiction services since mental health and addiction services since your mental health and addiction services since your announcements, mental health and addiction services since your announcements, 96,000 since your announcements, 96,000 students since your announcements, 96,000 students have since your announcements, 96,000 students have accessed since your announcements, 96,000 students have accessed the students have accessed the school-based students have accessed the school-based health students have accessed the school-based health services. students have accessed the school-based health services. 800 school-based health services. 800 additional school-based health services. 800 additional Maori school-based health services. 800 additional Maori and school-based health services. 800 additional Maori and Pacific school-based health services. 800 additional Maori and Pacific Maori additional Maori and Pacific Maori competence additional Maori and Pacific Maori competence cultural additional Maori and Pacific Maori competence cultural workforce additional Maori and Pacific Maori competence cultural workforce places competence cultural workforce places every competence cultural workforce places every year. competence cultural workforce places every year. 1,400 competence cultural workforce places every year. 1,400 place competence cultural workforce places every year. 1,400 place are every year. 1,400 place are supported every year. 1,400 place are supported by every year. 1,400 place are supported by the every year. 1,400 place are supported by the meth every year. 1,400 place are supported by the meth harm every year. 1,400 place are supported by the meth harm reduction supported by the meth harm reduction programme. supported by the meth harm reduction programme. 74 supported by the meth harm reduction programme. 74 Maori supported by the meth harm reduction programme. 74 Maori and supported by the meth harm reduction programme. 74 Maori and 18 supported by the meth harm reduction programme. 74 Maori and 18 Pacific programme. 74 Maori and 18 Pacific suicide programme. 74 Maori and 18 Pacific suicide prevention programme. 74 Maori and 18 Pacific suicide prevention suicide suicide prevention suicide initiatives suicide prevention suicide initiatives have suicide prevention suicide initiatives have been suicide prevention suicide initiatives have been funded. suicide prevention suicide initiatives have been funded. Mana initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake has initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake has been initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake has been expanded initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake has been expanded into initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake has been expanded into five initiatives have been funded. Mana Ake has been expanded into five new Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and we Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and we have Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and we have put Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and we have put $200 Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and we have put $200 million Ake has been expanded into five new DHBs and we have put $200 million in DHBs and we have put $200 million in for DHBs and we have put $200 million in for new DHBs and we have put $200 million in for new and DHBs and we have put $200 million in for new and existing DHBs and we have put $200 million in for new and existing mental DHBs and we have put $200 million in for new and existing mental health for new and existing mental health addiction for new and existing mental health addiction facilities for new and existing mental health addiction facilities which for new and existing mental health addiction facilities which we addiction facilities which we continue addiction facilities which we continue to addiction facilities which we continue to rolling addiction facilities which we continue to rolling out addiction facilities which we continue to rolling out and addiction facilities which we continue to rolling out and building continue to rolling out and building that continue to rolling out and building that capability. continue to rolling out and building that capability. What continue to rolling out and building that capability. What is continue to rolling out and building that capability. What is responsible that capability. What is responsible for that capability. What is responsible for the that capability. What is responsible for the failure that capability. What is responsible for the failure to that capability. What is responsible for the failure to deliver that capability. What is responsible for the failure to deliver on that capability. What is responsible for the failure to deliver on the for the failure to deliver on the $1.9 for the failure to deliver on the $1.9 billion for the failure to deliver on the $1.9 billion committed for the failure to deliver on the $1.9 billion committed by for the failure to deliver on the $1.9 billion committed by - for the failure to deliver on the $1.9 billion committed by - more $1.9 billion committed by - more mental $1.9 billion committed by - more mental health $1.9 billion committed by - more mental health in $1.9 billion committed by - more mental health in Budget $1.9 billion committed by - more mental health in Budget 2019 $1.9 billion committed by - more mental health in Budget 2019 that mental health in Budget 2019 that has mental health in Budget 2019 that has seen mental health in Budget 2019 that has seen only mental health in Budget 2019 that has seen only 0.2% mental health in Budget 2019 that has seen only 0.2% of mental health in Budget 2019 that has seen only 0.2% of the mental health in Budget 2019 that has seen only 0.2% of the funding has seen only 0.2% of the funding spent? has seen only 0.2% of the funding spent? I has seen only 0.2% of the funding spent? I completely has seen only 0.2% of the funding spent? I completely reject has seen only 0.2% of the funding spent? I completely reject the spent? I completely reject the premise spent? I completely reject the premise of spent? I completely reject the premise of that spent? I completely reject the premise of that question. premise of that question. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Is <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Is the <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Is the review <INTERRUPTION> Supplementary. Is the review into Supplementary. Is the review into mental Supplementary. Is the review into mental health Supplementary. Is the review into mental health funding Supplementary. Is the review into mental health funding just Supplementary. Is the review into mental health funding just announced mental health funding just announced an mental health funding just announced an admission mental health funding just announced an admission of mental health funding just announced an admission of her mental health funding just announced an admission of her Government's an admission of her Government's failure an admission of her Government's failure to an admission of her Government's failure to deliver an admission of her Government's failure to deliver on an admission of her Government's failure to deliver on the an admission of her Government's failure to deliver on the mental failure to deliver on the mental health failure to deliver on the mental health promises failure to deliver on the mental health promises of failure to deliver on the mental health promises of 2019? failure to deliver on the mental health promises of 2019? No. failure to deliver on the mental health promises of 2019? No. And failure to deliver on the mental health promises of 2019? No. And I health promises of 2019? No. And I say health promises of 2019? No. And I say again health promises of 2019? No. And I say again in health promises of 2019? No. And I say again in 2019 health promises of 2019? No. And I say again in 2019 - health promises of 2019? No. And I say again in 2019 - in health promises of 2019? No. And I say again in 2019 - in 2019 health promises of 2019? No. And I say again in 2019 - in 2019 we say again in 2019 - in 2019 we announce say again in 2019 - in 2019 we announce $1.9 say again in 2019 - in 2019 we announce $1.9 billion say again in 2019 - in 2019 we announce $1.9 billion across say again in 2019 - in 2019 we announce $1.9 billion across mental announce $1.9 billion across mental health announce $1.9 billion across mental health addiction announce $1.9 billion across mental health addiction services announce $1.9 billion across mental health addiction services and health addiction services and homelessness. health addiction services and homelessness. 10,000 health addiction services and homelessness. 10,000 sessions health addiction services and homelessness. 10,000 sessions of homelessness. 10,000 sessions of care homelessness. 10,000 sessions of care are homelessness. 10,000 sessions of care are being homelessness. 10,000 sessions of care are being provided homelessness. 10,000 sessions of care are being provided every homelessness. 10,000 sessions of care are being provided every month. care are being provided every month. We care are being provided every month. We are care are being provided every month. We are rolling care are being provided every month. We are rolling out care are being provided every month. We are rolling out into care are being provided every month. We are rolling out into schools. care are being provided every month. We are rolling out into schools. We We are rolling out into schools. We are We are rolling out into schools. We are funding We are rolling out into schools. We are funding support We are rolling out into schools. We are funding support for We are rolling out into schools. We are funding support for our We are rolling out into schools. We are funding support for our young are funding support for our young people, are funding support for our young people, we are funding support for our young people, we are are funding support for our young people, we are providing are funding support for our young people, we are providing CBT people, we are providing CBT training people, we are providing CBT training that people, we are providing CBT training that never people, we are providing CBT training that never used people, we are providing CBT training that never used to people, we are providing CBT training that never used to exist. training that never used to exist. So, training that never used to exist. So, Mr training that never used to exist. So, Mr Speaker, training that never used to exist. So, Mr Speaker, I training that never used to exist. So, Mr Speaker, I totally training that never used to exist. So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject training that never used to exist. So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject the So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject the member's So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject the member's suggestion So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject the member's suggestion that So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject the member's suggestion that nothing So, Mr Speaker, I totally reject the member's suggestion that nothing has member's suggestion that nothing has happened member's suggestion that nothing has happened in member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this space member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this space - member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this space - it member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this space - it is member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this space - it is - member's suggestion that nothing has happened in this space - it is - but happened in this space - it is - but it happened in this space - it is - but it takes happened in this space - it is - but it takes time happened in this space - it is - but it takes time to happened in this space - it is - but it takes time to build happened in this space - it is - but it takes time to build from happened in this space - it is - but it takes time to build from nothing. it takes time to build from nothing. Supplementary. it takes time to build from nothing. Supplementary. Is it takes time to build from nothing. Supplementary. Is it it takes time to build from nothing. Supplementary. Is it fair it takes time to build from nothing. Supplementary. Is it fair to it takes time to build from nothing. Supplementary. Is it fair to make Supplementary. Is it fair to make trades Supplementary. Is it fair to make trades people, Supplementary. Is it fair to make trades people, farmers Supplementary. Is it fair to make trades people, farmers or Supplementary. Is it fair to make trades people, farmers or large trades people, farmers or large families trades people, farmers or large families even trades people, farmers or large families even pay trades people, farmers or large families even pay to trades people, farmers or large families even pay to subsidise families even pay to subsidise someone families even pay to subsidise someone who families even pay to subsidise someone who can families even pay to subsidise someone who can afford families even pay to subsidise someone who can afford a families even pay to subsidise someone who can afford a brand families even pay to subsidise someone who can afford a brand new someone who can afford a brand new $70,000 someone who can afford a brand new $70,000 Tesla someone who can afford a brand new $70,000 Tesla model someone who can afford a brand new $70,000 Tesla model 3. someone who can afford a brand new $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually someone who can afford a brand new $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that as $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that as the $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that as the member $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that as the member would $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that as the member would have $70,000 Tesla model 3. Actually on that as the member would have heard that as the member would have heard me that as the member would have heard me say that as the member would have heard me say earlier that as the member would have heard me say earlier in that as the member would have heard me say earlier in one that as the member would have heard me say earlier in one of that as the member would have heard me say earlier in one of my that as the member would have heard me say earlier in one of my answers, me say earlier in one of my answers, in me say earlier in one of my answers, in fact me say earlier in one of my answers, in fact one me say earlier in one of my answers, in fact one of me say earlier in one of my answers, in fact one of our me say earlier in one of my answers, in fact one of our designs me say earlier in one of my answers, in fact one of our designs around in fact one of our designs around the in fact one of our designs around the scheme in fact one of our designs around the scheme we in fact one of our designs around the scheme we have in fact one of our designs around the scheme we have means in fact one of our designs around the scheme we have means that in fact one of our designs around the scheme we have means that we in fact one of our designs around the scheme we have means that we are the scheme we have means that we are not the scheme we have means that we are not just the scheme we have means that we are not just creating the scheme we have means that we are not just creating incentives the scheme we have means that we are not just creating incentives around not just creating incentives around EVs not just creating incentives around EVs and not just creating incentives around EVs and hybrids not just creating incentives around EVs and hybrids but not just creating incentives around EVs and hybrids but low-emissions EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles and EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles and that EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles and that means EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles and that means eight EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles and that means eight out EVs and hybrids but low-emissions vehicles and that means eight out of vehicles and that means eight out of ten vehicles and that means eight out of ten of vehicles and that means eight out of ten of the vehicles and that means eight out of ten of the most vehicles and that means eight out of ten of the most popular vehicles and that means eight out of ten of the most popular vehicles ten of the most popular vehicles that ten of the most popular vehicles that are ten of the most popular vehicles that are purchased ten of the most popular vehicles that are purchased in ten of the most popular vehicles that are purchased in the that are purchased in the second-hand that are purchased in the second-hand market that are purchased in the second-hand market in that are purchased in the second-hand market in New that are purchased in the second-hand market in New Zealand second-hand market in New Zealand either second-hand market in New Zealand either attract second-hand market in New Zealand either attract no second-hand market in New Zealand either attract no fee second-hand market in New Zealand either attract no fee or second-hand market in New Zealand either attract no fee or attract second-hand market in New Zealand either attract no fee or attract a either attract no fee or attract a discount. either attract no fee or attract a discount. So either attract no fee or attract a discount. So in either attract no fee or attract a discount. So in our either attract no fee or attract a discount. So in our mind either attract no fee or attract a discount. So in our mind it either attract no fee or attract a discount. So in our mind it is discount. So in our mind it is supporting discount. So in our mind it is supporting New discount. So in our mind it is supporting New Zealanders discount. So in our mind it is supporting New Zealanders to discount. So in our mind it is supporting New Zealanders to have supporting New Zealanders to have options supporting New Zealanders to have options around supporting New Zealanders to have options around vehicles supporting New Zealanders to have options around vehicles that supporting New Zealanders to have options around vehicles that are options around vehicles that are often options around vehicles that are often already options around vehicles that are often already popular. options around vehicles that are often already popular. Does options around vehicles that are often already popular. Does she often already popular. Does she agree often already popular. Does she agree with often already popular. Does she agree with her often already popular. Does she agree with her Minister often already popular. Does she agree with her Minister of often already popular. Does she agree with her Minister of Revenue agree with her Minister of Revenue that agree with her Minister of Revenue that "we've agree with her Minister of Revenue that "we've made agree with her Minister of Revenue that "we've made commitments agree with her Minister of Revenue that "we've made commitments that that "we've made commitments that we're that "we've made commitments that we're not that "we've made commitments that we're not making that "we've made commitments that we're not making new that "we've made commitments that we're not making new taxes that "we've made commitments that we're not making new taxes this we're not making new taxes this term"? we're not making new taxes this term"? If we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, how we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, how is we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, how is a we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, how is a $3,000 we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax we're not making new taxes this term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota Hilux term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota Hilux not term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota Hilux not a term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota Hilux not a tax? term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The term"? If so, how is a $3,000 tax on a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows that a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows that of a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows that of course a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows that of course if a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows that of course if you a Toyota Hilux not a tax? The member well knows that of course if you are well knows that of course if you are able well knows that of course if you are able to well knows that of course if you are able to legitimately well knows that of course if you are able to legitimately avoid well knows that of course if you are able to legitimately avoid paying well knows that of course if you are able to legitimately avoid paying a able to legitimately avoid paying a fee able to legitimately avoid paying a fee by able to legitimately avoid paying a fee by making able to legitimately avoid paying a fee by making a able to legitimately avoid paying a fee by making a different able to legitimately avoid paying a fee by making a different choice fee by making a different choice and, fee by making a different choice and, for fee by making a different choice and, for instance, fee by making a different choice and, for instance, you fee by making a different choice and, for instance, you have fee by making a different choice and, for instance, you have an and, for instance, you have an incentives and, for instance, you have an incentives regime and, for instance, you have an incentives regime attached and, for instance, you have an incentives regime attached that and, for instance, you have an incentives regime attached that is incentives regime attached that is not incentives regime attached that is not the incentives regime attached that is not the common incentives regime attached that is not the common definition incentives regime attached that is not the common definition of incentives regime attached that is not the common definition of a incentives regime attached that is not the common definition of a tax. not the common definition of a tax. What not the common definition of a tax. What I not the common definition of a tax. What I would not the common definition of a tax. What I would also not the common definition of a tax. What I would also say not the common definition of a tax. What I would also say is not the common definition of a tax. What I would also say is that not the common definition of a tax. What I would also say is that on What I would also say is that on that What I would also say is that on that side What I would also say is that on that side of What I would also say is that on that side of the What I would also say is that on that side of the House What I would also say is that on that side of the House based What I would also say is that on that side of the House based on What I would also say is that on that side of the House based on what that side of the House based on what I've that side of the House based on what I've seen that side of the House based on what I've seen according that side of the House based on what I've seen according to that side of the House based on what I've seen according to at that side of the House based on what I've seen according to at least I've seen according to at least Chris I've seen according to at least Chris Bishop, I've seen according to at least Chris Bishop, National I've seen according to at least Chris Bishop, National is I've seen according to at least Chris Bishop, National is meant I've seen according to at least Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 be Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 be the Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 be the party Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 be the party of Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 be the party of electric Chris Bishop, National is meant 20 be the party of electric vehicles. be the party of electric vehicles. -- be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be the be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be the party be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be the party of be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be the party of electric -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. If -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. If the -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. If the member -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. If the member is -- meant to be the party of electric vehicles. If the member is proposing vehicles. If the member is proposing that vehicles. If the member is proposing that they vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do not vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do not wish vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do not wish to vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do not wish to have vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do not wish to have a vehicles. If the member is proposing that they do not wish to have a fee that they do not wish to have a fee regime that they do not wish to have a fee regime attached that they do not wish to have a fee regime attached then that they do not wish to have a fee regime attached then that that they do not wish to have a fee regime attached then that is that they do not wish to have a fee regime attached then that is $1 regime attached then that is $1 billion regime attached then that is $1 billion - regime attached then that is $1 billion - $1 regime attached then that is $1 billion - $1 billion regime attached then that is $1 billion - $1 billion - regime attached then that is $1 billion - $1 billion - over regime attached then that is $1 billion - $1 billion - over 10 regime attached then that is $1 billion - $1 billion - over 10 years billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to fund billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to fund an billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to fund an incentives billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to fund an incentives regime billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to fund an incentives regime if billion - $1 billion - over 10 years to fund an incentives regime if it to fund an incentives regime if it does to fund an incentives regime if it does not to fund an incentives regime if it does not have to fund an incentives regime if it does not have a to fund an incentives regime if it does not have a fee to fund an incentives regime if it does not have a fee regime to fund an incentives regime if it does not have a fee regime attached. does not have a fee regime attached. I does not have a fee regime attached. I would does not have a fee regime attached. I would like does not have a fee regime attached. I would like to does not have a fee regime attached. I would like to know does not have a fee regime attached. I would like to know how does not have a fee regime attached. I would like to know how the I would like to know how the National I would like to know how the National Party I would like to know how the National Party would I would like to know how the National Party would pay I would like to know how the National Party would pay for I would like to know how the National Party would pay for that. I I would I would like I would like to I would like to know I would like to know how I would like to know how the I would like to know how the National I would like to know how the National Party I would like to know how the National Party would I would like to know how the National Party would pay I would like to know how the National Party would pay for I would like to know how the National Party would pay for that. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Oceans My question is to the Minister for Oceans and My question is to the Minister for Oceans and Fisheries: My question is to the Minister for Oceans and Fisheries: What Oceans and Fisheries: What announcements Oceans and Fisheries: What announcements has Oceans and Fisheries: What announcements has he Oceans and Fisheries: What announcements has he made Oceans and Fisheries: What announcements has he made about announcements has he made about improving announcements has he made about improving the announcements has he made about improving the sustainability announcements has he made about improving the sustainability of announcements has he made about improving the sustainability of the improving the sustainability of the marine improving the sustainability of the marine environment? This This morning This morning Dr This morning Dr Ayesha This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall as This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall as Minister This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall as Minister of This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall as Minister of Conservation, This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall as Minister of Conservation, and This morning Dr Ayesha Verrall as Minister of Conservation, and I, Minister of Conservation, and I, launched Minister of Conservation, and I, launched the Minister of Conservation, and I, launched the Government's Minister of Conservation, and I, launched the Government's plan Minister of Conservation, and I, launched the Government's plan to launched the Government's plan to revitalise launched the Government's plan to revitalise the launched the Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki launched the Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. launched the Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This delivers revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This delivers on revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This delivers on an revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This delivers on an election revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This delivers on an election promise. revitalise the Hauraki Gulf. This delivers on an election promise. It delivers on an election promise. It is delivers on an election promise. It is our delivers on an election promise. It is our busiest delivers on an election promise. It is our busiest environment, delivers on an election promise. It is our busiest environment, it is our busiest environment, it includes is our busiest environment, it includes the is our busiest environment, it includes the Auckland is our busiest environment, it includes the Auckland port is our busiest environment, it includes the Auckland port earn includes the Auckland port earn beaches, includes the Auckland port earn beaches, is includes the Auckland port earn beaches, is popular includes the Auckland port earn beaches, is popular for includes the Auckland port earn beaches, is popular for boating includes the Auckland port earn beaches, is popular for boating and beaches, is popular for boating and fishing beaches, is popular for boating and fishing and beaches, is popular for boating and fishing and is beaches, is popular for boating and fishing and is home beaches, is popular for boating and fishing and is home to beaches, is popular for boating and fishing and is home to aqua beaches, is popular for boating and fishing and is home to aqua culture fishing and is home to aqua culture and fishing and is home to aqua culture and a fishing and is home to aqua culture and a vast fishing and is home to aqua culture and a vast array fishing and is home to aqua culture and a vast array of fishing and is home to aqua culture and a vast array of We fishing and is home to aqua culture and a vast array of We -- and a vast array of We -- biodiversity. and a vast array of We -- biodiversity. The and a vast array of We -- biodiversity. The strategies and a vast array of We -- biodiversity. The strategies and biodiversity. The strategies and actions biodiversity. The strategies and actions will biodiversity. The strategies and actions will work biodiversity. The strategies and actions will work alongside biodiversity. The strategies and actions will work alongside the actions will work alongside the essential actions will work alongside the essential water actions will work alongside the essential water programme actions will work alongside the essential water programme in actions will work alongside the essential water programme in respect essential water programme in respect of essential water programme in respect of sediment essential water programme in respect of sediment issues essential water programme in respect of sediment issues sustained essential water programme in respect of sediment issues sustained action of sediment issues sustained action in of sediment issues sustained action in the of sediment issues sustained action in the Gulf of sediment issues sustained action in the Gulf is of sediment issues sustained action in the Gulf is necessary of sediment issues sustained action in the Gulf is necessary to of sediment issues sustained action in the Gulf is necessary to ensure in the Gulf is necessary to ensure that in the Gulf is necessary to ensure that its in the Gulf is necessary to ensure that its environmental, in the Gulf is necessary to ensure that its environmental, cultural in the Gulf is necessary to ensure that its environmental, cultural and that its environmental, cultural and economic that its environmental, cultural and economic benefits that its environmental, cultural and economic benefits can that its environmental, cultural and economic benefits can continue that its environmental, cultural and economic benefits can continue to that its environmental, cultural and economic benefits can continue to be economic benefits can continue to be enjoyed economic benefits can continue to be enjoyed by economic benefits can continue to be enjoyed by future economic benefits can continue to be enjoyed by future generations. enjoyed by future generations. What... enjoyed by future generations. What... Government's enjoyed by future generations. What... Government's plan enjoyed by future generations. What... Government's plan to What... Government's plan to revitalise What... Government's plan to revitalise the What... Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki What... Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf What... Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf include. revitalise the Hauraki Gulf include. The revitalise the Hauraki Gulf include. The package revitalise the Hauraki Gulf include. The package includes revitalise the Hauraki Gulf include. The package includes a revitalise the Hauraki Gulf include. The package includes a fisheries The package includes a fisheries plan The package includes a fisheries plan with The package includes a fisheries plan with some The package includes a fisheries plan with some 50s The package includes a fisheries plan with some 50s initiatives plan with some 50s initiatives including plan with some 50s initiatives including a plan with some 50s initiatives including a ring plan with some 50s initiatives including a ring of plan with some 50s initiatives including a ring of changes plan with some 50s initiatives including a ring of changes to including a ring of changes to commercial including a ring of changes to commercial and including a ring of changes to commercial and recreation including a ring of changes to commercial and recreation fishing commercial and recreation fishing practices commercial and recreation fishing practices and commercial and recreation fishing practices and catch commercial and recreation fishing practices and catch settings. commercial and recreation fishing practices and catch settings. Bottom practices and catch settings. Bottom trawling practices and catch settings. Bottom trawling is practices and catch settings. Bottom trawling is being practices and catch settings. Bottom trawling is being restricted practices and catch settings. Bottom trawling is being restricted to trawling is being restricted to carefully trawling is being restricted to carefully selected trawling is being restricted to carefully selected corridors. trawling is being restricted to carefully selected corridors. 18 trawling is being restricted to carefully selected corridors. 18 new carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are to carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are to be carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are to be created carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are to be created as carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are to be created as part carefully selected corridors. 18 new areas are to be created as part of areas are to be created as part of the areas are to be created as part of the framework areas are to be created as part of the framework to areas are to be created as part of the framework to support areas are to be created as part of the framework to support the areas are to be created as part of the framework to support the act areas are to be created as part of the framework to support the act of the framework to support the act of restoration the framework to support the act of restoration of the framework to support the act of restoration of some the framework to support the act of restoration of some of the framework to support the act of restoration of some of the the framework to support the act of restoration of some of the most the framework to support the act of restoration of some of the most bio restoration of some of the most bio diverse restoration of some of the most bio diverse regions restoration of some of the most bio diverse regions in restoration of some of the most bio diverse regions in the restoration of some of the most bio diverse regions in the Gulf. restoration of some of the most bio diverse regions in the Gulf. The restoration of some of the most bio diverse regions in the Gulf. The 18 diverse regions in the Gulf. The 18 new diverse regions in the Gulf. The 18 new protected diverse regions in the Gulf. The 18 new protected areas diverse regions in the Gulf. The 18 new protected areas will diverse regions in the Gulf. The 18 new protected areas will increase new protected areas will increase marine new protected areas will increase marine protection new protected areas will increase marine protection in new protected areas will increase marine protection in the new protected areas will increase marine protection in the Gulf new protected areas will increase marine protection in the Gulf almost marine protection in the Gulf almost threefold. marine protection in the Gulf almost threefold. Better marine protection in the Gulf almost threefold. Better monitoring marine protection in the Gulf almost threefold. Better monitoring will threefold. Better monitoring will improve threefold. Better monitoring will improve our threefold. Better monitoring will improve our understanding threefold. Better monitoring will improve our understanding of threefold. Better monitoring will improve our understanding of the improve our understanding of the marine improve our understanding of the marine environment improve our understanding of the marine environment and improve our understanding of the marine environment and track marine environment and track progress marine environment and track progress over marine environment and track progress over time. marine environment and track progress over time. We marine environment and track progress over time. We are marine environment and track progress over time. We are also progress over time. We are also working progress over time. We are also working with progress over time. We are also working with mana progress over time. We are also working with mana whenua progress over time. We are also working with mana whenua and progress over time. We are also working with mana whenua and local working with mana whenua and local communities working with mana whenua and local communities on working with mana whenua and local communities on local working with mana whenua and local communities on local area working with mana whenua and local communities on local area coastal communities on local area coastal management communities on local area coastal management in communities on local area coastal management in respect communities on local area coastal management in respect of communities on local area coastal management in respect of local management in respect of local depletion management in respect of local depletion issues. management in respect of local depletion issues. Promoting management in respect of local depletion issues. Promoting a depletion issues. Promoting a prosperous, depletion issues. Promoting a prosperous, sustainable depletion issues. Promoting a prosperous, sustainable aqua depletion issues. Promoting a prosperous, sustainable aqua culture prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry will prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry will also prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry will also help prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry will also help clean prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry will also help clean up prosperous, sustainable aqua culture industry will also help clean up the industry will also help clean up the water. industry will also help clean up the water. We industry will also help clean up the water. We thank industry will also help clean up the water. We thank all industry will also help clean up the water. We thank all of industry will also help clean up the water. We thank all of the industry will also help clean up the water. We thank all of the many water. We thank all of the many thousand water. We thank all of the many thousand of water. We thank all of the many thousand of Aucklanders water. We thank all of the many thousand of Aucklanders and water. We thank all of the many thousand of Aucklanders and people thousand of Aucklanders and people around thousand of Aucklanders and people around the thousand of Aucklanders and people around the Gulf thousand of Aucklanders and people around the Gulf for thousand of Aucklanders and people around the Gulf for their thousand of Aucklanders and people around the Gulf for their efforts thousand of Aucklanders and people around the Gulf for their efforts to around the Gulf for their efforts to bring around the Gulf for their efforts to bring forward around the Gulf for their efforts to bring forward the around the Gulf for their efforts to bring forward the Sea around the Gulf for their efforts to bring forward the Sea Change around the Gulf for their efforts to bring forward the Sea Change plans bring forward the Sea Change plans and bring forward the Sea Change plans and the bring forward the Sea Change plans and the ministerial bring forward the Sea Change plans and the ministerial advisory and the ministerial advisory committee and the ministerial advisory committee that and the ministerial advisory committee that helped and the ministerial advisory committee that helped us and the ministerial advisory committee that helped us get and the ministerial advisory committee that helped us get it and the ministerial advisory committee that helped us get it to committee that helped us get it to the committee that helped us get it to the shape committee that helped us get it to the shape in committee that helped us get it to the shape in which committee that helped us get it to the shape in which we committee that helped us get it to the shape in which we have committee that helped us get it to the shape in which we have landed. committee that helped us get it to the shape in which we have landed. the shape in which we have landed. ..oceans the shape in which we have landed. ..oceans and the shape in which we have landed. ..oceans and fishies the shape in which we have landed. ..oceans and fishies management? the shape in which we have landed. ..oceans and fishies management? The ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 report ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 report on ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 report on behalf ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 report on behalf of ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 report on behalf of the ..oceans and fishies management? The 2016 report on behalf of the prior 2016 report on behalf of the prior National 2016 report on behalf of the prior National Government 2016 report on behalf of the prior National Government by 2016 report on behalf of the prior National Government by Mike 2016 report on behalf of the prior National Government by Mike Heron 2016 report on behalf of the prior National Government by Mike Heron QC National Government by Mike Heron QC into National Government by Mike Heron QC into two National Government by Mike Heron QC into two operations National Government by Mike Heron QC into two operations showed into two operations showed significant into two operations showed significant discarding into two operations showed significant discarding and into two operations showed significant discarding and high significant discarding and high grading significant discarding and high grading of significant discarding and high grading of fish. significant discarding and high grading of fish. We significant discarding and high grading of fish. We will significant discarding and high grading of fish. We will never significant discarding and high grading of fish. We will never know grading of fish. We will never know the grading of fish. We will never know the exact grading of fish. We will never know the exact quantity grading of fish. We will never know the exact quantity of grading of fish. We will never know the exact quantity of what grading of fish. We will never know the exact quantity of what has grading of fish. We will never know the exact quantity of what has been the exact quantity of what has been happening the exact quantity of what has been happening but the exact quantity of what has been happening but it the exact quantity of what has been happening but it has the exact quantity of what has been happening but it has been the exact quantity of what has been happening but it has been material. happening but it has been material. As happening but it has been material. As a happening but it has been material. As a consequence happening but it has been material. As a consequence last happening but it has been material. As a consequence last week happening but it has been material. As a consequence last week we happening but it has been material. As a consequence last week we made As a consequence last week we made two As a consequence last week we made two significant As a consequence last week we made two significant announcements As a consequence last week we made two significant announcements to two significant announcements to remedy two significant announcements to remedy the two significant announcements to remedy the problem. two significant announcements to remedy the problem. The two significant announcements to remedy the problem. The first two significant announcements to remedy the problem. The first is two significant announcements to remedy the problem. The first is for remedy the problem. The first is for 300 remedy the problem. The first is for 300 in remedy the problem. The first is for 300 in shore remedy the problem. The first is for 300 in shore commercial remedy the problem. The first is for 300 in shore commercial fishing 300 in shore commercial fishing vessels 300 in shore commercial fishing vessels to 300 in shore commercial fishing vessels to be 300 in shore commercial fishing vessels to be fitted 300 in shore commercial fishing vessels to be fitted with 300 in shore commercial fishing vessels to be fitted with onboard vessels to be fitted with onboard cameras. vessels to be fitted with onboard cameras. This vessels to be fitted with onboard cameras. This delivers vessels to be fitted with onboard cameras. This delivers on vessels to be fitted with onboard cameras. This delivers on another vessels to be fitted with onboard cameras. This delivers on another of cameras. This delivers on another of the cameras. This delivers on another of the Government's cameras. This delivers on another of the Government's election cameras. This delivers on another of the Government's election commit cameras. This delivers on another of the Government's election commit 7s. the Government's election commit 7s. Onshore the Government's election commit 7s. Onshore cameras the Government's election commit 7s. Onshore cameras will the Government's election commit 7s. Onshore cameras will provide Onshore cameras will provide accurate Onshore cameras will provide accurate information Onshore cameras will provide accurate information about accurate information about commercial accurate information about commercial fishing accurate information about commercial fishing activity accurate information about commercial fishing activity and accurate information about commercial fishing activity and will commercial fishing activity and will provide commercial fishing activity and will provide greater commercial fishing activity and will provide greater transparency commercial fishing activity and will provide greater transparency and provide greater transparency and certainty provide greater transparency and certainty and provide greater transparency and certainty and more provide greater transparency and certainty and more evidence provide greater transparency and certainty and more evidence on provide greater transparency and certainty and more evidence on which certainty and more evidence on which to certainty and more evidence on which to base certainty and more evidence on which to base decisions certainty and more evidence on which to base decisions about certainty and more evidence on which to base decisions about policy certainty and more evidence on which to base decisions about policy and to base decisions about policy and regulation, to base decisions about policy and regulation, scientific to base decisions about policy and regulation, scientific research, regulation, scientific research, fisheries regulation, scientific research, fisheries and regulation, scientific research, fisheries and protected regulation, scientific research, fisheries and protected species fisheries and protected species management. fisheries and protected species management. The fisheries and protected species management. The roll fisheries and protected species management. The roll out fisheries and protected species management. The roll out will fisheries and protected species management. The roll out will be management. The roll out will be staged management. The roll out will be staged to management. The roll out will be staged to prioritise management. The roll out will be staged to prioritise those management. The roll out will be staged to prioritise those vessels staged to prioritise those vessels that staged to prioritise those vessels that pose staged to prioritise those vessels that pose the staged to prioritise those vessels that pose the greatest staged to prioritise those vessels that pose the greatest risk staged to prioritise those vessels that pose the greatest risk to that pose the greatest risk to protected that pose the greatest risk to protected species that pose the greatest risk to protected species such that pose the greatest risk to protected species such as that pose the greatest risk to protected species such as hectors protected species such as hectors dolphins protected species such as hectors dolphins and protected species such as hectors dolphins and antipodean protected species such as hectors dolphins and antipodean albatross. dolphins and antipodean albatross. When dolphins and antipodean albatross. When cameras dolphins and antipodean albatross. When cameras record dolphins and antipodean albatross. When cameras record activity dolphins and antipodean albatross. When cameras record activity on When cameras record activity on vessels When cameras record activity on vessels responsible When cameras record activity on vessels responsible for When cameras record activity on vessels responsible for about When cameras record activity on vessels responsible for about 85% When cameras record activity on vessels responsible for about 85% of vessels responsible for about 85% of the vessels responsible for about 85% of the commercial vessels responsible for about 85% of the commercial in vessels responsible for about 85% of the commercial in other vessels responsible for about 85% of the commercial in other catch vessels responsible for about 85% of the commercial in other catch by the commercial in other catch by volume. the commercial in other catch by volume. What the commercial in other catch by volume. What fisheries. the commercial in other catch by volume. What fisheries. ..As the commercial in other catch by volume. What fisheries. ..As a volume. What fisheries. ..As a consequence volume. What fisheries. ..As a consequence of volume. What fisheries. ..As a consequence of installing volume. What fisheries. ..As a consequence of installing cameras volume. What fisheries. ..As a consequence of installing cameras on consequence of installing cameras on boats? consequence of installing cameras on boats? This consequence of installing cameras on boats? This is consequence of installing cameras on boats? This is part consequence of installing cameras on boats? This is part of consequence of installing cameras on boats? This is part of a consequence of installing cameras on boats? This is part of a wider boats? This is part of a wider programme boats? This is part of a wider programme where boats? This is part of a wider programme where we boats? This is part of a wider programme where we are boats? This is part of a wider programme where we are clamping boats? This is part of a wider programme where we are clamping down programme where we are clamping down on programme where we are clamping down on discards programme where we are clamping down on discards and programme where we are clamping down on discards and high programme where we are clamping down on discards and high grading. programme where we are clamping down on discards and high grading. In on discards and high grading. In general on discards and high grading. In general from on discards and high grading. In general from when on discards and high grading. In general from when these on discards and high grading. In general from when these rules on discards and high grading. In general from when these rules come general from when these rules come into general from when these rules come into effect, general from when these rules come into effect, a general from when these rules come into effect, a fin general from when these rules come into effect, a fin fish, general from when these rules come into effect, a fin fish, if general from when these rules come into effect, a fin fish, if caught into effect, a fin fish, if caught commercially into effect, a fin fish, if caught commercially will into effect, a fin fish, if caught commercially will have into effect, a fin fish, if caught commercially will have to into effect, a fin fish, if caught commercially will have to be into effect, a fin fish, if caught commercially will have to be landed. commercially will have to be landed. This commercially will have to be landed. This will commercially will have to be landed. This will incentivise commercially will have to be landed. This will incentivise fishers commercially will have to be landed. This will incentivise fishers to This will incentivise fishers to innovate This will incentivise fishers to innovate and This will incentivise fishers to innovate and move This will incentivise fishers to innovate and move to This will incentivise fishers to innovate and move to more This will incentivise fishers to innovate and move to more selective innovate and move to more selective fishing innovate and move to more selective fishing practices innovate and move to more selective fishing practices in innovate and move to more selective fishing practices in order innovate and move to more selective fishing practices in order to innovate and move to more selective fishing practices in order to catch fishing practices in order to catch only fishing practices in order to catch only the fishing practices in order to catch only the fish fishing practices in order to catch only the fish they fishing practices in order to catch only the fish they want fishing practices in order to catch only the fish they want and fishing practices in order to catch only the fish they want and to fishing practices in order to catch only the fish they want and to find only the fish they want and to find ways only the fish they want and to find ways to only the fish they want and to find ways to avoid only the fish they want and to find ways to avoid catching only the fish they want and to find ways to avoid catching the only the fish they want and to find ways to avoid catching the smaller ways to avoid catching the smaller or ways to avoid catching the smaller or economically ways to avoid catching the smaller or economically lower ways to avoid catching the smaller or economically lower value ways to avoid catching the smaller or economically lower value fish ways to avoid catching the smaller or economically lower value fish if or economically lower value fish if they or economically lower value fish if they don't or economically lower value fish if they don't want or economically lower value fish if they don't want to or economically lower value fish if they don't want to catch or economically lower value fish if they don't want to catch them. or economically lower value fish if they don't want to catch them. The they don't want to catch them. The changes they don't want to catch them. The changes include they don't want to catch them. The changes include changing they don't want to catch them. The changes include changing - changes include changing - simplifying changes include changing - simplifying the changes include changing - simplifying the rules changes include changing - simplifying the rules around changes include changing - simplifying the rules around which simplifying the rules around which fish simplifying the rules around which fish must simplifying the rules around which fish must be simplifying the rules around which fish must be landed. simplifying the rules around which fish must be landed. Some simplifying the rules around which fish must be landed. Some of simplifying the rules around which fish must be landed. Some of the fish must be landed. Some of the rules fish must be landed. Some of the rules are fish must be landed. Some of the rules are very fish must be landed. Some of the rules are very complex fish must be landed. Some of the rules are very complex for fish must be landed. Some of the rules are very complex for the rules are very complex for the commercial rules are very complex for the commercial fishing rules are very complex for the commercial fishing sector rules are very complex for the commercial fishing sector to rules are very complex for the commercial fishing sector to comply commercial fishing sector to comply with commercial fishing sector to comply with currently. commercial fishing sector to comply with currently. As commercial fishing sector to comply with currently. As a commercial fishing sector to comply with currently. As a consequence commercial fishing sector to comply with currently. As a consequence of with currently. As a consequence of the with currently. As a consequence of the greater with currently. As a consequence of the greater transparency with currently. As a consequence of the greater transparency and with currently. As a consequence of the greater transparency and more the greater transparency and more simplicity the greater transparency and more simplicity of the greater transparency and more simplicity of rules the greater transparency and more simplicity of rules we the greater transparency and more simplicity of rules we are the greater transparency and more simplicity of rules we are able the greater transparency and more simplicity of rules we are able to simplicity of rules we are able to move simplicity of rules we are able to move to simplicity of rules we are able to move to a simplicity of rules we are able to move to a more simplicity of rules we are able to move to a more graduated simplicity of rules we are able to move to a more graduated set simplicity of rules we are able to move to a more graduated set of move to a more graduated set of penalties move to a more graduated set of penalties that move to a more graduated set of penalties that better move to a more graduated set of penalties that better reflect move to a more graduated set of penalties that better reflect the penalties that better reflect the scale penalties that better reflect the scale of penalties that better reflect the scale of offending. penalties that better reflect the scale of offending. Sometimes penalties that better reflect the scale of offending. Sometimes those scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are a scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are a bit scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are a bit over scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are a bit over the scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are a bit over the top scale of offending. Sometimes those penalties are a bit over the top for penalties are a bit over the top for minor penalties are a bit over the top for minor offending penalties are a bit over the top for minor offending at penalties are a bit over the top for minor offending at the penalties are a bit over the top for minor offending at the moment. penalties are a bit over the top for minor offending at the moment. This minor offending at the moment. This is minor offending at the moment. This is part minor offending at the moment. This is part of minor offending at the moment. This is part of wider minor offending at the moment. This is part of wider work minor offending at the moment. This is part of wider work we minor offending at the moment. This is part of wider work we are minor offending at the moment. This is part of wider work we are doing is part of wider work we are doing with is part of wider work we are doing with industry is part of wider work we are doing with industry leaders is part of wider work we are doing with industry leaders to is part of wider work we are doing with industry leaders to improve is part of wider work we are doing with industry leaders to improve the with industry leaders to improve the outcomes with industry leaders to improve the outcomes for with industry leaders to improve the outcomes for everyone. with industry leaders to improve the outcomes for everyone. I with industry leaders to improve the outcomes for everyone. I was outcomes for everyone. I was gratified outcomes for everyone. I was gratified to outcomes for everyone. I was gratified to see outcomes for everyone. I was gratified to see there outcomes for everyone. I was gratified to see there has outcomes for everyone. I was gratified to see there has been gratified to see there has been considerable gratified to see there has been considerable support gratified to see there has been considerable support from gratified to see there has been considerable support from not gratified to see there has been considerable support from not just considerable support from not just environmentalists considerable support from not just environmentalists but considerable support from not just environmentalists but also environmentalists but also significant environmentalists but also significant parts environmentalists but also significant parts of environmentalists but also significant parts of the environmentalists but also significant parts of the industry significant parts of the industry for significant parts of the industry for the significant parts of the industry for the measures significant parts of the industry for the measures that significant parts of the industry for the measures that we significant parts of the industry for the measures that we are significant parts of the industry for the measures that we are taking. for the measures that we are taking. Question for the measures that we are taking. Question No.6. for the measures that we are taking. Question No.6. To for the measures that we are taking. Question No.6. To the for the measures that we are taking. Question No.6. To the Minister for the measures that we are taking. Question No.6. To the Minister for Question No.6. To the Minister for COVID-19 Question No.6. To the Minister for COVID-19 Response, Question No.6. To the Minister for COVID-19 Response, does Question No.6. To the Minister for COVID-19 Response, does he Question No.6. To the Minister for COVID-19 Response, does he stand Question No.6. To the Minister for COVID-19 Response, does he stand by COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement on COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement on 17 COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement on 17 November... COVID-19 COVID-19 Response, COVID-19 Response, does COVID-19 Response, does he COVID-19 Response, does he stand COVID-19 Response, does he stand by COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement on COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement on 17 COVID-19 Response, does he stand by his statement on 17 November... My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: Does My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: Does he My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: Does he stand My question is to the Minister for COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by his COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by his statement COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by his statement on COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by his statement on 17 COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by his statement on 17 November COVID-19 Response: Does he stand by his statement on 17 November 2020, his statement on 17 November 2020, "when his statement on 17 November 2020, "when vaccines his statement on 17 November 2020, "when vaccines come his statement on 17 November 2020, "when vaccines come to his statement on 17 November 2020, "when vaccines come to the his statement on 17 November 2020, "when vaccines come to the market, "when vaccines come to the market, we "when vaccines come to the market, we will "when vaccines come to the market, we will be "when vaccines come to the market, we will be at "when vaccines come to the market, we will be at the "when vaccines come to the market, we will be at the front "when vaccines come to the market, we will be at the front of "when vaccines come to the market, we will be at the front of the "when vaccines come to the market, we will be at the front of the queue we will be at the front of the queue for we will be at the front of the queue for those", we will be at the front of the queue for those", and we will be at the front of the queue for those", and is we will be at the front of the queue for those", and is he we will be at the front of the queue for those", and is he satisfied we will be at the front of the queue for those", and is he satisfied with for those", and is he satisfied with New for those", and is he satisfied with New Zealand's for those", and is he satisfied with New Zealand's COVID-19 for those", and is he satisfied with New Zealand's COVID-19 vaccine New Zealand's COVID-19 vaccine roll-out? On On behalf On behalf of On behalf of the On behalf of the minister On behalf of the minister of On behalf of the minister of COVID-19 On behalf of the minister of COVID-19 response, On behalf of the minister of COVID-19 response, yes, On behalf of the minister of COVID-19 response, yes, the On behalf of the minister of COVID-19 response, yes, the New COVID-19 response, yes, the New Zealand COVID-19 response, yes, the New Zealand Government COVID-19 response, yes, the New Zealand Government negotiated Zealand Government negotiated advance Zealand Government negotiated advance purchase Zealand Government negotiated advance purchase agreements Zealand Government negotiated advance purchase agreements which advance purchase agreements which gave advance purchase agreements which gave us advance purchase agreements which gave us choices, advance purchase agreements which gave us choices, assuring advance purchase agreements which gave us choices, assuring us advance purchase agreements which gave us choices, assuring us access gave us choices, assuring us access to gave us choices, assuring us access to four gave us choices, assuring us access to four different gave us choices, assuring us access to four different vaccines gave us choices, assuring us access to four different vaccines against to four different vaccines against COVID-19. to four different vaccines against COVID-19. We to four different vaccines against COVID-19. We chose to four different vaccines against COVID-19. We chose a to four different vaccines against COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based strategy. COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based strategy. There COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based strategy. There are COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based strategy. There are a COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based strategy. There are a ring COVID-19. We chose a Pfizer-based strategy. There are a ring of strategy. There are a ring of effective strategy. There are a ring of effective COVID-19 strategy. There are a ring of effective COVID-19 vaccines strategy. There are a ring of effective COVID-19 vaccines in strategy. There are a ring of effective COVID-19 vaccines in use effective COVID-19 vaccines in use around effective COVID-19 vaccines in use around the effective COVID-19 vaccines in use around the world effective COVID-19 vaccines in use around the world and effective COVID-19 vaccines in use around the world and our effective COVID-19 vaccines in use around the world and our vaccine around the world and our vaccine rollout around the world and our vaccine rollout uses around the world and our vaccine rollout uses the around the world and our vaccine rollout uses the one around the world and our vaccine rollout uses the one that around the world and our vaccine rollout uses the one that is rollout uses the one that is routinely rollout uses the one that is routinely received rollout uses the one that is routinely received the rollout uses the one that is routinely received the highest routinely received the highest efficacy routinely received the highest efficacy estimates routinely received the highest efficacy estimates in routinely received the highest efficacy estimates in the routinely received the highest efficacy estimates in the world routinely received the highest efficacy estimates in the world and efficacy estimates in the world and it efficacy estimates in the world and it has efficacy estimates in the world and it has an efficacy estimates in the world and it has an excellent efficacy estimates in the world and it has an excellent safety efficacy estimates in the world and it has an excellent safety profile. it has an excellent safety profile. We it has an excellent safety profile. We have it has an excellent safety profile. We have secured it has an excellent safety profile. We have secured 10 it has an excellent safety profile. We have secured 10 million it has an excellent safety profile. We have secured 10 million doses it has an excellent safety profile. We have secured 10 million doses and We have secured 10 million doses and our We have secured 10 million doses and our rollout We have secured 10 million doses and our rollout has We have secured 10 million doses and our rollout has seen We have secured 10 million doses and our rollout has seen low We have secured 10 million doses and our rollout has seen low wastage We have secured 10 million doses and our rollout has seen low wastage of our rollout has seen low wastage of the our rollout has seen low wastage of the vaccine our rollout has seen low wastage of the vaccine and our rollout has seen low wastage of the vaccine and importantly our rollout has seen low wastage of the vaccine and importantly high the vaccine and importantly high uptake the vaccine and importantly high uptake of the vaccine and importantly high uptake of second the vaccine and importantly high uptake of second doses. the vaccine and importantly high uptake of second doses. Although the vaccine and importantly high uptake of second doses. Although the uptake of second doses. Although the Pfizer uptake of second doses. Although the Pfizer vaccine uptake of second doses. Although the Pfizer vaccine poses uptake of second doses. Although the Pfizer vaccine poses challenges uptake of second doses. Although the Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the need Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the need for Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the need for storage Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the need for storage at Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the need for storage at ultra Pfizer vaccine poses challenges such as the need for storage at ultra low as the need for storage at ultra low temperatures as the need for storage at ultra low temperatures we as the need for storage at ultra low temperatures we have as the need for storage at ultra low temperatures we have worked as the need for storage at ultra low temperatures we have worked there temperatures we have worked there that temperatures we have worked there that in temperatures we have worked there that in our temperatures we have worked there that in our rollout. temperatures we have worked there that in our rollout. We temperatures we have worked there that in our rollout. We are temperatures we have worked there that in our rollout. We are rolling that in our rollout. We are rolling out that in our rollout. We are rolling out this that in our rollout. We are rolling out this programme that in our rollout. We are rolling out this programme while that in our rollout. We are rolling out this programme while maintaining out this programme while maintaining border out this programme while maintaining border and out this programme while maintaining border and public out this programme while maintaining border and public health out this programme while maintaining border and public health protections border and public health protections that border and public health protections that keep border and public health protections that keep New border and public health protections that keep New Zealanders border and public health protections that keep New Zealanders safe border and public health protections that keep New Zealanders safe and border and public health protections that keep New Zealanders safe and as that keep New Zealanders safe and as a that keep New Zealanders safe and as a result that keep New Zealanders safe and as a result we that keep New Zealanders safe and as a result we have that keep New Zealanders safe and as a result we have seen that keep New Zealanders safe and as a result we have seen zero that keep New Zealanders safe and as a result we have seen zero community a result we have seen zero community cases a result we have seen zero community cases for a result we have seen zero community cases for more a result we have seen zero community cases for more than a result we have seen zero community cases for more than 100 a result we have seen zero community cases for more than 100 days. a result we have seen zero community cases for more than 100 days. I a result we have seen zero community cases for more than 100 days. I have cases for more than 100 days. I have confidence cases for more than 100 days. I have confidence in cases for more than 100 days. I have confidence in our cases for more than 100 days. I have confidence in our COVID-19 cases for more than 100 days. I have confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Has confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Has she confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Has she been confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Has she been advised confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Has she been advised as confidence in our COVID-19 vaccine rollout. Has she been advised as to rollout. Has she been advised as to how rollout. Has she been advised as to how many rollout. Has she been advised as to how many people rollout. Has she been advised as to how many people have rollout. Has she been advised as to how many people have had rollout. Has she been advised as to how many people have had their how many people have had their second how many people have had their second doses how many people have had their second doses of how many people have had their second doses of the how many people have had their second doses of the Pfizer how many people have had their second doses of the Pfizer vaccine second doses of the Pfizer vaccine delayed second doses of the Pfizer vaccine delayed beyond second doses of the Pfizer vaccine delayed beyond the second doses of the Pfizer vaccine delayed beyond the recommended second doses of the Pfizer vaccine delayed beyond the recommended three delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, in delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, in some delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, in some cases delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, in some cases up delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, in some cases up to delayed beyond the recommended three weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? I weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? I will weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? I will just weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? I will just remind weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? I will just remind the weeks, in some cases up to eight weeks? I will just remind the member weeks? I will just remind the member he weeks? I will just remind the member he is weeks? I will just remind the member he is asking weeks? I will just remind the member he is asking the weeks? I will just remind the member he is asking the minister, weeks? I will just remind the member he is asking the minister, not weeks? I will just remind the member he is asking the minister, not the he is asking the minister, not the associate he is asking the minister, not the associate minister he is asking the minister, not the associate minister but he is asking the minister, not the associate minister but go he is asking the minister, not the associate minister but go anyway. associate minister but go anyway. No, associate minister but go anyway. No, I associate minister but go anyway. No, I do associate minister but go anyway. No, I do not associate minister but go anyway. No, I do not have associate minister but go anyway. No, I do not have access associate minister but go anyway. No, I do not have access to associate minister but go anyway. No, I do not have access to that No, I do not have access to that information No, I do not have access to that information but No, I do not have access to that information but if No, I do not have access to that information but if the No, I do not have access to that information but if the minister information but if the minister wants information but if the minister wants to information but if the minister wants to - information but if the minister wants to - the information but if the minister wants to - the member information but if the minister wants to - the member wants information but if the minister wants to - the member wants to information but if the minister wants to - the member wants to put information but if the minister wants to - the member wants to put a wants to - the member wants to put a request wants to - the member wants to put a request if wants to - the member wants to put a request if writing wants to - the member wants to put a request if writing I wants to - the member wants to put a request if writing I would wants to - the member wants to put a request if writing I would happily request if writing I would happily provide request if writing I would happily provide it request if writing I would happily provide it to request if writing I would happily provide it to him. request if writing I would happily provide it to him. Has request if writing I would happily provide it to him. Has the request if writing I would happily provide it to him. Has the minister provide it to him. Has the minister been provide it to him. Has the minister been advised provide it to him. Has the minister been advised as provide it to him. Has the minister been advised as to provide it to him. Has the minister been advised as to how provide it to him. Has the minister been advised as to how many been advised as to how many vaccination been advised as to how many vaccination clinics been advised as to how many vaccination clinics the been advised as to how many vaccination clinics the opening been advised as to how many vaccination clinics the opening of vaccination clinics the opening of vaccination vaccination clinics the opening of vaccination clinics, vaccination clinics the opening of vaccination clinics, have vaccination clinics the opening of vaccination clinics, have been vaccination clinics, have been delayed vaccination clinics, have been delayed or vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put on vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put on hold vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put on hold due vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put on hold due to vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put on hold due to a vaccination clinics, have been delayed or put on hold due to a lack delayed or put on hold due to a lack of delayed or put on hold due to a lack of vaccine delayed or put on hold due to a lack of vaccine supply? delayed or put on hold due to a lack of vaccine supply? No, delayed or put on hold due to a lack of vaccine supply? No, but delayed or put on hold due to a lack of vaccine supply? No, but the delayed or put on hold due to a lack of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs continue of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs continue to of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs continue to track of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs continue to track according of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs continue to track according to of vaccine supply? No, but the DHBs continue to track according to the continue to track according to the targets continue to track according to the targets that continue to track according to the targets that we continue to track according to the targets that we have continue to track according to the targets that we have set continue to track according to the targets that we have set them continue to track according to the targets that we have set them and targets that we have set them and that targets that we have set them and that is targets that we have set them and that is the targets that we have set them and that is the main targets that we have set them and that is the main metric targets that we have set them and that is the main metric to targets that we have set them and that is the main metric to which targets that we have set them and that is the main metric to which we that is the main metric to which we are that is the main metric to which we are gauging that is the main metric to which we are gauging the that is the main metric to which we are gauging the rollout that is the main metric to which we are gauging the rollout according are gauging the rollout according to. are gauging the rollout according to. What are gauging the rollout according to. What is are gauging the rollout according to. What is the are gauging the rollout according to. What is the Government are gauging the rollout according to. What is the Government not are gauging the rollout according to. What is the Government not able to. What is the Government not able to to. What is the Government not able to release to. What is the Government not able to release how to. What is the Government not able to release how many to. What is the Government not able to release how many people to. What is the Government not able to release how many people each to. What is the Government not able to release how many people each DHB to release how many people each DHB has to release how many people each DHB has vaccinated to release how many people each DHB has vaccinated in to release how many people each DHB has vaccinated in each to release how many people each DHB has vaccinated in each of to release how many people each DHB has vaccinated in each of the to release how many people each DHB has vaccinated in each of the four has vaccinated in each of the four groups has vaccinated in each of the four groups or has vaccinated in each of the four groups or even has vaccinated in each of the four groups or even how has vaccinated in each of the four groups or even how many has vaccinated in each of the four groups or even how many people has vaccinated in each of the four groups or even how many people are groups or even how many people are in groups or even how many people are in each groups or even how many people are in each group groups or even how many people are in each group at groups or even how many people are in each group at a groups or even how many people are in each group at a DHB groups or even how many people are in each group at a DHB level? in each group at a DHB level? Because in each group at a DHB level? Because the in each group at a DHB level? Because the criteria in each group at a DHB level? Because the criteria for in each group at a DHB level? Because the criteria for the in each group at a DHB level? Because the criteria for the groups Because the criteria for the groups aren't Because the criteria for the groups aren't necessarily Because the criteria for the groups aren't necessarily things Because the criteria for the groups aren't necessarily things that aren't necessarily things that Government aren't necessarily things that Government has aren't necessarily things that Government has data aren't necessarily things that Government has data sets aren't necessarily things that Government has data sets on. aren't necessarily things that Government has data sets on. So... Government has data sets on. So... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> No, <INTERRUPTION> No, that's <INTERRUPTION> No, that's true. <INTERRUPTION> No, that's true. For <INTERRUPTION> No, that's true. For example <INTERRUPTION> No, that's true. For example there No, that's true. For example there is No, that's true. For example there is not No, that's true. For example there is not necessarily No, that's true. For example there is not necessarily a No, that's true. For example there is not necessarily a register No, that's true. For example there is not necessarily a register of is not necessarily a register of everyone is not necessarily a register of everyone who is not necessarily a register of everyone who meets is not necessarily a register of everyone who meets the is not necessarily a register of everyone who meets the conditions everyone who meets the conditions for everyone who meets the conditions for - everyone who meets the conditions for - criteria everyone who meets the conditions for - criteria for everyone who meets the conditions for - criteria for having everyone who meets the conditions for - criteria for having a everyone who meets the conditions for - criteria for having a chronic for - criteria for having a chronic condition for - criteria for having a chronic condition and for - criteria for having a chronic condition and so for - criteria for having a chronic condition and so that for - criteria for having a chronic condition and so that rests for - criteria for having a chronic condition and so that rests on for - criteria for having a chronic condition and so that rests on the condition and so that rests on the work condition and so that rests on the work to condition and so that rests on the work to make condition and so that rests on the work to make those condition and so that rests on the work to make those targets condition and so that rests on the work to make those targets rests condition and so that rests on the work to make those targets rests on work to make those targets rests on estimates work to make those targets rests on estimates and work to make those targets rests on estimates and - work to make those targets rests on estimates and - so work to make those targets rests on estimates and - so there work to make those targets rests on estimates and - so there is work to make those targets rests on estimates and - so there is not work to make those targets rests on estimates and - so there is not a estimates and - so there is not a register estimates and - so there is not a register of estimates and - so there is not a register of that estimates and - so there is not a register of that at estimates and - so there is not a register of that at the estimates and - so there is not a register of that at the DHB estimates and - so there is not a register of that at the DHB level. register of that at the DHB level. Will register of that at the DHB level. Will every register of that at the DHB level. Will every resident register of that at the DHB level. Will every resident living register of that at the DHB level. Will every resident living in register of that at the DHB level. Will every resident living in an Will every resident living in an aged Will every resident living in an aged care Will every resident living in an aged care facility Will every resident living in an aged care facility who Will every resident living in an aged care facility who wants Will every resident living in an aged care facility who wants a aged care facility who wants a COVID-19 aged care facility who wants a COVID-19 vaccine aged care facility who wants a COVID-19 vaccine get aged care facility who wants a COVID-19 vaccine get at aged care facility who wants a COVID-19 vaccine get at least aged care facility who wants a COVID-19 vaccine get at least their COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first dose COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first dose of COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first dose of the COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first dose of the vaccine COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first dose of the vaccine before COVID-19 vaccine get at least their first dose of the vaccine before the first dose of the vaccine before the end first dose of the vaccine before the end of first dose of the vaccine before the end of this first dose of the vaccine before the end of this month first dose of the vaccine before the end of this month as first dose of the vaccine before the end of this month as Dr first dose of the vaccine before the end of this month as Dr Bloomfield end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said last end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said last week end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said last week would end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said last week would be end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said last week would be the end of this month as Dr Bloomfield said last week would be the case? said last week would be the case? I'm said last week would be the case? I'm not said last week would be the case? I'm not aware said last week would be the case? I'm not aware of said last week would be the case? I'm not aware of - said last week would be the case? I'm not aware of - I'm said last week would be the case? I'm not aware of - I'm not said last week would be the case? I'm not aware of - I'm not aware said last week would be the case? I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of anything I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of anything that I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of anything that has I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of anything that has changed I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of anything that has changed since I'm not aware of - I'm not aware of anything that has changed since then anything that has changed since then but anything that has changed since then but I anything that has changed since then but I think anything that has changed since then but I think the anything that has changed since then but I think the important anything that has changed since then but I think the important thing anything that has changed since then but I think the important thing is but I think the important thing is that but I think the important thing is that the but I think the important thing is that the final but I think the important thing is that the final dose but I think the important thing is that the final dose of but I think the important thing is that the final dose of vaccine but I think the important thing is that the final dose of vaccine for that the final dose of vaccine for people that the final dose of vaccine for people in that the final dose of vaccine for people in aged that the final dose of vaccine for people in aged residential that the final dose of vaccine for people in aged residential care that the final dose of vaccine for people in aged residential care will people in aged residential care will be people in aged residential care will be offered people in aged residential care will be offered by people in aged residential care will be offered by the people in aged residential care will be offered by the end people in aged residential care will be offered by the end of people in aged residential care will be offered by the end of July. people in aged residential care will be offered by the end of July. Why be offered by the end of July. Why are be offered by the end of July. Why are MPs be offered by the end of July. Why are MPs around be offered by the end of July. Why are MPs around the be offered by the end of July. Why are MPs around the parliament be offered by the end of July. Why are MPs around the parliament being are MPs around the parliament being contacted are MPs around the parliament being contacted by are MPs around the parliament being contacted by people are MPs around the parliament being contacted by people in are MPs around the parliament being contacted by people in group are MPs around the parliament being contacted by people in group 3 are MPs around the parliament being contacted by people in group 3 with contacted by people in group 3 with underlying contacted by people in group 3 with underlying health contacted by people in group 3 with underlying health conditions contacted by people in group 3 with underlying health conditions who underlying health conditions who have underlying health conditions who have not underlying health conditions who have not been underlying health conditions who have not been contacted underlying health conditions who have not been contacted by underlying health conditions who have not been contacted by their underlying health conditions who have not been contacted by their DHB have not been contacted by their DHB and have not been contacted by their DHB and who have not been contacted by their DHB and who ring have not been contacted by their DHB and who ring their have not been contacted by their DHB and who ring their GP have not been contacted by their DHB and who ring their GP or have not been contacted by their DHB and who ring their GP or their have not been contacted by their DHB and who ring their GP or their DHB and who ring their GP or their DHB who and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell them and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell them they and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell them they have and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell them they have no and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell them they have no idea and who ring their GP or their DHB who tell them they have no idea when who tell them they have no idea when they who tell them they have no idea when they will who tell them they have no idea when they will be who tell them they have no idea when they will be vaccinated? who tell them they have no idea when they will be vaccinated? People who tell them they have no idea when they will be vaccinated? People in they will be vaccinated? People in group they will be vaccinated? People in group 3 they will be vaccinated? People in group 3 include they will be vaccinated? People in group 3 include over they will be vaccinated? People in group 3 include over 1.5 they will be vaccinated? People in group 3 include over 1.5 million group 3 include over 1.5 million people group 3 include over 1.5 million people and group 3 include over 1.5 million people and they group 3 include over 1.5 million people and they will group 3 include over 1.5 million people and they will be group 3 include over 1.5 million people and they will be invited group 3 include over 1.5 million people and they will be invited to people and they will be invited to have people and they will be invited to have a people and they will be invited to have a vaccine people and they will be invited to have a vaccine - people and they will be invited to have a vaccine - given people and they will be invited to have a vaccine - given their people and they will be invited to have a vaccine - given their booking have a vaccine - given their booking appointment have a vaccine - given their booking appointment by have a vaccine - given their booking appointment by the have a vaccine - given their booking appointment by the end have a vaccine - given their booking appointment by the end of have a vaccine - given their booking appointment by the end of July. appointment by the end of July. Question appointment by the end of July. Question No.7, appointment by the end of July. Question No.7, Willow-Jean appointment by the end of July. Question No.7, Willow-Jean Prime. Question Question No.7, Question No.7, Willow-Jean Question No.7, Willow-Jean Prime. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Associate My question is to the Associate Minister My question is to the Associate Minister of My question is to the Associate Minister of Education: My question is to the Associate Minister of Education: What My question is to the Associate Minister of Education: What recent Minister of Education: What recent progress Minister of Education: What recent progress has Minister of Education: What recent progress has she Minister of Education: What recent progress has she seen Minister of Education: What recent progress has she seen on Minister of Education: What recent progress has she seen on providing progress has she seen on providing barrier-free progress has she seen on providing barrier-free access progress has she seen on providing barrier-free access to progress has she seen on providing barrier-free access to education? Last Last week Last week I Last week I saw Last week I saw the Last week I saw the first Last week I saw the first free Last week I saw the first free period Last week I saw the first free period products Last week I saw the first free period products being Last week I saw the first free period products being delivered Last week I saw the first free period products being delivered into period products being delivered into schools period products being delivered into schools as period products being delivered into schools as part period products being delivered into schools as part of period products being delivered into schools as part of the period products being delivered into schools as part of the Government's schools as part of the Government's nation-wide schools as part of the Government's nation-wide rollout. schools as part of the Government's nation-wide rollout. So schools as part of the Government's nation-wide rollout. So far schools as part of the Government's nation-wide rollout. So far over nation-wide rollout. So far over 86,000 nation-wide rollout. So far over 86,000 pads nation-wide rollout. So far over 86,000 pads and nation-wide rollout. So far over 86,000 pads and tampons nation-wide rollout. So far over 86,000 pads and tampons have nation-wide rollout. So far over 86,000 pads and tampons have been 86,000 pads and tampons have been received 86,000 pads and tampons have been received by 86,000 pads and tampons have been received by schools. 86,000 pads and tampons have been received by schools. Free 86,000 pads and tampons have been received by schools. Free period received by schools. Free period products received by schools. Free period products are received by schools. Free period products are part received by schools. Free period products are part of received by schools. Free period products are part of the received by schools. Free period products are part of the wider products are part of the wider effort products are part of the wider effort to products are part of the wider effort to combat products are part of the wider effort to combat child products are part of the wider effort to combat child poverty, products are part of the wider effort to combat child poverty, help effort to combat child poverty, help increase effort to combat child poverty, help increase school effort to combat child poverty, help increase school attendance effort to combat child poverty, help increase school attendance and effort to combat child poverty, help increase school attendance and make increase school attendance and make a increase school attendance and make a positive increase school attendance and make a positive impact increase school attendance and make a positive impact on increase school attendance and make a positive impact on student a positive impact on student wellbeing. a positive impact on student wellbeing. It a positive impact on student wellbeing. It follows a positive impact on student wellbeing. It follows other a positive impact on student wellbeing. It follows other barrier wellbeing. It follows other barrier Free wellbeing. It follows other barrier Free access wellbeing. It follows other barrier Free access initiatives wellbeing. It follows other barrier Free access initiatives rolled wellbeing. It follows other barrier Free access initiatives rolled out Free access initiatives rolled out by Free access initiatives rolled out by this Free access initiatives rolled out by this Government Free access initiatives rolled out by this Government including Free access initiatives rolled out by this Government including free by this Government including free healthy by this Government including free healthy lunches by this Government including free healthy lunches in by this Government including free healthy lunches in school, healthy lunches in school, counsellors healthy lunches in school, counsellors in healthy lunches in school, counsellors in schools, healthy lunches in school, counsellors in schools, removing counsellors in schools, removing school counsellors in schools, removing school donations counsellors in schools, removing school donations and counsellors in schools, removing school donations and Mana counsellors in schools, removing school donations and Mana Ake counsellors in schools, removing school donations and Mana Ake mental school donations and Mana Ake mental health school donations and Mana Ake mental health and school donations and Mana Ake mental health and wellbeing school donations and Mana Ake mental health and wellbeing services. health and wellbeing services. Supplementary. health and wellbeing services. Supplementary. What health and wellbeing services. Supplementary. What feedback health and wellbeing services. Supplementary. What feedback has health and wellbeing services. Supplementary. What feedback has she Supplementary. What feedback has she received Supplementary. What feedback has she received on Supplementary. What feedback has she received on the Supplementary. What feedback has she received on the impact Supplementary. What feedback has she received on the impact this received on the impact this programme received on the impact this programme will received on the impact this programme will have? received on the impact this programme will have? I received on the impact this programme will have? I have received on the impact this programme will have? I have spoken programme will have? I have spoken to programme will have? I have spoken to many programme will have? I have spoken to many young programme will have? I have spoken to many young women programme will have? I have spoken to many young women and programme will have? I have spoken to many young women and girls programme will have? I have spoken to many young women and girls in to many young women and girls in schools to many young women and girls in schools who to many young women and girls in schools who have to many young women and girls in schools who have told to many young women and girls in schools who have told me to many young women and girls in schools who have told me first to many young women and girls in schools who have told me first the schools who have told me first the differences schools who have told me first the differences -- schools who have told me first the differences -- firsthand schools who have told me first the differences -- firsthand the differences -- firsthand the differences differences -- firsthand the differences this differences -- firsthand the differences this will differences -- firsthand the differences this will make differences -- firsthand the differences this will make in differences -- firsthand the differences this will make in their differences this will make in their lives. differences this will make in their lives. One differences this will make in their lives. One young differences this will make in their lives. One young girl differences this will make in their lives. One young girl last differences this will make in their lives. One young girl last week differences this will make in their lives. One young girl last week in lives. One young girl last week in Auckland lives. One young girl last week in Auckland girls lives. One young girl last week in Auckland girls grammar lives. One young girl last week in Auckland girls grammar shared lives. One young girl last week in Auckland girls grammar shared a Auckland girls grammar shared a story Auckland girls grammar shared a story on Auckland girls grammar shared a story on how Auckland girls grammar shared a story on how it Auckland girls grammar shared a story on how it will Auckland girls grammar shared a story on how it will make Auckland girls grammar shared a story on how it will make a story on how it will make a difference story on how it will make a difference to story on how it will make a difference to her story on how it will make a difference to her and story on how it will make a difference to her and her story on how it will make a difference to her and her single difference to her and her single parent difference to her and her single parent father. difference to her and her single parent father. The difference to her and her single parent father. The free difference to her and her single parent father. The free period parent father. The free period products parent father. The free period products will parent father. The free period products will not parent father. The free period products will not only parent father. The free period products will not only reduce products will not only reduce financial products will not only reduce financial stress products will not only reduce financial stress on products will not only reduce financial stress on their products will not only reduce financial stress on their household financial stress on their household but financial stress on their household but will financial stress on their household but will improve financial stress on their household but will improve her financial stress on their household but will improve her participation but will improve her participation and but will improve her participation and comfort but will improve her participation and comfort in but will improve her participation and comfort in school but will improve her participation and comfort in school life. but will improve her participation and comfort in school life. What but will improve her participation and comfort in school life. What are and comfort in school life. What are the and comfort in school life. What are the next and comfort in school life. What are the next steps and comfort in school life. What are the next steps in and comfort in school life. What are the next steps in this and comfort in school life. What are the next steps in this programme? the next steps in this programme? The the next steps in this programme? The subsequent the next steps in this programme? The subsequent phases the next steps in this programme? The subsequent phases of the next steps in this programme? The subsequent phases of this The subsequent phases of this programme The subsequent phases of this programme will The subsequent phases of this programme will include The subsequent phases of this programme will include refining The subsequent phases of this programme will include refining the programme will include refining the distribution programme will include refining the distribution model programme will include refining the distribution model so programme will include refining the distribution model so we programme will include refining the distribution model so we can programme will include refining the distribution model so we can further distribution model so we can further improve distribution model so we can further improve the distribution model so we can further improve the allocation distribution model so we can further improve the allocation of distribution model so we can further improve the allocation of products improve the allocation of products where improve the allocation of products where and improve the allocation of products where and when improve the allocation of products where and when they improve the allocation of products where and when they are improve the allocation of products where and when they are needed. improve the allocation of products where and when they are needed. This where and when they are needed. This will where and when they are needed. This will be where and when they are needed. This will be informed where and when they are needed. This will be informed by where and when they are needed. This will be informed by student where and when they are needed. This will be informed by student voice will be informed by student voice and will be informed by student voice and the will be informed by student voice and the aim will be informed by student voice and the aim is will be informed by student voice and the aim is to will be informed by student voice and the aim is to be will be informed by student voice and the aim is to be as will be informed by student voice and the aim is to be as flexible will be informed by student voice and the aim is to be as flexible to and the aim is to be as flexible to the and the aim is to be as flexible to the needs and the aim is to be as flexible to the needs and and the aim is to be as flexible to the needs and preferences and the aim is to be as flexible to the needs and preferences as the needs and preferences as possible. the needs and preferences as possible. An the needs and preferences as possible. An important the needs and preferences as possible. An important part the needs and preferences as possible. An important part of the needs and preferences as possible. An important part of this possible. An important part of this rollout possible. An important part of this rollout is possible. An important part of this rollout is the possible. An important part of this rollout is the programme possible. An important part of this rollout is the programme that possible. An important part of this rollout is the programme that will rollout is the programme that will involve rollout is the programme that will involve developing rollout is the programme that will involve developing educational involve developing educational resources involve developing educational resources to involve developing educational resources to support involve developing educational resources to support the involve developing educational resources to support the education resources to support the education to resources to support the education to reduce resources to support the education to reduce stigma resources to support the education to reduce stigma and resources to support the education to reduce stigma and include resources to support the education to reduce stigma and include our to reduce stigma and include our young to reduce stigma and include our young - to reduce stigma and include our young - to to reduce stigma and include our young - to help to reduce stigma and include our young - to help our to reduce stigma and include our young - to help our young to reduce stigma and include our young - to help our young people's young - to help our young people's comfort young - to help our young people's comfort in young - to help our young people's comfort in talking young - to help our young people's comfort in talking and young - to help our young people's comfort in talking and dealing young - to help our young people's comfort in talking and dealing with comfort in talking and dealing with their comfort in talking and dealing with their periods comfort in talking and dealing with their periods at comfort in talking and dealing with their periods at school comfort in talking and dealing with their periods at school for comfort in talking and dealing with their periods at school for both comfort in talking and dealing with their periods at school for both our their periods at school for both our male their periods at school for both our male and their periods at school for both our male and our their periods at school for both our male and our female their periods at school for both our male and our female students. male and our female students. Question male and our female students. Question No.8. male and our female students. Question No.8. Matt male and our female students. Question No.8. Matt Doocey. male male and male and our male and our female male and our female students. male and our female students. Question male and our female students. Question No.8. male and our female students. Question No.8. Matt male and our female students. Question No.8. Matt Doocey. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Health: My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, as My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, as of My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, as of the My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, as of the end My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, as of the end of My question is to the Minister of Health: Why, as of the end of April Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, had Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, had only Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, had only 0.2 Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, had only 0.2 percent Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, had only 0.2 percent of Health: Why, as of the end of April 2021, had only 0.2 percent of the 2021, had only 0.2 percent of the $235 2021, had only 0.2 percent of the $235 million 2021, had only 0.2 percent of the $235 million announced 2021, had only 0.2 percent of the $235 million announced in 2021, had only 0.2 percent of the $235 million announced in Budget $235 million announced in Budget 2019 $235 million announced in Budget 2019 for $235 million announced in Budget 2019 for capital $235 million announced in Budget 2019 for capital investment $235 million announced in Budget 2019 for capital investment in 2019 for capital investment in mental 2019 for capital investment in mental health 2019 for capital investment in mental health and 2019 for capital investment in mental health and addiction mental health and addiction facilities mental health and addiction facilities actually mental health and addiction facilities actually been mental health and addiction facilities actually been spent? The The $235 The $235 million The $235 million was The $235 million was set The $235 million was set aside The $235 million was set aside for The $235 million was set aside for the The $235 million was set aside for the investment The $235 million was set aside for the investment into The $235 million was set aside for the investment into rebuilding The $235 million was set aside for the investment into rebuilding or the investment into rebuilding or upgrading the investment into rebuilding or upgrading mental the investment into rebuilding or upgrading mental health the investment into rebuilding or upgrading mental health facilities upgrading mental health facilities from upgrading mental health facilities from the upgrading mental health facilities from the total upgrading mental health facilities from the total Vote upgrading mental health facilities from the total Vote Health from the total Vote Health allocation from the total Vote Health allocation of from the total Vote Health allocation of $1.1 from the total Vote Health allocation of $1.1 billion from the total Vote Health allocation of $1.1 billion for from the total Vote Health allocation of $1.1 billion for the allocation of $1.1 billion for the mental allocation of $1.1 billion for the mental health allocation of $1.1 billion for the mental health services allocation of $1.1 billion for the mental health services upgrade. mental health services upgrade. Health mental health services upgrade. Health capital mental health services upgrade. Health capital projects mental health services upgrade. Health capital projects follow mental health services upgrade. Health capital projects follow a Health capital projects follow a detailed Health capital projects follow a detailed process Health capital projects follow a detailed process which Health capital projects follow a detailed process which takes Health capital projects follow a detailed process which takes time. detailed process which takes time. This detailed process which takes time. This includes detailed process which takes time. This includes prioritisation, This includes prioritisation, business This includes prioritisation, business case This includes prioritisation, business case development This includes prioritisation, business case development and This includes prioritisation, business case development and design business case development and design work business case development and design work all business case development and design work all before business case development and design work all before building business case development and design work all before building can business case development and design work all before building can start. work all before building can start. For work all before building can start. For example, work all before building can start. For example, the work all before building can start. For example, the original For example, the original announcement For example, the original announcement for For example, the original announcement for the For example, the original announcement for the full For example, the original announcement for the full rebuild For example, the original announcement for the full rebuild of announcement for the full rebuild of the announcement for the full rebuild of the Henry announcement for the full rebuild of the Henry wrongo announcement for the full rebuild of the Henry wrongo my announcement for the full rebuild of the Henry wrongo my Bennett announcement for the full rebuild of the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre in the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre in Waikato the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre in Waikato said the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre in Waikato said the the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre in Waikato said the facility the Henry wrongo my Bennett centre in Waikato said the facility would in Waikato said the facility would open in Waikato said the facility would open in in Waikato said the facility would open in 2023, in Waikato said the facility would open in 2023, in in Waikato said the facility would open in 2023, in relation in Waikato said the facility would open in 2023, in relation to in Waikato said the facility would open in 2023, in relation to the open in 2023, in relation to the what open in 2023, in relation to the what the open in 2023, in relation to the what the member open in 2023, in relation to the what the member says open in 2023, in relation to the what the member says has open in 2023, in relation to the what the member says has been open in 2023, in relation to the what the member says has been spent what the member says has been spent the what the member says has been spent the member what the member says has been spent the member should what the member says has been spent the member should be what the member says has been spent the member should be aware what the member says has been spent the member should be aware there what the member says has been spent the member should be aware there is the member should be aware there is a the member should be aware there is a timing the member should be aware there is a timing difference the member should be aware there is a timing difference between the member should be aware there is a timing difference between what the member should be aware there is a timing difference between what is a timing difference between what is spent a timing difference between what is spent by a timing difference between what is spent by District a timing difference between what is spent by District Health a timing difference between what is spent by District Health Boards a timing difference between what is spent by District Health Boards on a timing difference between what is spent by District Health Boards on a spent by District Health Boards on a capital spent by District Health Boards on a capital project spent by District Health Boards on a capital project and spent by District Health Boards on a capital project and what spent by District Health Boards on a capital project and what is spent by District Health Boards on a capital project and what is claimed capital project and what is claimed by capital project and what is claimed by the capital project and what is claimed by the Ministry capital project and what is claimed by the Ministry of capital project and what is claimed by the Ministry of Health capital project and what is claimed by the Ministry of Health and capital project and what is claimed by the Ministry of Health and booked by the Ministry of Health and booked against by the Ministry of Health and booked against the by the Ministry of Health and booked against the relevant by the Ministry of Health and booked against the relevant appropriation. against the relevant appropriation. Claims against the relevant appropriation. Claims for against the relevant appropriation. Claims for expenses against the relevant appropriation. Claims for expenses incurred against the relevant appropriation. Claims for expenses incurred for Claims for expenses incurred for capital Claims for expenses incurred for capital projects Claims for expenses incurred for capital projects are Claims for expenses incurred for capital projects are made Claims for expenses incurred for capital projects are made at capital projects are made at relevant capital projects are made at relevant milestones capital projects are made at relevant milestones for capital projects are made at relevant milestones for example capital projects are made at relevant milestones for example once relevant milestones for example once the relevant milestones for example once the detailed relevant milestones for example once the detailed business relevant milestones for example once the detailed business case relevant milestones for example once the detailed business case and the detailed business case and allocated the detailed business case and allocated funding the detailed business case and allocated funding has the detailed business case and allocated funding has been the detailed business case and allocated funding has been approved allocated funding has been approved or allocated funding has been approved or at allocated funding has been approved or at relevant allocated funding has been approved or at relevant times allocated funding has been approved or at relevant times during allocated funding has been approved or at relevant times during the or at relevant times during the financial or at relevant times during the financial year. or at relevant times during the financial year. Of or at relevant times during the financial year. Of the or at relevant times during the financial year. Of the five or at relevant times during the financial year. Of the five projects financial year. Of the five projects funded financial year. Of the five projects funded from financial year. Of the five projects funded from the financial year. Of the five projects funded from the allocation, financial year. Of the five projects funded from the allocation, four financial year. Of the five projects funded from the allocation, four are funded from the allocation, four are in funded from the allocation, four are in the funded from the allocation, four are in the detailed funded from the allocation, four are in the detailed design funded from the allocation, four are in the detailed design phase funded from the allocation, four are in the detailed design phase and funded from the allocation, four are in the detailed design phase and one in the detailed design phase and one is in the detailed design phase and one is still in the detailed design phase and one is still awaiting in the detailed design phase and one is still awaiting a in the detailed design phase and one is still awaiting a business in the detailed design phase and one is still awaiting a business case. is still awaiting a business case. All is still awaiting a business case. All are is still awaiting a business case. All are incurring is still awaiting a business case. All are incurring expenditure is still awaiting a business case. All are incurring expenditure right All are incurring expenditure right now All are incurring expenditure right now but All are incurring expenditure right now but only All are incurring expenditure right now but only two All are incurring expenditure right now but only two have All are incurring expenditure right now but only two have sought All are incurring expenditure right now but only two have sought minimal now but only two have sought minimal reimbursement now but only two have sought minimal reimbursement for now but only two have sought minimal reimbursement for preliminary now but only two have sought minimal reimbursement for preliminary work. reimbursement for preliminary work. Why reimbursement for preliminary work. Why did reimbursement for preliminary work. Why did the reimbursement for preliminary work. Why did the Ministry reimbursement for preliminary work. Why did the Ministry of reimbursement for preliminary work. Why did the Ministry of Health Why did the Ministry of Health mislead Why did the Ministry of Health mislead the Why did the Ministry of Health mislead the media Why did the Ministry of Health mislead the media yesterday Why did the Ministry of Health mislead the media yesterday when Why did the Ministry of Health mislead the media yesterday when it mislead the media yesterday when it stated mislead the media yesterday when it stated they mislead the media yesterday when it stated they couldn't mislead the media yesterday when it stated they couldn't say mislead the media yesterday when it stated they couldn't say how mislead the media yesterday when it stated they couldn't say how much stated they couldn't say how much had stated they couldn't say how much had been stated they couldn't say how much had been spent stated they couldn't say how much had been spent on stated they couldn't say how much had been spent on building... stated they couldn't say how much had been spent on building... A had been spent on building... A point had been spent on building... A point of had been spent on building... A point of order, had been spent on building... A point of order, the had been spent on building... A point of order, the Hon had been spent on building... A point of order, the Hon Grant point of order, the Hon Grant Robertson. point of order, the Hon Grant Robertson. I'm point of order, the Hon Grant Robertson. I'm not point of order, the Hon Grant Robertson. I'm not sure, point of order, the Hon Grant Robertson. I'm not sure, I point of order, the Hon Grant Robertson. I'm not sure, I think Robertson. I'm not sure, I think there Robertson. I'm not sure, I think there are Robertson. I'm not sure, I think there are various Robertson. I'm not sure, I think there are various speakers Robertson. I'm not sure, I think there are various speakers Rulings there are various speakers Rulings about there are various speakers Rulings about using there are various speakers Rulings about using the there are various speakers Rulings about using the phrasing there are various speakers Rulings about using the phrasing the there are various speakers Rulings about using the phrasing the member about using the phrasing the member did about using the phrasing the member did in about using the phrasing the member did in that about using the phrasing the member did in that question. about using the phrasing the member did in that question. I'm about using the phrasing the member did in that question. I'm not about using the phrasing the member did in that question. I'm not sure did in that question. I'm not sure that did in that question. I'm not sure that is did in that question. I'm not sure that is within did in that question. I'm not sure that is within Standing did in that question. I'm not sure that is within Standing Orders. that is within Standing Orders. <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! Who <INTERRUPTION> Order! Who interjected <INTERRUPTION> Order! Who interjected then? <INTERRUPTION> Order! Who interjected then? The Order! Who interjected then? The member Order! Who interjected then? The member will Order! Who interjected then? The member will withdraw Order! Who interjected then? The member will withdraw and Order! Who interjected then? The member will withdraw and apologise. member will withdraw and apologise. I member will withdraw and apologise. I withdraw member will withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and member will withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. member will withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I member will withdraw and apologise. I withdraw and apologise. I will I withdraw and apologise. I will reverse I withdraw and apologise. I will reverse out I withdraw and apologise. I will reverse out the I withdraw and apologise. I will reverse out the decision I withdraw and apologise. I will reverse out the decision I I withdraw and apologise. I will reverse out the decision I made reverse out the decision I made earlier. reverse out the decision I made earlier. Point reverse out the decision I made earlier. Point of reverse out the decision I made earlier. Point of order. reverse out the decision I made earlier. Point of order. The reverse out the decision I made earlier. Point of order. The reason earlier. Point of order. The reason I earlier. Point of order. The reason I am earlier. Point of order. The reason I am able earlier. Point of order. The reason I am able to earlier. Point of order. The reason I am able to put earlier. Point of order. The reason I am able to put that earlier. Point of order. The reason I am able to put that primary I am able to put that primary question I am able to put that primary question is I am able to put that primary question is because I am able to put that primary question is because I I am able to put that primary question is because I received I am able to put that primary question is because I received from question is because I received from the question is because I received from the Ministry question is because I received from the Ministry of question is because I received from the Ministry of Health question is because I received from the Ministry of Health how question is because I received from the Ministry of Health how much question is because I received from the Ministry of Health how much they the Ministry of Health how much they actually the Ministry of Health how much they actually spent the Ministry of Health how much they actually spent yet the Ministry of Health how much they actually spent yet yesterday the Ministry of Health how much they actually spent yet yesterday when actually spent yet yesterday when they actually spent yet yesterday when they told actually spent yet yesterday when they told the actually spent yet yesterday when they told the media actually spent yet yesterday when they told the media when actually spent yet yesterday when they told the media when asked actually spent yet yesterday when they told the media when asked the they told the media when asked the same they told the media when asked the same question they told the media when asked the same question they they told the media when asked the same question they didn't they told the media when asked the same question they didn't know they told the media when asked the same question they didn't know how same question they didn't know how much. same question they didn't know how much. I same question they didn't know how much. I would same question they didn't know how much. I would call same question they didn't know how much. I would call that same question they didn't know how much. I would call that misleading. Speaking Speaking to Speaking to the Speaking to the further Speaking to the further point Speaking to the further point of Speaking to the further point of order. Speaking to the further point of order. The Speaking to the further point of order. The point Speaking to the further point of order. The point is Speaking to the further point of order. The point is it Speaking to the further point of order. The point is it was Speaking to the further point of order. The point is it was made Speaking to the further point of order. The point is it was made as Speaking to the further point of order. The point is it was made as a order. The point is it was made as a direct order. The point is it was made as a direct assertion. order. The point is it was made as a direct assertion. Mr order. The point is it was made as a direct assertion. Mr Doocey order. The point is it was made as a direct assertion. Mr Doocey has direct assertion. Mr Doocey has provided direct assertion. Mr Doocey has provided us direct assertion. Mr Doocey has provided us with direct assertion. Mr Doocey has provided us with information direct assertion. Mr Doocey has provided us with information that provided us with information that may provided us with information that may or provided us with information that may or may provided us with information that may or may not provided us with information that may or may not be provided us with information that may or may not be correct, provided us with information that may or may not be correct, we provided us with information that may or may not be correct, we can't may or may not be correct, we can't see may or may not be correct, we can't see that... may or may not be correct, we can't see that... <INTERRUPTION> see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who was see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who was that? see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who was that? It see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who was that? It was see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who was that? It was a see that... <INTERRUPTION> Who was that? It was a repeat Who was that? It was a repeat offender, Who was that? It was a repeat offender, Mr Who was that? It was a repeat offender, Mr Speaker. Who was that? It was a repeat offender, Mr Speaker. Who Who was that? It was a repeat offender, Mr Speaker. Who was Who was that? It was a repeat offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who made offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who made that offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who made that noise? offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who made that noise? I offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who made that noise? I did. offender, Mr Speaker. Who was it? Who made that noise? I did. The Who made that noise? I did. The member Who made that noise? I did. The member will Who made that noise? I did. The member will leave Who made that noise? I did. The member will leave the Who made that noise? I did. The member will leave the Chamber. Matt Matt Doocey. Matt Doocey. Would Matt Doocey. Would it Matt Doocey. Would it be Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if I Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if I slightly Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if I slightly rephrase Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if I slightly rephrase the Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if I slightly rephrase the question Matt Doocey. Would it be helpful if I slightly rephrase the question and I slightly rephrase the question and it I slightly rephrase the question and it might I slightly rephrase the question and it might get I slightly rephrase the question and it might get through I slightly rephrase the question and it might get through with I slightly rephrase the question and it might get through with your it might get through with your permission? it might get through with your permission? Can it might get through with your permission? Can I it might get through with your permission? Can I give it might get through with your permission? Can I give it it might get through with your permission? Can I give it a it might get through with your permission? Can I give it a go? it might get through with your permission? Can I give it a go? The permission? Can I give it a go? The member permission? Can I give it a go? The member can permission? Can I give it a go? The member can give permission? Can I give it a go? The member can give it permission? Can I give it a go? The member can give it a permission? Can I give it a go? The member can give it a go. permission? Can I give it a go? The member can give it a go. I permission? Can I give it a go? The member can give it a go. I was member can give it a go. I was tending member can give it a go. I was tending in member can give it a go. I was tending in his member can give it a go. I was tending in his direction member can give it a go. I was tending in his direction anyway member can give it a go. I was tending in his direction anyway but tending in his direction anyway but have tending in his direction anyway but have a tending in his direction anyway but have a go. tending in his direction anyway but have a go. That's tending in his direction anyway but have a go. That's OK. tending in his direction anyway but have a go. That's OK. Here tending in his direction anyway but have a go. That's OK. Here to tending in his direction anyway but have a go. That's OK. Here to help. have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been a have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been a tough have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been a tough day have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been a tough day for have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been a tough day for you have a go. That's OK. Here to help. It's been a tough day for you guys. It's been a tough day for you guys. So It's been a tough day for you guys. So the It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer is It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer is now It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer is now no. It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer is now no. So It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer is now no. So if It's been a tough day for you guys. So the answer is now no. So if the So the answer is now no. So if the member So the answer is now no. So if the member wants So the answer is now no. So if the member wants to So the answer is now no. So if the member wants to use So the answer is now no. So if the member wants to use another member wants to use another supplementary, member wants to use another supplementary, he member wants to use another supplementary, he can. member wants to use another supplementary, he can. Why member wants to use another supplementary, he can. Why has member wants to use another supplementary, he can. Why has only supplementary, he can. Why has only one supplementary, he can. Why has only one new supplementary, he can. Why has only one new mental supplementary, he can. Why has only one new mental health supplementary, he can. Why has only one new mental health facility one new mental health facility opened one new mental health facility opened since one new mental health facility opened since Labour one new mental health facility opened since Labour came one new mental health facility opened since Labour came into opened since Labour came into Government opened since Labour came into Government almost opened since Labour came into Government almost four opened since Labour came into Government almost four years opened since Labour came into Government almost four years ago? Government almost four years ago? There's Government almost four years ago? There's a Government almost four years ago? There's a very Government almost four years ago? There's a very good Government almost four years ago? There's a very good reason Government almost four years ago? There's a very good reason for Government almost four years ago? There's a very good reason for that There's a very good reason for that and There's a very good reason for that and that There's a very good reason for that and that is There's a very good reason for that and that is that There's a very good reason for that and that is that apart There's a very good reason for that and that is that apart from There's a very good reason for that and that is that apart from one and that is that apart from one facility and that is that apart from one facility that and that is that apart from one facility that the and that is that apart from one facility that the previous facility that the previous Government facility that the previous Government approved facility that the previous Government approved in facility that the previous Government approved in 2015 facility that the previous Government approved in 2015 and Government approved in 2015 and opened Government approved in 2015 and opened last Government approved in 2015 and opened last year, Government approved in 2015 and opened last year, that Government approved in 2015 and opened last year, that Government opened last year, that Government did opened last year, that Government did absolutely opened last year, that Government did absolutely flog opened last year, that Government did absolutely flog for opened last year, that Government did absolutely flog for mental did absolutely flog for mental health did absolutely flog for mental health services did absolutely flog for mental health services in did absolutely flog for mental health services in New did absolutely flog for mental health services in New Zealand. did absolutely flog for mental health services in New Zealand. They health services in New Zealand. They left health services in New Zealand. They left the health services in New Zealand. They left the mental health services in New Zealand. They left the mental health health services in New Zealand. They left the mental health services health services in New Zealand. They left the mental health services in left the mental health services in this left the mental health services in this country left the mental health services in this country in left the mental health services in this country in an left the mental health services in this country in an absolutely this country in an absolutely particle this country in an absolutely particle use this country in an absolutely particle use state this country in an absolutely particle use state which this country in an absolutely particle use state which is this country in an absolutely particle use state which is why this country in an absolutely particle use state which is why as particle use state which is why as soon particle use state which is why as soon as particle use state which is why as soon as we particle use state which is why as soon as we took particle use state which is why as soon as we took office particle use state which is why as soon as we took office we particle use state which is why as soon as we took office we did particle use state which is why as soon as we took office we did a soon as we took office we did a stock soon as we took office we did a stock take, soon as we took office we did a stock take, we soon as we took office we did a stock take, we had soon as we took office we did a stock take, we had a soon as we took office we did a stock take, we had a review soon as we took office we did a stock take, we had a review and soon as we took office we did a stock take, we had a review and we stock take, we had a review and we developed stock take, we had a review and we developed a stock take, we had a review and we developed a plan, stock take, we had a review and we developed a plan, a stock take, we had a review and we developed a plan, a $1.9 stock take, we had a review and we developed a plan, a $1.9 billion developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that is developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that is a developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that is a four developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that is a four to developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that is a four to five developed a plan, a $1.9 billion plan that is a four to five year plan that is a four to five year plan plan that is a four to five year plan and plan that is a four to five year plan and we plan that is a four to five year plan and we are plan that is a four to five year plan and we are partway plan that is a four to five year plan and we are partway through plan and we are partway through implementing plan and we are partway through implementing that plan and we are partway through implementing that with plan and we are partway through implementing that with all plan and we are partway through implementing that with all the implementing that with all the benefits implementing that with all the benefits that implementing that with all the benefits that the implementing that with all the benefits that the PM implementing that with all the benefits that the PM has implementing that with all the benefits that the PM has already benefits that the PM has already articulated benefits that the PM has already articulated but benefits that the PM has already articulated but we benefits that the PM has already articulated but we are benefits that the PM has already articulated but we are doing benefits that the PM has already articulated but we are doing a benefits that the PM has already articulated but we are doing a plan. articulated but we are doing a plan. It articulated but we are doing a plan. It is articulated but we are doing a plan. It is good, articulated but we are doing a plan. It is good, it articulated but we are doing a plan. It is good, it is articulated but we are doing a plan. It is good, it is making articulated but we are doing a plan. It is good, it is making a It is good, it is making a difference It is good, it is making a difference and It is good, it is making a difference and it It is good, it is making a difference and it is It is good, it is making a difference and it is the It is good, it is making a difference and it is the right It is good, it is making a difference and it is the right thing difference and it is the right thing to difference and it is the right thing to do difference and it is the right thing to do for difference and it is the right thing to do for vulnerable difference and it is the right thing to do for vulnerable New difference and it is the right thing to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. Supplementary. to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. Supplementary. What to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. Supplementary. What was to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. Supplementary. What was the to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. Supplementary. What was the point to do for vulnerable New Zealanders. Supplementary. What was the point of Supplementary. What was the point of the Supplementary. What was the point of the last Supplementary. What was the point of the last mental Supplementary. What was the point of the last mental health Supplementary. What was the point of the last mental health review the last mental health review initiated the last mental health review initiated by the last mental health review initiated by the the last mental health review initiated by the Government the last mental health review initiated by the Government in the last mental health review initiated by the Government in 2018 initiated by the Government in 2018 if initiated by the Government in 2018 if we initiated by the Government in 2018 if we now initiated by the Government in 2018 if we now need initiated by the Government in 2018 if we now need to initiated by the Government in 2018 if we now need to have initiated by the Government in 2018 if we now need to have another if we now need to have another review if we now need to have another review announced if we now need to have another review announced this if we now need to have another review announced this morning? if we now need to have another review announced this morning? The review announced this morning? The reason review announced this morning? The reason we review announced this morning? The reason we had review announced this morning? The reason we had the review announced this morning? The reason we had the review review announced this morning? The reason we had the review in review announced this morning? The reason we had the review in 2018 review announced this morning? The reason we had the review in 2018 is reason we had the review in 2018 is because reason we had the review in 2018 is because the reason we had the review in 2018 is because the previous reason we had the review in 2018 is because the previous Government reason we had the review in 2018 is because the previous Government left because the previous Government left mental because the previous Government left mental health because the previous Government left mental health services because the previous Government left mental health services in because the previous Government left mental health services in an mental health services in an absolutely mental health services in an absolutely particle mental health services in an absolutely particle use mental health services in an absolutely particle use state. mental health services in an absolutely particle use state. They absolutely particle use state. They just absolutely particle use state. They just totally absolutely particle use state. They just totally ignored absolutely particle use state. They just totally ignored the absolutely particle use state. They just totally ignored the emerging just totally ignored the emerging mental just totally ignored the emerging mental health just totally ignored the emerging mental health crisis just totally ignored the emerging mental health crisis in just totally ignored the emerging mental health crisis in this mental health crisis in this country. mental health crisis in this country. They mental health crisis in this country. They washed mental health crisis in this country. They washed their mental health crisis in this country. They washed their hands mental health crisis in this country. They washed their hands of country. They washed their hands of it. country. They washed their hands of it. The country. They washed their hands of it. The sad country. They washed their hands of it. The sad reality country. They washed their hands of it. The sad reality is country. They washed their hands of it. The sad reality is that country. They washed their hands of it. The sad reality is that Labour it. The sad reality is that Labour Government's it. The sad reality is that Labour Government's end it. The sad reality is that Labour Government's end up it. The sad reality is that Labour Government's end up picking it. The sad reality is that Labour Government's end up picking up it. The sad reality is that Labour Government's end up picking up the Government's end up picking up the pieces. Government's end up picking up the pieces. The Government's end up picking up the pieces. The pieces Government's end up picking up the pieces. The pieces when Government's end up picking up the pieces. The pieces when a Government's end up picking up the pieces. The pieces when a Government pieces. The pieces when a Government neglects pieces. The pieces when a Government neglects mental pieces. The pieces when a Government neglects mental health pieces. The pieces when a Government neglects mental health is pieces. The pieces when a Government neglects mental health is the neglects mental health is the shattered neglects mental health is the shattered lives neglects mental health is the shattered lives of neglects mental health is the shattered lives of vulnerable neglects mental health is the shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we are shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we are now shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we are now having shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we are now having to shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we are now having to repair shattered lives of vulnerable Nazi who we are now having to repair a who we are now having to repair a broken who we are now having to repair a broken system who we are now having to repair a broken system for who we are now having to repair a broken system for so who we are now having to repair a broken system for so they who we are now having to repair a broken system for so they get who we are now having to repair a broken system for so they get the broken system for so they get the care broken system for so they get the care they broken system for so they get the care they deserve. broken system for so they get the care they deserve. Supplementary, care they deserve. Supplementary, how care they deserve. Supplementary, how can care they deserve. Supplementary, how can New care they deserve. Supplementary, how can New Zealanders care they deserve. Supplementary, how can New Zealanders just care they deserve. Supplementary, how can New Zealanders just the how can New Zealanders just the Government's how can New Zealanders just the Government's review how can New Zealanders just the Government's review into how can New Zealanders just the Government's review into mental Government's review into mental health Government's review into mental health health Government's review into mental health health announced Government's review into mental health health announced by Government's review into mental health health announced by him Government's review into mental health health announced by him this health health announced by him this morning health health announced by him this morning when health health announced by him this morning when his health health announced by him this morning when his Government's morning when his Government's failure morning when his Government's failure to morning when his Government's failure to deliver morning when his Government's failure to deliver in morning when his Government's failure to deliver in mental morning when his Government's failure to deliver in mental health failure to deliver in mental health is failure to deliver in mental health is the failure to deliver in mental health is the problem? failure to deliver in mental health is the problem? I'm failure to deliver in mental health is the problem? I'm happy failure to deliver in mental health is the problem? I'm happy to failure to deliver in mental health is the problem? I'm happy to go is the problem? I'm happy to go through is the problem? I'm happy to go through what is the problem? I'm happy to go through what this is the problem? I'm happy to go through what this Government is the problem? I'm happy to go through what this Government has through what this Government has done through what this Government has done in through what this Government has done in the through what this Government has done in the two through what this Government has done in the two years through what this Government has done in the two years since through what this Government has done in the two years since the done in the two years since the announcement done in the two years since the announcement of done in the two years since the announcement of the done in the two years since the announcement of the $1.9 done in the two years since the announcement of the $1.9 billion announcement of the $1.9 billion upgrade, announcement of the $1.9 billion upgrade, 520 announcement of the $1.9 billion upgrade, 520 full-time announcement of the $1.9 billion upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles now upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles now added upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles now added to upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles now added to our upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles now added to our mental upgrade, 520 full-time equivalent roles now added to our mental health roles now added to our mental health services, roles now added to our mental health services, 360 roles now added to our mental health services, 360 health roles now added to our mental health services, 360 health ins roles now added to our mental health services, 360 health ins and roles now added to our mental health services, 360 health ins and health services, 360 health ins and health coaches services, 360 health ins and health coaches in services, 360 health ins and health coaches in GP services, 360 health ins and health coaches in GP practices. services, 360 health ins and health coaches in GP practices. 50 services, 360 health ins and health coaches in GP practices. 50 in coaches in GP practices. 50 in kaupapa coaches in GP practices. 50 in kaupapa Maori coaches in GP practices. 50 in kaupapa Maori health coaches in GP practices. 50 in kaupapa Maori health services, coaches in GP practices. 50 in kaupapa Maori health services, 50 coaches in GP practices. 50 in kaupapa Maori health services, 50 in kaupapa Maori health services, 50 in Pacific kaupapa Maori health services, 50 in Pacific mental kaupapa Maori health services, 50 in Pacific mental health kaupapa Maori health services, 50 in Pacific mental health services kaupapa Maori health services, 50 in Pacific mental health services and Pacific mental health services and another Pacific mental health services and another several Pacific mental health services and another several dozen Pacific mental health services and another several dozen in Pacific mental health services and another several dozen in our Pacific mental health services and another several dozen in our youth another several dozen in our youth mental another several dozen in our youth mental health another several dozen in our youth mental health services, another several dozen in our youth mental health services, so another several dozen in our youth mental health services, so we another several dozen in our youth mental health services, so we have mental health services, so we have added mental health services, so we have added considerably mental health services, so we have added considerably to mental health services, so we have added considerably to it. mental health services, so we have added considerably to it. We mental health services, so we have added considerably to it. We made added considerably to it. We made the added considerably to it. We made the commitment added considerably to it. We made the commitment to added considerably to it. We made the commitment to significantly the commitment to significantly upgrade the commitment to significantly upgrade or the commitment to significantly upgrade or rebuild the commitment to significantly upgrade or rebuild five the commitment to significantly upgrade or rebuild five mental upgrade or rebuild five mental health upgrade or rebuild five mental health facilities upgrade or rebuild five mental health facilities because upgrade or rebuild five mental health facilities because they upgrade or rebuild five mental health facilities because they were health facilities because they were left health facilities because they were left in health facilities because they were left in a health facilities because they were left in a state health facilities because they were left in a state of health facilities because they were left in a state of neglect health facilities because they were left in a state of neglect by health facilities because they were left in a state of neglect by the left in a state of neglect by the previous left in a state of neglect by the previous Government. left in a state of neglect by the previous Government. We left in a state of neglect by the previous Government. We have left in a state of neglect by the previous Government. We have done previous Government. We have done more previous Government. We have done more in previous Government. We have done more in mental previous Government. We have done more in mental health previous Government. We have done more in mental health in previous Government. We have done more in mental health in the previous Government. We have done more in mental health in the last more in mental health in the last 3.5 more in mental health in the last 3.5 years more in mental health in the last 3.5 years than more in mental health in the last 3.5 years than was more in mental health in the last 3.5 years than was done more in mental health in the last 3.5 years than was done in more in mental health in the last 3.5 years than was done in nine 3.5 years than was done in nine years 3.5 years than was done in nine years of 3.5 years than was done in nine years of that 3.5 years than was done in nine years of that previous 3.5 years than was done in nine years of that previous National years of that previous National Government. years of that previous National Government. Question years of that previous National Government. Question No.9. years of that previous National Government. Question No.9. The years of that previous National Government. Question No.9. The Hon Government. Question No.9. The Hon Eugenie Government. Question No.9. The Hon Eugenie Sage. Eugenie Eugenie Sage. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister for My question is to the Minister for Oceans My question is to the Minister for Oceans and My question is to the Minister for Oceans and Fisheries: My question is to the Minister for Oceans and Fisheries: Why My question is to the Minister for Oceans and Fisheries: Why has My question is to the Minister for Oceans and Fisheries: Why has the Oceans and Fisheries: Why has the Government's Oceans and Fisheries: Why has the Government's response Oceans and Fisheries: Why has the Government's response to Oceans and Fisheries: Why has the Government's response to the Oceans and Fisheries: Why has the Government's response to the Sea Government's response to the Sea Change-Tai Government's response to the Sea Change-Tai Timu Government's response to the Sea Change-Tai Timu Tai Government's response to the Sea Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Government's response to the Sea Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Hauraki Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Hauraki Gulf Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Hauraki Gulf Marine Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Hauraki Gulf Marine Spatial Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Hauraki Gulf Marine Spatial Plan Change-Tai Timu Tai Pari Hauraki Gulf Marine Spatial Plan not Gulf Marine Spatial Plan not implemented Gulf Marine Spatial Plan not implemented the Gulf Marine Spatial Plan not implemented the Hauraki Gulf Marine Spatial Plan not implemented the Hauraki Gulf Gulf Marine Spatial Plan not implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum target implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum target of implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum target of protecting implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum target of protecting 30 implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum target of protecting 30 percent implemented the Hauraki Gulf Forum target of protecting 30 percent of target of protecting 30 percent of the target of protecting 30 percent of the Hauraki target of protecting 30 percent of the Hauraki Gulf target of protecting 30 percent of the Hauraki Gulf Marine target of protecting 30 percent of the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park/Tikapa the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park/Tikapa Moana/Te the Hauraki Gulf Marine Park/Tikapa Moana/Te Moananui-a-Toi? The The Government's The Government's plan The Government's plan to The Government's plan to revitalise The Government's plan to revitalise the The Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki The Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf The Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf announced The Government's plan to revitalise the Hauraki Gulf announced today the Hauraki Gulf announced today include the Hauraki Gulf announced today include just the Hauraki Gulf announced today include just under the Hauraki Gulf announced today include just under a the Hauraki Gulf announced today include just under a Threefold include just under a Threefold increase include just under a Threefold increase in include just under a Threefold increase in marine include just under a Threefold increase in marine protected include just under a Threefold increase in marine protected areas increase in marine protected areas plus increase in marine protected areas plus a increase in marine protected areas plus a significant increase in marine protected areas plus a significant reduction increase in marine protected areas plus a significant reduction in increase in marine protected areas plus a significant reduction in the plus a significant reduction in the areas plus a significant reduction in the areas opened plus a significant reduction in the areas opened to plus a significant reduction in the areas opened to bottom plus a significant reduction in the areas opened to bottom trawling plus a significant reduction in the areas opened to bottom trawling and areas opened to bottom trawling and Danish areas opened to bottom trawling and Danish sane areas opened to bottom trawling and Danish sane fishing areas opened to bottom trawling and Danish sane fishing plus Danish sane fishing plus restrictions Danish sane fishing plus restrictions on Danish sane fishing plus restrictions on scallop Danish sane fishing plus restrictions on scallop plus Danish sane fishing plus restrictions on scallop plus habitat restrictions on scallop plus habitat restoration. restrictions on scallop plus habitat restoration. All restrictions on scallop plus habitat restoration. All of restrictions on scallop plus habitat restoration. All of these restrictions on scallop plus habitat restoration. All of these actions restoration. All of these actions are restoration. All of these actions are supported restoration. All of these actions are supported by restoration. All of these actions are supported by a restoration. All of these actions are supported by a cross restoration. All of these actions are supported by a cross agency are supported by a cross agency implementation are supported by a cross agency implementation plan are supported by a cross agency implementation plan with are supported by a cross agency implementation plan with a are supported by a cross agency implementation plan with a new implementation plan with a new monitoring implementation plan with a new monitoring and implementation plan with a new monitoring and reporting implementation plan with a new monitoring and reporting approach implementation plan with a new monitoring and reporting approach to monitoring and reporting approach to enable monitoring and reporting approach to enable changes monitoring and reporting approach to enable changes to monitoring and reporting approach to enable changes to the monitoring and reporting approach to enable changes to the strategy monitoring and reporting approach to enable changes to the strategy if monitoring and reporting approach to enable changes to the strategy if we enable changes to the strategy if we are enable changes to the strategy if we are not enable changes to the strategy if we are not satisfied enable changes to the strategy if we are not satisfied with enable changes to the strategy if we are not satisfied with progress. enable changes to the strategy if we are not satisfied with progress. I are not satisfied with progress. I note are not satisfied with progress. I note the are not satisfied with progress. I note the Hauraki are not satisfied with progress. I note the Hauraki Gulf are not satisfied with progress. I note the Hauraki Gulf Forum are not satisfied with progress. I note the Hauraki Gulf Forum today note the Hauraki Gulf Forum today welcomed note the Hauraki Gulf Forum today welcomed the note the Hauraki Gulf Forum today welcomed the Government's welcomed the Government's announcement welcomed the Government's announcement calling welcomed the Government's announcement calling it, welcomed the Government's announcement calling it, "An announcement calling it, "An important announcement calling it, "An important first announcement calling it, "An important first step announcement calling it, "An important first step towards announcement calling it, "An important first step towards the important first step towards the desired important first step towards the desired 30% important first step towards the desired 30% of important first step towards the desired 30% of marine important first step towards the desired 30% of marine area desired 30% of marine area protection." desired 30% of marine area protection." Today's desired 30% of marine area protection." Today's announcement desired 30% of marine area protection." Today's announcement in protection." Today's announcement in my protection." Today's announcement in my view protection." Today's announcement in my view is protection." Today's announcement in my view is a protection." Today's announcement in my view is a milestone protection." Today's announcement in my view is a milestone that protection." Today's announcement in my view is a milestone that ought my view is a milestone that ought not my view is a milestone that ought not be my view is a milestone that ought not be understated. my view is a milestone that ought not be understated. Were my view is a milestone that ought not be understated. Were the not be understated. Were the commercial not be understated. Were the commercial impacts not be understated. Were the commercial impacts on not be understated. Were the commercial impacts on commercial commercial impacts on commercial fishing commercial impacts on commercial fishing the commercial impacts on commercial fishing the major commercial impacts on commercial fishing the major reason commercial impacts on commercial fishing the major reason for commercial impacts on commercial fishing the major reason for fully fishing the major reason for fully protecting fishing the major reason for fully protecting only fishing the major reason for fully protecting only 5% fishing the major reason for fully protecting only 5% of fishing the major reason for fully protecting only 5% of the fishing the major reason for fully protecting only 5% of the Hauraki protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf marine protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf marine Park? protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf marine Park? No. protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf marine Park? No. Why protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf marine Park? No. Why is protecting only 5% of the Hauraki gulf marine Park? No. Why is the gulf marine Park? No. Why is the Government gulf marine Park? No. Why is the Government proposing gulf marine Park? No. Why is the Government proposing to gulf marine Park? No. Why is the Government proposing to delay Government proposing to delay legislation Government proposing to delay legislation to Government proposing to delay legislation to establish Government proposing to delay legislation to establish the legislation to establish the proposed legislation to establish the proposed new legislation to establish the proposed new marine legislation to establish the proposed new marine protected legislation to establish the proposed new marine protected areas proposed new marine protected areas until proposed new marine protected areas until 2024? proposed new marine protected areas until 2024? That, proposed new marine protected areas until 2024? That, I proposed new marine protected areas until 2024? That, I think, proposed new marine protected areas until 2024? That, I think, is proposed new marine protected areas until 2024? That, I think, is the until 2024? That, I think, is the date until 2024? That, I think, is the date for until 2024? That, I think, is the date for commission until 2024? That, I think, is the date for commission of until 2024? That, I think, is the date for commission of legislation. date for commission of legislation. There date for commission of legislation. There is date for commission of legislation. There is some date for commission of legislation. There is some preliminary date for commission of legislation. There is some preliminary steps date for commission of legislation. There is some preliminary steps that There is some preliminary steps that we There is some preliminary steps that we are There is some preliminary steps that we are required There is some preliminary steps that we are required to There is some preliminary steps that we are required to go There is some preliminary steps that we are required to go through There is some preliminary steps that we are required to go through before we are required to go through before introducing we are required to go through before introducing legislation we are required to go through before introducing legislation and we are required to go through before introducing legislation and then we are required to go through before introducing legislation and then we introducing legislation and then we it introducing legislation and then we it will introducing legislation and then we it will take introducing legislation and then we it will take its introducing legislation and then we it will take its ordinary introducing legislation and then we it will take its ordinary course. introducing legislation and then we it will take its ordinary course. I it will take its ordinary course. I would it will take its ordinary course. I would note it will take its ordinary course. I would note that it will take its ordinary course. I would note that the it will take its ordinary course. I would note that the process it will take its ordinary course. I would note that the process that it will take its ordinary course. I would note that the process that is would note that the process that is being would note that the process that is being proposed would note that the process that is being proposed just would note that the process that is being proposed just about would note that the process that is being proposed just about identical being proposed just about identical to being proposed just about identical to that being proposed just about identical to that which being proposed just about identical to that which is being proposed just about identical to that which is member being proposed just about identical to that which is member was to that which is member was promoting to that which is member was promoting when to that which is member was promoting when she to that which is member was promoting when she was to that which is member was promoting when she was herself to that which is member was promoting when she was herself the promoting when she was herself the Minister promoting when she was herself the Minister of promoting when she was herself the Minister of Conservation. promoting when she was herself the Minister of Conservation. I promoting when she was herself the Minister of Conservation. I don't Minister of Conservation. I don't think Minister of Conservation. I don't think a Minister of Conservation. I don't think a lot Minister of Conservation. I don't think a lot has Minister of Conservation. I don't think a lot has changed Minister of Conservation. I don't think a lot has changed since Minister of Conservation. I don't think a lot has changed since and Minister of Conservation. I don't think a lot has changed since and I think a lot has changed since and I thank think a lot has changed since and I thank her think a lot has changed since and I thank her for think a lot has changed since and I thank her for her think a lot has changed since and I thank her for her good think a lot has changed since and I thank her for her good efforts think a lot has changed since and I thank her for her good efforts back thank her for her good efforts back then. thank her for her good efforts back then. What thank her for her good efforts back then. What scientific thank her for her good efforts back then. What scientific research thank her for her good efforts back then. What scientific research and then. What scientific research and modelling then. What scientific research and modelling supports then. What scientific research and modelling supports the then. What scientific research and modelling supports the Government's modelling supports the Government's decision modelling supports the Government's decision to modelling supports the Government's decision to allow modelling supports the Government's decision to allow bottom modelling supports the Government's decision to allow bottom trawling modelling supports the Government's decision to allow bottom trawling to decision to allow bottom trawling to consider decision to allow bottom trawling to consider in decision to allow bottom trawling to consider in some decision to allow bottom trawling to consider in some areas decision to allow bottom trawling to consider in some areas against decision to allow bottom trawling to consider in some areas against the consider in some areas against the Sea consider in some areas against the Sea Change consider in some areas against the Sea Change plan consider in some areas against the Sea Change plan recommendation consider in some areas against the Sea Change plan recommendation that Sea Change plan recommendation that the Sea Change plan recommendation that the Government Sea Change plan recommendation that the Government exclude Sea Change plan recommendation that the Government exclude activities the Government exclude activities such the Government exclude activities such as the Government exclude activities such as dredging the Government exclude activities such as dredging and the Government exclude activities such as dredging and bottom the Government exclude activities such as dredging and bottom trawling such as dredging and bottom trawling from such as dredging and bottom trawling from the such as dredging and bottom trawling from the Gulf such as dredging and bottom trawling from the Gulf by such as dredging and bottom trawling from the Gulf by 2025? such as dredging and bottom trawling from the Gulf by 2025? There such as dredging and bottom trawling from the Gulf by 2025? There is from the Gulf by 2025? There is significant from the Gulf by 2025? There is significant changes from the Gulf by 2025? There is significant changes being from the Gulf by 2025? There is significant changes being made from the Gulf by 2025? There is significant changes being made here. significant changes being made here. Already significant changes being made here. Already bottom significant changes being made here. Already bottom trawling significant changes being made here. Already bottom trawling is significant changes being made here. Already bottom trawling is banned significant changes being made here. Already bottom trawling is banned on Already bottom trawling is banned on all Already bottom trawling is banned on all of Already bottom trawling is banned on all of the Already bottom trawling is banned on all of the inner Already bottom trawling is banned on all of the inner part Already bottom trawling is banned on all of the inner part of Already bottom trawling is banned on all of the inner part of the Already bottom trawling is banned on all of the inner part of the gulf. all of the inner part of the gulf. There all of the inner part of the gulf. There are all of the inner part of the gulf. There are extensions all of the inner part of the gulf. There are extensions to all of the inner part of the gulf. There are extensions to some all of the inner part of the gulf. There are extensions to some of all of the inner part of the gulf. There are extensions to some of the There are extensions to some of the saning There are extensions to some of the saning meth There are extensions to some of the saning meth ideas There are extensions to some of the saning meth ideas and There are extensions to some of the saning meth ideas and as There are extensions to some of the saning meth ideas and as I There are extensions to some of the saning meth ideas and as I have saning meth ideas and as I have already saning meth ideas and as I have already explained saning meth ideas and as I have already explained future saning meth ideas and as I have already explained future bottom already explained future bottom trawl already explained future bottom trawl willing already explained future bottom trawl willing be already explained future bottom trawl willing be limited already explained future bottom trawl willing be limited to trawl willing be limited to corridors. trawl willing be limited to corridors. Those trawl willing be limited to corridors. Those will trawl willing be limited to corridors. Those will be trawl willing be limited to corridors. Those will be chosen trawl willing be limited to corridors. Those will be chosen on corridors. Those will be chosen on the corridors. Those will be chosen on the basis corridors. Those will be chosen on the basis of corridors. Those will be chosen on the basis of minimising corridors. Those will be chosen on the basis of minimising damage corridors. Those will be chosen on the basis of minimising damage to the basis of minimising damage to benthic the basis of minimising damage to benthic environments, the basis of minimising damage to benthic environments, in the basis of minimising damage to benthic environments, in other the basis of minimising damage to benthic environments, in other words benthic environments, in other words supporting benthic environments, in other words supporting the benthic environments, in other words supporting the most benthic environments, in other words supporting the most important supporting the most important benthic supporting the most important benthic environments supporting the most important benthic environments from supporting the most important benthic environments from bottom benthic environments from bottom trawling. benthic environments from bottom trawling. We benthic environments from bottom trawling. We think benthic environments from bottom trawling. We think this benthic environments from bottom trawling. We think this will benthic environments from bottom trawling. We think this will make trawling. We think this will make significant trawling. We think this will make significant progress. trawling. We think this will make significant progress. It trawling. We think this will make significant progress. It will trawling. We think this will make significant progress. It will enable significant progress. It will enable us significant progress. It will enable us through significant progress. It will enable us through the significant progress. It will enable us through the monitoring significant progress. It will enable us through the monitoring regime significant progress. It will enable us through the monitoring regime to us through the monitoring regime to assess us through the monitoring regime to assess the us through the monitoring regime to assess the longer us through the monitoring regime to assess the longer term us through the monitoring regime to assess the longer term outcomes us through the monitoring regime to assess the longer term outcomes of assess the longer term outcomes of the assess the longer term outcomes of the sites assess the longer term outcomes of the sites relative assess the longer term outcomes of the sites relative to assess the longer term outcomes of the sites relative to each assess the longer term outcomes of the sites relative to each other. assess the longer term outcomes of the sites relative to each other. If the sites relative to each other. If we the sites relative to each other. If we have the sites relative to each other. If we have limited the sites relative to each other. If we have limited corridors the sites relative to each other. If we have limited corridors for the sites relative to each other. If we have limited corridors for bottom we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we will we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we will be we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we will be able we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we will be able to we have limited corridors for bottom trawling we will be able to carry trawling we will be able to carry out trawling we will be able to carry out some trawling we will be able to carry out some indepth trawling we will be able to carry out some indepth science trawling we will be able to carry out some indepth science of trawling we will be able to carry out some indepth science of what trawling we will be able to carry out some indepth science of what is out some indepth science of what is the out some indepth science of what is the effects out some indepth science of what is the effects of out some indepth science of what is the effects of bottom out some indepth science of what is the effects of bottom trawling out some indepth science of what is the effects of bottom trawling that the effects of bottom trawling that remains the effects of bottom trawling that remains as the effects of bottom trawling that remains as compared the effects of bottom trawling that remains as compared the remains as compared the environmental remains as compared the environmental outcomes remains as compared the environmental outcomes in remains as compared the environmental outcomes in other environmental outcomes in other areas. environmental outcomes in other areas. Why environmental outcomes in other areas. Why does environmental outcomes in other areas. Why does the environmental outcomes in other areas. Why does the Government's areas. Why does the Government's strategy areas. Why does the Government's strategy exclude areas. Why does the Government's strategy exclude protection areas. Why does the Government's strategy exclude protection of areas. Why does the Government's strategy exclude protection of the strategy exclude protection of the water strategy exclude protection of the water around strategy exclude protection of the water around the strategy exclude protection of the water around the Noises strategy exclude protection of the water around the Noises islands strategy exclude protection of the water around the Noises islands even water around the Noises islands even though water around the Noises islands even though the water around the Noises islands even though the Otatata water around the Noises islands even though the Otatata owners, water around the Noises islands even though the Otatata owners, the though the Otatata owners, the Auckland though the Otatata owners, the Auckland museum though the Otatata owners, the Auckland museum and though the Otatata owners, the Auckland museum and others though the Otatata owners, the Auckland museum and others have Auckland museum and others have actively Auckland museum and others have actively sought Auckland museum and others have actively sought the Auckland museum and others have actively sought the protection Auckland museum and others have actively sought the protection of actively sought the protection of those actively sought the protection of those waters? actively sought the protection of those waters? That actively sought the protection of those waters? That protection actively sought the protection of those waters? That protection hasn't those waters? That protection hasn't been those waters? That protection hasn't been ruled those waters? That protection hasn't been ruled out those waters? That protection hasn't been ruled out but those waters? That protection hasn't been ruled out but it those waters? That protection hasn't been ruled out but it hasn't those waters? That protection hasn't been ruled out but it hasn't been been ruled out but it hasn't been landed been ruled out but it hasn't been landed yet been ruled out but it hasn't been landed yet and been ruled out but it hasn't been landed yet and work been ruled out but it hasn't been landed yet and work is been ruled out but it hasn't been landed yet and work is continuing been ruled out but it hasn't been landed yet and work is continuing on landed yet and work is continuing on those landed yet and work is continuing on those issues. landed yet and work is continuing on those issues. Will landed yet and work is continuing on those issues. Will the landed yet and work is continuing on those issues. Will the minister those issues. Will the minister commit those issues. Will the minister commit to those issues. Will the minister commit to further those issues. Will the minister commit to further work those issues. Will the minister commit to further work to those issues. Will the minister commit to further work to publish commit to further work to publish marine commit to further work to publish marine protected commit to further work to publish marine protected areas commit to further work to publish marine protected areas over commit to further work to publish marine protected areas over at commit to further work to publish marine protected areas over at least marine protected areas over at least 30% marine protected areas over at least 30% of marine protected areas over at least 30% of the marine protected areas over at least 30% of the Hauraki marine protected areas over at least 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine protected areas over at least 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine marine protected areas over at least 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in this 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in this term 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in this term of 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in this term of Government? 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in this term of Government? If 30% of the Hauraki Gulf marine park in this term of Government? If not, in this term of Government? If not, why in this term of Government? If not, why not? in this term of Government? If not, why not? I'm in this term of Government? If not, why not? I'm very in this term of Government? If not, why not? I'm very suspicious in this term of Government? If not, why not? I'm very suspicious of why not? I'm very suspicious of people why not? I'm very suspicious of people who why not? I'm very suspicious of people who call why not? I'm very suspicious of people who call for why not? I'm very suspicious of people who call for us why not? I'm very suspicious of people who call for us to people who call for us to effectively people who call for us to effectively halt people who call for us to effectively halt and people who call for us to effectively halt and go people who call for us to effectively halt and go back people who call for us to effectively halt and go back again effectively halt and go back again and effectively halt and go back again and have effectively halt and go back again and have another effectively halt and go back again and have another talk effectively halt and go back again and have another talk about effectively halt and go back again and have another talk about what effectively halt and go back again and have another talk about what we and have another talk about what we might and have another talk about what we might do. and have another talk about what we might do. I'd and have another talk about what we might do. I'd rather and have another talk about what we might do. I'd rather get and have another talk about what we might do. I'd rather get on and have another talk about what we might do. I'd rather get on and and have another talk about what we might do. I'd rather get on and do might do. I'd rather get on and do what might do. I'd rather get on and do what we might do. I'd rather get on and do what we are might do. I'd rather get on and do what we are doing. might do. I'd rather get on and do what we are doing. I might do. I'd rather get on and do what we are doing. I really might do. I'd rather get on and do what we are doing. I really think might do. I'd rather get on and do what we are doing. I really think we what we are doing. I really think we should what we are doing. I really think we should not what we are doing. I really think we should not understate what we are doing. I really think we should not understate the should not understate the significance should not understate the significance of should not understate the significance of what should not understate the significance of what has should not understate the significance of what has been significance of what has been announced significance of what has been announced today. significance of what has been announced today. Question significance of what has been announced today. Question number significance of what has been announced today. Question number 10. announced today. Question number 10. Angela announced today. Question number 10. Angela Roberts. Angela Angela Roberts. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Transport: My question is to the Minister of Transport: What My question is to the Minister of Transport: What recent My question is to the Minister of Transport: What recent announcements Transport: What recent announcements has Transport: What recent announcements has he Transport: What recent announcements has he made Transport: What recent announcements has he made about Transport: What recent announcements has he made about increasing Transport: What recent announcements has he made about increasing the has he made about increasing the uptake has he made about increasing the uptake of has he made about increasing the uptake of low has he made about increasing the uptake of low emission has he made about increasing the uptake of low emission vehicles? Megan Megan Woods. Megan Woods. Recently Megan Woods. Recently my Megan Woods. Recently my self Megan Woods. Recently my self and Megan Woods. Recently my self and The Megan Woods. Recently my self and The Hon Megan Woods. Recently my self and The Hon -- Megan Woods. Recently my self and The Hon -- Michael Megan Woods. Recently my self and The Hon -- Michael Wood. Megan Woods. Recently my self and The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently myself The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently myself and The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently myself and Shaw The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently myself and Shaw Che The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently myself and Shaw Che announced The Hon -- Michael Wood. Recently myself and Shaw Che announced a myself and Shaw Che announced a package. We're We're supporting We're supporting the We're supporting the uptake We're supporting the uptake of We're supporting the uptake of zero We're supporting the uptake of zero and We're supporting the uptake of zero and low-emissions We're supporting the uptake of zero and low-emissions vehicles We're supporting the uptake of zero and low-emissions vehicles by We're supporting the uptake of zero and low-emissions vehicles by making and low-emissions vehicles by making and low-emissions vehicles by making and low-emissions vehicles by making sure that and low-emissions vehicles by making sure that electric and low-emissions vehicles by making sure that electric vehicle and low-emissions vehicles by making sure that electric vehicle charges sure that electric vehicle charges are sure that electric vehicle charges are now sure that electric vehicle charges are now available sure that electric vehicle charges are now available every sure that electric vehicle charges are now available every 75kms sure that electric vehicle charges are now available every 75kms along are now available every 75kms along most are now available every 75kms along most of are now available every 75kms along most of the are now available every 75kms along most of the State are now available every 75kms along most of the State Highway are now available every 75kms along most of the State Highway network most of the State Highway network nearly most of the State Highway network nearly quadrupling most of the State Highway network nearly quadrupling the most of the State Highway network nearly quadrupling the Low most of the State Highway network nearly quadrupling the Low Emission nearly quadrupling the Low Emission Transport nearly quadrupling the Low Emission Transport Fund nearly quadrupling the Low Emission Transport Fund to nearly quadrupling the Low Emission Transport Fund to grow nearly quadrupling the Low Emission Transport Fund to grow the Transport Fund to grow the nation-wide Transport Fund to grow the nation-wide EV Transport Fund to grow the nation-wide EV charging Transport Fund to grow the nation-wide EV charging network, nation-wide EV charging network, setting nation-wide EV charging network, setting up nation-wide EV charging network, setting up a nation-wide EV charging network, setting up a leadership nation-wide EV charging network, setting up a leadership group, setting up a leadership group, bringing setting up a leadership group, bringing in setting up a leadership group, bringing in a setting up a leadership group, bringing in a sustainable setting up a leadership group, bringing in a sustainable biofuels bringing in a sustainable biofuels mandate bringing in a sustainable biofuels mandate to bringing in a sustainable biofuels mandate to prevent bringing in a sustainable biofuels mandate to prevent over bringing in a sustainable biofuels mandate to prevent over 1 bringing in a sustainable biofuels mandate to prevent over 1 million mandate to prevent over 1 million tonnes mandate to prevent over 1 million tonnes of mandate to prevent over 1 million tonnes of emissions mandate to prevent over 1 million tonnes of emissions and mandate to prevent over 1 million tonnes of emissions and implementing tonnes of emissions and implementing a tonnes of emissions and implementing a Clean tonnes of emissions and implementing a Clean Car tonnes of emissions and implementing a Clean Car Discount tonnes of emissions and implementing a Clean Car Discount to tonnes of emissions and implementing a Clean Car Discount to help tonnes of emissions and implementing a Clean Car Discount to help get a Clean Car Discount to help get more a Clean Car Discount to help get more Kiwis a Clean Car Discount to help get more Kiwis into a Clean Car Discount to help get more Kiwis into clean a Clean Car Discount to help get more Kiwis into clean cars a Clean Car Discount to help get more Kiwis into clean cars at a Clean Car Discount to help get more Kiwis into clean cars at a more Kiwis into clean cars at a lower more Kiwis into clean cars at a lower price. more Kiwis into clean cars at a lower price. Why more Kiwis into clean cars at a lower price. Why is more Kiwis into clean cars at a lower price. Why is decarbonising lower price. Why is decarbonising the lower price. Why is decarbonising the transport lower price. Why is decarbonising the transport sector lower price. Why is decarbonising the transport sector a lower price. Why is decarbonising the transport sector a focus lower price. Why is decarbonising the transport sector a focus for lower price. Why is decarbonising the transport sector a focus for the the transport sector a focus for the Government? the transport sector a focus for the Government? Tackling the transport sector a focus for the Government? Tackling change the transport sector a focus for the Government? Tackling change is the transport sector a focus for the Government? Tackling change is a Government? Tackling change is a real Government? Tackling change is a real priority Government? Tackling change is a real priority for Government? Tackling change is a real priority for this Government? Tackling change is a real priority for this Government. real priority for this Government. The real priority for this Government. The transport real priority for this Government. The transport sector real priority for this Government. The transport sector currently The transport sector currently produces The transport sector currently produces 47% The transport sector currently produces 47% of The transport sector currently produces 47% of New The transport sector currently produces 47% of New Zealand's The transport sector currently produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 emissions produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 emissions and produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 emissions and between produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 emissions and between 1990 produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 emissions and between 1990 and produces 47% of New Zealand's CO2 emissions and between 1990 and 2018 emissions and between 1990 and 2018 domestic emissions and between 1990 and 2018 domestic transport emissions and between 1990 and 2018 domestic transport emissions domestic transport emissions increased domestic transport emissions increased by domestic transport emissions increased by 90%, domestic transport emissions increased by 90%, reaching domestic transport emissions increased by 90%, reaching New increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's goal increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's goal of increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's goal of net increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's goal of net zero increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's goal of net zero carbon increased by 90%, reaching New Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 will Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 will unclog Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 will unclog our Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 will unclog our city, Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 will unclog our city, clean Zealand's goal of net zero carbon by 2050 will unclog our city, clean up 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our area 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our area and 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our area and poor 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our area and poor the 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our area and poor the location 2050 will unclog our city, clean up our area and poor the location of our area and poor the location of new our area and poor the location of new businesses our area and poor the location of new businesses in our area and poor the location of new businesses in low our area and poor the location of new businesses in low carbon new businesses in low carbon industries new businesses in low carbon industries and new businesses in low carbon industries and create new businesses in low carbon industries and create sustainable industries and create sustainable jobs industries and create sustainable jobs around industries and create sustainable jobs around our industries and create sustainable jobs around our country. industries and create sustainable jobs around our country. Now industries and create sustainable jobs around our country. Now is industries and create sustainable jobs around our country. Now is the jobs around our country. Now is the time jobs around our country. Now is the time for jobs around our country. Now is the time for New jobs around our country. Now is the time for New Zealand jobs around our country. Now is the time for New Zealand to jobs around our country. Now is the time for New Zealand to move jobs around our country. Now is the time for New Zealand to move ahead time for New Zealand to move ahead with time for New Zealand to move ahead with the time for New Zealand to move ahead with the transition time for New Zealand to move ahead with the transition like time for New Zealand to move ahead with the transition like the time for New Zealand to move ahead with the transition like the rest time for New Zealand to move ahead with the transition like the rest of with the transition like the rest of the with the transition like the rest of the world with the transition like the rest of the world is. with the transition like the rest of the world is. Supply with the transition like the rest of the world is. Supply supplementary, the world is. Supply supplementary, what the world is. Supply supplementary, what reaction the world is. Supply supplementary, what reaction has the world is. Supply supplementary, what reaction has he the world is. Supply supplementary, what reaction has he seen the world is. Supply supplementary, what reaction has he seen to the world is. Supply supplementary, what reaction has he seen to the what reaction has he seen to the announcement? what reaction has he seen to the announcement? The what reaction has he seen to the announcement? The announcement what reaction has he seen to the announcement? The announcement has announcement? The announcement has been announcement? The announcement has been very announcement? The announcement has been very warmly announcement? The announcement has been very warmly welcomed announcement? The announcement has been very warmly welcomed across announcement? The announcement has been very warmly welcomed across New been very warmly welcomed across New Zealand been very warmly welcomed across New Zealand and been very warmly welcomed across New Zealand and by been very warmly welcomed across New Zealand and by the been very warmly welcomed across New Zealand and by the industry. been very warmly welcomed across New Zealand and by the industry. The Zealand and by the industry. The motor Zealand and by the industry. The motor industry Zealand and by the industry. The motor industry association Zealand and by the industry. The motor industry association chief motor industry association chief executive motor industry association chief executive David motor industry association chief executive David Crawford motor industry association chief executive David Crawford said motor industry association chief executive David Crawford said he motor industry association chief executive David Crawford said he was executive David Crawford said he was delighted executive David Crawford said he was delighted and executive David Crawford said he was delighted and New executive David Crawford said he was delighted and New Zealand executive David Crawford said he was delighted and New Zealand energy delighted and New Zealand energy solutions delighted and New Zealand energy solutions business delighted and New Zealand energy solutions business vector... solutions business vector... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! I <INTERRUPTION> Order! I ask <INTERRUPTION> Order! I ask the <INTERRUPTION> Order! I ask the Deputy <INTERRUPTION> Order! I ask the Deputy PM <INTERRUPTION> Order! I ask the Deputy PM to <INTERRUPTION> Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting a Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting a riot. Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting a riot. As Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting a riot. As I Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting a riot. As I was Order! I ask the Deputy PM to stop inciting a riot. As I was just inciting a riot. As I was just saying inciting a riot. As I was just saying the inciting a riot. As I was just saying the motor inciting a riot. As I was just saying the motor industry saying the motor industry association saying the motor industry association chief saying the motor industry association chief executive saying the motor industry association chief executive said saying the motor industry association chief executive said he association chief executive said he was association chief executive said he was delicked association chief executive said he was delicked and association chief executive said he was delicked and New association chief executive said he was delicked and New Zealand association chief executive said he was delicked and New Zealand energy was delicked and New Zealand energy solutions was delicked and New Zealand energy solutions vector was delicked and New Zealand energy solutions vector welcomed was delicked and New Zealand energy solutions vector welcomed our solutions vector welcomed our announcement. solutions vector welcomed our announcement. The solutions vector welcomed our announcement. The AA solutions vector welcomed our announcement. The AA policy solutions vector welcomed our announcement. The AA policy and announcement. The AA policy and research announcement. The AA policy and research manager announcement. The AA policy and research manager Simon announcement. The AA policy and research manager Simon Douglas announcement. The AA policy and research manager Simon Douglas said, research manager Simon Douglas said, "Reducing research manager Simon Douglas said, "Reducing emissions research manager Simon Douglas said, "Reducing emissions from research manager Simon Douglas said, "Reducing emissions from transport "Reducing emissions from transport will "Reducing emissions from transport will take "Reducing emissions from transport will take a "Reducing emissions from transport will take a mix "Reducing emissions from transport will take a mix of "Reducing emissions from transport will take a mix of actions "Reducing emissions from transport will take a mix of actions for "Reducing emissions from transport will take a mix of actions for new will take a mix of actions for new vehicles, will take a mix of actions for new vehicles, used will take a mix of actions for new vehicles, used vehicles will take a mix of actions for new vehicles, used vehicles and will take a mix of actions for new vehicles, used vehicles and the vehicles, used vehicles and the fuels vehicles, used vehicles and the fuels that vehicles, used vehicles and the fuels that vehicles vehicles, used vehicles and the fuels that vehicles already vehicles, used vehicles and the fuels that vehicles already on vehicles, used vehicles and the fuels that vehicles already on our fuels that vehicles already on our roads fuels that vehicles already on our roads run fuels that vehicles already on our roads run on" fuels that vehicles already on our roads run on" and fuels that vehicles already on our roads run on" and this fuels that vehicles already on our roads run on" and this package fuels that vehicles already on our roads run on" and this package from roads run on" and this package from the roads run on" and this package from the Government roads run on" and this package from the Government takes roads run on" and this package from the Government takes good roads run on" and this package from the Government takes good steps roads run on" and this package from the Government takes good steps on the Government takes good steps on all the Government takes good steps on all fronts. the Government takes good steps on all fronts. Question the Government takes good steps on all fronts. Question No.11. the Government takes good steps on all fronts. Question No.11. Jo all fronts. Question No.11. Jo Luxton. all fronts. Question No.11. Jo Luxton. -- all fronts. Question No.11. Jo Luxton. -- question all fronts. Question No.11. Jo Luxton. -- question No.11, all fronts. Question No.11. Jo Luxton. -- question No.11, Chris Luxton. -- question No.11, Chris Luxon. Luxton. -- question No.11, Chris Luxton. Luxton. -- Luxton. Luxton. -- question Luxton. Luxton. -- question No.11, Luxton. Luxton. -- question No.11, Chris Luxton. Luxton. -- question No.11, Chris Luxon. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Minister My question is to the Minister of My question is to the Minister of Transport: My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does he My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does he stand My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does he stand by My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does he stand by all My question is to the Minister of Transport: Does he stand by all his Transport: Does he stand by all his statements Transport: Does he stand by all his statements and Transport: Does he stand by all his statements and actions? Yes, Yes, in Yes, in particular Yes, in particular our Yes, in particular our Government's Yes, in particular our Government's maintaining Yes, in particular our Government's maintaining international Yes, in particular our Government's maintaining international air maintaining international air connectivity maintaining international air connectivity scheme maintaining international air connectivity scheme that maintaining international air connectivity scheme that has maintaining international air connectivity scheme that has helped connectivity scheme that has helped keep connectivity scheme that has helped keep trade connectivity scheme that has helped keep trade channels connectivity scheme that has helped keep trade channels open connectivity scheme that has helped keep trade channels open and keep trade channels open and maintain keep trade channels open and maintain supply keep trade channels open and maintain supply of keep trade channels open and maintain supply of time keep trade channels open and maintain supply of time critical maintain supply of time critical goods maintain supply of time critical goods like maintain supply of time critical goods like medicines maintain supply of time critical goods like medicines in maintain supply of time critical goods like medicines in New maintain supply of time critical goods like medicines in New Zealand. goods like medicines in New Zealand. Since goods like medicines in New Zealand. Since May goods like medicines in New Zealand. Since May last goods like medicines in New Zealand. Since May last year goods like medicines in New Zealand. Since May last year Government Since May last year Government support Since May last year Government support has Since May last year Government support has enables Since May last year Government support has enables more Since May last year Government support has enables more than Since May last year Government support has enables more than 7,000 support has enables more than 7,000 flights support has enables more than 7,000 flights carrying support has enables more than 7,000 flights carrying over support has enables more than 7,000 flights carrying over 136 support has enables more than 7,000 flights carrying over 136 tonnes support has enables more than 7,000 flights carrying over 136 tonnes of flights carrying over 136 tonnes of air flights carrying over 136 tonnes of air freight flights carrying over 136 tonnes of air freight helping flights carrying over 136 tonnes of air freight helping our flights carrying over 136 tonnes of air freight helping our economic air freight helping our economic recovery air freight helping our economic recovery and air freight helping our economic recovery and I air freight helping our economic recovery and I can air freight helping our economic recovery and I can confirm air freight helping our economic recovery and I can confirm there recovery and I can confirm there were recovery and I can confirm there were no recovery and I can confirm there were no weapons recovery and I can confirm there were no weapons for recovery and I can confirm there were no weapons for the recovery and I can confirm there were no weapons for the Saudis recovery and I can confirm there were no weapons for the Saudis on were no weapons for the Saudis on any were no weapons for the Saudis on any of were no weapons for the Saudis on any of those were no weapons for the Saudis on any of those flights. were no weapons for the Saudis on any of those flights. How were no weapons for the Saudis on any of those flights. How does were no weapons for the Saudis on any of those flights. How does $785 any of those flights. How does $785 million any of those flights. How does $785 million for any of those flights. How does $785 million for the any of those flights. How does $785 million for the proposed any of those flights. How does $785 million for the proposed Northern million for the proposed Northern Pathway million for the proposed Northern Pathway cycle million for the proposed Northern Pathway cycle bridge million for the proposed Northern Pathway cycle bridge represent million for the proposed Northern Pathway cycle bridge represent a Pathway cycle bridge represent a better Pathway cycle bridge represent a better use Pathway cycle bridge represent a better use of Pathway cycle bridge represent a better use of money Pathway cycle bridge represent a better use of money than Pathway cycle bridge represent a better use of money than a Pathway cycle bridge represent a better use of money than a new better use of money than a new Ashburton better use of money than a new Ashburton bridge better use of money than a new Ashburton bridge or better use of money than a new Ashburton bridge or fixing better use of money than a new Ashburton bridge or fixing one better use of money than a new Ashburton bridge or fixing one of Ashburton bridge or fixing one of New Ashburton bridge or fixing one of New Zealand's Ashburton bridge or fixing one of New Zealand's deadliest Ashburton bridge or fixing one of New Zealand's deadliest roads Ashburton bridge or fixing one of New Zealand's deadliest roads from New Zealand's deadliest roads from tipuna New Zealand's deadliest roads from tipuna to New Zealand's deadliest roads from tipuna to Omokoroa? New Zealand's deadliest roads from tipuna to Omokoroa? As New Zealand's deadliest roads from tipuna to Omokoroa? As the New Zealand's deadliest roads from tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will be tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will be aware tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will be aware the tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will be aware the Government tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will be aware the Government makes tipuna to Omokoroa? As the member will be aware the Government makes a will be aware the Government makes a range will be aware the Government makes a range of will be aware the Government makes a range of initiatives will be aware the Government makes a range of initiatives across will be aware the Government makes a range of initiatives across our range of initiatives across our transport range of initiatives across our transport system range of initiatives across our transport system and range of initiatives across our transport system and in range of initiatives across our transport system and in the range of initiatives across our transport system and in the recently transport system and in the recently announced transport system and in the recently announced New transport system and in the recently announced New Zealand transport system and in the recently announced New Zealand upgrade announced New Zealand upgrade package announced New Zealand upgrade package $8.9 announced New Zealand upgrade package $8.9 billion announced New Zealand upgrade package $8.9 billion of announced New Zealand upgrade package $8.9 billion of investment package $8.9 billion of investment have package $8.9 billion of investment have been package $8.9 billion of investment have been made package $8.9 billion of investment have been made across package $8.9 billion of investment have been made across road, package $8.9 billion of investment have been made across road, rail package $8.9 billion of investment have been made across road, rail and have been made across road, rail and walking have been made across road, rail and walking and have been made across road, rail and walking and cycling have been made across road, rail and walking and cycling initiatives. walking and cycling initiatives. This walking and cycling initiatives. This Government walking and cycling initiatives. This Government does walking and cycling initiatives. This Government does believe walking and cycling initiatives. This Government does believe if walking and cycling initiatives. This Government does believe if we This Government does believe if we want This Government does believe if we want good This Government does believe if we want good transport This Government does believe if we want good transport outcomes This Government does believe if we want good transport outcomes for This Government does believe if we want good transport outcomes for all want good transport outcomes for all New want good transport outcomes for all New Zealanders want good transport outcomes for all New Zealanders that want good transport outcomes for all New Zealanders that we want good transport outcomes for all New Zealanders that we have want good transport outcomes for all New Zealanders that we have to New Zealanders that we have to invest New Zealanders that we have to invest across New Zealanders that we have to invest across all New Zealanders that we have to invest across all of New Zealanders that we have to invest across all of those New Zealanders that we have to invest across all of those modes, invest across all of those modes, unlike invest across all of those modes, unlike the invest across all of those modes, unlike the previous invest across all of those modes, unlike the previous Government, invest across all of those modes, unlike the previous Government, we unlike the previous Government, we don't unlike the previous Government, we don't believe unlike the previous Government, we don't believe that unlike the previous Government, we don't believe that a unlike the previous Government, we don't believe that a four-lane don't believe that a four-lane motorway don't believe that a four-lane motorway is don't believe that a four-lane motorway is the don't believe that a four-lane motorway is the solution don't believe that a four-lane motorway is the solution to don't believe that a four-lane motorway is the solution to every motorway is the solution to every transport motorway is the solution to every transport problem. motorway is the solution to every transport problem. How motorway is the solution to every transport problem. How would motorway is the solution to every transport problem. How would the transport problem. How would the proposed transport problem. How would the proposed $785 transport problem. How would the proposed $785 million transport problem. How would the proposed $785 million north transport problem. How would the proposed $785 million north pathway proposed $785 million north pathway cycle proposed $785 million north pathway cycle bridge proposed $785 million north pathway cycle bridge shorten proposed $785 million north pathway cycle bridge shorten commutes proposed $785 million north pathway cycle bridge shorten commutes for cycle bridge shorten commutes for tradies cycle bridge shorten commutes for tradies stuck cycle bridge shorten commutes for tradies stuck in cycle bridge shorten commutes for tradies stuck in gridlock cycle bridge shorten commutes for tradies stuck in gridlock and cycle bridge shorten commutes for tradies stuck in gridlock and help tradies stuck in gridlock and help older tradies stuck in gridlock and help older Aucklanders tradies stuck in gridlock and help older Aucklanders get tradies stuck in gridlock and help older Aucklanders get to tradies stuck in gridlock and help older Aucklanders get to their older Aucklanders get to their commitments older Aucklanders get to their commitments on older Aucklanders get to their commitments on time? older Aucklanders get to their commitments on time? The older Aucklanders get to their commitments on time? The member older Aucklanders get to their commitments on time? The member for commitments on time? The member for - commitments on time? The member for - the commitments on time? The member for - the question commitments on time? The member for - the question displays commitments on time? The member for - the question displays an - the question displays an incredible - the question displays an incredible immaturity - the question displays an incredible immaturity in - the question displays an incredible immaturity in terms - the question displays an incredible immaturity in terms of incredible immaturity in terms of how incredible immaturity in terms of how transport incredible immaturity in terms of how transport policy... how transport policy... <INTERRUPTION> <INTERRUPTION> Order! <INTERRUPTION> Order! The <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member will <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member will resume <INTERRUPTION> Order! The member will resume his Order! The member will resume his seat. Order! The member will resume his seat. That Order! The member will resume his seat. That is Order! The member will resume his seat. That is not Order! The member will resume his seat. That is not an Order! The member will resume his seat. That is not an appropriate Order! The member will resume his seat. That is not an appropriate way seat. That is not an appropriate way to seat. That is not an appropriate way to start... seat. That is not an appropriate way to start... <INTERRUPTION> to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got little to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got little hair to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got little hair to to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got little hair to tear to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got little hair to tear out to start... <INTERRUPTION> I've got little hair to tear out but I've got little hair to tear out but when I've got little hair to tear out but when I'm I've got little hair to tear out but when I'm trying I've got little hair to tear out but when I'm trying to I've got little hair to tear out but when I'm trying to to I've got little hair to tear out but when I'm trying to to assist I've got little hair to tear out but when I'm trying to to assist the when I'm trying to to assist the member when I'm trying to to assist the member in when I'm trying to to assist the member in getting when I'm trying to to assist the member in getting the when I'm trying to to assist the member in getting the minister when I'm trying to to assist the member in getting the minister to member in getting the minister to answer member in getting the minister to answer in member in getting the minister to answer in an member in getting the minister to answer in an appropriate member in getting the minister to answer in an appropriate way member in getting the minister to answer in an appropriate way their answer in an appropriate way their support answer in an appropriate way their support is answer in an appropriate way their support is counter answer in an appropriate way their support is counter productive. answer in an appropriate way their support is counter productive. The support is counter productive. The minister support is counter productive. The minister will support is counter productive. The minister will withdraw support is counter productive. The minister will withdraw and support is counter productive. The minister will withdraw and apologise minister will withdraw and apologise and minister will withdraw and apologise and start minister will withdraw and apologise and start his minister will withdraw and apologise and start his answer minister will withdraw and apologise and start his answer again. A A transport A transport policy A transport policy that A transport policy that supports A transport policy that supports good A transport policy that supports good outcomes A transport policy that supports good outcomes for A transport policy that supports good outcomes for everyone A transport policy that supports good outcomes for everyone will good outcomes for everyone will bring good outcomes for everyone will bring together good outcomes for everyone will bring together different good outcomes for everyone will bring together different modes. good outcomes for everyone will bring together different modes. And bring together different modes. And so, bring together different modes. And so, just bring together different modes. And so, just saying bring together different modes. And so, just saying does bring together different modes. And so, just saying does a bring together different modes. And so, just saying does a particular so, just saying does a particular transport so, just saying does a particular transport project so, just saying does a particular transport project in so, just saying does a particular transport project in a so, just saying does a particular transport project in a particular transport project in a particular part transport project in a particular part of transport project in a particular part of the transport project in a particular part of the city transport project in a particular part of the city affect transport project in a particular part of the city affect an part of the city affect an individual part of the city affect an individual is part of the city affect an individual is not part of the city affect an individual is not the part of the city affect an individual is not the way part of the city affect an individual is not the way to part of the city affect an individual is not the way to develop individual is not the way to develop an individual is not the way to develop an integrated individual is not the way to develop an integrated transport individual is not the way to develop an integrated transport policy. individual is not the way to develop an integrated transport policy. What an integrated transport policy. What we an integrated transport policy. What we need an integrated transport policy. What we need - an integrated transport policy. What we need - what an integrated transport policy. What we need - what we an integrated transport policy. What we need - what we need an integrated transport policy. What we need - what we need to an integrated transport policy. What we need - what we need to do an integrated transport policy. What we need - what we need to do in an integrated transport policy. What we need - what we need to do in our we need - what we need to do in our congested we need - what we need to do in our congested cities we need - what we need to do in our congested cities is we need - what we need to do in our congested cities is actually we need - what we need to do in our congested cities is actually turn congested cities is actually turn around congested cities is actually turn around the congested cities is actually turn around the failed congested cities is actually turn around the failed policies congested cities is actually turn around the failed policies of congested cities is actually turn around the failed policies of the around the failed policies of the past, around the failed policies of the past, where around the failed policies of the past, where all around the failed policies of the past, where all we're around the failed policies of the past, where all we're focused around the failed policies of the past, where all we're focused on around the failed policies of the past, where all we're focused on is past, where all we're focused on is building past, where all we're focused on is building roads. past, where all we're focused on is building roads. That's past, where all we're focused on is building roads. That's what past, where all we're focused on is building roads. That's what has past, where all we're focused on is building roads. That's what has got building roads. That's what has got us building roads. That's what has got us into building roads. That's what has got us into the building roads. That's what has got us into the current building roads. That's what has got us into the current mess building roads. That's what has got us into the current mess we're building roads. That's what has got us into the current mess we're in. us into the current mess we're in. If us into the current mess we're in. If we us into the current mess we're in. If we continue us into the current mess we're in. If we continue doing us into the current mess we're in. If we continue doing it, us into the current mess we're in. If we continue doing it, we'll us into the current mess we're in. If we continue doing it, we'll get If we continue doing it, we'll get the If we continue doing it, we'll get the same If we continue doing it, we'll get the same outcomes. If we continue doing it, we'll get the same outcomes. That's If we continue doing it, we'll get the same outcomes. That's why If we continue doing it, we'll get the same outcomes. That's why this the same outcomes. That's why this Government the same outcomes. That's why this Government has the same outcomes. That's why this Government has a the same outcomes. That's why this Government has a policy the same outcomes. That's why this Government has a policy of the same outcomes. That's why this Government has a policy of investing Government has a policy of investing across Government has a policy of investing across the Government has a policy of investing across the modes, Government has a policy of investing across the modes, including Government has a policy of investing across the modes, including road, across the modes, including road, including across the modes, including road, including rail, across the modes, including road, including rail, and across the modes, including road, including rail, and including including rail, and including walking including rail, and including walking and including rail, and including walking and cycling. including rail, and including walking and cycling. And including rail, and including walking and cycling. And the including rail, and including walking and cycling. And the message walking and cycling. And the message for walking and cycling. And the message for people walking and cycling. And the message for people stuck walking and cycling. And the message for people stuck on walking and cycling. And the message for people stuck on those walking and cycling. And the message for people stuck on those roads walking and cycling. And the message for people stuck on those roads is for people stuck on those roads is every for people stuck on those roads is every single for people stuck on those roads is every single person for people stuck on those roads is every single person on for people stuck on those roads is every single person on Auckland every single person on Auckland roads, every single person on Auckland roads, Wellington every single person on Auckland roads, Wellington roads, roads, Wellington roads, Christchurch roads, Wellington roads, Christchurch roads roads, Wellington roads, Christchurch roads around roads, Wellington roads, Christchurch roads around the Christchurch roads around the country, Christchurch roads around the country, we Christchurch roads around the country, we get Christchurch roads around the country, we get onto Christchurch roads around the country, we get onto public country, we get onto public transport, country, we get onto public transport, we country, we get onto public transport, we get country, we get onto public transport, we get onto country, we get onto public transport, we get onto walking country, we get onto public transport, we get onto walking and transport, we get onto walking and cycling transport, we get onto walking and cycling as transport, we get onto walking and cycling as one transport, we get onto walking and cycling as one less transport, we get onto walking and cycling as one less person cycling as one less person congesting cycling as one less person congesting the cycling as one less person congesting the road cycling as one less person congesting the road that cycling as one less person congesting the road that tradie cycling as one less person congesting the road that tradie is congesting the road that tradie is stuck congesting the road that tradie is stuck on. congesting the road that tradie is stuck on. Will congesting the road that tradie is stuck on. Will the congesting the road that tradie is stuck on. Will the estimated congesting the road that tradie is stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 daily stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 daily users stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 daily users of stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 daily users of $785 stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 daily users of $785 million stuck on. Will the estimated 3,000 daily users of $785 million northern daily users of $785 million northern cycleway daily users of $785 million northern cycleway drive daily users of $785 million northern cycleway drive transport daily users of $785 million northern cycleway drive transport mode daily users of $785 million northern cycleway drive transport mode shift cycleway drive transport mode shift of cycleway drive transport mode shift of for cycleway drive transport mode shift of for a cycleway drive transport mode shift of for a city cycleway drive transport mode shift of for a city of cycleway drive transport mode shift of for a city of 1. cycleway drive transport mode shift of for a city of 1. 7 cycleway drive transport mode shift of for a city of 1. 7 million of for a city of 1. 7 million people. of for a city of 1. 7 million people. The of for a city of 1. 7 million people. The member of for a city of 1. 7 million people. The member has of for a city of 1. 7 million people. The member has used of for a city of 1. 7 million people. The member has used an people. The member has used an estimate people. The member has used an estimate that's people. The member has used an estimate that's 70% people. The member has used an estimate that's 70% below people. The member has used an estimate that's 70% below the estimate that's 70% below the estimate estimate that's 70% below the estimate provided estimate that's 70% below the estimate provided by estimate that's 70% below the estimate provided by Waka estimate that's 70% below the estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. Solving estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. Solving the estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. Solving the problems estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. Solving the problems will estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. Solving the problems will take estimate provided by Waka Kotahi. Solving the problems will take a Solving the problems will take a range Solving the problems will take a range of Solving the problems will take a range of investments. Solving the problems will take a range of investments. So Solving the problems will take a range of investments. So in Solving the problems will take a range of investments. So in terms Solving the problems will take a range of investments. So in terms of range of investments. So in terms of the range of investments. So in terms of the New range of investments. So in terms of the New Zealand range of investments. So in terms of the New Zealand upgrade range of investments. So in terms of the New Zealand upgrade package range of investments. So in terms of the New Zealand upgrade package of the New Zealand upgrade package of which the New Zealand upgrade package of which the the New Zealand upgrade package of which the northern the New Zealand upgrade package of which the northern pathway the New Zealand upgrade package of which the northern pathway is the New Zealand upgrade package of which the northern pathway is one which the northern pathway is one point, which the northern pathway is one point, we which the northern pathway is one point, we have which the northern pathway is one point, we have $2.1 which the northern pathway is one point, we have $2.1 billion which the northern pathway is one point, we have $2.1 billion of point, we have $2.1 billion of investments point, we have $2.1 billion of investments in... point, we have $2.1 billion of investments in... Can point, we have $2.1 billion of investments in... Can he point, we have $2.1 billion of investments in... Can he guarantee investments in... Can he guarantee the investments in... Can he guarantee the $785 investments in... Can he guarantee the $785 million investments in... Can he guarantee the $785 million cost investments in... Can he guarantee the $785 million cost will investments in... Can he guarantee the $785 million cost will not investments in... Can he guarantee the $785 million cost will not be the $785 million cost will not be increased the $785 million cost will not be increased further the $785 million cost will not be increased further in the $785 million cost will not be increased further in light the $785 million cost will not be increased further in light of the $785 million cost will not be increased further in light of the increased further in light of the 20-fold increased further in light of the 20-fold increase increased further in light of the 20-fold increase in increased further in light of the 20-fold increase in costs increased further in light of the 20-fold increase in costs since 20-fold increase in costs since Labour 20-fold increase in costs since Labour candidate 20-fold increase in costs since Labour candidate Michael 20-fold increase in costs since Labour candidate Michael Wood Labour candidate Michael Wood announced Labour candidate Michael Wood announced in Labour candidate Michael Wood announced in 2017 Labour candidate Michael Wood announced in 2017 it Labour candidate Michael Wood announced in 2017 it would Labour candidate Michael Wood announced in 2017 it would cost Labour candidate Michael Wood announced in 2017 it would cost $30 announced in 2017 it would cost $30 million? announced in 2017 it would cost $30 million? I announced in 2017 it would cost $30 million? I can announced in 2017 it would cost $30 million? I can give announced in 2017 it would cost $30 million? I can give confidence announced in 2017 it would cost $30 million? I can give confidence in million? I can give confidence in the million? I can give confidence in the robustness million? I can give confidence in the robustness of million? I can give confidence in the robustness of the million? I can give confidence in the robustness of the figures the robustness of the figures produced. the robustness of the figures produced. Mr the robustness of the figures produced. Mr Speaker, the robustness of the figures produced. Mr Speaker, the the robustness of the figures produced. Mr Speaker, the member the robustness of the figures produced. Mr Speaker, the member may produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want to produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want to talk produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want to talk to produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want to talk to others produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want to talk to others about produced. Mr Speaker, the member may want to talk to others about the want to talk to others about the long want to talk to others about the long history want to talk to others about the long history of want to talk to others about the long history of transport want to talk to others about the long history of transport projects long history of transport projects in long history of transport projects in this long history of transport projects in this country, long history of transport projects in this country, including long history of transport projects in this country, including the long history of transport projects in this country, including the roads in this country, including the roads of in this country, including the roads of national in this country, including the roads of national significance. in this country, including the roads of national significance. That of national significance. That concludes of national significance. That concludes oral of national significance. That concludes oral questions. of national significance. That concludes oral questions. Sorry, concludes oral questions. Sorry, Tamati concludes oral questions. Sorry, Tamati Coffey. concludes oral questions. Sorry, Tamati Coffey. I concludes oral questions. Sorry, Tamati Coffey. I apologise. concludes oral questions. Sorry, Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I concludes oral questions. Sorry, Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was just Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was just sort Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was just sort of Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was just sort of looking Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was just sort of looking forward Tamati Coffey. I apologise. I was just sort of looking forward to just sort of looking forward to getting just sort of looking forward to getting on just sort of looking forward to getting on with just sort of looking forward to getting on with the just sort of looking forward to getting on with the next just sort of looking forward to getting on with the next bit just sort of looking forward to getting on with the next bit of getting on with the next bit of business. My My question My question is My question is to My question is to the My question is to the Associate My question is to the Associate Minister My question is to the Associate Minister of My question is to the Associate Minister of Statistics: My question is to the Associate Minister of Statistics: How My question is to the Associate Minister of Statistics: How is My question is to the Associate Minister of Statistics: How is she Minister of Statistics: How is she ensuring Minister of Statistics: How is she ensuring that Minister of Statistics: How is she ensuring that Statistics Minister of Statistics: How is she ensuring that Statistics New Minister of Statistics: How is she ensuring that Statistics New Zealand ensuring that Statistics New Zealand increases ensuring that Statistics New Zealand increases the ensuring that Statistics New Zealand increases the data ensuring that Statistics New Zealand increases the data capability ensuring that Statistics New Zealand increases the data capability and increases the data capability and capacity increases the data capability and capacity of increases the data capability and capacity of iwi-Maori? Speaker, Speaker, I Speaker, I am Speaker, I am working Speaker, I am working with Speaker, I am working with stats Speaker, I am working with stats New Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand to Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand to support Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand to support the Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand to support the growth Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand to support the growth of Speaker, I am working with stats New Zealand to support the growth of iwi Zealand to support the growth of iwi Maori Zealand to support the growth of iwi Maori by Zealand to support the growth of iwi Maori by ensuring Zealand to support the growth of iwi Maori by ensuring the Zealand to support the growth of iwi Maori by ensuring the department Maori by ensuring the department works Maori by ensuring the department works collaboratively Maori by ensuring the department works collaboratively in Maori by ensuring the department works collaboratively in a Maori by ensuring the department works collaboratively in a community works collaboratively in a community led works collaboratively in a community led manner works collaboratively in a community led manner and works collaboratively in a community led manner and increasing led manner and increasing participation led manner and increasing participation within led manner and increasing participation within specified participation within specified communities, participation within specified communities, by participation within specified communities, by developing participation within specified communities, by developing an communities, by developing an approach communities, by developing an approach to communities, by developing an approach to engage communities, by developing an approach to engage iwi communities, by developing an approach to engage iwi led approach to engage iwi led collection approach to engage iwi led collection and approach to engage iwi led collection and analysis approach to engage iwi led collection and analysis of approach to engage iwi led collection and analysis of census collection and analysis of census data collection and analysis of census data and collection and analysis of census data and co-designing collection and analysis of census data and co-designing products collection and analysis of census data and co-designing products and data and co-designing products and services data and co-designing products and services to data and co-designing products and services to be data and co-designing products and services to be of data and co-designing products and services to be of value data and co-designing products and services to be of value to data and co-designing products and services to be of value to Maori services to be of value to Maori using services to be of value to Maori using census services to be of value to Maori using census data. services to be of value to Maori using census data. We're services to be of value to Maori using census data. We're working using census data. We're working with using census data. We're working with iwi using census data. We're working with iwi Maori using census data. We're working with iwi Maori including using census data. We're working with iwi Maori including the with iwi Maori including the co-design with iwi Maori including the co-design of with iwi Maori including the co-design of a with iwi Maori including the co-design of a Maori with iwi Maori including the co-design of a Maori data with iwi Maori including the co-design of a Maori data governance co-design of a Maori data governance model co-design of a Maori data governance model to co-design of a Maori data governance model to develop co-design of a Maori data governance model to develop an co-design of a Maori data governance model to develop an approach co-design of a Maori data governance model to develop an approach to co-design of a Maori data governance model to develop an approach to data model to develop an approach to data governance model to develop an approach to data governance that model to develop an approach to data governance that reflects model to develop an approach to data governance that reflects Maori model to develop an approach to data governance that reflects Maori needs governance that reflects Maori needs and governance that reflects Maori needs and interests. governance that reflects Maori needs and interests. What governance that reflects Maori needs and interests. What is governance that reflects Maori needs and interests. What is good governance that reflects Maori needs and interests. What is good for and interests. What is good for Maori and interests. What is good for Maori is and interests. What is good for Maori is good and interests. What is good for Maori is good for and interests. What is good for Maori is good for all. Maori is good for all. Supplementary. Maori is good for all. Supplementary. How Maori is good for all. Supplementary. How is Maori is good for all. Supplementary. How is Budget Maori is good for all. Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 helping Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 helping to Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 helping to increase Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 helping to increase iwi Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 helping to increase iwi Maori Supplementary. How is Budget 2021 helping to increase iwi Maori data helping to increase iwi Maori data capability helping to increase iwi Maori data capability and helping to increase iwi Maori data capability and capacity? helping to increase iwi Maori data capability and capacity? Mr helping to increase iwi Maori data capability and capacity? Mr Speaker, capability and capacity? Mr Speaker, Budget capability and capacity? Mr Speaker, Budget 2021 capability and capacity? Mr Speaker, Budget 2021 continues capability and capacity? Mr Speaker, Budget 2021 continues this Budget 2021 continues this commitment Budget 2021 continues this commitment towards Budget 2021 continues this commitment towards iwi Budget 2021 continues this commitment towards iwi Maori Budget 2021 continues this commitment towards iwi Maori data commitment towards iwi Maori data capability commitment towards iwi Maori data capability and commitment towards iwi Maori data capability and capacity commitment towards iwi Maori data capability and capacity building capability and capacity building with capability and capacity building with a capability and capacity building with a particular capability and capacity building with a particular focus capability and capacity building with a particular focus on capability and capacity building with a particular focus on census with a particular focus on census 2023. with a particular focus on census 2023. It with a particular focus on census 2023. It will with a particular focus on census 2023. It will enable with a particular focus on census 2023. It will enable stats with a particular focus on census 2023. It will enable stats New 2023. It will enable stats New Zealand 2023. It will enable stats New Zealand to 2023. It will enable stats New Zealand to collect 2023. It will enable stats New Zealand to collect census 2023. It will enable stats New Zealand to collect census data 2023. It will enable stats New Zealand to collect census data in Zealand to collect census data in two Zealand to collect census data in two geographical Zealand to collect census data in two geographical areas Zealand to collect census data in two geographical areas of Zealand to collect census data in two geographical areas of 10,000 two geographical areas of 10,000 dwellings two geographical areas of 10,000 dwellings each. two geographical areas of 10,000 dwellings each. It two geographical areas of 10,000 dwellings each. It will two geographical areas of 10,000 dwellings each. It will ensure dwellings each. It will ensure capability dwellings each. It will ensure capability and dwellings each. It will ensure capability and capacity dwellings each. It will ensure capability and capacity is dwellings each. It will ensure capability and capacity is build dwellings each. It will ensure capability and capacity is build in capability and capacity is build in two capability and capacity is build in two key capability and capacity is build in two key areas, capability and capacity is build in two key areas, data capability and capacity is build in two key areas, data collection capability and capacity is build in two key areas, data collection and two key areas, data collection and data two key areas, data collection and data analytics. two key areas, data collection and data analytics. This two key areas, data collection and data analytics. This approach two key areas, data collection and data analytics. This approach is two key areas, data collection and data analytics. This approach is an data analytics. This approach is an important data analytics. This approach is an important pilot data analytics. This approach is an important pilot to data analytics. This approach is an important pilot to strengthen important pilot to strengthen enduring important pilot to strengthen enduring ways important pilot to strengthen enduring ways for important pilot to strengthen enduring ways for the important pilot to strengthen enduring ways for the Crown important pilot to strengthen enduring ways for the Crown and important pilot to strengthen enduring ways for the Crown and I enduring ways for the Crown and I with enduring ways for the Crown and I with I enduring ways for the Crown and I with I to enduring ways for the Crown and I with I to work enduring ways for the Crown and I with I to work -- enduring ways for the Crown and I with I to work -- iwi enduring ways for the Crown and I with I to work -- iwi to enduring ways for the Crown and I with I to work -- iwi to work with I to work -- iwi to work together with I to work -- iwi to work together on with I to work -- iwi to work together on co-design with I to work -- iwi to work together on co-design and with I to work -- iwi to work together on co-design and delivering together on co-design and delivering together. together on co-design and delivering together. Delivering together on co-design and delivering together. Delivering for together on co-design and delivering together. Delivering for Maori together on co-design and delivering together. Delivering for Maori means together. Delivering for Maori means delivering together. Delivering for Maori means delivering for together. Delivering for Maori means delivering for all. together. Delivering for Maori means delivering for all. What together. Delivering for Maori means delivering for all. What data delivering for all. What data announcements delivering for all. What data announcements has delivering for all. What data announcements has the delivering for all. What data announcements has the minister delivering for all. What data announcements has the minister seen announcements has the minister seen in announcements has the minister seen in relation announcements has the minister seen in relation to announcements has the minister seen in relation to partnership announcements has the minister seen in relation to partnership with announcements has the minister seen in relation to partnership with iwi in relation to partnership with iwi Maori? in relation to partnership with iwi Maori? And in relation to partnership with iwi Maori? And Mr in relation to partnership with iwi Maori? And Mr Speaker, in relation to partnership with iwi Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's in relation to partnership with iwi Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats New Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats New Zealand Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats New Zealand and Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats New Zealand and data Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats New Zealand and data iwi Maori? And Mr Speaker, today's stats New Zealand and data iwi leaders New Zealand and data iwi leaders group New Zealand and data iwi leaders group have New Zealand and data iwi leaders group have released New Zealand and data iwi leaders group have released the New Zealand and data iwi leaders group have released the estimated group have released the estimated accounts group have released the estimated accounts to group have released the estimated accounts to help group have released the estimated accounts to help fill group have released the estimated accounts to help fill gaps group have released the estimated accounts to help fill gaps that accounts to help fill gaps that currently accounts to help fill gaps that currently exist accounts to help fill gaps that currently exist within accounts to help fill gaps that currently exist within the accounts to help fill gaps that currently exist within the data currently exist within the data system currently exist within the data system for currently exist within the data system for iwi. currently exist within the data system for iwi. Under currently exist within the data system for iwi. Under the system for iwi. Under the relationship system for iwi. Under the relationship agreement system for iwi. Under the relationship agreement signed relationship agreement signed between relationship agreement signed between stats relationship agreement signed between stats New relationship agreement signed between stats New Zealand relationship agreement signed between stats New Zealand and relationship agreement signed between stats New Zealand and the between stats New Zealand and the data between stats New Zealand and the data iwi between stats New Zealand and the data iwi leaders between stats New Zealand and the data iwi leaders group between stats New Zealand and the data iwi leaders group of between stats New Zealand and the data iwi leaders group of the data iwi leaders group of the national data iwi leaders group of the national iwi data iwi leaders group of the national iwi chairs data iwi leaders group of the national iwi chairs forum, data iwi leaders group of the national iwi chairs forum, we're national iwi chairs forum, we're aspiring national iwi chairs forum, we're aspiring towards national iwi chairs forum, we're aspiring towards changes national iwi chairs forum, we're aspiring towards changes to national iwi chairs forum, we're aspiring towards changes to ensure aspiring towards changes to ensure that aspiring towards changes to ensure that iwi aspiring towards changes to ensure that iwi Maori aspiring towards changes to ensure that iwi Maori have aspiring towards changes to ensure that iwi Maori have equitable aspiring towards changes to ensure that iwi Maori have equitable access that iwi Maori have equitable access and that iwi Maori have equitable access and responsibility that iwi Maori have equitable access and responsibility for that iwi Maori have equitable access and responsibility for the that iwi Maori have equitable access and responsibility for the data and responsibility for the data system. and responsibility for the data system. Alongside and responsibility for the data system. Alongside this and responsibility for the data system. Alongside this mahi and responsibility for the data system. Alongside this mahi and and responsibility for the data system. Alongside this mahi and with system. Alongside this mahi and with the system. Alongside this mahi and with the support system. Alongside this mahi and with the support of system. Alongside this mahi and with the support of stats system. Alongside this mahi and with the support of stats New system. Alongside this mahi and with the support of stats New Zealand, the support of stats New Zealand, the the support of stats New Zealand, the data the support of stats New Zealand, the data iwi the support of stats New Zealand, the data iwi leaders the support of stats New Zealand, the data iwi leaders group the support of stats New Zealand, the data iwi leaders group have the data iwi leaders group have created the data iwi leaders group have created the the data iwi leaders group have created the data the data iwi leaders group have created the data platform, the data iwi leaders group have created the data platform, an the data iwi leaders group have created the data platform, an online created the data platform, an online storehouse created the data platform, an online storehouse designed created the data platform, an online storehouse designed to created the data platform, an online storehouse designed to make created the data platform, an online storehouse designed to make iwi created the data platform, an online storehouse designed to make iwi data storehouse designed to make iwi data more storehouse designed to make iwi data more relevant, storehouse designed to make iwi data more relevant, accessible storehouse designed to make iwi data more relevant, accessible and storehouse designed to make iwi data more relevant, accessible and useful more relevant, accessible and useful to more relevant, accessible and useful to iwi. more relevant, accessible and useful to iwi. That more relevant, accessible and useful to iwi. That concludes more relevant, accessible and useful to iwi. That concludes oral to iwi. That concludes oral questions. to iwi. That concludes oral questions. I to iwi. That concludes oral questions. I have to iwi. That concludes oral questions. I have received to iwi. That concludes oral questions. I have received a to iwi. That concludes oral questions. I have received a letter questions. I have received a letter from questions. I have received a letter from the questions. I have received a letter from the honourable questions. I have received a letter from the honourable Eugenie questions. I have received a letter from the honourable Eugenie Sage questions. I have received a letter from the honourable Eugenie Sage and from the honourable Eugenie Sage and Chloe from the honourable Eugenie Sage and Chloe Swarbrick from the honourable Eugenie Sage and Chloe Swarbrick seeking from the honourable Eugenie Sage and Chloe Swarbrick seeking to from the honourable Eugenie Sage and Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate under Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate under Standing Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate under Standing Order Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate under Standing Order 399 Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate under Standing Order 399 the Chloe Swarbrick seeking to debate under Standing Order 399 the release under Standing Order 399 the release of under Standing Order 399 the release of the under Standing Order 399 the release of the government's under Standing Order 399 the release of the government's report under Standing Order 399 the release of the government's report on of the government's report on revitalising of the government's report on revitalising the of the government's report on revitalising the Gulf. of the government's report on revitalising the Gulf. This of the government's report on revitalising the Gulf. This is of the government's report on revitalising the Gulf. This is a revitalising the Gulf. This is a particular revitalising the Gulf. This is a particular recent revitalising the Gulf. This is a particular recent occurrence revitalising the Gulf. This is a particular recent occurrence for particular recent occurrence for which particular recent occurrence for which there's particular recent occurrence for which there's ministerial which there's ministerial responsibility. which there's ministerial responsibility. The which there's ministerial responsibility. The test which there's ministerial responsibility. The test for which there's ministerial responsibility. The test for whether responsibility. The test for whether the responsibility. The test for whether the matter responsibility. The test for whether the matter requires responsibility. The test for whether the matter requires the responsibility. The test for whether the matter requires the immediate the matter requires the immediate attention the matter requires the immediate attention of the matter requires the immediate attention of the the matter requires the immediate attention of the House the matter requires the immediate attention of the House is the matter requires the immediate attention of the House is a the matter requires the immediate attention of the House is a high attention of the House is a high one. attention of the House is a high one. The attention of the House is a high one. The matter attention of the House is a high one. The matter is attention of the House is a high one. The matter is undoubtedly attention of the House is a high one. The matter is undoubtedly an one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. The one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. The strategy one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. The strategy is one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. The strategy is to one. The matter is undoubtedly an important one. The strategy is to be important one. The strategy is to be implemented important one. The strategy is to be implemented over important one. The strategy is to be implemented over time important one. The strategy is to be implemented over time and important one. The strategy is to be implemented over time and there important one. The strategy is to be implemented over time and there will implemented over time and there will be implemented over time and there will be further implemented over time and there will be further opportunities implemented over time and there will be further opportunities to implemented over time and there will be further opportunities to debate be further opportunities to debate the be further opportunities to debate the success be further opportunities to debate the success of be further opportunities to debate the success of each be further opportunities to debate the success of each element be further opportunities to debate the success of each element of be further opportunities to debate the success of each element of it. the success of each element of it. Implementing the success of each element of it. Implementing parts the success of each element of it. Implementing parts of the success of each element of it. Implementing parts of the the success of each element of it. Implementing parts of the strategy Implementing parts of the strategy requires Implementing parts of the strategy requires legislation. Implementing parts of the strategy requires legislation. While Implementing parts of the strategy requires legislation. While the requires legislation. While the application requires legislation. While the application comes requires legislation. While the application comes close, requires legislation. While the application comes close, it requires legislation. While the application comes close, it does requires legislation. While the application comes close, it does not application comes close, it does not have application comes close, it does not have a application comes close, it does not have a sufficient application comes close, it does not have a sufficient element application comes close, it does not have a sufficient element of application comes close, it does not have a sufficient element of urgency have a sufficient element of urgency to have a sufficient element of urgency to warrant have a sufficient element of urgency to warrant setting have a sufficient element of urgency to warrant setting aside have a sufficient element of urgency to warrant setting aside the to warrant setting aside the business to warrant setting aside the business of to warrant setting aside the business of the to warrant setting aside the business of the House to warrant setting aside the business of the House today. to warrant setting aside the business of the House today. The business of the House today. The application business of the House today. The application is business of the House today. The application is therefore business of the House today. The application is therefore declined. application is therefore declined. It application is therefore declined. It could, application is therefore declined. It could, however, application is therefore declined. It could, however, the application is therefore declined. It could, however, the subject application is therefore declined. It could, however, the subject of application is therefore declined. It could, however, the subject of an It could, however, the subject of an application It could, however, the subject of an application to It could, however, the subject of an application to the